18
EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF 146 DYSBARIC DIVING ACCIDENTS J. Desola AI; and A. Carcia San Pedro The C.R.I.S. (Underwater Recovering and Research Center) was founded in Barcelona in 1954. Initially all dysbaric diving accidents produced in the Catalonian and Balearian Coasts were treated in a single monoplace chamber until 1964, when the present Multiplace Hyperbaric Chamber (MHC) was built (Fig. 1). The first case, however, was treated in 1967. Up to May 1983, 146 Dysbaric Diving Accidents (DDA) have been treated in our Hyperbaric Therapeutic Unit (HTU), placed in the Red-Cross Hospital of Barcelona*. Troubled divers have been received from a zone of more than 200 Kms. around, even from the "Costa Brava", in the North (the best and main touristic Spanish coasts for sport diving), and also from the coasts of Tarragona, in the south (the most irr~portant zone of comn~ercial diving), where several off-shore instalations are placed. 1 .- NUMBER OF CASES STUDIED The number of DDA has increased in the last few years since underwater sport activities became extremely popular in Spain. In the first ten years only 38 DDA were treated in the HTU. The other 108 cases took place in the last five years 1978-1 983 (Fig. 2). 2.- TYPE OF DDA The most important group of cases (107, 86.20%) correspon- ded to type I1 (neurological) Decompression Sickness (DS). The number of cases of type I DS (17, 13.70%) was comparatively very low, probably because a lot of sport divers did not recognize limb pain (bends) and skin rashes as symptoms of DS and they neglect the recompression. The number of cases of Burst Lung (BL) was relatively high (26, 17,00%) compared with commercial and militar diving, due to the inexperience of some beginners in case of emergency. BL often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of both entities (Table I). (*) Until 31st December 1983 the number of DDA treated was 154.

EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF 146 DYSBARIC DIVING ACCIDENTS

J. Desola AI; and A. C a r c i a San Pedro

The C.R.I.S. (Underwater Recovering and Resea rch C e n t e r ) was founded in Barcelona in 1954. Initially a l l dysbar ic diving acc iden t s produced in t h e Cata lonian and Balearian Coas t s w e r e t r e a t e d in a single monoplace chamber unti l 1964, when t h e present Mult iplace Hyperbar ic Chamber (MHC) was built (Fig. 1). The f i r s t case, however, was t r e a t e d in 1967.

Up t o May 1983, 146 Dysbaric Diving Accidents (DDA) have been t r e a t e d in our Hyperbaric Therapeut ic Unit (HTU), placed in t h e Red-Cross Hospital of Barcelona*.

Troubled d ivers have been received f rom a zone of m o r e than 200 Kms. around, even f rom t h e "Costa Brava", in t h e Nor th ( t h e bes t and main tour is t ic Spanish coas t s for spor t diving), and a lso f rom t h e c o a s t s of Tarragona, in t h e south ( t h e mos t i r r~por t an t zone of c o m n ~ e r c i a l diving), where seve ra l off-shore ins ta la t ions a r e placed.

1 .- NUMBER OF CASES STUDIED

The number of DDA has increased in t h e l a s t f e w yea r s s ince underwater spo r t ac t iv i t i e s b e c a m e ex t r eme ly popular in Spain. In t h e f i r s t t e n yea r s only 38 DDA w e r e t r e a t e d in t h e HTU. The o t h e r 108 cases took p lace in t h e las t f ive yea r s 1978-1 983 (Fig. 2).

2.- TYPE OF DDA

The mos t impor t an t group of cases (107, 86.20%) correspon- ded t o type I1 (neurological) Decompression Sickness (DS). The number of cases of t y p e I DS (17, 13.70%) was compara t ive ly very low, probably because a lo t of spor t d ivers did no t recognize l imb pain (bends) and skin rashes as symptoms of DS and they neglec t t h e recompression.

The number of cases of Burst Lung (BL) was re la t ive ly high (26, 17,00%) compared wi th commerc ia l and mi l i ta r diving, due t o t h e inexper ience of s o m e beginners in case of emergency. BL o f t e n happens during mandatory free-scape p r a c t i c e s in SCUBA courses. Some very impor t an t diving f a t a l i t i e s produced t h e addit ion of both e n t i t i e s (Table I).

(*) Until 31st December 1983 the number of DDA treated was 154.

Page 2: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

Fig. I : Hyperbarlc Mult~place Chamber of the C.R.I.S. placed in the Red-Cross Hospital of Barcelona.

Fig. 2 : Number of diving accidents treated in the Hyperbaric Multiplace Chamber of the C.R.I.S. since 1967 to - 1983.

Page 3: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

Type o f D i v i n g A c c i d e n t n %

Decompress i on S i c k n e s s

Type 1

Type I 1

B u r s t Lung 2 6 17.80

Decompress i on S i c k n e s s + B u r s t Lung

TABLE I : Type of diving accidents.

3.- ORIGIN

Only 14 DDA (9,6%) occurred to members of t h e CRIS. The majority of t h e cases developed from members of o the r Spanish spor t diving associations (92, 62.10%) all grouped in t h e Spanish Federation of Underwater Activit ies (FEDAS), although several DDA (28, 18.90%) occurred t o non authorized (illegal) divers.

An important number of DDA (20, 13.50%) corresponded t o foreign divers, and a final small number (8, 5.40%) t o commercia l divers* (Table 11).

O r i g i n n %

F.E.D.A.S.

Non a u t h o r i z e d

F o r e i g n e r s

Commerc i a l s

TABLE I1 : Origin of the l46 troubled divers.

(*) This number was duplicated in the last months of 1983 and the first of 1984.

Page 4: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

120 J. Desola and A. Garc ia

4.- DIVERS EXPERIENCE LEVEL

DS was mos t common in e x p e r t and in t e rmed ia t e d ivers and was r a r e in beginners. J u s t t h e opposi te happened wi th BL which in t h e major i ty of cases occurred t o beginners during f r e e scapes in t raining cour ses (Table 111).

L e v e l D . S . B .L . T o t a l

E x p e r t s

I n t e r m e d i a t e s

B e g i n n e r s

TABLE Ill : Levels of experienceof the l 46 troubled divers (percentage).

5.- DIVING DEPTH

The spec ia l conf igura t ion of t h e Cata lonian coas t s fo rces diving t o re la t ive ly deep imme, sions considering spo r t prac t ice . Three q u a r t e r s of t h e DDA w e r e produced a f t e r immersions deeper t han 40 m e t e r s depth. Only t h e cases of BL developed a f t e r shallow dives. The mean dep th was 34.40 m e t e r s (Table IV).

M e t e r s d e p t h n %

TABLE 1V : Mean depth o f the lrnrnerslons that produced the accidents.

6.- CAUSES OF ACCIDENT

A g r e a t major i ty of acc iden t s were due t o human e r r o r in following decompress ion schedules o r o the r negligible reasons, in sp i t e of t h e f a c t t h a t t hey o f t en do not a c c e p t it . Very f e w cases a r e due t o unavoidable causes (break of regula tors , d a m a g e

Page 5: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY O F 146 DYSBARIC ACCIDENTS 12 1

in a i r cylinders, etc.). A few well proved documented and be- lievable cases developed a f t e r apparent ly c o r r e c t and normal ' im- mersions (Table V).

Individual idiosynchratic fac tors , o f t en qu i t e d i f f e ren t f rom t h e human profi les of mil i tary and commerc ia l divers, m a y be t h e reason of those non understandable DDA probably d u e t o t h e use of inadequate decompression tables for spor t diving.

Cause n %

D i v e r ' s e r r o r 135 91 .20

M e c h a n i c a l d e f e c t 2 1 .40

U n e x p l a n a b l e 11 7 . 4 0

TABLE V : Causes of diving accidents.

7.- ONSET OF SYMPTOMATOLOGY

In t h e major i ty of t h e cases of DS t h e symptoms appeared immedia t ly a f t e r end of t h e dive. Only some cases of type I DS ini t iated the i r symptomatology s o m e hours la ter , even m o r e than 24 hours (Table VI).

I m m e d i a t e a p p a r i t i o n 67 .70

B e f o r e t h e 1 s t Hour 18 .80

Be tween t h e 1 s t a n d t h e 6 t h h o u r s 12.50

Be tween t h e 6 t h and t h e 2 4 t h h o u r s 12 .50

A f t e r t h e 2 4 t h h o u r s 1 .10

TABLE V1 : Time elapsed until the onset of the symptomatology (percentage).

8.- ELAPSED TIME UNTIL RECOMPRESSION

Few divers ar r ived t o t h e HTU sooner than t h r e e hours a f t e r t h e end of t h e dive. Approximately half of t hem las ted be tween 3 and 12 hours, and more than a third p a r t arr ived l a t e r than 24

Page 6: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

J. Desola and A. Garcia

hours a f t e r the onset of the symptomatology. The mean of t h e t ime elapsed. until t h e arrival t o t h e chamber was of 16 hours and 20 minutes (Table vII).

N u m b e r o f h o u r s n %

TABLE V11 : Time elapsed until t h e 'arrival t o t h e chamber.

9.- SYMPTOMATOLOGY

Spinal cord symptoms and bends were t h e symptoms most commonly observed in DS, of ten adopting the form of a Brown- Secquard Syndrome (Table VIII).

S y m p t o m s n %

B e n d s P a r a p a r e s i s B l a d d e r p a r a l y s i s M o n o p a r e s i s V e r t i g o S k i n r a s h H e a d a c h e P a r a p l e g i a

TABLE V111 : Symptomatology observed in t h e 124 cases of Decompression Sickness.

Page 7: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF 146 DYSBARIC ACCIDENTS 123

Air embolism (AE) was present in t h e majority of t h e BL cases, some of them with very serious cen t ra l neurological dis- turbances.

Differing with classical references ( I , 2, 3) pneumotorax and haemoptisis were observed in very ra re occasions. Pneumomedias- tinum-pneumopericardium was present in almost al l cases of AE. The subcutaneous emphysema was also commonly observed (Table IX).

S y m p t o m s n %

P n e u m o m e d i a s t i n u m B l a d d e r p a r a l y s i s T e t r a p l e g i a H e m i p a r e s i s H e a d a c h e R h i n o l a l i a S u b c u t a n e a l e m p h y s e m a V e r t i g o C o n v u l s i o n s H a e m o p t i s i s C o m a H e m i p l e g i a P n e u m o t o r a x T r e m o r

TABLE U( : Syrnptomatology observed in the 26 cases of Burst Lung.

10.- HEMATOLOGICAL AND BIOCHEMICAL ALTERATIONS

In al l cases of DDA we followed t h e analytical protocol w e presented in Cambridge in 1982 during t h e V11 Congress of t h e E.U.B.S. (4).

The higher number of observations presently accumulated have not changed those conclusions, and only a few analytical para- m e t e r s showed significant a l tera t ions as a evidence of neuromus- cular damage, and haemodinamic, metabolic, and coagulating dis- turbances somet imes clinically hidden (Table X).

As w e s t a t e d then, t h e absence of biochemical o r haematolo- gical a l tera t ions was considered as a sign of good prognosis, in

Page 8: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

P a r a m e t e r O.S. B .L . T o t a l

H a e m a t o c r y t ( 1 ) 20 .70 14.20 20 .30

P l a t e l e t s ( 1 1 39.60 42 .80 3 7 . 5 0

F.O.P. ( 1 ) 35.80 71 .40 39 .10

L.O.H. ( 1 ) 3 2 . 1 0 42.80 31 .20

G.O.T. ( 1 ) 9 .40 28 .50 7 . 8 0

C.K. ( 1 ) 50.90 57.10 50 .00

TABLE X : Percentage of analytical alterations detected in Decompression Sickness and Burst Lung.

spi te of the f a c t of having important neurological symptoms, and vice-versa.

1 1 .- TREATMENT

a. Pharmacologic.

Classical medical t r e a t m e n t ( 5 , 6, 7) was prescribed in a lmost all cases. Dextran 70.000 ( to begin) or 40.000 (later) was perfused in all serious neurological cases, and in those with important haematological o r haemodinamical alterations.

Salicylates were administered in almost all cases of bends. Occasionally and according t o the symptomatology of each case , steroids, diazepan, tyamine, hepar in , cynarizine, and vessel ac t ive substances were also administered.

b. Hyperbaric.

Until 1980 only a i r - t rea tment tables were used due t o technical reasons. Af te r the organizing of the current facilities, making sorne modifications in our old chamber, and allowing permanent 24 hours/day medical assistance, U.S. Navy oxygen tables were used (Table XI).

1 2.- EVOLUTION

In sp i t e of t h e f a c t of t h e delay in t h e beginning of t h e t r ea tment , t h e evolution was sat isfactory in t h e majori ty of t h e cases.

Page 9: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

T a b l e n %

TABLE XI : Air -Oxygen therapeutic tables used.

The improvement was d ramat ic in t h e cases of DS t r ea ted during t h e f i rs t 6 hours a f t e r the onset of the symptoms.

In the other cases some neurological sequelles usually remained and they needed complementary Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy (OHB) during t h e following days until full or satisfactory recupe- rat ion was obtained (Table XII).

E v o l u t i o n A i r O x y g e n

T o t a l i m p r o v e m e n t

M i l d i m p r o v e m e n t

No c h a n g e

W o r s e n i n g

D e a t h

TABLE XU : Evolution after recompression (percentage).

The results were obviously poor in t h e most delayed cases. However re la t ive good recuperation was obtained in some cases of type I1 DS t r ea ted even two days a f t e r the onset of t h e sympto- matology. Two cases of type I (only bends) DS t r ea ted more than 8 days a f t e r t h e dive obtained a full improvement a f t e r t h e f i rs t OHB treatment .

Page 10: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

126 J. Desola a n d A. G a r c i a

Two cases of s e v e r e AE a f t e r f r e e scape, t h a t a r r ived t o t h e HTU more than 24 hours a f t e r t h e dive, died in t h e c r i t i c a l c a r e unit of t h e hospital, s o m e hours a f t e r having finished t h e Tab le IV.

One case of DS wi th possible c r a n e a l t r aumat i sm, rece ived m o r e than 12 hours a f t e r t h e dive, died inside t h e c h a m b e r a f t e r t h e f i r s t 10 hours of t r e a t m e n t .

T h e evolut ion of ano the r 3 cases of AE t r e a t e d wi th t h e t a b l e 6A and c r i t i c a l c a r e intensive techniques pe r fo rmed inside t h e c h a m b e r w e r e sa t i s fac tory .

Our expe r i ence of t h i s kind i s no t ful l enough t o obta in s ignif icant conclusions, bu t t h e evolut ion of t h e m o s t ser ious cases s e e m s t o be much b e t t e r s ince w e use t h e oxygen tab les , special ly in t h e p a t i e n t s rece ived seve ra l hours a f t e r t h e onse t of t h e symptoms.

13.- COMPARISON WITH OTHER S P O R T FATALITIES

These d a t a a r e n o t r ep resen ta t ive of t h e t o t a l number of DDA in Spain, but i s ce r t a in ly approx ima te because i s along t h e Cata lonian C o a s t s where t h e g r a t e r number of both spo r t and commerc ia l d ives t a k e place.

Compar ing t h e m e a n number o f all t y p e o f s p o r t diving a c c i d e n t s p e r y e a r f r o m 1971 t o 1975, and f r o m 1976 t o 1980, wi th t h e m e a n of t h e total number of d ive r s during those periods, we obta in t h e INDEX OF MORBIDITY.

Compar ing t h e mean number of diving d e a t h s wi th t h e m e a n number of a c c i d e n t s during those s a m e periods, w e ob ta in t h e INDEX OF LETHALITY.

Compar ing finally wi th t h e s a m e procedure t h e number o f d e a t h s wi th t h e total number o f divers, t hen w e obta in t h e INDEX OF MORTALITY.

Studying with th i s s a m e technique s o m e popular and heal th- considered s p o r t s in Spain, and compar ing wi th those resul ts , w e m a y observe t h a t t h e spo r t diving (including in th i s c o n c e p t a l l t y p e of s p o r t underwater ac t iv i t ies ) produce t h e lowes t Index o f Morbidity of a l l s p o r t s (Table XIII).

We m u s t cons ider however t h a t t h e Indexes o f L e t h a l i t y a n d Morta l i ty are t h e highest , uppered only fo r t h e Hang gliding and o t h e r flying s p o r t s (Table XIV).

1 4.- CONCLUSIONS

SCUBA s p o r t diving produces in Spain a low number of acc iden t s , a l though with high Indexs of Letha l i ty and Mortal i ty.

The inc idence of DDA is obviously higher in spo r t t h a n in

Page 11: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

No. of sportsmen No. of accidents Morbidity Index Sports 1971-75 1976,80 1971-75 1976-80 1971-75 1976-80

Diving Flying sports Athletism Automobilism Basket-ball Hand-ball Cycling Skiing Hockey Judo Montanism Motor-cycling Rugby Tennis

TABLE X1II : Morbidity Indexes from several sports showing the lowest one for diving.

Sport No. ofdeaths Lethality Mortality

1971-75 1976-80 1971-75 1976-80 1971-75 1976-80

Diving Flying sports Athletism Automobilism Basket-ball Hand-ball Cycling Skiing Hockey Judo Montanism Motor-cycling

Rugby Tennis

TABLE XIV : Corr.parison of the lndexes of Lethality and Mortality from several sports.

Page 12: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

128 J. Desola and A. Garc ia

commerc ia l o r mi l i ta ry diving, due, in t h e major i ty of t h e cases, t o ignorance of diving secur i ty procedures, and inadequate , o r omi ted , decompress ion schedules.

The f r e e s c a p e mus t be well t augh t in theory t o t h e beginners, and a lso p rac t i ced in swimming pools, o r f rom shal low d e p t h s in t h e sea. But t h i s dangerous p rac t i ce mus t be forbidden as a p lace of usual t raining prac t ice .

Troubled d ivers o f t e n de lay t h e acces t o t h e recompression chamber again due t o ignorance o r negligence. They should be exhaust ively ins t ruc ted a b o u t t h e impor t ance of t h e ce l e r i t y of t h e t r anspor t t o t h e n e a r e s t hyperbar ic medical cen te r .

Oxygen t r e a t m e n t t ab l e s conf i rm in our modes t expe r i ence t o be m o r e e f f e c t i v e in t h e t r e a t m e n t of spo r t diving acc idents .

Off ic ia l inst i tut ions, federa t ions , and c lubs of SCUBA spor t diving should a s sume t h e s e conclusions and ought t o emphas i ze the i r d ivers t o become m o r e cautious, avoid unnecesary f r ee - scapes, forbid t h e m t o beginners, and proceed wi th t h e mos t urgency in t h e t r anspor t of t roubled d ivers t o t h e n e a r e s t hyper- bar ic medica l cen te r .

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT : The au tho r s wish t o expres s the i r know- ledge t o Drs. Josep Brull and Josep Prim t h a t reviewed t h e 72 f i r s t cases of t h i s s tudy; t o Miss Roser Cano and Miss Mont se r r a t ~ a r c i a , nurses of our serv ice , who cont r ibuted t o t h e review of t h e o t h e r 74 cases; and t o t h e Spanish "Mutualidad Gene ra l Deport iva" whose d a t a on spo r t f a t a l i t i e s have been consulted.

S U M M A R Y

Since 1967, 146 Dysbaric Diving Accidents (DDA) have been a t t e n d e d at t h e U.H.T. of t h e C.R.I.S. The major i ty of t hese w e r e spor t ing acc iden t s which took place on t h e C a t a l a n and Balear ic coasts. The principal d a t a of epidemiological i n t e re s t s tudied w e r e (age, level of exper ience , in terval of t i m e e lapsed be fo re t r e a t m e n t , de lay in t ranspor t ing t h e pat ient , etc.) a s well a s o t h e r c l in ica l and the rapeu t i c informat ion ( f rom t h e t r e a t m e n t given, medicat ion, etc.) and t h e pe rcen tages of cu res , par t ia l improvement o r residual e f f ec t s . Some of th i s d a t a has been compared wi th f igures f rom o t h e r sports. The following conclusions w e r e ab le t o be made. Diving shows t h e lowest Morbidity lndex of a l l spo r t s in Spain, although both t h e Lethal i ty and t h e Morta l i ty indices a r e high. Breath-hold diving produces the highest number of accidents . Decompression acc iden t s t ends t o hap- pen t o e x p e r t o r v e t e r a n divers. Burst Lungs predominate in new in i t i a t e s in to diving and o f t e n occur during t h e training courses. C e r t a i n Spor t c e n t e r s have a much higher Morbidity lndex t h a n others . The acc iden t v i c t ims tend t o delay

Page 13: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF 146 DYSBARIC ACCIDENTS 129

going to the Hyperbaric Medical Center becouse of indecision or ignorance. The majority of DDA's are a result of human rather than mechanical or accital causes. In spite of the delay in treatment, the majority of accident victims respond favorably i f recompression with air (tables IA, 2A, 3 and 4 USN) is ini- tiated before 6 hours after the onset of the symptomatalogy, or before 12 hours i f hyperoxigenated treatment (tables USN 5,6 and 6A) is given.

R E S U M

ESTUDI EPIDEMIOL~C~C DE 146 ACCIDENTS DISBARICS D'IMMERSI~. J. Desola A I ~ i A.Gar~ia San Pedro. Des de 1967 s'han ftes a la Unita: de Terapiutica ~ i p e r b i r i c a (UTH) del C.R.I.S. 146 AccidenJs Disbarics d'lmmersio (ADI), la rnajoria esportiste:, precedents. del l i toral catala i i l l en~ . S'han estu!iat les principals dades d'interes epiderniologic (edat, nivell d'experiencia, procedencia, int:rval de temps Iliure, tardanqa en el trasllat, etc.) i els percentatges de curacio, , de n i l lor ia parcial, o de seqiiel.les residuals. Algunes d'aquestes dades s'han comparat arnb les xifres procedent~ d'altres esports. Aquest estudi permet obtenir les conclusions segents. L'irnmersio produieix a Espanya e l rnenor Index de Morbilitat (IM) de tot? els esports, si rnes no els lndexs de Letalitat i de Mortalitat son alts. L'irnrnersio en, apnea produieix el rnbs gran nombre d'eccidents dintre de les Activitats Subaquatiques. Els Ac- cidents de Descornpressio es produieixen preferentment en escafandristes experts o veterans. Els de Sobrepressi6, predorninen en debutants i sovint es prodyieixen durant els cursets de formacio. Alguns centres espyrtius tenen IM rnolt rnes alts que d'altres., EIS eccidentats ,solen demorar innecesariament el trasllat a la UTH per indecisio ? be per ignorancia. La rnajoria dels AD1 obeiexen a causes hu; manes rnol t mes que mecaniques o accidentals. Malgrat la tardanqa en I'aplicacio del tractament hiperbaric,, la majoria dels accidentats evolucionen favorablement si s'inicia la recompressio amb aire (taules lA, 2A, 3 i 4 USM) abans de les 6 hores del inici de la sirnptornatologia, o de les 12 hores si s'apliquen taules hiper- oxigenades (5,6 i 6A USN).

R E S U M E N

ESTUDIO EPIDEMIOLOGICO DE 146 ACCIDEN~I-ES DISBARICOS DE BUCEO. J. Desola A l i y A. Garcia San Pedro. Desde 1967 se han atendido en la Unidad Terapeutica ~ i p e r b i r i c a (UTH) del CRIS. 146 Accidentes Disbsricos de Buceo (ADB), la rnayoria deportivos, procedenfes del l i toral Catalsn y Balear. Se han estudiado 10s principales datos de interes epi- derni016~ico (edad, lugar de procedencia, nivel de experiencia, interval0 de fiempo libre, demora en el traslado, etc.) asi corno, otros datos clhicos y terapeuticos (modalidad de tratemiento aplicado, rnedicacion complementaria, etc.) y 10s por- centajes de curacion, rnejoria parcial o de secuelas residuales. Algunos de estos datos se han cornparado con las cifras procedentes de otros deportes. Este estudio permite obtener las siguientes conclusiones. E l buceo produce en Espaiia el menor Indice de Morbilidad (IM) de todos 10s deportes, si bien sus tasas de Letalidad y Mortalidad son altas. Las disciplinas de buceo en apnea producen el mayor nirnero de accidentes. Los accidentes de Descornpresi6n ocurren preferenternente en buceadores expertos o veteranos. Los de Sobrepresi6n Pulmonar pre!orninan en debutantes y a rnenudo se producen, durante cursillos de forrnacion. Algunos centros deportivos tienen IM mucho mas altos que otros. Los accidentados suelen

Page 14: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

130 J. Desola and A. Garcia

demora r innecesa r i amen te e l t r a s l ado a la UTH por i n d e ~ i s i b n o ignorancia. L a moyoria d e 10s ADB obedecen a caysas humanas y no mecan icas o accidenta les . A pesar d e la demora e n . l a apl icacion de l t r a t amien to , la rvayorla d e 10s acciden- t ados evolucionan f avorab lemen te s i s e inicia la recompres ion con a i r e ( t ab la s USN IA, 2A, 3 y 4) a n t e s d e las 6 horas, o d e las 12 horas s i s e aplican t ab la s hiper- oxigenadas (USN 5, 6 y 6A).

R E S U M E

ETUDE EPIDEMIOLOCIQUE DE 146 ACCIDENTS DYSBARIQUES DE PLONCEE. J. Desola Ala et A. C a r c i a San Pedro. Depuis 1967 o n t 6t6 t r a i t & la UTH. du CRIS. 146 Acc iden t s Dysbariques d e plong6e (ADP), la p lypar t spor t i fs? e t , p r o v e n a n t du l i t t o ra l C a t a l a n y t d e s Balgares. Les principales donnees d1int6r:t epidemiologique (lieu d'origine, d e g r e d1exp&rien?e, in tervalJe d e t e y p s libre, de l a i d e >ransport , etc.) a ins i q u e d ' au t r e s ,donnees cliniques et the rapeu t iques (modal i te djppplication du t r a i t e m e n t , medicat ion cymplemen tp i r e , etc.) et les taux d e re tabl issement , ame l io ra t ion pa r t i e l l e PL! sequel lcs residuellcs o n t f a i t I 'objet d 'examen. Certain: d e c e s ch i f f r e s o n t ete compar6s a v e c ceux p rovenan t ,d fau t r e s sports. L a plongee provoque e n Espagne l e plus fa ib le 1ndi:e d e Morbilife (IM) p?r ~ a p p o r t aux a u t r e s sports; kien q u e 1:s t aux d e ~ 6 t a l i t e et Mor ta l i t e so i en t eleves. Les disciplines d e Flongee e n a p n e e e n t r a i e n t le plu,s ,grand nombre d'accidents. Les ,Maladiys d e Dycpmpression sur- v iennent d e p re fe rence c Q e z les plongeurs expyr imen tes ou veterans. Ceux d e Surpression Pulmonaire predominent c h e z les debu tan t s et, apparaissent souven t lors d,es yours d e format ion. C e r t a i n s , cen t r e s spor t i fs possedent un IM beaucoup plus e l eve que d 'aut res . Les acc iden tes o n t cou tume d e di f f6rer l e t r anspor t a I'UTH par dou te oy ignorance. L a plupar t des ADP , ~ b & i s s e ? t H d e s causes hu- maines et non mecaniques ou accidente!les: Malgre le dela i d 'appl ica t ion du t r a i t emen t , la ma jeu re pa r t i e des acc iden tes evoluent f avorab lemen t s i I'on en t r e - prend l a recompress ion I'air ( tables USN IA, 2At 3 et 4) a v a n t 6 heures, ou a v a n t 12 heures dans les c a s d 'uti l isation d e tables a I'oxygene (USN 5, 6 et 6A).

R E F E R E N C E S

I .- Edmonds C . : Barotrauma. In, St rauss R . H. : Diving Medicine. Ed. C r u n e and S t r a t ton , New York, 1976 ; 49-61.

2.- F ruc tus X. and Sciarli R. : La plongee, santg-securit6. Ed. Mari t imes et d 'outre- mer , 1980; 119-121.

3.- U.S.Navy Diving Manual. Navy Depar tmen t , Washington D C 20362, 1978; 8-1 3.

4.- Desola ~ l a J., Brull Martore l l J., and Pr im Cu t ig r rez J. : Biochemical and haematological f indings in 21 c a s e s of decompress ion sickness. In, El l io t t D. H . : Report of proceedings of ELlBS annual sc ient i f ic mee t ing Cambr idge 198 1 . Ed. North Sea Medical C e n t e r , 1982; 324-333.

5.- Broussolle B. : T r a i t e m e n t mgdicamenteux d e la ma lad ie d e d6compression. In, Medical a s p e c t s of diving accidents . Congress of t h e EUBS. Ed. Commiss ion of of t h e European Communi t ies , Luxembourg, 1978. 77-94.

6.- Davis J. C . and El l io t t D. H. : T r e a t m e n t of t h e decompress ion disorders. In, Bennet P. B. and El l io t t D. H. : The Physiology and Medicine of Diving. Ed. ~ a i l l k r e Tindall , London, 3rd. ed., 1982; 473-488.

7.- Hills B.A : Decompression Sickness. Ed. John Wiley & Sons, Ch iches t e r , 1977; 228-234

DIVING AND HYPERUARIC MEDICINE. Proceedings of the 1X Congress of the E.U.B.S. Ed. 3. Desola, CRIS, Barcelona, 1984.

Page 15: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

AND HYPERBARIC MEDICINE

4

Proceedings of the IX Congress of the Eyropean Undersea Biomedical Society

(E.U.B.S.)

English - Catala - Espaiiol - Francais

Page 16: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

DIVING AND HYPERBARIC MEDICINE

PROCEEDINGS OF THE IX CONGRESS

OF THE

EUROPEAN UNDERSEA BIOMEDICAL SOCIETY

(E.U.B.S.)

l , Sponsored by

CENTRE DE RECUPERACIO I D'INVESTIGACIONS SUBMARINES (C.R.I.S.)

Edited by

JORDl DESOLA ALA

EDlClONS C.R.I.S., BARCELONA

Page 17: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

0 Edicions C.R.I.S., 1984

C e n t r e d e ~ e c u ~ e r a c i 6 i d'Investigacions Submarines (C.R.I.S.) Raval d e Sant Mateu, 31 Esplugues d e Llobregat (Barcelona, Spain)

Par t ia l ly o r t o t a l reproduction a r e not allowed without mentioning t h e t i t l e , ed i tor , and authors of the book.

Prohibida la reproducci6 t o t a l o parcial sense c i t a r e l t i tol , I 'autor , i e l s edi tors del llibre.

Prohibida la reproducci6n parcial o t o t a l sin c i t a r e l t i tulo, au tor , y ed i to res d e la obra.

La reproduction par t ie l ou t o t a l n 'est pas authoris6e sans c i t e r le t i t r e , I 'edi teur, et les autheurs du livre.

ISBN: 84-398-2285-5

~ e ~ 6 s i to legal: 29.670

Printed in Barcelona, Spain. ~ r n p r e s a Barcelona, Espanya. Impreso e n Barcelona, EspaRa. 1rnprirn6 Barcelone, Espagne.

Page 18: EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDY OF DYSBARIC DIVING ......often happens during mandatory free-scape practices in SCUBA courses. Some very important diving fatalities produced the addition of

i th SEPTEMB

I X CONGRESS of

EUROPEAN UNDERSEA B I O M E D I C A L S O C I E T Y

(E.u.B. S.)

r