Upload
jonathan-stray
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 1/90
!"#$%&'"( #*
+#,-.%/%&#$/0 1#."$/0&(,
+#0.,2&/ 1#."$/0&(, 345##0
6''7 89: ;"/<&$= +#$40.(&#$( *"#, ;/%/
;'4',2'" >? @98A
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 2/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 3/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 4/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 5/90
;/%/ B#'($C% (-'/7 *#" &%('0*
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 6/90
D$%'"-"'%&$= ;/%/
;/%/ E +#$%'F% GH I'/$&$=
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 7/90
D$%'"-"'%/%&#$
J5'"' ,/K 2' ,#"' %5/$ #$' B'*'$(&20' &$%'"-"'%/%&#$
('%L
M." =#/0 &$ %5&( 40/(( &( %# ".0' #.% !"#$%$"&!'($ &$%'"-"
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 8/90
;/%/ &$%'"-"'%/%&#$ (%"/%'=K
! 65/% N.'(%&#$ /"' K#. /(7&$=O
! P$B'"(%/$B %5' N./$%&*&4/%&#$ -"#4'((
! Q./$%&*&'B "/$B#,$'(( /$B .$4'"%/&$%K
! I#B'0(? '(-'4&/00K 4/.(/0 ,#B'0(
! D$%'"-"'%/%&#$: 4#$%'F%? 4#=$&%&R' 2&/('(? ='$'"/0&S/2
! I'%5#B #* 4#,-'%&$= 5K-#%5'('(
! +#,,.$&4/%&#$ ,'%5#B(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 9/90
65/%T( K#." N.'(%&#$O
J5' N.'(%&#$ 4#,'( *&"(%L D% %'00( K#. <5/% B/%/ K#.
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 10/90
Q./$%&*&4/%&#$
J5' -"#4'(( %5/% 4"'/%'( B/%/L
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 11/90
U#< </( %5&( B/%/ 4"'/%'BO
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 12/90
8V>9 PL3L 4'$(.( '
&$(%".4%&#$
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 13/90
@989 PL3L 4'$(.( "/4' /$
N.'(%&#$(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 14/90
D$%'$%&#$/0 #" .$&$%'$%&#$/0 -"#20',
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 15/90
D$%'"R&'< %5' ;/%/! 65'"' B# %5'(' $.,2'"( 4#,' *"#,O
! 65# "'4#"B'B %5',O
!
U#<O! !#" <5/% -."-#(' </( %5&( B/%/ 4#00'4%'BO
! U#< B# <' 7$#< &% &( 4#,-0'%'O
! 65/% /"' %5' B',#="/-5&4(O
! D( %5&( %5' "&=5% </K %# N./$%&*K %5&( &((.'O
! 65# &( $#% &$40.B'B &$ %5'(' *&=."'(O! 65# &( =#&$= %# 0##7 2/B #" 0#(' ,#$'K /( / "'(.0% #* %5'(' $.,2'"(O
! D( %5' B/%/ 4#$(&(%'$% *"#, B/K %# B/K? #" <5'$ 4#00'4%'B 2K B&**'"'$% -
! 65/% /"2&%"/"K 45#&4'( 5/B %# 2' ,/B' %# ='$'"/%' %5' B/%/O
! D( %5' B/%/ 4#$(&(%'$% <&%5 #%5'" (#."4'(O 65# 5/( /0"'/BK /$/0KS'B &%
! ;#'( &% 5/R' 7$#<$ *0/<(O W"' %5'"' ,.0%&-0' R'"(&#$(O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 16/90
WBR'$%."'( &$ !&'0B ;'*&$&%&#$(
@99> X0'4%&#$? &$ !0#"&B/? "'4#.$%'B 2K I/%% 6/&%' &$ )*"#(!"+
-*.* *'/0. 1*2$ *"# 3.4"!2!.56
J5'"' <'"' ,#"' %5/$ >Y?999 !0#"&B&/$( #$ %5' *'0#$ -."=' 0&(
M* %5',? #$0K Z8[%5/%T( #$' %'$%5 #* #$' -'"4'$%[<'"'
U&(-/$&4 &$ / (%/%' <5'"' 8Y -'"4'$% #* %5' -#-.0/%&#$ 40/&,'B
U&(-/$&4 /( %5'&" "/4'L
LLLD$ %5' (%/%' R#%'" "'=&(%"/%&#$ B/%/2/('? U&(-/$&4 &( / "/4'L D$ %5
(%/%'T( 4"&,&$/0 5&(%#"K B/%/2/('? U&(-/$&4 &( /$ '%5$&4&%KL 65'
,/%45'B %#='%5'"? /$B <&%5 "/4' /( / 4"&%'"&/ *#" ,/%45&$=? %5'
$.,2'" #* ,/%45'( &$R#0R&$= U&(-/$&4 -'#-0' B"#-( %# $'/"
S'"#L
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 17/90
\/$B#,$'((
Q./$%&*&'B .$4'"%/&$%K
*
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 18/90
I/"=&$ #* X""#"
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 19/90
J5' -"#2/2&0&%&'( #* -#00&$=
D* \#,$'K &( %<# -#&$%( /5'/B #* M2/,/? >V] %# >Y]? &$ / -#00
,/"=&$ #* '""#"? 5#< 0&7'0K &( &% %5/% M2/,/ &( /4%./00K 0'/B&$=O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 20/90
^&R'$:\ G >V]? MG>Y]
IMX_\` G IMX_M` G aALA]
U#< 0&7'0K &( &% %5/% M2/,/ &( /4%./00K /5'/BO
b'% ; G \cM G @]L J5&( &( /$ #2('"R'B R/0.'? /$B &* <' -#00'B %5' <5#0'-#-.0/%&#$? <' <#.0B ('' / %".' R/0.' ;CL 6' </$% %# 7$#< -"#2/2&0&%K %5
M2/,/ &( /4%./00K /5'/B? &L'L d_;C e 9`
I/"=&$ #* '""#" #$ ; f IMX_\` E IMX_;` G a88] 2'4/.(' %5'K /"' /0,#(%
4#,-0'%'0K B'-'$B'$%? \EM f 899L
!#" 2'%%'" /$/0K(&(? (''5%%-:gg/24$'<(L=#L4#,g&,/='(gd#00&$=P$&%gIMX!"/$70&$L-B*
^&R'( IMX_;` G 89Lh]
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 21/90
3%BL B'R #* ; f IMX_;`g8LVZ /( IMX &( N.#%'B /( VA] 4#$*&B'$4' &$%'"R/0
G aALA]L
ic(4#"' #* c; G c@]gALA] G c9LjZ
d_Sec9LjA` G 9LjZ? (# jZ] 45/$4' / \#,$'K &( $#% /5'/B? #" /2#.% 8 &$ jL
d_M2/,/ /5'/B` d_\#,$'K /
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 22/90
65&45 #$' &( "/$B#,O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 23/90
M$' (%/" -'" 2#F k $#% "/$B#,
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 24/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 25/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 26/90
D( %5&( B&' 0#/B'BO
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 27/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 28/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 29/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 30/90
W"' %5'(' %<# B&4' 0#/B'BO
J # B&4' $#$ $&*#", B&(%"&2 %&#$
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 31/90
J<# B&4': $#$c.$&*#", B&(%"&2.%&#$
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 32/90
J<# -"&$4&-0'( #* "/$B#,$'((
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 33/90
J<# -"&$4&-0'( #* "/$B#,$'((
8L \/$B#, B/%/ 5/( </K -/%%'"$( &$ &% </K ,#"' #*%'$ %5/$ K#.
@L J5&( -"#20', ='%( ,.45 ,#"' 'F%"',' <5'$ K#. 5/R' 0'(( B
D( (#,'%5&$= 4/.(&$= 4/$4'"O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 34/90
D( (#,'%5&$= 4/.(&$= 4/$4'"O
+/$4'" "/%' -'" 4#.$%KL ;/"7'" G ="'/%'" &$4&B'$4' #* 4/$4'"L
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 35/90
65&45 #* %5'(' &( "'/0 B/%/O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 36/90
65&45 #* %5'(' &( "'/0 B/%/O
^0#2/0 %',-'"/%."' "'4#"B
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 37/90
^0#2/0 %',-'"/%."' "'4#"B
U#< 0&7'0K &( &% %5/% %5' %',-'"/%."' 7/"8. &$4"'/(' #R'" $'F% B'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 38/90
!"#, 94$ :!+"*( *"# .4$ ;/!&$? l/%' 3&0R'"
J5' U#<0/$B 6&00 J"&/0
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 39/90
J5' U#<0/$B 6&00 J"&/0
D% &( 4#$4'&R/20' %5/% %5' 8> '0B'"0K -'#-0' <5# /"' "'-#"%'B %
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 40/90
5/R' B&'B (##$ /*%'" "'4'&R&$= %5' R/44&$/%&#$ B&'B #* #%5'"
4/.('(L ̂ #R'"$,'$% #**&4&/0( &$ 45/"=' #* %5' -"#="/, 40/&,
%5/% &% &( /00 / 4#&$4&B'$4'? /$B -#&$% #.% %5/% #0B -'#-0' B"#-
B'/B 'R'"K B/KL J5' W,'"&4/$ -'#-0' 5/R' 'R'$ 2'4#,'
*/,&0&/" <&%5 / $'< (%/%&(%&4: W,#$= 'R'"K 899?999 -'#-0' ZA %YA K'/"( #0B? %5'"' <&00 2' $&$' #" %'$ B'/%5( &$ 'R'"K @>c5#."
-'"&#B .$B'" ,#(% $#",/0 4&"4.,(%/$4'(L
XR'$ .(&$= %5' #**&4&/0 (%/%&(%&4? &% &( B&(4#$4'"%&$= %5/% %5"''
'0B'"0K -'#-0' &$ #$' 40&$&4 &$ d&%%(2."=5? /00 R/44&$/%'B <&%5&$
%5' (/,' 5#."? (5#.0B B&' <&%5&$ / *'< 5#."( %5'"'/*%'"L J5&(
%"/='BK 4#.0B #44." 2K 45/$4'? 2.% %5' */4% "',/&$( %5/% &% &(
'F%"','0K &,-"#2/20' %5/% (.45 / ="#.- #* B'/%5( (5#.0B %/7'
-0/4' &$ (.45 / -'4.0&/" 40.(%'" 2K -."' 4#&$4&B'$4'L
< ;$7 =/>? 9!@$& 'B&%#"&/0? 8> M4%#2'" 8VYZ
W((.,&$= %5/% /2#.% >9 -'"4'$% #* '0B'"0K W,'"&4/$( <'"'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 41/90
R/44&$/%'B <&%5&$ %5' *&"(% 88 B/K( #* %5' -"#="/,? %5'$ /2#.%
,&00&#$ -'#-0' /='B ZA /$B #0B'" <#.0B 5/R' "'4'&R'B %5'
R/44&$' &$ '/"0K M4%#2'" 8VYZL W((.,&$= %5/% %5'"' <'"' A?99
40&$&4( $/%&#$<&B'? %5&( <#.0B 5/R' 2''$ 8Z> R/44&$/%&#$( -'"
40&$&4 -'" B/KL W -'"(#$ /='B ZA #" #0B'" 5/( /2#.% / 8c&$cY?9945/$4' #* BK&$= #$ /$K -/"%&4.0/" B/Km %5' #BB( #* /% 0'/(% %5"'
(.45 -'#-0' BK&$= #$ %5' (/,' B/K *"#, /,#$= / ="#.- #* 8Z
-/%&'$%( /"' &$B''B R'"K 0#$=? /2#.% >h9?999 %# #$' /=/&$(%L
U#<'R'"? .$B'" #." /((.,-%&#$(? %5'"' <'"' AA?999
#--#"%.$&%&'( *#" %5&( n'F%"','0K &,-"#2/20'o 'R'$% %# #44."[
A?999 40&$&4(? ,.0%&-0&'B 2K 88 B/K(L J5' #BB( #* %5&( 4#&$4&B'$#44.""&$= (#,'<5'"' &$ W,'"&4/? %5'"'*#"'? <'"' ,.45
(5#"%'"[#$0K /2#.% h %# 8
< l/%' 3&0R'" A 94$ :!+"*( *"# .4$ ;/!&$A +5L Y *##%$#%' @9
B B B B
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 42/90
\/$B#,&S/%&#$ %# B'%'4% &$(&B'" %"/B&$=
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 43/90
b##7&$= /% 'F'4.%&R'(C %"/B&$= &$ %5' <''7 2'*#"' %5'&" 4#,-/$&'( ,/B' $
1#."$/0 *#.$B %5/% #$' #* 'R'"K jj <5# B&--'B &$ /$B #.% -#(%'B /R'"/=
,#"' %5/$ @9] _#" /R#&B'B @9] B#<$%."$(` &$ %5' *#00#<&$= <''7L pK 4#
#$' &$ 88Y 'F'4.%&R'( <5# %"/B'B &$ /$ /$$./0 -/%%'"$ B&B %5/% <'00L
\/$B#, U/--'$(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 44/90
\/$B#, U/--'$(
qP$0&7'0K %# 5/--'$ 2K 45/$4'q &( #$0K / =##B /"=.,'$% &* K#.C
'(%&,/%'B %5' 45/$4'L
W0(#: / B*>.!20(*> 4#&$4&B'$4' ,/K 2' "/"'? 2.% &/@$ 4#&$4&B'$
(#,'<5'"' #44."( 4#$(%/$%0KL
W 0 % %5
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 45/90
W ,#"' 4#,-0'%' %5'#"K
+#,-/"' -"#2/2&0&%K #* ,.0%&-0' /0%'"$/%&R'(
J5' p/K'(&/$ /--"#/45:
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 46/90
-"#2/2&0&%K B&(%"&2.%&#$ #R'" 5K-#%5'('(
XL=L D( %5' lrd; %/"='%&$= ,#(N.'( *#" (%#-c/$Bc*"&(7O
8
9U9 U8 U@
l'R'" \#.%&$'0KM$4' #" %<&4'
sJ"&47K: K#. 5/R' %# &,/=&$' / 5K-#%5'(&( 2'*#"' K#. 4/$ /((&=$ &% /
-"#2/2&0&%KL
XR&B'$4'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 47/90
XR&B'$4'
D$*#",/%&#$ %5/% t.(%&*&'( / 2'0&'*L
d"'('$%'B <&%5 'R&B'$4' X *#" u? <' (5#.0B 2'0&'R' u q,#"'Lq
D$ %'",( #* -"#2/2&0&%K? d_uvX` H d_u`
3%"'$=%5 #* XR&B'$4'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 48/90
3%"'$=%5 #* XR&B'$4'
D( 4#.=5&$= (%"#$= #" <'/7 'R&B'$4' *#" / 4#0BO
XF-"'(('B &$ %'",( #* 4#$B&%&#$/0 -"#2/2&0&%&'(L
d_4#0Bv4#.=5&$=`
U&=5 R/0.'( G (%"#$= 'R&B'$4'L
;#$C% "'R'"(' -"#2/2&0&%&'(w
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 49/90
;#$ % "'R'"(' -"#2/2&0&%&'(w
D$ ='$'"/0 d_Wvp` x d_pvW`
d_4#.=5&$=v4#0B` f 9LV
d_4#0Bv4#.=5&$=` f 9Lj
p/K'(C %5'#"', =&R'( %5' "'0/%&#$(5&-
d_Wvp` G d_pvW` d_W` g d_p`
Q./$%&*&'B (.--#"% *#" 5K-#%5'('(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 50/90
Q./$%&*&'B (.--#"% *#" 5K-#%5'('(
U#< 0&7'0K &( / 5K-#%5'(&( U? =&R'$ 'R&B'$4' XO
M"? <5/% &( d"_UvX`O
D% B'-'$B( #$:
5#< 0&7'0K U </( 2'*#"' X? d"_U`
5#< 0&7'0K %5' X <#.0B 2' &* U &( %".'? d"_XvU`
5#< 4#,,#$ &( %5' 'R&B'$4'? d"_X`
p/K'(C %5'#"',:0'/"$&$= *"#, 'R&B'$4'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 51/90
0'/"$&$= *"#, 'R&B'$4'
d"_UvX` G d"_XvU` d"_U` g d"_X`
#"
d_UvX` G d"_XvU`gd"_X` s d"_U`
!"#$%"&''(
U#< 0&7'0K &( U
=&R'$ 'R&B'$4' XO
)*"'*
U#< 0&7'0K <
U %# 2'=&$ <
+'($% '- .
d"#2/2&0&%K #*
(''&$= X
&* U &( %".'
+'($% '- /
U#< 4#,,#$0K
B# <' ('' X /% /00O
W0&4' &( 4#.=5&$=L ;#'( (5' 5/R' / 4#0B
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 52/90
UK-#%5'(&( U G W0&4' 5/( / 4#0B
XR&B'$4' X G <' t.(% (/< 5'" 4#.=5
W0&4' &( 4#.=5&$=L ;#'( (5' 5/R' / 4#0B
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 53/90
UK-#%5'(&( U G W0&4' 5/( / 4#0B
XR&B'$4' X G <' t.(% (/< 5'" 4#.=5
d"&#" d_U` G 9L9A _A] #* #." *"&'$B( 5/R' / 4#0B`
I#B'0 d_XvU` G 9LV _,#(% -'#-0' <&%5 4#0B( 4#.=5`
I#B'0 d_X` G 9L8 _89] #* 'R'"K#$' 4#.=5( %#B/K`
W0&4' &( 4#.=5&$=L ;#'( (5' 5/R' / 4#0B
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 54/90
d_UvX` G d_XvU`d_U`gd_X`
G 9LV s 9L9A g 9L8
G 9L>A
D* K#. 2'0&'R' K#." &$&%&/0 -"#2/2&0&%K '(%&,/%'(? K#.
(5#.0B $#< 2'0&'R' %5'"'C( / >A] 45/$4' (5' 5/( /4#0BL
;&B %5' (%#-0&=5% "'B.4' /44&B'$%(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 55/90
;&B %5' (%#-0&=5% "'B.4' /44&B'$%(
1 2 3
Simulated without stoplight
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 56/90
0
2
4
6
8
0
2
4
6
8
0
2
4
6
8
4
0
2
4
6
8
5
0
2
4
6
8
6
0
2
4
6
8
7
0
2
4
6
8
8
0
2
4
6
8
9
0
2
4
6
8
1 2 3
Simulated with a 50% effective stoplight
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 57/90
0
2
4
6
8
0
2
4
6
8
0
2
4
6
8
4
0
2
4
6
8
5
0
2
4
6
8
6
0
2
4
6
8
7
0
2
4
6
8
8
0
2
4
6
8
9
0
2
4
6
8
I#B'0(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 58/90
I#B'0(
J5'K '$4#B' #." 2/47="#.$B 7$#<0'B='
/$B /((.,-%&#$(
;#'( 45#4#0/%' ,/7' K#. (,/"
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 59/90
;#'( ,/""&/=' ,/7' <#,'$ (/
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 60/90
0112345"'64% 7*'23 89'#"6:
!/",'"(? *#"'(%'"(? /$B *&(5'",/$ YY
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 61/90
I&$'"( /$B N./""K,'$ 8jY
^/(? 4#7' /$B 45',&4/0 ,/7'"( 88Y
^0/(( /$B 4'"/,&4( ,/7'"( V>
! ." $/4'? *#" ='? *#.$B" K? /$B "#00&$= ,&00 88Z
X0'4%"&4/0 /$B '0'4%"#$&4( <#"7'"( 89@
X$=&$''"&$= /$B /00&'B %"/B'( 888
6##B<#"7'"( Vj
b'/%5'" <#"7'"( hh
J'F%&0' <#"7'"( 89@
+0#%5&$= <#"7'"( V8
!##B? B"&$7? /$B %#2/44# <#"7'"( 89>
d/-'" /$B -"&$%&$= <#"7'"( 89Y
I/7'"( #* #%5'" -"#B.4%( 88@
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 62/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 63/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 64/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 65/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 66/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 67/90
U#< 4#""'0/%&#$ 5/--'$(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 68/90
ru
u 4/.('( r
ru
r 4/.('( u
ru
"/$B#, 45/$4'w
ru
5&BB'$ R/"&/20' 4/.('( u /$B r
ru
i 4/.('( u /$B r
i
U#< 4#""'0/%&#$ 5/--'$(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 69/90
ru
u 4/.('( r
ru
r 4/.('( u
ru
"/$B#, 45/$4'w
ru
i 4/.('( u /$B r
i
^.$( /$B *&"'/", 5#,&4&B'(O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 70/90
ru
&* K#. 5/R' / =.$? K#.C"' =#&$= %# .(' &%
ru
&* &%C( / B/$='"#.( $'&=52#"5##B? K#.C00 2.K / =.$
ru
%5' 4#""'0/%&#$ &( B.' %# 45/$4'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 71/90
p'/.%K /$B "'(-#$('(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 72/90
ru
%'00&$= / <#,/$ (5'C( 2'/.%&*.0
,/7'( 5'" "'(-#$B 0'((
ru
&* / <#,/$ &( 2'/.%&*.0?8` (5'C00 "'(-#$B 0'((
@` -'#-0' <&00 %'00 5'" %5/%
i
p'/.%K &( / q4#$*#.$B&$= R/"&/20'Lq J5' 4#""'0/%&#$ &(
"'/0? 2.% K#.CR' ,&(.$B'"(%##B %5' 4/.(/0 (%".4%."'L
p'/.%K /$B "'(-#$('(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 73/90
ru
%'00&$= / <#,/$ (5'C( 2'/.%&*.0 B#'($C% <#"7
ru
&* / <#,/$ &( 2'/.%&*.0?8` (5'C00 "'(-#$B 0'((
@` -'#-0' <&00 %'00 5'" %5/%
i
p'/.%K &( / q4#$*#.$B&$= R/"&/20'Lq J5' 4#""'0/%&#$ &(
"'/0? 2.% K#.CR' ,&(.$B'"(%##B %5' 4/.(/0 (%".4%."'L
65/% /$ 'F-'"&,'$% &(:&$%'"R'$' &$ / $'%<#"7 #* 4/.('(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 74/90
;#'( !/4'2##7 $'<( *''B 4/.('-'#-0' %# (5/"' 0&$7(O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 75/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 76/90
W =##B ,#B'0 5/( / %5'#"K #* %5' <#"0BL
p/B ,#B'0(? 2/B &$*'"'$4'(
D$%'"-"'%/%&#$
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 77/90
+#$%'F%? 4#=$&%&R' 2&/('(? ='$'"/0&S/2&0&%K
p&/(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 78/90
W &5&.$@*.!2 %'$B'$4K %# -"#B.4' /$ &$4#""'4% /$(<'"L
:5&.$@*.!2 ,'/$( &%C( $#% / "/$B#, '""#"L J5'"'C( / -/%%'"$ %# %
D,-0&'( <' 4#.0B B# 2'%%'" &* <' 4#""'4%'B *#" %5' -/%%'"$L
sJ"&47K: 'R/0./%&$= 2&/( "'N.&"'( 7$#<0'B=' #* 4#""'4% /$(<'"L
+#=$&%&R' 2&/('(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 79/90
WR/&0/2&0&%K 5'."&(%&4: <' .(' 'F/,-0'( %5/% 4#,' %# ,&$B?
&$(%'/B #* (%/%&(%&4(L
d"'*'"'$4' *#" '/"0&'" &$*#",/%&#$: <5/% <' 0'/"$ *&"(% 5/( /
,.45 ="'/%'" '**'4% #$ #." t.B=,'$%L
I',#"K *#",/%&#$: <5/%'R'" ('',( &,-#"%/$% *. .4$ .!@$ &(
<5/% ='%( "',',2'"'BL
+#$*&",/%&#$ 2&/(: <' (''7 #.% /$B =&R' ="'/%'" &,-#"%/$4' %#
&$*#",/%&#$ %5/% 4#$*&",( #." 'F-'4%/%&#$(L
+#$*&",/%&#$ 2&/(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 80/90
+#,'( &$ ,/$K *#",(L
LLL.$4#$(4&#.(0K *&0%'"&$= &$*#",/%&#$ %5/% B#'($C% *&% 'F-'4%/%&#
LLL$#% 0##7&$= *#" 4#$%"/"K &$*#",/%&#$L
LLL$#% &,/=&$&$= %5' /0%'"$/%&R'(L
J5' %5&$= /2#.% 'R&B'$4'LLL
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 81/90
W( %5' /,#.$% #* &$*#",/%&#$ &$4"'/('(? &% ='%( ,#"' 0&
(#,' &$*#",/%&#$ (#,'<5'"' (.--#"%( /$K -/"%&4.0/"5K-#%5'(&(L
D$ #%5'" <#"B(? &* K#. =# 0##7&$= *#" 4#$*&",/%&#$? K#.
J5&( &( $#% / 4#,-0'%' %".%5c*&$B&$= ,'%5#BL
I'%5#B #* 4#,-'%&$= 5K-#%5'('(
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 82/90
3%/"% <&%5 ,.0%&-0' 5K-#%5'('( U9? U8? LLL Ul
_\',',2'"? &* K#. 4/$C% &,/=&$' &%? K#. 4/$C% 4#$40.B' &%w`
^# 0##7&$= *#" &$*#",/%&#$ %5/% =&R'( K#. %5' 2'(% /2&0&%K %# ("<
2'%<''$ 5K-#%5'('(L
XR&B'$4' <5&45 (.--#"%( U& &( ,.45 0'(( .('*.0 %5/$ 'R&B'$4' <(.--#"%( U& ,.45 ,#"' %5/$ U t? &* %5' =#/0 &( %# 45##(' / 5K-#%
I'%5#B #* 4#,-'%&$= 5K-#%5'('(?N./$%&%/%&R' *#",
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 83/90
3%/"% <&%5 ,.0%&-0' 5K-#%5'('( U9? U8? LLL Ul
X/45 &( / ,#B'0 #* <5/% K#.CB 'F-'4% %# ('' d_XvU&`?
<&%5 &$&%&/0 -"#2/2&0&%K d_U&`
!#" '/45 $'< -&'4' #* 'R&B'$4'? .(' p/K'(C ".0' %#.-B/%' -"#2/2&0&%K #$ /00 5K-#%5'('(L
D$*'"'$4' "'(.0% &( -"#2/2&0&%&'( #* B&**'"'$% 5K-#%5'('=&R'$ /00 'R&B'$4'
y d_U9vX`? d_U8vX`? LLL ? d_UlvX` z
W B&**&4.0% 'F/,-0'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 84/90
lrd; -'"*#",( {Z99?999 (%"''% (%#- /$B *"&(7( -'"
65/% (#"%( #* 4#$40.(&#$( 4#.0B <' B"/< *"#, %5&( B/
^'$'"/0&S/2&0&%K
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 85/90
6&00 K#." 4#$40.(&#$( 5#0B &$ #%5'" 4#$%'F%(O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 86/90
65/%
B#'($C% /J<&%%'"
,/-
(5#<O
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 87/90
lr+-#-.0/%&#$
4#0#"'B 2K
&$4#,'
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 88/90
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 89/90
3%#- /$B !"&(7 +/.(/%&#$
7/23/2019 Drawing Conclusions From Data. Computational Journalism week 11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/drawing-conclusions-from-data-computational-journalism-week-11 90/90
3.--#(' K#. %/7' %5' /BB"'(( #* 'R'"K ,#(N.' &$ lr+?
B&(4#R'" %5/% %5'"' /"' 8A] ,#"' (%#-c/$Bc*"&(7( <&%5&
,#(N.'( %5/$ %5' #R'"/00 /R'"/='L
+/$ <' 4#$40.B' %5/% %5' -#0&4' /"' %/"='%&$= I.(0&,(