Upload
gloria-mazhim-de-decker
View
60
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
EDUCATIONAL COUNSELING SERVICES: A NEEDS
ASSESSMENT OF JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL THREE
STUDENTS IN IBADAN NORTH LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA,
IBADAN
BY
SUWA MAZHIM GLORIA
NTI/PGDE/2013/12475
BEING A PROJECT SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT
OF SCIENCE EDUCATION NATIONAL TEACHERS‘
INSTITUTE IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF POST GRADUATE
DIPLOMA IN EDUCATION (PGDE).
DECEMBER, 2013
2
DEDICATION
To my ABBA, He opened every door that I knocked.
3
ABSTRACT
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I thank God, the all sufficient one who remains faithful.
I am greatly indebted to my competent and brilliant supervisor, Dr. O. A. Odeniyi who has really
contributed immensely to this work. I appreciate the exceptional, professional and fatherly
guidance he gave me throughout the conduct of this study. He was always ready to listen, advise,
make constructive criticisms and help me with necessary materials. May God Almighty reward
him.
I wish to express my profound gratitude to all the facilitators at Loyola college study center
whose technical and moral support helped me in completing this study. I appreciate the support
of the officers at the Local Inspectorate of Education, Ibadan North Local Government, the
examinations department of post-primary teachers‘ service commission (TESCOM), Oyo State
Ministry of Education and all the teachers at the various schools I visited for the study. I also
acknowledge all the authors whose works were used as reference materials for this study.
I would like to thank all my friends and colleagues, who contributed in one way or the other to
the success of this research work. I must specially mention Akintayo Olamide Ogunwale whose
dissertation meticulously guided my work, Uchechi Ekezie, Ifeoluwa Makinde and Mr.
Oyeyemi. Thank you so much.
My heartfelt gratitude goes to Stefan who was the consistent push behind this project. Many
times, I felt I wouldn‘t meet the deadline, but your priceless support kept me going. Thank you
so much for ensuring that I got up to work!
I am eternally grateful to my wonderful parents, Mr. & Mrs. B.P. Suwa, who have been my
enduring, unshakable support. I appreciate their ceaseless prayers, encouragement and love. I
want to appreciate my lovely siblings; Kathryn, who ensured that I registered for the first
semester, Jemima and my cousin Grace. I love you so much.
5
CERTIFICATION
I certify that this project was carried out by Gloria Mazhim SUWA in of the department of
science education, National Teachers‘ Institute Kaduna, Nigeria under my supervision.
SUPERVISOR CENTER MANAGER
Dr. Odeniyi, Olujinmi Adebayo Dr. Odeniyi,
Olujinmi Adebayo
NCE (1985) Ila-Oragun ibid.
B.Ed. (1994) University of Ibadan
M.Ed. (1998) University of Ibadan
M.A. (2002) University of Ibadan
PhD. (2010) University of Ibadan
Date Date
6
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title page i
Dedication ii
Abstract iii
Acknowledgement iv
Certification v
Table of content vi
List of Tables ix
List of Figures x
Chapter one: Introduction
Background of the study 1
Statement of problem 3
Justification 3
Research questions 4
Objectives of the study 4
Chapter two: Literature review
Introduction 5
Confidence in preparing for tests and examinations 6
Participation in class activities and homework 9
7
Difficult subjects 10
Educational help topics of interest to students 14
Chapter three: Methodology
Study design and scope 16
Study area 16
Study population 19
Inclusion and exclusion criteria 19
Sample size 19
Sampling technique 20
Methods and instruments for data collection: 21
Validity 22
Reliability 22
Data collection process: Semi-structured questionnaire 22
Data management and analysis 23
Ethical considerations 23
Chapter Four: Research results
Respondents‘ Socio-demographic characteristics 24
Responses to confidence scale 27
Difficult subjects 31
Responses to scale of activity based on class work and homework 35
Meeting a counselor for help with school work 39
Help topics 45
Discussion, Conclusion and Recommendations
Socio-demographic characteristics of participants 47
8
Responses to confidence scale on tests and examinations 47
Difficult subjects 48
Scale of activity based on classwork and homework 48
Meeting counselor for help with school work 49
Help topics of interest to respondents 49
Implications for Health Education 50
Conclusion 51
Recommendations 51
Suggestions for further study 52
References 53
Appendix I Semi-structured Questionnaire 58
Appendix II Scoring guide for scales 61
Appendix III Letter of Introduction 62
9
Table Page
2.1 Summary of BECE results in IBNLG from 2009-2013 11
3.1 List of public junior secondary school in IBNLG 16
3.2 List of selected schools in IBNLG 20
4.1 Respondents‘ socio-demographic characteristics 25
4.2 Responses to confidence scale 28
4.3 Confidence grade by selected demographics 29
4.4 Likelihood of confidence grade 30
4.5 Difficult subjects by some selected demographic variables 34
10
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
4.6 Responses to activity scale on class work and homework 36
4.7 Class activity grade by some selected variables 37
4.8 Likelihood of activity grade in classwork 38
4.9 Meeting counselor for help by some selected demographics 43
4.10 Likelihood of meeting a counselor for help 44
Figure Page
11
2.1 Participation of counseling services in the United States 15
4.1 Respondents‘ type of work after school 26
4.2 Most reported difficult subjects 32
4.3 Reasons given for difficulty 33
4.4 Responses to who Respondents‘ met with school problems 40
4.5 Proportion of respondents that said they had a school counselor 41
4.6 Proportion of respondents that met their counselor for help 42
4.7 Responses to help topics that interested respondents 46
12
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Background to the study
According to Okobiah and Okorodudu (2006) Guidance and Counseling is encompassed by
activities of relevant services and also processes of helping persons within and outside the school
to achieve their full potentialities in their emotional, moral, social, academic and vocational
developments. The National Policy on Education (2004) of the Federal Republic of Nigeria
points out that guidance and counseling services are important education services that are
essential for successful implementation of the Nigerian educational system. It advocates setting
up guidance services in secondary schools with professionally trained counselors to administer
such services. The UNESCO module on guidance and counseling (2000a) posited that Guidance
is a programme of services to individuals based on their needs and the influence of
environmental factors. Educational counseling is the assistance given to pupils individually and
through group techniques to help them function more effectively in their school programme. It
helps the pupil to develop to their maximum potential. Guidance and counseling is seen as the
best strategy to improve students‘ academic performance in school, thus successfully
implementing Nigeria‘s 6-3-3-4 educational system introduced in 1982.
The Counseling Curriculum designed by the Counseling Association of Nigeria (Adegoke,
2004), noted that counseling should be viewed as an integral and comprehensive school
programme rather than a peripheral one. Adegoke, (2004) and Alutu and Etiobhio (2006) posited
that there is need to introduce classroom Guidance and Counseling as early as possible so as to
prevent social vices among youths. They noted that educational reforms which include guidance
and counseling as a subject to be taught and examined have the potentials for promoting
effective learning in schools. School counselors are vital members of the education team. They
help all students in the areas of academic achievement; personal/social development and career
development, ensuring today's students become the productive, well-adjusted adults of tomorrow
(American School Counselor Association, (ASCA) 1997). According to Muro and Kottman
(1995), the roles of the school counselor include:
13
1. Individual counseling and advisement
2. Consultation—working with administrators, teachers, and staff to meet student needs
3. Student appraisal—coordinating information that goes into confidential student files and
interpreting the info to help qualify students for special programs
4. Parent help—meet individual and in groups with parents, provide resources and
information on child development, specific topics
5. Referral—provide referrals to appropriate professionals in the schools and in the outside
community
6. Program planning—coordinating work of various school personnel, parents, and other
interested parties in implementation of the school counseling program.
7. Career development—developing and implementing career awareness as part of the
school counseling curriculum
8. Change agent for the school atmosphere
9. Student advocate in meetings with teachers and staff
10. Classroom observations on behaviors, relationships and providing feedback to teacher,
students, parents, staff
11. Public relations—explain importance of counseling with school staff, parents, teachers,
students, community members, explain problems students may have. Relate to cultural
stigmas
12. Local research—student population characteristics (drug use on campus, etc.)
13. Screen students—interview new students, etc.
14. Staff development—around particular issues
To transit from one level of the educational system to the next, pupils have to undergo selection
or achievement examinations to determine their suitability for the level they are transiting into.
To transit from junior to the senior secondary, the Junior Secondary Certificate Examination
(JSCE) is conducted for candidates in their third year of the Junior Secondary School. A
candidate is expected to sit for a minimum of ten subjects and a maximum of thirteen. A
candidate is deemed to have passed the JSCE if he/she has passes in six subjects including
English and Mathematics (NECO, 2003).
14
School counselors play a critical role in guiding the students, especially those writing the
Certificate examination, to enhance their performance. Studies in Cross River state have shown
that students have a positive attitude towards guidance and counseling services (Eyo et al.,
2010). It is therefore expected that the students meet the school counselors when they have
problems with schoolwork.
This study provides educational counseling information from a needs survey conducted among
students in junior secondary school three (JSS3) in Ibadan north local government area, Oyo
state.
Problem statement
Although the national policy on education advocates for counseling services, professional
counselors are often saddled with more classroom/teaching activities to carry out their activities
and have few amenities to implement counseling programs in schools (Eyo et al., 2010). The
Local Inspectorate of education (Ibadan North local government) does not perform academic
needs assessment surveys in the secondary schools but relies on general information from the
research and statistics department of the State ministry of education. Furthermore, there are no
student appraisal reports submitted to the local inspectorate from any counseling association. In
the light of this, there is scarce current information about the educational needs of the junior
secondary school three students in Ibadan north local government.
Justification
The educational needs of junior secondary school three (JSS3) students need to be assessed,
documented and considered for educational counseling intervention because they are at a critical
point in the education system, transiting from junior to senior secondary school.
This study will provide information about what subjects JSS3 students in Ibadan North Local
government find difficult, their confidence in taking tests and examinations and who they meet
when they have problems with school work; it will give the guidance and counseling department
baseline information for subsequent planning of educational interventions in the schools.
15
Research questions
1) What is the examination confidence level of Junior Secondary School Three (JSS3)
students in Ibadan North Local Government Area (IBNLG)?
2) What are the subjects that Junior Secondary School Three (JSS3) students in Ibadan
North Local Government (IBNLG) find difficult?
3) What is the class and homework participation level of Junior Secondary School Three
(JSS3) students in classwork?
4) Do Junior Secondary School Three (JSS3) students in Ibadan North Local Government
(IBNLG) meet the school counselor when they have problems with school work?
5) What academic help topics are of interest to Junior Secondary School Three (JSS3)
students in Ibadan North Local Government (IBNLG)?
Broad Objective
This study aims to conduct an educational needs assessment among Junior Secondary School
Three (JSS3) students in Ibadan North Local Government.
Specific objectives
1) To determine the examination confidence level of Junior secondary school three (JSS3)
students in Ibadan North Local Government (IBNLG)
2) To find out what subjects the students find difficult to learn
3) To discover the class and homework participation level of Junior secondary school three
JSS3 students in Ibadan North Local Government (IBNLG)
4) To ascertain whether Junior secondary school three (JSS3) students in Ibadan North
Local Government (IBNLG) meet the school counselor when they have problems with
school work
5) To find out which academic help topics are of interest to Junior secondary school three
(JSS3) students in Ibadan North Local Government (IBNLG)
16
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
School counseling was borne out of offering career services to students. As the 20th century
moved forward, academic guidance became more interwoven into the vocational counselor‘s
responsibilities (Gysbers, 2001). Guidance leaders like John Brewer and G.E. Meyers began
emphasizing the educational role that vocational counselors could assume within schools. By the
mid 1930‘s into the 1940‘s, guidance counselors began providing personal counseling to students
as well.
Olayinka (1985) is of the opinion that guidance is a programme that provides service to
individual students based upon their needs and understanding of their immediate environment
factor have on the students and the unique features of each school. Guidance and counseling can
also be as the process and techniques used by a counselor to assist individual to cope with the
problems in the areas of his/her life, so that he/she can become useful and contribute to the
society in which he lives.
Needs assessment
One very important function of the counselor is student appraisal. The Encarta dictionary (2009)
defines appraisal as an evaluation: a judgment or opinion of somebody, especially one that
assesses effectiveness or usefulness. This implies some form of assessment of the student to be
able to make a judgment on the students‘ performance.
United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) module on
guidance and counseling program development defines needs assessment as a formal process
which determines the gaps between what is and what should be.
Needs assessment finds out what is needed. It is the basis for accountability and allows for
programme evaluation.
17
Needs Assessment for guidance and counseling programs is carried out for the following
reasons:
1. To determine programme goals and objectives
2. To ensure the involvement of all staff members
3. To allow for programme evaluation
4. To ensure accountability
5. To ensure that the programme is relevant
6. To ensure the success of the programme
The needs assessment process involves:
a) Identifying the population to be surveyed
b) Collection of data
c) Classifying and analyzing data
The guide for Victorian government schools (2012) defines an educational needs assessment as a
diagnostic and clinical assessment using identified tools to address a child or young person‘s
particular and individual learning needs. This will provide advice to their Student Support Group
and significantly inform their Individual Education Plan. It may also provide advice about further
services or supports that may be required.
2.2 Confidence in preparing for tests and examinations
In 1999, the Nigerian government established the National Examination Council of Nigeria
(NECO) as an alternative to the West African Examinations Council.
To transit from the three years of junior secondary to the senior secondary, the junior secondary
certificate examination (JSCE) is conducted for candidates in their third year of the Junior
Secondary School. While each state of the federation and the Federal Capital Territory (FCT)
conducts the JSCE for its candidates, the National Examinations Council (NECO) conducts the
JSCE for Federal Unity Colleges, Armed Forces Secondary Schools and other Federal
establishments operating Secondary schools. Private Secondary schools also take part in the
NECO JSCE provided they are permitted by their State Ministries of Education.
Twenty two subjects are administered at the JSCE level. A candidate is expected to sit for a
18
minimum of ten subjects and a maximum of thirteen. A candidate is deemed to have passed the
JSCE if he/she has passes in six subjects including English and Mathematics.
The grading system is as follows:
A - Distinction
C - Credit
P – Pass
F - Fail (NECO, 2003).
Most students are nervous or afraid of examinations; however, a moderate nervousness is often
an advantage if the student is to perform at his/her best. Every student needs to believe in their
abilities to perform well in tests and examinations. Lack of confidence or fear can lead to poor
performance in examinations (Students Counseling services (SCS), 2012)
When nervousness becomes anxiety
Some students experience more burdensome anxiety problems regarding their examinations –
either when studying for the examination or at the examination itself. If the problems are
recurring, causing the student to fail or opt out of an examination several times, the problems can
turn into a regular fear of attending examinations.
Problems with preparation
When preparing for an examination fear or worry could make the student find it difficult to
structure reading properly; prioritize the reading material, or separate reading time and leisure
time. It is also very common that students push themselves too hard and study too much each
day.
Problems during the examination
In connection with the examination itself some students, because of fear and stress, experience
that they can't remember the material, despite the fact that they have prepared well for the
examination. This can happen during preparation, or memory may fail when they have sat down
in front of the examiner and external examiner.
19
Physical symptoms of anxiety
For some students it is enough just to think of the word examination before their body reacts
with symptoms of anxiety: Rapid heartbeat, outbursts of perspiration, and stomach aches. The
physical inconveniences may be so marked – possibly even several months before the
examination – that the student contemplates all kinds of solutions with the purpose of escaping
the discomfort. For instance, by skipping or considering postponing the examination or
considering to drop out.
Fear of examinations can be many things
Fear of examinations can be expressed in many ways, and may be connected to various issues:
Being a new student
Academic difficulties
Fear of examinations could be about having made the wrong choice of study programme, or lack
of motivation to do the necessary effort – or simply lack of abilities for some reason. The student
may fear an examination with good cause, because he is not properly prepared for it.
Inappropriate study techniques
If the student‘s motivation is high, he may not have learnt to pick up on the material yet because
of inappropriate study structuring and reading techniques.
Perfectionism and performance anxiety
Many students who fear examinations suffer from perfectionism, and thus often also of
performance anxiety. They set extremely high demands for themselves in all matters, and
thereby the risk of failure becomes greater, which in turn increases their anxiety. Here it is not
enough to look at the examination separately. The student must also consider the way he looks at
himself and others. Behind perfectionism people often hide a low self-esteem and lack of self-
confidence.
Severe personal problems
If the student had severe personal problems - for instance, serious problems concerning
relationships, a serious disease, or death of a loved one - it will naturally affect his preparation
and examination. It is therefore to be assumed that his fear of examination is not about his ability
20
to do the examination, but the fact that he has not had the necessary inner calm that examination
requires (SCS, 2012).
Students‘ lack of confidence was also identified as a cause of exam malpractice by such scholars
as Olasehinde (1993): Oladunni (1995); and Adeboye (1998). Also there is a need for adequate
guidance and counseling for the students. This should be done in order to instill acceptable moral
values and encourage regular attendance of lectures which would in turn give them confidence to
face examinations.
2.3 Participation in class activities and homework
According to Anahs (2008), Class works are daily written works done in the classrooms. The
teacher uses them to re-enforce information just explained. Class work may occur daily. The
teacher grades students for class work and class participation on a weekly basis. Homework is to
be performed at home. Homework is not a test of the knowledge of the student. The goal of
homework is to ―motivate‖ the student to open the textbooks, read, and find the correct answers.
Homework should re-enforce the effort of the teacher at class. Students are to be encouraged to
use all resources available for them: textbooks, internet, friends, teachers, parents, etc. The goal
is to prepare a ―neat‖ and ―correct‖ homework and understand it. The students are expected to be
able to answer the homework questions in class if they were asked by the teacher.
Active participation of students is imperative for learning. According to the Nigerian Educational
Research and Development Council (NERDC, 2013), Characteristics of Modern Teaching
Approaches include that it is Learner-centered, Activity or Task-based, and problem solving
centered, Interactive, Authentic materials based, Integrative, Inclusive, gives the students
Conceptual understanding , and it is Assessment based.
A learner–centered teaching/learning approach engages students actively in the teaching and
learning process. Students are the focus of teaching and learning. The teacher is simply a guide, a
coach, a motivator, or a facilitator of learning. He should provide learning experiences for the
students and guide them to investigate experiment, explore, and discover knowledge. To
facilitate this, he should first identify students‘ prior or initial ideas/conceptions and use
appropriate learner-controlled activities to counter ‗naïve‘ ideas/conceptions.
21
Modern teaching approaches are necessary for learning because most teachers dominate
classroom instruction as confirmed by research reports of Atkins and Brown, (2001) Anorue,
(2004) Lathrop, (2006) Weimer, (2008) who believed that the teacher determines the classroom
climate.A study by Oranu and Onwioduokit (2012) showed that teachers in their study
classrooms failed to use different strategies to draw out knowledge, positive ideas and
experiences from the student. Therefore, there was poor quality of classroom discussions as
teachers adopted to a large extent direct instruction method confirming the findings of Atkins &
Brown,(2001) Anorue, (2004) Lathrop, (2006) Weimer, (2008); the study therefore challenges
teachers to engage all students positively in classroom sessions. The results also indicated that
students in Government classrooms shy away from active classroom discussion; these students
very likely are afraid of speaking in a group, peer criticisms, they may also lack understanding of
the material; they may lack interest in the subject, they may be waiting for the teacher to call the
―smart kids‘‘ who know the answer; they may not like the instructor as documented by scholars
like Roe (2012), Dees (2010). Teachers need to create a warm and positive classroom, where
students are free to make voluntary verbal contributions with a high level of creativity instilled in
the students. Javaria, Nazia, and Sadaf (2008) and Bordbar (2010) strongly opined that classroom
participation helps students to perform better in school and engenders positive attitude toward
school subject. Furthermore, the findings by Fakeye and Amao (2013) revealed that only
classroom participation has a significant relative contribution to students‘ achievement in
Literature -in- English and therefore is the only factor that that predicts students‘ achievement in
Literature - in - English.
2.4 Difficult subjects
Although the curriculum of the Junior Secondary differs a little from that of Senior Secondary,
they have in common some basic core subjects like, Mathematics, English Language, Nigerian
Languages (Igbo, Yoruba, Hausa), Agricultural Science, French Language, (or Arabic
Language), Christian Religious knowledge/Islamic Religious knowledge and Arts (NERDC,
2007). It is speculated that achievement of students in these subjects at the JSCE, which also
stand, as entry qualification for the Senior-Secondary programme could positively predict
student‘s performance in Senior School Certificate Examination (SSCE) (Sylvanus & Okechuku,
2013). There are presently two versions of the SSCE: the one conducted by National
22
Examinations Council (NECO) and the one conducted by West African Examinations Council
(WAEC). The present study is focused on the SSCE conducted by NECO.
The Curriculum of the Junior Secondary differs from that of the Senior Secondary in terms of the
integrated subjects (Social Studies and Basic Science). At the Senior Secondary School level, Social
Studies is split into Geography, Economics, Government and History. Students in the science classes
offer geography and Economics, while Government and History are offered by students in the arts
classes. At the Senior Secondary level, Basic Science is likewise split into Chemistry, Biology and
Physics, but the popular choice among the science students are Biology and Chemistry. The issue of
whether or not performance of students in Social Studies in JSCE would positively predict
achievement in the related subjects in the NECO-SSCE remains uncertain and inconclusive
(Sylvanus & Okechukwu,2013).
In the SSCE, English Language and Mathematics are compulsory subjects for all candidates;
hence much time and attention are devoted to the teaching of these two subjects in both the
primary and secondary schools. Nevertheless, the students have not been doing well, and the
situation is not improving. For example, in the SSCE of May/June 1992, English Language
recorded only 13.8% passes with Distinction and Credit grades while 59.6% of the total 381,506
candidates failed. For Mathematics, only 9.7% passed in Distinction and Credit grades while
59.4% failed (WAEC, 1994). In the examinations taken in June 1994 by 618,119 students, 14.2%
and 13.7% passed with Distinction and Credit levels in English and Mathematics respectively.
The failure rates for the two subjects were 56.3% for English and 67.4% for Mathematics
(WAEC, 1994). Results in other subjects were equally poor with students doing much worse in
subjects with practical work. In SSCE of December 1996, for example, failure rates were 64.6%
for English, Biology 58%, Music 75%, and Book-Keeping 67%.
However, the JSCE result in the last five (5) years has shown impressive performance by the JSS
3 students in IBNLG. This is shown in the following table:
Table 2.1: Summary of Basic Education Certificate Examination (BECE) results in IBNLG
from 2009-2013
Year Percentage pass Percentage fail Subject failed
2013 97.10 24.56 Mathematics
2012 61.39 12.58 Mathematics
23
2011 90.52 12.73 Basic Science
2010 99.74 1.38 French
2009 90.91 11.8 Arabic
*Source, Examinations department, TESCOM.
2.5 Meeting the school counselor for help with school work
First coined by Truman Kelley in 1914 (Makinde, 1988), educational counseling is a process of
rendering services to pupils who need assistance in making decisions about certain important
aspect of their education such as choice of courses and studies, decision on interest and ability,
choices of college and high school. Educational counseling increases pupil's knowledge of
educational opportunities.
To ensure that counseling wears a national outlook, the National Policy on Education (2004)
made it clear that counseling services should be rendered to students in schools. The
aforementioned policy document noted that ―in view of the apparent ignorance of many young
people about career prospects and in view of personality maladjustment among school children,
career officers and counselors will be appointed in post primary institutions (Federal Republic of
Nigeria, 1981, p43).
Studies on students‘ attitudes towards school counselors (Eyo, et al., 2010) revealed that
students‘ attitude towards guidance and counseling services were significantly positive; that
gender and school location significantly influenced students‘ attitude towards guidance services.
The results further revealed that there are significant differences between attitude of male and
female students in rural and urban schools towards guidance and counseling services. Based on
these findings, the researchers recommended that secondary education board should open well
equipped counseling units in both urban and rural schools and qualified counselors should be
posted to practice and create awareness of guidance and counseling services. Unfortunately,
studies have shown (Oye et al., 2012; Alutu, 2007) that Funds for provision of basic guidance
services are lacking. Most of the vital counseling services needed for quality education are the
least regularly performed in schools e.g. use of psychological tests and keeping of cumulative
record folders.
24
Studies of parents‘ awareness on the importance of guidance counselor (Nwaokolo, 2006),
observed that most parents are only concerned with the principal of the schools any time they
bring problems about their children; they prefer to go to the principal than to the guidance
counselors. In the new national policy of education (6-3-3-4) the demand for guidance and
counseling is apparently made clear, and from the research carried out by individuals above the
principals, teachers and parents have wrong awareness of the importance of guidance and
counseling programme. In contrast to students ‗attitudes found by Eyo et al., 2010, students had
a generally negative attitude towards guidance and counseling in the Kenyan study by
Nyamwange et al., 2012 as only 46% of the study population deemed guidance and counseling
generally necessary in the schools. These findings concur with Kombo‘s (1998) that high school
students have a somewhat negative attitude towards guidance and counseling. Their study also
established that head teachers also had a negative attitude towards guidance and counseling. It
was observed that only 24% thought it had a role to play in improving students‘ academic
performance. This negative attitude of both students and head teachers towards counseling does
not contribute towards the utilization of guidance and counseling services by the students.
In another rating by Chireshe (2011), both school counselors and students did not rate highly
academic achievement in comparison to other benefits of school guidance and counseling. More
female students and school counselors rated the School Guidance Counseling (SGC) services
more favourably because of gender awareness orientation of the SGC services. More female
students than male students rated the services more positively because female students are
perceived as more socially competent or better adjusted to school than males (Mpofu et al.
2004). More male students than female students could have rated the SGC services negatively
because they are normally socialized to be strong and cope with their own problems hence they
often do not approach school counselors (Van Der Riet and Knoetze, 2004).School counselors
and students from rural boarding secondary schools viewed the SGC services substantially more
positively because the services in these schools are taken seriously. Most of the rural boarding
secondary schools in Zimbabwe are church-related and inculcating morality is one of their key
concerns, hence the seriousness in implementing the SGC services in these schools. Students
from forms 4 and 6 viewed the services negatively because of the focus on examinable subjects
given to those forms. At such levels, school counselors who are normally fulltime subject
teachers may not have time to focus on SGC services but examinable subjects. Olayinka (1999)
25
and Egbule (2006) noted that educational guidance and counseling helps students make the most
appropriate use of their educational opportunities. This accounts for the better performance of
students in schools with counselors than the schools without.
2.6 Educational help topics of interest to secondary school students
In guidance and counseling profession there are many services that the professional counselor
renders to the school and the host community but in this paper, the three major services would be
discussed. The services are; educational, vocational and personal social services. The educational
service in guidance and counseling is a service which takes care of all issues associated with
education as they relate to the physical environment of the school, the structural makeup of the
school, activities within the school, students in take, students‘ progress, and adaptability within
the school. To this end Olayinka (1999) says that academic counseling is assisting students make
the most appropriate use of their educational opportunities. Also Egbule (2006) defines
educational guidance as assistance given to pupils and students that enable them function well in
the school. He continues by saying that it assists them in understanding themselves and how their
potentials could be developed. With these definitions, educational guidance and counseling for
the adolescents is sin-qua-non if they must achieve maximally.
Academic guidance and counseling is mainly on the curriculum-related needs of the learner.
Some of these needs are:
Courses to enroll
How to carry out assignments and projects,
How to prepare for examinations,
Effective study habits
How to remedy weaknesses in particular courses are some of these needs.
These form the core of the business the learner routinely engages in academic institution.
A survey, conducted through the National Center for Educational Statistics (NCES) Fast
Response Survey System (FRSS), in the United States by the National Center for educational
statistics provides a description of public high school guidance programs, activities, and staff in
2002.
26
As in 2002, the activity in which students participated most often in 1984 was individual
counseling sessions (79 percent), and the activity in which they participated least often was job
shadowing (5 percent). Between 1984 and 2002, the proportion of students who participated in a
guidance activity increased for 5 of the 15 activities: occupational information units in subject-
matter courses, exploratory work experience programs, job-site tours, job shadowing, and the use
of computerized career information sources. No significant differences were detected between
these years in the proportion of students who participated in the remaining guidance activities.
The figure below is taken from the NCES website:
27
Source: National Center for Educational Statistics (NCES), United States.
Figure 2.1: High participation of counseling services in the United States
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
28
This section deals with the research design, study population, sampling technique, methods and
instruments for data collection, procedure for data collection and data analysis.
STUDY DESIGN AND SCOPE
This is a cross-sectional study designed to assess the educational counseling needs of JSS 3
students attending schools in Ibadan North Local Government Area (IBNLG).
STUDY AREA
The study was conducted in five (5) public schools randomly selected and one private school in
Ibadan north local government of Ibadan, Oyo state. The sampling from which the selection was
made was obtained from the office of the Local Inspector of Education (L.I.E).Ibadan North
Local Government Secretariat is situated at Agodi-Gate Ibadan, opposite the Oyo State
Government House, Ibadan.
Table 3.1- List of public junior secondary schools in Ibadan North Local Government Area
NAME OF SCHOOLS
ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL, BASORUN 1
ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL, BASORUN 11
ISLAMIC JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL, BASORUN 111
SAINT LIOUS JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL, MOKOLA. 1
SAINT LIOUS JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL, MOKOLA. 11
SAINT PATRICK‘S JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL, BASORUN. 1
SAINT PATRICK‘S JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL, BASORUN. 11
SAINT GABRIEL‘S JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL, MOKOLA. 1
SAINT GABRIEL‘S JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL, MOKOLA. 11
SAINT GABRIEL‘S JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL, MOKOLA. 111
29
MOUNT OLIVET JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL.
MOUNT OLIVET JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL.
MOUNT OLIVET JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL.
ANGLICAN JUNIOR COMMERCIAL GRAMMAR SCHOOL 1
ANGLICAN JUNIOR COMMERCIAL GRAMMAR SCHOOL 11
ANGLICAN JUNIOR COMMERCIAL GRAMMAR SCHOOL 111
ABADINA SENIOR COLLEGE, UI, IBADAN 1
ABADINA SENIOR COLLEGE, UI, IBADAN 11
ABADINA SENIOR COLLEGE, UI, IBADAN 111
METHODIST JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL, BODIJA. 1
METHODIST JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL, BODIJA. 11
OBA AKINBIYI 1 JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
OBA AKINBIYI 1 JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
OBA AKINBIYI 2 SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
OBA AKINBIYI 2 JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
POLY JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
POLY JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
POLY JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 111
IJOKODO JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
IJOKODO JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
IMMANUEL JUNIOR COLLEGE 1
IMMANUEL JUNIOR COLLEGE 11
IMMANUEL JUNIOR COLLEGE 111
30
UNITED JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL 1
UNITED JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL 11
BASORUN/OJOO JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL
HUMANI ALAGA JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
HUMANI ALAGA JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
HUMANI ALAGA JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 111
IKOLABA JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL 1
IKOLABA JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL 11
IKOLABA JUNIOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL 111
IKOLABA JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
IKOLABA JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
IKOLABA JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 111
CHESIRE JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL 1
CHESIRE JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL 11
BISHOP ONABANJO JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 1
BISHOP ONABANJO JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL 11
OBA AKINYELE JUNIOR MEMORIAL HIGH SCHOOL 1
OBA AKINYELE JUNIOR MEMORIAL HIGH SCHOOL 11
NAVLARI UN – DEEN JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL
COMMUNITY HIGH AGBOWO BODIJA JUNIOR 1
COMMUNITY HIGH AGBOWO BODIJA JUNIOR 11
IBADAN NORTH GOVERNMENT SECONDARY SCHOOL, INALENDE.
EBENEZER AFRICAN CHURCH GRAMMAR SCHOOL
31
* Source- Local Inspectorate of education, Ibadan North Local government
STUDY POPULATION
The study population consisted of junior secondary school three (JSS3) students in the selected
junior secondary schools in IBNLG.
INCLUSION AND EXCLUSION CRITERIA
The criterion for this study was that the study participants must be currently enrolled in JSS 3 of
the selected schools. Males and females were included in the study. The inclusion criterion
implied that other students not currently enrolled in JSS3 were excluded.
SAMPLE SIZE
The appropriate sample size was determined using Lwanga and Lemeshow (1991) sample size
formula. The formula is as follows:
n = Zα 2 (1-p)
(p) d2
Where,
Zα is standard normal deviation at 5% (Standard value of 1.96)
p is the assumed percentage of secondary school enrollment.
The gross enrollment ratio (GER) for secondary school education in Nigeria as given by
education statistics, World Bank (2013) is 44% as at 2010. However, a more specific percentage
of 35% for only junior secondary school enrollment was given by Aghenta (2001).This figure
was used to calculate sample size. Therefore, p= 35% i.e. 0.35
d is relative precision at 25% or 0.25
n = 1.96 2 (1-0.35)
0.35 × (0.25)2
32
= 113.5, approximately 114.
An attrition or incomplete response rate of 30% of 114 (34) was added to increase the sample
size to 148.
Knowing the minimum calculated sample size, an arbitrary total of 300 questionnaires were
prepared and administered to the study population.
SAMPLING TECHNIQUE
A multi-stage sampling technique involving three stages was used in selecting respondents for
the study.
Stage 1
In the first stage, five (5) schools were randomly selected from the sampling frame to participate
in the study and one private school (Blessed Group of schools) was purposively added to the list,
making a total of six schools. The selected schools are listed in the table below:
Table 3.2: List of selected schools in Ibadan North Local Government
S/n
Name of school
1 Anglican Commercial Grammar School Junior II,
Yemetu, Ibadan
2 Methodist Grammar School, Bodija Ibadan
3 Ikolaba High School, Ikolaba, Ibadan
4 Blessed Group of schools, Yemetu, Ibadan
5 Saint Louis Grammar School 1, Mokola, Ibadan
33
6 Community high school, Ijokodo, Ibadan
Stage 2
Proportionate sampling technique was used to distribute the number of participants into equal
proportions in the schools.
The calculation is shown below;
300/6 = 50
Therefore, fifty (50) questionnaires were administered in each of the selected schools.
Stage 3
In the third stage, upon getting to the schools, fifty students in JSS3 were randomly selected with
the help of the school teacher assigned by the principal.
Methods and instruments for data collection
Data collection was carried out using a pretested semi- structured questionnaire.
The collection of quantitative data was done by means of a semi-structured questionnaire. The
design of the questionnaire was done after literature review. The questionnaire was organized
into four sections labeled A- D (see appendix II)
Section A was used to collect information about the socio-demographic characteristics of the
respondents. Section B was a three-point, five item scale used to assess the respondents
disposition towards tests and examinations. The respondents‘ disposition toward classwork and
homework was assessed in section C which had opened ended questions and another five item
scale. Section D collected information about who the respondents preferred to meet for help with
school work and educational topics where they needed counseling.
Validity and Reliability
Validity
34
The content validity of the instrument was ensured by reviewing several literature and using
relevant variables and questions adapted from similar studies. Reviews with my research
supervisor also enhanced the validity of my instrument.
Reliability
In order to determine the reliability of the instrument, a pre-test was conducted among students
of Ibadan Municipal Grammar (I.M.G) school of Ibadan North East Local Government Area,
Ibadan. I.M.G shares similar characteristics with the study population. It is a government owned
school and has currently enrolled JSS 3 students. Ibadan North East Local Government has it‘s
secretariat at Iwo road, Ibadan.
The questionnaire was pre-tested among 30 students currently enrolled in JSS 3 attending I.M.G,
Agodi, i.e., 10% of the study population. The pretested questionnaires were cleaned, coded and
entered into the computer. The reliability of the questionnaire was determined using Cronbach‘s
Alpha model technique of SPSS (version 16). The reliability co-efficient was 0.52 implying that
the instrument was reliable
Data collection process
The quantitative data were collected using the semi-structured questionnaire (see appendix II).
The questionnaire was interviewer -administered to ensure that the participants clearly
understood the questions, and to allow them clarify any confusion. A total of 300 questionnaires
were administered, but 299 valid questionnaires were retrieved due to attrition. This yielded a
response rate of 99.7 percent.
The questionnaires were administered during lesson periods in school hours permitted by the
school principal to conduct the survey. The data collection was conducted within three days; two
schools were surveyed per day. The questionnaire was collected immediately the respondents
were through, except for a school where the school counselor administered the questionnaires
and returned them the following day. All the respondents were given tokens to appreciate their
participation in the survey.
35
Data management and Analysis
The questionnaires were collated and edited by the researcher. The questionnaires were checked
for completeness and a serial number was given to each for easy identification and recall. The
responses in each questionnaire were hand-coded facilitated by the use of a coding guide
developed by the researcher after a careful review of the responses in all the
questionnaires. After the entire questionnaire had been hand-coded, a template was then
designed on the SPSS (version 16) for entering of the coded data. Each questionnaire response
was entered into the computer using the SPSS software- version 16. The quantitative data were
analyzed using descriptive statistics, Chi-square, and logistic regression. The results are
presented using tables, pie charts and bar graphs in chapter 4.
Ethical considerations
Research in education in non-ethical, therefore, ethical approval was not sought from any Ethics
Review Committee.
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS
36
4.1 Respondents’ Socio-demographic characteristics
The findings of this study are presented in this chapter. They are organized into the following
sections: Respondents‘ socio-demographic characteristics, respondents‘ responses to confidence
scale, difficult subjects, responses to activity scale, meeting the school counselor for help and
help topics for the school counselor.
Questionnaires were administered to 299 students in JSS3 attending schools in Ibadan North
Local Government. Majority of the respondents (67.9%) were female and 32.1% were male. This
was so because one of the randomly selected schools (Saint Louis Grammar school II) was an all
girls‘ school. The mean age was 13.3± 1.3 years, ranging from 11-18 years. Almost all the
respondents‘ (84.3%) belonged to nuclear families, most of them (86.6%) were Yoruba, 76.9%
reported that they lived far from school, 56.9% of the respondents‘ said they did domestic work
after school. Only very few (5.6%) reported doing school work after school. Details of
respondents‘ type of work are shown in figure 4.1.
Participants were almost equally distributed across the six schools; Anglican Commercial
Grammar School Junior (16.7%), Blessed group of schools (16.4%), Ikolaba High School
(16.7%), Saint Louis Grammar School (16.7%), Methodist Grammar School (16.7%),
Community High School (16.7%).
Table 4.1: Respondents’ socio-demographic characteristics (N = 299)
37
FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE*
Study area
Anglican Commercial Grammar School 50 16.7
Ikolaba High School 50 16.7
Blessed group of schools 49 16.4
Saint Louis Grammar School 50 16.7
Methodist Grammar School 50 16.7
Community High School 50 16.7
Sex of respondents
Male 96 32.1
Female 203 67.9
Age of respondents
11 – 14 years 237 82.6
15 – 18 years 50 17.4
Ethnic group of respondents
Yoruba 259 87.2
Igbo 25 8.4
Others 13 4.4
Residence
Far from school 230 77.4
Close to school 67 22.4
Help parents after school
Yes 291 97.7
No 7 2.3
*Valid percent
38
Figure 4.1 detailing respondents type of work after school
39
4.2. Responses to confidence scale
The larger proportion (84.9%) said they were always confident in their ability to prepare for a
test, 75.5% were also confident to learn by themselves. However, 53.8% reported that they were
sometimes afraid to take a test (Details in table 4.2).
The responses on the scale were graded on a scale of 1-10. Scores of 0-5 were graded as ‗not
confident‘ while scores of 6-10 were graded as ‗confident‘. Almost half of the respondents
(45.9%) scored ‗not confident‘ on the scale. The confidence grade was tested for relationships
with selected demographics (details in table 4.3). There was a significant relationship between
secondary school and confidence grade. A logistic regression set at 95% confidence interval
showed that there was a significant relationship between Anglican commercial grammar school
(ACGS) and community high school (CHS, also reference category). Students of ACGS were
approximately eight (8) times more likely than those in CHS to be ‗confident‘. The regression
was not significant for the other schools details in table 4.4).
40
Table 4.2: Responses to confidence scale (tests and examinations)
‗I am confident about my ability to
prepare for a test‘
(N=299)
FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE (%)*
Sometimes 39 13.0
Never 6 2.0
Always 254 84.9
‘Although I have prepared for a
test, I feel afraid just before taking
a test’
(N=299)
Sometimes 161 53.8
Never 111 37.1
Always 27 9.0
‘I feel confident about my ability to
take charge of my own education
and learning’
(N=298)
Sometimes 50 16.8
Never 23 7.7
Always 225 75.5
*Valid percent was used
41
Table 4.3: Confidence grade by selected demographics
N=299
Variables Confidence grade
P value Not confident (%) Confident (%) Total
Secondary School
Anglican Commercial GS*
Ikolaba High School
Blessed groups of schools
Saint Louis Grammar
school
Methodist Grammar school
Community High School
7(14.0)
28(57.1)
27(57.4)
25(51.0)
21(42.0)
27(55.1)
43 (86.0)
21 (42.9)
20(42.6)
24(49.0)
29(58.0)
22(44.9)
50
49
47
49
50
49
X2
= 28.00
P<0.05
Sex of respondents
Male
Female
40(43.0)
95(47.3)
53(57.0)
106(52.7)
93
201
X2
= 0.463
P>0.05
*Anglican Commercial Grammar School 2
42
Table 4.4: Likelihood of confidence grade (tests and exams)
**Reference category
Variables
(N=299)
Odds ratio (95%
CI)
p-value
Secondary school
Anglican Commercial
Ikolaba High School
Blessed group of schools
7.54 (2.84-20.03)
0.92(0.41-2.05)
0.91(0.41-2.04)
p = 0.00
p >0.05
p >0.05
Saint Louis 1.18(0.53-2.61) p >0.05
Methodist Grammar School 1.70(0.77-3.75) p >0.05
Community High School** 0.82
43
4.3 Difficult subjects
There were varied responses as to what subject(s) they found difficult. Topping the list was
French (29.6%) and Mathematics (21.8%), with the most popular reason for difficulty being ‗I
don‘t understand it‘ (38.7%).Details are shown in figure 4.2.
The responses were further grouped into Mathematics, French and others and tested for
association with selected demographic variables. There was a strong association between
secondary school and responses to difficult subjects (details in table 4.5) with French being the
most reported difficult subject (68.0%) in ACGS (11.4% of total) and Mathematics being the
most reported difficult subject (40%) in CHS (10% of total).
44
Figure 4.2: The most reported difficult subjects of the respondents
45
Figure 4.3: Respondents‘ reported reasons for difficulty
46
Table 4.5: Difficult subjects by some selected demographic characteristics
N=299
Variables Difficult subjects
P value Math (%) French (%) Others*(%) Total
Secondary School
Anglican Commercial GS** 2
Ikolaba High School
Blessed groups of schools
Saint Louis Grammar school
Methodist Grammar school
Community High School
4(8.0)
7(14.0)
19(38.8)
4(8.0)
10(20.0)
20(40.0)
34 (68.0)
18 (36.0)
4(8.2)
3(6.0)
28(56.0)
0(0.0)
12(24.0)
25(50)
26(53.1)
43(86.0)
12(24.0)
30(60.0)
50
50
49
50
50
50
X2
= 12.90
P<0.05
Sex of respondents
Male
Female
25(26.0)
39(19.2)
32(33.3)
55(27.1)
39(40.6)
109(53.7)
96
197
X2
= 4.54
p>0.05
Age of respondents
11-14
15-18
53(22.4)
9(18.0)
61(25.7)
24(48.0)
123(51.9)
17(34.0)
237
50
X2=9.98
p>0.05
*Others: Basic science, basic technology, Cultural and creative arts, Civic education, Yoruba,
different combinations of these subjects
**Anglican Commercial Grammar School 2
47
4.4 Responses to scale of activity based on classwork and home work
Regarding their classwork and homework, many (77.4%) said they always submitted promptly,
most (72.9%) asked for help with their assignments when they needed it, and almost all (88.5%)
said they participated in classwork (details in table 4.6). Again, the responses were scored and
graded on a scale of 1-10. Scores of 0-5 were graded as ‗not active‘ while scores of 6-10 were
graded as ‗active‘. There was a significant association between secondary school and class
activity grade (details in table 4.7). Logistic regression revealed a significant relationship
between St. Louis and CHS (reference category) with students in St. Louis being approximately
four (4) times less likely to be active in classwork (details in table 4.8).
48
Table 4.6: Responses to scale on classwork and homework
FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE*
‘Do you submit your assignments on time?’
(N=296)
Sometimes 64 21.6
Never 3 1.0
Always 229 77.4
‘When I need it, I ask for help on my assignments’
(N=295)
Sometimes 215 72.9
Never 18 6.1
Always 62 21.0
‘I participate in classwork’
(N=296)
Sometimes 32 10.8
Never 2 0.7
Always 262 88.5
‘I answer questions in class’
(N=294)
Sometimes 191 65.0
Never 1 0.3
Always 102 34.7
‘I understand my teacher’s language’
(N=296)
Sometimes 80 27.0
Never 2 0.7
Always 214 72.3
*Valid percent
49
Table 4.7: Class activity grade by selected demographics
N=299
Variables Class activity grade
P value Not active (%) Active (%) Total
Secondary School
Anglican Commercial GS*
Ikolaba High School
Blessed groups of schools
Saint Louis Grammar
school
Methodist Grammar school
Community High School
6(12.0)
15(31.2)
5(11.1)
29(58.0)
18(36.0)
12(24.0)
44(88.0)
33(68.8)
40(88.9)
21(42.0)
32(64.0)
38(76.0)
50
48
45
50
50
50
X2
= 36.35
P<0.05
Sex of respondents
Male
Female
21(22.3)
64(32.2)
73(77.7)
135(67.8)
94
199
X2
= 2.99
P>0.05
*Anglican Commercial Grammar School 2
50
Table 4.8: Likelihood of activity grade in classwork
**Reference category
Variables
(N=299)
Odds ratio (95%
CI)
p-value
Secondary school
Anglican Commercial
Ikolaba High School
Blessed group of schools
2.32(0.80-6.77)
0.70(0.29-1.69)
2.53(0.81-7.85)
p >0.05
p >0.05
p >0.05
Saint Louis 0.23(0.10-0.53) p =0.01
Methodist Grammar School 0.56(0.24-1.33) p >0.05
Community High School** 3.17
51
4.5 Meeting a counselor for help with school work
Most (82%) of the respondents affirmed that their school had a guidance counselor. When asked
who they met when they had school problems, about half (42.6%) of them reported that they met
family or friends, another 42.6% said they met their teacher while only few of the respondents
(8.1%) met the counselor when they needed help with school work (details in figure 4.4).When
asked specifically if they met their school counselor for help, most of them (61.9%) said no. The
minority (38.1%) said yes.
Selected demographic variables were tested for association with ‗meeting a counselor for help‘.
Significant associations were found with secondary school and sex of respondents (see table 4.9).
Males were approximately three (3) times less likely than females to meet a counselor for help.
All schools showed significant association with meeting a counselor for help. CHS was used as
the reference category; all other schools were more likely to meet a counselor for help. Ikolaba
High School was the most likely school than CHS with an odds ratio of 44 (details in table 4.10).
52
N=284
Figure 4.4 Responses to who respondents met when they had problems with school work
53
N=295
Figure 4.5: Proportion of respondents‘ that said they had a school counselor
54
N=291
Figure 4.6: Proportion of respondents that met their school counselor for help
55
Table 4.9: Meeting counselor for help by some selected demographic characteristics
Variables Meeting counselor for help
P value Yes (%) No (%) Total
Age (in years)
11-14
15-18
79 (34.3)
23 (46.0)
151 (65.7)
27 (54.0)
230
50
X2
=
2.40
P>0.05
Secondary School
Anglican Commercial GS* 2
Ikolaba High School
Blessed groups of schools
Saint Louis Grammar school
Methodist Grammar school
21(42.0)
4 (8.3)
17(37.0)
6(12.2)
23(47.9)
29 (58.0)
44 (91.7)
29 (63.0)
43(87.8)
25(52.1)
50
48
46
49
48
X2
=
71.42
P<0.05
Community High School 40(80.0) 10(20.0) 50
Sex of respondents
Male
Female
52(55.3)
59(29.9)
42(44.7)
138 (70.1)
94
197
X2
=
17.36
P<0.05
*Anglican Commercial Grammar School 2
56
Table 4.10: Likelihood of meeting a counselor for help
Variables (N=299) Odds ratio (95% CI) p-value
Secondary School
Anglican Commercial 5.52 (2.26-13.48) P = 0.00
Ikolaba High School 44.0(12.78-151.45) P = 0.00
Blessed group of schools 6.82(2.71-17.15) P = 0.00
Saint Louis 28.67(9.54-86.11) P = 0.00
Methodist Grammar School 4.35(1.78-10.64) P = 0.01
Community High School** 0.25
Sex
Male 0.35(0.21-0.57) P <0.00 Female** 2.339
**Reference category
57
4.6 Help topics
Among the listed help topics supplied in the questionnaire, many of the respondents indicated
they needed help with improving scores (56.5% and study skills (68.4%).Details are shown in
figure 4.7.
58
N=299
Figure4.7: Respondents indication of topics where they needed guidance and counseling
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Improving scoresTaking notes Taking tests Study skillsAsking counselor for helpTime management
Yes
No
59
CHAPTER FIVE
DISCUSSION, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Socio-demographic characteristics and related information
Most of the respondents (86.6%) were Yoruba. This is expected because the study area, Ibadan
North Local Government, Ibadan, in Oyo state is native to the Yoruba people. The State which is
homogeneous has a population of about 4.5million and predominantly occupied by Yoruba
people. Within the State however, there are sub-ethnic groups with distinct dialect peculiarities.
The people of Oyo State may be divided into five broad groups which are: Ibadans, Ibarapas,
Oyos, Oke-Oguns and Ogbomosos (―The Official Website of the Oyo State Government‖ 2013).
Majority of the respondents (67.9%) were female and 32.1% were male. According to United
Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) Institute for Statistics, the
value for School enrollment, secondary, female (% gross) in Nigeria was 41.21 as of 2010 and
The value for School enrollment, secondary, male (% gross) in Nigeria was 46.78 as of
2010.This implies a higher enrolment rate of males in secondary schools. However, the larger
proportion of females in this study could be explained by the fact that one of the selected schools
was an all girls‘ school; this increased the percentage of females by 16.7%. The mean age was
13.3± 1.3 years, ranging from 11-18 years. This is in line with the average age of middle school
or junior high (Encarta, 2008). Almost all the respondents‘ (84.3%) belonged to nuclear
families, many (76.9%) reported that they lived far from school, 56.9% of the respondents‘ said
they did domestic work after school. This is very typical of the Nigerian culture. Only very few
(5.6%) reported doing school work after school, this will have implications on academic
performance.
5.2 Responses to confidence scale on tests and examinations
The larger proportion (84.9%) said they were always confident in their ability to prepare for a
test, 75.5% were also confident to learn by themselves. However, 53.8% reported that they were
sometimes afraid to take a test. Almost half of the respondents (45.9%) scored ‗not confident‘ on
60
the scale. High confidence level of the students is a predisposition to good performance in tests
and examinations, however, school counselors need to address the fear of tests in the students as
this can lead to poor performance and examination malpractice (SCS, 2012; Adeboye, 1998).
The study did not find a significant association for sex and confidence level (this may be due to a
higher percentage of female respondents), but it found a significant association between school
and confidence grade. This was interesting especially because the schools all had similar
physical characteristics. The difference may lie in the quality of the teaching methods or
teaching-learning environment provided by the teachers. The binary logistic regression analysis
was significant for only one of the schools with the reference category. The school was eight (8)
times more likely than the reference category to have a higher confidence grade.
5.3 Difficult subjects
The most reported difficult subjects were French (29.6%) and Mathematics (21.8%). It was not
surprising that mathematics would be popularly reported because there is still poor performance
in the subject (NECO, 2003). However, it was surprising that French would top the list. French
language, initially offered as an elective is now being offered in the certificate examinations. If it
is going to become compulsory, it is important for school counselors to liaise with the French
and mathematics teachers to reduce the difficulty to students.
Again, there was a strong association between secondary school and responses to difficult
subjects with French being the most reported difficult subject (68.0%) in one school (11.4% of
total) and Mathematics being the most reported difficult subject (40%) in another school (10% of
total).This show‘s that the different schools surveyed have inherent strengths and weaknesses
unique to them. Further investigation is needed to find out why and leverage on the strengths, so
they can be spread across board.
5.4 Responses to scale of activity based on classwork and homework
Only few (29%) scored low on the activity scale. The majority (71%) were active in classwork.
Once more, there was a significant association between secondary school and class activity grade
Logistic regression revealed a significant relationship between one of the schools and the
reference category, with students in that school being four (4) times less likely to be active in
classwork than the reference category. It is important for the school counselor to encourage
61
students participation in classwork as this predicts performance (Javaria, Nazia, and Sadaf
(2008); Bordbar (2010).
5.5 Meeting a counselor for help with school work
When asked specifically if they met their school counselor for help, most of them (61.9%) said
no. The minority (38.1%) said yes. When asked who they met when they had school problems,
about half (42.6%) of them reported that they met family or friends, another 42.6% said they met
their teacher while only few of the respondents (8.1%) reported that they met the counselor when
they needed help with school work. Attitudes towards counselors might be responsible for the
low utilization of the counselors‘ services. This finding supports studies by Nyamwange (2012)
and Kombo (1998). Significant associations were found with secondary school and sex of
respondents. Males were approximately three (3) times less likely than females to meet a
counselor for help. This agrees with Van Der Riet (2004), who said that social gender construct
makes males less likely to seek for help with their problems. All schools showed significant
association with meeting a counselor for help. Students in all other schools were more likely to
meet the school counselor than the reference category school.
5.6 Help topics of interest to the respondents
The questionnaire listed the following topics:
improving my scores
Taking notes
Taking tests
Study skills (preparing for tests, assignments and examinations)
How to ask my school counselor for help
Time management (between school, extracurricular, leisure, family, friends)
Among the listed help topics supplied in the questionnaire, many of the respondents indicated
they needed help with improving scores (56.5%) and study skills (68.4%).The identified topics
are evidence that there has not been adequate educational services available to the students.
These needs can adequately be met by a qualified school counselor.
62
Implication for educational counseling in Ibadan north local government
There is still low utilization of educational services, as found by Nyamwange (2012) in contrast
to the positive attitude to school counseling in Cross River state (Eyo,et al.,2010). There is need
for school counselors to plan interventions to increase the uptake of counseling services.
Students are still sometimes afraid to take tests. This could be a potential threat to peak
performance of the students in tests and examinations.
The study found that Schools have significant associations with confidence level, participation
level and likelihood to meet a counselor for help with school problems. All schools are indirectly
and directly conditioned by the teaching approaches employed by the teachers. School
counselors should take advantage of the schools as good environments for interventions.
Some topics have been identified by students in the surveyed schools. More training is needed
for the current school counselors. There is also need for more school authorities to pay more
attention to the school counseling units in schools.
63
Conclusion
The study surveyed junior secondary three (JSS3) students in Ibadan north local government area
to find out their educational counseling needs. The questionnaires were equally distributed across
six (6) randomly selected schools. Most of the students had a good confidence grade in test and
examinations, however, most of them still reported being sometimes afraid to take a test.
Significant associations were found for secondary school and confidence grade; activity grade
and meeting a counselor for help.
The most reported difficult subject was French language, followed by Mathematics. Majority of
the respondents also had a good class activity grade.
Even though majority of the respondents were aware that they had a school counselor, very few
of them met the counselor when they had problems with school work.
‗Improving scores‘ and ‗study skills‘ were the topics most of the respondents identified for help.
The study found that there is need for counselors in Ibadan north local government area to plan
interventions to both increase students‘ utilization of school counseling services and address the
difficulties the students are encountering.
Recommendations
1.) There is need for collaborative effort by school counselors and the local inspectorate of
education, Ibadan north local government to plan and implement interventions to increase
students uptake of counseling services
2.) There is need for experience sharing among the school counselors in Ibadan North local
government.
3.) More commitment and support from all stakeholders involved in education in Ibadan
north local government. This should be in the form of basic counseling amenities and
more counselors trained and posted to schools.
4.) In-service training for school counselors is highly recommended.
64
Suggestions for further study
1) A qualitative study to determine why only less than half of the study population met their
school counselor for help with school work
2) An In- depth study to ascertain what factors are responsible for increased likelihood of
confidence, class activity and meeting the school counselor for help.
65
REFERENCES
Adegboye, A. (1998). Examination malpractices in Nigerian tertiary institutions:Problems and
solutions. mA. Adegboye, 0. Olutoye, & B.O. Adetunberu (Eds.), Issues on examination
malpractices in Nigeria: A book of readings (pp. 54-6 1). Ikere-Ekiti: Ondo State College
of Education, Ikere-Ekiti.
Adegoke, A.A.(2004).Counselling Curriculum for Schools in Nigeria. A publication of the
Counselling Association of Nigeria. Ilorin Goshen Print Media Ltd,Ilorin.
Aghenta, J. A. (1998). Teacher recruitment and retention. In N. A. Nwagwu (ed.), Teachers and
teaching in Nigeria: Issues, challenges and prospects (pp. 44-58). Benin: The Nigerian
Academy of Education Yearbook No. 2.
Akinboye, J. O. (1987). Guidance and Counselling Strategies for Handling Adolescent
Alutu ,A.N.G & Etibhio C.(2006).Need to Introduce Classroom Guidance and couselling in the
Secondary School Curriculum in Nigeria, Paper accepted for Publication in Guidance and
Counselling, Canada. Youth Problems. Ibadan: University press.
Alutu,A.N. (2007). The status of Guidance Services in Secondary schools in Edo State. Nigerian
Journal of Guidance and Counseling 10 (1) 94-103.
American School Counselor Association. (1997). The Role of the professional school
Counsellor.Alexandria,VA.
Anorue, C. (2004) Patterns of Teacher Student Interaction in Social Studies in Imo State
Secondary School.Education Dissertation University of Port Harcourt.
Atkins, A & Brown. (2001) Sinclair & Couthard’s “IRF” model in one- to one classroom: An
Analysis. http://www.birmingham.uk/Documents/college_artslaw/cels/essays/csdpPatakin.pdf
Bordbar, F. (2010). English teachers‘ attitude toward computer-assisted language instruction.
International Journal of Language Studies, 4(3), 27-54.
Cherishe, R. (2011). School Counsellors‘ and Students‘ Perceptions of the Benefits of
School Guidance and Counselling Services in Zimbabwean Secondary Schools J Soc Sci,
29(2): 101-108.
Dees,J.(2010) How to get Students Participate in Class Discussion.
www.therereligionteacher.com/how-to-g…
66
Egbule, J. F. (2006). Guidance services In O. C. Okobiah and R. I. Okorodudu (editors) Issues,
concepts, theories and techniques of guidance and counselling Benin-City: Ethiope
Publishers, 76 – 110.
Embassy, U.S. 2013. ―Nigerian Education Profile.‖
Http://nigeria.usembassy.gov/nigeria_education_profile.html. March 27.
http://nigeria.usembassy.gov/nigeria_educatio_profile.html.
Eyo,M.B, Joshua,A.M, Esuong, A.E. (2010) Attitude of Secondary School Students towards
Guidance and Counseling Services in Cross River State. Edo journal of counseling, 1(3)
Fair, T.N., Evaluation of Counselling Services. Accountability in A Rural Elementary
School, Journal of Elementary School Guidance and Counselling. Vol. 29, N°1, Oct.
1994.
Fakeye,D.O., Amao A.T., (2013). Cross-Cultural Communication, 9 (3), 18-25
Federal Republic of Nigeria, (1998) National Policy on Education. NERDC,Lagos.
FME, Im (1988) Guidelines for Implementation of the 6-3-3-4 Education System.
Fasunle Nig. Co. Ltd., Lagos.
Federal Republic of Nigeria (2004). National Policy on Education. Lagos Federal
Ministry of Information, Printing Division.
Guide for Victorian Government Schools. Current as of 30 May 2012
Gysbers, N. C. (2001). School Guidance and Counseling in the 21st Century: Remember the Past
into the Future. Professional School Counseling, 5(2), 96. Retrieved from EBSCOhost.
Ipage, B. (1983). Guidance and Counseling Practices Ill-Ife University of Ife Press.
Javaria, R. Nazia, M., & Sadaf, N. (2008). Identifying factors affecting students’ participation in
the classroom. (Unpublished Master dissertation). University of Sargodha, Sargodha:
Kombo, K. D. & Tromp, D. L. A (2006) Proposal and Thesis Writing: An Introduction. Nairobi:
Paulines Publications Africa.
Lathrop, A (2006) Teaching how to Question: Participation Rubrics. www.facultyfocus.com.
67
Makinde, O. 1988. Fundamentals of Guidance and Counseling. MacMillan.
http://books.google.com.ng/books?id=BAVjAAAACAAJ.
Mapfumo, J., & Nkoma, E. (2013). The State of Guidance and Counselling Programmes in
High Schools in Manicaland, Zimbabwe. International Journal of Scientific Research in
Education, 6(2), 100-116. Retrieved [DATE] from http://www.ijsre.com
Microsoft® Encarta® 2009.©1993-2008 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Mpofu E, Thomas KR, Chan F 2004. Social competence in Zimbabwean multicultural schools:
Effects of ethnic and gender differences. International Journal of Psychology, 39: 169-
8.
Muro, J. J. & Kottman, T. (1995). Guidance and Counseling in the Elementary and Middle
Schools: A Practical Approach. WCB Brown & Benchmark Publishers: Madison WI.
NERDC (2003) National Family Life and HIV Education Curriculum for lower
Primary, Upper Primary, Junior Secondary and Senior Secondary Schools, in Nigeria.
Lagos: NERDC Press.
Nigeria - Secondary Education - Students, School, Schools, and Government -
stateUniversity.com http://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1104/Nigeria-SECONDARY-
EDUCATION.html#ixzz2nuu4mCAy
Nwaokolo, C. (2006). Appraisal of the Implementation off Guidance and Counseling Services at
the Post-Primary level. Paper presented at the 2006 Annual Conference of Education.
Nyamwange C.B.,Nyakan P. C.,Ondima P.C. (2012). Assessment of Challenges facing
Secondary School Guidance and Counselling Teachers in Nyamira District, Kenya.
Journal of Education and Practice (3)16, 41-47.
Okobiah, O. C. and Okorodudu, R. I. (2006). Concepts of guidance and counselling. In O. C.
Okobiah and R. I.Okorodudu (editors) Issues concepts, theories and techniques of
guidance and counselling Benin-City:Ethiope publishers, 24 – 54.
68
Oladunni, M.0. (1995).Examination ma/practices in tertiary institutions: Undo State College of
Education, Ikere- Ekiti experience. A paper presented at the in-house Seminar on
examination malpractices held at the Ondo State College of Education, Ikere-Ekiti (Jan.
‗26-27,1995).
Olaseinde, A.O. (1993). Cheating in examinations in the University of Ilorin: Styles, causes and
remedies.Nigerian Journal of Educational Foundations, 4, (1)
Olayinka, M.S (1985). Organizing the Guidance Services in Secondary Schools System.
Nigerian Journal of Counseling and Development, Vol. 1 No 2, Pg 1-3.
Olayinka, M. S. (1999). Guidance and counselling for Nigerian schools. Lagos: Lantem books.
Oranu,P.C., and Onwioduokit F.A (2012). Relative Effectiveness of Classroom Interaction
Techniques on Students‘ Participation in Rivers State, Nigeria. Journal of education and
social research. 2 (10) 81-88.
Oye N.D.,Obi M.C, Mohd T.N, Bernice,A.(2012) Guidance and Counseling in Nigerian
Secondary Schools: The Role of ICT I.J. Modern Education and Computer Science,
2012, 8, 26-33.
Roe, A. (2012) Over programming Leads to Poor Student Participation.
Sylvanus,O.U., Okechukwu, S.A. (2013). Predictive Validity of NECO Junior School Certificate
Examination on Students‘ Achievement in NECO Senior School Certificate Examination
http://stanonline.org/journal/pdf/JSTAN-Sylvanus&Okechukwu%202013.pdf
―The Official Website of the Oyo State Government.‖2013. Accessed December 3.
http://www.oyostate.gov.ng.
UNESCO (1991). World education report. Paris: UNESCO Statistical records. Lagos: WAEC
Office.
UNESCO (2000a). Guidance (Module I). Fr
United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) Institute for
Statistics.(―Nigeria-Secondary Education- Gross Enrolment Ratio- World Data
69
Atlas.‖2013.Knoema. Accessed December 9.
http://knoema.com/atlas/Nigeria/topics/Education/Gross-enrolment-ratio
Van der Riet M, Knoetze J 2004. Help seeking patterns in urban and rural youth in two South
African provinces: A socio-contextual view. School Psychology International,25(2): 223-
Weimer,M (2005) Putting Participation Puzzle together. www.facultyfocus.com. Magna
Publications, Inc 2718Dryden Drive Madison Wisconsin 53704 USA.
www.magnapus.com
http://www.examsguru.net/junior-school-certificate-examination-jsce/#sthash.3Dhb2RRh.dpuf
http://www.srg.dk
http://www.anahs.org/
APPENDIX I
STUDENT EDUCATIONAL NEEDS SURVEY
JUNIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL THREE (JSS3) STUDENTS
A) Demographic questions (please tick √ which applies to you)
70
1 Please tick your
gender
Male
Female
2 How old are you? …………………………….. years
3 Please circle your
language
Yoruba
Hausa
Igbo
Other………..
4 Type of family
Nuclear Extended Polygamous Others………
5 Where do you live?
Far from
school
Close to
school
6 Do you help your
parents to work after
School?
Yes No
7 What type of work do you do?
B) Tests and examinations
Directions: Please tick √ your answers to the questions according to the scale provided.
Never Sometimes Always
8 I am confident about my ability
to prepare for a test
9 Although I have prepared for a
test, I feel afraid just before
taking a test
10 I am involved in too many
activities to prepare for tests
11 I feel confident about my ability
to take charge of my own
education and learning
12 I depend on my friend to help
me during my tests and
examinations
71
C. Classwork and homework
13. What subjects do you find very difficult to learn?
………………………………………………..
14. What makes it difficult?
…………………………………………………………………………………………
Never Sometimes Always
15 Do you submit your
assignments on time?
16 When I need it, I ask for help
on my assignments
17 I participate in classwork
18 I answer questions in class
19 I understand my teacher‘s
language
D) Expectations for the school guidance counselor
20. Who do you meet when you have problems with school work? …………………
21. Do you have a school guidance counselor? Yes ( ) No ( )
22. Do you meet the school guidance counselor for help? Yes ( ) No ( )
23. Tick the topics of most interest to you.
I need help with:
improving my scores
Taking notes
72
Taking tests
Study skills (preparing for tests, assignments and examinations)
rricular, leisure, family, friends)
No help needed in the above areas
THANK YOU FOR PARTICIPATING
APPENDIX II: Scoring guide for scales
Confidence/Participation
scale
Never Sometimes Always
1 Scale Item 1 0 2
73
2 Scale Item 1 0 2
3 Scale Item 1 0 2
4 Scale Item 1 0 2
5 Scale Item 1 0 2
Total 5 0 10
The highest score was 2 and the lowest 0. The Item totaled 10 points.
Scores of 0-5= Poor, scores of 6-10= Good
74
APPENDIX III: Letter of Introduction