Upload
luis-alejandro-villa
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
1/11
Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology, 2010, 5: 2030
ABSTRACT
T td w dd t mp t ppbt
tw p tmt, dtvt mt d
d-ptt d (gPr), t dtt t-
d md-pd v t gwd cmt
od, fd. a md-pd d w t p
t t pm w, vtd, d mkd
b. cv, t-pd d w -
ttd d t t v dt
tt w bvd t d mtp dp, vtd,
d mkd v. Bt tmt dttd mtp
vtd b t md-pd d, w t
gPr dttd t d vtd b t t-
-pd d. nt tmt dttd t bk
t vt v t tt td m
d. T v p tq wd
dtmt t bt dt t pd
mxmm t gPr v m w
t . a tt tv p 0.25 m w
pb t 0.5 m, d mmdd w pm-
v mt t mkd v.
ftm, tm tt w t dt
dt , tt d b td pp-
d t t b, t tt kw. W
tm t , mxmm dt d t
v btd mpt d t
tt td bt X d y dt.
Itrducti
gp tmt t d t t wt
t vv dtt mkd b m
vt txt. i pt, d-ptt
d (gPr) bm pp p pt
v dtt (V 1986; Bv 1991; K t .
1993; nb 1999; Dv t . 2000; c 2006;
J 2008). at mm gPr t t
t b t dmt t t mkd
v t t t mt mp
xvt b. T t pv
mt mmt b dt t-
mkd v. f xmp, gPr mptt
t mkd b tt m b mptd d
d-xp tvt mt. a, t bt
t t mkd v t t
mmt (crM) txt b t dv
mkd b dd d t tb-
t d pvt t t ptt b m
m (c 2006b). W gPr bm pp
pt, t mpt t mkd v -
tt t d t mpvmt v p
v mtd, w tt t mtt
dt tmt p txt.
s t md-1980, gPr b mm d
crM wk mt tt, d v pb-
d td v p ddd mtd
dt gPr v vv v, wt
pt ttt t vb t dtt d
t (V 1986; Bv 1991; K t . 1993;
nb 1999; Dv t . 2000; c 2006b). f gPr
v tt d mt d t,
Pmt (2006), c (2006b), d J (2008) v
pvdd d tt p d p-
tt, bt w w b ttd t td.
o t t d, t k tt t
dtvt t mkd v t
mt.T pjt w dd t tt t bt
tw p tmt t t d mp mkd
d mkd v t mt wt tmt dt-
m t t pd t t pt d. T
t w t (1) tt t tt -
dtvt mt d gPr t dtt mkd d mkd
v, (2) mp t t btw t tw p-
tmt, d (3) t mmdt
t v t tmt.
Diati ad Rsuti f Cmtry Gravs
Usig a Cductivity Mtr ad Grud-Ptratig Radar
c a. D, D K. Wdw, d J J. st
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
2/11
Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology 21
charles a. Dionne, Dennis K. WarDlaW, anD John J. schulTz
Matrias ad Mthds
T mt td t pjt w gwd
cmt, w, t ppxmt 68.7 , t -
t mt wd d ptd b t t od,fd. T gwd cmt w ptm
t td v . i ddt t t
t mt, tmt p m t t,
wt v dt m 1880 t t pt. a, t
kw t t mkd b d t b
pv pbd pmd t t mt
p tmt. at t v dpt ttd,
t mt t d tt d -
dtvt mt d gPr t fd. T -
d fm-ub d mpx, w md-
t dd d t d t t dpttdd. T dt w td d d dt. Tw
t t mt w t tt t bt
t dtvt mt d gPr t dtt dt tp
b m dt pd. a md-pd wt
tmt m 1957 t 2002 td b
w d pm wd t md pt p-
w bd mt vt. cv,
t t-pd (b d t 75 ) d
t vd t tmt. T tmt -
td mkd d dp, vtd b
wt w mt k wd .T md-pd d md 11 x 23 m d
td 30 mkd dt wt mtp, db
tmt m dtt w, t b dt
btw 1957 d 2002. cmt d w d
t dtm t tp tmt pt t md-
-pd d. T mjt tmt w
pd bd mt vt, w v w pd
bd wd . Md b t gwd
cmt qd t b pd mt b
vt. it mm pt t utd stt t b
dd vt t pvt d tbtd t t dtt d bqt p -
. T v wd , dt m 1958 t 1962,
w m t dt b td wt t d.
ftm, tw dt td tmt, d
t b d mt vb.
a 25 30 m t-pd d w ttd
p t t mt. T t
tt d w dvt t td b t
w t tt d t t qt t gPr
t, d wt w btt ( v dt)
t w t pm d v. T v dt
dtd m 1895 t 1920, bt w w vb bd t t t dt. W t kw
t t m mkd tmt, t
dmtt vb p t mb w
d t mb b pt t t t
mt.
T tw p tmt d t td
w dtvt mt d gPr. T dtvt
mt d t td w mt- g eM-38
wt a cX dd dt . T tmt
t tmtt tt mt tm-
t wv w pd pm mt d t d, d v tt dtt t d
mt d md b dtv bjt t b-
tt. T d btw t tw mt d
ppt t t dtvt t t td
bw t d . T, b bjt
dttd w t dtvt t d-
t bjt d m t t dtvt t
(sm 1997; Km 2004). i t mt,
t dtvt mt d t t t
tt ppt. ad t c (2006),
d btw t v d t d -dtbd t m t t b
dttd b t tmt.i ddt, pkt wt
t mt mt m
tbt t v dtt t dtvt
mt (Bv 1991).
cdtvt b md tw w: t
tmt md tt tk d v d
t m md w d tk b
p btt t p t. T tmt
b t d t p (mt ptbt)
t d b t tmt d m dt-t md. Mt ptbt t t
d t w b t b mtd.
cdtvt d p mmt b tk
tw dp tt: t vt dp
(w t tmt d vt) bt dtt-
dt t t dpt, w t t dp
(w t tmt d t) btt td
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
3/11
22 Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology
DelineaTion anD resoluTion of ceMeTery graVes
dtt bjt t d (g
2006). T dtvt mt m d d-
tvt mm p mt (ms/m). T dt
tp btw dtvt d ms/m, btt
dt w t t v ms/m (Km2004). i t dtvt mt pxmt t
v dtv bjt, wv, t d
tv v. T d b t t dd -
t btw t tw d t td bd t
v (Wd 1990). cdtvt v m
d v b td z v, b t
v t t t mp w t vt
dtvt tt t v (Km 2004).
utt, dtvt d d t pvd dpt
mt dd tt.
T md-pd d w t p t mm tmb tt t wt t dt
pt. T dtvt dt w td t y
dt bt d tt p 0.5 m,
w t mmdt t mt tt
tt p d b q t t tmt
t (g 2006). it d b td tt w t-
t djt t dt w w d t 0.25 m
p t vd t m dt t.
o tt, dtvt d w -
td v 0.5 m. Mmt w dd
a cX d mpt tt w td t tdtvt mt. f w t td m t
d mpt t dktp mpt, w t w
pd t g tw DaT 38 d d
t gd stw s 8 tw (v 8.4).
T s tw w d t t t mp
t dtvt d t t t
dt tv wt t pt d-
0.5 ms/m. a v t t t
t dt w t ddd t
dtvt mp t dtm w m w -
td wt dt d w m ptdmkd v.
T gPr t d t pjt w Mala
raMac X3M wt 500 Mh t mtd
t t v w. T 500 Mh t
w d b t pvd xt mpm
btw dpt vw d vt t d
mm d d pp-
t (stb d Mg 1995; st t . 2006;
st 2007). B dt t t gPr t w
btd vt t td wv mtd
(c d l 1996) b p t gPr v -
mt b vt tt w pbd t bt t dpt t vt bw t d . T vt w t
btd t t dpt t t pb w
t. Dt m t md d w td
0.5 m tt p t y dt . ot w
md t v d t dt wt t d.
T t-pd d w vd t gPr
wt tt tv p 0.25 m, d dt w
td bt X d y dt. ot w
qd t v dt wt t d.
a gPr p w pmd gPr-slice
(v 6) t m d refleXW(v 5) t p. Bt t md-pd
d d t t-pd d w bjt t t m
ptp pd, w dd bkd
mv d bx mt t. i d t mk
dt mp wt t t m t dtvt
mt, t t-pd d gPr dt w t p-
d 0.5 m tt tv p d -
t t w dpt 0.2 m (35 ). nxt, t
t-pd d w pd bt dt, X
d y, t 0.25 m d Xy mpt t 0.25 m d t
dtm t t dd tt tv pd p tt. i d t t t t
tt tv 0.5 m, dt td
wt 0.25 m tt tv w d d v t
tt w mvd.
Rsuts
Modern-Period Grid
Bt tmt btd m t t md
d. T dtvt mt dttd mtp m- td twt dt w
td wt t d (f 1). T mjt t
m td t dtvt mp w d t
b t wt xt dt. i ddt,
mt d md tt dtvt m-
dttd t md-pd d w td
wt b t mt vt. ad t t
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
4/11
Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology 23
charles a. Dionne, Dennis K. WarDlaW, anD John J. schulTz
dtvt mp, tt v dt dd t v
m dttd pxmt. cmt d -
dtd tt t t dt td tmt
md wd , w t m tw
dt dd t t tmt. T gPr t t md d w m t t dtvt mt
t (f 2). a t , pt p-
pxmt dpt 0.4 m (1214 ), w mpd t t
dtvt mt v t dtm tt t m
w mt td wt t xt dt.
a t md-pd d wd tt t gPr
w b t dtt mt vt pt.
ftm, t p (f 3) w td
m t td w wt t md d d t
pvd t dt m gPr p. T t
t t p dtd b t wt
t t (f 2). T t p
dmttd w t, pb pd
m pdd b t w mt b vt
t md-pd d t dpt ppxmt 0.5 m.ov, t p d tt t dttd b
w tt wt t mt t dt pvdd
b c (2006b).
Historical-Period Grid
T dtvt mt dttd m d
t t-d v. T m w td
ppxmt t tt dt t
t t d (f 4). T m t pvd
Figur 1.cdtvt mp t md d wt tmt
tp v. T v pt mkd b d dt
t tp tmt. (Mp b c D, 2010)
Figur 2. gPr t t md d t p-
pxmt dpt 0.4 m (1214 ) dt m
td b b vt. T wt dt t t
t md-d t p; f 4. (f b
J st, 2010)
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
5/11
24 Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology
DelineaTion anD resoluTion of ceMeTery graVes
t v b d b w mt t pp.
n t m w td b t dtvt mt
t t bk t tmt w dttd.
T gPr dttd t w t pp
t t ppxmt dpt 0.2 m, 35 (f 5). B t m w
pt t w t , t tt t
bk m v t w t b dttd b
t gPr d tt t m t dp -
t md t p tmt. u
t t ppxmt dpt 0.85 m,
2123 (f 69), t gPr v dttd
mb dp m d t tw, wt t b td t twt d-
t. T t t dt td t y dt
v 0.5 m tt tv p (f 6)
Figur 3. Md d t p m f 2 w w t m pdd b t w vtd
b t ppxmt dpt 0.25 m. nt t dp m ptd t pt mkd, vtd b.
(f b J st, 2010)
Figur 4.cdtvt mp t t d dt t
t t v bvd v mk () d t
m td b t pp (center). (f b c
D, 2010)
Figur 5.sw t t t d w
t t pp dttd t dpt 0.2 m (35 ). (f
b D Wdw, 2010)
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
6/11
Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology 25
charles a. Dionne, Dennis K. WarDlaW, anD John J. schulTz
Figur 8. gPr t t t d t dpt
0.85 m (2123 ) 0.25 m tt p t X
dt . (f b D Wdw, 2010)
Figur 6. gPr t vtd, wd
t t d t dpt 0.85 m (2123 )
0.5 m tt p t y dt . (f b D
Wdw, 2010.)
Figur 9.gPr t t t d t dpt
0.85 m (2123 ) 0.25 m tt p pt
bt X d y dt. T wt dt t t
t t-d t p; f 11. (f
b D Wdw, 2010)
Figur 7.gPr t t t d t dpt
0.85 m (2123 ) 0.25 m tt p t y d-
t . (f b D Wdw, 2010.)
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
7/11
26 Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology
DelineaTion anD resoluTion of ceMeTery graVes
pdd mtp m, bt t w dttd d
t t wd tt tv p d t d
tpt qd p. W t dt w
pd 0.25 m tt tv t y dt
(f 7), t dmttd p t ddt t m mpd t t t
pd wt 0.5 m tt tv p. T
t t t td t X dt
0.25 m tt p (f 8) dtd
dd t t m, d w b
w dttd mpd t t t t
m tt p t y dt. f, t dt
pd mpt X-y d 0.25 m tv
p (f 9) dmttd t bt t, t
d dd bt tt, mmd t t
dt, d t pvdd t t t m wt t d w v dttd t
tt mb b.
a gPr t p (f 10) w td m
t t t (f 9) t . T
mb pb pd m ptd
f 10 d wt t mb d t
m bvd t t f 9 d ppxmt 1.0 m dp. T xt t t
t p ptd f 9 wt .
i d t m tt t m dttd t -
t p m t t-pd d (f 10)
w mkd, vtd b, mp w
md wt t p (f 11) m dt
t t mt tt td vtd b
(dpdt md b pb t v)
tm m t 1930 t t 1940. ov, bt -
t p w mt p, tt, d
dpt--v m, w tt wt tmt t dt pvdd b c (2006b).
T, t t dt m t t-pd
Figur 10.ht d t p m f 9 w w t m btw 0.5 d 1.0 m pdd
b t dp, vtd wd b tt w mkd d pb mt btw 0.0 d 0.5 m. (f b D
Wdw, 2010)
Figur 11.rt p pt w t m pdd b dp, vtd wd b t dpt
ppxmt 1.0 m tt w mkd wt dt, d kw md tmt t dpt ppxmt 0.5 m.
(f b D Wdw, 2010)
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
8/11
Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology 27
charles a. Dionne, Dennis K. WarDlaW, anD John J. schulTz
d d t tt t t w
mkd, vtd v w dttd wt t
t m t d.
Discussi ad Ccusis
T t btd dmtt d b-
tw t dtvt mt d gPr t bt t
dtt dt tp tmt. ad t c
(2006b), mt v m b dttd wt gPr b
m t tt d t dtbd b-
w d d t v; t dpd bk d
t t vt v t; t tmt tt d
t , m m, d td v tt;
d dmt tt mtd v
t tmt. i t wd pd, tbmt t vd p, wv, wt t t
dd wd d m m m t pvd
p m tt t b dttd
wt gPr. i t v t b d t
mpd dtt dt t tt, wv,
t v t m b dttd d t dt p
d m t bk dpt
t t d dtbd ttp d t
v (Bv 1991; K 1993; c 2006b).
gPr pvdd t bt t d dt
t dp vtd b t t d. Tmbt gPr p t dt (f 3)
wt t t (f 69) t ppt
t tt mkd v w dttd t
t . ov, t w p d-
btw t v t pdd m bt
d. s mt vt w bd t
mxmm dpt 0.5 m bw t d , t
t w m w (f 3) t t
m t d wd tp bd t dpt
1.0 m (f 10). T t m t mt b
vt w m t d t t tt pd/ m ppt btw t d d t -
mt vt, d/ t pvd vd p. ad t
c (2006b), b vt md bk t
pv vd p, d dtt tmt.
s tp t dtt d-
mt v. f xmp, mpd wt-
d bdk, v bb- dmt, bd,
d t tt t dt
d v b xtv tt t -
t p (Bv 1991; K 1993; c 2006b). i
ddt, w mb t v td dtv
mt t mt v dtt(W 1986; Bv 1991) d t dv
v (Dvpt 2001; Dp t . 2005; f t
. 1992; Km 2004; st t . 2006), t m t b
pb t dtt v b t p
tt t ttp w t tp
t vt v t. i t td, t tp td
m d d t bk v t w t
dtt d d t b dttd w -
w gPr t d t p. hwv,
v t d t mpd dtt d-
t t tt m b m mb t dttwt gPr (c 2006b; st 2008; st t .
2006). i m d , dtt v wtt
vt m b pbmt b t pd wd
d kt m t pvd p
d m tt t b dttd b gPr.
a, w mp t gPr m t
0.25 m d 0.5 m tt tv p, t m
tt p pd btt t d
dt b. W c (2006b) d J
(2008) mmd tt tv p 0.5
m t-mt v wt gPr, t dmttd tt tt tv 0.25 m
d w v vtd mt v. at
ptv t w t b btd tt t-
v 0.5 m, w tm pmt tt tv 0.25
m d b d. W pm p v
t, Pmt (2006) mmdd t-
t tt td ppd t t v tt
d t bt p tt t
t b t. W Pmt
(2006) dd t p t b, mm-
dt pptd b t d t td. it p v b pmd d-
t d t tm tt, tt d b td
ppd t t v, t t t, d
t bt mxmm t t b.
W t gPr t dtt mt v
w vb bt t md d t d,
t t dd t dtvt mt. T dt-
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
9/11
28 Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology
DelineaTion anD resoluTion of ceMeTery graVes
t t w t pp t t d
(f 4) dmttd t xt pbt t
dtvt mt dtt bd mt bjt.
T dtvt mt dttd t w mt
vt t md d (f 1),bt dd t dtt t d, dp, wd t t d
(f 4). it t p tt t mt vt w
dttd, b Bv (1983) pv dmtd
t bt t dtvt mt t dtt dtv-
t btw b t vd d t
d t. i ddt, t
dtvt mt mt ttd tt t -
tt md, mt b vt tbt
t t dtt t t d dtvt
v b t m v tt d m
b d wt b b (Mk ct 2006,p. mm.).
T dtvt mt dd t dtt t v
t dp, vtd t b wd .
T v w t dttd mb .
ft, t bk t vt v t w t d-
ttd, w w td wt t gPr. s t
w mpd m d, t bk mp-
t v t dd t pvd m d
p tt t b dttd. at b
td t t dpt ptt t m d-
tvt t. ad t t mt, t ttpk t dpt 0.4 m t vt dp t-
t, d t t tt d dpt
(g 2006). s t d wd w t
dpt 1.0 m, wt md t tmt w t
dtv t b dttd t t dpt mt t
dtvt t.
W gPr t pd pt
t mkd b, t dtvt mt
pv mb tt. a t
dmttd, dtvt t
t tmt t w bd vt mt . T p tmt pv
vmt w gPr mtd. f x-
mp, t b xtv - tt t
gPr t p m t t, t dtbd
, d t . i t t w
dtb b dttd p t, -
dtvt v b ptd wt t gPr v
t pvd pb ddt dt dt t
vt v t.a,t m b t w
t m t b pb t mv t gPr tt
w d t btt m b d tmp, d
dtvt t m b b t b d wt b d w t dtt t - t.
gd-ptt d vb p t
tt mm d t utd stt mt
mmt d crM wk t dtt d d-
mtt v. B w pp v mt-
d gPr, t t t t
d mkd b. W pb, v d b
pmd wt tt tv p 0.25 m p-
pd t t tt t v w, d
t gPr m d d bt gPr p -
t dt d t . T, gPr m t tt t td t tt t
dtm ptm v mtd mkd
b td tt vmt -
dt d mtp tm pd. D t t t
vmt dt d mpt, mt
wt v p mtd gPr,
dtvt, tvt, mtmt mptt t
dt t vb t dtt v. i dd-
t, dpd t tt, mbt
p t m pvd t t
t d dt mkd v, ptw v t v m dt tm
pd dt tp tmt.
ACknowleDGMenTS
W wd k t tk sxt D P pvd
t gwd cmt d mt d.
addt tk t M Mt d s Kd
t t wt dt t.
ReFeRenCeS
Bv, B W.
1983 etmt Mpp Bd et f-
t.Journal of Field Archaeology10(1):4754.
1991 T s gv. Geophysics56(9):1,310
1,319.
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
10/11
Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology 29
charles a. Dionne, Dennis K. WarDlaW, anD John J. schulTz
c, r. B
2006 cdtvt sv: a svv M. i
Remote Sensing in Archaeology: An Explicitly North American
Perspective,J. K. J, dt, pp. 1415. uvt
abm P, T.
c, lw B.
2006 gd-Ptt rd. i Remote Sens-
ing in Archaeology: An Explicitly North American Perspective,
J.K. J, dt, pp. 131159. uvt abm
P, T.
2006b gd-Ptt rd Tq t
Dv d Mp ht gv. Historical Archaeology
40(3):6473.
c, lw B., d J e. l
1996 Vt a a gd
Ptt rd td.Archaeological Prospection
3(1):2538.
Dvpt, ck g.
2001 rmt s appt f ivt-
t. Historical Archaeology35(1):87100.
Dp, T l., J J. st, sd M. W,
d l J. Wm2005 Forensic Recovery of Human Remains: Archaeological
Approaches. crc P, B rt, fl.
f, D l., Tm J. g, Jk g. swb, J
W. ldm, ck g. Dvpt, Vk Tmm,
c T. ambt, B Kdt, a n, Km
ct, d Dk hpk
1992 a Mtdp app t t Dt-
t cdt gv.Journal of Forensic Sciences
37(6):1,4451,458.
g
2006 EM38 Ground Conductivity Meter Operating Manual.
g, M, on.
J, g
2008 gp Mpp ht cmt.
Technical Briefs in Historical Archaeology3:2538 .
Km, edwd W.
2004 The Detection of Human Remains. c c.Tm, spd, il.
K, J a., B W. Bv, d rbt J. h
1993 T rbt gp sv t ht
Pd cmt: a exmp m t P cm-
t, Mv, Md. Historical Archaeology
27(3):416.
nb, Dvd c.
1999 gp sv B st: a c std
t o up st. Geophysics64(2):357367.
Pmt, Jm
2006 gd-Ptt rd P sp d
ott sb rt l ft.
Archaeological Prospection13(2):151153.
st, J J.
2008 sqt Mt B ct
sm P cdv u gd-Ptt rd.
Journal of Forensic Sciences53(2):279287.
2007 u gd-Ptt rd t lt
cdt gv hmd Vtm. Homicide Studies
11(1):1529.
st, J J., M e. c, d at B. ftt
2006 sqt Mt B ct
l P cdv u gd-Ptt rd.
Journal of Forensic Sciences51(3):607616.
sm, Pm V.
1997 Environmental and Engineering Geophysics. cm-bd uvt P, cmbd, uK.
stb, B K., d Jm W. Mg
1995 a std st a u
gd Ptt rd.Journal of Applied Geophysics
33(3):209225.
8/13/2019 Dionne et al. 2010 Prospeccin geofsica funeraria
11/11
30 Technical Briefs in hisTorical archaeology
DelineaTion anD resoluTion of ceMeTery graVes
V, c. J.
1986 gd Ptt rd sv ud a-
ivtt. Geophysics51(3):595604.
Wd, st h. (dt)1990 Geotechnical and Environmental Geophysics, V. 1.
st expt gpt, T, oK.
W, J c.
1986 a rvw gp Mtd ud
a. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal
1(3):245257.
Chars A. Di
Dptmt atpuvt st fd
4202 e. fw av. soc 107
Tmp, fl 33620
Dis k. warda
Dptmt atp
uvt ct fd
4000 ct fd Bvd.
od, fl 32816
Jh J. SchutzDptmt atp
uvt ct fd
4000 ct fd Bvd.
od, fl 32816