54
Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the side of a mountain… Dr. Greg Gaston, Department of Geography, University of North Alabama Dr. George Makowski, Department of History, University of North Alabama Changing lives. Creating futures. Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the side of a mountain… Dr. George Makowski, Department of History, University of North Alabama

Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Electrical Resistance ImagingLooking beneath the surface…

OrFinding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe…

AndLooking for buried ice on the side of

a mountain…

Dr. Greg Gaston, Department of Geography, University of North Alabama

Dr. George Makowski, Department of History, University of North Alabama

Changing lives. Creating futures.

Looking beneath the surface…Or

Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe…

AndLooking for buried ice on the side of

a mountain…

Dr. George Makowski, Department of History, University of North Alabama

Page 2: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Remote Sensing?

• Subsurface targets

• Simple technology with high order data processing

Page 3: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Significance?

• Big target technology searching for small targets

• Potentially a significant tool in exploring the impacts of climate change

• Identification of historical and recent archeological sites without damage

• High resolution images

• Flexibility

Page 4: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Why Electrical Resistance (ER) Imaging?

• Non-invasive • Widely used tool in archeological investigations• ER tools are more capable of recording data

where sub-surface water is present (Ground Penetrating RADAR [GPR] has difficulty penetrating saturated ground conditions)

• Relatively low cost• Buried ice has very high electrical resistance

Page 5: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

The physical principles…

Page 6: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Penetration is a function of the length of the electrode line and the distance between electrodes. Functionally, depth is 10-20% of the total length of the electrode array and the minimum target discrimination is ½ the electrode spacing.

Page 7: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Testing the ER system

Page 8: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 9: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 10: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 11: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Known Steam Tunnel

Steam Tunnel to adjoining building

Compaction and moisture near sidewalk

Page 12: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Case Study 1

Sweetwater PlantationER Data collected 15 December ‘06Additional Field Mapping 16 Feb. ‘07

Historical Applications:

Page 13: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 14: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 15: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Cemetery Site

(Approximately 450 feet from the house)

Page 16: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 17: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 18: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 19: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Survey Lines

Page 20: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 21: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Survey Line 3Data line 5 Schlumberger electrode firing pattern

Page 22: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Survey Line 4Data line 7 Schlumberger electrode firing pattern

Page 23: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Case Study 2: Coffee Plantation

Page 24: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 25: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Coffee Cemetery Line 8

Page 26: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

LaGrange Mountain Cemetery

• Experimental Data Collection

• Field Methods Class 6 March 2007

Page 27: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 28: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 29: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 30: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 31: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 32: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 33: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Results:

• Initial results at the Sweetwater Plantation site are encouraging.

• Results from the Coffee Plantation site are not as expected.

• The interpretation of ER images can change with different environmental conditions.

• The ‘Art’ rather than the ‘Science’ of image interpretation and analysis

Page 34: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Next steps in the research program:

• Test ER imaging at additional sites with known and suspected burial sites.

• We will retest Coffee cemetery with drier conditions.

Page 35: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Changes in glacial ice and ice marginal features of the

Cascades

Research sponsored by a grant from the College of Arts and Sciences at the University of North Alabama.

Thanks also to the UNA Department of Physics and Earth Science for the loan of the Electrical Resistance Imaging equipment.

Page 36: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Why glacial features in the Cascades?

• Glaciers exist at comparatively low elevationsIt is possible to measure moraine

features at 6000-7000 feet• Changes in ice and ice marginal features are

fairly well documented including a long record of aerial photography

• A wide variety of glacial features have (relatively) easy accessibility

• Previous Research Experience

Page 37: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

The Pacific Northwest

Page 38: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 39: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 40: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 41: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

The angle of repose of dry earth materials is generally 25-40 degrees.

35 degrees is the accepted ‘normal’ angle of repose

A steeper angle implies some sort of cohesion between particles.

Page 42: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

1990

2006

Page 43: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

http://glaciers.pdx.edu/gdb/maps/oregon_website/or_glaciers.html

1901

Page 44: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 45: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Carver Lake…

An example of a glacial lake created by ice cored moraines.

Page 46: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 47: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 48: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 49: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 50: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 51: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 52: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the
Page 53: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Site 2: Known Glacial Ice

Site 1:

Suspected Ice Cored Moraine

Page 54: Electrical Resistance Imaging Looking beneath the surface… Or Finding where the bodies are buried without a backhoe… And Looking for buried ice on the

Conclusions • The steeper angle of repose in many of the moraines of

the Cascades is caused by an ‘ice core’.• Electrical resistance imaging equipment was useful in

confirming the presence of ice in the moraine.• Interpretation of the levels of resistance suggest

discontinuous ice lenses rather than a solid mass of ice.• Lakes in the Cascades dammed by moraines with

similar slope are likely to fail as ice in the Cascades continues to melt.

• Mountains are taller and gravity appears to have dramatically increased over the last 16 years!