7/24/2019 Dec of Principles

1/4

BAYAN MUNA VS.ROMULO

MARCH 30, 2013~ VBDIAZ

.entry-met

.entry-!e"er

Byn M#n $% R&m#'&(. R. N&. 1)*+1, er#ry 01, 2011

/t%ett&ner Byn M#n % "#'y re%tere" 4rty-'%t r e%t'%!e" t& re4re%ent t!e

mrn'5e" %e/t&r% &6 %&/ety. Re%4&n"ent B'% . O4'e, n&7 "e/e%e", 7% t!eSe/retry &6 &ren A66r% "#rn t!e 4er&" mter' t& t!% /%e. Re%4&n"ent A'ert&

R&m#'& 7% m4'e"e" n !% /4/ty % t!en 89e/#t$e Se/retry.

R&me Stt#te &6 t!e Internt&n' Crmn' Crt

H$n :ey "etermnt$e ern &n t!% /%e % t!e R&me Stt#te e%t'%!n t!e

Internt&n' Crmn' Crt ;ICC< 7t! t!e 4&7er t& e9er/%e t% =#r%"/t&n &$er

4er%&n% 6&r t!e m&%t %er% /rme% &6 nternt&n' /&n/ern 9 9 9 n" %!'' e

/&m4'ementry t& t!e nt&n' /rmn' =#r%"/t&n%.>!e %er% /rme% "$erte" t&

/&$er t!&%e /&n%"ere" r$e #n"er nternt&n' '7, %#/! % en&/"e, /rme% n%t

!#mnty, 7r /rme%, n" /rme% &6 re%%&n.On De/emer 2, 2000, t!e R, t!r! C!re "A66re% 8nr?#e A. Mn'&, %ne" t!e

R&me Stt#te 7!/!, y t% term%, % %#=e/t t& rt6/t&n, //e4tn/e &r 44r&$'y

t!e %nt&ry %tte%. A% &6 t!e 6'n &6 t!e n%tnt 4ett&n, &n'y *2 t &6 t!e 13*

%nt&ry /ntre% 44er t& !$e /&m4'ete" t!e rt6/t&n, 44r&$' n" /&n/#rren/e4r&/e%%. >!e !'44ne% % n&t m&n t!e *2.

R-US N&n-S#rren"er Areement

On My *, 2003, t!en Am%%"&r rn/% @. R//r"&ne %ent US 8m%%y N&te N&.

00 t& t!e De4rtment &6 &ren A66r% ;DA< 4r&4&%n t!e term% &6 t!e n&n-%#rren"er 'ter' reement ;Areement, !eren6ter< et7een t!e USA n" t!e R.

V 89/!ne &6 N&te% N&. BO-02-03 "te" My 13, 2003 ;8N BO-02-03,

!eren6ter!e Areement 4ertnent'y 4r&$"e% % 6&''&7%

1. &r 4#r4&%e% &6 t!% Areement, 4er%&n%re /#rrent &r 6&rmer (&$ernment &66/'%,

em4'&yee% ;n/'#"n /&ntr/t&r%!% Areement %!'' remn n 6&r/e #nt' &ne yer 6ter t!e "te &n 7!/! &ne 4rtyn&t6e% t!e &t!er &6 t% ntent t& termnte t!e Areement. >!e 4r&$%&n% &6 t!%

Areement %!'' /&ntn#e t& 44'y 7t! re%4e/t t& ny /t &//#rrn, &r ny ''et&n

r%n, e6&re t!e e66e/t$e "te &6 termnt&n.

In re%4&n%e t& ?#ery &6 t!en S&'/t&r (ener' A'6re"& L. Ben4y& &n t!e %tt#% &6 t!en&n-%#rren"er reement, Am%%"&r R//r"&ne re4'e" n !% 'etter &6 O/t&er 2,

2003 t!t t!e e9/!ne &6 "4'&mt/ n&te% /&n%tt#te" 'e''y n"n reement

https://vbdiaz.wordpress.com/2013/03/30/bayan-muna-vs-romulo/https://vbdiaz.wordpress.com/author/vbdiaz/https://vbdiaz.wordpress.com/2013/03/30/bayan-muna-vs-romulo/https://vbdiaz.wordpress.com/author/vbdiaz/

7/24/2019 Dec of Principles

2/4

#n"er nternt&n' '7G n" t!t, #n"er US '7, t!e %" reement "" n&t re?#re t!e

"$/e n" /&n%ent &6 t!e US Sente.

In t!% 4r&/ee"n, 4ett&ner m4#te% r$e #%e &6 "%/ret&n t& re%4&n"ent% n/&n/'#"n n" rt6yn t!e Areement n" 4ry% t!t t e %tr#/: "&7n %

#n/&n%tt#t&n', &r t 'e%t "e/'re" % 7t!t 6&r/e n" e66e/t.

I%%#e !et!er &r n&t t!e R-US NON SURR8ND8R A(R88M8N> % $&" nt& 6&r

/&ntr/tn &'t&n% t!t re et!er mm&r' &r &t!er7%e t $rn/e 7t! #n$er%''yre/&n5e" 4rn/4'e% &6 nternt&n' '7.

R#'n >!e 4ett&n % ere6t &6 mert.

V'"ty &6 t!e R-US N&n-S#rren"er Areement

ett&ner% nt' /!''ene n%t t!e Areement re'te% t& 6&rm, t% t!re%!&'" 4&%t#re

en t!t 8N BO-02-03 /nn&t e $'" me"#m 6&r /&n/'#"n t!e Areement.

ett&ner%/&ntent&n4er!4% t:en #n7re &6 /ertn 7e''-re/&n5e" nternt&n'

"&/trne%, 4r/t/e%, n" =r&n%% #nten'e. One &6 t!e%e % t!e "&/trne &6

n/&r4&rt&n, % e94re%%e" n Se/t&n 2, Art/'e II &6 t!e C&n%tt#t&n, 7!eren t!e

!'44ne% "&4t% t!e ener''y //e4te" 4rn/4'e% &6 nternt&n' '7 n" nternt&n'=#r%4r#"en/e % 4rt &6 t!e '7 &6 t!e 'n" n" "!ere% t& t!e 4&'/y &6 4e/e,

/&&4ert&n, n" mty 7t! '' nt&n%. An e9/!ne &6 n&te% 6''% nt& t!e /te&ry &6nter-&$ernment' reement%, 7!/! % n nternt&n''y //e4te" 6&rm &6

nternt&n' reement. >!e Unte" Nt&n% >rety C&''e/t&n% ;>rety Re6eren/e (#"e!e reement /&n%%t% &6 t!e e9/!ne &6 t7& "&/#ment%,

e/! &6 t!e 4rte% en n t!e 4&%%e%%&n &6 t!e &ne %ne" y t!e re4re%entt$e &6 t!e

&t!er. Un"er t!e #%#' 4r&/e"#re, t!e //e4tn Stte re4et% t!e te9t &6 t!e &66ern

Stte t& re/&r" t% %%ent. >!e %nt&re% &6 t!e 'etter% my e &$ernment Mn%ter%,"4'&mt% &r "e4rtment' !e"%. >!e te/!n?#e &6 e9/!ne &6 n&te% % 6re?#ent'y

re%&rte" t&, et!er e/#%e &6 t% %4ee"y 4r&/e"#re, &r, %&metme%, t& $&" t!e 4r&/e%%

&6 'e%'t$e 44r&$'.In n&t!er 4er%4e/t$e, t!e term% e9/!ne &6 n&te%n" e9e/#t$e reement%!$e

een #%e" nter/!ne'y, e9/!ne &6 n&te% en /&n%"ere" 6&rm &6 e9e/#t$e

reement t!t e/&me% n"n t!r! e9e/#t$e /t&n. On t!e &t!er !n", e9e/#t$e

reement% /&n/'#"e" y t!e re%"ent %&metme% t:e t!e 6&rm &6 e9/!ne &6 n&te%

n" t &t!er tme% t!t &6 m&re 6&rm' "&/#ment% "en&mnte" reement%&r

4r&t&/&'%.A% 6&rmer US H! C&mm%%&ner t& t!e !'44ne% rn/% B. Syre &%er$e"

n !% 7&r:, >!e C&n%tt#t&n'ty &6 >r"e Areement A/t%

>!e 4&nt 7!ere &r"nry /&rre%4&n"en/e et7een t!% n" &t!er &$ernment% en"% n"

reement% 7!et!er "en&mnte" e9e/#t$e reement% &r e9/!ne &6 n&te% &r

&t!er7%e

en, my %&metme% e "66/#'t &6 re"y %/ertnment. 9 9 9It % 6r'y /'er 6r&m t!e 6&re&n "%?#%t&n t!t 8N BO-02-03e t $e7e" % t!e

N&n-S#rren"er Areement t%e'6, &r % n nter' n%tr#ment &6 //e4tn/e t!ere&6 &r %

/&n%ent t& e n"% re/&n5e" m&"e &6 /&n/'#"n 'e''y n"n nternt&n'

7rtten /&ntr/t m&n nt&n%.

Areement N&t Imm&r'N&t t Vrn/e7t! rn/4'e% &6 Internt&n' L7

ett&ner #re% t!t t!e Areement e %tr#/: "&7n % $&" nt& 6&r m4&%n

mm&r' &'t&n% n"&r en t $rn/e 7t! ''ee"'y #n$er%''y re/&n5e"

4rn/4'e% &6 nternt&n' '7. >!e mm&r' %4e/t 4r&/ee"% 6r&m t!e 6/t t!t t!e

Areement, % 4ett&ner 7'" 4#t t, 'e$e% /rmn'% mm#ne 6r&m re%4&n%'ty 6&r

#nmn'e tr&/te% t!t "ee4'y %!&/: t!e /&n%/en/e &6 !#mntyG 9 9 9 t 4re/'#"e%r /ntry 6r&m "e'$ern n Amer/n /rmn' t& t!e EICCF 9 9 9.+3

>!e &$e r#ment % :n" &6 re/y/'n &6 4ett&ner% er'er 4&%t&n, 7!/!, %

're"y "%/#%%e", /&nten"% t!t t!e R, y entern nt& t!e Areement, $rt#''y"/te" t% %&$erenty n" n t!e 4r&/e%% #n"ermne" t% trety &'t&n% #n"er t!e

R&me Stt#te, /&ntrry t& nternt&n' '7 4rn/4'e%.

>!e Crt % n&t 4er%#"e". S#66/e t t& %tte n t!% rer" t!t t!e n&n-%#rren"er

reement, % 4t'y "e%/re" y t!e S&'/t&r (ener', % n %%ert&n y t!e !'44ne%

&6 t% "e%re t& try n" 4#n%! /rme% #n"er t% nt&n' '7. 9 9 9 >!e reement %

re/&nt&n &6 t!e 4rm/y n" /&m4eten/e &6 t!e /ntry% =#"/ry t& try &66en%e%

#n"er t% nt&n' /rmn' '7% n" "%4en%e =#%t/e 6r'y n" =#"/%'y.

7/24/2019 Dec of Principles

3/4

ett&ner, 7e e'e$e, '&r% #n"er t!e err&ne% m4re%%&n t!t t!e Areement 7'"

''&7 '4n&% n" Amer/n% /&mmttn !! /rme% &6 nternt&n' /&n/ern t& e%/4e

/rmn' tr' n" 4#n%!ment. >!% % mn6e%t'y n/&rre/t. er%&n% 7!& my !$e/&mmtte" /t% 4en'5e" #n"er t!e R&me Stt#te /n e 4r&%e/#te" n" 4#n%!e" n t!e

!'44ne% &r n t!e USG &r 7t! t!e /&n%ent &6 t!e R &r t!e US, e6&re t!e ICC,

%%#mn, 6&r t!e n&n/e, t!t '' t!e 6&rm'te% ne/e%%ry t& n" &t! /ntre% t& t!e

R&me Stt#te !$e een met. &r 4er%4e/t$e, 7!t t!e Areement /&nte9t#''y4r&!t% % t!e %#rren"er y et!er 4rty &6 n"$"#'% t& nternt&n' tr#n'%, ':e t!e

ICC, 7t!t t!e /&n%ent &6 t!e &t!er 4rty, 7!/! my "e%re t& 4r&%e/#te t!e /rme

#n"er t% e9%tn '7%. t! t!e $e7 7e t:e &6 t!n%, t!ere % n&t!n mm&r' &r

$&'t$e &6 nternt&n' '7 /&n/e4t% n t!e /t &6 t!e !'44ne% &6 %%#mn /rmn'=#r%"/t&n 4#r%#nt t& t!e n&n-%#rren"er reement &$er n &66en%e /&n%"ere" /rmn'

y &t! !'44ne '7% n" t!e R&me Stt#te.

HARMAC8U>ICAL AND H8AL>H CAR8 $% DUU8III

&%te" &n Mr/! +, 200*y r?#e'."te

HARMAC8U>ICAL AND H8AL>H CAR8 ASSOCIA>ION O >H8 HILIIN8S$%. H8AL>H

S8CR8>ARY RANCISCO >. DUU8 IIIFACTS On O/t&er 2, 1*+, 89e/#t$e Or"er N&. )1 ;M': C&"e< 7% %%#e" yre%"ent C&r5&n A?#n& y $rt#e &6 t!e 'e%'t$e 4&7er% rnte" t& t!e 4re%"ent#n"er t!e ree"&m C&n%tt#t&n. >!e M': C&"e %tte% t!t t!e '7 %ee:% t& $ee66e/t t& Art/'e 112 &6 t!e Internt&n' C&"e &6 Mr:etn &6 Bre%tm': S#%tt#te%

;ICMBS!e

M': C&"e,%%'n t!t t!e RIRR 7% &n ey&n" t!e 4r&$%&n% &6 t!e M':

C&"e, t!erey men"n n" e94n"n t!e /&$ere &6 %" '7.

ISSUE !et!er &r n&t re%4&n"ent% &66/er% &6 t!e DOH /te" 7t!t &r n e9/e%% &6=#r%"/t&n, &r 7t! r$e #%e &6 "%/ret&n mntn t& '/: &r e9/e%% &6=#r%"/t&n, n" n $&'t&n &6 t!e 4r&$%&n% &6 t!e C&n%tt#t&n n 4r&m#'tn t!e

RIRR

RULING:

>!e S#4reme Crt AR>IALLY (RAN>8D t!e 4ett&n. Se/t&n% ;6!e De4rtment &6 He't! n" re%4&n"ent% reROHIBI>8D 6r&m m4'ementn %" 4r&$%&n%. >!e nternt&n' n%tr#ment%4&nte" t y t!e re%4&n"ent%, UNRC, IC8SR, C8DA, re "eeme" 4rt &6 t!e '7 &6t!e 'n" n" t!ere6&re t!e DOH my m4'ement t!em t!r! t!e RIRR. C#%t&mrynternt&n' '7 % "eeme" n/&r4&rte" nt& r "&me%t/ %y%tem. C#%t&m &r

/#%t&mry nternt&n' '7 men% ener' n" /&n%%tent 4r/t/e &6 %tte%

6&''&7e" y t!em 6r&m %en%e &6 'e' &'t&n ;&4n& =#r%!% my

/&n%tt#te %&6t '7&r n&n-n"n n&rm%, 4rn/4'e% n" 4r/t/e% t!t n6'#en/e

%tte e!$&r. Re%4&n"ent% !$e n&t 4re%ente" ny e$"en/e t& 4r&$e t!t t!e HA

https://isisrakel.wordpress.com/2009/03/06/pharmaceutical-and-health-care-vs-duque-iii/https://isisrakel.wordpress.com/author/isisrakel/https://isisrakel.wordpress.com/2009/03/06/pharmaceutical-and-health-care-vs-duque-iii/https://isisrakel.wordpress.com/author/isisrakel/

7/24/2019 Dec of Principles

4/4

Re%&'#t&n%, 't!! %ne" y m&%t &6 t!e memer %tte%, 7ere n 6/t en6&r/e" &r4r/t/e" y t 'e%t m=&rty &6 t!e memer %tte% n" &'t&ry n nt#re. >!e4r&$%&n% &6 t!e HA Re%&'#t&n% /nn&t e /&n%"ere" % 4rt &6 t!e '7 &6 t!e 'n"t!t /n e m4'emente" y e9e/#t$e en/e% 7t!t t!e nee" &6 '7 en/te" y

t!e 'e%'t#re. On t!e &t!er !n", t!e 4ett&ner% '%& 6'e" t& e94'n n" 4r&$e y/&m4etent e$"en/e =#%t e9/t'y !&7 %#/! 4r&te/t$e re#'t&n 7'" re%#'t n t!e

re%trnt &6 tr"e. Sn/e '' t!e re#'t&ry 4r&$%&n% #n"er t!e M': C&"e 44'ye?#''y t& &t! mn#6/t#rer% n" "%tr#t&r%, t!e Crt %ee% n& !rm n t!e RIRR.89/e4t Se/t&n% ;6