Upload
daktari
View
60
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
EBM 報告 吳晉嘉 張哲浣 何怡慧. 形成問題 找出相關文獻 評估文獻品質 總結證據結果 解讀文獻發現. Free form question. The role of albumin use in resuscitation of trauma patients. Structured question. Critically ill. Population: major trauma patients with unstable hemodynamics in intensive care units. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
EBM 報告吳晉嘉張哲浣何怡慧
2
• 形成問題• 找出相關文獻• 評估文獻品質• 總結證據結果• 解讀文獻發現
3
Free form question
• The role of albumin use in resuscitation of trauma patients
4
Structured question
• Population: major trauma patients with unstable hemodynamics in intensive care units.
• Intervention: albumin use duration• Outcome: mortality rate, morbidity• comparison
Critically ill
5
• 形成問題• 找出相關文獻• 評估文獻品質• 總結證據結果• 解讀文獻發現
6
Literature review
• Pubmed• CINAHL Plus with Full Text• Cochrane Library• DynaMed • Ovid Medline • Wiley-Blackwell
7
8
9
10
11
• 形成問題• 找出相關文獻• 評估文獻品質• 總結證據結果• 解讀文獻發現
罩門所在
12
13
• Exclude 1980以前 study
14
• 形成問題• 找出相關文獻• 評估文獻品質• 總結證據結果• 解讀文獻發現
15
• Comprehensive meta-analysis
16
17
18
19
Sensitivity test: One study removed
20
Study name Statistics for each study Odds ratio and 95% CI
Odds Lower Upper ratio limit limit Z-Value p-Value
SAFE 0.996 0.887 1.118 -0.070 0.944Maitland 2011 1.017 0.788 1.312 0.130 0.897Cooper 2006 4.125 0.392 43.383 1.180 0.238Maitland 2005 0.168 0.036 0.797 -2.246 0.025Goodwin 1983 4.552 1.160 17.860 2.173 0.030Grundmann 1982 1.444 0.051 40.541 0.216 0.829Metildi 1984 1.750 0.537 5.701 0.929 0.353Rachow 1983 0.667 0.080 5.537 -0.375 0.707Tollofsrud 1995 0.302 0.011 8.332 -0.708 0.479Woittiez 1997 3.429 0.750 15.671 1.589 0.112Zetterstrom 1981a 0.312 0.012 8.285 -0.696 0.486
1.010 0.911 1.120 0.191 0.8480.01 0.1 1 10 100
Favours A Favours B
Meta Analysis
Meta Analysis
21
-2.0 -1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
5
10
15
20Pre
cisi
on (1
/Std
Err
)
Log odds ratio
Funnel Plot of Precision by Log odds ratio
22
-2.0 -1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Sta
ndar
d Err
or
Log odds ratio
Funnel Plot of Standard Error by Log odds ratio
23
24
25
• 形成問題• 找出相關文獻• 評估文獻品質• 總結證據結果• 解讀文獻發現
26
• In general, compared with crystlloids, current albumin use has no statistical significance in treating critically ill patients.
• However, improvement of research method or subgroup analysis should be performed further.
27
感恩聆聽