Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A
Environmental Indemnity in Real EstateTransactions: Allocating Risks ofPotential Cleanup CostsNegotiating Key Provisions, Drafting and Reviewing the Agreement to Ensure Complete Coverage
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
TUESDAY, AUGUST 15, 2017
The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer'sspeakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If youhave any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 10.
Today’s faculty features:
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
R. Morgan Gilhuly, Partner, Barg Coffin Lewis & Trapp, San Francisco
Cindy J. Karlson, Founder, Law Offices of Cindy J. Karlson, Groton, Conn.
Tips for Optimal Quality
Sound QualityIf you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the qualityof your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internetconnection.
If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial1-866-873-1442 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, pleasesend us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we canaddress the problem.
If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance.
Viewing QualityTo maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,press the F11 key again.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Sound QualityIf you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the qualityof your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internetconnection.
If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial1-866-873-1442 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, pleasesend us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we canaddress the problem.
If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance.
Viewing QualityTo maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,press the F11 key again.
Continuing Education Credits
In order for us to process your continuing education credit, you must confirm yourparticipation in this webinar by completing and submitting the AttendanceAffirmation/Evaluation after the webinar.
A link to the Attendance Affirmation/Evaluation will be in the thank you emailthat you will receive immediately following the program.
For additional information about continuing education, call us at 1-800-926-7926ext. 35.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
In order for us to process your continuing education credit, you must confirm yourparticipation in this webinar by completing and submitting the AttendanceAffirmation/Evaluation after the webinar.
A link to the Attendance Affirmation/Evaluation will be in the thank you emailthat you will receive immediately following the program.
For additional information about continuing education, call us at 1-800-926-7926ext. 35.
Program Materials
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, pleasecomplete the following steps:
• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see aPDF of the slides for today's program.
• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, pleasecomplete the following steps:
• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see aPDF of the slides for today's program.
• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
Cindy J. Karlson
Phone: [email protected]
5
R. Morgan GilhulyBarg Coffin Lewis & Trapp, LLPPhone: [email protected]
I. General Principles for Contracts and Indemnities forReal Estate Transactions
II. The Architecture of an Environmental Indemnity
III. See You In Court: Case Law
IV. Practical Tips
I. General Principles for Contracts and Indemnities forReal Estate Transactions
II. The Architecture of an Environmental Indemnity
III. See You In Court: Case Law
IV. Practical Tips
6
General Principles #1
You cannot contractaway your liability vis-à-vis the government
7
General Principles #2
As the Third Circuit said with regardto indemnities and CERCLA liability:
“Agreements to indemnify or holdharmless are enforceable betweenthe parties but not against thegovernment.” Beazer East, Inc. v.Mead Corp., 34 F.3d 206 (3d Cir. 1994)
As the Third Circuit said with regardto indemnities and CERCLA liability:
“Agreements to indemnify or holdharmless are enforceable betweenthe parties but not against thegovernment.” Beazer East, Inc. v.Mead Corp., 34 F.3d 206 (3d Cir. 1994)
8
General Principles #3
For the most part,contracts only bind theparties to the contractand do not bind thirdparties
– Exceptions (sometimes):
• Successors and assigns
• Affiliates
• Running with the land
For the most part,contracts only bind theparties to the contractand do not bind thirdparties
– Exceptions (sometimes):
• Successors and assigns
• Affiliates
• Running with the land
9
General Principles #4
An environmental indemnity is only as good as theassets of the party giving the indemnity
Consider parent company guarantee, letter of credit, reserves, escrows,other financial mechanisms
An environmental indemnity is only as good as theassets of the party giving the indemnity
Consider parent company guarantee, letter of credit, reserves, escrows,other financial mechanisms
10
Key Questions to Ask and Answer
Who is giving protection?
Who is receiving protection?
“Indemnify, defend, and hold harmless”?
What is covered?
What is not covered?
Proportional fault, or not?
“Arising from or related to” vs. “to the extent caused by”
Who is giving protection?
Who is receiving protection?
“Indemnify, defend, and hold harmless”?
What is covered?
What is not covered?
Proportional fault, or not?
“Arising from or related to” vs. “to the extent caused by”
11
What Kinds of Liabilities Might Occur?
12
Types of Liability
CleanupLiabilities
1st PartyEconomic
Losses
ThirdParty
Claims
ThirdParty
ClaimsVoluntaryCleanup
NaturalResourceDamages
Gov’tOrderedCleanup
BusinessInterrupti
on&Delays
AddedCosts SiteRedevelop-ment
Diminished
PropertyValueToxic Tort Property
Damage
13
Site Cleanup Liabilities
Who is responsible – Buyer or Seller?
For what? Pre-closing legacy contamination only? Presumptions and baselines
Only government ordered cleanup?
Voluntary cleanup?
Cleanup of soil and groundwater only? Asbestos, lead paint, mold, drum removal, demolition?
Who is responsible – Buyer or Seller?
For what? Pre-closing legacy contamination only? Presumptions and baselines
Only government ordered cleanup?
Voluntary cleanup?
Cleanup of soil and groundwater only? Asbestos, lead paint, mold, drum removal, demolition?
14
Site Cleanup Liabilities What is the scope of cleanup covered? Industrial/commercial versus residential? Risked-based cleanup?
Use of institutional controls permitted? (e.g. site managementplan)?
How implemented and complied with? Deed restrictions? (e.g. for sensitive uses/site redevelopment)
Who controls communications with government?
What is the scope of cleanup covered? Industrial/commercial versus residential? Risked-based cleanup?
Use of institutional controls permitted? (e.g. site managementplan)?
How implemented and complied with? Deed restrictions? (e.g. for sensitive uses/site redevelopment)
Who controls communications with government?
15
Third Party Claims
Toxic tort claims Examples: Site workers, futureoccupants, offsite neighbors
Property damage claims Example: Offsite neighbors
Natural resource damages
Toxic tort claims Examples: Site workers, futureoccupants, offsite neighbors
Property damage claims Example: Offsite neighbors
Natural resource damages
16
First Party Costs and Damages First party costs and damages
– Site redevelopment costs– Voluntary cleanup– Diminution in value of property
acquired– Business interruption/delay– Other direct costs to buyer
IMPORTANT: Many courtsinterpret standard indemnities tocover only third party claims, notfirst party damages, costs and losses
Draft accordingly
First party costs and damages– Site redevelopment costs– Voluntary cleanup– Diminution in value of property
acquired– Business interruption/delay– Other direct costs to buyer
IMPORTANT: Many courtsinterpret standard indemnities tocover only third party claims, notfirst party damages, costs and losses
Draft accordingly
17
Site Redevelopment Costs
– Future owners may incuradded costs beyond gov’tordered cleanup• Excavation in connection with
redevelopment/construction
• Disposal of contaminated media
– Example - parking garage
• Cost of studies and hazmatcontractors
– Future owners may incuradded costs beyond gov’tordered cleanup• Excavation in connection with
redevelopment/construction
• Disposal of contaminated media
– Example - parking garage
• Cost of studies and hazmatcontractors
18
Vapor Intrusion Liabilities
Vapor intrusion intobuildings
Investigation and testing
HVAC control
Engineered vapormitigation systems
Installation and longterm O&M
Who pays? Who controls?Who is liable to thegovernment? To occupants?
Vapor intrusion intobuildings
Investigation and testing
HVAC control
Engineered vapormitigation systems
Installation and longterm O&M
Who pays? Who controls?Who is liable to thegovernment? To occupants?
19
Part II: The Architecture of anEnvironmental Indemnity
20
PART II AGENDA Indemnities: Not One Size Fits All
Specific Language Choices
Complex Structures
Synthesizing Indemnity Provisions With The MasterAgreement And Other Deal Documents
Indemnities: Not One Size Fits All
Specific Language Choices
Complex Structures
Synthesizing Indemnity Provisions With The MasterAgreement And Other Deal Documents
21
Key Contract Terms to AllocateEnvironmental Liabilities
Environmental Indemnity
• “We agree to indemnify, defend and hold harmless….”
Covenants and Affirmative Commitments
• “We agree to perform government ordered cleanup and reimburse youradded site redevelopment costs…”
Releases and Waivers
• Covenants not to sue
Representations and Warranties
• “We are in compliance with all environmental laws as of the closing…”
Environmental Indemnity
• “We agree to indemnify, defend and hold harmless….”
Covenants and Affirmative Commitments
• “We agree to perform government ordered cleanup and reimburse youradded site redevelopment costs…”
Releases and Waivers
• Covenants not to sue
Representations and Warranties
• “We are in compliance with all environmental laws as of the closing…”
22
NOT ONE SIZE FITS ALL
Do optics matter?
Sweet and simple Allocate based on knowledge of
existing conditions at closing
Complex indemnityprovisions Carve out specific environmental
conditions
Do optics matter?
Sweet and simple Allocate based on knowledge of
existing conditions at closing
Complex indemnityprovisions Carve out specific environmental
conditions
23
NOT ONE SIZE FITS ALLExample:
Tenant will indemnify and hold Landlord harmless fromand against any and all liabilities, losses, damages, suits,penalties, claims and demands of every kind, includingreasonable attorneys’ fees, arising out of or relating toany environmental conditions on the property or the
operations conducted thereon.
Example:
Tenant will indemnify and hold Landlord harmless fromand against any and all liabilities, losses, damages, suits,penalties, claims and demands of every kind, includingreasonable attorneys’ fees, arising out of or relating toany environmental conditions on the property or the
operations conducted thereon.
24
NOT ONE SIZE FITS ALLTenant will indemnify and
hold Landlord harmless fromand against any and all
liabilities, losses, damages,suits, penalties, claims and
demands of every kind,including reasonable
attorneys’ fees, arising out ofor relating to any
environmental conditions onthe property or the
operations conductedthereon.
Issue Spotting
1. Who can recovermonies (successors andassigns)?
2. Define any terms?3. Length of indemnity
period?4. Which costs covered?5. Which costs are NOT
covered?
Tenant will indemnify andhold Landlord harmless from
and against any and allliabilities, losses, damages,suits, penalties, claims and
demands of every kind,including reasonable
attorneys’ fees, arising out ofor relating to any
environmental conditions onthe property or the
operations conductedthereon.
Issue Spotting
1. Who can recovermonies (successors andassigns)?
2. Define any terms?3. Length of indemnity
period?4. Which costs covered?5. Which costs are NOT
covered?
25
SPECIFIC LANGUAGE CHOICES
Decision Point: Crafting general or specific language forscope of the indemnity
Pros Avoid potential costly litigation Manage parties’ expectations
Cons Could incur additional transactional costs in negotiation Could unknowingly exclude costs if provisions too specific
Decision Point: Crafting general or specific language forscope of the indemnity
Pros Avoid potential costly litigation Manage parties’ expectations
Cons Could incur additional transactional costs in negotiation Could unknowingly exclude costs if provisions too specific
26
SPECIFIC LANGUAGE CHOICES Definitions are critical!!!
“Environmental Laws”- Understand what is and is not included (agency guidance,directives, orders?)
“Hazardous Substances”- Be careful if you only limit it to substances under CERCLA- Petroleum and its by-products, PCBs, asbestos, lead paint, ureaformaldehyde (building materials), mold, microbial matter- Also consider including solid waste, explosives, radioactive
materials- Exclude substances ordinarily used for purposes of cleaning
Definitions are critical!!!
“Environmental Laws”- Understand what is and is not included (agency guidance,directives, orders?)
“Hazardous Substances”- Be careful if you only limit it to substances under CERCLA- Petroleum and its by-products, PCBs, asbestos, lead paint, ureaformaldehyde (building materials), mold, microbial matter- Also consider including solid waste, explosives, radioactive
materials- Exclude substances ordinarily used for purposes of cleaning
27
“Environmental Laws” are… “Environmental Laws” means any and all applicable
federal, state, or local law or regulation, whether now inforce or as amended or enacted in the future, pertaining topublic health or the environment, including, withoutlimitation, ……”***
***NOTE – These are excerpts are for example purpose onlyand should not be relied upon as legal advice.
“Environmental Laws” means any federal, state or localstatute, law, ordinance, code, common law, rule,regulation, order or decree, regulating, relating to, orimposing liability or other obligations concerning theprotection of the environment, natural resources, and/oractivities concerning air, water, solid waste, resourceprotection, inland wetlands, watercourses, orenvironmental conditions or involving any asbestos-containing materials, materials presumed by law tocontain asbestos, PCBs, petroleum, petroleum byproduct,and/or hazardous or toxic substances, chemicals ormaterials, or any other waste, materials, pollutant orcontaminant that is regulated to protect the environment,as may now or at any time hereafter be in effect, includingwithout limitation, the Comprehensive EnvironmentalResponse, Compensation and Liability Act, as amended (42U.S.C. Sections 9601, et seq.) (“CERCLA”), the ResourceConservation and Recovery Act, as amended (42 U.S.C.Sections 6901, et seq.), the Hazardous MaterialsTransportation Act, as amended (49 U.S.C. Sections 1801,et seq.), the Clean Air Act, as amended (42 U.S.C. Sections7401, et seq., the Toxic Substances Control Act, asamended (15 U.S.C. Sections 2601, et seq.), the Clean WaterAct, as amended (33 U.S.C. Sections 1251, et seq.), and/orany other applicable environmental law or any regulationspromulgated under any of the foregoing.
“Environmental Laws” means any and all applicablefederal, state, or local law or regulation, whether now inforce or as amended or enacted in the future, pertaining topublic health or the environment, including, withoutlimitation, ……”***
***NOTE – These are excerpts are for example purpose onlyand should not be relied upon as legal advice.
“Environmental Laws” means any federal, state or localstatute, law, ordinance, code, common law, rule,regulation, order or decree, regulating, relating to, orimposing liability or other obligations concerning theprotection of the environment, natural resources, and/oractivities concerning air, water, solid waste, resourceprotection, inland wetlands, watercourses, orenvironmental conditions or involving any asbestos-containing materials, materials presumed by law tocontain asbestos, PCBs, petroleum, petroleum byproduct,and/or hazardous or toxic substances, chemicals ormaterials, or any other waste, materials, pollutant orcontaminant that is regulated to protect the environment,as may now or at any time hereafter be in effect, includingwithout limitation, the Comprehensive EnvironmentalResponse, Compensation and Liability Act, as amended (42U.S.C. Sections 9601, et seq.) (“CERCLA”), the ResourceConservation and Recovery Act, as amended (42 U.S.C.Sections 6901, et seq.), the Hazardous MaterialsTransportation Act, as amended (49 U.S.C. Sections 1801,et seq.), the Clean Air Act, as amended (42 U.S.C. Sections7401, et seq., the Toxic Substances Control Act, asamended (15 U.S.C. Sections 2601, et seq.), the Clean WaterAct, as amended (33 U.S.C. Sections 1251, et seq.), and/orany other applicable environmental law or any regulationspromulgated under any of the foregoing.
28
SPECIFIC LANGUAGE CHOICES Environmental Claims –third party demand or can
buyer or seller make direct claims to reimburse coststhey incurred not at the request of thirdparty/government requirement? (what about a bank?)
Release – how broad you define a “release” will impactthe scope of the indemnity “spilling, leaking, pumping, pouring, emitting, injecting,
escaping or dumping” (what about “migration”? Potential or threatened
releases included?)
Environmental Claims –third party demand or canbuyer or seller make direct claims to reimburse coststhey incurred not at the request of thirdparty/government requirement? (what about a bank?)
Release – how broad you define a “release” will impactthe scope of the indemnity “spilling, leaking, pumping, pouring, emitting, injecting,
escaping or dumping” (what about “migration”? Potential or threatened
releases included?)
29
SPECIFIC LANGUAGE CHOICES Key concepts:
How is “known environmental liability” defined?
What is included as an “Environmental Matter”? Definition could include – generation, storage, handling, treatment and disposal of
hazardous materials/substances (not just release of same) Compliance with permits Financial assurance requirements Deed restrictions Covenants Site access costs
Key concepts: How is “known environmental liability” defined?
What is included as an “Environmental Matter”? Definition could include – generation, storage, handling, treatment and disposal of
hazardous materials/substances (not just release of same) Compliance with permits Financial assurance requirements Deed restrictions Covenants Site access costs
30
SPECIFIC LANGUAGE CHOICES Important definitions:
Environmental, health and safety?
Environmental Conditions What does this include?
Remediation Response activities? Land use restrictions? Financial
assurance?
Important definitions:
Environmental, health and safety?
Environmental Conditions What does this include?
Remediation Response activities? Land use restrictions? Financial
assurance?
31
COMPLEX STRUCTURES
Using a Materiality Trigger
Single event or in the aggregate
What costs will be considered as part of materiality total
What if the parties do not agree on what conditions are material forpurposes of triggering indemnity claims
Using a Materiality Trigger
Single event or in the aggregate
What costs will be considered as part of materiality total
What if the parties do not agree on what conditions are material forpurposes of triggering indemnity claims
32
COMPLEX STRUCTURESCaps and Baskets
Basket: Buyer maintains a running total of the post-closing environmental liabilities it has incurred; whenthe total exceeds the agreed threshold dollar amount,buyer may make an indemnity claim against seller
Cap: Dollar amount limit on a party’s liability (or canact as trigger for shared liability after the cap amount isreached)
Caps and Baskets
Basket: Buyer maintains a running total of the post-closing environmental liabilities it has incurred; whenthe total exceeds the agreed threshold dollar amount,buyer may make an indemnity claim against seller
Cap: Dollar amount limit on a party’s liability (or canact as trigger for shared liability after the cap amount isreached)
33
COMPLEX STRUCTURESWhen does the indemnity terminate?
Are termination provisions linked to achieving somekind of cleanup end point?
Obtaining a No Further Action letter from the agency(not all states provide this)
Obtaining sign off from environmental consultant
Completion of specific tasks
When does the indemnity terminate?
Are termination provisions linked to achieving somekind of cleanup end point?
Obtaining a No Further Action letter from the agency(not all states provide this)
Obtaining sign off from environmental consultant
Completion of specific tasks
34
Synthesizing Indemnity ProvisionsWithin the Purchase Agreement Itself:
Representations and Warranties Disclosure Schedules Covenants Third-Party Beneficiaries Assignment Survival Choice of Law
Within the Purchase Agreement Itself:
Representations and Warranties Disclosure Schedules Covenants Third-Party Beneficiaries Assignment Survival Choice of Law
35
Synthesizing Indemnity ProvisionsRepresentations and Warranties
What if party reps to “the absence of hazardoussubstances on Property” and the party stores typicalcleaning supplies which are considered hazardoussubstances on-site – you will automatically be subject toindemnity because of breach of representation
Knowledge qualifier – “to the best of seller’s knowledge”
Representations and Warranties
What if party reps to “the absence of hazardoussubstances on Property” and the party stores typicalcleaning supplies which are considered hazardoussubstances on-site – you will automatically be subject toindemnity because of breach of representation
Knowledge qualifier – “to the best of seller’s knowledge”
36
Synthesizing Indemnity Provisions Some generic reps & warranties that may tie in with
indemnity triggers:
Use of hazardous materials and/or substances is incompliance with all applicable laws All necessary environmental permits and authorizations. No release of hazardous substances No pending enforcement, administrative actions or
environmental claims against the Company
Some generic reps & warranties that may tie in withindemnity triggers:
Use of hazardous materials and/or substances is incompliance with all applicable laws All necessary environmental permits and authorizations. No release of hazardous substances No pending enforcement, administrative actions or
environmental claims against the Company
37
Synthesizing Indemnity Provisions Covenants Is certain work a required obligation? If default and another
party steps in to do the work, is it covered by indemnity orpotentially escrow or other funds?
Assignment Is the agreement assignable? With or without prior written
consent? Third party beneficiaries Who is a beneficiary to the agreement? Can they make
indemnity claims? Choice of law
Covenants Is certain work a required obligation? If default and another
party steps in to do the work, is it covered by indemnity orpotentially escrow or other funds?
Assignment Is the agreement assignable? With or without prior written
consent? Third party beneficiaries Who is a beneficiary to the agreement? Can they make
indemnity claims? Choice of law
38
Synthesizing Indemnity Provisions Disclosure schedules
What and how is information included in the disclosureschedules? Covered by indemnity? Issue – a disclosure schedule can be list of
environmental reports (which often reference otherprior reports and documents) Does mere reference constitute disclosure of a specific issue Does the simple mention of a description of the business
operations or a process constitute a disclosure? Limit to acknowledge without additional inquiry or investigation?
Disclosure schedules
What and how is information included in the disclosureschedules? Covered by indemnity? Issue – a disclosure schedule can be list of
environmental reports (which often reference otherprior reports and documents) Does mere reference constitute disclosure of a specific issue Does the simple mention of a description of the business
operations or a process constitute a disclosure? Limit to acknowledge without additional inquiry or investigation?
39
Synthesizing Indemnity ProvisionsWith other deal documents:
Master purchase and sale agreement Personal and Corporate Guarantees Loan and financing agreements Leases Risk Liability Transfer Contracts
With other deal documents:
Master purchase and sale agreement Personal and Corporate Guarantees Loan and financing agreements Leases Risk Liability Transfer Contracts
40
Example 1 Seller agrees, at its sole cost and expense, to indemnify, defend
and hold harmless Buyer, its directors, officers, stockholders,employees, assigns and successors, from any loss, cost, damage(whether direct or consequential), obligation, liability,judgment, action, penalties, claims, proceeding, injunction suit,fines, or expense (including consultants’, experts’, attorneys’ feesand court costs) incurred or sustained by Buyer arising directlyor indirectly, from : (a) any failure of Seller to comply with anyEnvironmental Laws; (b) Existing Contamination (whetherknown or unknown); (c) any breach of this agreement; or (d)contamination, if attributable to the actions or omissions ofSeller, including without limitation any of the following:….
Seller agrees, at its sole cost and expense, to indemnify, defendand hold harmless Buyer, its directors, officers, stockholders,employees, assigns and successors, from any loss, cost, damage(whether direct or consequential), obligation, liability,judgment, action, penalties, claims, proceeding, injunction suit,fines, or expense (including consultants’, experts’, attorneys’ feesand court costs) incurred or sustained by Buyer arising directlyor indirectly, from : (a) any failure of Seller to comply with anyEnvironmental Laws; (b) Existing Contamination (whetherknown or unknown); (c) any breach of this agreement; or (d)contamination, if attributable to the actions or omissions ofSeller, including without limitation any of the following:….
41
Example 2
Buyer shall indemnify, defend and hold Seller harmless fromany loss, cost, damage or expense (including attorneys’ fees)actually incurred or sustained by Seller in connection with
the Release or disposal of Hazardous Substances on theproperty by Buyer, its agents, tenants, employees or
contractors.
Buyer shall indemnify, defend and hold Seller harmless fromany loss, cost, damage or expense (including attorneys’ fees)actually incurred or sustained by Seller in connection with
the Release or disposal of Hazardous Substances on theproperty by Buyer, its agents, tenants, employees or
contractors.
42
Final Take-Aways
Boiler plate is only agood starting point
Understand andmemorialize the exactrisk allocation
Pick your battles
Boiler plate is only agood starting point
Understand andmemorialize the exactrisk allocation
Pick your battles
43
The Environmental Indemnity Tool Kit Default arrangement: Seller indemnifies buyer for all pre-closing liabilities Buyer indemnifies seller for all post-closing liabilities
Because buyers become liable for environmental costsupon purchase, the seller is usually asked to indemnifythe buyer for liabilities that arise post-closing but arerelated to pre-closing events Buyers may be willing in some cases to
assume environmental liabilities in returnfor a reduced purchase price or othercompensation
Default arrangement: Seller indemnifies buyer for all pre-closing liabilities Buyer indemnifies seller for all post-closing liabilities
Because buyers become liable for environmental costsupon purchase, the seller is usually asked to indemnifythe buyer for liabilities that arise post-closing but arerelated to pre-closing events Buyers may be willing in some cases to
assume environmental liabilities in returnfor a reduced purchase price or othercompensation
44
The Environmental Indemnity Tool Kit
Some commonly used tools: Insurance Deductibles and thresholds Cost Caps Cost sharing Time limits Corporate guarantee Letters of credit Reserves Escrow
Some commonly used tools: Insurance Deductibles and thresholds Cost Caps Cost sharing Time limits Corporate guarantee Letters of credit Reserves Escrow
45
The Toolkit: Insurance Pollution Legal Liability policy Covers liabilities that are unknown and unexpected Not always available, depending on market conditions,
size of potential claims Costly Time consuming
Cleanup Cost Cap policy Covers specific plan to clean up
known contamination Not available when site poorly
characterized Expensive, risky
Pollution Legal Liability policy Covers liabilities that are unknown and unexpected Not always available, depending on market conditions,
size of potential claims Costly Time consuming
Cleanup Cost Cap policy Covers specific plan to clean up
known contamination Not available when site poorly
characterized Expensive, risky
46
The Toolkit: Insurance Indemnity only for non-insured claims Watch out for policies that provide only excess coverage The indemnity may be considered primary coverage
47
The Environmental Indemnity Toolkit
Deductibles and thresholds: Many environmental statutes impose liability for trivial
releases Transaction costs may make indemnity for small claims
inefficient Limit indemnity to claims exceeding a $ threshold Or limit indemnity to amounts
exceeding a “basket” amount
Deductibles and thresholds: Many environmental statutes impose liability for trivial
releases Transaction costs may make indemnity for small claims
inefficient Limit indemnity to claims exceeding a $ threshold Or limit indemnity to amounts
exceeding a “basket” amount
48
The Environmental Indemnity Toolkit Cost Caps and Cost Sharing Cost caps may be coordinated with insurance Cost sharing may be linked to parties’ roles
with respect to site operations Time Limits Time limits may be linked to loan terms,
if property is financed May be extended if environmental issues
discovered Restrictions on use of property Indemnity limited to commercial/
industrial use Limits on types of businesses (e.g., daycare or
school)
Cost Caps and Cost Sharing Cost caps may be coordinated with insurance Cost sharing may be linked to parties’ roles
with respect to site operations Time Limits Time limits may be linked to loan terms,
if property is financed May be extended if environmental issues
discovered Restrictions on use of property Indemnity limited to commercial/
industrial use Limits on types of businesses (e.g., daycare or
school)
49
The Environmental IndemnityToolkit Other provisions: Predecessor operations covered? First-party claims covered? Notice and opportunity to defend Time limit for payment Copies of reports, communications with regulators Access/recorded easement Arbitration or mediation clause
Other provisions: Predecessor operations covered? First-party claims covered? Notice and opportunity to defend Time limit for payment Copies of reports, communications with regulators Access/recorded easement Arbitration or mediation clause
50
Part III: See You In Court Examples of contested issues involving environmental
indemnities: Expenses outside the scope of the indemnity Attorneys’ fees? Expert costs?
Work resulting from new construction Work resulting from change in use (commercial to residential) Work not necessary to comply with applicable laws Lenders’ costs associated with environmental due
diligence/mitigation/remediation First-party losses
Examples of contested issues involving environmentalindemnities: Expenses outside the scope of the indemnity Attorneys’ fees? Expert costs?
Work resulting from new construction Work resulting from change in use (commercial to residential) Work not necessary to comply with applicable laws Lenders’ costs associated with environmental due
diligence/mitigation/remediation First-party losses
51
Environmental Indemnity Case Law Early litigation: Do pre-CERCLA indemnity
agreements cover CERCLA liability? Section 9607(e)(1) of CERCLA provides:
“No indemnification, hold harmless, or similar agreement orconveyance shall be effective to transfer from the owner oroperator of any vessel or facility or from any person who may beliable for a release or threat of release under this section, to anyother person the liability imposed under this section. Nothingin this subsection shall bar any agreement to insure, holdharmless, or indemnify a party to such agreement for anyliability under this section.”
Early litigation: Do pre-CERCLA indemnityagreements cover CERCLA liability? Section 9607(e)(1) of CERCLA provides:
“No indemnification, hold harmless, or similar agreement orconveyance shall be effective to transfer from the owner oroperator of any vessel or facility or from any person who may beliable for a release or threat of release under this section, to anyother person the liability imposed under this section. Nothingin this subsection shall bar any agreement to insure, holdharmless, or indemnify a party to such agreement for anyliability under this section.”
52
Environmental Indemnity Case Law U.S. v. Hardage
985 F.2d 1427 (10th Cir. 1993) Under Section 9607, parties may allocate liability through indemnity
agreements Kerr–McGee Chem. Corp. v. Lefton Iron & Metal Co.
14 F.3d 321, 327 (7th Cir. 1994) Pre-CERCLA indemnity agreement covered CERCLA liabilities Indemnity agreement and “as is” clause considered as factors in allocating
liability in contribution action Beazer East, Inc. v. Mead Corp.
34 F.3d 206 (3d Cir. 1994) State law governs interpretation of agreements
allocating liability among private responsible parties Pre-CERCLA indemnity may be effective to transfer
CERCLA liability
U.S. v. Hardage985 F.2d 1427 (10th Cir. 1993) Under Section 9607, parties may allocate liability through indemnity
agreements Kerr–McGee Chem. Corp. v. Lefton Iron & Metal Co.
14 F.3d 321, 327 (7th Cir. 1994) Pre-CERCLA indemnity agreement covered CERCLA liabilities Indemnity agreement and “as is” clause considered as factors in allocating
liability in contribution action Beazer East, Inc. v. Mead Corp.
34 F.3d 206 (3d Cir. 1994) State law governs interpretation of agreements
allocating liability among private responsible parties Pre-CERCLA indemnity may be effective to transfer
CERCLA liability
53
Environmental Indemnity Case Law
Cadillac Fairview/California, Inc. v. Dow Chem. Co.299 F.3d 1099 (9th Cir. 2002) Indemnity agreement properly considered as
allocation factor in case finding government100% liable
Cadillac Fairview/California, Inc. v. Dow Chem. Co.299 F.3d 1099 (9th Cir. 2002) Indemnity agreement properly considered as
allocation factor in case finding government100% liable
54
Environmental Indemnity Case Law
The specific language of the indemnity matters Taracorp, Inc. v. NL Industries, Inc.
73 F.3d 738 (7th Cir. 1996) Two indemnities: One for environmental contamination
“located at, on, or near” Facility #1 One for liabilities “related to environmental
hazards associated with” Facility #2 NL argued that both indemnities were limited to
contamination on or near the facility But Seventh Circuit held that NL was liable as an arranger for
wastes transported off-site from Facility #2
The specific language of the indemnity matters Taracorp, Inc. v. NL Industries, Inc.
73 F.3d 738 (7th Cir. 1996) Two indemnities: One for environmental contamination
“located at, on, or near” Facility #1 One for liabilities “related to environmental
hazards associated with” Facility #2 NL argued that both indemnities were limited to
contamination on or near the facility But Seventh Circuit held that NL was liable as an arranger for
wastes transported off-site from Facility #2
55
Environmental Indemnity Case Law
VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013)
Borrower defaulted on loan secured by daycare centerwith suspected PCE contamination Lenders’ assignees foreclosed and sought appointment
of receiver rather than taking possession of property Lenders conducted Phase I assessments and indoor
air testing and sought costs from receiver
VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013)
Borrower defaulted on loan secured by daycare centerwith suspected PCE contamination Lenders’ assignees foreclosed and sought appointment
of receiver rather than taking possession of property Lenders conducted Phase I assessments and indoor
air testing and sought costs from receiver
56
Environmental Indemnity Case Law VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC
735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013) (cont’d) The Indemnity Agreement provided that borrowers
would indemnify the lenders:
“from and against all. . . costs, . . . demands, . . . expenses”and other liabilities “of any kind or nature whatsoever . . .sought from or asserted against Indemnitees in connectionwith, in whole or in part, directly or indirectly,. . . the presence, suspected presence,release, suspected release, or threat ofrelease of any Hazardous Material”on or around the Property
VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013) (cont’d) The Indemnity Agreement provided that borrowers
would indemnify the lenders:
“from and against all. . . costs, . . . demands, . . . expenses”and other liabilities “of any kind or nature whatsoever . . .sought from or asserted against Indemnitees in connectionwith, in whole or in part, directly or indirectly,. . . the presence, suspected presence,release, suspected release, or threat ofrelease of any Hazardous Material”on or around the Property
57
Environmental Indemnity Case Law VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC
735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013) (cont’d)
Court held recoverable costs limited to costs sought bya third party Court held indemnity was so broad that it must have
been limited by the next sentence providing “Suchliabilities shall include . . . .” To hold otherwise would make borrower
liable for costs that were neitherreasonable nor necessary
VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013) (cont’d)
Court held recoverable costs limited to costs sought bya third party Court held indemnity was so broad that it must have
been limited by the next sentence providing “Suchliabilities shall include . . . .” To hold otherwise would make borrower
liable for costs that were neitherreasonable nor necessary
58
Environmental Indemnity Case Law
VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013) (cont’d)
Lesson of VFC Partners is that courts will parse thespecific language of the indemnity and will applycommon sense limits Lenders will want provisions to allow recovery of costs
necessary to investigate contaminated property But an indemnity that is so broad that it
would subject the indemnitor tounlimited liability may backfireon the indemnitee
VFC Partners 26, LLC v. Cadlerocks Centennial Drive, LLC735 F.3d 25 (1st Cir. 2013) (cont’d)
Lesson of VFC Partners is that courts will parse thespecific language of the indemnity and will applycommon sense limits Lenders will want provisions to allow recovery of costs
necessary to investigate contaminated property But an indemnity that is so broad that it
would subject the indemnitor tounlimited liability may backfireon the indemnitee
59
Practice Tips A good contract has:
– A separate environmentalsection
– All of the above terms(indemnity, covenants,release of liability, repsand warranties)
– Consider a deedrestriction (no sensitiveuses)
– Consider an accessagreement
– Consider a technical riskmanagement plan
A good contract has:– A separate environmental
section– All of the above terms
(indemnity, covenants,release of liability, repsand warranties)
– Consider a deedrestriction (no sensitiveuses)
– Consider an accessagreement
– Consider a technical riskmanagement plan
60
Lessons Learned Consider all media Look past the current transaction Plan for stricter standards Consider eternity
Consider all media Look past the current transaction Plan for stricter standards Consider eternity
61