• Home

  • Documents

  • DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With...
33
United States Court of Appeals FOR T HE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT  ____________ No. 10-1097 September Term 2009 FCC-10-54 Filed On: August 30, 2010 Paging Systems, Inc.,  Appellant v. Federal Communications Commission,  Appellee BEFORE: Henderson, Tatel, and Kavanaugh, Circuit Judges O R D E R Upon consideration of the motion to consolidate cases, the opposition thereto, and the reply; the motion to hold case in abeyance, the opposition thereto, and the reply; the motion to dismiss case for lack of standing, the opposition theret o, and the reply; and the motion to intervene, it is ORDERED that the motion to dismiss be granted. “Bare allegations are insufficient . . . to establish . . . standing to seek judicial review of administrat ive action.” Sierra Club v. EPA, 292 F.3d 895, 898 (D.C. Cir. 2002). Rather, a party seeking review of an agency’s decision “must either identify in [the administrative] record evidence sufficient to support its standing to seek review, or, if there is none because standing was not an issue before the agency, submit additional evidence to the court of appeals.” Id. at 899. In this case, appellant has not provided any evidence to support its assertion that it limited its participation in the auction it seeks to set aside, and it has not asserted any other “concrete interest” affected by the procedure it challenges. Summers v. Earth Island Institute, 129 S. Ct. 1142, 1151 (2009). It is FURTHER ORDERED that the remaining motions be dismissed as moot. Pursuant to D.C. Circ uit Rule 36, this dis position will not be published. The Clerk is directed to withhold issuance of the mandate herein until seven days after resolution of any timely petition for rehearing or petition for rehearing en banc. See Fed. R. App. P. 41(b); D.C. Cir. Rule 41. Per Curiam Case: 10-1097 Document: 1263031 Filed: 08/30/2010 Page: 1 [Sky-Tel notes: Mobex (now MCLM), commenced this challenge to FCC Auction 57 of AMTS spectrum and to the Sky-Tel entities' success in that auction. Continued below.*] [* Note above continued: PSI took over the Mobex challenge. Sky-Tel entities, including E nvironmentel, Verde Sys tems, Skybridge and Intelligent Tra nsportation, opposed Mobex and PSI from the start, first, due to clear lack of standing. The FCC found lack of standing, but still for years dealt with the challenges on their substance (which was also defective). A Federal agency cannot, without good public-interest cause articulated, pursue a challenge's substance when it is procedurally defective and where there any private party adversely affected by not dismissing due to lack of standing. That is what the FCC did in this case before the FCC itself. The FCC then asserted Sky-Tel arguments on de fective standing to the court. to get the court to summarily dismiss what the FCC itself would not dismiss. A question remains as to the cause of this prejudicial FCC action. The larger context is relevant and shown in other FCC rec ords on AMTS, Sky-Tel entities, Mobex and MCLM and PSI.]

DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 1/33

Page 2: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 2/33

Page 3: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 3/33

Page 4: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 4/33

Page 5: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 5/33

Page 6: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 6/33

Page 7: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 7/33

Page 8: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 8/33

Page 9: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 9/33

Page 10: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 10/33

Page 11: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 11/33

Page 12: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 12/33

Page 13: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 13/33

Page 14: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 14/33

Page 15: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 15/33

Page 16: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 16/33

Page 17: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 17/33

Page 18: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 18/33

Page 19: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 19/33

Page 20: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 20/33

Page 21: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 21/33

Page 22: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 22/33

Page 23: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 23/33

Page 24: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 24/33

Page 25: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 25/33

Page 26: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 26/33

Page 27: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 27/33

Page 28: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 28/33

Page 29: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 29/33

Page 30: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 30/33

Page 31: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 31/33

Page 32: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 32/33

Page 33: DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC Decision

8/8/2019 DC Circuit Court Order Dismissing Paging System Inc. Challenge to FCC AMTS Auction, 8.30.10, With Attached FCC…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dc-circuit-court-order-dismissing-paging-system-inc-challenge-to-fcc-amts 33/33


2015.5.18 Order Dismissing Case

2015.5.18 Order Dismissing Case

Documents
Public Report and Order Dismissing Complaints

Public Report and Order Dismissing Complaints

Documents
Judge Goebel Written Order Dismissing Melongo's Eavesdropping Case

Judge Goebel Written Order Dismissing Melongo's Eavesdropping Case

Documents
FORGIVENESS & RECONCILIATION. WHAT IS FORGIVENESS? Forgiveness means dismissing a debt. Forgiveness means dismissing a debt. In the New Testament, the

FORGIVENESS & RECONCILIATION. WHAT IS FORGIVENESS? Forgiveness means dismissing a debt. Forgiveness means dismissing a debt. In the New Testament, the

Documents
Deneb BrochureREV.8.30.10

Deneb BrochureREV.8.30.10

Documents
DISMISSING FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH LEAVE TO

DISMISSING FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH LEAVE TO

Documents
Order Dismissing 2nd Amended Complaint

Order Dismissing 2nd Amended Complaint

Documents
Aguayo v. Jewell.order Dismissing.11.18.14

Aguayo v. Jewell.order Dismissing.11.18.14

Documents
The Ambiguity and Unfairness of Dismissing Bad Writing

The Ambiguity and Unfairness of Dismissing Bad Writing

Documents
Dismissing a Criminal Conviction in California

Dismissing a Criminal Conviction in California

Law
DC - Strunk - 2011-01-06 - OrDER Dismissing Case

DC - Strunk - 2011-01-06 - OrDER Dismissing Case

Documents
Slep-Tone & Phoenix Order Dismissing Case

Slep-Tone & Phoenix Order Dismissing Case

Documents
Order dismissing GMCR complaint

Order dismissing GMCR complaint

Documents
docs.cpuc.ca.govdocs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/AGENDA_DECISION/129423.doc · Web viewDECISION DISMISSING COMPLAINTS WITHOUT PREJUDICE DECISION DISMISSING COMPLAINTS WITHOUT PREJUDICE 1

docs.cpuc.ca.govdocs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/AGENDA_DECISION/129423.doc · Web viewDECISION DISMISSING COMPLAINTS WITHOUT PREJUDICE DECISION DISMISSING COMPLAINTS WITHOUT PREJUDICE 1

Documents
District Court Opinion Dismissing Damages Claims

District Court Opinion Dismissing Damages Claims

Documents
Sofpool v. KMart - Order Dismissing Case

Sofpool v. KMart - Order Dismissing Case

Documents
Steward v. West - Order on Motion dismissing most of claims

Steward v. West - Order on Motion dismissing most of claims

Documents
Middlebrooks Order Dismissing Spence Jones

Middlebrooks Order Dismissing Spence Jones

Documents
PA - 2012-05-25 - SCHNELLER - OPINION Dismissing Case

PA - 2012-05-25 - SCHNELLER - OPINION Dismissing Case

Documents
Gravity Presentation 8.30.10

Gravity Presentation 8.30.10

Documents
Order Dismissing Complaint & Counter-complaint

Order Dismissing Complaint & Counter-complaint

Documents
Cases Dismissing COVID-19 Business Interruption Claims Dismissing COVID... · 2021. 1. 29. · Cases Dismissing COVID-19 Business Interruption Claims By Adam H. Fleischer and Matthew

Cases Dismissing COVID-19 Business Interruption Claims Dismissing COVID... · 2021. 1. 29. · Cases Dismissing COVID-19 Business Interruption Claims By Adam H. Fleischer and Matthew

Documents
DePaul - Ruling by Neil Cohen Dismissing Case

DePaul - Ruling by Neil Cohen Dismissing Case

Documents
Berg v Obama - Memorandum and Order DIsmissing Berg v Obama

Berg v Obama - Memorandum and Order DIsmissing Berg v Obama

Documents
Greater san antonio chamber of commerce 8.30.10

Greater san antonio chamber of commerce 8.30.10

Documents
Leading Higher Education Differently: Desiring, Dismissing or Disqualifying Women?

Leading Higher Education Differently: Desiring, Dismissing or Disqualifying Women?

Documents
Buriva LLC et al Order Dismissing Case Without Prejudice

Buriva LLC et al Order Dismissing Case Without Prejudice

Documents
New York Supreme Court Order Dismissing Walnut Place MBS Suit

New York Supreme Court Order Dismissing Walnut Place MBS Suit

Documents
THE PERILS OF VOLUNTARILY DISMISSING … · THE PERILS OF VOLUNTARILY DISMISSING WITHOUT PREJUDICE: "BEWARE WHAT YOU DREAM FOR" ... SECTION 2-1009 PERMITS ... prosecution, or other

THE PERILS OF VOLUNTARILY DISMISSING … · THE PERILS OF VOLUNTARILY DISMISSING WITHOUT PREJUDICE: "BEWARE WHAT YOU DREAM FOR" ... SECTION 2-1009 PERMITS ... prosecution, or other

Documents
3219EN - Dismissing Your Petition for Dissolution of · PDF file · 2017-07-223219EN - Dismissing Your Petition for Dissolution of Marriage (Divorce) or Domestic Partnership . Instructions

3219EN - Dismissing Your Petition for Dissolution of · PDF file · 2017-07-223219EN - Dismissing Your Petition for Dissolution of Marriage (Divorce) or Domestic Partnership . Instructions

Documents