22
Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia Leigh Thwaites, David Fleer and Ben Smith SARDI Publication No. F2010/000681-1 SARDI Research Report Series No. 490 SARDI Aquatic Sciences PO Box 120 Henley Beach SA 5022 August 2010 A progress report for Biosecurity SA

Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Leigh Thwaites, David Fleer and Ben Smith

SARDI Publication No. F2010/000681-1 SARDI Research Report Series No. 490

SARDI Aquatic Sciences PO Box 120 Henley Beach SA 5022

August 2010

A progress report for Biosecurity SA

Page 2: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in

Lake Albert, South Australia

A progress report for Biosecurity SA

Leigh Thwaites, David Fleer and Ben Smith

SARDI Publication No. F2010/000681-1 SARDI Research Report Series No. 490

August 2010

Page 3: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

This publication may be cited as: Thwaites, L.A., Fleer, D. and Smith, B.B (2010). Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia: A progress report for Biosecurity SA. South Australian Research and Development Institute (Aquatic Sciences), Adelaide. SARDI Publication No. F2010/000681-1. SARDI Research Report Series No. 490. 18pp. South Australian Research and Development Institute SARDI Aquatic Sciences 2 Hamra Avenue West Beach SA 5024 Telephone: (08) 8207 5400 Facsimile: (08) 8207 5406 http://www.sardi.sa.gov.au DISCLAIMER The authors warrant that they have taken all reasonable care in producing this report. The report has been through the SARDI Aquatic Sciences internal review process, and has been formally approved for release by the Chief, Aquatic Sciences. Although all reasonable efforts have been made to ensure quality, SARDI Aquatic Sciences does not warrant that the information in this report is free from errors or omissions. SARDI Aquatic Sciences does not accept any liability for the contents of this report or for any consequences arising from its use or reliance placed upon it. © 2010 SARDI This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), no part may be reproduced by any process without prior written permission from the authors. Printed in Adelaide: September 2010 SARDI Publication No. F2010/000681-1 SARDI Research Report Series No. 490 Author(s): Dr Leigh Thwaites, David Fleer and Dr Ben Smith Reviewer(s): Chris Bice and Jason Nicol Approved by: Dr Qifeng Ye

Program Leader – Inland Waters & Catchment Ecology Signed: Date: 2 September 2010 Distribution: Biosecurity SA, SAASC Library and University of Adelaide Library Circulation: Public Domain

Page 4: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...........................................................................................1 BACKGROUND ...........................................................................................................3 METHODS ....................................................................................................................6

Estimating carp population and biomass via a Mark-Recapture experiment .............6 Carp tagging ...............................................................................................................7 Estimating carp population and biomass from the commercial catch ........................9

RESULTS ....................................................................................................................10

Petersen mark-recapture experiment.........................................................................10

DISCUSSION ..............................................................................................................12

Optimising the carp harvest and population estimate ..............................................13 Further considerations..............................................................................................16

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.........................................................................................17 REFERENCES ............................................................................................................17

i

Page 5: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Lake Albert is part of the Coorong, Lower Lakes and Murray Mouth Ramsar wetland.

It was disconnected from Lake Alexandrina via an earthen levee in March/April 2008

to minimise evaporative water losses during drought conditions that have persisted

since at least 2002. However, declining water levels have led to the exposure of

acid-sulfate soils and increasing salinities, which are threatening large-scale fish kills.

Intermittent pumping of environmental water from Lake Alexandrina to Lake Albert

has been required since May 2008, to maintain lake water levels above an

acidification trigger level (i.e. -0.75 m AHD) and to regulate salinity at

≈20,000 μS.cm-1 (electrical conductivity). Nonetheless, commercial carp (Cyprinus

carpio) harvesting was commissioned in 2009 and 2010 to reduce the biomass of fish

in Lake Albert, in anticipation of a possible future fish kill.

The aim of this study was to estimate the total biomass of adult carp in Lake Albert

and to quantify the success of the 2010 commercial carp harvesting operations- in

terms of the percentage of the carp population removed. Commercial fishing using

haul- and gill nets commenced on the 3rd March, ≈30 days after the onset of the

pumping of environmental water and when carp first started aggregating around the

inflow point in the Narrung Narrows.

The important findings from this project are:

• A total of 45,007 kg (≈10,793 individuals) of carp was commercially

harvested from 3rd March to 15th June 2010.

• Of 99 carp captured-tagged-released before the commercial fishing began, five

were later re-captured during commercial fishing operations.

• The total population of carp >500 mm TL at the time of tagging was estimated

using an adjusted Petersen population estimate. The estimate was ≈179,900

individuals (750,183 kg), with upper and lower 95 % confidence intervals of

415,154 individuals (1,731,192 kg) and 84,992 individuals (354,417 kg),

respectively.

1

Page 6: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

• The remaining population of carp >500 mm TL in Lake Albert is estimated at

≈169,107 (705,176 kg) as of 15th June 2010; this is the total estimate, minus

the 2010 commercial harvest.

• The 2010 commercial harvest captured ≈6% of the total population of adult

carp >500 mm TL (2.6% of the upper 95% confidence interval for the

population estimate and 12.7% of the lower).

An optimised carp harvesting and population estimation strategy is suggested for

harvesting in late-2010 (from October), which will coincide with the known peak

in carp movement for spawning. This would require a carp corral and population

survey equipment to be set-up within the entrance to the Narrung Narrows, and

additional tagging of carp in the lake. We estimate that >85% of the total adult

carp (>250 mm TL) population, or >700 tonnes of carp could be contained and

harvested utilising this strategy.

Finally, we suggest that there is also rationale and scope to evaluate the biomass

of bony herring - the second most abundant fish in Lake Albert – and the annual

biomass input arising from carp recruitment.

2

Page 7: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

BACKGROUND In recent years, reduced flows to South Australia and ongoing dry conditions have

resulted in flows over Lock and Weir 1 being insufficient to maintain the ‘pool-level’

(≈0.7 m AHD) downstream. Consequently, water levels in Lakes Alexandrina and

Albert have, at times, fallen to unprecedented low levels (minus 0.7-1.0 m AHD),

resulting in the exposure of large areas of acid sulfate soils. To maintain water levels

above a critical acidification level of -0.75 m AHD (the water level at which the

amount acid generated in the sediment will not be neutralised by the water that

inundates the sediment) in Lake Albert, water has been seasonally (typically

autumn/winter) pumped from Lake Alexandrina over an earthen levee, which was

constructed across the Narrung Narrows in March/April 2008 to separate the lakes

(Figure 1). While this management practice can help minimise the exposure of acid

sulfate soils, pumping is not continuous or guaranteed, and large-scale fish kills may

occur if salinity levels rise above ≈20,000 μS.cm-1 (electrical conductivity). Since

June 2008, Lake level and salinity have varied and salinities have approached 20,000

μS.cm-1; water levels were lowest and salinities greatest in March 2010 (Figure 2). A

large scale fish kill in Lake Albert would have negative impacts for the quality of the

remaining water and the social values of the lake for the surrounding communities.

Results from a commercial fishing trial in 2009 suggested that carp (Cyprinus carpio)

is the dominant large-bodied fish species in Lake Albert (≈70% of the biomass,

Bice 2010) and that this technique is potentially viable for reducing biomass. Thus, in

early-2010, Biosecurity SA again engaged commercial fishers from the Lower Lakes

and Coorong Fishery to harvest carp in order to limit the extent of a potential future

fish kill. A reduction in carp biomass may have additional benefits for the lakes

ecosystem as carp are ecologically destructive (disturb and suspend benthic

sediments, redistribute seeds etc.) and can compete with native species for food and

habitat (Sibbing et al. 1986; Gehrke and Harris 1994; Smith 2005; Miller and Crowl

2006; Matsuzaki et al. 2009). In order to gauge the effectiveness of the commercial

fishing, Biosecurity SA engaged SARDI Aquatic Sciences to estimate Lake Alberts

carp population (and biomass)

3

Page 8: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Figure 1. Map showing the Lower Lakes of the River Murray and location of the earth constructed weir across the Narrung Narrows- separating Lakes Alexandrina and Albert.

4

Page 9: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Wat

er L

evel

(m, A

HD

)

-0.8

-0.7

-0.6

-0.5

-0.4

-0.3

-0.2

-0.1

0.0

DateJu

n 10

May

10

Apr

10

Mar

10

Feb

10Ja

n 10

Dec

09

Nov

09

Oct

09

Sep

09

Aug

09

Jul 0

9Ju

n 09

May

09

Apr

09

Mar

09

Feb

09Ja

n 09

Dec

08

Nov

08

Oct

08

Sep

08

Aug

08

Jul 0

8Ju

n 08

Salin

ity (E

C u

nits

)

0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

16000

18000

20000

Figure 2. (top) Lake Albert water level and (bottom) salinity (expressed as electrical conductivity, EC, μS.cm-1) during June 2008 to June 2010.

5

Page 10: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

METHODS

Estimating carp population and biomass via a Mark-Recapture experiment The resident population of large-bodied carp (>500 mm Total Length, TL), which are

targeted by commercial fishers, was estimated via an adjusted Petersen

mark-recapture experiment according to Equation 1 from Ricker (1975, adapted from

Chapman 1951).

)1()1)(1(~

+++

=R

CMN …………………………………………………. (Equation 1)

Where M is the number marked and released, C is the number subsequently examined

for marks, R is the number of marks found (i.e. recaptures) in the sample C, N is the

total (and unknown) number in the population and Ñ is the adjusted Petersen estimate

of N.

The following assumptions are implicit in studies of this kind: • Fish will not lose their tags,

• Tagged and non-tagged fish suffer the same natural mortality rate, and

• All fish have an equal opportunity for capture.

In this study, the first two assumptions were expected to hold as prior experience and

knowledge of the lake suggested (SARDI unpublished data):

• Tag retention will be high,

• Tagging will not significantly affect mortalities in carp, and

• Loss of tagged and non-tagged carp (via amateur fishing, natural mortality) would

be minimal.

It was, however, suggested that the final assumption could be violated due to the

short-timeframes between tagging and commercial fishing, and the fact that most

large carp were aggregated (and tagged) in the area of the Narrows, where they were

6

Page 11: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

later re-captured by the commercial fishers (see below & Methods). If tagged fish

were over-represented in the catch, then this bias would result in a conservative

population estimate.

To minimise error/bias: • Carp were tagged both near the freshwater inflow (i.e. within the Narrung

Narrows) and far from the inflow (i.e. at Meningie and within Lake Albert

proper),

• All carp were double-tagged in the two weeks prior to the planned onset of

commercial fishing, to allow some time for tagged fish to recover and mix with

non-tagged fish,

• All tagged/non-tagged fish from the commercial catch were enumerated, and the

length and weight of sub-samples of the captured fish were recorded, and

• To calculate the Petersen population estimate and the 95% confidence intervals all

recaptures and the commercial catch from the narrows was pooled.

Carp tagging

To achieve a Petersen estimate of N that in 95% of trials would deviate no more than

25% from the true value of N, initial estimates of i) the Lake’s total carp population

and ii) the expected number of captured fish to be examined for tags, is required to

estimate the number of carp to initially tag (Figure 3; after Robson and Regier, 1964

and Ricker 1975).

The carp population within Lake Albert was estimated to comprise >100,000

individuals (≈400,000 kg; assuming an average weight of 4 kg) (Pers. Comms: Glen

Hill and Barry Jennings, commercial fishers). It was expected that up to 25% of this

population or 25,000 adult carp (≈100,000 kg, or approximately the same as was

captured by commercial fishing in 2009) could be harvested by commercial fishing

from March to June 2010. Thus, 200 carp should have been tagged and released

(Figure 3). However, due to time constraints (see below) only 99 carp

(500-780 mm TL) were able to be tagged and released prior to the onset of the

7

Page 12: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

commercial harvest. Of these, 30 were from the main lake and the remainder were

from the Narrows, adjacent to the water pumps.

Figure 3. Combination of number of marks (M) and number subsequently examined for marks (C) for a series of population sizes (N- curved lines), which provide Petersen estimates of N that in 95% of trials will deviate no more than 25% from the true value of N (from Robson and Regier, 1964 and Ricker 1975)

Fish tagging was undertaken from 24th February 2010 to 1st March. Commercial

fishing operations began on the 3rd of March (Tables 1-2). Carp were captured for

tagging using a 60 metre, 80mm stretched-mesh shore-based seine haul in the

Narrung Narrows and 4 by 250 metre commercial gillnets with 120 mm

stretched-mesh in the open lake. Gill nets were used in the main lake as seine netting

proved ineffective in capturing carp from open water. Captured carp were tagged with

two external dart tags inserted between the dorsal pterygiophores (the internal

extension of the dorsal fin ray structure, Figure 4a & b) and measured before being

released at the capture location.

8

Page 13: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Figure 4. Photographs showing (a) the carp tagging operation and (b) a double-tagged carp.

Estimating carp population and biomass from the commercial catch

Commercial fishing operations occurred over 28 days between 5th March and 15th

June 2010. Fishing was principally confined to waters within the Narrung Narrows,

where carp >500 mm TL had been aggregating since the onset of flow delivery in

early February. Carp <500 mm TL comprised just 0.05% (n = 585) of commercial

gillnet catches and these data were excluded from further analysis. Thus, the

population estimates presented relate to adult carp >500 mm TL, which represents

both the size targeted by the commercial fishers and the size range of carp tagged.

Catch data from commercial fishing operations was used to estimate the total carp

population via adjusted Peterson population estimates. For each operation, the total

weight of carp removed (kg) and the total number of tagged carp recaptured was

recorded. A sub-sample of carp captured using each fishing technique (haul nets,

n=114; gill nets, n = 112) was measured for weight and the average weight of the

sub-samples was used to calculate the total number of carp captured from each

harvesting event. Due to the low number of recaptures of tagged carp

(n=5, see Results), data from the commercial haul net operations was pooled

(as per Ricker 1975) and an overall population estimate calculated. In addition, 95%

confidence intervals for the overall population estimate were calculated according to

Ricker (1975).

9

Page 14: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

RESULTS

Petersen mark-recapture experiment

A total of 99 carp were tagged and released, and five were recaptured. Of the

recaptures, all were from commercial haul net operations within the Narrung narrows

and none were from gillnets set in the open lake.

The total weight of carp captured from 19 commercial haul net operations was

45,007 kg (Table 1). This equated to an estimated 10,793 individuals, given an

average weight of sub-sampled carp of 4.17 kg (n = 114). In contrast, commercial

gillnets in the main lake yielded 947 kg (n = 751 individuals) of carp from

12 operations (Table 2). Whilst all of the carp captured via commercial haul netting

were >500 mm TL, measurements from gillnet sub-samples (n =112) indicated that

only 28% of gilled carp were above >500 mm TL (average weight 2.4 kg).

The Peterson population estimate for carp >500 mm TL from pooled data was

≈179,900 (750,183 kg) at the time of sampling, with the upper and lower 95%

confidence intervals equating to 415,154 carp (1,731,192 kg) and 84,992 carp

(354,417 kg), respectively. Subtracting the commercial harvest (≈ 10,793 carp;

45,007 kg) from the population estimate from pooled data suggests a total population

of ≈169,107 (705,176 kg; upper 95% interval - 1,686,185 kg, lower 95% interval-

309,410 kg) adult carp >500 mm TL remaining in Lake Albert as of 15th June 2010.

10

Page 15: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Table 1. Summary of commercial haul net catches of carp (date and total weight) from the Narrung Narrows.

Date Weight of carp removed (kg)

Tags retrieved

12/03/2010 2280 16/03/2010 3570 17/03/2010 7820 1 18/03/2010 7300 1 22/03/2010 2890 23/03/2010 1890 24/03/2010 4650 25/03/2010 2720 8/04/2010 2125 9/04/2010 579 10/04/2010 2597 11/04/2010 905 1 22/04/2010 290 24/04/2010 774 2/05/2010 140 1 3/06/2010 1080 1 4/06/2010 510 10/06/2010 1700 15/06/2010 500

Table 2. Summary of commercial gill net catches of carp (date and total weight) from open water in Lake Albert.

Date Weight of carp removed (kg)

Tags retrieved

5/03/2010 155 6/03/2010 287 7/03/2010 147

11/03/2010 39 13/03/2010 65 14/03/2010 103 15/03/2010 52 17/03/2010 44 18/03/2010 11 20/03/2010 14 21/03/2010 7 22/03/2010 23

11

Page 16: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

DISCUSSION

The 2010 commercial harvest removed a considerable biomass of carp (45,007 kg or

10,793 carp >500 mm TL), yet this only represents 6% of the estimated adult carp

population that was present at the commencement of fishing (2.6% of the upper 95%

confidence interval and 12.7% of the lower). Currently, the total population of carp in

the lake (>500 mm TL) is estimated at over 700 tonnes (≈169,107 individuals).

While the 95% confidence intervals for the stated biomass estimate are large, Ricker

(1975, page 79) states that if recaptures are greater than four (five in this study), “then

the probability of statistical bias within the estimate can be ignored”. As such, the

upper and lower limits represent the likely limits of error for the population estimate,

but these could be improved significantly by introducing greater numbers of tagged

fish for recapture in future work.

Commercial gill net sampling within the greater Lake Albert indicated that the size

range targeted by commercial fishers and tagged in this study (>500 mm TL) may

represent, in terms of numbers, ≈28% of the resident carp population. While this

would suggest that a significant biomass is unaccounted for in the present estimate, it

is difficult to draw inferences as the majority of carp >500 mm TL were aggregated at

the narrows at the time of sampling, and may therefore have been underrepresented in

the gill net samples. Regardless, the total carp biomass comprising all size classes is

likely to be significantly higher than the estimate for carp >500 mm TL reported here

(≈700 tonne), and this should be quantified in future assessments.

Commercial haul netting has been shown to be an effective method for large scale

carp removal. However, the commercial harvest began ≈30 days after the onset of

flow, and the carp began dispersing from the inflow area (in the Narrung Narrows) in

early April (after ≈2 months of flow). Similar carp behaviour has been reported at

Banrock Station (Conallin et al., in prep) and Lake Bonney (Thwaites and Smith

2010), where the duration of carp’s attraction to the provision of environmental flows

was also two months in each case. Further, at Banrock Station, water temperature was

also found to be important in stimulating an initial response in carp and subsequently

12

Page 17: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

influenced catchability. Increased movement and a concurrent increase in catchability

was observed as water temperatures approached 16oC after winter, with peak catch

rates occurring when water temperatures reached 16oC.

Optimising the carp harvest and population estimate

Greater commercial harvesting success in the Narrung Narrows is predicted in

late-2010, since the proposed timing of the onset of the next inflow period is the

1st of October. This coincides with the typical peak spawning period and optimal

water temperatures (i.e. ≈16oC) following winter, and thus carp are likely to move ‘en

masse’ into the Narrows. However, substantial additional improvements in the carp

harvesting success could be made by:

1) Corralling adult carp near the entrance of the Narrows, as they migrate towards

the inflow point, and

2) Using acoustic telemetry and tagging data to determine the percentage of the total

population that has been corralled for harvesting.

Corralling migrating carp and using acoustic telemetry and tagging data to quantify

their abundance is the optimal solution because:

• Corralling will prevent carp from leaving the Narrows once they have entered,

• The carp are held in a fishable area, and are vulnerable to multiple fishing

methods; power haul, gill & fyke nets,

• Fishing activity can be continuous, and coincide with processing and market

requirements, and

• Rapid assessments of the total population in the corral can be made at any one

time.

13

Page 18: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

A desirable corralling location has been identified, which is ≈1000 m long x 200 m

wide (Figure 5). Setting the corral and survey methods would require:

1) One 275 m long upstream blocking net – heavily floated and weighted, as per the

nets used in Lakes Crescent & Sorrel (Tasmania) to block the access of carp to

desirable spawning habitat,

2) One 250 m long downstream blocking net with a funnel entrance – to allow the

carp access to the holding area, and to prevent them from escaping back into the

lake,

3) Six acoustic telemetry receivers, 40 acoustic telemetry transmitters (20 for carp

>500 mm TL, 20 for carp <500 mm TL), & 800 dart tags (two tags per fish; 400

for carp >500 mm TL, n = 200 fish; 400 for carp <500 mm TL, n = 200 fish), and

4) An access point to the holding area for commercial trucks and boats.

To optimise the accuracy of the estimates of the total adult (fishable) carp population

(including carp >250 mm TL), the percentage of the population contained by the

corral, and the confidence assigned to those estimates, a range of sizes of adult carp

(>250 mm TL) should be tagged and released in multiple-zones in the main lake

during mid-August to early-September (e.g. at least one month prior to the onset of

their migration towards the Narrows in October when flows commence). This will

facilitate better mixing of tagged and non-tagged carp and reduce any potential fishing

bias regarding the re-capture of tagged fish. It will also provide information on carp

movements in relation to the filling event e.g. are carp drawn to the inflow from

across the entire lake or only from the immediate vicinity?

**By using suitable blocking nets, we estimate that >85% of the total adult

carp population remaining in Lake Albert could be trapped and contained for

harvesting within the 1km long x 250 m wide corral proposed herein.

14

Page 19: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Figure 5. Conceptual overview of a carp corral and survey design to optimise the commercial harvest and carp population estimate for Lake Albert in late-2010. The blocking/containment nets (orange lines) delineate the carp holding and fishing zone (green shaded area). The acoustic receivers (yellow pins) are positioned to detect approaching and trapped carp, and any escapement from the corral. An access point (shaded yellow) for trucks, boats and carp processing equipment is proposed. A detachable carp collection net (cod-end, shaded orange) could be incorporated into the upstream net to optimise the removal of carp from the holding zone.

15

Page 20: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

Further considerations

1. Establish population estimates of other highly abundant large body species.

Bony herring are a widespread and abundant species (Lintermans 2007) that, together

with carp, dominate the large bodied fish biomass within Lake Albert (bony herring

were ≈25% of the 2009 commercial harvest, Bice 2010). With such a large biomass

the species is likely to contribute significantly to the negative impacts associated with

large scale fish kills. As this species also supports a commercial fishery in the Lower

Lakes, future work could additionally focus on quantifying the utility of the

commercial fishery at reducing/controlling the biomass.

2. What is the true effect of large scale carp harvesting? Although commercial

harvesting can remove a large biomass of carp, the effect of this removal may be

constantly negated by annual spawning and recruitment. Indeed, a reduction in the

biomass of large carp will reduce competition among small carp for the available

resources, which may increase the survival and growth rates of small carp. This is an

extremely important research question that may aid in focusing the application of carp

control measures.

16

Page 21: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This project was funded by Biosecurity SA. The authors would like to sincerely thank

commercial fishers Glen Hill and Barry Jennings for their cooperation, use of

facilities and input to this research.

REFERENCES Bice, C. (2010). Biological information and age structure analysis of large-bodied fish

species captured during the Lake Albert trial fish down October 2009. SARDI

Publication No. F2010/000159-1, SARDI Research Report Series No. 430

Conallin, A. J., Smith, B. B., Thwaites, L. A., Gillanders, B. M. and Walker, K. W.

(in prep) Exploiting innate behaviours to control common carp (Cyprinus

carpio L.) at wetlands.

Gehrke, P. C., and Harris, J. H. (1994). The role of fish in cyanobacterial blooms in

Australia. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 45, 905-915.

Lintermans, M. (2007). Fishes of the Murray-Darling Basin: An introductory guide.

Murray Darling Basin Commission Publication No. 10/07. 157 pp

Matsuzaki, S. S., Usio, N., Takamura, N., and Washitani, I. (2009). Contrasting

impacts of invasive engineers on freshwater ecosystems: an experiment and

meta-analysis. Oecologia 158, 673-86.

Miller, S. A., and Crowl, T. A. (2006). Effects of common carp (Cyprinus carpio) on

macrophytes and invertebrate communities in a shallow lake. Freshwater

Biology 51, 85-94.

Ricker, W. E. (1975). Computation and interpretation of biological statistics of fish

populations. Bull. Fish. Res. Board Can. 191: 382 p.

17

Page 22: Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake … · Estimating the biomass of adult common carp in Lake Albert, South Australia. ... Estimating the biomass of adult common

Estimating the biomass of carp in Lake Albert, South Australia

18

Robson, D. S. and Regier, H. A. (1964). Sample size in Petersen mark-recapture

experiments. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 93 (3), 215-226.

Sibbing, F. A., Osse, J. W. M., and Terlouw, A. (1986). Food handling in the carp

(Cyprinus carpio): Its movement patterns, mechanisms and limitations. Journal

of the Zoological Society of London 210, 161-203.

Smith, B. B. (2005). The state of the art: a synopsis of information on common carp in

Australia. Primary Industries and Resources South Australia, South Australian

Research and Development Institute, Adelaide. 67 pp.

Thwaites, L.A., and Smith, B.B. (2010). Design and installation of a novel wetland

carp harvesting set-up at Lake Bonney, South Australia. A summary report for

the South Australian Murray-Darling Basin Natural Resources Management

Board, Invasive Animals Cooperative Research Centre and the Murray-

Darling Basin Authority. South Australian Research and Development

Institute (Aquatic Sciences), Adelaide, 58 pp. SARDI Publication Number

F2010/000295-1. SARDI Research Report Series Number 469.