Upload
truongphuc
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Democratic Policymaking
An Analytic Approach
This introduction applies analytic models to policymaking challenges, equipping
students with tools to evaluate core policymaking dilemmas. Students are
introduced to the approaches of game theory, social choice theory, research
design, and causal inference. Key terms, along with current research, are
highlighted to build an understanding of public policy study. Exercises and
thought questions enable students to develop skills to assess public policy
dilemmas. The analytically rigorous style of the text is accessible and avoids
lengthy descriptions. Supplementary resources for instructors include extensive
notes, ancillaries, and online resources, including a test bank, quizzes, and
editable lecture slides for all chapters that can be modified to fit particular
courses. This textbook is suitable for introductory public policy and public
administration courses at both undergraduate and postgraduate level.
Charles Barrilleaux is LeRoy Collins Professor and Chair in the Department of
Political Science at Florida State University. His research and teaching focus on
public policy and US state and local government and politics. He is the author or
co-author of numerous articles, most recently in journals including Economic
Inquiry, Political Research Quarterly, Social Science Quarterly, and State Politics
and Policy Quarterly.
Christopher Reenock is an Associate Professor in the Department of Political
Science at Florida State University. His research interests include comparative
public policy, environmental regulatory policy, and regime dynamics. His articles
have appeared most recently in journals including Journal of Politics, Journal of
Public Administration Research and Theory, and Political Research Quarterly.
Mark Souva is Professor of Political Science at Florida State University. His
research interests include the causes of interstate conflict, military spending, and
economic sanctions. His most recent publications include articles in journals such
as the Journal of Conflict Resolution, the Journal of Peace Research, International
Studies Quarterly, and International Interactions.
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
DemocraticPolicymakingAn Analytic Approach
Charles BarrilleauxFlorida State University
Christopher ReenockFlorida State University
Mark A. SouvaFlorida State University
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
University Printing House, Cambridge cb2 8bs, United Kingdom
One Liberty Plaza, 20th Floor, New York, ny 10006, USA
477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, vic 3207, Australia
4843/24, 2nd Floor, Ansari Road, Daryaganj, Delhi – 110002, India
79 Anson Road, #06–04/06, Singapore 079906
Cambridge University Press is part of the University of Cambridge.
It furthers the University’s mission by disseminating knowledge in the pursuit ofeducation, learning, and research at the highest international levels of excellence.
www.cambridge.orgInformation on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521122764
© Charles Barrilleaux, Christopher Reenock, and Mark A. Souva 2016
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exceptionand to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,no reproduction of any part may take place without the writtenpermission of Cambridge University Press.
First published 2017
Printed in the United States of America by Sheridan Books, Inc.
A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Datanames: Barrilleaux, Charles, author. | Reenock, Christopher, author. | Souva, Mark A., author.title: Democratic policymaking : an analytic approach / Charles Barrilleaux, Florida State University ;Christopher Reenock, Florida State University ; Mark A. Souva, Florida State University.
Description: New York, NY : Cambridge University Press, 2016. | Includes bibliographical referencesand index.
identifiers: lccn 2016015780| isbn 9780521192873 (Hardback) | isbn 9780521122764 (Paperback)subjects: lcsh: Political planning–United States. | Public administration–United States. | United States–Politicsand government–Decision making | BISAC: POLITICAL SCIENCE / Government / General.
classification: lcc JK468.P64 B36 2016 | ddc 320.60973–dc23 LC record available athttps://lccn.loc.gov/2016015780
isbn 978-0-521-19287-3 Hardbackisbn 978-0-521-12276-4 Paperback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracyof URLs for external or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publicationand does not guarantee that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain,accurate or appropriate.
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Contents
List of Figures xv
List of Tables xvii
Preface xix
Introduction 1
Introduction 2
0.1 What Is Democratic Public Policy? 2
What Is Public Policy? 2
What Is Democracy? 3
What Is Democratic Public Policy? 4
0.2 The Opportunities and Challenges of Democratic Policymaking 4
0.3 Our Approach: Analytics and the Scientific Method 5
An Analytic Approach 6
Emphasis on the Scientific Method 8
Contemporary Scholarship 9
0.4 Textbook Overview 9
1 Public Policy Models 11
Introduction 12
1.1 Studying Public Policy 13
1.2 Why Study Public Policy? 14
Accountability 15
Efficiency Gains 16
Equitable Policy Delivery 16
Democratic Policymaking 17
1.3 The Policymaking Process 19
Problem and Solution Identification 20
Policy Demands 24
Agenda Setting 25
The Media and Agenda Setting 25
Factors That Drive Agenda Setting 26
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Policy Formulation 28
Policy Areas and Incentives for Action 28
Alternative Formulation 30
Policy Selection/Adoption 33
Policy Implementation 35
Contracting Out to the Bureaucracy 37
Why Red Tape? 38
Policy/Program Evaluation 39
Does Policy Cause Politics? 40
1.4 Models of Public Policy 41
Positing a Causal Relationship 41
And Why Is That? 42
Necessary and Sufficient Causality 44
Conditional Causality 44
Deterministic vs. Probabilistic Relationships 44
What Is a Model of Public Policy? 45
Why Do We Need Models of Public Policy? 47
Elements of a Good Model 48
Multivariate 48
Probabilistic 48
Parsimonious 49
Generalizable 49
Falsifiable 50
Clear and Logically Consistent 51
Ideologically Neutral 51
Elements of a Useful Model for Public Policy 51
Actors 52
Rules 52
Actors Interacting with Rules 53
1.5 Conclusion 53
2 Individuals and Social Dilemmas 57
Introduction: Origins of Social Problems 58
2.1 Game Theory as a Tool 59
2.2 Individual Action 60
Personal Utility Maximization 60
Challenges in Resolving Social Problems 63
2.3 Cooperation and Collective Action 64
Cooperation Dilemmas 64
Overcoming Barriers to Cooperative Behavior 67
Repeated Interaction 67
Internalized Norms/External Enforcement 71
vi � contents
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Barriers to Collective Action 74
Multi-Person Cooperation 74
Group Organization 76
2.4 Conclusion 77
3 Public Policy as a Solution to Social Dilemmas 80
Introduction: Institutions and Social Problems 81
3.1 Institutions as Facilitators of Individual and Collective Action 81
3.2 Markets 83
Property Rights/Credible Commitment 89
Market Limitations or Market Failure 93
Rivalrous and Excludable Goods 93
Non-Competitive Markets (Monopolies) 95
Negative Externalities 96
Incomplete Information 97
Transaction Costs 99
3.3 Government: Legitimate Coercion and Institutional Collective Action 99
Response to Market Failures 100
Provision of Goods and Services 101
Taxation Subsidy 102
Regulation 103
Government Limitations 104
Social Choice and Majority Rule 105
Market Distortions 108
Principal–Agent 109
3.4 Markets and Government in Combination 109
3.5 Conclusion 111
4 Scientific Inquiry and Uncertainty 114
Introduction 115
4.1 Scientific Inquiry 117
Counterfactual Model of Causal Inference 117
Minimum Conditions for Drawing Valid Inferences 119
Internal and External Validity 122
4.2 Estimating Statistics of Interest 123
Descriptive Statistics 123
Measures of Association 125
Correlation 126
Regression 127
4.3 Estimating Scientific Uncertainty 128
Sources of Uncertainty 128
Measurement Error 129
contents � vii
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Random Error 129
Sampling Error 130
Inferential Statistics 130
The “Magic” of Statistical Inference 131
Estimating Uncertainty with Probability 133
Hypothesis Testing 135
Standard Hypotheses for Descriptive Statistics 135
Standard Hypotheses for Measures of Association 135
Why 95 Percent? 136
The Non-Uniqueness of Scientific Uncertainty 138
Medical Uncertainty 138
Physics 139
Biology 139
Engineering 139
4.4 Statistical Uncertainty vs. Ill-Informed Skepticism 140
Ill-informed Skepticism/Adherence 140
Scientific Certainty/Ill-Informed Adherence 141
Scientific Uncertainty/Ill-Informed Adherence 141
Scientific Certainty/Ill-Informed Skepticism 141
Scientific Uncertainty/Ill-Informed Skepticism 142
Skepticism as a Political Asset 142
4.5 Empirical Research and “Policy-Oriented Learning” 144
4.6 Conclusion 145
5 The Economy and Income Security 148
Introduction 149
5.1 The Political Marketplace: The Foundation of the Economy 150
5.2 Approaches to Managing the Economy 152
Economic Goals 152
Classical Economic Model 153
Keynesian Economic Model 154
5.3 Tools for Managing the Economy 156
Fiscal Policy 156
Monetary Policy 157
Regulation 158
Taxes 159
Tax Rates and Government Transfers 162
Who Pays for Government? 162
Unemployment 162
Deficits and Debts 164
5.4 How Do Societies Ensure That Their Members Have Economic Security? 165
Rawls’s “Veil of Ignorance” 165
viii � contents
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
The Mixed Solution 166
5.5 How to Provide Income Security? 167
Saving 167
The Income Inequality Problem 167
Social Insurance 171
Redistribution 171
Ultimatum Game 172
Dictator Game 173
Does Our Analysis of These Games Provide Insights? 175
5.6 Programs Designed to Provide Income Security 175
Social Security 175
Unemployment Insurance 179
Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) 180
Earned Income Tax Credits (EITC) 183
The Minimum Wage 184
Food Security 185
Housing Security 185
5.7 Individual Preferences on Taxes and Redistribution 187
5.8 Conclusion 189
6 Environmental Policy 194
Introduction 195
6.1 Environmental Policy, Market Failure, and Negative Externalities 196
6.2 Public Opinion, Political Parties, and Environmental Policy 201
Public Attitudes on the Environment 202
Perceiving Policy Differences between Parties 206
Cross-Cutting Cleavages 207
6.3 Legislative Initiatives in Environmental Policy 207
Major Legislative Initiatives 209
6.4 Implementing Environmental Policy 211
Delegation Issues and Implementation 212
Adverse Selection 213
Moral Hazard 214
How Much Discretion? 220
6.5 Evaluating Environmental Regulation: Forty Years after EPA’s Founding 221
The Benefit of Environmental Regulation: Lower Pollution and
Health Gains 221
Air Pollution 221
Water Pollution 223
Drinking Water 224
The Costs of Regulation 225
Balancing Benefits vs. Costs: Risk Assessment and Risk Management 226
contents � ix
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Remaining Challenges: Climate Change 232
6.6 Conclusion 235
7 Health Policy 240
Introduction 241
7.1 Health Policy, Risk Pools, Adverse Selection, and Moral Hazard 243
Moral Hazard 245
Policy Solutions 247
7.2 Principal–Agent Problems and Health Care Markets 248
7.3 Health Outcomes in the United States and the World 249
7.4 American Health Policy and US National Health Care Programs 251
Obamacare 256
7.5 US Health National Government Health Care Programs 258
Medicaid 260
Child Health Insurance Program 261
Department of Defense and Veterans Administration 262
Indian Health Service 262
7.6 The Search for Health Care Price and Access 262
Taiwan’s Reforms 263
Oregon’s Medicaid Experiment 264
7.7 The Health Information Explosion 266
Digital Records 267
Medical Corporatization 267
7.8 Should We Ration Health Care? 268
7.9 Conclusion 269
8 Education 273
Introduction: Education Choices, Reforms, and Persistent Problems 274
8.1 Why Public Education? 275
The Value of Public Education and an Enlightened Citizenry 276
8.2 The Governance Structure of Education in the United States 276
Traditionally a State and Local Function 276
Variations in School Governance Finance 278
8.3 Education Quality in the United States 280
US Scores Rising 281
8.4 Federal Education Policy after Sputnik 282
The Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA) 283
No Child Left Behind 284
The Race to the Top 287
8.5 The Battle over Educational Content 289
The Anti-Evolution Movement 289
The Dover, PA Case 290
x � contents
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Pressures on Teachers 292
8.6 Delegation Problems in Public Schools 293
The Demand to Fulfill Multiple Roles 293
Principal–Agent Problems in Educational Performance 294
8.7 The Push for Early Childhood Education 299
Pre-kindergarten Expansions 300
8.8 Education Reforms 301
School Choice 301
Charter Schools 303
Charter Schools and the Harlem Children’s Zone 304
8.9 Higher Education in the United States 306
Concerns with Prices and Debt 307
Student Loan Debt and Higher Education: A Crisis? 307
Online Education 310
Affirmative Action in College Admissions 311
8.10 Conclusion 311
9 Crime and Punishment 316
Introduction 317
9.1 What Is Crime? 318
Measuring Crime 319
General Demographic Characteristics of Victims and Criminals of
Homicide 320
9.2 Why Do Individuals Engage in Crime? 321
An Expected Utility Model of Crime 322
Prospect Theory and Crime 324
Benefits and Costs of Criminal Success 325
Utility of Being Caught: Cost of Crime 328
Probability of Conviction 329
9.3 Strategies to Reduce Crime 330
Strategies that Reduce the Benefits of Crime 330
Economy 331
Education 332
Strategies that Decrease the Probability of Attaining Criminal Benefits 332
Strategies That Increase the Cost of Crime 333
Tough-on-Crime Policies 333
Public Education Programs 336
Strategies That Increase the Probability of Experiencing the Cost of Crime 338
Policing Strategies: Fixing Broken Windows 338
More Police 340
Who Gets Punished? 342
contents � xi
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
9.4 Abortion and Crime Rates 343
9.5 Capital Punishment 344
Punishment 345
Public Opinion and Capital Punishment 346
Principals, Agents, and Capital Punishment 348
9.6 Should Municipalities Increase Restrictions on Owning a Firearm? 348
9.7 Conclusion 350
10 Civil Rights 355
Introduction 356
10.1 Rights: Natural, Civil, and Human 356
10.2 Commitment Problems and Rights 358
Solutions to Commitment Problems 359
Civil Rights as a Commitment Problem 361
10.3 Political Speech 366
Campaign speech 367
The Fairness Doctrine 367
National Security and Free Speech 369
10.4 The Right to Privacy 371
Medical Records Privacy 372
Behavioral Targeting 374
10.5 The Right to Due Process of the Law 375
The Expansion of Marriage Rights 376
Due Process for People with Disabilities 379
10.6 Gender and the Right to Equal Pay for Equal Work 382
10.7 Conclusion 383
11 Homeland Security 387
Introduction 388
11.1 The Department of Homeland Security: An Example of Bureaucratic
Change 389
What Is Homeland Security? 389
What Is Bureaucracy? 390
Understanding Bureaucratic Change: Fire Alarms and Police Patrols 391
11.2 Homeland Security and Resource Allocation 395
Homeland Security as a Colonel Blotto Game 397
Security vs. Civil Liberties 399
Public Opinion on the Civil Liberties vs. Security Trade-Off 401
11.3 Principal–Agent Problems and Warrantless Wiretapping 403
The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) 404
PRISM 405
USA Freedom Act 407
xii � contents
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
11.4 Disaster Response as a Coordination Problem 407
11.5 Conclusion 411
12 Immigration Policy 415
Introduction 416
12.1 How Legal Immigration Works 417
Becoming a Legal Immigrant 418
Immigration and Citizenship 419
Non-Immigrant Visas 420
12.2 History of Immigration Policy 422
12.3 Why Do People Immigrate? 425
12.4 Economics of Immigration: Wages, Welfare, and Taxes 427
12.5 Immigrants and Assimilation 430
12.6 Illegal Immigration 432
Becoming an Illegal Immigrant 432
Why Is There Illegal immigration? 433
Addressing Illegal Immigration 434
New Requirements to Enter the Country 434
Border Fence 435
Work Force Audits 435
12.7 Immigration and Public Opinion 436
12.8 Collective Action, Credible Commitment Problems, and the Immigration
Reform Debate 439
12.9 Should the United States Repeal the Fourteenth Amendment? 441
12.10 Conclusion 442
13 Foreign and Defense Policy 446
Introduction 447
13.1 Principal–Agent Theory 449
Adverse Selection and Moral Hazard Problems 450
Standard Operating Procedures, Screening, and Outcome-Based
Incentives 451
13.2 Principal–Agent Problems and Foreign Policy 452
Gambling for Resurrection 452
Public Opinion and Foreign Policy 453
Public Opinion and Defense Spending 454
13.3 Principal–Agent Theory and the Iraq War 456
13.4 Diversionary Foreign Policy 458
13.5 Bargaining Failure and War 460
Strategies for Promoting Peace 463
Crisis Bargaining 465
contents � xiii
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
13.6 International Trade 469
Collective Action, Institutions, and Protectionism 472
13.7 Conclusion 474
Index 478
xiv � contents
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Figures
2.1 Possible Outcomes in a Simple Resource Allocation Game page 65
2.2 Choice Values in a Resource Allocation Game 66
2.3 Player Responses in a Resource Allocation Game 66
2.4 Resource Allocation Game with Defection Costs 71
2.5 Other Members Participating 75
3.1 Supply Curve 84
3.2 Supply Shift 85
3.3 Demand Curve 86
3.4 Supply and Demand Curves 87
3.5 Surplus and Shortage 88
3.6 Heritage Foundation’s Economic Freedom Scores 90
3.7 Goods Characteristics 94
3.8 Nutrition Facts 104
3.9 Ranked Funding Preferences by Legislator 106
3.10 Probabilities of a Cyclical Majority 107
4.1 Central Tendency and Dispersion 125
4.2 Inferential Statistics and Sampling Bias 131
4.3 Inferential Statistics 132
5.1 Laffer Curve 160
5.2 Earnings and Unemployment Rates by Educational Attainment 164
5.3 Satisfaction with Americans’ Opportunities to Get Ahead by Working Hard,
2001–14 Trend 170
5.4 Ultimatum Game 172
6.1 Negative Externalities and Dead Weight Loss 197
6.2 Salience of Environmental Regulation Relative to Other Issues 203
6.3 Effect of Information and Discussion on Citizen Support for Environmental
Policy 206
6.4 Trends in Air Pollution for Components Regulated by the Clean Air Act
(1980–2013) 222
6.5 Weather Variations vs. Climate Change 232
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
6.6 Human vs. Natural Sources of Global Temperature Increases 234
8.1 The Education Funding Pie, 2010 279
8.2 A Single Dimension in Policy Space 296
8.3 A Model of Legislator and Teacher Preferences with Uncertainty 298
8.4 Distribution of Student Loan Amounts 308
9.1 Homicide Rate Per 100,000 Population 319
9.2 Support for the Death Penalty, 1937–2009 346
9.3 Support for Death Penalty vs. Life Imprisonment 347
10.1 Civil Rights as a Credible Commitment Problem 362
10.2 Civil Rights as a Credible Commitment Problem 364
11.1 Major Functions in Homeland Security 390
11.2 Coordination Game on Which Movie to See 409
13.1 Support for President Bush’s Handling of the Iraq War 456
13.2 Crisis Bargaining Game 465
13.3 Scenario 1: Crisis Bargaining Game with Player Choices Highlighted 466
13.4 Scenario 2: Crisis Bargaining Game with Choices Highlighted 467
xvi � list of figures
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Tables
0.1 Areas of Opportunity for Making Public Policy page 5
0.2 Core Social Interaction Challenges 6
1.1 Cost-Benefit Analysis 34
5.1 Who Pays for Government? 163
5.2 Household Incomes in the United States 168
5.3 Factors Affecting Whether a Person Believes the Government Should Reduce Income
Differences between the Rich and the Poor 188
7.1 Oregon Health Insurance Experiment Treatment Effects 265
8.1 Number of Educational Institutions 1980–81, 1990–91, 2009–10 278
8.2 Effects on Math Scores and Absences for Charter vs. non-Charter Students 306
9.1 Who is Killed? Average Homicide Rates Per 100,000 People, By Age, Race, and
Gender, 1970s–2000s 321
9.2 Who Kills? Average Percentage of Homicides, By Age, Race, and Gender 321
9.3 The Impact on Violent and Property Crime of Imprisoning Drug Offenders Versus
Those Committing Other Types of Crimes 335
9.4 Changes in Crime as a Function of Abortion Rates 344
10.1 Should the Government require all radio and television stations to offer equal
amounts of liberal and conservative radio and television stations to offer equal
amounts of liberal and conservative political commentary? 368
10.2 Americans’ Opinions Regarding Surveillance 370
10.3 Practices with Electronic Health Records 373
10.4 Public Opinion Toward Recognition of Same-Sex Marriage 376
10.5 Public Opinion Toward Gay and Lesbian Rights and Public Policy 378
10.6 Diagnoses of College Students with Disabilities, 2008-09 381
11.1 Multiple Regression Estimates on Pro-Civil Liberties Responses 402
12.1 Persons Obtaining Legal Permanent Resident Status by Type and Major Class of
Admission: Fiscal Years 2000–2009 419
12.2 Persons Obtaining Legal Permanent Resident Status by Region: 1900–2009 422
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
12.3 Multiple Regression Predicting Support for H-1B Visas 438
13.1 Support for Military Spending among Party Activists and Identifiers 455
13.2 Labor Hours to Produce T-Shirts and Computers 470
13.3 Opportunity Cost of Producing T-Shirts and Computers 470
xviii � list of tables
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Preface: DemocraticPolicymaking
Public policy is the core of politics. Understanding how public policy is created is an
essential component of a liberal education. In this book we challenge students to think
critically about why policies are the way they are. Developing such an understanding
among students can help them work to demand and create better public policies.
We wrote this book as a result of our experience teaching introductory public policy
courses over the course of a decade. Our goal was to combine the dense policy
description that often is provided in undergraduate texts with the analytic rigor that
is available in more advanced policy analysis books and research that draws from
academic and scientific sources. We taught from a blend of descriptive texts and more
analytic texts and found it difficult to hit the right note: the books were typically too
much of one and too little of the other, too much of both, or too little of both. We
believe this book strikes a good balance between the descriptive and analytic. We’ve
taught versions of the book to large classes over the past four semesters and have
received positive reviews on it from students. We hope you have the same experience.
Democratic Policymaking assumes that students have a rudimentary understanding
of political systems, on the level of a good high school civics course. Students who have
completed an introductory American or comparative government course should be
able to understand the text with little difficulty. We have taught the text to under-
graduate students from a variety of majors, including the social sciences, business,
natural sciences, and liberal arts, and we have encountered little difficulty in their
ability to comprehend the materials.
We apply a broad theoretical framework that allows students to analyze core
challenges in the formation and implementation of all public policies; we apply the
scientific method to evaluate empirical evidence on public policies; and we draw on
contemporary professional public policy scholarship. We believe this distinguishes our
approach in Democratic Policymaking from that of the majority of texts that are
available for general public policy courses.
Cambridge University Press978-0-521-19287-3 — Democratic Policymaking
Charles Barrilleaux , Christopher Reenock , Mark Souva
Frontmatter
More Information
www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press
Our analytical approach focuses on what individuals want and how institutions,
interactions with others, and the context in which individuals operate affect the
policies that are produced. We highlight the value of the scientific method, which is
critical for evaluating and improving public policy. The scientific method leads to
better policy evaluation because its process is transparent. Students who understand
the scientific method will have a better understanding of the key questions to ask when
someone presents evidence in support of a position. Those students will understand
that not all evidence or all data is equal. Discriminating between good data and bad
data is a key part of a liberal education and aids the creation and implementation of
public policy. We pursue these goals by drawing on contemporary scholarship. We
draw on recent, scientifically based works as the evidentiary base for our substantive
evaluations of policy because such research forms the foundation of public policy as an
academic field and the motivation for many real-world public policies.
The first four chapters provide the theoretical and analytic foundation for the text.
Following those chapters, instructors may choose among substantive policy topics they
wish to teach in a given semester. Each of the substantive chapters incorporates one or
more of the analytic tools, and we note which tools are being emphasized in the
beginning of each chapter, so instructors may choose based on substance or analytics
what they wish to teach, or may teach the entire text over the course of the semester.
To summarize, Democratic Policymaking
� Introduces and applies a few models that are helpful for students learning about
public policy.
� Helps students to learn by example by applying the models that are included in
substantive chapters.
� Provides a more rigorous analytic framework than most introductory texts.
� Provides students and instructors with a full set of slides for use with each chapter.
� Provides instructors with a test bank.
� Uses examples from existing scientific and public policy studies to illustrate import-
ant concepts.
� Blends elements of introductory and more advanced public policy texts so that
instructors who wish to instruct students on elements of critical thinking may do so
in a single text.
� Enables instructors to pick and choose among the substantive topics they wish to
cover in a class.
xx � preface