Darab Complaint Revised

8/10/2019 Darab Complaint Revised

1/6

Republic of the PhilippinesDEPARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM

ADJUDICATION BOARDOffice of the Pro inci!l A"#u"ic!tor

Ur"!net!$ P!n%!sin!n

Ju!nit! P!scu! DARAB CA&E No' P()**+(*+Pl!intiff FOR DEC,ARATION OF

TENANC-( ersus(

Aileen B!utist!Defen"!nt

.(((((((((((((((((((((((((((.

COMPLAINT

P,AINTIFF$ throu%h the un"ersi%ne" Counsel unto this /onor!bleOffice$ 0ost respectfull1 ! ers2

3' Th!t Co0pl!in!nt$ ! Filipino$ of le%!l !%e$ 0!rrie"$ is !resi"ent of Br%1' P!l!0in%$ &!n C!rlos Cit1$ P!n%!sin!n 4here she0!1 be ser e" su00ons$ !n" other processes of this /onor!bleOffice5

)' Th!t Defen"!nt$ !lso Filipino$ of le%!l !%e$ 0!rrie"$ !resi"ent of Br%1' P!l!0in%$ &!n C!rlos Cit1$ P!n%!sin!n 4here she0!1 be ser e" su00ons$ !n" other processes of this /onor!bleOffice5

6' Th!t Co0pl!in!nt7s brother$ M!rcelo B!utist! !n"conse8uentl1 the f!ther of the Defen"!nt con ince" hereinCo0pl!in!nt to beco0e his ten!nt o er the p!rcel of l!n" he recentl1

bou%ht$ 0ore specific!ll1 9no4n !s ,ot )::;< loc!te" in B!r!n%!1P!l!0in%$ &!n C!rlos Cit1$ P!n%!sin!n before he 0i%r!te" to C!n!"!in 3;+=5


2/6

>' Th!t b1 irtue of Co0pl!in!nt7s institution !s ten!nt o er thes!i" l!n" b1 M!rcelo B!utist!$ there 4!s ! 0utu!l !n" erb!l!%ree0ent th!t herein Co0pl!in!nt sh!ll be in possession !n"occup!tion of the s!i" l!n" for the purpose of culti !tion !n"

pro"uction of !%ricultur!l pro"ucts5

=' Th!t Co0pl!in!nt7s brother$ M!rcelo B!utist! 4!s the one4ho !ctu!ll1 procure" the 0!teri!ls !n" hire" l!borers to buil" thehouse for the Co0pl!in!nt !n" her f!0il1 before he 0i%r!te" toC!n!"! in 3;+=5


3/6

their house !n" the rebuil"in% of the three ?6 f!llen electric!l posts onthe sub#ect l!n"5

36' Th!t Defen"!nt refuse" to %i e Co0pl!in!nt consent to be%in the rep!irs$ st!tin% th!t such rep!irs 4oul" ent!il ser ice truc9sfro0 the electric co0p!n1 !n" l!borers 4ho 4oul" constructCo0pl!in!nt7s house 4oul" enter !n" p!ss Defen"!nt7s pri !te l!n"le!"in% to further "!0!%e to the l!tter7s %!r"en5

3>' Th!t on June =$ )**+$ Defen"!nt brou%ht 4ith her fi e ?=0en !n" %!there" the "is0!ntle" p!rts of Co0pl!in!nt7s house4ithout the l!tter7s consent !n" left ! note st!tin% th!t Co0pl!in!nt

!n" her f!0il1 shoul" le! e the sub#ect l!n" !s the1 4ere not re!lten!nts of the sub#ect l!n" "ue to their f!ilure in re0ittin% Defen"!nt7ssh!re in the !%ricultur!l pro"uce fro0 Febru!r1 to April )**+5

3=' Th!t Co0pl!in!nt o4e" to h! e "eli ere" the Defen"!nt7ssh!re in the !%ricultur!l pro"ucts fro0 Febru!r1 to April )**+ to thel!tter7s el"est son 4ho h! e si%ne" !n" issue" receipts5

3 the 0!tter 4!s consulte" 4ith theDep!rt0ent of A%r!ri!n Refor0$ &!n C!rlos Cit1$ P!n%!sin!n5

3+' Th!t on June 3=$ )**+$ Rhon"!li! G' Po8ui $ the ,e%!lOfficer of the s!i" office con"ucte" ocul!r inspection o er the sub#ectl!n"5

3;' Th!t 0e"i!tion conferences 4ere sche"ule" !n" con"ucte" !tthe Office of the B!r!n%!1 Ch!ir0!n of P!l!0in%$ &!n C!rlos Cit1"urin% the follo4in% "!1s$ 1et no !0ic!ble settle0ent !s to the s!i"issue 4!s e er resol e" bet4een the p!rties5

)*' Th!t Defen"!nt cre!te" ! bloc9!"e pre entin% herein

Co0pl!in!nt of enterin% the sub#ect l!n" !n" rebuil"in% the r! ishe"house$ !lso pre entin% the0 fro0 continuin% their ten!nc1 on the!%ricultur!l l!n" in 8uestion5


4/6

)3' Th!t "ue to these unl!4ful !cts of Defen"!nt$ the hereinCo0pl!in!nt 4!s force" to liti%!te in or"er to protect her interest$ !n"thereb1 incurrin% e.penses in connection thereof !0ountin% toPE&O&2 Fift1 Thous!n" !n" 6= 3** ?P=*$***'** 50oreo er$Co0pl!in!nt 4!s not !ble to re"ee0 the p!rts !n" 0!teri!ls of her !bo"e 4hen Defen"!nt %!there" the0 4ithout her consent !0ountin%to PE&O&2 One hun"re" fift1 thous!n" !n" .. 3** ?3=*$***'** 5li9e4ise$ she !lso suffere" sleepless ni%hts$ 4oun"e" feelin%s$ !n"serious !n.iet1 4hich if con erte" into 0onet!r1 consi"er!tion 4oul"!0ount to PE&O&2 &i.t1 fi e thous!n" !n" .. 3** ?P==$***'** 5

/EREFORE$ pre0ises consi"ere" it is 0ost respectfull1 pr!1e" unto this /onor!ble Court$ th!t !fter tri!l !n" he!rin%$ #u"%0ent be ren"ere" in f! or of the Co0pl!in!nt !s follo4s2

3' Decl!rin% Co0pl!in!nt !s ten!nt of the sub#ect l!n" !n"continue in tillin% !n" culti !tin% the sub#ect l!n"5

)' Or"erin% the Defen"!nt to !llo4 the Co0pl!in!nt inco00encin% 4ith the necess!r1 house rep!irs'

6' Or"erin% the Defen"!nts to p!1 the Co0pl!in!nt the !0ountof P=*$***'** !s liti%!tion e.penses$ P3=*$***'** !s "!0!%eto propert1 !n" !nother P


5/6

ERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION FOR NON(FORUM&/OPPING

I$ Ju!nit! P!scu!$ un"er o!th st!tes2

Th!t I !0 the Co0pl!in!nt in the fore%oin% c!se5

Th!t I c!use" the prep!r!tion of the !fores!i" co0pl!int$ !n" I un"erst!n"the contents thereof to be true !n" correct !ccor"in% to the best of 019no4le"%e5

Th!t I h! e not co00ence" !n1 other !ction of si0il!r n!ture in ol in%s!0e p!rties$ sub#ect 0!tter$ !n" c!use of !ction$ in the &upre0e Court$ Court of Appe!ls$ or !n1 other tribun!l or 8u!si(tribun!l5 Th!t there is no pen"in% !ctionof the s!0e n!ture in ol in% the s!0e p!rties$ sub#ect 0!tter !n" c!use of !ction$ in the !fores!i" tribun!ls or 8u!si(tribun!ls5 Th!t if I le!rn of ! si0il!r !ction in ol in% the s!0e p!rties$ sub#ect 0!tter !n" c!use of !ction pen"in%

before those tribun!ls$ I un"ert!9e to 0!9e ! report in 4ritin% 4ithin = "!1sthereof5

IN ITNE&& /EREOF$ I h! e hereunto set 01 h!n"s this )* th "!1 of June )**+$ in Ur"!net! Cit1'

Ju!nit! B' P!scu! Affi!nt&enior Citi en Control No' 366D!te Issue"2 M!1 )$ )**:Pl!ce issue"2 &!n C!rlos Cit1$ P!n%'

&UB&CRIBED AND & ORN to before 0e this )* th "!1 of June$ )**+$Ur"!net! Cit1'

Mhelo"1 G' Bel0onte Not!r1 PublicUntil Dece0ber 63$ )*3=PTR No' $ &!n C!rlos Cit1MC,E No'


6/6

Documents

Darab Complaint Revised