Ethics and end of life in ICU/CCM Board review

8/10/2019 Ethics and end of life in ICU/CCM Board review

1/28

!"#$%&' )**+,* $- )-",-*$., /&0,1,2$%$-,

!"#$%&' )* +,-./0 1!0 1232''"4-&./ 56"7/''"6

!-6/4."60 56"$6&8 "9 :.,-4' &9;


2/28

3&%+'"4 5$*%'6*+0,*

D" >"./9=&%


3/28

7,4 869$%*

3.&9;&6;' "7 '#66"$&./ ;/4-'-"9 8&G-9$

3,&6/; ;/4-'-"9 8&G-9$

F' .,/6/ &9 /.,-4&% ;-'=94="9 C/.H//9 +I &9; +!

%-7/ '#>>"6.J

56-94->%/ "7 ;"#C%/ /K/4.

L#=%-.A &9; 4"9M-4. 6/'"%#="9


4/28

10: ;&+' $* & 6'2 ?&- @$"# & #$*"604 6A /B5 *C9 /BDEF

&2?$G,2 @$"# 9-,+?6-$&: H, 2,.,'69* *,9*$*F 1IJ3 &-2 $*

&2?$G,2 "6 "#, )/K @#,0, #, $* $-"+L&",2F .,-M'&",2 &-2 N$.,-90,**60* $- &22$M6- "6 &-ML$6M%*: BO,0 P 2&4* $- "#, )/KF 10:

;&+' $* %'$-$%&''4 +-%#&-N,2 ,Q%,9" A60 @60*,-$-N 0,-&' A+-%M6-R

#$* B;B/H! P *%60, 90,2$%"* ,A'-4-&9O C&'/; "9 .,/ >&=/9.P' @&%#/'

,A'-4-&9O &44"6;-9$ ." .,/ >&=/9.P' C/'. -9./6/'.'*

!* N,/ 4"#6.':* N,/ ,"'>-.&% /.,-4' 4"88-B//


5/28

I+006N&", 5,%$*$6- 1&U$-N


6/28

)/,&8> Q %/' "7 )-"8/;-4&%

:.,-4'* RSST

B+"6-6?4 $- )/K ;&M,-"*

2#."9"8AU ;/6-@/; 76"8 V6//G !"#$% WX'/%7YZ &9;

'$($% WX6#%/YZ

X5/6'"9&% 6#%/ "7 .,/ '/%7 .,&. -' 76// 76"8 4"9.6"%%-9$

-9./67/6/94/' CA ".,/6'*Y

="9' >6"8"./ .,/-6 '/%7O-9./6/'.*


7/28

)/,&8> Q %/' "7 )-"8/;-4&%

:.,-4'* RSST

I+006N&", 5,%$*$6->?&U$-N

F94&>&4-.&./; >&=/9.P' H-',/' &6/ '>"G/9 .,6"#$, & '#66"$&./U

I"&",2 @$*#,*Z .6/&.8/9. >6/7/6/94/' >6/@-"#'%A /[>6/''/; CA

.,/ >&=/9.*

I+L*M"+",2 [+2N?,-" *"&-2&02Z '#66"$&./ X;"9' .,/ 8/9.&%

8&9.%/ "7 .,/ >&=/9.*Y

X+,&. H"#%; .,/ >&=/9. '&A -7 ,/ 4"#%; '>/&G 7"6 ,-8'/%7JY

D,*" $-",0,*" *"&-2&02Z '#66"$&./ ;/4-;/' "9 .,/ .6/&.8/9.

4"#6'/ H-., .,/ ,-$,/'. C/9/\. 7"6 .,/ >&=/9. H-.,"#. 4%/&6

G9"H%/;$/ "7 H,&. .,/ >&=/9. H"#%; H&9.* 28/6-4&9 4"#6.' ,&@/ 6/>/&./;%A &]68/; .,&. '#66"$&./' 4&9 %-8-. %-7/ '#'.&-9-9$ .6/&.8/9.'*


8/28

"9'-C-%-.A 7"6 .,/ ;/4-'-"9

',&6/; C/.H//9 .,/ 4&6/$-@/6 ./&8 &9; .,/ >&=/9.P''#66"$&./*Y


9/28

3,/6-;&9 3d* 28 e 56/@ 1/; ^__T`^fUgfOff

I#&0,2 5,%$*$6->?&U$-N

NH"OH&A -97"68&="9 ',&6-9$ &9; !1 C/.H//9 .,/'#66"$&./ &9; >,A'-4-&9*

;#4*$%$&- $-9+"Z -97"68&="9 &C"#. .,/ ;-'/&'/ '.&./'04#66/9. .6/&.8/9.' &9; >6"$9"'-'*

I+006N&", $-9+"Z -97"68&="9 &C"#. >&=/9.P' @&%#/' &9;.6/&.8/9. >6/7/6/94/'*

]6$-" 2,'$L,0&M6- &-2 2,%$*$6-Z >,A'-4-&9 &9; '#66"$&./8#.#&%%A &$6// #>"9 & >%&9*


10/28


11/28

W$"#20&@$-N &-2 W$"##6'2$-N 80,&"?,-"

W$"##6'2$-NZ 9/@/6 '.&6=9$ & .6/&.8/9.

W$"#20&@$-NZ '.">>-9$ & .6/&.8/9.

D". &9 /.,-4&%%A 8/&9-9$7#% ;-'=94="9 H,/9 C"., 6/M/4.

>&=/9.P' @&%#/' ." C/ &%%"H/; ." ;-/*


12/28

^,N&' ;,0*9,%M., 6- 360,N6$-N 80,&"?,-"

F. -' %/$&%%A &9; /.,-4&%%A >/68-''-C%/ ." H-.,,"%; "6

H-.,;6&H &9A 8/;-4&% -9./6@/9="90 -94%#;-9$

9#.6-="9 &9; ,A;6&="9*

U.S. Supreme Court 1990, Cruzan decision


13/28

/#&-N$-N _&"+0, 6A 5,&"# $- "#, )/K

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

1987-8 (n=224) 1992-3 (n=200)

Percent

ofdeaths

Full supportWithhold LST

Withdraw LST

;0,-2,0N&*" ` ^+%,F B]\//1F abb


14/28

W#&" $A 46+ %6+'2 @$"##6'2 L+" -6"

@$"#20&@ "0,&"?,-"X

N,/ #9G9"H9 >&=/9. H-., 6/'>-6&."6A 7&-%#6/ -9 .,/

:h0 H," %&./6 -' 7"#9; ." ,&@/ &9 &;@&94/ ;-6/4=@/

'.&=9$ i!DFP*

N,/ >&=/9. H," H"#%; &44/>. & =8/ %-8-./; .6-&% "71j0 C#. 9". >6"%"9$/; 1j*


15/28

/&*, 6A 10: ;&+'

NH" ;&A' %&./60 ,/ ;/@/%">' ,A>/6G&%/8-& &9; &4-;"'-'

&' ,-' 6/9&% 7#94="9 ;/./6-"6&./' 7#6.,/6*

+,/9 A"# ;-'4#'' ,-' H"6'/9-9$ >6"$9"'-' H-., .,/7&8-%A0 .,/A '&A ,/ H"#%; 9". H&9. 7#6.,/6 %-7/

'#>>"6. &9; ."$/.,/6 A"# &$6// ." H-.,;6&H %-7/

'#>>"6.*


16/28

/&*, 6A 10: ;&+'

1/4,&9-4&% @/9=%&="9 &9; I! &6/ ;-'4"9=9#/;* a ,"#6' %&./6 16*5% -' '=%% &%-@/* I-' 7&8-%A &'G' -7 .,/6/ -' &9A.,-9$ A"# 4&9 ;" ."

8"@/ .,-9$' &%"9$* I-' H-7/ '&A'0 XF.P' k#'. &$"9-l-9$ 7"6 ,-8*Y

m"# "C'/6@/ .,&. 16* 5% &>>/&6' 4"87"6.&C%/ &9; ,&' 9"

"Ck/4=@/ '-$9' "7 >&-9 "6 ;-'.6/''*

Is it ethically acceptable to increase the opioid dose?A.

Yes

B.

No


17/28

N,/ 56-94->%/ "7 !"#C%/ :K/4.


18/28

56+L', !e,%"

F. -' >/68-''-C%/ ." &;8-9-'./6 .6/&.8/9.' -7 .,/-9./9;/;/K/4. -' ." .6/&. 'A8>."8'0 /@/9 -7 ,&'./9/;

;/&., -' & 7"6/'//&C%/ C#. #9-9./9;/;4"9'/n#/94/*

2;8-9-'./6-9$ ,-$,O;"'/ ">-"-;' ." .6/&. >&-9 -9 &

./68-9&%%A -%% >&=/9. -' &44/>.&C%/ /@/9 -7 .,/

8/;-4&="9 ,&'./9' .,/ >&=/9.o' ;/&.,

N,/ -9./9. -' 6/%-/7 "7 '#K/6-9$

N,/ 7"6/'//9 C#. #9-9./9;/; 4"9'/n#/94/ -' ,&'./9/; ;/&.,N,/ -9./9;/; /K/4. W>&-9 6/%-/7Z -' 9". &4,-/@/; .,6"#$, .,/

C&; /K/4. W4'-9$ ;/&.,Z*


19/28

/&*, 6A 10: ;&+'

1/4,&9-4&% @/9=%&="9 &9; I! &6/ ;-'4"9=9#/;* a ,"#6'

%&./6 16* 5% -' '=%% &%-@/* I-' 7&8-%A &'G' -7 .,/6/ -'

&9A.,-9$ A"# 4&9 ;" ." 8"@/ .,-9$' &%"9$* I-' H-7/ '&A'0

XF.P' k#'. &$"9-l-9$ 7"6 ,-8*Ym"# "C'/6@/ .,&. 16* 5% &>>/&6' 4"87"6.&C%/ &9; ,&' 9"

"Ck/4=@/ '-$9' "7 >&-9 "6 ;-'.6/''*

Is it ethically acceptable to administerKCl?


20/28

!+"#&-&*$& ` ;#4*$%$&- B**$*",2 I+$%$2,

:#.,&9&'-&O.,/ -9./9="9&% G-%%-9$ "7 & >&=/9.*

OF%%/$&% -9 ?3

5,A'-4-&9 2''-'./; 3#-4-;/U>,A'-4-&9 >6/'46-C/'

8/;-4&="9 ." >&=/9. G9"H-9$ .,&. .,/ >&=/9.

-9./9;' ." #'/ -. ." 4"88-. '#-4-;/*

Od/$&% -9 E6/$"9 &9; +&',-9$."9` -%%/$&% /@/6AH,/6//%'/ -9 ?3*


21/28

/&*, 6A 10: ;&+'

NH" ;&A' %&./60 ,/ ;/@/%">' ,A>/6G&%/8-& &9; &4-;"'-' &' ,-'6/9&% 7#94="9 ;/./6-"6&./' 7#6.,/6*

m"# C/%-/@/ .,&. 16* 5%P' 4,&94/ "7 '#6@-@-9$ ." ;-'4,&6$/ -'

pgq* +,/9 A"# ;-'4#'' .,-' H-., .,/ 7&8-%A0 .,/A '&A ,/H"#%; XH&9. /@/6A.,-9$ >"''-C%/ ." $-@/ ,-8 & 4,&94/Y &9;

&'G &C"#. '.&6=9$ ,/8";-&%A'-' 7"6 6/9&% 7&-%#6/*

Is hemodialysis futile in this setting?

A. YesB.

No


22/28

L#=%-.A


23/28

d" )* h/'"%@-9$ :.,-4&% !-%/88&' ^___` b^ObS

8#, /6-%,9" 6A 3+M'$"4

d&=9U)"*+,%- %/&GA E:!U)"*+.U %/&GA0 7&-%-9$ -9 .,/ ;/'-6/; /9; .,6"#$, -9.6-9'-4

;/7/4.*

V6//G 8A.,"%"$AU .,/ ;$,./6' "7 !&9' H/6/ 4"9;/89/;-9 I&;/' ." \%% & %&6$/ >"9; CA .6&9'>"6=9$ H&./6 -9 %/&GAC#4G/.'*

L#=%/ 8/;-4&% -9./6@/9="9' '/6@/ 9" 8/&9-9$7#% >#6>"'/0 9"

8&B/6 ,"H "r/9 .,/A &6/ 6/>/&./;*


24/28

d" )* h/'"%@-9$ :.,-4&% !-%/88&'* ^___` b^ObS

8#, I"0$%" /6-%,9" 6A 3+M'$"4]+*Mf%&M6- A60 K-$'&",0&' 5,%$*$6-*

!/\9-="9U .,/ -9./6@/9="9 H-%% 9". &44"8>%-', -.' -9./9;/; $"&%*

N,/ -9./6@/9="9 ,&' 9" >&.,">,A'-"%"$-4 6&="9&%/*W.6/&=9$

1F H-., &9=7#9$&% .,/6&>AZ


25/28

5$*%&02,2 %6-%,9"* 6A A+M'$"4

g+&-M"&M.,O 4,&94/ "7 '#44/''

I"H '8&%% -' '8&%% /9"#$,J WRqZ

I"H 8#4, >6"$9"'=4 #94/6.&-9.A -' .,/6/J g+&'$"&M.,O n#&%-.A "7 %-7/ >""6

D" H"6.,H,-%/ $"&%' 4&9 C/ &4,-/@/;

244"6;-9$ ." H,"8J

)/9/\.' 9". H"6., .,/ 4"'.

+," ;/4-;/'J


26/28


27/28


28/28

8#, B1B 5+, ;06%,** B9906&%# 86 \,*6'.,

5$*&N0,,?,-"* &L6+" V)-&990690$&",Y80,&"?,-"

R*

L&8-%A ',"#%; C/ $-@/9 -97"68&="9 &C"#. .,/ X-9&;@-'&C-%-.AY

;/./68-9&="9 >6"4/''

^* L&8-%A $-@/9 9"=4/ &9; -9@-./; ." >&6=4->&./ -9 .,/ 4"9'#%.&="9

>6"4/''

a*

:.,-4' 4"88-B// ',"#%; 8#'. >6"@-;/ & H6-B/9 6/>"6. "7 -.' \9;-9$' .".,/ 7&8-%A

T*

F7 ;-'>#./ 4&99". C/ 6/'"%@/;0 .,/9 ,"'>-.&% 8#'. &B/8>. ." &66&9$/

.6&9'7/6 ." &9".,/6 ,"'>-.&%*

Documents

Ethics and end of life in ICU/CCM Board review