Upload
others
View
6
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
DESIGN OF AN OVERFLOW CONCRETE WEIR FOR
UNIVERSITY OF ILORIN SUGARCANE RESEARCH FIELDS
BY
ADEBAYO, LUKMAN
(08/30GB092)
JULY, 2012.
ii
DESIGN OF AN OVERFLOW CONCRETE WEIR FOR
UNIVERSITY OF ILORIN SUGARCANE RESEARCH FIELDS
BY
ADEBAYO, LUKMAN (08/30GB092)DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
UNIVERSITY OF ILORINILORIN, NIGERIA.
A PROJECT REPORT SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF CIVILENGINEERING, UNIVERSITY OF ILORIN, IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT
OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF BACHELOR OFENGINEERING DEGREE IN CIVIL ENGINEERING
JULY, 2012.
iii
CERTIFICATION
This project has been read and approved as meeting the requirements of the
department of Civil Engineering, University of Ilorin, for the award of Bachelor
of Engineering (B. Eng) degree in Civil Engineering.
……………………........... …………………..Dr. O.G. Okeola DATESupervisor
……………………......... …………………..Dr. A.A. Jimoh DATEHead of Department
……………………............. ....…………………EXTERNAL EXAMINER DATE
iv
DEDICATION
This project is dedicated to Almighty Allah, the source of my inspiration. Also
to my parents and my boy, Abdulsamad Opeyemi for inspiring my dream.
v
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I am grateful to Almighty God who saw me through my academic programme
in this noble institution. Also I acknowledge my parents and siblings for their
unconditional love and support.
My sincere appreciation goes to my esteem supervisor and able lecturer,
Dr. O.G. Okeola, for all the support he gave me throughout this project work. I
cannot mention them all but I just pray Almighty ALLAH continue to
replenished him in His infinite mercy. I am heartily thankful to everybody that
made my stay in this institution easy and contribute to my success today most
especially Mr Wahab Yunus for granting me access to his computer system.
Jazakumul-llah khaeran.
vi
ABSTRACT
The proposed overflow concrete weir for University of Ilorin sugarcane
research fields was intended to improve the water storage needed to
irrigate the farm and also to control the flood hazards at the downstream
communities. The Snyder and Soil Conservation Service (SCS) methods of
hydrograph analysis were used and the maximum 24-hr rainfall depth of
50yrs return period for the river Oyun catchment was estimated using the
Snyder method as 180.56m3/s.
The estimated peak flow was adopted for the design of the weir. The
length of the overflow weir is 30m, the total depth of the water above the
weir base on 50yrs returned period was estimated as 1.02m. This implies
that there is about 29% increase in the total depth of water above the
overflow weir. The determined height of the concrete weir and base width
were 2.5m and 2.0m respectively. The criteria for the weir stability were
also satisfied.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENT
Title page `i
Certification ii
Dedication iii
Acknoledgement iv
Abstract v
Table of content vi
List of tables ix
List of figures ix
CHAPTER ONE: Introduction
1.1 General information 1
1.2 Justification of the study 4
1.3 Scope of the project 4
1.4 Description of study area 5
CHAPTER TWO: Literature Review
2.1 General review 7
2.2 Theory of unit hydrograpy 8
2.2.1 Snyder method 8
2.2.2 Soil conservation service (SCS) method 9
2.2.3 Unit hydrograph derivation 9
2.3 Weir 10
2.3.1 Types of weir 10
2.3.1.1 Broad-crested weir 11
2.3.1.2 Sharp crested weir 11
2.3.1.3 Combination weir 11
viii
2.3.1.4 V-notch weir 12
2.3.1.5 Minimum energy loss weir 12
2.4 Civil engineering standard method of measurement 13
2.4.1 Preparation of bill of quantities 13
2.4.1.1 Preamble 14
2.4.1.2 Preliminaries 14
2.4.1.3 Coding and numbering 15
CHAPTER THREE: Methodology
3.1 Data collection 16
3.2 Calculation of unit hydrograph characteristics 18
3.2.1 Snyder method 18
3.2.1.1 Lag time 18
3.2.1.2 Basin lag time 18
3.2.1.3 Peak discharge 19
3.2.1.4 Peak discharge per unit area 20
3.2.1.5 Base time 21
3.2.1.6 Width estimation of unit hydrograph 21
3.2.2 Soil conservation service method 22
3.2.2.1 Convertion factors 24
3.2.3 Development of design storm hydrograph 25
3.3 Design of concrete weir
3.3.1 Water pressure on overflow section 29
3.3.2 Estimation of water pressure and overturning moment 31
3.3.3 Force due to selfweight and resisting moment 32
3.3.4 Stability analysis 33
3.3.5 Uplift force on the base of concrete weir 35
3.3.6 Uplift pressure in the body of the concrete weir 36
ix
3.3.7 Vertical stress on the concrete weir 37
3.3.8 Principal and Shearing stresses at the toe 37
3.4 Concrete volume 38
3.5 Preparation of bill of quantity 39
3.5.1 Quantity computation 39
CHAPTER FOUR: Results and Discussion
4.0 Results and Discussion 40
CHAPTER FIVE:Conclusion and Recommendation
5.1 Conclusion 41
5.2 Recommendation 41
References 42
x
LIST OF TABLES
Table Description Page
3.1 Watershed parameter for river Oyun 18
3.2 Synthetic unit hydrograph parameter for 10hrs storm duration 20
3.3 Storm hydrograph ordinate for Oyun watershed 26
3.4 Coordinates of the design hydrograph 28
3.5 Forces due to self-weight and resisting moment 33
3.6 Design parameter for the concrete weir from the analysis 38
3.7 Bill of engineering measurement and evaluation 39
xi
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Description Page
1.1 Existing weir discharging water to the downstream side 6
1.2 Existing weir showing the water reservoir at the upstream side 6
3.1 Satellite imagery showing the location of the existing weir 17
3.2 A plot of 50-yr, 24-hr storm hydrograph 27
3.3 Hydrograph curve showing a plot of discharge againt time 29
3.4 Concrete weir section and pressure diagram 30
3.5 Concrete weir section divided into three sections 31
3.6 Uplift pressure diagram when there is water on the
downstream side 35
3.7 Uplift pressure diagram in the body of the concrete weir 36
xii
NOTATION
∅ Angle made by axial force to the vertical at the downstream
Storage coefficient
Storm duration
Overturning stability
Sliding stability
vertical stress on the concrete weir
Hydraulic height
Height of the concrete weir
Overturning moment
Resisting moment
Horizontal component of the force due to water pressure
Peak discharge
Base time
TIme to peak
Uplift pressure
Velocity head of water
Width estimation of 50% unit hydrograph
Width estimation of 75% unit hydrograph
Peak discharge per unit area
Bsin lag time
Time to recession
Top width of the weir
Base top width of the weir
Density of water
Principal stresses
xiii
Shearing stresses
A catchment area
Ct Coefficient representing variation of watershed
D Duration of excess rainfall
L river length
tL Length outlet to control
Base width
Runoff volume
Eccentricity
The value of each unit of time on the dimensionless hydrograph
Moment arm
The ratio of the total runoff volume to the area under dimenssionless
hydrograph
The ratio of the peak runoff for the design storm to peak flow of 100
units on the dimensionless hydrograph
Weight of the cocrete weir
Centroid
Point at which act from the toe of the weir
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
1
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 General Introduction
Flood prediction is an essential tool in the design of dam, drainages, weirs,
culverts, and all other flood control structures. Thus flood prediction otherwise
known as the peak flow prediction refers to the process of transformation of
rainfall into a flood hydrograph and to the translation of that hydrograph
throughout a watershed or any other hydrologic system (Ramirez, 2000).
The theory of unit hydrograph was developed by Sherman and has been
subjected to modifications by a number of researchers, but the basic principles
have remained unchanged. The unit hydrograph (UH) of a drainage basin is
defined as the hydrograph of direct runoff resulting from 1cm of excess runoff
generated uniformly over the basin at a uniform rate from a storm with
specified durations (Salami, 2010). The duration of the unit volume of excess or
effective rainfall, sometimes referred to as the effective duration, defines and
labels the particular unit hydrograph. The unit volume is usually considered to
be associated with 1cm of effective rainfall distributed uniformly over the
basin area.
The study of unit hydrograph used covers basically two methods; the Snyder
and the soil conservation service (SCS). The ordinate of the unit hydrograph
was picked at 1hr interval and used to generate storm hydrographs from which
the peak flow of 50yr return period were determined for the design of
concrete weir. The volume of concrete required for the construction of the
weir was estimated and subsequently used to calculate the cost. The unit
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
2
hydrograph was adopted due to lack of hydrological data at the site. The
method of developing hydrograph without stream flow data are usually
affected by the watershed characteristics. These characteristics include the
area of the watershed, land slope, channel slope, channel length, soil type,
vegetation cover, land used and channel roughness. Each of these
characteristics plays a significant role in the resulting hydrograph for the
watershed.
Sule et al., (2011) recommend that the synthetic unit hydrograph development
method of storm hydrograph should not be used in catchments with an area
greater than 500 kilometer square, where the assumption of nearly uniform
net rainfall cannot be justified. Conversely, it may be argued that in large
catchments, the existence of spatial and temporal averaging coupled with the
dominance of channel routing, means a linear model (unit hydrograph) may be
highly appropriate.
It is therefore desirable to evaluate or examine and compare the storm
hydrograph model of Snyder and United states soil conservation service (SCS),
using river Oyun with catchment area of 573 kilometer square to explore the
most efficient model in the determination of design peak flow. There have
been many studies that relate hydrograph features to watershed
characteristics. A storm hydrograph is as a result of the complex effects of
rainstorm, watershed characteristics and soil moisture within the basin prior to
the storm.
Snyder developed empirical formula using the morphological characteristics of
the watershed. The United States soil conservation service (SCS) synthetic unit
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
3
hydrograph method was based on methods well established to overcome the
non-availability of data in an ungauged watershed. Hence the need for a
thorough comparison of the two methods since the outcome is of immense
benefits to man and his environment.
This studies aims at evaluating each of the two methods and comparing the
different hydrograph development to facilitate the design of an overflow
concrete weir. A concrete overflow weir is a solid structure, made of concrete
or masonry, constructed across a river to create a reservoir at its upstream
(Ahmad, 2004). The section of a concrete weir is approximately triangular in
shape, with its apex at the top and maximum width at the bottom. The section
is so proportioned that it resists the various forces acting on it by its own
weight. Early concrete weirs were built of masonry, but most of the modern
weirs were built of concrete.
Concrete weir is usually provided with overflow spillway in some portion of its
length. The weir thus consists of two sections namely; the non-overflow
section and the overflow section or spillway section. The design in this report is
for the overflow section. The weight of the dam is the main stabilizing force in
a gravity dam. For computation, the cross sectional area of the weir is divides
into simple shapes, triangle, rectangle, etc. where the area and centriod can
easily be calculated. Hence, weight components can be found.
Water pressure acts on the upstream i.e. the direction of the water current
(the upstream pressure is the main overturning force) and on the downstream
i.e. tail water pressure helps in the stability. The weir is under an uplift
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
4
pressure when water enters the pores, thereby creating cracks and fissures
within the weir body and acts in all directions.
1.2 Justification of the Study
In most watersheds in Nigeria, there is considerable lack of data with regard to
rainfall and river discharges. This study aims at evaluating different storm
hydrographs development methods by generating the peak flows at a
predicted return period to facilitate the design of weir across a tributary of
river Oyun as a case study.
1.3 Objectives of the Study
This project is aimed at the design of an overflow concrete weir for University
of Ilorin sugarcane research fields. The specific objectives of the study include:
1. To evaluate storm hydrograph on Oyun river basin using the Snyder and
soil conservation service (SCS) unit hydrograph methods.
2. To produce a satisfactory correlation between rainfall and runoff such
that rainfall excess runoff can be predicted.
3. To make comparison between peak flows obtained using the Snyder and
SCS methods based on different return periods.
4. To design an overflow weir base on predicted peak flow.
5. To give recommendation with respect to safety of the concrete weir in
the immediate community.
1.4 Scope of the Project
The procedure utilized in the hydrograph generation was limited to the
development of unit and storm hydrograph based on Snyder and SCS synthetic
unit hydrograph methods. It illustrates the accuracy and application of the
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
5
relations developed for the computation of synthetic unit hydrographs for
Oyun river basin. Comparison of discharges by the two methods for 50yrs
return periods and the design of overflow concrete weir using the peak
discharges estimated from the unit hydrograph ordinates obtained from
Snyder method.
1.5 Description of Study Area
The catchment of Oyun river lies within Kwara state. Its total area is 573km2,
the maximum length of this catchment is 48.30km and the average slope of the
area is 0.003%. The topography is a fair representative of surrounding plains
which can be described as undulating with very broad and gentle slopes
(Salami, 2010).
The weir is located downstream of the University of Ilorin dam. The stream
serves as the main source of water for University of Ilorin campus and also the
major source for irrigating the sugarcane fields. Figure 1.1 represents the study
location showing the existing weir discharging water to the downstream side
of the river while Figure 1.2 represents the water reservoir at the upstream
side of the existing weir.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
6
Figure 1.1: The existing weir discharging water to the downstream side.
Figure 1.2: The existing weir showing the water reservoir at the upstream side.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
7
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 General Review
The unit hydrograph is a method of estimating runoff. It was reported by
Ramirez (2000) that unit hydrograph was first proposed by Sherman in 1932
and since then it has been used as a key concept. The unit hydrograph is
defined as the watershed response to a unit depth of excess rainfall uniformly
distributed over the entire watershed and applied at a constant rate to a given
period of time.
A significant contribution to the unit hydrograph theory was given by Clark
1945 who proposed a unit hydrograph based on combination of a pure
translation routine process followed by a pure routine process. Although Clark
does not develop a spatial distributed analysis, the translation part of the
routine process is based on the time area diagram of the watershed. The
storage part consists of routine and response of the translation through a
linear reservoir located at the watershed outlet. The detention time of the
reservoir is selected in order to reproduce the falling limb of observed
hydrographs. Note that the actual traveling time of a water particle, according
to this approach is the travel time given by the time-area diagram plus the
detention time of the reservoir which is somewhat inconsistent.
Many components of the rainfall-runoff process in a catchment are difficult to
observe routinely and unambiguously as they require costly measuring
facilities. An important component of this process is the runoff volume whose
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
8
temporal variation needed to determine yield of a catchment besides use in
many hydrological applications such as bridges, dams, reservoirs etc.
Salami (2010) reported that Chow et al., (1988) discussed the derivation of unit
hydrograph and its linear system theory. Furthermore Viessman et al., (1989)
and Arora (2004) presented the history and procedure for several unit and
runoff hydrograph methods. Ogunlela and Kasali (2002) applied four methods
of unit hydrographs generation to develop unit hydrograph for an unguaged
watershed. The outcome of the study revealed that there are significantly
differences in these methods except for Snyder and SCS methods which were
not significantly different from each other. Salami et al., (2010) came out with
a report that the designed concrete overflow weir over river Wuruma will
improve water supply to Kiaima, headquarters of Kiaima LGA in Kwara state.
Some of the unit hydrograph authorities are Snyder (1938), Taylor and Schwarz
(1952), Soil conservation service SCS (1957), Gray (1961), Espey and Winslow
(1974) are available in hydrological literature (Ayanshola et al., 2009).
2.2 Theory of Unit Hydrograph
2.2.1 Snyder Method
The synthetic unit hydrograph of Snyder is based on relationships found
between three characteristics of a standard unit hydrograph and descriptors of
basin morphology (Ramirez, 2000). These relationships are based on a study of
20 watersheds located in the Appalachian Highlands and varying in size from
10 to 10,000 square miles. The hydrograph characteristics are the effective
rainfall duration, tr, the peak direct runoff rate qp, and the basin lag time tl and
from these relationships, five characteristics of a required unit hydrograph for
a given effective rainfall duration may be calculated. These characteristics
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
9
include the peak discharge per unit of watershed area, , the basin lag, tlr,
the base time, and the widths, (in time unit) of the unit hydrograph at 50
and 75 percent of the peak discharge.
2.2.2 Soil Conservation Service (SCS) Method
The dimensionless unit hydrograph developed by the soil conservation service
has been obtained from the UH’s for a greater number of watersheds of
different sizes and for many different locations. The SCS dimensionless
hydrograph is a synthetic UH in which the discharge is expressed as the ratio of
discharge, q, to peak discharge, qp and the time by the ratio of time, t, to time
to peak of the UH, tp. Given the peak discharge and the lag time for the
duration of the excess rainfall, the UH can be estimated from the synthetic
dimensionless hydrograph for the given basin (Suresh, 2005).
2.2.3 Unit Hydrograph Derivation
To derive the unit hydrograph from a simple rainstorm divide the direct
discharge values of time-discharge curve by the height of effective rainfall to
get the unit hydrograph. Suppose that there are M pulses of excess rainfall and
N pulses of direct runoff are observed in a storm. Then N-M+1 value will be
needed to define the unit hydrograph. The discrete convolution equation,
given below allows the computation of direct runoff Qn given excess rainfall Pm
and the unit hydrograph Un-m+1.The reverse process is called deconvolution
(Uditha, 2011).
Mn
1m1mnmn UPQ (2.1)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
10
2.3 Weir
A weir is a small overflow dam used to alter the flow characteristics of a river or
stream (Wikipedia, 2011). In most cases weirs take the form of a barrier across the
river that causes water to pool behind the structure (not unlike a dam), but allows
water to flow over the top. Weirs are commonly used to alter the flow regime of
the river, prevent flooding, measure discharge and to help render a river
navigable. Some old world famous weirs includes the weir on the Humber River
near Raymore park in Ontario, Toronto, the weir at the Thorp grist mill in Thorp,
Washington, the weir in Warkworth, New Zealand (Wikipedia, 2011).
Weirs allow hydrologist and engineers a simple method of measuring the
volumetric flow rate in small to medium-sized streams, or in industrial
discharge locations. Since the geometry of the top of the weir is known, and all
water flows over the weir, the depth of water behind the weir can be
converted to a rate of flow. The calculation relies on the fact that fluid will pass
through the critical depth of the flow regime in the vicinity of the crest of the
weir. If water is not carried away from the weir, it can make flow measurement
complicated or even impossible. A weir may be used to maintain the vertical
profile of a stream or channel, and is then commonly referred to as a grade
stabilizer such as the weir in Duffield, Derbyshire (Wikipedia, 2011).
2.3.1 Types of Weir
There are different types of weir. It may be a simple metal plate with a V-notchcut into it or it may be a concrete and steel structure across the bed of a river.A weir that causes a large change of water level behind it as compared to theerror inherent in the depth measurement method will give an accurateindication of the flow rate. Some weirs are used as bridges for people to walkalong.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
11
2.3.1.1 Broad-crested weir
A broad-crested weir is a flat-crested structure with a long crest compared to
the flow thickness (Sturm 2001; Chanson 2004). When the crest is broad, the
streamlines become parallel to the crest invert and the pressure distribution
above the crest is hydrostatic. The hydraulic characteristics of broad-crested
weirs were studied during the 19th and 20th centuries. Practical experience
showed that the weir overflow is affected by the upstream flow conditions and
the weir.
2.3.1.2 Sharp crested weir
A sharp-crested weir allows the water to fall freely away from the weir. Sharp
crested weirs are typically 1/4" or thinner metal plates. Sharp crested weirs
come in many different shapes such as rectangular, V-notch and Cipolletti
weirs (Wikipedia, 2011).
2.3.1.3 Combination weir
The sharp crested weirs can be grouped into three groups according to the
geometry of weir: (a) the rectangular (b) the V or triangular notch and (c)
special notches, such as trapezoidal, circular or parabolic. For accurate flow
measurement over a wider range of flow rates, a combine V-notch with a
rectangular weir can be employed.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
12
2.3.1.4 V-notch weir
The V-notch weir is a triangular channel section used to measure small
discharge values. The upper edge of the section is always above the water level
and so the channel is always triangular simplifying calculation of the cross-
sectional area. V-notch weirs are preferred for low discharges as the head
above the weir crest is more sensitive to changes in flow compared to
rectangular weirs.
2.3.1.5 Minimum energy loss weir
The concept of the Minimum Energy Loss (MEL) structure was developed by
Gordon McKay in 1971. The first MEL structure was the Redcliff storm
waterway system, also called Humpy bong Creek drainage outfall, completed
in 1960 in the Redcliff peninsula in Australia (Wikipedia, 2011). It consisted of
MEL weir acting as a streamlined drop inlet followed by a 137 m long culvert
discharging into the Pacific Ocean. The weir was designed to prevent beach
sand being washed in and choking the culvert as well as to prevent salt
intrusion in Humpy bong Creek without a flux. The structure is still in use and
passed floods greater than the design flow in several instances without
flooding (Chanson, 2004).
The concept of the Minimum Energy Loss (MEL) weir was developed to pass
large floods with minimum energy loss and afflux, and nearly-constant total
head along the waterway. The flow in the approach channel is contracted
through a streamlined chute and the channel width is minimum at the chute
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
13
toe, just before impinging into the downstream natural channel. The inlet and
chute are streamlined to avoid significant form losses and the flow may be
critical from the inlet lip to the chute toe at design flow. MEL weirs were
designed specifically for situations where the river catchment is characterized
by torrential rain falls and by very small bed slope.
2.4 Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement (CESMM)
The main purpose of the Bill of Quantities is to assist the contractors to
produce an accurate tender figure efficiently and to enable post contract
administration in carried out an efficient and cost-effective manner. Estimation
is the process of pricing based on the available information, specification, and
various drawings toward arriving at total sum known as tender sum. This is to
be done within the context of form of contract and terms in which the sum will
apply (Okeola, 2012). Cost index is a tool used for project estimation and even
cost control for this reason correct application must be made to suit individual
and locality situations
2.4.1 Preparation of Bill of Quantities
Bill of Quantities is more appropriate to a building contract where the general
summary contains a list of individual Bills. In civil engineering documents the
equivalent Bills are called Parts so the overall document is a Bill of Quantities.
The pre-contract exercise of measuring the work also applies to the post-
contract task of measurement. The correct term for this task is re-
measurement where the work is physically measured on site or
admeasurement where the actual quantities are calculated from records.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
14
There are five sections in the Bill of Quantities. These sections include:
1. Preamble
2. List of Principal Quantities
3. Day work Schedule
4. Work Items (divided into parts)
5. Grand Summary
2.4.1.1 Preamble
The Preamble is an extremely important section of the Bill of Quantities and is
the potentially vital source of information to the estimator. If any other
Methods of Measurement have been used in the preparation of the Bill of
Quantities, the fact should be recorded there (Okeola, 2012). For this study the
material cost such as cost of concrete per meter cube was sourced from the
chief quantity surveyor of the University of Ilorin, physical planning unit. Also
some other cost such as the cost of demolition of the existing weir was
sampled from some artisans in Tanke tipper garage.
2.4.1.2 Preliminaries
The preliminaries section of the bill of quantities is the engineer or QS’s
introduction to the contract. The section provides information on the location,
size, and complexity of the project and gives details of the conditions of
contract under which the project is to be implemented (Okeola, 2012). This
aspect is of huge important to this study considering the complexity of the
work and the proximity to the area. In this view, the cost in the preliminaries
cover mobilization of workers and equipment, channelization of the river,
provision of access route to the area e.t.c.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
15
2.4.1.3 Coding and numbering
The aim of the coding is to produce a uniformity of presentation to assist the
needs of the estimator and the post-contract administration. There is a typical
presentation of coding and numbering of estimated items in the bill of
engineering measurement and evaluation (BEME) of this report (Table 3.7).
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
16
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Data Collection
The catchment of river Oyun is located between latitude 90 50’ and 80 24’ North
and longitude 40 38’ and 40 03’ East (Ayanshola et al., 2009). Oyun river lies
entirely within Kwara state of Nigeria and the river flow across University of
Ilorin campus. The project site is downstream of University of Ilorin dam.
River Oyun covers a catchment area of 573 km2 and the length of the river is
48.30 km to the weir axis. The method employed in the collection of the data
involves the collection of the topographical map covering the project site.
Figure 3.1 shows the satellite imagery of the case study. The catchment area,
the river length, the length along the main stream to a point nearest to the
basin centroid, catchment slope and the channel slope were obtained from
Sule et al., (2011).
Snyder and the soil conservation services (SCS) methods were used to generate
the peak discharge and the storm hydrograph of 50yrs return period were
determined. The peak flows obtained were subsequently used in the design of
the concrete weir. The watershed characteristics of the river are presented in
Table 3.1
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
17
Figure 3.1: Satellite imagery showing the location of the existing weir.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
18
Table 3.1 Watershed parameters for River Oyun.
A L Lc Ct Cp TL D Sc(km2) (km) (km) (hr) (hr)
573 48.30 27.87 1.60 0.6 10.00 1.82 0.003Source: Sule et al.,(2011).
3.2 Calculation of Unit Hydrograph (UH) Characteristics
Catchments area A =573 km2
River Length L = 48.30 km
Length (outlet to control) Lc=27.86km
3.2.1 Snyder Method
3.2.1.1 Lag time tL
tL = Ct (L x Lc)0.3 (3.1)
Ct is a coefficient representing variation of watershed slope and storage which
ranges from 1.0 to 2.2 (Arora, 2004). An average value of 1.60 was assumed
the best for the catchment.
tL= 1.6(48.30 × 27.86)0.3= 9.998≅ 103.2.1.2 Basin lag time
Adjusted basin lag time for 1hr storm duration is given ast = t + 0.25(D − D) (3.2)
WhereD = 1hrstormdurationand D = .∴ = . = 1.82hrs
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
19
1. for 1hr storm duration, Basin lag time= 10 + 0.28(1 − 1.182)= 9.80hrs2. for 2hr sstorm duration, Basin lag time= 10 + 0.28(2 − 1.182)= 10.05
The same procedure was followed for storm duration of 3 to 10hrs and the
value of basin lag time obtained are presented in Table 3.2.
3.2.1.3Peak discharge PQ
The peak discharge '
78.2
L
pp t
ACQ (3.3)
Where A is the catchment area, is the basin lag time for each storm duration
and is a storage coefficient varying from 0.4 to 0.8 (Suresh, 2005). An
average value of 0.6 was used for .
1. pQ for 1hr storm duration8.9
5736.078.21
pQ
smQp /53.97 31
2. pQ for 2hrs storm duration05.10
5736.078.22
pQ
2pQ = 95.10 /The same procedure was followed for storm duration of 3 to 10hrs and the
values of peak discharge obtained are presented in Table 3.2
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
20
Table 3.2 Synthetic unit hydrograph parameter for10hrs storm duration
D Tl Qp qp Tb W50 W75
(hr) (hr) (m3/s) (m3/s/km2) (hr) (hr) (hr)
1.0 9.80 97.53 0.170 101.52 39.99 23.05
2.0 10.05 95.10 0.166 102.15 41.03 23.65
3.0 10.30 92.80 0.162 102.90 42.13 24.94
4.0 10.55 90.60 0.158 103.65 43.28 24.94
5.0 10.80 88.50 0.154 104.40 44.50 25.64
6.0 11.05 86.50 0.151 105.15 45.45 26.19
7.0 11.30 84.58 0.148 105.90 46.45 26.77
8.0 11.55 82.75 0.144 106.65 47.84 27.57
9.0 11.80 81.00 0.141 106.65 48.94 28.21
10.0 12.05 79.32 0.138 108.15 50.09 28.87
3.2.1.4 Peak discharge per unit area
The value of peak discharge per unit area is presented mathematically as
(3.4)A
Qq p
p
Where is the peak discharge and A is the catchment area.
1. for 1hr storm duration is= = 97.53 3/573 2= 0.170 / /2. for 2hrs storm duration is= = . /
= 0.166 / /The same procedure was followed for storm duration of 3 to 10hrs and the
values of peak discharge per unit area obtained are presented in Table 3.2
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
21
3.2.1.5 Base time
For a small watershed, the base time is determined by multiplying by a value
ranging from 3 to 5 (Ward, 2004). Therefore, for this study,= 3 + ʹ(3.5)
1 for 1hr storm duration
880.931 bT
daysTb 27.41 .52.101 hrs
2 for 2hrs storm duration
805.1032 bT = 4.29 ≅ 102.15 .
The same procedure was followed for storm duration of 3 to 10 hrs and the
values of Base time obtained are presented in Table 3.2
3.2.1.6 Width estimation of unit hydrograph
It is possible to sketch many UHs through three known characteristic points of
the UH (i.e , , ) with its specific criteria i.e the area under the
synthetic unit hydrograph to be unity. To overcome this ambiguity associated
with the Snyder’s method, the US Army Corps of Engineers developed
empirical equation between widths of UH of 50% and 75% of i.e W50 and
W75 respectively as a function of expressible as
W50= 770( )-1.08 ; W75 = 440( )-1.08 Where 770 and 440 should be replaced
with 5.9 and 3.4 when metric unit system are used (Bhunya, 2011).
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
22
1. for 1hr storm duration
W50 = .. = .. .W50 .99.39 hrs
W75 = .. = .. .W75 .05.23 hrs
2. for 2hrs storm duration
W50 = .. = .. . = 41.03W75 = .. = .. . = 23.65
The same procedure was followed for storm duration of 3 to 10 hrs and the
values of base width of unit hydrograph obtained are presented in Table 3.2
3.2.2 Soil Conservation Service (SCS) Method
The SCS dimensionless hydrograph arbitrarily has units of 100 units of flow for
the peak and 100 units of time for the duration of flow. The area under
dimensionless hydrograph has 2620 square units of runoff. The SCS
hydrograph has 19 constant ordinates that represent the percentage of flow
and time (Uditha, 2011).
The following procedures are used to derive the design hydrograph
(Uditha, 2011):
(i) The Lag time ( ) can be estimated from the watershed characteristics
using curve number (CN) procedure as= 5.07.
7.08.0
1410486.222540YCN
CNLo
(3.6)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
23
Where is the lag time in hours; L is the hydraulic length of watershed in (m);
CN is the curve number (50 ≤ 95); and Y is the average catchment slope in
(m/m) (Bhunya, 2011). With the CN = 75 based on soil group B, lowest runoff
potential, includes deep sands with very little silt and clay
(Ayanshola et al., 2009).
5.07.0
7.08.0
003.075141047586.22254048300
= .. hrs76.38
(ii) Duration of rainfall excess D = . (3.7)= .. = 7.047(iii) Time to peak
Tp = tL + (3.8)
Tp = 38.76 +.
Tp = 42.28 hrs.
(iv) Time to recession
trc= 1.67tp (3.9)= 1.67 × 42.28= 70.61(v) Peak discharge in ⁄= . ( ) = . ×. (3.10)= 28.19 ⁄
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
24
(vi) Peak discharge per unit area (qp).= = .(3.11)= 0.0492 /⁄
(vii) Base time Tb in hrs.= + (3.12)= 42.28 + 70.61= 112.89(viii) Runoff volume V in= = . × .
(3.13)= 2.78 km3.2.2.1 Conversion factors
There are three sealing factors used in the dimensionless hydrograph. These
factors include (Uditha, 2011):
(i) The ratio of the total runoff volume to the area under dimensionless
hydrograph u.= = .(3.14)= 1.06 × 10 .⁄
(ii) The second factor is w and is the ratio of the peak runoff for the
design storm to the peak flow of 100 units on the dimensionless
hydrograph, generally found with the SCS peak flow equation.
(Uditha, 2011). Expressed as= = .(3.15)= 0.2819 /⁄
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
25
(iii) The third factor k, is the value that each unit of time on the
dimensionless hydrograph represents in the design hydrograph. Thus= = × . ×. (3.16)= 0.63 ⁄The coordinate of the design hydrograph are obtained by multiplying the flow
and time ordinate of the dimensionless hydrograph by ‘w’ and ‘k’ respectively,
as shown in Table 3.3. The values for ‘w’ and ‘k’ are used to plot the unit
hydrograph curve as presented in Figure3.2.
3.2.3 Development of Design Storm Hydrograph
The established unit hydrograph ordinates were used to develop the storm
hydrographs due to actual rainfall event over the watershed. Peak storm
hydrograph for 50yrs return period was developed through convolution. The
maximum 24-hr rainfall depths of the different recurrence interval for the
catchment under consideration are 144.99mm (Salami et al., 2010). The storm
hydrograph was derived from a multi-period of rainfall excess called
hydrograph convolution. It involves multiplying the unit hydrograph ordinates
(Un) by incremental rainfall excess (Pn), adding and lagging in a sequence to
produce a resulting storm hydrograph. Table 3.3 was developed from the
convolution of the unit hyrograph from which Figure 3.2 was ploted using
column 9 againts column 1.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
26
Table 3.3 Storm hydrograph ordinate for Oyun watershed
UH StormTime Ordinate P1Un P2Un P3Un P4Un P5Un P6Un Hydrograph(hr) Un
(m3/s)Qn (m3/s)
0 0.00 0.00 0.003 7.00 0.06 0.00 0.066 15.00 0.14 32.57 0.00 32.709 20.00 0.18 69.79 19.16 0.00 89.1312 21.00 0.19 93.05 41.07 7.14 0.00 141.4515 19.00 0.17 97.70 54.75 15.31 4.79 0.00 172.7218 17.00 0.15 88.40 57.49 20.41 10.25 3.85 180.5621 15.00 0.14 79.09 52.02 21.43 13.67 8.26 174.6124 13.50 0.12 69.79 46.54 19.39 14.36 11.01 161.2127 12.70 0.11 62.81 41.07 17.35 12.99 11.56 145.8930 11.50 0.10 59.09 36.96 15.31 11.62 10.46 133.5433 11.00 0.10 53.50 34.77 13.78 10.25 9.36 121.7636 10.00 0.09 51.18 31.48 12.96 9.23 8.26 113.2039 9.60 0.09 46.53 30.11 11.73 8.68 7.43 104.5842 9.00 0.08 44.66 27.38 11.22 7.86 6.99 98.2045 8.50 0.08 41.87 26.28 10.20 7.52 6.33 92.2948 8.00 0.07 39.55 24.64 9.80 6.84 6.06 86.9551 7.50 0.07 37.22 23.27 9.18 6.56 5.51 81.8154 7.00 0.06 34.89 21.90 8.67 6.15 5.29 76.9757 6.50 0.06 32.57 20.53 8.16 5.81 4.96 72.0960 6.00 0.05 30.24 19.16 7.65 5.47 4.68 67.2663 5.80 0.05 27.92 17.80 7.14 5.13 4.41 62.4466 5.20 0.05 26.99 16.43 6.63 4.79 4.13 59.0169 4.80 0.04 24.19 15.88 6.12 4.44 3.85 54.5472 4.30 0.04 22.33 14.24 5.92 4.10 3.58 50.2175 3.90 0.04 20.01 13.14 5.31 3.96 3.30 45.7678 3.40 0.03 18.15 11.77 4.90 3.55 3.19 41.5981 3.00 0.03 15.82 10.68 4.39 3.28 2.86 37.0684 2.50 0.02 13.96 9.31 3.98 2.94 2.64 32.8587 2.00 0.02 11.63 8.21 3.47 2.67 2.37 28.3790 1.80 0.02 9.31 6.84 3.06 2.32 2.15 23.7093 1.00 0.01 8.37 5.48 2.55 2.05 1.87 20.3396 0.80 0.01 4.65 4.93 2.04 1.71 1.65 14.9999 0.20 0.00 3.72 2.74 1.84 1.37 1.38 11.04102 0.93 2.19 1.02 1.23 1.10 6.47105 0.00 0.55 0.82 0.68 0.99 3.04108 0.00 0.20 0.55 0.55 1.30111 0.00 0.14 0.44 0.58114 0.00 0.11 0.11117 0.00 0.00
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
27
Figure 3.2: A plot of 50-yr, 24-hr storm hydrograph
The equation that apply to the SCS curve number method are given by= ( )( ) (3.17)
In which Qd is the runoff depth, P is the precipitation (maximum potential
runoff), S is the potential maximum watershed retention, Ia is initial abstraction
(Suresh, 2005).The initial abraction (Ia) is approximated by the following
empirical equation
)(2.0 mmSI a
Thus = ( )( . ) (3.18)
S is related to the soil and cover condition of the watershed through the CN.
CN is ranged from 0 to 100, and S is related to CN by= − 254 (3.19)
With CN = 70 based on soil group A, lowest runoff potential, includes deep
sands with very little silt and clay (Salami, 2010). S is estimated as 112.86 mm,
while Ia is 22.57 mm. This implies that any value of rainfall less than 22.57 mm
is regarded as zero. The storm hydrograph ordinate for the watershed due to
0.0020.0040.0060.0080.00100.00120.00140.00160.00180.00200.00
0 15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120
Stor
m h
ydro
grap
h flo
ws,
Q (m
3 /s)
Time (hr)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
28
SCS method were extracted and used to plot the design hydrograph as
presented in Figure 3.3.
Table 3.4 Coordinates of the design hydrograph from SCS method
Points Time Flow Design Designordinate ordinate hydrograph hydrograph(t) (q) (k*t) (w*q)
1 0 0 0 0
2 2 3 1.26 0.8457
3 6 19 3.78 5.5361
4 8 31 5.04 8.7389
5 12 66 7.56 18.6054
6 14 82 8.82 23.1158
7 16 93 10.08 26.2167
8 18 99 11.34 27.9081
9 20 100 12.60 28.1900
10 22 99 13.86 27.9081
11 24 93 15.12 26.2167
12 26 86 16.38 24.2434
13 30 68 18.90 19.1692
14 34 46 21.42 12.9674
15 38 ` 33 23.94 9.3027
16 44 21 27.72 5.9199
17 52 11 32.76 3.1009
18 64 4 40.32 1.1276
19 100 0 63.00 0
Source: Bhunya, (2011).
The unit hydrograph can be used to determine the direct runoff hydrograph
for any rainfall amount with any time distribution. When it is needed to derive
the time-discharge curve due to multiple storms when storm duration is nT
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
29
(n is integer) use proportionality and principle of superposition to get the total
hydrograph, this process is called convolution (Uditha, 2011).
Figure 3.3: Hydrograph curve showing a plot of discharge againt time
3.3 Design of Concrete Weir
3.3.1 Water Pressure on Overflow Section
W1 = 1.2m
Height (H2) = 2.5m
Hydraulic head (H1) = 0.3m
Peak discharge: using the Snyder peak discharge of Q = 180.56 m3/s
Va = where (3.20)
Area A = 30 × 0.3A = 9 m2
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Qisc
harg
e(m
3 /s)
Time duration (sec)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
30
The velocity head of the water is estimated as
Va= .Va= 20.06 m s⁄water head = V2g = 20.062 × 9.81 = 1.02m
Total height = 2.5 +1.02
= 3.52m
w1
w2
gvH a
a 2
2
oT.E.L
H2
H
H1
aw HH 1
aw HH 2
W.S
PH
UPFigure 3.4 concrete weir section and pressure diagram
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
31
3.3.2 Estimation of Water Pressure and Overturning Moment
2.5m A B 0.3m
C 1.0m
2.0m
0.8m
Figure 3.5 concrete weir section divided into three sections
Horizontal component of the force due to water pressure per unit length of the
weir PHP = γ (H + H )H + (3.21)
2
2.59.812.51.020.39.81P2
H
= 63.03
Point at which PH act at
z =
a
a
HHHHHHHH
232
31
12
1212
02.123.052.3
3.033.0252.33.052.331z
z =86.502.507.1
z =0.92Overturning Moment Mo
Mo = PH* z (3.23)
Mo = 63.03 × 0.92 = 57.96 KNm
1.2m
(3.22)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
32
3.3.3 Force due to Self weight and Resisting Moment
The concrete weir section is divided into three parts as shown in Figure 3.5
1. Part A
Weight of the section W (kN)
W = force × area
W = 24 × 2.5 × 1.2W= 72Moment arm (m)= × 1.2 + 0.8= 1.4m
Resisting moment Mr= ×= 72 × 1.4= 100.8 m
2. Part B
Weight W (KN)=
5.15.0
2124= 9
Moment armm= × 0.5 + 0.3= 0.63Resisting moment Mr= 9 × 0.63= 5.7
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
33
3. Part C
Weight W (KN)= 24 × 1 × 0.8= 19.2Moment armm= × 0.8= 0.4Resisting moment Mr= 19.2 × 0.4= 7.68
Table 3.5 Forces due to self-weight and resisting moment
Parts weights moment arm resisting moment(KN) (m) ( )
A 72 1.4 100.8B 9 0.63 5.7C 19.2 0.4 7.68∑ = 100.2 ∑ = 114.183.3.4 Stability Analysis
1. Overturning stability Fos= ∑ = .. (3.24)= 1.97Since 1.97 > 1.5, then overturning stability is o.k
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
34
2. Sliding stability Fss=HP
w
=03.63
2.10075.0 = 1.19Since 1.19> 1.0, then sliding stability is o.k
3. Centroid= ∑ × (3.26)= . . ×= 0.744. Eccentricity= − (3.27)= − 0.74= 0.26
= 0.26m which is less than 1, this implies that there is no tension in the weir.
Therefore the dimensions of the concrete weir are adequate as follows
Top width w1 = 1.2m
Top base width w2 = 0.5m
Base height = 1.0m
Height of the weir = 2.5m
Base width = 2m
Angle made by the downstream side to the vertical ∅ = 18
(3.25)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
35
3.3.5 Uplift Force on the Base of the Concrete Weir
Case 1: when there is water at downstream side= + ( − ) (3.28)= 2 , = 0.3 , = 2.5 = 9.81 ⁄= 9.81 × 0.3 × 2 + × 9.81(2.5 − 0.3)2= 27.47Act at a distance
BHHBH
BBHHBBHz
11
11
21
32
2
8.273.4
z = 1.69 from the toe.
Figure 3.6 illustrate the uplift pressure diagram on the base of the dam when
there is water on the downstream side.
1.2m
2.5m 0.3m
B=2.0m
Figure 3.6 uplift pressure diagram when there is water on the downstream side.
1.0m
UP
(3.29)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
36
Case II: When there is no water at downstream side= (3.30)= × 9.81 × 2.5 × 2= 24.533.3.6 Uplift Pressure in the Body of the Concrete Weir
At a depth 1.5m below the water surface as shown in figure 3.7 the width
b = 0.5m. Thus, the uplift force is given as= (3.31)= 9.81 × . × 0.5KNU p 68.3
And act at a distance 23( )
2×0.53
= 0.33m as shown in figue 3.7
Figure 3.7 Uplift pressure diagram in the body of the concrete weir
1.0m
1.2m
0.3m
B = 2.0m
UP
b = 0.5m2.5m 0.3m
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
37
3.3.7 Vertical Stress on the Concrete Weir
1. At the toe when reservoir is full
BBeW
Fyd
61
226.061
22.100
ydF
78.11.50ydF
2/18.89 mKNFyd
2. At the toe when the reservoir is empty
Be
BWFyd
61
226.061
22.100
ydF
2/02.11 mKNFyd
3.3.8 Principal and Shearing Stresses at the Toe
Principal stress at the toe
dydd f 2tan1
02 18tan118.89 d
2/6.98 mKNd
Shearing stresses at the toe
dydd f tan
018tan18.89 d
2/00.29 mKNd
The design parameters obtained from the analysis are presented in Table 3.6
(3.32)
(3.33)
(3.34)
(3.35)
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
38
Table 3.6 Design parameter for the concrete weir from the analysis
Parameters Values obtained
Approach velocity Va 20.06 m/s
Centroid 0.74 m
Concrete volume 177.3 m3
Depth due to approach velocity Ha 1.02 m
Eccentricity 0.26 m
Height of the weir H 2.5 m
Hydraulic area A 9.0 m2
Hydraulic depth 0.30 m
Length of overflow weir L 30.0 m
Overturning moment Mo 57.96 KNm
Principal stress d 98.6 KN/m2
Shear stress d 29.00 KN/m2
Uplift force: case I 27.47 KN
Uplift force: case II 24.53 KN
Vertical stress when reservoir is empty 11.02 KN/m2
Vertical stress when reservoir is full 89.18 KN/m2
Water pressure PH 63.03 KN
3.4 Concrete Volume
Volume A = 2.5 × 1.5 × 3 = 112.5Volume B = 0.5 × 0.5 × 1.5 × 30 = 11.25Volume C = 0.8 × 1.0 × 30 = 24Total volume of the concrete weir = 147.75Total volume of concrete using a 20% waste and shrinkageTotal volume of concrete = 0.2 × 147.75+ 147.75 = 177.3
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
39
3.5 Preparation Of Bill Of Quantity
The following price quotation was gotten from PPU (2012).
1. Concrete (1:3:6) = N 25,000/m3
2. Concrete (1:2:4) = N 28,000/m3
3. Excavation = N 500/m3
4. Formwork = N 1200/m2
5. Preliminaries = N 500,000
3.5.1 Quantity computation
1. Excavation = 1.0 × 2.45 × 30 = 73.52. Concrete blinding (1:3:6) = 0.05 × 2.45 × 30 = 3.6753. Formwork = 2(2.5 × 30 ) = 1504. Concrete (1:2:4) = 177.3m3
Table 3.7 Bill of Engineering Measurement and EvaluationS/No DESCRIPTION QTY UNIT RATE
(N)AMOUNT inNaria
1 Allow for preliminaries to be dispenced asdirected
LOT 500,000 500,000
2 Demolition of existing weir and cart away LOT 80,000 80,000
3 Excavation for concrete base 73.5 m3 500 36,7504 Concrete blinding (1:3:6) 3.675 m3 25,000 91,8755 Formwork 150 m2 1200 180,0006 Plain insitu concrete (1:2:4) 177.3 m3 28,000 4,964,4007 Stone pitching LOT 250,000 250,000
Total 6,103,025Add 2% contingencies 122,060.5Add 5% VAT 305,151.25
Grand Total 6,530,236.75
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
40
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1 Results and Discussion
The Snyder method of analysis was used to derive the synthetic unit
hydrograph of 50yrs rfeturn periods while the storm hydrograph for the
watershed was estimated from convolution analysis as presented in
Tables 3.2 and 3.3 respectively. Furthermore, the soil conservation services
(SCS) method was also used to analyse the unit hydrograph and the results
obtained were presented in Table 3.4.
The Snyder and the soil conservation services (SCS) method shows that the
peak flows for the river are 180.56m3/s and 28.19m3/s respectively. The
maximum peak discharge obtained (180.56m3/s) was subsequently used in the
design of the concrete weir. Some of the design results obtained include the
approach velocity Va (20.06 m/s), overturning moment Mo (57.96 KNm),
principal stress ∅ (98.6 KN/m2), shear stress (29.00 KN/m2) uplift force Up
(27.47 KN), vertical stress when the reservoir is full (89.18 KN/m2) and water
pressure PH (63.03 KN). All other design results for the weir were presented in
Table 3.6.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
41
CHAPTER FIVE
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
5.1 Conclusion
The design parameters obtained as shown in Table 3.6 means that the
concrete weir section is stable since all the stability criteria are satisfied. The
total depth of water over the crest of weir is 1.02m at maximum discharge of
180.56 m3/s. This implies that about 29% different in the total depth of water
above the overflow weir with the selected dimensions of the concrete weir of
2.5m height and 1.2m top width. It is therefore concluded that the
construction of the concrete weir should be executed to improve the
productivity of the research fields through the usage of the stored water for
irrigation purposes.
5.2 Recommendation
It is recommended that the established unit hydrograph can be used to
determine peak flow and design parameters for other hydraulic structures
such as drainage, culvert and small bridges all within the Oyun River basin.
It is also recommended that stone pitching should be provided at the two sides
of the weir to prevent scouring of the two sides which might eventually leads
to leakage of the stored water. It is further recommended that desilting of the
weir shoud be done periodically to prevent overfilling of the weir by sand and
debris deposite.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
42
REFERENCES
Ahmad, Z. (2004) Recent Advances in the Design of Trench Weir.Department of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee,India.
Arora, K.R. (2004) Irrigation, water power and water Resources Engineering.Standard Publishers Distributions, 1705-B, NAI SARAK, Delhi India.
Ayanshola, A.M., Salami, A.W., Olofintoye, O.O. and Abdulkadir, T.S. (2009)Development of Storm Hydrographs for Three Rivers within DrainageNetwork in Kwara State, Nigeria using Snyder’s Method. Department of CivilEngineering first annual conference paper, University of Ilorin, Ilorin,Nigeria
Bhunya, P.K., Panda, S.N. and Goel, M.K. (2011) Synthetic Unit HydrographMethod: A Critical Review. The Open Hyrology Journal (5)1-8. NationalInstitute of Hydrology, Roorkee, India.
Chanson, H. (2004) The Hydraulics of Open Channel Flow. 2nd editionButterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, UK.
Okeola, O. (2012) Civil Engineering Practice. A monograph on the basic CivilEngineering practice, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Ilorin,Ilorin, Nigeria.
Physical Planning Unit (2012) Personal communication with chief quantitysurveyor, Physical Planning Unit, University of Ilorin.
Ramirez, J.A. (2000) Prediction and modeling of flood hydrograph andhydraulics. Chapter 11 of Inland flood hazards: Human, Riparian andAquatic Communities. Edited by Ellen Wohl; Cambridge university press.
Sturm, T.W. (2001) Open Channel Hydraulics. Water Resources andEnvironmental Engineering Series, McGraw Hill, Boston, USA.
Design of an Overflow Concrete Weir for University of Ilorin Sugarcane Research Fields 2012
43
Sule, B.F., Salami, A.W., Bilewu, S.O., Adeleke, O.O. and Ajimotokan, H.A.(2011) Hydrology of River Oyun and Hydropower Potential of Unilorin Dam,Ilorin, Kwara State, Nigeria. New York Science Journal 4(1):69-78.(http://www.sciencepub.net/newyork).
Suresh, R. (2005) Watershed Hydrology (Principle of Hydrology). Secondrevised edition, standard publisher distributors, Nai-sarak, Delhi India.
Uditha R. (2011) Engineering Hydrology (CE 205). Lecture note, Departmentof Civil Engineering, University of Sri Lanka.
www.wikipedia.org/weir (December, 2011).