7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

1/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

Li fr~kalx`ai ai bas Jaijf~xvlk Lx hflkz s`xb klicvlcf lih z~ljf s`xb z~fj`g`j fgf-

fijf xa xbf saez lih s`x`icz ag Zak KfS`xx lih Mfk Oajbif)

Dlivlrp ?>

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

2/24

@ixrahvjx`ai

Zfwfrlk efp xbfar`zxz blwf sr`xxfi loavx+ `iwfzx`clxfh lih f~karfh iax`aiz ag klicvlcf lih z~ljf xa hfkwf

`ixa xbf jaiifjx`ic z~bfrfz ag ~b`kaza~bp lih rflk`xp+ xbfarp lih ~rljx`jf lih ofxsffi xbf mfixlk lih xbf za-

j`lk) @iXbf ahvjx`ai ag Z~ljf+Kfgfowrf f~kl`iz xbfzf iax`aiz gvrxbfr5

Fwfrp klicvlcf `z kajlxfh `i l z~ljf) Fwfrp h`zjavrzf zlpz zamfxb`ic loavx l z~ljf5 lih fwfrph`zjavrzf z fm`xxfh gram l z~ljf) Xbfrf lrf xbvz rfklx`aizb`~z ofxsffi klicvlcf lih z~ljf sb`jblrf xa l crflxfr ar kfzzfr fxfix m`zjaizxrvfh ar h`zrfclrhfh) "Kfgfowrf4

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

3/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

~rajfzz ag gvrxbfr`ic l xsa h`mfiz`ailk jaijf~x `ixa l xbrff h`mfiz`ailk zxrvjxvrf jli of zffi `i Zxlih`ic

A~fi Zxvjxvf+ Oklje >3 ~rfzfix) @i lhh`x`ai xa xb`z+ @ s`kk flm`if bas xbf f~fr`fijfz ag z~ljf s`xb`i

xbfzf sarez lrf jrvj`lkkp z`ci`g`jlix xa xbf w`fsfrz ~frjf~x`ai)

Xle`ic `ixa jaiz`hfrlx`ai xbf jaizxrl`ixz ag xb`z ~l~frz sarh javix+ `i arhfr gar vz xa flm`if xbfzf gljxarz l

hfg`i`x`ai ag klicvlcf lih z~ljf s`xb`i xbf G`if Lrxz jaixfx s`kk of lhhrfzzfh) Sblx s`kk of rfgfrrfh xa lz

klicvlcf xbravcbavx mp `iwfzx`clx`ai s`kk of lrxsarez `i xbf garm ag ~r`ixfh xfxz+ z`ciz+ sarhz ai l jliwlz+

sarhz ai l slkk ar+ sr`xxfi ~kliz+ zfxz ag rvkfz lih `izxrvjx`aiz) Mp hfg`i`x`ai ag z~ljf s`xb`i xbfzf lrxsarez s`kk

`ijkvhf ~frjf~xvlk lih ~bpz`jlk z~ljf) @ s`kk l`m xa f~karf bas KfS`xx lih Oajbifr xlef `ixa jaiz`hfrlx`ai xbf

xbfarfx`jlk+ ~bpz`jlk lih ~frjf~xvlk z~bfrfz lih bas xbfp lrf l~~k`fh xbravcb xbf`r sare)

Xbfzf `hflz lih jaijf~xz s`kk of f~karfh xbravcb li lilkpz`z ag xbfarfx`jlk xfxz) Xbfzf xfxz s`kk iax aikp

~raw`hf mf s`xb li vihfrzxlih`ic ag KfS`xx lih Oajbifrz garxp pflr rfxraz~fjx`wf+ ovx s`kk gvrxbfr mp eiask-

fhcf vihfrzxlih`ic xbf h`zjavrzf ag klicvlcf lih z~ljf) r`mlrp jammvi`jlx`ai s`xb Oajbifr vigarxvilxfkp

rfzvkxfh s`xb l rf~kp `ih`jlx`ic xblx bf hafz iax lizsfr |vfzx`aiz rfklxfh xa b`z lrxsare) Fw`hfijf ag xb`z ~r`-

mlrp jammvi`jlx`ai z gflxvrfh i mp l~~fih`jfz) Lz xbfrf lrf m`i`mlk k`xfrlxvrfz ai b`z rfjfix sarez+ mp

asi jaijkvz`aiz s`kk of hrlsi gram xbf `hflz lih |vfzx`aiz rl`zfh)

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

4/24

Jbl~xfr :4287-80) @x `z l jkflr `ixfr~rfxlx`ai xblx xbf `hflz lih jaijf~xz ag xbf sare sfrf ~r`ar`x`zfh awfr

xbf sarez ~bpz`jlk rflk`zlx`ai) Xbfrfgarf+ xbf klicvlcf lih wajlovklrp sb`jb fkvj`hlxfz l jaijf~xvlk ilrrlx`wf

xa xbf ~`fjf mlp iax blwf offi ~frjf`wfh `i b`z fih clmf ovx rfml`iz xbf ~r`ij`~kf fkfmfix xa xbf sare) Xbf

~a`ix of`ic+ xbfzf w`zvlk aodfjxz lrf w`fsfh `i xbf fb`o`x`ai basfwfr+ xbfp mlp iax of gvkkp h`cfzxfh vikfzz xbf

w`fsfr vihfrzxlihz xbf zpzxfm xblx cfifrlxfh xbf ~`fjf)

Lz KfS`xxz vzf ag klicvlcf z xblx sb`jb jaizx`xvxfz l zfx ag rvkfz lih ~fmvxlx`aiz xblx lrf sr`xxfi lih

~kliifh+ mp vihfrzxlih`ic xbfrfgarf `z xblx xbf lrx`zxz w`fs ag xbf gvijx`ai ag klicvlcf `z xa `izxrvjx lih `igarm

b`z hrlgxzmli `i mle`ic xbf lrx) Xbf sare ag lrx `z iax ~kl`i xfx ovx rlxbfr xbf `hfl `xzfkg sb`jb xbf klicvlcf

~arxrlpz) KfS`xxz `ixfix`aiz xa sr`xf jkflr lih jaij`zf `izxrvjx`aiz jli of jklr`g`fh xbravcb Zlvzzvrfz Javzf

`i Cfiflk K`icv`zx`jz sbfrf xbf ~rfzx`cf ag sr`x`ic `z hfzjr`ofh4

Xbf sr`xxfi garm ag l sarh zxr`efz vz lz l ~frmlifix+ zak`h aodfjx+ lih bfijf marf g`xx`ic xbli `xzzavih xa ljx lz l k`icv`zx`j vi`x ~frz`zx`ic xbravcb x`mf) Lkxbavcb xbf jaiifjx`ai ofxsffi sarh lih

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

5/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

sr`xxfi garm `z zv~frg`j`lk+ `x `z iaif xbf kfzz mvjb flz`fr xa crlz~ xbli xbf ilxvrlk lih aikp lvxbfix`jjaiif`ai+ sb`jb k`iez sarh lih zavih "Zlvzzvrf

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

6/24

~racrfzz xaslrhz l ilrrlx`wf vikaje`ic l grffham gram xbf garmlk lih lfzxbfx`j) Iax aikp xblx+ `x slz jkflr xblx

lrx`zxz slixfh xa zxf~ lslp gram lrx lz jammah`xp) @i rfklx`ai xa Zf`lk ^adfjx Ia)< "LOJH "G`c): xbf g`-

ilk`zfh zxrvjxvrf javkh of ~axfix`lkkp oavcbx+ basfwfr xbf `hfl sb`jb `z ~r`ij`~kf jliiax) KfS`xx ~rajkl`mfh

xblx xbf `hflz zakfkp ofkaic xa xbazf sba vihfrzxlih xbfm+ sb`jb frlh`jlxf lip garm ag jammah`xp) Kaae`ic `i

marf hf~xb ofb`ih xbf jaizxrvjx`ai agZf`lk ^adfjx Ia)< "LOJH "G`c): mp vihfrzxlih`ic ag xb`z jaig`rmz+

`i `xz hfmlxfr`lk`zfh garm+ xbf lrx aodfjx `z sr`xxfi klicvlcf)

Xa b`cbk`cbx xb`z gvrxbfr KfS`xx+ l pflr lgxfrZf`lk ^adfjx Ia)< "LOJH "G`c): slz fb`o`xfh+ h`zxr`ovxfh xbf

sr`xxfi gkaar ~kliz ag xbf sare lz l ~azxfr lih `iw`xlx`ai gar b`z Hsli Clkkfrp Kaz Licfkfz zbas "G`c)6) Xb`z

h`lcrlm ag f~klilxarp iaxfz h`z~klpz z~fj`g`j mflzvrfmfixz+ f~klilx`aiz+ z~lx`lk h`ggfrfijfz lih f|vlx`aiz

lz l hfjklrlx`ai xa xbf `m~arxlijf xbf lrx`zx ~kljfh ai xbf jaijf~x) Xb`z mlp blwf offi xa jklr`gp xa xbf w`fsfr

xblx KfS`xx sare slz iax mflix xa of ~frjf`wfh lz l w`zvlkkp ~kflz`ic aodfjx+ ovx `izxflh gvijx`aiz lz xbf ~fr-

gvijxarp lggl`r xa b`z `i`x`lk `hfl) Xbvz+ KfS`xx slz jblkkfic`ic sbfxbfr oaxb xbf sr`xxfi ~kliz "`hfl lih xbf g`-

ilk`zfh zxrvjxvrf "~rahvjfh garm javkh of ~frjf`wfh lz xsa lrxsarez `i xbf`r asi r`cbx) @i rfklx`ai xa sblx blz

offi h`zjvzzfh+ oaxb fkfmfixz agZf`lk ^adfjx Ia)< "LOJH "G`c):'6gvijx`ai `i wfrp h`ggfrfix mfliz) @x

jli of ~rfzvmfh xblx KfS`xxz hfj`z`ai xa `iwakwf b`z sr`xxfi ~kliz `ixa xbf clkkfrp fb`o`x `i xb`z jlzf+ rf`i-

zxlxfz sblx lrx b`zxar`li Dlmfz Mfpfr zvccfzxz `x slz iax dvzx li f~klilxarp cv`hf xa xbf zbas+ ovx xa fm-

~blz`zf xbf m~arxlijf ag xbf hfl+ vihfrkp`ic xbf jam~kfxfh lrxsare "Mfpfr ?>>>42) @x jli of lrcvfh xblx

xbf gvijx`ai ag xbf sr`xxfi ~azxfrz lih `iw`xlx`ai jlrhz sfrf xa ~kljf xbf w`fsfr jkazfr xa xbf lrx`zxz xbavcbxz

lih ixfix`aiz i arhfr xa vihfrzxlih xbf ~`fjf) Basfwfr+ mp vihfrzxlih`icz lrf xblx xbf sr`xxfi iaxfz sfrf

iax zakfkp l gvrxbfr f~klilx`ai5 ovx sfrf `ijar~arlxfh xa lkkas xbf w`fsfr xa l~~rfj`lxf oaxb lz xsa zf~lrlxf

sarez `i xsa lih xbrff h`mfiz`ailk garmlxz)

KfS`xxz klxfr ~`fjf+ Ifs Zxvjxvfz

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

7/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

Zf`lk ^adfjx Ia)< "LOJH "G`c):) Xb`z xrlizgarmlx`ai rl`zfz ivmfravz |vfzx`aiz zvrravih`ic xbf ~frjf~-

x`aiz ag xbf ~`fjf lih xbf jaixfx ag sbfi `x slz jrflxfh)

@i mp lilkpz`z+ xbf zb`gx gram zvjb grlc`kf cfamfxr`j garmz xa maivmfixlk okaje zxrvjxvrfz jli of z~fjvklxfh

lgxfr kaae`ic lx b`z sare

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

8/24

jlvzf xbf w`fsfr xa aoxl`i l kfzz `ix`mlxf f~fr`fijf agIfs Zxrvjxvrfz "G`c)8) Basfwfr+ sf jliiax hfip xblx

xb`z zjlkf garjfz xbf z~fjxlxar xa of lslrf ag xbfmzfkwfz `i rfklx`ai xa xbf sare) Xbfrfgarf l jaiifjx`ai of-

xsffi w`fsfr lih zxrvjxvrf jliiax of lwa`hfh sbfxbfr ix`mlxf ar iax)

Xbf iax`ai ag z~ljf `z iax aikp gvihlmfixlk `i xbf mle`ic ag xbf lrx+ ovx lkza |vfzx`aiz xbf awfrlkk f~fr`fijf

`i xbf ~frjf~x`ai ag xbf sare) _fgfrr`ic olje xa Marr`z zxlxfmfix+ `x `z vihfi`lokf xblx xb`icz zmlkkfr xbli avr-

zfkwfz lrf zffi h`ggfrfixkp xa xb`icz klrcfr+ basfwfr `i rfklx`ai xa KfS`xxz sarez `x jli of ~a`ixfh avx xblx xbf`r

garmz lkza h`ggfr `mmfizfkp `i xbf`r mlxfr`lk lfzxbfx`j) @i mp ~a`ix ag w`fs mlxfr`lk`xp mvzx of l gvihlmfixlk

lz~fjx xa xlef `ixa jaiz`hfrlx`ai ofjlvzf `x `z iax dvzx zjlkf sb`jb jaiwfpz xbf lrx`zxz `ixfix`aiz) Xbf ~a`ix of-

`ic+ `g xbf mlxfr`lk vzfh `i Ifs Zxvjxvfz "G`c)8 slz iax jaijrfxf lih blh xbf lfzxbfx`j |vlk`xp agZf`lk

^adfjx Ia)< "LOJH "G`c): xbf sare savkh blwf l kfzz `m~ljx`ic ~rfzfijf klrcf zjlkf ar iax)

B`z zxrvjxvrlk sarez awfr xbf ~lzx xb`rxp pflrz blwf iax aikp f~karfh ifclx`wf lih ~az`x`wf z~ljf xa vijawfr

xbf rfklx`aiz ofxsffi a~fi lih jkazfh jvofz+ ovx blz jammvi`jlxfh xbf grlc`k`xp lih zak`h`xp ag xbf fljx

zlmf garm) Op jblic`ic xbf mlxfr`lk`xp lih zjlkf ag xb`z garm jrflxfz li `m~rfzz`ai iaifxbfkfzz ai xbf w`fsfr

mfixlkkp lih ~bpz`jlkkp) @x `z jkflr xblx oaxb sarez sfrf jaizxrvjxfh vz`ic sr`xxfi `izxrvjx`ailk klicvlcf bas-

fwfr5 mlxfr`lk`xp lih xbf iax`aiz ag z~ljf blwf lkxfrfh bas xbfzf xbrff h`mfiz`ailk zxrvjxvrfz lrf ~frjf`wfh)

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

9/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

Jbl~xfr ?

Xbf sare ag Mfk Oajbifr s`kk ias of h`zjvzzfh ai xbf jaijf~xz lih |vfzx`aiz lr`zfi xbravcb xbf lilkpz`z ag

xsa efp sarez+ Mflzvfmfix4 _aam

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

10/24

Lz Oajbifr blz zxlxfh xblx mflzvrfmfixz bakh li fzzfix`lk iaxb`icifzz+ @ ofc`i xa |vfzx`ai xbf`r m~arxlijf

s`xb`i xbf sare) @x `z l~~lrfix sbfi w`fs`ic xbf sare xbf aikp xb`ic xbf w`fsfrz blwf xa jam~lrf s`xb Oajbi-

frz mflzvrfmfixz lrf xbf mflzvrfmfixz ag xbfmzfkwfz5 sb`jb mlp of sbp Oajbifr vzfh mflzvrfmfixz i

gffx lih `ijbfz) S`xb xb`z `i m`ih+ `x jli of |vfzx`aifh `g xbf ~bpz`jlk rflk`zlx`ai ag xbf zvrravih`icz jli aikp

of hfxfrm`ifh sbfi xbf w`fsfr z `i rfklx`ai xa xbf sare) Xa iwfzx`clxf xb`z gvrxbfr+ Pwf-Lkl`i Oa`z h`zjawfrfh

xblx4

Xbf mflzvrfmfixz ai xbf slkkz h`h iax rfljb `iz`hf xbf haar grlmfz ar s`ihas ~lifz) @i axbfrsarhz+ xbf mflzvrfmfixz h`h iax ml~ xbf z~ljf ag xbf raam lz `x savkh of f~fr`fijfh op xbf w`fs-fr) @izxflh+ xbf mflzvrfmfixz Oajbifr ~raw`hfh zvccfzxfh l havokfh lih h`ggfrfix z~ljf+ k`ef lilrjb`xfjxvrlk okvf~r`ix+ l cfamfxr`jlk lozxrljxfh rfihfr`ic ag xbf ~bpz`jlk z~ljf) Xbf raam blh offimflzvrfh+ ovx xb`z slz iax gar xbf zlef ag xbf w`fsfr) Xbf rflk`zlx`ai ag xb`z h`ggfrfijf savkh ~ra-hvjf l ~blixlzmlcar`j gffk`ic ag fzxrlicfmfix "Hf Zlkwa4?>>64:8)

Oajbifrz ml~~`ic xbf ~fr`mfxfr ag xbf clkkfrp zvccfzxz b`z ixfr~klp s`xb bvmli f~fr`fijf+ bas ~frjf~x`ai+

`mlc`ilx`ai lih xbf ~bpz`jlk`xp ag xbf z~ljf jli lkxfr lih lhdvzx ljjarh`ic xa xbf `ih`w`hvlk w`fsfr) @x `z ~azz`-

okf xblx Oajbifr slixfh xa jlvzf gr`jx`ai ofxsffi xbf w`fsfrz mfixlk lzzaj`lx`ai ag l mflzvrfmfix lih xbf`r

cfiv`if f~fr`fijf ag `x+ lkxfr`ic xbf`r fix`rf f~fr`fijf ag xbf sare) Marfawfr+ `x javkh of zxlxfh b`z `ixfr~klp

s`xb mflzvrfmfix mlp blwf offi mfrfkp l jaijf~x ag hfjaizxrvjx`ic l garm)

Xle`ic lkk xbfzf jaijf~xz ixa jaiz`hfrlx`ai mp vihfrzxlih`icz agMflzvfmfix4 _aam "G`c)3`z iax xblx ag

l zjvk~xvrlk sare+ ovx `z zx`kk xblx ag l xbrff h`mfiz`ailk `izxlkklx`ai) @x `z h`gg`jvkx gar mf xa zff xbf sare lz l

zjvk~xvrf+ c`wfi xblx xbf lrx`zx hafz iax) Basfwfr+ aif mvzx zx`kk xlef `ixa ljjavix xblx xbf lrjb`xfjxvrlk gavihl-

x`aiz vzfh sfrf iax z~fj`g`jlkkp ~rahvjfh `i xbf sare+ ovx zakfkp ljxfh lz l grlmf xa xbf sare) Xb`z ~lrx`jvklr

grlmf "xbf clkkfrp `zix l ifjfzz`xp xa Oajbifrz `hfl5 `i gljx xbf sare+ xa oarras gram Oajbifr `z iax l ~arxl-

okf aodfjx+ ovx l ~arxlokf `hfl "Oajbifr4?>>2463) C`wfi xbf jaixfx ag sbfi xbf sare slz jaiz`hfrfh aggfrz

li vihfrkp`ic z`ci`g`jlijf ai `xz ~az`x`ai s`xb`i xbf `izx`xvx`ai) @i mp vihfrzxlih`ic ag xb`z sare Oajbifr zavcbx

lgxfr+ lz bf hfjklrfh i li @ixfrw`fs s`xb Fklpif Wlr`li i

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

11/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

Mflzvfmfix4 _aam "G`c)3iax aikp fm~blz`zfz xbf lrflz ag xbf clkkfrp vzvlkkp viiax`jfh op xbf lrx z~fj-

xlxar+ ovx vzfz l k`if ag xl~f ai l slkk xa jaixl`i l z~ljf) Xbf clkkfp xbfi xrlizgarmz gram l ov`kh`ic xblx bavz-

fz lrx `ixa xbf lrjb`xfjxvrlk grlmf agli lrxsare) Oajbifr lkza f~karfz xbf rfklx`aizb`~ ofxsffi ifclx`wf lih

~az`x`wf z~ljf xa sb`jb `x `z |vfzx`ailokf+ sblx `z jaixl`ifh lih sblx `zix+ lz `z `x h`gg`jvkx xa jam~rfbfih xbf

fhcfz lih oavihlr`fz ag xbf grlmf) _fgfrr`ic olje xa sblx Pwf-Lkl`i Oa`z zxlxfh+ x z lcrfflokf Oajbifr mlp

iax blwf mflzvrfh xbf z~ljf gar xbf zlef ag xbf w`fsfr+ ovx x jliiax of hfi`fh xbf jaijf~x ag mflzvrfmfix

s`kk lkxfr xbf w`fsfrz f~fr`fijf ag xbf sare) Lgxfr lkk+ Oajbifr `z glzj`ilxfh s`xb bas f~fr`fijf `z garmfh)

@i b`z klxfr sarez+ Oajbifrz zfr`fz agXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz zvjb lz Mfli`ickfzz ?>>: "G`c)2+ Iaxb`ic

?>>8 "G`c)0+ lih Maifp!Aozjfif ?>>7 "G`c) jlvcbx mp fpf) @x slz iax aikp xbf ~kljfmfix ag sr`xxfi kli-

cvlcf ai l jliwlz ovx xbf slp i sb`jb xbf jakavrz vzfh mlhf jfrxl`i sarhz marf ~ram`ifix xbli axbfrz)

Xbf ~l`ix`icz ofc`i s`xb l efp sarh sb`jb `z zfkfjxfh op xbf lrx`zx5 l xbfzlvrvz `z xbfi vzfh lz l rfzavrjf `i

arhfr xa clxbfr zfmlix`jlkkp rfklxfh sarhz) Oajbifr xbfi ~l`ixz xbf lhh`x`ailk sarhz ai xbf jliwlz sb`jb gak-

kasz ai gram xbf `i`x`lk efp sarh) Xbf zfr`fz agXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz jaiz`zx ag a`k lih ljrpk`j ai jliwlz bas-

fwfr `i b`z ?>>7 sare Maifp!Aozjfif "G`c)a`k slz l~~k`fh xa wfkwfx)

OajbifrzXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz zxfmmfh gram b`z `ixfrfzx `i ~arxrl`xvrf+ bf blz zxlxfh xblx _lvzjbfiofrcz

^axl`x ag @`z Jkfx lih L~akk`il`rfz Jlkk`crlmmfz sfrf i xbf olje ag b`z m`ih sbfi bf l~~raljbfh xbf

xbfzlvrvz lz l rfzavrjf "Oajbifr4?>>24>24

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

12/24

Oajbifrz f~klilx`ai hfmaizxrlxfz bas klicvlcf blz lhl~xfh xbravcb x`mf v~ xa xbf ~a`ix sbfrf zklic

sarhz lrf ofjam`ic arh`ilrp i fwfrphlp z~aefi lih sr`xxfi klicvlcf) Xb`z mlp jfrxl`ikp rfgkfjx xbf pavxb

jvkxvrf ag xb`z hfjlhf lih xbf ~ak`x`jlk v~bflwlkz zvrravih`ic xbf zaj`lk jklzzfz iax xa mfix`ai xbf ifs jrf-

lx`wf garmz ag klicvlcf vzfh `i aik`if jblxraamz+ zaj`lk ifxsare`ic z`xfz lih loorfw`lxfh xfx mfzzlcfz)

Kaae`ic lx xbf ~l`ix`ic Iaxb`ic ?>>8 "G`c)0+ sarhz zvjb lz t`~ caazf fcc lih h`hhkpzb`x zxaah avx gar

xbf rflzai ag ~frzailkkp iax blw`ic lip lzzaj`lx`ai xa xbf sarh iaxb`ic)

Xa lhhrfzz xb`z gvrxbfr+ s`xb rfklx`ai xa OajbifrzXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz `i arhfr gar xbf w`fsfr xa jam~rfbfih

xbf w`zvlk rf~rfzfixlx`ai ag xbf ~l`ixfh sarhz+ xbf iax`ai iffhfh z jammai cravih4

Fwfrpxb`ic sf ha `z raaxfh `i `igarmlx`ai sf blwf loavx avr zvrravih`icz+ ljx`w`x`fz+ ~frjf~x`aiz+fmax`aiz+ ~kliz+ lih `ixfrfzxz) Fwfrpxb`ic sf ha da`ixkp s`xb axbfrz `z lkza raaxfh `i xb`z `igarmlx`ai+ovx aikp `i xblx ~lrx sf xb`ie xbfp zblrf s`xb vz) Jammai cravih `z `m~arxlix xa lip ljjavix ag kli-cvlcf vzf xblx l~~flkz xa jaixfx) Mazx ljjavixz haix zlp sblx jaixfx `z+ ovx rfkp ai avr `ixv-`x`aiz loavx xbf j`rjvmzxlijfz ag fljb vxxfrlijf "Jklre4

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

13/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

gkas`ic `ixa jrvhf sarhz mlp z~lre bvmavr ar h`zcvzx) Oajbifrz `igkvfijf ag w`z`ai lih ~frjf~x`ai `z iax aikp

fw`hfix xbravcb b`z `ixfr~klp s`xb klicvlcf ovx lkza `i b`z vzf ag jakavr)

XbfXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz rlicf gram wfrp oakh lih or`cbxkp ~l`ixfh sarhz sb`jb dvm~ ag xbf zvrgljf ag xbf

jliwlz xa sarhz sb`jb lrf za z`m`klr xa xbf oljecravih jakavr xbfp ~rawf h`gg`jvkx xa hfj`~bfr) @x `z fw`hfix xbf

Oajbifrz vzf ag jakavr `z xa h`zjarh ofxsffi xbf lvh`fijfz w`fs`ic lih rflh`ic ag xbf sare) Lz xbf jakavrz

lrf za w`w`h+ xbf w`fsfr mvzx w`fs lih rflh lx xbf zlmf x`mf jrflx`ic lseslrhifzz xa xbf gkas ag xbf sarhz)

Oajbifr blz zl`h jakavr h`wfrxz xbf xfx gram `xz hvxp ag mfli`ic "Ovrxai4?>>34:>7 "G`c) xbf sarhz lrf za oakh xbfp lrf lkmazx

ckas`ic5 l mlzz ag xfx `z clxbfrfh xacfxbfr `i l zmlkk z~ljf ai xbf jliwlz mle`ic `x fxrfmfkp h`gg`jvkx gar xbf

rflhfr xa jam~rfbfih) Iax aikp xblx+ xbf Aozjfif "G`c) xfx `z v~z`hf hasi sb`jb s`kk ~rawaef xbf rflhfr

xa xvri xbf`r bflh+ ~raw`ic zamfsblx `m~azz`okf xa hfj`~bfr) @g xbf w`fsfr hafz iax xvri xbf`r bflh v~z`hf hasi

xbfp savkh blwf xa rflh xbf zfmlix`jlkkp rfklxfh sarhz oljeslrhz+ marfawfr+ jblic`ic gram aif xa xbf axbfr

s`kk jlvzf h`tt`ifzz) Oajbifr blz rfmawfh l zfizf ag lo`k`xp bfrf gram b`z w`fsfrz `i jaixrlzx xa b`z axbfr

Xbfzlvvz l`ix`icz+ marf sarhz lrf `ijar~arlxfh lih hvf xa xbf`r jkazfifzz k`ifz lrf `ifw`xlokp ca`ic xa of

rfrflh jrflx`ic l h`zar`fixlxfh gffk`ic xa b`z z~fjxlxar) Vik`ef b`z axbfrXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz fwfrp kfxxfr `i

Maifp!Aozjfif "G`c)`z l h`ggfrfix jakavr xbfrfgarf sbfi zamf kfxxfrz lrf jkazf xa xbf oljecravih jakavr

l ~lrx ag l sarh xbfi ofjamfz h`zda`ixfh)

Oajbifrz `ixfr~klp ofxsffi klicvlcf lih jakavr ~klpz crflxkp s`xb xbf w`fsfrz ~frjf~x`ai ag xbf sare) Bf iax

aikp fm~blz`zfz xbf jrvhf lih aggfiz`wf klicvlcf ag xahlp ovx lkza b`z `m~kfmfixlx`ai ag jakavr jlvzfz gr`j-

x`ai ofxsffi rflh`ic lih w`fs`ic xbf ~`fjf) @x jli of `ixfr~rfxfh xblx Oajbifrz vzf ag klicvlcf `i b`zXbf-

zlvvz ^l`ix`icz mlp blwf offi l jr`x`jlk rfz~aizf xa bas klicvlcf slz ofk`fwfh xa of xrliz~lrfix) Kli-

cvlcf jliiax of zffi lz xrliz~lrfix+ bvmliz lrf iax xfkf~lxb`j+ lih ~fa~kf lkk blwf wlrp`ic jaijf~xz ag xbf

zlmf rf~rfzfixlx`ai ag sarhz) Xle`ic xb`z ixa ljjavix+ x javkh of zl`h xblx OajbifrzXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz

javkh of ov`kx v~ai awfr x`mf lih javkh f~lih gvrxbfr) @ gffk Oajbifr blz lkrflhp xlefi xb`z `ixa jaiz`hfrlx`ai

ofjlvzf lkk b`zXbfzlvvz l`ix`icz fih `i l jamml iax l gvkk zxa~)

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

14/24

Jaijkvz`ai

@i xb`z h`zzfrxlx`ai xbf iax`aiz ag klicvlcf lih z~ljf blwf offi f~karfh xbravcb efp sarez op jaijf~xvlk

lrx`zxz Zak KfS`xx lih Mfk Oajbifr) @ blwf flm`ifh bas lih sbp klicvlcf `z vzfh `i xbf`r sarez+ `iwfzx`clx-

`ic xbf lrx`zxz k`icv`zx`jlkkp jaizxrvjxfh hfjklrlx`ai ag `ixfix) Li lilkpz`z ag xbf e`ih ag klicvlcf vzfh lih xbf

zvoxkf jaixfxvlk jblicfz ag KfS`xx lih Oajbifrz sare gram xbf z xa "?>>3-~rfzfix blz lkza offi f-

~karfh) Marfawfr+ xbf f~fr`fijf ag z~ljf lih bas x oflrz ai xbf w`fsfrz ~frjf~x`ai blz offi vi~`jefh s`xb

li `ixfix`ai xa rl`zf `hflz+ jaijf~xz lih |vfzx`aiz)

Xbravcbavx xbf lilkpz`z jfrxl`i jaijf~xz zvjb lz xbf h`zzfm`ilx`ai ag `hflz xbravcb garm+ hfjaizxrvjx`ic l

jaixfx `i arhfr gar `x xa of vihfrzxaah+ lih |vfzx`ai`ic `g xbf `hfl lih ~rahvjfh garm lrf w`fsfh lz xsa lrx-

sarez `i xbf`r asi r`cbx blwf rl`zfh |vfzx`aiz `i rfklx`ai xa mp asi ~rljx`jf) KfS`xxz vzf ag `izxrvjx`ailk kli-

cvlcf gvrxbfrz l xsa h`mfiz`ailk jaijf~x `ixa l xbrff h`mfiz`ailk zxrvjxvrf+ sb`jb @ ofk`fwf oaxb+ xbf `hfl lih

~rahvjfh garm+ jli of zffi lz xsa lrxsarez `i xbf`r asi r`cbx) Xbvz fm~blz`t`ic bas sr`xxfi ~kliz lih `igar-

mlx`ai lrf fzzfix`lk xa xbf ~rahvjfh garm)

Oajbifrz vzf ag mflzvrfmfix blz rl`zfh |vfzx`aiz ag hfjaizxrvjx`ai lih jaixl`imfix ag l ~bpz`jlk z~ljf

ovx lkza bas mflzvrfmfix z mfrfkp l bvmli jaizxrvjx`ai olzfh ai ~frjf~x`ai) Marfawfr b`zXbfzlvvz

^l`ix`icz+ Mfli`ickfzz ?>>: "G`c)2+ Iaxb`ic ?>>8 "G`c)0 lih Maifp!Aozjfif ?>>7 "G`c) hfmai-

zxrlxfz bas ifs garmz ag klicvlcf blwf rf~rfzfixfh l jvkxvrlk zb`gx+ xa sb`jb zklic sarhz lrf ofjam`ic arh`-

ilrp `i fwfrphlp z~aefi lih sr`xxfi klicvlcf) @x javkh of zl`h xblx KfS`xx lih Oajbifr blwf jrflxfh xbf`r

sarez xa li `ixfihfh lvh`fijf rfklx`ic xa mp f~klilx`aiz ag jammai cravih lih da`ix ljx`ai) L gvrxbfr lilkp-

z`z ag Oajbifrz ~l`ix`icz vijawfrz bas b`z vzf ag jakavr h`zjarh ofxsffi xbf lvh`fijf w`fs`ic lih rflh`ic

xbf sare) Sblxz marf+ bas zamf jakavrz ckas ag xbf jliwlz lih axbfrz glhf `ixa xbf oljecravih jakavr jrf-

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

15/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

lx`ic lseslrhifzz sbfi rflh`ic xbf zpiaipmz) Xb`z jaijf~x ag h`zda`ixfh sarhz jli rfklxf z`ci`g`jlixkp xa b`z

jr`x`|vf ag xbf klicvlcf gflxvrfh s`xb`i xbf xbfzlvrvz+ b`z x`xkfz Mfli`ickfzz "G`c)2+ Iaxb`ic "G`c)0lih

Aozjfif "G`c) z~lre raip xa xbf ifs garmz ag klicvlcf sf blwf xahlp)

)

O`ok`acrl~bp

Oajbifr+ M)+ ?>>2)Zakl Zpzxfmz lih _fzx _aamz S`x`icz lih @ixfw`fsz >3) Mlzzljbv-

zfxxz4 Xbf M@X ^rfzz)

Ovrxai+ D)+ ?>>3)Mfk Oajbif Klicvlcf >7)Jb`jlrca4 Xbf Lrx @izx`xvxf ag Jb`jlca)

Jklre)B)B)+6)A~fi Zpzxfmz _fxb`ie`ic Lx) Kaihai4 Xlxf ^vok`zb`ic)

Gavjlvkx+ M)+ >

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

16/24

Kfgfowrf)B)+ >) M`i`mlk`zm-Xbfmfz lih Mawfmfixz) Kaihai4 bl`hai rfzz)

Zlvzzvrf+ G)+>:) Zak KfS`xx U@ixfifx] Oamo Mlclt`if+ Ifs Lrx vok`jlx`aiz) Lwl`klokf lx4

bxx~4!!oamoz`xf)jam!`zzvfz!26!lrx`jkfz!?62: ULjjfzzfh >? Dlivlrp ?>])

Kfslkkfi+ J) ?>>>) Zak KfS`xx!Mlx`r 7: U@ixfrifx] Vi`wfrz`xp ag Jlk`gari`l+ Ofrefkfp Lrx Mvzfvm ' ^lj`g`j

G`km Lrjb`wf) Lwl`klokf lx4 bxx~4!!sss)olm~gl)ofrefkfp)fhv!fb`o`x`ai!7: ULjjfzzfh >? Dlivlrp

?>])

^frzailk Jammvi`jlx`ai

Ilxxrfzz+ J)+ ?>>0 H`zjvzz`ai ai Zak KfS`xx lih Mfk Oajbif) U^rfzfixlx`ai] frzailk Jammvi`jlx`ai+ ?8

Iawfmofr ?>>0)

http://bombsite.com/issues/85/articles/2583http://bombsite.com/issues/85/articles/2583http://www.bampfa.berkeley.edu/exhibition/63http://www.bampfa.berkeley.edu/exhibition/63http://www.bampfa.berkeley.edu/exhibition/63http://bombsite.com/issues/85/articles/2583

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

17/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

L~~fih`jfz

G`cvf

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

18/24

G`cvf ?4 Oajbifr)M)+

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

19/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

G`cvf 84 KfS`xx+ Z)+ >>) M`i`mlk`zm-Xbfmfz lih Mawf-

mfixz) Kaihai4 bl`hai rfzz)

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

20/24

G`cvf 64 KfS`xx+ Z)+

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

21/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

G`cvf 34 Oajbifr+ M)+ >3!!Oajbifr)d~c

http://www.textezurkunst.de/static/content/2007/10/Bochner.jpghttp://www.textezurkunst.de/static/content/2007/10/Bochner.jpg

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

22/24

G`cvf 24 Oajbifr+ M)+ ?>>: Mfli`ickfzz) @mlcf gram sss)gr`ftf)jam

G`cvf 04 Oajbifr+ M)+ ?>>8 Iaxb`ic) @mlcf gram4

Ovrxai+ D)+ ?>>3)Mfk Oajbif Klicvlcf >7)Jb`jlrca4 Xbf Lrx @izx`xvxf ag Jb`jlca)

http://www.frieze.com/http://www.frieze.com/http://www.frieze.com/

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

23/24

Ja~pr`cbx ?> op Jklrf Ilxxrfzz

G`cvf 4 Oajbifr+ M)+ ?>>7 Maifp!Aozjfif @mlcf gram bxx~4!!|v`ixclkkfrp)jam!|v`ixs~!s~-

jaixfix!v~kalhz!mo-aozjfif-maifp)d~c

http://quintgallery.com/quintwp/wp-content/uploads/mb-obscene-money.jpghttp://quintgallery.com/quintwp/wp-content/uploads/mb-obscene-money.jpghttp://quintgallery.com/quintwp/wp-content/uploads/mb-obscene-money.jpghttp://quintgallery.com/quintwp/wp-content/uploads/mb-obscene-money.jpg

7/31/2019 Dissertation on Website

24/24

^`mlp Jammvi`jlx`ai s`xb Oajbif

Ja~pr`cbx Jklrf Ilxxrfzz+ ?>)

Xa rfgfrfijf xb`z ~kflzf zxlxf xbf gakkas4Ilxxrfzz+ J) "?>Li fr~kalx ai ai bas Jaijf~xvlk Lx hflkz s`xb klicvlcf lihz~ljf s`xb z~fj`g`j fgffijf xa xbf saez lih s`x`icz ag Zak KfS`xx lih Mfk Oajbif+U@ixfifx] Lwl`klokf gam bxx~4!!sss)jklf-ilxxfzz)jam!`ihfr)~b~1!s`x`ic!ljlhfm`j-s`x`ic! Ulj-jfzzfh ai hlxf])

http://www.clare-nattress.com/index.php?/writing/academic-writing/http://www.clare-nattress.com/index.php?/writing/academic-writing/