E-Book How Privatized Banking Really Works

!

!

!

"!#$%&!'$(!%)&!*+,!-&(./$0!$'!

1$2!*(/34%/5&6!7408/09!!"#$$%!:$(8.!

7;!<=!>4(?$.!<4(4!@!A$B&(%!*=!CD(E);!!

"#$!%&''&()*+!,-%!%)'$!).!,/&0)-$-!%&/!$-1234)&*3'!,1/,&.$.5!6$2),)$*4.!&%!4#).!%)'$!3/$!$*2&1/3+$-!4&!-).4/)714$!)48!()4#!4#$!1*-$/.43*-)*+!4#34!4#$!314#&/.!-&!*&4!3,,/&0$!&%!4#$!,#9.)23'!,/&-124)&*!&%!4#$!2&*4$*4.!%&/!/$.3'$5!!

"#&.$!)*4$/$.4$-!)*!,1/2#3.)*+!,#9.)23'!2&,)$.!&%!4#$!7&&:!;39!-&!.&!34!4#).!($7.)4$<!

!

#44,<==(((51.34/1.4&*')*$52&;=!!

!!!

"##$%&'!()*!+%*%!%,-!./*01234!5))6!!

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

!!!

!!!!!!!

!

K(6!?$9C*29>4.!G*<89<H!!C7%$$2!-($8+!

!

!

!

!K(6!?$9C*29>4.!G*<89<H!

C7%$$2!-($8+!!

<,87F*%8&,F!"/48*&%,!I#),)'&#4!9&81!!817!<,(&,&87!K%,6&,F!@),#708!

!!!!!!!!

=%!F*$;(+!=*$*!J(:4$2!?%!D1$L'A/!?'%#%!

!

!

!

!!!!!!!!@)02*&F18!N!OPQP!52!+?!@%*$)4!+%*%!R!C)57*8!;?!./*012!!U63!V'838/&NW%8&3.'!X)2,!SYUY!8&!3+.!Z&83.'!M3$3.6!/<!L7.%81$!5,!A17*&-%,!K))64S!<,#?T",,!"*5)*!.&#1&F%,!!GMHE![\]NYNÛTN_S^]SNT!!I/-.%!L%3!$&'!`.68:&!5,!L2-8&!L5).2/)<!$2-8&$5).2/)<a28-.=1/7!!!W+/3/!L%3!$&'!`.68:&!5,!M3.*+$&8.!#/&:!;;;=63.*+1%.$38-.=1/7!!O/%!8&</%7$38/&!$5/)3!)6.<)2!%.<.%.&1.!7$3.%8$26@!$''838/&$2!%.$'8&:! 28636@! $&'! /3+.%! $-$82$52.! %.6/)%1.6! <%/7! 3+.!$)3+/%6@!-8683!3+.8%!%.6*.138-.!;.5683.64!!

#=!I$%2/6!#$%$A!+33*Abb;;;=)6$3%)63/&28&.=1/7!K/5.%3!W=!()%*+,A!+33*AbbI/&6)238&:H,KW(=1/7!

!

!

560/#$7,-18,/*3!!

9/! )--'*'#/! *#! )77! *:,! 1&,)*! *:'/0,&3!$:#! :)(,! *);1:*! ;3! 3#!

8;6:! #(,&! *:,! <,)&3=,'*:,&! '/! >,&3#/! #&! '/-'&,6*7<! *:&#;1:! *:,'&!

?##03=$,!$#;7-!7'0,!*#!3>,6'@'6)77<!*:)/0!)!@,$!>,#>7,!$:#!$,&,!

'/3*&;8,/*)7! '/!*:,!6&,)*'#/!#@! *:'3!$#&0A!B:,!,/*'&,!*,)83!)*!?#*:!

B:,! C)@)<,**,! C'@,! 9/3;&)/6,! D#8>)/<! )/-! E;*;)7! B&;3*! C'@,!

9/3;&)/6,! D#8>)/<! 1&)6'#;37<! )77#$,-! ;3! *#! ('3'*! *:,'&! #@@'6,3! '/!

#&-,&!*#!7,)&/!)?#;*!*:,!'//,&!$#&0'/13!#@!$:#7,!7'@,!'/3;&)/6,A!2,!

3:#;7-! 3'/17,! #;*!F)('-! G&)/6'3! #@! C)@)<,**,!$:#! )&&)/1,-! @#&! *:,!

8,,*'/1!'/!*:,!@'&3*!>7)6,A!H#1,&!.)&*:!)/-!I*,>:,/!.)*+)!#@!E;*;)7!

B&;3*! $,/*! )?#(,! )/-! ?,<#/-! *:,! 6)77! #@! -;*<! '/! @',7-'/1! #;&!

J;,3*'#/3!)?#;*!6)3:!()7;,3!)/-!>#7'6<!7#)/3A!

F)('-! I*,)&/3K! >&,3'-,/*! #@! *:,! 9/@'/'*,! .)/0'/1! D#/6,>*!

B:'/0!B)/0!'/!.'&8'/1:)8K!57)?)8)K!:)3!,L*,/-,-!*#!;3!,(,&<!?'*!#@!

)33'3*)/6,!)3!$,!6#8>7,*,-!*:,!?##0A!!

F)('-! M#&-#/! )/-! I*,>:)/! N'/3,77)! )33'3*,-! $'*:! *:,!

5;3*&')/!3'-,!#@!#;&!&,3,)&6:A!

57('/! 5?;,7#;@! )/-! I*,>:)/',! C#/1! 6&,)*,-! *:,! 1&'>>'/1!

6#(,&!-,3'1/K!$:'6:!'3!)&1;)?7<!*:,!?,3*!)**&'?;*,!#@!*:,!?##0A!

G'/)77<K! $,! $#;7-! 7'0,! *#! ,3>,6')77<! *:)/0! 5//,! C)&)! @#&!

)6*'/1!)3!7')'3#/!$'*:!*:,!>;?7'3:'/1!6#8>)/<K!)/-!@#&!*:,!36#&,3!#@!

:#;&3!3:,!>;*!'/*#!*:,!>&,>)&)*'#/!#@!*:,!8)/;36&'>*A!2,&,!'*!/#*!@#&!

5//,K! *:'3! ?##0! $#;7-! 3*'77! 6#/3'3*! #@! )! 6#77,6*'#/! #@! 2#&-!

-#6;8,/*3!#/!*:,!);*:#&3O!&,3>,6*'(,!:)&-!-&'(,3A!

!!

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

!!

!!!!!!

B:'3!?##0!'3!-,-'6)*,-!*#!!)77!*:#3,!$:#!!

7#(,!#85.%3,!)/-!6:)8>'#/!M/)&'!(/&.,=!

!

!

F!M!5!&!,!5!&!I!!

!

?!E!J!&!!!M!5!,N!!!&'4!O1*<.*$A AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAP!!D:)>*,&!P4!!9/*&#-;6*'#/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQ!D:)>*,&!R4!!533,33'/1!*:,!E)'/!%&#?7,8 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QP!D:)>*,&!Q4!!C#3'/1!S;&!2)< AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA TP!D:)>*,&!U4!!C#3'/1!S;&!I>'&'* AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA VW!D:)>*,&!T4!!E#/,< AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA XP!D:)>*,&!V4!!F,>#3'*!.)/0'/1 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PYX!D:)>*,&!W4!!9/@7)*'#/AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PRW!D:)>*,&!Z4!!G&)6*'#/)7!H,3,&(,!.)/0'/1 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PUW!!

?E!J!&!!!&!-!MN!!!&'4!I(1<.!D(<4A!I(;129(< AAAAAAAAAAAAAAPQR!!

D:)>*,&!X4!!!B:,!H#7,!#@!I#6')7!9/3*'*;*'#/3AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PVW!D:)>*,&!PY4!!%&'()*,!%&#>,&*< AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PWT!D:)>*,&!PP4!!B&)-,AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PWX!D:)>*,&!PR4!!E#/,<AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PZQ!D:)>*,&!PQ4!!%&'6,3K!%&#@'*3!)/-!%7)//'/1AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PXP!D:)>*,&!PU4!!.)/0'/1AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA RYQ!D:)>*,&!PT4!!9/3;&)/6, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA RPQ!D:)>*,&!PV4!!M#(,&/8,/*!F'3*#&*'#/3AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA RRT!D:)>*,&!PW4!!B:,!I#;/-!E#/,<!I#7;*'#/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA RVP!!

?!E!J!&!!!&!K!J!,!,N!!&'4!SGF!F(<2$9:129(< AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATUP!!D:)>*,&!PZ4!!B:,!9/@'/'*,!.)/0'/1!D#/6,>* AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA RZT!D:)>*,&!PX4!!D#88#/!S?[,6*'#/3!*#!9.D AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QPP!D:)>*,&!RY4!!B:,!9.D!D#/*&'?;*'#/!*#!*:,!!

I#;/-!E#/,<!I#7;*'#/ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QQT!D:)>*,&!RP4!!D#/67;3'#/AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QUX!!ELL4<.9@4+ AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QTW!!

M&,)*!5;3*&')/3AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QTX!5?#;*!*:,!5;*:#&3 AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA QWX!

!!

!"

!"#$%&%

'()%*+",-"#.%

"

"!"#$%&'$%("#)$)"$&'%*$%$#+,-#'$(""./$0)$1,22$(")3$*,%4+"5'$"#&$

+%),"+65$ '7"+"8,7$ 1"'5$ %+*$ )3'+$ "99'&$ %$ &'%2,5),7$ 5"2#),"+/$ 0)$ 1,22$

*,57#55$ )3'$ 5:8;)"85$ "9$ )3'$ -#%+*%&:$ )3%)$ %22$ <8'&,7%+5$ 3%='$

;'&7',='*>$(#)$,)$1,22$'?;2%,+$)3'8$,+$%$1%:$:"#$8%:$+'='&$('9"&'$3%='$

'+7"#+)'&'*/$<9)'&$:"#$#+*'&5)%+*$)3'$;&"(2'8>$)3,5$("".$1,22$'?;2%,+$

%$;&%7),7%2$7#&'$)3%)$:"#$7%+$,8;2'8'+)$,88'*,%)'2:/$

@3,5$("".$7"='&5$8#73$4&"#+*/$0)$53"15$)3%)$"#&$7#&&'+)$7&,5,5>$

%5$ 1'22$ %5$ )3'$ 4'+'&%2$ 9,+%+7,%2$ 5)&#442'$ %992,7),+4$ %28"5)$ %22$

<8'&,7%+5>$,5$+")$*#'$)"$7"58,7$7",+7,*'+7'/$0)$,5$%25"$+")$A#5)$B)3'$1%:$

)3,+45$%&'/C$

D">$"#&$-#%+*%&:$3%5$='&:$5;'7,9,7$7%#5'5E$9,%)$8"+':$%+*$)3'$

;&%7),7'$ "9$ 9&%7),"+%2$ &'5'&='$ (%+.,+4>$ %+*$ )3'$ 4"='&+8'+)$

,+)'&='+),"+5$)3%)$;'&;')#%)'$)3'8/$0+$%$='&:$&'%2$5'+5'>$"#&$8"*'&+$

9,+%+7,%2$5:5)'8$7&'%)'5$8"+':$"#)$"9$)3,+$%,&>$%+*$7%+$*'5)&":$,)$A#5)$

%5$ -#,7.2:/$ @3,5$8%4,7%2$ %(,2,):$ 4,='5$ &,5'$ )"$ )3'$ 9%8,2,%&$ (""8F(#5)$

7:72'$,+$*'='2";'*$'7"+"8,'5/$

@3'$ &'7"4+,),"+$ "9$ )3,5$ )&"#(2,+4$ 9%7)$ ,8;2,'5$ +"$ 8"&%2$

7"+*'8+%),"+$ "9$ )3'$ 8,22,"+5$ "9$ ;'";2'$ 7#&&'+)2:$ '8;2":'*$ ,+$ )3'$

7"88'&7,%2$(%+.,+4$5'7)"&/$$G"5)$"9$)3'8$;&"(%(2:$3%='$+"$,*'%$)3%)$$

!"#$%&'()*%+,"-."#/%HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH$

$

#"

"#&$ '+),&'$ 9,+%+7,%2$ 5:5)'8$ &'5)5$ "+$ -#,7.5%+*/$ @3'$ 8'73%+,75$ "9$

9&%7),"+%2$&'5'&='$(%+.,+4$7%+$('$*,99,7#2)$)"$4&%5;>$%+*$,+*''*$8%+:$

;'";2'$ 1,22$ +''*$ )"$ &'%*$ )3,5$ ("".$ 5'='&%2$ ),8'5$ ('9"&'$ )3':$ )&#2:$

#+*'&5)%+*$,)/$I#)$"+7'$)3':$*">$)3':$1,22$('$53"7.'*/$$

J"#5'3"2*5$ 3%='$ )3'$ %(,2,):$ )"$ 5'7'*'$ 9&"8$ )3,5$ 73%"),7$

9,+%+7,%2$ 5:5)'8/$ @3':$ 7%+$ )#&+$ )"$ )&%*,),"+%2$ ,+5#&%+7'$ 7"8;%+,'5>$

&%)3'&$ )3%+$ 7"88'&7,%2$ (%+.5$ %+*$ K%22$ L)&'')>$ 9"&$ )3',&$ 9,+%+7,+4$

+''*5/$K'$'?;2%,+$%22$"9$)3,5$,+$*#'$),8'/$

!')$ ('9"&'$ "99'&,+4$ %$ 5"2#),"+>$ 1'$ 8#5)$ 9,&5)$ #+*'&5)%+*$ )3'$

-#%+*%&:/$0)$,5$8"+5)&"#5/$

$

"

!"

!"#$%&'()(

*+%',-./%0,+(

123(!#'4,5(6#'#7(

(

!"#"$%#&'$#()$*#'#+'(%#,'-#"./#("0#

1)2+%3(# )(# +"&)%/-# )+# +,%%4)$5#

/",'0*+# *%+/0.&/)"$6# 71%0%("0%#

%8%0-"$%9# )$# 1)+# ",$# )$/%0%+/+9#

2.+/#/10.+/#1)2+%3(#8)5"0".+3-#)$/"#

/1%# )$/%33%&/.'3# :'//3%6# !"$%# &'$#

+/'$*# '+)*%# ,)/1# .$&"$&%0$;# /1%#

)$/%0%+/+# "(# %8%0-"$%# 1'$5# "$# /1%#

0%+.3/+6#

<=.*,)5#8"$#>)+%+?#

#

#$"%&"'("#)*("+&"#)*(",&-($.""

/0" +#(" 1)+(" (2&-&,320" 45&6(00&5" 71)5(-2("

7)50&-"(891)3-(%:"+#30"30"+#("+$9("&6";<(0+3&-"$&<")5(",&0+"13=(1$"+&"

#()5"65&,")"$&<->"2#31%?"@&'(*(5:"'#(-")"2#31%")0=0")";<(0+3&-"13=("

+#30"+#(5("30"-&"5()1"3-+(5(0+"3-"=-&'3->")-$+#3->")A&<+"+#("&53>3-"&6"

,&-($:"&5"#&'" 3+" 6<-2+3&-0:"&5"(*(-")A&<+" +#(" 6)2+" +#)+" 3+" 30"&-1$")"

,(%3<,"&6"(82#)->(?"/2+<)11$:"+#(";<(0+3&-"0+(,0"(-+35(1$"65&,"+#("

3%()" +#)+" +#(" +#3->0" +#(" 2#31%" ')-+0" 2&0+" ,&-($" )-%" #(" %&(0" -&+"

#)*("(-&<>#"&6"3+?"B&"3-"(00(-2(:"+#("2#31%C0"5()1";<(0+3&-"30"'#$"#("

D"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

E"

2)-C+"#)*("'#)+(*(5"#("')-+0:"'#(-"#("')-+0"3+:"'3+#&<+"+#(5("A(3->"

)"2&0+")++)2#(%"+&"3+?F#

G&':"'#(-"'("0+(9"A)2=")-%"0(53&<01$"+#3-=")A&<+"3+:"+#30"30")"

*(5$">&&%";<(0+3&-")-%"-&+"&-1$"&6"2#31%5(-:"A<+")10&"&6")%<1+0?"H+"30")"

;<(0+3&-"+#)+"%&(0"-&+"95(00"&-"<0" +&&",<2#:"0&" 1&->")0" +#3->0")5("

>&3->"'(11" (2&-&,32)11$" )-%"'(" )11" #)*(" 0<66323(-+" 3-2&,(0" +&" 9)$"

6&5"+#("+#3->0"'("')-+")-%"-((%:"A<+"'#)+"#)99(-0"'#(-")11"&6"+#)+"

2#)->(0:")0"3-"+#("+$9("&6"2#)->(0"'(")5(")11"(89(53(-23->"+&%)$.""/11"

&6" )" 0<%%(-" +#(" )1)5," A(110" 0+)5+" +&" >&" &66" )-%" (*(5$&-(" 0+)5+0"

21),&53->"6&5")-0'(50")A&<+",&-($?"

H+"')0")2+<)11$"+#("'3%(095()%"21),&5"6&5"+#(0(")-0'(50"+#)+"

')0"&-("&6"+#("953-239)1",&+3*)+3&-0"6&5"+#("'53+3->"&6"+#30"A&&=?"H+"

)11"A(>)-"'3+#"+#(")1)5,3->"9)-32"+#)+"095()%"+#5&<>#&<+"+#("'&51%"

3-"+#("()51$"6)11"&6"FIIJ?""@(5("3-"+#("K?B?"3+"')0"(*3%(-+"(*(5$'#(5(?""

L*(5$"%)$:"6&5"'((=0"&-"(-%:"9(&91("'(5("+5)-0638(%"+&"+#(35"MN"0(+0"

)0" +#($" 130+(-(%" +&" +#3->0" +#($" #)%" %36632<1+$" 2&,95(#(-%3->:" A<+"

=-('" )11" +&&" '(11" +#)+" +#($" '(5(" (89(53(-23->" )" #&553632" 63-)-23)1"

,(1+%&'-" <-13=(" )-$" &+#(5" +#($" #)%" (*(5" '3+-(00(%?" M#("

<-2(5+)3-+$" +#(" 253030" 25()+(%" 6&5" (*(5$&-("')0" 3,9&003A1(" +&"#3%("

)-%" 3+" ')0" )99)5(-+" 3-" (*(5$%)$" 2&-*(50)+3&-0?"O&0+" -&+)A1$"')0"

+#(" 6()5" 3+" >(-(5)+(%" ),&->" 02#&&12#31%5(-" 65&," 03,91$" &A0(5*3->"

+#("0+)+("&6")-83(+$"3-"+#("6)2(0"&6"+#(35"9)5(-+0?""/,(532)-0:")1,&0+"

3-" <-30&-:" 2),(" +&" 5()13P(" 3-" )" *(5$" 9(50&-)1"')$" #&'" 65)>31(" &<5"

(-+35(" (2&-&,32" 0$0+(," #)%" A(2&,(" )0" +#($" '3+-(00(%" >3)-+"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

Q"

63-)-23)1" 0+5<2+<5(0" 25<,A1(?" H-" 6)2+:" 2&11)90(" &6" +#(" (-+35(" K?B?"

63-)-23)1" 0$0+(," %3%" -&+" (02)9(" )-$&-(C0",3-%:" (*(-" +#(",3-%0" &6"

+#(",&0+"0&9#30+32)+(%"(2&-&,32"(89(5+0?""

M&%)$"'(")5(" 1(6+"'3+#" +#(")6+(5,)+#"&6" +#("()51$"9#)0(0"&6"

&<5"95(0(-+" 63-)-23)1" 63)02&"'3+#",)-$"/,(532)-0"-&'"#)*3->" 1&0+"

+#(35" A<03-(00(0:" +#(35" R&A0" )-%" (-+35(" 136(" 0)*3->0?" M#(" %5),)+32"

25)0#" &6" +#(" 0+&2=" ,)5=(+" )-%" 3+0" (55)+32" A(#)*3&5" 03-2(:" 2&<91(%"

'3+#" +#(" 2&11)90(" &6" +#(" 5()1" (0+)+(" ,)5=(+:" #)0" 1(6+" 9(&91("

(*(5$'#(5(")0=3->S",1%0%#)$#/1%#,"03*#*"#-".#4./#-".0#2"$%-#$",A"

G&" &-(:" #&'(*(5:" 30:" &5" 2)-" A(:" 2&-63%(-+" 3-" #30" )-0'(5?" T()5" &6"

%&<A1(U%3>3+"3-61)+3&-:"(*(-"#$9(53-61)+3&-:"30"&-"+#(",3-%0"&6",)-$?"

V&1%")-%"><-0:">5&'3->"0+)+30+32)11$"#3>#"3-"%(,)-%:")5("(*3%(-2("&6"

+#(" <-2(5+)3-+$" &6" &<5" 6<+<5(?" /0" &<5" -)+3&-" 0+5<>>1(0" '3+#" +#(0("

95&A1(,0:" )0" 3+" )++(,9+0" +&" 5(%(63-(:" &5" 25()+(" )" -('" 0(-0(" &6"

%35(2+3&-:",)-$"#)*(")15()%$"1&0+")11"#&9("3-"+#("(2&-&,32"953-2391(0"

+#)+"&-2(",)%("+#30"2&<-+5$">5()+?"M#("(-+35("3%()")-%"#&9("&6")"65(("

,)5=(+" (2&-&,$" 30" 3-" 253030?" /" 5(2(-+" W53+30#" W5&)%2)0+3->"

7&59&5)+3&-" 9&11" )25&00" FX" %366(5(-+" 2&<-+53(0" 0#&'(%" JYZ"&6" +#("

FY:III" 3-%3*3%<)10" ;<(0+3&-(%" '(5(" %30311<03&-(%" '3+#" 2)93+)130,?"

M#30"30"'#$"+#&0("&6"<0"'#&"0+311"A(13(*("3-"+#(",)5=(+")-%"')-+"-&"

9)5+"&6"0&23)130,")5("%(,)-%3->"5(13)A1(")-0'(50"+&"#(19"<-5)*(1")11"

&6"+#("63-)-23)1"2&-6<03&-["

\6"2&<50(:"+#30"30"-&+")"-('"95&A1(,?"/0"-('")0"3+",)$"0((,"

+&"&<5"95(0(-+">(-(5)+3&-"3-"FI]I:"+#("0+5<>>1("6&5"+#("2&-+5&1"&*(5"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

^"

,&-($" 30")0"&1%")0",)-=3-%:"A<+"&-("0<5("91)2("+&"A(>3-"+#(";<(5$"

)A&<+" ,&-($" '3+#3-" +#(" K-3+(%" B+)+(0" 30" '3+#" +#30" 0+)5=" )-%"

9)5),&<-+" 5()13P)+3&-S" \K_" O\GL`" HB" G\M" TKaa`" HG" \K_"

7\GM_\a?"8"&( /&+%'#4( 2#+9( ,:( %"&( ;+0%&-( <%#%&5=%"&( >&-&'#4(

?&5&'@&="#5( #( /,A$4&%&( A,+,$,43( ,+( ,.'( A,+&3( #+-( %"05(

/,+%',4(05(A#+-#%&-(23(,.'(:&-&'#4(B,@&'+A&+%C"M#30"%&,3-)+3&-"

&6"&<5"(-+35(",&-(+)5$"0$0+(,"#)0"#)%"0(*(5("(2&-&,32")-%",&5)1"

5),3632)+3&-0?" M#(" (66(2+0" &6" +#30" ,&-&9&1$" )5(" +#(" 953,(" 5()0&-"

'#$"+#("*)1<("&6"&<5",&-($"#)0"6)11(-"0&,("YQZ"03-2("+#("T(%(5)1"

_(0(5*(C0"6&<-%3->"3-"]Y]!")-%"3+"30"+#("%35(2+"2)<0("&6"&<5"2<55(-+"

63-)-23)1" 253030?" D(" 2)--&+" (*(5" #&9(" +&" A(>3-" +&" +#3-=" )-%" 0(("

,&-($" '3+#" 21)53+$" <-+31" +#30" 5()13P)+3&-" 30" (89&0(%" )-%" 6<11$"

<-%(50+&&%?"M&"A(>3-"+)1=3->")A&<+"+#("65((",)5=(+:",&-($:"0)*3->0:"

3-+(5(0+:" 25(%3+:" 3-*(0+,(-+0" &5" A)-=3->" '3+#&<+" 6350+" #)*3->" )"

2&,91(+(">5)09"&6"+#30"+5<+#:"+#("6)2+"+#)+"'(")5("<-%(5"+#(">539"&6")"

2(-+5)11$" 91)--(%" ,&-($" ,(2#)-30,:" 1()%0" -&'#(5(" A<+" +&" (*(-"

>5()+(5" 2&-6<03&-" )-%" %30(-2#)-+,(-+?" @&'(*(5:" 3-" &5%(5" 6&5" +#30"

+5<+#"+&"A("6<11$">5)09(%"A$"+#(")*(5)>("K?B?"23+3P(-b+&"+#("%(>5(("

+#)+" 9<A132" &93-3&-" 2)-" (66(2+" )" 5()1" 2#)->(" )+" +#(" +&9" (2#(1&-0" &6"

>&*(5-,(-+b'311"+)=("-&+#3->"0#&5+"&6")",35)21(?"@&'"3-"+#("'&51%"

%&" $&<" +)=(" +#(" 953-+3->" 95(00" )')$" 65&," >&*(5-,(-+" &-2(" +#($"

#)*("#)%" 6<11"<0("&6" 3+")11" +#(0(",)-$"$()50."K-+31" +#30" 30"%&-(:"&<5"

K-3+(%"B+)+(0"'311" 2&-+3-<(" +&"#()%"%&'-")"9)+#"&6" 0&23)1:"9&13+32)1"

)-%"(2&-&,32"%(0+5<2+3&-?"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

X"

`(0:" 3+" 30" +5<(?" H+" 30" )11" 0&" #<>(1$" &*(5'#(1,3->" )-%"

#&9(1(00c+&&" A3>" +&" 638?" H-" 6)2+:" R<0+" #&'" '&<1%" &-(" >&" )A&<+"

2#)->3->" 0<2#" )" ,&-0+5&<0" 95&A1(,." D#(-" 136(" 30" 0#&5+" )-%" +#("

,&,(-+"&6")"9&003A1("*32+&5$"0&"6)5"3-"+#("6<+<5(:"'#$"(*(-"A&+#(5."

D#)+"30"+#("9&3-+"&6"(*(-"+5$3->."D(11:"6350+"&6")11"2&-03%(5"+#30:")-%"

2&-03%(5"3+"0(53&<01$?"H6"2#)->("%&(0"-&+"&22<5"#(5("3-"+#30"2&<-+5$:")"

2&<-+5$"'#(5("2#)->("30"0+311"9&003A1(:"+#(5("30"-&"91)2("(10("1(6+"&-"

+#30" 91)-(+" 6&5" )-" (02)9(?" M#(" (-+35("'&51%" &9(5)+(0" A$" +#30" 0),("

21&0(%" )-%" 2&-+5&11(%" ,&-(+)5$" 0$0+(,?" V&*(5-,(-+" ,)-%)+(%"

9)9(5",&-($" )-%" A)-=3->" 0$0+(,0" )5(" (*(5$'#(5([" H-" +#(" K-3+(%"

B+)+(0"+#("2(-+5)1"A)-="30"+#("T(%(5)1"_(0(5*(:"3-"+#("K?d?"+#("2(-+5)1"

A)-="30"+#("W)-="&6"L->1)-%:"3-"H+)1$"3+"30"+#("L<5&9()-"7(-+5)1"W)-="

)-%"0&"&-"3-"(*(5$",)R&5"6&5(3>-"2&<-+5$?"M#("9&'(5")-%">5&'+#"&6"

>&*(5-,(-+0" (*(5$'#(5(" )5(" 6<(1(%" A$" +#(0(" ,&-&9&1$" 0$0+(,0"

)-%"+#(35">5&'+#"#)0"2<+"3-+&"+#(";<)13+$"&6"136("6&5")11"3-%3*3%<)10"+&"

0+)>>(53->" 95&9&5+3&-0?" H+" 30" 13=(" )" *35<0:" 9)5)03+32" 3-" -)+<5(" )-%"

'#32#"'311" (*(-+<)11$" =311" +#(" #&0+?" H6"'(" %&" -&+",)=(" )-" (66&5+" +&"

2#)->("3+"#(5("3-"&<5"2&<-+5$"-&':"3+"'311"-(*(5"2#)->(")-%"36"'("%&"

-&+"0+(9"6&5')5%"+&"#(19"2#)->("3+:"-&"&-("'311?""

B(2&-%:" +#(5(" 30"-&"5)+3&-)1"5()0&-"+&"'&5=",$0(16")-%"$&<:"

+#(" 5()%(5:" <9" 3-+&" )" 5(*&1<+3&-)5$" 65(-P$" <-1(00" '(" 0+&9" 1&->"

(-&<>#"+&"5()13P("+#)+"'(")5("1&03->"0&,(+#3->"*(5$"95(23&<0c"B.0#

(0%%*"2C"M&"A53->"+#30"3-+&"9(509(2+3*(:"2&-03%(5"+#)+"+#(")A<-%)-2("

+#)+"'(" 0((" )-%" #)*(:" &<5" #3>#" 0+)-%)5%" &6" 13*3->" +#)+",&0+" &6" <0"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

J"

(-R&$" +&%)$:" 2),(" 3-+&" (830+(-2("A$" )",&*(,(-+" >(5,3-)+(%" 65&,"

+#(" 3%()"&6" 65((%&,?"M#30",&*(,(-+"(891&%(%"#(5(" 3-" +#30"2&<-+5$"

65&,"+#("2&1&-3)1"%)$0"<-+31"]Y]Eb)"*(5$"A53(6"9(53&%"&6"0&,("]QI"

$()50["7&,9)5(%"+&"+#("(-+35("#30+&5$"&6"+#("'&51%"+#30" 30"),)P3->[""

D(",<0+:"+#(5(6&5(:"5(*(50("+#30"+5(-%"6&5"3+"30"9&003A1("+#)+"'(",)$"

-(*(5"#)*("+#("&99&5+<-3+$"+&"%&"0&")>)3-?"

"eMf)=(c+#(" >5()+" 21)0032)1" 13A(5)1c5(*&1<+3&-)5$" ,&*(,(-+" &6"

+#("0(*(-+((-+#:"(3>#+((-+#:")-%"-3-(+((-+#"2(-+<53(0?"M#(0("&<5"

)-2(0+&50" 25()+(%" )" *)0+:" 095)'13->:" )-%" A53113)-+" 5(*&1<+3&-)5$"

,&*(,(-+:" -&+" &-1$" 3-" +#(" K-3+(%" B+)+(0" A<+" +#5&<>#&<+" +#("

D(0+(5-"'&51%:"+#)+"1)0+(%"6&5"2(-+<53(0?"M#30"')0"+#(",&*(,(-+"

1)5>(1$" 5(09&-03A1(" 6&5" 5)%32)11$" 2#)->3->" #30+&5$:" 6&5" )1,&0+"

%(0+5&$3->"#30+&5$")0"3+"')0"95(*3&<01$"=-&'-"+&",)-?"T&5"A(6&5("

+#(0(" 2(-+<53(0:" +#(" #30+&5$" &6" ,)-:" '3+#" &-(" &5" +'&" 1<,3-&<0"

(82(9+3&-0:" ')0" )" %)5=" )-%" >&5$" 5(2&5%" &6" +$5)--$" )-%"

%(09&+30,:" )" 5(2&5%" &6" *)53&<0" )A0&1<+(" B+)+(0" )-%" ,&-)52#0"

25<0#3->" )-%" (891&3+3->" +#(35" <-%(51$3->" 9&9<1)+3&-0:" 1)5>(1$"

9()0)-+0:"'#&" 13*(%")"A53(6" )-%"A5<+30#" 136(" )+" A)5(" 0<A030+(-2(:"

%(*&3%" &6" #&9(" &5" 95&,30(?" H+" ')0" )" 21)0032)1" 13A(5)130," )-%"

5)%32)130,"+#)+"A5&<>#+"+&"+#(",)00"&6"9(&91("+#)+"#&9(")-%"+#)+"

95&,30(:")-%"'#32#"1)<-2#(%"+#(">5()+"95&2(00"&6"6<16311,(-+?"/11"

+#)+" ,)-" #)0" )2#3(*(%" +&%)$:" 3-" 95&>5(00:" 3-" #&9(:" 3-" 13*3->"

0+)-%)5%0:" '(" 2)-" )++53A<+(" +&" +#(" 5(*&1<+3&-)5$",&*(,(-+:" +&"

+#)+"g5(*&1<+3&-h?"M#30">5()+"5(*&1<+3&-"')0"&<5"6)+#(5i"3+" 30"-&'"

&<5"+)0="+&"2&,91(+("3+0"<-63-30#(%"95&,30(?!###

"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

Y"

" M#35%:" )-%" ,&0+" 3,9&5+)-+:" 30" +#)+" )" ,&*(,(-+" 6&5" 5()1"

2#)->(" 2)--&+" 9&003A1$" A(" (66(2+3*(" 36" 3+" 0+)5+0" 65&," +#(" +&9" %&'-"

j>&*(5-,(-+"%&'-"+&"+#("3-%3*3%<)1"23+3P(-k?"M#(">(-(030"6&5"2#)->("

,<0+" 0+)5+" '3+#" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1?" H+" ,<0+" #)*(" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1" )0" +#("

953-239)1"253+(53&-")-%"095()%"&<+")-%"<9"65&,"+#(5(?"M#30"#)99(-0"

&-1$" '#(-" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1C0" (2&-&,32" 0<5*3*)1" ;<(0+3&-0" )5("

)-0'(5(%" +&" #30" 6<11" 0)+306)2+3&-" )-%" '#(-" #(" (89(53(-2(0"

3,,(%3)+(" 5(0<1+0" 6&5" #3,0(16" 3-" +#(" (-%()*&5" #(" (,A)5=0" <9&-?"

M#)+"30"'#)+"+#30"A&&="30")A&<+?"M#30"30"&6"25<23)1"3,9&5+)-2("A(2)<0("

'#(-" +#(5(" )5(" 3,,(%3)+(" A(-(63+0" +&" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1" 65&," #30"

95&%<2+3*(" (66&5+0:" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1" +)=(0" -&+32(" )-%" 3,,(%3)+(1$"

0((=0" +&" %<9132)+(" 3+?"D#(-"#(" 0((0" +#)+" +#(" A(-(63+0" #(" >)3-0" )10&"

#(19"0&23(+$")0")"'#&1(:"#("30"(-2&<5)>(%")-%",&+3*)+(%"+&"3-*&1*("

&+#(50:"A(>3--3->"'3+#"#30"&'-"6),31$",(,A(50")-%"+#(-"(*(5$&-("

(10(" '3+#3-" #30" 23521(" &6" 2&-+)2+0?" M#30" +$9(" &6" >&&%" -('0" )1')$0"

095()%0:"01&'1$"3-"+#("A(>3--3->:"A<+"+#(-"0<%%(-1$"3+"+<5-0"3-+&")-"

(*)->(130+32"(891&03&-?"/",&*(,(-+" +#)+"'&5=0" 3-" +#30",)--(5"2)-"

;<32=1$" +)=(" &-" )" 136(" &6" 3+0" &'-" )-%" 095()%" <-+31" 9<A132" &93-3&-"

>5&'0:"6&523->"+#("<99(5"(2#(1&-0"&6">&*(5-,(-+"+&",)=("*3+)1")-%"

-(2(00)5$" 2#)->(0?" H-" +#(" (-%:" )11" (2&-&,32"9&1323(0" )5("<1+3,)+(1$"

%(9(-%(-+" &-" +#(" *3('0" &6" +#(" >(-(5)1" 9<A132" )-%" +#(35" 2#&32(" 30"

63-)1[" H+" 30" +#(",)00(0" +#)+" %(+(5,3-(" +#(" 2&<50(" &6" #30+&5$:" A<+" 3+0"

3-3+3)1",&*(,(-+",<0+"0+)5+"'3+#"+#("3-%3*3%<)1?"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]I"

T&5" +#(0(" +#5((" 3,9&5+)-+" 5()0&-0" +#30" A&&=" 2&-+)3-0"

3-6&5,)+3&-" +&" ><3%(" )-%" (,9&'(5" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1?" H+" %(0253A(0" 3-"

%(+)31" +#5((" 3-%(9(-%(-+" 3%()0" +#)+" )5(" )15()%$" )+"'&5=" 095()%3->"

)-%" >)3-3->",&,(-+<," +#5&<>#&<+" +#(" >5)005&&+0" &6" &<5" 2&<-+5$?"

M#(" 9(&91(" )-%" 3-0+3+<+3&-0" 3-*&1*(%" '3+#" +#(0(" 3%()0" )5("

'&-%(56<11$"25()+3*(["/1+#&<>#"%30+3-2+:"+#(0("3%()0")5("0&"<-3;<(1$"

3-+(5+'3-(%" +#)+" A53->3->" +#(," +&>(+#(5" )0" &-(" 9&'(56<1" ,<1+3U

%3,(-03&-)1"(1(,(-+"3-"+#30"A&&="')0"-)+<5)1?"M#(0("+#5(("3%()0")5("

/<0+53)-" L2&-&,320:" +#(" B&<-%" O&-($" B&1<+3&-" )-%" 453*)+3P(%"

W)-=3->" )0" A(0+" %(0253A(%" A$" +#(" D$()$)/%# E'$F)$5# G"$&%4/:" )" A&&="

'53++(-"A$"_?"G(10&-"G)0#?"\-2("6<11$"<-%(50+&&%:"+#(0("+#5(("3%()0"

95&*3%("+#("A)030"6&5")"6&5,<1)"'3+#"9&'(56<1"+<5-U)5&<-%"%$-),320"

+#)+",)$"A("3,91(,(-+(%"A$"*35+<)11$")-$"3-%3*3%<)1?"M#("5(0<1+"30")"

953*)+("(2&-&,32"(-+(59530(")-%"0(16U9(59(+<)+3->"+()2#3->"+&&1"+#)+"

95&*3%(0" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1" +#(" 0)*3->0:" A)-=3->" )-%" 63-)-23->"

2)9)A313+3(0" #(" -((%0" +&" )2;<35(" )11" &6" #30",)+(53)1" -((%0:" 91<0" +#("

9&'(5" +&" 13+(5)11$" 5(2&-0+5<2+" -)+3&-)1",&-(+)5$" 9&132$?" H+" 30" +#(0("

A(-(63+0" +#)+" )5(" +#(" =($" +&" =((93->" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1" 3-0935(%" )0" #("

095()%0" +#(" ,(00)>(" +&" &+#(50?" /0" +#(" ,(00)>(" >5&'0:" 9<A132"

&93-3&-"'311"2#)->(?"

M#30" 9&'(56<1" 2&,A3-)+3&-" 30" +#(" g-('h# 3%()" 95(0(-+(%" 3-"

+#30" A&&=?" M#30" 30:" 63-)11$:" )" 0&1<+3&-" +#)+" )-0'(50" +#(" ;<(0+3&-" &6"

'#)+" &-("9(50&-" 2)-" )2+<)11$" %&" +#)+"'311",)=(" )" %366(5(-2(" 3-" )-"

(2&-&,32"(-*35&-,(-+"+#)+"#)0">&-("+(553A1$")'5$?""D#(-"$&<"A(>3-"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]]"

6350+" '3+#" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1C0" &'-" 953*)+(" (2&-&,32" )66)350:" +#3->0"

2#)->(" 3,,(%3)+(1$" 6&5" +#(" A(++(5?" H+" A(2&,(0" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1C0"

(02)9(" 5&<+(" +&" 65((%&,?" T<5+#(5,&5(:" +#(" B&<-%"O&-($" B&1<+3&-"

0<99&5+0" +#30" 3%()" )-%" /<0+53)-" (2&-&,320" 2&-635,0" 3+?" O&5("

3,9&5+)-+1$:" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1" 2)-" >&" 3-+&" +#(" (2&-&,32" (-+(59530("

3,,(%3)+(1$" 5(>)5%1(00"&6" +#("A53%1(%",&-($" 0$0+(,"#(",)$"A(" 3-"

)-%"'#)+" 30">&3->"&-")11")5&<-%"#3," 3-" +#("95(0(-+"0&23)1:"9&13+32)1"

)-%"(2&-&,32"(-*35&-,(-+?"/1+#&<>#"#30"#&9("5(0+0"3-"+#("<1+3,)+("

+53<,9#" &6" +#(" B&<-%" O&-($" B&1<+3&-:" '#32#" 30" 2#)->3->" +#("

-)+3&-)1" ,&-(+)5$" 9&132$:" +#(" 95&2(00" #(" 30" (->)>3->" #(190" +#5<0+"

6&5')5%" +#(" /<0+53)-" L2&-&,32",(00)>("'#31(" )%*)-23->" #30" &'-"

9(50&-)1"(2&-&,32"A(-(63+0"3-"+#("#(5(")-%"-&'?"

M#("3%()"30"0&"5)+3&-)1"+#)+" 3+"0#&<1%"-&+")+")11"A("%36632<1+"+&"

>5)09?"/11" +#)+" 30" 5(;<35(%" 30")-"&9(-",3-%:" +#("<-%(50+)-%3->"&6")"

6('"<-%(-3)A1(" (2&-&,32" 953-2391(0:" +#(" <0(" &6" 03-2(5(" 2&-*32+3&-:"

2&,,&-" 0(-0(:" 3,)>3-)+3&-:" 2&<5)>(" )-%:" )A&*(" )11:" %3023913-(?"

@&9(6<11$:" 3-" +#(0(" 6350+" 6('" A(>3--3->" 9)5)>5)9#0:" +#(" 5()%(5C0"

)99(+3+(" #)0" A((-" '#(++(%" (-&<>#" +&" ')-+" +&" A(2&,(" ,&5("

)2;<)3-+(%" '3+#" +#(" 95&2(00?" /6+(5" <-%(50+)-%3->" +#(" 3%()" 21()51$"

)-%">3*3->"3+"0(53&<0"+#&<>#+:"3+"'311"-)+<5)11$"6&11&'"+#)+"+#("5()%(5"

'311"')-+"+&"(,A)5="<9&-"+#("(-%()*&5?""H-")2+3->:"A$"3,91(,(-+3->"

+#(" 95&2(00" 3-" #30" &'-" (2&-&,32" )66)350:" +#(" 5()%(5" 2&-635,0" +#("

3,,(%3)+(" A(-(63+0" &6" +#(" 3%()" )-%" )00<5(0" #3,0(16" +#)+" 3+" %&(0" 3-"

6)2+" 5()11$" '&5=[" M#30:" 3-" +<5-:" 1()%0" $&<" 3-+&" +(113->" &+#(50" )A&<+"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]F"

$&<5"-('U6&<-%" 3-%(9(-%(-2(")-%" 65((%&," +#(5(A$" 095()%3->" +#("

0&1<+3&-"6&5"&<5"2&<-+5$"(*(5$'#(5(?"

*

*B+,'0+B(%"&(D.5%'0#+5(E,%(;5(0+(8"05(F&55(

"

H-" A53->3->" +&>(+#(5" )11" &6" +#(" +#&<>#+0" 2&-+)3-(%" 3-" +#30"

A&&=:"3+"30"3,9&5+)-+"6&5"+#("5()%(5"+&"=-&'"+#)+"H"#)*("5(2(3*(%")-"

(-&5,&<0"),&<-+"&6"#(19")-%"+&"5(2&>-3P("+#("0&<52("&6"+#)+"#(19?"

M#30" 30" 3,9&5+)-+" A(2)<0(" 36" +#(" 5()%(5" 30" +&" 3,91(,(-+" +#(" 3%()"

95(0(-+(%"#(5(:"#("'311"3%()11$"-((%"+&"+)=("*(5$"03,31)5"0+(90"6&5")"

,&5("3-U%(9+#")-%"2&,91(+("<-%(50+)-%3->"&6" 3+?"T350+"&6")11:" H"#)*("

A(-(63+(%" 3,,(-0(1$" A$" A(3->" )" 0+<%(-+" )-%" 9)003&-)+(" 5()%(5" &6"

+#(" '53+3->0" &6" +#(" >5()+" 21)0032)1" -)+<5)1" 1)'" +#(&530+0" 6&<-%" 3-"

/<0+53)-"(2&-&,320?"M#(0(",(-b0(*(5)1"&6"'#&,"95(%)+(%"/%),"

B,3+#:"'#&"6),&<01$">)*("(895(003&-"+&"3')++%HI(')0%"3-"]XX^b#)*("

2&,("%&'-" +&"<0" +#5&<>#"'53++(-"#30+&5$" 311<,3-)+3->" +#("%36632<1+"

)-%" +#(" <-0((-" &-" )11" +#3->0" #)*3->" +&" %&" '3+#" (2&-&,320?" H-",$"

&'-" 9(50&-)1" 0()52#" 6&5" +#(" +5<+#" 3-" +#(" (2&-&,32" )-%" 63-)-23)1"

5()1,:"H"#)*("6&<-%"-&"9)5)11(1")-%"&-1$"'30#"+#)+"H"#)%"#()5%")A&<+"

+#(,"()513(5"3-",$"136(?"D#)+")"%366(5(-2("+#)+"'&<1%"#)*(",)%(["H-"

O)52#"&6"FIIY:"R<0+"038",&-+#0")6+(5"+#("(2&-&,32"253030"&22<55(%:")"

5)5(" )-%" 3-+(5(0+3->" )5+321(" )99()5(%" 3-" +#(" 63-)-23)1" 9<A132)+3&-:"

E'00"$J+:"(-+3+1(%:"gH>-&53->"+#("/<0+53)-0"V&+"K0"3-"M#30"O(00?hE"M#("

)5+321(# 9&3-+(%" &<+" +#)+" +#(" /<0+53)-" 95(02539+3&-0" +&" 0&1*(" +#("

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]!"

'&51%C0" (2&-&,32"95&A1(,0"'(5(" 6350+" 3>-&5(%"A$" +#("G('"l()1" &6"

T5)-=13-" l?" _&&0(*(1+?" M#)+" ')0" 0(*(-+$U63*(" $()50" )>&[" /" >53,"

5(,3-%(5" +#)+" +#(" 5(6<0)1" +&" )22(9+" 0&<-%" (2&-&,32" +#3-=3->" #)0"

>&-(" &-" 3-" +#30" 2&<-+5$" 6&5" ;<3+(" 0&,(" +3,(?" H-0+()%:" d($-(03)-"

L2&-&,320" #)0" -&'" A(2&,(" (-+5(-2#(%" 3-" 0&23(+$" (*(5$'#(5(?"

L*(5$" ,)R&5" <-3*(503+$" 65&," @)5*)5%" &-" %&'-" 30" *(0+(%" 3-" +#30"

(55&-(&<0" ')$" &6" (2&-&,32" +#3-=3->?" /25&00" 9)5+$" 13-(0:" )0"

0<A0+)-+3)+(%"A$"+#("W<0#")-%"-&'"+#("\A),)")%,3-30+5)+3&-:"'3+#"

+#("mXII"A3113&-"%&11)5"M/_4"3-"1)+("FIIJ")-%"+#("mXJX"A3113&-"%&11)5"

0+3,<1<0" )" 6('" ,&-+#0" 1)+(5:" +#(" 5(R(2+3&-" &6" 0&<-%" (2&-&,320"

&A*3&<01$" 2&-+3-<(0?" M#(5(6&5(:" '3+#&<+" ;<(0+3&-:" &-(" &6" +#("

953-239)1")-%"3,9(5)+3*(">&)10"&6"+#30"A&&="30"6&5"()2#"5()%(5"+&"A("

3-0935(%"A$" )-"<5>(-+" ;<(0+" 6&5" =-&'1(%>(" &6" /<0+53)-" (2&-&,320?""

M#30"%&(0"-&+"3,91$"+#)+"&-(",<0+">&"A)2="+&"02#&&1")-%"A(2&,(")-"

(2&-&,32"02#&1)5:"A<+"5)+#(5"+&"+)=("<9"5()%3->"3+"&-")"5(><1)5")-%"

2&-030+(-+"A)030?"M&%)$:"'3+#"+#("#(19"&6"+#("H-+(5-(+"3+"30"()0$["\-1$"

A$"0((3->"+#("'&51%"65&,"+#("/<0+53)-"(2&-&,32"9&3-+"&6"*3('"30"&-("

)A1(" +&" 0&5+" &<+" )-%" %30+3-><30#" >&&%" (2&-&,320" 65&," A)%"

(2&-&,320?"

"

G-./#%0+B(H,.'5&4:((

"

a()5-3->" &6" +#(" &53>3-0" )-%" A)032" +(-(+0" &6" /<0+53)-"

(2&-&,320" 30" &A*3&<01$" +#(" 6350+" 0+(9?" H+"'311" -&+" +)=(" 1&->" 3-" &-(C0"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]E"

0()52#" +&" (*(-+<)11$" A(" 1(%" +&"71%#>)+%+# D$+/)/./%" j,,,62)+%+6"05K"

)-%"71%# L".$*'/)"$# ("0# M&"$"2)&# M*.&'/)"$# N,,,6(%%6"05K:" +'&" &6"

+#(" 1()%3->" )-%" ,&0+" 5(2&>-3P(%" 3-%(9(-%(-+" &5>)-3P)+3&-0"

2&,,3++(%"+&"095()%3->"65((",)5=(+"3%()0"#(5("3-"+#("K-3+(%"B+)+(0?Q""

/+"+#(0("+'&"'(A03+(0"$&<"'311"63-%")"'&51%"&6"311<,3-)+3->"(2&-&,32"

)5+321(0:" A&&=0:" 7l0:" lNl0" )-%" 02#&1)51$" R&<5-)10" +#)+" 2)-" A("

&A+)3-(%"65&,"+#(0("63-("953*)+("3-0+3+<+3&-0b,<2#"&6"3+"6&5"65((?"H6"

+#("5()%(5"30"#()53->"&6"+#("/<0+53)-"02#&&1"&6"+#&<>#+"6&5"+#("*(5$"

6350+" +3,(:" +#(0(" 953*)+(" 3-0+3+<+3&-0" )5(" 2(5+)3-1$" +#(" A(0+" 91)2(" +&"

0+)5+" )-%" 2&-+3-<(" )2;<353->" +#(" (%<2)+3&-" -((%(%?"I,J&@&'K( :,'(

$.'$,5&5(,:(50A$40:0/#%0,+K("&'&(05(J"#%(A#3(2&(/,+50-&'&-(%"&(

A,5%( 0A$,'%#+%( -05%0+/%0,+5( ,:( %"05( $#'%0/.4#'( 5/",,4( ,:(

&/,+,A0/(%"0+90+BC("

T350+"&6")11"3+"30"3,9&5+)-+"+&"5()13P("+#)+"+#("/<0+53)-"B2#&&1:"

)1+#&<>#" '&51%'3%(:" 30" -&'" ,&0+" 2(-+5)11$" 1&2)+(%" 3-" +#(" K-3+(%"

B+)+(0?" H+" 30" -&+" )" 9#$032)1" 02#&&1" &5"91)2(:" A<+" 5)+#(5" )-" (2&-&,32"

')$"&6"+#3-=3->?"H+0"95(%(2(00&50"6350+"&53>3-)+(%"3-"B9)3-"3-"+#("]^+#"

7(-+<5$:" A<+" 0&,(" &6" +#(" ,&5(" 3-61<(-+3)1" /<0+53)-" 02#&1)50" '(5("

65&,"N3(--):"/<0+53)?"/0")">(-(5)1"5<1(:"+#("953-2391("&6"+(,$()#-#)-%"

+#("2&-2(9+"&6"(.%)(/")5(")+"+#("2(-+(5"&6"/<0+53)-"(2&-&,320?"L*(5$"

)2+3&-" A$" (*(5$" )2+&5" 3-" )-" (2&-&,$" #)0" 3+0" &'-" 0(+" &6" *)1<(0:"

95(6(5(-2(0:" -((%0:" %(035(0" )-%" +3,(" 02#(%<1(0" 6&5" +#(" >&)10"

3-+(-%(%"+&"A("5()2#(%?"D#$."W(2)<0("(2&-&,32"*)1<("30"0<AR(2+3*("

+&" +#(" 3-%3*3%<)1?" M#30" ,)=(0" +#(" /<0+53)-" (2&-&,30+" 0((" +#("

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]Q"

2&,91(83+$" &6" )-" (2&-&,$:" )-%" (09(23)11$" +#(" ,)5=(+:" <-3;<(1$"

%366(5(-+" 65&,")11"&+#(5"02#&&10"&6" +#&<>#+?" "D#)+" 30" 5(,)5=)A1(" +&"

,(:"(*(-"-&':"30"+#)+:"2&-+5)5$"+&"+#("6)2+"+#)+"D)11"B+5((+:"+#(",(%3)"

)-%" ,&0+" &6" &<5" 9&13+32)1" 1()%(50" 3-" D)0#3->+&-" '(5(" 2)<>#+"

2&,91(+(1$"A$" 0<59530("'#(-" +#(" 63-)-23)1" 253030"#3+"<0" )11" 3-"FIIJ:"

+#(" /<0+53)-0" #)%" A((-" 95(%32+3->" 3+" )11" )1&->:" )-%" +#($" #)%" A((-"

%&3->"3+"6&5"%(2)%(0["

M#(5(" )5(" ,)-$" >5()+" 6&5(3>-" 02#&1)50" '#&" 2&<1%" A("

21)00363(%" )0" g/<0+53)-h" (2&-&,30+0:" 5(>)5%1(00" &6" +#(35" -)+3&-)13+$?"

M#(0("3-21<%("+#("T5(-2#"21)0032)1"(2&-&,30+0"n()-UW)9+30+("B)$")-%"

T5(%(532" W)0+3)+?" M#(" )2+<)1" 6&<-%3->" &6" +#(" /<0+53)-" B2#&&1"

&22<55(%"3-"]JX]"'3+#"+#("9<A132)+3&-"&6"7)51"O(->(5C0"O0.$*+P/H%9#

&5" Q0)$&)43%+# "(# M&"$"2)&+?" \+#(5" 6&5(3>-UA&5-" g/<0+53)-0h" 3-21<%("

L<>(-"*&-"Wo#,UW)'(5=:"D31#(1,"_o9=(")-%"G&A(1"453P(U'3--3->"

(2&-&,30+:"T?/?"@)$(=:" +&"-),("R<0+")" 6('?"/,(532)-UA&5-"/<0+53)-"

(2&-&,30+0" 3-21<%(" a(&-)5%" _()%:" @(-5$" @)P13++" )-%" O<55)$" G?"

_&+#A)5%" '3+#" +#(" 130+" >5&'3->" )-%" +&&" -<,(5&<0" +&" ,(-+3&-" )11"

#(5(?" @&'(*(5:" +#(",&0+" 2(1(A5)+(%" 63><5(" &6" +#(" /<0+53)-" B2#&&1:"

)-%"'#&0("2)5((5"A(>)-"0&,("]II"$()50")>&:" 30"a<%'3>"*&-"O30(0?"

M#30" >5()+" /<0+53)-" (2&-&,32" 02#&1)5" )22&,9130#(%" )" 6()+" -(*(5"

A(6&5(" %&-(" 3-" +#(" #30+&5$" &6" (2&-&,320?" @(" +&&=" 2(-+<53(0" &6"

02)++(5(%" (2&-&,32" +#3-=3->" )-%" A5&<>#+" 3+" )11" +&>(+#(5" 3-+&" &-("

2&,91(+(" 63(1%" &6" 0+<%$:"'#32#" #(" 2)11(%"40'R%"3"5-:" +#(" 023(-2(" &6"

#<,)-" )2+3&-?" H-" (00(-2(:" +#30" 023(-2(" <-%(502&5(%" +#(" 6)2+" +#)+"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]^"

A#+( #4J#35( #/%5( J0%"( #( $.'$,5&K( +&@&'( 0+( %"&( #BB'&B#%&K( 2.%(

#4J#35( #5( #+( 0+-0@0-.#4C" T&5" +#)+" 5()0&-:" ,)-" 2)--&+" A(" 91)2(%"

3-+&" )" 6&5,<1):" 2#)5+(%" &-" )" >5)9#:" &5" 91)2(%" 3-+&" )",)+#(,)+32)1"

2)12<1)+3&-" 6&5" )-$" +$9(" &6" 2(-+5)13P(%" 91)--3->" &5" 6&5(2)0+3->" )0"

,&%(5-" %)$" (2&-&,30+0" 3-030+" &-" %&3->?" D#)+" $&<" 1()5-" 65&,"

0+<%$3->"+#("'&5=0"&6"O30(0"30"+#)+"#("')0"&-("&6"+#&0("3-%3*3%<)10"

&6"3,9(22)A1("2#)5)2+(5"+#)+"2&,(0")1&->"&-1$"5)5(1$"3-"#30+&5$?"\-("

2&<1%" 0)$" +#)+" #(" 09(-+" #30" (-+35(" 136(" 63>#+3->" )-" 3%()" '3+#3-"

23*313P)+3&-" +#)+" ')0" 6)10(?" H-" 6)2+:" #(" A(13(*(%" +#30" 3%()" +&" A(" 0&"

%(1<03&-)1" )-%" %(0+5<2+3*(" +#)+" #(" 0)'" 3+" )0" )-" (*31" +#)+" -&" &-("

0#&<1%">3*(" 3-" +&?" H-",)-$"&A0(5*)A1("')$0:" 65&,"#30"'53+3->0")-%"

1(2+<5(0:" 3+" A(2),(" 21()5" +#)+" #(" ')0" -&+" 0&" ,<2#" +#3-=3->" &6"

#3,0(16:" A<+" 5)+#(5" 1&&=3->" )#()%" 2&-03%(53->" <0" 3-" &<5" %)$" )-%"

+3,(c&<5"=3%0")-%"&<5">5)-%=3%0?"M#("1(>)2$"+#)+"#("1(6+"A(#3-%:")+")"

>5()+"9(50&-)1"2&0+"+&"#3,0(16:"')0"+#("(-2&<5)>(,(-+"6&5")11"&6"<0"

+&" R&3-" 3-+&" +#30" 3-+(11(2+<)1" A)++1(" )-%" (*(-+<)11$" %(6()+" +#30" (*31"

3%()?"@("A(13(*(%"3+"+&"A(")",&5)1"5(09&-03A313+$"+#)+"()2#"&6"<0:"$&<"

)-%"H:"#)0"+&"0&23(+$?""

M&%)$:" 3+" 30" +#(" >5()+"'&5=" &6" +#("O30(0" H-0+3+<+(:" TLL:" )-%"

&+#(5" 0<2#" 953*)+(" 3-0+3+<+(0:" 6<-%(%" '3+#" -&" 2&--(2+3&-0" +&"

9&'(56<1" (13+(0:" +#)+" #)*(" A(2&,(" +#(" 2(-+(50" 6&5" 1()5-3->" +#("

(2&-&,32" 953-2391(0" +#)+" &<5" 2#31%5(-" )-%" >5)-%2#31%5(-" ,<0+" A("

+)<>#+?" M#($" 2&-+3-<(" +&" 6)-" +#(" 61),(" &6" 13A(5+$" A$" 9<A130#3->"

02#&1)51$" R&<5-)10:" 9<A130#3->"A&&=0:" #&1%3->" 2&-6(5(-2(0:" +()2#3->"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]X"

0+<%(-+0" )-%" #&1%3->" 0(,3-)50?" W(2)<0(" &6" +#(35" (66&5+0" 09)--3->"

,&5(" +#)-" Î" $()50" #(5(" 3-" /,(532):" #<-%5(%0" &6" +#&<0)-%0" #)*("

)15()%$" R&3-(%" 3-" +#(" 3-+(11(2+<)1" A)++1(" )-%" +#(" 2#)->(0" )5(" A(3->"

6(1+" (*(5$'#(5(?" M#(5(" 30" 6)3+#:" #&9(" )-%" (89(2+)-2$" )+" +#(0("

3-%(9(-%(-+" 02#&1)51$" 3-0+3+<+3&-0" +#)+" )" %5),)+32" 2#)->(" 3-" +#("

9&13+32)1" )-%" 0&23)1" 1)-%02)9(" 30" 53>#+" )5&<-%" +#(" 2&5-(5" )-%" 2)-"

#)99(-"-()51$"&*(5-3>#+"'#(-"+#(" 3%(&1&>32)1"2&-%3+3&-0")5("53>#+?"

M#(0(" 3-0+3+<+3&-0"2&-+3-<(" +&"95&*3%(" +#("(%<2)+3&-)1" 6<(1" +&"=((9"

+#("635("A<5-3->?"L*(5$"2&-023(-+3&<0"23+3P(-"0#&<1%"R&3-")-%"A(2&,("

)",(,A(5"&6"&-(?"/1&->"'3+#"+#30"A&&=:"+#(0(")5("+#("91)2(0"+&"A(>3-"

&-(C0"(%<2)+3&-)1" R&<5-($"&6"/<0+53)-"(2&-&,320"'#31(")+" +#("0),("

+3,("0+)$3->"3-*&1*(%"3-"+#30"A)++1("&*(5"+#(",3-%0"&6",(-?"

"

8"&(*+:0+0%&(L#+90+B(!,+/&$%(

"

H" )2=-&'1(%>(" &+#(5" >&&%" 653(-%0" )-%" 6(11&'" /<0+53)-0" )0"

3,9&5+)-+" 0&<52(0" &6" #(19" 6&5" +#("'53+3->" &6" +#30" A&&=?" l5?" 4)<1" /?"

71(*(1)-%:" 45&6(00&5" &6" L2&-&,320" )-%" T3-)-2(" )+" W35,3->#),"

B&<+#(5-" 7&11(>(:" '#&" '3+#&<+" ;<(0+3&-:" 30:" )-%" #)0" A((-:" ,$"

(2&-&,320" +()2#(5?" D#(-" '(" 6350+" ,(+" $()50" )>&" #(" ')0" )A1(" +&"

0<5,30(" ;<32=1$" )-%" )22<5)+(1$" '#(5(" H" ')0" 3-" ,$" R&<5-($" 3-+&"

(2&-&,320?"@("95&*3%(%"+#("-(2(00)5$"><3%)-2("6&5",("+&"2&-+3-<("

+&",&*(" 3-"+#("53>#+"%35(2+3&-")-%"2&-+3-<(0"+&"%&"+#)+" +&" +#30"%)$?"

M#(5(" 30" )10&" 7)-)%3)-UA&5-" l5?" _32#)5%" n?" V5)-+:" 45&6(00&5" &6"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]J"

L2&-&,320" )-%" T3-)-2(" )+" a3902&,A" K-3*(503+$:" '#&" 95&*3%(%"

3-*)1<)A1("3-03>#+0"3-+&"2<55(-+",&-(+)5$"9&132$"5(1)+3->"09(23632)11$"

+&" +#(" T(%(5)1" _(0(5*(" )-%" +#(" A)-=3->" 0$0+(,?" D3+#" #30" '3%("

(89(53(-2("&6"#)*3->"+)<>#+")-%"'&5=(%"3-"(3>#+"%366(5(-+"2&<-+53(0:"

#30")%*32("')0"3-0+5<,(-+)1"3-"#(193->"'3+#",3003->"93(2(0"H"#)%"-&+"

$(+";<3+(" 63><5(%"&<+?"/-%"+#(-:"&6"2&<50(:" +#(5(" 30",$"2&U)<+#&5"&6"

+#30"A&&=:"l5?"_&A(5+"4?"O<59#$?"/2+<)11$"$&<->(5"+#)-"0&,("&6",$"

&'-"2#31%5(-:"_&A(5+C0"(-(5>$")-%"9)003&-"6&5"#30"'&5=",)=(0"#3,:"

3-",$"&93-3&-:")"#&9(6<1">13,90("&6"+#("6<+<5("&6"/,(532)?"M#(5(")5(:"

&6"2&<50(:",)-$"&+#(50"+&"'#&,"H"&'(")">5()+"%()1"&6">5)+3+<%("6&5"

+#("+#&<>#+0"95&*3%(%"3-"+#30"A&&=:"A<+"'3+#",)-$")9&1&>3(0"'311"-&+"

A("130+(%?"""

H+"30")10&"95&A)A1$"'30("6&5",("+&"9&3-+"&<+"+#)+"3-"'53+3->"+#30"

A&&=:" H" #)*(" A&55&'(%" 3%()0" ;<3+(" 13A(5)11$" 65&," &+#(50?" H" %&<A+"

0(53&<01$"36"+#(5("30")-"&53>3-)1"3%()"3-"3+?"M#30"30")"0&5+"&6"A1)-=(+"$(+"

5(09(2+6<1")2=-&'1(%>(,(-+"&6")11"+#("25()+&50"&6"+#(0("3%()0"'#32#"

H"#)*("<0(%"'3+#&<+"0+&993->" +&">3*("&66323)1"25(%3+?"/+"A(0+:"_&A(5+"

)-%"H"#)*(")55)->(%"'#)+"'("+#3-=")5("A53113)-+"3%()0"3-")",)--(5"+&"

0<99&5+"'#)+"'("A(13(*(?"H6"+#("5()%(5"30"+)=(-"A$"+#30"A&&=")-%"+#("

13-("&6"+#&<>#+"3+"95&*3%(0:"+#(-"'("#)*(")22&,9130#(%"&<5"9<59&0("

3-"'53+3->" 3+?" a(+",(",)=(" 21()5:" #&'(*(5:" +#)+" +#(5(" 30" -&" >5()+(5"

3%()" 3-" +#30" A&&=" +#)+" 95&*3%(0" +#(" 2)+)1$+32" 6&52(" +&" (,9&'(5" +#("

3-%3*3%<)1:" +&" ,&*(" #3," +&" +)=(" 3,,(%3)+(" )2+3&-:" +#)-" +#(" 3%()"

95&*3%(%"A$"_?"G(10&-"G)0#")-%"#30"H-63-3+("W)-=3->"7&-2(9+"jHW7k?"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

]Y"

M#(5("'311"A(",&5("+&"0)$")A&<+"G(10&-")-%"HW7"1)+(5:"#&'(*(5:"H"'311"

0)$" -&'" +#)+" 3+"')0" G(10&-"'#&" 6350+" 0<>>(0+(%" H"'53+(" +#30" A&&=?"

D3+#" ()2#" (2&-&,32" )5+321(" H" '5&+(" )-%" %30+53A<+(%" +#5&<>#" +#("

H-+(5-(+:"#30"(-2&<5)>(,(-+"A$"')$"&6")"9(50&-)1"9#&-("2)11"'&<1%"

6&11&'?" H" '&<1%" #)*(" -(*(5" 2&-2(3*(%" &6" +#(" 3%()" +&" '53+(" )" A&&="

2&-+)3-3->",$"+#&<>#+0"#)%"3+"-&+"A((-"6&5"#30"<5>3->0:")+" 1()0+"-&+"

3-"+#("%35(2+3&-"#("=(9+"9<0#3->",(?"G(10&-:")" 1&->"+3,("0+<%(-+"&6"

/<0+53)-" (2&-&,320" 09)--3->" QF" $()50:" 2&<-0(1(%" ,(" )-%" 09&=("

'3+#",(")A&<+"+#(",(-+&53->"#("#)%"5(2(3*(%"()513(5"3-"#30"136("65&,"

a(&-)5%"_()%:" 6&<-%(5"&6"M#("T&<-%)+3&-" 6&5"L2&-&,32"L%<2)+3&-"

jTLLk?"M#("3%()0"6&5"G(10&-C0"A&&="&-"+#("H-63-3+("W)-=3->"7&-2(9+"

#)%" 2&,(" %35(2+1$" 65&," /<0+53)-" (2&-&,320?" H+" ')0" +#(0(" 0),("

2&-*(50)+3&-0"'3+#"G(10&-"G)0#"+#)+"H"'&<1%"3-"+<5-"A(>3-"+&"0#)5("

'3+#"_&A(5+"O<59#$?"B1&'1$:"&*(5")"9(53&%"&6")"$()5:"_&A(5+"A(2),("

2&-*3-2(%")-%"2&-*32+(%"&6"'#)+"#("')0"#()53->?"@30" 6350+",&,(-+"

&6"5()1"21)53+$"2),("&-("%)$"&*(5"1<-2#"'3+#"4)<1"71(*(1)-%?"_&A(5+"

#)%" R<0+" 63-30#(%"5()%3->"G(10&-C0"A&&=")-%"A$"+#(" +3,(" 1<-2#"')0"

&*(5" _&A(5+" <-%(50+&&%" +#(" 03>-3632)-2(" &6" '#)+" +#(" A&&=" ')0"

(891)3-3->")-%"0&&-"+#(5()6+(5"3,91(,(-+(%"+#("95&2(00"6&5"#3,0(16?""

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FI"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

(

(

(

8"&(<,.+-(F,+&3(<,4.%0,+(

"

M#(" %)$" _&A(5+" O<59#$" 2&,,3++(%" +&" 2&U)<+#&5" +#30" A&&="

'3+#",("30")"%)$"H"0#)11"-(*(5"6&5>(+"03,91$"A(2)<0("&6"+#("<-<0<)1"

)-%"<-(89(2+(%"')$"3-"'#32#"3+"#)99(-(%?"@&'(*(5:" 3+" 30"95(230(1$"

A(2)<0(" &6" +#(" ')$" 3+" #)99(-(%" +#)+" (891)3-0" )-%" 95&*(0" +#("

(891&03*(" *303&-" +#(" 3%()0" 3-" +#30" A&&=" 95&%<2(?" M&" 5(2&<-+" +#30"

09(23)1"%)$")-%"A(>3-"+&"9<+"3+"3-+&"95&9(5"9(509(2+3*(:"=((9"3-",3-%"

+#)+" <9" <-+31" +#(-" _&A(5+" )-%" H" #)%" A((-" *3>&5&<01$" 3-*&1*(%" 3-"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

F]"

-<,(5&<0" 2&-*(50)+3&-0" )A&<+" +#(" #<,)-" 95(%32),(-+" 3-" +&%)$C0"

(2&-&,32"(-*35&-,(-+?"_&A(5+:")0")"02#&1)5")-%"(89(5+" 3-"/<0+53)-"

(2&-&,320:" 2&<1%" (891)3-" '#$" +#3->0" '(5(" +#(" ')$" +#($" '(5("

)2)%(,32)11$?" @(" &A*3&<01$" 2&<1%" (89&<-%" &-" +#(0(" 95&A1(,0"

95&13632)11$"#)*3->"'53++(-"0(*(5)1"A&&=0:" 3-21<%3->"0+<%$"><3%(0" +&"

O30(0C" S.2'$# T&/)"$" )-%" O<55)$" _&+#A)5%C0" >'$9# M&"$"2-# '$*#

U/'/%:#-&+"+&"1()*("&<+"+#("2&<-+1(00")5+321(0"6&5"*)53&<0"3-%(9(-%(-+"

13A(5+)53)-"+#3-="+)-=0?"

@&'(*(5:"+#&5&<>#1$"(891)3-3->")-%"%3)>-&03->"+#("95&A1(,"

&6"&<5"-)+3&-")-%"&<5"'&51%"')0"-&+"+#(",)3-"300<(?"D#)+"(*(5$&-("

%(09(5)+(1$"')-+(%"+&"=-&'"')0"#&'"+&"638"3+["/%%3+3&-)11$:"'("A&+#"

<-%(50+&&%" +#(" B&<-%" O&-($" B&1<+3&-" '(11" )-%" A(13(*(%" 3-" 3+"

=-&'3->"+#)+" 3+"')0")-2#&5(%"A$"0&13%"/<0+53)-"+#3-=3->?"D("=-('"

)11"+&&"'(11"'#)+"')0"5(;<35(%"+&")66(2+"+#("=3-%"&6"-)+3&-)1"2#)->("

+#("B&<-%"O&-($"B&1<+3&-"2)11(%"6&5:"A<+"+#("95&A1(,"')0"+#)+"+#("

B&<-%"O&-($"B&1<+3&-C0"5(;<35(%"0+(90"'(5("#3>#1$"<-13=(1$"+&"(*(5"

A("3,91(,(-+(%")-%"'("A&+#"0)%1$"=-('"3+?"L*3%(-2("6&5"+#30"')0"3-"

+#(" 6)2+" +#)+" +#("B&<-%"O&-($"B&1<+3&-"')0"9<+" 6&5+#"%(2)%(0" )>&"

)-%" $(+:" 3-" 093+(" &6" )11" &6" +#(" )%*)-2(0" )-%" >5&'+#" +#(" /<0+53)-"

B2#&&1"#)0"#)%"%&,(0+32)11$" )-%" 3-+(5-)+3&-)11$:" +#(" B&<-%"O&-($"

B&1<+3&-"')0"-(8+"+&"3,9&003A1("+&"(*(5"0(("3,91(,(-+(%?"

_&A(5+")-%"H"'(5("A&+#"2(5+)3-1$"%&3->"&<5"9)5+"3-"095()%3->"

+#(",(00)>("'3+#"()2#"&6"<0"09()=3->"+&"*)53&<0">5&<90"+#5&<>#&<+"

+#(" 2&<-+5$" 3-" &<5" 5(09(2+3*(" 63(1%0:" A<+" +#(" 95&2(00:" '(" 5()%31$"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FF"

)%,3++(%:" ')0" 01&'" )-%" %302&<5)>3->" )+" +3,(0?"D(" )10&" =-('" &<5"

>&)1"')0"-&+")++(,9+3->"+&"2&-*3-2("+#("(-+35("-)+3&-:"2(5+)3-1$"-&+"

!II" ,3113&-" 9(&91(?" /<0+53)-" (2&-&,30+0" =-&'" +#)+" ]IZ" &6" +#("

9&9<1)+3&-"'&<1%",&0+" 13=(1$" A(" (-&<>#" +&" +<5-" 9<A132" &93-3&-" 3-"

&<5" 6)*&5i" '(" 03,91$" %&" -&+" #)*(" )-$'#(5(" 21&0(" +&" +#)+" ]IZ?"

\A*3&<01$"'("-((%(%",&5("9(&91(:"A<+"-&+"R<0+")-$A&%$?"D("-((%(%"

+#(" 53>#+" =3-%" &6" 9(&91(:" 5(09&-03A1(" )-%" 95&%<2+3*(" 9(&91(?" D("

-((%(%" 9(&91(" +#)+" '&<1%" >(+" 3-*&1*(%" )-%" 0+)$" 3-*&1*(%?" /10&:"

+#(5("-((%(%"+&"A(")"A<5-3->"9)003&-"3-03%("+#(0("9(&91("3-"&5%(5"+&"

0((" +#30" 2#)->(")11" +#("')$" +&" 3+0" 0<22(006<1" (-%?"D#)+"')0" 21()51$"

,3003->"')0" 0&,(" =3-%" &6" 3-%3*3%<)1" 3-2(-+3*(:" A<+" &-(" +#)+" 2&<1%"

'&5="'3+#" +#(",)3-" +(-(+0"&6" +#("B&<-%"O&-($"B&1<+3&-?"D#)+"'("

')-+(%",&0+"')0"+&"A5()="+#5&<>#"+#(">(-(5)1"9(003,30,"+#)+"#)0"

#<->" 13=(" )" A1)2=" 21&<%" &*(5" &<5" B2#&&1C0" 95(%(2(00&50?" @(-5$"

@)P13++:" &-(" &6" +#(" ,&0+" 5(2&>-3P)A1(" &6" +#(" /<0+53)-" (2&-&,30+0"

A(2)<0("&6"#30")66313)+3&-"'3+#"71%#V'33#U/0%%/#W".0$'3:"+#("!%,#X"0F#

7)2%+" )-%"!%,+,%%F:" )-%" )10&" +#(" )<+#&5" &6" +#("A(0+U0(113->"A&&=:"

M&"$"2)&+#D$#B$%#=%++"$9"%(0253A(%"+#30"9)5+32<1)5"9(003,30,"3-"&-("

&6"#30" 1)0+"9<A132"09((2#(0")0"#("9)00(%" +#("A)+&-"&*(5" +&" +#("-(8+"

>(-(5)+3&-S"

D#(-"H"1&&="A)2="&-",$"&'-"2)5((5:"H"2)-"63-%"91(-+$"&6"

5()0&-0"6&5"%302&<5)>(,(-+:"9(50&-)1"%302&<5)>(,(-+?"H"#)*("-&+"

1)2=(%"6&5"3-%<0+5$?"H"#)*("'53++(-")"%&P(-"A&&=0?"T&5",&0+"&6"QI"

$()50:" 65&," )>(" FI:" H" #)*(" A((-" '53+3->" 95)2+32)11$" (*(5$"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

F!"

'((=%)$S"-('0" 3+(,0:"(%3+&53)10:"2&1<,-0:")5+321(0i"0&,("]I:III"

'&5%0["/-%"3-"953-+["M#("*(5A)1"(;<3*)1(-+"&6")A&<+"]QI")*(5)>("

1(->+#"A&&=0[#

/-%" $(+:" '#)+" #)*(" H" )22&,9130#(%." M#(" '&51%" 30"

(-&5,&<01$",&5(" 0&23)13P(%" +#)-"'#(-" H" A(>)-c$(+" 3-" 093+(" &6"

+#30"H"),"#&9(6<1?"/6+(5")11:"HC,"0+311"3-">&&%"#()1+#:"HC,"0+311"65(("+&"

'53+(:"HC,"0+311"65(("+&"'53+("<-9&9<1)5"&93-3&-0:")-%"HC,"=((93->"

)+"3+?"/-%"0&")5(",)-$"&6"$&<?"B&"H"A53->"$&<"+#30",(00)>(S"A("&6"

>&&%"2#((5i"A("&6">&&%"09353+?"H6"+#("A)++1("30"-&+"$(+"'&-:"3+"30"-&+"

$(+" 1&0+" (3+#(5?" L*(-" +#&0(" &6" <0"'#&" #)*(" 5()2#(%" )-%" 9)00(%"

&<5" 0(*(-+3(+#" A35+#%)$0" 2)--&+" )66&5%" +&" 5(0+" &-" &<5" &)50" )-%"

09(-%" +#(" 5(0+"&6"&<5" 13*(0"%&P3->" 3-" +#("T1&53%)" 0<-?"M#(" +3,(0"

2)11"6&5"2&<5)>(?"M#("+3,(0"2)11"6&5"#)5%"'&5=?"W<+"36"+#("%(,)-%0"

)5(" #3>#:" 3+" 30" A(2)<0(" +#(" 0+)=(0" )5(" (*(-" #3>#(5?" M#($" )5("

-&+#3->" 1(00" +#)-" +#(" 6<+<5("&6"#<,)-" 13A(5+$:"'#32#",()-0" +#("

6<+<5("&6"23*313P)+3&-?^""

D#)+"_&A(5+")-%" H"A(>)-" +&"%&"-(8+"')0" +&">(+"#&-(0+"'3+#"

()2#"&+#(5?"D(")>5((%" +#)+"&<5" 3-%3*3%<)1" 2&-2(5-"'3+#" 5(>)5%0" +&"

'#)+" '(" )5(" (89(53(-23->" 3-" &<5" 9&13+32)1" )-%" (2&-&,32" )66)350"

2<55(-+1$" 2&<1%" A(" 0<,,(%" <9" 3-" &<5" =-&'3->"'#)+" 311" (66(2+0" )11"

+#30" (2&-&,32" <9#()*)1" 30" #)*3->" &-" 9(&91(C0" )A313+$" +&" ,)=(" )"

13*3->?""D("%3%"-&+"0#$")')$"65&,"+#30"5()13+$?"D("#)%"0(*(5)1"*(5$"3-"

%(9+#" )-%" 9(50&-)1" %302<003&-0" )A&<+" +#30" 2&-2(5-?"D(" =-('" +#)+"

6&5",&0+"&6"<0"3-"/,(532):"+#("-((%"+&"A(")A1("+&",)=(")"13*3->"30")-%"

)1')$0"#)0"A((-")"25<23)1" 6)2+"&6" 136(?" H+" 30" +#("A<03-(00" 65&,"'#32#"

'(" -(*(5" 5(+35(?" H-" 6)2+:" 3+" 30" %36632<1+" +&" 3,)>3-(" )-$" #<,)-" A(3->"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FE"

'#&" 30"-&+"95(&22<93(%"'3+#" +#30"(2&-&,32"(-%()*&5?"" H-"'#)+(*(5"

,)--(5"'("+5$"+&"(891)3-"&<5"0&23(+$:"&5"&<5">&*(5-,(-+:" 3-"+(5,0"

&6" +#(" 9)0+:" 95(0(-+" &5" +#(" 6<+<5(:" '(" 2)--&+" %&" 3+" )-%" 3>-&5("

g(2&-&,32",)-h")-%"#30"3--)+("-((%"+&",)=(")"13*3->?""

/-%"+#(-"3+"#)99(-(%["/11"&6")"0<%%(-"+#("(-+35("+#(,("&6"+#30"

A&&=:"65&,"A(>3--3->"+&"(-%:"#3+"_&A(5+"13=(")"F"A$"E")25&00"+#("#()%?"

@30" ($(0" '3%(-(%" '3+#" <++(5" ),)P(,(-+" )-%" #(" (821)3,(%" '3+#"

(823+(,(-+:"gM#)+C0"3+[h"O&,(-+0"1)+(5"#(")%,3++(%"+#)+"+#("*303&-"#3+"

#3," '3+#" 0<2#" 6&52(" +#)+" #(" #)%" -&+" (*(-" 0((-" 3+" 2&,3->?" H+" #)%"

-(*(5"%)'-(%"&-"#3,"<-+31"+#)+"*(5$",&,(-+"+#)+"'#)+"H:"4)<1")-%"

G(10&-"#)%"A((-"+)1=3->")A&<+")11"+#30"+3,("')0")2+<)11$"g0+(9"+'&h""

&6" +#(" +#5((" 0+(90" &6" +#(" B&<-%" O&-($" B&1<+3&-c01$)2,#)3/&*

4,"5)"678#@&'(*(5:"+#("09(2+)2<1)5")-%"<-A(13(*)A1("9)5+")A&<+"3+"

')0" +#)+" )-" 3-%3*3%<)1" 2&<1%" )2+<)11$" >&" 3-+&" 953*)+3P(%" A)-=3->"

53>#+" -&'[" M#(5(" ')0" -&" -((%" +&" ')3+" &-" >&*(5-,(-+" +&" 2#)->(?"

M#(5("')0"-&"-((%"6&5"+#("B&<-%"O&-($"B&1<+3&-"+&"A(")22(9+(%")-%"

9<+" 6&5+#" 3-+&" 9<A132" 9&132$?" M'0@#%&( 2#+90+B( /,.4-( 2&( -,+&(

0AA&-0#%&43( #+-( 0%( /,.4-( 2&( -,+&( 23( @0'%.#443( #+3,+&N" \<5"

25()+3*("(-(5>$"0<%%(-1$"0&)5(%")-%" +#(",3003->" 3-2(-+3*("'("#)%"

A((-" 0()52#3->" 6&5" 0<%%(-1$" A(2),(" 21()5" )-%" )99)5(-+?" " M#("

)-0'(5b+#(",3003->"13-=b')0"03,91$"+#("2&--(2+3->"&6"+#30"3--)+("

-((%"'3+#3-",)-:"+#("-((%"+&",)=(")"13*3->:"'3+#"+#("B&<-%"O&-($"

B&1<+3&-?" M#(" =($"')0" 0+(9" +'&" &6" +#(" B&<-%"O&-($" B&1<+3&-:" +#("

A<03-(00" &6" A)-=3->:" 953*)+3P(%" A)-=3->:" +#(" ,&0+" 95&63+)A1("

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FQ"

A<03-(00" 3-" +#("'&51%b3+" 2&<1%"A(" 3,91(,(-+(%" 53>#+" -&'"A$" )-$"

3-%3*3%<)1"23+3P(-["

"

"

"

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

""

H-" +#30" 3-+5&%<2+3&-" H" 0#&<1%" )10&" 0)$" )" 6('" '&5%0" &-" +#("

1)$&<+"&6"+#("A&&=?"H"#)*("A((-">3*3->"4&'(54&3-+"95(0(-+)+3&-0"&-"

+#(0(" ,)++(50" +&" *)53&<0" )<%3(-2(0" &6" 63-)-23)1" 95&6(003&-)10:" )-%"

+#(" 5()2+3&-" #)0" A((-" )0+&-30#3->?" L*(-" >5&<90" &6" :'$F%0+" )5("

)A0&5A3->" +#(" 3-6&5,)+3&-b,&0+" &6" +#(," #)%" -&" 3%()" #&'" +#(35"

&'-"3-%<0+5$"5()11$"'&5=(%["

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

F^"

\-" +#(" &+#(5" #)-%:" _&A(5+C0" ,)3-" )5(-)" ')0" 3-" 953-+?" /0" )"

6&5,(5" 2&11(>(" 95&6(00&5:" )-%" +#(" )<+#&5" &6" 0(*(5)1" A&&=0:" _&A(5+"

&A*3&<01$"2)-"95(0(-+"+#("/<0+53)-"3%()0"3-"+#("+5)%3+3&-)1"6&5,?"@("

+&&" #)0" 6&<-%" >5&'3->" 9&9<1)5" 3-+(5(0+" 3-" +#(0(" 3%()0:" A(2)<0(" &6"

+#("63-)-23)1"253030?"

H-"+#("95(0(-+"A&&=:"_&A(5+")-%"H"&A($(%"+#("9&9<1)5")%)>(:"

gH6"3+")3-C+"A5&=(:"%&-C+"638"3+?h"M#)+"30"+&"0)$:"3-"4)5+"H"&6"+#("A&&="H"),"

+#("953,)5$")<+#&5:" )-%" H"%3%",$"A(0+" +&" +5)-01)+(",$"4&'(54&3-+"

95(0(-+)+3&-0"3-+&"A&&="6&5,?"

_&A(5+:" &-" +#(" &+#(5" #)-%:" 30" +#(" 953,)5$" )<+#&5" &6" 4)5+" HH?"

M#(5("#("+53(0"+&"%30+311"+#(",&0+"3,9&5+)-+"9&3-+0"65&,"+#("/<0+53)-"

+5)%3+3&-:" 3-" &5%(5" 6&5" +#(" 5()%(5" +&" <-%(50+)-%" +#(" B&<-%"O&-($"

B&1<+3&-?"M#("03,91("130+3->"&6"3+0"+#5(("A<11(+"9&3-+0"'311",)=("13++1("

0(-0(:"'3+#&<+" 0&,("A)2=>5&<-%" =-&'1(%>(" &6" #&'" )" 65((",)5=(+"

(2&-&,$")2+<)11$"'&5=0?"

W(2)<0("&6"+#("A&&=C0"0+5<2+<5(:"3+"')0"<-)*&3%)A1("+#)+"+#(5("

30"0&,("5(%<-%)-2$?"_&A(5+")-%"H"+5()+",)-$"&6"+#("25<23)1"+&9320b

3-61)+3&-:" 65)2+3&-)1" 5(0(5*(" A)-=3->:" +#(" -)+<5(" &6" ,&-($:" )-%" 0&"

&-b3-" &<5" &'-" ')$0?" D(" #&9(" +#)+" 4)5+" H" 95&*3%(0" )" ;<32="

&*(5*3('" &6" +#(" 5(1(*)-+" +&9320:" 2&-*3-23->" +#(" 5()%(5" &6" +#(35"

3,9&5+)-2(:" '3+#&<+" +#(" <0(" &6" 3-+3,3%)+3->" R)5>&-" +#)+" +&&" &6+(-"

9)5)1$P(0"2&,95(#(-03&-?"M#(-"3-"4)5+"HH"'("9)00"+#5&<>#",)-$"&6"

+#("0),("300<(0"A<+" 3-">5()+(5"%(9+#?"T3-)11$:" 3-"4)5+" HHH"'("(891)3-"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FX"

+#("A)0320"&6"G(10&-"G)0#C0" H-63-3+("W)-=3->"7&-2(9+:" )-%"0#&'" 3+0"

2&-+53A<+3&-"+&"+#(")2#3(*(,(-+"&6"+#("B&<-%"O&-($"B&1<+3&-?"

H" )," 0<5(" +#)+" 0&,(" 5()%(50:" '#&" )15()%$" #)*(" )" %((9"

=-&'1(%>(" &6" ,&-(+)5$" )-%" A)-=3->" )66)350:" ,)$" 63-%" 9&5+3&-0" &6"

&<5"+5()+,(-+"03,9130+32?"W<+"H")0="$&<"+&"=((9"3-",3-%"+#)+"'("-((%"

+&"095()%"+#30",(00)>(" +&")" 1)5>(5">5&<9"&6"/,(532)-0" 36"'(")5(" +&"

#)*(")-$"#&9("&6"+<5-3->"+#("+3%(?"M#(0(")5("*(5$" 3,9&5+)-+" 300<(0"

+#)+" '311" )66(2+" +#(" +$9(" &6" 2&<-+5$" 3-" '#32#" &<5" 2#31%5(-" )-%"

>5)-%2#31%5(-" 13*(?"L09(23)11$" 3-"4)5+" H:"'("#)*(" +53(%" +&"A&31"%&'-"

+#(0(" )52)-(" )-%" 3-+3,3%)+3->" 2&-2(9+0" 3-+&" %(02539+3&-0" +#)+"

)-$&-(" 2)-" <-%(50+)-%?" M#(" 6)+(" &6" &<5" ,&-($" )-%" 3-%((%" &<5"

2&<-+5$")5("+&&"3,9&5+)-+"+&"A("1(6+"+&"g+#("(89(5+0?h"

/11" +&&"&6+(-" H" #)*("9(50&-)11$" 0((-"*(5$" 3-+(113>(-+"'&,(-"

'#&"2&-2(-+5)+("&-"&+#(5"5(09&-03A313+3(0")-%")11&'"+#(35"#<0A)-%0"

+&" g+)=(" 2)5("&6" +#(" 63-)-2(0?h" B<2#"'&,(-")5("&-("&6" +#("953,)5$"

+)5>(+" )<%3(-2(0" 6&5"'#&,"'(" )5("'53+3->?" H-%((%",)-$",(-"'311"

5(R(2+" +#(" 2&,,&-0(-0(" )-%" 2&-0(5*)+3*(" 63-)-23)1" 0+5)+(>3(0" '("

(891)3-" 3-" +#30" A&&=:" A(2)<0(" +#($C5(" g+&&" ()0$h" )-%" +&&" +3,3%?"W<+"

'#(-"3+"2&,(0"+&")"#&<0(#&1%C0"0)*3->0:"03,91323+$"30">&&%["D("#)*("

0((-"'#)+" +#(" g0,)5+(0+" ><$0" 3-" +#(" 5&&,h"%3%"&-"D)11" B+5((+?"D("

<5>("0+)$U)+U#&,("09&<0(0" +&" 5()%"%((91$"&-" +#(0(",)++(50")-%" +&"

+)=(")",&5(")2+3*("5&1("3-"+#(35"63-)-23)1"6<+<5(?"

"/0")"63-)1"9&3-+"3-"+#30"3-+5&%<2+3&-:"1(+",(")2=-&'1(%>("+#)+"

&<5"A&&="#)0")-"(891323+1$"/,(532)-"A3)0?"D(")5("'53+3->"+#30"A&&="

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FJ"

6&5" &<5" 6(11&'" /,(532)-" 23+3P(-0:" +#&<>#" &6" 2&<50(" +#(" 1(00&-0" &6"

/<0+53)-"(2&-&,320")5("<-3*(50)11$")99132)A1(?"M#(5(")5("+#5((",)3-"

5()0&-0"6&5"&<5"(,9#)030"&-"+#("K-3+(%"B+)+(0?"

T350+:" +#(5(" 30" +#(" 03,91(" 95&A1(," +#)+" 6&5(3>-" 5()%(50",)$"

-&+"A(")A1("+&"&A+)3-"'#&1("136("3-0<5)-2("9&1323(0"2&-63><5(%"3-"+#("

')$"G(10&-"G)0#"5(2&,,(-%0?" H-"2&-+5)0+:"/,(532)-"5()%(50"#)*("

0(*(5)1" )995&953)+(" 3-0<5(50" +&" 2#&&0(" 65&,:" '#&" 2)-" 2)+(5" +&" )"

213(-+"'30#3->"+&"3,91(,(-+"HW7?"

B(2&-%:"+#("T(%(5)1"_(0(5*("30"A$"6)5"+#(",&0+"9&'(56<1"6&52("

3-"+#("'&51%"(2&-&,$?"M#("6&11$"&6"+#("p3,A)A'("2(-+5)1"A)-="&-1$"

5<3-(%" +#(" 13*(0" &6" )" 0,)11" 65)2+3&-" &6" +#(" >1&A)1" 9&9<1)+3&-?" H-"

2&-+5)0+:" 36" W(-" W(5-)-=(" %&(0" -&+" )1+(5" 2&<50(" 0&&-:" A3113&-0" &6"

9(&91("'311"0<66(5"+#("2&-0(;<(-2(0?"

M#35%:"'("A(13(*("+#)+"+#("1&*(50"&6"13A(5+$",<0+",)=(")"63-)1"

0+)-%"3-"+#("K-3+(%"B+)+(0?"M&"9)5)9#5)0("_&-)1%"_()>)-:"36"'("1&0("

13A(5+$"#(5(:"+#(5(C0"-&'#(5("1(6+"+&">&?"n<0+")0"+#("6)11"&6"+#("B&*3(+"

K-3&-"95&*(%"+#("6<+313+$"&6"2&,,<-30,"+&",)-$"g95)>,)+30+0h"'#&"

'&<1%"-&+" A&+#(5"'3+#" )A0+5)2+" )5><,(-+0:" A$" +#(" 0),(" +&=(-" +#("

2&11)90("&6"+#("K-3+(%"B+)+(0"'311"2&-*3-2("+#("'&51%"+#)+"2)93+)130,"

+&&" %&(0" -&+" '&5=?" H+" '&<1%" A(" )-" (55&-(&<0" 2&-21<03&-b'("

2(5+)3-1$" %&" -&+" #)*(" )" 65((" ,)5=(+" 3-" &9(5)+3&-bA<+" +#)+" 30" +#("

*(5%32+" #30+&5$" '&<1%" >3*(" &-" /,(532)C0" A53(6" 613->" '3+#" 13,3+(%"

>&*(5-,(-+?"

!"#$%&'(#)%"*@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#

#

FY"

M#(" ;<3-+(00(-+3)1" /,(532)-" 9&13+32)1" +5)%3+3&-" 30" &-(" &6"

3-%3*3%<)1" 13A(5+$" )-%" (2&-&,32" 65((%&,?" L*(-" )0" /,(532)-"

9&13+323)-0" +5),91(" +#("7&-0+3+<+3&-:" +#($" 0+311" 9)$" 139" 0(5*32(" +&" 3+0"

21)<0(0?" /1+#&<>#" +#(" )*(5)>(" /,(532)-C0" 2&,,3+,(-+" +&" +#("

953-2391(0"&6" 3-%3*3%<)130,")-%"953*)+("95&9(5+$">5&'"'()=(5"'3+#"

()2#" >(-(5)+3&-:" (*(-" 0&" +#(5(" 30" )" 532#" #(53+)>(" +#)+" '(" #&9(" +&"

5(=3-%1(?"D("&'$"0<22((%?"/-%"'("2.+/"+5$?"

"

"

a?"7)51&0"a)5)"

G)0#*311(:"M(--(00(("

n<-(:"FI]I"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""1 Ludwig von Mises, Human Action: A Treatise on Economics (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1998). 2 A good question put forth by Clarence B. Carson, Basic Economics (Phenix City, AL: American Textbook Committee, 2003). 3 Murray Rothbard, “The Meaning of Revolution,” Libertarian Forum, Vol. I, No. VII, July 1, 1969, p. 1. Available at: http://mises.org/journals/lf/1969/1969_07_01.pdf. Accessed June 1, 2010. 4 Randall W. Forsyth, “Ignoring the Austrians Got Us In This Mess,” Barron’s, March 2009. 5 There are many other organizations and think tanks in the United states dedicated to free market economics, though not necessarily in the tradition of the Austrian School. 6 Henry Hazlitt, quoted in Fifteen Great Austrian Economists (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1999), pp. 178-179.

!"#$%&'(#)%"*!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#

#

!"#

!"#$%&'()(

*++&++,-.(%"&(/#,-(0'123&4(

#

!"#$%&'(% )#%"(*+,"*%,)-.% -."%/)0-%+0% 1"'#+($%23-%

."%)#%'4#+%5+##"##"*%+0%'55"-)-"#%'(*%'(%'6"1#)+(%

-+% 4'2+1$% '(*% -++% +0-"(% .)#% 1"'#+(% 2"(*#% -+% .)#%

+-."1% 7.'1'7-"1)#-)7#8% 9."% 0')431"% +0% 3-+5)'(#% -+%

'77"5-%-.)#%0'7-$%+1%'77"5-%&'(%'#%."%)#$%(+-%'#%."%

+3/.-% -+% 2"$% /)6"#% -.")1% #7."&"#% '% *1"'&4):"%

;3'4)-<8%

=>1'(:%?.+*+1+6@%!

%

%

$%#&'()#*&+',)-.)#/-0)#1%$*.2#)$%#3.%4#*2%-5#2%(0,*1%2#

*.# )$%# +,%6*'7(# 0$-+)%,# *(# )$-)# '7,# %//',)(# )'# $%8+#

'7,(%86%(9#'7,#/-&*8*%(9#'7,#17(*.%((%(9#-.2#78)*&-)%8:#'7,#0'7.),:9#

,%()(# %.)*,%8:#'.#'7,#-1*8*):# )'# (%%# )$%#.-)7,%#'/#'7,#+,'18%&#4*)$#

0'&+8%)%#08-,*):;#<*)$'7)#)$*(#7.2%,()-.2*.=#-(#-#+,*&-,:#()%+9#*)#*(#

*&+'((*18%# )'# )->%# )$%# .%%2%2# -0)*'.(# )'4-,2# 0',,%0)*.=# *);#

?$%,%/',%9# )$%# +,'18%&# &7()# 1%# /788:# %@+'(%2# -.2# &-2%#

0'&+,%$%.(*18%# )'# -(# &-.:# +%'+8%# -(# +'((*18%9# -.2# -(# A7*0>8:# -(#

+'((*18%;#

B'# 8%)# 7(# 1%=*.# )'# 2%0*+$%,# )$*(#&:()%,:# -.2# +'*.)# )'# ('&%#

'16*'7(# '1(%,6-)*'.(;# C*,()# '/# -889# 4%# &7()# &->%# -# ,-)$%,# 1'82#

()-)%&%.)# 4$*0$# 4%# 4*88# (%)# '7)# )'# +,'6%# *.# )$%# 0$-+)%,(# -$%-2;#

?#

"##$##%&'!()$!*+%&!,-./0$1#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA%

%

!D#

<$-)#4%# -,%# 2%-8*.=#4*)$# *(# -# 2%%+8:# $*22%.# -.2# 08%6%,8:# 0,-/)%2#

(0$%&%# 1:# )$%# /%4# *.# +'8*)*0-8# +'4%,9# +-()# -.2# +,%(%.)9# )'#

(:()%&-)*0-88:# 2%/,-72# )$%# .-)*'.# '/# *)(# 4%-8)$;# E)# *(# .')$*.=# 8%((#

)$-.#-#2*,%0)#-((-78)#'.#+,*6-)%#+,'+%,):F#?$*(#*(#'7,#1'))'&#8*.%;#E)#

*(#)$%#0,7@#'/#)$%#&-))%,;#G1('87)%#+'4%,#-84-:(#,%(*2%(#4*)$#)$'(%#

4$'# 0'.),'8# )$%#&'.%:;# H6%,# )$%# 0'7,(%# '/# $*()',:# =,%-)# /-&*8*%(9#

>*.=2'&(9#-.2#*.()*)7)*'.(#$-6%#(),7==8%2#4*)$#'.%#-.')$%,#)'#=-*.#

)$*(# 0'.),'8;# ?'2-:9# *.# 6*,)7-88:# %6%,:# &-I',# 0'7.),:# -0,'((# '7,#

=8'1%9#='6%,.&%.)(#8-:#08-*&#)'#)$*(#0%.),-8*J%2#+'4%,;#

#

E.# '7,# '4.# G&%,*0-.# %@+%,*%.0%9# '7,# /%2%,-8# ='6%,.&%.)#

%@%,0*(%(# %@),-',2*.-,:# +'4%,# '6%,#'7,#&'.%:;#H.0%# *)#4-(#&-2%#

+'((*18%#)'#)-+#2*,%0)8:#*.)'#'7,#+'0>%)#1''>(#4*)$#)$%#+-((*.=#'/#)$%#

"K)$# G&%.2&%.)# L)$%# /%2%,-8# *.0'&%# )-@M# *.# "N"!# -.2# )$%#

%()-18*($&%.)#'/#-#0%.),-8#1-.>#L)$%#C%2%,-8#O%(%,6%#B:()%&M#*.#)$%#

6%,:#(-&%#:%-,9#)$%#0$-88%.=%(#'/#&->*.=#-#8*6*.=#-.2#-007&78-)*.=#

4%-8)$# 0$-.=%2# /',%6%,# /',# -88# 0*)*J%.(# '/# )$%# P.*)%2# B)-)%(;# ?$%#

(%-,0$# )'# /*.2# -#4-:# '/# %(0-+%# /,'&# )$*(# 1'.2-=%# $-(# 1%0'&%# )$%#

$-,2# (),7==8%# '/# %6%,:# *.2*6*27-8# 0*)*J%.# (*.0%# )$%.;# G(# C,-.>#

Q$'2','6#%@+8-*.(R#

#E.# "N"!# 0-&%# )$%# -&%.2&%.)# )$-)# 0'&+8%)%8:# 7.($-0>8%2# )$%#

G&%,*0-.# ()-)%9# /',# 4*)$# )$%# ,%6%.7%(# 2%,*6%2# /,'&# 7.8*&*)%2#

*.0'&%#)-@-)*'.#*)#0'782#$%.0%/',)$#&->%#7.8*&*)%2#/',-:(#*.#)'#

)$%# %0'.'&:#'/# )$%#+%'+8%;#?$%# B*@)%%.)$#G&%.2&%.)#.')# '.8:#


%

!!#

6*'8-)%2# )$%# ,*=$)#'/# )$%# *.2*6*27-8# )'# )$%#+,'270)#'/#$*(# %//',)(9#

)$%#%((%.)*-8#*.=,%2*%.)#'/#/,%%2'&9#17)#*)#-8('#=-6%#)$%#G&%,*0-.#

B)-)%# )$%# &%-.(# )'# 1%0'&%# )$%# .-)*'.S(# 1*==%()# 0'.(7&%,9#

%&+8':%,9# 1-.>%,9#&-.7/-0)7,%,# -.2# '4.%,# '/# 0-+*)-8;# ?$%,%# *(#

.'4#.'#+$-(%#'/#%0'.'&*0#8*/%#*.#4$*0$#)$%#B)-)%#*(#.')#-#/-0)',9#

)$%,%#*(#.'#%.)%,+,*(%#',#'007+-)*'.#/,%%#'/#*)(#*.)%,6%.)*'.;D#

######################################################################

# H.#)$%#')$%,#$-.29# *)# *(#.')#('#(*&+8%#-(#)'#2%08-,%#)$-)#3)$%#

='6%,.&%.)5#0'.),'8(#)$%#&'.%:#(7++8:9#/',#)%0$.*0-88:#)$%#>"*"1'4%

B"#"16"# 0'.),'8(# *);# ?$%#C%29# )$'7=$# 0,%-)%2#1:# )$%# ='6%,.&%.)9# *(#

.'.%)$%8%((# '4.%2# 1:# +,*6-)%# *.2*6*27-8(# -.2# *.# *&+',)-.)# 4-:(#

'+%,-)%(# *.2%+%.2%.)8:# /,'&# )$%# 4*($%(# '/# )$%# ='6%,.&%.);# G(#

T7,,-:#O')$1-,2# ,%&-,>(R# 3?$%#C%2%,-8#O%(%,6%9# 6*,)7-88:# *.# )')-8#

0'.),'8# '/# )$%# .-)*'.U(# 6*)-8# &'.%)-,:# (:()%&9# *(# -00'7.)-18%# )'#

.'1'2:V-.2# )$*(# (),-.=%# (*)7-)*'.9# */# -0>.'48%2=%2# -)# -889# *(#

*.6-,*-18:#),7&+%)%2#-(#-#6*,)7%;5!%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

H6%,# )$%# +-()# (%6%,-8# 2%0-2%(9# )$%# *.()*=-)*'.# '/# )$%(%# )4'#

(*=.*/*0-.)# 8-4(# $-(# 8%2# )'# 4*2%(+,%-2# %0'.'&*0# /,7(),-)*'.# -.2#

0'./7(*'.#*.#G&%,*0-.#('0*%):;#?$%#-6%,-=%#0*)*J%.9#*.#-.#-))%&+)#)'#

+,')%0)# $*(# '4.# 4%-8)$9# 0'.()-.)8:# (%%>(# -88# ):+%(# '/# /*.-.0*-8#

(),-)%=*%(# )'#-00'&+8*($# )$*(9# ('&%)*&%(# ,%(',)*.=# )'#%@+',)*.=#$*(#

4%-8)$# )'# ')$%,# 0'7.),*%(;# G22*)*'.-88:9# $%# *(# *.7.2-)%2# 4*)$# )$%#

%.28%((#/',&(#-.2#/*8*.=(#4$*0$#-,%#&-.2-)%2#1:#='6%,.&%.);#?$%,%#

(%%&(# )'# 1%# -# /',&# "WNN# %6%,:4$%,%F# ?'2-:# )$%,%# -,%#

-++,'@*&-)%8:# XYK9WWW# 8*0%.(%2# /*.-.0*-8# ,%+,%(%.)-)*6%(# *.# )$*(#


%

!Y#

0'7.),:# ,%+,%(%.)*.=# '6%,# X9WWW# 1-.>(9# .%-,8:# "9WWW# 1,'>%,-=%#

/*,&(9# -.2# D9!WW# *.(7,-.0%# 0'&+-.*%(;# ?$%# .7&1%,(# '/# +718*0#

-00'7.)-.)(# -.2# 8-4:%,(# -,%# 8%=*'.;# Z%)# 4*)$# -88# )$%# 1%.%/*)(# '/#

+,'/%((*'.-8#-((*()-.0%#*.#.-6*=-)*.=#)$,'7=$#-#&-J%#'/#)-@#8-4(9#)$%#

/*.%# +,*.)# '.# /*.-.0*-8# +,'270)(# -.2# ,*(># 6-,*-18%(# *.# *.6%()&%.)#

+,'(+%0)7(%(9# )$%# *.2*6*27-8# +%,('.9# &',%# )$-.# %6%,# 1%/',%9# /%%8(#

1%),-:%2# -.2# 678.%,-18%;# [,%-&(# '/# /*.-.0*-8# (%07,*):# -.2#

+,'(+%,*):#%6-2%#P;B;#0*)*J%.(#-)#%6%,:#)7,.;#?$%#)-@#-.2#2%1)#17,2%.#

0'.)*.7%(#)'#=,'4#-..7-88:#-.2#$-(#1%0'&%#7.1%-,-18%;#\6%.)7-88:#

)$%#17,2%.#)->%(#*)(#)'88#-.2#0-7(%(#)$%#*.2*6*27-8#)'#8'(%#$'+%;#]%#*(#

/',0%2# )'# (7007&1# )'# %6%.#&',%# 2%+%.2%.0:# -.2# (71(%,6*%.0%# )'#

='6%,.&%.);#

Q8%-,8:9# -26*0%# '//%,%2# 1:# &-.:# *.# )$%# /*.-.0*-8# (%,6*0%(#

*.27(),:# *(# .')# +,'6*2*.=# )$%# $%8+# )$-)# *(# &'()# .%%2%2# 1%0-7(%# *)#

&%,%8:# (0,-)0$%(# )$%# (7,/-0%# '/# )$%# ,%-8# +,'18%&;# G# +%,('.U(# +'',#

I72=&%.)9# 7.2*(0*+8*.%2# &'.%:# &-.-=%&%.)# ',# 8-0># '/# )*&%# )'#

%@+%,)8:# ,%(%-,0$# %6%,:# -(+%0)# '/# /*.-.0*-8# 2%0*(*'.(# &-:# 1%# )$%#

078+,*)# *.# &-.:# 0-(%(9# $'4%6%,9# )$%# ,%-8# +,'18%&# ()%&(# /,'&# -#

0'&+8%)%8:# 2*//%,%.)# ('7,0%;# E)# *(# .15&'-4&-%( ,-%'6+,1-# -.29#

%(+%0*-88:9( 41-&%#'7( $13,87# 4$*0$# *(# -)# )$%# 0',%# '/# )$*(# &'.%:#

+,'18%&;# \6%,:# *.2*6*27-89# %(+%0*-88:# )$%# /*.-.0*-8# -26*(',9# $-(# )$%#

,%(+'.(*1*8*):# )'# 7.2%,()-.2# )$*(# 0'..%0)*'.9# )'# 8%-,.# (+%0*/*0-88:#

,.<# -.2# .+,# )$%# "N"!# )-@# -.2# 1-.>*.=# 8-4(# -,%# (:()%&-)*0-88:#

(),*++*.=# -4-:# )$%# 6-87%# '/# '7,# &'.%:;# E)# *(# ='6%,.&%.)# -0)*'.#


%

!^#

*.()*=-)%2#)$,'7=$#)$%#0%.),-8#1-.>#)$-)#0,%-)%(#)$%#2/..1!+&3!/4#(!

/4#%&$##! 5650$#7# )$-)# 0-7(%# ,%0%((*'.(# -.2# 2%+,%((*'.(F# ?$%#

*.2*6*27-89# .')# ,%-8*J*.=# $'4# -88# '/# )$*(# $-(# 0'&%# -1'7)9# *(# 8%/)# *.#

7.%.2*.=#/*.-.0*-8#1'.2-=%;##

G,&%2#4*)$#)$*(#),7)$9#)$%#*.2*6*27-8#*(#-18%#)'#-((%(#)$%#,'')#

'/# $*(# &'.%)-,:# +,'18%&(;# _'# 8'.=%,# *(# $%# &*(8%2# 1:# /*.-.0*-8#

%@+%,)(9# &%2*-# +%,('.-8*)*%(9# ',# '7,# 0'.=,%((*'.-8# 8%-2%,(# *.#

<-($*.=)'.;# `.'48%2=%# -.2# ),7)$# ('86%# )$%# ,*228%9# %8*&*.-)*.=#

+%,+%)7-8#0'./7(*'.;#a%)#7(#.')#/',=%)#)$%#/-&'7(#()-)%&%.)#'/#b'$.#

T-:.-,2#`%:.%(R#

#?$%,%# *(# .'# (71)8%,# ',# (7,%,#&%-.(# '/# '6%,)7,.*.=# )$%# %@*()*.=#

1-(*(# '/# ('0*%):# )$-.# )'# 2%1-70$# )$%# 07,,%.0:;# # ?$%# +,'0%((#

%.=-=%(# -88# )$%# $*22%.# /',0%(# '/# %0'.'&*0# 8-4# '.# )$%# (*2%# '/#

2%(),70)*'.9# -.2# 2'%(# *)# *.# -#&-..%,#4$*0$#-1%( 1-&(4#-( ,-( #(

4,33,1-(,+(#23&(%1(9,#.-1+&;Y#

(

:16-9(;",-<,-.(

#

H16*'7(8:9# */# )$*(# &:()%,:# *(# )'# 1%# ('86%2# -.2# -# ('87)*'.#

/'7.29# -# 0%,)-*.# 2%=,%%# '/# 2%8*1%,-)%# )$*.>*.=# *(# .%0%((-,:# '.# )$%#

+-,)# '/# -88# '/# 7(;# ]'4%6%,9# $%,%# 8*%(# )$%# /*,()# $7=%# '1()-08%;#

P.1%8*%6-18%#-(# *)#&-:#(%%&9# )$%#'6%,4$%8&*.=#&-I',*):#'/#+%'+8%#

$%,%# *.# '7,#P.*)%2# B)-)%(# (*&+8:# 2'#.')# )$*.>F# E)U(# ),7%F# ?$%,%# -,%#


%

!K#

7./',)7.-)%8:# .7&%,'7(# ()-)*()*0(# )$-)# +,'6%# )$*(# (-2# +'*.)#

%6%,:2-:;# H.%# (*=.*/*0-.)# /-0)',# *(# )$-)# '6%,# $-8/# )$%# G&%,*0-.#

+'+78-)*'.# *(# 2%+%.2%.)# '.# ('&%# /',&# '/# ='6%,.&%.)# (7++',);#

?$%,%/',%9#)$%#+'4%,#-.2#(4-:#'/#)$%#6'*0%#'/#='6%,.&%.)#$-(#&-2%#

,%-8#)$*.>*.=#6*,)7-88:#7..%0%((-,:#/',#&-.:;#C',#')$%,(9#)$*.>*.=#*(#

(*&+8:#*.0'.6%.*%.);#E)#,%A7*,%(#)*&%#-.2#%//',);#H/#0'7,(%9#4$-)#4%#

-,%#,%/%,%.0*.=# *(#3#+3(*%-.)(:)(/59# *.2%+%.2%.)#)$*.>*.=#,%A7*,*.=#

0'.0%.),-)*'.#-.2#0'.)%&+8-)*'.;# E)# *(#-# ):+%#'/# )$*.>*.=# )$-)#2'%(#

.')#%-(*8:#I7&+#)'#0'.087(*'.(9#.',#)->%(#-(#2'0),*.%#)$%#*./',&-)*'.#

)$-)#+'7,(#'7)#'/#)$%#&%2*-9#-.2#%(+%0*-88:#'7)#'/#Q-+*)'8#]*88;# # E.#-#

('0*%):# (70$# -(# '7,(# ('7.2# )$*.>*.=# $-(# 1%0'&%# %@),%&%8:# ,-,%9#

%6%.# *.#)$%# *./',&-)*'.#-=%#4$%.#,%-8#>.'48%2=%#$-(#=,'4.#&',%#

-00%((*18%#)'#)$%#8-:&-.#)$-.#%6%,#1%/',%;#

## <%#&7()#,%6%,(%#)$*(#),%.2#-(#-.#-1('87)%#/*,()#()%+#-.2#)->%#

7+#)$*(#2*(0*+8*.%V*.#(&-88#2'(%(#'/#0'7,(%c#')$%,4*(%#4%#4*88#.%6%,#

2'#*);#a*>%#-.:#')$%,#2*(0*+8*.%9#-#0%,)-*.#-&'7.)#'/#)*&%#&7()#1%#(%)#

-(*2%# %-0$# 2-:# /',# )$*(# +,-0)*0%# 7.)*8# *)# 1%0'&%(# $-1*)7-8;# ?$%#

()-,)*.=#+'*.)#*(#,%-2*.=#-#1''>;#Z%(9#:'7#,%-2#0',,%0)8:9#1"'*)(/F#E.#

$*(# =,%-)# 1''>9# 9.)(:)(/% '#% '% C7)"(7"9# G7(),*-.# %0'.'&*()# ]%.,:#

]-J8*))# &->%(# *)# 08%-,# )$-)# '7,# )$*.>*.=# *(# &'()8:# /',&%2# 1:# '7,#

,%-2*.=;#<%#($'782#(%8%0)#-.2#,%-2#'.8:#)$%#&'()#*./',&-)*6%#1''>(#

'.#)$%#&'()#%.8*=$)%.*.=#(71I%0)(R#3d?e$%#=,%-)#)$*.>%,(#'/#)$%#+-()#

*&+,'6%2#)$%*,#*..-)%#+'4%,(9#.')#1:#)$%#()72:#'/#,78%(#/',#)$*.>*.=9#


%

!X#

17)#1:#,%-2*.=#)$%#4',>(#'/#')$%,#=,%-)#)$*.>%,(9#-.2#7.0'.(0*'7(8:#

*&*)-)*.=#)$%*,#$-1*)7-8#&%)$'2#-.2#0-7)*'.;5^##

##################################################%

=#+,8(>81-14,8+(

#

a*>%4*(%# 4%# -8('# &7()# ,%-2# -.2# $'.%# '7,# )$*.>*.=# 1:#

(%8%0)*.=# )$%# (71I%0)(#&'()#4',)$# '7,# 3)$*.>*.=5# )*&%;# # G.29# (*.0%#

'7,# +,*&-,:# (71I%0)# &-))%,# *(# '7,# 07,,%.)# /*.-.0*-8# (:()%&9# 4%#

(),'.=8:#(7==%()#)'#)$%#,%-2%,#)$-)#$%#0-.#2'#.'#1%))%,#)$-.#)'#(%8%0)#

)$%#(71I%0)#'/#%0'.'&*0(;##

<$:#%0'.'&*0(f# #P.8*>%#-.:#')$%,#(71I%0)9#%0'.'&*0(#2%-8(#

4*)$#-.#%((%.)*-8#-.2#+,%((*.=#-(+%0)#'/#8*/%9#4$*0$#*(#&-.U(#.%%2#)'#

&->%#-#8*6*.=;#T'()#*&+',)-.)8:9#.'#(71I%0)#'/#)$%#D"()#0%.)7,:#(%%&(#

)'# '007+:#&',%# '/# )$%# +'8*)*0-8# 8*&%8*=$)# )$-.# %0'.'&*0# A7%()*'.(#

-.2#)$%*,#-.(4%,(;#?$%#+,%(%.)# /*.-.0*-8#0,*(*(# *(#'/#0'7,(%#-#&-I',#

*.0%.)*6%# /',# )$%# (%,*'7(# ()72:# '/# %0'.'&*0(;# G# &',%# 2-7.)*.=#

,%-('.# *(# )$%# 7.2%,()-.2*.=# )$-)# ='6%,.&%.)(# -.2# ,78%,(# -,%# -8('#

6%,:# &70$# *.6'86%2# 4*)$# )$%(%# (-&%# A7%()*'.(c# $'4%6%,9# )$%*,#

2%0*(*'.(# ,%=-,2*.=# %0'.'&*0# +'8*0:# 0-.# 1%# -# &-))%,# '/# 8*/%# -.2#

2%-)$V8*1%,):# ',# (%,/2'&;# # C',# (%8/# +,%(%,6-)*'.9# 4%# ($'782# 1%#

>.'48%2=%-18%#*.#)$%#1-(*0(#'/#)$*(#6%,:#*&+',)-.)#(71I%0);#

G22*)*'.-88:9#)$%#(71I%0)#'/#%0'.'&*0(#2%-8(#+,*.0*+-88:#4*)$#

)$%#+,'270)*'.#-.2#2*(),*17)*'.#'/#=''2(;#g7%()*'.(#/'88'4#$-6*.=#)'#

2'# 4*)$# )$%# &')*6-)*'.(# )'# +,'270%# )$'(%# =''2(9# 4$-)# ='%(# *.)'#


%

!h#

)$%*,#+,'270)*'.9#-.2#%6%.#4$:#=''2(#-,%#,%/%,,%2#)'#-(#D/++*#8E#?$%#

()72:# '/# %0'.'&*0(# -8('# +,'6*2%(# -.(4%,(# )'# A7%()*'.(# -(# )'#4$'#

=%)(#4$-)9#$'4#+,*0%(#-,%#2%)%,&*.%29#-.2#$'4#)$%#&-,>%)#'+%,-)%(;#

E)#*(#-#1,'-2#-.2#-88#%.0'&+-((*.=#(0*%.0%#4$*0$#1:#2%/-78)#+,%(%.)(#

A7%()*'.(# -.2# -.(4%,(# +%,)-*.*.=# )'# +718*0# +'8*0:;# ?$*(# 7.*A7%#

0$-,-0)%,*()*0# *(# '.%# '/# )$%# &-*.# ,%-('.(# 4$:# 6%,:# %-,8:# *.# *)(#

$*()',*0-8# 2%6%8'+&%.)9# %0'.'&*0(# 1%0-&%# %.)-.=8%2# 4*)$#

('0*-8*()(U# *2%-(;# E.# /-0)9# *)# 0-.# 1%# (-*2# )$-)# ('0*-8*()# *2%-(# $-6%#

=,%-)8:# -8)%,%2# 4$-)# *(# '/)%.# )-7=$)# )'2-:# -(# %0'.'&*0(;# H7,#

,%-2*.=9#)$%,%/',%9#&7()#1%#(%8%0)*6%#-.2#2%8*1%,-)%;##

?$%# ,%-2%,9# $'4%6%,9# &7()# 7.2%,()-.2# 08%-,8:# )$-)# -.#

-0-2%&*0# -++,'-0$# )'# %0'.'&*0(# *(# .')# %((%.)*-8# *.# ',2%,# )'#

7.2%,()-.2# '7,# 07,,%.)# %0'.'&*0# )7,&'*8;# _',# *(# (0$'8-,8:# ()-)7(#

.%0%((-,:# /',# 8%-,.*.=# $'4#4%# ($'782# ='# -1'7)# /*@*.=# *);# E)# *(# .')#

.%0%((-,:# )'#2%86%# *.)'# )$%# 0'&+8%@*)*%(# '/# %0'.'&*0(# -)# )$%#&',%#

('+$*()*0-)%2# 8%6%8(# '/# )$%# (0*%.0%;# ?$%,%# *(# .'# .%%2# )'# 1%0'&%#

%.&%($%2# *.# ()-)*()*0(9# 0'./7(*.=# =,-+$(9# 0$-,)(9# &'2%8(# ',#

0'&+8*0-)%2# -00'7.)*.=# 0-8078-)*'.(;# ?$%(%# /%-)7,%(# -88# 0%,)-*.8:#

$-6%# -# +8-0%# *.# )$%# ()72:# '/# %0'.'&*0(9# 17)# .')# /',# '7,# (+%0*/*0#

+7,+'(%;# E)# *(# ,-)$%,# )'# (7==%()# )$-)# )$%# ()72:# '/# %0'.'&*0(# 1%#

7.2%,)->%.# *.#',2%,# )'# =-*.# -# /*,&#=,-(+#'/# 0%,)-*.#>%:# 3%0'.'&*0#

+,*.0*+8%(5#)$-)#-,%#7.*6%,(-8#*.#)$%*,#-++8*0-)*'.;#?$*(#>.'48%2=%#*(#

/',#)$%#-6%,-=%#+%,('.9#.')#I7()#)$%#(0$'8-,;##


%

!N#

?$%# ()72:# -.2# 7.2%,()-.2*.=# '/# %0'.'&*0# +,*.0*+8%(# *(# '/#

+,*&-,:# *&+',)-.0%9# -.# %//',)# .')# )'# 1%# )->%.# 8*=$)8:;# ?$%(%#

7.2%,8:*.=# %0'.'&*0# +,*.0*+8%(# 0-.# 1%# (-*2# )'# 1%# *.2*(+7)-18%#

,%=-,28%((#'/#3(0$''85#',#+%,(7-(*'.#1%0-7(%#)$%:#-,%#2%,*6%2#/,'&#

/7.2-&%.)-8#0'.2*)*'.(#4$*0$#-,%#7.*6%,(-8;#E.#)$*(#,%(+%0)#)$%:#0-.#

1%# (-*2# )'# ,%(%&18%# )$%# 8-4(# '/# +$:(*0(# -.2# 0$%&*(),:;# ?$%:# -,%#

/'7.2-)*'.-8#0'.0%+)(#-.2#-++8:# )'#-88#+%'+8%(9# *.#-88#+8-0%(#-.2#-)#

-88# )*&%(;#]'4%6%,9#=*6%.# )$%#()-)%#'/#4$-)#4%#&-:#,%/%,# )'#-(#'7,#

3.-)*'.-8# *=.',-.0%95# )$%(%# %0'.'&*0# +,*.0*+8%(#4%,%# %*)$%,# .%6%,#

8%-,.%29# $-6%# 1%%.# /',='))%.9# *=.',%2# ',# -8)'=%)$%,# -1-.2'.%2# 1:#

'7,#+,%(%.)#=%.%,-)*'.;##

(

;"&(;?1(>@%'&4&+(

#

E.)%,%()*.=8:9# %0'.'&*0(# -(# -.# -0-2%&*0# 2*(0*+8*.%# $%,%# *.#

)$*(# 0'7.),:# *(# ,%8-)*6%8:# .%4;# E)# ,%-88:# 2*2# .')# 1%0'&%# +-,)# '/#

7.*6%,(*):# 07,,*0787&# 7.)*8# )$%# 8-()# $-8/# '/# )$%# "N)$# 0%.)7,:;#

\0'.'&*0# )$*.>*.=9# $'4%6%,9# $-(# *)(# )$%',%)*0-8# -.2# +$*8'('+$*0-8#

,'')(# 2-)*.=# 1-0># )'# )$%# i,%%>(9# ()-,)*.=# 4*)$# B'0,-)%(# LYKNj!NN#

k;Q;M9#l8-)'#LYDXj!YXk;Q;M9#-.2#G,*()')8%#L!hYj!DD#k;Q;M;###

\6%.# -)# )$*(# %-,8:# ()-=%9# 4%# 0-.# (%%# 2*//%,%.)# 3(0$''8(5# '/#

)$'7=$)9#(70$#-(#)$%#7)'+*-.*(&#'/#l8-)'V4*)$#$*(#2%(0,*+)*'.#'/#)$%#

3+$*8'('+$%,#>*.=(5#4$'#4'782#%@%,0*(%#,78%#*.#)$%#*2%-8#O%+718*0V

6%,(7(#)$%#,%-8*(&#'/#G,*()')8%;#[*//%,%.)#(0$''8(#-.2#*2%'8'=*%(#8*))%,#


%

YW#

)$%#/*%82#'/#+'8*)*0-8#-.2#%0'.'&*0#)$'7=$)#-(#4%88;#B'&%#'/#)$%#&',%#

+,'&*.%.)# '.%(# -,%# )$%# Q8-((*0*()(9# )$%# T%,0-.)*8*()(9# )$%#

E.()*)7)*'.-8*()(9# )$%# T-,@*()(9# )$%# C-1*-.(9# )$%# B:.2*0-8*()(9# )$%#

`%:.%(*-.(9# )$%# &'.%)-,*()(9# )$%# (7++8:j(*2%,(9# -.2# )$%# G7(),*-.(;#

B+%0*/*0#*2%'8'=*%(#*.0872%#0-+*)-8*(&9#('0*-8*(&9#0'&&7.*(&9#-.2#-#

4$'8%# 8*()# '/# ')$%,# D)#&#8E# O-)$%,# )$-.# ()72:*.=# %-0$# %@-&+8%# *.#

2%+)$9#4%#0-.#8''>#-)#-#(+%0),7&R#

#

*-#'8",+%mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm;1%#3,%#',#-(

#

G)#'.%#%@),%&%#-,%#)$'(%#)$-)#1%8*%6%#)$-)#='6%,.&%.)#*(#.')#

%((%.)*-8# -.2# )$-)# *)# 0-.# 1%# )')-88:# ,%+8-0%2# 1:# )$%#&-,>%);# ?$%(%#

4'782#1%#08-((*/*%2#-(#+'8*)*0-8#-.-,0$*()(;#G)#)$%#')$%,#%@),%&%#-,%#

)$%# -26'0-)%(# '/# )')-8*)-,*-.*(&;#?$%(%# *.2*6*27-8(#4'782#$-6%# )$%#

='6%,.&%.)# 0'.),'8# )$%# +,'270)*'.# -.2# 2*(),*17)*'.# '/# =''2(#

)$%,%1:#0'&+8%)%8:#2*(+8-0*.=#)$%#&-,>%);#G8)$'7=$#%6%,:#(0$''8#'/#

)$'7=$)#-.2# *2%'8'=:#$-(# *)(#'4.#(%0)(9#-)#-#1,'-2# 8%6%8#&-.:#(%8/j

2%(0,*1%2# 0'&&7.*()(# -.2#T-,@*()(# 4'782# /-88# '.# )$*(# %.2# '/# '7,#

(+%0),7&;# ?$%#&'()# *&+',)-.)# A7%()*'.(# )'# -(># '.%(%8/# -,%# )$%(%R#

DF."1"%'4+(/%-.)#%#7'4"%*+%G%2"4+(/HE9#',#DF."1"%'4+(/%-.)#%#7'4"%*+%G%

8+&(% -+%2"4+(/HE#<%#($'782#-(>#'7,(%86%(#)$%(%#A7%()*'.(#>%%+*.=#

*.#&*.2# )$-)# %0'.'&*0(# *(# .')# +'8*)*0(;# H.%# *(# -# (0*%.0%# 0'.0%,.%2#

4*)$#)$%#+,'270)*'.#-.2#2*(),*17)*'.#'/#=''2(;#?$%#')$%,#*(#)$%#-,)#'/#


%

Y"#

,78*.=c# $'4%6%,9# -(>*.=# '7,(%86%(# )$%(%# A7%()*'.(# /',0%(# 7(# )'# (%%#

$'4#A7*0>8:#4%#0-.#0'j&*.=8%#)$%#)4';#

]*()',:#2'%(#.')#,%0',2#-#)*&%#4$%.#)$%,%#4-(#-#0'&+8%)%8:#

-.-,0$*()# %0'.'&*0# %.6*,'.&%.);# a*1%,)-,*-.# 4,*)%,# C,-.>#

Q$'2','6#,%/%,%.0%(#*.#)$%#I++:%+0%J3*/"##-#)*&%#4$%.#D-."1"%,'#%(+%

:)(/%)(%G#1'"4$%23-%-.'-%"6"1<%&'(%*)*%,.'-%,'#%1)/.-%)(%.)#%+,(%"<"#8E%

?$*(# 4,*))%.# -00'7.)# 4'782# 0%,)-*.8:# *&+8:# 0'&+8%)%# /,%%2'&# *.#

%0'.'&*0#-//-*,(#-(#4%88#-(#')$%,(;#]'4%6%,9#%6%.#)$%#E(,-%8*)%(#4%,%#

.')#4*)$'7)#)$%#('0*-8#0'.),'8(#)$-)#-,%#)$%#%((%.0%#'/#='6%,.&%.);#

E.#')$%,#4',2(9#/,%%2'&#4-(#.')#8*0%.(%;#?$*(#4-(#)$%#(*=.*/*0-.0%#'/#

)$%# ,78%# '/# I72=%(9# -8)$'7=$# )$%*,# -7)$',*):# (%%&%2# )'# $-6%# ,%()%2#

('8%8:#'.#+718*0#'+*.*'.;#DKC+%#')*%!'.,".L9#$-2#)$%# /',0%#'/9# K#+%#'<%

,"%'448LE#

C',# )$%#&'()#+-,)9# $*()',:#$-(#=,-6*)-)%2# )'4-,2(# )$%#')$%,#

%@),%&%V)')-8*)-,*-.*(&;# ]*()',*0-88:9# ='6%,.&%.)(# $-6%# -84-:(#

('7=$)#)'#%@+-.2#)$%*,#+'4%,#'6%,#)$%*,#(71I%0)(U#8*6%(9#078&*.-)*.=#

*.#)$%#)')-8*)-,*-.#2*0)-)',($*+(#'/#_-J*#i%,&-.:9#B'6*%)#O7((*-9#-.2#

T-'*()# Q$*.-# *.# )$%# )4%.)*%)$# 0%.)7,:;# i'6%,.&%.)# 0'.),'8# '/# -88#

+,'270)*6%# +,'+%,):9# 0'&&-.2*.=# *)(# +,'270)*'.9# -.2# *)(#

2*(),*17)*'.# *(#-# )')-8#0'.),'8#'/# ('0*%):;#G# )')-8*)-,*-.#(:()%&# *(#1:#

*)(# 6%,:# .-)7,%# ):,-..*0-8;# <*)$*.# )$%# 0'./*.%(# '/# -# )')-8*)-,*-.#

(:()%&#)$%,%#*(#-1('87)%8:#.'#%0'.'&*0#/,%%2'&;#G(#08-((*0-8#8*1%,-8(#

(70$#-(#a724*=#6'.#T*(%(#(),%((%29#'.0%#)$%#='6%,.&%.)#-1'8*($%(#

%0'.'&*0# /,%%2'&(9#-88#')$%,# 8*1%,)*%(#2*(-++%-,#-(#4%88;# 3C,%%2'&#


%

YD#

'/# )$%# +,%((5# *(# -.# %&+):# (8'=-.# 4$%.# )$%# ='6%,.&%.)# '4.(# )$%#

.%4(+-+%,(# -.2# ,-2*'(9# -.2# *)# *(# .-n6%# )'# =7-,-.)%%# 0*)*J%.(# )$%#

,*=$)#)'#0,*)*0*J%#)$%#='6%,.&%.)9#*/#-)#-#&'&%.)U(#.')*0%#)$%:#0-.#1%#

,%-((*=.%2#)'#-#/-0)',:#*.#B*1%,*-;##

(

AB(/&-(C&'&(*-.&3+(

#

<$-)#*(#-)#)$%#,'')#'/#(70$#-#=8-,*.=#2*0$')'&:f#G.29#4$:#*(#

)')-8*)-,*-.*(&# /-6',%2f# E/# 4%# %@-&*.%# $*()',:# -(# -# 0'&+'(*)%# '/#

$7&-.# 1%$-6*',# '6%,# )*&%9# 4%# 0'.0872%# )$-)# )$%# -0)*'.# '/# &-.#

()%&(#%.)*,%8:#/,'&#-.#*.08*.-)*'.#'/#)$%#K."'1-%+0%&'(LV)$%#4-:#$%#

)$*.>(;#k7)#4$:#2'%(#$%#)$*.>#)$*(#4-:f#E)#*(#.3&'(%('-31"9#)$-)#/-)-8#

)%.2%.0:#'/#&-.>*.2#4$*0$#.%*)$%,#,%8*=*'.#.',#&',-8*):#0-.#()'+F#

_-)7,-8# a-4# )$%',*()(# 8'.=# -='# +'*.)%2# )'# )$%# +,'18%&(# '/# $7&-.#

.-)7,%;#G(#C,%2%,*0#k-()*-)#'1(%,6%2R#

#B%8/j+,%(%,6-)*'.#-.2#(%8/j2%6%8'+&%.)#-,%#0'&&'.#-(+*,-)*'.(#

-&'.=#-88#+%'+8%;#G.2# */# %6%,:'.%#%.I':%2# )$%#7.,%(),*0)%2#7(%#

'/#$*(#/-078)*%(#-.2#)$%#/,%%#2*(+'(*)*'.#'/#)$%#/,7*)(#'/#$*(# 8-1',9#

('0*-8#+,'=,%((#4'782#1%#0%-(%8%((9#7.*.)%,,7+)%29#-.2#7./-*8*.=;#

k7)# )$%,%# *(# -8('# -.')$%,# )%.2%.0:# )$-)# *(# 0'&&'.#

-&'.=#+%'+8%;#<$%.# )$%:#0-.9# )$%:#4*($# )'# 8*6%#-.2#+,'(+%,#-)#

)$%# %@+%.(%# '/# ')$%,(;# ?$*(# *(# .'# ,-($# -007(-)*'.;# _',# 2'%(# *)#

0'&%# /,'&# -# =8''&:# -.2# 7.0$-,*)-18%# (+*,*);# ?$%# -..-8(# '/#

$*()',:#1%-,#4*).%((# )'# )$%# ),7)$#'/# *)R# )$%# *.0%((-.)#4-,(9#&-((#


%

Y!#

&*=,-)*'.(9# ,%8*=*'7(#+%,(%07)*'.(9#7.*6%,(-8# (8-6%,:9#2*($'.%():#

*.#0'&&%,0%9#-.2#&'.'+'8*%(;#?$*(#/-)-8#2%(*,%#$-(#*)(#',*=*.(#*.#

)$%# 6%,:# .-)7,%# '/# &-.V*.# )$-)# +,*&*)*6%9# 7.*6%,(-89# -.2#

*.(7++,%((*18%#*.()*.0)#)$-)#*&+%8(#$*&#)'#(-)*(/:#$*(#2%(*,%(#4*)$#

)$%#8%-()#+'((*18%#+-*.;K#

#########

?$%# /,-&%,(# '/# '7,# Q'.()*)7)*'.#4%,%# -4-,%# '/# )$*(# ,%-8*):;#

?$%:#1%8*%6%2#)$-)#&-.#*(#-#8*&*)%2#-.2#/-88*18%#0,%-)7,%#-.2#)$-)#-88#

'/#$*(#',=-.*J-)*'.(9#*.()*)7)*'.(9#-.2#(),70)7,%(#-,%#-//%0)%2#1:#)$*(#

8*&*)-)*'.;# G00',2*.=8:9# )$%:# /%8)# )$-)# )$%# +'4%,# -.2# (4-:# '/#

-.:)$*.=#&7()# 1%# 8*&*)%2# -.2# )$-)# ='6%,.&%.)9# -1'6%# -889#&7()# 1%#

(%6%,%8:#8*&*)%2;#

E.#,%-2*.=#)$%#>"*"1'4)#-#%M'5"1#9#-#(%,*%(#'/#h^#-,)*08%(#4$*0$#

-++%-,%2# *.# .%4(+-+%,(# 1%)4%%.# "XhX# -.2# "Xhh9# 4%# 0-.#

0'&+,%$%.2# /',# '7,(%86%(# '7,# C'7.2%,(U# +$*8'('+$*%(# -.2#

&')*6-)*'.(# /',# )$%# ,-)*/*0-)*'.# '/# )$%# P.*)%2# B)-)%(# Q'.()*)7)*'.;#

C%2%,-8*()# _';# ^"9# 4,*))%.# 1:# b-&%(# T-2*('.9# *(# 0'.(*2%,%2#

7.+-,-88%8%2#*.#(0'+%#-(#)$%#08%-,%()#%@+'(*)*'.#'/#)$%#Q'.()*)7)*'.;#

H.%# +-,)*078-,# +-,-=,-+$# *(# -008-*&%2# )'# 1%# -# ($',)# 0'7,(%# *.#

+'8*)*0-8#(0*%.0%;#G#+',)*'.#'/#)$-)#+-,-=,-+$#()-)%(#)$%#/'88'4*.=R######

#G&1*)*'.# &7()# 1%# &-2%# )'# 0'7.)%,-0)# -&1*)*'.;# E)# &-:# 1%# -#

,%/8%0)*'.# '.# $7&-.# .-)7,%9# )$-)# (70$# 2%6*0%(# ($'782# 1%#

.%0%((-,:# )'# 0'.),'8# )$%# -17(%(# '/# ='6%,.&%.);# E/# &%.# 4%,%#

-.=%8(9# .'# ='6%,.&%.)# 4'782# 1%# .%0%((-,:;# E/# -.=%8(# 4%,%# )'#

='6%,.# &%.9# .%*)$%,# %@)%,.-8# .',# *.)%,.-8# 0'.),'8(# '.#


%

YY#

='6%,.&%.)#4'782#1%#.%0%((-,:;#E.#/,-&*.=#-#='6%,.&%.)#4$*0$#

*(#)'#1%#-2&*.*()%,%2#1:#&%.#'6%,#&%.9#)$%#=,%-)#2*//*078):#8*%(#*.#

)$*(R# :'7# &7()# /*,()# %.-18%# )$%# ='6%,.&%.)# )'# 0'.),'8# )$%#

='6%,.%2c#-.2#*.#)$%#.%@)#+8-0%#'18*=%#*)#)'#0'.),'8#*)(%8/;X#

%

?$%# '.%# /-0)# )$-)# *(# 1%*.=#&-2%# 0,:()-8# 08%-,# *(# )$-)#&-.# *(#

.-)7,-88:# *.08*.%2# )'# -6'*2#+-*.# -.2#2*(0'&/',);# B*.0%#4',># *(# -.2#

-84-:(# $-(# 1%%.# +-*./789# &%.# 4*88# ,%(',)# )'# ()%-8*.=# 4$%.%6%,#

()%-8*.=#*(#%-(*%,#)$-.#4',>;#B*.0%#.%*)$%,#,%8*=*'.#.',#&',-8*):#$-(#

1%%.# -18%# )'# 2%)%,# )$*%6%,:9# '.8:# )$%# /',0%# '/# N',% 0-.# ()'+# *);# ?$%#

/',0%#'/# 8-4#&7()#1%#&-2%# )'#+,')%0)#+,*6-)%#+,'+%,):#-.2#+7.*($#

()%-8*.=#*.#',2%,#/',#-#('0*%):#)'#/7.0)*'.#-.2#+,'(+%,;#

?$*(#4-(# )$%#08-((*0-89#.-)7,-8# 8-4#0'.0%+)*'.#'/# )$%#+,'+%,#

,'8%#'/#='6%,.&%.)9#.-&%8:#)'#$%8+#*.2*6*27-8(#(%07,%#)$%*,#,*=$)(#)'#

+%-0%# -.2# +,'+%,):# )$-)# 4%,%# 2%,*6%2# /,'&# ('&%)$*.=# &+1"%

03(*'&"(-'4# )$-.# )$%# ='6%,.&%.)# *)(%8/;# E/# )$%# ='6%,.&%.)# %6%,#

2%6*-)%2# /,'&# )$*(# -((*=.%2# ,'8%# '/# +,')%0)*.=# +,'+%,):9# -.2# *)(%8/#

1%0-&%#)$%#2%(+'*8%,9#)$%.#*)#4-(#.'#8'.=%,#8%=*)*&-)%;#?$*(#4-(#)$%#

7.2%,()-.2*.=# '/# )$%# G&%,*0-.# C'7.2%,(9# -.2# *)# *(# 4$:# )$%# P;B;#

Q'.()*)7)*'.# *(# 8-,=%8:# -# 8*()# '/# 51+.)2)-)+(## '.# )$%# /%2%,-8#

='6%,.&%.);# E.# +-,)*078-,9# )$%# k*88# '/# O*=$)(# +,'6*2%(# (),*0)#

8*&*)-)*'.(# '.# )$%# -0)*6*)*%(# '/# )$%# /%2%,-8# ='6%,.&%.)9# -.2# )$%#

?%.)$# G&%.2&%.)# &->%(# *)# 0,:()-8# 08%-,# )$-)# -.:# +'4%,(# .')#

%@+8*0*)8:#&%.)*'.%2#*.#)$%#Q'.()*)7)*'.#-,%#,%(%,6%2#%*)$%,#/',#)$%#

()-)%(#',#)$%#+%'+8%;#


%

Y^#

H1(%,6%9# $'4%6%,9# )$-)# '7,# +,%(%.)# 2-:# ='6%,.&%.)# $-(#

&'6%2# -4-:# /,'&# *)(# +,'+%,# 0'.()*)7)*'.-8# ,'8%# -.2# *(# .'4#

'+%,-)*.=# *.# (*&*8-,# /-($*'.# )'# -.0*%.)# +,-0)*0%(# -.2# 2'=&-(;# E)# *(#

*.6'86%2#*.#-,%-(#4$%,%#*)#($'782#.')#1%;#G8)$'7=$#('&%#0$-&+*'.(#

'/#8*1%,):9#(70$#-(#a:(-.2%,#B+''.%,9#$-6%#A7%()*'.%2#)$%#8%=*)*&-0:#

'/#)$%#Q'.()*)7)*'.#*)(%8/V-/)%,#-889#.'.%#'/#7(#)'2-:#%6%,#(*=.%2#)$*(#

30'.),-0)5FV4%#0-.#(-/%8:#(%)#-(*2%#(70$#+$*8'('+$*0-8#A7%()*'.(#/',#

-.')$%,#2-:;#H1(%,6*.=#)$%#-0)7-8#1%$-6*',#'/#)$%#P;B;#='6%,.&%.)9#

)$*(#&70$# *(# 08%-,R# \6%.# /',# )$'(%# '/# 7(#4$'# ,%6%,%# )$%# C'7.2*.=#

C-)$%,(# -.2# ,%(+%0)# )$%# Q'.()*)7)*'.# -(# '.%# '/# )$%# +*88-,(# '/# )$%#

P.*)%2# B)-)%(9# *)# *(# 7.2%.*-18%# )$-)# )$%# /%2%,-8# ='6%,.&%.)# .'#%

21+:"(%)-#%"(*%+0%-."%7+(-1'7-;#

<$%.#4%9# )$%#='6%,.%29#-,%#-18%#)'# *2%.)*/:#)$-)# 8-4&->%,(#

)->%#4$-)#*(#'7,(#-.2##=*6%#*)#)'#)$'(%#)$-)#$-6%#.')#%-,.%2#*)9#4%9#)$%#

6*0)*&*J%2# ='6%,.%29# -,%# 1'7.2# )'# 1%# -//%0)%2# 1:# )$-)# *.I7()*0%;# E)#

4'782#1%#-#0,*&%#*/#4%#2*2#4$-)#='6%,.&%.)#2'%(;#<%#4*).%((#)$-)#

()%-8*.=#*(#',=-.*J%2#1:#)$%#8-4#/',#)$%#+,'/*)#'/#)$'(%#)$-)#&->%#)$%#

8-4;# ?$%# 7.8-4/78.%((9# 0'&&*))%2# 1:# '7,# '4.# ='6%,.&%.)9# /',0%(#

7+'.# )$%# ='6%,.%2# )'#&->%# )$%#2*//*078)# 0$'*0%#'/# %*)$%,#1%),-:*.=#

)$%*,# &',-8# 0$-,-0)%,# ',# 8'(*.=# ,%(+%0)# /',# )$%# 8-4# -8)'=%)$%,;#

[%+%.2*.=# '.# )$%*,# 2%=,%%# '/# 7.2%,()-.2*.=# '/# )$*(# ,%-8*):9# )$%#

='6%,.%2#4*88#%*)$%,#4*($#)'#()'+#)$%# 8%=-8# )$%/)# )$%:#(%%#'007,,*.=#

4*)$#*&+7.*):9#',#($-,%#*.#*)#)$%&(%86%(;#

#


%

YK#

D'&&(>-%&'$',+&(

(

E.#8*=$)#'/#)$%(%#,%-8*)*%(#-,%#/,%%#&-,>%)(#+'((*18%f#Q-.#/,%%#

%.)%,+,*(%#%@*()f#E.#-.#-))%&+)#)'#-.(4%,#)$%(%#A7%()*'.(#4%#&7()#

/*,()# ,%-8*J%# )$-)# )$*(# +,%(%.)# =%.%,-)*'.# $-(# .%6%,# %@+%,*%.0%2#

0'&+8%)%8:# /,%%# &-,>%)(9# ',# /',# )$-)# &-))%,9# -# =%.7*.%8:# /,%%#

%.)%,+,*(%#(:()%&;#

C,%%#%.)%,+,*(%# *(#%((%.)*-88:#"7+(+&)7% 01""*+&;#?$*(#&%-.(#

)$%# /,%%2'&# )'# +,'270%# 4$-)%6%,# '.%# 0$''(%(# 4*)$# '.%U(# '4.#

&-)%,*-8(#-.2#)'#'//%,# )$%&#/',#(-8%#-)#4$-)%6%,#+,*0%#'.%#0$''(%(#

4*)$'7)#-.:#$*.2,-.0%#/,'&#-.:#('7,0%9#%(+%0*-88:#='6%,.&%.);#?$%#

'.8:#,%(),-*.)#*(#)$-)#'.%#&-:#.')#7(%#'.%U(#/-078)*%(#-.2#+,'+%,):#)'#

*.I7,%#')$%,(;#E.#%//%0)9#/,%%2'&#0-,,*%(#4*)$#*)#,%(+'.(*1*8*):;#

G22*)*'.-88:9# +,*6-)%#+,'+%,):# *(# -1('87)%8:# %((%.)*-8# )'# /,%%#

%.)%,+,*(%;#E)#*(#)$%#+,%j0'.2*)*'.#'/#/,%%#%.)%,+,*(%;#<*)$'7)#+,*6-)%#

+,'+%,):# )$%,%# 0-.# 1%# .'# /,%%# &-,>%)# ',# /,%%2'&# '/# %.)%,+,*(%;#

?$%,%/',%9# ,%(),-*.)(# '.# +,*6-)%# +,'+%,):# -,%# ,%(),-*.)(# 7+'.#

%.)%,+,*(%;#

E.# )$%# %.)*,%# $*()',:# '/# )$%# 4',829# )$%# '.%# +%,*'2# )$-)#

-++,'-0$%2#)$%#08'(%()#)'#)$%#08-((*0-8#8*1%,-8#6*(*'.#'/#*.)%,.-)*'.-8#

+%-0%#-.2#/,%%#),-2%#18'(('&%2#*.#)$%#"N)$#0%.)7,:9#-.2#%.2%2#4*)$#

)$%# /*,()# <',82# <-,;# ?$%# +,'(+%,*):# -(('0*-)%2# 4*)$# 8*&*)%2#

='6%,.&%.)9# /,%%# ),-2%9# )$%# E.27(),*-8#O%6'87)*'.9#-.2# )$%#08-((*0-8#

='82#()-.2-,2#()-,)%2#*.#i,%-)#k,*)-*.#17)#4-(#(''.#-2'+)%2#1:#)$%#


%

YX#

P.*)%2# B)-)%(;# ]%,%# *.# '7,# 0'7.),:9# 4*)$# )$%# .')-18%# %@0%+)*'.# '/#

(8-6%,:9#/,%%#%.)%,+,*(%#4-(#)$%#2'&*.-.)#+,-0)*0%#/,'&#)$%#0'8'.*-8#

+%,*'2#7.)*8#"N"Y;#H6%,#-#0%.)7,:#'/#4$-)#4%#0-.#),78:#0-88#%0'.'&*0#

/,%%2'&9#-)#8%-()#-(#/-,#-(#)$%#0%.),-8#L',#3/%2%,-85M#='6%,.&%.)#4-(#

0'.0%,.%2;#

]'4# 4-(# *)# -00'&+8*($%2f# E.# 4$-)# (%%&%2# -.# *&+'((*18%#

%@+%,*&%.)9# )$%# 0*)*J%.(# '/# )$%# :'7.=# P.*)%2# B)-)%(# &-.-=%2# )'#

,%)-*.#-# /-*,8:# 8*&*)%2#='6%,.&%.)# )$,'7=$#)$%# /*,()#$-8/#'/# )$%#"N)$#

0%.)7,:;# ?$%# '7)0'&%# 4-(# .')# +%,/%0)c# )$%# ='6%,.&%.)# %.-0)%2#

&%,0-.)*8*()#+'8*0*%(9#%.=-=%2#*.#,-*8,'-2#0'.(),70)*'.9#-.2#('#/',)$;#

k7)#1:#-.2#8-,=%9#%(+%0*-88:#1:#)'2-:U(#()-.2-,2(9#%.)%,+,*(%#4-(#.')#

,%=78-)%29# 0'.),'88%2# ',# 2*,%0)%2# 1:# )$%# /%2%,-8# ='6%,.&%.);# ?$%#

,%(78)# ),-.(/',&%2# )$%# P.*)%2# B)-)%(# *.)'# )$%# 8%-2*.=# 0'&&%,0*-8#

.-)*'.# '/# )$%# 4',82F# # ?$%# -6%,-=%# G&%,*0-.9# )$%# &*228%# 08-((9#

1%0-&%#4%-8)$*%,# )$-.#%6%,# *.#$*()',:;# E.# /-0)9#-88#'/# )$%#+,'(+%,*):#

-.2#-0$*%6%&%.)(#4%#$-6%#)'2-:#4%#'4%#)'#)$%#%//',)(#'/#)$*(#08-((#

'/#+%'+8%#-.2#)'#)$*(#(:()%&;#G.2#)$%#=%.%(*(#'/#)$-)#(:()%&#1%=-.#*.#

)$%# "h)$# 0%.)7,:# 4*)$# -.# )*"'O# )$%# *2%-# '/# 4')##"P% 0')1"=3,4,%,-.(

.15&'-4&-%(#-9(B'&&,-.(4&-E(

?$*(# +'4%,/78# *2%-# )''># $'82# -.2# 0$-.=%2# )$%# 4',82F# C,%%#

%.)%,+,*(%#*.0%.)*6*J%2#&-.#)'#+7)#$*(#$%-,)9#$*(#&*.29#-.2#$*(#$-.2(#

)'4-,2#+,'270)*'.#'/#$*(#'4.#.%%2(#4*)$#$*(#'4.#1%()#%//',)(;#?$%#

4',82#4*).%((%2#)$%#,%(78)(;#i'6%,.&%.)#$-(#.%6%,#1%%.#-18%#)'#2'#

)$*(9#0-..')#2'#)$*(9#.',#0-.#*)#/',0%#&%.#',#&-,>%)(#)'#2'#)$*(;#


%

Yh#

]'4%6%,9#'.%#/7.2-&%.)-8#*2%-#&7()#1%#/788:#=,-(+%2R#7.2%,#

/,%%#%.)%,+,*(%9#+%'+8%#&7()#1%#,%(+'.(*18%#/',#)$%*,#'4.#4%88#1%*.=;#

l%'+8%# 4$'# -,%# '82# %.'7=$# )'# 4',># -.2# -,%# -18%# )'# 2'# ('# &7()#

+,'6*2%#/',#)$%*,#.%%2(#-.2#4-.)(#1:#)$%*,#'4.#%//',)(;#?$'(%#4$'#

-,%#.')#-18%#)'#4',>#&7()#1%#+,'6*2%2#/',#1:#/-&*8*%(#-.2#6'87.)-,:#

',=-.*J-)*'.(;# P.8%((# /,%%#&%.# -((7&%# )$%(%# ,%(+'.(*1*8*)*%(9# )$%:#

/',/%*)#)$%&#)'#='6%,.&%.)#+'4%,(;#

P./',)7.-)%8:9# '7,# +,%(%.)# =%.%,-)*'.# $-(# -88# 17)# /',/%*)%2#

)$%*,#,%(+'.(*1*8*)*%(# )'#='6%,.&%.);#\6%.)7-88:9#4$%.#='6%,.&%.)#

$-(# )$%# +%'+8%# -.2# )$%# &-,>%)# +8-0%# 7.2%,# *)(# 0'&+8%)%# 0'.),'89#

)')-8*)-,*-.*(&# (%)(# *.# -.2# ('0*%):# *(# %.(8-6%2;# ['%(# )$*(# (+%88# )$%#

%.2f##

#

F1%(7&%G((

(

?$%#=%.%,-8#2%08*.%#*.#+,'270)*'.#4$*0$#='6%,.&%.)#*.270%(#

1:# *)(# '4.# 0'6%)'7(.%((# 2'%(# (+%88# *)(# '4.# 2%&*(%;# ]'4%6%,9# 4%#

&7()#.')#/',=%)#)$-)#='6%,.&%.)#$-(#.'#4%-8)$#'/#*)(#'4.#-.2#)$-)#*)#

0-.#'.8:#(7,6*6%#1:#)->*.=#4%-8)$#/',&#*)(#'4.#0*)*J%.(;#E.#-#0'7.),:#

-(# ,*0$# -(# '7,(9# )$*(# (A7-.2%,*.=# 0'782# ='# '.# /',# ('&%# )*&%;#

_%6%,)$%8%((9# *)# *(#(:()%&-)*0-88:# )->*.=#+8-0%#.'4;#]*()',*0-88:#-.:#

='6%,.&%.)U(# 78)*&-)%# 2%08*.%# $-(# 7(7-88:# 1%%.# '00-(*'.%2# 1:# -#

2*(-(),'7(# 4-,9# 17)# +,*',# )'# )$-)# %6%.)# $-(# 1%%.# )$%# 0'.)*.7'7(#

2%6-87-)*'.# '/# *)(# &'.%:9# )$%# *.0,%-(%# '/# 2%1)# -.2# 2*(0'7,-=*.=#


%

YN#

)-@-)*'.#4$*0$#78)*&-)%8:#2%(),':%2#)$%#-(+*,-)*'.(9#$'+%(#-.2#(%8/#

%()%%&#'/#*)(#0*)*J%.(;#?$*(#*(#)$%#,%-8#0,*&%9#)$%#,%-8#%6*8#'/#*)#-88;#?$*(#

*(#)$%#%6*8#4%#($'782#.')#=*6%#*.)';##

#########################################################1 Frank Chodorov, The Rise & Fall of Society (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2007), p. 153. 2 Chodorov, The Rise & Fall of Society, p. 8. 3 Murray Rothbard, The Case Against the Fed (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1994), p. 3. Available at: http://mises.org/books/fed.pdf. Accessed June 2, 2010. 4 John Maynard Keynes, The Economic Consequences of the Peace (1919), pp. 235-236. Available at: http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/15776. Accessed June 2, 2010. 5 Henry Hazlitt, Thinking as a Science (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., 1920), p. 244. Available at: http://mises.org/books/thinking.pdf. Accessed June 2, 2010. 6 Frederic Bastiat, The Law (Irvington-on-Hudson, NY: The Foundation for Economic Education, 2004), p. 5. 7 James Madison, The Federalist No. 51 (1788). Available at: http://www.constitution.org/fed/federa51.htm. Accessed June 2, 2010.

!""#""$%&'()#'*+$%',-./0#1'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#

#

!"#

!"#$%&'()(

*+,-./(01'(2#3(

#

#

!"#$%&'#( )*$$+#,( *( -*$.( &/( ,&)+#.%( &'(

0+,(,0&123#$,4(5&(&'#(+,($#2+#"#3(&/(0+,(

,0*$#(&/($#,-&',+6+2+.%(6%(&.0#$,4(

78139+:("&'(;+,#,<(

!

!

$%&%'($# )*(&$()+,-# .*,# $+.--($.+# *,.-%&,/# /,/0$1(%&-#

'./,# 23# 4*,.1# 15(&6,*-# %7# 15,# ).-1# .-# 15,3# %2-,*8,/#

'.&# .&/# 15,# 9%*+/# .2%01# 5(':# ;5,3# %*(4(&.1,# 7*%'# -,+7<,8(/,&1#

1*015-:# =,+7<,8(/,&1# 1*015-# .*,# 15%-,# 1*015-# 95($5# .*,# 15,(*# %9&#

,8(/,&$,:# ;5,3# .*,# &%1# +,.*&,/# 23# *,7,*,&$,# 1%# -%',# %15,*# 1*015:#

;5,*,# 5.-# 2,,&># 5%9,8,*># .# 4*%9(&4# .--.0+1# %&# 15,-,# ,-1.2+(-5,/#

)*,'(-,-#%8,*#15,#+.-1#%&,#50&/*,/#3,.*->#&%1#%&+3#(&#15(-#$%0&1*3>#

201#15*%045%01#15,#9%*+/:#;5(-#*,?,$1(%&#%7#,$%&%'($#)*(&$()+,-#5.-#

)01#%0*#$(8(+(@.1(%&#(&#4*,.1#/.&4,*:#;5,#&,,/#1%#10*&#2.$6#1%#15,-,#

1*./(1(%&.+# -1.&/.*/-# (-# 4*,.1,*# &%9# 15.&# (1# 5.-# ,8,*# 2,,&# (&# 15,#

5(-1%*3#%7#15,#9%*+/:##

#

A#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!B#

45#'5-%3(.#/!671.8#.5&(

#

C%#%15,*#,$%&%'($#)*(&$()+,#/,'%&-1*.1,-#15,#(&-(45170+&,--#

%7# .# -,+7<,8(/,&1# 1*015# 15.&# 15,# ,$%&%'($# )*(&$()+,# %7# ,)*$)+.%:#

D.&6(&/#+(8,-#(&#.#9%*+/#%7#-$.*$(13#&%1#.20&/.&$,:#E,-%0*$,->#(&#.++#

)+.$,-# .&/# (&# .++# 1(',-># .*,# -$.*$,:# ;5(-# (-># .&/# .+9.3-# 5.-# 2,,&># .#

7.$1# %7# 50'.&# ,F(-1,&$,# 5,*,# %&# )+.&,1# ,.*15:# G1# (-# 15,# )*('.*3#

*,.-%&#953#9,#'0-1#.++#+,.*&#1%#2,#7*04.+#.&/#,$%&%'(@,:#G&#,--,&$,#

9,#'0-1#$,01H)01#-%',15(&4#2.$6#7*%'#95.1#9,#5.8,#)*%/0$,/#1%#

$%&1,&/#9(15#15,#0&$,*1.(&13#%7#15,#7010*,:##

=$.*$(13># 5%9,8,*># $.&#2,# .# $%&70-(&4# $%&$,)1# 7%*#),%)+,# 1%#

0&/,*-1.&/#(&#15(-#/.3#.&/#1(',>#,-),$(.++3#5,*,#(&#15,#I&(1,/#=1.1,-:#

J71,*#.++>#+%%6#.*%0&/H/%#9,#&%1#-,,#.20&/.&$,#,8,*395,*,K#;5(-#

%28(%0-#7.$1#(-#)%(&1,/#%01#1%#0-#%&#.&3#4(8,&#/.3#23#-(')+3#9.+6(&4#

15*%045#.&3#+%$.+#-0),*'.*6,1:#A8,*395,*,#9,#+%%6>#15,#-5,+8,-#(&#

.&3#.(-+,#.*,#7(++,/#1%#15,#2*('#9(15#7%%/#)*%/0$1-#%7#,8,*3#13),#.&/#

/,-$*()1(%&:#;5,*,#.*,#.+-%#7*0(1-#.&/#8,4,1.2+,-#)(+,/#5(45#%&#.++#15,#

$%0&1,*-#.&/#-5%))(&4#2(&-:#D,.1->#/.(*3#)*%/0$1->#2*,./-># 15,# +(-1#

4%,-#%&#.&/#%&:#J20&/.&$,#,8,*395,*,L#

;5,# -.',# (-# 1*0,# (&# -5%))(&4# '.++-:# ;5,*,# .*,# *,1.(+# -5%)-#

.&/#/,).*1',&1#-1%*,-#7(++,/#9(15#.)).*,+>#7%%19,.*#.&/#.++#13),-#%7#

.$$,--%*(,-# 7%*# ',&># 9%',&# .&/# $5(+/*,&:# M0&/*,/-># -%',1(',-#

15%0-.&/->#%7#/(77,*,&1#/,-(4&,*-#.&/#'.&07.$10*,*-#5.8,#)*%/0$,/#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!N#

15,-,# 4%%/-:# # D%-1# %7# 15,'# .*,# '.&07.$10*,/# (&# /(77,*,&1# ).*1-# %7#

15,#9%*+/#.&/#(')%*1,/#5,*,#,-),$(.++3#7%*#%0*#$%&-0')1(%&:##

O,# .+-%# -,,# $.*-# ,8,*395,*,># (&# ).*6(&4# +%1-# .&/# %&# 15,#

*%./-:#O5,&#9,# 1*.8,+# (&#%0*#%9&#8,5($+,->#4%(&4# (&#.&3#/(*,$1(%&>#

9,# $.&# /*(8,# 23# .).*1',&1# 5%0-,-># $%&/%'(&(0'-# .&/# '.&($0*,/#

&,(452%*5%%/-#9(15#2,.01(70+#5%',-:#;5,#5(45#*(-,->#%77($,#20(+/(&4-#

.&/#,8,&#-63-$*.),*-#'.6,#$+,.*#95.1#9,#-,,:##G1#(-#&%1#-$.*$(13>#201#

*.15,*#15,#%))%-(1,P.20&/.&$,L#

O5.1# 9,# .*,# -,,(&4># 5%9,8,*># (-# 15,# -#$)#-.+&'# %7#

.20&/.&$,H.&# (++0-(%&# %7# .# -%*1:# Q,-># 15,# (1,'-# .*,# 15,*,# .&/# /%#

,F(-1>#201#9,#'0-1#4%#2,5(&/# 15,-,#)*%/0$1-# 1%#-,,# 15,#0&/,&(.2+,#

,$%&%'($#)*(&$()+,#%7#-$.*$(13#%7#95($5#9,#-),.6R#7%*#(7#9,#9,*,#1%#

$/#2#)*%/0$(&4# 7%*#.&3# +,&415#%7# 1(',>#.++#%7# 15(-#.20&/.&$,#9%0+/#

S0($6+3# /(-.)),.*:# O5.1# 9,# 7(&/# 2,5(&/# .++# %7# 15,-,# )*%/0$1-># .&/#

15,#-,*8($,-#.--%$(.1,/#9(15# 15,'># (-# 15,#)*%/0$1(%&# 15.1#4%,-# (&1%#

'.6(&4# 15,'#.&/# *,)+.$(&4# 15,'#95,&# 15,3# .*,# $%&-0',/:#I&/,*#

$+%-,*#(&-),$1(%&#9,#/(-$%8,*#95.1#.&$(,&1#15(&6,*-#.&/#,$%&%'(-1-#

5.8,# .+9.3-# )%(&1,/# %01H15.1# 50'.&# 9*'.,( .*,# ,&/+,--# .&/# '.&#

-,1-#%01#1%#.$S0(*,#5(-#9.&1->#3,1#15,#>#*',(7%*#.$S0(*(&4#15,'#.*,#

15,'-,+8,-#-$.*$,:#J-#E%152.*/#,F)+.(&-T#

#J++# 50'.&# +(7,#'0-1# 1.6,#)+.$,# +'( .+>#P:J#'.&U-# .+>## (-# .+9.3-#

-$.*$,:#M,#(-#&%1#(''%*1.+R#5(-#1(',#%&#,.*15#(-#+('(1,/:#A.$5#/.3#

%7# 5(-# +(7,# 5.-# %&+3# BV# 5%0*-# (&# 95($5# 5,# $.&# .11.(&# 5(-# ,&/-:#

W0*15,*'%*,>#.++#.$1(%&-#'0-1#1.6,#)+.$,#15*%045#1(',:#;5,*,7%*,#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!V#

1(',# (-# .# >#*',# 15.1# '.&# '0-1# 0-,# 1%# .**(8,# .1# 5(-# ,&/-:PXJY++#

',.&-#.*,#-$.*$,:B#

(

9"&(:&#.,(+;(<'+815%-+.(

#

;5,#',.&-#%7#)*%/0$1(%&#.*,#2*'3?(2*6&$(.&/()*-+.*2:#Z.&/H

95($5#(&$+0/,-#.++#&.10*.+#*,-%0*$,-#201#.+-%#-%',15(&4#.-#-(')+,#.-#

.#)+.$,#1%#-1.&/H(-#-$.*$,:#;5,#*,-%0*$,-#(&#15,#+.&/>#7*%'#15,#1%)#

-%(+# 0-,/# 1%# 4*%9# 7%%/# )*%/0$1-# 1%# 15,# %(+# %*# 4%+/# 9,# $.&# ,F1*.$1#

7*%'#(1>#.*,#.+-%#-$.*$,:#O,#/%#&%1#&,,/#1%#2,#,&8(*%&',&1.+(-1-#1%#

*,$%4&(@,#15(-#7.$1:#[01>#-0*)*(-(&4+3>#-%#(-#+.2%*:#;5,#-$.*$(13#%7#+.2%*#

$.&# 2,# ,8,&# '%*,# /(77($0+1# 1%# 7.15%'# 15.&# $%&-0',*# 4%%/->#

,-),$(.++3# (&# .&# ,$%&%'($# ,&8(*%&',&1# 95,*,# -%# '.&3# .*,# %01# %7#

9%*6# .&/# 9,# .*,# 2,(&4# 2%'2.*/,/# 9(15# 0&,')+%3',&1# -1.1(-1($-#

,8,*3/.3:#

;%# -,,# 15.1# +.2%*# (-# -$.*$,# 9,# &,,/# 1%# +%%6# 2,5(&/# 15,#

-1.1(-1($-#.&/#-10/3#%0*-,+8,-#.-#(&/(8(/0.+-:#O5.1#9,#7(&/#(-#15.1#9,#

.++#5.8,#.#4*,.1#'.&3#'%*,#15(&4-#15.1#&,,/#/%(&4#%*#15%-,#9,#9.&1#

1%#4,1#/%&,>#201#9,#5.8,#&,(15,*#15,#1(',>#,&,*43>#&%*#(&(1(.1(8,#1%#/%#

15,':# =%',# %7# 15,-,# 1.-6-# %28(%0-+3# *,S0(*,# '.1,*(.+-># 201# .++# %7#

15,'# *,S0(*,# +.2%*:# G7# %&,# ',*,+3# ,F1*.)%+.1,-# 15(-# 7.$1# (&# %&,U-#

'(&/# 1%# ,F1,&/# 2,3%&/# 5(-# %9&# -'.++# 9%*+/# %7# .$1(8(1(,-># 1%# 15,#

.$1(8(1(,-# %7# 5(-# $(13># 5(-# -1.1,># 5(-# &.1(%&># 5(-# 9%*+/># %&,# S0($6+3#

2,4(&-#1%#-,,#15.1#15,#)%1,&1(.+#/,'.&/#7%*#+.2%*#(-#(&/,,/#,&/+,--:#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!!#

G&#15,#,&/>#15(-#(-#)*,$(-,+3#953#+.2%*#(-#-$.*$,:#A8,&#/0*(&4#.#-,8,*,#

*,$,--(%&>#(1U-#&%1#15,#$.-,#15.1#),%)+,#\5.8,#&%15(&4#1%#/%:]#E.15,*>#

95.1# 5.)),&-# (-# 15.1# 15,# )%1,&1(.+# ?%2# %77,*-# .*,# $%&-(/,*,/# +,--#

.)),.+(&4#15.&#$%&1(&0,/#?%2#-,.*$5:#G&#15(-#*,-),$1>#0&,')+%3',&1#

(-#.$10.++3#8%+0&1.*3L(^G&#+.1,*#-,$1(%&-#9,#9(++#-,,#5%9#4%8,*&',&1#

'.&()0+.1(%&# %7# '%&,3# .&/# 2.&6(&4# +,./-# 1%# 15,# 7.'(+(.*# \2%%'<

20-1]#$3$+,#.&/#15*%9-#'(++(%&-#%7#J',*($.&-#(&1%#.#)%-(1(%&#95,*,#

0&,')+%3',&1#(-#15,(*#2,-1#.+1,*&.1(8,:_#

W(&.++3># 15,*,# (-# &%# 4*,.1# .*40',&1# &,,/,/# 1%# *,.+(@,# 15.1#

$.)(1.+# (-#-$.*$,:#;5(-#(-#,-),$(.++3#1*0,#(7#9,#.*,#15(&6(&4#%7#$.)(1.+#

(&#1,*'-#%7#'%&,3#.&/#$*,/(1:#[01#.$10.++3>#$.)(1.+#(-#15,#,S0()',&1#

%*# 1%%+-# 9,# 0-,# (&# )*%/0$1(%&:# `.)(1.+# 4%%/-# .*,# 95.1# .++%9# 0-# 1%#

)*%/0$,#,8,&#'%*,#$%&-0',*#4%%/->#.&/#15,#)*('.*3#*,S0(*,',&1#

7%*#%21.(&(&4#$.)(1.+# (-#,*"+':,:#O5,&#9,#*,-1*($1#%0*#$%&-0')1(%&>#

9,#-.8,:#O5,&#9,#1*.&-7,*#%0*#+.2%*#.&/#%0*#+.&/#1%#15,#7%*'.1(%&#

%7# $.)(1.+# 4%%/-># 9,# .*,# +'"#,.+':# (&# )*%/0$1(%&# 7%*# 15,# 7010*,:#

=.8(&4->#15,*,7%*,>#(-#.&#,--,&1(.+#).*1#%7#.#15*(8(&4#,$%&%'3>#,8,&#(7#

(1#(-#15,#,$%&%'3#%7#%&,#),*-%&:#J4.(&#9,#S0%1,#7*%'#E%152.*/T#

#G&#%*/,*#1%#(++0'(&.1,#$+,.*+3#15,#&.10*,#%7#$.)(1.+#7%*'.1(%&#.&/#

15,# )%-(1(%&# %7# $.)(1.+# (&# )*%/0$1(%&># +,1# 0-# -1.*1# 9(15# 15,#

53)%15,1($.+# ,F.')+,# %7# E%2(&-%&# `*0-%,# -1*.&/,/# %&# .# /,-,*1#

(-+.&/:# E%2(&-%&># %&# +.&/(&4># 9,# .--0',# 7(&/-# 5('-,+7# 9(15%01#

15,#.(/#%7#$.)(1.+#4%%/-#%7#.&3#6(&/:#J++#15.1#(-#.8.(+.2+,#(-#5(-#%9&#

+.2%*#.&/#15,#,+,',&1-#%7#)*%/0$1(%&#4(8,&#5('#23#&.10*,:N#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!a#

#

<'-=#%&(<'+$&'%3(

#

\b*%),*13#(-#.#&,$,--.*3#$%&-,S0,&$,#%7#15,#&.10*,#%7#'.&>](

9*%1,# 15,# W*,&$5# ,$%&%'(-1# W*,/,*($# [.-1(.1># (&# 15,# '(//+,# %7# 15,#

"c15#$,&10*3:#;5(-#(-#+(6,#-.3(&4#15.1#%9&,*-5()#%7#%0*-,+8,-#.&/#%0*#

7.$0+1(,-#(-#)*('.+>#201#15,&#-%#.*,#.++#%7#15,#-$.*$,#&.10*.+#*,-%0*$,-#

9,#7(&/#.++#.*%0&/#0-:#

A$%&%'(-1# D0**.3# E%152.*/># (&# 5(-# 4*,.1# 1*,.1(-,# ;*'?(

!)&'&>%(*'3(@.*.#>#'.6,-#$+,.*#15.1#

#15,#%*(4(&#%7#.++#)*%),*13#(-#0+1('.1,+3#1*.$,.2+,#1%#15,#.))*%)*(.1(%&#%7#.&#

0&0-,/#&.10*,<4(8,&#7.$1%*#23#.#'.&#.&/#5(-#\'(F(&4]#5(-#+.2%*#9(15#15(-#

&.10*.+#7.$1%*#1%#)*%/0$,##.#$.)(1.+#4%%/#%*#.#$%&-0',*-U#4%%/:#W%*#95,&#

9,#1*.$,#2.$6#15*%045#4(71-#.&/#15*%045#,F$5.&4,->#9,#'0-1#*,.$5#.#'.&#

.&/#.&#0&%9&,/#&.10*.+# *,-%0*$,:# G&#.# 7*,,# -%$(,13># .&3#)(,$,#%7#&.10*,#

15.1#5.-#&,8,*#2,,&#0-,/#(-#1'&9'#3#.&/#(-#-02?,$1#1%#.#'.&U-#%9&,*-5()#

15*%045#5(-#7(*-1#0-,#%*#'(F(&4#%7#5(-#+.2%*#9(15#15(-#*,-%0*$,:V#

#

W0*15,*'%*,># /,/0$1(8,# *,.-%&(&4# 1,++-# 0-# 15.1# 9(15%01#

%9&,*-5()# %7# %0*# %9&# )*(8.1,# )*%),*13# 9,# 9%0+/# &%1# 2,# .2+,# 1%#

,F,*$(-,#15,#7*04.+#0-,#%7#-$.*$,#*,-%0*$,-#1%#.$5(,8,#.-#'.&3#,&/-#

.-#)%--(2+,:#A8,&# 15,# .2(+(13# 1%# ,F$5.&4,#%0*#)*%),*13# (&# .#'.*6,1#

)+.$,# 9%0+/# 2,# (')%--(2+,># 7%*# 9,# '0-1# 7(*-1# %9&# (1# %01*(451:##

I+1('.1,+3># 9(15%01# )*%),*13# %9&,*-5()# 15,*,# 9%0+/# 2,# &%# -0$5#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!d#

15(&4#.-#.#'.*6,1#%*#,8,&#.&#,$%&%'3:#;5,*,7%*,>#(7#9,#.*,#1%#5.8,#

.&# ,$%&%'3# .1# .++># %9&,*-5()# %*# $%&1*%+# %8,*# )*%),*13# 23# 15,#

(&/(8(/0.+#(-#('),*.1(8,:##

#

>?-/"%(;'+@(A&#?-%3(

(

e8,*# 15,# ).-1# %&,# 50&/*,/# 3,.*-# 15,# ,')5.-(-# (&# 15,#

(&1,++,$10.+# *,.+'#%7# 15,# 4,&,*.+#)%)0+.$,#5.-#2,,&#0)%&# \$5.&4,]#

%*#15,#\$5.&4(&4#%7#15(&4-]#*.15,*#15.&#0)%&#15,#7(F,/#*,40+.*(1(,-#%7#

15,#0&(8,*-,:#;5(-#7%$0-#%&#$5.&4,#5.-#5./#15,#,77,$1#%7#0&/,*$011(&4#

15,# 2.-(-# 7%*# ,$%&%'($# )*(&$()+,-# %*# 7(F,/# &.10*.+# +.9-:# ;5(-#

*,?,$1(%&# %7# 15,# ',1.)53-($.+# (-# .# 9%*+/# 8(,9# (&# 95($5# 15,*,# (-# &%#

%*/,*#,F$,)1#95.1#'.&#1,')%*.*(+3#/,$(/,-#1%#(')%-,#%&#15(&4-:#

b*%7,--%*# `+.*,&$,# [:# `.*-%&# (&# 5(-# 1,F1># A*,+)( !)&'&>+),?#

,F)+.(&-# 15.1# '0$5# %7# 15(-# 9.3# %7# 15(&6(&4# 9.-# 4,&,*.1,/# 23# 15,#

E%'.&1($# '%8,',&1# 95($5# 4.(&,/# -1*,&415# /0*(&4# 15,# G&/0-1*(.+#

E,8%+01(%&#.&/#95($5#-1*,--,/#5.*&,--(&4#15,#)%9,*#%7#('.4(&.1(%&#

1%#,-$.),#15,#-$(,&1(7($#*.1(%&.+(@.1(%&#%7#&.10*,:#J+-%#15,#9*(1(&4-#%7#

`5.*+,-# f.*9(&># 95($5# -1*,--,/# 15.1# ,8,*315(&4# 9.-# 0&/,*4%(&4#

$5.&4,># 9,*,# 1*,',&/%0-+3# (&7+0,&1(.+:# ;5(-# 1*,&/# .&/# 9.3# %7#

15(&6(&4#9.-#.&#0&7%*10&.1,# *,8,*-.+#%7# 15,# 1*015#2,$.0-,#50'.&-#

.*,# .&/# .+9.3-# 5.8,# 2,,&# 95%++3# /,),&/,&1# %&# 15,*,# 2,(&4# .#

&.10*.+# %*/,*# 1%# 15,# 0&(8,*-,:# O,# $.&&%1# .$1# %&# .&3# 4(8,&# /.3#

9(15%01# 15,-,# 7(F,/# *,40+.*(1(,-:# ;5,3# .*,# &0',*%0-# .&/# .++# .2%01#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!g#

0-:#;5,#7.$1#15.1#J#.&/#&%1<J#$.&&%1#2,#-('0+1.&,%0-+3#1*0,>#%*#15,#

7.$1# 15.1#B#h#B#i#V>#.*,# (&5,*,&1# (&# 15,#9.3#%0*#'(&/-#9%*6:#e15,*#

7.$1-#.*,#,')(*($.+#*,40+.*(1(,-#.&/#$%0+/#$%&$,(8.2+3#2,#%15,*9(-,>#

3,1# 15,3# 1%%# )*%8(/,# 0-# 9(15# .# -,&-,# %7# .&# %*/,*+3# 0&(8,*-,:# W%*#

,F.')+,>#15,*,#(-#15,#$%&-1.&1#7.$1#15.1#15,#,.*15#*%1.1,-#%&#(1-#.F(-#

%8,*#15,#$%0*-,#%7#BV#5%0*-#,.$5#.&/#,8,*3#/.3:#;5,*,#(-#15,#*(-(&4#

.&/# -,11(&4# %7# 15,# -0&:# ;5,*,# .*,# 15,# *,40+.*# -,.-%&-># -)*(&4>#

-0'',*>#7.++#.&/#9(&1,*#95($5#*,$0*#3,.*#.71,*#3,.*#%7#15,#Na!#)+0-#

/.3-#(&#,.$5#*,$0**(&4#3,.*:#J&('.+-#.&/#)+.&1-#4%#15*%045#$3$+,-#%7#

+(7,># 2(*15># 4*%915># '.10*(13># /,1,*(%*.1(%&# .&/# /,.15:# ;5,-,># .&/#

'.&3#'%*,#,F.')+,-#+(6,#15,-,>#.*,#.++#.-),$1-#%7#%0*#*,.+(13:!#

;5,*,# .*,# 15*,,# +,8,+-# %7# *,.+(13T# 15,# )53-($.+># ',1.)53-($.+#

.&/#15,#-)(*(10.+:#`.*-%&>#%&#15,#',1.)53-($.+#-.3-#15(-T#

#G1#*,7,*-#1%#15,#+,8,+#%7#*,.+(13#2,19,,&#15,#-)(*(10.+#.&/#

15,# )53-($.+># 15.1# (-# .1# +,.-1# .&# ,&/0*(&4# *,.+'># 15.1# $.&# 2,#

*,.$5,/#%&+3#23#*,.-%&>#&%1#23#15,#-,&-,->#7%*#(1#$.&&%1#2,#-,,&>#

7,+1># 1.-1,/># -',++,/># &%*# 5,.*/:# G1# (-# 15,# +,8,+# %7# 0&/,*+3(&4# %*#

&.10*.+#+.9>#%7#15.1#95($5#4(8,-#7%*'#.&/#%*/,*#1%#.$10.+#$+.--,-#

%7#)53-($.+#2,(&4->#15,#-1*0$10*.+#).*1#%7#*,.+(13Pa#

(((((((((((((((#

E,.-%&># 15.1# -),$(.+# 7.$0+13# %7# '.&# 7%*# /,.+(&4# 9(15# 15,#

',1.)53-($.+>#(-#5%9#9,#.*,#.2+,#1%#0&/,*-1.&/#-,+7<,8(/,&1#1*015-:#

M%9,8,*>#%&$,#15(-#9.3#%7#*,.-%&(&4#(-#.2.&/%&,/#%*#7%*4%11,&>#9,#

.*,# +,71# 9(15# &%# &.10*.+# +.9-# %*# )*(&$()+,-# .&/># 15,*,7%*,># &%#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

!c#

,$%&%'($# -$(,&$,# 7*%'# 95($5# 9,# $.&# /(-$%8,*# 15,# %),*.1(%&-# %7#

$.0-,#.&/#,77,$1# (&#,$%&%'(,-:#;5(-# (-#&%1# 1%# (')+3# 15.1#,$%&%'($-#

/%,-# &%1# (&8%+8,# $5.&4,># 201# 15.1# 15,-,# $5.&4,-# %$$0*# 9(15(&# 15,#

7*.',9%*6#%7#7(F(1(,-:##

e0*# &.1(%&U-# W%0&/,*-# 9,*,# $%4&(@.&1# %7# 15(-# 4*,.1# *,.+(13:#

;5,(*# 6&%9+,/4,# %7# 15,-,# 70&/.',&1.+# )*(&$()+,-# (-# ,8(/,&1# (&# 15,#

9%*/(&4# %7# %0*# `%&-1(101(%&:# e2-,*8,># 5%9,8,*># 15.1# (&# %0*# /.3#

-,+/%'# .*,# 15,-,# 1*015-# ,8,*# /(-$0--,/# (&# 15,# )+.$,-# 15.1# '.11,*#

'%-1># -0$5# .-# %0*# 5%',-># %0*# )+.$,-# %7# 9%*-5()# .&/# )+.$,-# %7#

.--,'2+3:# ;5(-# -1,'-#)*('.*(+3# 7*%'# 15,# 7.$1# 15.1# 15,3#5.8,#&,8,*#

2,,&# ).--,/# /%9&# 1%# 15,# &,F1# 4,&,*.1(%&:# e0*# $5(+/*,&# .&/#

4*.&/$5(+/*,&# .*,# &%1# 2,(&4# 1.0451# 15,-,# (')%*1.&1# )*(&$()+,-# (&#

-$5%%+:#`%&-,S0,&1+3># (1# (-#&%1#-0*)*(-(&4# 15.1#9,#5.8,#'.&.4,/# 1%#

+%-,#15,'#%*#15.1#%0*#-%$(,13#(-#+%-(&4#(1-#9.3:##

f*:# b.0+# `+,8,+.&/># 9*(1(&4# 7%*# 15,# B&1$'*2( &/( C$+"*.#(

!'.#$-$+,##(&#"ccd>#-.3-T##

#D0$5# %7# 15,# 7.(+0*,# %7# 15,# I&(1,/# =1.1,-# $.&# 2,# 1*.$,/#

2.$6# 1%# 7.0+13# ,F),$1.1(%&-:# ;5.1# (-># ),%)+,# 5.8,# ,F),$1,/# 7.*#

'%*,# 7*%'# 4%8,*&',&1# 15.&# $.&# ,8,*# *,.-%&.2+3# 2,# ,F),$1,/:#

;5,-,#,F),$1.1(%&-#-)*,./#9(15#15,#)*%).4.1(%&#%7#*%'.&1($(-'#

(&#15,#&(&,1,,&15#$,&10*3:#I1%)(.&#9*(1,*-#2,$.',#S0(1,#)%)0+.*#

.&/#(&7+0,&1(.+:#J-#.#*,-0+1># 15,#(/,.#15.1#.#01%)(.&#-%$(,13#$%0+/#

2,#.$5(,8,/#2,$.',#9(/,+3#5,+/:#`+.*,&$,#`.*-%&#*,4.*/-#),%)+,#

)*%&,# 1%# 15(-# 8.&(13# .-# 15%-,# %&# .# \7+(451# 7*%'# *,.+(13:]#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

aj#

C,8,*15,+,--># 5.8(&4# 2,,&# $.)10*,/# 23# 15,# &%1(%&# 15.1# 15(-# (-#

)%--(2+,># '.&3# ),%)+,# .*,# -1(++# 1*3(&4# 1%# +,4(-+.1,# 15,# 9.3# 1%#

).*./(-,:d#

#

6(B#%1'#?(0'8&'(

#

D,&# 15*%045%01# 5(-1%*3# 5.8,# +%%6,/# 0)%&# 15,# 5,.8,&-# .&/#

15,# ,.*15# 9(15# .9,# .&/# 9%&/,*:# e8,*# 1(',># '.&# 5.-# 4.(&,/# '0$5#

(&-1*0$1(%&# 7*%'# 15,':#D,&#-0$5#.-#k,)+,*#.&/#C,91%&>#95%#4.8,#

'.15,'.1($.+# ,F)*,--(%&# 1%# 15,# '%1(%&-# %7# 15,# 5,.8,&+3# 2%/(,->#

-)0**,/# ',&# 9(15# &,9# @,.+# 1%# -,,6# %01# 15,# &.10*.+# +.9-# (&# %15,*#

.*,.->#(&$+0/(&4#15,#-%$(.+#.&/#15,#)53-($.+:#G&#15,#+.1,#"d15#.&/#"g15#

$,&10*(,-# 8.*(%0-# 15(&6,*-# 2,4.&# 1%# /(-$%8,*# .# &.10*.+# %*/,*# (&#

,$%&%'($-:#=%',#15(&6,*-#2,4.&#1%#*,.+(@,#15.1#15,*,#9.-#.#).11,*&#

%*# *5315'# (&# '.*6,1# .77.(*-># 15.1# .$1,/# (&/,),&/,&1# .&/# %71,&# (&#

$%&1*./($1(%&#%7#15,#/,-(*,-#%7#)%+(1($.+#*0+,*-:#J/.'#='(15#7.'%0-+3#

4.8,# ,F)*,--(%&# 1%# 15(-# $%&$,)1# (&# "dda# (&# 5(-# 2%%6># D#*2.0( &/(

5*.+&',:# # G&# .# 7.'%0-# ).--.4,># ='(15# ,F)+.(&,/# 15.1# (&# 15,# '.*6,1#

,$%&%'3# 15,*,# (-# .# &.10*.+# 5.*'%&3# 2,19,,&# .# )*%/0$,*U-# -,+7<

(&1,*,-1#.&/#15,#9,++<2,(&4#%7#-%$(,13T#

#X;5,#)*%/0$,*Y#4,&,*.++3>#(&/,,/>#&,(15,*#(&1,&/-#1%#)*%'%1,#15,#

)02+($# (&1,*,-1># &%*# 6&%9-# 5%9# '0$5# 5,# (-# )*%'%1(&4# (1:# [3#

)*,7,**(&4#15,#-0))%*1#%7#/%',-1($#1%#15.1#%7#7%*,(4&#(&/0-1*3>#5,#

(&1,&/-#%&+3#5(-#%9&#-,$0*(13R#.&/#23#/(*,$1(&4# 15.1# (&/0-1*3# (&#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

a"#

-0$5# .# '.&&,*# .-# (1-# )*%/0$,# '.3# 2,# %7# 15,# 4*,.1,-1# 8.+0,># 5,#

(&1,&/-# %&+3# 5(-# %9&# 4.(&># .&/# 5,# (-# (&# 15(-># .-# (&# '.&3# %15,*#

$.-,->#+,/#23#.&#(&8(-(2+,#5.&/#1%#)*%'%1,#.&#,&/#95($5#9.-#&%1#

).*1#%7#5(-#(&1,&1(%&:g#

(

e&,#8,*3#(')%*1.&1#7.$1%*#95($5#'0-1#2,#,')5.-(@,/#(-#15.1#

15,# &.10*.+# %*/,*# 7%*# .&# ,$%&%'3# /%,-# &%1# +,&/# (1-,+7# 1%# )*,$(-,#

'.15,'.1($.+# 7%*'0+.1(%&-#.&/#.&3#.11,')1-# 1%#/%#-%#9(++# 7.(+:#;5,#

*,.-%&# 7%*# 15(-# (-# 2,$.0-,># 0&+(6,# 15,# 5,.8,&+3# 2%/(,-# 95($5# .*,#

$%')%-,/# %7# '(&/+,--# '.11,*># ,$%&%'(,-# 9%*6# 15*%045# 50'.&#

.$1(%&#(&8%+8(&4#$%0&1+,--#/,$(-(%&-#.&/#$5%($,-#%7#(&/(8(/0.+-:#;5,#

-.',#15(&4#$.&#2,#-.(/#%7#%15,*#.*,.-#%7#-%$(.+#.$1(8(13#-0$5#.-#,15($-:#

G1# $.&# .+-%# 2,# -.(/# 15.1# ,$%&%'($-# /(77,*-# 7*%'# 15,# )53-($.+#

-$(,&$,-># -0$5# .-# $5,'(-1*3# %*# )53-($-># (&# 15.1# ,$%&%'($-# $%&1.(&-#

9(15(&# (1# 15,# ,+,',&1# %7# '.&U-# 3$145%$6! %&/1*1$/78# ;5(-# (')%*1.&1#

/(77,*,&$,#&,$,--.*(+3#1.6,-#(&#15,#-10/3#%7#'.&U-#50'.&#&.10*,>#15,#

,&8(*%&',&1#(&#95($5#50'.&-#.$1#.&/#15,#*,+.1(%&-5()#2,19,,&#15,#

19%:#W%*#15(-#*,.-%&>#,$%&%'($-#$.&&%1#2,#-%+,+3#0&/,*-1%%/#9(15(&#

15,# 7*.',9%*6# %7# '.15,'.1($.+# 7%*'0+.-># ,S0.1(%&-# %*# -1.1(-1($-:#

G&-1,./>#23#0-(&4#\/,/0$1(8,]#*,.-%&(&4# 15,#,$%&%'(-1#'%8,-# 7*%'#

.&#.+*,./3#,-1.2+(-5,/#)%-(1(%&#1%#%&,#95($5#7%++%9-#+%4($.++3# 7*%'#

(1>#201#(-#&%1#%15,*9(-,#6&%9&:#M,#0-,-#\(&/0$1(8,]#*,.-%&(&4#95,&#

-%',15(&4#(-#/(-$%8,*,/#%*#)*%8,&#23#&0',*%0-#(&-1.&$,-:#

e7# -0)*,',# (')%*1.&$,# (-# 15,# (/,.#%7# (&/(8(/0.+# 7*,,/%'# (&#

,$%&%'($# .$1(8(1(,-:# ;5,# $%&$,)1# %7# .# &.10*.+# %*/,*# (&# ,$%&%'($-#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

aB#

*,(&7%*$,-# 15(-# (/,.:# W%*# ,F.')+,># (7# 15,# )0*-0(1# %7# -,+7<(&1,*,-1#

*,-0+1-# (&# 15,# ,$%&%'($#9,++# 2,(&4#%7# 15,# (&/(8(/0.+# .&/# -%$(,13# .1#

+.*4,>#15,&#(1#-1.&/-#1%#*,.-%&#15.1#15,#(&/(8(/0.+#%0451#1%#2,#7*,,#1%#

)0*-0,# ?0-1# 15.1:# J&/# .4.(&># (7# 15,*,# (-# .# &.10*.+# %*/,*# 1%# 15,#

,$%&%'3>#15,&#(1#.+-%#-1.&/-#1%#*,.-%&#15.1#(1#(-#&%1#./8.&1.4,%0-#7%*#

4%8,*&',&1#1%#$%&1(&0.++3#(&1,*8,&,#(&#15,#,$%&%'3:#

#

C=+?1%-+.#'3(4+5-#?-,@(

(

;5,#/(-*,4.*/# 7%*# 15,# -,+7<,8(/,&1# 1*015-# 7%0&/# (&# ,$%&%'($#

)*(&$()+,-# 5.-# 5./# .# /*.'.1($# ,77,$1# %&# %0*# $%0&1*3U-# )%+(1($.+#

.4,&/.:# ;5,# )02+($U-# 4,&,*.+# 0&/,*-1.&/(&4# %7# 15,# )*%),*# *%+,# %7#

4%8,*&',&1# 5.-# $5.&4,/# 7*%'# .&# (&-1(101(%&# 15.1# '.(&1.(&-# 15,#

),.$,>#)*%1,$1-#)*(8.1,#)*%),*13#.&/#)0&(-5,-#%77,&/,*-># 1%# 15.1#%7#

2,(&4#15,#)*%8(/,*#.&/#/(-1*(201%*#%7#4%%/-#.&/#-,*8($,-:#G&#%*/,*#1%#

.$$%')+(-5#15(->#4%8,*&',&1#&%9#-,).*.1,-#15,#7*0(1-#%7#+.2%*#7*%'#

15,# )*%/0$,*-:# ;5,# -.8(&4-# .&/# 15,# ',.&-# %7# -.8(&4-# 5.8,# 2,,&#

1.6,&# .9.3:# l%8,*&',&1# 5.-# .+-%# 1.6,&# %8,*# 15,# *,-)%&-(2(+(13# %7#

+%%6(&4# .71,*# 15,# 9,++# 2,(&4# %7# ),%)+,# .&/# 15,# ),%)+,># 5.8(&4# 5./#

15,(*# (&/,),&/,&$,# ,*%/,/># 5.8,#3(,+/,/#0)# 15,(*# *,-)%&-(2(+(13# 1%#

+%%6# .71,*# 15,'-,+8,-:# G&# 15(-# 13),# %7# -3-1,'# )%+(1($(.&-# .*,# 8%1,/#

(&1%#%77($,#23#)*%'(-,-#%7#.#2,11,*#/(-1*(201(%&#%7#9,.+15#.&/#7.8%*-:#

;5,(*#-),$(.+#(&1,*,-1#4*%0)-#.*,#*,9.*/,/#.$$%*/(&4+3:#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

aN#

9"-,( -,( ,+5-#?-,@( #%( -%,( '++%,D# e7# $%0*-,# 9,# 9%0+/# &%1#

%),&+3# $.++# (1# 15.1#5,*,# (&# 15,#I&(1,/#=1.1,-:# =%$(.+(-'# (-#0&-)%6,&#

)*(&$().++3# 2,$.0-,# (1# 9%0+/# 2,# $.1,4%*($.++3# /,7,.1,/# .1# 15,# )%++->#

201#15,#13),#%7#-3-1,'#9,#&%9#5.8,#$.&&%1#2,#$.++,/#23#.&3#%15,*#

&.',:#;%#15(->#b*%7,--%*#`+,8,+.&/#.//-#15,#7%++%9(&4#-0''.1(%&T#

#;5,#(')%-(1(%&#%7#9,+7.*,#)%+($,-#(&#.#&.1(%&#(-#2,-1#0&/,*-1%%/#

(&# 15,# $%&1,F1# %7# -%$(.+(-':# G&# 15(-# $%0&1*3# (1# 9%0+/# 2,# 15,#

,8%+01(%&.*3# 7%*'#%7# -%$(.+(-':#;5.1# (-># (&#.&#,77%*1# 1%#,+('(&.1,#

)*%),*13#*(451->#-%$(.+(-1-#2,4(&#23#)*%)%-(&4#4*./0.+#)%+($(,-#%7#

$5.&4,:# ;5,# (')+,',&1.1(%&# %7# 9,+7.*,# )*%4*.'-# -,*8,-# .-# .#

0-,70+# 2,4(&&(&4# 7%*# 15,3# 0&/,*'(&,# )*%),*13# *(451-:# ;5,-,#

)%+($(,-# 8,(+# 15,# 7%*$,# %7# 4%8,*&',&1# 2,5(&/# 15,# '.-6# %7#

2,&,8%+,&$,# ,8,&# 15%045# 15,# 15*0-1# %7# 15,'# (-# 15,# 4*./0.+#

,*%-(%&# %7# )*%),*13# *(451-# .&/# 15,# /,8,+%)',&1# %7# -%$(.+(-':#

e71,&# 15,# )*%)%-.+-# .*,# 9(++(&4+3# .$$,)1,/# 2,$.0-,# 15,(*# -1.1,/#

,&/#(-#1%#.++,8(.1,#15,#-077,*(&4#%7#15,#)%%*:c#

(

J1# (1-# $%*,># =%$(.+# =,$0*(13# (-# 15,# $+.--($# ,F.')+,# %7# .#

*,/(-1*(201(%&(-1#)+.&>#201#(1#(-#%&+3#%&,#%7#'.&3#9,+7.*,#)*%4*.'-#(&#

15,# I&(1,/# =1.1,-# 15.1# 5.8,# 2,,&# (&# ,F(-1,&$,# 7%*# /,$./,-:# ;5,-,#

9,+7.*,#)*%4*.'-#,F(-1#&%1#%&+3#5,*,#.1#5%',>#201#.+-%#.2*%./:#;5,#

$%-1# 1%# ).3# 7%*# .++# %7# 15,'# (-# .-1*%&%'($.+L# 9"&( /+=&'.@&.%E,(

;1'%"&'( -.%'1,-+.,( -.%+( +1'( "&#?%"( 5#'&( F-??( $+,&( #.(

&G%'#+'8-.#'3( 8'#-.( +.( ;&8&'#?( 5+;;&',( +=&'( %"&( .&G%( ;&F(

8&5#8&,H((

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

aV#

D%-1# '%/,*&# 9,-1,*&# $%0&1*(,-# 5.8,# +,.*&,/# 1%# +,.8,#

)*%),*13#(&#)*(8.1,#5.&/-#(&#%*/,*#1%#7%-1,*#9,+7.*,#)*%4*.'-#*.15,*#

15.&# 1%# 1.6,# $%')+,1,# $%&1*%+# %8,*# .++# %7# (1:# J71,*# 15,# 7.(+0*,# %7#

-%$(.+(-'# (&# A&4+.&/# .&/# 15,# $%++.)-,# %7# 15,# I:=:=:E:># '%-1#

,8%+01(%&.*3#-%$(.+(-1-#9,*,#$%&8(&$,/#15.1#4%8,*&',&1#%9&,*-5()#

%7#15,#',.&-#%7#)*%/0$1(%&#9.-#&,(15,*#)%+(1($.++3#./8.&1.4,%0-#&%*#

&,$,--.*3:# ;5,3# $%0+/# -1(++# )+.&# 15,# ,$%&%'3# 15*%045# 4%8,*&',&1#

*,40+.1(%&># 1.F.1(%&># '%&,1.*3# ,F).&-(%&# .&/# $*,/(1# '.&()0+.1(%&:#

;5(-# (-# ,F.$1+3# 95.1# .++# 9,-1,*&# $%0&1*(,-# 5.8,# /%&,# .&/# (-# 15,#

-(10.1(%&#5,*,#(&#15,#I&(1,/#=1.1,-:#

;5,#$%&-,S0,&$,-#%7#-%$(.+(-1# 1*,&/-# (&#)%+($3#'.6(&4#.77,$1#

-%# '0$5# '%*,# 15.&# 15,# ,$%&%'3># $,*1.(&+3# %0*# '%&,3# 5.-# 2,,&#

/,2.0$5,/>#201#(1#(-#15,#'%*.+#.&/#,15($.+#/,1,*(%*.1(%&#15.1#5.-#50*1#

0-# 15,#'%-1:# #J&/#3,1>#.-#/(-$0--,/#,.*+(,*># 15,# (/,.#2,5(&/# (1#.++# (-#

7.+-,#.&/#$.&&%1#)%--(2+3#4%#%&#7%*,8,*:#G1#(-#.#7.+-,#&%1(%&#15.1#15,*,#

.*,# -0*)+0-,-# %7# 4%%/-# .&/# 15.1# -%$(,13# (-# './,# 0)# %7# .20&/.&$,:#

A$%&%'($#-$(,&$,#$+,.*+3# 1,.$5,-# 15,#%))%-(1,L#O,#5.8,#9.&/,*,/#

7.*# 7*%'# 15,# 1*015:# E,/(-1*(201(%&# %&+3# 9%*6-# -%# +%&4# .-# 15,*,# (-#

-%',15(&4#1%#/(-1*(201,H.#+%1#1%#/(-1*(201,L#

O,#,&/#9(15#.#S0%1,#7*%'#D(-,-T#

#J&# ,--,&1(.+# )%(&1# (&# 15,# -%$(.+# )5(+%-%)53# %7#

(&1,*8,&1(%&(-'# (-# 15,# ,F(-1,&$,#%7# .&# (&,F5.0-1(2+,# 70&/#95($5#

$.&#2,#-S0,,@,/#7%*,8,*:#;5,#95%+,#/%$1*(&,#%7# (&1,*8,&1(%&(-'#

"#$%&'!()*!+,-!==========================================================(

(

a!#

$%++.)-,-# 95,&# 15(-# 7%0&1.(&# (-# /*.(&,/# %77:# ;5,# =.&1.# `+.0-#

)*(&$()+,#+(S0(/.1,-#(1-,+7:"j(

(

##########################################################1 Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1998). 2 Murray Rothbard, Man, Economy, and State (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2004), pp. 4-5, some emphasis removed. 3 Rothbard, Man, Economy, and State, p. 47. 4 Rothbard, Man, Economy, and State, p. 169. 5 Clarence B. Carson, Basic Economics (Phenix City, AL: American Textbook Committee, 2003), p. 23. 6 Carson, Basic Economics, p. 21. 7 Paul Cleveland, “Government: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly,” The Journal of Private Enterprise, 1997, pp. 81-99. 8 Adam Smith, An Inquiry Into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), Book IV, Chapter 2. 9 Cleveland, “Government: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.” 10 Mises, Human Action, p. 854.

!"#$%&'()*'+,-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!!"

"

!"#

Chapter 4!

Losing Our Spirit

The most efficient organization in the

world is not any group of people but a

single person. A normal person can

conceive a plan, figure out how to carry

it out, and communicate the orders to

do the task to his faculties instantly,

with minimum likelihood they will be

misinterpreted… Moreover, an

individual who owns his own material,

has put up the investment for an

undertaking, and stands to gain

whatever profits arise from the

enterprise, must have the greatest

incentive to do the job well.

—Clarence B. Carson1

#

#

$# %# &'($)*+# ,(&-# %,# '(*,.# /0)-# ,'12# 344# 10550'$#

0$-%60)%$),.# 0)# 0,# 017'*)%$)# )'# *2%5082# )-%)# $')# %55# 72'752#

7*'9(&2#9(*0$:# )-20*#2$)0*2# 50;2)012<#='*#2>%1752.# 0$;%$),# &2*)%0$5+#

9'# $')# 7*'9(&2<# ?-2# 2592*5+# '*# ')-2*/0,2# 0$&%7%&0)%)29.# 9'# $')#

@#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!A#

7*'9(&2<# B2# &%$# ,%+# )-%)# )-2# ($2175'+29.# /-052# )-2+# *21%0$#

($2175'+29.# %*2# $')# 7*'9(&2*,<# C$9# )-2$# )-2*2# 0,# )-%)# 5%*:2#

,2:12$)#';#,'&02)+#/-0&-#9272$9,#2$)0*25+#'$#:'D2*$12$)#,(77'*)<#

?-2,2#72'752#%*2#'6D0'(,5+#$')#7*'9(&2*,#20)-2*<#E().#%5)-'(:-#/2#

%*2#%55#$')#7*'9(&2*,.#/2#%*2#%55##$%&'()*&<#F'#'$2#G$'/,#)-0,#62))2*#

)-%$#)-2#)%+*),*)%)'*<#

H$)*27*2$2(*,# %*2# )-',2# ($0I(2# 0$90D09(%5,# /-'# %*2#

&'$,)%$)5+# %,,2,,0$:# -(1%$#-.%+&# %$9# ;'*1(5%)0$:# 092%,# )'# 122)#

)-',2# /%$),<# ?-2+# 7%+# ,72&0%5# %))2$)0'$# )'# )-2# 1',)# (*:2$)# /%$),#

%$9# 92)2*10$2# )-2# 62,)# 12%$,# %$9# (,2,# ';# ,&%*&2# *2,'(*&2,# )'#

,%)0,;+# )-21<# ?-2+# %*2# ($0I(2# 72'752# 0$# )-%)# )-20*# ($(,(%5#

72*,'$%50)+.# )-20*#&*2%)0D0)+.# )-20*#(,2#';# 01%:0$%)0'$# 0,#$')# 52%*$29#

$'*# &%$# 0)# 62# )%(:-).# 6()# 0,# *%)-2*# 0$-2*2$)5+# 7',,2,,29# %$9#

&(5)0D%)29<#?-20*#J(9:12$)#';#)-2#;%&),#';#%$#($&2*)%0$#;()(*2#0,#%#&()#

%6'D2#)-2#*2,)#';#,'&02)+<#?-2+#%&)#'$#)-20*#,)*'$:#'70$0'$,#';#/-%)#

#$'/0"1).#1%$+# )012,#%:%0$,)#:*2%)#'99,#%$9#*0,GK#?-2+#%*2#%5/%+,#

'$# )-2# %52*)# ;'*# %#12%$,# ';#1%G0$:#,*$23+# 0$# %*2%,#/-2*2# )-2+# &%$#

2%*$# 1'*2# )-%$# )-2# :'0$:# *%)2# ';# 3%+)*)&+4# L(*# /'*59M,# ,(72*0'*#

,)%$9%*9#';#50D0$:#0,#%#90*2&)#*2,(5)#';#/-%)#)-2,2#2$)*27*2$2(*,#-%D2#

,2)# 0$# 1')0'$<# ?-2,2# 12$# %$9# /'12$# %*2# )-2# )*(2# ,)01(5(,# )'# %$#

2&'$'1+<#@$#;%&).#)-2+#%*2#)-2#2&'$'1+M,#.$/0'1.""2<#

The term entrepreneur is derived from the French word which

means “a person who organizes and manages a business undertaking,

assuming the risk for the sake of profit.” More specifically, his role is

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!N#

that of the individual who brings together the various means of

production to their final useful end. In essence he takes the elements of

production which are land, labor and capital and “mixes” them in such a

way that a product or service results. The entrepreneur can be a great

industrialist or he can be a farmer operating on a parcel of land.

One thing is certain: producing a product or service is not for the

faint of heart. The endeavor is filled with uncertainty, beginning first

with the simple fact that the product or service may not sell! The idea of

having to gauge wants and needs from infinite human desires is all

calculated guess work! The quantities, categories, styles, size, weight—

an endless variety of considerations like these, can easily be

overestimated. Plus, undertaking production may be on borrowed money

or credit and interest rates may rise. What about competition? All of

these factors are uncertainties. Obviously, one prominent characteristic

of the entrepreneur is that of risk taker. Without question he is an

individual who operates one step away from total failure, a lifestyle not

for everyone in society. To the outsider the entrepreneur appears to be a

person of great independence with power to wield in an organization. In

reality the entrepreneur is at all times keenly aware of the perilous risks

he must take in making his decisions. As Rothbard explains:

The entrepreneur is not creating uncertainties for the fun of it. On the

contrary, he tries to reduce them as much as possible. The

uncertainties he confronts are already inherent in the market

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"4#

situation, indeed in the nature of human action; someone must deal

with them, and he is the most skilled or willing candidate.2

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''"

The Market

The entrepreneur’s arena is the market place. Anywhere two or

more people meet to engage in buying and selling is a market.

Economists refer to “the market” as a concept, knowing that markets

exist everywhere in great varieties and numbers, with things common to

all. The varieties and kinds of products and services in a nation such as

ours are complex and extensive. It boggles the mind to gauge the

demand for such products and services against existing or non-existing

supplies.

And what about setting prices for all these goods and services?

Who or what determines price? Certainly, the cost of production will

play an important role in pricing, but since people acting in the market

tend to buy the highest quality goods at the lowest prices possible, cost

of production is always subordinated to supply and demand. In effect,

cost of production is irrelevant to the buyer.

Another factor to consider, is that all markets will invariably

have competition. A successful product or service will quickly have

many imitators. Competitors can run away with much needed sales! This

phenomenon is most clearly seen in fads, trends, and styles that can

create windfall profits for some producers while completely destroying

others. An entrepreneur enters this arena and carefully calculates the

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"O#

pros and cons of his planned innovation. It is the action he takes that

starts the whole ball rolling. It is a most courageous undertaking. The

environment is filled with uncertainty. Yet, this is what he does and

society reaps the rewards.

All things being equal, the unhampered market has always been

seen by classical theorists as a mighty and efficient instrument of social

order. For example: with regards to prices, the market itself eventually

dictates the “going price” because a price in a free market is the amount

a willing seller will take and willing buyer will pay. In other words,

prices are arrived at by agreement between buyer and seller. Even the

simplest purchase involves an unspoken agreement. This market price is

the result of the interplay of a changing supply and demand because

these elements are dynamic. Nothing in the free market stands still for

long. And as far as competition goes, it and it alone is the stimulant to

market efficiency, both in price and quality. Competition keeps

producers from charging exorbitant prices. It is actually the friend of the

consumer. Therefore, in what can only be explained as a true marvel, the

free and unhampered market operates like an “invisible hand,” as Adam

Smith described it, or in Rothbard’s description:

[T]he “free market”…creates a delicate and even awe-inspiring

mechanism of harmony, adjustment, and precision in allocating

productive resources, deciding upon prices, and gently but swiftly

guiding the economic system toward the greatest possible

satisfaction of the desires of all the consumers.3

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"P#

"#$%&'()*+(&*)"

"

Every entrepreneur invests in a process of production because he

expects to make a profit; however, it is an error to think of the economy

in which he operates as being made up of only profits. In reality it is a

profit and loss economy. A loss occurs when an entrepreneur has made

poor judgments in estimating his future prices and sales. He understands

that a free market rewards its efficient entrepreneurs and penalizes its

inefficient ones. His goal is to be efficient; however, his biggest problem

is that profit and losses are intertwined with the going interest returns. It

is this rate of interest, especially when artificially manipulated, which

ultimately creates the greatest threat to his success. This process of

artificial manipulation is hidden. He does not see it coming. In effect he

is tricked! The results, of course, are always disastrous—business losses,

business failure or bankruptcy. For society at large the results are

massive unemployment, recessions, depressions and the dangerous

possibility of a complete collapse of the monetary system. As Austrian

economist Hans Sennholz writes:

Inflation and credit expansion always precipitates business

maladjustments and malinvestments that must later be liquidated.

The expansion artificially reduces and thus falsifies interest rates,

and thereby misguides businessmen in their investment decisions. In

the belief that declining rates indicate growing supplies of capital

savings, they embark upon new production projects. The creation of

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"3#

money gives rise to an economic boom. It causes prices to rise,

especially prices of capital goods used for business expansion. But

these prices constitute business costs. They soar until business is no

longer profitable, at which time the decline begins. In order to

prolong the boom, the monetary authorities may continue to inject

new money until finally frightened by the prospects of a runaway

inflation. The boom that was built on the quicksand of inflation then

comes to a sudden end.4

"

,#-%*#$!./0+#*%/&!

It is difficult for entrepreneurs to put enough money aside to

invest in even a small business enterprise. In this century, entrepreneurs

have learned to organize in order to raise enough money to go into

business. Aside from borrowing, the most common way is partnering

with others who have saved money to put up for capital. However, the

greatest limitation to partnerships is that there is no shield against

creditors in case of business failure. The individual partners can be held

individually liable for all debts of the partnership. Consequently,

partnerships are most often very small enterprises. In fact most

businesses in the United States are small: The latest figures from the

U.S. Census Bureau list 25,409,525 businesses in the United States, of

which only 5,885,784 have one or more employees. All the others do not

report a payroll.

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"Q#

?-2# 1',)# /0925+# (,29# 12)-'9# ;'*# *%0,0$:# 1'$2+# ;'*# %#

6(,0$2,,# 0,# )-2##$*,$*.+3$%4#C#&'*7'*%)0'$# 0,#%$# 0$9272$92$)#2$)0)+#

&*2%)29# 6+# 0$90D09(%5,R%$# %:*2212$)# *2&':$0829# 6+# 5%/<#

@$)2*2,)0$:5+.# &'*7'*%)0'$,# %)# '$2# )012# /2*2# 0$,)*(12$),# ';# )-2#

S0$:<# @)#/%,#$')#($)05# )-2#109#ON)-# &2$)(*+# )-%)# &'*7'*%)0'$,#/2*2#

;0*,)# (,29# ;'*# 12%$,# ';# *%0,0$:# &%70)%5<# @$0)0%55+.# -'/2D2*.#

&'*7'*%)0'$,# /2*2# ,'525+# %# 7*0D052:2# ';# 7'/2*;(5# ;%10502,# '*#

7'50)0&%55+#&'$$2&)29#0$90D09(%5,<#

?'9%+.# )-2# ,2550$:# ';# ,)'&G# ;'*# 7(*7',2,# ';# *%0,0$:# &%70)%5# 0,#

&'11'$75%&2<#?-2#&'*7'*%)0'$M,#:*2%)2,)#%))*%&)0'$#0,#)-2#'77',0)2#

';# )-2# 7%*)$2*,-07<# ?-2# 50%6050)+# ';# )-2# &'*7'*%)0'$M,# 0$D2,)'*,# 0,#

/3(3+)0# )'# )-2#2>)2$)#';# )-2#%1'($)# 0$D2,)29<# @$#')-2*#/'*9,.# 0;# )-2#

&'*7'*%)0'$# ,-'(59# :'# 6%$G*(7).# )-2# 0$D2,)'*,# &%$# J(,)# /%5G# %/%+#

/0)-'()# %$+# -%*1# )'# )-20*# *27()%)0'$# '*# 72*,'$%5# 7'&G2)6''G<# C#

,)'&G-'592*.#0;#-2#0,#$')#%$#';;0&2*#'*#90*2&)'*.#1%+#$')#2D2$#$229#)'#

&'$&2*$#-01,25;#/0)-#)-2#6(,0$2,,#2$)2*7*0,2#'*#0),#7*'9(&)0'$<#='*#

)-0,# *2%,'$# 1%$+# 0$D2,)'*,# &%$# %$9# 9'# '/$# ,-%*2,# ';# ,)'&G# 0$#

&'*7'*%)0'$,<#

B2# ,-'(59# 7'0$)# '()# )-%)# 62&%(,2# ';# )-2# 1%$$2*# 0$# /-0&-#

,)'&G# ,-%*2,# %*2# '/$29.# )-2*2# 0,# %$# 'D2*5+# &'$&2$)*%)29# 217-%,0,#

'$# 7*';0)%6050)+R)-2# T6'))'1# 50$2UR%6'D2# %$+)-0$:# 25,2<# ?'# )-2#

,)'&G-'592*# )-2# 90D092$9# 72*# ,-%*2# %$9# )-2# 7*0&2# 2%&-# ,-%*2# /055#

6*0$:# 0$# )-2# 1%*G2)# %*2# )-2# 1%0$# &'$&2*$,<# ?-0,# ;%&)# 0,# 7*'D2$#

*272%)295+#0$#)-2#,)'&G#1%*G2)<#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"V#

@$#%990)0'$#)'#,2550$:#,)'&G#,-%*2,.#&'*7'*%)0'$,#&%$#%5,'#*%0,2#

1'$2+#)-*'(:-#)-2# 0,,(%$&2#';#926)# 0$,)*(12$),.#,(&-#%,#6'$9,#'*#

9262$)(*2,<#?-2,2#)+72,#';#,2&(*0)02,.#%,#/255#%,#)-2#,-%*2,#';#,)'&G.#

&%$#62#)*%$,;2**29#%)#/055<##

L;# 7*012# 017'*)%$&2# )'# )-0,# 90,&(,,0'$# 0,# )-2# 2$'*1'(,#

:*'/)-#0$#)-2#6(+0$:#%$9#,2550$:#%&)0D0)+#';#)-2,2#,2&(*0)02,#,0$&2#)-2#

&'*7'*%)0'$# -%,# 62&'12# )-2# 9'10$%$)# ;'*&2# ;'*# *%0,0$:# 1'$2+<# @$#

1'92*$#2&'$'102,#)-0,#%&)0D0)+#-%,#62&'12#'$2#';#)-2#5%*:2,)#;'*1,#

';# &'$&2$)*%)29# ;($9,<#?/'#')-2*# ;'*1,#';# &'$&2$)*%)29# ;($9,# %*2#

6%$G,#%$9# 0$,(*%$&2#&'17%$02,<#E%$G,#%*2#927',0)'*02,# ;'*#1'$2+#

%$9# %*2# :2$2*%55+# ($92*,)''9# )'# 62# 52$90$:# 0$,)0)()0'$,.# 6()# )-20*#

;0$%$&0%5#%&)0D0)02,#2>)2$9#62+'$9#)-2,2#,01752#5010),<#C#&5',2*#5''G#

%)#6%$G,#%$9#-'/#)-2+#'72*%)2#/055#62#2>%10$29#1'*2#&%*2;(55+# 0$#

)-2#$2>)# &-%7)2*<#B-%)# 0,# 017'*)%$)# )'#$')2#-2*2# 0,# )-%)#6%$G,#%*2#

)-21,25D2,#&'*7'*%)0'$,<#

@$,(*%$&2# &'17%$02,# 1%+# %5,'# 62# &'*7'*%)0'$,.# ,'12# %*2#

7*0D%)25+# '/$29.# ,'12# '/$29# 6+# %# 5%*:2# $(162*# ';# ,)'&G-'592*,<#

W()(%5# 0$,(*%$&2# &'17%$02,# %*2# 2>&5(,0D25+# '/$29# 6+# )-2# 7'50&+#

-'592*,<#?-2#7'0$)# 0,# )-%)# 0$,(*%$&2# &'17%$02,.# 50G2#6%$G,.# )%G2# 0$#

2$'*1'(,# %1'($),# ';# 1'$2+<# ?-0,# 1'$2+# &'12,# 0$# )-2# ;'*1# ';#

7*210(1#7%+12$),<#C#7'*)0'$#';# )-0,#1'$2+# 0,#$')# 2>72&)29# )'#62#

7%09# )'# 62$2;0&0%*02,# ;'*# 1%$+# +2%*,.# )-2*2;'*2.# )-2# 1'$2+# 0,# G27)#

0$D2,)29# 0$# ,-'*)# %$9# 5'$:# )2*1# 0$D2,)12$),<# # X'$,2I(2$)5+.#

0$,(*%$&2# &'17%$02,.# 50G2# ')-2*# 5%*:2# &'*7'*%)0'$,.# %*2# %# 1%J'*#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"!#

,'(*&2#';#&%70)%5<#B2#/055#%5,'#2>75'*2#0$,(*%$&2#&'17%$02,#0$#1'*2#

92)%05# 5%)2*<# E()# /2# 62:0$# )'# :2)# %# 70&)(*2# ';# )-2# D%,)$2,,# %$9#

&'1752>0)+#';#'(*#&%70)%50,)0&#,+,)21.#)-2#;5'/#';#1'$2+#%$9#/-2*2#

0),#%*2%,#';#&'$&2$)*%)0'$#&%$#62#;'($9<##

#

12(!3*/45!"#05(*!

#

There is a strange phenomenon with regards to corporations,

securities and the stock market which merits discussion here: Americans

hold a belief that the stock market is the driving force behind

corporations and American industry. Many believe declining stock

prices on the New York Stock Exchange or NASDAQ and other

exchanges signifies that the entire national economy is declining, and

that rising stock prices indicate that prosperity is ahead. This is indeed a

strange reaction to the stock market. Most Americans do not feel that

way about other products and services when they go up or down in

price. Why should stocks be any different? Clearly it is the manner the

stock market news is reported by the media, however, the major culprit

is misinformation about the stock market and how it functions.

The New York Stock Exchange, the NASDAQ and the several

other stock exchanges in the United Sates, including those abroad, are

just that, exchanges. As Professor Carson notes, the entrepreneur would

more properly refer to it as the used stock market because that is all that

is offered for sale, used stock! New stock issues that are sold in return

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

""#

for money are not offered on these types of exchanges. Actual wealth or

capital is transferred to the corporation at the time of the initial public

offering of the stock, or IPO. This is a one-time event. It represents the

true stock market for the corporation, occurring whenever IPOs are

offered to the public for sale. Some financial firms specialize in these

special securities, but the point here is that the stock exchanges, as in the

New York Stock Exchange or the NASDAQ, for all the daily trading

they do, provide no capital whatsoever for American industry.

Also, individuals who buy and sell stocks are frequently referred

to as “investors.” This too, can be confusing. We must not forget that

these individuals are only buying and trading shares. Although they may

be purchasing a return in dividends, their real motivation to buy a stock

is for the opportunity to sell at a profit when prices rise. In effect, they

are really speculators. They are primarily focusing on the exchange

value of the commodity. This is why purchasers of stocks only want bull

markets. On the stock exchanges, speculation is rewarded by the rising

price of a stock. When prices fall, all those who bet on the increase will

lose. It is this anticipatory element that defines speculation.

For example: On the famous “Black Monday,” October 19,

1987, the stock market was shocked by the loss of $500 billion in one

day. In reality this colossal amount of wealth simply vanished into thin

air because it existed only in the quoted price of the stocks on the stock

exchange. Factories and computers didn’t disappear on Black Monday;

doctors and engineers didn’t forget their skills. All that happened on

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"A#

Black Monday was that the prices of many corporations’ shares of stock

plummeted.

Do not misunderstand; stock speculators do serve a social

purpose. By selling (or “shorting”) overvalued shares and buying

undervalued ones, speculators help correct mispriced stocks. It is

important for stocks to have the “right” market price, because the

stockholders are the actual owners of the corporation and are ultimately

responsible for its fate. With accurate share prices, these owners

understand just how socially valuable their property is, and will have the

incentive to exercise the appropriate amount of oversight.5

However, important as stock speculation is, it is not an activity

for the average household, and certainly should not be confused with

old-fashioned saving. The typical American has been conditioned to

believe that investing in the stock market is the same thing as “saving

for retirement.” Americans have been lulled into a false sense of

security, in which investing in tech stocks is admittedly classified as

“speculative” and “risky,” while investing in the whole S&P 500 is

considered the epitome of caution. But even people with a “diversified”

portfolio can lose 40 percent in a single year, as recent events have

shown!

Additionally, we are pointing to the fact that stock trading can be

a highly emotionally charged activity. False signals are frequently sent

into the economy by either overvaluing or undervaluing particular

stocks. Naturally, when prices start to rise, trading tends to become

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"N#

irrational. Predictably, people panic when prices fall. Much of the

liquidity crisis created during the Crash of 1929 was that the irrational

thinking created by skyrocketing prices made a lot of stock speculators

borrow on credit (margin), or from other lenders, in order to buy stocks.

Buying stocks on credit has the potential to achieve greater gains,

however, as prices plummeted, speculators who did not get out in time

scrambled for cash to meet their obligations. Of course the cash was

nowhere to be found and huge losses were incurred by many.

A similar situation occurred during the recent inflation of prices

in the housing market. Many borrowed from their home equity on home

prices that were overinflated in order to buy even more real estate. Great

losses were suffered by those who did not flip those purchases fast

enough before market prices on homes crashed.

Erratic movement in the stock market is prompted by other

outside forces which we know to be artificial bubbles in the economy,

caused by monetary policy. Austrian economists refer to them as “boom

and bust business cycles.” Nevertheless, one still wonders why people

speculate on stocks? What is the attraction? While it is true that some

professional traders have the ability to profit on prices going up or down

and can exit the market quickly, not everyone has this advantage.

Furthermore, it is still speculation. No one can predict with accuracy

each and every time. Many have discovered too late that speculation in

stocks can be an extremely risky endeavor especially if one’s entire

life’s savings are vested in it.

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

A4#

Unfortunately this has become a large problem for many middle

class Americans. Huge losses have been suffered by individuals who

unknowingly were driven into the stock market via their employment

benefits, disguised as their retirement savings. These good people, who

for the most part are living from paycheck to paycheck, are taking great

risks with what they believe is their retirement savings. Individual

retirement accounts, the 401(k), 403(b), and other government

sponsored programs, all have their underlying assets invested in the

stock market mostly through mutual funds. Furthermore, these allocated

funds are virtually untouchable till age 59! unless one is willing to

incur a 10% penalty, plus pay the federal income tax which has only

been deferred.

All this has presented an unpleasant dilemma for Americans and

their dreams for retirement. To put this in perspective, we should not

overlook the fact that the median income for a working couple in the

United States is only $47,500! That means that half of this nation’s

working couples make less than this! Only 2% of the entire nation’s

population makes an income larger than $355,000. This means that the

margin for financial planning error for virtually 98% of Americans is nil.

Any type of financial setback or losses in the market or anywhere else

for that matter can be financially catastrophic. Somehow the definition

of real savings has been obscured.

There is absolutely no way to retire from work without first

having stockpiled a substantial amount of real savings. For an average

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

AO#

annual retirement income of $60,000 to $100,000, this means a stockpile

of several million inflation-plagued dollars! It simply cannot be done by

the average citizen in today’s economic environment. As it now stands,

most Americans live day to day buried in a mountain of debt and with an

ever rising cost of living. Most of that cost is taxes, not only direct taxes,

but indirect taxes caused by inflation. Americans know they need to

save and want to save, they simply cannot. Unless they can become fully

informed of the real source of their money problem, they will not be able

to solve this dilemma. Mises explains:

Everything that is done by a government against the

purchasing power of the monetary unit is, under present conditions,

done against the middle classes and the working classes of the

population. Only these people don’t know it. And this is the

tragedy….

These people can only provide for their old age practically

by either entering into labor contracts that give them a pension for

their later age, or they can save a part of their income and invest it in

such a way that they can use in later years. These investments can

either be either simple savings deposits with banks, or they can be

life insurance policies or bonds...6

There is a different position to consider when analyzing the middle class

employee to that of the business owner. Mises clarifies this distinction:

The man who owns an agricultural estate, the producer of

oil or foods, or the businessman who owns a factory is in a different

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

AP#

position. When the prices of the products that he is selling go up on

account of the inflation, he will not be hurt in the same way in which

other people are hurt by the inflation. The owner of common stock

will see that, by and large, most of this common stock is going up in

price to the same degree as the prices of commodities are going up

on account of the inflation.

But it is different for people with fixed incomes. The man,

who retired 25 years ago with a yearly pension, let us say of $3,000,

was by and large in a good situation or was believed to be in a good

situation. But this was at a time when prices were much lower than

they are today….

What I want to point out is that the greatest problem today

is precisely this, although the people don’t realize it. The danger is

due to the fact that people consider inflation as something that hurts

other people. They realize very well that they too have to suffer

because the prices of the commodities they are buying go up

continually, but they don’t realize fully that the greatest danger for

them is precisely the progress of inflation and the effect it will have

on the value of their savings.

…We should not forget that over and above the

consequences of destroying a country’s monetary standard, there is

the danger that depriving the masses of their savings will make them

desperate.7

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

A3#

In addition to this problem, is the fact that life has a way of

completely derailing the best and most disciplined savings plan. For

example, the fear of losing one’s employment is a constant threat to

individuals these days, particularly during recessionary times. An

accident or illness that incapacitates the breadwinner for extended

periods of time can deplete savings and limit income. Since statistics

show that Americans can continue to pay living expenses for no more

than three months without income, bankruptcy is many times inevitable

under any one of these circumstances. The same is true in the case of

divorce or other form of lawsuit. What about the untimely death of the

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

AQ#

bread winner? Yes, life, as we all know, is fragile and filled with

uncertainties. When these life events are coupled with severe money

problems, is there any wonder why Americans are forced to turn to the

government as the ultimate care giver?

Finally, the current housing crisis has added insult to injury. The

American home, one of the most sought after dreams and storehouse of

savings for all Americans, has been completely undermined. Americans

are reaching levels of complete exasperation, a sense of total defeat and

hopelessness.

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

AV#

!

678)(!/9!*2(!,%*%:(&!

#

Y$;'*)($%)25+.# )'9%+# /2# %*2# 50D0$:# 0$# %# /'*59# ';# 0$&*2%,0$:#

2&'$'10&#0550)2*%&+.#0$&*2%,0$:#D0,0652#7'D2*)+#%$9#0$&*2%,0$:#D0,0652#

2>&2,,<#?-2#*0&-#9'#,221#)'#62#:2))0$:#*0&-2*.#)-2#7''*#2D2$#7''*2*<#

X'$,2I(2$)5+.# )-2*2# 0,# %# 5')# 620$:# ,%09# %6'()# 5*))04" @)# ,221,# /2#

&%$$')# 2$)2*# 0$)'# &'$D2*,%)0'$.# 70&G# (7# %$+# ,'*)# ';# 7(650&%)0'$.#

/%)&-# )-2# $2/,# '$# )252D0,0'$.# '*# &-2&G# '(*# 2Z1%05,# /0)-'()# )-2#

12$)0'$#';#)-0,#'$2#-(1%$#&-%*%&)2*#92;2&)#%$9#0),#0$;5(2$&2#'$#'(*#

&(**2$)# /'*59# &*0,0,<# B-%)# %&)(%55+# 502,# 62-0$9# %55# ';# )-0,# *%17%$)#

&'**(7)0'$#7%*)0&(5%*5+#'$#)-2#7%*)#';#)-2#;0$%$&0%5#250)2[##

?'# %77*'%&-# )-0,# I(2,)0'$# &'**2&)5+.# 0)M,# 017'*)%$)# )'# $')2#

)-%)# 1%$# -%,# 622$# '77*2,,29# 6+# )-',2# /-'# :'D2*$# ;'*# 1',)# ';#

-0,)'*+<# \5%D2*+# %$9# 72%,%$)*+# -%D2# 622$# )-2# $'*1<# ]*';2,,'*#

X5%*2$&2#X%*,'$#7'0$),#'()#0$#-0,#2&'$'10&#)2>)#)-%)#

#)-2# D%,)# /2%5)-# ';# ^'(0,# _@`# /%,# 1',)5+# /*($:# ;*'1# )-2# 7''*#

72%,%$),# %$9# ,I(%$92*29# '$# -0,# 7*'J2&),# %$9#

10,)*2,,2,a<bcd%*9,-07#%$9#,(;;2*0$:#-%D2#622$#)-2#&'11'$#5')#

';#1',)#12$#)-*'(:-'()#)-2#%:2,<#c'(*,#';#/'*G#-%D2#622$#5'$:#

%$9#';)2$#($*210))0$:#;'*#b1',)#72'752d#)-*'(:-'()#-0,)'*+<#?-2#

90,7%*0)02,#62)/22$#)-2#/2%5)-+#%$9#)-2#7''*#-%D2#%5/%+,#622$#

D2*+#:*2%)<A#

#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

A!#

C5,'.#/2#1(,)#$')#;'*:2)#)-%)#/-052#1%$#0,#&2*)%0$5+#&%7%652#

';#*2%,'$#%$9#&%$#9'#,'#1(&-#:''9#;'*#,'&02)+.#)-2*2#0,#%$')-2*#,092#

)'#1%$M,#$%)(*2#)-%)# 0,#9%*G#%$9#62$)#'$#-0,#'/$#92,)*(&)0'$<#W%$#

7*2+,# (7'$# -0,# G0$9<# c2# &'110),# %55# ,'*),# ';# &*012<# # c2# &%$# 62#

%::*2,,0D2# %$9# 92,)*(&)0D2<# c2# 1%+# &-2%).# )*2,7%,,.# ,)2%5.# %$9#

&'$,70*2# /0)-# ')-2*,# )'# 9'# :*2%)# -%*1<# W%$# 0,# %5,'# ,%09# )'# 5'D2#

7'/2*#'D2*#')-2*,#%$9.#0;#-2#%))%0$,#0).#1%+#2>2*&0,2#0)#0$#90&)%)'*0%5#

;%,-0'$<#

='*#)-0,#*2%,'$#1%$#,2),#(7#)-2#0$,)0)()0'$#';#:'D2*$12$)#$')#

'$5+# )'#7*')2&)#7*0D%)2#7*'72*)+.#6()# 0$#'*92*# )'#7*')2&)#1%$# ;*'1#

1%$<# B-2$# :'D2*$12$)# 0,# %&)0$:# 0$# 0),# 7*'72*# *'52# 0)# %55'/,#

2&'$'10&#%&)0D0)+#)'#)%G2#75%&2<#\0$&2#%55#2&'$'10&#%&)0D0)+#0$D'5D2,#

20)-2*# )-2# 7*'9(&)0'$# '*# )*%$,;2*# ';# 7*'72*)+.# :'D2*$12$)# ,-'(59#

,)27#0$#/-2$#7*0D%)2#7*'72*)+#0,#)*2,7%,,29#(7'$.#,)'52$.#%6(,29.#'*#

92,)*'+29<# @)# 0,# $22929# )'# -%$952# 90,7()2,.# 2$;'*&2# &'$)*%&),# %$9#

')-2*# ,0105%*# 9()02,# ';# 7*0D%)2# 7*'72*)+# 7*')2&)0'$.# 6()# /-%)#

-%772$,#/-2$#:'D2*$12$)#)(*$,#'$#0),#72'752#0$#)-2#1%$$2*#/2#,22#

-%772$0$:#)'9%+[#

?-2# ;($9%12$)%5# 7*'6521# /0)-# :'D2*$12$)# 0,# )-%)# 0)# 0,#

1'$'7'50,)0&# 6+# $%)(*2<# ?-2# 7'/2*# 0)# -%,# 0$# 0),# (,2# ';# 52:%5# ;'*&2#

1%G2,# G2270$:# :'D2*$12$)# ,)*0&)5+# 5010)29# 017',,0652<# H>&2,,0D2#

)%172*0$:#/0)-#1'$2+#%$9# )-2#1%*G2)#62:%$#9(*0$:#B'*59#B%*# @.#

%$9#0$&*2%,29#,(6,)%$)0%55+#9(*0$:#)-2#e'',2D25)#TF2/#f2%5U#+2%*,<#

L$&2# )-0,# -%772$29# %55# &'$,)*%0$),# /2*2# *21'D29<# ?'9%+# 1'$2+#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

A"#

0$;5%)0'$# %$9# 92;0&0)# ,72$90$:# 0,# 9'$2# /0)-# ,(&-# 017($0)+# )-%)# )-2#

$%)0'$%5#926)#-%,#*2%&-29#,)%::2*0$:#7*'7'*)0'$,K#?-2#%;;0$0)+# )-%)#

2>0,),#62)/22$#7'/2*#%$9#/2%5)-.# %#1',)# ;2%*;(5# &'160$%)0'$.# -%,#

622$#($52%,-29#0$#)-2#1',)#017'D2*0,-0$:#/%+#'$#'(*#,'&02)+<#?-2#

*2&2$)# 6%$G# 6%05'(),# %$9# )-2# $%)0'$%5080$:# ';# 1(&-# ';# C12*0&%$#

0$9(,)*+# -%,# 2$*0&-29# )-2# 7'50)0&%55+# &'$$2&)29# %)# )-2# 2>72$,2# ';#

2D2*+'$2#25,2.#%$9#-%,#'$5+#%9929#)'#)-2#&'11'$#1%$M,#%6(,2<#?-2#

C12*0&%$# &0)082$# -%,# 622$# 52;)# D0*)(%55+# 017*0,'$29<# c0,# ,70*0)# -%,#

622$#92275+#/'($929#%$9#1%$+#%*2# ;2250$:# )-2+#-%D2#*2%&-29# )-2#

7'0$)#';#$'#*2)(*$<#

!

12(!3/$8*%/&!

!

B-%)# 0;# )-2*2# /%,# %# ,'5()0'$# )'# )-0,# 1%9$2,,[# B'(59# +'(#

-2,0)%)2#'$2#10$()2#0$#/%$)0$:#)'#G$'/#/-%)#0)#0,[#L;#&'(*,2#$')K#F'#

'$2# /'(59<# ?-0,# 7*'6521# 0,# ,'# 72*D%,0D2# 0$# $%)(*2# )-%)# %# ,'5()0'$#

%5,'# ,221,# 017',,0652# %$9# +2).# )-2*2# 0,# %# ,'5()0'$<# @)M,# &%5529# )-2#

67$'%0"8$%)9"7$/'+3$%4:# @)# 0,#$')#$2/<# @)M,#%&)(%55+#622$#%*'($9# ;'*#

&2$)(*02,<# C(,)*0%$# 2&'$'10,),# ,7'G2# %$9# /*')2# %6'()# 0)<# B-%)# 0,#

%1%80$:#0,#)-%)#%#*2D'5()0'$#'*#(7*0,0$:# 0,#$')#*2I(0*29#0$#'*92*#)'#

&-%$:2#)-2# 0$,%$0)+#';# )-2#/'*59#%*'($9#(,<# @)#&%$#62# 0175212$)29#

*2:%*952,,# ';# /-%)# :'D2*$12$)# %$9# )-2# 7'50)0&%55+# &'$$2&)29# %*2#

9'0$:# *0:-)# $'/<#?-2*2# 0,# $'#$229# )'# 70&G2)# )-2# ,)*22),.# -'59#-(:2#

*%5502,.#'*#,)'*1#B%,-0$:)'$#921%$90$:#&-%$:2,<#F')#%#,0$:52#,-')#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

AA#

$229,#)'#62#;0*29<#?-0,#,'5()0'$M,#'$5+#*2I(0*212$)#0,#)-2#%&)0'$#';#%#

,0$:52# 72*,'$# %&)0$:# 0$# %# 1%$$2*# )'# -257# '$5+# -01,25;.# 6()# 0$# ,'#

%&)0$:# (5)01%)25+# -2# -257,# %55# ';# ,'&02)+<# @)# 0,# )-2#1',)# $%)(*%5# %$9#

0$$'&2$)# %&)0'$# %# -(1%$# 620$:# &%$# 9'.# %$9# +2)# )-2# 092%# 0,# ,'#

7'/2*;(5# )-%)# %,# 0)# ,7*2%9,# ;*'1# '$2# 0$90D09(%5# )'# %$')-2*.# %#

1%,,0D2# 1'D212$)# ,052$)5+# 92D25'7,# %$9# :%0$,# D25'&0)+<# # L$&2# 0)#

,7*2%9,# )'# )-2# 1%,,2,.# $')-0$:# /055# 62# %652# )'# 7*2D%05# %:%0$,)# 0)K#

g'D2*$12$)# %$9# 92,)*(&)0D2# 1'$2)%*+# 7'50&+# /055# 62# ;'*&29# )'#

&-%$:2<#c0,)'*+#/055#62#*2&'*929#90;;2*2$)5+<###

?-2# \'($9# W'$2+# \'5()0'$M,# G2+# %&)0'$# 0,# 0$# 6;*3<.+3=)0"

>.%?3%54:" c'/# 0)# ,72&0;0&%55+# /'*G,# /055# 62# 2>75%0$29# 0$# :*2%)2*#

92)%05# 0$# ]%*),# @@# %$9# @@@# ';# )-0,# 6''G<# ?-0,# %()-'*# ,)*'$:5+#

%91'$0,-2,#)-2#*2%92*#$')#)'#J(17#%-2%9#)'#2>%10$2#)-',2#,2&)0'$,#

($)05#-2#-%,#%#;0*1#:*%,7#';#)-2#I(%$9%*+#)-%)#0,#620$:#2>75%0$29#0$#

)-0,# ,2&)0'$<# @$#7%*)0&(5%*#-2#1(,)#($92*,)%$9#1'$2+# %$9#6%$G0$:#

;*'1# )-2# 7'0$),# ';# D02/# 620$:# 2>75%0$29# -2*2<# ?-0,# *2I(2,)# 0,# $')#

0$)2$929#)'#0$)0109%)2#$'*#,5'/#9'/$#)-2#*2%92*.#6()#*%)-2*#)'#(*:2#

-01#)'#;'55'/#)-2,2#0$,)*(&)0'$,#;'*#-0,#(5)01%)2#62$2;0)<#?-2#*2%92*#

/055# I(0&G5+# *2%5082# )-%)# 1',)# ';# )-2# 2>75%$%)0'$,# 0$# )-2# $2>)# ;'(*#

&-%7)2*,# %*2# 2%,+# )'# ($92*,)%$9# /0)-# )-2# (,2# ';# %# 60)# ';# 7(*2#

&'11'$# ,2$,2<# c'/2D2*.# /0)-'()# )-0,# ($92*,)%$90$:.# )-2# \'($9#

W'$2+#\'5()0'$#&%$$')#62# ;(55+#:*%,729<#F22952,,# )'# ,%+.#'59# 092%,#

%$9#0$&'**2&)#72*&27)0'$,#/055#$229#)'#62#,2)#%,092<#?-2#*2%92*#/055#

$229#)'#%9'7)#%#&'1752)25+#$2/#7%*%90:1<#C#)-'*'(:-#2>%10$%)0'$#

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

AN#

';#)-2#*21%0$0$:#&-%7)2*,#';#)-0,#,2&)0'$#/055#%55'/#;'*#)-2#$2&2,,%*+#

,-0;)# 0$# )-0$G0$:# *2I(0*29# %$9# )-2# *2%92*# /055# 2>72*02$&2# )-2# ;(55#

017%&)# ';# ]%*),# @@# %$9# @@@<# ?-2# 1')0D%)0'$# )'# %&)# 0$# )-2# 1%$$2*#

7*2,&*0629#/055#62#$%)(*%5<#

#

#

########################################################1 Clarence B. Carson, Basic Economics (Phenix City, AL: American Textbook Committee, 2003), p. 185. 2 Murray Rothbard, Man, Economy, and State (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2004), p. 555. 3Rothbard, Man, Economy, and State, p. 1024. 4 Hans Sennholz, “The Great Depression,” reprinted from a Freeman article from October 1969, posted June 24, 2009 at: http://mises.org/daily/3515. Accessed June 3, 2010. 5 See Robert P. Murphy’s “The Social Function of Stock Speculators,” November 22, 2006, at: http://mises.org/daily/2381. Accessed June 2, 2010. 6 Ludwig von Mises, “Inflation Destroys Savings,” excerpted from a speech given circa 1960s, posted May 18, 2010 at: http://mises.org/daily/4408. Accessed June 3, 2010. 7 Mises, “Inflation Destroys Savings.” 8 Carson, Basic Economics, p. 263.

!"#$%&'()*'+,$*$-'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!

"#!

!

!"#

Chapter 5#

Money

Money is such a routine part of everyday

living that its existence and acceptance

ordinarily are taken for granted. A user

may sense that money must come into

being either automatically as a result of

economic activity or as an outgrowth of

some government operation. But just

how this happens all too often remains a

mystery.

—Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago1

#

#

$# %&# '(# )**+*# $+# $,%(-# $,'$# ).)*/0+1/# %(# &+2%)$/# $*34/#

3(1)*&$'(1&#5+()/6#,+7#%$#+*%8%('$)&6#,+7#%$#93(2$%+(&6#+*#

).)(#$,)#2+(2):$#$,'$# %$# %&#&%5:4/#'#5)1%35#+9#);2,'(8)<#=,)(#7)#

$'-)# $,)# $%5)# $+# &)*%+3&4/# 2+(&%1)*# $,)# &30>)2$# +9# 5+()/# '(1# '&-#

+3*&)4.)&# $,)# &'5)#-%(1#+9#?3)&$%+(&# $,)#/+3(8# 2,%41# '&-)1# %(# $,)#

+:)(%(8# 2,':$)*# +9# $,%&# 0++-6# 7)# 2+5)# 9344# 2%*24)# $+# *)'4%@)# $,'$#

5+()/# %&# $,)# 2+55+(#1)(+5%('$+*# +9# .%*$3'44/# ).)*/$,%(8#+(# $,%&#

:4'()$<#A%*$3'44/#).)*/$,%(8#%&#);:*)&&)1#7%$,%(#$,)#$)*5&#+9#$,%&#+()#

&/&$)5<#B+&$6# %9#(+$#'446#+9#+3*#*)4'$%+(&,%:&#7%$,#+$,)*#)($%$%)&#'(1#

C#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!D#

+$,)*# ,35'(&# %(.+4.)# 5+()/<# E.)(# $%5)# %&# );:*)&&)1# %(# $)*5&# +9#

5+()/<# C9# $,)# 8+'4# +9# $,%&# $);$# %&# $+# ,)4:# 0*%(8# 24'*%$/# $+# '44# +9# $,)#

,%11)(#'&:)2$&#+9#$,)#5+()/#:*+04)56#$,)(#7)#53&$#&$'*$#7%$,#$,)#

5+*)#0'&%2# 9'2$&# '0+3$#5+()/#'(1#5+.)#'4+(8# '#1)4%0)*'$)# 4%()#+9#

$,+38,$#$,'$#).)($3'44/#'11*)&&)&#+3*#2+(2)*(<#F,)#%1)'#%&#$+#5'-)#

&3*)#7)# %(9+*5#).)*/+()6#0)2'3&)#).)*/+()G&# 9344#3(1)*&$'(1%(8# %&#

%5:+*$'($#$+#+3*#2'3&)<#

H# 8++1# :4'2)# $+# 0)8%(# +3*# 0'&%2# &$31/# +9# 5+()/# %&# 0/#

:,/&%2'44/#);'5%(%(8#%$<#C$#%&#$*3)#$,'$#%(#+3*#23**)($#$%5)&#5+()/#%(#

+()# &)(&)#,'&#0)2+5)# %(.%&%04)<#I9$)(#5+.%(8#)4)2$*+(%2'44/# '$# $,)#

&:))1#+9#4%8,$#%$#1+)&#(+$#).)(#:+&&)&#'#:,/&%2'4#0+1/<#F/:%2'44/#%$#%&#

5+&$#+9$)(#&))(#'&#(350)*&#+(#'# 4)18)*#+(#&+5)#'22+3($#0'4'(2)6#

/+3*#'22+3($#+*#$,)%*&<#J).)*$,)4)&&6#'44#9+*5&#+9#+3*#23**)($#5+()/#

53&$# 2+(.)*$#0'2-# $+#+3*#:':)*# 23**)(2/#'(1# 2+%(&<#H(#)2+(+5%&$#

7+341# *)9)*# $+# +3*# 5+()/# '&# #$%&# 5+()/6# )4)2$*+(%2# +*# +$,)*7%&)<#

I3*#9%*&$#?3)*/#7%44#0)6#K=,/#9%'$#5+()/LM##

#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!N#

##

O%*&$# +9# '446# $,)# 7+*1# #$%&# %&# 1)9%()1# '&# '# K'()*%+%&$,-" ./"

012+(3(" *%4" ,+" %" #,+3%*" %1&5,+$6%&$,-7" %" ),33%-'89" # P/# 9%'$6# $,)#

&3:*)5)# 4'7# +9# $,%&# 4'(1# ,'&# 1)24'*)1# $,%&# :':)*# (+$)# $+# 0)# *(:%*"

&(-'(+" #,+" %**" '(.&0" 21.*$)" %-'"2+$;%&(8# Q$31/# $,)# &5'44# :*%($# '$# $,)#

$+:#4)9$#,'(1#2+*()*#+9#$,%&#9'5%4%'*#:%)2)#+9#8*))(#:':)*<#Q%5:4/#:3$6#

$,%&# %&# +99%2%'44/# +3*# 5)1%35# +9# );2,'(8)6# $,)# +(4/# 5+()/# 7)# 2'(#

3&)R2(+$,'S# =)# 5'/# 3&)# '# 2,)2-6# +(4%()# 0'(-%(8# +*# ).)(# 2*)1%$#

2'*1&#$+#:'/#9+*#$,%(8&6#03$#34$%5'$)4/#'44#:'/5)($#$*'(&'2$%+(&#'*)#

1)(+5%('$)1#%(#*)9)*)(2)#$+#$,)&)#:':)*#1+44'*&<#F+#24'*%9/#93*$,)*6#

%9#'#2*)1%$+*#+7)&#/+3#5+()/#'(1#/+3#*)93&)#$+#'22):$#$,%&#23**)(2/#

%(#:'/5)($6#$,'$#2*)1%$+*G&#1)0$#$+#/+36#0/#4'76#%&#&%5:4/#2'(2)4)1<#

J+$%2)# '4&+# '$# $,)# .)*/# $+:# +9# +3*# 1+44'*# 0%44# $,)# 7+*1%(8#

<('(+%*"=(0(+;(">,&(8"H8'%(6#.)*/#&%5:4/6# $,)#(+$)# %(1%2'$)&#24)'*4/#

$,'$# %$# 7'&# 5'1)# '(1# 1%&$*%03$)1# 0/# $,)# O)1)*'4# T)&)*.)6# +3*#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!U#

2+3($*/G&# 2)($*'4# 0'(-<# I0.%+3&4/6# 7)# -(+7# $,'$# $,%&# %&# :*%($)1#

5+()/# 0)2'3&)# %$# %&# :':)*# '(1# %(-<# =)# '4&+# 1)$)*5%()# 0/#

+0&)*.'$%+(# $,'$# %$# 2)*$'%(4/# '::)'*&# +99%2%'4<# C$# %&# )4'0+*'$)4/#

'1+*()1# 7%$,# '3$,+*%$'$%.)# %5'8)&# $,'$# );:*)&&# $,)# 9344# 9'%$,# '(1#

&$*)(8$,# +9# $,)#V<Q<# 8+.)*(5)($<# #W+7).)*6#7)# &,'44# &++(# &))# $,'$#

$,)*)#%&#(+$,%(8##('(+%*"'0+3$#%$#'(1#$,)*)#%&#(+#+(0(+;(8"

J+7# 2+5:'*)# $,)# 1+44'*# 0%44# +(# $,)# :*).%+3&# :'8)# 7%$,# $,)#

+()#+(#$,%&#:'8)<#

#

F,%&#1+44'*6#7,%2,#2%*234'$)1#%(#"!XY6#4++-&#);'2$4/#4%-)#$,)#1+44'*#+(#

$,)#:*).%+3&#:'8)#);2):$#9+*#$,%&#+()#.)*/#%5:+*$'($#1%&$%(2$%+(<#H$#

$,)# .)*/# $+:# 7)# &))# $,'$# $,%&# 1+44'*# ,'&# 7*%$$)(# '2*+&&# %$# ?@ABC="

DC=E@<@DFEC<##=)#'4&+#*)'1#$,)#9+44+7%(8Z#GE5$0")(+&$#$(0"&5%&"&5(+("$0"

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!X#

,-" '(2,0$&" 4$&5" &5(" E+(%01+/" ,#" &5(" H-$&('" ?&%&(0" ,#" F3(+$)%7" ,-("

'()*$+"',**%+7"2%/%.*("&,"&5(".(%+(+",-"'(3%-'89"

F,'$#%&#?3%$)#'#1%&$%(2$%+(<#C(#2'&)#$,)#*)'1)*#%&(G$#&3*)6#4)$#3&#

0)# 2*/&$'4# 24)'*Z#E5(+(" $0" -,&5$-:" .%)I$-:" ,1+" )1++(-&" )1++(-)/8# P/#

$,'$# 7)# 5)'(# $,'$# %$&# :*)2%+3&# 5)$'4# 2+(.)*$%0%4%$/# ,'&# 0))(#

*)5+.)16#8*'13'44/#'$#9%*&$6#03$#+.)*#$%5)#:)*5'()($4/<#F,%&#:*+2)&&#

'2$3'44/#0)8'(#7,)(#[*)&%1)($#O*'(-4%(#\<#T++&).)4$6# %(#+()#+9#,%&#

9%*&$# '2$&# %(# +99%2)6# 1)24'*)1# '&# %44)8'4# $,)# 3&)# +9# 8+41# '&# 5+()/# %(#

"!NN<# C$#7'&#:*+(+3(2)1#'# 2*%5)# 9+*# '(/# 2%$%@)(# $+# 2+($%(3)#3&%(8#

8+41#'&#5+()/6#'# 4'7#$,'$#7'&#&$*%2$4/#)(9+*2)1#0/#'#&$%99# 9%()6#).)(#

%5:*%&+(5)($<#O3*$,)*5+*)6#[*)&%1)($#T++&).)4$#1)5'(1)1#$,'$#'44#

8+41#0)#$3*()1#+.)*#$+#$,)#8+.)*(5)($6#$+#0)#&$+*)1#'(1#4+2-)1#%(#'#

.'34$#3(1)*#'*5)1#5%4%$'*/#:*+$)2$%+(<#F,)#8+41#.'34$# %&# -(+7(#'&#

O+*$#](+;#'(1#%&#4+2'$)1#%(#$,)#&$'$)#+9#])($32-/<#

I3*#2+%(&#7)*)#'$#+()#$%5)#5'1)#+9#!Y^#:3*)#&%4.)*<#F+1'/#

$,)/#'*)#5)*)4/#$+-)(&#5'1)#+9#2,)':#5)$'4<#=,)(#7)#&'/#$,'$#+3*#

5+()/# ,'&# 4+&$# !X^# +9# %$# .'43)# &%(2)# $,)# )'*4/# "!__&6# 7)# '*)#

&:)'-%(8#+9# %$&# 4+&&#+9#:3*2,'&%(8#:+7)*6#03$#'4&+#+9#$,)#9'2$#$,'$# %$#

,'&#0))(#3(`4%(-)1#9*+5#:*)2%+3&#5)$'4&R+(%*"3,-(/8##

I()#+$,)*#&%8(%9%2'($#:+%($#())1&#5)($%+(%(8<#F,)#V<Q<#+(2)#

+7()1# '# 4'*8)# &,'*)# +9# '44# $,)# 8+41# %(# $,)# 7+*416# 03$# $+1'/# $,)#

'5+3($# '2$3'44/# %(#V<Q<# :+&&)&&%+(# %&# 3(-(+7(<#J+# +3$&%1)# '8)(2/#

,'&#0))(#'44+7)1#%(&%1)#O+*$#](+;#%(#5'(/#1)2'1)&#$+#'31%$#$,)#8+41#

0344%+(# ,)41# $,)*)<# # I0.%+3&4/# (+()# +9# $,%&# %&# 8++1# ()7&<#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!a#

V(1)*&$'(1%(8#,+7#'(1#7,/#7)#,'.)#7+3(1#3:#%(#$,%&#&%$3'$%+(#%&#

+9# &3:*)5)# %5:+*$'(2)# $+# 3&# $+1'/<# =)# 7%44# 4)'*(# 5+*)# &:)2%9%2&#

4'$)*6#03$#9+*#(+7#$,)&)#9'2$&#&,+341#(+$#0)#9+*8+$$)(<#

#

!"#$%&'"()*$")'"!+&$%,-./"0-$12"3)4&5-$2"6%/5)$2"

#

F,)*)#7)*)# $7+# 4'*8)`&2'4)# );:)*%5)($&#7%$,# 9%'$#5+()/# %(#

+3*# 2+3($*/G&# )'*4/# ,%&$+*/<# P+$,# $%5)&# %443&$*'$)1# $,)# 1'(8)*# +9#

8%.%(8# :+4%$%2%'(&# 2+($*+4# +9# $,)# :*%($%(8# :*)&&<# F,)# 9%*&$# ):%&+1)#

+223**)1# 13*%(8# +3*# 2+3($*/G&# %(9'(2/<# \3*%(8# $,)# ='*# +9#

C(1):)(1)(2)6#$,)#1)&:)*'$)#b+($%()($'4#b+(8*)&&#0)8'(#:'/%(8#%$&#

1)0$&# %(# 9%'$# 5+()/# 2'44)1# D,-&$-(-&%*0<# H$# +()# :+%($6# c)()*'4#

='&,%(8$+(#2+5:4'%()1# $+#b+(8*)&&# $,'$# %$# $++-#'#7,))40'**+7#+9#

b+($%()($'4&#%(#+*1)*#$+#03/#0*)'1#9+*#,%&#&$'*.%(8#&+41%)*&<##[)+:4)#

7+341# (+$# *)'1%4/# '22):$# b+($%()($'4&# '&# 5+()/6# &%5:4/# 0)2'3&)#

$,)/#-()7#%$#7'&#(+$#*)'4#5+()/<# dF,)#*)'1)*#5'/#,'.)#,)'*1#$,)#

:,*'&)# K(+$# 7+*$,# '# b+($%()($'4<Me# F,)/# -()7# %$# 7'&# :':)*# 9%'$#

5+()/#7,+&)#2+(.)*$%0%4%$/#$+#'#:*)2%+3&#5)$'4#7'&#?3)&$%+('04)<#

C(1))1#$,%&#)'*4/#1%&'&$)*#7%$,#9%'$#5+()/#8*)'$4/#%(943)(2)1#

$,)# O+3(1%(8# O'$,)*&<# c<# E17'*1# c*%99%(# 1)&2*%0)&# &+5)# +9# $,)#

2+55)($'*/#'$#$,)#b+(&$%$3$%+('4#b+(.)($%+(Z#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!Y#

I4%.)*# E44&7+*$,# 9*+5# b+(()2$%23$6# 7,+# 4'$)*# 7'&# $+#

0)2+5)#+3*#$,%*1#b,%)9# f3&$%2)#+9#$,)#Q3:*)5)#b+3*$6#&'%16#KF,%&#

%&# '# 9'.+*'04)# 5+5)($# $+# &,3$# '(1# 0'*# $,)# 1++*# '8'%(&$# :':)*#

5+()/<#F,)#5%&2,%)9#+9#$,)#.'*%+3&#);:)*%5)($&#7,%2,#,'.)#0))(#

5'1)# '*)# (+7# 9*)&,# %(# $,)# :304%2# 5%(1# '(1# ,'.)# );2%$)1# $,)#

1%&83&$#+9#'44#$,)#*)&:)2$'04)#:'*$&#+9#H5)*%2'<M#

c)+*8)#B'&+(#9*+5#A%*8%(%'#$+41#$,)#1)4)8'$)&#,)#,'1#'#

K5+*$'4# ,'$*)1# $+# :':)*# 5+()/<M# [*).%+3&4/# ,)# ,'1# 7*%$$)(# $+#

c)+*8)#='&,%(8$+(Z#KF,)/#5'/#:'&&#'#4'7#$+#%&&3)#:':)*#5+()/6#

03$#$7)($/#4'7&#7%44#(+$#5'-)#$,)#:)+:4)#*)2)%.)#%$<#[':)*#5+()/#

%&#9+3(1)1#3:+(#9*'31#'(1#-('.)*/<M#

f'5)&#=%4&+(#+9#[)((&/4.'(%'#&'%1Z#KC$#7%44#,'.)#$,)#5+&$#

&'43$'*/# %(943)(2)# +(# $,)# 2*)1%$# +9# $,)# V(%$)1# Q$'$)&# $+# *)5+.)#

$,)#:+&&%0%4%$/#+9#:':)*#5+()/<M#

f+,(# g'(81+(# 9*+5# J)7# W'5:&,%*)# 7'*()1# $,'$# ,)#

7+341#*'$,)*#*)>)2$#$,)#7,+4)#:4'(#+9#9)1)*'$%+(#$,'(#$+#8*'($#$,)#

()7#8+.)*(5)($#$,)#*%8,$#$+#%&&3)#9%'$#5+()/<#

c)+*8)#T))1#9*+5#\)4'7'*)#1)24'*)1#$,'$#'#:*+.%&%+(#%(#

$,)#b+(&$%$3$%+(#8*'($%(8#$,)#()7#8+.)*(5)($#$,)#*%8,$#$+#%&&3)#

9%'$# 5+()/# K7+341# 0)# '&# '4'*5%(8# '&# $,)# 5'*-# +9# $,)# 0)'&$# %(#

T).)4'$%+(<MD##

J))14)&&# $+# &'/6# $,)# +*%8%('4# &%8()*&# +9# $,)# b+(&$%$3$%+(# 1%1#

-,&#$,%(-#$,)/#7)*)#2*)'$%(8#'#9)1)*'4#8+.)*(5)($#$,'$#,'1#$,)#*%8,$#

$+# 8%.)# 8*))(# :%)2)&# +9# :':)*# $,)# 9+*2)# +9# 4)8'4# $)(1)*<# F,)# 24'3&)#

8*'($%(8# b+(8*)&&# $,)# :+7)*# $+# K2+%(# 5+()/M# '(1# K*)834'$)# $,)#

.'43)#$,)*)+9M#,'&#0))(#'&#,)*+%2'44/#&$*'%()1#d%(#+*1)*#$+#>3&$%9/#$,)#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!h#

8+.)*(5)($G&# 1)0'&)5)($# +9# $,)# 1+44'*e# '&# $,)# +$,)*# 5+1)*(#

5%&%($)*:*)$'$%+(&# +9# $,)# +0.%+3&# %($)($%+(&# +9# $,)# &%8('$+*%)&<#

c*%99%(#);:4'%(&Z#

#C(# .%)7# +9# $,)# 9'2$# $,'$# 8+41# '(1# &%4.)*# 2+%(# 7'&#

&:)2%9%2'44/# 1)9%()1# '&# $,)# +(4/# -%(1# +9# 5+()/# $+# 0)# '44+7)16#

$,)*)#2'(#0)#(+#1+30$#+9#7,'$#7'&#5)'($iF+#2+%(#5+()/#5)'($#

$+#5%($#:*)2%+3&`5)$'4#2+%(&<#[)*%+1<#

F,)# &)2+(1#,'49# j+9# $,)# 24'3&)k# %&# )?3'44/# 24)'*<#P+$,# %(#

$,)#b+(&$%$3$%+(#'(1#%(#$,)#1%&23&&%+(&#'5+(8#$,)#1)4)8'$)&6#$,)#

:+7)*# $+# *)834'$)# $,)# .'43)# +9# 8+41# '(1# &%4.)*# 2+%(# 7'&# 24+&)4/#

$%)1#$+#$,)#:+7)*#$+#1)$)*5%()#7)%8,$&#'(1#5)'&3*)&<#F,)/#'*)6#

%(#9'2$6#+()#'(1#$,)#&'5)<#F+#*)834'$)#$,)#.'43)#+9#2+%(#%&#);'2$4/#

$,)# &'5)# '&# $+# &)$# $,)# ('$%+('44/# '22):$)1# .'43)# +9# '# 5%4)# +*# '#

:+3(1#+*#'#?3'*$<#C$#%&#$+#2*)'$)#'#&$'(1'*1#'8'%(&$#7,%2,#'#$,%(8#

5'/#0)#5)'&3*)1i<#

F,)# %($)($6# $,)*)9+*)6# 7'&# &%5:4/# 9+*# b+(8*)&&# $+#

1)$)*5%()# $,)# );'2$# 7)%8,$# +9# '# :*)2%+3&# 5)$'4# $,'$# 7+341#

2+(&$%$3$)#$,)#('$%+('4#5+()$'*/#3(%$<N#

#

F+#1*%.)#,+5)#$,)#:+%($#$,'$#$,)#O+3(1)*&#1%1#(+$#$,%(-#$,)#

()7# b+(&$%$3$%+(# 8'.)# $,)# 9)1)*'4# 8+.)*(5)($# $,)# :+7)*# $+# %&&3)#

9%'$#5+()/6#2+(&%1)*#$,)#9+44+7%(8#$,+38,$&#$,'$#c)+*8)#='&,%(8$+(#

7*+$)#%(#"Yh!Z#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!!#

=)# 5'/# +()# 1'/# 0)2+5)# '# 8*)'$# 2+55)*2%'4# '(1#

94+3*%&,%(8#('$%+(<#P3$# %9# %(# $,)#:3*&3%$#+9#$,)#5)'(&#7)#&,+341#

3(9+*$3('$)4/# &$3504)# '8'%(# +(# 3(93(1)1# :':)*# 5+()/# +*# '(/#

&%5%4'*#&:)2%)&#+9#9*'316#7)#&,'44#'&&3*)14/#8%.)#'#9'$'4#&$'0#$+#+3*#

('$%+('4#2*)1%$#%(#%$&#%(9'(2/<U#

#

\3*%(8#='&,%(8$+(G&#9%*&$#$)*5#'&#:*)&%1)($6#,%&#Q)2*)$'*/#+9#

$,)#F*)'&3*/#H4);'(1)*#W'5%4$+(#:*+:+&)1#$,)#2*)'$%+(#+9#'#2)($*'4#

0'(-#d$,)#O%*&$#P'(-#+9#$,)#V(%$)1#Q$'$)&e<#F,%&#*'%&)1#$,)#9%)*2)#%*)#

+9# Q)2*)$'*/# +9# Q$'$)# F,+5'&# f)99)*&+(6# 7,+# 1)24'*)1Z# KH# :*%.'$)#

2)($*'4#0'(-#%&&3%(8#$,)#:304%2#23**)(2/#%&#'#8*)'$)*#5)('2)#$+#$,)#

4%0)*$%)&# +9# $,)# :)+:4)# $,'(# '# &$'(1%(8# '*5/<MX# =)# &))# $,'$# $,)#

O+3(1%(8#O'$,)*&6#7)*)#$,)/#$+#.%)7#:*)&)($`1'/#H5)*%2'6#7+341#0)#

&,+2-)1#+(#3%-/#4).)4&<#

\)&:%$)# $,)# '7934# );:)*%)(2)# 7%$,# b+($%()($'4&# 13*%(8# $,)#

='*# 9+*# C(1):)(1)(2)6#0+$,#&%1)&# %(# $,)#b%.%4#='*#d+*#7,'$# %&#'4&+#

-(+7(#'&#$,)#='*#P)$7))(#$,)#Q$'$)&e#&322350)1#$+#$,)#$)5:$'$%+(#

$+# *)4/# +(# 3(0'2-)1# 9%'$# 5+()/# $+# :'/# $,)%*# );:)(&)&<# F,)# :*%2)#

%(94'$%+(# %(# $,)# b+(9)1)*'$)# &$'$)&# 7'&# '::'44%(86# '(1# ).)(# %(# $,)#

J+*$,#$,)#:304%2#0)2'5)#1%&%443&%+()1#7%$,#$,)#*':%14/#1)$)*%+*'$%(8#

Kc*))(0'2-&M#3($%4# $,)/#7)*)#+(2)#'8'%(# 4%(-)1# $+#:*)2%+3&#5)$'4&#

'9$)*#$,)#7'*<#

H(/$%5)#&+3(1#5+()/6#'&#%(#8+416#2%*234'$)&#'4+(8&%1)#:':)*#

5+()/#(+$#0'2-)1#0/#'#:*)2%+3&#5)$'46#$,)#:)+:4)#$)(1#$+#,+'*1#$,)#

&+3(1#5+()/#'(1#&:)(1#$,)#0'1#5+()/<#F,%&#:,)(+5)(+(#7'&#9%*&$#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"__#

1%&2+.)*)1# %(# $,)# "X__&# '(1# %&# -(+7(# '&# c*)&,'5G&# g'7Z# GJ%'"

3,-(/" '+$;(0" ,1&" :,,'" 1-'(+" *(:%*" &(-'(+" *%4089# =,)(# $,)#

8+.)*(5)($# 9+*2)&# 5)*2,'($&# '(1# 2*)1%$+*&# $+# '22):$# 1)0'&)1#

5+()/# '&# %9# %$# 7)*)# )?3%.'4)($# $+# $,)# 8)(3%()# '*$%24)6# ).)*/+()#

$*'1)&#'7'/#$,)#%(9)*%+*#.)*&%+(<#J+#+()#7'($&#$,)#:':)*#5+()/<#J+#

+()#&'.)&#$,)#:':)*#5+()/<#F,)#:)+:4)#7%44#,+'*1#$,)#8++1#5+()/#

)'2,# '(1# ).)*/$%5)<# F,%&# :'*$4/# );:4'%(&# O\TG&# 2+(9%&2'$%+(# +9#

2%$%@)(&G#,+41%(8&#+9#8+41#%(#"!NN<#

I(2)# '8'%(6# +3*# ('$%+(# %&# 3&%(8# '# :':)*# 5+()/# (+$#

*)1))5'04)#%(#:*)2%+3&#5)$'4&<#O)1)*'4#T)&)*.)#J+$)&#(+7#2%*234'$)#

%(# +3*# )2+(+5/# $+$'44/# 9*))# 9*+5# %$&# 5'%(# 2+5:)$%$+*&6# 8+41# '(1#

&%4.)*<#C$#%&#+99%2%'44/#4)8'4#$)(1)*#'(1#%$#%&#$,)#+(4/#5+()/#7)#2'(#3&)<#

E.)(# 5+*)# (+$)7+*$,/6# $+1'/# '44# 2+3($*%)&# %(# $,)# 7+*41# 3&)# 9%'$#

5+()/<# W)*)# '(1# '0*+'1# 7)# '*)# 2+5:4)$)4/# +99# $,)# 8+41# &$'(1'*1<#

V(%.)*&'44/#%$#%&#'44#(+$,%(8#5+*)#$,'(#:':)*#'(1#%(-<#

#

(7&"#$&55)4"8))9/"!:$&&+&45";<=="

#

H9$)*# =+*41# ='*# CC6# $,)# V(%$)1# Q$'$)&# )5)*8)1# '&# '# 7+*41#

&3:)*:+7)*<#V&%(8# $,%&#:+7)*934# %(943)(2)# $,)#V<Q<# 9+*534'$)1#'(1#

1*+.)# %($+# '22):$'(2)# '# ()7# 84+0'4# 5+()$'*/# &/&$)5# '$# $,)#

2+(9)*)(2)# %(#P*)$$+(#=++1&6#J)7#W'5:&,%*)# %(#"!UU<# C(#2+($*'&$#

$+#$,)#24'&&%2'4#8+41#&$'(1'*16#%(#7,%2,#).)*/#('$%+(G&#23**)(2/#7'&#

2+(.)*$%04)# 0/# '(/+()# %($+# '# &:)2%9%)1# 7)%8,$# +9# 8+416# $,)# ()7#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_"#

&/&$)5#)(&,*%()1#$,)#H8?8"',**%+"'&#$,)#'(2,+*#3:+(#7,%2,#'44#+$,)*#

9%'$# 23**)(2%)&#7)*)#0'&)1<#T'$,)*# $,'(# &$+2-:%4%(8#0'*&# +9# 8+41# %(#

$,)%*# .'34$&# '&# *)&)*.)&6# 9+*)%8(# 2)($*'4# 0'(-&#7)*)# )(2+3*'8)1# $+#

3&)#V<Q<#1+44'*&#'&#$,)%*#K*)&)*.)&<M#

V(1)*# $,)# P*)$$+(# =++1&# '8*))5)($6# $,)# V<Q<# 1+44'*# %$&)49#

7'&#&$%44#0'2-)1#3:#0/#8+416# '$# $,)#+99%2%'4# );2,'(8)#*'$)#+9#lNX#'(#

+3(2)6# $,3&# :*+.%1%(8# '# 9%*5# 9+3(1'$%+(# $+# $,)# )($%*)# &/&$)5<#

W+7).)*6# 3(4%-)# $,)#:*'2$%2)#13*%(8# $,)# 24'&&%2'4# 8+41# &$'(1'*16# %(#

$,)# ()7# '**'(8)5)($# +(4/# )(-&+%*" .%-I0# ,'1# $,)# *%8,$# $+# $3*(# %(#

$,)%*#:':)*#1+44'*&# 9+*#8+41#0344%+(<#H5)*%2'(#2%$%@)(&#7+341#().)*#

'8'%(#*)8'%(#$,)#'0%4%$/R&$*%::)1#9*+5#$,)5#0/#O\TR$+#$3*(#$,)%*#

1+44'*&#%(#9+*#8+41<#F,3&#+()#+9#$,)#5+&$#:+$)($#2,)2-&#+(#%(94'$%+(#

,'1#0))(#*)5+.)1<#

H&#&$'$)1#)'*4%)*6# $,)#V(%$)1#Q$'$)&#,'1#'#,38)#&$+2-#+9#8+41#

*)&)*.)&#'9$)*#=+*41#='*#CC#'(1#0)8'(#:3*&3%(8#'#,%8,4/#%(94'$%+('*/#

2+3*&)# 532,# $+# $,)# 1%&5'/# +9# 9+*)%8(# 2+3($*%)&<# H&# $,)# 1+44'*#

7)'-)()1#0)2'3&)#+9#$,)&)#5+()$'*/#'2$%.%$%)&6#8+41#&$'*$)1#94+7%(8#

+3$#+9#$,)#2+3($*/#%(#4'*8)#'5+3($&#'&#9+*)%8(#8+.)*(5)($&#2'&,)1#

%(# $,)%*# 1+44'*&# 9+*# 8+41<# # C$# *)'2,)1# '# 2*%&%&# :+%($# 0/# "!ah6# '(1# %(#

"!Y"# [*)&%1)($# T%2,'*1# J%;+(# $++-# +3*# 1+44'*# $+$'44/# +99# 8+41# '(1#

1)24'*)1#$,)#P*)$$+(#=++1&#'8*))5)($#(344#'(1#.+%1<#H$#$,%&#:+%($6#

$,)# V<Q<# 1+44'*R'(1# 0/# );$)(&%+(6# $,)# 23**)(2%)&# +9# +$,)*# 7+*41#

:+7)*&R7'&# '(# '&&)$# 3($+# %$&)496# ,'.%(8# (+# 4%(-# $+# $,)# :*)2%+3&#

5)$'4&<#H$#$,%&#:+%($6#$,)#+(4/#*)&$*'%($#+(#$,)#:*%($%(8#+9#()7#:':)*#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_D#

1+44'*&#7'&# $,)#1%&2*)$%+(#+9# O)1)*'4#T)&)*.)#+99%2%'4&<# F,)*)#7)*)#

(+#9+*5'4#2,)2-&#4)9$#+(#$,)%*#'::)$%$)#9+*#%(94'$%+(<#

B'(/#:)+:4)#);:)2$)1#$,'$#$,)#)($%*)#%($)*('$%+('4#5+()$'*/#

&/&$)5# 7+341# 2+44':&)# '9$)*# $,)# 0*)'-3:# +9# P*)$$+(# =++1&<#

Q3*:*%&%(84/# %$# 1%1(G$<# Q+5)# ,%&$+*%'(&# &:)234'$)# $,'$# V<Q<# 5%4%$'*/#

5%8,$# '(1# 9)'*&# +9# '(# +3$0*)'-# +9# =+*41# ='*# CCC# -):$# +$,)*#

8+.)*(5)($&# %(# 2,)2-6# 2+($%(3%(8# $+# 3&)# $,)# V<Q<# 1+44'*# '&# $,)#

7+*41G&# *)&)*.)# 23**)(2/# ).)(# $,+38,# $,)/# ().)*# 7+341# ,'.)#

'8*))1#$+#$,)#'**'(8)5)($#+*%8%('44/#7%$,+3$#$,)#1+44'*G&#0'2-%(8#0/#

8+41<# C(# '(/# ).)($6# $,)# V<Q<# );:)*%)(2)# +9# K&$'894'$%+(M# 13*%(8# $,)#

"!Y_&# &,+7)1# $,'$# $,)# $%)# $+# 8+41R7)'-# $,+38,# %$# 7'&# 3(1)*#

P*)$$+(#=++1&R,'1#*)&$*'%()1# %(94'$%+(<#H9$)*#J%;+(#*)5+.)1#$,)#

4'&$#&,'2-4)&6#$,)#V<Q<#&399)*)1#9*+5#'(#+*8/#+9#1+44'*#:*%($%(8<##

#

(7&">&4&/%/")'"3)4&2"

"

O+*# '# 2+5:4)$)# :)*&:)2$%.)# +(# 5+()/# '(1# 9+*# +3*# +7(#

:*)&)*.'$%+(6#%$#%&#%5:+*$'($#$+#-(+7#7,)*)#5+()/#+*%8%('44/#2'5)#

9*+5<# H3&$*%'(# )2+(+5%&$# B3**'/# T+$,0'*1# %(# &).)*'4# +9# ,%&#

);2)44)($# 0++-&# dK5%&" L%0" M,;(+-3(-&" N,-(" &," O1+" P,-(/Q6" E5("

D%0(" F:%$-0&" &5(" <('6" E5(" P/0&(+/" ,#" J%-I$-:6# '(1# ,%&# 9'5+3&#

)2+(+5%2#$*)'$%&)7"P%-7"C),-,3/"%-'"?&%&(e6");:4'%(&#$,%&#%5:+*$'($#

9)'$3*)#+9#5+()/#%(#4'(83'8)#$,'$#$,)#4'/:)*&+(#2'(#3(1)*&$'(1<#=)#

(+7#8%.)#'#&355'$%+(#+9#T+$,0'*1G&#);:4'('$%+(<#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_N#

O%*&$# +9# '446#5+()/#1%1#(+$# 2+5)# %($+#0)%(8#0/# &+5)# &+*$# +9#

'8*))5)($6#+*#&+2%'4#2+($*'2$<#B+()/#2+5)&#%($+#0)%(8#9*))4/#%(#$,)#

5'*-)$#:4'2)#0/#$*%'4#'(1#)**+*<#F,%&#,'::)(&#'&#%(1%.%13'4&#0)8%(#$+#

9'2%4%$'$)# $,)#:*+2)&&#+9#);2,'(8%(8#8++1&#7%$,#+()#'(+$,)*<# C(#$,)#

1'/&# +9# 0'*$)*%(8# d7,'$# )2+(+5%&$&# *)9)*# $+# '&# K1%*)2$# );2,'(8)Me6#

:*+04)5&# '*+&)# 7,)(# :)+:4)# '$$)5:$)1# $+# );2,'(8)# $7+# 1%99)*)($#

2+55+1%$%)&<# O+*# );'5:4)6# %9# /+3# ,'1# 03$$)*# $+# );2,'(8)# 9+*# 0))96#

03$#(+#+()#7%$,#0))9#7'($)1#/+3*#03$$)*6#$,)(#/+3#+0.%+3&4/#,'1#'#

:*+04)5<# F,%&# );2,'(8)# :*+04)56# 0)2'3&)# %$# 2'5)# 3:# ?3%$)#

9*)?3)($4/6# 9+*2)1# &+2%)$/# $+# &)'*2,# 9+*# '# 2+55+1%$/# $+# &)*.)# '&# '#

&(32,+%+/" (R)5%-:(6# +*# 7,'$# )2+(+5%&$&# *)9)*# $+# '&# '(# $-'$+()&"

(R)5%-:(8#I0.%+3&4/6# $,)#2+55+1%$/#&+2%)$/#34$%5'$)4/#&)4)2$)1# 9+*#

$,)#%(1%*)2$#);2,'(8)#,'1#$+#0)#,%8,4/#5'*-)$'04)<#C$#5'/#,'.)#0))(#

)88&6# 5%4-# +*# 0*)'16# 03$6# 7,'$).)*# %$# 7'&6# &+2%)$/# ).)($3'44/#

)5:4+/)1#%$#'&#5+()/<#

I.)*# $,)# 2+3*&)# +9# $%5)# $,)# +()# 5)1%35# +9# );2,'(8)# $,'$#

7+(# +.)*# '44# +$,)*# 9+*5&# +9# 5+()/# ,'&# 0))(# 8+41<# =,/# 8+41L##

P)2'3&)# %$#,'&# 9)'$3*)&#(+#+$,)*#2+55+1%$/#,'&<#O+*#);'5:4)6# %$# %&#

,(*('(-)$<# C5'8%()#$*/%(8#$+#1%.%1)#'#1%'5+(1#$+#:'/#9+*#&+5)$,%(8<#

c+416#+(#$,)#+$,)*#,'(16#2'(#0)#)'&%4/#23$#3:#%($+#$%(/#:%)2)&#7,%4)#

+(&%$-$-:"$&0"2+,+%&%";%*1(#&+#$,'$#5+()/#2'4234'$%+(&#2'(#0)#5'1)<#

P/# 5'-%(8# 8+41# %(# )%$,)*# 0344%+(# 0'*&# +*# 2+%(&6# %$# 0)2+5)&# .)*/#

."+/0-)$#'(1#.)*/#2+(.)(%)($#$+#3&)<#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_U#

F,)*)#%&#'4&+#$,)#9'2$#$,'$#9*+5#)'*4%)&$#*)2+*1)1#,%&$+*/#8+41#

,'&# 0))(# .'43'04)# '&# >)7)4*/# :*%(2%:'44/# 0)2'3&)# +9# %$&# 1)2+*'$%.)#

0)'3$/<#C(#'11%$%+(#$+#$,%&6#7)#53&$#(+$#9+*8)$#$,'$#8+41#%&#)(1(/$,&(#&

(/'& '2..)%<# C(# +*1)*# $+# 8)$# 5+*)# +9# %$6# %$# ,'&# $+# 0)# 5%()1# 9*+5# $,)#

8*+3(1# '$# 8*)'$# );:)(&)<## P3$# $,'$# %&# (+$# '44<# c+41# %&# );$*)5)4/#

,2+0-)$& '(1# (+(`:)*%&,'04)<# C$# 2'(# 4'&$# 9+*# 2)($3*%)&<# H(1# 9%('44/6#

8+41# %&# 3"1"4$#$"2'# '(1# )'&%4/# *)2+8(%@'04)8## C$# 2'(# 0)# 5'1)# $+#

4++-# );'2$4/# 4%-)# '(+$,)*# +9# %$&# -%(16# '&# %(# 8+41# 2+%(&<# O+*# $,)&)#

*)'&+(&#%$#%&#(+$#&3*:*%&%(8#$,'$#,%&$+*%2'44/#8+41#,'&#0))(#$,)#5+()/#

+9# 2,+%2)<# J+# 1+30$6# 8+41# %&# &+3(1# 5+()/<# O*+5# '# 2+(.)(%)(2)#

&$'(1:+%($6# :':)*# 5+()/# 2'(# 0)# 3&)934# 03$# +(4/# &+# 4+(8# '&# %$# %&#

34$%5'$)4/#4%(-)1#$+6#+*#:'/'04)#3:+(#1)5'(1#9+*6#8+41<##

What is the right quantity of money?

As we well know, there has been an astronomical increase of the

money supply by the Federal Reserve Bank during the last four decades,

especially in 2008. The general public innately knows that all this new

money creation is not a good thing for society simply because the more

we have of something the less it is worth. Before pondering the question

of the best or the “optimal” amount of money, try asking these

questions: What should the optimum amount of canned peas be in

society? Or: What is the optimum amount of fresh turkeys? Or:

watermelons? Or: cattle? or whatever commodity comes to mind. The

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_X#

point is that the more consumable goods we have in society the better it

is for everyone. In fact, more goods in the market help bring down

prices and our standard of living goes up, because there is more to

consume and enjoy per capita. However, this is not the case with more

money. An increase of money provides no social benefit whatsoever.

K=,/#(+# &+2%'4#0)()9%$LM# /+3#'&-<#P)2'3&)#5+()/#2'((+$#0)#

)'$)(# +*# 2+(&35)1<# B+()/6# *)5)50)*6# %&# 3&)1# 9+*# );2,'(8)#

:3*:+&)&#+(4/<#I(2)#'#2+55+1%$/# %&# %(#&399%2%)($#&3::4/#'&#5+()/6#

(+#93*$,)*#%(2*)'&)&#'*)#())1)1<#H(/#?3'($%$/#+9#5+()/#%&#+:$%5'4<#

F,)#5+*)#5%(%(8#+9#8+41#9+*#3&)&#+$,)*#$,'(#5+()/6#&32,#'&#>)7)4*/6#

%&#:)*9)2$4/#9%()6#03$#5+*)#8+41#'&#5+()/#%&#(+$#())1)1<#Q+#7,%4)#'(#

%(2*)'&)# %(# $,)# $+$'4# &3::4/# +9# 2'$$4)# +*# $)'# +*# 4':$+:&# %&# 1)9%(%$)4/#

0)()9%2%'4# 9+*# &+2%)$/6# '(# %(2*)'&)# %(# 5+()/# +(4/# 1%43$)&# %$&# .'43)m#

:)+:4)#2'(G$#2+(&35)#5+*)#8++1&#'(1#&)*.%2)&#>3&$#0)2'3&)#$,)*)#%&#

5+*)#5+()/#94+'$%(8#'*+3(1<#F+#:3$#%$#&%5:4%&$%2'44/Z#C9#7)#5'8%2'44/#

1+304)1#$,)#&3::4/#+9#2'*&6# $7%2)#'&#5'(/#:)+:4)#7+341#0)#'04)#$+#

1*%.)<# P3$# %9# 7)# 5'8%2'44/# 1+304)1# $,)# &3::4/# +9# 5+()/6# '44# $,'$#

7+341# ,'::)(# %&# :*%2)&# 7+341# 1+304)# d+(# '.)*'8)e<# [)+:4)# 5%8,$#

9))4#*%2,)*#9+*#'#4%$$4)#7,%4)6#03$#$,)/#7+341#*)'4%@)#%$#7'&#'(#%443&%+(#

+(2)#$,)/#&'7#:*%2)&#&+'*<#

H# 4'*8)# %(2*)'&)# %(# $,)# 5+()/# &3::4/R:'*$%234'*4/# 7,)(#

+223**%(8#%(#+3*#5+1)*(#9%('(2%'4#&/&$)5R2'3&)&#1%&$+*$%+(&#$+#$,)#

)($%*)# )2+(+5/# .(0$'(0# 1*%.%(8# 3:# :*%2)&<# =)# 7%44# );:4'%(# $,%&#

:*+2)&&#%(#8*)'$)*#1)$'%4#4'$)*#%(#$,)#0++-<#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_a#

#

Legalized Increases of Money #

F+#:3$# $,)&)#:+%($&# %($+#:)*&:)2$%.)6# %5'8%()#'# 9*))#5'*-)$#

)2+(+5/#7,)*)#8+41#%&#$,)#5+()/<#C(#&32,#'#&+2%)$/#+()#2'(#'2?3%*)#

$,)#8+41# %(#+()#+9#+(4/#$,*))#7'/&R3$-$-:7"&+%'$-:7#+*#'&#'#:$#&<# C(#

)'2,#+()#+9#$,)&)#5)$,+1&#+9#'2?3%*%(8#8+416#$,)#:*%(2%:4)#+9#:*%.'$)#

:*+:)*$/# %&# &$*%2$4/# ,+(+*)1<# W+7).)*6# 4)$G&# &3::+&)# '(# %(1%.%13'4#

1)2%1)&#$+#$'-)#'1.'($'8)#+9#8+41G&#5,3,:(-,10#9)'$3*)#'(1#2*)'$)&#

'(#)(+*5+3&#'5+3($#+9#2+3($)*9)%$#8+41#2+%(&#9+*#,%5&)49<#d[)*,':&#

,)#$'-)&#2+%(&#+9#'#0'&)*#5)$'4#'(1#2+'$&#$,)5#7%$,#8+41<e#F,%&#'2$#

7%44# 2*)'$)# '# :)*5'()($# 1)&$*32$%.)# *%::4%(8# )99)2$# $,*+38,+3$#

&+2%)$/S# C(# '11%$%+(# $+# %$&# 9*'3134)($# 5)$,+1# +9# '2?3%*%(8# $,)# 8+41#

d2+3($)*9)%$%(8e6#%$#3(1)*5%()&#$,)#9+3(1'$%+(&#+9#:*%.'$)#:*+:)*$/<#

F,)#2+3($)*9)%$)*#7%44#'4&+#%(2*)'&)#$,)#5+()/#&3::4/#&30&$'($%'44/#

7,)(#,)#&:)(1&#$,)#5+()/#%(#$,)#5'*-)$:4'2)<#

=%$,#5+*)#5+()/#%(#&3::4/#0)2'3&)#+9#$,)#2+3($)*9)%$%(86#%$&#

.'43)#7%44#()2)&&'*%4/#1)2*)'&)# $,)*)0/#5'-%(8#8++1&#'(1#&)*.%2)&#

2+&$# 5+*)<# F,%&6# +9# 2+3*&)6# %&# :*%2)# %(94'$%+(<# C$# %&# .)*/# 1)&$*32$%.)#

0)2'3&)# %$# %5:+.)*%&,)&# $,)# 7,+4)# +9# &+2%)$/6# );2):$# 9+*# $,)#

2+3($)*9)%$)*<#F,)#2+3($)*9)%$)*#0)()9%$&#%55)1%'$)4/#0/#8)$$%(8#$,)#

5+()/#9%*&$6#'&#+::+&)1#$+#$,)#4'$)*#*)2%:%)($&#+9#$,)#5+()/6#+*#$,+&)#

7,+#().)*#8)$#$,)#()7#5+()/#'$#'44<#V&3'44/#$,%&#$3*(&#+3$#$+#0)#$,)#

'.)*'8)# ,'*1# 7+*-%(8# 2%$%@)(<# F,)&)# 8++1# :)+:4)# 7%(1# 3:# :'/%(8#

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_Y#

1)'*4/<# F,)/# '*)# 4)9$# $+# 1)'4# 7%$,# $,)# %(2*)'&)1# :*%2)&# +(# '44# $,)#

8++1&# %(# $,)#5'*-)$#:4'2)<#O+*# $,)5#$,)#2+&$#+9# 4%.%(8#&%5:4/#*%&)&#

/)'*# '9$)*# /)'*6# '(1# (+# +()# 2'(# :*+.%1)# '(# );:4'('$%+(<# F,)/# '*)#

$+$'44/# 3('7'*)# +9# $,)# 2+3($)*9)%$)*<# O+*# $,%&# *)'&+(6# H3&$*%'(#

)2+(+5%&$&#,'.)#'47'/&#&'%1#$,'$#$,)#%(94'$%+(#:*+2)&&#d$,)#%(2*)'&)#

+9# $,)# 5+()/# &3::4/e6# %&# '# 9+*5# +9# %(1%*)2$# +*# G$-;$0$.*(" &%R9# +(#

&+2%)$/<#

O+*$3('$)4/6# :*%.'$)# 2+3($)*9)%$%(8# ,'&# *)'44/# ().)*# 0))(#

532,# +9# '# :*+04)5# %(# 5+1)*(# $%5)&<# b+3($)*9)%$%(8# 2'**%)&# &$%99#

:)('4$%)&#9+*#'(/+()#7,+#'$$)5:$&#%$<#W+7).)*6#7,)(#2+3($)*9)%$%(8#

%&#5'(1'$)1#0/#8+.)*(5)($6#7,)(#%$#%&#4)8'4%@)16#7)#,'.)#'#&)*%+3&#

)2+(+5%2# '(1# 5+*'4# :*+04)5# 9+*# '44# +9# &+2%)$/<# W%&$+*%2'44/6# $,)*)#

,'.)# 0))(# $7+# 5'>+*# -%(1&# +9# 8+.)*(5)($`&'(2$%+()1#

2+3($)*9)%$%(8Z# d"e# 8+.)*(5)($# :':)*# 5+()/# '(1# dDe# 9*'2$%+('4#

*)&)*.)#0'(-%(8<#F,)&)# $7+# 9+*5&#+9#5+()/# 2*)'$%+(#'*)#:*)2%&)4/#

7,'$#7)#,'.)# $+1'/6#(+$#+(4/# %(#+3*#V(%$)1#Q$'$)&6#03$#7+*417%1)<#

=)#*)2'44#P'&$%'$G&#?3+$'$%+(Z#

#F,)*)# %&# %(#'44# +9#3&#'# &$*+(8#1%&:+&%$%+(# $+#0)4%).)# $,'$#

'(/$,%(8# 4'7934# %&# '4&+# 4)8%$%5'$)<# F,%&# 0)4%)9# %&# &+# 7%1)&:*)'1#

$,'$# 5'(/# :)*&+(&# ,'.)# )**+()+3&4/# ,)41# $,'$# $,%(8&# '*)# K>3&$M#

0)2'3&)# 4'7# 5'-)&# $,)5# &+<# F,3&6# %(# +*1)*# $+# 5'-)# :43(1)*#

'::)'*#>3&$#'(1#&'2*)1#$+#5'(/#2+(&2%)(2)&6#%$#%&#+(4/#()2)&&'*/#

9+*#$,)#4'7#$+#1)2*))#'(1#&'(2$%+(#%$<a#

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

"_h#

#

#########################################################1 Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Modern Money Mechanics: A Workbook on Bank Reserves and Deposit Expansion (1994), p. 1. Available at: http://www.rayservers.com/images/ModernMoneyMechanics.pdf. Accessed June 3, 2010. 2 G. Edward Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island (Westlake Village, CA: American Media, 2002), p. 315. 3 G. Edward Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island, pp. 317-318. 4 Quoted in Griffin, p. 323. 5 Quoted in Griffin, p. 329. 6 Frederic Bastiat, The Law (1850), available at: http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html. Accessed June 3, 2010.

!"#$

Chapter 6$

Deposit Banking

The actual process of money

creation takes place primarily in

banks….[B]anks can build up

deposits by increasing loans and

investments...This unique attribute of

the banking business was discovered

many centuries ago. It started with

goldsmiths.

%!"#"$%&'(")"$*"'+%,-'./'0123%4.5''

'

he major control [of changes in the quantity of

money] rests with the central bank. The actual

process of money creation takes place primarily in banks.”2 This

statement, made in a 1994 Federal Reserve publication, can be

immensely helpful in dealing with one of the more difficult hurdles in

this intellectual debate. This hurdle has to do with the fact that some of

us reading this book are in the banking profession, or have friends and

family who are bankers. If this happens to be the case, there will be a

natural rising of our defenses not only to protect ourselves, but those

close to us that make an honest living being bankers. This is quite

understandable. Nearly everybody can appreciate this reaction regardless

“T'

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!"$

of his or her own profession. And most of us do have friends who are

bankers. We are also all aware of the criticism many times expressed

toward the legal professional, the medical doctor, the accountant, broker,

minister. No one is immune. Nevertheless, the main thing about this

statement made by the Federal Reserve is that it allows all of us,

regardless of profession or personal views, to confront the undeniable

fact it states: In our current financial system, money is ultimately created

and controlled by the Federal Reserve. It is a seat of power, set apart

from all other powers in society. It creates and controls what we use as

money, utilizing a system involving thousands of our commercial banks,

making this system unique.

However, what we must continually keep in mind is that banking

is a very old profession dating back centuries. Even the system we speak

of, the Federal Reserve System, was established almost 100 years ago.

All modern-day bankers, in fact, all citizens have been born into this

present system. Indeed, many bank professionals have probably never

even heard the type of analysis we present in this book. So we certainly

are not implying that the rank and file bank employee is consciously

participating in a sinister plot to defraud the general public.

At the same time, we must not be naïve. As we demonstrate in

this book, the present financial system allows commercial banks to

literally create money out of thin air, for the benefit of their owners and

their major customers. This system did not fall out of the sky. It was

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!!$

shaped and at times literally designed by the very people who stood to

profit from its creation.

The point of the present book is not to level accusations against

particular individuals. We are instead trying to alert the American public

to the fact that our current monetary and banking system rests on sand

(or more accurately, on paper). The primary purpose for studying the

path by which we arrived, is to demonstrate that it doesn’t have to be

this way. Modern Americans—including the vast majority of those who

currently work in the banking sector—have little reason to suspect that

life would be possible without a central bank exercising complete

dominance over the nation’s money. For many people, the key to this

realization is learning that powerful groups benefited from morphing our

system into its present form, a form that would be unrecognizable to

Americans from the early days of the Republic.

The Mystery of Banking

The Federal Reserve and its banking system have always been

shrouded in mystery. In order to better understand this mystery it will

serve us well to continue to use a publication from the Federal Reserve

as our guide, in addition to Murray Rothbard’s historical account from

his book The Mystery of Banking.

We will begin our study with the following three selections from

a 1994 publication distributed by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago:

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!&$

Money is such a routine part of everyday living that its existence and

acceptance ordinarily are taken for granted. A user may sense that

money must come into being either automatically as a result of

economic activity or as an outgrowth of some government operation.

But just how this happens all too often remains a mystery. … The major control [of changes in the quantity of money] rests with

the central bank. The actual process of money creation takes place

primarily in banks….[B]anks can build up deposits by increasing

loans and investments...This unique attribute of the banking business

was discovered many centuries ago. It started with goldsmiths.

… [B]ankers discovered that they could make loans merely by giving

their promises to pay, or bank notes, to borrowers. In this way, banks

began to create money. More notes could be issued than the gold and

coin on hand because only a portion of the notes outstanding would

be presented for payment at any one time….Transaction deposits are

the modern counterpart of bank notes. It was a small step from

printing notes to making book entries crediting deposits of

borrowers, which the borrowers in turn could “spend” by writing

checks, thereby “printing” their own money.3

We can all benefit by first acknowledging that the concept of

banking can be confusing. For example, one view of a bank is simply as

an institution that makes loans. By studying historical records we learn

that the earliest bankers were merchants who extended credit to their

customers and charged a fee for the delay of payment. This fee or

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!'$

interest was the price on time. This type of lending became a good

business practice where transactions of this sort multiplied and were

conducted outside in the market place with the merchants and their

customers “sitting” on bankas—the Italian word for benches, or banks.

One family in particular, in the 14th century, the Medici family, became

so successful at this type of business that they are regarded as the first

institutionalized bankers. But for our purposes, the important point is

that this type of banking was non-inflationary. In other words, the

business did not counterfeit or increase the money supply. It was simply

a legal and very profitable lending business.

Most people think of banks or bankers as businesspeople who

borrow money from one set of people and lend that money to another

group. These bankers charge an interest differential, or at least this is the

perception. This form of lending is known as loan banking. For our

purposes, the important distinction about loan banking is that it is non-

inflationary.

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!($

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

)*+,+$ -./$ *01+2+,/$ 3405*+,$ 567+$ 08$ 934:$ 5*35$ *3.$ 40$

;044+;5-04$1-5*$ <034$ 934:-4=$ 3.$ >?.5$ @+.;,-9+@A$ )*-.$ 567+$ 08$ 934:$

;3B+$ 390?5$ 9+;3?.+$ -5$ *3@$ 3$ 7,3;5-;3<$ ;044+;5-04$ 50$ B04+6/$ ,.7$

934:-4=A$ C5$ -.$ 5*-.$ 567+$ 08$ 934:$ 5*35$ 1+$ 4++@$ 50$ -42+.5-=35+$ B0,+$

;3,+8?<<6A$

)0$9+=-4$1-5*/$=0<@$;0-4.$34@$9?<<-04$3,+$*+326$50$<?=$3,0?4@/$

34@$ 5*+6$ ;34$ 9+$ <0.5$ 0,$ .50<+4A$ D0,$ 5*-.$ ,+3.04$ 7+07<+$ 9+=34$ 50$

@+70.-5$5*+-,$=0<@$34@$05*+,$23<?39<+$-5+B.$-450$13,+*0?.+.$80,$.38+$

:++7-4=A$ )*+.+$ B04+6$ 13,+*0?.+.$ ;3B+$ 50$ 9+$ :4014$ 3.$ #"8.)27'

9%,-)$ 34@$ 1+,+$ ?.?3<<6$ 07+,35+@$ 96$ =0<@.B-5*.A$ C4$ B0.5$ .50,3=+$

13,+*0?.+.$ 5*+$ @+70.-50,/$1*+4$ *+$ @+70.-5+@$ *-.$ =0<@/$ ,+;+-2+@$ 3$

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!E$

737+,$#"8.)27' 723-"7$0,$;0?704A$)*+$5-;:+5$*0<@+,$;0?<@$@+B34@$5*+$

,+5?,4$ 08$ *-.$ =0<@$ ?704$ 7,+.+4535-04$ 08$ 5*+$ 5-;:+5$ 34@$ 10?<@$ 9+$

;*3,=+@$3$)7.$%4"'/""$80,$5*+$.+,2-;+.$7,02-@+@A$$

$

$

$

F-4;+$5*+.+$1+,+$3;5?3<<6$.50,3=+$83;-<-5-+.$5*+6$10?<@$9+$40$

@-88+,+45$ 8,0B$ 3$ .50,3=+$ 83;-<-56$ -4$ 0?,$ @36$ 34@$ 5-B+A$ G*+4$

@+70.-5-4=$0,$.50,-4=$34$-5+B/$.?;*$3.$34$345-H?+$;*3-,/$34$*+-,<00B$

,?=/$ 3$ 73-45-4=/$ 0,$ 346$ 4?B9+,$ 08$ -5+B.$ -4$ 3$ .50,3=+$ 83;-<-56/$ 5*+$

@+70.-50,$ 3<136.$ ,+;+-2+.$ 3$ @+70.-5$ ,+;+-75/$ 3$ ;<3-B$ 5-;:+5$ 50$ 5*+$

-5+B$ *+$ *3.$ -4$ .50,3=+A$ $ )*+$ 70-45$ -.$ 5*35$ 5*+$ @+70.-50,$ -.$ .50,-4=$

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!I$

5*+.+$ -5+B.$ 80,$ .38+:++7-4=A$ )*+6$ 3,+$ 405$ 9+-4=$ J<+45K$ 50$ 5*+$

13,+*0?.+B34A$C4$05*+,$10,@./$-5$10?<@$9+$-4;0,,+;5$50$.36$5*35$5*+$

13,+*0?.+B34$13.$3$J@+950,K$08$5*+$@+70.-50,$0,$5*35$5*+$@+70.-50,$

13.$3$J;,+@-50,K$08$5*+$13,+*0?.+B34A$C8$ 5*+$+L3;5$345-H?+$;*3-,$ -.$

405$,+5?,4+@$?704$7,+.+4535-04$08$5*+$.50,3=+$5-;:+5/$ 5*+$@+70.-50,$

*3.$ +2+,6$ ,-=*5$ 50$ 3;;?.+$ 5*+$ 13,+*0?.+B34$ 08$ 5*+85A$$ )*35$ -.$

9+;3?.+$7<3;-4=$=00@.$-4$3$.50,3=+$83;-<-56$0,$.0B+5*-4=$.-B-<3,$50$3$

.38+56$@+70.-5$90L$-.$405$3$#"97' 3.,7$%37$9+51++4$5*+$@+70.-50,$34@$

5*+$.50,3=+$83;-<-56A$C5$-.$-4$83;5$3$9%2&:",7'3.,7$%37;'

M01+2+,/$ .0B+$ -5+B.$ 7<3;+@$ -4$ .50,3=+$ 3,+$ 08$ 3$ .7+;-3<$

435?,+A$ )*+6$ 3,+$ *0B0=+40?.$ 0,$ /<,429&";$ )*-.$ B+34.$ 5*35$ 60?$

;34405$5+<<$5*+.+$-5+B.$373,5A$N4+$.?;*$+L3B7<+$10?<@$9+$=,3-4$-4$3$

=,3-4$+<+2350,A$O?5/$5*+,+$-.$34$-5+B$5*35$-.$+2+4$B0,+$8?4=-9<+$5*34$

=,3-4$ 34@$ 5*35$ -5+B$ -.$ B04+6A$ P<<$ B04+6/$ 1*+5*+,$ -5$ -.$ =0<@$ 0,$

=02+,4B+45$ 737+,$ B04+6/$ <00:.$ 5*+$ .3B+A$ Q,3-4$ -.$ ?.+@$ 50$ B3:+$

.0B+5*-4=$+@-9<+/$34@$3<5*0?=*$-5$B36$9+$8?4=-9<+$80,$3$9,-+8$7+,-0@/$

+2+45?3<<6$ 5*+$ J0<@K$ =,3-4$ 4++@.$ 50$ 9+$ ,+B02+@$ 8,0B$ 5*+$ .50,3=+$

83;-<-56A$ R04+6/$ 04$ 5*+$ 05*+,$ *34@/$ @0+.$ 405$ *32+$ 50$ 9+$ ,+B02+@$

8,0B$5*+$13,+*0?.+$35$3<<$9+;3?.+$-5$1-<<$4+2+,$+L7-,+$0,$7+,-.*A$)*-.$

+<+B+45$08$B04+6S.$*0B0=+40?.$435?,+$+2+45?3<<6$07+4+@$5*+$@00,$

80,$+B9+TT<+B+45$34@$9+80,+$<04=$5*+$5+B7535-04$9+;3B+$500$B?;*$

50$,+.-.5A$

N2+,$ 5-B+/$ 5*-.$ 5+B7535-04$ +2+45?3<<6$ 5?,4+@$ -450$ 5*+$

;0?45+,8+-5-4=$ 08$ 13,+*0?.+$ ,+;+-75.$ 1*+4$ -5$ 13.$ ,+3<-T+@$ 5*35$

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!U$

@+70.-50,.$1+,+$ 5,3@-4=$ 5*+$13,+*0?.+$ ,+;+-75.$ 3.$B04+6A$ V35*+,$

5*34$ @+B34@-4=$ 5*+$ =0<@$ 93;:$ +3;*$ 5-B+$ 5*+6$ 1345+@$ 50$ B3:+$ 3$

7?,;*3.+/$ @+70.-50,.$ .-B7<6$ .-=4+@$ 02+,$ 5*+$ 13,+*0?.+$ ,+;+-75.A$

)*-.$B+345$5*35$5*+$+3,<6$@+70.-5$934:+,.%5*0.+$1*0$1+,+$.50,-4=$

=0<@$3.$3$.+,2-;+$50$5*+-,$;?.50B+,.%3<136.$*+<@$3$;+,53-4$3B0?45$

08$?4,+@++B+@$B04+6$ -4$ 5*+-,$ 23?<5.A$ C4$05*+,$10,@./$ 5*+,+$13.$3$

B3,=-4$50$7<36$1-5*$34@$7,08-5/$50$9+$B3@+$96$?.-4=$.0B+04+$+<.+S.$

B04+6A$P.$5*+$D+@+,3<$V+.+,2+$O34:$08$W*-;3=0$7?5.$-5X$

$YOZ34:+,.$ @-.;02+,+@$ 5*35$ 5*+6$ ;0?<@$ B3:+$ <034.$ B+,+<6$ 96$

=-2-4=$5*+-,$7,0B-.+.$50$736/$0,$934:$405+./$50$90,,01+,.A$C4$5*-.$

136/$ 934:.$9+=34$ 50$ ;,+35+$B04+6A$R0,+$405+.$ ;0?<@$9+$ -..?+@$

5*34$ 5*+$ =0<@$ 34@$ ;0-4$ 04$ *34@$ 9+;3?.+$ 04<6$ 3$ 70,5-04$ 08$ 5*+$

405+.$ 0?5.534@-4=$10?<@$ 9+$ 7,+.+45+@$ 80,$ 736B+45$ 35$ 346$ 04+$

5-B+[$

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!\$

'

'

$

$

C4$V05*93,@S.$2-+1$].*3,+@$96$B346/$5*0?=*$405$3<</$B0@+,4$

P?.5,-34$ +;040B-.5.^/$ *04+.5$ 13,+*0?.-4=$ -.$ @+8-4+@$ 96$ 3$

13,+*0?.+$ ,+;+-75$ 80,$ +2+,6$ @+70.-5+@$ -5+BA$ )*-.$ 10?<@$ 9+$ 5==>'

$")"$*"' ?%$"1.<)2,4;'N4$ 5*+$05*+,$*34@/$ -8$ 3$13,+*0?.+B34$ -..?+.$

83:+$ 13,+*0?.+$ ,+;+-75.$ 34@$ 5*+$ =0<@$ .50,+@$ -4$ 5*+$ 13,+*0?.+$ -.$

04<6$ 3$ 8,3;5-04$ ]0,$ .0B+5*-4=$ <+..$ 5*34$ !""_$ 08$ 5*+$ ,+;+-75.$

;-,;?<35-4=^$5*+4$*+$;0?<@$9+$.3-@$50$9+$+4=3=+@$-4$/$%372.,%&'$")"$*"'

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!!#$

?%$"1.<)2,4'1*-;*$V05*93,@$ ,+3.04+@$13.$ .-B7<6$ 3$ .07*-.5-;35+@$

80,B$08$8,3?@A$

$

$

$

)*-.$80,B$08$+B9+TT<+B+45$-.$*-=*<6$-48<35-043,6$34@$B0,3<<6$

1,04=A$ C5$ 2-;5-B-T+.$ 3<<$ 7,-235+$ 7,07+,56$ 014+,.$ 34@$ -.$ 3$ 5+,,-9<+$

;,-B+$ 50$ .0;-+56A$`+5/$ 5*+.+$3,+$ 5*+$ 5,?+$0,-=-4.$08$@+70.-5$934:-4=$

34@$ 8,3;5-043<$ ,+.+,2+$ 934:-4=$ 3.$ 1+$ *32+$ 5*+B$ -4$ 0?,$ B0@+,4$

5-B+.A$N2+,$5*+$;+45?,-+.$5*+$13,+*0?.+$,+;+-75$9+;3B+$:4014$3.$3$

J934:$ 405+AK$ R?;*$ <35+,/$ @+70.-5.$ ;3B+$ 50$ 9+$ :4014$ 3.$ J@+B34@$

@+70.-5.AK$ P$ 5,34.8+,$ 0,@+,$ ;0?<@$ 9+$ 1,-55+4$ 8,0B$ 5*+$ @+B34@$

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!&"$

@+70.-5$ 50$3405*+,$934:A$)*-.$ 5,34.8+,$0,@+,$9+;3B+$:4014$3.$ 5*+$

J;*+;:AK$ )*+4/$ 08$ ;0?,.+/$ 5*+$ J@+B34@$ @+70.-5K$ 9+;3B+$ 5*+$

J;*+;:-4=$3;;0?45AK$G+$5?,4$04;+$3=3-4$50$5*+$D+@$-5.+<8X'

'

Transaction deposits are the modern counterpart of bank notes. It was

a small step from printing notes to making book entries crediting

deposits of borrowers, which the borrowers in turn could “spend” by

writing checks, thereby “printing” their own money.

It would take many years of building a reputation of integrity

before a practice of counterfeiting warehouse receipts could actually be

done without being detected. Once the crime of counterfeiting has begun

there is the worry of being caught. The warehouseman could obviously

be accused of embezzlement and sent to jail. To prevent this from

happening it would be of utmost importance to hire attorneys and

financial experts to convince the courts that what the warehouseman was

doing was not a crime, but merely entrepreneurial activities. To make

this argument palatable, the courts would have to be convinced that the

deposits into the warehouse were not bailment contracts, but are actually

debt contracts.

At the time deposit banking was developing, bailment law had

not developed sufficiently to overcome the growth of deposit banking.

The British courts ruled in favor of deposit banking defining the money

deposit as a debt contract. These decisions were approved by American

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!&!$

courts and were ultimately adopted as law. In 1848 the House of Lords

ruled in the case of Foley v. Hill and Others:

The money placed in the custody of a banker is, to all intents and

purposes, the money of the banker, to do with as he pleases; he is

guilty of no breach of trust in employing it; he is not answerable to

the principal if he puts it into jeopardy, if he engages in hazardous

speculation; he is not bound to keep it or deal with it as the property

of his principal; but he is, of course, answerable for the amount,

because he has contracted.4

This decision that we have to this day in the United States

completely overlooks the fact that in the case of a “bank run” where all

depositors demanded their money all at once, the banker could not

possibly live up to his contract. Furthermore, it also authorizes a banking

system structured on deceiving the public.

The Central Bank

In order to go a step further and obtain a full grasp of what we

have explained thus far, the reader must imagine being in the deposit

banking business. First of all, suppose you have been in business many

years in the community conducting an honest 100% reserve warehouse

business where all property was promptly returned to customers upon

presentation of their warehouse receipts. You have one million dollars in

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!&&$

gold on deposit in the warehouse, but now decide you are going to make

a killing in this business and counterfeit five million dollars more in

warehouse receipts. You will then have five times more in warehouse

receipts than gold on deposit. As long as these warehouse receipts (bank

notes) trade as gold among your loyal clientele you are safe and will

make a lot of money.

But what if all of your customers decided to demand their gold

all at the same time, in effect a run on your bank? This event would not

only expose your fraud, but would be unstoppable. It would certainly

bankrupt you, law or no law!

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!&'$

Apart from the bank run, there is another powerful limit on your

counterfeiting scheme. What if one of your customers passed one of

your fake (i.e. non-backed) receipts to a non-bank customer, who in turn

presented it to another competing bank for redemption? The competing

bank would then present the ticket to you in the course of normal inter-

bank clearing operations. Consequently, redemption is a real problem

especially if that one fake warehouse receipt happens to be a two million

dollar receipt. Once again, your chicanery would have led to your ruin.

Only one force can overcome this limit…an agreement!

Developing an agreement with one or two competing banks whereby

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!&($

counterfeiting could be done together would be relatively easy to

accomplish. But in a society with thousands of banks it would not be

possible. To accomplish that feat, a central bank is needed.

Historically, the central bank has always had two major roles: (1)

To help finance the government’s deficits, and (2) to form an alliance of

the private banks in a society in order to remove the two great market

limits of the bank run and redemption.

A significant fact is that the original central bank, the Bank of

England in the late 17th century, began as a crooked deal between a near

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'

'

!&E$

bankrupt government and a corrupt group of financial promoters. Not

surprising since governments are always broke and short of money!

Over the centuries, other large nations eventually copied this

institution from England. Our United States was the last major nation to

establish a permanent central bank, adopting the Federal Reserve System

in 1913, which was explicitly modeled on the central banks that had

developed overseas. Our money and our society have never been the

same.

$

$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Modern Money Mechanics: A Workbook on Bank Reserves and Deposit Expansion (1994), p. 3. Available at: http://www.rayservers.com/images/ModernMoneyMechanics.pdf. Accessed June 3, 2010. 2 Modern Money Mechanics, p. 3. 3 Modern Money Mechanics, pp. 1 and 3. 4 Murray Rothbard, The Case Against the Fed (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1994), p. 42.

!"#$%&'()*+,&+-(!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#$

$

!"#$

!"#$%&'()(

*+,-#%./+(

!

!

"#$!%&'(!)*+,-./*&+0!&'*1*+.--2!.33-*$(!

4&-$-2! /&! /#$! 56.+/*/2! &,! 7&+$28! 9/!

7$.+/! /#./! /#$! :&-67$! &,! 7&+$2! %.4!

%&'()*+,;! <-&%+! 63;! &:$'$=/$+($(8! 9/! *4!

+&/! 7$'$! 3$(.+/'2! /&! *+4*4/! /#./! /#$!

%&'(! 4#&6-(! <$! 64$(! &+-2! *+! */4!

&'*1*+.-!7$.+*+18!"&!64$!*/!/&!7$.+!).!

'*4$! *+! 3'*>$40! *4! /&! ($,-$>/! .//$+/*&+!

.%.2! ,'&7! /#$! '$.-! >.64$! &,! *+,-./*&+!

.+(!/#$!'$.-!>6'$!,&'!*/$

-?$+'2!?.@-*//A!

!

!

.)*$ %/$ %&'()*%0&1$ 2.%/$ 304,5$ %'$ 4%6.*(7$ 8&,+4/*00,5$

308(,$.+(9$ (%'*$ *.+$:+%($ '40;$ *.+$+7+/$0'$;%((%0&/$ /0$

*.)*$ *.+$ .%,,+&$ 9)4*/$ 0'$ *.+$ ;0&+7$ )&,$ <)&=%&6$ 940<(+;$ >08(,$

'%&)((7$<+$4+:+)(+,?$2.%/$;)7$/08&,$ (%=+$)&$+@)66+4)*%0&A$.03+:+45$

&0*.%&6$ +(/+$ %&$ *.%/$ <00=$ >08(,$ <+$ /)%,$ 3%*.$ ;04+$ *48*.$ *.)&$ *.%/?$$

B&03%&6$*.+$*48+$,+'%&%*%0&$0'$*.%/$*+4;$)&,$.03$%*$>0;+/$)<08*$%&$

084$ +>0&0;7$ %/$ >48>%)($ *0$ 084$ 8&,+4/*)&,%&6$ 0'$ 084$ ;0&+7$

940<(+;/?$2.%/$ %/$ *.+$+&,$3.%>.$3+$.):+$<++&$;0:%&6$*03)4,$)&,$

C$

"#$%&'()#!BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB!

!

!"D$

0&+$0'$*.+$94%&>%9)($60)(/$0'$*.%/$<00=?$E%/8&,+4/*)&,%&6$*.%/$304,5$

04$;+4+(7$)//8;%&6$ *.)*$ %*$;+)&/$4%/%&6$94%>+/5$3%(($=++9$8/$ %&$ *.+$

,)4=?$$

C+$;8/*$ )(/0$ ),;%*$ *.)*$ %&'()*%0&$ %/$&0*$ )&$ +)/7$ >0&>+9*$ *0$

8&,+4/*)&,?$F&+$0'$*.+$;0/*$');08/$+>0&0;%/*/$0'$*.+$"G*.$>+&*8475$

H0.&$E)7&)4,$B+7&+/5$/*)*+,$*.)*$0&(7$I0&+$;)&$%&$)$;%((%0&J$>08(,$

64)/9$ *.+$940>+//?$F<:%08/(75$ *.+4+$ %/$;8>.$;04+$ *0$ %&'()*%0&$ *.)&$

3.)*$'%4/*$;++*/$*.+$+7+?$K*$ %/$*0$*.%/$8&,+4/*)&,%&6$*.)*$3+$,+:0*+$

*.%/$>.)9*+45$<+'04+$940>++,%&6$*0$ '4)>*%0&)($4+/+4:+$<)&=%&6$%&$*.+$

&+@*$)&,$'%&)($>.)9*+4$*0$*.%/$/+>*%0&?$

20$ <+6%&5$ H0.&$ L,);M/$ ');08/$ N80*+$ 3%(($ 940:%,+$ *.+$ <)/%/$

'04$084$%&%*%)($/*+9/$0'$,%/>0:+47O$)C--!/#$!3$'3-$=*/*$4;!>&+,64*&+!.+(!

(*4/'$44!*+!C7$'*>.!.'*4$!,'&7!/#$!(&%+'*1#/!*1+&'.+>$!&,!/#$!+./6'$!

&,!>&*+;!>'$(*/!.+(!>*'>6-./*&+80!

E)&7$0'$8/$)4+$');%(%)4$3%*.$*.%/$N80*+5$<8*$'04$084$98490/+/$

.+4+$%*$%/$>+4*)%&(7$304*.$+@);%&%&6$0&>+$;04+?$2.086.$L,);/$8/+/$

.)4/.$)&,$>4%*%>)($ ()&68)6+5$.+$90%&*/$*0$*.+$*.4++$*.%&6/$3.%>.$3+$

/.08(,$ )(($ 8&,+4/*)&,$ 8&+N8%:0>)((7O$ 7&+$2;! >'$(*/! .+(! #&%! */!

>*'>6-./$4!*+!&6'!$>&+&728$!

C+$/.08(,$9)7$9)4*%>8()4$)**+&*%0&$ *0$.%/$;+&*%0&%&6$0'$ *.+$

)3$'3-$=*/*$4;! >&+,64*&+! .+(! (*4/'$440$ <+>)8/+$ >0&/%,+4%&6$ *.)*$ *.%/$

/*)*+;+&*$3)/$;),+$ %&$!D"P5$3+$ /.08(,$<+$ )<(+$ *0$ +)/%(7$ /++$ *.)*$

*.+4+$%/$&0*.%&6$&+3$8&,+4$*.+$/8&?$2.+/+$/++;$*0$<+$*.+$%,+&*%>)($

+;0*%0&/$ 3+$ )4+$ ,+)(%&6$ 3%*.$ *0,)7?$ 2.)*$ %/$ <+>)8/+$ %&'()*%0&$ .)/$


!

!"P$

<++&$ 9()68%&6$ *.+$ .8;)&$ 4)>+$ '04$ )$ (0&6$ *%;+?$ Q:+47$ *%;+$ %*$ %/$

;7/*+4%08/(7$/+*$%&$;0*%0&5$%*$>4+)*+/$,%/*4+//$);0&6$*.+$9+09(+?$C+$

>08(,$ *4):+($ <)>=$ %&$ *%;+$ '%:+$ .8&,4+,$ 7+)4/5$ )$ *.08/)&,$ 7+)4/$ 04$

+:+&$*30$*.08/)&,$7+)4/$)&,$/++$+:%,+&>+$0'$*.+$/);+$*.%&6?$Q:+47$

*%;+$3+$/++$%*$3+$)(/0$/++$*.+$,+/*48>*%0&$%*$>4+)*+/?$

R04$+@);9(+5$(+*$8/$%;)6%&+$*.+$64+)*$S0;)&$Q;9%4+?$K&$7084$

;%&,M/$+7+$/++$*.+$903+4'8($T)+/)4$/%**%&6$0&$)$*.40&+$0:+4(00=%&6$)$

/+)$ 0'$ *+&/$ 0'$ *.08/)&,$ 0'$ .+):%(7$ )4;+,$ S0;)&$ /0(,%+4/$ )(($

+N8%99+,$ 3%*.$ *.+$ '%&+/*$ 3+)90&47$ %&$ *.+$ 304(,?$ T)&$ 708$ '++($ *.+$

903+45$ 90;9$ )&,$ >+4+;0&7$ *.)*$ %;)6%&)47$ :%/8)($ >4+)*+/1$ K'$ 708$

>)&$9%>*84+$*.+$)4;7$>0&/%,+4$'04$)$;0;+&*$*.+$>0/*$*0$08*'%*$/8>.$)$

'+)4/0;+$)&,$903+4'8($;%(%*)47$'04>+?$K;)6%&+$.):%&6$*0$'++,5$>(0*.+$

)&,$)4;$/8>.$)&$)4;7$0'$;+&$)&,$.04/+/?$2.+$>0/*$308(,$.):+$<++&$

)/*40&0;%>)(?$

U03$ *.%&=$ 0'$ S0;+$ %*/+('5$ *.+$ /9(+&,04$ 0'$ S0;+5$ *.+$ ():%/.$

)4>.%*+>*84+5$ *.+$ 3)*+4$ )&,$ %44%6)*%0&$ /7/*+;/5$ *.+$ >0(%/+8;/A$ 3+$

.):+$ )(($ /++&$ 9%>*84+/$ 0'$ 3.)*$ S0;+$ ;8/*$ .):+$ (00=+,$ (%=+?$

V4+)*.*)=%&6$7+/5$<8*$&03$ *.%&=$0'$ *.+$>0/*$ *0$;)%&*)%&$)(($0'$ *.)*?$

C+$.):+$*0$30&,+45$IW03$,%,$T)+/)4$9)7$'04$ %*$)((1J$2.+$)&/3+4$%/$

*.)*$S0;+M/$903+4'8($)4;7$940:%,+,$;8>.$0'$*.+$;0&+7$4+N8%4+,$*0$

>0:+4$/8>.$)$.86+$>0/*?$2.+$S0;)&$Q;9%4+$)>*8)((7$/*0(+$;8>.$0'$%*/$

3+)(*.$ '40;$ %*/$ >0&N8+4+,$ *+44%*04%+/?$ K&$ ),,%*%0&$ *0$ *.%/5$ T)+/)4$

>0((+>*+,$/'*<6/$5$&0*$0&(7$'40;$*.+$:%>*%;/$0'$3)45$<8*$)(/0$'40;$.%/$

03&$>%*%X+&/?$2.+/+$ *)@+/$3+4+$.+):7?$24%<8*+5$)/$ %*$ *84&/$08*5$3)/$


!

!YG$

;04+$ 0'$ )$ 940*+>*%0&$ '++5$ *.)&$ )&$ )>*8)($ :0(8&*)47$ 9)7;+&*?$ 2.+$

*.4+)*$0'$'04>+$3)/$)(3)7/$8/+,$%&$04,+4$*0$>0((+>*$%*?$2.+4+$3)/$0&+$

0*.+4$*.%&6$*.)*$3+$/.08(,$;+&*%0&$)<08*$*.+$3+)(*.$0'$S0;+?$2.+4+$

3)/$&+:+4$+&086.$;0&+7?$T)+/)4$.),$)&$%&/)*%)<(+$)99+*%*+$)&,$&0$

);08&*$0'$;0&+7$308(,$/)*%/'7?$

279%>)((75$)*$*.+$+&,$0'$+)>.$7+)4M/$*)@$>0((+>*%0&$)&,$)'*+4$)(($

*.+$ 9(8&,+4$ '40;$ >0&N8+4+,$ *+44%*04%+/$ .),$ <++&$ <4086.*$ %&*0$

S0;+5$T)+/)4$308(,$4+)(%X+$*.)*$.+$/*%(($.),$)$(0*$;04+$+@9+&,%*84+/$

*.)&$ 60(,?$ C.)*$ %/$ T)+/)4$ *0$ ,01$ W+$ =&03/$ <+**+4$ *.)&$ *0$ )/=$ '04$

;04+$*)@$;0&+7?$K'$60:+4&;+&*$*)@+/$*.+$9+09(+$*00$;8>.5$)$4+:0(*$

%/$*.+$4+/8(*?$

K&/*+),5$T)+/)4$>0;+/$89$3%*.$)$>(+:+4$/>.+;+?$W+$04,+4/$.%/$

;%&%/*+4/$0'$*.+$*4+)/847$*0$>(%9$)(($0'$*.+$+,6+/$0'$*.+$60(,$>0%&/$%&$

.%/$90//+//%0&$)&,$3%*.$*.+$>(%99%&6/$;)=+/$;04+$60(,$>0%&/?$U03$

.+$.)/$;04+$60(,$>0%&/$)&,$.+$>)&$;++*$.%/$+@9+&,%*84+/?$K&$*)=%&6$

*.%/$ )>*%0&$ 3+$ /.08(,$ %;;+,%)*+(7$ &0*%>+$ *.)*$ T)+/)4$ .)/$ /+>4+*(7$

*);9+4+,$3%*.$*.+$:)(8+$0'$*.+$;0&+7?$W+$.)/$,+:)(8+,$*.+$;0&+7$

<7$ 4+,8>%&6$ *.+$ 3+%6.*$ 0'$ +)>.$ 60(,$ >0%&?$ L,,%*%0&)((75$ .+$ .)/$

%&>4+)/+,$ *.+$ ;0&+7$ /899(7$ Z;+)/84+,$ %&$ *+4;/$ 0'$ >0%&/[$ )&,$ .+$

3%(($<+$*.+$'%4/*$*0$<+&+'%*$'40;$*.%/$%&>4+)/+?$

\9$*0$*.%/$90%&*$*.+$4+),+4$;)7$<+$*.%&=%&6$*.%/$%/$)$')%47$*)(+$

)(*+4+,$/0(+(7$*0$<+$8/+,$)/$)&$+@);9(+?$ K*$ %/$)&$+@);9(+A$.03+:+45$

*.%/$ %/$ )(/0$ ,0>8;+&*+,$ .%/*047$ Z3%*.$ /0;+$ 0'$ *.+$ ,+*)%(/$ <+%&6$

/%;9(%'%+,$ '04$084$ +@90/%*%0&[?$ K*$ )>*8)((7$.)99+&+,?$ ]0$3+$&++,$ *0$


!

!Y!$

>0&*%&8+$3%*.$*.%/$/*047$*0$%*/$+&,$%&$04,+4$*0$/++$%*/$)99(%>)*%0&$*0$

084$+>0&0;7$%&$"G!G?$

]0$ &035$ T)+/)4$ %/$ )<(+$ *0$ 9)7$ '04$ )(($ 0'$ *.+$ 4+N8%4+,$

+@9+&,%*84+/$3%*.$*.+$%&>4+)/+,$;0&+7$/899(75$9(8/$9+4.)9/$)$'+3$

0*.+4$(8@84%+/$'04$.%;/+('?$K*$'0((03/$*.+&$*.)*$*.+$9+09(+$3)%*%&6$*0$

<+$9)%,$>)&$&03$<+$>0;9+&/)*+,$)&,$*.+$&+3$;0&+7$60+/$08*$%&*0$

*.+$+>0&0;7$0'$S0;+?$U03$(+*M/$/)7$708$)4+$)$S0;)&$;+4>.)&*$ %&$

S0;+M/$;)4=+*$ 9()>+$ )&,$ 708$ /+(($ '4+/.$ '%/.$ )*$ )$ 94%>+$ 0'$ 0&+$ 60(,$

>0%&$'04$)$'%/.?$L$S0;)&$T+&*84%0&5$3.0$.)/$^8/*$<++&$9)%,$<7$T)+/)4$

3%*.$0&+$0'$*.+/+$&+3$>0%&/5$;)=+/$)$984>.)/+$)*$7084$'%/.$;)4=+*?$

W+$9)7/$708$0&+$60(,$>0%&$'04$*.+$'%/.5$<8*$890&$>(0/+4$+@);%&)*%0&$

0'$*.+$>0%&5$708$%;;+,%)*+(7$4+)(%X+$*.)*$*.+4+$%/$/0;+*.%&6$,%''+4+&*$

)<08*$ %*?$_08$4+)>.$ %&*0$7084$03&$90>=+*$)&,$98(($08*$0&+$0'$7084$

>0%&/$)&,$>0;9)4+$ %*$ *0$.%/?$2.+4+$ %/$)$,%''+4+&>+`$2.+$&+@*$/*+9$ %&$

*.+$ *4)&/)>*%0&$ /.08(,$ <+$ 0<:%08/?$ $ _08$ N8%>=(7$ ,+;)&,$ *30$ 60(,$

>0%&/$'04$7084$'%/.?$K*$%/$*.+$0&(7$4%6.*$)&,$')%4$*.%&6$*0$,05$/%&>+$*.+$

&+3$>0%&/$.):+$)$(03+4$60(,$>0&*+&*?$V8*$708$>)&$)(/0$/++$.03$*.%/$

/);+$ *79+$ 0'$ *4)&/)>*%0&$ 3%(($ <+$ 4+9+)*+,$ >08&*(+//$ *%;+/$

*.4086.08*$ *.+$ +&*%4+$ S0;)&$ +>0&0;7$ 3%*.$ *.%/$ &+3$ ;0&+75$ )&,$

+)>.$*%;+5$94%>+/$3%(($<+$%&>4+)/+,$0&$)(($600,/$)&,$/+4:%>+/?$K*$3)/$

T)+/)4M/$ >08&*+4'+%*%&6$ *.)*$ >)8/+,$ *.+$ %&>4+)/+$<0*.$ %&$94%>+/$)&,$

%&$*.+$/899(7$0'$;0&+7?$2.)*$%/$*.+$;)%&$90%&*$*0$8&,+4/*)&,?$$

2.%/$ /*0475$ 8&'04*8&)*+(75$ ,0+/$ &0*$ +&,$ .+4+?$ L>*8)((75$ *.+$

'0((03%&6$7+)4$T)+/)4$%/$)6)%&$')>+,$3%*.$*.+$/);+$940<(+;?$2.+$(00*$


!

!Y"$

'40;$)(($>0&N8+4+,$()&,/$.)/$>0;+$%&$)&,$/0$.)/$*.+$*4%<8*+5$<8*$%*$%/$

&0*$+&086.$60(,$*0$9)7$'04$+:+47*.%&6?$T)+/)4$/*)4*/$*0$98(($*.+$/);+$

>(%99%&6$0'$ *.+$ >0%&/$ *4%>=$)6)%&5$<8*$.+$&0*%>+/$ *.)*$ *.+$60(,$ >0%&/$

.):+$&03$)(($<++&$&0*>.+,$3%*.$4%,6+/$)408&,$*.+$+,6+/?$2.+$9+09(+$

.):+$60**+&$3%/+$*0$*.+$*4%>=`$2.+7$.):+$98*$)$;)4=$0&$*.+$;0&+7$/0$

*.)*$)&7$&+3(7$>(%99+,$>0%&$>08(,$+)/%(7$<+$/90**+,?$ZL/$)$;)**+4$0'$

.%/*04%>)($ %&'04;)*%0&5$ *.+/+$&0*>.+/5$ 04$ 4%&6/$ )408&,$ *.+$ +,6+/$ 0'$

>0%&/$)4+$=&03&$)/$'$$(*+1?$]7;<0(%>)((75$084$03&$>0%&/$)4+$4++,+,$

*0$ +@+;9(%'7$ 084$ 60:+4&;+&*M/$ 940*+>*%0&$ )6)%&/*$ )$ >08&*+4'+%*+4$

>(%99%&6$084$>0%&/?[$

U0*$)<(+$*0$>(%9$*.+$>0%&/$)6)%&5$T)+/)4$,4+);/$89$7+*$)&0*.+4$

/>.+;+?$ 2.%/$ *%;+$ .+$ 04,+4/$ )(($ *.+$ 60(,$ %&$ .%/$ 90//+//%0&$ *0$ <+$

;+(*+,$ ,03&$ )&,$ )$ <)/+$ ;+*)($ *0$ <+$ ;%@+,$ %&$ 3%*.$ %*?$ R40;$ *.+$

%&>4+)/+,$ ;%@*84+$ T)+/)4$ %/$ &03$ )<(+$ *0$ >4+)*+$ +:+&$ ;04+$ >0%&/?$

F&>+$)6)%&5$*.%/$ %/$)&0*.+4$'04;$0'$,+<)/%&6$*.+$;0&+7$%&$04,+4$*0$

>4+)*+$;04+$0'$%*?$L/$<+'04+5$*.+$%&>4+)/+,$;0&+7$'(00,/$*.+$;)4=+*$

9()>+$ )&,$ 94%>+/$ 0&$ +:+47*.%&6$ %&>4+)/+$ )6)%&?$ 2.%/$ >08&*+4'+%*%&6$

94)>*%>+$ >0&*%&8+,$ '04$;)&7$7+)4/$8&*%($ *.+$S0;)&$>0%&$ >0&*)%&+,$

(+//$ *.)&$ 0&+$ 9+4>+&*$ 0'$ *.+$ *48+$ 94+>%08/$ ;+*)(?$ T0&/+N8+&*(75$

S0;)&$ ;0&+7$ <+>);+$ *0*)((7$ 304*.(+//?$ 2.+$ +&*%4+$ ;0&+*)47$

/7/*+;$ >0(()9/+,?$ K&$ )&$ )**+;9*$ *0$ )44+/*$ *.+$ /9%4)(%&6$ 94%>+/-

3.%>.$ 3+4+$ *.+$ %&+:%*)<(+$ 4+/8(*$ 0'$ *.+$ %&'()*%0&-*.+$ S0;)&$

)8*.04%*%+/$ +&)>*+,$ /*4%>*$ 94%>+$ >0&*40(/?$ V8*$ /*4%99+,$ 0'$ *.+$ (+6)($

)<%(%*7$ *0$ 4)%/+$ *.+$ 94%>+/$ 0'$ *.+%4$ 940,8>*/$ %&$ (%&+$ 3%*.$ *.+%4$


!

!YY$

+/>)()*%&6$ >0/*/5$ ;+4>.)&*/$ /%;9(7$ 3+&*$ 08*$ 0'$ <8/%&+//?$ 2.+$

9098()*%0&$>08(,$&0$(0&6+4$0<*)%&$*.+$&+>+//%*%+/$0'$(%'+$)&,$'(+,$*.+$

>%*7$'04$*.+$>08&*47/%,+5$3.+4+$*.+7$>08(,$*47$*0$(%:+$0''$*.+$()&,?$L(($

0'$ *.+/+$ ,%/489*%0&/$ ;),+$ S0;+$ :8(&+4)<(+$ *0$ '04+%6&$ %&:),+4/5$

0&+/$3.0$.),$94+:%08/(7$<++&$+)/%(7$4+9+((+,?$V8*$8(*%;)*+(7$%*$3)/$

&0*$ <)4<)4%)&$ >0&N8+404/$ 3.0$ <4086.*$ ,03&$ S0;+?$ a+<)/%&6$ *.+$

;0&+*)47$8&%*$%/$)>*8)((7$3.)*$>)8/+,$*.+$')(($0'$*.+$S0;)&$Q;9%4+?"$

T)&$)(($/++$*.+$/%6&%'%>)&>+$0'$*.%/$9%+>+$0'$.%/*0471$C.+&$*.+$

:)(8+$0'$*.+$;0&+7$%/$,+(%<+4)*+(7$,%(8*+,$708$&++,$;04+$0'$%*$*0$<87$

3.)*$ 708$ &++,?$ b4%>+/$ &+>+//)4%(7$ 4%/+$ +:+473.+4+?$ K/&M*$ *.+$ /*047$

*.+$/);+$*0,)71$2.%/$(0//$0'$:)(8+$%&$*.+$;0&+7$/899(7$%/$.)99+&%&6$

&0*$ 0&(7$ 3%*.$ 084$ 03&$ ,0(()45$ <8*$ 3%*.$ )(($ >844+&>%+/$ 304(,3%,+?$

b4%>+/$)4+$)(/0$ 4%/%&6$+:+473.+4+$ *.4086.08*$ *.+$304(,5$ )/$N80*+,$

%&$*.+$(0>)($>844+&>7?$K&>4+)/%&6$*.+$;0&+7$/899(75$)/$708$>)&$/++5$%/$

&0*$8&%N8+$*0$T)+/)4?$L(($60:+4&;+&*/$.):+$,0&+$*.%/$%&$0&+$3)7$04$

)&0*.+4?$ K*$ %/$ %&.+4+&*$ %&$ *.+$ &)*84+$ 0'$ 60:+4&;+&*5$ &0*$ 0&(7$ *0$

>0&*40($*.+$;0&+7$/899(75$<8*$*0$*);9+4$3%*.$%*$'04$*.+$<+&+'%*$0'$*.+$

60:+4&;+&*$'%4/*?$K*$%/$(+6)(%X+,$)//)8(*$0&$94%:)*+$9409+4*7?$$

(

0/1#234(*+,-#%./+(

$

R)/*$ '043)4,$ *0$ ;0,+4&$ *%;+/O$ K&$ 04,+4$ *0$ 8&,+4/*)&,$

%&'()*%0&$ *.+4+$ )4+$ *30$ *.%&6/$ 3+$ ;8/*$ '8((7$ 4+>06&%X+?$ $ R%4/*5$ 084$

60:+4&;+&*$.)/$&0$;0&+7$0'$%*/$03&$)(*.086.$%*$.)/$)>>+//$*0$)(($0'$


!

!Yc$

%*?$ d0:+4&;+&*$ 0&(7$ /9+&,/$ *.+$ ;0&+7$ %*$ .)/$ '%4/*$ *)=+&$ '40;$ *.+$

94%:)*+$ /+>*04-)&,$ *4%((%0&/$ 0'$ ,0(()4/$ 0'$ %*`$ ]+>0&,(75$ 084$

60:+4&;+&*$.)/$+&04;08/$+@9+&,%*84+/?$d0:+4&;+&*$9)740(($)(0&+$

%/$ )/*40&0;%>)(?$ K*$ %/$ *.+$ ()46+/*$ +;9(07+4$ %&$ *.+$ 304(,$ 3%*.$ 0:+4$

*.4++$;%((%0&$+;9(07++/$3%*.$;04+$*.)&$.)('$0'$ *.+;$)4;+,$*0$*.+$

*++*.$3%*.$*.+$'%&+/*$3+)90&47$;0&+7$>)&$<87?$L&,5$3.)*$)<08*$*.+$

94064);/$%*$'8&,/$7+)4$)'*+4$7+)45$3%*.$&+3$0&+/$:0*+,$%&$4+68()4(71$

2.%&=$0'$*.+$>0/*?$C.)*$)<08*$*.+$>0/*$0'$3)41$K*M/$;0&/*408/`$

$C.+4+$,0+/$*.+$60:+4&;+&*$6+*$)(($*.+$;0&+7$*0$9)7$'04$)(($

0'$*.%/1$C+((5$'40;$8/$0'$>084/+?$C+5$*.+$9+09(+$0'$*.%/$>08&*475$9)7$

*)@+/?$W03+:+45$60:+4&;+&*$.)/$60**+&$/0$<%6$)&,$/0$+@9+&/%:+$*.)*$

%*$ &03$ *)=+/$ *30$ /)()4%+/$ %&$ +:+47$ .08/+.0(,$ *0$ ;)=+$ +&,/$ ;++*?$

F&+$ >08(,$ +)/%(7$ >0&>(8,+$ *.)*$ 0&+$ ;+;<+4M/$ +&*%4+$ %&>0;+$ 60+/$

^8/*$ *0$9)7$ '04$ *.+$>0/*$0'$60:+4&;+&*?$_+/5$9)7$ '04$)(($0'$ *.%/$3%*.$

084$ *)@+/$ )&,$ 7+/5$ %*M/$ <7$ '04>+?$ K'$ 708$ ,0&M*$ <+(%+:+$ *.%/5$ *47$ &0*$

9)7%&6$*.+;?$$

L>>04,%&6$*0$*.+$I0''%>%)(J$&8;<+4/5$60:+4&;+&*/$)*$)(($(+:+(/$

%&$*.+$\&%*+,$]*)*+/$/9+&,$Ye$>+&*/$08*$0'$+:+47$,0(()4$*.)*$3+$304=$

/0$ .)4,$ *0$ +)4&5$ )&,$ *.+$ 4+)($ '4)>*%0&$ %/$ ;8>.$ .%6.+4?Y$ C%*.$

60:+4&;+&*$*)=%&6$)$600,$#.-,$0'$3.)*$3+$940,8>+5$ %*M/$&0$30&,+4$

3+$ )(($ .)*+$ *0$ 9)7$ *)@+/?$ U0$ 0&+$ =&03/$ *.%/$ <+**+4$ *.)&$ *.+$

60:+4&;+&*?$ 2.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$ .)/$ &+:+4$ '0460**+&$ *.)*$ +@>+//%:+$

*)@)*%0&$ 3%(($ >)8/+$ *.+$ 9+09(+$ *0$ 4+:0(*?$ 2.%/$ %/$ 3.7$ /0$ '+3$

90(%*%>%)&/$ +:+4$ 9(+,6+$ *0$ 4)%/+$ $:$'2&+$D4! *)@+/?$ V8*5$ *.+$


!

!Ye$

60:+4&;+&*M/$ 8&<)()&>+,$ <8,6+*/$ )&,$ %&>4+)/%&6$ ,+<*$ *+((/$ 8/$

>(+)4(7$*.)*$*)@+/$)4+$&0*$+&086.$*0$9)7$'04$*.+$+@9+&,%*84+/5$/0$.03$

%&$*.+$304(,$,0+/$60:+4&;+&*$>0&*%&8+$*0$9)7$'04$*.+;1$$

$

$

$

0"&(5&1&'#-(6&4&'7&(824%&9(

$

2)@+/$)4+$0<:%08/(7$0&(7$0&+$3)7$ '04$60:+4&;+&*$ *0$)>>+//$

*.+$ &+>+//)47$ ;0&+7?$ ]0$ 3.+4+$ +@)>*(7$ ,0+/$ )(($ *.+$ +@*4)$ ;0&+7$

>0;+$ '40;1$ 2.%/$ %/$ 3.+4+$ *.+$ R+,+4)($S+/+4:+$ ]7/*+;$ >0;+/$ %&*0$

9()7?$ T+&*4)($ <)&=%&6$ %&$ %*/$ >844+&*$ %&>)4&)*%0&$3)/$ +/*)<(%/.+,$ %&$


!

!Yf$

*.+$ \&%*+,$ ]*)*+/$ %&$ !P!Y$ 3%*.$ 9)9+4$ >844+&>7$ %&%*%)((7$ <)>=+,$ <7$

94+>%08/$ ;+*)(/?$ ZU0*$ /0$ >0%&>%,+&*(75$ *.+$ '+,+4)($ %&>0;+$ *)@$ 3)/$

9)//+,$%&*0$()3$*.)*$:+47$/);+$7+)4?[$$

F&+$0'$*.+$%&%*%)($,8*%+/$0'$*.+$R+,+4)($S+/+4:+$3)/$*0$4+&+3$

*48/*$ )&,$ >0&'%,+&>+$ %&$ *.+$ &)*%0&M/$ &+3(7$ 046)&%X+,$ <)&=%&6$

/7/*+;?$2.+$98<(%>$9+4>+%:+,$*.+$R+,+4)($S+/+4:+$*0$<+$)/#$! -$+($'!

&,!-.4/!'$4&'/0$)/$)$3)7$*0$4+/>8+$<)&=/$3.0$3+4+$/8<^+>*$*0$)$I48&J$

)&,$ 3+4+$ %&$ ,)&6+4$ 0'$ &0*$ <+%&6$ )<(+$ *0$ /)*%/'7$ *.+%4$ ,+90/%*04/?$

2.4086.$ )$ >(+:+4$ >);9)%6&$ '8+(+,$ Z%40&%>)((7[$ <7$ /0;+$ 0'$ *.+$

3+)(*.%+/*$ '%&)&>%+4/$*.+;/+(:+/5$ *.+$98<(%>$3)/$ (+,$*0$<+(%+:+$*.)*$

*.+$ R+,+4)($ S+/+4:+$ 308(,$ +(%;%&)*+$ '%&)&>%)($ >4%/+/$ )&,$ 308(,$

+(%;%&)*+$*.+$%&'(8+&>+$0'$94%:)*+$%&*+4+/*/$0&$*.+$&)*%0&M/$'%&)&>%)($

/7/*+;?$

K*$ %/$ %;904*)&*$ *0$;+&*%0&$ *.)*$ 9)9+4$;0&+7$ (%&=+,$ *0$ 60(,$

(%;%*/$)$60:+4&;+&*M/$)<%(%*7$ *0$<04403$;0&+7?$2.%/$ %/$3.7$,84%&6$

*%;+/$ 0'$ /+:+4+$ >4%/%/-/8>.$ )/$ 3)4-60:+4&;+&*/$ 308(,$ 0'*+&$

4+&+6+$0&$ *.+%4$ 0<(%6)*%0&/$ *0$ 4+,++;$>844+&>7$ %&$ 60(,$ Z04$ /%(:+4[?$

a84%&6$ C04(,$ C)4$ K5$ )(($ *.+$ <+((%6+4+&*/$ +@>+9*$ *.+$ \&%*+,$ ]*)*+/$

+@9(%>%*(7$)<)&,0&+,$*.+$60(,$/*)&,)4,?$2.+7$'08&,$%*$*00$*+;9*%&6$

*0$ 9)7$ '04$ *.+$ 3)4$ +''04*$ <7$ 94%&*%&6$ &+3$ ;0&+75$ )&,$ 3.+&$ *.+$

%&+:%*)<(+$,4)%&$0&$*.+%4$60(,$4+/+4:+/$<+6)&$*0$;)&%'+/*$%*/+('5$*.+7$

/%;9(7$ :%0()*+,$ *.+%4$ 4+,+;9*%0&$ 9(+,6+?$ L'*+4$ *.+$ 3)45$ *.+$ ;)^04$

>08&*4%+/$ 4+*84&+,$ Z.)('.+)4*+,(7[$ *0$ )$ :)4%)&*$0'$ *.+$04%6%&)($ 60(,$

/*)&,)4,5$ <8*$ *.%/$ ;)=+/.%'*$ )44)&6+;+&*$ >0(()9/+,$ %&$ *.+$ d4+)*$


!

!Y#$

a+94+//%0&$0'$ *.+$!PYG/$3.+&$60:+4&;+&*/$0&>+$ )6)%&$3)&*+,$ *0$

/9+&,$ ;04+$ *.)&$ *.+%4$ >%*%X+&/$ 308(,$ *0(+4)*+$ *.4086.$ :%/%<(+$ *)@$

9)7;+&*/?$ C.)*$ *.+$ 90(%*%>%)&/$ >08(,$ &0*$ ,)4+$ *)=+$ ,%4+>*(75$ *.+7$

*00=$%&,%4+>*(7$*.4086.$*.+$.%,,+&$*)@$0'$%&'()*%0&?$

$

:&2+&4.#+(;</+/9.<4(

$

K&$ *.+$ ;%,/*$ 0'$ *.+$ d4+)*$ a+94+//%0&-3.%>.$ *.+$ 98<(%>$

+440&+08/(7$<();+,$0&$)$')%(84+$0'$>)9%*)(%/;$)&,$>()//%>)($+>0&0;%>$

*.+047-H0.&$ E)7&)4,$ B+7&+/5$ )$ <4%((%)&*$ V4%*%/.$ +>0&0;%/*5$

98<(%/.+,$ )$ <00=$ %&$ !PYf$ *.)*$ *00=$ *.+$ 304(,$ 0'$ +>0&0;%>/$ <7$

/*04;?$ 2.+$ *%;%&6$ >08(,$ &0*$ .):+$ <++&$ <+**+4?$ 2.%/$ &+3$ *.+0475$ )$

'04;$0'$I;0,+4&J$+>0&0;%>/5$940>()%;+,$*.)*$<8/%&+//$/(8;9/$3+4+$

>)8/+,$ <7$ )$ ()>=$ 0'$ ),+N8)*+$ I)664+6)*+$ ,+;)&,J$ *0$ +&/84+$ '8(($

+;9(07;+&*?$ g00/+(7$ /9+)=%&65$ B+7&+/$ )468+,$ *.)*$ )$ ;)4=+*$

+>0&0;75$ %'$ (+'*$ *0$ %*/$ 03&$ ,+:%>+/5$ >08(,$ 6+*$ /*8>=$ '04$ 7+)4/$ %&$ )$

/%*8)*%0&$3.+4+$>0&/8;+4/$)&,$<8/%&+//+/$3+4+&M*$43$+(*+1!$+&61#$

*0$<87$)(($*.)*$*.+$+>0&0;7$3)/$>)9)<(+$0'$940,8>%&6?$T0&/+N8+&*(75$

<+>)8/+$0'$*.+$+@>+//$>)9)>%*7$04$/()>=$%&$*.+$/7/*+;5$)$()46+$'4)>*%0&$

0'$ *.+$ 304='04>+$ 3)/&M*$ &++,+,$ )&,$ >0&/+N8+&*(7$ *.+/+$ 9+09(+$

4+;)%&+,$8&+;9(07+,?$

B+7&+/M$ /0(8*%0&$ 3)/$ /8494%/%&6(7$ /%;9(+5$ )&,$ 0&+$ *.)*$ *.+$

90(%*%>%)&/$+&*.8/%)/*%>)((7$+;<4)>+,O$K&>4+)/+,$60:+4&;+&*$,+'%>%*$

/9+&,%&6$>08(,$<00/*$)664+6)*+$,+;)&,$)&,$*.+4+<7$+(%;%&)*+$ *.+$


!

!YD$

6)9$<+*3++&$)>*8)($08*98*$)&,$90*+&*%)($08*98*?$K&$0*.+4$304,/5$*.+$

60:+4&;+&*$>08(,$<87$+&086.$/*8''$ %&$04,+4$*0$ ^8/*%'7$*.+$.%4%&6$0'$

)(($*.+$8&+;9(07+,?$

K&$ *+4;/$0'$ >0&N8+4%&6$8&+;9(07;+&*$ )&,$ +&,%&6$ )$ /+:+4+$

4+>+//%0&5$ %*$ ,%,&M*$ +:+&$ ;)**+4$ %#./$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$ /9+&*$ %*/$

;0&+7$0&?$K&$94%&>%9(+$%*$>08(,$9)7$0&+$;%((%0&$304=+4/$*0$,%6$.0(+/$

%&$*.+$6408&,5$)&,$9)7$)&0*.+4$;%((%0&$304=+4/$*0$'%(($*.+$.0(+/$<)>=$

89?$2.+$90%&*$3)/&M*$*0$>)4+'8((7$.8/<)&,$/0>%+*7M/$/>)4>+$4+/084>+/5$

<8*$ 4)*.+4$ *0$ <00/*$ %&>0;+/$ Z<7$ 6%:%&6$ 9)7>.+>=/$ *0$ *.+$ 304=+4/$

,%66%&6$ )&,$ '%((%&6$ .0(+/[$ /0$ *.)*$ /#$*'$ %&>4+)/+,$ /9+&,%&6$ %&$ *84&$

308(,$ '84*.+4$ /*%;8()*+$ *.+$ +>0&0;7?$ 20$ /++$ *.)*$ 3+$ )4+$ &0*$

940:%,%&6$ )$ >)4%>)*84+$ 0'$ B+7&+/5$ (+*$ 8/$ N80*+$ .%;$ ,%4+>*(7$ 0&$ )$

')&>%'8($3)7$*0$)((+:%)*+$;)//$8&+;9(07;+&*O$

$K'$*.+$24+)/847$3+4+$*0$'%(($0(,$<0**(+/$3%*.$<)&=&0*+/5$<847$*.+;$

)*$/8%*)<(+$,+9*./$%&$,%/8/+,$>0)($;%&+/$3.%>.$)4+$*.+&$'%((+,$89$

*0$ *.+$ /84')>+$ 3%*.$ *03&$ 48<<%/.5$ )&,$ (+):+$ %*$ *0$ 94%:)*+$

+&*+494%/+$ 0&$ 3+((h*4%+,$ 94%&>%9(+/$ 0'$ ()%//+Xh')%4+$ *0$ ,%6$ *.+$

&0*+/$89$)6)%&i*.+4+$&++,$<+$&0$;04+$8&+;9(07;+&*$)&,$3%*.$

*.+$.+(9$0'$*.+$4+9+4>8//%0&/5$*.+$4+)($%&>0;+$0'$*.+$>0;;8&%*75$

)&,$ %*/$>)9%*)($3+)(*.$)(/05$308(,$940<)<(7$<+>0;+$)$600,$,+)($

64+)*+4$*.)&$%*$)>*8)((7$%/?c$

!

2.+$=+7$%&/%6.*$0'$B+7&+/%)&$+>0&0;%>/$%/$*.)*$0&+$9+4/0&M/$

+@9+&,%*84+$>4+)*+/$%&>0;+$'04$/0;+0&+$+(/+?$Zb+4:+4/+(75$*.%/$)(/0$


!

!YP$

;+)&/$ *.)*$ %'$ /0;+0&+$ 4.:$4$ ;04+$ 0'$ .%/$ 03&$ %&>0;+5$ .%/$ )>*%0&$

'$(6>$4$ *.+$ %&>0;+$0'$ /0;+<0,7$ +(/+5$ 6%:%&6$ 4%/+$ *0$ *.+$B+7&+/%)&$

)**+&*%0&$*0$*.+$/0h>)((+,$I9)4),0@$0'$*.4%'*J$%&$3.%>.$*.+$>0;;8&%*7$

%;90:+4%/.+/$%*/+('$<7$*47%&6$*0$,0$*.+$4+/90&/%<(+$*.%&6?[$V7$*)=%&6$

*.%/$ *48%/;$ )&,$ )664+6)*%&6$ %*$ )>40//$ *.+$ +&*%4+$ +>0&0;75$ B+7&+/$

>0&>(8,+,$ *.)*$ *0*)($ %&>0;+$ +N8)(/$ *0*)($ +@9+&,%*84+/?$ T0;<%&+,$

3%*.$ *.+$ +N8)((7$ 9()8/%<(+$ )//8;9*%0&$ *.)*$ 9+09(+$ /9+&,$ 0&(7$ )$

'4)>*%0&$0'$3.)*$ *.+7$ +)4&5$ *.+$ /0(8*%0&$ *0$ )$,+94+//%0&$3)/$ >(+)4O$

2.+$60:+4&;+&*$&++,+,$*0$/9+&,$+&086.$+@*4)$;0&+75$ %&$04,+4$*0$

<00/*$ *0*)($&)*%0&)($ %&>0;+$ *0$ *.+$90%&*$)*$3.%>.$ *.+$ *0*)($);08&*$

/9+&*$ <7$ >0&/8;+4/$ )&,$ %&:+/*+,$ <7$ <8/%&+//+/5$ 308(,$ 6+&+4)*+$

+&086.$/)(+/$*0$98*$+:+470&+$*0$304=?$

C.+*.+4$ (%<+4)($ 04$ I>0&/+4:)*%:+5J$ 084$ '%&)&>%)($ 94+//$ *0,)7$

%/$*.04086.(7$%&'8/+,$3%*.$*.+$B+7&+/%)&$;%&,/+*?$b8&,%*/$0&$TUVT$

)&,$ V(00;<+46$ '4+*$ 0:+4$ I>0&/8;+4$ >0&'%,+&>+J$ )&,$ 34%&6$ *.+%4$

.)&,/$3.+&+:+4$9+09(+$,+>%,+$*0$/):+$;04+?$2.+$%;9(%>)*%0&$%/$*.)*$

%'$ 0&(7$ 3+$ >08(,$ .):+$ T.4%/*;)/$ +:+47$ ,)7$ 0'$ *.+$ 7+)45$ 3+$ 308(,$

&+:+4$ .):+$ 4+>+//%0&/?$ K&$ *.+$ B+7&+/%)&$ :%+35$ *.+$ 0(,h')/.%0&+,$

:%4*8+$0'$*.4%'*-0'$(%:%&6$<+(03$0&+M/$;+)&/-%/$90/%*%:+(7$.)4;'8($

,84%&6$)$4+>+//%0&?$

U++,(+//$ *0$ /)75$L8/*4%)&$+>0&0;%/*/$.):+$<++&$ *.+$ '%+4>+/*$

>4%*%>/$ 0'$ *.+%4$ B+7&+/%)&$ 4%:)(/?$ K&$ *.+$ L8/*4%)&$ :%+35$ ,+'%>%*$

/9+&,%&6$ %/$ *.+$ 304/*$ *.%&6$ 90(%*%>%)&/$ >)&$ ,0$ ,84%&6$ )$ /+:+4+$

4+>+//%0&?$K&$/8>.$)$/>+&)4%05$*.+$60:+4&;+&*$*)=+/$)&$+>0&0;7$*.)*$


!

!cG$

%/$)(4+),7$0&$%*/$=&++/5$)&,$),,/$)$'84*.+4$<(03$<7$/%9.0&%&6$;04+$

4+/084>+/$)3)7$ '40;$ *.+$940,8>*%:+$ /+>*04$)&,$ %&*0$ *.+$ %&+''%>%+&*$

90(%*%>)($940>+//?$K*$%/$&0$/8494%/+5$*.+$L8/*4%)&/$90%&*$08*5$*.)*$*.0/+$

4+>+//%0&/$ >.)4)>*+4%X+,$ <7$ *.+$ <%66+/*$ ,0/+/$ 0'$ B+7&+/%)&$

I;+,%>%&+J-&0*)<(7$*.+$!PYG/$)&,$084$>844+&*$>4%/%/-)4+$)(/0$*.+$

0&+/$3%*.$*.+$(0&6+/*$)&,$;0/*$()>=(8/*+4$4+>0:+4%+/?e$

$

=&>%(

!

C+$ /*%(($ ;8/*$ 940<+$ ,++9+4$ *0$ 8&,+4/*)&,$ *.+$ +@)>*$

;+>.)&%/;$<7$3.%>.$ 60:+4&;+&*$ %&>4+)/+/$ %*/$ ,+<*5$ )&,$ .03$ *.%/$

4+()*+/$*0$%&'()*%0&?$

C.+&$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$ &++,/$ ;04+$ ;0&+75$ *.+$ 24+)/847$

a+9)4*;+&*$%//8+/$<0&,/$%&*0$*.+$09+&$;)4=+*?$L$<0&,$%/$)$'04;$0'$

KF\?$ ]%&>+$ *.+$ <0&,$ %/$ )$ ,+<*$ %&/*48;+&*5$ *.+$ 940;%/+$ 0'$ *.+$

60:+4&;+&*$ %/$ *0$ 9)7$ *.+$ ,+<*$ *0$ *.+$ <0&,.0(,+4$ /0;+*%;+$ %&$ *.+$

'8*84+?$R04$,+<*/$0'$/8''%>%+&*$(+&6*.5$%&*+4+/*$9)7;+&*/$)4+$;),+$*0$

*.+$<0&,.0(,+4$9+4%0,%>)((7$%&$),,%*%0&$*0$*.+$4+*84&$0'$94%&>%9)($)*$

*.+$*%;+$0'$;)*84%*7?$

L&70&+$ >)&$ <87$ *.+$ <0&,/$ %//8+,$ <7$ *.+$ \&%*+,$ ]*)*+/$

60:+4&;+&*?$ K&/*%*8*%0&/5$ %&,%:%,8)(/5$ )&,$ +:+&$ 0*.+4$ >08&*4%+/$

984>.)/+$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$ /+>84%*%+/?$ ]0;+$ 0'$ *.+$ <%66+/*$

%&/*%*8*%0&)($<87+4/$)4+$>+&*4)($<)&=/5$&0*)<(7$%&>(8,%&6$*.+$R+,+4)($

S+/+4:+?$ B++9$ %&$ ;%&,$ *.)*$ *.+$ R+,+4)($ S+/+4:+$ ,0+/$ &0*$ .):+$ )$


!

!c!$

/):%&6/$ '8&,$ 0'$ ;0&+7$ /0;+3.+4+$ 3%*.$ 3.%>.$ *0$ 984>.)/+$ *.+$

60:+4&;+&*M/$ <0&,/5$ <8*$ %*$ >)&$ )&,$,0+/$ /%;9(7$ >4+)*+$ *.+$;0&+7$

08*$ 0'$ *.%&$ )%4?$ ]9+>%'%>)((75$ 3.+&$ *.+$ R+,+4)($ S+/+4:+$ <87/$ <0&,/$

%//8+,$ <7$ *.+$ \&%*+,$ ]*)*+/$ 60:+4&;+&*5f$ *.+$ R+,$ /%;9(7$ 34%*+/$ )$

>.+>=$0&$%*/+('?$L*$*.%/$/*)6+$%&$*.+$+@9()&)*%0&5$708$>)&$*.%&=$0'$%*$)/$

*.+$R+,$(%*+4)((7$94%&*%&6$89$>4%/9$&+3$j!GG$<%((/$)&,$.)&,%&6$*.+;$

0:+4$*0$*.+$60:+4&;+&*5$%&$+@>.)&6+$'04$%*/$KF\/?$

2.%/$940>+//$>)&$<+$:+47$;7/*+4%08/$)&,$>0&'8/%&65$/0$(+*$8/$

,+/>4%<+$ %*$ %&$ ,%''+4+&*$ 304,/?$ S+;+;<+4O$ *.+$ \?]?$ 60:+4&;+&*$

3)&*/$*0$/9+&,$;0&+75$;04+$;0&+7$%&$')>*$*.)&$%*$>0((+>*/$%&$*)@+/?$

]0$ 0&+$ ),,%*%0&)($ ):+&8+$ *0$ 4)%/+$ '8&,/5$ %/$ '04$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$ *0$

%//8+$ )&$ KF\$ Z)$ <0&,[$ *0$ *.+$ R+,+4)($ S+/+4:+?$ R04$ +@);9(+5$ *.+$

60:+4&;+&*$;%6.*$/+(($)$&+3$KF\$%&$4+*84&$'04$*.+$R+,$940:%,%&6$j!$

;%((%0&$%&$<4)&,$&+3$;0&+7?$2.+$60:+4&;+&*$>)&$*.+&$60$/9+&,$*.+$

j!$;%((%0&$0&$*)&=/5$'00,$/*);9/5$04$3.)*+:+4$*.+$90(%*%>%)&/$,+/%4+?$

2.+$ R+,5$ '04$ %*/$ 9)4*5$ &03$ ),,/$ j!$ ;%((%0&$ %&$ &+3$ <0&,/$ *0$ %*/$

.0(,%&6/$0'$0*.+4$)//+*/?$

F&>+$3+$<0%($,03&$*0$*.+$+//+&>+$0'$*.+$*4)&/)>*%0&5$3+$/++$

*.+$ /7;<%0*%>$ 4+()*%0&/.%9$ <+*3++&$ *.+$ R+,+4)($ S+/+4:+$ )&,$ *.+$

24+)/847?$V)/%>)((75$*.+$24+)/847$%//8+/$9)9+4$($</$*0$*.+$R+,5$3.%>.$

%//8+/$ 9)9+4$ 7&+$2$ %&$ +@>.)&6+?$ L*$ '%4/*$ 6()&>+5$ *.%/$ >0;9(%>)*+,$

940>+//$ <+)4/$ (%**(+$ 4+/+;<()&>+$ *0$ *.+$ /%;9(+$ >.%>)&+47$ <7$3.%>.$

*.+$S0;)&$60:+4&;+&*$,+<)/+,$%*/$>844+&>7?$


!

!c"$

_+*$ ,%6$ ^8/*$ )$ (%**(+$ ,++9+4?$ L(*.086.$ *.+$ 24+)/847$ ;)=+/$

%&*+4+/*$9)7;+&*/$*0$*.+$R+,$Z3.%>.$)'*+4$)(($%/$.0(,%&6$.8&,4+,/$0'$

<%((%0&/$ 0'$ ,0(()4/$ 304*.$ 0'$ 24+)/847$ KF\/[5$ *.+$ R+,$ *84&/$ )408&,$

)&,$ 1*:$4! */4! $=>$44! $.'+*+14! '*1#/! <.>E! /&! /#$! "'$.46'2F$ E04+0:+45$

*.+$ 6+&+4)($ *4+&,$ %/$ '04$ *.+$ R+,$ *0$ );)//$ )$ 6403%&6$ /*0>=9%(+$ 0'$

60:+4&;+&*$,+<*A$*.+$24+)/847$=&03/$*.)*$%*$3%(($&+:+4$.):+$*0$9)7$

0''$ *.+$ 94%&>%9)($ 0&$ %*/$ (0)&/5$ <+>)8/+$ *.+$ R+,$ 3%(($ >0&*%&8)((7$ 40(($

*.+;$0:+4$)/$*.+7$;)*84+?$K&$0*.+4$304,/5$+:+&$*.086.$%*$4$$74$)/$%'$

*.+$24+)/847$%/$9()7%&6$<7$*.+$/);+$48(+/$)/$+:+470&+$+(/+5$)&,$;8/*$

;)=+$ %&*+4+/*$ 9)7;+&*/$ )&,$ 94%&>%9)($ 9)7;+&*/$ 3.+&$ %*$ <04403/$

;0&+75$%&$94)>*%>+$*.+$R+,$(+*/$*.+$60:+4&;+&*$<04403$&+3$;0&+7$

3%*.$&0$/*4%&6/$)**)>.+,`$

K&$ *.+$ 64)&,$ />.+;+5$ *.+&5$ *.+$ '+,+4)($ 60:+4&;+&*$ )&,$

R+,+4)($S+/+4:+$+;9(07$*.+$/);+$<)/%>$;+>.)&%/;$8/+,$<7$T)+/)4O$

K&$),,%*%0&$*0$3.)*$*.+$60:+4&;+&*$/9+&,/$*.4086.$,%4+>*$*)@)*%0&$

)&,$ <04403%&6$ '40;$ 9+09(+$ %&$ *.+$ 94%:)*+$ /+>*045$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$

)(/0$ '%&)&>+/$ /0;+$ 0'$ %*/$ 984>.)/+/$ *.4086.$ *.+$ >4+)*%0&$ 0'$ &+3$

;0&+7$ Z/899(%+,$ <7$ *.+$ R+,[?$ 2.+$ 940>+//$ %/$ &0*$ )/$ &)=+,$ )/$

T)+/)4M/$;+*.0,/5$<8*$*.+$8&,+4(7%&6$+>0&0;%>/$)4+$+//+&*%)((7$*.+$

/);+?#$

F'$ >084/+5$ 4+)($ 4+/084>+/$ )4+$ >0&/8;+,$ <7$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$

3.+&$%*$/9+&,/$*.%/$&+3$;0&+7$>4+)*+,$<7$*.+$R+,?$2.+$60:+4&;+&*$

4+)((7$ (&$4$ 0<*)%&$ <0;<+4/$ )&,$ 4+)((7$ (&$4$ '%&)&>+$ 3+(')4+$

9)7;+&*/$ 3%*.$ %*/$ /9+&,%&6?$ ]0$ 3.)*M/$ *.+$ >)*>.1$ W03$ >)&$ *.+$


!

!cY$

60:+4&;+&*$0<*)%&$)(($*.+/+$600,%+/$;+4+(7$<7$.):%&6$*.+$R+,$94%&*$

89$64++&$9%+>+/$0'$9)9+41$

2.+$ )&/3+4$ %/$ *.+$ /);+$ &03$ )/$ %*$ 3)/$ ,84%&6$ *.+$ S0;)&$

Q;9%4+?$L(($.0(,+4/$0'$,0(()4$<%((/$8(*%;)*+(7$9)7$*.+$>0/*$*.4086.$*.+$

.%,,+&$*)@$0'$4%/%&6$94%>+/?$K&$0*.+4$304,/5$%&$),,%*%0&$*0$*.+%4$,%4+>*$

*)@$ 9)7;+&*/$ )&,$ 3.)*+:+4$ ;0&+7$ *.+7$ ,%4+>*(7$ (+&,$ *0$ *.+$

60:+4&;+&*$<7$<87%&6$24+)/847$<0&,/5$ *.+$98<(%>$ .-4&$ 9)7/$ %&$ *.+$

'04;$0'$*.+$4%/%&6$>0/*$0'$(%:%&6?$

B+7&+/%)&$ +>0&0;%>/$ 940:%,+/$ *.+$ %&*+((+>*8)($ ^8/*%'%>)*%0&$

'04$ *.%/$ ;)//%:+$ *4)&/'+4$ 0'$ 3+)(*.$ '40;$ *.+$ 98<(%>$ *0$ *.+$

60:+4&;+&*?$ F&>+$ 3+$ 8&,+4/*)&,$ *.+$ <)/%>$ ;+>.)&%>/$ 0'$ *.+$

09+4)*%0&5$3+$>)&$&03$8&,+4/*)&,$3.7$90(%*%>%)&/$)4+$/0$4+(8>*)&*$

*0$>8*$/9+&,%&6$)&,$<)()&>+$*.+$<8,6+*?$\&(%=+$)$94%:)*+$.08/+.0(,$

04$>04904)*%0&5$*.+4+$%/$&0$,)&6+4$0'$%&/0(:+&>7$'04$*.+$60:+4&;+&*5$

/0$(0&6$)/$%*$>)&$4+(7$0&$*.+$R+,$*0$>4+)*+$&+3$,0(()4$<%((/?$F'$>084/+5$

64+)*+4$ %&'()*%0&$0'$ *.+$;0&+7$/899(7$3%(($ (+),$ *0$4%/%&6$94%>+/$)&,$

/0)4%&6$%&*+4+/*$4)*+/5$)&,$/0$*.+$R+,$;8/*$+@+4>%/+$4&7$!4+/*4)%&*?$

U0&+*.+(+//$*.+$0:+4)(($*4+&,$%/$>(+)4O$2.+$60:+4&;+&*$%/$;)=%&6$&0$

4+)($+''04*$ *0$9)7$0''$)&7$0'$ *.+$;08&*%&6$,+<*$Z<0&,/[?$S+;+;<+4$

*.)*$8&,+4$B+7&+/%)&$+>0&0;%>/5$ %*$,0+/$&0*$&++,$*0?$T844+&*(7$*.+$

0''%>%)($ ,+<*$ (+:+($ %/$ /0;+$ *.%4*++&$ *4%((%0&$ ,0(()4/5$ )&,$ *.)*$ '%684+$

,0+/&M*$ %&>(8,+$ *.+$ *0*)($ 0<(%6)*%0&/$ 0'$ *.+$ 60:+4&;+&*$ ,8+$ *0$

E+,%>)4+$)&,$0*.+4$>0;;%*;+&*/?$$


!

!cc$

$

$

$

F&>+$3+$8&,+4/*)&,$*.+$940>+//$0'$%&'()*%0&5$3+$>)&$/++$.03$

)</84,$%*$%/$3.+&$R+,+4)($S+/+4:+$0''%>%)(/$/0(+;&(7$9(+,6+$*0$,*1#/!

%&'()*%0&?$ K*$ %/$ )$ <%*$ (%=+$ )4/0&%/*/$ 940;%/%&6$ *0$ ,0$ *.+%4$ 9)4*$ %&$

>0;<)*%&6$'04+/*$'%4+/?$K&$*.+$>0&*+@*$3+$/++$)$.)4;'8($+''+>*$0'$*.+$

>.)&6+$ %&$ ,+'%&%*%0&/5$ 3.+&$ *.+$ *+4;$ *+,-./*&+$ 8/+,$ *0$ ;+)&$ )&$

%&>4+)/+$%&$*.+$/899(7$0'$;0&+7$04$>4+,%*5$3.+4+)/$&03$;0/*$9+09(+$

8/+$ *+,-./*&+! *0$;+)&$4%/%&6$94%>+/?$Q:+47$ *%;+$*.+$R+,+4)($S+/+4:+$

94%&*/$&+3$;0&+75$%*$%/$%&'()*%&6$*.+$;0&+7$/899(75$*.+4+<7$,%(8*%&6$


!

!ce$

%*/$:)(8+?$2.+$*48*.$%/$*.)*$.%6.$94%>+/$)4+$*.+$+''+>*5$04$*.+$4+/8(*$0'$

%&'()*%0&?$$

V+70&,$*.+$>84/+$0'$>0&/*)&*(7$4%/%&6$94%>+/-04$3.)*$%/$*.+$

/);+$ *.%&65$)$>0&/*)&*$+40/%0&$0'$ *.+$:)(8+$0'$ *.+$,0(()4-%&'()*%0&$

:%)$ *.+$ R+,+4)($ S+/+4:+$ .-4&$ >)8/+/$ *.+$ <00;h<8/*$ >7>(+5$ )/$

+@9()%&+,$<7$L8/*4%)&$+>0&0;%/*/?$V8*$3+$'%4/*$&++,$*0$8&,+4/*)&,$

'4)>*%0&)($4+/+4:+$<)&=%&65$<+'04+$+@9(04%&6$*.%/$9%+>+$0'$*.+$98XX(+?$

$

$

$

$


!

!cf$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Henry Hazlitt, What You Should Know About Inflation (New York: D. Van Nostrand Company, Inc., 1965), p. 2. 2 Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1998), pp. 761-763. 3 See Robert P. Murphy, “The Costs of Government,” at: http://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2010/Murphygovernmentcosts.html. Accessed May 31, 2010. Government statisticians count government expenditures as part of Gross Domestic Product, and so the ratio of government spending to the size of “the economy” is artificially deflated. But once we recognize that many of the government’s “services” aren’t really worth what the politicians spend on them, the true fraction of real economic output seized by the government becomes much larger. 4 The Keynes quotation is listed in a Paul Krugman blog post, “Bush is right about something,” February 19, 2008, at: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/02/19/bush-is-right-about-something/. Accessed June 3, 2010. 5 For a full comparison of the Austrian and Keynesian theories, and their ability to explain historical episodes, see Robert P. Murphy’s The Politically Incorrect Guide to the Great Depression and the New Deal (Washington, D.C.: Regnery, 2009). 6 In practice, the Federal Reserve doesn’t directly buy new bonds auctioned by the Treasury. Instead, private dealers buy the new bonds, and then resell them to the Fed. 7 For a fuller description of this process, see Robert P. Murphy, “The Fed as Giant Counterfeiter,” at: http://mises.org/daily/4029. Accessed May 31, 2010.

!"#$

!"#$%&'()(

*'#+%,-.#/(0&1&'2&(3#.4,.5(

!

!

"#$%$! &'&! (#$! )*+$,! -*)$! .%*)/! 0(!

-1)$21+&!(#'3!'3!(#$!)*3(!')4*%(1+(!

3'+56$! (#'+5! (*! 7+*8! 19*:(! )*&$%+!

91+7'+52'(! -1)$! *:(! *.! (#'+! 1'%;!

<*))$%-'16! 91+732(#1(! '3=!

.%1-('*+16! %$3$%>$! 91+732-%$1($!

)*+$,!*:(!*.!(#'+!1'%;!

2?:%%1,!@;!A*(#91%&B!

!

!

%&'$()'*$%+$,-).,/($)$0+1/%2*$)3)'4$,/$5,)%$6)6(2$0122(/0*$

57+3,/.$ 52+-$ %4($8(9&'$62,/%,/.$62(''(':$;1%$3($)77$ </+3$

%4)%$ 6)6(2$ 0122(/0*$ ,/$ +12$ -+9(2/$ 3+279$ ,'$ 9,')66()2,/.=$ >/$ +12$

4,.4$%(04$(/?,2+/-(/%$-+/(*$/+3$-+'%7*$57+3'$(7(0%2+/,0)77*=$@4($

0+/91,%$ 5+2$ -+9(2/$ 9)*$ ,/57)%,+/$ ,'$ /+%$ 6)6(2$ 0122(/0*:$ ,%&'$ -%$&'(!

$C41+3'*+=$$

@+$1/9(2'%)/9$4+3$%4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?($(B6)/9'$+2$0+/%2)0%'$

%4($-+/(*$'1667*$1',/.$02(9,%:$3($/((9$)/$+?(2?,(3$+/$%4($-()/,/.$

)/9$3+2<,/.'$+5$%3+$51/0%,+/'$+5$-+9(2/$;)/<,/.=$>/$-)*$;($4(76517$

%+$ '(($ %4(-$)'$ %4($ +2,.,/)%,/.$ 51/0%,+/'$ +5$ %4($62+0(''=$C/($ ,'$ %4($

>$

"#$%&'()$*!+,-,#.,!/$)0')1!DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!

!

!"D$

.$&$%16! .:+&3! %1($$ )/9$ %4($+%4(2$ ,'$ %4($&'3-*:+(! %1($:$ ;+%4$+5$34,04$

)2($0+/%2+77(9$;*$%4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?(=$

E77$ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'$ 34,04$ )2($ )$ 6)2%$ +5$ %4($ 8(9(2)7$

A('(2?(&'$ F(/%2)7$ G)/<,/.$ H*'%(-$ -1'%$ <((6$ )$ 0(2%),/$ )-+1/%$ +5$

%$3$%>$3$%+$;)0<$16$01'%+-(2$9(6+',%'=$@4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?($0+/%2+7'$

%4,'$ 7,-,%=$ I2('(/%7*:$ %4($ 2('(2?($ 7,-,%$ ,'$ )662+B,-)%(7*$ !JK$ +/$

)?(2).($ L%4($ 2)%($ ;(,/.$ 9,55(2(/%$ 5+2$ ;)/<'$ +5$ 9,55(2(/%$ ',M('N=$ 8+2$

(B)-67(:$ ,5$ )$ ;)/<&'$ 01'%+-(2'$ 0+77(0%,?(7*$ 4+79$ O!$ -,77,+/$ ,/$

9(6+',%':$ %4(/$ %4($;)/<$-1'%$ ,%'(75$4)?($O!JJ:JJJ$ ,/$ 2('(2?('=$@4($

2('(2?('$0+/','%$+5$(,%4(2$0122(/0*$,/$%4($?)17%:$*%!)'$%4($;)/<&'$+3/$

04(0<,/.$ )00+1/%$ 3,%4$ %4($ 8(9(2)7$ A('(2?($ ,%'(75=$ @+$ 0+/%,/1($ +12$

(B)-67(:$%4($;)/<$-,.4%$4)?($OPQ:JJJ$,/$.2((/$6,(0('$+5$6)6(2$,/$,%'$

?)17%':$)?),7);7($5+2$ ,--(9,)%($01'%+-(2$3,%492)3)7':$)/9$,%$-,.4%$

4)?($O#Q:JJJ$7,'%(9$)'$%4($;)7)/0($+5$,%'$)00+1/%$3,%4$%4($8(9=$

82+-$%,-($%+$%,-(:$%4($?).)2,('$+5$%4($;)/<,/.$;1',/(''$7()9$

'+-($ ;)/<'$ %+$ 4)?($ (B0(''$ 2('(2?(':$ )/9$ +%4(2'$ %+$ 4)?($ 9(5,0,%$

2('(2?('=$ G)/<'$ 3,77$ ;+22+3$ 52+-$ ()04$ +%4(2$ ,/$ +29(2$ %+$ -)<($ 16$

%4(,2$9(5,0,%'$)/9$2(-),/$,/$.++9$'%)/9,/.$3,%4$%4($8(9=$@4($-)2<(%$

5+2$ +?(2/,.4%$ 7+)/'$ +5$ 2('(2?('$ ,'$ 0)77(9$ %4($ 5(9(2)7$ 51/9'$ -)2<(%:$

)/9$%4($,/%(2('%$2)%($L(B62(''(9$)'$)/$)//1)7$6(20(/%).(N$,'$%4($R5(9$

51/9'$2)%(=S$T4(/$3($4()2$,/$%4($/(3'$%4)%$%4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?($4)'$

,/02()'(9$+2$7+3(2(9$R,/%(2('%$2)%(':S$34)%$%4(*$4)?($)0%1)77*$9+/($

,'$'(%$)$R%)2.(%S$,/%(2('%$2)%($5+2$;)/<'$%+$04)2.($()04$+%4(2$5+2$%4('($

+?(2/,.4%$7+)/'=$


!

!"U$

@4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?($9+('$/+%$&'%$-(6,$'(%$%4($5(9$51/9'$2)%(:$

;1%$ ,/'%()9$ ,/9,2(0%7*$ ,/571(/0('$ ,%$ ;*$ (,%4(2$ )99,/.$ +2$ 2(-+?,/.$

2('(2?('$ 52+-$ %4($ '*'%(-=$ >5$ %4($ )0%1)7$ 2)%($ %4)%$ ;)/<'$ 04)2.($ 5+2$

7+)/'$,'$4,.4(2$%4)/$%4($9(',2(9$%)2.(%$2)%(:$%4(/$%4($8(9$;1*'$)''(%'$

)/9$)99'$2('(2?('$%+$%4($'*'%(-V$%4($,/571B$+5$/(3$2('(2?('$-)<('$,%$

()',(2$ 5+2$ ;)/<'$ %+$ -((%$ %4(,2$ 2('(2?($ 2(W1,2(-(/%':$ )/9$ '+$ %4($

)0%1)7$ 5(9$ 51/9'$ 2)%($ 5)77'$ %+3)29$ %4($ 9(',2(9$ %)2.(%=$ C/$ %4($ +%4(2$

4)/9:$,5$%4($)0%1)7$5(9$51/9'$2)%($,'$7+3(2$%4)/$%4($%)2.(%:$%4($8(9$0)/$

'(77$)''(%'$+55$ ,%'$;)7)/0($'4((%:$ %4(2(;*$92),/,/.$2('(2?('$52+-$%4($

'*'%(-$ )/9$ -)<,/.$ ;)/<'$ '02)-;7($ %+$ -((%$ %4(,2$ 2('(2?($

2(W1,2(-(/%'=$>/$%4,'$'(0+/9$'0(/)2,+:$%4($8(9$,/02()'('$%4($;)/<'&$

9(-)/9$5+2$2('(2?(':$)/9$%4(2(;*$%4($8(9$,/9,2(0%7*$0)1'('$%4($5(9$

51/9'$2)%($%+$,/02()'($L34,04$,'$34)%$%4($8(9$3)/%(9N=$

>/$ )99,%,+/$ %+$ ,/9,2(0%7*$ 0+/%2+77,/.$ %4($ 5(9$ 51/9'$ 2)%(:$ %4($

8(9$9,2(0%7*$'(%'$%4($&'3-*:+(!%1($:$34,04$,'$%4($,/%(2('%$2)%($%4)%$%4($

8(9$ 04)2.('$ +/$ 7+)/'$ ,%$ 9,2(0%7*$ -)<('$ %+$ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'=$ @+$

2(6()%:$,/$%4($-+2($%*6,0)7$%2)/')0%,+/:$)$;)/<$/((9,/.$2('(2?('$L,/$

+29(2$ %+$ ')%,'5*$ ,%'$ 7(.)7$ 2('(2?($ 2(W1,2(-(/%N$ 3,77$ '((<$ %4($ 51/9'$

52+-$ +%4(2$ ;)/<'=$ G1%$ ,%$ 0)/$ )7'+$ .+$ 4)%$ ,/$ 4)/9$ %+$ %4($ 8(9$ ,%'(75:$

;+22+3,/.$52+-$%4($R9,'0+1/%$3,/9+3=S$>/$+29(2$%+$9,'0+12).($%4,'$

)0%,?,%*X)/9$('6(0,)77*$%+$62(?(/%$)/$)2;,%2).($',%1)%,+/$,/$34,04$)$

;)/<$0+179$;+22+3$52+-$%4($8(9$)/9$7(/9$%4($2('(2?('$+1%$%+$+%4(2$

;)/<'X%4($8(9$1'1)77*$'(%'$,%'$9,'0+1/%$2)%($'7,.4%7*$4,.4(2$%4)/$%4($

%)2.(%$5+2$%4($5(9$51/9'$2)%(=$$


!

!QJ$

$

$

E7%4+1.4$ %4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?($4)'$;((/$-)<,/.$9,2(0%$ 7+)/'$

%+$ ;)/<'$ ,/$ )/$ (B%2)+29,/)2*$ -)//(2$ 912,/.$ %4($ 0122(/%$ 02,',':$

4,'%+2,0)77*$%4($8(9$,/571(/0(9$%4($-)2<(%$'+&'%$-(6,$;*$)55(0%,/.$%4($

%+%)7$ )-+1/%$ +5$ 2('(2?('$ ,/$ %4($ '*'%(-=$ @4,'$ +0012'$ %42+1.4$ *4$+!

)1%7$(! *4$%1('*+3:$ ,/$ 34,04$ %4($ 8(9(2)7$ A('(2?($ ;1*'$ )/9$ '(77'$

)''(%'=$ >/$ 62(?,+1'$ 04)6%(2'$ 3($ 4)?($ 9,'01''(9$ '+-($ +5$ %4($

-(04)/,0':$;1%$/+3$3($3,77$0+-67(%($+12$'<(%04=$

@+$;(.,/:$ '166+'($ %4)%$ %4($8(9(2)7$A('(2?($;1*'$O!$-,77,+/$

3+2%4$ +5$ .+?(2/-(/%$ ;+/9'$ 52+-$ )$ 62,?)%($ ;+/9$ 9()7(2=$ @4($ 8(9$

6)*'$5+2$%4($;+/9'$;*$32,%,/.$)$04(0<$16+/$%4($8(9$,%'(75=$@4($;+/9$


!

!Q!$

9()7(2$ 9(6+',%'$ %4($ 04(0<$ )%$ 4,'$ 7+0)7$ ;)/<:$ )/9$ /)%12)77*$ 4,'$

04(0<,/.$)00+1/%$,'$02(9,%(9$3,%4$O!$-,77,+/=$

82+-$%4($;)/<&'$6+,/%$+5$?,(3:$,%'$7,);,7,%,('$4)?($,/02()'(9$;*$

O!$ -,77,+/X+/($ +5$ ,%'$ 01'%+-(2'$ /+3$ 4)'$ O!$ -,77,+/$ -+2($ ,/$ 4,'$

04(0<,/.$)00+1/%=$G1%$ %4($;)/<&'$ )''(%'$4)?($.+/($16$;*$ %4($ ')-($

)-+1/%:$;(0)1'($%4($;)/<$%)<('$%4($04(0<$)/9$07()2'$,%$3,%4$%4($8(9=$

@4($;)/<$4)'$)$R04(0<,/.$)00+1/%S$)'$,%$3(2($3,%4$%4($8(9$,%'(75:$)/9$

(#1($)00+1/%$4)'$/+3$.+/($16$;*$O!$-,77,+/$)'$3(77=$

E%$ 5,2'%$ .7)/0(:$ ,%$ -,.4%$ '((-$ )'$ ,5$ %4($ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<$ ,'$

1/)55(0%(9$;*$%4($8(9&'$61204)'($+5$ %4($;+/9'=$E5%(2$)77:$ %4($;)/<&'$

7,);,7,%,('$4)?($.+/($16$;*$O!$-,77,+/:$)/9$,%'$)''(%'$4)?($.+/($16$;*$

%4($ ')-($)-+1/%=$E/9$ ,/9((9:$ ,/$ )$!JJK$2('(2?($;)/<,/.$ '*'%(-:$

%4,/.'$ 8*:6&! '%+6$ %4(2(=$ @4($ ;)/<$ 3+179$ -(2(7*$ ;($ )$ -,997(-)/$

;(%3((/$%4($8(9$)/9$%4($62,?)%($;+/9$9()7(2=$

Y+3(?(2:$ %4,/.'$ .(%$ -104$ -+2($ 0+-67,0)%(9$ 34(/$ %4($

0+--(20,)7$;)/<'$)2($+/7*$2(W1,2(9$%+$4+79$!JK$,/$2('(2?('=$>/$%4,'$

52)0%,+/)7$ 2('(2?($ (/?,2+/-(/%:$34(/$ %4($;+/9$9()7(2$ 9(6+',%'$ O!$

-,77,+/$,/$/(3$2('(2?('$,/%+$%4($'*'%(-:$%4,'$%2)/')0%,+/$/+3$)77+3'$

%4($0+--(20,)7$;)/<'$%+$-%$1($!EF!)'66'*+!'+!1&&'('*+16!6*1+3=$

@4,'$ 0)/$ ;($ )$ ?(2*$ 0+/51',/.$ 5)0%:$ '+$ 7(%$ 1'$ 2('%)%($ (B)0%7*$

34)%$ 4)66(/(9Z$ @4($ 8(9(2)7$ A('(2?($ )662+)04(9$ )$ 62,?)%($ ;+/9$

9()7(2:$)/9$32+%($4,-$)$04(0<$5+2$O!$-,77,+/$32,%%(/$+/$R%4($8(9(2)7$

A('(2?(=S$ @4,'$ -,77,+/$ 9+77)2'$ 3)'$ 02()%(9$ +1%$ +5$ %4,/$ ),2V$ ;*$


!

!QP$

9(5,/,%,+/:$ %4($ 8(9&'$ 04(0<'$ 07()2X,%$ ,'$ ,-6+'',;7($ 5+2$ %4($ 8(9$ %+$

;+1/0($)$04(0<[$

H+$ )72()9*:$ (?(/$ )%$ '%(6$ +/(:$ %4(2($ ,'$ )$ /(3$ O!$ -,77,+/$ ,/$

-+/(*$ L,/$ (7(0%2+/,0$ 5+2-N$ ,/$ %4($ (0+/+-*=$ G1%$ 34(/$ %4($ ;+/9$

9()7(2$9(6+',%'$4,'$04(0<$,/%+$%4($0+--(20,)7$;)/<,/.$'*'%(-:$7++<$

)%$ 34)%$ 4)66(/'Z$ @4($ %+%)7$ 04(0<,/.$ )00+1/%$ ;)7)/0('$ +5$ %4($

0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'$ ,/02()'($ ;*$ O!$-,77,+/$ L%4($ 04(0<,/.$ )00+1/%$ +5$

%4($ ;+/9$9()7(2$ 4,-'(75N=$ G1%$ )%$ %4($ ')-($ %,-(:$ %4(,2$ 2('(2?('$ L+/$

9(6+',%$3,%4$%4($8(9N$4)?($.+/($16$;*$O!$-,77,+/$)'$3(77=$

T($ </+3$ %4)%$ ;)/<'$ )2($ +/7*$ 2(W1,2(9$ %+$ '(%$ )',9($ !JK$ +5$

%4(,2$ 01'%+-(2$ 04(0<,/.$ )00+1/%$ ;)7)/0('$ )'$ 2('(2?('=$ @4(2(5+2(:$

%4($;)/<'$0)/$4)?($)/$+1%'%)/9,/.$%+%)7$+5$O!J$-,77,+/$,/$;)7)/0(':$

;(,/.$;)0<(9$16$;*$%4($L/(3N$O!$-,77,+/$,/$2('(2?('=$E/9$',/0($%4($

;+/9$ 9()7(2$ 4)'$ +/7*$ R'+)<(9$ 16S$ O!$ -,77,+/$ +5$ %4)%$ %+%)7:$ %4($

0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'$ )2($ 7(.)77*$ (/%,%7(9$ %+$ 02()%($ )/$ 1&&'('*+16$ OU$

-,77,+/$,/$/(3$7+)/'=$

Y+3$(B)0%7*$9+$ %4(*$9+$ %4,'\$ >/$ %4($ ')-($3)*$ %4)%$ %4($8(9$

,%'(75$ 9+('$ ,%X%4(*$ 02()%($ -+/(*$ +1%$ +5$ %4,/$ ),2:$ ]1'%$ )'$ A+%4;)29$

07),-(9$,/$+12$+6(/,/.$W1+%)%,+/$5+2$%4,'$04)6%(2=$H6(0,5,0)77*:$34(/$

)$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$4)'$R(B0(''$2('(2?('SX-()/,/.$%4)%$,%$4)'$-+2($

%4)/$!JK$,/$2('(2?(':$;)0<,/.$16$,%'$%+%)7$01'%+-(2$;)7)/0('X,%$,'$

)77+3(9$ %+$ ',-67*$ 02(9,%$ )$ 7+)/$ )667,0)/%&'$ 04(0<,/.$ )00+1/%$ 3,%4$

(B%2)$ /1-;(2'[$ 8+2$ (B)-67(:$ ,5$ )$ 0+167($ )667,('$ 5+2$ )$ OPJJ:JJJ$

-+2%.).(:$ %4($0+--(20,)7$;)/<$ ,'$ 7(.)77*$);7($ %+$',-67*$+6(/$16$)$


!

!Q^$

/(3$)00+1/%$)/9$%*6($,/$ROPJJ:JJJS$)'$%4($;)7)/0(:$3,%4$34,04$%4($

0+167($0)/$%4(/$;1*$%4(,2$92()-$4+1'(=$_+%$%++$'4);;*:$,'$,%\$

@+$2(?,(3Z$T4(/$%4($8(9$;1*'$.+?(2/-(/%$;+/9'$3+2%4$O!$

-,77,+/:$ ,%$32,%('$ )$ 04(0<$ +/$ ,%'(75$ 5+2$ %4($ )-+1/%$ +5$ %4($ 61204)'(=$

@4($6(2'+/$'(77,/.$ %4($;+/9'$ %4(/$ %)<('$ %4($ 04(0<$)/9$ L+5$ 0+12'(N$

9(6+',%'$,%$3,%4$)$0+--(20,)7$;)/<=$@4($0+--(20,)7$;)/<,/.$'*'%(-$

)%$ %4,'$ 6+,/%$ 4)'$ )/$ )99,%,+/)7$ O!$ -,77,+/$ ,/$ 2('(2?('$ L34,04$

2(-(-;(2$,/0719($/+%$]1'%$64*',0)7$0122(/0*$,/$%4($?)17%:$;1%$)7'+$)$

;)/<&'$9(6+',%'$3,%4$%4($8(9$,%'(75N=$G(0)1'($;)/<'$)2($+/7*$'1;](0%$

%+$)$!JK$2('(2?($2(W1,2(-(/%:$%4($,/02()'($+5$O!$-,77,+/$,/$2('(2?('$

-()/'$ %4)%$ %4($ ;)/<'$ )2($ /+3$ 7(.)77*$ )77+3(9$ %+$ (B6)/9$ %4(,2$

01'%+-(2'&$ %+%)7$ 04(0<;++<$ ;)7)/0('$ ;*$ O!J$ -,77,+/=$ @4($ 6(2'+/$

34+$ '+79$ %4($ ;+/9'$ %+$ %4($ 8(9$ )72()9*$ )00+1/%'$ 5+2$ O!$ -,77,+/$ +5$

%4('($/(3$04(0<;++<$;)7)/0('=$@4)%$-()/'$ %4($;)/<'$)2($'%,77$ 52(($

%+$7(/9$+1%$)/$)99,%,+/)7$OU$-,77,+/$%+$%4(,2$01'%+-(2':$)/9$,/$)$?(2*$

2()7$'(/'($%4,'$/(3$-+/(*$,'$02()%(9$+1%$+5$%4,/$),2=$

T4(/$ )77$ ,'$ '),9$ )/9$ 9+/(:$ %4($ 6(+67($ ,/$ %4,'$ 4*6+%4(%,0)7$

0+--1/,%*$)2($/+3$3)7<,/.$)2+1/9$3,%4$O!J$-,77,+/$-+2($-+/(*$

,/$ %4(,2$ 6+''('',+/:$ )/9$ '6(/9$ ,%$ +/$ .++9'$ )/9$ '(2?,0('=$ @4,'$

,/57)%,+/$+5$%4($-+/(*$'1667*$3,77$61'4$16$62,0('=$

$

$

$

$


!

!Q"$

$

$

T($4)?($+/($5,/)7$32,/<7($%+$)99$%+$+12$(B67)/)%,+/$+5$02(9,%$

,/57)%,+/=$ >/$+12$ '%+2*$ );+?(:$3($ '),9$ %4)%$34(/$ %4($8(9$ ,/](0%'$ O!$

-,77,+/$ ,/$/(3$ 2('(2?('$;*$61204)',/.$ )''(%':$ %4)%$ %4($ 0+--(20,)7$

;)/<'$2('6+/9$;*$02()%,/.$)/$)99,%,+/)7$OU$-,77,+/$,/$512%4(2$7+)/'=$

@4,'$,'$%21(=$Y+3(?(2:$,%$,'$+*($%21($%4)%$(#$!>$%,!.'%3(!91+7$%+$2(0(,?($

%4($ ,/,%,)7$O!$-,77,+/$04(0<$52+-$%4($8(9:$ ,'$ %4(2(5+2($.+,/.$%+$ 7(/9$

+1%$OU$-,77,+/$,/$/(3$7+)/'$%+$,%'$+3/$01'%+-(2'=$

@+$ '(($ 34*:$ 7(%&'$ 3)7<$ %42+1.4$ %4($ 5+77+3,/.$ '0(/)2,+Z$

E''1-($ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<$ È$ 4)'$ )$ 01'%+-(2$ 34+$ 2(0(,?('$ )$ O!$

-,77,+/$ 6)*-(/%$ 52+-$ %4($ 8(9$ L6(24)6'$ 5+2$ ;+/9'N$ )/9$ %4(/$


!

!QQ$

9(6+',%'$%4($04(0<$3,%4$;)/<$È=$G(0)1'($,%'$2('(2?('$3,%4$%4($8(9$

4)?($]1'%$,/02()'(9$;*$O!$-,77,+/:$%4($!JK$2('(2?($2(W1,2(-(/%$217($

)77+3'$;)/<$È$%+$-)<($)$7+)/$%+$a(22,77$b*/04$,/$%4($)-+1/%$+5$OU$

-,77,+/$ 9+77)2'=$ @+$ 0)22*$ %4,'$ +1%:$ ;)/<$ È$ ',-67*$ 04)/.('$ %4($

/1-;(2'$ ,/$ a(22,77$ b*/04&'$ 04(0<,/.$ )00+1/%$ )/9$ a(22,77$ b*/04$ ,'$

)1%4+2,M(9$ %+$ '6(/9$ %4($ -+/(*=$ >%&'$ 02,%,0)7$ %+$ 2()7,M($ %4)%$ %4,'$ OU$

-,77,+/$ %4)%$ 3)'$ 02(9,%(9$ %+$ a(22,77$ b*/04&'$ )00+1/%$ 9,9/&%$ R0+-($

52+-S$ '+-(34(2(V$;)/<$È$ ',-67*$ ,/02()'(9$ %4($/1-;(2$ '4+3,/.$

a(22,77$b*/04&'$;)7)/0($;*$OU$-,77,+/=$

@+$ 0+/%,/1($ +12$ '%+2*:$ '166+'($ a(22,77$ b*/04$ 9(0,9('$ %+$

61204)'($ 52+-$ %4($ cde$ 812/,%12($ H%+2(:$ OU$ -,77,+/$ ,/$ 512/,%12($ %+$

2(?)-6$)77$+5$,%'$(B(01%,?($+55,0('$/)%,+/3,9(=$>%$32,%('$)$04(0<$52+-$

,%'$ )00+1/%$ )%$ 0+--(20,)7$;)/<$È$-)9($+1%$ %+$ %4($cde$812/,%12($

F+-6)/*=$cde$F+-6)/*$9(6+',%'$%4,'$04(0<$)%$,%'$;)/<:$0+--(20,)7$

;)/<$`G=$T4)%$3,77$4)66(/$34(/$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$`G$62('(/%'$%4($

OU$-,77,+/$04(0<$%+$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$È$5+2$2(9(-6%,+/\$A(-(-;(2$

%4)%$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$È$+/7*$4)'$O!$-,77,+/$,/$2('(2?('=$


!

!Qf$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

@4($)/'3(2$ ,'$ %4)%$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$È$3,77$4)?($)$2('(2?($

9(5,0,%$ +5$ OD:!JJ:JJJ=$ A()7,M($ %4)%$ ,%'$ %+%)7$ 01'%+-(2$ 9(6+',%'$ )2($

/+3$ O!$ -,77,+/$ 4,.4(2$ %4)/$ %4(*$ 3(2($ +2,.,/)77*X;(0)1'($ 3($

)''1-($ %4($ ;+/9$ 9()7(2$ 4)'/&%$ '6(/%$ )/*$ +5$ 4,'$ /(3$ 04(0<,/.$

)00+1/%$ ;)7)/0(:$ 34(2()'$ a(22,77$ b*/04$ 4)'$ (-6%,(9$ +1%$ ,%'$ /(3$

)00+1/%X34,7($%4($;)/<&'$2('(2?('$)2($OD$-,77,+/$'-)77(2$%4)/$%4(*$

3(2($ ;(5+2($ %4($ 34+7($ 62+0(''$ .+%$ '%)2%(9=$ Y(/0(:$ ,5$ ;)/<$ È$

+2,.,/)77*$ 4)9$ ]1'%$ (/+1.4$ 2('(2?('$ %+$ 0+?(2$ ,%'$ %+%)7$ 01'%+-(2$

04(0<,/.$)00+1/%$;)7)/0(':$,%$3+179$/+3$;($OD:!JJ:JJJ$,/$%4($4+7(=$

G#'3$ ,'$ 34*$ )$ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<$ 3+179$ ;($ 5++7,'4$ %+$ 7+)/$ +1%$ 7)2.($


!

!Q#$

-17%,67('$ +5$ )/$ ,/,%,)7$ ,/](0%,+/$+5$ /(3$9(6+',%':$ ,/$ +/($ 5(77$ '3++6=$

F1'%+-(2'$34+$%)<($+1%$7+)/'$)2($7,<(7*$%+$'6(/9$%4($/(3$04(0<,/.$

)00+1/%$;)7)/0(':$)/9$,/%(2;)/<$07()2,/.$+6(2)%,+/'$3,77$'++/$-+?($

%4($(B0(''$2('(2?('$%+$+%4(2$;)/<'=$

Y+3(?(2:$ ,/$ %(2-'$ +5$ (#$! 91+7'+5! 3,3($)! 13! 1! 8#*6$:$ %4($

(B0(''$ 2('(2?('$ 0)/$ 17%,-)%(7*$ ;(0+-($ 2(W1,2(9$ 2('(2?('$ )'$ ()04$

;)/<$ '(W1(/%,)77*$ 02()%('$ -+2($ )/9$ -+2($ /(3$ 7+)/'=$ @4($ )*+$,!

):6('46'$%$ ,'$ )04,(?(9$ ;*$ )$ 0+-;,/)%,+/$ +5$ ;)/<'$ %42+1.4+1%$ %4($

0(/%2)7$ ;)/<,/.$ '*'%(-=$ g0+/+-,0'$ %(B%;++<'$ ',-67,5*$ %4($ 62+0(''$

;*$'166+',/.$%4)%$()04$;)/<$ 5+77+3'$)$ 7(/9,/.$ 5+2-17)$34,04$ ,'$ L!$

a,/1'$ %4($ a,/,-1-$ A('(2?($ A(W1,2(-(/%N$ h$ UJK$ +/$ ()04$ /(3$

9+77)2$9(6+',%(9=$ >/$+12$(B)-67(:$ %4($-)B,-1-$7+)/$)-+1/%$-)9($

%+$ a(22,77$ b*/04$ ,/$ %4($ 5,2'%$ 2+1/9$ 3+179$ ;($ OUJJ:JJJ:$ /+%$ OU$

-,77,+/=$>/$%4,'$3)*:$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$È$,'$'%,77$0+-67,)/%$3,%4$%4($

!J$6(20(/%$2('(2?($2(W1,2(-(/%:$(?(/$,5$a(22,77$b*/04$'6(/9'$)77$+5$

,%'$/(3$7+)/'$)/9$+%4(2$;)/<'$,--(9,)%(7*$9(-)/9$2(9(-6%,+/=$$


!

!QD$

$

$

C/0($ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<$ È$ 4+/+2'$ %4($ 2(9(-6%,+/$ 52+-$

0+--(20,)7$;)/<$`G:$ %4,'$;)/<$ ,'$+1%$+5$ %4($-+/(*$-17%,67,(2$ 7++6$

(?(/$%4+1.4$a(22,77$b*/04$'%,77$4)'$)$7+)/$+;7,.)%,+/$3,%4$,%=$G1%$/+3$

0+--(20,)7$;)/<$`G$0)/$ 7(/9$+1%$UJK$+/$ ,%'$9(6+',%$+5$OUJJ:JJJ=$

@4,'$ 3+179$ ;($ 7+)/'$ (W1)7,/.$ OD!J:JJJ=$ >5$ +/$ %4,'$ 04)2%$ 3($ 4)9$

)/+%4(2$;)/<:$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$`F:$%4,'$;)/<$3+179$;($);7($%+$7(/9$

+1%$UJK$+/$,%'$9(6+',%'$+5$OD!J:JJJ=$@4,'$3+179$;($ 7+)/'$(W1)7,/.$

O#PU:JJJ=$$


!

!QU$

T4)%$3($)2($92,?,/.$)%$ ,'$ %4)%$ ,%$ ,'$ %4($ %+%)7$+5$;)/<'$ ,/$ %4($

)..2(.)%($ %4)%$ (B6)/9$ %4($ -+/(*$ '1667*=$ T,%4$ ()04$ R2+1/9S$ )'$ ,%$

3(2(:$)/+%4(2$;)/<$,/$%4($04),/$0+/%2,;1%('$)$'-)77(2$,/02(-(/%$+5$)$

/(3$ 7+)/$ ,/%+$ %4($ '*'%(-=$ >/$ +12$ (B)-67(:$ ,5$ a(22,77$ b*/04$ .(%'$ )$

OUJJ:JJJ$7+)/$52+-$0+--(20,)7$;)/<$È$)/9$;1*'$512/,%12($3,%4$,%:$

cde$ F+-6)/*$ 3,77$ %4(/$ 9(6+',%$ %4($ OUJJ:JJJ$ )%$ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<$

`G=$d(%$%4,'$/(3$9(6+',%$,'$?(2*$',-,7)2$%+$%4($;+/9$9()7(2&'$+2,.,/)7$

9(6+',%$ +5$ O!$ -,77,+/:$ (B0(6%$ %4)%$ ,%$ ,'$ !J$ 6(20(/%$ '-)77(2=$ H+$ %4($

62+0(''$ 0+/%,/1('$ 5+2$ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<$ `G:$ ]1'%$ )'$ ,%$ 9,9$ 5+2$ ;)/<$

È:$ (B0(6%$ )77$ %4($ /1-;(2'$ ,/$ R2+1/9$ PS$ )2($ !JK$ 7+3(2$ %4)/$ %4(*$

3(2($,/$R2+1/9$!=S$@4($62+0(''$0)/$0+/%,/1($5+2$-)/*$2+1/9':$3,%4$

()04$'1;'(W1(/%$;)/<$-)<,/.$)$/(3$7+)/$%4)%$,'$!JK$'-)77(2$%4)/$

%4($62(?,+1'$;)/<&'$7+)/=$

G*$ ',-67*$ )99,/.$ %4($ (B6)/',+/$ +5$ 7+)/'$ 5+2$ %4($ 5,2'%$ %42(($

;)/<':$ E:$ G$ )/9$ F:$ %4($ %+%)7$ ,'$ )72()9*$ /()2,/.$ OP=Q$ -,77,+/=$ >/$ %4($

7,-,%:$%4($+2,.,/)7$O!$-,77,+/$,/](0%(9$;*$%4($8(9&'$61204)'($+5$;+/9'$

3+179$17%,-)%(7*$0)'0)9($,/%+$%4($02()%,+/$+5$)/+%4(2$OU$-,77,+/$,/$

/(3$7+)/'$)/9$'6(/9,/.$,/$%4($(0+/+-*=$

E%$ %4,'$6+,/%:$ %4($ '0)7('$-)*$;($ 5)77,/.$ 52+-$ %4($ (*('$+5$ %4($

2()9(2=$82)0%,+/)7$2('(2?($;)/<,/.$)/9$,%'$3+2<,/.'$)2($5,/)77*$;(,/.$

1/9(2'%++9=$ @4($ 9('%210%,?($ 2)-,5,0)%,+/'$ 5+2$ +12$ '+0,(%*$ )/9$ +12$

3+279$ )2($ '%)..(2,/.=$ d+1$ %4($ 2()9(2$ -)*$ ;($ 4)?,/.$ *+12$ 5,2'%$

-+-(/%$+5$07)2,%*$+/$ %4($'1;](0%$+5$ ,/57)%,+/=$T($)77$ 5)0($ ,--,/(/%$

9)/.(2=$ >5$ 3($ )2($ %+$ 4)?($ )/*$ 4+6($ +5$ '%+66,/.$ ,/57)%,+/$ )/9$ ,%'$


!

!fJ$

9('%210%,+/:$ %4,'$ 6,(0($ +5$ %4($ -*'%(2,+1'$ -+/(*$ 61MM7($ 0)//+%$ ;($

<(6%$ %+$ +/('(75V$ ,%$ -1'%$ ;($ 1/0+?(2(9$ )/9$ (B6+'(9$ %+$ %4($ .(/(2)7$

61;7,0$)'$'++/$)'$6+'',;7(=$>5$*+1$)2($/+3$)'<,/.$RY+3\S:$2()9$I)2%'$

>>$)/9$>>>$+5$%4,'$;++<$5+2$%4($?(2*$;('%$'+71%,+/=$

@4($ %42()%$ +5$ 9+1;7(i9,.,%$ 62,0($ ,/57)%,+/$ ,'$ ?(2*$ 2()7=$ @4($

0+77)6'($+5$+12$(/%,2($-+/(%)2*$'*'%(-$,'$6+'',;7(=$@4($%2,..(2$4)'$

)72()9*$;((/$6177(9=$@4($;)/<'$)%$ %4,'$?(2*$-+-(/%$)2($ ',%%,/.$+/$

-+2($2('(2?('$%4)/$%4(*$4)?($(?(2$4)9$,/$%4($4,'%+2*$+5$;)/<,/.$,/$

%4($ j/,%(9$ H%)%('[$ @4(*$ 4)?($ (B0(''$ 2('(2?('$ ,/$ 1/62(0(9(/%(9$

)-+1/%'[$ @4,'$ .2)64:$ %)<(/$ 9,2(0%7*$ 52+-$ %4($ 8(9(2)7$ A('(2?(&'$

3(;',%(:$'4+3'$%4($%(22,;7($'%+2*=$E7%4+1.4$-,77,+/'$+5$6(+67($4)?($

/+3$'((/$,%:$?(2*$5(3$0)/$1/9(2'%)/9$,%'$2)-,5,0)%,+/'$3,%4+1%$5,2'%$

4)?,/.$%4($</+37(9.($+5$%4($51/0%,+/$+5$52)0%,+/)7$2('(2?($;)/<,/.=$

d+1$ 0)/$ /+3$ '(($ ,%$ ,/$ ,%'$ 62+6(2$ 7,.4%=$ @4,'$ ,'$ ,/9((9$ )$ %(22,;7($

',%1)%,+/=$


!

!f!$

$

$

@4,'$ 04)2%$ ,'$ '%)2%7,/.=$_+%,0($ %4)%$ %4($ %,-(7,/($.+('$;)0<$ %+$

!UPQV$/+%4,/.$(?(/$2(-+%(7*$07+'($%+$+12$0122(/%$',%1)%,+/$4)'$(?(2$

+00122(9:$ (?(/$ 912,/.$ %4($ 9(6%4'$ +5$ %4($ k2()%$ l(62('',+/=$ _+%,0($

%4)%$%4($7,/($'4++%'$'%2),.4%$16$%4($04)2%$)77$,/$+/($*()2[$@4($8(9:$)'$

'4+3/$;*$%4($?(2%,0)7$7,/($-)2<,/.$(B0(''$2('(2?(':$4)'$)77+3(9$,%'$

;)7)/0($ '4((%$ %+$ (B67+9($ L;*$ 61204)',/.$ )''(%'$ %42+1.4$ +6(/$

-)2<(%$+6(2)%,+/'N$912,/.$%4($7)'%$%3+$*()2'=$>%'$;)7)/0($'4((%$3)'$

OUPJ$;,77,+/$,/$l(0(-;(2$+5$PJJ#=$>/$]1'%$+/($*()2$,%$]1-6(9$%+$OP=^$


!

!fP$

%2,77,+/$;*$l(0(-;(2$PJJD=P$@4,'$-()/'$%4)%$;)/<'$)2($',%%,/.$3,%4$

41.($(B0(''$2('(2?('$2,.4%$/+3[$

b(%$1'$'6(77$+1%$%4($6+%(/%,)7$ ,-67,0)%,+/'=$E'$+5$%4,'$32,%,/.$

L'62,/.$PJ!JN:$(B0(''$2('(2?('$4)?($(B0((9(9$O!$%2,77,+/=^$j',/.$%4($

2+1.4$ !JK$ 2('(2?($ 2)%,+:$ %4)%$ -()/'$ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'$ ,/$ %4($

j/,%(9$ H%)%('$ 4)?($ %4($ 7(.)7$ );,7,%*$ %+$ 02()%($ )/$ )99,%,+/)7$ EBH!

(%'66'*+!,/$/(3$7+)/'=$Y+3$-104$,'$%4,'\$F+/',9(2$%4)%$2,.4%$/+3$%4($

%+%)7$ )-+1/%$+5$64*',0)7$ 0122(/0*$)/9$ 04(0<;++<$9(6+',%'$4(79$;*$

%4($61;7,0$L34)%$,'$</+3/$)'$Ra!SN$,'$)$-(2($O!=#$%2,77,+/="$

@41':$ ,5$ %4($ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'$ ;(.)/$ 02()%,/.$ /(3$ 7+)/'$

6*2)-,9(9$+/$%+6$+5$%4($-)'',?($2('(2?('$%4)%$%4($8(9$4)'$61-6(9$

,/%+$%4($'*'%(-$',/0($%4($02,','$'%210<$,/$%4($5)77$+5$PJJD:$%4(*$3+179$

4)?($%4($);,7,%*$%+$0)1'($%4($(/%,2($-+/(*$'1667*$4(79$;*$%4($61;7,0$

%+$.+$16$9,!1!.1-(*%!*.!.'>$=$T4)%$9+('$%4,'$-()/\$T(77:$,5$3($)''1-($

%4)%$)77$62,0('$3+179$2('6+/9$-(04)/,0)77*$%+$%4($,/02()'(:$,%$3+179$

-()/$ .)'+7,/($ 62,0(9$ )%$ O!Q$ 6(2$ .)77+/=$ G1%$ +5$ 0+12'(:$ ,/$ '104$ )$

',%1)%,+/$6(+67($3+179$6)/,0$ )/9$ 57(($ %4($9+77)2:$-)<,/.$ %4($62,0($

,/57)%,+/$(?(/$3+2'(=$

T($9+$/+%$3,'4$%+$0)1'($%4($2()9(2$1/91($)7)2-=$T($)2($/+%$

/(0('')2,7*$4%$&'-('+5$%4)%$.)'+7,/($62,0('$3,77$'++/$4,%$O!Q=$8+2$+/($

%4,/.:$ %4($ 0+--(20,)7$ ;)/<'$ )2($ 07()27*$ /+%$ ().(2$ %+$ 02()%($ /(3$

7+)/'$)/*%,-($'++/:$;(0)1'($%4(,2$;)7)/0($'4((%'$-,.4%$%)<($512%4(2$

4,%'$)'$%4(*$0+/%,/1($%+$32,%($+55$;)9$7+)/'$)72()9*$+/$%4(,2$;++<'=$>%$

,'$ )7'+$ 6+'',;7($ %4)%$ 8(9$ 04),2$ G(/$G(2/)/<($ 0+179$ 2(?(2'($ 0+12'($


!

!f^$

)/9$;(.,/$92),/,/.$%4($(B0(''$2('(2?('$+1%$+5$%4($'*'%(-:$;(5+2($%4($

,/57)%,+/$.(/,($.(%'$+1%$+5$%4($;+%%7(=$$

A(.)297(''$+5$34,04$0+12'($4,'%+2*$17%,-)%(7*$%)<(':$*+1$%4($

2()9(2$4)?($/+3$'((/$+12$W1)/9)2*=$E/9$,%$,'$-+/'%2+1'=$

$

$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Murray Rothbard, The Mystery of Banking (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2008), p. 98. 2 For an excellent analysis of the changing composition of the Fed’s balance sheet over time, see Catherine Rampell’s NYT blog post, “Fed Balance Sheet Expansion: Some Takeaways,” May 7, 2009, at: http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/07/fed-balance-sheet-expansion-some-takeaways/. Accessed June 3, 2010. 3 The reason we have posted a slightly outdated chart—in which the excess reserves had not yet topped $800 billion—is that the St. Louis Fed truncated its data history soon after the chart in the text was captured. Consequently, if one tries to generate the most recent chart of excess reserves, it will only go back to the 1959, rather than our chart which goes back to the 1920s. 4 The St. Louis Federal Reserve lists these statistics at: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/data/M1NS.txt. Accessed June 3, 2010.

!"#$%&'(#)*+,-,".,*/#(0&(1*!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!

"#$!

!

!"#$

!"#$%&&%

'()%*+,-.%/+-)0%*+1,$2+-%

$

$!"#$%&'#!#()#*%+,#-.'#/'0)#1.%",%&234#5)#,+67.66),#'0)#8)")&%*#

)7-"-9+7#:&-;*)9#7%.6),#;2#67%&7+'2<#%6#()**#%6#'0)#6:)7+=+7#)7-"-9+7#

:&-;*)9#7%.6),#;2#8->)&"9)"'#=+%'#9-")2#%",#7)"'&%*#;%"?+"83#

!"#'0+6#6)7'+-"<#$%&'#!!<#()#)@:*%+"#'0)#A-.",#B-")2#A-*.'+-"3#!'#

+6#+"'+9%')*2#'+),#'-#'0)#)7-"-9+7#%"%*26+6#-=#'0)#C.6'&+%"#A70--*3#D"7)#

2-.#.",)&6'%",#'0)#;%6+7#9)70%"+76#-=#%#9%&?)'#)7-"-92<#2-.#(+**#6))#

0-(#'0)#=%9+*+%&#+"6'+'.'+-"6#-=#9-")2<#;%"?+"8<#%",#+"6.&%"7)#%**-(#

+",+>+,.%*6# '-# :)%7)=.**2# 7--:)&%')# '-# 8&%::*)# (+'0# '0)# :&-;*)9# -=#

67%&7+'23#

E"=-&'."%')*2<#'0)&)#%&)#:-()&=.*#=-&7)6#%'#(-&?#'-#,+6&.:'#'0)#

"%'.&%*# ,)>)*-:9)"'# -=# '0)6)#9%&?)'F;%6),<# >-*."'%&2# &)*%'+-"60+:63#

G0)# 6'.,)"'#-=#0+6'-&2#?"-(6#%**# '--#()**# '0%'# '0)# &+70#%",#:-()&=.*#

'.&"#'-#8->)&"9)"'#=-&#6:)7+%*#:&+>+*)8)6#%",#0%",-.'6<#%",#6%;-'%8)#

'0)#:)%7)=.*#-:)&%'+-"#-=#'0)#9%&?)'#)7-"-923#

!"# '0+6# 6)7'+-"# ()# (+**# )@:*%+"# '0%'# 8->)&"9)"'# +"')&=)&)"7)#

(+'0# '0)#9%&?)'# )7-"-92# *)%,6# '-# '0)# =+"%"7+%*# 7&+6)6# '0%'# 6))9# '-#

+")@:*+7%;*2#:*%8.)#-.&#7-."'&23#H-"'&%&2#'-#:-:.*%&#;)*+)=<#+'#(%6#"-'#

*%+66)IF=%+&)# 7%:+'%*+69# '0%'# 7%.6),# '0)# 0-.6+"8# ;.;;*)# %",# 7&%60# -=#

'0)#JKKK6<#"-&#,+,#+'#7%.6)#'0)#8&)%'#6'-7?#9%&?)'#7&%60#-=#LMJM3##

!"#$%&'()*%+,-./%0,.*1%+,2-$3,.%NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN#

#

!""$

O)+'0)&# P)-&8)#53# Q.60# "-&# )>)"# R)&;)&'# R-->)&#()&)# =&))F

9%&?)'# +,)-*-8.)6S# -"# '0)# 7-"'&%&2<# '0)2#()&)#Q+8#P->)&"9)"'#9)"#

(0-#)@:%",),#'0)#67%*)#-=#'0)#=),)&%*#8->)&"9)"'#-"#'0)+&#&)6:)7'+>)#

(%'70)63#

!"# -&,)&# '-# .",)&6'%",# '0)# A-.",# B-")2# A-*.'+-"<# 2-.# 9.6'#

=+&6'#.",)&6'%",#0-(#9-")2#%",#;%"?+"8#(-.*,#(-&?# +"#%#8)".+")*2#

=&))# 9%&?)'# )">+&-"9)"'<# (+'0-.'# 8->)&"9)"'# -;6'%7*)6# '-#

7-9:)'+'+-"# -&# ;%+*-.'6# =-&# :-*+'+7%**2# 7-"")7'),# +"')&)6'63# G0)"# 2-.#

(+**#.",)&6'%",#0-(#-.&#:&)6)"'<#:)&>)&'),#626')9#7%.6)6#%**#-=#'0)#+**6#

'0%'# %&)# '2:+7%**2# ;*%9),# -"# /7%:+'%*+6934# T-.#(+**# '0)"# .",)&6'%",#

'0)# ")7)66+'2# -=# '0)# A-.",# B-")2# A-*.'+-"U'0%'# '0)# -"*2# (%2# '-#

:)&9%")"'*2# )*+9+"%')# =+"%"7+%*# 7&+6)6<# %",# '0)# %**F'--F=%9+*+%&#

;--9V;.6'# 727*)<# +6# '-# 8)'# '0)# 8->)&"9)"'# -.'# -=# '0)# ;.6+")66# -=#

:&+"'+"8#9-")2#%",#:&-::+"8#.:#=%+*),#;%"?63#

$

$

!"#$

!"#$%&'()(

*"&(+,-&(,.(/,01#-(234%1%5%1,34(

$

$

!"#$%&'()*+%&#"$(#,-.-/-0+*-"%1#"%'#2$)*#

+33(',-+*'# *4+*# *4'# '5*'%&'&# "(&'(#

(')$/*'&# %"*# 6("2# 4$2+%# &')-7%# "(#

-%*'%*-"%# 8$*# )3"%*+%'"$)/9:# -*# +(")'#

6("2# $%-%*'%*-"%+//9# ,"%6"(2-%7# *"#

,'(*+-%# *(+&-*-"%+/# +%&# /+(7'/9# %&'()#

3(+,*-,');#

<=(-'&(-,4#>+9'?@#

$

$

&*+()$ -%)*-*$*-"%)$ (',$ ',)(-+&./0+1/$ (.2$ 3,0(4+&'()$

1'(*-+*,/$ -0(-$ ())&5$ 06%(./$ -&$ 3,--,'$ *&1,$ 5+-0$ -0,$

1'&3),%/$&7$)+7,$+.$-0+/$5&')28$9-$-0,$%&/-$:,.,'()$),4,);$+./-+-6-+&./$

*(.$+.*)62,$/-(1),/$&7$/&*+,-<$/6*0$(/$-0,$7(%+)<$(.2$-0,$%&'()$*&2,;$

36-$ +./-+-6-+&./$ *(.$()/&$ +.*)62,$ 7(+')<$ -'+4+()$ ,=(%1),/$ /6*0$(/$ -0,$

1'(*-+*,$&7$-+11+.:$&'$:+4+.:$:+7-/$&.$3+'-02(</8$

>./-+-6-+&./$ 1'&4+2,$ ($ 7'(%,5&'?$ &7$ *&.-+.6+-<$ (.2$

1',2+*-(3+)+-<$ -0(-$ ())&5/$ 1,&1),$ -&$ %&',$ (**6'(-,)<$ 1)(.$ -0,+'$

(*-+4+-+,/8$>.$1('-+*6)(';$+./-+-6-+&./$0,)1$6/$+.-,'(*-$5+-0$,(*0$&-0,'$

3<$+%1&/+.:$($/,./,$&7$/-(3+)+-<$(.2$&'2,'$&.-&$-0,$+.+-+())<$*0(&-+*$

@6%3),$&7$)+7,8$A,$())$6.2,'/-(.2$-0(-$1(',.-/$(.2$-,(*0,'/$.,,2$-&$

B$

!"#$%&'#$&($)&*+,'$-./0+010+&./$AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA#

#

!"C$

1'&4+2,$($D'&6-+.,E$7&'$<&6.:$*0+)2',.;$36-$+'&.+*())<$5,$(26)-/$.,,2$

'&6-+.,/$ &6'/,)4,/$ 7&'$ %&2,'.$ *+4+)+F(-+&.$ -&$ 3,$ 1&//+3),8$ A,$ :&$

-0'&6:0$&6'$'&6-+.,/$&7$:&+.:$-&$5&'?;$36<+.:$+-,%/$7'&%$-0,$/-&',;$

:&+.:$0&%,$-&$)+4,$5+-0$&6'$7(%+)<$%,%3,'/$G&'$'&&%%(-,/H;$(.2$&7$

*&6'/,$5,$2+',*-)<$*&%%6.+*(-,$5+-0$,(*0$&-0,'$5+-0$-0,$+./-+-6-+&.$

&7$ )(.:6(:,I*&%1),-,$ 5+-0$ +-/$ '6),/$ &7$ :'(%%('$ (.2$ 2,7+.+-+&./$

-0(-$,4,'<&.,$+.$-0,$*&%%6.+-<$/0(',/8$

$

*"&(6#%#-(!,30&1%(

$

J.,$ &7$ -0,$ /*&6':,/$ &7$ -0,$ KL-0$ *,.-6'<$ 5(/$ -0,$ (''&:(.-$

3,)+,7$ 3<$%(.<$ +.-,)),*-6()/$ -0(-$ -0,<$ *&6)2$&4,'-6'.$ -0,$ +.0,'+-,2$

/&*+()$ &'2,'$ (.2$ ',%(?,$ /&*+,-<$ 7'&%$ /*'(-*08$ >.$ -0,+'$ 4+,5;$ +7$ -0,$

,=+/-+.:$ *6/-&%/$ (.2$ /&*+()$ 1'(*-+*,/$ *&6)2.M-$ 3,$ @6/-+7+,2$ &.$ ($

16',)<$ D'(-+&.()+/-E$ 3(/+/;$ -0,.$ -0,<$ 5,',$ &34+&6/)<$ &3/&),-,$ (.2$

/0&6)2$3,$@,--+/&.,2$+.$7(4&'$&7$.,5;$D/*+,.-+7+*E$1'+.*+1),/8$

A,$ 0(4,$ 16-$ -0,/,$ -,'%/$ +.$ N6&-(-+&.$ %('?/$ 3,*(6/,$ +.$

',()+-<;$ +-$ 5(/$ +.*',2+3)<$ -((+*-"%+/$ -&$ -'<$ -&$ ',4(%1$ /&*+,-<$ 7'&%$

/*'(-*0;$ (.2$ +-$ 5(/$ 4,'<$ $%),-'%*-6-,$ -&$ -'<$ -&$ /63/-+-6-,$ -0,$ -+%,O

-,/-,2$ -'(2+-+&./$ 5+-0$ .,5$ 1'(*-+*,/$ 2',(%,2$ 61$ 3<$ +2,()+/-+*$

',4&)6-+&.('+,/8$ P'+,2'+*0$ Q(<,?;$ &.,$ &7$ -0,$ %&/-$ *,),3'(-,2$

96/-'+(.$ ,*&.&%+/-/$ (.2$ 5+..,'$ &7$ -0,$ !R#S$ T&3,)$ U'+F,;$ -,'%,2$

-0+/$063'+/$*4'#6+*+/#,"%,'-*8$>.$0+/$3&&?$!4'#=+*+/#B"%,'-*:#!4'#C(("()#

"6#D",-+/-)2;$Q(<,?$5'+-,/V$


#

!"R$

$WX0,$ /&*+()+/-/Y$ (//6%,$ -0(-;$ /+.*,$ 1,&1),$ 0(2$ 3,,.$ (3),$ -&$

7'%'(+*'$ /&%,$ /</-,%$ &7$ '6),/$ W+.$ /&*+,-<Y$ *&&'2+.(-+.:$ -0,+'$

,77&'-/;$-0,<$%6/-$()/&$3,$(3),$-&$&')-7%$(.$,4,.$3,--,'$(.2$%&',$

:'(-+7<+.:$ /</-,%8$ Z6-$ +7$ 06%(.?+.2$ &5,/$ +-/$ 4,'<$ ,=+/-,.*,$ -&$

&.,$ 1('-+*6)('$ '6),O:6+2,2$ 7&'%$ &7$ *&.26*-$ &7$ 1'&4,.$

,77,*-+4,.,//;$ +-$ /+%1)<$ 2&,/$ .&-$ 0(4,$ -0,$ &1-+&.$ &7$ *0&&/+.:$

(.&-0,'$%,',)<$ 7&'$ -0,$ /(?,$&7$ -0,$ (11(',.-$1),(/(.-.,//$ &7$ +-/$

+%%,2+(-,)<$ 4+/+3),$ ,77,*-/8$ X0,$ 2+/16-,$ 3,-5,,.$ -0,$ %('?,-$

&'2,'$(.2$/&*+()+/%$+/$.&$),//$-0(.$($%(--,'$&7$/6'4+4()8$X&$7&))&5$

/&*+()+/-$%&'()+-<$5&6)2$2,/-'&<$%6*0$&7$1',/,.-$06%(.?+.2$(.2$

+%1&4,'+/0$%6*0$&7$-0,$',/-8K$

$

X0,$ -'(:+*$ %+/-(?,$ &7$ -0,$ /&*+()+/-$ ',7&'%,'/$ &7$ -0,$ KL-0$

*,.-6'<$5(/$ +.$ -0+.?+.:$ -0(-$ -0,<$ *&6)2$ ',-(+.$ -0,$ 3&6.-<$ &7$ 7',,O

%('?,-$ *(1+-()+/%;$ 50+),$ *&'',*-+.:$ +-/$ ()),:,2$ 7(6)-/$ /6*0$ (/$

+.,N6()+-+,/$ +.$ 5,()-0$ &'$ 1,'+&2/$ &7$ 0+:0$ 6.,%1)&<%,.-8$ Z6-$ 3<$

&4,'-6'.+.:$-0,$-'(2+-+&.()$'6),/$&7$1'&1,'-<$'+:0-/;$-0,$/&*+()+/-/$2+2$

.&-$*',(-,$($6-&1+(8$>./-,(2$-0,<$6.5+--+.:)<$1(4,2$-0,$5(<$7&'$-0,$

%&/-$ %6'2,'&6/$ ',:+%,/$ +.$ 06%(.$ 0+/-&'<;$ 50,-0,'$ &.$ -0,$ D),7-E$

GB-()+.+/-$[6//+($(.2$\(&+/-$]0+.(H$&'$-0,$D'+:0-E$GQ+-),'M/$^,'%(.<;$

50,',$-0,$T(F+$U('-<$5(/$-0,$T(-+&.()$D",-+/-)*#U('-<H8$

$


#

!#L$

*"&( +&45-%4( ,.( 758#3( 90%1,3:( ;5%( <,%( ,.( 758#3(

=&41>3(

$

J.,$&7$Q(<,?M$%(@&'$+./+:0-/$5(/$-0(-$-0,$7(-()$*&.*,+-$&7$-0,$

/&*+()+/-$ +.-,)),*-6()/$ ),2$ -0,%$ -&$ 3,)+,4,$ -0(-$ /+%1)<$ 3,*(6/,$ ($

/&*+()$ +./-+-6-+&.$ 5(/$ ,('+*'&$ 3<$ 06%(./;$ -0(-$ +-$ 5(/$ -0,',7&',$

&')-7%'&$3<$-0,%$(.2$*&6)2;$+.$1'+.*+1),;$3,$('&')-7%'&$(/$($.,5$(.2$

+%1'&4,2$ +./-+-6-+&.8$ _/1,*+())<$ 3,7&',$ 5+-.,//+.:$ -0,$ 0&''&'/$ &7$

-&-()+-('+(.+/%;$%(.<$D:&&2$%,.E$3,)+,4,2$-0(-$($3,--,'$5&')2$*&6)2$

3,$*',(-,2$ +7$&.)<$ -0,$/%('-,/-;$%&/-$06%(.,$%,.$16-$ -0,+'$0,(2/$

-&:,-0,'$(.2$*'(7-,2$($3,--,'$1)(.$7&'$/&*+,-<8$>./-,(2$&7$-0,$(.('*0+*$

%('?,-$/</-,%;$ +.$50+*0$:&&2/$(.2$/,'4+*,/$5,',$1'&26*,2$&.$-0,$

3(/+/$ &7$ 1'&7+-;$ -0,$ /&*+()+/-/$ 5(.-,2$ -0,$ B-(-,$ -&$ &':(.+F,$ ())$

1'&26*-+&.$+.$-0,$/,'4+*,$&7$3'"3/'8$>-$5(/$/+%1)<$-0,$',+.*('.(-+&.$

&7$U)(-&M/$4+/+&.$&7$'6),$3<$-0,$10+)&/&10,'$?+.:/8$

Z,/+2,/$-0,+'$.(`4,$-'6/-$+.$-0&/,$50&$5&6)2$/,+F,$1&5,'$+.$($

/&*+()+/-$ B-(-,;$ -0,$ +.-,)),*-6()/$ *&%%+--,2$ ($ 3(/+*$%+/-(?,$ +.$ -0,+'$

(.()</+/8$9/$Q(<,?$',1,(-,2)<$(':6,2;$-0,/,$+.-,)),*-6()/$&4,')&&?,2$

-0,$*(1(*+-<$&7$/&*+()$ +./-+-6-+&./$ -&$ -(1$ -0,$&-)3'()'&# ?%"E/'&7'$&7$

-0,$ ,.-+',$ *&%%6.+-<8$ B&$ '(-0,'$ -0(.$ ',)<+.:$ &.$ ($ 7,5$ &7$ -0,$

D/%('-,/-$:6</$ +.$ -0,$ '&&%E$ -&$2,/+:.$($.,5$/&*+,-<$ 7'&%$-0,$ -&1O

2&5.;$ -0,$ +.0,'+-,2$ /&*+()$ +./-+-6-+&./$ ,77,*-+4,)<$ /&)+*+-,2$ +.16-$

7'&%$'.'(9"%';$3&-0$3'+))+(.-$(.2$26))8$X0,$*&%3+.,2$?.&5),2:,$(.2$

,=1,'+,.*,$&7$-0,$,.-+',$*&%%6.+-<$5(/$()5(</$3,--,'$-0(.$-0(-$&7$


#

!#!$

(.<$/%())$ /(%1),$&7$ +.2+4+26()/;$,4,.$ +7$ -0&/,$ +.2+4+26()/$5,',$ -0,$

3,/-$(.2$-0,$3'+:0-,/-8$

>-$ 5(/$ 6.2,'/-(.2(3),$ -0(-$ -0,$ /&*+()+/-$ ',7&'%,'/$

&4,')&&?,2$-0+/$?,<$+./+:0-a$+-$-&&?$($/*0&)('$&7$Q(<,?M/$3'+))+(.*,$-&$

7),/0$ &6-$ -0,$ 1&+.-$ 26'+.:$ 0+/$ )&.:$ *(',,'8$ Q(<,?$ 2,4&-,2$ ('-+*),/$

(.2$ 3&&?/$ -&$ -0,$ /-62<$ &7$ )3"%*+%'"$)# "(&'();$ ',7,''+.:$ -&$ /,)7O

&':(.+F+.:$/</-,%/$-0(-$,=0+3+-,2$1',2+*-(3),$1(--,'./;$,4,.$-0&6:0$

.&3&2<$ 2,)+3,'(-,)<$ /,-$ (3&6-$ -&$ ,('+*'$ /6*0$ (.$ &'2,')<$ 1(--,'.8$

Z&''&5+.:$ ($ 10'(/,$ 7'&%$ -0,$ B*&--+/0$ %&'()$ 10+)&/&10,'$ 92(%$

P,':6/&.;$ Q(<,?$ /(+2$ -0(-$ +.$ ($ /&*+()$ *&.-,=-;$ /1&.-(.,&6/$ &'2,'/$

5,',$D-0,$1'&26*-$&7$06%(.$(*-+&.;$36-$.&-$&7$06%(.$2,/+:.8E$

A0(-$ 2+2$ Q(<,?$ %,(.$ 3<$ -0+/$ &22$ 10'(/,b$ Q,$ 5(/$

6.2,'/*&'+.:$ -0,$ *'6*+()$ 7(*-$ -0(-$ /&%,$ &7$ &6'$ %&/-$ +%1&'-(.-$

+./-+-6-+&./I+.*)62+.:$/1&?,.$ )(.:6(:,;$&6'$'6),/$&7$%&'()+-<;$(.2$

-0,$%('?,-$ ,*&.&%<$ +-/,)7I(',$ &34+&6/)<$ .&-$ D.(-6'()E$ *',(-+&./;$

36-$ +./-,(2$ (',$ *),(')<$ -0,$ ',/6)-$ &7$ 06%(.$ 3,+.:/8$ J.$ -0,$ &-0,'$

0(.2;$5,$*(.M-$/*&6'$-0,$0+/-&'<$3&&?/$-&$7+.2$&6-$50+*0$5+/,$?+.:;$

&'$ :'&61$ &7$ /*0&)('/;$ -%.'%*'&$ -0,$ _.:)+/0$ )(.:6(:,;$ &'$ '6),/$ &7$

%&'()+-<;$ &'$ -0,$ &1,'(-+&.$ &7$ -0,$ *(1+-()+/-$ /</-,%8$ X0,$ ,(')+,/-$

,*&.&%+/-/$/(5$-0,$0(.2$&7$^&2$3,0+.2$-0,/,$&'2,')<$&6-*&%,/;$36-$

3&-0$-0,+/-$(.2$/?,1-+*()$5'+-,'/$6.2,'/-&&2$-0(-$06%(.$3,+.:/$&.$

-0,+'$&5.$2+2$.&-$2,/+:.$/6*0$+./-+-6-+&./8$

Z,7&',$ -(*?)+.:$ -0,$%&',$*&%1),=$/1&.-(.,&6/$&'2,'$&7$ -0,$

%&2,'.$%('?,-$,*&.&%<;$ ),-M/$ /-('-$5+-0$($ /+%1),$,=(%1),V$($1(-0$


#

!#K$

-0'&6:0$($ 7&',/-8$A0,.$($.,5*&%,'$3,:+./$($0+?,$ +.$ -0,$ 7&',/-;$0,$

5+))$ )+?,)<$ -(?,$ -0,$1(-0$&7$ ),(/-$ ',/+/-(.*,;$%,(.+.:$0,$5+))$ 7&))&5$

-0,$5,))O5&'.$-'(+)$-0(-$&-0,'/$0(4,$()',(2<$*',(-,28$T&5$-0+/$1(-0$

&'$-'(+)$+/$*),(')<$-0,$',/6)-$&7$06%(.$(*-+&.a$-0,$3'(.*0,/$5,',$.&-$

',%&4,2$3<$ 3,(4,'/;$ (.2$ -0,$ 7&)+(:,$ &.$ -0,$ :'&6.2$5(/$.&-$ ,(-,.$

(5(<$ 3<$ *&5/8$ _4,.$ /&;$ 5,$ 2&.M-$ .,,2$ -&$ (//6%,$ -0(-$ -0,$ 7+'/-$

06%(.$ -&$ /-6%3),$ +.-&$ -0,$ 4+':+.$ 5&&2/;$ 2,)+3,'(-,)<$ /,-$ &6-$ -&$

*',(-,$($1(-0$-&$/,'4,$/63/,N6,.-$-'(4,),'/8$

J.$ -0,$ *&.-'('<;$ +-M/$ ()%&/-$ *,'-(+.)<$ -0,$ *(/,$ -0(-$ -0,$ 7+'/-$

1,'/&.$-&$5(.2,'$+.-&$-0,$7&',/-$1+*?,2$0+/$5(<$-0'&6:0$+-;$)&&?+.:$

7&'$-0,$%&/-$(24(.-(:,&6/$'&6-,8$Q,$&34+&6/)<$5&6)2$5()?$('&6.2$

)(':,$ -',,/;$ 5&6)2$ (4&+2$ 1'+*?)<$ 36/0,/;$ (.2$5&6)2.M-$ 5()?$ +.-&$ ($

2,,1$'+4,'8$Z6-$50(-$-0,$1+&.,,'$5&6)2$3,$2&+.:;$N6+-,$6.5+--+.:)<;$

5(/$ %(?,$ +-$ ,(/+,'$ 7&'$ -0,$ %'5*$ 1,'/&.$ -&$ 7&))&5$ +.$ 0+/$ 7&&-/-,1/8$

U,'0(1/$0,$5&6)2$*(''<$($%(*0,-,$(.2$0(*?$(5(<$-0,$3'(.*0,/$(/$

0,$ /-6%3),2$ ()&.:$ -0+/$ %(+2,.$ 4&<(:,a$ -0+/$ 5&6)2$ %(?,$ +-$ %6*0$

,(/+,'$7&'$-0,$.,=-$1,'/&.$-&$-(?,$-0,$/(%,$'&6-,8$

^'(26())<;$ &4,'$ -0,$ 2,*(2,/;$ (.2$ ,/1,*+())<$ +7$ 06.2',2/$ &7$

1,&1),$ 0(2$ -&$ 5()?$ -0'&6:0$ -0+/$ 1('-+*6)('$ 7&',/-;$ ($ D:&&2E$ '&6-,$

5&6)2$3,$2+/*&4,',28$ >-/$,=*,)),.*,$5&6)2$3,$,.0(.*,2$,4,'<$ -+%,$

(.&-0,'$1,'/&.$5()?,2$()&.:$+-;$7&'$,(*0$/6*0$1(//(:,$5&6)2$/-(%1$

2&5.$ (.<$ 5,,2/$ (--,%1-+.:$ -&$ :'&5$ +.$ -0,$ 2+'-$ -'(+);$ (.2$ 5&6)2$

/.(1$(.<$/%())$3'(.*0,/$-0(-$0(2$4,.-6',2$+.-&$-0,$*&''+2&'8$


#

!#c$

X0+/$0<1&-0,-+*()$1(-0$-0'&6:0$-0,$7&',/-$5&6)2$-06/$*),(')<$

3,$-0,$',/6)-$&7$06%(.$(*-+&.;$(.2$<,-$.&-$&7$06%(.$2,/+:.8$9))$&7$-0,$

0+?,'/$ ,"//',*-.'/9$ *&.-'+36-,2$ -&$ +-/$ *',(-+&.;$ &4,'$ -0,$ *&6'/,$ &7$

2,*(2,/;$ ,4,.$ -0&6:0$ ,(*0$ +.2+4+26()$ 0+?,'$5(/$ (*-+.:$ +.$ 0+/$ &5.$

+.-,',/-$ (.2$ +.$ 7(*-$ 1'&3(3)<$ 0(2$ .&$ +2,($ 0,$ 5(/$ (//+/-+.:$ ())$

/63/,N6,.-$0+?,'/8$

T&5$ +-M/$ -'6,;$ -0,$ 1(-0$ %+:0-$ .&-$ 3,$ D&1-+%()E$ 7'&%$ -0,$

4+,51&+.-$&7$($1('?$'(.:,'$50&$*&.26*-/$($0,)+*&1-,'$/6'4,<$&7$-0,$

,.-+',$7&',/-8$X0,$'(.:,'$%+:0-$)(%,.-$-0,$7(*-$-0(-$-0,$1(-0$:&,/$($

*,'-(+.$5(<;$ '(-0,'$ -0(.$(.&-0,'8$_4,.$/&;$*+?-%7# *4'# E"(/&# +)# -*# -);$

-0,$'(.:,'$',()+F,/$-0(-$+-$5&6)2$3,$-&&$*&.76/+.:$-&$ -'<$-&$D7+=E$-0,$

1(-08$>-$5&6)2$-(?,$($)&-$&7$%(.1&5,'$G5+-0$%(*0,-,/$(.2$(=,/H$-&$

*),('$ -0,$ D3,--,'E$ 1(-0;$ (.2$ -0,.$ -0,$ '(.:,'$5&6)2$ 0(4,$ -&$ /,-$ 61$

7,.*,/$&'$&-0,'$&3/-(*),/$-&$+.26*,$1,&1),$-&$/-&1$6/+.:$-0,$&'+:+.();$

*&.4,.+,.-$1(-08$

J6'$ /+%1),$ ,=(%1),$ &7$ ($ 1(-0$ -0'&6:0$ ($ 7&',/-$ +/$ ($ :&&2$

%,-(10&'$7&'$-0,$96/-'+(./M$+./+:0-/$&.$-0,$+./-+-6-+&./$&7$($%('?,-$

,*&.&%<8$A,$5+))$ &6-)+.,$ /&%,$&7$ -0,$%&/-$ +%1&'-(.-$ &.,/$ +.$ -0,$

7&))&5+.:$ *0(1-,'/8$ Z6-$ +-$ +/$ +%1&'-(.-$ -&$ ?,,1$ +.$ %+.2$ -0(-$ ,4,.$

-0&6:0$5,$5+))$2+/*6//$-0,$'&),$&'$D76.*-+&.E$&7$,(*0$+./-+-6-+&.;$(.2$

0&5$ +-$ 0,)1/$ 06%(./$ 2,()$ 5+-0$ -0,$ ,*&.&%+*$ 1'&3),%$ &7$ /*('*+-<;$

-0(-$,4,.$/&$-0,/,$+./-+-6-+&./$5,',$.&-$*&./*+&6/)<$+.4,.-,2$3<$(.<$

06%(.$3,+.:8$

$


#

!#S$

$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Friedrich A. Hayek (ed. W. W. Bartley III), The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1988), p. 6. 2 Hayek, The Fatal Conceit, p. 7.

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

+',-#%&(+'.$&'%/(

$

$

!"#$%"&'( )#%*( +#&( %,-*&( .%/01*%( &2%"%(

0"%( 304*5(.1&( 304*(%,-*&(.%/01*%(&2%"%(

-*($"#$%"&'6(

78"%)%"-/(90*&-0&:(

$

$

%&$'($)*&$+',)$(-%./+&%)/0$,'12/0$2%,)2)-)2'%,$2,$$"-;0&%(

$"#$%"&'3$ 4%$ /$ 1/52)/02,)$ ,6,)&+7$ /00$ 52&1&,$ '($ )/%8290&$

:&/0)*7$ 2%10-.2%8$%')$ ;-,)$1'%,-+&<$8''.,$=>?,7$1'+5-)&<,7$ ,5'<),$

1/<,7$52@@/,A$9-)$/0,'$1/52)/0$8''.,$=)</1)'<,$/%.$.<200$5<&,,&,A$/%.$

%/)-</0$ <&,'-<1&,7$ /<&$ ':%&.$ 96$ 5<2B/)&$ 2%.2B2.-/0,3$ C'+&)2+&,$

0/<8&$ /,,&),$ ,-1*$ /,$ /$+/;'<$ 1'<5'</)2'%$ /<&$ ':%&.$96$ /$ 8<'-5$'($

2%.2B2.-/0,7$ 9-)$ &B&%$ *&<&$ )*&<&$ /<&$ .&(2%2)&$ ':%&<,*25$ 10/2+,$ '($

&/1*$5&<,'%$)'$/$,5&12(21$5'<)2'%$'($)*&$)')/0$/,,&)3$

D2,)'<2/%,$ /%.$ /%)*<'5'0'82,),$ 1/%$ .&9/)&$ )*&$ .2((&<&%)$

,6,)&+,$'($5<'5&<)6$0/:$2%$B/<2'-,$1-0)-<&,$(<'+$.2((&<&%)$&</,$/%.$

.2((&<&%)$ <&82'%,$ '($ )*&$ :'<0.3$ D':&B&<7$ 2%$ )&<+,$ '($ &1'%'+21$

/%/06,2,7$ )*&$ (-%1)2'%$'($5<2B/)&$5<'5&<)6$<28*),$ 2,$ ,)</28*)('<:/<.E$

F&1/-,&$ )*2,$ :'<0.$ 2,$ 50/8-&.$ 96$ ,1/<12)6G)*&<&$ /<&$ -%02+2)&.$

*-+/%$.&,2<&,$9-)$'%06$02+2)&.$<&,'-<1&,$)'$,/)2,(6$)*&+G)*&<&$2,$/$

%/)-</0$ /#+<3-/&$ 'B&<$ )*&$ -,&$ '($ )*&,&$ <&,'-<1&,3$ 4)$ 2,$ )*&$ ,'12/0$

H$

!"#$%&'(!")*'"&+(==========================================================(

(

!"I$

(-%1)2'%$ '($ 5<'5&<)6$ <28*),$ )'$ 9&$ )*&$ J)2&$ 9<&/K&<L$ /,$ 2)$ :&<&7$

:*&%&B&<$1'%(021)$/<2,&,3$M-,)<2/%$&1'%'+2,)$D/%,$D'55&$&N50/2%,E$

$O'<$ /$ 1'%1&5)$ '($ 5<'5&<)6$ )'$ /<2,&7$ )*&<&$ +-,)$ 9&$ /$ ,1/<12)6$ '($

8''.,3$ C*'-0.$ )*&<&$ 9&$%'$ ,1/<12)67$ /%.$ ,*'-0.$ /00$ 8''.,$9&$ ,'P

1/00&.$ J(<&&$ 8''.,L$ :*',&$ -,&$ 96$ /%6$ '%&$ 5&<,'%$ ('<$ /%6$ '%&$

5-<5',&$ :'-0.$ %')$ 2%$ /%6$ :/6$ &N10-.&$ ='<$ 2%)&<(&<&$ :2)*$ '<$

<&,)<21)A$ 2),$ -,&$ 96$ /%6$ ')*&<$ 5&<,'%$ '<$ ('<$ /%6$ ')*&<$ 5-<5',&7$

)*&%$ )*&<&$:'-0.$9&$%'$%&&.$ ('<$ 5<'5&<)63$ 4(7$ 0&)$ -,$ ,/67$ .-&$ )'$

,'+&$ 5/</.2,2/1$ ,-5&</9-%./%1&$ '($ 9/%/%/,7$ +6$ 5<&,&%)$

1'%,-+5)2'%$ '($ 9/%/%/,$ .'&,$ %')$ 2%$ /%6$ :/6$ <&.-1&$ +6$ ':%$

(-)-<&$ ,-5506$ =5',,290&$ 1'%,-+5)2'%A$ '($ 9/%/%/,7$ %'<$ )*&$

5<&,&%)$ '<$ )*&$ (-)-<&$ ,-5506$ '($ 9/%/%/,$ ('<$ /%6$ ')*&<$ 5&<,'%7$

)*&%$ )*&$ /,,28%+&%)$ '($ 5<'5&<)6$ <28*),7$ *&<&$ :2)*$ <&,5&1)$ )'$

9/%/%/,7$ :'-0.$ 9&$ ,-5&<(0-'-,3$ >'$ .&B&0'5$ )*&$ 1'%1&5)$ '($

5<'5&<)67$ 2)$ 2,$%&1&,,/<6$('<$8''.,$)'$9&$,1/<1&7$,'$)*/)$1'%(021),$

'B&<$)*&$-,&$'($)*&,&$8''.,$1/%$5',,2906$/<2,&3$4)$2,$)*&$(-%1)2'%$'($

5<'5&<)6$ <28*),$ )'$ /B'2.$ ,-1*$ 5',,290&$ 10/,*&,$ 'B&<$ )*&$ -,&$ '($

,1/<1&$ <&,'-<1&,$ 96$ /,,28%2%8$ <28*),$ '($ &N10-,2B&$ ':%&<,*253$

Q<'5&<)6$ 2,$ )*-,$ /$ %'<+/)2B&$ 1'%1&5)E$ /$ 1'%1&5)$ .&,28%&.$ )'$

+/K&$/$1'%(021)P(<&&$ 2%)&</1)2'%$5',,290&$96$,)25-0/)2%8$+-)-/006$

92%.2%8$<-0&,$'($1'%.-1)$=%'<+,A$<&8/<.2%8$,1/<1&$<&,'-<1&,3R$

$

>'$<&5&/)7$:&$/<&$%')$*&<&$)/0K2%8$/9'-)$*$%/-<-/()-*&"-.1&-#+*(

'($5<'5&<)6$<28*),3$4)$+/6$B&<6$:&00$9&$)*/)$'-<$1-<<&%)$0&8/0$,6,)&+$

*/,$ 82B&%$ 2),$ &%.'<,&+&%)$ '($ J5<'5&<)6$ <28*),L$ )*/)$ /<&$ 2%$ (/1)$ )*&$

!"#$%&'(!")*'"&+(==========================================================(

(

!""$

<&,-0)$'($*2,)'<21/0$ 2%;-,)21&,3$S&$/<&$%')$.&(&%.2%8$=%'<$/))/1K2%8A$

)*&$1-<<&%)$/,,28%+&%)$'($5<'5&<)6$<28*),3$

S*/)$ :&$ 0"%( ,/62%8$ 2,$ )*/)$ 5<2B/)&$ 5<'5&<)6$ 2),&0($ 2,$ /%$

2%.2,5&%,/90&$ 2%,)2)-)2'%7$:2)*'-)$:*21*$+'.&<%$12B202@/)2'%$:'-0.$

9&$2+5',,290&3$4%.&&.$2)$2,$,-1*$/$9&.<'1K$'($,'12&)6$)*/)$'%&$'($)*&$

>&%$ T'++/%.+&%),$ =J>*'-$ ,*/0)$ %')$ ,)&/03LA$ 5<&,-55',&,$ )*&$

&N2,)&%1&$'($5<'5&<)6$<28*),3$

$

$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Frederic Bastiat, “Property and Law” (1848), at: http://bastiat.org/en/property_law.html. Accessed June 4, 2010. 2 Hans Hoppe, A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism (U.S.A.: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1990), p. 18. Available at: http://mises.org/books/Socialismcapitalism.pdf. Accessed May 25, 2010.

!"#$%&'(!")*'"&+(!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!

"#$!

!

!"#$

!"#$%&'())(

*'#+&(

$

$

!"#$%&'( "#( )( #$&*++,-( .-$/--0( $/%(

1&"02"1,-#3( $4-( 1-)2-5*,( 1&"02"1,-3(

/4"24( )67)02-#( $4-( 6-7-,%18-0$( %5(

$&)6-3( )06( $4-( 8","$)&"#$9"81-&"),"#$(

1&"02"1,-3( /4"24( "0$-&1&-$#( 4*8)0(

#%2"-$'( 0%$( )#( )( 5&"-06,'( 6"7"#"%0( %5(

,).%*&(.*$()#($4-(5%&2".,-(&-1&-##"%0(%5(

#%8-(%5("$#(8-8.-&#(.'(%$4-&#:(

;<*6/"+(7%0(="#-#>(

$

$

%&'()*'$+,$&-.,$/&$0(1$*1-2&,34$&',$51-6&/6,$(0$7(%)2&-18$

$&)6-$)23,15/29$()1$,2&/1,$,6(2(:/6$989&,:;$<$989&,:$

(0$ 9'-1,3$=,%/,09$ -=()&$51/7-&,$51(5,1&8$ 1/*'&9$:/2/:/>,9$ 6(20%/6&9$

-23$-%%(+9$'):-29$&($%/7,$/2$5,-6,$+/&'$,-6'$(&',1;$?)&$/0$,7,18(2,$

+,1,$9&)6.$+/&'$+'-&,7,1$6(%%,6&/(2$(0$51(5,1&8$',$',%3$&"+4$()$($4"#(

8%8-0$@-23$ 3/32A&$ '-7,$ &',$ -=/%/&8$ &($ 9+-5$+/&'$ (&',1$ 5,(5%,@

&'/2*9$+()%3$=,$51,&&8$=%,-.4$ ,7,2$ 0(1$ &',$5,(5%,$+'($ 9&-1&,3$()&$

+/&'$-$%(&$(0$B9&)00;C$

D',$=,2,0/&9$(0$&1-3,$-1,$9($(=7/()9$&'-&$+,$9,,$&',:$,7,2$/2$

&',$ /2,1-6&/(29$(0$ 6'/%31,2;$<&$ %)26'$(2,$3-8$ E/::8$3/96(7,19$ &'-&$

<$

!"#$%&??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????(

(

!FG$

'/9$ :(&',1$ '-9$ 5-6.,3$ '/:$ -$ =(%(*2-$ 9-23+/6'4$ ,7,2$ &'()*'$ ',$

:)6'$51,0,19$5,-2)&$=)&&,1;$<&$&',$9-:,$&/:,4$H-%%8$(5,29$',1$%)26'$

=(I$&($0/23$-$5,-2)&$=)&&,1$9-23+/6'4$,7,2$&'()*'$9',$'-9$'-3$&',$

9-:,$&'/2*$&'1,,$3-89$9&1-/*'&;$D',$&+($6'/%31,2$6(:5%-/2$-%()3$(0$

&',/1$ :/9,1-=%,$ 51,3/6-:,2&94$ -23$ J)/6.%8$ 1,-%/>,$ &'-&$ &',8$ 6-2$

9&1/.,$ -$:)&)-%%8$ -37-2&-*,()9$ 3,-%;$ E/::8$ &1-290,19$ '/9$ 51(5,1&8$

K&',$=(%(*2-$9-23+/6'L$&($H-%%84$+'($/2$&)12$&1-290,19$',1$51(5,1&8$

K&',$ 5,-2)&$ =)&&,1$ 9-23+/6'L$ &($ E/::8;$ ?(&'$ 6'/%31,2$ 6(:,$ ()&$

-',-34$(1$-&$%,-9&$&',8$,I5,6&$&(;$

?,%/,7,$/&$(1$2(&4$,6(2(:/6$96/,26,$+-92A&$-=%,$&($-3,J)-&,%8$

,I5%-/2$ ,7,2$ 9)6'$ -$ =-9/6$ &1-29-6&/(2$ )2&/%$ &',$ %-&,$ !FGG9;$ ?,0(1,$

&',24$&'/2.,19$-9$-)*)9&$-9$<1/9&(&%,$'-3$=,,2$5%-*),3$=8$&',$0-)%&8$

2(&/(2$&'-&$*((39$-23$9,17/6,9$5(99,99,3$/2&1/29/64$B(=M,6&/7,C$7-%),;$

N2$&'-&$01-:,+(1.4$-$:-1.,&$,I6'-2*,$+-9$(2%8$M)9&$/0$5,(5%,$&1-3,3$

*((39$ &'-&$ +,1,$ (0$ -@*),$ 7-%),@(&',1+/9,$ (2,$ 5,19(2$ +()%3$ =,$

1/55/2*$(00$&',$(&',1;$

?)&$-9$()1$9/:5%,$9-23+/6'$,I-:5%,$9'(+94$-2%0%8"2(7),*-("#(

"0($4-(-'-(%5($4-(.-4%,6-&;$D($)9,$:(3,12$M-1*(24$,6(2(:/9&9$9-8$&'-&$

7-%),$/9$#*.A-2$"7-;$D'-&$/9$+'8$/&A9$5(99/=%,$0(1$.%$4(6'/%31,2$&($+-%.$

-+-8$ 01(:$ &',/1$ &1-3,4$ 0,,%/2*$ -9$ /0$ &',8$ *(&$ &',$ =,&&,1$ ,23$ (0$ &',$

3,-%;$ D'-&A9$ 2(&$ -$ 6(2&1-3/6&/(2O$ ?(&'$ 6'/%31,2$ 1,-%%8$ 3/3$ =,2,0/&P$

,-6'$ 6'/%3$ 6-2$ &1)&'0)%%8$ 9-8$ &'-&$',$(1$ 9',$*-7,$)5$-$ 9-23+/6'$(0$

%,99,1$7-%),4$-23$-6J)/1,3$-$9-23+/6'$(0$*1,-&,1$7-%),;$

!"#$%&??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????(

(

!F!$

Q(&/6,$ &'-&$ &'/9$ &85,$ (0$ 9&-&,:,2&$ (2%8$ +(1.9$ =,6-)9,$

,6(2(:/6$ 7-%),$ /9$ 9)=M,6&/7,;$ R(1$ ,I-:5%,4$ /&$+()%3$ =,$ /:5(99/=%,$

0(1$ ,-6'$ 6'/%3$ &($ +-%.$ -+-8$ +/&'$ &',$ 4-)7"-&$ 9-23+/6'4$ (1$ &',$

9-23+/6'$ +/&'$ :(1,$ 6-%(1/,94$ =,6-)9,$ +,/*'&$ -23$ 6-%(1/6$ 6(2&,2&$

-1,$ (=M,6&/7,$ 51(5,1&/,9$ (0$ 5'89/6-%$ (=M,6&9;$ ?)&$ &',$ -:()2&$ (0$

'-55/2,99$(1$9-&/90-6&/(2$&'-&$-$5,19(2$*,&9$01(:$-$5-1&/6)%-1$/&,:4$/9$

-$#*.A-2$"7-$51(5,1&84$-23$(2,$&'-&$7-1/,9$01(:$5,19(2$&($5,19(2;$H($

&',1,$/9$2($6(2&1-3/6&/(2$/2$,-6'$5,19(2$&'/2./2*$',$(1$9',$=,2,0/&,3$

01(:$&',$,I6'-2*,;$D1-3,$/9$-$1%#"$"7-9#*8$*-:,4$:,-2/2*$&'-&$(2,$

5,19(2A9$*-/2$3(,92A&$&1-29%-&,$/2&($9(:,(2,$,%9,A9$%(99;$

D($-7(/3$6(20)9/(24$+,$9'()%3$6%-1/08$&'-&$+,$-1,$&-%./2*$',1,$

-=()&$-2%0%8"2( 7),*-( )#( 1-&2-"7-6( .'( -)24( "06"7"6*),( 2%0#*8-&;$ D($

9-8$B7-%),$/9$9)=M,6&/7,C$/9$2(&$&($-3(5&$-$5(9/&/(2$(0$,&'/6-%$2/'/%/9:$

(1$:(1-%$1,%-&/7/9:;$<$5-1,2&$6-2$9&/%%$&'/2.$&'-&$/&A9$=-3$0(1$',1$6'/%3$

&($9:(.,$6/*-1,&&,9;$S7,2$9(4$/0$-2$,6(2(:/9&$/9$&18/2*$&($,I5%-/2$+'8$

6/*-1,&&,$51/6,9$-1,$9($'/*'4$5-1&$(0$&',$,I5%-2-&/(2$(=7/()9%8$1,%/,9$

(2$&',$)23,2/-=%,$0-6&$&'-&$:-28$5,(5%,$-0A%'$9:(./2*;$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1Ludwig von Mises, Socialism (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 1981), p. 268.

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#$

$

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

+,-&.(

$

$

!"#$%&'(&#")&*#&'#+$#)'"#&",&)-$&()*)$.&/)&

'(& #")& )-$& 01"234)& ",& *& 5$6'(5*)'+$& *4).&

7+$#& )-$& (*#4)'"#& ",& 0"5')'4*5& *3)-"1')%&

'(&#")&#$4$((*1%&,"1&')(&$8'()$#4$.&9$1)*'#&

4"::"2')'$(& 4*:$& )"& ;$& :"#$%& <3')$&

#*)31*55%=& *(& )-$& 1$(35)& ",& $4"#":'4&

1$5*)'"#(-'0(& )-*)& >$1$& <3')$&

'#2$0$#2$#)&",&)-$&0">$1&",&)-$&()*)$.&

?9*15&!$#6$1@&

$

$

%&$ '()*'*+*',()$,-$./'01*&$./,.&/*2$1(3$0,4+(*1/2$ */13&$

144,5$%+61()$ *,$ 71*1.+4*$ '(*,$1$6+7%$%'8%&/$ )*1(31/3$

,-$ 4'0'(8$ *%1($5,+43$ 9&$ .,))'94&$5'*%,+*$ *%&6:$ ;0&($ ),<$ *%&/&$ 1/&$

)&/',+)$4'6'*1*',()$,($2'1$4)&&=7%1(8&<$,/$5%1*$')$),6&*'6&)$7144&3$

;*1)$1:$

>($ 1$ .+/&$ 91/*&/$ &7,(,62<$ 5%&/&$ .&,.4&$ ,(42$ */13&$ 8,,3)$

1(3$)&/0'7&)$*%1*$*%&2$.41($,($+)'(8$.&/),(1442<$*%&/&$5,+43$9&$4'**4&$

)7,.&$ -,/$ ).&7'14'?1*',($ ,/$ -,/$ 9+)'(&))$ &(*&/./')&):$ @,/$ &=16.4&<$

(,9,32$ 7,+43$ 1--,/3$ *,$ 9&7,6&$ 1$ 3&(*')*<$ 9&71+)&$ 1(2*'6&$%&$51)$

%+(8/2<$ %&$5,+43$ %10&$ *,$ -'(3$ ),6&,(&$ '($ *%&$ 7,66+('*2$ 1*$ *%1*$

A$

!"#$%&AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA&

&

!"B$

0&/2$6,6&(*$5%,$%13$&=*/1$-,,3$*#2$1$*,,*%17%&:$C(3$'*$5,+43$9&$

&0&($ 6,/&$ '6./17*'714$ -,/$ 41/8&D)714&$ %,+)&)$ *,$ 9&$ 9+'4*<$ 9&71+)&$

5%1*$1/&$*%&$7%1(7&)$*%1*$1$7,+.4&$5,+43$%1..&($*,$%10&$1$)*,7E.'4&$

,-$ &(,+8%$ -,,3<$ 74,*%&)<$ 1(3$ ,*%&/$ 8,,3'&)$ *,$ &=7%1(8&$5'*%$ 144$ ,-$

*%&$5,/E&/)<$4+69&/$,5(&/)<$841?'&/)<$1(3$9/'7E61E&/)$(&7&))1/2$*,$

9+'43$1$%,+)&F$

>($)%,/*<$14*%,+8%$3'/&7*$&=7%1(8&$144,5)$-,/$1$/&3')*/'9+*',($

,-$ &=')*'(8$ ./,.&/*2$ *'*4&)$ '($ 1$ 512$ *%1*$ 61E&)$ &0&/2$ .1/*'7'.1(*$

9&**&/$ ,--<$ '*$ )*'44$ 3,&)(G*$ 144,5$ .&,.4&$ *,$ ).&7'14'?&$ '($ .1/*'7+41/$

,77+.1*',()<$ 1(3$ '*$ 3,&)(G*$ -,)*&/$ 41/8&D)714&$ ./,3+7*',(:$ A%&)&$

%14461/E)$ ,-$ &7,(,6'7$ ./,8/&))$ 71($ ,(42$ ,77+/$ 5'*%$ '#2'1$4)&

&=7%1(8&$1(3$+4*'61*&42$*%&$&6&/8&(7&$,-$6,(&2:$

$

/",(0-1&-%&2(+,-&.3(

$

H1/4$I&(8&/$51)$ *%&$ -,+(3&/$ ,-$ *%&$C+)*/'1($ J7%,,4<$5%'7%$

,--'7'1442$9&81($5'*%$%')$!"K!$*/&1*')&$,($*%&$B1'#4'05$(&",&74"#":'4(:$

L&$613&$61(2$7,(*/'9+*',()$*,$&7,(,6'7$*%&,/2<$'(74+3'(8$*%&$-'/)*$

)1*')-17*,/2$&=.41(1*',($,-$*%&$,/'8'($,-$6,(&2:$

I,)*$ .&,.4&$ ./,91942$ -144$ '(*,$ *%&$ */1.$ *%1*$ L12&E$51/(&3$

19,+*<$ 1(3$ 1))+6&$ *%1*$ )'(7&$ 6,(&2$ ')$ ,90',+)42$ 1$ M./,3+7*$ ,-$

%+61($ 17*',(<N$ *%1*$ *%&/&-,/&$ ),6&,(&$ ,/$ ),6&$ 8/,+.$6+)*$ %10&$

3&4'9&/1*&42$ '#+$#)$2$ 6,(&2:$ O+*$ '-$ 5&$ *%'(E$ 19,+*$ '*<$ *%1*$

&=.41(1*',($')$19)+/3:$@,/$,(&$*%'(8<$*%&/&$')$(,$%')*,/'714$/&7,/3$,-$


&

!"P$

1$ 5')&$ E'(8$ 51E'(8$ +.$ ,(&$ 312$ 1(3$ 7,661(3'(8$ %')$ )+9Q&7*)$ *,$

191(3,($91/*&/$'($-10,/$,-$1$6,/&$&--'7'&(*$)2)*&6:$

R&*$&0&($'-$)+7%$1$/+4&/$2'2&S'6.41+)'942T$3/&16$+.$*%&$'3&1$

,-$6,(&2<$ 1(3$ /&7,8('?&$ '*)$ 1301(*18&)$,0&/$91/*&/<$ %&$ )*'44$5,+43$

%10&$./,94&6)$'6.4&6&(*'(8$%')$(&5$)7%&6&:$U'7*+/&$*%&$5')&$E'(8$

7,44&7*'(8$1$9+(7%$,-$)&1$)%&44)$1(3$*&44'(8$%')$)+9Q&7*)<$ M@/,6$(,5$

,(<$5%&($2,+$51(*$*,$*/13&$1512$2,+/$)+/.4+)$8,,3)<$ >$3,(G*$51(*$

2,+$ *,$ 177&.*$ 8,,3)$ *%1*$ 2,+$ 17*+1442$ 014+&$ '($ &=7%1(8&$ -,/$ *%&6:$

>()*&13<$>$51(*$2,+$*,$177&.*$*%&)&$+)&4&))$)&1$)%&44)$5%&($2,+$)&44$

2,+/$ %,/)&)<$ .'8)<$ 1(3$ 419,/$ *,$ ,*%&/)$ '($ *%&$ E'(83,6:$ O+*$ 3,(G*$

5,//2$ *%1*$2,+$1/&$8&**'(8$7%&1*&3V$ >$5'44$ -,/7&$$+$1%"#$& $5($$ *,$3,$

*%&$ )16&<$5%&($ '*G)$ 2,+/$ *+/($ *,$9+2$8,,3)$5'*%$ *%&)&$+)&4&))$ )&1$

)%&44):N$

C4/&132$ *%&$.4,*$ ')$ *,,$ -1/D-&*7%&3$*,$9&$9&4'&0&3:$C(3$2&*$ '*$

8&*)$5,/)&:$;0&($'-$*%&$E'(8$%13$61(18&3$*,$.+)%$*%/,+8%$*%&$19,0&$

)7%&6&W.&/%1.)$+(3&/$*%/&1*$,-$)&0&/&$.+(')%6&(*W*%&$)+9Q&7*)$

'($%')$E'(83,6$5,+43(G*$E(,5$%,5$*,$01'4$$*%&'/$01/',+)$,9Q&7*)$'($

*&/6)$ ,-$ *%&$ (&5$ M6,(&2:N$ @,/$ &=16.4&<$ ,($ *%&$ -'/)*$ 312$ ,-$ *%&$

./,74161*',(<$)+..,)&$1$-1/6&/$%13$.41((&3$,($*/13'(8$1512$*%/&&$

.'8)$ -,/$ 1(,*%&/$ -1/6&/G)$ %,/)&:$ X,5$ *%&$ E'(8$ 7,6&)$ 14,(8$ 1(3$

,/3&/)$%'6$*,$-'/)*$)&44$%')$.'8)$'($&=7%1(8&$-,/$)&1$)%&44)<$5%'7%$%&$

5'44$*%&($+)&$*,$9+2$1$%,/)&:$H4&1/42$*%&(<$%&$5'44$(&&3$*,$E(,5$%,5$

61(2$)&1$)%&44)$1$%,/)&$7,)*)<$9&-,/&$)&**'(8$*%&$M)&1$)%&44$./'7&N$,($

%')$.'8):$O+*$%&$ 71(G*$ Q+)*$ 4,,E$ 1*$ *%&$ 1)E'(8$./'7&$ S'($ *&/6)$,-$ )&1$


&

!"Y$

)%&44)T$ -/,6$ *%&$ %,/)&D)&44&/<$ 9&71+)&$ *%1*$ 8+2$ ')$ '($ *%&$ )16&$

./&3'716&(*Z$

J,$5&$)&&$*%1*$ *%&/&$1/&$)&/',+)$ -415)$5'*%$*%&$*2.'714$0'&5$

*%1*$6,(&2$6+)*$ %10&$ 9&&($ 3&)'8(&3$ 92$ ),6&9,32$ '($ *%&$ 3')*1(*$

.1)*:$[($*%&$,*%&/$%1(3<$5&$E(,5$*%1*$6,(&2$')$,90',+)42$1$-3:*#$

.%&(,6&(,(:$J,$%,5$&=17*42$3'3$'*$1/')&F$

$

4"&(56'%"(,7(0-26'&8%(9:8"#-;&$

$

I&(8&/$./,0'3&)$*%&$7,6.&44'(8$),4+*',(:$ >('*'1442<$&0&($ '($1$

)*1*&$,-$91/*&/<$),6&$8,,3)$5&/&$6,/&$M)14&194&N$,/$S5%1*$5&$5,+43$

(,5$7144T$ 5'<3'2$ *%1($,*%&/):$@,/$&=16.4&<$1$.&/),($5%,$51(*&3$*,$

17\+'/&$1$%,/)&<$1(3$%13$.'8)$*,$*/13&$-,/$*%&6<$5,+43$9&$'($1$6+7%$

9&**&/$.,)'*',($ *%1($1$.&/),($5%,$51(*&3$1$%,/)&$9+*$%13$1$ -1(72$

*&4&)7,.&$ *,$ ,--&/:$ A%&$ 3'--&/&(7&$ 5,+43(G*$ 9&$ *%1*$ *%&$ .'8)$ 5&/&$

6,/&$ +*53*;5$$ *%1($ *%&$ *&4&)7,.&V$ '($ -17*<$ 3&.&(3'(8$ ,($ %,5$

),.%')*'71*&3$ '*$ 51)<$ *%&$ *&4&)7,.&$ 6'8%*$ 9&$ -1/$ 6,/&$ 014+194&:$

L,5&0&/<$9&71+)&$/&41*'0&42$-&5$.&,.4&$71($+)&$1$-1(72$*&4&)7,.&W

5%&/&1)$ .4&(*2$ ,-$ .&,.4&$ 7,+43$ -'(3$ 1$ 3'/&7*$ +)&$ -,/$ .'8)W*%&$

*&4&)7,.&$5,+43$9&$0&/2$'55'<3'2:$SA,$*1E&$1$6,/&$-16'4'1/$&=16.4&<$'*$

')$6+7%$&1)'&/$*,$)&44$1$7,/.,/1*&$9,(3$*%1($'*$')$*,$)&44$1$%,+)&<$&0&($

*%,+8%$1$%,+)&$6'8%*$%10&$1$6+7%$%'8%&/$61/E&*$./'7&$*%1($1$8'0&($

9,(3:$A%1*G)$5%2$5&$)12$ *%&$9,(3$ ')$ -1/$6,/&$ 5'<3'2$ 1($1))&*$ *%1($

*%&$%,+)&:T$


&

!"K$

I&(8&/$&=.41'(&3$5%1*$%1..&()$(&=*:$ >($1($,/'8'(14$)*1*&$,-$

91/*&/<$ .&,.4&$ 5%,$ 1/&$ )*+7E$ 5'*%$ /&41*'0&42$ '44'\+'3$ 8,,3)$ 1/&$

5'44'(8$*,$*/13&$*%&6$1512$-,/$6,/&$4'\+'3$1))&*)<$&0&($'-$*%&2$3,(G*$

'(*&(3$ ,($ +)'(8$ *%,)&$ '*&6)$ .&/),(1442:$ @,/$ &=16.4&<$ ,+/$

%2.,*%&*'714$ 61($5%,$51(*)$ 1$ %,/)&<$ 9+*$ ,(42$ %1)$ 1$ *&4&)7,.&$ *,$

,--&/$ '($ */13&<$ ./,91942$ 5,(G*$ -'(3$ ),6&,(&$ &4)&$ 1*$ *%1*$ &=17*$

6,6&(*$5%,$ S1T$ %1)$ 1$%,/)&$ 1(3$ S9T$51(*)$ 1$ *&4&)7,.&:$L,5&0&/<$

)+..,)&$ *%&$61($ /+()$ '(*,$ 1$ .&/),($5%,$2"$($51(*$ %')$ *&4&)7,.&<$

1(3$71($,--&/$S)12T$)&0&($)%&&.$'($&=7%1(8&:$;0&($*%,+8%$,+/$61($

612$%10&$(,$+)&$-,/$)%&&.$1*$*%&$6,6&(*<$%&$)*'44$6'8%*$18/&&$*,$*%&$

*/13&<$9&71+)&$%&$E(,5)$%&G)$6+7%$6,/&$4'E&42$*,$8&*$%')$%,/)&$'-$%&$

7,6&)$ *,$ *%&$ 91/81'('(8$ *194&$ 5'*%$ )&0&($ )%&&.<$ /1*%&/$ *%1($ %')$

,/'8'(14$*&4&)7,.&:$

C(3$ *%+)$ *%&$ ./17*'7&$ ,-$ '#2'1$4)& $84-*#6$$ 51)$ 9,/(:$ >($ 1($

'(3'/&7*$ &=7%1(8&<$ 1$ .&/),($ */13&)$ 1512$ %')$ 014+194&$ 8,,3)$ ,/$

)&/0'7&)<$ 1(3$/&7&'0&)$),6&*%'(8$ *%1*$%&$3,&)(G*$.&/),(1442$3&)'/&:$

L,5&0&/<$ *%&$ /&1),($ %&$ 18/&&)$ *,$ *%&$ */13&$ ')$ *%1*$ *%&$ ,9Q&7*$ %&$

17\+'/&)$ ')$6,/&$:*1C$)*;5$$ S,/$ 4'\+'3T$*%1($*%&$,(&$%&$810&$+.:$ >*$

.+*)$ %'6$ '($ 1$ 9&**&/$ .,)'*',($ *,$ 1**1'($ %')$ +4*'61*&$ ,9Q&7*'0&<$ &0&($

*%,+8%$*%&$'(3'/&7*$&=7%1(8&$'*)&4-$3,&)(G*$61E&$%'6$9&**&/$,--:$

>($*%&$Q1/8,($,-$&7,(,6'7)<$8,,3)$*%1*$1/&$177&.*&3$'($*/13&$

5'*%$ *%&$ '(*&(*',($ ,-$ 9&'(8$ */13&3$ 1512$ '($ *%&$ -+*+/&<$ 1/&$ 7144&3$

:$2'*& ",& $84-*#6$:$ ]+)*$ 1)$ 1'/$ ,/$ 51*&/$ 71($ 9&$ 1$:$2'3:$ *%/,+8%$

5%'7%$ ),+(3$ 510&)$ */10&4<$ ),$ *,,$ 71($ 8,,3)$ S)+7%$ 1)$ *%&$ )&0&($


&

!""$

)%&&.$ '($ ,+/$ &=16.4&T$ 9&$ 1$ :$2'3:$ *%/,+8%$ 5%'7%$ 1($ '(3'/&7*$

&=7%1(8&$')$-17'4'*1*&3:$

^'*%$ *%&$ ./17*'7&$ ,-$ '(3'/&7*$ &=7%1(8&<$ 1$ 7,66+('*2$ 71($

8/,5$ -1/$6,/&$./,).&/,+)$ *%1($ '-$ '*$ /&4'&3$,($.+/&$91/*&/:$@,/$,(&$

*%'(8<$ *%&/&$1/&$61(2$6,/&$.,)'*'0&D)+6$0,4+(*1/2$*/13&)$*%1*$71($

,77+/<$ 5%&($ */13&/)$ 9&8'($ 4,,E'(8$ *5,$ 1(3$ *%/&&$ 6,0&)$ 1%&13<$

/1*%&/$*%1($ 4'6'*'(8$*%&6)&40&)$*,$,(&D)%,*$ */1()17*',():$O+*$6,/&$

-+(316&(*1442<$ *%&$ ./17*'7&$ ,-$ '(3'/&7*$ &=7%1(8&$ 144,5)$ -,/$ 6+7%$

3&&.&/$61/E&*)$ '($*%&$6,)*$ 4'\+'3$8,,3)<$1(3$),$8'0&)$1($'(7&(*'0&$

-,/$ 1*$ 4&1)*$ ),6&$.&,.4&$ *,$ 9&8'($ ).&7'14'?'(8$ '($ *%&$ ./,3+7*',($ ,-$

*%,)&$8,,3):$>($,+/$&=16.4&<$1)$6,/&$.&,.4&$9&8'($177&.*'(8$)%&&.$

-,/$ *%&'/$ +)&$ 1)$ 1$ 6&3'+6$ ,-$ &=7%1(8&$ S/1*%&/$ *%1($ Q+)*$ -,/$ *%&'/$

3'/&7*$.+/.,)&)T<$'*$61E&)$'*$6,/&$4+7/1*'0&$*,$/1')&$)%&&.:$

$

4"&(9<&';&-8&(,7(+,-&.(

$

^&$(,5$7,6&$*,$*%&$-'(14$)*&.$,-$I&(8&/G)$&=.41(1*',(:$[0&/$

*'6&<$ *%,)&$ 8,,3)$ *%1*$ 5&/&$ '('*'1442$ *%&$ 6,)*$ 61/E&*194&<$ 8,*$ 1($

133&3$9,,)*$,(7&$.&,.4&$9&81($+)'(8$*%&6$'($'(3'/&7*$&=7%1(8&):$>($

,*%&/$5,/3)<$ *%&/&$51)$1$ )(,59144$&--&7*_$ 8,,3)$ *%1*$5&/&$ '('*'1442$

177&.*&3$ 92<$ )12<$ *&($ .&/7&(*$ ,-$ *%&$ 6&/7%1(*)<$ 5,+43$ ),,($ 9&$

177&.*&3$ 92$ *5&(*2$ .&/7&(*<$ 9&71+)&$ *%&$6&/7%1(*)$5,+43$ /&14'?&$

*%&)&$8,,3)$5&/&$0&/2$4'\+'3:$A%&$./,7&))$7,(*'(+&3<$+(*'4$*%&$.,'(*$

1*$5%'7%$,(&$,-$*%&$8,,3)$9&716&$3#'+$1(*55%&*44$0)$2$92$&0&/2,(&$


&

!"`$

'($ *%&$ 7,66+('*2$ '($ */13&:$ C*$ *%1*$ .,'(*<$ :"#$%$ %13$ &6&/8&3$

).,(*1(&,+)42$,($*%&$61/E&*:$

C-*&/$ 144<$ *%1*G)$ 5%1*$ 6,(&2$ ')_$ >*$ ')$ 1$ .1/*'7+41/$ 8,,3$ -,/$

5%'7%$.&,.4&$1/&$14512)$5'44'(8$*,$)&44$*%&'/$,5($51/&)$'($&=7%1(8&V$

'*$ ')$ *%&$6,)*$ 4'\+'3$ ,-$ 144$ 1))&*):$ X,$ ,(&$ &0&/$ %&)'*1*&)$ *,$ )&44$ %')$

'*&6)$'($&=7%1(8&$-,/$6,(&2$S),$4,(8$1)$*%&$./'7&$')$/'8%*T<$9&71+)&$

%&$ E(,5)$ %&$5'44$ %10&$ (,$ ./,94&6$ 8&**'(8$ ,*%&/$ .&,.4&$ 3,5($ *%&$

/,13$*,$177&.*$*%&$6,(&2$5%&($-$$51(*)$*,$9+2$*%'(8):$

>*$ ')$ +)&-+4$ *,$ )*&.$ 917E$ 1(3$ .,(3&/$ I&(8&/G)$ )7'&(*'-'7$

177,6.4')%6&(*:$ L&$ %1)$ 8'0&($ +)$ 1$ 7,%&/&(*$ )*,/2<$ &=.41'('(8$ *%&$

&6&/8&(7&$ ,-$ 6,(&2$ '($ 1$ )*/1'8%*-,/51/3$ 61((&/$ -/,6$ 1($ '('*'14$

)*1*&$ ,-$ 91/*&/:$ ]+)*$ 1)$ '($ ,+/$ )*,/2$ ,-$ *%&$ &6&/8&(7&$ ,-$ 1$ */1'4$

*%/,+8%$ 1$ -,/&)*<$ %&/&$ *,,$ 5&$ 3'3$ (,*$ 1))+6&$ *%1*$ 6&/7%1(*)$

7,()7',+)42$ '(*&(3&3$ *,$ M7/&1*&$ 6,(&2N$ -,/$ *%&'/$ 3&)7&(31(*):$

>()*&13<$ 5&$ )%,5&3$ %,5$ &17%$ '(3'0'3+14<$ 17*'(8$ '($ %')$ '66&3'1*&$

'(*&/&)*<$ (,(&*%&4&))$ .1/*'7'.1*&3$ '($ *%&$ 7/&1*',($ ,-$ 1$ ),7'14$

'()*'*+*',($,-$*/&6&(3,+)$'6.,/*1(7&:$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Carl Menger, Principles of Economics (Grove City, PA: Libertarian Press, Inc., 1994), pp. 261-262.

!"#$%&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!

"#$!

!

!"!#

!"#$%&'()*(

+',-&./(+'01,%./(#23(+4#22,25(

#

#

!" #$%&'$(%')" *+,,&%-" ,%./" '" 0.01

#$%&'$(%')" 2%&(+-&34" #&('$-&" 5&" +-"

6.%7+08" +0" '" ,+&3*" +0" 65+(5" +)" +-"

+/2.--+#3&" )." '22%'+-&" )5&" %&-$3)" .," '"

/'09-"&,,.%)"+0")&%/-".,"/.0&4:"

;<$*6+8"=.0">+-&-?""

#

$%&# '# (')*&+# ,&-&./01# +2&# 31&# /4# (/$&56# &$+7)&# $&8#

-71+'1#/0&$#30#4/)#&%/$/(7%#,&-&./0(&$+9#:&%'31&#+2&#

(/$&5# %/((/,7+5# &;71+1# /$# /$&# 17,&# /4# &-&)5# +)'$1'%+7/$6#

(&)%2'$+1#'$,#%/$13(&)1#%'$#<37%*.5#=)'10#+2&#)&.'+7-&#1%')%7+5#/4#

-')7/31#=//,1#'$,#1&)-7%&19#>$#/+2&)#8/),16#+2&#31&#/4#(/$&5#'../81#

0&/0.&# +/# )&,3%&# &%/$/(7%# /0&)'+7/$1# ,/8$# +/# '# %/((/$#

,&$/(7$'+/)9#

?1# 7$# 1/# ('$5# /+2&)# ')&'16# @'5&*# 8'1# /$&# /4# +2&# 4&8#

&%/$/(71+1# +/#=)'10# +2&#17=$747%'$%&#/4# +271# 4'%+9#@'5&*#-7&8&,# +2&#

0)7%&# 151+&(# 7$# '# (')*&+# &%/$/(5# '1# '# +50&# /4# %/((3$7%'+7/$#

$&+8/)*6# 7$#827%2#0&/0.&# A/$# +2&#=)/3$,B# 7$#/$&#')&'# +)'$1(7++&,#

)&.&-'$+# 7$4/)('+7/$# +/# &-&)5/$&# &.1&# +2)/3=2# +2&7)# C357$=# '$,#

1&..7$=#,&%717/$19#>$#'#4'(/31#!"DE#F/3)$'.#')+7%.&#@'5&*#8)/+&G#

#

H#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"I#

J&# (31+# .//*# '+# +2&# 0)7%&# 151+&(# '1# 13%2# '# (&%2'$71(# 4/)#

%/((3$7%'+7$=# 7$4/)('+7/$# 74# 8&# 8'$+# +/# 3$,&)1+'$,# 7+1# )&'.#

43$%+7/$K9L2&# (/1+# 17=$747%'$+# 4'%+# 'C/3+# +271# 151+&(# 71# +2&#

&%/$/(5#/4#*$/8.&,=&#87+2#827%2# 7+#/0&)'+&16#/)#2/8# .7++.&# +2&#

7$,7-7,3'.#0')+7%70'$+1#$&&,#+/#*$/8#7$#/),&)#+/#C&#'C.&#+/#+'*&#

+2&# )7=2+# '%+7/$9# >$# 'CC)&-7'+&,# 4/)(6# C5# '# *7$,#/4# 15(C/.6# /$.5#

+2&#(/1+#&11&$+7'.# 7$4/)('+7/$# 71#0'11&,#/$#'$,#0'11&,#/$#/$.5#

+/# +2/1&# %/$%&)$&,9# >+# 71#(/)&# +2'$# '#(&+'02/)# +/# ,&1%)7C&# +2&#

0)7%&#151+&(#'1#'#*7$,#/4#('%27$&)5#4/)#)&=71+&)7$=#%2'$=&6#/)#'#

151+&(# /4# +&.&%/((3$7%'+7/$1# 827%2# &$'C.&1# 7$,7-7,3'.#

0)/,3%&)1#+/#8'+%2#(&)&.5#+2&#(/-&(&$+#/4#'#4&8#0/7$+&)16#'1#'$#

&$=7$&&)#(7=2+#8'+%2#+2&#2'$,1#/4#'#4&8#,7'.16#7$#/),&)#+/#',F31+#

+2&7)# '%+7-7+7&1# +/# %2'$=&1#/4#827%2# +2&5#('5#$&-&)#*$/8#(/)&#

+2'$#71#)&4.&%+&,#7$#+2&#0)7%&#(/-&(&$+9#

#

:3+#>#4&')#+2'+#M&%/$/(71+1NO#+2&/)&+7%'.#2'C7+1#/4#'00)/'%27$=#+2&#

0)/C.&(#87+2#+2&#'113(0+7/$#/4#(/)&#/)#.&11#0&)4&%+#*$/8.&,=&#

/$# +2&#0')+#/4#'.(/1+#&-&)5/$&#2'1#(',&#31#1/(&82'+#C.7$,# +/#

+2&#+)3&#43$%+7/$#/4#+2&#0)7%&#(&%2'$71(KL2&#(')-&.#71#+2'+#7$#'#

%'1&#.7*&#+2'+#/4#'#1%')%7+5#/4#/$&#)'8#('+&)7'.6#87+2/3+#'$#/),&)#

C&7$=# 7113&,6# 87+2/3+# (/)&# +2'$# 0&)2'01# '# 2'$,43.# /4# 0&/0.&#

*$/87$=# +2&# %'31&6# +&$1# /4# +2/31'$,1# /4# 0&/0.&# 82/1&# 7,&$+7+5#

%/3.,#$/+#C&#'1%&)+'7$&,#C5#(/$+21#/4#7$-&1+7='+7/$6#')&#(',&#+/#

31&#+2&#('+&)7'.#/)#7+1#0)/,3%+1#(/)&#10')7$=.5P#+:&:A#+2&5#(/-&#7$#

+2&#)7=2+#,7)&%+7/$K9#

#

># 2'-&#,&.7C&)'+&.5#31&,# +2&#8/),# A(')-&.B# +/# 12/%*# +2&# )&',&)#

/3+#/4#+2&#%/(0.'%&$%5#87+2#827%2#8&#/4+&$#+'*&#+2&#8/)*7$=#/4#

+271# (&%2'$71(# 4/)# =)'$+&,9# ># '(# %/$-7$%&,# +2'+# 74# 7+# 8&)&# +2&#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"Q#

)&13.+# /4# ,&.7C&)'+&# 23('$# ,&17=$6# '$,# 74# +2&# 0&/0.&# =37,&,# C5#

+2&# 0)7%&# %2'$=&1# 3$,&)1+//,# +2'+# +2&7)# ,&%717/$1# 2'-&#

17=$747%'$%&# 4')# C&5/$,# +2&7)# 7((&,7'+&# '7(6# +271# (&%2'$71(#

8/3.,#2'-&#C&&$#'%%.'7(&,#'1#/$&#/4#+2&#=)&'+&1+#+)73(021#/4#+2&#

23('$#(7$,9I#

#

J&# ')&# $/8# C&=7$$7$=# +/# 1&&# 2/8# 1/%7'.# 7$1+7+3+7/$1# 2&.0#

23('$1#%/0&#87+2#+2&#'..R0&)-',7$=#0)/C.&(#/4#1%')%7+59#L2&#)&'1/$#

7+#+//*#1%2/.')1#/4#+2&#%'.7C&)#/4#S)7&,)7%2#@'5&*#+/#3$,&)1+'$,#+2&#

+)3&# 43$%+7/$# T'$,# 2&$%&# 7(0/)+'$%&U# /4# 0)7-'+&# 0)/0&)+5# '$,#

(')*&+#0)7%&16#71#+2'+#+2&1&#7$,710&$1'C.&#+//.1#8&)&#$/+#*&-+80&*#C5#

'$5/$&9#V7$%&#$/#17$=.&#0&)1/$# 7$-&$+&,#(/$&56#('$5# 7$+&..&%+3'.1#

+'*&# 7+1# 1&)-7%&1# 4/)# =)'$+&,# '$,# 7$,&&,# 7('=7$&# '# 3+/07'# 827%2#

'C/.712&1# (/$&5# '.+/=&+2&)9# >$# +271# %/$+&;+6# W3,87=# -/$# X71&1N#

4'(/31# %)7+7<3&#/4# 1/%7'.71(# 71# '$# &;%&..&$+# 7..31+)'+7/$#/4# +2&# 4'+'.#

%/$%&7+9#

#

6,.&.( 02( 7-0208,-( !#4-94#%,02:( ;"&( <923#8&2%#4(

+'0=4&8(>,%"(?0-,#4,.8(

#

>$# +2&# %2)/$/./=5# /4# ?31+)7'$# &%/$/(71+16# X71&1# '%+3'..5#

0)&,'+&1#@'5&*9# >$,&&,6#@'5&*# %)&,7+1#X71&1N# !"II#C//*# B.(+'3+-/#

87+2# %/$-&)+7$=# C'4&7# 4)/(# C&7$=# '# 1/%7'.71+Y# >$# '# S/)&8/),#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"D#

T8)7++&$#7$#!"Z[U#+/#+2&#C//*6#@'5&*#&;0.'7$1#2/8#2&#%'(&#+/#*$/8#

X71&16#'$,#+2&#&44&%+#2&#2',G#

#J2&$# B.(+'3+-/" 47)1+# '00&')&,# 7$# !"II6# 7+1# 7(0'%+# 8'1#

0)/4/3$,9# >+# =)',3'..5# C3+# 43$,'(&$+'..5# '.+&)&,# +2&# /3+.//*#/4#

('$5#/4#+2&#5/3$=#7,&'.71+1#)&+3)$7$=#+/#+2&7)#3$7-&)17+5#1+3,7&1#

'4+&)#J/).,#J')#>9#>#*$/86#4/)#>#8'1#/$&#/4#+2&(9#

J&# 4&.+# +2'+# +2&# %7-7.7\'+7/$# 7$#827%2#8&#2',# =)/8$#30#

2',#%/..'01&,9#J&#8&)&#,&+&)(7$&,#+/#C37.,#'#C&++&)#8/).,6#'$,#

7+#8'1#+271#,&17)&#+/#)&%/$1+)3%+#1/%7&+5#+2'+#.&,#('$5#/4#31#+/#+2&#

1+3,5#/4#&%/$/(7%19#V/%7'.71(#0)/(71&,#+/#43.47..#/3)#2/0&1#4/)#'#

(/)&# )'+7/$'.6# (/)&# F31+# 8/).,9# ?$,# +2&$# %'(&# +271# C//*9# H3)#

2/0&1#8&)&#,'12&,9#B.(+'3+-/# +/.,#31# +2'+#8&#2',#C&&$# .//*7$=#

4/)#7(0)/-&(&$+#7$#+2&#8)/$=#,7)&%+7/$9#

?#$3(C&)#/4#(5#%/$+&(0/)')7&16#82/#.'+&)#C&%'(&#8&..#

*$/8$#C3+#82/#8&)&#+2&$#3$*$/8$#+/#&'%2#/+2&)6#8&$+#+2)/3=2#

+2&# 1'(&# &;0&)7&$%&G# J7.2&.(# ]^0*&# 7$# _&)('$5# '$,# W7/$&.#

]/CC7$1# 7$# `$=.'$,# ')&# C3+# +8/# &;'(0.&19# a/$&# /4# 31# 2',#

7$7+7'..5# C&&$# X71&1N# 0307.19# ># 2',# %/(&# +/# *$/8# 27(# 827.&#

8/)*7$=#4/)#'#+&(0/)')5#?31+)7'$#=/-&)$(&$+#/447%&#827%2#8'1#

&$+)31+&,# 87+2# +2&# 7(0.&(&$+'+7/$# /4# %&)+'7$# %.'31&1# /4# +2&#

L)&'+5# /4# b&)1'7..&19# @&# 8'1# (5# 130&)7/)6# +2&# ,7)&%+/)# /4# +2&#

,&0')+(&$+9#

X71&1#8'1#+2&$#C&1+#*$/8$#'1#'#47=2+&)#'='7$1+#7$4.'+7/$9#

@&# 2',# ='7$&,# +2&# &')# /4# +2&# =/-&)$(&$+# '$,K8'1# 7((&$1&.5#

C315# 3)=7$=# +2&# =/-&)$(&$+# +/# +'*&# +2&# /$.5# 0'+2# C5# 827%2# '#

%/(0.&+&# %/..'01&# /4# +2&# %3))&$%5# %/3.,# 1+7..# C&# 0)&-&$+&,9#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"E#

Tc3)7$=# +2&# 47)1+# &7=2+# (/$+21# ># 1&)-&,# 3$,&)# 27(6# (5# $/(7$'.#

1'.')5#)/1&#+/#+8/#23$,)&,#+7(&1#+2&#7$7+7'.#'(/3$+9U#

KB.(+'3+-/"12/%*&,#/3)#=&$&)'+7/$6#'$,#/$.5#1./8.5#'$,#

0'7$43..5#,7,#8&#C&%/(&#0&)13',&,#/4#7+1#%&$+)'.#+2&1719Q#

#

J2'+# 8'1# X71&1N# A%&$+)'.# +2&171B# %/$%&)$7$=# 1/%7'.71(6# +2'+#

2',# 1/# 12/%*&,# @'5&*# '$,# 271# 0&&)1d# >$# '# $3+12&..6# X71&1# ')=3&,#

+2'+# +2&# 1/%7'.71+# 0.'$$&)1# 8/3.,# 47$,# 7+# 7(0/117C.&# +/# )'+7/$'..5#

'../%'+&# 1/%7&+5N1# 1%')%&# )&1/3)%&19# `-&$# 74# +2&5# 2',# +2&# C&1+#

7$+&$+7/$16#'$,#&-&$#74#+2&5#2',#'+#+2&7)#47$=&)+701#'..#/4#+2&#)&.&-'$+#

*$/8.&,=&# 4)/(# -')7/31# &;0&)+16# X71&1# ')=3&,# +2'+# +2&# 1/%7'.71+#

0.'$$&)1#8/3.,#2'-&#$/#8'5#/4#,&+&)(7$7$=#82&+2&)#+2&7)#0.'$1#4/)#

7$,31+)5# 8&)&# '# =//,# 7,&'6# /)# 82&+2&)# '$# '.+&)$'+7-&# 1&+# /4#

7$1+)3%+7/$1#8/3.,#C&#C&++&)9#

L2&#(')*&+#&%/$/(5#1/.-&1#+271#0)/C.&(#+2)/3=2#+2&#0)/47+R

'$,R./11# +&1+9# >$# '# %'07+'.71+# 1/%7&+56# &-&)5# 1%')%&# )&1/3)%&e

7$%.3,7$=#%'07+'.#=//,1#13%2#'1#+)'%+/)1#'$,#4'%+/)7&1e71#13CF&%+#+/#

0)7-'+&# /8$&)12709# L271# '../81# +2&# 4/)('+7/$# /4# (')*&+# 0)7%&1# 4/)#

&-&)5# 3$7+# /4# &-&)5# )&1/3)%&9# J2&$# '$# &$+)&0)&$&3)# 7$# '# (')*&+#

&%/$/(5# 8'$+1# +/# *$/8# 74# 2&# 71# )3$$7$=# '# 13%%&1143.# C317$&116# 2&#

2'1#'#17(0.&#'$,#/CF&%+7-&#%)7+&)7/$G#@&#%'$#1&&#74#+2&#)&-&$3&1#4)/(#

271# %31+/(&)1# ')&# =)&'+&)# +2'$# 271# &;0&$1&19# >4# +2&5N)&# $/+6# +2'+#

(&'$1#+2&#&$+)&0)&$&3)#71#./17$=#(/$&56#'$,#7$#'#(')*&+#&%/$/(5#

'$#3$0)/47+'C.&#/0&)'+7/$#71#1//$#123+#,/8$9#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"f#

a/8#+2&#1/%7'.71+1#.//*&,#30/$#+271#0)'%+7%&#87+2#1%/)$9#?4+&)#

'..6# (/$&5# 71$N+# &-&)5+27$=Y# J2/# 71# +/# 1'5# +2'+# '# 0')+7%3.')# 47)(#

('*7$=# ,7'0&)16# 4/)# &;'(0.&6# 12/3.,$N+# %/$+7$3&# +3)$7$=# 1%')%&#

)&1/3)%&1# 7$+/# (/)&# C/;&1# /4# ,7'0&)16# &-&$# 0'1+# +2&# 0/7$+# /4#

0)/47+'C7.7+56# 7$#/),&)# +/#2&.0# 1+)3==.7$=#(/+2&)1#87+2# 7$4'$+1d#L2&#

1/%7'.71+1# +2/3=2+# +2&# '%%/3$+'$+N1# AC/++/(# .7$&B# 8'1# '$# ')C7+)')5#

<37)*# /4# '# (')*&+# &%/$/(56# '$,# +2'+# 7+# ,7,$N+# %/))&10/$,# +/#

'$5+27$=#A)&'.B#+2'+#8/3.,#&;71+#7$#'#1/%7'.71+#8/).,9#

g&+# X71&1# ,&(/$1+)'+&,# +2'+# +2&# 1/%7'.71+1# 8&)&# 17(0.5#

8)/$=9#?.+2/3=2#+2&)&#')&#.7(7+1#+/#+2&#=37,'$%&#=7-&$#C5#(/$&+')5#

'%%/3$+7$=6# X71&1# 0/7$+&,# /3+# +2'+# 7+# =7-&1# 0&/0.&# -./&# =37,'$%&9#

L27$*# 'C/3+# 7+G# J2&$# '# 0')+7%3.')# &$+&)0)71&# 71# 3$0)/47+'C.&6# 7+#

(&'$1# +2'+# +2&#/8$&)# 71# 10&$,7$=#(/)&#(/$&5#/$# 7$03+1# +2'$#271#

%31+/(&)1#')&#87..7$=#+/#10&$,#/$#+2&#/3+03+19#W//1&.5#10&'*7$=6#8&#

%'$# 1'5# +2'+# +2&# /8$&)# 71# ,&1+)/57$=# 8&'.+26# C&%'31&# 2&# 71#

+)'$14/)(7$=# )&1/3)%&1# /4# '# 27=2# (')*&+# -'.3&# 7$+/# 47$712&,#

0)/,3%+1#/4#'#./8&)#-'.3&9#

X71&1# &;0.'7$&,# +2'+# +2&# (')*&+# 0)7%&1# /4# +2&# A(&'$1# /4#

0)/,3%+7/$B#8&)&#$/+#')C7+)')56#C3+# 7$1+&',# )&4.&%+&,# +2&7)# )&.'+7-&#

1%')%7+7&19# S/)# &;'(0.&6# '# 0/3$,# /4# %/00&)# T'1# /4# +271# 8)7+7$=U#

4&+%2&1#'#27=2&)#(')*&+#0)7%&#+2'$#'#0/3$,#/4#'.3(7$3(9#L271#71$N+#

1/(&#7))&.&-'$+#4'%+/7,#/4#%'07+'.71+#%/3$+)7&16#C3+#7$1+&',#)&4&)1#+/#'#

=&$37$&#)&.'+7/$1270#C&+8&&$#+2&#,7447%3.+5#7$#0)/,3%7$=#%/00&)#-19#

'.3(7$3(6# %/(0')&,# +/# +2&# 31&1# 0&/0.&# 2'-&# /4# +2&# +8/# ,744&)&$+#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"Z#

('+&)7'.19#L2&#)&'1/$#&$+)&0)&$&3)1#%'$#',,.%*#+/#0'5#1/#(3%2#(/)&#

4/)#'#0/3$,#/4#%/00&)6# 71# +2'+# +2&)&#')&#1/(&#0)/,3%+1# +2'+#%'$#C&#

(',&#87+2#%/00&)#'$,#$/+#'.3(7$3(6#'$,#%/$13(&)1#')&#87..7$=#+/#

2'4#4/)#+2&1&#0)/,3%+19#

>$#X71&1N#-7&86#+2&#&$+)&0)&$&3)#7$#'#(')*&+#&%/$/(5#'%+1#'1#

'# A('$,'+')5# /4# +2&# %/$13(&)6B# (&'$7$=# +2'+# 2&# '%+1# '1# +2&#

%/$13(&)N1# '=&$+# /)# )&0)&1&$+'+7-&9# ?)(&,# 87+2# '# *$/8.&,=&# /4#

2/8# (3%2# (/$&5# %/$13(&)1# 87..# 10&$,# /$# -')7/31# =//,1# '$,#

1&)-7%&16# +2&# &$+)&0)&$&3)1# &$+&)# +2&# (')*&+1# 4/)# )'8# ('+&)7'.16#

.'C/)6# '$,#/+2&)# )&1/3)%&1# '$,# &$='=&# 7$# '# C7,,7$=#8')#87+2# &'%2#

/+2&)9#?#27=2#0)7%&#4/)#'#0/3$,#/4#%/00&)6#%/(0')&,#+/#'# ./8#0)7%&#

4/)# '# 0/3$,# /4# '.3(7$3(6# 71# +2&# (')*&+N1# 8'5# /4# 17=$'.7$=# +2'+#

%/00&)# 71# (/)&# 7(0/)+'$+# 4/)# 0.&'17$=# %/$13(&)16# '$,# +2'+#

&$+)&0)&$&3)1# 12/3.,# &;&)%71&# (/)&# %')&# 82&$# 317$=# 7+# 7$# +2&7)#

/0&)'+7/$19#

>+# 71# +271# 4)'(&8/)*# +2'+# .&,#X71&1# +/# +)3(0&+# +2&#$/+7/$#/4#

A%/$13(&)# 1/-&)&7=$+56B# 827%2# %.'7(1# +2'+# +2&# )&'.# 0/8&)# 7$# '#

%'07+'.71+# 151+&(# ,/&1# 0.)# .7&# 87+2# +2&# %'07+'.71+16# '1# +2&# X');71+1#

C&.7&-&,G#

#L2&# %'07+'.71+16# +2&# &$+&)0)71&)16# '$,# +2&# 4')(&)1# ')&#

7$1+)3(&$+'.# 7$#+2&#%/$,3%+#/4#&%/$/(7%#'44'7)19#L2&5#')&#'+# +2&#

2&.(#'$,#1+&&)#+2&#12709#:3+#+2&5#')&#$/+#4)&&#+/#12'0&#7+1#%/3)1&9#

L2&5# ')&#$/+# 130)&(&6# +2&5# ')&# 1+&&)1(&$#/$.56# C/3$,# +/# /C&5#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!"[#

3$%/$,7+7/$'..5# +2&# %'0+'7$h1# /),&)19# L2&# %'0+'7$# 71# +2&#

%/$13(&)9D##

#

X71&1#8&$+#/$#+/#1'5#+2'+#$/+#/$.5#8'1#+2&#%/$13(&)#+2&#/$&#

7$#%2')=&6#C3+#+2'+#2&#8'1#'#,+(73&"%/(('$,&)#'+#+2'+G#

#L2&# )&'.#C/11&1# M3$,&)# %'07+'.71(O#')&# +2&# %/$13(&)19#L2&56#C5#

+2&7)# C357$=# '$,# C5# +2&7)# 'C1+&$+7/$# 4)/(# C357$=6# ,&%7,&# 82/#

12/3.,#/8$#+2&#%'07+'.#'$,#)3$#+2&#0.'$+19#L2&5#,&+&)(7$&#82'+#

12/3.,# C&# 0)/,3%&,# '$,# 7$# 82'+# <3'$+7+5# '$,# <3'.7+59# L2&7)#

'++7+3,&1#)&13.+#&7+2&)#7$#0)/47+#/)#7$#./11#4/)#+2&#&$+&)0)71&)9#L2&5#

('*&#0//)#(&$#)7%2#'$,#)7%2#(&$#0//)9#L2&5#')&#$/#&'15#C/11&19#

L2&5# ')&# 43..# /4# 827(1# '$,# 4'$%7&16# %2'$=&'C.&# '$,#

3$0)&,7%+'C.&9#L2&5#,/#$/+#%')&#'#827+#4/)#0'1+#(&)7+9#?1#1//$#'1#

1/(&+27$=# 71#/44&)&,#+/#+2&(#+2'+# +2&5# .7*&#C&++&)#/)# 71#%2&'0&)6#

+2&5#,&1&)+#+2&7)#/.,#03)-&5/)19E#

##

a/8#+2'+#8&#3$,&)1+'$,#X71&1N#%/$%&0+7/$#/4#+2&#0)/47+R'$,R

./11#151+&(6#'$,#2/8#7+#.&',1#&$+)&0)&$&3)1#7$#'#%'07+'.71+#&%/$/(5#

+/# %'+&)# +/# +2&# ,&17)&1# /4# +2&# 03C.7%6# 8&# %'$# =)'10# 271# %)7+7<3&# /4#

1/%7'.71(9# >$# '# 1/%7'.71+# 1/%7&+56# +2&# V+'+&# $'+7/$'.7\&1# '..# /4# +2&#

A(&'$1# /4# 0)/,3%+7/$6B# 7$%.3,7$=# +2&# %'07+'.# =//,1# '$,# $'+3)'.#

)&1/3)%&1#13%2#'1#4')(.'$,#'$,#%/'.#(7$&19#

:&%'31&# +2&# V+'+&# 71# +2&# 1/.&# /8$&)# /4# +2&# (&'$1# /4#

0)/,3%+7/$6#+2&)&#%'$#C&#$/#(')*&+#0)7%&1#4/)#+2&(9#g&+#+271#(&'$1#

+2&)&#%'$#C&#$/#(/$&+')5#%'.%3.'+7/$6#'$,#%/$1&<3&$+.5#$/#8'5#/4#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

!""#

,&+&)(7$7$=# 82&+2&)# +2&# )&1/3)%&1# C&7$=# 31&,# 30# 7$# '# 0')+7%3.')#

/0&)'+7/$#%/3.,#C&#C&++&)#,&0./5&,#&.1&82&)&#7$#+2&#151+&(9#

S/)# &;'(0.&6# +2&# 1/%7'.71+# 0.'$$&)1# (7=2+# /),&)# '# =)/30# /4#

%/()',&1# +/# +'*&#'#%&)+'7$#'(/3$+#/4#)3CC&)6#1+&&.6#&.&%+)7%7+56#'$,#

1/#4/)+26#7$#/),&)#+/#0)/,3%&#Eii#'3+/(/C7.&19#?4+&)#+2&#4'%+6#+2&)&#71#

17(0.5# $/# 8'5# 4/)# +2&# 0.'$$&)1# +/# *$/8# 82&+2&)# +2&# /3+03+# 8'1#

A8/)+2# 7+9B# V/# ./$=# '1# +2&# %')1# 8&)&# 137+'C.5# &$=7$&&)&,6# +2&#

0.'$$&)1#8/3.,#*$/8#+2'+#+2&#13CF&%+1#8&)&#C&++&)#/44#87+2#+2&#%')1#

+2'$#87+2/3+#+2&(P#7$#/+2&)#8/),16#+2&#%')1#8/3.,#C&#-'.3'C.&9#:3+#

+2&# +)3&# <3&1+7/$# 8'1# 82&+2&)# +2&# %')1# 8/3.,# C&# (/)&# -'.3'C.&#

)5'0" .)5&%" 2.)&0)+'3" 8..*-" )5')" (.$3*" 5'=&" #&&0" 2%.*$(&*" 6+)5" )5&"

%&-.$%(&-")5')"6&%&"$-&*"$2"65+3&"/'7+08")5&"('%-9#

L231#8&#1&&#+2&#43$,'(&$+'.#0)/C.&(#87+2#1/%7'.71(9#:&4/)&#

X71&16# +2&# ,&C'+&# /-&)# +2&# A0.'$$&,# &%/$/(5B# 2',# %&$+&)&,# /$#

7$%&$+7-&19# L/# 87+6# 7$# '# 151+&(# +2'+# 4/../8&,# +2&# %/((3$71+#

0)7$%70.&6# AS)/(#&'%2#'%%/),7$=# +/#271#'C7.7+56# +/#&'%2#'%%/),7$=# +/#

271#$&&,16B#8/3.,#+2&#8/)*&)1#'%+3'..5#0312#+2&(1&.-&1#'1#2'),#'1#

+2&5# ,/# 3$,&)# %'07+'.71(d# >$# /+2&)# 8/),16# 74# +2&# V+'+&# +//*# '..# +2&#

0)/,3%+7/$#'$,#+2)&8#7+#7$+/#/$&#=7'$+#07&6#+/#C&#,71+)7C3+&,#7$#'#8'5#

+2'+#,7,$N+#,&0&$,#/$#&'%2#0&)1/$N1#%/$+)7C3+7/$6#+2&$#8/3.,$N+#+2&#

/-&)'..#07&#12)7$*d#

j/(0&..7$=#+2/3=2#+271#/CF&%+7/$#('5#2'-&#C&&$6#+2&#1/%7'.71+#

+2&/)71+1# %.'7(&,# +2'+# +2&# =)&&,# '$,# 1&.4R%&$+&)&,$&11# /4# +2&#

'-&)'=&#('$#8'1#,3&#+/#271#=)/87$=#30#7$#'#%'07+'.71+#151+&(9#H$%&#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

Iii#

1/%7'.71(#2',#18&0+#+2&#8/).,6#+2&5#%.'7(&,6#'#$&8#AV/%7'.71+#X'$B#

8/3.,#&(&)=&#82/#&$F/5&,#0)/,3%7$=#4/)#271#1+)'$=&)1#'1#(3%2#'1#

4/)#271#/8$#4'(7.59#

>$# +271# %/$+&;+6# 8&# 1&&# 2/8# 0/8&)43.# X71&1N# %)7+7<3&# 8'19#

X71&1# %/$%&,&1# 4/)# +2&# 1'*&# /4# ')=3(&$+# +2'+# &-&)5# 8/)*&)# '$,#

4'%+/)5#('$'=&)#4'7+243..5#/C&51#+2&#/),&)1#/4#+2&#%&$+)'.#0.'$$&)19#

@&#'.1/#%/$%&,&1#4/)#+2&#1'*&#/4#')=3(&$+#+2'+#+2&#0.'$$&)1#2'-&#'..#

+2&# )&.&-'$+# +&%2$7%'.# '$,# 0)'%+7%'.# *$/8.&,=&# 7$# &-&)5# 17$=.&#

7$,31+)5#7$#+2&#&%/$/(59#`-&$#1/6#C&%'31&#+2&5#.'%*#(')*&+#0)7%&16#

+2&# 1/%7'.71+# 0.'$$&)1# 2'-&# $/# (&'$1# /4# 4&&,C'%*6# $/# (&'$1# /4#

,&+&)(7$7$=# 82&+2&)# +2&7)# =)'$,# 0.'$1# ')&# 317$=# )&1/3)%&1#

&447%7&$+.59#?1#X71&1#13((')7\&1#7$#271#=)'$,#+)&'+71&#C$/'0"!()+.0G#

#L2&#0')',/;#/4#A0.'$$7$=B#71#+2'+#7+#%'$$/+#0.'$6#C&%'31&#

/4#+2&#'C1&$%&#/4#&%/$/(7%#%'.%3.'+7/$9#J2'+#71#%'..&,#'#0.'$$&,#

&%/$/(5#71#$/#&%/$/(5#'+#'..9#>+#71#F31+#'#151+&(#/4#=)/07$=#'C/3+#

7$#+2&#,')*9#L2&)&#71#$/#<3&1+7/$#/4#'#)'+7/$'.#%2/7%&#/4#(&'$1#4/)#

+2&#C&1+#0/117C.&#'++'7$(&$+#/4#+2&#3.+7('+&#&$,1#1/3=2+9#J2'+#71#

%'..&,# %/$1%7/31# 0.'$$7$=# 71# 0)&%71&.5# +2&# &.7(7$'+7/$# /4#

%/$1%7/31#03)0/17-&#'%+7/$9f#

#

X/)&# +2'$# '$5# /+2&)# 1%2//.# /4# &%/$/(71+16# +2&# ?31+)7'$1#

)&%/=$7\&# +2&# 1/%7'.# 43$%+7/$# /4# (')*&+# 0)7%&1# '$,# 0)/47+R'$,R./11#

%'.%3.'+7/$19# c&107+&# 7+1# 4.'816# +2&# %'07+'.71+# 1/%7&+5e7$# 827%2#

0)7-'+&#7$,7-7,3'.1#C35#'$,#1&..#+2&#(&'$1#/4#0)/,3%+7/$#7$#'$#/0&$#

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&'(,-.(!/,--#-0(@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@"

"

Ii!#

(')*&+e71# +2&# /$.5# /$&# +2'+# %'$# 0/117C.5# 57&.,# '$# &447%7&$+# 31&# /4#

1%')%&# )&1/3)%&19# H4# %/3)1&# &$+)&0)&$&3)1# 7$# '# (')*&+# &%/$/(5#

('*&# (71+'*&1# '..# +2&# +7(&9# :3+# +2&# %)3%7'.# 0/7$+# 71# +2'+# +2&7)#

(71+'*&1#')&#%&8+-)&%&*"'-"-$(5#C5#+2&#1344&)7$=#/4#./11&19#L2&)&#71#$/#

13%2#4&&,C'%*#7$#'#1/%7'.71+#151+&(#/4#/3+)7=2+#%&$+)'.#0.'$$7$=6#'$,#

+231#$/#(&%2'$71(#+/#C)7$=#+2&#0.'$$&)1N#,&%717/$1# 7$+/#'.7=$(&$+#

87+2# +2&# &-&)# %2'$=7$=# %/$,7+7/$1# /4# 0)/,3%+7/$# '$,# +2&# +'1+&1# /4#

+2&#%/$13(&)19#

##########################################################1 Ludwig von Mises, Bureaucracy, p. 53, available at: http://mises.org/etexts/mises/bureaucracy/section1.asp. Accessed June 4, 2010. 2 Friedrich A. Hayek, “The Use of Knowledge in Society” (1945), American Economic Review, XXXV, No. 4, pp. 519-530, available at: http://www.econlib.org/library/Essays/hykKnw1.html. Accessed June 4, 2010. 3 Hayek, Foreword to Ludwig von Mises, Socialism (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 1981), pp. xix and xxi. 4 Mises, Bureaucracy, p. 226. 5 Mises, Bureaucracy, p. 227. 6 Mises, Human Action (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1998), p. 696.

!"#$%&'(!")*#+&(,-.(!/,--#-0(!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"!#

#

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

+#,-.,/(

$

$

!"#$#% &'(% )*% $#'(*)% &"'+#,#$% +*%

'-').*)% +"#% /$0)10/2#% *3% 3$##%

#)+#$/$0(#%0)%+"#%30#2.%*3%-')40)56%

789.&05%,*)%:0(#(;%

$

$

%&'$ ()*$ +,$ -&*$ '&*./0$ 1/$ %)./$ /2)3+,/4$ 5%/$

'6-,5),/-&'$ 4/./7-63/,5$ ),4$ '-8+)7$ 6&*6-'/$ -($

+,'5+5&5+-,'$ 5%)5$ )*/$9&+5/$ ()3+7+)*$ +,$ )$3)*:/5$ /8-,-30;$ +,87&4+,<$

6*+.)5/$6*-6/*50;$3-,/0;$6*+8/';$),4$6*-(+5'=$ >($ 5%/'/$1/*/$ 5%/$-,70$

5--7'$5%)5$%&3),'$%)4$4/./7-6/4$+,$5%/$'5*&<<7/$)<)+,'5$'8)*8+50;$ +5$

1-&74$ ?/$ /,-&<%$ 5-$ (-'5/*$3-4/*,$ 8+.+7+@)5+-,$ )'$1/$ :,-1$ +5=$ A&5$

5%/$ 3)*:/5$ %)'$ +36*-./4$ &6-,$ 5%/$ B'5)5/$ -($ ,)5&*/C$ 5%*-&<%$ 5%/$

4/./7-63/,5$-($-5%/*$+,'5+5&5+-,'$)'$1/77;$(+77+,<$0/5$3-*/$,+8%/'$5-$

3):/$ 3-4/*,$ 7+(/$ 3-*/$ 6*-4&85+./$ ),4$ 8-3(-*5)?7/=$ D,/$ '&8%$

+,'5+5&5+-,$+'$-')40)5=$

$

0(12'34(1.%"25%(+#,-.,/(

$

E-$)66*/8+)5/$5%/$+36-*5),8/$-($?),:+,<;$1/$8),$+3)<+,/$)$$

E$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!"F$

3)*:/5$ /8-,-30$ 5%)5$ 7)8:/4$ 5%+'$ +,'5+5&5+-,=$ G'$ 1/$ %)./$

'//,;$ '-$ 7-,<$ )'$ +,4+.+4&)7'$ %)./$ 6*+.)5/$ 6*-6/*50$ *+<%5';$ 5%/0$

<*)4&)770$ 1+77$ 4/./7-6$ )$ 3)*:/5H?)'/4$ 8-33-4+50$ 3-,/0;$ 1%+8%$

%+'5-*+8)770$ %)'$ ?//,$ <-74$ -*$ '+7./*$ )'$1-*741+4/$ 5*)4/$ 4/./7-6/4=$

D,8/$ 6/-67/$ ?/<+,$ &'+,<$3-,/0$ +,$ 5%/+*$ 5*)4/';$ 5%/0$ 8),$ 6/*(-*3$

/8-,-3+8$8)78&7)5+-,'$-($6*-(+5$),4$7-''$),4$<)+,$)77$5%/$)4.),5)</'$

5%)5$I+'/'$),4$J)0/:$'5&4+/4=$

J-1/./*;$1+5%-&5$?),:'$5%/*/$1-&74$?/$+,8-,./,+/,8/'$),4$

3+''/4$ -66-*5&,+5+/'=$ K-*$ /2)367/;$ 1/)75%0$ +,4+.+4&)7'$ 1%-$ %)4$

)89&+*/4$ 7)*</$ (-*5&,/'$ 1-&74$ (//7$ ./*0$ ),2+-&'$ )?-&5$ '5-*+,<$

'5-8:6+7/'$ -($ <-74$ ),4$ '+7./*$ +,$ 5%/+*$ %-3/';$ (-*$ (/)*$ -($ (+*/$ -*$

?&*<7)*0=$G,4$1%/,$3):+,<$./*0$7)*</$6&*8%)'/';$3/*8%),5'$1-&74$

%)./$5-$)**),</$(-*$./%+87/'$5-$5*),'6-*5$5%/$%)&7$-($<-74$?)*'$)5$5%/$

3-3/,5$ -($ ')7/=$ E%/'/$ *+':'$ ),4$ +,8-,./,+/,8/'$ 1-&74$ '5+(7/$ 5%/$

)88&3&7)5+-,$ -($ 1/)75%$ ),4$ 5%/$ 8-,'&33)5+-,$ -($ 1%)5$ -5%/*1+'/$

1-&74$?/$3&5&)770$)4.),5)</-&'$4/)7'=$

L+5%-&5$?),:';$7)*</H'8)7/$8*/4+5$5*),')85+-,'$1-&74$)7'-$?/$

3&8%$3-*/$4+((+8&75=$K-*$/2)367/;$)$0-&,<$8-&67/$3+<%5$1),5$5-$?&0$

)$,/1$%-&'/;$),4$5%/0$1-&74$?/$1+77+,<$5-$/)*3)*:$)$6-*5+-,$-($5%/+*$

(&5&*/$ 6)08%/8:'$ +($ -,70$ 5%/0$ 8-&74$ 3-./$ +,5-$ 5%/+*$ %-3/$

+33/4+)5/70=$D,$5%/$-5%/*$%),4;$4-@/,'$-($-74/*$6/-67/$+,$5%/$')3/$

8-33&,+50$ 3+<%5$ %)./$ 7)*</$ )88&3&7)5+-,'$ -($ 3-,/0$ 5%)5$ 5%/0$

1),5/4$5-$4/.-5/$5-$5%/+*$*/5+*/3/,5;$),4$6-''+?70$B6&5$+5$5-$1-*:C$

+,$5%/$3/),5+3/=$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!"M$

N7/)*70$5%/*/$+'$)$1)0$5-$7+,:$&6$5%/$0-&,<$8-&67/$1+5%$5%/+*$

-74/*$,/+<%?-*';$'-$5%)5$/./*0-,/$8-3/'$-&5$)%/)4=$E%/$'-7&5+-,$-($

8-&*'/$+'$(-*$5%/$-74/*$+,4+.+4&)7'$5-$7/,4$5%/+*$'&*67&'$3-,/0$5-$5%/$

8-&67/;$1%-$ 5%/,$?&0$ 5%/+*$4/'+*/4$%-&'/=$E%/,;$-./*$ 5%/$,/25$ (/1$

4/8)4/'$ 5%/$ 8-&67/$ 5*),'(/*'$ )$ 6-*5+-,$ -($ 5%/+*$ 6)08%/8:'$ /./*0$

3-,5%$ 5-$ 6)0+,<$ ?)8:$ 5%/+*$ 7/,4/*'$ )5$ +,5/*/'5=$ E%+'$ +'$ )$ 1+,H1+,$

'8/,)*+-;$ +,$ 1%+8%$ 5%/$ 8-&67/$ B6)0'$ 3-*/C$ (-*$ 5%/+*$ %-&'/;$ ?&5$ +'$

%)660$5-$4-$'-$?/8)&'/$5%/0$8),$3-./$+,$*+<%5$)1)0;$),4$1%/*/$5%/$

-74/*$+,4+.+4&)7'$4/(/*$5%/$&'/$-($5%/+*$')./4$(&,4';$?&5$)*/$%)660$5-$

4-$ '-$ ?/8)&'/$ 5%/0$ /,4$ &6$ */8-&6+,<$ 3-*/$ 5%),$ 5%/$ -*+<+,)7$

6*+,8+6)7=$

G7)';$5%/*/$+'$)$3)O-*$-?'5)87/$5-$-&*$(),8+(&7$'5-*0P$>,$5%/$*/)7$

1-*74;$)$0-&,<$8-&67/$6*-?)?70$8-&74,Q5$-?5)+,$(+,),8+,<$(-*$)$,/1$

%-&'/;$'+3670$?0$%+55+,<$&6$)$(/1$4-@/,$-($5%/+*$,/+<%?-*'$(-*$7)*</$

7-),'=$E%/$*/)'-,$+'$5%)5$67)8+,<$5%/+*$/,5+*/$').+,<'$+,$5%/$%),4'$-($

-,/$ 8-&67/Q'$ */)7$ /'5)5/$ 6&*8%)'/$1-&74$ ?/$ 5--$ $0(4=$ (-*$ 5%/$ -74/*$

,/+<%?-*'=$ K-*$ /2)367/;$ +($ 5%/$ 0-&,<$ %&'?),4$ 7-'5$ %+'$ O-?$ ),4$

4/()&75/4$-,$%+'$3-,5%70$*/6)03/,5';$ 5%/,$5%/$,/+<%?-*'$1%-$%)4$

7/,5$ %+3$ 5%/+*$ 7+(/$ ').+,<'$ 8-&74$ ?/$1+6/4$ -&5;$ -*$ )5$ 5%/$ ./*0$ ?/'5$

5%/0$1-&74$8-77/85+./70$?/$'5&8:$1+5%$)$%-&'/$5%)5$3+<%5$?/$4+((+8&75$

5-$ '/77=$ R,4/*$ 5%/'/$ 8-,4+5+-,';$ +5$ +'$ 87/)*$ 5%)5$ 5%/$ *+':$ -($ 4/()&75$

1-&74$3):/$+5$3&8%$%)*4/*$(-*$6-5/,5+)7$?-**-1/*'$),4$7/,4/*'$5-$

8-,,/85$ 1+5%$ /)8%$ -5%/*$ ),4$ 3):/$ 1+,H1+,$ /28%),</'$ -($ 6*/'/,5$

3-,/0$)<)+,'5$(&5&*/$8)'%$(7-1'=$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!"S$

$

6"&(672(85,9%.2,:(2;(+#,-.,/(

$

E%/$ +,'5+5&5+-,$ -($ ?),:+,<$ )44*/''/'$ 5%/$ 51-$ 6*-?7/3'$

4+'8&''/4$ +,$5%/$)?-./$'/85+-,=$ >5$'-7./'$5%/3$5%*-&<%$51-$4+'5+,85$

(&,85+-,'P$ 5%/$ 6*-.+'+-,$ -($ 8%/8:+,<$ )88-&,5'$ T)''-8+)5/4$ 1+5%$

4/3),4$4/6-'+5'U;$),4$5%/$6*-.+'+-,$-($').+,<'$)88-&,5'$T)''-8+)5/4$

1+5%$5+3/$4/6-'+5'U=$

>,$ 5%/$ 8)'/$ -($ )$ 8%/8:+,<$ )88-&,5$ 1+5%$ V""W$ */'/*./';$ 5%/$

?),:$ )85'$ '+3670$ )'$ )$&'$#"*9(#$ -($ 5%/$ 8&'5-3/*Q'$ 3-,/0=$ >($ 5%/$

8-33&,+50$ &'/4$ 6*/8+-&'$3/5)7'$ )'$ 5%/+*$3-,/0;$ 5%/,$ )$ 8&'5-3/*$

3+<%5$4/6-'+5;$')0;$ 5/,$-&,8/'$-($<-74$)5$ 5%/$?),:;$1%+8%$1-&74$?/$

67)8/4$ ')(/70$ +,$ 5%/$ .)&75=$ >,$ */5&*,;$ 5%/$ 8&'5-3/*$3+<%5$ </5$ ,-5/'$

+''&/4$?0$5%/$?),:;$)77-1+,<$5%/$?/)*/*$5-$*/4//3$5/,$-&,8/'$-($<-74$

1%/,$ 6*/'/,5/4$ )5$ ),0$ -($ 5%/$ ?),:Q'$ ?*),8%/'=$ >,$ 3-4/*,$ 5+3/';$

?),:'$ 4-$ ,-5$ +''&/$ ?),:,-5/'$ '-$3&8%$ )'$ 5%/0$ 6*-.+4/$ 8&'5-3/*'$

1+5%$ 8%/8:?--:'$ ),4$ 4/?+5$ 8)*4'=$ E%/$ 6*+,8+67/$ +'$ 5%/$ ')3/;$

%-1/./*P$ X-$ 7-,<$ )'$ 5%/$ ?),:$ %)'$ )$ '-7+4$ */6&5)5+-,;$ 3/*8%),5'$

:,-1$ 5%)5$ 5%/0$ 8),$ ')(/70$ )88/65$ )$ 8%/8:$ 1*+55/,$ -,$ 5%/$ ?),:;$

?/8)&'/$ 5%/$ ?),:$ 1+77$ */4//3$ +5$ (-*$ 5%/$ '5+6&7)5/4$ )3-&,5$ -($

6%0'+8)7$<-74$&6-,$*/9&/'5=$

>($ )77$ 5%/$ ?),:'$ :/65$ V""W$ -($ 5%/+*$ 8&'5-3/*'Q$ 8%/8:+,<$

)88-&,5$4/6-'+5'$')(/70$+,$5%/$.)&75;$5%/,$5%/$5-5)7$3-,/0$'&6670$+,$

5%/$8-33&,+50$1-&74$?/$&,)((/85/4$?0$5%/$?),:'Q$)85+.+5+/'=$G77$5%)5$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!"Y$

1-&74$ %)66/,$ +'$ 5%)5$ )$ 6-*5+-,$ -($ 5%/$3-,/0$ 8-33-4+50$ T'&8%$ )'$

<-74U$1-&74$3-./$-&5$-($5%/$%-3/$')(/'$),4$6-8:/5'$-($5%/$6/-67/$+,$

5%/$ 8-33&,+50;$ ),4$ 1-&74$ ?/$ '5-*/4$ +,'+4/$ 5%/$ ?),:$ .)&75=$ E%/$

8&'5-3/*'$1-&74$'5+77$%)./$&'/$-($5%/+*$3-,/0;$%-1/./*;$?/8)&'/$-($

5%/$ ?),:,-5/';$ 8%/8:?--:';$ ),4Z-*$ 4/?+5$ 8)*4'$ 6*-.+4/4$ ?0$ 5%/$

?),:=$A&5$ 5%/$?),:/*'$1-&74$%)./$,-$/((/85$-,$5%/$</,/*)7$ 7/./7$-($

6*+8/';$ ?/8)&'/$ 5%/0$ 1-&74,Q5$ ?/$ +,(7&/,8+,<$ 5%/$ 5-5)7$ '>*9)+% -($

3-,/0$ +,$ 5%/$ /8-,-30=$ >,'5/)4;$ 5%/0$1-&74$ '+3670$?/$ <+.+,<$ 5%/+*$

8&'5-3/*'$)$3-*/$8-,./,+/,5$1)0$5-$(+*$#$5%/+*$3-,/0=$

T>,$-&*$6*/'/,5$1-*74;$?),:'$4-$)*+$ -6/*)5/$ +,$ 5%+'$ ()'%+-,;$

?/8)&'/$ 5%/0$ -,70$ ://6$ )$ 3$'1+0*)$ -($ 5%/+*$ 8&'5-3/*'Q$ 8%/8:+,<$

)88-&,5$ 4/6-'+5'$ +,$ 5%/$ .)&75=$ E%+'$ 6*)85+8/$ +'$ 8)77/4$ 3$'1+0*)'2%

$#(#$,#%-')40)5$),4$+'$5%/$'-&*8/$-($5%/$3)*:/5$/8-,-30Q'$6/*+-4+8$

?--3H?&'5$8087/'=$L/$1+77$/267)+,$5%+'$+,$)$7)5/*$8%)65/*;$?&5$+5Q'$(+*'5$

,/8/'')*0$5-$&,4/*'5),4$5%/$?)'+8$-6/*)5+-,'$-($?),:+,<$+,$+5'$6&*/$

(-*3=U$

>,$ )44+5+-,$ 5-$ 6*-.+4+,<$ 1)*/%-&'/$ '/*.+8/'$ (-*$ 8&'5-3/*'$

1+'%+,<$ 5-$ -6/,$ 8%/8:+,<$ )88-&,5';$ ?),:'$ 8),$ )7'-$ )85$ )'$ 8*/4+5$

+,5/*3/4+)*+/';$ '/*.+,<$ )'$ B3+447/3/,C$ 7+,:+,<$&6$?-**-1/*'$1+5%$

')./*'=$>,$5%+'$-6/*)5+-,;$5%/$?),:$-((/*'$),$+,5/*/'5$*)5/$5-$?-**-1$

3-,/0$(*-3$6/-67/$+,$5%/$8-33&,+50$1%-$%)./$'&*67&'$3-,/0$5%/0$

1+'%$ 5-$ 7/,4=$ E%/,$ 5%/$ ?),:$ */7+/'$ -,$ +5'$ /26/*5$ '5)(($ 5-$ +,5/*.+/1$

6-5/,5+)7$ ?-**-1/*'$ +,$ 5%/$ 8-33&,+50$ ),4$ )''+<,$ 5%/3$ )$ %+<%/*$

+,5/*/'5$*)5/;$?)'/4$-,$5%/$*+':+,/''$-($5%/$7-),=$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!"[$

X-$ 7-,<$ )'$ 5%/$ ?),:$ 4-/'$ +5'$ O-?$ 6*-6/*70;$ +5$ /)*,'$ )$ %+<%/*$

)./*)</$ */5&*,$-,$ 5%/$ (&,4'$ +5$ 7/,4'$ 5%),$ +5$ 6)0'$ 5-$ 5%/$ +,4+.+4&)7$

7/,4/*'$1%-$%)./$/,5*&'5/4$5%/+*$').+,<'$1+5%$5%/$?),:=$E%+'$'6*/)4$

8-,'5+5&5/'$ 5%/$ ?),:Q'$ +,8-3/;$ +,$ +5'$ 8)6)8+50$ )'$ )$ 8*/4+5$

+,5/*3/4+)*0=$A&5$5%/$6/-67/$4/6-'+5+,<$5%/+*$').+,<'$1+5%$5%/$?),:$

)*/$%)660$1+5%$5%/$)**),</3/,5;$?/8)&'/$+5$+'$3&8%$')(/*$7/,4+,<$5-$

5%/$?),:$ 5%),$ 5-$ ),$ +,4+.+4&)7$3-*5<)</$)667+8),5=$G75%-&<%$ '-3/$

6/-67/$ 1+77$ '5+77$ 7-'/$ 5%/+*$ O-?'$ ),4$ 4/()&75$ -,$ 5%/+*$ 3-*5<)</$

6)03/,5';$ )$ 1/77H3),)</4$ ?),:$ 1+77$ %)./$ /,-&<%$ 3-*5<)</'$ +,$

67)8/$ 5%)5$ 5%/'/$6*/4+85)?7/$ 7-''/'$ 8),$?/$)?'-*?/4$),4$ '%)*/4$?0$

/./*0-,/=$E%/$/2+'5/,8/$-($5%/$?),:$5%&'$()8+7+5)5/'$5%/$3-./3/,5$-($

3-,/0$(*-3$7/,4/*'$+,5-$5%/$%),4'$-($?-**-1/*';$),4$.+8/$./*')$)'$

T3-'5$-(U$5%/$?-**-1/*'$6)0$-(($5%/+*$7-),'=$

$

6"&(+2,4(<#'-&%(

$

>,$ )44+5+-,$ 5-$ ?),:';$ ),-5%/*$ 3)O-*$ +,'5+5&5+-,$ (-*$ 7+,:+,<$

?-**-1/*'$ 1+5%$ 7/,4/*'$ +'$ 5%/$ -*).% >'$4#+=$ G75%-&<%$ -&*$

%06-5%/5+8)7$ 8-&67/$ 1-&74$ ,-5$ %)./$ 5%/$ */6&5)5+-,$ ),4$

8*/4+51-*5%+,/''$ 5-$)66/)7$4+*/8570$ 5-$ 7/,4/*';$3)O-*$-*<),+@)5+-,'$

'&8%$)'$8-*6-*)5+-,'$),4$<-./*,3/,5'$1')$-?5)+,$(&,4'$(*-3$5%-'/$

1%-$-*+<+,)770$')./4$5%/3=$

X6/8+(+8)770;$ 5%/$ 8-*6-*)5+-,$ T-*$-5%/*$/,5+50U$ +''&/'$)$?-,4;$

1%+8%$ +'$ )$ 7/<)770$ ?+,4+,<$ >DR$ /,5+57+,<$ 5%/$ ?&0/*$ 5-$ )$ '6/8+(+/4$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!"\$

'5*/)3$ -($ 8)'%$ 6)03/,5'=$ >,$ /28%),</$ (-*$ '/77+,<$ 5%+'$ )''/5;$ 5%/$

8-*6-*)5+-,$ -?5)+,'$3-,/0$ +33/4+)5/70=$ A/8)&'/$ 5%/$ ')7/$ 6*+8/$ -($

5%/$?-,4$+'$7-1/*$5%),$5%/$'&3$5-5)7$-($)77$(&5&*/$8)'%$6)03/,5';$5%/$

7/,4/*$T+=/=$5%/$?&0/*$-($5%/$?-,4U$1+77$/,4$&6$/)*,+,<$0)+#$#(+$-,$5%/$

7-),=$ K-*$ /2)367/;$ +($ )$ -,/H0/)*$ ?-,4$ 6*-3+'/'$ 5-$ 6)0$ 5%/$ ?/)*/*$

]V;"""$),4$'/77'$ (-*$]\M"$1%/,$+5$ +'$ (+*'5$ +''&/4;$ 5%/$0+/74$T+,5/*/'5$

*)5/U$-,$5%/$?-,4$+'$T]M"$Z$]\M"U$^$M=#$6/*8/,5=$

$$

6"&(=23&(2;(>,%&'&:%(=#%&:$

$

>,$5%/$G&'5*+),$.+/1;$+,5/*/'5$*)5/'$)*/$)$'6/8+)7$506/$-($6*+8/$

5%)5$8-33&,+8)5/$ +,(-*3)5+-,$)?-&5$5%/$*/7)5+./$ +36)5+/,8/$-($ 5%/$

8-33&,+50=$L%/,$ 6/-67/$ %)./$ ')5+'(+/4$ 5%/+*$ 6*/'/,5$ 4/'+*/'$ ),4$

1),5$ 5-$ 4/.-5/$ 5%/+*$ +,8-3/$ 5-$ 5%/$ (&5&*/;$ 5%/0$ ')./$ 3-*/=$ E%+'$

+,8*/)'/'$5%/$)3-&,5$-($(&,4'$).)+7)?7/$5-$5%/$?),:$(-*$7/,4+,<;$),4$

6&'%/'$ 4-1,$ +,5/*/'5$ *)5/'=$ G5$ 5%/$ 7-1/*$ +,5/*/'5$ *)5/';$

/,5*/6*/,/&*'$(+,4$+5$8%/)6/*$5-$ (+,),8/$ 7-,<H5/*3$6*-O/85';$),4$'-$

5%/0$?-**-1$3-*/$),4$/26),4$5%/+*$-6/*)5+-,'=$

E-$ &,4/*'5),4$ /2)8570$1%)5$ %)66/,'$ +,$ )$3)*:/5$ /8-,-30$

1%/,$5%/$8-33&,+50$4/8+4/'$5-$')./$3-*/;$1/$,//4$5-$ 7--:$)5$ 5%/$

6%0'+8)7$ '+4/$ )'$ 1/77$ )'$ 5%/$ (+,),8+)7=$ >($ )$ 7)*</$ ,&3?/*$ -($ 6/-67/$

4/8+4/$5-$')./$3-*/$-&5$-($5%/+*$8&**/,5$+,8-3/;$+5$3/),'$5%)5$5%/0$

19+%-'14%+"#0$%(/#).0)5$-,$<--4+/'$+,$5%/$6*/'/,5=$K-*$/2)367/;$5%/0$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!V"$

3+<%5$ <-$ -&5$ 5-$ 4+,,/*$ 7/''$ (*/9&/,570;$ )55/,4$ (/1/*$ 3-.+/';$ ?&0$

(/1/*$67)'3)$'8*//,$E_';$),4$'-$-,=$

E%/'/$'6/,4+,<$4/8+'+-,';$-($8-&*'/;$*/4&8/$5%/$?&'+,/''$(-*$

*/'5)&*),5';$ 3-.+/$ 5%/)5/*';$ ),4$ /7/85*-,+8'$ '5-*/'=$ N-,'/9&/,570$

5%/$*/'5)&*),5'$%)./$5-$7)0$-(($1)+5/*'$),4$8--:';$),4$?&0$7/''$(--4=$

E%/$ 3-.+/$ 5%/)5/*$ -1,/*'$ %)./$ 5-$ 7)0$ -(($ 1-*:/*'$ )'$ 1/77;$ ),4$

6/*%)6'$ 6-'56-,/$ 5%/$ 8-,'5*&85+-,$ -($ )$ ,/1$3&75+67/2$ )*/,)=$ E%/$

3),&()85&*/*'$ -($ 67)'3)$ '8*//,$ E_'$ 1+77$ -($ 8-&*'/$ ,//4$ 5-$ '8)7/$

?)8:$6*-4&85+-,$)5$ 5%/+*$ ()85-*+/';$ 7)0+,<$-(($1-*:/*'$),4$*/4&8+,<$

5%/+*$6&*8%)'/'$-($*)1$3)5/*+)7'=$

G75%-&<%$ '-3/$ '8%--7'$ -($ 5%-&<%5;$ '&8%$ )'$ 5%/$ `/0,/'+),;$

1-&74$ .+/1$ 5%/$ 4*-6$ +,$ 8-,'&3/*$ '6/,4+,<$ )'$ )$ 4+')'5/*$ 1%+8%$

1-&74$8*/)5/$*+667/'$-($<*-1+,<$&,/367-03/,5;$5%/$G&'5*+),'$)*<&/$

5%)5$)$%/)75%0$3)*:/5$/8-,-30$*/'6-,4'$5-$8%),</'$+,$6*/(/*/,8/'$

+,$ ),$ /((+8+/,5$3),,/*=$ >($ 3-'5$ 6/-67/$ 8&5$ ?)8:$ 5%/+*$ '6/,4+,<$ -,$

*/'5)&*),5';$3-.+/';$),4$E_';$+5$1-&74$?/$5-$?&+74$&6$5%/+*$)?+7+50$5-$

'6/,4$0)%+"#%39+9$#=$E%/$(*//4H&6$1-*:/*'$),4$-5%/*$*/'-&*8/'$(*-3$

5%/$*/'5)&*),5';$3-.+/$5%/)5/*';$),4$E_$()85-*+/'$1-&74,Q5$4+')66/)*$

(*-3$ 5%/$ ()8/$ -($ 5%/$ /)*5%a$ +,'5/)4;$ 5%/0$ 1-&74$ ?/$ )?'-*?/4$ +,5-$

-5%/*$'/85-*'$5%)5$1/*/$/26),4+,<=$>,$6)*5+8&7)*;$5%/$7-1/*$+,5/*/'5$

*)5/'$ T(&/7/4$?0$ 5%/$,/1$').+,<'U$1-&74$)77-1$-5%/*$?&'+,/''/'$ 5-$

(+,),8/$ <*-15%$ +,$ 5%/+*$ -6/*)5+-,';$ ),4$ 5%/0$ 1-&74$ %+*/$ 5%/$

&,/367-0/4$1-*:/*'$),4$'6)*/$3)5/*+)7'=$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!VV$

>,$ 5%/$ G&'5*+),$ .+/1;$ +,5/*/'5$ *)5/'$ '/*./$ 5-$ */<&7)5/$ 5%/$

3)*:/5$ /8-,-30Q'$ (-8&'$ -,$ 6*/'/,5$ ./*'&'$ (&5&*/$ 6*-4&85+-,=$ >($

3-'5$6/-67/$)*/$*/7)5+./70$+36)5+/,5b3/),+,<$5%/0$1),5$5-$'6/,4$

5%/+*$+,8-3/$-,$/,O-03/,5'$+,$5%/$,/)*$(&5&*/b5%/,$').+,<'$1+77$?/$

7-1;$ ),4$ +,5/*/'5$ *)5/'$ 1+77$ ?/$ %+<%=$ E%+'$ 1+77$ 6/,)7+@/$ 7-,<H5/*3$

?&'+,/''$ 6*-O/85';$ ?/8)&'/$ /,5*/6*/,/&*'$ 1+77$ (+,4$ 5%/$ B8-'5$ -($

8)6+5)7C$ 5--$ %+<%$ (-*$ 6*-O/85'$ 5%)5$ */9&+*/$ 3),0$ 0/)*'$ -($ +,6&5'$

?/(-*/$5%/0$0+/74$5%/+*$*/'&75'=$

D,$ 5%/$ -5%/*$ %),4;$ +($ 3-'5$ 6/-67/$ +,$ 5%/$ 8-33&,+50$ )*/$

*/7)5+./70$6)5+/,5b3/),+,<$5%/0$)*/$1+77+,<$5-$4/(/*$5%/+*$'6/,4+,<$

5-$5%/$4+'5),5$(&5&*/;$'-$7-,<$)'$5%/0$/)*,$)$6*/3+&3$(-*$4-+,<$'-b

5%/,$').+,<'$1+77$?/$%+<%;$),4$+,5/*/'5$*)5/'$1+77$?/$ 7-1=$E%/$8%/)6$

8-'5$ -($ 8)6+5)7$ 1+77$ /,8-&*)</$ /,5*/6*/,/&*'$ 5-$ <-$ 5-$ 5%/$ ?),:$ 5-$

(+,),8/$ 7-,<H5/*3$ 6*-O/85'$ 5%)5$ %)./$ )$ %+<%$ 6)0-(($ ?&5$ 5):/$3),0$

0/)*'$5-$8-367/5/=$

>,$ /+5%/*$ '8/,)*+-;$ 3)*:/5$ 6*+8/'$ T+,$ 5%/$ (-*3$ -($ +,5/*/'5$

*)5/'U$<&+4/$/,5*/6*/,/&*'$5-$4/67-0$'8)*8/$*/'-&*8/'$+,$1)0'$5%)5$

?/'5$ '&+5$ 5%/$ 4/'+*/'$ -($ 5%/$ 8-,'&3/*'=$ >5$ +'$ I+'/'Q$ </,/*)7$

-?'/*.)5+-,$ )?-&5$ 8-,'&3/*'$ '5//*+,<$ 6*-4&85+-,;$ )667+/4$ 5-$ 5%/$

'6/8+)7$ 8)'/$ -($ 6*-4&8+,<$ 8-,'&3/*$ <--4'$ T(),80$ 4+,,/*';$ 67)'3)$

'8*//,$E_'U$./*'&'$8)6+5)7$<--4'$T5*)85-*';$4*+77$6*/''/'U=$

>($ 5%/$ 6/-67/$ +,$ )$ 8-33&,+50$ )*/$ 1+77+,<$ 5-$ 4/(/*$

8-,'&365+-,;$+5$(*//'$&6$6%0'+8)7$*/'-&*8/'$5-$6*-4&8/$3-*/$8)6+5)7$

<--4'=$E%+'$3):/'$1-*:/*'$3-*/$6*-4&85+./;$?/8)&'/$5%/0$,-1$8),$

!"#$%#&'<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<%

%

!V!$

&'/$?/55/*$3)8%+,/'$),4$/9&+63/,5=$ >,$ 5%/$ 7-,<$ *&,;$ )$ 8-33&,+50$

5%)5$')./'$)$7)*</$(*)85+-,$-($+5'$+,8-3/$1+77$/,O-0$)$%+<%/*$'5),4)*4$

-($ 7+.+,<$ 5%),$ )$ 8-33&,+50$ -($ '6/,45%*+(5'=$ A/8)&'/$ 5%/$ 6*-4+<)7$

'6/,4/*'$')./$'-$7+557/$-&5$-($5%/+*$+,8-3/;$5%/$*/'&75$+'$),$/8-,-30$

</)*/4$ 5-1)*4$ 5%/$ 6*-4&85+-,$ -($ +33/4+)5/$ 8-,'&3/*$ <--4'=$

N-,'/9&/,570;$ 5%+'$ /8-,-30$ 1+77$ ,-5$ 4/./7-6$ 5--7'$ ),4$ -5%/*$

'&667/3/,5'$5-$+,8*/)'/$5%/$-&56&5$-($+5'$1-*:/*'$-./*$5+3/=$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1998), p. 440.

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

+,-.'#,/&(

$

$

!"#$%"&'(" )*" +(,-./" 0(" 1,(2)/." (+" ')*"

(&%"$--(3%0"+(,"')*"(4/"$5."#3*0"*$2."$"

1$,0" (+" ')*" )%-(#." (," 0$6." (30" $%"

)%*3,$%-." 1(4)-788893-'" $" #$%" )*" #(,."

4)6.47" 0(" 5.0" $%" )/.$" (+" 0'." .-(%(#)-"

1,(:4.#*" (+" ')*" -(3%0,7" 0'$%" $" #$%"

&'(#" $" 1.%*)(%" *-'.#." *..#)%547"

,.4).2.*"(+"$44"&(,,).*8"

;<3/&)5"2(%"=)*.*>"

"

$

%$ &'(%$ )%%*$ +&'+$ '$ ,-%%$ .'-/%+$ %01*1.23$ 4*$ 5&40&$

4*64(467'8)$+-'6%$+&%4-$9-19%-+2$4*$1-6%-$+1$4.9-1(%$

+&%4-$ 04-07.)+'*0%)3$ ,1)+%-)$ +&%$ 6%(%819.%*+$ 1,$ )104'8$ 4*)+4+7+41*)$

+&'+$ %*&'*0%$ &7.'*):$ ';484+2$ +1$ 7)%$ +&%4-$ 8';1-$ '*6$ +&%$ <4,+)$ 1,$

*'+7-%$4*$+&%$.1)+$9-1670+4(%$5'2=$>*$9'-+4078'-3$+&%$6%(%819.%*+$1,$

.1*%2$ '*6$ ;'*/4*<$ '8815)$ 4*64(467'8)$ +1$ .'/%$ -'+41*'8$ ,4*'*04'8$

<1'8)$ ,1-$ +&%4-$ %*+4-%$ 84,%+4.%)=$ ?1*+-'-2$ +1$ +&%$ 08'4.)$ 1,$ +&%$

)104'84)+)3$ 4*$ '$ )19&4)+40'+%6$ 0'94+'84)+$ )104%+2$ %'0&$ &17)%&186$

%*<'<%)$4*$5.%3)%.$@%01*1.40$98'**4*<=A$

B$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!"C$

D15%(%-3$ +&%-%$ 4)$ )+488$ 1*%$ .'E1-$ 4))7%$ +&'+$ 5%$ &'(%*:+$

64)07))%6=$ >*$ 17-$ 51-863$ 4*64(467'8)$ '-%$ )7;E%0+$ +1$ 7*84/%82$ ;7+$

0'+')+-19&40$,)*6*=$F1-$%G'.98%3$)1.%1*%$01786$;%$H74+%$-%)91*)4;8%3$

97++4*<$ ')46%$ '$ 8'-<%$ 91-+41*$ 1,$ &4)$ 9'20&%0/$ %(%-2$ .1*+&$ 4*+1$ '$

)'(4*<)$'0017*+$54+&$+&%$;'*/=$I%+$+&-17<&$*1$,'78+$1,$&4)$15*3$&4)$

&17)%$.4<&+$;7-*$615*$5&48%$&%$4)$'5'2$1*$('0'+41*=$J(%*$51-)%3$

+&%$ .'*$ 01786$ )766%*82$ 6-19$ 6%'6$ 1,$ '$ &%'-+$ '++'0/3$ 8%'(4*<$ &4)$

54615$54+&$'$.1-+<'<%$9'2.%*+$'*6$'*$4*'6%H7'+%$;'*/$;'8'*0%=$

$

0"&(1.,/%23,(34(5.'&(+,-.'#,/&$

$

K1$&%89$ 4*64(467'8)$019%$54+&$ +&%$*7.%-17)$-4)/)$ +&%2$ ,'0%3$

.'-/%+)$&'(%$6%(%819%6$+&%$4*)+4+7+41*$1,$4*)7-'*0%=$K&%$07)+1.%-)$

1,$ '*$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*2$ 9118$ +&%4-$ ,'+%3$ 4*$ '$ )%*)%3$ 4*$ 1-6%-$ +1$

'(%-'<%$17+$+&%4-$0188%0+4(%$17+01.%=$F1-$%G'.98%3$)7991)%$+&'+$17+$

1,$'$91978'+41*$1,$1*%$+&17)'*6$&1.%15*%-)3$ ,4-%$5488$6%)+-12$1*%$

1,$ +&%4-$ &17)%)$ 4*$ '*2$ <4(%*$ 2%'-3$ 0'7)4*<$ L!MM3MMM$ 51-+&$ 1,$

6'.'<%=$ >*$ +%-.)$ 1,$ .'+&%.'+40'8$ %G9%0+'+41*3$ +&%-%,1-%3$ %'0&$

.%.;%-$1,$+&4)$<-179$5488$84/%82$)7,,%-$L!MM$51-+&$1,$,4-%$6'.'<%$1*$

'(%-'<%$9%-$2%'-=$

N7+$1,$017-)%3$4*$-%'84+2$+&4*<)$98'2$17+$.70&$64,,%-%*+82=$>*$'$

+2940'8$ 2%'-3$ OOO$ 1,$ +&%$ &1.%15*%-)$ 5488$ )7,,%-$ *1$ 81))$ '+$ '883$

5&%-%')$1*%$.%.;%-$1,$+&%$<-179$5488$;%$6%(')+'+%6=$N2$97-0&')4*<$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!"P$

'$ &17)%$ Q4*)+%'6$ 1,$ -%*+4*<R3$ +&%$ 4*64(467'8)$ 4*$ +&4)$ <-179$ '-%$ 4*$ '$

)%*)%$)7;E%0+4*<$+&%.)%8(%)$+1$'$6'*<%-17)$<'.;8%=$

S$ 01.9'*2$ 9-1(464*<$ ,4-%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 0'*$ 4.9-1(%$ +&%$

)4+7'+41*$<-%'+82=$N2$0&'-<4*<$%'0&$&17)%&186$'*$'**7'8$9-%.47.$1,$

L!MP3$ +&%$ 01.9'*2$ 0'*$ 9-1.4)%$ +1$ 4*6%.*4,2$ '$ &1.%15*%-$ 5&%*$

&4)$ 1-$ &%-$ &17)%$ ;7-*)$ 615*=$ T1+40%$ +&'+$ +&4)$ '--'*<%.%*+$ 4)$ 2%+$

'*1+&%-$%G'.98%$1,$'$91)4+4(%U)7.3$54*U54*$%G0&'*<%$4*$+&%$.'-/%+V$

K&%$ 4*)7-%-$ ;%*%,4+)$ ,-1.$ %'-*4*<$ LP3MMM$ Q1(%-$ '*6$ ';1(%$ +&%$

6'.'<%$ 08'4.)R$ 4*$ '$ +2940'8$ 2%'-3$ 5&48%$ +&%$ &1.%15*%-)$ ;%*%,4+$

,-1.$01*(%-+4*<$+&%4-$).'88$0&'*0%$1,$'$0'+')+-19&40$L!MM3MMM$ 81))$

4*+1$+&%$.70&$.1-%$'00%9+';8%$0%-+'4*+2$1,$81)4*<$L!MP$4*$9-%.47.$

9'2.%*+)$ %(%-2$ 2%'-=$ QT'+7-'882$ 5%$ '-%$ 8%'(4*<$ 17+$ .'*2$ 1,$ +&%$

01.9840'+41*)$1,$+&%$-%'8U84,%$4*)7-'*0%$4*67)+-23$4*$1-6%-$+1$,107)$1*$

4+)$%01*1.40$%))%*0%=R$

W%198%$ 1,+%*$ 6%)0-4;%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ ')$ '$ ,1-.$ 1,$ <'.;84*<3$

)'24*<3$@B&%*$217$+'/%$17+$ ,4-%$ 4*)7-'*0%3$217:-%$;%++4*<$+&'+$217-$

&17)%$ 5488$ ;7-*$ 615*$ 5&48%$ +&%$ 01.9'*2$ +'/%)$ +&%$ 1991)4+%$

91)4+41*=A$ K&4)$ 01..1*$ (4%5$ &')$ +&4*<)$ %G'0+82$ ;'0/5'-6)=$ >,$

'*2+&4*<3$+'/4*<$17+$4*)7-'*0%$4)$+&%$(11(*)0.$1,$<'.;84*<=$B&%*$217$

<'.;8%3$217$+2940'882$9'2$'$).'88$'.17*+$1,$.1*%2$Q)70&$')$;724*<$

'$ 81++1$ +40/%+R$ +1$<'4*$%G91)7-%$ +1$'$ ).'88$9-1;';484+2$1,$54**4*<$'$

8'-<%$ '.17*+$ 1,$.1*%2=$ >*$ 01*+-')+3$5&%*$ 217$ +'/%$ 17+$ 4*)7-'*0%3$

217$ 9'2$ '$ ).'88$ '.17*+$ 1,$ .1*%2$ Q+&%$ 9-%.47.R$ 4*$ 1-6%-$ +1$

.4)#)%$0." 217-$ %G91)7-%$ +1$ '$ ).'88$ 9-1;';484+2$ 1,$ 4(*)%5$ '$ 8'-<%$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!"X$

'.17*+$ 1,$ .1*%2$ Q1-$ )7,,%-4*<$ )1.%$ 1+&%-$ 64)')+%-R=$ Y'.;84*<$

.'/%)$ 217-$ ,4*'*04'8$ ,7+7-%$ 4.**" 0%-+'4*3$5&%-%')$ 4*)7-'*0%$.'/%)$

217-$,4*'*04'8$,7+7-%$#(,.$0%-+'4*=$

>*$ +&%$0')%$1,$6%'+&3$ +&%$97-%$ ,1-.$1,$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 4)$ 0.,#" 4)+.=$

B&%*$ '*$ 4*64(467'8$ ;72)$ '$ +%-.$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01*+-'0+3$ &%$ 9'2)$ '$

01*+-'0+7'8$ )+-%'.$1,$ 9-%.47.)$5&48%$ +&%$ 4*)7-%-$ '<-%%)$ +1$ 9'2$ '$

0%-+'4*$ '.17*+$ 1,$ .1*%2$ Q+&%$ @6%'+&$ ;%*%,4+AR$ +1$ '$ *'.%6$

;%*%,404'-23$*("4(%5"$*"0'."/.$0'"(--3,*")%"$"*0)134$0./"0)#."+,$#.=$>,$

+&%$ 4*64(467'8$ )7-(4(%)$ +&-17<&17+$ +&%$ 9%-416$ 1,$ +&%$ 1-4<4*'8$ +%-.$

84,%$ 01*+-'0+3$ +&%*$ &%$ <%+)$ *1$ 9'2.%*+$ ,-1.$ +&%$ 4*)7-%-=$ >+$ 4)$

'*'81<17)$+1$'$&1.%15*%-$5&1$9'2)$,4-%$ 4*)7-'*0%$9-%.47.)$'*6$

*%(%-$&')$'$,4-%=$

$

5.'&( +,-.'#,/&( 56.-( 7#82,9-( :&"2/6&;( 5&'<#,&,%( =24&(

+,-.'#,/&(

$

>*$ '664+41*$ +1$ +%-.$ 918404%)3$ +&%$ .'-/%+$ &')$ 6%(%819%6$

'*1+&%-$ ,1-.$ 1,$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%=$ B4+&$ '$ 1.,#$%.%0" 4)+." )%*3,$%-."

1(4)-73$ +&%$ 4*64(467'8$1*0%$'<'4*$'<-%%)$ +1$.'/%$9%-41640$9-%.47.$

9'2.%*+)=$ >*$ %G0&'*<%3$ +&%$ 4*)7-%-$ 9-1.4)%)$ +1$ 9'2$ '$ .1*%+'-2$

;%*%,4+$ 7*6%-$ +51$ )0%*'-41)V$ >+$ 5488$ 9'2$ +&%$ *'.%6$ ;%*%,404'-2$ '$

6%'+&$;%*%,4+3$4*$+&%$%(%*+$+&'+$+&%$4*)7-%6$64%)$;%,1-%$'$0%-+'4*$'<%3$

(,"+&%$4*)7-%-$5488$9'2$+&%$15*%-$1,$+&%$918402$Q+&%$1*%$.'/4*<$+&%$

9-%.47.$9'2.%*+)R$4,$&%$)7-(4(%)$;%21*6$'$07+1,,$'<%$Q)70&$')$"MM$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!"Z$

1-$ "!"$ 2%'-)R=$ S$ 1.,#$%.%0" 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 918402$ 4)$ )1$ *'.%63$

;%0'7)%$ 4+$ 61%)$ *1+$ %G94-%$ ')$ 61%)$ '$ +%-.$ 84,%$ 918402=$ K&%$ 98'4*$

('*488'$ (%-)41*$ 1,$ 9%-.'*%*+$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 4)$ 0'88%6$ '$ &'(4." 4)+."

9184023$'<'4*$;%0'7)%$4+$9-1(46%)$'*$4*64(467'8$54+&$4*)7-'*0%$,1-$&4)$

5&18%$84,%3$-'+&%-$+&'*$E7)+$'$91-+41*$1,$4+=$

B4+&$ 9%-.'*%*+$ 84,%3$ +&%$ 4*)7-%-$ /*15)$ +&'+$ 4+$ 5488$ &'(%$ +1$

9'2$17+$)11*%-$1-$8'+%-$1*$%(%-2$918402$Q)1$81*<$')$+&%$918402&186%-$

)+'2)$ 07--%*+$ 54+&$ &4)$ 9-%.47.$ 9'2.%*+)R=$ N%0'7)%$ 1,$ +&4)3$ +&%$

9-%.47.)$'-%$&4<&%-$1*$'$9%-.'*%*+$918402$+&'*$,1-$'$01.9'-';8%$

+%-.$ 918402=$ QT1+%$ +&'+$ +&%$ (')+$ .'E1-4+2$ 1,$ +%-.$ 918404%)$ %G94-%$

54+&17+$'$08'4.$'<'4*)+$+&%$4*)7-%-=R$

[*$ +&%$ 1+&%-$ &'*63$ +&%$ &4<&%-$ 9-%.47.)$ 1,$ '$ 9%-.'*%*+$

918402$ '-%$ 01.9%*)'+%6$ ;2$ +&%$ <-154*<$ @0')&$ ('87%A$ 1,$ +&%$ 918402=$

F1-$%G'.98%3$4,$'*$4*)7-%-$9-1(46%)$'$)+'*6'-6$5&18%$84,%$918402$+&'+$

.'+7-%)$ '+$ '<%$"!"$ '*6$ 0'--4%)$ '$6%'+&$;%*%,4+$ 1,$ L"$.48841*3$ +&%*$

+&%$ 4*)7-%-$ .7)+$ 01*670+$ 4+)$ 19%-'+41*)$ )1$ +&'+$ +&%$ 9%-41640$

9-%.47.$ 9'2.%*+)$ '-%$ 4*(%)+%6$ 4*$ 1-6%-$ +1$ '0H74-%$ '$ ('87%$ 1,$ '+$

8%')+$L"$.48841*$;2$+&%$+4.%$+&%$ 4*)7-%6$+7-*)$"!"=$ Q>*$9-'0+40%$ +&%$

4*)7-%-$5488$&'(%$+1$61$.1-%$+&'*$+&4)3$;%0'7)%$+&%-%$4)$'85'2)$+&%$

-4)/$ +&'+$ +&%$ 4*)7-%6$ 5488$ 64%$ :.+(,.$ '<%$ "!"$ '*6$ -%H74-%$ +&%$ L"$

.48841*$9'2.%*+$%'-84%-=R$

K&%$ *'+7-%$ 1,$ '$ 5&18%$ 84,%$ 918402$ 4)$ )70&$ +&'+$ ',+%-$ %'0&$

9-%.47.$ 9'2.%*+3$ +&%$ )7-(4(4*<$ 918402&186%-$ .1(%)$ +&'+$ .70&$

081)%-$+1$+&%$L"$.48841*$9'2.%*+$Q%4+&%-$+&-17<&$6%'+&$1-$'++'4*4*<$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!"\$

'<%$ "!"R=$ >*$ '$ )%*)%3$ +&%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*2$ 4)$ )4.982$ 1(%-)%%4*<$

+&%$918402&186%-:)$9-%.47.$9'2.%*+)3$ +1$%*)7-%$ +&'+$ +&%2$<-15$+1$

+&%$ -%H74-%6$ '.17*+$ 4*$ +&%$ )+4978'+%6$ +4.%$ ,-'.%=$ N%0'7)%$ 1,$ +&4)$

'--'*<%.%*+3$ ')$ '*$ '66%6$ ,%'+7-%$ ,1-$ +&%4-$ 07)+1.%-)3$ 5&18%$ 84,%$

4*)7-'*0%$01.9'*4%)$'8815$918402&186%-)$+1$)7--%*6%-$+&%4-$918404%)$

'+$ '*2$ +4.%$ ;2$ )+1994*<$ 9'2.%*+$ 1,$ 9-%.47.3$ '*6$ <%++4*<$ '$ 87.9$

)7.$ 9'2.%*+$ 1,$ +&%$ @0')&$ )7--%*6%-$ ('87%A$ '+$ +&'+$ 914*+=$ >*$ +&%$

1-4<4*'8$ 01*+-'0+3$ +&%$ 4*)7-%-$ 9-1(46%)$ '$ 84)+$ 1,$ <7'-'*+%%6$ 0')&$

('87%)$'+$('-417)$2%'-)$4*+1$+&%$84,%$1,$+&%$918402=$

K1$ 01.9'-%$ +%-.$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 54+&$ 9%-.'*%*+$ 84,%$

4*)7-'*0%3$ '*$ '*'81<2$ ,-1.$ -%'8$ %)+'+%$ 4)$ '9+=$ ]1.%1*%$ -%*+4*<$ '$

&17)%$+2940'882$9'2)$'$815%-$'.17*+$9%-$.1*+&$+1$+&%$8'*681-63$+&'*$

+&%$ '.17*+$ &%$ 51786$ &'(%$ +1$ 9'2$ +1$ +&%$ ;'*/$ &'6$ &%$ +'/%*$ 17+$ '$

.1-+<'<%$ +1$ ;72$ +&%$ )'.%$ &17)%=$ D15%(%-3$ +&%$ &1.%;72%-$ 4)$

01.9%*)'+%6$,1-$&4)$&4<&%-$.1*+&82$9'2.%*+)$;2$+&%$,'0+$+&'+$1(%-$

+4.%$&%$;7486)$.@3)07$ 4*$ +&%$&17)%=$S,+%-$ +&%$.1-+<'<%$ 4)$ ,7882$9'46$

1,,3$ +&%$9%-)1*$15*)$ +&%$&17)%$17+-4<&+3$&'(4*<$'$('87';8%$'))%+$ 4*$

&4)$ 91))%))41*=$ >*$ 01*+-')+3$ +&%$ -%*+%-$ %*E12)$ 815%-$ .1*+&82$

9'2.%*+)$ +1$'0&4%(%$ +&%$)'.%$ ,815$1,$ @&17)4*<$)%-(40%)3A$;7+$&%$ 4)$

*1+$4*(%)+4*<$4*$&4)$81*<U+%-.$5%'8+&=$T1$.'++%-$&15$81*<$&%$.'/%)$

&4)$.1*+&82$-%*+'8$9'2.%*+)3$&%$&')$*1+&4*<$+1$)&15$,1-$4+$;%)46%)$

+&%$+%.91-'-2$-11,$1(%-$&4)$&%'6=$

K&%-%$ 4)$ '$ )4.48'-$ +-'6%1,,$ 4*$ +&%$ 0')%$1,$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%=$K&%$

9%-)1*$ ;724*<$ '$ +%-.$ 918402$ %*E12)$ +&%$ )'.%$ '.17*+$ 1,$ 97-%$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!"O$

4*)7-'*0%$ 01(%-'<%$ ,1-$ 815%-$ .1*+&82$ 9-%.47.)=$ D15%(%-3$ +&%$

.1.%*+$&%$)+19)$.'/4*<$+&%$9-%.47.$9'2.%*+)3$&%$&')$*1+&4*<$+1$

)&15$,1-$&4)$,'4+&,78$&4)+1-2=$>*$01*+-')+3$+&%$15*%-$1,$'$9%-.'*%*+$

84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 918402$ Q)70&$ ')$ 5&18%$ 84,%R$ '6.4++%682$ 9'2)$ '$ &4<&%-$

.1*+&82$ 9-%.47.$ ,1-$ +&%$ )'.%$ 6%'+&$ ;%*%,4+3$ ;7+$ 1(%-$ +4.%$ &%$

;7486)$79$%H74+2$4*$+&%$918402=$>,$&%$84(%)$81*<$%*17<&3$&%$%(%*+7'882$

@9'2)$ 1,,$ +&%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*2A$ '*6$ 15*)$ +&%$ ,'0%$ ('87%$ 1,$ +&%$

918402$17+-4<&+3$&'(4*<$'$(%-2$('87';8%$'))%+$ Q)70&$')$L"$.48841*$1-$

.1-%R$4*$&4)$91))%))41*=$

$

0"&(>.-%'2#,(5&'-$&/%28&(3,(+,-.'#,/&$

$

N%0'7)%$ +&%$ S7)+-4'*$ %01*1.4)+)$ )+-%))$ +&%$ 4.91-+'*0%$ 1,$

)'(4*<$'*6$0'94+'8$'007.78'+41*$4*$%01*1.40$6%(%819.%*+3$4+$4)$1*82$

*'+7-'8$ +&'+$ +&%2$ &'(%$ '*$ ',,4*4+2$ ,1-$ +&%$ 4*)+4+7+41*$ 1,$ 4*)7-'*0%=$

^%)_)$ D7%-+'$ 6%$ ]1+13$ '-<7';82$ +&%$ 51-86:)$ 8%'64*<$ )0&18'-$ 1*$

S7)+-4'*$;7)4*%))$0208%$+&%1-23$5-4+%)V$

$K&%$ )104'8$ )4<*4,40'*0%$ 1,$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*4%)$ )%+)$

+&%.$'9'-+$ ,-1.$1+&%-$ +-7%$ ,4*'*04'8$ 4*+%-.%64'-4%)=$ >*$ ,'0+$ +&%$

01*+-'0+)$1,,%-%6$;2$+&%)%$4*)+4+7+41*)$.'/%$4+$91))4;8%$,1-$;-1'6$

8'2%-)$ 1,$ )104%+2$ +1$ 7*6%-+'/%$ '$ <%*74*%3$ 64)04984*%6$ %,,1-+$ +1$

)'(%$,1-$+&%$81*<$+%-.=$>*6%%6$84,%$4*)7-'*0%$9-1(46%)$+&%$9%-,%0+$

5'2$ +1$ )'(%3$ )4*0%$ 4+$ 4)$ +&%$ 1*82$ .%+&16$ 5&40&$ <7'-'*+%%)3$

9-%04)%82$ '+$ +&1)%$ .1.%*+)$ 5&%*$ &17)%&186)$ %G9%-4%*0%$ +&%$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!!M$

<-%'+%)+$*%%6$Q4*$1+&%-$51-6)3$4*$+&%$0')%$1,$6%'+&3$64)';484+23$1-$

-%+4-%.%*+R3$ +&%$ 4..%64'+%$'('48';484+2$1,$'$ 8'-<%$)7.$1,$.1*%2$

5&40&3$ ;2$ 1+&%-$ )'(4*<$ .%+&16)3$ 01786$ 1*82$ ;%$ '007.78'+%6$

,188154*<$'$(%-2$9-181*<%6$9%-416$1,$ +4.%=$B4+&$ +&%$9'2.%*+$1,$

+&%$ ,4-)+$ 9-%.47.3$ +&%$ 918402&186%-:)$ ;%*%,404'-4%)$ '0H74-%$ +&%$

-4<&+$+1$-%0%4(%3$4*$+&%$%(%*+$1,$+&4)$9%-)1*:)$6%'+&3$,1-$4*)+'*0%3$'$

)7;)+'*+4'8$ '.17*+$ 1,$ .1*%2$ 5&40&$ 51786$ &'(%$ +'/%*$ +&%$

918402&186%-$.'*2$2%'-)$+1$)'(%$(4'$1+&%-$.%+&16)=$

àBb%$01786$01*0876%$+&'+$84,%$4*)7-'*0%$01.9'*4%)$'-%$

+&%$ H74*+%))%*+4'8$ @+-7%$ ,4*'*04'8$ 4*+%-.%64'-4%)3A$ ;%0'7)%$ +&%4-$

'0+4(4+2$ 01*)4)+)$ 9-%04)%82$ 1,$ %*017-'<4*<$ 81*<U+%-.$ )'(4*<$ 4*$

,'.484%)$'*6$0&'**%84*<$ )'(%6$ ,7*6)$ 4*+1$(%-2$ )%07-%$ 81*<U+%-.$

4*(%)+.%*+)$Q.'4*82$;87%U0&49$;1*6)$'*6$-%'8$%)+'+%R=!$

$

>*$'$ ,11+*1+%$+1$+&%$';1(%$6%)0-49+41*3$6%$]1+1$%G98'4*)$+&'+$

&%$4)$*1+$'81*%$4*$&4)$01*087)41*V$

$S7)+-4'*$ %01*1.4)+)$ &'(%$ '85'2)$ -%01<*4c%6$ +&%$ .'E1-$

-18%$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 98'2)$ 4*$ ,'0484+'+4*<$ (187*+'-2$ )'(4*<$ '.1*<$

;-1'6$)%0+41*)$1,$)104%+2=$K&7)$d40&'-6$(1*$]+-4<8$.'/%)$%G98404+$

-%,%-%*0%$ +1$ +&%$ @84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ ;7)4*%))3$ 5&40&$ 4)$ 1,$ )70&$

%G+-'1-64*'-2$ 4.91-+'*0%$ 4*$0'94+'8$ ,1-.'+41*=A`=a>b*$&4)$08'))40$

'-+408%$ 1*$ )'(4*<3$ F=S=$ D'2%/$ -%,%-)$ +1$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ '*6$ +&%$

97-0&')%$ 1,$ '$ &1.%$ ')$ +51$ 1,$ +&%$ .1)+$ 4.91-+'*+$ )17-0%)$ 1,$

(187*+'-2$)'(4*<`#$

$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!!"$

K&%$ (4-+7%)$ 1,$ 4*)7-'*0%$ <1$ ;%21*6$ +&%$ %*017-'<%.%*+$ 1,$

+&-4,+$ '*6$0'94+'8$ '007.78'+41*=$N2$ 4+)$(%-2$*'+7-%3$ 4*)7-'*0%$1,$'88$

/4*6)$9-1(46%)$.'-/%+$ 4*0%*+4(%)$ ,1-$ 4*64(467'8)$+1$%*<'<%$ 4*$)',%-$

;%&'(41-=$ F1-$ %G'.98%3$ 9-19%-+2$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01*+-'0+)$ .4<&+$ 1,,%-$

815%-$ 9-%.47.)$ ,1-$ &1.%15*%-)$ 5&1$ 4*)+'88$ ).1/%$ '8'-.)3$ ,4-%$

%G+4*<74)&%-)3$ 6%'6;18+)3$ 1-$ '*$ '8'-.$ )2)+%.=$ ?'-$ 4*)7-'*0%$

9-%.47.)$0'*$;%$.70&$&4<&%-$,1-$6-4(%-)$5&1$&'(%$;%%*$4*$.78+498%$

0'-$ '0046%*+)$ Q%)9%04'882$ '+$ ,'78+R$ '*6$ %)9%04'882$ 4,$ +&%2$ &'(%$ ;%%*$

01*(40+%6$ 1,$ ef>)=$ W%-&'9)$ +&%$ .1)+$ 1;(417)$ %G'.98%$ 1,$ +&%$

@,%%6;'0/A$,-1.$.'-/%+$9-40%)$1*$84,%)+28%$0&140%)$1007-)$4*$+&%$0')%$

1,$ 84,%$ 4*)7-'*0%$918404%)3$ 4*$5&40&$+&%$9%*'8+2$ ,1-$).1/4*<$ 4)$H74+%$

)+'-/$'*6$1;E%0+4(%=$ >*6%%63$ ^%,,$K70/%-$ Q%64+1-4'8$ (40%$9-%)46%*+$1,$

+&%$ g7654<$ (1*$ h4)%)$ >*)+4+7+%R$ 1*0%$ %G98'4*%6$ +&'+$ '88$ +&%$

&'*65-4*<4*<$ W7;840$ ]%-(40%$ S**17*0%.%*+)$ '*6$ +7+U+7++4*<$ ,-1.$

+&%$ T'**2$ ]+'+%$ 01786*:+$ <%+$ &4.$ +1$ <4(%$ 79$ &4)$ ;%81(%6$ 0&%54*<$

+1;'001=$N7+$')$'$.'--4%6$.'*$'99824*<$,1-$84,%$4*)7-'*0%3$^%,,$,4*'882$

H74+$4*$1-6%-$+1$H7'84,2$,1-$815%-$9-%.47.)=$

>*$ ,'0+3$ )1.%$ S7)+-4'*)$ <1$ )1$ ,'-$ ')$ +1$ %*(4)41*$ 4*)7-'*0%$

01.9'*4%)$,4884*<$+&%$(146$,1-$0-704'8$97;840$)%-(40%)$4*$+&%$%(%*+$1,$'$

8'-<%$-188;'0/$1,$ +&%$)019%$1,$<1(%-*.%*+=$F1-$%G'.98%3$1*%$1,$ +&%$

'7+&1-)$ 1,$ +&%$ 9-%)%*+$ ;11/$ &')$ 1,,%-%6$ '$ 9-191)'8$ +1$ 4.9-1(%$

'4-84*%$)',%+2$;2$)&7++4*<$615*$+&%$FSS$Q5&40&$9%-(%-)%82$<%+)$#(,."

+3%/)%5$ 5&%*%(%-$ '$ 98'*%$ 0-')&%)iR$ '*6$ '88154*<$ 4*)7-'*0%$

01.9'*4%)$ +1$ 9%-,1-.$ +&4)$ 4.91-+'*+$ ,7*0+41*=$ >,$ '$ )+'*6'-6$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!!!$

01.91*%*+$1,$'4-84*%$+40/%+)$5%-%$'*$4*)7-'*0%$918402$9'2';8%$4*$+&%$

%(%*+$1,$ '$98'*%$ 0-')&3$ +&%$ 4*)7-%-$ Q54+&$.48841*)$1,$6188'-)$1*$ +&%$

84*%R$ 51786$ &'(%$ +&%$ 01--%0+$ 4*0%*+4(%)$ +1$ 4*)9%0+$ +&%$ 98'*%)3$

-'*61.82$+%)+$9481+)$,1-$6-7<$7)%3$'*6$)1$1*=C$

S$ ,%5$ S7)+-4'*$ %01*1.4)+)$ &'(%$ 97)&%6$ +&4)$ 9-4('+4c'+41*$

81<40$+1$+&%$%G+-%.%3$ 4*$'*$'++%.9+$+1$)18(%$+&%$(%G4*<$9-1;8%.)$1,$

'*$ 7*'0017*+';8%$ 91840%$ .1*19182$ '*6$ 4**%-U04+2$ 0-4.%=$ h7--'2$

d1+&;'-6$%G98'4*)V$

$aSb)$ <1(%-*.%*+$ 91840%$ &'(%$ ;%01.%$ 4*0-%')4*<82$

4*%,,404%*+3$ 01*)7.%-)$ &'(%$ ;%%*$ +7-*4*<$ .1-%$ '*6$ .1-%$ +1$

9-4('+%$ ,1-.)$ 1,$ 9-1+%0+41*`=K&%-%$ '-%`9-4('+%$ <7'-6)3$

4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*4%)3$ 9-4('+%$ 6%+%0+4(%)3$ '*6$ )70&$ 4*0-%')4*<82$

)19&4)+40'+%6$ %H749.%*+$ ')$ )',%)3$ 810/)3$ '*6$ 081)%6U04-074+$ Kj$

'*6$;7-<8'-$'8'-.)`=$

J(%-2$ -%'6%-$ 1,$ 6%+%0+4(%$ ,40+41*$ /*15)$ +&'+$ 9-4('+%$

4*)7-'*0%$ 6%+%0+4(%)$ '-%$ ,'-$ .1-%$ %,,404%*+$ +&'*$ +&%$ 91840%$ 4*$

-%01(%-4*<$ )+18%*$ 9-19%-+2=$ T1+$ 1*82$ 4)$ +&%$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*2$

4.9%88%6$;2$%01*1.40)$ +1$)%-(%$ +&%$01*)7.%-k'*6$+&%-%;2$+-2$

+1$ '(146$ 9'24*<$ ;%*%,4+)k;7+$ +&%$ .'E1-$ ,107)$ 1,$ +&%$ 4*)7-'*0%$

01.9'*2$ 4)$ (%-2$ 64,,%-%*+$ ,-1.$ +&'+$ 1,$ +&%$ 91840%=$ K&%$ 91840%3$

)+'*64*<$ ')$ +&%2$ 61$ ,1-$ '$ .2+&40'8$ @)104%+23A$ '-%$ 9-4.'-482$

4*+%-%)+%6$ 4*$ 0'+0&4*<$'*6$97*4)&4*<$ +&%$ 0-4.4*'8l$ -%)+1-4*<$ +&%$

)+18%*$ 811+$ +1$ +&%$ (40+4.$ 4)$ )+-40+82$ )%01*6'-2=$ K1$ +&%$ 4*)7-'*0%$

01.9'*2$'*6$4+)$6%+%0+4(%)3$1*$+&%$1+&%-$&'*63$+&%$9-4.%$01*0%-*$

4)$-%01(%-2$1,$+&%$811+3$'*6$'99-%&%*)41*$'*6$97*4)&.%*+$1,$+&%$

0-4.4*'8$4)$)%01*6'-2$+1$+&%$9-4.%$97-91)%$1,$'464*<$+&%$(40+4.$1,$

!"#$%&"'()??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!!#$

0-4.%=$D%-%$5%$ )%%$ '<'4*$ +&%$64,,%-%*0%$;%+5%%*$'$9-4('+%$ ,4-.$

4.9%88%6$ +1$ )%-(%$ +&%$ 07)+1.%-U(40+4.$ 1,$ 0-4.%$ '*6$ +&%$ 97;840$

91840%3$5&40&$4)$7*6%-$*1$)70&$%01*1.40$01.978)41*=P$$

F1-$.'*2$-%')1*)3$S7)+-4'*$%01*1.4)+)$&'(%$&4)+1-40'882$&'6$

'*$ ',,4*4+2$ ,1-$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 01.9'*4%)=$ K&4)$ 4)$ *1+$ )7-9-4)4*<3$ )4*0%$

4*)7-'*0%$ 4)$ '$ .'-/%+U;')%6$ 4*)+4+7+41*$ +&'+$ '8815)$ 4*64(467'8)$ +1$

%*+%-$ .7+7'882$ '6('*+'<%17)$ 01*+-'0+)3$ 4*$ 1-6%-$ +1$ .4*4.4c%$ +&%$

4.9'0+$1,$-4)/$+&'+$+&%2$51786$1+&%-54)%$&'(%$+1$;%'-=$S)$54+&$1+&%-$

%8%.%*+)$ 1,$ '$ 01.9%+4+4(%$ .'-/%+3$ +&%-%$ 4)$ '$ *'+7-'8$ ,%%6;'0/$

.%0&'*4).V$ >,$ 4*)7-%-)$61$*1+$9'2$17+$ 8%<4+4.'+%$ 08'4.)3$1-$ 4,$ +&%2$

0&'-<%$ 9-%.47.)$ ,'-$ 4*$ %G0%))$ 1,$ +&%$ '0+7'-4'8$ '*6$ 1+&%-$

'6.4*4)+-'+4(%$%G9%*)%)3$+&%2$5488$;%$9%*'84c%6$;2$81)4*<$07)+1.%-)$

+1$-4('8$,4-.)=$

>*$ 84<&+$ 1,$ +&4)$ 81*<U)+'*64*<$ ',,4*4+23$ 4+$ )&1786$ *1+$ ;%$

)7-9-4)4*<$ +&'+$ 4*)7-'*0%$ 0'*$ 98'2$ )70&$ '*$ 4.91-+'*+$ -18%$ 4*$

4.98%.%*+4*<$+&%$]17*6$h1*%2$]187+41*3$')$5488$;%$%G98'4*%6$ ,7882$

4*$W'-+$>>>=$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Ludwig von Mises, “Planning for Freedom,” p. 92. 2 Jesús Huerta de Soto, Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2009), p. 586. 3 Huerta de Soto, footnote 104, pp. 586-587. 4 See for example Robert P. Murphy, “The Source of Air-Travel Insecurity,” November 26, 2001, at: http://mises.org/daily/836. Accessed June 1, 2010. 5 Murray Rothbard, For a New Liberty (San Francisco: Fox & Wilkes, 1994), pp. 217-218.

!"#$%&"'()!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!!"#

#

!!"#

!"#$%&'()*(

+,-&'./&.%(012%,'%1,.2(

#

#

!"#$#%&$#' (&)"*(+' *,' -&$#' *-.&$)/()'

)&0/1' )"/(' )&' #(2*+")#('.342*5'&.*(*&('

/4&3)' )"#' 4/,*5' 0*%%#$#(5#,' 4#)6##('

+#(3*(#' 7*4#$/2*,-8' 6"*5"' /09&5/)#,'

)"#' %$##' -/$:#)' #5&(&-18' /(0' )"#'

9/$*&3,' *()#$9#()*&(*,)' ./$)*#,' 6"*5"'

/$#' /09&5/)*(+' +&9#$(-#()'

*()#$%#$#(5#;'

<7306*+'9&('=*,#,>'

#$%#&'%(%)*+,#($-&.%'/#*+#.$*/#/%(.*0+#$-1%#)%/('*2%)#.$%#

2-/*(# 34+(.*0+*+,# 03# -#5-'6%.# %(0+0578#9%# $-1%# /%%+#

$0:#3'%%#*+)*1*)4-;/<#-(.*+,#0+;7#.0#*5&'01%#.$%*'#0:+#;*1%/#-+)#.$-.#

03#.$%*'#*55%)*-.%#3-5*;*%/#-+)#3'*%+)/<#+0+%.$%;%//#-'%#;%)#=-/#*3#27#

-+# >+1*/*2;%#?-+)@# .0#)%1%;0&# *+/.*.4.*0+/#/4($#-/#50+%7<#2-+6*+,<#

-+)#*+/4'-+(%#.$-.#5-6%#50)%'+#(*1*;*A-.*0+#&0//*2;%8#

B+30'.4+-.%;7<# -;0+,# .$%# :-7# .$%# '%-)%'# 4+)042.%);7#

'%(0,+*A%)# .$-.# /05%.$*+,# :-/+C.# D4*.%# '*,$.8# E;.$04,$# .$%#

)%/('*&.*0+#03#-#5-'6%.#%(0+057#*/#3-5*;*-'<#*.#)0%/+C.#(-&.4'%#:$-.#

$#/221#$-&&%+/#*+#04'#:0';)8#>+#&-'.*(4;-'<#2-+6*+,#)0%/#+0.#0&%'-.%#

-;0+,#.$%#;*+%/#/6%.($%)#04.#*+#F$-&.%'#GH8#

I#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!!J#

I$%#E4/.'*-+/#%K&;-*+# .$*/#)*/('%&-+(7#27#&0*+.*+,# .0# ;-',%L

/(-;%# +&9#$(-#()' *()#$9#()*&(8# >+# %1%'7# +-.*0+# .0)-7<# %1%+# .$%#

0/.%+/*2;7#=(-&*.-;*/.@#B+*.%)#M.-.%/<#.$%#,01%'+5%+.#/7/.%5-.*(-;;7#

'%,4;-.%/<#.-K%/<#/&%+)/<#-+)#0.$%':*/%#)*/.0'./#.$%#0&%'-.*0+#03#.$%#

5-'6%.#%(0+0578#

I$%#E4/.'*-+#('*.*D4%#03#,01%'+5%+.#*+.%'1%+.*0+#&0*+./#04.#

-# .'-,*(# *'0+7N# >+# (-/%# -3.%'# (-/%<# .$%# -;;%,%)# &4'&0/%# 03# -# +%:#

,01%'+5%+.#'%,4;-.*0+#0'#&'0,'-5#*/#.0#3*K#-#=5-'6%.#3-*;4'%@#.$-.#*/#

-(.4-;;7#(-4/%)#27#-#.$*&$',01%'+5%+.#*+.%'1%+.*0+O#>+#0.$%'#:0')/<#

.$%#/0(*-;#*;;/#.$-.#-'%#.7&*(-;;7#2;-5%)#0+#=4+'%/.'-*+%)#(-&*.-;*/5@#

-'%# *+# 3-(.# .$%#&'0)4(.# 03# ,01%'+5%+.# %330'./# .0#$*+)%'# (-&*.-;*/58#

P0'#%K-5&;%<# .$%#1%K*+,#&'02;%5#03#$*,$#4+%5&;075%+.# *+# (%'.-*+#

)%50,'-&$*(/# */# (-4/%)# 27# 5*+*545# :-,%# ;-:/<# (&)' 27# ('4%;#

%5&;07%'/#&%'#/%8#

I$%'%# -'%# 5-+7# E4/.'*-+# 2006/# -+)# -'.*(;%/# )%-;*+,# :*.$#

.$%/%# *//4%/8!# P0'# 04'# &4'&0/%/<# :%# :*;;# 30(4/# 0+# Q4/.# 0+%N# ?0:#

,01%'+5%+.# *+.%'3%'%+(%# :*.$# .$%# *+/.*.4.*0+/# 03# 50+%7# -+)#

2-+6*+,#)*;4.%/#.$%#(4''%+(7#-+)#/&-:+/#.$%#2005L24/.#(7(;%8###

3#'4&%56#2&7(!,//,71%8(3,.&8(9&'2:2(+,-&'./&.%(

;1#%(3,.&8#

#

I$%# 50/.# 021*04/# )*/('%&-+(7# 2%.:%%+# 04'# (4''%+.# :0';)<#

-+)#.$%#5-'6%.#%(0+057#/6%.($%)#*+#%-';*%'#($-&.%'/<#*/#.$-.#&%0&;%#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!!R#

+0:-)-7/# )0# +0.# 4/%# ,0;)# 0'# /*;1%'# -/# 50+%78# >+/.%-)<# .$%7# 4/%#

&*%(%/# 03# &-&%'# *//4%)# 27# ,01%'+5%+./8# 9$%+# .$%# 50+%.-'7# 4+*.#

:-/#*./%;3#-+#-(.4-;#(0550)*.7<#*./#&4'($-/*+,#&0:%'#$%;)#*./#1-;4%#

01%'#.*5%S#-#,0;)#04+(%#*+#GTGU#,%+%'-;;7#204,$.#.$%#/-5%#-504+.#

03# ,00)/# -/# -# ,0;)# 04+(%# *+# GVGU8# >+# (0+.'-/.<# :*.$# ,01%'+5%+.#

&-&%'<# .$%# &4'($-/*+,# &0:%'# 03# 50+%7# (0+/.-+.;7# 3-;;/W30'#

%K-5&;%<#.$%#B8M8#)0;;-'#$-/#;0/.#-204.#V"#&%'(%+.#03# *./#1-;4%#/*+(%#

.$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%# :-/# %/.-2;*/$%)# *+# ;-.%# GVGY8# M0# &%'1-/*1%# */#

,01%'+5%+.#*+3;-.*0+<#.$-.#&%0&;%#*+#04'#-,%#.-6%#*.#30'#,'-+.%)#.$-.#

&'*(%/#*+%K0'-2;7#'*/%#7%-'#-3.%'#7%-'<#-/#*3#.$*/#:%'%#-#3-(.#03#+-.4'%8#

>+# .$%# :0'/.# (-/%/<# /4($# -/# 9%*5-'# Z%'5-+7# 0'# 50)%'+L)-7#

[*52-2:%<#,01%'+5%+.#&'*+.*+,#&'%//%/#$-1%#(-4/%)#$7&%'*+3;-.*0+#

-+)#;*.%'-;;7#)%/.'07%)#.$%#(4''%+(78#

?0:# )*)# .$*/# .'-+/30'5-.*0+# 0((4'\# 9$7# :04;)# &%0&;%#

-2-+)0+#.$%#(0550)*.7#50+%7#.$-.#%5%',%)#/&0+.-+%04/;7#04.#03#

.$%*'# 5-'6%.# .'-+/-(.*0+/<# *+# 3-10'# 03# &-&%'# 50+%7# *//4%)# 27#

,01%'+5%+./#:*.$#-;;#.$%*'#-..%+)-+.#)-+,%'/\#

I$%# &'0(%//# :-/# +0.# 10;4+.-'78# E/# ]*/%/# /.-.%/# :*.$#

($-'-(.%'*/.*(#3'-+6+%//N#

#I$%#,0;)#/.-+)-')#)*)#+0.#(0;;-&/%8#Z01%'+5%+./#-20;*/$%)#*.# *+#

0')%'#.0#&-1%#.$%#:-7#30'#*+3;-.*0+8#I$%#:$0;%#,'*5#-&&-'-.4/#03#

0&&'%//*0+# -+)# (0%'(*0+<# &0;*(%5%+<# (4/.05/# ,4-')/<# &%+-;#

(04'./<# &'*/0+/<# *+# /05%# (04+.'*%/# %1%+# %K%(4.*0+%'/<# $-)# .0# 2%#

&4.#*+.0#-(.*0+#*+#0')%'#.0#)%/.'07#.$%#,0;)#/.-+)-')8Y#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!!T#

##

I$%# ,%+%'-;# &-..%'+# :-/# .$-.# ,01%'+5%+./# :04;)#

*+('%5%+.-;;7#'%,4;-.%#.$%#*//4-+(%#03#2-+6+0.%/<#4+.*;#.$%#&0*+.#-.#

:$*($#0+;7#0+%#+0.%#(*'(4;-.%)#*+#.$%#(04+.'7#:$*($#:-/#.$%#033*(*-;#

'%)%5&.*0+# (;-*5# 0+# .$%# ,%+4*+%# (0550)*.7#50+%7# ^,0;)# -+)_0'#

/*;1%'`8#I$%+<#0+(%#.$%#&42;*(#$-)#2%(05%#$-2*.4-.%)#.0#247*+,#-+)#

/%;;*+,# 4/*+,# .$%# ,01%'+5%+.L)%/*,+-.%)# &-&%'# +0.%/<# .$%*'#

'%)%%5-2*;*.7#:04;)# 2%# /4/&%+)%)8# E.# 3*'/.<# .$%# /4/&%+/*0+#:04;)#

0+;7# 2%# .%5&0'-'7<# )4'*+,#:-'/# 0'# 0.$%'# ('*/%/8# a4.# /*+(%#X*($-')#

b*K0+# 30'5-;;7# (;0/%)# .$%# ,0;)# :*+)0:# *+# GVRG<# -;;# 03# .$%# 5-Q0'#

(4''%+(*%/#03#.$%#:0';)#$-1%#2%%+#&4'%#%*/)'53$$#(5*#,<#5%-+*+,#.$-.#

.$%7#-'%#2-(6%)#4&#27#-2/0;4.%;7#+0.$*+,8#

c+(%#.$%#,01%'+5%+./#03#.$%#:0';)#:%'%#3'%%#03#.$%#3%..%'/#03#

.$%#,0;)#/.-+)-')<#.$%7#&'*+.%)#+%:#50+%7#:*.$#'%(6;%//#-2-+)0+8#

d006# -.# .$%# ($-'.# 03# .$%# F0+/45%'# e'*(%# >+)%K<# +0.*+,# .$%#

-((%;%'-.*0+#*+#&'*(%#*+3;-.*0+#-3.%'#.$%#)0;;-'C/#.*%#.0#,0;)#:-/#34;;7#

/%1%'%)#*+#GVRGN#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!!V#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

##

#

E;.$04,$# .$%#&%'30'5-+(%#03# .$%#B8M8# (%+.'-;#2-+6#$-/#2%%+#

-27/5-;#(05&-'%)#.0#-#,%+4*+%#5-'6%.L2-/%)#50+%.-'7#/7/.%5<#.$%#

E5%'*(-+# %K&%'*%+(%# $-/# -(.4-;;7# 2%%+# -# '%;-.*1%# /4((%//# /.0'7<#

(05&-'%)# .0# /05%# 0.$%'# (%+.'-;# 2-+6/8# I$%# )042;%L)*,*.# &'*(%#

*+3;-.*0+# 03# .$%# ;-.%# GVRU/# :-/# (%'.-*+;7# &-*+34;# ^-+)# (05&;%.%;7#

4++%(%//-'7`<# 24.# .$*+,/# (04;)# 2%# :0'/%N# E((0')*+,# .0# .$%# F-.0#

>+/.*.4.%C/# M%+*0'# P%;;0:# M.%1%# ?-+6%C/# (-;(4;-.*0+/<# *+# b01%52%'#

!UUT# [*52-2:%# -($*%1%)# -# -&()"21' *+3;-.*0+# '-.%# 03# RV8J# 4*22*&(#

&%'(%+.8# >+# .$*/# *+(0+(%*1-2;%# %+1*'0+5%+.<# &'*(%/# *+# [*52-2:%#

)042;%)# %1%'7# !"# $04'/OH# 9$-.%1%'# /$0'.(05*+,/# 5-7# &;-,4%# -#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YU#

5-'6%.L2-/%)#(0550)*.7#50+%7<#.$%7#-'%#+0.$*+,#(05&-'%)#.0#.$%#

)-+,%'/#03#,01%'+5%+.#&-&%'#50+%78##

;'#<%1,.#=(>&2&'-&(6#.41.?##

f-';*%'#:%#)*/(4//%)#2-+6*+,#*+#.$%#(0+.%K.#03#GUUg#'%/%'1%#

($%(6*+,# -((04+./8# >+# .$*/# -''-+,%5%+.<# -+# *+)*1*)4-;# 4/%/# -# 2-+6#

/*5&;7#.0#($-+,%#.$%#%&$-#03#$*/#50+%78#X-.$%'#.$-+#;4,,*+,#-'04+)#

$4+)'%)/#03#&04+)/#03#,0;)<#30'#%K-5&;%<#.$%#*+)*1*)4-;#:04;)#&;-(%#

*.# 0+# )%&0/*.#:*.$# -# '%&4.-2;%# 0',-+*A-.*0+#:$0#$-)# -# /.'0+,# /-3%#

-+)# (04;)# *//4%# %*.$%'# 2-+6+0.%/# 0'# -# ($%(62006# .0# -;;0:# .$%#

*+)*1*)4-;#.0#/&%+)#$*/#50+%7#*+#.$%#(0554+*.78#

?*/.0'*(-;;7<# ,0;)/5*.$/# :%'%# -50+,# .$%# 3*'/.# 2-+6%'/8#

a%(-4/%# .$%7# $-)# ,0;)# 0+# $-+)# -+7:-7# 30'# .$%*'# 24/*+%//<# *.# :-/#

0+;7#+-.4'-;#.$-.#,0;)/5*.$/#:04;)#.'7#.0#2%+%3*.#3'05#%(0+05*%/#03#

/(-;%#27#033%'*+,#.0#:-'%$04/%#.$%#,0;)#$%;)#27#0.$%'/#*+#.$%#-'%-8#

c1%'# .*5%<# .$%# ,0;)/5*.$/# +0.*(%)# /05%.$*+,# 1%'7#

*+.%'%/.*+,N#c+#-+7#,*1%+#)-7<#50/.#03#.$%*'#(4/.05%'/C#,0;)#)%&0/*./#

/-.#*);7#*+#.$%#1-4;.8#E;.$04,$#.$%#(4/.05%'/#$-)#.$%#;%,-;#-2*;*.7#.0#

(;-*5#.$%*'#)%&0/*./#-.#-+7#.*5%#-+)#'%.'*%1%#.$%*'#,0;)<# *+#&'-(.*(%#

50/.#03#.$%5#)*)#+0.#)0#/08#9$%+#/05%0+%#4/%)#-#2-+6+0.%#^*//4%)#

27#-#,0;)/5*.$`#.0#247#/05%.$*+,#3'05#-#;0(-;#5%'($-+.<#1%'7#03.%+#

.$%#5%'($-+.#:04;)#/*5&;7#$-+,#0+#.0#.$%#+0.%#-+)#/&%+)#*.#$*5/%;3<#

'-.$%'# .$-+# .4'+*+,# *.# *+# 30'# '%)%5&.*0+8# c+(%# 5%'($-+./# *+# .$%#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YG#

(0554+*.7# ;%-'+%)# .$-.#-#&-'.*(4;-'#,0;)/5*.$#(04;)#2%# .'4/.%)# .0#

'%)%%5#$*/#+0.%/<#.$%'%#:-/#;*..;%#'%-/0+#.0#.'-1%;#.0#.$%#,0;)/5*.$C/#

&;-(%#03#24/*+%//# -+)# '%501%# .$%# (;4+67#$4+6/#03# 7%;;0:#5%.-;8# >.#

:-/# 3-'# 50'%# (0+1%+*%+.# .0# /*5&;7# $0;)# .$%# 2-+6+0.%/# -/# .$%7#

.'*(6;%)#*+#3'05#(4/.05%'/<#.0#2%#/&%+.#27#.$%#5%'($-+.#;-.%'#0+8#

>+# .$*/# %+1*'0+5%+.<# *.# */# +0.# $-')# .0# ,4%//# :$-.# .$%# :*;7#

,0;)/5*.$/#)*)8#I$%7#2%,-+#,'-+.*+,#;0-+/#03#2-+6+0.%/#*('#@5#,,#03#

.$%#,0;)#/.0'%)#*+#.$%*'#1-4;./8#P0'#%K-5&;%<#*3#-#&-'.*(4;-'#,0;)/5*.$#

$-)# G<UUU# 04+(%/# 03# $*/# (4/.05%'/C# )%&0/*./# /.0'%)# *+# .$%# 1-4;.W

-+)# $-)# -;'%-)7# *//4%)# G<UUU# 2-+6+0.%/# :$*($# *+# %//%+(%# :%'%#

(;-*5#.*(6%./#0+#%-($#04+(%W.$%#,0;)/5*.$#5*,$.#*+#-))*.*0+#$-+)#

04.#GUU#-))*.*0+-;#2-+6+0.%/<#:$*($#:%'%#*)%+.*(-;#.0#.$%#+0.%/#$%#

$-)# ,*1%+# .0# .$%# 0'*,*+-;# (4/.05%'/# :$%+# .$%7# )%&0/*.%)# .$%*'#

&$7/*(-;# ,0;)8# I$%# '%-/0+# .$*/# 2%+%3*.%)# .$%# ,0;)/5*.$# */# .$-.# $%#

5*,$.#/*,+#-#(0+.'-(.# *+#:$*($# .$%#20''0:%'#-,'%%)# .$-.#$%#:04;)#

&-7# 2-(6# GGU# 2-+6+0.%/# *+# 0+%# 7%-'C/# .*5%8# I$4/<# -/# ;0+,# -/# .$%#

20''0:%'# )*)+C.# )%3-4;.# 0+# .$%# ;0-+<# .$%# ,0;)/5*.$# :04;)# $-1%#

%-'+%)#GU#,0;)#04+(%/C#:0'.$#03# *+.%'%/.#*+(05%#)4'*+,#.$%#(04'/%#

03# .$%# 7%-'<# :*.$04.# $-1*+,# &4.# 4&# -+7# 03# $*/# 0:+# 50+%7# *+# .$%#

&'0(%//8#

]-+7#:'*.%'/#$-1%#)%/('*2%)#3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#2-+6*+,#-/#-#

30'5#03# (04+.%'3%*.*+,<# 2%(-4/%# .$%# 2-+6%'# *+# -# /%+/%# ('%-.%/# +%:#

50+%7#04.#03#.$*+#-*'8#>+#04'#%K-5&;%#-201%<#.$%#(0554+*.7#:04;)#

$-1%#G<UUU#2-+6+0.%/#(*'(4;-.*+,#:$*($#:%'%#5%'%;7#(;-*5/#-,-*+/.#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!Y!#

.$%#G<UUU#,0;)#04+(%/#/*..*+,#*+#.$%#,0;)/5*.$C/#1-4;.<#24.#0+#.0&#03#

.$-.# .$%'%# :04;)# 2%# -+# /00*)*&(/2' GUU# +0.%/# (*'(4;-.*+,# -3.%'# .$%#

+%:#;0-+#$-)#2%%+#,'-+.%)8#I$%#5%'($-+./#*+#.$%#(0554+*.7#:04;)#

+0.# 2%# -2;%# .0# )*/.*+,4*/$# .$%# 0+%# +0.%# 3'05# .$%# 0.$%'<# -+)# .$4/#

&'*(%/#^D40.%)#*+#,0;)#04+(%/`#*+#.$%#(0554+*.7#:04;)#'*/%<#Q4/.#-/#

*3#5*+%'/#$-)#)*/(01%'%)#-+0.$%'#GUU#04+(%/#03#&$7/*(-;#,0;)8#>+#.$%#

,'-+)#/($%5%<#.$%#,0;)/5*.$C/#&'-(.*(%#03#3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#2-+6*+,#

:04;)#/$*3.#&4'($-/*+,#&0:%'#3'05#%1%'70+%#%;/%#*+#.$%#(0554+*.7#

^/.4(6# :*.$# .$%*'# 0'*,*+-;# -504+./# 03# &$7/*(-;# ,0;)# -+)_0'#

2-+6+0.%/`# *+.0# $*/# 0:+# $-+)/<# -/# $*/# 0:+# *+(05%# *+('%-/%)# *+#

&'0&0'.*0+#.0#.$%#'*/%#*+#&'*(%/#.$-.#$*/#%K(%//*1%#+0.%#*//4%#(-4/%)8#

>.# */# -2/0;4.%;7# %//%+.*-;# 30'# .$%# '%-)%'# .0# 4+)%'/.-+)# .$%#

=5-,*(@# 03# 3'-(.*0+-;# '%/%'1%# 2-+6*+,<# -+)# /0# :%# :*;;# ;%-1%# 04'#

$*/.0'*(-;# +-''-.*1%# *+10;1*+,# ,0;)# 04+(%/# -+)# 2-+6+0.%/<# -+)#

*;;4/.'-.%#.$%#&'0(%//#*+#-#50)%'+#(0+.%K.#:*.$#B8M8#)0;;-'/8#M4&&0/%#

-#.%%+-,%'<#a*;;<#*/#'455-,*+,#*+#.$%#-..*(#-+)#3*+)/#hG<UUU#*+#-+#0;)#

($%/.8# a*;;# */# %(/.-.*(# -+)# '4+/# .0# $*/# 2-+6<# :$%'%# $%# 0&%+/# -#

($%(6*+,#-((04+.#-+)#)%&0/*./#.$%#,'%%+#&*%(%/#03#&-&%'8#

B+)%'#-#GUUg#'%/%'1%#/7/.%5<# .$*/#:04;)#2%# .$%#%+)#03# .$%#

/.0'78# a*;;C/# (4''%+(7# $0;)*+,/# :04;)# 3-;;# 27# hG<UUU<# :$*;%# $*/#

($%(62006#2-;-+(%#:04;)#'*/%#27#hG<UUU8#I$%#-(.#03#)%&0/*.*+,# .$%#

50+%7#*+#.$%#2-+6#:04;)+C.#-33%(.#.$%#.0.-;#-504+.#03#50+%7#*+#.$%#

%(0+0578#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YY#

?0:%1%'<#*+#04'#(4''%+.#/7/.%5<#a*;;C/#2-+6#:04;)#/%%#-#+%:#

&'03*.#0&&0'.4+*.78#E3.%'#.$%#2-+6#&4.#.$%#hG<UUU#*+#(4''%+(7#*+.0#*./#

1-4;.<#*./#'%/%'1%/#:04;)#2%#.$-.#54($#$*,$%'<#:$*;%#*./#04./.-+)*+,#

)%&0/*.#;*-2*;*.*%/#:04;)#$-1%#'*/%+#27#hG<UUU#-/#:%;;#^*+#.$%#30'5#03#

a*;;C/# +%:# ($%(6*+,# -((04+.`8# a4.# /*+(%# 2-+6/# *+# .$%# B+*.%)# M.-.%/#

-'%# /42Q%(.# 0+;7# .0# -# '%/%'1%# '%D4*'%5%+.# 03# ^-&&'0K*5-.%;7`# .%+#

&%'(%+.<# .$%#2-+6#:04;)#$-1%##@5#,,' $#,#$9#,# 03# hVUU8# >3# *.# 304+)#-#

/4*.-2;%#20''0:%'<# .$%#2-+6#:04;)#$-1%#.$%# ;%,-;#-2*;*.7# .0#,'-+.#-#

+%:#;0-+#30'#.$*/#-504+.8#M4&&0/%#.$%#2-+6#304+)#/4($#-#20''0:%'<#

M-;;7<# -+)# ($-',%)# $%'# "# &%'(%+.# *+.%'%/.# 30'# -# G!L50+.$# ;0-+8#

E//45*+,#/$%#&-*)#033#.$%#;0-+#*+#-#.*5%;7#5-++%'<#$%'%#*/#:$-.#.$%#

2-+6C/# 2-;-+(%# /$%%.# :04;)# ;006# ;*6%# -.# 1-'*04/# /.-,%/# *+# .$%#

&'0(%//N#

#

( @A(6#.4B2(6#=#.<&(C"&&%(DE%&'(61==8B2(0&$,21%#

E//%./# d*-2*;*.*%/#i#M$-'%$0;)%'C/#

fD4*.7#

hG<UUU#*+#1-4;.#(-/$# hG<UUU#â*;;7C/#($%(6*+,#

-((04+.#2-;-+(%##

#

#

#

#

#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YH#

@@A(6#.4B2(6#=#.<&(C"&&%(DE%&'(F,#.(+'#.%&7(%,(C#==8(

E//%./# d*-2*;*.*%/#i#M$-'%$0;)%'C/#fD4*.7#

hG<UUU#*+#1-4;.#(-/$#

hVUU#;0-+#.0#M-;;7#-.#"g#30'#

G!#50+.$/#

hG<UUU# â*;;7C/# ($%(6*+,# -((04+.#

2-;-+(%`#

hVUU# ^M-;;7C/# +%:# ($%(6*+,#

-((04+.`#

#

@@@A(6#.4B2(6#=#.<&(C"&&%(DE%&'(C#==8(C$&.72(G&'(F,#.(,.(

6:21.&22(C:$$=1&2(

E//%./# d*-2*;*.*%/#i#M$-'%$0;)%'C/#fD4*.7#

hGUU#*+#1-4;.#(-/$#

hVUU#;0-+#.0#M-;;7#-.#"g#30'#

G!#50+.$/#

hG<UUU# â*;;7C/# ($%(6*+,# -((04+.#

2-;-+(%`#

hU# ^M-;;7C/# ($%(6*+,# -((04+.#

2-;-+(%`#

#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!Y"#

#

@9A(6#.4B2(6#=#.<&(C"&&%(DE%&'(C#==8(C&==2(G&'(H',7:<%2(E,'(

I)JKKK(!#2"(

#.7(0&$,21%2(%"&(H',<&&72(1.(G&'(D<<,:.%(

E//%./# d*-2*;*.*%/#i#M$-'%$0;)%'C/#

fD4*.7#

hG<GUU#*+#1-4;.#(-/$#

hVUU# ;0-+# .0# M-;;7# -.# "g# 30'#

G!#50+.$/#

hG<UUU# â*;;7C/# ($%(6*+,#

-((04+.#2-;-+(%`#

hG<UUU# ^M-;;7C/# ($%(6*+,#

-((04+.#2-;-+(%`#

#

#

9A(6#.4B2(6#=#.<&(C"&&%(DE%&'(C#==8(H#82(LEE(G&'(F,#.(H=:2(

@.%&'&2%(

E//%./# d*-2*;*.*%/#i#M$-'%$0;)%'C/#

fD4*.7#

hG<GUU#*+#1-4;.#(-/$#

#

hG<UUU# â*;;7C/# ($%(6*+,#

-((04+.#2-;-+(%`#

h""#^M-;;7C/#($%(6*+,#-((04+.#

2-;-+(%`#

hH"# *+# 2-+6# /$-'%$0;)%'#

%D4*.7#

#

#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YJ#

M,%&( E,'( $:'12%2N# >+# .$%# .-2;%/# -201%<# .%($+*(-;;7#:*.$# .$%# &-//-,%# 03# .*5%<# .$%#

5-'6%.#1-;4%#03#.$%#;0-+#.0#M-;;7#:04;)#*+('%-/%#3'05#*./#*+*.*-;#hVUU8#E/#.$%#;0-+#

5-.4'%)<# *./# -&&'%(*-.*0+# :04;)# 2%# 5-.($%)# 27# -+# %D4-;# ,'0:.$# *+# .$%#

/$-'%$0;)%'C/# %D4*.7#0+# .$%# '*,$.# /*)%#03# .$%#2-;-+(%# /$%%.8# ^>+#0.$%'#:0')/<# .$%#

/$-'%$0;)%'#%D4*.7#:04;)#,'-)4-;;7#*+('%-/%#.0#hH"#01%'#.$%#(04'/%#03#.$%#7%-'S#*.#

:04;)+C.#/4))%+;7#Q45&#3'05#hU#.0#hH"#:$%+#M-;;7#&-*)#033#.$%#;0-+8`#a4.#:%#$-1%#

+%,;%(.%)#.$*/#(05&;*(-.*0+#.0#6%%&#.$%#-201%#%K-5&;%#-/#/*5&;%#-/#&0//*2;%8#

#

E/#04'#$7&0.$%.*(-;#%K-5&;%#5-6%/#(;%-'<#:*.$#.$%#&0:%'#03#

3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#2-+6*+,<#2-+6%'/#(-+#-&&-'%+.;7#%-'+#*+(05%#04.#

03#+0.$*+,O#M0#;0+,#-/#a*;;7#;%-1%/#$*/#50+%7#*+#.$%#2-+6<#-+)#/0#;0+,#

-/#M-;;7#*/#-2;%#.0#%-'+#%+04,$#'%1%+4%/#3'05#$%'#24/*+%//#.0#-10*)#

)%3-4;.*+,#0+#$%'# ;0-+<#.$%#2-+6C/#/$-'%$0;)%'/#%+)#4&#:*.$#hH"#03#

.$%#(0554+*.7C/#(-/$<#3'%%#-+)#(;%-'8#

b0.*(%#.$-.#*+#0')%'#30'#.$*/#57/.%'*04/#&'0(%//#.0#4+30;)<#.$%#

2-+6#;*.%'-;;7#('%-.%)#hVUU#*+#+%:#50+%7#*+#.$%#(0554+*.7#:$%+#*.#

-)1-+(%)#.$%#;0-+#.0#M-;;7<#-+)#.$%+#/+433%)#*.#04.#03#%K*/.%+(%#:$%+#

/$%# &-*)# 033# $%'# )%2.8# >.# */# 2%(-4/%# 03# .$%/%# /.'-+,%#5-($*+-.*0+/#

.$-.#5-+7# ('*.*(/# 03# 04'# &'%/%+.# 3*+-+(*-;# 3'-5%:0'6# '%3%'# .0# *.# -/#

=)%2.L2-/%)#50+%78@#

P0'#.$%#+%:(05%'<# .$%#57/.*(-;#D4-;*.7#03# 3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#

2-+6*+,# */# -.# 3*'/.# $-')# .0# ,'-/&8# Z8# f):-')# Z'*33*+# '%;-.%/# -#

$450'04/#-+%()0.%#03#-#&0;*.*(*-+#;%-'+*+,#.$%#.'4.$N#

#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YR#

]-''*+%'# f((;%/# :-/# .$%# Z01%'+0'# 03# .$%# P%)%'-;#

X%/%'1%# M7/.%5# *+# GVHG8# c+# M%&.%52%'# YU# 03# .$-.# 7%-'<# f((;%/#

:-/# -/6%)# .0# ,*1%# .%/.*50+7# 2%30'%# .$%# ?04/%# F055*..%%# 0+#

a-+6*+,#-+)#F4''%+(78#I$%#&4'&0/%#03#.$%#$%-'*+,#:-/#.0#02.-*+#

*+30'5-.*0+#'%,-')*+,#.$%#'0;%#03#.$%#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#*+#('%-.*+,#

(0+)*.*0+/#.$-.#;%)#.0#.$%#)%&'%//*0+#03#.$%#GVYU/8#F0+,'%//5-+#

9'*,$.#e-.5-+<#:$0#:-/#F$-*'5-+#03#.$-.#(055*..%%<#-/6%)#$0:#

.$%#P%)#,0.# .$%#50+%7# .0#&4'($-/%# .:0#2*;;*0+#)0;;-'/#:0'.$#03#

,01%'+5%+.#20+)/#*+#GVYY8#I$*/#*/#.$%#%K($-+,%#.$-.#30;;0:%)8#

#

fFFdfMN#9%#('%-.%)#*.8#

eEI]EbN#c4.#03#:$-.\#

fFFdfMN#c4.#03#.$%#'*,$.#.0#*//4%#('%)*.#50+%78#

eEI]EbN#E+)#.$%'%#*/#+0.$*+,#2%$*+)#*.<#*/#.$%'%<#%K(%&.#

04'#,01%'+5%+.C/#('%)*.\#

fFFdfMN#I$-.#*/#:$-.#04'#50+%7#/7/.%5#*/8#>3#.$%'%#:%'%#

+0#)%2./#*+#04'#50+%7#/7/.%5<#.$%'%#:04;)+C.#2%#-+7#50+%78"##

E;0+,#.$%#/-5%#;*+%/<#X02%'.#?%5&$*;;<#F'%)*.#]-+-,%'#03#.$%#

P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#a-+6#*+#E.;-+.-<#:'0.%#*+#GVYJN#

#>3#-;;#.$%#2-+6#;0-+/#:%'%#&-*)<#+0#0+%#(04;)#$-1%#-#2-+6#

)%&0/*.<# -+)# .$%'%#:04;)# +0.# 2%# -# )0;;-'# 03# (0*+# 0'# (4''%+(7# *+#

(*'(4;-.*0+8# I$*/# */# -# /.-,,%'*+,# .$04,$.8# 9%# -'%# (05&;%.%;7#

)%&%+)%+.# 0+# .$%# (055%'(*-;# 2-+6/8# M05%0+%# $-/# .0# 20''0:#

%1%'7#)0;;-'#:%#$-1%# *+# (*'(4;-.*0+<# (-/$<#0'# ('%)*.8# >3# .$%#2-+6/#

('%-.%# -5&;%# /7+.$%.*(# 50+%7# :%# -'%# &'0/&%'04/S# *3# +0.<# :%#

/.-'1%8#9%# -'%# -2/0;4.%;7# :*.$04.# -# &%'5-+%+.#50+%7# /7/.%58#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YT#

9$%+# 0+%# ,%./# -# (05&;%.%# ,'-/&# 03# .$%# &*(.4'%<# .$%# .'-,*(#

-2/4')*.7# 03# 04'# $0&%;%//# /*.4-.*0+# */# -;50/.# *+('%)*2;%W24.#

.$%'%#*.#*/8J#

#

>.#*/#)%2-.-2;%#:$%.$%'#.$*+,/#-'%#A3*)##-/#)'-5-.*(#-/#f((;%/#

-+)# ?%5&$*;;# (;-*58# M.'*(.;7# /&%-6*+,<# .$%# (055%'(*-;# 2-+6/# 0+;7#

('%-.%#=)%2.L2-/%)#50+%7@#:$%+#.$%7#&7'-5*)#+%:#;0-+/#0+#.0&#03#

%K*/.*+,#'%/%'1%/8#a4.#.$%#'%/%'1%/#.$%5/%;1%/W:$%.$%'#*+#.$%#30'5#

03# -(.4-;# (4''%+(7# 0'# ('%)*./# :*.$# .$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%W)0# +0.#

(0+/.*.4.%# -# )%2.# (;-*5# 0+# -+7# (*.*A%+# 0'# (055%'(*-;# 2-+68# >+# 04'#

%K-5&;%#-201%<# .$%#hG<UUU# *+# (4''%+(7# .$-.#a*;;7#)*/(01%'%)#:-/#-#

&4'%# -//%.<# -/# 3-'# -/# $%# :-/# (0+(%'+%)8# ^>+# (0+.'-/.<# .$%# hVUU# *+#

-))*.*0+-;#50+%7# (04;)# 0+;7# 2%# 2'04,$.# *+.0# %K*/.%+(%#:$%+# M-;;7#

*+(4''%)#-#hVUU#)%2.# .0# .$%#(055%'(*-;#2-+6<#-+)# .$-.#/-5%#hVUU#

)*/-&&%-'%)#3'05#.$%#50+%7#/4&&;7#:$%+#M-;;7#&-*)#$%'#)%2.#0338`#

j%.# %1%+# $%'%<# .$%'%# */# -# )%3*+*.%# /%+/%# *+# :$*($# 2-+6#

'%/%'1%/#.$%5/%;1%/#-'%#-#30'5#03#)%2.<#-/#0&&0/%)#.0#-#,%+4*+%#-+)#

4+3%..%'%)# -//%.# -/# ,0;)# (0*+/# :04;)# 2%# *+# -# (0550)*.7L2-/%)#

/7/.%58# I$*/# */# /0# 30'# .:0# '%-/0+/8# P*'/.<# .$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%#

.7&*(-;;7# ('%-.%/# +%:# '%/%'1%/# 27# 247*+,# +&9#$(-#()' 0#4)8# >+# -#

/%+/%<# .$%# B8M8# I'%-/4'7# */# *+# .$%# &0/*.*0+# 03# M-;;7<# -+)#:$%+# *.# */#

^*+)*'%(.;7`# ,'-+.%)# -# +%:# ;0-+# 3'05# .$%# P%)<# .$%# .0.-;# -504+.# 03#

'%/%'1%/# *+# .$%# 2-+6*+,# /7/.%5# *+('%-/%/<# .$'04,$# :$-.# .$%#

.%K.2006/#)%/('*2%#-/#-+#=0&%+#5-'6%.#0&%'-.*0+8@#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!YV#

M%(0+)<# .$%# &-&%'# (4''%+(7# *+# 704'# &4'/%# 0'# :-;;%.# */# -#

;*-2*;*.7# 03# .$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%<# ;%,-;;7# /&%-6*+,8# E3.%'# -;;<# .$%/%#

,'%%+#&*%(%/#03#&-&%'#$-1%#=P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#b0.%@#:'*..%+#0+#.$%58#

I$*/# */# -+# -((04+.*+,# 3*(.*0+<# 03# (04'/%<# -# .$'0:2-(6# .0# .$%# )-7/#

:$%+# .$%# +0.%/# :%'%# /*5&;7# (;-*5/# .0# -(.4-;# ,0;)# 0'# /*;1%'8# >.C/#

$-');7# -# ;*-2*;*.7# .0# $-1%# 2*;;*0+/# 03# )0;;-'/# *+# =(;-*5/@# -,-*+/.# .$%#

P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#3;0-.*+,#-'04+)<#:$%+#.$%7#-'%#(;-*5/#.0#+0.$*+,8#^>3#

704#.'*%)#.0#&'%/%+.#-#h!U#2*;;# 30'#'%)%5&.*0+#-.#-#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#

033*(%<# 704#:04;)#2%# -2;%# .0# ,%.# .:0#hGU#2*;;/<# 0'# 304'# h"#2*;;/<# 24.#

(%'.-*+;7#+0#0.$%'#.7&%#03#-//%.8`#

>+#-+7#%1%+.<#.$%'%#*/#-#;-',%#)%,'%%#03#.'4.$#*+#.$%#(;-*5#.$-.#

04'# 3*-.#50+%7<# 3'-(.*0+-;# '%/%'1%#2-+6*+,# /7/.%5<# */# 0+%# *+#:$*($#

)%2.# */# *+.%'.:*+%)# :*.$# 50+%78# I$*/# /7/.%5# 3%-.4'%/# .$%# 4..%';7#

&%'1%'/%#&'0&%'.*%/#.$-.#5-//*1%#*+('%-/%/#*+#*+)%2.%)+%//#,*1%#'*/%#

.0#-#%4&$0'*(#2005#^-/#.$%#50+%7#/4&&;7#,'0:/`<#:$*;%#&%'*0)/#03#

3'4,-;*.7#-+)#)%2.#&-75%+.#(0*+(*)%#:*.$#&%'*0)/#03#)%&'%//*0+#^-/#

.$%# 50+%7# /4&&;7# (0+.'-(./`8# I$*/# */# +0.# -# 3%-.4'%# 03# .$%# 5-'6%.#

%(0+057<# 24.# *+/.%-)# -# '%/4;.# 03# ,01%'+5%+.# *+.%'1%+.*0+# *+# .$%#

50+%.-'7#-+)#2-+6*+,#-'%+-/8#

#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HU#

G,O(+,-&'./&.%(P.<,:'#?&2(;'#<%1,.#=((

>&2&'-&(6#.41.?#

#

I$%# /.-+)-')# Q4/.*3*(-.*0+# 30'# =(%+.'-;# 2-+6*+,@W*+# :$*($#

.$%# (%+.'-;# ,01%'+5%+.# $%-1*;7# '%,4;-.%/# .$%# 2-+6*+,# /%(.0'<# -+)#

*+)%%)# )%/*,+-.%/# -# /4&'%5%# 2-+6# .0# :$*($# -;;# 0.$%'/# -'%#

/420')*+-.%W*/# .$-.# :*;)(-.<# 4+'%,4;-.%)# 2-+6*+,# :04;)# ;%-)# .0#

'-5&-+.# *+3;-.*0+8# >+)%%)<#04'#)%/('*&.*0+#03# .$%#,0;)/5*.$/#:04;)#

;%-)#5-+7#'%-)%'/#.0#(0+(;4)%#.$-.#3'%%#%+.%'&'*/%#-+)#0&%+#%+.'7<#

:$*;%# .$%7#5*,$.#2%#,00)# *)%-/# *+#$-*'# /-;0+/#-+)#(-'#)%-;%'/$*&/<#

:04;)#2%#)*/-/.'04/#*+#.$%#2-+6*+,#*+)4/.'78#

I$%# 0&&0/*.%# */# .'4%8# >+# -# &4'%#5-'6%.# %(0+057<# .$%'%# -'%#

/.'0+,#5"#5:,#-,-*+/.#3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#2-+6*+,<#:$*($#&'%1%+.#-+7#

0+%#2-+6#3'05#*//4*+,#-+#%K(%//*1%#+452%'#03#4+2-(6%)#+0.%/#^0'#03#

,'-+.*+,# -# ;-',%# 3'-(.*0+# 03# +%:# ;0-+/# 0+# .$%# 2-/*/# 03# 0.$%'#

(4/.05%'/C# )%&0/*./`8# M4&&0/%# :%# /.-'.# *+# -+# *+*.*-;# &0/*.*0+# 03#

%D4*;*2'*45<# :$%'%# -;;# .$%# ,0;)/5*.$/# $-1%# =($%-.%)@# .0# -+# %D4-;#

%K.%+.<#/4($#.$-.#0+;7#VUg#03#-+7#,0;)/5*.$C/#(*'(4;-.*+,#2-+6+0.%/#

-(.4-;;7#$-1%#,0;)#'%/%'1%/#2-(6*+,#.$%5#4&#*+#.$%#1-4;.8#M0#;0+,#-/#

.$%#1-'*04/#,0;)/5*.$/C#(4/.05%'/#-'%#(0+.%+.#.0#6%%&#.$%*'#,0;)#0+#

)%&0/*.<# %1%'7.$*+,# */# 3*+%N#c+# -1%'-,%<# .$%# ,0;)/5*.$/C# (4/.05%'/C#

($%(6*+,# .'-+/-(.*0+/# 033/%.# %-($# 0.$%'<# /0# .$-.# .$%'%# */# +0# +%.#

501%5%+.#03#,0;)#3'05#0+%#/5*.$C/#1-4;.#.0#-+0.$%'8#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HG#

I$*/# %D4*;*2'*45#:*;;# 2%# )*/.4'2%)# *3# 0+%# 03# .$%# ,0;)/5*.$/#

2%(05%/#50'%# -,,'%//*1%<# &'*+.*+,#4&#+%:#2-+6+0.%/# -+)# ;%+)*+,#

.$%5# *+.0# .$%# (0554+*.78# # a%(-4/%# 03# .$*/# +%:# *//4-+(%<# /4&&0/%#

0+;7#R"g#03# .$*/#,0;)/5*.$C/#+0.%/#-'%#+0:#2-(6%)#4&#27#&$7/*(-;#

,0;)# *+# .$%# 1-4;.8# I$%# /$0'.L.%'5# 2%+%3*.<# 03# (04'/%<# */# .$-.# .$%#

,0;)/5*.$#+0:#$-/#-# ;-',%'# ;0-+#&0'.30;*0<#-+)#'%-&/#50'%# *+.%'%/.#

*+(05%#.$-+#4+)%'#$*/#50'%#(0+/%'1-.*1%#&0;*(78#

I$%#/4((%//#:*;;#2%#3;%%.*+,<#$0:%1%'8#a%(-4/%#03#.$%#'%;-.*1%#

*+('%-/%# *+# .$%# -504+.# 03# 2-+6+0.%/# 4/%)# 27# .$%# -,,'%//*1%#

,0;)/5*.$C/# (;*%+.%;%<# $*/# (;*%+./# :*;;# .%+)# .0# /&%+)# 50'%# :$%+#

247*+,# .$*+,/# 3'05# 0.$%'# 5%52%'/# 03# .$%# (0554+*.7<# .$-+# .$%#

(;*%+./# 03# 0.$%'# ,0;)/5*.$/#:*;;# /&%+)#0+# .$%# ,00)/#033%'%)#27# .$%#

3*'/.#,'04&8#>+#0.$%'#:0')/<#.$%#(;*%+.%;%#03#.$%#-,,'%//*1%#,0;)/5*.$#

:*;;# '4+# -# =.'-)%#)%3*(*.@#:*.$# .$%# (;*%+./# 03# .$%#50'%# (0+/%'1-.*1%#

,0;)/5*.$/8#

9$-.# .$*/# 5%-+/# */# .$-.# %1%+.4-;;7<# .$%# (0+/%'1-.*1%#

,0;)/5*.$/# :*;;# -((454;-.%# -+# %K(%//# 03# 2-+6+0.%/# *//4%)# 27# .$%#

-,,'%//*1%#,0;)/5*.$<#-/#.$%*'#(;*%+./#)%&0/*.# .$%/%#+0.%/# *+.0#.$%*'#

0:+# -((04+./8# k4'*+,# &%'*0)*(# (;%-'*+,$04/%# 0&%'-.*0+/<# .$%#

-,,'%//*1%# ,0;)/5*.$# :*;;# 3*+)# .$-.# $%# (0+/*/.%+.;7# $-/# +%.#

'%)%5&.*0+#(;-*5/#3'05#$*/#(05&%.*.0'/8#?*/#/.0(6&*;%/#03#,0;)#:*;;#

%1%+.4-;;7# 2%# )'-*+%)# -:-7# *+.0# .$%*'# 1-4;./<# -/# .$%7# (0+.*+4-;;7#

&'%/%+.#$*5#:*.$#50'%#03#$*/#0:+#2-+6+0.%/# 30'#'%)%5&.*0+<# .$-+#

$%#*+#.4'+#(-+#&'%/%+.#.0#.$%58#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!H!#

I$4/#:%#/%%#.$-.#-#3'%%#5-'6%.#*+#2-+6*+,#(0+.-*+/#-4.05-.*(#

/.-2*;*A%'/<# -#24*;.L*+# 3%%)2-(6#5%($-+*/5# .$-.#&%+-;*A%/# 3'-(.*0+-;#

'%/%'1%# 2-+6*+,8# >3# 0+%# 2-+6# 2%(05%/# 50'%# -,,'%//*1%# .$-+# *./#

&%%'/<#*./#+%:;7#*//4%)#;0-+/#:*;;#D4*(6;7#(05%#$05%#.0#'00/.#-/#.$%#

+%:# 50+%7# 3*+)/# *./# :-7# *+.0# .$%# $-+)/# 03# '*1-;# 2-+6%'/8#

P4'.$%'50'%<#*+#-#3'%%#5-'6%.#:*.$#0&%+#%+.'7<#.$%#2-+6/#(-+C.#%1%+#

-,'%%# .0# 30'5# -# (-'.%;# -+)# %K&-+)# ,*-32)/(#&3,21<# 2%(-4/%# .$*/#

:04;)#&'01*)%#-+#*+(%+.*1%#30'#-#+%:#/.-'.L4&#3*'5#.0#2%,*+#2-+6*+,#

:*.$#-#$*,$%'# '%/%'1%# '-.*0# .$-+# .$%# '%/.#03# .$%# *+)4/.'78#I$*/#+%:#

2-+6#:04;)#.$%+#,'-)4-;;7#)'-*+#-:-7#.$%#,0;)#'%/%'1%/#03#.$%#0;)#

%/.-2;*/$5%+.<#30'(*+,#.$%5#.0#-2-+)0+#.$%*'#-,,'%//*1%#;%+)*+,#-+)#

'-*/%#.$%*'#'%/%'1%#'-.*0/8#

a4.#*3#-#3'%%#5-'6%.#*+#2-+6*+,#:04;)#$-1%#24*;.L*+#*+(%+.*1%/#

30'#GUUg#'%/%'1%/<#:$7#)0#:%#+0.#/%%#.$*/#*+#&'-(.*(%\#I$%#-+/:%'#

*/#+&9#$(-#()'*()#$9#()*&(8#F0+.'-'7#.0#.$%#033*(*-;#Q4/.*3*(-.*0+/<#.$%#

&4'&0/%# 03# ,01%'+5%+.# 2-+6# '%,4;-.*0+# $-/# 2%%+# .0# (-'.%;*A%# .$%#

*+)4/.'7# -+)# #2*-*(/)#' .$%# 5-'6%.# 2'-6%/# 0+# 3'-(.*0+-;# '%/%'1%#

&'-(.*(%/8#I$%#%+.*'%#/0')*)#$*/.0'7#*/#2%70+)#.$%#/(0&%#03#.$*/#2006<#

24.#:%#:*;;#D40.%#]4''-7#X0.$2-')C/#/455-'7#03# .$%#&'0(%//#-/# *.#

:-/#&*0+%%'%)#*+#Z'%-.#a'*.-*+N#

#I$%#*+/.*.4.*0+#03#F%+.'-;#a-+6*+,#%-/%)#.$%#3'%%L5-'6%.#

'%/.'*(.*0+/#0+#3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#2-+6*+,#*+#/%1%'-;#:-7/8#>+#.$%#

3*'/.# &;-(%<# 27# .$%# 5*)L+*+%.%%+.$# (%+.4'7# -# =.'-)*.*0+@# :-/#

('-3.*;7# ('%-.%)# .$-.# .$%# F%+.'-;# a-+6# 54/.# -;:-7/# -(.# -/# -#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HY#

=;%+)%'# 03# ;-/.# '%/0'.@# .0# 2-*;# 04.# .$%# 2-+6/# /$04;)# .$%# 24;6# 03#

.$%5#,%.# *+.0# .'042;%8#I$%#F%+.'-;#a-+6#$-)# .$%#5*,$.<# .$%# ;-:<#

-+)# .$%#&'%/.*,%#03# .$%#M.-.%#2%$*+)# *.S# *.#:-/# .$%#)%&0/*.0'7#03#

.$%# M.-.%C/# -((04+./S# -+)# *.# $-)# .$%# *5&;*(*.# &'05*/%# .$-.# .$%#

M.-.%#'%,-')/#.$%#F%+.'-;#a-+6#-/#=.00#2*,#.0#3-*;8@l8a-(6%)#27#.$%#

F%+.'-;# a-+6# -+)# 2%70+)# *.# 27# .$%# M.-.%# *./%;3<# .$%+<# &42;*(#

(0+3*)%+(%# *+# .$%#2-+6*+,#/7/.%5#:-/#-'.*3*(*-;;7#20;/.%'%)<#-+)#

'4+/#0+#.$%#2-+6*+,#/7/.%5#2%(-5%#3-'#;%//#;*6%;78#

l#

I$%#e%%;#E(.# m03# GTHHn# /7/.%5# *+/4'%)# .$-.# .$%# F%+.'-;#

a-+6#(04;)#-(.#-/#-#(-'.%;*A*+,#)%1*(%<#-+)#*+#&-'.*(4;-'#.0#5-6%#

/4'%# .$-.# .$%# /%1%'%# 3'%%L5-'6%.# ;*5*./#0+# .$%#%K&-+/*0+#&%'/(1'

&(#' 4/(:# (04;)# 2%# (*'(451%+.%)l8mMn*+(%# .$%# :$0;%# &0*+.# 03#

3'-(.*0+-;L'%/%'1%# 2-+6*+,# */# (&)# .0# $-1%# /433*(*%+.# 50+%7# .0#

'%)%%5# .$%# '%(%*&./<# m-+# -,,'%//*1%# 2-+6n# :04;)# D4*(6;7# ,0#

4+)%'# m*+# -# 3'%%# 5-'6%.n8# a4.# *3# -# F%+.'-;# a-+6# %+Q07/# .$%#

50+0&0;7#03#2-+6#+0.%/<#-+)#.$%#(055%'(*-;#2-+6/#-;;#&7'-5*)#

%K&-+/*0+#03#.$%*'#)%5-+)#)%&0/*./#0+#.0&#03#.$%*'#='%/%'1%/<@#0'#

($%(6*+,#-((04+./#-.#.$%#F%+.'-;#a-+6<#.$%+#-;;#.$%#a-+6#+%%)#)0#

.0# -//4'%# /4((%//34;# (-'.%;*A-.*0+# */# .0# %K&-+)# &'0&0'.*0+-.%;7#

.$'04,$04.# .$%# (04+.'7<# /0# .$-.# -;;# (05&%.*+,# 2-+6/# *+('%-/%#

.$%*'#'%/%'1%/<#-+)#(-+#%K&-+)#.0,%.$%'#-.#.$%#/-5%#'-.%8R#

#

E/# *+# /0# 5-+7# 0.$%'# -'%-/<# *+# .$%# 3*%;)/# 03# 50+%7# -+)#

2-+6*+,<#,01%'+5%+.#*+.%'1%+.*0+#-($*%1%/#.$%#%K-(.#&..&,*)##03#*./#

/.-.%)#&4'&0/%8#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#033*(*-;/#/0;%5+;7#)%(;-'%#.$-.#.$%7#

:*;;#3*,$.#*+3;-.*0+#.0#&'0.%(.#.$%#)0;;-'<#-+)#7%.#*.#*/#.$%*'#(0+/(*04/#

)%(*/*0+# .0# 5$#/)#' -&$#' 0&22/$,# .$-.# %'0)%/# &4'($-/*+,# &0:%'# 3-'#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HH#

50'%# .$-+# 0((4''%)# 2%30'%# .$%# P%)C/# %K*/.%+(%8# >+.%'1%+.*0+*/./#

-//4'%# 4/# .$-.# -# 3'%%# 5-'6%.# *+# 2-+6*+,# :04;)# ;%-)# .0# '%(6;%//#

;%+)*+,#-+)#:*)%/&'%-)# *+/.-2*;*.7S#7%.# .$*/#&%'3%(.;7#)%/('*2%/# .$%#

/7/.%5#:%#$-1%#4+)%'#.$%#=&'0.%(.*0+@#03#.$%#(%+.'-;#2-+68#

e%'$-&/# :0'/.# 03# -;;<# ,01%'+5%+.# 5%));*+,# :*.$# *+.%'%/.#

'-.%/# (-4/%/# .$%# 2005L24/.# (7(;%# .$-.# &;-,4%/#50)%'+# %(0+05*%/8#

E))*+,#*+/4;.#.0#*+Q4'7<#34'.$%'#,01%'+5%+.#%330'./#.0#=&'01*)%#-#/03.#

;-+)*+,@# 0+;7# /%'1%# .0# *+.%+/*37# -+)# &'0;0+,# .$%# '%(01%'78# >3# :%#

6+0:# :$-.# .0# ;006# 30'<# .$%# &-..%'+# */# 021*04/# *+# 20.$# .$%# Z'%-.#

k%&'%//*0+#-+)#*+#04'#(4''%+.#('*/*/8#

#

;'#<%1,.#=(>&2&'-&(6#.41.?(!#:2&2(%"&(6:21.&22(!8<=&#

#

]-+7#%(0+05*/./<#%1%+#.$0/%#:$0#,%+%'-;;7#-)5*'%#.$%#3'%%#

5-'6%.<# 2%;*%1%# .$-.# .$%# 2005L24/.# (7(;%# */# -# +-.4'-;# 3%-.4'%# 03#

(-&*.-;*/58#P0'#:$-.%1%'#'%-/0+<#.$%'%#-'%#&%'*0)/#03#'-&*)#,'0:.$#

-+)# ;0:# 4+%5&;075%+.<# 30;;0:%)# 27# &%'*0)/# 03# /;4,,*/$+%//# -+)#

$*,$#4+%5&;075%+.8#>.#/%%5/#.$-.#.$%/%#(7(;%/#-'%#-#+-.4'-;#3%-.4'%#

03#5-'6%.# %(0+05*%/<#:*.$# .$%# ,01%'+5%+.C/# '0;%# ^*3# -+7`#2%*+,# .0#

/500.$#04.#.$%/%#&%'*0)*(#4&/L-+)L)0:+/8#

I$%#E4/.'*-+#%(0+05*/./#)*/-,'%%8#E((0')*+,#.0#.$%#24/*+%//#

(7(;%# .$%0'7#)%1%;0&%)#27#]*/%/# -+)# '%3*+%)#27#?-7%6W.$%# ;-..%'#

:*++*+,#$*/#b02%;#30'#.$*/#:0'6W*.#*/#,01%'+5%+.#*+.%'3%'%+(%#:*.$#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!H"#

.$%# 2-+6*+,# /7/.%5# .$-.# )*/.4'2/# .$%# 4+)%';7*+,# .'%+)# 03# +0'5-;<#

/4/.-*+-2;%#%(0+05*(#,'0:.$8#

M&%(*3*(-;;7<# :$-.# $-&&%+/# */# .$*/N# >.# */# 1%'7# &0;*.*(-;;7#

&0&4;-'#.0#&4/$#)0:+#*+.%'%/.#'-.%/#2%;0:#.$%*'#5-'6%.#;%1%;/8#I$%#

(%+.'-;# 2-+6# ^.$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%# *+# .$%#B8M8`# 247/# -//%./# /4($# -/#

,01%'+5%+.# 20+)/# -+)# *+Q%(./# +%:# '%/%'1%/# *+.0# .$%# 2-+6*+,#

/7/.%58# a%(-4/%# '%,4;-.*0+/# 0+;7# *+/*/.# 0+# 3'-(.*0+-;# ^*+/.%-)# 03#

GUUg`#'%/%'1%/<#.$%#(055%'(*-;#2-+6/#(-+#.$%+#-)1-+(%#+%:#;0-+/#

.0# .$%*'# (4/.05%'/<# :$*($# -'%# =&7'-5*)%)@# 0+# .0&# 03# .$%# *+3;4K# 03#

+%:# '%/%'1%/8# Î$%# &'0(%//# */# -+-;0,04/# .0# 04'# )*/(4//*0+# -201%<#

%K(%&.# .$-.# .$%# *+*.*-;# )%&0/*.# (05%/# +0.# 3'05# .$%# )*/(01%'7# 03#

hG<UUU# *+# (4''%+(7<#24.# 3'05# .$%# (%+.'-;#2-+6C/#&4'($-/%#03# -//%./#

27#:'*.*+,# -# ($%(6# )'-:+# 0+# .$%# P%)# *./%;38`# >+# 0')%'# .0#501%# .$%#

+%:# ;0-+/<# .$%# (055%'(*-;# 2-+6/# ;0:%'# .$%# '-.%# 03# *+.%'%/.# .$%7#

($-',%8#

>+# .$%# E4/.'*-+# 1*%:<# .$%# *+.%'%/.# '-.%# */# -# 1%'7# *5&0'.-+.#

5-'6%.#&'*(%<#:$*($#/%'1%/#.0#'%,4;-.%#.$%#/.%%'*+,#03#'%/04'(%/#*+.0#

(0+/45&.*0+#,00)/#1%'/4/#(-&*.-;#,00)/8#9$%+# .$%# *+.%'%/.# '-.%# */#

1%'7#$*,$<#*.#&%+-;*A%/#%+.'%&'%+%4'/#3'05#/.-'.*+,#;0+,#&'0)4(.*0+#

&'0(%//%/<# 2%(-4/%# .$%7# (-+C.# -330')# .0#$-1%# .$%*'# (-&*.-;# =.*%)#4&@#

30'#7%-'/#*+#-#1%+.4'%8#c+#.$%#0.$%'#$-+)<#*3# *+.%'%/.#'-.%/#3-;;<#.$%+#

(%'.-*+# ;0+,L.%'5# &'0Q%(./# 5-7# /4))%+;7# 2%(05%# &'03*.-2;%<# %1%+#

.$04,$#.$%7#:%'%#+0.#,00)#*+1%/.5%+./#-.#.$%#$*,$%'# *+.%'%/.#'-.%8#

P0'# %K-5&;%<# .0# 24*;)# -# /67/('-&%'#5*,$.# '%D4*'%# 7%-'/# 03# 4&3'0+.#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HJ#

*+1%/.5%+.<#2%30'%#.$%#24*;)*+,#(-+#2%#'%+.%)#04.#.0#%-'+#'%1%+4%/8#

I$%# /-5%# &'0Q%(.%)# 3;0:# 03# %K&%+/%/# -+)# *+(05%# (04;)# $-1%# -#

&0/*.*1%# 0'# +%,-.*1%# &'%/%+.# 1-;4%<# )%&%+)*+,# 0+# .$%# *+.%'%/.# '-.%8#

I$%#;0:%'#.$%#*+.%'%/.#'-.%#4/%)#.0#=)*/(04+.@#34.4'%#(-/$#3;0:/<#.$%#

50'%#&'03*.-2;%#.$%#&'0Q%(.#:04;)#2%(05%8#

E((0')*+,#.0#.$%#E4/.'*-+/<#:$%+#.$%#(%+.'-;#2-+6#-'.*3*(*-;;7#

;0:%'/# .$%# *+.%'%/.# '-.%<# .$*/# /%+)/#-# 3-;/%# /*,+-;# .0#%+.'%&'%+%4'/8#

I$%7# 2%,*+# ;0+,L.%'5# &'0Q%(./<# Q4/.# -/# .$%7# :04;)# *3# &%0&;%# $-)#

-(.4-;;7# *+('%-/%)# .$%*'# /-1*+,/# ^:$*($# /2,&# :04;)# &4/$# )0:+#

*+.%'%/.# '-.%/`8# P0'# -# :$*;%<# .$*+,/# -&&%-'# &'0/&%'04/8# I$%#

%+.'%&'%+%4'/#:$0#,%.# .$%#+%:#;0-+/#(-+#%K&-+)#.$%*'#0&%'-.*0+/<#

$*'%# :0'6%'/<# -+)# 247# /4&&;*%/# 3'05# 0.$%'# 24/*+%//%/8# I$%'%# */# -#

,%+%'-;#3%%;*+,#03#%4&$0'*-8#I$%#4&&-#%+/4%/8#

B+30'.4+-.%;7<# .$%#2005# */# *;;4/0'78#I$%# (%+.'-;# 2-+6#)*)+C.#

-(.4-;;7#*+('%-/%#.$%#-504+.#03#'%-;#/-1*+,/#*+#.$%#%(0+057<#Q4/.#27#

&'*+.*+,# 4&# 50+%7# -+)# ,*1*+,# *.# .0# 20+)# )%-;%'/# ^:$0# *+# .4'+#

)%&0/*.%)# .$%# +%:# 50+%7# *+# .$%*'# 0:+# (055%'(*-;# 2-+6/`8# I$%#

3-;;*+,# *+.%'%/.# '-.%# */# ,*1*+,# .$%# :'0+,# 5%//-,%# -204.# .$%# .'4%#

-504+.# 03# /-1*+,/# -1-*;-2;%# 30'# 24/*+%//%/# .0# 20''0:8# >.# */# +0.#

&$7/*(-;;7# &0//*2;%# 30'# 24/*+%//%/# .0# %K&-+)# *+# /05%# /%(.0'/<#

:*.$04.# (0''%/&0+)*+,# (0+.'-(.*0+/# *+# 0.$%'# /%(.0'/8# E+)# 7%.<#

)4'*+,# .$%# 2005#&%'*0)<# #9#$1# /%(.0'# /%%5/# .0# 2%# )0*+,#:%;;8# I$%#

'-+6/#03#.$%#4+%5&;07%)#/$'*+6<#2%(-4/%#24/*+%//%/# *+#,%+%'-;#-'%#

$*'*+,<#:$*;%#1%'7#3%:#-'%#;-7*+,#033#:0'6%'/8#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HR#

a%(-4/%#*.# */#24*;.#0+#/-+)<#.$%#2005#54/.#%1%+.4-;;7#%+)W

-+)#.$%#/00+%'#.$%#2%..%'8#9$%+#.$%#(%+.'-;#2-+6#%-/%/#2-(6#0+#*./#

*+Q%(.*0+/# 03# +%:# '%/%'1%/<# *+.%'%/.# '-.%/# 2%,*+# '*/*+,# .0# .$%*'# .'4%#

5-'6%.# ;%1%;8# E.# .$*/# /.-,%<#5-+7# 24/*+%//# 0:+%'/# -'%# (-4,$.# 3;-.L

300.%)8#E/#*+.%'%/.#'-.%/#'*/%<#-+)#-/#.$%#+%:#50+%7#&4/$%/#'%/04'(%#

&'*(%/# $*,$%'<#5-+7# 0:+%'/# '%-;*A%# .$-.# .$%7# $-1%# 2*..%+# 033#50'%#

.$-+# .$%7#(-+#($%:8#I$%*'#0&%'-.*0+/#-'%#+0# ;0+,%'#&'03*.-2;%<#-+)#

.$%7#-)Q4/.# .0# .$%#+%:#'%-;*.78# M05%#5%'%;7# /(-;%#2-(6#0&%'-.*0+/<#

24.# 0.$%'/# '%-;*A%# .$-.# .$%# 2%/.# .$*+,# .0# )0# */# /$4.# )0:+#

*55%)*-.%;7<#;-7#033#-;;#:0'6%'/<#-+)#;*D4*)-.%#:$-.%1%'#-//%./#.$%7#

0:+8#I$*/#*/#.$%#43,)#&$-/%8#

>'0+*(-;;7<#.$%#E4/.'*-+/#1*%:#.$%#2005#&%'*0)#-/#2-)<#:$*;%#

.$%# 24/.# */# ,00)8# k4'*+,# .$%# 2005# &%'*0)<# '%/04'(%/# -'%# 2%*+,#

-/2*(9#,)#08# I$%# ;0+,%'# .$%# 2005# &%'/*/./<# .$%# 34'.$%'# .$%# (-&*.-;#

/.'4(.4'%# 03# .$%# %(0+057# /.'-7/# 3'05# :$%'%# *.# '%-;;7# /$04;)# 2%8#

Î$*/#*/#2%(-4/%#.$%#(%+.'-;#2-+6#*/#+0.#-;;0:*+,#.$%#*+.%'%/.#'-.%#.0#

(0554+*(-.%# .$%# (0''%(.# *+30'5-.*0+8`# 9$%+# .$%# (%+.'-;# 2-+6#

3*+-;;7# '%;%+./# -+)# ;%./# .$%# *+.%'%/.# '-.%# =.%;;# .$%# .'4.$@#0+(%#-,-*+<#

24/*+%//%/#-)Q4/.# .0#.$%#,'*5#'%-;*.78# >.C/# .'4%<# .$%#24/.#&%'*0)# */+C.#

&;%-/-+.<# 24.# *.# */# +%(%//-'7# .0# (;%-+/%# .$%# %(0+057# 03# .$%#

5-;*+1%/.5%+./#3'05#.$%#2005#&%'*0)8#E#&0&4;-'#-+-;0,7#(05&-'%/#

.$%#2005#.0#-#)'*+6*+,#2*+,%<#-+)#.$%#24/.#.0#-#$-+,01%'8#

I$4/#:%# /%%# .$-.# ,01%'+5%+.# *+.%'1%+.*0+W*+# .$%# 30'5# 03#

(%+.'-;# 2-+6/# :$*($# 0',-+*A%# (-'.%;/# *+# .$%# *+)4/.'7# -+)# 30/.%'#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HT#

3'-(.*0+-;#'%/%'1%#2-+6*+,W*/#.$%#/04'(%#03#.$%#2005L24/.#(7(;%8#>+#

-#3'%%#5-'6%.<#:$%'%#.$%#*+.%'%/.#'-.%#'%3;%(.%)#.$%#,%+4*+%#-504+.#

03# /-1*+,/#5-)%# &0//*2;%# 27# &%0&;%# ;*1*+,# 2%;0:# .$%*'# 5%-+/# ^*8%8#

(0+/45*+,# ;%//# .$-+# .$%*'# *+(05%/`<# 24/*+%//# %K&-+/*0+#:04;)# 2%#

/4/.-*+-2;%8#I$%'%#:04;)#2%#+0#5-//*1%#/:*+,/#4&#-+)#.$%+#('-/$%/#

)0:+8# >.C/# .'4%<# *+#-+7#,*1%+#7%-'#/05%#24/*+%//#:04;)#-;:-7/# 3-*;<#

24.#.$%'%#:04;)+C.#2%#&%'*0)/#03#,1,)#-/)*5#3-*;4'%#/:%%&*+,#-('0//#

.$%#%+.*'%#%(0+0578#

#

PQ$=#1.1.?(%"&(+'&#%(0&$'&221,.#

#

E((0')*+,# .0# .$%# /.-+)-')# ;*+%# 50/.# '%-)%'/# &'02-2;7#

;%-'+%)#*+#,'-)%#/($00;<#.$%#Z'%-.#k%&'%//*0+#03#.$%#GVYU/#:-/#.$%#

3-4;.# 03# .$%# 4+'%,4;-.%)<# :*;)(-.# 3'%%# 5-'6%.8# a-(6# *+# .$0/%#

4+%+;*,$.%+%)# .*5%/W/0# .$%# 033*(*-;# /.0'7# ,0%/W.$%#B+*.%)# M.-.%/#

-+)# 0.$%'# -)1-+(%)# %(0+05*%/# $-)# -# '%;-.*1%;7# &4'%# (-&*.-;*/.#

/7/.%58#9$%+#4+'%,4;-.%)#/&%(4;-.0'/#('-/$%)#.$%#/.0(6#5-'6%.#*+#

GV!V<# e'%/*)%+.#?%'2%'.#?001%'# /-.# 2-(6# -+)#)*)#+0.$*+,# .0# -1%'.#

)*/-/.%'8# F;*+,*+,# .0# $*/# -+.*D4-.%)# 2%;*%3/# *+# /5-;;# ,01%'+5%+.<#

?001%'#:-.($%)#-/# .$%#+-.*0+#&;4+,%)# *+.0#)%&'%//*0+8# >.# .006# .$%#

20;)#*+.%'1%+.*0+*/.#P'-+6;*+#k8#X00/%1%;.#.0#%K&-+)#.$%#/*A%#03#.$%#

3%)%'-;#,01%'+5%+.#-+)#'%/(4%#.$%#%(0+057#3'05#.$%#/;45&#(-4/%)#

27#&4'%#(-&*.-;*/58#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!HV#

f1%'7#%;%5%+.# *+#.$*/#033*(*-;#/.0'7#*/#-#57.$8#I$*/# */#+0.#.$%#

&;-(%#30'#-# 34;;#'%34.-.*0+S#0+%#03#.$%#&'%/%+.#-4.$0'/#$-/#:'*..%+#-#

2006# 0+# .$%# /42Q%(.8T# P0'# 04'# &4'&0/%/<# :%# :*;;# 033%'# -# 3%:#

02/%'1-.*0+/8#

P*'/.<# 0+# .$%# 3-(%# 03# *.# .$*/# 033*(*-;# %K&;-+-.*0+# 5-6%/# +0#

/%+/%8# I$%# ('-/$# 03# GV!V# :-/+C.# .$%# 3*'/.# 3*+-+(*-;# &-+*(# *+# B8M8#

$*/.0'78# E+)# $0:%1%'# ;-*//%AL3-*'%# .$%#B8M8# ,01%'+5%+.#:-/# *+# .$%#

%-';7#GVYU/<#*.#(%'.-*+;7#:-/#/)'2#/,)#-/#;-*//%AL3-*'%#)4'*+,#.$%#&'*0'#

3*+-+(*-;# ('*/%/8# M0# .0# %K&;-*+# .$%# Z'%-.# k%&'%//*0+# -/# )4%# .0#

4+'%,4;-.%)# (-&*.-;*/5<# */# -# 2*.# ;*6%# 2;-5*+,# -# &-'.*(4;-';7# -:34;#

&;-+%#('-/$#0+#,'-1*.78#

j%.# *+#.$%#/%(0+)#&;-(%<# .$%#&'%5*/%#*./%;3# */#:'0+,8#?%'2%'.#

?001%'#:-/#(&)#-#;-*//%AL3-*'%#5-+W3-'#3'05#*.O#>+#'%/&0+/%#.0#.$%#

GV!V#('-/$<#?001%'#(-;;%)#-;;#.$%#2*,#24/*+%//#;%-)%'/#.0#9-/$*+,.0+#

-+)#*+/*/.%)#.$-.#.$%7#+0.#(4.#:-,%#'-.%/#-/#-#5%-+/#03#(0&*+,#:*.$#

.$%# ('*/*/8# I$*/# %+/4'%)# .$-.# ;-20'# 2%(-5%# -'.*3*(*-;;7# 50'%#

%K&%+/*1%#-/# .$%#7%-'/#)'-,,%)#0+<#-/#0.$%'#&'*(%/#&;455%.%)#24.#

24/*+%//%/#:%'%# '%;4(.-+.# .0# (4.# &-78# >.C/# +0.# /4'&'*/*+,# .$%+# .$-.#

4+%5&;075%+.# /0-'%)# .0# !"# &%'(%+.<# :$%+# ?001%'C/# $*,$L:-,%#

&0;*(*%/#)'01%#4&#.$%#^'%;-.*1%`#&'*(%#03#%5&;07*+,#:0'6%'/8#

a%;*%1%# *.# 0'# +0.<# ?001%'# *5&;%5%+.%)#:$-.# (04;)# 2%# 3-*';7#

(-;;%)# -# b%:# k%-;L;*.%# )4'*+,# $*/# /*+,;%# .%'5# *+# 033*(%8# >+# .$%# .:0#

7%-'/# 30;;0:*+,# .$%# /.0(6# 5-'6%.# ('-/$<# 3%)%'-;# /&%+)*+,# '0/%# H!#

&%'(%+.8# ?001%'# *+$%'*.%)# -# &%'3%(.# /.'*+,# 03# 3%)%'-;# 24),%.#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"U#

/4'&;4/%/# 4+)%'# $*/# &'%)%(%//0'# F-;1*+# F00;*),%<# -+)# 7%.# *+#

?001%'C/# ;-/.# 24),%.# 7%-'# .$%# 3%)%'-;# )%3*(*.# :-/# -# :$0&&*+,# H8"#

&%'(%+.# 03# Zke8# ^P0'# (05&-'*/0+<# )4'*+,# Z%0',%# 98# a4/$C/# 3*'/.#

.%'5W*+#:$*($# $%# =/.-'.%)# -#:-'# -+)# (4.# .-K%/# 0+# .$%# '*($@W.$%#

3%)%'-;# 24),%.# )%3*(*.# &%-6%)# -.# Y8J# &%'(%+.# 03# Zke8`# ?001%'# -;/0#

)'-/.*(-;;7# *+('%-/%)# .$%# .-K# 24')%+<#:*.$# .$%# .0&# *+(05%# .-K# '-.%#

,0*+,#3'05#!"#&%'(%+.#*+#GVYG#.0#BC'.#$5#()'&(#'1#/$'2/)#$8#E+)#*+#-#

501%#.$-.#/04+)/#1%'7#X00/%1%;.L*/$<#?001%'#01%'/-:#.$%#('%-.*0+#

03# .$%# X%(0+/.'4(.*0+# P*+-+(%# F0'&0'-.*0+# ^XPF`# .0# 2-*;# 04.#

.'042;%)#3*+-+(*-;#*+/.*.4.*0+/<#:$*($#)*/24'/%)#/05%#hG8"#2*;;*0+#*+#

GVY!#-;0+%8# Ê+)#'%5%52%'<# *+#GVY!#-#2*;;*0+#)0;;-'/#'%-;;7#5%-+.#

/05%.$*+,O`V#

E/#:%# /%%<# .$%# -(.*0+/# 03# .$%#?001%'#E)5*+*/.'-.*0+#$-');7#

Q4/.*37#$*/#'%&4.-.*0+#-/#-#(0;)L2;00)%)#)0,5-.*/.8#>'0+*(-;;7<#?001%'#

$*5/%;3# )%+*%)# /4($# -# )%/('*&.*0+<# /0# *.# */# 1%'7# (4'*04/# .$-.# .$%#

033*(*-;#57.$#&%'/*/./8#>+#$*/#5%50*'/#$%'%#*/#:$-.#?001%'#$-/#.0#/-7#

0+#.$*/#&%'*0)N#

#9*.$# .$%# c(.02%'Lb01%52%'# mGV!Vn# /.0(6L5-'6%.# ('-/$# .$%#

&'*5-'7#D4%/.*0+#-.#0+(%#-'0/%#-/#.0#:$%.$%'#.$%#e'%/*)%+.#-+)#

.$%# P%)%'-;# ,01%'+5%+.# /$04;)# 4+)%'.-6%# .0# 5*.*,-.%# -+)#

'%5%)7#.$%#%1*;/#/.%55*+,#3'05#*.8#b0#e'%/*)%+.#2%30'%#$-)#%1%'#

2%;*%1%)# .$%'%#:-/#-#,01%'+5%+.-;# '%/&0+/*2*;*.7# *+# /4($#(-/%/8#

b0# 5-..%'# :$-.# .$%# 4',*+,# 0+# &'%1*04/# 0((-/*0+/<# e'%/*)%+./#

/.%-)3-/.;7# $-)# 5-*+.-*+%)# .$-.# .$%# P%)%'-;# ,01%'+5%+.# :-/#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"G#

-&-'.# 3'05# /4($# %'4&.*0+/S# .$%7# $-)# -;:-7/# 2%%+# ;%3.# .0# 2;0:#

.$%5/%;1%/# 04.8# e'%/*)%+./# o-+# a4'%+<# Z'-+.<# F;%1%;-+)<# -+)#

I$%0)0'%#X00/%1%;.#$-)#-;;#'%5-*+%)#-;003l#

a%(-4/%# 03# .$*/# ;-(6# 03# ,01%'+5%+.-;# %K&%'*%+(%<#

.$%'%30'%<#:%#$-)#.0#&*0+%%'#-#+%:#3*%;)8#E/#-#5-..%'#03#3-(.#.$%'%#

:-/#;*..;%#%(0+05*(#6+0:;%),%#.0#,4*)%#4/8GU##

>+# $*/# -((%&.-+(%# /&%%($# 30'# .$%# GVY!# X%&42;*(-+#

&'%/*)%+.*-;# +05*+-.*0+<# ?001%'# ;006%)# 2-(6# 0+# .$%#

-((05&;*/$5%+./#03#$*/#3*'/.#.%'5#-+)#&'04);7#)%(;-'%)N#

#m9n%#5*,$.#$-1%#)0+%#+0.$*+,8#I$-.#:04;)#$-1%#2%%+#4..%'#'4*+8#

>+/.%-)<#:%#5%.#.$%#/*.4-.*0+#:*.$#&'0&0/-;/#.0#&'*1-.%#24/*+%//#

-+)# .0# F0+,'%//# 03# .$%# 50/.# ,*,-+.*(# &'0,'-5# 03# %(0+05*(#

)%3%+/%# -+)# (04+.%'-..-(6# %1%'# %10;1%)# *+# .$%# $*/.0'7# 03# .$%#

X%&42;*(8#9%#&4.#*.#*+.0#-(.*0+8GG#

#

M0# .$%'%# 704# $-1%# *.N# a0.$# .$%# /.-.*/.*(/# -+)# ?001%'C/# 0:+#

/.-.%5%+./# /$0:# .$-.# $*/# :-/# .$%# 50/.# *()#$9#()*&(*,)#

-)5*+*/.'-.*0+# *+# B8M8# $*/.0'7<# -.# ;%-/.# *+# .%'5/# 03# )%-;*+,# :*.$# -#

3*+-+(*-;#('-/$8#M*+(%# .$*/# =5%)*(*+%@# 3'05#9-/$*+,.0+#:%+.#$-+)L

*+L$-+)#:*.$# .$%#:0'/.# %(0+05*(# (0;;-&/%# *+# B8M8# $*/.0'7<# c((-5C/#

X-A0'# ^-/# :%;;# -/# E4/.'*-+# %(0+05*(# .$%0'7`# /4,,%/./# .$-.# .$%#

?001%'#5%)*(*+%#:-/#*+#3-(.#&0*/0+8#X-.$%'#.$-+#)%&-'.*+,#3'05#.$%#

;-*//%AL3-*'%# &0;*(*%/# 03# $*/# &'%)%(%//0'/<# ?001%'# /$04;)# $-1%#

30;;0:%)#.$%*'#%K-5&;%#-+)#;%.#.$%#5-'6%.#-)Q4/.#.0#.$%#('*/*/8#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"!#

I$%'%#*/#50'%#.0#.$%#/.0'7<#$0:%1%'8#I$%#/.0(6#5-'6%.#('-/$#

03#GV!V#*./%;3#:-/#+0.#)4%#.0#.$%#=3'%%#5-'6%.8@# >+# 3-(.<# .$%#P%)%'-;#

X%/%'1%# *+# GV!R# (0+/(*04/;7# (4.# *+.%'%/.# '-.%/# -+)# 34%;%)# B8M8#

*+3;-.*0+<# *+# 0')%'# .0# -//*/.# .$%# a-+6# 03# f+,;-+)8# I$*/# %-/7L50+%7#

&0;*(7#27#.$%#E5%'*(-+#(%+.'-;#2-+6#34%;%)#.$%#/.0(6#5-'6%.#2005#

03#.$%#;-.%#GV!U/<#:$*($#.$%+#(-5%#('-/$*+,#)0:+#*+#GV!V#:$%+#.$%#

P%)#2%,-+#-&&;7*+,#.$%#2'-6%/8#

E/#:*.$#.$%#34;;#$*/.0'7#03#.$%#GVYU/<#*.#*/#+0.#04'#&;-(%#$%'%#

.0# %K&;-*+# .$%# %+.*'%# /.0'7# 2%$*+)# .$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%C/# 3-.%34;#

)%(*/*0+8#>+/.%-)#:%#:*;;#,*1%#%+04,$#%1*)%+(%#.0#:$%.#.$%#'%-)%'C/#

-&&%.*.%# .0# 30;;0:L4&#:*.$# .$%#2006/#(*.%)# *+# .$%#%+)+0.%/8#?%'%# */#

.$%#GVYG#.%/.*50+7#03#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#5%52%'#E8#F8#]*;;%'<#2%30'%#

.$%#M%+-.%#F055*..%%#0+#a-+6*+,#-+)#F4''%+(7<#0+#.$%#(-4/%/#03#.$%#

GV!V#('-/$N#

#>+# .$%# 7%-'# GV!Rl704# :*;;# +0.%# .$%# &'0+04+(%)# *+('%-/%# *+#

mP%)%'-;# X%/%'1%# $0;)*+,/# 03# B+*.%)# M.-.%/# ,01%'+5%+.# )%2.#

/%(4'*.*%/n#*+#.$%#/%(0+)#$-;3#03#.$%#7%-'8#F04&;%)#:*.$#.$%#$%-17#

&4'($-/%/# 03# -((%&.-+(%/# *.# :-/# .$%# ,'%-.%/.# -+)# 20;)%/.#

0&%'-.*0+#%1%'#4+)%'.-6%+#27# .$%#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#M7/.%5<#-+)<#

*+# 57# Q4),5%+.<# '%/4;.%)# *+# 0+%# 03# .$%# 50/.# (0/.;7# %''0'/#

(055*..%)# 27# *.# 0'# -+7# 0.$%'# 2-+6*+,# /7/.%5# *+# .$%# ;-/.# R"#

7%-'/O888#

9$-.#:-/#.$%#02Q%(.#03#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#e0;*(7#*+#GV!R\#

>.#:-/#.0#2'*+,#)0:+#50+%7#'-.%/<#.$%#(-;;#'-.%#m.$%#*+.%'%/.#'-.%#

0+#;0-+/#.0#=5-',*+#247%'/@#:$0#247#/.0(6#-+)#0.$%'#/%(4'*.*%/#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"Y#

:*.$#20''0:%)#(-&*.-;n#-50+,#.$%5<#2%(-4/%#03#.$%#*+.%'+-.*0+-;#

*5&0'.-+(%#.$%#(-;;#'-.%#$-)#(05%#.0#-(D4*'%8#I$%#&4'&0/%#:-/#.0#

/.-'.#-+#04.3;0:#03#,0;)W.0#'%1%'/%# .$%#&'%1*04/# *+3;0:#03#,0;)#

*+.0#.$*/#(04+.'78G!#

#

b0:# -//45*+,# ]*;;%'C/# .%/.*50+7# */# -((4'-.%<# :$7# *+# .$%#

:0';)# :04;)# .$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%# $-1%# (0+/(*04/;7# -)0&.%)# -+#

*+3;-.*0+-'7# &0;*(7# *+# GV!R<# :*.$# .$%# *+.%+.*0+# 03# (-4/*+,# ,0;)# .0#

2#/9##.$%#(04+.'7\#

I$%# -+/:%'# */# -# ;0+,# -+)# +4-+(%)# 0+%<# -+)# $-/# 2%%+# -#

3-10'*.%# .0&*(# 03# =(0+/&*'-(7# .$%0'*/./@# :$0# 2;-5%# :0';):*)%#

(-;-5*.*%/# 0+# .$%# $*))%+# 5-($*+-.*0+/# 03# '*($# 2-+6%'/# -+)# 0.$%'#

&0:%'34;#*+)*1*)4-;/8#9$-.#:%#(-+#/-7#:*.$#(0+3*)%+(%#*/#.$-.#Z'%-.#

a'*.-*+# :-/# *+# .'042;%# -3.%'# 90';)# 9-'# ><# 2%(-4/%# .$%# a'*.*/$#

-4.$0'*.*%/# :-+.%)# .0# '%.4'+# .0# .$%# ,0;)# /.-+)-')# -.# .$%# &'%L:-'#

&-'*.7<#24.#$-)#&'*+.%)#.00#5-+7#&-&%'#+0.%/#.0#34+)#.$%#:-'#%330'.8#

>+#0')%'#.0#/.'%+,.$%+#.$%#&04+)#.0#*./#&'%L:-'#&0/*.*0+#1*/LpL1*/#.$%#

B8M8# )0;;-'<# .$%'%30'%<# a'*.*/$# ;-20'# 4+*0+/# :04;)# $-1%# $-)# .0#

.0;%'-.%#-#&-*+34;#)%3;-.*0+#-+)#*./#(0+(05*.-+.#*5&-(.#0+#:-,%/8#

X-.$%'# .$-+# .$*/# &0;*.*(-;;7# )*33*(4;.# /.'-.%,7<# -+0.$%'# '04.%#

:04;)#$-1%#2%%+# 30'# .$%#E5%'*(-+/# .0#6#/:#(# .$%*'#0:+#(4''%+(7<#

.-6*+,# .$%# /.'-*+# 033# .$%# a'*.*/$# &04+)8# E# )%1-;4-.*0+# 03# .$%# B8M8#

)0;;-'#:04;)#$-1%#'%501%)#.$%#/&%(4;-.*1%#&'%//4'%#0+#.$%#&04+)<#

:$*($#:-/#)'-*+*+,#,0;)#'%/%'1%/#3'05#.$%#a-+6#03#f+,;-+)8#d*2%'-;#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"H#

%(0+05*/.# q0$+#r%++%.$#Z-;2'-*.$# )%/('*2%/# -# /%('%.#5%%.*+,# .$-.#

5-7#%K&;-*+#.$%#P%)C/#)%(*/*0+#.0#2-*;#04.#a'*.-*+N#

#c+# q4;7# G<# GV!R<# .$%# =/3$#)/(*/' -''*1%)# *+# b%:# j0'6#

:*.$#.:0#+0.-2;%#&-//%+,%'/<#]0+.-,4#b0'5-+<#Z01%'+0'#03#.$%#

a-+6# 03# f+,;-+)<# -+)# ?Q-;5-'# M($-($.<# $%-)# 03# .$%# Z%'5-+#

X%*($/2-+6lI$%#/%('%(7#(01%'*+,#.$%#1*/*.#:-/#%K.'%5%#-+)#.0#-#

)%,'%%# 0/.%+.-.*04/8# I$%# +-5%/# 03# +%*.$%'# 03# .$%# ,'%-.# 2-+6%'/#

-&&%-'%)#0+#.$%#&-//%+,%'#;*/.8#b%*.$%'<#0+#-''*1*+,<#5%.#:*.$#.$%#

&'%//l#

>+#b%:#j0'6# .$%# .:0#5%+#:%'%# Q0*+%)# 27# F$-';%/#X*/.<#

.$%# k%&4.7# Z01%'+0'# 03# .$%# a-+D4%# )%# P'-+(%<# -+)# .$%7# :%+.#

*+.0# (0+3%'%+(%# :*.$# a%+Q-5*+# M.'0+,<# .$%# Z01%'+0'# 03# .$%#

P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#a-+6#03#b%:#j0'6#m-+)#.$%#)%#3-(.0#$%-)#03#.$%#

%+.*'%#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#M7/.%5#-.#.$%#.*5%nl#

I$%#&'*+(*&;%l/42Q%(.#03#)*/(4//*0+#:-/#.$%#&%'/*/.%+.;7#

:%-6#'%/%'1%#&0/*.*0+#03#.$%#a-+6#03#f+,;-+)8#I$*/<#.$%#2-+6%'/#

.$04,$.<# (04;)# 2%# $%;&%)# *3# .$%# P%)%'-;# X%/%'1%# M7/.%5# :04;)#

%-/%# *+.%'%/.# '-.%/<# %+(04'-,%# ;%+)*+,8# ?0;)%'/# 03# ,0;)# :04;)#

.$%+#/%%6#.$%#$*,$%'#'%.4'+/#3'05#6%%&*+,#.$%*'#5%.-;#*+#d0+)0+8#

E+)<# *+# .*5%<# $*,$%'# &'*(%/# *+# .$%#B+*.%)# M.-.%/#:04;)# %-/%# .$%#

(05&%.*.*1%#&0/*.*0+#03#a'*.*/$#*+)4/.'7#-+)#;-20'8GY#

#

I0# 20;/.%'# Z-;2'-*.$C/# *+.%'&'%.-.*0+<# :%# (-+# D40.%# 3'05# -#

;%..%'#&%++%)#27#a%+Q-5*+#M.'0+,#$*5/%;3#-#3%:#7%-'/#%-';*%'<#*+#]-7#

GV!H<#.0#.$%#B8M8#I'%-/4'7#M%('%.-'7#E+)'%:#]%;;0+N#

#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!""#

E.#.$%#&'%/%+.#.*5%#*.#*/#&'02-2;7#.'4%#.$-.#a'*.*/$#&'*(%/#

30'#,00)/#*+.%'+-.*0+-;;7#)%-;.# *+#-'%#-/#-#:$0;%<#'04,$;7<# *+#.$%#

+%*,$20'$00)# 03# GU# &%'(%+.# -201%# 04'# &'*(%/<# -+)# 0+%# 03# .$%#

&'%;*5*+-'*%/# .0# .$%# '%L%/.-2;*/$5%+.#03# ,0;)#&-75%+.#27#Z'%-.#

a'*.-*+#:*;;#2%#.0#3-(*;*.-.%#-#,'-)4-;#'%-)Q4/.5%+.#03#.$%/%#&'*(%#

;%1%;/#4#%&$##50+%.-'7#'%30'5#*/#4+)%'.-6%+8#>+#0.$%'#:0')/<#.$*/#

5%-+/# /05%# /5-;;# -)1-+(%# *+# &'*(%/# $%'%# -+)# &0//*2;7# /05%#

/5-;;#)%(;*+%#*+#.$%*'#&'*(%/l#

I$%#24')%+#03# .$*/# '%-)Q4/.5%+.#54/.# 3-;;#50'%# ;-',%;7#

4&0+#4/#.$-+#4&0+#.$%58#>.#:*;;#2%#)*33*(4;.#&0;*.*(-;;7#-+)#/0(*-;;7#

30'# .$%# a'*.*/$# Z01%'+5%+.# -+)# .$%# a-+6# 03# f+,;-+)# .0# 3-(%# -#

&'*(%# ;*D4*)-.*0+# *+# f+,;-+)l*+# 3-(%# 03# .$%# 3-(.# .$-.# .'-)%# */# /0#

&00'#-+)#.$%7#$-1%#01%'#-#5*;;*0+#4+%5&;07%)#&%0&;%#'%(%*1*+,#

,01%'+5%+.#-*)8GH##

Z4*)%)#27#04'#6+0:;%),%#03#.$%#24/*+%//#(7(;%<#)%1%;0&%)#27#

]*/%/#-+)#?-7%6<#:%#(-+#+0:#4+)%'/.-+)#.$%#/%1%'*.7#-+)#;%+,.$#03#

.$%# Z'%-.# k%&'%//*0+8# I$%# B+*.%)# M.-.%/# *+# .$%# ;-.%# GV!U/#

%K&%'*%+(%)#.$%#;-',%/.#-//%.#2005#*+#$*/.0'7<#:$*($#:-/#34%;%)#27#

.$%#P%)%'-;#X%/%'1%#M7/.%5#^:$*($#$-)#2%%+#*+#34;;#0&%'-.*0+#/*+(%#

GVGH`8# E3.%'# .$%# 2005# (0;;-&/%)# *+# GV!V<# .$%# 3%)%'-;# ,01%'+5%+.#

4+)%'# ?%'2%'.# ?001%'# %52-'6%)# 0+# -+# 4+&'%(%)%+.%)# ='%(01%'7@#

&'0,'-5#03#5-//*1%# *+.%'1%+.*0+<#:$*($# ('*&&;%)# .$%# -2*;*.7# 03# .$%#

5-'6%.#.0#$%-;#*./%;38#9*.$#.$%#%;%(.*0+#03#PkX#*+#GVY!<#.$%#b%:#k%-;#

&'0,'-5# 0+;7# .006# .$%# B+*.%)# M.-.%/# %1%+# (;0/%'# .0# 34;;L2;0:+#

/0(*-;*/58#>.# */#+0#/4'&'*/%#.$%+#.$-.#.$%#Z'%-.#k%&'%//*0+#;-/.%)#-.#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"J#

;%-/.#-#)%(-)%<#:$%'%-/#%-';*%'#B8M8#3*+-+(*-;#&-+*(/#$-)#4/4-;;7#2%%+#

'%/0;1%)#:*.$*+#.:0#.0#.$'%%#7%-'/8#

#

PQ$=#1.1.?(%"&(R+'&#%(>&<&221,.S(

#

fD4*&&%)#:*.$# .$%#E4/.'*-+#4+)%'/.-+)*+,#03# .$%#0&%'-.*0+#

03#-#.'4;7#3'%%#5-'6%.<#-+)#%/&%(*-;;7#:*.$#.$%#]*/%/L?-7%6#.$%0'7#03#

24/*+%//# (7(;%/<# :%# (-+# *+.%'&'%.# .$%# '%(%+.# $04/*+,# 2422;%# -+)#

/42/%D4%+.# 3*+-+(*-;# ('-/$# *+# -# /*5*;-'# 5-++%'# .0# .$%# Z'%-.#

k%&'%//*0+8# F0+.'-'7# .0# (0+1%+.*0+-;#:*/)05<# .$%# $04/*+,# 2422;%#

:-/# +0.# (-4/%)# 27# =)%'%,4;-.*0+@# 4+)%'# .$%# -;;%,%)# &-'-,0+# 03#

(-&*.-;*/5<# Z%0',%#98# a4/$8# ^904;)# -# ;-*//%AL3-*'%# *)%0;0,4%# $-1%#

&-'.*-;;7# +-.*0+-;*A%)# 5-Q0'# B8M8# 2-+6/# -.# .$%# %+)# 03# $*/# /%(0+)#

.%'5\`#

>+#3-(.<#30;;0:*+,#.$%#)0.L(05#('-/$<#.$%+LP%)#F$-*'5-+#E;-+#

Z'%%+/&-+#/;-/$%)#*+.%'%/.#'-.%/#.0#%K.'-0')*+-'*;7#;0:#;%1%;/8#?%'%#

*/#-#($-'.#/$0:*+,#.$%#&'*(%L*+3;-.*0+L-)Q4/.%)#3%)%'-;#34+)/#'-.%N#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"R#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

#

E/# .$%# ($-'.# *+)*(-.%/<# 27# ;-.%# !UUY# Z'%%+/&-+# $-)# &4/$%)#

B8M8# *+.%'%/.# '-.%/# )0:+# .0# .$%*'# ;0:%/.# ;%1%;/# ^'%;-.*1%# .0# &'*(%#

*+3;-.*0+`#/*+(%#.$%#;-.%#GVRU/8#q4/.#-/#.$%#]*/%/L?-7%6#.$%0'7#:04;)#

&'%)*(.<# .$%# '%/4;.# :-/# -+# 4+/4/.-*+-2;%# 2005# ;%-)*+,# .0# -+#

*+%1*.-2;%# ('-/$8# E/# $*/.0'*-+# I$05-/# 900)/# %K&;-*+/# *+# $*/#

2%/./%;;*+,#2006#=#2)0&6(N#

#I$%# P%)l/.-'.%)# .$%# 2005# 27# *+('%-/*+,# .$%# 50+%7#

/4&&;7#.$'04,$#.$%#2-+6*+,#/7/.%5#:*.$#.$%#-*5#-+)#.$%#%33%(.#03#

;0:%'*+,# *+.%'%/.# '-.%/8# >+# .$%# :-6%# 03# M%&.%52%'# GG<# :$*($#

(-5%#Q4/.#01%'#-#7%-'#-3.%'#.$%#)0.L(05#24/.<#.$%+#P%)#($-*'5-+#

E;-+#Z'%%+/&-+#/04,$.#.0#'%*,+*.%#.$%#%(0+057#.$'04,$#-#/%'*%/#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"T#

03# '-.%# (4./l>+# 0')%'# .0# 2'*+,# -204.# .$*/# '%/4;.<# .$%# /4&&;7# 03#

50+%7#:-/#*+('%-/%)#)'-5-.*(-;;7#)4'*+,#.$0/%#7%-'/l#

I$*/# +%:# 50+%7# -+)# ('%)*.# 01%':$%;5*+,;7# 304+)# *./#

:-7# *+.0# .$%# $04/*+,# 5-'6%.<# :$%'%# -'.*3*(*-;;7# ;-K# ;%+)*+,#

/.-+)-')/# 5-)%# %K(%//*1%# $05%# &4'($-/%/# -+)# /&%(4;-.*0+# *+#

$05%/# /%%5# .0#5-+7#E5%'*(-+/# ;*6%#,00)# 3*+-+(*-;#501%/8#I$%#

P%)# -;/0# %+(04'-,%)# .$%# ZMf/WP-++*%# ]-%<# Z*++*%# ]-%<# -+)#

P'%))*%# ]-(W-+)# .$%# P%)%'-;# ?04/*+,# E)5*+*/.'-.*0+# .0#

20''0:# -+)# ;%+)# -.# ;%1%;/# +%1%'# 2%30'%# /%%+8# M0# .$%# -;'%-)7#

%K*/.*+,# (-5&-*,+# .0# ;0:%'# ;%+)*+,# /.-+)-')/<# -;0+,# :*.$# .$%#

50+0&0;7# &'*1*;%,%/# %+Q07%)# 27# .$%# D4-/*L,01%'+5%+.-;#

-,%+(*%/# P-++*%# ]-%# -+)# P'%))*%# ]-(<# &;-7%)# -# '0;%# *+#

($-++%;*+,#*+.0#.$%#$04/*+,#5-'6%.#.$%#+%:#50+%7#.$%#P%)#:-/#

('%-.*+,8# a4.# *.#:-/# .$%# P%)<# 4;.*5-.%;7<# .$-.#5-)%# .$%# -'.*3*(*-;#

2005#*+#$04/*+,#&0//*2;%#*+#.$%#3*'/.#&;-(%<#-+)#*.#:-/#-;;#.$%#+%:#

50+%7#*.#('%-.%)#.$-.#,-1%#.$%#2*,,%/.#/.*54;4/#.0#.$%#4++-.4'-;#

'*/%#*+#$04/*+,#&'*(%/8G"##

+,-&'./&.%( @.%&'-&.%1,.( #( T"'&#%( %,( F1U&'%8( #.7(

H',2$&'1%8(

#

I$*/#($-&.%'#$-/#/$0:+#.$-.#.$%#/.4)7#03#E4/.'*-+#%(0+05*(/#

*/# +0.# -# 5%'%# &-/.*5%8# E'5%)# :*.$# -+# 4+)%'/.-+)*+,# 03# .$%#

5%($-+*(/# 03# -# 3'%%# 5-'6%.# %(0+057W-+)# $0:# ,01%'+5%+.#

*+.%'1%+.*0+#*+#50+%7#-+)#2-+6*+,#('*&&;%/#.$%#(-&*.-;*/.#/7/.%5W

:%# (-+# )*-,+0/%# .$%# (-4/%/# 03# .0)-7C/# %(0+05*(# ('*/*/8# 9%# -;/0#

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????'

'

!"V#

4+)%'/.-+)#:$-.#54/.#2%#)0+%#.0#%+)#.$%#2005L24/.#(7(;%<#-+)#.$%#

.$'%-.#03#$7&%'*+3;-.*0+<#0+(%#-+)#30'#-;;8##

#

#########################################################1 Ludwig von Mises, Economic Freedom and Interventionism, p. 244. 2 For a very readable introduction, see Robert P. Murphy’s The Politically Incorrect Guide to Capitalism (Regnery, 2007). 3 Mises, The Theory of Money and Credit, p. 461. 4 See Hanke’s calculations at: http://www.cato.org/zimbabwe. Accessed May 20, 2010. 5 G. Edward Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island (Westlake Village, CA: American Media, 2002), pp. 187-188. 6 Quoted in Creature, p. 188. 7 Rothbard, The Case Against the Fed (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1994), pp. 62-63. 8 Robert P. Murphy, The Politically Incorrect Guide to the Great Depression and the New Deal (Washington, D.C.: Regnery, 2009). 9 These facts are cited in Murphy’s book on the Great Depression, though some are documented in his online article “The New Deal Was a Bad Deal,” August 10, 2009, at: http://www.publicsquare.net/article_new-deal-was-a-bad-deal-302.htm. Accessed June 3, 2010. 10 Herbert Hoover, The Memoirs of Herbert Hoover: The Great Depression, 1929-1941 (New York: The Macmillan Company, 1952), p. 29. 11 Herbert Hoover, quoted in Murray Rothbard, America’s Great Depression, Fifth Edition (U.S.A.: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2008), p. 321. 12 A. C. Miller, quoted in Lionel Robbins, The Great Depression (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2007 [1934]), p. 53. 13 John Kenneth Galbraith, quoted in G. Edward Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island, p. 425. 14 Letter from Benjamin Strong, quoted in G. Edward Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island, p. 426. 15 Thomas E. Woods, Jr., Meltdown:A Free-Market Look at Why the Stock Market Collapsed, the Economy Tanked, and Government Bailouts Will Make Things Worse (Washington, D.C.: Regnery, 2009), pp. 26-27.

!"#$%&'$&()*+,("%(+"&,)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#$

$

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

+"&(,-./0(1-/&2(,-3.%4-/(

$

$

!"#$%#$&'(%%$)*+#"(#,-.%'#"/+#&+.0$0,#(1#

"/+#$2+.#(1#%(302#&(0+4#$1#(0+#2(+%#0("#

-+.*$5+# "/."# $"# 6.%# 2+7$%+2# .%# .0#

$0%"-3&+0"# 1(-# "/+# '-("+8"$(0# (1# 8$7$*#

*$)+-"$+%# .,.$0%"# 2+%'("$8# $0-(.2%# (0#

"/+# '.-"# (1# ,(7+-0&+0"%9# !2+(*(,$8.**4#

$"# )+*(0,%# $0# "/+# %.&+# 8*.%%# 6$"/#

'(*$"$8.*# 8(0%"$"3"$(0%# .02# )$**%# (1#

-$,/"%9#

:;326$,#7(0#<$%+%=#

$$

%$ &'(%$ )%%*$ +&%$ ,%)+-./+01*$2-1.3&+$ 45$ 60'+$71*%5$

'*,$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*90*3:$ ;&%$ 14(01.)$ )18.+01*$ +1$ +&%$

<-148%7)$ 16$ -'7<'*+$ <-0/%$ 0*68'+01*$ '*,$ %/1*170/$ /-0)%)=$ 0)$ +1$

-%71(%$ <180+0/'8$ 0*+%-6%-%*/%$ 20+&$ +&%$ 0*)+0+.+01*)$ 16$ 71*%5$ '*,$

4'*90*3:$>&%*$71*%5$0)$1*/%$'3'0*$'$311,$<-1,./%,$45$+&%$7'-9%+=$

'*,$ 2&%*$ 4'*9%-)$ -%/%0(%$ *1$ )<%/0'8$ <-0(08%3%)$ %?%7<+0*3$ +&%7$

6-17$+&%0-$/1*+-'/+.'8$14803'+01*)=$<%1<8%$2088$1*/%$'3'0*$4%$'48%$+1$

8%'*$ &%'(085$ 1*$ '$ )+'48%$ 7%,0.7$ 16$ %?/&'*3%$ 61-$ +&%0-$ 60*'*/0'8$

<8'**0*3:$>%$2088$&'(%$'$%(302#&(0+4:$

>$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"!$

@)$A0)%)$%?<8'0*)$ 0*$+&%$B.1+'+01*$'41(%=$)1.*,$71*%5$2')$

'*$0*+%3-'8$<8'*9$0*$+&%$/8'))0/'8$804%-'8$<-13-'7:$C.)+$')$'$6-%%$<-%))$

0)$*%/%))'-5$61-$'$6-%%$/0+0D%*-5=$)1$+11$0)$)1.*,$71*%5$*%/%))'-5$61-$

'$ 6-%%$ %/1*175:$ @88$ 1+&%-$ ')<%/+)$ 16$ 2&'+$ 0)$ 7%'*+$ 45$ +&%$ +%-7$

E%/1*170/$ 6-%%,17F$ 0*$ /1*(%*+01*'8$ /0-/8%)G812$ +'?$ -'+%)=$ 708,$

-%3.8'+01*=$ *1$ +-',%$ 4'--0%-)G'-%$ '$711+$ <10*+$ 06$ +&%$ 31(%-*7%*+$

&')$'$<-0*+0*3$<-%))$'+$0+)$,0)<1)'8:$

H8+07'+%85=$ '$ )1/0%+5$ /'*$1*85$ -%+.-*$ +1$ )1.*,$71*%5$2&%*$

%*1.3&$ <%1<8%$ ,%7'*,$ 0+$ 16$ +&%0-$ 31(%-*7%*+:$ ;&'+$ 0)$ 2&5$

%,./'+01*$ 0)$ +&%$ 60-)+$ '*,$ 71)+$ 07<1-+'*+$ )+%<G<%1<8%$ *%%,$ +1$

.*,%-)+'*,$+&%$07<1-+'*/%$16$)1.*,$71*%5=$'*,$+&%$,'*3%-)$16$60'+$

71*%5$ '*,$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*90*3:$ I(%-51*%$9*12)$1.-$ /.--%*+$ 60*'*/0'8$

)5)+%7$ 0)$ )0/9=$ 4.+$ 1*85$ <%1<8%$ )+%%<%,$ 0*$@.)+-0'*$ %/1*170/)$ /'*$

166%-$+&%$/1--%/+$,0'3*1)0)$'*,$/.-%:$

H*61-+.*'+%85=$1.-$ 60*'*/0'8$ 6-%%,17$2')$%-1,%,$1(%-$7'*5$

,%/',%)J$ 0+$ 2')$ '$ )812$ <'+&$ +1$ 1.-$ /.--%*+$ /-0)0):$ ;&%-%$ '-%$ '8)1$

7'*5$<12%-6.8$<%1<8%$'*,$0*)+0+.+01*)$2&1$4%*%60+$6-17$+&%$)+'+.)$

B.1:$;&0)$7%'*)$ +&'+$.*20*,0*3$ +&%$31(%-*7%*+K)$ )+-'*38%&18,$1*$

1.-$ 71*%5$ '*,$ 4'*90*3$ )%/+1-$ 7'5$ +'9%$ 5%'-)$ 16$ '30+'+01*$ '*,$

<180+0/'8$-%61-7:$

;&%$ <-%)%*+$ 4119$ 0)$ *1+$ '$ <180+0/'8$ 7'*06%)+1:$ ;&%$ /.--%*+$

'.+&1-)$ ,1$ *1+$ <-%+%*,$ +1$ 4%$ <180+0/'8$ )+-'+%30)+)=$ 8%+$ '81*%$

-%(18.+01*'-5$ 8%',%-):$ L*$ +&%$ -%7'0*,%-$ 16$ +&0)$ /&'<+%-=$ 2%$ 166%-$

)17%$<-'/+0/'8$ ).33%)+01*)$ 61-$&12$1.-$ )1/0%+5$ /1.8,$71(%=$ 40+$ 45$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"M$

40+=$ 4'/9$ +12'-,)$ +&%$.8+07'+%$31'8$16$ /17<8%+%$ 6-%%,17$ 0*$71*%5$

'*,$4'*90*3$1*/%$'3'0*:$;&%-%$ 0)$*1+&0*3$7'30/'8$'41.+$ +&%$4%812$

<-1<1)'8)=$ %)<%/0'885$ 0*$ +&%0-$ <'-+0/.8'-$ ,%+'08):$ N.+$ +&%$ 6188120*3$

31'8)$ '-%$ 6-%B.%*+85$ -%/177%*,%,$ 45$ +&1)%$ 2&1$ .*,%-)+'*,$ +&%$

8%))1*)$16$+&%$@.)+-0'*$%/1*170)+):$

$

,%&$()5(+4&(%"&(67,7(8-33#'(9#:;(%-(<-30$

$

A0)%)$ 1*/%$ 2-1+%=$ EO1.*,$71*%5$ )+088$ 7%'*)$ +1,'5$2&'+$ 0+$

7%'*+$0*$+&%$*0*%+%%*+&$/%*+.-5P$+&%$318,$)+'*,'-,:F!$A'*5$16$A0)%)K$

618812%-)$ %*,1-)%$&0)$ -%/177%*,'+01*$ 0*$1.-$12*$ +07%$')$2%88:$ L6$

+&%$ H*0+%,$ O+'+%)$ 31(%-*7%*+$ 1660/0'885$ '**1.*/%,$ +&'+$ 0+$ 21.8,$

1*/%$'3'0*$-%,%%7$,188'-)$61-$<&5)0/'8$318,=$)./&$'$418,$71(%$21.8,$

0*)+'*+85$-%')).-%$0*(%)+1-)$+&%$21-8,$1(%-$+&'+$+&%$,188'-$2')$1*/%$

'3'0*$'$4%,-1/9$'))%+:$

@*1+&%-$(0-+.%$16$ +&0)$71(%$ 0)$ +&'+$ 0+$/1.8,$4%$ 07<8%7%*+%,$

'+$'$717%*+K)$*1+0/%:$;1$+0%$+&%$,188'-$4'/9$+1$318,$21.8,$-%B.0-%$*1$

*%2$<12%-)$1*$+&%$<'-+$16$+&%$31(%-*7%*+=$1-$%(%*$-%B.0-%$'*5$*%2$

8%30)8'+01*:$ O+-0/+85$ )<%'90*3=$ Q%,$ R&'0-7'*$ N%*$ N%-*'*9%$ /1.8,$

)07<85$'**1.*/%$+&'+$+&%$Q%,$21.8,$&'*,$1(%-$'*$1.*/%$16$318,$61-$

'$ )+0<.8'+%,$ *.74%-$ 16$ ,188'-)=$ '*,$ S8%))$ /-./0'885T$ +&'+$ &%$ 21.8,$

&'*,$ 1(%-$ '$ )+0<.8'+%,$ *.74%-$ 16$ ,188'-)$ 61-$ '*51*%$ )%880*3$ '*$

1.*/%$16$318,:$N%-*'*9%$&')$+&%$<12%-$+1$4.5$'*,$)%88$'))%+)=$'*,$&%$

21.8,$7%-%85$4%$'**1.*/0*3$0*$',('*/%$&0)$20880*3*%))$+1$)%88$S'*,$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"U$

4.5T$318,$'+$'$<'-+0/.8'-$,188'-V<-0/%:$W6$ /1.-)%=$ +1$30(%$ +&%$<8%,3%$

-%'8$ +%%+&=$ R1*3-%))$ 21.8,$ %(%*+.'885$ &'(%$ +1$ /1,065$ +&%$ *%2$

'--'*3%7%*+=$<%-&'<)$%(%*$)<%/0650*3$<%*'8+0%)$S)./&$')$077%,0'+%$

,0)70))'8T$61-$Q%,$1660/0'8)$)&1.8,$+&%5$%(%-$-%*%3%$1*$+&%$*%2$<%3:$

;&%$ <10*+$ 0)=$ &12%(%-=$ +&'+$ 2%$ 21.8,*K+$ *%%,$ +1$ 2'0+$ 61-$ '$

<-1+-'/+%,$'*,$7%81,-'7'+0/$R1*3-%))01*'8$4'++8%$)+1(-+$ -%)+1-0*3$

)'*0+5$+1$+&%$21-8,$60*'*/0'8$7'-9%+)$20+&$'$)+'48%$/.--%*/5:$

L*$ 1-,%-$ +1$ 30(%$ '$ /1*/-%+%$ %?'7<8%$ 16$ &12$ )./&$ '$ <180/5$

/1.8,$21-9=$ ).<<1)%$ +&'+$ N%-*'*9%$ /'88%,$ '$ <-%))$ /1*6%-%*/%$ '*,$

'**1.*/%,$ +&%$ 6188120*3$ S9%%<0*3$ 0*$ 70*,$ +&'+$ +&%$ 1660/0'885$

-%<1-+%,$ H:O:$ 318,$ -%)%-(%)$ 0*$ X%/%74%-$ !YYZ$ 2%-%$ '$ 80++8%$ 1(%-$

[=YYY$+1*)TMP$

EI66%/+0(%$ 077%,0'+%85=$ +&%$ Q%,%-'8$ \%)%-(%$ 2088$ 4%30*$ '$

<-13-'7$16$318,$'//.7.8'+01*=$<.-/&')0*3$#YY$+1*)$<%-$71*+&=$.*+08$

+1+'8$1660/0'8$-%)%-(%)$%B.'8$#]=YYY$+1*):$I(%-5$B.'-+%-$2%$2088$'8812$

1.+)0,%$ '.,0+1-)$ +1$ 0*)<%/+$ 1.-$ ('.8+)$ '*,$ (%-065$ 1.-$ &18,0*3):$

Q.-+&%-71-%=$ 0*$%?'/+85$ +2%8(%$71*+&)$2%$2088$<%3$ +&%$1*%V71*+&$

6.+.-%$<-0/%$16$318,$'+$^!=YYY$<%-$1.*/%:$@*5$<'-+5=$2&%+&%-$61-%03*$

/%*+-'8$ 4'*9=$ 61-%03*$ 31(%-*7%*+=$ 1-$ <-0('+%$ 0*,0(0,.'8G,17%)+0/$

1-$ 61-%03*G2088$ 4%$ 3.'-'*+%%,$ +&%$ '4080+5$ +1$ 14+'0*$ '*$ .*8070+%,$

B.'*+0+5$16$318,$ 6-17$+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%K)$&18,0*3)$'+$^!=YYY$<%-$

1.*/%=$ '*,$ +1$ )%88$ 318,$ +1$ +&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$ '+$ '$<-0/%$16$ ^!=YYY$

<%-$ 1.*/%=$ 8%))$ '$ )7'88$ +-'*)'/+01*$ 6%%:$ ;&0)$ <%3$ 2088$ -%7'0*$ '$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"]$

<%-7'*%*+$6%'+.-%$16$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$<180/5=$'*,$+&%$,188'-V<-0/%$16$

318,$2088$-%7'0*$61-%(%-$60?%,$'+$^!=YYY$<%-$1.*/%:F$

;1$ -%<%'+=$ +&%-%$ 0)$ *1+&0*3$ 7'30/'8$ '41.+$ +&%$ <'-+0/.8'-$

*.74%-)$ 0*$ 1.-$ &5<1+&%+0/'8$ )/%*'-01=$ 4.+$ &%-%$ 0)$ +&%$ 8130/$ 16$ +&%$

0,%'P$N5$)+%',085$0*/-%')0*3$0+)$318,$&18,0*3)=$+&%$Q%,$21.8,$418)+%-$

0+)$ '4080+5$ +1$ &1*1-$ 0+)$ /1770+7%*+$ +1$ +0%$ +&%$ ,188'-$ 4'/9$ +1$ +&%$

<-%/01.)$7%+'8:$ N5$ )%++0*3$ +&%$ <%3$ 2%88$ '41(%$ +&%$ /.--%*+$7'-9%+$

<-0/%$S'-1.*,$^#=#YY$')$16$+&0)$2-0+0*3T=$+&%$Q%,$21.8,$14(0'+%$+&%$

*%%,$ 61-$ '$ 3%*%-'8$ ,-1<$ 0*$ +&%$ ,188'-V<-0/%$ 16$ '88$ 1+&%-$ 311,)$ '*,$

)%-(0/%):$

L*$1+&%-$21-,)=$2&%*$ +&%$Q%,$4%30*)$ '$7'))0(%$<-13-'7$16$

4.50*3$'*$'))%+G0*/8.,0*3$318,G+&'+$ '))%+K)$<-0/%$2088$ -0)%:$ L6$ +&%$

Q%,$&',$'**1.*/%,=$)'5=$'$ +'-3%+$318,$<-0/%$16$^#=YYY$1-$^]YY$ 0*$'$

5%'-K)$+07%=$%(%*$')$0+)$7'))0(%$318,$<.-/&')%)$,-1(%$.<$+&%$-%8'+0(%$

<-0/%$16$318,$/17<'-%,$+1$1+&%-$311,)=$+&%*$'/&0%(0*3$+&%$812$+'-3%+$

21.8,$ 61-/%$ '$ 7'))0(%$ /188'<)%$ 0*$ +&%$ <-0/%$ 16$ %(%-5+&0*3$ %8)%$

S2&%-%$ +&%$<-0/%$ 0)$7%').-%,$ 0*$H:O:$,188'-)T:$N5$)%++0*3$ +&%$ +'-3%+$

2%88$ .)(7+$ +&%$ /.--%*+$ 7'-9%+$ <-0/%=$ +&%$ Q%,$ 21.8,$ '8812$ +&%$

',_.)+7%*+$ +1$ 8'-3%85$ 1//.-$ 0*$ +&%$ )<09%$ .<2'-,$ 0*$ +&%$ 318,$ <-0/%=$

-'+&%-$+&'*$'$8'-3%$,-1<$61-$%(%-5+&0*3$%8)%:$

@)$ +&%$71*+&)$<'))%,=$ '*,$ +&%$,%',80*%$'<<-1'/&%,$ 61-$ +&%$

Q%,$ +1$ 4%30*$ -%,%%70*3$ ,188'-)$ 61-$ 318,$ '+$ +&%$ )<%/060%,$ -'+%=$

N%-*'*9%$ '*,$ +&%$ -%)+$ 16$ +&%$ Q%,K)$ <180/57'9%-)$ 21.8,$ *%%,$ +1$

/'-%6.885$71*0+1-$ +&%0-$'/+0(0+0%):$`-%).7'485$ +&%$318,$<-0/%$21.8,$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!""$

,-06+$ .<2'-,)$ S06$ 0+$ &',$ *1+$ 077%,0'+%85$ _.7<%,$ .<$ '6+%-$ +&%$

'**1.*/%7%*+T$ +1$ ."# *+.%"# ^!=YYY$ <%-$ 1.*/%=$ 4%/'.)%$ 0+$ 21.8,$ 4%$

)0885$ 61-$ &18,%-)$ 16$ 318,$ +1$ )%88$ '+$ *+%%$ +&'*$ +&'+$ <-0/%=$ 2&%*$ +&%5$

9*%2$+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$21.8,$)11*$166%-$^!=YYY$<%-$1.*/%$+1$'*5$

)%88%-):$

W*$ +&%$1+&%-$&'*,=$ ).<<1)%$ +&'+$ +&-%%$71*+&)$1.+$ 6-17$+&%$

,%',80*%=$ +&%$ 7'-9%+$ <-0/%$ 16$ 318,$ 2%-%$ ^!=UYY:$ N%-*'*9%$ 21.8,$

-%'80D%$ +&'+$ )<%/.8'+1-)$ 21.8,$ 80*%$ .<$ '+$ +&%$ Q%,K)$ ,11-$

S7%+'<&1-0/'885$ )<%'90*3T$ 1*$ +&%$ ,'5$ +&%$ -%,%7<+01*$ <180/5$2%*+$

0*+1$%66%/+=$0*$1-,%-$+1$4.5$318,$6-17$+&%$Q%,$'+$^!=YYY$'*,$+&%*$)%88$

1*$ +&%$7'-9%+$ 61-$ ^!=UYY:$ ;&0)$21.8,$B.0/985$ ,-'0*$ +&%$ Q%,K)$ 318,$

&18,0*3)=$'*,$,%)+-15$+&%$Q%,K)$/-%,04080+5:$

;&%-%61-%=$06$+&%$Q%,$2%-%$)%-01.)$'41.+$-%)+1-0*3$6'0+&$0*$+&%$

,188'-a318,$ <%3=$ N%-*'*9%$ '*,$ +&%$ 1+&%-$ Q%,$ <180/57'9%-)$ 21.8,$

&'(%$+1$'/+$B.0/985$+1$3%+$+&%$318,$<-0/%$,12*:$b12$21.8,$+&%5$,1$

+&0)c$O07<8%P$+&%5$21.8,$&'(%$+1$+03&+%*$.<$1*$71*%+'-5$<180/5:$;&%$

)+'*,'-,$2'5$16$ ,10*3$ +&0)$ 0)$ +1$ )%88$ '))%+)$ 6-17$ +&%$Q%,K)$4'8'*/%$

)&%%+=$ 0*$1-,%-$ +1$,-'0*$-%)%-(%)$ 6-17$+&%$4'*90*3$)5)+%7:$ S;&0)$ 0)$

2&'+$ +&%$ Q%,$ ,1%)$ 2&%*$ 0+$ 2'*+)$ +1$ -'0)%$ 0*+%-%)+$ -'+%):T$ ;&%$

-%,./+01*$0*$-%)%-(%)$21.8,$61-/%$+&%$/177%-/0'8$4'*9)$+1$809%20)%$

-%)+-0/+$+&%0-$12*$8%*,0*3=$0*$1-,%-$+1$3%+$+&%0-$1.+)+'*,0*3$,%<1)0+$

4'8'*/%)$4'/9$ 0*$ 80*%$20+&$ +&%$)7'88%-$'71.*+$16$ -%)%-(%):$d11)%85$

)<%'90*3=$ 06$ +&%$ ,188'-V<-0/%$ 16$ 318,$2%-%$ '41(%$ +&%$ ^!=YYY$ +'-3%+=$

N%-*'*9%$21.8,$*%%,$+1$-%71(%$,188'-)$6-17$+&%$%/1*175:$@)$71-%$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"e$

318,$2')$4-1.3&+$0*+1$/0-/.8'+01*$+&-1.3&$70*0*3$S,.%$0*$<'-+$+1$+&%$

&03&$<-0/%)$/'.)%,$45$+&%$Q%,K)$<.-/&')%)T=$'*,$')$+&%$1.+)+'*,0*3$

'71.*+$16$,188'-)$)&-'*9$,.%$+1$ +&%$ +03&+%*%,$Q%,$<180/5=$ +&%*$+&%$

,188'-V<-0/%$16$318,$21.8,$6'88:$

L*$1.-$&5<1+&%+0/'8$)/%*'-01G0*$2&0/&$N%-*'*9%$'**1.*/%,$

&0)$0*+%*+01*$+1$-%+.-*$+1$'$)+-0/+$,188'-a318,$<%3$0*$1*%$5%'-K)$+07%=$

'*,$5%+$+&%$7'-9%+$-%)<1*,%,$45$<.)&0*3$+&%$<-0/%$16$318,$.)(7+$+&%$

'**1.*/%,$ +'-3%+G+&%$ Q%,$21.8,$ &'(%$ +1$ )%88$ 166$ 0+)$ 1+&%-$ '))%+)=$

)./&$')$H:O:$;-%').-5$,%4+$ '*,$ E+1?0/F$71-+3'3%V4'/9%,$ )%/.-0+0%)=$

0*$1-,%-$+1$7'9%$-117$61-$0+)$3-120*3$)+1/9<08%$16$318,$4.8801*:$L6$+&%$

318,$<-0/%$)+'5%,$'41(%$+&%$+'-3%+$16$^!=YYY=$N%-*'*9%$21.8,$&'(%$

+1$ )&-0*9$ +&%$1(%-'88$ )0D%$16$ +&%$Q%,K)$4'8'*/%$ )&%%+=$ 0*$ ',,0+01*$ +1$

/&'*30*3$0+)$/17<1)0+01*$+12'-,)$318,:$Q1-$%?'7<8%=$61-$%(%-5$^#YY$

708801*$0*$*%2$318,$+&'+$N%-*'*9%$<.-/&')%,=$&%$703&+$&'(%$+1$)%88$

166$ ^#!Y$ 708801*$ 21-+&$ 16$ ;-%').-5$ ,%4+$ 1-$ 71-+3'3%V4'/9%,$

)%/.-0+0%)$S2&0/&$+&%$Q%,$/.--%*+85$<1))%))%)$0*$'4.*,'*/%T:$

W*/%$ +&%$ ,%',80*%$ &',$ <'))%,=$ '*,$ ')).70*3$ +&%$ Q%,$ &',$

,1*%$0+)$_14$'*,$31++%*$+&%$7'-9%+$<-0/%$16$318,$,12*$+1$^!=YYY$<%-$

1.*/%=$ 0+$ 21.8,$ 61-%(%-$ 4%$ /1*)+-'0*%,$ 0*$ 0+)$ /-%'+01*$ 16$ *%2$

,188'-)G'+$ 8%')+$ 06$ 0+$ 2'*+%,$ +1$ 9%%<$ 0+)$ /-%,04080+5:$ W(%-$ +07%=$ ')$

0*(%)+1-)$ 14)%-(%,$ +&'+$ +&%5$ /1.8,$ 4.5$ 318,$ 6-17$ +&%$ Q%,$ '+$ +&%$

)+'+%,$<-0/%=$ +&%5$21.8,$4%/17%$6'-$71-%$/1*60,%*+$ 0*$ 0*(%)+0*3$ 0*$

,188'-V,%*170*'+%,$ '))%+):$ ;&%5$ 21.8,$ 9*12$ +&'+$ 2&'+%(%-$ %8)%$

&'<<%*%,=$+&%5$21.8,$&'(%$'$E/'88$1<+01*$1*$318,F$')$0+$2%-%=$')$<'-+$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"[$

16$ +&%0-$ ,%/0)01*$ +1$ &18,$ H:O:$ ,188'-):$ L*(%)+1-)$ 21.8,$ 9*12$ +&'+$

-%3'-,8%))$16$+&%$,188'-V<-0/%)$16$1+&%-$'))%+)=$+&%5$21.8,$'82'5)$4%$

'48%$ +1$ 4'08$ 1.+$ 16$ ,188'-)$ '*,$ 14+'0*$ <&5)0/'8$ 318,$ 4.8801*:$ ;&0)$

1<+01*$21.8,$ 30(%$ +&%$ ,188'-$ '*$ %*1-71.)$ ',('*+'3%$ 1(%-$ +&%$ 60'+$

/.--%*/0%)$ 0)).%,$ 45$ 1+&%-$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*9)=$ 7'90*3$ +&%$ ,188'-$

'<<-%/0'+%$ '3'0*$ +&%$ %.-1=$ 5%*=$ %+/:=$ 5%'-$ '6+%-$ 5%'-$ 1*$ +&%$ 61-%03*$

%?/&'*3%):$ L*+%-%)+$ -'+%)$1*$,%4+$ 0)).%,$45$@7%-0/'*$/1-<1-'+01*)$

21.8,$6'88=$')$0*(%)+1-)$'-1.*,$+&%$21-8,$9*%2$+&'+$+&%$,188'-$21.8,$

4%$)+-1*3%-$S-%8'+0(%$+1$+&%0-$12*$/.--%*/0%)T$2&%*$+&%0-$81'*)$2%-%$

-%<'0,J$ +&%-%61-%$ +&%5$21.8,$ 4%$20880*3$ +1$ '//%<+$ '$ 812%-$ 0*+%-%)+$

-'+%$ ')$B.1+%,$ 0*$,188'-):$@7%-0/'*$4.)0*%))%)$'*,$ /1*).7%-)=$ 61-$

+&%0-$<'-+=$21.8,$60*,$+&'+$ 61-%03*$311,)$21.8,$4%/17%$/&%'<%-$+1$

4.5$ 1(%-$ +&%$ 5%'-)=$ ')$ +&%0-$ ,188'-)K$ <.-/&')0*3$ <12%-$ /1*)+'*+85$

3-%2$ -%8'+0(%$ +1$ %(%-5$ 1+&%-$ 21-8,$ /.--%*/5:$ I(%*$ 1*$ '$ <.-%85$

,17%)+0/$ 6-1*+=$ +&%$<-0/%)$16$@7%-0/'*$311,)$'*,$)%-(0/%)$ SB.1+%,$

0*$,188'-)T$21.8,$4%$)+'48%$1-$'/+.'885$/1.8,$3%*+85$6'88$5%'-$+1$5%'-=$

4%/'.)%$+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$/1.8,$1*85$/-%'+%$'$ 8070+%,$*.74%-$16$

*%2$,188'-)$,.%$+1$+&%$7'0*+%*'*/%$16$+&%$<%3$+1$318,:$

;&%$ -%')1*$ 61-$ +&%$ -%*%2%,$ 21-8,20,%$ /1*60,%*/%$ 0*$ +&%$

,188'-$21.8,$4%$ )07<8%P$W+&%-$ /%*+-'8$4'*9)=$20+&1.+$&'(0*3$'$<%3$

<0**0*3$,12*$+&%$<.-/&')0*3$<12%-$16$ +&%0-$-%)<%/+0(%$/.--%*/0%)=$

21.8,$4%$6-%%$+1$<-0*+$71*%5$2&%*%(%-$'$/-0)0)$)+-./9:$;&%$Q%,%-'8$

\%)%-(%=$0*$/1*+-')+=$.*,%-$+&%$*%2$<180/5$21.8,$&'(%$0+)$&'*,)$+0%,:$

L+$ /1.8,$ 1*85$ %?<'*,$ +&%$ ).<<85$ 16$ ,188'-)$ ')$ *%2$ 318,$ /'7%$ 0*+1$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!"Z$

/0-/.8'+01*$ S+&-1.3&$70*0*3$1-$7%8+0*3$,12*$16$ _%2%8-5T=$1-$')$ +&%$

,%7'*,$ 61-$ 318,$ 6%88=$ +21$ 6'/+1-)$2&0/&$21.8,$ +%*,$ +1$ <.)&$,12*$

+&%$318,$<-0/%:$N.+$%?/%<+$20+&0*$+&'+$*'--12$8070+=$+&%$Q%,$/1.8,*K+$

%?<'*,$+&%$).<<85$16$,188'-)$+11$B.0/985=$4%/'.)%$06$0+$,0,$+&%$,188'-V

<-0/%$ 16$ 318,$ 21.8,$ ).-3%$ '41(%$ ^!=YYY$ <%-$ 1.*/%=$ '*,$ <%1<8%$

21.8,$+-',%$+&%0-$<'<%-$,188'-)$61-$<&5)0/'8$318,$'*,$4%30*$,-'0*0*3$

+&%$Q%,K)$-%)%-(%):$

f'+.-'885=$ 0+$ 21.8,$ 4%$ (%-5$ .*809%85$ +&'+$ Q%,%-'8$ \%)%-(%$

1660/0'8)$ 21.8,$ &'<<085$ ).470+$ +1$ +&%$ '41(%$ )/%*'-01:$ L+$ 0)$ 0*$ +&%$

*'+.-%$ 16$ 4.-%'./-'/0%)$ +1$ %?<'*,$ +&%0-$ )/1<%$ 16$ '-40+-'-5$ <12%-=$

'*,$+1$-%)%*+$'*5$/1*)+-'0*+):$L*$1-,%-$+1$7'9%$0*(%)+1-)$4%80%(%$0*$

+&%$ *%2$ ,188'-a318,$ <%3=$ R1*3-%))$ 21.8,$ *%%,$ +1$ /1,065$ +&%$

'--'*3%7%*+$20+&$ )+066$ <%*'8+0%)$ 61-$ +&%$Q%,K)$ '4'*,1*7%*+$ 16$ +&%$

<8%,3%:$ I(%*$ 0*$ +&'+$ /')%=$ 0*(%)+1-)$ 21.8,*K+$ -+.**4$ +'9%$ +&%$ Q%,$

)%-01.)85$ .*+08$ +&%$ 60-)+$7'_1-$ /-0)0)=$ 0*$2&0/&$ +&%$ E18,$ Q%,F$21.8,$

&'(%$/.+$0*+%-%)+$-'+%)$'*,$<.7<%,$0*$41'+81',)$16$*%2$E80B.0,0+5=F$

2&%-%')$ +&%$ E*%2$ Q%,F$ -%)<1*,%,$ 7./&$ 71-%$ /1*)%-('+0(%85$ 61-$

6%'-$16$.*8%')&0*3$+11$7'*5$*%2$,188'-):$

;1$ -%0+%-'+%=$ 7%-%85$ -%0*+-1,./0*3$ '$ 318,$ )+'*,'-,$ 61-$ +&%$

H:O:$,188'-$21.8,$*1+$%8070*'+%$1.-$ 60*'*/0'8$21%):$N.+$ 0+$21.8,$4%$

'*$ %?/%88%*+$ 60-)+$ )+%<G<'-+0/.8'-85$ '70,)+$ 1.-$ /.--%*+$21-8,20,%$

/-0)0)G'*,$ 0*$ <-0*/0<8%$ +&%$ Q%,%-'8$ \%)%-(%$ /1.8,$ 07<8%7%*+$ +&0)$

)+-'+%35$077%,0'+%85:$

$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!eY$

,%&$(=5(>'4?#%4@&(1-/&2(#/0(9#/;4/A$

$

L*$ 1-,%-$ +1$ 7'9%$ )%*)%$ 16$ +&%$ O1.*,$ A1*%5$ O18.+01*=$ '*$

'*'8135$2088$4%$.)%6.8:$O.<<1)%$0+$0)$+&%$%'-85$#[YY)=$'*,$'$O1.+&%-*$

<8'*+'+01*$ 12*%-$ &')$ ,0%,$ 0*$ &0)$ 18,$ '3%=$ 8%'(0*3$ &0)$ %)+'+%$ +1$ &0)$

',.8+$/&08,-%*$S+&%$206%$&'(0*3$,0%,$%'-80%-T:$f12$<'-+$16$+&%$%)+'+%$

0*/8.,%)$ ,1D%*)$ 16$ )8'(%)=$2&0/&$ '-%$ -%/13*0D%,$ 0*$ +&%$ %5%)$ 16$ +&%$

8'2$')$E<-1<%-+5:F$b12%(%-=$+&%$/&08,-%*$&'(%$'88$-%',$+&%$2-0+0*3)$

16$ +&%$ '4180+01*0)+)=$ '*,$ '-%$ /1*(0*/%,$ +&'+$ )8'(%-5$ 2')$ '$ 71-'8$

1.+-'3%:$>&'+$)&1.8,$+&%5$,1c$

W*%$16$ +&%$ /&08,-%*$ ).33%)+)$ +&'+$ +&%5$ 077%,0'+%85$ 6-%%$ +&%$

)8'(%)=$ +&%*$ 80B.0,'+%$ +&%$ -%7'0*0*3$ '))%+)$ +1$ 30(%$ )17%$71*%5$ +1$

+&%$61-7%-$)8'(%)$+1$&%8<$+&%7$)+'-+$+&%0-$*%2$806%$16$6-%%,17:$;&0)$

)1.*,)$ 809%$'$ 3-%'+$ 0,%'=$.*+08$ 1*%$16$ +&%$ /&08,-%*$21--0%)$ +&'+$ +&%$

806%+07%$16$,%<%*,%*/5$7'5$*1+$&'(%$%B.0<<%,$+&%$)8'(%)$+1$7'9%$0+$

1*$+&%0-$12*:$@6+%-$'88=$+&%5$&'(%$&',$+&%0-$4')0/$*%%,)$+'9%*$/'-%$16=$

'*,$0+$703&+$'/+.'885$4%$.*90*,$+1$)07<85$,.7<$+&%7$0*+1$+&%$21-8,$

20+&$)17%$,188'-)$'*,$'$&'*,)&'9%:$

Q0*'885$+&%$/&08,-%*$&0+$.<1*$'*$%B.0+'48%$)18.+01*P$;&%5$2088$

077%,0'+%85$6-%%$'88$+&%$)8'(%)=$')$4%61-%:$b12%(%-=$+&%$/&08,-%*$2088$

/1*+0*.%$+1$-.*$+&%$<8'*+'+01*=$'*,$2088$166%-$%7<8157%*+$+1$'*5$16$

+&%$ 61-7%-$)8'(%)$2&1$20)&$ +1$-%7'0*:$ L*$1+&%-$21-,)=$'*5$ 61-7%-$

)8'(%$ 2&1$ 20)&%)$ +1$ E1<+$ 1.+F$ '*,$ )+'-+$ '$ *%2$ 806%$ 0)$ 6-%%$ +1$ 31=$

077%,0'+%85:$N.+=$61-$+&1)%$2&1$'-%$*1+$-%',5$61-$)./&$'$)&1/9=$+&%5$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!e#$

/'*$-%7'0*$1*$ +&%$<8'*+'+01*=$21-90*3$ 61-$ 611,=$)&%8+%-=$'*,$)1$1*:$

X.-0*3$+&%$20*,0*3$,12*$<%-01,=$ +&%$/&08,-%*$21.8,$,1$2&'+$ +&%5$

/1.8,$ +1$ <-%<'-%$ +&%$ 61-7%-$ )8'(%)$ 61-$ '*$ 0*,%<%*,%*+$ 806%=$ 45$

+%'/&0*3$ +&%7$ +1$ -%',=$ 9%%<$ +-'/9$ 16$ 71*%5=$ '*,$ )1$ 61-+&:$ ;&%$

.8+07'+%$ 31'8$ 21.8,$ 4%$ +1$ %)+'480)&$ '88$ 16$ +&%$ 61-7%-$ )8'(%)$ ')$

0*,%<%*,%*+$7%74%-)$16$ +&%$ /177.*0+5=$ 4.+$ +&0)$ '<<-1'/&$21.8,$

+'9%$0*$+&%$-%'80+0%)$16$+&%$8%3'/5$16$)8'(%-5:$

>%$ 0*$ +&%$H*0+%,$ O+'+%)$ 6'/%$ '$ )0708'-$ )0+.'+01*$ 0*$ +%-7)$ 16$

1.-$ 60*'*/0'8$ )5)+%7:$ ;&-1.3&$ ,%/%0+$ '*,$ 1.+-03&+$ 61-/%=$ +&%$

31(%-*7%*+$ &')$ +'9%*$ /1*+-18$ 16$ 1.-$ 71*%+'-5$ '*,$ 4'*90*3$

0*)+0+.+01*):$ L*$ -%/13*0+01*$ 16$ +&0)$ (018'+01*$ 16$ <-1<%-+5$ -03&+)=$ 1*%$

14(01.)$ )18.+01*$ 21.8,$ 4%$ '*$ 077%,0'+%$ '4180+01*$ 16$ +&%$ %*+0-%$

Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$'<<'-'+.):$

b12%(%-=$7'*5$<-0('+%$)%/+1-$0*)+0+.+01*)$'-1.*,$+&%$21-8,$

&'(%$ 4%/17%$ ,%<%*,%*+$ 1*$ +&%$ /.--%*+$ '--'*3%7%*+:$ L6$ +&%$

`-%)0,%*+$ 16$ +&%$ H*0+%,$ O+'+%)$ 2%-%$ +1$ '**1.*/%$ 1*$ '$ A1*,'5$

71-*0*3$ +&'+$&%$'*,$R1*3-%))$21.8,$'4180)&$ +&%$Q%,$ +&'+$2%%9=$ 0+$

703&+$.*8%')&$'$3814'8$<'*0/:$>0+&$+&%$6'+%$16$+&%$21-8,$%/1*175$)1$

0*+07'+%85$ +0%,$ +1$ +&%$ H:O:$ ,188'-=$ )./&$ '$ 4174)&%88$ /1.8,$ 2-%'9$

&'(1/$ 1*$ +&%$ (%-5$ <%1<8%$ 2&1$ 2%-%$ 4%0*3$ 6-%%,$ 6-17$ 60*'*/0'8$

41*,'3%$+1$+&%$H:O:$/%*+-'8$4'*9:$

L*$ 803&+$ 16$ +&%)%$ .*61-+.*'+%$ -%'80+0%)=$ '$ /17<-170)%$ <'+&$

703&+$ 4%$ +&%$ 4%)+$ 1<+01*:$ @)$ 20+&$ 1.-$ &5<1+&%+0/'8$ /&08,-%*$

0*&%-0+0*3$ +&%$<8'*+'+01*=$ +&%$H:O:$31(%-*7%*+$21.8,$30(%$ +&%$-03&+$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!e!$

16$077%,0'+%$E1<+0*3$1.+F$+1$'*5$4'*9$1-$1+&%-$60*'*/0'8$0*)+0+.+01*:$

L*$<-'/+0/%=$+&0)$21.8,$7%'*$+&%$077%,0'+%$'4180+01*$16$8%3'8$+%*,%-$

8'2)=$ +&%$ %8070*'+01*$ 16$ /'<0+'8$ 3'0*)$ +'?%)$ 1*$ 318,$ '*,$ )08(%-$ S+1$

6'/080+'+%$+&%0-$.)%$')$'8+%-*'+%$61-7)$16$71*%5T=$'*,$1<%*0*3$.<$+&%$

4'*90*3$)%/+1-$+1$*%2$%*+-'*+):$L*$)&1-+=$+&%$31(%-*7%*+$21.8,$4%$

'-$7."$5$0,$ 71*%5$ '*,$ 4'*90*3=$ -%+.-*0*3$ +&%7$ 1*/%$ '3'0*$ +1$ +&%$

6-%%$7'-9%+:$

L*$ +&%$ 7%'*+07%=$ +&%$ Q%,%-'8$ \%)%-(%$ 21.8,$ /1*+0*.%$ +1$

1<%-'+%=$ %*3'30*3$ 0*$ 1<%*$ 7'-9%+$ 1<%-'+01*)=$ 4.50*3$ '*,$ )%880*3$

'))%+)=$ '*,$)1$ 61-+&:$;&1)%$4'*9)$ +&'+$20)&%,$ +1$ -%7'0*$.*,%-$ +&%$

.74-%88'$16$+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$O5)+%7$/1.8,$,1$)1=$4.+$1+&%-$4'*9)$

21.8,$ &'(%$ +&%$ 6-%%,17$ +1$ 8%'(%:$ @*,$ 16$ /1.-)%=$ 06$ %*+-%<-%*%.-)$

2'*+%,$+1$)+'-+$0+6$4'*9)=$<%-&'<)$1*%)$+&'+$,%'8+$%?/8.)0(%85$20+&$

318,$,%<1)0+)$'*,$7'0*+'0*%,$#YYg$-%)%-(%)$1*$/&%/90*3$'//1.*+)$

S,%*170*'+%,$ 0*$ 318,T=$ +&%*$ +&%-%$ 21.8,$ 4%$ *1$ 31(%-*7%*+$

14)+'/8%)=$%?/%<+$61-$+&%$)+'*,'-,$%*61-/%7%*+$16$8%3'8$/1*+-'/+):$

;&%$ '<<%'8$ 16$ +&0)$ 3-',.'80)+$ '<<-1'/&$ 0)$ +&'+$ 0+$ 70*070D%)$

+&%$ )&1/9$ 16$ +-'*)0+01*0*3$ +1$ '$ 6-%%$ 60*'*/0'8$ )5)+%7=$ 2&08%$ '+$ +&%$

)'7%$+07%$%*,0*3$+&%$0771-'8$71*1<185:$>0+&$+&%$-%71('8$16$8%3'8$

+%*,%-$ 8'2)$ '*,$ 1+&%-$ -%)+-0/+01*)$ 1*$ '8+%-*'+%$71*%5=$ 1*85$ +&1)%$

7%-/&'*+)$2&1$20)&%,$ +1$.)%$ +&%$H:O:$,188'-$21.8,$,1$ )1:$@+$ 60-)+=$

<-%).7'485$ 1*85$ +&%$ 0,%18130/'885$ /&'-3%,$ %8%7%*+)$ 16$ @7%-0/'*$

)1/0%+5$21.8,$4%30*$/1*,./+0*3$ +&%0-$1<%-'+01*)$ 0*$318,$1.*/%)=$')$

1<<1)%,$ +1$ H:O:$ ,188'-):$ ;&0)$ 0)$ 4%/'.)%$ 16$ +&%$ 0*+%-+0'G20+&$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!eM$

%(%-51*%$%8)%$0*$+&%$/1.*+-5$)+088$.)0*3$,188'-)=$0+$21.8,$4%$,0660/.8+$

+1$-.*$'$4.)0*%))$1*$'*$'8+%-*'+%$.*0+$16$'//1.*+:$I(%*$)1=$1(%-$+07%$

71-%$ '*,$71-%$<%1<8%$ <-14'485$6(3*2$2%'*$ +&%7)%8(%)$ 6-17$ +&%$

,188'-=$ )20+/&0*3$ +1$ '$ 7'-9%+V4')%,$ &'-,$ 71*%5$ )./&$ ')$ 318,$ 1-$

)08(%-:$ ;&0)$ 21.8,$ 7'9%$ +&%$ %*+0-%$ )1/0%+5$ 8%))$ (.8*%-'48%$ +1$ +&%$

'/+01*)$16$ +&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%=$ -%,./0*3$ +&%$ E)&1/9)F$ 6-17$ 6.-+&%-$

<180/5$/&'*3%):$

$

,%&$(B5(C/0(%"&(D&0$

$

@6+%-$+&%$,188'-$&',$4%%*$1*/%$'3'0*$+0%,$4'/9$+1$318,G'*,$

%*1.3&$+07%$&',$<'))%,$61-$0*(%)+1-)$'-1.*,$+&%$21-8,$+1$4%80%(%$0*$

+&%$*%2$'--'*3%7%*+G'*,$+&%-%$2')$'$+&-0(0*3$*%+21-9$16$<-0('+%$

4'*9)$ 1<%-'+0*3$ )0,%V45V)0,%$ +&%$ 31(%-*7%*+V)<1*)1-%,$ )5)+%7=$

+&%$60*'8$)+%<$0*$+&%$O1.*,$A1*%5$O18.+01*$21.8,$4%$+1$'4180)&$+&%$

Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$ 0+)%86:$ L*$&0)$4119$?02# "/+#@+2$\1*$`'.8$ )<%88)$1.+$

+&'+$1.-$/.--%*+$60*'*/0'8$)5)+%7$0)$.*+%*'48%$'*,$+&%*$%?<8'0*)P$

$;&%-%$ 0)$ '*1+&%-$ <'+&=$ 4.+$ 0+$ -%B.0-%)$ '$ /17<8%+%$

+.-*'-1.*,:$ L+$ -%B.0-%)$ 1*85$ +&%$ <180+0/'8$ 2088$ +1$ .*<8.3$ +&%$

7'/&0*%-5$ 16$ +&%$ Q%,:$ R1*+-'-5$ +1$ 2&'+$ <%1<8%$ 703&+$ +&0*9$ '+$

60-)+=$ +&0)$ 2088$ *1+$ 7%'*$ '*$ %*,$ +1$ +&%$ 60*'*/0'8$ )5)+%7$ ')$ 2%$

9*12$0+:$L*$'$<1)+VQ%,$21-8,=$2%$2088$)+088$&'(%$+&%$,188'-=$4'*9)=$

@;A)=$1*80*%$+-',0*3=$>%4V4')%,$)5)+%7)$16$6.*,$+-'*)6%-G*1*%$

16$+&0)$0)$310*3$'*52&%-%h:$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!eU$

>&%*$ 2%$ .*<8.3$ +&%$ Q%,=$ +&%$ ,188'-$ 2088$ )+1<$ 0+)$ 81*3$

,%<-%/0'+0*3$ +-%*,=$ 0*+%-*'+01*'8$ /.--%*/5$ ('8.%)$ 2088$ )+1<$

68./+.'+0*3$ 208,85=$ 4'*90*3$ 2088$ *1$ 81*3%-$ 4%$ '$ ,0/%$ 3'7%=$ '*,$

60*'*/0'8$ <12%-$2088$ /%')%$ +1$ 3-'(0+'+%$ +12'-,$ '$ )7'88$ /0-/8%$ 16$

31(%-*7%*+V/1**%/+%,$ 0*)0,%-):$ ;&%$ %*+0-%$ 4'*90*3$ 0*,.)+-5$

21.8,$ .*,1.4+%,85$ 31$ +&-1.3&$ '*$ .<&%'('8$ 16$ )1-+)$ ')$ )1.*,$

4'*9)$ +&-0(%$ '*,$ .*)1.*,$ 4'*9)$ 31$ +&%$2'5$ 16$ +&%$ 0*(%)+7%*+$

4'*90*3$ 0*,.)+-5$ i0*$ !YY[jP$ 1.+$ 16$ 4.)0*%))$ ')$ +&%5$ )&1.8,$ 4%:$

;&1)%$2&1$'-%$,%<%*,%*+$1*$Q%,$2%86'-%$21.8,$&'(%$+1$/8%'*$.<$

+&%0-$ '/+$ 1-$ )&.+$ ,12*:$ X%<1)0+1-)$ 21.8,$ 4%/17%$ 0*+%*)%85$

'2'-%$16$2&0/&$4'*9)$'-%$)1.*,$'*,$2&0/&$'-%$*1+:U$$

@)$20+&$O+%<$#=$ +&%$)<%/060/$,%+'08)$16$O+%<$M$'-%$4%51*,$ +&%$

)/1<%$16$+&%$<-%)%*+$4119:$N.+$+1$<-1(0,%$'$3%*%-'8$)9%+/&=$)&.++0*3$

,12*$ +&%$ Q%,$ /1.8,$ 1//.-$ 0*$ +&%$ 6188120*3$ <1))048%$7'**%-P$ Q0-)+$

+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$21.8,$-%+.-*$0+)$&18,0*3)$16$31(%-*7%*+$,%4+G

')$16$+&0)$2-0+0*3$('8.%,$'+$êee$408801*]G+1$+&%$;-%').-5=$/'*/%80*3$

0+$1.+:$ SL*$1+&%-$21-,)=$ +&0)$<1-+01*$16$Q%,$'))%+)$21.8,$,0)'<<%'-=$

4.+$ )07.8+'*%1.)85$ +&%$ 6%,%-'8$ ,%4+$ 21.8,$ )&-0*9$ 45$ +&%$ )'7%$

'71.*+:T$ ;&0)$ '/+01*$ 21.8,$ *1+$ /&'*3%$ +&%$ '71.*+$ 16$ ,188'-$

-%)%-(%)$ 0*$ +&%$ 60*'*/0'8$ )5)+%7=$4%/'.)%$ +&%$Q%,$21.8,$ )07<85$4%$

2-0+0*3$166$+&%$81'*)$+1$H*/8%$O'7=$-%/1-,0*3$0+$')$'$81))$0*$+&%$Q%,K)$

E%B.0+5:F$

O%/1*,=$ +&%$ Q%,$21.8,$ )%88$ 166$ '88$ 16$ 0+)$ 1+&%-$ '))%+)=$ %?/%<+$

318,=$ '*,$ .)%$ +&%$ <-1/%%,)$ +1$ ',,$ +1$ 0+)$ 318,$ &18,0*3):$ L*$ 1+&%-$

21-,)=$'6+%-$60-)+$).4+-'/+0*3$1.+$+&%$31(%-*7%*+$41*,)=$+&%$)0D%$16$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!e]$

+&%$ Q%,K)$ 4'8'*/%$ )&%%+$ 21.8,$ +&%*$ -%7'0*$ +&%$ )'7%=$ 4.+$ +&%$

/17<1)0+01*$21.8,$/&'*3%$+1$/1*)0)+$%*+0-%85$16$318,$-%)%-(%):$

;&0-,=$ +&%$ Q%,$ 21.8,$ <-0*+$ .<$ /.--%*/5$ '*,$ 30(%$ 0+$ +1$ '*5$

4'*9)$ )+088$ &18,0*3$ %8%/+-1*0/$ ,188'-$ -%)%-(%)$ 1*$ ,%<1)0+$ 20+&$ +&%$

Q%,=$ +&%*$ 0+$21.8,$ /81)%$ +&1)%$ '//1.*+):$ L*$ 1+&%-$21-,)=$ '88$ 16$ +&%$

/177%-/0'8$ 4'*9)$ 21.8,$ E20+&,-'2F$ +&%0-$ /')&$ 6-17$ /&%/90*3$

'//1.*+)$ 20+&$ +&%$ Q%,=$ 4%61-%$ /81)0*3$ ,12*$ +&%$ '//1.*+):$ ;&0)$

<-1/%,.-%$21.8,$*1+$'66%/+$+&%$+1+'8$'71.*+$16$,188'-$-%)%-(%)$0*$+&%$

60*'*/0'8$)5)+%7=$0+$21.8,$)07<85$/&'*3%$+&%$/17<1)0+01*$+1$/1*)0)+$

%*+0-%85$ 16$ <'<%-$ /.--%*/5:$ L*)+%',$ 16$ 9%%<0*3$ '$ <1-+01*$ 16$ +&%0-$

,188'-$ -%)%-(%)$ <'-9%,$ '+$ +&%$ Q%,$ %8%/+-1*0/'885=$ +&%$ /177%-/0'8$

4'*9)$21.8,$&'(%$'88$16$+&%0-$,188'-)$0*$+&%$61-7$16$3-%%*$<0%/%)$16$

<'<%-$)+1-%,$0*$+&%0-$12*$('.8+):$

Q0*'885=$ +&%$ Q%,$21.8,$ +-'*)6%-$ 0+)$ 318,$ &18,0*3)$ +1$ +&%$H:O:$

;-%').-5=$2&0/&$21.8,$ +&%*$')).7%$-%)<1*)04080+5$ 61-$ 0)).0*3$*%2$

<'<%-$/.--%*/5$'*,$&1*1-0*3$+&%$,188'-a318,$<%3:$@+$ +&0)$<10*+$ +&%$

Q%,$21.8,$&'(%$*1$ -18%$ 8%6+$ +1$ <8'5=$ '*,$ /1.8,$ )&.+$ ,12*$20+&1.+$

,0)-.<+0*3$+&%$60*'*/0'8$7'-9%+):$

;&%$ '41(%$ 61.-V<-1*3%,$ <-1/%,.-%$ 61-$ <&')0*3$ 1.+$ +&%$

Q%,%-'8$ \%)%-(%$ 0)$ *1+$ 0*+%*,%,$ ')$ '$ 48.%<-0*+$ 61-$ -%61-7:$ N%61-%$

%74'-90*3$1*$)./&$'$<8'*=$14(01.)85$'/',%70/$%/1*170)+)=$ ')$2%88$

')$ %?<%-0%*/%,$ 60*'*/0'8$ <8'5%-)=$ 21.8,$ *%%,$ +1$ &'(%$ 81*3$

,0)/.))01*)$ '41.+$ +&%$ <-1)$ '*,$ /1*)$ 16$ ('-01.)$ <-1/%,.-%):$ ;&%$

07<1-+'*+$<10*+$ 0)$ +&'+$%8070*'+0*3$ +&%$Q%,$ $%$<1))048%=$ '*,$ 0+$*%%,$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!e"$

*1+$-.0*$+&%$,188'-$1-$+&%$21-8,$%/1*175:$@6+%-$'88=$+&%$,188'-$%?0)+%,$

81*3$4%61-%$+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%=$2&0/&$2')$*1+$/-%'+%,$.*+08$#Z#M:$

$

EF(+"4F(>-FF4G3&HI$

$

A'*5$-%',%-)$7'5$.*,%-)+'*,$+&%$31'8)$16$+&%$O1.*,$A1*%5$

O18.+01*=$4.+$2088$,0)70))$+&%7$')$&1<%8%))85$.*'++'0*'48%:$L+K)$+-.%=$

+&%-%$'-%$7'*5$14)+'/8%)$1*$+&%$<'+&$+1$'$6-%%$7'-9%+$0*$71*%5$'*,$

4'*90*3:$;&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$O5)+%7$,0,*K+$_.)+$)<-0*3$0*+1$<8'/%$45$

'//0,%*+G<12%-6.8$<%1<8%$0*)+'88%,$0+=$'*,$3.0,%,$0+)$,%(%81<7%*+=$

4%/'.)%$+&%5$4%*%60+$&'*,)17%85$6-17$0+k$

f1*%+&%8%))=$+&%$Q%,%-'8$\%)%-(%$0)$'$/-%'+01*$16$+&%$6%,%-'8$

31(%-*7%*+=$'*,$0+$/'*$4%$'4180)&%,$+&-1.3&$+&%$<180+0/'8$<-1/%))=$)1$

81*3$')$%*1.3&$/0+0D%*)$,%7'*,$0+:$;&%-%$0)$&0)+1-0/'8$<-%/%,%*+$61-$

)./&$-%61-7=$*'7%85$2&%*$`-%)0,%*+$@*,-%2$C'/9)1*$'4180)&%,$+&%$

O%/1*,$ N'*9$ 16$ +&%$ H*0+%,$ O+'+%)=$ +&%$ <-%,%/%))1-$ 16$ +&%$ Q%,%-'8$

\%)%-(%:$ @6+%-$ (%+10*3$ '$ 7%').-%$ +1$ -%/&'-+%-$ +&%$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*9G

2&0/&$2')$-.*$45$+&%$/-'6+5$'*,$<12%-6.8$f0/&18')$N0,,8%GC'/9)1*$

4')%,$ &0)$ -%V%8%/+01*$ /'7<'03*$ 1*$ +&0)$ /%*+-'8$ 0)).%:$ @//1-,0*3$ +1$

C'/91*K)$4013-'<&%-P$

$W*$ &0)$ &17%2'-,$ _1.-*%5$ i`-%)0,%*+$ C'/9)1*j$

-%<1-+%,85$<'0,$'88$&0)$%?<%*)%)$0*$318,:$Ef1$71-%$<'<%-$71*%5=$

51.$)%%=$6%8812$/0+0D%*)=F$&%$-%7'-9%,$20+&$%'/&$318,$<'57%*+=$E06$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!ee$

L$/'*$1*85$<.+$,12*$+&0)$f0/&18')$N0,,8%$'*,$&0)$71*)+%-$4'*9:F$

l18,=$&'-,85$+&%$<1<.8'-$7%,0.7$16$%?/&'*3%=$2')$&%8,$.<$+1$+&%$

<%1<8%$ ')$ +&%$ )'6%$ '*,$ )1.*,$ /.--%*/5$ 2&0/&$ C'/9)1*$ '*,$ &0)$

',70*0)+-'+01*$ &1<%,$ +1$ -%)+1-%$ +1$ -%3.8'-$ .)%:$ H*809%$ <'<%-$

71*%5=$ 318,$ -%<-%)%*+%,$ -%'8$ ('8.%$ '*,$ +-.%$21-+&:$ L+$ 2')$ +&%$

/10*$ 16$ &1*%)+$ 7%*:$ \'3$ 71*%5=$ 1*$ +&%$ 1+&%-$ &'*,=$ 2')$ +&%$

0*)+-.7%*+$ 16$ 4'*9)$ '*,$ )20*,8%-)$ +1$ /1--.<+$ '*,$ /&%'+$ '*$

0**1/%*+$'*,$(0-+.1.)$<.480/:"$

$

;&%$/1*+%)+$4%+2%%*$C'/9)1*$'*,$N0,,8%$0)$'$6')/0*'+0*3$1*%:$

@8+&1.3&$ C'/9)1*$ &',$ (%+1%,$ +&%$ -%/&'-+%-0*3$ 16$ +&%$ 4'*9=$ 0+)$

1-030*'8$ +%-7$&',$*1+$5%+$%?<0-%,:$E;&%$&5,-'$16$/1--.<+01*$ 0)$1*85$

%8("8/+2=$0("#2+.2=F$C'/9)1*$)'0,:$@6+%-$&%$2')$-%V%8%/+%,$1*$&0)$'*+0V

/%*+-'8V4'*9$ /'7<'03*=$ C'/9)1*$ 1-,%-%,$ &0)$ ;-%').-5$ )%/-%+'-5$ +1$

<8'/%$ '88$ *%2$ 6%,%-'8$ ,%<1)0+)$ 20+&$ %"."+$ 4'*9)=$ '*,$ +1$ <'5$ +&%$

31(%-*7%*+K)$%?<%*)%)$1.+$16$6.*,)$)+088$1*$,%<1)0+$20+&$+&%$O%/1*,$

N'*9$16$+&%$H*0+%,$O+'+%):$L*$+&0)$7'**%-=$6%,%-'8$,%<1)0+)$20+&$+&%$

/%*+-'8$4'*9$21.8,$4%$%(%*+.'885$,-'0*%,$'2'5=$-%71(0*3$1*%$16$+&%$

/&0%6$<088'-)$&18,0*3$0+$.<:$S;&0)$-'0)%,$'*$0*+%-%)+0*3$/1*)+0+.+01*'8$

B.%)+01*=$4%/'.)%$+&%$)%/-%+'-5$-%6.)%,$+1$/17<85$20+&$+&%$1-,%-=$1-$

-%)03*=$ '*,$ 0+$ 2')$ .*/8%'-$ 2&%+&%-$ +&%$ <-%)0,%*+$ /1.8,$ ,0)70))$ '$

7%74%-$ 16$ +&%$ /'40*%+$ 20+&1.+$ O%*'+%$ '<<-1('8:$ L*$ '*5$ %(%*+=$

C'/9)1*$ 2$2# 60-%$ &0)$ 0*).41-,0*'+%$ )%/-%+'-5=$ '*,$ 31+$ +&%$ 6.*,)$

-%71(%,$6-17$+&%$4'*9:T$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!e[$

f0/&18')$ N0,,8%$ ,0,*K+$ +'9%$ +&%$ '++'/9)$ 1*$ &0)$ 4'*9$ )0++0*3$

,12*:$b0)+1-0'*$\14%-+$\%70*0$%?<8'0*)P$

$N0,,8%$ /1.*+%-'++'/9%,:$ b%$ 0*0+0'+%,$ '$ 3%*%-'8$

/.-+'087%*+$ 16$ 81'*)$ +&-1.3&1.+$ +&%$ %*+0-%$ 4'*90*3$ )5)+%7h:L+$

7'-9%,$ +&%$ 4%30**0*3$ 16$ '$ 41*%V/-.)&0*3$ )+-.338%$ 4%+2%%*$ '$

<12%-6.8$ 60*'*/0%-$ '*,$ '$ ,%+%-70*%,$ '*,$ %B.'885$ <12%-6.8$

<180+0/0'*:$N0,,8%$.*,%-)+11,$2&'+$&%$2')$'41.+:$b%$9*%2$+&'+$06$

&%$ 4-1.3&+$ %*1.3&$ <-%)).-%$ '*,$ '31*5$ +1$ +&%$ 71*%5$ 7'-9%+=$

1*85$+&%*$/1.8,$&%$61-/%$+&%$`-%)0,%*+$+1$-%)+1-%$+&%$,%<1)0+):$b%$

'871)+$ 381'+%,:$ E;&0)$ 21-+&5$ `-%)0,%*+$ +&0*9)$ +&'+$ 4%/'.)%$ &%$

&')$)/'8<%,$L*,0'*)$'*,$07<-0)1*%,$C.,3%)=$&%$0)$+1$&'(%$&0)$2'5$

20+&$+&%$N'*9:$b%$0)$70)+'9%*:Fh$

E;&%$ +0%)$ 16$ <'-+5$ '88%30'*/%$ /'*$ 1*85$ 4%$ 4-19%*=F$ &%$

,%/8'-%,=$ E45$ +&%$ '/+.'8$ /1*(0/+01*$ 16$ %?0)+0*3$ ,0)+-%))$ 0*$ +&%$

/177.*0+5:F$@*,$)./&$,0)+-%))=$16$ /1.-)%=$21.8,$%(%*+.'885$<.+$

%(%-5+&0*3$ +1$ -03&+):$ Ef1+&0*3$ 4.+$ 20,%)<-%',$ ).66%-0*3$ 2088$

<-1,./%$'*5$%66%/+$1*$R1*3-%))h:W.-$1*85$)'6%+5$0)$0*$<.-).0*3$'$

)+%',5$/1.-)%$16$60-7$-%)+-0/+01*G'*,$L$&'(%$*1$,1.4+$+&'+$)./&$

'$ /1.-)%$2088$ .8+07'+%85$ 8%',$ +1$ -%)+1-'+01*$16$ +&%$ /.--%*/5$ '*,$

+&%$ -%/&'-+%-$16$ +&%$N'*9h:A5$12*$/1.-)%$ 0)$,%/0,%,:$@88$1+&%-$

4'*9)$ '*,$ '88$ +&%$ 7%-/&'*+)$ 7'5$ 4-%'9=$ 4.+$ +&%$ N'*9$ 16$ +&%$

H*0+%,$O+'+%)$)&'88$*1+$4-%'9:e$$

@+$ +&0)$ <10*+=$ 0+K)$ 21-+&$ -%70*,0*3$ +&%$ -%',%-$ 16$ +&%$

+-%7%*,1.)$ <12%-$ +&'+$ '$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*9%-$ 20%8,)$ 1(%-$ '$ /1.*+-5K)$

%*+0-%$ 60*'*/0'8$ )5)+%7:$ \%3'-,8%))$ 16$ +&%$ ('80,0+5$ 16$ N0,,8%K)$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

!eZ$

)+-.338%$20+&$ C'/9)1*=$ *1$ 0*,0(0,.'8$ 1.3&+$ +1$ &'(%$ +&%$ )+-'+%35$ 16$

E2-%/90*3$+&%$%/1*175F$0*$&0)$+11841?k$

N0,,8%$,0,$*1+$)+1<$20+&$/1*+-'/+0*3$/-%,0+:$b%$'8)1$.)%,$&0)$

+-%7%*,1.)$ 0*68.%*/%$ +1$ &'(%$ +&%$ O%*'+%$ 8'.*/&$ '$ /'7<'03*$

/-0+0/0D0*3$ +&%$`-%)0,%*+K)$ -%/98%))$ '/+01*)=$ /.870*'+0*3$ 0*$ '$ 61-7'8$

(1+%$ 16$ /%*).-%$ '3'0*)+$ C'/9)1*$ 1*$A'-/&$ ![=$ #[MU:$ ;&%*$ ')$ *12=$

+&1)%$ 0*$ /&'-3%$ 16$ +&%$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*9$ /1.8,$ /.8+0('+%$ +0%)$20+&$ 1+&%-$

<12%-6.8$ <%1<8%=$ %)<%/0'885$ <180+0/0'*):$ N0,,8%$ %(%*$ &',$ +&%$

%)+%%7%,$ O%*'+1-$ X'*0%8$ >%4)+%-$ 0*$ &0)$ ,%4+:$ @//1-,0*3$ +1$

l'84-'0+&P$

$N0,,8%$ 2')$ *1+$ 20+&1.+$ -%)1.-/%)$ i0*$ &0)$ 4'++8%$ 20+&$

C'/9)1*j:$L*$9%%<0*3$20+&$&0)$4%80%6$+&'+$4'*90*3$2')$+&%$.8+07'+%$

)1.-/%$16$<12%-=$&%$&',$-%3.8'-85$',('*/%,$6.*,)$+1$7%74%-)$16$

R1*3-%))$2&%*$ ,%8'5$ 1*$ '<<-1<-0'+01*)$ 4088)$ &',$ &%8<$ .<$ +&%0-$

<'5:$X'*0%8$>%4)+%-$2')=$'+$('-01.)$+07%)=$'$,0-%/+1-$16$+&%$N'*9$

'*,$1*$-%+'0*%-$')$0+)$/1.*)%8:$EL$4%80%(%$75$-%+'0*%-$&')$*1+$4%%*$

-%*%2%,$1-$-+1-+%/+2$')$.).'8:$L6$0+$4%$20)&%,$+&'+$75$-%8'+01*$+1$

+&%$ N'*9$ )&1.8,$ 4%$ /1*+0*.%,=$ 0+$ 7'5$ 4%$ 2%88$ +1$ )%*,$ 7%$ +&%$

.).'8$ -%+'0*%-):F$ f.7%-1.)$ 1+&%-$ 7%*$ 16$ ,0)+0*/+01*$ &',$ 4%%*$

'//1771,'+%,=$0*/8.,0*3$7%74%-)$16$+&%$<-%)):[$

$

L*$ +&%$ %*,=$ ,%)<0+%$ N0,,8%K)$ +-%7%*,1.)$ ',('*+'3%)=$ &%$

/1.8,*K+$,%6%'+$'$,%+%-70*%,$<-%)0,%*+$2&1$&',$<.480/$1<0*01*$1*$

&0)$ )0,%:$ ;&%$ O%/1*,$N'*9$ 16$ +&%$H*0+%,$ O+'+%)K$ /&'-+%-$ %?<0-%,$ 0*$

#[M":$ @7%-0/'$ 21.8,$ <-1)<%-$ 6$"/(3"$ '$ /%*+-'8$ 4'*9$ .*+08$ +&%$

!"#$%&'()$*&(#+$%&,'-.&($>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#

#

![Y$

%)+'480)&7%*+$ 16$ +&%$ Q%,%-'8$ \%)%-(%$ 0*$ #Z#M:$ @8+&1.3&$ /%*+-'8$

4'*9)$ '-%$ 61-70,'48%$ 0*)+0+.+01*)=$ '*,$ +&%0-$ ,0-%/+1-)$ &'(%$

/.8+0('+%,$ +0%)$ 20+&$ +&%$ 21-8,K)$ 71)+$ <12%-6.8$ <%1<8%=$ .8+07'+%85$

+&%5$ '-%$ /-%'+.-%)$ 16$ +&%$ 31(%-*7%*+:$ @*$ 0*61-7%,$ /0+0D%*-5$ /'*$

<-1(0,%$).<<1-+$61-$<180+0/0'*)$2&1$,'-%$+1$%*,$+&%$/1D5$'880'*/%$16$

N03$l1(%-*7%*+$'*,$N03$N'*9):$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Ludwig von Mises, The Theory of Money and Credit, p. 454. 2 Mises, The Theory of Money and Credit, p. 480. 3 See the Wikipedia entry at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_reserve. We also acknowledge that many cynics doubt the Federal Reserves’ official numbers. An added benefit of our hypothetical scenario is that it would force the Fed to prove the authenticity of its reports. (The Fed currently does not submit to outside audits of its gold holdings.) 4 Ron Paul, End the Fed (New York: Grand Central Publishing, 2009), pp. 202-203. 5 See http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/. 6 Quoted in G. Edward Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island (Westlake Village, CA: American Media, 2002), pp. 352-353. 7 Quoted in Griffin, The Creature From Jekyll Island, pp. 354-355. 8 John Kenneth Galbraith, quoted in Griffin, Creature, p. 351.

!"#$

!"#$%&&&%

'()%&*+%+,-$#./0$.,-%

$

$!"# $%&'# !!# ()# )*+,%-").# '/)# 012".# 31")4# 01,2'-1"5# 6/)# 1",4#

(%4#'1#&)7'1&)#7%"-'4# '1#12&# 8-"%"9-%,# 747'):#-7# '1#&)'2&"#:1")4#%".#

;%"<-"=# '1# '/)# +&->%')# 7)9'1&?# 8&))# 8&1:# %&;-'&%&4# +1,-'-9%,#

-"')&8)&)"9)5# !8# )"12=/# +)1+,)# 9%"# ,)%&"# '/)# ;%7-9# +&-"9-+,)7# 18#

@27'&-%"#)91"1:-97A%".#-"#+%&'-92,%&#'/)#3-7)7BC%4)<#'/)1&4#18#'/)#

;27-")77#949,)A'/)"#'/)4#(-,,#.):%".#'/%'#'/)#=1>)&":)"'#%;%".1"#

-'7#.)7'&29'->)# 912&7)5#6/)#012".#31")4#01,2'-1"# 8-&7'# '-)7# '/)#.1,,%&#

;%9<# '1# =1,.?# '/)"# +&->%'-D)7# '/)# -"7'-'2'-1"7# 18#:1")4# %".# ;%"<-"=?#

%".# 8-"%,,4# ),-:-"%')7# '/)# E).)&%,#F)7)&>)# -'7),85# @,'/12=/# '/)# 81&9)7#

72++1&'-"=# 9)"'&%,# ;%"<-"=# %&)# +1()&82,?# '/)4# %&)# "1'# -">-"9-;,)?# %7#

+&1>)"# ;4# @".&)(# G%9<71"H7# >-9'1&4# 1>)&# '/)# 0)91".# I%"<# 18# '/)#

J"-').#0'%')75#

J"81&'2"%'),4?# '/)&)# %&)# ,-:-'%'-1"7# '1# '/)# 012".# 31")4#

01,2'-1"?#%7#-'#/%7#;))"#-:+,):)"').#'/27#8%&5#!"#'/)#8-&7'#+,%9)?#-'#(-,,#

'%<)#%&'(# '1#).29%')#)"12=/#@:)&-9%"7#1"#'/)#.%"=)&7#18# 8&%9'-1"%,#

&)7)&>)# ;%"<-"=?# %# '1+-9# '/%'# -7# K2-')# .-88-92,'# %".# -"'-:-.%'-"=# 81&#

:17'#+)1+,)5#0)91".?#)>)"#-8#'/)#9&-'-9%,#'/&)7/1,.#18#)"&%=).#%9'->-7'7#

-7# %9/-)>).?# '/)&)# -7# "1# =2%&%"'))# '/%'# '/)4# (-,,# )".# 2+# >1'-"=# 81&#

+1,-'-9-%"7# (/1# &)%,,4# (-,,# -:+&1>)# :%'')&75# @,&)%.4# ()# 7))#

.):%=1=2)7#7))<-"=#'1#9%+-'%,-D)#1"#'/)#8&27'&%'-1"#18#'/)#:):;)&7#18#

!"#$%&'()*%+,-%-./$#012$0./%LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL#

#

!"!$

'/)# 6)%# $%&'4# :1>):)"'?# %".# :%"4# 1;7)&>)&7# %&)# 2".)&7'%".%;,4#

&),29'%"'# '1# '/&1(# '/)-&# ()-=/'# ;)/-".# %# M+1,-'-9%,# 71,2'-1"5N# 6/)4#

/%>)# K2-')# 7-:+,4# ;))"# ;2&").# '11# :%"4# '-:)7# -"# '/)# +%7'# ;4#

+1,-'-9-%"7#+&1:-7-"=#'1#&)81&:#%#;&1<)"#747'):5#31&)1>)&?#'/)#&%.-9%,#

&/)'1&-9# 91:-"=# 8&1:# 71:)# ),):)"'7# /%7# 8&-=/')").# :%"4# (/1#

1'/)&(-7)#%=&))#(-'/#'/)#9&-'-K2)7#18#'/)#O5P5#;%-,12'7#%".#.)8-9-'75#

!"# ,-=/'# 18# '/)7)# +&1;,):7?# ()# %&)# 1>)&Q14).# '1# &)+1&'# '/%'#

'/)&)# -7# %# :29/# 7-:+,)&# %++&1%9/5# !".->-.2%,# /127)/1,.7# 9%"# '%<)#

&''()&*%(#%9'-1"#'1#,-:-'#'/)#+1()&#18#'/)#E).#%".#91::)&9-%,#;%"<7#

'1#-"8,%')#'/)#:1")4#72++,45#6/)4#9%"#&''()&*%(+,# -:+,):)"'#0')+#R#

18# '/)# 012".#31")4# 01,2'-1"A+&->%'-D).# ;%"<-"=A(-'/12'#(%-'-"=#

81&#%# 7288-9-)"'#"2:;)&#18# >1')&7#.):%".-"=# 9/%"=)5#I)7'# 18# %,,?# '/-7#

")(#7'&%')=4#.1)7#"1'#&)K2-&)#7%9&-8-9)#;2'#-7#%9'2%,,4#-"#'/)#8-"%"9-%,#

-"')&)7'#18#)%9/#/127)/1,.#'/%'#-:+,):)"'7#-'5#I)9%27)#18#'/-7?#()#9%"#

)*+)9'#:1&)#%".#:1&)#-".->-.2%,7#%".#8%:-,-)7#'1#%.1+'#'/)#7'&%')=4?#

'/)&);4# 82&'/)&# ,-:-'-"=# '/)# +1()&# 18# '/)# E).)&%,# F)7)&>)# %".# '/)#

;%"<-"=#),-')5#

6/-7# 7'&%')=4# -">1,>)7# "1# .-&)9'# 91"8,-9'# (-'/# +1()&82,#

-"7'-'2'-1"7?# ;2'# :)&),4# %# (-'/.&%(%,# 18# 72++1&'5# !'# 9%"# (1&<# '1#

)88)9'->),4# ;&-"=# %;12'# 7)>)&%,# 91:+1")"'7# 18# '/)# 012".# 31")4#

01,2'-1"?#(-'/12'#%#7-"=,)#),)9'1&%,#2+7)'?#,)'#%,1")#%#7/1'#;)-"=#8-&).5#

F%'/)&# '/%"# /%>-"=# %"=&4# :1;7# 7'1&:# S%7/-"='1"?# '/)# 7'&%')=4#

-"7')%.# )"912&%=)7# /127)/1,.7# '1# :%<)# (-7)?# ,1"=B')&:# 8-"%"9-%,#

+,%"7# '/%'# +&1>-.)# 7'%;-,-'4# 81&# '/)-&# 8%:-,-)7# )>)"# -"'1# '/)# ")*'#

!"#$%&'()*%+,-%-./$#012$0./%LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL#

#

!"-$

=)")&%'-1"5#F%'/)&#'/%"#&)>1,2'-1"?#'/-7#7'&%')=4#&)+&)7)"'7#.(/(..&01#

8&1:#'/)#)*-7'-"=#1&.)&5#

S/%'# -7# '/-7# 7'&%')=4T# !7# -'# 71:)# ")(8%"=,).# ;&%-"9/-,.# 18# %#

,-;)&'%&-%"#+/47-9-7'?# -">1,>-"=#.)&->%'->)7# %".# ),)9'&1"-9# 92&&)"9-)7T#

U1?#'/-7#M")(N#7'&%')=4#-7#%9'2%,,4#1")#18#'/)#:17'#91"7)&>%'->)#:1")4B

:%"%=):)"'# 7'&%')=-)7?# (/-9/# /%7# ;))"# %&12".# 81&# :1&)# '/%"# '(1#

/2".&).#4)%&75#S)#7+)%<#18#(/1,)#,-8)#-"72&%"9)#+1,-9-)75#

C1()>)&?#'/)#91"")9'-1"#;)'())"#(/1,)#,-8)#-"72&%"9)#%".#'/)#

012".#31")4# 01,2'-1"#(12,.#")>)&# /%>)# ;))"#:%.)?#()&)# -'# "1'# 81&#

'/)#M!"8-"-')#I%"<-"=#P1"9)+'N#V!IPW#%7#.)>),1+).#;4#F5#U),71"#U%7/5#

S)#)*+,%-"#'/)#91"")9'-1"#;)'())"#!IP#%".#'/)#012".#31")4#01,2'-1"#

-"#'/-7#8-"%,#7)9'-1"5#

!"#$%&'()*%+,-%-./$#012$0./%!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#$

$

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

+"&(,-./-/%&(0#-1/-2(!3-4&$%(

$

$

!"#$%"&' "(' )*"+%$(,' -+' *$.$(' /)&*0'

"*'#"0+' 1-*)*2-)3' 45(50' +%)+' 6"5' %&'$

2"*+("3' +%$' 1-*)*2-)3' $*.-("*#$*+' -*'

&%-2%' 6"5' "7$()+$8' 9$(%)70' -+' -0'

2)50$/' :6' 3)2;' "1' -#)4-*)+-"*,' :5+'

&%)+$.$(' +%$' 2)50$,' 3$)(*-*4' +"'

2"*+("3' -+' -0'()*$+,-($./,01(&23*$+%-*4'

+%)+'6"5'2)*'/"'".$(')'3-1$+-#$8'

<=8'>$30"*'>)0%?'

$$

-$)*$(*33-$()*$-(,/4$1'$)1-$5'6*/7/,5'6$%3&--1%8$@$2"#-*4'

A"5('B&*'@)*;$(9:)1%)$)&-$ -,36$+,/*$ ()&'$!;;8;;;$

%,.1*-9<=$>*3-,'$>&-)$)1($5.,'$()*$?@'01'1(*$A&'B1'7$C,'%*.(D$1'$&$

03&-)$,0$/*E*3&(1,'$1'$()*$*&/34$FG";-=$>&-)$/*&31H*6$()&($()*$./,.*/$

5-*$,0$61E16*'6I.&41'7$:),3*$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$%,536$*E*'(5&334$&33,:$

-,+*,'*$(,$?2*%,+*$)1-$,:'$2&'B*/8D$+*&'1'7$()&($)*$%,536$,2(&1'$

)1-$ 310*(1+*$ 01'&'%1'7$ '**6-$ J0,/$ %&/-8$ %)136/*'K-$ *65%&(1,'8$

/*(1/*+*'($ 1'%,+*8$ &'6$ *E*'$ ),5-*$ .5/%)&-*-L$ 0/,+$ .,31%4$ 3,&'-$

&'6$61E16*'6$.&4+*'(-8$()+%$('+%)*$0/,+$(/&61(1,'&3$2&'B-$,/$,()*/$

3*'61'7$1'-(1(5(1,'-=$>&-)$*M.3&1'-$1'$()*$1'(/,65%(1,'N$

$

O$

!"#$%&'(&()#$*+&,(&-$./&0#1)$CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC'

'

!"P$

Q)*$ :),3*$ 16*&$ 1-$ (,$ /*%&.(5/*$ ()*$ 1'(*/*-($ ()&($ ,'*$ 1-$

.&41'7$(,$2&'B-$&'6$01'&'%*$%,+.&'1*-$0,/$()*$+&R,/$1(*+-$()&($

:*$'**6$65/1'7$&$310*(1+*S$

Q)1-$ 2,,B$ 1-$ ',($ &2,5($ 1'E*-(+*'(-$ ,0$ &'4$ B1'6=$ @($ 1-$

&2,5($ ),:$ ,'*$ 1-*)*2$0$ ()*$ ()1'7-$ ,0$ 310*8$ :)1%)$ %&'$ %*/(&1'34$

1'%356*$1'E*-(+*'(-S=$

@($ 1-$ ',($ &$ ./,%*65/*$ (,$ ?7*($ /1%)$ T51%B34=D$ Q,$ ()*$

%,'(/&/48$ 1($ /*T51/*-$ 3,'7$ /&'7*$ .3&''1'7=$ @K+$ *65%&(*6$ &-$ &$

0,/*-(*/8$)&E1'7$:,/B*6$1'$()&($01*36$&-$&$%,'-53(&'($0,/$(*'$4*&/-U$

@$(*'6$(,$()1'B$-*E*'(4$4*&/-$1'$()*$05(5/*=$@$:,'K($2*$)*/*9&'6$

'*1()*/$ :133$ 4,5925($ ()*/*$ 1-$ ',$ /*&-,'$ ',($ (,$ 2*)&E*$ 1'$ ()1-$

+&''*/=$?V3&'$&-$10$4,5$&/*$7,1'7$(,$31E*$0,/*E*/$&'6$31E*$&-$10$4,5$

&/*$7,1'7$(,$61*$(,6&4D$&..*&/-$(,$+*$(,$2*$&$7,,6$(),57)(=$W'*$

%&'$ 3*&/'$),:$(,$.3&'$&'6$&%($ 1'(*/7*'*/&(1,'&334=$Q)&(K-$,'*$,0$

()*$ ./1+&/4$ &6E&'(&7*-$ ,0$ )&E1'7$ 2**'$ &$ 0,/*-(*/=$ @$ 3*&/'*6$ (,$

()1'B$2*4,'6$()*$310*-.&'$,0$+4$%5//*'($7*'*/&(1,'=!$$

@'$ ()*$ &2,E*$ T5,(&(1,'8$ >&-)$ 1-$ /*0*//1'7$ (,$ ()*$ 0&%($ ()&($

:),3*$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$.,31%1*-$&/*$&'$*M%*33*'($:&4$ (,$ (/&'-0*/$ 3&/7*$

&+,5'(-$ ,0$ :*&3()$ J:1()$ -17'101%&'($ (&M$ &6E&'(&7*-L$ (,$ ()*$ '*M($

7*'*/&(1,'8$*1()*/$()/,57)$JFL$'&+1'7$%)136/*'$&-$()*$2*'*01%1&/1*-$

,'$ ,'*K-$ ,:'$ .,31%48$ ,/$ J!L$ 24$ 05'61'7$ .,31%1*-$ ,'$ %)136/*'$ ,/$

7/&'6%)136/*'$:)*'$()*4$&/*$T51(*$4,5'78$:)1%)$:133$./,E16*$()*+$

&%%*--$(,$&$3&/7*$-(,/*$,0$%&.1(&3$3&(*/$,'$1'$()*1/$31E*-=$

X,:*E*/8$ 1'$ ,5/$ %,'(*M($ >&-)K-$ -(&(*+*'($ %&//1*-$ &$ -.*%1&3$

-17'101%&'%*=$ O-$ :*$ :133$ -**8$ ()*$ :16*-./*&6$ ./&%(1%*$ ,0$ @AC$ :,536$

7/*&(34$&%%*3*/&(*$()*$&%)1*E*+*'($,0$()*$Y,5'6$Z,'*4$Y,35(1,'=$@'$


'

!"[$

&$ E*/4$ /*&3$ -*'-*8$ &$ ),5-*),36K-$ 6*%1-1,'$ (,$ ./&%(1%*$ @AC$ :,536$

1'%/*&-*$ ()*$ 31B*31),,6$ ()&($ 05(5/*$ 7*'*/&(1,'-$ %&'$ 7/,:$ 5.$ 1'$ &$

:,/36$*'R,41'7$+,'*(&/4$&'6$2&'B1'7$0/**6,+=$

$

,0!5(+"&(6&4"#-/47$

$

Q)*$ ./*-*'($ 2,,B$ 1-$ ',($ &$ -52-(1(5(*$ 0,/$ >&-)K-$ ,/171'&3$

%3&--1%=$ @'(*/*-(*6$/*&6*/-$+&4$&3-,$2*'*01($ 0/,+$\:&4'*$A5/'*33K-$

!;F;$ 2,,B]$ :)1%)$ 71E*-$ &$ +,/*$ %,'E*'(1,'&3$ ./*-*'(&(1,'$ ,0$ ()*$

%,+.*331'7$ %&-*$ 0,/$ 61E16*'6I.&41'7$ :),3*$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ &-$ &$

./56*'($ %,+.,'*'($ ,0$ &$ ),5-*),36K-$ 01'&'%1&3$ .3&'=$ @'$ ()*$

/*+&1'6*/$,0$ ()1-$ %)&.(*/$:*$:133$./,E16*$&$+*/*$-B*(%)$,0$>&-)K-$

16*&8$ -,$ ()&($ ()*$ /*&6*/$ 5'6*/-(&'6-$ ()*$ 3,71-(1%-$ ,0$ -*30I01'&'%1'7$

()/,57)$:),3*$310*$.,31%1*-=$^*$:133$()*'$2*$1'$&$.,-1(1,'$(,$*M.3&1'$

()*$-17'101%&'%*$,0$@AC$(,$()*$Y,5'6$Z,'*4$Y,35(1,'=$

Q)*$ 01/-($ -(*.$ (,$ ./&%(1%1'7$ @AC$ 1-$ (,$ (&B*$ ,5($ &$ 61E16*'6I

.&41'7$:),3*$310*$1'-5/&'%*$.,31%48$./,E16*6$24$&$+5(5&3$1'-5/&'%*$

%,+.&'4$J1'$:)1%)$()*$.,31%4),36*/-8$',($()1/6I.&/(4$-(,%B),36*/-8$

&/*$()*$R,1'($,:'*/-$,0$()*$%,+.&'4L=$>,/+&334$()1-$:133$2*$&$.,31%4$

,'$ ()*$ .*/-,'$ :),$ :1-)*-$ (,$ 1+.3*+*'($ @AC8$ 25($ 10$ ()&($ .*/-,'$ 1-$

5'1'-5/&23*$)*$%&'$-(133$*'R,4$()*$?31E1'7$2*'*01(-D$,0$@AC8$24$(&B1'7$

,5($&$.,31%4$,'$-,+*,'*$*3-*$1'$:),+$)*$)&-$&'$1'-5/&23*$1'(*/*-($

J-5%)$&-$&$-.,5-*8$%)1368$,/$25-1'*--$.&/('*/L=$


'

!""$

<*%&33$ 0/,+$ C)&.(*/$ F#$ ()&($ &$ :),3*$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ .,31%4$

&33,:-$()*$,:'*/$(,$&%%5+53&(*$?*T51(4D$1'$()*$.,31%48$&-$3,'7$&-$)*$

%,'(1'5*-$+&B1'7$./*+15+$.&4+*'(-=$Z,/*$-.*%101%&3348$()*$,/171'&3$

%,'(/&%($ -.*%101*-$ 75&/&'(**6$ -5//*'6*/$ %&-)$ E&35*-8$ :)1%)$ 7/,:$

*E*/4$4*&/$ ()*$.,31%4$ 1-$ 1'$ 0,/%*=$ JQ)*-*$E&35*-$&/*$?75&/&'(**6D$ 1'$

()*$ -*'-*$ ()&($ ()*$ .,31%4),36*/$ 1-$ 3*7&334$ *'(1(3*6$ (,$ ()*+$ 10$ )*$

6*%16*-$(,$&2&'6,'$)1-$.,31%4$&($&'4$.,1'(=L$A*4,'6$()*$45)()*+$$/$

%&-)$ E&35*-8$ ()*$ %,'(/&%($ :133$ &3-,$ -),:$ ./,R*%(1,'-$ ,0$)2+5)3$ %&-)$

E&35*-8$ 71E*'$&--5+.(1,'-$ &2,5($ ()*$.*/0,/+&'%*$,0$ ()*$ 1'-5/&'%*$

%,+.&'4K-$ &--*($ .,/(0,31,8$ &'6$ ()*$ /*1'E*-(+*'($ ,0$ 61E16*'6-$ 1'(,$

()*$.5/%)&-*$,0$&661(1,'&3$1'-5/&'%*=$@'$,()*/$:,/6-8$()*$%&-)$E&35*$

,0$&$:),3*$310*$.,31%4$)&-$&$%,'-(&'(34$/1-1'7$03,,/8$25($1(-$&%(5&3$E&35*$

&($ &'4$ 05(5/*$ 6&(*$ :133$ 31B*34$ 2*$ )17)*/$ ()&'$ ()*$ %,'(/&%(5&334$

75&/&'(**6$+1'1+5+=$

@0$4,5$(&3B$:1()$&'$&%(5&/48$)*$:133$(*33$4,5$()&($()*$%&-)$E&35*$

,0$&$:),3*$310*$.,31%4$&($&'4$71E*'$(1+*8$1-$%,+.5(*6$&-$()*$./*-*'(I

61-%,5'(*6$E&35*$,0$()*$6*&()$2*'*01(8$+1'5-$()*$./*-*'(I61-%,5'(*6$

E&35*$ ,0$ ()*$ ?&6R5-(*6$ 05(5/*$ ./*+15+$ 03,:=D$ ^)&($ +&B*-$ ()*-*$

E&35*-$ 61001%53($ (,$ %,+.5(*$ 1-$ ()*$ 5'%*/(&1'(4$ ,0$ ()*$ (1+*$ ,0$ 6*&()=$

A5($ ',(1%*$ ()&($ :1()$ *E*/4$ .&--1'7$ 4*&/8$ ()*$ ./*-*'($ E&35*$ ,0$ ()*$

3,,+1'7$6*&()$2*'*01($,2E1,5-34$ 1'%/*&-*-8$:)13*$ ()*$./*-*'($E&35*$

,0$ ()*$/*+&1'1'7$-(/*&+$,0$.,(*'(1&3$./*+15+$.&4+*'(-$,2E1,5-34$

6*%/*&-*-=$ Q)1-$ 1-$ :)4$ ()*$ %&-)$ E&35*$ ,0$ &$ .,31%4$ 7/,:-$

J*M.,'*'(1&334L$,E*/$(1+*=$


'

!"G$

O$ +,/*$ 1'(51(1E*$ :&4$ ,0$ 5'6*/-(&'61'7$ ()*$ 7/,:()$ 1'$ %&-)$

E&35*-8$1-$(,$/*&31H*$()&($10$()*$1'-5/*6$&((&1'-$&$)17)$*',57)$&7*$JF!F$

4*&/-$ 0,/$ *M&+.3*L8$ ()*$ 7/,:1'7$ %&-)$ E&35*$ :133$ )&E*$ ?%&57)($ 5.D$

:1()$ ()*$ 7/,:1'7$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01(=$ O($ ()&($ .,1'($ ()*$ .,31%4$ 1-$

%,+.3*(*68$&'6$()*$1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'4$-*'6-$&$%)*%B$J./,2&234$0,/$

-*E*/&3$ +1331,'$ 6,33&/-L$ (,$ ()*$ E*/4$ -*'1,/$ %1(1H*'=$ A*%&5-*$ ()*$

1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'4$B',:-$()&($1($:133$53(1+&(*34$)&E*$(,$.&4$&$3&/7*$

-5+$,'$&$:),3*$ 310*$.,31%49*1()*/$ (,$ ()*$'&+*6$2*'*01%1&/4$:)*'$

()*$1'-5/*6$61*-8$,/$(,$()*$.,31%4,:'*/$:)*'$()*$1'-5/*6$&((&1'-$()*$

/*T51/*6$ &7*$ &'6$ ()*$ .,31%4$ 1-$ %,+.3*(*69()*$ %,+.&'4$ '**6-$ (,$

:1-*34$1'E*-($()*$-(/*&+$,0$./*+15+$.&4+*'(-$(,$+&B*$-5/*$()*/*$1-$

-5001%1*'($ :*&3()$ (,$ +**($ 1(-$ %,'(/&%(5&3$ ,2317&(1,'-=$ O-$ &$ .,31%4$

+&(5/*-8$ ()*/*0,/*8$ ()*$ .,/(1,'$ ,0$ ()*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ %,+.&'4K-$ &--*($

.,/(0,31,$ ?2&%B1'7$5.D$ ()*$.&/(1%53&/$:),3*$ 310*$.,31%4$ %,'(1'5*-$ (,$

7/,:$ 1'$ +&/B*($ E&35*=$ Q)*$ 75&/&'(**6$ %&-)$ E&35*$ ,0$ ()*$ .,31%4$

/*./*-*'(-$J3,,-*34$-.*&B1'7L$()1-$&%%5+53&(1'7$.,,3$,0$&--*(-$2*1'7$

(*'6*6$24$()*$1'-5/*/=$

@'$&661(1,'$(,$()*$6*&()$2*'*01(9:)1%)$1-$.&16$(&MI0/**$(,$()*$

'&+*6$ 2*'*01%1&/4$ 5.,'$ ()*$ 6*&()$ ,0$ ()*$ 1'-5/*69&$ :),3*$ 310*$

.,31%4$ &3-,$ 7*'*/&(*-$ ?31E1'7$ 2*'*01(-=D$ W'*$ ,0$ ()*-*$ 2*'*01(-$ 1-$ ()*$

.&4+*'($ ,0$ 61E16*'6-=$ A4$ ()*1/$ '&(5/*8$ 1'-5/&'%*$ %,+.&'1*-$ &/*$

E*/4$ %,'-*/E&(1E*8$ %)&/71'7$ )17)*/$ ./*+15+-$ ()&'$ ()*4$ :133$ 31B*34$

'**6$ J1'$ &'$ &%(5&/1&3$ -*'-*L$ (,$ +&B*$ ()*$ '*M($ 4*&/K-$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01($

.&4+*'(-=$@'$&$+5(5&3$%,+.&'49,'*$1'$:)1%)$&33$()*$.,31%4),36*/-$


'

!G;$

%,33*%(1E*34$ ,:'$ ()*$ &--*(-$ ,0$ ()*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ %,+.&'49()*$ *M%*--$

*&/'1'7-$ &/*$ .*/1,61%&334$ 61-(/125(*6$ &-$ 61E16*'6-$ (,$ ()*$

.,31%4),36*/-=$ Q)*$ .,31%4),36*/-$ %&'$ 6/&:$ ,5($ ()*$ 61E16*'6-$ J(&MI

0/**8$5.$5'(13$ ()*$,/171'&3$ %,-($2&-1-$,0$ 310*(1+*$./*+15+$.&4+*'(-$

)&-$ 2**'$ -5/.&--*6L8$ ,/$ ()*4$ %&'$ %),,-*$ (,$ /*1'E*-($ ()*+$ 24$

.5/%)&-1'7$&661(1,'&3$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*=$ @'$*--*'%*8$24$ /*1'E*-(1'7$ ()*$

61E16*'6-$&$.,31%4),36*/$254-$&$?+1'1D$E*/-1,'$,0$)1-$,/171'&3$.,31%48$

1'$&$,'*I-),($(/&'-&%(1,'=$J>,(*$()&($()*$./*+15+$.&4+*'(-$6,$',($

1'%/*&-*$ :1()$ ()*$ .5/%)&-*$ ,0$ &661(1,'&3$ 1'-5/&'%*=$ Q)*$ ?+1'1D$

.5/%)&-*-$ &/*$ %,+.3*(*34$ 05'6*6$ 24$ ()*$ ,'*I-),($ .&4+*'($ ,0$ &$

/*1'E*-(*6$61E16*'6=L$

Q)*/*$ 1-$ &',()*/$ +&R,/$ ?31E1'7$ 2*'*01(D$ ,0$ &$ :),3*$ 310*$

1'-5/&'%*$ .,31%48$ :)1%)$ 7*(-$ (,$ ()*$ )*&/($ ,0$ @ACN$ Q)*$ 1'-5/&'%*$

%,+.&'4$ 1-$ ./*.&/*6$ (,$ +&B*$ 3,:I1'(*/*-(I/&(*$ 3")*0$ (,$

.,31%4,:'*/-8$:1()$()*$?%/*61($31+1(D$2*1'7$./,.,/(1,'&3$(,$()*$%&-)$

E&35*$ ,0$ ()*$ .,31%4=$ Q)*$ E&/1&23*$ /&(*$ ,'$ ()*$ 3,&'$ 1-$ %,'(/&%(5&334$

-.*%101*68$ &'6$ +&4$ &33,:$ ()*$ 2,//,:*/$ (,$ ,2(&1'$ ()*$ -&+*$ 3,:$

1'(*/*-($ /&(*$ ()&($ +&R,/$ %,/.,/&(1,'-$ &%)1*E*$ ,'$ ()*1/$ ,:'$ 2,'6-=$

Q)*$./,%*--$ 1-$&3-,$T51(*$-1+.3*=$Q)*/*$&/*$',$ 3*'7()4$ 0,/+-$(,$ 0133$

,5(8$ ',$ '**6$ 0,/$ &$ %/*61($ %)*%B8$ &'6$ ',$ '**6$ (,$ ./,E*$ ,'*$ )&-$ ()*$

1'%,+*$(,$.&4$2&%B$()*$3,&'=$@'$0&%(8$()*$1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'4$6,*-'K($

/*&334$2)($$:)*()*/$()*$.,31%4,:'*/$.&4-$2&%B$()*$3,&'_$

Q)*$*M.3&'&(1,'$1-$()&($()*$1'-5/*/$7/&'(-$()*$3,&'8$5-1'7$()*$

.,31%4K-$6*&()$2*'*01($&-$2"33)+$()3=$`/,+$()*$1'-5/*/K-$.,1'($,0$E1*:8$


'

!GF$

()*/*0,/*8$&$3,&'$(,$&$.,31%4,:'*/$1'$&$-*'-*$1-$()*$-&0*-($1'E*-(+*'($

1+&71'&23*=$ aE*'$ b=Y=$ Q/*&-5/4$ 2,'6-$ %&//4$ -,+*$ /1-B$ ,0$ 6*0&53(=$

X,:*E*/8$()*$1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'4$;*"&0$()&($1($:133$6*01'1(*34$/*%,5.$

*E*/4$3&-($.*''4$()&($&$.,31%4,:'*/$,:*-$,'$&$3,&'8$*E*'$1'%3561'7$

()*$ &%%5+53&(*6$ 1'(*/*-(8$ 2*%&5-*$ :)*'*E*/$ ()*$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01($ 1-$

.&16$,5(8$()*$,5(-(&'61'7$3,&'$2&3&'%*$:133$2*$-52(/&%(*6$2*0,/*$()*$

1'-5/*/$%5(-$&$%)*%B$(,$()*$2*'*01%1&/4=$>&(5/&3348$10$()*$.,31%4,:'*/$

.&4-$2&%B$&33$,/$&$.,/(1,'$,0$)1-$.,31%4$3,&'8$()*'$()1-$61+1'1-)*-$()*$

31*'$ &7&1'-($ ()*$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01(8$ &'6$ 0/**-$ 5.$ ()*$ %&-)$ E&35*$ ,0$ ()*$

.,31%4$0,/$05(5/*$3,&'-$&'6c,/$&$0533*/$6*&()$2*'*01($.&4+*'(=$

$

,0!5(+"&(8'#4%/4&$

$

>&-)$/*%,++*'6-$()&($1'61E165&3-$%,'0175/*$()*1/$:),3*$310*$

.,31%1*-$ (,$ &33,:$ 0,/$ ()*$ T51%B*-($ &%%5+53&(1,'$ ,0$ %&-)$ E&35*-$

/*3&(1E*$ (,$ ()*$ -1H*$ ,0$ ()*$ ./*+15+$ .&4+*'(=$ JQ)*/*$ &/*$ @<Y$

/*753&(1,'-$ 31+1(1'7$ ()1-$ ./&%(1%*8$ -,$ 1($ 1-$ ,0$ %,5/-*$ %/5%1&3$ ()&($

&'4,'*$&((*+.(1'7$(,$1+.3*+*'($@AC$6*&3-$:1()$&$%,+.*(*'($&7*'($

:),$ 5'6*/-(&'6-$ >&-)K-$ .)13,-,.)4$ &-$ :*33$ &-$ ()*$ /*3*E&'($ (&M$

3&:-=L$V5-)*6$(,$1(-$3,71%&3$*M(/*+*8$&$.*/-,'$:1-)1'7$(,$1+.3*+*'($

>&-)K-$E1-1,'$:,536$(&B*$,5($1'-5/&'%*$.,31%1*-$',($,'34$,'$)1+-*308$

25($ &3-,$ ,'$ E&/1,5-$ .*,.3*$ 1'$ :),+$ )*$ )&-$ &'$ 1'-5/&23*$ 1'(*/*-(8$

5'(13$ ()*$ .,1'($ &($ :)1%)$ )1-$ *'(1/*$ &''5&3$ 1'%,+*$ 1-$ 5-*6$ (,$ .&4$

1'-5/&'%*$./*+15+-=$@'$()1-$:&48$,'*$:,536$(/534$)&E*$2*%,+*$)1-$


'

!G!$

,:'$ 2&'B*/8$ +*&'1'7$ ()&($ ()*$ 01/-($ -(,.$ ,/$ ?)*&6T5&/(*/-D$ ,0$ )1-$

.&4%)*%B-$&'6$,()*/$-,5/%*-$,0$ 1'%,+*$:,536$2*$ 1'$&$%,33*%(1,'$,0$

)1-$:),3*$310*$.,31%1*-=$`,/$-5%)$&$.*/-,'8$()*$,'34$.,1'($1'$)&E1'7$&$

-(&'6&/6$%,++*/%1&3$2&'B$&%%,5'(8$:,536$2*$0,/$()*$%,'E*'1*'%*$,0$

:/1(1'7$ %)*%B-=$ Q)*$ %,++*/%1&3$ 2&'B$ :,536'K($ 2*$ '*%*--&/4$ &-$ &$

.3&%*$(,$.5($-&E1'7-8$),:*E*/8$,/$*E*'$&-$&$ (*+.,/&/4$/*-(1'7$-.,($

:)*'$,'*$0175/*-$,5($:)&($(,$6,$:1()$)1-$?%&-)=D$

>&(5/&3348$+,-($.*,.3*$6,$',($.5-)$()*$%,'%*.($()1-$0&/8$&'6$

1'$&'4$*E*'($1($:,536$(&B*$+&'4$4*&/-$(,$&%)1*E*$-5%)$&$.,-1(1,'=$@'$

()*$2*71''1'78$>&-)$/*%,++*'6-$()&($&$.*/-,'$05'6$&$-1'73*$.,31%4$

*',57)$(,$/*&%)$()*$01/-($+13*-(,'*$,0$2541'7$)1-$'*M($%&/$5-1'7$)1-$

:),3*$ 310*$ .,31%48$ /&()*/$ ()&'$ :1()$ &$ (/&61(1,'&3$ &5(,$ 01'&'%*$

%,+.&'4=$ @0$ ()*$%&-)$E&35*$)&-$7/,:'$-5001%1*'(348$ ()*$.,31%4),36*/$

%,536$254$()*$'*:$%&/$24$6/&:1'7$,5($()*$61E16*'6-$0/,+$()*$.,31%4=$

X,:*E*/8$ 1($ 1-$ +,/*$ 31B*34$ ()&($ &$ '*:%,+*/$ (,$ @AC$ :133$ ',($ *&/'$

*',57)$1'$-(/&17)($61E16*'6-$1'$()*$4*&/$)*$:1-)*-$(,$254$&$'*:$%&/=$

@'$ ()&($ %&-*8$ )*$ %&'$ (&B*$ ,5($ &$ .,31%4$ 3,&'$ 0/,+$ ()*$ 1'-5/&'%*$

%,+.&'48$/&()*/$()&'$(5/'1'7$(,$&$(/&61(1,'&3$&5(,$01'&'%1'7$3*'6*/=$

^)*'$'*:%,+*/-$(,$@AC$&..34$0,/$()*1/$01/-($.,31%4$3,&'8$()*4$

:133$2*$*3&(*6$(,$61-%,E*/$()&($()*4$%&'$2,//,:$&($/&(*-$%,+.&/&23*$

(,$235*I%)1.$2,'6$41*36-91'$,()*/$:,/6-8$()*$1'61E165&3$%&'$2,//,:$

,'$ (*/+-$ &E&13&23*$ (,$ +&R,/$ %,/.,/&(1,'-=$ aE*'$ -,8$ >&-)$

/*%,++*'6-$ ()&($ -,+*,'*$:),$2,//,:-$&7&1'-($)1-$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$

.,31%4$&($()*-*$3,:$/&(*-8$','*()*3*--$&%(-$&-$10$)*$1-$2*1'7$%)&/7*6$


'

!G]$

()*$ )17)*/$ 1'(*/*-($ /&(*$ )*$ 50$/' (,$ .&48$ ()/,57)$ %,'E*'(1,'&3$

%)&''*3-=$`,/$*M&+.3*8$-,+*,'*$2541'7$&$'*:$%&/$%,536$01/-($,2(&1'$

&$ :/1((*'$ -(&(*+*'($ 0/,+$ ()*$ &5(,$ 01'&'%*$ %,+.&'4$ -(&(1'7$ ()*$

1'(*/*-($ /&(*$ ()*4$&"53/' )&E*$ %)&/7*6$ 0,/$ ()*$ .&/(1%53&/$ %&/$ J&'6$

%/*61($-%,/*$,0$()*$2,//,:*/L$1'$T5*-(1,'=$>&-)$()*'$&6E1-*-$()&($()*$

.,31%4),36*/$.&4-$+%-0$ 1'(*/*-($/&(*$2&%B$(,$()*$1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'4=$

WE*/$()*$310*$,0$()*$3,&'8$()*$.,31%4,:'*/$:),$?.&4-$)1+-*30$2&%BD$1'$

()1-$+&''*/$:133$*'6$5.$',($,'34$:1()$&$.&16I,00$%&/8$25($&3-,$:1()$

)17)*/$%&-)$E&35*-$()&'$)*$,()*/:1-*$:,536$)&E*$)&68$&'6$&33$:1()$

()*$-&+*$,5(I,0I.,%B*($%&-)03,:-$()&($)*$,()*/:1-*$:,536$)&E*$-*'($

(,$()*$&5(,$01'&'%*$%,+.&'4=$

@'$ (*/+-$ ,0$ .-4%),3,71%&3$ +,(1E&(1,'8$ 1($ 1-$ 6*01'1(*34$ E*/4$

5-*053$0,/$.*,.3*$(,$E1*:$()*$-1(5&(1,'$&-$:1()6/&:1'7$+,'*4$0/,+$

?()*1/$ 2&'BD$ &'6$ ()*'$ .&41'7$ ()*$ 1'(*/*-($ &-$ :*33$ &-$ ()*$ ./1'%1.&3$

?2&%B$1'(,$()*1/$,:'$2&'B=D$X,:*E*/8$1($1-$1+.,/(&'($(,$5'6*/-(&'6$

./*%1-*34$ :)&($ )&..*'-$ :)*'$ ,'*$ 01'&'%*-$ &$ .5/%)&-*$ 1'$ ()1-$

+&''*/=$

@'$()*$01/-($.3&%*8$-(/1%(34$-.*&B1'7$()*$.,31%4,:'*/$6,*-$',($

?:1()6/&:D$ +,'*4$ 0/,+$ ()*$ :),3*$ 310*$ .,31%4$ :)*'$ (&B1'7$ ,5($ &$

.,31%4$ 3,&'=$ W'$ ()*$ %,'(/&/48$ ()*$ ./*+15+-$ %,'(1'5*$ (,$ 2*$ .&168$

:)13*$ ()*$ %&-)$ E&35*$ &'6$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01($ ,0$ ()*$ .,31%4$ 7/,:$ &-$ ()*4$

',/+&334$:,5368$/*7&/63*--$,0$()*$3,&'=d$

^)*'$&$.,31%4,:'*/$(&B*-$&$ 3,&'$&7&1'-($)1-$.,31%48$ 1($ 1-$()*$

-*05($(':),$&6E&'%*-$)1+$()*$+,'*4=$Q)*'$()1-$3,&'$2&3&'%*$7/,:-$


'

!Gd$

:1()$ 1'(*/*-(8$ &%%,/61'7$ (,$ ()*$ (*/+-$ ,0$ ()*$ 3,&'=$ Q,$ /*.*&(8$ ()*$

1'-5/*/$)&-$()*$.,31%4K-$6*&()$2*'*01($&-$%,33&(*/&38$-,$1($6,*-'K($%&/*$

),:$T51%B348$10$&($&338$()*$2,//,:*/$/*.&4-$()*$3,&'=$

>,:$ 10$ -,+*,'*$ &6,.(-$ ()*$ 0533$ -(/&(*74$ /*%,++*'6*6$ 24$

>&-)8$ 1'$:)1%)$)*$2,//,:-$ 0/,+$()*$ 1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'4$&($ J-&4L$#$

.*/%*'($25($+&B*-$.&4+*'($,'$()*$3,&'$&-$10$1($:*/*$/,331'7$,E*/$&($[$

.*/%*'($ J:)1%)$ 1-$ :)&($ ()*$ -(&'6&/6$ &5(,$ 01'&'%*$ %,+.&'4$ :,536$

)&E*$ %)&/7*6L8$ (*%)'1%&334$ :)&($ )&..*'-$ 1-$ ()&($ ()*$ 3,&'$ 0/,+$ ()*$

1'-5/*/$1-$.&16$,00$+,/*$T51%B34$()&'$()*$-&+*$3,&'$:,536$)&E*$2**'$

.&16$ ,00$ ()/,57)$ ()*$ &5(,$ 01'&'%*$ %,+.&'4=$ JQ)1-$ 1-$ ,2E1,5-8$ -1'%*$

()*$,5(-(&'61'7$3,&'$2&3&'%*$/,33-$,E*/$&($#$.*/%*'($,'$()*$1'-5/*/K-$

2,,B-$E*/-5-$[$.*/%*'($)&6$()*$3,&'$2**'$,2(&1'*6$1'$()*$(/&61(1,'&3$

+&''*/=L$ O($ -,+*$ .,1'(8$ ()*$ 3,&'$ (,$ ()*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ %,+.&'4$ :133$

)&E*$ 2**'$ 05334$ /*.&168$ &'6$ ()*'$ ()*$ /*+&1'1'7$ ?%&/$ .&4+*'(-D$

&%(5&334$ .5/%)&-*$ &661(1,'&3$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*8$ %&5-1'7$ &$ 7/*&(*/$

1'%/*+*'($ 1'$()*$%&-)$E&35*$&'6$6*&()$2*'*01($,0$ ()*$.,31%4=$Q)1-$ 1-$

:)4$ 1($ 1-$ -,$ +5%)$ -+&/(*/$ (,$ 01'&'%*$ &$ %&/$ 3,&'$ J,/$ ,()*/$ +&R,/$

.5/%)&-*L$ ()/,57)$ &$ :),3*$ 310*$ .,31%4$ 3,&'8$ /&()*/$ ()&'$ -**B1'7$

,5(-16*$01'&'%1'7N$A*%&5-*$()*$1'-5/&'%*$3,&'$1-$(4.1%&334$&($&$3,:*/$

/&(*$ ()&'$ ()*$ ,5(-16*$ 3,&'$ J:)1%)$ %&'K($ -*1H*$ ()*$ 2,//,:*/K-$ 310*$

1'-5/&'%*$ &--*($ 1'$ ()*$ *E*'($ ,0$ 6*0&53(L8$ ()*$ -&+*$ %&-)$ 03,:$

6*61%&(*6$ (,$ %&/$ .&4+*'(-$ :133$ (/&'-3&(*$ 1'(,$ '*($ %&.1(&3$

&%%5+53&(1,'8$/&()*/$()&'$-1+.34$*31+1'&(1'7$&'$,5(-(&'61'7$6*2(=$


'

!G#$

@0$()*$&2,E*$E*/2&3$6*-%/1.(1,'$)&-$',($%,'E1'%*6$()*$/*&6*/8$

()*$ '5+*/1%&3$ 1335-(/&(1,'-$ 1'$ >&-)K-$ 2,,B$ :133$ +&B*$ 1($ %3*&/$ ()&($

01'&'%1'7$E1&$@AC$E*/-5-$,5(-16*$3*'6*/-$1-$&$?',$2/&1'*/D$1'$(*/+-$,0$

*'61'7$5.$:1()$2,()$()*$.5/%)&-*6$&--*($&'6$+,/*$'*($:*&3()=$JQ,$

/*.*&(8$10$&$.*/-,'$)&-$2513($5.$)1-$.,31%4$-5001%1*'(348$)*$%&'$01'&'%*$

&$'*:$%&/$.5/%)&-*$%,+.3*(*34$,5($,0$()*$61E16*'6-8$/&()*/$()&'$24$

(&B1'7$,5($&'$&%(5&3$3,&'$&7&1'-($()*$.,31%4=L$

^)*'$ %,'-16*/1'7$ &'$ 1'61E165&3$ :),$ 254-$ &$ '*:$ %&/$ :1()$

,5(-16*$01'&'%1'78$%,+.&/*6$(,$-,+*,'*$:),$5-*-$()*$@AC$&../,&%)8$

-,+*$ ,0$ ()*$ 3&((*/K-$ &6E&'(&7*$ 1-$ -1+.34$ 65*$ (,$ ()*$ 0&%($ ()&($ ()*$

.*/-,'$5-1'7$@AC$)&-$./*E1,5-34$0).$/$()*$'*%*--&/4$%&.1(&3$1'$,/6*/$

(,$.5/%)&-*$()*$%&/=$Y,$.&/($,0$()*$/*&-,'$-,$+&'4$.*,.3*$)&E*$)&6$

()*1/$31E*-$(/&'-0,/+*6$()/,57)$@AC8$1-$()&($1($)&-$1'-(133*6$61-%1.31'*$

1'$ ()*1/$),5-*),36$ 01'&'%*-$&'6$()*4$-&E*$&$)17)*/$.,/(1,'$,0$ ()*1/$

1'%,+*$()&'$ ()*4$616$./*E1,5-34=$ @'$,'*$-*'-*$ ()1-$ 1-$&'$?&..3*-$ (,$

,/&'7*-D$ %,+.&/1-,'$ ()*'8$ :)*'$ *E&35&(1'7$ ()*$ &6E&'(&7*-$ ,0$ @AC$

E*/-5-$ ()*$ (4.1%&3$ O+*/1%&'$ ),5-*),36K-$ &../,&%)$ (,$ %/*61($ %&/6-8$

&5(,$01'&'%1'78$&'6$2&'B$+,/(7&7*-=$

@'$ ,()*/$ :,/6-8$ .&/($ ,0$ ()*$ ?+&71%D$ ,0$ @AC$ 1-$ -1+.34$ ()&($ 1($

*'%,5/&7*-$),5-*),36-$(,$0).$'57$2*0,/*$+&B1'7$.5/%)&-*-8$/&()*/$

()&'$2541'7$%&/-$&'6$,()*/$7,,61*-$24$7,1'7$1'(,$6*2(=$Q)1-$&-.*%($,0$

@ACK-$ &6E&'(&7*-$ )&-$ ',()1'7$ (,$ 6,$ 1'(/1'-1%&334$ :1()$ :),3*$ 310*$

1'-5/&'%*8$ 25($ /*03*%(-$ ()*$ ,2E1,5-$ 0&%($ ()&($ .*,.3*$ :),$ 6*0*/$


'

!GP$

%,'-5+.(1,'$*'6$5.$:*&3()1*/$,E*/$(1+*8$%,+.&/*6$(,$.*,.3*$:),$

-.*'6$()*1/$:),3*$.&4%)*%B$&-$-,,'$&-$1($%,+*-$1'$()*$6,,/=$

X&E1'7$-&16$&33$()&(8$1($1-$-(133$5'6*'1&23*$()&($+,-($O+*/1%&'-$

&/*$ ',($ /,2,(1%$ +,'*4%)&'7*/-8$ %),,-1'7$ ()*$ -(/1%(34$ ?,.(1+&3D$

-(/&(*74$ :)*'$ 1($ %,+*-$ (,$ ()*1/$ 01'&'%*-=$ Q)*/*$ 1-$ &$ 6*01'1(*$

7062%"3"4-2)3$ /*1'0,/%*+*'($ ()&($ ()*$ @AC$.)13,-,.)4$71E*-$ (,$+&'4$

),5-*),36-$:),$)&E*$2*75'$./&%(1%1'7$1(=$Q)1-$/*1'0,/%*+*'($1-$R5-($

&-$ ?/*&3D$ &-$ ,()*/$ 0&%(,/-$ :)*'$ %,'-16*/1'7$ E&/1,5-$ 01'&'%1&3$

-(/&(*71*-8$&'6$1($-),536$',($2*$61-+1--*6$&-$1//*3*E&'(=#$Y1+.34$.5(8$

.*,.3*$&/*$+5%)$+,/*$31B*34$(,$-,%B$&:&4$+,'*4$:)*'$()*4$E1*:$1($

*"+'&-8$?Y&E1'7$:)&(*E*/$1-$3*0($,E*/$()1-$+,'()D$&'6$1'-(*&6$E1*:$1($

&-8$ ?Q)1-$ 1-$ +4$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ ./*+15+8$ :)1%)$ @$ '**6$ (,$ +&B*$ 1'$

,/6*/$(,$B**.$+4$.,31%4$1'$0,/%*8$&'6$&3-,$1($05'6-$()*$1'%/*&-*$1'$+4$

%&-)$E&35*-$-,$@$%&'$2,//,:$1($3&(*/$,'$:)*'$@$'**6$1(=D$

^*$-),536$&3-,$+*'(1,'$()&($()*$&2131(4$(,$01'&'%*$.5/%)&-*-$

()/,57)$ .,31%4$ 3,&'-$ %&'$ %&//4$ .&/(1%53&/$ &6E&'(&7*-$ 0,/$ .,31%4$

,:'*/-$ :),$ &3-,$ /5'$ ()*1/$ ,:'$ 25-1'*--*-=$ `,/$ *M&+.3*8$ ()*$

),5-*),36$+&4$.5/%)&-*$&$%&/$J5-1'7$&$.,31%4$3,&'L$&'6$()*'$3*&-*$1($

(,$ ()*$ 25-1'*--=$ Q)*$ 3*&-*$ .&4+*'($ :,536$ ()*'$ 2*$ &$ 25-1'*--$

*M.*'-*=$O',()*/$.,.53&/$./&%(1%*$1-$0,/$6*'(1-(-$&'6$,()*/$+*61%&3$

./,0*--1,'&3-$ (,$ 5-*$ .,31%4$ 3,&'-$ (,$ .5/%)&-*$ *M.*'-1E*$ ,001%*$

*T51.+*'(8$ &'6$ ()*'$ 3*&-*$ 1($ (,$ ()*1/$,:'$./&%(1%*-=$Q)1-$ %&'$41*36$

-17'101%&'($-&E1'7-$%,+.&/*6$(,$-**B1'7$,5(-16*$3*'6*/-=$e*($&',()*/$

16*&$1-$(,$5-*$.,31%4$3,&'-$(,$&33,:$.&(1*'(-$(,$.&4$,'$%/*61(8$:)1%)$


'

!G[$

&33,:-$()*$6*'(1-($J0,/$*M&+.3*L$(,$1'%/*&-*$)1-$-&3*-$:)13*$,00*/1'7$

2*((*/$01'&'%1'7$(*/+-$(,$)1-$.&(1*'(-$()&'$()*4$%,536$)&E*$,2(&1'*6$

0/,+$&$()1/6$.&/(4=$

Y,+*(1+*-$ 61-%5--1,'-$ ,0$ ()*$ +&'4$ .,--12131(1*-$ ,0$ @AC9

&0(*/$&338$1($1-$%&33*6$()*$D*1-*-+$$A&'B1'7$C,'%*.(93*&6$()*$-B*.(1%&3$

,5(-16*/$(,$()1'B8$?Q)1-$1-$(,,$7,,6$(,$2*$(/5*=$^)&(K-$()*$%&(%)f$X,:$

%&'$@$7*'*/&(*$+,'*4$0/,+$',()1'7fD$

`,/(5'&(*348$ ()*/*$ 1-$ &$ -(/&17)(0,/:&/6$ &'-:*/N$ @(K-$ ',($ (,,$

7,,6$ (,$2*$ (/5*=$Y*((1'7$&-16*$ ()*$.-4%),3,71%&3$+,(1E&(1,'$ (,$ -&E*$

+,/*8$()*$&6E&'(&7*$,0$2,//,:1'7$0/,+$,'*K-$310*$1'-5/&'%*$.,31%49

&-$,..,-*6$(,$-**B1'7$,5(-16*$01'&'%1'791-$-1+.3*N$Q)*$3,&'$/&(*$1-$

3,:*/=$Q)1-$ 1-$:)4$&$6*'(&3$./&%(1%*8$ 0,/$*M&+.3*8$:133$ *'6$5.$:1()$

0&/$+,/*$:*&3()$&0(*/$&$0*:$4*&/-$,0$-*30I01'&'%1'78$()&'$10$1($/*31*6$,'$

%,'E*'(1,'&3$3*'6*/-=$

Q)*/*$ 1-$ ',()1'7$ +&71%&3$ &2,5($ ()1-$ 0&%(=$ Q)*$ ($)0"*$ ()*$

1'-5/*/$1-$:1331'7$(,$3*'6$&($-5%)$/*&-,'&23*$(*/+-8$1-$()&($1($)&-$()*$

.,31%4K-$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01($ &-$ %,33&(*/&3=$ ^)&($ ()1-$ +*&'-$ 1-$ ()&(8$ 10$ ()*$

6*'(1-($ -),536$ 7*($ )1($ 24$ &$ 25-$ :)13*$ )*$ -(133$ )&-$ &$ g#;8;;;$

,5(-(&'61'7$ 3,&'8$ ()*'$)1-$:16,:$,/$,()*/$2*'*01%1&/4$:133$7*($ ()&($

+5%)$3,..*6$,00$()*$6*&()$2*'*01($%)*%B=$

`,/$()1-$/*&-,'8$ 1($ 1-$ 1+.,/(&'($ 0,/$(),-*$:),$&/*$ 1'(*/*-(*6$

1'$ @AC$ (,$ 6,$ (:,$ ()1'7-N$ `1/-(8$ ()*4$ -),536$ +&B*$ -5/*$ ()*$

2*'*01%1&/1*-$ ,0$ ()*1/$ .,31%1*-$ 5'6*/-(&'6$ ()*$ 1+.31%&(1,'-U$ ()*$

1'-5/&'%*$ %,+.&'4$ 6,*-'K($ :&'($ &'7/4$ :16,:-$ 6*+&'61'7$ ?0533$


'

!G"$

.&4+*'(D$&0(*/$&'$@AC$&01%1,'&6,$61*-$,0$&$)*&/($&((&%B$&($d!=$Y*%,'68$

(),-*$ ./&%(1%1'7$ @AC$ -),536$ +&B*$ -5/*$ ()&($ ()*4$ &/*$ '*E*/$

2,//,:1'7$-,$+5%)$&7&1'-($()*1/$.,31%1*-8$&-$(,$3*&E*$&$),3*$1'$()*1/$

),5-*),36$01'&'%1&3$.3&'$1'$()*$*E*'($,0$&'$5'(1+*34$6*&()=$@'$,()*/$

:,/6-8$10$&$),5-*),36K-$01'&'%1&3$.3&'$/*T51/*-$gF=#$+1331,'$1'$6*&()$

2*'*01($ .&4+*'(-$ 1'$ ,/6*/$ 0,/$ ()*$2*'*01%1&/4$ (,$.&4$,00$ 6*2(-$ &'6$

31E*$ %,+0,/(&234$ :1(),5($ ()*$ +&R,/$ 2/*&6:1''*/8$ ()*'$ 10$ ()&($

2/*&6:1''*/$1-$./&%(1%1'7$@AC8$)*$,/$-)*$-),536$,'34$2,//,:$&7&1'-($

()*$.,/(1,'$,0$()*$6*&()$2*'*01($()&($1-$1'$$E2$00$,0$gF=#$+1331,'=$@AC$1-$

&$ (*%)'1T5*$ (,$ )#73-16$ ()*$ 2*'*01(-$ ,0$ 1'-5/&'%*U$ 1($ -),536$ ',($ 2*$

5-*6$1'$&$:&4$()&($6*0*&(-$()*$,/171'&3$.5/.,-*$,0$310*$1'-5/&'%*=$

$

+"&(2/345#(3.(,-%&'&7%(97:(%"&(6+)#(3.(,-%&'&7%(

$

@'$ ()1-$ 2,,B8$ :*$ %3&1+$ ()&($ ()*$ ?+,'*4$ +&-(*/-D$ 1'$ ()*$

7,E*/'+*'($ &'6$ +&R,/$ +*61&$ )&E*$ .533*6$ &$ 71&'($ %,'$ ,'$ ()*$

O+*/1%&'$.5231%=$^)*'$1($%,+*-$(,$1'03&(1,'8$0,/$*M&+.3*8$O+*/1%&'-$

&/*$ *'%,5/&7*6$ (,$ 3,,B$ &($ E133&1',5-$ O/&2$ '&(1,'-8$ 7/**64$

%,/.,/&(1,'-8$ ,/$ 7/&-.1'7$ 3&2,/$ 5'1,'-=$ O+*/1%&'-$ &/*$ *"+$ (,36$ (,$

3,,B$&($()*$(/5*$-,5/%*$,0$()*$1'03&(1,'8$'&+*34$()*$`*6*/&3$<*-*/E*$

&'6$ 0/&%(1,'&3$ /*-*/E*$ 2&'B1'7$ -4-(*+=$ @($ 1-$ ()*$ +&71%1&'K-$ %3&--1%$

/5-*$,0$+1-61/*%(1,'=$

`,/$&',()*/$*M&+.3*8$1'$O+*/1%&$?*E*/42,64$B',:-D$()&($()*$

-+&/($ ()1'7$ (,$ 6,$ 0,/$ /*(1/*+*'($ .3&''1'7$ 1-$ (,$ %,'(/125(*$ ()*$


'

!GG$

+&M1+5+$&+,5'($1'(,$(&MIT5&3101*6$+5(5&3$05'6-$4*&/$1'8$4*&/$,5(=$

Q)*$16*&$,0$5-1'7$310*$1'-5/&'%*$&-$&$+*(),6$,0$/*(1/*+*'($.3&''1'7$

1-$ -,$ 0,/*17'8$ ()&($ ()*$ T5,(&(1,'-$ 1'$ ()1-$ 2,,B$ (,$ ()&($ *00*%($ 0/,+$

h56:17$E,'$Z1-*-$-,5'6$),.*3*--34$&'&%)/,'1-(1%=$

O'6$ ,0$ %,5/-*8$ ()*$ 2177*-($ %,'$ ,0$ &33$ :&-$ (,$ %,'E1'%*$

O+*/1%&'-$ ()&($ 7/**'$ .,/(/&1(-$ ,0$ b=Y=$ ./*-16*'(-$ &/*$ &$ .*/0*%(34$

',/+&3$ ()1'7$ (,$5-*$ 0,/$+,'*4=$b-1'7$ 7,36$ &'6$ -13E*/$:&-$ ?-,$FG()$

%*'(5/4=D$

O3,'7$()*-*$31'*-8$>*3-,'$>&-)$)&-$0,5'6$&',()*/$*M&+.3*$,0$

()*$01'&'%1&3$17',/&'%*$,0$()*$O+*/1%&'$.5231%N$()*$0,%5-$,'$()*$()+$$

,0$ 1'(*/*-($ J,/$ 41*36L$ /&()*/$ ()&'$ ()*$ ."35#$$ ,0$ 1'(*/*-(=$ C,'-16*/$

>&-)K-$61&7',-1-$,0$()*$01'&'%1&3$-1(5&(1,'$,0$+1663*I%3&--$O+*/1%&N$

$Y*E*/&3$ 4*&/-$ &7,$ @$ 616$ &$ 7,,6$ 21($ ,0$ -(564$ ,'$ ()*$

-.*'61'7$)&21(-$,0$O+*/1%&'$ 0&+131*-=S@$25136$ -%*'&/1,-$&/,5'6$

()*$ ?O33IO+*/1%&'$ 0&+134D$ 2*%&5-*$ @$ 6,'K($ :&'($ .*,.3*$ (,$ ()1'B$

4,5$)&E*$(,$2*$/1%)$(,$%/*&(*$&$2&'B1'7$-4-(*+$()&($%&'$)&'63*$&33$

4,5/$'**6-$0,/$01'&'%*=$iW5/$)4.,()*(1%&3j$4,5'7$+&'$1-$!G$4*&/-$

,36$&'6$1-$+&B1'7$g!"8#;;$.*/$4*&/$&0(*/$(&M*-=$^)&($6,*-$)*$6,$

:1()$()*$&0(*/I(&M$1'%,+*f$

Q:*'(4$ .*/%*'($ 1-$ -.*'($ ,'$ (/&'-.,/(&(1,'8$ ()1/(4$

.*/%*'($1-$-.*'($,'$),5-1'78$0,/(4I01E*$.*/%*'($1-$-.*'($,'$?31E1'7D$

J%3,()*-8$ 7/,%*/1*-8$ %,'(/125(1,'-$ (,$ /*3171,5-$ &'6$ %)&/1(&23*$

%&5-*-8$ 2,&($ .&4+*'(-8$ %&-5&3(4$ 1'-5/&'%*$ ,'$ %&/-8$ E&%&(1,'-8$

*(%SL=$ X*$ 1-$ -&E1'7$ 3*--$ ()&'$ 01E*$ .*/%*'($ ,0$ 61-.,-&23*$ 1'%,+*=$


'

];;$

A5(8$(,$2*$&-$7*'*/,5-$&-$.,--123*8$3*(K-$&--5+*$()&($)*$1-$-&E1'7$

+$*'7$(2$*+$&'6$-.*'61'7$,'34$0,/(4$.*/%*'($,'$31E1'7$*M.*'-*-S$

Q)*$./,23*+$1-$()&($&33$()*-*$1(*+-$&/*$1-*)*2$/$24$,()*/$

2&'B1'7$,/7&'1H&(1,'-=$O'$&5(,+,213*$01'&'%1'7$.&%B&7*$0,/$()1-$

)4.,()*(1%&3$ .*/-,'$ 1-$ gF;8##;$ 0,/$ d"$ +,'()-$ :1()$ &'$ 1'(*/*-($

/&(*$,0$&($3*&-($"=#k$:1()$.&4+*'(-$,0$g!P;=;#$.*/$+,'()=$A5(8$10$

4,5$:133$ %)*%B$:1()$ ()*$ -&3*-$+&'&7*/$,0$ &'$&5(,+,213*$&7*'%4$

4,5$:133$01'6$()&($G#k$,0$()*$%&/-$()&($&/*$(/&6*6$1'$)($'*"+'7)-/'

1"(F$Q)1-$+*&'-8$&($()*$*'6$,0$];$+,'()-8$10$()*$%&/$1-$(/&6*68$!Fk$

,0$*E*/4$.&4+*'($6,33&/$1-$-*+$($0+S$

>,:$3*(K-$+,E*$(,$()*$),5-1'7$-1(5&(1,'=$Q)1-$4,5'7$+&'$

%&'$ T5&3104$ 0,/$ &$ ];$ 4*&/$ 01M*6I/&(*$ +,/(7&7*$ 1'$ ()*$ &+,5'($ ,0$

&2,5($gG]8;;;$&($&$01M*6$1'(*/*-($/&(*$,0$[k$OV<$:1()$.&4+*'(-$

,0$gPF"=[#$&'6$%3,-1'7$%,-(-$,0$-,+*$g!8#;;=$Q)*$./,23*+$1-$()&($

:1()1'$ #$ 4*&/-$ )*$ :133$ +,E*$ (,$ &',()*/$ %1(48$ &%/,--$ (,:'8$ ,/$

/*01'&'%*$()*$+,/(7&7*=$Y,+*()1'7$)&..*'-$(,$&$+,/(7&7*$:1()1'$

#$4*&/-=$ @'%3561'7$()*$%3,-1'7$%,-(-$&'6$1'(*/*-($.&16$,5($65/1'7$

()*-*$P;$+,'()-$)*$)&6$.&16$g]G8P!#8$25($,'34$g#8d#"$)&-$7,'*$

(,$/*65%*$()*$3,&'=$Q)1-$+*&'-$g]d8FP[$)&-$7,'*$(,$1'(*/*-($&'6$

%3,-1'7$%,-(-Siej,5$01'6$()&($GHI'"1'$.$(6'/"33)('7)-/'"5+'4"$0'+"'

+%$'2"0+'"1'1-*)*2-*4F==='

>,:8$&66$5.$&33$()*$1'(*/*-($)*$1-$.&41'7$,5($&'6$4,5$01'6$

()&($]d=#$%*'(-$,0$*E*/4$61-.,-&23*$6,33&/$.&16$,5($1-$-*+$($0+=$`,/$

()*$&E*/&7*$O33IO+*/1%&'$+&3*$()1-$./,.,/(1,'$*$.$('2%)*4$0S=@0$

4,5$:133$ 7*($ ()1-$ 4,5'7$+&'$ (,7*()*/$:1()$)1-$ .**/-$ &($ &$ %,00**$

2/*&B$,/$-,+*$-5%)$7&()*/1'7$&'6$)&E*$,'*$,0$()*+$-577*-($()&($

()*4$ 61-%5--$ 01'&'%1&3$ +&((*/-8$ @$ %&'$ ./*61%($ :)&($ ()*4$ :133$ (&3B$

&2,5(97*((1'7$ &$ %-4%' ()+$' "1' ($+5(*$ ,'$ ()*$ .,/(1,'$ ()*4$ &/*$


'

];F$

-&E1'7_$Z*&':)13*8$*E*/4$.&/(1%1.&'($1'$()*$%,'E*/-&(1,'$1-$6,1'7$

()*$&2,E*_P$

$

>,:$,'*$,0$()*$./*-*'($&5(),/-$1-$&$./,0*--1,'&3$*%,',+1-(8$

&'6$ )*$ %&'$ &'(1%1.&(*$ &$ (4.1%&3$ /*&%(1,'$ (,$ >&-)K-$ 61-%5--1,'=$ O$

?-,.)1-(1%&(*6D$01'&'%1&3$.3&''*/$+17)($/*&6$>&-)K-$61&7',-1-$,0$()*$

./,23*+$ 0&%1'7$ O+*/1%&'$ ),5-*),36-$ &'6$ -&48$ ?<5221-)_$ W0$ 2"5(0$$

1'(*/*-($/&(*-$+&((*/_$Y5..,-*$()*/*$&/*$(:,$),5-*),36-$+&B1'7$()*$

-&+*$&''5&3$1'%,+*8$&'6$05/()*/$-5..,-*$()&($()*4$6*E,(*$()*$-&+*$

0/&%(1,'$ ,0$ ()*1/$ 61-.,-&23*$ 1'%,+*$ (,$ 01'&'%*$ %)&/7*-$ *E*/4$

+,'()91'$,()*/$:,/6-8$()*4$+&B*$()*$-&+*$&+,5'($,0$+,'*4$&'6$

&3-,$ .&4$ ,5($ ()*$ -&+*$ lE,35+*$ ,0$ 1'(*/*-(K$ 1'$ >&-)K-$ (*/+1',3,74=$

Q)*$ ,'34$ 6100*/*'%*$ 1-8$ ()*$ 01/-($ ),5-*),36K-$ 6*2(-$ /,33$ ,E*/$ &($ Fk8$

:)*/*&-$ ()*$ -*%,'6$ ),5-*),36K-$ 6*2(-$ /,33$ ,E*/$ &($ F;k=$ >,:$

&%%,/61'7$(,$>&-)8$2,()$),5-*),36-$&/*$1'$()*$-&+*$2,&(8$-1'%*$()*4$

)&E*$()*$-&+*$E,35+*$,0$1'(*/*-($.&4+*'(-=$A5($()&(K-$'5(-U$:1()$()*$

-&+*$1'%,+*8$()*$.*,.3*$1'$),5-*),36$O$31E*$1'$&$+&'-1,'$&'6$6/1E*$

X5++*/-8$:)*/*&-$()*$.*,.3*$1'$),5-*),36$A$31E*$1'$&$(:,I2*6/,,+$

),5-*$ &'6$ 6/1E*$ m,3E,-=$ W0$ 2"5(0$$ 1'(*/*-($ /&(*-$ +&((*/8$ &'6$ ,0$

2"5(0$$ 1(K-$2*((*/$(,$*&/'$&$)17)*/$41*36$,'$4,5/$1'E*-(+*'(-$()&'$&$

3,:*/$41*36=D$

Q)1-$-(&'6&/6$/*&-,'1'7$1-$%,//*%($&-$0&/$&-$1($7,*-N$e*-8$-1'&$'

1-E'+%$'."35#$'"1'-*+$($0+')'%"50$%"3/'&-33'7)6'+"'"5+0-/$(0'-*'1-*)*2$'

2%)(4$0'$.$(6'#"*+%,'()*'$()*$3,:*/$()*$1'(*/*-($/&(*$2*1'7$%)&/7*68$


'

];!$

()*$ )17)*/$ ()*$ ),5-*),36K-$ -(&'6&/6$ ,0$ 31E1'7=$ Q)1-$ 1-$ 65*$ (,$ ()*$

-1+.3*$0&%($()&($0,/$&$01M*6$6,33&/$&+,5'($,0$01'&'%*$%)&/7*-8$&$3,:*/$

1'(*/*-($/&(*$:133$&33,:$()*$),5-*),36$(,$(&B*$,'$)'4($)+$(')#"5*+'"1'

/$:+$&'6$()5-$(,$254$2177*/$),5-*-8$0&'%1*/$%&/-8$&'6$+,/*$E&%&(1,'$

%/51-*-=$

A5($>&-)$1-$.3*&61'7$:1()$O+*/1%&'-$(,$0+"7'3$++-*4'0"2-$+6')+'

3)(4$' +$33' 6"5'&%)+' +%$' J7("7$(K')#"5*+'"1' "5+0-/$' 1-*)*2-*4' 0%"53/'

:$F$ @'$ ,()*/$ :,/6-8$ :*$ 6,'K($ '**6$ (,$ ?01MD$ ()*$ E,35+*$ ,0$ 1'(*/*-($

.&4+*'(-$ 7,1'7$ ,5($ ()*$ 6,,/$ *E*/4$ +,'()8$ &'6$ ()*'$ :1()1'$ ()&($

0/&+*:,/B$-%/&+23*$0,/$()*$2*-($6*&3-$(,$/,33$,E*/$,5/$+,5'(&1'$,0$

6*2(=$

C,'-16*/$()*$/*%*'($),5-1'7$2,,+$1'$()*$b'1(*6$Y(&(*-=$^)*'$

O3&'$ n/**'-.&'$ %5($ ()*$ 0*6*/&3$ 05'6-$ (&/7*($ /&(*91'$ ,/6*/$ (,$

./,E16*$&$?-,0($ 3&'61'7D$&0(*/$()*$6,(I%,+$%/&-)9()1-$.533*6$6,:'$

3,'7I(*/+$ 1'(*/*-($ /&(*-8$ 1'%3561'7$ %,'E*'(1,'&3$ +,/(7&7*$ /&(*-=$

>,:$10$O+*/1%&'-$)&6$%,'(1'5*6$(,$254$()*$-&+*$(4.*-$,0$),5-*-$&-$

()*4$ )&6$ &($ ()*$ )17)*/$ +,/(7&7*$ /&(*-8$ ()*'$ n/**'-.&'K-$

1'(*/E*'(1,'$ :,536KE*$ -1+.34$ (/&'-3&(*6$ 1'(,$ 3,:*/$ +,/(7&7*$

.&4+*'(-$0,/$()*$(4.1%&3$),5-*),368$&'6$)*'%*$+,/*$+,'*4$3*0($,E*/$

*&%)$ +,'()$ 0,/$ 61'1'7$ ,5(8$ +*61%&3$ 2133-8$ (51(1,'8$ ,/96&/*$ :*$ -&4$

1(f90,/$0).-*4=$

W0$%,5/-*8$()&(K-$',($:)&($+,-($O+*/1%&'-$616$:)*'$2541'7$&$

'*:$ ),+*$ 1'$ ()*$ .*/1,6$ !;;!$ o$ !;;#=$ @'-(*&68$ ()*4$ 5-*6$ ()*$

?*M.*/(D$/53*$,0$ ()5+2$(,$6*(*/+1'*$),:$+5%)$,0$,'*K-$61-.,-&23*$


'

];]$

1'%,+*$ ?-),536D$ 7,$ (,$ &$ +,/(7&7*$ .&4+*'(=$ O($ ()*$ &2-5/634$ 3,:$

+,/(7&7*$/&(*-8$()1-$&5(,+&(1%$6*E,(1,'$,0$&$01M*6$6,33&/$&+,5'($(,$

+,'()34$ ),5-1'7$ *M.*'-*-8$ (/&'-3&(*6$ 1'(,$ &$ :1331'7'*--$ (,$ 254$

+5%)$ +,/*$ *M.*'-1E*$ ),5-*-=$ @'$ ,()*/$ :,/6-8$ +&'4$ O+*/1%&'-$

616'K($01/-($6*%16*$:)&($(4.*$,0$),5-*$()*4$:&'(*68$&'6$()*'$-,57)($

&$ 3,&'$ (,$ .5/%)&-*$ 1(=$ >,8$ +&'4$ O+*/1%&'-$ :,/B*6$ ()*$ ,()*/$ :&48$

01/-($ -(&/(1'7$ ,5($ :1()$ ()*$ T5*-(1,'8$ ?X,:$ +5%)$ ,0$ &$ +,/(7&7*$

.&4+*'($ %&'$ :*$ &00,/6fD$ &'6$ ()*'$ -**1'7$ ?),:$ +5%)$ ),5-*D$ ()*4$

%,536$7*($0,/$1(=$

@'$ ()1-$ .&/(1%53&/$ *M&+.3*8$ ,0$ %,5/-*8$ ()*$ (/&7*64$ :&-$ ()&($

+,/(7&7*$ /&(*-$ *E*'(5&334$ (5/'*6$ 2&%B$ 5.8$ &'6$ ()*$ 25223*$

*E*'(5&334$.,..*6=$O($()&($.,1'(8$+&'4$O+*/1%&'-9*-.*%1&334$(),-*$

:),$ )&6$ 2,57)($ &$ ),5-*$ 0,/$ .5/*34$ -.*%53&(1E*$ /*&-,'-8$ &'6$

01'&'%*6$1($:1()$&'$&6R5-(&23*$/&(*$+,/(7&7*$JO<ZL9:*/*$%&57)($1'$

&$(*//123*$./*61%&+*'(N$Q)*4$:*/*$5'6*/:&(*/$,'$&$),5-*$0,/$:)1%)$

()*4$%,536'K($&00,/6$()*$+,/(7&7*$.&4+*'(-=$

A5($ *E*'$ 1'$ &'$ *'E1/,'+*'($,0$ -(&23*$ 1'(*/*-($ /&(*-8$:*$ -**$

()*$ ./,23*+$ ()&($ >&-)$ )&-$ 16*'(101*6N$ Q,,$ +&'4$ ),5-*),36-$ .&4$

()*1/$2133-$*E*/4$+,'()$&'6$()*'$01'68$?Q)*/*K-$',()1'7$3*0(_D$aE*'$10$

&$-.,5-*$(&B*-$&$-*%,'6$R,28$ 1($-**+-$()*/*$1-$',$:&4$(,$7*($&)*&6=$

Z&'4$),5-*),36-$/*+&1'$,'*$-1%B'*--$,/$3&4,00$&:&4$0/,+$01'&'%1&3$

/51'=$

Q)*/*$&/*$+&'4$/*&-,'-$0,/$()1-8$1'%3561'7$.5'1(1E*$(&M*-$&'6$

()*$ 2,,+I25-($ %4%3*$ 1(-*30=$ A5($ >&-)$ )&-$ .,1'(*6$ ,5($ ()&($ +5%)$ ,0$


'

];d$

()*$ /*-.,'-12131(4$ 31*-$ :1()$ ()*$ ),5-*),36-$ ()*+-*3E*-8$ 1'$ ()*1/$

&((1(56*$(,:&/6$6*2(=$Q)*/*$1-$',()1'7$?'&(5/&3D$&2,5($.&41'7$&$)57*$

0/&%(1,'$,0$61-.,-&23*$ 1'%,+*$ (,$,5(-16*$ 3*'6*/-$*E*/4$+,'()=$Q)*$

,'34$ /*&-,'$ 1($ -**+-$ '&(5/&3$ 1-$ ()&($ ?*E*/4,'*K-$ 6,1'7$ 1(8D$ 25($ ,5/$

+,()*/-$ -5..,-*634$ /*05(*6$ +%)+$ .&/(1%53&/$ R5-(101%&(1,'$ 1'$ ,5/$

%)136),,6-=$

O-$&$-1+.3*$*M.*/1+*'(8$:*$&-B$()*$/*&6*/$(,$75*--9:1(),5($

3,,B1'79),:$ +5%)$ )1-$ ,/$ )*/$ ),5-*),36$ -.*'6-$ .5/*34$ ,'$

1-*)*2-*4'2%)(4$0$*&%)$+,'()=$^/1(*$()1-$75*--$6,:'=$Q)*'8$()*$'*M($

(1+*$ ()*$ /*&6*/$ .&4-$ ()*$ 2133-8$ %&3%53&(*$ ()*$ &%(5&3$ '5+2*/=$

<*+*+2*/$()&($1($1'%356*-$',($R5-($,2E1,5-$1(*+-$-5%)$&-$()*$*M.31%1($

01'&'%*$%)&/7*-$,'$%/*61($%&/6-8$25($&3-,$()*$%,+.,'*'($,0$+,/(7&7*$

&'6$%&/$.&4+*'(-$()&($6,*-'K($7,$(,$./1'%1.&3$/*65%(1,'=$

Q)*$ /*-53($ :133$ ./,2&234$ -),%B$ +,-($ /*&6*/-=$ ^)&($ ()*$

'5+2*/$ +*&'-8$ 1-$ ()&($ ()1-$ 1-$ ),:$ +5%)$ $E+()' J-*2"#$K' ()*$

),5-*),36$ :,536$ )&E*$ *&%)$ +,'()8$ 10$ 1(-$ 6*2(-$ +&71%&334$

61-&..*&/*6=$ @($ -),:-$ ),:$ +5%)$ 7)0+$ 6*%1-1,'-$ (,$ &%%5+53&(*$

6*2(9(,$ -.*'6$ 2*4,'6$ ()*$ ),5-*),36K-$ +*&'-$ &($ ()*$ (1+*9&/*$

%,'-(/&1'1'7$()*$),5-*),36K-$25(($*+$01'&'%*-=$

>,$ ,'*$ 31B*-$ &$ .&-(,/$ :),$ %3&1+-$ (,$ 2*$ -1'3*--8$ &'6$ ()*$

./*-*'($&5(),/-$0/**34$&6+1($()&($()*4$)&E*$2**'$R5-($&-$-5-%*.(123*$

(,$()*$.*/E*/(*6$E1-1,'$,0$?()*$O+*/1%&'$6/*&+D$&-$&'4,'*$*3-*=$W5/$

.,1'($1'$()1-$-*%(1,'$1-$',($(,$:&7$,5/$01'7*/-$&($()*$/*&6*/$&'6$-%,36$

)1+$,/$)*/$0,/$1//*-.,'-123*$./,617&31(4=$


'

];#$

W'$()*$%,'(/&/48$,5/$),.*$1-$(,$)*3.$()*$/*&6*/$24$/-)4*"0-*4'

+%$'7(":3$#=$W'%*$()*$./,23*+$1-$ 16*'(101*69'&+*348$ (&B1'7$,'$ 0&/$

(,,$ +5%)$ *M(*/'&3$ 6*2(9()*$ -,35(1,'$ 1-$ 231'61'734$ ,2E1,5-N$

X,5-*),36-$'**6$(,$3-.$'&-+%-*'+%$-('#$)*0=$Q)*4$'**6$(,$0).$'#"($=$

Q)*4$'**6$(,$.,-(.,'*$217I(1%B*($.5/%)&-*-$2*%&5-*$?:*$ R5-($6,'K($

)&E*$()*$+,'*4$4*(=D$

Q)*$+&1'$16*&-$1'$()1-$2,,B$&/*$T51(*$-1+.3*=$^*$-(/*--$()&($

+,'*4$-),536$2*$-,5'68$2&'B1'7$-),536$2*$),'*-(8$&'6$),5-*),36-$

-),536$2*$ 0/57&3=$Y,+*),:$()*$E1/(5*$,0$ ()/10(9&$.*''4$-&E*6$ 1-$&$

.*''4$ *&/'*692*%&+*$ 4*($ &',()*/$ %&-5&3(4$ ,0$ ?+,6*/'$

*%,',+1%-=D$

@($ -0'.,--123*$ (,$-&3E&7*$4,5/$),5-*),36K-$ 01'&'%1&3$-1(5&(1,'8$

6*-.1(*$ ()*$-)&%B3*-$.5($ 1'$.3&%*$24$.,:*/053$ 0,/%*-=$A5($4,5$6,'K($

-(&'6$ &$ %)&'%*$ 10$ 4,5$ &33,:$ ()*-*$ -&+*$ 0,/%*-$ (,$ 6*-17'$ 4,5/$

235*./1'($0,/$*-%&.*=$O-$,'$-,$+&'4$,()*/$(,.1%-8$:)*'$1($%,+*-$(,$

01'&'%1'7$ 6*%1-1,'-$ O+*/1%&'-$ -),536$ %,'-53($ ()*$ 3*&61'7$

?*M.*/(-D9&'6$()*'$6,$()*$,..,-1(*=$

$

0&43;/-2(<3='(>?-(0#-1&'(

$

@($1-$*&-4$(,$7*($3,-($1'$()*$6*(&13-$,0$.&/(1%53&/$&..31%&(1,'-$,0$

()*$ @AC$ ./,%*--=$ @'$ ()*$ 7/&'6$ -%)*+*8$ :)&($ >*3-,'$ >&-)$ 1-$

/*%,++*'61'7$ 1-$ T51(*$ -1+.3*N$ X*$ &6E1-*-$ *E*/4$ ),5-*),36$ (,$ 7,$

1'(,$()*$2&'B1'7$25-1'*--8$1'$&661(1,'$(,$:)&(*E*/$,()*/$-,5/%*-$,0$


'

];P$

1'%,+*$1($*'R,4-=$X,:*E*/8$&'$@AC$2&'B$1-$-.*%1&3$1'$()&($1($)&-$,'34$

,'*$?6*.,-1(,/DN$()*$.*/-,'$:),$,:'-$1(=$@'$()1-$:&48$()*$),5-*),36$

2&'B1'7$ ,.*/&(1,'$ 1-$ ',($ -52R*%($ (,$ ()*$ '5+*/,5-$ /*753&(1,'-$

%,'%*/'1'7$%,'E*'(1,'&3$2&'B-8$2*%&5-*$()*$,'34$.*/-,'K-$:*&3()$&($

/1-B$1-$()*$,'*$+&B1'7$310*$1'-5/&'%*$./*+15+$.&4+*'(-=$

W'%*$ -,+*,'*$ )&-$ 2513($ 5.$ &$ -5001%1*'($ &+,5'($ ,0$ -&E*6$

%&.1(&3$1'$)1-$?2&'B8D$)*$1-$/*&64$(,$2*71'$+&B1'7$3,&'-$(,$2,//,:*/-=$

O7&1'8$&'$@AC$2&'B$6100*/-$0/,+$&$%,'E*'(1,'&3$2&'B$1'$()&($()*$01/-($

%5-(,+*/$ 1-$ 7,1'7$ (,$ 2*$ ()*$ 2&'B*/$ )1+-*30_$ Q)&($ 1-8$ ()*$ .*/-,'$

./&%(1%1'7$@AC$:133$2*71'$?3*'61'7$)1+-*30D$+,'*4$:)*'$)*$'**6-$(,$

254$ )1-$ '*M($ %&/8$ ,/$ :)*'$ )*$ '**6-$ (,$ .&4$ 0,/$ )1-$ 6&57)(*/K-$

:*661'7=$ e*($ &-$ ()*$ 6*%&6*-$ .&--8$ &'6$ ()*$ @AC$ ./,%*--$ 41*36-$ &'$

*E*/I7/,:1'7$ -(,%B.13*$ ,0$ &E&13&23*$ %&.1(&38$ ()*$ ),5-*),36$ 2&'B*/$

%&'$ 2*71'$ 5-1'7$ .,31%4$ 3,&'-$ (,$ (&B*$ &6E&'(&7*$ ,0$ 35%/&(1E*$

1'E*-(+*'($ ,..,/(5'1(1*-8$ &-$ ,..,-*6$ (,$ %,'E*'(1,'&3$ 310*(1+*$

'**6-=$Q)1-$+*&'-$()&($()*$@AC$./&%(1(1,'*/$)&-$,.(1,'-$5'&E&13&23*$

(,$()*$&E*/&7*$O+*/1%&'=$Q,$71E*$R5-($,'*$*M&+.3*8$>&-)$)&-$&$E*/4$

1'(/1751'7$ -*%(1,'$ 1'$ )1-$ 2,,B$ -),:1'7$ ()&($ 1($ +17)($ 6,$ &$ %)136$ 0&/$

+,/*$7,,6$(,$05'6$&$.,31%4$/&()*/$()&'$.&4$()*$-&+*$%&-)03,:$0,/$&$

0,5/I4*&/$%,33*7*$6*7/**=$Q)*$)*0(4$%&-)$E&35*$1'$-5%)$&$.,31%4$:,536$

()*'$ &33,:$ ()*$ !!I4*&/I,36$ J:1(),5($ &$ %,33*7*$ 6*7/**L$ (,$ -(&/($ &$

35%/&(1E*$%&/$3*&-1'7$25-1'*--8$&--5+1'7$)*$,/$-)*$)&6$()*$/*T51-1(*$

25-1'*--$-&EE4=$


'

];[$

Q)*$ 7*'15-$ ,0$ >&-)K-$ %,'%*.($ 1-$ ()&($ )*$ 16*'(101*6$ &$

(/&61(1,'&3$01'&'%1&3$./,65%($-1((1'7$:1()1'$*E*/4,'*K-$7/&-.8$&'6$4*($

*-%&.1'7$ *E*/4,'*$ *3-*K-$ ',(1%*=$ @'$ ./1'%1.3*8$ ),5-*),36-$ %,536$

-(,%B.13*$ -&E1'7-$ 5-1'7$ ,()*/$ (*%)'1T5*-8$ &'6$ 2*%,+*$ ?2&'B-D$

:1(),5($ 5-1'7$ :),3*$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*$ .,31%1*-=$ e*($ &-$ :*K33$ -**$ 1'$ ()*$

'*M($ %)&.(*/8$ :),3*$ 310*$ .,31%1*-$ &/*$ &..*&31'7$ ,'$ -*E*/&3$ %/1(*/1&8$

:)*/*&-$,()*/$E*)1%3*-$)&E*$&($3*&-($,'*$+&R,/$6/&:2&%B=$

O-$&$01'&3$',(*$1'$()1-$-*%(1,'8$:*$/*+1'6$()*$/*&6*/$()&($@AC$

1-$',($&$?71++1%B8D$',/$6,*-$1($/*34$,'$&$?(&M$3,,.),3*=D$@($1-$(/5*8$,'*$

,0$ ()*$ &6E&'(&7*-$ ,0$ @AC$ E*/-5-$ ,()*/$ .,--123*$ &../,&%)*-$ 1-$ ()*$

*M%*33*'($ (&M$ (/*&(+*'($ ()&($ :),3*$ 310*$ .,31%1*-$ %5//*'(34$ *'R,4=$ @'$

.&/(1%53&/8$ 10$ 61E16*'6-$ &/*$ /*1'E*-(*6$ 2&%B$ 1'(,$ ()*$ .5/%)&-*$ ,0$

&661(1,'&3$ 310*$ 1'-5/&'%*8$ ()*$ &%%5+53&(1'7$ %&-)$ E&35*-$ &/*$ ',($

-52R*%($(,$(&M=$h&(*/$,'8$10$()*$,:'*/$*3*%(-$(,$:1()6/&:$()*$61E16*'6$

.&4+*'(-$ &-$ 1'%,+*8$ ()*-*$ (,,$ &/*$ (&MI0/**$ 5.$ 5'(13$ ()*$ .,1'($ &($

:)1%)$ ()*$ 310*(1+*$ ./*+15+$ .&4+*'(-$ )&E*$ 2**'$ *M)&5-(*6=$ @'$

,()*/$:,/6-8$()*$.,31%4),36*/$1-$,'34$(&M*6$,'$()*$6,33&/-$(&B*'$,5($

,0$()*$E*)1%3*8$,E*/$&'6$&2,E*$()*$,'*-$1'1(1&334$.5($1'=$JQ)*$/*&-,'$1-$

()&($ ()*$ @<Y$ (/*&(-$ ()*-*$ .&4+*'(-$ ',($ &-$ 61E16*'6$ ,/$ 1'(*/*-($

1'%,+*8$25($&-$&$?/*(5/'$,0$./*+15+8D$2*%&5-*$()*$.,31%4,:'*/$:&-$

%)&/7*6$+,/*$./*+15+$()&'$()*$1'-5/*/$*'6*6$5.$'**61'78$1'$,/6*/$

(,$ +**($ 1(-$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01($ ,2317&(1,'-=L$ O'6$ &$ E*/4$ -17'101%&'($ (&M$

&6E&'(&7*$ 1-$ ()&($ ()*$ *'(1/*$ 6*&()$ 2*'*01($ 7,*-$ (,$ ()*$ 2*'*01%1&/4$

(&MI0/**=$


'

];"$

X&E1'7$-&16$&33$ ()1-8$ @AC$6,*-'K($:,/B$#$($36$2*%&5-*$,0$ ()*$

%5//*'($%,'0175/&(1,'$,0$()*$(&M$%,6*=$^),3*$310*$1'-5/&'%*$)&-$2**'$

&/,5'6$ (:1%*$&-$ 3,'7$&-$ ()*$ @<YU$ 1($ 1-$',($&$ %/*&(5/*$,0$ ()*$-(&(*=$ @($

R5-($ -,$ )&..*'-$ ()&($ ()*$ 0*&(5/*-$ ,0$ +5(5&334$ ,:'*68$ 61E16*'6I

.&41'7$:),3*$310*$1'-5/&'%*$%,+.&'1*-$&/*$&3+,-($.*/0*%(34$-51(*6$(,$

&33,:$+1663*I%3&--$),5-*),36-8$:1()$/*3&(1E*34$31((3*$)&--3*8$(,$2*71'$

&%%5+53&(1'7$ 01'&'%1&3$ %&.1(&3$ 1'$ ,/6*/$ (,$ *'(*/$ ()*$ 2&'B1'7$

25-1'*--=$

W'$ ()*$ -52R*%($ ,0$ (&M*-8$ :*$ -),536$ 1--5*$ ,'*$ 01'&3$ ',(*$ ,0$

%&5(1,'$-,$()&($()*$/*&6*/$5'6*/-(&'6-$()*$%,//*%($%&-*$0,/$@ACN$@0$&$

.,31%4,:'*/$ &6E&'%*-$ 3,&'-$ ,/$ 3*&-*-$ *T51.+*'($ (,$ )1-$ ,5(-16*$

%,+.&'48$ &'6$ ()*'$ )&-$ )1-$ %,+.&'4$ (/*&($ ()*$ 1'(*/*-($ &'6$ 3*&-*$

.&4+*'(-$ &-$ (&MI6*65%(123*$25-1'*--$ *M.*'-*-8$ )*$+5-($2*$ -5/*$ (,$

6*%3&/*$()*-*$.&4+*'(-$&-$(&M&23*$-*2"#$$:)*'$0131'7$)1-$),5-*),36$

(&M*-=$O-$,0$ ()1-$:/1(1'78$ ()*$ @<Y$6,*-$',($ ,2R*%($ (,$ ()*$ (*%)'1T5*-$

6*-%/12*6$&2,E*8$&'6$&%(5&3$@AC$./&%(1(1,'*/-$)&E*$-5/E1E*6$&561(-=$

Q)*$ B*4$ (,$ &$ -5%%*--053$ 6*0*'-*8$ ),:*E*/8$ 1-$ (,$ 6,%5+*'($ *E*/4$

(/&'-&%(1,'$ &'6$ (,$ +&B*$ -5/*$ ()&($ &'4$ %3&1+*6$ 25-1'*--$ *M.*'-*$

1'E,3E1'7$.&4+*'(-$ (,$ ()*$),5-*),368$ )&-$ &$ %,//*-.,'61'7$ 1'%,+*$

%3&1+$,'$()*$),5-*),36K-$(&M$0131'7=$

$

$


'

];G$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 R. Nelson Nash, Becoming Your Own Banker, Fifth Edition (Birmingham, AL: Infinite Banking Concepts, 2008), p. 18. 2 Nash, Becoming Your Own Banker, p. 3. 3 Dwayne Burnell, A Path to Financial Peace of Mind (Bothell, WA: FinancialBallGame Publishing, 2010). 4 We are simplifying somewhat in this section of the text, in order to introduce the mechanics of a policy loan. In practice, some insurance companies reduce the dividend that they pay to a policyholder, based on the size of any outstanding policy loan. (In other words, if two policyholders had identical whole life policies and cash values, but one had an outstanding loan while the other did not, some insurance companies would pay higher dividends to the second policyholder.) The advantages of self-financing through policy loans are obviously reduced, if doing so slows the internal rate of return on a policy’s cash values. However, this slight complication does not change the fact that the borrower still does much better by obtaining his financing at much lower interest rates from the insurer, than by turning to a traditional finance company. 5 The psychological motivation is not the only advantage of IBC. Depending on the specifics, it is possible that the internal rate of return on a whole life policy’s cash values are greater than the after-tax yield on bank CDs. Nash’s Table 1 (p. 45) illustrates a plausible scenario in which someone eventually accumulates more wealth by financing car purchases through IBC, rather than by using a sinking fund involving bank CDs. 6 Nash, Becoming Your Own Banker, pp. 17-18.

!"#$%&'(&()#$*+&,(&-$./&0#1)$!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!"#$

$

!""#

!"#$%&'()*(

!+,,+-(./0&1%2+-3(%+(45!(

#

#

!"#$%& '()*+*,-,./& )0& .$%& 1)--%2%3

%451+.%4& '%(6)7& %8%(& -%+(7,72& .$%&

*%7%0,.6&)0&9*+7:,72;&.$()52$&.$%&56%&)0&

<$)-%& -,0%& ,765(+71%& ,6& 7).& 8%(/& 2))4=&

>%& <,--& *%& %?')6%4& .)& 6)@%& '()0%66)(&

.%+1$,72&$,@&.$+.&9<$)-%&-,0%&,765(+71%&

,6& +& 8%(/& '))(& '-+1%& .)& '5.& @)7%/=;& A.&

<,--& .+:%& +& -).& )0& %00)(.& .)& 2%.& .$,6&

7).,)7& )5.& )0& $,6& $%+4B& *%1+56%&

957-%+(7,72;& ,6& @)(%& 4,00,15-.& .$+7&

-%+(7,72=&

CD=&E%-6)7&E+6$F&

##

$%# &'%()(*$+,-# .$%/%# &0# .$+1# 2&&3# +1# .&# 1$&4# .$%#

*&,,%*.+&,# 2%.4%%,#5%61&,#5)1$71# 89:# ),;# .$%# <&=,;#

>&,%?#<&6=.+&,@#A&4%'%(B# .$%(%#)(%#/),?#0+%(*%#*(+.+*1#&0# 89:#&,#)#

C=(%6?# 0+,),*+)6# 6%'%6@#D%(%# 4%# .&# +-,&(%# .$%1%# .?C+*)6# &2E%*.+&,1B#

.$%#(%);%(#*&=6;#,&.# *&,*%,.().%#&,# .$%# 0+,)6#*$)C.%(B#4$+*$#1C%661#

&=.# .$%# *&,,%*.+&,@# 8,# .$+1# *$)C.%(B# .$%(%0&(%B#4%#4+66# 0+(1.#C(%1%,.#

.$%#1.),;)(;#*)1%#0&(#4$&6%#6+0%#+,1=(),*%B#),;#.$%,#;%0=1%#1&/%#&0##

F#

!"##"$%&'()*+,"$-%+"%./!%GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG&

&

!"G#

.$%#/&1.#*&//&,#*(+.+H=%1#&0#89:@#

#

6"&(!#3&(7+'(8"+9&(:27&(4-3;'#-1&(

#

I# 1.),;)(;# 4)?# .&# /&.+').%# .$%# C=(*$)1%# &0# )# ;+'+;%,;J

C)?+,-# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# C&6+*?B# +1# .&# 0+(1.# )13# .$%# C(&1C%*.+'%#

*6+%,.# )2&=.# .$%# )..(+2=.%1# &0# )# .$%&(%.+*)66?# C%(0%*.# +,'%1./%,.@#

F$%1%#4&=6;#+,*6=;%#.$+,-1#1=*$#)1#1)0%.?#K/%),+,-#.$%#)11%.71#C(+*%#

4&=6;#,&.#6+3%6?#;(&CLB#6+H=+;+.?#K/%),+,-#.$%#&4,%(#*&=6;#.=(,#.$%#

)11%.# +,.&# +.1# M0)+(N# /)(3%.# ')6=%# H=+*36?# +0# ,%%;%;LB# $+-$# ().%# &0#

(%.=(,B# .)O# );'),.)-%1B# )# 1&=(*%# &0# +,*&/%# K+@%@# ,&.# /%(%6?#

)CC(%*+).+&,#+,#C(+*%LB#=,*&((%6).+&,#4+.$#.$%#1.&*3#/)(3%.B#)#$%;-%#

)-)+,1.#C(+*%#+,06).+&,B#),;#C(&.%*.+&,#0(&/#*(%;+.&(1#+,#.$%#%'%,.#&0#

2),3(=C.*?@#

F$%# /&1.# C&C=6)(# +,'%1./%,.# '%$+*6%1# )(%# 1.(&,-# &,# 1&/%#

*(+.%(+)#2=.#'%(?#4%)3#&,#&.$%(1@#P&(#%O)/C6%B#-&6;# +1#),#%O*%66%,.#

+,06).+&,# $%;-%B# 2=.# +.# ;&%1# ,&.# C(&'+;%# )# 06&4# &0# +,*&/%B# +.1#

)CC(%*+).+&,#*),#2%#.)O%;#)1#)#*)C+.)6#-)+,B#),;#.$%#-&'%(,/%,.#$)1#

*&,0+1*).%;#-&6;#+,#.$%#C)1.@#Q%)6#%1.).%#.&&#+1#),#+,06).+&,#$%;-%B#2=.#

+.#*),#2%#'%(?#+66+H=+;#),;#+.1#')6=%#.&&#*),#2%#H=+.%#'&6).+6%@#I,;#.$%#

1.&*3#/)(3%.B# .$&=-$# C(&/+1+,-# )# $+-$# ().%# &0# (%.=(,B# )61&# *&/%1#

4+.$#.$%#(+13#&0#/)11+'%#1$&(.J.%(/#6&11%1@#

F$%# 1.),;)(;# *)1%# 0&(# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# +1# .$).# +.# +1#

(%/)(3)26?# 1.(&,-# &,# 1%'%()6# &0# .$%# )2&'%# *(+.%(+)B# ),;# %'%,# +.1#


&

!"!#

4%)3#C&+,.1#)(%#,&.#)1#2);#)1#.$%#*(+.+*1#.$+,3@#8,#(%)6+.?#.$%(%#+1#,&#

1=*$# .$+,-# )1# .$%# C%(0%*.# +,'%1./%,.B# 2=.# .$%# *)1%# 0&(# /+;;6%J# .&#

=CC%(J+,*&/%# 0)/+6+%1# +,*6=;+,-# 4$&6%# 6+0%# )1# C)(.# &0# .$%+(#

*&,1%(').+'%# 0+,),*+)6# C6),# +1# H=+.%# *&/C%66+,-@# D$%,# 4%#

1=CC6%/%,.# .$%# 1.),;)(;# *)1%#4+.$# 5%61&,# 5)1$71# +,1+-$.1B# ),;# +,#

C)(.+*=6)(# .$%# (%6).+&,1$+C# &0# +,1=(),*%# ),;# 0()*.+&,)6# (%1%('%#

2),3+,-#K)1#4%#1C%66#&=.#+,#.$%#,%O.#*$)C.%(LB#.$%#*)1%#0&(#C()*.+*+,-#

89:#2%*&/%1#1.(&,-%(#1.+66@#

8,# &=(# %OC%(+%,*%B# /&1.# C%&C6%# (%E%*.# 89:# &=.# &0# $),;B#

2%*)=1%#.$%?#$)'%#&,%#&(#.4&#M;%')1.).+,-N#&2E%*.+&,1#.&#.$%#=1%#&0#

)#4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%#C&6+*?@# 8,# .$%# (%/)+,;%(#&0# .$+1# *$)C.%(B#4%#

;%0=1%#.$%1%#*&//&,#*(+.+*+1/1@#

(

<=>&'?+-&(@-+A3(?+;(B+(/&%%&'(%+(/;?(%&',(#-B(2->&3%(

%"&(B277&'&-1&CD(

#

8.# +1# M*&//&,# 3,&46%;-%N# )/&,-# /),?# C%&C6%# .$).# .$%#

+,.%(,)6#().%#&0#(%.=(,#&,#)#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?R%'%,#+0#;+'+;%,;1#)(%#

(%+,'%1.%;R+1# /=*$# 6&4%(# .$),# *&=6;# 2%# )*$+%'%;# &,# )6.%(,).+'%#

+,'%1./%,.1@# 8,# C)(.+*=6)(B# /),?# 0+,),*+)6# );'+1&(1# 4+66# H=+.%#

*&,0+;%,.6?# 1.).%# .$).# &,6?# )# 0&&6# 4&=6;# 2=?# C%(/),%,.# 6+0%#

+,1=(),*%B# 1+,*%# +.# +1# 1&# /=*$# 2%..%(# .&# M2=?# .%(/# ),;# +,'%1.# .$%#

;+00%(%,*%@N# 8,# &.$%(# 4&(;1B# .$%?# *6)+/# .$).# ),# +,;+'+;=)6# 1$&=6;#


&

!"S#

1%C)().%#.$%#.4&#;%*+1+&,1T#P+(1.B#$%#*),#2=?#4$).%'%(#;%).$#2%,%0+.#

$%#4),.1# +,#.$%#*$%)C%1.#/),,%(#C&11+26%#K+@%@#2?#)*H=+(+,-#)# .%(/#

6+0%# +,1=(),*%# C&6+*?L@# <%*&,;B# $%# *),# .$%,# =1%# .$%# 1)'+,-1# &,#

C(%/+=/# C)?/%,.1# .&# +,'%1.# +,# )# /=.=)6# 0=,;B# 4$+*$# $+1.&(+*)66?#

4+66#?+%6;#)#$+-$%(#().%#&0#(%.=(,#.$),#.$%#*)1$#')6=%#&0#)#4$&6%#6+0%#

C&6+*?@#

F$%(%#)(%#1%'%()6#C(&26%/1#4+.$#.$+1#-6+2#;+1/+11)6#&0#4$&6%#

6+0%# )1# )# M.%((+26%# +,'%1./%,.@N# P&(# &,%# .$+,-B# 1&# 6&,-# )1# .$%#

C&6+*?&4,%(# 1.+*31# 4+.$# )# C)(.+*=6)(# C&6+*?# 0&(# /),?# ?%)(1B# .$%#

)'%()-%#),,=)6+U%;#().%#&0#(%.=(,R%'%,#&,#)#C6)+,#'),+66)#4$&6%#6+0%#

C&6+*?# 4+.$# ,&# 0),*?# 89:# /),%='%(+,-R+1# C(&2)26?# /=*$# 2%..%(#

.$),#/),?#*(+.+*1#(%)6+U%@#D$%,#4%#*&,1+;%(#.$%#;),-%(1#)..%,;),.#

4+.$#&.$%(#C&.%,.+)6#+,'%1./%,.1B#.$%#*)1%#0&(#C=..+,-#&,%71#-%,=+,%#

6+8,726#+,.&#)#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?#2%*&/%1#1.(&,-%(@#

P&(#)#*&,*(%.%#+66=1.().+&,B#.$%#4%21+.%#8,1=(%@*&/#&00%(%;#),#

),)6?1+1G#.$).#.&&3#

#V)# 6&&3# ).# 2=?+,-V)#5%4#W&(3#X+0%#4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%#C&6+*?#

*&/C)(%;#.&#2=?+,-#.%(/#6+0%#+,1=(),*%#+,#.$%#1)/%#0)*%#)/&=,.#

),;# +,'%1.+,-# .$%#C(%/+=/#;+00%(%,*%# +,#)# M1+;%# 0=,;N#1=*$#)1#)#

2),3#&(#/=.=)6# 0=,;@#F$+1#*&/C)(+1&,#*&/%1#*&=(.%1?#&0# Y)/%1#

A=,.B#),#)*.=)(?#0&(#.$%#:&,1=/%(#P%;%().+&,#&0#I/%(+*)#K:PIL#

),;# 0&(/%(# +,1=(),*%# *&//+11+&,%(# &0# Z%(/&,.@# A+1# ),)6?1+1#

%1.+/).%1#.$%#M(%)6N#+,.%(%1.#().%#%)(,%;#&,#1)'+,-1#4+.$+,#)#*)1$#

')6=%#C&6+*?@#


&

!"[#

#

A%(%#)(%#.$%#(%1=6.1T#

#8,# .$+1# *&/C)(+1&,B# A=,.# 1$&41# .$).# +0# ?&=# 2=?# )#

*&/C)()26%# .%(/# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# C&6+*?# ?&=# ,%%;# .&# %)(,# S@\#

C%(*%,.#+,#?&=(#+,'%1./%,.#'%$+*6%#+,#&(;%(#0&(#?&=(#1+;%#0=,;#.&#

%H=)6#.$+1#4$&6%#6+0%71#*)1$#')6=%#)0.%(#G]#?%)(1@#80#?&=(#.%(/#6+0%#

+,1=(),*%# 1+;%# 0=,;# +1# +,'%1.%;# +,#)#2),3#:^#&(#2&,;# 0=,;B# ?&=#

/)?#,&.#2%#)26%#.&#,%.#S@\#C%(*%,.#)0.%(#.)O%1@#

#

I6.$&=-$#A=,.#4)1#6&&3+,-#).#.$%#*)1$#')6=%1#0&(#)#C)(.+*=6)(#

5%4#W&(3# X+0%#4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?B# $+1# (%1=6.1# )(%# .?C+*)6# 0&(# C&6+*+%1#

+11=%;#+,#.$+1#C%(+&;@#P&(#%O)/C6%B#)#C(%1%,.%(#).#.$%#89:#F$+,3#F),3#

+,#%)(6?#G]"]#1$&4%;#)#1.),;)(;#.)26%#&0#C(&E%*.%;#*)1$#')6=%1#0&(#)#

4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?B#+,#4$+*$#.$%#K)'%()-%#),,=)6+U%;L#+,.%(,)6#().%#&0#

(%.=(,# %'%,.=)66?# (&1%# .&# S@GS# C%(*%,.# 2?# .$%# .$+(.+%.$# ?%)(# &0# .$%#

C&6+*?@!#

I.# 0+(1.#1=*$#)#().%#&0#(%.=(,#/)?#1%%/#=,;%(4$%6/+,-B#2=.#

4%#1$&=6;#3%%C# +,#/+,;# .$).#).#)#![#C%(*%,.# .)O#2()*3%.B# 1&/%&,%#

4&=6;# ,%%;# .&# %)(,# \@[G# C%(*%,.# &,# ),# )6.%(,).+'%# +,'%1./%,.B# +,#

&(;%(#.&#/).*$#.$%#(%.=(,#+66=1.().%;#0&(#4$&6%#6+0%@#I6(%);?#4%#1%%#

.$).#4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# +1# ,&.# ,%)(6?# .$%# M2&,%$%);N# +,'%1./%,.#

.$).#1&#/),?#C%&C6%#)66%-%@#

>&(%&'%(B#4%# ,%%;# .&# *&,1+;%(# 1)0%.?@# 8,# &(;%(# .&# %)(,# \@[#

C%(*%,.#),,=)66?#&'%(#)#!]J?%)(#C%(+&;B#1&/%&,%#4&=6;#$)'%#$);#.&#


&

!"\#

C=.# $+1# /&,%?# +,# +,'%1./%,.1# .$).# 4%(%# (+13+%(# .$),# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%#

+,1=(),*%#C&6+*?B#4+.$#+.1#-=)(),.%%;#*)1$#')6=%1@#K8.71#.(=%B#+,#(%)6+.?#

,&.$+,-# +1# M-=)(),.%%;BN# 2=.# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?# +1# 1.+66# H=+.%# 1)0%(#

.$),#/&1.#&.$%(#+,'%1./%,.1@L#F&#%)(,#)#.)OJ);E=1.%;#\@[#C%(*%,.#&,#

),# %O.(%/%6?# 1)0%# ),;# 0)+(6?# 6+H=+;# +,'%1./%,.B# +1# ;%0+,+.%6?# ),#

)..()*.+'%# &C.+&,# .$).# /&1.# $&=1%$&6;1# 1$&=6;# *&,1+;%(# +,# .$%+(#

&'%()66#C&(.0&6+&@#

W%.#.$%(%#+1#&,%#/&(%#.$+,-#.&#*&,1+;%(B#+,#.$%#*&/C)(+1&,#&0#

4$&6%#6+0%#'%(1=1#)#*$%)C%(#.%(/#+,1=(),*%#C&6+*?@#<=CC&1%#D+66#),;#

F&/# )(%# +;%,.+*)6# .4+,1#4$&# )(%# !]# ?%)(1# &6;@#D+66# &C.1# .&# 2=?# )#

4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?#4+.$#)#/+66+&,#;&66)(#0)*%#')6=%B#4$+6%#F&/#;%*+;%1#

.&# 2=?# )# G]J?%)(# .%(/# C&6+*?# *)((?+,-# .$%# 1)/%# ;%).$# 2%,%0+.@# 8.71#

.(=%B#D+6671#C(%/+=/1#4+66#2%#/=*$#$+-$%(#.$),#F&/71B#),;#+.71#)61&#

.(=%# .$).#D+6671# )**=/=6).+,-# *)1$# ')6=%1#4+66# 2%# H=+.%#/&;%1.# .$%#

0+(1.# 0%4#?%)(1#&0# .$%#C&6+*?@# 80#D+66#),;#F&/#*&/C)(%#,&.%1#).#)-%#

![B# F&/# 4&=6;# 0%%6# .$).# $%# /);%# .$%# *6%)(6?# 1=C%(+&(# *$&+*%# +,#

&C.+,-#0&(#.%(/#+,1=(),*%@##

A&4%'%(B# 6%.71# E=/C# )$%);# .&# )-%# []@# I.# .$+1# C&+,.B# .$%#

)**=/=6).%;# 4%)6.$# &0# .$%# .4+,1# K4%766# 1=CC&1%L# +1# (&=-$6?# .$%#

1)/%_#D+6671#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?#$)1#2%*&/%#/=*$#/&(%#%00+*+%,.#)1#+.#

/).=(%;B# 4$+6%# F&/# 4)1# )26%# .&# =1%# .$%# 1)'+,-1# &,# $+1# *$%)C%(#

C(%/+=/1#+,#&(;%(#.&#2=+6;#),#+,'%1./%,.#C&(.0&6+&#.$).#)CC(%*+).%;#

K)0.%(#.)O%1L#)2&=.#.$%#1)/%#)1#D+6671#*)1$#')6=%1@#


&

!"`#

9=.# .$%(%# +1#&,%#/)E&(#;+00%(%,*%#2%.4%%,#.$%#.4&#2(&.$%(1#

,&4#.$).#.$%?#$)'%#=1%;#.$%+(#(%1C%*.+'%#1.().%-+%1#0&(#.4&#;%*);%1T#

D+66#*),#*&,.+,=%#C)?+,-#$+1#6%'%6#C(%/+=/R.$%#1)/%#&,%#$%#2%-),#

C)?+,-#).#)-%#!]R),;#3%%C#$+1# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%#C&6+*?# +,# 0&(*%B#=,.+6#

.$%#;)?#$%#;+%1@#F&/B#&,#.$%#&.$%(#$),;B#4+66#C(&2)26?#7).#(%,%4#$+1#

%OC+(+,-#.%(/#C&6+*?@#a)(.+*=6)(6?#+0#$%#$)1#$);#),?#$%)6.$#C(&26%/1B#

).#)-%#[]#F&/#4&=6;#0+,;#+.#'%(?#%OC%,1+'%#.&#&2.)+,#)#,%4#.%(/#6+0%#

+,1=(),*%#C&6+*?@#<&#%'%,#+0#F&/#$)CC%,%;#.&#$)'%#/&(%#4%)6.$#.&#

$+1# ,)/%# ).# )-%# []B# .$).# )6&,%#4&=6;,7.# 2%# ;%*+1+'%B# 2%*)=1%#D+66#

*&=6;#%)1+6?#/)+,.)+,#$+1# +,1=(),*%#*&'%()-%#4$+6%#F&/#*&=6;#,&.@#

P&(#%O)/C6%B#+0#2&.$#2(&.$%(1#;+%;#+,#)#*)(#)**+;%,.#).#)-%#["B#*6%)(6?#

D+6671#4+;&4#4+66#2%#@51$#2%..%(#&00#.$),#F&/71#4+;&4@#

D%#)(%#,&.#.(?+,-#.&#)(-=%#0(&/#)#,)((&4#0+,),*+)6#C6),,+,-#

C%(1C%*.+'%B#4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# +1# ,%*%11)(+6?# .$%#2%1.# &C.+&,# 0&(#

%'%(?#$&=1%$&6;@#D$).#4%#)(%#C&+,.+,-#&=.B#$&4%'%(B#+1#.$).#.$%#-6+2#

);'+*%# &0# M2=?# .%(/# ),;# +,'%1.# .$%# ;+00%(%,*%N# &'%(6&&31# /),?#

+/C&(.),.# (%)6J4&(6;# *&,1+;%().+&,1@# F$+,3# )-)+,# &0# .$%# ;+00%(%,*%#

&0#2=?+,-#)#$&=1%#'%(1=1#(%,.+,-T#W%1B#.$%#*$%)C%(#(%,.)6#C)?/%,.1#

K0&(# )# *&/C)()26%# 6+'+,-# )(%)L#/)?#/)3%# .$%#/&1.# 1%,1%# 0&(# 1&/%#

C%&C6%B# %1C%*+)66?# +0# .$%?# )(%# ?&=,-@# 9=.# 2=+6;+,-# =C# %H=+.?# +,# )#

$&=1%#/)3%1# )# 6&.#/&(%# 1%,1%# 0&(# )# 1.)26%# $&=1%$&6;#4+.$# )# 6&,-J

.%(/# 0+,),*+)6# C6),B# %6'%1,+--/# +0# 6),;6&(;1# C()*.+*%;# )-%#

;+1*(+/+,).+&,#),;#*$)(-%;#$+-$%(#().%1#.$%#&6;%(#)#(%,.%(#2%*)/%@#


&

!"b#

I1#)#0+,)6#C&+,.B#4%#(%C%).#),#&21%(').+&,#/);%#.&#&,%#&0#.$%#

)=.$&(1# 2?# ),# )*.=)(?B# 4$&# C&+,.%;# &=.# .$).#4$&6%# 6+0%# ,6& M2=?+,-#

.%(/# ),;# +,'%1.+,-# .$%# ;+00%(%,*%@N# F$).# +1B# 4$%,# .$%# +,1=(),*%#

*&/C),?# .)3%1# +,# C(%/+=/1# &,# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*+%1B# +.# /=1.#

*&,*%C.=)66?# +1&6).%# .$%# *&/C&,%,.# &0# %)*$# C)?/%,.# ;%;+*).%;# .&#

.$%# C(&'+1+&,# &0# .$%# ;%).$# 2%,%0+.B#4$+6%# .$%# (%/)+,;%(# +1# =1%;# .&#

0=,;# &'%($%);# ),;# )**=/=6).%# )11%.1# .&# 1).+10?# .$%# *)1$# ')6=%#

.)(-%.1@#

8,# )# 1%,1%B# .$%# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(%(# +1# )*.+,-# )1# 2&.$# )# .%(/#

C(&'+;%(# K4$%(%# .$%# .%(/# +1# .$%# %,.+(%# 6+0%# &0# .$%# *6+%,.L#+74# )1# )#

'%(?# *&,1%(').+'%# +,'%1./%,.# 0=,;# /),)-%(@# 8.# +1# &0# *&=(1%#

+/C&(.),.#0&(#+,;+'+;=)61#.&#%O%(*+1%#;=%#;+6+-%,*%#.&#1%%#+0#+.#/)3%1#

1%,1%#.&#-&#.&#)#1+,-6%#C(&'+;%(#&0#.$%1%#;=)6#1%('+*%1#K+@%@#),#+,1=(%(#

&00%(+,-#)#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?LB#2=.#.$%#*&/C)(+1&,#1$&=6;#2%#)CC6%1#.&#

)CC6%1@#<&/%&,%#4$&#&C.1#0&(#)#G]J?%)(#.%(/#C&6+*?#),;#+,'%1.1#.$%#

;+00%(%,*%# +,# )# /=.=)6# 0=,;# *&/C&1%;# &0# 1.&*31# ),;# 2&,;1# /)?#

)**=/=6).%#4%)6.$#).#)#0)1.%(#().%B#2=.#$%#+1#.)3+,-#&,#0)(#/&(%#(+13#

.$),#.$%#C%(1&,#2=+6;+,-#=C#)#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?@#

#

<6"&'&( #'&( +%"&'( %#EFG;#9272&B( $9#-3H( 3;1"( #3( ,?(

IJ)K@LMD#

#

8.#+1#.(=%#.$).#4$&6%#6+0%#+,1=(),*%#+1#,&.#.$%#&,6?#+,'%1./%,.#

'%$+*6%# .&#%,E&?# .)O#);'),.)-%1@#A&4%'%(B#&.$%(#'%$+*6%1# 1=*$#)1#)#


&

!"c#

S]"K3L# *)((?# ,=/%(&=1# (%1.(+*.+&,1B# /)3+,-# .$%1%# )11%.1# 0)(# 6%11#

6+H=+;# .$),# .$%# *)1$# ')6=%1# &0# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?@# P&(# %O)/C6%B#

%O*%C.# +,# 1C%*+0+%;# *)1%1# &0# %O.(%/%# $)(;1$+CB# )# C%(1&,# $)1# 1.(+*.#

(=6%1#&,#4$%,#$%#*),#4+.$;()4#$+1#/&,%?#0(&/#)#S]"K3L#&(#1+/+6)(#

.)OJH=)6+0+%;# C6),B# ),;# )61&# 4$%,# $%#@56.# 2%-+,# 4+.$;()4+,-# K.&#

)'&+;#C%,)6.+%1L@#

F$%(%# +1# )61&# .$%#C(&26%/#&0# *&,0+1*).+&,@# <+/C6?#C=.B#/),?#

),)6?1.1#%OC%*.#.$%#0%;%()6#-&'%(,/%,.#.&#M()+;#.$%#S]"K3L1@N#F$%(%#

$)'%# )6(%);?# 2%%,# .(+)6# 2)66&&,1# KH=+*36?# 4+.$;()4,L# 1=--%1.+,-#

.$).#I/%(+*),1#4&=6;#2%#2%..%(#&00#+0#.$%#-&'%(,/%,.#)11=/%;#.$%+(#

'&6).+6%# 1.&*3# C&(.0&6+&1# ),;# +,1.%);# -=)(),.%%;# .$%/# (%.+(%/%,.#

2%,%0+.1# ;&4,# .$%# (&);@S# 5%61&,# 5)1$# +,# 0)*.# $)1# 4(+..%,# &,#

C(%*+1%6?#.$+1#.&C+*B[#+/C6&(+,-#.$%#(%);%(#.&#2%#1=1C+*+&=1#4$%,#.$%#

-&'%(,/%,.#&00%(1#)#M1&6=.+&,N#K+@%@#.)OJH=)6+0+%;#C6),1L#.&#)#C(&26%/#

.$).#.$%#-&'%(,/%,.#+.1%60#*(%).%;#K+@%@#$+-$#.)O#().%1L@#

P+,)66?B#4%#C&+,.#&=.#.$).#%'%,#;+'%(1+0+%;#/=.=)6#0=,;1#.&&3#

)#2(=.)6#2%).+,-#+,#.$%#G]]]1@#^%C%,;+,-#&,#.$%#*&/C&1+.+&,#&0#.$%+(#

0=,;1B#/),?# $&=1%$&6;1#4%(%# 6=*3?# +0# .$%?# 2(&3%# %'%,# ;=(+,-# .$%#

%,.+(%#;%*);%@#8.71#)66#4%66#),;#-&&;#.&#.%66#1&/%&,%B#M9=?#),;#$&6;BN#

2=.#/),?#2(%);4+,,%(1#4+.$#S]"K3L1# ),;#&.$%(# *&/C)()26%#C6),1#

$);#.&#;%6)?#.$%+(#(%.+(%/%,.#)0.%(#.$%#26&&;2).$#+,#G]]b@#I1#&0#.$+1#

4(+.+,-#+,#1C(+,-#G]"]B#.$%#d@<@#%H=+.?#/)(3%.1#)(%#14+,-+,-#2?#=C#.&#

!#C%(*%,.#4+,-/@#

#


&

!G]#

<8+-N%(4(O&%('2$$&B(+77(/?(%"&(";O&(#O&-%(1+,,2332+-PD#

#

8.#+1#.(=%#.$).#)#6)(-%#C&(.+&,#&0#)#,%4#C&6+*?71#+,+.+)6#C(%/+=/#

C)?/%,.#0=,;1#.$%#*&//+11+&,#.$).#.$%#+,1=(),*%#*&/C),?#C)?1#.&#

.$%#)-%,.#4$&#2(+,-1#+,#.$%#*6+%,.@#F$+1#+1#.$%#/)+,#(%)1&,#.$).#.$%#

+,.%(,)6#().%1#&0#(%.=(,#&,#.$%#*)1$#')6=%1#&0#)#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?#)(%#

)2?1/)6#+,#.$%#0+(1.#0%4#?%)(1@#

d,0&(.=,).%6?B#C)(.#&0# .$%#%OC6),).+&,# 0&(#$+-$#*&//+11+&,1#

+1#-&'%(,/%,.# +,.%('%,.+&,#K).# .$%#1.).%# 6%'%6L@#I1#),?&,%#4$&#$)1#

)CC6+%;# 0&(# )# 1.).%# 6+*%,1%# .&# 2%*&/%# ),# +,1=(),*%# MC(&;=*%(N#

3,&41B#.$%#*)(;+,)6#1+,#+,#.$+1#+,;=1.(?#+1#-+'+,-#)#M3+*32)*3N#.&#.$%#

*=1.&/%(# 0&(# 2=?+,-# )# C&6+*?@# 80# ),# )-%,.# +1# *)=-$.# 1$)(+,-# $+1#

*&//+11+&,# 0%%1# 4+.$# ),?&,%# 4$&# ;&%1,7.# )61&# $)'%# )# 6+*%,1%#

K+,*6=;+,-# .$%# *=1.&/%(# 4$&1%# +,+.+)6# C(%/+=/# C)?/%,.1# )(%#

0=,;+,-# .$%# %,.+(%# *&//+11+&,LB# .$%,# .$%# &00%,;+,-# )-%,.#4+66# 6&1%#

$+1# 6+*%,1%@# 8,#.$+1#4)?B# .$%#1.).%#-&'%(,/%,.#%,0&(*%1#)#*)(.%6#),;#

3%%C1# .$%# C(+*%# &0# *&//+11+&,J2)1%;# +,1=(),*%# $+-$%(# .$),# +.#

&.$%(4+1%#4&=6;#2%@#

5&.4+.$1.),;+,-#.$%#+,.%('%,.+&,#2?#1.).%#-&'%(,/%,.1B#+.#+1#

%,.+(%6?#(%)1&,)26%#.$).#)-%,.1#%)(,#)#*&//+11+&,#&,#4$&6%#6+0%#),;#

&.$%(#C%(/),%,.# +,1=(),*%#C(&;=*.1@#I0.%(#)66B#)1# .$%#;+1*=11+&,# +,#

.$+1#'%(?#2&&3#)..%1.1B#)#4$&6%#6+0%#+,1=(),*%#C&6+*?#+1#*&/C6%OB#),;#

(%H=+(%1# 0)(#/&(%#-=+;),*%# .$),#)#1.),;)(;# .%(/# +,1=(),*%#C&6+*?@#

F$%# +,1=(),*%# )-%,.# 4$&# %OC6)+,1# .$%# /%*$),+*1# &0# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%#


&

!G"#

C&6+*?#.&#)#C(&1C%*.+'%#*6+%,.#,%%;1#.&#2%#*&/C%,1).%;#0&(#$+1#&(#$%(#

.+/%B#),;#.$%#+,;=1.(?#$)1#);&C.%;#.$%#*&//+11+&,#)CC(&)*$#.$).#+1#

*&//&,#0&(#/),?#.?C%1#&0#1)6%1C%&C6%@#Ke%%C#+,#/+,;#.$).#)66#&0#.$%#

C%(0&(/),*%# (%1=6.1# 4%# $)'%# .$=1# 0)(# C(%1%,.%;# ,71-54%# .$%#

*&//+11+&,#0%%1@L#

8.# +1# +/C&(.),.# .&# ,&.%# .$).# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?# *&,0+-=(%;#

)**&(;+,-# .&# 5%61&,# 5)1$71# C$+6&1&C$?# )*.=)66?# @,7,@,H%6# .$%#

C(&C&(.+&,# &0# .$%# +,+.+)6# C(%/+=/# C)?/%,.1# -&+,-# .&# .$%# )-%,.71#

*&//+11+&,@#F$+1#+1#4$?#+.#+1#+/C&(.),.#.&#&2.)+,#)#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?#

0(&/# ),# )-%,.# 4$&# .(=6?# =,;%(1.),;1# ),;# 2%6+%'%1# +,# .$%# 89:#

/+,;1%._# &.$%(# )-%,.1#4&=6;# $)'%# )# ,).=()6# +,*%,.+'%# .&# 1.%%(# .$%#

*6+%,.#)4)?#0(&/#.$%#C(&C%(#*&,0+-=().+&,B#),;#+,.&#)#C&6+*?#4$%(%#

.$%#*)1$#')6=%71#-(&4.$#+1#1.=,.%;#+,#.$%#2%-+,,+,-@# 8,# 0)*.B#4%(%# +.#

,&.# 0&(# 1.).%# 6)41# 4%# 4&=6;# %OC%*.# 89:# 1)6%1C%&C6%# .&# &00%(# .$%#

-(%).%1.#*&//+11+&,#*=.1#.&#.$%+(#*6+%,.1B#2%*)=1%#1&/%&,%#4$&#$)1#

)#-&&;#%OC%(+%,*%#4+.$#89:#4+66#=6.+/).%6?#)*H=+(%#/),?#C&6+*+%1@#

P+,)66?B# 4%# C&+,.# &=.# .$).# .$%# +,1=(),*%# )-%,.# M*)(.%6N#

)*.=)66?#$)1#(%6).+'%6?#6&4#2)((+%(1#.&#%,.(?@#F$%#(%H=+(%/%,.1#;+00%(#

0(&/#1.).%# .&# 1.).%B# 2=.# )#C%(1&,#4+.$#,&#2)*3-(&=,;# +,# +,1=(),*%#

*),# .?C+*)66?# &2.)+,# )# 6+*%,1%# )0.%(# .4&# ;)?1# &0# *6)11(&&/#

+,1.(=*.+&,B#)#1$&(.#.%1.#.$).#+1#H=+.%#%)1?B#),;#)#0%4#$=,;(%;#;&66)(1#

+,#')(+&=1#0%%1@#

#


&

!GG#

<4("&#'B(%"&(2-3;'#-1&(1+,$#-?(%#@&3(,?(1#3"(>#9;&3(

A"&-(4(B2&CD#

#

F$%# +,.%(,%.# +1# 0=66# &0# )**=1).+&,1# &0# .$%# ;)1.)(;6?# ;%%;1#

*&//+..%;# 2?# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# *&/C),+%1B# ),;# C%($)C1# .$%+(#

/&1.#,%0)(+&=1#C6&?#+1#.&#3%%C#.$%#*)1$#')6=%1#.$%#C&6+*?$&6;%(#$)1#

1C%,.# 1&# /),?# ;%*);%1# C).+%,.6?# )**=/=6).+,-B# ().$%(# .$),# -+'%#

.$%/# .&# .$%# 2%,%0+*+)(?#4$%,# .$%# +,1=(%;# ;+%1@# 8,;%%;B# .$%# 1.+,-?#

+,1=(%(1#/%(%6?#1%,;#)#*$%*3#0&(#.$%#;%).$#2%,%0+.B#2=.#;&#,&.#1%,;#

),#);;+.+&,)6#*$%*3#0&(#.$%#*=((%,.#*)1$#')6=%#&0#.$%#C&6+*?@#

I6.$&=-$# 1&/%# %OC&1+.+&,1# &0# .$%# 2%)=.?# &0# 4$&6%# 6+0%#

+,1=(),*%#/)?# -+'%# .$%# &CC&1+.%# +/C(%11+&,B# 6%.# =1# 2%# *6%)(T#I')7&

.$%&4%+.$&)0&.$%&,765(%4B&.$%&,765(+71%&1)@'+7/&6%746&+&1$%1:&0)(&.$%&

0)1+2%')$)3,+%"$45&.)&.$%&*%7%0,1,+(/@#F$%#*)1$#')6=%#&0#)#C&6+*?B#0&(#

),?#-+'%,#?%)(B#/%(%6?#1$&41#4$).#.$%#C&6+*?$&6;%(#4&=6;#(%*%+'%#+0#

$%#4%(%#.&#65((%74%(#.$%#C&6+*?#).#.$).#.+/%@#KfH=+')6%,.6?B#+.#1$&41#

.$%# =CC%(# 6+/+.# &0# 4$).# $%# *&=6;# 2&((&4# )-)+,1.# .$%# C&6+*?@L# F$%#

(%)1&,#.$%#+,1=(%(#*),#)00&(;#.&#-+'%#)#*)1$#')6=%#=C&,#1=((%,;%(B#+1#

.$).# +.#4&,7.#$+8%# .&# C)?# )# ;%).$# 2%,%0+.# &,# )# 1=((%,;%(%;# C&6+*?@#

F$%(%#1$&=6;#,%'%(#$)'%#2%%,#)#H=%1.+&,#&0#.$%#+,1=(%(#C)?+,-#*).$#

*)1$#')6=%#),;#;%).$#2%,%0+.1#.&#)#2%,%0+*+)(?R.$&=-$#4%#*&,*%;%#

.$).# .$+1# C&+,.# *),# 2%# *&,0=1+,-# .&# .$%# ,%4*&/%(B# 1+,*%# 1&/%#

%OC&1+.+&,1#&0#89:#.(%).#.$%#;%).$#2%,%0+.#)1#)#M2&,=1N#+,#);;+.+&,#.&#

.$%#0+,),*+,-#*)C)2+6+.+%1@#


&

!G!#

X%.#=1# (%.=(,#&,*%# )-)+,# .&# .$%#$&=1+,-# ),)6&-?T# <=CC&1%#)#

/),#;=.+0=66?#C)?1#;&4,#.$%#/&(.-)-%#?%)(#)0.%(#?%)(B#2=+6;+,-#=C#

.$%#%H=+.?#+,#$+1#$&/%@#I0.%(#!]#?%)(1#$%#/)3%1#.$%#0+,)6#/&(.-)-%#

C)?/%,.B# .$%,# 4)631# +,.&# .$%# 2),3@# F$%# 2),3# .%66%(# *&,-().=6).%1#

$+/#),;#$),;1#$+/#.$%#;%%;#.&#$+1#$&=1%@#F$%#/),#.$%,#*6%)(1#$+1#

.$(&).@#MfO*=1%#/%B#2=.#/?#)**&=,.),.#.%661#/%#8#$)'%#)**=/=6).%;#

g![]B]]]#+,#%H=+.?#+,#/?#$&=1%B#,&4#.$).#87'%#*6%)(%;#.$%#/&(.-)-%@#

^&#?&=#$)'%#/?#*$%*3hN#

F$%#/),#4&=6;#,&#;&=2.#2%#1$&*3%;#),;#&=.()-%;# .&# 6%)(,#

.$).#.$%#2),3#4)1#/%(%6?#$),;+,-#&'%(#.$%#;%%;B#),;#4)1#M3%%C+,-#

$+1# $&/%# %H=+.?N# 0&(# +.1%60@# 9=.# &2'+&=16?# .$).# 4&=6;# *&/C6%.%6?#

/+1*&,1.(=%# 4$).# 4)1# $)CC%,+,-# )66# .$&1%# ?%)(1# ;=(+,-# .$%#

C)?;&4,#&0#.$%#/&(.-)-%@#

8,# .$%# 1)/%#4)?B# 1&/%&,%# 2=+6;+,-# =C# .$%# *)1$# ')6=%# &0# )#

C&6+*?#+1#,%)(+,-#.$%#C&+,.#).#4$+*$#$%#K&(#$+1#2%,%0+*+)(?L#*),#*6)+/#

0=66# )**%11# .&# .$%# ;%).$# 2%,%0+.@# F$%# *)1$# ')6=%# +1# 4%0,7%4# )1# .$%#

;+00%(%,*%# 2%.4%%,# .$%# 6&&/+,-# ;%).$# 2%,%0+.# ),;# .$%# (%/)+,+,-#

C(%/+=/#C)?/%,.1B# );E=1.%;# 0&(# .$%# .+/%# ')6=%# &0#/&,%?# ),;# .$%#

C(&2)2+6+.+%1# &0# ;%).$# ).# ')(+&=1# C&+,.1# +,# .$%# 0=.=(%@# i,*%# 4%#

=,;%(1.),;#4$).#.$%#*)1$#')6=%#,6B#),;#4$?#.$%#+,1=(%(#+1#4+66+,-#.&#

/)3%#C&6+*?#6&),1#)-)+,1.#+.B#+.#2%*&/%1#&2'+&=1#4$?#.$%#2%,%0+*+)(?#

&,6?#(%*%+'%1#&,%#C)?/%,.#4$%,#.$%#+,1=(%;#;+%1@#

#


&

!GS#

<47( %++( ,#-?( $&+$9&( $'#1%21&( 45!H( A+-N%( %"&(

O+>&'-,&-%(3";%(2%(B+A-PD#

#

>),?# C%&C6%# 6%)(,# .$%# /%*$),+*1# &0# 89:# ),;# .$%,# 2%*&/%#

'%(?# C(&.%*.+'%@# F$%?# ;&,7.# 4),.# ),?2&;?# %61%# 6%)(,+,-# .$%# 2%1.J

3%C.#1%*(%.#+,#.$%#0+,),*+)6#4&(6;j#F$%+(#=,;%(1.),;)26%#0%)(#+1#.$).#

+0# .&&#/),?# C%&C6%# .)3%# .$%+(#/&,%?# &=.# &0# .$%# C&6+.+*)66?J0)'&(%;#

1%*.&(1#K1=*$#)1#D)66#<.(%%.L#),;#C)(3#+.#+,#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*+%1#1=2E%*.#

.&#/+,+/)6#.)O).+&,B#.$%,#%'%,.=)66?#.$%#-&'%(,/%,.#4+66#*$),-%#.$%#

(=6%1#),;#1C&+6#%'%(?.$+,-@#

5).=()66?# ,&# &,%# *),# C(&/+1%# .$).# )# C)(.+*=6)(# 0+,),*+)6#

1.().%-?# +1# +//=,%# .&# C&6+.+*)6# +,.%(0%(%,*%@# 80# .$%# -&'%(,/%,.#

2%-),# .)O+,-# %)(,+,-1# &,# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*+%1B# .$).# 4&=6;# *%(.)+,6?#

(%;=*%# .$%+(# )..()*.+'%,%11@# i,# .$%# &.$%(# $),;B# 4%#/=1.# (%+.%().%#

.$).# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# +1# 7).# )# *(%).+&,# &0# .$%# .)O# *&;%_# .$%1%#

C&6+*+%1#%O+1.%;#)#*%,.=(?#2%0&(%#.$%#8Q<@#8,#&=(#/&;%(,#4&(6;B#%'%,#

+0# .$%# .)O#);'),.)-%1#4%(%#%6+/+,).%;B# .$%#&.$%(#);'),.)-%1#&0# 89:#

/+-$.# 1.+66# (%,;%(# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# )# C(=;%,.# C6)*%# .&# 1.&(%# )#

C&(.+&,#&0#)#$&=1%$&6;71#4%)6.$@#

8(&,+*)66?B#4%#*),# 06+C# .$+1#&2E%*.+&,#&,# +.1#$%);#2?#)13+,-#)#

1+/C6%# H=%1.+&,T# D$?# $)1,7.# .$%# -&'%(,/%,.# (%/&'%;# .$%# .)O#

;%;=*.+&,# 0&(# /&(.-)-%# +,.%(%1.# %OC%,1%1B# %'%,# .$&=-$# /),?#

%*&,&/+1.1#)(-=%#.$).#.$+1#M6&&C$&6%N#+1#%*&,&/+*)66?#+,%00+*+%,.#),;#

;+1.&(.1#.$%#(%)6#%1.).%#/)(3%.h#F$%#),14%(#+1#&2'+&=1T#8.#4&=6;#2%#


&

!G[#

%O.(%/%6?# *&,.(&'%(1+)6# .&# (%/&'%# .$%# ;%;=*.+&,B# 1+,*%# 1&# /),?#

$&=1%$&6;1#/);%#)#/)E&(#0+,),*+)6#;%*+1+&,#2)1%;#&,#+.1#%O+1.%,*%@#

F$%# 1)/%# *&=6;# $&6;# 0&(# 4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# C&6+*+%1@# 80#

/+66+&,1# &0# I/%(+*),# $&=1%$&6;1# 2%-+,# +,'%1.+,-# +,# 6)(-%# C&6+*+%1B#

.$%?#4+66#()+1%#H=+.%#),#=C(&)(#+0#.$%#C&6+.+*+),1#.$(%).%,#.&#(%/&'%#

.$%+(#1C%*+)6#.)O#.(%)./%,.@#F$+1#+1#4$?#+.#+1#*(=*+)6#0&(#C()*.+.+&,%(1#

.&#1C(%);#.$%#4&(;#.&#.$%+(#0(+%,;1#),;#0)/+6+%1@#8.#+1#)61&#*(=*+)6#0&(#

C%&C6%#.&#C()*.+*%#89:#(%6')76,*-/@# 80# .$%#-&'%(,/%,.#%'%(#;&%1#M-&#

)0.%(# 89:BN# +.# 4+66# 4),.# 1&/%# E=+*?# 1.&(+%1# &0# 1$);?# 2=1+,%11/%,#

*$%).+,-#&,#.$%+(#.)O%1#+,#)#*&/C6+*).%;#1*$%/%#+,'&6'+,-#4$&6%#6+0%#

C&6+*+%1#),;#C&&(#;&*=/%,.).+&,@#D%#=(-%#.$%#(%);%(1#&0#.$+1#2&&3#

.&#7).#C(&'+;%#1=*$#%O)/C6%1#.&#.$%#C(%11#&(#.$%#C&6+.+*+),1@#

#

<8"#%(27(%"&(2-3;'#-1&(1+,$#-?(O+&3(/'+@&PD#

#

F$%(%#+1#,&#1=*$#.$+,-#)1#.$%#C%(0%*.#+,'%1./%,.@#k&6;#/)?#2%#

*&,0+1*).%;# 2?# .$%# )=.$&(+.+%1B# *)1$# =,;%(# .$%# /)..(%11# /)?# 2%#

1.&6%,# &(# ;%1.(&?%;# .$(&=-$# C(+*%# +,06).+&,B# ),;# (%)6# %1.).%# /)?#

*()1$#+,#C(+*%#&(#2%#.&&#+66+H=+;#+,#)#.+/%#&0#,%%;@#

D$&6%#6+0%#+,1=(),*%#C&6+*+%1#.&&#)(%#+/C%(0%*.@#f'%,#.$&=-$#

.$%?#M-=)(),.%%N#*)1$#1=((%,;%(#')6=%1#).#')(+&=1#)-%1#&0#.$%#C&6+*?B#

&0# *&=(1%# +.# +1# C&11+26%# .$).# .$%# +,1=(),*%# *&/C),?# 4+66# C&&(6?#

/),)-%#+.1#)11%.1#),;#2%#=,)26%#.&#/%%.#+.1#*&,.()*.=)6#&26+-).+&,1@#

A&4%'%(B# 2&.$# 1.).%# (%-=6).+&,1# ),;# .$%# %,.+(%# .();+.+&,# &0# 6+0%#


&

!G\#

+,1=(),*%#/)3%#+.#)#'%(?#*&,1%(').+'%#)11%.B#(%6).+'%#.&#/&1.#&.$%(1@#

f'%,#+0#)#C)(.+*=6)(#*&/C),?#-&%1#=,;%(B#.$%#(%1.#&0#.$%#+,;=1.(?#4+66#

.?C+*)66?# )11=/%# +.1# &C%().+&,1# .&# %,1=(%# .$).# C&6+*?$&6;%(1# )(%#

/);%# 4$&6%@# 8.# +1# +,# .$%# +,.%(%1.# &0# .$%# +,;=1.(?# .&# /)+,.)+,# .$%#

C=26+*71# .(=1.# .$).# M6+0%# +,1=(),*%N# +1# )# '%(?# *)(,72# ),;# 2%;(&*3#

+,1.+.=.+&,@# KF$%#C=(C&1%# &0# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# +1# ,&.# .&#/)3%# )# 3+66+,-B#

2=.# .&# C(&'+;%# 0&(# &,%71# 0)/+6?# +,# *)1%# &0# )# 3+66+,-@L# I1# ;%# <&.&#

%OC6)+,1T#

#F$%# +,1.+.=.+&,# &0# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# $)1# -();=)66?# ),;#

1C&,.),%&=16?# .)3%,# 1$)C%# +,# .$%# /)(3%.# &'%(# .$%# 6)1.# .4&#

$=,;(%;# ?%)(1@# 8.# +1# 2)1%;# &,# )# 1%(+%1# &0# .%*$,+*)6B# )*.=)(+)6B#

0+,),*+)6#),;#E=(+;+*)6#C(+,*+C6%1#&0#2=1+,%11#2%$)'+&(#4$+*$#$)'%#

%,)26%;#+.#.&#C%(0&(/#+.1#/+11+&,#C%(0%*.6?#),;#1=('+'%#%*&,&/+*#

*(+1%1# ),;# (%*%11+&,1# 4$+*$# &.$%(# +,1.+.=.+&,1B# %1C%*+)66?#

2),3+,-B# $)'%# 2%%,# =,)26%# .&# &'%(*&/%@# F$%(%0&(%# .$%# $+-$#

M0+,),*+)6# ;%).$# ().%N# &0# 2),31B# 4$+*$# 1?1.%/).+*)66?# 1=1C%,;#

C)?/%,.1# ),;# 0)+6#4+.$&=.# .$%# 1=CC&(.# &0# .$%# *%,.()6# 2),3B# $)1#

$+1.&(+*)66?#*&,.()1.%;#4+.$#.$%#$%)6.$#),;#.%*$,+*)6#1&6'%,*?#&0#

6+0%# +,1=(),*%# *&/C),+%1@# K8,# .$%# 6)1.# .4&# $=,;(%;# ?%)(1B# )#

,%-6+-+26%#,=/2%(#&0#6+0%#+,1=(),*%#*&/C),+%1#$)'%#;+1)CC%)(%;#

;=%#.&#0+,),*+)6#;+00+*=6.+%1@L\#

#

^%# <&.&# -&%1# &,# .&# %OC6)+,# .$).# .$%# '%(?# ,).=(%# &0# .$%# 6+0%#

+,1=(),*%# 2=1+,%11#/)3%1# +.# ),# %O*%66%,.# $%;-%# )-)+,1.# .$%# 2&&/J

2=1.#*?*6%1#*)=1%;#2?#0()*.+&,)6#(%1%('%#2),3+,-T#


&

!G`#

#F$%# 0&66&4+,-# .%*$,+*)6#C(+,*+C6%1# )(%# .();+.+&,)6# +,# .$%#

6+0%# +,1=(),*%# 1%*.&(T# )11%.1# )(%# ')6=%;# ).# $+1.&(+*)6# *&1.B# ),;#

C(%/+=/1# )(%# *)6*=6).%;# 2)1%;# &,# '%(?# C(=;%,.# .%*$,+*)6#

+,.%(%1.# ().%1B# 4$+*$# ,%'%(# +,*6=;%# )# *&/C&,%,.# 0&(# +,06).+&,#

%OC%*.).+&,1@# F$=1# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%# *&/C),+%1# .%,;# .&#

=,;%(%1.+/).%# .$%+(# )11%.1B# &'%(%1.+/).%# .$%+(# 6+)2+6+.+%1B# ),;#

(%)*$# )# $+-$# 6%'%6# &0# 1.).+*# ),;# ;?,)/+*# 1&6'%,*?#4$+*$#/)3%1#

.$%/#+//=,%#.&#.$%#;%%C%1.#1.)-%1#&0# .$%#(%*%11+&,1#.$).#(%*=(#

4+.$# %*&,&/+*# *?*6%1@# 8,# 0)*.#4$%,# .$%# ')6=%#&0# 0+,),*+)6# )11%.1#

),;#*)C+.)6#-&&;1#C6=,-%1#+,#.$%#/&1.#1%(+&=1#1.)-%1#&0#(%*%11+&,#

+,#%'%(?#*?*6%B#6+0%#+,1=(),*%#*&/C),+%1#)(%#,&.#=1=)66?#)00%*.%;B#

-+'%,#.$%#(%;=*%;#2&&3#')6=%#.$%?#(%*&(;#0&(#.$%+(# +,'%1./%,.1@#

D+.$#(%1C%*.#.&#.$%#)/&=,.#&0#.$%+(#6+)2+6+.+%1B# +,1=(%(1#*)6*=6).%#

.$%+(# /).$%/).+*)6# (%1%('%1# ).# +,.%(%1.# ().%1# /=*$# 6&4%(# .$),#

.$&1%# )*.=)66?# *$)(-%;# +,# .$%# /)(3%.@# A%,*%# .$%?# .%,;# .&#

&'%(%1.+/).%# .$%# C(%1%,.# ')6=%# &0# .$%+(# *&//+./%,.1# &,# .$%#

6+)2+6+.+%1# 1+;%@# >&(%&'%(# C&6+*?$&6;%(1# .)3%# );'),.)-%# &0# .$%#

C(&0+.1# +,1=(),*%# *&/C),+%1# 2(+,-# +,B# )1# 6&,-# )1# .$%# C(&0+.1# )(%#

;+1.(+2=.%;# +& ')6.%(,)(,# l+@%@# )0.%(# (%)6+U).+&,mB# +,# )**&(;),*%#

4+.$VC(&0+.J1$)(+,-#*6)=1%1@`#

#

<8"#%(#/+;%("?$&'2-79#%2+-PCD#

#

I1# &0# .$+1# 4(+.+,-# +,# 1C(+,-# G]"]B# /),?# /%/2%(1# &0# .$%#

I=1.(+),# /&'%/%,.# )(%# '%(?# *&,*%(,%;# )2&=.# .$%# 0).%# &0# .$%# d@<@#

;&66)(@# 8,;%%;# &,%# &0# .$%# C(%1%,.# )=.$&(1# $)1# 1C%*=6).%;# .$).# P%;#


&

!Gb#

:$)+(/),# 9%(,),3%71# (%*36%11# C&6+*+%1# /)?# =6.+/).%6?# 6%);# .&# ),#

&=.(+-$.# *&66)C1%# &0# .$%# ;&66)(# ),;# .$%# +,.(&;=*.+&,# &0# )# ,%4#

*=((%,*?@# 8,# 6+-$.# &0# .$%1%# 0%)(1B# +1,7.# +.# *()U?# .&# +,'%1.# +,# )#;&66)(J

;%,&/+,).%;#)11%.#1=*$#)1#6+0%#+,1=(),*%h#

#F$%(%# )(%# 1%'%()6# (%1C&,1%1# .&# .$+1# 6%-+.+/).%# H=%1.+&,@# 8,#

.$%#0+(1.#C6)*%B#4%#/=1.#*&,1.),.6?#(%/+,;#.$%#(%);%(#.$).#+,#.$%#89:#

C%(1C%*.+'%B# +& '%(6)7& ,6& 7).& J,78%6.,72K& ,7& <$)-%& -,0%B& *5.& ,6& (+.$%(&

$%+4L5+(.%(,72& $,6& <%+-.$& ,7& +& <$)-%& -,0%& ')-,1/@# 8,# C)(.+*=6)(B# +0#

1&/%&,%# 4),.1# .&# 2=?# -&6;B# (%)6# %1.).%B# ,&,J$?2(+;# 1%%;1B#

)//=,+.+&,B# &(# ),?# &.$%(# +,06).+&,# $%;-%B# $%# +1# 1.+66# 0(%%# .&# ;&# 1&B#

%'%,#4$+6%# C()*.+*+,-# 89:@# 80# $+1# *)1$# ')6=%1# )(%# 6)(-%# %,&=-$B# .$%#

C%(1&,#*),#4+.$;()4#$+1#;+'+;%,;1#0&(#.$%1%#+,'%1./%,.1B#&(#$%#*),#

.)3%#&=.#)#C&6+*?#6&),#+0#$%#,%%;1#)**%11#.&#/&(%#&0#$+1#*)C+.)6@#

I6.$&=-$# .$%# ;),-%(# &0#/)11+'%# C(+*%# +,06).+&,# +1# 1.+66# H=+.%#

(%)6B#4%#;&,7.#3,&4#.$%#%O)*.#.+/+,-@#I.#.$+1#C&+,.B#.$%#/)(3%.1#1%%/#

.&#$)'%# .)3%,#9%(,),3%#).#$+1#4&(;R1=*$#)1# +.# +1R),;# .$%#;&66)(#

$)1# ,&.# *&66)C1%;@# K8,# 0)*.B# .$%# ;&66)(# $)1# 1.(%,-.$%,%;# )/+;1.# .$%#

0%)(1#&'%(#.$%#f=(&U&,%71#1&6'%,*?@L#8,#.$+1#%,'+(&,/%,.B#1.&*3C+6+,-#

;&66)(1# +,# )# '%(?# 1)0%# C6)*%R)1# &CC&1%;# .&# .$%# +,*(%;+26?# '&6).+6%#

1.&*3#/)(3%.R+1#,&.#)#.%((+26%#+;%)B#6)&-)72&+6&.$%&')-,1/$)-4%(&1+7&

L5,1:-/&@)8%&<$%7&.$%&'(,1%&,70-+.,)7&2%7,%&*%2,76&-%+8,72&.$%&*)..-%@#

D%# 1$&=6;# C&+,.# &=.# .$).# 0=.=(%# C(+*%# +,06).+&,# +1# )# ;&=26%J

%;-%;# 14&(;#4$%,# +.# *&/%1# .&# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?@# 8.71# .(=%B# 6)(-%#

+,*(%)1%1# +,#*&,1=/%(#C(+*%1#4+66#;+6=.%# .$%#C=(*$)1+,-#C&4%(#&0#)#


&

!Gc#

*&,.()*.=)66?#1C%*+0+%;#;%).$#2%,%0+.@#i,#.$%#&.$%(#$),;B#6)(-%#C(+*%#

+,06).+&,#4+66# )61&# (%;=*%# .$%# 2=(;%,# &0# 0=.=(%# '(%@,5@& '+/@%7.6@#

f'%,# .$&=-$# .$%# +,1=(),*%# *&/C),?71# )11%.# C&(.0&6+&# $)1# )# $%)'?#

*&,*%,.().+&,#&0#2&,;1B# .$%#C%(1&,#4$&#2=?1#)#4$&6%# 6+0%#C&6+*?# +1#

,&.#$,@6%-0#2=?+,-#)#C&(.+&,#&0# .$&1%#2&,;1#=C0(&,.@#Q).$%(B#).# .$%#

/&/%,.#&0# 1+-,+,-# .$%#C&6+*?B# .$%#C%(1&,# +1#C6%;-+,-# .&#C)?#)# 6&,-#

1.(%)/# &0# 0+O%;# ;&66)(# C)?/%,.1B# 4$+6%# .$%# +,1=(%(# +1# C(&/+1+,-# )#

6&,-#1.(%)/#&0#KC&.%,.+)6L#0+O%;#;%).$#2%,%0+.#C)?/%,.1@#

D%#*),#.$+,3#&0#&,%#C&.%,.+)6#1*%,)(+&#+,#4$+*$#)#4$&6%#6+0%#

C&6+*?# 4&=6;# 2%*&/%# =,.%,)26%@# <=CC&1%# .$).# 1&/%&,%# 2%-+,1#

C+6+,-#/&,%?#+,.&#$+1#C&6+*?B#),;#)**=/=6).%1#g[]]B]]]#2?#.$%#?%)(#

G]"S@#A&4%'%(B#).#.$).#C&+,.#.$%#&00+*+)6#:a8#+1#(+1+,-#).#/&(%#.$),#G]#

C%(*%,.#),,=)66?B#),;#6&,-J.%(/#*&(C&().%#2&,;#?+%6;1#$)'%#1C+3%;#

.&#!]#C%(*%,.@#

P=(.$%(# 1=CC&1%# .$).# .$+1# C&6+*?$&6;%(# 1)4# .$%# ;),-%(# ),;#

$);#.)3%,#&=.#g!]]B]]]#0(&/#$+1#C&6+*?#.&# +,'%1.# +,#-&6;#),;#&.$%(#

+,06).+&,# $%;-%1@# i,# .$).# 0(&,.# $%# ;+;# H=+.%# 4%66@# A&4%'%(B# $%# +1#

.(&=26%;# .&# ;+1*&'%(# .$).# $+1# &=.1.),;+,-# g!]]B]]]# C&6+*?# 6&),# +1#

-(&4+,-# ).# )# ().%# &0# !]# C%(*%,.# K2%*)=1%# $+1# *&,.()*.# )66&41# .$%#

+,1=(%(# .&# );E=1.# .$%# C&6+*?# 6&),# ().%# +,# )**&(;),*%#4+.$#>&&;?71#

6&,-J.%(/# *&(C&().%# 2&,;# ?+%6;1L@# I6.$&=-$# $+1# *)1$# ')6=%1# $)'%#

1.)(.%;# (+1+,-# ).# )# /=*$# 0)1.%(# ().%# .$),# $+1# *&,.()*.# &(+-+,)66?#

C(&E%*.%;B#,&,%.$%6%11#.$%?#)(%#,&.#-(&4+,-#)1#H=+*36?#)1#$+1#C&6+*?#

6&),@#I0.%(#)66B#.$%#+,1=(%(71#2&,;#$&6;+,-1#$)'%#)#6&,-#;=().+&,B#),;#


&

!!]#

+.#.)3%1#.+/%#0&(#.$%#+,1=(%(#.&#(&66#&'%(#+.1#)11%.1#),;#2%-+,#%)(,+,-#

.$%#$+-$%(#+,.%(%1.#().%1@#

8,#.$+1#1*%,)(+&B#.$%#C&6+*?$&6;%(#4&=6;#C(&2)26?#,&.#4),.#.&#

4).*$#$%6C6%116?#)1#$+1#C&6+*?# 6&),#H=+*36?#*&,1=/%;#$+1#gG]]B]]]#

+,# )')+6)26%# *)1$# ')6=%1@# P&(.=,).%6?B# $%#4&=6;# $)'%# .$%# &C.+&,# .&#

65((%74%(# $+1# C&6+*?# ).# .$).# .+/%B# C)?+,-# &00# .$%# 6&),# ),;# .$%,#

+,'%1.+,-#$+1#gG]]B]]]#$&4%'%(#$%#;%1+(%;@#8,#0)*.B#+0#$%#1.+66#4),.%;#

.&#C()*.+*%#89:B#$%#/+-$.#&C%,#=C#)#,%4#4$&6%#6+0%#C&6+*?#&,*%#.$+,-1#

$);#1%..6%;#),;#C%&C6%#4%(%#/&(%#*&,0+;%,.# +,#.$%+(#C(&E%*.+&,1#&0#

6&,-J.%(/#+,.%(%1.#().%1@#

#

<8"?(1#-N%(4( Q/#-@N(/?(/+''+A2-O(#O#2-3%(,?("+;3&(+'(

+%"&'(#33&%3PD#

#

I.# 0+(1.# -6),*%# .$%# 89:#*&,*%C.#4&=6;# 1%%/# .&#4&(3# 0&(#+7/#

)11%.@# P&(# %O)/C6%B# )1# ),# +,;+'+;=)6# C)?1# ;&4,# $+1# /&(.-)-%B# $%#

)**=/=6).%1#)#6)(-%(#1$)(%#&0#%H=+.?#+,#$+1#$&=1%@#F$%,#4$%,#$%#$)1#

)# /)E&(# %OC%,1%B# $%# *&=6;# &2.)+,# )# 1%*=(%;# 6&),# 0(&/# .$%# 2),3B#

=1+,-#.$%#$&=1%#)1#*&66).%()6@#8,#&.$%(#4&(;1B#$%#*&=6;#K1)?L#C)?#0&(#

$+1#;)=-$.%(71#4%;;+,-B#&(#0+,),*%#)#*(=+1%#+,#$+1#\]1B#2?#.)3+,-#&=.#)#

$&/%# %H=+.?# 6&),@# <&# 4$).71# 1&# 1C%*+)6# )2&=.# )# 4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?h#

D$?# +1# 5)1$# *&,*%,.().+,-# &,# .$+1# C)(.+*=6)(# '%$+*6%# .&# M2%*&/%#

?&=(#&4,#2),3%(Nh#


&

!!"#

F$%(%# )(%# .4&#/)E&(# (%)1&,1# .$).# )#4$&6%# 6+0%# C&6+*?# +1# .$%#

C%(0%*.#'%$+*6%#0&(#5)1$71#+;%)B#4$%(%)1#-&+,-#.&#)#2),3#.&#&2.)+,#)#

1%*=(%;#6&),#&,#)11%.1#+1#;%0+,+.%6?#+,0%(+&(@#8,#.$%#0+(1.#C6)*%B#4$%,#

1&/%&,%#)CC6+%1#0&(#)#6&),#).#.$%#2),3R%'%,#4+.$#)#1%*=(%;#)11%.#

1=*$#)1#$&/%#%H=+.?B#)#2&).B#%.*@R.$%#2),3#4+66#/)3%#.$%#)CC6+*),.#

=,;%(-&#)#(+-&(&=1#C(&*%11@#F$%#2),3#4+66#4),.#.&#3,&4#.$%#'5(')6%#

&0# .$%# 6&),B# ),;# +.# 4+66# )61&# 4),.# .&# 3,&4# .$%# *(%;+.# $+1.&(?# ),;#

+,*&/%# 1&=(*%1#&0# .$%# )CC6+*),.# .&#/)3%# 1=(%#$%# *),#'+/&*+1:& .$%&

-)+7@# F$%(%#4+66# )61&#2%#)# 0+O%;#C)?2)*3# 1*$%;=6%@#i,*%# .$%# 6&),# +1#

/);%B# .$%#)CC6+*),.#*),7.#;%*+;%#)# 0%4#/&,.$1# +,B# .$).#$+1# 0+,),*%1#

)(%# .+-$.%(# .$),# $%# (%)6+U%;# ),;# $%71# E=1.# -&+,-# .&# 1.&C# C)?+,-# $+1#

+,1.)66/%,.1@#

8,# *&/C6%.%# *&,.()1.B# 1&/%&,%# (%H=%1.+,-# )# C&6+*?# 6&),# &,#

$+1#4$&6%#6+0%#*)1$#')6=%1#E=1.#,%%;1#.&#-+'%#.$%#;&66)(#)/&=,.#.&#.$%#

+,1=(),*%# *&/C),?@# F$%?# ;&,7.# )13# .$%# C=(C&1%B# .$%?# ;&,7.# (=,# )#

*(%;+.#*$%*3B#),;#.$%?#;&,7.#*)(%#+0#.$%#)CC6+*),.#$)1#),?#+,*&/%#).#

)66@#F$%?#4+66#-(),.#.$%#6&),#4+.$#)#*&,.()*.=)6#().%#&0#+,.%(%1.B#),;#+0#

.$%# )CC6+*),.# ;%*+;%1# .&# 1.&C# /)3+,-# C)?/%,.1B# .$%# &=.1.),;+,-#

2)6),*%#4+66#-(&4#2=.#.$%#+,1=(%(#4+66#,&.#&2E%*.@#

F$%# (%)1&,# 0&(# .$+1# ,+-$.J),;J;)?# ;+00%(%,*%# +,# .(%)./%,.#

+1,7.# .$).#2),31#$+(%# E%(31#4$+6%# +,1=(%(1#$+(%# 14%%.$%)(.1@#5&B# .$%#

;+00%(%,*%#+1#;=%#.&#.$%#,).=(%#&0#.$%#*&66).%()6#+,#.$%#.4&#1*%,)(+&1@#

F$%# 2),3# ;&%1,7.# (%)66?#<+7.# .&# 1%+U%# 1&/%2&;?71# $&=1%# &(# 2&).#

4$%,# $%# ;%0)=6.1# &,# )# 6&),@# F$%# 2),3# 4&=6;# /=*$# ().$%(# -%.# +.1#


&

!!G#

/&,%?#2)*3#+,#.$%#0&(/#&0#*$%*31#+,#.$%#/)+6B#().$%(#.$),#+,#.$%#0&(/#

&0#),#%O.(%/%6?#+66+H=+;#)11%.@#

F$%# +,1=(),*%#*&/C),?B#&,# .$%#&.$%(#$),;B# +1#H=+.%#*&,.%,.#

.&#6%.#.$%#2)6),*%#&,#)#C&6+*?#6&),#(&66#&'%(#).#+,.%(%1.B#2%*)=1%#+.#4+66#

+,1.),.6?# -%.# +.1#/&,%?# 2)*3#4$%,# .$%# +,1=(%;# ;+%1# ),;# .$%# ;%).$#

2%,%0+.# /=1.# 2%# C)+;# &,# .$%# C&6+*?@# I.# .$).# C&+,.B# .$%# +,1=(),*%#

*&/C),?# ;%;=*.1# .$%# &=.1.),;+,-# 6&),# 2)6),*%B# 4+.$# )# 1+/C6%#

3%?1.(&3%#)1#+.#4%(%R,&#,%%;#.&#C=.#)#$&=1%#=C#0&(#)=*.+&,B#$&C+,-#

.&#-%.#)#-&&;#C(+*%#0&(#+.@#

F$%(%# +1# ),&.$%(# (%)1&,# .$).# (%);%(1# &0# .$+1# 2&&3# 1$&=6;#

C(%0%(# .&# +/C6%/%,.# 89:#4+.$# )#4$&6%# 6+0%# +,1=(),*%#C&6+*?B# ().$%(#

.$),#=1+,-#&.$%(#)11%.1#)1#*&66).%()6#0&(#6&),1#0(&/#.();+.+&,)6#2),31@#

8,#&=(#0()*.+&,)6#(%1%('%#1?1.%/B#*&//%(*+)6#2),31#*),#&,6?#%OC),;#

.$%# /&,%?# 1.&*3# 2?# -(),.+,-# ,%4# 6&),1@# 9?# -&+,-# .&# +,1=(),*%#

*&/C),+%1B#().$%(#.$),#*&//%(*+)6#2),31B#.&#1).+10?#.$%+(#0+,),*+,-#

,%%;1B#$&=1%$&6;1#%,1=(%#.$).#.$%?#)(%#,&.#C)(.#&0#.$%#C(&26%/@#

8,#.$%#,%O.#*$)C.%(#4%#%6)2&().%#&,#.$%#*&,,%*.+&,#2%.4%%,#

89:#),;#.$%#<&=,;#>&,%?#<&6=.+&,@#

#

#


&

!!!#

#########################################################1 R. Nelson Nash, Becoming Your Own Banker, Fifth Edition (Birmingham, AL: Infinite Banking Concepts, 2008), p. 77. 2 “Cash value in life insurance: What’s it worth to you?” from http://www.insure.com/articles/lifeinsurance/cash-value.html, accessed May 25, 2010. 3 The presentation was given by Scott Bretl, president of The Financial Self Reliance Group. 4 See Robert Wenzel’s blog post: http://www.economicpolicyjournal.com/2010/02/where-did-links-go-that-point-to.html, accessed May 25, 2010. 5 See Nelson Nash, “Tax-Qualified Retirement Plans, Etc.” at: http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig8/nash2.1.1.html, accessed May 25, 2010. 6 Jesús Huerta de Soto, Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2009), p. 590. 7 Huerta de Soto, Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles, pp. 590-591.

!"##"$%&'()*+,"$-%+"%./!%!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!!"#

#

!!"#

!"#$%&'()*(

+"&(,-!(!./%'012%0./(%.(%"&(3.2/4(5./&6(

3.72%0./(

#

#

!"#$ %&'($ ("&($ )*%#$ *+,-.&+'#$ '/01&+*#,$

2/$+/($#31&+2$'.#2*($+/.$'.#&(#$0/+#4$

*,$ /56*/-,7$ #,1#'*&))4$ *%$ /+#$ '/01&.#,$

("#$ '/+(.&'(,$ ("#4$0&.8#($9*("$ 5&+8,:$

2#0&+2$2#1/,*($/1#.&(*/+,;$

<=#,>,$?-#.(&$2#$@/(/A$$

#$#%#&'()#%)#)*+#,-(+(#.$()-)/)+#0+1(-)+2#3/()4-%$#+5'$'6-()#

7'(+&*# 8%9+4$'# &4%-(+:# )*+# (&-4-)# ;)*'/<*# $')# )*+# =/99#

+5'$'6-5# /$:+4()%$:-$<># '=# )*+# ?,'@+# A'/4# ,'$+BC# 5%6&%-<$2#

0*-5*# /4<+(# &+'&9+# )'# 0-)*:4%0# )*+-4# 6'$+B# =4'6# )*+# &'9-)-5%99B#

5'$$+5)+:2# 1-<# D%99# 8)4++)# 1%$E(# %$:# -$()+%:# )'# :+&'(-)# -)# 0-)*#

5'66/$-)B# 1%$E(# %$:# 54+:-)# /$-'$(F# G'# 6')-@%)+# *-(# :-(5/((-'$#

8%9+4$'#4+5'/$)+:#%#&+4('$%9#%$+5:')+H#

#D*+$# .# 0%(# %$# /$:+4<4%:/%)+# %)# I'()'$# J'99+<+# -$# )*+# KLMN(2#

'$+#'=# )*+#0++E9B#/$:+4<4'/$:#$+0(&%&+4(# )*%)# 5%)+4+:# )'# )*+#

O"N2NNN# 5'99+<+# ()/:+$)(# -$# )*+# I'()'$# 6+)4'&'9-)%$# %4+%#

=+%)/4+:# %# &%<+# 9+$<)*# %:# 1B# )*+# 9+=)P0-$<# <4%:/%)+# +5'$'6-5#

()/:+$)(#'=#)*+#I'()'$#5*%&)+4#'=#QRST#;Q$-'$#'=#R%:-5%9##

.#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB$$

!!U#

S'9-)-5%9#T5'$'6-()(>F##G*+#%:#%&&+%9+:#)'#)*+#5'99+<+#()/:+$)(#'=#

I'()'$# )'#0-)*:4%0#%99# )*+#5%(*# =4'6#)*+-4#5*+5E-$<#%$:#(%@-$<#

%55'/$)(# )*+# ='99'0-$<# V4-:%B# %(# %# &4')+()# %<%-$()# )*+# W-+)$%6#

D%4F#I+-$<#%$#+5'$'6-5(#6%X'4#%$:#$+'&*B)+#3/()4-%$2#.#4+%9-Y+:#

)*%)#(/5*#%$#%5)-'$#0'/9:#5%/(+#(+@+4+#:-==-5/9)-+(#='4#)*+#1%$E(2#

1+5%/(+# )*+B# '$9B# *+9:# ;%)# )*+# )-6+># %1'/)# K!# 5+$)(# '=# +@+4B#

:'99%4#'=#:+6%$:#:+&'(-)(#%$:#!# 5+$)(#'=# +@+4B#:'99%4#'=# (%@-$<#

:+&'(-)(# -$# )*+# ='46#'=#5%(*F##G*+#4+()#'=# )*+#:+&'(-)(#0+4+# 9+$)#

'/)#='4#9'$<+4#'4#(*'4)+4#&+4-':(#'=#)-6+#:+(&-)+#)*+#=%5)#)*%)#)*+#

1%$E(# *%:# 5'$)4%5)/%99B# '19-<%)+:# )*+6(+9@+(# )'# 4+:++6# )*+#

+$)-4+# %6'/$)# '$#:+6%$:F## G*+4+#0%(#6/5*#:-(5/((-'$#'=# (/5*#

%$#%5)-'$#'$#)*+#IJ#%$:#')*+4#I'()'$#5%6&/(+(#:/4-$<#)*+#0++E#

9+%:-$<# /&# )'# )*+# &9%$$+:# 6%((# %5)-'$F# Z=# 5'/4(+2# 0*+$# V4-:%B#

4'99+:#%4'/$:#)*+#+@+$)#=-YY9+:2#1+5%/(+#()/:+$)(#0+4+#)''#1/(B#

&%4)B-$<# ;G*/4(:%B# 1+-$<# )*+# /$'==-5-%9# ()%4)# '=# )*+# 0++E+$:>F##

I/)#)*+#-:+%#0%(#%#14-99-%$)#'$+FO#

##

8%9+4$'#+[&9%-$+:# )*%)#,/44%B#R')*1%4:#*-6(+9=# 4+5'<$-Y+:#

)*%)# -$='46+:# 5-)-Y+$(#0+4+#$')#*+9&9+((# -$# )*+# =%5+#'=# )*+# 5/44+$)#

=-$%$5-%9#(B()+6H#

#,/44%B#R')*1%4:#$+@+4#)-4+:#'=#&'-$)-$<#'/)#)*%)#-$#%#=4++#('5-+)B#

&9%-$#5-)-Y+$(#5'/9:#14-$<#-$=9%)-'$%4B#=4%5)-'$%9#4+(+4@+#1%$E(#)'#

*++9#)*4'/<*#%#:+9-1+4%)+#%$:#5'$5+4)+:#5%6&%-<$#)'#<+)#&+'&9+#

)'# 0-)*:4%0# )*+-4# :+&'(-)(# -$# 5%(*F## ?3$)-1%$E# \+%</+(2C# %(# *+#

5%99+:# )*+62# 0'/9:# 1+# ='46+:# 1B# )*'(+# ?0*'# E$'0# )*+# )4/)*#

%1'/)# )*+# 4+%9# -$('9@+$5B#'=# )*+#1%$E-$<# (B()+6C# )'# ?/4<+#1%$E#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!!M#

4/$(FC##G*+#1%$E#4/$(#'4#)*+-4#@+4B#)*4+%)#0'/9:#?1+#%19+#)'#()'&#

%$:#4+@+4(+#6'$+)%4B#+[&%$(-'$FC#

##

G*+#&4'19+6#0-)*#(/5*#()4%)+<-+(2#'=#5'/4(+2#-(#)*%)#)*+B#%(E#

-$:-@-:/%9#*'/(+*'9:(#)'#?)%E+#'$+#='4#)*+#)+%6FC#.)#-(#'1@-'/(9B#@+4B#

-$5'$@+$-+$)#)'#+(5*+0#)*+#/(+#'=#1%$E-$<#%$:#(0-)5*#)'#5%(*P1%(+:#

)4%$(%5)-'$(F# A'/$<# &+'&9+# %$:# &''4# *'/(+*'9:(# 6-<*)# 1+# %19+# )'#

(/4@-@+#0-)*'/)#/(-$<#5*+5E-$<#%$:#(%@-$<(#%55'/$)(2#1/)#%#6-::9+P#

'4#/&&+4P-$5'6+#*'/(+*'9:#-$#%#6':+4$#+5'$'6B#59+%49B#5'/9:#$')F#

G*+#1+%/)B#'=#]+9('$#]%(*^(# .$=-$-)+#I%$E-$<#J'$5+&)_%$:#

)*+#54/[#'=# )*-(#1''E_-(#)*%)# .IJ# -(#+==+5)-@+#1')*# -$:-@-:/%99B#&+2#

5'99+5)-@+9BF# ]%(*# %$:# *-(# ='99'0+4(# *%@+# :+@')+:# )*+-4# )-6+# )'#

(*'0-$<#*'/(+*'9:(#)*%)#)*+B#5%$#&4'@-:+#)*+6(+9@+(#0-)*#%#6/5*#

6'4+# (+5/4+# =/)/4+# 1B# %55/6/9%)-$<# )*+-4# (%@-$<(# -$# 0*'9+# 9-=+#

-$(/4%$5+#&'9-5-+(2# %$:#1'44'0-$<#%<%-$()# )*+(+#&'9-5-+(# )'# =-$%$5+#

)*+-4# 6%X'4# &/45*%(+(F# ,%$B# 6+61+4(# '=# )*+# 6':+4$# 3/()4-%$#

85*''92# '$# )*+# ')*+4# *%$:2# *%@+# 1++$# +:/5%)-$<# )*+# &/19-5# '$# )*+#

:%$<+4(# '=# =4%5)-'$%9# 4+(+4@+# 1%$E-$<2# %$:# '=# )*+# <'@+4$6+$)^(#

-$@'9@+6+$)#-$#)*+#=-$%$5-%9#(+5)'4F#

.)# -(# )-6+# ='4# )*+(+# )0'# 6'@+6+$)(# )'# X'-$# ='45+(F# 3(# 0+#

+9%1'4%)+#-$#)*+#$+[)#(+5)-'$2#)*+#5'66+45-%9#1%$E(#5%$#'$9B#+[&%$:#

)*+# 6'$+B# (/&&9B# 1B# <4%$)-$<# $+0# )/&+,F# G*+# 6'4+# *'/(+*'9:(#

1+<-$#)'#&4%5)-5+#.IJ2#)*+#=+0+4#9'%$#%&&9-5%$)(#)*+#1%$E(#0-99#*%@+F#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!!`#

G*/(#.IJ#6%E+(#(+$(+#'$#%$#-$:-@-:/%92#*'/(+*'9:#9+@+92#1/)#-)#%9('#

5'$)4-1/)+(#)'#)*+#('/$:$+((#'=#)*+#:'99%4#%$:#:%6&+$(#)*+#1''6P

1/()#5B59+F#

.)# -(# $'# 5'-$5-:+$5+# )*%)# .IJ# -(# 5'6&%)-19+# %$:# +@+$#

5'6&9+6+$)%4B# )'# 3/()4-%$# &'9-5B# 4+5'66+$:%)-'$(F# D+# *%@+#

%94+%:B# $')+:# )*%)# 3/()4-%$# +5'$'6-5(# *%(# %$# %==-$-)B# ='4# )*+#

-$()-)/)-'$#'=#-$(/4%$5+F#I+B'$:#)*%)2#]+9('$#]%(*#*-6(+9=#-(#%#*/<+#

&4'&'$+$)# '=# )*+# 3/()4-%$# )4%:-)-'$2# *%@-$<# &+4('$%99B# 1++$#

-$()4/5)+:#1B#\+'$%4:#R++:# -$#)*+#KL"N(F# .$#)*+#(/<<+()+:#4+%:-$<#

9-()# %)# )*+# +$:# '=# C#'/0*+D$ E/-.$ F9+$ C&+8#.2# ]%(*# 9-()(# (+@+4%9#

1''E(# =4'6# )*+#V'/$:%)-'$# ='4#T5'$'6-5#T:/5%)-'$#%$:# )*+#,-(+(#

.$()-)/)+F#

G*+# &4'&'$+$)(# '=# .IJ# %$:# )*+# (5*'9%4(# -$# )*+# 3/()4-%$#

)4%:-)-'$#5%$#9+%4$#=4'6#+%5*#')*+42#%$:#-$#:'-$<#('#5%$#6%E+#)*+-4#

6+((%<+(# 6'4+# %))4%5)-@+# )'# )*+-4# 4+(&+5)-@+# %/:-+$5+(F# G*'(+#

)4B-$<#)'#(*'0#')*+4(#)*+#1+$+=-)(#'=#.IJ#5%$#%::#%#$+0#&'-$)#-$#-)(#

=%@'4H# .)(# 0-:+(&4+%:# &4%5)-5+# 0'/9:# &4+(+4@+# )*+# 5/44+$5B# %$:#

()4+$<)*+$#)*+#+5'$'6Ba##

V'4# )*+-4# &%4)2# 3/()4-%$# +5'$'6-()(# *%@+# :-==-5/9)B# )+%5*-$<#

)*+#:%$<+4(#'=#5+$)4%9#1%$E-$<#%$:#')*+4#<'@+4$6+$)#-$)+4@+$)-'$(2#

0*+$#-)#(++6(#)*%)#%#5*%$<+#5%$#'$9B#'55/4#'$5+#%#(/==-5-+$)#$/61+4#

'=#36+4-5%$(# (++# )*+# 9-<*)F#,'4+#&+'&9+#0-99# 1+#0-99-$<# )'# 9-()+$# )'#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!!L#

)*+-4# :-%<$'(-(# '=# )*+# &4'19+62# -=# )*+# 3/)4-%$(# 5%$# '==+4# %$#

-66+:-%)+#;&%4)-%9>#,/)-(*/+#%(#0+99F#

Q9)-6%)+9B2#)*+#8'/$:#,'$+B#8'9/)-'$#4+b/-4+(#)*+#5'6&9+)+#

4+6'@%9#'=#<'@+4$6+$)#-$)+4=+4+$5+#-$#=-$%$5-%9#%==%-4(F#,'$+B#%$:#

1%$E-$<# 6/()# 1+# 4+)/4$+:# )'# )*+# &4-@%)+# (+5)'42# 0*+4+# )*+B#

:+@+9'&+:F# c'@+4$6+$)# '==-5-%9(# 0-99# '$9B# 4+9-$b/-(*# )*+-4# @%()#

&'0+4(#-$#)*-(#4+%96#0*+$#&/19-5#'&-$-'$#:+6%$:(#-)F#

V'4)/$%)+9B2#)*+#4+)/4$#)'#('/$:#6'$+B#:'+(#$')#4+b/-4+#)*+#

?5'$@+4(-'$C# '=# %99# )*+# &'&/9%)-'$2# '4# +@+$# %# 6%X'4-)BF# ,%$B#

3/()4-%$(#1+9-+@+#)*%)# -=# )*+B#5'/9:# X/()#4+%5*#%#('9-:#KN#&+45+$)#'=#

)*+#&'&/9%)-'$2#+(&+5-%99B#-=#)*+B#5'$)%-$+:#4+&4+(+$)%)-@+(#=4'6#E+B#

&'(-)-'$(#-$#%5%:+6-%2#)*+#6+:-%2#%$:#)*+#1/(-$+((#5'66/$-)B2#)*+$#

)*-(#<4'/&#5'/9:#)/4$#)*+#)-:+F#3#9%4<+#(+<6+$)2#&+4*%&(#%#6%X'4-)B2#

'=# 36+4-5%$(# %4+# )''# 1/(B# %$:# 9%5E# )*+# -$)+4+()# )'# 5%4+=/99B# ()/:B#

)*+#-$)4-5%5-+(#'=#5+$)4%9#1%$E-$<#%$:#6'$+)%4B#)*+'4BF#d'0+@+42#-=#

%# (/==-5-+$)# $/61+4# '=# 4+(&+5)+:# -$:-@-:/%9(# 5*%99+$<+# )*+#

-$)+4@+$)-'$-()# '4)*':'[B# %$:# ,(&(#$ ("#$ /56*/-,_$%6+9B# )*%)#

&'9-)-5-%$(#:'$^)#6%E+# <'':# 4+</9%)'4(2# %$:# )*%)# &4-$)-$<#/&# <4++$#

&-+5+(#'=#&%&+4#:'+($^)#6%E+# )*+# 5'/$)4B# 4-5*+4_)*+$#%# 4+)/4$# )'#

('/$:#6'$+B# 5%$#*%&&+$F# G*+# (/4&4-(-$<#&'&/9%4-)B# '=#R'$#S%/9^(#

ONN`#&4+(-:+$)-%9#5%6&%-<$_%$:#-$#&%4)-5/9%4#)*+#4+('$%$5+#'=#-)(#

?T$:# )*+# V+:C# 6+((%<+# 0-)*# 5'99+<+# ()/:+$)(_-(# %# (-<$# )*%)# )*+#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!eN#

36+4-5%$#&+'&9+#E$'0#('6+)*-$<# -(# @+4B#04'$<#%$:# )*+B#0%$)# )'#

9+%4$#)*+#)4/)*F#

.$# )*-(# 1''E# 0+# *%@+# b/-)+# 5'$(5-'/(9B# 19+$:+:# )*+#

&4+(+$)%)-'$# '=# 3/()4-%$# +5'$'6-5(# %$:# )*+# &4-$5-&9+(# '=# .IJF#

]+9('$# ]%(*# *%(# :-(5'@+4+:# )*%)# %# )4%:-)-'$%9# =-$%$5-%9# &4':/5)_

:-@-:+$:P&%B-$<#0*'9+# 9-=+# -$(/4%$5+_5%$#1+#/(+:# )'# -66+:-%)+9B#

-6&9+6+$)# %# ='46# '=# &4-@%)-Y+:# 1%$E-$<2# '$+# *'/(+*'9:# %)# %# )-6+F#

Tb/%99B# -6&'4)%$)2# 0*+$# 6%X'4# &/45*%(+(# %4+# =-$%$5+:# )*4'/<*#

0*'9+#9-=+#&'9-5B#9'%$(2#)*-(#:'+(#+/(#+[&%$:#)*+#6'$+B#(/&&9B#%$:#

5'$)4-1/)+# )'# )*+#1''6P1/()# 5B59+F#D+# (&+99# '/)# )*-(# 54/5-%9# =%5)# -$#

)*+#$+[)#(+5)-'$F#

#

8".7&(90:&(;.70<6(9.#/=(>'&(4(*$,/:7#%0./#'6(

#

.$# J*%&)+4(# `# %$:# KU# 0+# +[&9%-$+:# *'0# '/4# =4%5)-'$%9#

4+(+4@+#(B()+6#5/44+$)9B#%99'0(#5'66+45-%9#1%$E(#)'#9-)+4%99B#54+%)+#

6'$+B#'/)#'=#)*-$#%-42#0*+$#)*+B#+[)+$:#$+0#9'%$(F#.$#'/4#+[%6&9+#

=4'6#J*%&)+4#KU2#I-99B#='/$:#fK2NNN#-$#5/44+$5B#%$:#:+&'(-)+:#-)#-$#%#

5'66+45-%9#1%$EF#G*+$# )*+#1%$E#%:@%$5+:#%# 9'%$#'=#fLNN# )'#8%99BF#

G*-(#fLNN#0%(#%$#%::-)-'$#)'#)*+#6'$+B#(/&&9B#*+9:#1B#6+61+4(#'=#

)*+#5'66/$-)BF#

.$#')*+4#0'4:(2#8%99B#0%(#%19+# )'#0%9E#%4'/$:#)'0$2#1/B-$<#

<'':(# %$:# (+4@-5+(# &4-5+:# /&# )'# fLNN2# 0*-9+# $'# '$+# +9(+# -$# )*+#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!eK#

)'0$_-$59/:-$<#I-99B#%$:#)*+#5'66+45-%9#1%$E+4(_*%:#)'#4+()4-5)#

&/45*%(+(F# .$# )*+# %<<4+<%)+2# 0-)*# +@+4B# 5'66+45-%9# 1%$E# 6%E-$<#

$+0#9'%$(# -$#%#(-6-9%4# =%(*-'$2# )*+#&4-5+(# -$#)*+#5'66/$-)B#0-99#1+#

&/(*+:#/&#1+5%/(+#'=# )*+#$+0#6'$+B#54+%)-'$F#D+#5'$59/:+:# )*%)#

/$:+4# $'46%9# 5-45/6()%$5+(2# )*+# 6%X'4-)B# '=# &4-5+# -$=9%)-'$# -(#

5%/(+:# +/(# 1B# )*+# V+:+4%9# R+(+4@+# :-4+5)9B# 1/)# -$()+%:# 1B# )*+#

5'66+45-%9#1%$E(#0*+$# )*+B# 5%44B#'/)# ()%$:%4:#1/(-$+((#&4%5)-5+#

-$#)*+#=4%5)-'$%9#4+(+4@+#(B()+6#='()+4+:#%$:#/&*+9:#1B#)*+#V+:F#

.$# )*-(# 5'$)+[)2# -)# -(# 4+%((/4-$<# )'# &'-$)# '/)# )*%)# 0*+$# %$#

*+,-.&+'#$'/01&+4#<4%$)(#%#$+0#9'%$#)'#%#&'9-5B*'9:+42#%"0=( 0=(/.%(

0/:7#%0./#'6F# G*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B# :'+(#+/(# *%@+# )*+# %1-9-)B# )'#

54+%)+#$+0#6'$+B#'/)#'=#)*-$#%-4F#.=#8%99B#0%$)(#)'#1'44'0#fLNN#='4#

*+4# 1/(-$+((2# %$:# (*+# *%(# &4+@-'/(9B# %55/6/9%)+:# (/==-5-+$)# 5%(*#

@%9/+(# -$# %# 9-=+# -$(/4%$5+# &'9-5B2# (*+# 5%$# )/4$# )'# )*+# -$(/4%$5+#

5'6&%$B#4%)*+4#)*%$#)*+#5'66+45-%9#1%$EF#D*+$#)*+#-$(/4+4#<4%$)(#

)*+#9'%$2#*($0-,($'/+(.&'($*(,$/("#.$&,,#($"/)2*+D,F#

.)# -(# *+9&=/9# )'# ()+&# 1%5E# %$:# 5'$(-:+4# )*+# 1-<# &-5)/4+F# .$#

+((+$5+2# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B# 4+5+-@+(#&4+6-/6#&%B6+$)(# =4'6#

)*+# &'9-5B*'9:+4(2# %$:# -)# 6/()# -$@+()# )*+6# -$# @+4B# 5'$(+4@%)-@+#

%((+)(# )'# 4+(&'$(-19B# 5%44B# '/)# -)(# =/$5)-'$# '=# &4'@-:-$<# :+%)*#

1+$+=-)#&%B6+$)(#0*+$#$++:+:F#G4%:-)-'$%99B#-$(/4+4(#-$@+()#-$#@+4B#

(%=+# 1'$:(# %$:# -$# 4+%9# +()%)+# ;0*-5*# 0+4+# 5'$(-:+4+:# %# (%=+# %((+)#

59%((# /$)-9# )*+# 4+5+$)# 1''6g1/()>F# d'0+@+42# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$-+(#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!eO#

5%$# %9('# -$@+()# -$# ?1'$:(C# -((/+:# 54$ ("#$ 1/)*'4"/)2#.,$ ("#0,#)6#,F#

G*%)# -(#+((+$)-%99B#0*%)#*%&&+$(#0*+$#('6+'$+#)%E+(#'/)#%#&'9-5B#

9'%$F#

G*+4+#-(#)*/(#$')*-$<#:/1-'/(#'55/44-$<#0*+$#%#&'9-5B*'9:+4#

'1)%-$(#%#9'%$#=4'6#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#5'6&%$B2#%$B#6'4+#)*%$#0*+$#%#

6%X'4# 5'4&'4%)-'$# '1)%-$(# %# 9'%$# =4'6# %$# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$BF#

.$:++:2#)*+#9'%$#)'#)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4#-(#%5)/%99B#,&%#.#)*%$#)*+#9'%$#)'#

%# 5'4&'4%)-'$2# 1+5%/(+# )*+# &'9-5B*'9:+4# 5%$^)# :+=%/9)F# ;R+6+61+42#

+@+$#-=#*+#'4#(*+#$+@+4#&%B(#1%5E#)*+#9'%$2#)*+#-$(/4+4#4+5'/&(#)*+#

-$@+()6+$)# 1B# (/1)4%5)-$<# )*+# '/)()%$:-$<# 1%9%$5+_0-)*# %554/+:#

-$)+4+()_=4'6#)*+#:+%)*#1+$+=-)#5*+5EF>#

8'# 0+# (++2# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B# -(# -$# )*+# &'(-)-'$# '=#

6%$%<-$<# %((+)(# ;=/$:+:#1B#&4+6-/6#&%B6+$)(># -$# '4:+4# )'#6++)#

-)(# 5'$)4%5)/%9# '19-<%)-'$(# %(# (&+99+:# '/)# -$# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# &'9-5-+(F#

G*+# &'9-5B*'9:+4(# *%@+# ?=-4()# :-1(C# '$# )*+# (/&&9B# '=# )*+(+# %((+)(2#

6+%$-$<#)*%)#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#5'6&%$B#=-4()#9''E(#)'#)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4(#

)'# (++# -=# %$B# '=# )*+6# 0-(*# )'# 1'44'0# =4'6# )*+# &''9# '=# &4+6-/6#

&%B6+$)(F#3=)+4#)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4(#*%@+#1++$#(%)-(=-+:2#)*+#4+6%-$-$<#

&''9#'=#6'$+B#-(#)*+$#-$@+()+:#-$#'/)(-:+#&4'X+5)(F#

]%)/4%99B# 0+# %4+# -<$'4-$<# ('6+# '=# )*+# 4+%9P0'49:#

5'6&9-5%)-'$(F#39)*'/<*#%#&%4)-5/9%4#&'9-5B#9'%$#-(#(%=+4#)*%$#+@+$#%#

19/+P5*-&#1'$:#-$#'$+#(+$(+2#'$#)*+#')*+4#*%$:#)*+#&'9-5B#9'%$#'$9B#

?6%)/4+(C#;%$:#-$=9/+$5+(#5%(*=9'0>#%)#/$5+4)%-$#)-6+(2#+-)*+4#0*+$#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!e!#

)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4#6%E+(#&%B6+$)(#'$#)*+# 9'%$#'4#0*+$#)*+# -$(/4+:#

:-+(# %$:# )*+# :+%)*# 1+$+=-)# 5*+5E# -(# 9'0+4# )*%$# -)# ')*+40-(+#0'/9:#

*%@+#1++$F#.$#5'$)4%()2#)*+#5'4&'4%)+#1'$:#'==+4(#%#6'4+#&4+:-5)%19+#

()4+%6# '=# 5%(*=9'02# %((/6-$<# $'# :+=%/9)F# ]')0-)*()%$:-$<# )*+(+#

4+%9P0'49:# 5'$(-:+4%)-'$(2# /9)-6%)+9B# &'9-5B# 9'%$(# %4+# X/()# %$')*+4#

%((+)# 59%((# -$# 0*-5*# )*+# -$(/4+4# 5%$# -$@+()# -)(# =9'0# '=# &4+6-/6#

&%B6+$)(2# 0*+4+# )*+# 1'44'0+4(# X/()# ('# *%&&+$# )'# '0$# 9-=+#

-$(/4%$5+#&'9-5-+(#0-)*#)*+#5'6&%$B#%$:#0*+4+#)*+(+#(%6+#&'9-5-+(#

&4'@-:+#)*+#5'99%)+4%9#6%E-$<#)*+#9'%$(#&+4=+5)9B#(%=+F#

G*+#54/5-%9#&'-$)#-(#)*%)#0*+$#%#&'9-5B*'9:+4#4+b/+()(#%#9'%$#

=4'6# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B2# *-(# %5b/-(-)-'$# '=# 6'$+B# $+5+((%4-9B#

6+%$(# )*%)# ('6+'$+##),## -$# )*+# +5'$'6B#$'0#*%(# 9+((#&/45*%(-$<#

&'0+4F# D*+$# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B# (+$:(# %# 5*+5E# )'# %#

&'9-5B*'9:+4# %=)+4# %# 9'%$# 4+b/+()2# )*%)# 6'$+B# *%:# )'# '/0## =4'6#

('6+0*+4+F#Q$9-E+#%#5'66+45-%9#1%$E2#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#5'6&%$B#5%$^)#

(-6&9B# -$54+%(+# )*+# $/61+4(# '$# -)(# 9+:<+42# (*'0-$<# *'0# 6/5*#

6'$+B# )*+# 5/()'6+4# *%(# ?'$# :+&'(-)FC# ]'2# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B#

-)(+9=#6/()#=-4()#4%-(+#)*+#=/$:(#;=4'6#-$5'6-$<#&4+6-/6#&%B6+$)(2#

-$5'6+#+%4$+:#'$# -)(# %((+)(2# '4# )*4'/<*# (+99-$<# ('6+#'=# -)(# %((+)(>#

1+='4+# )4%$(=+44-$<# )*+6# )'# )*+# &'9-5B*'9:+4# %(# %# 9'%$F# S+45B#

c4+%@+(2# -$#*-(# -$)4':/5)-'$#)'#%#1''E#1B#\/:0-<#@'$#,-(+(2#:4-@+(#

*'6+#)*+#5+$)4%9#&'-$)H#

#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!ee#

hGi*+#5%(*#(/44+$:+4#@%9/+(#'=#9-=+#-$(/4%$5+#&'9-5-+(#%4+#

$')# =/$:(# )*%)# :+&'(-)'4(# %$:# &'9-5B# *'9:+4(# 5%$# '1)%-$# %$:#

(&+$:# 0-)*'/)# 4+:/5-$<# )*+# 5%(*# '=# ')*+4(F# G*+(+# =/$:(# %4+# -$#

9%4<+#&%4)# -$@+()+:# %$:# )*/(#$')#*+9:# -$# %#6'$+)%4B# ='46F#G*%)#

&%4)# 0*-5*# -(# -$# 1%$E(# '4# -$# 5%(*# -(2# '=# 5'/4(+2# -$59/:+:# -$# )*+#

b/%$)-)B#'=#6'$+B#0*-5*#-(#+-)*+4#-$#'4#'/)#'=#1%$E(#%$:#(*'/9:#

$')# 1+# 5'/$)+:# %# (+5'$:# )-6+F# Q$:+4# &4+(+$)# 9%0(2# (/5*#

-$()-)/)-'$(# 5%$$')# +[)+$:# 54+:-)# 1+B'$:# (/6(# 4+5+-@+:F# .=# )*+B#

$++:# )'# 4%-(+# 6'4+# 5%(*# )*%$# )*+B# *%@+# '$# *%$:# )'# 6++)#

5/()'6+4#0-)*:4%0%9(2#)*+B#6/()#(+99#('6+#'=#)*+-4#-$@+()6+$)(#

%$:#4+:/5+#)*+#1%$E#%55'/$)(#'4#5%(*#*'9:-$<(#'=#)*'(+#0*'#1/B#

)*+6F# 355'4:-$<9B2# ("#4$ G*;#;$ ("#$ *+,-.&+'#$ '/01&+*#,H$ &.#$ *+$ +/$

1/,*(*/+$ (/$ #31&+2$ '.#2*($ /.$ *+'.#&,#$ ("#$ +&(*/+:,$ I-&+(*(4$ /%$

0/+#4$&,$'&+$'/00#.'*&)$&+2$'#+(.&)$5&+8,7$&))$/%$9"*'"$/1#.&(#$

/+$ &$ %.&'(*/+&)$ .#,#.6#$ 5&,*,$ &+2$ '&+$ )#+2$ 0/.#$ 0/+#4$ ("&+$ *,$

#+(.-,(#2$(/$("#0;!#

#

8'#0+#(++#)*%)#$')#'$9B#:'+(#.IJ#6%E+#(+$(+#'$#%$#-$:-@-:/%9#

=-$%$5-%9# 9+@+92# 1/)# -)# %9('# 9-6-)(# )*+#%1-9-)B#'=# 5'66+45-%9#1%$E(# )'#

+[&%$:# %$:# 5'$)4%5)# )*+# )')%9# %6'/$)# '=# 6'$+B# -$# )*+# +5'$'6BF#

D-)*# +%5*# $+0# *'/(+*'9:# )*%)# +614%5+(# )*+# .IJ# &*-9'('&*B2#

%$')*+4# (6%99# &'4)-'$# '=# )*+# $%)-'$^(# =-$%$5-%9# 4+('/45+(# 0-99# 1+#

)4%$(=+44+:#'/)#'=# )*+#@'9%)-9+# 5'66+45-%9# 1%$E-$<# (+5)'4# %$:# -$)'#

)*+# 5'$(+4@%)-@+2# ('9-:# -$(/4%$5+# (+5)'4F# 3(# 6'4+# &+'&9+# +614%5+#

.IJ2#)*+#%6&9-)/:+#'=#)*+#1''6P1/()#5B59+#-)(+9=#0-99#1+#:%6&+$+:F#

#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!e"#

-#/?0/@(#/4(,/=2'#/<&(>'&(A0=%0/<%(B/%&'$'0=&=#

#

39)*'/<*# ]+9('$# ]%(*# +$5'/4%<+(# *-(# 4+%:+4(# )'# 1+5'6+#

)*+-4#'0$#1%$E+4(#)*4'/<*#)*+#/(+#'=#0*'9+#9-=+#-$(/4%$5+#&'9-5-+(2#-)#

-(# -6&'4)%$)# ='4# .IJ# &4%5)-)-'$+4(# )'# 4+6+61+4# )*%)# 1%$E-$<# %$:#

-$(/4%$5+# &.## :-()-$5)# +$)+4&4-(+(F# ;3(# '$+# -$(/4%$5+# +[+5/)-@+#

5'6&9%-$+:# )'# )*+#&4+(+$)#04-)+4(H# ?S+'&9+# E++&# 4+=+44-$<# )'# )*+-4#

&'9-5B# %(# %#1%$E2#1/)#:-:# )*+B#+@+4#*%@+# )'#&++# -$# %# 5/&# )'#'&+$#%#

5*+5E-$<#%55'/$)jC>#

.$#&%4)-5/9%42#.IJ#&4%5)-)-'$+4(#(*'/9:#%90%B(#4+6+61+4#)*%)#

()4-5)9B#(&+%E-$<2#)*+B#%4+#$')#?0-)*:4%0-$<#)*+-4#6'$+BC#0*+$#)*+B#

)%E+#'/)#%#&'9-5B# 9'%$F# .$()+%:2#0*%)#*%&&+$(# -(# )*%)# )*+# -$(/4%$5+#

5'6&%$B#-(#)#+2*+D#)*+6#*(,#6'$+B2#X/()#%(#(/4+9B#%(#-=#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#

5'6&%$B#1'/<*)#1'$:(#-((/+:#1B#%#6%X'4#5'4&'4%)-'$F#.$#)*%)#5%(+2#

c+$+4%9# T9+5)4-5# 5+4)%-$9B# 0'/9:$^)# 1+# 0-)*:4%0-$<# ('6+# '=# ?cT^(#

6'$+BC#=4'6#)*+#-$(/4+42#%$:#$+-)*+4#-(#)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4#0*+$#*+#'4#

(*+#%&&9-+(#='4#%#9'%$F#

Z=# 5'/4(+2# %$# -6&'4)%$)#:-==+4+$5+#1+)0++$# )*+# 5%(+(# '=#cT#

%$:#%#&'9-5B# 9'%$2# -(# )*%)# )*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4#5%$#'$9B#1'44'0#%<%-$()#

)*+#(%@-$<(#*+#'4#(*+#*%(#&).#&24$&''-0-)&(#2#-$#%#&'9-5BF#G*+4+='4+#

)*+#)%E-$<#'/)#'=#%#9'%$#:'+($^)#(-<$-=B#%$#%1('9/)+#-$:+1)+:$+((2#1/)#

4%)*+4#%$#'==(+)#'=#)*+#59%-6#)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4#*%(#%<%-$()#)*+#%((+)(#

'=#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#5'6&%$B#;:/+#)'#)*+#9-=+#-$(/4%$5+#&'9-5B#-)(+9=>F##

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!eU#

.IJ#&4%5)-)-'$+4(#(*'/9:#%9('#E++&#-$#6-$:#)*%)#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#

5'6&%$B# -(# $')# %# 0%4+*'/(+# ='4# )*+-4# 6'$+Bk# -=# )*+B# @-+0# -)# %(# %#

1%$E2#)*+B#(*'/9:#4+%9-Y+#-)#-(#%)#1+()#%#)/&+$1%$E2#$')#%#2#1/,*($1%$EF#

.$#')*+4#0'4:(2#-=#)*+B#%4+#@-+0-$<#)*+-4#(/44+$:+4#5%(*#@%9/+(#%(#%#

1%$E#1%9%$5+2#)*+B#6/()#4+%9-Y+#-)#-(#%$%9'<'/(#)'#%#,&6*+D,#%55'/$)2#

%$:#$')#%#5*+5E-$<#%55'/$)F#

7+(l(# d/+4)%# :+# 8')'2# )*+# <4+%)# '&&'$+$)# '=# 6':+4$#

;=4%5)-'$%9# 4+(+4@+># 1%$E-$<# %$:# )*+# <4+%)# 5*%6&-'$# '=# )4%:-)-'$%9#

9-=+# -$(/4%$5+2# -(# b/-)+# 0%4B# '=# )*+# 4+5+$)# )+$:+$5B# '=# -$(/4%$5+#

5'6&%$-+(# )'# %))4%5)# 5/()'6+4(# 1B# +6/9%)-$<# )*+# )+5*$-b/+(# '=#

5'66+45-%9#1%$E-$<F#m+#8')'#5'6&9%-$(#)*%)#

#)*+#:-()-$5)#1'/$:%4-+(#1+)0++$#)*+# -$()-)/)-'$#'=# 9-=+# -$(/4%$5+#

%$:#)*+#1%$E-$<#(+5)'4#*%@+#'=)+$#1++$#19/44+:#-$#6%$B#0+()+4$#

5'/$)4-+(F# G*-(# 19/44-$<# '=# 1'/$:%4-+(# *%(# &+46-))+:# )*+#

+6+4<+$5+# '=# @%4-'/(# (/&&'(+:# ?9-=+# -$(/4%$5+C# '&+4%)-'$(#

0*-5*2# -$()+%:# '=# ='99'0-$<# )*+# )4%:-)-'$%9# &4-$5-&9+(# '=# )*+#

(+5)'42# *%@+# 1++$# :+(-<$+:# )'# 6%(E# )4/+# :+6%$:P:+&'(-)#

5'$)4%5)(# h-F+F# 5*+5E-$<# %55'/$)(i# 0*-5*# -$@'9@+# %$# %))+6&)# )'#

</%4%$)++# )*+# -66+:-%)+2# 5'6&9+)+# %@%-9%1-9-)B# )'# )*+#

&'9-5B*'9:+4# '=# )*+# 6'$+B# :+&'(-)+:# %(# ?&4+6-/6(C# %$:# '=# )*+#

5'44+(&'$:-$<# -$)+4+()F# G*-(# 5'44/&)-'$n*%(# +[+4)+:# %# @+4B#

$+<%)-@+# -$=9/+$5+# '$# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# (+5)'4# %(# %# 0*'9+# %$:# *%(#

6%:+# -)# &'((-19+# ='4# ('6+# 9-=+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$-+(# )'# 6%4E+)#

:+&'(-)(# -$# @-'9%)-'$# '=# )4%:-)-'$%9# 9+<%9# &4-$5-&9+(# %$:# )*/(# )'#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!eM#

%5)2# -$# :-==+4+$)# :+<4++(2# %(# 1%$E(2# -F+F2# )'# 9'%$# 6'$+B# %5)/%99B#

&9%5+:#0-)*#)*+6#'$#:+6%$:#:+&'(-)Fe#

#

.$#5'$)4%()#)'#)*+#?5'44/&)C#&4%5)-5+#-$#0*-5*#%#&'9-5B*'9:+4#

@-+0(#)*+#-$(/4%$5+#5'6&%$B#%(#*'9:-$<#*-(#&4+6-/6#&%B6+$)(#%(#%#

2#1/,*(#)*%)#-(#-66+:-%)+9B#%@%-9%19+#='4#?0-)*:4%0%9C_+@+$#)*'/<*#

)*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B# *%(# 9+$)# )*+# 6'$+B# )'# ')*+4(2# +%4$-$<#

-$)+4+()_:+#8')'#&4+=+4(#%#6'4+#)4%:-)-'$%9#/$:+4()%$:-$<H#

#h.i)# -(# -6&'4)%$)# )'# 4+6+61+4# )*%)# )*+# 5'$)4%5)# '=# 9-=+#

-$(/4%$5+# 1+%4(# $'# 4+9%)-'$# )'# )*+# h5*+5E-$<# %55'/$)# :+&'(-)i#

5'$)4%5)F# \-=+# -$(/4%$5+# -(# %$#&)#&(/.4# 5'$)4%5)# 1B#0*-5*#'$+#'=#

)*+#&%4)-+(2#)*+#5'$)4%5)-$<#&%4)B#'4#&'9-5B*'9:+42#5'66-)(#)'#)*+#

&%B6+$)#'=#)*+#1.#0*-0#'4#&4-5+#'=#)*+#'&+4%)-'$2#%$:#-$#4+)/4$#

)*+# ')*+4# &%4)B2# )*+# -$(/4%$5+# 5'6&%$B2# %<4++(# )'# &%B# 5+4)%-$#

1+$+=-)(#-$#)*+#+@+$)#)*%)#)*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4#:-+(#'4#(/4@-@+(#%)#)*+#

+$:#'=#%#(#.0# (&+5-=-+:# -$# )*+#5'$)4%5)F#G*+4+='4+2#("#$1.#0*-0,$

1&*2$ 54$ ("#$ 1/)*'4"/)2#.$ '/01)#(#)4$ '#&,#$ (/$ 5#$ &6&*)&5)#$ (/$ "*02#

%$:#%@%-9%1-9-)B# -(# =/99B# )4%$(=+44+:# )'# )*+# -$(/4+4F#d+$5+2#%99# 9-=+#

-$(/4%$5+# 5'$)4%5)(# -$@'9@+# %$# +[5*%$<+# '=# &4+(+$)2# 5+4)%-$#

<'':(# h-F+F# &4+6-/6# &%B6+$)(# '=# 6'$+Bi# ='4# =/)/4+2# /$5+4)%-$#

<'':(#;(-$5+#)*+-4#&%B6+$)#:+&+$:(#'$#%$#/$5+4)%-$#+@+$)2#(/5*#

%(# )*+#:+%)*#'4# (/4@-@%9# '=# )*+#&'9-5B*'9:+4>F#G*+# 9-=+# -$(/4%$5+#

5'$)4%5)#-(#)*+4+='4+#+b/-@%9+$)#)'#%#(%@-$<(#)4%$(%5)-'$n1/)#-)#-(#

%# ='46# '=# 1#.%#'(#2# ,&6*+D,2# 1+5%/(+# -)# 6%E+(# -)# &'((-19+# )'#

4+5+-@+# %# 5'$(-:+4%19+# (/6# =4'6# )*+# @+4B#6'6+$)# )*+# 5'$)4%5)#

)%E+(# +==+5)2# <-@+$# )*+# %$)-5-&%)+:2# /$5+4)%-$# +@+$)# )%E+(# &9%5+#

!"#$%&'$'()*+,-.*,()$*($*"#$/(.)0$$1()#2$/(3.*,()$


!e`#

;='4# +[%6&9+2# )*+# &'9-5B*'9:+4# :-+(>F# 3$B# ')*+4# )4%:-)-'$%9#

(%@-$<(# 6+)*':n0'/9:# 4+b/-4+# %# &4'9'$<+:# &+4-':# '=# 6%$B#

B+%4(# '=# (%@-$<# )'# %55/6/9%)+# )*+# 5%&-)%9# &%-:# 1B# %$# -$(/4%$5+#

5'6&%$B#-$#5%(+#'=#:+%)*F"#

#

.$#:+#8')'^(#@-+02#-$(/4%$5+#5'6&%$-+(#5%$#'$9B#4+)%-$#)*+-4#

&4-$5-&9+:# %$:# &4%<6%)-5# %:@%$)%<+(# '@+4# 6':+4$# =4%5)-'$%9#

4+(+4@+# 1%$E-$<# -=# 5/()'6+4(# 9''E# %)# )*+-4# &'9-5-+(# %(# 9'$<P)+46#

5'66-)6+$)(F# G*-(# -(# +$)-4+9B# 5'$(-()+$)# 0-)*# ]+9('$# ]%(*^(# '0$#

4+5'66+$:%)-'$# )'# 5'$:/5)# '$+^(# %==%-4(# -$)+4<+$+4%)-'$%99BF#

.$:++:2# -=# ('6+'$+#'&+$(# %#0*'9+# 9-=+# &'9-5B# 1/)# )*+$# %1%$:'$(# -)#

0-)*-$#%#=+0#B+%4(2#)*+#=-$%$5-%9#4+(/9)(#0-99#1+#6-(+4%19+F#I/)#-=#'$+#

0%$)(#%#6+)*':#)'#(%=+9B#)4%$(6-)#0+%9)*#:+5%:+(#-$)'#)*+#=/)/4+2#'4#

+@+$# )'# '$+^(# 5*-9:4+$# %$:# <4%$:5*-9:4+$2# %# 0*'9+# 9-=+# -$(/4%$5+#

&'9-5B#-(#%$#+[5+99+$)#@+*-59+F#

#

#########################################################1 Jesús Huerta de Soto, Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2009), p. 587. 2 Joe Salerno, “Rothbardian Antibank League on the Rise,” at: http://blog.mises.org/11773/rothbardian-antibank-league-on-the-rise/. Accessed May 27, 2010. 3 Percy Greaves, quoted in Huerta de Soto, footnote 106, p. 592. The italics have been added by de Soto. 4 Huerta de Soto, pp. 594-595. 5 Huerta de Soto, pp. 161-162, italics in original.

!"#$

!"#$%&'()*(

!+,-./01+,(

$

$

!" #$%&'(" #)#*+,-" .$/+0+1" 2+3+4&%&'(-"

%'33$*" /$15" &4" &*" &#" 3$*" #677$1*+8" 2)"

762(&%"$7&3&$39"

:;68/&<"0$3"=&#+#>"

"

$

%$&'(%$)*(%+%,$'$-*.$*/$0+*12,$32$.&34$5**67$82$9'+.$8:$

;%$<+*(3,%,$'2$*(%+(3%;$*/$.&%$)+3434$*1+$2'.3*2:$'2,$

32,%%,$ .&%$ %2.3+%$ ;*+-,:$ /')%47$ =3><-?$ <1.:$ .&%$ 4*12,2%44$ */$ *1+$

>*2%?$ 3.4%-/$ +%4.4$ *2$ 2*.&320$ 51.$ .&%$ .%)&23)'-$ ;3@'+,+?$ */$ A%,$

*//3)3'-4$ '2,$ .&%$ /32'2)3'-$ +%4.+'32.$ */$ B7C7$ <*-3.3)3'247$ D&34$

+%'-3@'.3*2$34$'-'+>320$%2*10&7$

E%.$ 3.$ 0%.4$ ;*+4%7$ F%$ )'22*.$ &*<%$ .*$ +%/*+>$ *1+$ /32'2)3'-$

4?4.%>$5?$.;%'6320$'$/%;$+%01-'.3*24:$*+$5?$)&'20320$.&%$<%+4*22%-$

32$'$/%;$6%?$<*43.3*247$D&%$%2.3+%$/+').3*2'-$+%4%+(%$5'26320$4?4.%>$

&*#+(4$ 34$5'26+1<.GH13.%$-3.%+'--?7$D*$+%2,%+$41)&$'$I1,0>%2.$34$2*.$

.*$>*+'--?$)*2,%>2$.&%$>3--3*24$*/$<%*<-%$;*+-,;3,%$;&*$,3+%).-?$

*+$ 32,3+%).-?$ ;*+6$ /*+$ .&%$ )*>>%+)3'-$ 5'264J$ 32,%%,$ .&%$ <+%4%2.$

'1.&*+4$.&%>4%-(%4$5%)'>%$/1--?$';'+%$*/$.&%$<+*5-%>$*2-?$;3.&32$

.&%$-'4.$/%;$?%'+47$K*2%.&%-%44:$+%0'+,-%44$*/$&*;$;%$'++3(%,$'.$*1+$

F$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!LM$

)1++%2.$4.'.%:$;%$>14.$'--$ +%)*023@%$ .&'.$;%$ /')%$'$ .+1%$+,+1<+3%)$

'2,$;%$>14.$'--$,*$*1+$<'+.$.*$4'-('0%$.&%$43.1'.3*27$

A*+.12'.%-?$.&%+%$34$&*<%7$N4$;%$%O<-'32%,$32$9'+.$88:$.&%$/+%%$

>'+6%.$ %)*2*>?:$ *+$ ;&'.$ 34$ */.%2$ )'--%,$ %'7&*'(&#,:$ )'2$ /*4.%+$

<%')%/1-$ '2,$ >1.1'--?$ 5%2%/3)3'-$ '++'20%>%2.4$ 32$ .&%$ '+%'4$ */$

>*2%?$'2,$5'26320:$I14.$'4$41+%-?$'4$.&%$>'+6%.$*5(3*14-?$P;*+64Q$

;&%2$3.$)*>%4$.*$39*,4$'2,$+%4.'1+'2.47$82,%%,:$>*2%?$'2,$5'26320$

'+*4%$ 4<*2.'2%*14-?$ *2$ .&%$>'+6%.:$ '2,$;%+%$ *2-?$ -'.%+$ )*R*<.%,$

'2,$)*++1<.%,$5?$0*(%+2>%2.$32.%+(%2.3*27$

D&%$ .'46$ 5%/*+%$ 14$ 34$ <*4435-%7$ D&%$ S23.%,$ =.'.%4$ &'4$ &',$

)%2.+'-$5'264$5%/*+%$.&%$A%,%+'-$T%4%+(%:$'2,$.&%?$;%+%$'--*;%,$.*$

,3%7$F&'.%(%+$ ;*++3%4$ <%*<-%$ >'?$ &'(%$ '5*1.$ '$ P;3-,)'.Q$ 4?4.%>$

-')6320$ .&%$ 013,'2)%$ */$ .%)&23)3'24$ /+*>$B7C7:$ 41+%-?$ .&%$ +%41-.4$ */$

*<%2$)*><%.3.3*2$'2,$)*2.+').$%2/*+)%>%2.$ 32$>*2%?$'2,$5'26320$

)*1-,$*2-?$5%$2+**+1$ .&'2$ .&%$4.+320$*/$ )+34%4$ .&%$S23.%,$=.'.%4$&'4$

%2,1+%,$432)%$.&%$A%,U4$/*12,320$32$V#V!7$

W/$ )*1+4%:$ 5%/*+%$ <*-3.3)3'24$ '2,$ A%,%+'-$ T%4%+(%$ *//3)3'-4$

+%-32H134&$ .&%3+$ <*;%+$5')6$ .*$ .&%$<+3('.%$ 4%).*+$ /+*>$;&3)&$ .&%?$

4%3@%,$ 3.:$ <15-3)$*<323*2$;3--$ 2%%,$ .*$12,%+0*$'$,+'>'.3)$ 4&3/.7$F%$

&'(%$ 4%%2$ .&%$ 4.3++3204$ */$ 41)&$ '$ )&'20%$ '4$ '$ +%41-.$ */$ .&%$

41+<+34320-?$ <*<1-'+$ )'2,3,')?$ */$T*2$9'1-7$ A*+$ .&%$ /3+4.$ .3>%:$ .&%$

A%,%+'-$T%4%+(%$34$$3"*.+"*'2(+$'4$'$>'..%+$*/$,34)1443*2:$'4$*<<*4%,$

.*$ 5%320$ .'6%2$ /*+$ 0+'2.%,$ '4$ .&%$ %O34.%2)%$ */$ .&%$ ;%'.&%+$ *+$

&3))1<47$ X*+%$ .&'2$ %(%+$ 5%/*+%:$ '(%+'0%$ N>%+3)'24$ '+%$ .'6320$ '2$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!LV$

32.%+%4.$ 32$ %)*2*>3)$ '//'3+4:$ <'+.3)1-'+-?$ .&%$ A%,%+'-$ T%4%+(%U4$

>'443(%$ 5'3-*1.4$ '2,$ .&%$ /%,%+'-$ 0*(%+2>%2.U4$ 12<+%)%,%2.%,$

,%/3)3.47$

D&%$ 4.1,%2.$*/$&34.*+?$62*;4$ .&'.$12+1-?$>*54:$ %(%2$;&%2$

/1%-%,$ 5?$ -%03.3>'.%$ 0+3%('2)%4:$ )'2$ */.%2$ %2,$ 1<$ +%<-')320$ *2%$

.?+'22?$;3.&$'2$%(%2$;*+4%$>*24.+*43.?7$D&'.$34$;&?$3.$34$)+1)3'-$/*+$

.&%$<15-3)$.*$5%$+86%'*+8$*2$4*12,$>*2%.'+?$'2,$5'26320$.&%*+?:$'.$

-%'4.$.&%$5'43)47$D*$'4434.$32$.&34$3><*+.'2.$.'46:$.&%$<+%4%2.$'1.&*+4$

'+%$ <-')320$ '$ 9BA$ (%+43*2$ */$ .&34$ 5**6$ *2-32%$ '.$ .&%3+$ +%4<%).3(%$

;%543.%4:Y$.*$'--*;$+%',%+4$.&%$'53-3.?$.*$<'44$'-*20$3.4$'2'-?434$.*$'4$

>'2?$<%*<-%$;&*$'+%$;3--320$.*$-34.%27$K'.1+'--?:$.&%$<+%4%2.$5**6$34$

2*.$'$4154.3.1.%$/*+$+%',320$.&%$>*+%$4)&*-'+-?$;*+64$/+*>$;&3)&$3.$

,+';4:$ 51.$ ;%$ &*<%$ *1+$ <+%4%2.'.3*2$ ;3--$ <3H1%$ .&%$ 32.%+%4.$ */$

<*.%2.3'-$ 4.1,%2.4$ ;&*$ *.&%+;34%$ ;*1-,$ 2*.$ &'(%$ +%'-3@%,$ .&%$

43023/3)'2)%$*/$.&%4%$32.3>3,'.320$.*<3)47$

N>3,4.$ .&%4%$ ,%%<$ 3441%4$ 4.'2,4$ .&%$ )*2.+351.3*2$ */$K%-4*2$

K'4&$'2,$&34$82/323.%$Z'26320$C*2)%<.7$K'4&$&'4$4&*;2$.&'.$'$(%+?$

.+',3.3*2'-:$ )%2.1+3%4R*-,$ /32'2)3'-$ (%&3)-%G;&*-%$ -3/%$ 3241+'2)%G

)'2$ '--*;$ N>%+3)'24$ .*$ %//%).3(%-?$ 4%)%,%$ /+*>$ .&%$ )1++%2.$

/+').3*2'-$+%4%+(%$5'26320$4?4.%>7$S2-36%$*.&%+$<*.%2.3'-$4.+'.%03%4$

/*+$ P4.'+(320$ .&%$ 5%'4.:Q$ .&%$ <+').3)%$ */$ 8ZC$ >'6%4$ #+3#+$ '.$ '2$

32,3(3,1'-$&*14%&*-,$-%(%-:$&3"'88&*&$3$.*$3.4$4*)3'-$5%2%/3.4$*/$>1.320$

32/-'.3*2'+?$)+%,3.$%O<'243*27$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!LY$

D&%$<+').3)%$*/$ 8ZC$ 34$2*.$ '$<'2')%'7$[(%2$ 3/$ -'+0%$21>5%+4$

5%0'2$ /32'2)320$ .&%3+$ >'I*+$ <1+)&'4%4$ %O)-143(%-?$ .&+*10&$

,3(3,%2,4$*+$<*-3)?$ -*'24:$ .&%$A%,%+'-$T%4%+(%$;*1-,$4.3--$&'(%$ .&%$

'53-3.?$.*$)+%'.%$12-3>3.%,$H1'2.3.3%4$*/$>*2%?$5?$6%?4.+*6%:$'2,$.&%$

)*>>%+)3'-$ 5'264$ ;*1-,$ 4.3--$ /32,$ ;3--320$ 5*++*;%+4$ 3/$ .&%?$ )1.$

32.%+%4.$+'.%4$%2*10&7$

[(%2$4*:$'4$>*+%$'2,$>*+%$&*14%&*-,4$5%032$<+').3)320$8ZC:$

;%$ ;3--$ 4%%$ .&+%%$ >'I*+$ %//%).4\$ A3+4.:$ .&%$ 3,%'$ */$ <+3('.3@%,$

5'26320G*2%$ */$ .&%$ <-'264$ 32$ .&%$ =*12,$ X*2%?$ =*-1.3*2G;3--$

4%%>$-%44$/'+/%.)&%,7$=%)*2,:$'$0+*;320$21>5%+$*/$&*14%&*-,4$;3--$

5%)*>%$ /32'2)3'--?$ &38+7+38+3*7$ D&%3+$ 5*2,'0%$ 12,%+$ .&%$ )1++%2.$

,%5.R5'4%,$ 4?4.%>$;3--$ 5%$ 5+*6%2:$ '2,$ .&%?$ ;3--$ 2*.$ 5%$ 2%'+-?$ '4$

(1-2%+'5-%$ .*$ .&%$ )+%,3.$ ;&3<4';4$ 12-%'4&%,$ 5?$ .&%$ A%,%+'-$

T%4%+(%7$D&3+,:$'4$>*+%$<%*<-%$',,$43@'5-%$-3/%$3241+'2)%$<*-3)3%4$.*$

.&%3+$ -*20R.%+>$ /32'2)3'-$ <-'24:$ .&%$ <15-3)$ '03.'.3*2$ '<'&3#*"

32/-'.3*2'+?$ <*-3)3%4$ '2,$ ,%/3)3.$ 4<%2,320$ ;3--$ 5%$ 4.+*20%+7$ D&%$

<+').3.3*2%+4$*/$8ZC$;3--$/32,$3.$32$.&%3+$0+%'.$<%+4*2'-$32.%+%4.$.*$'3,$

.&%$ N14.+3'24$ '2,$ *.&%+$ )&'><3*24$ */$ 4*12,$ >*2%?:$ 5%)'14%$ .&%$

('-1%$*/$.&%3+$3241+'2)%$<*-3)3%4$;*1-,$5%$%2&'2)%,$;3.&$'$4.+*20%+$

,*--'+7$

$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!L!$

2"&(300/&(30(4'&&5+67(8+%(9+,&:(

$

82$.&34$5**6$;%$&'(%$>',%$.&%$)'4%$/*+$4*12,$>*2%?:$&*2%4.$

5'26320:$ '2,$ /+10'-$ &*14%&*-,47$ 8.$ 34$ .+1%$ .&'.$ .&%$ ;3,%4<+%',$

<+').3)%$ */$ .&%4%$ .+',3.3*2'-$ (3+.1%4$ ;*1-,$ /*4.%+$ 32)+%,35-%$

<+*4<%+3.?$ 32$ *1+$ )*12.+?:$ '2,$ '+*12,$ .&%$ ;*+-,$ /*+$ .&*4%$ ;&*$

/*--*;%,$*1+$%O'><-%7$

E%.$32$.&%$/32'-$'2'-?434:$.&%$3441%$342U.$>'.%+3'-$<+*4<%+3.?7$82$

.&%$/3+4.$<-')%:$.&%$.+1-?$;34%$&'(%$-%'+2%,$.&'.$&'<<32%44$,*%4$2*.$

/-*;$ /+*>$>'.%+3'-$ <*44%443*247$ Z1.$ %(%2$ 3/$;%$ 2'++*;-?$ /*)14$ *2$

)*>>%+)%:$5?$'->*4.$'2?$>%'41+%:$N>%+3)'24$ .*,'?$'+%$;%'-.&3%+$

.&'2$.&%?$;%+%$32$V#VM7$B%4<3.%$.&%$4&')6-%4$<1.$*2$3.:$.&%$5'43)'--?$

)'<3.'-34.$ 4?4.%>$ */$ .&%$ S23.%,$ =.'.%4$ 4&*;%+%,$ N>%+3)'24$;3.&$ '$

0+*;320$ (*-1>%$ */$ '221'-$ *1.<1.$ *(%+$ .&%$ )*1+4%$ */$ .&%$ YM.&$

)%2.1+?7$[(%2$3/$.&%$)1++%2.$4-1><$>'+64$.&%$*<%2320$4.'0%4$*/$.&%$

4%)*2,$ ]+%'.$ B%<+%443*2G'4$ >'2?$ N14.+3'24$ <+%,3).GN>%+3)'24$

;3--$ 4.3--$ &'(%$ '$ &30&%+$ 4.'2,'+,$ */$ -3(320$ .&'2$ .&%3+$ )*12.%+<'+.4$

/+*>$'$)%2.1+?$%'+-3%+7$

Z1.$ .&%+%$ 34$ *2%$ .&320$ *1+$ <+%,%)%44*+4$ %2I*?%,$ 32$ >1)&$

0+%'.%+$'512,'2)%$ .&'2$;%$)1++%2.-?$<*44%44:$ '2,$ .&'.$ 34$ 41++8$,7$

82$;&'.$ %)*2*>3)$&34.*+3'2$T*5%+.$^3004$,%4)+35%4$ '4$ .&%$ P+'.)&%.$

%//%).:Q$;3.&$%')&$)+3434G;&%.&%+$/32'2)3'-$*+$>3-3.'+?G.&%$/%,%+'-$

0*(%+2>%2.$0+%'.-?$%O<'2,4$ 3.4$<*;%+$*(%+$.&%$)3.3@%2+?7$N/.%+$.&%$

)+3434$%554:$.&%$0*(%+2>%2.$+%-32H134&%4$4*>%$*/$3.4$2%;$'1.&*+3.3%4:$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!L"$

51.$ 3.$ 2%(%+$ +%.1+24$ .*$ .&%$ <+%R)+3434$ 43@%7$ W(%+$ .&%$ ,%)',%4:$ .&%$

+%41-.$34$'2$%(%+R0+*;320$-%(3'.&'2$=.'.%7!$

Z%)'14%$*/$.&%$+'.)&%.$%//%).:$>'2?$N>%+3)'24$.*,'?$)*243,%+$

3.$<%+/%).-?$2*+>'-$.&'.$.&%$0*(%+2>%2.$)'2$,%)-'+%$0+%%2$<3%)%4$*/$

<'<%+$-%0'-$.%2,%+:$)'2$*+,%+$N>%+3)'2$)3.3@%24$'44'4432'.%,$>%+%-?$

*2$ .&%$ <+%43,%2.U4$ 4'?R4*:$ )'2$ >'2,'.%$ .&'.$ %(%+?*2%$ <1+)&'4%$

&%'-.&$ 3241+'2)%:$ '2,$ )'2$ +%01-'.%$ &*;$ >'2?$ 0'--*24$ */$ ;'.%+$ '$

.*3-%.$.'26$)'2$&*-,7$8/$S7=7$)3.3@%24$/+*>$V#VM$+%',$'$,%4)+3<.3*2$*/$

.&%3+$)*12.+?U4$0*(%+2>%2.$'$)%2.1+?$32$.&%$/1.1+%:$.&%?$;*1-,$&'(%$

.&*10&.$3.$'2$'541+,$_'2,$)&3--320`$4'.3+%7$

D&%+%$ 34$ '$ 4.+*20$ )*22%).3*2$ 5%.;%%2$ %)*2*>3)$ 324%)1+3.?$

'2,$ .&%$ %>%+0%2)%$ */$ Z30$ ]*(%+2>%2.J$ .&%$ .;*$ 0*$ &'2,R32R&'2,7$

D&%$ >*+%$ *2%+*14$ 0*(%+2>%2.$ .'O'.3*2:$ +%01-'.3*2:$ '2,$ 32/-'.3*2$

5%)*>%:$ .&%$>*+%$ .&%?$ )+3<<-%$ .&%$ <+3('.%$ 4%).*+7$ E%.$ .&%$ <+*)%44$

;*+64$ 32$ .&%$ *<<*43.%$ ,3+%).3*2$ '4$ ;%--\$ N4$ '$ (*-'.3-%$ %)*2*>?$

.&+*;4$ >3--3*24$ *1.$ */$ ;*+6:$ '2,$ .&%$ .&+%'.$ */$ 32/-'.3*2$ >'6%4$ 3.$

3><*4435-%$.*$4'(%:$'(%+'0%$)3.3@%24$>14.$.1+2$.*$.&%$0*(%+2>%2.$'4$

.&%3+$ *2-?$ +%/10%7$ D&%$ (%+?$ <*-3.3)3'24$ ;&*$ &'(%$ +%,1)%,$ .&%>$ .*$

41)&$&%-<-%442%44$ .&%2$ 0+')3*14-?$ *//%+$ .&%>$4%)1+3.?:$ 32$ %O)&'20%$

/*+$I14.$'$/%;$>*+%$-35%+.3%47$

F&%2$ .&%$ 2'.1+'-$ 5-%443204$ */$ %)*2*>3)$ /+%%,*>$ '+%$

4'5*.'0%,:$ <%*<-%$ 5%)*>%$ ,%4<%+'.%7$ X'2?$ &34.*+3'24$ '2,$

%)*2*>34.4$5%-3%(%$.&'.$N,*-/$^3.-%+$;*1-,$2*.$&'(%$')&3%(%,$<*;%+$

;%+%$ 3.$ 2*.$ /*+$ .&%$ .%++35-%$ &?<%+32/-'.3*2$ 32$ 32.%+;'+$ ]%+>'2?:$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!LL$

;&3)&$ ;3<%,$ *1.$ .&%$ >3,,-%$ )-'447$ N$ .%++3/3%,$ <*<1-')%$ ;3--$

')H13%4)%$ .*$ 32)+%,35-%$141+<'.3*24$*/$ .&%3+$ .+',3.3*2'-$ -35%+.3%4:$ 4*$

-*20$ '4$ .&%$ +1-%+4$ )-'3>$ .&%$ 2%;$ >%'41+%4$ '+%$ 2%)%44'+?$ .*$ ,%'-$

;3.&$.&%$3>>%,3'.%$)+34347$D&34$34$.&%$<'.&$.*$,%4<*.34>7$

$

;#<&(=+/'0&.>7(?,5(@%"&'0(

$

D&%$N14.+3'2$%)*2*>34.4$;%+%$+30&.$'5*1.$.&%$&*14320$5**>7$

8/$.&%?$'+%$+30&.$'5*1.$*1+$)1++%2.$)+3434:$.&%$S23.%,$=.'.%4$34$32$4.*+%$

/*+$ '2$ %(%2$ 5300%+$ <-120%$ 32$ .&%$ 2%'+$ /1.1+%7$ a14.$ '4$ N-'2$

]+%%24<'2U4$P4*/.$-'2,320Q$'/.%+$.&%$,*.R)*>$)+'4&$>%+%-?$<'(%,$.&%$

;'?$/*+$'$-'+0%+$5155-%$32$&*14320:$4*$.**$>'?$/1.1+%$'2'-?4.4$)*>%$

.*$+%'-3@%$.&'.$Z%2$Z%+2'26%U4$Mb$32.%+%4.$+'.%4$;%+%$43><-?$-'+0%+$

,*4%4$*/$.&%$4'>%$<*34*27$

E*1$ >14.$ 2*.$ 5%$ <'+'-?@%,$ 5?$ /%'+7$ D&%+%$ )*1-,$ 4.3--$ 5%$

>*2.&4:$ %(%2$ ?%'+4:$ 5%/*+%$ .&%$ 2%O.$ ;*+-,;3,%$ )+3434$ &3.47$ 82$ .&34$

5**6:$;%$&'(%$*1.-32%,$'$)*24%+('.3(%$4.+'.%0?$/*+$>323>3@320$?*1+$

&*14%&*-,U4$ %O<*41+%$ .*$ .&%$ (*-'.3-%$ /32'2)3'-$ 4%).*+:$ '2,$ 32$ '$

>'22%+$ .&'.$ 2%1.+'-3@%4$ .&%$ &'+>/1-$ %//%).4$ */$ /+').3*2'-$ +%4%+(%$

5'263207$K*.$*2-?$,*%4$.&%$4;3.)&$.*$3241+'2)%$/32'2)320$>'6%$4%24%$

'.$ .&%$ 32,3(3,1'-$ -%(%-:$ 51.$ 3.$ '-4*$ )*2.+351.%4$ .*;'+,$ .&%$ 1-.3>'.%$

4*-1.3*2G.*$ +%>*(%$ 0*(%+2>%2.$ 32.%+(%2.3*2$ /+*>$ >*2%?$ '2,$

5'26320$'-.*0%.&%+7$

!"#$%&'("#)??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"

"

!Lc$

8/$;%$&'(%$ )*2(32)%,$?*1$*/$ .&%$H1'2,'+?$*1+$2'.3*2$ /')%4:$

'2,$3/$;%$&'(%$4&*;2$?*1$.&'.$.&%$N14.+3'24$&'(%$<*32.%,$.&%$;'?$

*1.$ 32$ .&%$ =*12,$ X*2%?$ =*-1.3*2:$ ;%$ 1+0%$ ?*1$ .*$ 4<+%',$ .&%$

>%44'0%7$F%$'-4*$1+0%$?*1$.*$+%(3%;$?*1+$&*14%&*-,$/32'2)%4:$'2,$

+%,*15-%$?*1+$%//*+.4$.*$5*-4.%+$?*1+$4'(32047$ 82$.&%$)*>320$4.*+>:$

;%$;3--$2%%,$%,1)'.%,$'2,$/32'2)3'--?$32,%<%2,%2.$/'>3-3%4$3/$;%$'+%$

.*$+%.'32$*1+$-35%+.?7$

$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1 Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (Auburn, AL: The Ludwig von Mises Institute, 1998), p. 861. 2 Lara and Murphy’s respective websites are http://www.usatrustonline.com/ and http://consultingbyrpm.com/. 3 Robert Higgs, Crisis and Leviathan: Critical Episodes in the Growth of American Government (U.S.A.: Oxford University Press, 1989).

!!!

!""#$%&'#()!!!!!!!!!

!

!"#$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+),&&

-($+&.#&/$"*$+$&%&"!'$($&')*+,$-./$.$

01.23/4$ 56/738$ 1936/8$ -4:$ 8.7;48$ .8$ 846$

<23=69/38>$ :?$ [email protected]$ D2$ A.2>$ 96/16B8/$ 846$

/B4:@./83B$89.E383:[email protected].$-./$.$

19:8:(F7/893.2$ />2846/3/$ :?$ /7GH6B83=3/8$

6B:2:A3B/$.2E$1:@383B.@$@3G698>C$D2$&"#I$J.93.2.$

-9:86$!"#$"%"#"&# $"%'(# ')(&'&*&'+)"# %KL2$ 846$M32;$

.2E$ 846$ 9:>.@$ 32/838783:2N+,$ E6?62E32;$ 8>9.223B3E6$ 72E69$ B698.32$

B:2E383:2/C$ O3/$ A:/8$ 3A1:98.28$ G::M,$!"# ,+)"&-"# ,*&-&'+)"# %KL2$

[email protected]:2$:?$A:26>N+,$.116.96E$32$&'P"C$J.93.2.$:G/69=6E$84.8$

[email protected]:2$K8.Q6/$84:/6$-4:$4.E$A:26>$G6?:96$.2E,$./$.$B:2/6R762B6$

84696:?,$.96$?:9B6E$8:$G7>$8432;/$A:96$E6.9@>CN#

$

&

0*12$".&3$+%*445+$ %&'IP$ S$ &T!*+,$ 3/$

96;.9E6E$ G>$ A.2>$ 43/8:93.2/$ :?$ 6B:2:A3B$

84:7;48$./$846$?39/8$;96.8$6B:2:A3B$846:93/8C$O3/$

@6;.B>$ B:2/3/8/$ :?$ :26$ 96A.9M.G@6$ 896.83/6,$

.((-'# /*$# 0-# 1-&*$"# 2*# 3+,,"$4"# ")# 56)6$-0,$

-43B4$ U3@@3.A$ 08.2@6>$ 56=:2/$ E7GG6E$ 846$

KV9.E@6$ :?$ W:@383B.@$ XB:2:A>CN$ J799.>$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'P$

Y:84G.9E$ B:2/3E696E$ V.283@@:2Z.2E$ )+&# FE.A$ 0A384Z./$ 846$

K?:72E32;$?.8469$:?$A:E692$6B:2:A3B/CN$

$

V.283@@:2$.283B31.86E$A.2>$?6.8796/$:?$ 846$F7/893.2$0B4::@C$O6$-./$

846$ ?39/8$6B:2:A3B$ 846:93/8$ 8:$6Q1@:96$ 846$9:@6$:?$ 846$628961962679C$

O3/$ A684:E$ :?$ .2.@>/3/$ 19:B66E6E$ E6E7B83=6@>$ 8:$ 72B:=69$ 846$

K2.879.@[email protected]:2/$:?$B.7/6$.2E$6??6B8$32$846$6B:2:A>C$

$

O3/$A:/8$?.A:7/$96/7@8$3/$846$96.@3[.83:2$84.8$32H6B83:2/$:?$A:26>$E:$

2:8$ B.7/6$ .@@$ 193B6/$ 8:$ 93/6$ 19:1:983:2.86@>$ 32$ :26$ ?6@@$ /-::1,$ G78$

32/86.E$ 9311@6$ 849:7;4:78$ 846$ 6B:2:A>C$ \46/6$ KV.283@@:2$ 6??6B8/N$

96E3/893G786$ -6.@84$ 328:$ 846$ 4.2E/$ :?$ 84:/6$ -4:$ 96B63=6$ 846$ 26-$

A:26>$ 6.9@>$ 32$ 846$ ;.A6C$ V.283@@:2]/$ .2.@>/3/$ :?$ 846$ K96.@N$

E3/879G.2B6/$ B.7/6E$ G>$ A:268.9>$ [email protected]:2$ -./$ .$ 26B6//.9>$

B:A1:2628$32$846$F7/893.2$846:9>$:?$846$G7/326//$B>B@6C$

&

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'&$

'++#&056#"%&-$17(#)&8("95%&%&T)T$S$&TI&+$-./$

.9;7.G@>[email protected];$6B:2:A3/8$:?$&I84$

B62879>$^9.2B6C$O3/$;96.8$-:9M,$

KY6?@6B83:2/$:2$846$^:9A.83:2$.2E$

_3/893G783:2$:?$U6.@84N$%&T''+$-./$.$A696$

?3?8>(84966$1.;6/,$.2E$>68$38$-./$E62/6$-384$

19:?:72E$.2.@>/3/$?.9$.46.E$:?$38/$83A6C$$

$

\79;:8$ .283B31.86E$ 846$ O.>6M3.2$ 32/3;48$

84.8$M2:-@6E;6$3/$E3/169/6E$849:7;4:78$846$6B:2:A>,$.2E$84.8$:2@>$

3?$ 16:1@6$ .96$ ?966$ B.2$ 846>$ E61@:>$ 84639$ /16B3.@3[6E$ M2:-@6E;6$ 32$

A787.@@>$ .E=.28.;6:7/$ 89.2/.B83:2/C$ $ \79;:8$ -./$ /M6183B.@$ :?$

1.8692.@3/83B$ ;:=692A628$ 96;[email protected]:2/$ 8:$ 19:86B8$ 846$ B:2/7A69,$

G6B.7/6$ 46$ M26-$ 84.8$ .2$ :162$ A.9M68$ 4.E$ 2.879.@$ B46BM/$ :2$

9.1.B3:7/$ G7/326//A62C$ \79;:8$ -628$ ?798469$ 8:$ /.>$ 84.8$ /7B4$

96;[email protected]:2/$ B:7@E$ G6$ B:7286919:E7B83=6`$ 89+# (*::+("# -00# 4+)(*,"$(#

&+#;"#2*:"(<# -)2#-00#,"$4=-)&(# -)2#,-)*>-4&*$"$(# &+# ;"# 4="-&(<# =-(#

&="# ">>"4&# +># -*&=+$'?')%# &=",# &+# ;"# (+<# -)2# +># 2"%$-2')%# -00# &="#

@+$A')%#,",;"$(#+>#&="#4+,,*)'&BCD$

&

L26$:?$\79;:8]/$A:/8$/3;23?3B.28$.B436=6A628/$-./$43/$E3/B7//3:2$:?$

/.=32;/$.2E$B.138.@[email protected]:2,$-43B4$-./$96A.9M.G@>$/[email protected]$8:$

846$ 1:@3/46E$ 846:9>$ :?$ X7;62$ =:2$ ab4A(a.-69M$ 84.8$ -:7@E$ B:A6$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!')$

:2@>$ .$ B62879>$ @.869C$ \79;:8$ 72E69/8::E$ 84.8$ B.138.@3/8(

628961962679/$ 266E6E$ 8:$ 96/893B8$ B:2/7A183:2$ 8:$ [email protected]$

/.=32;/$ 32$ 846$ ?:9A$ :?$ A:26>,$ -43B4$ B:7@E$ 8462$ G6$ 32=6/86E$ 328:$

/16B3?3B$ B.138.@$ ;::E/C$ \46$ B.138.@3/8/$ K.E=.2B6EN$ ?::E$ .2E$ :8469$

26B6//3836/$ 8:$ 846$-:9M69/,$-4:$266E6E$ 8:$G6$ ?6E$ 3AA6E3.86@>$.2E$

B:7@E$2:8$-.38$ ?:9$ 84639$ 19:E7B8/$ 8:$ 93162$ 328:$ ?32.@$ :78178C$ D8$-./$

847/$ 8493?8$ .2E$ ?.9/3;486E$ 32=6/8A628$ :?$ 846$ ?6-$ B.138.@3/8/$ 84.8$

.@@:-6E$/:B368>$8:$;9:-$32$A.8693.@$.G72E.2B6C$

$

$

-#$+:;$<%*)%#& =$>$ %&T'T$ ($ &I!)+$

-./$.$^962B4$6B:2:A3/8$.2E$G7/326//A.2C$O6$

-./$ 846$ 6138:A6$ :?$ .$ B@.//3B.@$ @3G69.@$ -4:$

?.=:96E$:162$B:A168383:2$.2E$?966$89.E6C$

$

c:-.E.>/$ 6B:2:A3/8/$ /16.M$ :?$ K0.>]/$ d.-,N$

-43B4$846>$B97E6@>$962E69$./$K/711@>$B96.86/$

38/$ :-2$ E6A.2ECN$ e6>26/3.2$ 6B:2:A3/8/$ 93E3B7@6$ 843/$ /711:/6E@>$

2.f=6$?.384$32$846$.G3@38>$:?$A.9M68/$8:$G:72B6$R73BM@>$:78$:?$/@7A1/C$

$

O:-6=69,$ 32$ 96.@38>$ 0.>]/$ Kd.-$ :?$ J.9M68/N$ -./$ .$ /:143/83B.86E$

72E69/8.2E32;$ :?$ 846$ 72E69@>32;$ K96.@N$ ?:9B6/$ 72E69@>32;$ A.9M68$

6QB4.2;6/C$D2$0.>]/[email protected];7.;6,$K19:E7B8/$.96$1.3E$?:9$-384$19:E7B8/CN$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'!$

^:9$6Q.A1@6,$3?$846$G.M69$-.28/$8:$:G8.32$?::E$?9:A$846$G78B469,$46$

A7/8$:??69$62:7;4$A:26>$8:$179B4./6$846$A6.8C$a78$-4696$E:6/$846$

G.M69$;68$ 846$A:26>g$a>$/6@@32;$43/$+@)$19:E7B8/$ 8:$:8469/C$ D2$ 846$

;9.2E$ /B46A6,$ 0.>$ .9;76E,$ 846$ G.M69$ [email protected]@>$ KE6A.2E6EN$ 846$

G78B469]/$A6.8$G>$/711@>32;$43/$:-2$G96.E$8:$846$B:AA7238>C$\4696$

3/$:G=3:7/@>$.$;96.8$E6.@$:?$ 89784$ 8:$0.>]/$ .2.@>/3/,$-43B4$ 3/$4.9E@>$

E:26$H7/83B6$G>$846$/4:98$149./6,$K/711@>$B96.86/$38/$:-2$E6A.2ECN$

$

W7/432;$43/$32/3;48$?798469,$0.>$:G/69=6E$84.8$K.$;@[email protected]$

:2@>$-462$84696$.96$8::$A.2>$A6.2/$:?$19:E7B83:2$.11@36E$8:$:26$

M32E$ :?$ 19:E7B8$ .2E$ 2:8$ 62:7;4$ 8:$ .2:8469CN& D2$ B:289./8$ 8:$ 84:/6$

-4:$ [email protected]$ G7/326//$ /@7A1/$ ./$ E76$ 8:$ .$ E6.926//$ :?$ A:26>Z:9$

32.E6R7.86$ B:2/7A69$ E6A.2E,$ 32$ :79$ A:E692$ 869A32:@:;>Z0.>$

72E69/8::E$ 84.8$ 846$ 6B:2:A>$ B:7@E2]8$ G6$ 1@.;76E$ G>$ .$ @.BM$ :?$

A:26>$169$/6C$D8$.@/:$B:7@E2]8$G6$1@.;76E$G>$K:=6919:E7B83:2,N$/32B6$

846$ =69>$ A.9M$ :?$ 6B:2:A3B$ 19:;96//$ -./$ 846$ /86.E>$ ;9:-84$ 32$

:78178$ .A:2;$ =.93:7/$ /6B8:9/C$ F/$ 43/$ R7:8.83:2$ 32E3B.86/,$ 0.>$

96.@3[6E$ 84.8$ 846$ 19:G@6A$ :?$ .$ G7/326//$ /@7A1$ 3/$ E76$ 8:$ .$ ("4&+$-0#

',;-0-)4"C$\43/$.283B31.86/$ 846$A:E692$F7/893.2$E6/B93183:2$:?$ 846$

72/7/8.32.G@6$G::A$.2E$8462$26B6//.9>$G7/8C$

&

&

&

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'*$

34$(.#&?"@.@"*1&;$)%*$%$$%&IP&$ S$ &I"P+$ -./$ .9;7.G@>$ 846$ ;96.86/8$

1:@6A3B3/8$ :?$ ?966$ A.9M68$ 6B:2:A3B/$ -4:$

4./$6=69$@3=6EC$O3/$6//.>/$32$/711:98$:?$?966$

89.E6$ 32$ [email protected]$ 96A.32$ A:E6@/$ 8:$ 843/$

E.>C$ a./83.8$ =36-6E$ 846$ ?966$ A.9M68$ ./$ .$

2.879.@@>$4.9A:23:7/$ 32/838783:2$ 32$-43B4$

6=69>:26]/$19:169@>$72E69/8::E$328696/8/$-696$.@3;26EC$

$

a./83.8]/$A:/8$?.A:7/$6//.>,$K\46$W68383:2$:[email protected]/,N$3/$.$

/.8393B.@$:162$@68869$-938862$G>$^962B4$A.27?.B87969/[email protected];$-384$

84639$ ;:=692A628$ 8:$ G.9$ 846$ 72?.39$ B:A168383:2$ :?$ @3;48$ :??696E$ G>$

846$ /72C$ D?$ :2@>$ 846$ ^962B4$ ;:=692A628$ -:7@E$ 96R7396$ 84.8$

G7/326//6/$ .2E$ 4:A6/$ B@:/6$ 84639$ /478869/$ E7932;$ E.>@3;48$ 4:79/,$

843/$ -:7@E$ G::/8$ 846$ E6A.2E$ ?:9$ E:A6/83B$ B.2E@6/,$ /179932;$

6A1@:>A628$ .2E$ /4:-6932;$ 846$ B:AA7238>$ -384$ 728:@E$ G@6//32;/C$

a./83.8]/$1:328,$:?$B:79/6,$-./$8:$6Q1@:E6$846$B:AA:2$19:86B83:23/8$

.9;7A628/$8:$3A1:/6$8.93??/$.2E$:8469$89.E6$96/893B83:2/$32$:9E69$8:$

/436@E$ E:A6/83B$ A.27?.B87969/$ ?9:A$ 846$ K72?.39N$ B:A168383:2$ :?$

?:963;2$19:E7B69/C$

$

a./83.8]/$6//.>$K\46$d.-N$-./$.$B@.//3B$6Q1:/383:2$:?$846$19:169$9:@6$

:?$;:=692A628$32$19:86B832;$2.879.@$93;48/C$D?$846$;:=692A628$B6./6E$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'"$

169?:9A32;$ 843/$ @6;383A.86$ ?72B83:2$ .2E$ G6;.2$ 8.M32;$ ?9:A$ :26$

;9:71$ .2E$ ;3=32;$ 4.2E:78/$ 8:$ .2:8469,$ 8462$ 846$ ;:=692A628$ -./$

62;.;6E$ 32$ K@6;.@3[6E$ 1@72E69CN$ FBB:9E32;$ 8:$ a./83.8,$ K\46$ /8.86$ 3/$

846$ ;96.8$ ?3B8383:7/$ 62838>$ G>$ -43B4$ 6=69>:26$ /66M/$ 8:$ @3=6$ .8$ 846$

6Q162/6$:?$6=69>:26$6@/6CN$

$

$

3$"4& /#+9#"& %&I*P$ S$ &#)&+$ -./$ 846$

?:72E69$ :?$ 846$ F7/893.2$ 0B4::@$ 19:169h$ 846$

6.9@369$ 8432M69/$ -696$ A696$ ?:96972269/C$

F@84:7;4$ 2:$ /B4:@.9$ -9386/$ 32$ .$ B:A1@686$

=.B77A,$5:/[email protected],$KJ62;69$

-./$ 2:G:E>]/$ 1713@CN$ a>$ 843/$ 0B47A16869$

A6.28$ 84.8$ -4.8$ -6$ 2:-$ M2:-$ ./$ F7/893.2$

6B:2:A3B/$B.2$G6$89.B6E$.@A:/8$6QB@7/3=6@>$8:$J62;69]/$E$')4':0"(#+>#

.4+)+,'4($%&IT&+C$

$

i3987.@@>$ 6=69>$ 89.38$ :?$ KF7/893.2$ 6B:2:A3B/N$ -./$ 196/628$ 32$

J62;69]/$ 13:266932;$ G::MC$ D8/$ /32;@6$ A:/8$ 3A1:98.28$ .B436=6A628$

-./$ 8:$ :=698792$ 846$ B@.//3B.@$ 6B:2:A3/8/]$ B:/8$ :9$ @.G:9$ 846:9>$ :?$

=.@[email protected]$A.9M68$193B6/$G>$846$B:/8$:?$846$96/:79B6/$

;:32;$ 328:$ 846A,$ J62;69$ 96=69/6E$ 846$ B.7/.@$ ?@:-C$ O6$ .9;76E$ 84.8$

A.9M68$ 193B6/$ -696$ E6869A326E$ G>$ 846$ /7GH6B83=6$ 196?6962B6/$ :?$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!''$

B:2/7A69/,$ .2E$ 84.8$ 846/6$ 193B6/$ 32$ 8792$ ;.=6$ 628961962679/$ 846$

.G3@38>$8:$G3E$71$846$193B6/$:?$32178/C$^:9$6Q.A1@6,$62;.;6A628$932;/$

.962]8$ 6Q162/3=6$ G6B.7/6$ 72B78$ E3.A:2E/$ .96$ 6Q162/3=6C$ Y.8469,$

62;.;6A628$ 932;/$ .96$ 6Q162/3=6$ G6B.7/6$ -:A62$ ?32E$ 846A$

[email protected]$ 8462$ G6B.7/6$ :?$ 843/$ ?.B8,$ H6-6@69/$ .96$ -3@@32;$ 8:$

/162E$.$;96.8$E6.@$:?$A:26>$.BR73932;$72B78$E3.A:2E/C$

$

A2*4*<& B*1C)%##.& %&I**$ S$ &#)T+$-./$ .$ B:286A1:9.9>$ :?$ J62;69C$ O6$ -./$

a9383/4$ G>$ :93;32$ .2E$ B:7@E$ 2:8$ 6=62$ G6$

B@.//3?36E$ ./$ KF7/893.2N$ 32$ 869A/$ :?$ 43/$

6B:2:A3B/C$ X=62$ /:,$ 32$ A.2>$ 96/16B8/$ 43/$

-:9M$ G:96$ .$ ;96.869$ /[email protected]>$ 8:$ 846$

E6=6@:132;$ F7/893.2$ 89.E383:2$ 84.2$ 8:$ 846$

a9383/4$ c6:(V@.//3B.@$ 0B4::@$ /1.-26E$ G>$ F@?96E$ J.9/4.@@C$ U4696./$

J.9/4.@@$/:7;48$8:$96?326$846$-:9M$:?$846$B@.//3B.@$6B:2:A3/8/$%/7B4$

./$FE.A$0A384+,$U3BM/866E$-.286E$8:$96=:@783:23[6$6B:2:A3B/$-384$

846$ 26-$ .119:.B4$ :?$ /7GH6B83=3/AC$ U3BM/866E$ -./$ :26$ :?$ 846$

13:2669/$:?$846$A:E692$B:2B618$:?$K:11:987238>$B:/8,N$-43B4$=36-/$

B:/8/$)+&$ ./$ 86B423B.@$ ?.B8/$ G78$ 9.8469$ ./$ /7GH6B83=6$ [email protected]:2/$ :?$

?:9?6386E$:11:98723836/C$

$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'T$

F283B31.832;$ 846$ -:9M$ :?$ J3/6/$ .2E$ O.>6M,$ U3BM/866E$ =36-6E$ 846$

A.9M68$6B:2:A>$./$.$:$+4"(($32$-43B4$A3/8.M6/$.96$A.E6,$G78$/::2$

B:996B86EC$

$

D(9#+& E5+& ;F2G:;$H#"C&%&I"&$S$&#&*+$-./$.$A6AG69$:?$846$/6B:2E(

;6269.83:2$ :?$ 846$ F7/893.2$ 0B4::@$ 19:169,$

-4:/6$ -:9M$ -./$ 46.=3@>$ 32?@762B6E$ G>$

J62;69]/$ E$')4':0"(C$ D2$ .EE383:2$ 8:$ 43/$

E6=./8.832;$ B9383R76/$ :?$ J.9Q3/8$ 6B:2:A3B/,$

ab4A(a.-69M]/$ A:/8$ E3/832;73/432;$

B:2893G783:2$-./$43/$846:9>$:?$B.138.@$.2E$328696/8C$

$

ab4A(a.-69M$ [email protected]$ 84.8$ -462$ 16:1@6$ 32$ .$ B:AA7238>$ @3=6E$

G6@:-$ 84639$ A6.2/ZA6.232;$ 846>$ B:2/7A6E$ @6//$ 84.2$ 84639$

32B:A6Z843/$ .@@:-6E$ 846A$ 8:$ B4.226@$ 9.-$ A.8693.@/$ .2E$ @.G:9$

4:79/$ 328:$ 846$ 19:E7B83:2$ :?$ B.138.@$ ;::E/C$ \46$ 6Q89.$ A.B4326/,$

8::@/,$.2E$/6A3(?323/46E$;::E/$-:7@E$8462$.7;A628$846$19:E7B83=38>$

:[email protected]:9$32$846$?78796C$\47/,$G>$32=6/832;$2.879.@$96/:79B6/[email protected]:9$

328:$A:96$K9:72E.G:78N$19:B6//6/,$/:B368>$-:7@E$6=6287.@@>$62H:>$.$

169A.2628@>$ 43;469$ /8.2E.9E$ :?$ @3=32;,$ ./$ 846$ 19:E7B8/$ :?$ 846$ 26-$

6R731A628$6A69;6E$:78$:?$846$K1316@326CN$

$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'I$

ab4A([email protected]$328696/8$G>$846$43;469$/[email protected]:2$

:?$ 196/628$ ;::E/$ =69/7/$ ?78796$ ;::E/C$ D2$ 6//62B6,$ ab4A(a.-69M$

8::M$J62;69]/$E3/B:=69>$:?$/7GH6B83=6$=.@76$846:9>$.2E$.11@36E$38$8:$

;::E/[email protected]@6$ 32$E3??69628$83A6$1693:E/C$a6B.7/6$16:1@6$;6269.@@>$

-:7@E$G6$-3@@32;$ 8:$1.>$A:96$ ?:9,$ /.>,$ .$4:7/[email protected]@6$ $'%=&#)+@$

9.8469$84.2$.$A696$40-',$:2$.$4:7/6$84.8$-:7@E$:2@>$G6$E6@3=696E$32$

&)$ A:284/,$ ab4A(a.-69M$ /4:-6E$ 84.8$ .$ B.138.@3/8$ B:7@E$ G7>$ 846$

A.8693.@/$ 26B6//.9>$ 8:$ B:2/897B8$ .$ 4:7/6$ .2E$ 6.92$ .$ 968792$:2$43/$

32=6/8A628$-462$46$/:@E$846$?323/46E$4:7/6$32$:26$>6.9]/$83A6C$\47/$

ab4A(a.-69M$/4:-6E$ 846$E661$B:226B83:2$G68-662$ 328696/8$ 9.86/$

.2E$846$B:AA7238>]/$-3@@32;26//$8:$E6?69$B:2/7A183:2C&

$

&

&?"$+C& '46#"%& ?#%%#"# %&I'!$ S$

&#*#+$ -./$ .$ A6AG69$ :?$ 846$ FA693B.2$

KW/>B4:@:;3B.@$ 0B4::@N$ :?$ 6B:2:A3B/,$

A6.232;$ 84.8$ 46Z@3M6$ 846$ F7/893.2/Z

=36-6E$ 6B:2:A3B/$ ./$ .$ /87E>$ 32$

/7GH6B83=3/A,$ G6B.7/6$ .@@$ 6B:2:A3B$

1462:A62.$ A7/8$ [email protected]@>$ -:9M$ &=$+*%=$

32E3=3E7.@/]$ A628.@$ :169.83:2/C$ W4>/3B.@$ ?.B8/$ ./$ /7B4$ B:7@E$ :2@>$

.??6B8$ /711@>,$ ?:9$ 6Q.A1@6,$ 8:$ 846$ 6Q8628$ 84.8$19:E7B69/$;"0'"F"2# ')$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!'#$

846/6$ 14>/3B.@$ ?.B8/$ .2E$ .EH7/86E$ 84639$ E6B3/3:2/$ 8:$ G7>$ .2E$ /6@@$

.BB:9E32;@>C$

$

[email protected]$328696/8$8:$F7/893.2/$3/$^68869]/$4-:'&-0'?-&'+)#&="+$B$:?$

328696/8$.2E$9628,$-43B4$-./$46.=3@>$G./6E$:2$ab4A(a.-69M]/$:-2$

-:9MC$^[email protected]$846$193B32;$:?$.$B.138.@$;::E$32$846$?:@@:-32;$

-.>`$D8/$9628.@$193B6$32$.2>$;3=62$1693:E$-:7@E$G6$E6869A326E$G>$846$

19:E7B83=38>$ :?$ 38/$ /69=3B6/C$ ^:9$ 6Q.A1@6,$ 3?$ .$ ?.9A69$ B:7@E$4.9=6/8$

j&,PPP$A:96$32$B9:1/$169$-66M$-384$.$89.B8:9$84.2$-384:78$38,$8462$

846$?.9A69$-:7@E$G6$-3@@32;$8:$1.>$71$8:$j&,PPP$.$-66M$8:$9628$846$

89.B8:9C$

$

O:-6=69,$ 8:$ B.@[email protected]$ 846$ :*$4=-("# :$'4"$ :?$ 846$ 89.B8:9,$ ^68869$

32=:M6E$ 846$ 2:83:2$ :?$ 83A6$ 196?6962B6,$ -43B4$ -./$ 846$ /7GH6B83=6$

196A37A$ 16:1@6$ [email protected]$ :2$ B:2/7A32;$ /::269$ 9.8469$ 84.2$ @.869C$

a6B.7/6$ :?$ 83A6$ 196?6962B6,$ ?78796$ E:@@.9/$ -696$ @6//$ 3A1:98.28Z

?9:A$:79$=.28.;6$1:328$&+2-BZ84.2$196/628$E:@@.9/C$U462$E6B3E32;$

4:-$ A7B4$ 8:$ /162E$ 8:E.>$ :2$ .$ 89.B8:9,$ 8462,$ B.138.@3/8/$ -:7@E$

2'(4+*)&$ 846$ ?78796$ B./4$ ?@:-/$ 846$ 89.B8:9$ -:7@E$ >36@E$ ?9:A$ 9628.@$

1.>A628/C$

$

a6B.7/6$ 846$ B.138.@3/8$ B:7@E$179B4./6$ 846$ 89.B8:9$ ?:9$ .$ @:-69$193B6$

84.2$846$/7A$:?$9628.@$1.>A628/$38$-:7@E$>36@E$:=69$38/$@3?683A6,$846$

B.138.@3/8$ -:7@E$ 6.92$ .$ 1:/383=6$ >36@E$ :2$ 43/$ 32=6/8A628C$ \47/$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!TP$

328696/8$32B:A6,$32$^68869]/$=36-,$4.E$.G/:@786@>$2:8432;$8:$E:$-384$

846$ 19:E7B83=38>$ :?$ B.138.@$ ;::E/Z843/$ H7/8$ [email protected]$ 84639$ 9628.@$

193B6/C$D28696/8,$/.3E$^68869,$-./$E76$8:$83A6$196?6962B6,$846$?.B8$84.8$

16:1@6$-3@@$1.>$.$ /A.@@69$.A:728$:?$A:26>$ 8:E.>,$ ?:9$.2$6Q16B86E$

/896.A$:?$?78796$A:268.9>$6.9232;/C$

&

&

I(.H*9& E5+& /*)#)# %&II&$ S$

&#T!+$ -./$ 846$ ;96.86/8$ A6AG69$ :?$ 846$

26Q8$ ;6269.83:2$ :?$ F7/893.2$ 6B:2:A3/8/,$

-4:$G73@8$:2$846$-:9M$:?$ab4A(a.-69MC$

J:96$84.2$.2>$:8469$6B:2:A3/8,$J3/6/$3/$

96/1:2/3G@6$ ?:9$ 846$ 96/79;62B6$ :?$

F7/893.2$ 6B:2:A3B/$ 32$ 846$ @.8869$ 4.@?$ :?$

846$)P84$ B62879>,$-43B4$-./$ @.9;6@>$E76$ 8:$43/$&#*#$A.;27A$:17/$

G*,-)#H4&'+)C$

$

J3/6/$-./$ .$ B96.83=6$ ;6237/$-4:$A.E6$ 3A1:98.28$ B:2893G783:2/$ 32$

A.2>$.96./$:?$6B:2:A3B/C$O6$3/$.9;7.G@>$:26$:?$846$A:/8$3A1:98.28$

6B:2:A3/8/$32$43/8:9>C$^:9$6Q.A1@6,$32$&#)P$J3/6/$?396E$846$:16232;$

/.@=:$ 32$ 846$ K/:B3.@3/8$ B.@[email protected]:2$ E6G.86N$ G>$ .9;732;$ 84.8$ /:B3.@3/8$

[email protected]/,$ @.BM32;$ A.9M68$ 193B6/$ ?:9$ B.138.@$ ;::E/,$ B:7@E$ 2:8$

6??3B3628@>$ .@@:B.86$ /:B368>]/$ 96/:79B6/C$ F@84:7;4$ A.32/896.A$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!T&$

6B:2:A3/8/$B:2B@7E6E$84.8$846$A.846A.83B.@$A:E6@/$:?$846$/:B3.@3/8$

846:93/8/$4.E$-:2$ 846$E.>,$A.2>$ B4.2;6E$ 84639$ 8726$E6B.E6/$ @.869$

-462$846$0:=368$<23:2$B:@@.1/6EC$ D2$9689:/16B8,$ 846>$B:2B6E6E$84.8$

1694.1/$J3/6/$%.2E$43/$?:@@:-69$O.>6M+$4.E$G662$:2$8:$/:A68432;$32$

84639$B9383R76$:?$/:B3.@3/8$6??3B362B>C$

$

D2$ 43/$ &#&)$ 9="# 9="+$B# +># I+)"B# -)2# 3$"2'&,$ J3/6/$ 3286;9.86E$

KA3B9:N$ .2E$ KA.B9:N$ 6B:2:A3B/$ 328:$ .$ 723?36E$ G:E>,$ G>$ 7/32;$

/7GH6B83=3/8$193B6$846:9>$8:[email protected]$846$179B4./32;$1:-69$:?$A:26>C$

%\43/$4.E$6@7E6E$:8469$6B:2:A3/8/$7283@$J3/6/$/4:-6E$846$/:@783:2C+$

J:96$ 3A1:98.28,$ 32$ 843/$ G::M$ J3/6/$ E6=6@:16E$ 43/$ G7/326//$ B>B@6$

846:9>C$ _9.-32;$ :2$ 32/3;48/$ ?9:A$ =.93:7/$ 196E6B6//:9/,$ J3/6/$

[email protected]$ 846$ G::A(G7/8$ B>B@6$ :2$ 846$ .983?3B3.@$ 6Q1.2/3:2$ :?$ G.2M$

B96E38$-43B4$17/46E$328696/8$9.86/$G6@:-$84639$19:169$@6=6@C$$

$

a6>:2E$ 43/$ 86B423B.@$ -:9M,$ J3/6/$ -./$ .@/:$ .$ ;96.8$ B:2893G78:9$ 8:$

6B:2:A3B$ A684:E:@:;>C$ O6$ B:2B63=6E$ :?$ 6B:2:A3B/$ 38/6@?$ ./$ .$

G9.2B4$ :?$ :$-J"+0+%B,$ -43B4$ -./$ 846$ /B362B6$ :?$ 47A.2$ .B83:2C$ D2$

J3/6/]$ 72E69/8.2E32;,$ 6B:2:A3/8/$ E3E$ 2:8$ E6=6@:1$ .2E$ K86/8N$

6B:2:A3B$ @.-/$ 32$ 846$ /.A6$ -.>$ 84.8$ 14>/3B3/8/$ :9$ B46A3/8/$ 86/86E$

84639$ 4>1:846/6/C$ L2$ 846$ B:289.9>,$ J3/6/$ .9;76E$ 84.8$ 6B:2:A3B$

1932B31@6/$B:7@E$G6$E6E7B6E$ @:;3B.@@>$ ?9:A$846$ 32/3;48$ %:9$ K.Q3:AN+$

84.8$16:1@6$4.=6$B:2/B3:7/$;:.@/$.2E$.B8$8:$.B436=6$846AC$

&

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!T)$

&

J#+">& J$K4*%%# %&I#*$ S$ &##!+$ -./$

846$ ;96.86/8$ 1:[email protected][69$ :?$ ?966$ A.9M68$

6B:2:A3B/$ 32$ 846$ )P84$ B62879>C$ #O3/$ B@.//3B$

-:9M,$.4+)+,'4(#')#K)"#L"((+),$E9.-/$:2$846$

32/3;48$ :?$ a./83.8$ .2E$ [email protected]/`$ 89="# -$&# +>#

"4+)+,'4(# 4+)('(&(# +># 0++A')%# )+&# ,"$"0B# -&#

&="#',,"2'-&"#;*&#-&#&="#0+)%"$#">>"4&(#+>#-)B#

-4&#+$#:+0'4BM#'&#4+)('(&(#')#&$-4')%#&="#4+)("N*")4"(#+>#&=-&#:+0'4B#)+&#

,"$"0B# >+$# +)"# %$+*:# ;*&# >+$# -00# %$+*:(CD# O6.=3@>$ 32?@762B6E$ G>$

d7E-3;$ =:2$ J3/6/,$ O.[@388]/$ G::M$ 96A.32/$ 846$ /32;@6$ G6/8$

3289:E7B83:2$8:$G./3B$6B:2:A3B/C$

#

J:E692$ 96.E69/$ A.>$ G6$ /79193/6E$ 8:$ @6.92$ 84.8$ E6/1386$ 43/$ /89:2;$

B:AA38A628$ 8:$ ?966$ A.9M68/,$ O.[@388$ -9:86$ 6E38:93.@/$ ?:9$ 846$1"@#

O+$A# 9',"(# .2E$ 1"@(@""A$ E7932;$ 43/$ 3@@7/893:7/$ B.9669$ ./$ .$

H:792.@3/8C$

#

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!T!$

?"*#."*12&'(9()%&E5+&J$>#C$ %&I##$ S$ &##)+$ 3/$ 846$

A:/8$ -3E6@>$ M2:-2$ :?$ 846$ A:E692$

F7/893.2/,$ 4.=32;$ -:2$ 846$ c:G6@$ W93[6$ 32$

&#T*$ ?:9$ 43/$ [email protected]:9.83:2$ :?$ J3/6/]$ 846:9>$

:?$ 846$ G7/326//$ B>B@6C$ O.>6M$ .@/:$ 8::M$ 71$

846$J3/6/3.2$G.2269$E7932;[email protected]$

/:B3.@3/8$B.@[email protected]:2$E6G.86C$

$

W.983.@@>$ ./$ .$ 96/7@8$ :?$ 43/$ /1.9932;$ -384$

/:B3.@3/8$6B:2:A3/8/,$32$846$&#!P/$.2E$&#*P/$O.>6M$-9:86$.$/6936/$:?$

/6A32.@$ 1.169/$ :2$ 846$ B:226B83:2$ G68-662$ 6B:2:A3B/$ .2E$

M2:-@6E;6C$ D2$ B:289./8$ 8:$ A:/8$ :?$ 43/$ B:@@6.;76/$ -4:$ A:E6@6E$

6B:2:A36/$ ./$ 3?$ .@@$ 32?:9A.83:2$ -696$ 17G@3B@>$ [email protected]@6,$ O.>6M$

72E69/8::E$ 84.8$ M2:-@6E;6$ 3/$ KE3/169/6EN$ .2E$ 84.8$ :26$ :?$ 846$

193A.9>$ ?72B83:2/$ :?$ 846$ 193B6$ />/86A$ 3/$ 8:$ B:AA723B.86$

32?:9A.83:2$G68-662$32E3=3E7.@/$-4:$B.2$6.B4$E396B8@>$:G/69=6$:2@>$

.$832>$?9.B83:2$:?$846$6B:2:A>C$

$

F$ A.H:9$ 846A6$ 32$ O.>6M]/$ -:9M$ 3/$ 84.8$ :?$ (:+)&-)"+*(# +$2"$,$

/16B3?3B.@@>$:?$/:B3.@$32/838783:2/$84.8$.96$K846$96/7@8$:?$47A.2$.B83:2,$

G78$2:8$:?$47A.2$E6/3;2CN$O.>6M$-.926E$/:B3.@3/8$96?:9A69/$.;.32/8$

846$ K?.8.@$ B:2B638Nh$ H7/8$ G6B.7/6$ [email protected]$ 32/838783:2/,$ /7B4$ ./$

193=.86$19:1698>$ 93;48/,$-696$2:8$ B:2/B3:7/@>$E6/3;26E$G>$.2>$:26$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!T*$

169/:2$:9$;9:71$:?$6Q1698/,$E3E$)+&$A6.2$ 84.8$ 846$96?:9A69/$B:7@E$

6./3@>$B:[email protected]$

$

O.>6M]/$A:/8$ 1:[email protected]$-:9M$-./$43/$ &#**$9="#P+-2# &+# /"$>2+,,$ 32$

-43B4$46$-.926E$84.8$E6A:B9.83B.@@>$6@6B86E$/:B3.@3/8$;:=692A628/$

-:7@E$ 6=6287.@@>$ /7BB7AG$ 8:$ 846$ 32269$ @:;3B$ :?$ 8:[email protected]/AC$O6$

1:3286E$:78$ 84.8$A.2>$:?$ 846$ 3E6.@3/8/$ 32$ 846$U6/8692$E6A:B9.B36/$

6AG9.B6E$ 846$ /.A6$1932B31@6/$:?$ B6289.@$ [email protected];$ .2E$ B:@@6B83=3/A$

.E:186E$G>$84639$c.[3$?:6/C$

&

L)"$#4&/M&N*"K+#"& %&#!P$ ($ +$ 3/$

:26$:?$846$?6-$F7/893.2$6B:2:A3/8/$-4:$

-./$ .2$ .B87.@$ /87E628$ :?$ J3/6/$ E7932;$

43/$83A6$.8$c6-$k:9M$<23=69/38>C$e39[269$

43A/6@?$ -628$ :2$ 8:$ 86.B4$ .8$ ck<,$

M66132;$ 846$ F7/893.2$ 89.E383:2$ .@3=6C$ F$

-6@@(96/16B86E$ 43/8:93.2$ :?$ 6B:2:A3B$

84:7;48$ 6=62$ 32$ A.32/896.A$ B39B@6/,$

e39[269$ 3/$ G6/8$ M2:-2$ ?:9$ 43/$ [email protected]:9.83:2$ :?$ J3/6/]$ 846:9>$ :?$

628961962679/431C$

$

D2$e39[269]/$.119:.B4,$ 846$628961962679$1://6//6/$.$/16B3.@$/M3@@$:?$

-0"$&)"(($8:$19:?38$:11:98723836/$84.8$:8469/$4.=6$A3//6EC$a>$G7>32;$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!T"$

72E69193B6E$ 96/:79B6/,$ .2E$ 89.2/?:9A32;$ 846A$ 328:$ .$ 19:E7B8$ :9$

/69=3B6$84.8$B.2$G6$/:@E$?:9$.$19:?38,$846$628961962679$/8669/$:78178$

8:-.9E$846$1.88692$A:/8$1@6./32;$8:$B:2/7A69/C&

&

&

/(""$>& OM& 05%26$".# %&#)'$ S$

&##"+$ -./$ .2$ 32B96E3G@>$ 19:E7B83=6$

6B:2:A3/8$-4:$R7386$B:2/B3:7/@>$-:9M6E$32$

846$ 89.E383:2$ :?$ 43/$ A628:9,$ d7E-3;$ =:2$

J3/6/C$ D2$ 43/$ ;96.8$ 896.83/6$ I-)<# .4+)+,B<#

-)2# /&-&"$ %&#')+$ Y:84G.9E$ 8::M$ J3/6/]$

3283A3E.832;$G*,-)# H4&'+)$ .2E$ 962E696E$ 38$

32$19:/6$84.8$.2>$3286@@3;628$@.>169/:2$B:7@E$

72E69/8.2EC$a78$Y:84G.9E$-./$2:$A696$/6B:2E(4.2E69,$ ?:9$46$.@/:$

E6=6@:16E$/6=69.@$:93;32.@$@326/$:?$.9;7A628C$

$

^:9$6Q.A1@6,$Y:84G.9E$B:A1@686@>$8496-$:78$846$A.32/896.A$846:9>$

:?$ A:2:1:@>$ 193B6,$ .9;732;$ 84.8$ 846$ :2@>$ G62B4A.9M$ G>$ -43B4$ 8:$

H7E;6$.2$6B:2:A>$-./$846$:78B:A6$:BB79932;$:2$.$?966$A.9M68$-384$

:162$B:A168383:2C$Y:84G.9E$.@/:$E96-$:2$ab4A(a.-69M3.2$B.138.@$

846:9>Z/:A68432;$ 84.8$ J3/6/$ 4.E$ [email protected]=6@>$ 26;@6B86EZ.2E$

3286;9.86E$38$328:$846$J3/6/3.2$?9.A6-:9MC$

$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!T'$

a6>:2E$ 43/$ ;96.8$ 846:9683B.@$ B:2893G783:2/,$ Y:84G.9E$ -9:86$

=:@7A32:7/@>$:2$6B:2:A3B$43/8:9>C$O3/$E:B8:9.@$E3//698.83:2$:2$846$

W.23B$ :?$ &I&#$ 96A.32/$ .$ /8.2E.9E$ -:9M$ :2$ 846$ 8:13BC$ D2$H,"$'4-Q(#

5$"-&#!":$"(('+),$Y:84G.9E$7/6E$ 846$J3/6/3.2$ 846:9>$:?$ 846$G::A(

G7/8$B>B@6$8:[email protected]$846$&#)#$/8:BM$A.9M68$B9./4C$

$

Y:84G.9E$-./$.$;96.8$:11:2628$:?$?9.B83:2.@$96/69=6$G.2M32;,$.2E$.$

B4.A13:2$ :?$ /:72E$ A:26>C$ O3/$ &##*$ 9="# 3-("# H%-')(&# &="# R"2$

96A.32/$846$A:/8$/7BB32B8$.88.BM$:2$B6289.@$G.2M32;C$

$

$

$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777#

#

!TT$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$&$\43/$628396$.1162E3Q$96@36/$=69>$46.=3@>$:2$846$/4:98$G3:;9.143B.@$6//.>/$32$Y.2E.@@$O:@B:AG6$%6EC+,$ST#5$"-&#H*(&$'-)#.4+)+,'(&($%F7G792,$Fd`$\46$d7E-3;$=:2$J3/6/$D2/838786,$&###+C$U6$-3@@$:A38$/16B3?3B$B38.83:2/$8:$.=:3E$86E37AC$

!"#$%&'()%"*$+)&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

"

!

"#$!

!

! "#$!

About the Authors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

!

!

!!!

Documents

E-Book How Privatized Banking Really Works