1
Early Commissioning Results from the SALT RSS Spectropolarimeter Kenneth Nordsieck* a * [email protected] a Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 475 N. Charter Street, Madison WI 53706-1582 ABSTRACT The Robert Stobie Spectrograph is currently the prime spectroscopic instrument on the 11m Southern African Large Telescope (SALT), which is now in commissioning. The current visible beam of RSS was designed with spectropolarimetric versions of all its modes, imaging, grating spectroscopy (with Multi Object Spectroscopy capability) from 3200 to 9000 , and Fabry-Perot Spectroscopy from 4300 to 9000 , with spectral resolution up to R = 10000. The polarimetric field of view is 4 × 8 arcmin. The instrument was designed with an upgrade path leading to a simultaneous Near InfraRed beam (out to 1.7μ), now in development, which will duplicate the spectropolarimetric modes in the NIR. We will describe results from early polarimetric commissioning of the visible beam. THE ROBERT STOBIE SPECTROGRAPH COMMISSIONING Filters CCD Camera Collimator Focal Plane Collimated Beam Triplet Silica/ NaCl/ Silica Quadruplet Silica/ CaF / Silica/ CaF 2 2 Doublet Silica/ CaF 2 Triplet CaF / NaCl/ CaF 2 2 Field Lens Silica/ CaF 2 Beamsplitter Grating/ FP etalons Shutter Waveplates T Pyxidis: a convenient Commissioning Lamp The Robert Stobie Spectrograph (RSS) 1 is an imaging spectrograph designed to occupy the Prime Focus Instrument Package of the Southern African Large Telescope (SALT) 2 . The optical design of RSS 3 features - spectral range 320 - 900 nm - all-refractive collimator and camera using fused silica, CaF 2 and NaCl elements - collimated beam diameter of 150 mm and field of view of eight arcmin - low to medium resolution grating spectroscopy using one conventional and five Volume Phase Holographic (VPH) transmission gratings - an articulating camera giving resolution R = 500 - 5500 (1.2" slit) and R up to 11,000 (0.6" slit) - a dual etalon Fabry-Perot mode for R = 320 - 9000 over the full FOV for wavelengths 450 - 900 nm - A simultaneous NIR beam for 900 nm – 1.7 microns, with the fold flat replaced by a dichroic, and which duplicates all the visible modes, is under development 5 - spectropolarimetry 4 for both grating and Fabry-Perot modes, using rotating quarter- and half- waveplates near the telescope focal plane and a calcite mosaic beamsplitter in the collimated space. POLARIMETRIC OPTICS REFERENCES [1] Kobulnicky, H.A., Nordsieck, K.H., Burgh, E.B. Smith, M.P., Percival, J.W., Williams, T.B., and O'Donoghue, D., "Prime Focus Imaging Spectrograph for the Southern African Large Telescope: Operational Modes," Proc. SPIE 4841, 1634 (2003). *2+ Buckley, D.A.H., Swart G.P., Meiring, J.G., “Completion and commissioning of the Southern African Large Telescope”, Proc SPIE 6267, 62670Z (2006). [3] Burgh, E. B., Nordsieck, K. H., Kobulnicky, H. A., Williams, T. B., O'Donoghue, D., Smith, M. P., and Percival, J. W., "The Prime Focus Imaging Spectrograph for the Southern African Large Telescope: Optical Design", Proc SPIE 4841, 1463 (2002). [4] Nordsieck, K.H., Jaehnig, K.P., Burgh, E.B., Kobulnicky, H.A., Percival, J.W., and Smith, M.P., "Instrumentation for high-resolution spectropolarimetry in the visible and far-ultraviolet." Proc SPIE 4843, 170 (2003). [5] Sheinis, Andrew I.; Wolf, Marsha J.; Bershady, Matthew A.; Buckley, David A. H.; Nordsieck, Kenneth H.; Williams, Ted B., “The NIR upgrade to the SALT Robert Stobie Spectrograph”, Proc SPIE 6269, 153 (2006). [6] Buckley, D. A. H.; Barnes, S. I.; Burgh, E. B.; Crawford, S.; Cottrell, P. L.; Kniazev, A.; Nordsieck, K. H.; O'Donoghue, D.; Rangwala, N.; Zánmar Sánchez, R.; Sharples, R. M.; Sheinis, A. I.; Väisänen, P.; Williams, T. B., “Commissioning of the Southern African Large Telescopes (SALT) first-generation instruments” Proc SPIE 7014, 6 (2008). [7] Williams, R. 2011 Private Communication WAVEPLATES BEAMSPLITTER SN2006mr 300 l/mm M30 unfiltered Orion Neb Hα T Pyx 20110519 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 Pol (%) 80 90 100 110 Position Angle (deg) Polarized Flux (arb units) -1.0% -0.5% 0.0% 0.5% 1.0% -2.0% -1.5% -1.0% -0.5% %U %Q 0.0% Wavelength (Ang) O III Bowen O III Bowen H I H I N III Bowen N III Bowen N II N II 1.8 1.0 0.2 I n t e n si t y ( ar b u n i t s ) 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 0 On 14 April, 2011, (one week after lift of RSS onto the telescope) the Recurrent Nova T Pyxidis underwent its first outburst since 1967. With a declination within one degree of the SALT latitude, it was ideal for observation. Being quite bright (Vmax ~ 7 mag) it was ideal as a first test for RSS high S/N modes: spectropolarimetry, high-speed, high-resolution spectroscopy. 20110519 Data (the rest has not yet been analyzed!) Observational Details: - Grating: 900 l/mm VPH grating, 1.5 arcsec slit, R = 800. - Polarimetry: Four 8 waveplate position linear polarization runs (minus the last 2 images, for 30 images), 1600 secs total. - Calibration: Not flux calibrated (roughly straightened). 2006 polarimetric efficiency and PA calibration, extrapolated to 3100 D. No instrumental polarization calibration yet (2006 data said ~0.2%) Spectrum (top plot): - Strong P-Cyg lines of HI (Balmer), He I, N II (Williams (2011) 7 He/N phase). - Strong Bowen lines, esp OIII 3133 (!). Spectropolarimetry (plots 2, 3): - Very high S/N. Data above 4300 D is unbinned. - H I, He I, N II P Cyg lines all show depolarization => intrinsic polarization. (magnitude 0.6%). Likely electron scattering polarization in distorted Nova atmosphere (like in supernova polarization). - Strong polarization features in Bowen fluorescence features. Not seen before? - Rough IS Polarization removal: remove P Cyg emission features in net polarized flux (plot 4, 5): 0.7% at PA within 5E of intrinsic. Kind of small IS polarization for supposed distance of 3 kpc. May provide upper limit to distance. Polarized flux features remaining after IS polarization removal: - P Cyg absorption, remains in absorption: => line absorption is not patchy, which could cause intrinsic polarization enhancements as in SNe). - Bowen NIII features. Complex intrinsic polarization feature. Suggests looking for other fluorescence lines in polarization. Some likely to be magnetically sensitive (Lazarian, 2010). Demonstrates future possibilities of UV-sensitive spectropolarimeter on 10m class telescope. Date R λ 1 λ 2 Comment 20110511 880 3800 10000 20110512 5700 3030 3852 20110519 800 3076 6212 20110603 806 2991 3817 20110605 10900 6144 6963 60 sec cadence 20110614 800 3077 6213 Modes: There are many RSS polarimetric modes, broken down into the three major instrument configurations (data format to the right:) - Grating spectropolarimetry. Each spectrum is split by Wollaston prism by ~ 4 arcmin into E and O spectrum. Can be done in Multi-Object Spectroscopy (MOS) mode. - Imaging. Either classical imaging polarimetry (through filters), or unfiltered imaging spectropolarimetry where each image is dispersed by chromatic dependence of Wollaston prism into ~20 arcsec objective prism-like spectrum. A unique mode. - Fabry Perot. Fabry Perot rings are split into E and O rings. Waveplate positions and Fabry Perot scanning is done in double Do-Loop. Another unique mode. Status: - Some commissioning of all these modes was done during one week in 2006 6 . - To correct spectrograph UV throughout problems and telescope imaging problems, it was off line until re-commissioning of the telescope and spectrograph in Mar-June 2011. - Re-commissioning of the grating spectropolarimetry mode (including UV performance ) is now in progress, with data now taken for linear polarization efficiency, position angle, instrumental polarization (unpolarized standard), and absolute position angle. Prospects - Grating spectropolarimetry: We expect commissioning to be complete by September 2011, and SALT will then be able to issue a announcement of opportunity for this mode. - Imaging, Fabry Perot. At best, end of 2011. Instrumental polarization effects that need to be understood: - Position in the field of view, and on the position of the telescope tracker. - Grating polarimetric properties. - Effect of slit on pupil uniformity (compare slitless with slit-limited polarimetry). Later polarimetric modes: - Circular and All-Stokes polarimetry with quarter-wave/ halfwave plate combination. - High Speed spectropolarimetry (up to 10 Hz) using detector fast readout modes. - Drift imaging spectropolarimetry. The rotating waveplate subsystem consists of two slides, a halfwave plate slide and a quarterwave plate slide, together with plane-parallel windows when not in use (the waveplates are in the diverging beam of the collimator, requiring focus compensation). - The halfwave plate alone is used for linear polarimetry, and the combination of the linear- and quarterwave plates are used for circular and all-Stokes polarimetry (below). - Each plate (fabricated by Bernhard Halle, Berlin) consists of a Pancharatnam “superachromatic” stack of six thin pieces of crystal quartz and magnesium fluoride, glued between two fused quartz substrates. - The Pancharatnam design covers 3100 Ang – 1.7 microns (for the future NIR beam), with the F/4.2 diverging beam accounted for. - The waveplates are rotated by miniature stepper motors, and actively detented at each rotation position, for angular repeatability. The polarizing beamsplitter consists of a 3x3 mosaic of calcite Wollaston prisms, each 62 x 73 x 25 mm, mounted in a slide just before the first element of the camera, so that it articulates with the camera. - When the beamsplitter is inserted, the collimated beam is split perpendicular to the grating dispersion direction into two beams with polarization parallel and perpendicular to the articulation axis of the camera, with a separation of 5 degrees, which projects to four arcminutes on sky. - The two prism wedges of each Wollaston mosaic element are lens fluid coupled, both to reduce ghost images at the prism interface and to allow for coalignment of the mosaic by adjusting the fluid wedges individually until the mosaic lines up. - The calcite is UV grade Mexican material, with internal transmission at 3200 Ang > 65%. Mode Linear Circular All-Stokes Plate ½ ½ ¼ ½ ¼ 1 0 0 +45 0 0 2 45 0 -45 45 67.5 3 22.5 22.5 -45 90 135 4 67.5 22.5 +45 135 202.5 5 11.25 45 +45 180 270 6 56.25 45 -45 225 337.5 7 33.75 67.5 -45 270 45 8 78.75 67.5 +45 315 112 Grating Spectropolarimetry Imaging Spectropolarimetry Fabry Perot Spectropolarimetry

Early Commissioning Results from the SALT RSS ...khn/salt/Outgoing/STARPOL_2011/... · Early Commissioning Results from the SALT RSS Spectropolarimeter Kenneth Nordsieck*a * [email protected]

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Early Commissioning Results from the SALT RSS Spectropolarimeter Kenneth Nordsieck*a

    * [email protected] a Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 475 N. Charter Street, Madison WI 53706-1582

    ABSTRACT The Robert Stobie Spectrograph is currently the prime spectroscopic instrument on the 11m Southern African Large Telescope (SALT), which is now in commissioning. The current visible beam of RSS was designed with spectropolarimetric versions of all its modes, imaging, grating spectroscopy (with Multi Object Spectroscopy capability) from 3200 to 9000 Å, and Fabry-Perot Spectroscopy from 4300 to 9000 Å, with spectral resolution up to R = 10000. The polarimetric field of view is 4 × 8 arcmin. The instrument was designed with an upgrade path leading to a simultaneous Near InfraRed beam (out to 1.7μ), now in development, which will duplicate the spectropolarimetric modes in the NIR. We will describe results from early polarimetric commissioning of the visible beam.

    THE ROBERT STOBIE SPECTROGRAPH

    COMMISSIONING

    Filters

    CCD

    Camera

    Collim

    ator

    Focal Plane

    Collimated Beam

    TripletSilica/NaCl/Silica

    QuadrupletSilica/CaF /

    Silica/CaF

    2

    2

    DoubletSilica/CaF2

    TripletCaF /

    NaCl/CaF

    2

    2

    Field LensSilica/CaF2

    Beamsplitter

    Grating/FP etalons

    Shutter

    Waveplates T Pyxidis: a convenient Commissioning Lamp

    The Robert Stobie Spectrograph (RSS)1 is an imaging spectrograph designed to occupy the Prime Focus Instrument Package of the Southern African Large Telescope (SALT)2. The optical design of RSS3 features - spectral range 320 - 900 nm - all-refractive collimator and camera using fused silica, CaF2 and NaCl elements - collimated beam diameter of 150 mm and field of view of eight arcmin - low to medium resolution grating spectroscopy using one conventional and five Volume Phase

    Holographic (VPH) transmission gratings - an articulating camera giving resolution R = 500 - 5500 (1.2" slit) and R up to 11,000 (0.6" slit) - a dual etalon Fabry-Perot mode for R = 320 - 9000 over the full FOV for wavelengths 450 - 900 nm - A simultaneous NIR beam for 900 nm – 1.7 microns, with the fold flat replaced by a dichroic, and which duplicates all

    the visible modes, is under development5

    - spectropolarimetry4 for both grating and Fabry-Perot modes, using rotating quarter- and half- waveplates near the telescope focal plane and a calcite mosaic beamsplitter in the collimated space.

    POLARIMETRIC OPTICS

    REFERENCES

    [1] Kobulnicky, H.A., Nordsieck, K.H., Burgh, E.B. Smith, M.P., Percival, J.W., Williams, T.B., and O'Donoghue, D., "Prime Focus Imaging Spectrograph for the Southern African Large Telescope: Operational Modes," Proc. SPIE 4841, 1634 (2003). *2+ Buckley, D.A.H., Swart G.P., Meiring, J.G., “Completion and commissioning of the Southern African Large Telescope”, Proc SPIE 6267, 62670Z (2006). [3] Burgh, E. B., Nordsieck, K. H., Kobulnicky, H. A., Williams, T. B., O'Donoghue, D., Smith, M. P., and Percival, J. W., "The Prime Focus Imaging Spectrograph for the Southern African Large Telescope: Optical Design", Proc SPIE 4841, 1463 (2002). [4] Nordsieck, K.H., Jaehnig, K.P., Burgh, E.B., Kobulnicky, H.A., Percival, J.W., and Smith, M.P., "Instrumentation for high-resolution spectropolarimetry in the visible and far-ultraviolet." Proc SPIE 4843, 170 (2003). [5] Sheinis, Andrew I.; Wolf, Marsha J.; Bershady, Matthew A.; Buckley, David A. H.; Nordsieck, Kenneth H.; Williams, Ted B., “The NIR upgrade to the SALT Robert Stobie Spectrograph”, Proc SPIE 6269, 153 (2006). [6] Buckley, D. A. H.; Barnes, S. I.; Burgh, E. B.; Crawford, S.; Cottrell, P. L.; Kniazev, A.; Nordsieck, K. H.; O'Donoghue, D.; Rangwala, N.; Zánmar Sánchez, R.; Sharples, R. M.; Sheinis, A. I.; Väisänen, P.; Williams, T. B., “Commissioning of the Southern African Large Telescopes (SALT) first-generation instruments” Proc SPIE 7014, 6 (2008). [7] Williams, R. 2011 Private Communication

    WAVEPLATES

    BEAMSPLITTER

    SN2006mr 300 l/mm

    M30 unfiltered

    Orion Neb Hα

    T Pyx 20110519

    0.0

    0.5

    1.0

    1.5

    Po

    l (%

    )

    80

    90

    100

    110

    Po

    sit

    ion

    An

    gle

    (d

    eg

    )P

    ola

    rized

    Flu

    x (

    arb

    un

    its)

    -1.0%

    -0.5%

    0.0%

    0.5%

    1.0%

    -2.0% -1.5% -1.0% -0.5%

    %U

    % Q

    0.0%

    Wavelength (Ang)

    O III Bowen

    O III Bowen

    H I

    H I

    N III Bowen

    N III Bowen

    N II

    N II

    1.8

    1.0

    0.2

    Inte

    nsit

    y (

    arb

    un

    its

    )

    3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500

    0

    On 14 April, 2011, (one week after lift of RSS onto the telescope) the Recurrent

    Nova T Pyxidis underwent its first outburst since 1967. With a declination within

    one degree of the SALT latitude, it was ideal for observation. Being quite bright

    (Vmax ~ 7 mag) it was ideal as a first test for RSS high S/N modes:

    spectropolarimetry, high-speed, high-resolution spectroscopy.

    20110519 Data (the rest has not yet been analyzed!)

    Observational Details:

    - Grating: 900 l/mm VPH grating, 1.5 arcsec slit, R = 800.

    - Polarimetry: Four 8 waveplate position linear polarization runs (minus the last

    2 images, for 30 images), 1600 secs total.

    - Calibration: Not flux calibrated (roughly straightened). 2006 polarimetric

    efficiency and PA calibration, extrapolated to 3100 D. No instrumental

    polarization calibration yet (2006 data said ~0.2%)

    Spectrum (top plot):

    - Strong P-Cyg lines of HI (Balmer), He I, N II (Williams (2011)7 He/N phase).

    - Strong Bowen lines, esp OIII 3133 (!).

    Spectropolarimetry (plots 2, 3):

    - Very high S/N. Data above 4300 D is unbinned.

    - H I, He I, N II P Cyg lines all show depolarization => intrinsic polarization.

    (magnitude 0.6%). Likely electron scattering polarization in distorted Nova

    atmosphere (like in supernova polarization).

    - Strong polarization features in Bowen fluorescence features. Not seen before?

    - Rough IS Polarization removal: remove P Cyg emission features in net

    polarized flux (plot 4, 5): 0.7% at PA within 5E of intrinsic. Kind of small IS

    polarization for supposed distance of 3 kpc. May provide upper limit to

    distance.

    Polarized flux features remaining after IS polarization removal:

    - P Cyg absorption, remains in absorption: => line absorption is not patchy,

    which could cause intrinsic polarization enhancements as in SNe).

    - Bowen NIII features. Complex intrinsic polarization feature. Suggests looking

    for other fluorescence lines in polarization. Some likely to be magnetically

    sensitive (Lazarian, 2010).

    Demonstrates future possibilities of UV-sensitive spectropolarimeter on 10m class

    telescope.

    Date R λ1 λ2 Comment

    20110511 880 3800 10000

    20110512 5700 3030 3852

    20110519 800 3076 6212

    20110603 806 2991 3817

    20110605 10900 6144 6963 60 sec cadence

    20110614 800 3077 6213

    Modes: There are many RSS polarimetric modes, broken down into the three major instrument configurations (data format to the right:) - Grating spectropolarimetry. Each spectrum is split by Wollaston prism by ~ 4 arcmin into E and O spectrum. Can be done

    in Multi-Object Spectroscopy (MOS) mode. - Imaging. Either classical imaging polarimetry (through filters), or unfiltered imaging spectropolarimetry where each image

    is dispersed by chromatic dependence of Wollaston prism into ~20 arcsec objective prism-like spectrum. A unique mode. - Fabry Perot. Fabry Perot rings are split into E and O rings. Waveplate positions and Fabry Perot scanning is done in double

    Do-Loop. Another unique mode. Status: - Some commissioning of all these modes was done during one week in 2006 6. - To correct spectrograph UV throughout problems and telescope imaging problems, it was off line until re-commissioning of

    the telescope and spectrograph in Mar-June 2011. - Re-commissioning of the grating spectropolarimetry mode (including UV performance ) is now in progress, with data now

    taken for linear polarization efficiency, position angle, instrumental polarization (unpolarized standard), and absolute position angle.

    Prospects - Grating spectropolarimetry: We expect commissioning to be complete by September 2011, and SALT will then be able to

    issue a announcement of opportunity for this mode. - Imaging, Fabry Perot. At best, end of 2011. Instrumental polarization effects that need to be understood: - Position in the field of view, and on the position of the telescope tracker. - Grating polarimetric properties. - Effect of slit on pupil uniformity (compare slitless with slit-limited polarimetry). Later polarimetric modes: - Circular and All-Stokes polarimetry with quarter-wave/ halfwave plate combination. - High Speed spectropolarimetry (up to 10 Hz) using detector fast readout modes. - Drift imaging spectropolarimetry.

    The rotating waveplate subsystem consists of two slides, a halfwave plate slide and a quarterwave plate slide, together with plane-parallel windows when not in use (the waveplates are in the diverging beam of the collimator, requiring focus compensation). - The halfwave plate alone is used for linear polarimetry, and the

    combination of the linear- and quarterwave plates are used for circular and all-Stokes polarimetry (below).

    - Each plate (fabricated by Bernhard Halle, Berlin) consists of a Pancharatnam “superachromatic” stack of six thin pieces of crystal quartz and magnesium fluoride, glued between two fused quartz substrates.

    - The Pancharatnam design covers 3100 Ang – 1.7 microns (for the future NIR beam), with the F/4.2 diverging beam accounted for.

    - The waveplates are rotated by miniature stepper motors, and actively detented at each rotation position, for angular repeatability.

    The polarizing beamsplitter consists of a 3x3 mosaic of calcite Wollaston prisms, each 62 x 73 x 25 mm, mounted in a slide just before the first element of the camera, so that it articulates with the camera. - When the beamsplitter is inserted, the collimated beam is split

    perpendicular to the grating dispersion direction into two beams with polarization parallel and perpendicular to the articulation axis of the camera, with a separation of 5 degrees, which projects to four arcminutes on sky.

    - The two prism wedges of each Wollaston mosaic element are lens fluid coupled, both to reduce ghost images at the prism interface and to allow for coalignment of the mosaic by adjusting the fluid wedges individually until the mosaic lines up.

    - The calcite is UV grade Mexican material, with internal transmission at 3200 Ang > 65%.

    Mode Linear Circular All-Stokes

    Plate ½ ½ ¼ ½ ¼

    1 0 0 +45 0 0

    2 45 0 -45 45 67.5

    3 22.5 22.5 -45 90 135

    4 67.5 22.5 +45 135 202.5

    5 11.25 45 +45 180 270

    6 56.25 45 -45 225 337.5

    7 33.75 67.5 -45 270 45

    8 78.75 67.5 +45 315 112

    Grating Spectropolarimetry

    Imaging Spectropolarimetry

    Fabry Perot Spectropolarimetry