1
Although resistance to yeast pathogens used to be a very rare event, during the early 1990s, hospitals began to report cases of increased resistance to antifungal drugs, particularly when Candida albicans, C. glabrata and C. krusei were involved. Candida infections can give rise to a variety of conditions including acute pseudomembraneous candidiasis (oral thrush), chronic atrophic candidiasis (denture stomatitis), chronic hyperplastic candidiasis, angular cheilitis and vaginal candidiasis (vaginal thrush). In addition, systemic disease can be spread via the blood (candidaemia) to infect the liver, kidneys and central nervous system. Although all species of Candida can cause these diseases, C. albicans is the most common, while C. glabrata is often associated with vaginitis. An added factor is that the incidence of opportunistic fungal infections is increasing and this is particularly evident in immunocompromised individuals (for example, individuals with AIDS or those undergoing bone marrow transplants). One major worry for clinicians is that cross- resistance is emerging between some previously very effective, established antifungal drugs such as fluconazole and itraconazole. Dr Dominique Sanglard (Institut de Microbiologie, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, Lausanne, Switzerland) and his colleagues have shown that resistance in clinical isolates of C. albicans can develop by overexpression of different multidrug efflux transporter genes. These belong to one of two classes: the ABC transporters (Cdr1p and Cdr2p) or the major facilitators (BEN r ), which have different, but sometimes overlapping, substrate specificity. High levels of resistance are associated with increased drug efflux from the cell and, put at its simplest, drug molecules entering the cell from the bloodstream are rapidly pumped out before high enough intracellular levels can be reached to kill the pathogen. Dr Sanglard reported his group’s findings at the 4th Congress of the European Confederation of Medical Mycology (Glasgow, UK, 11–13 May 1998). Fortunately, there is as yet no evidence that resistance can be transferred from one strain to another. C. albicans has no sexual cycle and there are no documented cases of gene transfer between strains. Therefore, individual strains of C. albicans develop resistance independently when exposed to antifungal drugs (acquired resistance). This resistance is stable so that, even in the absence of drugs, such strains retain their resistance. However, there is now worrying evidence emerging that these resistant strains are entering the ‘commensal’ population, i.e. those strains carried by normal, healthy individuals. Hygiene surveys in many hospitals have shown that resistant strains are passed from patient to patient via the hands of healthcare workers. This is supported by a number of recent studies showing that, in some hospitals, standards of hygiene have fallen below minimum acceptable levels. So far, it is not known whether these efflux pumps have a normal role to play in cellular function, although it would seem reasonable that they are involved in the transport of other (i.e. non-drug) compounds out of cells. However, no endogenous pump substrates have yet been identified. At the same meeting, Dr Richard Cannon (Department of Oral Sciences and Orthodontics, University of Otago, New Zealand) described the work his group have been carrying out on Cdr1p. This protein is similar to P-glycoprotein, which is responsible for the multiple drug resistance observed in tumour cells, but it possesses a unique pumping specificity. Previous studies have established a correlation between drug resistance in C. albicans and the expression of plasma membrane proteins homologous to energy- dependent pumps from the ABC protein family. Dr Cannon’s group has adapted a secretory vesicle assay to investigate the specificity of drug translocation by the C. albicans protein Cdr1p (Fig. 1). This in vitro system uses a secretory vesicle preparation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae SY1, which has been previously used to investigate the pumping behaviour by human P- glycoprotein. Using this assay, they have found that pumping is not inhibited by verapamil (a known P-glycoprotein inhibitor) or several antifungal agents (Fig. 1). Using this technique, they have been able to show that Cdr1p specifically transports a number of azole drugs such as fluconazole, itraconazole and ketoconazole. More detailed information about the pumping activity of efflux pumps from C. albicans should allow the development of pump inhibitors, or at least point the way towards novel antifungal agents that are not substrates for these efflux pumps. Dr Cannon has already identified some competitive pump inhibitors but is currently reluctant to give any more information because they are not patented. David Jack 275 N e w s MOLECULAR MEDICINE TODAY, JULY 1998 Copyright ©1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 1357 - 4310/98/$19.00 Figure 1. The use of secretory vesicles (sv) to identify drug pump inhibitors. (a) Shows the normal cellular location for Cdr1 in the plasma membrane, where it translocates the antifungal agent fluconazole (Fcz) out of drug-resistant cells. (b) Secretory vesicles can be isolated in large numbers from S. cerevisiae sec6-4 cells incubated at the non-permissive temperature of 37°C. (c) Isolated secretory vesicles can be used to identify compounds that inhibit Cdr1 and prevent [ 3 H]-fluconazole accumulation by the vesicles. sec6-4 37°C Fcz Cdr1 [ 3 H]Fcz Inhibitor a b c sv Do efflux pumps hold the key to better antifungal treatment?

Do efflux pumps hold the key to better antifungal treatment?

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Although resistance to yeast pathogens used to be avery rare event, during the early 1990s, hospitalsbegan to report cases of increased resistance toantifungal drugs, particularly when Candidaalbicans, C. glabrata and C. krusei were involved.Candida infections can give rise to a variety ofconditions including acute pseudomembraneouscandidiasis (oral thrush), chronic atrophiccandidiasis (denture stomatitis), chronichyperplastic candidiasis, angular cheilitis andvaginal candidiasis (vaginal thrush). In addition,systemic disease can be spread via the blood(candidaemia) to infect the liver, kidneys andcentral nervous system. Although all species ofCandida can cause these diseases, C. albicans is themost common, while C. glabrata is often associatedwith vaginitis. An added factor is that the incidenceof opportunistic fungal infections is increasing andthis is particularly evident in immunocompromisedindividuals (for example, individuals with AIDS orthose undergoing bone marrow transplants).

One major worry for clinicians is that cross-resistance is emerging between some previouslyvery effective, established antifungal drugs suchas fluconazole and itraconazole. Dr DominiqueSanglard (Institut de Microbiologie, CentreHospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, Lausanne,Switzerland) and his colleagues have shown thatresistance in clinical isolates of C. albicans candevelop by overexpression of different multidrugefflux transporter genes. These belong to one oftwo classes: the ABC transporters (Cdr1p andCdr2p) or the major facilitators (BENr), whichhave different, but sometimes overlapping,substrate specificity. High levels of resistance areassociated with increased drug efflux from thecell and, put at its simplest, drug moleculesentering the cell from the bloodstream are rapidlypumped out before high enough intracellularlevels can be reached to kill the pathogen. DrSanglard reported his group’s findings at the 4thCongress of the European Confederation of MedicalMycology (Glasgow, UK, 11–13 May 1998).

Fortunately, there is as yet no evidence thatresistance can be transferred from one strain toanother. C. albicans has no sexual cycle andthere are no documented cases of gene transferbetween strains. Therefore, individual strains of C. albicans develop resistance independentlywhen exposed to antifungal drugs (acquiredresistance). This resistance is stable so that,even in the absence of drugs, such strains retaintheir resistance. However, there is nowworrying evidence emerging that these resistantstrains are entering the ‘commensal’ population,

i.e. those strains carried by normal, healthyindividuals.

Hygiene surveys in many hospitals have shownthat resistant strains are passed from patient topatient via the hands of healthcare workers. This issupported by a number of recent studies showingthat, in some hospitals, standards of hygiene havefallen below minimum acceptable levels.

So far, it is not known whether these effluxpumps have a normal role to play in cellular function,although it would seem reasonable that they areinvolved in the transport of other (i.e. non-drug)compounds out of cells. However, no endogenouspump substrates have yet been identified.

At the same meeting, Dr Richard Cannon(Department of Oral Sciences and Orthodontics,University of Otago, New Zealand) described thework his group have been carrying out on Cdr1p.This protein is similar to P-glycoprotein, which isresponsible for the multiple drug resistanceobserved in tumour cells, but it possesses aunique pumping specificity. Previous studies haveestablished a correlation between drug resistancein C. albicans and the expression of plasmamembrane proteins homologous to energy-dependent pumps from the ABC protein family.

Dr Cannon’s group has adapted a secretoryvesicle assay to investigate the specificity of drugtranslocation by the C. albicans protein Cdr1p(Fig. 1). This in vitro system uses a secretoryvesicle preparation of Saccharomyces cerevisiaeSY1, which has been previously used toinvestigate the pumping behaviour by human P-glycoprotein. Using this assay, they have foundthat pumping is not inhibited by verapamil (aknown P-glycoprotein inhibitor) or severalantifungal agents (Fig. 1).

Using this technique, they have been able toshow that Cdr1p specifically transports anumber of azole drugs such as fluconazole,itraconazole and ketoconazole. More detailedinformation about the pumping activity of effluxpumps from C. albicans should allow thedevelopment of pump inhibitors, or at leastpoint the way towards novel antifungal agentsthat are not substrates for these efflux pumps.Dr Cannon has already identified somecompetitive pump inhibitors but is currentlyreluctant to give any more information becausethey are not patented.

David Jack

275

N e w sMOLECULAR MEDICINE TODAY, JULY 1998

Copyright ©1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. 1357 - 4310/98/$19.00

Figure 1. The use of secretory vesicles (sv) to identify drug pump inhibitors. (a) Shows the normal cellularlocation for Cdr1 in the plasma membrane, where it translocates the antifungal agent fluconazole (Fcz) outof drug-resistant cells. (b) Secretory vesicles can be isolated in large numbers from S. cerevisiaesec6-4 cells incubated at the non-permissive temperature of 37°C. (c) Isolated secretory vesicles can beused to identify compounds that inhibit Cdr1 and prevent [3H]-fluconazole accumulation by the vesicles.

sec6-4

37°C

FczCdr1

[ 3 H]Fcz

Inhibitor

a

b

c

sv

Do efflux pumps hold the key tobetter antifungal treatment?