162

disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

��� � �����

���� ������������������ � ���� �"!#��$%� &')(+*-,/.�0�132546.7(98;:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: >?A@B0�46CB85(9D-46.7(38=EF.7,/CG@IH68<0�[email protected]%46LM@N:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: [email protected]%[email protected]=*-85.%,[email protected],/CB@7HS8%T3DU46CRV#.7H64QL5@J8<CG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QL5@W:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: X' 034SY%85,ZDU4[H64SY%85H6HS4[8\@7CRV34S*-4[H6.7K%46L54W:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: ]^_,-8MY78=8a`3La19,/D-19DbDc*/.7,/46L5.d:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�fg 13K%K78M,-46CB85(+*-4hV346V3H64S.%K7,Z@�i"L54j:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: elk

m n\opn\qsr�t-uhowv�x9qsy<q�z�tc{|tUq�}~o��c� �A�� �����A���h�M�9�M��� ���� � ������#!#��$7�����"���"�����%���#���9 �� �3�

e7:6e�'bLa.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4AY785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64N:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�]e7:�k�^b@7D-4|0�4AL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4b:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�k%ke7: >�?A@GD-46(%*Z@7D/DU4[0�[email protected]@P�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH68<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�k%X

� �����A�+���3�h�M��$7������ � ���� �"!#��$%�����"���"�����%���#���9 �� �"�k�:6e�')(+*-,/.�0�132546.7(98�:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�k7�k�:�k��~.%2546.7(34�DU8MCB@7(+*-4QLZ�38�EF.%(903@7CJ8M(+*/@IH64�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�>%fk�: >��s,/.7�9,-468a*� @P0�8MHSH68�*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74687:�¡�¢+1346Y�@IH685(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@£:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�>7Ok�: O �s,/.7�9,-468a*� @P0�8MHSHQ@J,[email protected](38<0�4|L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@PHS.%K74QL5@ :<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�>%¤k�:�X ¥ .7("LaH619DU46.7(98¦:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�>%�k�: §�¨~�9�"8M(90�4QLa87©�'_L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4|Y%85,/.I��EF13(32546.7("@IH64"8<46H|H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.PL5.7CR19(38G:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:;O+f

&�ªa _«w�+�M�|��������!# �� ¬­ F® �%��¯�|���°�9�h�M��$%� ±[²>3:6e�')(+*-,/.�0�132546.7(98�:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:;O�X>3:�k�')H|CB8a*/.�0�.³0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.GDU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.µ:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:;O+§>3: > ¥ .7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@P8\La.7CB�3H68a*/852M2M@B0�85HACJ85*-.�0�.G0�8MHSH�´ @7HSV#85,/.GDU8MCG@I(+*-4QLa.¶:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�§%f>3: O�' *-85.%,-8MCB4|0�4ALa.%CB�9@�*-*-852M2M@J8<0�4AL5.7CB�3H68a*-8M252�@REF.%,U*/8·:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�§7O

±�ªa ¯¸P�3 �$%�" ������� � ���¹º�+�����7���#���¼»½���M����3 �� ¾ �O9:6e�')(+*-,/.�0�132546.7(98�:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�§�]O9:�k�¿~(¼LM@IHQLa.%HS.B@7D/DU46.7CG@I*-4QLa.À:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�§�]O9: >�¿~(¼LM@IHQLa.%HS.B0�85H6HQ@J038M0�132M4S.%(38�(9@�*/13,Z@IH68R:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�]7k

O9: >3:6e ?A8<,-8MK7.7H68�0�85H|[email protected]�85H6HQ@J038M0�132M4S.%(38�(9@�*/13,Z@IH68Á:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�]7kO9: >3:�k ¯8MK7.%HS8�85H646CJ46(9@7V34SH64|8<0�8M,-46Y�@I2546.7(94°:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�]�OO9: >3: > ¥ .%(9La85*U*-4ACJ85*/@I*-85.%,-4QLa4[8�H6.7,/.P�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @À:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�¤%fO9: >3: O ?�@JL5.7,/,-85*U*/85252�@[email protected]�85H6H6@B0�8�0�132M4S.%(38<(9@�*/13,Z@IH68µ:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�¤+kO9: >3:�X ?�@JL5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@B0�85HALM@IHQLa.%HS.B0�85H6HQ@J038M0�132M4S.%(38<(9@I*-13,Z@IH68�:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�¤7O

O9: O ¿~(¼LM@IHQLa.%HS.B0�854|D-8M¢+138M(+*-4A@7HSHQ@GÃ=85(+*-2M85(Ä:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�¤�]O9: O9:6e ?A8<,-8MK7.7H68�0�85H|[email protected]�854|D-8M¢+138M(+*-4Å:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�¤%¤O9: O9:�k ')H|CB85*-.�0�.G0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.GDU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.G@JV3HS.�LMLZ�34Æ:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:��%f

e

Page 2: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

kO9: O9: > ¯[email protected](38=*/,/@[email protected]�8M4AD-8M¢+1385(+*/4[8=46H|CB8a*/.�0�.³0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.G@PV9HS.�L5LZ�94 :<:�:<:��+k

�=�M�+�$7���7���­�� ��������|�_�3 � ������l�M��ª � ²�­���5� �"�M�M� ���A��!#!"�+������+�h���s���+³¬ �$7�����_����!" ����=�M�+�$7���7� ��� ²

m�m n\op�cqsr�t-uho~�AtJv�x3���t-uho ��t�~�A�Jv�x9t��pq��°x��tU}~� �����²����������h�M�9�M��� �� ��������°�3�h����$7������ � ��� ��"!#��$%�����������������$7����� �#� ²

X�:6e�')(+*-,/.�0�132546.7(98�:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e7elXX�:�k�?A@GD-46(%*Z@7D/DU4[0�[email protected]@J0�8M4|�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4|0�8MH[�3,-46CB.G.7,Z0�46(38�:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e7elX

X�:�k�:6e ¥ .+Dc*Z@I(+*-4[46(90�46Y�460�1"@IH64|8��3,-8�0�4QL5@�*/4SY%8�:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e7elXX�:�k�:�k ¥ .+Dc*Z@I(+*-4hEF13(92546.7(9@7HS4³:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e7e�]X�:�k�: > ��19@7(+*-4Si"L5@I*-.7,/4_:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e7e��X�:�k�: O ')H|H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.B0�[email protected]%46LM@P03854|�3,/8M0346LM@�*-4 :<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�k7fX�:�k�:�X �s@7,-4Q@IV346H64[HS46V"8M,-8<8�Y�46(9La.%H6@I*-87: g .+Dc*/4 */132546.7(98p:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�k%k

X�: >�?A@GD-85CG@7(%*/46LM@[email protected]@B0�8M4[�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4Å:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�kIOX�: >3:6e ')(+*-8M,-�9,-85*/@I2M4S.%(34p:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�kIOX�: >3:�k ��8M,-4S*l @9T9DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H64 *� @3T�Y�@IH646034 *� @P8<8�¢+134SY�@7HS8M([email protected]@ :<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�k+]X�: >3: > ¨�H6L513(38<�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34hY�@IH6460�8�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>+kX�: >3: O ¡�HS46CB4S(9@7V346HS4S*l @B0�8MHSH68\La.+Dc*Z@I(+*-4[46(90�46Y�460�1"@IH64�:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>+kX�: >3:�X g .�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H64 *� @B8=Y�@7HS4Q0�4S*l @G0�8MHSH68������_@I�#85,-*-8<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>%>X�: >3: § ������*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46LZ�38 :=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>%>X�: >3: ] ')(+*-8M,/038ai9(346V346HS4S*l @G03854A¢+19@7(%*/4 i#L5@�*/.7,/4<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>+XX�: >3: ¤ ��,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34[D-4SCB46HS4 :<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>+X

¾�ªa _«w�+�M�|�������� � ��S¬ F®��+����A���°�3�h����$7� � & �§3:6e�')(+*-,/.�0�132546.7(98�:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:=:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>�]§3:�k�')H|CB8a*/.�0�.³0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.GDU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.µ:�:<:<:�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: eM>%¤§3: >�Â~@7�3�".%,U*/4[EF,[email protected](3(98a*U*/4SY�4|8<¢+19@7(%*/4 i#L5@�*/.7,/4�:<:�:<:=:<:<:�:<:�:<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e5O�X§3: O ��19@7(%*/4 i#L5@I2M4S.%(38�CR13HS*-46�3HQ@J8\@IH6V"8M,-4|LZ�38�Y�@I(9(3.³@IH6H�´ 46(�i9(34S*-. :<:�:<:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�X%k§3:�X ¥ .7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@P8\La.7CB�3H68a*/852M2M@B0�85HACJ85*-.�0�.G0�8MHSH�´ @7HSV#85,/.GDU8MCG@I(+*-4QLa.¶:<:�:<:=:<:�:<:<:�:<:�:<: e�X7§

Page 3: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �W���<��� �<� ���£� � ����� � �� �����

���������������! "����#

?A@�H6.7K%46LM@� 8º13(9@�0346D/La46�3H64S(9@�LZ�38 �9@�03@�*/85CB�".°@%L5¢+134QDU4S*-.�13("@�038MLa4QD/@�@71�*-.%(3.7CB4Q@�8�0  8 @7,U*/46L5.7HQ@�*Z@�46(D-Yl@7,-4Q@�*/4¯DU85*U*-.%,-4�T�D-�"8�D-D-.�@IHQ¢%1"@I(+*-.�8a*-8M,-.%K78M(3854_�"8M,G.7V3468a*-*-46Y�4_8 CB8a*/.�0�4�T (3854~¢+19@7HS4b.%�"8M,/@7(3.�D-�"8�La4Q@IH646DU*-4La.%CB8 46(R.%K7(34�@IHS*-,/.�,Z@ICB.=0�85H6H�´ 46CJ�9,-8�D-@=D-L54S8M(+*-4Si"L5@9:  ¡�@7D/D-@74+@7,/0�19.��3,/.7�#.7,/,-8 13(9@=L5@7,/@I*U*-8M,-46252�@I2M4S.%(38s0�[email protected]@GLZ�98\�".+D-D/@3T#03@G13(½HQ@�*/.9T"*-8M(385,=La.7(+*/.³0�85H6HS8JDU198\CB.7HS*-85�9HS4QLa4�0�4S,Z@[email protected](34|8%T#09@IH6H�´ @IHS*-,/.9T"8MD/DU8M,-8\L5.%D)  $La46,ZLa.%DU*/@7(3254Q@�*Z@G03@³0�8MHS46CB4 *Z@I,/8R46(¼CB.�0�.­D-1&%³La4685(+*-8MCJ8M(+*-8R�9,-8�La4QDU.³46H�D-13.º@ICRV94 */.³8RH68RD-138RCB8a*/.�0�.7H6.7K%4S8%:')(G¢+138MDU*-8¯H6852M4S.%(34�T+La.%CR13(9¢+138%T%D-46@7CB.=46(+*-8M,-8�D-D/@�*/43DU.+Dc*Z@I(32M46@7HSCB85(+*/8b@%0J13(3.\D-.7H6.�0385K7H649@%DU�#8a*-*-490�8MHSH�´ @ICB�346.Y78M(+*/@IK%HS46.¯0�85H6H68�,-4QLa8M,/LZ�38�L5.7(90�.7*U*/8s(385H6H�´ @7CRV34S*-.~0�[email protected]@9T5.+D-D-46@b@¯¢+138MHSH6.~Dc*/.7,/46LM@ICB85(+*/8��34U 1\@7(+*-4QLa.b8s�34U 1D-�"8�La4Si"La."T%LZ�38~D-43�3,/8ai9K%K78_H�´ @I("@IH646D-438¯HQ@<L5@I,Z@�*-*-8M,-46252�@I2546.7(98 0�8M49�3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/430�8M0�13*U*-46Y�4�T+H�´ 46(90�46Y�460�1"@I2546.7(988�H�´ 8MD-�3H646L54 *Z@I2M4S.%(38<0�854ALM@I(3.%(34|0�8MHALa.%,-,/8a*-*-.B0�8M0�19,-,/8�8%T3(3.%(ºD-8ML5.7(903@7,-4Q@ICB8M(%*/87T�0�8MH|HS46(3K%19@IK%K746.RCB8M0�4Q@I(+*/846HA¢+19@IH68<DU4[8�DU�3,/46CJ.%(3.B4[,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-4[DU*-8MD/D-4�:

¿~(9. 03854�L5.7CB�34S*-4s�3,/46(9La46�9@IH64s0�8MHSHQ@ HS.%K74QL5@� 8G¢+1385H6HS.½0�4!')(+*-,/.1032546.87:9;4"')'"<=,/.?>)</9-'@4+AB*-4@9DCE0�7F<GA3.1>)0H(I2G0J 2G< J <K'[email protected]</9-. T �3,/8M0�4QDU�#.7(985(90�.�0�85H6H68G*-8�La(34QLZ�38­�#85,B0�85*-85,/CB4S("@I,/8­¢+19@I(903.¼H6@�Y78M,-4S*l @½0�4_13(9@�La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38La.%(9D-85K7198�(38�La8MD/D/@I,/46@7CJ8M(+*-8�09@IH6H6@PY78M,-4S*l @P0�85H6HS8��3,/85CB8�D-D-8NMG0/2)'O,B4@PQ<39R'L(+250/9S,/.UT : ¿~( @IHS*-,/.P@7D-�#8a*U*/.9T3DU*-,/8a*-�*/@7CB85(+*-8bLa.%HSH685K+@�*-.�La.7(R4SH��3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/87T� 8_¢%1985H6HS.�0�4�0�8a*/85,/CB4S(9@7,-8%T�03@�*/8_L585,-*-8��9,-8MCJ8�D-D-87T�@7H */,-8 �3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94LZ�38<D-.7(3.PHS.%,-.BLa.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@RHS.%K74QL5@VM5032)'�[email protected]@9;,3.UT : g 8=4|L5,-4S*-8M,-4h�#85,~DU*/@7V34SH646,-8�¢+19@I(903.P13(A´ @7,-K%.7CB85(+*/@I�2546.7(98J 8=L5.7(�Y�4S(9L585(+*-8�.B�#85,ZDU19@%DU46Y�@PD-.7(9.J0�4�@7D/D-@74h034U%³La46H68<8MD-�3HS4QLa4S*/@72546.7(38�8�,/4SK%.7,/4S2M2M@I2M4S.%(38ZY³8<,/4S8M(%*/,/@7(3.(38MHSHQ@½La.+DU4Q030�85*U*/@[(\4)</2L.10[,B4@787^] 032IA_<3PQ4@9-(\0`[email protected]<39;4aY° 8G�#.%D/DU46V346HS8G46(90�46Y�460�1"@I,/8³0�85H6HS8­,-8MK7.7H68GLZ�38­L5.7(9D-85(+*-.%(3.0�4��9@%D-D/@I,/8P09@ 19(�46(9D-4S8MCJ8G0�4��9,-8MCJ8�D-D-8B@­13("@ºL5.7(9L5HS1"DU46.7(38BLZ�38B(38  8BLa.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@ HS.%K74QL5@9:R?A@ HS.%K74QL5@9T¢+1346(90�4�T9La.%(%*/,/@7,-4Q@ICB8M(%*/8�@%0­13(A´ .%�34S(94S.%(38<0�4Ubh19D/@GLZ�38�H6@J4Q0�85(+*/4 i"LM@JK785(985,/46LM@ICB85(+*-8�La.%( H�´ @I,-*-8<0�85H[,Z@IK%4S.7�(9@7CJ8M(+*-.9T+Y�@R46(+*-8�D-@9T+@7HSCB85(9.R46(­�3,/4SCG@P@I�3�3,/.%D/D-4SCG@I2M4S.%(387T%La.7CB8N7F<�'L(I*-,3.1<c,B4@787F4�2G4+Ad</7e4O,/.�.89 �"4"254@9DCE0c>)fR4'@</9S<V>)<32L254"(+(\4aT".%D/DU4Q@GLZ�38\La.%(90�19L5.7(3.³@­La.7("LaH619DU46.7(94|Y78M,-8%T"¢[email protected],Z@B@I�3�9HS4QL5@I*-8\@G�3,/85CB8�D-D-8\LZ�38\,/46D-13HS*/@7(3.Y78M,-8%T�Y�@IH68�@B0�46,/8�2G4+Ad</7e4�>)fR4O2L.g' J 4@(+(h039;<6.87�9;4"')'"<i,/.j>)</9-'@4+AB*-4@9DCE0c7F<GAB.1>G0I:

��8M0346@7CJ.�.7,Z@�0�4~�3,/8ML546D/@I,/8­CB85K%HS46.�@IHQLa13(34~@%DU�#8a*-*-4¯EF.%(903@7CJ8M(+*/@IH64¯0�85H6H�´ 46(903@7K746(38 HS.%K74QL5@3:·')(Å�3,-46CB.H613.7K%. Y�@º,-46V9@%0�4 */.½LZ�38BHS.½DU*-190�46.½0�854�,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-4 DU4�,/4SY%.7H6K78B@ ¢%1985H6HS4�K%4  @k4"' J 7l.1>@.8(h03(I. 46(�19(9@ ¢%1"@IHQLZ�38EF.7,/CG@½0�4sH64S([email protected]³(3.7(�@7HSH�´ @I*U*/4SY�4S*l @½0�8MH�,[email protected]("@I,/87T|@I4��3,-.�L58MD/DU4s46(+*-8M,-(34 0�85H �"8M(9DU4685,/.-m�@7HSCB85(9. 09@n3,/85K%8¯4S(G�#.74A 8~0�46Y78M(+13*/@<LZ�34Q@I,Z@�H6@<034SY�@I,/4QL5@I2M4S.%(38b*-,Z@�HQ@��9DU4QLa.%HS.%K74Q@=8~H6@\HS.%K74QL5@3T%03@�*/.\LZ�38�¢+138MDU*M´ 13HS*-46CG@\DU4,/4SY%.7H6K78=(3.7( @IH6H�´ @�*-*-46Y�4 *� @G0�85H6H6@J(3.+Dc*/,/@PCB85(+*-8%T3CG@GDU8MCBCB@74|@IHpo-�"8M(9D-@I*-.dq3T�13(9@JY%.7HS*/@BLZ�38<¢+138MDU*-.  8<DU*/@�*/.La.%CR13(946LM@�*-.B@�*-*-,Z@lY78M,/D-.\¢+19@IHQLZ�38�EF.7,/CB@J0�4[H64S([email protected]:�')( DU8�La.7("0�.RH613.7K%.9T�46( ,/4 EF8M,-46CB85(+*-.B@IHhH64S(9K719@7K7K746.(9@I*-13,Z@IH687T�DU4s�91� .½.%D/DU8M,-Y�@7,-8BLZ�38³D-.7H6.½13(9@ �9@7,U*/8B034�8MD/D-.ºY�4685(38³L5.7CP13(385CB8M(%*/8G4SCB�34685K+@�*Z@ (385H6H�´ @�*-*-46Y�4 *� @46(�EF85,/85(32M46@7HS8%© K74) @�@��9@7,U*/4S,/8 03@�¨~,/46DU*-.7*-85H68 H6@�H6.7K%46LM@�D-4< 8º,-46Y7.%H *Z@�@7H�0�4QD-L5.7,ZDU.�@7D/DU8M,U*/.7,/4S."T�La46.9 8º¢+138MHSH6.La.+Dc*/4 */134S*-.¼03@º85(�13("La4Q@�*-4 LZ�38G�".+D-D-.7(9. 8�D-D-85,/8BY785,/4�. E�@IHQD-4�:�rP´ @7H */,/@ �"@I,-*-87TAH�´ .7V3468a*-*-46Y7.so-�3,-46CG@I,/4S.dq³(3.%( 8½La.+Dc*/4 */134S*-.�03@7HSH�´ @I(9@7HS4QDU4~03854�,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4¯La.7("0�.I*-*-4�(9854~H64S(9K719@7K7K74¯("@�*-19,/@7HS4�: ')(�E�@I*U*/4�T¯(38MH��3,/.%D/D-4SCB.�9@7,/@7K7,Z@�EF.PL585,ZLZ�385,/85CB.J0�4ALZ�34Q@I,/4S,/8�La.7CB8�[email protected]%46LM@R,/4QLZ�34S8�03@JH�´ 46(%*/,-.�0�192546.7(38<0�4|19( H64S([email protected]@I,-*-4Si"La4Q@IH68LZ�38%T#D-85�3�913,-8RCJ.�0�8MHSHQ@�*/.­@lY78M(90�.G�3,/8MD-85(+*/4�@IHQLa19(38RL5@7,/@I*U*/85,/46DU*-4QLZ�38\0�8M4�H64S(9K719@7K7K74A(9@�*/13,/@7HS4�Y Y�@IH68R@³0�46,/8¢+1385H6H68JLZ�38P4S(+*/85,/Y785(9K7.7(9.³(385H6H�´ @I*U*-46Y�4 *� @ 038M0�1�*-*-46Y�@cYhT[(3.7(¼�91� .º@3bh@I*U*/.­4Q0�85(+*-4Si"LM@I,ZDU4 La.%(�13(�EF,/@7CJCB8M(%*/.0�4�13(3.°0�4~8�D-D-4�T_46( ¢+19@I(+*/.�Y�13.%HS8½�9,-.%�".%,/D-4~La.%CJ8½(9.7(Å,-4SEF85,/85(+*/8MD-4~@70 13(3.°D-�"8�La4Si"La.°L5.7(+*-8M(�1�*-."TbL54S.9 8La.%CB8B03.I*/@I*-.½0�4s19(��9,-8�La4QDU.½D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/.9T|CG@ �3461�*-*-.%DU*-.½L5.7CB8G13(�La.%(%*/85(34S*-.%,-8J�#.I*-8M(3254Q@IH68³0�4�034Ubh85,/85(+*-4D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/4[�9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-4�:

>

Page 4: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O��� �� �� #?���� "����#��3�N�����"# � # �������"���N ����

g 8\D-4|La.%(9DU4Q0�8M,/@7(3.P4|*-,/8�D-85K%1385(+*/4[8MD-85CB�34A0�4[,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/.9©���4aP�.89;<3254Q,/.��� 4a*&9H9-*&Pc4"25< �4aP�.89;<3254N,3.:*&9=037l(I2G<�� 0/787e</250i.87 '@4)>)</9;,_< �4OPQ0`A`AB.1</2G4c,B4@7 J 2L.8Pc<� �[email protected]</254c,3. �� 0c2G4"(+(h0�2 �4 J 4"2 J 4@9;,/.1>)<37F0/254c03787F06254"(+(\0Q'� 4a*&9H254"(+(\0 �4 J 4@2 J 4@9;,3.1>G<37F0/2G4c0B,6*&9S] 037l(+250��j0/787e</250i7F0c'"4)>)</9S,B0 �4a.89S>".1,_4"9X(h4�0/787e0 J 2L.8PQ0' �4O.89;>@.1,B4@9-(\4N0_,�2�H032L.1< �4O9-. J </(\4�,/.�� 7F,_<� 4a*&9S0 J 4"2)'@</9S0 �4O9-. J </(\4�,/.:*&9 ] 0/7U(I250 �j0/787F<3250�!"*-4"'L(E] *&7l(+.8Pc0 �4�C".1<i,B4@787F0 J 2L.8Pc0� 7e,B< �4�[email protected]<6,3."�H0/2L.1<

D-4%�31� .�46CJCB8�0�46@I*/@7CJ8M(+*-8 L5.7(9DU*/@I*/@7,-8sHQ@~H6.7,/.�DU*-,/8a*-*-4QD-D-4SCG@�@I(9@7HS.%K74Q@3:[')(<*/1�*U*/4�8s*-,/8�19(9@~�3,/85CB8�D-D/@~@/bh85,/CG@46H�DU1"D-D-46DU*-8M,-8³034s13(9@½L585,-*/@ ,/[email protected](98PEF,Z@º13(�46(90�46Y+4Q0�13.½8­13(�@IHS*-,/.-m�H�´ @IHS*-,Z@ �3,/85CB8MD/D-@ LZ�38G46H�D-19D/DU4QDc*/85,/80�4~¢+138�Dc*Z@�,/85HQ@I2M4S.%(38 La.7CB�#.7,-*/@9T ¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4¯D-46@7(3.�4~03138½4S("0�4SY�4Q0�134�T 46H~D-19D-D-4QDc*/85,/8 034¯13(|´ @IHS*-,Z@�,/85HQ@I2M4S.%(38*-,Z@³46H�DU8�La.%(90�.­46(90�46Y�460313.­8J4SH �3,/46CJ.Xm[H6@ La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38P@3b#8M,-CG@­LZ�98P¢+138MDU*M´ 13HS*-46CG@­,/85HQ@I2M4S.%(38RD-19D-D-4QDc*/8REF,Z@46HsDU8�La.7("0�. 8J46H��3,/4SCB. 46(90�46Y+4Q0�13. CB85(92546.7(9@I*-4�(38MHSHQ@º�3,-46CG@º�3,-8MCB8MD/D-@9: g 4s0346L58³LZ�38B4 *-,/8J,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4�9@7(3(3.ºH6@ DU*-8MD/D/@��"<32LPQ0�7e<5AB.1>)0�:G� 85,�46HsDU19D/D-46DU*-8M,-8B0�85H�(98MD/DU.º0�4�La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@³H6.7K74QL5@­(3.7(� 8J4SCB�#.7,-*/@I(+*/8HQ@B(9@�*/13,/@G0385K7H64|46(90�46Y�460�194�CB85(92546.7(9@I*-4jM�(+19CJ8M,-4�T9,/8a*-*-8%T9�#85,ZDU.%(38ETaT3($#8\0�8MHSH68\,/85HQ@I2M4S.%(34|La.%4S(�Y7.%H */8cMFCB4S(9.7,/88JCB@7K7K%4S.%,-8%T9�#85,/�"8M(90�4QLa.7HQ@I,/8\8J4S("La4Q0�85(+*-8%T[(346�".7*-8J8R2546.dTaT|¢+19@I(+*-.­4�(98MD/DU4 Dc*Z@IV346H64 */4�EF,Z@³H68J�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8P8RHQ@La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(387:�¨��3�9@I,/8\@IH6H6.7,Z@P0�8MH[*-13*U*-.G("@�*-19,/@7HS8�,/85(90�8M,-8=*/,/@%DU�9@7,-8M(+*-8�¢%1"@I(+*-.  8<DU1R%GL54S8M(+*-8\@JK%@7,/@7(%*/4S,/846H�,/46L5.7(3.+D-L54SCB85(+*/.º0�8MH�(38�D-D-.¼0�4�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@ºHS.%K74QL5@ La.%(�13(9@ .%�3�".%,U*/13(9@ ,/46D/La,/4S*U*-19,/@9: g 8³46(90�4QLZ�[email protected].%(&%R8 ' 490�138¯46(90�46Y�460�194�T+La.7()(�HQ@��3,/4SCG@=,/[email protected](987TILa.%(+*�HQ@�DU8�La.%(903@QMF.�Y�Y78M,-.�4S("0�46LZ�946@7CJ.\L5.7(JHS85*U*/85,/8K7H64[85H685CB8M(%*/4!oUY�@7,-4Q@IV346H64eqP(3854|*-,/8=,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4gT D-4[.I*U*/4S8M(387©

,?0 �J 4"2O<GA39X.j,/*-4O.89;,3.8W`.1,3*&.�-.�0/���'@41,2-3/�� 03787F</250 � /�-� �)0

M54BT

')H#(38MD/DU.J0�4[La.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@\HS.%K74QL5@R@%L5¢+134QDc*Z@RD-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-.\�3,/.7�9,-46.\46(­,/[email protected](98�@RD/La,/4S*U*-19,-8=La.7CB8�¢+138MDU*/@9T46( La134¯i"K713,Z@I(3.�0�8M4~*/85,/CJ46(34�4SH�L5134�Y�@7HS.%,-8� 8½46(90�85*-85,/CB4S("@�*-.":¦Â¯4S*-.%,-("@I(90�.�@7H~�3,/4SCB.°0�8M4~*-,/8½8MD-85CB�340�4�,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.9ThHS8³03138B�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8BDU.%(3.ºY785,/8J8GH6@ºLa.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38  8JY%85,Z@³8%T�¢+1346(90�4�TA(3.%(�@7�3�9@I,/8RCB.%H */.D-85(9D/@�*/. @3b#8M,-CG@7,-8BLZ�38G46Hs,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.� 8GLa.%,-,/8a*-*-.º�".%46LZ�$#87TAD-8GHS8G�9,-8MCJ8�D-D-8GDU.%(3. Y78M,-8%T|HS.� 8B@7(9LZ�38BHQ@La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(387T309@�*-.³LZ�987T90�4AE�@�*-*-.9T9HS8<�3,/85CB8�D-D-8<8<[email protected](9L5HS1"DU46.7(38<D-.7(3.BY%85,/87:s�~8MH�[email protected] T946(�Y78�La87T��"@�#85,-EF8a*U*Z@ICB85(+*/8=D-85(9D-.P034S,/87T3@%0G8MD-85CB�346.9T�o-D-81(6%7'� 8=Y78M,/@_q<46( ¢+19@I(+*/.9T�@RD-8ML5.7(903@P0�85H[D-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-.P0348%#T30�4'�8\0�49(JT:(6%7'~�#.I*/,l @B8�D-D-85,/8=Y785,Z@�M�@%0 8�DU8MCB�34S.³D-8;%=<¦k�T>'2< X3T:(?<wCJ46(3.%,-8%T3.7�3�913,-8<D-8�%=< §3T>'$< >3T(@<j03.7�3�346.dT�.7�9�313,/8RE�@7H6D/@=M�DU8=%A<W]�TB'�<pX�TB(@<pCB4S(3.%,-8%T[.7�3�913,-8BD-8=%C<Á§3TB'�< O"T9(@<W0�.%�3�346.dT :')H[(38�D-D-.G0�4|La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@9T�8�¢+1346(90�4AH6@BLa.%,-,/8a*-*-8M252M@P0�85HA,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-.9T�D-19D-D-4QDc*/8��#85,ZLZ�$#8%T�¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4D-46@7(3.GK7H64�46(90�46Y�4603134�0385(3.7*/@�*/4�03@D% 8P03@D'lT#8\H68R,/[email protected](94A0�85(9.I*/@I*-8R09@D(Á8R03@D*bT '@4�7F4 J 2G4"Pc4L')'@4N'@</9S<W/4"254E� 0/787e</250 �4OWK4@2506039;>)fR4N7F0i>G<39;>@7l*D'L.1</9S4a:

¥ 4) .�LZ�38_@IV3V34Q@ICB.~8MY�460�8M(3254Q@�*/.�46(P¢+138�Dc*/.�L5@%DU.��9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-8s@%L5L5@%0�8�46(RK%85(38M,/@7HS8%©[DU8b03@�@7H6L513(38 �3,-8MCB8MDU�D-8\0�46D/La8M(90�8\H6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*/8=19(9@GLa.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(387T3H6.³DU*-8MD/D-.B@%L5LM@70�8<46(º*-1�*-*-8RH68\D-4 */19@I2M4S.%(34|46(¼La134�HS8<�3,/85CB8�D-D-88ºH6@�La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38­�9@7(3(3.�H6@�Dc*/8MD/D-@¼EF.7,/CG@¼H6.7K74QL5@9:�?s´ 4S(9034SY�4Q0�19@I2M4S.%(38 0�85H6H6@�EF.7,/CG@¼H6.7K%46LM@�@lY�Y�4S8M(38­La.%(,/4 EF8M,-46CB85(+*-.­@­13(¼H64S([email protected]�8�DU�3,/8MD/D-4S.%(34|(3.%(�DU.%(3.³($#8\Y78M,-8%T9($#8\E�@IHQDU8%T"CG@­LZ�98PD-.7(3.­D-19D/La85*U*-46V346HS40�4|CB.%H */85�3H646L54|46(%*/85,/�3,/8a*/@72546.7(34�M�8\DU.%HS.B0�.7�#.G13(9@J46(+*-85,/�3,/8a*[email protected](98=@%D-D-13CB.7(3.J13(½D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/.B�3,-8�La4QDU.DT :

?s´ 19D-.½0�854�D-46CRV#.7H64�T�.%D/DU4Q@º4SHs�"@7D/D-@7K7K746. @%0 MF43TaT�(3.%(· 8G8MD/DU8M(3254Q@IH68VM�(�13HSHQ@ Y�4S85*/@9TA(38MHs�3,/4SCB.½,[email protected]("@��CB85(+*-."T+0349�3,/8MD/La46(90�8M,-8~03@7H"D-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-.\0�4[k�T�X�T+CJ46(3.%,-8¯[email protected],/8ETaTICG@�E�@7L54SH64S*/@<8M(3.7,/CB85CB85(+*-8�H�´ @I([email protected]@R0�85Hh,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-.":A')(3.%H */,-8%T+L5.7CB8�Y%8M0�,/85CB.P4S(­D-85K%134S*-.9T�D-4",/46Y785HQ@<.%�3�".%,U*/13(3.REF.7,/CB@7HS46252�@I,/8�@I("LZ�38H68\,-8�Dc*Z@I(+*-4A�9@I,-*-4A0385K7H64|8M(+19(9La4Q@�*/4�0�4��9@I,-*-8M(32M@9T3�"8M,�L5134�T"4S(¼038ai9(34S*-46Y�@3T"H6@�MF43TbY%85,/,l @J@70½@%D-D-13CB85,/87T303.7�#.

Page 5: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

XH68<�3,-8�[email protected](34[LZ�38=E�@7,-8MCJ.B46(½DU8MK7134S*-."T+HQ@GD-85K71985(+*-8<La.%(�i9K%13,/@72546.7(38%©

,?0 �������� M ( ����� * ��� T� �)0

MF4.4BT

87T9�"8M,¯4S(90346LM@I,/8�LZ�98=46H|,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.­ 8<La.%,-,/8a*-*-."T�D-4|D/La,/4SY%87© ( %7'� ������� M ( ����� * ��� T� �� < *' %

M�LZ�98sDU4%HS8MK7K78%©Io-H6@ �3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38*' %< 8sLa.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@_H6.7K74QL5@b0�8MHSH�´ 4S(9D-4685CB8s0�47�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34 (6% '�T ������� M ( �����* ��� T� EqdTLm3D-4|.7CB8a*-*-.%(3.B�".%4[�"8M,~V3,/85Y�4 *� @JHS8��9@7,-8M(%*/8MD-4[K7,Z@/bh87©

(6%7'� ������� M ( ����� * ��� T�� < *'E%��

����@� �N �����p��� # ��#!�O�: ���3�O������"#�� �� ���� ���@ ���� #������ # ������ E���

[email protected]@9T�0�13(9¢+138%Th 8�13(9@B0�4QD-L54S�3H646([email protected],/CB@7HS8%©�H�´ 4S(9034SY�4Q0�19@I2M4S.%(38<0�[email protected],/,-85*U*/85252�@R0�8M4[,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-4hDU4V9@%D-@<D-13H6H6@��"<32LPQ0�0�8MK7H64985(�13("La4Q@�*-4hLZ�38~46(+*-8M,-Y%85(3K%.7(3.�46(³8MD/DU4�T+�3,-8�D-L54S("0�85(903.\03@I4"HS.%,-.RD-�#8MLa4Si"L54"La.%(+*-85(�1�*/4�:')H��9,-.%V3HS8MCG@�0�4�0�85i9(346,-8�La.7(Å8�D-@I*U*-8M252�@�La.%D/@�D-4~4S(+*/85(903@°�"8M, ocEF.%,-CG@�H6.7K%46LM@Bq� 8¼@I,Z0�13."T_(9.7(��9@�13("@D-.7H6132546.7(38G0�85i9(34S*-46Y�@½8G(3.7(Å 8G�#.%D/D-4SV346H68³@/bh,-.%(%*Z@I,/HS.º46(�Y+4Q@º�3,/85H64SCB46(9@I,/87:º¨~4s(3.+Dc*/,-4 D-L5.7�34¯ 8³D-1&%³La4685(+*/8HQ@ LM@I,Z@�*U*/85,/[email protected](38\46(+*-134S*-46Y�@½DU8�La.%(90�.­HQ@º¢%1"@IH68JHQ@­EF.7,/CB@ H6.7K74QL5@¼ 8B0�8a*/85,/CJ46(9@I*/@º03@ ¢+138M4 *-8M,-CB46(34s0�85H0�4QD-L5.7,ZDU. M�0�85*U*/4 ').89S>)0/(\4+Ad</2G4"Pc0/(+.1>".UTG4b¢+19@7HS4¯(9.7(��"@I(3(3.�13( Y78M,-.�8 �3,/.7�9,-46.�D-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-.9T�CB@�@IK%46D/La.%(3.D-13H~DU46K7(94 i"LM@�*/.�034~@IHS*-,/4b*-85,/CB4S(94~03@I(903.�H613.%K7.�@�(�13.�Y�4b*/85,/CJ46(34~0�.7*/@I*-4~0�4�D-46K7(34Si"L5@I*-.": ��85K7H64¯8MD-85CB�34�3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/4�T+DU.%(3.�*-8M,-CB46(34"03.I*/@I*-4#0�4"D-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-.��3,/.7�3,/4S.cM�0�8a*-*-4�>G03(h4hAd</254@Pc0/(+.1>".UT_k�T�X�T7CB46(3.7,/87T%CG@IK7K%4S.%,-8%THQ@\,/8a*U*Z@���T��"8M,-�#85(90346L5.7HQ@I,/87T+4S(9L5460385(+*-8%T+8�L5L7: M�¢%1985H6HS4[LZ�38�@[email protected]".%HS46252�@�*/.\(385H6HQ@6M54BT^TaT+CB8M(%*/,-8�DU.%(3.D-4S(9LM@�*/85K7.%,-8MCG@�*-4QLa4�4A*/85,/CB4S(34�qI*-1�*-*-4gq­8 o-D-8³:5:M:5T|@7HSH6.7,Z@ :5:M:5qMFY�@IH68P@ 0�4S,/8B¢%1985H6HS4 LZ�38B@IV3V34Q@ICB.³HQ@7D/La4Q@�*/.(3.%(ºD-4SCPV".%HS46252�@�*/4|(385H6HQ@VMF43TpTa:

� L5L5.7,/,-8<0�4QDU*-46(3K7138M,-8V>G<32L254@(I(\4GC)CE0\034A13(¼,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/.G03@�W/4"2L.8( �0\0385H6HS8JLa.7("LaH619DU46.7(94�:�¥ .%(9DU4Q0�8M,[email protected]%1385(+*-4[8�DU8MCB�34�©�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4��)2G0/9;>)4"'@4�R*&(+(I.�. �)25039;>)4L'L.�'@<39;<6>)<32)').�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4N>)<32)'"<

MceKT

�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4 Ad4@9;</W/4"'"4�R*&(+(I.�. Ad4"9S</W/4L'L.�'@</9S<i>@.89;4"'L.�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4N>@.89;4"'@4

M�k_T

�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4N>)<32)'"<�R*&(+(I.�.j>)</2)'L.�'@</9S<��)25039;>)4"').�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4��)2G0/9;>)4"'@4

M�>dT

�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4N>@.89;4"'@4�R*&(+(I.�.j>@.89;4"').:'"<39;<i>G<32)'L.�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4N>)<32)'"<

MFODT

�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4��)2G0/9;>)4"'@4�R*&(+(I.�. �)25039;>)4L'L.�'@<39;<64@*&25< J 4@.�N0 J </7F4)<39;4 �4N>)<32)'"<

M�X_T

'��3,-46CB49¢+19@�*-*-,/.�,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-43D-.7(3.<La.%,-,/8a*-*-4+mI*/1�*U*Z@lY+4Q@=4S(�MUeET�HQ@<La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38= 8bY785,Z@=8¯13(9@��3,/85CB8�D-D/@ 8BE�@7H6D/@3T 46( M�kBT\H6@�La.7("LaH619DU46.7(98  8GE�@IHQD/@ 8­85(+*/,/@7CRV#8GHS8 �3,-8MCB8MD/DU8³D-.7(3. E�@7H6D-87T 46( M�>dT�H68­�3,/85CB8MD/D-8³DU.%(3.

Page 6: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§Y78M,-8G8 H6@�La.7("LaH619DU46.7(98GY785,Z@3T�46( MFOdT\HS8­�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8³D-.7(3.¼E�@IHQDU8³8­H6@¼L5.7(9L5HS1"DU46.7(38GY%85,Z@3:½?A@½EF.7,/CB@ H6.7K%46LM@M�D-46CRV#.7H646LM@_T_0�4A¢+138�Dc*/4|�3,/4SCB4A¢+19@I*U*-,/.J,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-4� 87©

�p0��� M�� � ����� T� 0

MF4.4.4BT

?A@PLa.%,-,/8a*-*-852M2M@\0385Hh,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.\8�D-L5HS1"0�8=LZ�98�D-4#�#.%D/D/@\�3,/8MD-85(+*/@7,-8�4SH[[email protected]( La194#H68=�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8=DU.%(3.85(+*/,/@7CRV#8�Y78M,-8�8�[email protected]("LaH619DU46.7(98~E�@IHQD/@Rm�K7H64[@IHS*-,/4#[email protected](9.\*-13*U*-4[�#.%D/D-4SV346H64�: ')(=M�XBTaT3@I(9LZ�38=DU8=H68��3,/85CB8�D-D-88RHQ@­L5.7(9L5HS1"DU46.7(38JDU.%(3.³Y%85,/87T#4SH�,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.½ 8PD-L5.7,/,-85*U*-."T"46(�¢+19@7(%*/.­HQ@³Y%85,/4 *� @³0�85H6HQ@­La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38\(3.%(D-85K7198�@3bh@I*U*/.B09@J¢+138MHSHQ@G0�8MHSH68��3,-8MCB8MD/DU8%:

?A@�H6.7K%46LM@�DU4=.�L5L513�9@�0�4�EF.7,/CB8¼HS.%K74QLZ�38¼La.%CB8¼H6@ M54.4BTB8¼HQ@ M5434.4BT T¯H68�¢+19@IH64�D-.7(3.�8�DU�9,-8�D-D-8½4S( 13(H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.­@I,-*-4Si"L546@7HS8RLZ�98P�9@­H6@ L5@7,/@I*U*-8M,-4QDU*-4QL5@³0�4 �3,/8MD/La46(90�8M,-8R4S(�H6@7,-K%�346D/D-4SCG@GCB4QDU13,Z@��\03@I4 La.%(+*-85(�1�*/4�T8RL54  .  8<,/8MD-.G(38ML58MD/D-@7,-46.B03@IH6H�´ .7V94S85*U*-46Y7.³034A85Y�4Q0�85(9254Q@I,/8=46HA(98MD/DU.³0�4�La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]%46LM@3: g 8PDU4�La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@LZ�38%T[4S(�DU8M(9D-.­HQ@�*-."T[13(9@­*-8M.7,/46@¼ 8R13(�H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.³CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8J46H�¢+19@IH68JD-4�E�@I(3(9.º@3b#8M,-CG@I2M4S.%(34�,-8MH6@I*-46Y78P@%013(�03@�*/. 19(34SY%85,ZDU.º0�4�.7K%K785*U*-4�T|D-4��31� . 0�4S,/87TA4S(��3,/4SCG@º@I�3�3,/.%D/D-4SCG@I2M4S.%(387ThLZ�38BH�´ 13(94SY%85,ZDU.�µ0�8MHSHQ@­H6.7K%46LM@ 8½La.+Dc*/4 */134S*-.�03@7HSHQ@�LaHQ@7D/DU8¼0385H6HS8 EF.%,-CB8½H6.7K74QLZ�38 8MD-�3,/8MD/DU8 46(�13(�H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.�D-46CRV#.7H646L5.�µ8MD/@�*-*/@ICB8M(%*/80�85i9(34S*-.9T�8=H�´ .7V94S85*U*-46Y7.P�3,/85Y�@IH685(+*-8\ 8�¢+138MHSH6.P0�4[0�85*-8M,-CB46(9@I,/8�H68�EF.%,-CB8�HS.%K74QLZ�38�La.%,-,/8a*-*-8�,-8MH6@I*-46Yl@7CB85(+*-8�@%013(½La.%(9La85*U*/.J,/46K7.7,/.%D/@ICB8M(%*/8�0�85i9(34S*-.G0�4AL5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@PHS.%K74QL5@ �I:

?s´ 19D-.G0�4|13( H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.PLZ�38<46CB�34685K%@J(�13CB85,/.%D-4[DU46CRV#.7H64|�9@PE�@I*U*-.³D)  $[LZ�38<HQ@JHS.%K74QL5@JDU4Q@GDc*Z@�*Z@JD-.�Y78M(+*-8@7LMLa.%CJ�"@IK7("@�*/@G09@IH6H�´ @�*-*-,/4SV313*-.�'L.8P �)</7l.1>)0�:���@IH68\*/85,/CB4S(38­ 8R.%,/@­L5@7031�*-. 4S(�0346D-19D-.­�#.74QLZ� #8RD-.I*-*-.7H646(38M@­13(@7D-�#8a*U*/.<La.7("La8a*-*-19@7HSCB8M(%*/8bCJ8M(3.\D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/4SY%.�0�8MHSH�´ 4S(909@IK746(38¯H6.7K%46LM@3: � </2LPc0/7l.FC)CE0`[email protected]<39;4�8 ').8P �)</7l.FC)CE0`[email protected]<39;4D-.7(3.�03138ºL5.7(9L58a*-*-4b0�4SY%85,ZDU4�:�¿�(·D-46DU*-8MCG@¼0�4¯DU46CRV#.7H64� 8³46(%*/,-.�0�.7*U*/.��#85,J.I*U*/85(38M,-8 CG@IK7K%4S.%,-8³LZ�946@7,-8M252M@9T�3,/8ML546D-4S.%(38¯.RL5.7(9L546D-4S.%(38aM�@%0B8MD-85CB�346.9T%H6@\DU*-8M(3.7K%,/@Ii"@3T7H6@\D-85K%(9@IH68a*/46LM@�Dc*/,/@%03@IH687T%4SH"HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.\@7HSK%85V3,/4QLa.dTaTCG@~La.%(9D-85,/Yl@b¢+19@%DU4+DU8MCJ�9,-8�46H%D-13.�L5.7(+*-8M(+13*-.9: n3.7,/CG@IH64S2M2M@7,-8%T546(+Y%8ML587TlDU46K7(34Si"LM@ J 254"'@>".89S,B4@254!,B03.S>)<39-(\4"9X*&(I.8³La4) . (3.7(�,/46LZ�3468M038J(98MLa8�D-D/@I,/4Q@ICB85(+*-8JH�´ 19D-.½0�4s13("@ºD-46CRV#.7H64S2M2M@I2M4S.%(387T�@I(9LZ�38GD-8G¢%198MDU*/@ La.+Dc*/4 */1346D/La8B13(9.DU*-,/13CB85(+*-.GLZ�38=E�@7L54SH64S*/@B85(9.7,/CJ8MCB85(+*-8�H�´ 46(903@7K746(38<0�4[*-46�#.BEF.7,/CB@7HS8%:

')(3.%H */,-8%T�HS.³D/La.%�".G0�8MHSHQ@BHS.%K74QL5@J(3.%(� 8�*Z@I(+*-.³¢+138MHSH6.³0�4|8MHS8M(9L5@7,-8�H68�EF.7,/CB8\La.7,/,/8a*U*/8<0�4|,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-."TCG@¼D-.7�3,Z@�*-*-1�*-*-.9T La.%CB8GY78M03,-8MCJ.½(985H D-85K%134S*-.�0�4_¢+138MDU*-8³H6852M4S.%(34�T�¢+138MHSH6.�0�4 ,-4QLa.%(90�13,/HS8³@%0�13(�(�13CB85,/.8MD-46K713.\0�49EF.7,/CB8¯CJ.%H */.\85H685CB8M(%*Z@I,/4�:s¥ .7CB8¯46(GCG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QL5@�19(³K7,Z@I(J(�13CB85,/.\0�43*/85.7,/85CB490346D/La8M(90�8�03@\13((�13CB85,/.B,-4QDc*/,-85*U*/.B034�@7D/D-4S.%CJ4[D/La8MH */4|4S(94S2M46@7HSCB85(+*/87T"L5.%D)  $h4S( H6.7K%46LM@JD-4AL585,ZL5@J0�4�D/La.%CJ�#.7,/,/8�4|,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4La.%CB�3HS8�D-D-4=4S(À13(9@·DU8M,-468�034=�"@7D/DU4=85H685CB85(+*Z@I,/4�8�DU�3H64QLa4S*/@ICB8M(%*/8�038ai9(34S*-4�:£¨�(9LZ�38�H6@�HS.%K74QL5@3T�¢%194S(9034�T�DU4DU*-,/1�*U*/13,/@ 0�8M031�*U*/4SY�@ICB8M(%*/8JL5.7CB8RCB.%H */8P@IHS*-,/8\*/85.%,-468PD/La4685(+*-4Si"LZ�38%Th8P¢+138MDU*/@¼ 8\13("@­0�8MHSH68P,Z@IK%4S.%(34A�#85,=H68¢+19@IH64#8MD/D-@G 8�CB.7HS*-.JDU�#8MD/[email protected]�9@7K7(9@I*/@<03@7HSH�´ @�*U*/,-46V31�*/.6Pc0/(\4"Pc0/(+.1>)0�T�03@P4S(+*/85(90�8M,/D-4 7F<5AB.1>)0 J 2G4L'@4@9-(\0/(\0>)</9[Pc4"(\<`,_<iPQ03(h4@PQ03(I.1>)<��%:�?A@³H6.7K%46LM@B�9@­@lY�1�*/.­La.%CB8RL5@7CJ�#. 034�@7�3�[email protected](98\�3,/4SY�46HS8MK74Q@�*-.G�9,-.%�3,-46.GHQ@CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@3:��A1�*-*/@lY�4Q@3T| 8<V#85(98<*-8M(385,~�9,-8�DU8M(%*/8\LZ�38\HQ@BHS.%K74QL5@GD-4A@I�9�3HS4QL5@B46( *-13*U*-8PHS8\*-85.%,-468<(38MHSH68\¢+19@IH64�T.7HS*-,/8¯@IH6HS8¯�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(343@7CBCJ8�D-D-8b4S(JEF.%,-2�@=038549L5,-4S*-8M,-4��3,/.7�9,-430�8MHSHQ@=*-8M.7,/46@�DU*-8�D-D/@3T7D-49@%L5La85*U*Z@I(3.�¢+1385H6HS8~LZ�98(38BDU.%(3. L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]%46LM@3:  ¡ �3,/.7�3,/46.³4SH�LM@I,Z@�*U*/85,/8 �"</2LPc0/7e4<0�85H6HQ@³H6.7K74QL5@9T".+D-D-4Q@³46H��9,-8�D-L54S(90385,/8R03@IH6H68L5@7,/@I*U*/85,/46DU*-4QLZ�38~0�8M4"D-4S(3K%.7H64913(94SY%85,ZDU49034#0�4QD/La.7,ZD-.9T7LZ�38�La.7(3EF85,/46D/La8�@%0B8MD/D-@�H�´ @I�3�3H64QL5@IV94SH64 *� @<(38M4#L5.7(+*-8�Dc*/49�34U 1D-Yl@7,-4Q@�*/4�:=')(�038ai9(34S*-46Y�@3ThEF.%,-CG@IH687ThD-4SCPV".%HS4QL5@9T#CG@I*-85CG@I*-4QL5@­D-.7(9.­@�*-*-,/4SV313*-4�LZ�38BDU.%(3.³46CJ�94S8MK%@�*/4 �"8M,�13("@,[email protected](98�V#85( �3,/8ML546D/@R8<�9H6@719DU46V346HS8��7:������������ "!$#&%('������)'+*,#-!�./%�0"��%�1�0�#2%�./%43�)!�./56���&�70".�8+#&%:9�1+*,%�0".;�&�<56./� 0������&#&!�#=#&%�0"�������"��0�*,>�#&./%�#?8@!�./56�) �#=AB��'��C3*�#&%D'��70�0E*,F/�&#&.

#&%G ���F/1�# 0".�8+'��7AB./%�.6 �.,0�0"./ "0�*,���)*H'��70"����56#&%+*C0"#=A�#&%�!�./�&#?IJ!$����0��<�&�70�0������KA,*,%�%�.�#&%B0"�$�"�����70�*C0��)#&%G#&%�'�# A�#&'�1�#?8�*,� 0��"�K#&%L�(��./���"#&��0C3*(8*,� 0"����#&%������M*,>�#&./%�#N�B8�#&%�./� 0��"�/8-*,�&!�1�%�#N �#&5HO@./�&#QPR#S �#&5TO@./�&#-�&./F/#&!$#?8�9�1+*,�&#?8�*,'4�� "�$56�(#&.�82UV�XW�Y[Z+*,%�%�.:1(%+*L#&%B0����"�����70�*,>$#&./%(����"��\� � E*C0�*(]^C��%_�7`=�70�0�#?8K �./%�.a�@./ � "#&O�#&�&#bA,*,��#&��!$*,�E*C0�0����"#&>$>$*,>�#&./%�#)'����<!�./%�!��70"0".c'�#[!$./%( ���F/1���%�>$*d�&./F/#&!$*a�/8[9�1�#&%�'(#?8bA,*,��#&���&./F/#&!EZ��/]

eSf �� �#& �0���%�>$*H'(#�1�%+*H�(�&1��E*,�&# 0C3*T'�#��&./F/#&!EZ���3�<1�%�.H'���#�!$*,�E*C0�0�����#���#�31LA�#& "0"./ �#='����&�&�<��#&!�����!EZ��[!$./%('�.,0"0"�H%(�$� AB��%�0"�� �#&56.� "�$!�./�&.�]g e *H�&.�!$1(>$#&./%(�:h��&./F/#&!$*�5;*C0"�$5;*C0"#&!$*,i���1-3.;*,%(!EZ��X*$AB�����)#&�= �#&F/%�# \+!$*C0".;'�#Sj k�lBmRnEoLp�q$jRj oLrHoBs?qtr�o/s?mRnEo/8@�@���b ".,0"0"./�&#&%��$*,���)�M*

"0"���70�0E*T'�#&�@�$%('���%�>$*�'����&� f #&%�'+*,F/#&%��K�&./F/#&!$*X'+*T9�1����&�M*T!�./%�'�.,0�0�*;%(�$�&�&�[ �!�#&��%�>��K5;*C0���5;*C0"#&!EZ��/] e �[A�#&!��$%('��<'����&�M*T5;*C0"��5;*C0�#&!$*.,0�0�.�!��$%B0"�$ "!$*uZ+*,%�%�.vF/�E*,'�*C0E*,56��%B0��L56�$ " �.w#&%�&1(!$�G!EZ��G#&�Q%��� � ".�'�#x!$./%( ���F/1���%�>$*4�&./F/#&!$*3�L!���%B0���*,�&�L#&%a5;*C0"��5;*C0�#&!$*(8J#&%9�1+*,%�0".:3�<9�1����&�&.�!EZ��<�&��FB*�#=0"��./����56#�*,F/�&#�*, � "#&./56#='����&�&�[0"��./��#&�<5;*C0"��5;*C0�#&!EZ(�B]yCzK#&��%��L0�*,� AB./� 0�*v#&56��#&��FB*C0".u*,%(!EZ��:� f *C0�0��"#&O�1(0".:{Nj k/|7k"{SnEo/8x#&%aF/�$%(�$�"�D!�./%B0���*,���@./ "0".a*v5;*C0"��5;*C0�#&!$*(8N�@�$�6 ".,0"0"./�&#&%��$*,���

�M*w�@�$��0�#&%(�$%(>t*}P~'(#b1�%�*v�+*,��0��tYT'(�$�&� f #&%('+*,F/#&%��G�&./F/#&!t*�!�./%}�M*�\+�&./ ".,\@*(8�%(�$�� ���%� ".�!EZ��:�M*w�&./F/#&!$*a3�G1�%�.v "0"��1(56�$%B0".4!�./%}#&�9�1+*,�&�) �#2*C` ��./%B0E*,%(.G�(��./O��&��56#�!�Z��/8 0"�E*,'(#&>$#&./%�*,�&56�$%B0"�B8@ "./%�.; "0�*C0�#-./F/F/�70�0�.G'�#-#&%B0����"�$ " ��)'����&�M*H\+�&./ ".,\@*(]x��%:0�1�0"0�*6�M*� "0"./��#M*'����&�M*:\+�&./ �.,\+*v "#K3�L'�#& "!�1� � ".4 "�L�M*w�&./F/#&!$*:�~./ " ��G.v%(.4�+*,��0��G'����&�M*:\+�&./ �.,\+*v�/8���*,�E*,�&�&���M*,56��%�0"�D*,F/�&#x �A(#&�&1��(��#�0���!�%�#&!�#���#�31����!���%�0"#?8- "#x3�T'�#&O+*C0�0�1(0".w ��T�M*G�&./F/#&!$*;�~./ " ��H.L%�.D��*,�"0"��'����&�M*G5;*C0"��5;*C0�#&!$*(]T��%�./#J��#M*,!��6 �./ "0"��%�������!�Z����M*L�&./F/#&!$*; �#M*;1�%+*'�#& "!$#&�(�&#&%+*:*,1(0"./%�./5;*(82#&%u9�1+*,%B0�.� �0�1�'(#M*:1�%u1�%(# AB�$�" �.:!�Z��;�&�:3�G�(��./���"#&.�8-�;� ./#&!�Z���;�&.: "0"1�'�#M*D!�./% �0��"1�56��%�0"#S�R./��5;*,�&#JZ+*

Page 7: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

]� �� ���#!�"�� �` ��N#1���@ # ����� )�� �"� �� E�! g 4� 8\0�8a*-*-.G46(½�3,/8MLa8�0�85(92M@GLZ�38<13("@B*-8M.7,/46@º 8<8�D-D-85(32M46@7HSCB8M(%*/8<13([email protected]�3�34Q@�� <�� ����aT#L5.%DU*-4S*-134S*/@G03@³13(H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.:�CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8~4SH#¢+19@IH68�D-498MD-�3,/4SCB.%(3.<HS8��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(943Y78M,-8¯,/85HQ@�*/4SY%8~@70B13(³19(34SY%85,ZDU.�.%K7K785*U*/19@IH68�J:½?s´ 4S("03@IK%4S(38 DU1�13("@º*-85.%,-4Q@½D-4 D-Y+46H613�3�9@½46(�13(9@¼(+19.�Yl@º*/85.%,-4Q@ � �AT 0�8a*-*/@kPc4@(h03(h4)</2L.10ITsLZ�38­@%D-D-13CB8La.%CB8º19(34SY%85,ZDU.�0�4~46(903@7K746(38 46H~H64S(9K719@7K7K746. µ0385H6H6@�*-8M.7,/46@�.7K%K78a*-*-.�8½LZ�387Tb@�D-19@�Y7.%H *Z@3T�D-4�D-85,/Y�4S,� @�0�413(�HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.d���T|038a*U*/.=Pc4@(h037l.89dAB*[email protected]<VM�.�Y+Y%85,/.C� � <�� �� t���KT :\?�@³CB8a*Z@�*/85.7,/4Q@³DU4�0�46Y�46038P46(0�138½L5.7CB�".%(385(+*/4�©ºH6@ 'L.89-(\0K')'L. T (985H6H6@�¢+19@IH68 HS8º�3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @�0�46WY78M(3K7.%(3.�46(903@7K%@�*/8 D-85(32�@¼*/85(38M,³La.%(%*/.0�8MH�E�@I*U*/.ºLZ�38uÁ 8R46H HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S. 0�85H6HS8P*-8M.7,/46@��\T#8PHQ@�'@4@PQ039-(+.1>)0�T[(38MHSHQ@ ¢+19@7HS8JDU4�DU*-190346@7(3. H68R�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @0�4: 4S( EF13(32M4S.%(38�0�85H�,Z@I�3�#.7,-*-.�EF,/@ ¶8 �J: g 4B 8�@7LMLa8M(3(9@�*/.·@7H�E�@I*U*/. LZ�38%T�(38MH\L5@%DU.�0385H6H6@·HS.%K74QL5@9TH�´ 13(94SY%85,ZDU.��£ 8<La.+Dc*/4 */134 */.9T#@IH6CJ8M(3.G46(½�3,-46CG@G@I�3�9,[email protected](38%T�09@IH6HS8�EF.%,-CB8\La.%,-,/8a*-*-8\0�4�,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.8�LZ�98~4SH#H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.w L5.7(+*-8M,-,� @�0�854hD-4SCPV".%HS4h¢+19@IH64>%#T7'lT (PT7*bT � T � :�?�@RD-4S(+*/@%D-D-4�T%¢+1346(90�4�T�D-4#.�LMLa13�#85,� @\0�4DU*-190�4Q@I,/8�H68s�3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @b0�8MH7H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.¯@I,-*-4Si"La4Q@IH68<�LZ�38sL5.7(9D-85(+*-8s03478MD-�3,/4SCB8M,-8�H68�EF.7,/CB8s0�854%,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-4+mHQ@³DU8MCG@I(+*-4QL5@9T34S(�Y%8MLa8%T9@lY�,l @BL5.7CB8\46(3K7,/8M0�4685(+*/8<�3,-46(9L54S�9@7HS8<46HA(98MD/DU.³0�4�La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]%46LM@ MFCB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8\4SH¢+19@IH68<DU4A8MD-�3,-46CB87T3L5.7CB8<DU4� 8<0�85*U*/[email protected],/,/8a*U*/852M2M@J0�854|,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4gTa:

?A@³�3,-46CG@G46�".7*-8MD-4|EF.%(903@7CJ8M(+*/@IH68³ 8R4SH J 2L.89S>". J .1<�,/. �".8W/0/7F4@9DCE0P46(¼V9@7D-8R@7H�¢+19@IH68\.%K7(34��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(98B 8Y78M,/@P.JE�@IHQD-@�M�8<(3.7(º85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8�H68\La.+DU8KT T�.%D/D-46@P�9@3T"La.7CB8<D-4[19D-@B0�46,/87T3Y�@IH6.7,/8�0�4|Y78M,-4S*l @��d.����I:[email protected](903@P46�".7*-8MD-4s 8=46H J 2L.89S>". J .1< ,/.�W/4"25<�� �)*&[email protected]</9S0/7l.8( �0�: r�4QDU*-46([email protected]<�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94#46(½DU8MCB�3HS4QLa48<La.%CJ�#.%DU*-8%:�?|8��3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34 '@4@P J 7l.1>@.�M�.�03(h<3PN.1>)fR4GT¯D-.7(3.B¢+1385H6H68�LZ�98�(3.%(ºL5.7(+*-8M(3K7.%(3.P@7HhHS.%,-.J4S(+*/85,/(3.�9@7,U*/4~LZ�387Tb@�H6.7,/.�Y7.%H *Z@3T�L5.%DU*-4S*-134QD-L5.7(3.�0�8MHSH68 �3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34�: ')(ÅL5@7D-.�La.%(%*/,/@7,-46.�H68 �3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34¯DU.%(3.

0�85*U*-8V>G<3P J <K'L(\4a:_¨�0 8�DU8MCJ�94S."T�*-1�*-*-8\H68\�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34[LZ�38\@[email protected]("La.7(+*/,/@I*-.B(3854A,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-4[0�85K%HS4¡�D-85CB�34:MUeET)�)M�XBTb0�8MH[�9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.R�3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/8<DU.%(3.GDU8MCJ�9HS4QLa4�:g .%(3.G8MD-85CB�34�0�4A�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34AL5.7CB�#.%DU*-8\H68RD-85K71985(+*-4�©OoZk  8<CB4S(3.%,-8P0�4�XB8JX  8\CG@IK%K746.7,/8�034�k3q9T:o g 8

¨~HQ0�.³ 8¯4SH"(34S�#.I*/8�0�4��¼@I,/[email protected],Z@��¼@I,/46.J 8¯HS.\2M4S.P0�4"¨�H60�.dq3T o->�(3.%(  8¯CB4S(3.%,-8~034[]3q3T o g 8¯�346.�Y78~@7(90�[email protected]( @I13*-.7CB.%V34SH687T�CG@3T3D-8=(3.7( �34S.�Y%87T�@I([email protected]@R�94S8�0�4eq9T�o/XG 8��9@7,-4#.7�9�313,/8R 8�0�4QDU�9@7,-4gq3T o-¤³ 8=�9@I,/4#D-8=8=D-.7H6.D-8��º 8<0�4QD-�9@I,/4eq9T�o-?A@J,/8a*-*/@��­ 8�46(9La4Q0�8M(%*/8<.B�9@I,Z@IH6HS8MH6@J@IH6HQ@P,/8a*-*/@��MHeq-m�8\La.+D   $hY�4Q@3:

�~8MHhHS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.v·46(+*-,/.�0313,-,/85CB.J0�854[D-4SCPV".%HS4h�#85,¯0�85(9.I*/@7,-8�HS8=�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34hDU8MCJ�9HS4QLa4h8�@IHS*-,/4#D-4SCPV".%HS4�#85,\0�8M(3.I*Z@I,/8J@7H6L513(34sLa.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4�CB8M0�4Q@I(+*-8B4s¢+19@7HS4sD-4�.I*-*-85(9K7.7(9. �3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34�La.%CB�".+Dc*/8B@ �9@7,U*/4S,/8J09@�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34AD-85CB�3H646L54�:¯¡�V3V"8M(387T#(3.%4�La.%(9D-460�8M,-8M,-8MCB.BD-.7H6.H>)</9X9;4@(I(+.8W`.jWK4@25<�� �)*&9&[email protected]</9;037l. ThY�@IH68R@³0�46,-8PLa.7(3�1�%+*v56�70�.�'�./�&./F/#M*u%�./%d'�#& " �#&56#&�&�;'+*49�1����&�M*4'(�$�&�M*v5;*C0���5;*C0"#&!$*dPR!EZ��3�:�M*v �!�#&��%�>$*4'����6h"�R./��5;*,�&��i�YEIw9�1�#&%�'�#b�M*v�&./F/#&!$*d3� �./ �0E*,%(>$#M*,�&56��%B0��)�&./F/#&!$*�5;*C0"�$5;*C0"#&!$*DP~%(�$�- "��%� �.6'�#��&./F/#&!t*H0"�E*C0�0�*C0E*;5;*C0���5;*C0"#&!$*,56�$%B0"�CYE]���# 3.6%�./%: "#&F/%�# \+!$*�!EZ��)�M*��&./F/#&!$*5;*C0"�$5;*C0"#&!$*6�$ �*,1���#& "!$*;!�./56���&�70�*,56��%�0"�H� f ./�"#&>$>�./%B0��X'����&�M*6'�#& �!�#&���&#&%�* ��#&%(�~*C0�0�#?8 '+*C0".L!�Z��HF/�&#21�%�# AB���" �#2'����bh��E*,F/#&./%+*,56��%B0�./i �./%(.[56./� 0"�$�(�&#&!$#/�S!$#M*, "!�1�%�.[Z�*�!$*,�E*C0�0"�$�"#& "0"#&!EZ��Q�@��!�1��&#M*,��#?8C� ���-56./� 0"#/'�#��$ " �#�%�./%) �#@3��*,%�!�./��*b#&%�'�# A�#&'�1+*C0".[1(%X%(�$ " �.[*,'���F/1+*C0�.'�#@!�./%� ���F/1���%�>$*X�&./F/#&!t*)��1�%+*) �.�'�'�#& "�~*,!���%�0"�b�R./��5;*,�&#&>�>$*,>�#&./%��b56��'�#M*,%B0"�b1�%6!�./�"��1� Q'��7\+%�# 0".X'�#@����F/./�&���R./��5;*,�&#(!$./�"���70�0��/]�!�#��1-3.6 "./ "0"��%������X!EZ��X1�%: ��70�0�./�"�)'����&�M*��&./F/#&!t*�'(# AB�$%(FB*;'(#xh��&./F/#&!$*�5;*C0���5;*C0"#&!t*,i69�1+*,%�'(.GZ�*��E*,F/F/#&1�%B0�.;1�%:*,'���F/1+*C0�.G�&# AB���&�&.'�#=5;*C0�1���*,>�#&./%��K�K "#���1-3.H����./�@./���"�[!�./56�K56.�'����&�&.GP �R./��5;*,�&�tYN'����&� f *C0�0�# A�# 0,3*T'���'�1(0�0�# A,*�#&%L1�%G'��70"�$�"56#&%+*C0".6*,5HO�# 0".T0"��./��#&!�.�]��# 3.a3�D9�1+*,%�0".u "#<3�LAB����# \+!$*C0".u�@����56./� 0"�L�&./F/#&!EZ(�D#&%B0���%� "#&./%+*,�&#XPR9�1+*,�&#b�M*w�&./F/#&!$*�56.�'+*,�&�/8S�M*��&./F/#&!$*�'���./%�0"#&!$*(8x�M*w�&.,�~F/#&!$*����#& "0"��56#&!$*(8���!�!B] YH!�Z��< �./%�.H "0�*C0��)����!���%�0"��56��%�0"�<�~./�"5;*,�&#&>$>$*C0"�K#&%D56.�'�.T �.�'�'�#& "�~*,!���%�0"�/]

"$# #Q �./�&# 0".w#&�Q56�70E*,�&#&%�F/1�*,F/F/#&.&%('*) 3�G�M*:�&#&%�F/1+*:# 0�*,�&#M*,%+*�*,���"#&!�!EZ�# 0�*:'+*w1�%a!��$��0�.�%�1�56����.w'�#Q "#&5HO@./�&#S�@���H'(�$%(.,0E*,�"�F/�&#����&��56��%�0"#[PR �#&5HO@./�&#?8-�R./��5T1��&�/8-��!$!/] Y '�#+%�] 3, *, � �*,#�!�./5H1�%(�G� f 1( �.o�-(s?k/.+m r�kG'���#Q ���F/%�#?8J!EZ(�D*,%�!�Z��L%(./#Q*,'�.,0�0�������56.�I�@���H�7A(# 0�*,���;'�#S#&%�0"��.�'�1��"����0"��./����#Q%�1�.$A(#Q "#&5HO@./�&#?8-%�����56�70�*,�&#&%�F/1+*,F/F/#&.w#� "#&5HO@./�&#S'����Q�&#&%�F/1�*,F/F/#&.P?*,'�� "�$56�(#&.�0@821C8SUc8W�Y<*, � "1�56./%�.w#&���"1�./�&.w'�#�%�./56#S'�#��&./��.w �0��� " �#?] 3, �M*:'�#& "0"#&%�>�#&./%��;0���*�-(|7k;�wr�q3.54$m~k�.@q$I6#&%�% 1(% �#&5TO ./�&.LA(#&��%��;1� �*C0�.�8#&%6%�'*) A(#&��%���56��%�>�#&./%+*C0"._P?*,�&!�1�%�#K*,1(0�./�"#<1� E*,%(. �#&5TO ./�&#�'�# AB���� "#K#&%7% �&%('8)b8b*,� 0��"#[1� �*,%�.a#&%6%�'*) �&�:A�#&��F/./�&�70�0���@���656�$%(>$#&./%�*,���D#� �#&5TO@./�&#Q�DF/�&#��$�&��56��%B0�#�'�#9%�YE] 3, 0"1(0�0E*�A(#M*u "��56�����G!EZ�#M*,�".u'+*,��!�./%�0"�� "0". ��L �#� "0�*4./�@���E*,%�'�.4#&%�%�8.� ��G �#<3�G%����&�M*�56�70�*C0���./�"#M*(8�!�#&.�3�D#&%:% '*) 8S�L9�1�#&%�'�#x� f 1� ".v*,1(0�./%(#&56.v'(�$#x "�$F/%(#�%(./%d!�./56�@./�"0�*w�+*,�"0"#&!�./�M*,��#x�@����#&!�./�&#Q'�#�R�E*,#&%B0���%�'�#&56��%B0�.�]<;�%�*, ��@�70"0".: "./�&.G#&%('�#&���70�0E*,56��%B0���!�./�&�&��FB*C0".D!�./%�9�1��� �0�.v3�H#&�- ���F/1���%B0��/I< "#Q3�H'��70�0�.L!EZ����&.; "0"1�'�#&.G'����&�M*�&./F/#&!$*TPR!$#&.(3�x�M*�56��0�*C0"�$./�"#M*BY�3�Q!�./%�'(.,0"0�*<!$./%T56�70�.�'�.K5;*C0"��5;*C0�#&!�.=�B!�# 3.[ "#&F/%�# \+!$*(8/0���*[� f *,� 0"��.�8,!�Z��x'�.tA�����56.[�(���� ���%B0E*,�"�xA,*,��#&�'�#&56./ �0���*,>$#&./%(#?]�>[��O@��%��/8@#&%:9�1��� "0"�T'�#&56./ �0���*,>�#&./%�#��~*,����56.�1� ".6'�#-�E*,F/#&./%+*,56��%B0�#-!�./%�'(.,0"0"#N56��'�#M*,%B0"�X9�1����&�&�) "0"�� � ��X����F/./�&�!EZ��T �./%�.G./F/F/�70"0".:'�#2#&%�'�*,F/#&%��H%����&� f *,5TO�# 0�.6'(�$�&�M*6�&./F/#&!$*;!$./56�)0"�$./�"#M*(]?!�#2!����$*69�1�#&%('�#N1(%+*G!�#&�"!$./�M*,�"# 0,3*(I��@���K�E*,F/#&./%�*,���H "#1� �*)�M*K�&./F/#&!$*)�/8�9�1�#&%�'(#?8��@���S��*,F/#&./%+*,���� �1(�&�M*K�&./F/#&!t*< "# 1( E*<�M*K�&./F/#&!$*(]A@J���� "�@�$>�>$*,����0E*,�&��!�#&��!�./�&.)O+*, "0�*)'�#& "0"#&%�F/1�������#&�+�&# AB���&�&.0"�$./�"#&!�.w'+*D9�1����&�&.:56�70E*C0"��./��#&!�.�IH#&%v9�1��� "0 f 1�� 0�#&56.D �#S1( E*D#&%456.�'�.L#&%(�R./��5;*,�&�H�M*uh��&./F/#&!$*:'�����O�1�./%4 ���%� �./i�8J!EZ(�w3�69�1����&�M*!EZ��)A�#&�$%(�X�R./��5;*,�&#&>�>$*C0E*H*,�-�&# AB�$�&�&.T0���./��#&!�.�]B!��)�&.6 �!�./�@.;'����&� f #&%�'+*,F/#&%��<�R./ � ��) "./�&.69�1����&�&.6'�#-���&��%�!$*,���X'����&�&�<�~./�"56�<!�./�����70�0��'�#2�E*,F/#&./%�*,56�$%B0".G�X�@���K'�#&56./ "0"�E*,�"%��)�M*6!$./�"���70�0���>�>$*L!�#2'�.tAB�� � "#&56.6 ����"A�#&���X'����&�&�X!$./�"��#& "� ./%('���%�0"#-�~./�"56�X'(#-�E*,F/#&./%+*,56��%B0�.%����&�M*K�&./F/#&!$*<'���� �&#&%(F/1+*,F/F/#&.)!$./5T1�%��/8B�7A(#&'(�$%B0"�$56��%B0��[#&��!�#&��!�./�&.) E*,����O�O@�xA(#&>�#&./ ".�]2��%6���$*,� 0,3*(8�!�./56�x �#�3�b*,!�!$��%�%�*C0�.�8(F/�&#+ �!�./��# �./%(.6*,� 0��"#?8��< �*,�E*,%�%�.H��A�#&'���%�>�#M*C0"#-5;*,%G5;*,%(.H!EZ��) "#�*,%�'��C3*�*$A,*,%�0"#-%����&�&.H �0�1('�#&.�'����&�M*H�&./F/#&!$*(]

C , �#& �0�./%(.� "A,*,��#M*C0"#= "#& "0"�$56# �&./F/#&!�#�%���#=9�1+*,�&#=%�./%G �#�*, " �1�56�b�M*XA,*,�&#&'�# 0,3*X'�#=0�*,�&�<���"#&%�!�#&��#&.=��0"�E*X'�#��� " �#=A�#� "./%�.H�&�Tj k�lBmRn�D(qE kBj mGFCo/j qH.+s~mR8J�&�Dj kEl/m~nID�q EKJ kML�oML$m j m |Es?mRn�D(q$8N�&�Lj k�lBmRn�D(qONP-/4P43Q/8��$!�!/]&82%����&�&�69�1+*,�&#�#&�2A/*,�&./���6'(#SAB����# 0C3*D'�#S1(%+*D���"./� ./ "#&>�#&./%��6��1-3.*, � "1�56������ �A/*,�"#M*C0�#JA/*,�&./��#?]6z[#S "./%�.:�@./#Q*,� 0"�����&./F/#&!EZ(�6%����&�&�69�1+*,�&#N%�./%*G0�1(0�0"�G�&�6�(��./�@./ �#&>�#&./%�#N �#�*, " ���F/%+*:1�%�A/*,�&./�"�6'�#AB����# 0C3*(]

Page 8: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

¤(385*U*-46Y�4�*/@7HS4sLZ�98J46H�Y�@IH6.7,/8J034sY78M,-4S*l @º0�85H6H68J�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34�L5.7CB�".+Dc*/8B.I*U*/85(�1�*/8P*/,/@7CB4 */8J8�D-D-4s0�46�"8M(90�8³D-.7H6.03@74:Mc 8=EF13(32M4S.%(38\0�8M4gT_Y�@IH6.7,/4|0�4[Y%85,/4 *� @J0385H6HS8<�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34[La.%CB�".%(385(+*-4�:

¿~(P@IHS*-,/.~K78M(385,/8�0�4�La.%(9DU4Q0�8M,/@72546.7(34I,/46K719@7,/03@bHQ@�D/La8MH *Z@~0�8MK7H64%46(3K7,/8M034S8M(%*/4%0�8MH%H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.6�4S(\EF13(32546.7(980�8MH9K7,Z@703.\0�4"@7�3�3,/.IEF.7("0�4SCB8M(%*/.\0�85H"H6@lY%.7,/.=0349EF.%,-CG@[email protected](38¯LZ�38�DU4"4S(+*-8M(90�8~.%�"8M,/@7,-8b(38M4#L5.7(�EF,/.7(+*/490�85HH64S(3K%19@IK%K746.P("@�*-19,/@7HS8%:

¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/[email protected](+*-8�,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-."©���������� � ������������� ��������� �� ������� ����� "! ��#%$&�'��� �&���� �(������� �)� � � ) ������* � "� �������,+-� � ��� " ����.��� � */ �0����*/ �0�1�2��� ���! ������� !"3)� ��#4$&�5���������� �6���&� ������"! � */ �0����*/ �0�1�2��� ���! ������� !3")� ��#4$&����7��� � � �8�������������9� �&: �0���,� �! ��.�� !3!" �1�����7���;*/ �0�1��� ;���! ���<��� !"")� ��#>='� � � .?+0�@������� �����8��������� ���� ��: �0���,� �! ��./� !"!3 �1�A+������ ����� �2� A �B���&� ����� "! ��#

')(³8�D-D-.<i9K%13,/@7(3.R@7H6L513(38~�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34#La.7CB�#.%DU*-8%:�')("0�46LZ�[email protected](­HS85*U*-8M,-8�HS8��3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34"D-85CB�3H646L54�©C < @I(903,l .B46(ºY�@%L5@I(92M@P4S(½@I8M,-8M.D < @I(903,l .B46(ºY�@%L5@I(92M@P4S(½@I13*-.7CB.%V34SH68� < K74613(3K%85,� .P�3,/46CB@B@G0�8�Dc*/4S("@I2546.7(98� < �".7*-,� .B�".%,U*Z@I,/8=CB.%H */8=Y�@7HS46K7468E < @lY�,l .J13(9@BY�@7LM@I(32�@PL5.7(�EF.%,U*/85Y%.7H68

g 4[�#85,/Y�4S8M(38\@IH6HS.%,/@J@IH6HQ@PD-85K%1385(+*-8=EF.%,-CG@[email protected](38%©J . !DU8 J @IH6H6.7,Z@GFh2¯8<(3.%(['-HDU8 !�@IH6H6.7,Z@V'DU8�( @IH6H6.7,Z@V'DU8�( @IH6H6.7,Z@A!

� 85,³L5.7(�Y�4S("La85,ZLa4~LZ�98¼4SH�,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.· 8¼La.%,-,/8a*-*-."T �3,/.�La8�0�46@7CB.�L5.7CB8¼D-85K71987: g 13�3�#.7(34Q@ICB."T_�#85,@7D/D-13,/03.9T�LZ�38<H68<�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8<D-46@7(3.BY785,/8=8<[email protected](9L5HS19D-46.7(38=E�@IHQD/@3: g 8<[email protected]("LaH619DU46.7(98P 8�E�@7H6D/@B@IH6HS.%,/@ E  8<Y785,Z@8 D  8BE�@7H6D/@ M�@lY+,� .½13(9@¼Yl@%L5@7(32M@½L5.7(�EF.%,U*/85Y7.%HS8³D-85(92M@ 8MD/D-85,/8³@I(903@I*-.¼46(°@I13*-.dTa:Hr=@IH6H�´ 13HS*-46CB@¼�3,-8MCB8MD/D-@9T8MD/D-85(90�. E Y785,Z@3T",-4QD-13H *Z@GY78M,/@G@7(9LZ�38��6M�DU8J@lY+,� .G13(9@­Y�@7L5@7([email protected](�EF.%,U*/85Y%.7H687T"@7HSH6.7,Z@G@lY�,l .G�#.7,-*/@I*-.³CB.%H */8Y�@IH64SK%4S8KT :�r�@7HSHQ@��3,/4SCG@��3,/85CB8�D-D/@3T%8MD/DU8M(90�. D E�@IHQD-@9T%D-85K7198bLZ�98� 8¯Y78M,/@ C [email protected],Z@=09@IH6H6@<D-8ML5.7(903@=�3,/85CB8�D-D/@D-85K7198bLZ�98= 8 Y%85,Z@�HQ@=([email protected](98b034 �7T+La46.9 8bLZ�38��� 8_E�@7H6D/@3TI46(BLa.7(+*/,/@%030�462546.7(38bLa.%(J¢+19@7(%*/.��3,-46CG@=.I*U*/85(�1�*/.�II:

�~.%(º 8¯4SCB�#.7,-*/@7(%*/8~.7,Z@�DU.Bb#8M,-CG@7,/L549DU1³¢+138�Dc*Z@�K74619DU*-4Si"[email protected](38 YP@7(3254�T%(985H"D-85K%134S*-.9T%H6@�K%4S1"Dc*/4 i"LM@I2M4S.%(380�8MHSHQ@¼La.%,-,/8a*-*-8M252M@½03854_,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-4sD/@I,� @½La.7("0�.I*-*/@¼L5.7(�*-8�La(34QLZ�38 �34U 1��3,-8�La4QDU8­8­DU.7i"DU*-4QL5@�*/8QY�¢+19@7(%*/.D-.I*U*/.7H64S(98M@I,/8­46H_E�@�*-*-.�LZ�38­HQ@�L5.7,/,-85*U*/85252�@� 8ºDc*Z@�*/@�DU*/@IV94SH64 *Z@�D-85(92M@½E�@7,P46(+*-8M,-Y%85(346,-8 4Qo-La.%(+*-85(�1�*/4eq�0�85H6H68�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34bDU8MCJ�9HS4QLa4 C T D T ��T � 8 E : g 4b*/,/@I*U*/@�0�4b13("@�K%4S1"Dc*/4 i"LM@I2M4S.%(38º@�H64SY%85H6HS.��3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH687T�46(¢+19@I(+*/.³DU4�V9@7D/@GDU.%HS.GD-134A(98MD/DU4�LZ�38\DU1"D-D-46DU*-.%(3.B*-,Z@BH68\�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34|DU8MCB�3HS4QLa4�(385H6H68\�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34ALa.%CB�".7�DU*-8G@7D/DU19(%*/8JL5.7CB8J�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8J8B(385H6H6@ºLa.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(387:P¡sV3V#85(38%T|(38MHSHQ@ 7F<5AB.1>)0 J 25< J <K'[email protected]</9S0/7F4PDU4 8�D-@7CJ46(9@7(3.D-.7H6.J,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4[LZ�38\@ICBCB8a*-*-.7(9.B¢+138�Dc*/.B*-46�".³034|K74619DU*-4Si"[email protected](38�8<(38MHALa134�HS46(3K%19@IK%K746.JD-.7(3.B�3,/8MD-85(+*/4D-.7HS*/@I(+*/.PH68a*-*-85,/8<�#85,¯�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34|D-85CB�3H646L54[8\DU46CRV#.7H64[�"8M,�La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4|Y78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS4�:

g 8<La.%(9D-460�8M,[email protected](½@IHS*-,/.G0�85K%HS4[8�DU8MCJ�94[4S(9L5.7(+*-,Z@�*/4[4S( �3,/8ML58M0�8M(32M@9©�O0 J <37F4)</9;4 �4�A_4@9;<3WK4"'@4�&*&(+(+. . Ad4@9;</W/4"').:'"<39;<i>".89S4L'L.�O0 J <37F4)</9;4 �4�>".89S4L'@4

D-4"�31� .R.%D/D-85,/Yl@7,-8¯LZ�38%T%�#85,_K74619DU*-4Si"L5@7,-8�4SH#(38MD/D-.R0�4hLa.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@�H6.7K%46LM@3T7.�LMLa.7,/,/8~La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@I,/8¯4hLa.7(+*/85(�1�*-40�8MHSH68\*/,-8P�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94 M */1�*U*/8JD-85CB�3H64QLa48T�L5.746(+Y%.7HS*-8%:�?A@ La.7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@G0�8MH�,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/.B(3.7(¼�91� .­8�D-D-85,/8DU*/@IV94SH64 *Z@�@IH�H64SY%85H6HS.=�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH687T�CG@=V34QDU.%K7(9@�.7�#85,Z@I,/8�13("@�EF.%,-CG@7HS46252�@I2546.7(98 �34U 1Pi9(38¯,/46D-�"85*U*/.�@�¢+138MHSHQ@0�8MHSH�´ 8�DU8MCB�34S.��9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8%T_L5.%D/@�LZ�98½�"8M,/@7H */,-.�@IV9V346@7CB.�K%4  @�@7(+*-4QLa46�9@�*/.�([email protected] : g 4~�9@7D/D/@�@7HSH6.7,Z@@IH6HQ@ 7e<5AB.1>)0 ,_4". J 254),/.1>)0/(+.N,B4@7 J 2L.8PQ< </25,3.89;4G(985H�L5134�H64S([email protected] LZ�38½4S("0�46LZ�985,/85CB.�La.7( 'J�T¯D-4~�9@I(9(3.

K�!�#�./ � "���"A�#�!EZ��X�M*T0"�$�">$*;�(����56�� � E*;3�)#&����#&�&�7A,*,%�0"�)*,#�\+%�#�'(�$�- "1� � "#& "0"�����<'����-%��� � ".6'�#�!�./%� "�$F/1(�$%(>t*;�&./F/#&!$*(8@!�./56�<��1�����3�#&%��� � "��%�>�#M*,�&�<#&����1(./�&.H'����&�M*H���"./�@./ �#&>�#&./%��ML;P~#&����*,F/#&./%+*,56��%�0".L3�<�"#&'�./%�'+*,%B0��tYE]

Page 9: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

�@°0�4QD-�".+DU462546.7(38%T_*-,Z@�H�´ @IHS*-,/.9Tb.%H */,-8�@74�D-4SCPV".%HS4��"8M,­4�La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4�Y78M,-.7��EF13(92546.7(9@7HS4�T_L5.%DU*/@7(%*/4�8¼Y�@7,-4Q@IV346H6446(90�46Y+4Q0�19@7HS4�8~L5.%DU*/@7(%*/4��"8M,��3,-.%�3,/4S85*l @�8¯,[email protected](34 M�L5.%DU*/@7(%*/4��3,-8�0�4QL5@�*/4SY%8ETaTI8b49DU46CRV#.7H64��#85,�43¢+19@I(+*/4 i"LM@�*/.7,/4H6.7K74QLa4 � MF�#85,�.7K7(94gTb8��kMF8�DU4QDc*/8ETb�#85,�4S("0�4SY�4Q0�134�Th4S(½CB.�0�.­03@³�".7*-85,�8MD-�3H646L54 *Z@I,/8\H6@JEF.%,[email protected]%46LM@B4S(+*/85,/(9@0�8MHSH68<�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34[DU8MCJ�9HS4QLa4�:

¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/[email protected].%,/@J46H|DU8MK7138M(%*/8�,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-.PL5.7,/,-85*U*/.9©� 0/2L7F<V>)</2L254O7F4@9-(\0/Pc4"9X(h4� 0/2L7F<V>)</2L254

�~8MHSH�´ @ICRV94 */[email protected]%46LM@P0�8M4|�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4A0385H|�3,/46CJ.B.%,/0�46(38�o-L5.7,/,-8M,-8�HS8M(+*/@ICB8M(%*/8`qJ8 o-L5.7,/,-8M,-8Eq\8�DU�3,/4S�CB.7(3.B0�138�0�4QDc*/4S(+*/8=�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @Rm�D-8�H68�46(90�4QLZ�[email protected],-4QDU�#8a*-*-46Y�@ICB85(+*-8<L5.7( �w8 � DU4h�#85,/Y�4S8M(38=@7HSHQ@JDU8MK7138M(%*/8EF.7,/CG@[email protected](38%©

�p0� 0

(38MHSHQ@­¢+19@7HS8\(9.7(¼,/46D-13HS*/@­85Y�460385(32M46@I*-.³46H (38MD/DU. 0�4�L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]%46LM@�MF46HAE�@I*U*/. LZ�38P13(�L585,-*-.³46(90�46Y�460�19.@IV9V346@�13(9@�L585,-*/@¼�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @�(9.7(�46CB�3H646LM@�LZ�98 (38½@7V3V34Q@�13("@�L585,-*/@�@IHS*-,Z@�(3.%(·L5.7H6HS8MK%@�*Z@�@7HSHQ@��9,-46CG@_T :¡sY�4Q0�85(+*/85CB85(+*-8JLa4) . 0�8M,-46Y�@­03@7HAE�@I*U*/. LZ�38PH6@³EF.7,/CB@7HS46252�@I2M4S.%(38<E�@­D-�9@7,-46,-8RHS.ºDc*/,-85*U*-. HS8MK%@7CJ8REF,/@ �W8 � :¿~("@�EF.%,-CG@7HS46252�@I2546.7(98­�34U 1 @%0�85K%19@�*Z@�D-4¯.I*-*-4685(38 .+D-D-85,/Y�@I(90�.�LZ�38 H�´ @lY�Y785,/V346. o-HS8M(%*Z@ICB85(+*/8`q3T�4S( ,-8�@IHS*l @9T46(90�4QL5@º13(9@ �3,/.7�9,-468a*� @­(3.%(�0�4 ¥_@I,/HS."T|CG@ 0�85Hao/La.%,-,/85,/8`q9T#8G@7�3�9@I,/8B�"8M,U*Z@I(+*-. �34U 1�(9@�*/13,Z@IH68=oU*-,Z@70�13,/H6._qLa.%(B13(9@��3,/.7�3,/468a*l @:�À0�85H"La.7,/,/85,/8�M � TLm+4S("0�46LM@I(903.\La.7(�cM � T H6@��9,-.%�3,-468a*� @6o/La.%,-,/85,/8 H685(+*Z@ICB85(+*-8Eq3T7D-43�31� [email protected],Z@PD/La,/4SY%85,/87©

�cM � T %� %

(38MHSHQ@�¢%1"@IH68� 8º,/8MD-.�8MD-�3HS4QLa4S*-.�46H~(38�D-D-.�034�La.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@�H6.7K74QL5@9: ��4� 8 4SH�CJ.�0�."T @7HSCB85(9.�46(�L5@%DU4~L5.7CB8¢+138MDU*-."T|0�4�85Y�4S*/@7,-8B0�4�,/46L5.7,/,-8M,-8R@ �3,/.7�3,/468a*l @º0�4��3,/.7�9,-468a*� @3Th,-8�Dc*Z@I(903.ºL5.%D)  $�(985H6H�´ @ICPV34 */.º0385H6H6@ºH6.7K74QL5@ 0�85H�3,/4SCB.�.7,Z0�4S(98BmsV9@%Dc*Z@�D/@I(9L54S,/8­LZ�38 4SH¯L5.7,/,-8M,-8GH685(+*/@7CB85(+*-8 4SCB�3H646LM@�46HbLa.7,/,/85,/8G8 46(+*-,/.�0313,-,/8³13("@¼(�13.�Y�@�3,/85CB8MD/D/@3©

�p0� � M�� � � � � T� 0

')H¯�9@%D-D/@IK%K746.�@70 13("@�H6.7K%46LM@�0�4~.7,Z0�46(38½DU19�"8M,-46.7,/8º@7H~�3,/4SCB.Å 8 (38�La8MD/D/@I,/4S.�¢%1"@I(90�.�D-4�La.%(9D-460�8M,/@7(3.�3,/.7�3,/468a*l @P8<,/[email protected](94#Y�@7,-4Q@IV346H64�T�8\D-4|¢+19@I(+*-4Si"LM@JD-1 0�4|8MD/D-87: g 8<@/bh85,/[email protected]@70 8MD-85CB�346.9©

� AB9-.�.89S,/.8WE.1,/*-<cfR0V0/7lPc4@9;<c*&9S0 J 25< J 2L.14"( �0�#85,~.7*U*-8M(385,/8�13(9@JEF.%,-CG@[email protected](38�D-4A0�85Y%8\0�4QDU�#.7,/,-8<0�4A13(9@BY�@I,/46@7V346HS8�� �"8M,~�3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @VM�0�4QDU*-46(%*Z@³03@7HSHQ@Y�@I,/46@7V346HS8 � �#85,¯46(90�46Y+4Q0�1348T ©

� � ��� M�� � T¥ .7CB8 8MD-85CB�346.��34U 1PD-46K7(34Si"L5@I*-46Y7.=0�4��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(98 LZ�38_DU4+EF.7,/CG@IH64S2M2M@�@IH�DU8�La.%(90�.~.%,/0�46(38bLa.%(9DU4Q0�8M,-4Q@ICB.

46H|�3,/4S(9L54S�94S.G0�4|46(90�192546.7(38�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@3T3LZ�38\D-4[85(�13([email protected] *Z@ICB85(+*/8=(985H|CB.�0�.GDU8MK7138M(+*-87©� 4[*&9S0 J 25< J 2L.14"( �0sW/0/7e4 J 4"2 .87�9-*&Pc4@25<�f 4 �C!"*-039;,B<sWK037F4 J 4@2=*&9 9X*&PQ4@25<��iWK037F4 J 4"2[.87')*->)>)4"'G'L.8W/<6,3.�!"*-4@7�9-*&Pc4@25<�� 03787F</25067F0 J 25< J 2L.14@( �06W/0/7F4 J 4"2�(+*&(I(+. .:9-*&Pc4"2L.�9S0/(+*&250/7l. :

� 85,ºEF.%,-CG@IH646252M@7,-HQ@·.�LMLa.%,-,/8�.+D-D-85,/Y�@I,/8�LZ�38�*Z@IH68��3,-46(9L54S�346. D-4<,-4SEF85,/46D/La8�(3.%( @70À13(9@ �3,/.7�3,/468a*l @ 46(�9@7,U*/46L5.7HQ@I,/87T�CG@J@%0­.%K7(34[�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @3T��#85,�L5134|13(9@[email protected],/CG@IH64S2M2M@I2M4S.%(38�D-@7,l @J0�85H|*-46�".�I©

� � M^M���f� � � M�� � � � � J T5T � ��� � � T�� a#&%('�#&!$*T�M*H!�./%�F/#&1�%(>$#&./%(�X�&./F/#&!$*(8����-#&�= �1�!�!��� � "./���)'�#�L���H�&.H>�����.�]

Page 10: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

eMfg 8bDU4+�9@7(3(3.�@�0�4QDU�#.%D-462546.7(38bDU46CRV#.7H64+�"8M,��9,-8�0�46LM@�*/4�034+�9,-8�0�46LM@�*/4%8_Y�@I,/46@7V34SH64+�"8M,��9,-8�0�46LM@�*/4�LZ�98��#.%D/DU.%(3.

8MD/D-85,/8�¢+19@I(+*/4 i"LM@�*/8�D-4#�"@\46H#H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.�8J Jh0�[email protected]@R0�85H[D-8MLa.%(90�.P.7,Z0�4S(987:�rR´ @IHS*-,Z@\�"@I,-*-8R 8�.�Y�Y�4S.RLZ�9846H_�9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-.�D-4b�31� .�4S*-8M,/@7,-8­4S(9038ai9(34S*/@7CB85(+*-8%T�La.%(9DU4Q0�8M,/@7(90�.¼�3,/8M0346LM@�*-4b0�4b�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4b0�4_�3,-8�0�4QL5@�*/4�TY�@I,/46@7V346HS4��"8M,��3,-8�0�4QL5@�*/4�0�4��3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4�8BL5.%D)  $AY�4Q@3:P¥ .%CJ8JY78�0�,/85CB.9ThK74) @­@7H HS46Y78MHSH6. 0�8MHsDU8�La.%(90�.­.%,/034S(38JDU446(9La.%(%*/,/@7(3. @7H6L513(34�(3.7*-8MY7.7H64 �3,/.7V3H685CB4�TALZ�38GDU19K7K78M,-4QD/La.7(9.­0�4sDUEF,-1�*-*/@7,-8G@IH CB85K%HS46. HS8B�#.I*/85(32M46@7HS4S*l @º0�[email protected]@½03854��9,-8�0�46LM@�*/4 0�8MH �3,/46CJ.�.7,Z0�4S(987T La85,ZL5@7(90�.¼0�4 85Y�4S*/@I,/8³46H��9@%D-D/@IK%K746.½@IK7H64�.%,/034S(34 DU19LMLa8�D-D-4SY�4�:�r�4E�@�*-*-.<D-4�,-468MD/La8b@~EF.%,-CG@7HS46252�@I,/8�K7,Z@I(P�9@I,-*-8b0�8M4�,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-4�@IV34S*-19@7HS4�(985H6H�´ @ICPV34 */.=0385H6H6@=H6.7K74QL5@=0�8MH��3,-46CB..7,Z0�46(387:

¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/[email protected](�i9(38<46HAD-85K%1385(+*-8�,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.9©� 0/2L7F<�'L(h06>G<32L254@9;,B<� 0/2L7F<V0/WE2 �0V>G<32)'@<

g 4Q@ICB.¼46(°�3,/8MD-85(32�@½0�4_13(°,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-.½L5.7,/,-85*U*-."©PD-8 @%0�8MD/DU.�¥_@7,-H6.¼La.%,-,/87T D/@I,� @ Y785,/.½(38MH�EF1�*/13,/.LZ�38½¥_@I,/HS.½�9@�La.%,/D-.½4S(�13(�4QDc*Z@I(+*-8­�9@7D/D-@I*-.":�?A@¼D-19@¼EF.7,/CB@7HS46252�@I2M4S.%(38BEF13.7,/468MD/La8­03@7HSH68³�#.%D/DU46V346HS4S*l @�0�854H64S(3K%19@IK%K74li9(P¢%194746(%*/,-.�0�.7*U*/4�T��".%46LZ�$#8�(3.7(<D-49 8sD-�#8MLa4Si"LM@�*-.¯19(<CJ.�0�.��"8M,A,Z@I�3�3,/8MD-85(+*Z@I,/8�47*-85CB�34�0�8M47Y78M,-V94���:¨[email protected].%D)  $h13( 8MD-85CB�346.G0�4[13( ,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.J0�4[EF,/.7(+*-8�@IH|¢+19@7HS8�HQ@i7e<5AB.1>)0i>@7F0K')'L.1>)0cM�LZ�98\La.7CB�3,/85("0�8@I�9�313(+*-.³HQ@³H6.7K%46LM@B�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH68<8RH68RH6.7K%46LZ�38\03854��3,-8�0�4QL5@�*/4gT�DU4�,-46Y78MH6@³4S(9@%0�85K%19@�*Z@3:!rP´ @7H */,/@³�9@I,-*-8\K%HS4@7D-�#8a*U*/4#*-85CB�#.7,Z@IH64#D-.7(9.P@7D/D-85(+*-4#03@IH6H6@RK7,Z@I(³�"@I,-*-8�0385H6H�´ @�*-*-46Y+4S*l @P0�8M031�*U*/4SY�@3T3@%0G8MD-85CB�346.P09@P¢+138MHSHQ@RLZ�38=DU4D-Y7.7H6K78�46(½@ICRV94 */.GCB@I*-8MCB@I*-4QLa.":s')(3.7HS*-,/87T"La.7CB8\D-4s 8<0�85*U*-."T94AD-4QDc*/85CB4AH6.7K%46L54|LZ�38<8MD/@ICB46(385,/85CB.B4S(¼¢+138�Dc*/.La.%,/D-.RD-.7(3.P@IH6H6@RV9@7D-8�0�8MHSH68�DU19LMLa8�D-D-4SY%8~8MDU*-8M(9D-4S.%(34"�#85, EF.7,/CG@IH64S2M2M@7,-8�@7CRV34S*-4#�34U 1 @7CJ�94h0385Hh,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.La.%(90�.7*U*-.B(38M4|H64S(3K%19@IK%K74h(9@I*-13,Z@IH64�:

� ��# ��# #�� �!���"����� �����O�: E�p��s,/.%D-85K%134Q@ICB.�¢+138�Dc*/.°L5@I�94 */.7H6.�46(+*-,/.�0�1�*U*/4SY%.�La.7(Å13(ÅV3,/85Y�4QD-D-46CJ.��9@7(3.7,Z@ICG@�Dc*/.7,/46L5.�0385H6HS8 *Z@I�3�#8¼�34U 1D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/4SY%8¼0�85H6HQ@�HS.%K74QL5@�8�0385H6H�´ .7�#85,Z@�0�854=�3,/4S("La46�9@IH64�DU*-190�46.%D-4�LZ�98¼Y78M,-,Z@I(3(9.�CB8M(32546.7(9@I*-4�4S( ¢+138�Dc*/.*-8�Dc*/.9:

?|.PDc*/190�46.P0�8MHSHQ@<[email protected]�0346D/La46�3H64S(9@\EF.7,/CG@IH68�LZ�38�D-4#.�LMLa13�"@\0�85HhLa.%,-,/8a*-*-.R038M0�13,/,/8< 8~�3,/8MD-85(+*/8~K74) @46(������� ��� ������hT[19(34SY%85,ZD-@7HSCB8M(%*/8R,/46L5.7(3.+D-L54S13*-. L5.7CB8R46H�oU�"@70�,/8P0�8MHSHQ@ HS.%K74QL5@Bq9:=¨�0�¨�,-4QDU*-.I*/85H68JD-4�0�85Y%8HQ@R(3.7*-4QD-D-46CB@\*-8M.7,/46@P0�85H|D-4SH6H6.7K74QD-CJ."T+L54S.9 8~H�´ @7(9@IH64QDU4[0�4[@IHQLa19(38�EF.%,-CB8=�9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-4#0�4h,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.6M�¢+19@IH64�©o-D-8B*-13*U*-4 4�K%,-8�La4sD-.7(3. 13.%CJ46(34 8B*-1�*-*-4_K7H64s13.7CB46(34�D-.7(3.½CB.%,U*Z@IH64�T�@IH6HS.%,/@­*-1�*-*-4_4sK7,/8ML54�D-.7(3. CB.7,-*/@7HS4gq_Ta:�s19,�8MD/D-85(90�.P4S(+*/8MD/@\03@R¨�,-4QDU*-.I*/85H68�L5.7CB8~13(9@\*-8M.7,/46@<K%85(38M,/@7HS8�0�85H6H�´ 46(�EF85,/85(32�@3T+H6@\*-8M.7,/46@\0385HhDU46HSH6.7K%46D-CB.³ 8%T46( 8@b#85*U*-4�T9D-.7H6.P19(­EF,Z@ICBCB85(+*-.B0�8MHSHQ@JHS.%K74QL5@R03854[�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4|0�8MH[�3,/4SCB.J.7,Z0�4S(98�M�4S( 8MD/D/@\46(%*/85,/Y78M(3K7.%(3.PD-.7H6.�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4[CB.7("@70�4QLa4�T�.%D/DU4Q@RD-46CRV#.7H64[�"8M,¯�3,-.%�3,/4S85*l @_Ta: g 85CB�3,/8�(385H6H�´ @ICPV34S*-.G0�85H[�#85("DU4685,/.PK%,-8�La."T�@74hi9H6.%D-.Ii0�8MHSH68�'@>@*-</7F4QPc4hA_032L.1>)0\86')(\</.1>)0PDU4 0�8MY78R19(¼�3,/4SCB. D-Y�4SH613�3�#. 0385H6H6@³*-85.%,-4Q@³0�8M4�L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�4�HS.%K74QLa4�T#L54S.9 8R0�4¢+13854|*-85,/CB4S(94�0�8MHAH64S(3K%19@IK%K746.J¢+19@7HS4?oU(3.%(-q3T:o-8`q9T�oU._q9T�o-D-87:6:S:6T @IH6HS.%,/@9:S:6: q�CB8M0346@7(%*/8<4�¢+19@7HS4AD-4AL5.%DU*-,/1346D/La.%(3.�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34AL5.7CB�".+Dc*/8\�9@7,U*/85(90�.³09@G�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34AD-85CB�3H646L54�T"8P¢+1346(90�4�D-4A�#.%D/D-.7(3.G,/4S(+*/,/@%L5La4Q@I,/8�4A�3,/46CJ485H685CB8M(%*/4A0�8MHSHQ@JHS.%K74QL5@P�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH687:

��,/@7H6@%D-L546@7(90�.³4sL5.7(+*-,/4SV91�*-4s0�8M4�HS.%K74QLa4 CB8M0�46.�85Y�@IH64�T[H6@ La194�4SCB�#.7,-*/@I(92M@� 8JDU*/@I*/@ ,-4QLa.%(3.%D/La461�*Z@­D-.7H6. 46(85�#.�L5@B@7D/D/@I4h,-8�La8M(%*/8�8\LZ�98�D-.7(9.P.%K7K785*U*/.J0�4[19(|´ @I*U*/85(+*/@B,/4SY�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(387Th 8�0�.�Y78M,-.+DU.J@IH6CB85(3.JCB85(32M4S.%(9@I,/8HQ@~i9K%13,Z@~0�4����� � ������� �!��#"����#$&%'���(�)��*OMce�§IO%§I�/e�]�e�§_T T54SH3¢+19@7HS8 �9@�@7(+*-4QLa46�9@�*/.�H68 4Q0�858 EF.7("03@ICB85(+*Z@IH640�8MK7H64%D-Y+46H613�3�34%�34U 1R,-8�La85(+*/4%0�8MHSHQ@¯H6.7K74QL5@9T5Y�@IH68�@~034S,/8sHQ@~La.+Dc*/,-132M4S.%(38s0�4%13(\H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.¯DU46CRV#.7H646L5.~13(346Y78M,/D/@IH68M5>)fR03250B>@(\4"2L.g'L(+.1>G0�*&9-.8W/4"2)'@037l.g'^T_8�H�´ 8MH6@7V".%,/@72546.7(38�0�4h13( [email protected]>G037F>@*&7l*D'�2G0/(+.1<`>@.89;03(h<32^T LZ�987T�La.%(9DU8M(+*-85("0�.HQ@½CB8ML5LM@I(346252�@I2M4S.%(38­0�4 *-1�*-*-4_4�*/4S�94b034 ,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.[MG0/2)'V>)<3P �@.89;03(h<32L.10@T T �".7*-8�D-D-8­0�46,-46CB85,/8G*-13*U*-8ºH68¢+138MDU*-46.7(94�:

?s´ @I(9(3.R0�4#(9@7D/La4S*/@R0�85H6H6@RHS.%K74QL5@�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@³ 8�K785(985,Z@IH6CJ8M(+*-8~La.%(9D-460�8M,/@I*-.\46H�eM¤IO�]�T7@7(3(3.P4S(­L5134hDU.%(3.DU*/@�*/8½�313V3V9HS4QL5@I*-8¼HQ@,+�-/.1032/4657-98#:<;³0�4=�?>�@A>��B �>A�DC��FEG����@�HA) MUeM¤%f7§��ZeM¤�]�eKT<87T~D-.7�9,/@I*U*-13*U*-."T=I7J�KL 2�M<J�KN0O2�M<:P;Q2R4TSVU�2/4XW�Y1:ZY[-]\�5^-98#:<; 034����T����@��`_a�7���#��Mce�¤3elXl�ZeM¤7§7OdTa:�r�8 �½.7,/K%@7(G8�^_.+.%HS8%T%19(34 *Z@ICB85(+*/8@ 4SH6HS1"Dc*/,-4sD-85K%19@7L54A*/,/@ 4s¢+19@IH64�b6"H���#���`c7dfeg�����h�� Mce�¤7>7�I�/e��3eMOdT_8Oi6�)��B jc�h�"���k�A����� MceM¤7O9e5�/e��7f%k_T TD-Y+46H613�3�9@7,-.%(3.³HQ@³H6.7K74QL5@­@IH6H6@ Dc*/,-8MK719@³034�19(9@ 0346D/La46�3H64S(9@­CG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QL5@9T[La.7CB8P13(�Y%85,/.³8P�9,-.%�3,-46.­[email protected] , �#& �0��Q1(%� ��70�0�./�"�b'����&�M*[�&./F/#&!$*(8B�M*[!�./ "#&'�'��70"0�*6j k�lBmRnEoTs�q$r E k J o/j qt8�%�����9�1�*,�&�� "#(�R./��5;*,�&#&>�>$*,%�.K�E*,F/#&./%�*,56�$%B0"#�9�1�*,�&��9�1����&�&../�E*T����./�@./ "0".�]

Page 11: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

e%e@IH6K78MV3,/46L5.�����:s?s´ @IH6K785V9,-46252�@I2546.7(98~0�[email protected]@9T%�913,¯La.%DU*-4S*-1985(90�.P13(º�9@7D/DU.P0�4hEF.7(909@ICB85(+*/@7HS8�4SCB�#.7,-*/@7(32M@9T(3.%(PD-4" 8 ,-46Y78MH6@I*-.�@7(9La.%,/@�DU1&%³L54S8M(%*/8 �#85, H�´ 8MH6@7V".%,/@72546.7(38 0�4�Y785,/478_�3,/.7�3,/4�L5@IHQLa.%HS4+H6.7K74QLa4+m� 8_Dc*Z@�*-.�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-46.13(P,-46V9@IHS*/@7CB85(+*-.=0�4��3,-.+DU�#8a*-*-46Y�@3©|(3.%(R�34U 1RHQ@~H6.7K%46LM@¯*/,/@I*U*/@I*/@�La.7CB8_0�46D/La46�3H64S("@�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@3TlCG@�HQ@~H6.7K%46LM@@IH|D-85,/Y�4S2M4S.B0�8MHSHQ@BCG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QL5@9:

��138�Dc*/.º0�8�La4QDU46Y7.º�9@%D-D-.­46(�@lY�@7(%*/4_ 8JDU*/@I*-.½La.%CB�34S13*-. 03@IH�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46L5. 4 *Z@IH646@7(3. ���>��B�������Ge6� H�)A�Mce�¤%X7¤��ZeM�7>+kBT�8­03@7HSHQ@½DU1"@¼D-L513.7HQ@½LZ�38%T�L5.7(�H�´ 46(+*-85(+*/.¼�3,/4SCG@I,/46. 034 ,/85(90385,/8³La.7CB�3H68a*Z@ICB85(+*/8³,-46K7.%,-.+DU8JH680�46CB.%DU*-,[email protected](94�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LZ�987T|�9@ºLa.%(90�.7*U*-.º13(|´ @I("@IH646D-4�DU8M,-,Z@�*Z@­0�8MH�HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S. 0�85H6H6@ºCG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@3Th*/,/@I�0�19L585(903.7H6.P46(ºD-46CRV#.7H64#8�La8M,/LM@I(903.P0�4[8�DU�3H64QLa4S*/@I,/8�4[�9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-4[La.%(­4[¢+19@IH64|DU4h.7*U*-8M(3K7.%(3.R4h*/85.%,-8MCJ4�:  ¡(38MHSH�´ @7CRV34S*-.B0�[email protected]@R0�4|� 8�@I(3.JLZ�38<DU.%(3.PDU*/@I*-4[8�DU�3H64QLa4S*/@�*/4[4[(�13.�Y�4hLM@I(3.%(34[0�85H6H�´ @%D-D-4S.%CG@�*-4QL5@9T%46(ºV9@7D-8@I4#¢+19@IH64�© @_T�K7H64"@7D/D-4S.%CJ4#DU.%(3.\La.%(9D-460�8M,/@I*-49@\�3,-8�D-L54S("0�85,/8~03@<.%K7(34",-4SEF85,/4SCB8M(%*/.R@70B19(³La.7(+*/85(�1�*-.R8MDU*-85,/(3."T(3.%(½�34U 1½�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34A85Y�460385(+*-4�T"CG@³D-19D/La85*U*-46V346HS4�0�4�CJ.%H */85�3H64QLa4A46(+*-8M,-�3,/8a*Z@I2M4S.%(34Im"VXTb4 La.%(9La85*U*-4��3,/4SCB4S*-46Y+4�9@7(3(3.�13(³D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/.=LZ�98~0�4S�#85("0�8�D-.7H6.=03@<¢+19@7(+*-.�8MD-�3,/8MD/DU.=(385K%HS4"@7D/DU46.7CB4�T�49¢+19@IH643Y78M(3K7.%(3.�@<La.%DU*-4S*-194S,/813([email protected],-*/@J0�4|0�85i9(3462546.7(38�46CJ�9HS4QLa4S*/@G0�8M4|La.%(9La85*U*-4|DU*-8�D-D-4�: g 4  8�Y785(�1�*/.J¢+1346(90�4AK7,Z@70�19@7HSCB8M(%*/8�@3b#8M,-CG@I("0�.13(º(�13.�Y7.PCJ.�0�.G0�4[46(+*-8M(90�85,/8=H�´ @�*-*-46Y+4S*l @JCG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@3T�46H|¢+19@IH68��"@JL5.7CB�#.7,-*/@�*/.RHQ@J(9@7D/La4S*/@J0�4h*-13*U*/@J13("@(�13.�Y�@BDU8M,-468<0�4|�3,/.7V3H685CG@I*-4QLZ�38�,-8MH6@I*-46Y78<@IH6H6@BL5.+8M,-8M(32M@9T�@IH6H�´ 4S("0�4S�#85("0�85(32�@3T#@IH6H6@BLa.%CB�3HS85*-8M252M@B0�8M4AD-46DU*-8MCJ40�4A@%D-D-46.7CB4[8<H�´ 8MD-46K785(92M@B0�4|8�DU�3H64QLa4S*/@I,/8<H�´ @7�3�9@I,Z@�*/.J038M0�1�*-*-46Y7.³0�8MHSH68�*-8M.7,/4S8�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LZ�98<8<�9@GLa.%(90�.I*-*-."TLa.%CB8=Y%8M0�,/85CB.PEF,/@BV9,-8MY787T�@7HSHQ@J85HQ@IV#.7,[email protected](98=0�8M4[�3,/[email protected][H6.7K74QLa4[Y%85,/4h8<�3,-.%�3,/4�:

')H[,/4SV9@7H *Z@ICB85(+*/.BL5.7(9L58a*-*-19@7HS8�(38M4|La.7(3EF,-.%(%*/4|0�85H6HQ@BCB@I*-8MCB@I*-4QL5@P85,Z@BDc*Z@�*-.BK%4  @BLa.%(90�.7*U*-.Ji9(9.B@7HSH68<DU1988MDU*-,/85CB8 La.%(9DU8MK7138M(3258º03@G���� � ����(������@A� MUeM¤IO+¤��ZeM�+k7XBT=46H~¢+19@IH687T (385H6HQ@�D-19@�� KQ8�. :�Y Y�; J�. :�\ M�M��� �KB-��8�.N2���2BT\0385H�eM¤�]��3T�@lY%85Y�@¼46(+*-,/.�03.I*U*/.�K%HS4¯DU*-,/13CB85(+*-4b�#85,B13(9@��"8M,UEF85*U*Z@�038M0�132M4S.%(38 EF.7,/CB@7HS8%Ts@7D/DU4QLa19,/@I*/@03@7HSH�´ 1"DU.G0�4�13(3.GDc*/,-19CJ8M(+*-.³D-4SCPV".%HS4QLa.B8\03@B13(A´ @7(9@IH646D-4|0�8M4ALa.%(9La85*U*-4 M EF.7("03@�*Z@GDU13H�La.7("La8a*-*-.³0�4|EF13(32546.7(988½0�4¯@I,/K7.%CJ8M(+*-.dT\,-4QD-13H *Z@�*Z@�0�8�La4QDU46Y�@��#85,BHQ@�La,/8M@I2M4S.%(38 03854¯[email protected]_H6.7K%46L54�: �A1�*-*/@lY�4Q@3Tjn9,-8MK78 @lY785Y�@�13(.7V94S85*U*-46Y7.JLZ�38�@I(903@lY�@<V#85(º.7HS*-,/8�@7HSHQ@\,/4QLa.%DU*-,/132M4S.%(38~,/4SK%.7,/.%D/@<0�85H6HS8�0�46CB.%DU*-,[email protected](94"CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LZ�987© DU8�La.7(3�0�.B46Hhi9HS.+DU.7EF.J*-8M038MD/[email protected]@J0�.�Y%85Y�@\EF.%,-(94S,/8�46H[EF.%(903@ICB8M(%*/.JDU*-8�D-D-.G0�85H6HQ@PCG@I*-85CG@I*-4QL5@3T�(985H|D-85(9D-.JLZ�984sLa.%(9La85*U*/4�CB@I*-8MCB@I*-4QLa4�@lY�,-8MV3V#85,/. 0�.�Y�1�*/. 8�D-D-85,/8R,/4603.I*U*/4s@ L5.7(9L58a*-*-4s0�4��319,/@ HS.%K74QL5@��t��:J')H �3,/.7K7,Z@[email protected]%46L546DU*/@_qG0�4�n3,/85K78REF1�La.%CB�3HS85*/@7CJ8M(+*-8R,/4Q0�4SCB8M(9DU46.7("@�*-. 03@IH6H6@ D-L5.7�#85,-*/@9T9(38MH_e��7f+k�T"09@G�9@I,-*-8J0�4 _g����� ��H�)����=>�� � ���#�QMce�¤+]Ik��/e��+]If_T Tl0�4319(9@�@I(+*-46(3.7CB4Q@��$��:���138MDU*/@�E�@7D-87T%0�4SY%85(�1�*Z@�(9.I*/@�L5.7(J4SH3(9.7CB8¯0�4:o-L5,-4QD-40�8M4[EF.7(909@ICB85(+*-4|0385H6H6@BCG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@Bq9T�EF1º46H|�319(%*/.G0�4A@lY�Y�4S.B0�4|13("@GDU8M,-468�4SCB�#.7(38M(%*/8<0�4|,/46L585,ZLZ�387:�r=@B13(HQ@�*-."T"H6. DU*-8�D-D-.­Â¯1"D-D-85H6H�,/46�3,-8�DU8R4SH��3,/.7K7,Z@[email protected]*/@JEF,/85K78�@I(3.­8R�#85,/Y785(9(38R@IH6HQ@³�[email protected](38iM�La.%(��������������A�� " �!"�Z ���"�� H�� Mce�¤7§3e5�/e��IO�]3T^T 0�8M4�*/,-8RY7.7H613CB4 0�854��f. : U�;1:���:Z23L 2 MPJ�KQ032 MP:<;N2�MUeM�3e�f��ZeM>dT T.7�#85,Z@ºLZ�38G@lY785Y�@­H�´ .7V3468a*-*-46Y7.½0�4�CB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8PL5.7CB8BH6@ºCG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@³EF.+D-D-8B,-4QL5@lY�@7V34SH68PD-.7HS*/@7(+*-. 03@º�3,-46(9L54S�34H6.7K74QLa4pM�H6@ HS.%K74QL5@ 85,Z@³46(+*-8MD/@ La.%[email protected]. 0�8MHSH68B�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34�8G0�8M4��3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4�0�4�.7,Z0�46(38B¢%1"@IHQDU4Q@7D-4�Y½HQ@La.+DU4Q030�85*U*Z@J*-85.%,-4Q@B0�854A*-46�34 Y­8P0�4A,/85K%.7H68�@I*U*/8\@G85Y�4S*/@I,/8�HS8P@I(+*-46(3.7CB468ETa: rP´ @7H */,-.GHQ@�*/.9T�C H��A�������#(T���# Mce�¤7§+kl�ZeM�IO+>_TaT�@7H"¥ .7(3K%,-8�D-D-.�0�8M4 �¼@I*-85CG@I*-4QLa430�49��@7,-46K74�0�8MH[eM�%f7f3TI@lY%85Y�@��".+Dc*/.=46(B,-4QD/@IHS*-.=4SH3�9,-.%V3HS8MCG@�0�8MH �HQ@P0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I2M4S.%(38�0�4[(9.7( La.7(+*/,/@%030�4S*U*-.%,-468a*� @R0�8MHSH�´ @I(9@7HS4QDU4hCG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@R8=46(ºD-85K%134 */.9T�(38MK7H64h@7(3(34[Y%85(+*-4�T�EF1�� �# #M*,56.61�% f #&'��$*6'�#2!�./ E*6!�# 3.; �#&F/%�# \+!�Z�#?] eSf ��9�1+*,>�#&./%��"!$#&%�#uPR!EZ��T �#2��1-3.;�&��F/F/�����T#&%� �#&��56#& "0"#&!$*,56��%�0"�Gh�� f #&%�0"���� "�$>�#&./%��

'�#'!;�K'�#'#w3�(#�iH��'G�$9�1�# A,*,�&�)*Dh)#:3�K!�./%B0���%�1(0".6#&%*!�i�Y� �# ��1-3.T#&%�0"��%�'������K!�./56�;h"0"1(0�0�#=F/�&#�#; "./%�.+!�i�]�,[1�#&%�'�#?8(*,'G�$ "��56��#&.�8h"0"1(0"0"#x#QF/����!�#Q �./%�.w1(./56#&%�#&i:�4h"0�1�0"0"#xF/�&#�1�./56#&%�#� "./%�.w56./�"0�*,�&#&i�82 �#S�$ "����#&56./%(.:!�./%-#.!-%�!u�;>/#-%�# P0#1% 1(./56.�8�!%�F/����!�.=�->2%�56./�"0�*,�&�tYI��5;*;'�*G9�1��� "0"�6'�1�����9�1+*,>�#&./%�#?8�!�./%v ���56���&#&!�#- �./ �0�# 0"1�>�#&./%�#S*,�&F/�$O(��#&!EZ��/8� �#J.,0"0"#&��%���>/!3%4!uP~./ " �#M*h"0"1(0"0"#-#�F/�"��!$#� �./%�.�56./��0E*,�&#&i�YE]2��%(�~*C0"0"#?8+'+*T>�#5%6# 8�56./� 0"#&���&#&!$*,%�'�.H*,5HO@.�#=56�$5TO���#@�@���7!�8� �#�Z�*H>/#.!8%9#$!B8��< �./ �0�# 0"1���%�'�.#&%w��%�0"�E*,5TO�#-#-56��5HO��"#:#$!w!�./%5!uPR'+*C0".D!EZ��;#$!<%=!+YE8= �#-�@���"A�#&�$%(��*6>/!&%�!B] ;b%�*;'(�$'(1�>�#&./%��/8�9�1�#&%�'�#?8=*, � "1�56�)�M*��~./�"5;*'�#�1(%+*H0���*, "�R./��5;*,>�#&./%��K'(#���9�1+*,>�#&./%�#?] eSf *, ��@�70"0".��R./%�'+*,56��%�0�*,�&�)'�����!$*,�&!�./�&.6'�#?>�.�./�&�<�$��*H�M*H "1+*�'�1����&#&!��<#&%B0����"�����70�*,>$#&./%(�!�./56�[!$*,�&!�./�&.H'����&�&�K!��M*, " �# �K!�./56�[!$*,�&!�./�&.H'����&�&�K���"./�@./ �#&>�#&./%�#?]�@+1��"./%�.@2��#&��!��K�O!�!EZ��BA./'(�$�x!EZ(�<*,56���&#M*,��./%(.T�&�b� .,0"��%�>�#M*,�&# 0,3*'�����!$*,�&!�./�&.�O@.�./�&�$*,%�.6#&%B0"��.�'�1�!���%�'�.tA�#-#�9�1+*,%B0�# \�!t*C0"./��#QP~*,%�!EZ��)'�#=./��'�#&%(�< �1��@����#&./�"�CYE]�7�DC ���K ���!�./�&.a �!�./�" �.�8b#&�[���"./F/�E*,565;*4�"#&'�1�>�#&./%�#& �0E**�AB�7A/*a��#&!�./%�'�.,0�0".d�M*v0���./��#M*'(�$#[%�1�56���"#[���$*,�&#?8���9�1(#&%�'�#K� f *,%+*,�&#& "#

5;*C0"�$5;*C0"#&!$*(8J*,�&�M*D0���./�"#M*:'���#�%�1(56�$�"#S%+*C0"1���*,�&#Q�$'*,'a*,�&!�1�%�#Q���&��56�$%B0"#�'����&�M*D0���./�"#M*:'����&�&�6!$�M*, " �#?] !�#S0���*C0"0�*$A,*v9�1�#&%�'(#�'�#��#&'(1����"�H#&�S!�./%�!��70�0�.�'�#N%�1�56���".D%+*C0"1��E*,�&�;*G��1��"�6%�./>�#&./%�#��&./F/#&!EZ��/]E@+����F/�6!�����!�3.:'�#N���$*,�&#&>�>$*,���69�1��� "0".w����./F/�70�0�.w�&./F/#&!�#& "0�*'+*,���(��#&5;*u!�./%9F(G0H-I7JLKLM'N.O0PBQ.HRM=NSHRJ8TUJ)GWVYX[ZEH�VG�\ P)]D^_^�`�YD���@./#)%���#<'�1���AB./�&1�56#;F(G0H-I7JBK�M'N$Q.HRa/HLVbBH-NSHRJ8T(JcGWVXSZEHLVYG�\P�]D^_d_eLfR]Dd �_eBY7]�"^ ,[1��� "0�*H*,%B0�#&%�./56#M*X*,%�'+*�A/*T*,'L*,F/F/#&1(%�F/���� �#�*X9�1����&�&�[!�Z��K���E*,%�.X "0�*C0"�< �!�./�@�$��0��[%����&� f *,5HO�# 0".)'����&�M*)0"��./��#M*)'���F/�&#=#&%� "#&��56#

'�#hgji.k'l�m<n7o'p'q�k'lvP�]D^�`srLfR]Dd[]D^BYE] eSf *,%B0�#&%(./56#M*)'(#�tx1� � "���&� "#=�(1-3.�8(#&%;O��"�7AB�B8(!�./ 3 u@�~./�"5H1��M*,�"�B] !�#M*+v � f #&%( �#&��56�x'�#+0�1(0�0"#�F/�&##&%� "#&�$56#�!EZ���%�./%v*,����*,�"0"�$%(F/./%�.w*6 ��T "0"�$ " �#QPR#&%�0"���"A�#&�$%(��9�1(#J1(%�.L'(�$#J���"#&%�!�#&��#2'����&�M*60"��./��#M*;'���F/�&#2#&%� �#&��56#?8@#&� E�J mG.@n$m E mRkwpBmnEk/r E�J qH.+|�m~k�.@qt8�#&%6O+*, "�b*,�@9�1+*,�&��� f �$ �0���%� "#&./%���'�#+./F/%�#+���"�$'(#&!t*C0".;3��1(%6#&%� �#&��56���B9�1(#&%�'�#+#&�+���"�$'(#&!t*C0".Lh�%�./%;*,���+*,��0���%����"�K*< �� "0"�� � "./iH'��70"�$�"56#&%+*)1�%L#&%( �#&��56�/8(*,�(��1�%B0�.�� f #&%( �#&��56�x'���F/�&#�#&%� "#&�$56#+!�Z��K%�./%L*,���+*,��0���%�F/./%�.;*X ��b "0"�$ " �# YE]�!��K �#@ "1����@./%��<!EZ��v *,���+*,�"0"#&��%��T**v�8@*,�&�&./��*L3�<1�%:#&%� "#&��56�K!EZ��)%�./%w*,�(�+*,�"0"#&��%��H*� "�< "0"�� � �.�8@�)9�1�#&%�'�#?v %�./%:*,���+*,�"0"#&��%��T**v�]Sz[#&!���AB���" E*(8 ��Ev %�./%u*,���+*,��0�#&��%��G*wvw82*,�&�&./�E*L*,���+*,�"0"#&��%��G*,�&� f #&%� �#&��56�X'���F/�&#S#&%� "#&��56#N!EZ(�6%�./%*,����*,�"0"�$%(F/./%�.v*D ��� �0��� " �#?8-!EZ(�w3�2v�8�69�1�#&%�'�#xv *,�(�+*,�"0"#&��%��G*5v�];��%4'��7\+%�# 0"# A/*wv *,���+*,��0�#&��%��;*5v "���6 �./�&.L ��*v %�./%u*,���+*,�"0"#&��%��;*wvw8-��9�1��� "0�*u3��1�%+*!�./%�0"�E*,'('�#&>�#&./%��/]

Page 12: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

e�k@IH6HQ@�K%134Q03@�0385H3�3,/.7K%,/@7CBCB@6ocEF.%,-CG@IH64QDc*Z@Bq3TILZ�98bD-4��#.7(38MYl@=H�´ .%V3468a*U*/4SY%.<0�43,/460�19,-,/8 HQ@=CG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QL5@�@�D-46DU*-8MCJ4EF.7,/CG@IH64A8B0�4 0�4SCB.+Dc*/,/@7,-(38RH6@­(3.7(�L5.7(+*-,Z@7090�4 *-*-.%,-468a*� @3: g 1�13(¼*/85,/25.GEF,/.7(+*-8�%'>�Z �* ��) i d���d _g���A>��3���Mce�¤7¤9ea�ZeM�7§%§_T�DU4 E�@%La85Y�@ �#.7,-*/@lY%.�L58J034�13(�CB.�0�.½,/@%0�4QL5@IH6CB85(+*-8B(�13.�Y%.º0�4 4S(+*/85(90�8M,-8BK%HS4s8M(+*-4sCG@�*/85CG@�*/4 �La4�©R(985H6H6@½D-19@ La.%(9La8M2546.7(38%T�0�85*U*/@HqI46(%*/13462546.7(34QDUCB.dq3TALZ�38G46(+*-8M(90�8³�3,/46Y+46H685K74Q@I,/8BK7H64�@7D-�#8a*U*/4ao-L5.%DU*-,/1�*U*/4SY�4gq0�8MHSH�´ @I*U*/4SY�4S*l @GCG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@3T9@7(9LZ�38<HQ@BHS.%K74QL5@BD-13V34QD-L58\0�85H6HS8R�3,-.7EF.7(9038�*-,[email protected],/[email protected](34�M�(385H6H6@³HS.%K74QL5@J4S(+*/134 �2546.7(946DU*/@9T9@70º8MD-85CB�346.9T"(3.7( Y�@IH6K7.%(3.B4S(½K%85(38M,/@7HS8�46H|�3,/4S("La46�34S.³0385H|*/85,/25.G8�D-L5HS19D-.B8\HQ@BHS8MK7K78<0�8MHSHQ@³0�.%�3�34Q@(38MK%@I2M4S.%(38��$�@Ta: ?A8b*-,/8~D-L513.7H68bEF.7("03@I2M4S.%(9@IH64�MFH6.7K%46L546D-CB.9T�EF.%,[email protected](+*-194S2M4S.%(346D-CB.dT (9.7(B,-4619D/La46,-.%(3.9T��#85,0�46Y78M,/D-8�,Z@IK%4S.%(34�T+(985H|H6.7,/.P46(+*-8M(%*/.³0�4[EF.%,-(346,/8�13("@BV9@7D-8<DU4QLa13,Z@P8\0�8ai9(94 */4SY�@B�#85,¯HQ@BCB@I*-8MCB@I*-4QL5@9:

¯46CG@I(903@7(90�.³@74[*-8�Dc*/4�La4S*/@I*-4��34U 1¼@lY�@7(%*/4|�#85,~K%HS4A@7�3�3,/.IEF.%(90�46CJ8M(+*-4A0�4�¢+138MDU*-8<*/85CG@�*/46LZ�987T"@B(9.74|46(+*-8a�,/8MD/D-@PDU.%HS.BDU.7*U*/.7H64S(38�@I,/8=L5.7CB8=(385Hse��%k3e7T�i6$ �� % d�eg�7�� kMUeM¤%�+]��ZeM�+X�ODT �"8M,-Y%85(3(98=@%0­13("@J034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I2M4S.%(380�4AL5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@J�"8M,~4SH�L5@IHQLa.%HS.J�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH68=8\LZ�387T90313,/@7(+*-8�K7H64|@I(3(94|Y78M(%*/4�T��~46HSV#85,-*~8<4AD-13.74|L5.7H6H6@7V".7�,Z@�*-.%,-4�T#*-,Z@³4s¢+19@7HS4 �!��#"����#$ �=d'� h��7���$ H�)�) MUeM¤%�7§��ZeM�%§%k_T TTe H>�� _=���)H��7�VMUeM¤7¤%¤��ZeM��]7]3T:Y½8G@IHS*-,/4DU*-190�46.%D-43*/,/@<L5134�T�A"�)6���A) � ��>�$VH�)�) MUeM�7f%>��se��%X%]BT�8��H�h��A>����w�����(���H�)��kMUeM�7f%¤��ZeM�%>3eETSYP.I*-*-8M(3(38a�,/.RY�@I,/4h,-4QDU19H *Z@�*-4h0�4|L5.+8M,-8M(32M@\8=0�4[L5.7CB�3H68a*-8M252�@P0�4h�9@7,U*/4[0�85H6H�´ @I,/4S*-CB8a*/46LM@<EF.7,/CG@IH64S2M2M@I*/@R@7H"�9,-46CB.P.%,/0�46(38%TCB85(+*-,/87T�(38MH�e��%kI¤9T���4SH6V"8M,U*P8­¨�L� %85,/CB@7(3(��313V3V9HS4QL5@7,-.%(3.½4SH �3,/4SCB.¼CG@I(�19@7HS8³034 H6.7K%46LM@ CG@I*-85CG@I*-4QL5@½46(H64S(38�@BLa.7(ºH68�@I*U*/19@IH64[4SCB�#.%DU*/@72546.7(34 �7�%:s�~8MH�eM�7>%f3T��O>��# � k�A������MUeM�%f7§��ZeM��]�¤dT�0�46CJ.+Dc*/,l [email protected]�3H68a*/85252�@0�8MH|L5@IHQLa.%HS.B0�8M4|�3,/8M0�4QL5@I*-4|0�8MH[�3,-46CB.B.7,Z0�4S(98 � ��8�H�´ @7(3(3.GD-85K71985(+*-8�46H|La85H685V9,-8=*-8M.7,/85CG@J0�4|46(9La.%CJ�9HS85*-852M2M@9T�3,/.7V9@7V346HSCB85(+*/8¯4SH#�34U 1G4SCB�#.7,-*/@I(+*/8~,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/.\0�85H6H6@\HS.%K74QL5@�CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@�� � T�LZ�38~�9@�*/,/@�H68�D-138�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(32M8LZ�38³ 8\4SCB�#.%D/DU46V346HS8J0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@7,-8RH6@³L5.�85,/85(32�@³0�4�13(�D-46DU*-8MCB@­@IV3V9@%Dc*Z@I(32�@G�#.I*-8M(+*-8PL5.7(½CB8a*/.�0�4 4S(+*-8M,-(94�@IHD-46DU*-8MCB@�Dc*/8MD/DU.�8­H�´ 46(9La.%CB�3HS85*-8M252M@�0�85H6HQ@¼H6.7K74QL5@�0�85HbDU8�La.%(90�.¼.%,/0�46(38 MF8 034_.%,/034S(38ºDU19�"8M,-46.7,/8ETa: �s@I(3(9.@IH6CB85(3. La4S*/@�*/4�Th46(3.7HS*-,/87T#46H�L5.7(+*-,/4SV91�*-.­0385H_eM�3elXB0�4 %'���(���A��� %?k��3��)�"����$ MUeM¤+]I¤��ZeM�+X%]3T 46H�¢+19@7HS8%T#D-85�3��313,J19D/@I(903.¼13(9@½H6.7K%46LM@¼LZ�38­@7CBCJ85*U*/8³EF.7,/CR19HS8º0�4 H613(3K%�3852M2M@½46(�i9(94 *Z@�D-13HSHQ@¼D/La4Q@¼0�8MHSH�´ 46(+*-8M,-�3,/8a*Z@I2M4S.%(380�8M4b¢+19@7(+*-4Si"L5@I*-.7,/4 034 g LZ�3,��.+0�85,B�1I�Ts0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@�LZ�38­.%K7(34 EF.7,/CR19H6@�DU.�030�4QDUE�@7La46V346HS8� 8 D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8 4S(·13(0�.%CJ46(346.½i9(34S*-.�.¼(�13CB85,Z@IV346HS8%TA*/85.%,-8MCB@½LZ�98GEF1°�#.74�,/46�3,-8�DU.½8 @703@I*U*/@I*-.¼@7HSHQ@½H6.7K74QL5@½0385H��9,-46CB.¼.7,Z0�46(3803@��a"�����HA��� c����A����$ Mce�¤7¤�]��ZeM�7§+kBTa:���1�*-*-4 K7H64�DU*-19034S.+DU4�i9(3.%,/@³L54 *Z@�*/4��"@I(3(3. La.7(+*/,-46V3134S*-."ThLZ�94��34U 1�LZ�34CB85(3."T�@IH6HQ@�L5.7(�i9K%13,[email protected](98­@�*-*-19@7HS8 0�85K%HS4¯DU*-19034~0�4bHS.%K74QL5@¼CG@I*-85CG@I*-4QL5@3:°?�@�0346DU*-46(32546.7(98­*/,/@�*-8M.7,/46@�8CB8a*Z@�*-8M.7,/46@9T3*/,/@ DU46(+*/@7D/D-4A8PD-85CG@7(%*/46LM@3T9*-,Z@³4�Yl@7,-4�HS46Y78MHSH64�HS.%K74QLa4ACG@I*-13,� .³H685(+*/@7CJ8M(+*-8R46(�¢+138�Dc*/.­�#85,/4S.�0�.XmHQ@BK7,Z@I( �9@I,-*-8\0385K7H64ADU*-19034S.+DU4 M1n3,/85K%87T9� 8M4S,ZLa8%T g LZ�3,��.%0385,�T9� 8M@7(3.9T3¯1"D-D-85H6H�T#?��.�� 8M(3�38546C T g %.7H685C�T¯@703.I*U*� .13(9@ H6.7K%46LM@ �34U 1�,-4QL5LM@º034 ¢+1385H6HQ@½0�85H �3,-46CB.½.7,Z0�46(387©\.¼@7HSCB8M(3.¼0�85H_DU8�La.%(90�.½.7,Z0�46(387T�.½4S(3i9(34S*/@I,/4Q@kM�La.%(8MD-�3,/8MD/DU46.7(94¯4S(�i"(34 *Z@ICB85(+*/8½HS13(9K7�38KT :¦?�@�HS.%K74QL5@�0�8MH~�3,/4SCB.�.7,Z0�46(38 85CB85,ZD-8¼La.7( 46H~*-8�Dc*/.°0�4���4SH6V"8M,U* 8¨�L� %85,/CG@I(3(|T�L5.7(�4_H6@lY%.7,/4�0�4 g 7.%HS8MC 46(�*/85.7,/4Q@¼0�85K%HS4 4S("DU4685CB4�Ts8­D-.7�3,Z@�*-*-1�*-*-.�L5.7(�4bLa4S*/@I*-4 *-85.%,-8MCB4_0�4La.%CB�3HS85*-8M252M@R8<0�4h4S(9L5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@P034[Ã��.+0�85H�:��~8MH�eM�7>%§<46H#H6.7K%46L5.R�#.7HQ@7LMLa.����#�#������ H������7�MUeM�7f+kl�ZeM�%¤7>_T�3,/8MD-85(+*l .½HQ@¼0�85i9(3462546.7(38 DU8MCB@7(+*-4QL5@½0�4_Y78M,-4S*l @ CG@�*/85CG@�*/46LM@½LZ�38­L5.%DU*-4S*-134QD-L58³46H La.%,-.%(9@ICB8M(%*/.½0�4_¢+138�Dc*Z@E�@7D-8�0�8MK7H64"DU*-19034"H6.7K%46L543(385H6HQ@R¢+19@IH68~D-.7(3.RDU*/@I*-4"85HQ@IV#.7,Z@�*-494#L5.7(9L58a*U*/498�HS8¯*/8ML5(346LZ�98�LZ�38~E�@7(3(3.R09@\DU19�3�".%,U*/.@IK%HS4|@7,-K%.7CB85(+*/4hLZ�98�@3b#,/.7(+*/85,/85CB.P(985HAD-85K%134 */.9:

� ��� �N#!�: �� #?���� � �C�@ @� �O�"� �A�! ! ¬#"B�[���9��������+ � ��� ��#!"��$7�$'<La.%(%*/,-46V31�*/4 0�4¯¥�:9�¼@7(3K746.7(98G4S(°?�:�Ã=8�%�CB.7("@�*MT'&�M -]. :Z2= �KN4��^KQUTY :�KQ.�- ��4�-/YN-S�;�- KOY�; :�KNU�MP:��;N-�Ts] ��.%HSH�:STÃ�@I,/2M@7(+*-4�T �¼4SHQ@I(3."T|eM��]Ik3:�\: g LZ�3.7H627T(&M -]. :�21 KQ4�4Z2 4�-98�:P;Q23T�?A@�*/85,/2M@9T3^_@7,-4�TheM�%¤7>3:) :6T ��:(*�(38�@IH687T(&�M -]. :Z21 �KN4 4�2�4�-]8�:P;Q23T�¡�4S("@I190�4�T2��.7,/4S(3."T[eM��]Ik�:+":3^ .�LZ�38M(9D, +4�T�5A2 4�-98#:<;N2?\P-/.1032/4�KlT9k���.%HSH�:ST"¡s46(9@I19034�T2��.7,/4S(9.9T[eM��]Ik3:Â<:9^_HQ@I(9LZ�$#87T 5A2 4�-98#:<;N2�K64�2�Y�-�2�Y M -/.1:�2 �2 S .1:ZY M -�M KQ4�K=2/.0- Y YQKN4 4�T3¿~V9@7H6034S(34�T9¯.%CG@3T|e��+]�>9:�\: ' : g *21U@I23 +46(|T�&M -]. :�21 KQ4�4Z2 4�-98�:P;Q23T�¡�0�4S*-.%,-4|¯4613(34S*-4�T"Â~.7CG@3T[e��7¤7f9:��g e *Lj k�lBmRnEoGmG.+s -�m 4�m~k�.+m |Es�o�3�K �0E*C0�*H�~./�"5;*,�&#&>�>t*C0�*T%(�$F/�&#�*,%�%�#�0"����%B0E*H'�*54Ul�i$p7698Ui;:�q�<�p�maP�]D^_d_^LfR]Dd_^ �BYE]� y # ]>=�#&�&O ����0t83? ](�[!A@/����5;*,%(%�8�B J -5.@p 4�C-Bl�q6pBq J s D�q�k J q$s?mR|En�D(qH. D�kEl/mFE,8�!��(��#&%�F/���t8S>������&#&%�8:]DdHG_^(]� "�I ]�J+A./'(�$�?8-h # #&�bzN./�&�& "0DA*,%�'�#&FH@/��# 0Q'(�$�Q� #(#&./56��'����Q�&./F/#& �!�Z���% @+1�%�@�0"#&./%+*,�K@,*,�K@:A1��& "i�87Lvk�.@o/s?| D(q NEs�q�N�C- J Lvo/sGD(qtrHo/s?mFE- .@p

M D5Q/|EmKEje;NGP)]Dd_e �BYE8@����]Se�`sdLf eHO � �+0"�E*,'�](# 0t]+%(�$�&� f *,%B0"./�&./F/#M*�*H!�1��E*X'�# , ]��Q*, E*,�"#?8�!�# 0E*C0�*H%����&�M*HO(#&O��&#&./F/�E*C\@*(]� C�P-�E*,'�](# 0t](#&%�! ] JT]�!�Z+*,%�@/���TP~*H!�1���*H'�# YE8RQEj�s�qEk J qtrHoDp/mSB�CkBpBqtj TVUA.@o;r�qt|�|7oDo NI-(ktn�kB8S@+�E*,%�!�.VW:1�>�>�#&.�8=@J*,'�.$A/*(8?]Dd_d[]/]� K�!���!$./%('�.L�� " E*61�%w9�1+*,%�0"# \+!$*C0"./����1�%(# AB�$�" E*,�&�)��9�1(# A/*,�&��*�1(%+*6!$./%(F/#&1�%�>�#&./%���#&%(\�%�# 0E*6�)1�%w9�1+*,%B0�# \+!$*C0"./������ "#& "0"�$%(>$#M*,�&�

*H1�%�*H'�#& �F/#&1(%�>�#&./%��<#&%(\+%�# 0�*LP~*,%�!EZ��X��#"31G!EZ��)%�1�56���E*,O�#&�&�tYE]

Page 13: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

e�>¥�: �¼@7(3K746.7(987T g :9^_.72M254�T(&�M -/.1:�2 �KQ4�4�2 4�-98#:<;N2����=23�V-�-]4�Kg2/:�8#:�-/.1U�:U�-/Y M<. :�T9Ã�@7,-2�@I(+*-4�T �½4SHQ@I(9.9T[eM�%�7>9:��: �¼13K7(9@74:M�@BLa19,/@B0�48T T�572 4�-]8�:P;Q2 #2�57KN:��/U�:�� 2�+�.�K 8�KlT3?A.+8�D-LZ�985,�T���.7,/46(3.9TheM�%¤%k3:¡~:"¥_@%D-@7,-4�M�@GLa13,Z@P034gTaTT5A2 4�-98#:<;N2 �KN4�U�-�/K9;NKNU�M -�T�?A.+8�D-LZ�985,�T���.7,/46(3.9TheM�%¤3e%:¡~:"¥_@%D-@7,-4�M�@GLa13,Z@P034gTaT�=2/4�4Z2 4�-98�:P;Q2�2/4�4�2 0 K/M 2/4�-98#:<;N2�T g @7(9DU.%(34�TRn�46,/85(32M87T[eM��]��9:g : ��@I,Z@7L5LZ�946@9T��[.�K��]K6Y M -/.1:�2 KQ4�4Z2 4�-98�:P;Q2�2RU�MP:<;N2�T�¡s19,-.%CB@I� ?�@JÃ=.%HS4Q@I,Z0�4QL5@9T�Â~.7CG@3T[e��7¤+]�:¥�: �¼@7(3K746.7(987T ��:-n9,/@7(9LZ�385H6HQ@3T�57K/M M,-R.NK& :A57-98#:<;N2�T�?A¡ rw¡�034S2M4S.%(34�TA�¼4SHQ@I(3."T[eM�%�7>3:��:b^_.7,/K%@3T¯� :Zn3,/85K%13K7H646@9T!rR:b��@IH6HQ@70�46(3.9T2� ;�-]U�M<. :�� -�M<:g\P-]U #2 � :�-/UT2/4�:& �KN4 4�2,YB;3-#-/4Z2 :w�'K�2/U�-�Tpn3,Z@I(9L5.¨~(9K785H64�T �½46H6@7(3.9T[e��7¤%X3:¡~:A�¼.7,/46L5.7(34�T�5A2 M K -]. :Z21 �KN4 4�2 :�03-RYBMP.Q2��B:�-]U�Kw :�� : 4�� KQ.9MUT9^_46V3HS46.7�#.7H64QD5T3��@I�#.7H64�T|e��7¤�]�:g :�ÃJ: g �9@7(� 78M,�M�@BLa13,Z@B0�48T T�� 4 M KB-].�KQ0321 :����-h �KQ4�:�¿~(9@BCB8MD/D/@P@PEF13.�La."TRn3,Z@I(9L5.��½13252M4S."T3��@70�.�Y�@9T"e��7�3e%:ÃJ:9?A.7H6HS4�T?� U;N-/0&��4�K/M K����92��'&�2]8�8�:�-?Y3-���-R. M����-h �KQ4�T3')H+�½13H646(3.9T9^_.%HS.%K7(9@9T#e��7�+k�:!�� "�����3�����7���#���_���M�3 ����3���½���_�"���+��½�9���!"�����3 �� $ÃJ: ) :9?|8M4SV3(94S2%T�&�;1. : M M<:; :�4�-98�:P;Q23T3k ��.%HSH�:6T9?A@I*-85,/2M@9T�^_@7,-4�T[eM�%�%k3:ÃJ:9^_.�.7H687T?� U7 �2]8�:�U�K6Y3-R4 4�K 4�KQ8 8#:� �KQ4 �^KQUTY :�KQ.�-�T3¡�4S(9@7190�4�T2�A.%,-46(3."T#e��+]I§3:¥�: g :9� 8546,ZLa87T�&�; .1: M MP:j :�4�-98#:<;N2�T�?A@B��13.�Y�@P' *Z@IH646@9TRn�4S,/85(32M87T|e��7¤9e7:ÃJ:-n9,-8MK787T�5^-98#:<;N2�Kg2/. : M<0 K]MP:<;N2�T3^_.7,/4S(9K7�34685,/4�T-��.7,/4S(9.9T[eM�%§%X3:ÃJ:-n9,-8MK787T�S 4 4�Ka-]. : 8�:�U�:U �KQ4�4Z2�U�-#-��2 4�-]8�:P;Q23T�^_.%,-46(3K7�94S8M,-4�T-�A.%,-46(3.9T[e��7¤%>3:ÃJ:-n9,-8MK787T(&�;1. :PM1M<: �^-/Y M -R0�:�T9^_.7,/4S(9K7�34685,/4�T-��.7,/4S(9.9TheM�%¤7§3:ÃJ:-n9,-8MK787T�.V:<;�KQ. ; J�K 4�-]8�:P; J�KlT3Ã=138M,-46(34|8<¨�D/D-.�L546@I*-4�TA�½46H6@7(3.9T[e��7¤7¤9:¨\: �\:�)��34S*-85�98M@70|T"^=:"¯1"D-D-85H6H�T�� U�MP.N-� (-��B:�-]U�K=2R:� �'.1:�U;1:���:�2�L 2 MPJ�KQ032 MP:<;N2!�T3?A@G�~19.�Yl@B' *Z@IH646@9T-n�4S,/85(92587TeM��]7]�:rP:(�~46HSV#85,-*MT�. :<;�KQ. ; J�K6Y�- :�\P-]U7 �2/0 KQU�M<:� KQ4�4Z2�032 M KQ032 MP:<;N2�T3^_46V3HS46.7�#.7H64QD5T3��@I�#.7H64�T|e��7¤+X�:?s: ¡~: +":3^ ,/.71��_85,�T#5^K"� :�-/U�:�Y�- 4 4�# :�U�M -R:$�B:�-]U�:�Y10 -�T9^_.7,/46(3K7�34685,/4�T���.7,/46(3.9TheM�%¤7>9:! ¸�"Pªa�h�Ml�A�����7���"���b�3 � �� ����"®� ��+�����M��$&%�� �M�� � ��������M��������� � ��� ��"!#��$%�$¡~:3¨�K%@725254:M�@GLa13,Z@J0�4gTaT�57-]8�:P;Q2 032 M KQ032 MP:<;N2�K 4�-98#:<;N2&��4�-/YN-S��;Q2�T3?�@ g La13.%H6@9T3^_,-8�D-L546@9T#e��7�%f3:¡~:3¨�K%@725254�T�5A2 4�-98#:<;N2 Y1: 0'��-/4 :P;Q23T3?A@ g L513.7HQ@3T3^_,/8MD/La4Q@3T[eM�%¤7�9:¨�¨R: � �R:6T)(a4�K"�B:�-]U�:� :�4�-98�:P;Q23TRn3,Z@I(9L5.��¼13252M4S."T3��@70�.�Y�@3The��7�7f9:��: ?s:-r=@IH6HQ@G¥ �946@7,/@9T�5^-98#:<;N2�T�' g ¡ r�' TA�½46HQ@I(3."T[eM�+]�O9:��@7.�)�@7(3K9T��=2/4�4Z2 032 M KQ032 MP:<;N2O2/4�4Z2<��4�-/YN-S�T23T3^_.7,/4S(3K%�34685,/4�T-��.7,/4S(3."TheM�7¤7O9:ÃJ:9?A.7H6HS4�T�5A2 032�; ; J�: U�2�K64�K& :�03-RYBMP.Q2��B:�-]U�:�T�')H+�½13H646(3.9T9^_.%HS.%K7(9@9T#e��7¤�]�:ÃJ:9?A.7H6HS4�T�*f-/Y+#-,K 4�2 4�-]8�:P;Q2 032 M KN032 M<:P;Q23TRn3,Z@I(9L5.��¼13252M4S."T3��@70�.�Y�@3The��7�%k3:n_:|^_85H6HS4QD-D-46CB@9TA� :[��@IK%HS4�T�5A2.�]KN.1: M,2 M<.N2RY10 KNY Y 2�� 5A2 4�-98�:P;Q2 2 M1M<.N2/�]KN. YN-�4�K �: 0 -/Y M<.N2 � :�-/U�:70O2�M KN0O2�M<:P; J�KlTg @7(9DU.%(34�TRn�46,/85(32M87T[eM�%�7>9:ÃJ:9?A.7H6HS4�T�* 2$��:�.�K - UT2 : 0 -RYBMP.Q2��B:�-]U�K�T�')H+�½13H64S(3."T9^_.7H6.7K%(9@3TheM�%¤7¤9:ÃJ:9?A.7H6HS4�T�* 2$��:�.�KV4�2 032 M KN032 M<:P;Q23T�')H��½13H646(3.9T9^_.%HS.%K7(9@9T"e��7�7§9:! ¹ "B�|�� _����"®� ����°�¼���+�10 �"�����3�°���h�M�_���� � ��������M���°������$%�$¡~:"¥_@%D-@7,-4�T)2 -#KNY M<:�-]U�:� : ��4�-/YN-S�T21 �KN4 4�2�032 M KN032 M<:P;Q23TRn38MH */,-46(385H6H64�T �¼4SHQ@I(3."T[eM�%§7>3:¡~:"¥_@%D-@7,-4�M�@GLa13,Z@P034gTaTT5A23��4�-/YN-S��2 �KN4 4�2 032 M KN032 M<:P;Q2 �KN43# (�4�4+T g @I(9D-.7(94�TRn�46,-8M(3258%T|eM��]�>3:¨\:h¥_@I(+*-46(34:M�@GL513,Z@J034gTaT�� \P-/U7 #2R03KNU�M<:� �KN4 4�2 0O2�M KN0O2�M<:P;Q23T9?|.�8MD/LZ�38M,MT-��.7,/4S(3."TheM�+]I�3:¥�:#¥ 8MHSH619L5L54:M�@GL513,/@B0�48T TT5A23��4�-/YN-S�T21 �KQ4�4�2 032�M KQ032�M<:P;Q2�T3?�@�*/85,/2M@3T3^b@7,-4�TheM�7§�]�:��:�^_.7,/K%@9TKn_:/n319,-46(3K7�98a*U*/4�M�@=La13,Z@�034gTaT'� 4���.�-5�/4�KQ0325 KQ:�\P-]U7 �2/0 KQU�M<:� �KN4 4�2 0O2�M KN0O2�M<:P;Q23TI¡_¥ 'UÃJTIÃ=85(3.�Y�@9TeM�%¤7§9:��:9^_.%,-K+@3T&rR:#��@IH6H6@%0�46(3.9T)6[4 M<.�K6: 4�0�: M - �KN4 4�2 ;1. :�Y1:��f+�-/U7 #2/0 KNU�MP:7K ��4�-/YN-S�T21 �KN4 4�2�032 M KN032 M<:P;Q2 U�KN4)787YNK9;N-/4�-�T�?A@ g La19.7HQ@3T3^_,-8�D-L546@9T[eM�%�+]�:! �0"P«w�3�[���3 ��b��� ��"!#��$%� ! ���3�_� �:9� �� ����°���h�M�3l� �3�_���:9�Å$7�#��� ����M��� ">$¡~: +":3?|85CBCB.7(AT�;f4�KQ0 KQU�M<:; :�4�-98�:P;Q23T�?A@�*/85,/2M@9T�^b@7,-4�T[eM�%¤7§3:) :(��.�03K78MDMT�57-]8�:P;Q23T�Ã�@7,-2�@I(+*-4�T[eM�%¤7§9:' : ��:#¥ .7�94�T"¥�:#¥ .%�385(AT?� U�MP.N-� (-��B:�-]U�Kg2/4�4�2 4�-98#:<;N2�T�')H��½19HS46(3.9T"^ .%HS.%K7(9@­eM�%�+]�:��:�ÃJ:9^_19LZ�385,�T?� U�M<.�-� (-��B:�-]U�K62R4 4�2 4�-]8�:P;Q2�T"¥_?�¿�¡ ^�T3^_.%HS.%K7(9@9T#e��7�%§3:��: �¼.7(903@%0�.7,/4�T �°:-rR´ ¨~K%.%DU*-46(3.9T�5^-98#:<;N2�T�^_,-13(9.��¼.7(903@%0�.7,/4�T �¼4SHQ@I(3."T|eM�%�+]�:

Page 14: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

e5O¡~:3^_8M(9La46Y78M(3K%@9T�� 4���.1:�0 - 4 :��/.�- �:�4�-]8�:P;Q23T�^_.%,-46(3K7�94S8M,-4�T-�A.%,-46(3.9T[e��7¤7O9:?s:2�¼@IK%(9@I(34�T�Â<:"Ã=8M(3(9@I,/4�T�L 2/U�-�2R4�Kw :�4�-98#:<;N2��^57-]8�:P;Q23;14�2RY Y :P;Q2�K< �KN4�YQKNU�YN-O;�-]0 -RU�KlT9Ã=1985,/4S(34�T �½46HQ@I(3."TeM�%�+]�:��:9^_.%,-K+@3T+;f4�KQ0 KQU�M<:; :�4�-98�:P;Q2 032 M KQ032 MP:<;N2�T3¡s19,-.%CB@I� ?�@PÃ=.%HS4Q@I,Z0�4QL5@3T�¯.%CG@3T[eM�%¤IO":ÃJ:9?A.7H6HS4�T?� U�M<.�-? �-��B:�-]U�Kg2R4 4�2 4�-]8�:P;Q2 \P-]. 0O2R4�K�T�')H��½13H646(3.9T3^_.7H6.7K%(9@3The��7�3e%:��:9��85K%,-4�T�;f4�KQ0 KQU�MP:� :�57-]8�:P;Q23T�¡ 0�462546.7(34|?�¡jrPT �½46H6@7(3.9T[e��7�IO":��:9^_.%,-K+@3T�+�-]U #2/0 KQU�MP:j :�4�-98#:<;N2�T�¨~(3K%85H64�T2�½4SHQ@I(9.9T[eM�%�%X3:¡~:A�¼85(90�8MH6D-.7(AT�� U�M<.�-? �-��B:�-]U�K62/4�4�2 4�-98#:<;N2?032�M KQ032�M<:P;Q2�T"^ .%,-46(3K%�34S8M,-4�T��A.%,-46(3.9T[e��+]7k�:+": Â<: g �3.�85(�i"85HQ0[T�57-]8�:P;Q2 032 M KN032 M<:P;Q23T3^_.7,/4S(3K%�34685,/4�T-��.7,/4S(3."TheM�7¤9e7:¡~:"¥_@%D-@7,-4�T 5�:�U�K�2R0 KQU�M<:j �:�4�-]8�:P;Q2 032 M KN032 M<:P;Q23TRn38MH */,-46(385H6H64�T �¼4SHQ@I(3."T[eM�+XI�3:¡~:"¥_@%D-@7,-4�Th� U�M<.�-? �-��B:�-]U�Kg2R4 4�2 4�-]8�:P;Q2�T�¿L�¯¡X��TJ��.7,/4S(9.9TheM�%�+]�:¥�:J��.3bh.7HQ@I,/4�T�� :"¥ 46(+*-46.7H64�T�5^-98#:<;N2 L 2�M KN0O2�M<:P;Q23TA�¼L\Ã=,/@��b� �~46H6H�T �½46H6@7(3.9T9k7f7f%f3:

Page 15: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ������� �

� � � �� ��� � � � � �p�� � � � ���

elX

Page 16: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-
Page 17: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ����� ������

� � ���<� �� � �p� � ������� � �� ��� �

� � � �p�� � � � ���

����� � �p��� ��#Z� �� ��i �N#!����� �B� ���! "�������@ �~8MHSHQ@JHS.%K74QL5@R�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH687T�La.7CB8<D-4� 8=0�85*U*/.J(985H6H6@}� 254@Pc4L')'@0�T9D-4[@I(9@7HS46252�@I(3.J4[,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-4"(3854|¢[email protected](3.³L5.746(+Y%.7HS*-8<�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34|L5.7CB�".+Dc*/8\CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8\�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34|DU8MCB�3HS4QLa4 M�D-85(32�@³@I("@IH64S2M2M@I,/8�4�L5.7(+*-8M(+13�*-4¯46(+*-8M,-(34~034�¢+138MDU*-8º13HS*-46CJ8KTLm~H68 �3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34¯La.7CB�#.%DU*-8 DU.%(3.�.I*U*/85(�1�*/8¼03@IH6HS8º�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34¯DU8MCB�3HS4QLa4CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8=>)</9-9S4"(+(+.8W`.pW/4"2G<�� �)*&[email protected]<39;0/7U. T�Yl@7HS8 @½0�4S,/8³.%�"8M,/@I*-.7,/4sD-1��9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34 LZ�38G�9@I(9(3.½H6@�DU8MK7138M(%*/8�3,/.7�3,/468a*l @9©�46H|Y�@IH6.7,/8�0�4[Y78M,-4S*l @J0�85H6H68<�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94hL5.7CB�#.%DU*-8=.I*U*/85(�1�*/8�*-,Z@ICB4 */8�8MD/DU4|0�46�#85(90�8\D-.7H6.B03@I4:Mc 8EF13(32M4S.%(38\0�8M4gT_Y�@IH6.7,/4[0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @J0385H6HS8��3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34|La.%CB�".%(385(+*-4�:

'�L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�4sD-4��".+D-D-.7(9.º0�4QDU*-46(3K7138M,-8B46(�V"@7D-8B@7H�(�13CB85,/.º0�4s@7,-K%.7CB85(+*/4�©�¢+1385H6HS4sLZ�98BD-4s@I�9�3HS4QL5@7(3. @13(9@RDU.%H6@=�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38¯DU.%(3.\0�85*U*-4 PQ<39;<��^0/2IAd</Pc4"9X(h037l. T�¢+1385H6HS4#LZ�38~D-4"@I�9�3HS4QL5@7(3.\@<0�138��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(943DU.%(3.0�85*U*-4 �". �^032IA_<3PQ4@9-(\0/7U. T~¢%1985H6HS4~LZ�38½D-4�@I�9�3HS4QL5@7(3.�@�*/,-8 �3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34 (+2L. �^0/2IAd</Pc4"9X(h037l. T�:5:M:5T_4S(ÅK78M(385,Z@IH689 �^032IAd</Pc4"9X(h037l.#¢+138MHSH64ALZ�38<D-4A@I�9�3HS4QL5@7(3.B@����3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34 � :

��4�DU.%(3.JD-.7H6.G¢+19@�*-*-,/.P�#.%D/DU46V346HS4�La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4ACJ.%(3.%@7,-K%.7CB85(+*Z@IH64�� � T�� � T�� � 8�� � ©� �3®��� � �� �����

� � � M � T � � M � T � � M � T � � M � T� � � � �� � � � �

g .%HS.�� �  8BDU46K7(34Si"LM@�*-46Y7. M�� � 8�� � �9@7(3(3.ºY�@IH6.7,/8JL5.%DU*/@I(+*/87T[46(90�46�"8M(90�85(+*/8³03@IH�Y�@IH6.7,/8P034sY78M,-4S*l @ 0�4 � TCB85(+*-,/8�� � HQ@7D/La4Q@ 4S(�Y�@I,/46@I*-.¼46H_Yl@7HS.%,-8³034 � T © � � M � T<�9@�Yl@7HS.%,-8­.7�3�#.%DU*-.�@�¢%1985H6HS.�0�4 � :=r=@�*/.�LZ�38�� �46(+Y%85,-*-8�46H[Yl@7HS.%,-8<0�4AY785,/4S*l @3Th 8<0�85*U*/. 9;[email protected]</9;45T38<�#85,¯8�D-D-.GDU4[19D/@J4SH�DU46CRV#.7H6. !_: g 4|�9@G¢+1346(90�4�©� ! �� �� �

')H~D-4SCPV".%HS."! D-4¯H685K7K%8 oU(3.%(-q3Ts�#.74QLZ�$#8%T�(38MH¯HS46(3K%19@IK%K746.�La.%CR13(987T� 8º�9,-.%�3,-46.¼*/,/@7CB4 */8½H6@�(385K+@I2M4S.%(38oU(9.7(-qJLZ�38\0�4AD-.7H64S*-.BDU4|46(�Y78M,U*/8=46H[Y�@IH6.7,/8<0�4|Y78M,-4S*l @J0�4|19(º8M(�13(9La4Q@�*/.9:

¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/4Q@ICB.�.%,/@�4¯�".+D-D-46V34SH64~La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4~Y78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS4_V34Q@I,/K7.%CJ8M(+*/@IH64�:·¡�D/D-4bD-.7(9.·e�§3: g 8 4S(��0�4QLZ�34Q@ICB.�La.%( � 8$# 4<0�198�@I,/K7.%CB85(+*-4�8�La.%(%� � T\:5:M:5T&� � � 4=D-8M0�4QLa4�La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4�T=DU4=�9@�H6@·DU8MK7138M(%*/8*/@7V"8MHSHQ@ � ©����% O+*, "��*,�&�M*v'(��\�%�#&>�#&./%��w'�#xAB�$�".�f?�R1�%�>�#&./%+*,�&# 0C3* 3�:#&%�'�# ` ������%B0��D!$./%( �#&'����E*,�"�:1�%d!�./%�%��70"0"# AB.a!�./56�:1�%d./�@�$��*C0�./�"�:�~��*

���"./� ./ "#&>�#&./%�#XP~*$AB��%B0��w!�./56�D*,��F/./56��%�0".v'����&�&�D���"./� ./ "#&>�#&./%�#b�L!�./56�LA/*,�&./�"�D1�%�*v���"./�@./ �#&>�#&./%��:!�./56�@./ "0�*BYH.4!�./56�G1�%+*�R1�%�>�#&./%��)*$AB��%B0��X �#M*X!�./56�<*,��F/./56��%B0�#?8( �#M*H!�./56�[A,*,�&./��#?8�# A/*,�&./�"#�'�# AB�$�"# 0,3*(' �*)<]^ C ���&�&�[0�*,O ���&�&�/8+�@���bO(���7A(# 0C3*(8+ "!$�"# A(#M*,56.(+-,�*,%�>�#&!EZS��.+-,EP0/*132)YE]

e�]

Page 18: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

eM¤� �3®��� � �� �����

� # � � � � � � � � � � � � � I � � � � � ��� � �C� � ��� � ��� � ��� � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

g 8b*/,/@%D-L513,-4Q@ICB.�4"L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�49LZ�98~�9@I(9(3.<13(GY�@IH6.7,/8¯La.%DU*/@7(+*-87T%4S("0�4S�#85("0�85(+*-8�03@<¢+1385H6HS4#0�4 � 8&# M�L54S.9 8� � 8 � � � T Th8J¢+138MHSH64 LZ�38JD-4�,-4Q0�19L5.7(3.º@70 � T[. @ #­Th.º@7HSH68RH6.7,/.³(38MK%@I2M4S.%(34 M � � 8 � � T � �$� 8 � �t� T Th,/8MDU*/@7(3.0�468ML54ALa.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4[V346@7,-K%.7CB85(+*Z@IH64hD-46K7(34Si"L5@I*-46Y�4�©� �3®��� � �� �����

� # � � � � � � � I � � � � � ��� � �$� � ��� � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �

¥ .7("La85(+*/,[email protected],Z@³HQ@³(9.%DU*-,Z@³@�*-*-85(92546.7(38BDU194��3,/46CJ4�L54S(9¢+138VMF4�D-8MLa.%(90�4 La46(9¢+138BDU4��".+D-D-.7(9.­.I*-*-8M(385,/803@74[�3,-46CB4|@�*-*-,Z@lY785,ZD-.\H6@P(38MK%@I2M4S.%(387© (38MK%@7(90�.�� � DU4[.7*U*-4685(98 � � � T�(385K+@I(90�.�� � D-4[.I*U*/4S8M(38�� ��� T�8<La.+D)  $"Y�4Q@_T :� � � M � #�T=�9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8J0�4�Y%85,/4 *� @�� ¢+19@7(90�.½@IH6CB85(3.º13(9@ 0�8MHSH68G0�138B�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34 � 8�# �9@ Y�@IH6.7,/8

��T�8M0Å�9@�Y�@7HS.%,-8 �d¢+19@7(90�.°8M(%*/,/@7CRV#8 � 8 #N�9@I(9(3.°Y�@IH6.7,/8 ��: � � M � #NT­DU4=0�46L58 ,3.g' AB.8*&[email protected]<39;4­.0/7U(h4@2L9;03(I.8W/0VM 9;<39 4L'@>@7l*D'L.8WK0`T�034 � 8P034 # M � 8 #¶D-.7(3.³4!,3.g' AB.8*&9-(+.UTLmA�"8M,=L5.7CB.�0�4 *� @3T[@I(9254QLZ� #8�� � M � #NTD/La,/4SY�4Q@ICB. ��� #­T�4S(+*-,/.�0�19L585(90�.P4SH[D-4SCPV".%HS. � �#85,bH6@P0�4QDUK%4S13(92546.7(38%:K��@IH68�D-46CRV#.7H6.PD-4#H685K%K78ioU._q9T7�#.74QLZ�$#8%T(38MH#H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.RL5.7CP13(387T��#85,b46(90�4QL5@I,/8�LZ�38�,/4 */85([email protected],/@<19(9@R�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(38=La.%CJ�#.%DU*/@P0�4[0�138<¢+19@I("0�.@IH6CB85(3.<19(9@P 8¯Y78M,/@9T�19DU4Q@ICB. o-._q�. oU.7�9�313,/8`q=(385H"DU8M(9DU.<0�4 WK4@7 : g 43�"@<@IH6HS.%,/@�H6@<D-85K%1385(+*/8b*/@lY7.%H6@=0�43Y%85,/4 *� @�#85,~HQ@B0�46D-K74613(32M4S.%(387©

� # ��� #� � �� � �� � �� � �

� � � M � #NT<�"@ Y�@7HS.%,-8G0�4 Y785,/4S*l @ � ¢+19@I(903. � 8 #d�9@I(9(3. 85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8GY�@IH6.7,/8���T�8G�9@ Y�@IH6.7,/8�� 46(*-13*U*-4�K%HS4�@7H */,-4 L5@%DU4�Th4S(�La134�@7HSCB85(9.­13(9@­*-,Z@ � 8�#£�9@ Y�@IH6.7,/8���:�� � M � #NT=D-4�0�46L58�>)<39dAB.8*&[email protected]</9S4�0�4 �8 034(# M � 8�#�D-.7(3.¼4 >)</9dAB.8*&9-(+.UTLm_@I(32M46LZ�$#8 � � M � #NT\D/La,/46Y+4Q@ICB. � $#³T�46(+*-,/.�0�19La8M(90�.¼46HbDU46CRV#.7H6. �#85,¯[email protected](9K74613(32546.7(987:�')HADU46CRV#.7H6. �D-4[H685K7K%8io-8`qJ�#.74QLZ� #8=(385H|H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.JLa.7CP13(38%T��"8M,�@7D/DU8M,-46,/8�HQ@PY%85,/4 *� @D-4SCP13H *Z@I(38�@³0�4�0�138P�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34�T#DU4 @703.7�#85,Z@G�3,/.7�3,/4S.GHQ@­L5.7(3K%4S19(32546.7(38HoU8`q9:�?A@G*/@lY7.%H6@G034�Y%85,/4 *� @³0�85H6HQ@La.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38P 8<¢%194S(9034|H6@BD-85K%1385(+*-8%©

� # � #� � �� � �� � �� � �

� � � M � #�Ts�9@RY�@IH6.7,/8�0�4#Y785,/4S*l @&� D-.7H6.R¢+19@7(90�. � �9@\Y�@7HS.%,-8�034"Y%85,/4 *� @�� 8 #w�9@RY�@IH6.7,/8�0�4hY78M,-4S*l @&��T8~�9@\Yl@7HS.%,-8~0349Y78M,-4S*l @ � (385K%HS4#@IHS*-,/49L5@%DU4�: � � M � #NTsD-4"0346L58N>)</9;,[email protected]</9;037F4BFhPc0/(\4"2L.1037F4�H¯034�039-(\4G>)4),B4@9-(\4 � 8>)</9-'"4hAB*-4"9X(h4 #6m3@I(32M46LZ�$#8 � � M � #�TbD-L5,-46Y�46@7CJ. � � #­T�4S(+*-,/.�0�19L585(90�.B46H|DU46CRV#.7H6. � �"8M,¯4SH|L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH68CG@�*/85,/46@7HS8%:P?|8B�3,/8ML58M0�8M(+*-4sLa.%(90�462546.7(34�0�4�Y785,/4S*l @ºLa.7,/,/46D-�".%(90�.%(3.­@ ¢+1385H6HS8B46CB�34S8MK%@I*-8B(3854�,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4CG@�*/85CG@�*/46L543¢%1"@I(90�.<D-43@/bh85,/CG@6o/DU8 � T+@IH6HS.%,/@ #OqQMF.<@I("LZ�387TI8�¢+134SY�@7HS8M(%*/85CB85(+*/87T�o � D-.7H6.�DU8 #OqdT ©�4S(�E�@I*U*/4�TLa.%(­*Z@IH68��9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(38�D-4#46(+*-8M(90�8\@/bh85,/CG@I,/8�LZ�38�(3.%( �91� .J09@I,ZDU4h46H|[email protected]�38�H�´ @I(+*-8�La8�0�85(+*-8 � DU4Q@JY78M,-.P846HALa.%(9DU8MK7138M(+*-8 #pE�@IHQDU.": g 4|�9@B¢+134S("0�4|HQ@GDU8MK7138M(%*/8�*Z@lY7.%H6@J0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @R�#85,~46HAL5.7(90�462546.7("@IH687©

Page 19: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

e��� # � � #� � �� � �� � �� � �

� g 4=.%D/DU8M,-Y�4¯.%,/@�LZ�38$� � M � #�TG(3.%(À 8�@IHS*-,/.°LZ�38¼46H�L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH68½CG@�*-8M,-4Q@IH68¼0�4=@I(+*-8�La8M0385(+*-8 # 8La.%(9D-85K71985(+*-8 � M�La46.9 8 # � � T T38<¢+1346(90�4[(3.%(ºL5.7,/,-4QD-�".%(90�8�@%0­19(ºL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY%.JL5.7(9L58a*U*/19@IH6CB85(+*-8<0�46Y78M,/D-.03@7H[�3,-8�La8�0�85(+*-8%:� � I M � #NT=�9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8J034sY78M,-4S*l @7� ¢+19@I(903. � 8 #¶�9@7(3(3.½Dc*/8MD/DU. Y�@IH6.7,/8B0�4sY78M,-4S*l @9T[8G�9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8J0�4

Y78M,-4S*l @��¦4S(¼[email protected](+*/,/@7,-46.9: � I M � #NT� 8=46H��@.1>)</9S,/[email protected]</9S0/7F4=0�4 � 8�#j8\DU4A4S(90346LM@ ��� #­T946(%*/,-.�0�1"La85("0�.46HADU46CRV#.7H6. � LZ�38\D-4[HS8MK7K78�o/DU8�8<DU.%HS.GD-8`q-m+HQ@GLa.%,-,/4QDU�#.7(90385(+*-8�*/@lY%.7HQ@P0�4[Y%85,/4 *� @  8�HQ@GD-85K71985(+*-8%©

� # ��� #� � �� � �� � �� � �

� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � :s�s,/46CB@J0�4|�9,-.+DU8MK71346,-8=(38MHSHQ@J(3.%DU*-,Z@J�9@I(3.%,/@7CB46LM@R0�8M4ALa.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4|Y78M,-.7��EF13(92546.7(9@7HS4�T.%D/D-85,/Y+4Q@ICB.�LZ�98 ��� #³T7L5.7CB8¯0�8ai9(94 */.�09@IH6H6@��3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/8�*[email protected]@�034�Y785,/4S*l @3T�8�¢+134SY�@7HS8b@NM � � #�T OM�# �� Ta:B')(�E�@�*-*-4�T�D-8BLM@IHQLa.%HS4Q@ICB.º4SH�Y�@IH6.7,/8B0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @º0�4�¢+138�Dc*�´ 13HS*-46CG@º8MD-�3,-8�D-D-46.7(38J4S(�EF13(32M4S.%(38G0�854�Yl@7HS.%,-4�0�4Y78M,-4S*l @�0�4 � 8_0�4 #ÀDU8M,-Y%85(903.�L54+0385H6HS8 */@lY%.7H68 0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @��3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/4%,/85HQ@�*/4SY%8 @� 8 � T7D-4�.I*U*/4S8M(38 E�@7La46H6CJ8M(+*-87©

� # M � � #NT M�# � � T� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �

LZ�38­L5.7,/,-4QD-�".%(90�8G@ ��� #³: ')H V946L5.7(90�462546.7("@IH68º 8³13(°La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.½Y%85,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH68BV346@7,-K%.7CB85(+*Z@IH68BLZ�98�31� . 8MD/DU8M,-8P0�8ai9(94 */. D-85,/Y785("0�.%D-4A0�8M4�0�198JL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4�Y785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64 8 � :��~.%(� 8P¢+1346(90�4�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-46.46(%*/,-.�0�19,-,/8­(�13.�Y�4 D-46CRV#.7H64_�#85,J*/1�*U*/4¯4_(�13.�Y�4bLa.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4�©­L5.7CB8� 8­19D-19@IH68º(385H6HS.�DUY�46HS19�3�".�0�8MHSH68­*/85.%,-468D/La4685(+*-4Si"LZ�38%Tl@%D-D-13(+*-4+@IHQLa13(94+L5.7(9L58a*U*/4+L5.7CB8s�3,/46CJ4S*-46Y�4�T�K%HS4�@IHS*-,/4%D-4+4S(+*-,/.�0�19L5.7(3.~CB8�0�46@7(+*-8�0�85i9(3462546.7(34�: �~85H� e7: >3T%@70P8MD-85CB�346.9T%¢+19@7(90�.�46(%*/,-.�0�19,-,/85CB.=4SH3H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.=�"8M,�H6@�H6.7K%46LM@��9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(9@7HS8%T�(3.7(G@%D-D-13CB85,/85CB.La.%CB8­DU46CRV#.7H6.¼�3,/46CJ4S*-46Y7.�0�85H6H�´ @IHSE�@IV#8a*/.¼46H_D-4SCPV".%HS. � �#85,J4SH_V34QLa.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68Bm�H6.¼46(+*-,/.�0313,-,/85CB.½46(�Y78ML58La.%CB8�D-46CRV#.7H6.B038ai9(34S*-."©

��� #W8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@�M � � #NT =M�# � � T� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � :�¨~H6HS.\DU*-8�D-D-.�CJ.�0�.\D-43�31� .<.%D/DU8M,-Y�@I,/8bLZ�[email protected]@ICB.�46H9Y�@7HS.%,-8¯0�8MHSH�´ 8�DU�9,-8�D-D-4S.%(38

M ! � T � #W4S(ºEF13(92546.7(38\0�8M4|Y�@IH6.7,/4[0�4 � 8�#³T3D-4[*/,-.�Y�@3©� # M ! � T � #� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �

.%D/D-46@BD-4|.I*-*-4685(38\HQ@GDU*-8MD/D/@REF19(32546.7(38P0�4|Y78M,-4S*l @B0�4 � � #³: g 4A�31� .³¢+1346(90�4�@/bh85,/CG@I,/8�LZ�98<4SHAL5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH68CG@�*/85,/46@7HS8�0�4A0�198=�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34 � 8�#p�[email protected]*-8�D-D-.JD-46K7(34Si"L5@I*-.B0�4jM ! � T � #p87T3La.%CB8=.+D-D-85,/Y�@�*/.R46(º�9,-85�La8�0�85(92M@J@P�9,-.%�".+DU4S*-.J0�85H|V946L5.7(90�462546.7("@IH687T��".7*-,/85CBCB.P8MY�4 *Z@I,/8=0�4[46(+*-,/.�0�13,/,-8�La.%CJ8=�3,/4SCB4S*-46Y7.B46H|DU46CRV#.7H6.� T3,-4QLa.%(90�19L585(903.7H6.J@�!�8 � : g La,/4SY�[email protected]¢%194S(9034�©

� � #W8�¢%194SY�@IH68<@ M ! � T � #

Page 20: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

kIf¯4S*-.%,-(9@7(90�.~.%,/@�@IH6H6@;��@IV#85H6HQ@\e7:6e 03854�0�4S8�La4�La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4�TID-4" 8�K74) @~0�85*U*/.=LZ�38 4+D-8ML5.7(9034+L54S(9¢+138_DU4+�#.%D/DU.%(3.

.I*-*-8M(385,/8�L5.7CB86o-([email protected](94eq<0�8M4h�3,-46CB4[La46(9¢+1387:�¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/[email protected]+@70G8�DU8MCJ�94S."T � �/� M � #NTa:s¡�D/DU.\�"@\Y�@IH6.7,/8�d¢+19@I(903.P13("@P8�13("@JD-.7HQ@R0385H6HS8��3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34 � 8 #p�9@JY�@IH6.7,/88��T�8M0 �9@PY�@IH6.7,/8 � (385K%HS4|@7H */,-4[L5@%DU4�: ')(@I("@IH6.7K74Q@=@<¢%1"@I(+*-.=i9(3.%,/@�@3b#8M,-CG@�*/.9T7D-43�31� .\La.7("Dc*Z@�*/@7,-8bLa.%CB8 � �/� M � #NTsLa.7,/,/46D-�".%(903@=@IH6H6@�,3.g'^A3.8*&9&C".1<39;44"'">@7l*D'L.8W/0�T�@ ¢%1985H6H6@½L5.7CRV94S([email protected](38JY78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS8BLZ�38G(38MHsH64S(3K%19@IK%K746.ºL5.7CP13(38B8MD-�3,/4SCB4Q@ICB.½La.7( oU.dq. o-.7�3�319,-8EqB(385H�DU8M(9DU.³034Z03*&(�: g 4��".7*-,/85V3V#[email protected],Z@B4S(+*/,-.�0�13,/,/8<13(¼(�13.�Y7.GD-4SCPV".%HS."T"@%0 8MD-85CB�346.��PT3*Z@IH68LZ�38%©

� # � ��#� � �� � �� � �� � �

rP´ @7H */,/@ �9@7,U*/87T�La.7CB8�D-4G 8�K74) @·.+D-D-85,/Y�@�*/.9T=(3.7(Á 8�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-46.�46(+*-,/.�0�13,/,-8�(�13.�Y�4\DU46CRV#.7H64�: ¥ .%(¦4La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4|K74) @J4S(+*/,-.�0�.7*U*-4|D-4[�31� .G8�DU�9,-46CB85,/8�HQ@G0�4QDUK%4S13(92546.7(38�8MD/LaH619D-4SY�@9T�4S( ¢+19@I(+*-."©

� � #p8�¢%194SY�@IH68\@�!ZM ��� #NT.G@I(9LZ�987T��#85,�¢+19@7(%*/.P�9,-46CG@BY+4QDU*-.B(385H6H�´ � D/DU8M,-Y�@72546.7(38Pe7T3D-85(32�@P,/4QLa.7,/,/85,/8�@IHAV346L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH687©

� � #W8�¢+134SY�@7HS8<@�!ZM^M � � #NT =M # � � T^T.G@I(9L5.7,Z@iM � D-D-85,/Y�@I2M4S.%(38�k_T_DU8M(32M@J,/46L5.7,/,-8M,-8=@IH|La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8%©

� � #W8M¢+1346Y�@IH68�@�!ZM5M^M ! � T � #NT =M5M ! #�T � � T5T� �����% �3�3�%���#���½&A:s¿~(ºCB8a*-.�0�.BK%85(38M,/@7HS8=�"8M,¯8MD-�3,/4SCB85,/8=13(½La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y7.BDU8M,-Y%85(90�.+DU4[D-.7H6.J034 !_T _T �

 8J4SHsD-85K%1385(+*/87: g 4�La.%(9D-460�8M,/@7(3.­H68B,-46K7�98J0�8MHSHQ@ */@lY%.7HQ@ 0�4�Y%85,/4 *� @­46(�La134s46HsLa.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.º�9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8�� M�(385HL5@%DU.J0�4��PT%HQ@JDU8�La.7("03@\8�H6@R*-8M,-2�@\,/4SK+@_T :�r=@�*-.BLZ�38�(385H6H6@JD-8MLa.%(903@<,/46K%@ � �9@RYl@7HS.%,-8*� 8 #Á�9@\Y�@IH6.7,/8*��T@IH6HQ@RD-8MLa.%(903@R,-46K%@\E�@[email protected].%,-,/4QDU�#.7(90385,/8~H6@JLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(387© � �M ! #NT�M�H6@J¢+19@IH68R 8=Y78M,/@RDU8=8=D-.7H6.PD-8 � 8~Y%85,Z@�8 #µ 8¯E�@IHQD/@_T : � .74QLZ�$#8¯(985H6H6@�*/85,/2M@<,/46K%@ � �9@<Y�@IH6.7,/88�Å8 # �9@<Y�@IH6.7,/8���T�@7HSHQ@�*/85,/2M@<,/4SK+@=E�@[email protected].%,-,/4QDU�#.7(90385,/8¯H6@JLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(387©ZM ! � T �# MFHQ@R¢+19@IH68R 8�Y78M,/@RDU8=8�D-.7H6.PD-8 �  8~E�@7H6D/@\8 #£ 8�Y78M,/@dT : � .74QLZ�$#8HQ@B�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(98 � � #d 8<Y785,Z@BDU8R8\DU.%HS.³D-8RD-4|Y78M,-4Si"L5@B19(3.³0�4 ¢%198MDU*-4A0�198RL5@%DU4�T9�#.%D/[email protected]�3,/4SCB8M,-HQ@La.%CB8�@7H */85,/(9@�*/4SY�@P*-,Z@JHS8<0�198\La.7(9K74613(32546.7(94�:���1346(90�4�©

� � #p8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8\@�M � M ! #NT5T � M^M ! � T #�T¨¦*-4S*-.%HS.³0�4AY785,/4Si"L5@[email protected]@7CJ.J46H|Y�@IH6.7,/8=0�8MHSHQ@J8MD-�3,/8MD/DU46.7(38�@B0�8MDU*-,Z@3©

� # M � M ! #�T^T � M^M ! � T #NT� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �

87T"La.7CB8<D-4[Y78M0387T3D-4|.I*-*-85(9K7.7(9.JL5.7CB8<,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/4[�3,-.%�3,/4S.J4|Y�@IH6.7,/4[0�4jM � ��#�T :� ¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/4Q@ICB.½.7,Z@�� � M � #NT :¼¡ D-D-.½�9@ Y�@IH6.7,/8:�jD-.7H6.¼¢%1"@I(90�. � 8 #�D-.7(3.½8M(+*-,Z@ICRV#8GY78M,-8%T�8�0

�9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8 � (38MK7H64�@IHS*-,/4 *-,/8JLM@7D-4�: ��138MDU*-. La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.ºY�4S8M(38G0�8a*-*-. oU.º46(9La.%CJ�"@�*-46V346HS8Eq3T|46(�¢%1"@I(+*-.º(385HH64S(3K%19@IK%K746.¼(9@I*-13,Z@IH68³19D-46@7CB.¼*/@7HSY%.7HS*/@so-._q�La.7(·¢%198MDU*-.�D-46K7(34Si"L5@I*-. M�¢+19@I(903.�46(%*/85(90346@7CJ.�D-.I*U*/.7H64S(98M@I,/8LZ�38=0�138=�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94"(3.%(³�#.%D/DU.%(3.R,/46D-13HS*/@7,-8~8M(+*-,Z@ICRV#8�Y%85,/8 � Ta:s�~8MHSHQ@\H68a*-*-85,Z@�*/13,Z@R¢+138MDU*-.JLa.%(3(38a*-*-46Y7.­ 8(3.7*-.³La.%CB8 ocEF13(+*-.%,-8\034 g �38@b#8M,GqB8RY+4685(98R0�85(9.I*/@I*-.³L5.7( 4SH�DU46CRV#.7H6. � M�8\�9@G13("@B4S(+*-8M,-8�D-D/@I(+*/8=�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @D-13HSHQ@B¢+19@IH68=*-.7,/(38M,-8MCJ.J(38MH � e7:�kBTa: ��194S(9034�©g �['w�� ���56��#&.�8 9�1+*,%�'�.D*C`=���"56#M*,56.�hI> �#25;*,%�F/#M*([email protected] �#-�+*,�"�M*,i�8�./���(1����:hI>� "#2 "0�*G*C0�0"�$%B0"#?8-.; �#2������%�'(./%�.D*,�(��1�%B0�#&i�8

#&%B0���%�'�#M*,56.X �.,0�0"./�&#&%��$*,���K!EZ(�H3�b�~*,�& �.)!EZ��[�&�['�1��[����./�@./ �#&>�#&./%�# !�./56�@./%���%�0"#=�@./ " E*,%�.T�$ " ������b��%�0"�E*,5TO ��AB���������&��'�1��K�(��./�@.�f �#&>�#&./%�#2 "./%�.GAB���"�H9�1+*,%�'�.G �#-�~*;1(%+*G'(�$�&�&�T'�1��T!$./ "�/8�5;*6*,%�!EZ(��9�1�*,%�'�.D%(./%v "�T%(�T�~*;%(�$ " �1�%�*L'����&�&�X'�1��LPR9�1+*,%�'�.L �./%�.��%�0"�E*,5TO@�K�?*,�& "�CYE8+�@./#&!EZS��X%�./%L �#�A�1�./�&�) �./ �0���%������)!EZ(�)A,*� ���56���"�[�?*C0�0�*;1(%+*H'����&�&�)'�1��)!�./ ��6PR#&��!EZ��X E*,�"��O�O@�)*, � �1(��'�.�YE8@5;**,����1(%�0".6!EZ��)%�./%GA/*,%�%�.��~*C0�0��)��%�0"�E*,5TO@�B]

Page 21: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

k3e� # M � � #�T� � �� � �� � �� � �

¥ .7(º46H|�3,/.�L58M0�46CB85(+*-.J�3,/4SCG@J46HSH619DU*-,Z@�*-.B(38MHSH�´ � D-D-85,/Y�@I2546.7(98=>BD-4|.I*-*-4685(38<LZ�38%©� � #p8M¢+1346Y�@IH68\@�M � M ! #�T^T � M5M ! � T #NT � M^M ! � T HM ! #NT^T

.G@I(9LZ�987T��34U 1½DU8MCJ�9HS4QLa8MCJ8M(+*-87T9,-4QLa.%,/03@7(90�.J¢%1"@I(+*-.BK74) @B0�8a*-*-.G46( �3,-8�La8�0�85(32�@3©� � #W8�¢%194SY�@IH68<@ !ZM � #�T

� �����% �3�3�%���#����±A:­��85HsCB8MCRV3,/.¼0�4�0�8�Dc*/,/@ 0�8MHSHQ@ �#85(�13HS*-46CB@¼8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8M(32M@ @7V3V34Q@ICB.½D-L5,-4S*U*/.º19(|´ @7H �*-8M,-("@�*-46Y�@�EF,Z@°*/,-8�CB85CRV9,-4+m\(38MH�D-85K%134S*-.�1"DU8M,-8MCJ.·DU�#8MD/DU. La.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(34�8�0�4QDUK%4S19(32546.7(34=CR19H */4S�3H68�0�85H*-46�#.9©

� # �� ����� # � �LZ�38%T�4S( CB.�0�.G@I(9@7HS.%K7.P@7HSH68<@703034S2M4S.%(34|.BCB.7HS*-46�[email protected](34|@7,-4S*-CB85*-4QLZ�387T�Y�@I(9(3.B4S(+*-8�DU8<L5.7CB8\@7D/DU.�L546@I*-8

@BDU46(34QDc*/,/@9©M^M5M � #�T ���T ��iT

M^M � � #�T � ��T')(³.%K7(34hL5@%DU.\(9.7(­Y�4� 8~�#85,/46L5.7H6.P0�4[L5.7(�EF19D-46.7(38�4S(­¢+19@7(+*-.��8 � K%.�03.7(3.R0385H6H6@P�3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @\@%D-D-.�La4Q@�*/4SY�@

87T"¢%194S(9034�©M � HM # ���T^T 8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@ M5M � #�T ���TM � � M # � ��T^T 8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@ M5M ��� #�T � ��T

')(ºK785(985,Z@IH687©� 13(9@GLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38\0�4��34U 1½CJ8MCRV3,/4A�"@BYl@7HS.%,-8\034AY78M,-4S*l @�� DU8\8PDU.%HS.³D-8<*-13*U*-4�4ACB8MCRV3,/4�L5.7(3K%4S13(+*/4�9@I(3(9.JY�@7HS.%,-8�0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @ � m

� 13(9@º0�46D-K74613(32M4S.%(38G0�4��34U 1�CJ8MCRV3,/4 �9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8J0�4�Y%85,/4 *� @�� D-8J8BD-.7H6. DU8G@IH6CB85(3. 13(�0�4QDUK%4S19(%*/. �"@Yl@7HS.%,-8�0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @ ��:

� � 85, La.7CB�3H68a*Z@I,/8¯H6@\(3.%DU*-,Z@�,/@%D-D-85K%(9@�0�854#La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�49Y78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS49V346@7,-K%.7CB85(+*Z@IH64�,-46�".%,U*Z@�*/43(385H6HQ@��@IV#85H6H6@�e%:Se%T .%D/DU8M,-Y�4Q@ICB.½LZ�38 � �$� M � #NT<8 � ��� M � #�TRL5.7,/,-4QDU�#.7("0�.7(3.½@7HSH68³(38MK%@I2M4S.%(34 034(� � M � #NT\8 0�4� � M � #NT�M�8\¢+134S("0�4A@�!ZM � � #NT_8�!ZM�# � � T^Ta:� � � � M � #NT��9@\Y�@7HS.%,-8��¶DU8�8�D-.7H6.RD-8 � 8 # D-.7(9.\85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8�E�@IHQDU8_m�DU4"*-,Z@�*-*/@\0�8MH[La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y7.RLZ�38�(385H

H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.GLa.7CP13(38³ 8\DU.%HS4S*/@7CJ8M(+*-8<8MD-�3,/8MD/DU.³09@koU($#87:6:S:6T ($#87:6:S: q3T3LZ�98B 8RD-4SCPV".%HS46252�@�*-.³09@��G8M0� 8R4SH�DU8�La.7("0�.ocEF19(%*/.7,/8<0�4 g �38@b#8M,Gq9©

� # � � #� � �� � �� � �� � �

� D/DU8M,-Y�[email protected]�38%©� � #W8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@�!ZM � � #NT

Page 22: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

k7kMF�#.74QLZ�$#8 � � � M � #NT� 8~HQ@\(985K%@72546.7(38�0�4 � � M � #�T^T�CB@P@I(9LZ�987T+�"8M,_¢+19@7(%*/.\8MD-�#.%DU*-.\46(­�3,/8ML58M0�8M(32M@\(385H6H�´ � DU�D-85,/[email protected](38�>3©

� � #W8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@ M ! � T M ! #�T��1346(90�4#4SH[L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY%. �J�31� .R8�D-D-85,/8�038ai9(34S*-.J@R�"@I,-*-46,-8�09@IH6H6@P0�46D-K74613(32M4S.%(38�8�03@7HSHQ@\(38MK%@72546.7(38~.B03@7HSHQ@

La.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38�8<03@IH6H6@J(38MK%@72546.7(38%:�r=@IH|L5.7(�EF,/.7(+*/.J0�8MHSH68\0�138<19H */4SCB8<8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(32M8<DU8MK7138<LZ�38%©!ZM � � #�T_8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@�M ! � T M ! #�T

8\@I("LZ�38�M�(385K+@I(903.B@7CRV#.B4|CB85CRV9,-4[8<.+D-D-85,/Y�@I(90�.JLZ�38�!ZM ! � Tb8M¢+1346Y�@IH68<@70 � Ta©

M ��� #NT_8M¢+1346Y�@IH68<@�!ZM5M ! � T M ! #�T^T Mce%:SeKT¨~H6H6.BDU*-8�D-D-.BCB.�03.BD-4|Y%85,/4 i"LM@PLZ�987©

M � #NT_8M¢+1346Y�@IH68<@�!ZM5M ! � T � M ! #�T^T Mce%: k_TMce%:SeKT[8 Mce%: k_TAD-.7(3.�0�138b,[email protected](34%CB.7HS*-.=4SCB�#.7,-*/@I(+*/4%46(P¢+19@7(%*/.�H685K+@I(3.�EF,/@�HS.%,-."TM*/,/@7CB4 */8 HQ@~(38MK%@72546.7(38%T

4AL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4|0�4AL5.7(3K%4S19(32546.7(38�8<0�4A0346D-K74613(32M4S.%(387:�¡�D/D-8=�9,-8M(90�.7(9.J46H[(3.%CJ8\034:7F4hA`AB.j,/.��N4��H</2IAd0/9":¯4Q@7D/DU19CJ8M(90�."T+46( ¢%198MDU*-.J�9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.R@[email protected](+*/,-.�0�.7*U*-.B0�8M4|DU46CRV#.7H64[�"8M,¯0�85(3.7*/@7,-8�@IHQLa13(94hL5.7(3(98a*U�

*-46Y�4|Y78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS4�©� 4SH�DU46CRV#.7H6. !º�#85,�4SH�La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.�CJ.%(3.I�)@I,/K7.%CB85(+*/@7HS8pM EF19(32546.7(38_03@ � H� _4S( � � KT[034%(38MK%@72546.7(38%©

� ! �� �� �

� 4 D-46CRV#.7H64 � T _T � T � T �PT ��T �º�"8M,=@7H6L513(34�La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4 V346@7,-K%.7CB85(+*Z@IH64 M EF19(32546.7(34s09@ � H� ��R46( � � %T3La46.9 8�EF19(32546.7(34|LZ�98\@70 .7K7(94|La.7�9�346@B0�4AYl@7HS.%,-4[0�4AY785,/4S*l @B@7D/DU.�L546@7(3.R13( Y�@IH6.7,/8�0�4|Y78M,-4S*l @dT ©� # � � # � # � � # ��� # � � # � � # � � #� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �

����� � �;�� �� �p�N� ��#Z� �� /�i �~8MH��9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.­�3,/8ML58M0�8M(+*-8B@IV3V34Q@ICB. 8MD/@ICB46(9@�*/.º@7H6L513(34sL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4�Y78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS4�8M0�@IV9V346@7CB.ºY�4QDc*/.La.%CB8¯*-,Z@\0�4"8MD/DU4�T+L5.7(9D-4Q0�85,Z@�*/49La.%CJ8~EF13(32546.7(949*/,/@�Y�@IH6.7,/4"0349Y78M,-4S*l @9T%D-19D/DU4QDc*Z@I(3.\0385H6HS8�,[email protected](34�:A')(­¢+138�Dc*/.�9@7,/@7K7,Z@�EF.~8�D-@7CJ46(34Q@ICB.=�34U 1GD-46DU*-8MCG@�*-4QL5@7CB85(+*-8 */@7HS4�,Z@I�3�#.7,-*-4�.+D-D-85,/Y�@I(90�.=La.%CJ8b13(J(�13CB85,/.=@%D-D/@I4��34QL5L5.7H6.0�4AL5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�4|Y%85,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64#L5.7(9D-85(+*/8�034A0�8ai"(34S,/8=*-1�*-*-4�K7H64|@IHS*-,/4�:

¿~(�¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4�La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7. �h�)@I,/K7.7CB8M(%*Z@IH68³ 8J13(9@ EF13(32M4S.%(38G03@ � H� ���4S( � H� +: g 4s�"@ LZ�38B8�D-D-.�31� .B8�D-D-85,/8<0�8ai9(94 */.GCJ8�0�4Q@I(+*-8�!_T _T � : ��138MDU*-.PE�@�*-*-.³D-4[85(�13(9L546@G0�4QLa8M(90�.GLZ�38%©

! � �4a*&9S0 �)0K'@4Q,/.j>)</9X9;4@(I(+.8W`.

Page 23: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

k7>0�.�Y%8\13(9@­V9@7D-8P0�4�L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4  8R13(�¢%1"@IHQDU4Q@7D-4�46(9D-4S8MCB8P0�4�La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4�LZ�98PLa.%(9D-85(+*-8J0�4�0�8ai9(94S,/8\*/1�*U*/4�K%HS4@IHS*-,/4�:

?A@�0�46CB.%DU*-,[email protected](987T LZ�98º(9.7( �3,-8�DU8M(+*-4Q@ICB.�(9854~0�85*U*/@7K7H64�TbD-4bEF.7(903@�D-13H¯CB8a*/.�03.�K%4  @�46HSH619DU*-,Z@�*/.�(38MH �H�´ � D/DU8M,-Y�@72546.7(38º>�0385H~�9@7,/@7K7,Z@�EF.¼�9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8 8½LZ�38 ,-46�3,/85(90346@7CJ.�La.%(·19( 8�DU8MCB�34S.":�¥ .%(9D-460�8M,-4Q@ICB.�4SHLa.%(3(385*U*-46Y7. *-,/4Q@I,/K7.7CB8M(%*Z@IH68��wLZ�98PY�@IH68�� ¢%1"@I(90�. @IH6CB85(3. 0�138B0�8MK7H64s@I,/K7.7CB8M(%*/4��"@I(3(3.ºY�@IH6.7,/8 � m|HQ@D-19@P*/@lY7.%H6@  8=H6@GD-85K%1385(+*/87©

� # � � M � # ��T� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �

g 4|L5.7(9D-460385,Z@I(3.\H68�,-46K7�98�46(ºL5134����"@RY�@IH6.7,/8 �¶8%T��"8M,¯La4Q@7D/La13(9@J0�4[8�D-D-87T�D-4|D-L5,-46Y78=13(9@JLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(384�L5134�L5.7(3K%4S19(%*/4AD-.7(3.G. � T #­T �Á.GHS8RHS.%,-.G(38MK%@72546.7(34|@³D-8ML5.7(909@JD-8\(38MHSHQ@B,/[email protected]*-*-.GHQ@GHS85*U*/85,Z@3T3Y�4� 8��.�� m9¢+1346(90�4�©

��,-46CG@R,/4SK+@3© � # ��g 8�La.%(903@J,-46K%@9© � # M ! ��T��85,/2M@P,-46K%@9© � M ! #�T ����1346(+*/@J,/4SK+@3© M ! � T �# ��

?A@J0�4QDUK%4S19(32546.7(38<0�8MHSH68\La.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(34[La.+D   $h.7*U*-8M(�1�*-8�8M¢+1346Y�@IH687T3(985H|D-85(9D-.BK74) @PLZ�34Q@I,/4S*-.J4S( �3,/8ML58M0�8M(32M@9T@IH|L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY%.G03@�*/.9©

� M � # ��T_8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8\@�M � # ���T � M � # M ! ��T^T � M � M ! #�T ���T � M^M ! � T �# ���T ¡�85Y�4Q0�85(+*/8~LZ�38�¢+138MDU*-.<�9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-.<DU4"�31� .\@7�3�3H646LM@I,/8¯4S(GK%85(38M,/@7HS8¯@70J13(³¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-49La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y7.<La.%(

13( (�13CB85,/.G¢%1"@IHQDU4Q@7D-4[0�4A@I,/K7.%CB85(+*-4�:� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � :B')H�,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/.ºY�@7HS8G@I("LZ�38GDU8B46(�*/1�*U*/8³HS8B,/4SK%�38BLa.7CB�9@7,-8��<:G¨�0�8�DU8MCJ�94S."T|�"8M,<4SH

La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.\*-,/46@7,-K%.7CB85(+*/@7HS8¯LZ�38��9@RD-85CB�3,/8~Y�@IH6.7,/8���DU4"�31� .J@7D/DU13CB8M,-8¯HQ@\D-85K71985(+*-8�0346D-K74613(32M4S.%(38�LZ�38~�"@D-85CB�3,/8=Y�@7HS.%,-8 ��©

M � =M ! � T5T � M�# M ! #NT^T � M � =M ! ��T^TM�@7V3V34Q@ICB.=19D-@I*-.�*-,/8 H68a*-*-85,/8_�"8M,�,/4QDU�#8a*-*/@I,/8_4SH�(�13CB85,/.�0�43@7,-K%.7CB85(+*/4gTa:A¨~(9LZ�98_4�L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4 � � T � � T � � T � �C� T� �$� T+8&� � � 0�8MHSHQ@w��@7V"8MHSHQ@Be7:6e7T+LZ�38~(3.%(G@IV3V34Q@ICB.<,/4S�#.7,-*/@I*-.�(38MHSHQ@���@IV#85H6H6@Be%:Se<T+�".+D-D-.7(9.=8�D-D-85,/8¯,/46L5.7(90�.7*U*/4@�!_T _T � La.%(º46H[�3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/.J46H6HS19DU*-,Z@�*/.9:�¨�0º8�DU8MCJ�94S."©

� � M � #NT 8M¢+1346Y�@IH68�@ M � #NT � M � M ! #�T^T� �t� M � #NT 8M¢+1346Y�@IH68�@ M � M ! #�T^T � M5M ! � T =M ! #NT5T� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � : ')H|,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/.P.7*U*-8M(�1�*-.  8=CB.7HS*-.GDU46K7(94 i"LM@�*/4SY%.9: g 4  8�0�8a*-*-.³LZ�38�([email protected]%46LM@R�9,-.%�".7�D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH68<DU4�Y7.7K%HS46.7(9.JDU*-190346@7,-8<4�(38MD/DU4�0�4�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@GLZ�38\La.%4S(�Y%.7H6K7.7(9.R�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34AL5.7CB�".+Dc*/8

.I*-*-8M(+13*-8<CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8RLa.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4|Y78M,-.7��EF13(92546.7(9@7HS4[@B�9@7,U*/4S,/8\03@B�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34|D-85CB�3H646L54�: ��19@I(+*-.G@7V3V34Q@ICB.@I�9�"8M(9@ Dc*Z@IV346HS4S*-.� 8GLZ�38%TACB8M0346@7(%*/8B4�*-,/8GDU.%HS4sL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4(!_T _T � T� 8B�".+D-D-4SV94SH68B8MD-�3,-46CB85,/8P19(�¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.�Y78M,-.7��EF13(92546.7(9@7HS8%:[')(R@IHS*-,/47*/85,/CB4S(34�TID-46@7CJ.�4S(PK7,Z@70�.~0�4�0�.%CB4S(9@7,-8�4S(PCJ.�0�.�8MD/@I19DU*-46Y7.�H�´ @ICPV34 */.0�8MHSHQ@JY785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64S*l @3:

¿~("@\Y7.%H *Z@\0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@�*-.PLZ�38 ! � R 8�13("@\V9@%DU8�034hL5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�4�T+D-8�(98��#.%D/DU.%(3.<.I*-*-8M(385,/8~E�@%La46HSCB85(+*/8@IHS*-,/87:�r=@IH6H6@JH685K%K78<0�4 r�8&�½.7,/K%@7(=MUe7:6eET_DU8MK7138<LZ�38 � �31� .G8�D-D-85,/8=038ai9(34S*-.³@J�9@7,U*/4S,/8<03@�!°8 _T"¢%194S(9034�©

Page 24: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

k�O

! �4O*&9;0 �G0/'@4N,3. >)</9-9S4"(+(+.8W`.¨~("@IH6.7K%@7CB85(+*-8%T�09@IH6H�´ @IHS*-,Z@RH685K%K78<0�4 r�8&�½.%,-K+@I(=MUe7:�kBTaT3DU8MK7138<LZ�38%©

! � �4O*&9;0 �G0/'@4N,3. >)</9-9S4"(+(+.8W`.¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/4Q@ICB. .7,Z@½HS8 0�138­8�DU�9,-8�D-D-4S.%(34(!ZM � � M ! #NT5T\8 M ! � T � # 8­[email protected]@ICB.7(38GH68³*Z@lY7.%HS8³0�4

Y78M,-4S*l @9©� # ! M � � M ! #NT5T M ! � T � #� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �

g 4� 8�Y%85,/4 i"LM@�*/.JLZ�38%©M � #�T 8�¢+134SY�@7HS8<@ !ZM � � M ! #�T^TM ��� #�T 8�¢+134SY�@7HS8<@ M^M ! � T � #�T

87T#¢+134S("0�4�T#LZ�38\HQ@GLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38<8<H6@­0�46D-K74613(32M4S.%(38<�#.%D/DU.%(3.B8MD/DU8M,-8\0�85i9(34S*-8\CB8�0�46@7(+*-8\HQ@B(385K+@I2M4S.%(38�8\4SHLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8%:�� 85,-*/@I(+*/.9©

! � B 8�13(9@BV"@7D-8=0�4�La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4')(Å*-13*U*-4�K%HS4�8MD-85CB�34�0�4�V"@7D-4�0�4�La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4�i9(¦¢%194=L5.7(9D-460385,Z@�*-4~i9K713,Z@�HQ@�(38MK%@I2M4S.%(38 !_: ?�@�D-19@

�3,/8MD-85(32�@½ 8J8MD/DU8M(3254Q@IH68R46(�¢+19@7(+*-.9T[@%0¼8MD-85CB�346.9T � � � B(3.7(° 8P13("@³V9@%DU8B0�4�La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4�:<')(�E�@I*U*/4�T*-13*U*-4�8\¢+19@�*-*-,/.G4�L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4AV946@7,-K%.7CB85(+*/@7HS4|034�¢+138MDU*-.G46(9D-4S8MCB8\@7D/DU13CB.%(3.GY�@IH6.7,/8 � ¢%1"@I(90�.G8M(+*-,Z@ICRV94K7H64�@7,-K%.7CB85(+*-4��"@I(3(3. Y�@IH6.7,/8���:  ¡ @IH6HS.%,/@º.�Y�Y�4S. LZ�387T La.%CR13("¢%198BD-4�L5.7CB�".%(3K%@7(3. HS8GH6.7,/.ºEF13(32M4S.%(34 0�4Y78M,-4S*l @9T�H6@GEF13(32546.7(98\La.7CB�#.%DU*/@G@%D-D-13CB85,� @RY�@7HS.%,-8 ��¢+19@7(90�.G4AD-13.74�@I,/K7.7CB8M(%*/4[,-4QLa8MY7.%(3.PY�@7HS.%,-8���: �~.%(D-4¯�".7*-,� @�¢+1346(90�4¯8�DU�3,/46CJ8M,-8%Ts46(·EF19(32546.7(38½0�4~¢+138�Dc*/4~¢+19@�*-*-,/.�L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4�T�HQ@�EF19(32546.7(38½0�4¯Y%85,/4 *� @�034¯13(La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.�M�¢+19@7HS8�@70­8MD-85CB�346. � T LZ�38�@7D/DU19CJ8=Y�@IH6.7,/8*� ¢+19@7(90�.J4|DU19.74h@I,/K7.7CB8M(%*/4",/4QLa85Y%.7(3.PY�@IH6.7,/88��: ¡¼46(+*-8M,-8�D-D/@I(+*-8�.%D/DU8M,-Y�@I,/8sLZ�38 � ~ 8�19(9@~V9@%DU8_0�4�La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4�:�')H%EF19(%*/.7,/8 0�4 g �38@b#8M, oU.�46(9L5.7CB�9@�*/4SV94SH68`q9T03@\D-.7H6.9T%La.7("DU8M(%*/8~0�4"038ai9(346,/8¯*-1�*-*-4#K7H649@IHS*-,/4"L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�4"Y785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64�:A')(�E�@I*U*-4�T�DU8~D-4"[email protected]@I(9.=4"Y�@IH6.7,/40�4�©

M � � � T 8<0�4sM � � � T �VM�# � #NTD-4[.I*U*/4S8M(38<,/46D-�"85*U*/4SY�@ICB8M(%*/87©

� � � �� �� �

� # M � � � T � M�# � #�T� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �8\¢+1346(90�4�©

! � 8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@ M � � � T��� # 8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8<@ M � � � T �VM�# � #NT¥ 4) .PD-4SK%(34 i#L5@RLZ�98 !�8 � D-4h�".+D-D-.7(3.P0�8ai9(94S,/8�*/,/@7CB4 */8 � T�87T3¢+1346(90�4�T+�#.74QLZ�$#8 ! � P 8�13(9@PV9@7D-87T�@I("LZ�38

� J 8�13(9@BV9@%DU8%:¨~("LZ�38 �� B 8�13(9@JV9@%DU8<0�4�La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4�: g 4|Y%85,/4 i#L5@P4S(�E�@I*U*/4�LZ�38%©

! � 8M¢+1346Y�@IH68<@ M � � � T� # 8M¢+1346Y�@IH68<@ M � � � T � M�# � #�T87T98MD/DU8M(90�. ! \19(9@JV9@7D-87T�H6.º 8<@I(9LZ�38 �� %:

Page 25: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

k%X����� ��� �� @�Q���;��� � # ���E���@� �N ������������ ��� @�! "�N�����@#¨~V9V346@7CB.³.7,Z@G@³0�4QDU�#.%D-462546.7(38<K%HS4�4S(3K%,-8�0�4685(+*-4�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-4[�#85,�4S(346254Q@I,/8\H6.­D-Y+46H613�3�#.³.7,/K%@7(346L5.G0�[email protected]%46LM@�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH687TA�9@I,-*-8M(90�.¼03@7HSHQ@ 0�8ai9(94S2M4S.%(38­0�8MH�DU19.½HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S."TALZ�38³LZ�34Q@ICB8M,-8MCJ._�T�8G�9,-.+DU8MK7138M(90�.La.%( H6.GDc*/190�46.³0�85H6H68\DU138��3,/.7�9,-468a*� @PD-4S(+*Z@�*U*/46LZ�987:m%�J�Ut-}~r���o rsr�tcq ~�A�-�co �Uqsr�t-uho y�x3qsy<q z+tU{|tcq�}�o��c�')HhHS46(3K%19@IK%K746.w 0�8MHSHQ@PHS.%K74QL5@<�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS8< 8=La.+Dc*/4 */134 */.J09@R0�138�La.%CB�".%(385(+*-4�T�H�´ @IHSE�@IV#8a*/.�� 8�H�´ 46(9D-4S8MCB8�p0385H6HS8��"<32LPN*&7F4 �)4"9 �"</2LPc0/(\4¯. �"</2LPc4 J 25< J </')[email protected]<39;0/7U.jM EF�XTa©) < �� � � :

?s´ @IHSE�@IV#8a*/.��£ 8<L5.%DU*-4S*-134S*-.³03@P*/,-8�46(9DU4685CB4A0346D-K74613(+*-4A034ADU46CRV#.7H64�©M50`T­19(º46(9D-4S8MCB8<(+19CJ8M,/@7V346HS8 � 0�4|H68a*U*/85,/8��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH64�©

� < C D � � E C � D � � � � � E � C � D � � � $� � E � C � D � � � � � � M �GT­19(º46(9D-4S8MCB8 � 0�4|D-46CRV#.7H64|�"8M,~La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4|Y78M,-.7��EF13(92546.7(9@7HS4�©

� < ! � � M5>GT­19(º46(9D-4S8MCB8 *�0�4�DU8MK7(34|@719DU46H646@7,-4�MFH68<�9@7,-8M(%*/8MD-4h*-.%(90�8<@I�#85,-*/@J8\LZ�34619D/@_T ©

* < M GT ?|8=H68a*U*/85,/8��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH64"�9@7(3(3.BHQ@REF19(32546.7(38<0�4[46(90�4QL5@7,-8=H68=�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34[D-85CB�3H646L54�:s��85H[H64S(9K719@7K7K746.

Å@IV3V34Q@ICB.\46(+*-,/.�0�.I*-*-.PD-46CRV#.7H64"�#85,b¢+19@�*-*-,/.PLa.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4"Y%85,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64�©�(385K+@I2M4S.%(387T+La.7(9K74613(32546.7(987T�0�4 �D-K74613(32546.7(98~8�L5.7(90�462546.7("@IH687:�¨�Y�,-8MCJCB.P�".7*-1�*/.R46(%*/,-.�0�19,-,/8¯13(³(�13CB85,/.\CG@IK%K746.7,/8~0�4hDU46CRV#.7H64"�9,-8M(90�85("0�.46(·La.%(9D-460�8M,/@72546.7(38³@7H */,-4¯L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4�T�.�@7(9LZ�38 L5.7(9D-4Q0�85,Z@I,/(38G13(·(+19CJ8M,-.�CB4S(3.%,-8%T�HS46CB4 *Z@I(903.�L54¯@70�13("@¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4�V9@7D-8R0�4 La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4R�%:�?|8R�9@I,/85(+*-8�DU4�YºLa.%CB8PD-4� 8\K%4  @³Y+4QDU*-.­(9854��9@I,Z@IK%,/@Iiº�3,/8ML58M0�8M(+*-4 Y �9@I(9(3.HQ@\Dc*/8MD/D-@<EF13(32546.7(98�LZ�38~,/46Y78MDU*-.%(3.<46(­@IH6K78MV3,/@9T7.+D-D-46@�,/85("0�85,/8~13(346Y7.�LM@ICB85(+*-8�4S(+*-8MHSH685K%K746V346HS4"HS8�EF.7,/CR13H68~�34U 1La.%CB�3HS8�D-D-87:

?A@J0�85i9(3462546.7(38<0�4hEF.%,-CP13H6@JV#85( EF.7,/CG@�*/@P.JEF.7,/CG@R�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS8�M EF�XT �  8�0�4h*-46�".G46(90�13*U*-46Y7."T�.%D/DU4Q@­ 8EF.7,/CR19H6@I*/@PCJ8�0�4Q@I(+*-8<,/85K%.7H68=LZ�38<L5.7(9D-85(+*-.%(3.B0�4|.I*-*-8M(385,/8�(+19.�Y78=EF�½03@PEF�ºK%4  @J.7*U*-8M(�1�*-8%©

� � � K7(94[HS85*U*-8M,/@J�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS8P 8�13(9@PEF�� � g 8 �  8�13("@REF�AT9@IH6HS.%,/@VM ! � T� 8�13(9@PEF��~& g 8 � 8�#WD-.7(3.JEF�|[email protected],Z@VM � #NTaT M � � #�T T M � � #�TbDU.%(3.REF�A:�¯±½�~4685(+*�´ @7H */,-.  8�13(9@PEF� � :?s´ 4Q0�8M@  8�¢+138MHSHQ@�LZ�38�HS8�EF.7,/CB8��3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS4�M�LZ�38�La.%,-,/46D-�#.7(90�.%(3.�@7HSH68��3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34=La.7CB�#.%DU*-8KT

D-.7(3.�.7*U*-8M(�1�*-8�09@IH6HS8¼H68a*-*-8M,-8¼�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(9@7HS4NM�LZ�38�DU*/@7(3(3.��#85, HS8��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94~DU8MCJ�9HS4QLa48TG4S*-8M,/@7(90�.�H68.7�#85,Z@I2M4S.%(34�0�4=(38MK%@I2M4S.%(387T~L5.7(3K%4S19(32546.7(38%T~0�4QDUK%4S13(92546.7(38¼8�La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8%: ��134S("0�4�T�@70�8�DU8MCJ�94S."T~DU.%(3.EF.7,/CB8��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH64�©

C D � � � � �8<�#.74�©y # *,�@��1�%B0�.X'�#�A�#& "0�*X'����&� f #&%�'�*,F/#&%��x56��0�*C0"�$./�"#&!$*(8( "�b#&�+%�1�56����.<'���#@ �#&5TO@./�&#�'����&� f *,� �?*,O@�70".63��56#&%�./�"�B8�*,�&�&./��*K#&�+�&#&%�F/1+*,F/F/#&.

3�;��#"31 "�$56�(�&#&!$�6�G�&�;'�#&56./ "0"�E*,>�#&./%�#S��#&!EZ�#&��'�./%(.w�M*:!$./%( �#&'����E*,>�#&./%��G'�#Q1�%a%�1�56����.D56#&%�./���6'�#S!t*, "#?] # *,����1�%B0".4'�#�A�#& "0�**,�����&#&!$*C0"# AB.�8,#&%BAB��!$�/8C��#�31<��#&!�!�.<3�N#&�/�&#&%�F/1�*,F/F/#&.�8,��#"31<'�#&�"�70"0"�S "./%�.x�&�Kh"0"�E*,'�1(>$#&./%(#&ib%����B�&#&%�F/1+*,F/F/#&.�'����&�M*Q�&./F/#&!$*x�(��./�@./ �#&>�#&./%+*,�&�/]��%D9�1��� "0".�0"�$ �0�.;*,'(.,0"0"#M*,56.�1�%L�E*,F/#&./%��7AB./�&�)!�./56����./56�� � ".X�R�E*X#�'�1(�<��1�%B0�#�'(#�A(#& �0E*(]

" C ���&�M*�����#&5;*X�+*,�"0"�X1� �������56.6�"�$F/./�M*,�"56��%�0"�)� f *,O�O����7A�#M*,>�#&./%��X�R�4PR�@���[�~./�"5;*T���"./�@./ �#&>�#&./%+*,�&�X.;�R./��56�[����./�@./ �#&>�#&./%+*,�&# YE8��#& "���"A/*,%('�.K� f *,O�O��"�7A(#M*,>�#&./%��Q�RO(�2PR�R./��5T1��M*bO@��%H�R./��5;*C0�*b.[�R./��5T1��&��O@��%H�~./�"5;*C0��tY��@���N�M*[��*,�"0"�� "��!$./%('+*<'���'�#&!$*C0E*)*,�&�M*[�&./F/#&!$*'���#����"��'�#&!$*C0�#?]

C e *G�"��F/./�M* )��u!�./%� "��%�0"�6'�#J "0�*,O�#&�&#&���X9�1�*,%�'�.D1(%+*L�� ��(���� � "#&./%��T�R./��5;*C0�*6'+*G "#&5HO@./�&#-'����&� f *,� �~*,O �70".L%(./%}3�T1�%+*G�R��] e ��R�: �./%�.;�&�X�&#& "0"�)'�#2 �#&5HO@./�&#=.,0"0"��%�1(0"�;*��+*,��0�#&�"�T'+*,�&�&�)�&�70�0������T����./�@./ "#&>$#&./%�*,�&#�P0)��(Yb56��'�#M*,%B0��)�&�X./� ����*,>$#&./%(#J'(#-%���FB*,>$#&./%(�B8!�./%�F/#&1�%�>�#&./%��/8@'�#& "F/#&1�%�>�#&./%��<�<!�./%�'�#&>�#&./%+*,�&�6P )��D�*)�� YE] e *H����F/./�M* )��:��9�1�# A/*,�&�)*,'D*C` �$�"5;*,���K!�Z��)� f #&%� �#&��56��'����&�&�K�~��3�<#&���#"31L��#&!�!$./�&.H#&%� �#&��56�[!�Z��)!$./%B0"#&�$%(�X�&�[�&��0�0"�$�"�)����./�@./ �#&>�#&./%+*,�&#=��'u3�K!EZ�#&1( �.��"#& ��@�70"0".;*,�&�&�K9�1+*C0"0"��.6./�@���E*,>�#&./%�#�#&%�'�#&!$*C0��/]

Page 26: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

kI§

M ! C T `M C D T `M � � C T `M � � D T `M ! �KT � � �8<�3,/.%D-85K%1385(903.9©

M !ZM ! C T5T�`M5M ! �KT � M � � D T5T�`M D � M � � D T^T `M � M C D T5T�EM !ZM � � C T5T� � � �8\D-4[.I*U*/85(3K%.7(3.PEF�½Y�46@JY�4Q@P�94U 1½La.%CB�3HS8�D-D-87©

M !ZM5M ! C T � M D � M � � M ! �KT^T5T^T^TM^M^M ! C T HM C � D T^T � M C � M ! �3T^T5TM5M^M5M C � D T � M D 7�KT^T � M D � M ! C T^T^T � M !ZM D � �3T^T5T

� � �

¥ .7CB8 DU4¯Y%8M0�8%Ts�34U 1 L5.7CB�3H68MD/D-@· 8ºH6@�EF�|T_�34U 1  8 0�4F%GL54SH68½HQ@�H68a*-*-13,Z@3:·')H¯,-13.%HS.�0�8MHSH68 �"@I,/85(+*-8�DU4�M�LZ�980�46Y78M(3K7.%(3.<Y�46@RY+4Q@<�34U 1­(�13CB8M,-.+DU8KT_ 8~�3,/.7�9,-46.\¢+1385H6HS.J0�4hLa.7("DU8M(%*/4S,/8�0�4hDU*/@IV94SH64S,/8�46(³CB.�0�.R19(34SY%.�La.\4#�9@7D/D-4CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8_43¢+19@7HS4�HQ@�EF�  8_DU*/@I*/@=.I*-*-85(�1�*Z@�@��9@7,U*/4S,/8¯03@IH6H68 H68a*-*-85,/8b�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64�: g 85(92M@�85(+*-,Z@I,/8 46(P*-,/.7�3�340�85*U*/@7K7H64 *-8�La(34QLa4�.+D-D-85,/Y�46@7CJ. LZ�387TAD-8BD-L5,-46Y�46@7CJ. D-.7H6.­H68J�"@I,/85(+*-8�DU4�LZ�38Ji9K%13,/@7(3.­(985H6HS8JEF�|T�DU4 .I*-*-8M(3K7.%(3.La.%(�i9K%13,/@72546.7(34[¢+19@7HS4:M��"8M,~HS8�13HS*-46CB8<*-,/8=EF�XT ©

M^M5MIT"M5M^M+T^T^T5T^TM^M5MIT"M+T^T@M^MIT5T^T

M5M^M5MIT"M+T^T@M^MIT5T^T@M^MIT5T^T¡sV9V"8M(387T3D-4h�31� .G0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@7,-8�LZ�38=13( @IH6HS46(38M@7CB85(+*-.B0�4|13(º(�13CB85,/.P�"@I,/4h034[�9@I,/85(+*-8�DU4[@7�"8M,U*/8=8�LZ�34619D-8

MF46(J13K719@7H�(+19CJ8M,-.DTA0385H�K78M(385,/8b@ICBCB8a*U*/8b13(PD-.7H6.Q0_>)>G< JBJ .10/Pc4"9X(h< J 25< J 2L.1<�I�:�¥ 4) .=L5.7(9D-85(+*/8_0�43034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8H�´ 46CB�".%,U*Z@I(+*-8%©�_�+�"����°� � � & ��� !�� ����$7���9�����b���+$%�"�°���"�����%���#����" �p4@2H<GA39X. EF� � WK037F4H*&9;0 4),k*&9S0='@</7F0 ,B4@787F4�'"4M�AB*-4"9X(I.:>)</9S,/[email protected]</9X.��e%: � �4a*&9S0c7F4@(+(h4@250 J 25< J <K'[email protected]</9S0/7F4��k3:O4L'L.g'L(h4O*&9;064G,�*&9;0�'@<37F0<EF�$# (\0/7F4�>Gf-4 ��� M ! #NT��>9:O4L'L.g'L(h<39;< 4L'@03(I(\0/Pc4"9X(h4i,/*-4REF� #�4 � 4G,H*&9 *&9X.1>G< >)</9X9;4@(I(+.8WK< �".89S0/2L.1< � � � (h037l. >)fR4� < M # � ��T���~8MH3L5@%DU.\k=DU4"0�46L58¯LZ�38¯H6@�EF� �  8b13(9@�9S4+Ad0`[email protected]<39;4@m%(38MH9L5@%DU.�>3T+DU8 � < _T%@IH6H6.7,Z@ �  8b13("@Q>)<39dAB.8*&[email protected]</9S4aT

D-8 � < � [email protected],Z@ �  8J13(9@[,/.g'^A3.8*&9&[email protected]</9;4<87T|D-8 � < � T|@IH6H6.7,Z@ �  8P19( >)</9S,/[email protected]</9S0/7F45:B�~85HsLM@7D-.ºk !� 8J4SH>)</9X9;4@(I(+.8WK< J 2L.89S>". J 0/7F4�0�8MHSHQ@PEF�|T3(38MHAL5@%DU.B> �  8�46H >)</9X9;4@(I(+.8W/< J 2L.89S>". J 0/7e4�0�8MHSHQ@PEF�|:g 4 �31� .½0�85i9(346,-8 >)</P J 7F4"')'L.8( �0B0�4�19(9@³EF��46H�(+19CJ8M,-.º0�4sLa.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4��3,/8MD-85(+*-4 46(�8�D-D/@­@713CB85(+*/@I*-. 0�4beMF46( */@7H|CB.�0�.7H68<HS85*U*/85,/8<�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH64hD-.7(9.BEF� 034�La.%CB�3HS8�D-D-4S*l @ºeETa: � K7(94hEF� � LZ�38<(3.%( D-4Q@P19(9@GH68a*U*/85,Z@�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH68R 8=.7*U*/85(�1�*/@BCB8�0�46@7(+*-8�� � T2�~&º.��¯±�03@J13([email protected]�138�EF�½0�4AL5.7CB�3H68MD/DU4S*l @PCB4S(9.7,/87:

q�}�����}~{|tcq }�tJ}~q ��o {|tcq�}�o��Ut')( �3,/4SCB.BHS19.7K7.J46(%*/,-.�0�1"[email protected]@I(9LZ�38�H68=EF�¼La.%DU*-,/134S*-8<La.%( 46H|V34QLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8 � ©

M ��� #�T� 8�4S(+*-8�[email protected]<@IV3V3,/85Y�4Q@I2M4S.%(38=034jM^M � � #NT =M # � � T5TK P-�$!�%�#&!$*,56��%B0��/8@1�%oBnEn�k E/E mRoBrHqH.+s�k E�J k E�J m~k;3�<1�%+*H�R1�%�>�#&./%��)O�#&1�%(# AB.�!$*��L0"�E*��&�<�+*,�"�$%B0"�$ "#- �#&%�#& �0��"�K�)'��� "0"���K0�*,�&#�!EZ��/8 ����v3�K1�%+*��+*,�"��%�0"�� �#� "#&%�#& "0"�E*(8���P � YK3�K1�%+*H��*,����%�0"�� �#-'��� �0���*H!EZ��<�M*H "��F/1��<%����&� f *,�&�&#&%��$*,56��%�0".H�/8+ "��� � ��� � � �./%�.���*,����%�0"�� �#

�#&%(#& "0"���[0�*,�&#�!EZ(�����-���"��!$��'������ � 8+*,�&�&./��*���P ��� �?Y[3�<1�%+*T�+*,����%B0��� �#-'(�$ �0���*H!EZ��<�(����!��$'(����P ����YE]

Page 27: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

k+]g .7*U*-.%HS46(38M46@7CJ. LZ�98�HS8�EF�ÁDU.%(3.�.I*-*-85(�1�*/8�La.%CB8°4S("0�46LM@�*/.�(385H6H6@ 0�8ai9(94S2M4S.%(38°46(90�1�*-*-46Yl@ �3,/8MLa8�0�85(3�

*-8%:�Ã=4) @�09@IH6H�´ 4S(94S2M4S.�0385Hb(3.%DU*-,/.�0�4QD/La.7,ZD-.¼@IV3V34Q@ICB.¼1"D-@I*-.¼H68 H68a*-*-8M,-8 CB@74S1"D-L5.7H68­0�4_4S(3462546.�0385H6H�´ @IHSE�@IV#8a*/.M � # � � � �lTJ�#85,G46(90�4QL5@I,/8ºEF��¢%1"@IHQDU4Q@7D-4�: ��1346(90�4�© � # � � � �?M�L5.7(Å85Y%85(+*-1"@IH64b@7�34QLa4~.�46(90�4QLa48TBDU.%(3.Y�@I,/46@7V346HS4�CB8a*Z@�*/85.7,/4QLZ�38B�"8M,�EF�|: ¿�(9@½D-L5,-4S*U*/13,Z@ L5.7CB8³¢+1385H6H6@ LZ�38³@7V3V34Q@ICB.½@I�3�#85("@º@%0�.7�#85,Z@�*/.9T|8³L54S.9 8M^M � � #�T M�# � � T^TaT9(3.%(º,Z@I�9�3,-8�DU8M(+*/@\19(9@JEF�kMFCB85(+*-,/87T"@70 8MD-85CB�346.9T M5M C � D T =M D � C T^TaT9.%�3�313,/8M^M5M C � �3T � M ! D T^T M^M ! D T � M C � �3T5T^TbD-.7(3.REF�XT T3�#.74QLZ�$#8 � 8 #p(3.7(ºDU.%(3.PD-46CRV#.7H64h0385HhHS46(3K%19@IK%K746.R0�[email protected]@J�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS8%T+CG@JY�@I,/46@7V346HS4[CB8a*Z@�*/85.7,/4QLZ�387: g L5,-4S*U*/13,/8\0�4A¢+138MDU*-.BK%85(38M,-8<D-.7(3.G@7D/D/@I4#EF,-8�¢+1385(+*-4A8�3,/85(903.7(3.G46HA(3.%CB8\0�4:'@>)fR4@PN.|0�4AEF�|:¯�s4U 1 �3,-8�La4QD-@7CB85(+*-8%T313(3.­D/LZ�38MCB@G034|EF�¼@I�9�9@I,/8\La.%CJ8<19(9@JEF��D/@IH6Y7.LZ�38 La.%(%*/4S8M(387T @IHb�".+Dc*/.�034~@IHQLa13(38[MF.�*/1�*U*/8ETPHS8 H68a*-*-85,/8º�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH64�Ts0�8MHSH68 Y�@I,/46@7V34SH64_CJ85*/@I*-85.%,-4QLZ�38%T8B¢%194S(9034�oU,Z@I�3�3,/8MD-85(+*Z@BqB(38MHSHQ@ºCJ85*/@I*-85.%,-4Q@³19(|´ 46(�i9(94 *� @º034�EF�AT|8P�9,-8�La4QD-@7CJ8M(+*-8B¢%1985H6HS8BLZ�38BDU4 .I*-*-8M(3K7.%(3.D-.%DU*-4S*-138M(90�.¼0�8MHSH68³EF�°@7H��#.%DU*-.¼0�8MHSH68³Y�@I,/46@7V346HS4sCB85*/@�*/85.%,-4QLZ�38³0�8MHSH6.�D/LZ�385CG@ �I: Â~46L5.7,Z0�46@7CB.½4S(3.%H */,-8³LZ�98H�´ 46(9D-4S8MCJ8J0�4�*-1�*-*-8JHS8REF�� 8J0�85(9.I*/@I*-.­L5.7( �³T[¢+138MHSH6.­0�8MHSH68PH68a*-*-8M,-8P�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH64ALa.%( �J:�¿�D-46@7CJ. �".%4�4D-4SCPV".%HS4�CJ85*/@I*-85.%,-4QLa4�©����������������#85,~46(90�4QL5@7,-8<H68a*-*-85,/8\�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS4|@7,-V34S*-,Z@I,/4687:���85H�D-85K%134S*-.³L5@7�34S�*-8M,l @GD-�#8MD/DU.³0�4�0�.�Y78M,�La.%(9D-460�8M,/@7,-8=46(9DU4685CB4 0�4|EF�A:b� 8M,~8MD/D-4|19D-85,/85CB.GHS8RHS85*U*-8M,-8 � � �� M�85Y%85(+*-19@7HSCB8M(%*/8La.%(º@7�34QLa4|.B46(90�4QLa48T :�A�9����������M���"��� ���_� ����+�h�����M�¥ .7CB8B85CB8M,-K%8JK%4  @º03@74��".�LZ�34s8�DU8MCB�34�i9(3.%,/@ 8MD-�#.%DU*-4�T|HS8BEF��Y%85(3K%.7(3. @ La.7(+*/85(38M,-8J13(�K7,Z@I(�(+19CJ8M,-.½0�4�9@7,-8M(%*/8MD-4�T��"8M,/@7H */,-. (38�La8�D-D/@I,/4S8J�#85,\K+@I,Z@I(+*-46,-8JHQ@½0�8ML5.7CB�".%(346V34SH64S*l @ 13(34QL5@½0385H6HS8GEF��DU*-8�D-D-87:  ¡¦�#.%D/D-4SV346H68La.%CR13("¢%1987T3La.%CB8=46(½@IH6K78MV3,/@9T%,/4Q0�13,/,-8�46H[(+19CJ8M,-.G0�8MHSH68<�9@7,-8M(%*/8MD-4[DU8M(32M@J�#85,Z0�85,/8�H�´ 13(346Y7.�La4S*l @G0�4[H68a*-*-13,Z@3:')(��3,/4SCB.�H613.7K%.�DU4~�#.%D/D-.7(3.°D-85CB�3,/8½85H64SCB46(9@I,/8 HS8�0�138¼�9@7,-8M(+*-8MD-4¯�34U 1�8MDU*-8M,-(38%: ')(3.%H */,-8¼D-4�@%0�.I*-*/@�HQ@La.%(�Y785(92546.7(38\LZ�38�! H685K+@B�34U 1�Dc*/,-85*U*Z@ICB85(+*-8P0�4 8 � T#4 ¢%1"@IH64�@BH6.7,/.GY7.7HS*/@BH685K+@I(3.G�94U 1�DU*-,/8a*-*/@7CJ8M(+*-8R0�4� : ?A8=L5.7(3K%4S19(32546.7(34#8�H68�0�46D-K74613(32M4S.%(34#,-46�"85*-1�*/8cM�La.%CB8�K74) @R038a*U*/.P(985H6H�´ � D-D-85,/Y�@I2M4S.%(38~OP0385H � e%:SeKTsY�@I(9(3.46(%*/8MD-8<La.7CB8\@%D-D-.�La4Q@�*-8�@BDU46(34QDc*/,/@9:���134S("0�4�©

M C D T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( C DM^M ! D T � �3T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( ! D � �M !ZM D � �3T^T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( !ZM D � �3TM^M ! C T � D T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( ! C � DM !ZM C D T^T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( !ZM C D TM C � M !ZM D �3T^T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( C � !ZM D �3TM C � M^M ! D T �3T5T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( C � ! D �M^M ! C T � !ZM C M ! D T5T^T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( ! C � !ZM C �! D TM !ZM C � M^M5M ! �3T � D T5T � M ! C T^T^T5T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( !ZM C � ! � � D � ! C TM^M !ZM C � M ! �3T^T5T � M D � M ! C T^T^T D-4|@IV9V3,-8MY�46@J46( !ZM C � ! �3T � M D � ! C T

� 3, O@�$%(�b0"�$%(�$�S������ ���%B0��b!EZ�� � 1���1 L 1������� "./%�.)�&��0�0"�$�"�['�# AB���" ��/8�56�$%B0"��� /.1 2 1�� 1������B�@./ � "./%�.X#&%�'�#&!$*,����*,%�!EZ(�K�M*K "0"�� � E*<�R��]

Page 28: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

kI¤

Page 29: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ����� ������ �

� � �;��� � � �j��� � � � ����� � �� ��� �

� � � �p�� � � � ���

����� ���������������! "����#¨~Y%85(903.�@�0346D-�".+DU462546.7(98º46H~H64S(9K719@7K7K746.�0385H6H6@�H6.7K%46LM@��3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS8 DU4Q@ICB.�46( K%,/@%0�.�0�4~46CJ�#.%DU*/@7,-8 46(CB.�0�.B�34U 1 ,/4SK%.7,/.%D-.R46H|�3,/.7V3H685CG@JLZ�38\@[email protected]*-,Z@�*/.J(985H6H6@J�3,/85CB8MD/D/@3: ')H|,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-."©

� 9S,/2 �<�.89 WK0_>)0/9DCE0�.89 0B4@254)<H<�.89 0/*&(\</Pc< �@.87F4 � � 46039;,32 �<�.89 0_4"2G4G<iA3.8*&9DA_4@2 �< J 2L.8PQ0 0,B4"')(+.89;[email protected]</9;4E�Z4N9S</9 J <3(I2 �< J <32L(h03254NPQ<37l(\4OW/0/7U.UA3.14 � � 4�0/9;,32 �<i.89[03*&(h<3PQ< �".87F4 J </(+2 �< J <32L(h03254PQ<37l(h4HW/0/7l.UAB.14 � � 4 0/WE2 �< *&9S0kW/0B>)0/9&CE0 >)</9 �"</2L(\4"W/</7e4 �i03787F</250 03W`2 �< J </2L(\0/(\<kPc</7l(\4=WK037l.UA3.14 �� *&.89S,/. ��'@4�0/WE2 �<�*&9S0QWK0_>)0/9DCE0V>)</9 �"<32L(h4@W/</7F4E�Z03787F</250�'@0/2 �<V0/9S,B0/(\<c.89[0/*&(\</Pc< �@.87F4 �

�31� .B8�D-D-85,/8=EF.7,/CB@7HS46252�@�*/.P(38MH|CB.�0�.GDU8MK7138M(%*/87:�� .7(985(90�."©C < @I(903,l .B46(ºY�@%L5@I(92M@P4S(½@I8M,-8M.D < @I(903,l .B46(ºY�@%L5@I(92M@P4S(½@I13*-.7CB.%V34SH68� < K74613(3K%85,� .P�3,/46CB@B@G0�8�Dc*/4S("@I2546.7(98� < �".7*-,� .B�".%,U*Z@I,/8=CB.%H */8=Y�@7HS46K7468E < @lY�,l .J13(9@BY�@7LM@I(32�@PL5.7(�EF.%,U*/85Y%.7H68

H68~�3,/85CB8MD/DU8¯0�8MH9,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.�D-43�#.%D/DU.%(3.�8MD-�3,/4SCB85,/8¯46(a M�D-49.+D-D-85,/Y�43LZ�38¯H6@�oU._q�0�8MHSHQ@��3,/4SCG@��3,/85CB8�D-D/@ 8�LZ�34Q@I,Z@ICB85(+*-8�13( o/@I1�*)q3T�8<LZ�38=4SHpo-CB@_qR0�8MHSHQ@JDU8�La.7("03@R�9,-8MCJ8�D-D/@3T�03@7H[�313(+*-.B0�4[Y�46DU*/@PY78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS8%T 8�46(%*/85,/�3,/8a*/@7V346HS8�La.%CJ8�13("@GLa.7(9K74613(32546.7(98ET ©

M C �! D T � M ! C D T"m C � � ! �_m D � �_m E � �

8<[email protected](9L5HS1"DU46.7(38=,/46D-13HS*/@3© E � D :¨~("@IH6.7K%@7CB85(+*-8%T+46HAD-85K%1385(+*-8�,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.9©� 4=� .825>)< �4�PQ<32L(h< J 4@2�>G03*D'@4c9;03(I*&2G0/7l.!4),H4@250�039;,B03(h<=,B037:PQ4),3.1>G< ��0/787e</250H.87�PQ4),3.1>G< �4

')(\0/(\<V9;4hAB7l.UAd4"9X(h4 � � .825>)<H4@250�039;,B03(h<H,B0/7jPQ4),/.1>)<=4c.87�Pc4G,3.1>)< �4Q'L(\0/(\<V9;4hAB7l.UA_4@9-(\4 � � *&.89;,/.��.82G>G< �4aPc</2L(\< J 4@2O>G03*D'@4a9S0/(+*&250/7l.

�#.7(38M(90�.9©C < �½46,/L5.  8=CB.%,U*/.J�#85,�L5@I1"DU8=(9@�*/13,Z@IH64D < �½46,/L5.B85,Z@P@7(903@�*/.G03@IH[CB8M0346L5.� < 46H|CB8M0�4QLa.  8<DU*/@�*/.B(385K%HS46K78M(%*/8

k7�

Page 30: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>7fD-4h*-,Z@70�19L58<4S(c�CB8M0�4Q@I(+*/8<HS8<D-85K71985(+*-4[�3,/85CB8�D-D-87© C D � �Dm D ��T98�[email protected]("LaH619DU46.7(98 C :')H��3,/.7V3H685CG@º0�85H6HQ@½La.7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@­03854�0�198J,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4�DU4 */,/@%0�19La8B(38MHSH6.½Dc*Z@IV346H64S,/8GDU8BHQ@­EF� E � D  8La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@P0�8MHSH�´ 4S(9D-4685CB8\0�4[EF�|©

M C �! D T � M ! C D T"m C � � ! �_m D � �_m E � � 8\D-8=HQ@PEF� C  8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@PHS.%K74QL5@J0�85H6H�´ 46(9DU4685CB8\0�4|EF�|©

C D � �Dm D � � V3468a*-*-46Y7. �3,/4S(9L54S�"@IH68B034�¢+138MDU*-.½L5@7�34S*-.7H6.� 8G¢%1985H6HS.¼0�4��3,-8�DU8M(+*/@I,/8J13(9@ 0�8ai"(34S2M4S.%(38³0�8MH�La.%(9La85*U*-.½0�4

>)</9-'"4hAB*-4"9&CE0c7F<GA3.1>)0=*/,/@PEF�¼0�4� LZ�38<�".+D-D/@J8MD/DU8M,-8=1�*/4SH64S2M2M@I*-.G�#85,~,/46D-.7H6Y78M,-8�4SHA�3,-.%V3H685CG@J�3,-.%�".+Dc*/.9:<��@IH680�85i9(3462546.7(38_*-,Z@70313,-,� @3T�,/85HQ@�*/4SY�@7CJ8M(+*-8b@IH�H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.=0385H6H6@=H6.7K74QL5@��3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH687Tl46H9La.%(9La85*U*/.=46(+*-134S*-46Y7.�46(V9@%DU8�@IH[¢+19@IH68=13(9@J�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38\ 8�La.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@RHS.%K74QL5@P0�4|@IHS*-,/8=D-8P 8�Y%85,Z@\.%K7(34Q¢+19@IH6Y7.%H *Z@\¢+138MDU*-8=13HS*-46CJ8D-.7(3. Y78M,-8%:  ¡�(38�La8�D-D/@I,/4S. ¢+1346(90�4�46(+*-,/.�0�13,/,-8B13(9@ (9.72546.7(98³0�4sY78M,-4S*l @ �#85,RHS8BEF�°0�4T�:¼¥ 4  .½Y�4685(38BE�@I*U*/.@�*-*-,Z@lY78M,/D-.<4SH|L5.7(9L58a*-*-.B0�4�WK037l*&([email protected]</9;4aMF.V.89-(\4"2 J 254"(\0`[email protected]<39;4GT :s')( DU46(+*-8�DU4�T�13(9@PYl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38�@�*U*/,-46V3134QD/La8=13(Y�@IH6.7,/8\0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @ M � .��!T~@IH6HS8<H68a*-*-85,/8\�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS4[8%T"La.%CB8<Y78M03,-8MCJ.G�94U 1½46(¼0�8a*-*/@7K7H64S.G(38MHA�3,/.%D/D-4SCB.�9@7,/@7K7,Z@�EF.9T98MD/D-@³038a*-8M,-CB46(9@G13(�Yl@7HS.%,-8P0�4�Y%85,/4 *� @G�#85,�La4Q@7D/La13(9@GEF��0�85H�H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.a�:<¥ 4  .ºLa4 La.7("DU8M(%*/4S,� @0�4A038ai9(346,/8=46( CB.�03.J,/46K7.7,/.%D-.RHQ@J(3.72M4S.%(38<0�4AL5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@3:

����� � �N�! "�N� � # ��a���� E����# �3�����C��� #?��� ���@ ¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q���� ! �<�3 ����M�9�7���#��� ! �����h�M�+l����+�M�3�%���#����"3" � .:,/.1>)4�Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38QM5<=46(%*/85,/�3,/8a*/@72546.7(38KT*&9;0C!@*-0/7l').10/'L.��)*&[email protected]</9S4�� ,B0/7875] .89R'L.14"Pc4�� ,B4@787F467F4"(+(\4"254 J 25< J </')[email protected]<39;0/7U.�0/7875] .89R'L.14"Pc4 � H� =,[email protected]/0/7F<32L.,/[email protected]( �0 �

¿~("@ Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38��"T ¢+1346(90�4�T�@%D-D-85K%(9@ @ L546@%D-L513(9@ºHS85*U*/85,Z@ �3,-.%�".+DU462546.7("@IH68 �·13(3.¼0�8M4 0�138GY�@7HS.%,-4s0�4Y78M,-4S*l @9©� DU8��SM ��T�< � D-4A0�4QLa8<LZ�38��° 8�Y785,Z@P(385H6H6@JY�@IH61�*[email protected](98�;m� DU8��SM ��T�< �ÀD-4A0�4QLa8<LZ�38��° 8=E�@7H6D/@J(385H6H6@JY�@IH61�*[email protected](98�#:

¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q��Q� ! �<�3 ����M�9�7���#���½®��|�# ����3����" � .p,/.1>)4<Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98RV#.+.%HS8�@I(9@k,_4"787^] .89-'L.14"Pc4 � ,B4@787F4� J *&9;0�!@*-0/7 'L.10/'). �)*&[email protected]<39;4�� ,_0/787^] .89-').14@Pc4 � 0/787^] .89-').14@Pc4 � H� �,[email protected]</2L.p,/. [email protected]( �0 >Gf-4�'@<`,_,/.g'��"0 7F4'@4hA3*-4@9-(+.!"*-03(I(+25<�>)</9S,/[email protected]</9X.��

MceKT �SM ! � T < � '@4 �SM � T�< ��SM ! � T < � '@4 �SM � T�< �

M�k_T �SM � #�T�< � '@4 �SM � T�<�SM�#�T�< ��SM � #�T�< � '@4 �SM � T�< � <��;M #NT�< � F <64@9-(+250/P �)40H

M�>dT �SM ��� #�T�< � '@4 �SM � T�< � <��SM�#�T�< � F <64@9-(+250/P �)40H�SM ��� #�T�< � '@4 �SM � T�<�SM�#�T�< �

MFODT �SM � � #NT< � '@4 �SM � T�< � <��;M #NT�< � F <i4"9X(I2503P �)4�H�SM � � #NT< � '@4 �SM � T�< � 4��SM�#�T�< �

¿~("@¼Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38­V".�.7H68M@7(9@� 8 13(9@�@7D/DU8MK7([email protected](38G0�4bY�@IH6.7,/4 0�4_Y78M,-4S*l @�@IH6HS8³EF�·0�4�ÁLZ�98­,/46D-�"85*U*Z@¼H68*/@lY%.7H68¼0�4=Y785,/4S*l @�0�8M4=L5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4�L5.7CB8¼46(+*-,/.�03.I*U*/8�(38MH � e7:6e�0�85H=L5@7�34 */.7H6.°�3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/87:  ¡µ@I*U*/,/@lY%85,ZDU.¢+138MDU*/@P0�8ai"(34S2M4S.%(38�LZ�98�4[DU46CRV#.7H64 !_T _T � T � MF4[¢+19@IH64�T+(985H#HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.v�T�Y�@I(3(3.P4S(+*/8MD-4#L5.7CB8��319,-4[D-85K7(94K7,Z@�i#La48T D-.7(9.J@%D-D-.�La4Q@�*-4[@74ALa.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4[Y785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%([email protected](94SCB4 � :

')H[,/46D-13HS*/@�*/.JEF.7(903@7CB85(+*/@7HS8%T3LZ�38<DU4|�91� .G0�4SCB.+Dc*/,/@7,-8=,-46K7.%,-.+D-@7CB85(+*-8��"8M,¯4S(903132546.7(38%T| 8�46H|DU8MK7138M(%*/87©� @J���b9�1��� �0E*6�E*,F/#&./%(�T*,�&!�1�%(#2*,1(0�./�"#-�����7�R����#& �!�./%�.H#&%�'�#&!$*,���)#&%:56.�'�.�'�# AB���" �.6#�!�./%�%��70�0�# A�#-AB����.�f?�R1�%�>�#&./%+*,�&#-%����&�M*�56�70�*Lf

0"�$./�"#M*T�K%(�$�&�M*)0���./�"#M*(] C ���� B]/]�]K'����=!t*,�(# 0�./�&.��(����!��$'(�$%B0"�B8 *�A(�"��5656.X�@.,0"1(0".6#&%�'�#&!$*,���b#�!�./%�%��70�0�# A�#�'�#=%���FB*,>$#&./%(�B8�!$./%(F/#&1�%[f>�#&./%��/8�'(#& �F/#&1�%�>�#&./%��X�X!$./%('�#&>�#&./%+*,�&�/8�!�./%�8�*,'w�� ���56��#&.�8�������8������+8����+8�� �"!�!�!#��$&%��"!�!�!D�X./�E*6#&%�0"�������"�70E*,�"�B8 56��'�#M*,%B0��X�M*'��7\+%�#&>�#&./%��)���"��!$��'���%B0��/8@#�%(./ "0"��#�9�1+*C0�0��".6 �#&5TO ./�&#@'�# %d./�"'�#&%+*C0�*,56�$%B0"�<#&%D9�1��� "0"#�9�1�*C0"0"��.6!�./%�%��70�0�# A�#�AB����.�f?�R1�%�>�#&./%+*,�&#?]

Page 31: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>9e���9� �"�����%���#��� ��Q���� �N03(h0�*&9;0�W/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]<39;4 � ,_4"787F4i7F4@(+(h4@254 J 25< J <K'[email protected]</9S0/7l. �O4"'L.g')(\46*&9;0�4), *&9S0V'@</7F0W/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]</9S4 �G<E</7e4G039;0V,B4@787^] .89R'L.14@PQ4c,_4"787e4 � J >)fR4�>G<3.89;>@.1,B4c>)</9 �H'L*&787F4O7F4@(I(\4@254 J 25< J <K'[email protected]</9S0/7l.��

')(�@7H */,-4 *-8M,-CB46(34�T DU8 DU4b@7D/D-85K7("@½13(�Y�@7HS.%,-8­034_Y%85,/4 *� @�@7HSH68­H68a*-*-85,/8­�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(9@7HS4�T Y�4= 8­13(3.�8M0�13(D-.7H6.�CB.�0�.��#85,B8�Dc*/85(90�8M,-H6.�@�*-13*U*-8 H68­EF� 46(·CB.�0�.�LZ�98ºD-46@7(3.�,/4QDU�#8a*-*/@�*/8 HS8 La.%(90�462546.7(34 MceKT+YSM�OdTP0�85H6HQ@0�85i9(3462546.7(38��3,-8�La8�0�85(+*-8%:�¥ 4  .³ 8�46CJCB8�0�46@I*/@PLa.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@\0385H6H6@P0�8ai9(94S2M4S.%(38�46(90�1�*-*-46Y�@P0�4#EF�|© .%K7(34"EF� �  8.I*-*-8M(+13*/@B4S*-85,Z@I("0�.BHS8\¢+19@I*U*-,/.B.7�#85,Z@I2M4S.%(34|@B�9@I,-*-46,/8�09@J@7H6L513(38<H68a*-*-85,/8<�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64+m3¢%194S(9034�T�*/,/@7CB4 */8H68�La.%(90�462546.7(34 MUeEThYSMFODT T+4SH"Y�@IH6.7,/8~0�49Y%85,/4 *� @<@�*U*/,-46V3134S*-.P@IH6HS8¯H68a*-*-85,/8~�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS43D-43*/,/@%DUCB8a*-*-8�@I*U*/,/@lY%85,ZDU.H68\DU.7*U*-.7EF.7,/CR13H68=Y+4Q@JY�46@J�34U 1½La.7CB�3H68MD/D-8�i"(3.G@IH6H6@PEF� � :�=�M����� ��� � � � ��� g 4Q@ � <%!ZM C D � �3T � M D � !ZM C D T^T 8�GH6@PY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��"8M,¯H6@J¢+19@IH687© �;M C T�< ��T�SM D T�< ��T �;M �3T < ��:

��19@7(90�. �SM C T�< �N8 �;M D T)<���[email protected],Z@3T�46(�V9@%DU8­@7HSHQ@¼L5H6@719DU.%H6@ M�kBTaT �;M C D T�< ��:�')(·V9@7D-8­@7HSHQ@LaHQ@I1"DU.%H6@cM�OdT T�D-8��;M C D T< �·8 �;M �/T < ��[email protected],Z@�;M C D � �3T�< ��T%CB8M(%*/,-8%T%46(GV9@%DU8�@7HSHQ@<LaHQ@I1"DU.%H6@cMUeET T�SM !ZM C D T^T�< ��: g 8 �;M C D � �3T�< ��T%@7HSH6.7,Z@��SM !ZM C D � �3T^T�< ���#85,�HQ@[email protected]@OMceKT TI8%T7D-8 �SM D T�< �8 �SM !ZM C D T5T�< ��[email protected],Z@��;M D � !ZM C D T^T�< � �"8M,�HQ@­L5H6@719DU.%H6@ M�>_Ta:�')(�i9(987T[DU8 �;M !ZM C D � �3T2< �8 �SM D � !ZM C D T^T=<���[email protected],Z@ �;M � T=< �N46(°V9@%DU8­@7HSHQ@¼L5H6@719DU.%H6@kM�OdTa: ��1346(90�4�Ts03@IH_Y�@IH6.7,/8³0�4 Y%85,/4 *� @@�*-*-,/4SV9134 */.º@7HSH68RH68a*-*-8M,-8J�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64AD-4�,/4QD-@7HS8P4S(�CJ.�0�. 13(346Y7.�La."T[@I�3�3H64QL5@I("0�.­H68PL5H6@719DU.%HS8VMceKT+YSM�OdTaTh@%0@�*-*-,/4SV9134S,/8�13( Y�@IH6.7,/8=0�4AY785,/4S*l @B@IH6H6@REF�¼03@I*/@3: �

�=�M����� ��� � � � � � ¥[email protected]@7CJ."T�4S(½V"@7D-8\@IH6H6@GDU*-8�D-D/@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38\0�8MHSH�´ ¡�D-85CB�346.­k�:�k�:6e7T346HAY�@IH6.7,/8<0�4AY%85,/4 *� @0�8MHSHQ@PEF��# < !ZM ! C � D T � M ! D �3T :g 4��9@3© �;M ! C T$< ��T��SM ! C � D T$< ��T �;M !ZM ! C � D T5T < ��T �;M ! D T < ��T �SM ! D �3T$< ��:b')(�i9(987T"09@�SM !ZM ! C � D T^T�< � 8��SM ! D �3T�< ��T9D-85K%138��;M #NT�< � MF46(ºV"@7D-8�@7HSHQ@[email protected]@VM�>_T5T : �

�=�M����� ��� � � � � & r�8a*/85,/CJ46([email protected].%,/@R4SHhY�@IH6.7,/8�034#Y%85,/4 *� @RD-85CB�3,/8=0385H6H6@REF��#p0�85H6H�´ ¡ DU8MCJ�94S.Gk�:�k�:�k�T+CG@R46(V9@%DU8<@IH6HQ@JD-85K%1385(+*/8=Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(387©

�;M C T�< � �;M D T�< � �;M �/T < �g 4��9@3© �;M ! C T�< ��T �SM ! C � D T < ��T �;M !ZM ! C � D T^T$< ��T �;M ! D T$< ��T �SM ! D �3T�< ��:¯')(�¢+138�Dc*/.

L5@%DU."T�03@��;M !ZM ! C � D T^T�< � 8��SM ! D �3T�< ��T3D-85K%138<LZ�38��SM�#NT < ��: �

�=�M����� ��� � � � � ±�¥ .%(9DU4Q0�8M,-4Q@ICB.³HQ@GEF� � < M C � ! �3T kM D � ! �3T=8JL5@IHQLa.%HS4Q@ICB.%(38\46H�Y�@7HS.%,-8R034�Y%85,/4 *� @46(ºV"@7D-8�@7HSHQ@JY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��G�#85,~HQ@B¢%1"@IH687©

�;M C T�< � �SM D T�< � �;M �/T < �g 4|�"@3© �;M ! �3T < ��T��SM C � ! �3T < ��T �;M D � ! �/T < �d�#85,�L5134 �SM ��T�< ��:g 8�46(+Y%8ML58=HQ@JY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38B 8=*/@7HS8<LZ�38%©

�SM C T�< � �;M D T�< � �SM �3T < �D-4[�9@3© �SM ! �3T < ��T �SM C � ! �3T�< ��T��SM D � ! �3T�< � �"8M,�La134 �;M ��T�< �<: �

� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � :=¿�(9@³Y�@IH61�*[email protected](987T#�"8M,=0�85i9(3462546.7(38%T[@7D/DU8MK7(9@G19(¼Y�@IH6.7,/8R0�4 Y78M,-4S*l @³@³*-1�*-*-8JHS8PHS85*U*/85,/8�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64�:  ¡À0�85H�*/1�*U*/. .�Y�Y�4S. LZ�38P46H Y�@IH6.7,/8P0�4 Y78M,-4S*l @ LZ�38R19(9@³EF� � ,-4QLa8MY78R46(�V"@7D-8P@70�13(9@º03@�*Z@Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38P0�4S�#85("0�8PD-.7H6.­03@74AY�@IH6.7,/4�0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @GLZ�98\H6@­Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38\@%D-D-85K%(9@G@IH6HS8RHS85*U*-8M,-8P�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64LZ�38=i9K%13,/@7(3.J(385H6H6@JEF� � :

r=@�*/@°13(9@�EF� � T~DU4��31� . 0�8a*/85,/CJ46(9@7,-8¼¢+19@7HS8¼Y�@7HS.%,-8¼0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @°@%D-D-13CB8¼@IH�Y�@I,/46@7,-8¼0�8MHSH68¼�#.%D/DU46V346HS4Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(34+m%¢+138�Dc*/8b13H */4SCB8~D-.7(3.=46(�i9(34S*-8¯CG@3T%4S(JV9@%DU8¯@�¢+19@I(+*-.�8�DU�#.%DU*-.=(385H6HQ@��9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8 � D/DU8M,-Y�@I2M4S.%(38e7ThD-46LMLa.7CB8RL5.7(+*/@7(3.³D-.7H6.³4�Y�@7HS.%,-4A034�Y%85,/4 *� @³@7D/DU19(%*/4�03@7HSH68\H68a*-*-85,/8R�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(9@7HS4�LZ�38<i9K%13,/@7(3.G46( � ThH68¢[email protected](3. 46(�(�13CB85,/.ºi9(34S*-."TA4�LM@7D-4 09@º*-,Z@�*U*Z@I,/8JD-.7(9.º46(�(+19CJ8M,-.ºi9(94 */.9:³�s4U 1��3,-8�La4QD-@7CB85(+*-8%TADU8B46( �Y�4_D-.7(9. ��HS85*U*-8M,-8 �3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64�T�H68­�#.%D/DU46V346HS4 Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(34 LZ�98 0�4Fb#8M,-4QD/La.7(9.¼�"8M,R46H CB.�0�.�0�4 Y�@7HS1�*Z@I,/8@IH6CB85(3.º13(9@ H68a*U*/85,Z@ LZ�98Ri9K%13,Z@­46( � D-.7(3.½k � :B¥ .+D)  $�T[@70�8MD-85CB�346.9T[�#85,�HQ@­�3,/8ML58M0�8M(+*-8PEF� �JT|4sLM@7D-4�09@8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/8RD-.7(3.­.I*U*/.­8P4�,/4QDU13HS*/@I*-4 DU4��#.%D/DU.%(3.³,/4S�#.7,-*/@7,-8\(985H6H6@ DU8MK7138M(%*/8<*/@7V"8MHSHQ@HM�@I(9@7HS.%K%@³@ ¢+1385H6HS8PK74) @46(9La.%(%*/,/@I*-8�(38MH|L5@I�94 */.7H6.J�9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8KT ©

Page 32: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>%kC D � M C � ! �/T M D � ! �/T� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �

')Hh,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/.Ri9("@IH68J 8�([email protected](9([email protected]*-*-.B@IH[La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.J�3,/4S("La46�9@IH68cMF46(º¢+138�Dc*/.JLM@7D-. �Ta: g 4[Y78�0�8=LZ�9846H�Y�@IH6.7,/8\@7D/D-13(+*-.³03@ �pY�@7,-4Q@G@IH�Yl@7,-4Q@I,/8<0�85H6HQ@GY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38%: g 8RD-4A,/4S�#8a*/8R46HA�3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/.­La.%(½H6@BEF� �0�8MHSH�´ ¡ DU8MCB�34S.³k3: k3:Se�DU4|*-,/.�Yl@9©

C D � ! M C D � �3T � M D � ! M C D T^T� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

g .7*U*-.J@IH[La.%(3(385*U*-46Y7.P�3,/4S(9L54S�"@IH68~i9K%13,/@7(3.<*/1�*U*/8 ��T�¢%194S(9034[H6@\EF� � @7D/DU13CB8=Y�@IH6.7,/8��¶¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4#D-46@R4SHY�@IH6.7,/8=034|Y78M,-4S*l @B@�*-*-,/4SV9134 */.G@IH6HS8�H68a*U*/85,/8<�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64[LZ�38=i9K713,Z@I(9.P46( 8MD/D-@9:¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q�� & ! «w�|���� � ���" � .10 �[*&9;0iWK037l*&(\0`[email protected]</9S4c4 � *&9S0 � J � � 4 �SM � T2< �A� 'L. ,/.1>)4�>)fR4� �4CB.�0�85H6HS.[,/. � 4�'L.�'@>@2L.8WK4 � � < � F+'@4��SM � T < � � >".1< �4 �=9S</9 �4OPc<`,_4"787F<�,3. � �:'L.�'@>@2L.8WK4 ��� � < � H � ��0/(\0*&9;0cWK037l*&([email protected]</9;4 � 4a*&9 .89R'L.14@PQ4�,/.�� J ��� '@4 J 4@2a<5AB9-. � � ��SM � T�< � ��').j,3.1>)4N>)fR4�� �4�Pc<E,B4@787F<i,3.� �j4a').�'@>@2L.8WK4 � � < � �

¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q�� ± ! �_�3�A���" ��"!#����" � .p,3.1>)4i>)fR46*&9;0 � J � �4�*&9S0P*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@ F �4\Y�@IH64603@�H6'@464c'@</7F< '"40K')'L*&Pc4aW/0/7F<3254*� .89 �)0/'"4Q0_,6<GA39X.�WK037l*&([email protected]</9;4E�Z</')').10�'@4O<GA39X.:W/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]</9S4 �4OPc<`,_4"787F<�,3. � �� 85,b46(90�4QL5@7,-8<LZ�38 �  8=13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@JDU4|D/La,/4SY%8 � < � m9¢+1346(90�4?�I©

� < ����� �"8M,~.7K%(34 �� � � < �g 4|0�4QLa8<LZ�38�13("@REF� �  8=13(9@ >)</9X(I250_,B,3.FC".1<39;4�DU8=8\D-.7H6.JD-8<@7D/DU13CB8=Y�@IH6.7,/8 � 4S( V9@%DU8�@70 .7K%(34[Y�@IH61�*/@I�

2546.7(987T#.%D/[email protected](94AY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38R(3.7(� 8<CB.�0�8MHSH6. 0�4 � :�¨�0½8MD-85CB�346.9T� 8<13("@­La.%(+*-,Z@7030�462546.7(98 C ! C M�846(ºK%85(38M,-8=13(9@G¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4"EF�½0�8MH[*-46�#. � �! � T :

g 4[Y%85,/4 i"LM@J4SCBCB8M0�4Q@�*Z@ICB85(+*/8�LZ�987©�  8=13([email protected](+*-,Z@703034S2M4S.%(38 ��� ! �  8�13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@�  8=13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@ ��� ! �  8�13([email protected](+*-,Z@7090�4S2M4S.%(38

�~.%(  8 ¢+134S("0�4b(38ML58MD/D-@7,-46.�46(+*-,/.�0313,-,/8­19(·D-4SCPV".%HS.��"8M,B4S(90346LM@I,/8 LZ�38 �  8 13("@�L5.7(+*-,Z@703034S2M4S.%(387T�46(¢+19@I(+*/.P*Z@IH68<La46,/L5.%DU*/@I(92M@JDU4[�31� .G8MD-�3,-46CB85,/8=L5.7( � < ! � :¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q�� ² ! �A�|�������&0 �3$7��®��� ����9��" � .6,/.1>)4 >Gf-4 *&9;0 � J � �4�DU.�030�4QDUE�@7La46V346HS8 '@4 4 '"<37F< 4L'L.g'L(h40/7UPQ4@9;<6*&9;0QW/0/7U*&(h0EC".1<39;4 �k>Gf-4 �4OPQ<E,B4@787F<�,/. � �

g .�0 ����� 8MD-46DU*-8<13("@PY�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38��G*/@7HS8<LZ�38�� � < �^C���� �#&5TO ./�&.�� *,O(O����7A�#M*H#&�Qh� "�<�K �./�&.� "��i�56�70E*C0"��./��#&!�.�]

Page 33: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>%>r�4S,/8�LZ�38 �  8�D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8~8�¢+134SY�@7HS8=@70G@/bh85,/CG@I,/8~LZ�38 � (3.7(½ 8~13([email protected](+*/,/@%030�462546.7(38%:�� 85, 4S("0�46LM@I,/8

LZ�38 �  8JD-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8GD/La,/4SY%85,/85CB. g .�0 � : g 4�.%D/DU8M,-Y�4 LZ�38 g .�0 �  8J8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-8G@º0�46,-8BLZ�38B(3.7(�Y�@IH68� < ! � M�4SHhLZ�38%T+@<D-19@<Y%.7HS*/@3T%(3.7(G8�¢+134SY�@7HS8�@R0�4S,/8�� < ��� TaT�LZ�98~4S("0�46LZ�985,/85CB.\@I(9LZ�98 � � < ! � :�')H"L5.7(9L58a*-*-.R0�4D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH64 *� @\D-498MDU*-8M(90�8=@70B46(9DU4685CB4h0�43EF�A: g 4"0�4QLa8=LZ�38~13(­4S(9D-4685CB8 � 0�4"EF�¼ 8~D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V34SH68OM g .�0 � TD-8J 8�D-.7H6.BDU8<8�DU4QDc*/8�13(9@JY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38<LZ�38B 8�CB.�0�85H6HS.³034h*-1�*-*-8\H68�EF�½0�4 �°©

g .�0 � ��� 8MD-4QDc*/8=19(9@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��G*Z@IH68�LZ�987T��#85,~.%K7(34 � � � � < �� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � : g 4h(3.7*-4hLZ�38�19(³4S("DU4685CB8=�31� .R(9.7(³8�D-D-85,/8�D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH68�@7(9LZ�38�D-8�D-.7(3.PDU.�030�4QDUE�@7La46V346HS4*-13*U*-8BH68JEF��LZ�38JK7H64�@I�3�9@7,U*/85(3K%.7(3.":<¨�0�8MD-85CB�346.9T[DU4Q@ H6@­EF� ! C T|DU4Q@ H6@­EF� C D D-.7(9. D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH64pMFHQ@�3,/4SCG@J�9@JY�@IH6.7,/8 � DU8��SM C T < ��T3HQ@BDU8�La.7("03@J�9@JYl@7HS.%,-8 � D-8��;M C T< �;M D T�< � T T3CG@JH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCJ8%©

� < ! C C D (3.%(j 8�D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V34SH68°46(Á¢+19@7(%*/.9TRL5.7CB8·D-4JY785,/4Si"L5@ E�@%La46HSCB85(+*/87TJ(38MD/DU19(9@�Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��31� . ,/85("0�85,/8D-4SCP13H *Z@I(38�@ICB85(+*/8=Y%85,/8�H68�EF�½0�4 �°:

¿~(·4S("DU4685CB8­(9.7(·D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8 Y+4685(98º0�85*U*/. '@4@PQ039-(+.1>G03PQ4@9-(\4V.89;>)<E4"2G4"9X(h4P8­�"@�HQ@¼�3,/.7�9,-468a*� @¼LZ�387TLa.%CR13("¢%198�03@I*/@P13(9@\Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(387T�46(­V9@%DU8=@70³8�D-D/@\@7HSCB85(9.P13("@RD-19@\EF�º@7D/DU19CJ8�Y�@IH6.7,/8*��:�� 85,_4S("0�46LM@I,/8LZ�38��Æ 8�(3.7( DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H68\D-L5,-46Y78M,-8MCJ.J�~.%( g .�0 ��:�=�M����� ��� � � � � ²¦¥ .%(9DU4Q0�8M,[email protected]\0�138�EF�A©

� < M C �! D T � M ! C D T# < C � D

8\D/La,/4SY�[email protected](38=H68�*Z@lY7.%HS8�0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @3©� #

C D M C ! D T � M ! C D T C � D� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

g 4��31� .½.%D/DU8M,-Y�@I,/8PLZ�98J(985H6HS8G,/4SK%�38B4S(�L5134 � �9@ºY�@IH6.7,/8B034sY78M,-4S*l @7� MFHQ@ DU8�La.7("03@º8JHQ@º*-8M,-2�@_T=@I("LZ�38#¶�9@ Yl@7HS.%,-8J0�4 Y78M,-4S*l @7�HmA¢+1346(90�4�T|46(�@7H */,-4�*-8M,-CB46(34�TADU8º 8PY785,Z@ � [email protected],Z@  8JY785,Z@­@7(9LZ�38 #³: ��1"@I(90�.ºDU4Y78M,-4Si"LM@\13(9@JD-4 */19@I2M4S.%(38=0385HhK78M(385,/8�D-4[0�46L58<LZ�38 #  8=La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@RHS.%K74QL5@R034 � : g 4[�31� .B@IHS*-,/8MD)  $".%D/DU8M,-Y�@I,/8LZ�38JY�4  8J13(�L5@7D-.=M�H6@ �3,/4SCG@­,-46K%@9Th¢+19@7(90�. C 8 D D-.7(3. 85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8JY78M,-8KT¯46(�La194 #¶�9@­Y�@IH6.7,/8 � CJ8M(+*-,/8� �9@BY�@7HS.%,-8�� m"¢+1346(90�4A(3.7( Y�@IH68RLZ�38%T9¢+19@I(903.�#d 8�Y785,Z@3T�H6.½ 8<@I("LZ�38 � T"�"8M,�La134 � (3.7(� 8\L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]@J0�4 #­: �

¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q�� ¾ ! ¸P�"�����+!#���+���7�� ��#!#��$7��" � .j,/.1>)4c>Gf-4�7F0 � J # �4=La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]%46LM@J0385H6H6@BEF� � �4a').�'@>@2L.8WK4 � � <�#+��'"4�4a'"<37F<�'"4�<GA39X.�WK037l*&([email protected]</9;4Q>)fR4 �4aPc<E,B4@787F<�,/. � �4�0/9S>Gf-4NPQ<E,B4@787F<V,/. � �

� � <�# ��� �#85,�.7K7(94 � �ADU8�� � < � @7HSH6.7,Z@�� � <�#�=�M����� ��� � � � � ¾ g 8%T~La.%(�,-4SEF85,/4SCB8M(%*/.�@IH��3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/8¼8MD-85CB�346.9Tb46(9DU8M,-4Q@ICB.�@7(9LZ�38½HQ@�*/@lY%.7HQ@�0�4 � <!ZM C D Ta©

� # �

C D M C ! D T � M ! C D T C � D ! M C D T� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

Page 34: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>IOD-4��31� .­.%D/D-85,/Yl@7,-8\LZ�987Th¢%1"@I(90�. #µ8 �jDU.%(3.³8M(%*/,/@7CRV#8\Y78M,-8iMF(38MHSHQ@ D-8ML5.7(909@G8R(38MHSHQ@G*/85,/2M@G,/46K%@_TaT#@7HSH6.7,Z@@I("LZ�38 �  8 Y%85,Z@3:·¨�(9LZ�38¼D-8ºD-4< 8 .%D/D-85,/Yl@I*-.�4S( �3,/8MLa8�0�85(92M@�LZ�38 � (3.7(¦ 8 La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@�HS.%K74QL5@�0�4&#³T*-13*U*/@lY�4Q@ � ,-4QDU19H *Z@ºL5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@³H6.7K%46LM@ 034 # �� %:B')(�¢+138MDU*-. 8MD-85CB�346.9T�La.7CP13(9¢+138GD/La85HS*-8³03138JEF,/@ºH68*-,/8=EF� � T #p8 �JT3HQ@P*-8M,-2�@P(98J 8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@PHS.%K74QL5@3: �

¹º��� �����7���"��� ��Q��Q� ! ¸P�"�����+!#���+���7�� ��#!#��$7��!"�����+l�9 ����%�7������" � .�,/.1>)4�>Gf-4�7F0�� J � �4bL5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@=HS.7�K74QL5@­0�85H6H�´ 46(9DU4685CB8J0�4AEF� � �Z4N'L.:'@>@2L.8WK4 ��� < � � '"4c4N'@<37F<i'@4�<GAB9-. WK037l*&([email protected]</9;4c>)fR4 �4�PQ<E,B4@787F< ,/. � �40/9S>Gf-4 Pc<`,_4"787F<c,3. � Fh.89�0/7l(+2L. (\[email protected]. � '@4�<GA39X. W/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]<39;4�>)fR4 254@9;,_4�WK4@254�(+*&(I(\4?7F4 � J ,/.�� 2G4"9S,B4�W/4"2500/9S>Gf-4;�'H �

� � < � ��� �"8M,~.7K%(34 � �AD-8 � � < � �[email protected],Z@ � � < �

¥ .7(º,/4 EF8M,-46CB85(+*-.G@IH6H�´ ¡ DU8MCJ�94S.Gk�:�k�: §PD-4|�31� .BD/La,/46Y785,/87© C � D !ZM C D T �� < M C ! D T � M ! C D T

.G@I(9LZ�987T�*-,Z@IHQ@7D/La4Q@I("0�.PH68��9@I,/85(+*/8MD-4[K7,Z@/bh87©C � D !ZM C D T�� < M C �! D T � M ! C D T

� �����% �3�3�%���#���½���"�M�3�%���#���3 ��#:�')H|DU46CRV#.7H6. � <  8<Dc*Z@�*-.B46CB�34S8MK%@I*-.J�"8M,~4S("0�46LM@I,/8�Yl@7,-4|L5.7(9L58a*-*-4�©eKT � � < � M�H6@JY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��³,/85("0�8�Y785,Z@PH6@PEF� � Tk_T � � < � M�H6@JY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��³,/85("0�8�Y785,/8=*-1�*-*-8<H68�EF�½0�85H6H�´ 46(9DU4685CB8 �=T>dT � < � M�H6@PEF� �  8�13(9@P*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@_TODT � � < # M�H6@PEF� #¶ 8<La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@J0�8MHSHQ@PEF� � TX_T � � < � M�H6@PEF� �  8<La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@J0�8MHSH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCB8\0�4[EF� �=T :

?A@JODT_�31� .G8MD/D-85,/8=Y�4QDc*[email protected]<13(½[email protected]�"@I,-*-4QLa.7HQ@I,/8�0�85H6H6@GX_T T9¢+19@7(90�.GH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCJ8 � La.%(+*-4685(38<13(½D-.7H6.85H685CB8M(%*/.9©�DU8�� < � %TA@7(3254QLZ�$#8 � � < #­TADU4sD/La,/46Y78 � � < #­:J?�@ºX_T T|(985HsL5@%DU. 4S(�La194 � D-46@ Y�13.I*/.M � <��BT T78M¢+1346Yl@7HS8_@IH6H6@�>_Ta©A46(�E�@�*-*-4�� � < � 8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8b@�� < � M�13(9@�EF� �  8_L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@¯H6.7K%46LM@�0�8MHSH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCB8Y�13.I*/.RD-8< 8~Y%85,Z@=*-1�*-*-8�H68�Y%.7HS*-8�LZ�98�DU.%(3.<Y78M,-8�HS8¯EF�º0�4��3T%CG@R�".%46LZ�$#8~¢%198MDU*M´ 13H */4SCG@PLa46,/L5.%DU*/@I(92M@P 8�D-85CB�3,/8V9@7(9@IH6CB85(+*-8PY785,/4Si"L5@I*/@B�¯�#85,�.7K%(34 �#T � � <�� �\�ZT[La4) . 8�¢%194SY�@IH68P@ 0�46,-8BLZ�38 �  8JDU8MCJ�9,-8PY785,[email protected] 8PLZ�38­ 813(9@<*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@dT :�?s´ 4SCB�34685K%.R0�85H6H6.RDc*/8MD/DU.\D-46CRV#.7H6.<4S(­>dT T%OdT 8�X_T T�¢+134S("0�4�T+(3.%(³0A @<H613.7K%.\@70B8M¢+1346Y7.�L54�:�')(eET_8\k_T_4SHAD-46CRV#.7H6.  8��3,/8ML58M0�13*-.³03@7HSHQ@JHS85*U*-8M,/@ �#T9La46.9 8=03@7H|(3.%CJ8<0�4A13(9@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38%T�8�(3.7( �31� .B8�D-D-85,/Y�4La.%(�EF19D-4S.%(38<La.%( K%HS4A@7H */,-4|LM@7D-4�:

����� � �������: "#p��� � # ���"# ���a�i� �&�"���N "# �� � � /�;���"#?�������@� �� E���

��[email protected]<�3,/4S(9L54S�"@IH64[�3,-.%�3,/4S85*l @P8<,[email protected](34#*-,Z@B@IHQLa13(94ALa.%(9La85*U*-4[46(+*-,/.�0�.I*-*-4|(38MH � k3: k3:�_�+�"����°� �� & ��� � 0 � J # �4�>)</9-'"4hAB*-4"9&CE0 7F<GA3.1>)0�,B4@787F0�� J � '@4?4!'@</7F<�'@4!7F0�� J � � # �4p*&9S0 (h03*&(h<37F<GA3.10 �

� � <�# ��� � < � � #

¹º����: M � T � 8M, 46�#.I*-8�DU4 � � <�#­T�8=D-4#0385Y78�0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8�LZ�38 � � #£ 8�13(9@R*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3: � 85,b@7D/DU19,/0�."TD-8 � � #j(3.7(ºEF.+D-D-8<13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@3T"0�.�Y�,-8MV3V"8�8�DU4QDc*/85,/8<13(9@BY�@IH61�*[email protected](98��³*/@7HS8\LZ�98��;M � � #NT < ��:�¼@º@IH6HS.%,/@³,-4QDU19H */85,/85V3V#8 �SM � T1< � 8 �;M #NT < ��T[La.%(+*-,/.­H�´ 46�".7*-8�DU4pM�D-8J13(9@ Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38R,/85("0�8RY%85,Z@ � T0�8MY78�,-8M(90�8M,-8�Y78M,/@J@I("LZ�38�#NT :M � T¯� 8M,_46�#.I*-8�DU4 � � #  8<19(9@P*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@9T�8\DU4�0�85Y%8�034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8<LZ�38 � � <�#­: g 4Q@��³13(9@BY�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38LZ�38P,-8M(90�8RY%85,Z@ � M �;M � T < �VTa:�r=@�*/. LZ�38 � � #  8\13(9@­*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3T��SM � � #NT2< ��:�r�8MY78P¢+1346(90�4g !��L�� "#& "0"�$ " ��L1�%+*��u!EZ(�D%�./%c3�L56.�'����&�&.w'����&� f #&%� "#&��56��A(1�.,0".�8S0�*,�&���4'�.tA�����O�O@�L����%�'������;�~*,�& E*w1�%+*:�R�a'�#��(8S�L!$# 3.3�

#&56�@./ � "#&O�#&�&�b�@./#&!EZS����T%�./%D!�./%B0�#&��%��X*,�&!�1�%+*H�R��]

Page 35: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>+X8MD/D-85,/8�SM�#�T < � M�DU8�EF.+D-D-8��;M #NT < ��T#@IH6HS.%,/@9T303@��SM � T < � DU8MK71346,-8MV3V#8��;M � � #�T < �!T :���1346(90�4�T9D-8�³,/85(9038=Y%85,Z@ � T3,/85(90�8�Y%85,Z@ #­T3LZ�38J 8�H6@J*/8MD-4�: ¥�: �R: rR:� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � :�� 8M,�46H2��85.7,/85CG@�k�: >3:6e H�´ 8MD/DU8M,-8 #�La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@�HS.%K74QL5@=0�4�13(9@�EF� � 8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8¯@7HSH�´ 8�D-D-85,/813(9@­*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@­0�8MH�La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68 � � #³: ��138MDU*-.º,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/. D-4�8�Dc*/85(9038RE�@%La46HSCB85(+*/8J@7HSHQ@ L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]@J03@B13(º46(9DU4685CB8�i9(94 */.³0�4[EF�|:

g 8 � < � � � � � � � ��� +T9@IH6HS.%,/@J8MY+4Q0�8M(%*/85CB85(+*/8<13(9@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38B 8<CB.�0�8MHSH6.³0�4 � D-8<8\DU.%HS.GD-8B 8CB.�0�85H6HS.G0�8MHSH�´ 13(34QL5@JEF�½LZ�38J 8�[email protected](3K%4S13(92546.7(38<0�8MHSH68=EF�¼0�4 �°©

� � < � � � � � � � � � ��� � � < � � � � � � � � �r=@J¢+138�Dc*Z@J8M¢+1346Yl@7HS8M(32M@J8\03@7Hx�A8M.7,/85CG@Bk�: >3:6e=D-4|.I*-*-4685(38%©

� � � � � � � � � �� <�# ��� � � � � � � � � � � <�# ��� � < � � � � � � � � � � #�_�+�"����°� �� & �Q� � 4�� < � 4�� < � � #)� 03787F</2G0 � <�# �

¹º����:¯')(�E�@I*U*/4�T|D-8 � < � � #³T[03@7H[��85.%,-8MCG@³k�: >3:6eRDU8MK7138 � � < #­T[La46.9 8\.%K7(34�Y7.%H *Z@³LZ�38 �  8RY%85,Z@3TA 8Y78M,/@�@7(9LZ�38 #�m+CG@ � T%�#85,�4S�#.I*/8MD-4�T3 8~DU8MCJ�9,-8bY78M,/@9T7¢+1346(90�4| 8¯D-85CB�3,/8bY785,Z@�@I(9LZ�98 #­T%L54S.9 8 � < #³: ¥�: �R: rR:�_�+�"����°� �� & � & � < � # ��� � < � 4�� <�# �

¹º����: ¡�D-85,ZLa462546.9:¹º��� �����7���"��� �� & ��� ! ���[�����3�3 ������7�� ��#!"��$7��" � .j,3.1>G4c>)fR4O7F4Q,/*-4 � J � 4�� '@</9S<\H6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*/8=8�¢+134SY�@I�H685(+*-4 � 4O'L.�'">@2L.8W/4 ��� #)�:'@4�4a'@<37F<c'@4 � � < # 4 # � < � F\>@.1< �4�*&9S0 �4�>)</9R'@4hAB*-4"9&C`067F<GA3.1>)0V,B4@787^] 0/7U(I250 4WE.1>G4@W/4"2)'@0,H �

��� # ��� � � <�#µ8 # � < �� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � :Or=@I4 *-8M.7,/85CB4 �3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/4�T[,/46L5.7,Z03@I("0�.³HQ@ 0�85i9(3462546.7(38G0�4 � � #¶03@IH6HQ@ ¢+19@7HS8BDU4

,/46LM@lYl@BLZ�38 �;M � � #NT < ��DU8R8RDU.%HS.GD-8��SM � T$< �SM�#NTaT#L54S.9 8<DU8RHS8R03138<EF� � 8�#µ�9@I(3(9.³4S(½V"@7D-8\@��­H6.DU*-8MD/D-.JY�@7HS.%,-8�0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @3T�DU8MK7138=E�@%La46HSCB85(+*/8\LZ�387©

��� # ��� � < ��� #M�03138=EF� D-.7(9.PH6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*-8�8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-4|D-8�8�D-.7H6.PD-8�4SH[H6.7,/.JV346L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH68R 8=13(9@P*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@_Ta: �½8M0�4Q@I(3�*-8 4SH_La.%(9La85*U*-.�0�4 8�¢+134SY�@7HS8M(32M@ H6.7K%46LM@½DU4 �".+D-D-.7(3.½8�DU�9,-46CB85,/8­La.%(�CB@7K7K%4S.%,-8B�3,/8ML546D-4S.%(38GH68­8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(32M846(9La.%(%*/,/@I*-8�(38MH � e7:6e<0�85H ¥_@I�|:[e%:

?s´ 8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@­ 8=19(9@B,[email protected](38�0�4|8�¢+134SY�@7HS8M(32M@R*-,Z@PEF�|T9.+D-D-46@³ 87©M50`T­,/498MD/DU46Y�@3© �#85,¯.7K%(34 � T ��� �M �GT D-46CJCB85*-,/46LM@3© �"8M,~.7K%(34 � 8�#³T9D-8 ��� #­[email protected],Z@ # �%� mM5>GT³*/,/@7(9D-4 */4SY�@3© �#85,~.%K7(34 � T #W8 �JT9D-8 ��� #W8�# � �JT9@IH6HS.%,/@ ��� �

g 8 �  8~19(9@<EF�­LZ�98�La.%(+*-4685(38�H6@<H68a*-*-8M,/@���T�46(90�4QLZ�[email protected].%( � M � � #NT�HQ@�EF� LZ�38=DU4".I*-*-4685(38�DU.+Dc*/4 */1385("0�.46( � .%K7(34[.�LMLa.7,/,/85(32�@R0�8MHSHQ@JHS85*U*-8M,/@ ��La.7(ºHQ@JEF��#­:

�=�M����� ��� � : g 8 � < C � M ! D C TaT3@IH6HS.%,/@9©� M C � D � �3T�< D � � � M ! D M D � �3T^T

� M C ��� � ! C T< M � � ! C T � M ! D =M � � ! C T^T� M D � !ZM D � �3T^T�< C � M ! !ZM D � �/T C T

� M D �&M C � D T � ! �KT�< C � M !ZM^M C � D T � ! �KT C T

Page 36: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>7§

eKT C � ! C MF�3,/4S("La46�34S.G0�8MH[*-8M,-2M.B8MD/LaH619DU.DTk_T !ZM C ! C T MF�3,/4S("La46�34S.G0�4A(3.7( La.%(%*/,/@%030�462546.7(38KT>dT C C � C MF4Q0�85CB�#.I*-8M(32M@G0385H6H6@BLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38ETODT C D � D C M�La.%CBCR1�*Z@�*-46Y�4 *� @B0�[email protected](3K%4S13(92546.7(38KTX_T M C D T � � C M D �3T M�@7D/D-.�L546@I*-46Y�4 *� @P0�8MHSHQ@BLa.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38ET§dT C D � C]BT C D � D¤dT M C � D T � M^M C � �3T � M C � D �3T5T�dT C � C � C MF4Q0�85CB�#.I*-8M(32M@G0385H6H6@B0�4QDUK%4S19(32546.7(38KTeMfdT C � D � D � C M�La.%CBCR1�*Z@�*-46Y�4 *� @B0�85H6H6@B0�4QD-K74613(32546.7(98ETe7eKT M C � D T � � � C � M D � �3T M�@7D/D-.�L546@I*-46Y�4 *� @P0�8MHSHQ@B0�4QDUK%4S13(92546.7(38KTe�k_T C � C � DeM>dT D � C � De5ODT M C � �3T � M^M D � �3T � M C � D � �3T^Te�X_T C =M C � D T � C MFH685K7K%8<0�4|@7D/DU.%,-V94SCB85(+*/.dTeM§dT C � M C D T � C MFH685K7K%8<0�4|@7D/DU.%,-V94SCB85(+*/.dTel]BT C =M D � �3T � M C D T � M C �3T M�0�4QDc*/,-46V31�*/4SY�4S*l @G0�4 °,/46D-�#8a*U*/.G@ � TeM¤dT C � M D �3T � M C � D T M C � �3T M�0�4QDc*/,-46V31�*/4SY�4S*l @G0�4 � ,/46D-�#8a*U*/.G@ �TeM�dT ! ! C � C MFH685K7K%8<0�85H6H6@B0�.%�3�34Q@J([email protected](98ETkIfdT !ZM C D T � ! C � ! D MFH685K7K%8<0�4�r�8&�¼.7,/K%@I(;Tk�eKT !ZM C � D T � ! C �! D MFH685K7K%8<0�4�r�8&�¼.7,/K%@I(;Tk7k_T M C D T � M C �! D T � CkI>dT M C � D T M C � ! D T � Ck�ODT M C � D T � M ! C � D Tk7X_T M C � D T � M^M C � D T � D TkI§dT M C � D T � !ZM C ! D Tk%]BT M C � D T � M ! C � D TkI¤dT M C D T � !ZM C � ! D TkI�dT M C � D T � M ! D � ! C T MFH685K7K%8<0�4|La.%(%*/,/@7�3�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38ET>7fdT M C � ! D T � M D � ! C T MFH685K7K%8<0�4|La.%(%*/,/@7�3�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38ET>3eKT M ! C � D T � M ! D � C T MFH685K7K%8<0�4|La.%(%*/,/@7�3�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38ET>%k_T C � M D � C T>7>dT M C � D T � M^M D � �3T � M C � �/T5T M�D-4SH6HS.%K74QDUCB.DT>IODT M C D � �3T � M C � M D � �3T5T>%X_T M C � D �3T � M5M C � D T =M C � �3T^T>7§dT M C � D � �3T � M5M C � D T � M C � �3T^T>+]BT M C � D � �3T � M5M C � �/T =M D � �/T5T>7¤dT C � M D � C D T>7�dT M^M C � D T � C T � C MFH685K7K%8<0�4|� 8546,/L58ETO%fdT M C � M D � �3T^T � M^M C � D T � M C � �3T^T MFH685K7K%8<0�4�n3,/85K%8ETO9eKT C � M ! C � D T MFH685K7K%8<0�4 g La.7*-.DTO+k_T C ! C � D MFH685K7K%8<0�4 g La.7*-.DTO%>dT M C � D T � M^M C � ! D T � ! C TO7ODT M C � D T � M^M C D T � M ! C �! D T^TO+X_T !ZM C � D T � M^M C �! D T � M ! C D T5TO%§dT C � CO�]BT M C � D T � M D � C TO%¤dT M C � M D � �3T^T � M^M C � D T � �3TO%�dT M C � D T � M ! C � ! D TXIfdT !ZM C � D T � M ! C � D TX�eKT C � M C D T^T � M C � D TX7k_T M C � M C � D T^T � M D � C TXI>dT M C � D T � M C � � D �/TX�ODT M C � D T � M C � � � D � �/TX7X_T M C � D T � M^M � � C T � M � � D T^TXI§dT M C � D T � M^M C � �3T � M D � �/T5T

n�4SK%13,Z@Bk3:Se%© �� ��+��$7������ � ��º�������$7�F� �3 ������3�A���" ��"!#���

Page 37: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>�]�_�+�"����°� �� & � ± � 4�� < � � 03787F</250 � J 4"2O<GAB9-. � 4&#+� � < � M � � #NT �

¹º����:Á')(�E�@�*-*-4�T��3,/8MD/@°19(9@�¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4=Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38 �"T�4SH�Y�@IH6.7,/8 �SM � M � � #NT^TaT��#85,½¢+19@I(+*/.�@I�3�#85("@.%D/D-85,/Yl@I*-."T�La.%4S(9L546038 L5.7( 4SH¯Y�@7HS.%,-8 0�4 � (38MHSHQ@�Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38 LZ�38� 8º13K719@7HS8½@ ��D/@IH6Y7.��"8M,³4SHbE�@I*U*/.�LZ�98@7D/D-85K7("@­@ ��46H�Y�@IH6.7,/8 �SM�#�T ::�¼@ ¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4 DU4Q@ºH6@ºY�@IH61�*[email protected](98P46HsY�@IH6.7,/8J034 �  8�� M�8MD/DU8M(90�. � < � T T�8¢+1346(90�4 �SM � M � � #�T^T< �d,-4QD-�"85*U*-.G@%0 .%K7(34hY�@IH61�*[email protected](98=8 � M � � #NT� 8�13(9@P*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3: ¥�: �R: rR:

r=@IH6�A8M.7,/85CG@�k3: >9: O�DU8MK7138 LZ�38%Ts�3,/8MD/@�13("@�¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4 */@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@ M�@70°8�DU8MCB�34S.�13(9@�¢+19@7HS13("¢%198º0�4¢+1385H6H68�LZ�98=D-.7(3.J85H685("L5@�*/8�(985H6H6@Pi9K%13,/@Bk�:6eETaT�DU8<D-4hD-.%DU*-4S*-1946D/La8=13(9@JH68a*U*/85,Z@�Y³.�Y�13(9¢+138�@I�9�9@I4Q@ Y­La.%(­13("@EF� ¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4�T�DU4#.I*-*-4685(38=@I(9L5.7,Z@<13(9@\*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@Rm�La.%D)  $#03@IH6H6@<*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@R>%k�T C � M D � C T T�D-4"�"@RLZ�38=DU.%(3.*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74687©

���! � � M D � � �! �ET � M C � ���! �KT! ! D � M D � ! ! D T � M C � ! ! D TM C M D � �3T^T � M D � M C M D � �3T^T^T � M C � C =M D � �3T^TC � M !ZM D � �3T � C T � M D � !ZM D � �3T^TC � M^M C � ! �3T M C � ! �ET � C T � M D �&M C � ! �3T =M C � ! �ET5T

')(ºK785(985,Z@IH68=D-4|�31� .G0�46,/8\LZ�387©� � M # � � T

 8P13(3.�'@>)fR4@PQ0 ,3.Z(h03*&(h<37F<5AB.145©�¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4AEF��D-4�D-.%DU*-4S*-134QD/L5@I(9. @IH��#.%DU*-. 034 � 8 #¶D-4�.7*U*/4S8M(38PD-85CB�3,/8R13("@*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3: ¿�( @I(9@7HS.%K7.�0�4QD-L5.7,ZDU.�Y�@IH68½�"8M,G*-13*U*-8�HS8 *Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%4S8¼LZ�38%T 46(�V9@%DU8¼@7HG�A8M.7,/85CG@�k�: >3: O9TbDU4�#.%D/DU.%(3.R*/,/@%DcEF.%,-CG@7,-8�4S(½D/LZ�385CB4A0�4|*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%4S8%:

g 4Q@ � 13("@GEF�½8 � J 19(9@³D-.I*U*/.IEF.%,-CP13H6@G034 � : g 8�# J  8\19(9@BEF��¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4�T9L5.7( � M � J � # J T�DU4�4S("0�46LM@GHQ@EF� #jLZ�38<DU4A.I*U*/4S8M(38<DU.+Dc*/4 */1385("0�.G4S( � [email protected]*U*-.7EF.7,/CR13HQ@ � J L5.7(ºH6@PEF� # J :�_�+�"����°� �� & � ² �p4@2O<5AB9-. � � J # J � � < M � J � # J T � M ��� #�T

¹º����: g 4�0385Y78�0�4SCB.+Dc*/,/@7,-8¼LZ�38 M � J � # J T � M � � #�T½ 8½13(9.·D/LZ�385CG@�0�4�*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%4S8%Tb.%D/DU4Q@LZ�38%T~¢%1"@IHQDU4Q@7D-4~DU4Q@�HQ@�Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38 �#T~¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4�D-4Q@I(3.�HQ@�EF� � T¯HQ@°D-19@�D-.I*U*/.IEF.%,-CP13H6@ � J 8¼HQ@�EF�%# J T�SM^M � J � # J T � M ��� #NT^T < ��T30�.�Y78�# < � M � J � # J T :g 4Q@ �³13(9@B¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4[Y�@IH61�*[email protected](987: g 4|�9@7(3(3.G0�138<LM@7D-4�©e%: �;M � J T� 8 0�4SY%85,ZDU.~09@��SM�# J T"mI4S(\*/@IH+L5@%DU.��SM � J � # J T< ��TlCG@�@7HSH6.7,Z@b4SH�La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8��9@�@7(%*/8ML58M0�8M(%*/8E�@IHQDU.J8\¢+134S("0�4 �SM^M � J � # J T � M ��� #NT^T < � m

k3: �;M � J TB 8G13K%19@IH68­@ �SM�# J TLms46(�*/@7H L5@%DU. �SM � J � # J T <��Hm�(38­D-85K71987T��"8M,PLa.%CB8­DU4� 8G8MD-85K%134S*/@ HQ@DU.+Dc*/4 */132546.7(38%TsLZ�38 �;M � T+< �SM�#�T T_�"8M,JL5134 �;M � � #NT+< � m CG@�@IH6HS.%,/@¼4SH¯La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8 �9@�DU4Q@H�´ @I(+*-8�La8�0�85(+*-8<LZ�38�46HALa.%(9D-85K71985(+*-8=Y78M,-4�T��"8M,~La134 �;M5M � J � # J T � M ��� #�T^T�< ��:

')(º85(+*-,Z@ICPV34[4AL5@%DU4 �SM^M � J � # J T � M ��� #NT5T�< ��: ¥�: �R: rR:r=@IHx��85.7,/85CG@Bk�: >3:�XP8�09@IH���85.%,-8MCB@Bk�: >3:�kPDU8MK7138�46CJCB8�0�46@I*/@7CJ8M(+*-87©

D-8�� < � J � # J [email protected],Z@ � < ��� # M � J � # J � ��� #NT.%D/D-46@9T�D-8 � J  8=H6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*/8�8�¢%194SY�@IH685(+*/8�@�# J [email protected],Z@ �  8�H6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*/8=8�¢+134SY�@7HS8M(%*/8<@ #­: ��1346(90�4�T9DU8�46(13(9@B¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4hEF� � D-4|DU.+Dc*/4 */134QD-L58=19([email protected]*U*-.7EF.7,/CR13HQ@ � J L5.7( 13([email protected]@7CB85(+*-8=8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-8�# J T3HQ@PEF� #LZ�38¯(38�,-4QDU19H *Z@J 8¯HS.%K74QL5@7CJ8M(+*-8b8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-8�@7HSHQ@�EF�­0�4"�9@I,-*-8M(32M@9: g EF,/1�*U*Z@I(903.R¢+138MDU*/@��3,/.7�9,-468a*� @3T703@I*/@�13("@EF� � T"DU8<(38<�91� .G.I*-*-85(985,/8=19(9@BHS.%K74QL5@7CJ8M(+*-8�8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-8\LZ�38<@7V3V34Q@G¢%1"@IHQLZ�38<L5@I,Z@�*-*-8M,-4QDc*/46LM@P038MD-460�8M,/@I*/@9:¨�0º8�DU8MCJ�94S."T3DcEF,/1�*U*Z@I(903.JH6.³D/LZ�385CG@J0�4[*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74687©

M�# � ��T � M ! # � ��TM�LZ�98 D-4 .7*U*-4685(98º03@7HSHQ@ *Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@�kIO¼K78M(385,Z@IH64S2M2M@7(90�.7HQ@½La.%(°46HH��85.%,-8MCB@�k�: >3: OdT T�D-8 D-4_D-.%DU*-4S*-1946D/La8 .7K7(94D-.I*U*/.IEF.%,-CP13H6@�0�4 � LZ�38< 8~0�8MHSHQ@=EF.7,/CG@cM�# � ��TpM�L54S.9 8¯LZ�38� 8¯13(GLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8KT T+La.7( M ! # � ��TaT�D-43.7*U*-4685(98

Page 38: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>7¤13(9@�EF� HS.%K74QL5@ICB8M(%*/8­8�¢%194SY�@IH685(+*/8º@%0 � LZ�38 La.7(+*/4S8M(38ºD-.7H6.�4b*/,-8 La.%(3(385*U*-46Y�4 !_T _T � : g EF,/1�*U*Z@I(90�.�H68H685K7K%4#034Sr�8��½.7,/K%@7(³DU4h�31� .P�3,/.%D-85K%1346,-8~.7*U*/85(38M(90�.R19(9@\EF�ºH6.7K74QL5@7CB85(+*-8~8�¢+134SY�@7HS8M(%*/8=@%0 � LZ�38�La.7(+*/4S8M(38D-.7H6.G4�0�138PLa.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4 !_T _T#.7�9�313,/8\DU.%HS.G4�0�138RL5.7(3(385*U*/4SY�4 !_T � : g EF,/1�*U*Z@I(903.³K7H64AD/LZ�385CB4�034|*/@71�*-.%HS.%K7468� # � !ZM � � ! #�T¯8 ��� # � M ! � � #�T~D-4A�31� .­�"8M,-Y%85(346,-8<@%0 13(9@BEF�½8�¢%194SY�@IH685(+*/8R@70 13("@³03@�*Z@LZ�38<La.%(+*-4685(38<D-.7H6.J4�La.7(9(38a*-*-46Y+4 !_T � :�=�M����� ��� � � & ��� ��85H6HS8<D-85K71985(+*-4h*/,/@%DcEF.%,-CG@I2M4S.%(34hDU4[.7*U*-8M(3K7.%(3.PEF�ºH6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*/8�8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-4h*/,/@JH6.7,/.VM�DU4K74619DU*-4Si"LZ�34|L546@%D-L513( �"@7D/[email protected]©

eET C � M D � ! ! �3T � C � M D � �/T � C � !ZM ! D ! �3T � !ZM C ! !ZM ! D �! �/T5T �� !ZM C ! D �! �3TkBT ! C � M D � C T � ! C � M5M D � C T M C � D T^T � ! C � M5M ! D � C T M ! C � D T5T �

� !ZM ! C �!ZM^M ! D � C T M ! C � D T^T5T � !ZM ! C M !ZM ! D � C T � !ZM ! C � D T^T5T �� !ZM ! C M5M ! ! D �! C T � M ! ! C �! D T5T^T � !ZM ! C HM5M D �! C T � M C ! D T5T^T �� !ZM^M ! C M D �! C T^T � M ! C M C ! D T^T5T � !ZM ! C D T � ! ! C � ! D � C � ! D>_T C =M ! D � M C � D T5T � !ZM C � !ZM ! D � M C � D T^T � !ZM C � !ZM ! ! D � M C � D T5T^T �� !ZM C � !ZM D � M C � D T5T^T � !ZM C � !ZM D � M^M C � D T M D � C T^T^T5T �

� !ZM C � !ZM D � !ZM5M C � D T � !ZM D � C T5T^T5T�

��� � � �������: "#p��� � # ���E� ��#1�E���! "����# �� �p�N��� #2�N��# ������"� �� E���

¡�D/@ICB46([email protected].%,/@J@IHQLa19(38<13HS*-85,/46.7,/4#�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @B0�85H6H6@J(3.%2546.7(38<0�4�La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@RHS.%K74QL5@3:�_�+�"����°� �� ± ��� ! ���"������+�9�����b�°�"���"�M�#����$7�F�/9��" � 4 � � < � � 03787F</2G0 ��� � < � �

¹º����: ¡�Y�460�8M(+*-85CB8M(%*/87T=DU8�13(9@°Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38�,/85(9038�Y78M,-8�*-1�*-*-8�HS8�EF�¦0385H6H�´ 4S("DU4685CB8 ��� �M�L54S.9 8� � < ��� NTaT @7HSH6.7,Z@½,/85(90�8ºY78M,-8ºH68­EF�Å0�4 � M�La46.9 8 � � < �=T T�8 ¢+1346(90�4�T��#85,B46�".7*-8�DU4�T�,/85(9038 Y%85,Z@ � :

¥�: �R: rR:��1346(90�4�T+D-8~13("@<EF�¼ 8�La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@�H6.7K%46LM@<0�4"19(³4S("DU4685CB8�0349EF� ��T%@\[email protected],�,Z@IK%4S.%(38< 8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@

0�4|19( D-.7�9,/@74S(9D-4685CB8=034 �°:  ¡ 4S(3.%H */,-8�8MY+4Q0�8M(%*/8<4SH�DU8MK7138M(%*/87©�_�+�"����°� �� ± �Q� � 4 � ���:03787F</2G0 � � < � ��_�+�"����°� �� ± � & � 4 � � < � 4 � � <�#+� 0/787F<3250 � � <�# �

¹º����: g 46@ �­*Z@IH68JLZ�98 � � < �°:�� 85,�H6@­�3,/4SCG@³46�#.I*-8�DU4 � � < � : g 8 � � < � Th�"8M,�HQ@ D-8ML5.7(909@G4S�#.I*/8MD-4�T� � <�#­:���1346(90�4�T3DU8�� � < ��T3@IH6HS.%,/@ � � <�#³T"La46.9 8 � � < #³: ¥�: �R: rR:�_�+�"����°� �� ± � ± � � < ����� �~.7( g .�0 ��� ! � �

¹º����:jM � T g 46@ � � < � %:�� 85,s@7D/D-13,/03.9TID-8 EF.+D-D-8 g .�0 ����! � T70�.�Y�,/85V3V#8b8MD-46DU*-8M,-8b13(9@�Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38�º*/@7HS8BLZ�38 � � < ��� ! � +T[.%D/DU4Q@B*/@7HS8BLZ�38 � � < �Æ8 � � < ! � TAL54S.9 8���� � < � :\� 8M,�46�".7*-8�DU4�T[DU8 � � < ��[email protected],Z@ � � < � T38\D-4  8=*-,/.�Yl@I*-.JH�´ @7D/D-13,/03.9:M � T g 4Q@G�~.%( g .�0 ��� ! � 7: g 8�(3.%(ºEF.%D/DU8�� � < � T3Y�4AD/@I,/85V3V#8�13(9@JY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��G*Z@IH68<LZ�38�� � < � 8��� � < � T"La46.9 8� � < ! � :�¼@­DU8<8�DU4QDc*/8MD/DU8��­*/@IH68RLZ�38�� � < � 8�� � < ! � [email protected],Z@PD/@I,/85V3V#8 g .�0 ��� ! � %TLa.%(+*-,/.PH�´ 46�#.I*-8�DU4�: ¥�: �R: rR:

¡sH685("LZ�[email protected]�HQ@7D/La4Q@I("0�.�La.7CB8�8MD-85,ZLa462546. H6@ ,/85HQ@�*-46Y�@·034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I2M4S.%(387T�@IHQLa19(38�@IHS*-,/8��9,-.%�3,-468a*� @·LZ�98,/4SK%19@I,Z03@I(9.\EF�½La.%CJ�#.%DU*-8<LZ�38\D-.7(9.JL5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@P034|13( 4S("DU4685CB8\0�4[EF�A©�_�+�"����°� �� ± � ² � � < ! � ��� �~.7( g .�0 ��� � ��_�+�"����°� �� ± � ¾ � � < � 4 � � < # ��� � � < � # ��_�+�"����°� �� ± �Q� � 4 � � < � � 0/787F<3250 � � < � � # 4 � � <�# � � ��_�+�"����°� �� ± ��� �� � �� < � 4 �� # �� < � ��� ��� � � # � < � �

Page 39: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

>%��_�+�"����°� �� ± �6� �� � �� < # ��� � � < � � # ��_�+�"����°� �� ± ����� ��� � � <�# 4 ��� # �� < ����� � � < M ��� #�T���_�+�"����°� �� ± ���#� *�� ��� � �� <�# 4 ��� ! � �� < #)� 0/787e</250 � � < # �

g .%(3.<4SCB�#.7,-*/@7(%*/4"H68�0�198�D-85K71985(+*-4"�3,-.%�3,/4S85*l @3: ?A@\�3,-46CG@\@/bh85,/CG@<LZ�38�19(G4S(9D-4685CB8�(3.%(³DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H680�4[EF� �[email protected]\La.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@RHS.%K74QL5@B¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4#EF�|©�_�+�"����°� �� ± ���3� � 4���.7( g .�0 � � 0/787e</250 � J 4"2O<GA39X. � J � � � � < � �

¹º����:_')(�E�@�*-*-4�Th�"8M,/LZ�$#8<(3.7(½Y�@IH6K%@ � � < � T".�LMLa.7,/,/8\LZ�38\8MD-4QDc*Z@B13(9@³Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38��­*Z@IH68RLZ�38�� � < �8�� � � < � :��¼@ L54  .� 8J4SCB�#.%D/DU46V346HS8B�#.74QLZ� #87T[�#85,<46�#.I*-8�DU4�TA��.7( g .�0 ��TAL54S.9 8P(9.7(�8�DU4QDU*-8G@IHQLa13("@ �½*Z@IH68JLZ�98� � < �°: ¥�: �R: rR:

[email protected](903@J@/bh85,/CG@BLZ�38�13(9@J*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@³ 8<L5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@P034A¢+19@IHQDU4Q@7D-4h4S("DU4685CB8\0�4[EF�A©�_�+�"����°� �� ± ��� & � 4�� < � � 0/787F<3250�� J 4@2O<5AB9-.j.89R'L.14"Pc4�,/.�� J � � � � < � �

¹º����:s¥ .7CB8=(385H|[email protected]�3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/87T��#85,ZLZ�$#8�(3.7( Yl@7HSK+@ � � < � T�.�LMLa.%,-,/8�LZ�38=8MD-4QDc*Z@R13("@PY�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38�º*/@7HS8BLZ�38 � � < � 8 � � � < � :&�¼@­L54  .� 8R46CB�".+D-D-4SV94SH68P�#.74QLZ�$#8%T"�#85,�46�".7*-8�DU4�T � < � T[8B¢+134S("0�4�T[�#85,�.%K7(34 �"T� � < � : ¥�: �R: rR:

����� � �N���2�@���� "����#��19@7(%*/.ºi9(3.7,Z@ Y�46DU*-.¼L54�La.%(9D-85(+*-8³0�4 ,-4QD-.7H6Y785,/8J4SH �3,-.%V3H685CG@ �".+Dc*/.½(385H � k�:6e7:º� 85,<Y%85,/4 i"LM@I,/8GDU8G13("@ EF��  8RLa.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]%46LM@G0�4�13(�46(9D-4S8MCJ8 � M i9(94 */.dT~034�@7H */,-8³ 8RDU1R%GL54S8M(+*-8R�"@7D/D-@7,-8<46(¼,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@P*-13*U*-8JH68�#.%D/DU46V346HS4�Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(34 M�HS46CB4 *Z@I(90�.�L54�@=La.%(9D-460�8M,/@7,-8�4��".+D-D-4SV94SH64�Yl@7HS.%,-4�0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @�0�85H6H68_H68a*-*-8M,-8_�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64LZ�38Ri9K713,Z@I(9.³4S( � 8R46( � T~8BLa.%(+*-,/.7H6H6@7,-8\D-87T[¢+19@I("0�.³*/1�*U*/8PH68REF��0�4 � �9@7(3(3.­Y�@7HS.%,-8&��T|@I(9LZ�98 � �"@Y�@IH6.7,/8�0�4[Y%85,/4 *� @&��:�')( L5@%DU.J@/bh85,/CG@�*-46Y7. �  8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@\H6.7K%46LM@R0�4 � m�46(º[email protected](+*-,Z@I,/4S."T%L54S.9 8�D-8��#85,@IH6CB85(3.½19(9@ Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38B*/1�*U*/8­H68BEF��0�4�� ,/46L585Y7.%(3. Y�@IH6.7,/8��N8 � ,/46L585Y78BY�@IH6.7,/8:��T @IH6HS.%,/@ � (3.%(  8La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@P0�4 �°:

��8M0346@7CJ.ºLa.%CJ8PEF13(32M4S.%(9@­*/@IH68J�3,-.�L58M0�46CB85(+*-. (385HsLM@7D-.­0�85HsD-8ML5.7(903.­,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-.G,/4QLZ�346@7CG@�*-. (385H� k3:Se%:g 4h*/,/@I*U*/@B0�4AY785,/4Si"L5@7,-8�DU8%©

C D � � D � � < Cg 8³L5.7(9D-460385,/46@7CJ. HQ@½Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38 ��*/@7HS8­LZ�98 �;M C T < ��T �SM D T < ��T �;M �3T�< ��T�@IH6HS.%,/@ �SM C D �

�3T < ��T��SM D �3T�< �d8���M C T�< ��: g 8\L5.7(9D-4Q0�85,/[email protected]@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38��G*Z@IH68\LZ�38��;M C T�< ��T��SM D T < ��T�SM �3T < ��T�@IH6HS.%,/@��;M C D � �3T�< ��T �;M D ��3T�< �£8�SM C T < ��:s^b@7DU*/@\¢+138�Dc*/.R�#85,bLa.%(9LaH6190�8M,-8=LZ�38�(3.%(D-19D-D-4QDc*/8=46H|(38�D-D-.G0�4|La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@VM�87T3¢+1346(90�4�T"LZ�38�46H|,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-.³ 8<D-L5.7,/,-85*U*-.DT :

�~8MH|L5@%DU.G0�8MH|�3,/4SCB.B,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.JDU4h*/,/@I*U*/@B0�4AY785,/4Si"L5@7,-8�DU8%©M C �! D T � M ! C D TLm C � � ! �_m D � �_m E � ��� < E � D

¨[email protected]) @\�9,-8�@I(3(�13(9L546@I*-.RLZ�98~*/@7HS8�,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.G 8=La.%,-,/8a*-*-.\8%T�¢+1346(90�4�T�LZ�38�46Hh�3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/8�(38�D-D-.0�4�La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@~H6.7K74QL5@�DU19D/D-46DU*-8%: ¥ 4) .=D-4SK%(34Si"L5@�LZ�387T��#85,�@lY78M,-8 13(9@�La.7(3EF85,/CB@=@�*-*-,Z@lY78M,/D-.¯4SH��3,/.�La8�0�4SCB8M(%*/.46(90�4QL5@�*/.9T703.�Y+,/85CBCB.��"@7D/D-@7,-8 4S(J,/@%D-D-85K%(9@b*/1�*U*/8¯HS8_�".+D-D-46V34SH64�Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(34�LZ�38b0�4Fb#8M,-4QD/La.7(9.��#85,�46H�CJ.�0�.<0�4Y�@IH61�*/@7,-8~@7HSCB8M(3.�13(9@=*-,Z@�H68~HS8¯H68a*-*-8M,-8¯�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(9@7HS4 C D � $�¯8 E :�¡�D/D-8bD-.7(9.=46(G(�13CB85,/.\0�4�*/,-8M(%*Z@70�198��7T¢+1346(90�4|46H|[email protected],/.³ 8�H613(3K%.J8\L5,-8�D-L58�46( CG@I(34685,Z@J8MD-�".%(385(32M46@7HS8<L5.7(º4SH|(�13CB8M,-.B0�85H6H68<HS85*U*-8M,-8\L5.746(�Y7.7HS*-8%:g 4+�31� .�@IH6HS.%,/@9T�L5.7CB8 @7V3V34Q@ICB.�K%4  @�@7L5L585(3("@�*-.�(385H6HQ@D� 254@Pc4L')'@0�TI�9,-.�La8�0�85,/8s�#85, @7D/DU19,/0�.": g 13�9�".%([email protected]�38�46H|(38MD/D-.B034ALa.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@P(3.%(ºD-19D/DU4QDc*Z@3:�r�85Y78<8�DU4QDU*-85,/8�@IH6HS.%,/@P13(9@BY�@IH61�*[email protected](98 �G*Z@IH68\LZ�387©

�;M5M C �! D T � M ! C D T5T�< � �SM C � ���! �KT�< � �SM D � �KT�< � �SM E � �KT< �y,��%�F/��%����E*,�&�/8� ��x�&�Q�&�70"0"����������./�@./ �#&>�#&./%+*,�&#(!$./#&%BAB./� 0"�b "./%�.��N8B�&��A,*,�&1(0E*,>�#&./%�#@'+*K�(����%�'������x#&%�!�./%� "#&'����E*,>�#&./%��� �./%�.�8B!�./56�

�&�K�"#&F/Z��<'����&�&�K0E*�AB./�&�<'�#�AB����# 0C3*(8�#&%L%�1(56�$�".H'�# G��J]

Page 40: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O%fCB85(+*-,/8

�;M E � D T�< �:

r=@ �SM E � D T< ��T9D-85K%138 �SM E T < �d8��SM D T�< ��:g 8��SM E T�< ��[email protected],Z@3T�03@ �SM E � �KT< ��T9D-85K%138��;M �ET< ��:g 8 �SM �KT;< ��T�@IH6H6.7,Z@ �SM ! �KT�< ��T�8³@I(9LZ�98 �SM �� ! �KT�< ��: ��194S(9034�T�03@ �;M C � � $! �KT;<���T�D-85K%138�SM C T < ��:r=@��SM C T < ��8 �;M D T�< �°D-85K%138�D-46@��;M C ! D T�< �°LZ�98��SM ! C D T< ��T�8_@IH6HS.%,/@��;M5M C ! D T � M ! C D T5T< ��T46( L5.7(+*-,Z@7090�4S2M4S.%(38�La.7( �SM^M C ! D T � M ! C D T^T�< ��:

�~.%(½�".7*-8M(90�.³8�DU4QDc*/85,/8<13(9@GY�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38\LZ�38\,/85(9038\Y78M,-8<H68\�3,/85CB8MD/D-8<8<E�@IHQD-@BHQ@³L5.7(9L5HS19D-46.7(38\D-4A�31� .La.%(9LaH6190�8M,-8<LZ�38<D-19D/DU4QDc*/8�4SH|(98MD/DU.G0�4|L5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@RH6.7K%46LM@�MF8<¢+134S("0�4ALZ�38<46H[,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-.­ 8<La.7,/,/8a*U*/.dTa:

�~8MH��3,-.+D-D-46CJ.�L5@I�94 */.7H6.�La4�D-.3bh85,/CB85,/85CB.�@ICB�34Q@ICB8M(%*/8 �9,-.%�3,-46.�D-1P¢+138�Dc*�´ 13HS*-46CB.�CB85*-.�0�.�0�4�,-4Q0�132M4S.%(38@IH6H�´ @%D-D-13,Z0�.9T 8MD-�3H646L54 *Z@I(903.7H6.�@�*-*-,Z@lY78M,/D-.¼13( DU4QDc*/85CG@�0�4b,-8MK7.7H68³CB8MLML5@7(346LZ�987:·¥ 4) .�L54bL5.7(9D-85(+*/4S,� @3TsL5.7CB8Y78�0�,/85CB.9Th(3.%(�D-.7H6. 0�4�,/46D-.7H6Y78M,-8R�34U 1�D-�"8�0�4 *Z@ICB85(+*/8P8�DU8M,/L54S2M4 034�Y%85,/4 i#L5@­034 */@I13*-.7H6.7K%4S8P8J034sLa.7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@0�4|,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4�T�CG@B@I(9LZ�98�034|.I*-*-85(985,/8=(�13.�Y%8�46(�EF.%,-CG@I2M4S.%(34|D-13H[(38MD/D-.B034ALa.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@9:

����� � � �=# ���� E�p#���� �p�N� ��#Z� �� /�i ��#!��� � �_� ���! "�N�����` # �� �@ `���N���;� �� "��p�&� � ��#

�~8MH �9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.G�3,-8�La8�0�85(+*-8JDU4_ 8\Y�4QDc*/.ºL5.7CB8RH68\*/8ML5(346LZ�98P�3,/8MD-85(+*Z@�*-8PLa.7("DU8M(%*Z@I(3. 0�4�0�8ML5460�8M,-8JDU19HSHQ@­L5.7,-�,/8a*U*/852M2M@½.¼CB8M(3.�0�8M4 ,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4�:  ¡ V#85(98­�#85,� .¼�3,/8MLa4QD/@I,/8³LZ�38³HQ@�D-.7H6132546.7(38G.7*U*/85(�1�*/@° 8­0�85i9(34S*-46Y�@D-.7H6.¼�"8M,J¢+19@7(+*-.�,/46K719@7,/03@ 46Hb�3,/.7V3H685CG@¼0�4¯DU*/@7V34SH646,-8­D-8­19(9@�L585,-*/@½EF� � 0�8MHbHS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S. £ 8­.�(3.7(  8La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@PH6.7K%46LM@G0�4A19(�03@�*/.G4S("DU4685CB8 � 0�4�EF�|ThDU8MCJ�9,-8\0�8MHAH64S(9K719@7K7K746.�T#@7D/DU19(%*/8\La.%CJ8R�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8%:'R,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4_D-.7(9.�DU*/@I*-4¯46(34S2M46@7HSCB8M(%*/8 8MD-�3,-8�D-D-4_(385H¯H64S(9K719@7K7K746.�("@�*-19,/@7HS8º87T_�3,/4SCG@�LZ�38½DU4b�#.%D/D-@7(3.@I�9�3HS4QL5@7,-8�H68<(3.72M4S.%(34[46HSH619DU*-,Z@�*-8<46(½¢+138MDU*-.GL5@7�34S*-.7H6.9T[ 8�DU*/@I*/@B(38�La8�D-D/@I,/46@P13(9@[oU*-,Z@70�192546.7(38EqP03@7H[HS46(3K%19@IK7�K746.�(9@�*/13,/@7HS8º@IHbH64S(3K%19@IK%K746. �:�?|8½La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(34_.I*U*/85(�1�*/8º�#.%D/D-.7(3.�8MD/DU8M,-8 ,-46�".%,U*Z@�*/8º@74_,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/4D-.7H6.�DU8ºHQ@ oc*/,/@%0�132M4S.%(38`q� 8ºDc*Z@�*Z@½EF8M0385H687:�¥ .7CB8 D-4� 8 0�85*U*/.9T�46H_H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.½(9@I*-13,Z@IH68­(9.7(  8º@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@I*-.@IH i9(38º0�4_8MD-�3,-46CB85,/8³,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-4+ms@I(9254�Ts03@�¢+138�Dc*/.¼�313(+*-.�0�4bY�46DU*/@9T @7�3�9@7,-8­@%D-D/@I4_L5@7,-8M(%*/8­@¼LM@I19D/@0�8MHSH68�D-138~,/460�.%(903@7(3258%T%DUEF13CG@�*-19,-8%T+@7CRV346K7134S*l @9©A(38MHSH�´ 19DU.P0�85H"HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.�(9@I*-13,Z@IH68�D-49�3,/8MD-85(+*Z@I(3.<D-Yl@7,-4Q@�*/8D-4 */19@I2M4S.%(34�4S(�L5134sHQ@ oUEF.7,/CG@­H6.7K%46LM@Bqº0�85H6HS8G�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34 (3.%(�DU.%HS.� 8J*-1�*-*M´ @IHS*-,/.½LZ�38B*-,Z@7D-�9@I,/85(+*/87T[CG@� 8�#85,ZDU46(3.B4S( La.%(+*-,Z@7DU*-.PL5.7(º[email protected],/.PH68a*-*-13,Z@JDU46(+*/@�*-*-4QL5@BD-13�"8M,Ui#La4Q@IH687:���1346(90�4�T3.�L5La.%,-,/8~*/85(38M,¯�3,/8MD-85(+*-8�LZ�387T�#85,~@I�9�3HS4QL5@7,-8�H68=*-8ML5(34QLZ�38�EF.7,/CG@IH64|@IH6H�´ @I(9@7HS4QD-4h034|,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-4h(38MH[HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.BLa.%CR13(987T�.�L5L5.7,/,-.%(3.P0�198E�@7D-4"0346DU*-46(+*-87© HQ@aq�*/,/@%0�132M4S.%(38`q�46(}�8%T%�#.74�T�H�´ 46CJ�94S8MK7.R0�8MHSH68~*/8ML5(346LZ�98~,-8MH6@I*-46Y78�@��:�?A@<�9H6@719DU46V346HS4S*l @P0�85H6H68La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(34�0�46�"8M(90�8­03@7HsLa.%,-,/8a*-*-. D-Y7.%HSK%4SCB8M(%*/.º034�85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8BH68PE�@%DU4�: � ,-V#85(987T|46HsH6.7K74QLa.� 8B4S(+*/85,/8MD/D-@I*-.8MD/D-85(32M46@7HSCB85(+*/8P@IH6HQ@­D-8MLa.%(903@³E�@7D-87ThCB85(+*-,/8RH�´ 8�DU8�La132M4S.%(38P0385H6H6@ �3,/4SCG@¼ 8P0�4�La.%CB�"85*-85(92M@­0385H6HS. Dc*/190�46.%D-.0�8MHAH64S(3K%19@IK%K746.9T346H ¢%1"@IH68\�9@G46H�L5.7CB�34S*-.­0�4�,/4SY%85HQ@I,/8=HQ@³DU*-,/1�*U*/13,Z@GHS.%K74QL5@[o-�3,-.7EF.7(909@Bq�MFH�´ 8@b#85*U*/4SY%. D-4SK%(34 i9�L5@I*-.DTs0�8MHSH68��3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(34#0�85H#HS46(3K%19@IK%K746.<(9@�*/13,/@7HS8%: ��198MDU*-4h@7D-�"85*U*-4[D-.7(3.R�9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-CB85(+*/8¯85Y�460385(+*-4hDU8=DU4La.%(9D-460�8M,/@JLa.%CB8�D-.7(9.J46CB�34685K%@I*-4[4AL5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY�4|(985H[H64S(3K%19@IK%K746.P("@�*-19,/@7HS8%:� ¥ .%(9D-460�8M,-4Q@ICB.<[email protected](3K%4S13(92546.7(38�o-8`q9:���85H#HS46(3K71"@IK7K%4S.<("@�*-19,/@7HS8�o-8`qPLa.7(9K74613(3K78¯(9.7(­D-.7H6.\�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34�TCG@B@I(9LZ�38�(3.%CB4�T3Y%85,/V34�T3@lY+Y%85,/V34�T+8<L5.%D)  $hY+4Q@3:

?A@~�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(987©po � 032L7F<�4 ��0/2L.1<�'@</9S< .8(\0/7l.1039-.lqR 8s85Y�4Q0�85(+*/85CB85(+*-8 8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-8_@3©!o � 032L7F< �4Z.8(\0/7l.1039;<4 ��0/2L.1< �4c.8(\0/7l.1039;<@q MF8BH�´ 19D-.½0�4�oU8Eq� 8PY%85,/.I��EF13(32546.7("@IH68ET :u�A13*U*/@lY�4Q@ºH6@º�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(387©io � 0/2L7e<H4 ��0/2L.1<'@</9S<�03PN.1>@.lq3T��913, @lY%85(90�.<HQ@\DU*-8�D-D/@\DU*-,/1�*U*/13,/@\K7,Z@ICBCG@�*-4QL5@7HS8%TI(3.%(³�9@<46H#D-46K7(34Si"L5@I*-.\0�4�© o � 0/2L7e< �4�0/P�.1>G<4 �N032L.1< �4�0/P�.1>)<"q½CG@½0�4�©Ho � 0/2L7F< �4i03PN.1>)< ,/. ��0/2L.1< 4 �N032L.1< �4�0/P�.1>)<=,3. � 0/2L7F<@q MF8­H6@ o-8`q� 8GY78M,-.7�EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH68ETa:&�¼@ºDU8J0�[email protected]©�o � 032L7F<�4 ��0/2L.1< J 4"'@0/9;<��3����A`q³. @I("LZ�387©�o � 0/2L7F< 4 ��0/2L.1<�'"<39;<V*&9S0�)4"787e0i>)< J_J .10@qG(3.7(½D-4[�31� .³0�4QDU*-,/4SV3194S,/8�4SH|�9,-8�0�46LM@�*/.JD-134AD-4S(9K7.7H64[46(90�46Y+4Q0�134�:s?A@J�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(38%©

� � 0/2L7F<V4 ��0/2L.1<c'L(h039-9;<�WK4@9;4@9;,_< � M�k3:SeKT�31� .GD-4SK%(34Si"L5@7,-8=DU4Q@3© o � 032L7F<c'L(\0QW/4"9S4"9S,B<64 �N032L.1<Q'L(\0QWK4@9;4@9;,_<"qGD-46@9© o � 0/2L7F<i4 ��0/2L.1<c')(\0/9X9;<QW/4@9;4@9;,B<.89R'L.14@PQ45q3:=')(�¢+138�Dc*/. D-8MLa.%(90�.­LM@7D-.³HQ@³Y78M,-4S*l @­0�85H6H6@³�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(986M�k3:SeKT¯(3.%(�0�46�"8M(90�8BDU.%HS.­09@IH6H6@GY%85,/4 *� @

Page 41: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O"e0�8MHSH68P�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34 La.%CB�".%(385(+*-4pM@o � 0/2L7F<�')(\0VW/4"9S4"9S,B<"qº8 o ��0/2L.1<V'L(\0VWK4@9;4@9;,_<"qdT~8G¢+1346(90�4�*/@7HS8J19D-.º0�4oU8Eq³(3.%(� 8PY78M,-. Y785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH687:<¨�(9LZ�38J(385H�L5@%DU.º0�4�©io � [email protected]�,_4"7 � .87F039 �4c25</')'"0 4c9;4@250"q (3.7(�DU446(%*/85(9038³@/b[@�*U*/.¼@/bh85,/CG@I,/8BLZ�987© o � 0 [email protected] ,B4@7� .87F039 �4625<K')'@0H467F0HPQ0`A37U.10=,_4"7���.87e0/9 �4i9S4"250@q3:­¿�(@IHS*-,/.=8MD-85CB�346.=0�4�1"DU.=(3.7(JY78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS8 0�4:oU8Eq\ 8_46H3DU8MK7138M(%*/87©!o � <39;<a039;,B03(h<�0/787e0 'L([email protected]</9;4�4ZfR< J 254"'"<.87�(+254"9S<"q­4S(�La134�HQ@³Y%85,/4 *� @­0�8MHSHQ@­�9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(38J0�46�"8M(90�87TA.7HS*-,/8PLZ�38B03@IH6HQ@­Y%85,/4 *� @­0�8MHSH68J03138JL5.7CB�#.7(38M(%*/4�T@I("LZ�38 03@7H H6.7,/.¼.%,/0�46(38G*/85CB�#.7,Z@IH687:  ¡w46(�E�@�*-*-4¯0�46Y785,ZD-.¼0�4S,/87©ko��O< J 2G4L'@<=.87Z(I254@9;< 4i'@</9S<k0/9;,_0/(\<[0/787F0'L([email protected]</9;45q�M�H6@<(9.7(BY�@IH6460�4S*l @R0�85H6H6@��9,-.%�3,-468a*� @<La.%CJCP1�*/@I*-46Y�@J 8¯4S("0�46L58�0�8MHSHQ@�(3.7(GY%85,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH64 *� @�0385H6H�´ 19D-.0�4!o-8`qdT :

Ã=4) @°¢+138MDU*-4��#.�LZ�94�8�DU8MCJ�94�46HSH619DU*-,Z@I(3.·La.7CB8�(3.7( D-85CB�3,/8 o-8`q°�"@�4SH<D-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-.�L5.�034 i"LM@�*/.�La.%( 4SHLa.%(3(385*U*-46Y7. m HQ@ oc*/,/@%0�132546.7(98`q 0�4Oo-8`q La.%( o �q� 8GH68MLa4S*/@½¢+19@7(90�.½H�´ 1"DU.¼0�4OoU8`q� 8P*/,/@ �9,-.%�".+DU462546.7(34�8�0 8 Y785,/.I��EF13(32M4S.%(9@IH687:�')(�CB.7HS*-4¯LM@7D-4 HQ@½*/,/@%0�132546.7(98� 8 HS8�La4S*/@3T�8M0� 8 �"8M,G¢%198MDU*/@¼,Z@IK%4S.%(38­LZ�38ºH685K7K%46@7CB.¼4SHD-4SCPV".%HS.[o �qBL5.7CB8�oU8`q9T�CG@P(9.7( Y�@IH68=46H|Y�4QLa85Y%85,ZD-@9:� ��85H L5@%DU.­034 o-._qGHQ@­D-4 */19@I2M4S.%(38³ 8P@I(9L5.7,Z@G�34U 1�La.%CJ�9HS8�D-D/@3:���85H � e%:SeP0�85Hs¥_@I�|:�ePD-4� 8RY�46DU*-. LZ�387T[@I("LZ�38,/8MDU*/@I("0�.~(38MHSH�´ @7CRV34S*-.�0�8MHSHQ@~Y%85,/.I��EF13(32546.7("@IH64 *� @3T�Y+4�D-.7(3.=@IH6CB85(3.�*-,/8�19D-4�0�4�oU._q9©[H6@�0�4QDUK%4S13(92546.7(38 4S(9L5HS1"DU46Y�@M W/4@7 T T#H6@G0346D-K74613(32M4S.%(38�8MD/LaH619DU46Y�@ M503*&(gT_8<HQ@G0�4QDUK%4S13(92546.7(38\0�4A4S(9L5.7CB�9@I*-46V34SH64S*l @3:_?s´ 19D-.B034|*/@7HS8\L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY%. 8\�#85,-*/@7(+*-.³46(+*-,/4S(9D-8MLM@ICB85(+*/8\@ICRV94SK%13.9T"�".%46LZ�$#8\DU.%HS.³46H La.7(+*/8MDU*-.�MF. H6@­0�46LZ�946@7,/@72546.7(38\0�8MH��"@I,/H6@7(%*/8ET_�31� .LZ�34Q@I,/4S,/8�@J¢+19@7HS8<0�8M4[*-,/8<DU46K7(94 i"LM@�*/4|DU4[E�@%L5L546@J,/4 EF8M,-46CB85(+*-.":� ')H�L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY%.³LZ�38\D-.7H6HS8MYl@9T346(¼¢%198MDU*-.³La.%(+*-8MDU*-."T346HACG@IK%K746.7,¯(�13CB85,/.G0�4A�3,/.7V9HS8MCJ4s 8<4SH�La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8%T34SH¢+19@IH68BY�4S8M(38GHS85*U*/. o/DU8 :M:5:5T�@IH6HS.%,/@�:5:M:5q9:J')HsE�@�*U*/.� 8GLZ�387TA(385HsH646(3K719@7K7K%4S. La.%CR13(38%T!o-D-8 :5:M:5T�@7HSH6.7,Z@�:5:5:5qY�4S8M(38�46CB�34685K%@I*-.\�#85,b8�DU�3,/46CJ8M,-8�13(³(38�D-D-.<*-,Z@\H�´ @I(+*-8�La8M0385(+*-8�8�46H#L5.7(9D-85K%1385(+*-8�8�¢+1346(90�4hH6@RY78M,-4S*l @\034"13("@�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38G0�85H�*-46�".so/DU8 � T�@7HSH6.7,Z@�#Oq½D-4�V9@%D-@ D-13H D-19D/DU4QDU*-85,/8G0�4s*Z@IH68G(38MD/D-.[M�8³(3.%(�D-.7H6.¼D-13HsY�@IH6.7,/80�4bY78M,-4S*l @�0�4 � 8º0�4 #�TLmb4S( @IHS*-,/4_*-85,/CB4S(94�TsK%HS4b19D-4¯0�85HQo/DU8�:5:5:MT�@IH6H6.7,Z@�:5:M:5q DU.%(3.�CB.7HS*-.�D-�"8�D-D-.�(3.%(Y78M,-.7��EF19(32546.7(9@7HS4�: �s,/4SCG@J0�4|Y78�0�85,/8�¢%1"@IHQLZ�38�8�DU8MCB�34S."T�*-.%,-([email protected],/85Y78MCB85(+*-8<D-13H[�3,/.7V3H685CG@B0�85H6HQ@JD/La8MH *Z@0�8MHSHQ@G*[email protected]@G0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @³034 � M�0�8MH�La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68\CG@�*/85,/46@7HS8KT :���85H � e%:SeP0�85Hs¥_@I�|:�eRD-4  8\K74619DU*-4Si"L5@I*/@B*Z@IH68D/La85HS*/@�@/bh85,/CG@I(903.�LZ�38 */@7HS8º*/@lY%.7HQ@¼La.%,-,/4QDU�#.7(9038 @IH6H�´ 19D-.�0�85HQo-D-8�:5:5:MT�@IH6H6.7,Z@°:5:M:5q LZ�38 D-4b@%0�.I*-*/@�(385H,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-. CG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QLa.": ��8M0�4Q@ICB. �"8M,/LZ�$#87:  ¡À(3.I*/.ºLZ�38BHQ@½Dc*/,/@7K7,Z@I(9038RCG@IK%K746.7,Z@I(32�@³0�854s*-85.%,-8MCB40�4|CG@I*-85CG@I*-4QL5@B�9@7(3(3.B�3,/.7�3,/[email protected],/CB@ o/DU8 � T9@IH6HS.%,/@ #Oq9:�� 85,~034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8=H6@BY%85,/4 *� @J034!o-D-8 � T"@7HSH6.7,Z@#Oq­DU4�@7L5L58a*-*/@³0�4��#.I*-8M,��3,/.�La8�0�85,/8 oU�#85,=@7D/DU13,Z0�.dq3: g 4�D-13�3�#.7(38JLZ�38\46H|*/85.7,/85CG@GD-46@GE�@IHQDU.HM�La46.9 8\LZ�98�o-D-8� [email protected],Z@�#NqP@7V3V34Q@RY�@IH6.7,/8*�!T 8�DU4h�#.7(38�LZ�38�@IH6HS.%,/@ � M�H�´ 46�".7*-8MD-48T� 8�Y%85,Z@<8 # M�H6@R*-8�DU48T~ 8�E�@7H6D/@3:�r�.7�#.J0�4LZ�38JDU4 0�8M0319La8P13(�@7D/D-13,/03.9:�¨�HSH6.7,Z@³D-4�La.%(9LaH6190�8JLZ�38R46H�*-85.%,-8MCG@  8\Y%85,/.9: g 4 @7D/D-13CB8R¢+134S("0�4�LZ�98RH�´ 13(946L5.L5@%DU. � 46(­La134 o-D-8 � T�@7HSH6.7,Z@�#OqR�9@\Y�@7HS.%,-88�À 8=¢+19@I(903. � �9@RY�@IH6.7,/8 � 8 #w�9@<Y�@7HS.%,-88� M�La.%CJ8R 8�D/@I(9L54 */.(38MHSHQ@P*/@lY7.%H6@J0�4 � T :

¨�13HS*-8M,-46.7,/8 ,-46�3,/.�Y�@_0385H6H6@~@%0�85K%19@�*/852M2M@_0�85H6H6@¯*/@lY7.%H6@b0�4 � TlLa.%(9D-460�8M,[email protected]@¯�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38�@I,/4 */CJ85*-4QL5@9©q J 4@2O<5AB9-.9-V4 J 4@2O<5AB9-."/��:'@4 - �4�,/.8WE.g'@</254Q,3./�� 0/787F<3250=- �4�,/.8WE.g'@</254Q,3.�k7/"q9:

¡�D/D/@B 8=Y785,Z@<(38M4[(�13CB85,/4#("@�*-19,/@7HS4�T+¢+1346(90�4|0385Y7.%(3.R8�D-D-85,/8�Y%85,/49*/1�*U*/4|4[DU19.74[L5@%DU4#�9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-4 MF.7*U*-8M(�1�*-4D-.%DU*-4S*-138M(90�.B(�13CB85,/4|@IH|�#.%DU*-.G0�8MHSH68�Yl@7,-4Q@IV94SH64 � 8 � TLm9D-.7(3.B¢+1346(90�4|Y%85,/87©

'@4�> �4N,3.8W`.g'@<3254c,/.|� � 0/787F<3250R> �4N,3.8W`.g'@<3254Q,/.se�¤ M�k3: k_T'@4�§ �4N,3.8W`.g'@<3254c,/.|� � 0/787F<3250R§ �4N,3.8W`.g'@<3254Q,/.se�¤ M�k3: >dT'@4=X �4N,3.8W`.g'@<3254c,/.|� � 0/787F<3250PX �4N,3.8W`.g'@<3254Q,/.se�¤ M�k3: ODT

MF46HhLa.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68¯�9@<Y�@7HS.%,-8 �¶¢%1"@I(90�.\@7(+*-8ML58M0�8M(+*-8~8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(+*/8~�9@I(9(3.<Y�@IH6.7,/8���M�k3: k_T T�¢+19@I(903.\H�´ @I(3�*-8�La8�0�85(+*-8��9@\Y�@IH6.7,/8�� 8�46H"L5.7(9D-85K%1385(+*-88��M�k3: >dT 8�¢+19@7(90�.<H�´ @7(%*/8ML58M0�8M(%*/8~�9@RYl@7HS.%,-8�� 8�4SH#La.7("DU8MK7138M(%*/8�M�k�: OdT5T :

?A@<D-4S*[email protected](38�LZ�98~DU4",-8MK74QDc*/,/@�(38MH9,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB85(+*/.=CG@I*-85CG@I*-4QLa.�MF46(­L5134946H o/DU8 � [email protected],Z@�#OqRDU49*-,Z@70�19L58La.%( 46H<La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68�CG@I*-85,/4Q@IH68 � T­(9.7(¦D-4�,-8�@IH64S2M2M@�46(ÀK785(985,/8�(38MH=H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.�L5.7CP13(387:µ��85H6HS8�0�198�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34�©Vo � 4+�H0/25>)< J 4"'"0 �.� � A ��0/787e</250 �H0/25>)< J 4"'@0 J . �* ,/. ,3*-4 !@*&.89-(\0/7l.lq 8ko � 4)��0325>)< J 4"'"0�.� � A � 0/787F<3250D�H0/25>)< J 4"'"06Pc4"9S<6,/. � A@qJH�´ @7(+*-8ML58M0�8M(+*-8�8<4|La.%(9DU8MK7138M(+*-4|D-.7(3.J*-13*U*-4|E�@IHQDU4jM�DU8��¼@7,/L5.�9@J13( �#8MD-.J(9.7,/CB@7HS8%T3@70 8MD-85CB�346.G0�4�]�f�*�KDT T�CG@JH6@B�3,/46CB@J�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(38P 8=Y785,Z@J8�H6@BD-8MLa.%(903@PE�@IHQD/@3:

" !��<#&��h� "�*/X8(*,�&�&./�E* 2<iT�~./ " ��[�~*,�& �.X#&%D*,� 0"��#=!$*, �#?8�#&� �E*,F/#&./%�*,56�$%B0".��@�$��*, " �1��"'�.H'�.$A(�"��O�O@�X!�./%B0���56���M*,�"�&# 0"1(0�0�#?]N���=�~*C0�0�.!EZ��< "#�*,!�!��70"0"#2'�#��� E*,56#&%�*,��%��K1(%�.� �./�&.H!$./%��~����5;*X!EZ��< "#�*,'�.,0�0E*6�M*)0E*�AB./�M*�'�#=AB����# 0C3*H'�����!�./%�'(#&>$#&./%�*,�&�X5;*C0"����#M*,�&�/]

Page 42: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O+k')(|© o � 4&�H0/2G>G< J 4"'@0 �3� ��A ��03787F</250A�H0/25>)< J 4"'@0 Pc4"9S<H,/.?,3*-4D!@*&.89-(\0/7l.lq 8ko � 4&�H0325>)< J 4L'@0 �.� �

A � 03787F</2G0C�H0/2G>G< J 4"'@0 J . �*k,3. � A@qºH�´ @7(+*-8ML58M0�8M(+*-8  8JE�@IHQDU.º8B4sLa.7("DU8MK7138M(%*/4�DU.%(3. Y785,/4�T[CB@ºHQ@º�3,-46CG@�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(38P 8=E�@IHQD-@J8�[email protected](903@JY%85,Z@3:�~8M4%,Z@IK%4S.%(9@ICB8M(%*/47.%,/0�46(9@7,-4�T�¢%194S(9034�TID-4��".+D-D-.7(3.�Y785,/4Si"L5@7,-8�D-4S*[email protected](34+4S(VM�@7�3�9@I,/85(+*/8ET|L5.7(+*-,Z@7090�4S2M4S.%(38

La.%( HQ@P*-,Z@�*-*/@I2M4S.%(38��3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/87:g 8�*/,/@%0�19La8�D-D-46CJ.GH�´ @/bh85,/[email protected](38%©ao � 4a9S4"7 J <[email protected]< J .1</W/4"2 �0 �p03787F</250V9S</9[0/9-9S0�� 4"2 �<i7^] <32L(h<@q³La.%(

M C � ! D T T��#.I*-,/85CBCB.�038M0�13,/(38sH6.7K%46LM@ICB85(+*/8?M D � ! C TaTILa46.9 8%©Zo � 4p039-9S0�� 4"2 �< 75] </2L(\<�� 0/787e</250a9;</9 J .1</W/4"2 �09;4@7 J </Pc4"2L.UAEAB.1<"q3T"4SH�LZ�38J 8��9@IH68MD-85CB85(+*/8�@%D-D-13,Z0�.9:g 4��".7*-,/85V3V#85,/.GCB.7HS*-46�3HS4QL5@7,-8<K%HS4A8MD-85CB�34�LZ�98\85Y�4Q0�85(32M46@7(3.³La.%CB8<K7H64A19D-4�0�8MH q%DU8G:M:5:5T#@IH6HS.%,/@º:M:5:5q�(385HH64S(3K%19@IK%K746.¼La.%CR13(38ºDU4Q@I(9.�DU�#8MD/D-.�0�4QD-D-4SCB46HS4b03@7H_L5.7CB�".%,U*Z@ICB85(+*/.�0�85HbLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8­CB@I*-8M,-4Q@IH68 � : g .%(3.DU*/@�*/4�La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@�*/4 o-�9@I,Z@703.%D/DU4gqG0�85H6H�´ 46CB�[email protected](38JCG@�*/85,/46@7HS8JH6@ Y�@IH646034 *� @ 0�4 � � M�# � � TOM��"8M,\La134�D-8�  8<13("@J*-8MD-4�T[ 8<46CJ�9HS4QL5@I*/@G03@G¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4#­T9@I("LZ�38\DU8\¢+138�Dc*Z@B(3.7( �9@G@7H6L513( ,-19.7H6.J�#85,�Dc*Z@IV346HS46,/8 � Tb8\0�4! � � M � � #NTaM�LZ�38<D/@I(9L546D/La8<LZ�38<03@J13(9@JE�@7H6D-4S*l @BDU8MK7138<¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4h�3,/.7�#.%D-462546.7(38KT�I�:

�~8M4[,/@7K746.7(9@7CB85(+*-4[La.%(90�.7*U*-4A(385H[H64S([email protected](38%T�(3.7( DU8MCB�3,-8<Y�@7HS8�HQ@P�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @P034|CB.7(3.7*-.7(946@9T.%D/D-46@9T�D-8 @713CB85(+*/@7(3.¼H68³�3,/85CB8MD/DU8%T �".+D-D-.7(3.�CR1�*Z@I,/8³HS8 La.7("DU8MK7138M(3258%:�¨�0�8�DU8MCB�34S.�DU4_�31� .�@%L5L58a*U*Z@I,/8LZ�38%© o � 4 .87XPc</(\</2G4�,3.�,_4L'L(+250O9;</9 �)*&[email protected]<39;0��j03787F</250�.87 J .87e</(\0�(h4@9-(\0�*&9 0/(+(h4@2L250`A`AB.1<c,/. �"</2L(+*&9;0"q9T7CG@<�31� .8MD/D-85,/8sE�@IHQD-.9©!o � 4Z.87&Pc</(\</254 ,/. ,_4L'L(+250 9;<39 �)*&[email protected]<39;0a4!.87&PQ<3(h<3254 ,3.;').89X.g'L(I250 �4p.89�� 0/P�PQ4E� 0/787e</250a.87 J .87F<3(h0(\4"9X(h0Q*&9 0/(+(h4@[email protected]<i,3.��"</2L(+*&9;0@qVM�La.%( */1�*U*/4|4|CB.I*/.7,/4[4S(½@lY�@I,/4Q@R(3.%(ºD-4|�31� .P*/85(+*/@7,-8�13(½@I*U*-8M,-,Z@IK%K746.P0�4EF.7,-*-19(9@3T+CG@RLa.%(�Y+4685(98~H6@7(9La4Q@I,ZD-49La.%H9�9@7,/@%L5@7031�*-8KT T�La.7(+*/,-.<46H9E�@I*U*/.PLZ�38%T+D-8�Y�@IH68 C � D T�@7HSH6.7,Z@�Y�@IH68�@I("LZ�38C � � D �I:¨~K%K74613(3K%46@7CJ.�@I(9L5.7,Z@¼LZ�387T CB.7HS*-.�D-�#8MD/DU."Ts(385HbH64S(9K719@7K7K746.�L5.7CR19(38 46HQo-D-8�:M:5:MT�@IH6HS.%,/@°:5:5:Gq Y+4685(9846CJ�94S8MK%@�*/.­La.%(½4SH D-4SK%(34 i#L5@�*/.­0�4�o-D-8\8PD-.7H6.³D-8`q3: ��19@I(903.­0�4QLa.­@%0½13(�@7CJ4QLa."©No � 4Q<GA`AB. �"0 �)4@787F<��?0/787e</250W/4"9DA_<i0�(+25</W/0/2L(+.lq3T�8MK7H64[CB4A@7D-�"85*U*Z@[o-D-8=8<D-.7H6.GDU8Eq\E�@BV#85H6HS.":

��85,/CJ46(34Q@ICB.¼¢+138MDU*/@½@7�3�#85(90�4QLa8 La.7(°@7H6L513(38³�9,-8�[email protected](34sD-13H6H�´ 4SCB�34685K%.�0�8MH La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8G8 0�85H V34 �La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8=(38MH|HS46(3K%19@IK%K746.JL5.7CR19(387T3D-.7�3,Z@�*-*-1�*-*-.B46( ¢+138MHSH6.BCG@�*-8MCG@�*-4QLa.":

¨~(9254S*-1�*-*-.9T"@IH[�#.%DU*-.³0�4po/DU8 � T"@IH6HS.%,/@ #Oq9T3DU4|1"D-@7(3.GDU�#8MD/DU."©o g 8 � T #Oqo #³T"DU8 � qo � D-.7H6.JD-8�#Oqo #³T"DU13�9�".+Dc*/.BLZ�98 � qo-?s´ 46�".7*-8MD-4 � 46CB�3HS4QL5@JHQ@P*-8MD-4 #Nq8ML5L7:

g 8<D-4|,-4QLa.%,/09@RHQ@P*/@lY7.%H6@J0�4|Y%85,/4 *� @B0�85HAL5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH687T3D-8�4SHAL5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH68J 8�Y785,/.J8M0� 8�Y78M,-. � [email protected],Z@­ 8Y78M,-.B@I("LZ�38�#³T9D-4[K74619DU*-4Si"L5@JH�´ 19D-.G0�4�©�o �  8<La.%(90�462546.7(38<D-1&%³La4685(+*-8<�#85, #Nq=o #  8<La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(38�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-4Q@�#85, � q

¨~("LZ�38�H6@JH6.�L5132546.7(987©o-D-.7H6.JD-8�#³[email protected],Z@R¨ q

 8�13( CB.�03.J�#85,�8MD-�3,-46CB85,/8=LZ�98�#  8�L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(38�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-4Q@R�#85, � :')H|V34QLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8 o � D-8<8RDU.%HS.GD-8�#OqB8�¢+134SY�@7HS8\@ko/DU8 � T#@7HSH6.7,Z@�#OqB8�o/DU8�#­T"@IH6H6.7,Z@ � q3: g 4A.+D-D-85,/Y�4

LZ�38%T946(so � D-8\8RD-.7H6.³DU8 #Oq3T"4SH��3,/4SCB.ko-D-8`q M@o � D-8�#Nq_Tb46(90�4QL5@G46H�D-8ML5.7(903.³La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68�M"o/DU8�#­T#@7HSH6.7,Z@� qdT T3CB8M(%*/,-8�46H!o-D-.7H6.BDU8EqP46(90�4QL5@J46H|�3,/4SCB.GLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8cM@o-D-8 � [email protected],Z@�#OqdT :o � D-8\8RD-.7H6.³D-8�#Oq3T"8MD/DU8M(90�.GHQ@³La.%(3K74613(32M4S.%(38\0�8MHSH68R0�138R�3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(94po �  8\L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(38<(38ML58MD/D-@7,-4Q@

C , �#& �0��x1�%;*,56�(#&.K ��70�0�./�"�['����&�M*K�&./F/#&!$*(8��M*Hj k�lBmRnEo6nEk�.@p/m 4$mRk�.@o/j qt8�%����+9�1+*,�&�b "#+!��$�"!$*,%�.�8�0"�E*K� f *,� 0"��.�8B'(�$�&�&�Q�R./��5;*,�&#&>�>$*,>�#&./%�#��#"31T*,'���F/1+*C0"��'(�$�-h� ��[]$]�]$8/*,�&�&./�E*X]�]�]"iw!$./56�N1(0"#&�&#&>$>$*C0".<%���#(��*,F/#&./%+*,56��%�0"#(./�"'�#&%+*,��#?8C#&%)!$1(#�%�./%;3�Q �1��6!�#&��%B0��Q� f *, "� �70�0�.bAB�$�".�f�R1�%�>�#&./%+*,�&�/8(5;*K�(#&1(0"0"./ "0".X� f #&� .,0"�70�#&!$*<AB����# 0C3*X'����&� f *,%B0���!���'���%�0"��3��1�%6���&�$56��%B0�.X'����&�M*< ���#&��FB*,>�#&./%��b'����&�M*)#&�@.,0"�70�#&!$*<AB�$�"# 0,3*)'����!�./%� ���F/1���%B0��6�/8=#&%�./� 0"���/8@A(#&��%��H*C`=�"./%�0�*C0�*L�M*6'�#&O+*C0�0�1�0E*D�(��./O��&��5;*C0"#&!t*6'���#xnEk�.@p/m 4�m~k�.@o/j mbnEk�.+s J k N�o/s?s -(o/j mQPR!$./%v*,%B0���!���'���%�0"��~*,�& �.�YE]

K C ���Q ��70�0�./�"�D'����&�&�wj k�lBmRn�D(q�pBqtj j o J m j q3F,o�.54toG �#Q#&%B0��".�'(1�!�./%�.4�G �#Q �0�1('�#M*,%�.�'���#Q!$*,�&!$./�&#x�&./F/#&!�#Q!EZ��G%�./%a#&%�!�./�"��./%�.�%���#�+*,��*,'�./ � "#�'����&� f #&56���&#&!$*,>�#&./%��[5;*C0"����#M*,�&�/]� �����~*C0"0".<!EZ��Q#&���E*,F/#&./%+*,56��%B0�.K!�./5T1�%��x*,O�O�#M*b9�1��� �0E*[!$*,��*C0"0"����#& "0"#&!$*K�@�$�J!�1�#?8B*,��!$�"�� �!������Q'����&�&�Q#&%(�R./��5;*,>�#&./%�#B'�#& "� ./%(#&O�#&�&#?8

A/*,�"#M*,%�.G�&�H!�./%� ���F/1���%�>��/8x3��*,�&� f ./�"#&F/#&%��T'(�$�&� f ��%�./�"56�) "A�#&�&1����@.�8�#&%w0"�$56�(#J�"��!$��%B0�#?8�%����N!$*,56�@.G'����&� f ��%�0"���&�&#&F/�$%(>t*G�[��0�# \+!�#M*,�&�PR'�.tAB�T �#�A�1�./�&�T�"#&����.�'�1��"���X*,1(0"./5;*C0�#&!$*,56��%B0��X#&�-!�./56� ./��0E*,56��%B0�.;#&%B0����&�&#&F/��%B0��X'����&� f 1�./56.�YE8@'����J "�70"0"./���T'����&�&�;j kEl/m~nID(q�.@k�.r�k�.@k/s��k�.@qt]

Page 43: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O+>�#85,(#NqcM"o/DU8 #­[email protected],Z@ � q_T�86o �  8~L5.7(90�462546.7(98~DU1&%³L54S8M(%*/8~�#85,.#Nq�M"o/DU8 � [email protected],Z@ #Oq_TaT%D-49�31� .<8MD-�3,-46CB85,/8@I("LZ�38<La.7(A©

o �  8�La.%(90�462546.7(38�(38�La8MD/D/@I,/46@P8<DU1&%³L54S8M(%*/8<�"8M,&#OqoZ¥ .7("0�4S2M4S.%(38�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-4Q@\8\D-1&%³La4685(+*/8\@/%G(9LZ�$#8 #  8 � q

¨w0�4Fbh85,/85(32�@³0�85H�La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8%T34SH�V34QLa.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8B 8RL5.7CBCR13*/@�*/4SY%.9T3�#85,=La134�H68\�3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/4|HS.�L5132546.7(348M¢+1346Y�@IH6K7.%(3.J@7(9LZ�38<@3©

o #  8<La.%(90�462546.7(38�(38�La8MD/D/@I,/46@P8<DU1&%³L54S8M(%*/8<�"8M, � qoZ¥ .7("0�4S2M4S.%(38�(38ML58MD/D-@7,-4Q@\8\D-1&%³La4685(+*/8\@/%G(9LZ�$#8�¨Á 8�#Oq

46(�La194�HQ@ºLa.7("0�4S2M4S.%(38R(98MLa8�D-D/@I,/4Q@º 8R46H�La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(9@IH68Ho/DU8 � T|@7HSH6.7,Z@ #Oq 8JH6@ La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(38PD-1&%³La4685(+*/8  8=o-D-8#³T"@IH6HS.%,/@ � q9:��19@7(90�.<Y�@IH68~46H"La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8co/DU8 � T�@IH6HS.%,/@ #Oq9T%CG@<(9.7(GY�@IH68~46H#L5.7(90�462546.7("@IH68¯4S(�Y78M,/D-.cM"o/DU8&#­[email protected],Z@� qdT T3�#85,~D-.I*-*-.%HS46(38M@7,-8=HQ@G0�46D/D-4SCBCB8a*/,-4Q@BLZ�38<DU4[46(9DU*/@I19,/@PEF,Z@PH68<�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(34 � 8�#³T9D-4A0�4QLa8�*[email protected]*/@9©

o-¨W 8�La.%(90�462546.7(38<D-1&%³La4685(+*-8%T3CG@P(9.7( (38ML58MD/D-@7,-4Q@3T+�#85,&#Nqo #  8<La.%(90�462546.7(38�(38�La8MD/D/@I,/46@9T+CG@J(3.%( D-1&%³La4685(+*/87T��#85,�¨ q3:

Page 44: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O7O

Page 45: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ����� ������ �

� � � � �� � � � �<� � ��� � �£� �;��� �Ä� �j��� �

����� ���������������! "����#g 4\ 8½.%D/DU8M,-Y�@�*/.�4S(Å�3,/8ML58M0�8M(32M@�L5.7CB8½4SH��3,/.�L58M0�46CB85(+*-.��#85,º0�8ML5460�8M,-8¼D-8½13(9@�EF� �  8 13(9@�*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@MF.%�3�313,/8¼D-8� 8¼La.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@�H6.7K%46LM@�034�13(�46(9D-4S8MCJ8¼i9(34S*-. �Ä0�4�EF�XTBV9@%D-@I*-.°D-13HSHQ@�La.%CB�34SHQ@I2M4S.%(38½0�85H6HQ@*/@lY%.7HQ@�034~Y78M,-4S*l @�D-46@�HQ@IV#.7,/4S.+DU.�8½La,/8MD/L5@�8MD-�".%(385(9254Q@IH6CJ8M(+*-8½@IH6H�´ @I19CJ8M(+*/@I,/8 0�85H~(�13CB8M,-.�0�8MHSH68½HS85*U*/85,/8�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64~�3,/8MD-85(+*/4�46( � M�8�46( �=Ta: ¿~("@�@IHS*-8M,-("@�*-46Y�@°D-�"8�D-D-.�Y�@I(+*Z@IK7K%4S.+D-@�L5.7(9D-46DU*-8%T~La.%CJ8�K74) @46HSH619DU*-,Z@�*-.B(38MH�¥_@I�94 */.7H6.Bk3T3(385H6HQ@P,/4QLa85,ZL5@J0�4|19( L5.7(+*-,/.�8MD-85CB�346.9:�=�M����� ����& ������� g 19�3�".%([email protected]�4|Y7.%HS8M,¯Dc*Z@IV346HS46,/8�D-8�H6@JEF�A©

� < C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T 8º.�(9.7(¦ 8 19(9@�*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@9: g 8 8MD-4QDc*/8 13("@�Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38 ���"8M,JHQ@�¢+19@IH68 �SM � T < ��T @7HSH6.7,Z@3Ts8�D-D-85("0�.� 13( La.%(90�462546.7(9@7HS8%T~�#85,ºH6@·0�8ai9(94S2M4S.%(38�0�4�Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98¼V".�.%HS8�@I(9@9T�DU4=�9@9© �;M C M D � �/T5T < � 8�SM D � C �3T�< �<:

r=@�¢+138�Dc*�´ 13HS*-46CG@�L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(387Tl�#85, HS8bDU*-8MD/D-8 ,Z@IK%4S.%(34�TlD-85K7198_LZ�38�M D T�< �p8 �SM C �/T < ��T�CB8M(%*/,-8b03@7HSHQ@�3,/4SCG@9T3*-,Z@�*-*/@7(90�.%D-4A0�4�13(9@³L5.7(3K%4S19(32546.7(38%T9D-4A.I*-*-4685(38PLZ�38��;M C T$< � 8��SM D � �3T < ��:pr�@ �SM C T < ��8�SM C �3T < ��T9D-85K7198�SM �3T < �<: � ,Z@3T�H68�*-,/8\La.%(90�462546.7(34[.7*U*/85(�1�*-8%© �SM D T�< ��T��;M �/T < ��T��;M D � �3T < �(3.%(º�#.%D/D-.7(3.GD-19D-D-4QDc*/85,/8\DU46CR13HS*/@7(38M@7CB85(+*-8�M�DU8��SM D T$< �d8��;M �3T < ��T"@7HSH6.7,Z@ �;M D � �3T < �!TaT#@7(9LZ�38<D-8La.%(9D-85K719.7(3.³03@7HSH�´ 4S�#.I*/8MD-4�46(346254Q@IH68 �SM � T1< ��:�¥ 4) . D-46K7(34Si"L5@­LZ�387Th�#85,=(38MD/DU19(9@ �#T[�31� .­8�D-D-85,/8��SM � T2< �87T"¢%194S(9034�T9LZ�98 �  8�13("@J*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@9: �

�=�M����� ����& ����� � ¯46�#8a*[email protected]|�3,/.�L58M0�46CB85(+*-.G0�8MHSH�´ ¡�D-85CB�346.B>9:Se%:Se�La.%( HQ@JEF�|©#?< M C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3T

g 8 �;M #NT=< ��Ts@IH6HS.%,/@ �SM C � D � �3T=<�� 8 �SM D � C � �3T&< ��: r�@7HSH�´ 19H */4SCG@�La.7("0�4S2M4S.%(38­D-85K%138�SM D T�< � 8��;M C � �3T < ��::r=@��;M C � �3T < �ÀDU4[.7*U*-4685(98��;M C T�< � 8��SM �3T�< ��:

� ,Z@3T3D-8��;M C T$< ��T"D-4A�9@B�9,-.%�3,-46. �SM C � D � �3T$< � 8R(3.7(¼D-4s 8\,Z@IK%K74613(+*/@J@IHQLa13("@³La.%(%*/,/@%030�462546.7(38%:� 85,-*/@7(+*-.9T�19(9@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38<�#85,�H6@G¢+19@7HS8��SM C T < ��T��SM D T$< ��T �;M �/T$< �  8�*/@7HS8RLZ�98��;M #NT < ��T"8<�"8M,U�*/@7(+*-. #¦(9.7(­ 8 13("@�*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@NMc 8 E�@IHQD-@��#85,s@IH6CB85(3.=13(9@=Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98ET :��~8MHSHQ@=,-4QLa8M,/LM@�0�8MH3La.7(+*/,-.�8MD-85CB�346.(3.%(�D-46@7CB. �#85,/Y78M(+13*-4s@70�13(9@ L5.7(+*-,Z@703034S2M4S.%(387T[CG@º@ 46(90�46Y�460319@I,/HS."TALa46.9 8P@ La.+Dc*/,-1346,/8P13("@ Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38LZ�38%T�,-8M(90�85("0�.JE�@IHQD-@JHQ@REF�½46(º8MD/@ICB87T3L5.7(9D-85(+*-8<0�4�La.7("LaH6190�85,/8<LZ�38�8MD/D-@J(3.%(� 8=19(9@P*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@9: �

�=�M����� ����& ����� & g 19�3�".%([email protected]�4#Y7.%HS8M,�Dc*Z@IV346H64S,/8�D-8�HQ@�EF� � < D � �\ 8�La.%(9DU8MK7138M(32M@�H6.7K%46LM@\0�8MHSH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCB80�4[EF� � < C � D � � � C � � %:')H9CB85*-.�0�.R0�8MHSHQ@�*[email protected]@�0�4#Y785,/4S*l @<La.%CB�".%,U*/85,/85V3V#8~HQ@<La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@I2M4S.%(38~0�4�eM§<L5@%DU4�:��s,/.�La8M0346@7CJ.�46(�Y78ML58@IH6HQ@~,/46L585,ZL5@�034+19(PLa.%(+*-,/.+8�DU8MCB�34S.": g 8 � (3.7(³ 8 La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@~H6.7K74QL5@�0�4 �°T�0�85Y%8 8�DU4QDU*-85,/8�19(9@�Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38�­LZ�38�,/85(9038=Y%85,/8�HS8�EF�½0�4 � 8=E�@IHQD-@ � ©

�SM C � D T�< � ��;M � � �ET< � ��;M C � �/T < � �SM D � �ET< �

O�X

Page 46: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O%§r=@IH6H�´ 13HS*[email protected](9034S2M4S.%(38<DU8MK7138��SM D T�< � 8��SM �KT< ��:r=@��;M D T�< �¦8��;M C � D T< ��T9D-85K%138��;M C T< ��:¨~("@IH6.7K%@7CB85(+*-8%T�09@��;M �ET< �¦8�SM � � �KT< ��T9D-85K%138�;M �/T < ��:�¼@ �SM C T < � 8��;M �/T < �ÀDU.%(3.J4S(½La.%(+*-,Z@7030�462546.7(98=L5.7( �;M C � �/T < ��:

��1346(90�4�T[(3.7(��31� .º8MD-46DU*-8M,-8P13(9@ Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38JLZ�38P,/85("0�8PY%85,/8RH68P�9,-8MCJ8�D-D-8J8RE�@7H6D/@³HQ@ L5.7(9L5HS1"DU46.7(38%Th8�#85,-*/@I(+*/.J.%K7(34[Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38<LZ�38�,-8M(90�8�Y78M,-8�H68�EF�¼034 � ,/85(9038<Y785,Z@J@I(9LZ�38 � T3�"8M,~La134 � � < � T3.%D/DU4Q@3©

C � D � � � C � � � < D � ��

�=�M����� ����& ����� ± ��8M,-4Si"L5@7,-8�D-87©C � M D � �3T C � ! D � < C � �

�s,/.�La8�0�85(903.JL5.7CB8�(385H6H�´ 8MD-85CB�346.B�3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/8=Y%8M0�[email protected]=�91� .B8MD-46DU*-8M,-8�13(9@��B*Z@IH68\LZ�387©�SM C � M D � �3T^T < � ��;M C � ! D T< �d8��;M C � �3T�< �

r=@IH6H�´ 13HS*[email protected](9034S2M4S.%(38<DU8MK7138��SM C T< �d8��;M �3T < ��:r=@��;M C T< �d8�SM C � ! D T< ��T9D-85K7198�SM ! D T < �d8%T3¢%194S(9034�T��SM D T < ��:��138�Dc*/8�L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(34[(3.7(½L5.7(+*-,[email protected](3. �;M C � M D � �3T^T < ��:

��1346(90�4�T�D-8 �SM C T�< ��T �SM D T�< �p8 �SM �3T�<�� H68³�3,/85CB8�D-D-8G�9@I(9(3.½Y�@IH6.7,/8�� 8GH6@�La.7("LaH619DU46.7(98J�"@Y�@IH6.7,/8 ��: ��194S(9034|4SHA(38MD/DU.G0�4�La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@RHS.%K74QL5@J(3.7( D-19D-D-4QDc*/87: �

')(�¢+138MDU*-.½L5@7�34S*-.7H6.½46(%*/85(90346@7CJ. ,Z@/%G(9@7,-8G¢+138MDU*-. CB8a*/.�0�.¼0�4�,/4QLa85,ZL5@º0�8MH La.%(+*-,/.+8�DU8MCB�34S.º,/46L5.7(90�13�La8M(90�.%HS.³@7HSH�´ @7�3�3H646LM@I2M4S.%(38\0�4�13(¼DU4QDU*-85CG@³034A,/85K7.%HS8\LZ�98RLa4�La.7("DU8M(%*Z@I(3.³034A�#85,/Y785(94S,/8\@³DU*/@IV94SH64S,/8RD-8\HQ@BEF�03@I*/@ �  8J.º(3.7(� 8P19(9@³*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9T#. D-8  8J.º(3.7(° 8JL5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@³H6.7K%46LM@­0�4�13(�4S("DU4685CB8 �Æ0�4�EF�|:��½8a�0�4Q@I(+*-8J¢+138MDU*-8P,-8MK7.7H687ThLa.%CB8RY78�0�,/85CB.GEF,Z@³V3,/85Y%87ThDU4�La.+Dc*/,-1946D/La8\19(9@­DU*-,/1�*U*/13,Z@­@70�@IH6V"8M,-."T#0�85*U*Z@ 037 �)4"25<'@4"Pc0/9X(I.1>)<IT9LZ�38\La.%(9D-85(+*-8�0�4|,/46D-.7H6Y78M,-8�¢+138MDU*-.J*/4S�#.³0�4|�3,/.7V9HS8MCJ4�:

¯4QLa.%,/0�4Q@ICB.³LZ�38%T[La.7CB8PK74) @G85Y�4Q0�85(32M46@I*-. (385H6H�´ � D/DU8M,-Y�@I2M4S.%(38GeP0385H � k3: >³0385Hs¥_@I�|:[k�ThH�´ 8�D-D-85,/8 � La.7(3�D-85K71985(32�@ H6.7K%46LM@ 0�4�13(�46(9D-4S8MCJ8³i9(34S*-. �  8B8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(+*-8³@7HSH�´ 8�D-D-85,/8B13(9@º*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@ºH6@ºEF�°L5.7(9034S2M4S.%(9@IH68LZ�38G�9@½L5.7CB8­@7(%*/8ML58M0�8M(%*/8BH6@¼L5.7(3K%4S19(32546.7(38G0�8MHSH68GEF�°0�4 �Æ8 La.7CB8³L5.7(9D-85K%1385(+*-8 � :º� 8M,U*Z@I(+*-."TAHQ@½DU85�La.%(903@P¢%198MDU*-46.7(38%T�¢+138MHSHQ@\,/85HQ@�*/4SY�@P@[email protected]("DU8MK7138M(32M@<H6.7K%46LM@3T+�31� .J8MD/DU8M,-8�,-4QLa.%(90�.I*-*/@P@IH6H6@R�3,-46CG@3T�,/85HQ@�*-46Y�@@IH6H�´ 8�D-D-85,/8¯13(9@\*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@9T7�#85,bLa134"H�´ @IH6K7.%,-4S*-CB.R034#L5.%DU*-,/132546.7(38~0385H6H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.PDU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.RD/@I,� @�4S(94S2M46@7HSCB85(+*/8i9(9@7HS46252�@�*/.B@7H[�3,/.7V3H685CG@B0�85H6HQ@J038MLa4QD-4S.%(38<0�4A¢+138MDU*M´ 13HS*-46CB.G�3,-.%V3H685CG@3:

����� � � � #Z����� � � #1����� ��� � #!��� � # ��a���� E�p�¯4QLa.%,/0�[email protected]�387T9,-4QDU�#8a*-*-.G@70 13(9@G¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4#Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(387T3D-4[Y78M,-4Si"L5@B¢+19@7(%*/.JD-85K%1387©

eM@dT DU8�! �  8�Y%85,Z@3T @IH6HS.%,/@ �  8=E�@IHQD-@e5VXT DU8�! �  8=E�@7H6D/@3T @IH6HS.%,/@ �  8�Y78M,/@kI@dT DU8 � #¶ 8�Y78M,/@9T @IH6HS.%,/@ � 8�#jDU.%(3.B85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8�Y%85,/8k�VXT DU8 � #¶ 8=E�@IHQD/@3T @IH6HS.%,/@ �  8=E�@IHQD-@J.%�3�313,/8�#¶ 8�E�@7H6D/@>7@dT DU8 ��� #¶ 8�Y78M,/@9T @IH6HS.%,/@ �  8�Y78M,/@P.7�3�913,-8�#  8�Y%85,Z@>IVXT DU8 ��� #¶ 8=E�@IHQD/@3T @IH6HS.%,/@ � 8�#jDU.%(3.B85(+*-,Z@ICPV"8=E�@7H6D-8O%@dT DU8 � � #  8=Y%85,Z@3T @IH6HS.%,/@ �  8=E�@IHQD-@J.%�3�313,/8�#¶ 8�Y%85,Z@O7VXT DU8 � � #  8�E�@7H6D/@3T @IH6HS.%,/@ �  8�Y78M,/@P8�#  8=E�@IHQD-@

¸P�"� �#�����%���#��� ���9���3�7���"���3 ��#:��~8MHSHQ@JLa.%DU*-,/132M4S.%(38�0�8MHSH�´ @7HSV#85,/.PD-85CG@7(%*/46L5.R19D-85,/85CB.\8�DU�9,-8�D-D-4S.%(34h0�85H#*-46�#.��� ��� 8Qn�� ��� T|0�.�Y78 �  8P13(9@­EF�|:R¡ D-D-8P�9,-8M(90�.7(9.­46H�(9.7CB8J034 � J '"4hAB9;03(h4�8GDU4 H685K%K7.7(9.³,-4QD-�"85*U*-46Y�@ICB85(+*/8o �  8�Y%85,Z@BqP8Vo �  8=E�@IHQD-@_q3: g 4ADU*-46�313HQ@J�".%4ALZ�387T�46( V9@7D-8<@70º13(9@JY�@IH61�*[email protected](98�#T9D-4|@IV3V946@9©

� � < ��� ��� ��� �SM � T�< �� � < n�� ��� ��� �;M � T�< �

Page 47: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O�]M�¢+1346(90�4 ��� ��� DU4�L5.7CB�".%,U*Z@­L5.7CB8 � 8Qn � ��� D-4�La.%CJ�#.7,-*/@ La.%CJ8�! � m�@IH6HS8PEF��D-85K%(9@�*/8JD-4 �31� .º8MDU*-85("0�85,/8HQ@P(9.7CB85(9L5H6@I*-13,Z@\,/85HQ@�*/4SY�@J@IH6HS8=EF�[M�LZ�38<L5.7CB�[email protected](9.P(38MHSH68��9@I,/85(+*/8MD-4h¢+19@%0�,/8ET :�r=@�*Z@PHQ@REF� D-85K%(9@�*Z@ ��� ��� Tn�� ���  8�HQ@JD-19@ >)</9X.8*BA_03(h0�8�Y�4QLa85Y%85,ZD-@9:�Å�|rsq��U� y<�|x��Uo uhq�z ��x �~{|tUq�}~� ~�A�-���Fo����<�|x3qÁz+���po�} �3tUuhq?s´ @IH6V#85,/.=D-85CG@I(+*/46L5.R 8_13(G@IH6V"8M,-.�(38543L5134�(3.�0�4�i9K%13,Z@I(3.�EF�JD-85K%(9@�*/87: g EF,-13*U*/@7(90�.�46H�*-85.%,-8MCG@�0�43038MLa.%CB�".7�D-4S2M4S.%(38�13(946LM@R8�¢+19@I(+*-.P,-4QLZ�34Q@ICG@�*/.P@7HSH�´ 46(3462546.P0�8MH[�9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.<�"[email protected]�DU�3,/46CJ8M,-8�4S(­EF.7,/CG@RD/LZ�385CG@�*/46LM@H68G,-8MK7.7H68B�"8M,RHQ@½La.+Dc*/,-132M4S.%(38G0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.9:º¡�D/DU8GD-.7(3.½.7*U*-.½8³D-.7(9.½4S(�La.%,-,/4QDU�#.7(90385(32�@ºL5.7(�H68½eM@_ThY+O%VXT�3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/4 M�0�138B�#85,�.7K%(34�L5.7(3(98a*U*/4SY%.9©¯13("@­�#85,�HQ@GEF��DU8MK7(9@I*/@³L5.7( �W8RH�´ @IHS*-,Z@³�#85,�H6@­EF��D-85K%(9@�*Z@³La.%(n�T¯8RL546@%D-L513(9@G0�4�8MD/DU8R4S(90346LM@³¢[email protected](3.G4�(3.�0�4�D-19LMLa8MD/D-.7,/4�T3.H>)<39R'@4hA3*-4@9DCE45T#LZ�38RYl@7(3(3.G�#.%DU*-4�(3854�,/@7CB4LZ�38­L5.7(+*-8M(3K7.%(3. 4SH (3.�0�.½46(°@IHS*-.9:½� 8M,\La46(9¢+138­0�4 8MD/DU8%T�LZ�38 LZ�346@7CB46@7CJ.[254hAd</7F4�,_4"7��c(+. J <IT 8­La46.9 8½e�@_TaTkI@dT T�e5VXTaT[>IVXT�8RO%VXT ThY�4�D-.7(9.­DU.%HS.ºDU1"L5La8�D-D-.7,/4A0�46,/8a*U*/4pMF13(3. �"8M,Pe�@_T~8RHQ@¼e5V;T¯8B0�138R�#85,=H68J@7H */,-8KT T#.%D/DU4Q@La4Q@7D/La19(¼,/@7CB.­La.%(%*/85(38M(+*-8J4SH�(3.�0�.º4S(�@7H */.­Y�4685(38J�3,/.7H613(3K%@I*-.­L5.7(¼H68BDU138JLa.%(9DU8MK7138M(3258%:=¨��3�3H646LM@I(903.­H68@IHS*-,/8=*-,/87T9LZ�98�LZ�946@[email protected]_<37F4Q,B4@7����a(I. J <�T"8<La46.9 8�>7@dT T�O%@dT_8\k�VXTaT3H�´ @IH6V#85,/.BD-13V34QD/La8�13([email protected],[email protected](38%T.%D/D-46@ºLa4Q@7D/La13(�,Z@ICB.ºLZ�98BL5.7(+*-4685(98J46H�(3.�0�. 46(�@7H */. Y+4685(98B034SY�4QDU. 46(�0�198G,/@7CJ4�46(�La4Q@7D/La13(3.½0�8M4s¢+19@IH64sDU4�#.7(38<13("@J0385H6HS8\0�198\La.7("DU8MK7138M(3258%:

?|8�.7*U*-.B,/85K%.7H68=D-.7(3."©�_� �"�# �� �

e�@_T n�� ������ ! ���

k7@_T

��� # ���� ���

��� � # �>7@dT

��� ��� ��� # ��

��� ��� # �O+@_T n�� ��� ��� # �

� ���� � � # �

eMVXT��� ���n � ! ���

kIVXT n�� ��� n�� # ��� � �

n�� � �# �>IVXT

n�� # �n�� ���

n�� ��� # �O%VXT

n�� # ���� ���

n�� � � # �

?A@RLa.%DU*-,/132M4S.%(38�0�8MHSH�´ @7HSV#85,/.R@lY�Y�4S8M(38�46(90�13*U*-46Y�@ICB85(+*/8=D-Y�4SH613�3�9@7(90�.\4h,Z@ICB4�:�¿�(­,[email protected] 8�038a*U*/.V0 J 4@2L(h<D-8�(3.%(\La.7(+*/4S8M(38�13("@bEF�PD-85K%(9@�*Z@b8�HQ@~DU1"@~La.%(34S19K%@�*Z@3Tl8 >)fD.8*D'@< @IHS*-,/4SCB85(+*/4;M�DU4+,-4QLa.%,/0347LZ�387Tl�#85, 0�8ai"(34S2M4S.%(387T13(º,/@7CB.P�9@7,U*/8<DU8MCJ�9,-8�03@IH6HQ@R,Z@70�4QLa8=8=i9(34QD-L58�4S( 13([email protected]%HS4Q@3T�.+D-D-4Q@\HQ@P,Z@70346L58P 8�La.%CR13(98�@R*-13*U*-4A4[,/@7CJ48T :

')H9�"@7D/DU.<0�8MHSH�´ 46(90�192546.7(38\ 8¯4SHhDU8MK7138M(+*-87: g 13�3�#.7([email protected]�4"@lY%85,sK%4  @<L5.%DU*-,/134 */.<H�´ @IH6V#85,/.��\: g 8¯*/1�*U*/4"(3.�0�4�3,/8MD-85(+*-4%(3854+,Z@ICB4+@7�"8M,U*/4%L5.7(+*-8M(3K7.%(3.~DU.%HS.�HS85*U*-8M,-8 �3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64I.�D-.7(9.�La.%(%*/,/@%D-D-85K%(9@�*/4�4SH J 2G<`>)4),/.8Pc4"9X(h<(\4"2LP�.89;0I: g 87T746(�Y78�La87T%Y�4[ 8~@IH6CB85(3.<19(G(3.�0�.\46(G13(G,/@7CB.�@7�"8M,U*/.\LZ�38¯(3.%(º 8~Dc*Z@�*-.\@7(9La.%,/@�L5.7(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@I*-.8RLZ�38\L5.7(+*-4685(98<13(9@JEF��L5.7CB�".+Dc*Z@�MF8R¢+1346(90�4�LZ�38B 8\0�4�13(3.³0�8MK7H64A.I*-*-.B*/4S�34�La134� 8<@I�3�9HS4QL5@7V34SH68\13("@B,-8MK7.7HQ@0�8MHSHQ@ ��@lY%.7HQ@°eETaT_D-4¯�3,/.7H613(3K+@I(3.�*-1�*-*-4~4¯,Z@ICB4~@7�"8M,U*/4~0�4�� LZ�38 �9@7D/D/@I(3.��"8M,G4SH�(3.�0�.�@IK7K%4S19(3K78M(90�.�4D-19L5L58MD/DU.%,-4[0�8MH|(3.�0�.GLa.%CJ8��3,/8MD/La,/4S*U*-.G03@7HSHQ@J,-4QD-�"85*U*-46Y�@J,-8MK7.7HQ@3: g 4 >)<39-(+250K')'@4hA39S0=4SH|(9.�03.J8�D-@7CB4S(9@I*-.B8<DU4LZ�346190�.%(3.R4#,/@7CB4"(38M4[¢%1"@IH64#L5.7CB�9@I,/8~13("@\EF�ºDU8MK7(9@I*/@<8�H6@JDU1"@RLa.%(34613K%@I*/@3: g 8�*-1�*-*-4[4#,/@7CJ4hD-.7(3.JLZ�34S1"DU4#4SHJ 2G<`>)4),/.8Pc4"9X(h<N(\4"2LP�.89;0~8~H�´ @7HSV#85,/.B 8~0�85*U*-.V>Gf&.8*D'"<I:�')(³L5@%DU.\L5.7(+*-,Z@I,/4S.<@7HSH�´ @7HSV#85,/.�� J La.+D   $9.I*U*/85(�1�*/.6M�0�85*U*/.13( 'L*->)>G4"')'@</254a.8PNPc4),/.10/(\<\034�� TbD-4[�31� .G,/46@7�3�3H646LM@I,/8�46H[�9@%D-D-.9:

?A@ V"@7D-8­0�85H6H�´ 46(90�132M4S.%(38­0�46�#85(90�8º03@IH�*-46�".�0�4��3,/.7V9HS8MCB@�LZ�38³DU4 4S(+*/85(90�8º@/bh,-.%(+*/@I,/87:º�~8MH_LM@7D-. LZ�988MD/@ICB46([email protected]�#85,¯�9,-46CB.9T�La46.9 8�.87 J 2G< �@7F4"Pc0V,/.j,B4)>@.1,B4@254O'@4�*&9;0�� J � �4N<c9;<39 �4�*&9S0Q(\0/*&(\</7F<GA3.10IT3H�´ @7HSV#85,/.46(34S2M46@7HS8B 8<L5.%DU*-4S*-134S*-.G03@7HADU.%HS.J(3.�0�.cn�� ��� :

')H��3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/.� 8J�94U 1°D-85CB�3H646L58G0�4�¢+19@I(+*/.º�#.%D/D/@º@7�3�9@7,-46,-8B03@7HSHQ@½DU1"@º038MD/La,/4S2M4S.%(387:B')H6HS19DU*-,/[email protected]�4Q@I(+*/8�¢+19@7H6LZ�98=8�DU8MCB�34S.": ¥ .7CB8<La.%(%*/,/@%D-D-85K%(3.R1"[email protected]#.7H6.+4�:�=�M����� ����& � � ��� ¨��3�3H646LZ�34Q@ICB. 4SH �3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/.­0�4�La.+Dc*/,-132M4S.%(38R0�8MHSH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.ºDU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa. @7HSHQ@BEF� � 0�8MH �H�´ ¡ DU8MCJ�94S.G>3:6e7:6e�0�85H|�"@I,Z@IK7,Z@�EF.P�3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/87©

Page 48: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O%¤

� < C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T?s´ @IH6V#85,/.P46(346254Q@IH68J 87©

n�� C =M D � �/T � M D � C �3T �¨�0º8�D-D-.JD-4|�31� .B@7�3�3H646LM@I,/8�HQ@B,/85K7.%H6@RO7VXT_8\D-4[.I*-*-4685(38%©

n�� D � C � �

��� C M D � �3T �

n�� C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T � 4

��4hD-.7(3.R03138�(3.�0�4h03@R8MD/@ICB4S("@I,/87:A')( K78M(385,/8�La.%(�Y+4685(98�D-L585K%HS4685,/87T+DU8~�#.%D/D-4SV346H687T�13(3.R034h¢+138MHSH64h@I4"¢+19@7HS4D-4 @I�9�3HS4QL5@¼13(9@½,/85K%.7HQ@½LZ�38³(3.%(��3,-.�0�1"La8³V34SEF.7,[email protected](38%T�.+D-D-4Q@ 13(9@½,/85K%.7HQ@½0�85H_'=*-46�".":¼')(°¢+138MDU*-.�[email protected](+*/,/@7CRV34 �9@7(3(3.½¢+138MDU*/@ L5@7,/@I*U*/85,/46DU*-4QL5@­[email protected],Z@­D/[email protected]|@70�8MD-85CB�346.9TA4SH��34U 1�Y�46L54S(3.½@7HSHQ@­,Z@70346L587T|@IH¢+19@IH68<DU4�@I�3�3H64QL5@JH6@J,/85K%.7HQ@PkI@dT ©

��� D � � �

��� C �

n�� D � C � �

��� C =M D � �/T � 4

n�� C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T � 4

')H�(9.�03. ��� C �  8�0�4=¢%1985H6HS4�@I4=¢%1"@IH64�(3.%( DU4��31� .�@7�3�3H646LM@I,/8�@IHQLa13("@�,-8MK7.7HQ@3: ��,/@�4=0�138�@I(9L5.7,Z@�09@8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/87T&n�� D � C � � 8 ��� D � � � Th 8��3,-85EF85,/4SV94SH68�4SH[�3,/46CJ.G@7H|¢%1"@IH68�D-4|@I�9�3HS4QL5@P13(9@B,/85K%.7HQ@R0�8MH['�*/4S�#.9©

n�� C � �

��� D �

��� D � � �

��� C �

n � D � C � � 4

��� C =M D � �/T � 4

n�� C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T � 4

¨À85(+*-,Z@ICPV34h4|(3.�0�4|LZ�38<L5.7(+*-8M(3K7.%(3.\EF�½La.%CB�".+Dc*/8=8�(3.%(º@7(9La.%,/@PLa.%(%*/,/@%D-D-85K%(9@�*/4 M�8<La46.9 8 ��� D � � � 8n�� C � � TbY�@G@I�3�9HS4QL5@I*/@J13(9@B,/85K%.7HQ@J0385H|'-' */4S�#.9T"�"8M,�La194AD-L585K%[email protected]@%0º8MD-85CB�346.9T9¢+138MHSH6.G�34U 1½Y+4QLa46(3.³@7HSHQ@,Z@70�4QLa8%T3La46.9 8 ��� D � � � ©

Page 49: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

O+�

n�� D �<;<;<;<

��� � ����� � �

n�� C � �

��� D �

��� D � � � 4

��� C �

n � D � C � � 4

��� C =M D � �/T � 4

n�� C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T � 4

?s´ @I�9�[email protected](38~0385H6H6@R,-8MK7.7HQ@<0�8MH"'-'�*-46�".JLa.%CJ�#.7,-*/@\13(9@\V94 EF.%,/[email protected](987©A(985H6H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.PDU.%(3.\.7,Z@<�3,/8MD-85(+*/40�138³EF.7K7H6468³8­¢+1346(90�4b0�138³,Z@ICB4 M�DU4 ,-4QLa.%,/034�DU8MCB�3,-8 LZ�38³46H�,[email protected]��"8M,P0�85i9(3462546.7(38%T �9@I,-*-8³D-85CB�3,/8­03@7HSHQ@,Z@70�4QLa8_8¯@I,/,-46Y�@�@�13(9@�EF.7K%HS4Q@_Ta:�')H�,Z@ICB.�0�43D-4S(34QDU*-,Z@�L5.7(+*-4685(38 ��� D � 8pn�� D � TI8¯¢+1346(90�49D-43LZ�346190�8�MF8¯@7HSH6.7,Z@~(3.%(Y�4S8M(38\�34U 1½�3,/.7H613(3K+@�*-."©s46(%*/134S*-46Yl@7CB85(+*-8R@%0 8MD/DU.³L5.7,/,-4QD-�".%(90�8�13(9@G�#.%D/D-4SV346H64 *� @G0�4�D-Y�4SH613�3�#.­LZ�38RD-4|,/4SY%85HQ@La.%(+*-,Z@7030�4S*U*/.7,/46@dT :�')(90�4QLZ�[email protected]@BLZ�34619DU19,/@P0�85H[,[email protected](C<;<;<;<R: ��85H|,[email protected]�4|0�8MDU*-,Z@PY+4� 8=@7(9La.%,/@R13((3.�0�.B8MD/@ICB46(9@IV94SH687T�8\L54S.9 8�n�� C � � :s��,-.�La8�0�[email protected]¢+1346(90�4�La.7(ºHQ@P,/85HQ@�*/4SY�@J,/85K7.%H6@Jk�VXTa©

n�� D �<;<;<;<

n�� C �<;<;<;<

n�� � �<;<;<;<

��� � � �

��� � ������� � �

n�� C � � 4

��� D �

��� D � � � 4

��� C �

n � D � C � � 4

��� C =M D � �/T � 4

n�� C M D � �3T � M D � C �3T � 4

g 4s0�85*-8M,-CB46(9@I(3. @IHS*-,/4s0�138B,Z@ICB4sLZ�38GD-4sLZ�34S1"0�.7(3.º85(+*/,/@7CRV34pM�¢+138MHSH6. �34U 1�@ 0�8�Dc*/,/@ �#85,ZLZ� #8BLa.7(+*/4S8M(38��� � � 8 n � � � T+¢+138MHSH6.\�34U 1³@\D-4S(34QDU*-,Z@��"8M,/LZ�$#8~La.7(+*/4S8M(38���� C � 8?n�� C � Ta: ')H9�3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/.<*-8M,-CB46(9@��"8M,/LZ�$#8b*-1�*-*-44A,Z@ICB4�DU.%(3.³LZ�34619DU4�:¯?s´ @IH6V"8M,-.½ 8\LZ�34S1"DU.":~¥ 4) .­D-4SK%(34Si"L5@GLZ�38RH6@G,/4QLa85,ZL5@B0�8MH�L5.7(+*-,/.�8MD-85CB�346.JE�@IH6HS4QD-L587T".%D/DU4Q@(3.%(ºD-4|�31� .GD-.�030�4QDcE�@7,-8�HQ@P,Z@70346L587T3¢+1346(90�4 � (3.%( �91� .G8MD/DU8M,-8�E�@IHQD/@ T98�@7HSH6.7,Z@­ 8�13(9@P*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3: �

Page 50: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

XIf�=�M����� ����& � � � � ¯46�#8a*-4Q@ICB.\46H9�9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-.\La.%(GH6@<EF�³La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@�*Z@�(385H6H�´ ¡ DU8MCJ�94S.\>9:Se%: k�0�8MH9�9@7,/@7K7,Z@�EF.46(%*/,-.�0�13*U*-46Y7."©

#?< M C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3Tg 4[�9@7,U*/8<03@3©

n��FM C � D � �/T � M D � C � �3T �8\D-4[�9@3T��#85,~HQ@J,-8MK7.%H6@PO7VXTa©

n�� D � C � � �

��� C � D � � �

n��FM C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3T � 4

¡�D/@ICB46([email protected]�9,-46CG@PH�´ 13H */4SCB.G(3.�0�. M�La134AD-4|@I�9�3HS4QL5@J13("@B,-8MK7.7HQ@J0�85H[' *-46�".DT ©

n�� C � � �

��� D �

n � D � C � � � 4

��� C � D � � �

n��FM C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3T � 4

� 85,bHQ@BDc*/8MD/D-@J,[email protected](98�8MD/@ICB46([email protected]�4|(�13.�Y7.J�3,/4SCG@JH�´ 13HS*-46CB.G(3.�0�.9©

n�� � �

n�� C �

n�� C � � � 4

��� D �

n � D � C � � � 4

��� C � D � � �

n��FM C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3T � 4

¯8�Dc*Z@P.%,/@J03@J8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/8 ��� C � D � � � ©

Page 51: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X3e

n � C � ��� D � � ��� � �n�� � �

n�� C �

n�� C � � � 4

��� D �

n � D � C � � � 4

��� C � D � � � 4

n��FM C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3T � 4

¨¶¢%198MDU*-.��913(+*-.�DU4_�31� .�.%D/DU8M,-Y�@7,-8³LZ�38º(38MH_,Z@ICB.�@�D-4S(34QDU*-,Z@½*-13*U*-4b4b(3.�0�4¯D-.7(3.�Dc*Z@�*-4b8�D-@7CJ46(9@I*-4_846Hs,/@7CB. (3.%(�D-4¯ 8BLZ�34619DU.": ��138MDU*-.� 8BDU1&%³L54S8M(%*/8G�"8M,\La.%(9LaH6190�8M,-8GLZ�38BHQ@­,/46L585,ZL5@º0�85H La.7(+*/,-.�8MD-85CB�346.­�"@03@I*-.³8�DU4S*-.GE�@lY%.7,/85Y%.7H687©�@7(9LZ�38RD-8PD-4A�3,/.7H613(3K+@B4SH�,Z@ICB.³0�4 0�8MDU*-,Z@GH�´ @7HSV#85,/.³(3.%(½�".7*-,� @GCG@I4 LZ�34S1"0�85,ZDU4 MF46(¢+19@I(+*/.RDU19H#,[email protected]#D-4S(946DU*-,Z@\(3.%(­D-4"8�DU8MK7138�@7H6L513(­@7H */,-.P4S(+*-8M,-Y%85(+*-.R8�,/4SCG@I(98�@I�#85,-*-.J@I(9LZ�38�(385K%HS4h@IH6V#85,/4D-19L5L58MD/DU46Y�4gTa:R?A@­EF� #¶(3.%(� 8J13(9@­*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3:R¨ *-4S*-.%HS.½0�4�8�DU8M,/L54S2M4S. �3,/.%D-85K71946@7CJ.­(385H�,Z@ICB. 034s0�8MDU*-,Z@0�.�Y%8�Y�4s 8<@7(9La.%,/@P03@B8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/8�46H|(3.�0�. ��� D � � � m9D-4[.I*-*-4685(38%©

n � C �

��� D � ��� � �<;<;<;<

��� � ���� D � � � 4

���� � �n�� � �

n�� C �

n�� C � � � 4

��� D �

n � D � C � � � 4

��� C � D � � � 4

n��FM C � D � �3T � M D � C � �3T � 4

')Hh,/@7CB.R�34U 1 @J0�8MDU*-,Z@RD-4[LZ�346190�8QM�La.%(+*-4685(38 n�� � � 8 ��� � � T�8�Y�4  8�13( 19H */85,/4S.%,-8�,/@7CJ.JLZ�38�(9.7( D-4[LZ�346190�87:¨ ¢+138MDU*-.G�913(+*-.G46H|�3,/.�L58M0�46CB85(+*-.J*/85,/CJ46(9@B46(½¢%1"@I(+*-.B*/1�*U*/4A(3.�0�4jM�D-@7HSY%.G¢%1985H6HS4ALZ�98\La.7(+*/85(3K%.7(3.JHS85*U*/85,/8�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH648T�D-.7(3.GDU*/@I*-4|La.%(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@I*-4�:g 4[�31� .G.%D/DU8M,-Y�@I,/8�L5.7CB87T94S(½La.%,-,/4QDU�#.7(90385(32�@R0�4|19(º,[email protected]@I�#85,-*-."T3@70 8MD-85CB�346.G¢%1985H6HS.G�34U 1½@BDU46(34QDc*/,/@9TD-8PD-4�La.%(9D-460�8M,/@7(3.G4�(3.�0�4�LZ�98PLa.%(+*-85(9K7.7(9.GHS8PHS85*U*-8M,-8P�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64�T98MD/DU4 La4�4S("0�46LM@I(3.­13(9@³Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38

Page 52: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X7kM�¢+138MHSHQ@º�"8M,\La134 �SM C T <���T �;M D T < ��T �SM �3T;<��!T�LZ�38J,-8M(90�8JE�@IHQD-@ #³:B')H��3,/.�La8�0�4SCB8M(%*/.9TA¢+1346(90�4�T|(3.%(D-.7H6.¼La4 0346L58 D-8³H6@½EF�°8MD/@ICB46(9@�*Z@� 8³13(9@ *Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@kM�DU8³H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.�D-4 LZ�94S19038ET�.�D-8³(3.%(�HS.° 8�M�D-8­,/4SCG@7(38@IH6CB85(3.J13( ,/@7CJ.B@I�#85,-*-.DT T�CG@R46( ¢+138�Dc*�´ 19H */4SCB.GL5@%DU.JLa4[La.%(9DU8M(+*-8�0�4|0�8a*/85,/CB4S(9@7,-8=0�85H6H68=Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(34#LZ�98E�@IHQD-4 i"LM@I(3.­H6@³EF�|:<¨~(32M4�T|D-8PD-4��9,-.+DU8MK7138<i"(3. @7HA*/85,/CJ46(38J0�85H [email protected],/.9T"DU4 .I*-*-8M(3K7.%(3.G*-13*U*-8JH68PY�@IH61�*[email protected](94LZ�38\HQ@JE�@IHQD-4 i"LM@I(3.�M�87Th¢+134S("0�4�T#�#85,�034Ubh85,/85(32�@3T#¢%1985H6HS8RLZ�98<H6@G,/85("0�.7(3.GY%85,Z@_TaT3�"8M,�L5134�D-4A�9@7(3(3.³H68RDU*-8�D-D-846(�EF.7,/[email protected](94|0�85H6H6@P*[email protected]@J0�4|Y78M,-4S*l @9: �

�=�M����� ����& � � � & ��8M,-4Si"L5@7,-8�D-8=HQ@JEF�|©� < M5M^M C � M D � � � �KT^T C T �! �3T � M ! � � ! D T

 8�.B(3.7(� 8�13(9@P*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@3:��138�Dc*Z@GY7.%H *Z@G�3,/8MD-85(+*-4Q@ICB.³K%4  @GH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.­D-85CG@7(%*/46L5.³46(%*/85,Z@ICB85(+*/8PD-Y+46H613�3�9@I*-.HM�4�(�13CB8M,-4 @IH6H6@­0�8MDU*-,Z@

0�8M4|(3.�0�4A0�8MHSH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.BDU8M,-Y%.7(3.J�#85,¯4Q0�85(+*-4Si"LM@I,/8=4A(3.�0�4ADU*-8MD/D-4[(385H6H6@BD-�34685K%@72546.7(38�D-85K71985(+*-8KT ©

n � C � MceM>dT<;<;<;<

n�� D � Mce�X_T<;<;<;<

��� � � Mcel]BT<;<;<;<

��� � � Mce�¤_T<;<;<;<

��

��

��

��

��� � � � � 4DMUeM§_T��������

��

��

��� D � � � � � 4&MceMOdT�����������

��

��

��� D � MUe�k_T

n�� � � MUe7eKT

n�� ! D � 4DMUeMfdT��� ! � � 4&M��_T��� C � M�¤_T

��� C � M D � � � �KT � 4DM ]3T

n�� � � M�§_T

��� ! � � 4&M�XBT���FM C � M D � � � �KT^T C � 4&M�OdT

n�� ! � � ! D � 4&M�>dT���FM5M C � M D � � � �KT^T C T �! � � 4DM�kBT

n��eM^M5M C � M D � � � �KT^T C T �! �3T � M ! � � ! D T � 4&MUeET

�|�����+!#�3�%���#���#:�r=@IH6H6@[MceKT�DU8MK713.%(3.ºH6@kM�kBT�8GH6@kM�>_T=�#85,<HQ@ ,-8MK7.%H6@ O7VXT�8³D-4�La.%(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@­H6@[MceKTLm�03@7HSHQ@M�k_T ThLZ�38\D-4�La.%(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@9T3DU8MK713.%(3.GH6@ M�OdT~8\H6@ M�XBT~�"8M,�HQ@B,-8MK7.7HQ@³kI@dTLm"8MD/@ICB4S([email protected]�9,-46CG@BH6@�M�XBT¯LZ�98RDU4

Page 53: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X7>La.%(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@9T�8�D-49.I*-*-4685(38�H6@�M�§_Ts4S(³V"@7D-8~@IH6H6@<,/85K%.7HQ@JeM@_T"m+09@IH6H6@�M�OdTaT+LZ�38�DU4hLa.%(%*/,/@%D-D-85K%([email protected]*U*/85(3K%.7(3."T�#85,�HQ@�,/85K%.7HQ@�k7@_T T7H6@�M�]BTA8¯HQ@�M�¤_Ta:�¨�¢+138�Dc*/.��913(+*-.�,-8�Dc*Z@I(3.�03@=8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/8_4�(3.�0�4�M�>dTA8�M ]3T :�¡ D-@7CJ46([email protected]�3,/4SCB.G@IH�¢%1"@IH68\DU4A@7�3�3H646LM@B13(9@B,/85K%.7HQ@J0385H|'_*-46�#.9© L5.7(+*-,Z@7D/D-85K7([email protected]@ M�>_T_8\.7*U*/85([email protected]|(3.�0�4 M��dT_8Mce�f_T LZ�38�8MD/@ICB46([email protected]*-."T�8=L5.7(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(34Q@ICB."T7.I*-*-8M(385(903.J4[(9.�034:Mce7eKTs8cMUe�kBTa:s¯8MDU*/@J03@J8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/846H_(9.�03. M ]3T T @IHb¢%1"@IH68 D-4b@7�3�3H646LM@¼HQ@�,/85K%.7HQ@½O%@dT ©³D-4¯La.7(+*/,/@%D-D-85K%(9@ 4SHb(3.�0�. M�]BT\8 D-4 .7*U*-8M(3K7.%(3.�4b(3.�0�4Mce�>_TR8 MUe5ODT\La.%(�HQ@¼V34SEF.7,[email protected](38º0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.9:�')Hb,/@7CB.�@�D-46(346DU*-,Z@�D-4¯LZ�346190�8[MF4b(3.�0�4�M�¤dTR8 Mce�>_TPDU.%(3.La.%(34613K%@I*-48T :��~8MH[,/@7CJ.J@P038MDU*-,Z@PD-4h8MD/@ICB4S("@\46H[(3.�0�.VMUe5ODT�LZ�38�D-4|La.7(+*/,/@%D-D-85K%(9@�8<03@IH[¢+19@IH68�DU4h.I*-*-8M(3K7.%(3.La.%(�V34 EF.%,/LM@I2M4S.%(38³0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/.½4�(3.�0�4�McelXBT=8HMUeM§_T=�#85,PH6@¼,-8MK7.7HQ@ O%@_Ta: ')H ,/@7CB.¼LZ�38B*-8M,-CB46(9@½46( Mce�X_T�DU4LZ�346190�8cMF4A(3.�0�4jMcelXBT 8cMcelkBT_DU.%(3.GLa.%(34S19K%@�*/4gTa:��~85H6H�´ @7H */,-.GD-4[8MD/@ICB4S("@P46H[(3.�0�. Mce�§_T_@IH|¢+19@7HS8<D-4A@I�9�3HS4QL5@PHQ@,/85K7.%H6@J>7@dT_8\DU4�.I*-*-85(9K7.7(9.9T3La.%( V34 EF.%,/LM@I2M4S.%(387T�4|(9.�034 Mce�]3T_8�MUeM¤_Ta: ¡�(%*/,/@7CRV34[4A,/@7CJ4�DU4ALZ�94S1903.7(3.�M�DU.%(3.La.%(34613K%@I*-494"(3.�0�4�Mcel]BT 8OM�§_T T�8~4#(3.�0�4�Mce�¤_T 8OMUe7eKT^T :�?�´ @7HSV#85,/.B 8�LZ�34619D-.9: ��1346(90�4 �  8~13("@�*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3: �

�=�M����� ����& � � � ± g 4[Y%85,/4 i#LZ�34|La.%( 46H|CB8a*/.�03.³0�85H6H�´ @IH6V#85,/.JD-85CG@I(+*/46L5.BLZ�98=HQ@PEF�|©� < !ZM C D � �/T � M D � !ZM C D T5T

 8�13(9@P*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@��l:�s,/8MD-85(+*/[email protected].%HS.JH�´ @7HSV#85,/.JD-85CG@7(%*/46L5.PHQ@7D/La4Q@I("0�.J@7HhHS85*U*-.%,-8�46H|La.%CJ�94 */.B034[K74619Dc*/4 i#L5@I,/8=HS.GD-Y+46H613�3�#.=�I©

��� D �<;<;<;<

��� C �

��� C D � 4

n�� !ZM C D T � 4

n � D �

n�� C D � � �

n�� D � !ZM C D T � 4

��� !ZM C D � �3T � 4

n�� !ZM C D � �/T � M D � !ZM C D T5T � 4

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.JD-4ALZ�346190�8_m3¢%194S(9034|H6@PEF� �  8�13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9: �

� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � : g 4��#.I*/,-8MV3V#8B034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8R,/46K7.7,/.%D/@ICB8M(%*/8\LZ�38B4SH �3,/.�La8�0�4SCB8M(%*/.º034sLa.%DU*-,/132M4S.%(38P0�8MH �H�´ @7HSV#85,/.­*/85,/CB4S(9@ D-85CB�3,/8G0�.7�#. 13(�(�13CB8M,-.ºi9(34S*-.½0�4��9@7D/DU4�:³¥ 4  .� 8B@IV3V"@7DU*/@I(92M@ .�Y+Y�46.­46(+*-134S*-46Y�@ICB85(+*-8D-8­DU4 La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@½LZ�38%T�0�.%�".½H�´ @I�3�3H64QL5@I2M4S.%(38³0�4 .7K7(94s,-8MK7.%H6@9TA,/8MDU*/@I(9. 09@½8MD/@ICB46(9@I,/8B(3.�0�4 L5.7(+*-8M(385(+*-4�EF�0�4bLa.%CJ�9HS8�D-D-4 *� @ CB4S(3.%,-8%:½?|8³Y�@I,/468GEF�|Ts¢+1346(90�4�T�Y%85(3K%.7(3. ,/4603.I*U*/8­@½H6.7,/.¼DU.7*U*/.IEF.7,/CR19HS8Bi9(9.�@½K74613(3K%85,/885Y%85(+*-1"@IH6CJ8M(+*-8<@IH6HS8�H68a*-*-85,/8<�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH64�T%.+D-D-46@[email protected],/CR19HS8<0�4AL5.7CB�3H68MD/DU4S*l @ºe%:�=�M����� ����& � � � ² g 4[Y%85,/4 i#LZ�34|LZ�38�H6@JEF�A©�H���R�t] , ���56��#&. G(] G(]�]/8��Q*,��]>G(8� G(] G(]^ !�#�0"�$%(FB*G���"�� ���%�0"�X!EZ��)#&�����".�!���'�#&56��%�0".6%�./%43�)'��70"����56#&%�#& �0�#&!�.6�@���b!�1�#?8@ "�X�&.H "0"1�'���%�0"�H �A(#&�&1(���+*�'+*� ���<� f *,�&O ���".�8+��1-3.

.,0�0���%�����%(�w1�%�.u'(# AB�$�" �.dP~ "�D�� E*,56#&%+*�#�%�.�'(#b#&%}1�% *,� 0��".4./�"'�#&%��tYE]#P-1(0�0E*�A(#M*(8�9�1+*,�& �#M*, "#x �#M*�#&�b�@����!�./�� ".4 "��F/1�# 0�.�8x!�./56�'�#&56./ �0��"�$�"��56.T��#"31L*$A,*,%�0"#?8+ "�<� f *,�&O ���".H �#=!EZ�#&1�'(�X "��F/1���%�'�.61�%L!$����0�.� �A(#&�&1(���@.�8+ �# !EZ�#&1�'(�X#&%G9�1+*,�& �#M*, "#�*,� 0"��.� �A(#&�&1��(� .�]

Page 54: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X�O

� < M C � ! �/T HM D � ! �3T(3.%(� 8�13("@R*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9:

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.P,/46D-13HS*/@9©

��� � �

n�� ! � � 4��� C �

n�� C � ! � � 4

��� � �

n�� ! � � 4��� D �

n�� D � ! � � 4�����

��

��

n��eM C � ! �3T =M D � ! �/T � 4

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.­,/4SCG@I(98J@7�"8M,U*/.-m[HQ@³EF� �j(3.%(� 8J13(9@­*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3:<')H ,Z@ICB. @7�"8M,U*/.º0�4sD-46(346DU*-,Z@­L5.7(9D-85(+*/8J0�40�8�0�13,/,-8<LZ�38�(38MHSH68�Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(34[46( L5134 C 8 �PD-.7(3.BY%85,/87T �µ 8�E�@7H6D/@�M�¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4[D-46@J46H|Y�@IH6.7,/8=0�4 D T T3.+D-D-46@ � 8=E�@IHQD/@PD-87©

�;M C T< � ��;M D T�< � �SM �3T�< �d.7�3�913,-8��SM C T�< � �SM D T�< � �SM �3T�< �

¨~("@IH6.7K%@7CB85(+*-8%T903@IH6H�´ @7H */,-.G,Z@ICB.³@I�#85,-*-. DU4�0�8M0�1"La8PLZ�98 �£ 8<E�@IHQD/@GDU8RD-.7(9.³Y78M,-8 D 8 � M�4S(9034S�#85(90385(��*-8MCB85(+*-8\03@7H[Y�@IH6.7,/8�034 C TaT�.%D/DU4Q@��j 8=E�@IHQD/@JD-87©�;M C T�< � ��;M D T�< � �SM �3T < � M�L5.7CB8<�3,/4SCG@_T .%�3�313,/87© �SM C T < � ��;M D T�< � �SM �3T < �

g 4 DU.%(3.­L5.%D)  $A0�85*-85,/CB4S("@�*-8RHS8R*-,/8R,/4SK%�38R0�8MHSHQ@G*[email protected]@G0�4�Y78M,-4S*l @G46(�L5134 �p�"@GY�@IH6.7,/8 ��Th8P¢+1346(90�4 �  8Y78M,/@P(38MHSH68<4S(+*/85,/�3,-85*/@72546.7(34[La.%,-,/4QDU�#.7(90385(+*-4[@IH6H68�@7H */,-8<L54S(9¢+138<,/46K7�38%: �

� �����% �3�3�%���#��� � : ¥ .7CB8<D-4� 8�K74) @RY�4QDc*/.G(385H6H�´ � D/DU8M,-Y�@72546.7(38Pe7T � k�: >P0�8MH�¥_@I�A:"k�T�HQ@JY785,/4Si"L5@B0�[email protected]("DU85�K71985(32�@BHS.%K74QL5@G03@B13(�4S(9D-4685CB8<i9(34S*-. 0�4|EF�¼8�¢+134SY�@7HS8\@³¢+138MHSHQ@³0�4�13(9@B*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9© � � � � � � � � � � <# ��� � < � � � � � � � � � � #³:rP´ @7H */,/@ �9@7,U*/87T�H�´ @IH6V#85,/.¼DU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.¼LZ�38³�"@¼La.%CJ8­,/@%0�46L58�n�� � � � � � � � � � � # � D-4 D-Y�4SH613�3�"@

(38MH|CB.�03.BD-85K%1385(+*/87©

��� � � �:M:5:

��� � � ���� � � �n�� # �

��� � � � � � � � � � � 4n�� � � � � � � � � � � # � 4

Page 55: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X%Xg 4��31� . @7HSH6.7,Z@­@%03@�*-*/@7,-8J4SH��9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-. 0�4sLa.+Dc*/,-132M4S.%(38B0�85H6H�´ @IH6V#85,/.ºD-85CG@I(+*/46L5.9T|La.%CB8B0385H�,/8MDU*-.� 8

46(%*/134S*-46Yl@7CB85(+*-8<8MY+4Q0�8M(%*/87T3�#.7(985(90�.GL5.7CB8�V9@7D-8�13( �3,-46CB.GDU8MK7CB85(+*-.G0�4A,/@7CJ."©

��� ��� �:5:a:

��� � � ���� � � �n�� # �

.%D/D-46@G�#.7,/,/8\E�@IHQD/@GH6@ºLa.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38\8JY78M,-8\H68J�3,-8MCB8MD/DU8%T"8J�".%4��9,-.�La8�0�85,/8PL5.7CB8R(985K7H64�8MD-85CB�34��3,-8�La8�0�85(+*-4@IH6HQ@�,/46L585,ZL5@�0�85H3L5.7(+*-,/.�8MD-85CB�346.9: g 8_H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.�DU4�LZ�346190�8b46H3La.%(%*/,-.�8�DU8MCJ�94S.�(3.7(J8MD-46DU*-8b8¯D-19D-D-4QDc*/8 46H�(38MD/D-.=0�4La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@PH6.7K%46LM@3T�CB85(+*/,-8%T"D-8<H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.B,/4SCG@7(38\@I�#85,-*-."T34SH�(38MD/D-.³0�4ALa.%(9D-85K71985(32�@PH6.7K%46LM@J(3.7(¼D-19D/DU4QDc*/8MF8<4[,Z@ICB4|@7�"8M,U*/4[4S(90346LM@I(3.BH68<Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(34[,/46D-�"85*U*/.B@7HSH68<¢+19@IH64[HS8<�9,-8MCJ8�D-D-8�DU.%(3.BY785,/8=8=HQ@GLa.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(38P 8E�@IHQD/@_T : ��8�0�46@7CB.³La.7CB8<D-4[�3,-.�L58M0�8�(38MK7H64|8MD-85CB�34|0�8MH|�9@7,/@7K7,Z@�EF.R46(+*-,/.�0�1�*U*/4SY%.9:�=�M����� ����& � � � ¾ ��8M,-4Si"L5@7,-8�D-87©

C � D � � � C � � � < D � �?|.GD-Y�4SH613�3�#.º 8�4SHAD-85K%1385(+*/87©

��� C �<;<;<;<

��� � �<;<;<;<

��� ��

n�� � � ��� � �<;<;<;<

��� ��

��

��

n � C � ��� D �<;<;<;<

��� � � � � � � � �

n�� � �

n � D �

��� C � � � 4

��� � � � � 4

��� C � D � 4

n�� D � � � 4

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.JD-4ALZ�346190�8_m��"8M,U*Z@I(+*-. D � �G 8<La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@J0�4 � < C � D � � � C � � %: �

�=�M����� ����& � � � � ��8M,-4Si"L5@7,-8�D-87©C � M D � �3T C � ! D � < C � �

�s,/.�La8�0�85(903.JL5.7CB8�(385H6H�´ 8MD-85CB�346.B�3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/8�D-4|.7*U*-4685(98=46HAD-85K%1385(+*-8<@7HSV#85,/.GDU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.9©

Page 56: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

XI§

n�� C �<;<;<;<

n�� C �<;<;<;<

n�� D � ��� � �<;<;<;<

��� � �n � D �

��� ! D � 4����

��

��� D � � � 4�

��

��

��

��

n � � �

��� C �

��� C � ! D � 4��� C � M D � �3T � 4

n�� C � � � 4

')(�¢+138�Dc*/. L5@%DU. H�´ @IH6V#85,/.³(3.7(�DU4 LZ�346190�8%:\¥ 4) .9T[L5.7CB8PD-4  8P0�85*U*-."T|DU46K7(94 i"LM@³LZ�38J(3.7(�DU19D/D-46DU*-8P4SH (38�D-D-.0�4AL5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@PHS.%K74QL5@3: g 8<L5.7(9D-460385,/[email protected]�´ 13(946L5.G,/@7CJ.B@I�#85,-*-. M�¢%1985H6HS.³LZ�38��[email protected]=EF.7K%HS4Q@Qn � D � T T38�D-D-.La4 46(90�4QL5@ºLZ�38RHQ@ Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38R46(�L5134 C  8RY78M,/@9T D  8\E�@7H6D/@³8��¼ 8RE�@IHQD-@­,-8M(90�8JY785,/8\H68P�9,-8MCJ8�D-D-8R8PE�@IHQD/@³HQ@La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(387: �

�=�M����� ����& � � � � g */190�4Q@I,/87T#La.7(½46H�CJ85*-.�0�.­0385H6H�´ @IH6V"8M,-. DU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa.9T"H6@­La.7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@G0�8MH�D-85K71985(+*-8\,Z@IK%4S.7�(9@7CJ8M(+*-.9©

� 4O.87 (+2L.10/9dAd</7e< � �4N254@(+(h039dAd</7F< �Z0/787e</250�0/7UPQ4@9;<6*&9;<i,B4@. ,/*-4N(+2L.10/9DA_<37l.�� J 4*� J J �4N.g'@<K'@>)4"7e4 �� 48� J �4�.g'@</'">)4@7F4E�p03787F</250�� 9S</9 �4N254"(+(\0/9dAd</7e< � � 4N.87�!@*-0B,32L.87F0/(\4"2G< � �4N*&9H25<3P �)< �Z0/787e</250V.87(I2L.1039dAd</7F< � J J 9;</9 �4!.g'@<K'@>)4"7F4 � � *&.89S,/. � '@4Z.87&(+2L.10/9DA_<37F< � �4p254@(+(h039dAd</7F< � 0/787F<3250�.87:!@*-0B,32L.87F0/(\4@25<� 9;</9 �4a*&9�2G</P �G< �

¥ .7CB8_DU4h 8_K74) @�D-.I*-*-.7H646(38M@I*-.=4S(P�3,-8�La8�0�85(32�@3TI¢+138�Dc*/.�*/4S�#.=034��3,-.%V3H685CG@~Y�@�8MD-85K7194 */.�46(P0�198 E�@%DU4�:���,-46CG@.�L5L5.7,/,-8�oc*/,/@%0�13,/,-8Eq�46(a�HS8��3,-.%�".+DU462546.7(9430�85H3H646(3K719@7K7K%4S.�(9@I*-13,Z@IH68¯LZ�38¯4S(+*/85,/Y785(9K7.7(9.�(38MH3,[email protected]("@ICB85(+*-.":

� .7(985(90�."©C < oU46Hh*-,/4Q@I(3K%.7H6.��  8�,-85*U*/@7(3K7.%HS.dqD < oU46Hh*-,/4Q@I(3K%.7H6.�� J  8=4QD-.%D/La85H68`q� < oU46Hh*-,/4Q@I(3K%.7H6.�� J J  8�4QDU.+D-L585H68`q� < oU46H|¢+19@703,-46H6@I*-8M,-. �  8=19(º,/.7CPV".dq

46H|�3,/.7V3H685CG@J0�4SY�4685(38\¢+138MHSH6.G0�4|Y%8M0�8M,-8<D-8�D-19D/DU4QDU*-8�.BCJ8M(3.G46H|DU8MK7138M(%*/8�(38MD/DU.G0�4�La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@PHS.%K74QL5@9©

C � D � � D � ! C $� � ! � � < C � ! �?s´ @IH6V#85,/.JD-85CG@I(+*/46L5.  8�46HAD-85K71985(+*-8%©

Page 57: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X+]

n � C �<;<;<;<

n � D �<;<;<;<

n � C �<;<;<;<

��� ! C � 4��� �

��

��� D �

n � � �<;<;<;<

n�� � �<;<;<;<

��� ! � � 4��� �

��

n�� D �n�� C �

<;<;<;<

��� ! C � 4��� �

��

��

��

��� � ����������

��

��

��

��� D � � � 4��������������

��

��� � �

n�� ! � � 4��� C �

��� � � ! � � 4��� D � ! C � 4

��� C � D � � � 4

n�� C � ! � � 4

��1�*U*/4�4�,/@7CB4�D-4�LZ�346190�.%(3.9Th¢+1346(90�4�H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.¼ 8RLZ�34619D-.³87Th�#85,-*/@I(+*/.9T"D-19D/DU4QDU*-8R46H�(38MD/DU. 0�4�L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]@9: ')H[,/@7K746.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-.­ 8�L5.7,/,-85*U*/.9: �

� �����% �3�3�%���#���p&|: g 19�3�".%(34Q@ICB. 0�4\@lY78M,-8�13(�46(9DU4685CB8�i9(34S*-. 034<EF� � < � � � � � � � ��� +: g 8D-Y+46H613�3�[email protected]�´ @IH6V#85,/.BD-85CG@7(%*/46L5.P46HAL5134|�3,/4SCB.J*-,Z@�*-*-.  8%©

��� � � �:5:M:

��� � � ���� � � �

@IH6H6.7,Z@3TsD-8ºH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.�DU4~LZ�346190�8%T D-4SK%(34Si"L5@�LZ�38ºHS8ºEF�Å0�4 � (3.%(��#.%D/DU.%(3.�8MD/DU8M,-8ºDU46CR13HS*/@7(38M@7CB85(+*-8ºY78M,-8%TLa46.9 8RLZ�38 �  86.89-'"<E,B,3.g'��"0B>@.��".87F4iM���.7( g .�0 �HTa:<')(+Y%8ML587ThDU8JH�´ @IH6V#85,/.9Th0�.7�#.º@lY%85,�8MD-85K7194 */.G*-1�*-*-4��9@%D-D/@IK%K74�T(3.%(�D-4�LZ�34S1"0�[email protected],Z@ �  8i'"<E,B,3.g'��"0B>@.��".87F4VM g .�0 � T�8B46(�L5.7,/,-4QD-�".%(90�85(92M@­034�.7K7(94�,Z@ICB.º@I�#85,-*-.½DU4 �31� .46(90�46Y+4Q0�19@7,-8�13("@BYl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38�LZ�38<,-8M(90�8�Y78M,-8�*-13*U*-8RHS8�EF�½0�4 ��:�=�M����� ����& � � �Q� r�8a*/85,/CJ46(9@7,-8<D-8=H�´ 4S(9D-4685CB8\0�4[EF�|©

� < !ZM D � E T � � M � � E T C � ! � � C � M D � �/T�

Page 58: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

XI¤ 8<D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687:

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.P,/46D-13HS*/@9©

n�� � �<;<;<;<

��� C �<;<;<;<

n � D �<;<;<;<

��� � �<;<;<;<

��� ��

n�� � � ��� E �<;<;<;<

��� ��

��

��

��� D � � � 4��������

��

n�� C �n�� � �

<;<;<;<

��� ! � � 4��� �

��

��

��

��

��

��� � � E � 4

��������������

��

n�� E �

��� D �

n�� D � E � 4

��� C � M D � �3T � 4

��� � �

��� C � ! � � 4��� � � M � � E T � 4

��� !ZM D � E T � 4

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.PD-4hLZ�94S190387T3¢+1346(90�4[H�´ 46(9D-4S8MCJ8 ��(9.7(� 8�D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687: g 4|L5.7(+*-,/.7H6HS46(3.PV"8M(38�4#�"@7D/D-@7K7K74#0�85H6H6.D-Y+46H613�3�#.9: g 4 �3,-.�Y�4s�#.74_@¼D-Y+46H613�3�9@7,-8GH�´ @7HSV#85,/.½Y�@I,/46@7(90�.½H�´ .%,/034S(38 0�4�8�D-@7CJ8 0�854 (3.�0�4~�7:½')(3.7HS*-,/87T D-8­DU4*-8M(3K7.%(3.G�3,/8MD-85(+*-4A4b��85.7,/85CB4Ak3: O": OG8Rk3: O": XB0�8MH � k�: OB0385H ¥_@7�|:"k3T913(½,/46D-13HS*/@I*-.³0�4�4S(9D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS4S*l @B�31� .8MD/D-85,/8³La.7(�Y%85,-*-4S*-.¼46(�,-4QD-13H *Z@�*/4 ,/85HQ@�*/4SY�4 @7HSHQ@¼L5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@ HS.%K74QL5@kM�8­Y�46L585Y%85,ZD-@dT : ��1346(90�4�Ts@70�8�DU8MCJ�94S."T03@7HSHQ@J4S(9D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS4S*l @B0�4 � D-85K7198�LZ�98�D-19D/DU4QDU*-.7(9.J4|D-85K%1385(+*/4[(38MD/DU4�0�4|La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@9©

� � M � � E T C � ! � � C � M D � �3T�� < D � E� � M � � E T� C � ! � C � M D � �3T� !ZM D � E T � < ! �� � M � � E T C � M D � �3T� !ZM D � E T ��� < !ZM C � ! �KT

�=�M����� ����& � � ��� � g */@7V34SH646,-8\D-8�H�´ 4S("DU4685CB8\0�4[EF�A©� < C � D C � ! � ! C `M D � �3T M � � D T

g C ./#b*,O�O�#M*,56.v!$���"!t*C0".u1(%�.u �A(#&�&1��(� .ch�O��"��AB��i�] �x*,5TO�#M*,%�'�.v� f ./��'(#&%��L'(#b�� E*,56�L'���#b%(.�'�#?8��&.4 �A(#&�&1��(� .v'����&� f *,�&O@����.!$*,5HO�#M*(](P-1(0�0�*$A�#M*(8+ ��<%�./%L �#=!$./5656�70�0�./%(.�������./�"#?8�*,�&�M*)\+%��)� f *,�&O@����.X'��7AB�X!�Z�#&1�'����� "#?]

Page 59: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

X7� 8<D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687:

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.JD-85CG@I(+*/46L5.  8%©

��� C �<;<;<;<

n�� D �<;<;<;<

n�� � �<;<;<;<

��� D ���� �

��

��� � �������

��

n � C �

n � D �<;<;<;<

��� � �<;<;<;<

��� ��

n�� � �

��� ! � � 4�

��

��

��

� � � � � � � �

��� D �

��������������

��

��� � � D � 4

��� D � � � 4

n�� C �

���eM D � �3T M � � D T � 4

��� ! C � 4��� C � ! � � 4��� C � D � 4

?s´ @IH6V#85,/.³�9@G13(�,/@7CB.­LZ�38R,/46CB@7(38R@7�"8M,U*/.9: ��194S(9034 �  8JDU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H687:�?�@³Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98R@7D/DU.�L546@I*/@@IH6H�´ 13(946L5.­,Z@ICB.­@I�#85,-*-. M�¢+138MHSH6. LZ�38P�9@ ��� D � L5.7CB8\EF.%K7H646@dT= 87© �SM C T2< ��T �SM D T < ��T �;M �3T < � 8R,/85(9038Y78M,-8�*-13*U*-8RHS8�EF�½0�4 ��: �

�=�M����� ����& � � ���"� ')H�CB8a*/.�03. 0385H6H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.¼D-85CG@7(%*/46L5.½DU4s�91� .¼@I�3�9HS4QL5@7,-8%TA@I(32M46LZ�$#8J@ºEF�AT�@ D/LZ�385CB4�0�4�EF�[email protected](ºCB8a*/@lY�@7,-4Q@IV346H64gTa: ?�´ 8�DU�9,-8�D-D-4S.%(387©

M � � M # � ��T^T � M^M � � #NT � M � � ��T5T

 8�13(3.GD/LZ�385CG@9© ¢+19@7(90�.G@IH[�#.%DU*-.G0�4 � T #W8 �ÁDU4|D-.%DU*-4S*-1946D/La.%(3.J0385H6HS8�EF� �9@7,U*/46L5.7HQ@I,/4hD-4[.I*-*-4685(38<19(9@JEF�|:g Y�46HS13�9�[email protected]%1385(+*-8<@7HSV#85,/.9©

Page 60: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§7f

n�� ���<;<;<;<

n�� ���<;<;<;<

n�� # �<;<;<;<

��� � �<;<;<;<

��� ��

��� # �������

��

��� # � � � 4

��������

��

n � � �

��� ���n�� � � � � 4

��� � � # � 4n��eM � � #NT � M � � ��T � 4

��� � � M�# � ��T � 4

n��eM � � M�# � ��T5T � M^M � � #�T � M � � ��T^T � 4

¡�D/D-.½ 8\13( Pc4"(\0��^037 �)4"25<IT[(385H�D-85(9D-. LZ�987T[@IH�Y�@I,/46@7,-8R034 � T#£8��JT|D-4��9@7(3(3.­*/@I(+*/4 @7HSV#85,/4 0�4SY%85,ZDU4�:  ¡.�Y�Y�4S.RLZ�987T�03@�*/.PLZ�38�H�´ @IH6V#85,/.PD-4hLZ�94S190387T�DU4hLZ�346190�8M,/@7(3(3.R@7(9LZ�38~*/1�*U*/4[K7H64#@7HSV#85,/4h.I*-*-85(�1�*/4[DU.+Dc*/4 */1385(903. � T#µ8 �WLa.7( EF���9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-4�: ')(�Y%8MLa8%T"D-8\H�´ @7HSV#85,/.GEF.%D/D-8\,-46CG@7DU*-.³@7�"8M,U*/.9T9(9.7(¼D-4��#.I*/85Y�@³La.%(9LaH6190�8M,-8<(�13H6HQ@�#.74QLZ� #8J4SHsHQ@lY7.%,-. (3.7(�D/@I,/85V3V#8P*-85,/CB4S("@�*-."TA�#.74QLZ�$#8JY�4�DU.%(3.º(3.�0�4�¢+19@IH64 ��� ��� T n � # � T�:M:5:/LZ�38B,-4QLZ�3468M0�.%(3.13HS*-8M,-46.7,/4s�9@%D-D-4�D-8­@IH �".+Dc*/.�0�4 � T #d8�� D-4�CB8a*-*-.7(9.½EF���9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-4�: ��134S("0�4�T�4_,-4QDU19H *Z@�*-4�.I*U*/85(�1�*/4 46(�3,/8ML58M0�8M(32M@�(38MH#LM@7D-.<4S(³L51349H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.RD-4"LZ�94S190387T+�".+D-D-.7(3.<8�D-D-85,/8¯K78M(385,Z@IH646252M@I*-43¢+19@7(90�.\(38M49(3.�0�4"i9K%13,/@7(3.D/LZ�385CB4|0�4[EF�A:

Ã=85(985,Z@IH64S2M2M@I("0�.RH�´ ¡ DU8MCB�34S.G>9:Se%:Se<D-4[�9@BLZ�387©� < � =M�# � ��T � M�# � � ���T

.%D/D-46@9T�¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4|DU4Q@I(3. � T�#W8 �JT � M�# � ��T � M�# � � ���TaT| 8=13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K74Q@3:¥ .%D)  $�T�K785(985,Z@IH64S2M2M@I("0�.RK%HS4|¡ DU8MCJ�94|>3:�k�: §P8p>3:�k�: ¤PD-4|�9@9©

� � # � � � � � � � <�# � �� � # � � # � ! � � � ! � � < � � ! ��

����� � �O����#Z� � #!�p��� # �p��� �C�"#Z��#!�p��� � # � � #Z����� � � # ����� ��� � #!��� � # ����a���� ��p�

')(�¢+138�Dc*/.³�9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.BY7.7K%[email protected]%4S19DU*-4Si"LM@I,/8<4S(¼CB.�0�. ,-46K7.%,-.+DU.B46HAEF13(92546.7(9@7CJ8M(+*-.­0�8MH��9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-.­0�4La.+Dc*/,-192546.7(38\0�8MHSH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.­D-85CG@7(%*/46L5.³8\H68PL5.7(9L5HS19D-46.7(34ALZ�98PD-8\(38\*/,/@7K7K%.7(3.":H��@IH68\K74619DU*-4Si"[email protected](38PDU4�V9@7D/@D-13HSHQ@BDU8MK7138M(+*-8��3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @JLZ�38J 8�4SCBCB8M0346@I*/@GLa.%(9D-85K71985(32�@P0�8MHSHQ@B0�8ai"(34S2M4S.%(38<0�4|Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98=V#.�.7H68M@7(9@3©���9������+�9��& � & ���

F\0�H �N03(h0 *&9;0V254hAd</7F0�,_4"7���(+. J <��p'@4c*&9S06W/0/7U*&(h0EC".1<39;4 �4QPc<`,_4"787F<=,B4@7�9;<E,B<�.89 037l(\<���03787F</250 �4cPc<��,B4@787F<H,_4"787e4Q'L*-4c>)</9R'@4hAB*-4"9&C`4c,3.8254@(I(\4 �?4E� .89XWK4@2)'@0/Pc4"9X(h4E�Z'@4Q*&9;0iW/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]</9S4 �4�Pc<`,_4"787e<H,B4@787F4>)</9R'@4hAB*-4"9&C`4�,B4@7�9S<`,_<�� 03787F</250 �4OPQ<E,B4@787F<V,B4@7 9S<`,_<c.89 037l(\< �

Page 61: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§9eF���H �N03(h0�*&9;0�254hAd</7F0a,_4"7 � � (I. J <�� '"4!*&9;0�W/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]<39;4 �4pPQ<E,B4@787F<O,_4"7-9;<E,B< .896037l(h< � 0/787e</250 �4ZPQ<E,B4@787F<,/.!0/7UPQ4@9;<V*&9S0i,_4"787F4i,/*-4c>)</9-'@4+AB*-4@9DCE4 �!4E�Z.89XWK4@2)'@0/Pc4"9X(h4E� '"4c*&9;06WK037l*&([email protected]</9;4 �4�PQ<E,B4@787F<�,3.

0/7lPc4@9;<6*&9;0�,_4"787F4c,3*-4O>)</9-'@4+AB*-4@9DCE4 � 03787F</2G0 �4OPc<`,_4"787F<V,B4@7 9S<`,_<c.89[0/7l(\< �¥ .%D)  $�T�@70 8MD-85CB�346.9T9D-8�13(9@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38B 8�CB.�0�85H6H6.B034���� ! ��� MF,/85(90�8<Y%85,Z@ ! � T T#@IH6HS.%,/@­ 8�CB.�0385H6HS.³0�4

n�� ��� MF,/85("0�8�E�@IHQD-@ � T T38<Y�4QLa85Y%85,ZD-@9:g 8<13("@PY�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38J 8�CB.�0�8MHSH6.³0�4 ��� � �# � MF,/85(90�8<Y%85,Z@ � #�T [email protected],Z@­ 8�CB.�0�85H6H6.³DU4Q@B0�4 ��� ��� T9D-46@B0�4��� # � MF,/85(90�8<Y%85,/8=D-4Q@ � D-4Q@ #�T T38<Y�4QLa8MY785,ZD/@3:g 8�13(9@JY�@IH61�*[email protected](98P 8=CB.�0�85H6HS.B0�4 ��� � � # � MF,/85(90�8�Y%85,Z@ � � #�T [email protected],Z@³ 8�CB.�0�85H6H6.B034|@IH6CJ8M(3.J13(9@P*-,Z@��� ��� 8 ��� # � M�,-8M(90�8<Y78M,/@J@IH6CB85(3.B13("@R*/,/@ � 8�#�T T38�Y�46L585Y%85,ZD-@9:g 8�13(9@PY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38J 8=CB.�0385H6HS.B0�4�n�� � �# � MF,/85(9038�E�@7H6D/@ � #NTaT3@IH6HS.%,/@³ 8�CB.�0�8MHSH6.J034|@IH6CJ8M(3.J13(9@P*-,Z@n�� ��� 8an�� # � MF,/85("0�8=E�@IHQD-@B@IH6CB85(3.B13("@J*-,Z@P8 � 8�#�T T38<Y�4QLa85Y%85,ZD-@9:g 8\19(9@BY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38B 8<CB.�0�85H6H6.­0�4 n�� � � # � MF,/85(9038�E�@IHQD-@ � � #�T T"@7HSH6.7,Z@­ 8<CB.�0385H6HS.³D-46@G034���� ��� T#DU4Q@0�4 n�� # � M�,-8M(90�8<Y%85,Z@ � 8=E�@IHQD/@ #�T T38<Y�4QLa8MY785,ZD/@3:¡ÅLa.+D   $hY�4Q@P�#85,�K7H64|@IHS*-,/4|L5@7D-4�:¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � & ��� ! «w�|���� � ������ ���Å��3�°�" � .�,3.1>)4O>)fR4�*&9S0�WK037l*&(\0`[email protected]</9S4 � �4bCB.�0�8MHSH6.J034#19(­,Z@ICB.,/.Z*&9 0/7 �G4@25<V'@4@PQ039-(+.1>)<i'"4i4�'@</7F<�'"4 �4QPQ<E,B4@787F<=,/. (I*&(+(I. .Z9;<E,/.p,B4@7�250/Pc< Fh.89 0/7l(+2L. ([email protected]. �p'@4Q254@9;,B4W/4"254O7F4 � J >)fR4 � AB*&25039;<c9S4"7 2G0/Pc<c'@4hA39S0/(\4O>)</9�� 4��"0/7 '@4=!"*-4@787F4O'@4hA39S0/(\4N>)</9 � H �¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � & �Q� ! �­�9�°�����|������� 0 �3$%�F® �� �� "�� 9Å,Z@ICB. �4¼D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH68 '@4 4['@<37F< '@4 4"'L.g')(\4[*&9S0W/0/7l*&(\0`[email protected]</9S4 �[>)fR4 �4aPc<E,B4@787F<�,B4@7�250/Pc< �¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � & � & ! ¬­ �®��+������|������� 0 �3$%�F® �� �� "�� 9¼@IH6V#85,/. �4RDU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H68�'"464�'@</7F< '"4NfR0�037lPQ4@9;<*&9�2503PQ<c'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��".87e4 �� �����% �3�3�%���#���#:A¡�Y�460�8M(+*-85CB8M(%*/8!*&9�250/Pc<�>Gf&.8*D'@<�9;</9 �4 '@<E,B,/.g'��"0_>".��@.87F4pM�4S(R¢+19@7(+*-.¯(38�D-D-13(9@¯Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38�31� .¯8�D-D-85,/8sLa.%(+*-85CB�#.7,Z@I(38�@ICB85(+*/8�CB.�0�8MHSH6.~0�4719(9@_EF�\DU8MK7(9@I*/@b8s0�8MHSHQ@¯D-19@~La.%(34613K%@I*/@_TaT58s¢+1346(90�4X*&9Q037 �)4"25<>)fD.8*D'@<�9S</9 �4a'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��@.87F4a:¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � & � ± ! �b� ���%����3��®��� ��½$%�"���� �����|$7�������°���h�M�����+ � ��6�3 F®��+��������°�3�h����$7�" � .X,3.1>G4p>)fR47F0 � J � �4�0385,/4SY�@IV94SH68\La.%(º46H|�3,/.�La8�0�4SCB8M(%*/.G0�85H6H�´ @IH6V#85,/.³DU8MCB@7(+*-4QLa. �j4a'L.�'@>"2L.8W/4�� � �:'@4N4a'@</7F<�'@4Q4L'L.g'L(h40/7UPQ4@9;<i*&9 037 �)4"2G<V>)fD.8*D'@<�</(+(\4"9X*&(h<c')WE.87l* J_J 039;,B<V75] 0/7 �)4@25<�>G</'L(I.8(+*&.8(h<V,B03787^] *&9-.1>)<V9S<`,_<Nn�� ��� Pc4G,3.10/9X(h4�7F4254hAd</7F4�,/. >)</')(+2L*[email protected]</9S4 ��_�+�"����°��& � & ��� ! �_���9����°�����_$7�"���+�5�����7�7��"

� 4�� � � 0/787e</250 � < �

¹º��� � g 4�0�85Y%8�0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8sLZ�387TlDU8 8MD-46DU*-8�13(\@IH6V"8M,-.�LZ�34S1"DU.~.7*U*/85(�1�*-.��9@I,-*-8M(90�.~La.%(<H6@�,/@%0�4QLa8:n�� ��� [email protected],Z@�  8�19(9@\*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9:�¥ .%(9DU8MK7138�E�@7L54SH6CB85(+*-8�03@7HSHQ@P��,-.%�3,/4S85*l @\>9: >9:Se=LZ�38�'"4�*&9H0/7 �)4@25<�� �4�'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��".87e4 �0/787e</250�*&9 !"*-037 'L.10K'L. 0/7 �G4@25< � J >)fR4 �4 'L*->)>)4L')'@</254a.8PNPc4),/.103(h<i,/. � M�L54S.9 8�.7*U*-8M(�1�*-.B03@ ��@I�3�3H64QL5@I("0�.R13("@D-.7HQ@ 0�8MHSH68B,-8MK7.%HS8KT �4i0/9;>)<3250V'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��@.87F4a: ')(�E�@�*-*-4�T �W�9@ 13(�,Z@ICB.ºD-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8%: g 4Q@��¶*/@7HS8B,[email protected]�LZ�98J(9.7(��91� . 8MD/DU8M,-8BLZ�34619DU.º�#85,�H�´ � D/DU8M,-Y�@I2M4S.%(38R�9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8KT�8 �½HQ@ Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38JLZ�98PH6.½DU.�030�4QDUE�@3: g 8� J  8G.I*-*-85(�1�*/.¼@I�3�9HS4QL5@7(90�. 13(9@ ,/85K%.7HQ@ @ 13(�(9.�03. LZ�98G(3.7(�La.%CB�9@I,/8B4S(�� T�@7HSH6.7,Z@º85Y�4Q0�85(+*-8MCB85(+*-8�,/4SCG@I(98~4S("@IHS*-85,Z@�*/.<4S( � J T%8=¢%194S(9034 � J  8�D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8~�#.74QLZ�$#8~L5.7(+*-4685(98~4SH#,Z@ICB.�pLZ�38\ 8~D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V34SH687:g 8 � J  8G.7*U*-8M(�1�*-.¼03@ �£@I�3�3H64QL5@I("0�.½13(9@ ,/85K%.7HQ@ 0�8MH�'�*-46�".�@ 13(�(3.�0�.¼LZ�38³L5.7CB�9@I,/8B4S(�� T @IH6HS.%,/@º46(� J L5.7CB�9@I,/8³46Hb,/@7CJ.�.I*U*/85(�1�*/.��3,/.7H613(3K+@I(90�.�� L5.7(°H68 La.7("DU8MK7138M(3258­0385H_(3.�0�.�8�D-@7CJ46(9@I*-.9: �¼@3T��#85,HQ@���,-.%�3,-468a*� @�>9: >9:Se%T�H6@�Y�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38 �°DU.�030346DUE�@�@7(9LZ�38 */@7HS4¯La.%(9D-85K71985(32M8 8%T�¢+134S("0�4�T_DU.�030346DUE�@�4SHb,Z@ICB.�3,/.7H613(3K+@�*-."T�8½(�13.�Y�@ICB8M(%*/8 � J L5.7(+*-4685(98½13(�,/@7CB.�D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8%: g 87Tb46(�i9(38%T � J  8½.7*U*/85(�1�*-.°09@ �@I�9�3HS4QL5@7(90�.�13(9@=,/85K%.7HQ@�0�8MH�'U'�*-46�".\@%0R19(J(9.�03.�034 � T%@IH6H6.7,Z@��wY+4685(98_�9,-.%HS13(9K%@�*/.=L5.7(J13(9@=V34SEF.7,[email protected](38_m46( � J Y�4AD-.7(9.J.%,/@B0�198<,/@7CJ4�LZ�38<�3,/.7H613(3K%@7(3.��j8%T"D-85CB�3,/8=�#85,�H6@G��,-.%�3,/4S85*l @J>3: >3:6e7T � D-.�030�4QDcE�@G@7HSCB8M(3.13(3.º0�854�0�138P,/@7CJ4�T#8R¢+134S("0�4�� J La.7(+*/4S8M(38\13(¼,Z@ICB.­D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8%: ��138MDU*-.­0346D/La.%,/D-.³DU4��31� .­8MD-�3,-46CB85,/80�4QLa8M(90�.RLZ�38N7F0O'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��".87U.8( �0�'L. (+250K'LPc4"(+(\4?W/4@2)'"<�.87 �)0K')'@<~(985H"D-85("DU.RLZ�987T�DU8~19(9@\Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98~DU.�030�4QDUE�@

Page 62: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§%k13(°,Z@ICB."T�D-.�030�4QDcE�@¼@7(9LZ�38­@7HSCB8M(3.½13(3.�0�854 �3,-.%HS19(3K%@7CJ8M(+*-4�LZ�38ºDU19V346D/La8 0�13,Z@I(+*-8³46H��9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-.�0�4La.+Dc*/,-192546.7(38%: ¡À@IH6HS.%,/@­4SCBCB8M0�4Q@�*/.ºL5.7(9L5HS1"0�85,/87T[�#85,\@%D-D-13,Z0�.9ThHQ@ 0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I2M4S.%(38P0�8MH *-8M.7,/85CG@ 034sLa.7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@3: g 8� (3.7( EF.%D/DU8�13(9@�*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3T�Y+4<D/@I,/85V3V#8�@IH6CJ8M(3. 13(9@·Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38 �ÅLZ�98�D-.�030�4QDcE�@ n�� ��� :¶� .74QLZ�$#8HQ@�D-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS4S*l @�D-4¯*-,Z@7D-CB8a*-*-8 Y78M,/D-.�46H~V9@%D-D-.9T 13(�¢+19@IHQDU4Q@7D-4~@IH6V#85,/.�D-Y�4SH613�3�"@�*-.��9@7,U*/85(903.�09@ n�� ���0�.�Y�,/85V3V#8�@lY78M,-8¯19(­,[email protected].�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687:B�¼@3T��#85,_4S�#.I*/8MD-4�T+Y�4� 8�13(­@7HSV#85,/.RLZ�34619D-.RD-Y+46H613�3�9@I*-.R�"@I,-*-85("0�.03@Qn�� ��� T38<La4) .º 8�@%D-D-13,Z0�.J�".%46LZ�$#8�13(½@7HSV#85,/.GLZ�34S1"DU.B(3.%( �9@B@7H6L513( ,/@7CJ.BD-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687: ¥�: �R: rR:

��.7K%[email protected],Z@G0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8=H�´ 4S(�Y78M,/D-.G0�85HA*-8M.7,/85CG@G0�4�L5.7,/,-85*U*/85252�@3T9L54S.9 8<LZ�387T#DU8 �  8<13(9@G*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@[email protected],Z@ 8�DU4QDU*-8�@7HSCB85(9.¯13(\@IH6V"8M,-.~LZ�94S19D-.¯.I*-*-8M(+13*-.�@%D-D-13CB85(903.~La.7CB8�,Z@70�4QLa8:n�� ��� :A')(<8@b#85*U*/4+0�46CB.%DU*-,/85,/85CB.LZ�38%T3DU8 �  8�13(9@J*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9T+.%K7(34|@7HSV#85,/.J�"8M,?n�� ��� T9D-8<@70�8MK719@I*/@7CJ8M(+*-8<DUY�46HS19�3�9@�*/. � T"0�85Y%8�LZ�94S190385,ZDU4�:¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � & � ² ! �­�9�°����¬­ F® �%���$7�#��� ��+�M�3�M�"�� 9P,/@7CB. � ,/. *&9V037 �)4"25< �4�,B4@(+(h<�La.%CJ�9HS85*/@�*/.'@4 �4 >)fD.8*D'@<�< JBJ *&254?'@4 <GA39X. 9;<E,B<�>Gf-4 9;</9�>)</9-(+.14@9;4?*&9;0�7e4"(+(h4@250 J 25< J </')[email protected]<39;0/7e4 �4p'L(\0/(\<N>)<39-(+250K')'@4hA39S0/(\<��>@.1< �4 �

�B0�H '"4 ��� ! ��� � 03787F</2G0On�� ��� �� 0�H '"4 ��� � �# � � 03787F</2G0 ��� ��� � 4 ��� # � �� 0�H '"4 ��� ��� # � � 03787F</2G0 ��� ��� � < ��� # � �� 0�H '"4 ��� � � # � � 03787F</2G0On�� ��� � < ��� # � �� ��H '"4 n�� ! ��� � 03787F</2G0 ��� ��� �� ��H '"4 n�� � # � � 03787F</2G0On�� ��� � <an�� # � �� ��H '"4 n�� � � # � � 03787F</2G0On�� ��� � 4?n�� # � �� ��H '"4 n�� � � # � � 03787F</2G0 ��� ��� � 4 n�� # � �� 9 @IH6V"8M,-.�'L.j,/.1>)4=La.%CB�3HS85*/@I*-. '@4�<5AB9-.�2503PQ< �4N>)<3P J 7F4"(\0/(\< � �

���9������+�9��& � & �Q� � AB9-.�2G0/Pc<6>)</P J 7F4@(\0/(\<i4O9;<39=>Gf&.8*D'@< �4a'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��".87e4 �¹º����:A¥ .7("DU4Q0�85,/4Q@ICB. 19(�¢+19@7H6D-46@%DU4 ,Z@ICB. �dLa.%CB�3HS85*/@I*-. 8B(3.7(�LZ�34619D-.9:Qr�85i9(34Q@ICB. � 13("@ Y�@7HS1�*Z@I2M4S.%(38(38MH|CB.�03.BD-85K%1385(+*/87:�� .7(34Q@ICB."©

�;M � T< � DU8 ��� � � ��;M � T< � DU8 n � � � ��;M � T< �d.��SM � T< � @BD/La85HS*/@ DU8 ( #8 ��� � � T3($#8�n�� � � � I?A@P0�8ai"(34S2M4S.%(38R 8�V#85(­�#.%DU*/@R�".%46LZ�$#8��p(3.%(¼ 8=LZ�34S1"DU.P8�¢+1346(90�4[(3.%(³�31� .BLa.%(%*/85(38M,-8�DU4Q@ ��� � � DU4Q@�n � � � :

g 4¯0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@ E�@7L54SH6CB85(+*-8º�"8M,P46(90�192546.7(38 DU19HSHQ@�L5.7CB�3H68MD/DU4S*l @¼03854b(3.�0�4¯LZ�38³*Z@IH68­Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98 ��DU.�030346DUE�@*-13*U*-4#4#(3.�0�4"0�8MH9,[email protected]:�')(�E�@I*U*-4hD-.�090�46DUE�@3T%�"8M,_L5.7CB8< 8�DU*/@I*/@<0�85i9(34S*/@9T%4#(3.�0�4"LZ�98�La.%(%*/85(3K%.7(3.�13("@\H68a*U*/85,Z@�3,/.7�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(9@IH68 MF.+D-D-46@º4 (3.�0�4 0�4_La.%CJ�9HS8�D-D-4 *� @�eET : �s,/8MD-. 13(°¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4�(3.�0�.�� L5.7(+*-8M(385(+*/8G13(9@ EF�°0�4La.%CB�3HS8�D-D-4S*l @ � � e7T�.%D/D-46@JLa.%(%*/85(38M(+*-8 ��La.%(3(38a*-*-46Y�4#H6.7K%46L54�T�8�D-D-.­ 8�0�4[13(9.J0�8MK7H64h.I*U*/.R*/4S�94[(385H6HS8��3,/85CB8�D-D-80�8MHSH68 e�@_ThY+O7V;Tb�3,/8MLa8�0�85(+*/4�:�� 85,�H6@ 0�8ai9(94S2M4S.%(38P0�4 ,Z@ICB.­L5.7CB�3H68a*/@I*-."T"46H ,/@7CJ. La.7(+*/4S8M(38RH68PL5.7(9D-85K%1385(32M80�4�� MF8��9,-8�La4QD-@7CJ8M(+*-8½H68�La.%(9DU8MK7138M(3258¼D-8�@7H�(3.�0�.�D-4�@7�3�3H646LM@�13(9@�,/85K%.7HQ@�0�85H�'J*-46�"."T�@IH6CB85(3.�13("@0�8MHSH68�La.%(9D-85K71985(32M8¼DU8¼@7H�(3.�0�.�D-4�@7�3�3H646LM@�13(9@�,/85K%.7HQ@�0�85H�'U'J*-46�".DT :w� .%46LZ�$#8­*Z@IH64�La.%(9D-85K71985(32M8¼DU.%(3.0�4~L5.7CB�3H68MD/DU4S*l @�CB4S(3.%,-8º.�13K719@7HS8 @$��T��#85,B4S�#.I*/8MD-4¯4S("0�1�*U*/4SY�@�D-.7(3.�DU.�030346DUE�@�*-*-8½03@ �[email protected],Z@3T��#85,BHQ@�s,/.7�9,-468a*� @P>9: >9:Se%T�� DU.�030�4QDUE�@��°: ��134S("0�4 �³D-.�090�46DUE�@B.7K%(34h(3.�0�.³0�4 �j8�d 8�DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H687: ¥�: �R: rR:�_�+�"����°��& � & �Q� ! �_���9����°�����_$7�#���� ��+�M���7�%� ��"

� 4�� < � � 03787F</2G0 � �y 3, O@��%��60"�$%(�$�X���"�$ "��%�0"�;!EZ��6%����&�M*D'��7\+%(#&>$#&./%(�6'�#Q*,�&O@����.D "��5;*,%�0"#&!�.:%�./%d3�6�"#&!EZ�#&�� "0".D!�Z��; �#J �#M*,%�.:�� �*,56#&%+*C0�#J0�1�0"0"#�#

%�.�'�#?]J�['G1�%D9�1+*,�& "#M*, �#� �0E*,'(#&.�'��������".�!���'�#&56��%B0�.� "#J3�K#&%G���"�$ "��%�>$*�'�#�1�%L*,�&O@����.� "�$5;*,%B0"#&!$.�] C �$F/�&#=�� ���56��# ������ ���%B0E*C0"#-%�����+*,��*,F/�E*C�R.G�(����!��$'(�$%B0"�H �#-�(��./ ���F/1�# A,*�\+%�.G*,�&�M*6!EZ�#&1� "1��E*�'����&� f *,�&O@����.6.6\+%�.G*,'�*�AB�$�[�$ �*,1���# 0".6� f �� E*,56�)'���#-%�.�'�#QP~'(�$#2��*,56#*,�@���"0"# Y7]

"HJ[�&#�*,�&O@����#��(���� ���%B0E*C0"#-%���F/�&#��� ���56��# '������+*,��*,F/�E*C�R.�������!���'���%�0"�X �./%�.H0"1(0�0�#�!$./56�(�&��0�*C0"#?]C/�Q./56�K*,O�O�#M*,56.HF/# 3*X�?*C0�0�.H%���F/�&#��� ���56��#�'(�$�=�+*,�E*,F/��*C�~.H������!���'���%�0"�/]K @S#"31c'(�E*, "0"#&!$*,56��%�0"�4 "#K�@.,0��"��O�O@�4�@./���"� �@P��=Y&% ' "�v�� "./�&.a ��wz ���H3�v#&%� L8b./ � �#M*'�*,���wA/*,�&./�"��' *,�&�&���&�70�0������

���"./� ./ "#&>�#&./%+*,�&#��@���b�&�[9�1+*,�&#=z ���N3�<%������E*,56.T�KA/*,�&./�"� ) *T0"1(0"0"�)�&�)*,� 0��"�/]

Page 63: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§%>¹º��� � g 4�Y�13.7H68�0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8�LZ�38%T�DU8 �  8�13(9@�*Z@I1�*/.7H6.7K%46@9T~@IH6HS.%,/@�8�DU4QDc*/8�@7HSCB85(9.°13(¦@7HSV#85,/.�LZ�34619D-.�#85,Nn�� ��� :�¥ .%(9DU4Q0�8M,-4Q@ICB.½13(�¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4�@IH6V"8M,-. �j�"8M,�n�� ��� LZ�38­D-46@�La.7CB�3H68a*Z@�*/. � :=r�46CB.%DU*-,/46@7CJ.¼LZ�98(38�La8MD/D/@I,/46@7CJ8M(+*-8 �� 8 LZ�34619D-.9T 8 ¢%194S(9034 � � :�')(�L5@%DU.�L5.7(+*-,Z@I,/46.¼Y�4_D/@I,/85V3V#8³46( �¶@IH6CB85(3.�13(°,Z@ICB.@I�#85,-*-. La.7CB�3H68a*Z@�*/.-m#CB@9T"�#85,�H6@ �s,/.7�3,/468a*l @B>9: >9: k3T3*/@7HS8P,/@7CB.³D-@7,-8MV3V"8PDU.�030�4QDUE�@7La46V346HS8%T#¢+1346(90�4 0�.�Y�,/85V3V#88MD-4QDc*/85,/8 13("@�Y�@IH61�*[email protected](98_LZ�38bD-.�090�46DUE�@�*-1�*-*-4�43D-13.74�(3.�0�4�TI46(P�"@I,-*-4QLa.7HQ@I,/8 n�� ��� M�H6@=,Z@70�4QLa8�E�@��"@I,-*-8b0�4�*-1�*-*-44�,/@7CJ48TLmhCG@³L54  .¼ 8\4SCB�#.%D/DU46V346HS8P�".%46LZ�$#87T"�"8M,�46�".7*-8�DU4�T �  8\13("@G*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@ MF8P.7K7(94AY�@IH61�*/@72546.7(38PDU.�030�4QDUE�@��� ��� Ta: ¥�: �R: rR:

g 4�DU.%(3.·L5.%D)  $~K%4S19DU*-4Si"LM@�*-8�HS8�La.%(9LaH619D-4S.%(34�.7*U*/85(�1�*-8�(38MK7H64=¡ DU8MCJ�94=0�8MH��9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.��9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8%: g 4.%D/D-85,/Y+43@7(9LZ�38�LZ�987T746(G8"bh8a*-*-4�T�DU4A 8~0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@I*-.\LZ�38%T%D-8�� < � T+(3.%(³DU.%HS.<8�DU4QDc*/8~13(³@7HSV#85,/.\LZ�34619DU.<�#85, n�� ��� TCG@�.7K%(34~@IH6V"8M,-.�L5.7CB�3H68a*/@I*-.Å 8½LZ�34619D-.9: ¯8�Dc*Z@�La.%D)  $bK74619DU*-4Si"L5@I*/@�HQ@�(9.%DU*-,Z@��9,-8�La8M0385(+*-8½@/bh85,/CG@I2M4S.%(38D-8MLa.%(90�.GHQ@³¢+19@IH687T#(38MHSHQ@³La.+Dc*/,-192546.7(38\0�8MHSH�´ @IH6V"8M,-."T"D-4A�31� . �3,/.�L58M0�8M,-8\D-85K%1385("0�.³DUY�46HS19�3�34 0�4SY%85,ZDU4�T9�913,�0�4La.%(+*-,Z@7D/DU8MK7(9@7,-8~Y�4Q@JY+4Q@P*-1�*-*-4�4|(3.�0�4[i9(9.B@P*/85,/CJ46(9@7,-8�46H|H6@lY%.7,/.9:

¡�DU*-8M(90�4Q@ICB. .7,Z@ºHS8³(9.%DU*-,/8³La.7("DU4Q0�85,Z@I2M4S.%(34s03@7HSH68B*/@71�*-.%HS.%K7468³@IH6H6@º,/[email protected](98³0�4�La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@ H6.7K%46LM@03@·13(À4S(9D-4685CB8 ��:j')H\L5@7D-.�46(¦L5134<H�´ 46(9D-4S8MCJ8 �  8�46(�i9(34S*-.�D/@I,� @�*-,Z@�*-*/@�*/.·(985H��9@I,Z@IK%,/@IEF.�D-85K71985(+*-8_mLa.%(9D-460�8M,[email protected]¢+134S("0�4|46HAL5@%DU.B0�4 � i9(34S*-.":¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � & � ¾ � . ,3.1>G4 >)fR4V7e0�� J # �4J0�85,/46Yl@7V346HS8º03@IH6H�´ 46(9DU4685CB8 � � � � � � � � � ºL5.7(�46H �3,/.�La85�0�46CB85(+*-.¼0�8MHSH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.¼D-85CG@I(+*/46L5. ��4�'L.Z'">@2L.8W/4 � � � � � � � � � � #+�?'@4i4�'@</7F<�'@4�4L'L.g'L(h4V0/7UPQ4@9;<H*&90/7 �G4@25<V>Gf&.8*D'@<6</(+(\4"9X*&(h<�'LWE.87l* JBJ 0/9S,B<i7^] 037 �)4"25<6.87 >@*&.�(I2G0/(+(h<�[email protected]/7F4 �4 �

��� � � �:5:a:

��� � � ���� � � �n�� # �

�_�+�"����°��& � & � & � � � � � � � � � ���# ��� � � � � � � � � � �� < #

¹º��� � r�@7HSHQ@J�3,-8�La8�0�85(+*-8 � D/DU8M,-Y�@72546.7(38�kB0�85H � >3:�k�T3D-4|.I*-*-4685(38=E�@7L54SH6CB85(+*-8\LZ�98����7© � � � � � � � � � � # ��� � � � � � � � � � � � #

r=@I4[*/85.7,/85CB4|0�4�La.7,/,/8a*U*/852M2M@\8\L5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@BDU4[�9@9©� � � � � � � � � � � # ��� � < � � � � � � � � � � #

Ã=4) @JD/@I�9�[email protected]�98=Y�@7HS8%©� < � � � � � � � � � � # ��� � � � � � � � � � �� <�#¥ .7("L5@�*/85(9@7(90�.B¢+138MDU*-8�*/,-8�8M¢+1346Y�@IH685(32M8<DU4|.7*U*/4S8M(387© � � � � � � � � � �� # ��� � � � � � � � � � �� <�#

��P2*,� AB./� 0E*D9�1��� "0".:0"�$./�"��5;*43�6'��70"0".w'�#Kn�kBr E j qts?qI4P4tovpBq$L�k/j qH�@���X'(#& "0"#&%�F/1������&.:'�*,�S0���./�"�$5;*G'�#KnEk/r E j qts�qP4P4to N�k J s�q)!EZ��'�#&56./ �0��"�$�"��56.T%����=�+*,�E*,F/��*C�~.� "��F/1���%�0"�/]l/!�#�3�xF/# 3*K./ � �����A/*C0".X#&%H������!���'���%�>$*X!EZ(�b�&.< �A(#&�&1��(� .<'(#+1�%6*,�&O@����.< ���5;*,%B0�#&!�.<�@���S1�%�*<�R�T0"����56#&%+*K "��56�����Q#&%T1�%6%�1(56�$�".

\+%�# 0".�'�#��+*, � "#?]�� ,[1��� "0�*)��9�1�# A/*,�&��%�>$*) ���F/1���'+*,���~*C0"0".)!EZ��/8� ��x �#�!�Z�#&1�'���1�%6*,�&O@����.<!EZ(�b#&%�#&>�#M*K!�./56�x ��@��!�# \+!$*C0�.)%����&�M* # �7\+%�#&>�#&./%��(e(] e(] O(8

*,�&�&./�E*X �#=!EZ�#&1�'��)� f *,�&O@����.X!EZ��)�+*,��0��<!�./%5@ / � / ^ ������ &/ �

U 2 �-�KA�#&!��7AB�$�" E*(]

Page 64: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§IO��� � ���#!�O��# �� �� ��p��� ����� ��#!�p��� # �� �p�����C�@#Z� #?�p����3�O� ��#')H3*/85.%,-8MCB@�0�4#La.%CJ�"@�*U*/852M2M@cM�D-85CG@7(%*/46LM@_T�8�DU�3,/46CJ8¯19(9@�4SCB�#.7,-*/@7(%*/8¯�3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @<0�8MH3(38�D-D-.\0�4"L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]@9:�_�+�"����°��& � ± ��� ! �_���9����°�����_$7�#�����3�5�M���%�7� ! �����°�3�h�M��$7��" ! ¬#"�" � 4 � � < � �60/787e</250s4"'L.g')(\4=*&9'@</(+(I.89-'L.14"Pc4 �j9-.8(\<�� ,/. � (h037F4N>)fR4�� � < � �¹º��� � ')H+*-8M.7,/85CG@�@3b#8M,-CG@�LZ�387T7D-8�19(9@�EF� �  8 L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@~H6.7K%46LM@~0�4�13(P4S("DU4685CB8¯0�4+EF� ��TI@IH6HS.%,/@ �  8_K74) @La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@~H6.7K74QL5@=0�4�13(GD-.I*-*-.746(9D-4S8MCB8�i9(94 */.�034 �°: g 8 �� 8_i9(34S*-.<@IH6H6.7,Z@~46H�*-8M.7,/85CG@\ 8¯D/La.%(%*Z@�*/.9Tl�".%46LZ�$#8D-4s�31� .½�3,/85("0�85,/8BHS.½DU*-8MD/D-. � La.%CB8³DU.7*U*-.%4S("DU4685CB8Ji9(34S*-.¼0�4 �°:G')H�*/85.7,/85CG@9T|�"8M,U*Z@I(+*-."Ts 8³D-4SK%(34Si"L5@I*-46Y7.D-.7H6.BD-8��N 8�46(�i9(34S*-.":�� .7([email protected]¢+134S("0�4�©

� < � � � � � � � � � � � � 8<�3,/.�[email protected].%CB8�D-85K%1387:g Y�46HS13�9�346@7CB.\13(­@7HSV#85,/.<�"8M, n�� ��� : g 8�8�D-D-.\DU4hLZ�346190�8%[email protected],Z@ �  8~19(9@�*/@71�*-.%HS.%K74Q@3T%8M0  8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@

H6.7K74QL5@�0�43¢+19@IHQD-46@%DU4�46(9DU4685CB8�M���85.%,-8MCG@�k�: O9:6eM>9T � k3: O"T%¥_@I�|:IkBTaT7¢+1346(90�43@I("LZ�38_034�13(J¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4�D-.I*-*-.%4S(9D-4685CB8i9(34S*-.J0�4 �°: g 8�H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.RL5.7CB�3H68a*Z@�*-.P,-46CG@I(38�@I�#85,-*-.iM�8�¢+1346(90�4 � (9.7(¼ 8�13(9@\*/@I13*-.7H6.7K%46@dT T+@IK7K%4S19(3K74Q@ICB.��� � � � L5.7CB8<(�13.�Y�@JEF.7K7H64Q@J@J*/1�*U*/4�4�,/@7CB4|@I�#85,-*-4A8<�9,[email protected]@GL5.%DU*-,/132546.7(38<0�8MHSH�´ @IH6V"8M,-.": g 8R¢+138�Dc*/.D-8MLa.%(90�.�@IH6V"8M,-.�D-4~LZ�34S1"0�87TbDU4~LZ�94S19038 @7(9LZ�38 H�´ @7HSV#85,/.�@7H~La134¯46(3462546.�DU4< 8 �#.%DU*-.[n�� ��� 8 ��� � � � �C��: ¥ 4) .D-4SK%(34 i#L5@­LZ�98 � � � < � Th8B¢+134S("0�4�LZ�98 � �  8R46H�D-.I*-*-.%4S(9D-4685CB8\i9(94 */.��j0�4 � ,/4QLZ�34S8�Dc*/.­03@7HA*/85.7,/85CG@9:g 8�@I(9LZ�98�¢+138MDU*-.JDU8�La.%(90�.R@7HSV#85,/.R,/4SCG@7(38�@7�"8M,U*/.9T�DU4h�3,/.�La8M038�@IK%K74613(3K78M(90�. ��� � � � @\*-1�*-*-4[4#,/@7CJ4h@I�#85,-*-48<�3,/.%D-85K%1385(903.J46HA�9,-.�La8�0�46CJ8M(+*-.9: g 8<46HA(�13.�Y7.G@7HSV#85,/.GDU4ALZ�94S190387T"@7HSH6.7,Z@3T3@7([email protected]+@ICB85(+*/8�@B�9,-46CG@3T9D-85K%138LZ�38 � � � � �� < � T�8<¢%194S(9034|LZ�38 � � � � J 8�46H|D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8�i9(34S*-.��Á0�4 ��,/46LZ�94S8�Dc*/.J03@7H#*-85.%,-8MCG@3: ')(L5@%DU.BLa.%(+*-,Z@I,/4S."T�D-4|@IK%K74613(3K%8 ��� � � � @74[,/@7CB4|@I�#85,-*-4[8\D-4[�3,-.+DU8MK7138%:�¨��3,-46.7,/4[DU4A�9@I(3(9.B03138��".+D-D-4SV94SH64 *� @3©e%:~@70º13(¼La8M,U*/.GDc*Z@70�46.9T90346L546@7CJ.³03.7�#.³@lY785,¯46(+*-,/.�0�.I*-*-. ��� � � � 8\D-Y�4SH613�3�"@�*-."T3H�´ @7HSV#85,/.³DU4�LZ�34S1"0�87:_')(¢%198MDU*-.¼L5@%DU. � � � � � � � � � � < � 8 � � � � � � � � � ½ 8G4SH DU.7*U*-.%4S("DU4685CB8Gi9(94 */.�� ,/4QLZ�34S8�Dc*/.03@IHh*/85.7,/85CG@-m

k3:¯4SH��3,/.�L58M0�46CB85(+*-.­(3.7(½�9@³i9(38%T#.+D-D-4Q@B4S(¼(98MD/DU13(9.­Dc*Z@70�46.­H�´ @IH6V"8M,-.³D-4�LZ�94S190387: g 8P0�46CB.%DU*-,/46@7CJ.³LZ�98¢%198MDU*-.GDU8�La.%(90�.BL5@7D-.  8�4SCB�#.%D/DU46V346HS8%T34SHh*/85.%,-8MCB@B0�4�La.7CB�9@I*U*/85252�@­ 8�034SCB.%DU*-,Z@�*/.9:

g 8GD-4s,-8�@IH64S2M2M@ 4SH DU8�La.7("0�.½[email protected]�@IH6HS.%,/@ H�´ @IH6V#85,/. D-4�D-Y�4SH613�3�9@ @7HSH�´ 46(�i9(94 */.9: g 4��9@ @IH6HS.%,/@ºLZ�38GH�´ @7HSV#85,/.La.%(+*-4685(38_13(R(�13CB8M,-.=4S(3i9(34S*-.�0�4�(3.�0�4�8 (98bD-85K%138��$��LZ�98_L5.7(+*-4685(38_13(J,/@7CB.�46(�i9(34S*-.�� :�� 8M,�46H�CB.�03.=L5.7CB8H�´ @7HSV#85,/.� 8JDU*/@I*-. La.%DU*-,/134S*-."T|DU4 �9@ LZ�38 �dLa.%(+*-4685(38J*-13*U*-4�4�(3.�0�4:n�� ��� T ��� � � � T ��� � � � Ts:5:M:5T ��� ����� Ts:M:5:5T87T�46(3.7HS*-,/87Th 8�La.%CB�3HS85*/@I*-.iM�.7K%(34h(3.�0�.­ 8�DU*/@�*/.R8�D-@7CJ46(9@I*-.dT�8=.�Y+Y�4Q@ICB85(+*/8~(3.7(ºLZ�34619DU.�MF8�D-D-85("0�.R46(�i9(34S*-.DT :� 85,RH6@½��,-.%�3,-468a*� @ >3: >3:�k 0�4SCB.+Dc*/,/@I*/@º(385H � >9: >9T �  8³D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687T La46.9 8G8�DU4QDU*-8G13(9@¼Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38 ��LZ�98D-.�090�46DUE�@�*/1�*U*/4#4hD-13.74"(3.�0�4�:<��@IH68�Y�@IH61�*[email protected](987T7�#85,-*/@7(+*-.9T+,/85(90�8�Y785,/8 � � � � � � � � � � � �78~E�@7H6D/@ � :B��@La4) .PL5.7(+*-,Z@7090�46L58�H�´ 46�#.I*-8�DU4 � � < � :���1346(90�4[46H[DU8�La.%(90�.PLM@7D-.\�#.7,-*/@J@70G13("@PL5.7(+*-,Z@703034S2M4S.%(38�La.%(­H�´ 46�#.I*-8�DU48\¢+1346(90�4|(3.%(ºD-4[�31� .G,/8M@7HS46252�@I,/87: ¥�: �R: rR:

g 4�.%D/DU8M,-Y�4�LZ�38½H�´ 4S(�Y78M,/D-.°0�8MH~*-8M.7,/85CG@�0�4�La.%CJ�"@�*U*/852M2M@Å 8½.�Y�Y�46@�L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@�0�85H6HQ@��3,/.7�3,/4S85*l @�0�4CB.7(3.7*-.%(346L54 *� @ M���85.%,-8MCB@³k3: O":Se%T � k�: O9T ¥_@I�|:9k_T ©bDU8 �  8RL5.7(9D-85K%1385(32�@JHS.%K74QL5@G0�4�13(�D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8�i"(34 */. 0�4�°T3@JCG@IK%K746.7,b,/@7K746.7(38R 8<La.%(9DU8MK7138M([email protected]@J0�4 ��:

r�85H�*-8M.7,/85CG@�0343La.7CB�9@I*U*/85252�@�D-4��31� .�03@7,-8_13(9@�EF.7,/[email protected](38 4S(P*-8M,-CB46(3430�43D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH64 *� @QM�@I(9254QLZ� #80�4AL5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@PHS.%K74QL5@_Ta©�7� 3, �7A(#&'(�$%B0"�$56��%B0��X�&.6 "0"�� � ".;*$AB���[�@./ "0".&/ � "1�O�# 0".6'�./�@.;�M*��E*,'�#&!��j@ / ��8+.;*,��0"����56#&%��<'(�$#��E*,56#�*,�@���"0"#-#&%:9�1+*,%B0�.;�M*!EZ�#&1( �1���*H'����&� f *,�&O@�$�".�8(!�./56�< "#N3�<./ � "���"A/*C0".�#&%L������!���'���%�>$*(8@%�./%D'�#&�@��%�'��)'+*,�&� f ./�"'�#&%��K#&%G!�1�#� "./%�.��� E*,56#&%+*C0"#�#=%�.�'�#?]�"^ z�*,�&�:#&%��?*C0�0�#b#&�b "��F/1���%�0"������� ����������� ���-I��=q&- . o/j L�q J kamG._nH-(mXk�l/.+m<.@ktpBk�D(o}oBj E m �-7- .6.�-�r�q J kL{2.+m s�k}pBm|P-(nEnEqt|�|7k J m+D(owmG.t{2.+m s?m+.@k$pBm��)o/j j k J o�D(o�o/j rHqH.@k�- . J o/r�k�mG.t{2.+m s�k/];b%+*G'�#&56./ "0"�E*,>�#&./%��T#&%4 "#&%�0"�� �#x3���M*G "��F/1���%�0"�/I # *C0�.

1�%w*,�&O@����.6!�Z��) �.�'�'�#& "�~*�� f #&�@.,0��� "#?8+!EZ�#M*,56#M*,56.TO�1�./%�.;1�%:%(.�'�.6 "�)Z+*�#&%(\+%�# 0"#-'�#& "!$��%�'(�$%B0"#xPR!�#&.�3�) ��)Z+*6*,�-'�#� ".,0"0".;#&%(\+%�# 0"#%�.�'�# YE8=�)!$*C0�0�# AB.G#&%:!$*, �.;!�./%�0"�E*,�"#&.wP~!�#&.�3�X ��XZ+*�1�%w%�1�56����.�\+%�# 0".6'�#-'�#& "!��$%('���%�0"# Y7] !��X1�%w%�.�'�. v Z+*�0"1(0"0"#2#- �1�!�!��� � "./��#!$*C0"0"# A�#?8+*,%�!EZ(�;v 3�[!$*C0�0�# AB.�8+�@./#&!EZS��B8(�@�$�S#&� .,0"�� �#?8�./F/%�#�%(.�'�.XZ+*X1�%;%�1�56���".)\�%�# 0�.T'�# �1�!�!��� � �./�"#JPR# '�#& �!���%�'���%B0�#='�#:v �./%�.#+ �1(!$!��� � "./��#@�x#+'�#& �!���%�'���%B0�# '���#@ �1�!�!��� � "./��#?8�#+9�1�*,�&#+!$./ �0�# 0"1�#& "!$./%(.T1�%6#&%( �#&��56��\+%�# 0".�Y7]�,[1�#&%('�#?8�1�%6%�.�'�.)O�1�./%�.XZ+*<*,�&56��%�.1�% "1�!�!��$ " �./�"�GO(1�./%�.�] e *:��*,'�#&!��/8N#&%('�#&!EZ�#M*,56./�M*G!$./%�0 8J�@���T#&�@.,0"�$ "#?8x3�61�%%�.�'�.wO�1�./%(.}PR�@./#&!EZS��;� f *,�&O@����.43�;#&%(\+%(# 0�.w�0"1(0"0"#�# %�.�'�# �./%�.T'�#& �!���%�'���%B0�#='����&�M*T�E*,'(#&!$�tYE]J�[�&56��%�.)1�%; �1�!�!��� � "./���<'����&�M*)�E*,'�#&!��/8( "#M*?0 � 8 3�[1�%G%�.�'�.HO�1(./%�.�]J�[�&56��%�.X1�% �1(!$!��� � "./���<'�# 0 � 8( �#M*0 ^ 8�3�K1(%D%�.�'�.6O�1�./%(.�8+�<!�./ 3 u�A�#M*(I�� 0 1 0 � 1P0 ^ 1������ ��3�<1(%D�E*,56.T#&%(\+%�# 0".�]

Page 65: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§+X�_�+�"����°��& � ± �Q� ! �_���9����°�����_$7�#�����3�5�M���%�7� !�� "�" � 4�<GAB9-. '"<3(I(\</.89-'L.14"Pc4 �:9X.8(h< ,3. � �4�'@<E,B,/.g'��"0��>@.��".87F4E�Z03787F</2G0 � �4a'@<`,_,/.g'��"0B>@.��".87e4 �

')H¯*/85.7,/85CG@�0�4=La.7CB�9@I*U*/85252�@�4S(�¢+138�Dc*Z@�DU8�La.7("03@�EF.7,/CG@�D-4��91� .°0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@7,-8½L5.7(Å13(��3,/.�La8M034SCB85(3�*-.·DU46CB4SH68�@°¢+138MHSH6.�4SCB�34685K+@�*/.°(385H6HQ@°0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@72546.7(38 �3,/8ML58M0�8M(+*-8��$�I: ��,-85EF85,/46@7CJ."T 46(�Y78�La87T~034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8H�´ 8�¢%194SY�@IH685(92M@PEF,/@JH68\0�138=EF.7,/[email protected](34�:

r�4SCB.%DU*-,/[email protected]�3,-46CG@GLZ�38<46Hb��85.7,/85CG@B0�4AL5.7CB�9@I*U*-8M252�@B(385H6H6@JEF.%,[email protected](98QM�¨ Tb46CB�3H646LM@G4SHb�A8M.7,/85CG@0�4AL5.7CB�9@I*U*-8M252�@P([email protected],/[email protected](38QM�^pT_8<�#.74[46H|Y�46L585Y78M,/D/@3:�_�+�"����°��& � ± � &

! ¬#" � !�� "

¹º��� � g 4=�"@I(3(3. 0�138�4S�#.I*/8MD-4�©·@_T DU8�13(9@�EF�  8�La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@�H6.7K%46LM@°0�4�13(¦4S(9D-4685CB8�034�EF�À@IH6HS.%,/@� 8La.%(9D-85K71985(32�@PH6.7K%46LM@B0�4A13(�DU.7*U*-.%4S("DU4685CB8�i9(34S*-. 0�4�¢+138MHSH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCB87T98RVXTb.7K%(34AD-.I*-*-.746(9D-4S8MCB8�i9(34S*-.­0�4 �  8D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687: g 4|0385Y78\034SCB.%DU*-,Z@I,/8�LZ�38��Æ 8�D-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687:

�s,/.�La8�0�[email protected]�"8M,=@%D-D-13,Z0�.9: g 8 � (3.7(¼EF.%D/DU8JDU.�030�4QDUE�@7La46V346HS8%T#¢+19@7H6D-4Q@7D-4|EF��D/@I,/85V3V#8RD-19@­L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]@VM���85.%,-8MCG@Bk3: O":Se�>3T � k3: O"T9¥_@I�|:"k_T : ')( �9@I,-*-4QLa.%H6@7,-8%©

� � < C �! C� 85,­H6@��3,/46CB@�46�#.I*-8�DU4=@_TaT C ! C D-@7,-8MV3V"8¼L5.7(9D-85K%1385(92M@�HS.%K74QL5@�0�4�13( D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8 i"(34 */. � 0�4 ��©� � < C ! C :³� 8M,�H6@ D-8MLa.%(903@ 4S�#.I*/8MD-4sVXTaT �  8BD-.�030�4QDcE�@%La46V346HS8%T�¢+1346(90�4s8�DU4QDc*/8��½*/@7HS8GLZ�38�� � < �B:���@@IH6H6.7,Z@³0�.�Y�,-8MV3V#8R8MD/D-85,/8�� � < C �! C ThCG@ºLa4) .� 8P4SCB�#.%D/DU46V346HS8J�".%46LZ�$#8\(38�D-D-13(9@­Yl@7HS13*/@I2M4S.%(38R�91� . ,/85("0�85,/8Y78M,/@P13([email protected](+*-,Z@7090�4S2M4S.%(38�¢%1"@IH68 C �! C : ¥�: �R: rR:�_�+�"����°��& � ± � ±

!�� " � ! ¬#"

¹º��� � g 4s�9@7(3(3.¼0�198G4S�#.I*/8MD-4�©R@dT�DU8B.%K7(34�D-.I*-*-.%4S(9D-4685CB8Ji9(34S*-.¼0�4s19(�4S(9D-4685CB8º 8³DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H687T�@7HSH6.7,Z@H�´ 46(9D-4S8MCJ8³ 8RD-.�090�46DUE�@7L54SV94SH687T"8RVXT � � < � : g 4�0�85Y%8R0�46CJ.+Dc*/,/@7,-8\LZ�98\8MD-46DU*-8R13(�D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8\i9(34S*-.­0�4 �LZ�38��9@ � L5.7CB8<La.7("DU8MK7138M(32M@PHS.%K74QL5@9:r=@IH6H�´ 4S�#.I*/8MD-4AVXT~DU8MK7138�M"�A8M.7,/85CG@³k�: O9: O9T � k�: O9T#¥_@7�|:#k_Tb�~.7( g .�0 ��� ! � %:b� 85,~H�´ 46�#.I*-8�DU4�@_T M�DcEF,/1�*U*Z@�*Z@�#85,~La.%(+*-,Z@I�3�#.%D-4S2M4S.%(387© D-8=19( 46(9D-4S8MCJ8�(3.%(� 8=D-.�030�4QDcE�@%[email protected],Z@J@IH6CJ8M(3.J13(½DU13.BD-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8=i9(94 */.(3.%(� 8\DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H68ET T#8MD-4QDc*/8\13(¼D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8\i9(34S*-. �W0�4 � � ! � JLZ�38\(3.%(� 8\DU.�030346DUE�@7L54SV346H687:�¥ .7(3�D-460�8M,[email protected]�138\LM@7D-4|@JD-8ML5.7(909@JD-8�! � (3.7(½@7�3�9@I,-*-4685(98�.³@7�3�9@I,-*-4685(98=@��B:g 8�! � � �BT3@IH6HS.%,/@�� � �°:�� .74QLZ�$#8��~.7( g .�0��JT3�#85,b46Hx�A8M.7,/85CG@Bk�: O9:6eM>3T � k3: O"T9¥_@I�|:9k3T � � < � 8 �µ 8=4SHD-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8=i9(94 */.³0�4 � La85,ZL5@I*-.":g 8 ! � �BT�@7HSH6.7,Z@ � < � J � ! � ³La.%( � J � �°:cr=@º��.7( g .�0 � J � ! � %T�DU8MK7138 M���85.%,-8MCG@ºk3: O": O"T� k3: O"T"¥_@I�|:9k_T T � J � < � 8�� J  8�4SHAD-.I*-*-.%4S(9D-4685CB8=i9(34S*-.³0�4 � La8M,/LM@�*-.": ¥�: �R: rR:¹º��� �����7���"���¼& � ± ��� �N03(h<V*&9 .89R'L.14@PQ4 � ,3. � J 4c*&9;0 � J � �p'L.p,/.1>)4�>)fR4 �  8J0�85,/46Yl@7V346HS8B03@ �ÆLa.7(�4SH�3,/.�La8M034SCB85(+*/.­0�85H6H�´ @7HSV#85,/. D-85CG@I(+*/46L5. �Z4N'L. '@>"2L.8W/4�� � � � '@4�4N'@</7F<i'@4c4"'L.g')(\4Q*&9='@</(+(h<3.89R'L.14"Pc4 �j9-.8(\< � � � � � � � � � �,/. � (\0/7F4�>)fR4 � � � � � � � � � �� � ��� ���g,��% �#&%B0"�$ "#?8X!$./56�u%����&�M* '�#&56./ �0���*,>$#&./%(�������!���'���%�0"�/86 �1(���@./ "0".�� #&%�\+%�# 0".�8�*,� 0"��#&56��%B0�#X#&�X0"��./����5;* 3�.$A�A�#&.�8T!$#&.(3�

� % � / � 1 / ^ 1������-1 / �

1������ ��8� �#J!$./ �0��"1�#& �!����H �#2 "A�#&�&1����+*G1�%4*,�&O ���".L#&%� "������%�'�.GA(#M*;A(#M*;%���#S��*,56#-!EZ��6��#&5;*,%(F/./%�.D*,�@���"0"#z / � � 1 z / ^ �01������ 1 z / �

� 1������ ](P2*,�&�b*,�&O ���".X%(./%G�(1-3.T!�Z�#&1�'����� "# *,� 0��"#&56�$%B0"#�A(#+ �*,����O�O@�[1�%; ".,0"0"./#&%� �#&��56�x\+%�# 0".T'(#�� P~9�1���� f�&.G!$./ �0�# 0"1�# 0".D'+*,�&�&�X�~��!EZ(�H\+F/1���*,%�.D%���#J%�.�'�#S!EZ(�� �./%�.G "0�*C0"#S#&%B0��".�'�.,0�0"#S���"#&5;*�'����&�M*G!EZ(#&1� �1���*BY[#&%� �.�'�'�#& ��?*,!�#&O�#&�&�/8=!�./%�0"��.� f #&�@.,0��� "#?] @2���"0�*,%�0".w� f *,�&O@����.DA,*:*$A,*,%�0"#x*,�&� f #&%(\+%�# 0".:�/829�1�#&%�'�#?82Z+*:1(%u�E*,56.L!�./56���&�70E*C0".w%�./%!EZ(#&1� �.:!�Z��;!$./%B0"#&�$%(�G0"1(0�0�#%�.�'�#�z / � � 1 z / ^ � 1������-1 z / �

� 1������&] P2*,�&���E*,56.�8/�@���S�M*B@N��./���"#&�70,3*je(] e(] G(8�3�� �.�'�'�#& ��?*,!�#&O�#&�&�Q���M*bA/*,�&1�0E*,>�#&./%��b!EZ����&.< �.�'�'�#& "�~*����%�'(�[AB�����K0"1(0"0"�<�&�[�R�;'�#�� �/8(9�1�#&%�'(#?8�� 3�K �.�'�'�#& ��?*,!�#&O�#&�&�/]2!�# ./ � "���"A�#�*,%�!EZ(�<!EZ��<� f #&56���&#&!$*,>�#&./%���#&%�AB���� �*;3�K.$A�A�#M*(IJ ���� 3� �.�'�'�#& ��?*,!�#&O�#&�&�/8(�&.L3�)*,%�!EZ(�X./F/%(#� �1�.H �.,0�0�./#&%� "#&��56�[\+%�# 0".�]� y e *H'��7\+%�#&>�#&./%��)'�#���/�3�[0E*,�&�<!�Z��./ 3�<'(�$�"# A/*,O�#&�&�['+*�� ��<�< "./�&.H ��H3�['�����# A/*,O(#&�&�<'+*H1�%G �.,0�0�./#&%( �#&��56�K\+%�# 0".�'�#��48

�<9�1�#&%�'�#= �# ��1-3.�'�#&�"�K!EZ��KA,*,�&�<�M*T���"./����#&�70C3*T'�#=!�./56�+*C0"0"��>�>t*6 "#&%�0�*C0"0"#&!$*LPR./ � �#M*XA/*,�&�K�@���b�M*X'�����# A,*,O�#&�&# 0,3*X9�1�*,%�0".6#&� 0"��./����5;*'�#=!$./56��*C0"0"��>$>$*6 ���5;*,%B0�#&!$*H �*,%�!�#& �!��<�����M*C0"# A/*,56��%B0��)*,�&�M*H!�./%� "��F/1���%�>$*;�&./F/#&!$*BYE]

Page 66: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

§7§�_�+�"����°��& � ± � ² ! �_���9����°�����_$7�"���+�5�����7�7� 0 �"l�M��"

� 4 � � � � 0/787e</250 � � < �

¹º��� � g 8 � � � Th�#85,�H6@ 0�8ai9(94S2M4S.%(38\�3,/8ML58M0�8M(%*/87T#8MD-46DU*-8R13(�D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8\i9(34S*-. � � � � � � � � � P0�4� */@IH68<LZ�38 � � � � � � � � � � � ::r=@IH���85.%,-8MCG@P@7HSHQ@Pi9(38<0�85H � >3: >3T�D-85K%138 � � � � � � � � � �� < � T98¢+1346(90�4 � � < � �"8M,~HQ@P�9,-.%�3,-468a*� @P034|CB.7(3.7*-.7(946@9: ¥�: �R: rR:�_�+�"����°��& � ± � ¾ ! �_���9����°�����_$7�#���� ��+�M���7�%�.0 �9l��� "

� 4 � � < � � 03787F</2G0 � � �

¹º��� � g 8 � � < � [email protected],Z@3T��"8M, 4SH�*/85.7,/85CG@~0343La.7CB�9@I*U*/85252�@3Tl8MD-4QDc*/8 13(JDU.7*U*/.746(9DU4685CB8 i9(34S*-. � 0�8MHSH�´ 46(9D-4S8MCB8�°T �@< � � � � � � � � � %T[*Z@IH68JLZ�38 � � � � � � � � � � < � :J� 8M,�46H *-8M.7,/85CG@º@IH6H6@­i9(38G0�8MH � >3: >3T[(98D-85K7198�LZ�98 � � � � � � � � � �� � T387T9�"8M,¯H6@B0�85i9(3462546.7(38<�3,/8ML58M0�8M(+*-87T � � � : ¥�: �R: rR:

� 85, 0�4SCB.+Dc*/,/@7,-8~46H"*-85.%,-8MCG@\0�4hLa.7CB�3H68a*/852M2M@�EF.%,U*/87T�La.%(G4SHh¢+19@IH68~*/85,/CJ46(9@RH6@<(9.%DU*-,Z@<8MD-�".+DU462546.7(98�0�85H6H68�3,/.7�3,/468a*l @º0�8MHSHQ@º�3,-.�L58M0�13,Z@º0�85H6H�´ @IH6V#85,/. D-85CG@7(%*/46L5.9T|D-4b 8JE�@�*-*-. 19D-. 0385H *-8M.7,/85CG@ 0�4sLa.%CB�9@�*-*-852M2M@º8G0�85H*-8M.7,/85CG@B0�4�L5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@ M�DUEF,-13*U*/@I*-.G(38MHSHQ@³0�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I2M4S.%(38=0385H|*/85.%,-8MCB@B@7HSHQ@Ji9(38R0385H � >3: >_Ta: �s@IH68R@I("LZ�3846HAY�46L585Y%85,ZD-@9:_��.7(¼D-.7H6.³03@IH[�A8M.7,/85CG@G0�4�L5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@BEF.7,-*-8\D-85K%138\46Hb��85.%,-8MCB@G034�La.%CB�3HS85*-8M252M@HM�LZ�38\(98La.+Dc*/4 */134QD-L58=19( [email protected]�"@I,-*-4QLa.7HQ@I,/87T�¢+19@7(90�. �Æ 8=Y�13.7*-.DT T�CG@B@I(9LZ�38%©�_�+�"����°��& � ± �Q� �N037 �X4G<3254@PQ0i,/. >)</P J 7e4"(\4GC)CE0 �"</2L(\4�'@4hA3*-4a.87 �X4)</254@PQ0i,/. >)<3P J 0/(+(h4)C)CE0�� � �¹º��� � g 46@ � � < � ::r�@7HS��85.%,-8MCB@R0�4#L5.7CB�3H68a*/85252�@<EF.%,U*/8�DU8MK7138 � � � T�L54S.9 87T%�"8M,_0�85i9(3462546.7(38%T�8MD-46DU*-8�13(D-.I*U*/.746(9D-4S8MCJ8Ri9(34S*-. � � � � � � � � � G0�4 � *Z@IH68PLZ�38 � � � � � � � � � � � :ar�@7H *-8M.7,/85CG@­@7HSHQ@Gi9(980�8MH � >3: >�MF(38MHSHQ@�La13430�46CB.%DU*-,Z@I2M4S.%(38_D-4�DcEF,/1�*-*/@=4SH�*/85.%,-8MCB@=0�43L5.7CB�3H68a*-8M252�@=LZ�987TILa.%CB8bD-4�#8b.%D/DU8M,-Y�@I*-.9T�D-85K%13803@7Hx�A8M.7,/85CG@P034ALa.%CJ�9HS85*[email protected],-*-8KT T9D-4[,/46LM@lYl@ � � � � � � � � � �� < � 8<¢+1346(90�4ALZ�98 �  8�L5.7(9D-85K%1385([email protected]@J0�4|19( D-.I*-*-.%4S(9D-4685CB8=i9(34S*-.³0�4 ��: ¥�: �R: rR:

� " ,[1��� "0".40"�$./�"��5;*a3�L1(0�#&�&�L�@./#&!EZ���:#&%}56./� 0"�L0"�E*C0�0E*,>�#&./%�#b'����&�M*v�&./F/#&!$*�����./�@./ �#&>�#&./%+*,�&�D �#x'�#&56./ "0"�E*(8S!�./% 1�%�*�0"��!$%(#&!t*!EZ��XAB��'�����56.G%����J�(��./ � "#&56.6!$*,��# 0�./�&.�8�'�#&���70�0E*,56��%B0��H#&� P-�$./�"��5;*G'�#2!�./56���&�70"�$>�>$*G�R./�"0"�/])����P-�$./�"��5;*G'�#2!�./56���&�70"�$>�>$*L�T#&�P-��./����5;*T'(#�!�./56�+*C0"0"��>�>t*� "#�.,0�0���%�F/./%(.D*,�&�&./��*T!�./56�K!�./��./�&�M*,�"#�'���� P-��./�"�$5;*X'�#�!�./56���&�70"�$>�>$*H�R./�"0"�B]

Page 67: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ����� ������ �

� � � ��������� � � ����� � ��� � ����� �� ����� ������

���! "$#&%('*),+.-0/213)&#04526!798!:<;>=@?BAC7@AD;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6,:<LML>=N:POQAD=@7N7@RTSU?FEF:<?BAD=N7VOQ63?FAWH>A.HI6G7N7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA.S[6!OQ:PJK?B=\83AM]^=N79_KRM:<7N6,83ACJMSB6GJK?B6,HI=` 6!EB=@aT8!:<EF6&SB6QR>JM:0H>:b?c:�de;gf6&RMJM:�?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=N:�ADS[60f6i8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJ>jk:l7NAPhC=N8!:�H>=m:<7@?BEF6PnQopJq_CRM6!S[?BAD8G:P;>=r?FAP7NA=NJC?F6GJMH>=N:PO&As:<tZEFAPJK?c:<EF69R>JiHI= ` 6!EFSBA�;>EBACL>7N6GOi:>] ` :P7@62:�HI=NEF6u_KR>6!7@7NAsHI=>hC6GJ>6!EF:PEB6v7N6u?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=@6u62HI=MEB=\8G: ` :<EF67N6283APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>jG6u7NAPhP=\8cw>6uH>:�R>JQ=NJMS[=N6GOQ62HI=M;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6Cn^xHy6kS[6!OQ;>=@AT]<J>6!7{zF|Mn@}~HI6!7Z�v:<;>=@?BAC7@A�|�SB=�f6~SU?c:<L>=N7N=r?FA83ACJs83ACJMS[=\HI6!EF:PjG=NAPJ>=PH>=CJM:<?BR>Ec:~SB6GOi:<JK?B=\8G:��eACSFSB=N:~:<?[?BEc: ` 6!EFSBAu7@6 ` :P7@R>?F:<j!=@ACJ>=��$8cw>6m7\:ude;2�$�����s���<�9���Y����V���b�uf6uR>JM:?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:>]b6~8cw>6~7\:�de;i�����f6u83APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:7@AChP=\8G:�HI6G7N7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6~�����B�l���W�[�s���C���V���K�Cnop7~OQ63?FAWH>A�H>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�SB6GOi:<JK?B=\83A�83ACJMSB6GJK?B60HI=~EF6GJMHI6!EB6g�[OQ6k8G8G:PJ>=\8cw>6!��?F:P7@=28GAPJMSB=NH>6GEc:<jG=NAPJM=Vd�:C836GJTHIAP7N6HI= ` 6!JC?c:<EF6�RMJ ` 6GEFA�60;>EFAP;MEB=NA�8!:<7\83AC7@AT]V83ACJMHIA<?B?BA�OQ6!HI=\:<JK?F6�EF6GhCAP7N6�8GAPOQ;>7N63?c:<OQ6GJK?B606kS[;>7N=\83=@?F:b?F60608cwM6;>R fA�6!SFSB6GEF6�=NO&;M7@6!O&6!JK?F:b?FA�SBR�HI=*RMJ�8G:P7N8GAP7\:b?FAPEF6Pn�¡VSFS[AT]M?FRI?[?c: ` =\:>]{wT:l6kSBSB6GJ>j!=N:P7@OQ6!JC?F6�7\:,JM:<?BR>Ec:lH>=*R>J?B6kSU?&HI= ` 6GEF=raT8!:>]$AKSBSB=\:�:CSBSBR>OQ6,83ACOQ6,H>:b?c:07N:�de;¢HI6!7@7\:._KRM:P7@6,8G=VS[=v8cw>=N6!HI6,SB60f6iR>JM:�?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhC=N:�A.SB60f683ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:27NAPhP=\8G:�HI=IR>J&=NJMS[=N6GOQ6~H>:<?BA��¢n(�9ACO&6~SB=Zf6vH>63?[?FAM]C=@J ` 6k836C] ` APEFEF6GOQOQAHI=\S[;ZAPEFEF69HI=IR>Ji8!:<7\83AP7NA8cw>6�83= 83APJTS[6!JC?c:yH>={?BEFA ` :<EF67N6�?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=N66sHI=£EB=\8G: ` :<EF6�~���sH>:P7@7�X =@JMSB=N6GOQ6����¤�B�����W�B���¥�P�Y���,�K�Kn526!7T8GAPEcS[AsHI6!7 ` 6GJK?B6kS[=NOQAsS[6k83AC7@A�SBAPJMAsSU?c:b?B=Z6G7\:<LZAPEc:b?F=MS ` :PEB=\:b?F=M8G:P7N8GAP7N=M7NAPhC=N8G=T8cw>6�SB=M;ZACSFSBAPJ>AsHI= ` =NH>6GEF6=NJ�?FEB6�8G7N:CSBSB=Y¦

�B§!��8!:<7\83AC7@=$:CSBSB=@ACOi:b?B=\83=*��A��F:<7N7N:Q¨�=@7NLT6!E[?c�C�3©�BªF��8!:<7\83AC7@=$HI6!7@7\:QHI6!H>R>jG=NAPJ>6�JT:b?BRMEF:P7@6C©�B«F��8!:<7\83AC7@=$HI6!=£SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=m�eA��B:P7@7\:i¬�6GJK?Bj!6GJM�K�­n

52ACJ>ACS[?F:PJK?B6l7\:�7@ACEBA�6GJ>ACEBOQ6 ` :PEB=N63?bf:>]mSB=u?BEc:b?[?c:�HI=udeACEBOi:P7@=\S[OQ=9?BEc:�7NAPEFA�6k_KR>= ` :P7@6!JC?F=~H>:<7u;>R>JK?FA�HI=` =NS[?F:iH>6G7N7@6�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:yOQ6G?F:b?F6GACEB=\8cw>6�deAPJMHM:<OQ6GJK?F:P7@=9��83ACEBEF63?B?B6!jGj!:&6s8GAPOQ;>7N63?B6!jGjk:C�v6�8cw>6sSB=£HI=@t�6GEF6GJ>j!=N:PJ>A;Z6GEc8cwv®6i:<7\83R>JM=9SBAPJ>AD;>=[fR¢:PHM:b?[?F=9HI=v:<7@?BEF=V:DSF83AP;M=V;M:PE[?F=N8GAP7\:<EF=Yn,opJq;MEB=NOi:.:<;>;MEBAKSBSB=@Oi:PjG=NAPJ>6QS[=9;>R fA.HI=NEF68cw>6�=£8!:<7\83AP7N={:PSFS[=NAPOi:<?B=\83=$SBAPJ>A&Oi:<hPhC=@ACEBOQ6!JC?F6EF= ` AP7@?B={:P7{;>EBACL>7N6GOi:QHI6G7N7N:&hC6GJ>6!EF:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI6G7N7N6?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhC=@6C]_KR>6G7N7N=ZHI6!7@7\:sHI6kHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6�:P7M;>EFAPL>7N6GOi:sH>=TEF=@J ` 6GJ>=NEB6~7N68GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMjG627NAPhC=N8cw>62H>=TR>J�=@JTS[=N6GOQ6�HI=Tde;$]_KR>6G7N7N=£HI6G=$SB6!_KR>6!JK?B=$;>EF6!SB6GJK?c:<J>A ` :<JK?F:PhPhP=�;Z6GE~=N7$EF=@J ` 6!J>=NO&6!JK?BAQ6�7YX :<JM:P7@=\SB=$HI6G7N7@6sH>6GEF= ` :<j!=@ACJ>=�n���­¯ °�#²±~³s´3±~)&´3)µ³�¶ ¶(13)&·¸³�%(1G±~)526!=T8!:<7\83AP7N=M:CSBSB=@ACOi:b?B=\83=TS[=Z:PSFS[R>OQACJ>As83ACO&62:CSBSB=NAPOQ=M:<7\83RMJ>=TSF8cw>6GOQ=ZHI=>deACEBOQ6~;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=�]<ACSFS[=\:�?BR>?[?B67N6y�e=NJIaMJM=r?F6k�mde;l8cw>6�wT:<J>J>A�R>JM:�8G6GEB?F:sS[?BEFRI?B?BR>Ec:sSB=@JK?F:<?[?F=N8!:>]K6SB=T=NJK?BEFAWH>RM83ACJ>AsHI6G7N7N6�EF6GhPAC7@6~;Z6GEuHI6!EB= ` :<EFJ>6:<7@?BEF6�:¢;M:<EB?B=NEB6�H>:¹_KR>6!7@7N6�hC=ºf:¢EB=\8G: ` :b?F6Pn»¬�7@=�:PSFSB=@ACO&=�S[ACJ>Aq?FRI?[?F=�SF8cw>6!O&=�HI=�?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=N6.6�7N6�EB6!hPAP7N6��8cwM6&SB;T6kSBSBAlSB=(EB=\HIRM8GAPJ>A�:PHDR>JT:lSBAP7\:>]�=@7(OQAIHIRMS;TACJ>6GJTS�¼�½9�83APJTS[6!E ` :<JMAi7N:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:,H>=^6kSBSB6GEF6sR>JT:?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:>ng¿$AqS[;M=@EF=r?FAq8cw>6DS[AC7@=@?F:PO&6!JK?B6�hPR>=\H>:�7N:�SF836!7r?c:�HI6!hP7N=2:PSFS[=NAPOQ=�f6D_KR>6G7N7NA�?F=@;M=N8GA�H>6G7~OQ63?FAWH>A:PSFSB=@ACOQ:<?B=\83AT] ` :<7N6l:.HI=NEF6l_KR>6G7N7@A�HI=9AP?[?F6GJ>6!EB6,_KRM:PJC?FA�:<RTS[;>=\8G:<?BA.:D;T:<EB?B=NEB6,H>:.R>J¢JWR>OQ6GEFADOQ=@J>=NOQA�HI=

ÀWÁ

Page 68: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

À��:PSFSBR>J>jG=NAPJM=Yn��9APOQ6i;Z6GE&_CRT:PSB=m?BR>?[?B=v=uS[=\SU?F6GOQ=9:CSBSB=NAPOi:b?F=N8G=Y]^S[ACJ>AD;TAKSBSB=NL>=@7N=9S ` :<EF=N:<?B6,:CSBSB=@ACOi:b?B=NjGjk:<j!=@ACJ>=:<7@?B6!EBJT:b?B= ` 6C]Z?BRI?B?B6&?BEc:,7NAPEFAl6k_CRM= ` :<7N6GJK?F=Yn���JM:�H>=NS[?B=NJ>jG=NAPJM6&HI6!EB= ` :�HM:�_KRM:P7@=(83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` =mS[=*SBAPJ>A�:PSFS[R>JK?F=83ACOQ6�;>EF=@OQ=@?B= ` =ZJM6G7�7@=NJ>hCRM:<hChP=NA���n��W=(f6hP=pf:�: ` RI?BAyOQAWH>AyHI={:P8!836!J>JM:<EF6�8GAPOQ6�=NJ�� S[=�;ZACSFSB:PJ>A�:CSBSBR>OQ6GEF683ACOQ6u8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` =I;>EF=NO&=@?B= ` =>_KR>6G7N7@=THI=IR>JM:�_KRM:<7NR>JM_KR>6uLM:CS[6uA�HI=>R>JT:6kSU?F6GJMSB=NAPJ>6uHI=>R>JT:LT:PSB6P¦$=>EF=NOQ:PJ>6GJK?F=83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` =£SB={;TAKSBSBAPJ>A��BH>63aMJ>=NEF6!�Q:&;M:<EB?B=NEB6�H>:Q_KR>6!7@7N=£:PSFSBR>JK?B=$83ACOQ6�;MEB=NOQ=r?F= ` =�nopJDR>J>A�HI6G=^8G:<7\83AC7@=£;>=[fR�HI=rt�RMSB=£J>6!7@7\:i7N63?B?B6GEc:b?FR>Ec:iS[=^:PSFS[R>OQACJ>AiJ>6G7 7@=NJ>hCRM:<hChP=NAQSBAP7NAi= 8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` =� 6� ]M83ACO&6�:CSBSB=@ACOQ=Z= S[6!hPR>6!JC?F=$SB8cwM6GOQ=$HI={?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhP=N6P¦

���}k� ����� � ������P� �� ����� �����[�m�¸�[�� ���y�m���� �����B���|C� ���� �����&�V����� � �6D83ACO&6�R>J>=\8G:�EF6GhCAP7\:.=N7������������ �"!$#%!&���Y¼.½9�3¦mS[60SB=2S[ACJ>A�AP?[?F6GJWRI?B607N6�de;' 6( �)� �+*$,-#%./#0�1�%#B�=NJMHI=N;T6!JMHI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6yH>:<7{7NAPEFAyACEFH>=@J>6C]>S[=£;>R fAiHI6GEF= ` :PEB62� �B«1�"!Z«%34���05���!$#F�­n6�I8cw>6!OQ:<?B=\8G:PO&6!JK?B6P¦

� ��

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDCFEGC�HJIK798;L�=�M&N&?�=�@A<>8�"PO>!Z§�H>6GEF= ` :<j!=@ACJ>6RQ#S�T!Z§U�%#1VW�X#%!�Yk§ Z[!X5+\p§]��5A^�*_�`b�%aba%aG�cedSf9«W5�§"g�G«W�T!�§h��#%3+3i#SV%�M§�345UQ#��j�T!.§k�1�05���.i§]�lQ#���\�\m#W!A�T\º§U�P§]�"�X#�^�*�«cnX#�3@§e*o,-#c«c#1�;��!$�/.h#1��5�§"!X\m#��T!qp §c*;*$345�«c§bY%5��"!$#��#%3+3@§�,-#sr;�"3@§]���ut798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDCFEGCFEvIKw6xzy>8;L�=�M&NT{>=�|�8�"POD!Z§ide;l}�15e�"5�«1#QHI6GEF= ` :PL>=@7N6�~K#��056�3«%,05+��#]�R �(�%#9#��W�"3i���W##W�15F�0\m#��T!�§]��#%,05+�b§bY%5���!o#]��5V«%�T5G�Q#S3@§u^�*]Z�!�§�3i#�t���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqC�Hv�*6!EB=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAQ8cw>6S�i��� � n

�U}¾� � �����[� �0� �Z�m� ���[�m���B� ����� ��� ���[�V���r��� �Z�B����C� �����B� ��� ���V� �Z���|K� � ����� ��� ���[�V���r��� �Z����W� �����r��� �Z����C� ��� �� x>=�8��$N&?;=�@$<D8Zn*¿£:��U}¾�2f6�R>J�6!SB6GOQ;>=NA&H>6G7N7@AiSF8cw>6GOi:l�Yx��C��Y83ACJ9 �¢�£]&� � � ��� ���­]X�¤�q���­n*¿£:����C��f6R>J06!SB6GOQ;>=NA,HI6!7@7NA,SB8cwM6GOi:0��xs}¾����8GAPJ( �¢�£]$� � �r��� ���[�3n9¿£:0�Y|C��f6�AP?[?B6!JWRI?F:iH>:D�[}k�v6,���P�v;Z6GE�¼.½(n¿£:����W�2f6�R>J�6!SB6GOQ;>=NA&HI6!7@7NAQSB8cw>6!Oi:l��x�}k����8GAPJ9 �z� �q�Z�­n*opJ>aMJ>6P]I7\:l���P�2f6�A<?[?F6GJWRI?c:yH>:���|K�m6Q���W�m;Z6GE¼.½(n

�W6A ` RMJM_KR>6P]WJ>6!7@7\:yH>6GEF= ` :<j!=@ACJ>62;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6P]I:P7T;ZACS[?BAQHI=W��SF83EF= ` =\:<OQAS�]I:<L>L>=\:<OQAyR>JM:yO&6G?F:CHI6GEF= ` :"�jG=NAPJM6Q��ACSFS[=\:&R>J>AiSF8cw>6GOi:QHI=£HI6!EB= ` :<j!=@ACJ>=\�vHI=D � �83=NAMf6�;Z6GE~APhCJ>=�de;(s¦�� �

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDCFEGC���IK798;L�=�M&N&?�=�@A<>8�y>N��><R=�<>�b=�8���8�y>=���x � "��&§�\m���T!R5+!&�05�#%.h#l����5�^�*$fS�05S��5�«1#HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM6&HI6!7@7\:�de;� HM:<7N7YX =@JTS[=N6GOQ6,���T!Z§_�W#1V%�X#W!TYk§2Z�!A5+\º§��"5G^�*� ` �ba%a%aG�- d fu\p§�3i#�«1n&#j d �� #�cr"!A5Ge¡�Q#j���T!�§k�1�05���.i§kf �RQ#S�T!�#%3i#W./#%!X\m���"5{�Jf¢�RQ#h��\�\m#W!A�T\º§]�C§��"�X#[^�*¹«cnX#j3@§�*o,-#c«c#1�;��!$��./#c�"5�§�!A\s#�T!Z§l§c*�*o345�«c§bY%5���!o#]��#%3+3@§�,-#sr���3@§/���ut

�W6�6!SB=\SU?F6�RMJM:QHI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>6�HI=G�H>:&��S[=$H>=N8G6s8cw>62 f6h�;#W,05+�b§Pª%5+3i#�H>:&��6sSB=$SF83EF= ` 6�}��sn[�W6���f6aMJ>=@?BAT]C8G=@AMf6u� �����`¾�%aba%a3�cedy�C]C:<J>j!=N8cwu®6v�£��s]C8G=@AMf6����`¾�%aba%a!�-ed������]KSF83EF= ` =\:<OQA��`<�%aba%a3�ced¤��snopJq_KR>6!S[?BAD83ACJK?B6!S[?BA0� f6,HI6G?[?BA0?c:<7 ` AC7r?c:�5+!X�15�#%./#9�;#W3+3�#�5 *X��\m#W�15(6,SB=m;M:PEB7\:0:<JM8cw>6iHI=���#%,05+�¾§�YW5��"!$#��%��\�\m�5 *X��\m#0�05�n

Page 69: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

À��

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqC+ER�*6!EB=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAQ8cw>62 � �,�c� ���P�� � �&¦�U}¾� ��� �����m���� ����� � ���[� ��x�}k����C� � ��� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$�����|K� ����� ����� ��HM:��[}k�v6,���P�9;T6!E�¼.½v����W� �� ����� �����B�V���B�� � �&�V���� � ���[� ��x��P����C� �� � �y�m���� ����� ��HM:��Y|C�v6,���K�9;T6!E�¼.½v�� À � � � �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$���� Á � ��� ��HM:����P�v6,� À �9;T6!E�¼.½v��W=�?FEF:<?[?F:gHI=�R>JT: ./#%\º§;��#%,05+�¾§�YW5��"!$#G¦ 83ACO�R>JT_CRM6�SB=sS[AKSU?F=r?FR>=\SB8!:<J>A�s]2� 6J� 83ACJ de;¤S[=�wT:¹R>JT:HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM6Pn¿£:�HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM6yHI6!7@7�X 6kS[6!OQ;>=@A_�Tn �>n �,;>R fA06!SFS[6!EB6yAPEc:�S[deEFRI?[?c:b?F:�83ACOQ6yJWR>A ` :�EB6!hPAP7\:l:�HIR>6Q;>EF6GOQ6kSBSB6��H>63?[?c:iHI=9«1��!�«c§�\m#W!�§bY%5���!o#~6�:<L>LMEB6 ` =\:b?c:y8GAPJ.�9APJM8k�­¦

���� � � � �

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqCF�z�*6!EB=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAQ8cw>6S���� ���� � �&�­¦�U}¾� �� ������� ������ ��x�} ` ����C� ����� �����V���� � �&� ��x|C���|K� �� ���� ���&� ��HM:��[}k�v6,�Y|C�9;T6!E��9APJT8!�

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqC�B �*6!EB=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAQ8cw>6S����� � s¦�U}¾� ��� ������ �������� �e;Z6GE�7N:U�Mn �In |��!����C� ���� �������v������� ��� ��x|��k���|K� ��� ������� ���� ��HM:��[}k�v6,���P�9;T6!E��9APJT8!����W� ����� �������¤� �B�V���[����� � �����V������� � �B� ��x��P����C� ����� ������v������� ��� ��HM:��Y|C�v6,���K�9;T6!E�¼.½v�� À � ��� ����� ��¡9S[6!OQ;>=@Ah�Tn �>n@}¾�� Á � ��� � ��HM:����P�v6,� À �9;T6!E�¼.½v�

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqC��R�*6!EB=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAQ8cw>6S�� � ����U}¾� ���� � �� ��HM:<7N7N:U�Mn �In ���k����C� ������¤�����9���� � ���� ��x|��k���|K� ����� ��HM:��[}k�v6,���P�9;T6!E�¼.½v�

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqCz�*6!EB=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAQ8cw>62 � � ����� ����s¦�U}¾� � � �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$������C� ��� � ��HM:<7N7N:U�Mn �In �K���|K� ��� � � ��HM:��[}k�v6,���P�9;T6!E��9APJT8!����W� � ������ ��HM:<7N7N:U�Mn �In �P����C� ��� ������ ��HM:��Y|C�v6,���K�9;T6!E��9APJT8!�� À � ����� ������y�v������� � ��� ��x|C�� Á � ��� ���� ��HM:����P�v6,� À �9;T6!E�¼.½v�x2JT8cw>6�7\:S�Tn �>n À ;>R fA&6!SFS[6!EB62RTSB:<?F:�8GAPOQ6�JWR>A ` :�EB6!hPAP7\:,�YHI63?B?F:&HI=m«c�"!X\�,B§c*;*&���05iYW5��"!$#u6�:<L>LMEB6 ` =\:b?c:s83ACJ�9APJK?FEc�3¦

� ��������������������� �"!$#%�'&(�*)+����������� �,!$#%).-/0��������������������� �"!$#%�'&(�*�����1���2������� �"!$#3).-/ �������*�3�����������4�4�"!5#3).-6 ��������������������� �"!$#%�(-6 �����7�����8���9������� ��!$#:).-<;=&>�*� &>?�@5# �4�A�B��� C>&>D &>E,�A���*�F&G��� ��D4&,#F�*C>��E,�5# �4�A!5#*#F�5!5# HI#F!5@J��D4&"KI@5���F#9� ����� # �4@5L>#F���5#*� #�� ���5�

����&>DM�N�4&(�$&O?��F#���� � #F��E,#-

Page 70: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á��

� ���� � ��83AKSpf ��8GAPOQ6�H>:<7N7�X :CSBSB=@ACOi:y|QSB={A<?[?F=@6!J>6�d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6�7\:&EB6!hPAC7N:���HI6G?[?c:i:<JM8cw$X 6!SFSF:yHI=v«c�"!X\�,B§c*;*&���05iYW5��"!$#F�­¦�� ������ ���9ACSpf ��]WRMSB:PJMHIA&7@6sH>6GEF= ` :<j!=@ACJ>=q�Mn �In �&62�Mn �In �I]IS[={AP?[?F6GJ>hCAPJ>A&d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6C¦

������ ����

�� � ���� �

¿mX 6!SB6GOQ;>=NAQEB=\8cw>=\:<Oi:b?FA&:P7@7�X =@J>=NjG=NAiHI6G7£;M:<Ec:<hCEF:<deA��3�[?BEc:PHIRT836GJTHIAC�Q�*�uHI= ` =N6GJM6P¦���b8��Jx�=�@�B�C+EqC��R�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6C¦{�,�¥�W�[�����C�c�Z���������(�s���C¦�U}¾� ����� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$������C� �(�s���Z� ��HM:��[}k�v;Z6GE��9ACJK?BE­���|K� �Z����� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$������W� �(�s��� ��HM:����P�v6,�Y|C�9;T6!E��9APJT8!����C� �s��� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$���� À � �(�s��� ��HM:����K�v6,���P�9;T6!E��9APJT8!�

�½(6GE�S ` =N7@R>;M;M:<EF6.OQ6GhC7@=NA¢7N6�HI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>=6�AP?[?B6!J>6GEF6�:P7r?FEB=EB=\S[RM7r?c:b?B=�SB=�;>R fAgHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6D=N7�S[6!hPR>6!JC?F6=NO&;ZAPEB?F:PJK?B6P¦

� 8�@AL�8���N�BDCFEGC�HJI � 8�@XL�8���N�y>=�yD8�y>�D?;=�@$<D8�"

���D�k���������� �� � �

x�H�6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]>H>:<7 � 6GACEB6!OQ:&HI=£H>6!HIR>j!=@ACJ>6�6�H>:<7N7\:j�Tn �>n �>n@]>SB={wM:QSBRM8G8G6!SFS[= ` :<OQ6GJK?B6C¦ � � �¹��� � ���m���� �����

�¢�� ���&�m���[��� �����V���� �����[�6s83AKSpf �ZSBAPJ>AQ6k_CRM= ` :<7N6GJK?F=Y¦����� ��¤6S��� ��

�� � ����62 ������WR>;M;TACJ>=N:POQAQ8cwM6�SB= ` APhP7N=\:yHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6P¦

���u�� �����&�V���u��� �������8cwM6D�U?BEc:PH>RM836k�h��¢�9� � � �9�3n½(6GEuAP?[?B6!J>6GEF6�_KR>6!S[?BAQEF=NSBR>7@?F:b?FAQLM:PS[?F:Q: ` 6!E~HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:<?BAM¦

�¹��� ������V���� �����y�6s:<;M;>7@=\8G:PEB6�7\:yEF6GhCAP7\:yH>=£83ACJC?FEF:P;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6Pnx�H�6kSBSBAiS[={;Z6GE ` =@6!J>6�:<;>;>7N=\8G:<JTHIAQ=@7�� 6GACEB6!Oi:yHI= HI6!HIRMjG=NAPJ>6�:>¦

� ���� �� ������*6GEF=@aT8cw>=\:<OQAi:<7N7@ACEF:y_CRM6!S[?!X R>7r?F=@Oi:QEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6�H>=£HI6GEF= ` :PL>=N7@=@?¾f:M¦

�U}¾� � ���� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$������C� ��� ����� ��HM:��[}k�v;Z6GE��9ACJK?BE­���|K� ����� �e;Z6GE�7N:U�Mn �In �In ����W� ����� �e;Z6GE��9APJM8�:0���C�v6Q�Y|C�B��WR>;M;TACJ>=N:POQAQH>= ` AC7@6!EuH>6GEF= ` :<EF6�7N:&?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhP=\:>¦

Page 71: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á }

�����Y�s���<�V���������r�y���b�B�ACSFSB=N:&HI= ` 6GEF=raT8!:<EF6P](�U?FEF:CHIRM8G6GJMHIAK�&�v]T8cw>6P¦

���u�r�����u�Y�����b�B�V���Y��� �u� �����^�<�[�x¤_KR>6!S[?BAiEF=NSBR>7@?F:<?BAQS[=$;MR fAi:<EFEB= ` :<EF6�:P;>;>7N=N8!:<JMHIAQHIR>6 ` AP7@?B6�=N7��£6!APEF6GOi:&HI=£HI6kHIR>jG=NAPJM6�:M¦

�u�r�����u���s���<�[�3�B�����u� �����^�<�8cw>6C]>:iS[RM: ` AP7@?F:>]ISB=$A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�8GAPJ07N:&EF6GhCAP7\:yHI=$8GAPJK?BEc:<;M;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�H>:M¦

�����^�b�B�2�i��� �u���s���<��W6!O&;MEB6�;Z6GE~=N7��£6!APEF6GOi:QHI=$HI6kHIR>jG=NAPJM6&f6�SBR��,83=N6GJK?F6sHI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6�8cw>6P¦

�����^�b�B�W�Y�����u�Y�s���<�8cw>6C]>:iS[RM: ` AP7@?F:>]ISB=$A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�d�:C83=N7@OQ6GJK?F6�;T6!E�83ACJC?FEF:P;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6H>:M¦

�����^�b�Y�£�F���������(��*6GEF=@aT8cw>=\:<OQA&:P7@7NAPEc:&_CRM6!S[?!X R>7r?F=@Oi:QEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6�H>=£HI6GEF= ` :PL>=N7@=@?¾f:M¦�U}¾� �����^� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$������C� � �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$�����|K� �^� ��HM:��[}k�v6,���P�9;T6!E�¼.½v����W� ����� �e6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BAiHI=$������C� �^�s���(� ��HM:����K�v;Z6GE��9ACJK?BE­�� À � �(� ��HM:��Y|C�v6,���P�9;T6!E�¼.½v��9APOQ626!OQ6GEFhP6283ACJ,8cw>=\:<EF6GjGjk:�H>:s_KR>6kSU?kX R>7@?B=NOQA�6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]C7N6�HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM=MJ>6!=T8G:P7N8GAP7N=T:CSBSB=@ACOi:b?B=\83=TS[ACJ>A=NJ¹hP6!J>6GEF6,7\:<LZAPEF=@AKS[6i6C]m;Z6GE&;TAP?B6GEF7N6�S ` =N7NR>;>;M:PEB6C] ` :PJ>J>A�SBA<?B?BAC;TAKSU?F6l:D?FEF:CSUdeACEBOi:<j!=@ACJ>=m;>EF6G7N=NO&=NJM:PEB=uHI6G7?B=N;ZA�HI=*_KR>6G7N7N6�APEc:i6kS[6!O&;M7@=@aT8G:<?B6Cn526!7 ;MEBAKSBSB=@OQA,;T:<Ec:<hPEc:bdeAQ=NJK?BEFAWH>R>EBEF6GOQAiR>J�8G:P7N8GAP7NAi;>=[fR �[JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6!�M]J>6!7£S[6!JMSBA&8cw>6s8GAPJMSB6GJK?F6�H>={AP;Z6GEc:<EF6�HI=NEF63?[?c:<OQ6GJK?F6sS[R>7N7N6�SB6!_KR>6!J>jG6sH>=�de;$nopJ.AChPJ>=^8G:PSBAM]�SB= ;ZACSFS[ACJ>AlHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6sEF6G7\:b?B= ` :<OQ6GJK?F6�:<7(8G:P7N8GAP7NAl:PSFS[=NAPOi:<?B=\83Ai;>EF6!SB6GJK?F:<?BAT]M=6\s#1�",-#W.U5

��5v«c�",0,-#%\�\m#cY1Yk§&��HI6!LTAC7@6�6�deACE[?F6k�3¦�W6j��s]T:<7N7@ACEF:�� �

�W6��£��s]T:<7N7@ACEF:���� �

6�=\m#c�",-#%.j5[�"59«1��.e*$3i#%\s#1Y1Yk§i��HI6!LTAC7@6�6�deACE[?F6k�­¦�W6�� � �]M:<7N7NAPEc:h��

�W6���� � �]M:<7N7NAPEc:��£��

8cw>6�SF:<JT83=\SB8GAPJ>A�7\:�;T6!E[de6G?[?c:s:PHI6!hPRM:<?B6!jGj!:�H>6G7T8!:<7\83AC7@As:PhP7N=MSB8GAP;>=T;>EF63aTSFSB:<?B=��b¦^J>APJ,SBAP7NA�APhCJ>=>de;lH>6GEF= ` :<LM=@7N6f6iR>JT:0?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:���6,R>JM:Dde;¹HI6GEF= ` :PL>=N7@6,H>:.R>Jq=@JTS[=N6GOQ6,��HI=9de;qJ>6.f6,8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMj!:07NAPhP=\8G:K�­] OQ:.APhPJM=?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:>]W;Z6GE�_KRM:PJC?FAi83APOQ;>7N6!SFSF:>]Zf6sHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@6�OQ6!H>=N:PJC?F6�7N:QSBAP7\:&EB6!hPAP7\:&¼.½ H>:<hC7@=$:CSBSB=@ACOQ=$:PSFS[R>JK?F={6APhCJ>=�de;D8cw>6&f6�83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:y7NAPhP=\8G:&HI=$� f6�:<JM8cwM6�H>6GEF= ` :<LM=@7N6sH>:&�¢n� @5&>�4�4#*�4&O��D4&>E,#�� ���5C>#F� C>���5���B� C>��E,�5�F&G�M� &>KI@$# H����F&>�5LO� �4DM� �B� !5&>D # H����5#F�F# �� �<�5&>��CO���FCO���F�A��� �4#F��E �N� #FC>�<&"�B�<!$&OD4# H����5#F�F# �� �

E,&>!5#B���0� & #F��E,&>�4� !5�.!5&>�F��� ������&>D �"�4&>E ��� �4#FC>�.�4�4@5!5#B�N� �"�5&>��CO���5# �4���F�"�5D4&OC>&>!5&>�0� &�-

Page 72: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á ������ °�#²±~³s´3±~)&´3)µ+D4�´G´G³¸+D42+.-0/213)&#04 #0³�%(-0'*³s´G4526!7�8G:<7\83AC7@A HI6G7N7N:gHI6kHIR>jG=NAPJM6�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6�J>ACJ ` =yf6�7\:¹HI=\S[?B=NJ>jG=NAPJ>6�deEc:¹:PSFSB=@ACO&=�6�EF6GhCAP7N6P¦q=N7�8G:<7\83AC7@A f683AKSU?F=r?FR>=@?BAiS[AC7@AiH>:&EF6GhCAP7N67N6s_KRM:<7N=$83ACJMS[6!JK?BAPJMA&HI=$?BEc:PS[deAPEFOQ:PEB6�S[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6�aMJ>=@?B6sHI=$de;���AiHI=$OQ63?c:���de;T�­n798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C�HJI � 8��q�>8�<D?;N�" OD!�§2SB6!_KR>6!J>j!:zQ#e�T!�§2345F�0\p§[Z[!X5+\p§j#e!$�"!����X��\p§U��5�^�*Gt���p �T34\�5+.i§�^�*��"5�T!Z§2�%#cV%�X#%!�Yk§JQ#���#%\�\º§S5+3C8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6U��#%3+3@§S�W#1V%�X#W!TYk§�t��D#�§�34\�,-#>^�*2^W�",0.Q§"!$�j3 p 5+!X�15�#%./#2��#sr"3 5T:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=��#%3+3@§2�W#1V%�X#W!TYk§�t���p 5+!&�05�#%.h#���#sr�345£§�!A\s#c«1#1��#%!X\�5"*o�eQ��#0�1�%#%,-# ���X��\m��# 5+!�#W�1�%�2!$�"!l«1��!X\p§�!o��!��# 3 p ��,-�"5+!$#���#%3+3i#^�*Af¢!��#S3i#j#%��#W!A\��M§"345,05 *&#%\�5iYW5��"!X5�t

½(6GEu=NJMHI=\8G:PEB6�7N6�SB6!_KR>6!J>jG6�RMSB6GEF6GOQAiSF83EF=r?B?BR>EF6�HI6G7{?F=@;ZAM¦ ` �%aba%a!�- d

=NJ08GR>=� f6�=N7£83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!JK?B6�6��`¾�ba%abaG�-�d SBAPJ>A&hP7N=£:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=Yn¡VSB6GOQ;>=$H>=£S[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6�S[ACJ>AM¦�(�s���b�B�u���W�c��Z� ����������������u�0�¾�­�1�^�u��������<� �y���� ������

�WACJ>AQ6!SFS[6!J>jG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6�7\:&S[?B6kSBSF:QS[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:>¦�����W������� �Z����������W������� �Z����������W�������W�Y����� �Z����������W�������W�Y�����W�Y�����W������� �Z�����

� ���� ������������������� �"!$#%��!$�����&���'���(#)��� ��*�+�,(��-��.-�#0/�*���#%�(�¿$6(,c#�r���3�#�83ACJMS[6!JK?BAPJMA�HI=9SB8GEB= ` 6!EB6QHI6G7N7N6,S[6k_CRM6GJ>j!6&6,H>=mA<?B?B6GJM6GEFJ>6iHI6G7N7@6iJWR>A ` 6y;T:<EB?B6GJTHIADH>:DS[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6hP=pf:QA<?B?B6!JKR>?B6Pn2½V=[fRD;MEB6k83=\SB:PO&6!JK?B6�R>JM:�,-#sr;�"3@§0§hY�#%,-�2*$,-#%.h#W�1�%#�8GAPJMSB6GJK?B6yHI= SF83EF= ` 6GEF6�HI=@EF63?B?F:PO&6!JK?B6sR>JT:SB6!_KR>6GJMj!:2HI=KR>J�8G6GEB?BA~?F=@;ZAM]¾R>JT:�,-#sr���3@§�§;���T!Z§�*$,c#W./#0�1�G§b]<HM:b?F:2R>JM:�SB6!_KR>6!J>j!:~H>=CR>Jy836GEB?BA2?B=N;TAT]<83APJTS[6!JC?F6HI=^SB8GEB= ` 6!EBJ>6�R>J£X :P7r?FEF:,:CH�6!SFSB:i8GAP7N7@6!hC:b?c:>]>RMJM:(,-#sr���3@§0§9���X#u*$,-#%./#0�1�%#3]�H>:<?B6�HIRM6�S[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6�83ACJMSB6GJK?B6sHI=SF83EF= ` 6GEFJ>6QR>JM:0?F6GEFj!:>]^6l8GACSpf � ` =N:Mn0½(6!Es6GJWR>JT83=\:<EF6i7@6,EF6GhCAP7N6,83=vS[6!E ` =NEB6!O&ADHI6!7@7\:0deACEBOi:DSF8cw>6GOi:b?F=N8!:0hP=pf:=NO&;M=@6!hC:b?c:&=@JD;>EF6!8G6!HI6!J>j!:M¦*7@6sSB6!_KR>6!J>jG6s8cwM6d�:PJ>J>A,H>:Q;MEB6!O&6kSBSB6 ` 6!J>hPACJ>AiS[6!;M:<Ec:b?F6OQ6!H>=N:PJC?F6�R>JM:QEF=@hK:APEF=NjGjGACJK?F:<7N6�H>:<7N7N:QSB6!_KR>6!J>j!:&8cw>6&f6�7N:Q8GAPJM8G7@RMSB=NAPJ>6�HI6!7@7\:&EB6!hPAP7\:&SU?F6!SFSB:Mn(¿£6�EB6!hPAP7N6�S[ACJ>AQA<?[?FAMnH$C21�8��A@$|�N�y>=6N&���b�><D?;=�@$<D84365��87��Y:QjG6GEFA&;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦*½(6GE~AChPJ>=�de;(�SB={;>R fA,SF83EF= ` 6GEF6�7\:iS[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:>¦

EGC21�8��A@$|�N�y>=6=�<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8(yD8�|�|�N;:;@A<>�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8(<>8�|�:;@A<>�b8��$�D8�<$9�843=<G�070��:iHIRM6�;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦ ` �%a%abaG�c d � ` �%aba%aG�c�?> �

�`b�%aba%aG�cedy�-�2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� > ¹�9���SB6lS[=vS[ACJ>A.hC=ºf:DSF83EF=r?B?B6�HIR>6lSB6!_KR>6!J>jG6l_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=Y](S[=9;>R fA�SB8GEB= ` 6!EB6Q7\:.S[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:.8cw>6,wT:.83ACO&6l=@JT�S[=N6GOQ6iHI6GhC7@=m:PJK?B6!8G6!HI6!JK?B=*7�X R>JM=@ACJ>6iHI6GhC7@=*=NJMSB=@6!O&=mH>6GhP7N=m:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=mHI6G7N7@6,H>R>6iS[6k_CRM6GJ>j!6P]$6,8GAPOQ683APJTS[6!hPR>6!JC?F67\:Q83ACJ>hP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G=$8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B=��­n

��C21�8��A@$|�N�y>=68�|�=��l=�<>N&?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N@:�@$<D�$=��><>?�=�@$<>8(<D8�|�:�@$<D��8��A�>8�<$9b8A34���07���:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:C�3¦�`¾�ba%abaG�-�d ¹����`¾�ba%abaG�-�d

�`<�%aba%a3�ced ¹�9��`¾�ba%a%a!�-�d �

Page 73: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á |��SB6lS[=�f6,hC=ºf:�SB8GEB=@?[?c:DR>JM:�S[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:D=@7u83RM=v8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6Df6,R>JM:�83APJMhP=NR>J>jG=NAPJM6P](S[=v;>R fA�SF83EF= ` 6GEF6i7\:S[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:y8GAPJ0SU?F6!SFS[=£:PJK?B6!8G6!HI6!JK?B={6�83ACJ08GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?F6R>JMAQH>6G=£HIRM6s83APJMhP=NR>JK?B=��­n

BDC21�8��A@$|�N�y>=6=�<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8(yD8�|�|�N�y>=����$=��><D?;=�@$<D8_<>8�|�:�@$<>�b8��$�D8�<$9b8436<G�070��:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:C�3¦ ` �ba%abaG�- d

�`¾�ba%abaG�-�d ¹��� ` �%aba%a3�c d

�`<�%aba%a3�ced � �9��SB6�S[=£f6~hP=pf:�SF83EF=r?B?F:�R>JT:sS[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:�_KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=�]CSB=M;>R fAySB8GEB= ` 6!EB6~7\:�S[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:s83ACJ,SU?F6!SFS[=T:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B=T683APJ083ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJK?B6�R>JM:iHI=\SBhP=NR>J>jG=NAPJM6�H>=$83R>=$RMJ0H>=NSBhP=NR>JK?BA0f6�=N7$83APJTS[6!hPR>6!JC?F6�HI6G7N7N:QSB6!_KR>6!J>j!:QH>:<?F:C�3n

�GC21�8��A@$|�N�y>=68�|�=��l=�<>N&?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N�yD=��b�$=��><>?�=�@$<>89y>N&| :�@$<>�b8��$�D8�<$9b8434���070��:y?FEB6�;>EF6GOQ6kSBSB6k�3¦�`b�ba%aba3�-�d ¹�9��2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > �- �� ` �%aba%a3�1� � �-� �

�`b�%a%abaG�cedy�-�2`¾�%aba%a!�-� > �1�6`b�%aba%aG�1� � �

��SB6�SB=$SBAPJ>AQhP=pf:&SB8GEB=@?[?F6�?BEF6�SB6!_KR>6!J>jG6�HI=$8GR>=$R>JT:ywT:i83APOQ6�83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJK?B6�R>JM:QHI=\S[hC=@RMJ>jG=NAPJ>62¢�9�,]:<7@?BEF6QH>R>6iwM:<JMJ>A.SU?F6!SFS[AD8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6]� 6Q?BEc:�hP7N=V:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=mR>JM:0wM:( 6i7YX :<7@?BEc:_�,](:<7N7@ACEF:�S[=;>R fA.SF83EF= ` 6GEF6y7\:DS[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:0HI=98GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6]� 6l: ` 6!JK?B6i83ACO&6i:PJC?F6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=*?BR>?[?B=u_KR>6G7N7N=VHI6G7N7N6Q?BEF6S[6k_CRM6GJ>j!6�hC=ºf:&SF83EF=r?B?B6P]T83APJ�7�X 6kSB8G7@RMSB=NAPJ>6�HI=�¤62�&�­n�C21�8��A@$|�N�y>=6=�<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8(yD8�|�:�@$<Dy>=�?;=�@$<DNX|�8(<>8�|�:�@$<>�b8��$�D8�<$9b8436<!� 7��Y:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB:K�­¦

�`b�ba%a%aG�-ed&�c � ` �%aba%a3�c d ���

��SB6,S[=�f6,SB8GEB=@?[?c:0R>JM:.SB6!_KR>6!J>j!:D_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=Y]^S[=9;>R fA�SF83EF= ` 6GEF6Q7N:DSB6!_KR>6!J>j!:0=N798GR>=98GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6Df6iR>J83APJTHI=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6~=N7Z8GR>=Z:PJK?B6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6�f62RMJ>AyHI6!hP7N=T:PJC?F6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=T6�=@7�83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!JK?B6�f62=N7�83APJTS[6!hPR>6!JC?F62HI6G7N7\:S[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:�hC=ºf:QSF83EF=r?B?F:C�3n�GC21�8��A@$|�N�y>=68�|�=��l=�<>N&?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�:;@A<>yD=�?�=�@A<>N&|�8(<>8�| :�@$<D��8��A�>8�<$9b843 ��� 7���:iH>R>6�;>EF6GOQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦

�`b�ba%aba3�-�d � ��2`¾�ba%abaG�-� >

�`b�ba%aba3�-�d��c��`<�%aba%a3�c� > �

�Uf6�7N:QEF6GhCAP7\:�8GAPEFEB=\S[;Z63?B?B= ` :&H>6G7����������� ��!o#W!X�[�­n� C21�8��A@$|�N�y>8�|�|�N�<>8��$N&?;=�@$<D8 :;|�N&����= :�N 34��� 70��:QHIRM6�;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦

�`b�ba%aba3�-�dy�1�� ��2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > �c�� ���

�`b�%aba%aG�cedy�-�2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� >

��SB6QSB=mSBAPJ>ADSF83EF=r?B?B6iHIR>6iSB6!_KR>6GJMjG6i: ` 6!JC?F=m83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!JK?B=(R>J>A07\:�JM6GhC:PjG=NAPJ>6QHI6!7@7�X :P7r?FEBA06i: ` 6!JK?B=(6GJT�?BEc:<O�LZ6���»?FEF:�hP7N=9:PJK?B6!8G6!HI6!JK?B=�] :<7N7NAPEc:�SB=m;>R^fA.SB8GEB= ` 6!EB6Q7\:DS[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:�: ` 6GJK?B6,8GAPOQ6,:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=_CRM6G7N7@=mHI6!7@7N6,SB6!_KR>6GJMjG6QhP=pf:�SF83EF=@?[?B6i8GAPJ�7YX 6!SF837NRMSB=@ACJ>6iHI=¢��»6i: ` 6!JC?F=m83ACO&6i8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6hsni¡9SBSF:deAPEFOQ:P7@=NjGjk:�=N7~Ec:<hP=NAPJT:<OQ6GJK?BA �[;Z6GE,:CSBSBR>EcHIAC�M¦�SB6D:PSFS[R>OQ6!JMHIAJ���83ACO&60=N;TAP?B6kS[=2SB=2A<?B?B=N6GJ>60R>JT:83APJK?FEF:CH>HI=NjG=NAPJ>6C]W:P7@7NAPEc:�SB=mf6�HI=NOQACS[?BEc:b?c:j��­n�(@ 9bN/{[8�<>8Z¦��RM:<JTHIA�SB=I:<;>;M7@=\8G:R>JM:EB6!hPAC7N::HIRM6vA?BEF6v;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6vJ>APJ&83ACJC?c:�7�X APEcHI=@JM6v8GAPJy8GR>=WaMhCR>EF:PJ>A7N6�;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6Cn

Page 74: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á �798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���CFEvIK798;L�=�M&N&?�=�@A<>8�"��$5D��5�«1#uHI6!EB= ` :<j!=@ACJ>6��T!Z§S345F�0\p§[Z[!X5+\p§j�"5G�%#1VW�X#%!�Y�#���\�\s#%!X�T\p§�§1*�*$3 5+g«c§�!o����3i#j�"\�\m�h,-#sr���3i#u*o,-#c«c#1�;#W!A\�5�t¿£:,;>EB=NOi:lSB6!_KR>6!J>j!:,H>=^RMJM:lHI6!EB= ` :<j!=@ACJ>6,f6�SB6GOQ;>EF6ySF83EF=@?[?F:,=@J�LM:PSB6�:<7N7\:,EF6GhPAC7N:iH>=(:CSBSBR>J>j!=@ACJ>6�� x�S���©7\:&SB6!8GAPJMHM:lf6�SF83EF=r?B?F:&AQJWR>A ` :<OQ6GJK?B6�=NJ0LM:PSB6�:PH�� xS��£AC;>;>R>EF6�:<;>;M7@=\8G:PJMHIAQR>JM:&EF6GhPAC7N:&:PH�R>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF::<7N7�X R>JM=N8!:,S[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:ihP=pf:lSF83EF=@?[?F:M©T7\:i?F6GEFj!:,SB6!_KR>6!J>j!:0f6ySF83EF=r?B?F:i=NJ.LM:CS[6�:CH�� x�S���]�AP;M;>R>EF6�:<;>;M7@=\8G:PJMHIA,R>JT:EF6GhPAC7N:D:CHqR>JM:�;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB:�:PHqR>JT:�HI6!7@7N6�;MEB=NOQ6�HIR>6�S[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6P]*AC;>;>R>EF6l:<;M;>7@=\8G:PJMHIA�R>JM:.EF6GhCAP7\:D:�HIRM6;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB6�:P7@7N6�HIR>6sSB6!_KR>6GJMjG6�hP=pf:&SF83EF=@?[?B6C]I6�83ACSpf � ` =N:M©>83=\:PSF83R>JT:ySB6!_KR>6!J>j!:lf6�SB8GEB=@?[?c:y=NJ�LM:PSB6�:PH�R>JM:QHI6G7N7N6EF6GhPAC7@6C]I:<;>;>7N=\8G:<JTHIAP7\:y:iSB6!_KR>6!J>jG6�hC=ºf:&SB8GEB=@?[?F6s8cw>6�J>6s83AKSU?F=r?FR>=\SB8GAPJ>A&7@6�;MEB6!O&6kSBSB6Pn

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C���I � 8��q�>8�<D?;N�yD8�L�=�M&NT{�=�|�8�"¤OD!�§�S[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:h�`<�%a%aba3�-�d ��05�"5�«1#2HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@6�f#�05��G«W,05+��#

���`b�%aba%aG�ced �%#�#W�c�G§�Q#�3-p �T34\�5+.i§U�%#1VW�X#%!�Yk§h��5��T!�§U�;#W,05+�b§bY%5��"!$#�t��0!_\p§�3$«c§k�%�U�05��"5�«1#�§�!�«cnX#s«1n&#u �;#W,05+�b§]�C§�3+3i#S5 *&�"\s#W�05�`<�%aba%a3�cedht

�*6!H>=N:PO&A�HIR>6ySB6GOQ;>7N=\83=^6!SB6GOQ;>=(HI=^H>6GEF= ` :<j!=@ACJ>=�n f¡ AC;>;TACE[?FR>J>A,JWR>OQ6!EF:PEB6�7N6ySB6!_KR>6!J>jG6�H>6G7N7N:�HI6GEF= ` :"�jG=NAPJM66�SB8GEB= ` 6!EB6�:P8!8G:<JK?FAy:&83=\:PSF83R>JM:yHI={6!SFSB67\:�EF6G7\:b?F= ` :�hP=NRMSU?F=raZ8G:<j!=@ACJ>6P]WAKSBSB=N:�=@J�LM:CS[6�:y_KRM:P7@6�EF6GhPAC7N:if6S[?F:b?c:QSB8GEB=@?[?c:���6s_KRM:<7N=$S[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6�;>EB6k836kHI6GJK?B=$SBAPJMAQ:CHIAP;Z6GEc:b?F6�8GAPOQ6�;>EF6GOQ6!SFS[6¾�­n�U}¾� � � � x�S�����C� ����� ����� � x�S����|K� �£�Y����� � � ¡v���V�U}¾�­]\���C����W� � � �����<�m��� � oB���V��|C����C� �����[� �����<�V���<� � oB���V���K�

�R>=NJMHI=�¦¢� �����[�r�����<�m���<�3n�U}¾� ����� ����� � x�S�����C� ����� � � ¡9� �V�U}¾���|K� ����� � � ¡9� �V�U}¾����W� ����� �u�y� � o[� �9���C�­]\��|C�

�R>=NJMHI=�¦¢�i����� �v�y�£n� ���� � �������(��� ��,�� ,�-�#��?,���,2����� � ,�� # +�,(��- ,½(6GE�;ZA<?F6GE�S ` =@7NR>;>;T:<EF6&;M=[fR¢:PhP6 ` AP7NOQ6GJK?B6&7@6,H>6GEF= ` :<j!=@ACJ>=~f6iAC;>;TACE[?FR>J>A0=NJC?FEBAIHIRMEBEF6QR>J¢836!E[?FA�JWR>OQ6!EBA.HI=:<7@?BEF6,EF6GhCAP7N6P] H>63?[?F6 #%345+.U5+!Z§Pª%5+3459=@J¢_KRM:PJC?FA.7\:07@ACEBA.:P;>;>7N=N8!:<jG=NAPJM6,S[=9;>R fA�hC=@RTSU?F=raT8!:<EF6i=@JqLT:PSB6l:<7N7@6iAP?[?FAEF6GhPAC7@6QH>:<?B6Pn�x2;>;>7N=\8G:<EF6iR>JM:�EF6GhCAP7\:l6!7@=NOQ=@JM:PL>=N7@6i=NJqR>JM:0HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM6QSB=NhPJ>=@aT8G:0SF83EF= ` 6GEF6yRMJM:DS[6k_KR>6GJ>jk::<7N7\:y_KRM:P7@6�SB=$SB:PEB6!L>LT6�;Z6GE ` 6!JKR>?B={83ACJ�7N6�A<?[?FAQEB6!hPAP7N6�H>:b?F6�OQ6kHI=N:PJK?B6�=@7{;MEBAI836kHI=NO&6!JK?BAi8cw>6�83AKSU?F=r?FR>=NSF836�7\:hP=NRMS[?B=@aT8G:PjG=NAPJ>6sH>6G7N7YX 6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<LM=@7N=r?bf:,HI6!7@7\:iEF6GhPAC7N:iS[?B6kSBSF:>n �R>=NJMHI=�]T7�X :<;>;>7N=\8G:<j!=@ACJ>6sHI6!7@7N6sEF6GhPAC7@6�6!7@=NOQ=@JT:<L>=N7@=83ACJMSB6GJK?B6DHI=2HI6!EB= ` :<EF6�RMJM:�S[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:�8GAPJ R>J JKRMO&6!EBA�HI=2;T:PSFSB:PhPhP=v=NJIde6GEF=@ACEB6�EF=NSB;T6G?[?FA�:�_KR>6!7@7NAq8cw>6�f6EF=N8cw>=N6!S[?BA0SB6QSB=*EF=N8GAPEFEB6QS[AC7r?c:<JK?BA0:<7N7N6&AP?[?FA�EF6GhCAP7N6�=NJ>=NjG=\:<7N=Y] 6Q8G=ºfA�d�:C83=N7@=@?F:�J>AP?B6 ` AP7NOQ6GJK?B6&7N:�EF=N8G6GEc8G:�HI6G7N7N6HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM={;T6!E~A<?[?F6GJ>6!EB6�R>JT:iH>:b?c:&SB6!_KR>6!J>j!:MnH$C21�8��A@$|�N�y>=�L�N��[@ALk?;N&��8�<$9b@�y>8�|�|�N�xDL�8���8����bNA361]x07��Y:&R>JM:Q;>EF6GOQ6!SFSF:C�­¦

�`<�%a%aba3�-�d ` �ba%a%aG�- d �c�

��:<7N7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6�HI6GhC7@=u:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=9HI=uR>JM:�S[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:DhP=pf:.AP?[?F6GJWRI?F:�S[=v;>R fA�S[6!OQ;>EB6�:<hPhC=@RMJ>hP6!EB6iR>JT:_CRT:<7\S[=\:PSB=Zde;_�&���Cn��� � D4&>?����B��� � � � C>���5� &>�0� &�!$# ��E,�5�F#B��D4&<� �5#B��C>&>D & ��� #F�5� #F&>E,& !5&>?��F# ��� �4&>C>&O!$&O�0�4# !5&>�F�F&A� &>K @5&>�5L>&�&"!�K @5#F�5!5##!9!5# �����4&>D

���5�5�F#FCO��D4& �F&<D &>?����F&$� ,&% �'!�� (*)$� &+� ��,-� ���$C/.5&AK @J���5!$�7�5&>?��F# ��� �4&>C>&O!$&O�0�4# !5&>�F�F& �4&>KI@5&>�5L>&�C0.5&21 ���5�5� !J� �5D &>E,&>� � ���5���C>��E,�J��D & �B�31 �<&>� �5�F#FC># � �N�M�$-

Page 75: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á �¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ����P� � � � xS���Y|C� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c� ¹�9� � o[� �u�U}¾�­]\���P����K� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c� � ¡v� �9��|K�

EGC21�8��A@$|�N�y>= :�@$<':;N 9b8�<>N&?�=�@A<>8A3 � <'70��:QHIR>6�;>EF6GOQ6kSBSB6k�3¦�`b�ba%aba3�-�d �2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > �- �

` �ba%aba3�- d �c� ` �%aba%a3�c�?> �

��SB6� HI6GEF= ` :iHM:i836GEB?B6�de;� ` �ba%abaG�- d ]T6sH>:/�6�:P7r?FEB6�de;�� ` �ba%abaG�-�2>iHI6!EB= ` :/�,]Z:<7N7@ACEF:h� HI6!EB= ` :H>:<7N7YX =NJMS[=N6GOQ6�HI={de;( ` �ba%a%aG�- d �-� ` �%a%aba3�-�2>K�­n¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ����P� � ` �%a%abaG�c�?>M�- � � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ��Y|C� � ` �%a%abaG�c�?> � � � oB���V���C����K� ` �%a%aba3�- d �c� ` �%aba%a3�c�?> � � ¡u� �V�[}k�3]N�Y|C�

��C21�8��A@$|�N�=�<$9b�>=�?;=�@$<D=�� 9�N��%y>=¢<>8��ANX?�=�@$<>8434��= 70��:QHIRM6�;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦�`b�ba%aba3�-�d �2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > ��

�`b�ba%aba3�-�d��c��`<�%aba%a3�c� > �

��SB6�H>:l8G6GEB?B6�de;�HI6GEF= ` :] 6yH>:l:<7@?BEF6�HI6GEF= ` :���s]{H>:Q?FRI?[?F6y7N6sde;�H>6GEF= ` :iR>JT:Qde;�� _KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=Y© f6�7\:deAPEFOQ:l83APJ�83R>=*SB= 6!JKRMJM83=\:,J>6!7*8G:<7\83AC7@A�HI6G7N7N:�HI6!H>R>jG=NAPJ>6&JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6s7\:,7N6GhPhC6yHI=��I8GA<?FA¹��#��D§PªW�0�T,-����W#1V%�T5+\��T,2V%�X�b��3 5�ªc#%\\�C�­n¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� ` �%a%aba3�- d � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ����P� � ` �%a%abaG�c�?> �� � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ��Y|C� ` �%a%aba3�- d �1��� � �2;��9�U}¾����K� ��`b�%a%abaG�c� > �c��� �� � �2;��9���C����P� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c��`<�%aba%a3�c� > � � ��� �V�Y|C�­]\���W�

BDC21�8��A@$|�N :;|�N&����= :�N y>=�y>@AxDx�=�N�<D8��$N&?�=�@A<>843 79< 70��:QRMJM:&;>EB6!OQ6!SFSB:K�­¦ ` �ba%abaG�- d ����`<�%a%aba3�-�d

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d ��� � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB: ����P� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1�� ��� � �~;��9�[}k��Y|C� �� �� � x�S�����K� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d � ��� �9���C�­]\��|C�

�GC21�8��A@$|�N��l=�<>=���N&|�8-y>=6<D8��$N&?�=�@A<>8434��� 7���:QHIR>6�;MEB6!O&6kSBSB6k�3¦� � ��!5&>�5��E,#F�J��L>#F���5&<!5#�K @5&>�4� � D4&>?����B� !$&OD4# H���!J���&1 �N��� � C/.5&"!*� & � #��4���4�4# � @$#F� C>& �B��D4&>?����B� � � ,-��C>��� �B��D &>?����B� � �%# �#!9�4#

����� #F&>�5& �B�.�F��?�#FCO�.#F�0� @$#FLO#F���$#F�4� �$-

Page 76: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

ÁbÀ ` �ba%aba3�- d �c �� ` �ba%abaG�-�2>M�- ���

` �ba%a%a!�- d �c� ` �%a%abaG�c�?> ��

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� ` �%a%aba3�- d �c � � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ����P� � ` �%a%abaG�c�?>M�- ��� � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ��Y|C� ��� ��� � xS�����K� ��� � �J��9�Y|C����P� ` �%a%aba3�- d �1��� � � �9J �9�U}¾�­]\���K�� À � � ` �%a%abaG�c�?>M�c��� ��� � �9J �9���C�­]\���K�� Á � �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c��`<�%aba%a3�c� > �� � ��� �9���P�3]N� À �

�C21�8��A@$|�N�=�<$9b�>=�?;=�@$<D=�� 9�N�y>=�y>@AxDx�=�N�<D8��$N&?�=�@A<>843 79<'< 7��Y:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB:K�­¦ ` �%a%aba3�- d �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d ���

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� ` �%a%aba3�- d � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB: ����P� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1�� � �~;��9�[}k��Y|C� �� �� � x�S�����K� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d ��� � �^O$�9���C�­]\��|C�

�GC21�8��A@$|�N�y>=6N&�'9b@$��@$<>yDN&?;=�@$<D8 3=5��870��:&R>JM:Q;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:C�3¦ ` �ba%a%aG�- d �c�� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1�� � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB: ����P� �� �� � x�S���Y|C� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d � ��� �9�U}¾�­]\���P�opJ�OQAIHIA,:<JT:<7NAPhPA&S[=£hP=NRMSU?F=raZ8G:yd�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6�7\:>¦

� C21�8��A@$|�N�y>=6N&�'9b@�:;@A<$9bLkNXyDy>=�?;=�@$<D8A365 : 7��Y:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB:K�­¦ ` �ba%a%aG�- d �- ���`¾�%aba%a!�-ed ��

� C21�8��A@$|�8_y>=�:;@A<$9bLkN&xDx[@$��=�?�=�@A<>843 � x07��Y:&R>JM:Q;>EF6GOQ6!SFSF:C�­¦

��:C� �`b�ba%aba3�-�d��c � ` �ba%a%a!�- d �1��� ��

�eLZ� �`<�%aba%a3�ced&�- ��� ` �%aba%a3�c d �-� ��

�Y8!� �`¾�ba%a%a!�-�d��1�� � ` �ba%a%a!�- d �1���

��HT� �`<�%aba%a3�ced&�c�� ��� ` �%aba%aG�c d �-�

���I& � #�� ���4�4# �4@5#F� C>& � ��, �2CO���+� �3E � !5�4#2����� #F&>�5& �B� �F��?�#FCO�.E,#F�$#FE ���F&0-��I#��5@ �"!5#FE,���4�4DM��D4& C/.$& CO���$� � ,-�2�4#2�5@ �"?�#F@5�4�4# �JCO��D &� �%# ��& C>��� � �%# ��� #2�5@� �"?�#F@5��� # �5C ��D4&�� �3E � !JE � �5��� H$#FC>&GH0&>D �M� !���&>D CO@$#��B�.�F��?�#FCO�.#F�0� @5#FL>#F���5#F���M� & �5# @ !5& �����F&�� �5&>���4&O�$� �,C/.5&#F��&>� � �,� ���5�<!5&>D # H����5#F�F#%E,&>�5�,� &>K @5&>�5L>& !$&O�F�B�,�F��?�#FCO�,�5D �������4#FLO#F���5���F& C>�B��� �4#FCO� !�&(�B�,�F��?�#FCO� E,#F�$#FE ���F& & �$# @�!5& �����F&.!5&>�F�B��F��?�#FCO�.#F�0� @5#FL>#F���5#F���M�$-

Page 77: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

ÁCÁ¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6�H>=V��:K�­¦�[}k� ` �%a%aba3�- d �c � � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB: ����P� ��� ��� � x�S���Y|C� s�c��� ��� � �~;��9���P����K� ` �%a%aba3�- d �1��� �� � �^O$�9�U}¾�­]\��|C�¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6�H>=V��8k�­¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1�� � � ;>EB6!OQ6!SFSB: ����P� ��� ��� � x�S���Y|C� ��s�c��� ��� � �~;��9���P����K� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1��� � ��� �v�U}k�3]N�Y|C�

H��GC21�8��$@A|�N�y>=¢8���N&�D�89b=�@A<>843 ���87���:QHIRM6�;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦ ` �ba%aba3�- d �c ��2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > �c�� �

` �ba%aba3�- d �c� ` �%aba%a3�c�?> �¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� ` �%a%aba3�- d �c � � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ����P� ��`b�%a%abaG�c� > �c�� � � ;MEB6!O&6kSBSF: ��Y|C� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1��� �� � �9; �º�[}k����K� ��`b�%a%abaG�c� > �c��� ��� � �9; �º���P����P� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c��`<�%aba%a3�c� > � � ��� �V�Y|C�­]\���W�

H$HAC21�8��$@A|�N�y>=¢8�|�=���=�<>N&?;=�@$<D89yD8�|�|�N;:;@A<>�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8(<>8�|�|���N&<$9b8 :;8�y>8�<$9b843r����70��:�RMJM:s;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:C�3¦ ` �ba%abaG�- d �c¢�9� ��`<�%aba%a3�ced&�-��-� �

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c¹�9� � � ;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF: ����P� � xS���Y|C� � � � xS�����K� s�-� ¹�9� � o[� �9���P�3]N�Y|C����P� ` �%a%aba3�- d �cs�c� � � �9J��V�[}k�3]N���K�

H&EqC21�8��$@A|�N�y>=¢=�<$9%L�@Gy>�D?;=�@$<D8�y>8�|�|�N;:�@$<>�A=��D<>?�=�@A<>8(<D8�|�|��iNX<$9b8 :�8�y>8�<$9�843 � < 70��:&R>JT:Q;>EB6!OQ6!SFSB:K�­¦�`<�%aba%a3�ced&�-��-� � ` �ba%abaG�- d �c¢�9� �

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� ` �%a%aba3�- d �cs�c� � � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSF: ����P� ¹�9� ¹�9� � x�S���Y|C� ¹�9� � ¡9� �V���P����K� ¹�9� � � ¡9� �V���P����P� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c¹�9�,�c� � � �9J��9�[}k�3]N�Y|C�� À � �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��c¹�9� � � �9J��9���K�3]N���P�

� ���b8�LkM&N&?�=�@A<>8Zn�¼D6kHI=N:PJK?B6Q7@6QEF6GhCAP7N6 � �(¡ �m6 � �^o/�º]$RI?F=@7N=NjGj!:PJMHIAD:<JT8cw>6y7N6&EB6!hPAP7N6 � ¡u� �*6 � oB���º]£S[=HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:�d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6 `�� 7\:QS[6!hPR>6!JC?F6�6!_KR>= ` :P7@6!J>j!:M¦��� (�� 1�N���4#

Page 78: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á��

���`<�- � �%aba%a!�-ed � ����`*�9 � ��aba%a!�9ed � ACSFS[=\:]3@§���#%,05+�¾§CªW5+3 5+\�Q§_��5��T!�§U�%#cV%�X#%!�Yk§'Q#S#1V%�T5+�¾§"3i#%!X\m#y§"3+3@§��;#W,05+�b§Pª%5+345+\TQ§9�;#W3+3-p �T!X5�«c§e^�*¢«1��!$�"5iY%5���!Z§"3i#«cnX#6nM§y«1�".h#�§�!A\s#c«1#1��#%!X\m#u3N§y«1��!�r"5+�T!TY%5���!$#��;#�r�345(§�!X\m#c«1#c�;#W!A\�5��;#W3+3N§��%#1V%�X#W!TY!§j#�«c�".h#�«1��!X�%#�r��X#%!X\m#5+3v«1��!X�W#sr��X#W!A\s#9��#%3+3@§��%#1VW�X#%!�Yk§<n �R>6!S[?BA.EF=\S[R>7@?F:<?BAqf6l=@OQ;ZAPEB?F:<JK?F6,;TAC=N8cwu®6i=@7N7NRMSU?FEF:.7N:.SBACS[?F:PJ>jG=\:<7N66!_KR>= ` :P7@6!J>j!:�?FEF:�=�8G:P7N8GAP7N=M:PSFSB=@ACOQ:<?B=\83=>6_CRM6G7N7@=ZHI6G7N7N:�HI6!HIRMjG=NAPJ>62JT:b?BRMEF:P7@6Cn �6GEF= ` :PEB6~R>JT:sS[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:6!_KR>= ` :P7@6�:QHI6!EB= ` :<EF6R>J£X R>JM=N8!:&de;��Y83ACO&6�JM6G=$8G:P7N8GAP7N=$:PSFS[=NAPOi:<?B=\83=��­n

HT�GC21�8��$@A|�N�y>=¢=�<$9%L�@Gy>�D?;=�@$<D8�y>8�|�:;@A<>y>=�?�=�@A<>N&|�8(<D8�|�| �iN&<$9�8 :�8�yD8�<$9�843r�4< 7��Y:QHIR>6�;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB6k�­¦�`b�ba%aba3�-�dy�1�� �� ` �ba%abaG�-�2>M�-� �

�`<�%aba%a3�ced&�-�2`¾�ba%aba3�-� > �c ��� �

¬�=@RMS[?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6P¦�[}k� �`<�%a%aba3�-�d��1�� � � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSF: ����P� � ` �%a%abaG�c�?>M�-� � � ;>EF6GOQ6!SFSF: ��Y|C� � x�S�����K� � � � � � x�S�����P� s�- � � � � ¡v���V��|K�­]\���W�� À � � ` �%a%abaG�c�?>M�-��- � � � � �9J��9���P�3]N���P�� Á � ` �%a%aba3�- d �c� ` �%aba%a3�c�?>M�- ��� � � ¡VS��V�U}¾�­]\� À �

��� � ��� , ��,"����� ,�� #0+�,���-�,

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC�H � ���_�Z��U}¾� � � � xS�����C� � ���_�Z� � o[� �p�U}¾���|K� �Z� �Z� � xS�����W� �Z� ���_�Z� � o[� �p��|K����C� ���_�Z� � ¡9S��V���P�­]\���W�

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC+E � �u� ���_�Z�Z��U}¾� ���_�Z� ���_�Z� � x�S�����C� ���_�Z� � � ¡9� �V�[}k���|K� ���_�Z� �Z� � ¡9� �V�[}k����W� �u�r�y���Z��� � �^O$�9���C�­]\��|K�

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GCF� �i����� �Z�y����U}¾� �Z� �Z� � x�S�����C� �Z� �Z����� � o[� �9�U}¾���|K� � � � x�S�����W� � �Z����� � o[� �9��|K����C� ����� �Z����� � �qo/�V���P�­]\���W�

� �� � � ��� �� � ����� � ��� � !J���5�5�F#FCO���5!5�,D4#F��&G�4@$� ��E,&O�0�4&2� ��(#�#!J�4#����4�4#F&>�5&� � � � �� �� ����� �<��� ��!J�"C>@5#��B��4&O�4#���&>D � (*)$��-� �� �� � � �<�� �� ����� � ��� � � � �� �� ����� � ��� � � ��� ! ���5�5�F#FCO���5!5� D #F��&G� @$� ��E,&>� �4& � ��� � � # .J� �

� ��� �� � ����� � � � � � �<�� �� ����� � � ���!J���F��� #F����� &>�4#� � � � � � ����� � � � ) � !5��&>D � � )$�#!5�4&>?�@5& �B�(�4&O�4#-

Page 79: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

Á�����b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC�B ���Z����� �����

�U}¾� � � � xS�����C� � � � xS����|K� �W��� � � �~; �9���C����W� � ����� � oB���9��|K����C� �Z� �Z� � xS��� À � �£�1�Z� � � �^= �9�U}¾�­]\���C�� Á � �Z� ����� � oB���9� À �� � � �Z�y��� �Z�y��� � xS��� � � �Z�Z� ����� � ¡v� �9���W�­]\� Á �3]N� � ����b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC�� �i����� �u���Z�y�_�(�<�

�U}¾� ����� �y��� � xS�����C� ����� � � ¡v� �V�U}¾���|K� ����� � � ¡v� �V�U}¾����W� �Z�$� � �y���<� � �9; �º���P����C� �(�"� � �y���<� � �9; �º�Y|C�� À � �Z�y�9�(� �Z�y�_�(� � xS��� Á � �Z�y�9�(� �u� �y���<� � ¡v� �V���W�­]\���P�3]N� À �� � � ����� �u���Z�Q���(�<� � �9; �º� Á ����b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC ���u���Z�y�_�(�<� �����

�U}¾� �Z� �Z� � xS�����C� �Z� �Z�y�_�(� � o[� �v�U}k���|K� �u���Z�&�9�(�<� � � �9; �9���C����W� �(� �(� � xS�����C� �(� �Z�y�_�(� � o[� �v���K�� À � �u���Z�&�9�(�<� � � �9; �9���C�� Á � �u���Z�&�9�(�<� �y��� � o[� �v��|C�3]N� À ����b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC�� �¢�r�����<�$��� �����<� �����Y�~�,�<�

�U}¾� ����� �y��� � xS�����C� ����� � � ¡v� �9�U}¾���|K� ����� � � ¡v� �9�U}¾����W� ����� �~��� � o[� �v��|C����C� ����� �y�����~���<� � o[� �v���P�3]N���K�� À � ����� �y�l� � xS��� Á � ����� � � ¡v� �9� À �� � � ����� � � ¡v� �9� À �� � � ����� �~��� � o[� �v� � ��U} � � ����� �y�����~���<� � o[� �v� Á �3]N� � ��U}C}k� �r�����<�$���r�y���<� � �&���<�£���r�y���b� � xS���U}k�P� �r�����<�$���r�y���<� �y�����~���<� � ¡v� �9���C�­]\�U} � �­]\�U}C}k����b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC � �i�����W�1�(� �

�U}¾� � � � x�S�����C� � � � x�S����|K� �(� �(� � x�S�����W� �W�c�(� � � �^= �9���P�3]N�Y|C����C� ����� ����� � x�S��� À � �����W�c�(� � � ¡9� �V�U}¾�­]\���W�­]\���P�

Page 80: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC � �i�����b�Y�����W�[�s��� �~�0��U}¾� �l��� ����� � xS�����C� � � � xS����|K� � ���l��� � � ¡u� �V�[}k�3]N���P����W� � ���l��� �v�0� � o[� �v��|C����C� ����� ����� � xS��� À � � � � xS��� Á � �b�B��� � � � ¡u� �V���P�3]N� À �� � � �b�B��� � �v�0� � o[� �v� Á �� � � ����� ���l� � xS���U} � � �����b�Y�,�¥�W�[����� �v�0� � ¡v� �V���W�­]\� � �3]N� � �

���b8��Jx�=�@�B�CF�GC�H � � ����� �����V���[�� � �y�m���� �����B��U}¾� ����� ����� ����� ����� � x�S�����C� � � ��� � x�S����|K� � x�S�����W� ����� �����­�c � � � � ¡v���9�U}¾�­]\��|K����C� � �l�- � � ¡v���9���C�­]\��|K�� À � ����� �����­�c � �l�- � � ¡v���9���W�­]\���C�� Á � ����� �����­�c � � � � � oB� �v� À �� � � ����� ����� �� ���&�m���� � ��� � oB� �v� Á �� � � ����� �����m�¸�[�� ���y�m���� �����B� � oB� �v� � �

� �� � � ��-�!$� / /�,$�&��/ #0/ ����� ,�! ,����(������� ��� � � ,(� /��#½(6GE�=@7^8G:<7\83AC7@AiHI6!7@7\:,HI6kHIR>j!=@ACJ>6sJM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6sHI=NO&AKSU?FEB=\:<OQAQAPEc:Q=$?F6GACEB6!O&= HI=^8GAPEFEB6G?[?F6GjGjk:&6�HI= 8GAPOQ;>7N63?F6GjGjk:deAPEB?B6Cnm½mEF=@Oi:y;T6!E¾fAiHI6GaMJ>=\:<OQAQEB=NhPACEBAKSB:POQ6GJK?B6=£83ACJM836G?[?B=$8GAP=NJ ` AP7@?B={6�S[?F:PL>=@7N=\:<OQAPJ>6�:P7N8GR>J>={7N6GhC:POQ=Yn798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���CiB'IK��8�y>8;L�=�M&NT{>=�|�8(y>N���Ip�£�� "�" �&§�\m���T!R5+!&�05�#%.h#l�)��5^�*P#��T!Z§h^�*'�fS�05��5�«1#y«cnX#e Q#�HI6GEF= ` :PL>=@7N6�H>:���f#2�15D�G«W,05+��#�� �� ~s!$#%3$«F§"3@«1��3i����#%3+3@§9��#1���;Y%5���!o#2!�§�\��T,B§�3i#K�S�%#j#��%��3i�/�W##W�15F�0\m#��T!9�%��\�\s�"5+!&�05�#W./#�Z[!X5+\m�y���`¾�%aba%a!�-ed�����5�� \º§"3i#s«1n&#����`¾�%aba%a!�-ed �f[�k�1�05�§U�%# Q#���#%,05+�b§Pª%5+3i#�T!Z§h�W#1V%�X#W!TYk§/5+3 «%�T5V«1��!&�%#sr��X#W!A\s#JQ#e #�5V«%�T5V§�!A\s#c«1#1��#%!X\�5��W�"!$��#W3i#%./#W!A\�5[�"5$�vtopJQ;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB6u7\:�de;]�f6~HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@6y��SB6GJ>jk:�=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\�3]P6�SB=MSF83EF= ` 6��(s]WSB6�f62HI6GEF= ` :PL>=N7@6~7\:�S[6k_KR>6GJ>jk:�83A��S[?B=@?BR>=@?F:2HM:u ��SB6GJMj!:~:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=<6V83ACJ2¢83ACO&6983APJTS[6!hPR>6!JC?F6k�3nD�W6m� f6(aMJ>=@?BAT]¾ACSFS[=\:u� ���� ` �ba%a%aG�- d �C]:<JMjG=\8cwv®6y�� ` �%aba%a3�c d �����]MSB8GEB= ` =N:POQAU ` �ba%a%aG�- d ���n¿$6�AP?[?FA,EB6!hPAC7@6�HI6!7 8G:P7N8GAP7NAiH>:<J>JMA,7@RMAPhPAi:CHD:<7@?BEF63?[?c:<JK?B6�;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:iHI6G7^83ACJM836G?[?BA,H>= HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@=@?¾f:iHM:R>J0=NJMS[=N6GOQ6��¢¦

��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NvH �W62����¢]>:<7N7NAPEc:��£���n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NJE �W6��}��¤6 ���,]M:P7@7NAPEc:s���� ��¢���ln��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N��P�W6��}��¢�9�l]M:<7N7@ACEF:y�£��¤6��£���ln��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N B �W6��}���]M:<7N7NAPEc:>]K;T6!E2APhCJ>=G�,]>�£��¹�9� 6��£��� �9sn��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N � �W6��}��¢�9�»6 �.��s����� 6 � �����i�����&]M:<7N7NAPEc:����� ���R���&n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N+P�W6�������������,]M:P7@7NAPEc:y� �� ��� `-` n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N � �W6��}��¤6 �� � �,]T:<7N7@ACEF:y���� ���,n

�G� @5&>�4� �.�5D ���$D #F&G�� �(C>��D D #F�4�����5!5& ����� &>��D4&OE � !5#�!5&>!5@5L>#F���5& ��&>D #�CO���FC>���F#2���4� #F��E �N�4#FCO#�C/.5& ��� �5#B��E,�.&>� @5�5C>#B�N�4�"�5&>�����5- �$-((C ���FC>���F# !5&>�F�B� !5&>!5@5L>#F���5&��5�N� @5D ���F& .J���$�5� �B� �5D4���5D #F&G�� � C0.5&A#F�:�4&>��D &>E � !5# !5&>!5@5L>#F���5& &<� H H$#B� C>���5� &>?�@5&>�5LO�7!$&O�F��� �>H0&>D��!5�����M�N�4� �B�.D &>?����B�(!5#&� (*)$�-

Page 81: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� }��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N � �W6������k��������»6 ���k����������,]Z:<7N7@ACEF:�� �� ��snx27@?BEF6�;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:&83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>APJ>A&:<7N7@6�EF6GhPAC7@6�6G7N=NO&=NJM:PL>=@7N=�nVx�H�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]>HM: � �^= � S[6!hPR>6C¦��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N � �W6��}��¤6 ����s]M:P7@7NAPEc:>]W;Z6GE2AChPJ>=q�l]>��� ���,n�9ACSpf ��]IH>:<7N7@6�EF6GhCAP7N6�HI= :<RI?FA<deAPJTH>:<j!=@ACJ>6�6�H>=£:<RI?FAI83APJK?FEF:CH>HI=NjG=NAPJ>6�S[6!hPR>ACJ>A&7@6�;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:M¦��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NvH��¤�I6�� ������������]M:<7N7NAPEc:��£���n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NvH$HR�I6�� ���k��������]M:<7N7NAPEc:��£�����n6s83AKSpf � ` =\:Q;T6!E~7@6s:P7r?FEB6�EF6GhPAC7@6�6G7N=NO&=NJM:PL>=@7N=�n798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C�vIB�V?BE�� " �$5¢��5�«1#Q«cnX#j�T!�5+!&�05�#%.h#h�"5X^�*0� Q#�8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=r?B?BAPEF=NA&f5+!��05+.iªc�"345(�V?FE~�Jf�%#j#��%��3i�/�%#j#W�05F�1\m#S�T!Z§u^�*( \p§�3i#&«1n&#� ��¹�_��jt

��:<7N7@6�½mEFAP;MEB=N63?bf:U�y6�|QS[6!hPR>6�8cw>6��V?BE���SB6�6�SBAP7NAiS[6�6kS[=\SU?F6�R>JM:&de;(¤;T6!E283R>=£� ��¤6�� ����¤6P]H>:P7@7\:2½mEFAP;MEB=N63?bf: � ]bS[=CA<?[?F=@6!J>698cwM6P]¾S[6v�V?FE2�q]b:<7N7@ACEF:M]!;Z6GE APhCJ>=;�l]k�£��� �-�C§��T!j5+!X�05�#W./#2«1��!A\�,B§;���"5+\�\m��,05��Q#U��#%,05+�¾§CªW5+3i#U�T!�§�V%�M§�3 �05�§��15A^�* ` � �3n798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C �IU5�83?BE2� " O>!l5+!&�05�#%.h#&� !$��! «1��!A\�,B§;���"5+\�\m��,05���~K��«c��#%,-#W!A\s#Wf���«1��!X�05F�1\m#%!X\m#m�kf�5+!�05+.Qª1�"345£5�83?BE2��f]Q#S�T!�5+!X�15�#%./#U�C§�3DV%�M§�3�#S!o��! Q#U��#%,05+�b§Pª%5+3i#i§�3@«%�T!Z§�«1��!A\�,B§;���"5iYW5��"!$#&�� �9����%t

�W6!hPR>6�HM:<7N7N:s8GAPJMSB=\HI6GEc:<j!=@ACJ>6~;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�8cw>658­?FE2� �%#2#��%��3��j�W#2#W�05F�0\s#s§"34./#W!o�U�T!Z§�^�*�� «cnX#�!$�"!Q#U��#%,05+�¾§CªW5+3i#/�C§s�¹n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NvH&E �V?FE2� �.������ � ��}��sn79=��RC ¹� �W6��V?FE2���D������C]T:<7N7@ACEF:M]K;Z6GE2_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=�de;_�l]>� �.����������,nopJ0;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB6C¦ � ���k��s�����n½(6GE~:PRI?BAPdeAPJMH>:PjG=NAPJ>6i�Y½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:l} � �vSB6GhCR>6��£��sn

� � �W6��£��s]T:yOi:PhPhP=NAPEvEc:<hP=NAPJM6�����k��s�e��¤6P]M;T6!E~7N:i½VEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:,}C]I� �������������sn½(6GEu=NJK?BEFAWH>R>jG=NAPJ>6�HI6!7@7\:i83ACJ>hP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6Q�eJ>6!7£83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!JK?B6k�vSB={wM:>¦*���.�k��s����¹�_���n�R>=NJMHI=^�V?FE~���.������Pn �n ��n ��n��:<7N7N:Q½mEFAP;MEB=N63?bf:l}k�ySB6GhCR>6�;T6!E�83ACJC?FEF:P;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6P¦��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NvHT� 58­?FE2���D������ � �� � �����¤J>ACJ�f6�HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N6�HM:Q���­no98GAPJM8G63?B?B=$SB=@JK?F:<?[?F=N8G=£HI=$HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@=@?¾f:&6sHI={JMAPJD83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@6G?¾f:�SB={7N6GhC:PJ>AQ:<=$83ACJM836G?[?F=£S[6!Oi:<JK?B=\83=$HI=83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:�7NAPhC=N8!:�6sSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N=@?¾f:QHI63aTJ>=r?F=$J>6!7^�v:<;$nX�>¦��x�� � 8�@XL�8���N�yD=�:�@ALkLk8�989b8�?�?;N¢��deACE[?F6k�­¦ � �� ���� �

���~� � 8�@XL�8���N�yD=�:�@$�Jx�|�8�9b8�?�?;N��edeAPEB?B6¾�­¦ � � � �� ��

���u� � 8�@XL�8���N�yD=�:�@G8�L�8�<D?;N{¦ �WAIH�� �58­?BE��� ��� � 8�@XL�8���N�yD=�8��b=�� 9�8�<>?�N�yD8�|6��@Gy>8�|�|�@£¦ 5�8­?FE2� ��WAIH��

�=@OQACS[?BEF=\:<OQA�7�X 6k_KR>= ` :P7@6!J>j!:�?BEc:�=N7W?B6!APEF6GOi:�H>=>83APEFEF63?[?F6Gj!j!:26u=N7K?B6GACEB6!Oi:HI=>8GAW6GEF6GJ>jk:269?BEc:�=N7W?B6!APEF6GOi:HI=£8GAPOQ;>7N63?F6GjGjk:&6�=N7{?F6GAPEF6GOi:QHI={6kS[=\SU?F6GJ>jk:QHI6G7$OQAIHI6!7@7NAMn� �� �,#F�5�4#F&OE,&�� !J�(C>@5# & !5&>D # H����5#F�F&=K @J���F�4#B��� #J�5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& &=!5&G�4�4����� �� ������������������ ��������� � �!"���� ���!# � � �J���5���F&M-*;=&>�F�B�

�F��?�#FCO� C>�B��� �4#FCO� !2C>��E,&.�4# &(H$#F��� � !$���%!"���!#���&���('�)���� �� ���������������*�� ����+�,�� � �!#�+�� ���!+ -��.�� �� /��0'�1�� ��������� � �!"���� ���!# �- � �!5&>D # H���L>#F���5& !5#�@5�J� C>��� �4DM��!$!5#FL>#F���5& !J� @5� #F�5� #F&>E,& !5#�#F�����4&>� #2� D &>�5!$&3� �J���J���F& � #F� @$�4#F�F&/!I�5&>���4&O�$� �(C/.5& !J�4� � #�!5&>D4# H��K @J���F� #B���4# 1 �2-��9�4#F�4�4���5� !5&>#3� #F�4�4&>E,#��F��?�#FC>#%#F� C>@5#%�B�,CO���0�4DM��!5!5# ���4��D #F&G�� �<�5��� #FE,�5�F#FCO�.��� ���4� ���F@$� �,CO���0�4DM��!5!5# ���4��D #F&G�� � !2#F��C>@5##!K @5#F�5!5##!9�B��!5&>D # H���L>#F���5&A!5#�@5�J� C>��� �4DM��!5!$#FLO#F���$&�!J� @5� #F�5� #F&>E,& !5# #F����� &>�4# �$��� �F� �J���5���F#FLOLO�$-653���F# �F��?�#FC/.$&A� ���$� !$&>���4&� �7�!#�98��;:<�����=�� ��>�,�>����! -

Page 82: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

��x� µ���u�<0x[@ 9b8���= $ �}�� �� � �

�WAIH�� � 8���= $ 58­?FE2�79=��RCu½(6GE2:CSBSBR>EcHIAM]ISBR>;>;ZAPJ>=\:<OQA,8cw>6sSB=N:,�V?FE~�¢nVx27N7NAPEc:>]I;Z6GE�_KRM:P7N8cw>6��]>�}��¹�_��sn ��:<7N7\:Q;>EB=NOi:=N;TAP?B6!SB=~S[6!hPR>6�� � � ����sn ��:<7N7\:�SB6!83ACJMH>:�=@;ZA<?F6!SB=~S[6!hPR>6�8cw>6�6kS[=\S[?B6�R>JM: ` :P7@R>?F:<j!=@ACJ>6���?c:<7N6�8cwM6��� ���¢nV¼.:iSB6�¹�_�� f6s83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:�7NAPhC=N8!:&H>=$�¢]MHIA ` EF6GL>LZ6�6!SFS[6!EB6�� � � ¹�_��s]T=@7^8cw>6&f6s:PSFS[RMEFHIATn�n ��n ��n���u� ��Yx�

<0x[@ 9b8���= $ �WAIH�� �5�83?BE~��}��� 8���= $ ��� �

79=��RC �:�� ��s]£;T6!E�7\:�½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:D}k�I]$SB6GhCR>6i�V?FE~���.������Pn �:P7@7\:�;>EB=NOi:l=N;ZA<?B6kS[=~�Y:<;>;>7N=\8G:b?c:l;Z6GE83ACJK?BEc:<;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6P¦m�V?BE~� �5�APJA�IAWH����­]TS[6!hPR>6�52ACJA�WAIH�� ��������P]>6C]I;T6!E[?c:<JK?BAT]I� � � �n �n ��n ��n���~� �� ���

<0x[@ 9b8���= $ � � � ��}��58­?BE�� � 8���= $ �IAWH��79=��RCv½(6GE~:PSFS[RMEFHIAT]IS[6�52ACJA�WAIH��¢]>S[6!hPR>6���� � ¹�9��sn ��:<7N7N:&;>EF=NOQ:&=N;TAP?B6kS[=$SB6GhCR>6�� ��¢�_��s]>=NJ83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=NjG=NAPJM6�8GAPJ�7N:QSB6!83ACJMH>:&=N;TAP?B6!SB=£58­?BE~�¹n �n ��n ��n� ��� ����~�

<0x[@ 9b8���= $ 58­?BE�� �WAIHl�� � � � 8���= $ �£��

79=��RC ��:<7N7�X =N;TAP?B6kS[=2� � � S[6!hPR>6052ACJA�WAIH�� �.�k��s�Cn ��:<7N7N:�;>EF=@Oi:�=N;TAP?B6!SB=��Y:<;>;>7N=\8G:b?c:�;Z6GE�83APJ&�?BEc:<;M;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6C¦s52ACJA�WAIH�� ¥�V?FE~����SB6GhPRM6��V?BE~�����k����C] 6,_KR>=NJMHI=9� �z�;T6!Es7\:D½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:�}��>n�n ��n ��n526!7 ;MEBAKSBSB=@OQA�;M:<Ec:<hCEF:<deAU�Tn |Mn ��HI=NO&AKSU?FEB6!EB6!OQA,=@7^?F6GAPEF6GOi:,H>=(8GAPEFEB6G?[?F6GjGjk:QdeAPEB?B6y;T6!E=N7*8G:P7N8GAP7NAlHI6G7N7\:HI6kHIR>jG=NAPJM6�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6��Y83AC7u8cwM6�SF:<Ebf:.HI=NOQACS[?BEc:b?BA�:<JM8cwM6l=N7u?B6GACEB6!Oi:�HI=~83AW6!EB6!J>j!:K�­nq526!7uSBRM8!836!SFSB= ` A�;M:"�Ec:<hPEc:bdeA��Mn |>n �lHI=NOQACS[?BEF6GEF6GOQAl=N7(?B6!APEF6GOi:lH>=*6!SB=NS[?B6!J>j!:�HI6G7*OQAIHI6!7@7NA��Y83AC7m8cw>6&SF:<Ebf:lH>=@OQACS[?BEc:b?FA�:PJM8cw>6&=@7?B6!APEF6GOi:&HI=£83ACOQ;>7@6G?B6!jGj!:ydeACE[?F6k�­n

� �� ��# !$������� / / ��+ + #)���'� !$#%� !$���(� ��� � �(#)���'��*�+�,���-��.-�#'/�*���#%�(�op7{?F6GAPEF6GOi:&HI=£8GAPEFEB6G?[?B6!jGjk:�wM:&=N7£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6�6GJWR>JT83=\:b?BAT¦

�}�( ���� �

½(6GE~HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C]I�}���SB=@hCJ>=@aT8G:&8cw>6�6!SB=\SU?F6�RMJ0SBA<?B?BAC=@JMSB=N6GOQ6�aMJ>=@?BA0���`¾�ba%a%aG�-ed���HI=$��?F:P7@6s8cw>6C¦�� ` �%aba%aG�c d

�W6�HI=NOQACS[?BEF=N:PO&Ai8cw>6C¦�� ` �%a%abaG�c d � ��k ` �%a%aba3�- d � � �

:&Oi:<hPhC=@ACEuEF:PhP=NAPJ>6&�e;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:QHI=£O&ACJ>A<?FAPJ>=\:C�vSF:<Ebf:���� � sn798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C �vI � 8��q�>8�<D?;N :�@AL�L�8�9 9�N�" OD!�§�S[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:]�05>�"5�«1#~83ACEBEF63?B?F:��W#�5+3$«1��!X�%#�r��X#%!X\m#�Q#�«1�"!Xg�%#sr"�X#%!�Yk§/3��-r�5�«c§��;#W3+3 p 5+!X�05�#W./#/��#sr�3459§�!A\s#c«1#1��#%!X\�5�t

�R>=NJMHI=�]I=@7$?B6GACEB6!Oi:&H>=$83APEFEF63?[?F6Gj!j!:&SB:PE¾f:&HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:<?BAQR>JM: ` AP7@?F:Q8cw>6�S[=*f6�H>=@OQACS[?BEc:b?FA&8cwM6P¦

Page 83: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� |� r"!A5>�W#1V%�X#W!TYk§���#%,05+�b§Pª%5+3i#vQ#y«1�",0,-#W\�\p§

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C � I(1�8��$@A|�N;:;@XLkL�8�9 9bN�" OD!Z§,EB6!hPAC7N: �05��"5�«c#Q8GAPEFEB6G?[?c: �W#Wf�VW�M§"3i��,B§�§c*;*$345�«c§"\º§q§/*$,-#%g./#0�1�%#y«1�",0,-#W\�\m# ` � fo*o,-�b�"�M«1#��T!�§h�%#1VW�X#%!�Yk§,«1��,0,c#W\�\º§;t½(AP=\8cwu®6�?BRI?B?B6,7N6lSB6!_KR>6!J>jG6iHI=9R>JM:D_KRM:<7\SB=N:CS[=mHI6!EB= ` :<j!=@ACJ>6iS[ACJ>ADSB8GEB=@?[?F6i=@JqLM:CS[6i:P7@7N6iA<?B?BADEF6GhPAC7@6C]£SB6HI=NOQACS[?BEF=N:PO&A�8cw>6&7@6&A<?B?BAlEF6GhCAP7N6ySBAPJ>A�83ACEBEF63?B?B6P]�J>6QSB6GhPRM6y8cw>6&APhCJ>=*S[6k_CRM6GJ>jk:lHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@6lf6y8GAPEFEB6G?[?c:,6P]_KR>=NJMHI=�]>;T6!E�_KRM:<JK?FAyAKSBSB6GE ` :b?BA&=NJ�;MEB6k836!H>6GJ>jk:>]I8cw>6 ` :<7N6�=@7�� 6GACEB6!Oi:yHI= 83APEFEF63?[?F6Gj!j!:>n

�D#U��\�\s�],-#sr;�"3i#j�;#W3(«c§�3@«1��3����;#W3+3@§9��#1�"�;YW5��"!$#j!Z§"\��T,F§�3i#��%��!$��«1��,0,-#%\�\m#79=��RC� x�S�� <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ � 8���= $� � � �W=^?BEc:b?B?F:0HI=*HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6y8cw>6C]$;T6!E�APhPJM=��]$7\:�SB6!_KR>6!J>j!:� f6&8GAPEFEB6G?[?F:M]{83=NAMf6&8cw>6U � �£�]$Oi:83=pfA�f6�A `W` =NAMn

� o[� � <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d � � � ` �%a%abaG�c�?> � � �

� 8���= $��`b�%aba%aG�cedy�-�2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� > � � ¢�9��W=�?FEF:<?[?F:QHI= HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6�8cw>6sSB6�7N6sSB6!_KR>6GJMjG6P¦

�`¾�%aba%a!�-ed ��`b�%a%abaG�c� > �

SBAPJ>Ai83ACEBEF63?B?B6C]W:P7@7NAPEc:y7N:QSB6!_KR>6GJMj!:>¦�`b�ba%aba3�-�dy�c��`b�%aba%a3�c� > ¹�9�

f6�83ACEBEF63?B?F:M]W8G=@AMf6�S[6C¦�`¾�ba%abaG�-�d � � ��`<�%aba%a3�c� > � � �

:<7N7NAPEc:>¦�`<�%aba%a3�cedy�-�2`b�ba%a%aG�-� > � � ¹�9�

opJId�:<?[?B=�]bS[6 � � � �� ` �ba%a%aG�- d �-� ` �%a%aba3�-�2>>�C]b:<7N7@ACEF:M] � � � �k ` �%a%abaG�c d �C]bH>:28GR>=P;Z6GE 7N:~;MEB=NOi:~=@;ZA<?F6!SB=Y]� � �}�]$6 � � ���k� ` �%a%abaG�c�?>>�C]£HM:�8GR>=m;Z6GE�7\:�SB6!8GAPJMHM:l=N;TAP?B6kS[=�] � � �}�ln �:�� � �} 6 � � �}�l] SB6GhCR>6� � � ¹�9�ln� ¡9� � <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ ` �ba%abaG�- d � � ¹�9� � 8���= $� ` �%aba%aG�c d � � �� ` �ba%a%a!�- d � � �y�¡ ` =\HI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6C]KSB6 � � � �� ` �%aba%a3�c d �C]W:<7N7NAPEc:>]P;Z6GEu=N;TAP?B6kS[=�] � � � ��h�l]K6�H>:&_CRM6!S[?F:�SB6GhCR>6 � � � �e6 ��� � �y�­n� o[� � <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d � � � 8���= $��`b�%aba%aG�ced � � ������`¾�ba%a%a!�-�d � � � �9�¡ ` =\HI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6C]KSB6 � � � �� ` �%aba%a3�c d �C]W:<7N7NAPEc:>]P;Z6GEu=N;TAP?B6kS[=�] � � � s]I6�H>:�_KR>6kSU?c:�SB6GhPRM6 ��� � ��h��e6 ��� � � �9�­n

� ¡9� � <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ ` �ba%abaG�- d � � ¹�9�� ` �%a%abaG�c�?>M�- � � �� ` �%aba%aG�1� � �-� � � �

� 8���= $� ` �%aba%aG�c d �-� ` �ba%a%a!�-�2>>�1�&}P�ba%a%aG�c��� � ��

�W=\: �.?c:<7N6�8cw>6 � � ���k ` �%a%aba3�- d �c� ` �%aba%a3�c�?>M�c� ` �%aba%a3�1� � �Cn.x27N7NAPEc:>]^=@J¢;T:<EB?B=\83AP7\:<EF6P]^S[=9wM:>¦ � � ��� ` �ba%a%a!�- d �K] � � ����� ` �%aba%a!�-�2>I�&6 � � � ��� ` �%aba%a!�c� � �Cn ��:<7N7N:l;>EF=@Oi:,=N;ZA<?B6kS[=*SB6GhCR>6 � � � �(�l]�HM:��/��9# @7�$D &>C>#F�M��E,&>� �4& ,@5�J��D4&>?����B� ��LO&>D4� �5D &>E,&>� �4& &<C>��D4D &G�4� � � & C>���5� &>�0� &<!5#��4COD4# H0&>D &,@5�J���4&>KI@5&>�5LO� C>��D D &G���M� � @5�J�

D &>?����B����! @5�J� �5D &>E,&>� � � &"C>��D D4&G�4� ��� &"!%K @J���5!5�����5�5�F#FCO�N�M� �<@5�J�A�4&>KI@5&>�5LO��C>��D D4&G�4� ���5D � !5@5C>&,@5�5�A� &>K @5&>�5LO��CO��D4D &G���M� �@5�J�(D &>?����B�(� !5@5& �5D &>E,&>� �4& & C>��D4D &G�4� � �4&"!5K @J���5!5�.���5�5�F#FCO�N�M�.�(!5@$& � &>K @5&>�5L>&(C>��D4D &G�4�4&"!5�5D4�I!$@5C>& @5�J�(� &>KI@$&O�$L � CO��D4D &G���M� �& C>��� ��H$#B�$-

Page 84: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

83RM= � � � AP;>;>RMEB6 � � � �,nu�W6 � � � s]�H>: � � ���k��`k�ba%abaG�-� > �s6yH>:P7@7\:iS[6k83ACJMH>:Q=N;TAP?B6!SB= SB6GhCR>6 � � � �&n�W6 � � � �l]MH>: ��� � ��� ` �%aba%a3�1� � ��6�H>:<7N7N:y?F6GEFj!:&=@;ZA<?F6!SB=£SB6GhPRM6 ��� � �&n*opJ�AChPJ>=$8!:PSBA � � � �&n� oB� � <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d��c � � � � 8���= $��`b�%aba%aG�ced � � � ��W=\: ��?F:P7@608cw>6 � � � �k�`b�%a%aba3�-�dy�Cn��W6 � � � � �]V:<7N7NAPEc: � � � � �ln��W6 � � � �]V:<7N7@ACEF: � � ����`¾�ba%a%a!�-�d��c���6sH>:<7N7�X =N;TAP?B6kS[=$SB6GhCR>6�� � � �,]I;Z6GE83R>= ��� � ���,n*opJ�APhCJ>=$8G:CS[AiSB={wM: ��� � � �ln

� ¡v��� <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d � � ��`b�%a%abaG�c� > � � ���

� 8���= $��`b�%aba%aG�cedy�-�2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� > � � �

�W=\:��D?F:P7@6,8cw>6 � � � ���`¾�ba%a%a!�-�d��c��`b�%a%abaG�c� > �CniopJ�;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB6QSB=mwM:�� � � ���`b�%aba%aG�ced��i6 � � ����2`¾�ba%aba3�-� > �Kn �:P7@7N6&H>R>6y=N;ZA<?B6kS[=*SB6GhCR>APJ>A � � � 6 � � � � �ln ��:�_CRM6!S[?B6&R>7r?F=@OQ6QHIR>6QS[=(AP?[?B=N6GJM6� � � �ln� ��� � <0x¢@ 9�8���= $ �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d��1�� � � �

��`b�%a%abaG�c� > �c�� � � ���� 8���= $��`b�%aba%aG�cedy�-�2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� > � �

�W=\: �.?c:<7N6l8cw>6 � � � �k�`¾�ba%aba3�-�dy�c��`b�%aba%a3�c� > �Cn��W=vHI6 ` 6lHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6,8cw>6 � � � sn�½(6!E�:PSFS[RMEFHIAT]SB6�J>ACJ ` :<7N6!SFS[6 � � � �]$:<7N7@ACEF:iSB=(: ` EF6GLMLT6 � � � ���n �:P7@7N6yHIRM6�=N;TAP?B6!SB=(S[6!hPR>=NEB6!L>LZ6GEFA,EB=\SB;T6G?[?B= ` :<OQ6GJK?F6� � � �»6 � � � ���lnV¼.:Q83=pfA�f6�:PSFS[RMEFHIA0� �lJ>APJ�;>R fAiEF6GJMH>6GEF6 ` 6GEF6�SB=\:U�l]MSB=N:/���y�3n �n ��n ��n� ���� ��# !$�3���?�(� / ��+ + #)��� �"!$#%��!$����� ��� � �(# ��� ��*�+�,(��-��.-�#0/�*���#%�(��9APOQ6�SB=£f6~ACSFS[6!E ` :b?FA�:<7N7N:�aTJ>6�HI6!7M;M:PEF:PhPEc:bdeA��Mn |>n |>]<;Z6GEvHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6~=N7 � 6GACEB6!Oi:�HI=T8GAPOQ;>7N63?B6!jGjk:,��deACE[?F6k�­]SB={;>R fA,HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6=N7�� 6GAPEF6GOi:&HI=$6kS[=\SU?F6GJ>jk:QHI6G7{OQAIHI6G7N7NAM¦

5�8­?FE2� ��WAIH��

�2JT:,?F6!83JM=N8!:l=NJK?BEFAWH>A<?[?c:�HM:�¨�6GJ��W=NJ�;Z6GEsHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�=N7 �£6!APEF6GOi:lHI=*6kS[=\S[?B6GJMj!:�HI6G7*OQAIHI6G7N7NAM]$8cw>6QS[=:<;M;>7@=\8G:�:PJM8cw>6~;Z6GEmOQAC7r?F=T:<7@?BEF=M8!:<7\83AP7N=I7NAPhP=\83=�]>f6~7\:�SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6C¦ H>:<?BA�R>J,_KRM:P7NSB=N:CS[=I=NJMSB=@6!OQ62J>APJi8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=r?-�?BACEB=NA�� 7@A�SB=K6kSU?F6GJMH>69=N7W;>=[fR&;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6v=@JyOQAWH>A�8cw>6u83ACJMSB6GE ` =K7\:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:2HI=I6!SFSB6GEF6VJ>ACJy83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@ATn�W=^HI63?F6GEFO&=NJM:iRMJM: ` :<7NRI?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�8cwM6�EB6!JMHI6 ` 6GEF6�?BRI?B?B6s7N6�de;�HI=^_KR>6!S[?BA,:PO&;M7@=\:<OQ6GJK?FAMn � :P7@6 ` :P7@RI?c:<j!=@ACJ>6EF6GJMHI6 ` 6GEF6�:PJM8cw>6�7N6de;DHI=£�¢]I6�;T6!E[?c:<JK?BAQ��f6�S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6Cn798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8(BDC���C � I(<W<>�b=�8���8�<>@$< :�@$<$9%L�N&y>yD= 9 9b@AL�=�@��lN&�b��=��lN&|�8�" �A5���5�«1#�«cnX#(�T!q=NJMSB=@6!O&6.H>=~de;�f6DJ>ACJ 83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@A�Oi:PSFS[=NOi:<7N6��%#�#��%��3i���%#� Q#�!o��! «1�"!X\�,B§��;��5+\�\s�",05���#WfU�W#� �� hf,§�3+3���,B§�V?BE �D�k���topJ¹:P7r?FEB6,;T:<EFAP7N6P](R>J¹=NJMSB=@6!OQ6lJ>ACJ¹83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@ADOi:PSFSB=@Oi:<7N6.f6lR>J¹=NJMSB=@6!O&6�J>APJ 83APJK?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?BACEB=NA?F:P7@6�8cw>6C]MSB6�hC7@=$SB=£:PhPhP=NR>J>hC6RMJM:yde;��Y8cw>6�hP=pf:&J>APJ�hP7N=$:<;M;M:<EB?B=N6GJ>6¾�­]MH>= ` =N6GJ>6�83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@ATn

�[8����lN�B�CF�GC�H�I��[8�����N(y>=��[=�<Dy>8�<o{>N&�>� " � r"!A5�5+!X�05�#W./#�!$��! «c�"!X\�,B§��;��5+\�\s�",05��.� §".j./#%\�\m#(�T!�§#W�1\m#%!&�05���!o# !o��!�«c�"!X\�,B§��;��5+\�\s�",05�§].i§k�1�05+.i§�3i#�t79=��RC¢�I=N:&��RMJ�=NJMSB=@6!O&6�J>ACJ�8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=r?B?BAPEF=NAMn(�9ACJMSB=NHI6!EB=\:<OQAyR>JM:&6GJWR>OQ6GEc:<j!=@ACJ>6H>=�?BRI?B?B6�7@6�de;0HI=q��¦

�`<�- � �- � �ba%aba3�-�d��ba%a%aba%aba�63aMJ>=\:<OQAi;Z6GE~=NJMHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�R>JM:QSBRM8G8G6!SFS[=NAPJM6�HI=£=@JMSB=N6GOQ=£HI={de;0� �P�B��`¾�[� � �%a%abaG�B���Z�ba%a%aba%abaM83ACO&6�SB6GhCR>6P¦�UN&�b8 � �� ��eNX�b��@

���>`~� �� ��� �.�k��>`k� SB6�58­?FE2��� ������D`¾���� SB6s�V?FE~��� ���k��D`¾�

Page 85: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

�W=u;M:PE[?F6�H>:P7@7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6�J>ACJ¹83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@A�� ��� � �¾�&H>:b?FAMn��W=~83ACJMS[=\HI6!EF:D7\:�de;v�`<©uS[6�J>APJ¹d�:HI= ` 6!J>=@EF6l8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=r?B?BAPEF=NAD�¸7N:�S[=v:<hChP=NR>J>hP6�:PHq� ��6l� ` � � � �¹�� ` �b�­]m:<7@?BEF=NO&6!JK?B=v7N:.SB=uSB8!:<EB?F:¢��6� ` � � � �­n�½(AP=vS[=v;M:PSFSF:.:PHv � ©vS[6�J>APJ¹d�:�HI= ` 6!J>=NEB6�83APJK?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?BACEB=NAD� ` 7\:�SB=~:<hPhC=@RMJ>hP6,:CHq� ` ��6� � � � ` �,�� � �¾�3]I:<7@?BEF=@OQ6GJK?F=M7\:�SB=TSF8G:<EB?F:l�e6�� � � � ` �­©W6�83ACSpf �MSB=Z;>EBAI8G6!HI62;T:PSFSB:PJMHIA�=NJlEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:?BR>?[?B67N6�de;$]MSF8G:<EB?F:PJMHIAQ_KR>6G7N7@6�8cw>6s8GAPJMH>RM83ACJ>A&:Q8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=@j!=@ACJ>66�=NJMSB6GEF6GJMH>A&7N6�:<7@?BEF6Pn¡ ` =\HI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6C]W;T6!Eu8GAPOQ6yf68GACS[?BEFR>=r?c:�7\:&S[RM8!836kSBSB=@ACJ>6H>6GhP7N=�=@JTS[=N6GOQ={�/¡U]>8G=N:CSB8GR>Jl=NJMSB=@6!O&6��/¡9f6�J>ACJ83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@AT]W6�=NJ>AC7r?FEB6C¦� ���g��`��¹� � �¤a%a%a�� ����� a%aba½(APJM=N:PO&A ���¢� ¡ ]>AKSBSB=\: f6�7�X R>JM=@ACJ>6sHI=�?BR>?[?B= hP7N=$=NJMS[=N6GOQ={� ¡ n

�=@OQACS[?BEF=\:<OQA&8cwM6 �SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:&=$EF6!_KR>=\SB=r?F={EB=\8cw>=N6!S[?B=�n(x�J>jG=@?BR>?[?BAl6 ` =NH>6GJK?B6!O&6!JK?B6���� ,n�B§!� Q# !$�"! «1��!A\�,B§;���"5+\�\m��,05��<n �W6�deACSFS[6��V?BE ,]:<7N7@ACEF:M]v;Z6GE�_KRM:<7\8cw>6��] � ��v��sn ½(6!EH>63aMJ>=NjG=NAPJM6P]M8G=ºfAiSB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:Q8cw>6�6!SB=NS[?B6�R>JDSBA<?B?BAP=NJMSB=@6!OQ6aTJ>=r?FA0��� ` �ba%a%aG�-�2>I�sHI= ?c:<7N6s8cw>6P¦

� ` �ba%aba3�-�2>S��¹�_���yX :<7@?BEc:�;M:PE[?F6P]b;Z6GE*83ACOQ6 f69S[?F:<?BA�83AKSU?FEBR>=@?BAT]<83=\:PSF83R>JT:e��~f696G7N6GOQ6GJK?BA�HI=>_KRM:P7N8cw>69�/¡[n(½(AP=\8cwu®67N6���vS[ACJ>As=NJ,JWR>OQ6GEFA�aMJ>=@?BAy62hP7N=M�/¡£SBAPJMA�83ACJC?F6GJWRI?F=M7�X R>JMAsJ>6G7N7�X :P7r?FEBAl�edeAPEFOi:<J>A�R>JT:s8G:<?B6GJT:C�­]` =MSF:<Ebf:�R>JQ�/¡$8cw>6283ACJK?B=N6GJ>6u?FRI?[?F=M7N6u�����SB6e� ` �����T�%aba%aG�c�� �0�� C]CLM:PS[?F:�;MEB6!JMHI6GEF6~83ACO&6�� =@7Oi:CSBSB=@OQAy?BEc:��^�%aba%a3� �W�3nm¼.:QS[6��/¡^8GAPJK?B=N6GJM6��k� ` �ba%abaG�-�2>>�C]I:<7N7@ACEF:yS[=�wM:&:<JT8cw>6�/¡D��q�]��s]8GAPJK?BEFA&=@7{d�:<?[?FA,8cw>6�83=\:PSF83R>J�� ¡ f6�J>APJ083ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@ATn

�BªF� )Q#�.Q§��c�05+.i§�3i#Gn��W=\:�� �� ,n��W=vHI6 ` 6,HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6,8cwM6��V?BE �����,�Pn �:<?BA�8cwM6iJ>6G7N7YX 6GJWRT�OQ6!EF:PjG=NAPJ>6�=NJ>=NjG=\:<7N6�S[ACJ>A,6!7@6!JM8G:<?B6�?FRI?[?F6�7N6sde;$]�:<JM8cwM6S��aMhCR>EF6GEbf:y=NJ.6kSBSF:>©�S[=\:/� �¤ � >` n��I6 � D` J>APJ�:<;>;M:PE[?F=@6!J>6y:CH�,] ` R>AP7^HI=NEB6&8cw>6lf6ySU?c:b?F:�SB8!:<EB?F:<?F:i_KRM:<JTHIA.f6 ` 6GJWRI?FAl=N7^SBR>Ai?FR>EBJMAJM6G7N7N:�8GACS[?BEFR>jG=NAPJ>6u=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` :l��:P7>;M:CSBSBA �>�­]K6283=pfAsS[=NhPJM=raT8!:�8cw>6~� � �y�� � D` ��f6283ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@ATn¼�:�:<7N7NAPEc:>] :�Oi:<hPhC=@ACE�EF:PhP=NAPJ>6C]9f6l83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@A �¢�� � D`b�C](ACSFS[=\:� �¹���,�C]*8cw>6.f6lR>JSBAP;MEF:P=@JMSB=N6GOQ6�H>=$� � ���k � D`b�,�e6kSBSB6GJMH>A&� � � &�­n

�n ��n ��n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N y>8��$|�=�=�<>��=�8���=<>@A< :;@A<$9bLkNXyDy>= 989b@ALk=6��NX�b��=���NX|�=526!7£SB6GhPRM=r?FAQ8GAPJ =@JMH>=N8cw>=\:<OQAQR>J0=NJMS[=N6GOQ6�J>ACJ�8GAPJK?BEc:PHMHI=r?B?BACEB=NAyOi:CSBSB=@Oi:P7@6�HI=�de;$n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NvHlI(:��>=��>�b�DL�N�"

���� ��79=��RC ¹� �W62�� ,]T:<7N7@ACEF:M]C6 ` =\HI6!JC?F6GOQ6GJK?F6,��½mEFAP;MEB=N63?bf:l}C]rzc�Mn |>n |C�­] ��sn

� �e�W=\:>]�;Z6GE�:PSFS[R>EcHIAT]$ �� ,n�¡VSFS[6!JMHIA� OQ:CSBSB=NOQ:P7@6C]Z:P7@7NAPEc:l�V?BE �.�k��Pn �R>=NJMHI=(H>:� ����s�HI6!EB= ` :&_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=Tde;£]M=NJ�;M:PE[?F=N8GAP7\:<EF6P¦ ����s������

H>:083RM=Y]^;T6!E�:<R>?BAI83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=NjG=NAPJ>6C]£SB=mwM:>¦ £� ��sn0�9=pfAqf6i:PSFSBR>EFH>A�;ZAP=\8cwu®6C]$;Z6GEs=N;TAP?B6kS[=�] £�z»65�83?BE ,n �n ��n ��n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��NJE'I(:;@A��x>|�8 9�8�?�?�N�L�=��bx[8�9 9b@�N�� "¾¦

��� � � � �� 79=��RC ���W6]��� � l]£:<7N7@ACEF: �'���lnh�W6&deAKSBSB6U� � i]^S[=*: ` EB6!L>LZ6&:PJM8cw>6 ��� 83ACJC?FEBA�7\:lJ>ACJ83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@6G?¾f:&HI= in �RM=@JMH>=�� ���in

� ���W6]� �� ,]^;T6!E�7\:0Oi:PSFS[=NOi:<7N=r?bf:DHI= l]*�V?FE �D�k�i�Kn�¼.:D:P7@7NAPEc:>]^83ACO&6iJM6G7N7N:.H>=@OQACS[?BEc:<j!=@ACJ>6;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F6P] �q���,��� ��� 6,_KR>=NJMHI= £�z����;T6!Es7N:0EF6GhCAP7\:�H>=9:<R>?BAI83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=NjG=NAPJ>6Cn �:�£� ���SB6GhPRM62��� �� ;Z6GE27\:Q½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:�}Pn �n ��n ��n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N��RI(:;@A��x>|�8 9�8�?�?�N�L�=��bx[8�9 9b@�N�� "¾¦

Page 86: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

�PÀ� �_� �� � � ��»6�� �

79=��RC ¹� �I6�� �_� ��i]Z:<7N7@ACEF: ��� �_�&]M6s_KR>=NJMHI=V��;T6!E26G7N=@OQ=NJM:<j!=@ACJ>6sHI= �v©T½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:&|>]{zc�Mn |>n |C�3] ��� 6 ���&nm526sSB6GhCR>62� ��»6�� �� ;Z6GE�7N:Q½mEFAP;MEB=N63?bf:l}Cn

� �e�W6U� � 6h� � i]{:<7N7NAPEc: �J� 6 ���&]{6y_KR>=NJMHI=u�e;Z6GE�=NJK?BEFAWH>R>jG=NAPJ>6yHI=(�v©$½VEBAC;>EF=@6G?¾f:]�I]z-�Tn |Mn |K� P��� �_� 6P]I=NJIaMJ>6C]X� �_� � »;Z6GE~7\:&½VEBAC;>EF=@6G?¾f:�}Pn �n ��n ��n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N BzI(:;@A��x>|�8 9�8�?�?�N�L�=��bx[8�9 9b@�N�� "¾¦

� �_� ��� � � AP;>;MR>EB6�� � 79=��RC �D�I6��0� � ��l]<:<7N7@ACEF: �(�0� �&n(½(6!E AP?[?F6GJ>6!EB697N:�?B6kS[={��8cwM6f6vS[AP?[?FA�deACEBOi:�H>=KRMJ$X :P7r?F6GEFJM:b?F= ` :K�HI=NOQACS[?BEF=N:PO&A�8cw>6P]�S[6U� �� ,]�:<7N7NAPEc:�� � ,n��I6j� �� l]Z6kSBSB6GJTHIA��Oi:PSFSB=@Oi:<7N6P]^f6&�V?FE �.���i�C]Z;Z6GE83RM= �q���i�/�'�&n&½(AC=N8cwu®6U� �'�&]£H>:P7@7N6&?BEF6i83APJTHI=@j!=@ACJ>= ���¤���&] ���k�i�h�z�&]D� �'�&] SB6GhCR>6 ��� ��;T6!E~6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<j!=@ACJ>6�HI= �v©M½VEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:U�>]rzc�Mn |>n |C�3]K6�=NJIaMJM6S� �� ;T6!E~7N:i½VEBAC;>EF=@6G?¾f:,}Cn

� �2�W6]� � l]^:P7@7NAPEc: £�z�,](H>:083R>= �z����� �e;Z6GEs=NJK?BEFAIHIR>jG=NAPJM6,HI=9�v©*½mEFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:9�T]rzc�Mn |>n |C�6Q_CRM=@JMH>=�� ��� � ;T6!E�7N:�½mEFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:�}PnS�W6/� � 7\:�HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PjG=NAPJ>6lf6y:PJM:<7NAPhK:>¦2H>:� ��� SB6GhCR>6 ��� �9� 6s_KR>=NJMHI=�� �_� � ,n �n ��n ��n��L�@Xx>L�=�8�9��N �'I(:;@A��x>|�8 9�8�?�?�N�L�=��bx[8�9 9b@�Nq� "b¦

� � � ��� � �� »AP;>;>RMEB6�� � 79=��RC �[�I=N:j� ��� ��l]WHM:s83R>= ��� � �&n*½(6GEvHI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6~7\:�?F6!SB=^�Y8cw>6�f6�R>J$X :<7@?B6GEFJM:<?B= ` :K�*LM:CSU?c:HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cw>6P]{SB6j� � ,]{:<7N7@ACEF:�� � in�¼.:lSB6j� � ,]{SB= wM:� �J� 7N:�_KRM:<7N6P]�83ACJ �J� � �&]83ACOQ;TACE[?c:���;T6!E~6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<j!=@ACJ>6�HI=^� ©M½mEFAP;MEB=N63?bf: Á ]rzc�Mn |>n |C� P���&]MH>:i8GR>=�� ��»;Z6GE~7\:Q½mEFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:�}Pn

� ���W=\:9� �� lnsx27N7@ACEF:M]�;T6!E�7\:,Oi:CSBSB=@Oi:P7@=@?¾f:�HI= ,] �V?BE ���k�i�P]$H>:�83RM= �����,�U�l� 6&_KR>=NJMHI=�e;Z6GE�=@JK?BEFAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI=^� ©>½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f: À ]@z-�Tn |Mn |K� ��� ��� 6�_KR>=NJMHI=D� ��� � ;Z6GE~7\:i½mEFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:l}Pn�W=\:�� ��ln^x�7@7NAPEc: ���&n*x Oi:PhPhP=NAPE*Ec:<hC=@ACJ>6 �Q���i����� 6P]W83ACO&6�=@Ji;>EF6!8G6!HI6!J>j!:M]� ��� ���6s_KR>=NJMHI=�� ��� ��in �n ��n ��n

� 8�@AL�8���N�BDC���C�H � r"!A5>5+!X�05�#W./#j!$��!�«c�"!X\�,B§��;��5+\�\s�",05���.Q§��c�05+.i§�3i#vQ#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#bt79=��RC��W=\: RMJ�_KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=£=NJMSB=@6!OQ6�J>ACJ�83ACJC?FEF:CH>HI=@?[?FAPEF=@AiOi:PSFSB=@Oi:<7N6Pn2½(6!EHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6s8cw>6 f6�SBAWHMHI= �S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6�L>=\S[AChPJM:yHI63aTJ>=@EF6�RMJM: ` :P7@RI?c:<j!=@ACJ>6�8cwM6�EF6GJMHI6 ` 6!EB6�?BRI?B?B6�7N6�de;0HI= ,n*½(6GEv7\:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:sHI=$83ACOU�;>7N63?F6GjGjk:�EF=\S[;Z63?B?BAQ:U�¢6;Z6GEu7\:�J>ACJ�8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=r?B?BAPEF=N63?¾f:yHI= SB=�wM:&8cw>6P]W;Z6GE~APhCJ>=Z7@6G?[?B6!EF:y;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6� ]>A � �� A]� � � �e6�J>ACJ�6!JK?BEc:<O�LZ6�7@6s8GACSB6k� ` �Pn½(ACSFSB=N:PO&A&:<7N7@ACEF:&HI6GaMJ>=NEB6�7\:&SB6GhCR>6GJK?F6 ` :P7@RI?c:<j!=@ACJ>6P¦

��� � �V��� �� � �

�e6s_KR>=NJMHI= �Z� � �9�Rw � � �� � �� � � y�3n�=@OQACS[?BEF=\:<OQA�8cw>6y?F:P7@6 ` :<7NRI?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �.SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:� HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<JMH>AM]�;T6!E�=@JTHIR>jG=NAPJM6&SBR>7N7N:�83ACO&;M7@6kSBSB=r?bf:HI=��]M8cw>6C]I;T6!E2APhCJ>=�de;(s¦

������V��� ��� � �§k�%#3¦¢ � �opJ�?F:<7 8G:PSBA&7N:y?B6kS[=mf6��Z� � �9��� � � ��l]M8cw>6 ` :<7N6�;Z6GE�7N:QHI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6sS[?B6kSBSF:yH>= �Tn�~§��c�%�<¦

��� @5&>�4� � &��B��DM��?�#F���5&*��&>D�C>@5##! ��&>D�!5#FE,���4�4DM��D4&3#F��� &>��D &>E ��!5#0&>� #F��� &>�5LO� !5&>� E,� !5&>�F�F� ! � #�D #FC>��D4D &����F�F&*&>��� &>�5�4#F���5#IE ���4� #FE ���F#-(��0� @5# �4# H���E,&>�0� &"!��5��D4�4&O�$!5� !J� � �F� � # &O��� &>�5!$& � C>���(�B� �4&>C>�5#FCO�=#F�F�F@5��� D �N�M� �5&>�F�B��!5#FE,���4�4DM��L>#F���5&*!5&>� � &>E,E �:!5# � #F�$!5&>� �J��@$E ��! @5� #F�5� #F&>E,&"E ���4� #FE ���F&���!3#F�*KI@5���F&<C>���0� #F&>�5& ���&>D E �N�4&,� �5&>?0�N� & � @I�4�4& �F&<�F&G��� &>D4&<�$D ������� #FL>#F���J���F#-2(�E,�����5&>�5!5� C/.5&� #B���$�(H0&>D & �F& �F&G�4�4&>D & C0.5& � ���5�(#F�� � & 1���F�4& K @5&>�F�F& �B�(CO@$#��5&>?0��L>#F���5& & #F�� 9� #�C>���4�4D @$#F� C>& �B� H����F@$� ��L>#F���5& C/.5& D4&O�$!5&=H0&>D &�4@$�4�4& & � ���F& �F& 1 �A!$#��,-

Page 87: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

�WÁ}Cnu � ����W=$HI6 ` 6�HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6C¦ �������&�V� � � ��� � �Y:PSFS[R>OQ6!JMHIA&7YX =@;ZA<?F6!SB=$=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` : �����&�V� � ��

� ��&�­n�W=$wM:M¦ �������y�u� � � �Z���y�u� w �� �e;Z6GE=@;ZA<?F6!SB=$=@JTHIRI?[?F= ` :K�u� �� � ��e;Z6GE7N:i½VEBAC;>EF=@6G?¾f:�yH>=£83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:yEB=\SB;T6G?[?BA,:/�*� ��� � ,n

�>nu �z� �_��W=^H>6 ` 6&HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6 �����¤�����~� � � �¤�(� � ��Y:PSFS[R>OQ6!JMHIAl7N6�=N;ZA<?B6kS[=^=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` 6 �Z���y�2�� ���� � 6 �������V� � � �� � y�­n�W=*wM:>¦ ������������� � � �Z���y��� ��6 ��������� � � ��;T6!E�7@6Q=N;TAP?B6!SB=*=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` 6k��� � 6� � � ��e;Z6GE27\:Q½mEFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:&|QHI=£8GAPOQ;>7N63?B6!jGjk:�EF=NSB;Z63?[?FA,:i�*�6� �_� � ,n

|Mnu �z� �_��W=^H>6 ` 6&HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6 �����¤�����~� � � �¤�(� � ��Y:PSFS[R>OQ6!JMHIAl7N6�=N;ZA<?B6kS[=^=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` 6 �Z���y�2�� ���� � 6 �������V� � � �� � y�­n�W=$wM:M¦ ����� �(���v� � � �����&�9� � AP;>;MR>EB6 �������u� � � ���;T6!E27@6�=@;ZA<?F6!SB=$=@JTHIRI?[?F= ` 6k� � ��AP;>;>RMEB6�� ��� ���;T6!E27N:Q½VEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:S�iHI= 83APOQ;>7N63?F6Gj!j!:yEB=\S[;Z63?B?BA,:i�*�6� �_� ��ln

�Tnu �z� ����W=^H>6 ` 6&HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6 ����� � ���2� � �� ��� � � ��:CSBSBR>OQ6GJMH>Al7N6�=N;TAP?B6!SB=^=@JMH>RI?[?F= ` 6&8GAPOQ6J>6G=$HIRM6s8G:PSB={;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=\�3n�W=>wM:M¦ ����� �����m� � � �����y�9�zw AP;>;MR>EB6 �������V� � � ��e;Z6GEV7@6~=N;TAP?B6kS[=>=NJMHIR>?[?B= ` 6¾�� � AP;>;>RMEB6�� ��� ���;T6!E27N:Q½VEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:U�&HI= 83APOQ;>7N63?F6Gj!j!:yEB=\S[;Z63?B?BA,:,� �6� ��� ��ln

�n ��n ��n� 8�@AL�8���N�BDC���CFEvI � 8�@XL�8���N�y>=�8���=��89b8�<>?�N�yD8�|6��@Gy>8�|�|�@"

5�8­?FE2� ��WAIH��79=��RC��I6�5�83?BE2�q]Z;T6!E�=N7 ¿£6GOQOi:,HI=(¿$=NJMHI6GJWLM:PR>O 6!SB=NS[?B6�R>JT:i6!S[?B6!JMS[=NAPJM6sJ>APJ.8GAPJK?BEc:PHMHI=r?B?BACEB=\:&OQ:CSBSB=i�Oi:<7N6 �HI=Z�¢n(½(6GEm=N7>?F6GAPEF6GOi:�;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6 �f62SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@6Cn^¼.:s7N: ` :P7@RI?c:<j!=@ACJ>628cw>62EF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEF6u?BR>?[?B67N6sde;�HI= ,]{:iOi:PhPhP=NAPE�EF:PhP=NAPJ>6C]>EB6!JMHI6 ` 6GEF6�?FRI?[?F6y7N6�de;�H>= �¸�Y8cw>6lf6�R>J�SBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6yHI= &�­]�6y_KR>=NJMHI=` :<7N6��WAIH��qn �n ��n ��nopJ,HI6GaMJ>=@?B= ` :M]K: ` 6GJMH>A�H>=@OQACS[?BEc:b?FA�=@7 �£6!APEF6GOi:�HI=T6!SB=NS[?B6!J>j!:�HI6!7MOQAIHI6G7N7NAM]WS[6!hPR>62:PJM8cw>6~=N7 � 6GAPEF6GOi:�HI=83ACOQ;>7@6G?B6!jGj!:�deAPEB?B6y��� � � ��£����V8cw>6sf6:CHi6!SFS[A�6!_KR>= ` :P7@6!JK?B6Pn*½(6!EV_KRM:<JK?BAyACSFS[6!E ` :<?BAs:<7N7\:�aMJ>6�HI6G7zF|Mn �iHI6!7 �v:<;$nT|>]>SB={wM:<J>JMAQ:PJM8cw>6�83ACOQ6s83APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>jG6�=@7 �£6!APEF6GOi:yH>=£83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:QHI6!LTAC7@6�6�=N7 �£6!APEF6GOi:HI=£8GAPOQ;M:<?[?B6!jGjk:���J>6G7N7N6sS[R>6�HIRM6�deAPEFO�R>7\:<j!=@ACJ>=�6!_KR>= ` :P7@6!JK?B=��­n���[� °�#²±~³s´3±~)&´3)µ+D4�1¹¶^4 � -04#&%(1¹³s´G´3³�� 4�#&%(/~4�#526!=V8G:P7N8GAP7N=m:<7N7N:D¬�6!JC?FjG6!J¢S[=(?FEF:<?[?F:PJ>ADS[6k_KR>6GJ>j!6i=@Jq8GR>= ` =2f6QR>J�=NJMS[=N6GOQ6,HI=9:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B=m6iRMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6HI=$8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B=�]I8cw>6�8cw>=N:POQ=N:PO&A&S[6k_KR>6GJK?B=�;Z6GE2HI=\S[?B=NJ>hPR>6!EB7N={H>:<7N7N6�SB6!_KR>6!J>jG6�HI6G7$8!:<7\83AC7@A&HI6G7N7N:&HI6kHIR>jG=NAPJM6JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6Pn¢�I6Q�� ` �%aba%a3�c d �Qf6�7YX =@JTS[=N6GOQ6�HI6!hP7N=£:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F={6Q��� ` �%aba%a!�-� � ��7�X =@JMSB=N6GOQ6�HI6!=£83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!JK?B=�]=N7£S[6k_KR>6GJK?B6�SB=$SB8GEB= ` 6C¦

` �ba%a%a!�- d�� � ` �ba%a%a!�-� ��e=NJD83R>=£=@7£SB=NO�LZAP7NA � S[6!;M:<Ec:yhP7N=$:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B=$H>:P=£83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJK?B= ` �!�­n526!7TSB6GhCR>=r?FAsHI=T_KR>6kSU?FAs;M:PEF:PhPEc:bdeA�RMS[6!EB6!OQA�R>JM:�J>AP?F:PjG=NAPJ>62:PL>L>EF6 ` =N:<?F:�;ZAPJ>6!JMHIA��¤���� ` �%aba%a3�c d �6� � �k� ` �%aba%a3�c� � �K]I;T6!E283R>=£=@7£SB6!_KR>6!JK?B6�;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�SB=£SF83EF= ` 6GEbf:s;>=[fRD83ACJM83=\SB:POQ6GJK?B6C¦

� � �

�46 �I#2D4#FCO��D4!5#2�4&>E,�5D & C0.5& �5&>?��F#�#F�5�4#F&OE,#��5��� C>��� � ���5� ��& ��� ��D !$#F�5& !5&>?��F#�&>�F&>E,&>� �4##!5��& �F& &>H0&>�0� @5���F#%D #F��&G� #FL>#F���5#-

Page 88: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

���

�W=(HI=\836y8cwM6�R>JM: ` :<7NRI?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �0EF6GJMH>6���#W,-�sR>J�SB6!_KR>6!JK?B6ySB6s6QS[AC7@A�S[6sA�EB6!JMHI6�d�:<7\SB:iRMJM:ide;�HI= � AEF6GJMHI6 ` 6GEc:�R>JM:�de;,HI=��»�eAM]C6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B6!O&6!JK?B6P]KS[6~6S[AC7@A�SB6P]C_KRM:PJMHIA�EF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEF6v?BRI?B?B627N6~de;,HI=��&]PEF6GJMH>6` 6!EF:&:<7NOQ6GJ>AQR>JT:�de;DHI= �y�­n*opJD8G:CS[AQ83ACJK?BEc:<EF=@A �iEB6!JMHI6�d�:<7\S[AQ=N7$S[6k_KR>6GJK?B6Cn��2JDSB6!_KR>6GJK?F6yf6,«1��,0,c#W\�\s��SB6�6SBAP7NAQSB6&f6 ` 6GEFAQEB=\SB;T6G?[?BAi:CHlAChPJ>= ` :<7NRI?c:<jG=NAPJM6PnopJ0:<7@?BEF6�;T:<EFAP7N6P]>SB6�:CSBSBAI83=\:<OQAQ:<7$SB6!_KR>6GJK?F6�7\:yde;$¦ �R�`*��a%a%a¾���d � �2`(��a%abak�����

=N7 ` :P7@ACEB6QHI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:�HI6!7mS[6k_KR>6GJK?B6QEF=NSB;Z63?[?FAD:PH�R>JM: ` :P7@R>?F:<j!=@ACJ>6 �.83AC=@JM8G=NH>6Q8GAPJ�_CRM6G7N7@ADHI6!7@7\:�de; �]£6Q=@7SB6!_KR>6GJK?F6&f6�8GAPEFEB6G?[?FA&SB6�6sS[AC7@AQS[6� f6�R>JT:�?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhC=N:Mn�W6�7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6sH>6GhP7N=$:<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F=(f6 ` RMA<?BAT]I=@7 S[6k_CRM6GJK?B6�SB=£SB8GEB= ` 6C¦

� �

6�7\:�de;D:CSBSBAI83=\:b?F:,f62��`m��aba%a!�9� ��n�W6�7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6sH>6G=£8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B=(f6 ` R>AP?BAM]I=N7£SB6!_KR>6!JC?F6�S[=$SF83EF= ` 6P¦

� �

6�7\:�de;D:CSBSBAI83=\:b?F:,f6��u���`m��a%aba!�9ed��­nopJIaMJM6P]MSB=N: � 8cw>6 � ;TAKSBSBAPJMAy6kSBSB6GEF6 ` R>AP?B=�]>6sSB={wM:&=@7£SB6!_KR>6!JK?B6 ` R>A<?FAM¦�

8cw>6Qf6�SB6GOQ;>EF6d�:P7NSBAD��:CHl6kSBSBAiS[={;>R^fA,:PSFS[AI83=\:<EF68GAPOQ6�de;DR>JM:Q83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=NjG=NAPJM6�_KRM:P7@62¹�_���3n� ��� ������������������� �"!$#%��!$�����&���', � � � *�� -�/ ,op7I8G:P7N8GAP7NA�HI6G=ISB6!_KR>6!JC?F=IS[=KLM:PSF:�SBR�RMJ>A�SF8cw>6!OQ:HI=I:PSFS[=NAPOQ=Z�eR>JM:EF6GhPAC7N:�:�j!6GEFA2;>EF6GOQ6!SFS[6¾�$6vS[RyA<?B?BA�EB6!hPAP7N6HI= =@JIde6!EB6!J>j!:M]THIRM6s;T6!E8G=N:CSB8GR>JD83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` A.�eRMJM:i;Z6GE�7�X =@JK?BEFAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6!7 83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` AiJM6GhP7N=£:PJC?F6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=Y]7�X :P7r?FEF:&;Z6GE~7�X =NJK?BEFAWH>R>jG=NAPJ>6�HI6!7£83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` AQJ>6!=£83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJK?B=��­n5�����=�@$��= 3=5�� 7U¦ �u�c � �V�-�n

�WACJ>A�:PSFSB=@ACO&=V?BRI?B?B607N6�SB6!_KR>6GJMjG6l=NJ¹8GR>=u7YX =@JTS[=N6GOQ6�H>6GhP7N=u:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B=v6l7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6�HI6!=v8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?F=wM:PJ>J>AQR>JM:yde;D=NJ08GAPOyR>J>6Pn1�8��$@A|�8

<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N@:�@$<D�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8(<>8�=�:;@A<>��8��$�>8�<$9�=23r� � 7��Y:&H>R>6�;>EF6GOQ6!SFS[6¾�­¦� � �V�- � � �V�-�

� � �V�- ���<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N@:�@$<D�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8(<>8��A|�=[N&<$9�8 :�8�yD8�<$9�=�3 � 5 70��:&R>JT:Q;>EB6!OQ6!SFSB:K�­¦

�~�-��-� � ��u�c¢��� � �

<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N�yD=��b�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8_<>8�=�:;@A<>�b8��$�D8�<$9�=23r� � 70��:&R>JT:Q;>EB6!OQ6!SFSB:K�­¦� � �V�-s�c�� � �V�- ���

<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N�yD=��b�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8_<>8��A|�=[N&<$9�8�:;8�yD8�<$9b=�3r� 5 70��:QHIR>6�;MEB6!O&6kSBSB6k�3¦�~�- � � �~�-� � �

�u�c¢��� � �

Page 89: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

���

<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�:�@$<>yD=�?�=�@$<>N&|�8(<>8�=�:;@A<>�b8��$�D8�<$9�=23@� � 70��:&R>JM:Q;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:C�3¦�u�c � �m�c�� � �m�c � �

<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�:�@$<>yD=�?�=�@$<>N&|�8(<>8��A|�=[N&<$9�8�:;8�yD8�<$9b=�3@� 5 7��Y:QHIR>6�;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB6k�­¦� � �V�- �u�-� � �

�~�- � � � �<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N�<D8��$N&?�=�@A<>8(<D8�=�:�@$<D��8��A�>8�<$9b= 34� � 70��:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:C�3¦

�u�c � �� � �m�1��

<W<$9bLk@�yD�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N�<D8��$N&?�=�@A<>8(<D8��$|�=�N&<$9b8 :;8�y>8�<$9b=�34� 5 7��Y:QR>JM:&;>EF6GOQ6!SFSF:C�­¦� � �V�-�~�c�� � �

�W=�HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:�d�:P83=N7NO&6!JK?B68cwM6�=N7�8!:<7\83AC7@Aif6�83ACEBEF63?B?BAM]K83=NAMf628cwM6�APhCJ>=�S[6k_CRM6GJK?B6�HI6GEF= ` :PL>=@7N6sf683APEFEF63?[?FAl�ehC7@=:PSFSB=@ACO&=(SBAPJ>A0S[6k_KR>6GJK?B=*8GAPEFEB6G?[?B=^6QS[6&7@6Q;>EF6GOQ6kSBSB6yHI=*RMJM:lEF6GhCAP7\:,SBAPJ>A083ACEBEF63?B?B6lf6y83ACEBEF63?B?BA�=@7mSB6!_KR>6!JC?F683ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJK?B6v:<7N7YX :<;>;M7@=\8G:PjG=NAPJ>6VH>6G7N7N:�EB6!hPAP7\:C�3nD�W=I;>R^fAHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6V:<JM8cwM69=N7K?B6GACEB6!Oi:2HI=I83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:2deAPEB?B6Pn�*6!H>=N:PO&A&?FEB6�6!SB6GOQ;>= HI=£HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM=ZJM6G7£8!:<7\83AP7NAQHI6G=£SB6!_KR>6!JK?B=�¦

���b8��Jx�=�@lH

� �B�����b�B� � ��� x�� �� �(x���y�����s���<�­�F� � �

�£�F� � �b�B� � x�� � � �B�W�B� � � � x�� �� �¹x � ` ��£�F�W�B����� � �

� �(x�������������<�­�B� � �� �m� ������������<�­�F� � �����

� � � ��������s���<� � ����� �����<�� �g� �

� �������s���<�V���Y�����r�y���<�[����b8��Jx�=�@�E

�s���C��� � �W�c�P�Y��� x�� �$�����C�Y�£�B� � �W�c� � x�� �� �¹x ����¥�P�Y�l���W��� � �W�F�

�����W�[� � �W�F�C�[� � x�� �M�l���W�[�b�c� � �W�F� � x�� �� �¹x ����¥�P�Y�l���W�[� � �W�c�

� �(x ����¥�P�Y�����W������� � �W�c�� �m� ����¥�C���l���W�Y����� � �v�0�

���b8��Jx�=�@ �� � � �B� � x�� �D�£�B� � ��� x�� �

� �¹x ��l���W��� � �� �(x ������W��� �c�(� �� �m� ������W�c�(� � �Z�� � � ������ � �(��� �Z�

� � ����������� ���� !�������� !���� � !J)����$-

Page 90: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

� ��� ��� �&��/ ����� ��� ����� #%��� ����� � � � # -�/�,�!$�&# �?�(��! !�� ,�W6sSB=�?B=N6GJ>6�;MEB6kS[6!JC?F6�7N:QS[?BEF63?[?c:&EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6�?BEc:&=@7$SB6!_KR>6!JK?B6�hP6!J>6GEF=\83AM¦

` �ba%a%a!�- d�� � ` �ba%a%a!�-� �6�7N:yde;$¦

�`m��aba%a!�9�d � �2`*��a%a%ak��� �f6�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6�:CSBSBAI83=\:<EF6�:P7$S[6k_KR>6GJK?B6�=N7£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6�=NJMS[=N6GOQ6�HI={de;DSB6GhCJM:b?F6P¦

���'�$� �` �º�%aba%a!� �+� ed �º��� � �2`"���ba%a%aG��� � � � �=NJ�_KRM:<JK?BA�=@7(SB6!_KR>6GJK?F6lf6�8GAPEFEB6G?[?FAlS[6y6ySBAP7NAlSB6�7\:ide;¹f6sR>JM:,?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=N:lS[6y6ySBAP7NAlS[6y7YX =NJMS[=N6GOQ6y�¥J>APJ¢f6SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N6Pn

��:�_KRM:<JK?FAy:<LML>=N:POQA�:<;>;MEB6kS[AsJM6G7£�v:<;$nW|>]W7�X =NJMSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N=@?¾f:�H>=Z��f6�6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B6�:<7�8cw>=NRMHI6GEcSB=ZHI6!7 �7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA2S[6!Oi:<JK?B=\83A~:<7C83R>=<=NJ>=NjG=NA�SB=<;TACJ>6*R>J�?FEF:<?[?BA2H>=<EF:POQA283APJ�=<JMAWH>=��+� ` �º]@n!n3nG] �+� d �º] � � � ` ��]NnGn!n3] � � � � ��n¼DAIHI=@aT8cw>=\:<OQA&7N:Q83AKSU?FEBRMjG=NAPJ>6�HI6G7N7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA&OQ6G?[?B6!JMHIAQJ>6!={J>AIHI=Y]>:PJ>jG=\8cwu®6�SB=@J>hCAP7N6�de;0SB6GhPJT:b?B6C]IHI6G={L>7NAI8G8cw>=HI=*de;¢SB6GhCJM:b?F6&8cwM6,83APEFEF=NSB;TACJMHIACJ>A�:P=*EF:POQ=mHI6G7N7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA�JM6G7N7N:D8GACS[?BEFR>jG=NAPJ>6Q;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6Pn �RT:<JMHIA0=NJ�R>JL>7NAI8G83A ` =�f6,R>JM:Dde;¢S[6!hPJM:<?F:D83RM=9SB=9:<;M;>7@=\8G:.R>JM:DEF6GhCAP7\:�H>6G7Vo�?F=@;ZAM](=N79L>7NAI8G8GA.S[RM8!836kSBSB= ` A.83ACJC?F6GEFE¾f:M]£:<7;ZACS[?BA�HI6!7@7\:�de;,=NJ,_KR>6!S[?B=NAPJ>6C]P7N6�SBR>6�83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>j!62HI=@EF63?B?B6C©K_KRM:PJMHIA�=NJ,R>JiL>7NAI8G83A ` =£f6~R>JM:�de;,SB6GhCJM:b?c:�83R>=SB=$:<;>;>7N=\8G:yR>JM:&EB6!hPAC7N:sH>6G7{o[o9?B=N;ZAM]I=N7{L>7@AI8!83A ` =N6GJM6�SB6GhCR>=@?BAM]I8GAPJlLM=rdeACEF8!:<jG=NAPJM6P]IH>:QHIR>6�L>7NAI8G8cw>={83=\:PSF83RMJ>AHI6!=v_KRM:P7@=v83APJK?F=@6!J>6P]*:<7v;ZACS[?BA�HI6!7@7\:Dde;¹=@J¢AChPhC63?[?FAM]^R>JM:�HI6G7N7@6�S[RM6l83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!J>jG6Cn(�*AP7N6GJMH>A�SB=V;ZACSFS[ACJ>A83ACJK?BEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:PEB6s7N6&de;�OQ:PJ�OQ:PJ>A08cw>6,S[=m:P;>;>7N=N8!:<J>A�7N6iEB6!hPAP7N6PnU�2J�L>7NAI8G83ADSB=m8cw>=NRMHI6,_KRM:<JTHIAD83APJK?F=@6!J>6R>JM:sde;�SB6GhCJM:b?c:�6�7\:�SBRM:�8GAPJ>=NR>hK:b?F:i��6;Z6GEuSB6GhPJT:<7\:<EF628cw>6�=N7TLM7@AI8G8GAlf68cw>=@RTS[Ay;TACJ>=N:POQA��b:P7@7�X 6kSU?F6GEFJ>AK�3n��I67NAyS ` =N7NR>;>;ZAy83ACJMHIRM8G6:�LM7@AI8G8cwM=Z8cw>6�S[=�8cw>=NRMHIACJ>A�?BR>?[?B=�]>:<7N7NAPEc:�=@7�L>7NAI8G83Ay:<7N7N:�EF:CHI=N8G6�f6�=NJMSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6 ` �<n�*6!H>=N:PO&A&?FEB6�6kS[6!O&;M=Yn���b8��Jx�=�@lH

� � � �º]9�+� � �p]� � � � � �+� � ��]� � � ��]�� � � � ������

�+� ����� ���K]_�+� � ��� � � �

�+� ����� �º]��$� � �J�+� �(� ���

�$� ����� ��]9�+� �y�_�(� ���

�$� ����� ��]�� � �u�r�y�_�(�<�/���

� �@�r�����<�m� �u�r���_�(�<�/���

opJl_KR>6kSU?FA�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]W=NJ�8GR>=�J>6G7ZL>7NAW8!83Ay=@J>=NjG=\:<7N6�f6�;>EF6!SB6GJK?B6R>JM:&S[AC7N:�de;�SB6GhPJT:b?F:y83ACJ��v]WSB=Z;T6!E ` =N6GJ>6�:HIR>6L>7NAW8!8cw>=�8cw>=@RTS[=(�e=NJ�_KR>6!7@7NA�:�SB=NJ>=NS[?BEc: ` = f6�� � � �{6e�+� � �º©W=@J�_CRM6G7N7@A&:�HI6kSU?FEF:2�$� � ��6�� � � ���­nV�9=ºfA&S[=NhPJM=raT8!:8cw>6�7\:&de;��r�����<�m���u�r�y�_�(�<�f6�R>JM:y?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:>n� � �I& #F� �5�F�IC>C>� #F�5#FL>#B���F& & C>���4�4# �4@5# � �<� ���F�,!5��� � � �#!�#F��C/.5#F@$!5&>D � #%!$&O�F�F� ��H$#F�F@5�$���,&>K @5# H����F& ��� � � �� & @5�5�,� ��@$�4���F��?�#B��G-

�I&(#F� �5�F� C>CO�<#F�5#FL>#B���F& &�� � � � � !F-O->-�! � � ��� � ! � � ) �#!�#F��C/.5#F@$!5&>D � #%!$&O�F��� ������&>D � � �5�F� C>C/.5#3� #F?��$# �JCO� C0.5&") & C>���5� &>?�@5&>�5LO�A�F��?�#FCO�!5# �N� � � ����� � ��� !3���4� #B�<C/.5& � � � ����� � ��� ) ) &,@5�J� � ��@$�4���F��?�#B�$- �I&,#F� �5�F� C>CO� #F�$#FLO#B���F& &�� � � � � !F->-O-�! � � ��� � ! � � ) � �#!->- -�! � � )�� � !�#F�%C/.5#F@5!$&OD4� #%!5&>�F��� ������&>D �<� �5�F� COC0.5#3� #F?��5# �JCO�,C/.5& �B� 1 � � � � ����� �A� � ) ) � % ����� % )�� &(@5�J�,�M��@I� ���F��?�#B� � &K @5#F�5!5#�C0.5& #F�2�4&OK @5&>�0� & C>��D D4#F� �����5!5&>�0� & & C>��D D4&>���4� G-

Page 91: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� }���b8��Jx�=�@�E

�$� � �º]� � � ��]� � � � � �$� � �º]�� � � ��]� � � � ������

�$� ���¥� ���K]�� � � �º]� � � �

�$� ����� �º]9�+� �Z� ���W]� � � �

x2JT8cw>6~=@Ji_KR>6kSU?FA�6!SB6GOQ;>=NA�SB=>;Z6GE ` =@6!J>62:�HIR>6~L>7NAI8G8cw>=T8cw>=@RTS[=�]P;Z6GEV8GR>=>7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6~=@J>=NjG=\:<7N62HI=Ide;,SB6GhCJM:b?F6f6�=NJMS[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6P©>SB=(f6�SU?c:<L>=N7@=@?BAi_KR>=NJMHI=£8cwM6~�����W�1�Z� � �»�Wn���b8��Jx�=�@ �

�+� ����� �º]� � � �º]9�+� � �º]_�+� � � �

� � � �º]� � � ��]_�+� � �º]9�+� �� � �+� � ��]�� � � �º]9�+� � �p]��$� � � �������� � � � � � � �

�+� ����� ���W]� � � �º]9�$� � ��]9�+� � �������������� � � � � � � �

�$� ����� ��]�� � �~��� ���W]9�$� � ��]9�+� � �

�+� ����� �º]� � �2�l� �º]_�+� � �º]� � �^�� �

�+� ����� �º]� � �2�l� �º]�� � �����^� ���

x2JT8cw>6�=NJ _KR>6kSU?FA¹?F6GEFjGA 6!SB6GOQ;>=NAgSB=�;T6!E ` =N6GJ>6�:¹LM7@AI8G8cwM=�8cw>6�SB=�8cwM=@RMH>APJ>ATn ½(6GEB?F:<JK?FAM]27�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6J>6!7L>7NAI8G8GA¹:<7N7N:¹EF:CHI=\836.EF=NSBR>7@?F:q=NJMSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn �W=�;>R fA :P7@7NAPEc:q83ACJM837NRMHI6!EB6�8cw>6�7\:�de; �r� � �<����[���2���<�{���r�����^�<�[��f6�R>JT:&?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=N:M]W6�=N7£SB6!_KR>6!JC?F6P¦�l��� � �2�l�W�Y�����^�

f6�83ACEBEF63?B?BATn1�8��$@A|�89x[8�L�|�N@:�@$� 9bLk�>?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|���N&|�{¢8;L�@ N�{�|�@ : :��D=�W6����R�$� ` �º�%aba%a3�-�+� d �º��� � � ` �º�%aba%a!��� � � � �º]M:<7N7@ACEF:M¦

����� ��� ���

��� �����

����� ��� ������� ���

��� �������

!��� ��� ���

��� ���

""" # # #

��� ��$����

% �!� ��� ���

��� �&�

""" # # #

��� �(')�&�

�+*,� ��� ���

-�� �.���

�/*,� -�� ���

-�� ���

000 # # #

��� �������

1*,� ,�� ���2��� �&�

��� ��$����

% *-� ��� ������� �&�

-�� �(')�&�

¿£:08GACS[?BEFR>jG=NAPJ>6QHI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA.:�L>7NAW8!8cw>=VSB=*6!SB6GhCR>6i:<;>;>7N=\8G:<JTHIA07@6iEF=NSB;Z63?[?F= ` 6iEB6!hPAC7@6Q:<=mLM7@AI8G8cwM=*deAPhC7@=N6J>6!=VEc:<OQ=mhP=pf:083AKSU?FEBR>=@?B=VaMJ>A.:CH�RMJ¢836GEB?BA.S[?F:CHI=NAMn�x�7V;>EFAI836kHI=@OQ6!JC?FA.HI6G7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAD:DL>7NAW8!8cw>=VSB=m;ZACSFS[ACJ>A:PHM:b?[?c:<EF6&?BRI?B?B=v=mEF:PhP=NAPJM:POQ6GJK?B=mS ` AC7r?F=mJ>6G7u�v:<;>=@?BAC7@A.|M] 6,_KR>=NJMHI=vS[=m;ZACSFSBAPJ>A.HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6y= �£6!APEF6GOQ=VHI=83ACEBEF63?B?B6!jGj!:y6�83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:0��deACE[?F6k�3n

Page 92: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

� � � � � ��# +�,(��-�� / ��# ,���!$#%��!$����� ��� , � � � *��'-�/�,�� , � � � / ����� ��� ����� #%��� ����� #�?�(��! !�� ,

�W6����¤���+� ` ���ba%a%a!� �$� d �º��� � � ` ���ba%aba3��� � � � ����6�=@JMH>=N8cw>=\:<OQA,8GAPJ �¾� �I=@7£SB6!_KR>6!JK?B6P¦�`b�ba%a%a!�-�d � �2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� �

SB= ` 6!H>6d�:C83=N7@OQ6!JC?F6s8cw>6�7@AiSF8cw>6GOi:QHI=£:CSBSB=NAPOQ={HI6G7£8!:<7\83AC7@AQHI6G= S[6k_CRM6GJK?B=$SB=$;>R fAiSF83EF= ` 6GEF6P¦�¾�.� �$� ���� � � �� �

6Q8cw>6y:P7@7N6�EF6GhCAP7N6s;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F=^8GAPEFEB=\S[;ZAPJTHIAPJ>AlAPEcHI=@JT:b?F:POQ6GJK?B6s7N6&EB6!hPAP7N6�HI6!7*8G:<7\83AC7@A�HI6G=*SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=^8cw>6&S[=A<?B?B6!J>hPACJ>AiSB8!:<O�LM=N:PJMHIA&;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[6�6s83ACJM837NRMSB=@ACJ>={6�OQ63?B?B6GJTHIAP7N6�?BEc:QS[LM:PEBEF6PnV�9AKSºf ��]>:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]T:<7N7N:�}!:K�83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6P¦�¾�.� � � �� ��¾�.� �$� ���� �

8cw>6�SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:>¦�`¾�%aba%a!�-ed � �2`¾�%aba%a!�-� ���- ` �ba%abaG�- d �1�� � � ` �ba%aba3�-� �

ACSFSB=N:y7N:&EF6GhCAP7\:yHI=£=@JK?BEFAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7N7N:&J>6!hC:PjG=NAPJ>6�J>6!hP7N=$:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B= � �(x �pnx27N7\:yEF6GhCAP7\:U�P:C�v83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6P¦�¾�.�-�+� �º� �$� � � ��¾��� �+� ¹�9� � �

8cw>6�SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:>¦�`b�%a%abaG�cedy�-s�c� � �2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� � ` �%aba%a!�- d �- ��� � � ` �%aba%a3�c� �

ACSFSB=N:y7N:&EF6GhCAP7\:yHI=£=@JK?BEFAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7N7N:Q8GAPJ>hC=@R>JMjG=NAPJ>6�J>6!hP7N=$:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B= � �(x �pnx27N7\:yEF6GhCAP7\:y|C:C�v83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6P¦�¾�.�-�+� � � �¾�.� �$� � � �

�¾��� �+� ¹�9� � �8cw>6�SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:>¦

�`<�%a%abaG�cedy�- � �2`¾�ba%abaG�-� � �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d��c� � �2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� � ` �%aba%a!�- d �- ��� � � ` �%aba%a3�c� �

ACSFSB=N:y7N:&EF6GhCAP7\:yHI=£=@JK?BEFAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7N7N:QHI=\SBhP=NR>J>jG=NAPJM6�JM6GhP7N=£:PJC?F6!8G6!HI6!JC?F= � �(x���nx27N7\:yEF6GhCAP7\:S�K:C�v83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6P¦�¾�.��� � � � �¾�.�-�+� � � �

�¾�.� �$� ��� � �8cw>6�SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:>¦

�`<�%a%abaG�ced � ��`b�%a%aba3�-� �{�c �`¾�ba%abaG�-�d��c� � �2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� � ` �ba%abaG�- d �c � � � � ` �ba%abaG�-� �

ACSFSB=N:y7N:&EF6GhCAP7\:yHI=£=@JK?BEFAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7£8GAPJMH>=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6JM6GhP7N=£:PJC?F6!8G6!HI6!JC?F= � �¹x �ºnopJ�OQAIHIA�:<JM:P7@AChPA2SB=W;>R fA�83APJTSU?c:b?F:PEB6Vd�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6u83ACO&6v:<7N7@6vEF6GhPAC7@6�}GLT�3];�bLT�3]<|<LT�£6��PLT� 83ACEBEF=NSB;ZAPJMH>:PJ>A7N6�EB6!hPAP7N6�HI=$=NJC?FEBAIHIRMjG=NAPJ>6�HI6G= 83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =£J>6G=£8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?F=�� �m� �p] � �m� �p] � �m� �£6 � � � �ºn

Page 93: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� |x2hC7@=$:CSBSB=NAPOQ=$HI6G7$8!:<7\83AC7@AQHI6G= S[6k_CRM6GJK?B=£SBAPJMA&:CSBSBAI83=\:b?B={HI6!=$L>7NAI8G8cw>=£8cwM=@RMSB=�n��:,_KR>6!S[?F:,8GAPEFEB=\SB;TACJMHI6GJMj!:QS[=^;>R fA�HI6!HIRMEBEF6�_KRM:<JK?FA,S[6!hPR>6C¦vSB6�J>6!hP7N= :P7@LZ6GEF= :iLM7@AI8G8cwM=Y]�:<7 ;TAKSU?FAlHI6G=L>7NAI8G8cw>=*OQ63?B?B=\:<OQA07@6iSB6!_KR>6!J>jG6Q83ACEBEF=NSB;ZAPJMHI6!JK?B=�]$_CRT:<JMHIA07�X :P7@LZ6GEFA�f6Q8cwM=@RMSBA��e=NJ�?FRI?[?F6i7@6&deAChP7N=@6 ` =mS[ACJ>AL>7NAI8G8cw>={8cw>=NRMSB=\�3]>S[6�S[=$8!:<;ZA ` AC7@hC627YX :<7NLZ6GEFA��eAKSBSB=\:ySB=�;>EBAI8G6!HI6�H>:<7N7N6�deAChP7N=@6 ` 6!EFSBA�7\:�Ec:PH>=N8G6k�9S[={AP?[?B=N6GJM6R>JT:HI6!EB= ` :<jG=NAPJM6J>6!7£8G:P7N8GAP7NA&H>6G=£SB6!_KR>6!JC?F=Yn�*6kHI=\:<OQAP7NAi:y;MEBAC;TAKS[=@?BAQHI6G=$?BEF6�6kS[6!OQ;>=$;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=Yn

���b8��Jx�=�@lH��� 3��!«c«1n�5 �o#1VW�X#%!X\�5*«c�",0,05F��*&�"!$��#%!X\�5� � � ��]T�$� � �º] � � � � � � �£�F��+� � ��]X�+� � �º]�� � � � �W��� � ��+� ����� �º]&�+� � �º]�� � � � �,���W��� � ��+� ����� �º]&�+� � �º]&�+� �(� � �,���W���£�1�(� ��+� ����� �º]&�+� ���_�(� � �,���W���y�9�(� ��+� ����� �º]�� � �u�r�y�_�(�<�/� �,��� � �u� �y�_�(�<�� �@�r�����<�m���u� �&�9�(�<��� � �r�����<�m���u�r�y�_�(�<�

x27N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAl:iL>7NAI8G8cw>=(S ` =N7NR>;>;M:<?BA,J>6!7@7�X ¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA.}y8GAPEFEB=\S[;ZAPJTHI6�7N:�S[6!hPR>6!JK?B6�HI6!EB= ` :<j!=@ACJ>6�HI6!7^8!:<7\83AP7NAHI6!=£S[6k_KR>6GJK?B=�¦� � � �B� � x�� �¢�W��� � ��� x�� �

� �¹x ��l���W��� � �� �(x ������W��� �c�(� �� �(x�������W�Y���_�(� �� �m� ������ � �u� �&�9�(�<�

� � � �� �r�����<�m���u�r�y�_�(�<�

���b8��Jx�=�@�E���R>6kSU?c: ` AP7@?F:&SB8GEB= ` =N:PO&A&HI=NEB6G?[?F:POQ6GJK?B6�7\:yHI6!EB= ` :<j!=@ACJ>6JM6G7$8G:P7N8GAP7NA&H>6G=$SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=�8cwM6�8GAPEFEB=\SB;TACJMHI6:P7@7�X :<7i�LZ6GEFAQ:&L>7NAI8G8cw>= S ` =N7@R>;M;M:b?FA&JM6G7{;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F6�¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA/�>¦

� � � �B� � x�� � � � � �B� � x�� �� �(x ������ � � �B�

� �(x ������W�c�Z� � ����b8��Jx�=�@ ���x2JT8cw>6�=NJ _KR>6!S[?BAg8G:CS[A¹SF83EF= ` =\:<OQA¢SBR>L>=@?BA 7N: HI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>6DJ>6!7�8G:<7\83AC7@A¢H>6G=�S[6k_CRM6GJK?B=�8cw>6�8GAPEFEB=\SB;TACJMHI6:<7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA&:&L>7NAI8G8cw>= S ` =N7@R>;M;M:b?FA&JM6G7$;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6�¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA&|M¦

�����W��� �[� � � � x�� �� �[� � �£�F��� x�� � �£�B�W�B� � ��� x�� �

� �¢x�������W�Y�£�[� � �� �m� ������W��� �[� � �u���

� �m� ������W�Y� � �~���W�1�^�� � � ������ � �~���W�Y�����^�

¡ ` =\HI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6~SB=>A<?B?B=N6GJ>6~RMJM:�HI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>6uJ>6!7M8G:P7N8GAP7NA�HI6!=MSB6!_KR>6GJK?F=MS[AC7@A�_KRM:PJMHIA�7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA�:�L>7NAI8G8cw>=f628cw>=NRMSBAl��:P=ML>7NAI8G8cw>=MdeAPhC7@=N6283ACEBEF=NSB;ZAPJMHIACJ>A�:PSFS[=NAPOQ=MH>6G7�8G:<7\83AC7@A�HI6!=ZSB6!_KR>6!JK?B=��­n(¿£:s8GAPEFEB=\S[;ZAPJTHI6GJ>jk:?BEc:�=@7OQ63?FAWH>AyHI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA�SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GAy:�L>7NAI8G8cw>=Z6�=@7�8G:P7N8GAP7NA�HI6G=�SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=Z8GAPJMSB6GJK?B6HI=Z?BEc:PS[de6GEF=@EF62:<7�8G:P7N8GAP7NA�HI6G=SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=^7N6&;>EBAC;>EF=@6G?¾f:lH>=(8GAPEFEB6G?[?F6GjGjk:i6Q83APOQ;>7N63?F6Gj!j!:�HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:<?B6y:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=r?FA�HI6!7(O&6G?BAIHIA0HI6G7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFASB6GOi:<JK?B=\83ATn

Page 94: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� �

Page 95: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� � � � ������ � � ��������� � ������� � �µ� � � �

52ACJiS[RMHMHI= ` =\HI=\:<OQA�hP7N=I6!SB6GEc83=NjG=>:�S[6k83ACJMH>:�HI6G=M8!:<;>=@?BAC7@=I=NJi_KRM:<JK?BA�:P7N8GR>J>=>HI=>6kSBSB=I;ZACSFS[ACJ>A�6!SFS[6!EB6uS ` AP7@?B=I=NJ;>=[fR0O&AIHI=�]M8GAPJ�?B6k83J>=\8cw>6�6!SB;TAKSU?F6�=@J0OQAPOQ6!JC?F=$HI=@tZ6!EB6!JC?F=£HI6!7{?B6kSU?FAMnm¿mX APEcHI=NJ>6�HI6GhC7@=£6!SB6GEc83=NjG=�]>83APOyR>JM_KR>6C]SB6GhPRM6�:PL>LM:CSU?c:<J>jk:sde6kHI6G7NOQ6GJK?B6�7NAiS ` =N7@R>;M;TA,HI6!7@7\:y?BEc:b?B?F:<j!=@ACJ>6Pn}Cn���=\SB8GRI?B6!EB6�S[6�=@7u83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` ADL>=\:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?F:P7@6q�BOQ:C��f6,A�J>APJ f6 ` 6GEFA"��deR>J>j!=@ACJM:<7N6PnDx�=@RI?c:<JMH>ACSB=983ACJ6!SB6GOQ;>=uSU?c:<L>=N7@=NEF6�SB6�=N7~83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` A�LM=N:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?F:P7@6¹�B:DOQ6GJMA�8cw>6k�¢f6 ` 6!EBADdeRMJ>jG=NAPJM:P7@6�6P]m=NJ 8!:PSBA:bt�6GEFOQ:<?B= ` AT]K6kS[;MEB=NOQ6GEF7@A&=@J�deR>JMjG=NAPJ>6sHI=~�FS[6Cn@nNnN]>:<7N7@ACEF:Mn@nNn ��6D�[J>ACJM�>n�>n2x2=NRI?F:PJMHIACSB=$83ACJ�7N6sHIR>6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>=�¦

�F5�:<;ZAP7N6GACJ>6yf6�deEF:PJM836kS[6C]IO&6!JK?BEF6�¼�:<jGj!=@JM=(f6�=r?c:<7N=N:PJ>AC��c�9AC7@ACO�LZAywT:iSB8GAP;Z6GEB?BA&7YX x2OQ6GEF=\8G:&OQ6GJK?BEF6�¬�:<EF=@LT:<7\HI=�OQ:PEF8G=N: ` :&S[R � EB6!JK?BAC�SU?c:<L>=N7@=NEF6�SB6�=@7 83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` A��[OQ6GJK?FEB6k�,f6 ` 6!EBA��YdeRMJ>jG=NAPJM:P7@6Cn

|Mne�K?F:PL>=@7N=NEB6C]�8GAPJ�AP;>;ZAPEB?BR>JM= 6kS[6!O&;M=Y]$8cw>6&=*83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` =^OQACJ>AC:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?F:P7@= S[6!hPR>6!JC?F= JMAPJ�SBAPJMA ` 6!EBA��deR>J>jG=NAPJT:<7N=y�e=N7 ` :<7NAPEF6.HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:¢HI=��J>ACJ HI6G?B6GEFOQ=@JT:qR>J>= ` AI8G:POQ6GJK?B6.=N7 ` :P7@ACEB6�HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:qHI6G7N7\:;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6u8GAPOQ;ZACS[?F:C�3¦� f¡�;TAKSBSB=NL>=@7N6�8cw>6u�>©(� f¡�JM6!836kSBSF:<EF=NA�8cwM6e��M© �F¼.:<Ec836!7@7NA�83EF6!HI628cw>6���>©�B¼D=\8cw>6G7N6�SB:Q8cw>6��>©*� f¡gLZ6GJ0J>AP?BAi8cw>62��Mn�Tn���=\SB8GRI?B6!EB6yS[6C]MJ>6!7@7N6ySB6GhCR>6GJK?B=£;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=Y]T7N:,H>=NSBhP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6Qf6�=NJM837NRMSB= ` :.��J>APJ.6kSB8G7@RTS[= ` :C�uA,6kSB8G7@R&�S[= ` :>¦

�F§G�g�[opJ,8G6GEB?B6�de6GEFOQ:<?B6=@7T?BEc:<O de6GEFOi:�SBAP7NA�SB6 ` =ZSBAPJ>A�;T6!EFSBAPJ>6�8cw>6H>6 ` ACJ>AsSF836GJTHI6GEF6�AC;>;>R>EF6SF:<7N=@EF6!�M©�BªF�g�F¬�=NA ` :<J>JM=�SB=$=\SB8GEB= ` 6!E¾f:y:&OQ:<?B6!OQ:<?B=\8G:&AP;M;>R>EF6�:&aZS[=\8G:C�>©�B«F�g�Bx�7$83ACJM83ACEFSBA&SBAPJMA&:PO&OQ6kSBSB=$83=@?[?c:PHI=NJ>=$=@?F:P7@=\:<J>=£AP;>;>RMEB6�83ACJ>=NR>hP=$HI=$8G=r?B?F:CHI=@JM=$=r?c:<7N=N:PJ>=\�>©�c�G�g�B½*:PAP7NAySB;TAKS[6!E¾f:&¼.:PEB=NJM:yAP;>;>RMEB6s¬�:<LMEB=N6G7N7N:C�>n

�>n2x27\HIAM] �vEFR>J>AQ6y�v:<EF7@AQSBAPJ>Ay?BEF6sSU?FRMHI6!JC?F=£8cw>6�wM:PJ>J>AiS[AKSU?F6GJWRI?FA&RMJ�6kSB:POQ6Pn*½(APJ>6!JMHIAT¦� � �Fx27\HIAQwM:QS[RM;T6!EF:<?BAQ7YX 6!SF:<OQ6k�� � � �vEBR>JMAywM:iSBR>;Z6GEc:b?FAy7�X 6kSB:POQ6!�� � �­�v:<EF7@A&wM:QSBR>;T6!EF:<?BAQ7�X 6kSB:PO&6k�

HI63?F6GEFO&=NJM:PEB6�7@6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>={8GAPOQ;TAKSU?F6�8cw>6�?BEc:PHIRT83APJMAy=£SB6GhCR>6GJK?F={6GJWR>JM8G=N:<?B=�¦�F§G�g�c�IAP7NAi�v:PEB7NAywT:iS[R>;Z6GEc:b?FAy7�X 6!SF:<OQ6!�M©�BªF�g�c�IAP7NA&x�7NHIAiJMAPJ�wM:QS[R>;Z6GEc:b?FAQ7YX 6!SF:<OQ6!�M©�B«F�g�c�IAP7NAyR>JMAQH>=£x27\HIAM] �9EFR>J>AQ6��v:<EF7NA&wT:&SBR>;Z6GEc:b?FA&7�X 6!SF:<OQ6!�M©�c�G�g�Bx�7@OQ6!J>AQR>J>AiHI=£x�7NHIAT] �vEBRMJ>AQ6s�v:PEB7NA&wM:iS[RM;T6!EF:<?BA&7YX 6!SF:<OQ6!�M©�-#F�g�Bx�7@OQ6!J>AiHIR>6�?BEc:Qx27\HIAM] �vEFR>J>AQ6y�v:<EF7NAywM:PJ>J>AiSBR>;T6!EF:<?BAQ7�X 6kSB:PO&6k�>©� ^U�g�Bx�7{;>=[fR0H>R>6�?BEc:Qx27\HIAM] �vEFR>J>A&6y�v:<EF7@A&wM:PJ>J>AiS[RM;T6!EF:<?BAQ7YX 6!SF:<OQ6k�>©

� �

Page 96: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

�PÀ��rk�g�B¡9SB:<?[?c:<OQ6GJK?B6�HIR>6�?FEF:Qx�7NHIAT] �vEBR>JMA&6y�v:PEB7NA&wM:<J>JMAQSBR>;Z6GEc:b?FA&7�X 6!SF:<OQ6!�Mn

À n2x2J>hC6G7NAM] �9EFR>J>A�6��v:<EF7NA�S[ACJ>AshC7@=TR>J>=\83=Z?BEF6�OQ6GOyL>EF=THI=�R>JM:y83ACO&OQ=\SBSB=NAPJ>6�8cwM6 ` AP?F:�R>JT:s;>EFAP;ZACS[?F:Mn½(APJ>6!JMHIAM¦� � �Fx2J>hC6G7NA ` A<?c:y:&d�: ` APEF6HI6!7@7\:Q;>EFAP;ZACS[?F:P�� � � �9EFR>J>A ` A<?F:&:yd�: ` ACEB6�HI6G7N7\:y;MEBAC;TAKSU?c:P�� � �­�v:<EF7@A ` AP?F:Q:yd�: ` APEF6H>6G7N7N:Q;>EFAP;ZACS[?F:C�

HI63?F6GEFO&=NJM:PEB6�7@6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>={8GAPOQ;TAKSU?F6�8cw>6�?BEc:PHIRT83APJMAy=£SB6GhCR>6GJK?F={6GJWR>JM8G=N:<?B=�¦�F§G�g�B¿ : ` A<?c:<jG=NAPJM6yf6�S[?F:<?F:&R>JM:PJ>=@OQ6k�>©�BªF�g�B¿ :�;MEBAC;TAKSU?c:lf6�;M:CSBSF:b?c:y:&Oi:<hChP=NAPEc:<J>jk:P�M©�B«F�g�B¿ :�;MEBAC;TAKSU?c:ywT:yEF=\836 ` RI?FAQR>J0JKRMO&6!EBAQHI=\S[;T:<EF=$HI= ` AP?B=\�>©�c�G�g�B¿ :�;MEBAC;TAKSU?c:lf6�S[?F:<?F:&EB6kS[;M=@JK?F:M]IOi:yJMAPJD:<7N7YX R>JM:PJ>=NO&=@?¾f:C�>©�-#F�g�B¿ :�;MEBAC;TAKSU?c:lf6�S[?F:<?F:&EB6kS[;M=@JK?F:Q8GAPJ�=@7 ` A<?FA&8GAPJK?BEc:<EF=@AQHI= �vEFR>J>AC�M©

Á ne�W6�= ` :P7@ACEB={HI= ` 6GEF=@?¾f:>]I:PJ>jG=\8cwu®6 � 6�w�]>SBAPJMAy=NJMHI=\8G:<?B=£8GAPJ�={JKRMO&6!EB= � 6i}Q�eACSFSB=N:&S[=£;TACJ>6��Z���V��}:<J>j!=N8cwu®6 �����v��� 6 ������V� � :PJ>jG=\8cwu®6 �Z���9�zw2�­] ` 6GEF=raZ8G:<EF6�8cw>6P¦�F§G���������9��}�� �Z����BªF������¹�9�y�m� ����� � �����&��B«F������¹�9�y�m� ������� �����&��� �Z��� � �Z���y��c�G������ ���&�m��}�� ������� ������ � �Z���y��-#F����������&�m� ������ � �Z���y��� �U}�� �����B� � �U}�� �Z���y�B�V��}�� � �������� �Z���y� �

� n�9APJ�7N6iJ>AP?F:<j!=@ACJ>=*HI6G7N7�X ¡9S[6!EF8G=@j!=@A Á 6iS[deEBR>?[?F:PJMHIA07�X =NJK?B6GEcHI6GaMJ>=NL>=@7N=@?¾f:0HI6G=983APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =�]£HI6G?B6!EBOQ=NJM:<EF67@6�deR>J>j!=@ACJ>=£:PEB=@?BOQ63?F=N8cwM6�EF6G7\:b?F= ` 6�:>¦�F§G�������l�y��BªF������ �"�&��B«F���������y�

� n�9APJMSB=NH>6GEc:<EF6=N7£83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` AQ?FEB=\:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?F:P7@6 � ?c:<7N6s8cw>6�������-�l�c���9� ��SB6�6sS[AC7@AiSB6�R>JDJWR>OQ6GEFAHI=NSB;M:PEB=V?BEc:�s][��69� SBAPJMA ` 6!EB6Cn��I83EF= ` 6GEF6,7\:D?c: ` AP7\:DHI= ` 6!EB=@?¾f:�HI6G7u83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` A.6kHq6!SB;>EF=@OQ6!EB7NAO&6kHI=\:<JK?B6�7\:yLT:PSB6y���v�F�v�c�9�Cn �~=N;T6G?B6!EB6�7�X 6kS[6!EF8G=@j!=@A&Oi:Q83APJ0=N7$83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` Ai_KRM:PH>EB=\:<EFhPACO&6!JK?F:<7N6Pn} � n~¡VSB;>EB=NOQ6GEF6=$8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` = �v]��¤6�Q=@J�deR>JMjG=NAPJ>6sHI= � n}P}Cn~¡VSB;>EB=NOQ6GEF6=$8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` = �v]��¤6��W=NJ�deR>J>jG=NAPJM6�H>=�Mn}��>n ��6G?B6GEFOQ=@JT:<EFJ>6�=@7$8GAPJ>J>6G?[?F= ` A&;MEB=NJM83=N;M:P7@6�HI6!7@7N6sS[6!hPR>6!JK?B=�de;$¦

�F§G�����u�r�y�����Z���[�[��BªF���[���Z�Z�$�����u���Z�Z�B�[��B«F�����u���u� �������(�<�[�B�[��c�G���[�r�������(�<�[�v�����^�<�B��-#F��� �����B���(�<�V�����^�<�[�[�� ^U���[�r�����<�$�����������Z�Z�[�B���rk���[�B�[���Z�Z�V���<�£�l�<�V�����(�<�[��sn<���[�B� �y���<�{���<�V���r�y�����u�l�<�B�[��K5r���[�B� �����<�9������� �Z�B�$�����u�r�y�0�k�B�[�� 3 ���[�B�[�r�y�����(�<�[�9���<�V���<�9���r�����<�[�

Page 97: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

�WÁ� .����[�B�[�B���u� �Q���<�[�$���<�m���������<�B�$���<�$���[���(�<�$�y�Z�[�� !K���[�B�[�B���Z�Z� ���<�$�l�<�9���e�s���<�[�£���Y�~���B���(�<�£�y���[�[��c�G���[�B�[�B�[���Z���£�����~�y�Z�B�m���<�V���<�$���<�$���[���(�<�£�y�Z�B��+*I���[�B�[���Z�Z�£�����~�y�Z�B�m���<�V���Y�v���Y�u���B���(�<�£���Z�B�[�B��-VF���[�B�[���Z�Z�£�����~�y�Z�B�m���<�V���B�[�Y�u���<�$�����(�<�B�£�y�Z�B��K,[���[�B�[���Z�Z�£�����~�y�Z�B�m���<�V���B���~���<�{���[���(�<� �y�Z�[�B�

}!|Mnu�K?F:PL>=@7N=NEB6�_KRM:<7N=$HI6!7@7N6sS[6!hPR>6!JK?B={6!SB;>EF6!SFS[=NAPJM=�SBAPJMAyde;£¦�F§G��� �����r�����(�<�[��BªF���[���Z�Z�$���r�������(�<�B�[��B«F��� �����<�m���(�<��c�G���[�B�[�r�����<�{���e�s���[�[�9�����(�<�B�V���<��-#F���[�B�[�B� �����<�m�����u� �0���<�V���<�V���<�$���<�� ^U���[�r�������(�<�[�v���[�B�e�2�����~���b�B�V�����(�<�[�B���rk���[�r�������(�<�[�v���[���u���Y�u���<�[�9���<�[��sn<���[�B�[�r�y���<�$�����2���¾�B�m�����u�r�y���<�[�[� ���Y�~�����^�<�[�[��K5r���[�B���Z���$�����(�<�[�9��� �����������e�s���Y��� ���[�[�B�[�� 3 ���[�r�����<�V�����u�Y�s���e�~�0�k�B�[�B�� .����[�B�[�B� �������u�0�¾�[�£���<�£�l�<�V���b�9���[�

}%�Tn~x2L>L>EF6 ` =\:<EF67N6�de;DHI6G7N7�X ¡9S[6!EF8G=@j!=@A�}!|&S[AC;>;>EF=@OQ6!JMHIAQ7@6�;T:<EF6GJK?B6kS[=�=NJ>6!SFS[6!J>jG=\:<7N=�n}��>n �~=@;MEB=\SU?F=@JT:<EF67N6�;M:<EF6GJK?F6!SB=ZJM6G7N7@6sSB6GhCR>6GJK?B=�de;DSF83EF=r?B?B6�=NJ�deAPEFOQ:&:<LML>EB6 ` =N:<?F:>¦

�F§G�&�l� �(��BªF�(�Z�����(��B«F�(�u� ��� �(�<��c�G�&������� �^�u����-#F�&�����������^�2�l�<�� ^U��� ���������^�<�£�����rk��� �����Y�����^�<�B� ����sn<�&������� �u�e�2�l�<��K5r��� �����v�_�^�<�9���� 3 ��� �����<�$�����^�����<�� .��y�l���Y�v�_�^�s���<�� !K�y� ���u����c�G�&�l���u���e� ���Z�Z�

} À n ��6G?B6GEFOQ=@JT:<EF6�7\:y?F: ` AP7\:yHI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:QHI6G7N7@6�de;DHI= 83R>=$:P7@7�X ¡9S[6!EF8G=@j!=@A�}��>n} Á nu�K?F:PL>=@7N=NEB6�SB6�7N6sSB6GhPRM6GJK?B=�de;DSBAPJ>AQAQJ>APJ0SBAPJ>A&?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=N6P¦

�F§G���[�r�����<�V���<�{�_�Z��BªF���[�r�����<�V���<�m� �Z��B«F��� �����v�_�(�<�V���Z��c�G���[�r�����<�V���<�V���[�e�s� ���m���Y��� �Z�B��-#F��� � � ���9�Z��� ���Z�� ^U��� �����b�£���Y�s���¾�m�����^�2�_�*����Z�&���(�<���rk��� �����Y�u���<�[�9��� �����Y�s���<�[�

Page 98: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

���

�sn<���[�r�����<�V���u�Y��� �Z�[� ���u� � ���<��K5r��� � ���<�$���r� ���(�<�� 3 �(�Z�����r���������<�� .��y� ���B� �����<�$��� ���_�(�<�[�� !K��� ���������<� ���B� �����<�$���Y�����b�B�

} � n6�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6�8cwM6�7N6�de;06G7N6GJM8!:b?F6�JM6G7*z0�In |&H>6G7^�v:P;$nX�&S[ACJ>A&?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=@6Cn} � nu�K?F:PL>=@7N=NEB6�SB6� � � � 6��¾AiSB6�� � � ¤J>6G=$SB6GhCR>6GJK?B=$8!:PSB=Y¦

�F§C� � �u�r�����<� � � �u� �&���<��Fª!� �q�������u���<� � � � �����<�$����F«!� �q�l���Y����� �����<�B� � � ����� �����Y�s� �Z�B��c�>� � �r�����<�£�,� � �¢������c#¾� � �u�r�����<� � � �(��i^{� �q�����������<� � �¢����� � ���l���rI� �q� � � � �����<�V� ��snM� � �r�����<�m�����s� ��� � � � � ���<�$�����(�~�y�Z�� 5º� � �u�r�����<� ���������^�<� � �¢������� �^�� 3�� �q���������^� � �¢���_�(������ � n �:<?F:&7N:yde;(s¦

�F§G��� �����<�$���u�r�y���<��BªF��� �����<�$���Y�s� �Z��B«F�&���_�Z��c�G��� �����b�£���Y�s���<�

HI63?F6GEFO&=NJM:PEB6�:<7NOQ6GJ>A&?BEF6�de;D8cw>6�S[=\:<JMAQ8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMj!:y7@AChP=\8G:&HI=�sn�I}Cn6�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6�8cwM6 ` :P7@6���� � ¤J>6G= S[6!hPR>6!JC?F=$8G:CS[=�¦

�F§C� ���¤�F�l���W�B�����b�c�^�K� � �Z��Fª!� ���¤�F�����^�b�Y�����W�B�C� � ��F«!� ���¤�F�l���(�W�c�(�s���^�K� �¢�����^��c�>� ���¤�F�l�����s���Z���­��� ���K� � �(�~���Z��c#¾� ���¤�¾�v���b�Y�,�¥�W�B��� �$� �¢������i^{� ���¤�F�l���W�B�����b�[�s���C�c�*�C�Y�y� �c� � ���rI� ���¤�W� �����<�{���e�2�0�¾�­�!�r�����<�$�������¥�¾�­�1�^�K� � ��snM� ���¤�F�l���W�c�^�s���Y�����[�3�[�~���r���0�k�3�c�^�K� � �u� �� 5º� ���¤�F�l���W�������e�2���<�­�c�����^�b�1�u� �y���<�­� � �*�V�_�(�� 3�� ���¤���Z���_�(�W�������K� � �� .,� ���¤�F�l���~�l�b�1�(�����u�_�*�P� � �s���� !�� ���¤�F���l�����b�1�*����u� �V� ���3�[����� �V� �{�c� �¢�����Y�����¾����>n6�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6�8cwM6�JMAPJ ` :<7N6���� � ¤J>6!=$S[6!hPR>6!JK?B=$8G:CS[=�¦

�F§C� � ���B�l���W�B�����C�Y�����P� � �u�l��Fª!� � ���k�u�r�����<�3�c�Z�y�9�(�s���~���C�c����c� � ��F«!� � ���B�s�_�(�W�c�u���^�����*�¾�­�1�u���Z�Q�9�*�¾�­� � �(������c�>� � ���B�l���Y�u���<�­�F�s���Y�9� �[�3� �m� �^�c�u� �&���¾�­� � �Z��c#¾� � ���B� ���Y�u���<�­�F� ���e�~�y�Z�­�B����� �����<�­�1�Z�$� � �u�l��i^{� � ���B�l���W�F�����b�B��� �£����� �^�C� �¢���_�(���rI� � ���B�s���W�������^�K� �¢�������^� ���<�

Page 99: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

���

�<|Mn6�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6�SB6 ` :<7N6�� � � ¤J>6!=£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B=$8!:PSB=Y¦�F§C� ���¤�W� �l���<�m� �$� �¢��Fª!� ���¤�F�$� � � �����<�m� ��F«!� ���¤�F�$� � � �����<�m����c�>� ���¤�F�l���W�B�~�l�C� �¢������c#¾� ���¤�F���l�W�Y�����^�K� �¢�������^�����<��i^{� ���¤�F���l�����b�1�*����u� �V� ���3�[����� �V� �{�c� �¢�����Y�����¾���rI� ���¤�F�l���W�[�s���(�W�!����� �Z�Z�m���K� � � �{������� �V���¾��snM� ���¤�F�����Y�s���<�­�F�����������[�3�������*�C�c�<� � ������ 5º� ���¤���Z���_�(�����b�c�9�9�^�K� �¢������ 3�� ���¤���Z���_�(�W�!�e�s� ��� ���(�W�F�P� � �V���� .,� ���¤�¾�v����� �£�1�(�W�����9�^�K� � �Z�� !�� ���¤�F�����u�Y�~�l�<�3�c�(�W�c�u�r�&���<�c� �¢������c�P� ���¤�F�����u�Y�~�l�<�3�c�(�W�c�u�r�&�_�^�<�c� �¢�

���Tn6�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6�8cwM6�=N7£SB6GhCR>6GJK?B6�=NJMSB=@6!O&6���HI=�de;DJ>ACJ�f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@6C¦�F§G�����¤�F���������2���C�1�^�b���$��BªF�����¤�F�,���W�[�s���(�W�c�u�r�����^�<�c��B«F�����¤�F�,���W�c�u� ��� �����<�c��c�G�����¤�F�,���W�����������b�c�u� �&�l�<�3���$��-#F�����¤�F�,���W�!� �����b�9���9���W�Y���������b�1�*�P�Y�$�� ^U�����¤�F���������b�B�~���s��� ������� ���[�B�­�Y�y�0�P�1�u�Y� ���[�c���rk�����¤�W� ���9�(�<�£���P�1�Z�y�����Z�����<�­�1�u���s���¾�c��sn<�����¤�F�,���W�B����� �����2���¾�­�[� ���C�c�u���2���¾�3���$��K5r�����¤�F���������^�b�[�2���Y�9� �[�­��� ���W�c�u� �0���¾�c�� 3 �����¤�W� �����<�$���b�c�*�� �u���2�l�b�3�B�s���r����� �[�­� �$���*�P�

���>n �:<?F:&7N:yde;$¦�F§G�(�u� �����<�V���v����BªF�(�u���(�s� �����<��B«F�&�����������~�9�Z����c�G�(�Z� ���Y�����<��-#F�(�u� � ���<�� ^U�(�Z��������� �Z���rk�(�Z�����u�Y�u���<�

?BEc:PS[deAPEFOQ:PEB7\:�=NJ0R>JM:Q7NAPhP=\8G:POQ6GJK?B6�6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B6�8cw>6s8GAPJK?B=N6GJ>6C¦�e=��0SBAP7NAy=£8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` =D�v]Z���=@=��0SBAP7NAy=£8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` =D�v]Z��e=N=@=��0SBAP7NAy=£8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` =D�v]��

� À n ��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cw>6C¦�F§G�0SB6� � � �»6S� � � ���,]Z:<7N7@ACEF:�� � �u�� �9���3©�BªF�0SB6� � � �»6S�� � � �&]M:<7N7@ACEF: � � � �_�&©�B«F�0SB6���� � ¤6�� � ����l]>:<7N7@ACEF:y� � � �,©�c�G�0SB6 � � �� � 6� � � �&]M:<7N7@ACEF:U� � � �&©�-#F�0SB6�5�APJA�IAWH�� �������6s5�APJA�WAIH����.������P]T:<7N7@ACEF:&52ACJA�WAIH��qn

Page 100: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} � �� Á n ��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6=�� 6GACEB6!OQ=�HM:<7D�>n �Tn �y:<7��>n �Tn@}C}�HI6!7*z1�>n �iHI6!7 �v:<;$n$�In� � nu�K?F:PL>=@7N=NEB607N6�EF6GhCAP7N6�;Z6GEi7\:�83AKSU?FEBR>j!=@ACJ>6�H>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBAqSB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GA�;Z6GEiJ>AIHI=HI6G7u?F=@;ZAJ�+� ���� �26

� � �� � ��n� � nu�K?F:PL>=@7N=NEB6.7N6.EF6GhCAP7N6D;T6!El7\:¢83AKSU?FEBR>j!=@ACJ>6.HI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA¹SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GAq;T6!E�J>AIHI=�HI6G7?B=N;ZA��+� �l� ��6

� � �l� �ºn| � n6�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6�SB6�=£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B={Ec:<hC=@ACJM:<OQ6GJK?F=�SBAPJMA&8GAPEFEB6G?[?B=�n

�F§G�(�W6s�v:<EF7@A&wM: ` =@JK?BA&7\:yhK:<Ec:>]W:<7N7@ACEF:�¼.:<EF=@A�f6�:<EFEB= ` :b?FA�S[6k83ACJMHIA&AP;>;>RMEB62�W6GEFhP=NAlf6�:PEBEF= ` :<?BA?B6!EBj!AMnQ¼.:<EF=NA�f6i:<EFEF= ` :b?FA�SB6!8GAPJMHIATn �RM=@JMH>=Y]^S[6l�v:<EF7NA�wM: ` =NJC?FA�7\:�hC:PEF:M]$:<7N7@ACEF:9�W6GEFhP=NAJ>ACJ�f6�hC=@R>JK?FAy?F6GEFjGATn�BªF�(�W6s�v:<EF7@A&wM: ` =@JK?BA&7\:yhK:<Ec:>]W:<7N7@ACEF:�¼.:<EF=@A�f6�:<EFEB= ` :b?FA�S[6k83ACJMHIA&AP;>;>RMEB62�W6GEFhP=NAlf6�:PEBEF= ` :<?BA?B6!EBj!AMn[�W6!EBhC=@A&J>ACJ�f6�:PEBEF= ` :<?BAy?B6!EBj!AMn �R>=NJMHI=�]MSB6s¼.:<EF=@A&J>ACJ�f6�:PEBEF= ` :<?BAQS[6k83ACJMHIAM]>:P7@7NAPEc:�v:<EF7NAyJ>ACJ�wT: ` =NJK?BAQ7\:yhK:<Ec:>n�B«F�(�W6��v:<EF7@AswT: ` =@JK?FAy7\:shK:<Ec:>]C:P7@7NAPEc:�¼.:PEB=NA,f6�:<EFEB= ` :b?BAyS[6k83APJTHIAs62�W6GEFhP=NAQf6:PEBEF= ` :<?BA�?F6GEFjGATn¼.:PEB=NAyJMAPJ�f6�:<EFEB= ` :b?BAQSB6!83ACJMHIATn(½(6!E[?c:<JK?BAi�v:<EF7@AQJ>ACJ�wT: ` =NJK?BAQ7N:QhK:<Ec:>n�c�G�(�W6~�v:<EF7@A~wM: ` =@JK?BA�7N:�hC:<Ec:>]¾:<7N7NAPEc:>]!SB69¼�:<EF=@A�f6v:<EFEB= ` :b?FA2S[6k83APJTHIAM]¾:<7N7@ACEF:u�I6GEFhP=NA�f6V:PEBEF= ` :<?BA?B6!EBj!AMn~¼.:PEB=NAiJ>APJqf6�:<EFEB= ` :b?FA,S[6k83APJTHIAMn �R>=NJMHI=�]TA0�v:<EF7@AiwM: ` =NJK?BA,A9�W6GEFhP=NA0f6�:PEBEF= ` :<?BA?B6!EBj!AMn�-#F�(�W6�d�:<Ebf:yLT6!7{?B6!O&;ZA,:<JTHIEB6!OQA&:&;M:CSBSB6GhChP=NAMn>�I6sSU?c:<EF6GOQAy=NJ08G:PSF:yhP=NAW8cwM6GEF6GOQA&:&8G:PE[?F6Pn��:<JTHIEB6!OQAl:,;M:CSBSB6GhChP=NAQA�S[?F:<EF6GOQA,=NJ�8!:PSF:>n �RM=@JMH>=Y]�A,d�:PE¾f:,LT6!7 ?F6GOQ;ZAlAlhC=@AI8cw>6!EB6!OQA,:8G:PE[?F6Pn� ^U�(�W6�hP=NAW8cwM=96�SU?FRMHI=~S[RM;T6!EB6!EF:P=VhP7N=v6!SF:<OQ=Y](Oi:�SB6�hP=NAW8cwM=V6lJMAPJ¹S[?BRMH>=vJMAPJ¹SBR>;Z6GEF6GEc:<=VhC7@=6!SF:<OQ=�n&½(6!E[?c:<JK?BAT]$S[6QhC=@AI8cw>=�]$:<7N7@ACEF:�ADSU?FRMHI=*6,SBR>;Z6GEF6GEc:<=(hP7N=*6!SF:<OQ=(A0J>APJ�SU?FRMHI=m6QJ>ACJSBR>;T6!EB6!EF:P=�hP7N={6!SF:<OQ=Yn��rk�0¿mX :b?B?F:C8G83AEB=NRMSF83=NE¾f:�SBAP7NASB6v=N7IJ>6!O&=\83A&f6u83AC7r?FA�H>=>S[ACEB;>EF6!SF:~A�SB697\:�;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�f6v;TAI8GA�HI=@de6!SF:>nop7£JM6GOQ=N8GAiJ>APJ.SF:<Ebf:Q83AC7r?FA,HI= SBAPEF;>EF6!SF:&:QOQ6!J>Al8cw>6sJMAPJD:<L>LM=N:iEF=\836 ` RI?FAiEB=NJIdeACEBj!=Yn6�W6s7\:;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6,f6y;TAI83A�HI=@de6!SF:�:P7@7NAPEc:Q=@7(J>6!OQ=N8GAlJ>ACJ�wM:lEB=\836 ` R>?BAlEF=NJIdeAPEFjG=�n �R>=NJMHI=(7�X :<?[?c:P8G8GAJ>ACJ�EF=@RTSB8G=@Ebf:>n�sn<�(�W6-�v=\:<JM8cw>={JMAPJ0wM:&=@JT83APJK?FEF:<?BA �~ACSFSB={7N:&J>AP?[?B6sSF83ACEFSF:>]I:P7@7NAPEc:�A �2ACSFS[={6!EF:&7�X :CSBSF:PSFS[=NJ>AyA

�v=N:PJM8cw>=>OQ6!JC?F6Pn�W6 �~AKSBSB=>J>ACJQ6GEc:�7YX :PSFSB:CSBSB=NJ>AM]<:P7@7NAPEc:*�9=\:<JT8cw>=>J>ACJ&wT:�=@JT83APJK?FEF:<?BA �~ACSFSB=7\:0J>A<?B?B6lSF83ACEFSF:�6,=@7vHI6G7N=@?[?BAqf6l: `W` 6GJWRI?FADHIAP;ZADOQ6GjGjk:<J>AP?[?F6Pn(�W6,=N79HI6!7@=@?[?FAqf6,: `W` 6!JKR>?BAHIAC;TA07\:0O&6!jGjk:<J>AP?[?B6C] :P7@7NAPEc:lA �2ACSFS[=*6!EF:�7�X :CSBSF:PSFS[=NJ>A�A �v=N:PJM8cw>=*OQ6GJK?B6Cn�½(6!EF8G=ºfA �~ACSFSB=6GEc:y7YX :PSFSB:CSBSB=NJ>AMn�K5r�(�W6i7�X =NJ ` 6kSU?F=@OQ6GJK?FA0H>6G=98!:<;>=@?F:P7@=*EF=NOQ:PJ>6,83AKSU?c:<JK?B6C] :P7@7NAPEc:�8GEB6kSB8G6GEc:<J>JMA�7N6,S[;Z6!SB6,HI6!7mhPA��` 6!EBJMA,AP;>;MR>EB6&S[= ` 6!EB=@aT8cw>6!EF:PJ>J>AQde6!J>APOQ6GJM=(H>=^HI=\SBAW8!83R>;T:<jG=NAPJM6Pn2�W6�J>ACJ�:<RMO&6!JK?B6GEc:<JMJ>A7N6&SB;T6kS[6iHI6!7(hPA ` 6!EBJMAM]Z;TAP?BEc:<J>J>A�6!SFSB6GEF6�EF=NHIAP?[?F6y7N6&?F:PSFSB6Pnj�W6&7N6y?c:PSFS[6&;ZA<?BEc:<JMJ>Al6kSBSB6GEF6EF=NHIAP?[?F6,6,7�X =NJ ` 6!S[?B=NOQ6GJK?BA�HI6G=u8G:P;>=r?c:<7N=VEF=@Oi:PJ>6l83AKSU?c:<JK?B6C] JMAPJ¢SB=v: ` Ec:<J>J>A�de6!J>APOQ6GJM=vHI=HI=\S[AI8!83R>;M:PjG=NAPJ>6Cn �RM=@JMH>=£:<R>OQ6!JC?F6GEc:<J>JMAy7N6sS[;Z6!SB6�HI6G7£hPA ` 6!EBJMAMn� 3 �0¿£:��CR ` 6!JK?BRMS(wM: ` =NJK?BA�7N:�;M:PE[?F=r?c:�A�=@7M¼.=@7\:<J$]KS[6uwM:�hC=@AI8!:b?BA�=NJi8G:PSF:>]bwT: ` =NJK?BA�7\:�;M:<EB?B=@?F:Mn

�W6y7YX opJK?B6GEwM: ` =NJK?BAM]�:<7N7NAPEc:,S[6�=@7(¼D=N7N:PJ.wM: ` =NJK?BAM]Z=N7^¼D=N7\:<J¢f6y8G:<OQ;>=NAPJM6yH{X oº?F:P7@=\:>n��I6�7\:�CR ` 6!JC?FRMSuwM: ` =@JK?FAM]M:P7@7NAPEc:�7�X opJC?F6GE~wM:Q;Z6GEcSBAMn*¿mX opJK?B6GE�wM: ` =NJK?BATn �R>=@JTHI=Y]TS[6�=N7£¼D=N7N:PJ�wT:hP=NAI8G:<?BA&=@JD8G:CSB:M]I:<7N7@ACEF:lf6�8G:PO&;M=@ACJ>6�H{X oº?c:<7N=N:Mn

� .��_�W6v=@7>¼.=@7\:<J ` =NJM8G697\:�;T:<EB?B=@?F:>]C:<7N7@ACEF:��CR ` 6GJK?BRMS^6vopJK?B6GE*SF:<Ec:<J>JMA�=NJ&SB6!8GAPJMH>:�;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6Pn>�I67\:��CR ` 6GJK?BRMSuAQ7�X opJK?F6GE�f6�=NJ0SB6!8GAPJMHM:�;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6�SB:PE¾f:yJ>6k836!SFSF:<EF=@A&R>J>AiSB;M:<EF6GhChP=NAMn �R>=@JTHI=Y]SB6�=N7£¼D=N7\:<J ` =NJM8G6P]MSF:<Ebf:�JM6!836kSBSF:<EF=NA�R>J>A,SB;M:PEB6!hPhP=NAMn� !K�_�W6v=@7I¼D=N7\:<J ` =NJM836v7\:�;M:PE[?F=r?c:>]<:P7@7NAPEc:��CR ` 6!JC?FRMS AopJK?B6!E^SF:<Ec:<JMJ>A�=NJySB6!8GAPJMH>:�;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6Pn>�I6�CR ` 6!JC?FRMS(6~opJK?B6!EVSB:PEF:PJ>J>A�=NJQSB6!8GAPJMHM:;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6C]C:<7N7NAPEc:SF:<Ebf:�J>6!8G6!SFSB:PEB=NARMJ>A�SB;M:<EF6GhChP=NAMn�R>=NJMHI=�]>S[6�=N7£¼D=N7\:<J ` =NJM8G6P]MSF:<Ebf:�JM6!836kSBSF:<EF=NA�R>J>A,SB;M:PEB6!hPhP=NAMn�c�G�(�W6,=N79_KRM:CHIEF=@7\:b?F6GEFA���2f6iR>J¹EBACO�LZAM](:<7N7@ACEF:0:<7NOQ6GJ>ADRMJ>A�HI6!=vHIRM6i?BEF=N:PJ>hPAC7@=���*6��� �2f6

Page 101: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} � }=\S[AKSB8G6G7N6Pn(�W6���~f6i=NSBACSF836!7@6C]^:P7@7NAPEc:�� �VJMAPJgf6iR>J¢EFAPOyLTATn_�I6,=@7v_KRM:PHIEF=N7N:<?B6GEFA � � �~f6lR>JEFAPO�LZAM]I:P7@7NAPEc: � ��JMAPJ�f6�=NSBACSF836!7@6Cn �RM=@JMH>=Y]MSB6� �(f6�R>J0EFAPO�LZAM]>:P7@7NAPEc: � � ��J>APJ07NA�f6Pn

�+*I�(�W6~J>6kSBSBR>J>A�HI6!=THIRM6u?BEF=N:PJ>hPAC7@= � 6 � � f6u=NSBACSF836!7@6C]P:<7N7@ACEF:=N7M_KRM:PHIEF=N7N:<?B6GEFA� � f6~R>JQEFAPOyLTATn�W6� ��f6~=\S[AKSB8G6G7N6P]C:P7@7NAPEc: � �$f6~R>JiEBACO�LZAMn�W62=N7T_KRM:CHIEB=N7\:b?B6!EBA� � �MJ>APJDf6~RMJiEBACO�LZAM]C:P7@7NAPEc:�� ��J>ACJ�f6�=\S[AKSB8G6G7N6Pn �R>=NJMHI=�]>S[6 ���J>APJ�f6�R>J0EBACO�LZAM]>:P7@7NAPEc:��� ��7NA�f6Pn

|>}Cn �:<?B6�7@6sSB6GhCR>6GJK?F={;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=Y¦�F§G�g�c�I6�x�7NH>AQ:PJMHIEbf:Q:<7N7N:&hP=@?F:M]>:<JM8cwM6*�vEFR>J>Ai83=$:PJMHIEbf:P��BªF�g���vEFR>J>A&Al�v:<EF7@AT]KOi:QJ>ACJ�6!JK?BEc:<O�LM=Y]>:PJMHIEc:<J>J>AQ:<7N7\:yhC=r?c:P��B«F�g� � �:PEB=NAQAQ¡V7raTA&AQ6!JC?FEF:PO�L>=$:PJMHIEc:<J>JMA&:P7@7\:&hP=@?F:P��c�G�g� ��:<EF=NAy6��v:<EF7NAQ:PJMHIEc:<J>JMAy6!JC?FEF:PO�L>=$:P7@7\:yhP=@?F:QAQJ>6!SFSBR>J>AiHI6G=$H>R>6s:<JMH>E¾f:C��-#F�g�c�I6�¡V7raTAQ:PJMHIEbf:y:P7@7\:&hP=@?F:M]>:<JM8cw>6�x�7NHIAi6 ��:<EF=@Ai:PJMHIEc:<J>J>AQ:<7N7\:yhC=r?c:P�

S[={;>R^fAQH>6!HIR>EFJ>6s8cw>=$:PJMHIEbf:&6�8cwM=$J>APJ0:<JTHIE¾f:Q:P7@7\:&hP=@?F: �|;�>n~526G7$8!:<7\83AC7@Ai:PSFSB=@ACOQ:<?B=\83A&HI6G7*zc�Mn �I]T�v:P;$nT�M]>HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cwM6P¦

�F§G���� ������� � �u�� � �&�[��BªF���¹���� � ��m� �B«F���¹�� � �&�V���[���� � �&�V� �y��c�G�_ ����� �����­�cs�1�� ������-#F�_ ����� ��������� ������� ��� ^U�_ � � �¹���� � ����V������� �&���rk�_ �¹���u��� �����V������V������������&��sn<�_ ����� ���������u�� �����&�V����K5r�_ � �l�c�¤���,�1�� ���P���� 3 �_ � �l�- � ��� ����� .��9s�c� ���u�� �����&�

|P|Mn �2J¹SB=NS[?B6!Oi:�:PSFSB=@ACOQ:<?B=\83A.8G7N:CSBSB=N8GA¹��SBACS[?F:PJ>jG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6�_CRM6G7N7@A�HI=v¨�=@7NLZ6GEB? ���96!EBJT:��WSc��:CSBSBR>OQ6�8GAPOQ6;>EB=NOQ=r?F= ` ={=£8G=@JT_CRM6s83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =��v]��v]T�v]Z� ] � 6�=$SB6GhPRM6GJK?B=£_KR>=NJMHI=\83=$SF8cw>6!O&= HI=£:PSFSB=@ACO&=�¦}¾� ����� � ���C� �� ���� � �y�B�m���� � �y�|K� �� � �&�m���[��� �����V���� �����B��W� ��� ���C� ��� ���À � �� � �&�m���[�� � ���m���� � � �9���[�Á � � ¢�9�� � � � ¢�9�� � �� � �&�m���[��� � �y�m����¹�_� ���y�[�} � � �� � �&�m���� ���y�}C}k� �� � �&�m����� ���}k�P� �� � �&�m���[��� � �9���� ���y�[�}k|C� �� � �&�m������� � ���}b�K� �����}k�P� ��� �

6�8GAPOQ6�R>J>=\8G:QEF6GhCAP7\:s=N7���b�"���e�u��!$#%!&�u¼.½(n��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6*7YX 6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJ>jk:u?BEc:2_KR>6!S[?BA8G:<7\83AC7@A2:CSBSB=NAPOi:b?F=N8GAv6v_KR>6G7N7@A�;>EB6kS[6!JK?F:b?FA~J>6G7Tz-�Tn �2HI6G7I�v:<;$nb��eACSFSB=N:M](HM:b?BA�8cw>6l=NJ¢6GJK?FEF:PO�L>=v7YX R>J>=\8G:�EB6!hPAC7N:�f6�¼.½(]^8cwM6l=NJ¹83=\:PSF83R>JMA�HI6!=vHIRM6�SBAPJ>A�H>6GEF= ` :<LM=@7N=Y]AP;>;ZAPEB?BR>JT:<OQ6GJK?B6?BEc:PH>A<?[?F=Y]MhP7N=$:PSFS[=NAPOQ=$HI6!7@7�X :P7r?FEBAW�­n

Page 102: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} � �|"�Tn~526G7vS[=\S[?B6GOi:.H>=���7N6G6!J>6lSB=9:PSFSBR>OQAPJ>A._KRM:<?[?BEFA.83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` =9;MEB=NOQ=r?F= ` =���v]V�v]V�v]V�¹�s6,=vSB6GhCR>6GJK?F=HI=@6k83=$SF8cw>6GOQ=£H>=$:PSFS[=NAPOQ=�¦

}¾� ����� � ���C� �� ����� � ���[�m�¸�[�� ���y�m���� �����B�|K� ��� ���W� ��� ����C� ����� � ���&�[�À � � ¢�9�Á � � � ¢�9�� � �� �����V���[��� � ���m���� ��� � ���[�� � �� � �&�m���[�� � ���&�m�����} � � ��� �

6�7�X R>J>=\8G:QEF6GhPAC7N:,f6�=@7������������ �"!$#%!&�u¼.½(n��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6*7YX 6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJ>jk:u?BEc:2_KR>6!S[?BA8G:<7\83AC7@A2:CSBSB=NAPOi:b?F=N8GAv6v_KR>6G7N7@A�;>EB6kS[6!JK?F:b?FA~J>6G7Tz-�Tn �2HI6G7I�v:<;$nb��eACSFSB=N:&8cw>6�=@JD8G=N:CSB8GR>J>AiHI6G= HIR>6�S[ACJ>AiHI6GEF= ` :PL>=N7@={hC7@=£:CSBSB=NAPOQ={HI6G7N7YX :<7@?BEFAK�3n�W6�S[=$SBACS[?B=@?BR>=\SF836Q} � �98GAPJ�} � X ���� ���� � �y���Y8cw>6&f6�HI6GEF= ` :PL>=@7N6�H>:�}k�m�F} � �[�vSB={A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�7\:y7NAPhC=N8!:;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6�=NJC?FR>=NjG=NAPJ>=\SU?c:>n��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cw>6�=NJ._KR>6!S[?!X R>7@?B=NOi:Q7@AChP=\8G:&J>APJDSBAPJ>AiHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N=$=@7 ;>EF=@JM8G=@;M=@AiHI6!7$?B6!EBj!AQ6!SF837NRMS[AD�� ����v6�7\:y7N6GhChP6�HI=$HIAC;>;>=\:&J>6GhK:<jG=NAPJM62��� � �SUdeEFRI?B?F:<JTHIAQ=@7$;MEBAI836kHI=NO&6!JK?BAiS[6!hPR>6!JK?B6PnopJC?FEBAIHIRT83=\:<OQA�?FEB6 ` :<7NAPEF=$HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf: � ]$}�6���6�7N6sSB6GhPRM6GJK?B=�?c: ` AP7N6�;T6!E~=£83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` =Y¦

��� �} }� �

� � �� � �} � �� � �

� } }} } �� } �

� � �} � �� � �

� ¹���� � �} � }� � �� } }} } }� } �� � �} � �� � �

� ¹�9�� � �} � �� � �

� } �} } }� } }� � �} � }� � � �

�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6~8cw>6u?BRI?B?B=ThP7N=M:PSFS[=NAPOQ=>HI6!7@7\:�7NAPhP=\8G:�=NJK?BR>=NjG=NAPJ>=\S[?F:�wM:PJ>J>AsSB6GOQ;>EF6 ` :P7@ACEB6 � 628cw>6~=N7q���������� ��!o#W!X�c]ISB6�:P;>;>7N=N8!:b?FAy:�H>R>6�de;�HI= ` :<7NAPEF6 � ]WwM:&83ACOQ683ACJM837NRMSB=@ACJ>6�RMJM:�de;0HI= ` :<7NAPEF6 � n ��SFS[6!E ` :<EF68cw>6j ���� 6h��� � J>ACJ�wM:PJ>J>A�S[6!O&;MEB6 ` :P7@ACEB6 � 6QHI6!H>R>EBJM6y8cw>6&J>APJ�S[ACJ>A,?F6GAPEF6GOQ=(HI6G7N7\:7@AChP=\8G:y=@JK?BRM=@j!=@ACJ>=NS[?F:Mn

|;�>nuopJ R>JM:¹H>= ` 6GEcSB:q:CSBSB=@ACOi:b?B=NjGjk:<j!=@ACJ>6DHI6G7�8G:P7N8GAP7NAq;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N60SB=�:PSFS[R>OQACJ>A¢83ACO&6�83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =;>EB=NOQ=r?F= ` =��¹6y� 6�=£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B=$SB6G=$SF8cw>6GOQ=£H>=£:PSFS[=NAPOQ=�¦}¾� ����� � ���C� �� ����� � ���[�V���B�� ���y�V���� �����[�|K� �B�� � �&�m� �9� �W� �� � �y�V������� �������C� �����À � �� �¸�� ������&�6�8GAPOQ6�R>J>=\8G:QEF6GhCAP7\:s=N7���b�"���e�u��!$#%!&�u¼.½(n��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6*7YX 6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJ>jk:u?BEc:2_KR>6!S[?BA8G:<7\83AC7@A2:CSBSB=NAPOi:b?F=N8GAv6v_KR>6G7N7@A�;>EB6kS[6!JK?F:b?FA~J>6G7Tz-�Tn �2HI6G7I�v:<;$nb��eACSFSB=N:.8cwM6�=NJ 8G=N:CSB8GR>J>A�H>6G=~HIR>60S[ACJ>A�HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N=vhC7@=u:PSFSB=@ACO&=uHI6!7@7�X :P7r?FEBAW�­n��W60S[=uSBAP;>;>EF=NO&60|C��S[=A<?[?F=@6!J>6~7\:�7@AChP=\8G:=@JK?BRM=@j!=@ACJ>=NS[?F:i�Y8­deEkn 7�X ¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NA�|��K� 6P]KS[62SB=MSBAP;>;MEB=NOQ62:<JM8cw>6 À �(S[=>AP?[?F=@6!J>627\:7NAPhC=N8!:O&=NJ>=NOi:<7N6Pn

Page 103: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} � || À nu�W=M83ACJMSB=NHI6!EB=NJ>A�7N6�HIR>6�SB6GhCR>6GJK?F=W?F: ` AC7@6~:�?FEB6 ` :P7@ACEB=$��EB6!7N:<?B= ` 62:<=THIR>6�8GAPJ>J>6G?[?F= ` =A��6��SF836!7r?F=T8GAPOQ6LM:PSB6�HI6G7{J>AKSU?FEBAi8!:<7\83AP7NAQ:PSFS[=NAPOi:b?F=N8GAK�98cw>6�=@JTHI=N8cwM=N:PO&Ai8GAPJ � ]$}�6��I¦

��� }} }� �

� � �� � �} � �� � �

� } �} } �� } �

� � �} � �� � �

�*6GEF=raT8!:<EF6&8cwM6P]£_KRM:P7NSB=N:CS[=*SB=N:PJ>A�= ` :P7@ACEB=*HI=¢s]�� 6]��� � ]9}yA��P�3]$hP7N=mSF8cw>6GOQ=mHI=m:CSBSB=@ACOQ=2��x��C�6��x�|K�~:PSFSBR>OQAPJ>AiSB6GOQ;>EF6 ` :P7@ACEB6 � n¢�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6C]TSB6��6� � ��wM:PJ>J>A ` :<7NAPEF6 � ]Z:<7N7@ACEF:Q:<JT8cw>6�»wM: ` :<7NAPEF6 � n �W=£AKSBSB6GE ` =$8cw>6P]MSB6S ` :P7@6i}�6S� ` :P7@6S�>]T:P7@7NAPEc:h � ��� � � ` :P7@6S�>n �6!H>R>EBJM68cw>6�7@A,SF8cw>6GOi:0��x�}k�vJ>ACJ0;>R fAi6!SFSB6GEF6�H>6GEF= ` :b?FAi:PSFS[R>OQ6!JMHIAi83ACO&6s:CSBSB=NAPOQ={S[AC7@AQhP7N=£SF8cw>6GOQ=V�Yx��C�v6��x�|K�v6�83APOQ6�EF6GhPAC7N:&¼.½(]IAKSBSB=N:Q8cw>6i�Yxs}k��f6�=NJMHI=N;Z6GJMHI6!JK?B6sH>:0��x��P�v6,�Yx�|C�3n

| Á n~½(6GEH>=@OQACS[?BEc:<EF6s7�X =NJMHI=N;Z6GJMHI6!J>j!:0HI=~�Yx��P�H>:���x�}k��6��Yx�|C��EF=@;Z63?F6GEF6�R>J�EF:PhP=NAPJM:PO&6!JK?BAl:PJM:<7NAPhCA,:_CRM6G7N7@AiHI6!7@7�X ¡9S[6!EF8G=@j!=@AQ| À ]MSBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIAQ= ` :<7NAPEF=$HI=D�� 8GAPJ$]MJ>6G7N7YX APEcHI=NJ>6P]£}P� � �G}�6s_KR>6G7N7@= HI=� � �83APJ � � � � � �c�>�c�>� � �!}P� � � � n| � nu�W6[ f6*RMJM:ude;$]¾=NJMHI=\8cw>=N:POQA283APJ��m���$7N:vde;sAP?[?F6GJWRI?F:�H>: ¹SBAP;>;MEB=NOQ6GJMHIAu?FRI?[?F=C=KS[6!hPJ>=CHI=PJ>6!hC:PjG=NAPJ>6Cn

�W= AKSBSB6GE ` = 8cw>6C]{:<;>;>7N=\8G:<JTHIA��¢:,RMJ�_KRM:<7\SB=N:CS[= 6!SB6GOQ;>=NAlHI=~��x�}k��A�HI=u��x��P�­]$SB=^A<?[?F=@6!J>6y:PJM83ACEF:,R>J6!SB6GOQ;>=NAyHI=(��x�}k�VA���x��P��e6�_KR>=@JTHI=�R>JM:�?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=N:K�­n��W= ` 6GEF=@aT8cw>=�8cw>6P]WS[6��m�� ���y�V6��m���9S[ACJ>A?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=@6C]M:<7N7NAPEc:&:PJM8cw>6��m���y��f6�R>JM:Q?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhP=\:>n6�W=£AKSBSB6GE ` =£8cw>6C]M=NJ ` 6!8G6P]MSB6�SB= :<;M;>7@=\8G:��q:CH0R>J6!SB6GOQ;>=NA�HI=(��x�|K�*J>ACJlSB=TAP?[?B=N6GJM6�=NJ,hP6!J>6GEc:<7N6~R>JM:s?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=N:Mn �6!HIRMEBJ>6�8cw>6�7NA�SF8cw>6GOi:sH>=Z:CSBSB=@ACOQ=��x�|K�^J>APJ0f6~HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N62:PSFS[R>OQ6!JMHIA�83ACO&6~:CSBSB=@ACOQ=$��xs}¾�(6s��x��P�^628GAPOQ6~EB6!hPAC7N:�¼.½(]<AKSBSB=N:�8cw>6s�Yx�|K�f6�=NJMHI=N;Z6GJMHI6!JK?B6�H>:0�Yxs}k�v6,�Yx��C�­n| � n~526G7$8!:<7\83AC7@AiHI6!7@7\:QHI6!HIRMjG=NAPJ>6�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6P]>HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF67�X 6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<L>=N7N=r?bf:iHI6G7N7@6sSB6GhCR>6GJK?F={EB6!hPAP7N6P¦

1�8��A@$|�N�yD=6=�<$9bL�@GyD�>?�=�@A<>8(y>8�|�|�N�yD=��b�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8_<>8��A|�=[N&<$9�8�:;8�yD8�<$9b=�3r� < 7U¦�`b�ba%aba3�-�dy�c ��2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > �-� �

�`b�%a%abaG�cedy�-�2`¾�%aba%a!�-� > �c¢��� �

1�8��A@$|�N�yD=68�|�=���=�<>N&?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�|�N�y>=����A=��D<>?�=�@A<>8_yDN&�$|�=�N&<$9�8�:;8�yD8�<$9b=�3r����7[¦�`¾�%aba%a!�-edy�- ��� � ` �%aba%a3�c d �- �

�`<�%aba%a3�ced&�-¢�9� � ` �ba%a%a!�- d �c� �

1�8��A@$|�N�yD=68�|�=���=�<>N&?�=�@A<>8�y>8�|�:;@A<>y>=�?�=�@A<>N&|�8(yDN&�$|�=�N&<$9�8�:;8�yD8�<$9b=�3@��� 7U¦�`b�%a%abaG�cedy�- � � � ` �%aba%aG�c d �-� �

�`<�%aba%a3�ced&�- � � � ` �%aba%aG�c d �c�� �

� � n �RM:<7NAPEc:D=N72L>=\83APJTHI=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6 � deACSFS[60:PSFS[RMJC?FA�8GAPOQ60;>EF=@OQ=@?B= ` AM]VdeAPEFO�R>7\:<EF6l7N6D_KRM:b?B?BEFA�EF6GhCAP7N6�HI=6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<j!=@ACJ>6�6�H>=$=@JK?FEBAIHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7£L>=N8GAPJMH>=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6JM6G7£8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6�6�J>6!hP7N=$:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B=�n

Page 104: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} � ��M}Cn ��6!EB= ` :<EF67N6sS[6!hPR>6!JK?B=$SB6!_KR>6GJMjG6�J>6G7 8G:<7\83AC7@AQHI6!7@7\:QHI6!HIRMjG=NAPJ>6�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6P¦

�F§G��� �u� �y�y���{����BªF��� �Z�y��� �����<��B«F���,����� �u�y��c�G��� �u� �y���<�$���Y�v�y�Z��-#F���,�����Y�v���<� � �����<�$���� ^U���,�,�¸�������<�­�Y����� �l�����rk���,����� �u���Z�&�9�(�<��sn<�����u���Z�y�_�(�<� ������K5r���,�����Y�v���<� � �����<�$���r���l�<�� 3 ���,�,�¥�W�[�����(� �����^�� .��(�,�,�¸�������<� ����� �����<�� !K�(�,�,�¸�������<� �^����� �����(�<��c�G���,�,�¥�W�[����� ���Z�����<�V����+*I���,�,�¥� �u� �&�9�(�<��-VF�����u� ���_�(�<� �l����K,[�(�,��������� ������m�[�(�,�,�¥�W�������s���b��� �����

���>nuopJ ` =NE[?PfRiHI6G7I?F6GACEB6!OQ:�H>=M83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:M]<;T6!E98G=N:CSB8GR>JM:�HI6G7N7N62HIAIHI=N8G=>EF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM=>HI=T8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJ>jk:�7NAPhC=N8!:HI6G7N7YX ¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NAJ�I}P]~SB=2A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�R>JM:qSB6!_KR>6GJMj!:qHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@6DJM6G7�8!:<7\83AP7NAqHI6G7N7\:¢HI6!H>R>jG=NAPJ>6DJT:b?BRMEF:P7@6Cn��6!EB= ` :<EFJ>6�_KRM:P7N8GR>JM:Mn

�C|Mn ��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�HI=NEF63?[?c:<OQ6GJK?F6�7\:i83ACEBEF63?B?B6!jGj!:yHI6G7N7N6�EB6!hPAP7N6�6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<L>=N7N=$;>EFAP;ZACS[?B6�J>6G7$?B6!S[?BATn���Tn �~=NSBAP7 ` 6!EB6:<7\83R>J>=�HI6!hP7N=�¡9S[6!EF8G=@j!=T;MEBAC;TAKSU?F=T=NJ�} Á ]Z} � ]T�I}6��"��OQ6!H>=N:PJC?F6�:P7@LZ6GEF=�:�L>7NAI8G8cw>=�n��I83EF= ` 6GEF67N:Q83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6GJK?B6�HI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>6�J>6!7£8G:P7N8GAP7NA&HI6!=£SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=Yn���>n ��=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6~7N:y83APEFEF63?[?F6Gj!j!:�HI6!7@7N6EF6GhCAP7N62HI6G7�8G:P7N8GAP7NA�HI6!=ZSB6!_KR>6!JC?F=T;MEB6kS[6!JC?c:b?FAsJ>6G7 z-�Tn �yHI6G7£�v:<;£n��Mn

Page 105: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � ���� � � �� ����� � � � ������ � � � � ����¥�

}Cn£opJ�hC6GJ>6!EB6y�[Oi:P�M]<H>:<7W;>RMJC?FA�H>= ` =\SU?c:H>6G7N7N: ` 6GEFA"��deR>J>j!=@ACJM:<7N=@?¾f:>]bSB=I83APOQ;ZAPEB?F:83APOQ697N:�83ACJ>hP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6�[6k�>n��-¤:QOQ6GJMAQ8cwM6��y�iS[=NhPJM=raT8!:ySBAP7N=@?F:<OQ6!JC?F60�BSB6�JMAPJ_�,]M:P7@7NAPEc:j�>n

�In 526!7@7\:�;>EF=@Oi:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6¹�BOQ6GJK?BEF6!� ��8GAPOQ6 �[Oi:P�K�­]�f6 ` 6GEFA"��deR>J>j!=@ACJM:<7N6�6DSB=283ACO&;ZAPEB?F:�8GAPOQ6�[6k�>©CJ>6G7N7N:�SB6!8GAPJMH>:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6Q�[OQ6!JC?FEB6k��J>APJ�f6 ` 6!EBA��YdeRMJ>jG=NAPJM:P7@6C]¾;TAC=N8cwu®6v7\: ` 6!EB=@?¾f:�HI6!7@7\:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>683ACOQ;TAKSU?c:�J>ACJgH>=@;Z6GJMH>6.S[AC7@A�H>:<7 ` :P7@ACEB60HI= ` 6!EB=@?¾f:�HI6!7@7N60;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=u8GAPOQ;ZAPJ>6!JC?F=Y]9Oi:�:PJM8cw>6DH>:P7@7\:7NAPEFA08GAPJK?B6!OQ;TACEF:PJ>6G=@?¾f:Mnlx2JM:P7@AChC:PO&6!JK?B6iJ>ACJ�SBAPJMAD=@J�hP6!J>6GEF6 ` 6!EBA��YdeRMJ>jG=NAPJM:P7@=(=v83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =y�B_KRM:PJMHIAC�M]�[;MEB=NOi:P�>]��BH>AP;ZAC�0;ZAP=\8cwv®6i7\: ` 6!EB=@?¾f:DHI6!7@7N6,;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6,8GAPOQ;TAKSU?c:.HI=N;T6!JMHI6�H>:<79;T6!EB=NAIHIA.HI=9?B6GOQ;ZA�=NJ83RM= ` :P7@hCAPJ>A¹7@6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=�83APOQ;ZAPJ>6!JK?B=�n �9ACSpf ��J>APJ S[ACJ>A¹=NJ hC6GJ>6!EB6 ` 6!EBA��YdeR>JMjG=NAPJM:P7@==s83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =L>=\:<EFhPACO&6!JK?F:<7N=��B:08G:PRMSB:�HI=\�>]2�B;TAC=N8cwu®6!�M]Z;Z6GEc8cwu®6k�>]$H>:<?BA08cw>6Q7N: ` 6GEF=r?bf:�HI6!7@7\:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6&8GAPOQ;ZACS[?F:�f6SBR>LTACEFH>=@JM:<?F:Q:<7$SBRMSFS[=\S[?B6GEF6�HI=$R>J0J>6kSBSBA&?BEc:y= 83APJK?F6GJWRI?B=$H>6G7N7@6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>={83ACOQ;TACJ>6GJK?B=�n

|>n��I6] f6 ` 6!EF:M]2� f¡ ;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6,8cw>6/��f6iS[6!J>jPX :<7@?BEFA ` 6GEc:>]£OQ:M] SB6] f6&d�:<7\SB:M]£J>ACJqS[=m;MR fA.SU?c:<L>=N7N=@EF6=N7 ` :<7NAPEF6sHI= ` 6GEF=@?¾f:iHI=� f¡ ;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6s8cwM6S��,SB6GJMj!:i6!JC?FEF:PEB6�J>6!7 OQ6!EB=@?BAlH>6G= 8GAPJK?B6!JWRI?B=^HI=D�©�:CH06!SB6GOQ;>=NA;ZACSFS[=\:<OQADEF=r?F6GJ>6!EB6 ` 6GEc:g� f¡�;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6�8cw>6 ` =9SB=N: ` =@?F:.SBR¹¼.:PE[?F6!�D:PJM8cw>6,SB6lSB:P;T6kSBSB=NO&A�83APJqSB=N8GR>EF6GjGjk:8cw>6&J>APJ ` =uf6 ` =r?c:�SBR�¼.:PE[?F6P]�Oi:lEF=r?F6GJ>=\:<OQAld�:<7\SB:¹� f¡ ;ZACSFSB=@L>=N7N6&8cw>6h� �'�,� |P�Mn �2:<hC=@ACJM:<EF6�=@J�OQAWH>A:<JT:<7NAPhPAy;T6!E2hP7N=$:<7@?BEF=$83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` =Yn

�Mn^opJi:C�(628k�(7\:�HI=NSBhP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6�f6u=NJM837NRMSB= ` :>n*5�6G=T8!:PSB=>LT�(62HT�vf6u6!SF837NRMSB= ` :>n�W=T;>R fA�ACSFSB6GE ` :PEB6~8GAPO�RMJM_KR>68cw>6,SB;T6kSBSBA07N:DH>6!83=\SB=@ACJ>6iJ>APJgf6,:PhP6 ` AP7N6y=NJ¢_KRM:<JK?FAM]£SB6i7@6l;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=(H>=NSBhP=NR>JK?B6iJ>ACJ�;TAKSBSBAPJ>A06kSBSB6GEF66GJK?FEF:PO�LZ6 ` 6GEF6P] ` =@6!J>6&:lOi:<JM8!:<EF6�=N7m8G:PSBA�8cwM6&HI=\SF83EF=@OQ=NJM:,7N6&H>R>6iHI=NSBhP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>=�©$83ACSpf ��]�J>6G=*8G:CS[=(LT��6iHM�­]SB=N:PO&AD;ZAPEB?F:<?B=v:.HI=NEB6,8cw>6l7N:.H>=NSBhP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>60f6i6!SF837NRMSB= ` :D;ZAP=\8cwu®6iSF:<;>;M=N:PO&A.8cwM6,R>J>A�S[?BRTHI6GJK?B6lJ>APJq;>R^fA=\SB8GEB= ` 6!EFSB= :�HIR>6Q83ACEFSB=^H>=^7\:<RMEB6k:,6Q8cw>6�R>J�R>ACO&A�J>APJ�;>R fA0S[;ZACSF:<EF6�HIRM6&HIACJ>J>6Cn�op7^;M=[fR�HI6G7N7N6 ` AP7@?B6�;Z6GEHI6k83=\HI6GEF6�_CRM6!S[?BA&?B=N;TA,H>=£_KR>6!S[?B=NAPJ>={AI8!83APEFEF6�8GAPJ>AKSB8G6GEF67�X =NJK?B6!J>jG=NAPJ>6�HI= 8cw>={6!SB;>EF=@OQ6�7N:Q;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6Cn��I6SB= ` R>AC7@6y6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<EF6�7�X :PO�L>=NhPRM=r?bf:>]ZJ>6G7(8G:CS[AlH>6G7N7N:�HI=NSBhP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6�=NJM8G7@RMSB= ` :�S[=^;>R fA�S[;Z6!8G=raZ8G:<EF6P¦Q�c A��l]�A6GJK?FEF:PO�L>=\���e?F:P7 ` AP7@?F:QS[=$SF83EF= ` 6�¤6 �¾Ah�y�3]M6�J>6!7£8G:CS[AQHI=£_KR>6!7@7\:&6!SF837NRMS[= ` :>¦��- A/�,]MOQ:&J>ACJ�6!JK?BEc:<O�LM=N�Mn�W= ` 6!EB=@aT8cw>=£8cwM6l�� �_�y� ���� �_�&�~6��� �v�&��� �� �_�y��S[ACJ>Ai6GJK?BEc:<OyLT6�7@AChP=\8G:<OQ6!JC?F6�6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B=^: �9� 6�8cw>6,��g�_�y� �9�u��g�9�&�~6l�� �v�y� �9�u��g�9�&�2SBAPJ>Ai6!JC?FEF:PO�LZ6�7@AChP=\8G:PO&6!JK?B6�6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B= :

} � �

Page 106: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} �CÀ�l�,n

�In �B§G�_�Z�y�_�(�u����FªB�_�Z�y���u����F«B���r�y���(�~�_�^�<�£�����Z�&�l�~�_�^�<�£�����Z�y�_�(�~���b��-�G�y�����~�,��c#B���r�y�l�~���<�$��� �y���~�_�^�b� ���r�y�_�(�v���<�£�����Z�����~�l�<�� ^U�_�u�r�y���v���<���r!���r�y�l�~�_�^�<�£��� �y�_�(�~�l�b� �����Z�y���~�l�<�

À n �F§G��� �&�l�~���<�$�����Z�y�_�(�u�9�^�<��FªB��� �&�l�~���<�$�����Z�y���u�l�<�$���r�y���(�~���<�£��� �y���u�_�^�b��F«B��� �&�l�~���<�$��� ���_�(�~�9�^�<� �����Z�y���u�9�^�<�£�����Z�&�9�(�~�l�<��c�G��� �&���(�~�_�^�<�£�����Z�����~�_�^�b�£�����Z�y�_�(�~�,�<��c#B�����Z�&�9�(�~�9�^�<�£�����Z�y�_�(�u���b� ��� ���_�(�~���^�<�

} Á n��WAPJ>Ay?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=N6P¦~���I�3]£���G�3] ���K�3]£���b�­] ���{�­] ���Z�­]£� �p�3]£�����­]£��0�v6�J>ACJ07@AiSBAPJ>AT¦u��3�­] � �>�­]£� �£�­n

} � nD�B§K�2� � � �©u�Fª!����� � s©u�B«k�� � � � 6]��� � s©~�-�M�� � � �l©v�c#k�� � � �,©~�i^Z�� � � � 6� � � s© ��rI� � � � 6�� � � �©£��nT� � � �»62� � � �©£�K5p�u6i�K3��vJu®6� � � �,]>Ju®6�� � � �n

�<|Mnmop7£JM6!SFS[A,HI= 83APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:&7NAPhP=\8G:QSBRMSFS[=\SU?F6�=@J£¦���I�3]^��3�­]^���G�3] ���{�3] ���I�3] ���Z�­](���<�~6sJ>APJDSBRMSFS[=\SU?F6�J>6G=EF=@Oi:<JM6GJK?B=�n

| � n>�WACJ>A�8GAPEFEB6G?[?B=�¦u�Bªk�­]{�B«k�­]{� ^��­]��K3��3]{�K.,�­]{�-�C�­]$�+*{�*6J>APJ,SBAPJMA�83ACEBEF63?B?B=>hC7@=Z:<7@?BEF=Y¦u�B§K�­]$�c�>�­]{�-#¾�3]���rI�­]��nT�­]^�K5p�­]^�K!{�

|>}Cn��WAP7NA ��:<EF=NA&6y�v:PEB7NAQ:<JMHIEc:<JMJ>A&:P7@7\:&hP=@?F:Mn

|;�>n*op7£7N63?B?BAPEF6�EB=\83ACEFH>=$8cw>6�R>JDEF=NSBR>7@?F:b?FAiHI= HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N=r?bf:y;MR fAi6!SFS[6!EB6�AP?[?B6!JWRI?BA,8GAPJDHI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>={OQAC7r?FAHI= ` 6!EFSB6P]WOi:<hK:<EF=Z;M=[fR0L>EF6 ` =$6kHl6!7@6!hC:<JK?F=$HI=£_KR>6G7N7N6�_KR>=£;>EBAC;TAKSU?F6Pn

���I���[}k� ��=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\����P� ���[�� � �y�V���y� �YH>:hs�c � � ���»6?F6GACEB6!OQ:QHI= HI6!HIRMjG=NAPJ>6¾��Y|C� �� � �y�9� � �YH>:0�U}¾�v6,���P�9;Z6GE�¼�½9����K� ��� � �u�� � �&� �YH>:0��|K�v;T6!E�83ACJC?FEF:P;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k�

��:U ����� ���u�� � �&�uS[6!hPR>6S�� ������� � �u�� � �&�[�u;Z6GE~=N7{?F6GAPEF6GOi:QHI=$HI6kHIR>j!=@ACJ>6Pn

Page 107: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} �WÁ��G���U}k� ���� ���� ���u���� � ��[�[�9��[���� � ��m������ ���u����¤� �B�[� �Yx��P�

���P� �� ���� ���u���� � �B� ��;T6!E��&HI6G7*zc�Mn �I¦[���� ���� ���y�[���|C� ���� ���V������ ���u���� � �B� �YH>:D�U}¾�v6Q���P�v;Z6GE�¼�½9����K� �� � ��=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\����P� �� ���u���� � � �YH>:D��|K�v6Q���K�v;Z6GE�¼�½9�� À � ���� ���V� �YH>:D���C�v;T6!E283APJK?FEF:P;>;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6k�� Á � �YH>:D���W�v6Q� À �v;Z6GE�¼�½9���:����� � ��[���SB6GhCR>6S�q���� ����m� ¤;T6!E2=N7�?B6GACEB6!Oi:&H>=£HI6!H>R>jG=NAPJ>6 ` �Pn

���!���U}k� � � �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=�����P� �� � � �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=����|C� ��� ����� ��H>:D���P�9;T6!E�83ACJK?BEc:<;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k����K� ��� � �e;Z6GE�|Mnrzc�Mn �P����P� ��� � ��H>:D�Y|C�96,���W�v;T6!E283APJT8G:b?F6GJM:PjG=NAPJ>6¾�� À � ��� � � ��H>:D�[}k�96,���C�v;T6!E283APJT8G:b?F6GJM:PjG=NAPJ>6¾�� Á � ����� ���y�m� � �e6!SB6GEc83=NjG=NA0��3�v;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6k�� � � � ��H>:D� À �96,� Á �v;T6!E2¼.½9�H>:h � �l�c�� � � ���»SB6GhPRM6&n!nGn���W���U}¾� ����� ����� �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=�����C� �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=����|K� � ��� ��H>:D�[}k�v6i���C�v;T6!E2¼.½9����W� �������� ��H>:D�Y|C�v;Z6GE283ACJK?BEc:<;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k����C� �� �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=��� À � ��� ��H>:D���K�v6i���C�v;T6!E2¼.½9����b� �W=£A<?[?F=@6!J>6�d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B62 �¸��� �����3�-s�c� ��� H>:Q8GR>=mnGn!n���{�vop7£7@6G?[?BACEB6�hC=@RMS[?B=@aT8cw>={=£;M:PSFSB:PhPhC=T6s8GAPOQ;>7N63?B={7\:iHI=NOQACS[?BEc:<jG=NAPJM6P¦

�U}¾� � ����C� �� ������|K� �¤� ���W� ����C� � À � �� �>�2�9APOQ6�J>6!7@7�X 6kS[6!EF8G=@j!=@A&;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F6�=@7$7N63?B?BACEB6�hP=NRMS[?B=@aT8cw>=$={;T:PSFSB:PhPhP=�6�83ACOQ;>7@6G?B=�¦

�U}¾� �u��� �����V�������C� ����� �������|K� ���W� � ������C� ��������� À � ��� Á � ������Z� �W6!hPR>6�d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6sHM:����K�3n� �U���[}k� ��� �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=�����P� �� � �y�9���[���� � �y�m� �y� ��¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NA0���G�B��Y|C� ���� � �y�9� � ��H>:0�U}¾�v6,���C�V;Z6GE¼.½9����K� �� � � �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=�����P� ��� � �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=��� À � �� ��� ��H>:0���W�v6,���C�V;Z6GE83APJT8G:b?F6GJM:PjG=NAPJ>6¾�� Á � � ��H>:0��|K�v6,� À �V;Z6GE¼.½9�

� ��;=&>�2�4&O?�@$# � �,�5��� � &>E,�5D4& &>� �5�F#FC># �4&OD4&>E,�.�F& ���5�$�F#FC ��L>#F���5#2!5&>�2� &>��D4&OE � !5#2!5&>!5@$LO#F���$&0-

Page 108: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} �;�

�����µ�U}k� � � ��=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\����P� ����� ��=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\���|C� ��� ���� �YH>:D�U}¾�v;T6!E283ACJC?FEF:P;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k����K� ���� ���� �YH>:D���C�v;T6!E283ACJC?FEF:P;>;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k����P� ����� � ���V���B������»�����V� ��� �Y¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NA����G�[�� À � ������ � ���V���� �YH>:D��|K�v6i���P�v;Z6GE2¼�½9�� Á � �� �YH>:D���W�v6i� À �v;Z6GE2¼�½9���D���U}¾� ��=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\����C� � ��=@;ZA<?F6!SB=\���|K� �������� ���u�� �����y�B� ��6!SB6GEc83=NjG=NAD���I�[����W� ���� � �u�� �����&� �YH>:D�U}¾�96,��|C�v;Z6GE2¼�½9����C� � ������ ��hP=pf:QHI=@OQAKSU?FEF:<?BAK�� À � � ���u�� �����&� �YH>:D���W�96,���P�v;Z6GE28GAPJM8!:b?F6GJM:PjG=NAPJ>6¾�� Á � �u�� �����y� �YH>:D���C�96,� À �v;Z6GE2¼�½9�|P|Mn£½(6GE^HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6m8cwM6m?BR>?[?B6v7N6mde;yH>6GEF= ` :<LM=@7N=CJM6G7WS[=\SU?F6GOi:�H>=K¨�=@7NLT6!E[?-���v6!EBJM:��IS S[ACJ>A�HI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@=W:<JT8cw>6J>6!7£8G:P7N8GAP7NAQH>6G7mzc�Mn �I]ILM:CSU?c:iHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6�8cw>6�= _CRM=@JMH>=N8G= SF8cw>6GOQ=£SBAPJ>AiHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N=$=@JD6kSBSBAMnv¬�7@=£SF8cw>6!O&=V}k�­]|C�3]M}k|C�­]T}%�W�£6�}��P�^SBAPJ>A�As:CSBSB=@ACOQ=IA�hP=pf:�SU?c:b?B=THI=@OQAKSU?FEF:<?B=IJ>6!7$z-�Tn �6~J>6!7@7�X 6!SB6GEc83=NjG=NA�;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B6CnD�*6kHI=N:POQA7\:&H>6GEF= ` :<LM=@7N=r?bf:QHI6G=$EF=NOQ:PJ>6GJK?F=Y¦

�P�µ�[}k� ���� � �&� �e=N;ZA<?B6kS[=�����P� �� ���� � �y�B�V���[�� � ��V���� � �y�B� ��x��P��Y|C� �� � ��m���� ���y� ��HM:D�U}k�96,���P�v;Z6GE2¼.½v����K� �� �ehC=ºf:QHI=NOQACS[?BEc:b?FAK����P� ��� ��HM:D��|C�96,���K�v;Z6GE2¼.½v���:2 ���� ���y���� � �,]KS[6!hPR>6��¹�� �¸�� � �&�[�V���� � �&�(;Z6GEm=N7I?B6!APEF6GOi:�HI=MH>6!HIR>j!=@ACJ>6Pn

�K��¹�9� � �SB={?FEF:CHIRM836�=NJ��u�� �����&�m��

�U}¾� �� ���� � ���y� ��H>:]���� ���� � �y�B����C� �u�� �����&�V����� ��H>:0�[}k�v;Z6GE�8GAPJK?BEc:<;>;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6¾���|K� ��� � �ehC=ºf:QHI=NOQACS[?BEc:b?BAW����W� �u�� �����&�V� ��H>:0���P�v6,��|K�9;T6!E�83ACJM8G:<?B6GJT:<jG=NAPJM6k��P�e �_� � � S[= ?BEc:PH>RM836s=NJ �u�� � ���y�2� �l]$8cw>6�SB=^HI6!EB= ` :id�:C83=N7@OQ6GJK?F6yH>:9��� �µ�� � ���y���x�}k�v;Z6GE�8GAPJK?BEc:<;M;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6CnÀ �&�� � �y�s��[�� �����s��� � ��� ���[��SB=*?BEc:PH>RM836Q=NJ �� � �y�s��B�� �����s��� �

�u��� ������[��U}¾�6 ��� �e=N;ZA<?B6kS[=�����C�6 � � �e=N;ZA<?B6kS[=����|K�6 �e=N;ZA<?B6kS[=�����W�6� ��HM:��[}k�v6i��|K�v;T6!E�¼.½v����C� � ��HM:����P�v6i��|K�v;T6!E�¼.½v�� À � �u��� ������ ��HM:����K�v6i���C�v;T6!E26!SB6GEc83=NjG=NA0��D�v;>EB6k836kHI6GJK?B6¾�Á �� � ����SB=�?BEc:PH>RM836�=NJ_ �¸���� � �y�u8cw>6�SB=$HI6GEF= ` :yd�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6C¦

Page 109: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} ���

�U}¾�6 �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=�����C� �� �e=N;TAP?B6!SB=����|K� �� ���� � �y� �ehP=pf:QHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:<?BAW����W�6 ��� ��H>:0���C�v6,��|K�V;Z6GE¼.½9����C�6� ��H>:0�U}¾�v6,���W�V;Z6GE¼.½9�

��:U��c�� ����SB6GhPRM6��� ������ � �y�v;Z6GE�=@7�?F6GAPEF6GOi:QHI=£H>6!HIR>j!=@ACJ>6Pn

� ��� � ����SB=�?BEc:PH>RM836�=NJ_� ������ � �&�u8cw>6&f6�R>JD8G:CS[AiHI=m�Yxs}k�3n

� �s�� � �y�~�µ�[��� � �y�~� �� �(� � �y�B�2SB=£?FEF:CHIRM8G6s=@J£¦��� � �&�~�µ�[��� � �y�~� �[���� ����V� �&�[�B�­]M8cw>6sSB=$HI6!EB= ` :&:P;>;>7N=N8!:<JMH>A&=N7{?F6GAPEF6GOi:&HI=£HI6kHIR>j!=@ACJ>6s:<7N7N:�� �U�uHI6!7@7�X ¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NA&|��In

} � �96&}C}k�3]W?BEc:PHIRM8G6GJMH>Ah�����83APJ��� � �y�$����� � �3]MEF=@6!JC?FEF:PJ>A�=NJ_�K�v6��P�3n

}��C�&�� � �y�s� �[����� ����� � �&�[��SB=*?BEc:PH>RM836i=NJ$¦,�� � �&����[����� ������u�[�� ��y�m� �u��� � ��[�B�­]M8cw>6�SB=TAP?[?B=N6GJM6�d�:C83=N7@OQ6GJK?F6�H>:P7@7\:���D�VHI6!7@7�X ¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NA�|P|��e;ZAPJ>6!JMHIAh � � :<7�;TAKSU?FAHI=�¤62� ���:<7{;ZACS[?BAiHI=��&�­n½(6GE^HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB69=@7 ` =\836 ` 6GEcSB:M]b83=NAMf6V8cwM697N6Vde;QHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7@=KJ>6!7>S[=\SU?F6GOi:�H>6G7�z-�Tn ��S[ACJ>AH>6GEF= ` :<LM=@7N=I:<JM8cw>69J>6G7SB=NS[?B6!OQ:iH>=£¨2=N7@LZ6GEB? ���v6GEFJM:��ISG]ILT:PS[?F:iHI6!EB= ` :<EF6�=NJ._KR>6!S[?!X R>7@?B=NOQA,S[=\SU?F6GOi:D��x|C������ � ���y�9�¸���»�����8cwM6¹f6.RMJM:qdeACEBOi:¹H>=�8GAPJK?BEc:<;>;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6¾�­n �9=pfA SB=AP?[?F=@6!J>6.d�:C83=N7@OQ6GJK?F6�H>: }!|C�,6�H>:PhP7N=SF8cw>6GOQ=�HI6G7N7\:HIAC;>;>=\:lJ>6!hC:PjG=NAPJ>6yRMSB:PJMHIA�=@7(?F6GACEB6!OQ:�HI=*HI6kHIR>jG=NAPJM60�Y8cw>6QS[=*;>R^fA�HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6y:PJM8cw>6&;T6!E�=@7mSB=NS[?B6!Oi:�HI=¨2=N7NLT6!E[?-���v6GEFJM:��ISc�­n

|"�&6s|;�>nV�VdeE!n*7\:QS[AC7@R>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7N7YX ¡VSB6GEc83=NjG=NAQ|P|>n

� � n

� ¡ � ��`b�%aba%aG�ced �� � ` �%aba%aG�c d � �

�`<�%aba%a3�ced ���� ` �%aba%a3�c d � �

� o ����`¾�ba%a%a!�-�d � ��2`¾�ba%abaG�-� > � �

�`b�%aba%aG�cedy�-�2`¾�ba%a%a!�-� > � �

� �¹¡ � �`b�%aba%aG�cedy�- � �l�-� � � ` �ba%aba3�- d �c�� � �

� �¢o/� �`b�ba%aba3�-�dy�c�� � � ` �%aba%aG�c d �- � �l�-� � �

�M}Cn,½mEF6!SB6GJK?B=\:<OQAD:<7\83RMJ>6,HI6GEF= ` :PjG=NAPJ>=�niop7V7N63?B?BACEB6Q?F6GJ>hK:�;MEB6kS[6!JC?F6,8cw>6i7\:DS[AC7@R>j!=@ACJ>6QJ>APJ f6QR>JM=N8!:0683ACOQ;>7@6G?B=m7N6ihP=NRMS[?B=@aT8G:PjG=NAPJ>=mH>6G=V;T:PSFSB:PhPhP=�]{ACSFSB=N:�HI63?F6GEFOQ=@J>=9=@J�LM:CS[6i:D_KRM:P7@6iEF6GhCAP7\:.f6,SF83EF=r?B?F:083=\:PSF83RMJM:SB6!_KR>6GJMj!:>¦

Page 110: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P} ����I� �[}k� ����� �����

���P� � ��Y|C� � ����K� ����� ����P� ����� �u� �y���Z�$�y�� À � �u� �y�y�Z� �u� �y���Z�� Á � �u� �y�y�Z� �u� �y���Z�$�y�� � � �u� �y���Z�$�y� � ¡VS��V���C�­]£� Á ���3� �U}¾� �Z� �Z�

���C� �Z� �Z����� �����<���|K� � ����W� � ��������C� � �Z����� �����<�� À � � �Z����� �����<� � ¡9S��V���P�3]N� Á ����G� �U}¾� � �

���C� � �u�����|K� � ����W� � �u������C� ����� ������ À � ����� �u��� � ¡v� �9���C�­]\���W�­]\���P����{� �U}k� �����������<� �������s���<����P� ����� �������|C� � ����K� �����������<�­�Y� �s������P� �����W��� �� À � �����������<�­�Y�����W�Y� �� Á � �����������<�­�Y����� ������ �>� �[}k� �Z���_�(� �Z�y�_�(�

���P� �Z���_�(� �Z��Y|C� �Z���_�(� �(����K� � �u���Z�&�9�(�<����P� � �u���Z�&�9�(�<�� À � ����� �u���Z�&�9�(�<� � �^o/�9���W�­]\���C��� ` 6kHI=£¡9S[6!EF8G=@j!=@Aj� � �

Page 111: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P}C}

���Z� �[}k� � ����P� � ������Y|C� �u�r�y���<� �Z����K� � ����P� � ������ À � �u�r�y���<� �(�� Á � �u�r�y���<� �Z���_�(�� � � �u���Z�y�_�(�<� �����

��D� �[}k� �����������<� �����������<����P� � ��Y|C� �����������<�­�Y� ��������K� � ����P� �����������<�­�Y�£�B� �� À � �����������<�­�F� ������ Á � �����������<� �����r�����<�� �£� �U}k� �����������<� �����������<����P� � ���|C� �����������<�­�Y� ��������K� � ����P� �����������<�­�Y�£�F� �� À � �����������<�­�Y�£�1�^� �(�� Á � �����������<�­�1�^� �����(�� � � �����������<� �^����� �����(�<����<� �U}¾� ����� �����

���C� � ���|K� �����W�Y� ����W� �Z����� �Z��������C� �Z� �Z�� À � �Z�����b�1�Z� �� Á � �s��� �s���� � � �s���W�c�Z�����b�c�Z� �� � � �����W�B�����W�c�Z����� ��U} � � �����W�B����� ���Z�0���<�V���� ��� �U}¾� ����� �l���

���C� � ���|K� �����W�Y� ����W� � �c�(� �u�r�����<����C� ���_�(� �u�r�����<�� À � ����� �u�r���9�(�<����<� �U}¾� � �

���C� �(� �(���|K� �£�1�(� ���_�(����W� �u� �y�_�(�<�3��� ��(����C� �u� �y�_�(�<�3��� �� À � �u� �y�_�(�<� �����

Page 112: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P}k�

Page 113: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ������� ��

� ������� � � ��� � �»��� ��������� � � � � � ��� �� � � ��� �

}P}k|

Page 114: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-
Page 115: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ����� ������

� � ���� � � � � � ��� � � � ���������� � � ������������ � � � � � �»��� ��� �����

� �! "$#&%('*),+.-0/213)&#04526!7@7\:&;>EF=@Oi:y;M:<EB?B6�:<LML>=N:POQAy=NJK?BEFAWH>A<?[?FAyRMJ�7N=NJ>hPRM:PhPhC=@A&:<EB?B=@aT83=\:<7N6�� 8GAPJ�=@7$_KRM:P7@6�SB={;TAKSBSBAPJ>A�deAPEFOi:<7N=@j%�j!:PEB6�7@6&;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>= SB6GOQ;>7N=N8G=*HI6G7^7@=NJ>hCRM:<hChP=NA,JM:b?FR>Ec:<7N6�6�7N6&;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM= 83ACOQ;TAKSU?F6y:,;T:<EB?B=NEB6�HM:l6kSBSB6OQ6!HI=\:<JK?F6�83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` = ` 6!EBA��YdeRMJ>jG=NAPJM:P7@=�]>6�8G=ºfA�:<7$aTJ>6�HI=(HI63aTJ>=@EF6sR>JDJM6!SFS[AlH>= 83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:Q7@AChP=\8G:y?BEc:i7N6deAPEFOQ6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@=MH>=A�g8cw>68GAPJMSB6GJK?F:�HI=ZS[?BRTHI=N:PEB67N:�83APEFEF63?[?F6Gj!j!:sHI=�:<7\83RMJ>62deACEBOQ6�HI=ZEc:<hP=NAPJT:<OQ6GJK?BATnx2LML>=N:POQA�;ZAP=~=NJK?BEFAIHIA<?B?BA�R>J OQ6G?BAIHIAq:<7NhPACEB=@?BOQ=\83A �Y_KR>6G7N7@AqHI6!hP7N=2:<7NLT6!EB=~SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8G=\�y;Z6GEi=N7~EB=\83ACJ>ACSF83=i�OQ6GJK?BA�HI6G7vS[RMSFSB=NS[?B6!EB6iHI=v;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:�6,EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>=VSB6GOi:<JK?B=\8cw>6.��6!SFS[6!EB6Q?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhP=\:>] 6!SFS[6!EB6iSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6P]6!SFSB6GEF6283APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:�7NAPhC=N8!:C�^6:P7N8GR>J>=Z8G:<7\83AC7@= ��:PSFSB=@ACOQ:<?B=\83=�]KH>6G7N7N:sH>6!HIR>j!=@ACJ>62JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6P]KHI6G=�SB6!_KR>6GJK?F=\�(;Z6GEEF6GJMHI6!EB6&;>=[fR�OQ6k8G8G:PJ>=\83Al=N7*EF=@J ` 6!J>=NO&6!JK?BA0HI6G7N7@6y?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=N6y6iHI6!7@7N6Q83APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>jG6&7@AChP=\8cw>6yH>=*R>J�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6HI= deAPEFOQ6�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N=Yn~¼D6kHI=N:PJK?B6s7N6�HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<jG=NAPJM=£HI6G= ?B6!APEF6GOQ= H>= 83ACEBEF63?B?B6!jGj!:Q6yHI=^8GAPOQ;>7N63?F6GjGjk:iS[=f6�6 ` =\HI6GJ>j!=N:<?F:y7N:y?FA<?F:P7@6�:CHI6GhCRM:b?F6GjGjk:�HI=�?c:<7N=$8G:P7N8GAP7N={;T6!E~=�aMJ>={;Z6GE~=$_KRM:<7N=$SBAPJ>AQSU?c:b?F=$83ACS[?BEFR>=@?B={6�7\:�7NAPEFASBACS[?F:<JMjG=\:<7N66k_CRM= ` :<7N6GJMj!:>n¼D6kHI=N:PJK?B6l=N7~7N=@J>hCRM:<hChP=NA�HI6!7@7\:�7NAPhC=N8!:.;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6lSB=u;TAKSBSBAPJMA.deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:PEB6lSBAP7NA�Ec:<hC=@ACJM:<OQ6!JC?F=7\:�8GR>=283ACEBEF63?B?B6!jGj!:�S[=�LM:PSF:�SBR>=~J>6kSBSB=u?BEc:�7@60;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=~S[6!OQ;>7@=\83=�]uS[6!J>j!:�:<7\83R>JgEF=rde6!EB=NOQ6GJK?BAq:<7u7NAPEFA83ACJK?B6GJWRI?FAMniopJq_KR>6!S[?F:�;M:PE[?F6Q=@JK?B6!JMHI=\:<OQA0;>EF6!HI=\S[;ZAPEFEF6&RMJ�7N=NJ>hPRM:PhPhC=@A�;>=[fR�:PE[?F=N8GAP7\:b?FA�8cw>6i8GAPJMSB6GJK?F:0HI=S[?BRMHI=\:<EF6�7N:Q8GAPEFEB6G?[?B6!jGjk:yHI=£R>J0JKRMO&6!EBA&OQAP7@?BAi;>=[fRD:<OQ;>=NAiHI=$Ec:<hP=NAPJT:<OQ6GJK?B=Z7NAPhP=\83=�n

� �­¯ �¢³�¶(1G#Q%^³�¶^¶^1g+D4�´!´3³ ´G)� y1G±~³¸+D4�1��0'*42+.13±~³�%*1¹+D4�´��0'm1G· ) )�'*+.1!#04� ����� � � � / #%-�/�,",�-�� ,���,�� *�#%��,�� � ��� � ,�!$#0/�,����

�9APJTS[=\HI6GEF=\:<OQA&:P7N8GR>J>={6kS[6!O&;M=£HI=$;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>={SB6GOQ;>7N=N8G=£HI6G7{7N=NJ>hPRM:PhPhC=@A&JM:b?FR>Ec:<7N6P¦�B§!�¹�­�v:<EF7@A�f6�SU?FRMHI6!JC?F6!��BªF�¹�F|lf6�RMJ�JWR>OQ6!EBAQJM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6!��B«F�¹��:PEB=NA�f6�;M:PHIEF6�HI=£¡V7@=\SB:C��-�!�¹�1�K?B6Gd�:<J>A0f6�;>=[fRD:<7@?BAiHI=£¡VOQ=@7N=@AK��-#F�¹�-��f6�=N7£HIAC;>;>=NAiHI=D�<��i^U�¹�1�I: ` ACJM:,f6?FEF:i¬�6!J>A ` :y6�opOQ;Z6GEF=N:C���rk�¹� � f6�=N7$;>EFAIHIA<?B?BAiHI=D�y62�K���nP�¹� � f6�7\:iSBAPOQOi:yHI=��&62�K�� 5r�¹�BoV;>RMJC?F=£xs] � � 6 � S[ACJ>A ` 6GEB?B=\83=$H>={R>JD_CRT:PHIEc:b?FAC�

}P}k�

Page 116: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P} À���[�¹�F¿£:,SF_KRM:PH>EF:iHI6!7 ¼D=N7\:<J�8cw>6�wM: ` =@JK?FA,7N:l83AP;M;M:,HI6!=^8!:<OQ;>=NAPJ>= J>6G7v} ��� � f6�S[?F:<?F:QdeACEBOi:b?c:iH>:<=hC=@AI8!:b?BACEB=�¬�:P7@7N=�]2¼.:<7\HI=NJ>=Y] �^:PSFSBA<?[?F=Y]~x�JM836!7@AP?[?B=�]�9ACS[?F:C83R>EB?F:M]��u:PEB6kS[=�] �APJT:PHIACJ>=Y] �2= � �b:P:PEFH$]

�m:PJ �v:CSU?F6GJ$]M¬�RM7@7N=r?k]M¡ ` :PJ>=N�opJ ?BRI?B?B6._KR>6!S[?B60;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=vaMhCR>EF:PJ>A�HI6G=2JMAPOQ=2HI=~=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>=y���v:<EF7NAM]9|M] ��:<EF=@AT]9¡V7@=\SB:M]V6k8G8<n � 67\:0;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6&:<tZ6!EBOi:0AD8cw>6iR>J�=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>A�wM:�R>JM:D836!E[?c:0;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:�AP;>;MR>EB6,8cwM6Q?BEc:�:P7N8GR>J>=VH>=V6!SFSB=SBRMSBSB=\SU?F62R>JM:y836GEB?F:sEB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6Cn£op7T?B=N;TAQHI=TdeAPEFOQ:P7@=NjGjk:<j!=@ACJ>628cw>6�SB=Z:CHIA<?B?F:�=NJ,7NAPhC=N8!:�HI6G=Z;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=�83APJTS[=\SU?F6J>6!7@7�X =NJMHI=\8G:PEB6�83ACJ,7@6G?[?F6GEF6OQ=NJKRTSB8GAP7N62=�J>APOQ={HI6GhC7@=Z=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>=*�Y83ACS[?F:PJK?B=Z=@JMH>= ` =\HIRM:<7N=���(=@J�hP6!J>6GEF6SB=TRTSB:PJ>A7N63?[?F6GEF6DHI6G7N7YX =NJ>=@j!=@AqHI6!7@7�X :<7@d�:<LZ63?BAT¦ �Z] ¾] �b] �T]�nGn!nG]96 ` 6!JK?BRM:P7@OQ6GJK?F6�8GAPJ :<;>=\83=uA�=@JTHI=N8G=6�s6D83APJ 7@6G?[?F6GEF6Oi:<=NRMSF83AP7N6�=$J>ACO&=$H>6G7N7@6�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:�6sHI6!7@7N6�EF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM=(�Y83AKSU?c:<JK?B={;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?B= ` 6�AiSB=@OyLTAC7@=£H>={;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?FAK�[�V=NJhP6!J>6GEF6SB={RMSF:<J>Ay7@6G?[?F6GEF6�Oi:P=@RMSF83AC7@6�HI6G7N7\:&SB6!8GAPJMHM:s;M:PE[?F6�HI6!7@7�X :<7@d�:<LZ63?BAT¦��Q] �Q]��y]��~]{nGn3n!]>:<JM8cw$X 6!SFSB683ACJ6 ` 6GJK?BRT:<7N=9:<;M=N8G=VA.=NJMHI=\83=�n��9=\:PSF83R>JM:D8GACS[?F:PJC?F6,;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` :�f6l:P8!83ACO&;T:<hPJT:b?F:0H>:�R>JqJWR>OQ6GEFA.JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N68cw>6�=NJMHI=\8G:Q:Q_CRT:<JK?B6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B={=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:<7N= ` :Q:P;>;>7N=N8!:b?F:&7\:y8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` :Mnm�9ACOQ6R>JT:y;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:f6,:DRMJ¹:<EFhPACO&6!JK?BAM] R>JM:�EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6iL>=NJM:PEB=\:�f6,:.HIRM6�:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?B=�] RMJM:0?B6!EBJT:<EF=N:D:0?FEB6C](6l83AKSºf � ` =\:>]*8GACSpf �R>JM:�83ACS[?F:PJK?B6i;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` :0;>R fA.6kSBSB6GEF6,:0R>J>AT](H>R>6P]^?BEF6l:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?B=�]£6�83ACSpf � ` =\:>nD½(6GE�J>ACJ¢:<;>;Z6!SF:<JK?F=@EF67\:DJ>A<?c:<j!=@ACJ>6i7N:CSB8G6GEF6GOQAM] A ` 6i;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6C]^SBA<?B?B=NJK?B6!SBA0?F:P7@6lJKRMO&6!EBATn0o�SB=NO�LZAP7N=9HI=9;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?FA.S[=vSB8GEB= ` ACJ>AH>: ` :<JK?F=$:<7N7@6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B={=NJMHI= ` =NH>RM:<7N=£:<=$_KRM:P7@=$SB=£:P;>;>7N=N8!:<J>ATn¿$6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=*��:K�v6,�eLT�v;ZACSFSBAPJ>A&6!SFS[6!EB6�deACEBOi:<7N=NjGj!:<?B6C]W:CHl6kS[6!OQ;>=@AT]>83ACJ$¦

� �T]IAC;>;>R>EF6� ¾]IAC;>;>R>EF6� �b]HIA ` 6�7\:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�=NJMHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@6�� �T] �A ���V=NJMHI=\8G:l�v:PEB7NAQA&=N7$JWR>OQ6GEFAi|Q6�7N:i8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` :j�� A� �V=@JTHI=N8!:&7N:&;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:��B6!SFS[6!EB6�SU?FRMHI6GJK?F6!�QA��[6kSBSB6GEF6JWR>OQ6!EBAQJM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6!�Mnx2JT:<7NAPhC:POQ6GJK?B6Q��8k�­]£�YHM�v6,�e6¾�v;TAKSBSBAPJ>A&6!SFSB6GEF6deACEBOi:P7@=NjGjk:b?B6�83ACJ$¦

� � ¾]IAC;>;>R>EF6�� �b]IAC;>;>R>EF6� � �

HIA ` 6s7@6&83AKSU?c:<JK?B= =@JMH>= ` =\HIRM:<7N=^=@JMH>=N8!:<J>A,hC7@=^=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>=>� �:PEB=NAM]�¡m7N=NSF:>]o�K?B6Gd�:<J>AT]{¡mOQ=@7N=NAM]$�M]q�h�9OQ6!JC?FEB6y=@7SB=@OyLTAC7@A&HI=T;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?FA���� A�� �(=@JMH>=N8!:�7\:sEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>62L>=NJM:<EF=\:D�[6kSBSB6GEF62;M:CHIEB6HI=(nGnGnF�>]KAP;>;MR>EB6��[6kSBSB6GEF62;>=[fR:<7@?BAiHI=VnGnGnF�>]IAC;>;>R>EF60�[6!SFSB6GEF6�HIAC;>;>=NAiHI=mnGnGnB�>n526!7@7N60;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=���dF�Q6q��hK�QSBAPJ>A�;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=~R>JT:�EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6�?B6GEFJM:PEB=\: �G�[6kSBSB6GEF6l?FEF:gn!nGn[6�n!nGnB��AP;&�;>R>EF6 �[6kSBSB6GEF6l=N7~;>EFAWH>A<?[?FAqHI=�nGn!n[6DHI=�nGn!nB�K��6�?BEF60J>APOQ=2HI=~=NJMHI= ` =NHIRM=�8cw>607N:�SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:<JMAM]V;Z6GE,8GR>=~7\:deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:PjG=NAPJ>6�f6�HI6G7{?F=@;ZAM¦� � �b]IAC;>;>R>EF6� � �

x2JT8cw>6�J>6!7@7\: �ewT�.f6�;MEB6kS[6!JC?F6�R>JT:¢EF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6D?B6!EBJM:PEB=\: �G�[6!SFSB6GEF6�7\:¹SBAPOQOi:¹HI=Qn3n!n[6�HI=QnGnGnB�C�­]Oi:7�X =NJMHI= ` =NHIRMA/��f6�OQ6!J>jG=NAPJM:<?BAQHIR>6 ` AP7@?B6P]I;Z6GE83R>={7\:&deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:<j!=@ACJ>6�f6P¦�I:PL>L$]IAC;>;>R>EF6 �~LZ8!8<n

526!7@7\:q�e=���SBAPJ>A0;>EF6!SB6GJK?F=mR>JM:0EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6&_KRM:<?B6!EBJM:PEB=\:��3�B6!SFS[6!EB6 ` 6!E[?F=N8G=mHI=VRMJ�_KRM:CHIEc:b?BAK�C�6,_KRM:b?B?BEFA=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>= 8cw>6�7N:QSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PJ>AM]I;Z6GE28GR>=$7\:�deACEBOi:P7@=NjGjk:<jG=NAPJM6P]I:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]{f6C¦�2:<L�8GH$n

526!7@7\:i�e7��­]K=NJIaMJ>6C]KSBAPJ>A�OQ6!J>jG=NAPJM:<?B=>RMJMHI=\83=Z=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>=M6�R>JM:�EF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6u?BEc:�6!SFS[=M:�RMJMHI=\83=M;ZACS[?B=^�3�F: ` 6GEF6hP=NAI8G:<?BAs=NJ�RMJM:�8G6GEB?F:�SF_KRM:PH>EF:sH>=$8G:<7\83=NAC�K�(6�7N:sdeAPEFOQ:P7@=NjGjk:<j!=@ACJ>62EF=N8cw>=N6!H>6�R>J0S[=NO�LZAP7NAyH>=Z;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?FAy:,}C};ZACS[?B=£SB6GhCR>=r?FAiH>:�}P}�83AKSU?c:<JK?B=�=NJMHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=�n½(6GE _CRT:<JK?BAEB=NhPRM:PEFHM:u7YX RMSBAHI6!7@7N698GACS[?F:<JK?F=C=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:<7N=C6v;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` 62f6VAP;>;ZAPEB?BR>JMA2aMJ�H$X ACEF:2SB6GhCJM:<7\:<EF68cw>6�J>6G7N7N6ldeACEBOyR>7@6�HI=~¿mX*83AKSU?c:<JK?B=uHI=\SU?F=@JK?F6�;ZACSFS[ACJ>A�:PJM8cw>6�HI6GJ>AP?F:PEB6�7@A�SU?F6!SFS[A�=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>A�A�7NA�S[?B6kSBSBA;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?BATn¿$6�6kS[;>EF6!SFSB=@ACJ>=Z8GACS[?B=@?BR>=@?B6sHM:yRMJ�SB=@OyLTAC7@AQHI=$;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?FA&:&J�;TAKSU?F=$S[6!hPR>=@?B6�H>:&JD83AKSU?c:<JK?B=�=NJMHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=SBAPJ>AiHI6G?[?B6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>={:<?BAPOQ=\8cw>6Pn��JM:QJ>A<?c:<j!=@ACJ>6;Z6GE�6!SFS[6yf6�7N:iSB6GhCR>6GJK?F6P¦��¡ �-` � � aba%a � ��� �P�

Page 117: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P} ÁHIA ` 6 � �¡ f6�=@7£SB=NO�LZAP7NAQH>=$;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?BA0�e7�X :P;>=N8G6���=NJMHI=\8G:&=N7$JWR>OQ6GEFAiHI=£:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?B=�]W7YX =@JTHI=N8G6��2f6�R>J0JWR>OQ6GEFA` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6u8cw>62SB6GE ` 6u:�H>=NS[?B=NJ>hPRM6GEF69= ` :PEB=>SB=@OyLTAC7@=>H>=>;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?BA�:���:<EFhPACO&6!JK?B=��$6~= �K¡{S[?F:PJ>J>Ai��:P7@OQ6GJMA�;Z6GEAPEc:C�*;T6!Eu8GACS[?F:PJC?F=M=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:<7N=YnV�96GEc8cw>6!EB6!O&AyHI=�6 ` =r?c:<EF62;Z6GEu_CRT:<JK?BAy;TAKSBSB=@LM=@7N6�J>AP?F:PjG=NAPJ>=M?BEFAP;>;ZA�;Z6!SF:<JK?B=6lEF=\83APEFEF6GEF6GOQA0O&AC7r?FA�SB;T6kSBSBA�:�S[=NO�LZAP7N=vH>=v;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?FA�S[6!J>j!:�:<;>=\83=v6l=NJMHI=\83=�]V_KRM:<7N=u_CRM6G7N7@=v=@OQ;>=N6GhK:b?F=9=NJ;>EF6!8G6!HI6!J>j!:Mnv¿£6s7@6G?[?F6GEF6 � 6 �Q]T_KR>=NJMHI=�]�SU?c:<J>J>A,:CH06!SB6GOQ;>=NAi;T6!E � 6 �&]MOQ6GJK?FEB6 � 6 � S[?F:<JMJ>Ai;T6!E �6��&n� ����� � � � / #%-�/�, � * -�+�,���-�#%��,opJ�OQAC7r?F6y;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=^hP7N=(=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>=(J>APJ�S[ACJ>A�H>6GJ>AP?F:b?F=*HI=@EF63?B?F:PO&6!JK?B6Q:b?[?FEF: ` 6GEcS[Ai=N7(7@ACEBA�J>APOQ6Cny�9ACSpf �SB6�H>=N8G=N:PO&AT¦

�[op7{;M:CHIEB6�HI=^¬�=@ACEBhC=@A�f6�OQ6!HI=\83AK�>]7\:;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:��[6!SFSB6GEF69OQ6!H>=N8GAC�yf6~:b?B?BEF=@L>RM=r?c:�:<7I;M:CHIEB6~HI=Z¬�=@ACEBhC=@AT]b=@7M_KRM:P7@6~JMAPJ�f6uO&6!J>jG=NAPJT:b?BA�OQ6!H>=N:PJC?F6~=@7SBR>AJMAPOQ6��Y8cw>6v;>R fA�6!SFS[6!EB6C]b:PHs6kS[6!OQ;>=@AT]<¡mEFJ>6!S[?BAW�­]bOi:�:<;>;>RMJC?FA�?FEF:POQ=r?F69=N7>S[RMA7N6GhK:<OQ69HI=I;T:b?B6!EBJM=r?bf:�83ACJ¬�=NAPEFhP=NAMn��2JM:�deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:<j!=@ACJ>6�8GAPJ$]I:PH,6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]�� �D��HIA ` 6 � S[?F:�;T6!EQ�[6!SFSB6GEF62OQ6!HI=\83AK��6�:yS[?F:y;T6!Ey�B=@7;M:CHIEB6�HI=£¬�=NAPEFhP=NAC�K�mJMAPJ0HI=NS[?B=NJ>hCR>6GEF6GL>LZ6�7\:yJMACS[?BEc:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6�H>:Q¡mEFJ>6!S[?BA�f6�OQ6!HI=\83AT]IOQ6GJK?BEF6�7@6sHIRM6;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=(wM:<JMJ>A�6 ` =NHI6!JK?B6GOQ6!JC?F6iHI= ` 6GEcS[A ` :<7NAPEF6y=NJIdeAPEFOi:b?F= ` Al6P]^_KR>=@JTHI=Y]£J>APJ�S[ACJ>A�6!_KR>= ` :P7@6!JK?B=*H>:<7;>R>JK?FA�H>= ` =NS[?F:�HI6kHIRI?[?F= ` AMn^op7>;>R>JK?FA&f6v8cw>6Q�B=@7>;T:PHIEF6vH>=$nGn!nB�qf6uR>JT:6kS[;MEB6kSBSB=@ACJ>6uHI=W?B=N;TA�deRMJ>jG=NAPJM:P7@6��Y83=NAMf6C]SB6s:<;>;>7N=\8G:b?c:Q:<7$J>ACOQ6sHI=£R>J0=NJMHI= ` =NHIRMAM]T:CH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAl¬�=@ACEBhC=@AT]K;MEBAIHIRM8G6�=@7 J>APOQ6sHI=£R>J.:<7@?BEFAQ=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>AM]:<;M;>R>JK?BA �[=N7 ;M:CHIEF6�HI=m¬�=@ACEBhC=@AK�C�3]T:<JT:<7NAPhC:i:l_CRM6G7N7@6&HI=(7N:PEBhCAi=@OQ;>=N6GhCAlJ>6!7 7N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NAiOi:b?F6GOi:b?F=N8GA��3�B=@7_KRM:PH>EF:<?BA.HI=�nGn!nB�>]��B7N:DEc:PH>=N8G6l_KRM:PHIEc:b?c:DHI=�nGnGnF�>]��[=N7uS[6!J>A�HI=�nGn3nF�>]*A�:PJM8cw>6l:.;>=[fRg:<EFhPACO&6!JK?B=�]^8GAPOQ6�[7\:�SBAPOQOi:�H>=�n3nGnB6�HI=�n!nGnB�M]s�[=N7u;>EFAWH>A<?[?FA�HI=�n!nGn[60HI=�nGn!nB� ` ]s�[=N7u;>R>JK?BA�OQ6!HI=NA�HI=�nGnGnB6�n!nGn[���Y:�HIRM6:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?B=��­]C=@7ZLM:<EF=\836GJK?FEBAsHI6!=M?FEB6;>R>JK?B=^nGn!nG]ZnGn!n[6�nGnGn0��:�?FEB6:<EFhPAPOQ6!JC?F=\�3]P6�83ACSpf � ` =\:C�3n(½(6!E[?c:<JK?BAT]CSB=M;>R^fA:<OQ;>7N=\:<EF6�=N7$7N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NA&=@JMSB6GEF6GJTHIA&H>6G=£SB=@OyLTAC7@= HI={deR>J>j!=@ACJ>6�Ai83AKSU?c:<JK?B=�deR>JMjG=NAPJM:P7@=�nv�9ACSpf ��]IS[6�=NJMHI=\8cw>=\:<OQA83ACJld��[=N7$;M:CHIEF6�HI=VnGnGnF�>]I7\:&;>EB6k836kHI6GJK?B6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6�;>R fAQ6kSBSB6GEF6�deACEBOi:P7@=NjGjk:b?F:&83ACJ$¦

�i���(���W�B���H>A ` 6P]>:,���c¬�=@ACEBhC=@AK�>]Cdm���B=@7{;M:CHIEF6�HI=VnGnGnF��6s½ ���B6!SFS[6!EB6�OQ6!HI=\83AK�C�­nx2JT:<7NAPhC:POQ6GJK?B6�7N:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6C¦

�[op7{hK:b?[?FAiHI=£¼.:PEB=NA�f6�;M=[fRD:bt�63?B?BR>AKS[AiHI6!7£8G:PJ>6�HI=£¼.:PEF8GAC�SB={;>R fAQdeAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:PEB6�83ACJ$¦

�Q���(���W�3� �{��3�B�HIA ` 6 ��� �B6!SFS[6!EB6,;M=[fR :bt�63?B?BR>AKS[A�HI=N�M]*d����B=@7vhC:<?[?FA�HI=�n!nGnB�M]V:����F¼.:<EF=NAC�>](h¢���[=N7v8!:<J>60HI=�nGn!nB�M]mL���B¼�:<Ec83AC�Mn¿£:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6C¦

�[op7{;>EFAIHIA<?B?BAiHI=G�Q6��lf6�OQ:PhPhC=@ACEB6�HI6G7N7\:&SBAPOQOi:QHI=D�y6 Á �SB={;>R fAQdeAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:PEB6�83ACJ$¦

����d[��:M] LZ�­] hT�eL£] 8k�[�� �I#$�5���4#5�B� !5# ��&OD4&>�5LO� � D ��� &>� �4&OD4&�#F�$�5D4�I!$���4�4� !5#�-O->-�&�!5#�-O->-�� !0C0.5& &�@5�J� D4&>�B��LO#F���$& � �4D & ��D ?���E,&>�0� ##!�CO��E,&9�5&>�F��� &O�4&>E,�5#F�

�5D4&OC>&>!5&>�0� & � ��&>D�CO@$#���� &�#F�$�$D � !5���4�4� !5#�� &� �� &�@5�J�=�5D ������� #FL>#F���5&:H0&>D � &����� &�#F�$�$D � !5���4�4� !5# � &��� &�@5�J�=�5D ������� #FL>#F���5&1 ���F�M��:&�� #F�2�5D4�I!$���4�4�,!5#*-O->- & !$#*->- -�� C/.5& & @5�J� &O�4�5D &>�4� #F���5&�1 @5�5L>#F���J���F& �.!$@5&(��D ?���E,&>� �4# ��� #F���5D4�I!$���4�4�,!5#�� &� ��"�5��� &@5�J�"�$D ������� #FL>#F���5&��:�$��� &(��& H0&>D � !J��& 1���F� ���/!5E � #F���5��E,& !5#�@$��#F�5!5# HI#F!5@5� !�C>#F� &�����G-=�:��� ��� � & �B�.DM��!5#FC>& K @J��!5DM�N� �,!5#��� �5@� �,&>� �4&>D & 1 ��D4E ���F#FLOLO�N� �.C>�������! !5� H0&���� � !" � �,&����#� &>� �4&OD4& �B�"D ��!5#FC>& KI@J��!$DM�N� � !$#:- ->-�� !�E,&O�0�4D &�� �B�,DM��!5#FC>&K @J��!5DM�N� �.!5#3->->-$� & @5�5�(&>� �$D &>� �4#F���5& 1 @5�5L>#F���J���F& ��!<@5�<��D ?���E,&>�0� � � �4& ���5�5�F#FCO�N� �.��!<@5� #F�$!5# H$#F!$@5� !$@$�<� @5E,&>D � !I�5D4�I!5@$CO&@5�A��� � D4�"#F�5!5# HI#F!5@5� !$�B� DM��!$#FCO& K @J��!5D �N�M�"!$&O�2�I@5E,&>D4� �!$��&>D C>@5#�� �B�.D ��!5#FC>& KI@5��!5DM�N� �"!5# ��� & @5�A�5��E,& !5&>�F��� #F�5!5# HI#F!5@5� �$-

Page 118: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P} �HIA ` 6 � ���[6!SFSB6GEF69Oi:<hChP=NAPEF69HI=£nGnGnF�>] �0���[=N7I;>EFAIHIA<?B?BA�HI=$n!n3n[62HI=£nGnGnF�>] �Q��� �K�>] u���c�<�M] �Q�»�B7N:�SBAPOQOi:HI=mn!nGnB6�H>=mnGn!nB��6 ����� Á �>n¿£:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6C¦

�B¿ :�Ec:PH>=N8G6�_KRM:CHIEc:b?F:&HI=D�;�,f6�8GAPOQ;>EF6!SF:s?FEF:&=N7£_KRM:PH>EF:<?BAQHI=D�y6S�y6G7N6 ` :b?FAQ:P7@7\:y?B6!EBjk:P�SB={;>R fAQdeAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:PEB6�83ACJ$¦

�~���(���I�­� ����3�­� �£��¾� �G�B�HIA ` 6 � ���B6!SFS[6!EB6s8GAPOQ;>EF6!SBA&?BEc:P�>] �q���B7N:QEc:PH>=N8G6�_KRM:PHIEc:b?c:iHI=Vn!nGnF�>] �D���c�;�<�>] �D���[=N7 _KRM:CHIEF:<?BA,HI=nGn!nB�M] �� �c�<�M] �.� �B7N:y;ZA<?B6!J>j!:iH>={LM:PSB6QnGnGnB6�6!SB;TACJ>6GJK?F6&n!nGnF�>] �s� �F|P�>n¼D6kHI=N:PJK?B6SB=NO�LZAP7N=ZHI=ZdeR>JMjG=NAPJ>6�S[=�;ZACSFS[ACJ>A�8GACS[?BEFR>=@EF626kS[;>EF6!SFSB=@ACJ>=T8cw>6�HI6GJMA<?F:PJ>A�=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>={:<EB?B=\83AP7\:b?F6=NJ�OQAIHIAQ;>=[fRD83APOQ;>7N6!SFSBAMnV�9ACSpf ��]W:CHl6kS[6!OQ;>=@AT¦

�[op7{;T:PHIEF6�HI6G7N7YX =NJM_KR>=@7N=NJ>A,HI=£¬�=NAPEFhP=NAC�SF:<Ebf:sdeACEBOi:<7N=NjGj!:<?BAQ83ACJ�R>JT:Q6!SB;>EB6kSBSB=NAPJ>6�HI6G7�?F=@;ZAM¦

�(� �{���I�B�HIA ` 6�dV���[=N7{;M:PH>EB6�HI=mn!nGnF�>]Ihl�7YX =NJM_KR>=@7N=NJ>AiHI=mnGn!nQ6s:i���c¬�=@ACEBhC=@AK�>n

�B¿£:QSBAPOQOi:QHI6G7N7N:&Ec:PHI=\836�_KRM:CHIEF:<?F:&HI=m} À 6sHI6!7$;>EFAIHIA<?B?BAiHI=��Q83ACJ�7\:&EF:CHI=\836�_KRM:PHIEc:b?c:yH>= � �SB=�deAPEFOQ:P7@=NjGjk:Q83APJ£¦

�(�������I�­� � ��b� �{���G�B�[�HIA ` 6 ��� �B7N:QSBAPOQOi:&H>=mnGn!n[6sHI=mnGnGnB�M] ��� �B7N:&Ec:PHI=\836�_KRM:CHIEF:<?F:&HI=mn!nGnB�M] ��� �G} À �>] ��� �[=N7$;>EFAWH>A<?[?FAHI=mn!nGnB6�H>=mnGn!nB�>] �� �1�<�M] ����� � �>n526!7@7�X =@JK?B6!JK?BAyH>=Z;MEBAC;TACEBEF62R>JM:s?BEc:b?B?F:<j!=@ACJ>6�=NJ�8GR>=ZhP7N=�:P;>;>EFA<deACJMHI=NO&6!JK?B=�S[ACJ>As=NJMS[6!EB=@?B=ZhPEc:PH>RM:<7NOQ6GJK?B6C];>EF63de6!EB=\:<OQA&;T6!E2APEc:�,05+!A�T!Z«%5�§�,-#&§�5��15+.iª1��345���5&^1�T!�Y%5��"!$# � n ((�4#FE �����F#:!5# 1 @5�5L>#F���5& � ���5� �J��D�� #FC>���B��D E,&>�0� &<@$�4#F�F# ��&>D 1 ��D E ���F#FL>LO��D &,D ��?�#F���J��E,&>� �4# �5&>� �F#F�5?�@J��?�?�#F� �J�N� @$DM���F&A&<�5&>�

�F#F�5?�@J��?�?�#F�AE �N� &>E �N�4#FCO� � �$&O�9KI@J���F&"!3C>��E,& &,�5���4� !3�F& 1 @5�5L>#F���5#9D4# H0&>�4�4���5��@5� D @5���F� !5#:���4� ���F@$� �A�5D4&OE,#F�$&O�$L ��/!3E � � ���5���� � ��#9E,&>�5� #F�5!5#F� ��&>�5� ���5#F�F#*��&>D KI@5��� �4� D #F?�@J��D4!J� �B�<�4DM�N���M��L>#F���5&<!5&>�F�B� �F��?�#FCO� #F� ?�&>�5&>DM���F&�- �I#*�5@� ��#F�5��� �4D &.D #F�F&GH���D4&.C/.5&"!#F�7�F#F�$& ��!$#:�5D #F�$CO#F�$#F� !3� #:�5@ � !5&>�:� @$���4� 1 ��D & ��E,&>�5�A!5&>#�� #FE �����F#�!5#&1 @5�5L>#F���5& #F�7K @J���0� � @5�J� 1 @5�5L>#F���5& & � &>E,�5D4&"@5�J�D &>�B��L>#F���5&=!5#J� #F���.�5��D4�4#FCO���B��D4& � ��� �4#B� C>���<�B� �5D ���5D4#F&G�� � !5&>�F��� @5�5# H0� C># �� ��M-&� &>�4� ���5!5� ��&>D:�4&>E,�5�F#FC># �� � ����CO��� �.!$#�@$�J� 1 @5�5L>#F���5&��! @5� ��D ?���E,&>�0� � !I@5�J� 1 @5�5L>#F���5&�� #F�4�4# � @$#F� C>&=@$�J�(D4&>�B��LO#F���$&=�4DM� #F��� @5� !5��E,#F�5#F�(� & #F��� @5� C>� !5��E,#F�5#F� )�� ���F& C/.$& ��! ��?��5#&>�F&>E,&O�0�4�A� !5&>�3!5��E,#F�5#F�<� &"���4� � C>#B�N� �<@5�5� &O! @5� �4���F� &>�F&>E,&>� �4� !$&O��C>�I!$��E,#F�5#F� ) � &.!5#�� ���F# �4� � #3� C>D # H0&� ��� � � G-;=@$�F�B� HI#F&G�M�(!5#2C>���5�4#F!5&>DM��D & �M���F&�1 @5�5L>#F���5& CO��E,&=@5�J�(D &>�B��L>#F���5&��'� !5@$& ��D ?���E,&>�0� #�C/.5& �F&>?0� ?��F#�&>�F&>E,&>� �4#2!5#�� C>��� K @5&>�F�F#!5#�)'#F�"E,� !5� C/.5& ���! �&OK @5# H����F?0�(�� ��� � � M-:�����"���FCO@$�5#���COC>��D4?�#FE,&O�0�4#5� &>C>�5#FC>#�� #J�5@� � H0&>!5&>D & C/.5&"! � ����� # �4@5&>�5!5�(#J� #FE �����F#!5# 1 @5�$LO#F���$&,CO��� ���5����D4�4@5�5#:�4#FE �����F#�!5#9�5D4&>!5#FCO�N� ##!%�$���7� # .J�����FC>@5�J� ��&>D4!5# �M� !5#9�����4&OD4&,&>� �5D4&O�4� # H0�5- � � #F!$& � &"� &>E,�5�F#FC>& ���5L>#FC/.�& � #F�5�J��!$D & !5#�� #F��D4?�#F� & E,&>!5#FC>��� 1 ��D E ���F#FL>L>#B��E,� � �9D �$&O��� � & #F�$�5��!5D & !5#�� #F��D4?�#F� &��9D �$&O��� � & E,&>!5#FC>��� � ���! ����� ����5L>#FC/.�& �0(��%?0�N�4�4�<!5# ��D #F��&(�5# @��4#FE,�J�N� #FC>�,!5&>�%CO���5& !5#� ��D C>��� 1 ��D4E ���F#FL>LO#B��E,� � �I#F� H0&>�4�4D � &(#F��?0�N��� �<!5# ��D #F�"&��3#F!5� &"#F��CO���5&,!5#� ��D4C>�A&��I#F� H0&>��� D4� &"�5# @ � #FE,�5�N� #FC>�<!5# �3#F!5� � � � � � �� ��� ��� ��� � � � � M- �I#9�$@� �A#F�5��� �4D &31��D4&,� E,&>�5�<!5#E,&>�5L>#F���J��D &��*D �5&>�4�4� ! �I#F� H0&>�4�4D � & �3#F!5� � D &>�4� ���5!5� �5# @ 1 &>!5&>�F#�� KI@5��� �4�(���5�J��D & &>� �5�F#FC># � ��E,&>� �4& �5&>�F�F& �$D ������� #FL>#F���5#J#F�5#FL>#B���F# /!@5� ���5!5�,H���D4#B���5#F�F#2&(#F�2K @J���0� # �JCO�N�4��D &"&>�4#F�4�4&O�$LO#B���F&��:H0&>!5#%�$# @��OH���� �4#3�5&>� ���$- �$- � ����&OD C>@5# � #F�%�J��!5D4& !5#�� #F��D ?�#F� & E,&>!5#FC>���� # 1 ��D4E ���F#FL>L � C>���

��� � � � ����� �

���4H$# & @$�A#F�5!5# HI#F!5@5�.C/.5& & #F�2�5��!5D & !5#�� #F��D ?�#F�"& C/.5& & E,&>!5#FC>��� �& �B�(� &>C>���5!J�"�5D4������� #FL>#F���5& C>���

������� � � � ��� � � ��� ���

���4H$#� & @5�,#F�5!5# HI#F!5@5� C/.$& & #F�5?0�N�4�4�.!$#� ��D #F� & @5� ��� � D4� C/.5& & #F�JCO���5&=!5#� ��D C>� & #F�5�5D #FE,� &=�5# @,�4#FE,�J�N�4#FCO� !5&>���4&>CO���$!5��� G-

Page 119: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}P} �� ��� � �4*�# -�/�,��2!$#0/ ��� ,

��=^S[ACJ>AiHI6G7N7N6s;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=$S[6!OQ;>7@=\83=^8cw>6�J>ACJ0SB=$7\:PSF83=\:<J>AQ=NJM_KRM:PH>EF:PEB6�J>6!7$?B=N;ZAlHI=£:PJM:<7N=NSB={aMJMAPEc:&S ` AC7r?c:�VAKSBSB=N:&;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?BAi:���;TAKSU?F=£:<;M;>7@=\8G:<?BAi:���=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>=G�9=@JD_KRM:<JK?FA&=NJD6!SFSB6aThPR>Ec:<J>AiSBAP7NAQ;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F=Yn �£Ec:HI=$6kSBSB6�7@6�;>=[fRDS[6!OQ;>7@=\83= S[ACJ>Ai_CRM6G7N7@6�8cw>6�=NJK?B6GE ` 6!J>hPACJ>A�JM6G=£SB=@7N7NAPhP=\SBO&={:PEB=\SU?FA<?F6G7N=N8G=Y¦

�B§!�¹� �£R>?[?B=£hP7N={R>APOQ=NJ>=£SBAPJ>AQOQAPEB?F:P7@=\�>©�BªF�¹�F52ACJl?FRI?[?F=£=$hCEB6k83={S[ACJ>Ai:b?F6GJ>=N6!SB=N�M©�B«F�¹� �RM:<7\8cw>6�R>APOQA0f6�deAPEB?BRMJM:b?FAC�>©�-�!�¹�F¡VSB=NS[?B6�R>J�JWR>OQ6GEFAQ;>EB=NOQAi8cw>6�J>APJ�f6�HI=\S[;T:<EF=N�M©�-#F�¹�Fx27\83R>JM={?BEF=N:PJ>hPAC7@=�=\S[AKSB8G6G7N=$S[ACJ>A&6!_KR>=N7N:<?B6GEF=\�>©�i^U�¹�c�2J�?BEF=\:<J>hCAP7NA�6!_KR>=N7\:b?B6!EBA�f6�:<JT8cw>6�=NSBACSF836!7@6k�>n

opJ _CRM6!S[?B6D;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=uJ>APJ ` =�SBAPJ>A�J>APOQ=�H>=~=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>=�]vOi:�SBAP7NA�H>=2;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=~607YX :bt�6GEFOi:<j!=@ACJ>6EF=@hCRM:<EcH>:u7\:2_KRM:<JK?B=@?¾f:HI=K=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>=I8cw>6VSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PJ>A2=K;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F=Y©b;M=[fRy;>EB6k83=\SB:POQ6GJK?B6C]!J>6!7@7\:2;MEB=NOi:2S[=W:bt�6GEFOi:8cw>6?BRI?B?B=$hC7@=�=NJMHI= ` =NHIRM=$8cw>6wT:<J>J>A&7\:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:�HI={6kSBSB6GEF6�R>ACOQAywM:PJ>J>A&7N:y;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:yHI={6!SFSB6GEF6�OQAPEB?F:P7@6C©J>6!7@7\:QS[6k83APJTH>:Q8cw>6 ` =$SBAPJMAQH>6GhP7N={=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>= 8cw>6�wM:<J>JMA&7\:&;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:&HI=$6kSBSB6GEF6hCEB6k83=$SB6GJ>jk:y:P7$83ACJC?F6GOQ;ZAhPAIHI6!EB6�HI6G7N7\:¹;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:¢HI=�6!SFSB6GEF6�:b?F6GJ>=N6!SB=Y©�J>6G7N7N:¹?B6!EBjk:¹8cw>6 ` =�SBAPJMA HI6!hP7N=�=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>=s8cw>6�wM:<J>JMA¹7N6;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:0HI=96!SFS[6!EB6QR>ACOQ=@J>=96lHI=96!SFS[6!EB6&deAPEB?BRMJM:b?F=Y©(6l8GACSpf �*;T6!Es7N6l:<7@?BEF6PnD�9=ºfA.8cw>6lEB6!JMHI6i7N6i;>EB6k836kHI6GJK?B=deEc:PSB=(H>6G7N7@6Q;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=u��83=NAMf6&SBRMSF8363?B?B=NL>=N7@=mHI=*6kSBSB6GEF6 ` 6GEF6&Ald�:P7NSB6k�sf6&7N:�;>EF6!SB6GJ>jk:lHI6!7@7N6Q;M:<EFAP7N6��U?BR>?[?B=\�>]�B_KRM:P7N8cwM6!�>](�B6!SB=NS[?B6k�>]I:<7\83R>JM=Y]MH>63?[?F6�VW�M§"!X\�5 Z9«c§�\m��,05Z;Z6GE27\:&EF:PhP=NAPJ>6�:<;>;Z6GJT:y6kS[;MEB6kSBSF:>n526!7@7\:Q7NAPhP=\8G:&HI6!=$;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=£HI6!7$;>EF=@OQAiACEFHI=NJ>6�SB=$=@JK?FEBAIHIRM8GAPJ>AiHIRM6�S[AC7@=$_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF=�]I=@7¢V%�M§�!A\�5 Zv«c§�g

\m��,-#]�T!X5+��#W,1�G§�3�#��8cw>6i8GAPEFEB=\S[;ZAPJTHI6&: �[?BRI?B?B=\�>]�[APhCJ>=\�l6,SB=@OQ=N7@=���6Q=@7�V%�M§�!A\�5 Zv«c§�\m��,-#9#0�05F�0\m#W!TYW5�§"3i#���8cwM683ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6v:��[6kS[=\SU?F6!�M]{�B:<7NOQ6GJ>A�R>J>AK�>]$�F_KRM:<7\8cw>6!��6~:<JM:P7@AChPw>6¢�$EB=@de6GEF=@?B=>:PHy=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>=�n(½(6GE^deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:<EF6;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=(83APJK?F6GJ>6!JC?F=(=@7*_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?FAPEF6�R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7N6P]�8cw>6QS[=(=NJMHI=\8G:�83ACJ��^]�6Q_KR>6G7N7@A�6!SB=\SU?F6GJ>j!=N:P7@6C]�8cwM6SB=V=NJMHI=\8G:D83ACJ���](AW8!83ACEBEF6Q=@JK?BEFAIHIR>EFEB6iHI6!=9SB=@OyLTAC7@=�](HI63?B?B= ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N=*=@JTHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=�](;T6!Es=@JTHI=N8!:<EF6i=@JTHI= ` =\HIR>=hP6!J>6GEF=\83=�©M;Z6GE�6kSBSB=£RTS[=\:<OQAi7N6s7@6G?[?F6GEF6sOQ=@JWRMSF83AC7@6sHI6!7@7\:i;M:PE[?F6�aMJM:P7@6yHI6G7N7YX :<7@d�:<LZ63?FAl_KRM:<7N=�� ]�]��M]$n!nGnk��83ACJ6 ` 6GJK?BRT:<7N=$:<;>=\83={6�=NJMHI=\83=��­n¿$6�SB6G={;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>={;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B=$SB=�deAPEFOQ:P7@=NjGjk:<J>AQ83ACOQ6�SB6GhCR>6P¦

�B§!� ��� � ����� ���������e;Z6GE�AChPJ>=^=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>A��£] S[6�� f6yR>J ����8G=@AMf6�RMAPOQAK�3]$:<7N7@ACEF: � f6yR>J ����8G=@AMf6OQACE[?c:<7N6k�[�3©�BªF�9����� � ���0� ���Z�vAi6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B6!OQ6GJK?B6����^� ���Q�9� ���Z������J>APJ0;Z6GE2?FRI?[?F=£hC7@=$=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>=�� ]TSB6��f6 � �Y83=NAMf6�¬�EB6k83AW�­]I:<7N7@ACEF:���f6�� ��83=NAMf6xv?B6!J>=N6!SB6k�­]>8cwM66k_CRM= ` :<7N6�7@AChP=\8G:<OQ6!JC?F6:��[6kS[=\SU?F6�:P7@OQ6!J>ARMJ�=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>A,8cw>6&f6s¬�EB6k83A&6�J>APJ�f6�xv?B6!J>=N6!SB6!�C�3©�B«F����� � ���Q� ���Z����� ` =*f6�:P7@OQ6GJMA&RMJ�=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>A �.8cw>6&f6� �Y83=NAMf6�R>ACO&AW�96 � �Y83=NAMf6deAPEB?BR>JT:b?BAW�[�3©�-�!����� � �����]� �������0� ` =(f6�:<7NO&6!J>A�RMJ�=NJMHI= ` =NHIRMA���?F:P7@6�8cw>6���f6 � ��8G=@AMf62;>EF=NO&AW�m6�J>ACJDf6 ����8G=@AMf6H>=NSB;M:<EF=��[�­©�-#F����� � ���Q� ���Z����� ` =*f6�:P7@OQ6GJMA&RMJ � ��8G=@AMf6?BEF=N:PJ>hPAC7@A&=NSBACSF836!7@6¾�V8cwM6&f6�:PJM8cw>6� ��8G=@AMf6�?FEB=\:<JMhPAP7NA6k_KR>=@7\:b?F6GEFAK�B�­©�i^U� ��� � ���D� ���Z�����3�BR>JM�iSB=@hCJ>=@aT8G:��BR>J._KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=\�Q6�_KR>=@JTHI=Y]Z;Z6GE�AChPJ>=£=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>A�� ]ZSB6��¢f6�R>J

� ��8G=@AMf6?BEF=N:PJ>hPAC7@A&6!_KR>=N7N:<?B6!EBAW�­]I:<7N7@ACEF:��qf6�R>J � ��83=NAMf6?FEB=\:<JMhPAP7NA�=\SBACSF836G7N6k�B�­n

�9APJ&=>_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?FAPEF=WSB=I;ZACSFS[ACJ>A�deACEBOi:P7@=NjGjk:<EF69;ZAP=I;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=W;>=[fRi83APOQ;>7N6!SFSB6vHI=T_CRM6G7N7@6u;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=Yn�*6!H>=N:PO&Ai_KRM:P7N8cw>6�6kS[6!O&;M=@Ai83ACJ�7\:QEF6G7\:b?B= ` :sdeACEBOi:P7@=NjGjk:<jG=NAPJM6P¦

Page 120: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� �� � RI?[?F=�=�JKRMO&6!EB=�OQ:PhPhC=@ACEB=DHI=��»SBAPJMA:<JM8cwM6�Oi:PhPhP=NAPEF={HI=m} � � � �^� ��� �Q� ��� 3��B½(6!EµAChPJ>=�JWR>OQ6GEFA J>6 6!SB=NS[?B6²R>JMAOi:<hPhC=@ACEB6k� � � ��� �

�B5�6!SFS[R>JlJKRMO&6!EBAyOQ=@J>ACEB6�HI={|,f6�83ACO&;MEB6%�S[A&deEc:/�&6&} � � � � � � � ��� � � �G��B½(6!E¤H>R>6�;>R>JK?B= _CRT:<7\S[=\:PSB=�;M:PSFSB: R>JT:EB6G?[?c:P� � � � ���Z� ���s� ��� ����� � � ��� ����W�G��c�W6iRMJq;>R>JK?BA.x�S[?F:�deEc:0HIR>6,;>RMJC?F=�� 6�]M:<7N7NAPEc:yS[?F:Q:<JT8cw>6�deEF:,� 6*�u� � � � ���Z� ����� ��� ������� � � ���� � � � >�[�� �hCJ>=,JWR>OQ6GEFA¤;M:<EF=0f6 SBAPOQOi:�HI=lHIR>6JWR>OQ6GEF=$;>EF=@OQ=\� � �^� ����� �� ���Z� ��� ����� � � ��W�[��c�v:PO�L>=\:<JMH>A¢7YX APEcHI=NJ>6�H>6GhP7N=�:PH>HI6!JMHI=�7\:S[ACOQOQ:&J>ACJD8G:<OyL>=\:P� � � � ���Z� � ��� � � � � >�O�

�W=vACSFS[6!E ` =V8cwM6,?BR>?[?B6�7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=V8cwM6�:<LML>=N:POQA.deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:<?BADOQ6!HI=\:<JK?F6l=u_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB=vS[ACJ>A?BR>?[?B6l;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=(SB6GOQ;>7N=\83=V8cw>6C]£J>6!7V8G:P7N8GAP7NA0;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P]$: ` EB6!OQO&A0HIA ` RI?FA�=NJMHI=\8G:PEB6,8GAPJ�7@6G?[?F6GEF6;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=�nz��=�S[ACJ>A�J>6G77@=NJ>hPRT:<hPhC=@A�?F:PJK?B=:P7r?FEB=_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB=�n ¼DAC7r?F=�HI=�6kSBSB=��0;TAKSBSBAPJ>A�6kSBSB6GEF6�[EF6!8GR>;Z6GEc:b?B=\��OQ6GJK?BEF6�:<7@?BEF=#�vdeR>APEF=@6kSB8GAPJ>A�H>:P7@7N62;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@=@?¾f:�H>=MdeACEBOi:<7N=NjGj!:PjG=NAPJ>6uHI6!7@7\:�7NAPhP=\8G:�H>6G=M;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?F=HI6!7$;>EF=@OQAQAPEcHI=NJ>6Pn� ��� ���"��,�-���*�# ����,(�&��� ����#)�(����,�!$#)���', � ��� � ,�!$#0/�,op7345+!�r"�M§brbr�5����_pT��#%3+3@§�3i�cr"5�«c§��;#W5q*$,-#1��5�«c§"\�5¢�;#W3T*$,05+./����,c��5+!$#�f6�83ACS[?B=@?BRM=r?FAQHM:yRMJ�§"3 ^3§Pª1#%\s�<]TH>:P7@7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6HI6!=�\s#%,0.U5+!X5Z6�HM:<7N7YX =@JTS[=N6GOQ6sHI6!7@7N6 ^W��,0.U�T3i#Qªc#%!S^W�",0.Q§"\s#�� ^3ª�^B�­n¿mX�§�3 ^3§Pª1#W\m� � X$f6�8GACS[?B=@?BR>=@?BA,HM:<=$SB6GhPRM6GJK?B={=NJ>hPEF6!H>=@6!JC?F=Y¦

�B§!�lRMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6�JKRMO&6!EF:PL>=N7@6��iHI=£8GACS[?F:PJC?F={=@JTHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=�¦�&�¤� �T� ¾� �<� �T� � ` � ` � � ` � � ` � � � � � � � � �%aba%ar�

�BªF�lRMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6�JKRMO&6!EF:PL>=N7@6 � HI= ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@={=NJMHI= ` =NH>RM:<7N=Y¦� � � �£� �� �M� � ` � ` � � ` � � � � � � � � �%a%abar�

�B«F�l;Z6GE�APhPJM= ��R>J0=NJMS[=N6GOQ6�� � H>=£83AKSU?c:<JK?B=�;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` 6�: ��:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?F=Y¦� � � �

` � � � � � � � � � �%a%aba6 �I& � #�#F� �4D � !5@5C>&(���5C/.5& #F���5D &>!5#FCO�N�4� � � &>� � &>D4&(� @5E,&>D � 9�4# .J�

��� ��� � ) � � ��� � � � ���

6 �����,?��F#$�4�4D @5E,&>�0� # �J�$��DM� #F�0� D4�I!5�����4#��5���.� #B��E,� #F�"?�D ��!5� !5#J&>� �5D4#FE,&>D &&1 ��D E ���FE,&>� �4&:�B� �5D4������� #FL>#F���5& � ��&>D*!5@5& �5@5�0� #!5#F��� #F�0� #��J��� � � @5�5� &>! @$�J�.� ���B� D &G���M��� !5��� � #B�(�5���<�����4� #B��E,�(� ��&>C># �JCO��D & C/.5& #��5@$� �4#�� ���$�.!5#F��� #F�0� #�& C/.5& �B� D &G���M� & @5�5#FCO�$-

6 �I#3D #FC>��D !5#%C0.5&"��� �$#B��E,�,!5&>CO#F�4� !$#�D4#F�I@$�5C>#B��D &(��#3� #FE �����F#�!$# 1 @5�5L>#F���5& ��&OD CO@$# ����� H��<�F&G��� � � � & �B�,�4��E,E �.!5# � &� � � & K @5#F�5!5#2��� �5#B��E,�(�J��DM��1 DM��� �N� � �B� �5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& !J�N� �.C>��� !5��&>D ��?��5# � ! � & � ! � & �B�(� ��E,E � !5# � & � �4& & �4���F� �4& � &�B�"� ��E,E � !5# � & � !��B� K @J���F&(#FE,�5�F#FCO�.��� @5?�@J��?��F#B���$L �,!5&>�F�B�,� ��E,E �(!5# � & � &(!$&O�F�B�,�4��E,E �.!5# � & � M- �:��� #%� #FE �����F#�!5#1 @5�5L>#F���5& ����� �4#B��E,� #F�$!5#FCO��D & C>����� �B� 1 @5�5L>#F���5& !$#2��!5!$#FLO#F���$& &-!$�OH0&>�5!$�,� !5#F�4����� #FL>#F���5& ���5C0.5& #F���$D &>!5#FCO�N� �.!5#�#F!$&O�0�4# �� � !J�4#����� #F&>�5& @5�J� 1 ��D4E.@5�B� �5# @����$# � @J���F& ������� � � � � � � � � � � � � G-� @J���F#3��! &>� &>E,�5#F� ! � &>� #F��� ���5� ���FE,&>�5�,!5@5& � ! � &>� #F�4�4���5�<���FE,&>�5�"�4D & � ! � �5��� �5# @�!5#3C>#F�5K @5& � ! � &>�M�N��� ��E,&O�0�4&.K @J�N�4�4D ���&.#F� ?�&>�5&>D &,K @5&>�F�F#3C/.5&"���M���$#F�F#F� C>���5�AC0.5&,���FE,&>�5�<@5� CO&>D�� � �I@5E,&>D4� !2� �5��� �$# @ !$#*@5� C>&>D4�4�A� @5E,&>D � !��A&>�M�N��� ��E,&O�0�4&,@5�C>&>D4�4�"�I@$E,&OD4�.!5#2#F�5!5# HI#F!5@5# .5���5�5�"@5�5�"CO&>D��M�.�$D ���5D4#F&>�� �$-

� � � &>� &>E,�5#F� & � �B��E ��?�?�#F��D(�J��D4�4&<!5# � � � � � E ��?�?�#F��D �J��D4�4& !5&># E �N� &>E �N�4#FCO#9� ���5� !5#F��� D �N�4�4# � M- � � ��� � D4� & �4� ���0� #K @J��� �4# � ���0(���KI@$&O���M�"���M���$L �.HI#2�4���5�.� ��� �4#%@5��E,#F�5#�K @J��� �4& !5���5�5& � M- �=� � D4#����5C>��DM� � ���5� � ��� C/.5# � ! � K @J��� #�� @$���4# � !J&>COC�-

Page 121: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��>}�-�!�lRMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6���HI=£SB=@OyLTAC7@={;Z6GE83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` = ` 6GEFA"��deR>J>j!=@ACJM:<7N=Y¦

�0�¤���v�F�v�c�v�c� ��-#F�lRMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6 ��HI=£SB=NO�LZAP7N={;T6!E�_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?BACEB=�¦

���¤� �^� ����i^U�lRMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6 �¹HI= S[6!hPJ>=$:PRMS[=N7N=N:PEB=*�e7N6�;M:PEB6!JC?F6!SB=�?BACJMHI6�:<;Z6GEB?F:&6s8cw>=NRMSF:C�­¦

���¤�K�[�F�c���SB6GEF6GOQAD7N6,7N63?[?F6GEF6 �Z] ¾] �b]unGnGnF83ACO&6lO&6G?F: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@=V;T6!Ey83AKSU?c:<JK?B=9=@JTHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=��eACSFSB=N:D;Z6GEy=@JTHI=N8!:<EF683AKSU?c:<JK?B=(=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:<7N=^hC6GJ>6!EB=\8cw>6QHI= �K�6C]£:<JM:P7@AChC:PO&6!JK?B6P]ZRMSB6GEF6GOQA��£]��]��T]*nGnGnF83ACO&6&OQ63?c: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N= ;Z6GE` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@={=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:<7N=Y]>AKSBSB=\:�;Z6GE~6!7@6!O&6!JK?B=$hC6GJ>6!EB=\83=$HI= �in

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GCFEGC�HJI � 8;L���=�<D8��@��#~«1�k�0\p§�!A\�5A5+!$��5+��5����M§"345�#�3i#��b§�,05�§CªW5+345q5+!o��5+��5����M§"345$�W�"!$�2�;#W\�\s#£?F6GEFO&=NJ>=mt½(6GE�=NJMHI=\8G:PEB6Q?F6GEFOQ=@J>=9hP6!J>6GEF=N8G=*RMSB6GEF6GOQAD7@6iOQ6G?F: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@=�¦ �­] � �Y] � � ��] � ` ] � � ] � � ]9n!nGn!n@n�6P]^=@J¢_KR>6kSU?FA83ACJK?B6!S[?BAT]I7@6�8GACS[?F:<JK?F={=@JMH>= ` =\HIRM:<7N=£SBAPJ>AQHI6G?[?B6y:<JM8cw>6h\m#W,0.U5+!X5V«1n�5+���05�n

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GCFEGCFEvIKw�@AL����>|�N�N 9b@$��= :�N����A5��"5�«c�"!$��^W��,0.U�T3i#�§"\s�".j5�«1n&#�\��T\�\m# 3�#�#W��*$,-#W�1�05���!X5���#%3X\�5 *&� � � ` � � aba%a � �

���"�k# � Q#��T!�§l«1�k�0\p§�!A\s#6*$,-#1��5�«c§"\�5+�b§0§�� §�,�r;�".h#%!X\�5[# �-`kf � � f�t�t�t0f � � �%��!o�/\m#W,0.U5+!X5�t¿£:&HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6�HI6!7@7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6�H>6G7N7@6�deAPEFO�RM7@6�LZ6GJ�deAPEFOQ:<?B6�HI6!7@7\:&7@AChP=\8G:�H>6G={;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=*f6�HI=�?F=@;ZAi=@JTHIRI? �?B= ` AT]>:<JM:P7@AChC:y:&_KR>6!7@7\:&hP=pf:�=NJM8GAPJK?BEc:b?c:�J>6!7@7\:&7@AChP=\8G:y;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6&��6�83APJK?F=@JWR>6!EB6!O&AQ:&RMSF:<EF6��]X�,]A�&]nGn!nB8GAPOQ6�O&6G?F: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@=�;Z6GE~deACEBOyR>7N6�LZ6GJ�deACEBOi:b?F6k�3n

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GCFEGC���IKw�@AL����>|�N�{[8�<'��@AL���N 9�N�� OD!qp #0��*o,-#0�1�05���!o#u��5��9p�Q#6�T!�§�^3ª�^¢�%#��%������5F��^3§��T!Z§2��#%3+3i#�%#sr"�X#%!X\�5m«c�"!$�"5iYW5��"!X5*

��� � r�!X5T^W��,0.U�T3@§�§�\m��.U5�«F§ Q#S�T!Z§ ^3ª�^�� �q#u�Q#S�T!Z§u^3ª�^Wf9§�3+3i�",B§l������Q#��T!�§ ^3ª�^�� �q#u #�� �%�"!$�u^3ª�^1f9§"3+3i��,B§���¹�9�y�1fV��¹�9�y�0f9�� � �&���%��!o�e^3ª�^� � �q#u�Q#S�T!Z§u^3ª�^S# � Q#S�T!Z§]�¾§",05�§Pª%5+3i#U5+!$�"5+�b5��"�M§�3i#Wfu§"3+3i��,F§�� � �$�S#y� ���A���%��!o�u^3ª�^��� ��5�#W!A\�p §"34\�,c�RQ#S�T!Z§ ^3ª�^%t½(6GEuAChPJ>=&^3ª�^9x ` :P7@6�R>JT:y6kH�R>JM:QS[AC7N:QHI6!7@7N6sSB6GhPRM6GJK?B=$8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJM=Y¦}Cnu f6�RMJM:&deAPEFO�R>7\:&:b?BACOQ=N8!:>©�>n~6!SB=NS[?B6�R>JM:&6kH�RMJM:QS[AC7N:�^3ª�^�� ?c:<7N6�8cw>62 �������y�­©|Mn~6!SB=NS[?BACJ>A,6!SF:b?B?F:PO&6!JK?B6�HIRM6�^3ª�^e� 6h�»6!H.R>J.R>J>=\83A�83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` A�L>=@JT:<EF=@A]{¤�Y� A��gA0� �u?c:<7N=^8cwM6 � ��� {l���­©

�Tn~6!SB=NS[?BACJ>A¹6kSB:<?[?F:POQ6GJK?B6�R>JM: ^3ª�^9�,]�R>JM: ` :<EF=N:PL>=@7N6 �¤6�R>J _KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF6 � � ��A �>�l?c:<7N=�8cwM6 � � �����y�3n

526!7�8G:CS[A ���P�QSB=�HI=\836.8cw>6D7\:(^3ª�^h�f6DRMJM:'!$#srK§bY%5���!o#3©J>6G7�8G:PSBA ��|C�3]~S[6({ ���v]~:<7N7@ACEF:��f60R>JT:«1��!�r"5+�T!TYW5��"!$#G]*S[6/{ � �v]^:P7@7NAPEc:_ f6iR>JM:��"5F� r"5+�T!TYW5��"!$#G]mS[6/{¤��� ]^:<7N7@ACEF:_ f6iR>J¢8GAPJMH>=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P©^J>6G78G:CS[A.���K�3]TSB6 � � �^]Z:<7N7@ACEF:h�f6�RMJM:2^W��,0.U�T3@§_VW�M§"!X\�5 Z9«c§�\p§��T!X5+��#W,1�G§�3 .h#%!X\m#3]�SB6 � � ��]T:P7@7NAPEc:h�f6�R>JT:^W��,0.U�T3@§hV%�M§�!X\�5 Z9«c§"\º§U#0�05F�0\m#W!TYW5�§"34./#W!A\s#Gn[�W6e¤f6�R>JM: ^3ª�^(J>APJ,:<?BAPOQ=\8G:M]C:<7N7NAPEc:=N7T8GAPJ>JM63?[?F= ` A�;>EF=@JM8G=@;T:<7N6�f6��J>6G7T8G:PSBA,���C�­]Mf66{�J>6!7M8G:CS[A,�Y|C�­]COQ6GJK?BEF6~J>6G7Z8G:CS[Ai���W�9f6�� =@7TS[=NO�LZAP7NA�7@AChP=\83A�;>EF=@JT83=N;M:<7N6Pn(526!7T8G:CS[Ai���K�^7\:` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6 �0f6uHI63?B?F:U5+!$�"5�«c#��;#W3oVW�M§"!X\�5 Z9«c§�\m��,-#^6u7\:6^3ª�^>�¤=@7£«c§".u*X�j��p §bY%5���!o#j~m��,B§�!�r;�0�S��#%3$V%�M§�!X\�5 Z9«c§"\s�",-#3n

Page 122: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��;��9APOQ6�S[=^f6�hP=pf: ` =\SU?FAy:y;>EFAP;ZACSB=r?FA&HI6!7�7@=NJ>hPRT:<hPhC=@AyHI6G7N7N:&7NAPhC=N8!:s;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P]KS[=�;>R^fA&=NJK?BEFAIHIR>EFEB6R>J:<7NhPACEB=@?BOQAi;Z6GE�SU?c:<L>=N7N=@EF6�SB6sR>JM:l6!SB;>EB6kSBSB=NAPJ>6if6�R>JM:S^3ª�^­n��9ACJK?B=NJKRM=N:PO&A�:PH.:CHIA<?B?F:<EF6�7N6y83ACJ ` 6GJMjG=NAPJ>=£8cwM683ACJMSB6GJK?BACJ>A.HI=VEF=\HIR>EFEB6i=N79JWR>OQ6!EBA.HI6!7@7N6,;M:PEB6!JK?B6!SB=�¦�AP7@?BEF6l:P7@7N6l837\:<RTS[AC7@6ihC=ºf:D:CHIA<?B?F:b?F6,J>6!798G:CS[AD;MEBAC;TA��SB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P]{SB=mSU?c:<L>=N7@=\SF836Q8cw>6y=*_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?FAPEF=(7@6!hPw>=NJ>Al;M=[fR�SU?FEB6G?[?c:<OQ6GJK?B6QHI6!=m83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =*;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM:P7@= ��e;Z6GEu83RM=T=N7Z8!:<OQ;ZA�H{X :<jG=NAPJM6�HI=�R>Jl_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?FAPEF6�f6�SB6GOQ;>EF627\:�OQ=@J>=NOi:e^3ª�^m8cw>6�S[6!hPR>62=N7�S[R>A�=@JMH>=N8G6k�­nmxH6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM¦

�[�B� � �^��� ��� �I�B�£��� �� � >�B�m� ��� >�SB=$SB8GEB= ` 6

� �o� ��� �� �� � &� ���

� � �^�[�[��� ��� �I�$��� � >�B�m� ��� >�[�SB=$SB8GEB= ` 6

��� ��� ��� �� � &� ���I�

� � �^�[��� ��� �W�£��� {� � Q� ��� >�[�B�[�SB=$SB8GEB= ` 6

� �^��� ��� ��� {� � &� ���I�B�

�B� ��� ��� ��� �W�B�$��� {� � Q� ���I�B�[�SB=$SB8GEB= ` 6

���$� ��� ��� {� � &� ���I�½(6GE~HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cwM6?FRI?[?F6s7N66^3ª�^vwM:<JMJ>AQR>JM:Q;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f: � f6�SBR��,83=N6GJK?F6sHI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6�8cw>6P¦}Cnu?BRI?B?B6�7N6�deAPEFO�R>7N6�:b?BACOQ=N8cw>6�wM:PJ>J>AQ7\:y;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf: �Q©�>n2S[6�7\:�^3ª�^6¤wM:&7N:&;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf: � �e=N;TAP?B6kS[=$=NJMHIR>?[?B= ` :C�3]T:<7N7NAPEc:�7\:�^3ª�^�������uwM:&;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f: �Q©|Mn2S[6�7@6]^3ª�^U 6(��wM:PJ>J>A�7N:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf: ���e=N;TAP?B6!SB=~=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` 6k�3]~:<7N7@ACEF:�7@6/^3ª�^��� ���&�­]��� ���y�­]�� � �&�vwM:<J>JMA&7\:Q;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f: �Q©�Tn2S[697N:�^3ª�^D¹wT:�7\:2;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf: ���e=N;ZA<?B6kS[=I=NJMHIR>?[?B= ` :C�3]P:<7N7@ACEF:27@6�^3ª�^9� ���A�£6�� ���$�^wM:PJ>J>A�7\:2;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:

�Qn� ����� �@#0� ,(#�� , ��,�� ,�� ��� � � ��, -�!$����#0/ ������ � /�, /�*�+�,���-���63aMJ>=NjG=NAPJM6Pn��2JT:�AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>j!:�HI=�R>JM: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N6 �,=NJlRMJM:�^3ª�^2f6HI6G?[?c: ` =NJM83AC7N:<?F:yS[6�6�SBAP7NAySB6 �Df67�X =@JMH>=N8G6HI=2RMJ _KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF60AP;>;MR>EB6DSB6D6!SFSB: f6DJ>6!7�8G:POQ;TAqHI=�:PjG=NAPJ>6DHI=�R>J _KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?BACEB60: ` 6!JK?B6��g8GAPOQ6=NJMHI=\836Pn��2JM:lAI8G83ACEBEF6GJMj!:&J>APJ ` =NJM8GAP7\:b?F:lHI= RMJM: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6if6yHI6G?[?F:lR>JM:iAI8!83APEFEF6GJ>jk:Q7@=NLT6!EF:Mn��W=(HI=\836y8cwM6R>JM: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6 ��f6�7N=NLT6!EF:&=NJ�RMJM:2^3ª�^vx�SB6�6�SBAP7NAiS[6 ��wM:Q:<7NO&6!J>AQR>JM:&AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>j!:�7@=NLT6!EF:Q=NJ0xsn

� ����� �#!0��!.&>�4&OE,�$#F� !��B������� ��� � � �� � !>H��=�F&>��� � � ��� � � �� � !O&O! &:!5# H0&>D � � !J� ��� ��� � �� � G-2;=&>�I�5D #FE,� CO��� � �B� � !5#� � �$��� &:�$&O�ICO��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5&�!5&>� KI@5��� �4# �JCO�N� ��D4&"!IE,&>�0� D4&:�F� &:�5&>�F�B�=�4&OC>���5!5�$- � ������ ��� � � ��� � ) ��� � ��� % � � � # �F&O?�?�& � � ��� � � ��� � &) � � ��� � ��� % � � �& #F��C>���5�5&G��� # H0�<�5D #F�$CO#F�5���F& & ) - (��0H0&>C>&.�5&>�F�B� ����� ��� ��� � ��� � ) ��� � � ��� % � � #F�%C>���5�5&G��� # H0� �5D #F�5C>#F�J���F& &(� &>E,�5D &3) !�E �.�B� � !5#�� � & �5&>�3CO��E,���<! � ��LO#F���$&.!5&>�3KI@5��� �4# �JCO�N� ��D4& ��� &(�B� � !5#� � &(�5&>�CO��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5&=!5# ��� � E,&O�0�4D & �B� � !5# � ��� �5��� & �$&O��CO��E,���(! � ��LO#F���$& !5# ��� G-3; &>�F�B������ ��� ��� � ��� � ) ��� � ��� % � �#F�2C>���5�$&>���4# H0�<�$D #F�5C>#F�J���F& & % !$�4@$��� & �F& � � ���5�"�$&O��CO��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��� & �B� � !5# � � �5��� & �$&O�2C ��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��� -� ������� ��� � � � ��� � ) ��� � ��� % � � & @5�J�"C>���5?�#F@5�5L>#F���5&"!�#F��C ��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��� & � � & #F��CO��E,���.! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��� &� ��� !5K @5#F�5!$#2�B� � !5#�� � & �B� � !5# � ��� �5���A�4���5�"�5&>��C ��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��� !$& �B� � !5# � � �$��� & �5&>��C ��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5& !5#��� - � �������� ��� ��� � ��� � ) ��� � � ��� % � � & K @J���0� # �5C �N� �A@5�$# H0&OD4�M���FE,&>�0� &�� �$���+.J� @5� C>���5�5&G��� # H0�A�5D #F�5C>#F�J���F&"!�E �,#F�� #FE �����F�(�F��?�#FC>�"�$D #F�5C>#F�J���F& & � �!I#F��C ��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��� & ��� � ��� � ) ��� � � ��� % � � 9& K @5&>�F�F�.!$# ��� & � � ��� % � � 9&�4@$�4�4& �F& H���D4#B���5#F�F#��4���5�,�5&>�2CO��E,���"! � ��L>#F���5& !$&O#2D #F� ��&G��� # HI#2K @J���0� # �JCO�N�4��D #-

Page 123: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��P|���b8��Jx�=�@+�qC+EqC�Hg5�6G7N7N:�^3ª�^���:C� � �o� � � �l� �� � ¤� ��� ���8cwM6 f6�R>J 8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6k�i7N6�;MEB=NOQ6�HIRM6AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG6sHI= ��SBAPJMA ` =NJM8GAP7\:b?B6��e7\:i;>EF=@Oi:i;Z6GEc8cwu®6if6�7YX =@JTHI=N8G6yHI6!7^_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF6��^]T7N:lS[6k83APJTH>:i;Z6GEc8cwv®6f6�J>6!7$8G:<OQ;ZAiH{X :PjG=NAPJ>6�HI= � �Z�3]>OQ6GJK?BEF6�7N:y?F6GEFj!:&AI8G83ACEBEF6GJMj!:�H>=���f6�7@=NLZ6GEc:���=@JD_KRM:PJC?FAQJ>APJ�f6�J>6G7$8!:<OQ;ZAH{X :<j!=@ACJ>69HI=KR>J&_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB6V: ` 6GJK?B6 �&8GAPOQ6V=NJMHI=\836C©<=@7W8G:POQ;TA�HI=I:<jG=NAPJM69HI= � �lf6�� ��� �I�3©P:<JM:P7@AChC:PO&6!JK?B67N6�;MEB=NOQ6�H>R>6�AI8G83ACEBEF6GJMjG6H>=�lSBAPJ>A ` =@JM8GAP7\:b?F6�6�7\:y?B6GEFj!:y6�7N=@LZ6GEc:>n*¿$6 ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@= �D6�lSBAPJMAy7N=@LZ6GEF6�J>6G7N7\:^3ª�^���=@JD_KRM:PJC?FAQwM:<J>JMAQ:P7@OQ6!J>AQR>JM:&AI8G83ACEBEF6GJMj!:s7N=NLT6!EF:K�­n

526!7@7\:u^3ª�^2�eLZ� � �^��� ��� �9���� � i� ��� >�~�Y8cw>6sf62RMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@OQ6!JC?F62_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?F:K�^?BR>?[?B6�7N62AI8G83ACEBEF6GJMjG6HI= ��S[ACJ>A ` =@JM8GAP7\:b?F62�e=N7P8G:PO&;ZA�H{X :<j!=@ACJ>6*HI= ���Qf6(=@J>d�:b?[?F=�� ��� �I� �� � Q� ��� >�3]k7N6*;>EF=@OQ6mHIRM6mAI8G83ACEBEF6GJMjG6HI= �SBAPJ>A ` =NJM83AC7N:<?B6�6s7�X R>7r?F=@Oi:l7@=NLT6!EF:D��=@7(8G:POQ;TAlH$X :PjG=NAPJ>6sHI= ���f6 � >�­n �R>=NJMHI= 7N: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N6��.J>ACJ�f67N=@LZ6GEc:&J>6G7N7N:�^3ª�^3]IOQ6GJK?FEB6�7\:�Df6�7@=NLZ6GEc:>n526!7@7\:S^3ª�^s�Y8!� � � ��� ��� ��� ��{� � �� ��� >�[�2?BR>?[?B6&7N6�AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG6sSB=N:�HI= ��8cw>6&HI= DS[ACJ>A ` =@JT83AP7\:b?F6�e=N7 8!:<OQ;ZA,H{X :PjG=NAPJ>6sH>= � �qf6S� � � �������� � i� ��� >�3]MOQ6GJK?BEF6�_KR>6!7@7NA,HI= ���f6 � Q� � �>�­nu50®6��.Ju®6

DS[ACJ>A,7N=@LZ6GEF6�JM6G7N7N:j^3ª�^­n�^3ª�^�83APOQ6y7N:���8!�3]{8cw>6�J>ACJ�83ACJK?B6GJMhPAPJMAiAW8!83ACEBEF6GJ>j!6�7@=NLZ6GEF6yHI=*:<7\83RMJM: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6C]SBAPJ>AiHI6G?[?B6s8cwM=@RMSB6Pn526!7@7\:u^3ª�^~��HM� � �o� ��� �V����{� � Q� ��� >�2�Y8cw>6sf62RMJM:s83ACJ>hP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6k�*J>APJ ` =TSBAPJMAsAI8G83ACEBEF6GJMjG6u7@=NLZ6GEF6HI= �]IOi:�7�X R>7r?F=@Oi:QAI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>j!:�HI= ��f6�7@=NLT6!EF:��e=N7$8G:POQ;TAiH{X :<j!=@ACJ>6�H>= � ��f6�� ��� �W�3nm¿£:�^3ª�^­]>_KR>=@JTHI=Y]IJMAPJ�f68cw>=NRMSF:��Uf6�:<;Z6GEB?F:K�­n¿$66^3ª�^��6k�­] ��dF�3]£�ewT�3]£� �B�3]£� �>�96i�e7��vS[ACJ>A&8cwM=@RMSB6�=@J0_KRM:<JK?FA�=NJ�6kSBSB6�?BRI?B?B6�7@6�AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG6�HI6G7N7N6 ` :PEB=\:<L>=N7N=SBAPJ>A ` =@JT83AP7\:b?F6Pn526!7@7\:/^3ª�^&��hK� ��� � ��� � � �^� ��� y� ��� ��>�[��7N6iAW8!83ACEBEF6GJ>j!6iHI= �¢SBAPJ>A ` =NJM83AC7N:<?B6C] _KR>6G7N7N6,HI= �S[ACJ>A7N=@LZ6GEF6D�eJ>6kSBSBR>Jq_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?BACEB6&wM:��8GAPOQ6Q=@JMH>=N8G6k�­©(SB=mACSFS[6!E ` =(:<JM8cwM6Q8cwM6&JM6G7N7N:0SBA<?[?FA<deACEBOyR>7N: ��� ��D7\:` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6���f6�S[AC7@AQJ>6!7@7�X =@JMH>=N8G6sHI6G7$_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?FAPEF66�JMAPJ�J>6G7£8!:<OQ;ZAQH$X :PjG=NAPJ>6 <nopJIaMJM6P]IJ>6!7@7\:�^3ª�^���=\��� � � ����� ���Z�V7@6�HIRM6�;MEB=NOQ6AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG6�HI= ��SBAPJ>A ` =NJM8GAP7\:b?B6�6�7N:�?B6!EBjk:lf6�7N=@LZ6GEc:�e=NJD_KRM:<JK?BAQ=N7£8G:POQ;TAiH{X :<j!=@ACJ>6�HI=�� ��f6 ���Z�3]M6�_KR>=NJMHI=$7\:D�e=��f6�R>JM:2^3ª�^v:P;T6!E[?c:>n�W6�S[=�83ACJMS[=\HI6!EF:PJ>A�?BRI?B?B6�7@6�^3ª�^V8cw>6:PL>L>=\:<OQAs=NJC?FEBAIHIAP?[?FA�J>6!7£z0�In ��;T6!EVdeACEBOi:P7@=NjGjk:<EF6~7@6 ` :PEB=N62;>EFAP;ZACSB=i�jG=NAPJM=MHI6G7T7@=NJ>hCRM:<hChP=NA�JT:b?BRMEF:P7@6C]CSB=M;>R fA�d�:C83=N7@OQ6!JC?F6�83ACJMS[?F:b?c:<EF6~8cw>626!SFSB62S[ACJ>A�?BRI?B?B68cwM=@RMSB6P]CACSFS[=\:�8cw>6~J>ACJ83ACJK?B6GJMhPAPJMA:<7\83RMJM:�AI8!83APEFEF6GJ>jk:~7@=NLZ6GEc:HI=>_KRM:P7N8cwM6 ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6Cn �R>6kSU?c:�8G=@Ec83AKSU?c:<J>jk:2J>ACJlf6u:bt{:b?B?BA�8G:PSBRM:P7@6C¦7N6S^3ª�^�8cw>6l83ACJK?B6GJMhPAPJMA ` :PEB=\:<L>=N7N=m7@=NLZ6GEF6lJ>ACJ��U?BEc:PH>RM83ACJ>AC��;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=mHI6!797N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NA0JM:b?FR>Ec:<7N6Pn��W6P]:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM] � ��deACEBOi:<7N=NjGj!:¹�c�.f6�;MEB=NOQAC��7N:U^3ª�^ ����SU?c:l;Z6GED�!n3nGnGf6�;>EF=NO&AK� �{]{6QS[6�� � �deAPEFOi:<7N=@j!j!:¢�1�f6iOi:<hChP=NAPEF6&H>=9|P�M]���: ��S[?F:0;Z6GE��c��f6iOi:<hChP=NAPEF6iHI=�n!nGnB�M] ��� &;Z6GE��Gn3n!nGf6iOi:PhPhP=NAPEF6QHI=9|C�06 ��� �;Z6GE�GnGnGnGf6&Oi:PhPhP=NAPEF6QHI=2nGn!nB�M]£ACSFSB=N:�6!SB;>EF6!SFS[=NAPJM=(H>6G7m7N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NA�JM:b?FR>EF:P7@6i8GAPJK?B6!J>6GJK?B=V;TAKSU?F= ` R>A<?F=���HIA ` 6 ` =SBAPJ>A,=^;>R>JK?F=@J>=��­]$H>63?[?F6�deRMJ>jG=NAPJ>=^;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=£;ZAP=\8cwu®6sH>= ` 6GJ>hCAPJ>A,;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>=v�e6&_CRM=@JMH>=(SBRMSF836G?[?B=NL>=N7@=HI=v6!SFS[6!EB6 ` 6GEF6lA.d�:<7\S[6¾�sSBAP7NA�_KRM:<JTHIA.=v;TAKSU?F= ` R>AP?B=uS[ACJ>A.EF=@6!OQ;>=r?F=v8GAPJ¢JMAPOQ=vH>=v=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>=Yn f¡ _KR>=NJMHI=HI6!7~?BRI?B?BAq6 ` =\HI6!JC?F6.8cw>6.:�J>AP=�=@JK?B6!EB6kSBSF:<JMA�=NJ O&AIHIAq;T:<EB?B=\83AP7\:<EF6�7@6]^3ª�^Q8cw>=@RTS[6q��8cwM60deAPEFOQ:P7@=NjGjk:<J>A�7N6;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=mHI6!7V7N=@J>hCRM:<hChP=NA�JT:b?BRMEF:P7@6¾��6iJ>APJq7N6�^3ª�^�:P;T6!E[?F6.��8cw>6,S[?F:PJ>J>AD;Z6GE�deRMJ>jG=NAPJ>=9;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=HI6!7~7@=NJ>hPRT:<hPhC=@A�JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N6k�3n � RI?[?c: ` =N:M]9H>:<?F:�7N:�HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>60=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` :qHI=�^3ª�^3]9;Z6GEiAP?[?B6!J>6GEF6/^3ª�^&8cw>=NRMSB683ACJD_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB={L>=\SBAPhPJT:y;T:PSFSB:PEB6�:b?B?BEc: ` 6!EFSBA�^3ª�^~:<;Z6GEB?B6Cn9½(6GE2:PEBEF= ` :PEB6�:<7N7N6u^3ª�^u8cw>=NRMSB6�� � ��� ] ��� ���£]

� � ��� �Z]���� � � �Z] � � � ���� �] � ������ ��]��� � � � �qS[=~HI6 ` 6l=NJ>=NjG=\:<EF6�8GAPJ¢7N6h^3ª�^&:b?FAPOQ=N8cwM6�:<;Z6GEB?B6 ���£]��� �Z]���� l6s_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:PEB6�7N6 ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N=Yn798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GCFEGCiB'I ��L�@Xx¢@A��=�?;=�@$<D8��;�D#^3ª�^�«cnX#2!$�"!�«1��!X\m#%!�r���!$�/345�ª1#W,B§l§�3@«%�T!Z§U�b§�,05�§CªW5+3i#�~K�k�1�05�§,«1n&#!$�"! «1��!A\s#%!�r���!o�¹§"3@«W�T!�§l�k«c«c�",0,-#%!�Yk§�3 5�ªc#%,B§���5jV%�M§�34�15�§��05S�b§�,05�§Pª%5+3i#K�kf��k�1�05�§�3i#U^3ª�^�«1n�5+���%#0fh�%��!o�l�;#W\�\s#;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=u~K��6!JWR>JM83=\:b?F= ��t���b8��Jx�=�@+�qC+EqC+E �WACJ>AQ6!SB6GOQ;>=£H>=$;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=m�eAC7r?FEB6s:y?BR>?[?B6�7@6u^3ª�^uHI6G7Vz1�In �P�3¦ � �Z©�� � b© � � �Z©��� ���£©� � � � � ©���� ��� � © ��� ��� � � �*�� � �Z�3©�� � >� ��� � ���,� � � 3�­©����^� ���0� ���Z�3© ����� {� � �&� � �m�� ��Z�­©� �^� ����� ��{� ��i� ���I�B�9� ���$� ��� ©�� �^� ��� � � ��� � ���D� �� ��>�[� `�� ©���� � ��� ���g� �� ��� ��� >� `c` ©��� � ���Z� ��� �_� ��� �K�3n

� @5&>�4� �� & @$�J�7H0&>DM� & �5D ���$D #B� ���5��E ���F#B� !5� HI@$� � ���F�B�7!5& �J�5#FL>#F���5& #F�5!5@$���4# H�� !5&>�F�F& ������7KI@5���5!5� � # #F� �4D � !5@5C>& @5�K @J��� �4# �JCO�N�4��D &AC>��� @5�5�AH���D #B���$#F�F&,CO��E,& #F�5!$#FCO& �5��� &<D4#FC/.5#F&>�4�4� C/.5&<�B� H���D #B���5#F�F&,K @J���0� # �JCO�N� � �J?�@$D #:�F#���&>DM�A�$&O��CO��E,���! � ��L>#F���5& !5&>��K @J���0� # �5C �N�4��D &�� #F� � ����CO��� �"�4#2!5#FC>& C/.5& �B�(KI@J���0�4# �JCO��LO#F���$& & HI@5��� ��G-

Page 124: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��"�798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GCFEGC� �y§"\º§h�T!�§ ^3ª�^ 2f9«1��!�+� � � � �¢5+!A\s#%!$�"5�§�./�]3N§u^3ª�^s«cnX#2�05���\�\�5�#%!$#j�P§S �%�k�0\�5+\��X#%!$�;��cr"!A5[�!«c«1��,0,-#%!�Yk§]345�ª1#W,B§9��#%3+3@§��b§�,05�§Pª%5+3i#�� «c�"!�3@§�«1�k�0\º§"!X\m# �qt2� � � � �9Q#j�;#W\�\s���c*X#W,F§�\m��,-#U��5�%���1\�5+\��;YW5��"!$#�t���b8��Jx�=�@+�qC+EqCF� ��� � � � � ��� � �T© ��� � � � � �{� � �b© ��� � � ���� ��� ©���� � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � �Z� � � ���Z© ��� ��� � � � �Z� ��� ��� ����y� ��� &� �� � � � � � �Z� � �� � � Q� �� � ���y� ��� &� �� � � � ��T� ���y� ��� ~� �� � � � �����_� � � � � � � ��� � � �����_� � � Z© ��� ���y�_� ��� � � ��Z� � � ���&��� ��� bn

�W=£?B6GJMhC:Q;>EF6!SB6GJK?B6y8cw>6�7YX AP;Z6GEc:b?FAPEF6sHI= SBACS[?B=@?BRMjG=NAPJ>6�7\:PSF83=\:/ =NJM:<7@?B6!EF:<?F:QSB6sJ>APJ ` =^S[ACJ>AiAI8G83ACEBEF6GJMjG67N=@LZ6GEF6�H>6G7N7N: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N6l8cw>60S[=uHI6 ` 6�SBACS[?B=@?BRM=@EF6Pn �R>=NJMHI=�]VS[69�f6lR>JM:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6P](;Z6GEQAPhCJ>=��g6l;Z6GEAPhCJ>= �Z]� � � � � �9���nQ5�6G7m8!:PSBA�=NJ�8GR>=�»wM:�AI8G83ACEBEF6GJMjG6&7@=NLT6!EB6iHI=*RMJM:0S[AC7N: ` :<EF=N:PL>=@7N6����2=NJ�?F:<7m8!:PSBASF83EF= ` 6GEF6GOQAsS[;Z6!SFSBAj�� �Z���F]ISBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIA���8GAPJ,R>JT:�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6 �T]W7\:e^3ª�^[+� � � � �A�*8cw>6=@JMH>=N8cw>6!EB6!OQAySB;T6kSBSBA:<JT8cw>62����I�¢�VEF=\S[R>7@?F:&R>JT:y;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6Q��SB6GJMj!:&;>=[fR0:P7N8GR>JM: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6�7N=@LZ6GEc:C�3n����8���x>=�@ �GCFEGCiB

�W6�y� �Z�9� ��� :P7@7NAPEc: ����I�m� � � ���6����3�m� � G��W6�y� �Z�9� ��� � :P7@7NAPEc: ���3�m� � s�e6�y���G�9� � � �G��W6�y� �Z�9� ������ :P7@7NAPEc: ���3�m� ���� �W6�y� >�m� ��� ��� ���� ��� � �� :P7@7NAPEc: ����I�m� ��� ��� ���9� ��� � � ��W6�y� >�m� �����y� � ��� :P7@7NAPEc: ���3�m� � ���y� ��� � � �W6�y� �W�m� � �{� ������ ��� >� :P7@7NAPEc: ����I�m� ��� ��{� ��� �&� � � >��W6�y� �Z�9� ���y��� {� � �&� ��� ���Z�V��� ��� ���&� ���Z�3]:P7@7NAPEc: ����I�m� � ��� ��{� � � y� ��� �����9��� ��� ���&� � �W�3n� ��� �¢³�¶^4�· ³s#&%(1G±~³ +D4�´!´3³ ´G)� y1G±~³¸+D4�1��0'*42+.13±~³�%*1� ���� ��-�/ � � ������/ # +�,���-�,�I8GAP;ZA�HI=I_KR>6!S[?BA2;T:<Ec:<hPEc:bdeA�f69_CRM6G7N7@A�H>=K6kSB:POQ=@JM:PEB6m8GAPOQ69SB=C:CSBSB6GhCJM:<JMA~= ` :<7NAPEF=CH>= ` 6GEF=r?bf:2:<7N7@6V;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=HI6!7v7N=NJ>hPRM:PhPhC=@A(�X@nq526!7@7\:.7NAPhC=N8!:D;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6i=N7u8GAPJM8G63?B?BA.deACJMH>:PO&6!JK?F:<7N6.f6�_KR>6G7N7@A�HI= ` :<7NRI?F:PjG=NAPJ>6C¦OQ6!HI=\:<JK?F6�R>JT: ` :<7NRI?c:<jG=NAPJM6�SB=~:PSFS[6!hPJM:DRMJ ` :<7NAPEF6�H>= ` 6GEF=r?bf:�:P7@7N6�7N63?B?B6!EB6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=96C]mR>JM: ` AC7r?c::b?B?BEF=@LMR>=r?FA�R>J ` :<7NAPEF6~HI= ` 6!EB=@?¾f:�:P7@7N6u7@6G?[?F6GEF6P] ` =N6GJM62:b?[?FEB=NL>R>=@?BA�RMJ ` :P7@ACEB62HI= ` 6GEF=@?¾f:�:�?BRI?B?B627N6~de;,8GAPOQ;TAKSU?F6:b?B?BEc: ` 6!EFSBA�=Z83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =�n(526G7N7\:�7@AChP=\8G:�HI6!=>;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=>=N7THI=\SF83APEcSBAyf6u;>=[fR,83ACOQ;>7@6kSBSBA�62;>R fA�6kSBSB6GEF6~:<EB?B=\83AC7N:<?BA=NJqO&AIHI=9HI=rt�6GEF6GJK?F=Yn.�9=VSBA<t�6GEFO&6!EB6!OQA0SBRqHI=VRMJq;>EBAI8G6!HI=NOQ6GJK?BAD8cw>6,8GAPJMSB6GJK?B6,H>=9:b?B?BEF=@LMR>=@EF6iR>J ` :<7NAPEF6HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:ySBAP7NA&:P7@7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=*�eACSFSB=N:&:<7N7N:�^3ª�^98cw>=NRMSB6k�3]M8cw>6�;>EB=NOi:&=@7N7@RTSU?FEB=\:<OQAy?BEc:<OQ=r?F6�:<7\83R>J>={6kS[6!OQ;>=YnopJ>=NjG=\:<OQA�8GAPJMSB=\HI6GEc:<JMH>A,;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>= :<?BAPOQ=\8cw>6�8cw>=NRMSB6y_KRM:P7@=*½*:>] �L$] �2:PL$] �~LZ8P]G�I:<L�8<]{6k8G8<ns�9APOQ6lf6=NJC?FR>=@?B= ` :POQ6GJK?B62A `W` =NAM]b;Z6GEm;ZA<?F6GEVHI=NEF62S[6~R>JT:�HI=M_KR>6!S[?B6~;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>={f6 ` 6GEc:�Ad�:P7NSF:>]CAI8G83ACEBEF6uS[;Z6!8G=raT8!:<EF6:�8GACSF:sSB=ZEF=@de6GEF=NSF83ACJ>A�7@6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B=T=@JTHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=�6�;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` 6�8cw>6AW8!83ACEBEFAPJ>A�=NJl6kSBSF:>nm�9ACSpf ��]CSB6:ySU?c:s;Z6GEu=@7JWR>OQ6GEFAj��6�½¹S[=NhPJ>=@aT8!:D�[6kSBSB6GEF6u;M:<EF=N�M]C:P7@7NAPEc:�½*:�EB=\SBR>7r?c: ` 6!EF:i��;TAC=N8cwu®6e�Qf62;T:<EF=\�3]POQ6GJK?BEF6P]WSB6�:sS[?F:s;Z6GE9=@7JWR>OQ6GEFAu�26v½.S[=NhPJM=raT8!:i�[6kSBSB6GEF6mHI=\S[;T:<EF=N�M]k:P7@7NAPEc:~½*:uEB=\SBR>7r?c:ud�:<7\SF:s�e;ZAP=\8cwu®6���J>APJif69HI=NSB;M:PEB=��­©<SB6V:�S[?F:2;T6!E>�I]LyS[?F:�;T6!E Á 6 �¹S[=NhPJ>=@aT8!:,�[6kSBSB6GEF6*OQ=@JMAPEF6!�>] �2:PL,f6 ` 6GEc:s��;TAC=N8cwu®6¢��f69OQ=@J>ACEB6vHI= Á �­]bOQ6!JC?FEB6C]<S[6vS[=KOi:<JK?B=N6GJM67NAsSU?F6!SFS[A�SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:b?FA�;T6!EV:�6~L$]P6 � SB=@hCJ>=@aT8G:��[6kSBSB6GEF6uHI= ` =\S[ACEB6k�>] �2:PL�f6vd�:<7\SB:i��;TAC=N8cwu®6 �J>ACJ�f6~HI= ` =\S[ACEB6~HI=Á �3n��W=£?BEc:b?B?F:i:<7N7NAPEc:&H>=£hP6!J>6GEc:<7N=NjGj!:PEB66s;>EF6!8G=NSF:<EF6�_CRM6!S[?BAiHI=\SB8GAPEcS[ATnmopJD;>EF=@OQAi7NR>APhCA&AI8!83APEFEF6aZSBSF:<EF6�R>JHIACO&=NJ>=NA��.]IACSFS[=\:sR>J0_KRM:<7\SB=N:CS[=Z=@JTS[=N6GOQ6�J>APJ ` R>A<?FA ` ��EF6G7\:b?F= ` :<OQ6!JC?F6�:P7{_CRT:<7N67N6�J>ACS[?BEF6�deACEBOyR>7N68cw>=NRMSB6:PSFSBR>OQAPJ>A.RMJ¹S[=NhPJM=raT8!:b?FA¹�e=NJK?BR>=@?B= ` :<OQ6GJK?B6C¦,APhCJ>=9deAPEFO�R>7\:.8cw>=NRMSF:�HI= ` =@6!J>6lR>JT:�:bt�6GEFOi:<j!=@ACJ>6,EF6G7\:b?B= ` :

�G� �I#%�5���4#*C/.$& #F� K @5&>�4� �<�$D ������� #FL>#F���5&"!�C>��E,& �5@$D &(#F��KI@$&O�F�B�,�5D4&>CO&>!5&>�0� &"!2�B� ��� &>�4�M�"H���D4#B���5#F�F& � &(#F�5!5#FC>&(!5#%!5@5& KI@5������4# �JCO�N� ��D4#- ; &O�F�B� �5D4������� #FL>#F���5&<�5D &>C>&>!5&>� �4&�#�!5@5&<K @J��� �4# �JCO�N�4��D # CO��� ��� &>�4� � #F�5!5#FC>& .J���5�5� CO��E,�5#:! � ��L>#F���5& !5# ��&OD4&>� �4# �� � ) ��� � � � � � ��� &��� � �/!9#F� KI@$&O���M� #F��CO��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5&A!5&>� �$D #FE,� K @J��� �4# �JCO�N�4��D & & � � ��) ��� ��� � % ��� � � � & HI#F�5C>���B� ��� � C>C>��D D &>�5LO� �F#���&OD ��!5# � #F� � � � �!9E,&O�0�4D &<KI@5&>�F�F� !5&>� � &>C>���5!5�� &�� � % ��� � � - � �$@5���J� �$��D E ��&GH$# � ��D &<#� E,&>� C>���B��E,&>� �4# �.!$#�H���D4#B���5#F�F##!5���4� #B� 1��D C>��E,�J��D #FD4& �B�.��� &>�4�M� H���D #B���5#F�F& �4#B� �F#���&>DM�(C/.5& H$#F�$CO���B�N� �"�5&>�F�B� ��� &>�4�M�������M-

�G� �I#���� �4&OD�H$#9C/.5&<#F�:�5D #FE,�AKI@J���0�4# �JCO�N� ��D4& &,H$@$��� � #F�7K @J���0� � �5&>��� @5� CO��E,��� ! � ��L>#F���5&<�5��� HI# &A���FC>@5�5� � C>C>��D D &>�5LO��F#���&>DM�,!5# � - � ���*�$@5� �4�A!$#3HI#F�4� � #F� �4@5# �4# H0�A�F&.K @J���0� # �5C ��L>#F���5#�H$@$��� &,�4���5� !$&O�3�4@$�4�4�A#F� @$�4#F�F##!2C>��E,&(�5@5D4&.� ���$�A&GH$# � ���5#F�F#3#� E,&>� C>���B��E,&>� �4# �<!5#�H���D #B���5#F�F#3C>@5#�� # &,��C>C>&O�$�J�N� � �$&O�F�B� �5��� � �5D4&>CO&>!5&>�0� &�-�� � ��� �4DM� �J��D�� & �$#F� ��?��J� � &>�5&>D �$&"C>��� �4����&>D C/.�&C>���5� &>�0� # �4&(!J���F�B� �5����� D �.!5& �J�5#FL>#F���5& #F�5!$@$�4�4# H��"!$# �����M-

� � #5�4���5� � &G��� ��D4#J!5&>�F�B� �F��?�#FCO� #F�.C>@5#$� #J��E,E,&G��� &:C0.5& ��� #F�5� #F&>E,&��1�����4�M� ���5C0.5& &O�4� &>D &:HI@5���4�5- �I#$�4DM�N���M� !5&>�F�F&�C>��� #F!5!$&>���4&�F��?�#FC/.5& #F�$CO�F@$� # H0&�- 5%��D �5&>D &>E,� �5# @��>H����0� #%�4@ K @5&>�4�4� ��� ��&G�4�4�5-

Page 125: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��;�:<hC7@=96G7N6GOQ6GJK?F=vHI= �l�3n���JM: ` AP7@?F:0aTSFSF:b?BA�=@7uHIAPOQ=NJ>=NAM](AI8G83ACEBEF6q�[=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<EF6!�07N6�8GACS[?F:<JK?F=V=NJMHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=6�;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?F= ` 6P]2AKSBSB=N:¹:PSFS[AI83=\:<EF6D7NAPEFA¢R>J SB=NhPJ>=@aT8G:<?BA¢EF6G7\:b?F= ` :PO&6!JK?B6�: �Dn �9APJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&A :<7N7@ACEF:�R>JT:deR>J>j!=@ACJ>6,oQ��HI6G?[?c:D=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6¾��8cw>6iwM:D83ACOQ6,HIAPOQ=NJ>=@AD7N6l8GACS[?F:<JK?F=m=@JTHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=m6l;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` 6Q6,=@783RM=V83AIHIACO&=NJ>=NA ` :0AP;>;ZAPEB?BR>JT:<OQ6GJK?B6iSB;T6k83=@aT8G:<?BAD:DSB6!83ACJMH>:0HI=V_KRM:P7@6Q?F=@;ZA.HI=v83ACS[?F:PJK?B6iS[=m?BEc:b?[?c:>n,½(6!E_KRM:<JK?FA�EF=@hCRM:<EcH>:�7N6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=Z=@JMH>= ` =\HIRM:<7N=�]>83APOQ6�f6=NJK?BR>=@?B= ` :<OQ6GJK?F6A `W` =@AT]K:CSBSBAI83=\:<OQA�:&83=\:PSF83R>JT:�HI={6kSBSB6R>J06G7N6GOQ6!JC?FAiHI= �D¦

½(6GEuAChPJ>=$8GACS[?F:<JK?F6�=NJMHI= ` =NH>RM:<7N6 �T] �T���W� � �

�W6C]�:CHD6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM] ��� ���I�B|M� À � Á �!}��>�G}!|>�C]I:<7N7NAPEc:i;TAP?BEbf:,6kSBSB6GEF6 �Z���I�2��|M] �Z��G�2�»}��>] �Z���!�2� �>] n!nGnGnopJlRMJ$X :P7r?FEF:y=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �MXI;ZA<?FE¾f:�6!SFS[6!EB6 � � ���I�V� À ] �Z��3�m� }!|M] � � ���G�m� À ]�nGn!n[¡ ` =\HI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6C]>H>:b?FA8cw>6 ` =~SBAPJ>A�=@JIaTJ>=r?F6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F=9=NJMHI= ` =NH>RM:<7N=Y]9:<L>L>=\:<OQA�=@JIaTJ>=r?F=uO&AIHI=~HI= ` 6!EFSB=V;Z6GEQ=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<EF7@6 ` �¾nJ�2JT:` AC7r?c:saZSBSF:b?c:�R>JT:�=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6 �T]>:PH�APhCJ>={83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�=@JMH>= ` =\HIRM:<7N6�HI6G7$7N=NJ>hPRM:PhPhC=@A,f6�:CSBSBAI83=\:b?BAyR>J0LT6!J;>EF6!8G=NSBAy6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BA,HI= �Dn½(6GEu_KRM:<JK?FAyEF=@hCRM:<EcH>:�7N6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B=�;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` 6C]CAI8G8GAPEFEB6�HI=\SU?F=@J>hCR>6GEF6�:ySB6!8GAPJMH>:&HI6!7{JKRMO&6!EBA&HI=$:<EFhPA��OQ6GJK?B=^HI6G7N7\:,83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�S[?B6kSBSF:>n �W6s7\:,8GACS[?F:<JK?F6�;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` :0f6y:PH0R>J.:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?BAT]M:PH06kSBSF:iSB= :PSFSBAW8G=N:&R>JT:;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:l=@J �Dni�9ACSpf �Y]{SB6 �D]£83ACOQ6yJ>6!7@7�X 6!SB6GOQ;>=NA�;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6P]*f6yR>J�=NJMS[=N6GOQ6iHI=*JWR>OQ6GEF=(JM:b?FR>Ec:<7N=Y]$:P7@7\:83AKSU?c:<JK?B6 � :PH&R>J,:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?BA�SB=>;>R fAs:CSBSBAI83=\:<EF697\:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:��[6kSBSB6GEF6v;M:<EF=N�M]<AD�[6kSBSB6GEF6u;>EF=@OQAC�M]<AD�[6kSBSB6GEF6O�RM7r?F=@;>7NAsHI=Z|P�>]P6!8G8Pn@]COQ6GJK?BEF6P]KS[6 � f6uR>Ji=NJMSB=@6!O&62H>=M;Z6GEcS[ACJ>6P]P:� SB=>;>R fAs:CSBSBAI83=\:<EF697\:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:��[6kSBSB6GEF6=@?F:<7N=\:<J>AK�>]WA��[6!SFSB6GEF6L>=NAPJTHIAC�M]IA��F: ` 6!EB6R>J0;T6kS[AiSBR>;T6!EB=NAPEF6�: À � ��hC�>]W6k8G8<n(op7£8GAPJM8G63?B?BAiHI=$;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:�=NJR>J�=@JTS[=N6GOQ6i;>R fA�6!SFSB6GEF6yOQ6GhC7@=NADS[;Z6!8G=raZ8G:b?FA�:CHIA<?B?F:PJMHIAM] 83APOQ6�f6Q83APJTS[R>6G?BA0=NJ�7NAPhC=N8!:>]{=N7*;>R>JK?BADHI= ` =\SU?c:6!S[?B6!JMSB=@ACJM:<7N6�=NJ�LT:PSB6�:P7�_KRM:P7@6�R>JM:y;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:�=@J � S[=�=\HI6GJK?B=@aT8!:y8GAPJ�7YX =@JTS[=N6GOQ6�HI6GhC7@=�6G7N6GOQ6!JC?F=$HI= � 8cwM67\:&SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PJ>AMn�9ACSpf ��]I:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]>SB6 � ���k�>�B|>� À � Á �G}k�I�!}!|I�K]<:<7N7@ACEF:y=NJ �.¦� ¡VSFS[6!EB6�;M:<EF=£�»���I� À �G}k�W�� 6!SFS[6!EB6�;>EF=@OQAl� ���I�B|M� Á �G}!|>�� 6!SFS[6!EB6�O�R>7@?B=N;>7NA,HI=£|,� �¾|>� À �G}k�W�Knf¡ 8cw>=\:<EFAi:<7N7@ACEF:i8cwM6sAPhCJ>=£;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:Q6!SB;>EB6kSBSF:Q7N=@J>hCR>=\SU?F=N8!:<OQ6GJK?B6 ` =N6GJM6s=NH>6GJK?B=@aT8G:<?F:,8GAPJDR>J�S[AP?[?BAC=@J&�SB=@6!O&6DHI= �Dnz�W=�:PSFSBR>OQ608cwM6 ` :P7@hK:�:PJM8cw>60=@7 ` =\836 ` 6!EFSF:>]*AKSBSB=N:�8cw>60AChPJ>=~SBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6DHI= ��SB=N:�R>JT:;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:,=@J �Dny�9ACSpf � :PJM8cw>6l�k�I� Á �!}��W�K]{� À � Á �G}!|>�C]£�k�I�!}��I�C]$�K}��I�yS[ACJ>A,;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:,=NJ �¥�Y:<JM8cw>6QSB6s?F:P7@=SBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&=WJ>ACJySBAPJ>A�SU?c:b?F=KAP?[?F6GJWRI?B=>8GAPOQ6v=K;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B=WOQ6!HI=\:<JK?F69R>JT:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:2RMSBRM:<7N6P]<_KRM:P7@6&�[6kSBSB6GEF6;M:PEB=\�>](�[6kSBSB6GEF6�HI=NSB;M:PEB=\�>]I6k8G8<n �­n[�I=£:PSFS[RMO&6�;Z6GEB?F:<JK?FAQ8cwM6P¦

½mEFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:y=@J � � �WAP?[?FAP=NJMS[=N6GOQ6sHI= �

½(6GEB?F:PJK?BA�7�X =NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM62HI=�R>JM:�8GACS[?F:PJC?F62;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` :���:PHiRMJ,;TAKSU?FAySF:<Ebf:�R>JlSBA<?B?BAC=@JMSB=N6GOQ6 ` � HI=�D¦

�T� �s� � �

�R>6kSU?FA.HI=NSF83ACEFSBA.SB=9;>R^fA�APEc:�d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6�hP6!J>6GEc:<7N=@j!j!:PEB6Cn_�W6 ��f6,R>JM:�83ACS[?F:PJK?B6,;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?B= ` :.:.HIRM6:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?B=�]M:PH�6kSBSF:Q7YX =NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �,d�:<Ebf:i83ACEBEF=NSB;ZAPJMHI6!EB6�R>JM:,EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6�L>=NJM:<EF=\:&deEF:i6!7@6!OQ6GJK?B=^HI= �Dn��/ �'#FE,����D��M���0�4&"� ����� ���F#F�$& ��D4&,C/.5&,�<C>���4� ��� �4#:!5#F��� #F�0� &.�5@� �A&>�4� &>D &,���4� � C>#B�N� � �F�A�4�4&>� �4�A&>�F&>E,&O�0�4� !5# � - �1��� �4D &G���M���0� �

#FE,����D4� ��� �4& � &>�5&>D �5D4&>� &>� �4&(C/.5&.@$�J�,#F� �4&>D �5D4&>� ��L>#F���5& & @5�5� 1 @5�5L>#F���5&(K @J���F� #B���4#%!5#%C>�I!5��E,#F�$#F� � &-!�K @5#F�5!5##!��5��� & !5&G��� �C/.5&"�4@$��� #9?��F#*&>�F&>E,&>� �4#9!5# � �4#B���5�A�$D &>� #*#F� C>���5�4#F!5&>DM��L>#F���5&,!J���F��� #F�0� &>D4�5D &G� ��LO#F���$&0- �=! &>�4&OE,�$#F� !������ D4&>E,E,�A���4� � CO#B��D4&,��4@$�4�4& �F& C>���4� ��� �4#%#F�5!5# HI#F!5@J���F#���� &O�F&>E,&>�0� � �.!5# �2!$���5�5@5D4& ��� �4�IC>#B��D & �4���F�"?��F#2&>�F&>E,&>� �4#� &�� � &>�5LO�.@$�4#F�F#FL>LO��D & ?��F#���� �4D #-

�����I&,� &"�4���4�4��#F�5� #F&>E,& !5#�)8� #�� C>D # H0&"!�C>��E,& &"�5���4� !3��� ).- � � #F�5�4#F&>E,& !5&>#�� ����� ��#F�$� #F&>E,#*!$#*@5� #F�5�4#F&OE,& � &.!5&G��� �#F�5�4#F&OE,& �����4&>�5LO�<!$#%� !J& �4#�#F�5!5#FCO��� � � M- �I&>C>���5!5� #F���5@5�0�4�,!5#�H$#F���M�"&>��� &>�5�4#F���J���F&"!�!J�N� � @5�A#F�5� #F&>E,& � !J��� #F�5� #F&>E,&�� �� & ��� #F�5�4#F&OE,&=!5&>�F�F& �5D4���5D #F&G�� �.#F��� - @$#F�5!5##!5��� #F�0�4&OD4�5D &G� ��L>#F���5&(��� � � C>#B�"�.C>#B��� C>@5�5�"CO�����M���0�4&(�$D &>!5#FCO�N� # H��,��!A@5�A��D ?���E,&>�0� �@5� � ����� ��#F�5�4#F&>E,& !5# �2!$��� � #B�(@5�A&>�F&>E,&>� �4�"!5#� � � M-

Page 126: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� Àx�Hg6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]9SB6 � f6�R>Jg=@JMSB=N6GOQ6.HI=~JWR>OQ6GEF=~JM:b?FR>Ec:<7N=Y] �T� ���y;>R^fA�6kSBSB6GEF6g�[6!SFSB6GEF6�OQ=NJ>APEF6�H>=snGn3nF�>]9A�[6kSBSB6GEF6,Oi:<hChP=NAPEF6lHI=�nGn!n[�>]VA �[6kSBSB6GEF6,OyR>7r?F=@;M7@A�HI=�n3n!nB�>]VA �[6kSBSB6GEF6,;>EF=NO&A�83ACJ nGn!nB�M]*6!8G8Pn@]VO&6!JK?BEF6�SB6�¥f6yR>J�=NJMS[=N6GOQ6iHI=*;Z6GEcS[ACJ>6P]$:CH ��SB=*;>R fA0:PSFS[AI8G=N:PEB6y7N:�EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6��[6kSBSB6GEF6�;>=[fR�:<7@?BA0HI=~nGn3nF�>]$Ag�[6kSBSB6GEF6;M:PEB6!JC?F6�HI=un3n!nB�>]�A¢�B6!SFS[6!EB6y83AW63?c:<J>6!AlHI=vnGnGnF�>]Z6!8!8<n��9ACOQ6y:<LML>=N:POQA,=NH>6GJK?B=@aT8G:<?BA�R>JM:,;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:i83ACJ.=@7SBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6deAPEFOi:b?FAyH>:PhP7N=Z6!7@6!OQ6GJK?B={8cw>6�7N:&SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:<JMAM]I83AKSºf �Z;ZACSFS[=\:<OQA�=\HI6!JC?F=raZ8G:<EF6�7\:yEB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6=@J �83ACJ�7�X =@JMSB=N6GOQ6sHI6G7N7N6s83AP;M;>=@6�HI=£6G7N6GOQ6GJK?B= HI= � 8cw>6�7N:iSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PJ>AMn�9ACSpf ��]IS[6 ��� ���I�B|M� À � Á �!}��>�G}!|>�C]<:P7@7NAPEc:�=NJ �D¦

� ¡VSFS[6!EB6iOQ=NJ>APEF6����K���I] |C�­]u���>] À �­]2���I] Á �­]~���I]N}��P�3]v���I]N}!|K�­]~��|M] À �­]~��|M] Á �­]\��|>]N}��C�­]\��|M]@}k|C�­]u� À ] Á �­]~� À ]@}k�P�3]� À ]N}!|K�­]{� Á ]@}k�P�3]$� Á ]N}!|K�­]$�[}��I]N}!|K�c�� ¡VSFS[6!EB6uOi:<hChP=NAPEF6~���K�Y|>] �P�­]Z� À ] �C�­]�� Á ] �P�3]T�[}��I] �P�3]T�[}!|>] �P�3]M� À ] |K�­]�� Á ] |K�­]T�[}��>] |K�­]T�[}!|M] |K�­]M� Á ] À �­]��U}k�I] À �3]�U}!|M] À �­]{�U}k�I] Á �3]$�U}!|M] Á �­]$�[}!|>]N}��C�c�� ¡VSFS[6!EB6�O�R>7@?B=N;>7NAQ;>EBAC;>EF=@A,�»�W� À ] �C�­]\� À ] |C�3]N�[}��>] �C�­]\�U}��>] |K�­]\�U}k�I] À �c�� ¡VSFS[6!EB6u;>EF=@OQA�8GAPJ�� �K���I] |C�3]Z�Y|>] �P�­]����>] Á �­]Z� Á ] �P�3]Z���I]N}!|K�­]��U}!|M] �C�­]Z��|>] Á �3]Z� Á ] |C�3]Z�Y|>]N}!|C�3]T�[}!|>] |C�3]T� À ] Á �­]� Á ] À �3]$� À ]@}k|C�­]$�[}!|M] À �­]$� Á ]@}k�P�3]$�U}��>] Á �­]$� Á ]N}!|C�3]{�U}!|M] Á �­]$�[}��I]N}!|K�­]$�[}!|>]N}k�­�¿mX =NJMS[=N6GOQ6DHI=~?FRI?[?F6D7@6D8GAP;>;>=N6DHI=26!7@6!O&6!JK?B=2HI= � ` =N6GJ>6DHI6G?[?BAT]9=NJ ?B6GACEB=\:�HI6GhC7@=~=NJMSB=@6!OQ=Y]v;>EFAWH>A<?[?FA8G:PE[?F6!SB=N:PJ>AM]W6�SB=$=@JTHI=N8!: � � � Ai:<JM8cwM6 � � n526!7@7�X 6!SB6GOQ;>=NA � � 83APEFEF=NSB;TACJMHI6�:<7$SB6GhCR>6GJK?B6�=NJMSB=@6!O&6C¦

�W���>] �C�­]$���>] |K�­]$���I] À �­] ���I] Á �3]$���>]@}k�P�­]$���I]N}!|K�­]$��|M] �C�­]$�Y|>] |C�­] ��|>] À �3]$��|M] Á �­]£�Y|>]N}��P�3]{��|>]N}!|K�­]$� À ] �P�­] � À ] |C�3]$� À ] À �­]� À ] Á �­]$� À ]@}k�P�3]$� À ]N}!|K�­]$� Á ] �P�­] � Á ] |C�3]$� Á ] À �­]$� Á ] Á �­]£� Á ]N}��C�­]$� Á ]@}k|C�3]$�U}��>] �C�­]$�[}��I] |C�3]{�U}��>] À �­]$�[}��I] Á �3]$�U}k�I]N}��P�3]�U}k�I]N}!|K�­]{�U}k|>] �P�­]$�[}!|M] |K�­]$�U}k|>] À �3]$�U}!|M] Á �­]$�[}!|>]N}��C�­]{�U}k|>]N}!|K�c��2JT:�EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6&L>=@JT:<EF=N:�f6i:<7N7@ACEF:�R>JqSBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6iHI= � � n��9ACO&6Q=NJ�;>EB6k836kHI6GJ>jk:�:0;MEBAC;TAKS[=@?BA0HI6G7N7N6;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:M] HI=\83=\:<OQA�8cwM6iR>JM:DEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6iL>=NJM:<EF=N:0=NJ ��f6iR>J _CRT:<7\S[=\:PSB=mS[AP?[?FAP=NJMS[=N6GOQ6lH>= � � ]^AKSBSB=\:0APhPJM==NJMS[=N6GOQ6sHI= 83AP;M;>=@6�ACEFHI=NJM:<?B6�HI={6G7N6GOQ6!JC?F=£HI= � f6�R>JM:QEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6�L>=@JT:<EF=N:M¦

�~6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6�L>=@JT:<EF=N:&=NJ ����SBA<?B?BAC=@JMSB=N6GOQ6�HI= � �

�R>=NJMHI=�]C7�X =@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6~HI=ZR>JM:s8GACS[?F:<JK?F6~;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` :s:�H>R>6�;ZACS[?B= � SB:PE¾f:�R>J�S[AP?[?BAC=@JTS[=N6GOQ62HI= � � ¦�Z� ��� � � �

½(6GE�7@6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=m;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?B= ` 6�:D;>=[fR¹HI=uHIR>6�:PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?F=VS[=v;>EFAI836!H>6,=@J¹O&AIHIA�:<JM:P7@AChPAMn��W6_� f6,R>JT:83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` :�:.?FEB6�:<EFhPACO&6!JK?B=�]m:PH¢6kSBSF:D7�X =NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6,d�:PE¾f:�83APEFEF=NSB;TACJMHI6!EB6,RMJM:�EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6?B6!EBJT:<EF=N:0deEc:�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?B=~HI= �Dn¢xH¢6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]VS[6 �¸f6�R>J¹=NJMSB=@6!OQ6�HI=uJWR>OQ6GEF=�]mo3���>��;>R fA�6!SFSB6GEF6¹�[6kSBSB6GEF683ACOQ;>EB6kS[A¹?BEc: n!nGn[6gnGnGnB�>]A �B6!SFS[6!EB6�7N:gS[ACOQOQ: HI=in3n!n[6�HI=in3nGnF�>]A �B6!SFS[6!EB6.=N7�;>EFAIHIA<?B?BA H>=&n!nGnB6�HI=nGn!nB�M]{6!8G8Pn@]{OQ6!JC?FEB6QSB6��¥f6yRMJ�=NJMS[=N6GOQ6iHI=(;Z6GEcS[ACJ>6yo3���>�;>R fA�6!SFS[6!EB6��[wM:�;Z6GE�hP6!J>=r?FAPEF=unGnGn[6�n!nGn[�M]{A�wT:R>J$X :<7@?B6!jGjk:,=NJC?F6GEFOQ6!HI=\:Q?BEc:.n!nGnB6lnGn!nG]�6!8!8<ns�9APOQ6�=NJ.;>EF6!8G6!HI6!J>j!:M]T=\HI6!JC?F=raZ8cw>=N:POQAl7\:,EF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6�?B6!EBJM:PEB=\:83ACJ�RMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6sHI={?B6!EBJM6�H>=$6G7N6GOQ6GJK?F=£HI= �Dn�9ACSpf ��S[6 � ���k�>�B|>� À � Á �G}k�I�!}!|I�K]<:<7N7@ACEF:y=NJ �.¦� ¡VSFS[6!EB628GAPOQ;>EF6!SBAy� �K��|M] �>] À �­]Z��|>] �I] Á �3]Z�Y|>] �I]N}��C�­]T�Y|>] �I]N}!|K�­]�� À ] �I] Á �3]Z� À ] �I]N}��C�­]T� À ] �I]N}!|K�­]T� À ] |>] Á �3]Tn!nGnG]�U}��>] �>]@}k|C�3]��[}��>] |M]@}k|C�­]{�[}��I] À ]N}!|K�­]{�U}k�I] Á ]N}!|K�c�� ¡VSFS[6!EB6�S[ACOQOQ:i���K� À ] |M] |K�­]\�U}k�I] À ] À �­]\�U}k|>] À ] Á �3]N�[}!|>] Á ] À �­�� ¡VSFS[6!EB6�;>EFAWH>A<?[?FAi���K� À ] �I] |C�3]N� À ] |>] �P�­]\�U}k�I] �I] À �3]N�[}��I] À ] �P�­��W=*=\HI6GJK?F=raT8!:�_KR>=NJMHI=VR>JM:�EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6y?B6!EBJM:PEB=\:ideEc:�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?F=mHI= � 8GAPJ�R>JqS[AP?[?BAC=@JTS[=N6GOQ6QHI= � � ��8G=@AMf67�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6DHI=u?FRI?[?F607@6�?B6!EBJM6�HI=~6!7@6!OQ6GJK?B=~HI= �l�3]V60;Z6GEB?F:<JK?FAM]VSB6 ��f6�R>JgSB=NO�LZAP7NA�HI=~;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?FA�:�?BEF6:<EFhPACOQ6GJK?B=�¦

Page 127: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� Á�Z� �m� � � �

opJ hC6GJ>6!EF:P7@6C]�SB6 ��f6�R>J SB=@OyLTAC7@AgHI=�;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?BAg: � :PEBhCAPOQ6GJK?B=�]�:CH 6!SFSBA¹7�X =NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6Dd�:<Ebf:83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6GEF6�R>JM:QEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6��o�º:PEB=\:ySBR �D] ` :<7N6�:iHI=@EF6�R>JDS[AP?[?FAP=NJMS[=N6GOQ6�HI= � � ¦�Z� � � ¡Y��� � �

opJ H>63aMJ>=@?B= ` :>]mRMJM:�=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6 ��:PSFS[AI8G=N:.:�83=\:PSF83RMJM:.83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�=@JTHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@6�R>J¹6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BA�HI6G7HIACO&=NJ>=NA � 6�:l83=\:PSF83R>JM:i8GACS[?F:PJC?F6s;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B= ` :iR>J.SBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6yHI= �.� � � � � � �%a%abaG� � � �%aba%aT:lS[6k83APJTH>:HI6!7$JWR>OQ6GEFA&HI= :<EFhPAPOQ6!JC?F={HI6G7N7N:i8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�S[?B6kSBSF:>n� ���� �@��� , /��#�� � ����� , � � #%! ,�� , ��,(/ �#�� �0#%��, ��,(/ �#���� � *�,��0#%��� -�+ # ������, !$#��:b?BA&R>J0HIAPOQ=NJ>=NAy6�R>JM:y=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6C]CAKSBSB=N:�7N:&83AC;>;>=\:�� �.� ���­]>SB=�;>R fAQ:PSFS[AI8G=N:PEB62RMJ ` :<7NAPEF6H>= ` 6GEF=r?bf::PH�R>JM:i_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=Z;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�:b?FAPOQ=\8G:Q8cw>=NRMSB:QHI=q� � n�*6!HI=\:<OQAQ;>EF=@Oi:&R>J06!SB6GOQ;>=NAMn���b8��Jx�=�@+�qCF�GC�H'�W=\:<JMA � �¤�k�I�F|>� À � Á �G}k�I�G}k|I�26��Q?c:<7N6�8cwM6 ` �<¦

�T���W�m� |�T��3�m� À�T���G�m��}k|�T� �s�m�¤6!SFSB6GEF6�;T:<EF= � �k�>� À �G}��I��T� �s�m� ���I� Á �G}k�I�G}k|I��T� ���m�6kSBSB6GEF6�HIAP;>;M=@Al���K� À �B|K�­�!�[}��>� À �­��T� �m�m�¤�W���>�c�P�3�!�Y|>� À �­�k�U}!|M�B|K�­�!� Á �!}��P�3�!�[}��I� Á �3�!�U}k|>�!}G|C�­�

¿£:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6 � �Df6�d�:<7\SF:y=NJ�LM:PSB6�:&_KR>6kSU?c:Q=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�=@J0_KRM:<JK?FA �Z���I�3]M83=NAMf6�|>]MJ>APJ�f6�;M:<EF=�]J>ACJ�f6�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FAlHI= �Z� �s�3n2opJ ` 6k836�� �f6 ` 6GEc:y=NJ�_KRM:PJC?FA �T��3�­]�83=NAMf6 À ]£f6�;M:<EF=Y] ACSFSB=N:�f6�6!7@6!O&6!JK?BAlHI= �Z� �s�­n� �if6�d�:<7\SB:,=@J�_CRT:<JK?BA �Z���!�2J>ACJ¢f6y=@J �T� �s�­n � ��6 � �SBAPJMA,d�:<7\SB6�=NJ�_KR>6!S[?F:,=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6s=NJ�_KRM:PJC?FAJu®6 �Z���I����8G=@AMf6|K�­]>Ju®6 �Z��3���Y83=NAMf6 À �vS[?F:y=@J �Z� �s�3]IO&6!JK?BEF6 � �sf6 ` 6!EF:y;TAC=N8cwu®6 �Z���!�­]>83=NAMf6y}k|>]Zf6�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BAiHI=�Z� �s�3n½(ACSFSB=N:PO&As:P7@7NAPEc:sSF83EF= ` 6GEF6P]K=@J�:<JM:P7@AChP=\:s83ACJ,7\:�J>AP?F:PjG=NAPJ>6;T6!Ev7\:s7NAPhC=N8!:s;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6C¦ �Z� � �I�m�zw�]�Z� � 3��� ��] �T� � �G��� w�] �T� � �I��� w�] �T� � 3��� w�] �Z� � �G�� ��nsopJ�6GtZ6G?[?B=�]£_KRM:PJMHIAl7\:�83AP;M;>=N:�� ��� ���EF6GJMHI6 ` 6GEc:,R>JM:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6hs] RMS[=\:<OQA�7N:�J>AP?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 � � �} ��:PJ>jG=\8cwu®6&7\:l;>=[fR�6!SF:b?B?F:�� �.� ��� � �£��­]8cw>6�S[=Z7@6!hPhC6 �,f6OQAWH>6G7N7@A&HI=$�n*¿£:s;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6 � � vEF=NSBR>7@?F:�d�:P7NSF:�=NJl_KRM:<JK?FA �Z���I�m� |sJ>APJ.f62=@7{HIAC;>;>=NAHI= �T��3�Q� À ©m;>=[fR¢deACEBOi:P7@OQ6GJK?F6P](7N:�83AP;M;>=N: � �Z���I�­� �T��3�[��J>ACJ f6,6!7@6!O&6!JK?BA�HI= �Z� ���­n�opJ ` 6!8G6P](7\:�83AC;>;>=\:� �Z��G�­� �Z���I�B�­]�83=NAMf6i� À �B|K�­]$f6�6!7@6!OQ6GJK?BA,HI= �T� ���3]T_KR>=NJMHI= � �.f6 ` 6!EF:&EF=NSB;Z63?[?FAl:<7N7\:yJMACS[?BEc:Q=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6� � � � � �I�­n(¿$62;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>= � � �Z] � b] � � �b] � � �Z] � �b] � � v6 � � �2SBAPJ>A�?FRI?[?F6�d�:P7NSB62EF=NSB;T6G?[?FA�:�o­nT�I:<L$]=NJ ` 6!8G6P]WEB=\SBR>7r?c: ` 6GEc:>]K=@J�_CRT:<JK?BA&7N:y83AC;>;>=\:�� �T���W�3� �Z��3�B�­]>8G=@AMf6y�Y|>� À �­]�f66G7N6GOQ6GJK?BAQHI= �Z� �m�3n9�9ACSpf �MEF=NSBR>7@?F:PJ>A` 6!EB6 � � �l6 � � ��=NJ._CRT:<JK?BAi7N6�83AC;>;>=N6l� �Z���!�­� �����W�B�~6l� �T���G�­� �T���G�[�3]{83=NAMf6i�U}k|>�F|C�u6l�[}!|M�G}!|K�­]MSBAPJMAi6G7N6GOQ6GJK?B=HI= �Z� �V�­nm¿$6�:P7r?FEB6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>={8cw>6�83ACJC?F6GJ>hCAPJ>A �u]>6�8G=@AMf6 � � �Z]�� �T]�� ¾]�� � �b]�� ��6�� � b]>S[ACJ>A�d�:P7NSB6Pn¿mX 6!SB6GOQ;>=NAQwM:&=@7N7NRMSU?FEF:<?BAQ=N7£S[=NhPJM=raT8!:b?FA&HI6!7@7\:QS[6!hPR>6!JK?B6P¦

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C�HR�y§"\s���T!l����.U5+!X5�� � #��T!Z§(5+!X\m#W,�*o,-#W\p§bY%5��"!$# ���0� �_fu�05e�"5�«c#0«1n&# �DEF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEc:7\:��Uf6OQAIHI6!7@7NA&H>6G7N7N:K�V;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�:b?FAPOQ=N8!: � �-` � � a%a%a � ��~m�;����#�5�\m#W,0.U5+!X5>�%��!o�,«1�k�0\p§�!X\�5�5+!$�"5+�b5��"�M§�345 �kf6#�05��G«%,05+�k# � � � � �-` � � a%aba � �$f[�%#/#S�%��3i���%#j3@§ �g�*$3N§�«1���1\�5+\��T5+\º§9�P§br"345 #%3i#W./#%!X\�5¢��5 � §��c�%�k«W5�§"\�5~§�5¢\s#%,0.U5+!X5� ` � � � �ba%a%a!� � � fU���1�15�§¹� �Z� � ` �­� �T� � � �­�ba%abaG� �Z� � � �[�1fS�1\p§�!o#W3+3@§J,-#W3N§bY%5���!o#�§��c�%�k«W5�§"\º§ § �jf&«%5��Q#�§1*�*M§�,0\�5�#W!o#�§�Z� ���

�46 ����E,& �5&>�JCO��� � �5D4������� #FL>#F���J���F&"! @5�J� H����F@$� ��L>#F���5& ���4� &>?��J� @5�J� H����F��D4& !5#JH0&OD4# �� � � �4@$��� &=�F& �F&G��� &>D4& �5D4�������4#FL>#F���J���F##!0C>��� ��5&>�F�B�"�F��?�#FCO�"!5&>#��5D4&O!$#FC �N�4#%@5�J�,#F�0� &>D4�5D &G� ��LO#F���$&.���4� &>?��J�,@5�AH����F��D &(� �4@$�4�4&.�F& C>�����M���0� #3#F�5!$# H$#F!5@5���F#�& �5D &>!5#FCO�N�4# H0&0- �:��E,&��&>D�H����F@$�M��D4&�@5�J� 1 �(CO��E,�������M� !$&O�F�B�=�F��?�#FC �=�5D ������� #FL>#F���J���F& &��4@,C>#F&>� �4&�C>���5��� C>&>D & # H����F��D #$!5#IH0&>D # �� � �N��� D4#��5@5# �4#J���F�F&:�F&G��� &>D &C/.5& �J?�@$DM���5� #F�A&>�4�M� !JC>��� �%�$&O�F�B� �F��?�#FC �"!$&O#2�5D &>!5#FCO�N�4##!���&>D=��� �4&O?��5��D &(@5� H����F��D & !5#2H0&>D # �� �,���F�F& �5D4�������4#FL>#F���5##! & � @"CO#F&>�0� &C>���5��� C>&>D & C>��E,& �4���5�.#F�0�4&OD4�5D &G� �N� & �F& CO�����M���0�4#�#F�5!5# HI#F!5@J���F#�& �5D4&O!$#FC �N�4# H0& � C/.5& H0&>�5?����5�,!$&>���4& CO�����M���0�4#�&��I�4DM���F��?�#FC/.$&�C/.5&� COC>��D4D ���5� #F�"&>� � �$-�;=&>�F��� &>� &>E,�5#F� !�K @5#F�5!$##!0#F�5!5#FC/.5#B��E,� CO��E,& �4���5� #F� �4&>D �5D4&G�M�N�4& ���FC>@5�5& C>���4� ��� �4#�&��I�4DM���F��?�#FC/.$& &�H����F@$�4#B��E,�� ���F�������9C/.5& C>��� �4&>�5?����5� �M���F#�C>���4� ��� �4#-

Page 128: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� �

��� � � � ` � � aba%a � � � �� �Z� � ` �3� �Z� � � �­�%aba%a!� �Z� � � �[� � �Z� � �¡ � ���InN}k�

�2JT: ` AC7r?c:.S[?F:<LM=@7N=r?FA�_KRM:PJMHIA.RMJM:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�:b?BACOQ=N8!:�f6 ` 6GEc:DA.d�:P7NSF:>]mH>APL>L>=\:<OQA.6kSU?F6GJMH>6GEF6l7\:HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6�:<7�8G:PSBAs=NJ�8GR>=�7N:�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6�83ACJC?F=@6!J>68GACS[?F:PJC?F=M7NAPhC=N8cw>6y��83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` =�6�_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?FAPEF=\�3n^¿ :J>AKSU?FEF:,H>63aMJ>=NjG=NAPJM6lf6s;Z6GE�=NJMHIR>j!=@ACJ>6ySBR>7^JKRMO&6!EBAlJ�HI=*83AKSU?c:<JK?B= 7@AChP=\8cw>6s;>EF6!SB6GJK?B= J>6G7N7\:,;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6l��6=N7�8!:PSBA�HI6!7@7N6;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>=�:b?FAPOQ=\8cw>6sf67N:yLM:PSB6H>6G7N7YX =@JTHIR>jG=NAPJM6P¦(=@J�6!SFS[6=@7�JWR>OQ6GEFAyH>6G7N7@6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=Z7@AChP=\8cw>6f6 �0� � �3n�W6�7N:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6� 83ACJC?F6GJ>6!JK?B6 � 83ACS[?F:PJK?B=v7@AChP=\8cw>6.f6�R>JM:�J>6GhK:<jG=NAPJM6P]*R>JM:�83ACJ>hP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>6P]*R>JT:HI=\S[hC=@RMJ>jG=NAPJ>6�AQR>JD83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6�7\:iHI63aMJM=@j!=@ACJ>6�EB=\8G:P7N8!:y_KR>6!7@7\:iHI6G7N7\:y7NAPhC=N8!:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6C¦

�I6� � ���l]M:<7N7@ACEF: ��� � � J>ACJ ��� � � � � �� � �&�¹���In �P��W6� �z� �_�&]M:P7@7NAPEc: ��� � � ��� � �»6 ��� � � ���In |C��W62 �z� �_�&]M:<7N7NAPEc: ��� � � � � � �»A � � � � ���In �K��I6� �z� ���&]T:<7N7@ACEF: ��� � � � �� � �»A ��� � � ���In �P�

��SB=(ACSFS[6!E ` =^8cw>6P]$SB6j f6�RMJM:l;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6C]TAKSBSB=\:,J>ACJ�83ACJK?B=N6GJ>6y7@=NLT6!EF:�:<7\83RMJM: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6C]{:<JM8cw>6U� 6/�SBAPJ>A0;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=(6P] ;T6!E�HI63?F6GEFOQ=@JM:PEB6QSB6 � � � �SB=N:POQA�EF=\83APJTHIA<?B?B=m:0SU?c:<L>=N7N=@EF6iS[6 � � � � 6 � � � �&]ACSFSB=N:&:QHI63?F6GEFO&=NJM:PEB6�SB6 �0f6�OQAIHI6!7@7NAiHI=$;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>={: ` 6!JC?F={R>J�JKRMO&6!EBAiHI= 83ACS[?F:PJK?B={7NAPhP=\8cw>6�OQ=@J>ACEB6�HI=�£�­n

�~6kSU?c:yH>:&6kSB:PO&=NJM:PEB6=@7$8!:PSBA�=NJ08GR>=G f6�R>JM:y;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?c:���R>J>= ` 6GEcSF:<7NO&6!JK?B6�A&6kS[=\S[?B6GJ&�jG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6¾�­n�W=\:0:<7N7@ACEF:9 � � �$�,n��I6]� J>APJq83ACJK?B=N6GJ>6 �¢7N=@LZ6GEc:>] ACSFS[=\:�S[6i7\:D_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:<jG=NAPJM6�f6 ` R>AP?F:>]^:<7N7@ACEF:M]6!SFSB6GJMHIAU RMJM:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6C]C7NAlf6:<JT8cw>6��l©>:<7N7@ACEF:�;ZAPJM=N:PO&AT¦ � � � SB6�6�SBAP7NAySB6 ��� � � �e6�� wM:sR>JT:83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�7NAPhC=N8!:�=NJ0O&6!J>AQEB=\SB;T6G?[?BA,:CH���­n�WR>;M;TACJ>=N:POQA�:<7N7@ACEF:�8cwM6e� 8GAPJK?B6!J>hC:���7@=NLT6!EF:l�e6 �.f627�X R>JM=N8!: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6~7N=@LZ6GEc:sHI=o�,]K=NJl_KRM:<JK?BAT]KSB62=NJ

� 8GAPOQ;M:PEB=\SBSB6�7@=NLZ6GEc:,_KRM:<7\8cw>6�:P7r?FEF: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6sH>= ` 6GEcSB:iH>:��£]�6!SFSB:QEF=\S[R>7@?B6!EB6!L>LZ6s7@=NLZ6GEc:,:<JM8cwM6s=@J��]Z8cwM6_KR>=NJMHI=�J>APJ�SB:PEB6!L>LT6�R>JM:y;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6k�­n��W=Z?B6!J>hC:�;>EB6kS[6!JK?B6�8cw>6C]W=@J�_CRM6!S[?BA�8!:PSBAM]�� f6R>JM:e^3ª�^m:P;T6!E[?c:s6P]_KR>=NJMHI=�] ��� � � JMAPJ�f6HI6GaMJ>=@?BAMnm½(6!E9:PhPhP=NEc:<EF6�_KR>6!S[?BAyACS[?F:P8GAP7NA�:PH>A<?[?F=N:POQA�R>J�;>EFAW8G6!HI=NOQ6GJK?BA&8cw>6�;>EB=NOi:=N7@7NRMS[?BEF=N:PO&Ai8GAPJ0:<7\83R>J>={6kS[6!OQ;>=Yn���b8��Jx�=�@+�qCF�GC+E �W=\: ��� ���M� À � � � � �G}��I�&6�83ACJMS[=\HI6!EB=\:<OQAD7\:.;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6�� � ���£n��W6lEF=N8GAPEcHI=\:<OQAD=@7SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:b?FAD=@JK?FR>=r?F= ` A.HI= �(] ` APhC7@=\:<OQA08cw>6,6!SFSF:�SB=\: ` 6GEc:0S[6l6lS[AC7@ADSB6i?BR>?[?B=9hP7N=V6!7@6!O&6!JK?B=9H>= ��hPAIHIACJ>AHI6!7@7\:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:�SBR,83R>=>=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?F=N:POQA�� �Y:PH&6!SB6GOQ;>=NAD�[6kSBSB6GEF6uO&=NJ>ACEB62HI=o� � �>]<AC;>;>R>EF6i�[6kSBSB6GEF69Oi:PhPhP=NAPEF6HI=v|P�>]^AP;M;>R>EF6q�[6!SFSB6GEF6&;MEB=NOQA.83APJ¢|��<�K�­nlopJ¢:P7r?FEB6i;T:<EFAP7N6P](S[= ` R>AC7@6�8cw>6�� � ���¹S[=\: ` 6!EF:0=NJ � �y] o[�sSB6i6SBAP7NA�SB6 �Z� �s�,���b�T� À � � � � �!}��W�D� �Dn op7~;>EBACL>7N6GOi:�8cwM6�HIACL>L>=\:<OQA�EB=\S[AC7 ` 6GEF6.f60_KR>6G7N7@A�HI=~EF=N8GAPJMH>R>EBEF67�X 6kSBSB6GEF6�oO&AIHI6!7@7NA0HI= � � ����:<7N7�X 6kSBSB6GEF6 �0OQAIHI6G7N7NA�HI=(R>JT:l;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6&: ` 6GJK?F6�R>J�JWR>OQ6GEFAlOQ=@JMAPEF6&HI=83AKSU?c:<JK?B=^7NAPhP=\8cw>6Cn f¡ 6 ` =\HI6!JC?F6&8cwM6&SB6 �Z� �s��� �D]$:<7N7@ACEF: ��f6yOQAIHI6G7N7NA�HI6!7@7N6&;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM= � �Z] � ¾] � �b]nGn!nG¦2_KRM:P7NSB=N:CS[= S[=\:<J>A �T���W�3] �T��3�­] �Z���G�3](nGnGnB6!SFS[=^S[ACJ>A,6!7@6!O&6!JK?B=*HI= � 6y_KR>=NJMHI=*HI= �T� �s�­n�½mR>EB?BEFAP;M;TAiJ>ACJ` :<7N60=@7 ` =\836 ` 6GEcSF:>n¹opJ LM:CS[6D:�R>JM:�=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6 ��?FRI?[?F6.7@60;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>= � �Z� � ¾� � �b�%aba%a(;ZACSFS[ACJ>A6!SFSB6GEF6 ` 6GEF6s6C]M?FRI?[?c: ` =\:>] � � ���.d�:P7NSF:.��:CHD6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]ZS[6 �T� �s�~� �b�T� À �K]M:<7N7NAPEc:�� � ���¹f6�d�:P7NSF:i;ZAP=\8cwv®6 � � �6�}��lJ>APJ�hPAIHIAPJMA�HI= �Z� �s�­©£?BRI?B?F: ` =\:�SB6y;ZAPJM=N:PO&A �Z���I��� �M] �Z��3�� �T] �T���G�� �M]*n!nGn!] ��f6yOQAIHI6G7N7NA�HI=� �Z� � ¾� � �b�%aba%a �3n�¿£:QEc:<hC=@ACJ>6sHI=^83=pfA0f6s6 ` =\HI6GJK?F6P¦ �l:PSFSBAW8G=N:i:P7@7N6s83AKSU?c:<JK?B= �Z� ¾� �b�%aba%a>R>J�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BA,H>= �D]Oi:&J>APJ�f6�H>63?[?FAi8cw>6�?BRI?B?B=$hC7@=�6G7N6GOQ6!JC?F=$HI= � ` 6GJMhC:<JMAy83AC=@J ` AP7@?B={H>:<7N7\:�=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6 ` �bn*½(6GE~:<hChP=NEF:PEB6

� � �7E,��� �4� #FE,�5#F&>?0�N� � �$&O�F�B� �F&G��� &>D �N� @5D �(K @5&>�4�4� �5D � C>&>!5#FE,&>� �4� � C/.$&=�5��#J�$���,� &>?�@5#FD &>E,� %@5�J� H0��� � � �J� � �N� � @5�"!$��E,#F�5#F��2!%�4#:��?�?�#F@5�5?����$� ���9�F#F�5?�@J��?�?�#F�A� ��� �4& �I@$� H0& C>���4� ��� �4#�KI@5��� �4#�� ���5�A?��F#9&>�F&>E,&O�0�4#:!5#�� &,� #9#FE,�����5&.C/.5&,K @5&>�4�4& � @5� H0&C>���4� ��� �4#3� #B���5� � � �$�F#F?0�N� ��D4#B��E,&O�0�4&(#F�0�4&OD4�5D &G� �N� & � @5#%C>��D4D #F� �����5!$&O�0�4#%&O�F&>E,&>�0� #%!5# � - (����4&>D E,#F�5#�� &>E,�5�F#FC>##!J�4#%��?�?�#F@5�5?����5��5��E,#���&>D�&O�F&>E,&>�0� #�!5# �8#F� E,� !5� C/.5& �4@$��� #�?��F#�&>�F&>E,&>� �4#�!5# �8�4#B���5� � D ���5�5D4&O�4&>� � �N� # �.!J�(@$�J� C>���4� ���0� &�-&(�� K @5&>�4�4�.E,� !5�� #2�5@� � ����D D &���� � ��� ) � � �� & & � ���F�,�4&�� � � ) ��� ��&>D ��?��$#%CO�����M���0�4&��A!5&>�%�F#F�5?�@5��?�?�#F� ��E,�$�F#B�N� �5- �3��#FC/.�& � �5@ �<&>�4� &>D &#F� �J�$# � � !2���5C/.5& �5# @ C/.5& �I@$E,&OD ���5#F�F&"!��M���F& �5D � C>&O!$#FE,&O�0�4�<C>��E,����D4� � ��� #F� �4D � !5@5L>#F���5&(!5#3@5�J� KI@5��� �4# �� �<#F� �J�5# � � !����5C/.5&.�5# @C/.5& � @5E,&>DM���$#F�F&-!$!5#2� @5�OH0&(C>�����M���0� #-

Page 129: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� �?F:P7@6�ACS[?F:P8GAP7NAM]>8GAPJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&AQR>JD6kS[6!OQ;>=@A,H>6G7N7N:�^3ª�^ ���£]Z:PH06kS[6!O&;M=@A � � ` �<n~½(6GE2HI=\8cw>=\:<Ec:<EF6 ` 6GEc:�� � ���EF=N8cw>=N6!H>=N:PO&A,8cwM6 � ��S[=\: ` 6!EF:i8GAPOyR>JM_KR>6�=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?F=N:POQA �T]ZACSFSB=N:&d�:C8G83=\:<OQA ` :PEB=\:<EF6 �T���I�~=NJ � =NJD?BRI?B?B==(OQAWH>=^;ZACSFSB=@L>=N7N=Yn�opJ�?F:<7(OQAIHIA0: ` =@6!J>6&=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:b?FA ` =N: ` =N:l=@J�?BRI?B?B=*hC7@=(6G7N6GOQ6!JC?F=*HI= ��6P]$_KR>=NJMHI=�]$SB6� �QEF=NSBR>7@?F:&S[6!O&;MEB6 ` 6!EF:M]KSB=N:POQA&:PRI?BACEB=NjGjk:b?B=�:&HI=N8cwM=N:PEF:PEB6 ` 6GEc:���� ���£n*opJ�HI63aTJ>=r?F= ` :&;ZACSFS[=\:<OQAyH>=@EF6�8cwM6� � ����f6 ` 6GEc:y=@J �,SB6�6sS[AC7@AQS[6Qf6�=NJ ��f6 ` 6GEc: � �l83ACO�R>JT_CRM6�SB={EF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?B={7\:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6 �Zn�9APJTS[=\HI6GEF=\:<OQAyACEF:&7\:Q;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6���� ��� �Zn¢�*APhP7N=\:<OQAiHI=N8cwM=N:PEF:PEB6 ` 6!EF:y?F:P7@6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�EF=NSB;T6G?[?FA:PH�R>JM:&=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6 �iHI=£H>APOQ=@JM=@A � SB6�6�S[AC7@AQS[6�AChPJ>=�6G7N6GOQ6!JC?FA �lHI6!7$HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA � wM:&7\:yEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6:PSFSBAW8G=N:<?F:�:CH �¤83APJl7YX =@JTHI= ` =\HIR>A&:PSFS[AI83=\:b?FA�:PH �Tn �R>=NJMHI=�]W:PHi6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]WSB6 �Z���I�V� À ] � � � � �lf6 ` 6!EF:s=@J �SB6~62S[AC7@A�SB6 �T� ���(8GAPJK?B=N6GJM6u?BRI?B?B627N6283AC;>;>=N6s���M� À �3�!� À � À �­�!� � � À �­�k� � � À �3�!�[}��I� À �3©<S[6C]<=@J ` 6!836C]<deAKSBSB6 �T���W�9� � ]� � ��� ��f6 ` 6GEc:i=NJ.o�SB6�6ySBAP7NA�SB6 �Z� ���83ACJC?F=@6!J>6�7N6y8GAP;>;M=@6����M� � �3�!� À � � �­�!� � � � �­�k� � � � �3�!�[}��I� � �3n�½(ACSFS[=\:<OQAA<?B?B6!J>6GEF6i?F:P7@6�83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJ>6,6!7@=NOQ=@JT:<JMHIA�H>: ��� ��� ��=@7u_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?FAPEF6�� �£]*SBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIA.JM6G7N7N:�^3ª�^s:P;T6!E[?c:��� �D7\: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6&7@=NLZ6GEc: �¢8GAPJ�R>JM:083AKSU?c:<JK?B6C]£:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NA ¾]$6Q=NO&;ZAPJM6GJMHIA.8cwM6&7\:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6 � �A<?B?B6!JKR>?F:.SB=N: ` 6GEc:�=@J ��83ACO�R>JT_CRM6lS[=9=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?B=m7\:.8GACS[?F:<JK?F6 ¾n0opJ¢:<7@?BEF6,;M:PEBAC7@6C] SB6P]^d�:P8G6GJMHIA ` :PEB=\:<EF67�X 6!7@6!O&6!JK?BA,:PSFSBAW8G=N:<?BAi: ¾]T7N:Q;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6� �,EF=NOQ:PJ>6 ` 6!EF:M]>83=pfA,S[=NhPJM=raT8!:i8cw>6 �Z� ���~83ACJK?B=N6GJ>6�?FRI?[?F6s7N683AC;>;>=N6�� ��� �Z���I�[��:<7 ` :<EF=N:PEB6sHI= ��=NJ �D]�83=NAMf6 ` :<7N6s7N:�83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJ>6sEF=\8cw>=@6kSU?c:i;Z6GE�HI=N8cwM=N:PEF:PEB6 ` 6GEc:�� � ��� �Tnf¡ =@OQ;ZAPEB?F:<JK?F6&AKSBSB6GE ` :<EF6�8cw>6i:<LML>=N:POQA�SBACS[?B=@?BR>=@?BA�7\: ` :PEB=\:<L>=N7N6��q83ACJ�7\:083ACS[?F:PJK?B6 s8cw>6QJ>ACJ�83ACOQ;M:<EF6=NJ ��� �Zn �W6�: ` 6kSBSB=@OQADSBACS[?B=@?BR>=@?BA � 83ACJ � ��8cw>6lhP=pf:0aMhPRMEF:D=NJ ��� �I�sJ>APJ¹: ` EF6GOQOQADA<?B?B6GJWRI?FA�_KRM:PJC?FA:<RTS[;>=\8G:<?BATn�opJ>d�:b?[?F=Y](7\:D;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6 � � �¢f6 ` 6GEc:0=@J ��SB6,6lSBAP7NA.S[6,7\:.8GAP;>;>=\:q� �����W�3� �Z���I�[�if6i=NJ �T� ����eAKSBSB=\:2S[6 �T���I�$wM:�7N:2EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6 �Z� ��� 83ACJsSI®69SU?F6!SFS[AW�­n��T:P8G6GJMHIA ` :<EF=N:PEB6*7�X =NJMHI= ` =NH>R>A:CSBSBAI83=\:b?BA:<7N7N:28GACS[?F:PJC?F6��S[=KA<?B?B=N6GJ>6m7\:28GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJM6V8cw>6 �Z� ���$8GAPJK?B=N6GJM6*?BRI?B?B697@6v83AP;M;>=@6���M�-�K�3�!� À � À �­�!� � � � �­�k� � � � �3�!�[}��I�!}��C�I69_KR>6kSU?c:83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJ>6VJ>APJ,f6V_KR>6G7N7N:2;>EB=NOi:2=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:b?F:Mn �^:<7N698GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJM6P]k=@Jy63t�63?[?F=Y]<8GAPEFEB=\SB;TACJMHI6m:<7N7\:2;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6� � ��� �¢�e7\:i_KRM:<7N6sHI6 ` 6�EF=NSBR>7@?F:<EF6 ` 6!EF:y=@JDRMJM:Q=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�S[6�6sSBAP7NAiS[6 �Z� ����f6�EF=��M6!SFS[= ` :>]>8G=@AMf6�APhPJM==NJMHI= ` =\HIR>A0wM:l?F:P7@6&EF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6&8GAPJ�SB6QSU?F6!SFS[AW�­n�½VEBAI836kHI6GJTHIA�8GAPOQ6&SBAP;MEF:M]Z6!7@=NOQ=@JT:<JMHIA0=N7m_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?BACEB6C]6�SBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIAi=NJ ��� �.7\: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6�7N=@LZ6GEc: ��8GAPJD:,SB=$A<?B?B=N6GJ>6 � � �Z]M6C]M=NO&;ZAPJM6GJMHIA�8cw>6s_KR>6!S[?F:iSB=N: ` 6GEc::<7 ` :PEB=\:<EF6�HI6G7 OQAWH>A,HI=£=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<EF6 �Z]ZS[=$wT:i7N:i8GAPJMH>=@j!=@ACJ>6�;T6!E�HI=\8cw>=\:<Ec:<EF6 ` 6GEc:�� � ����£n �~=r?FAPEFJM:<JTHIA: � � ��� �¹SB=�;MR fA¢SU?c:<L>[email protected]>6�� � ��� � f6 ` 6GEc:�=@J � S[6D6�S[AC7@AqSB6�f6 ` 6!EF:�=NJ �¢7\:�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6 � �EF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PJMHIAQ7\:i83ACS[?F:PJK?B6 =@J0?FRI?[?F=£=£OQAIHI= ;TAKSBSB=@LM=@7N=V�e6y8cw>6�� � � ���f6 ` 6!EF:&=NJ �lSB6�6sS[AC7@A,SB6�=@J �Df6` 6!EF:y7\:y;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6 � � �,EF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PJMHIA �,=NJ�?FRI?[?F=$=$OQAIHI=$;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@=��­n¿£:iH>=NSF83RMSFSB=@ACJ>6sS ` AP7@?F:QJ>6!7@7�X ¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA,;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�=@7N7@RTSU?FEF:i=N7£;MEBAI836kHI=NO&6!JK?BAihP6!J>6GEc:<7N6�;Z6GEH>=N8cw>=\:<Ec:<EF6` 6!EF:�RMJM:s;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>62HI6!7>?F=@;ZA����A�l� �Z�3¦mS[=T6G7N=@OQ=NJM:s=N7 ���,6�SB=ZSBACS[?B=@?BRM=NSF8362AChPJ>=TAI8G83ACEBEF6GJMj!:�7@=NLZ6GEc:sHI6G7N7\:` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6��D83ACJDR>JM:,8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�:,8cw>6�J>APJ�8GAPOQ;M:PEB6�=NJ��l� �Z�3©$S[= EB=\8cw>=N6!HI6�8cwM6s7N:,;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6�A<?[?F6GJWRI?c:

�l���I�uS[=\: ` 6GEc:y=@J �i6�7NAiEB6kSU?F=$:<JM8cw>6�8!:<O�LM=N:PJMHIA&7YX 6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA,HI= � :PSFS[AI83=\:b?FA&:CH�: ` �Pn798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���CFE �y§"\º§e�T!Z§�VW�M§"3 �05�§k�05$5+!X\m#W,�*o,-#W\p§bY%5��"!$# ����5$�;��.U5+!X5�� � «cnT5�§�.U5�§�./� �;��EF6G=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6HI= �R~K#h3@§(5+!$��5�«1n�5�§".h��«1��! �����9�T!Z§_V%�M§�3 �05�§k�05 5+!A\s#%,�*$,-#%\p§bY%5���!o#,«cnX#l«1��5+!�«W5��;#�«1�"! �������T!$V%�X#0f6�G§�34���.§"3*$5�Q� ` W*&#%,25+3G./�b�;���"5�5+!X\m#W,�*o,-#%\º§",-#23@§�«1�k�0\p§�!X\m# �qt

½(ACSFSB=N:PO&AQACEF:Q;>EFACSB6GhCR>=NEB6�7\:iJ>AKSU?FEF:iHI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6y=@JTHIRI?[?F= ` :�HI= � � � 8GAPJK?B6!OQ;>7N:PJMHIA,=N7(8G:PSBAi=NJ�83R>= f6_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?c:�R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7NOQ6GJK?B6C¦^SB6� � � �$�,]I:<7N7@ACEF:M]CSB6:if6�R>JM:y83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�8cwM6�J>ACJ�83ACOQ;M:<EF62=NJ� � � ¦

��� � � � � � � ��� � � � �£;Z6GE�APhPJM= ���ºEF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI= � ���In À �� � �9&>!5D4&OE,�(� D �.���IC>�"C0.5& ��� &O�4&>E,�5#F�(H��.� C>&>� �4�,CO��� @5�J�.�$D &>CO��@5L>#F���5&�-� � (�� �$D � CO&>!5#FE,&>�0� � C/.$&:��� �5#B��E,��#F�F�F@$�4�4DM�N�4� �$@� � ���$�J��D #FD4&*���FK @J���0� � ��D4�4# �JC>#F��� � � � #�!5&GH0&9D4#FC>��D D &>D4&*��� �4�4D @5C>C>��� !5#0� ���4�4# �4@5#FD &

�B�.H���D4#B���5#F�F& �F#���&OD �"C>��� @5�J�"C>���4� ��� �4&"���5����D�� @5�5� &(����# 1��D H���D4#B��D & ��� #F� �4&>D �5D4&G�M��L>#F���5&(!5#%K @5&>�4� � C>�����M���0� &.��&>D=�J��� � ��D & #F�DM���4� &>?��J��� @I�4�4#$?��F#0&>�F&>E,&O�0�4#I!5&>� !5��E,#F�5#F�5-2;=��� � # !5#FE,&>�0� #FC/.$#0�4@$���M�>H$#B� C/.5&"!���&>D%����� &>D%�5D4�IC>&>!5&>D &:#F�$!5@$��� # H���E,&O�0�4&-!���� �5#B��E,��B� �$&OC>&>� �4# �� � !5#*D4#FC>���5!5@5D4D &"�B�,H0&>D # �� � !5#*@5�J� �$D ������� #FL>#F���5&,�4@ K @5&>�F�B� !$#9@5� � ��� �4DM�<�5D �������4#FLO#F���$& � &>!� &"��&OD K @5&>�4�4��C/.5&,�4#� ����� # �4@5#F�4CO& �B� H���D4#B���5#F�F& �F#���&OD � C>���,�B� C>���4� ��� �4& :�OH0&>� �4& @$�"�I@$E,&OD4� E,#F�5��D &�!$#5C>���4� ��� �4#��F��?�#FC0.5&"!I&>! & � @.KI@5&>���M� C/.5& D #FCO��!5&��� �N��� D4#��5@5L>#F���5& !5&>�F�B�=H0&>D # �� � !5&>� � ��&>D*��?��5# � !0��&>D�CO@$#J�IC>C>��D D4&�C/.5&��M���F& C>���4� ���0� & ����� �M� �4�J��L>#B��D &��4@5�F��� #F� �4&>D � !$��E,#F�5#F�5- �3��#FC/.�&��� #F�0� &>D �$D &G�M��L>#F���5&<���4� &>?��J� @5� ��&>� �5D4&>CO#F�4� &>�F&OE,&>�0� ����CO#B���4C>@5�J��C>���4� ��� �4&"!:� C>CO��D4D & D &>#F�0� &>D4�5D &G� ��D &,�M���F& C>���4� ���0� & � &>!� &��&>D KI@5&>��� � C/.5&"�B� C>���4� ��� �4&,H�� � C>&>� �M� � �I@5�OH���� !%����#FC/.�&"�5��� � #3H$@5���F& E.@$� ��D & #F�%H����F��D &.�N�4�4D #��$@5# � �����F�F& C>���4� ���0� #:C0.5&"?�# ��J?�@5D ���5�"�5&>�F�B�.�$D ������� #FL>#F���5& K @J���0� # �JCO�N� ��G-

� � (��.K @5&>�4�4� E,�I!5� ���5C/.5& � D4#F� @5� � �=@$�J� ����D &>#F�0� &>D �$D &G�M��L>#F���5& !5#(M- @5&>�4�4� &�#FE,����D4� ��� �4&:����#FC/.�& ���5C0.5& CO��E,& (�#F� �4&>D �5D4&G�M�� H�� � &>� @$�4�,#F�AC>���5� #F!$&OD ��L>#F���5&�- ���I#=�$@� �7!5#FE,����� D ��D & D #F?���D ��� ��E,&>� �4&A��&>D,#F�5!5@5L>#F���5& C0.5&�#F� � @5�4� #F�4�4&>D & !5# � � � � �5��� !5#F��&>�5!5&�!J���F�B� C>���4� ��� �4& �5������5�J��D�� &>�5&>�0� &(��! � � C>&>� �M�$- � !5&>��D &>�4�4�.#F�0�4@5# � # H���E,&>� �4& &GH$#F!$&O�0�4& C/.5& � ���F& C>���4� ��� �4& �4H0���F?�& � ���F�(#F��D4@5���F� !$# � �4&>?��J�������4�4���&"!5K @5#F�5!5##!5@5� � �4&O?��5��������� ���,H����F& ��� ��� � D4� � �5@5D C0.�& �5����?�# �(�5D &>� &>�0� & �5&>�F�B�.�$D ������� #FL>#F���5& M-

Page 130: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!| �op7�8G:CS[AgHI6G7N7N: ;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6�_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?F:¢6kS[=\S[?B6GJMjG=\:<7NO&6!JK?B6�S[=�?BEc:b?B?F: OQAWH>=raT8!:<JMH>A _KR>6G7N7NA ;Z6GE07\:;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>60_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?F:�R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7NOQ6GJK?B6Cn¹op728G:CS[A�HI6!7@7\:�_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:PjG=NAPJ>6 ` R>A<?c:�SB=u?BEc:b?B?F:�83ACO&60=NJ;>EF6!8G6!HI6!J>j!:��eAKSBSB=\:~83APOQ6mSB6*=@7K_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?BACEB6^J>ACJs83=bdeAKSBSB6k�3n x2JT8cw>6m_KR>= ` 6!HI=\:<OQAu;>EF=@Oi:~_KRM:<7\8cw>6*6kS[6!O&;M=@ATn

���b8��Jx�=�@+�qCF�GCF� �W=\: ��� ���M� À � � � � �G}��I�Cn�x �iJM8cwu®6Q7\:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6 ��� ���¹S[=\: ` 6!EF:�=@J�LM:CS[6i:CH�R>JT:=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 � ` APhC7@=\:<OQA�8cwM6:<7NOQ6GJ>A&R>J�=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>AQHI6G7{HIACO&=NJ>=NA&:PL>L>=\:�7\:s;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf: �Z� �s�3n �R>=@JTHI=Y]SB6P]M:CH�6kS[6!OQ;>=@AT] �Z� �s�����[6kSBSB6GEF6;T:<EF=N�,���b�M� À � � �G}k�W�K]���� ����HI6 ` 6�6!SFSB6GEF6�H>=N8cw>=\:<Ec:b?c: ` 6GEc:>]>SB6 �Z� �s�2��[6kSBSB6GEF6sHI=\S[;T:<EF=N�l� � � �C]��� ��� ` :iJWR>A ` :PO&6!JK?B6�HI=\8cw>=\:<Ec:b?c: ` 6GEc:>]TO&6!JK?BEF6�S[6 �T� �s�����[6!SFSB6GEF6�O�R>7@?B=N;>7NAHI=e�P�>]9:P7@7NAPEc: �Z� �s��f6 ` R>AP?BA�6���� ��� ` :�HI=N8cwM=N:PEF:<?F:Dd�:P7NSF:>n �9APOQ60;Z6GEi=N728G:PSBA�HI6G7N7N:�_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:<j!=@ACJ>6R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7N6P]$H>APL>L>=\:<OQA�AP;Z6GEc:<EF6&SBR>7N7N:U^3ª�^�AP?[?B6!JWRI?F:�6G7N=NO&=NJM:PJMHIA0=@7m_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF6 ���£]^83=NAMf6 ���£]£6&d�:PEB7\:HI= ` 6!JC?c:<EF6RMJM:&;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6SBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIAQ7@6�AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG6�7N=@LZ6GEF6�HI6G7N7N: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6��D83ACJ�R>JT:&8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�8cwM6J>ACJ�83ACO&;T:<EF6�=NJ ��� ���£]$:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NA �Z©$SB= AP?[?B=N6GJM6 � �Zn�¿mX =@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�:CSBSB6GhCJM:,:CH.:,R>J�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA�Z���I��HI= �.n f¡¤8cw>=\:<EFA08cwM6QSB6 � � � � �¹��ACSFS[=\:0S[6 �Z���I��wM:07\:0;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f: �Z� �s�B�­](:<7N7@ACEF:�;TAKSBSB=\:<OQA0;TACEBEF6� � � ��� ���£n � RI?B?F: ` =N:�;>R^fA.H>:<EcS[=*8cw>6 �Z���I��J>ACJ�:PL>L>=\:�7\:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f: �T� �s�­] OQ:08cw>6i7\:0:<L>LM=N:�R>Jq:<7@?BEFA6G7N6GOQ6!JC?FA �QHI= � ��6�_KR>=NJMHI=T8cwM6 ��� ��� ` :CH>:�HI=\8cw>=\:<Ec:b?F: ` 6GEc:C�­¦ S[6�:CSBSBAI83=\:<OQA�:<7N7N:�8GACS[?F:<JK?F62:�7YX 6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA��HI= �D] �Z���I�V� ��hPAIHI6VHI= �Z� �s�­n �R>=NJMHI=�]b;T6!E HI=\8cw>=\:<Ec:<EF6 ` 6!EF:���� ���£]<LT:PS[?F:28cw>6VR>JM: �;�ºEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6HI= �sEF6GJMHM: ` 6!EF:� �Znm�9APJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&A�ACEF:�7\:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6 ��� ��� �&62J>6!7@7�X =NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6 �ySB=\:��T���W�9� � n½(6GEQHI=\8cw>=\:<Ec:<EF6 ` 6!EF: ��� ��� �qLT:PS[?F:�8cwM6�:P7@OQ6GJMA�R>Jg=@JTHI= ` =\HIR>A �¢HI= ��:<L>L>=\:�7N:�EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6 �T� ���y83ACJ� ]{AKSBSB=\:l8cw>6&=@J �T� ��� ` =*SB=N:�:<7NOQ6GJ>A�R>JM:�HI6G7N7@6i8GAP;>;>=N60���M� � �3�!� À � � �­�!� � � � �­�k� � � � �3�!�[}��I� � �3n��WR>;M;TACJ>=N:POQA8cw>6 �Z� ���D� �W� � � � �3�!�U}k�I� � �­�k� � �G}��C�­�k���M� � �3�!�U}k�I�!}��P�­�Cn opJ ��� ��� �g6!7@=NOQ=@J>=\:<OQA ��� 6.;M:PSFSB=N:PO&Aq: � �SBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIA�7N: ` :<EF=N:PL>=@7N6���8GAPJ�7N:�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6 ¾n&½(6GE�SB:P;T6!EB6QS[6�� ��f6 ` 6!EF:l=@J ��L>=NSBAPhCJM:�SB:P;T6!EB6Q_KRM:<7N6=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>A �l:PSFS[AI83=\:&: b]>Oi:y;Z6GEHI=@EF6�8cw>6���� � � �.f6 ` 6GEc:�LM:CSU?c:&R>JM:i8cw>6�R>JM: 1��EF6G=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6HI= �EF6GJMH>: ` 6GEc:� �Zn*½(AP=\8cwv®6~S[6�;TACJ>=N:POQA �T��3�V��}��I] � �yEB=\S[RM7r?c: ` 6!EF:i��7N:y83AP;M;>=N:l� �Z��3�3� �Z���I�[�3]>83=NAMf6s�[}��I� � �3]f6&=@J �Z� ���[�3] 83ACJM837NRMHI=\:<OQA08cw>6���� ��� ��f6 ` 6!EF:l=@J �Tnh�W6i8GAPJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&A�7N:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6 ��� ��� � ]^:P7@7NAPEc:;M:CSBSB=N:POQA�: � � �Tn � � �Qf69d�:<7\SB:�=NJ �l�e;ZAP=\8cwv®6v7N:�83AC;>;>=\:Q� �����I�­� �T���I�[�­]K83=NAMf6�� � � � �­]<J>ACJ�f69=NJ �T� ���[�­]P?BRI?B?F: ` =\:J>6!7@7\: �;��EF6G=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6�HI= �,;Z6GE�8GR>= �Z���I�v� }��I] � � ��EB=\S[RM7r?c: ` 6GEc:0�e7\:i83AC;>;>=\:D�U}��>�G}k�P��f6�=NJ �T� ���B�­]T6_KR>6!S[?BAi8G=(f6�S[R��,8G=@6!JC?F6�;T6!E2HI=\8cw>=N:PEF:PEB6�8cw>6��iEF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEc:���� ��� � � ` n�W=$wT:&:P7@7NAPEc:>¦�W6� � ���A�l]M:<7N7NAPEc:>]IS[6 �Df6�R>JM:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�8cw>6�J>ACJ08GAPOQ;M:PEB6�=@J(�¦

��� � � ��� � � � � � � � �£;Z6GE2:<7NOQ6GJ>AQR>JT: ���ºEF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI= � ���In Á �

½(6GE~8GAPOQAIHI=r?bf:&EB=\SB8GEB= ` =N:POQAy7\:QHI63aMJM=@j!=@ACJ>6�=@JTHIRI?[?F= ` :iHI= ��� � s¦}Cn2S[62 � � �-` � � a%aba � �{]>:P7@7NAPEc: � � � �S[6�6�SBAP7NAQSB6i� �Z� �­}¾�­� �Z� � �C�­�ba%a%a!� �Z� � �£�B� � �Z� ����>n2S[62 � ���,]M:P7@7NAPEc:>¦ ��� � �SB6�6�SBAP7NAiS[6�� �� � �|Mn2S[62 � � �9�&]T:<7N7@ACEF: ��� � �SB6�6�SBAP7NAiS[6���� � �»6 � � � ��Tn2S[62 � � �9�&]T:<7N7@ACEF: ��� � �SB6�6�SBAP7NAiS[6���� � �»A ��� � � �eAi6!JK?BEc:<O�LZ6k��>n2S[62 � � ���&]M:<7N7NAPEc: ��� � �SB6�6sS[AC7@AiSB6�� �� � �»A ��� � � ��Ai6GJK?BEc:<OyLT6¾�À n�� �k � � �A�l]M:<7N7NAPEc:>]WS[6 �Df6�RMJM:Q83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�8cw>6�J>APJD8GAPOQ;M:<EF6�=@J(s¦

��� � �SB6�6�S[AC7@AiSB6 � � � � � � � � � �£;Z6GE~AChPJ>= �;�ºEB6!=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6H>= �Á n2S[62 � ���A�l]M:<7N7@ACEF:M]IS[6 �Df6�RMJM:Q83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�8cw>6�J>APJ083ACOQ;M:<EF6�=@J(s¦

� � � �S[6�6sSBAP7NA&SB6���� � � ��� � � � �£;Z6GE:<7NO&6!J>AQR>JM: �;��EF6G=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6HI= � � �I&"! ��! &>�4&OE,�$#F� !:!J� � � � .� ���5�5D4#FE,&>� � #FE,�A�B� C>���5�5#B� ��� � � � ��/! �B� �5D4������� #FL>#F���5& ��� � ��� D #F� @$� � &>D & � ��& 1���F� � ����#FC/.�&

�5&>� �4@5�J�"� �D &>#F� �4&>D �5D4&G�M��L>#F���5& !5# � D &>�5!5& H0&>DM�����!��-

Page 131: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!|M}��:b?BA�R>J�HIACOQ=@J>=NA � 6�R>JM:�=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �&SBR �D]WACSFS[=\:�SB6SB=ZSBAPJ>A�=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:b?F62?FRI?[?F67N68GACS[?F:<JK?F==NJMHI= ` =\HIRM:P7@=(6y;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F= ` 6P]�:<7N7@ACEF:M]TH>:<?F:lR>JM:�_CRT:<7\S[=\:PSB=£;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6��]{A ��f6�OQAIHI6G7N7NA�HI= AC;>;>R>EF6 �J>ACJ�f6�OQAIHI6G7N7NAQH>=���e6�=NJ�?F:<7$8!:PSBAM]I;Z6GE2HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C] �0f6�OQAIHI6G7N7@AiHI=>���­¦

��� � ¤A � �� � ���6�J>APJ�6GJK?FEF:PO�LZ6�7N6s83AKS[6¾�opJy8GAPJIdeACEBOQ=@?¾f:�83ACJ�7N69J>AP?F:PjG=NAPJ>=W=NO&;M=@6!hC:b?F69JM6G7N7N:�7NAPhP=\8G:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P]bSB6 �&f6vOQAWH>6G7N7@A�HI=& SB8GEB= ` =N:"�OQA�:<JM8cw>6 �Z���9���&6P]PSB6uJ>APJ�f6vOQAWH>6G7N7@A�HI=X�] �T���V� �Vn*�9=>SB6GE ` =@EF6GOQA�?BRI?B?F: ` =N:�SBAP7NA�SB;ZAPEc:PHI=\8G:PO&6!JK?B6HI=£_KR>6kSU?c:&J>A<?c:<jG=NAPJM6Pnx ` 6GJMH>Al:,HI=\S[;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6s=N7 8GAPJM8G63?B?BAlSB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GAlHI=^LM:PSB6P]Z_CRM6G7N7@A�HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:iAid�:<7\SB=r?bf:,HI=^R>JM:i;>EFAP;ZACSB=i�jG=NAPJM6y=NJ�LT:PSB6&:CH.R>JM:�=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6ySBR�R>J�HIAPOQ=NJ>=NAM]{;ZACSFS[=\:<OQA�EB=N;>EF6GJMHI6!EB6�?F:P7@=(6i_KRM:<7N=*H>:<7m8!:<7\83AP7NA;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6�7@6�HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>=£H>6GhP7N=$:<7@?BEF=$83ACJM836G?[?F=£S[6!Oi:<JK?B=\83=�¦

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C���I�� @Gy>8�|�|�@ � �q#�� Q#]�T!l5+!&�05�#W./#_��5�*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A5Ff2�T!Z§_5+!A\s#%,�*$,-#%\p§bY%5���!o# �l�0�J�T!���".j5+!A5�� � Q#2OQAWH>6G7N7@A��"5{� �%#JQ#2./����#%3+3i���"5\��T\�\m#�3i#�*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A5D �"5{� ~i*&#%,��-r�!X5G �0�.� � � � ��t798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���CiB'I �2N&|�=�yD= 9��N�� O>!Z§S*$,c�c*X�k�05iY%5���!$#�� Q# ` :<7N=NH>:J�W#�#h�%��3��_�%#0f�*X#%,��-r�!X5u���".j5+!A5�� ��#�cr"!A55+!X\m#W,�*o,-#W\p§bY%5��"!$# ���0� �_f � Q#�./����#%3+3i���"5�£~i*X#W,S�cr�!X5 � # �&f � � � ��t798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C�vI � @GyDy>=����sN�:�=�{>=�|�= 9��N�y>=6�D<>N�x>L�@Xx¢@A��=�?;=�@$<D8��¤O>!Z§S*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!o#S�Q#U�%�����"5F�+^3§C«W5+gª%5+3i#_�%#�#9�%�"3i���%#�#0�05F�0\m��!$�J�T!R�;��.U5+!X5�� � #_�T!�§�5+!X\m#W,�*o,-#W\p§bY%5��"!$# �R�1� � \º§"3i#.«1n&# � Q#�.h����#%3+3i���"5 �N� t

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C �I � @GyDy>=����sN�:�=�{>=�|�= 9��N�� �A5���5�«1#Q«cnX#��T!(5+!X�05�#W./#2���"5$*$,-�1*&���15iY%5��"!X5�Q#�S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6�%#j#2�%��3i�]�%#S#W�15F�0\m��!o�/�T!��;��.U5+!X5�� � #2�T!�5+!A\s#%,�*$,c#W\p§bY%5���!o# ���0� � \º§"3i#y«1n&#Wfq*X#W,S�cr�!X5G ���.� ��� � Ut798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C �vI � @A<>��8��$�>8�<>?�N |�@$�$= :�N � �$5���5�«1#D«1n&#�3@§]*$,-�1*&���05iYW5��"!$#/� Q#Q83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:�7NAPhC=N8!:��#%3+3@§h*$,-�1*&���15iY%5��"!$#U2f�#/�15��G«%,05+�k#j � �}�/f �%#�#U�%�"3i�_�%#�*X#%,/�cr�!X5 � #�*X#W,]�cr"!A5 �J�1� �(f6�%# � � �£�f§�3+3���,B§ � � � �9t798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C � IK�?�q�D=�M&N&|�8�<>?�N |�@$�A= :�N����A52��5�«1#�«1n&#�3i#j*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A5e #/� �%��!o��7@AChP=\8G:<OQ6!JC?F66!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B=�f¢#��15��G«%,05+�k#� � �]f�W#U#��W�"3i�]�W#� � � � #�� � � jt798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>81�GC���C � I � @A<>��8��$�>8�<>?�N |�@$�$= :�N � �$5���5�«1#.«1n&#93@§]*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!o#] Q#Q83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:07NAPhC=N8!:��#%3+3 p 5+!X�15�#%./#/��5o*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A5£� �%#j#��%��3i�]�%#0fo*X#%,S�-r�!X5 � #U�cr"!A5 ���0� �_f�%# � � �»�Jf9§�3+3i�",B§ ��� � jt�W=�H>=@OQACS[?BEc:<JMA�:PhP6 ` AP7NOQ6GJK?B6�?FRI?[?F6.7@6�;>EBAC;>EF=@6G?¾f:�hP=pf:�=@JM8GAPJK?BEc:b?F6DJ>6G7N7\:�7@AChP=\8G:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6�8cwM6EF=@hCRM:<EcH>:<JMA�=u83ACJ>J>6G?[?B= ` =���=@J>d�:b?[?F=Y]V7@6�837\:<RMSBAP7N6,=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` 69�C�s�K�P��H>6G7N7N:�HI63aMJM=@j!=@ACJ>6lHI= � � � EF=\8G:<7\8G:PJ>A_KR>6G7N7N6�;>EBAC;TAKSU?F6JM6G7N7N:Q;>EF=NOQ:&;M:PE[?F6k�3n(5�6�EB=\83ACEFH>=N:PO&AQ:<7\83RMJ>6P¦}Cn � � � � � � � � �����>nu � � � � � � � �|Mnu¢��� �� � � �9��Tn � � ¤6 � � � � � � � ��>n � � ¢��� �� � � ¤6�� � �À n~� � � � � � � � � �C� �_���m:<7N6�=NJ>AC7r?FEB6y7YX =@OQ;ZAPEB?F:PJC?F6s?F6GAPEF6GOi:,H>=^SBACS[?B=@?BR>j!=@ACJ>6P¦2SB6�=NJ�RMJM:,;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6S S[=(SBACS[?B=@?BR>=\SB8G6�R>JT:SBA<?[?FAP;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6(� 8GAPJ R>JT:¢7NAPhP=\8G:POQ6GJK?B6D6k_CRM= ` :<7N6GJK?F6P]�SB=�AP?[?B=N6GJM6�R>JM:¢;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6D7@AChP=\8G:<OQ6!JC?F66!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B6i:P7@7\:�HM:b?F:MnS�*6kHI=N:POQA�ACEF:�:<7\83RMJ>=*6!SB6GOQ;>=mHI=*;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>= ` :<7N=\HI6y6i:P7N8GR>J>6i:<7@?BEF6y;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:HI6!7@7N6sHI63aTJ>=@j!=@ACJ>={=NJC?FEBAIHIAP?[?F6�=@JD_KR>6!S[?BAi8!:<;>=@?BAC7@ATn � �"!5& �J�5#FL>#F���5&(!5#2H����F#F!5# �� �"!$#%�1D4#FC/.5#F&>!5& C/.5&(��&>D=��?��5#%!$��E,#F�5#F�.& ��?��5#%#F�0� &>D4�5D &G� ��LO#F���$& �,� @ KI@$&O�%!$��E,#F�5#F�"� #2��� �5#B�

� � � �(- �I#��5@� �(#F�0� D4�I!5@$D D & ���5C/.5& �B�(�5��L>#F���5& !5#�H����F#F!5# �� �(#F�,@5�<!5��E,#F�5#F� � 3@$�J� �5D4������� #FL>#F���5& & H����F#F!J�(#F�,@5� !5��E,#F�5#F� �� & & �4���F�"� &"!J��&>D ��?��5# �.�4@ �2! ��� � �(-�� �5���F��?0��E,&O�0�4&-!5� #2�$@� �,#F� �4D � !5@5D4D & �B�(�5��L>#F���5& !5#�� � !5!5#F�*1��C>#��5#F�F# �� � #F� @5�A!$��E,#F�5#F�� @5�J�,�5D4������� #FL>#F���5& &(� � !5!5#F�*1��C>#��5#F�F& #F��@$� !5��E,#F�5#F� � � &(&(� ���F� � & &>� #F��� & ���FE,&>�5� @5�J�,#F� �4&>D �5D4&G�M��L>#F���5& �<!5#%!$��E,#F�5#F�� � ���F& C/.5& ��� � �(- �I#��5@� �<���F�F��D �.!5#FD & C0.5& @5�J�"�5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& & H����F#F!J�"� & & �4���F�,� & & H����F#F!J�"#F� ��?��5#%!5��E,#F�5#F� & C/.5& @5�J��5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& & � � !5!5#F�*1��C>#��5#F�F& �4& & � ���F� � & & � � !5!5#F�*1��C>#��5#F�F& #F�A���FE,&>�5� @5�A!5��E,#F�$#F�5-

Page 132: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!|��� �� � � � ! *�-�� � ��� � � � ,(+�,���-�, � # � ,����}k�Q�9APJTS[=\HI6GEF=\:<OQA�7\:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6 � � ��� � � �Zn��W= ` 6!HI6�=@OQOQ6!H>=N:<?F:<OQ6!JC?F6�8cwM6�6kSBSF:¢f6 ` :<7N=\H>:>nv�I6SBAPJ>ADH>:<?B=mR>JqHIACOQ=@J>=NA ��6iR>JM:�=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �DSBR � ?c:<7N=V8cw>6 � � � � � ���£]£;Z6GEyHI63aMJM=@j!=@ACJ>6P] APhPJM=LT�ºEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6iHI= �¹f6,OQAWH>6G7N7@A�H>= � ¾n�opJ¢;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB6C] 7\:DLT�ºEF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6i8cw>6�:PSFS[AI8G=N:D:P7@7\:83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�Li7YX =@JTHI= ` =\HIR>A&8cw>6 �&:PSFS[AI83=\:�:PHi:���8G=@AMf6 �T�Y:C�B�­]WEB6!JMHI6 ` 6GEc:�½mL$]K;Z6GE98GR>= �T�Y:C� � �Z� �s�3]W6�:<7N7@ACEF:��� � � �Zn �R>=NJMHI=�]MSB6 � � � � � ���£]Z:<7N7@ACEF: � � � � �Z]>;Z6GE28GR>= � � � ��� ����� � �Znm¡VSFS[6!JMHIA � 6 �,_KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=�]J>6sSB6GhCR>6�7N: ` :<7N=NH>=r?bf:&H>=�� � ����� � �ZnopJQhP6!J>6GEc:<7N6P]KS[6uy� �Z�~f6~R>JM: ^3ª�^*: ` 6!JK?B6 �l8GAPOQ6~R>J>=\8G: ` :PEB=\:<L>=N7N6~7@=NLT6!EF:M]P6 �,f6~R>JM:�83ACS[?F:PJK?B6~_KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=�]83ACJ�RMJ�Ec:<hC=@ACJM:<OQ6!JC?FAy:PJM:<7NAPhCA&SB=$HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:Q8cw>6C¦

� � ���A�� �Z�V������I��P�2�9ACJMSB=NHI6!EB=\:<OQAQAPEc:&7N:Q;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6� �i� ��� ���£n �=@OQACS[?BEF=\:<OQA,8cw>6s:<JT8cw$X 6kSBSF:�f6 ` :<7N=NHM:>n��I=N:PJ>AH>:<?B=�R>J0HIAPOQ=NJ>=@A � 6�R>JM:y=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �QS[R ��?F:P7@={8cw>6 � � � � �D��_KR>=NJMHI=�¦ �T�Y:C� � �Z� �s�B�­nm526�SB6GhCR>68cw>6 ��� � ��� ��� n*opJId�:b?B?B=�]W7N:�L&��EF6G=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6vHI= ��8cwM6�:PSFS[AI8G=N:�:�L,7�X 6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BAyHI= � 8cwM6 �y:CSBSBAI83=\:�:CH:l�Y83=NAMf6 �Z��:K�[�3]Zf62OQAWH>6G7N7@A&HI= � ��e68G=ºfAT]W;T6!E9HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C]W:CSBSB=\83R>Ec:�8cw>6 � � � ��� ���Z�­n �RM=@JMH>=Y]ISB6 � � � � �T]:<7N7NAPEc: � � � ��� ���£]T;T6!E�83RM= � � � � �&� ��� ��� nV¡VSFS[6!JMHIA � 6��,_KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=�]IJ>6sS[6!hPR>6�8cw>6� �Q� ��� ���¢f6

` :<7N=NHM:>nm¬�6GJ>6!EF:P7@=NjGjk:<JMH>A&8GAPOQ6�J>6G7$8!:PSBAQ;>EB6k836kHI6GJK?B6C]>S[={AP?[?F=@6!J>6P¦� � ����W�9� �Ay� �Z�

|C�£¿£:�HI63aTJ>=@j!=@ACJ>6uHI= � � � ���Ay� �Z� 6uHI= � � � ���Ay� �Z�vf6m?F:P7@6u8cw>6C]<S[6 � � � ���Ay� �Z�3]C:P7@7NAPEc: � � � ���Ay� ���­nopJId�:<?[?B=�]$SB6�?FRI?[?F6&7N6Q:��ºEB6!=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>=£HI= ��EF6GJMHIACJ>A ` 6GEc:�����I�­]$:<7NOQ6GJ>A�R>JM:�:��ºEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6sHI=�qEF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEc:�y���I�­n¤�9=ºfAq83ACJMSB6GhPRM60HM:<7ud�:b?B?BA¢8cw>6C]9;Z6GEi=N;ZA<?B6kS[=�]u=@72H>APOQ=@JM=@A ��J>APJ¤f6 ` R>AP?BA �e=NJ R>JHIACO&=NJ>=NA ` R>A<?FAu?BRI?B?B6V7N6m;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=<_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?F6*R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7NOQ6GJK?B6mSBAPJ>A ` 6GEF6*6(?BRI?B?B69_KR>6!7@7N6V_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?F66!SB=\SU?F6GJ>j!=N:P7@OQ6GJK?F6�SBAPJMAyd�:P7NSB6k�3n �R>=@JTHI=Y¦ � � � �A � ���A � �

� �� � � ,�� ,�-�# �?,�� , /��# ��� ����� !$� � / #%-�/�, ,�- ��,���, ��*�#%� ,�W6~x f6vR>JM:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>698cw>6u83ACJK?B=N6GJ>6u7\:8GACS[?F:<JK?F69=NJMHI= ` =NHIRT:<7N6 �Z]PSB=\: �iR>JT: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6u8cw>6uJ>ACJy83ACOQ;M:<EF6=NJjg6V;ZAPJ>=\:<OQA��� �Z� 7N:�^3ª�^£:<;Z6GEB?F:y��8GAPJ��i8GAPOQ6VR>JM=N8!: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@697@=NLZ6GEc:C�£A<?[?F6GJWRI?c:�SBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIA�A ` RMJM_KR>67\:y8GACS[?F:<JK?F6 �i83ACJl7\: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6 �£]>SB6GhPRM6H>:P7@7\:�HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C]>83ACO&6�S[=(f6;T6!EF:P7r?FEBA�hP=pf: ` =\SU?FA�=NJl;>EF6!8G6!HI6!J>j!:M]8cw>6C¦

��� � � ��� � ���$�� �Z��yX :P7r?FEF:i;T:<EB?B6P]�SB6 � � � ���$�� �Z�­]$HM:b?BA�8cw>6�:lJ>APJ.8GAPOQ;M:<EF6s=NJ ���$�� ���&�e;Z6GE�83APOQ6,f6�SU?c:b?c:i6!SB6GhCR>=r?c:7\:&SBACS[?B=@?BRMjG=NAPJ>6¾�­]>;Z6GE2HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C] � � � � y���I�v;T6!E�:<7NOQ6GJ>AQR>JT: �;�ºEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI= �Tn �R>=@JTHI=Y¦

�IAWHX � ��WAIH ���$�� ����9APJ0:<JT:<7NAPhPwM6�8GAPJMSB=NH>6GEc:<jG=NAPJM=ZSB=£HI=NOQACS[?BEc:&8cwM6P¦

� � � � � ���Ay� �Z��R>=NJMHI=�]�3@§]�%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ª%5+345+\�Q§�#j3@§]�b§�3 5���5+\TQ§(��5o*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A5~«1�"!X\m#W!o#W!A\�5V«1�k�0\p§�!A\�55+!o��5+��5����M§�3 5¢�05�,05�«1�"!Xg

���M«1�"!$�D§_VW�X#%3+3i#]�"5G*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A56�%#W!TY!§0«1�k�0\p§�!A\�5��eLT:PS[?F:lSBACS[?B=@?BRM=@EF6s7N6y83AKSU?c:<JK?B=(83ACJ ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@=^HI= ` 6GEcS[6�68cw>6sJMAPJ0AI8G83ACEBEFAPJMA&=NJ.x�6�_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:PEB7N6�6!SB=NS[?B6!J>jG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6��uS[6sSB=\:<OQAi=@JK?F6GEF6!SFSB:<?B=£:P7@7\:iS[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N=r?bf:�*AyRMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@OQ6!JC?F6e�mSB6�SB=\:<OQAy=NJK?B6!EB6kSBSF:b?F=Z:P7@7\: ` :P7@=\HI=@?¾f:C�3n �:Q_KRM:<JK?FAy:<;M;T6!JM:QHI63?B?BA&6�HM:y_KRM:PJC?FA ` =\SU?FA=NJ(�>n |Mn |&SB6GhPRM6P]>:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM¦

� � ���� � � ���,� ��I�� � ���� ��&� ��� ���Z�

/ ;=&>�F�F& �F��?�#FC/.5& #F�5C>�F@5�4# H0& � #F�AC>@5#�#F��!5��E,#F�5#F� �5@� �"&>� �4&>D & HI@5��� � :� ���F&(�$D ������� #FL>#F���5& �5��� & H����F#F!J�$-

Page 133: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!|C|� ���� � ������, � � #%! ,�� ,�� , /��#.� �0#%��, ��,(/ �#)��� �����������4#�� ��� / ��9APJTS[=\HI6GEF=\:<OQAQAPEc:QR>JM:�^3ª�^~:<;Z6GEB?F:/�©�SBR>;>;ZAPJM=N:PO&A,8cwM6�83ACJC?F6GJ>hK:&7@=NLT6!EF:,7N:,SBAP7\: ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@6�� n�9APOQ6sS[=f6�:<EFhPAPOQ6!JC?c:b?FA�=@J�;>EB6k836kHI6GJ>jk:>]W;Z6GEuR>JM:s?F:<7N6deAPEFO�R>7\:sJ>ACJlwM:yS[6!JMSBAy8cw>=N6!HI6!EFSB=�S[6�f6 ` 6GEc:�Asd�:P7NSF:y=@J�LM:PSB6:PH0RMJM:,=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6sS[R.RMJ�HIAPOQ=NJ>=NAMn�¨:Q?BRI?B?F: ` =\:lSB6GJMSBAl8cw>=N6!HI6!EFSB=£SB6lf6yS[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6�AlS[6,f6 ` :<7N= �H>: � �Cn(½(6!EvH>63aMJ>=NEF6�?c:<7N=�8GAPJM8G63?B?B={83={SB6GE ` =\:<OQA�H>6G7N7YX :<JM:P7@AChP=\:s83ACJ�_KRM:PJC?FA�6kS[;ZACS[?BAyJ>6G7{;>RMJC?FAy;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B6C]?BEc:b?B?F:PJMHIAQ7N: ` :<EF=\:<L>=N7@6�8GAPOQ6�deACSFS[6�R>JM:Q8GACS[?F:<JK?F6Pn*½m=[fR0;>EB6k83=\SB:POQ6GJK?B6�;TACJ>=\:<OQAM]I;Z6GE�H>63aMJ>=NjG=NAPJM6P¦

�IAWHX � ��WAIH ���$�� ���

� � � � � ���Ay� �Z��R>6kSU?c:i6!S[?B6!JMS[=NAPJM6�HI6G=(83ACJM836G?[?F=^SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8G=^HI=(SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N=r?bf:���6 ` :<7N=NH>=r?bf:C�2:P7@7N6�^3ª�^28GAPJ.R>JT: ` :<EF=N:"�L>=N7@6y7@=NLZ6GEc:,S[=^6!S[?B6!JMHI6�d�:C83=N7@OQ6!JC?F6y:P7 8G:CS[Al=@J�8GR>=^J>6G7N7N:ideAPEFO�R>7\:] ` =^S[=\:<J>Al;>=[fR ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N=£7N=@LZ6GEF6P¦uLM:CSU?c:_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:<EF6l6kS[=\SU?F6GJ>j!=N:P7@OQ6!JC?F6���A�RMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@OQ6!JC?F6k��?BRI?B?B607@6 ` :<EF=N:PL>=N7@=v7@=NLZ6GEF6�AI8!83APEFEF6GJK?B=9J>6G7N7N:�deAPEFO�R&�7\:>n2�W=(A<?[?F=@6!J>6�RMJM:,;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6l��R>JM:U^3ª�^8cw>=NRMSB:K�~HI6G?[?F:�EF=NSB;T6G?[?F= ` :<OQ6!JC?F6 :��>=��>�b�DL�Nl8���=��89b8�<D?;=�N&|�8���A

:��D=��D���DLkN��><D=�MA8�L��bNX|�8I�vHI=� � �Cnx�H�6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]>S[6� � ����� ���Z� ����2� � �>�­]>7\:Q8cw>=@RTS[R>Ec:&6!SB=NS[?B6!J>jG=\:<7N6�HI=� f6C¦������{� ����� � �T� � � ��� � � >�[�

� � � {� ���l� � �T� � � ��� � � >�[��W=�wM:y:<7N7@ACEF:M]C;Z6GE~HI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C]W8cwM6� f6��%������5F��^3§C«W5�ª%5+3i#j�%#S#��%�"3i�U�%#�3i�'Q#�3@§j�0�M§i«cnT5+���0�T,B§]#W�15F�0\m#W!TY%5�§�3i#6s8cw>62 f6h�¾§"345��P§��%#U#2�%��3��/�%#S3i�RQ#S3@§h�0�M§�«cnT5+���1�T,F§/�T!X5+��#%,1�3§"3i#Gn½(ACSFSB=N:PO&AT]K:CHl6kS[6!OQ;>=@AT]>HI=NEB6�8cw>6

� � � � ����� ��

� � ��Q� ��� ���

;ZAP=\8cwv®6�S[=*f6 ` =\SU?FAQ:P7@7\:yaMJ>6sHI6!7{;>R>JK?BAi;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B6�8cw>6�7N6�7@ACEBAQ8cw>=NRMS[RMEB6�R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7N={S[ACJ>A ` :<7N=NHI6Cn� ���� ����A/ #%*�/ ���(����,�! ����9APJTS[=\HI6GEF=\:<OQAy7N6sHIR>6 ^3ª�^­¦N���� �^� � � u� ���Z�9��� � � ~� ��� ���Z�{ �¹� � � ����� � � 3�m������� � u� ��� � �����x�SFSBAW8G=N:POQA&:CHl6kSBSB6�7@6sHIRM6sS[6!hPR>6!JC?F=�de;DHI6G7N7N:&7NAPhC=N8!:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6C¦

N��l�����Y�����<� � ��� ��� � � � v� �����­©V��� � � ¾©(��� � � �����­©{ �¹�r�����<�m�����(��� �Z�Z� �r��� � � ���£©m��� � � G� � �I& C>���5� #F!5&>D4#B��E,�.��!<&>� &>E,�5#F� � � &"!5#F�<@5�<!5��E,#F�5#F�(!5#2� @5E,&>D #��J�N�4@5DM���F##!5��� �5#B��E,� � ��� �1&>� �4&OD4& �J��D4##!$�5���2.J� �4&>�5� �

C/.5#F&>!5&>D4� #�� & � � & H0&>DM� � 1 ���F�M� ! #F� K @J��� �4� �4DM��!$@5C>& � - ->- &=�J��D4# � � �4@$���M�>H$#B� .J� � &>�5� �(C/.5#F&>!5&>D4� #�� & & K @J���FC/.5& H0��� � � H0&OD ��� � &���FE,&>�5�.@$�A#F�5!5# HI#F!5@5�.!5&>�2!5��E,#F�5#F� & �J��D # 9�.� & & � &>E,�5D4&=H0&>DM� � �4& � @$���4#%?��F#2&>�F&>E,&O�0�4#2!5&>��!5��E,#F�$#F�.� ���$�"�J��D # M- 6 �I&,#F� �+HI#:� ���5�A�5# @ H���D #B���5#F�F#*�F#���&>D4&-!�� ���5�������4� #��5#F�F#*�5# @ C0.5#F@5� @$D &,&>� #F��� &>�5L>#B���F#:��@$�5# H0&>D �M���F#9�A� &>C>���5!J��!$&O�F��� ��D4!5#F�5&C>��� C>@5#�� #�K @J���0� # �JCO���5� �F&,H���D4#B���5#F�F#- �9���F&>�5!$� �4#��5@� � ���M���5#F�F#FD4& @5� ��D !5#F�$&<C>��� C>@5#�K @J���0� # �JCO��D4&A�F&,H���D4#B���5#F�F# � �4@$���M�>H$#B�� #2!5#FE,���4�4DM�31 ��C>#F�FE,&>� �4& C/.5& CO��E �5#B���$!5�,��� ��D !5#F�$& !5#%KI@5��� �4# �JCO��L>#F���5& � � D �N�4� ���5!5���4#*!$#�KI@5��� �4# �JCO��L>#F���5#��4@$��� &(&>� #F��� &>�5L>#B���F#%��4@$�4�4& @5�5# H0&>D � ���F# :� #2�����4&O�$?����5� �5D ������� #FL>#F���5#�� @$���4&(�F��?�#FCO��E,&>�0� & &>K @5# H����F&>�0� # 1 DM�(�F��D �5-

Page 134: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!|���9ACSpf �2RMJM:qde; :PSFS[AI83=\:b?c:q: ��� � ���»� ���Z��f6.; �eOQ6GJK?BEF6�R>JM:qdeACEBOi:q;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6.:CSBSBAI83=\:b?c:q:

� � ����� � � ����f6u��� �Z�3n�o#�3@§u^W�",0.Q§2*$,c�c*X�k�05iY%5���!Z§"3i#,§��c�%�k«W5�§"\º§�§��j�Q#S�T!Z§/\º§"�T\s�"3i�-r�5�§�§�3+3i�",B§S�Q#��b§�3 5��P§ � �Wn¿£:�LZ�(;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6P]C:CHQ6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]CwM:s83ACOQ6udeAPEFOQ:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6~:CSBSBAI83=\:b?F:�7\:�?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:Q� �����<�m����(�¹� �Z�Z�3n ½mEF6!SB=~R>J _KRM:<7\S[=\:PSB=~HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA � 6DR>JT: �¹S[R �D]u=@JTHI=@;Z6GJTHI6GJK?B6!OQ6GJK?B6.H>:P7ud�:b?B?BA¢SB6 � f6OQAIHI6G7N7@A�A.J>A�HI6!7@7N6,;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>= ��� ���¢6 � � ¾] 6kSBSB6GJTHIA¹� � ���<��� ���(��� �Z����R>JT:0?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:>] �

� � � ��� ����� � � G�m������� � ~������� ���Z�3]>6s_KR>=NJMHI=$7\:&LT�f6 ` :<7N=NH>:MnopJ _KR>6kSU?FA�SB6GJTS[A�7N:�7NAPhP=\8G:�HI6!=v;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?F=v6kSU?F6GJMH>6�7\:�7@AChP=\8G:�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P¦i;>EF6!SF:�RMJM:�_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=?F:PRI?BAC7@AChP=\:>]>SB6sS[AKSU?F=r?FR>=\:<OQAQ7@6�7N63?B?B6GEF6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=$83ACJ0;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=$HI6G7$7N=NJ>hPRM:PhPhC=@AQHI6G7N7\:Q7@AChP=\8G:QHI6G=;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=���:�7N63?B?B6GEF60R>hPRT:<7N=~;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=9R>hCRM:<7N=��ySB=~A<?B?B6!J>hPACJ>A�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>= ` :<7N=NH>60H>6G7N7N:�7@AChP=\8G:�HI6G=;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=�n �R>=@JTHI=Y]T:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]>SBAPJ>A ` :<7N=NH>6P¦��� ������� � ���l� � � ���

� � �&��� ��� ����� � �I�[�m���[� � �Q� ��� ���Z�V�¸� � �Q� � �I�[�� �� �� u��� ����� v� � ������ �>���� ���l� � � ^� ��� ������ ������ Q��� � �u� � � �� ���I����� ��� � � �y����� ��� � � �

�W=^;>R fA�=@J>AC7r?FEB6yACSFS[6!E ` :PEB6s8cw>6&_KR>6!S[?F:�83=NEF8GACS[?F:<JMj!:iSB= ` 6GEF=raZ8G:,:PJM8cw>6s;Z6GE�7N6�^3ª�^2:<;Z6GEB?B6y7N:�83R>=^deAPEFOi:;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6i:PSFS[AI8G=N:<?F:�f6,R>JM:�?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhC=N:Mn0�9APJTS[=\HI6GEF=\:<OQAM]^:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]� � � ��� ���Z]^7\:.83R>=deAPEFOi:�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6�:CSBSBAI83=\:b?F: f6Q�¤� �£n ½(6!E,_KRM:<JK?BA ` =\SU?FA�JM6G72;>RMJC?FAq;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6P]v;T6!ElSU?c:<L>=N7N=@EF67\: ` :<7N=\HI=r?bf: H>=� HIACL>L>=\:<OQA 83APJTS[=\HI6GEc:<EF6.7\: 8cwM=@RMSBR>Ec:¢R>JM= ` 6GEcSB:P7@6�HI=2s] � ����{� ��� � � �>�­n ½(6!EHI6GaMJ>=NjG=NAPJ>6C]MH>:b?FAiR>J.HIACO&=NJ>=NA �D]MRMJM:Q=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6��,SBR � f6�O&AIHI6!7@7NA,HI=�� ����{� ��� &� ��� >�uSB6�6SBAP7NAlS[6yAPhCJ>=^:"��EF6G=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6�HI= ��f6yOQAWH>6G7N7@A�HI=���{� � � �� � � >�3]Z6&83=pfA�:C8G8G:CHI6�SB6�6&S[AC7@A�S[6yAPhPJM=LT�ºEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI=(_KR>6!S[?F:,:"��EF6G=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6�HI= ��f6sOQAIHI6!7@7NAlHI= � � �� � � ¾n2¼�:l_KR>6!S[?!X R>7@?B=NOi:;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6&f6 ` :<7N=NHM:.�e7\:QdeAPEFOi:Q;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6�:PSFS[AI83=\:b?c:lf6sR>JM:&?c:<RI?FAP7NAPhP=\:C�3]T8G=@AMf6P]I;Z6GEAPhPJM= �D]ZAPhPJM==NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6lf6ySBR>A�OQAWH>6G7N7@ATn �R>=NJMHI= � � � {� ���0� ���I�yf6 ` :<7N=NH>:�6P]£;T6!E�H>63aMJ>=NjG=NAPJM6P]{7NA�f6Q:<JT8cw>6��� i� ��� �n*op7{EF:PhP=NAPJM:POQ6GJK?BA&6!SB6GhCR>=r?FAy=NJD_KR>6!S[?BAi8G:CS[AQ;M:PE[?F=N8GAP7\:<EF6�wM:&R>JT: ` :P7@=\HI=@?¾f:&hP6!J>6GEc:<7N6P¦

�o#��T!�§�^3ª�^2V%�M§�3 �05�§k�05�n>§l«c�".h#�^W��,0.i§�*$,-�1*&���05iYW5��"!Z§"3i#y§��1�W�k«%5�§�\p§/�T!Z§j\p§��T\m��3i�cr�5�§,§�3+3i�",B§]#W�1�3§�Q#2�¾§"345��P§~K#�3��RQ#&§�!Z«1n&#j3@§/�0�M§l«1n�5+���0�T,B§/�T!A5+�k#%,1�G§�3i#K�bn�WACJ>Ai_CRM=@JMH>= ` :<7N=NHI6C]M:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM¦����� ���

� � &� � � ��9� ������&��� ��� ��� ���I��u� ���y� ���Z� � � ���y�_� ���� � � ������� �� �I�m��� �� �&����� � ���Z���� ��� ������ ����y� ��� ���� ���*HI#F!5&>� �4&>E,&O�0�4&.�5����H����F& #F��HI#FC>&>H0&>D4�M�$- � #%� ���5� E,��� �4& �5D ������� #FL>#F���5#�H����F#F!5&(�B� C>@5# 1 ��D E � �5D ������� #FL>#F���J���F&(�5��� &(@5�J�

� ��@$� ���F��?�#B� � ��!�&>� &>E,�5#F� ��� � � ) ��� � � & H����F#F!J� �$- �$- �.& @5�J� 1 ��D E �(�5D ������� #FL>#F���J���F&(���4� � CO#B�N� � & ) � � C/.5&(�5��� & @5�J�� ��@$� ���F��?�#B��/!�& �F�.��� &>�4� �"��C>CO��!5& ��&>D ��� � � ) ���"&���� ) � � � � - � & �5D �������4#FLO#F���$# ��� � ��� � � ) � � 9& ��� � � � ) ��� � � � ���$�.H����F#F!5& & @$�J�.�F��D � 1 ��D4E �(�$D ������� #FL>#F���J���F& & �4&OE,�$�F#FCO&>E,&>�0� & � C/.$&(�$��� & @5�J�.� ��@$�4���F��?�#B��G-

Page 135: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!|��� ���� ��-�/ � � ��� �2-�,�� ,�� , /��#.��� , � *�#%-�/�,��2!$#'/ ��� ,¿$6�HIR>6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=�����x�� �Z�V6�� �o�(x�� ���uS[ACJ>A�7NAPhC=N8!:<OQ6GJK?F626!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B=�n(opJId�:b?B?B=�]WSB6P]IH>:<?B= ��6 �M] � � �� ��x�� �Z�983=pfAySB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:s8cw>6C]C;MEB6kSB:�7\:�8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�:�8cwM6�J>ACJl83ACO&;T:<EF6~=@J�� �Txy� ���­]WAPhCJ>= �;�ºEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6HI= �lf62OQAWH>6G7N7@A&HI=Zxy���I�­nm¼�:s:<7N7@ACEF:sJ>APJ ` = f6�:<7\83RMJM:s:��ºEF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6~HI= �Q8cw>6sf6�O&AIHI6!7@7NAyH>=o�(xy���I�­];Z6GE~83R>= �QJMAPJ�f6OQAIHI6G7N7NA&HI=����$�¢xy� ���v6P]I=NJIaMJ>6C] � � � � ���$� x�� �Z�­n��W= ` 6kHI6=NOQOQ6!HI=\:b?c:<OQ6GJK?B6�8cw>6 ` :<7N6:<JT8cw>6�=@7 ` =\836 ` 6GEcSF:s6s_KR>=NJMHI=�¦

� � ���A�� �Z� � � ���$��y� �Z�opJ�O&AIHIA,:PJM:<7NAPhCAySB=£HI=NOQACS[?BEc:y8cw>6C¦

� � ���$�� �Z� � � ���$��y� �Z��e6�:PJM8cw>6P¦ � � �����Ay� �Z� � ���$��y� ���­© � � � ���A�� �Z� � � �o���� �Z�[��R>6kSU?F6�6k_CRM= ` :<7N6GJMjG6�7@AChP=\8cw>6�OQAKSU?FEF:PJ>A�8cw>6D: ` EF6GOQOQA�;ZA<?BR>?BA�=@JK?FEBAIHIR>EFEF6lJ>6!7~7@=NJ>hPRT:<hPhC=@A���X*R>JMASBAP7NA�HI6!=mHIR>6i_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?BACEB=^6QHI63aMJM=@EF6y7�X :<7@?BEFA��Y83APOQ6Q:<L>LM=N:PO&A ` =NS[?BA�:l;MEBAC;TAKS[=@?BA0HI6G=*8GAPJ>J>6G?[?F= ` =��­nU�I6: ` 6kSBSB=NO&A�SB8G6G7@?BA �¢: ` EF6GOQOQAl;ZA<?FRI?BAD;ZAPEFEF6 ���$�� �Z��8GAPOQ6&:PL>L>EF6 ` =\:<jG=NAPJM6&HI=[�����$��y� �Z��6P] ` =\836 ` 6GEcSB:M]SB6�: ` 6!SFS[=NOQA&SF836!7r?FA���: ` EF6GOQOQAy;ZA<?FRI?BAi;ZAPEFEF6����A�� �Z�~8GAPOQ6�:<L>LMEB6 ` =\:<j!=@ACJ>6�HI=�� ���$��y� ���­n

� ���� �@��� � � � ,�+�,(��- , � ,�� ,�� ,¿$6�HIR>6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=���� ���l6�� ����]C8GAPOQ6�;>RMEB67@6�HIR>6;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM= ��� ����6�������]KSBAPJ>A�7@AChP=\8G:<OQ6!JC?F66!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B=�n&opJId�:b?B?B=�] H>:<?B=*R>J�HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA � 6QR>JM: �DSBR �D]£;T6!E�?BRI?B?B6i6i_KRM:b?B?BEFA�7N6Q;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=(SB=\:<OQAEF=N8GAPJMHIAP?[?F=(:08GAPJMSB=NH>6GEc:<EF6�=N7m83APOQ;ZAPEB?F:PO&6!JK?BA�H>6G7N7@6i:��ºEF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>= EB=\SB;T6G?[?BAD:P7@7\:l;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6&½*:�e6sSB={;>R fA,SF836!hP7N=@6!EB6�:&;T6!E26GJK?FEF:PO�LZ6�=NJ083=\:PSF83R>JM:Q8GAP;>;>=\:C�3n �R>=@JTHI=Y¦� � � � � ���DSB6�6�S[AC7@AiSB6 � � � � ���

� � � ��� ���.SB6�6�S[AC7@AiSB6 � � � �����

x2JT8cw>6�_CRM6!S[?BAiEF=NSBR>7@?F:b?FAiS[={;>R^fAQd�:P83=N7NO&6!JK?B6�hP6!J>6GEc:<7N=NjGj!:PEB6Cn opJK?FR>=r?F= ` :PO&6!JK?B6sSB=$;>R fAiHI=NEB6s8cwM6�=N7$J>ACOQ6HI=$RMJM: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N6 ` =NJM8GAP7\:b?F:yJ>ACJ�f6�=NOQ;TACE[?c:<JK?B6Cn[�WAPJ>AQ7NAPhC=N8!:<OQ6GJK?B6�6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B=�¦� �������� �� � ��� ����£� ���� � ����M��������� ��� �£�83ACOQ6�;MR>EB6C¦� � ���l� ��� ���£� �� ��Q� ��� ���M����� ����� �� ����6�:<JM8cwM6P¦���^� ����� � � ���Z�­� ��{� ��Q� ��� ���W�­� ���T� ���y� �� ��>�­�&6s83ACSpf � ` =N: � �PnmopJ0hP6!J>6GEc:<7N6P]>SB6��� �Z��f6�R>JT:

^3ª�^^: ` 6GJK?B6��l8GAPOQ6 ` :<EF=N:PL>=@7N6u7@=NLZ6GEc:�6u�� >�vf6~7\:6^3ª�^*8cwM6uSB=>AP?[?B=N6GJM6�S[AKSU?F=r?FR>6GJTHIA�APhPJM=IAW8!83ACEBEF6GJ>jk:�7N=NLT6!EF:�HI=�083APJ �]ISB=THI=\836�8cw>6ey� �Z�96��� >�VS[ACJ>A�SB=@OQ=N7@={SB626SBAP7NA�SB6��� >�mwM:sAW8!83ACEBEF6GJ>j!6~7@=NLZ6GEF6HI= �Q6!SF:b?B?F:<OQ6!JC?F6J>6!hP7N=$SU?F6!SFS[={;ZACS[?B={=NJ�8GR>=��0wM:&AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG67@=NLT6!EB6�=NJ_�� ���­nV¡VL>LZ6GJ>6C]>S[={;>R^fAQH>=@OQACS[?BEc:<EF6d�:P83=N7NO&6!JK?B6�8cw>6P¦

�%#uy� �Z���� >�2�%��!o�h�05+.U5+345Ffv§�3+3���,B§ � � ���Ay� �Z� � � &���� >�� � ���A�� �Z� � ��&���� I�

opJId�:<?[?B=�]�H>:<7N7�X =N;TAP?B6kS[=sHI6!7@7\:gS[=NOQ=@7N=r?FRMHI=NJ>6¢HI=�y� �Z�D6�y� >�­]�SB6GhCR>6�8cwM6P]�;T6!E ` 6!H>6GEF6�SB6�R>JM:g=@JK?F6GE-�;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6 � f6�O&AIHI6!7@7NA H>=����A�� �Z�3] � Ty� >�­] ���$�� �Z�­]���T�� >�,SB=yf6�EB=\83ACJMHIA<?B?B=�:<7N7YX :<JM:P7@=\SB=HI6!7@7N6�:"�EF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>=>H>= �sEF=\S[;Z63?B?BAs:<7N7\:�SU?F6!SFSB:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6 ����I�2��H>A ` 62:Qf6~R>JT:�83ACS[?F:PJK?B628cw>6~J>ACJiAI8G83ACEBEF6J>6!7@7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=\�3n � � �B�,CO��� �,� #3����� D4& � ��& 1��C>#F�FE,&>�0� & &>�4�4&>�5!5&>D &,���$C/.5&"���3CO��� �<!5# ����� CO��� H���D #B���5#F�F#��F#���&>D & =��! &>� &>E,�5#F� ! � � ��� & � � � �

� ���$�"�F��?�#FCO��E,&O�0�4& &OK @5# H����F&O�0�4#-

Page 136: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!| À

Page 137: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

� ����� ������ �

�¤� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��� � �»� � � � ����������

� �! "$#&%('*),+.-0/213)&#04opJ�_CRM6!S[?BAD8G:P;>=r?FAP7NA�6kSU?F6GJMH>=N:PO&A�=N7*O&6G?BAIHIADHI6!hP7N=m:<7NLT6!EB=mSB6GOi:<JK?F=N8G=^;Z6GE�?FEF:<?[?c:<EF6y7\: ` :P7@=\HI=@?¾f:M]$7N:�SBAWHMHI= �S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@=@?¾f:�6l7\:�8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJ>jk:07@AChP=\8G:DJM6G7N7YX :<OyL>=r?FA�HI6!7@7\:.7NAPhC=N8!:.HI6G=v;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=�n�op7vOQ63?BAIHIA�S[=u:<;M;>7@=\8G:�:;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=V�i^3ª�^28cwM=@RMSB6k�26ySB= HI=@t�6GEF6GJ>j!=N:,HM:l_KR>6G7N7NA,=@JK?FEBAIHIAP?[?BAlJ>6G7N7N:,;>EB=NOi:i;M:PE[?F6s;T6!E7\:i;>EF6!SB6GJMj!:,HI=_KRM:b?B?BEFAiJWR>A ` 6�EF6GhCAP7N6�EB6!7N:<?B= ` 6s:<7N7N6�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=£_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?B6Cn~¿mX =NHI6k:,HI=£deAPJMHIAlEB=NOi:<J>6�7\:,S[?B6!SFSF:>¦V;Z6GE` 6!EB=@aT8!:<EF62S[6R>JM:�HM:b?F:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6u f6 ` :<7N=NH>:yS[=�836!EF8!:sHI=�83AKSU?FEBR>=NEF62R>J�8GAPJK?BEFAW6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]CACSFS[=\:sHI=Z=@JTHI= �` =NH>RM:<EF6RMJ�HIACOQ=@J>=NAQ6�HI63aMJM=@EF6RMJM:&=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6�EB=\S[;Z63?B?BAQ:<7N7N:&_KRM:<7N62 EB=\S[RM7r?c:sd�:P7NSF:>]>S ` =@7NR>;>;M:PJMHIAT]83ACOQ6sJ>6G7^8G:CS[AQ;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P]MR>J.:<7NLT6!EBA,: ` 6GJK?B6�� � �*:<7N7N:QEc:PH>=N8G6Pnvop7£;>EFAI836!H>=@OQ6GJK?FAiEB=\S[RM7r?c:i;>=[fR.:<EB?B=i�83AC7N:<?BA,:,8!:<RMSF:iHI6!7@7\:QOi:<hPhC=@ACEB6�EF=N8!8cw>6Gj!j!:iHI6!7£7N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NAh��XZEB=\SB;T6G?[?BA�:<7$7N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NAh�n~5�6G7(8G:PSBAiHI6G7N7\:7NAPhP=\8G:s;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P]P;Z6GE ` 6kHI6GEF6�SB6�R>JT:�H>:<?F:�de;.f6�AyJ>APJ.f62R>JM:s?F:<R>?BAP7NAPhC=N:M]CLT:PS[?F:s8GACS[?BEFR>=@EF627\:�?c: ` AP7\:HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:>n^op7$OQ63?FAWH>AQH>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�f6�R>J0;>EFAW8G6!HI=NOQ6GJK?BAi:P7r?F6GEFJM:b?F= ` A�EF=NSB;T6G?[?FAQ:P7@7\:Q83AKSU?FEBR>j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7N7YX =NJC?F6GEc:?F: ` AP7\:�HI= ` 6GEF=r?bf:>n*526!7$8G:PSBAyH>6G7N7N:y7@AChP=\8G:yHI6G={;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?B=�]W=@J ` 6!836C]W7N:&HI63aTJ>=@j!=@ACJ>6�HI= ` :<7N=NH>=r?bf:yHI={RMJM:�;MEBAC;TA��SB=@j!=@ACJ>62 JMAPJ�=$JMHI=\8G:&R>J0;>EFAI836!H>=@OQ6GJK?FAy;>Ec:b?F=N8!:<OQ6GJK?F6�;Z6GEc83ACEBEF=NL>=@7N6P¦(SB=$HIA ` EB6!L>LT6�83ACJK?BEFAP7N7N:PEB6�8cw>6�x f6` 6!EF:�8GAPO�RMJM_KR>6�SF836G7@?BA�RMJi=@JMSB=N6GOQ62J>ACJ ` R>AP?BAs8GAPOQ6�HIACO&=NJ>=NA �»6�83ACO�R>JT_CRM62SB8G6G7@?F:�R>JM:s=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@A��J>6 �ySBR �Dn � RI?[?c: ` =N:M]C=Z;TAKSBSB=NL>=@7N=�HIAPOQ=NJ>=�6�7N6�EF6G7\:b?B= ` 6�=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>=TSBAPJMAs=@JlJKRMO&6!EBA�=@JIaTJ>=r?FAy6J>APJ.f6;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6�;M:CSBSF:<EF7N={=@JDEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:y?FRI?[?F=Yn��9=pfAiJ>APJ ` R>AC7£HI=NEB6s8cw>6�J>APJDSB=£;ZACSFSB:Q=NJD:<7\83R>JDOQAIHIA,S[?F:<LM=@7N=@EF6sSB6R>JM:,;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6&f6sA,J>ACJ�f6 ` :<7N=NH>:M¦9JM6G7N7N:i;T:<EB?B6�aMJT:<7N6�HI6G7^8G:P;>=r?FAP7NAi;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�:<L>LM=N:PO&A,H>=@OQACS[?BEc:b?FA7\: ` :<7N=NH>=r?bf:�HI= ` :<EF=N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=u�e6QHI=q^3ª�^[��6QHI=*:<7\83R>J>=*SF8cw>6GOQ=*HI=(;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=�]TRI?F=@7N=NjGj!:PJMHIA�;T6!E¾fA�HI6G=Ec:<hP=NAPJT:<OQ6GJK?B=9HI= ` 6GEcS[=9:.S[6k83ACJMH>:.HI6!7@7N6�8G=@Ec83AKSU?c:<J>j!6Pn0op7vO&6G?BAIHIA�H>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�83ACS[?B=@?BRM=NSF836,=NJ ` 6k836P]*8GAPOQ6` 6kHIEF6GOQAM](R>J¢;MEBAI836kHI=NO&6!JK?BA.OQ6!8!8G:PJ>=N8GA�:P;>;>7N=N8!:<L>=N7@6�83APJ¹hP6GJM6GEc:<7N=r?bf:>n�¡9SBSBADJ>APJ¹;>EB6kS[6!JK?F:DJ>A ` =@?¾f:D;Z6GE_KRM:<JK?FA&EF=NhPRM:PEFH>:&=N7{?BEc:b?B?F:PO&6!JK?BA,HI6!7@7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=$8cw>6�wM:PJ>J>Ai7\:&deAPEFOQ:QHI= J>6GhK:<j!=@ACJ>6P]>8GAPJ>hC=@R>JMjG=NAPJ>6C]HI=\S[hC=@RMJ>jG=NAPJ>6y6y8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P©�=@7(EFR>AP7NA�H>6G7N7@6y7@6G?[?B6!EB6&;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N= ` =N6GJ>6yAPEc:,S ` AP7@?BA�H>:<7N7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@A��J>=m:<?BAPOQ=\8cw>6D� � �Z] � b] � � b] � � �T]@nNn@n �­] J>6G7mSB6GJTS[A08cw>6i_KRM:<JMH>A�=NJ�R>J�JMAWH>A08GAPOQ;M:PEB6&R>JM:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6:b?FAPOQ=\8G:l:CHD6!SFSBA,J>APJ�;>R fA�6!SFS[6!EB6&:<;>;>7N=\8G:b?c:,:<7\83RMJM:,EF6GhCAP7\:>n f¡ _KR>=@JTHI=*S[R��,8G=@6!JC?F6y=NJK?BEFAIHIR>EFEB6s7N6�JWR>A ` 6EF6GhPAC7@6�;Z6GE?BEc:b?B?F:PEB6s7N6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>= _CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?B6Cn¡VH�f6�_KR>=^8cwM6�S[=^EF6GhP=\S[?BEc:QR>JM:��"5 �e#%,-#W!TYk§(#0�1�%#W!TY%5�§�3i#83ACJ�_KRM:<JK?FA�:P8!8G:CHI6sJ>6!7@7\:,7NAPhC=N8!:i;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6Pn2opJ�_KR>6!S[?!X R>7@?B=NOQ:M]{_CRT:<JMHIA�S[=^6!SF:<OQ=NJM:,RMJ�J>AIHIA�83APJ&�?B6!J>6GJK?F6�RMJM:.de; SB6GhPJT:b?F:�:<;>;M7@=\8G:PJMHIA�7\:�EB6!7N:<?B= ` :�EB6!hPAC7N:M]*=@7~J>AIHIA ` =@6!J>6083APJK?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:b?FAD6�J>ACJ f6�;>=[fRJ>6k836!SFSF:<EF=@A�;>EB6!JMHI6!EB7NA�HI=~JWR>A ` A�=NJ 83APJTS[=\HI6GEc:<j!=@ACJ>6Pn¢½(AC=N8cwu®6,=~J>AIHI=28GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJ>jk:�8GAPJK?B6!J>hPACJ>A.de; ;>=[fRSB6GOQ;>7N=N8G=Y]MH>R>EF:PJK?B6�=@7$;MEBAI836kHI=NO&6!JK?BAiS[=$H>6 ` ACJ>A&6!SF:<OQ=@JT:<EF6�de;DSB6GhPJT:b?B6 ` =\: ` =\:y;M=[fR0L>EF6 ` ={6�S[=$aMJ>=\SB8G6�;Z6GE;Z6GE ` 6GJM=@EF6�:sJMAWH>=�8GAPJK?B6!J>6GJK?F=ZSBAP7NA�7N63?B?B6GEF6�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM:P7@=�n(¡mL>LZ6GJ>6C]WJ>6G7�8G:CS[A�H>6G7N7N:y7@AChP=\8G:sH>6G=Z;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F=Y]��5e�%��!o��!$����5�«cnX#_!$�"!���#%!�r���!$�q«1�"!X\�,B§k�1�%#sr"!�§�\�5�]*ACSFS[=\:�8cw>6 ` :<J>J>A�S[6!OQ;>EB6l?B6!JKR>?B=u;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=�]m:<JM8cwM6�SB6SBAPJ>A�hP=pf:�S[?F:<?B=*6kSB:PO&=NJM:<?B=�n�opJq:<7@?BEF6y;T:<EFAP7N6P]{;>R fADSBRM8G8G6!HI6!EB6Q8cw>6QS[=*=NJ>J>6kSU?F=mR>J�OQ6!8G8!:<J>=\SBO&A�=NJ�LM:CS[6Q:<7_KRM:<7N6~836!E[?F=>J>AIHI=MHI6 ` ACJ>A�6!SFS[6!EB6u;Z6GEF=@AIHI=\8G:PO&6!JK?B6uEB=N6!SF:<OQ=NJM:b?F=I6P]K_CRM=@JMH>=Y]K8cw>6~=@7M;>EBAI8G6!HI=NOQ6GJK?BA�J>ACJQ:PL>L>=\:?B6!EBOQ=NJ>6P]�AKSBSB=N:i8cwM6�7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAlSB=^S ` =@7NR>;>;>=(:<7N7�X =NJIaMJ>=@?BATn��9ACO&6 ` 6kHIEB6!OQAM]THM:b?F:,R>JM:,;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6yxs]�S[6Uf69�¾§"345��P§<]^:P7@7NAPEc:i7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA0S[6!OQ:PJK?B=\83A�;T6!E � � �9SB=*8cw>=NRMHI6D��8GAPOQ6QJ>6G7*8G:CS[A�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6k�26&_KR>=NJMHI=*wT:R>J>A0S ` =N7NR>;>;ZA08cwM6yEF=N8cwM=@6kHI6�R>J�JWR>OQ6GEFAlaTJ>=r?FA�H>=*;M:PSFS[=�n � RI?[?c: ` =\:>]$SB6h JMAPJ¹f6 ` :<7N=NHM:>]$:<7N7NAPEc:,7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAJ>ACJlS[={8cw>=NRMHI6C]W6SB=ZwT:<J>J>A&HIR>6�8G:PSB=�¦^:K�V:CHiR>J�8G6GEB?BA&SU?c:PHI=NAs7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAlf6�?B6!EBOQ=NJM:b?FAM]KACSFS[=\:�J>6kSBSBR>JM:�EB6!hPAP7\:

}!| Á

Page 138: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!| �;>EFAIHIRM836�JWR>A ` ={J>AIHI=�]>AC;>;>R>EF6�LT�u7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA ` :i: ` :PJC?F=$:<7N7YX =NJIaMJ>=@?BATn ��X :<7@?BEc:Q;M:PE[?F6P]>:<JT8cw>6sS[6�=NJDOQAP7@?B=£8!:PSB=f6ld�:P83=N7N6�EF6GJMH>6GEcS[=v83APJK?FA�8cw>60S[=uEF6!:P7@=NjGjk:D=@7~8!:PSBA�LT�3]mACSFS[=\:�8cwM6l7NA�S ` =@7NR>;>;ZA�HI6!7@7�X :<7NLT6!EBA�J>APJ : ` Ebf:DOi:<=?B6!EBOQ=NJ>6P]KJ>ACJ0f62;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@62EF=\83APJMACSF836GEF7NA�=NJ,hC6GJ>6!EF:P7@6Cn£opJl:P7r?FEB=M?B6GEFOQ=@JM=Y]WS[6SU?F=N:PO&AyS ` =N7@R>;M;M:<JMH>AsR>Jl:P7@LZ6GEFA;Z6GE�� � ��m6P]£:�R>J�836!E[?FA�S[?F:CHI=@AT]$7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAlJ>ACJ f6yJu®6&8cw>=NRMSBAM]{Ju®6�?F6GEFO&=NJM:<?BAM]{JMAPJ�;ZACSFSB=N:PO&A0HI6k83=\HI6GEF6&SB6P]83ACJK?B=NJKRT:<JMHIA�7@A�S ` =N7@R>;M;TAT]*7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�S[=u8cw>=NRMHI6GEbf:>]*A.?B6GEFOQ=@JM6GEbf:�:PH¢R>J>A�S[?F:CHI=NA�S[RT8G836kSBSB= ` AM](A�SB6�:PJMHIEbf:: ` :<JK?B=^:<7N7YX =NJIaMJ>=@?BAT]T6C]Z_KR>=NJMHI=�]TJMAPJ.;ZACSFS[=\:<OQA,HI6k83=\HI6GEF6�SB6S f6�A,J>APJqf6 ` :<7N=NH>:Mn �R>6!S[?BAl=@JM8GAPJ ` 6!J>=N6GJK?B6C]83ACO�R>JT_CRM6P]£JMAPJ f6i=@OQ;>R>?F:<LM=@7N6,:<7mOQ6G?BAIHIA.HI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFADS[6!Oi:<JK?B=\83AT]£Oi:�f6QR>JM:07N=@OQ=@?F:<j!=@ACJ>6,HI=V_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=;>EFAI836!H>=@OQ6GJK?FA�OQ6k8G8G:PJ>=\83A�;T6!ElSBA<?[?FAP;ZAPEFEB60: ` 6!EB=@aT8G:�7\: ` :P7@=\HI=@?¾f:qHI6!7@7N6D;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=2HI6!7@7\:�7@AChP=\8G:�HI6G=;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=�n>��J,=NO&;ZAPEB?F:PJK?B6~?F6GAPEF6GOi:sH>={�9wWR>Ec8cwiHI6G7^} � | À HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:�8cw>62J>ACJi6!SB=NS[?B6�:<7\83R>Ji;>EFAI836kHI=@OQ6!JC?FAOQ6!8!8G:<JM=N8GA�8cwM6u8GAPJMSB6GJK?F62HI=MS[?F:<LM=@7N=@EF6u=@JQR>JQJWR>OQ6GEFA�aMJ>=@?BAsHI=M;M:PSFS[=>SB6~R>JM:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6uHI6!7@7\:�7@AChP=\8G:�HI6G=;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=�HI6G7Z;>EF=@OQAyAPEcHI=@JM6�f6�AyJ>APJDf6 ` :<7N=NHM:>¦�3@§U3i�cr"5�«c§]�;#W5A*$,c#c�"5�«c§�\�5�;#W3�*o,05+.h�/�",-��5+!o#JQ#�5+!o��#c«%5���5�ª%5+3i# ` nop7(OQ63?BAIHIA0HI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA0S[6!OQ:PJK?B=\83A�SB=(LM:PSF:lSBR>7N7N:�EF=N8G6GEc8G:,HI6!7*83APJK?FEBAW6!SB6GOQ;>=NAMn��W=mSBR>;>;ZAPJM6&8cw>6h ;TAKSBSF:6!SFSB6GEF6ud�:<7\SB:,�YS[=T;TACJ>6:P7@7\:�Ec:PHI=\836�� � �e�*6C]KSB627�X :P7@LZ6GEFAsS[=�8cw>=NRMHI6C]KSB=M;>R^fA�83ACJM837NRMHI6!EB628cw>62?F:<7N6�EF=\836GEc8G:�J>ACJ;>R fAy: ` 6GEF6~6!SB=@?BAs6C]K_KR>=NJMHI=�]K8cwM627N:s;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6�f6 ` :<7N=NH>:Mn��W627�X :P7@LZ6GEFAsJ>ACJ,S[=Z8cw>=@RTHI6�SB=Z8GACS[?BEFR>=NSF836C]C8GAPOQ6: `W` =@6!J>69JM6G7M8!:PSBA;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6C]kRMJQ8GAPJK?BEFAW6!SB6GOQ;>=NA8cw>6u=N7@7NRMS[?BEc:�83APOQ6u7\:JMACS[?BEc:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6� ;TAKSBSF:EF=NSBR>7@?F:<EF6ud�:<7\SF:>n��2Jl8GAPJK?BEFAW6!SB6GOQ;>=NA�J>6G7N7N:s7@AChP=\8G:sHI6!=M;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?B=ZHI6 ` 626!SFSB6GEF6283ACS[?B=@?BRM=r?FAyH>:�RMJlHIAPOQ=NJ>=NA �6HM:�R>JM:�=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6 �&S[R ���eEF=NSB;T6G?[?FA�:<=�_KRM:<7N=Y]W:<;M;>R>JK?BAT]� S[=\:�d�:<7\SF:C�­n*¡VL>LT6!J>6P]K7�X =\HI6!:yHI=TdeAPJMHIA,f6_KR>6G7N7\:HI=IR>?B=N7@=NjGjk:<EF697N6v8GACS[?F:PJC?F=IHI6G7I7N=@JMhPRM:PhPhP=NAu��X¾;T6!Em83ACS[?BEFR>=NEB6 �D¦£=N7>HIACO&=NJ>=NA � f69deAPEFOQ:<?BARI?B=N7@=NjGjk:<JMH>A7N6u8GACS[?F:PJC?F=W6v7�X =@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6u8cw>6v:CSBSBAI83=\::�83=\:PSF83RMJM:8GACS[?F:PJC?F6���=@JK?F6!SF:�8GAPOQ6v6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BA�HI6!7I7@=NJ>hCRM:<hChP=NAK�7\:&8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�S[?B6kSBSF:��e=NJC?F6!SF:Q83APOQ6�6G7N6GOQ6!JC?FAiHI6G7£H>APOQ=@JM=@AW�­nV�9=£SB= ` =N6GJM6�:P7@7NAPEc:�:y?FEBA ` :<EF6�J>6G7N7N:ydeACE[?FR>JM:b?c:83=NEc83ACS[?F:PJ>j!:sJ>6G7N7N:y_KRM:<7N6�AChPJ>=Z6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FAyHI6!7�H>APOQ=@JM=@Alf68GAP=NJ ` AP7@?BA�HM:<7N7N:�=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>626�83=pfA�EF6GJMHI6�;>=[fRSB6GOQ;>7N=N8G6�7N:y?BEc:b?B?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI6G7N7N6�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=�_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?B6�R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7NOQ6GJK?B6�6�6!SB=NS[?B6!J>jG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6 � n

� �­¯ "$´g·¸4u%(),+D) +D4´G´��[³s´���42'*)�¶^4�·¸³s#&%*13±~)½(6GE�;>EF6!SB6GJK?F:PEB6�=@7(OQ63?FAWH>A�HI6!7@7�X :<7NLT6!EBA�S[6!OQ:PJK?B=\83Al;Z6GE�7\:l7NAPhC=N8!:,HI6!=^;MEB6kHI=N8!:b?F=(H>6G7(;>EF=@OQAlACEFH>=@J>6C]$H>:b?FA8cw>6&83APJK?F=@JWR>=\:<OQA�:CH.:P8!836G?[?F:PEB6�7@6&EB6!hPAC7@6s;Z6GE�7N6yJ>6!hC:PjG=NAPJ>=�]Z8GAPJ>hC=@RMJ>jG=NAPJ>=�]�HI=NSBhP=NR>J>j!=@ACJ>=(6y8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N=LM:CSU?c:y=NJK?BEFAIHIR>EFEB6�7@6�EF6GhCAP7N6;Z6GEu?FEF:<?[?c:<EF6�=£J>AIHI=$8cw>6s83ACJK?B6GJMhPAPJMAy;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>={_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?F6Pn1�8��$@A|�89x[8�L�=�|��q�DN&<$9�=�: :�N 9�@XL�8 �D<>=�M$8�Lk��N&|�8��:K� �~6GhCAP7\:�;Z6GEe�+� � �Ay� ���/�

�W6�SB=£6kSB:POQ=@JM:QRMJ.J>AIHIAlHI6!7$?F=@;ZA��$� ���A�� �Z���º]�SB=£;>EFAP7NR>J>hK:<J>AQ=^EF:PO&= :<;Z6GEB?B= 8cwM6s7@A�83APJK?F6GJ>hCAPJ>Ai83ACJ=$J>AIHI=��+� ����I���^;Z6GEu?FRI?[?F6s7@6s8GACS[?F:PJC?F= �l8cwM6aThPR>Ec:<J>AQ=NJD83=\:PSF83R>J0Ec:<OQA���6�8cw>6�SBAPJ>AiSB6GOQ;>EF6�=@J0JWR>OQ6GEFAaMJ>=@?BAW�­¦

�+� ����I����+� � �$�� ���/�

;Z6GE~?FRI?[?F6�7@6s8GACS[?F:PJC?F= �,8cw>6�aMhCR>Ec:<J>A&J>6G7£EF:PO&A�03q!o�b�;�]!o��!���5�#%!$#Q«1��!X\�,B§��c�%#sr�!Z§�\m��t¿£:,hP=NRMSU?F=raZ8G:<j!=@ACJ>6�=NJC?FR>=@?B= ` :�HI=(_CRM6!S[?F:iEF6GhCAP7\:�f6�7N:�S[6!hPR>6!JK?B6Pne�I6if6 ` 6GEc:QR>JM:,;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6s_KRM:PJK?B=i�aT8!:b?F:QRMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@OQ6!JC?F6P]>HI6 ` ACJ>Ai6!SFS[6!EB6 ` 6GEF=�?BRI?B?B=^=£S[RMAP=£8!:PSB=$;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB=�]IACSFSB=N:Q_KR>6G7N7N= 8cw>6sSB=$A<?B?B6!J>hPACJ>A

� �9# @(#F�(!$&>��� ��?��F#F� 3#F�I�5D4�IC>&>!5#FE,&>�0� �=!5&>�F��� ������&>D4� � &>E ���0� #FC>�=&���� � D4#$���5���F��?".5#5!J���5�$� @5�J� D4#F� �����4� � #F� @5�(� @5E,&>D � �5�5# � �=!5#�J���4� #�� &=�B�(�5D4������� #FL>#F���5& � &=H����F#F!5� !$E � ����� �4���5� �$��� !J��D4& D4#F� �����4� � � & � �5��� & H����F#F!J�$- (����4&O��D4&>E �(!5#��&. @5D C/. !5#FE,����� D ��5D4���5D #F� C0.5&=�$���,�5@� � &>� #F�4�4&>D & @5�"�$D � CO&>!5#FE,&>�0� � E,&>C>CO���5#FC>� C/.5& !5#B� @5�J� D #F�4�����4� � #F�"@5�"� @5E,&>D � �5�5# � � !$#J�J��� �4#JKI@J���$!5�(��5��� & H����F#F!J� �� & &>� #F��� &>� �4&"!5���5�$�F#FC ���$!5� �4#FE.@5� � ���5&O��E,&>� �4&=��! � � #B� �M���F&=�5D � C>&>!5#FE,&>� �4� !$�4#B� KI@5&>�F�F� !5&>�F��� ������&>D � � &>E ���0� #FC>� !!J�N�4� C/.5&<� &,H����F#F!5��� �5��� �F� &"!��5D #FE �<� ����##!3C>��E @5�5K @5& #F� @5� � @5E,&>D � �5�5# � � !5#9�J��� �4##!*@$�5� !5&>#�!5@5& �5D4�IC>&>!5#FE,&>� �4#?�#F@5�5?�&>D4& � ��& ����� &>D4E,#F�5&.& ���F�F��D �<�����4D &>E,E,� !$&OC>#F!5&>D4&,� & � &,� �5���� &.H����F#F!J�$- (��7��� � D4#��4&>D E,#F�5##!2��� �5#B��E,� @5� �4&>�4�(C/.5&1 @5�5L>#F���J�.�4& �B� �5D4������� #FL>#F���5& & H����F#F!5� !5E � �5������� �$#B��E,���*& ��&OD #F��� &>��D &>E �(!5#%�&. @5D C/. �5���<�����4� #B��E,�.�OH0&>D & ��#F���4&>�4� C/.5&1 @5�5L>#F���J�"� & �B� �5D ������� #FL>#F���5& �5��� & H����F#F!J�$- �I#2!5#FC>&(���5C/.$&(C0.5& � �)� �7�!+���1 ���! :2���� �!#������!'�&��>��!# �����!# �!��9!#� ��!J��&>D=�4���4�4���F#F�5&O��D &C/.5& ��� �5#B��E,�"@5�<� &>�4� E,&>C>CO���5#FC>�"C/.5& 1 @5�5L>#F���J�.��&>D=E,&G�� � !5���4� #B� �$&O�2C ���4�"#F�<CO@$#%� &=H����F#F!J�$- �I& #F��!$��E,#F�5#F� & 1�N��� �.!5#2C>���4� ���0� #�& ��?��5#�C>���4� ��� �4& & #F�0� &>D �$D &G�M�N� �"� @<� & �4�4&O�4�M� !$@5�J�.�5D4������� #FL>#F���5& !5&>���4#F��� ��� � � � &H0&>DM�.#F� �.�4& & � ���F� � &"!5��&>D ��?��5# �,#F� �2!$� � � & H0&>DM�(#F� � !$& @5�J� �$D ������� #FL>#F���5& !5&>�2�4#F��� ��� � � � & H0&>DM�(#F� �.�4& & � ���F� � &&>� #F��� & ���FE,&>�5� @5�J�.C>���4� ���0� &��,#F� � � ���F& C/.5& � � � & H0&OD �.#F� �

Page 139: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}!| �_KRM:<JTHIAi7N: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N6Qf6�SBACS[?B=@?BR>=@?F:iHM:iR>JM:,8GACS[?F:PJC?F6Pnu�W=^8G:<;M=NSF836�:PJM8cw>6�;Z6GEc8cwu®6�=N7£J>AIHIAlJ>APJ ` :,8GAPJK?BEc:PS �SB6GhPJT:b?BATne�W6�JM6G7^EF:PO&A ` 6GJMhPAPJMAi=@JK?BEFAIHIA<?B?B6y=@J�SB6GhCR>=@?BA,JWR>A ` 6s83ACS[?F:PJK?B=�]ZSB6,f6 ` 6GEFAl8cw>6s;Z6GE�APhCJ>=�� ` :<7N6�� �Z�3]A�� �Z�uHIA ` Ebf: ` :<7N6GEF6�:<JM8cw>6�EF=NSB;Z63?[?FA&:Q_KR>6kSU?F6�JWR>A ` 6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F=Yn�W=$;MR fA&_KR>=NJMHI= ` 6GEF=@aT8G:PEB6=@7$8!:PSBAy=NJ83RM=$=@7£J>AIHIAiHI6GL>LT:y6kSBSB6GEF6�EB=N6!SF:<OQ=NJM:b?FAMn �R>6!S[?F:&EF6GhCAP7\:�EF=N8cwM=@6kHI6RMJM:i837\:<RMSBAP7\:&:<hPhC=@RMJC?F= ` :M¦

� |�N&�>��@A|�N��i_CRT:<7NAPEc:�JM6G7VEc:<OQA0J>ACJ�aThPR>EF=V:<7\83RMJM:D83AKSU?c:<JK?B6C] :<7N7NAPEc:�SB=V=NJK?BEFAIHIRM836i=N7VJMAWH>A(�+� ����I���º]HIA ` 6�:�f6�R>JM:i8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB= �bn�eLZ� �~6GhCAP7\:�;Z6GE�� � � �$�� ���/��W6&S[=^6!SF:<OQ=NJM:,R>J�J>AIHIA�H>6G7 ?B=N;TA� � ���A�� �Z���º]{SB=(;>EBAC7@RMJ>hC:iAChPJ>= EF:POQA�8cw>6y7@A�83APJK?F=@6!J>6y8GAPJ.=N7 JMAWH>A

� � y���I�/�p]MH>A ` 6�:�f6�RMJM:Q83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�8cw>6�J>APJ�aMhCR>Ec:�J>6!7$Ec:<OQAM¦

� � y���I�/�� � ���Ay� �Z�����

HIA ` 6 �Df6�R>JM:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�8cw>6�J>ACJ�aThPR>Ec:�JM6G7$Ec:<OQA�03q!o�b�;�]��5�#%!$#&«c�"!X\�,B§k�1�%#sr"!�§�\m��t¿£:uhC=@RTSU?F=raT8!:<j!=@ACJ>6*=@JK?FR>=r?F= ` :�f6m7N:~SB6GhCR>6GJK?F6Pn>�I6m7N:2;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6^RMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@OQ6!JC?F6m_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?F:����Ay� �Z�f69d�:<7\SB:M] ` =MHI6 ` 6u6!SFS[6!EB6u:<7NOQ6GJ>A�R>J&=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>AsH>6G7>HIACO&=NJ>=NA�;T6!Em83R>=MJ>APJ ` :<7N6v7\:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:��� �Z�­©W;ZAP=\8cwu®6v=@7HIACO&=NJ>=NAyf6983AKSU?F=r?FR>=@?BA�H>:<7N7@6u83AKSU?c:<JK?B=�]<SB=K=NJK?BEFAIHIRM836vR>JM:�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6vEF6G7\:b?B= ` :<OQ6GJK?F69:<7N7\:_KRM:P7@6uS[=W=NOQ;TACJ>6v8cwM67\:i;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:h�� �Z�S[=\:&d�:<7\SF:>n��9APOQ6sSB= ` 6kHIEbf:QJ>6GhC7@= 6!SB6GOQ;>=�]M7\:iEB=\8cw>=N6!S[?F:i8cw>6�7N:i8GACS[?F:<JK?F6sS[=\:iJWR>A ` :QJ>6G7Ec:<OQA,f6�H>A ` R>?F:s:P7Md�:<?[?BAQ8cw>6C]CEF=NSB;Z63?[?FAy:P7@7N68GACS[?F:<JK?F=MhP=pf:s;MEB6kS[6!JC?F=M=NJl6kSBSBAM]C=@7�Ec:<OQA�deAPEFJ>=\SB8G62=NJIdeAPEFOi:<jG=NAPJM=8cw>6,;ZACSFSBAPJ>A.6kSBSB6GEF6i=NJM83ACO&;T:b?B=NL>=N7@=u83ACJq=@7vJ>ACJq;TAKSBSB6!HI6!EB6l7N:D;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:(�� �Z�­n�¿£:D;MEB6kS[6!J>j!:.H>6G7VJMAWH>A

� � y���I�/�V:CSBSB=\83R>Ec:,8cw>6y=@7(J>AIHIA� � � �$�� �Z�/�VSB=\:lSBAWHMHI=NS[d�:b?B?BA�=@JMH>=@;Z6GJMH>6GJK?B6!O&6!JK?B6iH>:<=(SBRM8G8G6!SFS[= ` =^S ` =@7NR>;>;>=HI6!7PEc:<OQAu6P]b_KR>=@JTHI=Y]b8cw>6*6kSBSBA2SB=P;ZACSFSB:~8GAPJK?BEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:PEB6v�eJ>ACJQf6*;>=[fR�J>6!8G6!SFSB:PEB=NAvEB=N6!SF:<OQ=NJM:<EF7@AW�­n ��SFS[6!E ` =\:<OQA=NJ>AP7@?BEF6v8cwM6v7�X 6!SF:<OQ6vH>=IR>JyJMAWH>A�HI=>_KR>6kSU?FA�?F=@;ZA�83ACO&;ZAPEB?F:7\:8GAPOQ;M:<EcSF:2J>6!7IEF:PO&A�HI=IR>JM:JWR>A ` :8GACS[?F:PJC?F66P]T_CRM=@JMH>=Y]ZS[=£8!:<;>=\SF836s83ACOQ6�SB=\:Q6 ` 6!JK?BRM:P7@OQ6GJK?F6�JM6!836kSBSF:<EF=NA&EF=N6!SF:<OQ=@JT:<EF6=$JMAWH>= HI6!7{?B=N;TA��+� � �Ay� ���/� ;Z6GESBAWHMHI=NS[d�:<EF7N=$83APJ�7N6�JKRMA ` 6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=$8cw>6�;>R fAi8!:<;>=@?F:PEB6�HI=£: ` 6GE~HIA ` RI?FAy=NJK?BEFAWH>R>EBEF6�83ACJ�_KR>6kSU?c:yEF6GhCAP7\:>n1�8��$@A|�89x[8�L�=�|��q�DN&<$9�=�: :�N 9�@XL�8 8��b=�� 9�8�<>?�=�N&|�8¿$6uEF6GhCAP7N6V;Z6GE*=N7>_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB696!SB=NS[?B6!J>jG=\:<7N6vSB=I;ZACSFS[ACJ>AEF=\83APJTHIR>EFEB6C]k;Z6GEm_KRM:PJK?BA ` =\S[?BA�:<7I;>R>JK?FA��>n |Mn Á HI6G7�v:<;£n>�y]M:&_CRM6G7N7@6�HI6!7$_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB6�R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7N6Pn^opJId�:b?B?B=q�$� ���$�� �Z�/�(6!_KR>= ` :<7N6�:U�$� ���$���� �Z���U]I6�_KR>=NJMHI=: � � ���$���� �Z���U]vOQ6!JC?FEB6�� � ���Ay� �Z����6k_KR>= ` :P7@6.: � � �����$� ��� ���/�U]v6._KR>=@JTHI=: �+� � �o���� �Z�/�Un¤�9APO�RMJM_KR>6;>EF63de6!EB=\:<OQAydeAPEFO�R>7\:<EF7@6�6!SB;>7N=N8G=r?c:<OQ6GJK?F6�;T6!E~;TAP?B6GEF7N6s:<;>;>7N=\8G:<EF6�HI=@EF63?B?F:PO&6!JK?B6�J>6GhC7@=£6!SB6GOQ;>=�n��8k� �~6GhCAP7\:�;Z6GE �$� ���A�� �Z���

�W6�S[=�6!SF:<OQ=NJM:sRMJ,J>AIHIAQHI6G7Z?B=N;ZAj�$� ���$�� �Z�/�U]ISB=�;>EBAC7@RMJ>hC:�AChPJ>=ZEc:<OQA�:<;Z6GEB?BAy;M:PSFSF:<JK?B62;Z6GEu6kSBSBA�83ACJ=N7$J>AIHIAh�+� ����W���p]M83ACJ ��83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�8cw>6�J>APJ�aMhCR>EF:yJ>6!7$EF:POQA&6h5+3D!$�����h�05V«1��!A\�,F§k�1�%#�r�!Z§

�+� ����I�/��$� ���$�� �Z�/� �

HIA ` 6 �Df6�RMJM:Q83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�8cw>6�J>APJ�aMhCR>Ec:�J>6!7$Ec:<OQA��HT� �~6GhCAP7\:�;Z6GE�� � ���Ay� ���/��W6�S[=�6kSB:PO&=NJM:�R>J�JMAWH>AyHI6!7�?B=N;TA � � ���$�� �Z�/�U]>SB=�;>EFAP7NR>J>hC:�APhCJ>=TEc:<OQA&:<;Z6GEB?BA�;T:PSFSB:PJC?F6�;Z6GEu6!SFSBAy83ACJ=$J>AIHI=�� � ����I�/�£;Z6GE~?FRI?[?F6�7@6s8GACS[?F:PJC?F=$:Q8cw>6�AW8!83ACEBEFAPJ>Ay=@JD8G=N:CSB8GR>J�Ec:<OQAT¦

� � ����W���� � ���$�� ���/�

;Z6GE2?BRI?B?B6�7N6s83ACS[?F:PJK?B= �,8cw>6�aThPR>Ec:<J>A&J>6!7$EF:POQA/ 53���F&�CO�B��@$� ���B� .5� @5�J� #FE,����D��M���0� &&1 @5�5L>#F���5& %&>�4�M�=C>��D4D #F� �����5!$& ���F�B�=�5����� D � � C>&>� �M�=#F� �J���4& ���F�B�=K @J���F&�#F�$!$��E,#F�5#F� ���5���

& E ��#IHI@5���4�5- � & �4#5� ���$�5D #FE,&9� ���F& C>�B��@5� ���B� �4# .J� @5�5� �F��?�#FC � #F�$CO�F@$� # H��$- �*&>!5D &>E,� �4DM� �5D &GH0& &>� &>E,�5#5#F� CO@$#J&O�4�M� #F�0�4&OD�H$#F&>�5&�-�:��?��F#B��E,�"��� � COCO���4#F���5& ��&>D �4&>?��J���B��D &(C/.5&(#F�%D # �J@I� �,!5&>�%!5��E,#F�$#F�"H$@5���4� !5&>D # H�� !5���F�B�"� C>&>� �M�,� &>C>���5!5� �B�,K @J���F& �F&(C>�����M���0� #!5&>�5��� ���5�A�4&>E,�5D & #F�5!$# H$#F!5@$#%!5&>�%!5��E,#F�5#F� � � &(#F��!5��E,#F�5#F� & HI@5���4� !2&GHI#F!5&>� �4&>E,&O�0�4&.�F&(CO�����M���0�4#��4���5� �5��� !5&>�5��� ��� �4# M- � ������ �4#��5#F�F# �� � !5&>�F�B� �5���(!5&>�5��� ��L>#F���5& .5�=#FE,����D4� ��� �4#$D4#F�4H0��� �4# �5�F��� � �JC>#$&:�4&>C>�5#FC>##!0&O! &:�4DM�N���M�N� � #F�.���$�����4# � #I� &G��� ��D4#$!5&>�F�B� �F��?�#FCO�� �F��?�#FC/.5&.#F�$CO�F@$� # H0&"!��F��?�#FC/.5&.�F#���&>D &"!�&>C>C�- G- � � #F�5C>��� H0&>�5#F&>�0� &.�5��� � D ��� C>@5DM���$#F�F& !5&>�F��� ���4� @5E,&>D & �B�,����� �4#��5#F�F# �� �"!5&>��!$��E,#F�5#F�HI@5��� � & #F���4&>?�@5&>� �4& *�F& �5D4�������4#FL>#F���5#����3) ��� & ����� ) ��� ) ��� � � � ) � � %� ���$�(H����F#F!5&=#F�.��?��5#�!$��E,#F�5#F� !0E,&>� �4D & �B��5D4�������4#FL>#F���5&=�����4&O� @$� �.��&>D9E,� !5@5�9�����5&>�5��! � � � � � ) � � & 1 ���F�M� � C>��E,& �4@$��� &=�F&=�$D ������� #FL>#F���5#J&>� #F��� &>�5L>#B���F# 3�5&>��!$��E,#F�5#F�HI@5��� � � KI@$#F�5!5##!�� &(� #3��E,E,&G��� &(#F�%!5��E,#F�5#F�.HI@5���4� !���&>D �4#F�5� �B�"D &>?����B�,!5&>��E,� !5@5�=�����5&>�5� � �<�B�"D &>?����B� !5#%&>�F#FE,#F�J��L>#F���5& !5#) �5��� D #F�4@5� �M�(C>��D D &G���M�"& H��.E,� !5# �JCO�N�M�$-

Page 140: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%� ��03q!o�b�;�]!o��!(�05V«1��!A\�,F§k�1�%#�r�!Z§;t� |�N&�>��@A|�N��&_KRM:P7@ACEF:�J>6!7mEF:POQA�J>ACJ�aMhPR>Ec:0:<7\83R>JT:�8GACS[?F:PJC?F6P]£:P7@7NAPEc:�S[=m=NJK?BEFAIHIRM836Q=N7mJ>AIHIA � � ����I���º]HIA ` 6 �.f6�R>JM:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�_KRM:<7\SB=N:CS[=�nopJId�:<?[?B=�]¾;T6!E SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PEB6�$� ���$�� �Z�/�U] ` =CH>6 ` 6*6kSBSB6GEF6*R>Js=NJMHI= ` =NH>R>A�8cw>6*wM:27N:~;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf:6�� ���­]b6mLM=NSBAPhCJM:;>EF6GJMH>6GEF7@A�JWR>A ` AT]Z;ZAP=\8cwu®6&7N6Q8GACS[?F:PJC?F=*hP=pf:l;MEB6kS[6!JC?F=(J>6G7mEc:<OQA�;TAP?BEF6GL>LZ6GEFA�J>APJ�;TAP?B6!Es: ` 6GEF6P]�;Z6GJM:�R>JT:=NJMHI6!SB=\HI6GEc:b?c:8GAPJK?BEc:PH>H>=@j!=@ACJ>6P]¾7\:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:�=NJ&_KR>6kSU?F=@ACJ>6Pn � � ���$�� �Z�/� f6uS[AIH>HI=\S[d�:b?[?FA�SB6vJ>6!SFS[RMJy=NJMHI= ` =NHIRMAwM:�7\:q;>EFAP;>EF=N63?¾f:�y� �Z�3]26�_KR>=NJMHI= ` :�EF=N6!SF:<OQ=@JT:b?BA¢SB6DJ>6!7�Ec:<OQA¢S[=�=@JK?BEFAIHIRM8GAPJ>AqJWR>A ` 608GACS[?F:PJC?F=���8cwM683ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>APJ>A�:lJWR>A ` =(=@JTHI= ` =\HIR>=VH>6G7mHIACO&=NJ>=NAK�3n&¿ :�8G7N:PRMSBAP7\:l83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6&:P7@7�X =N;ZA<?B6kS[=m8cwM6y=N7mHIAPOQ=NJ>=NAJ>ACJ�f6 ` R>AP?BAM]I6s_KR>=NJMHI= 8cw>6�83APJK?F=@6!J>6�:<7NO&6!J>AQR>JM:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6Cn¿£:�EB6!hPAC7N:¢�Y:C�y83ACEBEF=NSB;ZAPJMHI6�:<7N7N:�EB6!hPAC7N:¢�YHM�­]vS[=~:P;>;>7N=N8!:�8GAPJ¹7N6083ACS[?F:PJK?B=vhP=pf:.;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=���A�8GAPJ¢R>JT:=NJC?FEBAIHIAP?[?c:iH{X R �i8G=@Al;T6!E�7\:,837\:<RMSBAP7\:C�96s=N7£JMAWH>A,J>APJ.SB=£8GAPJK?BEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:Mnv�9w>=\:<OQ=\:<OQA,7N6sHIR>6�EF6GhCAP7N6i��:C�~6��HT��Lk8��$@A|�8(yD8�|�< < < 9b=�x[@ n¿£:yEF6GhPAC7N:l�eLT�v83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6:<7N7\:�EF6GhCAP7\:l��8k�­]>SB={:<;>;>7N=\8G:y=@JK?BEFAIHIRM8G6GJMHIA&R>JM:yJWR>A ` :y8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�6�=N7ZJMAWH>ASB=$83APJK?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:>n�9w>=\:<OQ=\:<OQAy7N6sHIR>6�EF6GhCAP7N6&��LT�v6,��8k��L�8��$@$|�8(y>8�|�< � 9b=�x[@ n½mEF=NOQ:lHI=*;M:PSFSF:<EF6�:<hC7@=^6!SB6GOQ;>=(ACSFSB6GE ` =\:<OQA,8cw>6C]$83ACO&6yJ>6G7*8!:PSBAl;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6,f6y;>=[fR�83ACJ ` 6GJM=@6!JC?F6:<;M;>7@=\8G:PEB6�7N6�EF6GhCAP7N6sHI6G7^ov?B=N;TA�;>EF=@Oi:,HI=(_KR>6G7N7N6yHI6!7£o[ou?F=@;ZA���ACSFS[=\:,SB=£EF= ` 6G7\:Q;>=[fR.6�,83=N6GJK?F6�EF=@Oi:<JTH>:<EF6�=@7;>=[fR�;TAKSBSB=@LM=@7N6Q7@6iL>=@deAPEc8G:PjG=NAPJ>=��­]$8GACSpf �vf6&;>=[fRq8GAPJ ` 6!J>=@6!JK?B6i:<;>;M7@=\8G:PEB6C]$_CRT:<7NAPEc:l;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6C]$;>EF=@Oi:�7N6iEB6!hPAP7N6HI6!7$om�¤?B=N;TAi6�;ZAP= _CRM6G7N7@6sHI6!7$o[oBov?B=N;TATnmopJId�:b?B?B=mf6�7�X :<;>;>7N=\8G:<j!=@ACJ>6�HI6G7N7N6�EB6!hPAP7N6�HI6G7$om�¤?F=@;ZAl8cw>6�8GAPOQ;TACE[?c:7�X =NJK?BEFAWH>R>jG=NAPJ>6QHI=(JWR>A ` 6&83AKSU?c:<JK?B=*83ACJ�7N6&_KRM:P7@=�]{=NJ�AChPJ>=(8G:CS[AT] ` :PJ>J>A0S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:b?[?F=*J>AIHI=*8cw>6&EB=\8cw>=N6!HIACJ>A7�X :P;>;>7N=N8!:<jG=NAPJM6uH>=IR>JM:�EF6GhPAC7N:HI6G7Mo[o[o ?B=N;ZAMn(opJQhP6GJM6GEF6P]<_KR>=NJMHI=�]C:<;M;>7@=\8cw>=\:<OQAM]C_CRT:<7NAPEc:�;ZACSFS[=NL>=N7@6C]<;>EF=@Oi:�7N6EF6GhPAC7@62H>6G7Mo*6�om� ?B=N;ZAM]K;TAC=Z_KR>6!7@7N6�HI6!7ToBo[o*62=NJIaMJ>6�_KR>6G7N7@6HI6G7Zo[o(?F=@;ZAl�eAKSBSB=\:�EB=NOi:<JMH>=N:PO&A�=N7Z;>=[fRi;ZACSFSB=@L>=N7N67N6�L>=rdeACEF8!:<j!=@ACJ>=\�3n

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqC�Hv�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6C¦ � � � � ����� � �Tn¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFAyEF=NSBR>7@?F:M¦

�+� � � ��������

� � � � �

�+� � � ��� �

� � ��� ����� � � ���

opJ>=NjG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6iSB=uf6&:P;>;>7N=N8!:b?c:l7\:�EB6!hPAP7\:,;Z6GE�� � � � ��n&op7mJ>AIHIA9�+� � � ��� �VEF=N8cwM=@6kHI6yRMJM:�EB6!hPAP7\:lH>6G7*o[oBo?B=N;ZAM¦2SB=£?FAPhP7N=N6�=N7�����6P]�J>6!7@7\:S^3ª�^~EF=NSBR>7@?F:PJC?F6 ���£]$SB=(S[AKSU?F=r?FR>=NSF836�7N: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N6s7N=@LZ6GEc:���83APJ�R>JM:l8GACS[?F:PJC?F6hP=pf:�;>EF6!SB6GJK?B6~JM6G7>Ec:<OQAM]P=@J,_KR>6kSU?FAs8G:PSBA �Z]C62SB=MAP?[?B=N6GJM6 �+� � � �pn(¿mX :<7NLT6!EBAsSB=M8cw>=NRMHI6�6~7N:�deACEBOyR>7N:Qf6 ` :P7@=\H>:>n�9APJ�=N7$OQ63?BAIHIA,H>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBAQSB= ` 6!EB=@aT8G:&:<JT8cw>6�7N:&hP6!J>6GEc:<7N=NjGj!:PjG=NAPJ>6�HI6G7N7\:Q;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6P¦� � ���A�� �Z�V������I�

�W=$AP?[?F=@6!J>6�R>J0OQ63?F:"�º:P7@LZ6GEFAM¦

�+� ����I����������

� � ����W����+� � �$�� ���/�

� � � �$�� �Z�V� y���I�/���

Page 141: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%�T}opJ0OQAWH>AQ:PJM:<7NAPhCA&SB= ` 6kHI6�8cw>6P¦ � � � �Q� ��� ���6P]MhP6GJM6GEc:<7N=@j!j!:<JTHIAM¦ � � ����I�V� ���Ay� �Z�3n �

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqC+ER�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6 � � � � ����� ��� ���opJ>=NjG=\:<7NOQ6GJK?B6�SB={wM:>¦

� � ��� ��� �

�+� � � ��� �

� � � � ����� ��� ��� ���

x¢_KR>6kSU?FA2;>R>JK?BAS[=CwM:<J>JMA�H>:u6!SF:<OQ=NJM:<EF6mHIR>6VJ>AIHI=K:P=P_KRM:<7N= ` :2:P;>;>7N=N8!:b?c:uR>JM:~EF6GhCAP7\:~HI6G7Co[o[o�?F=@;ZA��e?F:<7 ` AC7r?c:HI=NEB6!OQA&:PJM8cw>6P]W;>=[fR�L>EB6 ` 6!O&6!JK?B6P]WJ>AIHI=$H>6G7�o[oBoV?F=@;ZAK�3nm526G7{Ec:<OQAyJ>APJ�83APOQ;M:PEB6�:<7\83RMJM:y8GACS[?F:PJC?F6P]K;T6!E283R>=` :Q:<;>;>7N=\8G:b?c:�7\:Q837\:<RMSBAP7\:s6�SB={=@JK?FEBAIHIRM8G6�H{X R �i8G=@AQR>JT:y8GACS[?F:<JK?F6�:M¦mH>:S�$� ��� ��� � S[6!hPR>6�:<7N7NAPEc:��+� � � ��n*op7J>AIHIA � � ��� ��� �^;>R fAiACEF:y6!SFS[6!EB6�SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:b?B?BAi83ACJD:y6�SB=$A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�� � � � �$6�7YX :<7NLT6!EBAiSB=$8cw>=NRMHI6P¦

� � � � ��������

�+� � � �

� � ��� ��� �

�+� � � ��� �

� � � � ����� ��� ��� ���

x2LML>=N:POQA,83ACSpf � ` =\SU?FA,8cw>6s7�X =NOQ;>=N6GhPA,H>6G7N7N:,8G7N:PRMSBAP7\:i:<7N7@6�EF6GhCAP7N6sHI6G7 o[o[ov?F=@;ZA.f6sJM6!836kSBSF:<EF=NA&;Z6GEhP=NRMS[?B=i�aT8!:<EF6&7\: ` :<7N=NH>=r?bf:DHI6G7N7N:0;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6Q8cw>6,8!:<Ec:b?[?F6GEF=@j!j!:�7N:0JMACS[?BEc:�SF836!7r?c:0HI6G7vHIAPOQ=NJ>=@A0J>ACJ ` RMA<?BA¢��J>6G7HIACO&=NJ>=NA ` RMA<?BA&?c:<7N6�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6J>ACJ�f6 ` 6GEc:C�3n �

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqCF�z�*6kHI=N:POQAM] 8GAPJ�=N7mOQ63?BAIHIA.H>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBA.SB6GOi:PJC?F=N8GAM]$7\: ` :<7N=NH>=r?bf:DHI6G7N7@6,deAPEFO�R>7N6i8cw>6ihC:"�Ec:<JK?B=\SB8GAPJ>A&7�X =NJK?B6GEcHI6GaMJ>=NL>=@7N=@?¾f:QHI6G= _CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB=�¦

� � � �Ay� ��� ��� ���o���� ��� � � ���A�� �Z� ����� �o���� ���

¬�7N=$:<7NLT6!EB=£SBAPJMA��<¦� � �.��� @5!$&O�0�4& !5� HID & � ��& � &>?�@5#FD4& �N��� &>�0�M��E,&>�0� & #��J��� � ��?�?�#2�5&>#�!5@5& ������&>D #3!$����� ��� ���5�5�F#FCO��L>#F���5& !5&>�F�B� D &>?����B� !$&O��� !$�4#

���5�5�F#FCO�N� �.�B� D &>?����B�(!$&O� (��4#F���.D4&O�B�N�4# H�� ���F�B�(�$&O?0��L>#F���5&�- (��<�4@$��� #�& K @J�N�4�4D �.#�D ��E,# � !5&>#�!5@5& ������&>D # �HI#�� ���5� !J� &>�M��E,#F�5��D &!5@5&��$�I!5##!�@5�5� C>���.D4&>?����B�=!5&>� (*(*(�� #F��� &���� ��� �4D � C>���.D4&O?����B� !5&>� ( � � #F���5- � � �5#B��E,� � &>E,�5D &*&>�M��E,#F�J�N�4� �5D4#FE � K @5&>�4� � @5� �4#FE,� !�F�"��� �5#B��E,�"� � !5!5#F�*1�N���4�"C>�����B� C>���4� ���0� &�� � �4@5�5�����4� �"�I@$� H��"�$&O�2DM��E,� 9& �F�"��� �5#B��E,�.C>���0� D ��� � &>?��J�N�4�5- �I& �4# & ����� &>� @$� �@5�J� �$&O?0��L>#F���5& �B� ��� �5#B��E,� � � !5!5#F�*1�N��� � � @ �5# �4� &�����#5�4#B��E,� �J���4�M�N�4#J���5�5� !5� !5&>� (*(�(��4#F��� ! ��� � D4#FE,&>� �4#$�5D4#FE � �4# &�&>�M��E,#F�J�N�4�#F�2�$�I!5�.!5&>� (�(*(:�4#F���.& �5& & D #F�4@5� � �N�M�.@$�J�.�5&>?0��L>#F���5&�-&(��<� @$���4#%#2CO��� #�#F��DM��E,�(� # & C/.5#F@5�4�5-

Page 142: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%���

�+� ����I����������

� � ����W����+� ������W��� ��$� ���o���� �Z�/� �� � � ���$��y� ���/� ��+� � �$�� ���/�

�$� y���I�/��������

� � ������W������ � y���I�/�

� � ���o���� �Z�/��$� � ���o���� �Z�/� �� � � �Ay� ���/���

�����

� � � �$�� �Z� ��� ���$���� �Z��� �

� � y���I�/��������

�$� ��y���I�/� ��+� ����I�/�

�+� � �$��y� ���/�� � �����$���� �Z��� ��+� ���$�� ���/� �

� � ����W����������

�+� ����I���� � ������I�/� �� � ���$��y� �Z������+� ��� �$��y� ���/� �� � ���$�� ���/�

�����

� � ���$�� �Z� ����� �o���� ���/���

��:b?BAi8cw>6�hC7@=£:P7@LZ6GEF=$SB=$8cw>=@RTHIAPJ>AQ7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>={S[ACJ>A ` :P7@=\HI6Pn �

op7uOQ63?BAIHIA�HI6G7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA�SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GA�;>R fA�6!SFSB6GEF6�:<;M;>7@=\8G:<?BAT]m83APOQ6�:<L>L>=\:<OQA ` =\S[?BA�J>6G7��v:<;£n^|M]mAP7@?BEF68cw>6Q;Z6GE ` 6GEF=raT8!:<EF6&SB6QR>JM:0;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6�f6 ` :<7N=NH>:M]$;Z6GE ` 6!HI6!EB6iSB6QH>R>6i;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=mS[ACJ>A�7@AChP=\8G:<OQ6!JC?F66!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B=�]>SB6sS[RMSFSB=NS[?B6�=N7{J>6!SFS[AiHI= 83APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:�7@AChP=\8G:y?BEc:�RMJ�=NJMSB=@6!OQ6�� ��aMJ>=@?BAW�v6�R>JM:Q;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6xs]TS[6�R>J0=NJMS[=N6GOQ6,�eaMJ>=@?BAK����f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@6Cn���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqC�B �*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB6P¦

� ��� � ��� �&� � �I�­�1� � �T� � � ���$� ��� �

¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFAEF=NSBR>7@?F:Q��SB=>EF=N8GAPEcHI=I8cw>6~S[=I=NJ>=NjG=\:�7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA;ZAPJ>6!JMHIA ` 6GEF697N6~;>EF6GOQ6!SFS[6v6ud�:<7\SF:7\:�83ACJM837NRMSB=@ACJ>6k�3¦

� � � � � �������� �+� � � ��������

""" � � �

�+� � � �&� � � ���

�$� � �y� � � �

�$� � � �&� � � �

�$� � � � �

� � � � � � ���

� � � � �

� � ���$� ��� � ���

�+� � � � ���

�$� ��� � ��� �&� � �I�/�

Page 143: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%�K|�"*o5�#srC§�YW5��"!$#Gn��I8GEB=@?[?F=V=m?FEB6lJ>AIHI=9=NJ>=NjG=\:<7N=Y]^6!SF:<OQ=NJ>=\:<OQAD;>EF=@Oi:(�$� � � � �v8cwM60f6,R>JM:.J>6GhK:<jG=NAPJM6P]£;ZAP=

� � ���$� ��� � ���Y8cw>60EB=\8cw>=N6!HI6�R>JM:�EF6GhPAC7N:�HI6G7~om� ?B=N;ZAM]vACSFS[=\:>]m;M=[fRgL>EF6 ` 6!OQ6GJK?B6C]mR>JgJ>AIHIA�H>6G7~om� ?B=N;TAW�­]8cw>60S[=~SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:�83ACJ¹R>JM:�8GACS[?F:<JK?F6�8�JWR>A ` :.J>6!7vEc:<OQAT©vSB=uA<?[?F=@6!J>6�� � � � � � ��8cw>6�6!SF:<OQ=NJ>=N:POQA�SBR>L>=@?BAMnx»_KR>6!S[?BA0;>R>JK?FA�EF=NOQ:PJ>6Q:<JM8GAPEc:�H>:�6!SF:<OQ=NJM:<EF6&=@7*J>AIHIAD:P7@7\:lEc:PH>=N8G6P]$=N7m_KRM:<7N6yEF=\8cw>=@6kHI6QR>JM:�EF6GhPAC7N:�HI6G7o[oBoi?B=N;ZAM]26�_CRM=@JMH>=�SB=�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:¹83APJ 7@6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=�;MEB6kS[6!JC?F=�J>6!7Ec:<OQA �Y83=NAMf6�:>]~L 6�8!�l6�S[=�A<?B?B6!J>hPACJ>A�+� � � �&� � � �Y]T�$� � �Q� � � �Y]T�$� � � �Q� � � ��n��W6�SB={6!SF:<OQ=@JT:�;>EF=NOQ:Q_KR>6kSU?kX R>7@?B=NOQAQJ>AIHIAy7�X :<7NLT6!EBAQS[=8cw>=NRMHI6Cn&op7m8cwM=@RMH>6GEcS[=mHI6!7@7�X :<7NLT6!EBAT]$83APOQ6QJ>6!7m8G:PSBA�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P]$SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:�8cw>6QJ>APJ�S[=*;MR fA0EB6k:<7N=@j!j!:<EF6_KRM:<JK?FAi;TAKSU?FA,:<7N7YX =@JM=@j!=@AT]MACSFSB=N:&7N6s;>EF6GOQ6!SFS[6 ` 6GEF6�6s7N:i8GAPJM8G7@RTS[=NAPJ>6�d�:P7NSF:>]M6�_KR>=@JTHI= 8cw>6sSBRMSFS[=\S[?B6�=N7£J>6kSBSBAHI=£8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMj!:y7@AChP=\8G:>n �

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqC��R�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB6P¦��� ���0� � ��� � � � � ���$� ��� �$a

½mEFAI836kHI=N:POQAy83ACOQ6�JM6G7N7YX 6!SB6GOQ;>=NAi;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6P¦

� � � ��

� � � � �

� � ��� ��� �

�+� � � ��������

�+� � � � �

�+� � ��� � �

����� � � �

� � � � �

�+� � � � ���

�$� ���o� ��� � ���

� � � ���$� ��� � � �

�+� ��� ����� � ��� � � �

�"*o5�#srC§�YW5��"!$#Gn��I83EF=r?B?B=u=uHIR>6�;>EB=NOQ=9JMAWH>=¢�$� ��� ���0� �� �� � �Y] � � � ���$� ��� � �26kSB:PO&=NJ>=\:<OQA.;>EF=NOQ:�=@7SB6!83ACJMHIAg��8cw>6�f6lRMJM:�JM6GhC:PjG=NAPJ>6¾�­]m=N7~_KRM:<7N6�wT:�8GAPOQ6�8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMj!:DR>JgJ>AIHIA�8cw>6�EF=\8cw>=@6kHI6�R>JM:�EB6!hPAP7\:HI6!7mom�»?B=N;TAT] 8cw>6Q6kSB:PO&=NJ>=\:<OQA0S[R>LM=r?FAM]£=NJK?BEFAIHIRM836!JMHIA07\:�JWR>A ` :083AKSU?c:<JK?B6&L$¦sSB=*EB=\8G: ` :��+� � � � �98cw>6iS[=6!SF:<OQ=NJM:.SBR>L>=@?BATn�x _KR>6!S[?BA�;>R>JK?BA�EB=@?BACEBJ>=\:<OQA�:P79JMAWH>A�=NJ>=@j!=N:P7@6�8cw>6�H f:.7NR>APhCA�:<7N7\:DL>=@deAPEc8G:<j!=@ACJ>6Pn�opJ6GJK?FEF:PO�L>=T=TEc:<OQ=>aThPR>Ec:�R>J,J>AIHIA&8cw>62EF=N8cwM=@6kHI62R>JM:�EB6!hPAC7N:�HI6!7MoBo[o*?F=@;ZA�6�8cw>6�SB=ZSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:s8GAPJi7N68GACS[?F:<JK?F=;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=�]C8G=@AMf6u:�6~L$n*x _KR>6!S[?BA�;>R>JK?FAs=@7MEF:PO&A�:�HI6kSU?FEF:�SB=T8cw>=NRMHI6s��6!SFS[6!JMHIA ` = � � � � �M6 �$� � � �e�­]CO&6!JK?BEF6=N7£Ec:<OQA,:iS[=NJ>=\SU?FEF:QEF=NOQ:PJ>6s:<;Z6GEB?BATn9opJ._KR>6kSU?FAiEF:POQAi7YX R>J>=\83AiJ>AIHIAlJ>APJD83ACJK?BEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:<?BA0��:i;M:PE[?F6s_KR>6G7N7@=8cw>6.8GAPJK?B6!J>hPACJ>A�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=2:b?BACOQ=N8cw>6¾�lf6 � � ��� ��� �i��8cw>6qf60H>=_KR>6G7N7N=�8cw>6DJ>ACJ S[=�8GAPJK?BEc:PSFSB6GhPJT:<J>AW�­©?BR>?[?F: ` =\:>]vH>:b?FA�8cw>60_KR>6!S[?BA�J>AIHIA f6�hP=pf:�S[?F:<?BA�S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:b?[?FAq83APJ¹?BRI?B?B6D7N6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F=u;>EB6kS[6!JK?B=uJ>6G7~Ec:<OQAT]:<JT8cw>6yEF=N6!SF:<OQ=@JT:<JMHIAC7@A�J>APJ�S[=m:PhPhC=@R>JMhP6y:P7N8GR>J�JWR>A ` AlJ>AIHIA06C]$_CRM=@JMH>=Y] 7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�f6y?B6GEFOQ=@JT:b?BATn �R>6kSU?c:` AC7r?c:s7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA&J>APJ�S[=(f6�8cw>=@RTS[AT]K=NJ0_CRT:<JK?BAyR>J�Ec:<OQAlf6�EF=@Oi:CSU?FAy:<;Z6GEB?BATnV�9APOQ6�:PL>L>=\:<OQA�hC=ºf:&:<JK?F=N8G=@;M:<?BAT]83=pfA.SB=@hCJ>=raZ8G:D8cw>6i=N7VJ>6kSBSBA.HI=v83APJTS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:�7@AChP=\8G:0J>ACJqS[RMSFSB=NS[?B6Cn�op7mEc:<OQA.:P;T6!E[?FAM]£=NJ>AC7r?FEB6C] =NJMHI=\8G:0R>JT:SB=r?FRM:<j!=@ACJ>6�[email protected]>=$7\:y;MEB6!O&6kSBSF:�f6 ` 6!EF:&6�7\:&8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMj!:yd�:<7\SB:Mn9�9APJMSB=\HI6GEF=N:POQAy=N7£HIACO&=NJ>=NA � 83ACS[?B=@?BRM=r?FAH>:P7@7N6y8GACS[?F:<JK?F= 8cw>6�aMhPR>Ec:<JMA,J>6G7^Ec:<OQAM]ZACSFS[=\: � � �¾:>] L{�Cn��9APOQ6�SB=9f6yHI6G?[?BAT]{S[=^=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:i7\:l8GACS[?F:PJC?F6:i=NJ.:>]T6�LD=NJDL$n2½(AP=\8cwu®6�J>6!7£Ec:<OQAQaMhPRMEF: � � � � �^=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?B=\:<OQA � [email protected],8cw>6�7N:,8GAP;>;M=N:.��L$] :C�uJ>ACJS[?B=\:Q=@J �Z� ���3nMopJ._KR>6kSU?FA&OQAIHIA �~LT:�f6�d�:<7\SB:M]A� � � ` 6GEc:>] ���o� ��� � ` 6!EF:y6j� ���o� � � ��d�:<7\SB:MnV½(AP=\8cwu®6�J>6G7Ec:<OQAs83ACO&;T:<=NAPJ>A�� � � � �Z6�� � � �Z=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?F=N:PO&A�� =NJiOQAWH>A�8cw>62Ju®6�:�Ju®62L,S[?B=\:<JMAs=@J �Z��½v�2��6P]K=@Jl_KR>6kSU?FA8G:CS[AT]$83=pfA�SB=NhPJ>=@aT8G:08cw>6 �Z��½9�������­nQ½(AP=\8cwv®6�JM6!SFS[R>J�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA0H>= � wT: �Z��½v�­]{=NJ�?c:<7N6Q=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6

Page 144: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%�;���� ����f62d�:<7\SB:�6C]I_CRM=@JMH>=Y] ��� ����� � ��� � ` 6GEc:i�e6!SFSB6GJMHIAyR>Jl8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6�83ACJl:<JK?B6k836kHI6GJK?B62d�:<7\S[AW�­n��W= f683AKSpf �T?FEBA ` :<?BA&R>J06!SB6GOQ;>=NA&=NJD83R>=£7N:Q;>EF6GOQ6kSBSF:������ ����� ���� �I�2f6 ` 6GEc:y6�=@7£8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?F6&��� ���$� ��� �I�d�:<7\SBAM]I;Z6GE283RM=$J>APJDSBRMSFS[=\SU?F6�=@7{J>6kSBSBAiHI=£8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJ>jk:�7NAPhC=N8!:>n �

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqCz�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB62�IAWH�� � � ��� ] � �o� ���$�Cn¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFA�EB=\S[RM7r?c:i��SB=TEF=N8GAPEcHI=M8cw>6C]P?FEF:<?[?c:<JMHIAKS[=THI=TRMJM:s_KR>6!S[?B=NAPJM6�HI=TSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@=@?¾f:M]KSB=M;ZAPJ>hCAPJ>A ` 6GEF6?BR>?[?B6�7@6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>={HI6G7N7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6¾�­¦

� � � � ��������

�$� � � � ���

�+� � � �

�+� � �$� ��� �

�+� � � ��� �

�"*o5�#srC§�YW5��"!$#Gn~¡mJK?BEc:<OyL>={=£J>AIHI=£=@J>=NjG=\:<7N=£EF=\8cw>=@6kHIAPJMA&RMJM:QEB6!hPAC7N:QHI6!7$o[oBo9?F=@;ZAM]Z;Z6GE�8GR>=£6kSB:PO&=NJ>=\:<OQAQ=@7;>EF=@OQATn ��:b?BA�8cw>6vJ>6G7WEc:<OQA2J>ACJ ` =IS[ACJ>A8GACS[?F:PJC?F=Y]<SB=W:<;>;>7N=\8G:7N:837\:<RMSBAP7\:26uS[6vJ>6v=@JK?FEBAIHIRM8G6VR>JT:H{X R��,83=NAM]:PH�6kS[6!O&;M=@A.:M]£6lSB=mA<?B?B=N6GJ>6/�$� � � �pnlop79S[6k83APJTHIADJ>AIHIAD;>R fADACEF:�6kSBSB6GEF6iS[AIH>HI=\S[d�:b?[?FA.83ACJ�?c:<7N6,83AKSU?c:<JK?B6C]6ySB=(A<?B?B=N6GJ>6j�+� � � � �mH>:P7@7\:l_KRM:P7@6yS[6!hPR>6�� � � � �^6QSB=^8cw>=NRMHI6y=@7(Ec:<OQAMn��9=ºfA�S[=NhPJM=raT8!:,8cw>6y7@6y;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=HI6!7@7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6iJ>APJ�;ZACSFS[ACJ>A06!SFS[6!EB6iSB=@OyR>7r?c:<J>6k:<OQ6GJK?F6 ` 6GEF6Q6P](_CRM=@JMH>=Y](8cw>6i7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6Df6&=NJMSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn�W=ACSFS[6!E ` =2:<JT8cw>6.8cw>6._KR>6!S[?BAqEF=\S[R>7@?F:<?BAqHI=N;T6!JMHI6�H>:<7N7YX : ` 6!EQ6!SF837NRMS[Aq=N7�HIACOQ=@J>=NA ` R>AP?BAMn 526!7�HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA` R>A<?FAM] =@JId�:<?[?F=Y]^7@6,H>R>6i;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=m_KRM:<JK?B=@aT8!:b?B6iRMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@OQ6!JC?F6&SBAPJMA�6!JK?BEc:<O�LZ6 ` 6!EB6Cn,¿mX 6!SF837NRMSB=@ACJ>6HI6!7$HIAPOQ=NJ>=@A ` R>A<?FA�f6AP?[?B6!JWRI?F:M]>83APOQ6�SB=^f6hC=ºf:&HI63?B?BAT]>83APJ�7�X =NJMSB6GEF=@OQ6GJK?FA&HI6!7@7\:&837\:<RMSBAP7\:�JM6G7N7@6�EF6GhPAC7@6�HI6G7o[oBoV?F=@;ZAM]T837\:<RMSBAP7\:y8cwM6sS[=*f6�:P;>;>R>JK?BAi:P;>;>7N=N8!:b?F:&=NJ�_KR>6kSU?FAi6!SB6GOQ;>=NAMn �

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC+EqC��R�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB62�IAWH�� ��� ��� � ���o� ���$�Cn½mEFAI836kHI6GJMH>A&8GAPOQ6�J>6G7N7YX ¡VSB6GOQ;>=NAQ;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�SB={wM:Q=N7$S[6!hPR>6!JK?B6�:<7NLT6!EBAT¦

� � � ��

�+� � � ����

�+� � � �

�$� ���$� ��� � �

�+� ��� ��� ���

�"*o5�#srC§�YW5��"!$#GnuovJMAWH>=£=NJ>=@j!=N:P7@=£EB=\8cw>=N6!HIACJ>AQR>JM:iEF6GhCAP7\:yHI6!7£om��?F=@;ZAMn ��:<7£;MEB=NOQAM]M8cw>6sSB= 8GAPJK?BEc:PSFSB6GhPJT:>]SB6GhPRM6U�$� � � �º] OQ6!JC?FEB6iH>:P7VSB6!83ACJMHIAT]£8cw>6 ` :0:<JM8cw$X 6!SFSBA08GAPJK?BEc:PSFSB6GhPJT:b?BAT]{S[6!hPR>6h�+� � � ��º]^HM:�8GR>=�� � � ���nx�_KR>6!S[?BA0;>RMJC?FA�?BRI?B?B=V=*JMAWH>=VS[ACJ>AD83ACJC?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:b?F= 6Q7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA�f6QEB=NOi:PS[?BA0:<;Z6GEB?BAM©^7N6&;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>=*HI6!7 �7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6.HM:b?BA�;ZACSFS[ACJ>A�6!SFS[6!EB60SB=@OyR>7r?c:<J>6k:<OQ6GJK?F6 ` 6GEF6P]v6D_CRM=@JMH>=�7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6�f6DSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn �9ACOQ6J>6!7@7�X ¡9S[6!OQ;>=@A À n �>n �y=N7$EF:POQAy=NJMHI=\8G:QR>JT:&SB=@?BRM:PjG=NAPJ>6�8cw>6�EF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEF6�7@6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=�n��W=$;ZAPJ>6 �����¾:>] L{��eAKSBSB=\:l7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6QH>6G7N7@6Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B=*8cw>6i83ACOQ;M:<=NAPJ>A�J>6G7*Ec:<OQAW�­n�½(AC=N8cwu®6�J>6!7*EF:PO&A ` =mS[ACJ>A��$� � � �*6 � � � ��;ZAPJ>=\:<OQA �T� �s�B���k:>�C]9ACSFS[=\:�8cw>6 �Z��½v�lf6 ` 6GEc:�HI=2:�60J>ACJ f6 ` 6!EF:�HI=~L$n 526!72HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA � 83ACJg_KR>6kSU?c:=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�SBAPJ>A ` 6!EB6�SB=N: ��� ���¹�e=NJD_CRT:<JK?BA ` 6!EF: � �I�­]>SB=N: ���o� ���¹�e=NJD_KRM:<JK?BA ` 6GEc:U� � 3�3n

Page 145: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%����9APhC7@=\:<OQAi7�X AI8!8G:PSB=NAPJ>6s;Z6GE�SBA<?[?FAP7N=@JM6!:<EF6sR>J�:PSB;T6G?[?BA�=@OQ;ZAPEB?F:PJC?F6Pn�526G7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAl;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6P]�_KRM:<JTHIA:<LML>=N:POQA¹6!SF:<OQ=NJM:b?FA��+� ���o� ��� �s7NA :<LML>=N:POQA SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:b?B?BAg83APJ 7N: 83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�L �e=NJ _KRM:PJC?FA¹:¢6!EF:¹hP=pf:;>EF6!SB6GJK?B6�J>6!7$Ec:<OQAK�3n�I6�: ` 6!SFS[=NOQAyRTSB:<?BAiHI=$JWR>A ` A�7\:i83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�:&: ` EF6GOQOQA&8cwM=@RMSBAQ7YX :<7NLZ6GEFAM¦

� � � � ��������

�$� � � � ���

�+� � � �

�$� ���$� ��� � �

�+� ��� ��� ���

x ` EF6GOQOQA�_KR>=NJMHI=9HI=N8cwM=N:PEF:<?BAl=NJMSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6QR>J�=@JTS[=N6GOQ6i8cw>6P] 83APOQ6iSB=uf6 ` =\SU?FAM]mf6&SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn�R>6kSU?FA,6!SB6GOQ;>=NA,=N7@7NRMS[?BEc:,83ACJ.;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB6�8cw>=\:<EF6Gj!j!:i8GAPOQ6�Oi:<=�]�_CRT:<JMHIA�S[=^:<;>;>7N=\8G:iR>JT:,EF6GhPAC7N:iH>6G7^om�?B=N;ZAM] ` :&=@JK?BEFAIHIA<?B?F:yR>JM:&JWR>A ` :y8GACS[?F:PJC?F6P¦^=@7{JMAWH>AU�$� ���$� ��� �Vf6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:<?[?FAQ_KRM:PJMHIA ` =(f6RMJ�=NJMHI= ` =NHIRMA8cw>69J>APJ�wM: �T� �s�­]b6vHI6G7N7YX =NJMHI= ` =\HIR>A�HI6GJMA<?F:<?BA�HM:�:~J>6!7CEc:<OQA�SB=Mf6VhP=pf:~EF=N8cwM=@6kSU?FA28cw>6VhCAWHM:2HI= �T� �s�­n �R>=@JTHI=Y]SB6�S[=TEB=\:PH>AP;Z6GEc:�:M]CSB=MAP?[?B=N6GJM62R>JM:s8GAPJK?BEc:PHMHI=@j!=@ACJ>6P]C8cw>6~?BR>?[?F: ` =\:�J>ACJ�f62=@JTS[=@?F:�JM6G7N7@6�H>R>62;>EF6GOQ6!SFSB6s��83ACOQ66GOQ6!EBhC6�HM:<7N7@AiS ` =N7NR>;>;ZAQ8GAPEFEB6G?[?FA&HI6!7$OQ63?FAWH>AQH>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBAW�­n �

� ��� � ³ � ��)�'^%*1��P'*³�±~)y#D#04u% %(1���1¹4 � -0³s#&%(1��.±~³�%^)�'m1�*6!H>=N:PO&A�APEc:>]�SUdeEFRI?B?F:<JTHIAl=N7(O&6G?BAIHIA�HI6G7N7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA�SB6GOi:<JK?B=\83AT]Z:P7N8GR>J>6y;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM= 8cw>6�?BEc:b?[?c:<J>A�= Ec:<;&�;ZAPEB?B=�deEc:Q=$83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` =£6�=$_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB=�n���b8��Jx�=�@ GCF�GC�Hv�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6 � � � �^� ���y� � �I�m� ��� ����� � �

�$� � �9� � �������� �+� � � �9�[} � ��������

�����

�+� � ��� � � �p� � ��+� � *� � � ���I� Á �

� � � ��p� À �� � � � �º���C�

� � � � ��� ���I���K�� � ��� ����� � � ���W��|K��+� � �^� ���y� � �I�/�p���C�

� � ��� � ���&� � �W�m� � � ����� � � ���I�U}¾�

Page 146: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%� À�"*o5�#srC§�YW5��"!$#�t �:P7@7\:D�U}¾�uS[6!hPR>ACJ>A&7N:D���P�v6�7\:D��|C�v;Z6GE�7N:QEF6GhCAP7\:yHI=�� � � � �9�e7\:Q;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6�H>:b?c:f60R>J 83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6¾�­n ¿£: ���P�yEB=\8cw>=N6!HI60R>JT:�EB6!hPAP7\:�HI6G7~oBo[o&?B=N;TAT]9;Z6GE�83R>=~EF=@Oi:PJMHI=\:<OQA�=@7�SBR>A�6!SF:<OQ6C]6�:<;>;>7N=\8cw>=N:POQA¹:<7N7N: ��|K�,7\:¢EF6GhCAP7\:qHI= � � ¹�9� �º]�AP?[?F6GJ>6!JMHIAg7N: ���K�l6�7\: ���P�3n»¿ : ���P��83APJK?F=@6!J>6�R>JT:;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6s:b?FAPOQ=\8G:i6&:PHD6kSBSF:iJ>ACJ�S[=^;>R fA�:<;>;>7N=\8G:<EF6�:P7N8GR>JM:iEF6GhCAP7\:>n��>Ec:,7\:.���P�~6y7N:����W�­]{SB8G6GhC7@=\:<OQA_KR>6!S[?!X R>7@?B=NOi:i8cw>6�EB=\8cw>=N6!HI6�R>JM:&EF6GhCAP7\:yHI={om�¤?F=@;ZAM¦mSB=$AP?[?B=N6GJM6�7\:0� À �v6G7N=@OQ=NJM:<JMH>A&=N7£_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?FAPEF6����06SBACS[?B=@?BR>6!JMHIAl=NJ�½ �D:P7 ;ZACS[?BA�HI= �07\:,JWR>A ` :,8GACS[?F:PJC?F6sL¹��6y7\:����K�2SB=(83APJK?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:C�3n2½*:PSFS[=\:<OQAiAPEc:,:P7@7\:���C�*8cw>6�SBAIH>HI=\SUaZ:<OQAs83ACJi7@6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F=>hP=pf:�;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=TJ>6G7TEF:POQAM]<AKSBSB=N:�L.��6SB=>wM:�7\:,� Á �[�*6�:,�e6S[=TwM:�7\:,� � �[�­n

��:<7N7N:.� Á �~SB=£AP?[?F6GJ>hCAPJ>AT]T83ACJ0L>=rdeACEF8!:<j!=@ACJ>6P]T7N:D� � �~6�7N:.�[} � �v6s6GJK?BEc:<OyL>=£= EF:POQ= SB= 8cw>=NRMHIACJ>AMn �:<?BAl8cwM67�X :P7@LZ6GEFA�SB=>8cw>=NRMHI6~7\:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�f6 ` :<7N=NH>:Mn �RM6!S[?BA�EB=\S[RM7r?c:b?BA�SB=I;>R fA�hP6!J>6GEc:<7N=NjGj!:PEB6VJ>6G7>OQAIHIA�SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6C¦� � � �^��y� �Z�£���&�V� ���A�� �Z�$�9����SB6 �lJ>APJ�aMhCR>Ec:�7N=@LZ6GEc:&=@J �~�­n

���b8��Jx�=�@ GCF�GC+E ®¡ ` :<7N=NH>A&=N7£8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6=NJ ` 6GEcSBA&HI= _CRM6G7N7@A ` =NS[?BAQJ>6!7@7�X ¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA À n |Mn@}C¦� � ��� ����� � �y� ��� � ���y� � �I�

opJId�:<?[?B=�¦

�+� � ���������

�$� ��� ��� � �+� � � ��������

�����

� � � � �

� � � ��

� � � *� � � ���

� � ��� � ���y� � �I�/����+� � � ����� � � ���

� � � � ���y� � �&� ��� � ���&� � �W��� �

�W=*AKSBSB6GE ` =^8cw>6i:PL>L>=\:<OQA�6kSB:POQ=@JM:<?BA�=@7*JMAWH>A��$� ��� ���y� � � �*=@7V;>=[fR�?F:PEFH>=*;TAKSBSB=@LM=@7N6Pn&526G7N7�X 6kSB:PO&6iHI=� � ��� � ���y� � �I�/�T:PL>L>=\:<OQA�=@JK?FEBAIHIAP?[?BA�7\:�JWR>A ` :�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6~L$n(op7TJ>AIHIA2�+� � � ��� �TJMAPJ,SB=T83ACJK?BEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:�6�S[=SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:�8GAPJ,7N6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=ZhP=pf:�;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=ZJ>6G7�Ec:<OQAl�Y: ` EF6GOQOQAyH>A ` R>?BA�:PJM8cw>6SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PEB7NA�8GAPJl:M]W8G=@AMf6~d�:PEB7NASB6GhPRM=@EF6,H>:(�$� � � �º]^Oi:�J>APJ f6lS[?F:<?BA.JM6!836kSBSF:<EF=NA�;Z6GEc8cwu®6,SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C836!JMHIAP7NA.83ACJqLq=@7vEc:<OQA.S[=�f6,8cw>=NRMSBAK�­nx2JT8cw>6�=@JD_KR>6kSU?FAQ8!:PSBA&SB={A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�d�:C83=N7@OQ6!JC?F6�7N:QSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6�hC6GJ>6!EF:P7@=NjGjk:<jG=NAPJM6P¦

� � � �Ay� ���$�9� � � �^���� �Z� ���&�3��SB6 ��JMAPJ�7@=NLT6!EF:Q=NJ �u�3n6�7�X R>7@?B6!EB=NAPEF6�hP6GJM6GEc:<7N=@j!j!:<j!=@ACJ>6�=NJD83R>=£7N:�^3ª�^f6�:P;T6!E[?c:>n���b8��Jx�=�@ GCF�GCF�z�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB6P¦:K� � � � � ��������� ����� ��� � ����� ���Z�LT� � � � � � ����� ���Z�V� � � ��������� ���:C�6�W=£wM:>¦

Page 147: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%� Á

�+� � � ��������

�$� ��� ��� �

�+� � � ��������

�+� � � ��� �

�����

� � � � �

� � � � �

� � � ��� � � � �

� � ��� � ���&� �����/����+� � � ���y��� � ��� ���

� � � � ��������� ����� ��� � ����� ���Z�[�����

¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFA�SB=m8cw>=@RTHI6P]£_KR>=NJMHI=V7N:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6lf6 ` :<7N=\H>:>nyop7*EB=\S[RM7r?c:b?BA0SB=*hP6GJM6GEc:<7N=@j!j!:id�:C83=N7@OQ6!JC?F6D��83ACJR>J0OQ63?c:��p:<7NLT6!EBAQS[=NOQ=@7N6s:<7{;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B6¾�V6sSB={A<?B?B=N6GJ>6C¦� � ���Ay� �Z�£� ���A��� �Z�9� � �^���� �Z� ����� ���[�

LT� �W={wT:>¦

�$� � � ���������+� � �� �$� � ��������

�����

�+� � � �

����������

�$� � (� � ����

�$� � ��� � � � �

� � � ��

� � � � �

� � � � ��� ���

� � ��� ��� ���

� � � � ���y� � � ���Z�/����+� � �^� ���y� �����/���

� � � �^� ���y� ���Z�9� � � ����� ��� ��� ���

Page 148: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%� ��2J0Ec:<OQA�f6�EB=NOi:PS[?BAQ:<;Z6GEB?BAT]>;T6!E�83RM=$7N:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6�J>ACJ�f6 ` :<7N=\H>:>nV¿£6�deAPEFO�R>7N6�;>EF6!SB6GJK?B={J>6!7$Ec:<OQA:<;Z6GEB?BAy=@JTHI=N8!:<J>AT]>83ACO&6hP=pf:�=N7N7@RMS[?BEc:b?FA�=NJ�;MEB6k836!H>6GJ>jk:>]K7N:&S[=@?BRT:<jG=NAPJM6=NJ�8GR>={7N:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6�J>ACJ�f6 ` 6!EF:Mn

�W= ;TACJ>6 ���»��:M] L��K] �T�Y½9��� L¢�e;ZAP=\8cwu®6�J>6!7£Ec:<OQA ` =*f62�+� � ��£6�� � � � ���3] �Z� ���2� :D�e;ZAP=\8cwu®6�J>6!7$Ec:<OQA` =^f6��$� � � �{6 � � � ��\�3n[�W={EB=\83ACJ>ACSF836:<7N7@ACEF:y8cw>6�SBAPJMA&SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:<?[?B6?BR>?[?B6�7N6�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=ZSB6GhCJM:b?F6;>EF6!SB6GJK?F=J>6!7$EF:POQAM©I=NJD;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB6yf6 ` 6!EF:�� �^� �������������e=NJ._KRM:<JK?BAQAChPJ>={6!7@6!O&6!JK?BA,HI= � wT: �Z��½v�uA �T� ���­¦Z:ywT:�Z� ����6iL�wM: �Z��½9�B�­] O&6!JK?BEF6QSBAPJMA�d�:P7NSB6�� � ���q6�� � ��� �eJ>ACJ�?BRI?B?B=VhC7@=*6!7@6!OQ6GJK?B=VH>= ��wM:<JMJ>A �T�Y½9�­]£A�Z� ���[�3]>;Z6GE�8GR>={7N:Q;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6�=NJ>=@j!=N:P7@6Qf6�d�:P7NSF:>n5262SB6GhCR>6~8cw>6P]PO&6!JK?BEF6 � �Ay� ���<��� 6�� �^���� �Z�<���&�mSBAPJ>A�7NAPhP=\8G:POQ6GJK?B6u6!_KR>= ` :<7N6GJK?B= ��¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA À n |>nN}k�3]J>ACJ,7@A&S[ACJ>A����A�� �Z�I��� �$�l� ���v6 ��� ��y� ���I�S��� �Z�B���e7\:�SB6!8GAPJMHM:Qf6�8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJ>jk:�7NAPhP=\8G:�H>6G7N7N:�;>EB=NOi:>]KOi:J>ACJ ` =\836 ` 6GEcSB:K�>�bn �

x2LML>=N:POQAy_KR>=NJMHI=�6!SF:<OQ=NJM:b?FA�=NJ�HI6G?[?F:PhP7N=@Ay=@7�Ec:<;>;ZAPEB?BAsdeEF:�=@7{_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?FAPEF62R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7N6�67N:&HI=\S[hC=@R>J&�jG=NAPJM6Pn�W=I;>R fA�83ACOQ;>=@6!EB6vR>J$X =NJMH>:<hC=@JM6uSB=\SU?F6GOi:b?F=N8!:�H>6G=IEc:<;>;ZAPEB?B=KdeEc:=>_KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF=W6u=M83ACJ>J>63?B?B= ` =I7@AChP=\83=�n�*6!H>=N:PO&Ai:PJM83ACEF:&:<7\83R>JM=$6!SB6GOQ;>=�n

���b8��Jx�=�@ GCF�GC�B �*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6� � ��� ��y� ��� �9�l� �Z�B�V� ���$�� ���£� ���$�l� ���

6s8cw>6�7�X =NJ ` 6GEcSF:�J>ACJ�f6 ` :P7@=\H>:>nop7{OQ63?c:��p:<7NLT6!EBA&EB=\SBR>7r?c:>¦

� � ����I�/��������

� � ���$�� �Z�/�� � �����I�/��������

� � ���A�l� �Z��������

�$� �����I�/��+� ����I���

�+� ����I� �������I�/���� � ���A�� �Z�^� ���A��� �Z������$� ���^��y� �Z�^���l� ���[��� �

� � ���^��y� �Z�^���l� ���[�v� ���Ay� ���£� ���A��� ���/� �

¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFAySB=$8cw>=@RTHI66�7NA&SF8cw>6!OQ:�f6 ` :<7N=NHIATnV�9APJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&AyAPEc:sR>J08G:CS[A&;M:PE[?F=N8GAP7\:<EF6�HI6G7$8GAPJMH>=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6=NJ ` 6GEcS[A&6�83=NAMf6���� ���&����� ���0� ��� � ���&� �����v6�S ` =@7NR>;>;M=N:PO&AQ7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAM¦6 �I#J!5#FE,���4�4D #$C/.5& �B� �5D ������� #FL>#F���5& ��� � � � % ��� ) � � &=�F��?�#FCO��E,&>� �4& &OK @5# H����F&O�0�4& ���F�B� �5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& ������� � � � � % ) � �

C>��� � !5# H0&>D4� � !J� � � ���4� #B� � &9�4#I�4���4�4# � @$#F� C>���5� �F&�� COC>��D4D &>�5L>&��F#���&OD4&*!$# � #F� ) � � 2C>��� � &:����#0� # KI@5��� �4# �JCO���5� @5�$# H0&OD4�M���FE,&>�0� &&>� �4DM��E ��&<�F&,H���D #B���5#F�F# M- @J���F��D ��� #:C>���5�4#F!5&>DM��� �4&>D � ����� ����&>D�� &<KI@$&O���M� &>K @5# H����F&>�5LO� �F��?�#FC ��C>���0� #F� @5&>D & � ��&A��� @5�4� #F�4�4&>D &�5@5D4C/.�& �4#2� C>&>�F?0�"���5����D4�4@5�J��E,&>�0� & �B� H���D #B���$#F�F& � !$��� � #B�(� #�� C>&>�F?0�"@5�J� H���D #B���5#F�F& C0.5& �5��� & �F#���&>DM�(#F� � � � :�"#F��� � � M-

Page 149: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}%� �

� � � � ���������+� � �� � � � ���������

�����

� � � � �

����������

� � � (� � ����

� � � ��� � � � �

�+� � ��

�+� � � �

�+� ��� ��� ���

�+� ��� ��� ���

� � ���^� ���Q� ���Z�/��+� ��� ���Q� ��� �����/���

� � ��� ���&����� ����� ��� � ���&� ���Z�����

¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFA�f6mEB=NOi:PS[?BA2:P;T6!E[?FAM]¾_CRM=@JMH>=P7\:~;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6(J>APJif6 ` :P7@=\H>:s��6P]b:~Oi:<hChP=NAPE{Ec:<hP=NAPJM6P]GJMAPJ&f6 ` :<7N=\HIA7NA�SF8cw>6GOi: ���Ay� ���^� ���A��� ����� ��� ���� ���*����� �Z�B�[�3n&5�6G7mHIACO&=NJ>=NA ��� �k:M] L$�&83ACJ�7�X =NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6��?F:P7@6Q8cw>6 �Z��:C�F��:>] �Z�eLT�F�L$] �Z��½v�B�»:M] �T� ������L�SBAPJMA ` 6!EB6 ��� ��� � ��� ���£]£Oi:�f6yd�:<7\SB: ��� � ���,� ������eJM6!SFS[R>JMAQH>6G=£HIRM6�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?B= HI6G7$HIACOQ=@J>=NAiwM:&6GJK?FEF:PO�LZ6�7N6�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f: �Z��½9�96 �Z� ���B�­n �

���b8��Jx�=�@ GCF�GC��R�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6C¦

� � ��� ���� ���V� �&� ��� ���A�� �Z�v� �y�

6� � ��� ��y� ���9� �&� ��� ���Ay� �Z�9� �y�

SB6 ��J>APJ�f6�7N=@LZ6GEc:&=@J �~���SFS[=\:>¦{=N7I_CRT:<JK?B=@aT8G:<?BACEB6mRMJ>= ` 6GEcSB:P7@69H>: ` :<JK?B=K:�R>Jy83APJTHI=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6V=NJy8GR>=K7N: ` :PEB=\:<LM=@7N69_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?c:283ACOQ;M:<EF6SBAP7NA�J>6!7@7�X :PJK?B6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6.f6�7@AChP=\8G:PO&6!JK?B6l6k_KR>= ` :P7@6!JC?F6�:P7v8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6l=N7u8GR>=u:<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B6�f6�_KRM:PJC?F=raZ8G:b?FA6!SB=\SU?F6GJ>j!=N:P7@OQ6GJK?F6¢�e6�7NA¢S[?B6!SFSBA¢:P8G8!:PHI6.:P7�_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?FAPEF6D6!SB=NS[?B6!J>jG=\:<7N6.8cw>6.HI= ` =@6!J>6.R>J _KRM:PJK?B=@aT8G:<?BAPEF6R>J>= ` 6!EFSF:<7N6�;M:PSFSB:PJMHIA&J>6G7N7�X :PJC?F6!8G6!HI6!JC?F6�HI6G7£8GAPJMH>=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6k�3n

�W={wM:M]>;Z6GE2_KRM:<JK?FA&EF=NhPRM:PEFH>:y7\:y;MEB=NOi:>]I=N7£S[6!hPR>6!JK?B6�OQ63?F:"�º:P7@LZ6GEFAQS[6!OQ:PJK?B=\83A0��8cw>6sSB=$8cw>=NRMHI6k�3¦

Page 150: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� �

� � y���I�/�������� �$� � ��������

�����

�$� y���I�V� � ���

�+� ����I�/�� � � �

�+� ���$�� ���/� �� � ���Ay� �Z�v��� ���

�$� ��� ��y� ���V� �y���

� � ����I����������

� � ���$�� ���/� �$� � ��������

�����

� � � �

�$� y���I�/�� � ����I�V��� ���

�+� ���Ay� ���9� � ���

� � ��� ���� ���9� �&�/�������������

��

��

��

��

��

� � ��� ��y� ���9� �&� ��� ���A�� �Z�v� � ���

6P]M;T6!E2_CRT:<JK?BAQEF=@hCRM:<EcH>:s7\:iSB6!83ACJMH>:M]WSB=$wM:&=N7£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6�OQ63?c:��p:<7NLT6!EBAQ8cw>6�S[= 8cw>=@RTHI6P¦

� � y���I�/�������� �$� � ��������

�����

�+� ����I�/�� � � �

�$� ���A�� �Z����$� y���I�V� � ���

� � � �Ay� ���V��� ���

�+� ���^���� �Z�u� �y�����

� � � ��������

�$� y���I�/�� � ����W�9� � ���

� � ����I���� � �q�� �Z�/���

� � � ��������

�+� ����I�/�� � y���I�V� � ���

�$� � �

�����

�+� � �$�� ���V� � ���

� � ��� ���� ���v���y�/�����������

��

��

��

��

��

� � ���^��y� �Z�u� �&� ��� ���Ay� �Z�9� � ���

�W=WACSFSB6GE ` =W8cw>6uJ>6!7KEc:<OQA�;>=[fR&:�HI6!S[?BEc:=@7WJ>AIHIA � � y���I�V� � �MS[=WAP?[?B=N6GJM6uHM:�� � ��� ���� ���v��� �>=NJC?FEBAIHIR&�836!JMHIAD�e6 ` 6!JC?FRM:<7NOQ6GJK?B6¾�vR>JM:i8GACS[?F:<JK?F6�H{X R��,83=NA.�e=NJD_KRM:<JK?BAQJ>6!7$Ec:<OQAQJ>APJ0S[ACJ>AQ6 ` =\HI6GJ>j!=N:<?B6s8GACS[?F:<JK?F=\�3©=NJ ` 6!8G6P]IJ>6!7$EF:POQA&HI= 836GJK?FEBAT]I=@7$JMAWH>A � � ����W�9� � � SB={A<?B?B=N6GJ>6sSB6GOQ;>EF6�H>: � � ��� ��y� ���9� � ��]>Oi:QSBAWHMHI= �S[d�:P836!JMHIAC7@A,8GAPJ07N:l83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�:i=NJC?FEBAIHIAP?[?c:Q;T6!ESBAWHMHI=NS[d�:<EF6�=N7£J>AIHIA � � � �Ay� ���/�~��8cw>6sEF=\8cw>=@6kHI6�R>JM:,EB6!hPAP7\:HI6!7$om�¤?B=N;TAW�­n�

���b8��Jx�=�@ GCF�GCz�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB6 � ��� � � ����� � � ���Z�m� � � � ����� ������W={wM:M¦

Page 151: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��>}

� � � ��

� � ��� ��� ���

�+� � � ��������

�+� � � ���Z�/������

� � � � �

�+� � � �

� � � �&� � � ���

� � ��� � ����� �����/����$� ��� ����� ��� ��� ���

� �N� ��� ����� ��� �����m� � �^� ����� ���Z�/���

¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFA0f6sEF=@Oi:PS[?BA�:<;Z6GEB?BA��YS[=^ACSFS[6!E ` =^8cw>6P]ZJ>6G7^Ec:<OQAl:,SB=@JM=NS[?BEc:>]Z;T6!E�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PEB6 � � � � ��� �(AI8G83ACEBEF6R>JM:,JKRMA ` :i8GACS[?F:PJC?F6P]T6P]TSB6�SB=£RMSF:PSFSB6�JKRMA ` :POQ6GJK?B6s:M]M7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAlSB= 8cw>=NRMHI6!EB6!L>LT6sd�:P836!JMHIAI83=^83ACJM837NRMHI6!EB6�=NJOQAIHIAy6!EBEFAPJM6GAy8cwM67\:&;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6�f6 ` :P7@=\H>:K�­nm526!7$HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA�� � �k:M] L$��83ACJ�7�X =@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6 �Z��:K�B��:M]�Z�eLT�F�L$] �T�Y½9�F���k:I���e=NJId�:b?B?B=WJ>6G7WEc:<OQA ` =Tf6��+� � � �I6 � � � ���3] �T� ��� � �!L$���eAC;>;>R>EF6 �Z� ���F���I]¾=NJ�_KRM:<JK?BAJ>6G7Ec:<OQA ` =£f6�SBAP7NA � � � � �\�­]ISB=MwM:�8cw>6 ��� ���.f62d�:<7\SB:M]P6�_KR>=NJMHI= � � ����� � � ��� ` 6GEc:>]<OQ6GJK?FEB6���� � ����� �����f6�d�:<7\SF:�=NJD_CRT:<JK?BA � �&� � �Df6�d�:<7\SF:>]I6!SFSB6GJMHIAQ½*: ` 6!EF:y6 ��:�d�:P7NSF:>n �

�~=\:PSFS[RMO&=\:<OQAiSF8cw>6GOi:b?F=N8!:<OQ6GJK?F6�7N6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>= ` :<7N=NH>6�8cw>6sS[?F:<LM=@7N=NSF83ACJ>AQ=$Ec:<;>;ZAPEB?B=�deEc:Q= _KRM:PJC?F=raX�8G:<?BACEB=�6�=$83APJMJ>63?B?B= ` ={7NAPhC=N8G=Y]I=NJ ` =r?c:<JMHIA&7NA&S[?BRMH>6GJK?B6�: ` 6!EB=@aT8G:PEBJM6�7\: ` :<7N=\HI=r?bf:Q83APJ�=@7{OQ6G?BAIHIAiHI6G7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFASB6GOi:<JK?B=\83AD�Y83APJ � SB={=NJC?F6GJMH>6�R>JM:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6�_KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=\�3n5 � 1�8�|�N&?�=�@A<>=�9%L�N@�q�>N&<$9�=�: :�N 9�@XL�= 8�<>8��AN&?;=�@$<D8 �

� � � �$�� �Z� � ���$���� �Z�� � ���$�� ��� �������$��y� �Z�� � ��� �$�� �Z� � ���$��y� �Z�� � � ���$�� ��� � � �$��y� ���

� ��1�8�|�N&?;=�@$<D=�9%L�N �q�DN&<$9�=�: :�N 9�@XL�= 8 :;@A<>�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8 �� � � �^��y� �Z� �9�y� � ���A�� �Z� ���� � � �^��� �9y� �Z�B� � � �����A�� �Z�� � � �^��y� �Z� �9�l� ���[� � � �Ay� ���£� � �A��� ���� � ���^���� �Z�^�9�y� � ���$�� �Z�^���� � ���^��� �9y� �Z�B� � � � ���$�� �Z�� � ���^���� �Z�^�9�l� ���[�V� ���Ay� �Z�^�����A��� �Z�

� � 1�8�|�N&?;=�@$<D=�9%L�N �q�DNX<$9b=�: :�N�9b@ALk= 8�yD=��b�$=��><D?;=�@$<D8 �� � � �^��y� �Z� �9�y� � ���A�� �Z� ���� � � �^��� �9y� �Z�B� � � �����A�� �Z�� � � �$�� �Z�£� � �$�l� �Z�V� ��� ���� ���£�9�l� �Z�B�� � ���^���� �Z�^�9�y� � ���$�� �Z�^���

Page 152: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��;�� � ���^��� �9y� �Z�B� � � � ���$�� �Z�� � ���^���� �Z�^�9�l� ���[� � ���Ay� �Z�^�����A��� �Z�

7 ��1�8�|�N&?;=�@$<D=�9%L�N �q�DN&<$9�=�: :�N 9�@XL�=u8 :;@A<>y>=�?�=�@A<>N&|�8 �

� � � �^��y� �Z�v� �y� ��� ���$�� ���9� �y�� � � �^��� � �� ���[� ����� � ���Ay� �Z�B�� � � �^��y� �Z�v� �l� �Z�B�V��� ���Ay� �Z�9� � �$�l� �Z�[�� � ���^���� �Z�u� �y� ��� � �$�� �Z�V� �y�� � ���^��� � �� ���[� ����� � ���A�� �Z�B�� � � ���A�� �Z�u� ���$�l� ���[�v� ��� ���� �Z�9���l� ���[�

¿$6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=$SBAPJ>Ai_KRM:CS[=�?FRI?[?F6�S[AP?[?FAydeACEBOi:QHI=$LM=N8GAPJMHI=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P©I=NJ0_KR>6!7@7N6sSBA<?[?FA&deAPEFOQ:QHI=^83ACJMHI=i�jG=NAPJT:<7N69J>ACJ�f6 ` :<7N=\HIA=N7>83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6v=NJ ` 6GEcS[ATn£¿£:�7N=NS[?F:�;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6vEB=NOi:<J>6 ` :<7N=NH>:�:PJM8cw>6uS[6uJ>6!hP7N=WSF8cw>6!O&=aMhCR>EF:PJ>A/^3ª�^�:P;T6!E[?F6.�e;>RMEF8cwu®6 ��J>APJqSB=N:07N=NLT6!EF:0=NJ �~�­nD�W=9A<?B?B6GJMhPAPJMA�OQAC7r?F=VL>=\83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJM:P7@= ` :P7@=\HI=VSB6,S[==NJC?FEBAIHIRT83APJMA,HIR>6s_KRM:<JK?F=raT8!:b?FAPEF=£83ACJ�=NJMHI=\836yHI= ` 6GEcS[AD�Y83APJD7�X =@;ZA<?F6!SB= 8cw>6-��� �>�~SB=\:QA<?[?F6GJWRI?c:,S[AKSU?F=r?FR>6GJTHIA�,J>6!7@7N6�AI8G8GAPEFEB6!J>jG6�7@=NLZ6GEF6�H>= ��=NJ ��� �M�[�­©T:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM¦

� � ���A�� �Z�^� ���A�l� �Z� � ��� {���� ���£�9�l� >�[�

� � � �$�� ���$��� �$�l� ��� � ����� {���� ���$���l� >�B�

� �[� � -0³s#Q%(1��.±~³�/21G)y#04 ·�-D´­%(1 �D´G³ 4¥³s´ ��42'm1¹±��04 ��³s#D#0)¸³s´G´ �[1G# ��#D1­%^)526!hP7N=~6!SB6GOQ;>=2HI=2:P7@LZ6GEF=~S[6!Oi:<JK?B=\83=28cw>60:<LML>=N:POQA�=NJM83ACJK?BEc:b?BA�J>6!7~;M:<Ec:<hCEF:<deA.;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�SB=~;T6!E ` 6GJ>= ` ::<7N7\:i8cw>=@RTS[R>Ec:&A,:<7N7N:&?F6GEFOQ=@JM:PjG=NAPJ>6sH>6G7N7@A,S ` =@7NR>;>;ZA,=NJ�RMJDJKRMO&6!EBAQaTJ>=r?FAlHI=$;T:PSFS[=�]T8G=@AMf6�J>APJDSB=*f6s:<JT83APEc:` 6!EB=@aT8!:b?BA2_KRM:PJK?BA: ` 6 ` :<OQA2:PJ>JWR>JM83=\:b?FA2=NJ�S[6kHI6V=NJK?BEFAIHIRI?[?F= ` :Mn opJ�_KR>6kSU?FA�;M:PEF:PhPEc:bdeAu6!SF:<OQ=NJ>=\:<OQA�:<JT83APEc:_KRM:<7\8cw>6;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM62;T6!E~SU?FRMHI=\:<EFJ>6�7\: ` :P7@=\HI=@?¾f:y6 ` 6kHIEF6GOQAy_KRM:P7N8cw>66!SB6GOQ;>=NAyHI={:P7@LZ6GEFA�=N7{83R>={S ` =N7NR>;>;ZA` :Q: ` :PJK?B=$:<7N7�X =NJIaMJ>=@?BATn

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC�B�C�Hv�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6� � ������ ��� � � ��� ���

� � ��� ������ � �� ��� � �

�*6!H>=N:PO&A S[AC7@Aq=N78!:PSBA � � � ���� � � ��� ��� �e7\:PSF83=\:<JMHIAq=N7�83APJTHI=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6D=NJ ` 6GEcS[A�6�=@7�S[6k83APJTHIAL>=\83ACJMHI=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6�;Z6GE~6!SB6GEc83=NjG=NAK�3¦

Page 153: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��P|

�$� � � ��������

�$� � � ��

�+� � � � �

�$� ���� �

�+� � �� � �

� � � � �

� � � � � � � ���

� � � � � ��� � �

�+� � � � ���� �

� � ����� ���� y� � � � � � � �

�W={;ZACSFS[ACJ>A&d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6 ` 6!EB=@aT8!:<EF6�:PJM8cw>6�7@6�SB6GhCR>6GJK?B={hC6GJ>6!EF:P7@=NjGjk:<j!=@ACJ>=Y¦� � �������y� � � >� � � ���A�� �£� I�� � ��� ��T�� �£� I� � �� ���$�� � � >�

����b8��Jx�=�@ GC�B�C+ER�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�8cw>6C¦ � � ������ ���&� � ��� ��� �n

�W={wM:M¦

� � � � ��������

�$� � � ��

�+� � � � �

� � ��� ��� ��

�+� � �� � �

� � � ��� � � ���

�+� ������ ��� ���

� � ��� � ���� &� � ��� ��� ���

Page 154: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��"��W={;>R^fA ` 6GEF=@aT8G:PEB6;>=[fR0=NJ0hP6GJM6GEc:<7N6�8cw>6C¦ � � ������T�� � � >�m� �� ���Ay� �£� >�

���b8��Jx�=�@ GC�B�CF�z�*6!EB=@aT8G:PEB6�SB6 � � � � �� ���&� �� � � ��� �nopJ0_CRM6!S[?BAQ6!SB6GOQ;>=NAQ=@JMH>=N8cw>=\:<OQAQ7N6s83ACS[?F:PJK?B=�]>83APJ �&`¾] � � ] � � ] � � ] � � ]$n3n!nGnm¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFA&EF=\S[R>7@?F:M¦

n!nGn�+� ���� � � � �>�U}��C�� � � � � � � �º�[}%�W�� � � � � � � �º�[}!|K��$� � � � � � �º�[}��P��$� � � � � � �º�[}P}k�� � ��� ��� � � ���>�U} � �� � � � ��� � � ���I� � ��+� ���� � � ���>� � ��+� ���� � � ���>� Á �� � � � � �T`"�p� À ��$� � �&` � � �º���P�� � � � ��� � ` ���I���K��+� ���� �&` ���>��|K�� � �� ��� ��� �p���C��$� ��� ������ �p�U}k�

� � ��� ������ &� �� � � ��� ���

�"*o5�#srC§�YW5��"!$#�t*o(J>AIHI=M8cwM62S[=TA<?[?F6GJ>hCAPJ>A�H>:P7@7\:�Ec:PHI=\836C]P83=NAMf6��[}k�^6����P�­]CEB=\8cw>=N6!HIACJ>A�6GJK?BEc:<OyL>=>R>JT:�EB6!hPAP7\:HI6!7Io[o[o ?B=N;ZAMn(opJK?BEFAWH>RM83=\:<OQA�_CRM=@JMH>=>R>JM:�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6uH{X R��,83=NAi���&`G� 62SBAIH>HI=\SUaT:POQA&�[}k� 6s���C�9�Y8cw>6uJ>APJ ` :<JMJ>A83ACJK?BEc:PSFS[6!hPJM:<?B=��283ACJ�6kSBSF:>]{AP?[?B6!J>6GJTHIA0=*J>AIHI=2��|K��6D���K�­n �R>6kSU?F=*R>7r?F=@OQ=*EF=N8cwM=@6kHIAPJ>A�R>JM:�EF6GhCAP7\:lHI6!7*om�?B=N;ZA�6�_CRM=@JMH>=v7N=uS[AIH>HI=\S[aT:<OQA.EF=NSB;Z63?[?F= ` :PO&6!JK?B6083APJ¹7@6�JKRMA ` 6l8GACS[?F:<JK?F= � � 6 � � ]m7N=v8GAPJK?BEc:PSFSB6GhPJT:<OQA06A<?B?B6!J>=N:POQAs=TJMAWH>=^���P�*6&� À �­n �:<?BA�8cwM6:<LML>=N:POQAs=@JK?FEBAIHIAP?[?BAyHIR>6�JWR>A ` =Z83ACS[?F:PJK?B=TH>APL>L>=\:<OQAsEF=@?BAPEFJM:PEB6~:<=J>AIHI=^�U}k�m6����C�(6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PEB7N=T8GAPJi6!SFSB6~6�S[=ZA<?B?B6!J>hPACJ>A�=MJ>AIHI=^� Á �­]�� � �3]{� � �*6��U} � �­n �R>6kSU?F=MEF=N8cw>=N6!H>APJ>A�R>JT:

Page 155: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}��;�EF6GhPAC7N:�HI6G7�om� ?B=N;TAQ6_KR>=NJMHI=$SB={S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:<J>A&83ACJl_KRM:b?B?BEFA�JWR>A ` 6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B= � � ] � � ] � � 6 � � ]I6�S[=�A<?B?B6!J>hPACJ>A={J>AIHI=V�[}P}¾�­]{�U}k�P�­]$�[}!|K�V6i�[}%�K�3nm¼.:&83APJ0_KR>6!S[?B6�JWR>A ` 6�8GACS[?F:<JK?F= ` :PJ>J>AQEB=N6!SF:<OQ=NJM:b?F=�={J>AIHI=m�U}¾�v6Q���P�96�=@7;>EFAI836!H>=@OQ6GJK?FAQ8GAPJK?B=NJWRM:>nopJQ_CRM6!S[?BA�8G:CS[A�f6~HI6G7W?FRI?[?FA�6 ` =NH>6GJK?B6~8cw>6u=N7IO&6k8G8!:<J>=\S[OQA ` :�: ` :PJC?F=>:<7N7YX =NJIaMJ>=@?BAi�e7�X :<7NLT6!EBA�J>ACJ&SB=I;TAP?BEbf:Oi:<=W8cw>=NRMHI6GEF6k�3n 5�69SB6GhPRM6V8cw>6m7\:2;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6*J>ACJQf6 ` :P7@=\H>:>n£op7CEc:<OQA2=NJMHI=\8G::<JM8cw>6VR>J�8G:CS[A�=@J�8GR>=K7N:~;MEBA��;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6yf6d�:P7NSF:>n��W=£;TACJ>6 � �»� �&`k� � � � � � � � � �M� � � � � � �%a%abar��6��Z� ���2�»�K���&`b� � � �3�!��� � � � � �3�!��� � � � � �3�%aba%a@��eAKSBSB=\:i7@6&83AC;>;>=N6���� ¡ � � � �u?c:<7N=^8cwM6S�+� � � ¡ � � �vf6�J>6!7 Ec:<OQAW�­n2opJD?c:<7(8G:CS[A,7�X :<JK?B6k836!H>6GJK?B6,f6 ` 6!EBAT]MACSFSB=N:i;Z6GEAPhCJ>=(6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA0H>6G7*HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA ` 6yJM6�f6yR>JMA08cwM6�f6Q83ACJ�7NR>=*J>6!7@7\:�EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6 �T� ���­]$OQ6!JC?FEB6&=N7m83APJTS[6!hPR>6!JC?F6f6�d�:<7\S[AT]{ACSFS[=\:iJ>ACJ ` =9f6yJM6G7*HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA�:P7N8GR>J�6!7@6!O&6!JK?BA�?F:<7N6Q8cw>6�?FRI?[?F=*hP7N=(6G7N6GOQ6GJK?B=*HI= ��wM:<JMJ>A�8GAPJ�7@R>=7\:lEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6 �Z� ��� � nG��J�:<7@?BEFAl6kS[6!OQ;>=@A0HI=mSB=r?FRM:<j!=@ACJ>6�=NJ�8GR>=*7\:,;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6lf6sd�:<7\SF:.f6&=@7*SB6GhCR>6GJK?B6C¦�SB6

����� �Z� k��6 �Z���I�F� �T] �T��3�B� b] �Z� ���F���W���Z� G�­�!��¾� �I�­��:P7@7NAPEc:&7YX :<JK?F6!836kHI6GJK?F6Qf6 ` 6!EBAD�e;MEB6kS[AiR>J._KRM:P7NSB=\:PSB=6G7N6GOQ6!JC?FA.HI6G79HIAPOQ=NJ>=@A ` 6iJ>6Df6iR>JMA.83APJq8GR>=2f6i=NJqEB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>60�e=NJId�:<?[?B=u:�f6Q=NJqEB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6i83ACJ ¾]£6 �f6i=NJEF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6�83ACJ �W�3]�O&6!JK?BEF6�=N7^8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJK?B6,f6�d�:<7\SBAl;ZAP=\8cwv®6�J>ACJ ` =9f6�R>J�6!7@6!O&6!JK?BA�8GAPJ.8GR>=^?BRI?B?B=*S[ACJ>A,=NJEF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6��YS[62?BRI?B?B=>deAKSBSB6GEFA�=@JiEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6~83ACJ �T]C=@J �Z� �� ` =THIA ` EF6GL>LZ6GEFA�6!SFS[6!EB6u6GJK?FEF:PO�LZ6~7@628GAP;>;>=N6����T� �I�6y��¾� �I�3]KOQ6!JC?FEB6�SB62?BR>?[?B=ZdeAKSBSB6GEFAs=NJlEF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6�83ACJ ¾]W=@J �T� ��� ` =�HIA ` EF6GL>LZ6GEFAs6!SFSB6GEF626GJK?BEc:<OyLT67@6�83AC;>;>=N6���Z� 3�v6i��¾� 3�[�3n �

op7(OQ6!8G8!:<J>=\SBO&A�8cw>6&;>R fA�d�:<E�SB8!:b?[?c:<EF6�7NA�S ` =@7NR>;>;ZA0:<7N7YX =@J>aMJ>=@?BA0S[=(;>EF6!SB6GJK?F:M]{:PHD6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]$_CRT:<JMHIA�S[=wM:&R>J0J>AIHIAiHI6!7{?B=N;TAT¦�+� � �������� �

opJId�:<?[?B=�]MSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C836GJTHIAP7NAi83APJ � ` ]MSB=�?BEFA ` :>¦�+� ���� �&` �

8cw>6C]C;Z6GEv7N:sEB6!hPAP7\:�HI6!7Tom� ?B=N;TAT]IS[=Z83APJK?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:�6SB=ZSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:s8GAPJ,RMJM:sJWR>A ` :�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6C]K:CHQ6!SB6GOQ;>=NA � � ¦�+� � �Z} �T� ��n

¿mX =NJC?FEBAIHIRMjG=NAPJ>6�HI= � � 8GAPOQ;TACE[?c:�=N7$EF=@6kSB:POQ6�HI6!7$J>AIHIAQ=NJ>=@j!=N:P7@6�6�SB=$wM:M¦�+� ���� � � �8cw>6C]IJKRMA ` :POQ6GJK?B6C]IEB=\8cw>=N6!HI6�R>JM:&JWR>A ` :Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6i��SB=\: � � �v6sS[={wM:M¦�+� � � � � � �ºn

�W=£H>6 ` 6�:P7@7NAPEc:�EF=N6!SF:<OQ=@JT:<EF6=N7{J>AIHIAi=NJ>=@j!=N:P7@6�6�SB=$wM:>¦�+� ���� � | �

SB={;>EBAKS[6!hPR>6�83ACJ$¦�+� � � � � � �83AKSpf � ` =\:Q:<7N7YX =@J>aMJ>=@?BAMn

�W=*AP?[?B=N6GJM6&RMJ�OQAIHI6G7N7NA08GAPJ ��� � �&`¾� � � � � � � � � �%aba%ar�Q6 �Z� ��������:>}C] :��P�3]N�Y:;�I] :P|K�­]\��:C|>] :"�K�3]@nNnNn�8cwM6yEF6GJMH>6` 6!EF:y7\:y;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6 � �������� �n�W=$;MR fAi83APOyR>JM_KR>6�ACSFSB6GE ` :PEB6�8cw>6�?F:P7@6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6�S[= S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:&:PJM8cw>6C]IO&AC7r?FAQ;>=[fRDSB6GOQ;>7N=N8G6GOQ6GJK?F6P]>83ACJ��� � �M��6��Z� ���2���K���T� �I�c�Cn

�2JMAQS ` =@7NR>;>;ZA,:<7N7�X =NJIaMJ>=@?BAiSB=£HI6G?B6GEFOQ=@JT:&:PJM8cw>6�SB6�SB=$wM:Q:Q8cw>6�d�:PEB6�83ACJ�RMJ�JMAWH>AQH>6G7{?F=@;ZAM¦� � ����� ���� �

opJId�:<?[?B=�]{S[6�7@AlSB=(S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:,83ACJ �T`b]{S[= wM:>¦ � � ���� �&` ��]Z=N7 _KRM:P7@6�EB=\8cw>=N6!HI6sRMJM:,EF6GhCAP7\:&H>6G7^om� ?B=N;ZA�8cw>6�H f:� � � �&` � � ��8GAPJ,7\:�JWR>A ` :s83AKSU?c:<JK?B6 � � ]I8cw>68GAPOQ;TACE[?c:�=@7�EF=@6kSB:POQ62HI6G7�J>AIHIAs=NJ>=NjG=\:<7N6�6�S[=T?BEFA ` : � � � �� � � ��]H>:Q83RM=£S[6!hPR>6 � � � � � � � �£6�83AKSºf � ` =\:>n���b8��Jx�=�@ GC�B�C�B ¡9S[6!O&;M=@AU�Mn9�9=$8cw>=N6!H>=N:PO&AiSB6P¦

�WAIH�� � �o� ��� �£� � ������ ����� � � � �¾� � ��� �Z� ���~� ����s� ����W�c�Cn¿mX :<7NLZ6GEFA&8cw>6�=NJ>=NjG=\:i83APJ£¦� � & C>���5�$#F& � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � / � ��� ������� !�#F�%C/.5&(&>HI#F!5&>�0� &>E,&>� �4&.�$��� ��COCO��!5& �5&>�3�5���4�4D �,&>� &>E,�5#F�5- � � ��� � D4� &O�4&>E,�5#F�

!5#�� # �4@J��L>#F���5&=#F�,CO@$#��B� �5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& & 1���F� � &=#F��� &>?�@5&>�0� & �I& � �'#F�5�4#F&OE,&�!$&O#�� @5E,&>D #J�J�N�4@5DM���F#�& � �#� ��'&>� �4&OD4& E,#F�5��D4&"!���F�F��DM� & H0&OD4� ��� ��� �4&>CO&>!5&>�0� & ��&>D���?��5#�� @5E,&>D � �J�N�4@5DM���F&=�5& &>� #F��� &=@5�5�(!5#�C>@5#�&O�4� � & E,#F�5��D4& � �J�����M�(�5D &>�5!$&OD4& #F�J�4@5C>CO&>�4� ��D &!5&>��� @5E,&>D � /!5E,&>�0� D4& &�1���F�4�.#F��CO���$� &>?�@5&>� �4&(&O�4#F�4�4& @5�A� @5E,&>D � � �M���F& C/.$& � @$���4#%#2� @5E,&>D #2�4���5�"E,#F�5��D4#�!5# � -

Page 156: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� 
�$� ����� � �T� � �2� ������ ����W�/��+� � ������ � �

�+� � �o� ��� � �

` :q: ` :<JK?B=2:P7@7�X =NJIaMJM=r?FA ��6D=@7S[6k83APJTHIA�J>AIHIAgf6D_CRM6G7N7@A¢8cw>60=NJ>J>6kSU?c: ��83APOQ6.SB=�f6 ` =NS[?BAq=NJ ;>EB6k836kHI6GJ>jk:��=N7~O&6k8G8!:<J>=\S[OQAqHI=2S ` =@7NR>;>;ZAq:<7N7YX =@J>aMJ>=@?BAK�3]96DSB=2HI6!H>RM836.8cw>6�7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6�f6DSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pngop72HIACO&=NJ>=NA�67�X =NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6�8cwM6�EB6!JMHIAPJMA ` 6GEF6�7@6s?BEF6�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM={EB=\S[RM7r?c:<J>AT¦ ���»� �&`¾� � � � � � � � � �%aba%a �y6 �T� ������K���&`¾� � � �­�!��� � � � � �­�k���&`¾� � � �­�k��� � � � � �­�k���&`¾� � � �­�k��� � � � � �3�!��� � � � � �3�%aba%a@��� �W��� � � � > �&¦ � ��� � > ���e6lSB=m;>R^fA=\HI6GJK?B=@aT8!:<EF6 � 8GAPJ�7YX =@JTS[=N6GOQ6sHI6!={JKRMO&6!EB=£JM:b?FR>EF:P7@=�6 �Z� ���u8GAPJ07\:yEF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6�6!SFS[6!EB6�OQ=@J>ACEB6 � �3n�

��SFS[6!E ` =\:<OQA�ACEF:�8cw>62!o��!��W#%.e*$,-#���5q�%��!$�&«1��!A\�,-��#W�W#%.e*$5 «1��!(���".j5+!A5;Z[!X5+\�5�n(xH&6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]X5+3A.h����#%3+3i���#%3+3i#j\�,-#�*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!A5uH>6G7$;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6�¡VSB6GOQ;>=NA À n �Mn �M¦

� �o� ��� �£� � ������ ����� � � ���Z� ���~� ����s� ����W�n>§�!o#F«1#W�1�3§",05�§�./#W!A\s#(�;��.U5+!$� 5+!�Z�!X5+\m�bnq�96GEc8cw>=\:<OQA.HI=u8G:<;M=@EF6,;Z6GEc8cwv®6Pn�526G7uHIACO&=NJ>=NA �Y8cw>6lJ>ACJ f6,Oi:<=` R>A<?FAK� ` =$HI6 ` 66kSBSB6GEF6:P7@OQ6GJMAyR>J�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA ��`¾nm½(6!E97\:y;>EB=NOi:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6 ��`�J>ACJ�f6�=NJlEF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM683ACJSB6�SU?F6!SFS[ATn^½(6!Em7\:sS[6k83ACJMH>:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6 ` =TH>6 ` 6�6!SFS[6!EB62RMJ,=@JTHI= ` =\HIR>A�8GAPJ,8GR>= ��`�f6~=@J,EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>6~6P]I8GAPOQ6SB=Vf6&:<;>;Z6GJM:lHI63?B?BAM]Z?c:<7N6�=NJMHI= ` =\HIR>AT]TJMAPJ.;ZA<?F6GJMHIA�6!SFS[6!EB6 ��`�SU?F6!SFS[AT]THI6 ` 6�6kSBSB6GEF6�R>J�S[6k83APJTHIAi6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FAHI6!7>HIAPOQ=NJ>=@AT]<83=NAMf6 � � n^x�JM8cw>6 � � JMAPJ�;MR fA6kSBSB6GEF6V=NJ&EB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6v83APJ&S[6uS[?B6!SFSBA&��;T6!E^7\:;>EB=NOi:�;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>6¾�6lHI6 ` 6i6kSBSB6GEc83=mRMJq=@JMH>= ` =\HIR>A�8GAPJ¢83RM=~f6,=NJqEB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6D��;T6!E�7\:.S[6k83ACJMH>:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k�3n �^:<7N6i6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FAJ>ACJ.;>R fA�6!SFS[6!EB6 � � ��8GAPOQ6ySB=9f6�:<;>;Z6GJT:�HI6G?[?FAK�­]�Oi:,JMAPJ�;MR fAl6kSBSB6GEF6sJ>6!O&OQ6!J>A ��`b©{=NJId�:<?[?B=�]$SB6sdeACSFSB6 � �=NJ�EF6G7\:<j!=@ACJ>68GAPJ � ` ]I;ZAP=\8cwu®6 � ` f6�=NJlEF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM683ACJ � � ]>HM:<7N7N:s?B6GEFj!:y;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6y��;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:s?BEc:<JMSB=r?F= ` :K�SB6GhPRM=@EF6GL>LZ6D8cw>6 � � f6�=NJgEB6!7N:PjG=NAPJ>6083ACJ � � ��8GACSF:�8cwM60:PL>L>=\:<OQA�6!SF837NRMSBAK�­n �R>=NJMHI= � � HI6 ` 606!SFSB6GEF6�=NJEF6G7\:<jG=NAPJM6s83APJ�R>J.R>7@?B6!EB=NAPEF6�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA � � HI6!7^HIACOQ=@J>=NAMn52R>A ` :<OQ6!JC?F6P] � � HI6 ` 6s6!SFSB6GEF6�[email protected]\:<j!=@ACJ>6s83ACJR>J�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BA0HI6!7(H>APOQ=@JM=@A��e;Z6GE�7\:�SB6!8GAPJMH>:l;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6k�26�?c:<7N6y6!7@6!O&6!JK?BA�J>APJ.;MR fA�6kSBSB6GEF6�Ju®6 � ` ]{Ju®6� � ]mJu®6 � � �Y:<7@?BEF=@OQ6!JC?F=9;Z6GEQ7\:.?F6GEFj!:�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM6lS[=vA<?B?B6!EBEF6GL>LZ6�R>JM:�8GAPJK?BEc:PHMHI=@j!=@ACJ>6l8GAPJ¹7\:.;MEB=NOi:C�­]_KR>=NJMHI=£HI6 ` 6�6kSBSB6GEF6�R>JD_CRT:<EB?BAQ6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA � � ]>6s83AKSºf � ` =\:>]>6sSB=£HI6kHIRM836s8cwM6 � 8GAPJK?B=N6GJ>6�=NJIaMJM=r?F=£6G7N6GOQ6!JC?F=Yn®¡¤;>EFAP;>EF=NA�7�X 6kS[=\S[?B6GJMj!:0HI=m;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=m8cw>6,SBAPJMA0SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@=mSBAP7NADS[RqHIACO&=NJ>=m=NJIaMJM=r?F=98cw>6i6 ` =\HI6!J>jG=\:7�X =NJMHI6k83=\HI=@LM=@7N=r?bf:iHI6G7£;>EBAI8G6!HI=NOQ6GJK?BAiHI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAiS[6!Oi:<JK?B=\83ATn

� � � � )�'*'*4u% %^42/~/~³ 4 ±~)y· �D´34u%(42/~/~³ +D4�´ ·¸4u%(),+D) +D4�´!´��U³s´ ��42'*) ¶^4��· ³s#&%(1G±~)

¿£:�83ACEBEF63?B?B6!jGj!:�607N:�83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:�HI6G7~OQ6G?BAIHIA�HI6G7N7YX :<7NLZ6GEFA�SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GA�;Z6GEQ7\:�7NAPhC=N8!:�HI6!=~;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=~S[=HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<J>As8GAPJiR>Ji;>EFAI836kHI=@OQ6!JC?FA�OQAP7@?BA�SB=@OQ=N7@6:s_KR>6G7N7@A�=@OQ;>=N6GhK:b?BA�;Z6GE9=@7�8G:P7N8GAP7NA�;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6���;M:��Ec:<hPEc:bdeAs|Mn |K�­]W;Z6GEu83R>={83=�7N=@OQ=@?B=\:<OQAQ:s;>EF6!SB6GJK?F:PEB6�7@6O&AIHI=@aT8cw>6�8cw>6�S[=�EF= ` 6G7\:<J>AsJM6!836kSBSF:<EF=N62;T6!Eu6!S[?B6GJTHI6GEF67N6QH>=@OQACS[?BEc:<j!=@ACJ>=(hP=pf: ` =\SU?F6i:<7*;>EF6!SB6GJK?B6Q83ACJK?B6!S[?BAT©$RI?F=@7N=@j!jG=\:<OQA0=@JMAP7@?BEF6&7\:�J>APOQ6!JM837\:b?FR>EF:l=@JK?FEBAIHIAP?[?F:�=NJ_KR>6G7N7\:&SB6!H>6Pn5 � � @AL�L�8�9 9�8�?�?�N¿£:y83ACEBEF63?B?B6Gj!j!:yS[=�LM:CSB:&S[RM7Td�:<?[?FA&8cw>6�7\:&SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@=@?¾f:&S[=Z?FEF:CS[OQ63?B?B6 ` 6!EFSBA�=N7�LM:PSFS[AT¦^SB6�R>J�Ec:<OQAlf6SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N6s6s7NAlSB=£;>EFAP7NR>J>hK:���AlSB=£L>=@deAPEc8G:K�~:<;>;M7@=\8G:PJMHIAiR>JM:lHI6G7N7@6�EB6!hPAP7N6s:PH0RMJ>A,HI6G=^J>AIHI=�]Z:P7@7NAPEc:&=@7Ec:<OQA�;>EFAP7NR>J>hC:<?BA,�Y:<7NO&6!J>A�RMJ>A�HI6!=TEc:<OQ=T8cwM6�S[=TA<?B?B6GJMhPAPJMA�H>:<7N7\:�L>=@deAPEc8G:<j!=@ACJ>6k�vf6�S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6Pn3�v:CSU?c:HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cw>62?c:<7N6�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf: ` :<7N6_KRM:<JTHIAySB=Z:P;>;>7N=N8!:sR>JT:�_KRM:<7NR>JM_KR>6EB6!hPAC7N:sH>=TR>JMAyHI6!=�_KRM:<?[?FEBA�?F=@;M=Yn

��� & � D4&(�$D ������� #FL>#F���5#%�4���5�"H0&>D & #F�A� ���F&(#F�0�4&OD4�5D &G� ��L>#F���5&.#F� KI@J���0�4� �4#2� D ��!5@5C>���5� #F� ; &>� � @$���I@$E,&OD4� & E,#F�5��D & !5#%� &�4�4&>� �4� � �3&OD ��?��5#��I@$E,&OD4�.�5& &>�4#F�4�4& @5����� �4D � !5#2C>@5# & E,#F�5��D & � �I& @5�<�I@$E,&OD4� & E,#F�5��D4&=!$#�@5� ��� � D4�.& K @5&>�4�4� & E,#F�5��D &=!5#@5�<� &>D L>�"� @5E,&>D � !5���F�F��DM�(#F�2�5D4#FE,� & E,#F�5��D4& !5&>�2�4&>D L>�5-

Page 157: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� Á:K�_�W6l=N7u;>EBAC7@RMJ>hC:PO&6!JK?BA�HI6!7uEF:PO&A�S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6�� f6lAP?[?F6GJWRI?BA�OQ6!HI=\:<JK?F6lR>JM:�EF6GhPAC7N:DH>6G7uo�?B=N;ZA�eAP;M;>R>EF6�7\:,L>=@deAPEc8G:PjG=NAPJ>6,f6�A<?B?B6!JKR>?F:,OQ6kHI=N:PJK?B6�RMJM:lEF6GhCAP7\:iHI6G7(oBo~?B=N;TAW��8cwM6y=N7 Ec:<OQA�;>EBAC7@RMJ>hC:<?BA��:<7NOQ6GJ>AiRMJ>A,HI6G= HIR>6sEc:<OQ={A<?B?B6!JKR>?B= H>AP;ZAi7N:QL>=@deAPEc8G:PjG=NAPJ>6¾�vS[=\:iS[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6sS[=$hC=@RTSU?F=raT8!:Q6!SF:b?-�?F:<OQ6!JC?F6�83ACOQ6�J>6!7^8!:<7\83AP7NA,;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6Cn�9= LM:CSU?c:,:<7N7NAPEc:Q6!SF:<OQ=@JT:<EF6s=@7(8G:CS[Ai=NJ�8GR>=^=@J�� ` =9f6R>J�JMAWH>A,83R>=$SB=£:<;M;>7@=\8G:&R>JT:yEF6GhCAP7\:yH>6G7$oBo[ovAQH>6G7$om�¤?F=@;ZAMnLT�D�9APJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&Ay=@7 8G:PSBAQ=@J083RM=$=@J�� ` = S[=\:&R>J�JMAWH>A,HI6G7�?F=@;ZA/�+� � �$�� ���/� ���W=\:<JMA � 6 �i=N7$HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA6&7�X =@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6QS[R ��8cw>6iS[AIH>H>=NS[d�:<J>A���n �R>=NJMHI=�] � � � � �$�� �Z�­n9�W6,:<7*J>AIHIADSB=m:<;>;M7@=\8G:�7\:EB6!hPAP7\:�H>6G7$oBo[o9?B=N;TAT]>=@7£EF:PO&A�� ` =N6GJ>6�;MEBAC7@R>JMhC:b?FA&8GAPJ0HI6G=£J>AIHI=$HI6G7$?B=N;TA/�$� y���I�/�^;T6!E~7@6s8GACS[?F:<JK?F=:i8cw>6�aMhCR>EF:PJ>AQJ>6G7 EF:POQAMn �W=Vf6sH>=@OQACS[?BEc:b?FA.�e;M:PEF:PhPEc:bdeA/�In |>nN}k�u8cw>6�7@AlSF8cw>6!OQ:����Ay� �Z�u� ����I��f6` :P7@=\HIA�6P]$_KR>=NJMHI=�]£H>: � � � � �Ay� ���­]£SB6GhCR>6 � � � y���I�;T6!E�APhPJM= �Znsx�7@7NAPEc:,=N7*EF:POQAl;>EFAP7NR>J>hK:b?BA.f6S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6�EF=NSB;Z63?[?FAi:<hP7N=$S[?B6!SFSB= � 6 �Tn

8k�D�9APJMSB=NH>6GEF=N:PO&A�ACEF:�=N7Z8!:PSBA�=@J�83R>=T=@J�� ` =ZSB=\:�R>JiJ>AIHIA�H>6G7T?B=N;TAj�+� ���Ay� �Z��� <n���=�SBAPJ>A ��6 �ySBR �8cw>6sS[AIH>H>=NS[d�:<J>A��ln �R>=NJMHI= � � � ���Ay� ���­n��W6y:<7£JMAWH>AlS[= :<;>;>7N=\8G:i7\:iEF6GhPAC7N:QHI6!7£om��?F=@;ZAM]Z=N7£Ec:<OQA� ` =@6!J>6;MEBAC7@R>JMhC:b?FA&8GAPJ�=@7{J>AIHIAh�$� y���I�/�p]>HIA ` 6 �0f6�R>JM:Q8GACS[?F:<JK?F6�8cw>6�J>ACJlaMhCR>Ec:�=NJ���n �R>6kSU?c:` AP7@?F:�J>ACJgSB=~;>R fA�83ACJM837NRMHI6!EB6D8cw>6 � � � y���I�­]v=@J _KRM:<JK?FA ��;MR fAq:PSFS[AI83=\:<EF6�:CH¹:�R>Jg6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FAHI= ��;Z6GE&83R>=�����W�sEB=\SBR>7r?c:0d�:<7\SF:>n �:P7@7�X =@;ZA<?F6!SB= � � � ���$�� ���­]VSB6GhCR>6P]^;Z6GEyH>63aMJ>=NjG=NAPJM6P]*8cw>6,R>JT:LT��EF6G=NJK?B6!EB;>EF63?c:<j!=@ACJ>6&H>= �.EF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEc:_���3�­n(�W=\: ��7�X 6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BA�HI= ��8cw>6Q?c:<7N6iEB6!=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6:PSFS[AI83=\:i: ¾n f¡ :<7N7@ACEF:i8cwM=N:PEBA,8cw>6&S[6�O&AIHI=@aT8cw>=\:<OQA ��=NJ.OQAWH>Al8cw>6y:CSBSBAI83=£:CH ��7YX 6G7N6GOQ6GJK?FA ��]�S[=A<?[?F=@6!J>6~R>JM:�JWR>A ` :�=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �TXP8cw>628GAP=NJM83=\HI6283ACJ �ySB:P7 ` A�:P7>;>=[fRQ;T6!Em=@7Md�:b?B?BAs8cw>6 �TXN���I�m� ��]6u?F:<7N6�8cw>6 �TX � � y���I� `�� n^opJMAP7@?BEF6 �MXKS[AIH>HI=\S[d�:�?BRI?B?B=Z=MJ>AIHI=ZHI=�� ;TAC=N8cwu®6 �MXK83AP=NJM8G=NHI683APJ ���e7\:s_KRM:<7N6;T6!E=N;TAP?B6kS[=(S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:i?FRI?[?F=^=(J>AIHI=(HI=�Q��SF:<7 ` Ai;Z6GE�=N7 OQAIHIA�HI=(=@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<EF6 �06 ��J>ACJ�83ACOQ;M:<EF6=@J0:<7\83R>J0J>AIHIAiHI=�ln �RM=@JMH>=$=@7£EF:PO&A&;>EFAP7NR>J>hK:b?BA�f6�SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N6�EB=\S[;Z63?B?BAi: � 6 �MXNn

x�_KR>6!S[?BAQ;>RMJC?FAi7N:Q8GAPEFEB6G?[?B6!jGjk:>¦H>=@O' � � �

SB=$HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:Q83ACOQ6�JM6G7£8!:PSBAy;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJM:P7@6C¦SB6�HI=NO'�]Z8G=@AMf6sSB6�6!SB=\SU?F6sR>J�:P7@LZ6GEFAl8cw>=NRMSBAi;T6!E � � �p]Z:P7@7NAPEc: � � s]{83=NAMf6� f6 ` :<7N=NHM:>n2opJId�:<?[?F=Y]{SB6S J>ACJdeACSFSB6 ` :P7@=\H>:>]I6kS[=\S[?B6GEF6GLMLT6!EBA�� 6��,8cwM6EF6GJMH>APJ>A ` 6!EF: � � ��9�e6s_KR>=NJMHI=$7�X :<7NLT6!EBAQ83AKSU?F=r?FR>=r?FAiH>:<7$SBAP7NAyJMAWH>A� � ��mSB:PEB6!L>LT6yS[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6¾�­n�¼.:l:P7@7NAPEc:>]T;T6!E�_KRM:PJC?FAlSBAP;>Ec:,HI=NOQACS[?BEc:b?BAT]T=NJ.AChPJ>=^:<7NLT6!EBA,;Z6GE � � �� ` =HIA ` EF6GL>LZ6i6!SFS[6!EB6QR>JqEc:<OQA.SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6.�e;ZAP=\8cwu®6i7\:DSBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N=r?bf:DS[=V?BEc:PSBOQ63?[?F6 ` 6!EFSBA0=@79LM:PSFS[AW�­] 683=pfA.83ACJK?BEc:PH>HI=\836i7�X =@;ZA<?F6!SB=98cw>6,6kS[=\S[?F:0R>J¢:[email protected]>=NRMS[A¢��=@7u_KRM:<7N6i6 ` =\HI6GJK?F6GOQ6GJK?B6lJ>APJqwM:�:<7\83R>J�Ec:<OQASBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N6k�3nI � � � @A�Jx�|�8�9�8�?;?�N�IKy>8;{¢@A|�8 �½(6GE~HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF67\:Q83ACO&;M7@6G?B6Gj!j!:QHIACL>L>=\:<OQAi:<OQ;>7N=N:PEB6�7@6�JMAPjG=NAPJM=$HI=$Ec:<OQAy6sH>=£:<7NLT6!EBAQ83ACOQ;>7@6G?F:<?BAMn

798;:�<>=�?�=�@A<>8��C�GC�H OD!�,F§�./��� �056��5�«1#i«1��.e*$3i#%\º§"\s���%#�Q#Q«cnT5+���%�9�1*�*o�T,-#j�%#U!$��! Q#i«cnT5+���%�9#u*X�k�1�05�#1��#3i#��%#�r��X#%!X\�5X*o,-�c*o,05�#W\TQ§ `c` � � ��� C>#B��E,����&>D &>�4&OD4C>#FLO#F� ��� ��� �4D � CO��� � !5#����$�5�F#FCO��LO#F���$& !5#9@5�J��D &>?����B��!5&>�&(*(*( � #F��� !�C>#F� &<K @J���5!$� #F�*�5� !5� & !5&>�:� #F���

� � ��� � � � #� !JC/.5&(� #2�4DM�N��� �<#F� E,�I!5�"���J���F��?��5- ����E @5�5K @5&"! � � ��� � � � �3&>K @5# H����F& � � � � ��� ��� � � #�#!�& KI@$#F�5!5#3��� � ��� �3� � � #�'!C/.5& & !$&O��� #F���"C/.$&(��� #B��E,� ���J���F#FL>LO���5!5�5-

� ����E,& �5&>�=CO���4� � .�5D4&>CO&>!5&>�0� &"!=�B��� C>#B��E,� ��&OD &>� &>D4CO#FL>#F� ��� ��� � D4� CO���4�7!5#=���5�5�F#FCO��L>#F���5& !5# @5�J� D &>?����B� !5&>� ( � � #F��� !C>#F� & K @J���5!$�<#F�2�5�I!$� &(!5&>���4#F����� � ��� � � � #�'!�C/.5&(� #��4DM�N��� � #F�AE,�I!5� ���5���F��?��5- �:��E @5�5K @5&"!���� ���5���F#F� #2!$# � � ��� � � � #�%�4#��5@� �D #FC>���5!$@5D D4& � KI@$&O�F�B�=!5# � � � ��� ��� � � #� !0&�K @5#F�5!5#J�=KI@5&>�F�B� !$# � � ��� �3� � � #�#!�C/.5& &�@5�.�5�I!$� !5&>�$�4#F��� C0.5& �4�4#B��E,� ���J���F#FL>LO���5!5�5-

��� � � � D4&>#F� �4&>D �5D4&>� ��L>#F���5&"!5# � D &>�5!5&(H0&>DM� � � �!2&.K @5#F�5!5# � ��D &>�5!5&(H0&>DM� � � � #F� K @J���0� � &>� �4DM��E ��&(#F�0� &>D �$D &G�M���$�A�B�C>���4� ��� �4&(CO��#F�0H0��� � �"�5&>�F��� &O�F&>E,&>�0� � �<& C>��#F�5C>#F!5���5�,��&>D�� @I�4�4#%?��F#���� �4D #�� #FE �����F#��5D &>�4&O�0�4#��5&>�F�B� �5D4������� #FL>#F���5&�-

�G� � & �5D4���5D #F&G�� � #F�5!5#FCO���5�(� &>E,�5�F#FC>&>E,&O�0�4& C0.5& ��?��5#��5� !5�(C/.5& D4#FC/.5#F&>!5& @5�J� D &>?����B� !5&>� (/! (*(*� ( � �4#F��� &=�4� �N� �(&>�M��E,#F�J�N�4�& C>��� �4DM���4� &>?��J�N�4� & K @5&>�F�F#%C/.5& D #FC/.$#F&O!$���5� @5�J�"D &>?����B�"!5&>��(*(�(��4#F���,� ���5�,���M�N�4#3� � !5!5#F��1 �N��� #�C>�����4@$��� & �F& CO�����M���0�4#��$D &>� &>�0� #�5&>��D ��E,�5-

Page 158: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� �}!:K� S[62�$� ���� ����] :P7@7NAPEc: � � � ����<:K� S[62�$� ��� � ���l] :P7@7NAPEc:S�$� �� ����62�+� � � ���|P:K� S[62�$� ��� � ���l] :P7@7NAPEc:S�$� �� ����A/�+� � � ����C:K� S[62�$� ��� � ����] :P7@7NAPEc: � � � ����Ah�$� � � ����<:K� S[62�$� ���Ay� �Z��� ����]:P7@7NAPEc:�;Z6GE~AChPJ>= ��8cw>6�83ACO&;T:<EF6=NJ��l]X�+� ����I��� ���À :K� S[62�$� ���A�� �Z��� ����]:P7@7NAPEc:>]W;Z6GE2_KRM:<7\8cw>6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B6 �Z]T�+� ����I�/� ���}GLZ� S[6�� � �� � ����] :P7@7NAPEc:S�$� �� ����bLZ� S[6�� � ¹��� � ����] :P7@7NAPEc: � � � ����A � � � � ���|<LZ� S[6�� � ¹��� � ����] :P7@7NAPEc: � � � ����6�� � � � ����PLZ� S[6�� � � � � ����] :P7@7NAPEc:S�$� �� ����6�� � � � ����bLZ� S[6�� � � �$�� ���/� ����] :P7@7NAPEc:�;Z6GE2_KRM:P7N8cwM6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F6 �T] � � ����W��� ���À LZ� S[6�� � ���Ay� ���/� ����] :P7@7NAPEc:�;Z6GE~AChPJ>= ��8cw>6�83ACO&;T:<EF6=NJ��l] � � ����I�/� ����2JD:P7@LZ6GEFA�f62:;@A��x>|�8 9�N 9b@0SB6�6sS[AC7@AQS[6�7NA�f6�APhPJM=$S[R>AQEc:<OQAMnop7{?F6GAPEF6GOi:&HI=£8GAPOQ;>7N63?B6!jGjk:&SB={LM:CSB:QSBR>7£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6�7@6!OQOQ:D�YHI=£¨�=@JK?B= ��b:C�­¦

�hCJ>={EF:POQA&8GAPOQ;>7N63?F:<?BAQ6�J>ACJ�8cw>=NRMSBA�f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@6Cn

�S5+.h���1\�,B§�YW5��"!$#�t&�9ACJMSB=NHI6!EB=\:<OQA�R>J�_KRM:P7NSB=N:CS[=^Ec:<OQA�� 8GAPOQ;>7N63?F:<?BA�6yJMAPJ�8cwM=@RMSBAMns½(6!E�H>=@OQACS[?BEc:<EF68cw>6 ��f6,S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6,HIAPL>LM=N:PO&A0?FEBA ` :PEB6&R>J¢HIACO&=NJ>=NA ��6iR>JM:0=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6 ��S[R ��8cw>6iEF6GJMH>6` 6!EB6y?BR>?[?B6i7N6&;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJM=(SB6GhCJM:b?F6&H>= ���eEF6GJMH>6 ` 6GEF6y7N6h»;T6!E�8GR>=�+� �96yd�:P7NSB6&7@6/ ;T6!Es83R>= � � ���­n�9APOQ6�H>APOQ=@JM=@A � ;MEB6!JMHI=\:<OQAi7YX =NJMS[=N6GOQ6&HI6G7N7@6y83ACS[?F:PJK?B=£;MEB6kS[6!JC?F=$=NJ���n2¿mX =@JK?B6!EB;MEB6G?F:<j!=@ACJ>6��.f6yHI63aMJM=r?c:��8GAPOQ6�S[= f6 ` =\S[?BA�JM6GhP7N=�6!SB6GOQ;>={HI6!=Z;T:<Ec:<hPEc:bai;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B=��mJ>6!7�O&AIHIAQSB6GhPRM6GJK?B6C¦ ;Z6GEuAPhCJ>=�83ACS[?F:PJK?B6 �i8cwM683ACOQ;M:<EF6=NJ���] �T���I�2� ����APhCJ>=$83AKSU?c:<JK?B6Qf6�=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:<?F:&=@JDSB6�SU?F6!SFSB:K�­n

�W6� �¡ f6�R>JDSB=@OyLTAC7@AiHI=£;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?FAiS[={;ZAPJ>6C¦ �T� � �¡ �2� �K� � ` �baia�a@� � � ��¦��+� � �¡ � ` a�aia � � � ���l� ` �opJ�LM:PSB6�:&_KR>6kSU?c:Q=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �iS[ACJ>AiS[AIH>H>=NS[d�:b?B?B={?FRI?[?F=$=$J>AIHI=£H>= ��¦SB6� ����]M:P7@7NAPEc: � � � �n¿£:�HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<j!=@ACJ>6P]P8GAPOQ6~J>6!7M8G:CS[A�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P]CS[=>AP?[?F=@6!J>6~;T6!Em=NJMHIR>j!=@ACJ>6�SBR>7@7\:�83ACOQ;>7@6kSBSB=@?¾f:�HI6G7N7N6;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>={S[6!hPJM:<?B6�8cw>6�83ACOQ;M:<=NAPJ>A&=NJ���n�§k�%#3n��W6�¤wM:Q:<7@?B6!jGj!:�}C]>:<7N7@ACEF:U����$� � �¡ �-`ka�a�a � � �£A/�� � � � �¡ �­}�a�aia � �&�ºn�W6 ����+� � �¡ � ` a�aia � � � � ��]�:P7@7NAPEc: � � ` �%a�aiaN� � � � � �Z� � �¡ �­]�8G=@AMf6¢� �Z� �­}¾�­�baia�a@� �Z� � �£�[� � �Z� � �¡ �­]H>:¢83RM= � � ���¡ �-`ka�aia � ��]>AKSBSB=N: � � � �$� � �¡ �-`ka�a�a � � �ºn

�W6_�� � � � �¡ � ` aia�a � � ��� �l]v:<7N7@ACEF:M](6!SFS[6!JMHIA���:P;T6!E[?FAM]�+� � �¡ � ` a�a�a � � � �� ��]m;Z6GEi83RM=�� � ` �baia�a@� � � � �� �Z� � �¡ �­]ACSFSB=N:�� ��� � ` �­�baia�a@� ��� � � �B� �� �Z� � �¡ �3]>6�_CRM=@JMH>= � �� � ��¡ � ` aia�a � � ]TH>:Q83R>=£SB6GhCR>6�� � � � � � �¡ � ` aia�a � � �ºn

�~§��c�%�;t��W6 gwM:8GAPOQ;>7N6!SFS[=@?¾f:�� ��}C]<:<7N7@ACEF:sf69H>=IR>J>A�HI6G=K?F=@;>=>8cwM69aThPR>Ec:<J>AJ>6G7N7N69;>EF6GOQ6kSBSB6vH>6G7I;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F66G7N6GJT83AiHI=$;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:l}k:C�s� À LZ�­n�W=\:�����+� � �9�2� � ��n ½(6GEQ7\:�;MEBAC;>EB=N63?bf: �P:C�3]9H>: �+� � �9�2� � �¥S[6!hPR>6D8cw>6_�+� � � � ��6_�+� �2� � �ln½(AP=\8cwu®6 � 6�� wM:PJ>J>Ay8GAPOQ;>7N6!SFS[=@?¾f:sO&=NJ>ACEB6�H>=Z_KR>6!7@7\:�HI=os]K;Z6GEv=@;ZA<?F6!SB=T=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` : � � �/�$� � �Z6 ��� �]�+� �2�º]ACSFSB=N: � � � �»6�� � � �&]MH>:i8GR>=$SB6GhPRM6 � � � � ��� 6P]M=@JIaTJ>6P] � � �]�+� � �_�2�º]M83=NAMf6 � � � �n�W=\:�x����+� � � �2�ºn(½(6GE(7N:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:e�K:C�­]CH>:��+� � ���2� ��� S[6!hPR>6u8cw>6uA � � � � ���¤A��+� �2� ����n*½(AP=\8cwu®6� 66� wM:<JMJ>A�8GAPOQ;>7N6!SFS[=@?¾f:OQ=@JMAPEF6vHI=>_KR>6!7@7\:�HI=&s]<;Z6GE*=N;ZA<?B6kS[=W=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` :>] � � ��� � � �����¤A � � �/�$� �2� ���l]` :<7N6�:iHI=@EF6�� �� �z�»A � � � �&]MHM:i83R>=$SB=$A<?B?B=N6GJ>6�� � � � ��� 6C]I=@J>aMJ>6P] � � �/�$� � � �2��]M8G=@AMf6 � � � sn�W=\:q:PHg6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]~x�� � � � �_�2��n ½(6GEi7\:�;>EFAP;>EF=@6G?¾f:J�bLZ�­]~H>:�� � � �9�2� � ��S[6!hPR>6D8cw>6DA � � � � � �¥A� � �2� � �ln��9APOQ6�SBAP;>Ec:>]T;T6!E=N;ZA<?B6kS[=^=NJMHIRI?B?B= ` :M] � � ��� � � �(A � � � � � �2�p]TAKSBSB=N: �,J>ACJ.EB6!JMHI6 ` 6GEc:QA�� A� 6P]M_KR>=NJMHI=�]>J>ACJ�f6�OQAIHI6G7N7NAQH>=�� �_� 6C]>=@J>aMJ>6P] � � � � � � �9�2�p]>8G=@AMf6 � � � snopJ¹OQAIHIA�:<JM:P7@AChPA�SB=v?BEc:b?B?F:<JMA.d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B60hC7@=~:<7@?BEF=u8G:PSB=u;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N=������+� ��� �º]¢����+� � �_�2��] � � � ��� �p]& � � � � �_�2�º]X � � � � ���2���3nm¡VSF:<OQ=@JM=N:PO&AQ:<7N7NAPEc:�=£8!:PSB={;>=[fR�?F=@;M=N8!:<OQ6GJK?B6�;>EF6!H>=N8!:b?B= ` =Yn�W=\:� ���+� � �Ay� ���/�ºn ��:<7N7N:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf:��<:K�­]<H>:��+� � �$�� �Z�/� ����SB6GhCR>698cw>6C]<;Z6GE(APhCJ>=I83ACS[?F:PJK?B6 ��8cw>6VaThPR>Ec:J>6!7£Ec:<OQAM]T�$� y���I�/� � ��]M6s_KR>=NJMHI=�]M;Z6GE2=N;ZA<?B6kS[= =@JTHIRI?[?F= ` :M]T8cw>6 � � �]�+� ����I�/�pn6�I=£HI6 ` 6sHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6�8cw>6 �� �/�$� ���Ay� �Z���p]KAKSBSB=\:�8cw>6 � � � ���Ay� �Z�3n[�W6P]W;Z6GEu:PSFS[RMEFHIAT] �yJ>ACJ,deACSFSB6�OQAIHI6G7N7@A&HI=� �$�� ���­]>SB=@hCJ>=@aT8G:s8cwM6

� @5&>�4� � !$& �5�5#FL>#F���5& � ���5C>#F� C>& KI@5��� �4�A��� �5#B��E,�.HI#F�4�4�,#F�AE,��� �4#�!5&>?��F#�&>� &>E,�5# �5�5��DM�"��H0��� � # � KI@5���5!5� @5� ������&>D �,�5��� �4#C/.5#F@$!5&GH���M- �I& #F� @5� DM��E,� ����&>D4�4�<HI#�� ���5��� � ���"�#! � � ���/�#!����F�F��DM� � � � � ��� � � � � & H$#�� ���$��� � ���! 0� ! � � ��� ���'! � � �� 0����F�F��DM� � �'� � � � � � � � � � � � � � &.C>��� �3HI#B�$- �I&>C>���5!5�<�M���F& !5& �J�5#FL>#F���5&"D4#F� @5� � ���5� 1 ���F� &(� #B�"�F&.�$D ������� #FL>#F���5#��N�4��E,#FC/.5& �� ���F#2C/.5& � � � � & #F� � !5� #B�(KI@$&O�F�F& � ���F#2C0.5& ��& � � � �#!5��& � � � ���4� ���5�5�.#F� � -

Page 159: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

}�� �R>JM: c�ºEF6G=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6 �TX>HI= �QEF6GJMH>6d�:P7NSF:U���G�­n �^:<7N6EF6G=NJK?B6GEF;>EF63?c:<jG=NAPJM6:PSFSBAW8G=N:y: 2R>J�6G7N6GOQ6GJK?BAiHI=�D]ZACSFS[=\:&R>JM:,8GACS[?F:PJC?F6 ��8cw>6�8GAPOQ;M:<EF6�=@J �ln~¼.:l:<7N7@ACEF: �,EF6GJTHI6�d�:<7\SB:�����!�s�e=NJ._KRM:<JK?FA �l:PSFSB6GhPJT:&:CH����G�u7NA,SU?F6!SFS[A ` :P7@ACEB6�8cw>6�7\:QEB6!=@JK?F6GEF;>EB6G?F:PjG=NAPJ>6��TXM:PSFS[AI8G=N:Q:/���3�­]Z=NJ0_KRM:PJK?BA �Z���G��� �TXN��3��� ��6sS[R>7N7N6:<7@?BEF6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B= �i6 �TXM8GAP=NJM83=\HIAPJMAK�­n*¼.:i8G=ºfA0f6�:CSBSBR>EcHIAM]W;ZAP=\8cwv®6P]>8GAPOQ6�S[=*f6�H>63?[?FAM] � � � ����W�3]>;Z6GE2AChPJ>= �8cw>6�83ACOQ;M:<EF6�=@J���]>6s_KR>=@JTHI= � � � y���G�3n�W=\:� ���+� ���Ay� ���/�pn*½(6GE(7N:�;>EFAP;MEB=N63?bf: À :C�­]CH>:��+� ���Ay� �Z��� ����S[6!hPR>6~8cw>66�$� y���I�/� ���¤;Z6GEmR>JT:�8GACS[?F:PJC?F6�Z] 6�_CRM=@JMH>=Y](;Z6GEs=N;TAP?B6kS[=9=@JMH>RI?[?F= ` :>]*8cw>6 � � � ����W�3nD¼.:.SB6 � � � ����I�­]*:<7N7@ACEF:M]£;Z6GEs7\: ` :<7N=\HI=r?bf:DHI6G7N7NASF8cw>6GOi:h����W�9� ���Ay� ���­]MJM6sS[6!hPR>6�� � � ���$�� �Z�­] ` :<7N6s:&H>=@EF6�� � �/�$� ���$�� �Z�/�U]T83=NAMf6 � � � sno~8G:CS[= � � � �$�� �Z�/�(6 � � ���Ay� �Z���VS[=£?BEc:b?B?F:<JMAi=@JDOQAIHIAl:PJM:<7NAPhCAQ:P= HIRM6�;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JC?F=V�e6&:PH06kSBSB=£SB=£;ZACSFS[ACJ>AEF=N8GAPJMHIRMEBEF60EB=\83ACEFH>:PJMHIA¢8cw>6����Ay� �Z�Df6D7NAPhP=\8G:POQ6GJK?B6D6k_CRM= ` :<7N6GJK?F6�:l� ���o���� ���­]6�_KR>=@JTHI= � � � �$�� ���/�6!_KR>= ` :<7N6y:/�$� ���$���� �Z���[]�6y:<JT:<7NAPhC:POQ6GJK?B6����$�� ����f6s7NAPhP=\8G:POQ6GJK?B6s6k_KR>= ` :P7@6!JC?F6y:������$��y� �Z�3]$6y_KR>=NJMHI=� � ���A�� �Z���^6k_CRM= ` :<7N6�:U�+� � �$��y� ���/�Y�v6�7@=£7N:CSB8G=N:PO&A&;Z6GE26kS[6!EF8G=@j!=@ATn �½(6GEvHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6�7N:y83APOQ;>7N63?F6Gj!j!:�H>6G7�OQ63?BAIHIA&HI6G7N7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAySB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GAsL>=\S[AChPJM:yHI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6�8cwM6SB=T;>R^fAS ` =N7NR>;>;M:PEB6s7�X :<7NLT6!EBA�=@J�O&AIHIA�8cw>6�AChPJ>= EF:POQA�SB=N:,8GAPOQ;>7N63?c:b?BATnopJ�?F:P7^8!:PSBAM]�S[6y7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�J>APJ�S[=(8cw>=NRMHI6P]` =uf6i:<7NOQ6GJ>A0R>J�EF:POQA0:P;T6!E[?FA�8cwM6�f6Q8GAPOQ;>7N63?c:b?BA06i_KR>=NJMHI=VSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Q;T6!Es=N7(?B6GACEB6!Oi:�;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B6Cn526!7m8G:CS[A�HI6G7N7N:�7NAPhC=N8!:,;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6sJ>ACJ ` =(6GEc:<JMA�;M:PE[?F=N8GAP7\:<EF=£;>EFAPLM7@6!O&=(=NJ�_KRM:PJK?BA�=@7*;>EFAI836kHI=@OQ6!JC?FAHI=v83ACS[?BEFR>j!=@ACJ>6Q?B6!EBOQ=NJM: ` :.S[6!OQ;>EB6iA�83APJq7\:.8cw>=NRMSBR>Ec:>]£A�_CRT:<JMHIA�APhPJM=mJ>AIHIA.J>ACJ¢83ACJC?F6GJ>6!JK?B6iR>JM:.de;:b?FAPOQ=\8G:y6GEc:yS[?F:<?BAQ83APJK?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:b?FAl�e6�_KR>=NJMHI=$={Ec:<OQ={83ACO&;M7@6G?F:b?F=\�3nm526!7$8G:PSBAQHI6G7N7N:&7NAPhC=N8!:�HI6!={;>EB6kHI=\8G:b?F=Y]=NJ ` 6!8G6P]$AI8G8GAPEFEB6&R>JM:�Oi:<hChP=NAPEF6�;>EF6!8!:<R>j!=@ACJ>6Pn&opJId�:<?[?B=�](S[6iSB=m=@JT83APJK?FEF:�R>J�J>AIHIADHI6G7(?F=@;ZA(�+� � �������� ��]83ACOQ6SB= f6 ` =NS[?BAT]K6kSBSBA�=NJ>J>6kSB8!:sR>J�OQ6!8G8!:<J>=\SBO&Ay8cw>6;MR fA�;ZAPEB?F:PEB6�:PHiR>JMA&S ` =@7NR>;>;ZA�=NJIaMJ>=@?BAy?BEc:PSF83RMEF:PJMHIAhP7N=�:<7@?BEF=MJ>AIHI=�n9�9ACSpf �>;ZA<?FEB6!L>LT6�S[RT8G836kHI6GEF68cwM6�S[=�83ACJK?B=NJKRM=T=N7Z8G=N8G7@Ay6_KR>=NJMHI=�S[= ` :PH>:y:<7N7YX =NJIaMJ>=@?BA&S[6!J>j!:s8cwM6SB= 6kSB:PO&=NJ>=�]{:PHD6kS[6!O&;M=@AT]Z7�X :<7@?BEFA,J>AIHIA9�+� ������T� ��� �*8cw>6C]Z=NJ ` 6k836P]Td�:<EF6GLMLT6&8cw>=@RTHI6GEF6�=N7(EF:PO&ATn�opJ�:<7@?BEF=?B6!EBOQ=NJ>=�]bAW8!83ACEBEF6*8cw>6m?FRI?[?F=C=KJ>AIHI=WS[=\:<J>A�6!SF:<OQ=@JT:b?B=C6P]bH>:<?BA�8cw>6 ` =CSBAPJ>A�_KR>6!7@7N=W8cw>6mJ>ACJ�S[=K83ACJC?FEF:CSBSB6GhCJM:<JMAM]AI8G8GAPEFEB6�8cw>6�_CRM6!S[?B=$SB=N:PJ>A&SB=\SU?F6GOi:b?F=N8!:<OQ6GJK?B6�EF=@6kSB:POQ=@JM:<?B=�n��IAP7NAQ8GAPJ�R>JM:&;>EFAW8G6!HIRMEF:&S[=\S[?B6GOi:<?B=\8G:&S[={;>R^fAhC:PEF:PJK?B=NEB6�8cw>6�R>J0EF:POQA&8cw>6�EF=@Oi:PJ>6�:<;Z6GEB?BAiS[=\:Q83ACO&;M7@6G?F:b?FAMn

�2J0OQAIHIAiS[=\S[?B6GOi:<?B=\83AQ;T6!E~;>EFAW8G6!HI6!EB6&f6C]>:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]I=N7£SB6GhPRM6GJK?B6Cn� �M§�!o���j�05m§c*�*o345�«c§]�T!�§U,-#sr;�"3@§,§h�T!_!o�b�;�]��#%3 ������\�5 *X�kf�05*«1��!X\�,B§��c�%#sr�!Z§0��8GAPJK?BEc:<EF=\:<OQ6GJK?B6:y_KRM:PJC?FASB= f6d�:b?B?BAyaMJ>ACEF:K� 5+3q!$������f.Q§h3��j�15�,05 *X#W\m#25+!�^W�"!$�;�l§����-r�!X5>,B§�./�,«1n&#�,05+.Q§"!$#�§1*&#%,0\m��t �e�/�cr�!X5A*>§��1�W��f

5+! �cr�!X5,B§".h�/�15[#W�G§�.U5+!Z§�5+3�!o�b�;�/!$�"!�§�!�«1��,B§�«1��!X\�,B§��c�%#sr�!Z§�\m��*o5;Q�(�b5�«%5+!$��§�3+3N§],B§;��5�«1#Gn�R>=NJMHI=�]C=�J>AIHI=�HI6!7T?F=@;ZAS�$� ���Ay� �Z���$6�� � ���Ay� �Z���U]I_CRT:<JMHIA&S[=Z=NJM83ACJC?FEF:PJ>AsHI=\SB8G6GJMH>6GJMHIA&H>:<7N7\:sEc:PHI=\836C]SB=£S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:<J>A,8GAPJ07N6�83AKSU?c:<JK?B=$;MEB6kS[6!JC?F=Y]TS[=£8GAPJK?BEc:PSFSB6GhPJT:<J>A&6sS[= EB=\83AC;>=\:<J>AQ=NJ�deACJMHIAl:P=$Ec:<OQ=$;Z6GE26kSBSB6GEF6EF=@6kSB:PO&=NJM:<?B=(HIAP;ZA�8cwM6&SBAPJ>A�SU?c:b?F=^6kSB:POQ=@JM:<?B=(hP7N=*:<7@?BEF=Y]�;Z6GE�;ZAP=(6 ` 6GJK?BRT:<7NO&6!JK?B6�6kSBSB6GEF6�EF=N6!SF:<OQ=@JT:b?B=(83ACJ7N6.SU?F6!SFS[6DOQAIH>:<7N=@?¾f:>n��9w>=\:<OQ=N:POQA'�15F�0\m#W.i§�\�5�«c§¹_KR>6kSU?c:�JWR>A ` :�;MEBAI836kHIR>Ec:�HI=8GACS[?BEFR>jG=NAPJ>6DHI6!7@7�X :<7NLT6!EBATnx�H>A<?[?c:<JMH>A�R>JM:�;>EFAI836!H>R>EF:�SB=NS[?B6!OQ:<?B=\8G:�SB=N:POQA�SB=\83R>EF=$�e627NA�S[=M;TAP?BEF6GL>LZ6�HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF69EF=@hCAPEFACSF:<OQ6GJK?F6k�$8cwM6APhCJ>={Ec:<OQA&SB=\:&8GAPOQ;>7N63?c:b?BATn�W={AP?[?B=N6GJM6s:<7N7@ACEF:�d�:P8G=@7NOQ6GJK?B6�=N7

� 8�@AL�8���N �C�GC�HJI � 8�@XL�8���N�y>=�:�@$�Jx>|�8�9b8�?�?;NvIKy>8�{[@$|�8�� �� � ���HI=NO�

opJId�:<?[?B=�]mSB6��f6 ` :P7@=\H>:M](8GACS[?BEFR>=\:<OQADR>J¹:P7@LZ6GEFA.;Z6GE � � �~:PH>A<?[?c:<JMH>A.R>JM:D;MEBAI836kHIR>Ec:.SB=NS[?B6!OQ:<?B=\8G:Mn�*APhC7@=\:<OQA�HI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6v8cw>69?F:<7N6~:<7NLT6!EBA�S[=>8cwM=@RMH>6���6~_CRM=@JMH>=>8cw>6vH>=@OR�3n��I69?c:<7N6~:<7NLT6!EBAJ>APJQS[=>8cwM=@RMH>6!SFS[6C]:<7N7NAPEc: ` =�SF:<EF6GL>LZ6�:<7NOQ6GJ>AyR>J,Ec:<OQA�:P;T6!E[?FAMn � :P7@6EF:PO&AySB:PEB6!L>LT683APOQ;>7N63?c:b?FAl�e6�J>6SB=\:<OQA�SB=N8GR>EB=T;TAC=N8cwu®6:<LML>=N:POQA,:PHIAP?[?F:<?BAi7\:Q;>EFAW8G6!HIRMEF:QSB=NS[?B6!OQ:<?B=\8G:K�­nu¼.:QR>JDEc:<OQAi:<;Z6GEB?BA,83ACOQ;>7@6G?F:<?BADf6sSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn���=SF:<EF6GL>LZ6GEFA�_KR>=NJMHI= � 6 �.8cwM6QSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PJ>A0APhCJ>=*J>AIHIADHI6G7VEF:PO&AT]$=NJ�;T:<EB?B=\83AP7\:<EF6 � � ����8cw>6C]£6!SFSB6GJMHIA�7\:Ec:PHI=\836C]>d�:i;M:PE[?F6�HI=^APhCJ>=$Ec:<OQAK�3n2¼.:,83=pfADf6�:CSBSBR>EcHIAi;ZAP=\8cwv®6P]M;T6!E=N;TAP?B6kS[=�]$�f6 ` :<7N=NHM:i6�_KR>=NJMHI=^J>6!SFS[RMJM:=NJC?F6GEF;>EF63?F:PjG=NAPJ>6�;>R fAiEF6GJTHI6GEF6�d�:P7NSF:h���8G=@AMf6 ` 6GEc: � � ���­n

�2JT:s83ACJMS[6!hPR>6!J>j!:�HI6!7@7\:sHI=\SF83RMSFS[=NAPJM6uaMJ,_KR>=TS ` AC7r?c:yf627N:�SB6GhCR>6GJK?F6Pn�W627\:�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>6u�f62SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:"�83=NL>=N7@6C]>:<7N7@ACEF:s7YX :<7NLT6!EBAQ83AKSU?FEBRM=r?FAy83ACJl;>EFAI836kHIR>Ec:�SB=NS[?B6!OQ:<?B=\8G:y;T6!E6�+� �$J>ACJ�;>R^fA&8cw>=NRMHI6!EFSB=�n>�=^f6�_KR>=NJMHI=J>6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFAQR>J0EF:POQA&:P;T6!E[?FAQ8cwM6&f6�8GAPOQ;>7N63?c:b?BATn � :P7@6�Ec:<OQAD�e6�=NJ0;M:<EB?B=\83AC7N:PEB67N:QEc:PHI=\836��+� �p]>6s_KR>=NJMHI=:<JT8cw>6j���f6&S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@6y=@J�R>J�H>APOQ=@JM=@A�83ACS[?B=@?BRM=r?FA�83ACJ.7N6y83AKSU?c:<JK?B=(8cw>6&83APOQ;M:P=@ACJ>A,J>6!7 Ec:<OQATn �^:<7N6HIACO&=NJ>=NA�f6�aMJ>=@?BAiAQJWR>OQ6GEc:<L>=N7@6Cn��m:<7N6�_KR>=NJMHI=£=@7�¦� 8�@AL�8���N �C�GCFEvI � 8�@XL�8���NvI yD8�{[@$|�8���yD=����@��S8�< �D8�=���� � �A@$|�8�� � �o#��T!�§u*$,-�1*&���15iY%5��"!$#� Q#��W�����"5+g��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#0f2§�3+3i�",B§j�Q#��W�����"5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3i#]5+!��T!��;��.U5+!X5���Z�!A5+\s���/!X�T./#%,B§Pª%5+3i#�t

Page 160: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} À �� ����8;LkM&N&?;=�@$<D8Zn���SFS[6!E ` =\:<OQAy8cw>6�=N7�?B6!APEF6GOi:&;>EF6!836kHI6GJK?F6�SB={;>R fA,SB;Z6!83=@aT8!:<EF6J>6!7$OQAIHIA,S[6!hPR>6!JK?B6P¦

�o#��T!Z§�*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!o#2 Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#0f§"3+3i��,B§ � Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#/5+!��T! ����.U5+!X5���!X�T./#%,B§Pª%5+3i#�t½(ACSFSB=N:PO&A�=NJId�:b?B?B=ZOQAWH>=raT8!:<EF62=N7TOQ63?FAIHIA�HI6!7@7�X :P7@LZ6GEFA�SB6GOi:<JK?F=N8GAs=@OQ;ZAPJ>6!JMHIA&HI=ZSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PEB6~=ZJ>AIHI=�HI6G7o[oBo�?F=@;ZA ` =N: ` =N:08GAPJ�?BRI?B?B6i7N6Q8GACS[?F:PJC?F=2�e6QJ>ACJ�SBAP7NAM]$8GAPOQ6iS[=~f6�d�:<?[?BAT] 8GAPJ�_CRM6G7N7@6Q;>EF6!SB6GJK?B=(J>6!7mEc:<OQAK�3n�9=pfAlwM:i7\:l8GAPJMSB6GhCR>6GJMj!:i8cw>6C]T=NJ�;>EF6!SB6GJMj!:iHI=(J>AIHI=(HI6G7^o[oBou?B=N;TAT]Z?BRI?B?B=(= Ec:<OQ=(:<;Z6GEB?B= ` :PJ>J>A�:<7N7YX =@J>aMJ>=@?BAMn�9APJ0_KR>6!S[?F:yOQAIHI=raZ8G:>]>8GAPOQ6�HIAPOQ=NJ>=NA � 83ACEBEF=\S[;ZAPJMH>6GJK?B6�:PH�R>J�EF:PO&AQ:<;Z6GEB?BAQSB={;>R fAQ;>EF6GJMHI6!EB6�SB6GOQ;>EF67�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6¢��JWR>OQ6GEc:<L>=N7@6¾�QHI=~?FRI?[[email protected][?F:PJC?F=Yn¤�W=N8!83ACO&6DSB=2;>R fAq=\HI6!JC?F=raZ8G:<EF6D7�X =NJMSB=@6!O&6.H>[email protected][?F:<JK?F=83ACJD7YX =NJMS[=N6GOQ6&5 HI6G=^JWR>OQ6GEF=£JM:<?BR>Ec:<7N=�]TSB=£;>R fAldeAPEFO�R>7\:<EF6�=@7 ?B6!APEF6GOi:iHI=(¿��A � 6!J>w>6G=NOU�m� �PAP7N6GO J>6G7 OQAWH>ASB6GhPRM6GJK?B6C¦�o#��T!Z§�*o,-�c*X�k�05iY%5���!o#2 Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#0f§"3+3i��,B§j�Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ª%5+3i#/5+! �jt ��RM:PJC?FA2aMJMAPEc:2A<?B?B6!JKR>?BA�S[=W6kSU?F6GJMHI6u=NOQO&6kHI=\:b?F:POQ6GJK?B6u:<7N7N:�83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:27NAPhP=\8G:M]<:<7N7N:S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N=r?bf:6s:<7N7\:yHI6!EB= ` :<L>=N7N=r?bf:&_KRM:PJMHIAiSB=£83ACJMS[=\HI6!EF:PJ>Ay=NJMSB=@6!OQ=�aMJ>=@?B=�n�m:<7N6�=@J>d�:b?[?F=Y]T83APOQ6sSB=(f6 ` =NS[?BAQJ>6!7$;M:<Ec:<hCEF:<deA�|>n |>]>8cwM6P¦���}P�c��I�baia�aN�- �� � � � � � � s}V�9��~��a�aia¾�� � ��

� �HI=NO��}9����2��a�aia!�9 � �� �ks}C�-��>�%a�aiaN�- ��¾HI=NOv��WAIH����}P�-��I�baia�a@�c ��2�IAWH_�}V����~��aia�a!�9 6P]m_KR>=NJMHI=�]*7\:�83ACJMSB6GhPRM6GJ>jk:D7@AChP=\8G:DH>:�R>J¹=NJMSB=@6!OQ6,aMJ>=@?BAT]*7N:�HI6GEF= ` :PL>=N7@=@?¾f:�H>:.R>J¹=@JMSB=N6GOQ6,aMJM=r?FA�HI=;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=�]K7\:&S[AIH>HI=\S[d�:P83=NL>=N7@=@?¾f:QHI={RMJ�=NJMSB=@6!O&6�aMJM=r?FAQSB={EF=N8GAPJMHIRT83APJMAy:<7N7\: ` :P7@=\HI=@?¾f:>]>:P7@7\:&HI6GEF= ` :PL>=@7N=@?¾f:y6:<7N7\:&SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@=@?¾f:QHI=$RMJM:QS[=NJ>hPAC7N:&;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6Cn

I � � � @A��x>N 989b8�?�?;N�8 :;@A��x>|�8 9�8�?�?�N�IK�s@AL 9�8���9APOQ6�S[= f6 ` =\S[?BA�JM6G7£�v:<;>=@?BAC7@A&|>]ISB=T;ZACSFS[ACJ>A�;MEBAC;TACEBEF6�HIR>6deAPEFO�RM7N:PjG=NAPJ>=T6!_KR>= ` :P7@6!JK?B={HI6G7 � 8�@XL�8���N

y>=�:;@A�Jx�N 989b8�?�?;N'I �b8���NX<$9b= :;N��¾¦�W6�� � � s] §"3+3i��,F§�#W�05F�1\m#S�T!(�%��\�\s�"5+!&�05�#W./#�Z�!A5+\s���£�"5{� \º§"3i#Q«cnX#�� � � jt�o#j�-r�!X5��%�"\�\m��5+!X�15�#%./#¢Z[!X5+\m�]��5£� Q#2�%������5F��^3§C«W5�ª%5+3i#Wf2§"3+3i��,F§s� Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#bt½(6GEvHI=NO&AKSU?FEF:PEB6�=@7Z?B6!APEF6GOi:�H>=�8GAPOQ;M:<?[?B6!jGjk:s;Z6GEv7N:y7@AChP=\8G:sH>6G=�;>EF6!HI=\8G:<?B=Z;TAKSBSB=N:POQAySB6GhPRM=@EF6�7NAyS[?B6kSBSBA;>EFAI836!H>=@OQ6GJK?FA�:CHIA<?B?F:b?FA�JM6G7N7N:�7NAPhP=\8G:l;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6P]�;>EFAI836!H>6GJMHIA�;Z6GEbfA�8GAPJ�:<7\83R>J>=*:C8G83ACEBhC=@OQ6!JC?F=^8cwM6SB={EB= ` 6!7N:PJ>AyJM6!836kSBSF:<EF=�;TAC=N8cwu®6�S[=\:<OQA&=@J0;>EF6!SB6GJ>jk:QHI=$=NJMS[=N6GOQ={=NJIaMJ>=@?B=^HI=$;>EFAP;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>=�n

�*6!H>=N:PO&AiSBR>L>=@?BAT]M:b?B?BEc: ` 6GEcSBA�R>J�6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM]>RMJ�;MEBACL>7@6!Oi:y8cw>6�SB=$;>R fAQ;>EF6!SB6GJK?c:<EF6Pn�9w>=N6!HI=\:<OQAI83=$SB6&f6�S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6�=@7$SB6GhCR>6GJK?B6�=NJMSB=@6!O&6�=NJIaMJM=r?FA,HI=$;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=�¦� ��� ���£�1� � �&`¾�c� � � � �c� � � � �ba%aba3�c� � ��dy�%a%abar�¿$AiS[?BRMH>6GJK?B6sJMAPJDS[=£7N:CSB8G={?BEc:<EFEB6�=NJ0=@J>hK:<J>JMAMnV¿VX =NJMSB=@6!O&6�=@JD_KR>6!S[?B=NAPJM6Qf6�6 ` =\HI6GJK?B6!OQ6GJK?B6sSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=i�L>=N7@6C¦(LM:PS[?F:y83APJTS[=\HI6GEc:<EF6~R>J�HIAPOQ=NJ>=@A�� HI=�HIR>6�6G7N6GOQ6!JC?F=Y]I:CHi6!SB6GOQ;>=NAM] � � �K}P] �W�26�;TACEBEF6 �Z� �s�F���C}<�6

�Z���&`3�F� �T��� � �B� n!nGnF� �Z����d��B� nGn!nc�¤�In^opJ,_KR>6!S[?BA�8!:PSBA � � � ��� ���l;ZAP=\8cwu®6�}2wT:��T� �s�­]W6 � � � � � ��dy]C;Z6GEAPhCJ>= �]M;ZAP=\8cwu®6�� � ��dy]TH>:<?BA,8cw>6 �Z����d������ �� �Z� �s�­nu�W6�=@OQ;>=N6GhCw>=N:POQAi=@7$OQ6G?BAIHIAlHI6!7@7�X :<7NLT6!EBA,SB6GOi:<J&�?B=\83A083ACOQ6�7NA�:PL>L>=\:<OQA,aMJMAPEc:,=NO&;ZACS[?F:<?BA0S[ACEBhC6sR>J�;>EBACL>7N6GOi:>n��W6&=@JM=@j!=N:PO&A083ACJ��$� ��� ��� �p]$HIACL>L>=\:<OQASBAWHMHI=NS[d�:<EF6Q=@7VJ>AIHIAD83APJ�R>JT:D83ACS[?F:PJK?B6&;TACJ>6GJMH>A.:PH�6!SB6GOQ;>=NA_�+� � � ¡ �º© Oi:D:<7N7NAPEc:�_KRM:PJMHIA0=@JTS[6!EB=\:<OQA0=@7J>AIHIA]�$� � � � ¡ ��]ZJ>6�SB6GhCR>6�� � � � ¡ � 6y7YX :<7NLT6!EBA.�Y8cw>6,f6s8GACS[?B=@?BR>=@?BA�H>:iR>J.RMJ>=N8GA,Ec:<OQAK�uSB= 8cw>=NRMHI6��e6y_KR>=NJMHI=HIA ` EF6GOQOQA�8GAPJM8G7@RMH>6GEF6&8cw>6Q7�X =NJMSB=@6!OQ6�f6y=NJMSBAWHMHI=NS[d�:P8G=@LM=@7N6k�3nQ¿VX 6!EBEFAPEF6,f6Q6 ` =\HI6!JC?F6P¦�_KRM:<JTHIA�SBAIH>HI=\SUaZ:<OQAR>J�J>AIHIAiHI6G7{om�¤?F=@;ZAQAI8G83ACEBEF6�=NJK?BEFAIHIR>EFEB6�R>JM:Q83AKSU?c:<JK?B6�JWR>A ` :�JM6G7{Ec:<OQAM©WOi:&=@J0_KR>6!S[?BAi8G:CS[AT]I:<JM8cw>6�SB6:<7N7�X =NJ>=NjG=NA,J>APJ�:<L>L>=\:<OQAl8GACS[?F:PJC?F=Y]Z_KRM:<JMH>A,=@JK?FEBAIHIRM8G=N:POQA,7@6y:<7@?BEF6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=�] ` 6!J>=N:POQAl:i=NJC?FEBAIHIRMEBEF6?BR>?[?B6�7N6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F=Z:&HI=\S[;ZACSB=NjG=NAPJ>6;T6!Eu8GR>={J>6kSBSBR>JM:y83ACS[?F:PJK?B6�f6�=NJl63t�63?B?B= ` 6GEc:<OQ6GJK?B6JWR>A ` :>]K;TAC=N8cwu®62?BR>?[?B6;>EF=@Oi:&AQ;TAC= ` 6!EBEc:<JMJ>A�=NJK?BEFAWH>A<?[?F6Pn½(6GE~SBR>;Z6GEc:<EF6�_KR>6kSU?FA&=NJM8GAPJ ` 6!J>=@6!JK?B6�LM:PS[?F:QHI=\SU?F=@JMhPR>6!EB6�7N6�8GACS[?F:PJC?F=$83ACJ�8GR>=$83AKSU?FEBR>=\:<OQA&7@6�;>EFAP;ZACSB=i�jG=NAPJM=CH>:2_KR>6!7@7N698cwM6m=@OQ;>=N6GhCw>=\:<OQA~;T6!E^SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:PEB6*=KJ>AIHI=KHI6G7Kom�q?B=N;ZAMn(½(A<?BEF6GOQOQA283ACJ ` 6GJM=@EF6*HI=K:CHIAP;Z6GEc:<EF6J>6!7@7N69;MEBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJ>=WSBAP7NA27@6u83AKSU?c:<JK?B=WHI=I=NJMHI=\836v;M:<EF=K6vHI=I:CHIAP;Z6GEc:<EF6V_KR>6G7N7N6vHI=W=NJMHI=\836uHI=\S[;M:PEB=K;Z6GE*S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:<EF6={J>AIHI=$HI={om� ?F=@;ZAMn �;>;MR>EB6�SB=Z;MR fAQ=@JK?BEFAIHIR>EFEB6R>J$X :<7@?BEc:ySBRM8!836!SFSB=@ACJ>6 ` �H>=$83ACS[?F:PJK?B= � ` � � � � � � �ba%aba>83APJ�83R>=SBAWHMHI=NS[d�:<EF6s=^J>AIHI=(HI6G7^om� ?F=@;ZAMn�¿£:,EF6GhCAP7\:iHI6G7^om� ?F=@;ZA ` =N6GJ>6&:<7N7@ACEF:QOQAIHI=@aT8G:<?F:lJ>6G7(S[6!JMSBAl8cw>6s=N7 JMAWH>A` =@6!J>6�S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:b?B?BA,83ACJ�7\:&;>EF=@Oi:QHI6G7N7N6�JKRMA ` 6�83ACS[?F:PJK?B=$8cw>6�J>ACJ�aThPR>Ec:�JM6G7$Ec:<OQAMn��/ (�� �4D � !5@5C>#B��E,�(@5� � #F� �J�$# �� �(�I@5E,&>D ���5#F�F& !5#�C>�����M���0� #��I@$� H0&"!5�4#B� ��&>D C0.�& #F� @5� #F�5� #F&>E,& #F� �J�$# � �(����� � ���$�.&>� �4&OD�H$#�#F� �5�5# � &

�5D4�������4#FL>#F���5#JC/.5& D #FC/.$#F&O!$���5� @5�J� D &>?����B� !5&>� ( � �4#F��� ! �4#B� ��&>D4C/.�& �����4� ���5�(&>� �4&OD�H$#J�$D ������� #FL>#F���5# � !5&>�J� #F��� !5# � � ����� � � ��� � C/.5&=� #�D #F&>� ��E,#F�J���5� ��&OD4#F�I!$#FC ��E,&>�0� &=& .J���$�5� C>��E,&=CO���$� &>?�@5&>�5LO�.@5�J� �5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& C/.$& D #FC/.$#F&O!$& @5�J� D &>?����B� !5&>� ( �'� #F���5-

Page 161: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} À }�9=pfAD;>EB6!OQ6!SFS[AT] ;Z6GE&HI=@OQAKSU?FEF:PEB6i=N7m?F6GAPEF6GOi:DHI=v83ACO&;T:b?[?F6Gj!j!:>]^;ZACSFS[=\:<OQAD;>EFAI836!H>6GEF6,83APOQ6,JM6G798!:PSBA;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6�83APJ�R>J$X R>J>=\8G:iH>=rt�6GEF6GJ>jk:Q8cw>6�APEc:�=N7@7NRMS[?BEF=N:POQAMn�W=\:�� ���� ` �- � �%aba%a3�c d �%aba%a@�0RMJg=NJMSB=@6!OQ6D=@JIaTJ>=r?FAqHI=2;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>=v?F:[email protected]>6C]V;Z6GE,=N;ZA<?B6kS[=�]vAPhPJM=SBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6�aMJ>=@?BA f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn �W= ` R>AP7N6�HI=NOQACS[?BEc:<EF6�8cw>6�� f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn � ` =N7@R>;M;>=N:POQA83ACJ�;>EFAI836kHIR>Ec:,S[=\S[?B6GOi:<?B=\8G:��e6Q83APJ�7@6&EF6GhPAC7@6yHI6G7*om� ?B=N;TA0OQAIHI=@aT8G:<?B6Q83APOQ6&:<;>;Z6GJM:�HI6G?[?BAW�R>J�:P7@LZ6GEFASB6GOi:<JK?B=\83A�;M:<EB?B6!JMHIA�83APJ��+� ` �m6y=NJMSB6GEF6GJMHIAT]ZH>AP;ZA�AChPJ>=^;M:PSFSBAM]�=@J�APhCJ>= Ec:<OQA�:<;Z6GEB?BAM]o�$� � �º]q�+� � ��]6i83AKSºf � ` =N: ` �Pn��^:<7N6&:P7@LZ6GEFA�J>APJ�;>R fAD8cw>=NRMHI6GEcSB=^=NJ�_CRT:<JK?BAT]$S[6QS[=m8cwM=@RMH>6!SFS[6C]$: ` EF6GOQOQAl=NJMSB6GEF=r?FA�SBAP7NA�R>JJWR>OQ6GEFAiaMJ>=@?BA0HI=(;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJ>= H>= �¥6y=@7*8cw>=NRMHI6!EFSB= H>6G7N7YX :<7NLT6!EBA�83ACO&;ZAPEB?B6!EB6!L>LZ6�8cw>6y?F:<7N6ySBA<?B?BAC=@JMSB=N6GOQ6J>ACJ�f6�S[AIH>H>=NS[d�:P8G=@L>=N7N6P]C8GAPJK?BEFA�7YX =N;TAP?B6!SB=T8cwM62APhCJ>=MSBA<?[?FAP=NJMSB=@6!O&6uaTJ>=r?FA,f62SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn ��:b?FAs8cw>627�X :P7@LZ6GEFAJ>ACJ�SB=m8cw>=NRMHI6P]^:<7NOQ6GJ>A0R>J�EF:POQA ` :0: ` :<JK?B=*:P7@7�X =NJIaMJM=r?FAM] 8GAPJK?B=N6GJM6y?FRI?[?F6i7@6/�$� �d����e;Z6GE�APhCJ>= D��6!H¹f683ACOQ;>7@6G?F:<?BA¢�e;ZAP=\8cwu®6,SB=9:CHIA<?B?F:D7\:0;>EFAI836!H>R>EF:DSB=\SU?F6GOi:b?F=N8!:C�­n �^:<7N6iEF:POQA�f6,:<7N7@ACEF:DSBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=N7@6.�YH>:b?FA8cw>6�APhCJ>={Ec:<OQAi83APOQ;>7N63?c:b?FA�f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6k�v6C]>_KR>=@JTHI=Y]M��f6�SBAIH>HI=\SUd�:C83=NL>=@7N6Pn�2JT: ` AP7@?F:QHI=NOQACS[?BEc:b?BA&=N7{?B6!APEF6GOi:yH>=£83ACO&;T:b?[?F6Gj!j!:QS[={AP?[?F=@6!J>6P]M8GAPOQ6�J>6G7 8G:PSBA&;>EBAC;TAKS[=NjG=NAPJT:<7N6P]W=@7�¦

� 8�@AL�8���N �C�GC���I � 8�@XL�8���N�y>=�:�@$�Jx>|�8�9b8�?�?;NvIK�s@AL 9b8�� ��o#2� � � �f9§�3+3i�",B§y��HI=@O'

�eop7$?B6GACEB6!Oi:yHI= 83APEFEF63?[?F6Gj!j!:�deAPEB?B6�S[=$H>=@OQACS[?BEc:Q83ACO&6�SB=(f6 ` =NS[?BAQJ>6!7£8G:CS[A&;>EFAP;ZACSB=@j!=@ACJM:<7N6k�3n½(AP=\8cwu®6Q=N7VOQAIHI6G7N7NA�83AKSU?FEBR>=@?BADJM6G7N7N:D;MEB6k836!H>6GJK?B6lH>=@OQACS[?BEc:<j!=@ACJ>6iHI6G79?B6!APEF6GOi:DHI=v83APOQ;M:<?[?F6GjGjk:�f6l:P7V;>=[fRJWR>OQ6GEc:<L>=N7N6Q�Uf6�83AKSU?F=r?FR>=r?FAiH>:Q83ACS[?F:PJK?B= ` 6k8G8cw>=N6�6�JWR>A ` 6¾�mJ>6sSB6GhCR>6�=@7�¦� 8�@AL�8���N �C�GCiB'I � 8�@XL�8���NvI �s@XL 9b8��jy>= � �@ �S8�< �D8�=�� � � �A@$|�8�� � �q#��T!95+!X�05�#W./# � Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#0f§�3+3���,B§ � Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#h5+!��T!��;��.U5+!X5���Z�!A5+\s���/!X�T./#%,B§Pª%5+3i#�t6P]I;Z6GE�7YX ��SBSB6GE ` :<j!=@ACJ>6�;>EF6!8G6!HI6!JK?B6P]>SB=$;>R^fAQSBAP;M;>EB=NOQ6GEF67�X :<7@?B6GEFJM:<?B= ` :Q8cw>6�=N7$HIACO&=NJ>=NA,S[=\:yaMJ>=@?BAT¦

� 8�@AL�8���N �C�GC�vI � 8�@XL�8���NvI �s@XL 9b8��jy>= � �@ �S8�< �D8�=�� � � �A@$|�8�� � �q#��T!95+!X�05�#W./# � Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#0f§�3+3���,B§ � Q#��%�b�;��5F��^3§P«%5�ªW5+3�#h5+!��T!��;��.U5+!X5���!X�T./#%,B§Pª%5+3i#�t

����;=&>��CO���4�.�5D4�������4#FL>#F���J���F& �4#��5@ � �5D4�IC>&>!5&>D & #F�,@$�A��� �4D �(E,�I!$�5- �I#���H$#F�F@$�5�J� ��� ������&>D4�(!$# � � � � � � �J�5�.���F�B�(�4@J� � &>D E,#F�5� �L>#F���5&"!�����#3�4#%#F� �4D � !5@5C>& � � �� �� !��$&O#%D ��E,#%����&>D4�4#�& �4#%�4HI#F�F@5�5�J� �J�5�<���F�B�.�4&>D E,#F�J��L>#F���5&"!�� #%#F�5�4&>D #F� C>& � � � / �3&(CO��� ��H$#B�$- (����� �4D & �J��D4���F&-!5� #��5@ �"� &>D E,#F�5��D & #F���B�OH0��D �,�$D #FE � !5#�#F�0� D4�I!5@$D D & �B� �I@5�OH��,�5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& � � � � ��!5&>�F��� #F�5� #F&>E,&�-*;=&>��CO��� �"�$D & �!5#FCO�N�4# H0� !�#F� H0&>C>&"!J��� ������&OD4�.!5#2@5�J�.�4#F�5?����B�.�5D4�������4#FL>#F���5& �5@� �,���5!5��D &(���F��� #F� �J�5# �4�.��&>D CO@$# �5#F� ��?��5�"#F�5� &>D #FD4& �F& �5D4������� #FL>#F���5#� � � �#����&>D #F� !5#FCO��E,&O�0�4& & �5D � C>&O!$&OD4& #F�AE,� !5�.�4#F�4�4&>E �N� #FC>�5-

Page 162: disi.unitn.itdisi.unitn.it/~bouquet/filosofia_della_scienza/dispensa_logica.pdf · w < £ ! " #?a@ h6.7k%46lm@ 8º13(9@ 0346d/la46 3h64s(9@ lz 38 9@ 03@ */85cb ".°@%l5¢+134qdu4s*-

} À �