8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

1/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page1 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

2/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page2 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

3/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page3 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

4/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page4 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

5/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page5 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

6/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page6 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

7/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page7 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

8/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page8 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

9/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page9 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

10/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page10 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

11/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page11 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

12/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page12 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

13/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page13 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

14/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page14 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

15/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page15 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

16/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page16 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

17/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page17 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

18/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page18 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

19/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page19 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

20/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31 Filed09/19/11 Page20 of 20

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

21/118

EXHIBIT A

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page1 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

22/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page2 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

23/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page3 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

24/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page4 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

25/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page5 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

26/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page6 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

27/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page7 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

28/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page8 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

29/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page9 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

30/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page10 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

31/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page11 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

32/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page12 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

33/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page13 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

34/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page14 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

35/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page15 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

36/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page16 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

37/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page17 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

38/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page18 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

39/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page19 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

40/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

41/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page21 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

42/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page22 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

43/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page23 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

44/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page24 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

45/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-1 Filed09/19/11 Page25 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

46/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page1 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

47/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page2 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

48/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page3 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

49/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page4 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

50/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page5 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

51/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page6 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

52/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page7 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

53/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page8 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

54/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page9 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

55/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page10 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

56/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page11 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

57/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page12 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

58/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page13 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

59/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page14 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

60/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page15 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

61/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page16 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

62/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page17 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

63/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page18 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

64/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page19 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

65/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page20 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

66/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page21 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

67/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page22 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

68/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page23 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

69/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-2 Filed09/19/11 Page24 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

70/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page1 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

71/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page2 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

72/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page3 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

73/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page4 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

74/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page5 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

75/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page6 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

76/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page7 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

77/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page8 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

78/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page9 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

79/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page10 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

80/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page11 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

81/118

EXHIBIT S

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page12 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

82/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page13 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

83/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page14 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

84/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page15 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

85/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page16 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

86/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page17 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

87/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page18 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

88/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page19 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

89/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

90/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page21 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

91/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page22 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

92/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

93/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page24 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

94/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-3 Filed09/19/11 Page25 of 25

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

95/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page1 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

96/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page2 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

97/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page3 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

98/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page4 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

99/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page5 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

100/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page6 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

101/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page7 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

102/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page8 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

103/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page9 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

104/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page10 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

105/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page11 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

106/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page12 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

107/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page13 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

108/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page14 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

109/118

EXHIBIT

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page15 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

110/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

111/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page17 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

112/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

113/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page19 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

114/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

115/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page21 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

116/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page22 of 24

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

117/118

8/2/2019 Declaration of Steve Tanabe--Freeman v ABC Legal Services Inc (09!19!2011)

118/118

Case3:11-cv-03007-EMC Document31-4 Filed09/19/11 Page24 of 24