Sheet1IdentificationGeneral ApproachPolicy toolsIndividual attitudes1.What are your predictions about the impact in Europe of resource scarcities?2. Resource efficiency has the potential to:3. How would you rate the current use of the following resources in Europe in terms of efficiency?4. How much potential do the following policies have to help make the European economy more resource efficient?5. How significant are the following obstacles in preventing the economy from becoming more resource efficient?1. Lack of long term thinking in private innovation and investment in efficiencyHow potentially effective are the following ways to promote long-term thinking and planning in the private sector?2. Insufficient public funding/incentives for investment and innovation for resource efficiencyHow potentially effective are the following as ways of boosting investment in innovation for resource efficiency?3. Limits of existing infrastructure How potentially effective are the following as ways to ensure private investment in a resource-efficient infrastructure (e.g. energy, transport and communication)?4. Current consumption patterns How potentially effective are the following as ways of steering consumers towards more sustainable alternatives?5. Current business models For each of the following factors, say how significant it is as a barrier to adopting new business models/ organisational innovations by private companies that could contribute to more resource efficiency?6. How potentially effective are the following as ways of shifting business behaviour to resource efficient business models?7. Inadequate market signals for resource efficiencyHow potentially effective are the following as ways of steering the market towards resource efficiency?8. Monitoring and measuring progress on resource efficiency1. What do you see as the main criteria steering individual behaviour and decisions to improve resource efficiency?2. Should the resource efficiency footprint of products (resources used in their production, consumption) be indicated on the product' labels?3. In order to reduce the impact of resource consumption outside of the EU, should the EU trade only products that respect sustainability criteria and labelling (e.g. the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) label certifying that wood is sourced from well managed forests)?4. Would you be willing to pay comparatively more for sustainably produced/imported products (e.g. certified timber, certified sustainable biofuels, etc)?5. Would you be willing to change your diet to reduce the environmental impact of the food-production chain (e.g. favouring seasonal fruit and vegetables)?6. Would you consider leasing or buying a service for the following as an alternative to buying goods if the option was available?7. What factors would influence you in deciding whether to opt for a service or sharing/leasing scheme (e.g. car sharing) instead of buying a product for your personal use?8. Would you agree to higher taxes on goods with higher environmental impacts (e.g. energy from fossil fuels, imported goods involving high resource use, etc.) if this was offset by lower taxes on goods with a lower environmental impacts (sustainable products or services) so that there was no increase in your taxes overall? This would increase the price of less sustainable products and services and reduce the price of more sustainable ones.9. How potentially effective do you consider the following private initiatives to contribute to resource efficiency?Affiliationorganisation typeOrganisation NameEmailCountryPrivacyWe will consume natural resources at an unsustainable rate and sustainability limits of natural resources will be exceededAccess to resources will become difficult (e.g. because of tensions between countries)Europe will face physical shortages of resources like water and mineralsThe prices of some materials/resources will rise considerablyHelp the EU's economy cope with sudden price rises and shortages on world marketsMake the EU's environment more resilientCreate new jobs and growth in the European economy (e.g. new technologies and services)Metals and minerals (e.g. iron, copper, lithium)Food (e.g. agriculture products, meat, drinks)Fossil fuels (e.g. oil, gas, coal)WaterBiotic materials (e.g. wood, biofuels)Construction materialsEnergyEcosystem services (e.g. pollution sink, water regulation, pollination)ChemicalsAgriculture and rural developmentClimate change policyConsumers and health policyEmployment policyEnergy policyEnvironmental policyIndustrial policyMaritime and fisheries policyRegional policyResearch and innovation policyTrade policyTransport policyInadequate market signals for resource efficiency (i.e. prices do not reflect impact on resources)Consumers purchasing decisions not reflecting long term sustainabilityLack of information (on alternative options)Lack of long-term thinking in decision making (e.g. awareness of new technologies, working methods and processes among managerial staff)Insufficient public funding/incentives for investment and innovation promoting resource efficiencyLimits in existing infrastructure (e.g. energy, transport and communication)Dependence on existing technologiesCurrent business modelsSkills gaps in the workforce and sub-optimal functioning of the labour marketUnhelpful existing regulationLack of targets/indicatorsLack of prioritisationInsufficient R&D funding and investmentEducation & training of consumers, entrepreneurs and workers to raise awareness of resource-saving opportunitiesBinding regulations and standards (e.g. fuel efficiency standards, eco-design requirements, compulsory resource accounting and reporting)Mandatory long-term targetsMarket-based instruments (e.g. energy and resource taxes and incentives) to induce resource-saving measuresFinancial support to trigger long-term investments in the private sectorPublic-private partnerships in R&D and innovationSupport to R&D into new technologies and organisational structuresInformation tools to strengthen the market for sustainable products (e.g. product labels indicating resource footprint)Eco-friendly procurement contracts by public authorities (to strengthen the market for resource-efficient products)Incentives to consume less, re-use, recycleTrade policy measures (e.g. introduction of sustainability criteria for imported products)Phase out of environmentally harmful subsidiesAccess to credit for efficient use of energy, water and waste management and other sustainable products and services for householdsTax incentives for sustainable companiesEducation & training of consumers,entrepreneurs and workers on how to use innovation to their advantageBinding technical regulations and standards (e.g. public buildings energy and water standards to boost investment in the construction sector)Financial support to increase energy efficiency of buildings and invest in renewable energyInformation tools (e.g. resource footprint information on cars for consumers)Eco-friendly public procurement to develop the market for more sustainable products and servicesPublic-private R&D and innovation partnershipsIncreased funding for resource-efficient infrastructure through EU's structural and cohesion fundsOther market based instrumentsCap and tradetype quotas combined with economic incentivesMarket-based instruments (e.g. higher taxes on energy, roads and congestion instead of income tax)SubsidiesDevelopment of demand-side management strategies in parallel with any major infrastructure projectsBinding technical regulations and standards (e.g. uniform standards and targets for energy and resources to influence infrastructure-related emissions)Information tools (e.g. standardised methodologies on life-cycle analysis for use by suppliers to increase transparency and allow market comparison)Eco-friendly public procurement (e.g. public infrastructure tenders to impose compliance with sustainability and ecological requirements/indicators)Public-private partnershipsIncreased funding for resource-efficient infrastructure (e.g. through EU's structural and cohesion funds)Education & training of consumers, entrepreneurs and workers for sustainable consumption and waste generationBetter research & design of consumers choicesBinding minimum technical product regulations and standards to remove the least sustainable products from the marketMarket-based instruments (e.g. energy and resource taxes reflected in product prices) to make sustainable products more price-competitiveInformation tools (e.g. labelling of products on their resource foot-print)Corporate social responsibility (CSR)Eco-friendly public procurement to develop the market for sustainable consumer products and servicesTrade measures (e.g. introduction of sustainability criteria for imported products) to develop the market for sustainable consumer goodsStricter requirements for waste disposal and recycling for consumersExcessive perceived riskLack of funds-financing (e.g. in R&D)Long payback period for investments compared to short term investors expectationsLimited access to information and knowledge (e.g. among managerial staff)Lack of suitable business partnersUncertain market demandMarket dominated by established firmsRegulations not providing the right incentivesLack of qualified personnelLack of adequate infrastructureLack of technological and management capabilitiesMarket-based instruments (e.g. energy and resource taxes/incentives in support of resource efficient business models)Cap and tradetype quotasEducation & training of employees, entrepreneurs and workers about progressive businesses case studies and how to replicate them in their environmentBinding technical regulations and standards (e.g. fuel-efficiency standards or eco-design requirements and compulsory resource accounting and reporting)Easy access to investment/R&D and innovation fundingInformation tools (e.g. products information on resource foot-print to encourage businesses to create more sustainable supply chains and business models)Requirement for public procurement to comply with sustainability and ecological standardsTrade measures (e.g. introduction of sustainability criteria for imported products to push businesses to create more sustainable supply chains and business models)Voluntary sectoral agreement (with commitments and targets, possibly to become mandatory after agreement with all parties)Financial support mechanisms to correct price distortions in the marketInfluence markets through pricing environment and resource use (e.g. energy and resource taxes instead of income taxes)Independent and trustworthy advice (by public authorities) to consumers and SMEs on energy efficiency applications (in their homes/business)Information tools (e.g. products information on resource foot-print to help consumers)Eco-friendly public procurement to influence markets and consumer perceptionTrade measures (e.g. introduction of sustainability criteria for imported products to send the right signal to national and international markets)Binding regulations and standards (e.g. compulsory resource accounting and reporting, fuel-efficiency standards, eco-design requirements)Private sector financial stimuli (e.g. long-term soft-loan for energy efficient projects)How should the European Commission approach the issue of indicators so that improvements in resource efficiency across different parts of the EU economy can be effectively monitored and measured?Compliance with social, religious or ethical norms (e.g. waste disposal)Perceived usefulness/benefit to society of the individual's effortTendency for short-term thinkingPerceived cost (e.g. up-front investment, more expensive products) and effort (e.g. red tape, complex authorisation systems)Perceived long-term savingsPerceived trade-offs in terms of comfortConsumer informationFinancial incentivesTransport (e.g. car leasing or buying mileage instead of buying a vehicle)Personal electronic appliances (e.g. mobile phone, computing)Household electrical/electronic appliances (e.g. home entertainment, laundry)Ease and flexibility of contractual arrangementPracticality/availability/reliability of serviceAttractiveness of serviceLower environmental impactSocial imagePrice/value for moneyChange of diet and consumption patterns (e.g. not throwing away food, reducing the number of electronic devices owned)Using alternative means of transport to minimise private car use and air travelInvesting in higher-efficiency installations (e.g. insulation, double-glazing, heating/cooling through air/ground source pumps, energy star rated boilers, thermostats and aquastats)Reducing waste by composting and recyclingInvesting in smart meters to control consumption and cost (water, electricity)Investing in small-scale renewable technologies (e.g. solar thermal to heat water, solar photovoltaic and small-scale wind turbines to generate your own electricity and sell the excess back to the grid)Additional CommentsI am answering as an individualPolandMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the longer termNot at allIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termVery efficientMore or less efficientVery efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientVery efficientVery efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantNo opinionMore or less significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelIndicators will not be needed and should thus be abolished to reduce administrative burdenVery relevantNot relevantNot relevantVery relevantVery relevantNot relevantVery relevantVery relevantStrongly DisagreeAgreeStrongly DisagreeAgreeNoNoNoMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantNot relevantVery relevantStrongly DisagreeMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveTHE QUESTIONNAIRE SHOULD BE APPROPRIATE TO OCCUPANCY OF PEOPLE ASKED TO ANSWER.I am answering as an individualBelgiumMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)No opinionNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantNot significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantNot significantNot significantVery significantVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelContinue using the existing sustainable development indicators as they cover all needs for monitoring appropriatelyVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeYesYesYesVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantNot relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveI would like to see the resource efficiency debate more strongly linked with the protection of natural resources and with the Sustainable Development Indicators (SDIs). I would like regular stakeholder workshops around the ten themes (SDIs) to take place in the context of the Resource Efficient Europe Flagship Initiative, whose progress and public visibility seems for the moment to be limited to a tight circle of those involved in the decision-making process.I am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationBelgiumMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termNo opinionIn the longer termIn the longer termNo opinionVery efficientNo opinionNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNo opinionMore or less efficientNo opinionSome potentialNo opinionLow potentialSome potentialLow potentialHigh potentialNo opinionNo opinionSome potentialNo opinionSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelNot significantSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelNot significantNot significantSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantNot significantNot significantNot significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantAgreeDisagreeAgreeAgreeYesYesYesMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantAgreeMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)More or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNo opinionNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionDon't knowDon't knowDon't knowDon't knowNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionDon't knowNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionbei Frageblock 4 Derzeitige Verbrauchsmuter wird unter Punkt 4.6 nicht die Methode spezifiziert Frageblock mit persnlicher Einstellung sollte bei einer Antwort als Institution oder Unternehmen entfallenI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the longer termNot at allIn the short term (by 2020)Not at allIn the longer termIn the longer termVery efficientNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionMore or less efficientNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionHigh potentialHigh potentialNo opinionNo opinionSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot significantNot significantVery significantNot significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantNot significantNot significantNot significantVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeStrongly agreeAgreeStrongly agreeNoNoNoVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantNo opinionNo opinionVery relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)non-governmental organisation / association of NGOsFinlandMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termNo opinionMore or less efficientNot efficientVery efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialLow potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelVery effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelContinue using the existing sustainable development indicators as they cover all needs for monitoring appropriatelyVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeYesYesYesMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantAgreeMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)More or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientHigh potentialHigh potentialLow potentialLow potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantNot significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionDon't knowDon't knowDon't knowDon't knowNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionDon't knowNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionOn policy tools to promote long-term thinking: market-based instruments are often the best approach to enforce long-term behavioral changes. The nature of the resource needs also to be taken into account and regulation might be needed when resource availability is at risk. Most of the policy tools would gain in effectiveness if applied at global level. As this is not always possible, we encourage the adoption of measures that are least compatible (Standards harmonization is a good example). On the effectiveness of labels, we believe that a distinction needs to be made between products from different manufacturers versus product categories. LCA methods are not always accurate enough to distinguish between essentially similar products from different manufacturers (particularly if different system boundaries and assumptions are used in the calculations). As a conclusion, GE believes that several opportunities exist to increase a more efficient use of our resources, particularly on the supply side of products. This approach should be supported by policy-makers through the creation of the right incentives to encourage investors by attaching more visibility to the value of social and environmental impacts. Demand and supply side efficiency represent complementary strategies that can work in tandem to deliver a full range of efficiency potential.I am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationGermanyMake this contribution anonymousNot at allIn the longer termNot at allIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termNot at allNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionVery efficientNo opinionVery efficientVery efficientVery efficientNo opinionHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialLow potentialSome potentialLow potentialLow potentialLow potentialSome potentialHigh potentialLow potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelNot significantSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelNot significantNot significantNot significantSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantNot significantMore or less significantNot significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelIndicators will not be needed and should thus be abolished to reduce administrative burdenNot relevantNot relevantNot relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly DisagreeStrongly DisagreeStrongly DisagreeAgreeNoNoNoNot relevantNot relevantNot relevantNot relevantNot relevantNot relevantStrongly DisagreeMore or less effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationNetherlandsMake this contribution anonymousNot at allIn the longer termNot at allIn the short term (by 2020)Not at allIn the longer termNo opinionVery efficientNo opinionVery efficientNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionVery efficientNot efficientVery efficientNo opinionSome potentialNo opinionLow potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionNot significantNo opinionSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelNot significantNo opinionSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionMore or less effectiveNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNot significantNot significantVery significantNot significantMore or less significantNot significantNot significantNot significantNot significantNot significantNot significantNot effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionDon't knowDon't knowDon't knowDon't knowNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionStrongly DisagreeNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionI am answering as an individualGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)Not efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantNot significantMore or less significantNot significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelAdd more indicators to the existing sustainable development indicators in order to be sure that all possible aspects will be coveredMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeAgreeStrongly agreeAgreeYesYesYesMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantStrongly agreeMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveI would like to state that the CE (self-) certification should be bundled with the REACh regulation. I. e., if someone is (self) certifying to be compliant and is not taking REACh into account, i.e. by not answering Art. 33 B2C (business to consumer) or B2B requests, this person should not be allowed to use the EU-owned "CE" mark. This is my deep concern with children's toys where many companies are not answering my requests and my country has not introduced legislation yet to sanction such non-compliant behaviour. Also, I think that PET bottles or children's picknick bottles, for example, containing phtalates or Bisphenol A (BPA) should not be marketed. Why are these not shown on the RAPEX index to a much larger extend? Is the European Commission gambling with the European Union citizen's health? Or do we have to give in as not to affect our WTO relationship with producers of such cheap plastics???I am answering as an individualUnited KingdomMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)No opinionNot efficientNot efficientNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNot efficientNo opinionNo opinionHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNot significantNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelMore or less effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionNo opinionVery significantNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentVery relevantMore or less relevantNo opinionVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantNo opinionVery relevantStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeYesYesYesVery relevantVery relevantNot relevantVery relevantNot relevantMore or less relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationBelgiumMake this contribution anonymousNot at allIn the longer termIn the longer termNo opinionNo opinionIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termMore or less efficientNo opinionNo opinionMore or less efficientNo opinionMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNo opinionSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialNo opinionNo opinionHigh potentialNo opinionHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionNo opinionSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNo opinionNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNo opinionNot effectiveNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveNo opinionMore or less significantNo opinionMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantNo opinionMore or less significantNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNot effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNo opinionNot effectiveNo opinionContinue using the existing sustainable development indicators as they cover all needs for monitoring appropriatelyVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantNot relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantDisagreeDisagreeDon't knowAgreeYesYesYesVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantDon't knowMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveI am answering as an individualGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)No opinionNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNo opinionNot efficientNot efficientNo opinionSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionNo opinionSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionNot effectiveNo opinionNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantNo opinionStrongly agreeAgreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeYesNo opinionYesMore or less relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantNo opinionStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)non-governmental organisation / association of NGOsSwedenMake this contribution anonymousI am answering as an individualLatviaMake this contribution anonymousNo opinionNot at allNo opinionIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)No opinionNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientNo opinionNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less significantVery significantVery significantNot significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantNo opinionVery relevantNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionVery relevantVery relevantDon't knowAgreeDisagreeDon't knowNoNoNoVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantNot relevantVery relevantDisagreeMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationBelgiumMake this contribution anonymousNot at allIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)Very efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialLow potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantAgreeStrongly agreeAgreeDon't knowYesNoYesVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveHydro thanks the Commission for the opportunity to provide this initial input. Hydro will support our submission with the provision of an explanatory note in the coming month.I am answering as an individualBelgiumMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)Very efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNo opinionHigh potentialHigh potentialLow potentialLow potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelNot significantNot significantSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantNo opinionVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantVery relevantNot relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantAgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly DisagreeYesNoYesMore or less relevantMore or less relevantNo opinionMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveI would never sacrifice a standard of living unless it's completely necessary. Since the planet didn't go down the drain yet, I like to believe we can turn our bad habits around by chosing for the right policies and technological investments while we will keep on enjoying an increasing standard of living.I am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)law firm / consultancyRomaniaMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)Not efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantAgreeAgreeAgreeDon't knowNo opinionNoNoVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantAgreeMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)No opinionNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly DisagreeAgreeAgreeAgreeYesNoNoVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveRegulations and policies concerning resource efficiency must include renewable raw materials (RRM) for all non food applications and outlets. The most efficient use of RRM has to be guaranteed. This implies that biomass has to be utilised for industrial processes first and secondly for energetic uses. Currently the setup of the policy framework neglects this principle and prefers the direct energetic use. Upcoming regulation aiming to enhance resource efficiency must be targeted to enable use cascades for any raw materials. Bio-based plastics can be used for many plastics applications and recycled back to plastics or by other established methods. Energy recovery of bioplastics waste generates green energy due to their high RRM content. Bioplastics as well as recyclates of conventional plastics can significantly increase resource efficiency and contribute to the goals of the Europe 2020 strategy. Cascade use of bioplastics should be supported by the EU and included in the upcoming communication.I am answering as an individualGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termNo opinionNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelNot significantSignificant mainly at EU levelNot significantEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less significantNot significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantNot significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantNot significantVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelIndicators will not be needed and should thus be abolished to reduce administrative burdenMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantNot relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeYesYesYesVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveI am answering as an individualUnited KingdomMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)No opinionNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNo opinionNot efficientNot efficientNo opinionSome potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialNo opinionSome potentialNo opinionHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNo opinionMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantNo opinionMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionMore or less effectiveNo opinionMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelNo opinionEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantNot relevantMore or less relevantNot relevantMore or less relevantStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeNo opinionNoNoMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantNot relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveI am answering as an individualFranceMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termVery efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialLow potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialLow potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelNo opinionSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeAgreeDon't knowAgreeNoYesNoVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantAgreeVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveI am answering as an individualSpainMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)In the short term (by 2020)More or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSome potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialHigh potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNot significantNot significantSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNo opinionEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveNot significantMore or less significantVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantNot significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantVery significantVery effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantAgreeStrongly agreeDon't knowStrongly agreeYesYesYesVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantNot relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveI am answering as an individualGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the short term (by 2020)In the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the longer termIn the short term (by 2020)More or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientNot efficientVery efficientMore or less efficientNot efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientLow potentialSome potentialSome potentialLow potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialLow potentialSome potentialLow potentialLow potentialSome potentialSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNot significantEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNo opinionNo opinionMore or less effectiveNo opinionVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveNo opinionMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveVery significantMore or less significantVery significantMore or less significantNo opinionVery significantVery significantVery significantMore or less significantNo opinionVery significantVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEstablish a limited selection of particularly important high-level indicators in order to improve public visibility and focus attention for policy developmentMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantStrongly agreeStrongly agreeStrongly agreeAgreeYesYesYesMore or less relevantVery relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantMore or less relevantVery relevantStrongly agreeMore or less effectiveVery effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveVery effectiveI am answering on behalf of an organisation or institution (business, NGO, public authority, ...)company / business associationGermanyMake this contribution anonymousIn the longer termIn the longer termNot at allIn the longer termNot at allNot at allNot at allMore or less efficientNot efficientMore or less efficientVery efficientNo opinionVery efficientVery efficientVery efficientVery efficientLow potentialSome potentialLow potentialLow potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialSome potentialHigh potentialLow potentialSome potentialNot significantNot significantSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at national levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at EU levelSignificant mainly at global levelSignificant mainly at global levelNot significantNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at global levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at EU levelEffective mainly at national levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at global levelNot effectiveEffective mainly at national levelEffective mainly at EU levelMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less significantNot significantVery significantMore or less significantMore or less significantVery significantNot significantMore or less significantNot significantNot significantNot significantNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveVery effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveMore or less effectiveMore or less effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveNot effectiveEffective mainly at EU levelN