Davidson. Mental Events

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    1/10

    26

    Donald Dvison

    "Met Eet

    Ment eent uh e,is. mmn.n n n ature i t nomo-I of hl ry Ho n hs ct nd th the u rl f meta n n py: d? Rocl fdm ihl etenim hem

    i supe at ul trmnsmnal u n nd f o u from hemQl Be n rminliv eve o w ' onyi o r i val n onict with d- (m. Ifl) y ry no wh etinm;o!(t(iu ll uer lw i ul m nthr m-

    m umpn t h dn nd aomalousn f meale ee My m i tfo toex n t iuli. hw I m in ymh ith Kant n

    t s ipsib ! ir frt m & t aue fr .aPy 1r mc tM C t b t, c tt t h fr vc up t e t tt f-m f ab n w m b 1 cttdC \:i F i

    tht f r r .t t t aal t1

    Gnelz human tion to mtl evet ubitut aoml o rem n thi i r-ion o my problm. Ad c the netio

    is r. Kn fm 3nml.

    o mc t fomuac a i m cll he .!pprcnt otn utmntlns that ant o i a na iitc m n temming rm h priipl.

    h prnpc t mmntl n intert ull wth hicCen oul thi the Ppe o uInten h for mp i mo nth then rous mntl vt sch n in. cjudmcn. c- intennl ios hnges of liepl a ul l in h nkg the B

    In pul ld ug h he t h mon nk eis ht n wa tht a y ental n ofn h tis il movement inu h B o nk1 crption illustate lit m te pil h mnl: if m r, h hp i apin tn ship prohing mu a

    ue im t mc o hC\ tt hi tS rochig (Nhgcn o

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    2/10

    a) tm ths Pin:op f he >glChaa of C) T nk, i ht wil an aumptoo og h s ting b' of nteraton

    e ppc i t o stc dteins On h b1is hh mna c rct and land (h n aim fhe Mnt.

    pd I wis t ds ass f son ho is in n t pt h h ssumios or nils. d hnks hy a c oStn t oC ntr The Cntcy is tof ou forma l mo rms ac addd.cvch i s aua n that the w pnes that to. d t ocl har of aly. oghr!)' t t s ena s prd n xpaed o t Ia-.il tpnip of t nlism of th nal dnis

    _ik.)'Jjl s phe h, ac wit othut aget t \ic r pcip d la t a oactn t c to m

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    3/10

    H MHYSA AS

    L us cl 1on h or 'h evnth M r tn of orm n xisM m

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    4/10

    tJcntt o he t nals hat N wnd Kim

    l t c 8, l1 mus b a.:OtR t\O n O( C B. s c t nn SL kty 1h th n !c t t t obatio ld r r lut :t d ccn

    h h s e t nno dona mght b abe uce uh i 3 rmltm tta1 i, d h -o"annot n geneal doe

    Th l exme i in ufu nl h thes o awl m ud onsid Thof s 'aur te ne valaf me l>n&>ge L rces dquat t expre 3 n amut f maemats, n tso S L L amed h th tth prcat truein h "m I L (ad

    3 mke th suto erer gv a ou h L pc ut w a dnc

    c>fato of hr of h tio dpon r o e eh tce i t men>l an ph ee ht emp o of th th t f L onis nencc of i t l ad ms t he e no pdte of snt On h oe hand thr th phcal" vl). mr ho ompl. d h h ny. h istence of tha appi o al n t e nte of ca law; on the oer hand he th The an b o hop l i t fom

    -tifenS ai$ldiolif a on- ho d tis. er a hu dvd l'

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    5/10

    THE MENL-PYSICAL S

    In fac hor nohing I an y bu th dilt of th mal v b ld ap; and kind o idciliy i di tFor if anomalous ons iscoc n oly n

    l vnt niqel singled ot uso pica o sn h nm ofs ta als unr h mt rit mr know nite. e m l xs phsal on nec cxnsv i achn rdia oug t oru it vol h tium of a lgth ad 4ii alaon nded een f iud is o ssthe sm o omlg reson o d thtth old cs dic on ad o phsial.

    The thei s tr ht h eal i oolg irl: th< ma b ru ger smn rti th m t hi samt ha hav te of Ia t ty

    ae o (i s rog n o dd)f b ardl mote h e t stuleo 3ic bophi eion uld ha o o l i oh h tu

    delarng ht hr ar (str)hphi , h h m p of ne om o gin hplophe on ? Oc t jda sten lae o lgl s o to i ittth ogh: lat t th accpc of stnt o the of isancs i il ms po But a, aoism ds t itl jusify phly for gen- the rou o ddg to tt a a

    o h asis of s ics wil n oe y thrtil ad empl o no o iii m hose of e. If he of spo la ik h l t y- di it a on a t alo oib of h la o m to hagigth bct y hang th sjt I n r

    deidinot to

    tthe teo of ali trm of th ablar of proioa t

    i d hi h f

    aioal o? No ul jst e l aa ar conspos idqae Ratr i is ea w r sadd. as are i I a f sn\ o fs of deitonl duio

    (atrlim in ics instntlis ad oratoalim i h ns aus t oaning pnomas ad ot caa of piophy's dfeas tht hee i e firs So y no sin >nynl onps a is fo a a o 1e s lfe on Mar O in w cod ak tS h. a cai ud s u th m'

    Is ee lf o Ma) he prde anoer " Yes" Bt o ou his ho h lsr i i o a on h desads ni hs pcon of und ws intonad a ne to te nd eigmthi i Eg d o. o a di de w adda wpo. Ye no ma

    tc h a he mal ondtio w a th r itiolcodion (oed h nOis. ndrnds e.)a i mn

    A kng fau o m t dfia dton how itt m o hng o h eti o yym tc dns d niedm our b imi nerple d cs o ynm u t of al pops a ng onuon f wr o nd n oh in beavol s and exa xtnsiv "th enal pdi nong d ) rsad s tht we had found i We ko too muau hoht d hao o t xa d ni

    at iing tm Beifs and dsie in haor oly as edd uhr i ad dei tt ad ad whou limt Cay hs ols of n m a le both 1 t aoom ad o tanolos charaer o the menl

    h earks apo deniioal avo

    s rov hi of h old ot nomoloa oeon w h med i l h

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    6/10

    2 O D O

    sc nomloliy is mc l aic) as u c r i glat

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    7/10

    E E T

    Un his aw (or sme hiid nhold cnno aiy mak n of he conco ng. Thr ll no o inin numrs to g vn much a in egthlet lone he oe pel dmand of a

    met on a io Ad hi ark oton o a h

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    8/10

    E NAYSIA ONA

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    9/10

    E NAYSIA ONA

    give t a nq hsil npoi hat brn indr vat law). E ee kew heenr phy his f h word ad eeml e! e dcal wh a iwld n follo ha h ld c exlain

    a inl mal even! ( derib. f corse)T fc3urcs of mena i Ih aion

    0 philcl dndn nd n-ic indendecomine 1hc 10 disolwha has fe > a ad. 1h ay fu d pu in macra world adhe rdo a \V y eve

    a eing. mcng deion d acon. " cal le 1m mid \sicahap huh e laon of a d f; bu ha e me f a insulaSenal ens. as o as do no hane theidiom frm si a ta an i il ea

  • 8/13/2019 Davidson. Mental Events

    10/10

    u u . "GoQue Jur1i_I LU (9)p hn . W 'G, fln- mn 38 n VCar P" J P

    uv ( 5 O l28-l nd 687 y n ienclAmc ke &C IK.f t t my E Nm" a P X ( 787

    5 T nu W V n's dm t 2 m. bv