Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Phone: 020-66289400/407
Fax: 020-25521607
E-mail: [email protected]
MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd.
Agriculture College Campus
Near DIC Office, Shivaji Nagar
Pune -411005
PREPARED BY
EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-104:R00dt.:12/09/2014 Revision No. 1 dated 04.05.2015
Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwant
nagar, Upalai(T), Barshi, Dist: Solapur
by
M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
REPORT
of
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune i
DECLARATION
Declaration by Experts contributing to the EIA Report of Industrial Construction
Project by Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd., Bhagwantnagar, Upalai (T), Tal: Barshi, Dist:
Solapur.
I hereby certify that, I was a part of the EIA team in the following capacity that
developed the above EIA.
EIA Coordinator:
Name: Ms.KavitaZog
Signature:
Period of involvement: January 2014 to till date
The following team members of EME were engaged in preparation of EIA report
Sr. No.
Name of the
Personnel Degree
Designation
NABET FAE
Role Signature
1. Mr. Sanjay Shevkar
M.Sc. Env. Sciences
Executive Vice President
Noise, ISW, AP, WP
Coordinating and guiding the overall project and suggestions regarding Noise, ISW, AP, WP component of the report.
2. Ms.Kavita Zog
M.Sc. Env. Science
Principal Consultant
EIA Coordinator, EB
EIA Coordinator. EIA report drafting and preparation. Carrying out Ecology & Biodiversity Study
3. Mr.Nilesh Deshmukh
M. Tech. Env. Engg.
Assistant Vice President
WP, Inputs is WP aspects
4. Dr. Chaitanya Sathe
PhD. in Inorganic Chemistry
Assistant Vice President
WP, ISW
Provide s Technical inputs in WP, ISW aspects.
5. Mr. Shrikant Kakade
M.Sc. Env. Science
Principal Consultant
EB Carrying out Ecology & Biodiversity Study & WP. Compilation of EIA EMP Report
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune ii
Declaration by the Head of the Accredited Consultant Organization
I, Mr. Sanjay Shevkar hereby, confirm that the above mentioned experts prepared the
EIA Study of proposed 45KPLD Distillery Project by Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd.
Name &Signature: Mr. Sanjay Shevkar
Designation: Executive Vice President Name of the EIA Consultant Organization:
MITCON Consultancy and Engineering Services Ltd. Environment Management & Engineering Division Agriculture College Campus, Next to DIC office, Shivaji Nagar, Pune. 411 005, Maharashtra (India) Tel: +91-20-66289500, 400,403,405, 406, 408, 409 Email: [email protected] Visit us at: http://www.mitconindia.com
6. Mr. Ashvin Badge
B.E. Chemical Engineering.
Principal Consultant
AQ Collation of baseline data.
7. Mr. Adhikrao Yewale
M.sc. Env. Science
Chief Consultant
AP Inputs in AP aspects in EIA report
8. Mr. Kuldeep Gurav
Msc. Env. Science
Principal Consultant
EB Assisting for carrying out Ecology & Biodiversity Study.
9. Mr. Ganesh Dhansing
Khamgal
MSW Divisional Manager
SE Inputs in socioeconomic aspects
in EIA report
10. Mr. Sharad Bade
B.Sc. Chemistry, Zoology and Physics
Senior Executive (Env.)
- Baseline data collection surveys.
11. Mrs. Prajakta Chitnis
B.Sc. chem. &Post Grad. Dip. in Ind. & Analytical Chemistry
Senior Chemist
- Co-ordinating testing of samples, water, soil and air and assistance in impact assessment for these parameters.
12. Mr. Rakesh
Gupta
M Tech
Chemestry Engg.
- RH Inputs in RH aspects in EIA report
mailto:[email protected]://www.mitconindia.com/
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune iii
TABLE OF CONTENT
CHAPTER 1 .................................................................................................. 1
INTRODUCTION ......................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
1.1 BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................. 1
1.2 IDENTIFICATION OF PROJECT & PROJECT PROPONENT .............................................. 3
1.3 THE SALIENT FEATURES OF PROJECT SITE ................................................................... 3
1.4 PROJECT LOCATION ..................................................................................................... 4
1.5 PURPOSE OF EIA & EMP .............................................................................................. 5
1.6 SCOPE OF THE STUDY .................................................................................................. 6
CHAPTER 2 .................................................................................................. 8
PROJECT DESCRIPTION .............................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
2.1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 8
2.2 NEED OF THE PROJECT ................................................................................................ 8
2.3 PROPOSED DISTILLERY................................................................................................. 9
2.3.1 Location .................................................................................................................... 9
2.3.2 Communication ........................................................................................................ 9
2.3.3 Land ........................................................................................................................ 10
2.3.4 Water requirement ................................................................................................ 12
2.3.5 Water Balance ........................................................................................................ 12
2.3.6 Steam Balance ........................................................................................................ 14
2.3.7 Raw material requirement ..................................................................................... 14
2.3.8 Manpower requirement ........................................................................................ 14
2.3.9 Manufacturing Details ........................................................................................... 15
2.3.10Pollution control measures ................................................................................... 20
CHAPTER 3 ................................................................................................ 23
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT ...................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
3.1 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 23
3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS ............................................................................... 23
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune iv
3.3 DETAILS OF SITE AND ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING OF STUDY AREA ......................... 23
3.4 TOPOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................ 24
3.5 GEOLOGY ................................................................................................................... 25
3.6 HYDROGEOLOGY ....................................................................................................... 26
3.6.3 Ground /Surface water Quality ............................................................................. 29
3.7 CLIMATE AND RAINFALL ............................................................................................ 30
3.8 AMBIENT AIR QUALITY .............................................................................................. 41
3.8.1 Observation & Results .......................................................................................... 43
3.9 NOISE QUALITY MONITORING .................................................................................. 44
3.10 GEOMORPHOLOGY AND SOIL TYPES .......................................................................... 46
3.10.1 Soil Characteristics ............................................................................................... 47
3.11 DRAINAGE SYSTEM & RIVERS .................................................................................... 48
3.12 SEISMOLOGY ............................................................................................................. 49
3.13 ECOLOGY ..................................................................................................................... 49
3.13.1 Objectives of Ecological Studies ....................................................................... 49
3.13.2 Methodology adopted for Ecological Studies .................................................. 49
3.13.3 Methodology for sampling and analysis .......................................................... 50
3.13.4 Floristic Studies ................................................................................................ 50
3.13.5 Faunal Composition .......................................................................................... 54
3.14 MINERAL WEALTH AND INDUSTRIES ........................................................................ 56
3.15 HISTORICAL & CULTURAL MONUMENTS AND PLACES OF RELIGIOUS IMPORTANCE
56
3.16 LAND USE ................................................................................................................... 56
3.17 SOCIO-ECONOMIC STATUS ........................................................................................ 58
3.17.1 Baseline Status ..................................................................................................... 58
3.17.2 Demographic Structure ........................................................................................ 59
3.17.3. Demography of the study area ........................................................................... 60
CHAPTER 4 ................................................................................................ 66
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune v
ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES... Error! Bookmark not
defined.
4.1 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 66
4.1.1 Phase I ................................................................................................................... 66
4.1.2 Phase II .................................................................................................................. 67
4.2 IMPACT ON LAND USE ............................................................................................... 67
4.3 IMPACT ON SOIL ........................................................................................................ 68
4.4 IMPACT ON WATER USE ............................................................................................ 69
4.5 IMPACT ON WATER QUALITY .................................................................................... 69
4.6 RAINWATER HARVESTING ......................................................................................... 70
4.7 IMPACT ON TRAFFIC .................................................................................................. 70
4.8 IMPACT ON AIR ENVIRONMENT ................................................................................ 71
4.9 ODOUR ENVIRONMENT ............................................................................................ 71
4.10 NOISE ENVIRONMENT ............................................................................................... 72
4.11 IMPACT ON ECOLOGY................................................................................................ 72
4.12 IMPACT ON DEMOGRAPHY & SOCIOECONOMICS .................................................... 73
CHAPTER 5 ................................................................................................ 76
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES (SITE AND TECHNOLOGY) ........... Error! Bookmark not defined.
5.1 SITE ALTERNATIVES ................................................................................................... 76
5.2 TECHNOLOGY ALTERNATIVES.................................................................................... 77
CHAPTER 6 ................................................................................................ 82
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAMME ....................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
6.1 MONITORING PLAN ...................................................................................................... 82
6.2 SAMPLING SCEDULE AND LOCATIONS ......................................................................... 83
6.3 LABORATORY FACILITIES ............................................................................................... 84
6.4 BUDGET FOR MONITORING .......................................................................................... 85
CHAPTER 7 ................................................................................................ 86
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune vi
ADDITIONAL STUDIES にRISK ASSESSMENT AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLAN ........... Error! Bookmark not defined.
7.1 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 86
7.2 METHODOLOGY OF MCA ANALYSIS .......................................................................... 86
7.3 CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS.......................................................................................... 87
7.3.1 Factors Influencing the Use of Physical Effect Models .......................................... 87
7.3.2 Models for the Calculation of Heat Load and Shock Waves .................................. 88
7.3.3 Model for a BLEVE .................................................................................................. 88
7.3.4 Ignition of a Gas Cloud ........................................................................................... 89
7.3.5 Burning Torch ......................................................................................................... 89
7.3.6 Injuries resulting from Flammable Liquids and Gases ........................................... 89
7.3.7 Damage Models for Heat Radiation ...................................................................... 89
7.3.8 Damage Model for Pressure Waves ...................................................................... 90
7.3.9 Specific Emergencies Anticipated and Mitigation Measures ............................... 90
7.3.10 Disaster Management Plan .................................................................................. 92
7.4 ON-SITE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT ...................................................................... 95
7.4.1 Duties of personnel if fire occurs ........................................................................... 95
7.5 FUNCTION OF MEDICAL CENTER ............................................................................... 97
7.6 FUNCTION OF MEDICAL ADVISOR ............................................................................. 97
7.7 ACTION TO BE TAKEN BY SHIFT SECURITY CHIEF ...................................................... 98
7.8 ACTION TO BE TAKEN BY EXTERNAL CONTACT CENTER ........................................... 98
7.8 OFFSITE EMERGENCY PLAN ....................................................................................... 99
7.8.1 Responsibilities of the Police ............................................................................... 100
7.8.2 Responsibilities of the fire brigade ...................................................................... 100
7.8.4 Technical (Factory Inspectorate, Pollution Board, Technical experts from industry,
research and training institution) ................................................................................. 100
7.8.5 Rehabilitation (Local authorities and district administration) ............................. 100
7.9 MEASURES TO BE TAKEN DURING THE EMERGENCY .............................................. 100
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune vii
CHAPTER 8 .............................................................................................. 102
PROJECT BENEFITS .................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
8.1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 102
8.2 PROJECT BENEFITS ................................................................................................... 102
8.3 SOCIO-ECONOMIC WELFARE MEASURES ................................................................ 103
CHAPTER 9 .............................................................................................. 104
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN .................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
9.1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 104
9.2 OBJECTIVES OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN ....................................... 104
9.3 CHECKLIST OF STATUTORY OBLIGATIONS ............................................................... 104
9.5 CONSTRUCTION PHASE ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT ....................................... 106
9.5.1 Site Preparation .................................................................................................. 106
9.5.2 Noise ................................................................................................................... 106
9.5.3 Construction Equipment and Waste ................................................................... 106
9.5.4 Site Security ........................................................................................................ 106
9.7 OPERATIONAL PHASE WATER ENVIRONMENT & MANAGEMENT .......................... 107
9.7.1 Water Pollution & Control Facilities ................................................................... 107
9.7.2 Effluent Treatment Scheme for the Distillery Unit ............................................. 107
9.8 NOISE ENVIRONMENT ............................................................................................. 109
9.9 BIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT ................................................................................... 109
9.10 LAND ENVIRONMENT .............................................................................................. 109
9.11 GREEN BELT ............................................................................................................. 109
9.11.1 Plantation: Ecological Need & Location ......................................................... 110
9.12 OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY & HEALTH ......................................................................... 110
9.13 SOCIO-ECONOMIC WELFARE ACTIVITIES ................................................................ 111
9.14 RISK ASSESSMENT- STORAGE & TRANSPORTATION OF RS/ENA ............................ 111
9.15 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING SCHEDULE .......................................................... 112
9.16 ENVIRONMENTAL BUDGET ..................................................................................... 112
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune viii
CHAPTER 10 ............................................................................................ 114
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION .................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
10.1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 114
10.2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................ 115
10.2.1 Location ............................................................................................................. 115
10.2.2 Communication .................................................................................................. 115
10.2.3 Land ................................................................................................................... 115
10.2.4 Water requirement ........................................................................................... 116
10.2.5 Raw material requirement ................................................................................ 116
10.2.6 Manpower requirement ................................................................................... 116
10.3 DESCRIPTION OF ENVIRONMENT ............................................................................ 116
10.3.1 Ground water and surface water quality........................................................... 116
10.3.2 Climate and Rainfall ........................................................................................... 117
10.3.3 Noise quality ...................................................................................................... 117
10.3.4 Soil quality .......................................................................................................... 117
10.3.5 Ambient Air quality ............................................................................................ 118
10.4 IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES .................................................................. 118
10.5 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES ................................................................................... 122
10.6 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PLAN ................................................................... 123
10.7 RISK ASSESSMENT AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLAN ....................................... 124
10.8 BENEFITS OF THE PROJECT ...................................................................................... 125
10.8.1 Socio-economic welfare measures .................................................................... 125
10.9 ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN ................................................................ 126
10.9.1 Environmental Management Cell (EMC) ........................................................... 126
CHAPTER 11 .................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANTS ENGAGED ............................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table1.1: Salient Features of the Project ................................................................... 3
Table 2.1: Ethanol Production and consumption in India (million litres) ................... 8
Table 2.2: Ethanol consumption demand by 2011-12 (million litres) ......................... 9
Table 2.3 : Water Balance for Proposed 45 KLPD Distillery ...................................... 13
Table 3.1: Environmental Setting of the Study Area ................................................ 24
Table 3.4: Water Sampling Locations ...................................................................... 29
Table 3.5: Water Quality Analysis............................................................................ 29
Table 3.6: Meteorological Parameters Monitored at Site ........................................... 30
Table 3.6: Relative Humidity Data – Solapur IMD Observatory (2000 to 2010) ........ 32 Table 3.6: Yearly (2000-2010) Average Rainfall data of Solapur District .................. 33
Table 3.7: Monthly Metrological Data during study period ...................................... 37
Table: 3.7: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Locations.............................................. 41
Table 3.8: Summary of Ambient Air Quality Results - Project Site ........................... 43
Table 3.9: Noise Monitoring Locations ..................................................................... 44
Table 3.11: Ambient Noise Level Monitoring ............................................................ 46
Table 3.12: Soil Sampling Locations ........................................................................ 47
Table 3.13: Soil Type of Project Area........................................................................ 47
Table 3.14: Soil analysis results .............................................................................. 47
Table 3.15: List of Ecological sampling locations ..................................................... 50
Table 3.15 a): List of herbs ...................................................................................... 50
Table 3.15c): List of trees ........................................................................................ 52
Table3.15 d): List of agriculture crops ..................................................................... 54
Table 3.15 g): Birds of the study area ...................................................................... 56
Table 3.16: Landuse in the study area .................................................................... 57
Table 3.17: Demography of 10 KM radius study area .............................................. 61
Table 3.18: Literacy of the village/wards in 10km radius around project site .......... 62
Table 3.29: Workers Categorization in village of 10km radius around project .......... 64
Table 6.1: Post project Monitoring Schedule ............................................................ 83
Table 6.2: Budget for environmental monitoring ...................................................... 85
Table 9.1 Hazards & Mitigation Measures Associated with RS/ENA ...................... 112
Table 9.2: Cost of Environmental Protection Measures for distillery Unit............... 113
Table 10.1 : Project features .................................................................................. 114
Table 10.2 : Item –wise split up of the land requirement ....................................... 115 Table 10.4 : Post project Monitoring Schedule ....................................................... 123
Table 10.5 : Cost of Environmental Protection Measures ....................................... 127
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune x
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1.2: Location of the Proposed Distillery .......................................................... 4
Figure 2.1 : Google Earth Image depicting the proposed distillery ........................... 11
Figure 2.2 : Layout plan depicting various facilities ................................................. 12
Figure 2.3 : Water Balance for the proposed distillery ............................................. 13
Figure 3.1: 10 KM radius study area ....................................................................... 25
Figure 3.2: Decadal variation(min. & max. mean relative humidity at 8.30 hrs) ...... 32
Figure 3.3: Decadal variation (min. & max. mean relative humidity at 17.30 hrs) ... 33
Figure 3.4: Average Rainfall data yearwise (2000-2010) in Solapur District ............. 34
Figure 3.5: IMD windrose (8.30 Hrs) from IMD station Solapur ............................... 35
Figure 3.6: IMD windrose (17.30 Hrs) from IMD station Solapur ............................. 36
Figure-3.7 Seasonal Windrose for the month of October – December 2014 .............. 38 Figure-3.8 Windrose for the month of October 2014 ................................................ 39
Figure-3.9 Windrose for the month of November 2014 ............................................ 39
Figure-3.10 Windrose for the month of December 2014 .......................................... 40
Figure3.11: Ambient Air Monitoring Locations ........................................................ 42
Figure 3.12: Ambient Noise Monitoring Locations ................................................... 45
Figure 3.13: Dendritic Drainage System .................................................................. 48
Figure 3.14: Landuse in the study area ................................................................... 58
Figure 7.1: Typical organogram for onsite emergency management plan ................. 99
Figure 7.2: Typical Organogram for off-site emergency management plan ............. 101
Figure 9.1: Environment Management Cell ........................................................... 105
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune xi
LIST OF ANNEXURE
Annexure 1 : TOR & TOR Compliance Report
Annexure 2 : Distillery process flow diagram
Annexure 3 : Sampling location Map
Annexure 4 : Water analysis report
Annexure 5 : Air quality monitoring report
Annexure 6 : Noise quality monitoring report
Annexure 7 : Soil Quality Analysis Report
Annexure 8 : Seismology map of India
Annexure 9 : Spent wash Treatment
Annexure 10 : Company Registration Certificate
Annexure 11 : IEM License
Annexure 12 : Public Hearing details
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 1
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND
India is the largest producer of sugarcane and sugar. However the Sugar Factories cannot survive in healthy condition on a single product i.e. sugar. Hence it is necessary to develop sugar factory into affiliated chemical complex and use the valuable by-products more profitably. Molasses is a very important by-product of the sugar industry. The profit earned by conversion of molasses to alcohol shall be much higher than the value released by sale of molasses. There is a good demand for alcohol in the country as production and consumption of alcohol in India is quite balanced. The target of alcohol demand as projected in the perspective plan for chemical industry, prepared by government of India, Ministry of Industry, Department of chemical and petrochemicals is 2400 millions litres per annum by year 2000. In addition, now a days, there is a good potential to export alcohol out of country. Alcohol has assumed a very important place in the economy of the country. The importance and utility of alcohol is well known as an industrial raw material for manufacture of a variety of organic chemicals including pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, potable alcohol etc. This is partly due to high costs of products produced through petroleum route, consequent to the phenomenal increase in petroleum price. Further, it is a potential fuel in the form of power alcohol when blended with petrol. Alcohol is a substitute to the imported petroleum. Being produced from renewable source it is an environmental friendly product. Large demand is also anticipated for its use as fuel. Use of alcohol as an ingredient in beverages is well known. It is a major source of revenue by way of excise duty for the State Governments. The location of distillery site is shown in the District map of Maharashtra. (Figure: 1.1)
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 2
Figure-1.1 Location of the project
Site Location 褐
Tal.:Barshi
(Bhagwantnagar,
Uplai (T))
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 3
1.2 IDENTIFICATION OF PROJECT & PROJECT PROPONENT Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd.(ISML) is proposing a molasses based distillery of 45 KLPD capacity unit in the premises of existing sugar unit. The project site is at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), at Taluka Barshi in district Solapur. The land required for the proposed distillery is approximately 10 acres and is already in possession of ISML. Molasses is available for operation of distillery unit. The registration number of the karkhana is under the government of India no. U15421PN2010PLC135614 dated 17th February 2010. The projects features are given in Table-1.1 1.3 THE SALIENT FEATURES OF PROJECT SITE The salient features of the project are given in table below.
Table1.1: Salient Features of the Project
S.No. Feature Particulars
1.
Name and address of the Company
M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd., Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Tal: Barshi, Dist: Solapur
2. Project Proposed molasses based Distillery of 45 KLPD
3. Date of registration 17th February 2010
4. Accessibility Nearest Town Uplai 2 km (Aerial distance )
Nearest Railway station
Uplai 5 km (Aerial distance)
Nearest Airport Solapur 70 km (Aerial distance)
5. Total water requirement
360 m3/day
6. Raw material requirement
Molasses 24560 MT (Own )
29619 MT (Procured)
7. Fuel requirement Steam Source: Slop fired boiler with capacity of 23.5 TPH
8. Operational days 330/ year
9. Project Cost Rs. 84 crores
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 4
1.4 PROJECT LOCATION The proposed distillery project site is located at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), at Taluka Barshi in district Solapur. 10 km radial study area is covered by SOI Toposheets 47N/11 and 47N/12 and the same is shown in the map below.
Figure 1.2: Location of the Proposed Distillery
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 5
1.5 PURPOSE OF EIA & EMP Industrial activities such as distilleries invariably involve utilization of natural resources and generation of waste substances and they may have adverse consequence to the environment. However, mankind as it is developed today can not live without taking up these activities for his food, security or other needs. Hence, there is a need to harmonies developmental activities with the environmental concern. Consequently, there is a need to harmonious developmental activities with the environmental concern. EIA is one of the tools available with the planners to achieve the above goal. It is desirable to ensure that the project activity is sustainable. Hence, the environmental consequence must be characterized early in the project cycle and accounted for in the project design. The objective of EIA is to fore see the potential environmental problems that would arise out of the proposed development and address them in the project planning and design stage. The present EIA report incorporates the environmental consequence of the proposed distillery project along with the measures adopted in the distillery for control of pollution and enhancement of environmental quality. Alcohol is produced in the distilleries by fermentation and distillation processes. Molasses, a waste/byproduct of sugar industry is used as raw material by most of the distilleries. Spent wash produced as an effluent is the major pollutant from the distilleries. It is highly contaminated with inorganic and organic matter. Proper handling and disposal of spent wash is necessary to prevent its adverse effects on the environment. State and Central pollution control authorities have issued guidelines to the distilleries for treatment and safe disposal of spent wash. Accordingly, the distillery spent wash will be treated and disposed through bio-methanation, compost, evaporation and incineration. The salient feature of the proposed expansion is zero discharge of spent wash to environment. The proposed distillery project is listed under EIA Notification dated 14-09-2006 of Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), Government of India. Further, It is categorized under Category -A of Schedule 5 (g) of this notification. As per the above notification, prior clearance from MoEF is mandatory before establishment of this industry. Under Environmental Protection Act (EPA) 1986, before establishment of any project it is also mandatory for the project proponents to obtain consent on environmental angle from State pollution control board. EIA studies have to be conducted and its report is to be prepared for submission to the authorities along with the prescribed application forms to secure their clearance for the proposed project. Hence, the present report is prepared for submission to MoEF New Delhi.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 6
1.6 SCOPE OF THE STUDY MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune has been entrusted the task of carrying out EIA/EMP studies in order to obtain regulatory clearances from the the Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) , Industry – II of MoEF for the proposed project of 45 KLPD Distillery. The EIA studies were carried out for various environmental components so as to assess the anticipated adverse impacts due to the proposed facilities and to suggest suitable mitigation measures. Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) for the Environmental Appraisal has issued TOR for the preparation of the EIA report vide F.No. J-11011/118/2014-IA II (I)dated 24th July 2014, based on the documents submitted and presentation made by the project proponent. Copy of ToR along with compliance report is attached Annexure-1. As per the EIA notification dated 14th September 2006 of the Ministry of Environment & Forests, New Delhi (MoEF) EIA report is prepared in line with covering following chapters given in notification ( Appendix – III) Chapter 1. Introduction The chapter provides the purpose of the report, background information of the proposed distillery project, brief description of nature, size and location of project, objectives of the project, estimated project cost, scope and organization of the study. The key environmental legislation and the standards relevant to the project and the methodology adopted in preparation of this report have also been described in this chapter. Chapter 2. Project Description The chapter deals with the need of the project, location, environmental setting of the project, details of distillery project, other technical and design details and sources of pollution from the proposed activity and measures proposed to control pollution. Chapter 3. Description of the Environment The chapter presents the methodology and findings of field studies undertaken to establish the environmental baseline conditions, which is also supplemented by secondary published literature. Chapter 4. Anticipated Environmental Impacts & Mitigation Measures The chapter details the inferences drawn from the environmental impact assessment of the proposed distillery project during various phases of project advancement, such as design, location of project, construction, and regular operations. It also describes the overall impacts of the proposed project activities and underscores the areas of concern, which need mitigation measures.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 7
Chapter 5. Analysis of Alternatives (Technology & Site) The technology and project site alternatives are discussed in the chapter. Chapter 6. Environmental Monitoring Program Environmental monitoring requirements for effective implementation of mitigatory measures during operational phase have been delineated in this chapter Chapter 7. Additional Studies The chapter describes public consultation issues & various risks associated during operational stage of the project such as fuel storage, chemical storage, fire etc. A disaster management plan to minimise the risks or to combat the associated risks is also discussed. Chapter 8. Project Benefits This chapter describes various benefits of the project to the community in the vicinity and as well as to the region on the whole. Chapter 9. Environmental Management Plan (EMP) It also provides recommendations/ Environment Management Plan (EMP) including mitigation measures for minimizing the negative environmental impacts of the project. The assessment will cover the baseline data generation, predictions and evaluation of impact on various environmental components and preparation of adequate Environmental Management Plan. Chapter 10. Summary & Conclusion This Chapter highlights the expected benefits of the proposed plant to the socio-economic scenario in the study area and to the country as a whole.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 8
CHAPTER 2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION
2.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter covers the processes and affiliated facilities of the project including production and infrastructure, resources utilization, products formed along with wastes/ pollutants generated from the project. The information is needed to assess the impact of these activities on the environment and to delineate the mitigation measures. The proposed project is a distillery unit of 45 KLPD. The same is proposed within the factory premises. 2.2 NEED OF THE PROJECT The ethanol production and consumption in India has been increasing over the years as predicted by Indian Sugar Mills Association (ISMA), the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) and Indian Chemical Council (ICC) a tabulated in Table 2.1
Table 2.1: Ethanol Production and consumption in India (million litres)
Ethanol Production
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
ISMA( in sugar year)
1240 1925 2950 2715 1560 ---
ICC (in alcolhol year)
980 1590 2100 2200 1300 1680
USDA FAS 1199 1300 1898 2398 2150 1073
Ethanol consumption
ISMA( in sugar year)
1410 1550 1700 1840 2010 ---
ICC (in alcolhol year)
1470 1740 2120 2280 1650 2870
USDA FAS 1430 1479 1639 1750 1940 1780
Surplus ethanol
ISMA( in sugar year)
(-170) (375) (1250) (875) (- 450) ---
ICC (in alcolhol year)
(-490) (-150) (-20) (-80) (-350) (-1190)
USDA FAS (-231) -179 259 648 210 (-707)
Imports
ICC (in alcohol year)
490 150 20 80 350 ---
USDA FAS --- --- 29 15 70 280
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 9
The Table 2.1 reflects that the deficit has been increased from 350 million tonnes to 1190 million tonnes as per Indian Chemical Council in the year 2008 and 2009 respectively. Also as per ISMA the deficit recorded was 450 million tonnes in the year 2008. As per USFDA FAS there was a deficit of 707 million tonnes in the year 2009. The ethanol consumption demand by 2011-12 (million litres) is given in Table 2.2
Table 2.2: Ethanol consumption demand by 2011-12 (million litres)
Year Ethanol Demand (MMT)
Molasses production Th. KL
Ethanol production Utilization of Ethanol
Molasses Th. KL
Cane Th. KL
Total Th KL
Potable Th. KL
Industry Th KL
2001-02 416.14 8.77 1775 0 1775 648 527
2006-07 582.72 11.36 2300 1485 3785 765 2309
2011-12 756.35 11.36 2300 1485 3785 887 2054
2016-17 965.30 11.36 2300 1485 3785 1028 1754
Note: A growth of 3% in potable use and a 3.5% in chemical and other use has been assumed. (Source: Report of the Committee on Development of Biofuels published by planning commission April 16, 2003.)
The Table 2.2 reflects that the estimated ethanol consumption / utilization by chemical industry (which is growing at 3.5% p.a.) rose from 527 Th KL in 2001-02 to 2054 Th KL in 2011-12. which reflects increase in the demand of ethanol by industry. Also the demand for potable alcohol (which is growing at 3% p.a.) is projected to increase from 648 Th. KL in the year 2001-02 to 1028 Th. KL in the year 2016-17. The Tables 2.1 and 2.2 reflect the ever growing demand and supply gap in the ethanol production. Against this background ISML plans to propose molasses based distillery of 45 KLPD to meet the ever growing demand of RS/ENA for potable purposes and chemical industry. 2.3 PROPOSED DISTILLERY 2.3.1 Location The proposed distillery is located at factory premises at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai (T),
Tal: Barshi, Dist: Solapur. The approximate co-ordinates of the proposed 45 KLPD
distillery of ISML are Latitude:18o 13’21.51’’ N and Longitude: 75o 37’ 31.36’’ E.
2.3.2 Communication The nearest railway station is Upalai – 5 km away from the project site. The nearest National highway is SH- 67 which is located at 2 km away from the project site. The nearest airport is Solapur which is 70 km away from the project site.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 10
2.3.3 Land The land requirement for the proposed 45 KLPD distillery is approximately 10 acres amounting to an area of 40469 sq.m. which is available within premises of existing sugar factory of ISML. The item –wise breakup of the land required for the proposed distillery is tabulated in Table 2.3. titled “Item- wise split up of the land requirement”
Table 2.3: Item –wise split up of the land requirement
Proposed molasses storage tank 31 X 31 961 M2
Day molasses tank 5 X 5 25
Molasses unloading section (ISML scope) 18.6 X 11.4 212.04 M2
Spent wash lagoon 30 X 20 600 M2
Emergency collection room 3 X 3 9 M3
Security cabin 5 X 5 25.00 M2
Admin office & excise office 17 X 15 255.00 M2
Condensate polishing unit 25 X 20 500 M2
Water treatment plant 33.8 X 83+(83.2/12 X 48.5-33.8)
3713.86
Process; soft & DM water tank 21 X 10 210 M2
Raw water tank 17 X 15 255 M2
Independent evap, cooling tower 7.7 X 7.4 56.98 M2
Distillation, dehydration cooling tower 9.8 X 7.4 72.52 M2
Fermentation cooling tower 6.9 X 5 34.50 M2
F A receiving & storage 33.8 X 83+(83.21.2 X 48.5-33.8
3713.86 M2
RS , ENA receiving & storage 53.3 X 25+34.8 X (44.1-25)
1997.18 M2
MCC room, PLC & lab 23 X 6 138 M2
Independent evap. Section 26 X 11 286 M2
Distillation & F A section 24 X 18 432 M2
Fermentation section 32 X 23 736 M2
Description TOTAL 14234
The Google image depicting the proposed distillery is depicted in Figure 2.1 on next
page and the layout plan is depicted in Figure 2.2 on subsequent page.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 11
Figure 2.1 : Google Earth Image depicting the proposed distillery
Proposed distillery
Sugar Unit
Co-generation Unit
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 12
Figure 2.2 : Layout plan depicting various facilities 2.3.4 Water requirement The total water available per year is 118800 m3/annum. As the operational days are 330. The water requirement for the proposed the distillery unit is 360 m3/day. The water demand will be fulfilled from existing water supply scheme/ existing well. 2.3.5 Water Balance
The water balance for the proposed 45 KLPD distillery is given below in Table 2.3. The
detailed water balance diagram for the same is given in Figure 2.3.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 13
Table 2.3 : Water Balance for Proposed 45 KLPD Distillery
Sr.No Water usage
Water requirement
Losses /evaporation
Effluent generation
1. Domestic 5 1 4
2. Industrial use
210 210 0
3. Cooling 75 72 3
4. Boiler 70 67 3
Total 360 350 10
Note:- All figures in m3/day
Figure 2.3 : Water Balance for the proposed distillery
(Note: All figures in m3/day)
Total Water Requirement: 360
Industrial Processing: 210
Spent wash:
Multieffect Evaporator:
Slop fired boiler: 0
Losses: 210
Domestic Usage: 5
Sewage: 4
ETP
Losses: 1
Cooling Makeup: 75
Effluent: 3
ETP
Losses: 72
Boiler Makeup: 70
Boiler Blowdown: 3
ETP
Losses: 67
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 14
2.3.6 Steam Balance Proposed Distillery Unit The distillery employs multi pressure system for achieving steam economy. The working steam pressure is 3.5 kg/cm2g. The steam from back pressure turbine will be supplied to fuel ethanol plant using 23.5 TPH boiler. The total steam requirement for the proposed fuel ethanol plant will be as under Steam Quantity:
-aerator, 1.00 TPH Steam will be generated through slop/ effluent fired boiler. 2.3.7 Raw material requirement Proposed Distillery Unit
As the sugar plant will crush about 5.00 lakh MT of sugarcane at the rate of 3200 MT/Day, molasses of around 24560 MT will be produced and will be utilized by the distillery unit, leaving 29619 MT outside molasses (from sister concern) as the total molasses requirement is 54179 MT for optimum level of operation.
Hence the ISML can easily generate the required quantity of molasses and procured molasses from nearby sugar mills to operate plant for 330 days. Molasses storage tanks – 2Nos.X9000MT Molasses Balance: Molasses require for 45 KLPD Distillery for 1 day- 164 MT 330 days- 54179MT Own Molasses- 24560MT Procured Molasses (sister concern)- 29619MT 2.3.8 Manpower requirement The total manpower requirement is 75 nos. out of which 63 will be workers and 12 will be staff members.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 15
2.3.9 Manufacturing Details 1. Fermentation
Molasses, diluted with water to the desired concentration is metered continuously into a single tank fermenter. Additives like urea (in the form of pellets or prills) and defoaming oil are also introduced in the fermenter as required. There is an automatic foam level sensing and dosing system for defoaming oil. Every Kilogram of alcohol produced, generates about 290 Kcal of heat. This excess heat is removed by continuous circulation of fermenting wash through an external plate heat exchanger called the Fermenter Cooler. The fermenter temperature is always maintained between 32 and 35deg.C, the range optimum for efficient fermentation. The yeast for the fermentation is initially (i.e. during start-up of the plant) developed in the Propagation Section described further on. Once propagated, a viable cell population of about 500 million cells/ ml is maintained by yeast recycling and continuous aeration of the fermenter. Fluctuations in the yeast count of +/- 20% have little effect on the overall fermenter productivity. Yeast cell vitality which is usually above 70% may, in times of stress. (such as prolonged shut-downs) drop to 50% without affecting the fermentation. Fermented wash passes through a series of hydrocyclones (one to three or move in number depending on plant capacity), which remove grit, iron filings and similar heavy particulate matter. This rejected material along with some wash, is taken to the bottom portion of the wash column for alcohol recovery. The overflow from the first hydrocyclone is taken a wash tank, also provided with an arrangement to facilitate removal of heavy settable particulate matter. Overflow from the wash tank is taken to the yeast separator, which clarifies the wash. The hydrocyclone and the wash tank protect the separator from erosion damage by removing grit and similar hard particles.
Yeast Recycling: The yeast in the fermented wash is removed as a 45 to 55 v/v slurry, and is returned to the fermenter. This feature ensures that a high yeast cell concentration is achieved and maintained in the fermenter. By recirculating grown, active yeast, sugar that would have otherwise been consumed in yeast growth, is made available for ethanol production, ensuring high process efficiency.
Distillation: Clarified or de-yeasted wash flows by gravity to the propagation vessel No. III, which during continuous production, operates as an intermediate wash tank. From here, fermented wash is pumped to the wash preheater, which uses vapours from the rectifying column to preheat wash. Further heating is done in an exchange of heat with spent wash (see flow sheet for primary distillation).
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 16
Preheated wash then enters the degasifying column of the distillation section.
Primary Distillation: The CO2 and the degasifying section help remove the CO2 and other non-condensable entrained in the wash. The wash column is first column in the distillation section. It is also called the analyser. Wash is boiled in this column with steam either supplied as live steam from the boiler (after pressure reduction and desuperheating) or from a reboiler which generates steam by evaporating effluent wash.
Alcohol in wash vaporizes and is carried, along with water vapour, to the top of the wash column from where it goes to the rectification column. As wash travels down the analyser, it is progressively ‘stripped’ of its alcohol content. At a point in the column, where the alcohol concentration is 0.5 to 1.0% v/v, a portion of the wash is drawn off.
Propagation: The propagation section is a feeder unit to the fermenter. Yeast, either Saccharomyees cereviseae or Schizosaccharomyees pombe (the choice being determined by other process parameters, mainly the downstream effluent treatment system) is grown in 3 stages. The first two stages are designed for aseptic growth. Propagation vessel III develops the inoculum using pasteurized molasses solution as the medium. This vessel has a dual function. During propagation, it serves for inoculum build-up. When the fermenter enters the continuous production mode, Propagation Vessel III is used as an intermediate wash tank. Propagation is carried out only to start up the process initially or after very long shut-downs during which the fermenter is emptied.
CO2 Scrubbing and Recovery: The carbon-di-oxide produced during fermentation is scrubbed with water in packed-bed scrubber, to recover alcohol. The water from the scrubber is returned to the fermenter. About 1.0% of the total alcohol production is saved by scrubbing the fermenter off gas. In plants where it is desired to recover carbon-di-oxide, a part of the wash is drawn into a separate vessel and is aerated there. This external aeration allows the recovery of CO2 uncontaminated with air. More details of this system can be supplied on request.
Fermentation Parameters (Typical): The pH of the fermenter is maintained between 4.0 & 4.8 usually without addition of any acid. The alcohol concentration is maintained between 7.0 & 7.5 % v/v, unless a highly concentrate effluent is to be produced. Conversion of sugar to ethanol is instantaneous, and the residual sugar concentration is maintained below 0.2 % w/w as glucose. This usually corresponds to a residual reducing substances concentration of 2.0 to 2.5 % w/w in wash. All the nutrient elements necessary for yeast growth exist in adequate quantities as impurities in molasses. Occasionally, Nitrogen may have to be supplemented. Defoaming oil (DFO), say Turkey Red Oil is added to the fermenter by an automated DFO dosing system, to control foaming. Usually no other additives are required.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 17
Flexibility: This process accords tremendous flexibility to the operator. Process conditions and plant design can be varied to suit individual requirements of alcohol quality, effluent concentration and characteristics.
2. Multi Pressure Vacuum Distillation: After fermentation the next stage in the manufacture of alcohol is to separate alcohol from fermented wash and to concentrate it to 95% alcohol called as rectified spirit. For this purpose, distillation process is employed. Distillation step consumes a considerable amount of energy and is also a deciding factor in the quality of ethanol produced. Hence, in line with the demand of the industry, efforts have always been to minimize requirement of energy and to improve the basic quality of alcohol produced. Ease of operation, reliability, lower down time and flexibility of operations are other parameters considered during the design. Three basic types of plant are designed: a) One is to produce primary quality of alcohol, usually referred to as 'Rectified Spirit' (R.S.) from the fermented wash. Such plants are also referred to as ‘Primary distillation’ plants. b) Second is to produce fine quality of spirit usually referred to as 'Extra Neutral Alcohol' (ENA) starting from R.S. Such plants are also referred to as 'secondary distillation' plants. c) Third is to directly produce fine quality alcohol (ENA) from fermented wash. Such plants are referred to as 'wash (mash) to ENA' plants, where the two steps of primary and secondary distillation are combined. Such plants usually have lower consumption of energy than two separate plants Multi-pressure vacuum distillation system for production of Rectified Spirit / ENA consists of following distillation columns namely 1. Degasifying cum analyzer column – Operation under vacuum 2. Pre-rectification column – Operation under vacuum 3. Rectification cum Exhaust Column - Operated under pressure 4. Recovery column - Operated under atmospheric 5. Extractive distillation column – Operated under vacuum 6. Simmering column – Operated under atmospheric Benefits of Pressure Vacuum Distillation: - Following are the advantages of pressure vacuum distillation.
Since the analyzer column operates under vacuum, the formation of by-products such as acetal may minimize there by improvement in quality of alcohol.
Pre-rectification column ensure removal of sulfur compounds/mercaptans and also reduces load of lower boiling volatile compounds passing on to Rectifier cum exhaust column.
The chances of scaling due to invert solubility of certain precipitating inorganic salts are minimized in vacuum distillation.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 18
Vacuum distillation requires low steam consumption with reboiler Integrated Multi-products Concept: It is now possible to install a distillation system, which can produce different products. In the proposed scheme; the production of fuel ethanol have been considered. This allows flexibility of operation and various products can be manufactured depending on the market demand. This integrated multi-product system involves less capital investment as compared to independent system. In this type of system, switching over from one product to another is quite easy and there is no chance of contamination of one product with another. The system can work under multi-pressure principle with few columns operating under vacuum and few under pressure/atmospheric. 3. Dehydration of Alcohol Molecular Sieve: The feed (Rectified Spirit) ,pumped from the storage tanks, Is heated through the heat exchanger by the dehydrated alcohol ,then heated Rs of 93% to 96% is fed to the top of the distillation column. The liquid passes through the distillation column where ethanol is stripped of. The alcohol free liquid called spent lees is separated and discharged from the bottom of the distillation column and the ethanol stream, with strength of about 96% by volume, is removed as vapor, at the top section of the distillation column and feed to the molecular sieve unit after a super heating about 115oC by steam in the heat exchanger. Fusel oils are removed from an intermediate point of the column in order to avoid any risk of flooding of the column and feed to the static settling device where are separated from the weak water which are recycled to the column. The distillation column has an operating pressure of about 160 kPa(A) and is heated with low pressure steam by means of reboiler. This solution shows following advantages:
Total recovery of steam condensate which is recycled to the steam boiler at high temperature with consequent increasing of the efficiency of the reboiler (higher production of steam per unit of fuel)
Lower cost for softening of demineralization of raw water to be fed to the boiler as steam condensate does not need any treatment
Lower quantity of stillage, potential source of pollution The super-heated ethanol stream removed at the top of the distillation column feeds one of the two sieve beds is now in regeneration mode.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 19
The second sieve bed when in regeneration mode (under vacuum) and receives a small amount of vapour from bed working in over pressure. As soon as regeneration is finished (a regeneration cycle lasts about 5 minutes), an automatic control system changes the operating conditions of the two sieve beds in order to have the first sieve bed in regeneration and the second one in dehydration mode. The dehydration process releases a vapour ethanol stream with a very small amount of water (500 ppm or less), which is condensed in the condensor cooled in the heat exchangers and sent to the storage as dehydrated alcohol. The regeneration process releases a certain amount of absorbed water and ethanol, which are condensed in the condenser and recycled to the column. Cooling media of the first cooling step of the dehydrated alcohol (condenser) is the regeneration stream recycled to the distillation column and cooling media of the second cooling step of the dehydrated alcohol (condenser) is the fed stock coming from the storage tanks, which is preheated as herein above described. Remaining vapors and liquid are condensed and cooled by cooling water in S &T or P&F heat exchangers. The unit operation is fully automatic and all operations are governed by logics executed by a PLC Control system. The process flow diagram is given in Annexure 2. Ethanol storage tanks details for proposed distillery:
S. No. Description Qty Volume (each)
Nos. m3
1. RS Day Receiver Tank 3 60
2. RS Bulk Storage Tank 1 700
3. IS Day Receiver Tank 3 15
4. IS Bulk Storage Tank 1 200
5. ENA Day Receiver Tank 3 60
6. ENA Bulk Storage Tank 3 700
7. TA Day Receiver Tank 2 15
8. TA Bulk Storage Tank 1 200
9. Denatured Spirit Storage Tank 1 50
10. AA Day Receiver Tank 3 60
11. AA Bulk Storage Tank 2 400
12. Fusel Oil Storage Tank 1 10
13. Intermediate RS Tank 1 120
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 20
2.3.10 Pollution control measures Spent wash treatment and disposal options As per recent Environmental Protection Norms from Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), it is Corporates Responsibility to achieve Zero Discharge in Inland Surface Water. Considering this aspect, following treatment system / Options may have to be considered by the Distilleries.
Primary treatment Secondary treatment Disposal
Concentration (Reboiler)
Composting On land
Concentration (60-65 Brix)
Incineration of Concentrated Spentwash
As Auxiliary fuel for boiler
Technology Alternatives 1. Anaerobic digestion process: Anaerobic digestion is the biological decomposition of organic matter in absence of oxygen. In the recent years, the escalation of energy costs and environmental concerns have increased the interest in direct anaerobic treatment of distillery spentwash. Anaerobic digestion consists of the two distinct stages, which occurs simultaneously. The first stage is known as Acid Fermentation consist of hydrolysis and liquefaction of high molecular weight organic acid-by-acid forming bacteria. Acetic acid and butyric acid is the most common product in the first stage. The second stage is known as Methane Fermentation or Methanogenesis. It is the conversion of organic acid into methane and carbon dioxide by acid splitting methane-forming bacteria. The major benefits and limitations are as follows. Limitations: 1. Relatively long periods of time are required to start up the process. 2. It is a Primary treatment method. The treated effluent BOD will be in the range of
5000-8000 mg/L and hence an adequate post-treatment (BoD
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 21
The mixing of spent wash and press-mud (50-70% moisture) is being carried out (3.5:1 proportion) in trenches with the help of excavator- cum –loader for mixing, turning, loading and unloading of compost material. Addition of cow dung will provide bacterial culture required for composting. It is observed that in the first five days, fungal activity is predominant and in subsequent days bacterial activity continues until stabilization of organic matter into humus is accomplished. Limitations:
1. Area requirement for Bio-composting process is very high. 2. Press mud requirement is high. 3. Total time required for completion of one composting operation cycle is very
high. 4. It is not possible to continue composting process during rainy season as a result
of that it is essential to stop distillery operation if bio-composting is a method of effluents treatment.
5. Spent storage tank of huge capacity is required. 6. The distillery operation is permitted for not more than 270 days per Annum
3. Spent wash Incineration Technology:
The spent wash of a distillery process is a serious problem by way of threat to the environment. Its volume from continuous fermentation plant is as large as 480 KL/day for a distillery of 60 KL/day capacity if Mojj distillation technology of multi pressure distillation with integrated evaporator system has been used and it may vary as per different technologies of Praj as well as Biostil of Alfa- Laval The spent wash evaporation technology is a multiple effect evaporator system in which heat recovered from one effect is used to concentrate spent wash in second effect evaporator with continuous recirculation of concentrated spent wash within the system until desired concentration is obtained. This entire concentration process is carried out under vacuum leading to less consumption of steam and maximum concentration of spent wash with in less period of time. The concentrated spent wash generated after entire process of evaporation is then sprayed in a furnace with auxiliary fuel such as bagasse and is then burnt in a boiler.
Choice of Spent wash Treatment System In order to fulfill the Pollution Norms and to achieve zero Discharge and at the same time to operate distillery for the period more than 300 days per annum, Factory proposes to go for spent wash Concentration and Incineration Technology simultaneously generating Steam and Power for the process and Distillery. With effective utilization of such a technology big hurdle of spent wash disposal will be solved and distilleries will become zero effluent discharging units to be called as “Evergreen BIO- FUEL Refineries”.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 22
Spent wash Generation and treatment
Sr. No. Particular Details
1. Spent wash Generation 400 kl/day
2. Sent to Multi effect evaporator
3. Quantity of spent wash remaining 94 kl /day
4. Sent to slop fired boiler
Boiler capacity 23.5 TPH
Stack height 70 mts.
Pollution control equipment ESP of efficiency 99.9 %
5. Hence zero discharge is achieved
ISML proposes to go for spent wash Concentration and Incineration Technology simultaneously generating Steam and Power for the process and Distillery.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 23
CHAPTER 3 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT
3.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter covers the description of existing environmental conditions of the study area with respect to the prominent environmental attributes. The data was collected from both primary and secondary sources. Primary data was collected through environmental monitoring & survey in the study area. The sampling locations are selected based on the following: i. Existing topography and meteorological conditions. ii. Locations of water intake and waste disposal points. iii. Location of human habilitation and other sensitive areas present in the vicinity of
the proposed project site. iv. Representative areas for baseline conditions. v. Accessibility for sampling Secondary data were collected from previous studies carried out and the data from Government records. The data thus collected were compared with the standards prescribed for the respective environmental parameters.
Study Period: The studies were conducted during the post-monsoon period of October, November, and December 2014.
3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS As per the Terms of Reference (TOR) specified by the MoEF, the environmental parameters are studied including air, noise, water, soil and ecology and presented in this chapter. Both primary and secondary data is collected to describe the baseline environmental status. The study area for monitoring of environmental quality includes 10 km region around the project site. Monitoring location map is given in Annexure 3 3.3 DETAILS OF SITE AND ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING OF STUDY AREA The proposed plant site is located at Latitude: 18o 13’21.51’’ N, Longitude: 75o 37’ 31.36’’ E. Site is well connected with state highway -67 connecting to Barshi and Paranda (2 km). Nearest Railway station is Upalai (5 km) and nearest Airport is
Solapur at the distance of 70 km. The land is in possession of sugar factory of which
10 acres is utilized for establishment of the distillery and its associated activities. The
site and its immediate surroundings were barren without any vegetation. However, the
industry has developed planned greenery and green belt in the premise. a) There are
no distilleries within the 10 km radial study area.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by MITCON Consultancy & Engineering Services Ltd., Pune 24
Table 3.1: Environmental Setting of the Study Area
Sr. No. Particulars Details
1. Location Bhagwantnagar, Uplai(T), Tal: Barshi, Dist: Solapur,
2. Latitude 18o 13’21.51’’ North
3. Longitude 75o 37’ 31.36’’ East
4. Total Plant Area Total Land Area: 10 acres (for distillery)
5. Proposed Plant Capacity Distillery - 45 KLPD
6. Nearest Railway Station Upalai, 2 Km
7. Nearest Airport Solapur, 70 Km
8. Nearest Highway SH-67
9. Nearest Village Upalai 2 Km
10. Nearest City Barshi - 8 Km
11. Nearest River/ water body
Pimpalwadi Dam -9.5 Km
12. National Park/ Wildlife Sanctuary/Biosphere reserve
None
13. Reserve Forests None
14. Archeological monuments None
3.4 TOPOGRAPHY
The 10 km radial study area is covered by SOI Toposheets 47 N/11/6 and 47 N/12. The R.L of the project site is as indicated by the contours on the toposheet is 540 m. The highest R.L in north is 540 m while the lowest R.L in south is 480 m which indicates that the ground is sloping from North towards South. The site is a plian area with undulating surface.
Environmental Impact Assessment Report Proposed Distillery of 45KLPD at Bhagwantnagar, Upalai(T), Barshi by M/s Indreshwar Sugar Mills Ltd. EME/CS/EIA- ISML-DIST/2014-15/104:R00dt.:12/09/2014
Prepared by