Draft Inception Report - eceee · Task 2.1 is dealing with the products in the green area marked by 2. 1 The five Lots are: Solid fuel small combustion installations (ENER Lot 15),

Preparatory Study to

establish the Ecodesign

Working Plan

2015-2017

implementing Directive

2009/125/EC

Task 2 Draft Final

Report

In collaboration with:

European Commission, Directorate-General for Enterprise and Industry

15 September 2014

2 Preparatory study to establish the Ecodesign Working Plan 2015-2017 – Task 2 Draft Final Report

Document information

CLIENT

European Commission – DG ENTR

REPORT TITLE Task 2 Draft Final Report

PROJECT NAME Preparatory Study to establish the Ecodesign Working Plan

2015-2017 implementing Directive 2009/125/EC

DATE 15 September 2014

PROJECT TEAM BIO by Deloitte (BIO), Oeko-Institut and ERA Technology

AUTHORS Dr. Corinna Fischer (Oeko-Institut)

Mr. Carl-Otto Gensch (Oeko-Institut)

Mr. Rasmus Prieß (Oeko-Institut)

Ms. Eva Brommer (Oeko-Institut)

Mr. Shailendra Mudgal (BIO)

Mr. Benoît Tinetti (BIO)

Mr. Alexis Lemeillet (BIO)

Dr. Paul Goodman (ERA Technology)

KEY CONTACTS Corinna Fischer: [email protected]

Or

Benoît Tinetti: [email protected]

DISCLAIMER The project team does not accept any liability for any direct or

indirect damage resulting from the use of this report or its

content. This report contains the results of research by the

authors and is not to be perceived as the opinion of the

European Commission.

Please cite this publication as:

BIO by Deloitte, Oeko-Institut and ERA Technology (2014) Preparatory Study to establish the

Ecodesign Working Plan 2015-2017 implementing Directive 2009/125/EC – Task 2 Draft Final

Report prepared for the European Commission (DG ENTR)

mailto:[email protected]

mailto:[email protected]


Contents

1. Task 2.1: Review of product categories already considered ...................................... 5

1.1 Objective and methodology ................................................................................................ 5

1.1.1 Purpose of Task 2.1 ............................................................................................................ 5

1.1.2 Approach of Task 2.1 .......................................................................................................... 5

1.2 Results of the review of existing Ecodesign Regulations ................................................... 7

1.3 Conclusions on Task 2.1 ................................................................................................... 11

2. Task 2.2: Complementary product groups ................................................................... 13

2.1 Objective and methodology .............................................................................................. 13

2.1.1 Purpose of Task 2.2 .......................................................................................................... 13

2.1.2 Approach of Task 2.2 ........................................................................................................ 13

2.2 Results of Task 2.2 ........................................................................................................... 17

3. Conclusions on Task 2 ................................................................................................... 18

3.1 Lists of products to be considered .................................................................................... 18

3.2 Potential horizontal measures ........................................................................................... 19

4. Annexes ........................................................................................................................... 20

4.1 Annex I: Detailed review of all product categories considered in Preparatory Studies and

in Regulations ................................................................................................................... 20

4.3 Annex II: Remaining products list ..................................................................................... 34

4.4 Annex IV: Comparison of product groups in Working Plan studies I and II ...................... 59


Foreword

BIO by Deloitte is pleased to submit this draft Task 2 report for the project “Preparatory Study to

establish the Ecodesign Working Plan 2015-2017 implementing Directive 2009/125/EC”, on behalf of

the project team composed of BIO by Deloitte, Oeko-Institut and ERA Technology.

This report presents a review and clustering of product groups in order to arrive at a list of products

that will provide a basis for the choice of priority products for the 3rd

Working Plan.

The report is structured as follows: Chapter 1 reviews products that have been included in Preparatory

Studies but not yet regulated in order to identify products that might have to be reincluded

(subtask 2.1). Chapter 2 develops a complementary list of product groups, consisting of products that

have either not yet been studied in depth in earlier Working Plan studies or for which new evidence

has become available (subtask 2.2). Chapter 3 sums up the resulting list of potential products and

suggestions for horizontal issues.

This work will be the basis for an additional pre-screening at the beginning of Task 3, which will result

in no more than 30 product groups that will be the object of this study.


1. Task 2.1: Review of product

categories already considered

1.1 Objective and methodology

1.1.1 Purpose of Task 2.1

The objective of this Task 2.1 is to identify product categories that have been considered in previous

Working Plans and yet fail to be addressed through an Ecodesign regulation. Hence the list of

products included either in the transitional period or in previous Working Plans will be re-assessed.

The assessment will identify the main reasons why it was not possible or desirable to establish

Ecodesign Implementing Measures for these products. Depending on the reasons given, they might

be reincluded into the list of products to be considered in the next tasks.

This chapter deals with the possible gaps between the Ecodesign Preparatory Studies and the

Regulations: at end of May 2014, 23 product-specific Ecodesign Regulations (excluding amendments)

have been adopted, and 2 Voluntary Agreements have been recognised by the Commission. For the

five Lots which currently bear the status “Draft regulation”, this exercise will be repeated when a

Regulation is passed during the course of this Working Plan study1.

1.1.2 Approach of Task 2.1

In Task 2.1, the focus is on product categories which have been in scope of Preparatory Studies and

yet are not in scope of the matching regulations (or Voluntary Agreements)2. While such “gaps” are

not extremely frequent, they have to be carefully studied in order to track any missing product

categories. To clarify what is meant by “gap”, the Figure 1 below demonstrates that the scope of the

Preparatory Study does not necessarily match the scope of the Regulation. The green squares

symbolise the products that are in the scope, or out of scope of the Preparatory Study. The blue

squares symbolise those that are in scope, or out of scope, of the Regulation (or Voluntary

Agreement). The various overlaps illustrate the various positions products can theoretically have.

Task 2.1 is dealing with the products in the green area marked by 2.

1 The five Lots are: Solid fuel small combustion installations (ENER Lot 15), Local room heating products (ENER Lot 20),

Refrigerating and freezing equipment (ENTR Lot 1), Distribution and power transformers (ENTR Lot 2), Air-conditioning

products, except air-conditioners < 12kW (ENTR Lot 6).

2 Product categories are meant to be smaller than product groups: while product groups correspond to the title of a Preparatory

Study (e.g. boilers and combi-boilers), product categories correspond to all product types that can be included in a given

product group (e.g. gas fired boilers, oil fired boilers, electric boilers, etc.).


Figure 1: Different scopes and purpose of Task 2.1

The scope of the Preparatory Study is generally described in its Task 1, which is consistent with the

MEEuP/MEErP methodology. Still, the scope is often not as clear as one could wish, and the

Preparatory Studies do not always specify which product categories are in scope. In that case, a

deeper look was taken at the whole Preparatory Study, especially the tasks related to economic and

market analysis (Task 2) and the definition of the base-cases (Task 4 or 5, depending on the

methodology and the DG commissioning the Preparatory Study).

The scope of the regulation is defined in its Article 1 (Subject matter and scope) and Article 2

(Definitions). Usually, the scope of the Regulation does not specifically refer to product categories, and

for this reason one has to take a closer look at the definitions. Sometimes, the definitions also refer to

the Annexes (mostly in case of further technical details of products included or excluded from the

scope of the Regulation).

Two specifications must be added to the methodology:

Regulations often bear a paragraph beginning with “The Regulation shall not apply to”. Still,

these products are not generally the topic of the present Task 2.1, since many products to

which the Regulation shall not apply were also not included in the scope of the Preparatory

Study. We have “non-scope/non-scope” products, as is illustrated in Figure 1;

Only the main products are being looked at, as indicated in the column “Main product

categories in scope of Preparatory Study but excluded from the Regulation”. This means that

small product categories or product categories excluded from the Regulations for safety

reasons are not taken into account. Such product categories are for example “self-priming

pumps” (in ENER Lot 11 Water pumps), “motors specified to operate exclusively in potentially

explosive atmospheres” (in ENER Lot 11 Motors), or “spin-extractors” (in ENER Lot 16 Laundry

driers)3.

3 As soon as a product category is not or barely mentioned in the Preparatory Study, this implies it is not significant. Thus, it is

assumed that it is not relevant anyway for reinclusion.


1.2 Results of the review of existing Ecodesign Regulations

The complete screening of all Preparatory Studies and Regulations is available in Annex I. Only the

most prominent results are displayed in Table 1.

Table 1: Product categories for which reinclusion should be considered

Lot number & title Matching

Regulation

Main product categories in the scope of

Preparatory Study but excluded from the

Regulation

ENER Lot 1

Boilers and combi-

boilers

Reg. 813/2013 Heaters generating heat only for the purpose of

providing hot drinking or sanitary water

ENER Lot 4

Imaging equipment

Voluntary

Agreement

Scanners

ENER Lot 7

External power

supplies and battery

chargers

Reg. 278/2009 Battery chargers

ENER Lot 10

Residential ventilation

and kitchen hoods

Reg. 206/2012 Range hoods

ENER Lot 11

Electric motors

Reg. 640/2009 and

Amendm. 4/2014

Motors specified to operate wholly immersed in a

liquid

Motors completely integrated into a product (for

example gear, pump, fan or compressor)

ENER Lot 11

Ventilation fans

(power output >125W)

Reg. 327/2011 Fans integrated in:

Products with a sole electric motor of 3 kW

or less where the fan is fixed on the same

shaft used for driving the main functionality;

Laundry and washer dryers ≤3 kW

maximum electrical input power;

Kitchen hoods <280 W total maximum

electrical input power attributable to the

fan(s).

Fans with electric input power >500 kW

ENER Lot 11

Water pumps in the

following applications:

commercial buildings,

drinking water,

agriculture and the

food industry

Reg. 547/2012 Positive displacement water pumps

ENER Lot 13

Domestic refrigerators

and freezers

Reg. 643/2009 Wine storage appliances

ENER Lot 14

Domestic washing

machines

Reg. 1015/2010

Household combined washer-driers

ENER Lot 16

Laundry dryers

Reg. 932/2012

ENER Lot 17 Reg. 666/2013 Wet vacuum cleaners


Lot number & title Matching

Regulation

Main product categories in the scope of

Preparatory Study but excluded from the

Regulation

Household vacuum

cleaners

Wet and dry vacuum cleaners

Battery operated vacuum cleaners

ENER Lot 22

Domestic and

commercial ovens

Reg. 66/2014

Commercial ovens

Microwave ovens

Steam ovens

Portable ovens

Small ovens

ENER Lot 23

Domestic and

commercial hobs and

grills

Commercial hobs

Portable hobs

Grills

The reasons of why specific requirements were not developed for these product categories have been

investigated. Only very few product categories have been deemed worth reincluding in the present

study. Typical reasons for an exclusion from Regulation that could be identified are the following:

Product category is already considered elsewhere;

Revision process of the Regulation is ongoing or planned;

Test standards are missing;

Sales are too low;

Improvement potential is too low; or

Unknown reasons.

Product categories not reincluded because considered elsewhere

A few product categories of the above table (in scope of Preparatory Study but excluded from the

Regulation) do not need to be reincluded in this Working Plan study because they are already

considered elsewhere. This is the case for:

ENER Lot 1: Heaters generating heat only for the purpose of providing hot drinking or sanitary

water are already covered in ENER Lot 2 and regulated under Regulation 814/2013;

ENER Lot 10: Range hoods are already included in Regulation 66/2014 (also including

domestic ovens and hobs);

ENER Lot 11: Positive displacement pumps have been already included in Working Plan 2

(conditional list); and

ENER Lot 11: Fans integrated in:

- Laundry and washer dryers ≤3 kW maximum electrical input power. These product

categories are already included in Regulations 1015/2010 (domestic washing

machines) and 932/2012 (household tumble driers); and

- Kitchen hoods <280 W total maximum electrical input power attributable to the fan(s).

Kitchen hoods are not to be reincluded, since they are already part of Regulation

66/2014.


Product categories not reincluded because they will be considered in a review process

Some product categories mentioned in the table above are not worth reincluding in the present

analysis because it is explicitly written that they will fall under the review process of their respective

regulations. This is the case of:

ENER Lot 13: Wine storage appliances is a product category to be revisited during review.

According to Article 7 of Regulation 643/2009, “the Commission shall assess the need to adopt

specific Ecodesign requirements for wine storage appliances no later than two years after the

entry into force of this Regulation”. The group has in the meantime been investigated in ENER

Lot 34;

ENER Lot 14 and ENER Lot 16: Household combined washer-driers fall in-between

Regulations on domestic washing machines (Reg. 1015/2010) and household tumble driers

(Reg. 932/2012). According to the Impact Assessment of Ecodesign requirements for

household tumble driers, “it is not possible to cover the washing part of a washer-drier in the

washing machine legislation and the drying part in the driers legislation because the machines

with the continuous washing/drying cycle will not be covered, although not all washer-driers

have this continuous cycle. A product specific legislation (Ecodesign/labelling Regulations) is

needed for washer-driers”4. This specific product group will actually be art of ENER Lot 14

review to be launched in 2014; and

ENER Lot 22 and ENER Lot 23: Commercial ovens and Commercial hobs – the inclusion of

professional and commercial appliances is to be considered during the review. According to

Article 7 of Regulation 66/2014, “the review shall assess, amongst others, the feasibility of:

potential requirements to enhance the recovery and recycling of the appliances; durability and

lifetime requirements; the inclusion of professional and commercial appliances; and fume and

odour removal requirements”.

Also a few product categories are not explicitly mentioned in the table above, but will be subject to a

review. They are only mentioned here for the sake of exhaustiveness:

ENER Lot 8: At first sight, a couple of exemptions mentioned in Annex I may be worth

reincluding. Very small HID lamps, for instance, are not yet covered by Regulation 245/2009.

However, this discussion is extremely technical, and the review of the Regulation should be

performed this year (i.e. 5 years after its entry into force);

ENER Lot 11: Drinking water circulators are subject to information requirements in the current

Regulation (622/2012). Implementing specific requirements for this product category could be

discussed when reviewing the Regulation. According to Article 7 of the Regulation, the

Commission shall review this Regulation before 1 January 2017, in the light of technological

progress; and

ENER Lot 19: A number of exemptions in Article 1 of Regulation 244/2009 are quite technical.

Some of them are obviously covered by other Ecodesign Regulations on lighting (this is the

case for directional lamps, fluorescent lamps without integrated ballast and high intensity

discharge lamps); some others could be reviewed during the revision of the Regulation, which

should be performed in 2014 (i.e. 5 years after its entry into force).

One last item to mention is Voluntary Agreements (currently in force for imaging equipment); in this

case, it is up to the European Commission, not to the Working Plan study, to assess the effectiveness

and efficiency of the Voluntary Agreement.

4 EC Working document: http://ec.europa.eu/energy/efficiency/ecodesign/doc/td_impact_assessment.pdf

http://ec.europa.eu/energy/efficiency/ecodesign/doc/td_impact_assessment.pdf


Product categories not reincluded because of missing test standards

Quite a few product categories included in the Preparatory Study were excluded from the Regulation

because specific requirements could not be based on any existing measurement standard. Yet for

some product categories, test standards are still missing today, which is why they are not considered

worth reincluding. This is the case for:

ENER Lot 11: Motors completely integrated into a product (for example gear, pump, fan or

compressor) were excluded from standard IEC 60034-30, dealing with low voltage AC motors.

According to the latest updates, motors completely integrated into a machine still cannot be

tested independently of the load5; and

ENER Lot 17: Wet vacuum cleaners, Wet and dry vacuum cleaners and Battery operated

vacuum cleaners could not rely on any suitable efficiency measurement method. This is why

they have been excluded from Regulation 666/2013 (on vacuum cleaners). Still, no

measurement standards have been developed since the entry into force of the Regulation, and

this is why these product categories are not reincluded.

Product categories not reincluded because of low sales

This is specifically the case for three product categories:

ENER Lot 4: Scanners have been excluded from the Voluntary Agreement on imaging

equipment. According to the Preparatory Study, the scanner function is more and more

integrated in Multi-Function Devices (MFD), meaning that fewer and fewer scanners-only are

sold. And according to Eurostat, sales for Prodcom codes including scanners are decreasing.6

Hence, it justifies the decision not to reinclude scanners in the next Working Plan;

ENER Lot 22: Small ovens have low sales. Regulation 66/2014 defines small ovens as cavities

with “a width and depth of less than 250 mm or a height less than 120 mm”, which corresponds

to a maximum volume of 7.5 litres. According to market data presented in the Preparatory

Study, small ovens are a niche market and no new information indicates that sales have

strongly increased;7 and

ENER Lot 23: Portable hobs represent a niche market too. According to the Preparatory Study,

portable hobs account for approximately one percent of market share within the EU, and no

new information indicates that sales have strongly increased. As some portable ovens have

hobs, sales data may be inaccurate though and there may be some overlap.

Product categories not reincluded because of low improvement potential

This is especially the case of one lot:

5 M. Doppelbauer (2012), Update on IEC 60034-2-1 and IEC 60034-30-1, EMSA Testing Centres Workshop (Motro Summit

2012), http://www.motorsummit.ch/data/files/MS_2012/presentation/10_ms12_doppelbauer.pdf

6 There is not any specific Prodcom code for scanners but.both “Data-processing machines, automatic, presented in the form of

systems comprising at least a central processing unit, one input unit and one output unit (excl. portable weighing <= 10 kg

and excl. peripheral units)” and “Input or output units for automatic data-processing machines, whether or not containing

storage units in the same housing (excl. keyboards)” can include scanners. Both categories show a sharp decline in sales

between 2006 and 2012 (-88% for the first category and -24% for the second category).

7 Small ovens should not be confused with “portable ovens” that are usually larger than 7.5 litres and Eurostat data indicates

that sales may be 8-10 million per year in the EU (and considered for reinclusion, see below).

http://www.motorsummit.ch/data/files/MS_2012/presentation/10_ms12_doppelbauer.pdf


ENER Lot 22: Microwave ovens have a low improvement potential according to the

Preparatory Study. Yet no technological leap could be observed since the completion of the

Preparatory Study, and newer models do not seem to be much more energy efficient: this

means that energy savings are still too low to consider the reinclusion of microwave ovens in

the Ecodesign Working Plan.

Unknown reason for exclusion

Three product categories have been included in Preparatory Studies, but excluded from Regulations

for reasons that fail to be identified. This is the case for:

ENER Lot 11: Motors specified to operate wholly immersed in a liquid can probably be

assumed as a niche market (i.e. annual sales below 200,000 units in Europe). To the extent

that the market has not soared, this would justify that those motors are not reincluded; and

ENER Lot 11: Fans integrated in products with a sole electric motor of 3 kW or less where the

fan is fixed on the same shaft used for driving the main functionality.

ENER Lot 11: High power fans (above 500 kW) are in scope of the Preparatory Study, which

does not define a maximum power for fans to be included. However, the maximum power input

of the various base-cases defined is 4 kW, much lower than the 500 kW threshold. There is no

explicit argument for not considering fans >500 kW, but the recommendation at the end was

not to include them in Reg. 327/2011. However, this does not seem to pose a problem as the

market is probably insignificant and it is unlikely that their exclusion can be used as a loophole:

The electrical power input is a much higher value than fans usually manufactured. According to

the Preparatory Study, “this ensures that manufacturers producing fans above the 10 kW rating

cannot choose a larger motor just to bypass the possible minimum energy performance

standards”.

Stakeholders are invited to provide information regarding the exclusion of these specific product

categories from the respective Ecodesign Regulations.

1.3 Conclusions on Task 2.1

Most product categories presented in Table 1 and discussed in the above paragraphs should not be

reincluded in the present Working Plan study. But some product categories can be considered

valuable for reinclusion, namely:

ENER Lot 7: Battery chargers had been excluded from Regulation 278/2009 due to missing

measurement standards. Yet today, new standards seem to be available:

- The California Energy Commission (CEC) has an energy efficiency battery charger

test procedure8; and

- The US Department Of Energy (DOE) published a final rule on Energy Conservation

Standards for External Power Supplies (including battery chargers), which includes an

International Efficiency Marking Protocol for External Power Supplies9.

ENER Lot 22: Portable ovens were excluded from Regulation 66/2014. Reason is unknown. It

could be either due to lack of data or because of inapplicability of the electric oven energy

consumption measurement standard. They may be worth reincluding, since the energy savings

8http://www.energy.ca.gov/appliances/2008rulemaking/2008-AAER-1B/2008-11-

19_BATTERY_CHARGER_SYSTEM_TEST_PROCEDURE.PDF

9 In section IV of version 3.0: https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/02/10/2014-02560/energy-conservation-program-

energy-conservation-standards-for-external-power-supplies

http://www.energy.ca.gov/appliances/2008rulemaking/2008-AAER-1B/2008-11-19_BATTERY_CHARGER_SYSTEM_TEST_PROCEDURE.PDF

http://www.energy.ca.gov/appliances/2008rulemaking/2008-AAER-1B/2008-11-19_BATTERY_CHARGER_SYSTEM_TEST_PROCEDURE.PDF

https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/02/10/2014-02560/energy-conservation-program-energy-conservation-standards-for-external-power-supplies

https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/02/10/2014-02560/energy-conservation-program-energy-conservation-standards-for-external-power-supplies


potential appears to be significant (up to 3TWh p.a.) and annual sales may be up to 10 million

or greater, based on Prodcom Eurostat and other data in the Lot 22 report.

ENER Lot 22: Steam ovens lacked a standard when the Preparatory Study was completed. Yet

with some new standard published, it may be possible to determine the improvement potential.

A new standard is to be published in June 2014 by the European Committee for

electrotechnical standardisation. The standard EN 60350-1:2013 is entitled: “Household

electric cooking appliances - Part 1: Ranges, ovens, steam ovens and grills - Methods for

measuring performance”10

.

ENER Lot 23: Grills were considered to be a too diversified product category, and therefore

were excluded from Regulation 66/2014 (also, no EU energy measurement standards are

available). Yet, the definition of grills can be revised and some products with a grill function be

included in upcoming Regulations.

In addition, depending on the information provided by stakeholders regarding the exclusion of

specific motors and fans for which reasons are unknown, these product categories might be

reincluded in the present study.

Typical reasons for not setting specific Ecodesign requirements have been derived and depending on

the reasons, it has been decided whether the products should be reincluded into the analysis in the

next tasks. Furthermore, the reasons can be used as an evaluation criterion for the pre-screening of

other product categories – which will be conducted at the start of Task 3.

10 http://www.cenelec.eu/dyn/www/f?p=104:110:3007508292391089::::FSP_PROJECT,FSP_LANG_ID:23130,25

http://www.cenelec.eu/dyn/www/f?p=104:110:3007508292391089::::FSP_PROJECT,FSP_LANG_ID:23130,25


2. Task 2.2: Complementary product

groups

2.1 Objective and methodology

2.1.1 Purpose of Task 2.2

The purpose of Task 2.2 is to set up a list of product groups that have not or not sufficiently been

considered in the previous Ecodesign process and may thus become the object of the third Working

Plan. This list shall be grouped into logical and feasible categories that fulfil the following criteria:

Exhaustiveness and mutual exclusiveness in order to ensure a systematic coverage of

products;

Technical similarity in order to allow for meaningful Ecodesign requirements;

Similarity of function, field of application (household / industrial / tertiary) and / or industrial

branch, if not identical with technical similarity, will be applied as additional criterion in order to

facilitate the policy process (identifying relevant stakeholders and target groups;

communication of the measure); and

Wherever possible, compatibility with existing categories, especially Prodcom and existing

Working Plan studies.

Furthermore, issues will be identified where a product-specific approach comes to its limits. For these

cases, other solutions such as a horizontal approach, a systems perspective or other approaches will

be suggested.

A specific issue in this Working Plan study, as opposed to the earlier ones, is a focus on resource

efficiency issues beyond energy efficiency. Therefore, a further purpose of Task 2.2 is to suggest

products or horizontal issues that are interesting from a resource perspective.

The goal of Task 2.2 is not yet a prioritisation of products.

2.1.2 Approach of Task 2.2

Three sources were used for the identification of product groups not yet sufficiently considered: the

first and second Working Plan study as well as the Prodcom database. After a review of various other

classification systems (CPC, CPA, CN, HS), the team has decided that it was not necessary to

consider additional classification systems: First, the sources mentioned above already provided for a

combination of top-down and bottom-up approaches that was mostly suitable for the purpose. Only a

few product groups remained which did not fit either a Prodcom code or a classification done by

another Working Plan study. But the introduction of yet another classification for those groups would

not have provided added value. It would have increased complexity without actually helping to find

data for these groups because EU-wide statistics similar to Prodcom are not available for these

classifications


In a first step (top-down approach), the product groups identified in Task 2 and 3 of the second

Working Plan study were taken as a starting point. They were matched with the groups suggested in

the first Working Plan study, and with the Lots that have been initiated by the Commission, to check

which product groups would be worth being re-assessed for inclusion into a third Working Plan (see

Annex IV). The following types of products were considered to merit re-assessment:

Product groups that have not been or could not be studied in depth in the second Working Plan

study (meaning they were identified in Task 2 but not studied in Task 3 or 4)11

;

Product groups that were judged as non-priority products by both Working Plan studies, but for

which new evidence has emerged in the meantime or is suspected to emerge in the course of

closer study (e.g. because one of the studies had mentioned the necessity of further study,

because the assessment in previous studies was rather weak, or because consortium

members or stakeholders hinted at possible new evidence); and

Product groups that were first or second priority in any of the previous Working Plan studies (A

or B in the first or second working plan, dark or medium green in the second Working Plan), but

which were not included in a Working Plan or Preparatory Study and for which new evidence

has emerged in the meantime or is likely to emerge.

In contrast, the following groups were judged not to merit re-assessment:

Product groups which were included in a Working Plan and for which a Preparatory Study has

been launched (except if some specific product categories considered in the Preparatory

Study, if any, were not included in the Ecodesign Regulation, as analysed in Task 2.1);

Product groups which have not been found first or second priority by any of the previous

Working Plan studies, and for which no new evidence has emerged or was likely to emerge;

and

Product groups which have been judged first or second priority in any of the previous Working

Plan studies but which were not included in a Working Plan or Preparatory Study, and for

which no new evidence has emerged or is expected to emerge (these were listed in a

“reminder list”12

).

Figure 2 illustrates the process.

11 The first Working Plan Study did no detailed assessment of specific product groups in the way the second did.

12 The final version of the “reminder list” is published in the Task 3 report.


Figure 2: Decision process for determining remaining product groups

re-assess

Has the product been included in

Task 3 of the second Working

Plan Study?

n

re-assess

y

Has it been judged first or second priority

in any of the two WP studies?

n n

do not re-

assess

y y

reminder list

Has a Preparatory Study been launched?

y

do not re-assess (except if identified in

Task 2.1)

n

Has it been included in a

Working Plan?

Has new evidence emerged or is

additional research likely to provide any?

reminder list n

y

n

re-assess y

Has new evidence emerged or is

additional research likely to provide any?


In the course of this exercise, some of the product groups, as defined in the second Working Plan

study, had to be redefined due to the following reasons:

A Preparatory Study had been launched only for some categories of the product group. The

group had to be redefined so that it excluded these product categories already analysed.

A reformulation of a product group’s boundaries or the splitting of an existing group was

needed to create groups that were technically or functionally more similar.

A reformulation of a product group’s boundaries was needed to eliminate overlaps.

In a second step (bottom-up analysis), the Prodcom 2013 list was assessed, starting from the

assessment of the 2009 list in the second Working Plan Study. Changes in the Prodcom classification

that had been implemented between 2009 and 2013 were recognised, and product groups were re-

scanned in order to verify which product groups were considered in scope of the Ecodesign Directive,

based largely on the previous assessment and correcting it only in a few cases. Excluded were

products that were not in scope because:

An impact on energy consumption could not be verified;

They are means of transport;

They are mass goods (such as cement), primary materials (such as plastics, woods) or

chemicals13

; or

They are parts of other goods that were not sold individually to the end consumer or of which

environmental performance could not be assessed individually.

Then, the product groups in scope were re-scanned in order to identify whether any product group

showed up that had not been considered in the previous Working Plan Studies. A few additional

product groups could be identified this way.

A three-level structure was chosen for the resulting product list:

The first level describes thematic areas or fields of application, according to activity involved

(e.g. “food preparation”, “heating”). This level links to everyday understanding, intending to

facilitate communication and identify relevant stakeholders.

The second level groups products more according to technical similarity; it is therefore closer to

the scope of a potential Preparatory Study. It may include an indication of the intended sector

(industrial, tertiary, or domestic) and of the technical process involved. Examples are “domestic

cooking appliances” or “domestic or tertiary kitchen appliances with chopping, grinding, mixing,

or blending function”. This level is however in many cases still too broad to provide e.g.

detailed sales and trade or energy consumption data for all involved products.

On the third level, concrete product examples are given, such as “mixers, toasters”. Meaningful

data will generally relate to this level, meaning that in the case of broader product groups, a

few examples will have to be chosen for study.

Industrial machines and installation make an exemption to this approach. Although they are extremely

energy relevant, a number of issues arise that make them a challenging subject for potential

Ecodesign Regulations, including:

Huge variety of very heterogeneous products, each produced in small numbers or custom

made;

13

The latter are not explicitly excluded from the Ecodesign Directive; however, it is generally understood that the Directive does

not apply to them.


Difficulty to define a meaningful grouping, e.g. according to industrial sector or cross-cutting

technical function; and

Often covered by other instruments such as ETS (Emissions Trading Scheme) or IED

(Industrial Emissions Directive).

Therefore, a general approach for dealing with them needs to be proposed before developing a

detailed grouping. The groups defined by the first two Working Plan studies have been adopted for the

moment, even if they follow a slightly different logic (more according to industrial sector in the first

Working Plan study, more according to functions in the second Working Plan study).

First arguments for the priority or non-priority of the product groups were noted in column J, where

available. A more thorough screening will follow at the beginning of Task 3.

In deviation from the proposal, a Prodcom correspondence table was not set up at this stage. As only

selected products would be studied in Tasks 3 and 4, the team perceived a detailed correspondence

list to be of limited added value for the products that would not be chosen. It was therefore decided to

identify the corresponding Prodcom codes rather for the product groups actually studied, in the course

of Task 3.

2.2 Results of Task 2.2

The results of Task 2.2 are two lists: The “reminder list” collects:

Product groups that have been suggested as first or second priority in the second Working

Plan study, but which have not been included in a Working Plan or for which no Preparatory

Study has been launched so far; and

Product groups that have been the object of a Preparatory Study but not included in the

regulation; and are deemed worth reconsidering.

The reminder list has been updated later in the project, in the course of Task 3 work and stakeholder

consultations. Therefore it is not included in the present report, but can be found in the conclusions of

the Task 3 report.

The “remaining products list” includes product groups identified through the Prodcom and previous

Working Plan study assessment as described above (Chapter 2.1.2). In a final step of integration,

results of Task 2.1 were added to these lists. The final content and structure of the lists is described in

the following Chapter 3.


3. Conclusions on Task 2

3.1 Lists of products to be considered

The overall results of Task 2.2 are two lists, presented in Annex II and in the Task 3 report.

Annex II presents a list of product groups from which the product groups for further analysis in Task 3

will be chosen. The list is created from two sources:

Product groups identified in Task 2.1 as having been the object of a Preparatory Study, but not

regulated to date, and merit further study but unlikely to be included in a review (coloured in

light blue); and

Product groups identified in Task 2.2, Step 1, as remaining product groups (coloured in white).

The list has a three-level structure: The first level (column B) describes thematic areas or fields of

application, according to activity involved (e.g. “food preparation”, “heating” etc.). The second level

(column C) groups products more according to technical similarity; it is therefore closer to the scope of

a potential Preparatory Study. On the third level (column D), concrete product examples are given,

such as “mixers, toasters”.

Besides the product groups, the table gives the source for the respective group (column E) and the

rank it had been assigned in the respective Working Plan study (Columns F, G). Column H, “status”

informs whether the group stems from a previous Working Plan study (“old”) and if so, whether it has

been studied in detail and whether it has been suggested as a priority product. If the group has been

added to the previous Working Plan studies, it is classified as “new”, and if group boundaries have

been changed, as “redefined”. Column I, “detailed investigation lacking?” informs whether the group is

in need for detailed investigation or has already been subject to an investigation of sales and trade

data, resource consumption, improvement potential and further considerations. The latter is assumed

to be the case

If it is one of the groups studied in Chapter 4 of Task 3 of the second Working Plan study;

If there is, at present, no indication that relevant new information may have emerged; and

If it does, according to a preliminary investigation of resource-related issues conducted by

Oeko-Institut14

, not present any additional resource issues.15

The list also contains, in column J, preliminary considerations that may affect the priority of the

products. Results of the additional resource report have also been included in this column, where

relevant. In column K, it is indicated whether a systems perspective suggests itself.

Furthermore, a “reminder list” was developed collects products and issues that will not be the object of

the present Working Plan study for various reasons, but need political decision making by the

Commission. Among them are:

14

This investigation is not included in this report but has been submitted as a separate report.

15 The second Working Plan study looked into energy consumption only.


From Task 2.1, products that have been in the scope of a Preparatory Study but not in the

scope of the Regulation, and which would merit reconsidering in the course of the review of

existing Implementing Measures; and

From Task 2.2, Step 1, products that have been suggested as first or second priority in any of

the previous Working Plan Studies but which have not been included in a Working Plan or for

which no Preparatory Study has been launched so far. At the same time, the evidence

provided by the second Working Plan study is deemed to be sufficiently detailed so that no

new evidence is expected to emerge from further study.

The reminder list is not yet presented here. In the course of Task 3, and according to stakeholder

input, it has been updated and complemented by a list of outstanding revisions and the products that

may be covered therein. It will therefore be presented in its final form in the conclusions of Task 3.

3.2 Potential horizontal measures

According to the resource report, the following horizontal measures may be envisaged from a

resource efficiency perspective:

Marking of devices containing components with specific materials. An illustrative example

would be the marking of l devices containing rare earth permanent magnets (e.g. motors,

generators, fans, pumps, elevators, machines). They would be marked with respect to

permanent magnets: Does the device contain permanent magnets? If yes, which type (e.g.

SmCo, FeNdB); and

Battery powered electronic devices: Easy extraction of rechargeable batteries in the recycling

facility (not identical with the easy removability during use required by the battery directive).

The issue of potential horizontal measures will be further explored in the conclusions of the Task 3

report and a fuller assessment will be presented there.


4. Annexes

4.1 Annex 2.A – Detailed review of all product categories considered in Preparatory Studies and in Regu-lations

Title of the Preparatory

Study

Lot number

Product categories in scope of the Preparatory Study

Legislative stage

Product categories in scope of the Regulation

Main product categories in scope of Preparatory Study but excluded from

the Regulation

Reason for exclusion

Transitional period

Boilers and combi-boilers

ENER Lot 1

Gas fired boilers Oil fired boilers Electric boilers Boilers with water heating functions Storage tanks used for central heating water or sanitary hot water Boilers that produce electricity as a by-product of heat generation Electric heat pumps (hydronic heating) Solar thermal systems (as part of hydronic system)

Reg. 813/2013

Space heaters and combination heaters (for both space heating and water heating) with a rated heat output ≤ 400 kW

Heaters generating heat only for the purpose of providing hot drinking or sanitary water

Product category already considered in ENER Lot 2

Water heaters ENER Lot 2

Electric Storage water heater Electric Instantaneous water heater Gas or oil-fired storage water heater Gas or oil-fired instantaneous water heater Solar water heater Heat pump water heater

Reg. 814/2013

Water heaters with a rated heat output ≤ 400 kW Hot water storage tanks with a storage volume ≤ 2000 litres

None

Personal computers and computer monitors

ENER Lot 3

Desktop computers Notebook computers Integrated desktop computers Small-scale servers

Reg. 617/2013

Computers and computer servers. Following products that can be powered directly from the mains alternating current (AC) including via an external or

None

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Heaters_Ecodesign_Reg_813_2013.pdf?PHPSESSID=45b842e329dfba507a04502b96590f02

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Heaters_Ecodesign_Reg_813_2013.pdf?PHPSESSID=45b842e329dfba507a04502b96590f02

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Water_heaters_Ecodesign_Reg_814_2013.pdf?PHPSESSID=45b842e329dfba507a04502b96590f02

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Water_heaters_Ecodesign_Reg_814_2013.pdf?PHPSESSID=45b842e329dfba507a04502b96590f02

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/REG_617-2013_Computers.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/REG_617-2013_Computers.pdf



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


internal power supply: - Desktop computers; - Integrated desktop computers; - Notebook computers; - Desktop thin clients; - Workstations; - Mobile workstations; - Small-scale servers; - Computer servers.

Imaging equipment

ENER Lot 4

Printers Copiers Fax machines Multi-function devices Scanners

Voluntary Agreement

Copiers, multifunctional devices, printers and fax machines that use one of the following marking technologies: electrophotography, solid ink or high performance ink jet and are designed for household or office use, that is: - Standard black & white (BW) format products with maximum speed < 66 A4 images per minute; - Standard Colour format products with maximum speed <51 A4 images per minute; Cartridges produced by or recommended by the OEM for use in these products

Scanners Low and declining sales

Televisions ENER Lot 5

TV set TV/Video combo TV component unit

Reg. 642/2009 and Amendm. 801/2013

Televisions (television meaning a television set or a television monitor; television set including additional components such as DVD, HDD or VCR drives)

None

Standby and off-mode losses

ENER Lot 6

Household appliances Cooking appliances Personal care appliances Information technology equipment intended primarily for use in the domestic environment Consumer equipment Toys

Reg. 1275/2008 and Amendm. 801/2013

Standby and off mode, and networked standby, electric power consumption for the placing on the market of electrical and electronic household and office equipment

None

http://www.eurovaprint.eu/fileadmin/eurovaprint_files/pdfs/Lot4_VA-version_4.pdf

http://www.eurovaprint.eu/fileadmin/eurovaprint_files/pdfs/Lot4_VA-version_4.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/TV/TV_regulation_090723.pdf




http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/REG_801-2013_Standby_losses.pdf






Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


External power supplies and battery chargers

ENER Lot 7

External Power Supplies Battery Chargers

Reg. 278/2009

Electric power consumption in no-load condition and average active efficiency of external power supplies

Battery chargers No suitable test standard

Office lighting

ENER Lot 8

Ballasts: - Magnetic ballasts; - Ballasts for discharge lamps or tubes; Lamps: - Fluorescent hot cathode discharge lamps with double ended cap; - Fluorescent hot cathode discharge lamps; - Incandescent lamps.

Luminaires Reg. 245/2009 and Amendm. 347/2010

Fluorescent lamps without integrated ballast

High intensity discharge lamps

Ballasts and luminaires able to operate such lamps as defined in Article 2

Few technical exemptions To be considered in the revision process

Street lighting

ENER Lot 9

Ballasts: - Ferromagnetic or electromagnetic ballasts for discharge lamps; - Electronic ballasts for discharge lamps; - Electronic power supply for solid state lamps; Lamps: - High pressure sodium lamps; - Low pressure sodium lamps; - Metal halide lamps with quartz arc tube; - Metal halide lamps with ceramic arc tube; - High pressure mercury lamps;

Luminaires

None

Room air conditioners (<= 12 kW)

ENER Lot 10

Air conditioners

Reversible air conditioners Reg. 206/2012

(range hoods included in Reg.)

Electric mains-operated air conditioners with a rated capacity of ≤ 12 kW for cooling (or heating if the product has no cooling function)

Comfort fans with an electric fan power input ≤ 125W

None

Residential ventilation and kitchen hoods

ENER Lot 10

Ventilation units include fans with electric power input of less than 125W Ventilation heat recovery systems Range hoods

Range hoods Product category already considered in Reg. 66/2014

Comfort fans ENER Table desk fan

None

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/EPS/eps_regulation_278_2009.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/EPS/eps_regulation_278_2009.pdf



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


(power input < 125 W)

Lot 10 Wall fan Floor fan Pedestal fan Ceiling fan Tower fan Box fans

Electric motors

ENER Lot 11

Single speed, three-phase, squirrel cage, electric motor 0.75-375 kW, with 2-6 poles, up to 1000 V

Reg. 640/2009 and Amendm. 4/2014

Motors (including those integrated in other products): electric single speed, three-phase 50 Hz or 50/60 Hz, squirrel cage induction motors that: - have 2 to 6 poles; - have a rated voltage up to 1000 V; - have a rated output power between 0.75 kW and 375 kW.

Motors specified to operate wholly immersed in a liquid Unknown reason for exclusion Motors completely integrated into a product (for example gear, pump, fan or compressor) Motors excluded from standard IEC 60034-30 (low voltage AC motors)

Ventilation fans (power output >125W)

ENER Lot 11

Axial fans Centrifugal fans Other (box-fans, roof-fans, cross-flow fans)

Reg. 327/2011

Fans (including those integrated in other products): rotary bladed machines whose work per unit mass does not exceed 25 kJ/kg, and which: - are designed for use with or equipped with an electrical motor with an electric input power between 125 W and 500 kW; - are axial fans, centrifugal fans, cross-flow fans or mixed flow fan; - may or may not be equipped with a motor when placed on the market or put into service.

Fans integrated in: - Products with a sole electric motor of 3 kW or less where the fan is fixed on the same shaft used for driving the main functionality; Unknown reason for exclusion

- Laundry and washer dryers ≤ 3 kW maximum electrical input power; Included in Reg. 1015/2010 and Reg. 932/2012

- Kitchen hoods < 280 W total maximum electrical input power attributable to the fan(s). Included in Reg. 66/2014

Fans with electric input power > 500 kW Much higher value than fans usually manufactured

Circulators in buildings

ENER Lot 11

Glandless standalone circulators (of centrifugal design)

Reg. 641/2009 and

Glandless standalone circulators and glandless circulators integrated in

None

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Regulation_4-2014l_00220140107en00010002.pdf




http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/fans_regulation_110406.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/fans_regulation_110406.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Circulators_amending_reg_120712.pdf




Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


(Electrical power consumption < 2500W)

Amendm. 622/2012

products

Water pumps in the following applications: commercial buildings, drinking water, agriculture and the food industry

ENER Lot 11

Single stage end suction close coupled pumps (ESCC) In-line ESCC pumps (ESCCi) Single stage end suction own bearing pumps (ESOB) Submersible multistage well pumps (4” & 6”) Vertical multistage water pumps Positive displacement water pumps

Reg. 547/2012

Rotodynamic water pumps for pumping clean water. One of the following designs: - End suction own bearing (below 150 kW) - End suction close coupled (below 150 kW) - End suction close coupled inline (below 150 kW) - Vertical multistage - Submersible multistage (4” & 6”)

Positive displacement water pumps Not a realistic option for most water pumping applications in scope of Lot 11 Positive displacement water pumps are included in WP2 (conditional list)

Commercial refrigerators and freezers

ENER Lot 12

Refrigerated display cabinet (remote and plug in) Cold vending machines

Working Document;

Domestic refrigerators and freezers

ENER Lot 13

Refrigerator without other compartments Refrigerator-cellar Refrigerator-chiller Refrigerator with a 0 star compartment Refrigerator-freezer Upright freezer Chest freezer Multi-use and other refrigerating appliances Wine storage appliances

Reg. 643/2009

Electric mains-operated household refrigerating appliances with a storage volume up to 1500 litres

Wine storage appliances Only generic requirement in Reg. 643/2009. Product category to be considered in the revision process

Domestic dishwashers

ENER Lot 14

Household dishwashers (approximately 4-16 place settings)

Reg. 1016/2010

Electric mains-operated household dishwashers (including those sold for non-household use and built-in household dishwashers)

None

Domestic washing machines

ENER Lot 14

Household washing machines (indicative capacity 3-10 kg)

Reg. 1015/2010

Electric mains-operated household washing machines (including those sold for non-household use and built-in

Household combined washer-driers Fall in-between Lots 14 & 16



http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/Working_Documents/Waterpumps_regulation_120626.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/Working_Documents/Waterpumps_regulation_120626.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/Refrig/Household_refrigerator_regulation_090723.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/Refrig/Household_refrigerator_regulation_090723.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/washing_dish/REG_1016_2010_dish.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/washing_dish/REG_1016_2010_dish.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/washing_dish/REG_1015_2010.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/washing_dish/REG_1015_2010.pdf



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


household washing machines)

Solid fuel small combustion installations

ENER Lot 15

Open fireplace Closed fireplace Traditional cooker Traditional stove Modern stove Small manual boiler Small automatic boiler Medium automatic boiler

Draft Regulation

Laundry dryers

ENER Lot 16

Electric tumble dryers (either air vented or air condenser) Gas-fired tumble dryers Combined washer-driers

Reg. 932/2012

Electric mains-operated and gas-fired household tumble driers and built-in household tumble driers

Household combined washer-driers Fall in-between Lots 14 & 16

Household vacuum cleaners

ENER Lot 17

Canister vacuum cleaners (including wet and dry) Upright vacuum cleaners Battery operated / cordless vacuum cleaners

Reg. 666/2013

Electric mains-operated vacuum cleaners, including hybrid vacuum cleaners

Wet vacuum cleaners No suitable test standard Wet and dry vacuum cleaners No suitable test standard Battery operated vacuum cleaners No suitable test standard

Simple set top boxes

ENER Lot 18a

Simple set top boxes without conditional access Reg. 107/2009

Simple set top boxes None

Complex set top boxes

ENER Lot 18

Standalone devices for the reception of Standard Definition (SD) or High Definition (HD) digital broadcasting services

Voluntary Agreement

Complex set top boxes

Non-directional lighting

ENER Lot 19 (Part 1)

Incandescent lamp Halogen lamp Fluorescent lamp

Reg. 244/ 2009 and Amendm. 859/2009

Non-directional household lamps None

Directional lighting

ENER Lot 19 (Part 2)

Luminaires Reflector lamps

Reg. No 1194/2012

Directional lamps Light-Emitting Diode (LED) lamps Equipment designed for installation

None

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Draft_Ecodesign_solid_fuel_boilers_Jan_2014_1.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Draft_Ecodesign_solid_fuel_boilers_Jan_2014_1.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/Final_Documents/Household_tumble_driers_regulation_121012.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/Final_Documents/Household_tumble_driers_regulation_121012.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/REG_666-2013_Vacuum_cleaners.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/REG_666-2013_Vacuum_cleaners.pdf

http://www.eceee.org/ecodesign/products/simple_set_top_boxes/Regulation_sstb

http://www.eceee.org/ecodesign/products/simple_set_top_boxes/Regulation_sstb

http://cstb.eu/home/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/Voluntary-Industry-Agreement-CSTBs-V-3-1-Final.pdf

http://cstb.eu/home/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/Voluntary-Industry-Agreement-CSTBs-V-3-1-Final.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Produktgruppen/Lots/IM/Adopted_IM/Light/regulation_household_lamps_244_2009.pdf




http://www.eceee.org/ecodesign/products/directional_lighting/Directional_lamps_Regulation_1194-2012.pdf

http://www.eceee.org/ecodesign/products/directional_lighting/Directional_lamps_Regulation_1194-2012.pdf



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


LEDs between the mains and the lamps, including lamp control gear, control devices and luminaires (other than ballasts and luminaires for fluorescent and high-intensity discharge lamps)

Professional dishwashers

ENER Lot 24

Undercounter water-change dishwashers Undercounter one-tank dishwashers Hood-type dishwashers Utensil / Pot dishwashers One-tank conveyor-type dishwashers Multi-tank conveyor-type dishwashers

Working document

Professional laundry machines and dryers

ENER Lot 24

Semi-professional dryer, Condenser Semi-professional dryer air vented Professional Cabinet dryer Professional tumble dryer (<15 kg) Professional tumble dryer (15 - 40 kg) Professional tumble dryer (>40 kg) Pass-through (transfer) tumble dryer

Working document

Pumps for private and public wastewater and for fluids with high solids content (< 160 kW)

ENER Lot 28

Centrifugal submersible pumps Centrifugal drywell pumps Slurry pumps

Working Document

Pumps for private and public swimming pools, ponds, fountains and aquariums, as well as

ENER Lot 29

Domestic/commercial pumps with built in strainer Fountain and pond pumps to 1 kW Aquarium pumps to 120 W ESCC pumps from 150 kW to 1 MW ESOB from 150 kW to 1 MW Submersible bore-hole pumps (8”, 10”, 12”, 12”+)

Working Document

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/WD2_Lot24_Prof_Wet_Draft_Measure_v1.0.pdf






Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


clean water pumps larger than those regulated under TREN Lot 11

Vertical multi-stage pumps

Products in motor systems outside the scope of the Regulation 640/2009 on electric motors

ENER Lot 30

Motors outside the output power range of 0.75–375 kW Brake motors, other operation ratings Other technologies (single-phase motors, permanent magnet motor, line-start permanent magnet motors, switched reluctance motors, special purpose inverter duty motors)

Working Document

Products in motor systems outside the scope of ENER Lot 30 and the Regulation 640/209 on electric motors

ENER Lot 31

Compressors driven by three phase electric motors

Working Document

Working Plan 1

Local room heating products

ENER Lot 20

Convector heaters (electric, gas and liquid fuel) Oil-filled heaters (electric) Fan heaters (electric) Radiant heaters (electric and gas-fired) Storage heaters (electric) Thin film/cable heating system (electric) Fires (electric, gas and liquid fuel) Air curtains (electric and gas-fired)

Draft Regulation

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/20140311_ED_SolidLocalSpaceHeaters.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/20140311_ED_SolidLocalSpaceHeaters.pdf



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


Industrial unit heaters (electric, gas and liquid fuel)

Central heating products that use hot air to distribute heat

ENER Lot 21

Warm air heaters (gas heaters, liquid fuel heaters, mutli-fuel heaters, electric heaters) Heat pumps (above 12 kW cooling capacity) (all-electric heat pumps, gas-fired heat pumps)

Working document

Domestic and commercial ovens

ENER Lot 22

Domestic (food) ovens: - Domestic range ovens - Conventional domestic ovens - Domestic microwave ovens - Toaster/Grill ovens - Roaster ovens

Commercial (food) ovens: - Commercial static ovens - Commercial forced-convection ovens - Deck ovens - Rotary rack ovens - In-store bakery convection ovens

Reg. 66/2014

Domestic ovens (including when incorporated in cookers), domestic hobs and domestic electric range hoods, including when sold for non-domestic purposes

Commercial ovens No suitable test standard

Microwave ovens Low energy savings

Steam ovens No suitable test standard Portable ovens Unknown reason for exclusion Small ovens Niche market

Domestic and commercial hobs and grills

ENER Lot 23

Domestic hobs (electric, gas and combi) Domestic range cookers Commercial hobs Portable hobs Grills

Reg.66/2014 Commercial hobs No suitable test standard and non reliable data

Portable hobs No accurate sales data Grills Too diversified product category

Non-tertiary coffee machines

ENER Lot 25

Combined coffee machines Drip/filter coffee machines Pad filter coffee machines Espresso coffee machines

Reg. 801/2013

Standby and off mode, and networked standby, electric power consumption for the placing on the market of electrical and electronic household and office

None

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/20130717_Lot21_ED_1.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/20130717_Lot21_ED_1.pdf

http://www.eup-network.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Ecodes_domestric_ovens_REG_66_2014.pdf





Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


equipment

Networked standby losses

ENER Lot 26

House equipment with integrated network interfaces Information technology equipment Consumer electronics equipment Other electric and electronic equipment

Reg. 801/2013

Networked standby electrical and electronic household and office equipment

None

Uninterruptible power supplies

ENER Lot 27

Electronic power converters Switches and energy storage devices (such as batteries) constituting a power system for maintaining the continuity of power to a load in the case of input power failure

Preparatory Study completed

Refrigerating and freezing equipment

ENTR Lot 1

Service cabinets Blast cabinets Walk-in cold rooms Process chillers Water dispensers Ice-makers Dessert and beverage machines Minibars Wine storage appliances Remote condensing units

Draft Regulation

Distribution and power transformers

ENTR Lot 2

Distribution transformer MV/LV Distributed energy resource (DER) transformer MV/LV Industry dry transformer MV/LV Industry oil transformer MV/LV Power transformer Phase shifter Separation/isolation transformer

Reg. 548/2014

Sound and imaging equipment

ENTR Lot 3

Video Player Video Recorder Projector Games consoles

Voluntary Agreement submitted for adoption by the



http://www.eceee.org/ecodesign/products/cold_appliances/EU177_EN_1_1.pdf

http://www.eceee.org/ecodesign/products/cold_appliances/EU177_EN_1_1.pdf



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


Commission.

Industrial and laboratory furnaces and ovens

ENTR Lot 4

Laboratory furnaces Laboratory ovens Steriliser ovens Metal melting furnaces Metal heat treatment furnaces Waste incinerators Induction furnace Tunnel furnace Bakery/biscuit ovens Smelting furnaces Batch furnace for ceramics Glass melting furnace Glass annealing furnace (lehr) Infrared ovens Hydrocarbon cracker Cement kiln Lime kiln

Impact assessment ongoing

Machine tools and related machinery

ENTR Lot 5

Metal working machine tools Woodworking machines Welding, soldering, and brazing machines Other machine tools

Impact assessment ongoing, Draft Voluntary Agreement

Air-conditioning products, except air-conditioners < 12kW (ENER lot 10)

ENTR Lot 6

Package, split and multi-split air conditioners Positive temperature air condensing units Variable Refrigerant Flow (VRF) systems Chillers for air conditioning applications Fan coils Cooling towers

Draft Regulation

Non-domestic ventilation products

ENTR Lot 6

Small extraction fan (local exhaust) Rooftop/boxed ventilation units (central exhaust or central supply) Local Heat Recovery Ventilation (LHRV) unit Central Heat Recovery Ventilation (CHRV) unit



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


Air Handling Unit (AHU)

Taps and showers

JRC Kitchen taps Basin taps Showerheads and showers Electric showers and low pressure showers

Preparatory Study ongoing

Working Plan 2 (Priority List)

Window products

ENER Lot 32

Windows for buildings Window doors Roof windows


Steam boilers ( < 50MW)

ENTR Lot 7

Steam boilers Preparatory Study ongoing

Power cables ENTR Lot 8

Lighting circuit in industry and services sectors Socket-outlet circuit in industry and services sectors Dedicated circuit in industry and services sectors


Enterprises’ servers, data storage and ancillary equipment

ENTR Lot 9

Servers Storage Network


Smart appliances

ENER Lot 33

Preparatory Study to be launched in Sept. 2014

Wine storage appliances (c.f. Reg. 643/2009)

ENER Lot 34

Preparatory Study ongoing (will be incorporated in ENER Lot 13 review)



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


Water-related products

No Preparatory Study so far

Working Plan 2 (Conditional List)

Positive displacement pumps


Fractional horse power motors under 200W


Heating controls


Lighting systems

ENER Lot 37

Preparatory Study planned (following a short study completed)

Thermal insulation in buildings

ENER Lot 36

Short study completed

No Implementing Measure envisaged



Study

Lot number


Legislative stage



the Regulation


Other product groups

Medical imaging equipment

No lot Computer Tomography (CT) Ultrasound, X-Ray Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) Nuclear medicine

Draft Voluntary Agreement

Power generating equipment under 50 MW

ENER Lot 35

Short study completed

No Implementing Measure envisaged


4.3 Annex 2.B – Remaining products list

A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I

Detailed investig. lacking

J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

I Thermal insulation

1 Thermal insulation (non-building)

VHK Task 2

none none old, not studied

yes Used for ovens and furnaces so already covered by Lot 22 and Lot 4 prep studies. However, it is also used for other thermoprocessing equipment which is not covered by a previous Lot study. Might be out of scope because it is not an individually sold product, but could be a horizontal measure.

yes (integrated in larger product)

2 IR reflective paints

Prodcom

none none new yes Used mainly to keep buildings cool in warm climates - reduces need for air-conditioning.

yes (integrated in building)

II Construction products

3 Construction products

fibreboard, plates, tiles, bricks, blocks, prefabricated walls, flooring, glass sheets, cement, mortar, concrete, roofing paper, mastics, surfacing preparations...

Prodcom

none none new yes Affect thermal insulation; excluded by VHK; probably better covered by CPR

yes (integrated in building)

III Pre-fabricated houses

4 Greenhouses Own, based on VHK 4.4

none none re-defined

yes Greenhouses may be heated especially commercial ones in northern Europe. VHK cites high energy consumption and improvement potential. Energy consumption will depend on insulation efficiency as well as other design issues. Unclear whether Ecodesign is best instrument

yes (type of heating relevant)

5 Pre-fabricated houses, garden huts etc.

Own, based on Prodcom

none none new yes In scope if heated or cooled. Materials may be covered by construction products regulation To check whether planning laws and building regulations (thermal insulation) apply.

yes (type of heating relevant)


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

IV Solar shading devices

6 Curtains and interior blinds

Own, based on Prodcom (see also VHK 5.5)

none none new yes Affect thermal insulation; difficult to imagine meaningful regulation: effect depends on material and colour which cannot be regulated without excessively restricting consumer choice and on placement / size which is custom made.

yes (must be suited to window)

7 Shutters and blinds

Own, based on Prodcom (see also VHK 5.5)

none none new yes Affect thermal insulation; difficult to imagine meaningful regulation: effect depends on material which cannot be regulated without excessively restricting consumer choice and on placement / size which is custom made.

yes (must be suited to window)

V indoor climate equipment

8 Humidifiers and dehumidifiers, domestic

VHK 5.3, VHK task 2

none none old, conditional

yes ?

9 Humidifiers and dehumidifiers, tertiary

VHK Task 2


yes ?

10 Humidifiers and dehumidifiers, industrial

various equipment for climate of process conditions: process humidification (clean rooms, paper mill, wood processing) and dehumidification

VHK Task 2


yes ?

11 Air filters air filters VHK 5.1 none none old, conditional

yes ?

VI Building control and access

12 Building automatic doors, burglar alarms, VHK none none old, yes yes


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

control & access

fire/smoke alarms, thermostats, sensors, building automation systems ,indicator panels, Electric sound or visual signalling apparatus, Signal generators

Task 2, EPTA 37

not studied

(integrated in building)

VII Space Heating equipment not yet covered

13 Space Heating equipment not covered by existing lots

ionisation heating emitters, district heating space heating/cooling equipment, patio heaters

Own, based on VHK task 2, EPTA 13

re-defined

yes Relevant? yes (heating system)

14 Radiators for central heating

Prodcom

none none new yes Unclear how much difference this would make to overall heating system energy efficiency, especially if valves are already regulated under heating controls.

yes (heating system)

VIII Hot water related equipment not yet covered

15 Equipment for heated water applications not yet dealt with

water purification/filtering equipment (anti-legionella) district heating water heating equipment

VHK Task 2

re-defined

yes yes (integrated in hot water provision system)

16 Bathtubs, sinks

Prodcom

none none new yes Material and construction might affect heat loss; many architectural / aesthetic / practical considerations; probably little difference, unlikely to be regulated

IX Swimming pool, sauna, and spa equipment

17 Swimming pool / Spa equipment, permanently installed (commercial?)

indoor and outdoor Spa / Whirlpool / swimming pool equipment not covered (e.g. water heating, water cleaning, special equipment for massage jets, fountains...)

Mainly based on VHK 5.4

none (condidional)

none (conditional)

old, conditional

yes Domestic appliances are a niche market. To check whether sufficiently covered by pumps and water heating. Production impacts may be most significant for unheated pools. Solar heating of pools can be used, even in northern Europe.

yes (designed to fit size and design of pool)


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

X Cold water equipment

18 Other equipment for cold water applications

taps, water dispensing equipment (horticultural products, cleaning products), water purification/filtering

VHK Task 2

old, not studied

yes

XI Lighting products not yet covered Some missing applications might also be covered in the review of Reg. 244/2009 and 245/2009.

19 Other safety and signalling lighting equipment

Emergency/safety lighting, Traffic signs and road signalisation products,

VHK Task 2

old, not studied

yes It depends what lamps are in use and what their specifications are. If Halogen or incandescent is used (as exempted so far) they are highly relevant in terms of efficiency as safety and signalling lighting has long burning times. As many applications are CFL (safety exits etc.), they are not so relevant when it comes to efficiency. However, CFLs will generally use mercury as well as sometimes phosphor. Regular LEDs can include arsenic, indium, antimony or gallium.Often High intensity discharge lamps (HID) are used that are highly efficient, but mercury relevant.Safety lighting in buildings is often battery powered (in case of power cuts) so energy efficiency should be important to extend battery lifetime.

20 Commercial lighting equipment

Retail Lighting, illuminated displays, illuminated advertising, signs, electronic labels, decorative/festivity lighting (city beautification, X-mas lighting etc.) Non-task area lighting in office buildings (corridors, toilets, reception areas etc.)

VHK Task 2


yes General retail lighting should be covered by 245/2009/EU. Directional lighting is sometimes used in commercial applications which would be in scope of 1194/2012 (this includes LEDs and luminaires).Very often in retail halogen is used for accent lighting. LED can be used by today; efficiency requirements


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

should be considered.Many application have changed to LED already (X-mas lighting…). LEDS combined with Cd quantum dot technology could become relevant in the near future in displays. The LEDS strips used for signing to my knowledge do not use the Cd QD technology at present but contain some of the materials mentioned above.Handicraft luminous discharge tubes (HLDT) are also used for signs, decorative lighting and lightartwork. They contain large amounts of mercury in comparison with regular CFLs. In some cases LEDs are used, in some cases it is not possible. A RoHS exemption was requested for such HLDTs but I think the EU COM has not decided yet. Still, not all HLDTS are RoHS regulated. Group is difficult to regulate as they are hand crafted and custom made.When it comes to general commercial lighting the scope of efficiency requirements should be shifted from lamps to luminaires (lamps+ballasts+luminaire) as the whole system is very relevant when it comes to efficiency. General commercial lighting is ruled by 245/2009/EU Efficiency requirements in terms of Luminaire efficiency factor (LEF) including ballast and properties of the luminaire and the lamps should be considered

21 Other Lighting Applications not covered by existing lots

Industrial Lighting, Tunnel lighting, Private outdoor lighting, other colour lamps, daylight systems

EPTA 42

new yes Daylight and presence control should definitely be considered under eco-design or the buildings directive (EPBD), e.g. every new commercial building must be equipped with daylight and presence


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

control (huge potential!!!!).Industrial lighting (factories etc.) should be considered. High potential due to long burning hours in factory halls (24h/d) etc. Not covered by 244/2008. Check if and how covered by 245/2009 and 1194/2012. Private outdoor lighting: usually short burning hours.Tunnel lighting: safety relevance very high (glare!); I would suppose that LED solutions are on their way and due to low LCC used anyway. Where CFLs are used, the main concern is as usual mercury. A RoHS exemption was handled last year for special purpose lamps needing more mercury to enable longer service life (lamps for industrial halls and places where maintenance is difficult), Such lamps are relevant here.Close loopholes such as shock proof lamps (not in the 244/2009) that can be used for general lighting. (see EU lighting strategy currently prepared by EC and stakeholders.)

XII Ventilation equipment not yet covered

22 Special purpose ventilation (if not covered elsewhere)

e.g. for tunnel ventilation, (subways, underground motor ways, underground railways), mine shafts, parking buildings, Fans for material transportation, Process Cooling fans, Process Heating fans

own, based on VHK Task 2, EPTA 52

re-defined

yes

23 Blowers (pressure ratio > 1.1)

as applied in various household and tertiary equipment / appliances

VHK 4.7 12 15 old, Priority B

no Possible overlap with personal care, hand driers might go here. Hand driers energy consumption varies considerably, e.g. whether they use heat or not. Leaf blowers: to check whether regulated by motor and fan regulation.


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

24 Ducts and duct systems

air ducts for ventilation systems VHK 5.2 none none old, conditional

yes yes (integrated in ventilation system)

XIII Power generation

25 Medium/large electric power generation

power generation >50 MW (fossil, nuclear, hydro and renewable fuels, separate or combined)

Own, based on VHK Task 2


yes Probably covered by ETS yes

26 Mobile power generators

with engines, for construction sites or emergency power

VHK 4.10

30 26 old, not suggested

yes Discussion may need to be reopened. Energy efficiency probably poor (we need data) - numbers may be significant. However, according to VHK study, no significant improvement potential => to discuss

XIV Power distribution

27 Medium large electric power transport / distribution

cables for electric power transport and distribution (high to medium voltage, not low voltage applications)

VHK Task 2


yes Check other legislation? ETS? yes

28 Electrical insulators

Prodcom

none none new yes yes

29 Power cables (domestic)

Own, based on VHK 4.36

re-defined

No Industrial and tertiary covered by ENTR 8. Domestic have been excluded due to alleged small losses. There is a trade-off between energy loss and manufacturing energy (cable thickness)

XV Power storage

30 Medium/large electric power storage

power storage > 50 MW own, based on VHK Task 2


yes Large scale storage is being studied by Japanese manufacturers, e.g. Mitsubishi; also possible by pumped storage if two nearby reservoirs available with one higher than the other (used in several EU States) - but need suitable geography. Solar energy

yes


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

storage R&D in Spain using molten salt storage with solar energy. Ecodesign possibly not appropriate tool.

31 Small scale electric power storage (< 50 MW)

batteries, chemical accumulators, flywheels for UPS

VHK Task 2


yes Interesting: Redox cell

XVI Power electronics products

32 Inverters and converters

Inverters, static converters, rotary converters, rectifiers, a.c. converters,

Own, based on EPTA 10

12 12 re-defined

yes Originally suggested priority A, but not included in Working Plan.

yes

33 Power supplies and battery chargers

accumulator chargers, power supply units, internal power supplies, chargers for industrial applications, chargers telecommunication network equipment, battery chargers for vehicles

Own, based on EPTA 10

12 12 re-defined

yes ENER 7 covers battery chargers and EPS, but battery chargers were not regulated because of lack of standards. In the meantime, standards have become available.

34 Inductors inductors Own, based on EPTA 10

12 12 re-defined


35 Soft starters Own, based on EPTA 10

12 12 re-defined


XVII Transformers not yet covered

36 Measuring Transformers

Voltage measuring tranformers, current measuring transformers

EPTA 25

18 18 old, Priority B

yes

37 Equipment transformers

Own new yes Equipment transformers are not regulated and were not studied. These

yes (integrated


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

are much smaller and are used inside electrical equipment in very large numbers. From ERA's work, it appears that there are many poor quality transformers from Asia which will waste more energy than necessary. Horizontal measure (like motors regulation which includes motors in appliances) may be an effective approach.

in product)

XVIII Handheld power tools

38 Handheld power tools

various handheld / portable motor tools for professional and DIY use (lawn blowers, hand tools, etc.) "...used for (but not limited to) (...) construction, agricultural, horticultural, industrial and domestic context. Examples (...) are demolition jack hammers, electric power tools (e.g. in construction and building / DIY), chainsaws (...) and hedge trimmers, cutters (...) leaf or lawn blowers." Both electric and with internal combustion engine. May also include hand-held tools for soldering or brazing.

VHK 4.3 32 31 old, not suggested

yes Discussion may need to be reopened. VHK dealt only with a selection of possible tools. new evidence: manufacturers may use larger size motors than necessary for marketing reasons. Reducing maximum motor rating could be an option.

XIX Mowers

39 Lawn and riding mowers

includes mowers pushed by a human, self-propelled, and pulled behind a tractor, both electric and with internal combustion engine.

VHK 4.17

31 30 old, not suggested

yes Discussion may have to be reopened, especially with respect to electric mowers where data were missing. Based on the possible over-sizing of motors, there could be an energy saving. Electric mowers will be used for more hours per year than domestic power tools so annual energy consumption should be much larger.


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

XX Cleaning equipment

40 Detergents detergents for applications where hot water is required: clothes, dishes, surfaces; domestic and professional

Own, based on VHK 4.14

22 10 re-defined

yes Is an ErP in that detergents affect washing / cleaning temperature and / or amount of hot water needed and thereby energy consumption (but then there is often a trade-off with chemicals use). Strong opposition by industry. VHK treatment restricted to clothes and dishes.

41 Cleaning / hygienic equipment

floor cleaning equipment (floor washing / mopping) professional mobile (self-propelled) cleaning/service products: cleaning trucks, sweepers, snow graders, etc.

VHK Task 2

old, not studied

yes

XXI Clothes cleaning and drying products not yet covered

42 Centrifugal clothes driers

Prodcom

none none new yes

43 Household combined washer-driers

UBA suggestion to VHK; Task 2.1

none none new yes DG ENER mentioned that they will be part of the review of ENER Lot 14.

44 Textiles dry cleaning equipment

UBA suggestion to VHK;

none none new yes

XXII Clothes care products

45 Clothes ironing products, tertiary (ironing machines and presses)

Prodcom

none none new yes

46 Sewing One re- yes


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

machines (domestic, tertiary)

product in EPTA 7

defined

XXIII ICT and telecommunication equipment not yet covered

47 Network switching subsystem

new new yes To check, why has not network switching subsystem be studied by previous Working Plan studies?

yes

48 Base station subsystem

ICT transmission/distribution equipment (landlines and wireless) - for TV, radio, internet, phone, data

VHK 4.18, EPTA 35


no Large number of telecom base stations (transmitter / receiver / amplifier / booster) in the EU and these probably consume a lot of energy, incentive for energy efficiency small.

yes

49 In-house networking

LAN hotspot, router, modem, hub, servers

VHK Task 2, EPTA 34

old, not studied

yes Most important impact is standby consumption, operating times are comparatively short and little improvement potential Standby is regulated by ENER 26 Networked standby. Operating

yes

50 Telecom end terminating equipment, portable

Mobile phones, smartphones, satellite phones, cordless phones, PDA, palm top, Portable receivers for calling or paging, tablets

own, based on VHK 4.34, EPTA 39a

25 24 re-defined

yes New evidence exists from a resource perspective: Manufacturing and end-of life impacts are most important, so requirements for durability, easy disassembly, and the erasure of personal data can be envisaged.

yes

51 Telecom end terminating equipment, non portable

telephone sets, Telephone answering machines, Videophones, fax machines

own, based on EPTA 39a and others

re-defined

yes Declining markets or no important energy consumption

52 Battery-powered ICT devices

Calculators, gaming devices, portable media player

own, based on VHK Task 2 and others

re-defined

yes Mobile gaming devices etc have rapidly increasing sales. New evidence exists from a resource perspective (see resource chapter). Manufacturing and end-of life impacts are most important, so durability requirements might be important.


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

53 Aerials, antennas, radars, radio navigation and control items

Radar apparatus, Radio navigational aid apparatus, (gps based navigation) Radio remote control apparatus, antennas for telecommunications, aerials

own, based on VHK Task 2, EPTA 36, EPTA 39a

19 19 old, Priority A

yes yes

XXIV Basic electronic units parts

54 Basic electronic units parts (capacitors, resistors, printed circuits)

Capacitors, Resistors, PCBs EPTA 33.


yes Unlikely to result in energy savings as components are designed to have specific functions and design does not affect energy consumption - except for quality of transformers (above). PCB design can affect energy consumption, but better to regulate finished equipment as difficult to regulate how products are designed.

yes (integrated in product)

XXV Sound and imaging equipment not yet covered

55 Home audio/video equipment not yet covered

Both for playback and recording, such as: Home cinema systems, beamers, Digital cameras, Microphones, Loudspeakers, Headphones and earphones, Electric amplifiers, Jukeboxes, Sound recording or sound reproducing apparatus, Radio receivers

own, based on VHK 4.15, EPTA 28/29

26 32 re-defined

yes Will have to be split up even more to create meaningful Preparatory Studies

56 Professional sound and imaging equipment

Transmission apparatus for radiobroadcasting or television, studio equipment, Television cameras, Photographic enlargers and reducers

own, based on EPTA 28, VHK Task 2


yes

57 Photographic Flashlights (excluding photographic Prodco none none new yes


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

equipment flashbulbs, flashcubes and the like); photographic enlargers; apparatus for photographic laboratories; negatoscopes

m

XXVI Food and drink preparation equipment not yet covered

58 Domestic and commercial cooking equipment not yet covered by existing lots

Domestic and commercial fryers, steam ovens, domestic portable ovens, domestic and commercial grills

own, based on VHK 5.7, EPTA 17, and others

re-defined

yes Portable ovens were excluded from Regulation 66/2014 due to a lack of data. They may be worth reincluding, since the improvement potential may be significant (estimated at >1TWh/year). Steam ovens lacked a standard when the Preparatory Study was completed. Yet with some new standard published, it may be possible to determine the improvement potential. Grills were considered to be too diversified product category, and therefore were excluded from Regulation 66/2014. Yet, the definition of grills can be revised and some product with a grill function be included in upcoming Regulations. The group does not include commercial ovens and hobs because they will be included in the review of Reg. 66/214.

59 Domestic Kitchen appliances

Juicers, blenders, mixers, toasters, bottle warmers, bread makers, etc.

new, based on VHK 4.16 and own considerations

34 2 re-defined

yes Functions include heating, chopping, cutting, blending, mixing, etc. All have electric motors, the main energy user, but may be rated larger than needed for marketing.

60 Professional kitchen appliances

Juicers, blenders, mixers etc. new, based on VHK 4.16 and own consider

34 2 re-defined

yes Functions include heating, chopping, cutting, blending, mixing, etc. May be separated by functions.


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

ations

61 Electric kettles / water cookers

Includes classical water cookers and "installed" versions with hot water storage at least 100 degrees

VHK 4.22


yes May have to be reassessed because of new evidence: Durability is an issue. 3% failure within 1 year is normal and is >3% for poor quality kettles. There are a few references (marketing) that suggests that significant energy savings are possible, by better control of the amount of water heated and with thick-film elements

XXVII Food presentation and storage equipment

62 Hot vending machines

Hot beverage vending machines Own, based on EPTA 8

27 27 re-defined

yes Cold vending machines covered by ENER 12

63 Food presentation and storage equipment (commercial)

Heated displays/service cabinets for hot food, catering equipment

own, based on VHK 5.7 and task 2

re-defined

yes

XXVIII Person and goods transport systems

64 Elevators, escalators, and moving walkways

Elevators, escalators, moving walkways;

VHK 4.27

10 12 old, Priority A

yes VHK study mentions further research needs

65 Other person transport

Teleferics, ski-draglines; and others?

new, based on EPTA 16

re-defined

yes

66 Other goods transport; logistic systems

According to VHK: systems for moving equipment and goods (include single materials handling product and complete turnkey systems). Is usually not about optimizing individual products but

new, based on VHK 4.30; EPTA 16

23 13 re-defined

yes yes


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

complete system. Cross-cutting issues can be addressed by regulations of motors and VSD; to discuss: optimization by smart controls. EPTA lists individual products such as conveyors, forklifts, mobile platforms, platform truck, electric pallet jack, telescopic handler, chairlifts, cranes, Pulley tackle, hoists, winches, capstans, built-in jacking systems, Loaders, Rolling-mill machinery. May be worthwhile to cross-check whether specific products can be singled out.

XXIX Medical equipment not yet covered

67 Medical equipment not covered by SRI, Diagnostic

For instance Electro-cardiographs, Scintigraphic apparatus, Electro-diagnostic monitoring apparatus for simultaneous monitoring of two or more physiological parameters, electro-diagnostic apparatus for brain functions, Electric Blood pressure meters

Own, based on EPTA 24, except those dealt with in VHK 4.33, and SRI

10 10 re-defined

yes Many different types with small individual sales numbers. Another SRI possible ? Discussion may have to be broadened beyond the types studied by VHK.

68 Medical equipment not covered by SRI, Therapeutic

Medical drill engines, diathermic apparatus, lithotripsy instruments, Apparatus for nerve stimulation, electric surgical knifes, laser surgical apparatus, Electrical vibratory-massage apparatus, Mechano-therapy appliances, massage apparatus, psychological aptitude-testing apparatus, Ozone

Own, based on EPTA 25 and SRI

5 5 re-defined

yes Many different types with small individual sales numbers. Another SRI possible ? Discussion may have to be broadened beyond the types studied by VHK.


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

therapy, oxygen therapy, aerosol therapy, respiration apparatus, Breathing appliances, Medical, surgical or laboratory sterilisers.

XXX Leisure equipment

69 Amusement park and fairground equipment

Roundabouts, swings, shooting galleries, rollercoasters...

Prodcom; see also VHK Task 2 "outdoor leisure"


yes Very individual; motors are probably relevant part

70 Mobile (outdoor) equipment/machinery not belonging to group "transport"

Snowmobiles, quads, amusement boats etc.

Own, based on VHK Task 2 "Outdoor leisure"


yes Partly covered by "transport"; relevance?

71 Gaming automates and tables

Tables for casino games, automatic bowling alley equipment, and other funfair, table or parlour games, including pintables; games operated by coins, banknotes ‘paper currency’, discs or other similar articles; billiards, electric car racing sets

Prodcom; see also VHK Task 2 "indoor leisure", EPTA 7, 21 and 22

none none new yes Very heterogeneous?

72 Electric music instruments

Electric guitars, digital pianos, electric violins, electric bass guitars, electronic keyboards.

Prodcom; see also VHK Task 2 "indoor leisure", EPTA 7,


yes Relevance?


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

21 and 22

73 Electric toys Electric trains, electric cars, electric dolls, electric robots,decoration: animated displaysaquarium (pump dealt with; water heating and lighting?)



yes Probably small impact and potential; there could be a horizontal measure for devices containing batteries e.g. with regard to removing time in recycling (different from removability during use phase)

74 Video games Game consoles Own; based on VHK 4.15, “home audio / video", EPTA 7, 21 and 22


no Important market. Might also go to ICT and telecommunications.

75 Aquarium equipment other than pump

Aquarium: water heating and lighting



yes Pumps already covered. relevance?

76 Gymnasium or athletics articles

Home trainers, treadmill Prodcom

none none new yes

XXXI Electrically operated clocks and watches

77 Electrically Wall mounted electric clocks, office EPTA none none old, yes Probably little impact


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

operated locks and watches

clocks, alarm clocks. 23 not studied

XXXII Personal care

78 Personal care: equipment with motors and moving parts

Electric shavers, hair-shearing apparatus; electric hairdressing apparatus; massage equipment; electric toothbrush; motorised mattress support; both domestic and tertiary

Own, based on VHK 5.6, EPTA 5, Prodcom


yes Probably small impact and potential

79 Personal care: blowers

Hairdryers, hot air hand driers; both domestic and tertiary



yes Some impact in hand driers?

80 Personal care: heating equipment

hair drying hoods, electric blankets, waterbed; both domestic and tertiary



yes Probably small impact and potential

81 Personal care: suntanning equipment

Sunbeds, sunlamps Own, based on VHK 5.6, EPTA 5, Prodcom

none none new yes

82 Personal weighing scales

Personal weighing scales Own, based on VHK 5.6, EPTA 5,


yes Probably small impact


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

Prodcom

XXXIII Lasers

83 Lasers Prodcom

none none new yes

XXXIV Energy using equipment used in means of transport

84 Energy using equipment used in means of transport

Car air conditioning, car electronics, lighting

Prodcom; Ecodesign evaluation study

none none new yes Unclear whether in scope (it is not the means of transport itself); might consume considerable amounts of energy, is increasing => alternative to regulate under fuel efficiency regulation?

XXXV Fuels and their additives

85 Fuels and their additives

Diesel, kerosene, gas, biofuels, additives…

Prodcom

none none new yes Affect performance of motors. In scope?

XXXVI Industrial machines and equipment - to be determined

86 (opto)Chemical process equipment

For instance used for etching, vacuum deposition, wafer machines, etc.

VHK Task 2


yes Photo-lithography - probably small energy consumption in the EU. Used for semiconductor and printed circuit board manufacture where most production is outside of the EU.

may be relevant for many industrial installations

87 fluid handling Irrigation equipment, separators, reverse osmosis equipment, spraying equipment

VHK Task 2


yes Includes many types of equipment in several different industry sectors (manufacturing, water treatment, agriculture, etc.)


88 Fluid power: hydraulic equipment

Hydraulic pump, distribution, end-use equipment (cylinders, actuators, power washer, etc.) incl. suction pumps

VHK Task 2


yes A very diverse range; meaningful breakdown might have to be developed



A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

89 Fluid power: pneumatic equipment

Other than compressor: distribution, end-use equipment (spray guns, riveters, drills, sand-blasting) incl. vacuum pumps

VHK Task 2


yes A very diverse range; meaningful breakdown might have to be developed


90 Water and sand cleaning appliances

Water blasting machines, sand blasting machines, steam cleaning

EPTA 40


yes This group consists mainly of standard designs but the market for each type of industrial machine may not be sufficiently large. Need to differentiate from domestic jet washers and steam cleaners which are standard designs sold in relatively large numbers.


91 Industrial process heating equipment, other than ENTR 4

For instance used for distilling, drying, cleaning, sterilizing

VHK Task 2


yes Probably very significant energy consumption even if DG ENTR Lot 4 is excluded. Similar issues as in Lot 4 (very diverse, mostly custom designs, etc.). Improvement potential may not be large though. Includes steam generation for plant and process heating, so quality of thermal insulation important


92 Material processing equipment other than ENTR 5

Equipment that is not covered by the ENTR 5 prep study, because it does not form geometrically defined workpieces into other geometrically defined forms, but deals with amorphous materials E.g.: homogenizing equipment (mixers, grinders, pulverizing, kneaders, etc.) combining equipment (blending) drying equipment for materials spinning, centrifuging, dispersing, spraying, projecting equipment cutting, chopping, shredding etc.

own, from VHK Task 2 and EPTA 50, 57


yes Difficulty is that some are achieved by different processes, e.g. drying can be by heating in ovens, spray drying, freeze drying, evaporators, extrusion, moulding, etc. Q: Should specific sectors such as food, textiles, paper, plastics be excluded and treated individually (as suggested by EPTA and below?)


93 Industrial cleaning of articles

Cleaning of bottles or other containers; textiles, tools / equipment…?

Own, from EPTA


yes To discuss grouping. Many different processes: Cleaning can be hand wiping with a cloth, vapour degreasing, sand

may be relevant for many


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

50, 57 blasting, jet or spray cleaners, immersion in tanks - these can be hot or ambient. Energy consumption may be dependent on the cleaning solvent used - more energy with water-based than with organic solvents. Many different types of equipment are used depending on what is being cleaned, how clean it needs to be, etc. Significant improvement potential may exist, e.g. by switching to a different cleaning method, but a very diverse group and will be difficult to regulate. One issue is that lower energy options may use may hazardous chemicals.

industrial installations

94 Industrial drying of articles (not materials)

Drying of bottles or other containers; textiles, tools / equipment…?

Own, from EPTA 50, 57


yes To discuss grouping. Many different processes: Drying can be in an oven ( Lot 4), vacuum drying, air drying (using a jet of dry air), etc. In scope of IED and ETS when installed in installations that are in scope of these legislation but many will be used in other installations. A diverse group with many custom designs.


95 Paper production equipment, other than ENTR 5

Machinery for making paper pulp, paper or paperboard, Machines for making cartons, boxes, cases, tubes, drums, or similar containers of paper or paperboard, book-binding machines, Cutting machines for paper or paperboard, Machines for making bags, sacks or envelopes of paper or paperboard, Folding machines for books

EPTA 20.


yes Very large energy consumption. Very heterogeneous. Most installations already in scope of IED and some EU ETS. In ENTR 5 study defined as "related machinery". Paper and pulp mills are in scope of the IED and ETS and are very large energy consumers and so there is a large incentive for reducing energy consumption. Other paper equipment (such as envelope, book and magazine manufacture) is a very diverse group with many products being custom designs. Energy consumption of each



A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

type of machine may not be large with only small energy saving potential.

96 Machines and equipment for textile and clothes industry

Machines for extruding, drawing or cutting man-made textile materials, Machines for preparing textile fibres, Textile spinning machines, Textile doubling or twisting machines, Textile winding, Weaving machines (looms) Circular knitting machines, Flat knitting machines, stitch-bonding machines and warp knitting machines, Dry-cleaning machines, Machines for washing, bleaching or dyeing textile yarns, fabrics or made-up textile articles, Industrial automatic sewing machines, Centrifugal clothes-dryers, Carding machines for preparing textile fibres

EPTA 32


yes Very heterogeneous. Excluded from DG ENTR Lot 5 due to nature of material, but defined as "related machinery". Pre-treatment or dying of textile fibres and textiles is in scope of the IED (if >10 tonnes / day). Otherwise, this is a very diverse group of types of equipment.


97 Plastics industry machines, other than ENTR 5

Vacuum-moulding machines, other thermoforming machines for working rubber or plastics, machinery for moulding or retreading pneumatic tyres, other presses for moulding or forming rubber or plastics, Machines for processing reactive resins, Machines for the manufacture of foam products, Mixers, kneaders and agitators, for preparing rubber or plastics, Plastics Cutting, splitting and peeling machines

EPTA 49


yes Need to consider separately from "material processing"? In ENTR 5 study defined as "related machinery". Most will be excluded from the IED as not used in IED installations. This is a very diverse variety of equipment much of which will be custom designed to some extent. Numbers in use in the EU of each type of machine and the total energy consumption may be too small and it would be difficult to regulate all plastic industry machinery.


98 Industrial machines for food manufacture (other than

Bakery machinery, Brewery machinery, Industrial machinery for the preparation of meat or poultry (other than ovens), cream separators, presses and crushers

Own, based on EPTA 17 -


yes May need to consider separately from "material processing" as equipment designs are different"? Not considered in ENTR 5 study . Only the largest installations are in scope of the IED. A

may be relevant for many industrial installation


A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

ovens) for wine, fruit juices and beverages, industrial machines for meat preparation, distilling machines for drinks production

very large variety of food production processes and equipment designs, many of which are custom designs, are used in the EU.

s

99 Packaging equipment

Machinery for filling, closing, sealing, capsuling or labelling machines, Packing or wrapping machines

EPTA 41


yes In ENTR 5 study defined as "related machinery". Some will be in scope of the IED when designed for installations in scope of the IED, however, this will have no effect on energy consumption. Packaging machines are usually custom designs, although individual sub-parts will be standard designs.


100 Industrial equipment for special processes

Distilling or rectifying plant, Machinery and apparatus for filtering or purifying liquids, Producer gas or water gas generators, vacuum-vapour plant for the deposition of metal

EPTA 56.


yes Group seems very heterogeneous. May include spirits, food, pharmaceuticals, petrochem, etc.


101 Printing equipment

Offset printing machinery, letterpress printing equipment, Phototypesetting and composing machines, film printing machines;

EPTA 27.


yes Modern printing equipment is quite diverse, with ink jet, laser, thermal transfer, etc. Printing of packaging, publications probably account for most types of equipment.


102 Large scale electrolysis equipment

For instance used for aluminium production

VHK Task 2


yes Includes large-scale aluminium electrowinning and copper and zinc electrorefining. There are a small number of aluminium refineries in the EU that electrowin aluminium from bauxite using the Hall-Heroult process. Due to the very high energy consumption (30% of production costs), there is already an incentive for energy efficiency. Large scale installations for metal recovery by electrorefining of copper and zinc and aluminium electrowinning are in scope of the IED and ETS



A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

103 Small scale electrolysis equipment

For instance used for electrochemical surface treatment (electro galvanizing, chrome-plating, etc.)

VHK Task 2


yes Used for electrochemical surface treatment (electroplating, electro galvanizing, chrome-plating, etc.). Energy efficiency is process dependent and also depends on good process control (so user dependent). Improvement potential is probably too small, all installations are custom designed and larger installations are in scope of the IED.


104 Industrial sensing and controlling: equipment for measurement / testing

(1) Electronic measurement equipment for physical and chemical properties (weighing/scales (totalisers, constant weight scales, hopper scales, check weighers), Pressure meters, angle meters, light meters, flow meters, temperature meters, humidity meters, liquid meters, liquid analysers, gas meters, gas analysers, Electronic meteorological, hydrological and geophysical instruments, level metres, electronic rangefinders, electronic theodolites and tachymeters "tacheometers", electronic ph and rh meters, optical instruments, sensors, spectrometers (2) Electronic instrumentation for measuring and testing electrical magnitudes: Voltmeters, ampmeters, wattmeters, power analysers, resistance and capacitance meters, electromagnetic waves meters, oscillographs, electric gain meters, etc.

VHK Task 2, EPTA 12, 19, 46


yes Very large variety with many different functions. Fairly small numbers of each type and energy consumption of each type small.



A

Level I No.

B

Level II No.

C

Product group name

D

Examples

E

Source

F

Final rank

G

Energy rank

H

Status

I


J

Comments

K

Systems Persp

(3) testing equipment

105 Industrial sensing and controlling: process control components

Control panels, switchboards, powered valves, dosing systems (solenoids, magnetic couplings, etc.)

VHK Task 2


yes Affects energy consumption of industrial process, very significantly. Design usually process dependent. Energy consumption of controllers may not be large.


106 Industrial sensing and controlling: process diagnostic equipment

For instance X-ray equipment used for e.g. weld checking

VHK Task 2


yes A very diverse group. Most types will have relatively small energy consumption and most instruments will have fairly low energy consumption.


107 Mining / tunelling machinery

Coal or rock cutters, boring or sinking machinery, oil and gas platforms

Prodcom

none none new yes Probably only a very small number on the market


108 Industrial robots

Prodcom

none none new yes Very heterogeneous and special. Check applicability of ENTR Lot 5.



4.4 Annex 2.C – Comparison of product groups in Working Plan studies I and II

Dark, medium, light green: First, second, third priority in Second Working Plan study

Dark, medium, light yellow: Priority A, B, none in First Working Plan study

2nd

WP priority list (VHK Task 4 report,

Table 8, p.36)

2nd

WP Task 2 name (VHK Task 1&2 report, Table 2.5.2, p.

Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)

Examples (EPTA report Annex 13)

Working

Plan

Lots Regulated Remaining

Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank

Product group name and number

EuP group (3

rd level)

Examples (source: Task 3 report, if not available: Table 2.5.2)

Rank Product group name and number

1 2 4.20 Taps and showerheads

equipment for heated water applications

showerheads and taps (indirect ErP)water purification/filtering equipment (anti-legionella) district heating water heating equipment

WP 2 JRC Taps and showers

not yet none

2 3 4.12 Window products for buildings

Task 3 report, chapter 4.12:

"assembled products consisting of at least the window glazing and the window frame to hold this glazing. Other elements contributing to the energy performance of windows (for example solar shading systems) may form part of the window.". Possibility to add other parts of "fenestration systems" such as doors or roof windows to be discussed.

WP 2 ENER 1/03 Window products

not yet none

3 6 4.9 Positive displacement pumps

positive displacement pumps

both reciprocating and rotary (for industrial processes and also hydraulic applications)

WP 2 (cond.)

ENER 29 Clean water pumps (larger than under Lot 11)

not yet 4.9 Positive displacement pumps remaining in entirety (not covered by ENER 29)

4 7 4.35 Fractional horsepow


"electric motors with a rated power input below 1 horsepower (equals

23 54. Other motors or motor

Large Motors >150KW, small pumps (<0,75KW),

WP 2 (cond.)

ENER 30 Motors and drives

not yet From WP2: Fractional HP Motors under 200


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



er motors (below 200 W, broad range of household and tertiary applications)

roughly 750 W). The DG ENER Lot 30 Preparatory Study (...) is required to cover part of the FHM, namely those of a power input above 200W (...). Therefore the (...) scope (...) should be limited to such motors below 200 W."

driven equipment not covered by existing lots and the above categories

small motors (<0,75KW), DC motors, Petrol and oil dispensing pumps

(outside scope of Regulation 640/2009) (products over 200 W)

W

From WP1 maybe some types of motors and pumps

5 8 4.36 Power cables

small scale power distribution

power cables (low-voltage, for local distribution - within buildings)

WP 2 ENTR 8 Power Cables in Indoor Electrical Installations

not yet Prep study focuses on applications in industry and service sector, as losses in domestic sector are small

6 11 4.19 Servers and data storage equipment

(data / communication) professional end-use equipment

TV-A/V equipment (AV studio, camera's, equipment for PA/public address) ICT equipment (blade servers, data storage, i/o, phone, local area network equipment) financial transactions equipment (cashiers, ticketing, ATMs)

1 34. In-house networking (LAN) and data processing, storing and providing equipment

Central storage units, Server, data storage, racks, large server, mainframe, IT Servers and Data distribution and storage centres, Thin clients

In-house networking: WP 1, Enterprise servers: WP2

ENTR 9 Enterprise servers ENER 26 Networked standby ENER 27 Uninterruptible Power Supplies

ENTR 6: Draft ENTR 9 not yet ENER 26: Reg. 801/2013 ENER 27: not yet

Possibly remaining from WP 2: 1) TV-A/V equipment;

28 39a. End equipment for data use and communication with option of net connection

Telephone answering machines, Telephone sets, Videophones, Portable receivers for calling or paging, gps based

2) Phone / LAN equipment: see 4.34 Mobile phones.


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



navigation aids,mobile phones, satellite phones, Facsimile machines, palm tops

7 9 4.24 Steam boilers / systems

steam boilers steam/vapour boilers

(for chemical, paper, food production industry, etc.)

33 30. Boilers Watertube boilers, Firetube boilers, Vapour generating boilers, Superheated water boilers, Heat exchange units

WP 2 ENTR 7 Steam Boilers

not yet Heat exchange units?

8 5 4.31 Heating controls

indoor climate equipment

for instance used for humidification, dehumidification, filtration, ionisation heating emitters, heating control equipment, district heating space heating/cooling equipment, see also 5.1, 5.2 and 5.5 Task 3 report, chapter 4.31:

heating controls: thermostats, timers, thermostatic radiator valves, zone controllers, weather compensators, automatic balancing devices and occupancy detection devices Heating control systems: an interconnected set of control products installed in a building to manage energy using appliances, distribution systems and where appropriate emitters and heat exchangers in relation to the building and occupants needs so

WP 2 4.31 Heating controls in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



that energy use and carbon emissions are minimised (e.g. thermostat AND valve).

9 4 4.32 Lighting Controls (tertiary and public street lighting)


"product systems for control of tertiary and public street lighting. (...) The options applied by such lighting control (systems) are daylight linking, presence detection, time management and constant luminance level control system."

25 42. Lighting installations not covered by existing lots

Retail Lighting, Industrial Lighting, Emergency lighting, Traffic signs and road signalisation products, Tunnel lighting, Lighting products for city beautification, Private outdoor lighting, lighting control system components not integrated into a luminary, Non-task area lighting in office buildings (corridors, toilets, reception areas etc.), Ballasts, Electrical signalling for safety or traffic control equipment (see also 4.29 and Commercial lighting (without number))

Lighting controls: WP 2

ENER 8 Office Lighting ENER 9 Street Lighting

Reg. 245/2009, Amendm. 347/2010

4.32 lighting controls remaining in entirety (not covered by ENER 8 and 9)

Possibly some lighting products from WP 1, e.g. tunnel lighting, private outdoor lighting, non-task-area lighting.... See also groups 4.29 Traffic lighting, and "Commercial lighting" (without number).

10 12 4.27 Elevators, escalators etc.

person transport (tertiary sector;

person transport (elevators, escalators, moving walkways, telerefics, etc.)

20 16. Lifting, moving, and loading equipment

Elevators, escalators, moving walkways, conveyors,

4.27 Elevators, escalators… remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



building control access and transport)

Teleferics, ski-draglines; chairlifts, cranes, Pulley tackle, Lifts, hoists, winches, capstans, built-in jacking systems, fork-lift, Loaders, Rolling-mill machinery.

Logistic equipment (secondary sector)

various moving equipment (ride-on, hand-guided or towed) for internal and external transport purposes. Examples are: forklifts, mobile platforms, platform truck, airport people carrier, electric pallet jack, telescopic handler, etc. Note: This product group could also contain products from the tertiary sector, used for road/floorcleaning etc.

11 14 4.33 Medical equipment

medical equipment: therapeutic &support equipment

for instance various equipment for life support, patient monitoring, therapeutic applications, etc.

5 25. Surgical, patient recovery and healing equipment

Ultraviolet or infra-red ray medical, medical drill engines, diathermic apparatus, lithotripsy instruments, Apparatus for nerve stimulation, electric surgical knifes, laser surgical apparatus, Electrical vibratory-massage apparatus, Mechano-therapy appliances, massage apparatus, psychological aptitude-testing

SRI covers Computed Tomography (CT), Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), Nuclear Medicine, Ultrasound and X-Ray Imaging equipment. Other diagnostic and treatment apparatus mentioned under WP1, PG 24,25 and 26 remain.


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



apparatus, Ozone therapy, oxygen therapy, aerosol therapy, respiration apparatus, Breathing appliances, Medical, surgical or laboratory sterilisers.

medical equipment: diagnostic imaging equipment

for instance MRI, CT scan, X-ray and/or ultrasound equipment

10 24. Electrodiagnostic apparatus

Electro-cardiographs, Ultrasonic scanning apparatus, Scintigraphic apparatus, Electro-diagnostic monitoring apparatus for simultaneous monitoring of two or more physiological parameters, electro-diagnostic apparatus for brain functions, Electric Blood pressure meters

ENTR Medical Imaging Equipment

Draft SRI

24 26. High energy diagnostic and healing equipment

X-Ray machines, X-Ray Tomography, Magnetic Tomography,


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



Gamma Cameras,

12 15 4.7 Blowers

blower (pressure ratio > 1.1)

as applied in various household and tertiary equipment / appliances

4.7 Blowers remaining in entirety

13 17 4.22 Electric kettles / water cookers


includes classical water cookers and "installed" versions with hot water storage at up to 100 degrees

4.22 Kettles / water cookers remaining in entirety

14 21 4.6 Small fans (< 125 W)

small fans (< 125 W)

as applied in various household and tertiary equipment / appliancesTask 3 report, chapter 4.22: Often included in other

appliances such as PCs, cars, hairdryers; but also for ventilation e.g. in tertiary sector

ENER 10 Residential ventilation and comfort fansENER 11 Fans

ENER 10: Reg. 206/2012ENER 11: Reg. 327/2011

4.6 PG 4.6 Small fans probably remaining. PG covers fans that are below 125 W and therefore excluded from 327/2011, but not for residential ventilation either and therefore excluded from 206/2012. Study suggests to take them up in review of 327/2011

15 22 4.8 High temperature fans

special purpose ventilation

for high temperature, safety, smoke extraction, etc. Task 3 report, chapter 4.8:

Above 125 W, e.g. for tunnel ventilation, mine shafts, industrial ovens, parking buildings, exhaust gases

31 52. Ventilation equipment for underground infrastructures and special

Combustion Fans for Power Stations and Boilers, Fans for material transportation, Mines Ventilation, Transportation Tunnels Ventilation (subways,

4.8 High temperature fans remaining in entirety Some fan types from WP1 may be remaining (material transportation?)


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



processes underground motor ways, underground railways), Process Cooling fans, Process Heating fans

none 53. Motors and motor driven equipment for traction and transportation applications

Electric Motors used for traction and transportation applications, Fans in ventilation systems used in transportations, Motor Driven Equipment for traction and transportation

ENER 30 Motors and drives (outside scope of Regulation 640/2009) (products over 200 W)

not yet Motors / motor equipment remaining; for fans see above

16 23 4.23 Point-of-sale / ATM equipment

(data / communication) professional end-use equipment (see also 4.19)

TV-A/V equipment (AV studio, camera's, equipment for PA/public address) ICT equipment (blade servers, data storage, i/o, phone, local area network equipment) financial transactions equipment (cashiers, ticketing, ATMs) (see also 4.19)

21 48. Cashiers and ticketing machines

Cash registers, Postage-franking machines, ticket-issuing machines, ATM and Automated Bank Machines

4.23 Point of sale / ATM equipment remaining in entirety. For ICT equipment see 4.19, servers; for phone equipment 4.34 Mobile Phones.

17 25 4.13 Clothes ironing products

personal care

personal care (hair dryers, waterbed, motorised mattress support, massage, sauna, personal weighing scale, clothes ironing products) for both domestic and tertiary applications (see also 4.26 and 5.6)

7 7. Domestic equipment for clothes caring and others

Electric steam irons, household ironing machines, household sewing machines.

4.13 Clothes ironing from WP 2 remaining in entirety

Some PG from WP 1, e.g. ironing machines, sewing machines


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



18 27 4.28 Non-domestic hot beverage equipment

food/drink preparation equipment

kitchen appliances (mixers, juicers, blenders for both domestic or professional use), coffee/tea makers (nondomestic only), see also 4.16

26 17. Food and drink production equipment

Commercial cooking equipment, commercial coffee and tea machines, Bakery machinery, Brewery machinery, Industrial machinery for the preparation of meat or poultry, cream separators, presses and crushers for wine, fruit juices and beverages, industrial machines for meat preparation, distilling machines for drinks production, non domestic hobs

ENER 25 Non-tertiary coffee machines

Reg. 801/2013

4.28 Non-domestic coffee machines remaining in entirety (Reg 801/2013 covering only domestic ones)

All other commercial food production equipment from WP 1 PG 17 remaining

19 28 4.29 Traffic lights

safety and signaling lighting equipment

lighting for emergency/safety lighting, traffic signalling,) daylight systems


Retail Lighting, Industrial Lighting, Emergency lighting, Traffic signs and road signalisation products, Tunnel lighting, Lighting products for city beautification, Private outdoor

ENER 9 Street Lighting

Reg. 245/2009, Amendm. 347/2010

4.29 Traffic lights remaining in entirety (not covered by ENER 9)

Possibly some lighting products from WP 1, e.g. tunnel lighting, private outdoor lighting, non-task-


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



lighting, lighting control system components not integrated into a luminary, Non-task area lighting in office buildings (corridors, toilets, reception areas etc.), Ballasts, Electrical signalling for safety or traffic control equipment (see also 4.32 and Commercial lighting (without number))

area lighting.... See also groups 4.32 Lighting Controls, and "Commercial lighting" (without number).

20 29 4.21 Toilets

equipment for cold water applications

toilets, taps, water dispensing equipment (horticultural products, cleaning products), water purification/filtering

none (COM addition) Water-using equipment

WP1 4.21 Toilets remaining in entirety; plus possibly some other cold water-using appliances from WP 1

21 1 4.11 Thermal insulation products for buildings


"factory made products in the form of rolls, batts, boards or slabs, with or without facings, or 'in situ' applied materials, which are used for the thermal insulation of buildings. (...) may also be used in prefabricated thermal insulation systems and composite panels. Excluded (...) are building materials (or components) of which

ENER 36 Thermal insulation in buildings

No and will not (following the short study completed)

4.11 Thermal insulation remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



the material (...) provides other primary functions such as providing structural integrity (such as lightweight concrete, certain gypsum building blocks, and even straw bale construction). Also excluded (...) are thermal insulation products intended to be used for the insulation of equipment and industrial installations.

22 10 4.14 Detergents

cleaning / hygienic equipment

floor cleaning equipment (floor washing / mopping) professional mobile (self-propelled) cleaning/service products: cleaning trucks, sweepers, snow graders, etc.

4.14 Detergents remaining in entirety

23 13 4.30 Logistic systems

logistic equipment

(intra)logistic systems (address single materials handling product and complete turnkey systems. It focuses on automation, control and IT, and integration of several types of materials handling equipment into one system)various moving equipment (ride-on, hand-guided or towed) for internal and external transport purposes. Examples are: forklifts, mobile platforms, platform truck, airport people carrier, electric pallet jack,telescopic handler, etc. Note: This product group could also contain products from the tertiary sector, used for road/floor cleaning etc.

4.30 Logistic systems remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



24 19 4.18 Base station subsystems

distribution of data/communication

ICT transmission/distribution equipment (landlines and wireless) - for TV, radio, internet, phone, data (e.g. base stations)

11 35. Network equipment for all types of data process-sing (data, telecommunication, internet, and radio network equipment)

base station for mobile net creation, hubs, routers, networking equipment, modems

WP 1 ENER 26 Networked standby

Reg. 801/2013

4.18 Base station subsystems remaining in entirety

19 36. Aerials, antennaes, radars, radio navigation and control items

Radar apparatus, Radio navigational aid apparatus, Radio remote control apparatus, Base stations and antennas for telecommunications, antennas – aerials

25 24 4.34 Mobile phones


Classical phones and smartphones. Other portable electronic devices that are not continuously connected to a network (PDA, gaming devices, portable media players, navis…) excluded.

28 39a. End equipment for data use and communication with option of net connection

Telephone answering machines, Telephone sets, Videophones, Portable receivers for calling or paging, GPS based navigation aids, mobile phones, satellite phones,

4.34 Mobile phones remaining in entirety

other phone / LAN equipment remaining (see also 4.18 base station subsystems)


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



Facsimile machines, palm tops

26 32 4.15 Home audio/video equipment

(data / communication) domestic end-use equipment

consumer electronics (mostly limited to audio/video products and portable electronics not already dealt with by Ecodesign process)

13 28. Sound and image processing machines and equipment

Video player/recorders, Transmission apparatus for radiobroadcasting or television, Television cameras, Digital cameras , Video camera recorders, slides projectors, Microfilm, microfiche or other microform readers, Photographic enlargers and reducers

WP 1 ENTR 3 Sound and imaging equipment

ENTR 3: not yet

Most PGs from WP 1, as the study only covers video players / recorders, video projectors, and video games consoles.

22 29. Sound processing machines and equipment (including radio equipment)

Microphones, Loudspeakers, Headphones and earphones, Electric amplifiers, Jukeboxes, CD players, Sound recording or sound reproducing apparatus, Radio receivers

WP 1

27 16 4.4 Stationary agricultural

stationary agricultural equipment

various stationary equipment used in agricultural, horticultural and forestry applications (excluding equipment already dealt with by

none 44. Agricultural and farming machines

Milking machines, homogenisers, irradiators, butter-making machines,

4.4 stationary agricultural equipment remaining in


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



equipment Ecodesign policy process), for instance poultry incubators/brooders, milking robots, etc.

and equipment

cheese-making machines, Animal feeding stuffs, Poultry incubators and brooders, haymaking machinery, straw and fodder balers, Harvesting machines, harrows, Scarifiers and cultivators, Rotovators, Weeders and hoes, Planters and transplanters, Distributors for mineral or chemical fertiliser for soil preparation, Manure spreaders and fertiliser distributors (excluding for mineral or chemical fertilisers), Haymaking machinery, Straw or fodder balers, Potato-diggers and potato harvesters, Grape harvesters, Forestry machinery, Automatic drinking

entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



troughs for farm animals, see also 4.1

28 18 4.1 Mobile agricultural machinery

mobile agricultural machinery

various mobile equipment for soil cultivation (plough, tiller, rotovator, cultivator, etc.), planting (seeder, etc.), fertilizing & pest control, harvesting / post-harvest, hay making, loading , etc. (includes mobile machinery for horticultural and forestry)

none 44. Agricultural and farming machines and equipment

Milking machines, homogenisers, irradiators, butter-making machines, cheese-making machines, Animal feeding stuffs, Poultry incubators and brooders, haymaking machinery, straw and fodder balers, Harvesting machines, harrows, Scarifiers and cultivators, Rotovators, Weeders and hoes, Planters and transplanters, Distributors for mineral or chemical fertiliser for soil preparation, Manure spreaders and fertiliser distributors (excluding for mineral or chemical fertilisers), Haymaking machinery, Straw

4.1 mobile agricultural equipment remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



or fodder balers, Potato-diggers and potato harvesters, Grape harvesters, Forestry machinery, Automatic drinking troughs for farm animals, see also 4.4

29 20 4.2 Mobile construction machinery

mobile construction equipment

various moving equipment for mining & quarrying (dozers, crawlers), building construction (dozers, scrapers, cranes), road construction (excavators, road rollers, etc.), tunnel construction (tunnel boring machinery), bridges, dams & canal construction etc.

none 45. Building public works equipment

Crawler dozers, Wheeled dozers, Motor graders and levellers, Motor scrapers, Loaders, bulldozers, excavators, Pile-drivers and pile-extractors, coal or rock cutters and tunnelling machinery, crushing, grinding, mixing, kneading machines, machines for mixing mineral substances, Concrete mixers, see also 4.5

4.2 Mobile construction machinery remaining in entirety

30 26 4.10 Mobile power generators

small scale electric power generation (<50 MW)

fossil fuel installations: CHP equipment and power generating sets renewable energy installations: wind turbines, photovoltaic-,

34 31. Generating sets using fossil fuels

Diesel generators, gasoline generators, gas-fired generators

ENER 35 Power generation equipment <50 MW

No and will not following the short study

4.10 Mobile power generators remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



hydropower-, geothermal-, waste-heat driven installations (e.g. Organic Rankine Cycles)

completed

31 30 4.17 Lawn and riding mowers


includes mowers pushed by a human, self-propelled, and pulled behind a tractor, both electric and with internal combustion engine.

32 43. Mowers Lawn mowers, mowers for parks, mowers for grounds, mowers with a seat, turners, side delivery rakes, tedders

4.17 Lawn and riding mowers remaining in entirety; some additional PGs from WP1 (tedders, side delivery rakes)

32 31 4.3 Handheld power tools

handheld tools

various handheld / portable motor tools for professional and DIY use (lawn blowers, hand tools, etc.)Task 3 report, chapter 4.3:"...used for (but not limited to)

(...) construction, agricultural, horticultural, industrial anddomestic context. Examples (...) are demolition jack hammers, electric power tools (e.g. in construction and building / DIY), chainsaws (...) and hedge trimmers, cutters (...) leaf or lawn blowers." Both electric and with internal combustion engine.

17 9. Electromechanical hand tools

Drills, saws, grinders, angle grinders, sanders, planers, chainsaws, hedge trimmers, lawn edge cutters

4.3 Handheld power tools remaining in entirety

33 33 4.5 Stationary construction equipment

stationary construction equipment

various stationary equipment used in construction applications, including mining and quarrying. (excluding equipment already dealt with by Ecodesign policy process)

none 45. Building public works equipment

Crawler dozers, Wheeled dozers, Motor graders and levellers, Motor scrapers, Loaders, bulldozers, excavators, Pile-drivers and pile-extractors, coal or

4.5 Stationary construction equipment remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



rock cutters and tunnelling machinery, crushing, grinding, mixing, kneading machines, machines for mixing mineral substances, Concrete mixers, see also 4.2

34 2 4.16 Kitchen appliances

food/drink preparation equipment

kitchen appliances (mixers, juicers, blenders for both domestic or professional use), coffee/tea makers (nondomestic only), see also 4.28

14 6. Domestic food preparing equipment

Domestic electric ovens and hobs, mixers, microwave ovens, fruit grinders, toasters, electric grills, domestic coffee machines.

WP 1 ENER 25 Non-tertiary coffee machines

ENER 25: Reg. 801/2013

Domestic coffee machines only networked standby

ENER 22 Domestic and commercial ovens ENER 23 Domestic and commercial hobs and grills

ENER 22, 23: Reg 66/2014

domestic use: only ovens regulated; small kitchen tools still unregulated,


Commercial cooking equipment, commercial coffee and tea machines, Bakery machinery, Brewery machinery,

All commercial food production equipment from WP 1 PG 17 remaining


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



Industrial machinery for the preparation of meat or poultry, cream separators, presses and crushers for wine fruit juices and beverages, industrial machines for meat preparation, distilling machines for drinks production, non domestic hobs

35 35 4.25 Hot tub / Spa / Whirlpool

indoor leisure equipment

music instruments, toys, animated displays, aquarium, sewing machines, hot tubs/whirlpools, sauna's for both domestic and professional applications, see also 4.26

see 4.26 see 4.26 4.25 Hot tub / spa / whirlpool remaining in entirety

36 36 4.26 Sauna's

indoor leisure equipment

music instruments, toys, animated displays, aquarium, sewing machines, hot tubs/whirlpools, sauna's for both domestic and professional applications, see also 4.25 and WP 1: 7,21,22

none 21. Music instruments

Electric guitars, digital pianos, electric violins, electric bass guitars, electronic keyboards.

4.26 Saunas remaining in entirety

none 22. Electric toys

Electric trains, electric cars, electric dolls, game

Many PGs from the areas "indoor leisure equipment"


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



consoles, portable game consoles, electric robots.

and "personal care" remaining, including products from groups 5,7,21,22 and 55 of WP1



personal care

personal care (hair dryers, waterbed, motorised mattress support, massage, sauna, personal weighing scale, clothes ironing products) for both domestic and tertiary applications (see also 4.13 and 5.6) and WP1: 5 and 7

30 5. Machines for personal care

Household weighing machines, electric shavers, electric hair drying machines



none 55. Water beds and swimming pools

Water Beds, Swimming Pools, see also 5.6

none

none 5.1 Air filters


for instance used for humidification, dehumidification, filtration, ionisation heating emitters, heating control equipment district heating space heating/cooling equipment, see also 4.31, 5.2, 5.3 and 5.5

4 13. Electric and fossil fuels heating equipment

Electric water heaters, Electric storage heating radiators, Liquid filled electric radiators and Electric heaters for space heating and soil-heating, for space-heating and soil-heating,

ENER 15 Solid fuel boilers ENER 20 Local room heaters ENER 21 Central heating products using hot air

ENER 20: Draft ENER 21: Not yet

5.1 air filters remaining in entirety. Heating controls covered in 4.31. For other heating products see PG 13 of WP1. For other products from indoor climate equipment


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



Electric heating resistors, Gas-and oil fired dry space heating systems, local heating - gas fires, electric 'fires', electric night store heaters, patio heaters, hot air distribution systems

to distribute heat

see 5.2, 5.3 and 5.5

none

none 5.2 Ducts and duct systems



5.2 ducts remaining in entirety. Heating controls covered in 4.31. For other heating products see PG 13 of WP1. For other products from indoor climate equipment see 5.1, 5.3 and 5.5

none

none 5.3 Humidifiers (tertiary)


for instance used for humidification, dehumidification, filtration, ionisation heating emitters, heating control equipmentdistrict heating space heating/cooling equipment, see also 4.31, 5.1, 5.2 and 5.5

5.3 humidifiers remaining in entirety. Heating controls covered in 4.31. For other heating products see PG 13 of WP1.For other products from indoor climate equipment see


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



5.1, 5.2 and 5.5

none

none 5.4 Swimming pool equipment

outdoor leisure equipment

stationary equipment such as swimming pools (including indoor pools), amusement parks, playground equipment, etc. mobile (outdoor) equipment/machinery, such as snowmobiles, quads, etc. (not belonging to group 'transport' which is excluded from scope)



ENER 29 Clean water pumps (larger than those under Lot 11)

not yet 5.4 some water heating and cleaning equipment for swimming pools, special applications such as whirlpools, massage jets?,

broader group "Outdoor leisure equipment" remaining in entirety

none

none 5.5 Solar shading devices



5.5 Solar shading remaining in entirety. Heating controls covered in 4.31. For other heating products see PG 13 of WP1. For other products from indoor climate equipment see 5.1, 5.2 and 5.3

none

none 5.6 Personal care

personal care

personal care (hair dryers, waterbed, motorised mattress support, massage, sauna, personal weighing scale, clothes ironing products) for both domestic and tertiary applications (see also 4.13

30 5. Machines for personal care

Household weighing machines, electric shavers, electric hair drying machines

Many PGs from the area "personal care" remaining, including products from groups 5,7,


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



and 4.26) 7 7. Domestic equipment for clothes caring and others


and 55 of WP1



none

none 5.7 Commercial kitchen equipment


fryers, hot food holding cabinets, steam cookers


Commercial cooking equipment, commercial coffee and tea machines, Bakery machinery, Brewery machinery, Industrial machinery for the preparation of meat or poultry, cream separators, presses and crushers for wine, fruit juices and beverages, industrial machines for meat preparation, distilling machines for drinks production, non domestic hobs

ENER 22 Domestic and commercial ovens ENER 23 Domestic and commercial hobs and grills

Reg. 66/2014

Specific equipment (apart from ovens and hobs), such as fryers, steam cookers remaining. See also 4.28 and 4.16

none

none 5.8 Low-voltage

power handling

non-utility power equipment (converters, inverters,

2 1. Transformer

Distribution transformers,

WP 1 ENTR 2 Distribution

Draft none


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



switchgear and control gear

equipment transformers) s power transformers and Power Transformers

12 10. Power electronics products (inverters, static converters, inductors, soft starters)

Uninterruptible power supplies (UPS), Inverters, static converters, rotary converters, rectifiers, a.c. converters, accumulator chargers, inductors, soft starters, power supply units, internal power supplies, EPS/BC, chargers for industrial applications, chargers telecommunication network equipment, battery chargers for vehicles

ENER 7 Battery chargers and external power supplies ENER 27 Uninterruptible power supplies (UPS)

ENER 7: Reg. 278/2009 ENER 27: not yet

Everything but UPS and EPS (ENER 7 does not yet cover battery chargers)

none 38. Panels for controlling operating electric power distribution

Programmable memory controllers, Boards and electric control cabinets, electric panels and switchboards, Numerical control panels

WP 1 PG 38 Control panels remaining in entirety


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



none

none tooling equipment

includes laser-cutting, electrode shaping, water-jet cutting

3 4. Tool machines (manufacturing - industrial use)

Horizontal lathes, vertical lathes, milling machines, grinding machines, bending machines, straightening machines, folding machines, flattening machines, cutting machines, drilling machines.

WP 1 ENTR 5 Machine tools

Draft SRI ENTR covers any machinery that changes the geometric shape of a workpiece to a defined new shape (forming, cutting, and joining). It expands on wood working, metal working, and joining technology. Excluded are machines for primary shaping, surface treatment, shredding, machines for manufacturing / treating textiles, food, or material from animal or human origin, as well as tools portable by hand. Draft SRI not completely specific with respect to type of equipment covered.

none

none material processing

homogenizing equipment (mixers, grinders, pulverizing, kneaders,

none 57. Calendering

Calendering or other rolling

ENTR 5 Machine

Draft SRI Probably some groups not


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



equipment etc.)combining equipment (rolling, laminating, calendering)bonding equipment (gluing, fastening, ultrasonic welding, stitching, sewing)mechanical drying equipment: spinning, centrifugingdispersing, spraying, projecting equipment

, rolling machines, centrifuges and other special machines

machines, machines with individual functions, rope or cable-making machines, industrial robots for multiple uses, machines and apparatus for electroplating; electrolysis or electrophoresis, machines for balancing mechanical parts, machinery for cleaning or drying bottles or other containers, laboratory centrifuges, non-domestic dish-washing machines

tools covered by ENTR 5

none

none fluid handling

irrigation equipment, separators, reverse osmosis equipment, spraying equipment

Fluid handling remaining

none

none fluid power: pneumatic equipment

compressor, distribution, end-use equipment (spray guns, riveters, drills sand-blasting) incl. vacuum pumps

none 40. Water steam and sand cleaning appliances

water blasting machines, sand blasting machines, steam cleaning machines, see also: fluid power hydraulic

some pumps: ENER 29

not yet Pneumatic equipment remaining

non none fluid power: hydraulic pump, distribution, end- none 40. Water water blasting some not yet Hydraulic


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



e hydraulic equipment

use equipment (cylinders, actuators, power washer, etc.) incl. suction pumps

steam and sand cleaning appliances

machines, sand blasting machines, steam cleaning machines, see also: fluid power pneumatic

pumps: ENER 29

equipment remaining

none

none medium/large electric power generation and storage

power generation and storage >50 MW (fossil, nuclear, hydro and renewable fuels, separate or combined)

Medium / large scale power generation and storage remaining

none

none medium large electric power transport / distribution

cables for electric power transport and distribution (high to medium voltage, not low voltage applications)

Medium / large scale power generation and storage remaining

none

none small scale electric power storage (< 50 MW)

batteries, chemical accumulators, flywheels for UPS

Small scale storage remaining

none

none large scale electrolysis equipment

for instance used for aluminium production

Large scale electrolysis remaining

none

none small scale electrolysis equipment

for instance used for electrochemical surface treatment (electro galvanizing, chrome-plating, etc.)

Small scale electrolysis remaining

none

none (Opto)chemical process equipment

for instance used for etching, vacuum deposition, wafer machines, etc.

Opto-chemical equipment remaining

none

none industrial process

for instance used for distilling, drying, cleaning, sterilizing

Industrial process heating remaining


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



heat: process heating equipment

none

none industrial process heat: radiation process equipment

for instance used for UV curing systems, cleaning by heat treatment heat recovery

Radiation process equipment remaining

none

none industrial process heat: thermal joining process equipment

for instance used for welding (gas arc, ultrasonic, IR, induction, laser, etc.)) for instance used for soldering, brazing

6 18. Industrial and laboratory furnaces and ovens

Infra-red radiation ovens, resistance heated industrial and laboratory furnaces and ovens, electrical induction industrial or laboratory furnaces and ovens, Furnaces and ovens functioning by dielectric loss, furnace burners for solid, liquid or gaseous fuels, furnaces and ovens for heat-treatment of surfaces or materials, furnaces and ovens for the incineration of rubbish

WP 1 ENTR 4 Industrial and laboratory furnaces and ovens ENTR 5 Machine tools

ENTR 4: not yet ENTR 5: Draft SRI

Should be mostly covered by ENTR 4 and 5. ENTR 5 covers any machinery that changes the geometric shape of a workpiece to a defined new shape (forming, cutting, and joining technologies). Excluded are machines for primary shaping, surface treatment, shredding, machines for manufacturing / treating textiles, food, or material from animal or human origin, as well as tools 9 3. Welding machines


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



Automatic and welding machines

for metals, for plastic or rubber. Automatic or semi automatic welding machines.

portable by hand. It expands on wood working, metal working, and joining technology (including welding). Draft SRI not completely specific with respect to type of equipment covered.

none

none Industrial (de)humidification equipment

various equipment for climate of process conditions: process humidification (clean rooms, paper mill, wood processing) and dehumidification

Industrial dehumidification remaining

none

none industrial sensing and controlling: process control components

control panels, switchboards, powered valves, dosing systems (solenoids, magnetic couplings, etc.)

Industrial process control remaining

none

none industrial sensing and controlling: equipment for measurement / testing

measurement equipment for physical and chemical properties (weighing/scales, power meters, flow meters, clocks/timers) and testing equipment - includes utility meters, parking meters

none 12. Weighing machines and equipment

Scales, totalisers, constant weight scales, hopper scales, check weighers.

Industrial measurement equipment remaining

none 19. Electronic instrumentation for

Voltmeters, ammeters, wattmeters, power analysers,


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



measuring and testing electrical magnitudes

resistance and capacitance meters, electromagnetic waves meters, oscillographs, electric gain meters, etc.

none 19. Electronic instrumentation for measuring and testing electrical magnitudes

Pressure meters, angle meters, light meters, flow meters, temperature meters, humidity meters, liquid meters, liquidanalysers, gas meters, gas analysers, Electronic meteorological, hydrological and geophysical instruments,level metres, electronic rangefinders, electronic theodolites and tachymeters "tacheometers", electronic pH and rH meters, optical instruments, sensors, spectrometers


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



none

none industrial sensing and controlling: process diagnostic equipment

for instance X-ray equipment used for e.g. weld checking

Industrial process diagnostic remaining

none

none commercial lighting equipment

illuminated displays, signs, electronic labels, decorative/festivity lighting (e.g. X-mas lighting etc.)


Retail Lighting, Industrial Lighting, Emergency lighting, Traffic signs and road signalisation products, Tunnel lighting, Lighting products for city beautification, Private outdoor lighting, lighting control system components not integrated into a luminary, Non-task area lighting in office buildings (corridors, toilets, reception areas etc.), Ballasts, Electrical signalling for safety or traffic control equipment (see also 4.29, 4.32)

ENER 8 Office Lighting ENER 9 Street Lighting

Reg. 245/2009, Amendm. 347/2010

Commercial lighting remaining. See also groups 4.29 Traffic lighting, and 4.32 Lighting controls (without number).

none

none building control & access

automatic doors, burglar alarms, fire/smoke alarms, thermostats, sensors, building automation

none 37. Signalling and alarm

burglar alarms, fire alarms, Indicator panels, Electric

Building control and access remaining in


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



systems equipment sound or visual signalling apparatus, Signal generators

entirety

none

none food presentation and storage equipment

heated displays/service cabinets, catering equipment

Food presentation and storage remaining

none

none (data / communication equipment) other radio wave transmission / positioning

other radio wave equipment (radar/radio) for positioning, navigation, etc.

Radio wave transmission equipment remaining

4 13. Electric and fossil fuels heating equipment

Electric water heaters, Electric storage heating radiators, Liquid filled electric radiators and Electric heaters for space heating and soil-heating, Electric heating resistors, Gas-and oil fired dry space heating systems, local heating - gas fires, electric 'fires', electric night store heaters, patio

WP 1 ENER 2 Water heaters ENER 15 Solid fuel boilers ENER 20 Local room heaters ENER 21 Central heating products using hot air to distribute heat

ENER 2: Reg. 814/2013 ENER 15: Draft ENER 20: Draft ENER 21: not yet

Maybe certain heating equipment missing (district heating, ionisation heaters)


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



heaters, hot air distribution systems

8 11. Compressors

Compressors, Air Compressors

ENER 31 Compressors

not yet None

15 15. Refrigerating equipment

Compressors for refrigerating equipment, freezing equipment, evaporators, condensers, Chillers, ice makers, walk in cold rooms, 'refrigerated service cabinets'.

WP 1 ENTR 1 Refrigerating and freezing equipment

not yet None

16 14. Air condition systems and heat pumps

Air conditioning machines with refrigeration unit, Heat pumps, Cooling towers, Larger (non Lot 10) Packaged Air Conditioners, Water cooled air conditioning, Air conditioning for IT rooms, Air Handling Units, Ventilation packages for collective housing and small tertiary,

WP 1 ENER 1 Boilers and combi-boilers ENER 10 Residential room air conditioning appliances ENER 11 Fans ENTR 6 Air-conditioning and ventilation systems (two

ENER1: Reg. 813/2013 ENER 10: Reg. 206/2012 ENER 11: Reg. 327/2011 ENTR 6: Draft

Probably none. ENER 1 deals with heat pumps. ENER 10 with residential air conditioning < 12 kW and residential fans below 125 W. ENER 11 deals with industrial fans above 125 W. ENTR 6 studies deal with air conditioning > 12 kW and with ventilation systems that


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



air conditioners with cooling capacity above 12 kW, chillers, fan coils, Larger space cooling systems (CAC, top-cooling, district cooling).

studies) include individual fans above 125 W. See also WP 2 PG 4.6 Small Fans, and figure 1-2 p.8 in ENTR 6 study "ventilation part".

18 2. Measuring Transformers

Voltage and current measuring transformers

WP 1 PG2 "Measuring Transformers" remaining

27 8. Vending machines for beverages and goods

Cold vending machines, water dispenser

ENER 12 Commercial refrigerators and freezers

not yet Hot vending machines

29 51. Motor-driven equipment for waste water process, hot water and chemical process

Sewage and wastewater pumps and mixers, Jet Aerators and Air Injection Systems, Blowers and Fans for waste water treatment, Dosing pumps, pumps for hot water, special pumps for chemicals

ENER 28 Waste water pumps

Pumps for hot water and chemical processes remaining

none 20. Paper production equipment

Machinery for making paper pulp, paper or paperboard, Machines for

ENTR 5 Machine tools

WP 1 PG 20 Paper production equipment remaining; probably most of it


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



making cartons, boxes, cases, tubes, drums, or similar containers of paper or paperboard, book-binding machines, Cutting machines for paper or paperboard, Machines for making bags, sacks or envelopes of paper or paperboard, Folding machines for books

not covered by ENTR 5

none 23. Electrically operated clocks and watches

Wall mounted electric clocks, office clocks, alarm clocks.

WP 1 PG 23 clocks and watches remaining

none 27. Printing equipment

Offset printing machinery, letterpress printing equipment, Phototypesetting and composing machines, film printing machines

WP 1 PG 27 Printing equipment remaining

none 32. Machines and equipment for textile

Machines for extruding, drawing or cutting man-made textile materials,

WP 1 PG 32 Machines textiles industry remaining; not covered by ENTR


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



and clothes industry

Machines for preparing textile fibres, Textile spinning machines, Textile doubling or twisting machines, Textile winding, Weaving machines (looms) Circular knitting machines, Flat knitting machines, stitch-bonding machines and warp knitting machines, Dry-cleaning machines, Machines for washing, bleaching or dyeing textile yarns, fabrics or made-up textile articles, Industrial automatic sewing machines, Centrifugal clothes-dryers, Carding machines for preparing textile fibres

5

none 33. Basing electronic units parts (capacitors, resistors, printed

Capacitors, Resistors, PCBs

WP 1 PG 33 Basic electronic units remaining


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



circuits)

none 39.b) End equipment for data use without option of net connection

Electronic calculators, Machines with translation or dictionary functions

WP 1 PG 39b end equipment without network connection remaining

none 41. Packaging equipment

Machinery for filling, closing, sealing, capsuling or labelling machines, Packing or wrapping machines

WP 1 PG 41 Packaging equipment remaining; not covered by ENTR 5

none 47. Machines for treatment of stone, ceramics, concrete

Sawing, grinding or polishing machines for working stone; ceramics; concrete; asbestos-cement or like mineral materials or for cold working glass, Machine-tools for working stone; ceramics; concrete; asbestos-cement or like mineral materials or for cold working glass


Draft SRI Should be mostly covered by ENTR 5

none 49. Plastics industry machines

Vacuum-moulding machines, other thermoforming machines for working rubber or


Draft SRI All equipment that does not treat workpieces with defined geometrical


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



plastics, machinery for moulding or retreading pneumatic tyres, other presses for moulding or forming rubber or plastics, Machines for processing reactive resins, Machines for the manufacture of foam products, Mixers, kneaders and agitators, for preparing rubber or plastics, Plastics Cutting, splitting and peeling machines

shapes but does primary forming of liquid / pasty (semi-solid) materials is excluded from ENTR 5

none 50. Non-domestic dryers

Dryers for agricultural products, Dryers for wood, paper pulp, paper or paperboard, Dryers for ceramic articles, Nondomestic dryers

ENER 24 Professional washing machines, dryers and dishwasher

not yet WP 1 PG 50 Non-domestic dryers remaining (except for laundry dryers which are covered by ENER 24) and oven (ENTR Lot 4)

none 56. Industrial equipment for special processes

Distilling or rectifying plant, Machinery and apparatus for filtering or purifying liquids, Producer

WP 1 PG 56 Industrial equipment special processes remaining


2nd


Table 8, p.36)

2nd


Corresponding 1st

WP priority list

(EPTA report p.33)


Working

Plan


Fi-nal rank

Ener-gy rank


EuP group (3

rd level)



gas or water gas generators, vacuum-vapour plant for the deposition of metal

Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee, and its network of member firms,

each of which is a legally separate and independent entity. Please see www.deloitte.com/about for a detailed description of the legal structure of

Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited and its member firms. In France, Deloitte SA is the member firm of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, and

professional services are provided by its subsidiaries and affiliates.

© Deloitte France. Member of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited