Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Distribution and populations ofDistribution and populations ofArmillariaArmillaria in the regionin the region
R. Rippy
JOHN W. HANNAJOHN W. HANNA1,21,2, James A. Moore, James A. Moore11, Terry M. Shaw, Terry M. Shaw11,,Geral I. McDonaldGeral I. McDonald22, Mee, Mee--Sook KimSook Kim22, Ned B. Klopfenstein, Ned B. Klopfenstein22
11Department of Forest Resources, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID Department of Forest Resources, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID 838448384422USDA Forest Service, RMRS, 1221 S. Main St. Moscow, ID 83843USDA Forest Service, RMRS, 1221 S. Main St. Moscow, ID 83843
Hanna et al. 2004
ArmillariaArmillaria Species and Relative PathogenicitySpecies and Relative Pathogenicity
NABSa Species Pathogenicity Primary Host
I
VI
A. ostoyaeA. melleaA. tabescens
High
High
High?
Conifers
Hardwoods
Hardwoods
II
IX
A. geminaA. nabsnona
Moderate?
Moderate?
Hardwoods
Hardwoods
III
V
VII
XI
A. calvescensA. sinapinaA. gallicaA. cepistipes
Low
Low
Low
Low
Mixed
Mixed
Mixed
Mixed
X Unnamed Rarely pathogenic Mixed
aaNABSNABS = North American Biological Species= North American Biological Species
Hanna et al. 2004
IFTNC IFTNC ArmillariaArmillaria species summaryspecies summary
During the 1999 and 2000 field seasons over 8,500 During the 1999 and 2000 field seasons over 8,500 trees were sampled for trees were sampled for ArmillariaArmillaria, 1,310 isolates of , 1,310 isolates of ArmillariaArmillaria were collected from 23 IFTNC sites. were collected from 23 IFTNC sites. Based on over 8,000 somaticBased on over 8,000 somatic--incompatibility tests, incompatibility tests, these isolates were found to consist of 221 genets these isolates were found to consist of 221 genets (individual clones).(individual clones).
Of the 10 North American Biological Species 6 were Of the 10 North American Biological Species 6 were associated with the IFTNC sites.associated with the IFTNC sites.
Hanna et al. 2004
Huckleberry
Soldier Creek
Enterprise
Stanton
Hanna et al. 2004
NABS I NABS I –– Armillaria ostoyaeArmillaria ostoyae62 genets collected from 17 IFTNC sites62 genets collected from 17 IFTNC sites
Serious plant pathogen found throughout the Northern Serious plant pathogen found throughout the Northern Hemisphere that causes root and butt rot on diverse Hemisphere that causes root and butt rot on diverse woody plant hosts. woody plant hosts.
Adversely impacts commercial timber production by Adversely impacts commercial timber production by causing tree mortality and growth reduction. causing tree mortality and growth reduction.
Genetically diverse and may be comprised of several Genetically diverse and may be comprised of several races. Intraspecific hybrids are common.races. Intraspecific hybrids are common.
Hanna et al. 2004
NABS X NABS X –– Unnamed Unnamed ArmillariaArmillaria speciesspecies69 genets collected from 16 IFTNC sites69 genets collected from 16 IFTNC sites
Unnamed Unnamed ArmillariaArmillaria species found in the northwestern species found in the northwestern United States. United States.
Mainly saprophytic, living on dead organic matter. Mainly saprophytic, living on dead organic matter.
Hanna et al. 2004
NABS III, V, VII complex NABS III, V, VII complex ––A. calvescensA. calvescens, , A. sinapinaA. sinapina, , A. gallicaA. gallica58 genets collected from 14 IFTNC sites58 genets collected from 14 IFTNC sites
Group of similar species of Group of similar species of Armillaria Armillaria found throughout found throughout North America. North America.
Primarily saprophytic with low pathogenicity (less than Primarily saprophytic with low pathogenicity (less than 5%). 5%).
Hybridization is common between species.Hybridization is common between species.
Hybrids are difficult to identify.Hybrids are difficult to identify.
Hanna et al. 2004
NABS X / NABS III, V, VII NABS X / NABS III, V, VII complex hybridscomplex hybrids31 genets collected from 31 genets collected from 12 IFTNC sites12 IFTNC sites
Common within the Inland Common within the Inland Northwest. Northwest.
Previously grouped with NABS X Previously grouped with NABS X until their discovery using molecular until their discovery using molecular techniques.techniques.
Mainly saprophytic (less that 5% Mainly saprophytic (less that 5% pathogenic).
Hanna et al. 2004
pathogenic).
NABS IX NABS IX –– Armillaria nabsnonaArmillaria nabsnona1 genet collected from 1 IFTNC site1 genet collected from 1 IFTNC site
A rare species found primarily on hardwoods, such as A rare species found primarily on hardwoods, such as Alnus Alnus species, in riparian areas of western North America. species, in riparian areas of western North America.
IFTNCIFTNC’’s isolation of this species from s isolation of this species from Abies grandis Abies grandis is is one of the first reports of this species being isolated from a one of the first reports of this species being isolated from a conifer.conifer.
Thomas J. VolkThomas J. VolkHanna et al. 2004
Types of information collected from Types of information collected from Nutrition CoNutrition Co--op sitesop sites
Isolate IDIsolate ID
LocationLocation
Host SpeciesHost Species
Collection Type (Bark Fan, Rhizomorph, or Wood)Collection Type (Bark Fan, Rhizomorph, or Wood)
Host Collection (Dead or Alive)Host Collection (Dead or Alive)
Habitat TypeHabitat Type
Fertilization TreatmentFertilization Treatment
Species IDSpecies ID
Rock TypeRock Type
Hanna et al. 2004
Bark fan collection typeBark fan collection type
Bark fans from live trees indicate high pathogenicityBark fans from live trees indicate high pathogenicityof an of an ArmillariaArmillaria individual individual
Dead trees with bark fans and Dead trees with bark fans and resinosusresinosus and or wound and or wound periderm may indicate pathogenicity periderm may indicate pathogenicity
Dead trees with bark fans without Dead trees with bark fans without resinosusresinosus indicate indicate saprophytic behaviorsaprophytic behavior
Hanna et al. 2004
Wood samples are usually taken from trees that haveWood samples are usually taken from trees that haverecently been killed or are infected with a recently been killed or are infected with a pathogenic pathogenic ArmillariaArmillaria individual. individual.
Often dark lines known as zone lines can be seen in Often dark lines known as zone lines can be seen in infected wood.infected wood.
Wood collection typeWood collection type
Hanna et al. 2004
All species of All species of ArmillariaArmillaria form rhizomorphs. form rhizomorphs.
Most rhizomorphs are found on the surface of a root, some grow Most rhizomorphs are found on the surface of a root, some grow freely through the soil, and others can be found under the bark freely through the soil, and others can be found under the bark of a of a highly infected tree. highly infected tree.
Presence of rhizomorphs does not necessarily indicate pathogenicPresence of rhizomorphs does not necessarily indicate pathogenicity ity of an of an Armillaria Armillaria individual.individual.
Hanna et al. 2004
Rhizomorph collection typeRhizomorph collection type
DNA SequencingDNA Sequencing
Nuclear SmallNuclear Small rDNArDNA
ITS-1IGS-2 ITS-2
Nuclear Large rDNANuclear Large rDNA
IGS-1
5S5S
IGS-2
NuclearNuclearSmallSmallrDNArDNA
5.8S5.8SrDNArDNA
Ribosomal DNA regions currently being investigated forRibosomal DNA regions currently being investigated forphylogenetic signal include IGS, ITS, and LSU.phylogenetic signal include IGS, ITS, and LSU.
Hanna et al. 2004
Variable nucleotide positions of aligned nLSU sequences.
GENET 126bp 129bp 165bp 172-173bp 227bp 407bp 470bp 477bp 481bp 500bp 514bp 518bp 524bp 602bp 656bp 750bp 787bp 812bpT
T
AT C
A
A
A T
T
T
T
T
T C
C
C
C
T
GA
GA
GA
GA
GA T
T
T
T
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
T
T
C
G
G
G
A A
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
G
C
C
C
C
A
A
A
G
C
C
T
T
G
G
G
G
A
A
A
T
TA
T
NC1126, SSF4-B
NC765-B, P1404, R1348-B, R1389-B
837-A***, D82-A***, POR100***, R1299, ST1, ST8*, ST11-A*, U5, U16
T
T
T
T
A
A
C21**, M90** A
C G
G
G
G
T
A
A
A
837-B*** A
ST16** G
G
G
G
G
C
C
C
G
G
C C
C
A
GA T C
R
C G
C
C C
C
ST11-B* A T C
CTC C GA T
CT
C C
T
T
T
D82-B*** A T C GA T C
Y M C
T
T
A
T
T
OR10 A T C GA T C T A T
A
T
T
A
C
A
A
A
A
A
R A C
A
YOR1 A T C GA T C T Y G A A T
R A A TC G A CGA Y C TR1329 A T C
G A A TC G A CT C T TBC18F-B, NC1070-B A T Y
G A A TC G A C
A T TNM115, NM120, TS7, U73 A T C GA T C
A
T TA G
C T
BC18F-A, NC1070-A A T Y
A T T
A A T T
T
T
T
A Y G AY C M GGA T Y YR1374 A T C
T T
T C C G A C G
T
Y G A AC C G A
T
NC837, R1330 A T C GA T Y Y Y
G A A TC G A Y
T
T Y C
T C
C
T C
M
GA T C
GA T C
GA T C
~~
PC514 A T C
MNF4, NC94, NC540, NC765-A, P4352, R1348-A, R1389, SSF4-A, ST2 A T C
Hanna et al. 2004
Radial 50% majority rule consensus trees based on 24,000 trees from the Bayesian inference analysis of 850 base-pairs in the nLSU rDNA region. Scale bar = 0.001 substitutions per site.
0.98
0.98
0.001
0.64
** NABS IX*** NABS X
* NABS II
PC514
D82-B***
837-B***
BC18F-B,NC1070-B
BC18F-A,NC1070-A
NC765-B, P1404,R1348-B, R1389-B
R1329
NC1126,SSF4-B
MNF4, NC94, NC540,NC765-A, P4352, R1348-A,R1389, SSF4-A, ST2
ST11-B*
37-A***, D82-A***, POR100***,1299, ST1, ST8*,T11-A*, U5, U16
OR10
OR1R1374
NC837, R1330
NM115, NM120,TS7, U73
C21**, M90**
ST16**
0.001
NM115, NM120,TS7, U73
C21**, M90**
ST16**
837-A***, D82-A***, POR100***,R1299, ST1, ST8*, ST11-A*, U5, U16
D82-B***
837-B***
ST11-B*
MNF4, NC94, NC540,NC765-A, P4352, SSF4-A,ST2, R1389, R1348-A
NC765-B, P1404,R1348-B, R1389-B
NC1126,SSF4-B
PacificNorthwest
Rockies
Circumboreal
Hanna et al. 2004
Phylogenetic tree showing genetic diversity of Phylogenetic tree showing genetic diversity of Armillaria ostoyae Armillaria ostoyae based on the IGSbased on the IGS--1 DNA region1 DNA region
NC588 N. Idaho NC588 N. Idaho -- Soldier CreekSoldier Creek
NC542A N.E. Oregon NC542A N.E. Oregon -- EnterpriseEnterprise
NC435A N. Idaho NC435A N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
P416A N. Idaho P416A N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
NC403 N. Idaho NC403 N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
NC666A N. Idaho NC666A N. Idaho -- Dick’s CreekDick’s Creek
P2399 N. Idaho P2399 N. Idaho -- Priest RiverPriest River
NC436A N. Idaho NC436A N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
NC94 N. Idaho NC94 N. Idaho -- HuckleberryHuckleberry
NC435B N. Idaho NC435B N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
P4352 N. Idaho P4352 N. Idaho -- Priest RiverPriest River
P416B N. Idaho P416B N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
NC1126 N. Idaho NC1126 N. Idaho -- WhiskeyWhiskey
NC436B N. Idaho NC436B N. Idaho -- StantonStanton
NA142 S.W. Washington NA142 S.W. Washington -- T.T. MungerT.T. Munger
NC542B N.E. Oregon NC542B N.E. Oregon -- EnterpriseEnterprise
NC666B N. Idaho NC666B N. Idaho -- Dick’s CreekDick’s Creek
NM120A New.Mexico NM120A New.Mexico -- JemezJemez
NM115 New.Mexico NM115 New.Mexico -- JemezJemez
NM120B New.Mexico NM120B New.Mexico -- JemezJemez
HUA9242 Japan HUA9242 Japan -- Terashima et al. 1998Terashima et al. 1998
P255A N. Idaho P255A N. Idaho -- Priest RiverPriest River
P255B N. Idaho P255B N. Idaho -- Priest RiverPriest River
Pacific Pacific Northwest ANorthwest A
PacificPacificNorthwest BNorthwest B
RockiesRockies
Hanna et al. 2004
Factors associated with genetic races and Factors associated with genetic races and intraspecific hybridization within intraspecific hybridization within A. ostoyaeA. ostoyae
Adaptation to a variety of environmentsAdaptation to a variety of environments
May be responsible for differing levels of May be responsible for differing levels of pathogenicity and virulencepathogenicity and virulence
“Hybrid vigor” may contribute to enhanced “Hybrid vigor” may contribute to enhanced growth, survival, and/or pathogenicitygrowth, survival, and/or pathogenicity
Hybrids may adapt better to environmental Hybrids may adapt better to environmental changechange
Hanna et al. 2004
Does Does ArmillariaArmillaria affect tree growth?affect tree growth?
Hanna et al. 2004
Impact of Armillaria Root Disease on Tree GrowthImpact of Armillaria Root Disease on Tree Growth
Volume loss has been shown as high as 40% over 4Volume loss has been shown as high as 40% over 4--8 years8 yearsin eighteenin eighteen--yearyear--old Douglasold Douglas--fir (Cruickshank, 2000).fir (Cruickshank, 2000).
Hanna et al. 2004
Average mortality rates in a 10Average mortality rates in a 10--year period for sites year period for sites covering northern Idaho, northeastern Oregon, covering northern Idaho, northeastern Oregon, and eastern Washington vary from 8.8% for and eastern Washington vary from 8.8% for DouglasDouglas--fir, 4.2% for grand fir, and 1.5% fir, 4.2% for grand fir, and 1.5% for redcedar habitat types based on 8 sitesfor redcedar habitat types based on 8 sites(Moore et al., 2000).(Moore et al., 2000).
Growth loss and mortality due to Growth loss and mortality due to ArmillariaArmillariain British Columbia have been cited as in British Columbia have been cited as between 1.4 and 3.8 million mbetween 1.4 and 3.8 million m3 3 annuallyannually(White and Morrison, 1999).(White and Morrison, 1999).
Hanna et al. 2004
Does Does ArmillariaArmillaria affect tree growth?affect tree growth?
Influence of Armillaria ostoyae collected adjacent to growth plots on six-year gross-basal-area growth (sq.ft/a)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Spirit Lake Whiskey Huckleberry Soldier Creek Skookum Lake Dick's Creek
IFTNC Site
Ave
rage
incr
ease
in b
asal
are
a (s
q.ft/
a) Without A.ostoyae
With A.ostoyae
0 7752486777 10
*** *
# of plotsaveraged
* **α < .05 α < .10Hanna et al. 2004
!(!(
!(
!(!(
!(
!(!(!(!(
!(
!(!( !(!(
!(
!( !(!(!(
!( !(!(
!( !(!(
!(!(!(
!(
!(!(!(
!(!(!(!(!(
!(
!(!(!(
!(!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(
!(!(
!(
!(!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(!(
!(!(
[[
[
[
[[
[
[
[
[
[
[
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
DD
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
DD
D
D
DD
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
Soldier Creek - Study SiteIntermountain Forest Tree Nutrition Co-op
D Plot corners
[ Bark fans live trees
!( NABS X
!( NABS X - III-V-VII Hybrid
!( NABS I
Plot 1300N & 200K
Plot 2300N & 200K2SO4
Plot 3100N & 0K
Plot 4100N & 0K
Plot 5200N & 0K
Plot 14300N & 0K
Plot 13200N & 0K
Plot 12600N & 0K
Plot 6200N & 0K
Plot 7Control
Plot 8100N & 0K
Plot 9200N & 0K
Plot 10300N & 0K
Plot 11300N & 0K
Tsuga heterophylla / Asarum caudatum
Tsuga heterophylla / Clintonia uniflora
western hemlock / queen cup beadlily
western hemlock / wild ginger
0 140 28070 Meters
´6-year Net- and Gross-Basal-Area Growth (sq.ft/a) in GREEN
59.7G57.5N
35.6G35.6N
55.0G55.0N
32.3G23.1N
32.4G32.2N
49.4G45.8N
41.8G41.8N
45.5G44.4N
51.3G51.3N
60.5G58.2N
42.5G42.0N
44.4G42.8N
49.8G49.8N
53.1G53.0N
1
2
Hanna et al. 2004
Influence of Armillaria ostoyae collected adjacent to growth plots on six-year net-basal-area growth (sq.ft/a)
05
101520253035404550
Spirit Lake Whiskey Huckleberry Soldier Creek Skookum Lake Dick's Creek
IFTNC Site
Ave
rage
incr
ease
in b
asal
are
a(s
q.ft
/a)
Without A.ostoyae
With A.ostoyae
4 72 50 7 7 7 6 8 10 7
*
*
**
* **
# of plotsaveraged
α < .05 α < .10Hanna et al. 2004
D
DD
DD
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D D
D
D D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
DD
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
DD
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(!(
!(!(!(
!(!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(!(!(!(
!(
!( !(
!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(
!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(
!(
!(!(!(!(
[_[_
[_
[_
[_
[_
[_[_
[_
[_
[
[
[[
[
[
[
[
Plot 1512.1N & 290.2K
Plot 2300N & 170K
Plot 3300N & 170K
Plot 4300N & 170K
Plot 5600N & 170K
Plot 6512.1N & 49.8K
Plot 7300N & 0K
Plot 8300N & 340K
Plot 987.9N & 290.2KPlot 10
0N & 170K
Plot 11300N & 170K
Plot 1287.9N & 290.2K
Plot 13Control
Plot 14300N & 200K2SO4
Abies Grandis / Clintonia uniflora - Physocarpus malvaceus phaseGrand fir / queen cup beadlily - ninebark phase
Abies Grandis / Physocarpus malvaceus - Physocarpus malvaceus phase
Abies Grandis / Spiraea betulifolia
Grand fir / ninebark phase - ninebark phase
Grand fir / spiraea
LegendD plot corners
D plot centers
!( Genet 1 NABS I A.ostoyae
!( Genet 2 NABS X
!( Genet 3 NABS III,V,VII complex
!( Genet 4 NABS III,V,VII complex
[_ Barkfan on dead tree
[ Barkfan on live tree (active pathogen)
1 inch equals 61.886223 meters
0 280 560140 Meters
Huckleberry Creek - Study SiteIntermountain Forest Tree Nutrition Co-op´
19.3G1.1N
24.0G24.0N
26.6G18.0N
29.2G27.5N
20.2G15.9N
27.9G27.9N
29.3G21.8N
37.2G31.5N
31.9G21.9N
21.3G9.3N
27.4G9.9N23.9G
18.8N
31.6G30.9N
28.1G26.2N
6-year Net- and Gross-Basal-Area Growth (sq.ft/a) in GREEN
Hanna et al. 2004
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
DD
DD
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
D
!(
!(!(
!(!(!(
!(!(!(!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(
!(
[_
[_
[
[
[_
Spirit Lake - Study SiteIntermountain Forest Tree Nutrition Co-op
Plot 4300N & 0K
Plot 5300N & 170K
Plot 1600N & 0K
Plot 20N & 170K
Plot 3200N & 0K
Plot 6100N & 0K
Plot 7Control
0 130 26065 Meters
LegendD plot corners
D plot centers
!( Genet 1 NABS I A.ostoyae
!( Genet 2 NABS I A.ostoyae
!( Genet 3 NABS I A.ostoyae
!( Genet 4 NABS X
[_ Barkfan on dead tree
[ Barkfan on live tree (active pathogen)
[_ Wood Sample (Note: from Holodiscus discolor)
´
western hemlock Series
Thuja plicata
Tsuga heterophylla
western redcedar Series
Thuja plicata
western redcedar Series
Series
Series
Series 6-year Net- and Gross-Basal-Area Growth (sq.ft/a) in GREEN
27.7G24.2N
17.4G-12.9N
21.3G20.7N
28.7G24.7N
31.4G29.5N
19.4G14.7N
18.6G16.4N
1
2
Hanna et al. 2004
Influence of Armillaria species collected adjacent to growth plots on six-year net- basal-area growth (sq.ft/a)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Spirit Lake Whiskey Huckleberry SoldierCreek
SkookumLake
Dick's Creek
IFTNC Site
Ave
rage
incr
ease
in b
asal
ar
ea (s
q.ft
/a)
Without Armillaria
NABS X Only
X and I
NABS I Only
* ***
* **
# of plotsaveraged
α < .05 α < .10
0 2 50 0 7 07 4 2 1 7 4 0 4 6 2 2 30 0 7 6 1
Hanna et al. 2004
Factors that interact with Factors that interact with ArmillariaArmillaria totoinfluence tree growthinfluence tree growth
Interacting FactorsInteracting Factors ::
Habitat TypeHabitat TypeSoil CharacteristicsSoil CharacteristicsParent MaterialParent MaterialFertilizationFertilizationOther PestsOther Pests
Hanna et al. 2004
Future StudiesFuture Studies
Better characterize Better characterize ArmillariaArmillaria species with molecular species with molecular genetic techniques to better understand pathogenicity genetic techniques to better understand pathogenicity and virulenceand virulence
Assess direct effects of Assess direct effects of Armillaria ostoyaeArmillaria ostoyae on tree on tree growthgrowth
Evaluate effect of Evaluate effect of ArmillariaArmillaria species interactions on species interactions on tree growthtree growth
Investigate saprophytic Investigate saprophytic ArmillariaArmillaria species as a possible species as a possible biological control of biological control of Armillaria ostoyaeArmillaria ostoyae
Hanna et al. 2004
Tree growth is affected by a multitude of interacting Tree growth is affected by a multitude of interacting factors that include factors that include ArmillariaArmillaria. .
It is difficult to assess how nutritional treatments affect It is difficult to assess how nutritional treatments affect ArmillariaArmillaria impacts on growth without knowledge of preimpacts on growth without knowledge of pre--existing existing ArmillariaArmillaria influences.influences.
Pretreatment studies of Pretreatment studies of ArmillariaArmillaria distribution and distribution and impacts across a range of environments are needed as impacts across a range of environments are needed as baseline information. This baseline would help forest baseline information. This baseline would help forest managers better understand how treatments affect managers better understand how treatments affect ArmillariaArmillaria and overall growth of a stand.and overall growth of a stand.
Hanna et al. 2004
AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements
Intermountain Forest Tree Intermountain Forest Tree Nutrition CoNutrition Co--opop
and theand theUniversity of IdahoUniversity of Idaho
USDA Forest ServiceUSDA Forest Service
Mariann GarrisonMariann Garrison--JohnstonJohnstonMark KimseyMark KimseyHoward JenningsHoward JenningsBob AtwoodBob AtwoodPeter MikaPeter MikaLeonard JohnsonLeonard Johnson
James B. DonleyJames B. DonleyRaini C. RippyRaini C. RippyJane E. StewartJane E. StewartBryce A. RichardsonBryce A. RichardsonTroy HensiekTroy HensiekJoanne TirockeJoanne TirockeKwanKwan--Soo WooSoo WooJonalea R. TonnJonalea R. TonnPaul J. ZambinoPaul J. ZambinoDebbie S. PageDebbie S. Page--DumroeseDumroese
Hanna et al. 2004