8
Henry H Rowshan, DDS, * Mary A. Parham, DVM, t Dale A. Baur, DDS, MD,! RaeLynn D. McEntee, BBA,.f Eugene Cauley, fI Dane T Carriere, IIJoseph C Wood, PhD, MD,# William J Demsar, DMD, MS, ** Jose M Pizarro, MS, PhDtt Effect of Intermittent Systemic Administration of Recombinant Parathyroid Hormone (1-34) on Mandibular Fracture Healing in Rats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short- and long-term effects of recombinant parathyroid hormone (PTH 1-34) on mandibular fracture healing in rats. Materials and Methods: A controlled unilateral mandibular fracture was created surgically in 29 male Sprague-Dawley rats and then stabilized using an external fixation device. The rats were divided into 2 groups: 1 group received daily subcutaneous injections of 10 JLg/kg of PTH(l-34) and 1 group served as the vehicle controL The rats were killed on postoperative days 7 and 21, and radiographic densitometry and histologic evaluation of new bone formation were performed. Results: A novel unilateral mandibular fracture model was established that has significant differences from preViously published models, both in the location of the osteotomy site and in the rigid external stabilization device. The PTH(l-34) treated rats showed a statistically significant difference (P < .05) in callous formation compared with the control animals. Radiographic densitometry evaluation of the injury site revealed an increase in bone denSity, apparent at day 7 in the experimental group. Visual inspection of the histologic sections stained with Masson's trichrome blue showed an apparent increase in new bone formation at 21 days in the PTH·treated group compared with the control group. Conclusions: Intermittent systemic administration of PTH(l-34) might enhance the healing of mandibular fractures in the early phase (7-day period). Long-term administration (21-day period) showed no statistically significant differences between the control and experimental group by radiographic densitometry. © 2010 American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons ] Oral Maxillofac Surg 68:260-267, 2010 "'Chief of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Department of Oral and MaxillofJcial Surgery, Dwight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon, GA. ttOfficer in Charge, Department of Clinical Investigation, DWight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon, GA. This research was supported by internal funding from Southeast Regional Dental Command and Dental Activity and Dwight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center. The views of the authors do not purport to reflect the position of the Depanment of the Anny or Department of Defense (paragraph 4-3), AR 360-5. Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr Bam: De- partment of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Case Western Reserve Ulliversity!Univcrsiry Hospitals, 212; Abington Olive, Cleveland, OH .+4106-490-;: e-mail: [email protected] 't' 2010 Amcric.on A'$'Xlotion of Oral ond .'\tIlJxillcfocio: Surge )ns -' 0278·2391'10/6802{)()()5$36 00/0 doi: lO.1016/j.lom:;2009.09,045 260 :j::Assodate Professor and Chair, Department of Oral and Maxillo- facial Surge!)', Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland. OH. §Research SpecialisL Department of Clinical Investigation, Dwight David Eisenhower Anny Medical Center, Fon Gordon, GA. Animal Technician, Department of Clinic;\l Investi- gation, D",.·ight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center. Fort Gor- don, GA. IIResearch Specialist. Depanment of Clinical Investigation, Dwight David Eisenhower ArnlY Medical Center. Fon Gordon, GA. #Chief, Department of Clinical Investigation, DWight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center. Fort Gordon. GA. *Formerly, Chief ReSident, Department of Droll and Maxillofacial Surgery, Dwight David Eisenhower Ann)' Medical Center, Fon Gordon, GA; and Currently, Chief, Oral and Maxillofacial Surge!)', Ft Irwin, CA. tChief of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Clinical Investiga- tion, Dwight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon, GA.

Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

Henry H Rowshan, DDS, * Mary A. Parham, DVM, t

Dale A. Baur, DDS, MD,! RaeLynn D. McEntee, BBA,.f

Eugene Cauley, fI Dane T Carriere, IIJoseph C Wood, PhD, MD,#

William J Demsar, DMD, MS, **Jose M Pizarro, MS, PhDtt

Effect of Intermittent SystemicAdministration of RecombinantParathyroid Hormone (1-34) on

Mandibular Fracture Healing in Rats

Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short- and long-term effectsof recombinant parathyroid hormone (PTH 1-34) on mandibular fracture healing in rats.

Materials and Methods: A controlled unilateral mandibular fracture was created surgically in 29 maleSprague-Dawley rats and then stabilized using an external fixation device. The rats were divided into 2groups: 1 group received daily subcutaneous injections of 10 JLg/kg of PTH(l-34) and 1 group served asthe vehicle controL The rats were killed on postoperative days 7 and 21, and radiographic densitometryand histologic evaluation of new bone formation were performed.

Results: A novel unilateral mandibular fracture model was established that has significant differencesfrom preViously published models, both in the location of the osteotomy site and in the rigid externalstabilization device. The PTH(l-34) treated rats showed a statistically significant difference (P < .05) incallous formation compared with the control animals. Radiographic densitometry evaluation of the injurysite revealed an increase in bone denSity, apparent at day 7 in the experimental group. Visual inspectionof the histologic sections stained with Masson's trichrome blue showed an apparent increase in newbone formation at 21 days in the PTH·treated group compared with the control group.

Conclusions: Intermittent systemic administration of PTH(l-34) might enhance the healing of mandibularfractures in the early phase (7-day period). Long-term administration (21-day period) showed no statisticallysignificant differences between the control and experimental group by radiographic densitometry.© 2010 American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons] Oral Maxillofac Surg 68:260-267, 2010

"'Chief of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Department of Oral

and MaxillofJcial Surgery, Dwight David Eisenhower Army Medical

Center, Fort Gordon, GA.

ttOfficer in Charge, Department of Clinical Investigation,

DWight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon, GA.

This research was supported by internal funding from Southeast

Regional Dental Command and Dental Activity and Dwight David

Eisenhower Army Medical Center. The views of the authors do not

purport to reflect the position of the Depanment of the Anny or

Department of Defense (paragraph 4-3), AR 360-5.

Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr Bam: De­

partment of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Case Western Reserve

Ulliversity!Univcrsiry Hospitals, 212; Abington Olive, Cleveland,

OH .+4106-490-;: e-mail: [email protected]

't' 2010 Amcric.on A'$'Xlotion of Oral ond .'\tIlJxillcfocio: Surge )ns

-' 0278·2391'10/6802{)()()5$36 00/0

doi: lO.1016/j.lom:;2009.09,045

260

:j::Assodate Professor and Chair, Department of Oral and Maxillo­

facial Surge!)', Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland. OH.

§Research SpecialisL Department of Clinical Investigation,

Dwight David Eisenhower Anny Medical Center, Fon Gordon, GA.

llRq~istered Animal Technician, Department of Clinic;\l Investi­

gation, D",.·ight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center. Fort Gor­

don, GA.

IIResearch Specialist. Depanment of Clinical Investigation,

Dwight David Eisenhower ArnlY Medical Center. Fon Gordon, GA.

#Chief, Department of Clinical Investigation, DWight David

Eisenhower Army Medical Center. Fort Gordon. GA.

*Formerly, Chief ReSident, Department of Droll and Maxillofacial

Surgery, Dwight David Eisenhower Ann)' Medical Center, Fon

Gordon, GA; and Currently, Chief, Oral and Maxillofacial Surge!)',

Ft Irwin, CA.

tChief of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Clinical Investiga­

tion, Dwight David Eisenhower Army Medical Center, Fort Gordon,

GA.

Page 2: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

ROWSHAN ET AL

The mandible is rhe second most frequently fracturedcomponent of the facial skeleton. Hippocrates de­scribed the practice of bandaging fractures to stabilizebone segments to allow healing. I Twentieth centuryadvanced technology allowed surgeons to combinethe principles of immobilization first described byHippocrates with surgical placement of plates andscrews to treat a variety of mandible fractures. Animalmodels continue to aid in the clinical study of facialskeleton fractures. Many unilateral mandibular osteot­omy models found in published studies involve per·forming the mandibular osteotomy immediately ante­rior to the first molar, immediately posterior to thelast molar, or between the second and third molars.l-~

Novel models using alternative locations are neededbecause of the high risk of damage to the tooth rootsand the subsequent increase in oral contamination.Other published techniques have involved a critical­size defect, '5 which did not achieve the presentstudy's goal of simulating a displaced mandibular frac­ture requiring stabilization. Surgically created mandib·ular fractures that underwent distraction osteogenesishave been reported,<,·7 as have models in which noform of stabilization was used. A

•9 We used an osteot­

omy model that completely transects the ramus fromthe sigmoid notch through the inferior border of themandible, followed by repair with a rigid fixationdevice that is secured by 2 screws on each side of theosteotomy site.

The treatment of the mandible fracture ranges frommaxiUomandibular fixation to open reduction withinternal fixation. Fracture healing is a complex andsequential process, regulated by multiple inflamma­tory, growth, and hormonal factors. 10-13 Currently, nopharmacologic adjuncts are available to enhance thehealing of mandibular fracnlres. In published ortho­pedic studies, systemic administration of parathyroidhormone (PTH) has demonstrated enhancement ofhealing in an extremity fracture model using rats I4

.1'5;

however, it should not be assumed that these resultswill apply to mandibular fractures, because the man­dible differs significantly from long bones in terms ofdevelopment and force load. The mandible, similar tothe flat bones of the skull, develops primarilythrough the process of intramembranous ossifica·tion. In contrast, long bones develop by endochon­dral ossification. In addition, although the mandibleand long bones are subjected to the 3 differenttypes of strain (ie, compression, tension, andshear), the predominant force acting on the mandi­ble during physiologic movement is shear, but thelong bones, particularly the femur and tibia (thebones evaluated by most of the studies to date), areprimarily subjected to compression forces. 1(,.17

PTH is an essential regulator of calcium and phos­phate metabolism 1'5 bur has also been shown to have

261

anabolic and catabolic effeps on the skeleton. 18 Inrecent years, PTH has been approved for the treat·ment of osteoporosis, and its anabolic effect has beenstudied in clinical trials. Although recent studies onthe use of recombinant PTH (PTIl 1-34) have demon­strated a significant increase in bone denSity and areduction in skeletal fractures in postmenopausalwomen,19 it is not currently prescribed for fracturerepair. From the available data, reason exists to sus­pect its possible value in such areas. Current researchhas indicated that PTH enhances both caIlus forma­tion and remodeling by stimulating the proliferationof osteoprogenitor cells, synthesis of bone matrixproteins, and osreoclastogenesis.1 4 In 1932, Selye de·termined that once-daily administration of PTH had ananabolic effect on the bones of rats, but larger dosesresulted in bone resorption. .It has since been shownthat intermittent administration increases bone depo­sition but that continuous administration actually de­creases bone mass. This is likely a result of the differ­ence in effects of intermittent versus continuousinfusion of PTH on osteogenesis and osteoclastic ac­tivity. Bone deposition occurs with both forms ofadministration; however, with continuous infusion,bone resorption offsets deposition,'l° Dobnig andTurner21 reported that intermittent administration ofPTH increased osteoblast numbers and activity, appar­ently owing to the activation of resting bone liningceUs to become osteoblasts. In vitro studies haveshown that transient exposure of osteoblasts to PTHstimulates their synthesis of collagen type I but thatcontinuous exposure inhibits its production. 22

.l3

Intermittent PTH also postpones osteoblast apopto­sis24 but has no effect on osteoclast numbers.2"i Incontrast, sustained elevation had no effect on os­teoblast apoptosis and actually increased osteoclastnumbers. 26 PTH also affects cortical and cancellousbone differently. It has a greater anabolic effect oncancellous bone than on cortical bone. 27 Variousstudies have indicated a greater effect on bonecontaining primarily red marrow compared withbone containing yellow marrow. 16 Intermittenttreatment with PTH has been shown to increasecallus formation and mechanical strength in exper­imental fracture healing. 1.f.UU8 A daily dose of 200J.Lg/kg was more effective in enhancing callus for­mation and mechanical strength than a dose of 60J.Lg/kg in rat tibial fractures. 2R Howeyer, irs efficacy,and optimal dosing in treating fractures of the man­dible has not been researched. We developed awell-controlled mandible fracture model in rats andexamined the hypothesis that daily systemic admin·istration of PTH(l-34) could enhance mandibularfracture healing.

Page 3: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

FIGURE 1. Open surgical creation of mandibular fracture that was then stabilized using external fixation device. A.B, Vertical platessurgically placed on mandible. C, Vertical osteotomy was created using sagittal saw. 0, Placement of insulin syringe barrE!l and impressionmaterial filling for plate stabilization (block arrow indicates osteotomy site). E, Wound closed, leaving external fixator device extendingbeyond incision.

ROlI's!:Jrll/ (If al. EJJects oj PTH /)1/ Malldil;ular Fracture HealiJlg. J Oral Maxil/oJae SIII,& 20 W.

262

Materials and Methods

SUBJECTS AND HOUSING

A total of 29 adult male Sprague-Dawley rats(weight 550 to 600 g) were pair-housed until surgerywith food (standard rat chow) and water ad libitum.The rats were kept on a 12-hour light/dark cycle(lights on from 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM). The InstitutionalAnimal Care and Use Committee reviewed and ap­proved all procedures. Research was conducted incompliance with the Animal Welfare Act and otherfederal statutes and regulations relating to animals andexperiments and adhered to principles stated in theGuide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals,NRC Publication, edition 1996. Of the 29 rats, ISwere randomly assigned to the experimental group,receiving PTH injections, and 14 rats were assigned tothe control group.

PREPARATION AND ADMINISTRATION OF PTH

PTIi fragment 1-34 (Sigma Chemical, St Louis, MO)was suspended in 1% acidic acid and sterile water anddiluted accordingly to create a ID-/LglmL solution,follOWing the manufacturer's guidelines. The ratswere weighed and injected with 10 /Lglkg of PTIisubcutaneously once daily from the day of surgeryuntil death. The control group received no injections.

EFFECfS OF PTH ON MANDIBULAR FRACfURE HEALING

SURGICAL PROCEDURE

The rats were premedicated with subcutaneousbuprenorphine (0.02 to 0.04 mglkg), and then anes­thesia was induced with a mixture of ketamine (80mglkg) and xylazine (4 mglkg), administered intra­peritoneally. Anesthesia was maintained with 1% to2% isoflurane in oxygen administered by way of anose cone. No antibiotics were given to any ratsbefore surgery. The rats were placed in a supineposition under a surgical microscope (Carl Zeiss, Ber­lin, Germany). A 1· to 1. 5-cm incision was made alongthe inferior border of the right mandible. Sharp dis­section was carried down to the periosteum throughthe body of the masseter muscle. Subperiosteal dis­section w~s conducted in a superior and Iateml direc·tion to expose the sigmoid notch and posterior bor­der of the mandible. Two 5.0-hole plates (OsteoMed,Addison, TX), were placed parallel to the osteotomy,one anterior and one posterior to the sigmoid notch,approximately 4 to 5 mm apan. The plates weresecured with 4, ;-mm·long, 1.8 mm diameter screws,and positioned such that the plates extended throughthe incision. Using a sagittal saw, a vertical osteotomywas created from the sigmoid notch to the inferiorborder of the mandible. The proximal and distal endsof the fractured mandible were then reapproximated

Page 4: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

ROWSHAN IT AL

using the previously secured plates and held in posi­tion. A small portion of the barrel of an insulin syringewas split longitudinally along one side. positionedwith the ends of the 2 plates inserted into the barrelthrough the split, and filled with Fast Set (BlueMousse-Impression Material Parkell, Farmingdale, NY)

[0 provide rigid external fixation. The mandible wasthen manipulated to ensure that the 2 segments of theosteotomy were fixated securely (Figs lA-D).

POSTOPERATIVE CARE

The wound was then closed in layers around theprotmding ends of the plates (Fig IE). The rats wereallowed to recover, and buprenorphine at the prean­esthetic dose was administered subcutaneously every8 to 12 hours for 48 hours for postoperative painmanagement. For the remainder of the experiment.the rats were housed separately and fed a soft diet.The rats were divided into 7- and 21-day groups re­ceiving PTH(I-34) injections, as described previously.The rats were sacrificed on day 7 and 21, and themandibles were harvested and divided into the rightand left sides. The hardware was removed, and the

Control

263

riglu mandibles underwent r..ujiographic and histo­logic analysis.

RADIOGRAPHIC DE SITOMETRY ANALYSIS

The right fracture-bearing mandible was radio­graphed, and the digital images were analyzed withImage] (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD)software. The images were inverted to measure dark­ness within the fracnrre site. The entire fracture sitefrom the inferior border of the mandible to the sigmoidnotch was outlined and the measurement obtained.Next, the filling of the fracture site representing callousfonnation was outlined and the measurement obtained.The fracture site measurement and the filling measure­ments were then expressed as a ratio to represent theamount of radiographic callous fonnation witltin thefracture site (Fig 2). All sections were analyzed by 2observers who were unaware of which group was beingmeasured.

HISTOLOGIC PREPARATION AND EXAMINATION

The tissues were fixated in 10% buffered formalinsolution, decalcified using standard procedures, and

PTH(1-34)

7 days

21 days

FIGURE 2. Radiographic images of control at A, 7 days and C, 21 doys and PTH-treated groups 01 B, 7 days and 0, 21 dayspostoperatively. PTH-treoted group showed enhanced bone density 01 7 days followed by a decrease of bone density at 21 days aftersurgery.

RO/l's!:Jall et al. Effects of PTH Oil Jlalldiblllar Fracture Healing J Oral ,11axi!/o/ac Slll:~ .lOlO.

Page 5: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

21

Control

c:=lPTH (10uglkg)

n=6

Days

PTH

•n=7

n=8

EFFECTS OF PTH ON MANDIBULAR FRACTURE HEALING

120

o

140

~ 100

~ 80•oe. 60o~ 40

20

Digital photographic analysis was used to deter­mine the radiographic densitometry in the fracturesite at 7 and 21 days postoperatively. Densitometricanalysis of the fracture site showed significant differ­ences between the PTH(I-34)-treated and control ratsat 7 days postoperatively (Figs 2, 4). The PTH(1-34)­treated rats showed a statistically significant differ­ence in callous formation compared with the controlrats. Two-way analysis of variance showed a statisti­cally significant interaction between 7 and 21 daygroups and treatment (P < .05). The increase in

RADIOGRAPHIC DENSITOMETRY FINDINGS

FIGURE 4. Histograms representing bone densitometric analysisof PTH( 1-34)-treated and control group at 7 and 21 days postop­eratively. Optical density measurements were obtained by tracinginjury site and normalized using area (density/area). Significantincrease seen (P < .05) in bone density in PTH-treated rats com­pared with controls at day 7. Data shown as mean ratio:!: stan­dard error of mean.

ROlI'S/)(/1/ et at. l:.Jjects oj PTH 011 Mandibular Fracture Heatingj Om/ Maxi//ojac SurJ: 2010.

Control

21 days

264

We established a mandibular fracture model using atechnique that involved placement of the osteotomysite caudal to the molars to avoid damaging the toothroots during the procedure. Also, the fracture wasstabilized using an external fixation device anchoredby 2 screws on either side of the fracture site formaximum stabilization. Finally, a nonadjustable fix­ator was used to stabilize the osteotomy site (FigslA-E).

FIGURE 3. Histologic evaluation of specimens showing fractured healing differences in PTH-trealed and control groups at 21 days aftersurgery. Sections stained with Masson's trichrome blue 10 stain for collagen formation within osteotomy site. LiHle bone development se~n !ncallus of control group, as denoted by band of light blue collagen. PTH-treated groups, however, showed abundance of bone withinosteotomy site (dark blue; original magnification x60).

Rowshcm et af. Effects of PTH 011 Mandibular Fracture Healing. J Oral Maxillofac Surf!, 20JO.

Results

MANDIBULAR FRACTURE MODEL

The data were analyzed using statistical analysiscomputer software (SigmaStat, version 3.0, SigmaPlot,Point Richmond, CA). The 2-way analysis of variancemethod was used to compare the radiographic mea­surements between the control and PTH-treated frac­ture groups. The data are presented as the mean :t

standard error of the mean. The measurements werecompared, and P less than .05 was chosen as thecritical level of statistical significance.

embedded in paraffin wax. Serial, 4-/Lm-thick sectionsof the entire osteotomized right mandibles were cutparallel to the long axis of the osteotomy site. Thesections were stained with Masson's trichrome blueto stain for collagen formation within the osteotomysite. Light microscopic examination was performed atlOX and 6ox. Digital photographs were taken andexamined using Image] (National Institutes of Health)software program. The fracture sites were examinedfor collagen material filling and new bone formation(Fig 3).

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

Page 6: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

ROWSHAN IT AL

radiographic densitometry was evident in the earlyphase (7 days) of fracrure healing; however, as shownin Figure 4, a decrease in optical densiry had occurredat 21 days after surgery. Moreover, these differencesbetween the control and treated rats on day 21 didnot reach statistical significance.

HISTOLOGIC EXAMINATION FINDINGS

The effects of PTH(l-3~) treatment were examinedusing light microscopy at lOX to 60x magnificationand the Image] digital photographic analysis softwareprogram (Fig 3). Visual inspection of the histologicsections stained with Masson's trichrome blueshowed a general [feod in the collagen deposition andvoid filling in the early 7- and 21-day PTH-treatedexperimental group. Masson's trichrome blue stainsdark blue for old bone and light blue for collagen andnew bone formation. This finding was consistent inthe early ;-day group and 21-day experimental group.Also, subjective evaluation of the slides showed anapparent trend toward increased new bone fOffilationin the osteotomy site in the 2 I-day PTH-treated groupcompared with the 21-dar controls.

Discussion

Postfracture bone healing is a complex processinfluenced by many molecular, cellular. and biome­chanical factors. 10.1 I Recent studies have been con­ducted to evaluate the effect of several biologic sub­stances on bone fracture healing, induding bonemorphogenetic protein, transforming growth fac­tor-f3. platelet-derived growth factor. and vascular en­dothelial growth factor. 29-3 I A systemically adminis­tered medication that enhances fracture healing couldhave a dramatically positive effect on the clinicalmanagement of fracture treatment. To study novelpharmacologic adjuncts to enhance the healing ofmandibular fractures, we established a unique rodenthemimandibular fracture model. Our mandibular frac­ture model involved the placement of the osteotomysite caudal to the molars to avoid damaging the toothroots during the procedure. This technique variesconsiderably from previous studies that used a distrac­tion technique to examine mandibular fractures. ~.-I..:U

The distraction method involved the creation of anosteotomy site that ran between the second and thirdmolars, and the fixation device was attached by im­plantation of one post on either side of the osteotomysite. TIle device was also designed to place graduallyincreasing distraction forces on the osteotomy site to

study the effects of such forces on fracture healing.Daily subcutaneous injections of PTH (l0 lLg/kg)

were used with our unique rodent mandibular frac­ture model as a pharmacologic adjunct to enhance thehealing of mandibular fractures. PTH is produced by

265

the chief cells of the parathyroid gland. It is an R4­amino acid polypeptide that physiologically regulatesserum calcium and phosphate levels by increasingbone resorption. increasing gastrointestinal calciumabsorption. and increasing renal calcium and phos­phate reabsorption.IK..\.\..\~ The continuous adminis­tration of PTH results in net bone resorption; how­ever, intermittent administration causes a net increasein bone deposition.I~.IH.3(,Because of the very shorthalf-life of PTH, apprOXimately I hour in humans aftersubcutaneous injection. daily dosing such as was con­ducted in the present experiment would constituteintermittent administration ..\-;- Andreassen et al lR

showed that intermittent administration of high (200lLg/kg) doses of PTH( 1-3~) significantly increased frac­ture caUus fOffilation in a rat model. In addition,PTH(l-34) has been administered to patients withosteoporosis, with dosages of 10 to 40 ILg and hasbeen shown to effectively increase bone mass after a21-month clinical triai lO We chose the low IQ-ILg/kgdosage to avoid the side effects of high-dose adminis­tration of PTH, and because it is comparable to theproven clinical dose given for the treatment of osteo­porosis. Additionally, Nakajima et all-i demonstratedthat dosages as low as 10 lLg/kg in a rat fracture modelincreased both mechanical strength and bone mass ofcallus formation in a rat femur fracture model.

In the present study, the radiographic densitometryanalysis results revealed that at 7 days after fracture,an increase occurred in callus and density in thePTH-treated group compared with the control group.However, although the optical denSity levels ap­peared to decline with time, the levels were notsignificantly different from those of the controls at 21days. Nakajima et al 14 showed that daily subcutaneousinjection of 10 lLg/kg of PTH(l-34) induced a signifi­cant increase in the osteoclast index in the hard callusand an increase in insulin-like growth factor-I, rype Icollagen (COLlAI), osteonectin, and osteacalcinmRNA expression at 7 days after a femoral fracture.These cellular and molecular events are perhaps in­dicative of the enhancement of fracture healing usinglow-dose PTH(l-34) during the early stages of femoralbone healing. Our data have also indicated thatPTH(l-34) has enhancement properties in the earlystages of mandibular fracture healing. At days 14 and21, Nakajima et a1 14 observed mature trabeculae inthe PTH·treated group but no significant difference inthe osteoclast index. Although in their study they didnot meaSllre the bone mineral density at 21 days, theyclearly showed a significant increase at 28 and 42 daysafter femoral fracture. In our study, we found a de­crease-although not significant-in the radiographicoptical density in the PTH·treated rats compared withthe control group. l1lis is consistent with the findingof Alkhiary et aI, I' in which they compared the effect

Page 7: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

I!

II

266

of PTH(l·:'-i) daily suhcutaneous injections un femo­rdl bone fracture healing. The)' found that at 21 daysafter fracture, the animals treated with the lower doseof 5 fLg/kg PTH(l-34) did not show any differences inbone mineral density compared with the control an­imals. However, they observed a significant differencein bone mineral density with the lower dose at 35days after fracture.

Visual inspection of the histOlogic sections stainedwith Masson's trichrome blue also suggested that ad­ministration of PTH might playa role in overall carti­lage remodeling and bone formatioo. Even at a lowdosage of 10 fLg/kg, these histOlogic sections showeda general trend in collagen deposition and void fillingin the PTH-treated group. On visual inspection at 60Xmagnification, a trend also appeared toward an in­crease in bone fill in the PTH group compared withthe controls at 21 days. In our study, subjective anal­ysis of the 21-day PTH-treated group displayed anincrease in staining and callus maturity comparedwith the control group.

In conclusion, we were able to show evidence thata low dosage of PTH administration might enhancethe healing process in the early phase of a mandibularfracture model in rats. Although low-dose PTH admin­istration showed evidence of enhanced bone healing,additional studies are needed to quantify these results.In addition, additional research is needed to deter­mine the parathyroid hormone receptor activitywithin the bone after fracture to establish the optimaltime of drug administration in rdation to the fracturehealing mechanism. Furthermore, the effects of dif­ferent dosages of PTH on our fracture model shouldbe examined at different intervals. Biomechankal test­ing to evaluate the strength of the callus formation isan an~a of future intt'rest. These tests might prove thatPTH is the first systemic drug to enhance the fracturerepair of patients with mandible fracture.

A ck110ll 'IedgIllel1t

The l"ditoriaJ assis!ancl" of N:lznn'n S. Kaka is gn.·atly apprt.:l:i·atnl.

References,1:UlH:S IUl. Frl"dricksOll C. Kl"nt .IN: Prospl'etin' stlld~- of man­dihul:lr fr:lCtun.::' . .I Or:ll Surg :\9:2""'''. Il.JH I

1. Cll11pbi P. HanH..Iy He. Lallzicr D. et al: Expres:-.ioll of honemllrpJltJ~L'nctk pnJteins ullring mandihul:lr di~lr;ll'tiun Ilsteo­gL·nt·sis. Plast HI'Ulllstr S\,r~ 111:201. 2(}(1.-\

.'\. Howe Ni\l. .\khr:lr:l I~J. Dudziak ;\IE. t·t aJ: R:H mandihulartlistr.lL·tion l):->tl'l)gelll..:sb. Pan I. IlistoJo~ic anti r.lllill~raphk

allal~-sis. Plast RI..:L·oll:-.tr Surg 102:2022. 19l.JH-L Stdnhrt:l.."h DS . .\khrar:l B.I. Hm\"(,' ~.\1. et al: Gelw L·xpre.;sion of

T{ir-ht·t;l. T(iF-heta rl·(:t.:ptor. :lIld extran:J111lar matrix pmtt·in....duril1~ IlH::mhrallou:-. honl" hl'aling in rats. PJast Ikl'onstr :-iurg10":2021{.200t)

;. Am:-ill"ena OA. Collin ... \\'1..: Ddel."t n:pair in the r.1I mandihlL'with hol1t:: lllorphogcnk protdn " :l1lU prost:lgl:llldin E I . ArchOlolaryngol Hcatl Ned.: Surg 12l): 112':,. 200:'!

EFFECTS OF PTH ON MANDIBULAR FRACTURE HEALING

6. E....ki 1\1. Nbanci .\1. Cil Y. l't a[: A l.."ll:,(ulll-madt' di:-tractiolldl.·vin: fur cxpcrimt·nt;ll mam..lihul;lr distr.ll'tion oSleogcllt:sis. JCmniofac Surg 16:6-". 200')

- Buchman SH. 19ndzi MAJr. Radu C, (.'( al: Uniqut: rodent modt:!of distraction osteiJgcne~is of Ihe: mandihle:. Ann Plast Surg-t9:511. 2002

R. Fukunaga T. Yamashiro T. Ora S, et <II: Connec(i"e: tissuegrowlh facwr mRNA expression pattern in canilage:s is assod·ated with thdr type I collagen expression. Bone 33:911. 2003

9. Zheng L Yamashiro T. Fukunaga T, et al: Bone morphogeneticprotein 3 expression patlem in rat condylar cartilage, femoralcanilage and mandibular fracture callus. Eur J OraJ Sci 113:,31 B.2005

1O. Childs SG: Stimulator~ of bone healing: Biologic and biOOll:­chanica I. Onhop Nllrs 22:421. 2003

11. Ordfo RO: Growth factors for skeletal reconstruction andfraClure repair. Curl' Opin Invt'stig Drugs 5:419. 200-1

12. Bolander ME: Regulation of fmcture re:pair br growth faclors.Proc Soc Exp Bioi Med 200: 165. 1992

1:\. Chapman MW: Thol\ght~on clinical tri:tls to e:valu:lle the actionand dft:ctivt:ne:ss of BMPs in hone healing. J Bone Joint 5urgAm H:\A(Suppl. 1):SI6:\. 2UOI

14. Nakajima A. Shimoji N. Shiomi K. e[ al: Ml:ch:lllisll1s for tIll:enhanceml:nt of fracture hc:aling in rats tre:Hed with intermit­tent low-dose human parmhyroid hormone (1-:\4). .I BoneMiner Res 17:2038. 2<X12

1'). Alkhiarr YM. (ierstenfdd LC, KrJIJ E. l't al: Enh:mcemt:nt ofe:xrx:rimt:l1Ial franurc·he:lling hy systemic :ldministr.ttion ofrecomhinant human parathyroid hormone (PTH 1-:\-0. .J BoneJoint Slirg Am H"':7:\I, 200')

16. Rudman KE. kspde:n RM. Meakin .IR: Compre:ssion or tension?'nle stress distrihution in the: pmximal femur. Bionled Eng(}nlim: 5: 12. 2006

17. vall Eijden TM: Biol1le:dlar1ics of the mandible. Cdt Rev OralBioI Meu I I: 11:\. 200t)

IH. Holzer G. Majeska HJ, Llinur MW. et al: ParJthrroid hormoneenhanet:s fracture healing: A prdiminarr rc:pon. Clin OrthopRd:u Rcs 25H. 1999

19. Ne:e:r RM. Amalld CD, Zanchetta JR, e( al: Effh.1 of parathyroidhomlOne (l.:\-i) on tbCHlre~and hone mincr.J.l dcn~i(r in postOleno·pallSLI womell with osteoporosis. N EnglJ l\-kd :\-i-4:1-t3-t. 200l

20, Seehach C. Skripitl. R. Andreassen n', t:t al: Intemliut:l1t par.l­thyroid honllont" (1-_'\4) t'nhanct:s me:chankal strength anddcnsity of llCW hont: after distraction ostt'ogenesis in rals.J Ortllop Res 22:-i72. 200..

2 J. Dohnig Ii, Turner RT: Evidence thal imemliUem lrt:atmt:l1Iwith par.lthrroid hormollc increast:s bone formation in adultr.HS hy anh'alion of honc lining n·lls. Endocrinology J:\6::\6:\2.Il)l)')

22. Canalis E. Centrdla M. I3un:h W. et al: Immlin-Iike growthfactor I mediates Sdeeti"e: :ll1aholic effects of par:uhrrokl llor­mone in hont: Cl1ltllrL's. .J Clin Invcst H5:60. 19H9

25. C:lllalis E. P:lsh J. Var~hest: S: Skektal growth factors. Cril RL'"Eukaryot (i(".'111;" Expr .1:1')';.199.1

2-i. Jilk:l RI.. \Vt.:instdn RS. Bdlido T. t:t :II: Increasl'U hOI1t' forma·tion h~' prevention of ostl.'ohlast apopwsis wilh parathyroidIHlfllml1c. .J elin Inn:st 1O-i: ... 5l). 1999

2". Hdlido T. Ali AA. Plotkin L1. t:t al: Proteasom:ll ul'graU:lIion ofHUllX2 shortens pa['atlJ~T(Jid hllrllllllle-induccd anti-:lpl)pltJticsiWlaling in ostl'oblasts: A put:lti\,e explanation for wily inttT­lllith:nt :llJministr.nion is nn·uL·d for hone anaholislll . .1 RiolChem TH:')02:'i9. 200.~

26. Skripitz H. :\.spl·nlX'r~ P: Par:lIh~ mid homlOlll:-A drug forllnhopl'llic surgery~ Acta Onlwp Scam! -':;:6"-i. 200-1

r Billlkb RJ Dempslt"r .lA. R:ll1lakers PI.. t't al: Effect of proteinkin;lst: (: :Kti"ati(lll ;lntl dllwnregulatitJll on :It"tin: t':llcilllllIf'Jnspon. Kidnt'Y 1m -i5:2l)". \l)95

2H. Amlre;l:,sen rL EjeNnl C. Oxlund H: Intermittent paralhyroidhormone (I·.~-t) treltmenl increasL's call1l-'' forlllation and me·d1:ll1ical strt·ngth of healing rat fraullre~. .J BOlle Mint:r Hes10-1:960. 1999

2l). Ah(: N. Lee YP. Saw.\1. t:t al: Enhaneelllcnt of hone repair witha he1rx:r-ucpl.·ndent adl'nm'ir:11 trJllsft:r of h()J1e llll)rphogem:tic.:prllteill·2. Bioc1wm Biophrs Hes Commun 29::-;2.~. 2002

Page 8: Effect ofIntermittent Systemic Administration ...Mandibular Fracture Healing inRats Purpose: To establish a rat mandibular fracture model and investigate the short-and long-termeffects

ROWSI-lAN ET AL

.~(). Yogdin .\!DE. .rOlH:S NF. Lieberman JR. et at: Prdahrication ofbOlle by usc of a \";lscularizl·d periosteal tlap and hone mor­phogenetic protein. Plas! Ik<.:onstf Surg Itl'-}:ll)O. 2002

:i I Lieherman JR. Daluiski A. Einhorn Tr\: The rok of growthfactors in the n:pair of hone: lIiology and clinical applications,J BOll<: J()int Surg Am H-iA:I0:'2. 20()2

~2 \'"illiams.lK. Rowe N.\-I, .\lackooj R). et al: Controlled l11ultipJa­oar di.o;traction of the mandible. Part II: Laboratory studies ofsagittal (;.lIltcroposterior) and vertical (superoinferior) move­ments. ] Craniofac Surg 9:'504, 1998

~.3 Habener JF. Kronenberg H.\1: Parathyroid hormone biosynthe­sis: Structure and function of biosynthetic precursors. Fed Procr:2.,61, 19-H

26

.3-1. Hdnrich G, Kronenberg t-1i\L Polts .IT .Jr. l't al: Pamth' .hormone messenger rihonlll:!l'ie add' Fffcct. r ,'.} fOUj. _ . ., .' . .'"' ." s () ca ('nml on

(dlul.lr .1t.:gl~.LI.IIOI~ In \ 1110, EndolTllhllogy 1 12: 1-.i9. 1<)83

y; H~ISk.a KA. Ll\"I{c~ It DUIlCU1 H: ct al: H('guJation of skdctal rl'lllod_dmg by 11;U~lthyrold hOnllOne, Contnh Ncphrol <)1..~K. 1')l->1

."!(J. Sllirot;l T: Tashiro M. ()h~o K. ct al: Effl'ct ut intermittentparathyrOId hon1H~ne (1"5-1) treatmcnt on thc bonc rl':-,pOl1seafter placement ot titanium implants into the tibia uf O\"ariec.wmized rats. J Oral ,\laxillufac Surg 6l:-i~1. 2()D."!

37. Schwif;'ren HR. Groen EW. Sollie FA. l't al: Single-dose subcu­taneOllS administration of recombinant human parathyroid hor­mone [rhPTH(l-84)] in healthy postmenopausal volunteersClin Pharmacol Ther 61 :.160. 1997

Ii

!

I

il

fli.1I'·,1itIIiI

i