1
Relevance: Hand osteoarthritis is a highly prevalent disease with clinical and social burdens. Therapists need to understand the current levels of evidence that support the interventions they are using in the treatment of hand osteoarthritis. Research/Evidence-Based Practice KRISTIN A. VALDES, OTD, OTR, CHT Effects of Manual Therapy on Pain Perception in Individuals with Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. 1: Identify the difference be- tween a direct neural mobiliza- tion technique and a sham neural mobilization technique. 2: Describe that immediate clinical outcome did not differ based on type of neural mobilization tech- nique used to treat carpal tunnel syndrome. Purpose: We present preliminary findings of the effects of neural mobilization (NM) on pain per- ception in individuals diagnosed with carpal tunnel syndrome. Methods: Participants were ran- domly assigned to receive either direct NM or a sham NM Mechanical visual analog scales (MVAS) and 101 point numeric rating scales (NRS) were used during the first treatment session to quantify self report of current carpal tunnel pain and the per- ception of standardized painful thermal stimuli. Repeated mea- sure ANOVAs were used to eval- uate pain perception prior to and immediately following the intervention. Results: Thirty three individ- uals met the criteria and agreed to participate. A main effect was present for self report of current pain (F(1,31) ¼ 4.40, p ¼ 0.04, par- tial h2 ¼ 0.12) with a mean de- crease of 6.09 mm; however, this was independent of group assign- ment (p ¼ 0.72). Pain perception to standardized thermal stimuli did not decrease over time or differ by group assignment (p . 0.05). Conclusion: Self report of pain specifically related to carpal tunnel syndrome was lessened immediately following a NM in- tervention regardless of whether the intervention was specific to the median nerve or not. Perceptions of standardized ther- mal pain stimuli were not altered by either NM technique. Clinical Relevance: The results provide preliminary support that the influence of NM on CTS self report of pain may be inde- pendent of the specificity of the technique used. Instead, pain re- lief may result from non- specific effects of treatment. Research/Evidence-Based Practice STEVEN GEORGE, PT, PHD JOEL E. BIALOSKY, MS, PT MARK D. BISHOP, PT, PHD MICHAEL E. ROBINSON,PHD DONALD D. PRICE,PHD 428 JOURNAL OF HAND THERAPY

Effects of Manual Therapy on Pain Perception in Individuals with Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Relevance: Hand osteoarthritisis a highly prevalent diseasewith clinical and social burdens.Therapists need to understandthe current levels of evidencethat support the interventionsthey are using in the treatmentof hand osteoarthritis.

Research/Evidence-BasedPractice

KRISTIN A. VALDES, OTD, OTR,CHT

Effects of Manual Therapy onPain Perception in Individualswith Carpal Tunnel Syndrome.

1: Identify the difference be-tween a direct neural mobiliza-tion technique and a sham neuralmobilization technique. 2:Describe that immediate clinicaloutcome did not differ based ontype of neural mobilization tech-nique used to treat carpal tunnelsyndrome.

428 JOURNAL OF HAND THERAPY

Purpose: We present preliminaryfindings of the effects of neuralmobilization (NM) on pain per-ception in individuals diagnosedwith carpal tunnel syndrome.

Methods: Participants were ran-domly assigned to receive eitherdirect NM or a sham NMMechanical visual analog scales(MVAS) and 101 point numericrating scales (NRS) were usedduring the first treatment sessionto quantify self report of currentcarpal tunnel pain and the per-ception of standardized painfulthermal stimuli. Repeated mea-sure ANOVAs were used to eval-uate pain perception prior to andimmediately following theintervention.

Results: Thirty three individ-uals met the criteria and agreedto participate. A main effect waspresent for self report of currentpain (F(1,31)¼ 4.40, p¼ 0.04, par-tial h2¼ 0.12) with a mean de-crease of 6.09 mm; however, thiswas independent of group assign-ment (p¼ 0.72). Pain perception

to standardized thermal stimulidid not decrease over time or differby group assignment (p . 0.05).

Conclusion: Self report of painspecifically related to carpaltunnel syndrome was lessenedimmediately following a NM in-tervention regardless of whetherthe intervention was specific tothe median nerve or not.Perceptions of standardized ther-mal pain stimuli were not alteredby either NM technique.

Clinical Relevance: The resultsprovide preliminary supportthat the influence of NM on CTSself report of pain may be inde-pendent of the specificity of thetechnique used. Instead, pain re-lief may result from non- specificeffects of treatment.

Research/Evidence-BasedPractice

STEVEN GEORGE, PT, PHDJOEL E. BIALOSKY, MS, PTMARK D. BISHOP, PT, PHDMICHAEL E. ROBINSON, PHD

DONALD D. PRICE, PHD