112
id we really land n the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Did we really land on the Moon?

Dr Martin HendrySchool of Physics and AstronomyUniversity of Glasgow

Page 2: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Did we really land on the Moon?

Dr Martin HendrySchool of Physics and AstronomyUniversity of Glasgow

Page 3: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Mankind’s greatest adventure?...

Between July 1969 and

December 1972, 12

astronauts walked

on the Moon.

Page 4: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

FOX TV Documentary“Conspiracy Theory: Did We Really

Go to the Moon?”

Page 5: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

The Hoax ClaimIt never happened

Page 6: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

The protagonists:

’Hoax’ theorists

o Bill Kaysing

o Bart Sibrel

Page 7: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 8: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 9: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. shadows aren’t parallel?

2. no stars?

1. waving flag?

3. shadows aren’t parallel?

Page 10: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. shadows aren’t parallel?

4. film played fast looks like

on Earth

2. no stars?

1. waving flag?

3. shadows aren’t parallel?

Page 11: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

6. lit in the shade?

7. Dust problems

5. Lens crosshairs behind things?

8. Radiation

footprints no blast crater

Page 12: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

now you see it! now you don’t?

9. Identical backgrounds

Page 13: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

10. fuel jets?

now you see it! now you don’t?

9. Identical backgrounds

Page 14: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

4. slowed film4. slowed film

7. Dust problems

1. waving flag

2. no stars 3. non-parallel shadows

5. crosshairs

6. lit in the shade

9. similar backgrounds

Convincing?

8. radiation

10. no jets10. no jets

Page 15: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

4. slowed film4. slowed film

7. Dust problems

1. waving flag

2. no stars 3. non-parallel shadows

5. crosshairs

6. lit in the shade

9. similar backgrounds

Convincing?

8. radiation

10. no jets10. no jets

What do you think?...

Page 16: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

4. slowed film4. slowed film

7. Dust problems

1. waving flag

2. no stars 3. non-parallel shadows

5. crosshairs

6. lit in the shade

9. similar backgrounds

Convincing?

8. radiation

10. no jets10. no jets

4. Slowed film

10. No jets

Page 17: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

Page 18: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

What the TV Show says

Page 19: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 20: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

Page 21: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

Would the flag wave on the Moon, where there’s no

atmosphere?

Page 22: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 23: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

Page 24: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

Page 25: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

1. The Waving Flag

Labor Day in Johnson City, TN

Page 26: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 27: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 28: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

2. No stars

Page 29: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

2. No stars

Page 30: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

2. No stars

Page 31: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 32: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 33: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 34: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 35: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 36: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 37: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 38: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

What the TV Show says

Page 39: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 40: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 41: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

Page 42: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

Page 43: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

Page 44: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

Page 45: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

Page 46: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

3. Non-parallel Shadows

Page 47: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 48: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

4. Film slowed down

Page 49: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

4. Film slowed down

What the TV Show says

Page 50: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 51: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

4. Film slowed down

Page 52: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 53: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

5. Disappearing Crosshairs

What the TV Show says

Page 54: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 55: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

5. Disappearing Crosshairs

Page 56: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

5. Disappearing Crosshairs

Page 57: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

5. Disappearing Crosshairs

Page 58: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 59: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

6. Lit in the Shade?

What the TV Show says

Page 60: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 61: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

6. Lit in the Shade?

Page 62: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

6. Lit in the Shade?

Page 63: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

6. Lit in the Shade?

Page 64: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

6. Lit in the Shade?

Page 65: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 66: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

7. Dust problems?

What the TV Show says

Page 67: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 68: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

The final descent of Apollo 11

Page 69: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

7. Dust problems?

No blast crater?

Page 70: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 71: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

7. Dust problems?

Page 72: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

7. Dust problems?

Simulating the LEM descent

Page 73: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 74: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

7. Dust problems?

Driving the lunar rover

Page 75: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 76: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 77: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

8. Radiation

Page 78: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Charged particles from the Sun reach the Earth and are trapped in the Van Allen

radiation belts

7. Radiation

Page 79: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

7. Radiation

Page 80: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Shielding against radiation

7. Radiation

Page 81: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

8. Radiation

Page 82: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 83: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 84: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

9. Similar Backgrounds?

What the TV Show says

Page 85: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 86: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 87: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

9. Identical Backgrounds?

Page 88: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

9. Similar Backgrounds?

Page 89: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

9. Similar Backgrounds?

Ridge

Page 90: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

9. Similar Backgrounds?

Page 91: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

9. Similar Backgrounds?

Page 92: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 93: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

10. No fuel jets?

What the TV Show says

Page 94: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 95: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

10. No fuel jets?

Page 96: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

10. No fuel jets?

Page 97: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Back to main menu

Page 98: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 99: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 100: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 101: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 102: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 103: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 104: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Apollo 11

Page 105: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 106: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

“Proof” that Moon Landings Happened

All the live video footage was tracked by a network of “dishes” during the Apollo missions

Page 107: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

“Proof” that Moon Landings Happened

Over 382kg of moon rocks brought back

All the live video footage was tracked by a network of “dishes” during the Apollo missions

Page 108: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

“Proof” that Moon Landings Happened

Over 382kg of moon rocks brought backOver 130 separate lunar ranging studies rely on reflectors left behind by astronauts

All the live video footage was tracked by a network of “dishes” during the Apollo missions

Page 109: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 110: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

Gravity measured from original footage checks out at ~1/6th Earth’s gravity, as expected

Page 111: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow
Page 112: Did we really land on the Moon? Dr Martin Hendry School of Physics and Astronomy University of Glasgow

www.astro.gla.ac.uk/users/martin/moonhoax/

www.tinyurl.com/23vc7sq

[email protected]