O

O

Transmission Upgrading & Reinforcement Project Coordination Office, Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP)

Addis Ababa, Ethiopia August 2016

SFG3021P

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

edP

ublic

Dis

clos

ure

Aut

horiz

ed

Page | 2  

(Revised Report)

Table of Contents

34TList of Figures 34T ........................................................................................................................................ 6 

34TList of Abbreviations34T ............................................................................................................................. 6 

34TEexecutive Summary 34T ................................................................................................................................... 8 

34TI. General Background and Introduction 34T ................................................................................................ 17 

34T1.1. General Background34T ..................................................................................................................... 17 

34T1.2. Introduction34T .................................................................................................................................. 18 

34T1.3. Objectives of the RAP34T .................................................................................................................. 18 

34T1.4. Scope of Work (SOW)34T ................................................................................................................. 19 

34T1.5. Approach and Methodology34T ........................................................................................................ 20 

34T1.6. Challenges and Limitations34T ................................................................................................... 21 

34T2.1. Key Components and Description of the Project 34T ...................................................................... 22 

34T2.2. Project Funding34T ........................................................................................................................... 24 

34T2.3. Topography of the Line Route34T .................................................................................................... 24 

34T2.4. Population and Livelihood Profile34T .............................................................................................. 25 

34T2.4.1. Alamata Woreda 34T .................................................................................................................... 25 

34T2.4.2. North Wollo Zone 34T ................................................................................................................. 26 

34T2.4.3. South Wollo Zone 34T ................................................................................................................. 27 

34T2.4.4. Oromia Special Zone of Amhara Region34T ............................................................................ 28 

34T2.4.5. North Shoa Zone 34T ................................................................................................................... 28 

34T2.4.6. Legetafo-Legedadi Woreda (Finfine Zuria Special Zone of Oromia)34T ............................... 29 

34T3.1. The Constitution of Ethiopia 34T ....................................................................................................... 30 

34T3.2. Environmental Policy of Ethiopia34T .............................................................................................. 31 

34T3.3. The Land Tenure Policy34T ............................................................................................................. 31 

34T3.4. The National Policy of Women 34T .................................................................................................. 32 

Page | 3  

34T3.5. Proclamation No. 455/200534T ........................................................................................................ 32 

34T3.6. Council of Minister Regulation No. 135/200734T ........................................................................... 33 

34T3.7. Ethiopian Electricity Agency-Directive # EEA/1/200534T ........................................................... 34 

34T3.9. The World Bank Policy for Involuntary Resettlement34T ............................................................. 35 

34T3.9. Comparisons of the National Polices and the World Bank OP 4.12 34T ....................................... 36 

34TIV. Household Baseline Survey, Asset Inventory and Assessment and Review of First Phase Compensation Implementation 34T ................................................................................................................ 39 

34T4.1 Baseline Household Survey (Socioeconomic) Findings 34T ............................................................. 40 

34T4.2. Summary of Household (PAPs) Assets Inventory34T .................................................................... 40 

34T4.3. Vulnerability Assessment34T ............................................................................................................ 42 

34T4.4. Review of the First Round Compensation Implementation (2008 - 2011) 34T .............................. 43 

34TV. Project Impact Assessment and Categorization of Project Affected People 34T .................................. 48 

34T5.1. Major Social Benefits and Positive Impacts 34T ............................................................................... 48 

34T5.1.1 Facilitation of Improved Delivery of Social Services34T ........................................................... 48 

34T5.1.2. Reduced Rate of Deforestation and Public Health Risks 34T .................................................. 48 

34T5.1.3 Extending Local Employment Opportunity during the Stringing Operations 34T ................ 49 

34T5.2. Adverse Impacts of ROW Clearance34T .......................................................................................... 49 

34T5.3. Classification and Categorization of PAPs 34T ................................................................................. 51 

34T5.4. Cut-off Date for Determining Eligibility34T ................................................................................... 54 

34T5.5. Eligibility for Entitlement34T............................................................................................................ 54 

34T5.6. Other Anticipated Temporary Adverse Project Impacts 34T .......................................................... 60 

34T5.6.1. Potential Safety Hazards During and After Stringing of Transmission Cables34T ............. 60 

34T5.6.2. Improper Waste Disposal Practices 34T ..................................................................................... 62 

34T5.6.3. Road Traffic Flow Impacts during the Stringing Period34T................................................... 62 

34T5.6.4. Road Traffic Safety Hazards 34T ................................................................................................. 62 

34T5.6.5. Damage to Soil and Communal Lands34T ............................................................................... 63 

Page | 4  

34T5.7. Summary of Potential Adverse Impacts of the Project34T ............................................................. 63 

34T6.1. Consultation with Project Affected People at Senbete Town 34T ................................................... 65 

34T6.3 Consultation with Local Authorities and Other Stakeholders 34T .................................................. 67 

34T6.4. Public Views and Opinions about the Project 34T ........................................................................... 67 

34TVII. Mitigations for Adverse Impacts -Resettlement Action Plan 34T ........................................................ 69 

34T7.1. Legislative & Administrative Frameworks for Compensation of Affected Households and Assets 34T .................................................................................................................................................... 69 

34T7.2 Parameters and Applied Rates & Guidelines for Compensations 34T ............................................. 70 

34T7.3. Asset Valuation and Estimates of Compensations for PAPs 34T .................................................... 71 

34T7.4. Special Assistance for Vulnerable Groups 34T .................................................................................. 73 

34T7.5. Transitional Assistance for Informal Settlements 34T ...................................................................... 74 

34T7.6. Organizing PAPs under Housing Cooperatives and Provision of Serviced Land 34T .................. 75 

34T7.7. Measures of Mitigation to Resolve Outstanding Complaints 34T ................................................... 77 

34T7.8. Mitigation for Temporary and Other Project Related Adverse Effects34T ................................... 78 

34T7.8.1. Minimizing Potential Work and Safety Hazards during Construction Period34T ................ 78 

34T7.8.2. Mitigation Measures for Road Traffic Flow Anticipated Impacts 34T ..................................... 78 

34T7.8.3. Mitigation Measures for Anticipated Road Traffic Safety Hazards 34T ................................... 79 

34T7.8.4. Mitigation Measures for Improper Waste Management and Disposal Practices 34T ............. 79 

34T7.8.5. Mitigation Measures to Minimize Damage to Soil and Communal Lands 34T ...................... 79 

34T8.1. Parties Responsible for Implementation of the RAP34T ................................................................ 79 

34T8.2. RAP Implementation Management Plan 34T .................................................................................. 81 

34T8.2.1. Institutional Arrangement and RAP Implementation Committee 34T ................................... 81 

34T8.2.2. Mechanism to Address Complaints Related to Compensations and Other Issues 34T .......... 82 

34T8.3. Public Disclosure of RAP34T ........................................................................................................... 84 

34T8.4Monitoring and Evaluation 34T ........................................................................................................... 85 

34T8.3.1. Internal Monitoring 34T ............................................................................................................... 85 

Page | 5  

34T8.3.2. External Monitoring 34T .............................................................................................................. 86 

34TTable 12: Summarized Monitoring & Evaluation Indicators 34T ........................................................... 88 

34TIX – Costs and Budget for Implementation of the RAP34T........................................................................ 89 

34T9.134T  34TCompensation Payment 34T ......................................................................................................... 89 

34T9.2. Special Support for Vulnerable Groups and Budget for Informal Settlers 34T .............................. 90 

34T9.3. 34T  34TProject Management & Running Costs 34T ................................................................................. 90 

34TXI. Summary and Conclusions 34T ................................................................................................................. 95 

34TXII. References:34T .......................................................................................................................................... 97 

34TXIII. Annexes 34T ............................................................................................................................................. 98 

34TAnnex I: Summary of Baseline Survey of Affected Households 34T ..................................................... 98 

34TAnnex II – List of Category I to V PAPs 34T .......................................................................................... 99 

34TAnnex – III: Minutes of Consultation34T ............................................................................................. 120 

34TBrief Description and Components of the Stringing of Almata-Kombloch II –Legetafo 2 P

ndP

Circuit Power Transmission Line Project (Prepared by the consultant for public consultation meeting)34T ............................................................................................................................................. 123 

34TAnnex IV: Kalu Woreda Asset Valuation Guidelines &Rates 34T ....................................................... 143 

34TAnnex V: Estimated Monetary Value of Affected Assets (Based on Current Prices) 34T ................. 152 

34TLetter 2: land allocation commitment letter form Municpal Office of Senbete Town 34T ............... 212 

34TWith regards, 34T ...................................................................................................................................... 213 

34TAnnex VII: List of Contacted People34T .............................................................................................. 214 

List of Tables

Table 1: Transmission Line Stretch..............................................................................................27

Table 2: Summary of Ethiopian Legislation and the World Bank Policy..............................40

Table 3: Summary of Inventoried Household (PAPs) Assets...................................................44

Table 4: Summary of Assets Compensated During First Phase Period (2008 – 2011).........47

Table 5: Summary of Formal and Informal Reported Complaints (Cases) ...........................49

Table 6: Summary of PAPs remained occupying ROW after Compensations ....................50

Page | 6  

Table 7: Description and Categorization of PAPs......................................................................56

Table 8: Entitlement Matrix..........................................................................................................58

Table 9: Summary of Issues and Responses Presented at Consultation Meetings ...............66

Table 10: Asset Valuation Guidelines & Rates. ( Kalu Woreda)...............................................70

Table 11: Summary of Compensation Payments.......................................................................71

Table 12: Grievance Redressing Flowchart ................................................................................79

Table 13: Summarized Monitoring & Evaluation Indicators ...................................................82

Table 14: Budget for Asset Valuation Committee.....................................................................85

Table 15: Summary of Budget for Implementation of RAP.....................................................86

Table 16: Summary of RAP Implementation Action Plan and Schedule ............................86

List of Figures

Figure 1: Transmission towers near Sendafa town.....................................................................27

Figure 2: Partial topographic view of the line route...................................................................28

Figure 3: Transmission line route ................................................................................................34

Figure 4: Concentrated informal settlements within the ROW (Shoa Robit town).............46

Figure 5: Informal settlements within the ROW (Debresina & Senbete towns)..................51

Figure 6: Public Consultation Meetings in Senbete and Shoa Robit Towns........................64

Figure 7: Public consultation meeting attendees in Shoa Robit and Senbete towns............65

List of Abbreviations

EEA Ethiopian Electricity Agency

EEP Ethiopian Electric Power

EEPCo Ethiopian Electric Power Corporation

ENREP Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project.

ESIA Environmental & Social Impact Assessment

ETB Ethiopian Birr

FY Fiscal Year

GOE Government of Ethiopia

Page | 7  

GRC Grievance Redressing Committee

GTP Growth & Transformation Plan

HH Household

ICS Inter Connected System

KV Kilo Volt

MW Mega Watt

MoFED Ministry of Finance & Economic Development

MoWIE Ministry of Water, Irrigation & Energy

PAP Project Affected People

PAA Project Affected Area

RAP Resettlement Action Plan

ROW Right of Way

RPF Resettlement Policy Framework

TOR Terms of Reference

ULG Urban Local Governments

USD United States Dollar

WB World Bank

Page | 8  

Eexecutive Summary

1. General Summary

The Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP) has recently completed a feasibility study to reinforce Alamata - Kombolcha II-Legetafo - Kaliti I Second Circuit 230kV transmission line with power generated from Tekeze hydro power plant. The stringing of the second circuit 230 kV transmission line requires a 30 meter wide Right of Way (ROW) to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the power transmission line. All permanent structures, such as residential houses, plants and other assets found within the established ROW need to be removed in order to give way for the stringing activity. This RAP is, therefore, prepared with goal to identify and alleviate the various impacts associated with clearance of the Right of Way (ROW) of the transmission line and its subsequent operation on the socio-economic environment of the local inhabitants currently residing along the transmission line route.

Taking into consideration the large area coverage of the line route and the nature and intensity of the proposed activities, the EEP has carefully designed the line route to minimize large-scale displacement of urban and rural settlements as well as damages on agricultural land and farming activities. However, the social impact assessment carried out between January 21, 2015 – April 15, 2015 identified a total of 120 HHs (699 PAPs) currently occupying the ROW of the transmission line likely to be affected to the extent of demolition of their houses and or removal of permanent plants to give way for the designated 30 meters ROW clearance of the project. The type of assets to be affected include 180 residential houses and attached household facilities made with wood structure, plastered with mud and cement mortar, corrugated sheet metal and other substandard roofing materials and 823.

Table 1. Summary of Category of Project Affected Persons

Description Number of HHs

Remark

Total number of HHs affected by the project

120

HHs requiring physical relocation 117 103 HHs do not have legal title(informal settlers)

HHs not requiring physical dislocation, but need only compensation for trees

3

Page | 9  

Furthermore, a total of 80 HHs (400 PAPs), who were covered and compensated by the resettlement plan for the first phase of the project, continued to occupy the ROW clearance areas due to various reasons including unresolved compensation complaints, lack of efficient grievance redressing system and absence of clear and effective evacuation instructions after compensation payments made out to PAPs during the 2008-2011 resettlement implementation .

According to the directive issued by the Ethiopian Electric Agency ( Directive # EEA/1/2005 Article 7, Sub Article 7.1.4 ) farmers are allowed to cultivate seasonal crops up to 7 meters height and slow growing vegetation beneath the overhead electricity line transmission line projects not exceeding voltage of 230kV. Hence, the project will not affect agricultural production and livelihood activities under the designated ROW.

For residential houses that are situated within the designated ROW clearance area, affected households will be provided replacement land to construct houses regardless of their landholding status, i.e., either legal or informal landholdings. As many of the affected households are informal settlers without legal landholding rights, the RAP proposed a special land allocation arrangement to transform informal (squatter) settlements into legal and lawful housing settlements through formation of housing cooperative program. The program enables both formal and informal project affected households to have and establish legal landholding status and access serviced land from the local governments. This proposed land allocation arrangement not only helps PAPs to establish legal status, but also benefit the local government to minimize costs associated with serviced land development and lowers cost for PAPs (per member) in all services and products associated with the housing development.

During consultations and discussions with PAPs and representatives from the two local governments in the project area, the proposed land allocation arrangement was agreed and approved as a viable and lasting solution by the affected persons and the government. Further, as a result of several consultative meetings, the affected local administrations in the two towns confirmed their commitment in writing to make land available to PAPs as soon as cooperatives are formed and registered with concerned authorities and the project agreed to facilitate this process. Provision of replacement land and relocation of PAPs will take place prior to commencement of the stringing project activities. Copies of commitment letters (English translation) are attached in the annex.

Page | 10  

2. Project Description

2.1. Key Components of the Project

The proposed project involves laying of power transmission cables on existing 230 kV transmission line towers that have been constructed along Alamata -Kombolcha – Legetafo substations. The total length of the stringing of reinforcement line is 459 km, having 30 meters wide ROW. The ROW is required to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the transmission line. The stringing project also includes installation of equipment and accessories useful for upgrading the substations in Alamata, Kombolcha and Legetafo.

2.2. Topography of the Transmission Line Route

The transmission line passes through plain agricultural lands, hilly terrains and depleted mountain forests while deliberately avoiding concentrated settlement in major towns and rural areas located along the line route. The altitude of the line route area ranges from 800 meters in the low lands of Kalu woreda to 3100 meters above sea level rugged mountains of Tarmaber (Debresina). Several rivers cross the area fed by the highland watershed to the west. The main rivers are Birbisa, Sirinka, Alewuha, Gimbora, Golina, and Hormat rivers, along with numerous intermittent streams. Natural vegetation found along the line route includes bush scrub, acacia species and kurkura (wild nut) trees.

3. Funding Sources of the Project

According to the TOR document provided for this study, the World Bank is the principal funding institution for stringing of Alamata-Kombolcha II –Legetafo the 2P

ndP Circuit 230kv

Transmission Line project.

4. Approach and Methodology

The approach and methodology used in preparation of the RAP, includes

a) Collection of qualitative and quantitative social-economic data through baseline household survey, Census & Land Inventory of properties

b) Identifying and documenting type, physical conditions, and ownership status of properties located within the ROW of the transmission line route.

c) Formal and informal consultation with Project Affected People (PAPs) and other relevant stakeholders.

d) Collection and registration of attitudes, views and opinions expressed by project affected people and other stakeholders about the project.

Page | 11  

e) Review of past resettlement implementation documents

f) Review of relevant legal and administrative frameworks that have due relevance with the proposed stringing construction and subsequent operation.

5. Review of National Policies and Resettlement Frameworks

All relevant and applicable national laws, polices and regulatory frameworks that have due relevance to the resettlement and compensation procedures, including the federal law, national policies on Women and Environment, Council of Ministers Regulation on Compensations, the ENREP and the World Bank Policy Frameworks on involuntary resettlement and rehabilitation of PAPs have been carefully reviewed and analyzed. Comparisons and suggestions to address gaps between the Ethiopian laws and the World Bank’s Operational Policy on involuntary resettlement (OP 4.12) are presented in a table format as part of the report.

6. Key Findings

The census and land asset inventory recorded 180 residential houses and attached facilities, such as service rooms, patio, kitchen and fences occupying an average built up land area of 26.8MP

2P, and 823.6 permanent and fruit trees, including eucalyptus tree, acacia, banana and

mango trees. Of the total surveyed and inventoried properties, 30% is owned and occupied by people who have legal or customary landholding rights and 70% of property owners do not have formal or legal documents. The highest number of affected properties in the latter category is recorded in Shoa Robit woreda of Semen Shoa Zone (94 in Kebele 01 and kebele 04) followed by Legetafo – Legedadi town of Finfinife Special Zone of Oromia State (8) and Debresina Town of North Shoa Zone (2).

The vulnerability assessment showed elderly persons, over the age of 60 years, constitute only 2% of the total household members, 2 elderly household head PAPs with visual impairment and physical challenges and 57 women headed households. During the course of the assessment, none of the surveyed households reported to experience loss of income or livelihood activities resulting from the proposed loss of land as a result of the project activities. When measured in the broad context of inability to cultivate or experience loss in income and livelihood, the project impact on vulnerable groups is minimal.

Table 2: Summary of Key Survey Findings

Total length of transmission line 459 km

Number of Woredas the transmission line passes through 10

Number of kebeles covered under the survey 35

Page | 12  

Total number of households covered under the survey 208

Total number of household members covered under the survey 1202

Percentage of households headed by women 35%

Percentage of households headed by elderly person 2%

Total number of households affected by the project 120

Number of affected HHs requiring compensations for affected assets and require physical relocation

117

Number of affected households with legal landholding rights requiring physical relocations

14

Number of affected households without legal landholding rights (squatters) requiring physical relocation

103

Total number of households requiring compensations for plant assets only(not requiring physical relocation)

3

Number of affected residential houses and associated facilities 180

Number of affected perennial trees and plants 823.6

Percentage of affected household assets & properties with legal/formal ownership titles

30%

Percentage of affected household assets and properties owned without legal landholding rights

70 %

Number of households who remained occupying the ROW from the first phase resettlement program

80

Number of households who remained occupying the ROW due to compensation related complaints

45

Number of households who remained occupying the ROW due to absence of clear instruction and loose enforcement mechanisms

35

7. Reviews and Assessment of Performances of the Past RAP Implementation (2008-2011)

The consultant made concerted efforts to assess performances of past compensation implementation through formal and informal consultation with project affected people, discussions with local authorities and through review of compensation disbursement vouchers and project related reports. The findings indicate that the project disbursed compensation payments to 3559 project affected people along the line route and grievance-

Page | 13  

redressing mechanisms and procedures were established to ensure individuals and community grievances are handled fairly and addressed in a timely manner. However, the current assessment identified and recorded a total of 80 HHs, who were covered and compensated by the resettlement plan for the first phase of the project, that continue to occupy the ROW clearance areas due to various reasons including unresolved compensation complaints, lack of efficient grievance redressing system and absence of clear and effective evacuation instructions after compensation payments made out to PAPs.

8. Cut-off Date for Determining Eligibility

The cut-off date for eligibility claims and other forms of entitlements was established as the date the baseline survey and household asset inventory were completed, that is April 5, 2015. This date has been communicated with all stakeholders including PAPs.

9. Assessments and Analysis of Project Impacts

The major adverse impacts of the stringing activity would be the removal or demolition of household assets and useful resources found within the designated 30 meters ROW of the transmission line.

Accordingly, the assessment identified and determined that: 

A total of 117 HHs currently occupying the ROW of the transmission line will be physically relocated

A total of 3 HHs will be losing only trees

A total of 80 PAPs who were covered and compensated in the first phase project implementation period are still occupying their plots due to unresolved compensation complaints or other factors.

About 70 % of landholders have no formal or legal documents regarding land titles. Vulnerable population includes women headed households representing 35 % of the

total households and elderly members of households representing 2 % of the total households. Also there are two households headed by old people who are over 60 years of age with visual impairment or physical challenges.

The project needs access roads to reach transmission tower sites for both line construction and maintenance cases. For temporary purposes, feeder roads, footpaths and open communal or private lands may be used as access road during the stringing construction period. Temporary access to land for feeder roads and footpaths will be negotiated in advance with the private land owner or the community and compensation shall be provided prior to acquisition in accordance with this RAP.

Page | 14  

Anticipated safety and health hazards for communities during the stringing and its subsequent periods would likely to occur:  

From absence of proper workplace safety precautionary measures, Accidents and fatalities due to intensive vehicular movements and Electrical shocks from close contacts with low clearance and subsiding power

transmission cable lines. Workers will also be exposed to health and safety impacts. Worker and community

health and safety issues are treated comprehensively in the ESMP of this project.

10. Public Consultations and Communications

Two rounds of public consultation meetings were held with project affected people and other stakeholders. Basic components of the project, its likely impacts on landholdings, plants and other assets, cut-off date for claims, methods and procedures used for asset valuation, complaint or grievance redressing mechanisms and other relevant issues were discussed and communicated to PAPs. Topics discussed with local authorities include roles and responsibilities of local authorities in facilitating the resettlement plan, coordinating evacuation of PAPs from the ROW clearance areas, roles to resolve issues and complaints reported by PAPs and maintenance of sustained communications with EEP and project management staff. Minutes of consultation meetings along with list of participants are attached as Annex III.

11. Public Views and Opinions about the Project

Despite the possible loss of assets and personal and family inconveniences resulting from the resettlement process and other related concerns, project affected people who participated in the formal consultation meeting expressed support for the project development. Summary of the consultation meetings held and issues discussed with PAPs and local stakeholders is presented in section three of this document.

10. Eligibilities and Entitlement Matrix

The GOE legislation and the World Bank policy objectives require all individuals and households whose assets and productive resources affected as a result of the stringing project are entitled for compensation and/or other forms of assistance. Pursuant to the policy frameworks, PAPs eligible for entitlements include individuals/households with formally recognized property rights and those who have held land under informal purchase agreements and arrangements. Special entitlement in the form of financial assistance is proposed for vulnerable groups, such as elderly, women and individuals with health problems and physical challenges/disabilities to assist them in the relocation and resettlement process.

Page | 15  

12. Asset Valuations and Compensations Framework

The size of each affected property and useful assets of households were physically investigated and measured by a qualified professional with the presence of head of households or their family members. The monetary estimates of affected housing structures and other valuable assets and assistance for relocation is estimated and calculated based on rates used by local governments for similar projects and will conform to the rates set out in this RAP. Recommendations for compensations and other entitlements comply with existing legislative and administrative frameworks of the GOE and the World Bank guidelines.

13. Mitigation for Potential Risks and Safety Hazards

As the construction work involves safety issues and occupational hazards, potential risks to project staff shall be reduced by introducing and complying mandatory precaution safety measures and practices. Risks to the general public shall be minimized by promoting public awareness and education along with physical measures such as displaying appropriate warning signs and dissemination of public safety information through public announcements.

14. Costs and Budget for Implementation of the RAP

The overall budget for implementation of the proposed Resettlement Action Plan is estimated at ETB 6,074,725(USD 281747.84). This total budget is comprised of compensation for targeted residential housing units and other attached household facilities including kitchen, fences and storage rooms, perennial and fruit trees, demolition and moving expenses, temporary housing allowances, special assistance for vulnerable groups, a budget to support transition of project affected informal settlers into viable housing cooperatives, administration and management costs to implement the resettlement action plan and a contingency budget.

Table 3: Summary of Budget for Implementation of RAP

S/N Budget Item Birr USD A Compensations A.1 Houses and related household facilities 3, 503, 255.55 162,187.75 A.2 Fences 1, 181, 800.00 54,712.96 A.3 Trees and Fruit Plants 80,640.00 3,733.33 B Financial assistance for vulnerable groups 59, 000.00 2,731.41 C TA budget for informal settlers

&Temporary Housing Allowance 400,000.00 18,981.48

Page | 16  

D RAP Implementation Budget 371,000.00 17,175.92 Total Budget 5,204, 295.55 240,939.62 Contingency (10%) 520, 229.55 24,084.70 Grand Total Budget 6,074725.00 281,747.84

15. Parties Responsible for Implementation of the RAP

Parties responsible for effective implementation of the RAP are the Ministry of Water, Irrigation and Power, Ministry of Environment and Forestry and Ministry of Women and Children through their regional offices and Regional Governments through Urban Local Governments and local administrations. Above all, the EEP bears the overall responsibility for planning, budgeting, monitoring of the RAP through the various implementation phases.

16. RAP Implementation Management Plan

To ensure effective management and implementation of the RAP, the EEP will be establish a special RAP implementation management committee under Power System Planning Social Experts Unit responsible to oversee and maintain sustained communications with the various units and actors responsible for execution of the plan and to ensure consistency of the RAP with established ENREP Resettlement Policy Framework and the World Bank guidelines.

17. Grievance Redressing Mechanism

A committee composed of representatives of the local administration, the project management authorities and representatives of PAPs shall be established to ensure a mechanism and venue for redressing grievances and complaints related to any aspect of the compensation and resettlement procedures.

18. Monitoring and Evaluation

The process of inspections and monitoring shall involve reviewing and documenting implementation of all aspects of proposed activities based on a set of recommended baseline indicators and measuring overall satisfaction of PAPs at the various phases. Qualified and trained team of in-house and external experts will also do monitoring and evaluation.

Page | 17  

I. General Background and Introduction

1.1. General Background

With an estimated population of over 94 million (2012)P0F

1P, Ethiopia is the second populous

Sub Saharan African country next to Nigeria. The rate of population growth is estimated at 2.73% per year. About 17% of the population is urban and 83 % rural, electricity power coverage stands at 53% and power demand is projected to increase by an average rate of 32% per year for the coming five years. As of 2015, the main national energy supply sources are hydropower 88 %, diesel generators 11% and wind and geothermal 1% P1F

2P .

Considering the substantial resource potentials and in response to the growing demand for power, the government of Ethiopia is pursuing a strategy to increase power generation capacity from the present 2,000 MW to about 10,000MW through construction of various sizes of power dams in different parts of the country. To complement the hydropower generation, the strategy also encourages innovative energy solutions, such as wind harvesting, geothermal and solar energy technologies.

In realizing this strategic power development goal, the Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP) in the past 10 years has constructed and completed 6 medium and large-scale hydropower dams including the Ashgoda (Tigray) and Adama II (Oromia) wind farms. Additionally four major dams including the Great Renaissance Dam on River Nile (GERD) are currently under construction.

To improve existing systems stability and reliability of power services, the EEP has recently completed construction of Gibe III – Addis Ababa 400 kV transmission line for power generated from Gibe III hydro power plant and implementation of 230kV Alamata -Kombolcha II -Legetafo transmission line project with power generated from Tekezie plant has been completed with installation of 980 power transmission towers along the line route. The total length of Alamata-Kombolcha II – Legetafo transmission line is about 459km, and traverse through rural farms, chain rugged mountains and a number of urban areas, including Alamata, Kobo, Woldiya, Wuchalie, Dessie, Kombolcha, Kemissie, Shoa Robit, Debre Sina, Debre Birhan and Legetafo. Compensation payments for project affected people (PAPs) found within 40 meters wide Right of Way (ROW) along the line route has been made between 2008 and 2011 (or Ethiopian calendar year 2001 and 2005) in accordance with the Ethiopian law, Proclamation No. 455/2005. Taking cognizance of Ethiopia’s expanding towns, emerging buildings construction near high voltage overhead power transmission lines

                                                            1World Bank Data Sheet on Ethiopia, 2014 2 Gilgel Gibe I (2004), Gilgel Gibe II (2009), Tekezie (2009), Beles (2010), Gilgel Gibie III (2013) and Finacha Amerti (2013, and Gilgel Gibe IV, Gilgel Gibe V and GERD are under construction, Tigray Online (2014)

 

Page | 18  

and the potential for negative effects of electromagnetic fields (EMF) near the transmission lines on human health, the GoE has enacted a legal Directive on ROW regulation to provide an access corridor for maintenance of transmission line with consideration to safety clearances and EMF exposures limits. The Directive prescribes minimum safety requirements for Transmission routes. Accordingly, the 40 meters ROW for the project has been changed to 30 meters to meet and fulfill the directive set by the Ethiopian Electricity Agency (Directive # EEA/1/2005). The Alemata Kombolcha –Legetafo 230kv2nd circuit transmission line Row clearance is set to have transmission line ROW of 30 meters.

1.2. Introduction

The Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP) has completed a feasibility study to reinforce Alamata - Kombolcha II-Legetafo - Kaliti I Second Circuit 230kV transmission line with power generated from Tekeze hydro power plant. The proposed transmission line passes through rural and urban areas, including the surrounding areas of Alamata, Kobo, Woldiya, Dessie, Kombolcha, Kemissie, Shoa Robit, Debre Sina, Debre Birhan and Legetafo towns before it reaches to the main load center in Kaliti.

As part of the preparation to implement the stringing of power transmission cables along the routes and surrounding areas, the EEP has selected and commissioned Amha Aligaz Consultancy to undertake social impact assessment and to prepare Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) consistent with the laws of the Government of Ethiopia and the World Bank Involuntary Resettlement Policy Framework (OP4.12)

1.3. Objectives of the RAP

The first phase resettlement and installation of transmission towers was undertaken by the EEP with funding provided by GOE. During a site visit on July 2014, , the World Bank mission observed gaps in the implementation of the first phase resettlement activities and required ENREP to prepare an inclusive and comprehensive social impact assessment and prepare a RAP consistent with the resettlement policy objectives acceptable to the Bank prior to commencement of the stringing project activities.

Hence, this study is undertaken:

a) Identify and address observed gaps in the first resettlement activities

b) To identify PAPs who are PAPs who are currently occupying the ROW of the transmission line route

Page | 19  

c) To prepare Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) consistent with the legislative frameworks and compensation guidelines of the Government of Ethiopia, ENREP and the World Bank’s Involuntary Resettlement Policy (OP 4.12) objectivesP2F

3P.

Pursuant to these general objectives, the social impact assessment survey was conducted between January 21 and April 5, 2015 and covered all PAPs who are currently occupying the Right of Way (ROW) clearance of the transmission line and those PAPs who had been covered during the first phase implementation period (2008-2011) but remained occupying the right of way for reasons including but not limited to disagreement and dissatisfaction with the rate and amount of compensations and for absence of effective follow up and monitor systems encompassing all aspects and components of the resettlement and relocation process.

The primary objective of the RAP for the proposed second phase 230KV transmission line-stringing project is to identify and alleviate the various impacts of the project on the social-economic environment.

The specific objectives of the RAP are the following:

To prepare an assessment report covering the social situation, identify and register property that are found inside the ROW, conduct public consultation with people that occupy the ROW, meet and discuss with local administration and other relevant stakeholders.

To mitigate the adverse impacts associated with the implementation of the proposed 230KV transmission line development project.

To deliver entitlements to project affected people and support them in restoration of livelihoods in line with Resettlement Policy Framework and the World Bank operational policies and procedures (OP & BP 4.12).

To ensure that the standard of living of PAPs is improved or restored to pre-project level.

To ensure adequate mechanism for efficient implementation of resettlement, rehabilitation & enforcement of the RAP.

1.4. Scope of Work (SOW)

The scope of work as defined and described in the TOR is to obtain all relevant details of persons living in the ROW of the 230KV transmission line route relating to individuals, families, resource use and infrastructure through household baseline survey and Census and Land Inventory.

                                                            3The World Bank mission report of July 2014 required ENREP to prepare an inclusive and comprehensive social impact assessment and preparation of RAP consistent with the resettlement policy objectives acceptable to the Bank prior to commencement of the stringing project activities 

Page | 20  

The TOR also requires the survey and assessment to include details on both voluntary (if there is any) and involuntary resettlement that affect the productive assets and livelihood/source of income, families and the community structure. This process involved preparation of local/kebele profile, definitions of project-affected area and project affected structures, recommendation of resettlement action plan, identifying and establishing baseline monitoring indicators and institutional arrangement for effective implementation of the plan.

1.5. Approach and Methodology

The social impact assessment focused on two major distinctively different PAPs groups/categories:

i) Identifying and determining eligibility of PAPs who were not covered and compensated under the first phase of installation and implementation of the project due to various reasons.

ii) Reviewing compensation data and claims of PAPs who have disputed the compensations or who continued occupying the land they have been compensated for.

In the first case, the consultant applied standard tools and methodology to collect, analyze, measure and evaluate actual and perceived social impacts of the proposed transmission line stringing project operations on people who are currently occupying and operating livelihood activities within the project ROW clearance areas.

In the second case, the assessment focused in collecting data and information on compensation disbursements, grievance redressing systems and mechanisms, formal and informal filed complaints, reviewing and evaluating resettlement related documents and reports prepared by the EEP project management staff.

The preparation of the RAP, therefore, involved the following steps, procedures and activities:

a) Preliminary reconnaissance field trip through the entire transmission line route to familiarize the consultant team with the project area along the route and to lay the groundwork for subsequent visits.

b) Collection of qualitative and quantitative social-economic data through baseline household survey, Census & Land Inventory of properties

c) Identifying and documenting type, physical conditions, and ownership status of properties located within the ROW of the transmission line route.

Page | 21  

d) Formal and informal consultation with Project Affected People (PAPs) and other relevant stakeholders.

e) Collection and registration of attitudes, views and opinions expressed by project affected people and other stakeholders about the project.

f) Review of relevant legal and administrative frameworks that have due relevance with the proposed stringing construction and subsequent operation.

g) Impact assessment and categorization of project-affected people, establishing cut-off date for determining beneficiaries of the resettlement action plan.

h) Mitigation recommendations, preparation of compensation plans as per the policies and proclamations of the GOE’s, Resettlement Policy Framework of ENREP and the World Bank’s Involuntary Resettlement Policy objectives. .

i) Identification of parties responsible for implementing the proposed RAP, recommendation for mechanism to address complaints related to compensations and other issues pertaining to the project activities and establish baseline indicators for monitoring and evaluation of effective implementation of the plan.

1.6. Challenges and Limitations

a) The transmission line route altitude ranges from 800 meters in the low lands of Kalu Woreda to 3100 meters above sea level rugged mountains of Tarmaber (Debresina). Except for few plain lands in the outskirts of major urban centers, the transmission line passes through hilly terrains and depleted mountain forests with no vehicular access roads or foot tracks. Absence of temporary access roads to the transmission towers in most of the line route was physically challenging exercise.

b) In some parts of the project areas, such as Legetafo, Shoa Robit, and Senbete towns, limitation of organized documentation on population, landholdings and settlement/occupancy information presented challenges to identify and distinguish legal occupants from that of illegal/squatter settlements. In other areas, such as Wuchalie of North Wollo Zone, the consultant was unable to obtain legal documents to verify and counter check claims and disputes on compensation payments and issues reported by PAPs to the consultant during formal and informal consultation sessions.

c) Unwillingness of some survey respondents to disclose information on landholding status and approximate household income limited the study to quantify and determine accurately possible loss of incomes and other resources from livelihood activities.

Despite the many challenges, the survey and assessment covered all areas along the transmission line route and the Resettlement Action Plan presented in this report consists

Page | 22  

major findings obtained through baseline household survey and asset inventory, analysis of scope and magnitude of impacts, classifications and categorization of project affected people, public consultation, eligibility matrix for compensation, entitlements or other forms of assistance, implementation plan establishing responsibility for delivery of all forms of assistance, grievance redressing system and mechanism, list of baseline indicators for monitoring and evaluation and proposed timetable for implementation of the resettlement action plan.

II. Key Components of the Project, Topography and Population Profile

2.1. Key Components and Description of the Project

The major component of the project is stringing of a second circuit reinforcement 230KV transmission cable line from Alamata substation to the main Interconnected System (ICS) load center in Akaki. The total length of the reinforcement transmission line is 459 km, passing through10 woreda towns and several rural settlements located in Tigray, Amhara, Oromia regions and one Sub city in Addis Ababa Administration.

The stringing work will involve laying of power transmission cables on one shoulder of existing Alamata - Kombolcha – Legetafo - Kaliti I 230 kV Transmission line towers.

The total estimated number of existing erected transmission towers along the proposed routes is estimated at 980, with an average span of 350 meters between towers. The tower is made of steel structure having an average height between 14 and 33 meters, depending on the topography and soil formation. Tower installation materials and methods confirm to EEP standards.

The ROW width for the proposed 230 kV transmission line is 30 meters, which is 15 meters either side of the centerline. The ROW is required to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the power line.

The stringing project also includes installation of substation upgrading equipment at Kombolcha II and Legetafo substations.

Except in urban areas, access to transmission towers is limited to the use of existing feeder roads, footpaths and open farmlands.

For easy inspection and management purposes, the consultant organized the transmission line route study under four stretches covering towns and surrounding rural villages. The organization of the stretches is as follows:

Page | 23  

 

Fig 1: Type of transmission tower installed near Sendafa town

Stretch 1– Alamata to Woldia: 88.5 km stretch, primarily passing through plain agricultural land, crossing rivers and unconsolidated soil formations.

Stretch 2– Woldia to Kombolcha – 135 km, passes through hilly undulating terrain avoiding Dessie and Kombolcha towns to reach Kombolcha II Substation.

Stretch 3 – Kombolcha to Debre Berhan – 143.4 km, passing through hilly topography and undulating terrain via Kemissie, avoiding Shoa Robit and Debre Berhan towns.

Stretch 4 - Debre Berhan to Legetafo: 117 km stretch, passing through flat agricultural land and small hilly plateaus, parallel to the major interstate highway avoiding urban settlements of Sendafa town.

Table 1: Transmission Line Stretch

Stretch Line Route KM

Stretch 1 Alamata to Woldia 88.5

Stretch 2 Woldia to Kombolcha II 135.4

Stretch 3 Kombolcha to Debre Berhan 143.4

Stretch 4 Debre Berhan to Legetafo 117

Page | 24  

2.2. Project Funding

The World Bank is the principal funding institution for stringing of the Second Circuit of 230 kV Alamata-Kombolcha II –Legetafo Transmission Line project.

2.3. Topography of the Line Route

The proposed 458 km long 230 kV power transmission reinforcement line originates from Alamata substation passing through 3 regional states, namely Tigray, Amhara and Oromia, and through one woreda under the City Administration of Addis Ababa to reach to the final load center in Kalti.

Approximately, a total of 891 transmission towers, made of steel structure with four stands, are mounted parallel to the existing 132kV transmission line, crisscrossing the main interstate highway that runs north of Addis Ababa via Dessie to Mekelle at several points. The traffic density is observed to be high due to intensive and frequent movement of long distance public transport buses, medium and short distance mini bus transport services and heavy trucks and freight transport vehicles.

 

 

Figure 2: Partial Topographic View of the Line Route

The transmission line passes through plain agricultural lands, hilly terrains and unconsolidated soil formations and depleted mountain forests while deliberately avoiding crossing most towns and concentrated rural settlements located along the line route. The altitude of the line route area ranges from 800 meters above sea level in the low lands of Kalu woreda to 3100 meters above sea level of rugged mountains of Tarmaber (Debresina). Several rivers cross the area fed by the highland watershed along with numerous intermittent streams. Natural vegetation found along the line route includes bush scrub, acacia species and kurkura (wild nut) trees.

Page | 25  

The following section of the report is intended to provide background information on the general population, livelihood activities and other relevant information on local inhabitants situated along the transmission line route. Except for tower erection footprint purpose, which is already in place, no farm land is and will be affected and no single household will have a problem to cultivate or experience loss of income as a result of the stringing phase of the projectP3F

4P. Additionally, through visual inspections, consultations with local authorities

and informant interviews, the consultant learned that no cultural, religious or historical heritage sites exist in the project line route or in close proximity to the three substations located in Alamata, Kombolcha and Legetafo locations.

2.4. Population and Livelihood Profile

Based on CSA’s 2014 projection, the combined total inhabitants along the transmission line route are estimated 8,227,121, of which about 48 % male and 52 % female. The main ethnic groups are Amhara, Tigray and Oromo. Smallholding agricultural cultivation and livestock development dominate economic activities in the rural areas and service and petty trading are the two major employment and income generating activities in urban centers. The major crops cultivated include, maize, sorghum, barley, teff, beans and peas. The landscape and livelihood activities in urban peripheries are gradually changing due to expansion of urban boundaries for settlement purposes.

2.4.1. Alamata Woreda 4F

5

Alamata is one of the woredas in the Tigray region sharing a border with north Wollo to the south, Afar region to the East, Enderta to the North, and Endemahoni and Ofla to the west. Based on the 2014 projection, the woreda has a total population of 94,004, of which 46,438 men and 47,566 female with a total of 20,532 households. About 80.27% of the population said to be Orthodox Christian and 19.68% Muslim. With an area of 1,952.14 square kilometers, Alamata has a population density of 43.75, persons per square kilometer. It is situated in the kolla agro-ecological zone, dominated by plains, undulating mountains and rugged terrain in the South East toward Hintalo Wejirat. The vegetation is mainly bush scrub and cactus with scattered acacia trees. The main crops cultivated are sorghum, teff and maize. Sorghum is the staple food, and teff is produced for both food and cash income. The woreda is considered to be food sufficient and agriculture related trading activities are the major economic activities generating income and employment for both the                                                             4 For details, please refer the impact assessment section of the report.  

5 Woreda is an Amharic word equivalent to the English word of District. It is established as a territorial division for governmental administrative and electoral purposes, having basic administrative units, such as judiciary, health and education offices, police, tax revenue collection, business licensing and regulations, land management, municipal services and other governmental functions. It is the highest level administrative structure under the Zone, also responsible for managing and supervising local level or Kebele administrations.

Page | 26  

town and rural population. Rural landholding ranges from less than half hectare for the very poor to 3 hectares for the better off. Livestock from Alamata is sold to Mehoni, and is shipped through Maichew for market in Mekelle and to Woldiya destined for Dessie market (Amhara region). One of EEP's power transmission substations, Alamata Substation, is located about 3 km south of Alamata town.

2.4.2. North Wollo Zone

North Wollo is one of the 10 Zones of the Amhara Region with an area of 12, 172.50 square km. South Wollo on the south, North Gondar borders it on the west, and Wag Hemra on the north, and Tigray Region on the northeast and Afar region on the east. The zone covers highlands of Delanta, Dawnt, Wadla and parts of Guba Lafto, Gidan and Meket with a total estimated population of 2,131,857, of whom 1,075,206 are men and 1,056,651women (2014 projection). About 90 % of the population is urban and 10 % rural inhabitants and the largest ethnic group is Amhara (about 99.61%). Around 83.36% of the population practice Orthodox Christian and 17.64% believed to be Muslim faith followers. The dominant cultivated crops are barley and wheat. Lentils and flax are also cultivated in favorable localities of the lower dega area. Wealth in this livelihood zone is determined by the ownership of livestock in general and ownership of oxen in particular. There is no big difference in the ownership of land between different wealth groups. Average landholding ranges from a little less than 1 hectare for very poor to a hectare and more for middle and better off. The area is generally classified as one of food insecure zones of the region, with a long history of food aid distributions.

Located at a distance of about 521 km from Addis Ababa, Woldia is the Capital of North Wollo Zone. It has a total population of 46,139, of which 23,000 men and 23,139 female, The town serves as center of commerce and transportation for the Semien Wollo Zone and a key transport hub for the surrounding areas. Service sector economic activities and petty trading of agricultural crops dominate the urban economy and employment.

Kobo is the other major woreda town in the zone bordered on the south by the Logia River, which separates it from Habru and Guba Lafto, on the west by Gidan, on the north by Tigray Region and on the east by the Afar region. It has an estimated population of 221,958, of which 36,147 resides in the urban center. From the urban population, 18,552 are male and 17,595 female inhabitants. The rural livelihood activities are based on cereal cultivation, livestock rearing with some production of fruits and vegetables. The fertility of the sandy and loam soils is enhanced by the alluvial soils washed down by flood waters from the surrounding highlands and good rainfall contribute to make this zone generally food secure. Rural landholding ranges from less than a hectare for the very poor to a little more than a hectare (4 to 5 timads) for the better off. Petty trading of agricultural products

Page | 27  

dominates the urban economic and employment activities. The main road that runs from Mekelle to Dessie to Addis Ababa enhances market access.

2.4.3. South Wollo Zone

The South Wollo part of Amhara region is composed of Argoba, Kalu and Werebabu woredas bordering Artuma Fursi, Dewa Chefa, Jille Timuga, Bati and Dewa Harewa woredas of Oromia Special Zone of Amhara region. Dessie Zuria Woreda is one of the major woredas of the zone border by Albuko and Wore Ilu on the south, Legambo on the southwest, Tenta on the northwest, Kutaber on the north, Kalu woreda on the east and Tehuledere on the northeast.

Dessie town, located 400 km north of Addis Ababa, is the capital of Dessie Zuria and South Wollo Zone. The largest ethnic group is Amhara and majority of inhabitants believed to practice Muslim religion. The altitude of the Woreda ranges from 1,800 to 3,500 m.a.s.l and characterized by a rugged and undulating topography (steep slopes, hills, and plains). Cultivated food crops include barely, wheat, and maize. Approximately two third of the area is sown for food crops. This pattern is similar across all-weather groups and agro ecological zones. Livestock has a very important role in the livelihoods of the area as a source of manure for firewood especially in higher highlands and source of income for highlands and midlands. Generally the Woreda is characterized as one of food insecure area of the county with little or no irrigation practices and few cash crops. Dessie is one of the major commercial towns along the main highway linking Addis Ababa and Mekelle. It is also linked to Afar region through Kombolcha.

The other main woreda in the Zone is Kalu, also known as Harbu. The woreda has a total population of 186,181, of whom 94,187 are men and 91,994 women based on the 2007 census. About 10% of the population is urban and majority of the inhabitants practice Muslim religion. The altitude of the woreda ranges from 800 meters in the lowlands to 1750 meters at foot of the mountain north of Kombolcha. It has a predominantly kola agro-ecology, consisting mainly of plains covered in rich loam and black alluvial soil that is eroded from the Amhara highlands and the eastern escarpments and deposited in the zone. Major cultivated staple crops are sorghum, maize, and teff complemented by an assortment of cash crops that include masho (mung bean), tobacco, fruits and vegetables. The main determinant of wealth in the area is land and oxen ownership. The very poor, poor, middle and better-off households own 0.25 hectare to half hectare, from half hectare to one hectare and one to one and half hectare each respectively.

Kombolcha town, located some 367 km north of Addis Ababa is the major industrial zone of the Amhara region and serves as dry port for the northern part of the country. The second power transmission substation is also located in the town. Based on the 2007 national census survey, the town has a population of 85,367 people, 41,968 men and 43,399

Page | 28  

female. The major industries include Kombolcha textile, BGI brewery, metal and leather processing plants. Industrial College of Wollo University is also located in the town. Due to the presence of heavy and small-scale factories and dry port activities, the town attracts people from the surrounding urban and rural areas seeking employment opportunities. One of EEP's power transmission substations, Kombolcha II Substation, is located about 5 km south of the center city at a locality called Cheffe Mesendi.

2.4.4. Oromia Special Zone of Amhara Region

Kemissie is the Oromia zone of Amhara region. The zone was established as having two town administrations and five rural Woredas, namely Artuma Fursi, Dewa Chefa, Jille Timuga, Bati and Dewa Harewa. The Zone borders Semien Shoa on the southwest, South Wollo on the northwest and Afar region on the east. The capital is Kemissie town. Based on the 2007 Census survey, the Zone has a total population of 457,278, of which 227,328 men and 229,950 women. The majority of the inhabitants are Muslim (76.29%) and the remaining 21.24% belong to the Orthodox Christian faith. The soil is sandy, sandy clay and sandy loam with moderate fertility. The main cereals grown are sorghum, teff and maize, and vetch is the main pulse. Cattle, goats and sheep are the major livestock in order of importance, but there are also a few camels kept by wealthier people for burden. The average land holding ranges between 0.25 hectare for the very poor to a little less than two hectares to the middle and better-off households. Sorghum, maize and teff are the major crops traded out of the zone, moving from local markets into Afar, and to the markets of Dessie, Kombolcha. Cattle and goats mainly go via main-road collection markets to be finally sold Addis Ababa, while sheep from Bati and Kemissie markets are traded to Dessie and Kombolcha.

2.4.5. North Shoa Zone

The zone is comprised of Antsokiya, Eferatana Gidem, Gishe Rabel, Menze Lalo Meder, Menze Mama Midir, Gera Midir, Keya Gabriel, Kewet, Moja, and Taremaber woredas with a combined total population of 1,733,616, of whom 867,917 are men and 865,699 women; with an area of 15,936.13 square kilometers. While 214,227 or 11.66% are urban inhabitants, a further 112 or 0.01% are pastorals. The three largest ethnic groups reported are Amhara (95.73%), the Oromo (2.14%) and the Argoba (1.71%). The main towns in the zone are Mehal Meda and Debre Sina, located 90km north of Debre Birhan, in which the latter is the capital of the zone. The highway from Addis Ababa to Dessie crosses part of the zone. The topography is dominated by chain of hills and rouged mountains with some low lands. The altitude ranges from 1500 to 3100 meters above sea level and about 45.65 % of the Zone is rugged type mountain. The major rivers are Gengero, Gemecha and Robe. Because of the topography and rugged nature of the terrain, the area is prone to landslide and flooding affecting the farmlands and livelihood of the farming population. The major crops grown in the area are barley, field beans and wheat. Flax and lentils are also grown

Page | 29  

for sale. Oxen are the traction power, and the household members only do land preparation, sowing, weeding and harvesting. The average landholding ranges between 0.50 hectare for the very poor to 2.25 hectare for the middle and better off households. The main livestock are sheep, whilst households also own cattle and equines. Sheep are especially sold and occasionally slaughtered during the main holidays, while equines are used as pack animals. The dominant perennial vegetation planted is eucalyptus tree, but there are patches of indigenous trees and bushes. The eucalyptus tree is used for construction and firewood sales. Firewood and charcoal sales and wool sales are major sources of cash income for households. Shoa Robit, Antsokiya, Debre Birhan are places where people migrate to get seasonal employment on weeding and harvesting. Main agricultural commodities produced are teff, pulses and wheat and are traded in the local rural markets with Debre Berhan as the final collecting market for the major trade down to Addis Ababa. Similarly sheep and cattle are sold from main markets of Ankober, Chacha, Enewari and Deneba directly to Addis Ababa.

Debre Berhan town, located about 120 km north of Addis Ababa, is one of the city/woreda town located in the Semien Shoa Zone of the Amhara region. Based on the 2007 Census survey, the town has a total population of 65,231, of which 31,668 men and 33,563 female. The town serves as an important economic and political center for the surrounding rural communities before and after the restructuring of the administrative zones in 1992. The Debre Berhan blanket factory and water bottling are major industrial level employers for the urban residents. Dashen and Habesha breweries are currently under construction with a plan to commence production in a short time. Service sector economic activities and whole sale/ retail agricultural commodities trading are the main livelihood activities. In the highland communities, crop production with animal husbandry, is the common practice. The main crops grown include barley, various types of wheat, horse beans, peas, lentils and linseed. The main livestock are cattle, sheep and goats, and draught animals such as donkeys, horses and mules.

2.4.6. Legetafo-Legedadi Woreda (Finfine Zuria Special Zone of Oromia)

 

Legetafo is located in Bereh district of Oromia National regional State, along the road to Dessie at a distance of 21km north of Addis Ababa. Before it was established as municipal town in 2006, Legetafo was a rural village under rural peasant kebele administration. Based on the 2007 Census, the town has a population of 9,840 Oromo ethnic inhabitants. Smallholding agricultural crop production and livestock is the major economic activity of the rural families. In recent years, the town is experiencing rapid growth in new housing development and construction of industrial warehousing facilities north of Addis Ababa.

Page | 30  

 

Figure 3: Transmission Line Route (Route highlighted by the Consultant on Google Earth Map)

III. Review of Legislation and Policy Frameworks Relevant to the RAP

Development projects in Ethiopia are required to meet and fulfill relevant legal provisions and policy frameworks that are intended to protect the wellbeing of the society in general and affected communities in particular. The national legislations and policy frameworks as well as the World Bank guidelines relevant to involuntary resettlement and compensation procedures are reviewed here and presented as follows.

3.1. The Constitution of Ethiopia

Article 40(2), 40(4), 40(5) and 40(8) are the major provisions in the constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia that are intended to defend and protect the Ethiopian citizens ‘rights to private property and set conditions for expropriation of such property for state or public interest.

Article 40(8) of the constitution states that “without prejudice to the right to private property, the government may expropriate private lands for public purpose” with prior payment of adequate compensation.

Page | 31  

Article 44(2) stipulates that all people who have been displaced or whose livelihoods have been adversely affected as a result of the state programs shall have the right to receive adequate monetary or other alternative compensation, including transfer with assistance to another locality.

3.2. Environmental Policy of Ethiopia

The overall goal of the Environmental Policy of Ethiopia is to improve and enhance the health and quality of life of all Ethiopians and promote understanding of the essential linkage between environment and development. In addition to its guiding principles, the policy addresses sartorial and cross-sectorial environmental issues. Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) policies are included in the cross sectorial environmental policies. The ESIA policy emphasizes the early recognition of environmental issues in project planning at all levels of administration. The principal features of the Environmental Policy in this area are:

Providing protection of human and natural environments. Provision of an early consideration of environmental impacts in projects and

program design. Recognition of public consultation. Inclusion of mitigation plans and contingency plans. Provision of monitoring and auditing Establishment of legally binding requirements Institutionalization of policy implementation

The policy establishes the Federal Environmental Ministry of Environment & Forestry (formerly known as Environmental Protection Authority) to harmonize sectorial development plans and implement environmental management programs for the country.

3.3. The Land Tenure Policy

The Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (FDRE) states that the right to ownership of rural and urban land, as well as all natural resources, is exclusively vested in the State and People of Ethiopia.

Article 40 of the Constitution asserts that land is a common property of the Nations, Nationalities and the People of Ethiopia, and shall not be subjected to sale or to other means of transfer.

Also article 4(5) of the Proclamation 94/1994 deals with the provision of land for conservation, development and utilization of state forests or protected areas. However, this can be effective only after the consultation and consent of the peasantry and subject to the assurance of their benefits.

Page | 32  

In general, all legal provisions cited above, make rural and urban lands the property of the People and Government of Ethiopia, and buying and selling of land is prohibited but usufruct rights only over land. This gives the user of the land the right to use and the right to benefit from the fruits of her/his labor which may be crops or tress , etc found on the land or any permanent works such as buildings.

Even though the state controls landownership, the customary law in Ethiopia guarantees rural peasants with lifetime “holding” right excluding sale and mortgage of the land. Moreover, it also provides right for landowners to be compensated fully and satisfactorily if his/her land is expropriated by the state.

The Land Policy of Ethiopia strongly supports that all development plans shall include attractive and sustainable resettlement strategies to the people who are going to be displaced as a result of the project, and affected households have to be fully convinced, compensated and participate in all phases of the project development and implementation phases.

3.4. The National Policy of Women

The National Policy of Women was introduced in March 1993. The policy requires and emphasizes that government policy, laws, regulations, plans, programs and projects should

Ensure participation of women in the formulation of government policies, laws, regulations, programs and projects that directly or indirectly benefit and concerns women

Support and encourage participation and involvement of women in implementation and decision making processes

Guarantee equal access of men and women to the country’s resources

3.5. Proclamation No. 455/2005

The proclamation establishes the legal principles and framework for expropriation of landholdings for public purposes and payment of compensations. The basis and amount of compensation is clearly explained in the following articles:

Article 7(1), which states “land holder whose holding has been expropriated shall be entitled to payment of compensation for his/her property situated on the land and for permanent improvements he made”.

Article 7(2) states that “the amount of compensation for property situated on the expropriated land shall be determined on the basis of replacement cost of the property”.

Article 8(1) requires a displaced land holder whose land holding has been permanently expropriated shall be provided displacement compensation, which

Page | 33  

shall be equivalent to ten times the average annual income he/she has been generating for the five years preceding the expropriations of the land.

It also entitles all PAPs and organizations, whether public or private, with impacted properties, crops or sources of income shall be compensated or rehabilitated according to the type and amount of incurred losses. The cutoff date for determination of eligibility for compensation shall be set once all detailed measurements have been completed. Compensation shall not be paid for any structures erected or crops and trees planted purely for the purpose of gaining additional compensation. Cultivating land, constructing settlement in project affected areas after the cut-off date shall and will not be eligible for compensation or for subsidies.

3.6. Council of Minister Regulation No. 135/2007

The Council of Ministers regulation is issued for the purpose of not only paying compensation but also to assist displaced persons to restore their livelihood. The regulation provides the procedures for application of proclamation No 455/2005. The regulation provides for compensation payment for property situated on expropriated land for public benefit. The regulation is titled “payment of compensation for property situated on land holdings expropriated for public purposes”.

The type of properties and assets identified to be eligible for payments of compensation include buildings, fences, crops, perennial crops, trees, protected grass, improvement made on rural land; relocated property, mining license and burial grounds.

The regulation also provides guideline and formula for calculating the amount of compensation payable for lost assets due to development project. For example, Part Two- Article 3 (1 to 4) of the regulation states compensation for buildings shall be determined on the basis of the current cost per square meter or unit for constructing a comparable building including patios, septic tanks, and other attached service facilities, estimated cost for demolishing, lifting, reconstructing, installing and connecting utility lines of the building. The owner of a building shall have the right to claim compensation for the entire building by surrounding the total land in his possession where part of the building is subject to be removed.

Furthermore, compensation for fences is, suggested to be determined through calculating the current cost per square meter or the unit cost required for constructing a similar fence, for trees shall be determined on the basis of the level of growth of the trees and the current local price per square meter or per unit and the amount of compensation for a relocated property to be determined by computing the estimated costs of labor, material and transport to be incurred at market value for removing, transferring and installing the property.

Page | 34  

The regulation prohibits payment of compensations for any construction or improvement of a building, any crops sown, perennial crops planted or any permanent improvement on land, where such activity is done after the owner of the land is served with the expropriation order.

3.7. Ethiopian Electricity Agency-Directive # EEA/1/2005

The Ethiopia Electricity Agency is responsible for setting standards and specifications for electricity transmission line projects and related activities. Accordingly, the Agency has issued a directive which determines the ROW set back and the restriction of growing of trees exceeding 7meter in the transmission lines. The Alemata Kombolcha –Legetafo 230kv2nd circuit transmission line Row clearance is set according to the Directive #EEA/1/2005 Article 7, sub article 7.14 which states that transmission lines with voltage not exceeding 230kv shall have transmission line ROW of 30 meters. The Directive also allows cultivation of crops not exceeding 7meters in height beneath the overhead electricity transmission line.  

T3.8. Resettlement Policy Framework of the EEP (former EEPCo)

In December 2011, the then Ethiopian Electric Power Corporation (EEPCo) prepared and endorsed a Resettlement Policy Framework, for implementing the Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project (ENREP). The objective of the Resettlement/Rehabilitation Policy Framework (RPF) is to clarify resettlement principles, organizational arrangements and criteria to be applied in the implementation of the Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion project. The RPF is stated to be valid for upgrading of the power transmission system executed by EEP, irrespective of the source of funding, be it from the FDRE or international donors.

According to the ENREP RPF, displaced persons may be classified in one of the following three groups:

a. Those who have formal legal rights to land (including customary and traditional rights recognized under the laws of the country);

b. Those who do not have formal legal rights to land at the time the census begins but have a claim to such land or assets, provided that such claims are recognized under the laws of the country or become recognized through a process identified in the resettlement plan (see Annex A, Para. 7 (f); and 20).

c. Those who have no recognizable legal right or claim to the land they are occupying.

Page | 35  

Overall, the EEP resettlement policy framework is intended to address social impacts of projects undertaken by the agency on the lives of people residing in project areas through advance planning and implantation of mitigation measures to minimize adverse effects resulting from project activities and subsequent operations. The specific objectives of the RPF are focused on:

a) PAPs are compensated for loss of assets and crops,

b) When applicable, PAPs are assisted in resettlement or relocation,

c) PAPs income and livelihood capacity is restored after resettlement and

d) PAPs livelihood condition is improved in relation to prior to resettlement or relocation.

The ENREP RPF document also recognizes and affirms that in case of conflicts between the national law and Bank Policy, the Bank policy will prevail as the Resettlement /Rehabilitation Framework as part of an international credit agreement between the Government of Ethiopia and the Bank.

3.9. The World Bank Policy for Involuntary Resettlement

The key objective of the World Bank’s Operational policy 4.12 is to “ensure that displaced persons are assisted in their efforts to improve their livelihoods and standards of living or at least to restore them, in real terms, to pre-displacement levels or to levels prevailing prior to the beginning of project implementation, whichever is higher”. The Bank requires mitigation recommendations and resettlement action plan to ensure displaced persons are:

Informed about their options and rights pertaining to resettlement; Consulted upon, offered choices among, and provided with technically and

economically feasible resettlement alternatives; Offered prompt and effective compensation at full replacement cost for losses of

assets and moving allowances; cash compensation level should be sufficient to replace the lost land and assets at full replacement cost in the local markets;

Provided equivalent productive assets for the loss of residential houses, agricultural land etc.;

Supported during the transition period (between displacement and livelihood restoration) with development assistance (credit facilities; training and job opportunities);

The policy objectives also require

Page | 36  

Eligibility for compensations and other benefits should include all PAPs who have formal legal rights to land (include customary and traditional land rights recognized under the law), who do not have formal legal rights to land at the time of census but have a claim to such land or assets and those who have no recognizable legal right to the land they are occupying;

Preference will be given to land based resettlement strategies for displaced persons whose livelihoods are land based and depreciation and salvage values will not be deducted from the compensation value;

Particular attention will be paid to the needs of displaced vulnerable groups, especially those below the poverty line, landless, elderly, women, children and ethnic minorities

The displaced persons and their communities will be provided timely and relevant information, consulted on resettlement options, and offered opportunities to participate in planning, implementing, and monitoring resettlement.

Appropriate and accessible grievance mechanisms will be established, and a grievance redress mechanism will be made functional to resolve all complaints and grievances of PAPs.

3.9. Comparisons of the National Polices and the World Bank OP 4.12

There are a number of differences and gaps between the national policies and legislation and the World Bank Policy OP 4.12. These gaps relate to the general principles for resettlement, eligibility criteria, the notification period for expropriation and resettlement, and the procedures required throughout the resettlement process.

Table 2: Summary of Comparison of the Ethiopian Legislation and World Bank’s Operational Policy, and Recommendations to Address Gaps.

Theme WB OP/BP4.12 Ethiopian Law Comparison Measures

to address gap

Policy Objectives

OP4.12 requires that involuntary resettlement should be avoided wherever possible or minimized by exploring alternatives.

Resettlement program should be sustainable, include

The Constitution of Ethiopia and Proclamation No 455/2005 give power to Wereda or urban administrations to expropriate rural or urban landholdings for public purpose where it believes that it should be used for a

Avoidance or minimization of involuntary resettlement is not specified in the Ethiopian legislation.

Proclamation No 455/2005 allows for a complaints and grievance

World Bank OP 4.12 overall objectives shall be applied to avoid or minimize involuntary resettlement and to ensure consultation throughout the process.

Page | 37  

Theme WB OP/BP4.12 Ethiopian Law Comparison Measures

to address gap

meaningful consultation with affected parties and provide benefits to affected parties

Displaced persons should be assisted in improving livelihoods etc. or at least restoring them to previous levels

better development

Article 7(5) states that the cost of removal, transportation and erection shall be paid as compensation for a property targeted for the project.

process.

Proclamation No 455/2005 allows for some form of support to the displaced persons, but does not explicitly specify consultation with affected persons through the process.

Notification period /timing of displacement

Article 10 of OP4.12 requires that the resettlement activities associated with implementation of the development project to ensure displacement or restriction of access does not occur before necessary measures for resettlement are in place. In particular, taking of land and related assets may take place only after compensation has been paid and where applicable, resettlement sites and moving allowances have been provided to displaced persons.

Article 4 of Proclamation No 455/2005 requires notification in writing, with details of timing and compensation, which cannot be less than 90 days from notification. It requires that land should be handed over within 90 days of payment of compensation payments. If there is no crop or other property on the land, it must be handed over within 30 days of notice of expropriation. It further gives power to seize the land through police force should the landholder be unwilling to hand over the land

There is a gap in Proclamation No 455/2005 to allow land to be expropriated before necessary measures for resettlement take place, particularly before the displaced person has been paid. This can have serious consequences for those affected, as they may be displaced without shelter or any means of livelihood.

OP4.12 will be applied to ensure displaced person are compensatedand/or resettlement site and moving allowance provided and supported prior to handover of land to the development.

Eligibility for Compensation

OP4.12 gives eligibility to all PAPs whether they have formal legal rights or do not have formal legal rights to land, but have a claim to such land and those who do not have recognizable legal

Proclamation No 455/2005, Article 7(1) allows’ landholders’ to be eligible for compensation if they have lawful possession over the land to be expropriated and owns property situated

While Ethiopian law only grants compensation to those with lawful possession of the land, OP4.12 entitles compensation for assets to all affected individuals

ENREP RPF document acknowledges in an event where there is a conflict between the national law and WB OP/BP4.12 guidelines, the WB policy prevails as resettlement

Page | 38  

Theme WB OP/BP4.12 Ethiopian Law Comparison Measures

to address gap

right or claim to the land.

thereon” regardless of landholding rights to land titles (including squatter settlements)

framework and compensation for assets will be provided to all PAPs (including those without legal title).

Compensation

World Bank OP4.12 Article 6(a) requires that displaced persons be provided with prompt and effective compensation at full replacement cost for losses of assets attributable directly to the project. If physical relocation is an impact, displaced persons must be provided with assistance during relocation and residential housing, housing sites and /or agricultural sites to at least equivalent standards as the previous site. Replacement cost does not take depreciation into account. In term of valuing assets. If the residual of the asset being taken is not economically viable,

Article 7 of Proclamation No. 455/2005 entitles the landholder to compensation for the property on the land on the basis of replacement cost; and permanent improvements to the land, equal to the value of capital and labor expended.

Where property is on urban land, compensation may not be less than constructing a single room low cost house as per the region in which it is located. It also requires that the cost of removal, transportation and erection will be paid as compensation for a relocated property continuing its service as before. Valuation formula are provided in Regulation No. 135/2007

The World Bank requirement for compensation and valuation of assets is that compensation and relocation must result in the affected person securing property and a livelihood to at least equivalent standards as before. This is not clearly stated in local Proclamations. It is expected that the regulations and directives will provide more clarity and clearer guidance in this regard.

The World Bank requirements for compensation must be followed, as per OP4.12 footnote 1, which states, “Where domestic law does not meet the standard of compensation at full replacement cost, compensation under domestic law is supplemented by additional measures necessary to meet the replacement cost standard”

Responsibilities of the project proponent

According to OP4.12, Article 14 and 18, the borrower is responsible for conducting a census and preparing, implementing, and

Article 5 of Proclamation No 455/2005 sets out the responsibilities of the implementing agency, requiring them to gather data on the land

The process required for the project proponent / implementing agency lacks descriptive processes in local

As per the World Bank requirements, project processes included screening, a census, and the development of a plan, management

Page | 39  

Theme WB OP/BP4.12 Ethiopian Law Comparison Measures

to address gap

monitoring the appropriate resettlement instrument. Article 24 states that the borrower is also responsible for adequate monitoring and evaluation of the activities set forth in the resettlement instrument. In addition, upon completion of the project, the borrower must undertake an assessment to determine whether the objectives of the resettlement instrument have been achieved. This must all be done according to the requirements of OP4.12. Article 19 requires that the borrower inform potentially displaced persons at an early stage about the resettlement aspects of the project and takes their views into account in project design.

needed and works, and to send this to the appropriate officials for permission. It also requires them to pay compensation to affected landholders

legislation. of compensation payments and monitoring and evaluation of success. It must also include proper consultation with the affected parties throughout the process.

 

 

IV. Household Baseline Survey, Asset Inventory and Assessment and Review of First Phase Compensation Implementation

The purpose of the baseline household survey was to establish a social inventory of local inhabitants occupying and operating livelihood activities on the ROW of clearance of the transmission line route through collection of vital and relevant information on size, age, sex,

Page | 40  

religious affiliation, ethnicity and income distribution of individual PAPs and households that are likely to be affected by the project activities.

While the first round baseline census survey was carried out between 16/02/2015 and 2/03/2015 covering 37 kebeles, the second round survey was conducted between 02/04/2015 and 05/04/2015 focusing on highly concentrated settlement areas of Shoa Robit and Senbete towns where large number of households/PAPs believed to have occupied the transmission line ROW. The survey collected information on possession of immovable assets, such as houses, land, perennial plants, landholding status, tenure and duration of residence, approximate income from employment, farming or other activities.

4.1 Baseline Household Survey (Socioeconomic) Findings

The household baseline survey targeted a total of 208 households comprising 1202 individual PAPs with an average family size of 5.78 persons residing in 37 kebeles within the project Right of Way clearance areas.

Of the total surveyed PAPs, 53% are women and 47% men, elderly persons over the age of 60 constitute 2 % and children account for 47 % of households. Average household age is about 22.2 year and 62.4% of school age children attend school in their respective locality. About 62 % belong to the Orthodox Christian religion and 32 % Muslim.

About 47% of the surveyed households generate income from production and marketing of fruits and vegetables, 20% from small scale business activities, 13% from private sector employment, 3.5% from government employment and 7% engaged in a variety of income generating public activities including public transport services (horse cart and taxi (Bajaj) operators), construction /carpentry and employment with faith based services. The average monthly income ranges between Birr 175.00 and Birr 4000.00, very few households reported average monthly income in excess of Birr 10,000.00 from production and marketing of fruit and vegetable products (Refer Annex 1 for baseline survey findings).

4.2. Summary of Household (PAPs) Assets Inventory

The census and asset inventory focused on properties situated within and inside the project 30meter ROW clearance areas. The survey identified 208 households owning residential houses, household service facilities, fences, trees, such as acacia and eucalyptus, fruit plants, such as papaya, hops, moringa, hot pepper, banana and mango. About 51.2 % of the surveyed households (PAPs) posse legal title for the land they own and 48.8% claimed to have settled informally without legally issued land title or permits to occupy vacant land along the transmission line route.

Page | 41  

Table 3: Summary of Inventoried Household (PAPs) Assets

No Type of Asset Description of Asset # of Properties

1 Residential house

Made of wood structure, mud or cement mortar plastering, corrugated metal sheet roof

87

2 Service room Made of wood structure, mortar plastering and corrugated sheet metal roof

12

3 Residential house

Made of wood and mud structure with straw, canvas or plastic roofing

37

4 Patio/Veranda Corrugated sheet metal roof, concrete floor and handrail

6

5 Kitchen Made of wood structure and corrugated sheet metal, straw, plastic or canvas roofing,

31

6 Other structures

Shower rooms, septic tank, poultry cage and storage rooms

7

7 Fence Made of corrugated sheet metal and wood shrubs

85

8 Perennial plant Acacia, eucalyptus tree, fruit plants (mango, papaya, banana)

823

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 42  

The size of each property and useful assets were physically investigated and measured by a qualified professional with the presence of head of households or adult member of the family. About 61 % of inventoried houses and attached household facilities are permanent structures, occupying an average built up area of 26.9 m2, made of wood frame, corrugated sheet metal roof, plastered with mud or cement mortar and 27 % are made of lower quality construction materials, such as straw, thatches, plastic rugs and canvas roofing. Of the total households, about 60 % either own houses, fences or plants only and about 40% own both houses and permanent plants. Many of the surveyed houses are located in the outskirts of the towns as an extension of urban settlements, mainly serving for residential purposes. The highest number of informal settlement is recorded in Shoa Robit town of Semen Shoa Zone (94 households in Kebele 01 and kebele 04) followed by Legetafo – Legedadi town of Finfine Special Zone of Oromia State (8) and Debresina Town of North Shoa Zone (2).

 

Fig 4: Informal settlements within the ROW of the transmission tower in Shoa Robit town

Through visual inspection of the line route and informant interviews, the consultant confirmed that the stringing project activity and its subsequent operation would not permanently affect any of the farmlands or crops as the EEA directive permits cultivation of crops up to 7 meters height beneath the transmission line right of way clearance. In case of temporary impacts and disturbances, the project shall negotiate in advance and provide adequate compensations for affected parties. Furthermore, no social and cultural heritage sites observed in close proximity to the project transmission line route.

4.3. Vulnerability Assessment

The vulnerability assessment under this study is focused and analyzed within the context of the following parameters:

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 43  

a) Households with elderly persons, over the age of 60 year, as primary income earner of the family,

b) Households with women as head of households,

c) Households with mentally or physically challenged family members and

d) Households with income levels less than the subsistence level.

When measured against the above parameters, women headed household account 35.2 % of surveyed families and elderly household members represent about 2 % of the total family members and only two households headed by an elderly person over the age of 60 years reported to have visual impairment and physical challenges that require special assistance during relocation and restoration of livelihood activities.

4.4. Review of the First Round Compensation Implementation (2008 - 2011)

Based on reviewed document reports, a total of 3559 households along the project line route have been paid out compensations for targeted houses, perennial plants and crops situated within the ROW of the proposed transmission line route. The record also shows a total amount of ETB 38,597,545.29 made by EEP to PAPs between 2008 and 2011. The smallest compensation disbursement amount ETB 8, 775 made in Kimbibit woreda of North Shoa Zone of Amhara region and the highest disbursement paid out in Tehuledere Woreda of South Wollo Zone of Amhara Region with the amount of ETB 5, 805,917.

Table 4: Summary of Assets Compensated During First Phase Period (2008 – 2011)

No Type of Asset Description of Asset Number of Unit

Size in M P

2P or

Quantity

1 Residential house

Made of concrete hollow block/bricks with corrugated iron roof

108 822.7

2 Residential house

Made of wood structure, mud or cement mortar plastering, corrugated metal sheet roof

184 807.2

3 Residential house

Made of wood structure with mud mortar plastering and straw roof (Cottage huts)

156 684.3

4 Farm land estimated by

Teff, wheat, barley, sorghum, Maize, masho, potato, tomato etc.

Quintal 4523.3

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 44  

crop yield

5 Grazing land estimated by fodder yield

Grass used for fodder of domestic animals

5139.7

6 Permanent plant

Eucalyptus tree of various sizes 166,047

7 Perennial plant Fruit plants (mango, papaya, avocado, Chat)

1150

Based on formal and informal consultations with PAPs, the methods and procedures undertaken to mitigate and address adverse social impacts during compensation implementation, for the most part, seems to be within the context of established national legislation and social safeguard management guidelines of the GOE.

A committee composed of EEP staff; representatives of local administration and community elders in each affected woredas supervised and oversaw the compensation and resettlement activities. Compensation amounts were estimated based on calculated value of affected assets at replacement cost with current price. The local EEP staff in the presence of PAPs and representatives of local authorities disbursed compensation payments. PAPs were informed and advised on their rights to report compensation related complaints to grievance committees in their respective woredas.

However, despite the many positive achievements of the RAP, in some of the surveyed towns, the ROW clearance areas of the transmission line route continued to be occupied by PAPs who claimed to have not been compensated due to lack of legal title deeds for their properties, unresolved compensation issues, and from absence of coordinated enforcement to clear the ROW after compensations was made out to PAPs.

PAPs occupying the ROW in Shoa Robit and Legetafo towns were mainly not covered by the first round compensation implementation scheme. To understand and examine the scope and magnitude of informal and squatter settlements in Kebele 01 and Kebele 04 of Shoa Robit town, the consultant conveyed public consultation meeting on February 21, 2015 at Kebele 01 Office, attended by representative of affected households and local authorities. During the meeting the consultant learned that though most of the settlements existed during and before commencement of installation of the 230kV transmission towers, many of the assets were not assessed and considered for compensation by the EEP staff due to the fact that they do not hold legal landholding titles for the land they occupy. It was also learned that while two of the households found within the transmission line clearance area

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 45  

were forcibly demolished to install the towers by the local authorities without payment of compensation, others were left to remain inside the ROW for no apparent explanations.

The total number of reported grievance/complaint related cases from the first round compensation implementation recorded during the current assessment is 35 and the highest number recoded in Senbete Woreda of Oromia Special Zone of Amhara Region (21 cases), followed by Debresina and Wuchale towns of Amhara State (4 each), Legetafo- Legedadi town of Oromia State (3 cases) and North Wollo Zone of Amhara State (2 cases). The major stated complaints as stated by PAPs are:

The compensation amount offered do not reflect the current value of assets (10 cases),

Delay in provision of replacement land for construction of houses (10 cases), uncollected compensations (3 cases) and

Replacement land offered smaller than original affected land (2 cases).

Of the total PAPs under this group, 25 households claimed to submit verbal complaints to local administrations including one case to the local mayor, 3 filed formal written complaint to the local court and complaint hearing committees and the rest reported informally filed verbal complaints to concerned authorities in their localities. (Refer table C - in annex I for detail list of project affected households)

Table 5: Summary of Formal and Informal Reported Complaints (Cases)

Woreda /Zone

Town/kebele Cases Reason Status

North Wollo Harbu 2 Undervalued

asset Formal complaint filed to the court

system

South Wollo Wuchale

Kalu 3 2

Undervalued asset

Formal complaint filed to the court system

Oromia Special Zone

Senbete 21 Undervalued

asset Formal complaint filed to the court

system

North Shoa D/Sina Kwot

1 3

Not collected compensation

Formal complaint filed to the court system

Legetafo Legedadi

Alelitu Moye

1 1 1

Undervalued Undervalued Undervalued

Verbal complaint to local authorities

Total 35

 

On the other hand the total number of enforcement related cases from the first round compensation implementation recorded during the current assessment is 45. Almost all claimed that they have not been instructed to vacate the ROW within a specified and

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 46  

agreed time frame after disbursement of compensations. Of the total 45 reported cases, the highest number registered in Debresina Woreda of North Shoa Zone (25 cases), 4 in Legetafo Woreda of Finfine Zuria Special Zone, 4 in Oromia Special Zone of Amhara State, 3 in North Wollo Zone of Amhara State, 2 in Alamata woreda of Tigray State, and 1 South Wollo Zone of Amhara State. Additionally, 2 PAPs reported they were misinformed and advised by some local authorities not to demolish their houses after they collected compensation and one visually impaired elderly PAP reported physical challenges and shortage of money prevented him from demolishing and removing his affected asset to give way for the project activities.

Table 6: Summary of HHs remained occupying ROW after Collection of Compensations between 2008 - 2011

Woreda/Zone Town/kebele # Of

Households Reason for not

Vacating Status

Alamata Rari

Harle 1 1

Absence of Enforcement

Remained occupying the ROW

North Wollo Habru Kobo

2 1

Absence of Enforcement

Remained occupying the ROW

South Wollo Harbu 1 Absence of

Enforcement Remained occupying

the ROW

Oromia Special Zone

Arthuma Farsi Senbete

1 8

Absence of Enforcement

Remained occupying the ROW

North Shoa

Genet Washa Gundo Beret

Asfachew Chira Mmeda

D/Sina – D/Sina 01 D.Sina -

Kwot

1 1 3 1 4 9 4 3

Absence of Enforcement

Remained occupying the ROW

Finifine Special Zone

Legebolo – Legeberi

Moye

3 1

Absence of Enforcement

Remained occupying within ROW

Total 45

Furthermore, most of the vegetation coverage currently found within the range of the ROW clearance area in Tarmaber woreda is owned by Forestry Development Enterprise of Amhara Region. According to reviewed reports, despite the Dessie Region EEP project

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 47  

office repeated reminder-notices, the enterprise has not made any attempt to clear the ROW area from vegetation coverage after collection of compensation for targeted assets.

 

Fig 5: Occupied settlements within the ROW clearance areas in Debresina & Senbete towns

To sum up, the main identified problems for continued occupation of the ROW after compensation payments were made to PAPs are:

a) PAPs that were not compensated for their assets during the first round of compensation because of lack of legal land deed title

b) Unresolved compensation issues arising from limited communications with PAPs on the rate and the basis of determining compensation to affected assets,

c) Absence of clear and effective institutional arrangement and sustained communications to redress complaints as they arise

d) Inefficient legal and municipal adjudication systems to resolve complaints when reported

e) Lack of strong commitment and will to enforce the resettlement plan at each level and

f) Inadequate monitoring and evaluation system to effectively supervise and oversee implementation of the plan after payment of compensation paid out to PAPs.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 48  

V. Project Impact Assessment and Categorization of Project Affected People

The main purpose of the Alamata –Kombolcha II –Legetafo –Kaliti I 2nd Circuit 230 kV Transmission Line reinforcement construction is to improve system stability and reliability of power services by transmitting additional power generated from Tekeze hydro power plant from Alamata Substation to the Inter Connected System (ICS) main load center at Kaliti via Kombolcha II and Legetafo sub stations.

The project has a wide range of social, economic and environmental benefits both at national and local levels. Providing reliable power for household use, supporting and facilitating delivery of improved social service, contributing to environmental mitigation and provision of temporary employment opportunities for area residents during the stringing period are a few of major positive impacts of the project.

5.1. Major Social Benefits and Positive Impacts

5.1.1 Facilitation of Improved Delivery of Social Services

Provision of quality educational and health service facilities, clean potable drinking water supply and emergency care services are limited and constrained in most urban areas and rural settlements due to slow economic growth and limited power infrastructure development. The stringing project, in addition to providing reliable power for household activities, will enable increased use of electricity to support quality of life of citizens by facilitating delivery of improved social services in education, health, communication and in promoting economic activities that enhances and contributes to the overall local and national development goals and objectives.

5.1.2. Reduced Rate of Deforestation and Public Health Risks

The heavy reliance on traditional energy sources, such as biomass fuels, for cooking and lighting in rural and most urban communities have serious and dire consequences on health, agricultural productivity, the environment and the surrounding ecosystem. Biomass fumes (household smoke pollution) cause respiratory problems and cutting indigenous trees for household energy results in deforestation, erosion and degradation of agricultural lands. Soil degradation causes decline in agricultural yields, while soil erosion, which is the most common type of degradation, affects not only agricultural productivity but also reduces the capability of water supply sources.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 49  

Effective expansion of power distribution lines and household connections would increase availability and access to modern energy sources and minimizes environmental problems resulting from heavy dependence on application of biomass fuels for household energy uses. It would also reduce critical health problems on women and children caused by indoor air pollution resulting from large quantities of household smoke due to incomplete combustion of firewood when used for cooking and lighting.

Availability and accessibility of modern electric power for household uses also significantly reduces the rate of deforestation caused by cutting trees for firewood, lighting and cooking and improve climate change mitigation efforts in reduction of household carbon emission.

5.1.3 Extending Local Employment Opportunity during the Stringing Operations

The stringing operation may create temporary employment opportunities for skilled, semi-skilled and unemployed local people as construction laborers or may also offer business opportunities to local communities from sale of food items and other supplies to construction crews and others.

For these and other unlisted reasons, the combined advantages make the project's strategic engagement socially, economically and environmentally desirable and justifiable.

5.2. Adverse Impacts of ROW Clearance

The project social impact assessment attempted to cover all areas likely to be adversely affected as a result of the planned power transmission cable stringing activities of the project. The major social impact is likely to occur as a result of designating ROW clearances along the transmission line route. The ROW clearance is required to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the power transmission line, all permanent structures, such as houses, plants and other assets found within the established 30 meter ROW need to be removed in order to give way for the stringing and safe operation of the transmission line.

The context and parameters used in evaluating and measuring anticipated project related adverse impacts include whether the impact is within the transmission line area, whether the intensity is large or small and if the duration of the impact is long term or temporary in nature coinciding with the stringing project activities.

Taking into consideration the large area coverage of the line route and the nature and intensity of the proposed activities, the EEP has carefully designed the line route to minimize large-scale displacement of urban and rural settlements as well as damages on agricultural land and farming activities. Furthermore, for unavoidable impacts, EEP has paid out compensations payments for impacted assets located within the 40m ROW of the

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 50  

transmission line route based on applicable national laws prior to installation of transmission towers. However, the current assessment followed the new directive issued by EEA that sets the standard for an electric transmission line with a voltage between 230kV and not exceeding 400kV to have clearance space of 30 meters ROW.

In measuring the nature and magnitude of such impacts, the following criteria and parameters were applied to assess and classify affected assets and affected households:

a) Visual inspection, consultation with PAPs, investigation and physical measurement of distance of asset from the center of the designated transmission clearance area, i.e. if asset is situated 15 meter either side from the centerline of the transmission line,

b) Determine and verify type and condition of targeted asset regardless of ownership status, which is whether legally owned and occupied or acquired through other informal or illegal means

c) Checking and verifying whether affected PAP is compensated for targeted asset in the past or the property was excluded from compensation, or is constructed in recent period

Inventoried and assessed assets included and qualified to be eligible for compensations based on the above list of criteria and parameters include:

Assets that existed during and before commencement of installation of the 230kV transmission towers, but excluded by the EEP staff because the properties were considered to be out of the range of the designated 40 meters ROW

Assets that existed before and during commencement of installation of transmission towers, but disqualified for compensation because of their landholding status, i.e. illegal ownership and occupation of land targeted by the project 5F6.

Assets and other properties constructed and occupied by PAPs after installation of power transmission towers

                                                            

6. The TOR defined the ROW clearance as 30 meters, instead of the 40 meters used in the first phase of the project. The reduction in ROW width was pursuant to the directive issued by the Ethiopian Electricity Agency, which sets standards on overhead electric line clearances and quality supply. The directive set the standard for a line with a voltage between 230kv and not exceeding 400kv to have clearance space of 30 meter ROW instead of 40 meter ( Directive # EEA/1/2005 ).

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 51  

The assessment also anticipated, in a very limited way, the project activities may trigger temporary safety and health hazards on local inhabitants during the construction and after completion of the stringing work. All important and relevant health and safety risks have been identified compiled in the ESMP to be supervised included with the contractor bid document.

5.3. Classification and Categorization of PAPs

As the ROW clearance is required to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the power transmission line, all permanent structures, such as residential houses, plants and other assets found within the established 30 meter ROW need to be removed in order to give way for the stringing activity, the major adverse social impacts of the proposed project arise from demolition or removal of physical assets within the established 30m Right of Way (ROW) clearances along the line route. Accordingly, the assessment identified a total of 180 residential houses and attached household facilities made with wood structure, plastered with mud and cement mortar, corrugated sheet metal and other substandard roofing materials and 823 permanent and fruit trees, presently occupying and situated within the 30meter right of way of the transmission line belonging to 120 HHs (699 PAPs), requiring removal, clearing or reposition to give way for the stringing project activities. Additionally, 35HHs (202 PAPs) require transparent and efficient grievance redressing system mechanism to resolve and settle their compensation related formal and informal complaints filed on local courts and other offices.

Since the Alamata –kombolcha –Legetafo power transmission line voltage is 230kv, the directive issued by the Ethiopian Electric Agency ( Directive # EEA/1/2005 Article 7, Sub Article 7.1.4 ) permits cultivation of low height crops ( up to 7 meters) and slow growing vegetation beneath the overhead electricity line with voltage of 132kV but not exceeding 230kV. Therefore, the stringing project will not affect cultivation of seasonal food crops beneath the overhead electricity line ROW. .

In general, based on type, magnitude and nature of impacts, the above mentioned and all the other PAPs are classified and categorized under the following five categories:

Category I: PAPs who legally own and occupy residential houses, and who reported to exist during the first phase project implementation period but excluded in the assessment and compensation payouts and PAPs who constructed residential houses after the first phase assessment and project implementation period. The first group (about 14 HHs) claim their properties existed at the time of the first phase implementation period, but excluded from the assessment because the project staff believed the assets are out of the range of the ROW clearance area and the second group (4 HHs) reported to have built houses on land bought from individuals who reported to be compensated in the first phase project implementation

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 52  

for their perennial trees only. These PAPs also claimed that they were not aware of the restrictions to construct houses within the ROW and no one from the local authorities attempted to advise or to serve them a stop order notice when undertaking the construction activities.

Since the residential houses and plant assets are situated within the designated ROW clearance area and because the ENREP - RPF and the World Bank Operational Policy (OP 4.12) require compensation and relocation shall be provided regardless of legal landholding status of affected people, which includes informal and squatter settlements, the consultant included both groups of PAPs and qualified them to be eligible for adverse impact mitigation and compensations (Refer table-A in Annex II for list of Category I PAPs).

Category II: PAPs who reside within the ROW of the transmission line and were excluded from the first phase assessment and compensation scheme because they were considered as squatter and illegal settlements. The total number of HHs identified under this category is 103 and almost all are found in Shoa Robit town of the North Shoa zone and Legetafo area of the Finfine Zuria Special Zone in Oromia regional state. The properties in Shoa Robit are concentrated in the outskirts of the town at localities known as kebelle 01 and kebelle 04.

In the context of this study, this group of PAPs is referred as informal settlers, instead of squatters. Unlike the classic definition of squatters, most of the PAPs who are classified as illegal occupants/ settlers in this study purchased the land they occupy through informal transactions and used their own resources to construct permanent housing facilities, which are considered to be better structures by local standards. Furthermore, even though some of the PAPs knowingly occupy the vacant land informally and constructed housing structures for residential purposes, based on resettlement frame works of the ENREP-RPF and the World Bank OP -12, they are entitled for compensation for lost assets and qualify for other forms of assistance to restore their present living condition after resettlement. Additionally, two HHs in Shoa Robit, whose properties were forcefully demolished by local authorities without payment of compensations during transmission power installation, are included in this assessment and mitigation plan (Refer table B - Annex II for list of Category II PAPs).

Category III: This category comprises 8 households with a total number of 46 PAPs found in Wutchale town of North Wollo Zone of Amhara Region. Except for one HH, the rest of them in this category have received compensation for their affected assets during the first compensation implementation period carried out by EEP. These PAPs are aware of the restrictions of building houses within the ROW after the cut of date of the first survey carried out by the EEP. Nevertheless, they remained occupying the land they collected

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 53  

compensations and continued building new houses on the part of the land and sold the remaining land for others to build houses. The new individual HH who bought land from compensated PAP to build his residential house came from Gishen Mariam due to health reasons. These PAPs are disqualified and excluded from the current survey and compensation plan due to:

a) The fact that the land they build houses and or sold for other individual has been included and compensated in the past and

b) The new construction took place after the cut of date of the first survey and compensation scheme. (Refer Table E - .in Annex II for detail list of the HHs).

Category IV: PAPs who have been covered by the first phase project compensation implementation, but continued occupying the ROW clearance areas for various reasons including presence of unresolved complaints arising from disputes on asset valuation, delay in provision of land to build replacement houses and absence of efficient grievance redressing system to resolve complaints when reported. The total number of HHs under this category is 35 (202 PAPs).

Category V: PAPs who reported to have been covered and compensated fully during the first phase project implementation period, but continued to occupy the ROW because of absence of efficient enforcement system to facilitate evacuation of PAPs and removal of compensated assets. The total number of HHs under this category is 45 (260 PAPs).

Table 7: Description and Categorization of PAPs

Category Description No. Of HHs

Category I HHs, who legally own and occupy residential houses, possess perennial plants and other facilities within the designated ROW of the transmission line route but not covered and compensated during the first phase project implementation period because their assets were determined to be out of the range of the ROW of the line route.

17

Category II HHs who were excluded and disqualified from the first round assessment and compensation on the basis of absence of legal land ownership right as determined by the municipal or other offices.

103

Category III Households who have established residential settlements within the ROW clearance area with no legal ownership right of the land they occupy after the cut of date of the first round survey carried out by

8

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 54  

EEP or after compensation payments were made out to the legitimate PAPs and installation of the 230kV transmission towers completed.

Category IV HHs who were covered during the first phase implementation period but continued to occupy the ROW of the transmission line clearance because of unresolved issues or expressed grievances on the method and system their assets were valued and compensated or other legitimate reasons.

35

Category V HHs who were covered and fully compensated in the first round compensation period but remained to occupy the ROW of the transmission line route for absence of effective time frame and clear enforcement to vacate the land they collected compensations.

45

Total 208

5.4. Cut-off Date for Determining Eligibility

The impact assessment and identification of PAPs was carried out between February 2015 and April 5, 2015. During the survey, households were advised and encouraged to report and register residential facilities and their useful assets that are likely to be affected by the proposed project activities. PAPs were also informed the cut-off date for claims as April 5, 2015, the date the baseline survey and household asset inventory completed. Any claim not reported and registered on or before the cut of date will not be eligible for compensations and other forms of entitlements.

5.5. Eligibility for Entitlement

The GOE and the World Bank Resettlement Guidelines require all Individuals and households whose assets and productive resources affected as a result of the stringing project are entitled for compensation and/or other forms of assistance. Pursuant to the policy frameworks, eligible PAPs for entitlement under this assessment include households with formally recognized property rights and those who have held land under informal purchase agreements and arrangements. It also includes vulnerable groups, such as women headed households, elderly families and people with health and physical challenges, requiring special assistance and rehabilitation during relocation and resettlement activities.

Type and size of affected asset qualified for entitlement and mechanisms for other forms of assistance are presented below in matrix format.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 55  

Table 8: Entitlement Matrix

Land and Assets Types of Impact Person(s) Affected

Compensation/Entitlement/Benefits

Agricultural land Cash compensation for affected land equivalent to market value

Less than 20% of land holding affected

Land remains economically viable.

usage title holder

Cash compensation for affected land equivalent to replacement value, taking into compensation rates as per government regulation.

Tenant/ lease holder

Cash compensation for the harvest or product from the affected land or asset, equivalent to ten times the average annual income s/he secured during the five years preceding the expropriation of the land.

Greater than 20% of land holding lost

Land does not become economically viable.

Farmer/ Title holder

Land for land replacement where feasible, or compensation in cash for the entire landholding according to PAP’s choice, taking into account market values for the land, where available

Land for land replacement will be in terms of a new parcel of land of equivalent size and productivity with a secure tenure status at an available location which is acceptable to PAPs. Transfer of the land to PAPs shall be free of taxes, registration, and other costs.

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + assistance in re-establishing economic trees + allowance up to a maximum of 12 months while short- term crops mature )

Tenant/Lease holder

Cash compensation equivalent to ten times the average annual income s/he secured during the five years preceding the expropriation of the land.

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + assistance in re-establishing economic trees + allowance up to a maximum of 12 months while

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 56  

Land and Assets Types of Impact Person(s) Affected

Compensation/Entitlement/Benefits

short- term crops mature

Commercial land Land used for business partially affected

Limited loss

Title holder/ business owner

Cash compensation for affected land, taking into account market values for the land, where available.

Opportunity cost compensation equivalent to 5% of net annual income based on tax records for previous year (or tax records from comparable business, or estimates where such records do not exist).

Business owner is lease holder

Opportunity cost compensation equivalent to 10% of net annual income based on tax records for previous year (or tax records from comparable business, or estimates where such records do not exist).

Assets used for business severely affected

If partially affected, the remaining assets become insufficient for business purposes.

Title holder/business owner

Land for land replacement or compensation in cash according to PAP’s choice; cash compensation to take into account market values for the land, where available. Land for land replacement will be provided in terms of a new parcel of land of equivalent size and market potential with a secured tenure status at an available location which is acceptable to the PAP.

Transfer of the land to the PAP shall be free of taxes, registration, and other costs.

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + allowance)

Opportunity cost compensation equivalent to 2 months net income based on tax records for previous year (or tax records from comparable business, or estimates)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 57  

Land and Assets Types of Impact Person(s) Affected

Compensation/Entitlement/Benefits

Business person is lease holder

Opportunity cost compensation equivalent to 2 months net income based on tax records for previous year (or tax records from comparable business, or estimates), or the relocation allowance, whichever is higher.

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting)

Assistance in rental/ lease of alternative land/ property (for a maximum of 6 months) to reestablish the business.

Residential land Land used for residence partially affected, limited loss

Remaining land viable for present use.

Title holder Cash compensation for affected land, taking into account market values for the land, where available.

Rental/lease holder

Cash compensation equivalent to 10% of lease/ rental fee for the remaining period of rental/ lease agreement (written or verbal)

Title holder Land for land replacement or compensation in cash according to PAP’s choice; cash compensation to take into account market values for the land.

Land for land replacement shall be of minimum plot of acceptable size under the zoning law/s or a plot of equivalent size, whichever is larger, in either the community or a nearby resettlement area with adequate physical and social infrastructure systems as well as secured tenure status.

When the affected holding is larger than the relocation plot, cash compensation to cover the difference in value.

Transfer of the land to the PAP shall be free of

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 58  

Land and Assets Types of Impact Person(s) Affected

Compensation/Entitlement/Benefits

taxes, registration, and other costs.

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + allowance)

Land and assets used for residence severely affected

Remaining area insufficient for continued use or becomes smaller than minimally accepted under zoning laws

Rental/lease holder

Refund of any lease/rental fees paid for time/use after date of removal

Cash compensation equivalent to 3 months of lease/ rental fee

Assistance in rental/ lease of alternative land/ property

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + allowance)

Buildings and structures

Structures are partially affected

Remaining structures viable for continued use

Owner Cash compensation for affected building and other fixed assets taking into account market values for structures and materials.

Cash assistance to cover costs of restoration of the remaining structure

Rental/lease holder

Cash compensation for affected assets (verifiable improvements to the property by the tenant), taking into account market values for materials.

Disturbance compensation equivalent to two months rental costs

Entire structures are affected or partially affected

Remaining structures not suitable for continued use

Owner Cash compensation taking into account market rates for structure, labour and materials for entire structure and other fixed assets without depreciation, ; or alternative structure of equal or better size and quality in an available location which is acceptable to the PAP.

Temporary accommodation should new housing construction not be completed or serviced by

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 59  

Land and Assets Types of Impact Person(s) Affected

Compensation/Entitlement/Benefits

date of evacuation

Right to salvage materials without deduction from compensation

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + allowance)

Rehabilitation assistance if required (assistance with job placement, skills training)

Rental/lease holder

Cash compensation for affected assets (verifiable improvements to the property by the tenant)

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + allowance equivalent to four months rental costs)

Assistance to help find alternative rental arrangements

Rehabilitation assistance if required (assistance with job placement, skills training)

Squatter/informal dweller

Cash compensation for affected structure without depreciation

Right to salvage materials without deduction from compensation

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting + assistance to find alternative secure accommodation preferably in the community of residence through involvement of the project

Alternatively, assistance to find accommodation in rental housing or in a squatter settlement scheme, if available)

Rehabilitation assistance if required assistance with job placement, skills training)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 60  

Land and Assets Types of Impact Person(s) Affected

Compensation/Entitlement/Benefits

Street vendor (informal without title or lease to the stall or shop)

Opportunity cost compensation equivalent to 2 months net income based on tax records for previous year (or tax records from comparable business, or estimates), or the relocation allowance, whichever is higher.

Relocation assistance (costs of shifting)

Assistance to obtain alternative site to re- establish the business.

Standing crops Crops affected by land acquisition or temporary acquisition or easement

PAP (whether owner, tenant, or squatter)

Cash compensation equivalent to ten times the average annual income s/he secured during the five years preceding the expropriation of the land.

Trees Trees lost Title holder Cash compensation based on type, age and productive value of affected trees plus 10% premium

Temporary acquisition

Temporary acquisition PAP (whether owner, tenant, or squatter)

Cash compensation for any assets affected (e.g. boundary wall demolished, trees removed)

Loss of Livelihood

Households living and/or working on the project area, including title holders/non-title holders/daily laborers working in the market

Rehabilitation Assistance

Training assistance for those interested individuals for alternative income generating activities; providing employment opportunities on the construction site for the PAPs.

5.6. Other Anticipated Temporary Adverse Project Impacts

5.6.1. Potential Safety Hazards During and After Stringing of Transmission Cables

During the stringing phase, failure to comply with standard safety procedures and precautionary measures may result in exposing construction workers and the general public

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 61  

to potential safety hazards and risk of electrocution from contacts to low and high-tension transmission wires.

During operation, low elevation clearance of conductor cables in some areas along the transmission line route may cause potential electric shock hazards to humans, livestock and the wildlife. For example, during the assessment period, the consultant learned that in the phase 1 of 2008 (not funded by the World Bank), the occurrence of such potential hazards on the general public and live animals due to close contacts with conductor cables and subsiding transmission lines caused by natural calamity, such as flooding, windstorm disturbances and landslides happened.

Furthermore, unauthorized continued existence of residential dwellings near or inside the ROW clearance may likely expose households to potential safety hazard of electric shocks from dropping cables or collapse of tower due to natural calamities, such as landslide, during operation times.

Electromagnetic Field Hazards as Reported by Local Residents in 2008-20011

Reported Case 1 - On the cliff of Tarmaber, above Debresina town, between tower number 328 and 329, the conductor cable was reported causing major shock risk to wildlife due to low elevation clearance (1.5. to 1.75m) from the edge of the cliff on the mountain.

Reported Case 2 -Members of the community residing on the cliff sections of Kombolcha to Dessie via Tita village was reported to experience electric shock while passing under a subsiding transmission line between tower number 323 and 324.

Reported Case 3 –Subsiding conductor cable located in Ambassel woreda near a village called Volvo, a location next to Mersa town, tower number 253, installed at the confluence of two rivers, is reported to have caused electric shock hazard to a cattle herding boy who got himself in contact with the cable with a wet stick.

These incidents were reported to EEP’s Inspection & Maintenance Unit in Dessie district and required maintenance works and remediation were made on the towers to minimize any reoccurrence. EEP also informed the RAP consultant that the reported incidents were minor shocks from passing through dropping cables or from collapsed tower due to natural calamities, such as landslide. As part of the mitigation measures, essential information and awareness creation orientation on electric shock, health risks and precautionary safety measures were provided to the community. These measures also captured in the ESMP.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 62  

5.6.2. Improper Waste Disposal Practices

The main types of waste likely to be produced during the stringing operation are disposal of packaging materials, scrub metals and cables, plastic water bottles and other food packaging materials and other forms of debris. Improper disposal of these materials on the project site area, especially on farms and communal grazing lands, may likely cause health hazards and can easily spread out and contaminate the ground and surface water resources.

5.6.3. Road Traffic Flow Impacts during the Stringing Period

In relative terms, the traffic density of the main highway that passes through the project towns and rural areas is considered very high due to intensive and frequent movement of long distance public transport buses, medium and short distance mini bus transport services and movement of heavy trucks and freight transport vehicles from north to south and vise verse. Low bed and wide load trucks also frequently use the road to transport heavy-duty road construction equipment and machinery to project sites along the line routes and towns.

As the transmission towers are located close to the main highway in several areas, from time to time, the stringing activities may likely cause traffic stoppage and traffic flow disruptions that will result delay in movement of public transport and freight vehicles. Though these impacts will be temporary in nature and minimal in impact, they may cause inconvenience to vehicle operators, public transport passengers and to the general community.

5.6.4. Road Traffic Safety Hazards

Road traffic accidents are becoming a major public safety and development obstacles in Ethiopia. Inexperienced drivers, poorly designed roads and vehicle conditions, absence of suitable traffic and pedestrian crossing signs and lack of road traffic safety knowledge of pedestrians are among the major contributors of road traffic accidents. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) data published in April 2011, road traffic deaths in Ethiopia reached 2.77% of the total deathsP6F

7P.

Intensive vehicular movement in connection with the stringing project activities in the project sites and lack of basic traffic safety knowledge of rural households would be a major concern for traffic accidents and fatalities involving pedestrians, children, cattle and other livestock.

                                                            7In a recent survey carried out in Amhara region, pedestrian death accounted for 35.7 % of the total people killed in car accidents in Amhara region(Journal of Health Development,2011) 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 63  

5.6.5. Damage to Soil and Communal Lands

The stringing operation may involve setting up temporary camps on private or communal lands to serve as shades for workers and as storage facility for construction materials near to the towers of the transmission line. From time to time, the project may also require using farmlands as temporary access roads to transport construction materials useful for the stringing operation from the main highway or from temporary storage facilities to the towers. These activities may likely cause damage to communal grazing lands and on growing crops if the stringing activity is undertaken before farming or harvest collection seasons. Since many of the towers do not have dedicated access roads, these impacts are unavoidable, and may last for the duration of the stringing period.

5.7. Summary of Potential Adverse Impacts of the Project

The overall impact assessment findings are summarized as follows:

a) In most parts of the project area, the planned stringing of 230 kV power transmission line has avoided major urban areas and rural settlements and will not trigger mass displacement or significant disruption on agricultural and farming activities as most of the surveyed households are urban dwellers engaged in small trading and other related activities.

b) Many of the rural households that have been affected by the land taking activities, i.e. for erection of the transmission towers and ROW clearance, have been compensated for affected assets according to the national laws and are also allowed to cultivate lands under the transmission line with a reasonable distance from the tower foundation footprints

c) A total of 120 HHs currently occupying the ROW of the transmission line likely to be affected to the extent of demolition or reposition their properties or removal of plants out of the designated 30 meters ROW clearance of the project.

d) Of the above total, 17 HH have legal landholding rights and 103 HHs are informal/illegal settlers without legal landholding title or customary landholding rights issued by local authorities.

e) Many of the PAPs have landholdings such as farm land other than their residential plots. If PAPs are losing land it is all below 20% of their total land holdings. The amount of land loss for the total households is below 20%. No one will lose more than 20% of their land.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 64  

f) The survey also noted that absence of clear and effective land management policy and weak enforcement capacity of local authorities contributed for illegal land sale, informal transactions and development of informal settlements along the line route.

g) No cultivable agricultural land or business premises will be affected as the result of the land taking activities of the project. Therefore, the project impact on livelihood activities of the vulnerable groups is minimal or negligible.

h) Except for the substations, throughout the transmission line stretch, the consultant has not observed constructed or dedicated access roads to transmission towers. Instead, towers are accessed using locally available options such as rural roads, village roads, foot tracks on farmland and open community grazing lands. If the stringing project is implemented during the dry season (which is most likely the case), its impacts on farmland will be minimum or negligible.

i) Unauthorized and continued presence of people near and inside the ROW clearance area and under high voltage transmission cables will be serious hazards concerns in the event of natural calamities or collapse of transmission tower during operation times. Low elevation clearance and subsiding power transmission line near and around mountain cliffs is also likely to cause potential safety hazard of electric shocks on livestock and the general public during operation period.

VI. Consultations and Communications with PAPs and Other Stakeholders

To provide an opportunity for affected households, project proponents and relevant local authorities to express their views and concerns regarding the proposed transmission line stringing project and its likely impacts on the local community, the consultant organized two rounds of public consultation meetings in Senbete town of Oromo Special zone of Amhara Region and in Shoa Robit town of Semien Shoa zone.

While the public consultation in Senbete was mainly aimed at PAPs who have legal or customary ownership titles and landholding rights for properties they own and who have been covered by the first round of compensation scheme, but remained occupying the ROW for various reasons, the public consultation meeting in Shoa Robit town targeted PAPs who occupy the land through informal transactions and purchases with no legal ownership rights and landholding titles. A separate forum also was held with local authorities in Shoa Robit town to discuss the extent and magnitude of informal settlements and to learn about planned measures to address the problem.

In all consultation meetings, in addition to verbal explanations, the consultant provided written summary description of the proposed project activities in local language (i.e.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 65  

Amharic) including basic components of the project, it’s likely adverse impacts on landholdings, crops and plants and other assets and major benefits the stringing project activities will bring to local communities, temporary employment and other local economic opportunities.

6.1. Consultation with Project Affected People at Senbete Town

Consultation meeting at Senbete town was held on 03 April 2015 attended by PAPs, representatives of the local government and the consultant team. The main points and concerns raised and discussed at the meeting are:

a) PAPs expressed frustration and complaints on the slow progress and delayed responses of the town municipality in providing replacement land after their original houses were ordered to be demolished by the project.

b) PAPs discussed the amount of compensation payments they collected two years ago cannot fully cover material and labor costs to build similar type of housing structures with the current market escalated price levels. They demanded adjustments to be made to compensation amount to offset increased costs of construction material and associated costs.

c) PAPs also complained the slow progress and lengthy process to address and resolve filed complaints and grievances related to compensations.

d) PAPs also requested if some of their properties would be spared from demolition since the designated ROW clearance width is reduced from the initial 40 meters to the current 30 meters.

 

Figure 6: Public Consultation Meetings in Senbete and Shoa Robit Towns

In responding to PAPs concerns and questions, the local official informed meeting attendees that

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 66  

The municipality and woreda administration offices are working earnestly to identifying replacement lands within the town boundary for project-affected people.

Replacement land will be provided to eligible PAPs who have qualified for compensations by EEP staff during the first phase survey and cut of date.

PAPs who have not submitted compensation related complaints to the grievance committee within the specified time period may not be allowed to submit fresh complaints for consideration or to qualify for complaint hearings.

The consultant has made clear to PAPs that any property/asset located outside the Right of Way (30 meter) will not be affected.

6.2. Consultation Meeting at Shoa Robit Town

The consultation meeting at Shoa Robit was held on 05 April 2015 attended by PAPs (informal/illegal settlers) local authorities and the consulting team members. Some of the major points and opinions expressed and discussed at the meeting include:

a) Most households in the project-affected area of the town acquired their present lands as far back as 10 years through purchases and other arrangements from original owners. A few of them said they established their residence right before installation of towers for the 230KV power transmission line.

b) Though they are aware of the health and safety risks in living under high voltage transmission line, they will continue to do so for lack of alternative land to construct permanent housing and dwellings.

c) If removal and evacuation from the designated ROW clearance area is unavoidable, they demand to be compensated for their affected assets and be provided with plots of land to build houses regardless of their present status, as informal settlers.

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 67  

Figure 7: Public consultation meeting attendees in Shoa Robit and Senbete towns

In responding to expressed concerns of households, the local administration representative acknowledged the challenges and dilemma of informal settlements within the transmission line clearance area and other parts of the city boundaries and promised to address the issues through viable housing development approach based upon local land development plans and applicable policies. PAPs also found out that they will be compensated for their affected assets based on applicable estimates and in accordance to the national laws and regulations, regardless of their landholding status.

6.3 Consultation with Local Authorities and Other Stakeholders

The consultant held consultation meetings with Zonal, woreda and city administrations as well as relevant sector offices such as construction and design, land administration and management, agriculture and rural development departments.

Topics discussed include roles of local authorities in supporting and assisting clearance of the ROW, facilitating and administering compensation related complaints, addressing issues and concerns of informal settlements and dwellings constructed without legal landholding rights and other challenges related to the implementation of the proposed project development. During the meeting, representatives of the local authorities also expressed frustration about the absence of efficient and sustained communications with the EEP to address and resolve compensation complaints and other project related issues.

An understanding was reached on taking proactive measures and strategies to handle and address informal settlements, including assisting informal settlers into becoming legal settlers through the government housing cooperatives—i.e., providing land for construction of houses, facilitating clearance of ROW only after compensation payment have been made out to PAPs and resolving all past outstanding complaint related legal issues ---these are the major topics discussed and agreed upon in the meetings.

6.4. Public Views and Opinions about the Project

The consultation meeting provided forum to PAPs to freely express their views and opinions about the proposed project and enabled them to discuss issues and concerns with local authorities.

PAPs were also pleased to learn the local authorities’ plans and intentions to address issue and challenges of informal settlements through viable legal means.

Despite the possible loss of assets and personal and family inconvenience resulting from the relocation activities and other related concerns, project affected people who participated in the formal consultation meetings expressed support for the project development.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 68  

(Minutes of the meetings held with PAPs, local authorities and stakeholders including list of participants is presented in Annex III).

Table 9: Summary of Issues and Responses Presented at Consultation Meetings

Issues and Concerns Responses to Address Concerns & Issues Slow progress and delayed responses of the town municipality in providing replacement land to construct dwellings in.

The municipality is currently working in identifying replacement plots for affected households and promised to deliver it shortly.

Compensation payments made to PAPs two years ago cannot fully cover costs to build similar type of housing structure with the current construction material and labor price levels.

Concerns are reported to project authorities (the EEP) with the present RAP report and will be addressed.

PAPs like to know if some of their properties will be spared from demolition since the designated ROW clearance width is reduced from the initial 40 meters to 30 meters.

Residential houses and other properties located within the designated 30 meters ROW clearance will be demolished and removed from the site. PAPs will be allowed to use lands outside of the 30 meters clearance width of the transmission line.

Most households in the project affected area acquired lands through purchases from original owners and some established residence after installation of the 230KV transmission line. What type of legal supports will be available to address informal and illegal settlements

Regardless of their landholding status, PAPs who own houses and other properties within the 30m ROW clearance area will be fairly compensated Informal settlements will be offered supports through relevant offices to form viable housing cooperatives to access land legally and to micro loans to construct replacement residential houses.

There is lack of efficient and sustained communications between EEP and local authorities (Woreda) in the project areas.

EEP authorities will be notified about the complaints presented by local authorities and measures will be suggested to close communications gap and ensure maintenance of efficient and sustained communications between local woreda authorities and EEP

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 69  

VII. Mitigations for Adverse Impacts -Resettlement Action Plan

The Federal, Regional and the World Bank guidelines require where involuntary resettlement and land acquisition is unavoidable, resettlement and compensation activities shall be prepared and implemented by providing sufficient investment resources. The mitigation recommendations presented in this document, therefore, are developed according to legislative and resettlement frameworks to compensate fairly and equitably for loss of assets, systems and approaches to resolve outstanding issues related to compensation matters, to assist transition of project affected informal/illegal settlements into viable legal settlements and to support vulnerable groups improve or restore their present living condition after relocation and resettlement.

The overall mitigation recommendations are comprised of:

a) Compensation for loss of physical assets, houses, and attached household service facilities, including kitchens, storage rooms, septic tanks and fences.

b) Compensation for loss of perennial and fruit trees, such as mango, papaya, banana eucalyptus trees, which are used to generate additional sources of income to support and compliment livelihood activities,

c) Creating enabling environment to support transition of informal settlements into legal and viable housing settlements through provision of technical assistance

d) Provision of special financial assistance for vulnerable groups to help and support in relocation activities.

e) Provison of temporary housing allowance for PAPs who will be physically dislocated

e) Resolving all outstanding compensation and other resettlement related issues by revitalizing and strengthening grievance redressing system and mechanisms

f) Improving and strengthening monitoring and evaluation system to ensure effective implementation of the resettlement plan and timely evacuation of human settlements and vegetation coverage from the designated ROW clearance areas.

7.1. Legislative & Administrative Frameworks for Compensation of Affected Households and Assets

The specific proclamation and guidelines that form the basis for determining eligibility for compensations and other forms of assistance for recommendation of allocation of resources

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 70  

for implementation of unavoidable resettlement and compensation for lost permanent plants are:

1. Federal, Proclamation No. 455/2005 on “ Expropriation of Landholdings for Public Purposes and Payment of Compensation”

2. Council of Ministers, Regulation No. 135/2007, on the “Payment of Compensation for Property Situated on Landholdings Expropriated for Public Purposes”

3. The World Bank Social Safeguard Management Policy, specifically OP 4.12 4. Resettlement Policy Framework of ENREP, 5. Recent Guidelines and compensation rates used by the City of Kombelcha and Kalu

Woreda to estimate monetary value of physical construction and other useful properties and assets ( Refer to Annex IV for Kalu Woreda Asset Valuation Guidelines and Rates)

While mitigation for permanent impacts is recommended within the context and frameworks of the above policies and guidelines, mitigation for temporary project related adverse impacts is recommended based on prior experience and professional judgments.

7.2 Parameters and Applied Rates & Guidelines for Compensations

The Government of Ethiopia and the World Bank involuntary resettlement policies require that all affected assets and structures of households shall be compensated at the replacement costs of affected asset. The compensation amount shall also be equivalent to replace the asset in its existing condition and to ensure persons affected by land acquisition are supported through alternative strategies to improve or restore their present living condition after resettlement.

Since most of the assets targeted for demolition or removal are located in Amhara National Regional State, the most recent rates and guidelines used by Kalu Woreda and Kombolcha City Administration have been used to calculate the monetary value of properties, demolishing costs and to estimate moving and transportation expenses associated with clearing and vacating affected assets.

The parameters used to determine replacement value of affected assets of PAPs are:

a) For residential houses and attached household service facilities

Type, size and description of the property, such as residential house, service facilities, patios, storage room, incomplete construction, fences, etc.

Type and quality of materials used to construct the property, such as type of construction material, (wood, bricks stone) roofing (corrugated sheet metal, straw,

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 71  

plastic sheet or canvas), plastering material (mud or cement mortar), ceiling (chip wood, plastic sheet or canvas), and floor type (mud or concrete). etc.

Current use and condition of the structure, such as residence, storage or service facility

Construction cost estimates for a similar structure at the current market price level, such as construction material and labor costs.

b) For permanent trees

Major use and application of the plant, such as for fruit tree, firewood, for housing and building construction, or other uses

Maturity, height and thickness of the plant Current market price for similar type and size plant

c) For Fruit Trees

Type and maturity (fruit bearing or not) of plant, mango, avocado or other fruit plant

Productive life of the plant Current market price for similar plant product

d) For demolition and removing expenses

Estimated local labor costs for demolition of targeted houses Estimates of local labor cost for clearing debris and other useful parts Estimates for moving and transporting

7.3. Asset Valuation and Estimates of Compensations for PAPs

Consistent with the legal and resettlement policy frameworks, household assets targeted by the project, regardless of whether properties are constructed, owned and occupied through legal means or not or whether the land is occupied or acquired through informal means, are assessed and measured by a competent professional in the presence of head of households or family members. The monetary worth of affected assets is calculated using replacement cost method with current price level of materials and labor costs to build similar or better structures.

Table 10: Asset Valuation Guidelines &Rates ( Kalu Woreda Asset Valuation Rates)

S/N Description of Asset Class Rate/M2 (ETB)

1 Residential house made of hollow blocks, interior and 1 2, 600

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 72  

exterior cement plastering, corrugated sheet metal roofing, chip-wood ceiling, cement floor, metal door and window glazing

2 Residential house made of wood structure and mud plastering, masonry foundation, plastic and cotton fabric ceiling, metal door and window and mud floor

2 2, 275

3 Residential house made of wood structure, mud plastering, corrugated sheet metal roof, mud floor and no ceiling

3 1, 758

4 Residential house made of wood structure, only interior wall mud plastering, corrugated metal sheet roof

3 1, 690

5 Residential house made of wood structure, mud plastering and straw roof, wood door and window

4 950

6 Other facilities, patio, detached kitchen, storage room and fences with corrugated sheet metal roof

5 650

7 Tree plants, such as Eucalyptus, acacia tree Piece 60

8 Fruit Plants, such as mango, papaya and other plant tree

Piece 80 – 800

9 Bush /shrubs Piece 10

Table 11: Summary of Proposed Compensation Payments (monetary value of affected assets including demolition and mobilization costs)

Location /Zone PAPs Compensation (Birr) Remark

North Wollo Zone 4 119,176.60 Houses only

South Wollo Zone 4 97,028.40 Houses & Plants

Oromia Special Zone 4 476,494.41 Houses only

North Shoa Zone 98 3,665,445.82, Houses, fences & plants

Finfine Zuria 10 427,036.30 Houses, plants and fences

Total 120 4,785,381.53

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 73  

The asset valuation rates used by Kalu Woreda Administration of Amhara region for recent similar projects have been applied to determine monetary value of assets and removing costs for calculating compensation amounts. Accordingly, a total of 120 PAPs are determined to be eligible for compensation for affected residential houses, perennial plants and fences. The total compensation amount including demolition and clearing costs is Birr 4,785,381.53.(Refer to Annex V for detail calculation of compensation for affected assets and other costs).

Total Number of PAPs requiring compensations for affected assets and physical relocations

120

HHs not requiring physical relocations , but need compensation for plant asset only

3

HHs, who legally own and occupy residential houses, possess perennial plants and other facilities within the designated ROW of the transmission line route but not covered and compensated during the first phase project implementation period because their assets were mistakenly determined to be out of the range of the ROW of the line route. This group of HHs require compensations for affected assets and physical relocation ( replacement land for construction of houses)

14

HHs who were excluded and disqualified from the first round assessment and compensation on the basis of absence of legal land ownership right as determined by the municipal or other offices ( informal or squatter settlers) . This group require compensations for affected assets and physical relocation ( replacement land for construction of houses)

103

The land taking activities mainly affect PAPs who were excluded from the first RAP for not having legal landholding rights or permits and PAPs with legal landholding rights but not covered in the past for various reasons.

7.4. Special Assistance for Vulnerable Groups

Although no single issue related to vulnerable groups discussed at the consultation meetings, the household survey and assessment documented two households headed by elderly PAPs with visual impairment and physical challenges and about 57 women headed households. These two groups of PAPs require special assistance to smoothly facilitate their relocation activities during the resettlement process.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 74  

The two elderly household heads with visual impairment and physical challenges requested special assistance in demolition their targeted assets and transportation of their valuables household belongings to new relocation sites. The consultant also recommends that special assistance be provided for the 57 women headed households to enable them cover costs of labor for demolition of properties and removal of household belongings to the new relocation sites after collection of compensation and securing land for construction of replacement houses. As indicated in the impact assessment section of the report, no single PAPs including the two vulnerable groups will incur crop losses as a result of the relocation activities.

The project will facilitate provision of additional assistance from established government institutions, such as Women and Children Services, which is responsible for ensuring and guaranteeing women get equal access for resources and receive benefits (directly or indirectly) from programs and projects initiated by the government or any other institutions.

7.5. Transitional Assistance for Informal Settlements

The two main identified reasons for development of informal settlements within the ROW of the transmission clearance area in the project towns, specifically in Shoa Robit and Legetafo towns, are lack of access to legally own tenured land to construct residential houses and absence of uniform policy and permits for construction of residential houses. As a result of these problems, about 48.8% of project-affected people are informal settlers with no legal landholding rights and documents for the land they occupy. The total built up land area to be cleared to give way for the transmission line is about 3,196.5 square meters.

Considering the magnitude and scale of informal settlements along the transmission line, the consultant recommend to address and resolve the issue of informal settlements through pragmatic strategic approach and diligent legal means. The proposed strategy focuses acknowledging the existence of informal settlements and creating and facilitating enabling environment through:

a)Provision of technical support to organize informal settlers as viable housing cooperatives

b) Provision of special assistance to securing serviced land for PAPs ( both formal & informal settlers) who are organized under housing cooperatives

c) Development of methods and communication strategies to inform and educate both formal and informal settlers on land management regulations, permit requirements for housing and other constructions, land transfer procedures and legal

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 75  

restrictions and penalties for violation of established land management laws and regulations.

Overall, the cooperative housing arrangement is proposed as a means to transform informal (squatter) settlements affected by the stringing project development and others into legal and viable housing settlements. This proposed arrangement not only helps affected informal and formal settlers, but also benefits the local governments to minimize costs associated with serviced land development and lowers cost for PAPs ( per member) in all services and products associated with the housing development.

7.6. Organizing PAPs under Housing Cooperatives and Provision of Serviced Land

Proclamation no 147/1998 is the federal guideline for establishment of cooperative societies which are formed by individuals or groups with common and similar needs for creating such association. Membership to the cooperatives shall be voluntary and open to individuals and groups with common and similar interests.

At the public consultation meetings held in Shoa Robit and Senbete towns, local authorities announced plan to make serviced lands available after incorporating expansion areas into the towns’ boundaries. They also announced plans to make serviced lands available to PAPs who are organized under housing cooperatives in conformity with the guidelines on provision of urban land allocation for housing cooperatives. Serviced land refers to plots of land prepared within the city boundaries for new housing development purposes. It has all essential and basic public infrastructure including roads, power connection and water lines.

As most of the affected households are found in Amhara regional state, the regional government cooperative guideline (Directive # 22/2007), that encourages and enables organized PAPs to qualify for forming housing cooperatives with the goal of accessing serviced land jointly for construction of residential houses will be used to form cooperatives. The directive among other things requires membership to cooperatives shall be voluntary and open to all interested individuals or groups who do not currently own houses or whose current property is expropriated by the state for development purposes.

As urban and rural land is owned by the state, individuals as well as groups have the right to access it on lease terms. The lease term for private housing construction and development is 99 years. Individuals also have right to sell or transfer the property (house),but not the land.

The number of HHs (formal and informal settlers) requiring replacement land for construction of housing is 117 households. These PAPs are currently residing in

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 76  

concentrated settlements in the outskirts of the two major towns (Shoa Robit and Senbete towns of the Amhara Region) occupying the ROW of the transmission line. This total number includes both informal and formal PAPs with landholding titles affected by the stringing project activities.

PAPs will be grouped in housing cooperatives having a minimum of 12 and a maximum of 24 members. Membership will be voluntary and open for all individuals and groups whose properties are targeted for demolition or repositioning to give way for the stringing project activities. As the national law requires providing replacement land for PAPs with legal landholdings titles, those HHs who have legal title have the right to get replacement land individually or have the option of joining the cooperatives if they wish to do so.

The cooperatives will have management board elected by members and by-laws established by the general assembly to provide framework for the cooperatives management and operation.

The board of directors is responsible for the overall governance and implementations of policies and procedures approved by the general assembly including securing and facilitating serviced land for the cooperative from the local government. This body is also responsible in providing support to members during construction, enforcing rules and regulations on utilization of common areas, ensuring and facilitating provision of basic infrastructure services, management of household waste collection and disposal arrangement, landscape development, collection of a set of fees for common services and others as needed. Unlike other forms of cooperatives, the proposed cooperative board does not have right to screen or select who may live in the cooperative or terminate lease agreements.

The articles of incorporation and bylaws will specifies agreements on rights and responsibilities of members occupying the house as well as other legal rights and procedures on transfer or sale of the property to other individuals.

The Federal proclamation No. 147/1998 also places responsibility on the MSE offices at each level of government to assist individuals or groups who wish to establish cooperatives with the goal of accessing service land for construction of residential houses. The MSE offices in the two project towns are, therefore, responsible for providing technical assistance to register cooperatives with proper authorities, facilitate and securing serviced land from local authorities, provide orientation and training on cooperative management, leadership roles and on developing effective system on use of common facilities and areas.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 77  

The urban land management offices in the two towns are the responsible agencies for preparing serviced land for cooperatives. After securing plots from local governments, each individual cooperative member is responsible for raising funds to build his/her house and each individual household will be issued ownership title for his/her house after completion of construction.

As the new settlement areas will be located within the town’s expansion boundaries, resettled households will be able to access and served by health and school facilities that are already in place. As similar housing projects have been successfully undertaken by local governments in the past, the project do not anticipate any serious issue of adjustment of PAPs in their new resettlement locations. PAPs have been communicated and agreed on the cooperative housing arrangement during the public consultation meetings.

Following consultations and discussions with PAPs and concerned authorities in the two project towns, the local administrations confirmed their commitment in writing to make serviced land available to PAPs as soon as cooperatives are formed and registered with concerned authorities. Provision of replacement land and relocation of PAPs is expected to take place prior to commencement of the stringing project activities. Copies of commitment letters with a brief English translation are attached as annex.

7.7. Measures of Mitigation to Resolve Outstanding Complaints

To resolve existing formal and informal complaints related to compensations, a special committee composed of project management authorities, representatives of local administrations and PAPs shall be formed at a Woreda level with full mandate and authority to review and resolve all past compensation related grievances and complaints prior to implementation of the stringing project activities.

The committee shall expeditiously examine all formal and informal reported complaints, adjudicate cases fairly and equitably, and communicate decisions in writing to all the parties. A party dissatisfied with a decision rendered by the committee shall also be advised to appeal to the regular or municipal or appellate court, which may be appropriate, within 30 days, from the date of the decision.

The plan shall also include a coordinated institutional arrangement of local administrations and project management staff to ensure effective enforcement and clearance of the ROW of the transmission line after all compensations related issues and complaints is resolved. A plan with well-defined actions is fundamental to evaluate and measure achieved progress of compensations and ensure timely relocation of PAPs and clearance of the ROW areas from human settlements and vegetation coverage.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 78  

7.8. Mitigation for Temporary and Other Project Related Adverse Effects

7.8.1. Minimizing Potential Work and Safety Hazards during Construction Period

Anticipated work hazards to employees and the general public shall be minimized by promoting work place safety procedures and measures, which include ensuring compliance of safety manuals and practices, such as use of personal protective equipment (PPEs) like safety goggles, gloves, safety harness, helmets, etc.

Communicating and posting signs that restrict and prohibit local people from entering construction areas or standing close to worksites could also help to minimize risks to the general public.

Generally proper design, construction, periodic inspection and maintenance of transmission lines ensure to minimize electromagnetic field (EMF) hazards at the edges of the right-of-way after completion of stringing work:

Climbing preventive devices shall be placed on all faces of the tower to discourage children and local inhabitants from having contact with high-tension cables and towers.

Public announcement regarding operations of the transmission line shall be made to the inhabitants in the vicinity.

Periodic inspection of towers, cables and warning signs shall be undertaken to ensure the health and safety of local inhabitants.

The altitude of cables should be ensured to be high enough as to be safe for members of the public and workers to pass under without experiencing electric shocks in subsiding transmission lines.

Vegetation along the transmission line shall be maintained to required height to prevent contact with cables and avoid potential hazards.

All important and relevant health and safety risks have been identified and compiled in ESMP to be supervised and included with the contractor bid document.

7.8.2. Mitigation Measures for Road Traffic Flow Anticipated Impacts

The project shall schedule the stringing activities in a manner that will cause and create minimum blockage and obstruction to public transport and freight vehicle movements. Where temporary road closure is unavoidable, the project shall communicate and announce in advance to the general public and public vehicle operators about the proposed work activities, road closure dates and hours, advise on use of alternative access ways and to apply safe driving and caution when approaching project site areas and around the working corridor.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 79  

7.8.3. Mitigation Measures for Anticipated Road Traffic Safety Hazards

The project shall instruct construction vehicles to follow a safe speed limit in project site areas and advise all vehicle operators to apply maximum care and caution when driving, loading and unloading construction materials and personnel to and from project sites. In collaboration with the woreda transport bureaus and traffic police, traffic safety orientation and instructions shall be provided to local communities and schools in advance through verbal communications in local languages, written leaflets and via mass media announcements. These public orientation and education efforts will be helpful to increase road safety awareness and minimize traffic related accidents to pedestrians, children and animals.

7.8.4. Mitigation Measures for Improper Waste Management and Disposal Practices

The project shall plan and supply temporary containers or bins for collection of trashes and debris produced at construction sites and make arrangement for removal of such trash containers from work sites immediately after completion of daily work activities. Workers should be properly advised and instructed to avoid random dumping and disposal of trashes and debris at all times. Timely collection and proper disposal of project related litters would minimize the chances of spreading waste materials to farmlands and water resources.

7.8.5. Mitigation Measures to Minimize Damage to Soil and Communal Lands

The project will use the existing access road and access will be kept as close to the centerline of the ROW as possible to minimize environmental impacts, disruption resulting from transmission line construction and maintenance activities. In fact, access roads will be used as temporary access roads during the stringing construction activities, the RAP recommends maximum care shall be applied to avoid any kind of damage or contamination to the soil during movement of material and workers from and to the towers. Care must be taken in the selection consideration for the access roads and their attendant stream crossing in the early planning phases, access to and along the ROW will be limited to existing foot trucks, and if required, additional access road shall be negotiated in advance with the landowner or with the community based on the resettlement principles agreed in this RAP. On site negotiated solutions shall be reported as part of the required quarterly progress report to the World Bank.

VIII - Parties and Institutions Responsible for Implementation & Management of the RAP

8.1. Parties Responsible for Implementation of the RAP

Institutions and parties that have due relevance and major responsibilities for effective management and successful implementation of the resettlement action plan are:

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 80  

1. The Ministry of Water, Irrigation and Energy (MoWIE) is the main federal body responsible for planning, budgeting, guidance, supervision and execution of power and power related projects in Ethiopia. The ministry oversees power sector development projects through the Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP).

2. The Ministry of Environment and Forest is the agency responsible for ensuring the RAP and other project related activities are planned and executed in a manner that protect and safeguard the welfare of the people and maintain sustainability of the environment.

3. The Ministry of Women and Children through its regional and woreda offices shall be responsible for encouraging participation of women in all aspects of planning, management and implementation of the RAP.

4. Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP) is established under the ministry of water, Irrigation and Energy with a mandate and responsibility to engage in electricity generation, transmission and other related activities. The EEP bears the overall responsibility of allocating sufficient budget, disbursement of compensations and monitoring of all recommended systems and structures are in place for effective implementation of the RAP.

5. The Power System Planning Social Experts Unit under EEP is the responsible body for reviewing, validating and ensuring consistency of the RAP with ENREP Resettlement Policy Framework and guidelines.

6. The EEP Regional Project Offices shall be responsible for establishing compensation committees, disbursement of compensation payments for PAPs in the project areas, coordinate and facilitate relocation activities in collaboration with local authorities, monitor overall progress of the proposed RAP activities.

7. The Regional and woreda level Urban Local Governments (ULGs) in the project regions shall be responsible for facilitating disbursement of compensation for Project Affected People, assisting relocation of displaced households through provision of technical assistance and serviced land for construction of dwellings and ensuring all compensated physical assets and vegetation are removed and cleared timely to give way for implementation of the stringing project activities.

8. The EEP Regional Inspection and Maintenance Unit will be responsible for periodic inspection and maintenance of the ROW clearance, and will monitor the plants heights underneath the overhead electricity line, conductor cable and the transmission towers.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 81  

8.2. RAP Implementation Management Plan

8.2.1. Institutional Arrangement and RAP Implementation Committee

One of the major shortcomings of the first phase project implementation was absence of a well-defined management system and systematic coordination of tasks aimed at facilitating effective implementation of the RAP at each level. Even though RAP committees, composed of EEP staff, representatives of local administration and community elders, were formed in the project Woredas to undertake implementation of the RAP, including payment of compensations, the EEP did not establish a separate body specifically responsible for facilitating, coordinating and overseeing the RAP implementation at required capacity and efficiency level. Absence of such committee resulted and contributed to many of implementation related issues including dependency on local authorities, lack of efficient system and mechanism to resolve compensation related grievances, delays in allocation of land for relocation of PAPs, inadequate M&E system, critical gaps in recording and documentations of activities and inefficient coordination of enforcement measures to clear and vacate the ROW after compensation payments made to PAPs.

To correct the past RAP implementation shortcomings and ensure all planned activities are implemented timely and effectively, the EEP shall establish RAP Management Committee under the EEP Power System Planning Social Experts Unit, specifically responsible for managing, overseeing and monitoring and evaluating implementation of the RAP.

The RAP Management Committee shall be composed of representatives from the power system social experts, representatives from the Ministry of Women and Children, EEP’s Sub Station Reinforcement, Upgrading and Power Transmission Coordination Office. From parties responsible for implementation of the RAP, five ( 5) of them are proposed to be represented in the RAP management and implementation committees, while the Ministry of Water and Energy (MoWIE) is represented through EEP, the Ministry of Environment & Forestry, is excluded as it is a regulatory agency.

The RAP management committee, among other things, shall be responsible for ensuring all required financial, organizational and logistic planning is in place prior to implementation of the plan including establishment of RAP implementation committees in the project Woredas and overseeing the overall coordination and implementation. It will also ensure all implementation activities are documented and reported timely and monitoring and evaluation is undertaken periodically.

RAP implementation committees at the project Woreda level shall be formed to manage, coordinate, facilitate and implement all activities in their respective localities. The committees shall be composed of representatives of the EEP district offices, PAPs,

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 82  

members of the Woreda Women and Children offices and local administrations. The committees shall be responsible for establishing compensation committees, disbursement of compensation payments for PAPs in the project areas, coordinate and facilitate relocation activities in collaboration with local authorities, ensure all grievances and complaints related to compensations and relocations are documented, fairly reviewed and addressed through the Grievance Redressing Committees and monitor overall progress of the proposed RAP activities.

8.2.2. Mechanism to Address Complaints Related to Compensations and Other Issues

Grievance addressing mechanisms are proposed for allowing affected people to voice concerns about the compensations as they arise and, if necessary, for corrective action to be taken expeditiously. Such mechanisms are fundamental to achieving transparency in the compensation and relocation process.

The report handled and treated the first and second RAP as inter-connected and linked cases for two important reasons: a) The TOR requires reviewing, assessing and identifying unresolved complaints and

issues related to the first RAP and propose a mechanism to address them according to the ENREP –RPF and the World Bank guidelines and resettlement policy frameworks.

b) The ROW should be first cleared from current occupants and vegetation coverage in order to implement the stringing project

Therefore, addressing and resolving legitimate and valid issues of PAPs are not only critical pertinent for successful implementation of the RAP, but also a requirement by the GOE and the World Bank social impact mitigation guidelines and resettlement frameworks. The grievance redressing mechanism along with resolution channel and procedures flow chart presented below is intended to be applied to all present and past claims.

8.2.3. Grievance Redressing Mechanism & Procedures

A committee composed of representatives of the local administration, the project management authorities and representatives of PAPs shall be established to ensure a mechanism and venue for redressing grievances and complaints related to any aspect of the compensation and resettlement procedures.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 83  

PAPs shall be given sufficient time to review compensations package and be advised to report complaints and grievances related with compensations package. The GRC shall examine all reported complaints, give expeditious decisions and communicate the decision to the parties in writing after receipt of complaints.

A party dissatisfied with a decision rendered by the committee shall be advised the right to appeal to the regular appellate or municipal appellate courts, as may be appropriate.

GRC or the municipal appellate court shall review PAPs appeal and make final decision within 10 days from the date of filing the appeal. PAP shall also be advised that the decision of the court shall be final.

The GRC procedure shall also require all grievances to be recorded and responded in writing to ensure all complaints are handled fairly and timely in a transparent manner. The overall objective of the grievance redressing procedure is to respond to all complaints of PAP in a fair, transparent and timely manner.

Table 12: Grievance Resolution Channel and Procedures Flow Chart

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 84  

 

8.3. Public Disclosure of RAP  

Public disclosure of the RAP has to be made to PAPs and other stakeholders for review and comments on entitlement measures and other issues in the implementation of the RAP. The purpose of the disclosure is to receive comments and suggestions from PAPs and to incorporate the appropriate suggestions. EEP will publicly disclose this RAP, in English and in local languages and make copies available and distribute with a letter accompanied to the Amhara region, the respective districts and wordea authorities. This could be done by: a) publishing it on EEP'S website (in English and in local languages); b) publishing it in local newspapers; c) announcing it on local radio stations and d) depositing/posting it in a range of publicly accessible places such as, districts, Woreda offices and Kebele offices.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 85  

Once this RAP is disclosed, the public have to be notified both through administrative structures and informal structures about the availability of the RAP documents and also be requested to make their suggestions and comments. Once disclosed in Ethiopia, the FDRE will authorize the WB to disclose at the Info-shop in Washington DC.

8.4Monitoring and Evaluation  

The monitoring and evaluation process should be an integral part of this RAP and will be a device for overseeing the implementation of RAP and the extent to which it complies with the recommendations set out in the RAP. Lessons learnt from the monitoring and evaluation results will be used to enhance the preparation and implementation of future resettlement action plans.

The monitoring and evaluation process should be as much as possible participatory whereby all the stakeholders namely PAPs, Wereda, Municipality and Kebele administrations are involved.

8.3.1. Internal Monitoring

Internal monitoring will be the overall responsibility of the resettlement implementation agency (EEP).The day-to-day field supervision will be conducted by the supervision Engineers and reported in the monthly and quarterly progress reports, which are subject to review by EEP. The resettlement /implementation committees’ at each woreda level will also conduct its own monitoring of the RAP or in collaboration with the PIU.

The EEP management team will make the necessary follow-up to ensure that proper monitoring is being undertaken. EEP will assign a qualified Sociologist/Social scientist to conduct individual evaluations of PAPs re-establishment socio-economic progress. This service aims at evaluating, and reporting on, the level of living conditions and social services of the PAPs, both before and after the re-establishment. The evaluation will be done on quarterly and annual basis for two consecutive years. The monitoring and evaluation results will be based on a number of key indices for selected households, in combination with the special observation by the social scientist.

The monthly monitoring report prepared by PIU staff will be submitted to local authorities (Woreda and Municipality). A copy of this will be submitted to EPA and EEP management. It will also be enclosed in the construction progress reports submitted by supervising engineers.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 86  

The overall objective of internal monitoring is to ensure that implementation complies with the approved RAP. The specific objectives are to:

Check the achievement of the acquisition and resettlement process against the planned time schedule and budget;

Ensure that the channels of communication and consolation between the administrators and affected persons have been established and are operational;

Ensure that compensation payments for affected persons are paid in full and in a timely manner;

Verify that the processing of grievances has taken place within the given time limits;

Closely watch the adherence to lawful approved allocation of acquisition and resettlement funds so as to ensure the absence of corruption;

Ensure project-affected people, both formal and informal settlers, are provided with adequate land for construction of replacement residential houses and moving allowances are paid to PAPs in a timely manner.

Ensure the transmission line ROW is vacated and cleared from human habitation and vegetation coverage after full compensation payments and replacement-serviced land is provided to affected households.

8.3.2. External Monitoring

The external monitoring and evaluation will be done in a predictable manner and period. The Federal EPA and the Regional EPAs will be responsible for the external monitoring of the RAP. Both the Federal and Regional EPA’s have significant role in the external monitoring and evaluation of the RAP.

The external monitoring and evaluation, which is also a post resettlement assessment will be done by an independent consultant (or an NGO) commissioned by EEP, to ensure that the project affected persons have secured and able to maintain at least their livelihood prior to the construction of the project.

Hence, at the end of all expropriation/compensation operations a household survey will be carried out to evaluate the impacts of the resettlement and other implemented social mitigation measures. During the survey, Woreda and Kebele level administrations will be consulted to provide their assessments of the impacts of the mitigation measures applied.

After completion of the resettlement operations, it is expected that livelihood of PAPs should be better than prior to the resettlement. Therefore, resettlement operations need to be monitored as regard performance and compliance with the set goals.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 87  

The evaluation report will be used as a planning instrument to correct pending issues and suggest a post-project monitoring period in the aim to ensure that PAPs have not been subject to impoverishment induced by the project.

Regarding HIV/AIDS activities in particular, the Contractor, shall sub contract HIV/AIDS activities to local NGOs in consultation with PIU. Since this is an activity beyond the scope and experience of construction works it would be appropriate to sub contract. The EEP Environmental & Social Unit is required to make periodic monitoring of the performances and give advice on issues requiring rectifications as the construction progresses.

EEP staff shall supervise all issues contained in the RAP and Environmental and Social management Plan:

Compensation Payment for lost properties,

Rehabilitation of PAPs,

Implementaion of mitigation measures for the negative impacts; Safety and health requirements;

Implementation of mitigation measures for the negative impacts; Safety and health requirements;

HIV/AIDS and STD control measures ;

The contractor’s obligations shall include the assignment of at least two of his staffs as Environmental Officer and Safety/Health Officer, well experienced in their respective assignments. Contractor’s staffs are also recommended to attend training and briefing on the negative social impacts and on its mitigation and avoidance measures.

The main indicators that will be monitored regularly are:

a) The asset valuation and compensation payments are carried out in accordance with established legal and administrative procedures.

b) Payment of compensations to the PAPs is made in accordance with the level of compensation described and determined in the RAP to the minimum.

c) Ensure formal agreement and understanding is reached and signed with PAPs prior to disbursement of compensations and other assistances.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 88  

d) Complaints and grievances are addressed and resolved expeditiously to the satisfaction of the PAPs according with established procedures,

e) Provision of special financial assistance and support to vulnerable groups is made in accordance to the recommendation.

f) PAPs provided adequate and proper training and technical assistance for establishment of housing cooperatives prior to relocations

g) Serviced land for construction of housing is secured and provided to both formal and informal settlers prior to commencement of the stringing project activities.

h) Public information and public consultation are made in a timely manner.

i) Formal negotiation and agreements are made for temporary use of private and communal lands for project activities.

j) All PAPs are satisfied with the manner and the method the resettlement action plan is handled and carried out.

k) Type and number of temporary employment and economic opportunities created by the project are recorded and reported.

l) All project activities are recorded, documented and maintained in a timely manner.

Table 12: Summarized Monitoring & Evaluation Indicators

Indicator Time Frame

Establish RAP Implementation Committees at all levels Three to five months before handing over project to the Contractor

Conduct workshop for the RAP Implementation Committees and local authorities concerning the process and

Week two after committee has been established

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 89  

responsibility

Confirm compensation and rates and relocation options through

From week three to week seven

consultation with RAP IC and the Wereda Administration

Payment of Compensation From week four to week nine

Provision of land From week four to week nine

Construction of new houses From week four to week twelve

Installation of utilities for PAPs (electricity, and telephone) From week four to week ten

Relocation of public utilities (electricity and telephone) by service providers

From week one to week five

 

IX – Costs and Budget for Implementation of the RAP

The cost and budget presented below is prepared for compensation payments of affected properties currently found within the designated 30 meters ROW clearance area and financial plan for the implementation of the RAP including a special assistance budget to support vulnerable groups, temporary housing allowance and an estimated 10% contingency for unforeseen expenses, which equals to a total of Birr 6,075,725 (USD 289320.23). The RAP budget also specifies mechanisms for transferring and channeling funds to responsible organizations and agencies for disbursement to PAPs.

The EEP will be responsible to disburse, administer and oversee the overall budget. At Woreda level, the resettlement/implementation committee in collaboration with EEP regional office team will be responsible for making compensation payment and undertaking relocation activities. The budget details and justifications are summarized below for each category; namely, compensation payment for affected properties and other assets, demolition and moving expenses, special support for vulnerable groups, and RAP administration & management costs.

9.1 Compensation Payment

Compensation estimates for the different types and categories of houses such as, residential houses made of wood structure, corrugated metal sheet roofing, houses made of wood

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 90  

structure and straw roofing and fences is estimated on the basis of bill of quantities obtained from the Woredas administration and professional judgments and experiences from other similar projects.

The total compensation value for houses and related service facilities is estimated based on current replacement costs, which equals Birr 3,503,255.55 (USD 162,187.75)

Compensation for fence made of various materials is estimated at Birr 1,181,800 (USD 54,721.96).

Compensation for plants and trees is estimated Birr 80,640 (USD 3,733.33).

Total estimated replacement value for houses, fences and plant/trees is Birr 4,765, 695.55 (USD 220,634.05)

If the stringing project activities commence before PAPs completed construction of houses in their new relication sites, PAPs will be assisted to move into temporary rental houses and be compensated for rental expenses incured for a period of three (3) months. Compensation for rental ecpenses is calculated based on the average monthly rental rates of the areas, which is Birr 1,000 per month per HH. The total cost for temporary rental psyments is estimated Birr 351,000 (16,714.28) (117HH × 1000 monthly rental rate × 3 months).

9.2. Special Support for Vulnerable Groups and Budget for Informal Settlers

a. Financial Support for Vulnerable Households/PAPs: Financial support for vulnerable households for demolition and livelihood restoration activities is estimated at a cost of Birr 1000 per HH and the total estimate is Birr 59,000.00 (USD 2,730.21).

b. Technical Assistance Support for Informal Settlers: Costs for provision of technical assistance to transform informal settlers into viable housing cooperatives, which include forming housing cooperatives for informal settlers, legal registration fees, cooperative management training and other related expenses is estimated a lump sum of Birr 50,000 (USD 2,313.74.

9.3. Project Management & Running Costs

a. Budget for Asset Valuation Committee: This includes costs such as, Birr 300 daily allowances for 3 persons for one month (30 days), fuel at 20 liters daily and Birr 1000 (USD 46.29) daily vehicle cost.

Table 13: Budget for Asset Valuation Committee (Exchange Rate USD = 21.60 Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 91  

Description Number # days Unit Total (Birr)

USD

Perdiem 3 (persons) 30 300 27, 000.00 1,250.00

Transportation 3 30 100 9, 000.00 416.66

Miscellaneous LS LS 10, 000.00 462.96.00

Total 46,000.00 2,129.62

A total of Birr 46,000.00 is budgeted for the property valuation committee to undertake asset valuation activities (USD 2,129.62).

b. Budget for Resettlement/implementation committee: It includes budget for 5 person daily allowance for 3 months for perdiem; material cost, fuel and vehicle costs, Secretarial services, and Office equipment and communication costs is estimated Birr 250,000.00 (USD 11,574.07)

c. Monitoring & Evaluation Cost: Regular monitoring of the RAP implementation and periodic evaluation cost is estimated a lump sum of Birr 75, 000.00 (USD 3,472.00).

Table 14: Summary of Budget for Implementation of RAP

S/N Budget Item Amount in Birr USD A Compensation A.1 Houses and related household facilities 3, 503, 255.55 162,187.75 A.2 Fences 1, 181, 800.00 54,712.96 A.3 Trees and Fruit Plants 80,640.00 3,733.33 B Assistance for Vulnerable Groups B.1 Assistance for Female Headed HHs 57, 000.00 2,638.88 B.2 Assistance for Elderly Households 2, 000.00 92.59 C Technical Assistance C.1 T. Assistance for Informal Settlers 50, 000.00 2,314.81 C.2 Temporary Housing Allowance 350,000.00 16,714.28 D RAP Implementation Budget D.1 Budget for Asset Valuation 46,000.00 2,139.53 D.2 RAP Implementation Committee 250, 000.00 11,574.07 D.3 Budget for Monitoring & Evaluation 75, 000.00 3,472.22 A+B+C+D Total Budget 5,204, 295.55 240,939.62 Contingency (10%) 520, 229.55 24,084.70

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 92  

Total Budget 6,074,725.00

281,747.84

The above cost and budget estimate is prepared on the basis of required compensation payment for PAPs and budget required for implementing this RAP.

X- Implementation Action Plan

The action plan depicted below encompasses all aspects of the RAP activities and suggests methods by which the plan shallbe effectively implemented. The ROW should be first cleared from any inhabitants or vegetation coverage prior to the stringing phase of the project along the line route.

Table 15 – Summary of RAP Implementation Action Plan and Schedule

Action Mechanism Responsible Party

Time Frame

I. Review & Validate Resettlement Action Plan

Ensure consistency of RAP with established guidelines and resettlement frameworks, secure budget & required human resources, develop guidelines for Woreda level RAP implementation committees

EEP through Power System Planning Social Experts Unit.

One week from submission of the RAP

2. Set up RAP implementation committees at the project office and in project Woredas.

Form new or reactivate previously formed RAP committees at project and Woreda levels, improve and refine grievance redressing system and mechanisms, collect, review and analyze validity of documented formal and informal complaints, resolve all existing outstanding complaints in accordance with the resettlement policy objectives and frameworks3

EEP through Power System Planning Social Experts Unit and RAP committee.

Two weeks from date of submission of the RAP

3. Review and agreement of compensation

Disclose compensation packages to PAPs. The compensation

Consultants, EEP As part preparation of

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 93  

packages with PAPs methodology and rates applied to monetary worth of assets shall be communicated to each PAP in plain clear language. Discuss compensation packages to PAPs and secure confirmation and written agreement from PAPs

the RAP

PAPs shall be given sufficient time to review package and be advised of process to report complaints

4. Secure serviced land for housing construction

Communicate with local authorities about securing serviced land for cooperatives

The EEP, RAP committees and Local Adm

Two months from date of submission of RAP

5. Disburse Compensation for eligible PAPs covered under current RAP

Verify list and addresses of PAPs to be compensated, make payments through RAP committees

RAP Committees, Project Management Offices and Local Authorities

Four weeks from the date of submission of the RAP

6. Ensure vulnerable groups and other PAPs provided required transitional assistance and services

Facilitate other forms of support and assistances as proposed in the plan, secure commitment from local authorities for provision of technical assistance and transitional services to improve or restore living conditions and status of PAPs to pre relocation level.

EEP, RAP committee and local authorities

Four weeks from date of disbursement of compensation

7. Ensure grievance redressing committees are effective and functional

Establish systems and procedures for allowing affected people to voice concerns about compensation as they arise and take corrective action expeditiously

RAP committee local administrations and project management

One week from the date of disbursement of compensation

8.Organize PAPs under cooperatives

List and register PAPs who wish to participate in cooperative housing

EEP, RAP committee at local level and MSE offices at the local level

Two weeks from compensations payments

9. Provide training for cooperatives

Train cooperative members on membership rights and

MSE offices in the Two weeks from formation of

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 94  

responsibilities, cooperative management role and responsibilities cooperative board functions and responsibilities ,

two project cities cooperatives

10. Elect board of officers

Hold general assembly , approve article of cooperation and bylaw and elect board of directors

MSE offices & RAP committees in the two project towns

Two weeks from formation of cooperatives

11. Register cooperatives

Register cooperatives with concerned authorities

MSE offices and Coop board of directors

Two weeks from formation of cooperatives

12. Assign replacement land and inspect accessibility

Inspect accessibility of selected location for housing construction, ensure basic infrastructure is in place and provided to sites and land titles and construction permit issued for cooperatives at local offices .

EEP, RAP Committee and Coop board

Two weeks from securing lands

13. Commence housing construction

Coordinate PAPs and facilitate activities for construction of houses

RAP committee and Coop board

Two weeks from securing land

14. Establish deadlines for evacuation of past and current compensated PAPs from ROW clearance.

Establish effective institutional arrangement to improve enforcement issues, set evacuation date for clearance of ROW from compensated PAPs and vegetation coverage.

RAP Committee, EEP-Sub Station

Reinforcement and Upgrading Coordination Office, Local Authorities and Coop board

Three months from date of commencement of housing construction.

Should housing construction not be complete or service connections not be available by the evacuation date, PAPs can apply for transitional allowance for temporary

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 95  

accommodation.

15. Develop effective monitoring & evaluation plan

Put in place an effective monitoring and evaluation system, review and refine proposed baseline indicators for M&E activities.

Allocate budget and human resources to oversee and ensure monitoring and evaluation activities are undertaken as planned.

Provide timely feedback for monitoring and evaluation reports, measure outcomes against plan, take timely corrective measures to improve weakness for reported and observed problems and issues.

EEP, Reinforcement and Substation Upgrading Project Coordinating Office and concerned authorities and offices.

Plan to be completed before commencement of construction

XI. Summary and Conclusions

The impact assessment presented in this RAP report is intended to focus on measuring the magnitude of social impacts and determining eligibility of PAPs who are currently found and situated within the right of way and related access roads of the stringing project route and other impacts likely to arise as a result of the construction and operation of the transmission line project. It also assessed and reviewed complaints and issues raised in connection with implementation of the first phase resettlement action plan undertaken by EEP.

Taking into consideration the large area coverage of the line route and the various project activities, the social impact of the stringing construction will not result in large-scale displacement or significant negative impact on agricultural land and farming activities. However, in a limited way, the stringing project will trigger and result in removing or repositioning of residential housing facilities and loss of plant assets of households not covered under the first phase, temporary and minimal disruptions on traffic movement and restricted hazardous activities within the line route.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

Page | 96  

Though no issue of vulnerable groups has been raised at the consultation meetings, the survey and assessment has identified very few households as vulnerable groups who should be assisted with additional financial support to facilitate smooth transition and their relocation activities.

Based on review data and examination of registered complaints expressed by PAPs who had been reportedly compensated during the first phase of the project, the undertaken RAP seems to be within the context of established national legislation despite the unresolved claims arising from absence of transparent institutional mechanisms to redress complaints and lack of coordinated arrangement to effectively implement the resettlement action plan,

This SIA study together with suggested RAP management plan will help EEP to successfully executing the planned project activities and in complying with the World Bank standards on environmental and social mitigation management components.

 

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

97 | P a g e   

XII. References:

1. Cernea, Michael M, Involuntary Resettlement in Development Projects: Policy Guidelines in World Bank Financed Projects, World Bank Technical Paper, 1996

2. FH Mekonnen, S. Teshager, Road Traffic Accident: The neglected health problem in Amhara Region, Journal of Health Development (Vol. 28), 2014

3. Growth & Transformation Plan (2009/10 -2015), Ministry of Finance Economic Development (MoFED), Government of Ethiopia

4. Livelihood Profile of Amhara and Tigray Regions, DPPC, 2007

5. Sirivalals, Hari, Defining Squatter Settlements, 1991

6. Terms of Reference for Alamata Legetafo Second Circuit 230kv Power Transmission Line Stringing Project, EEP, 2014

7. Tigray Online, Ethiopia's hydroelectric power through the past 70 years and now, April 2011

8. Resettlement Policy Framework – ENREP, Power System Planning Office- Environmental and Social Experts, EEP, 2011

9. The World Bank Data Sheet -Ethiopia (2011)

10. The World Bank Operational Manual – Operational Directives (June 1990)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

98 | P a g e   

XIII. Annexes

Annex I: Summary of Baseline Survey of Affected Households

Woreda Name # of

Kebele # of HHs

Ave, Size of

HHs

Ave Age

of HHs

Male

Female

Elderly Female HHs

Children Children in school

(%)

Landless Squatter % of Christians

% of Musli

m

Tigray Alamata 2 2 9 20.1 12 5 0 0 10 90 0 0 100 0 Amhara(N.W) Harbu 4 5 5.4 38.5

17 10 3 1 11 81 1 0

0 100

Kobo 2 2 6 12 7 5 0 1 9 33 1 0 100

0

Gubalafto 1 2 6 22.5

3 8 0 1 4 75 2 0 36.6

63.6

Amhara(S.W) Wuchale 3 7 5

25.9 19

17 0 2 10 90 5 0 38.8

61.1

Kallu 3 5 5 29.6

12

13 1 0 9 66.6 3 0 0

100

Tewledere 1 1 6 Amhara(Oromo.S.Zone)

Jile Timuga 2 24 5 25 52 68 5 10 49 65.3 16 14 0 100

Artuma Fursi 1 2 6 27.75 7 5 2 1 5 60 2 0 0 100

Dachefa 1 1 7 14.7 3 4 0 1 6 66.6 1 0 0 100

Amhara(N.Shoa) Shoarobt city administration

2 94 4 25.24 185 191 14 34 163 71.9% 94 94 62%

38%

Debresina 7 9 4.5 22.5 14

27 2 2 24 75 1 2 95.1

4.8

Kwot 3 6 6 28.9 23 13 1 0 9 66.6 2 0 100

0

Oromia (Finfine Zuria)

Legetafo Legedadi

1 11 4 23.7 17 27 0 1 18 72.2 5 8 97.7

2.2

Legebolo Legeberi

2 5 5.4 24 11 16 0 2 19 57.8 0 0 100

0

Aleltu 1 1 6 16.5 4 2 0 0 4 25 1 0 100

0

Moye 1 2 8 20.8 7 9 0 0 12 66 0 0 100

0

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

99 | P a g e   

Annex II – List of Category I to V PAPs Table A: List of Category I PAPs

No. Name Zone Woreda/Kebel

Affected property

Reason for inclusion

Area /Qty

Remark

1 Ato Wodajo Kassaw

North Wollo

Guba Lafto 04/Doro Giber

House made with mud, wood and straw

Not included in the past compensation

18m2

2 W/ro Tiru Mekonen

North Wollo

Guba Lafto 04/Doro Giber

House made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof

New construction after the transmission line is constructed

25.42 m2 and 7.64 m2

Previous owner, Shibeshi Degu, received compensation for trees and sold the land for current owner, Tiru Mekonen,

3 W/ro Abebech Zewedu

North Wollo

Raya Kobo (Cheffa Robit) 012/Charo

House made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof

New construction after transmission tower mounted

31.62 m2

4 W/ro Tebiba Mohammed

North Wollo

Habru 06/Melheta

kitchen room made with wood and corrugated iron sheet roof

New construction after the transmission tower mounted

9.61m2 W/ro Tebiba Mohammed rented the kitchen to another person

5 W/ro Aregu Beshir

South Wollo

Ambasel/ Wuchale ketma 01/Awsedit

service room made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof

Not included in the past compensation

22.345m2 Possibly omitted due to the higher elevation between the house and the transmission line

6 Ato Abrha Abera Darge

South Wollo

Ambasel/ Wuchale ketma 05/ Abalebu

1. house made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof 2. Perennial plants Papaya Gravilia

Not included in the past compensation

30.74m2 1 15

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

100 | P a g e   

7 Ato Ali Ibrhaim Ali

South Wollo

Kalu/Choresa fontonina

Perennial plants (eucalyptus trees(mager)

Not compensated

97 piece The portion of land covered with eucalyptus trees was not compensated

8 Ato Imam Seied Hassen

South Wollo

Kalu 06/Kasele

1. house made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof 2. Perennial plants

Not included in the first compensation

22.89m2 30 piece

9 Ato Awol Umar Mohammed

Oromia Special Zone ( Amhara Region)

Jelie Tumuga Gerbi

house made with wood plastered with mortar and corrugated iron sheet roof

Not included in the past compensation

37.8m2 Service room was compensated, but family room was omitted from the compensation

10 W/ro Ashura Yusuf Mohammed

Oromia Special Zone ( Amhara Region)

Kemise/Dawa Chefa 03/Hijurota

Service room made with wood, mud and straw roof

Not included in the past compensation

12.9m2

11 Ato Yusuf Adam

Oromia Special Zone (Amhara Region

Artuma Fursii 01/Chefa Robit

1. Residential building made with wood, mud and plastered with mortar and corrugated iron sheet roof 2.Veranda

Not included in the first compensation

89.3025m 20.16m2

It was thought that the house was not under the right of way

12 W/ro Hawa Adam Afesa

Oromia Special Zone ( Amhara Region)

Artuma Fursii 01/Chefa Robit

1. House made with wood, mud and plastered with mortar and corrugated iron sheet roof with 2. Veranda

Not included in the first compensation

63.02m2 14.85

It was thought that the house was out of the range of the right of way

13 Ato WaldeMariam Mamo

North Showa

Debresina/Tarmaber Gudoberet

1. House made with wood and straw roof Manger

Not included in the past compensation

46.56m2 21.6 m2

Compensation paid only for trees the house is omitted from the compensation

14 Ato Demisse Shewaye

North Showa

Debresina/Tarmaber 01

1.House made with wood and

New construction

20.80m2 Newly constructed house sold to

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

101 | P a g e   

mud and corrugated iron sheet roof

after transmission tower construction

Babusha Tesema

15 Ato Hailu Areghagn

North Showa

Debresina/Tarmaber 01

1.Service room made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof 2. Kitchen room made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof 3.Veranda

Not included in the past compensation

23.63m2 6.58m2 10.4m2

16 W/ro Yimenashu Indris

North Showa

Tarmaber Asfachew

1. Residential house made of wood and straw roof 2. Perennial plants (Mango Acacia tree

Not included in the past compensation

20.42m2 1 piece ( mango) 9 piece ( trees)

17 W/ro Tigist Getachew

Finfinee Zuria Special Zone

Lagebolo 02/safera

1.Service room made with wood and corrugated iron sheet roof

New construction after transmission tower construction

8.94m2

Table B: List of Category II PAPs

No Name of PAP Zone Woreda & Kebele

Type of affected property

Land Holding Status

Reason for inclusion

Remark

1 Abrham Zegene

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Unfinished house made of wood & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated

New construction, HH lives nearby in a rental house.

2 Abayneh Basha

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated

3 Worku Lake N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron

Squatter Not compensated

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

102 | P a g e   

sheet 4 Mebrate

W/Michael N. Shoa Shoa Robit

K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

5 Hailu Atlaw N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

6 Mikiyas Getaneh

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

7 Yeteshawork Mamo

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

8 Emiyu Tatek N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence made of corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW, only the fence enters in to the ROW.

9 Zeleke Wube N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence made of corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

The house is out of the RO, only the fence that enters in to the ROW.

10 Fantaye Abera

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW, only the fence that enters in to the ROW.

11 Wondwossen Demisse

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW, only the fence that enters in to the ROW.

12 Seid Mohammed

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence & Kitchen made of wood, straw & grass

Squatter Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW, only the kitchen & fence that enters in to the ROW.

13 Mengesha Abayneh

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

14 Tekeda Ketema

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

15 Agonafir Deribe

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

16 Aysha N. Shoa Shoa Robit House made of Squatter Not

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

103 | P a g e   

Mohammed K/01 (Mariam sefer)

wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

compensated  

17 Etagegn Getahun

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

18 Jemanesh H/Mariam

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

19 Yiftusra Lakew

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

20 Shumye Getaneh

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Demolished house made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

No house found on the land except a fence & a tower. HH claims the house is demolished during tower erection.

21 Ahmed Oumer

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

22 Abegaz Yesouf

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter Not compensated  

23 Kelsum Hussien

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter  Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW, only the fence that enters in to the ROW.

24 Etagegn Zewdu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & plastic sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

25 Yilma Lake N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

26 Zemed Belay N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

27 Tefera Belete N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Demolished house made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

No house found on the land except a fence & a tower. HH claims house is demolished during tower erection.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

104 | P a g e   

28 Agate Zewde N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

29 Yeshihareg Kebede

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

30 Rukye Beshir N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter  Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW. It is only the fence that enters in to the ROW.

31 Fatuma Mussa

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

32 Adebebech Mulatu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

33 Sisha Metaferia

N. Shoa Shoa Robit K/01 (Mariam sefer)

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

34 Baye Asamnew

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01(Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

35 Fatimat Ahmed

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

36 Mahmud Seid

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw& grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

37 Showadenekesh Sahle

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw& grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

38 Sintayehu Meshesha

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

39 Negesse Debebe

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud &corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

105 | P a g e   

40 Wro Jember N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter  Not compensated  

No house found on the land

41 Abebe Tessema

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw& grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

42 Dawd Hassen

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

Kitchen made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW. It is only the kitchen that enters in to the ROW.

43 Teshome G/tsadik

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01(Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw& grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

44 Aminat Abdu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

45 Seid Mustefa N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

46 Awel Seid N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

47 Jemila Nuru N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

48 Ato Sultan N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

49 Yimenashu Hailu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

The house enters in to the ROW only for 2.7 meters (one house) but the house is big & has four rooms.

50 Emaw Wondimarzewal

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

51 Ato Zenebe N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter  Not compensated  

The house is out of the ROW. It is only

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

106 | P a g e   

the fence that enters in to the ROW.

52 Ayalnesh Moges

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

53 Dawd Abuye N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

54 Minda Bereded

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01(Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw & grass

Squatter  Not compensated  

55 Almaz Wube N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

56 Aysha Abuye N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01(Chereka Sefer

Residential house made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

57 Ferni Beredew

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

58 Yinebeb Balew

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01(Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

59 Kefelegn Hailu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

60 Hamza Mohammed

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

61 Mersha Zewge

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01(Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

62 Abdu Ahmed

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

107 | P a g e   

63 Aster Abebe N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

64 Seid Ali Yimer

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

65 Salih Ysha Siraj

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

66 Abebe Gizaw

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

67 Fatuma Muga

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

68 Dinber Yigezu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /01 (Chereka Sefer

Fence made of chefeka

Squatter  Not compensated  

Only the fence is within the ROW.

69 Mulugeta Belayneh

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

70 Sisay Tilahun N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

71 Sasaw Bizuwerk

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

72 Bezawerk Hailu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

73 Aysha Seid Shiek Oumer

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

74 Alye Shume N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

75 Dawd Amanu

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud &

Squatter  Not

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

108 | P a g e   

corrugated iron sheet

compensated  

76 Hailemeskel Haile

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

77 Ngatu Mekonen

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

78 Halim Nure N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

79 Nure Mohammed

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

80 Worku Molla N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

Residential house made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

81 Melese Tadesse

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud &corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

82 Tity Mohammed

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

Unfinished house made of wood & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

Unfinished and abandoned, HH lives neaby in a rental house.

83 Wossenyelesh Goshme

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

84 Kassa Masresha

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

85 Sikeberu Kibret

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

86 Awraris Desta

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

109 | P a g e   

87 Getenesh Wondimtegegn

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

88 Aregahegn Assefa

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

89 Abush Shewaferaw

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, straw & grass with plastic sheet roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

90 Abubeker Beshir

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

House made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

91 Awel Beshir N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer 

Residential house made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

92 Rahmet Ali N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04(Chereka Sefer

Residential house made of wood, mud & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

93 Derege H/Selassie

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka sefer

Unfinished house made of wood & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

Unfinished and abandoned.

94 Neighbor of Rahmet Ali

N. Shoa Shoa Robit /04 (Chereka Sefer

Unfinished house made of wood & corrugated iron sheet

Squatter  Not compensated  

Unfinished and abandoned.

95 Gebremariam Temesgen

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

House made with wood, mud and corrugated iron sheet roof Fence

Squatter  Not compensated  

PAP claims compensation paid only for perennial plants

96 Adugna Heirpo

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

Perennial plant

Squatter  Not compensated  

97 Abrham Mezgebu

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

Toilet made with plastic wall and corrugated

Squatter  Not compensated  

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

110 | P a g e   

iron sheet roof Fence

98 Dawit Lemma

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

1. Residential house made with concrete block and corrugated iron sheet roof 2. Perennial plants

Squatter  Not compensated  

99 Wendante Fantaye (previous owner Ato Tadesse Tufa)

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

1. Residential house made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof 2. Service room made with wood and corrugated iron sheet wall and roof 3. Service room made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof 4. Kitchen room made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof roof 5. Store room made with wood and corrugated iron sheet wall and open roof 6. Manger with corrugated iron sheet roof 7.Veranda work 8.Fence work in meters

Squatter  Not compensated  

AtoTadesse Tufa, previous owner, sold the house for WendanteFantaye, current occupant. Occupants didn’t know whether compensation paid or not

100 Muhedin kemeru

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

Perennial plants

Squatter  Not compensated  

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

111 | P a g e   

101 Grma Yifru

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

House made with wood and mud and straw roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

Compensated only for eucalyptus

102 Grma Yifru and W/ro Beletu Yifru

Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

House made with wood and mud and corrugated iron sheet roof with veranda and Fence

Squatter  Not compensated  

103 Lemma Yifru Finfine Zuria

Lagetafo 01/ Gewasa

House made with wood and mud and straw roof

Squatter  Not compensated  

Table C: List of Category III PAP

No.

Name of PAP Zone Woreda Town/ Kebelle

Asset Reason Occupied by PAP

Remark

1 Ato Molla Abeje

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

Bought plot from Mekonen Wolle, who was compensated for perennial trees on it.

2 Ato Asfaw Shimuye

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

>>

3 Ato Akele Damte

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

>>

4 W/ro Medina Teka

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

Medina was compensated for perennial trees but built house on the RoW & sold the remaining plot to Ato Amare Mola

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

112 | P a g e   

Table D: List of Category IV PAPs

5 Ato Amare Mola

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

6 Ato Hailu Mekonen

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

He built the house on a plot freed after compensation

7 Ato Birhanu Mola

South Wollo

Ambasel Wuchalle-Awsadit

House Built after cut-off date

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

113 | P a g e   

No. Name of PAP

Woreda Kebelle/village

Type of property affected

Reason Occupied by PAP

Type/Nature of complaint

Submission of complaint

North Wollo Zone

1 Shiferaw Abate

Habru Mersa 06 House Presence of unresolved issues.

Insufficient compensation

Filed formal complaint at local court and Woreda complaint hearing committee.

2 Mohamed Yimam

Habru Mersa 06 House Presence of unresolved issues.

Insufficient compensation

Filed formal complaint at the local court and Woreda complaint hearing committee

South Wollo Zone

3 Kedija Yasin Adem

Ambasel Wuchale / Melake 02

House Presence of unresolved Complaint

Insufficient compensation

Not collected compens.

4 Getahun Asfaw Ali

Ambasel Wuchale/Melake (02).

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Filed verbal complaint to local admin.

5 Ali Yasin Ambasel Wuchale/Melake (02)

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

6 Ahmed Yimer Yimam

Tehuledere

02 Dingay Mansha

Perennial trees (Eucalyptus)

Presence of unresolved complaint.

Compensation not paid

PAP collected compensation for house, not for tree.

6 Awel Ibrahim

Kalu Charisa -06

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

7 Indris Mohammed

Kalu Charisa - House The presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

Oromo Special Zone – Kemisse

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

114 | P a g e   

8 Zufan Mussa Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

9 Endris Hajji Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

10 Adem Alye Adem

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Goda Chele

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal omplaint to the local admin.

11 Alye Abdu Gunjo

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Koda Mereti

House Uncollected compensation

Covered in the past comp, not collected comp. H.H was out of the country.

12 Oumer Shie Alye Gunjo

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Koda Mereti

House Uncollected compensation

out of the country during comp disbursemen

13 Mohammed Adem

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Koda Mereti

House Uncollected compensation

out of the country during compens. disburseme.

14 Seid Yibre Indris

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved issues

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint at the local admin.

15 Emetu Abdela Hassen

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal compliant to the local admin.

16 Aminat Ali Muhe

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

17 Ansha Muhe Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filedverbal complaint to the local admin

18 Merima Habib

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

115 | P a g e   

19 Kedija Muhe Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

20 Oumer Indris

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

21 Oumer Indris & Mohammed Kemal

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House used as mosque

Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

22 Ali Seid Maeruf

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House

Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

23 Amina Oumer Abdi

Jile Timuga

Senbete/ Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

24 Aminat Yimer Gizaw

Jile Timuga

Senbete / Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Filed formal written complaint to the local court.

25 Aminat Abre Jile Timuga

Senbete / Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

26 Seid Mohammed

Jile Timuga

Senbete / Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

27 Mohammed Ali Muhe

Jile Timuga

Senbete / Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

28 Mohammed Ali Oumer

Jile Timuga

Senbete / Merewa

House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

North Shoa Zone

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

116 | P a g e   

Table E: List of Category V PAPs

29 Nigatu Kidane

Debresina Bakellu House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

30 Yitaferu Demisse

Kiwot

Firfir House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

claims replacement land offered is smaller than his original place

31 Degnetu Teshome

Tarmaber

Armania House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Filed verbal complant to the mayor of the woreda.

32 Zembalaw H/Selassie

Kwot / Shewarobit

04 House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Filed verbal complaint to the local admin.

Finfine Zuria Special Zone – Oromia

33 Brhanu Kebede

Legebolo Legeberi

Sefera - 02 House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Claims not received compensation for one house, but local authorities said the house is less than one meter. The complaint is verbal.

34 Kuba Abera Aleltu Tukuye House Presence of unresolved complaint.

Lack of replacement land

Verbal complaint filed to the local administration

35 Abebe Dube Moye Chole Serkole

House The presence of unresolved complaint.

Insufficient compensation

Compennsation paid for trees, but not for the house.

No. Name of Woreda Kebelle/ Type of Reason Occupie Abandoned Remark

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

117 | P a g e   

PAP Village property

d by PAP

Southern Tigray Zone 1 Adane

Chekol Alamata Rarih House Absence of

enforcement

2 Alemu Zegeye

Alamata Harle House Lack of enforcement

North Wollo Zone 3 Argaw Sisay Habru Menentera House Absence of

enforcement The head of the

H.H is an old blind man & he has no financial ability to demolish the house.

4 Mohammed Hassen

Habru Milhata House Absenceof enforcement

5 Amare Negash

Kobo Golisha (03kebele)

House Absence of enforcement

South Wollo Zone 6 Seid Ahmed Harbu/

Kallu Terefos House Absence of

enforcement

Oromo Special Zone – Kemisse 7 Hawa

Modeye Jile Timuga

Kade mereti (near senbete)

House Absence of enforcement

8 Adem Oumer,

Jile Timuga

Kade mereti (near Senbete)

House Absence of enforcement

9 Tuma Gidu, Jile Timuga

Kade mereti (near Senbete)

House Absence of enforcement

10 Ahmed Gelemso,

Jile Timuga

Kade mereti (near Senbete)

House Absence of enforcement

11 Dingo Mohammed

Jile Timuga

Kade mereti (near Senbete)

House Absence of enforcement

12 Zeineb Artuma Kade House Absence of

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

118 | P a g e   

Ahmed Fursi mereti (near Senbete)

enforcement

13 Betlu Abdela

Jile Timuga

Senbete House Absence of enforcement

The house is being demolished.

14 Hussein Ahmedu

Jile Timuga

Senbete House Absence of enforcement

North Shoa Zone 15 Lakech

Admasu Tarmaber

Keyit House Absnece of enforcement

The H.H claims that he was told by EEP staff to demolish only one of the houses from the four houses for which compensation was paid.

16 Eshete Negash

Tarmaber

Genete Washa/ Baso Dengora

House Absence of enforcement

17 Moges W/Meskel

Tarmaber

Ametsegna Ager

House Absence of enforcement

18 Laschalew Emishaw

Kwot Shoa Robit Kebele 08

House Absence of enforcement

19 Abe Zshoale Kwot Shoa Robit Kebele 08

House Absence of enforcement

20 Degu T/Haimanot

Tarmaber

Armania Absence of enforcement

HH claims that he was told by the EEP staff to demolish only one of the houses from the two that are found under the ROW.

21 Manaze Tadesse

Kwot 04 kebele House Absence of enforcement

22 Mamare Besemu

Gudo Beret

House Absence of enforcement

23 Shiferaw Genete House Absence of

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

119 | P a g e   

Habte Washa enforcement 24 T/Aregay

G/Tsadik Nifas

Mider House Absence of

enforcement

25 Wondwesen Negate

Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

26 Ato Tilahun Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

27 Ato Grim H/Michael

Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

Ato Grim rented the house after receiving compensation.

28 Ato Genet Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

Ato Genet rented the house after receiving compensation.

29 Memre Zewde

Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

Ato Memre rented the house after receiving compensation.

30 Ato Barium Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

Ato Barium rented the house after receiving compensation.

31 Asasahegn Tefera

Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

Ato Assasahegn rented the house after receiving compensation.

32 Wondemagegn Worku

Debresina

01 House Absence of enforcement

Ato Wondemagegn rented the house after receiving compensation.

33 Abebe Gebre

Debresina

Gelila House Absence of enforcement

34 Begashaw Deferes

Debresina

Gelila House Absence of enforcement

35 Wondimu Ayele

Debresina

Gelila House Absence of enforcement

36 Ketema Bekele

Debresina

Gelila House Absence of enforcement

37 Negash Belayneh

Tarmaber

Shola Meda

House Absence of enforcement

38 Ato Alemu Tarmaber

Chira Meda

House Absence of enforcement

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

120 | P a g e   

Annex – III: Minutes of Consultation

Consultation I - Senbete Town Public Consultative Meeting with Stakeholders and Affected parties

Date: April 3, 2015 Project: SIA /RAP Study for Stringing of Alamta – Kombolch II – legetafo Second Circuit 230kV Transmission Line

Location: Merewa Kebele Center, Senbete Town Zone/Woreda: Oromia Special Zone of Amhara Region, Jile Tumuga Woreda

UMeeting AttendeesU:

1. Ato Ahmed Mohamed Abdella, Lead Municpal Manager of Senbete Town 2. Ato Zeru Girmay, the Consulting Team Leader 3. Twenty eight (28) Project Affected Households, representatives to the local community and

other stakeholders ( Refer to attached signup sheet for names of attendees)

UPurpose of the Meeting:

The purpose of the meeting

a) To brief local residents and other stakeholders regarding the major components and description of the Stringing of Alamta-Kombolcha II- Legetafo 2 P

ndP Circuit 230kV Transmission Line Project

of the EEP

39 Abebe Yilma

Tarmaber

Asfachew House Absence of enforcement

40 Mamo Mekonen

Tarmaber

Asfachew House Absence of enforcement

41 Laschalew Emishaw

Tarmaber

Asfachew House Absence of enforcement

Finfine Special Zone – Oromia Region 42 Alemayehu

Tadesse Legetafo Legebolo

Legeberi House Absence of

enforcement

43 Jemanesh Tenkolu

Bereh Legeberi Sendafa03

House Absence of enforcement

44 Mengistu Shumu

Bereh Legeberi Sendafa03

House Absence of enforcement

45 Birhanu Bekele

Moye Chele Senkole

House Absence of enforcement

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

121 | P a g e   

b) To discuss the location of the line route and required ROW clearance width, its likely impact on household assets situated within the designated clearance area and the legal and administrative frameworks for compensations of affected assets.

c) To collect concerns and issues from affected households and other parties.

UBrief Summary of the Meeting U:

The consultation meeting was attended by more than 28 participants, representing affected households and other stakeholders from Senbete town.

The meeting started at 9:30 am, chaired by the Ato Zeru Girmay. Zeru welcomed all attendees and introduced himself as the lead consultant for SIA/RAP study of the project and Ato Ahmed Mohamed, the municipal manger and other participants. Zeru briefly discussed the purpose of the meeting and the agenda. He highlighted the primary objectives of the power stringing project, major components of the stringing construction activities, the transmission line route, anticipated positive and adverse impacts that will arise during construction and subsequent operation of the project. He also explained and described the type of properties that will be affected or required to be repositioned to give way for the string project activities. He clarified that the stringing project will not affect any farm land or business premises owned by local residents other than the properties situated within the newly designated 30 meters ROW. He discussed the legal and administrative guidelines and mechanisms of compensations for affected assets by the project.

Following Zeru’s brief introduction and presentation, Ato Ahmed Mohamed, the municipal manger, discussed why the transmission line ROW clearance requires evacuation of residents outside of the clearance area and some of the issues related with compensations and land allocation for relocations. He thanked participants for attending the meeting and encouraged them to actively participate in the discussions and to raise all issues and concerns that they may have regarding evacuation of the transmission line clearance area.

After Ato Ahmed’s brief presentation, the floor opened for the public to present their issues and concerns for discussion.

Several opinions, questions and comments were aired by participants. Some of the issues raised in the meeting include the following:

- PAPs asked that since the ROW is now reduced from 40 meters to 30 meters width, some of their properties that are beyond the 30 meters ROW should be spared from demolition and be given permission to repossess them.

- PAPs who were compensated during the first phase project implementation expressed their disappoint on the slow progress of the municipal office in providing replacement land after

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

122 | P a g e   

their properties were ordered to be demolished during installation and erection of power transmission towers.

- Some PAPs discussed because of delayed land allocations, the amount of compensations they collected two years ago may not fully cover the cost of labor and material to construct similar or better houses with the current escalated price levels. They requested the authorities to expedite land allocations and consider some kind of financial adjustments to offset for increased costs of constructions.

- PAPs also demanded expeditious resolution and settlement of past compensations complaints and grievances filed to local municipal courts and other offices.

The following is brief summary of the responses of Ato Ahmed Mohamed Abdella, the Municpal Manager, to PAPs questions and concerns:

- The municipal and Woreda level administration offices are working to identify lands within the town boundary to prepare and provide replacement lands for project affected people to build houses.

- Replacement land will be provided to eligible PAPs who were listed in the census/ asset inventory and promised during the compensation period and for those who have submitted formal requests within the cut-of-date. He also stated that the Municpal Office will not consider land allocations for PAPs who constructed residential dwellings within the ROW clearance area after installation of transmission towers.

Several similar questions regarding compensations, land allocations and grievance handling and management issues were raised by participants and sufficient explanation and answers were provided to PAPs by the Municpal Manager.

PAPs were provided additional explanations and clarifications for their various land allocations and compensations concerns and expressed satisfaction by the progress made on the meeting. The consultant read minutes of meeting to participants and asked their agreement. Participants through their local representatives expressed their agreement and signed on the minutes of the meeting. The meeting was concluded with a thank you note by the consultant at 12:30pm.

The following brief Amharic description of the Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 KV Alamta –Kombolcha II – Legetafo Power Transmission Line Project Activities was prepared and distributed to public consultation meeting participants in Senbete and Shoa Roabit towns

 

U              1    230          

           

U        

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

123 | P a g e   

         

             1    230                                 

          (Inter  Connected  System  (ICS) main  load  center)                 (system  stability)                                   ( )           

              458  .            20                  

     

                      

               

                   

         

      

                30                       

         

                                       

                       

Brief Description and Components of the Stringing of Almata-Kombloch II –Legetafo 2 P

ndP Circuit Power

Transmission Line Project (Prepared by the consultant for public consultation meeting)

The Stringing of Alamata –Kombolcha-Legetafo Second Circuit 230KV Transmission line construction project is to improve existing system stability and reliability of power services with power generated from Tekzie plant.

The transmission line passes through rural and urban areas to reach the main Interconnected System (ICS) load center in Akaki.

The total length of the reinforcement transmission line is 459 km, passing through10 Woreda towns and several rural settlements located in Tigray, Amhara, Oromia regions and one Sub city in Addis Ababa Administration.

Major advantages of the project

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

124 | P a g e   

- To reinforce existing power supply with power generated from Tekezie hydropower plant. - Expansion of power services will contribute to the national and local economic development - Expansion of power services will help to improve quality of life of citizens and provision of public

services Adverse impacts of the project

- The transmission requires 30 meters width or 15 meters clearance from each side of the center of the transmission line.

- The ROW clearance requires evacuation and clearance of residential houses and plant assets; this will affect a number of households currently occupying the designated ROW.

- Access roads to the tower will be required during the stringing and subsequent operation of the project. The access road is required to ensure the safe construction, maintenance and operation of the power line.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

125 | P a g e   

Minutes of Consultation Meeting of Senbete Town

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

126 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

127 | P a g e   

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

128 | P a g e   

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

129 | P a g e   

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

130 | P a g e   

Consultation II – Shoa Roabit Town Public Consultative Meeting with Stakeholders and Affected

parties

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

131 | P a g e   

Date: April 5, 2015 Project: SIA /RAP Study for Stringing of Alamta – Kombolcha II – Legetafo Second Circuit 230kV Transmission Line

Location: Shoa Roabit Administration Meeting Hall, Shoa Robit Town Zone/Woreda: North Shoa Zone of Amhara Region, Shoa Robit Woreda

UMeeting AttendeesU:

1. Ato Minale Meaza, Assistant City Manager, Shoa Robit Town 2. Ato Zeru Girmay, the Consulting Team Leader 3. Over 70 Project Affected Households currently residing in Kebele 04 & Kebele 01 local

administrations , representatives of the local community and other stakeholders ( Refer to attached sign-up sheet for names of attendee)

UPurpose of the Meeting:

The purpose of the meeting is

d) To brief local residents and other stakeholders regarding the major components and description of the Stringing of Alamta-Kombolcha II- Legetafo 2 P

ndP Circuit 230kV Transmission Line Project

of the EEP

e) To discuss the location of the line route and required ROW clearance width, its likely impact on household assets situated within the designated clearance area and the legal and administrative frameworks for compensations of affected assets.

f) To collect concerns and issues from affected households and other parties.

UBrief Summary of the Meeting U:

The consultation meeting was attended by more than 70 participants from Kebele 04 & Kebele 01 local administration representing affected households, most of who are informal settlers (squatter) who were excluded from past compensations schemes for lack of legal landholding rights and other stakeholders from Shoa Robit town.

The meeting started at 9:30 am. The meeting was chaired by the Ato Zeru Girmay, introduced himself as the lead consultant for SIA/RAP study of the project. He also introduced Ato Minale Meaza, Assistant City Manager, and other participants. Zeru began the meeting by thanking all who came to attend the consultation meeting and discussed the purpose of the meeting agenda by highlighting the primary objectives of the power stringing project, major components of the stringing construction activities, the transmission line route, anticipated positive and adverse impacts that will arise during construction and subsequent operation of the project.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

132 | P a g e   

He described the type of properties that will be affected or required to be repositioned due to the transmission line ROW clearance and to give way for the string project activities. He informed participants the stringing project will not affect any farm land or business premises owned by local residents other than residential properties and plant assets situated within the newly designated 30 meters ROW.

Zeru said according to the baseline survey and asset inventory findings carried by the SIA team, most of residential houses and plant assets situated within the 30 meter width ROW clearance area are occupied by informal settlers who were not covered and compensated for their targeted assets by the first phase project implementation phase due to issues related to legal landholding rights and other problems. He also said, under this assessment, regardless of their legal landholding status, all properties of PAPs currently situated within the ROW are registered and documented, assessed and valued for compensations in accordance to the national law on compensations, the ENREP – RPF and the World Bank involuntary resettlement guidelines, specifically OP4.12. He also explained the procedures and mechanisms for filing compensation related complaints and grievances by property owners and their right for fair hearing and expeditious resolution of complaints.

Following the brief introduction and presentation by the consultant, the floor was opened for discussion. Several opinions, questions and comments were aired by the participants. Some of the issues raised in the meeting include the following:

- A number of PAPs said they have been living in their current place of residence for the past 10 years or more by acquiring the land through informal transactions and arrangements from former owners. Therefore, they have legal claims for the land and deserve to be compensated fairly for their affected assets.

- Some of the PAPs also said even though they are aware of the danger of living under high tension transmission towers, they will remain living there until they are provided alternative land for construction of houses and fair and equitable compensations for their affected assets regardless of their legal landholding status as informal settlers ( squatters)

- If removal and evacuation from the designated ROW clearance area is unavoidable, they should be acknowledged and recognized as formal settlements and provided all available benefits and assistance in their relocation activities.

Ato Minale Meaza, Assistant City Manager, Shoa Robit Town provided the following explanations and clarifications for the questions and concerns raised by PAPs:

- The local administration acknowledges the problems and challenges facing informal settlers in Kebele 04 and Kebele 01 of the city and others who are currently occupying land within the transmission line clearance area.

- The city is exploring ways and means to address issues of illegal land occupants through local land development plans and policy approaches.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

133 | P a g e   

- All registered concerns and issues of PAPs presented in this consultation meeting will be addressed and resolved in the near future through a pragmatic approach of developing viable housing development strategy that will be inclusive of all local residents who are likely to be affected by the power transmission line project and others who seek plots for construction of residential dwellings.

- The Assistant City Manager also informed and assured PAPs that they will be compensated for their affected assets based on applicable national laws. Their affected properties will be fairy assessed and estimated based on and according to established asset valuation rates and guidelines.

Several similar questions regarding compensations, land allocations and grievance handling and management issues were raised by participants and sufficient explanation and answers were provided to PAPs by the Assistant City Manager.

PAPs were provided additional explanations and clarifications for their various land allocations and compensations concerns; expressed satisfaction how their issues and concerns are received and handled by the city officials and the consultation forum organizers. Prior to adjourning the meeting, the consultant read minutes of meeting to participants and asked their agreement. Participants through their local representatives expressed their full agreement and signed on the minutes of the meeting. The meeting was adjourned at 1:30pm.

 

 

 

 

 

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

134 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

135 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

136 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

137 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

138 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

139 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

140 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

141 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

142 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

143 | P a g e   

Annex IV: Kalu Woreda Asset Valuation Guidelines &Rates

 

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

144 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

145 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

146 | P a g e     

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

147 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

148 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

149 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

150 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

151 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

152 | P a g e   

Annex V: Estimated Monetary Value of Affected Assets (Based on Current Prices) Survey # 1 Ato Wodajo Kassaw Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Wollo Woreda/ City: Guba Lafto Kebele/Village: 04/Doro Giber Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty.

(m2)

Unit Rate

(Birr/m2)

Total

(Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, plastered wall with mud mortar and straw roof

2. Demolition cost

3. Mobilization/transportation cost

Total proposed compensation

1 18 650 11,700.00

200.00

200.00

12,100.00

Survey # 2 W/o Turu Mekonnen Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Wollo Woreda/ City: Guba Lafto Kebele/Village: 04/Doro Giber

Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (mP

2P)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, wall plastered with mud mortar with corrugated sheet metal roof, cotton and plastic sheet ceiling, metal doors and windows (with grills where glazed)

2 25.42 1, 690 42, 959.8

2. Kitchen made of wood structure, plastered with mud mortar straw roof 3.Demolition or removal cost 4.Mobilization /Transportation cost Total compensation

2 7.64 350 2674 800 600 47,033.80

Survey # 3 W/o Abebech Zewdu Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Wollo Woreda/ City: Raya/Kobo (Cheffa Robit) Kebele/Village: 012/Charo Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

153 | P a g e   

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, wall plastered with mud mortar, corrugated sheet metal roof, cotton and plastic sheet ceiling, metal doors and windows (with grills where glazed) 2.Demolition /removal cost 3. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation

2 31.62 1690 53, 437.8 600 400 54,437.80

Survey # 4 W/o Tibeba Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Wollo Woreda/ City: Harbu Kebele/Village: 06/Melheta Description of Affected Property CLAS

S

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential housing made of wood structure, plastered with mud mortar, corrugated sheet metal roof and wood door 2. Demolition or removal cost 3. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation

5 9.61 500 4805 400 400 5,605

Survey # 5 W/o Aregu Beshir Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: South Wollo Woreda/ City: Ambasel/Wuchale Kebele/Village: 01/Awsedit Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, internal wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal roof and door 2. Demolition /removal cost 3. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed composition

5 22.345 950 21,227.75 600 400 22,227.75

Survey # 6 Ato Abraha Abera Darge Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: South Wollo Woreda/ City: Ambasel/Wuchale Kebele/Village: 05/Aalebu Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

UNIT PRICE (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

154 | P a g e   

1. Residential house made of wood structure, internal and external wall plastered with mud mortar, corrugated sheet metal roof and wood door and window

4 30.74 1470 49, 017.15

2. Perennial plants Papaya Grabilia 3. Removal/Demolition cost 4. Transportation cost Total proposed compensation

1 15

85 100

85 1,500 600 400 51,602.15

Survey # 7 Ato Ali Ibrahim Ali Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: South Wollo Woreda/ City: Kalu Kebele/Village: Choresa Fotonina Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty.(Piece)

Unit Rate(Birr/piece)

Total(Birr)

1.Perennial plants, eucalyptus tree (Mager) 2. Removal/ Demolition cost 3. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation

97

60

58 20 100 100 6,020

Survey # 8 Ato Imam Seid Hassen Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: South Wollo Woreda/ City: Kalu Kebele/Village: 06/Kasele Type and Description of Affected Property CLASS

Qty. (m2)

UNIT PRICE (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, mud wall and straw roof

1 22.89 650 14878.5

2. Perennial plants Eucalyptus tree 3. Removal/Demolition cost 4. Transportation cost Total Proposed compensation

30

50

1500 400 400 17,178.50

Remark: Ato Ahmed Yimer Imam is covered under the compensation scheme of the first phase of the project. Therefore he is eliminated from this report (schedule 1)

Survey # 9 Ato Awol Umar Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: Oromia Special Zone Woreda/ City: Jelie Tumuga Kebele/Village: Gurbi

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

155 | P a g e   

Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty.(m2 )

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total(Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, external wall plastered with cement mortar, corrugated sheet metal roof, cotton fabric and plastic sheet ceiling, mud floor and corrugated sheet metal door and window 2.Demolition/Removal cost 3. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total Proposed compensation

3 37.8 1785 67473 700 400 68,573

Survey # 10 W/o Ashura Yusuf Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: Oromia Special Zone Woreda/ City: Kemmissie Kebele/Village: 03/Hijurota Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, only internal wall plastered with mud, straw and plastic roof, mud floor and wood door 2. Demolition /removal cost 3. Mobilization /Transportation cost Total proposed compensation

5

12.9

950

12, 255 400 400 13,055

Survey # 11 Ato Yusuf Adam Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: Oromia Special Zone Woreda/ City: Artuna Farsi Kebele/Village: 01/Chefa Robit Type and Description of Affected Properties S

CLASS

Qty or (mP

2P)

Unit rate Total (Birr)

1. Residential housing made of wood structure, masonry foundation, internal and external wall plastered with cement mortar, corrugated sheet metal roof, cotton rug and chip wood ceiling, and concrete slab floor. 2. Veranda(Patio) Concrete floor slab with stairs and hand rail Corrugated sheet metal roof 3. Removal/Demolition cost 4. Transportation cost Total proposed compensation

1 1

89.3025 20.16

2275 1272

203163.19 25, 643.52 1200 800 230,806.71

Survey # 12 W/o Hawa Adam Asefa Region: Amhara National Regional State

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

156 | P a g e   

Zone: Oromia Special Zone Woreda/ City: Artuma Farsi Kebele/Village: 01/Chefa Robit Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, external wall plastered with cement mortar, mud and mortar plastered wall and a corrugated sheet metal roof, concrete slab floor, cotton rug and plastic sheet ceiling, metal window and door panels. 2. Veranda Concrete floor slab with stairs and hand rail Corrugated sheet metal roof Removal/ Demolition cost . Mobilization and Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

1 1

63.02 14.85

2275 1272

143, 370.5 18,889.2 1200 800 164, 259.70

Survey # 13 Ato Woldemariam Mamo Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Shoa Woreda/ City: Debresina/Tarmaber Kebele/Village: Gundoberet

Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, internal and external wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal roof and door and window made of wood 2. Fence/Manger 3. Removal/Demolition cost Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

5 46.56 21.6

950 280

44,232 6, 048 800 600 51,680

Survey # 14 Ato Demssie Shewayne Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Shoa Woreda/ City: Debresina/Tarmaber Kebele/Village: Kebele 01 Type and description of Affected Property CLAS

S

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, internal wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal iron roof, metal door panel and mud floor 2. Demolition cost 3. Removal/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

4 20.8 1470 30,576 400 400 31,376

Survey # 15 Ato Hailu Areghan Region: Amhara National Regional State

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

157 | P a g e   

Zone: North Shoa Woreda/ City: Debresina/Tarmaber Kebele/Village: Kebele 01 Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Service quarter /room made of wood structure, internal wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal roof and door, window covered with plastic sheet and concrete slab floor 2. Kitchen room made of wood structure, internal wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal roof and mud floor 3. Veranda work Concrete floor slab with stairs and hand rail Corrugated sheet metal roof 4. Removal /Demolition cost 5, Mobilization/ Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

4 5 2

23.63 6.58 10.4

1470 950 884

34,728.75 6251 9,193.6 1000 800 51, 973.35

Survey # 16 W/o Yimegnush Idris Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Shoa Woreda/ City: Debresina/Tarmaber Kebele/Village: Asfachew Type and description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2), piece

Unit Rate (Birr/m2), (Birr/piece)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, wall plastered with mud and straw roof

1 20.42 650 13, 273.00

2. Perennial plants Mango plant Acacia tree 3. Removal/Demolition cost 4. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

1 9

800 20

800 180 600 400 15,253

Survey # 17 W/O Tigist Getachew Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 02/Sefera

Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

158 | P a g e   

1. Residential house made of wood structure without plastering and wood panel door 2. Removal/Demolition cost 3. Mobilization /Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

5 8.94 500 4470 400 400 5,270

Survey # 18 Ato Gebremariam Temesgen Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa

Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, internal wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal roof and mud floor 2. Fence made of corrugated sheet metal 3. Removal/Demolition cost 4. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

4 17.92 5

1470 210

26342.4 1050 400 400 28,192.40

Survey # 19 Ato Adugna Heipro Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (Piece)

Unit Rate (Birr/piece)

Total (Birr)

1. Perennial plants Eucalyptus tree (Aweraj) Eucalyptus tree (Mager) Eucalyptus branch (chefeqa) 2. Fence work in meter Corrugated iron sheet 3. Removal/Demolition cost 4. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

4 4 38 28.9

60 50 10 210

240 200 380 6,069 200 200 7,189

Survey # 20 Ato Abraham Mezgebu Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Toilet/ septic tank with wood platform and wall covered with plastic sheet and corrugated sheet metal roof 2. Fence made of corrugated sheet metal 3. Removal/Demolition cost

3 1

2.31 30

651 210

1503.81 6300 200

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

159 | P a g e   

4. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

200 8,203.81

Survey # 21 Ato Dawit Lemma Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa DESCRIPTION

CLASS

Qty.

(m2)

Unit Rate

(Birr/m2)

Total

(Birr)

1. Residential housing made of concrete block with corrugated sheet metal roof, masonry foundation, chip wood ceiling, internal and external wall plastered with cement mortar, painted metal door and window panels, concrete slab floor 2. Perennial plants (in piece) Eucalyptus tree (mager) Eucalyptus tree (chefeqa) 3. Fence work in meters (wood) 4. Removal/Demolition cost 5. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

1 38.06 15 77 93

2600 50 10 130

98962.5 750 770 12,090 1000 800 114,372.5

Survey # 22 Ato Wondante Fantaye Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa (Previous owner Ato Tadesse Tufa) DESCRIPTION

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

UNIT PRICE (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, corrugated sheet metal roof, chip wood ceiling, internal and external wall plastered with mud and painted, metal doors and windows and concrete slab floor 2. Service quarter/ room made of wood structure, corrugated sheet metal wall, roof and door

1 3

39.4 15.91

1755 674

69,147 10,723.34

3. Service room made of wood structure, corrugated sheet metal roof, internal and external wall plastered with mud, wood panel door and concrete slab floor 4.Kitchen room made of wood structure, corrugated sheet metal roof, internal and external wall plastered with mud, wood door panel

3 4

13.125 13.125

1625 1470

21,328.125 19,293.75

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

160 | P a g e   

5. Store room made of wood structure, corrugated sheet metal wall, open roof 6. Manger with corrugated iron sheet roof 7. Veranda work Concrete floor slab 8. Fence work in meters Made with corrugated iron sheet Removal /Demolition cost Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

3 3

15 9.675 43.75 86.2

674 200 200 210

10110 1935 8750 18102 2400 2000 163,789.215

Survey # 23 Ato Muhedin Kemeru Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa DESCRIPTION

CLASS

Qty. (Piece)

Unit Rate (Birr/piece)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants Eucalyptus plant (chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

6

10

60 100 100 260.00

Survey # 24 Ato Girma Yifru Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, internal wall plastered with mud wall, straw roof, wood door panel, mud floor 2. Removal/Demolition cost 3. Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

1

30.49

750

22867.5 600 400 23,867.50

Survey # 25 Ato Girma Yifru & W/O Beletu Yifru Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa Type and Description of Affected Property

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

161 | P a g e   

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, internal and external wall plastered with mud, corrugated sheet metal roof, wood panel door and mud floor 2. Veranda work Made of stone 3. Fence work Made with stone and (chefeqa) in meters 4. Removal/Demolition cost 5. Mobilization/Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

1 3

32.2 8.625 70

1470 627 55

47, 334 5407.88 3850 800 600 57,991.88

Survey # 26 Ato Lema Yifru Region: Oromia National Regional State Zone: Finfine Zuria Special Zone Woreda/ City: Legetafo-Legebolo Kebele/Village: Kebele 01/Gewasa DESCRIPTION

CLASS

Qty. (m2)

UNIT PRICE (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1. Residential house made of wood structure, masonry foundation, internal wall plastered with mud wall, straw roof, wood panel door and mud floor 2. Removal/Demolition cost 3. Mobilization/ Transportation cost Total proposed compensation amount

1

22.8

750

17,100 400 400 17,900

Survey # 27 Ato Worku Laake Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North showa Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebelle/Village Name: 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr

1. Residential house made with wood and mud wall with corrugated sheet metal roof, plastic sheet ceiling, plastered internal and external wall, masonry foundation, metal window and doors 2. Perennial plants (in piece) 3. Fence made of Aydarke (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Moving Cost Total compensation

2 25.915 1 7

1690 75 55

43796.35 75 385 1000 600 45, 861

Survey # 28 Ato Hailu Atalew Region: Amhara National Regional State Zone: North Shoa Woreda/City: Kiwet / Shoa Robit Kebelle/Village Name: 01

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

162 | P a g e   

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

1.House made of wood and mud wall with corrugated sheet metal roof, no ceiling internal and external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, mud floor 2.Kitchen made of wood (chefeqa) and corrugated sheet metal roof, wall not plastered and window and doors no plastering, uninstalled doors and windows 3.Fence made of Aydarke (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Moving expenses Total

3 36 13.97 24.1

1625 280 55

58500 3911.6 1325.5 1000 600 65,337.10

Survey # 29 Ato Abrham Zagene Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / Shoa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof No ceiling Wood wall Masonry work under the walls No doors and windows Fence work in meters(Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5 18.5 73.3

950 55

17575 4031.5 700 400 22,706.50

Survey # 30 Ato Mickayas Getaneh Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / Shoa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

163 | P a g e   

1.Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, un plastered external wall , masonry work under the walls timber doors and windows ,mud floor 2.Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 36.8 26

1470 55

54096 1430 1000 600 57,126

Survey # 31 W/ro Emiyu Tateke Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Fence made of Aydarke (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

12.7 55

698.5 100 100 898.50

Survey # 32 ` W/o Yeteshawork Mamo Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling Internal wall plastered and painted Masonry foundation Metal doors and windows Mud floor 2, Fence in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 14 32.1

1690 55

23660 1765.5 700 400 26,525.50

Survey # 33 Ato Seid Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

164 | P a g e   

Kitchen made of straw, Chefeqa and Plastic (canvas) roof No plastering Door made of corrugated iron sheet Mud floor Masonry foundation u Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium-big size) Fence work in meters Made with Aydarke (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

6.25 3 23.4

650 75 55

4062.5 225 1287 400 400 6374.50

Survey # 34 Ato Wondwossen Demassie Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium-big size) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 1 19

75 55 55

150 55 1045 100 100 1450

Survey # 35 Ato Fantaye Abera Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1 2 18.6

150 55 55

150 110 1023 100 100 1483

Survey # 36 Ato Abayneh Basha Region: Amhara National Regional State

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

165 | P a g e   

Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof No ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud Unplastered externally wall Masonry work under the walls Metal and corrugated iron sheet doors and windows Mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 28.43 9

1470 55

41788.425 495 1000 600 43,883.42

Survey #37 Ato Mebrate W/Michael Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof No ceiling mud plastered internal wall, unplaster external wall,, masonry foundation, corrugated sheet metal door and window Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature and started to produce fruit Casmir (medium size) Wanza Kundo Barbare Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 23.115 1 1 1 2 32

1470 300 50 10 5 55

33979.05 300 50 10 10 1760 1000 600 37,709.05

Survey # 38 Ato Zeleke Wube Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

166 | P a g e   

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1 1 11.3

55 35 55

55 35 621.5 100 100 911.50

Survey # 39 Ato Mengesha Abayneh Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof No ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud Externally plastered with mud Masonry work under the walls Metal doors and windows Mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Made with corrugated iron sheet Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3 49.45 2 1 30.2 8.2

1625 150 10 55 210

80356.25 300 10 1661 1722 1000 600 85,649.25

Survey # 40 Ato Takede ketema Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, plastic ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud and painted, Unplastered external wall, masonry foundation metal doors and windows mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 16.65 1

1690 150

28138.5 150 700 400 29,388.50

Survey # 41 Ato Agonafer Derbe Region: Amhara National Regional State

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

167 | P a g e   

Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, internal wall plastered with mud and painted, external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows and mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (chegegn ) Diredawa (big size) Papaya (mature and started to produce fruit) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 44.13 1 1 1 7 57.7

1690 150 10 500 300 55

74579.7 150 10 500 2100 3173.5 1000 600 82,113.20

Survey # 42 W/ro Aisha Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

168 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud and painted, External wall plastered with mud , masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet doors and windows , concrete slab floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Moringa (small size) Nim Diredawa Eucalyptus (medium-small size) Eucalyptus (very small size ) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

14 3 1 1 2 7 9 24.7

1690 150 100 80 150 60 10 55

23660 450 100 80 300 420 90 1358.5 700 400 27,558.50

Survey # 43 W/o Etagegne Getahun Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof,2 rooms Canvas ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud and painted, external wall plastered with mortar, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor Service room made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, single room, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, internal and external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door and timber window, mud floor Cage (chicken house) made with steel wire, wood and corrugated iron sheet roof , single room, Steel wire wall, corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants Kasale (big size) Nim (big size) Nim (very small size) Papaya (started to produce fruit) Diredawa (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa)

1 4 3

34.34 19.17 9.84 1 1 1 2 2

2275 1470 674 150 400 10 300 100

78123.5 28179.9 6632.16 150 400 10 600 200

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

169 | P a g e   

Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

29

55 1595 1200 800 117,890.56

Survey # 44 W/o Shumye Getaneh Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Fence work in meters(Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

17 55 935 100 100 1135.00

Survey # 45 W/o Jemanesh Habtemariam Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01 Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, unplaster External wall, masonry foundation, corrugated sheet door, window covered with plastic sheet , mud floor , open roof room made with corrugated iron sheet Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 13.23 8 7 20

1470 210 150 55

19448.1 1680 1050 1100 700 400 24,378.1

Survey # 46 W/o Kalsum Hussein Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

170 | P a g e   

Perennial plants in piece - Kasale (small size) - Diredawa (small size) Fence made with Aydarke (Chefeqa) Demolition Transportation Total

1 1 1.5m

55 100 55

55 100 82.50 100 100 437.50

Survey # 47 Ato Tefera Belete Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Fence made with Aydarke (Chefeqa)

20m

55

1300

Survey # 48 Ato Ahmedu Umar Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof,3 rooms Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud and painted, external plastered with mud, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling, mud floor, Internal wall partially plastered with mud Unplaster external wall, corrugated iron sheet door and window Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Moringa (big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 5

46.2 14.46 1 1 31

1690 950 150 300 55

78078 13739.375 150 300 1705 1200 800 95,972.37

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

171 | P a g e   

Survey # 49 Ato Yiftusera Lake Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, 3 rooms Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling , Internal wall plastered with mud and painted, external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor, Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling. mud floor Partial plastered wall with mud, corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Diredawa (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 5

27.6 5.76 1 23.2

1690 950 300 55

46644 5472 300 1276 1200 800 55,692

Survey # 50 Ato Yilma Lake Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof,2 rooms, no ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 32.035 5

1470 150

47091.45 750 1000 600 49,441.45

Survey # 51 W/o Etagegne Zewdie

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

172 | P a g e   

Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall, no masonry foundation, Corrugated iron sheet door , Mud floor Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5 18

950

17100 700 400 18,200

Survey # 52 Ato Abegaz Yusuf Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof,5 rooms Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud and painted, Unplastered external wall masonry foundation, metal doors and windows ,mud floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and plastic roof, no ceiling, mud floor Partial wall plastered with mud, Corrugated iron sheet door, Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Made with corrugated iron sheet Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 5

51.025 6.5025 11.7 5.5

1690 650 55 210

86232.25 4226.625 643.5 1155 1200 800 94,257.37

Survey # 53 Ato Zemedie Belay Region: Amhara National Regional State

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

173 | P a g e   

Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Service room made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, partial plastered external wall with mud, masonry foundation, Corrugated iron sheet doors and windows ,mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature ) Papaya (very small size) Banana (mature ) Banana (very small size) Mango (medium size) Mango (very small size) Lemon (medium size) Lemon (very small size) Casmir (very small size) Fence work in meters Made with corrugated iron sheet Demolition cost Transportation cost Total Remark – Only partial of the property is affected

3 14.6 1 10 7 8 2 1 1 1 1 1.8

1625 300 5 280 13 800 50 350 15 25 210

23725 300 50 1960 104 1600 50 350 15 25 378 700 400 29,657

Survey # 54 W/o Erkuye Beshir Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Eucalyptus (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 2 34.5

55 5 55

220 10 1897.5 100 100 2327.50

Survey # 55 W/o Yeshareg Kebede

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

174 | P a g e   

Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, two rooms Cotton rug ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall plastered with mud masonry foundation, Steel plate doors and windows, concrete slab floor Service room made with wood and mud wall , corrugated iron sheet roof, has bathroom and toilet, no ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, unplaster external wall, masonry foundation, Steel plate door and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with corrugated iron sheet wall and roof, mud floor corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature fruit) Papaya (very small size) Bisana (medium size) Diredawa (medium-big size) Diredawa (medium size) Eucalypts (medium) Shiewshwa (very small size) Kasale (big size) Kasale (medium size) Fence made with corrugated iron sheet Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1 3 3

24.225 13.75 5.5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 17.2

1755 1625 674 300 50 50 300 150 50 5 150 55 210

42514.875 22343.75 3707 300 50 50 300 150 50 5 150 55 3612 1200 800 75,287.62

Survey # 56 Ato Agete Zewdie Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud, wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, has two rooms, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling Internal wall

2 29.7975

1690

50357.775

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

175 | P a g e   

plastered with mud and painted, Unplastered external wall, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows ,mud floor Demolition cost Transportation cost Total Only plants are affected by the clearance

600 400 51,357.78

Survey # 57 W/o Fatuma Musa Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, plastered and painted internal wall, unplaster external wall, masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet doors and windows, mud floor Service room made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 rooms Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall, masonry foundation, Corrugated iron sheet doors and windows, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature ) Mango (mature fruit) Mango (medium size) Lemon (medium size) Coffee (medium size) Eucalypts (medium) Nim (big size) Nim (medium size) Nim (small size) Diredawa (big size) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 3

11.16 33.75 4 2 1 1 1 2 2 1 2 1 4 73.8

1690 1625 300 3500 800 350 58 50 300 150 75 500 150 55

18860.4 54843.75 1200 7000 800 350 58 100 600 150 150 150 600 4059 1200 800 90,921.15

Survey # 58 W/o Adabebech Mulatu

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

176 | P a g e   

Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud, wall and corrugated iron sheet roof,2 rooms Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, external plastered wall with mud, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with wood (chefeqa) wall and ,canvas roof, no ceiling, mud floor ,corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

30.6 6.16 1 2 6 51.5

1690 350 200 55 10 55

51714 2156 200 110 60 2832.5 1200 800 59,072.50

Survey # 59 Ato Sisha Metaferia Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

177 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered and painted, external plastered wall with mud, masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door and window, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Diredawa (big size) Kasale (medium size) Eucalyptus (medium size) Gamme (very small size) Kurkura (small size) Acacia (Girar small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

15.17 4 2 1 2 1 1 53

1625 500 55 50 10 15 10 55

24651.25 2000 110 50 20 15 10 2915 600 400 30,771.25

Survey # 60 Ato Baye Asamnew Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, unplaster external wall masonry foundation, metal door and windows mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Diredawa (small size) Kasale (medium-big size) Kasale (very small size) Kundo Barbare (medium size) Acacia (Girar small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

20.52 1 1 1 1 2 7.4

1690 100 200 10 50 5 55

34678.8 100 200 10 50 10 407 600 400 36,455.8

Survey # 61 W/o Fatuma Ahmed Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

178 | P a g e   

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud, wall and corrugated iron sheet roof Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud , unplaster external wall, masonry foundation, timber door, mud floor Kitchen made with wood (chefeqa) wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, mud floor, corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium-big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

16.2 5.75 2 9.4

1470 350 150 55

23814 2012.5 300 517 800 400 27,843.50

Survey # 62 W/o Shewadegesh Sahle Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall , corrugated iron sheet roof, two rooms, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, unplaster External wall, no masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

22.04 6.3

1670 55

32398.8 346.5 400 400 33,545.30

Survey # 63 Ato Mohamed Mohammed Seid Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

179 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered and painted with gypsum, unplaster external, no masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door , mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kurkura (medium size) Eucalyptus (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

16.9725 1 1 34.25

1470 50 10 55

24,949.575 50 10 1883.75 400 400 27,893.33

Survey # 64 Ato Abebe Tesema Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

180 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud , unplaster External wall, masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door , mud floor Kitchen made with wood (chefeqa) wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, mud floor Corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Eucalyptus (medium size) Eucalyptus (small size) Kasale (big-medium size) Kasale (medium size) Papaya (mature and started to produce fruit) Papaya (medium size) Gamme (medium size) Dammakasse (small size) Diredawa (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

16.2 7.81 1 2 7 5 2 3 1 1 7 65.6

1470 350 50 10 150 75 300 85 50 60 100 55

23814 2733.5 50 10 1050 75 600 255 50 60 700 3608 800 400 34,205.50

Survey # 65 Ato Dawud Hassen Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Kitchen made with wood (chefeqa) wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, no masonry foundation, Internal wall plastered with mud, mud floor ,corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (small size) Kurkura (medium-small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total Remark: only some portion of the properties are within the ROW

5

10.2375 3 1 2 6

950 200 20 50 55

9725.625 600 20 100 330 400 400 11,575

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

181 | P a g e   

Survey # 66 W/o Jember Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1 4 7.1

55 35 55

55 140 390.5 100 100 785.50

Remark: The owner of the house claims that her house was destroyed during the erection of the tower. remnants of her property registered during the survey is considered for valuation

Survey # 67 W/ro Sentayehu Meshesha Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, two rooms, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, un plastered external wall, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor Room made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, un plastered external wall, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 3

37.38 18.06 1 1

1690 1625 75 35

63172.2 29347.5 75 35 1200 800 94,629.70

Survey # 68 Ato Negasie Debebe Region: Amhara National Regional State

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

182 | P a g e   

Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall plastered with mud masonry foundation, metal door and window concrete slab floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and, corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling, mud floor corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1

16.34 7.84 1 2 34

1755 950 150 20 55

28676.7 7448 150 40 1870 800 400 39,384.70

Survey # 69 Ato Teshome Gebretsadik Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / Showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

House made with wood and mud wall, canvas roof, no ceiling ,Internal wall plastered with mud, un plastered external wall, masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall, canvas roof, no ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, mud floor, corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature & producing) Kasale (big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 5

18.15 5.4 2 1 24.3

1470 950 300 200 55

26680.5 5130 600 200 1336.5 400 400 34,747

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

183 | P a g e   

Survey # 70 W/ro Aminat Abdu Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / Showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered and painted, un plastered external wall, masonry foundation work, metal door and window, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and, canvas roof, no ceiling, mud floor, no door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

12 8 6 1 44.2

1625 350 55 20 55

19500 2800 330 20 2431 600 400 23,650

Survey # 71 Ato Seid Mustefa Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation, metal door and window, concrete slab floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, mud floor ,no door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium-small size) Kurkura (medium-small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

29.32 7.68 2 1 43

1690 350 35 15 55

49550.8 2688 70 15 2365 600 400 53,000.80

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

184 | P a g e   

Survey # 72 Ato Awol Seid Haji Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and straw roof, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling Internally plastered with mud, unplaster external wall masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature Kasale (big size) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

19.72 1 1 2 47.6

950 600 200 55 55

12818 600 200 110 2618 400 400 17,146

Survey # 73 W/t Jemila Nuru Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internally partially plastered, Unplastered external wall Masonry work under the walls corrugated iron sheet door/ window ,mud floor Unfinished house (under construction) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

13.26 12.56 11

1470 200 55

19492.2 2512.605 605 400 400 23,412.70

Survey # 74 Ato Sultan Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

185 | P a g e   

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internally partially plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall masonry foundation, metal door and windows ,mud floor Unfinished house (under construction) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

25.2 8.82 50.6

1470 950 55

37044 8379 2783 700 400 49,306

Survey # 75 W/o Yemnashu Hailu Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood, mud and cement mortar wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 4 rooms. Plastic (PP bag) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted external wall plastered with mortar, masonry foundation work ,steel plate doors and windows, concrete slab floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, Internal wall plastered with mud mud floor corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Kurkura (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1 5

62.18 13.46 1 1 2 1 30.4

1755 950 200 55 20 10 55

109125.9 12787 200 55 40 10 1672 1200 800 125,889.90

Remark: The main house is in the ROW 2.7m from one end; partially affected properties include kitchen and two rooms from the main house.

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

186 | P a g e   

Survey # 76 W/o Emaw Wondemarzawe Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and straw (canvas) roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall, no masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium-big size) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5

14.24 1 1 40

950 75 55 55

13528 75 55 2200 400 400 16,658

Survey # 77 Ato Zenebe Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total Remark – Only perennial plant and fence are within the ROW

1 19.5

55 55

55 1072.5 100 100 1327.50

Survey # 78 W/o Alaynesh Moges Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

187 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling internal wall plastered and painted , Plastered external wall with mud masonry foundation metal door and window, concrete slab floor Perennial plants (in piece) Banana (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

27.18 4 50

1690 15 55

45934.2 15 2750 600 400 49,699.20

Survey # 79 Ato Dawud Aboye Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 3 rooms, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall partially plastered wall with mortar, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor, Service room made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling , Internal wall plastered with mud. Un plastered external wall, masonry foundation, metal doors and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, Internal wall plastered with mud mud floor, corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature to produce fruit) Papaya (very small size) Mango (very small size) Banana (medium size) Banana (Very small size) Trengo (Very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost

2 3

28.69 12.71 7.56 2 2 1 2 3 1 33.7

1982 1625 650 300 5 50 120 13 25 55

56863.58 20653.75 4914 600 10 50 240 39 25 1853.5 1200

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

188 | P a g e   

Transportation cost Total

800 87,248.83

Survey # 80 W/o Aysha Aboye Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made of wood and mud canvas roof, no ceiling, plastered internal wall with mud , Un plastered external wall ,masonry foundation , Corrugated iron sheet door mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

8.5 3 34.2

950 55 55

8075 165 1881 400 400 10,921

Survey # 81 W/o Minda Braded Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and straw roof, no ceiling, Plastered internal wall with mud, Un plastered external wall, masonry foundation , Corrugated iron sheet door ,mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (very small size) Kurkura (medium size) Tadecha (big size) Papaya (very small size) Banana (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

12.48 3 1 1 2 2 4 58.4

650 55 20 50 150 50 13 55

8112 165 20 50 150 100 52 3212 400 400 12,661

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

189 | P a g e   

Survey # 82 W/o Almaz Wube Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 rooms, Plastic (pp. bag) ceiling, Plastered internal wall with mud Unplastered externally wall, masonry foundation Corrugated iron sheet doors and timber window mud floor, Kitchen made with wood and mud wall canvas roof, Wall internally plastered with mud, Mud floor ,Corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature to produce fruit) Casmir (very small size) Kasale (big size) Kasale (small size) Diredawa (medium size) Eucalyptus (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

29.05 13.8 2 8 4 3 2 1 30.4

1470 650 300 35 150 20 150 50 55

42703.5 8970 600 280 600 60 300 50 1672 1200 800 57,235.50

Survey # 83 Ato Ferni Beraded Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation, corrugated iron sheet door and window, mud floor Kitchen made of wood, plastic wall and straw roof, no ceiling, mud floor, no door

4

17.4 8.1

1470 350

25578 2835

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

190 | P a g e   

Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (very small size) Fence work in meter /Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

1 34.3

5 55

5 1886.5 600 400 31,304.50

Survey # 84 Ato Yinabeb Boalew Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, No ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud , Unplastered external wall ,masonry foundation ,metal door and windows ,mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kurkura (very big size) Shewshewa(very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

27.54 1 2 75.8

1625 300 5 55

44752.5 300 10 4169 700 400 50,331.50

Survey # 85 Ato Kifle Hailu Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

191 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof,2 rooms, plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internally plastered and painted, external un plastered wall, masonry work under the walls, metal doors and windows concrete slab floor Service room made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof.no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall, masonry foundation , metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor , Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, Internal wall plastered with mud mud floor, corrugated iron sheet door, Perennial plants (in piece) Banana (medium size) Banana (Very small size) Kasale (big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2 3

37.31 23.37 17.4 1 1 1 80.4

1690 1625 650 120 13 150 55

63053.9 37976.25 11310 120 13 15 4422 1200 800 118,910.15

Survey # 86 Ato Hamza Ahmed Region: Amhara National Regional State

Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit

Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall Corrugated sheet door and window mud floor, Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost

5

13 16

950 55

12350 880 400

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

192 | P a g e   

Transportation cost Total

400 23,412.70

Survey # 87 Ato Mersha Zewge Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roofing, plastic (PPP bag) ceiling Internal wall plastered and painted ,external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation metal door and window, concrete slab floor Kitchen made of wood, straw wall ,canvas roof, No ceiling, mud floor ,corrugated iron sheet door , Perennial plants (in piece) Shewshewa (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

29.4 9.54 1 43.2

1690 350 5 55

49686 3339 5 2376 600 400 56,406

Survey # 88 Ato Seid Ali Umer Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 rooms, plastic (PP bag) ceiling , Internal wall plastered and painted ,external wall plastered and partially painted ,masonry foundation ,metal doors and windows, mud floor and extended concrete slab veranda Service room made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling , Internal wall

1 3

28.29 18.72

1755 1625

49,648.95 37,976.25

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

193 | P a g e   

plastered with mud , external wall plastered with mud, masonry work under the walls metal doors and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof , un plastered wall, mud floor, Corrugated iron sheet door, Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature to produce fruit) Mango (very small size) Nim (medium size) Diredawa (small size) Kasale (big size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (very small size) Kurkura (medium size) Wanza (very small size) Damakase (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

13.68 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 3 1 2 83

350 300 50 150 100 200 55 10 30 5 25 55

4788 300 50 150 100 400 55 20 90 5 50 4565 1200 800 100,198.20

Survey # 89 W/o Fatuma Muga Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, external wall plastered with mud, masonry work under the walls, metal door and window, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and straw roof, no ceiling, mud floor, Corrugated iron sheet door, Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

29.4 8.63 9.75

1625 350 55

47,775 3,020.5 536.25 600 400 52,331.75

Survey # 90 Ato Abebe Gizaw Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

194 | P a g e   

Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

House made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, external wall plastered with mud, masonry foundation corrugated iron sheet door and windows mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale ( big size) Kasale (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

24.15 1 2 29.5

1625 150 35 55

39,243.75 150 70 1,622.5 600 400 42,086.25

Survey # 91 Ato Abdu Ahmed Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

House made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall ,No masonry foundation ,Corrugated iron sheet door ,mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale ( very big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5

12.76 1 31

950 200 55

12,122 200 1705 400 400 14,827

Survey # 92 Atu Shuali Issa Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

House made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 rooms No ceiling, Internally plastered with mud,

4

24.5

1470

36,015

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

195 | P a g e   

external plastered with mud ,masonry work under the walls, Corrugated iron doors and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof, un plastered wall, mud floor , corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature to produce fruit) Papaya (very small size) Mango (very small size) Banana (small size) Banana (very small size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (very small size) Kurkura (small size) Diredawa (small size) Wacho (medium-big size) Moringa (medium size) Mezazim (medium size) Mezazim (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

17.67 2 3 1 1 4 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 50.25

350 300 5 50 120 13 55 20 15 150 150 100 100 10 55

6184.5 600 15 50 120 52 165 20 15 150 150 100 100 10 2763.75 1200 800 48,510.25

Survey # 93 W/o Aster Abebe Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

House made with wood, mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Plastered internal wall with mud, plastered external wall with mud, masonry foundation metal door and window, mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

26.6 28.3

1625 55

43225 1556.5 700 400 45,881.50

Survey # 94 Ato Dinberu Yigezu

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

196 | P a g e   

Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total Only partial of the property is within the ROW

3 1 22.5

55 20 55

165 20 1237.5 100 100 1622.50

Survey # 95 W/o Aysha Seid Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

House made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof,2 rooms, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internally plastered and painted ,externally wall plastered with mortar and partially painted ,masonry foundation work ,metal doors and windows, Concrete slab floor Bathroom and toilet made with wood wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling internally and externally un plastered , masonry foundation work ,metal doors and windows, concrete slab floor Kitchen made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, Internally plastered with mud mud floor ,Corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (very small size) Mango (very small size) Kasale (big size) Kurkura (small size) Date (very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost

1 3

32.04 9.135 5.85 2 1 3 1 2 54.3

2275 1625 650 5 50 150 15 50 55

72,891 14,844.375 3,802.5 10 50 450 15 100 2,986.5

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

197 | P a g e   

Transportation cost Total

1,200 800 97,149.37

Survey # 96 W/o Bezawork Hailu Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made of wood and mud wall andcorrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall ,no masonry work under the walls, open door , mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5 12.765 42.5

950 55

12,126.75 2,337.5 400 400 15,264.25

Survey # 97 Ato Hailemeskel Haile Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud, Unplastered external wall No masonry work , Corrugated iron sheet door mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5 13.44 28.8

950 55

12,768 1,584 400 400 15,152

Survey # 98 Ato Dawud Amanu Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

198 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Unplastered internal and external walls, no masonry work, Corrugated iron sheet door mud floor Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5 33.11

950

31,454.5 600 400 32,454.50

Survey # 99 Ato Alee Shume Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / Showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling unplaster external and internal walls, no masonry work ,no door ,mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total Remark: The house is partially collapsed and no occupants.

28.635 16

500 55

14,317.5 880 400 400 15,997.50

Survey # 100 Ato Sasaw Bezuwork Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling , Internal wall plastered with mud, unplaster external wall no masonry work under the walls , corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale ( very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5

9.1 2 26

950 20 55

8645 40 1430 400 400 10,915

Survey # 101 Ato Mulugeta Belayneh

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

199 | P a g e   

Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling ,Internal wall plastered with mud , unplaster external wall no masonry work under the walls, corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (mature to produce fruit) Papaya (very small size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale ( very small size) Wacho(medium size) Wacho(small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5

8.75 2 2 3 2 1 1 52

950 300 5 55 20 75 40 55

8312.5 600 10 165 40 75 40 2860 400 400 12,902.50

Survey # 102 Ato Sisay Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud ,un plastered external wall, masonry foundation metal door and window, Mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 13.455 8.4

1470 55

19778.85 462 400 400 21,040.85

Survey # 103 Ato Nigatu Mekonnen Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

200 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud , Unplastered external wall, no masonry work, Corrugated iron sheet door ,mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale ( big size) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

12.47 1

650 150

8105.5 150 400 400 9055.5

Survey # 104 W/o Halima Nure Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 rooms, no ceiling , Internal and external walls plastered with mud , masonry foundation ,metal door and window , mud floor Fence work in meter (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3 24.795 28.35

1625 55

40291.875 1559.25 600 400 42,851.12

Survey # 105 Ato Nure Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State

Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit

Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

201 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling, Internal and external walls, plastered with mud, masonry work under the walls, metal door and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof, no ceiling , mud floor, Plastered internal wall ,No masonry foundation, Corrugated iron sheet door , Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

30.45 11.4 52.1

1625 650 55

49481.25 7410 2865.5 1000 600 61,356.75

Survey # 106 Ato Worku Mola Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 rooms no ceiling , Internally plastered with mud Externally un plastered, masonry foundation work , metal door and window, mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3 30.295 26.6

1625 55

49229.375 1463 600 400 51,692.37

Survey # 107 Ato Melese Tadesse Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

202 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, Plastic (Madaberya) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall plastered with mud masonry foundation ,metal door and window concrete slab floor , Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, Plastered internal wall /mud, mud floor , corrugated iron sheet door Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

29.25 7.13 2 43.2

1690 650 55 55

49432.5 4634.5 110 3052.5 800 400 58,429.50

Survey # 108 W/o Wossenie Gosheme Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, Internally plastered with mud, external un plastered wall, no masonry work , Corrugated iron sheet door mud floor Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5 16.8625 16

950 55

16019.375 880 400 400 17,669.37

Survey # 109 W/o Titi Mohammed Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internally un plastered ,external un plastered wall, no masonry work , no door ,mud floor

21.12

500

10560

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

203 | P a g e   

Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

400 400 11,360

Remark- partially collapsed house and construction stopped during erection of tower

Survey # 110 Ato Kassa Masresha Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, external wall plastered with mud, masonry work under the walls, corrugated iron sheet door and windows mud floor , Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof, no ceiling, Internally un plastered mud floor, no door Perennial plants Kasale (medium) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

26.06 7.5 3 47

1625 280 55 55

42347.5 2100 165 2585 600 400 48,197.50

Survey # 111 W/o Sikeberu Kibret Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, Plastic (PP bag) ceiling, Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall plastered with mud masonry foundation work ,metal door and windows, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof, mud floor and no door Perennial plants (in piece)

2

29.815 5.5

1690 280

50387.35 15,340

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

204 | P a g e   

Papaya (small size) Papaya (very small size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Mango (very small size) Banana (very small size) Moringa (small size) Fence work in meters/ (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4 1 2 1 32 30 1 6.5

85 5 55 20 50 13 100 55

340 5 110 20 1600 390 100 357.5 600 400 55,849.85

Survey # 112 Ato Awraris Desta Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal wall plastered with mud, external un plastered wall, no masonry work ,corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Kitchen made with wood and straw wall and canvas roof, mud floor, no door Perennial plants (in piece) Papaya (small size) Kasale (medium size) Kasale (small size) Eucalyptus (very small size) Diredawa (small size) Fence work in meters/ (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5

29.815 11.94 3 5 1 3 1 44.9

950 280 85 55 20 10 100 55

28324.25 3341.8 255 275 20 30 100 2469.5 600 400 35,815.55

Survey # 113 W/o Getienesh Mondemtegen Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

205 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall and straw roof, no ceiling, Internal plastered with mud, external wall un plastered no masonry work ,corrugated iron sheet door mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Kasale ( very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3.83 3 3 17.8

650 55 20 55

2487.76 165 60 979 200 200 4091.76

Survey # 114 Ato Aregahagne Assefa Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, 2 room, no ceiling, Internal wall plastered with mud , external wall un plastered, masonry foundation work ,timber door and windows mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium size) Eucalyptus ( very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

3

19.25 2 1 28.7

1625 55 10 55

31281.25 110 10 1578.5 400 400 33,779.75

Survey # 115 Ato Abush Shiferaw Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

206 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and canvas roof, no ceiling ,Internal wall plastered and painted, external wall un plastered , no masonry work under the walls corrugated iron sheet door, mud floor Kitchen made with wood wall and canvas roof, mud floor and no door Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

5

19.35 5.5 7.6

950 280 55

18382.5 1540 418 600 400 21,149.50

Survey # 116 Ato Abubakar Bashir Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof,2 rooms ,Plastic ( PP bag) ceiling , Internal wall plastered and painted , external wall plastered with mud . masonry foundation work, metal door and windows, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (small size) Kundo barbare ( big size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

2

25.16 1 1 40.7

1690 20 150 55

42520.4 20 150 2238.5 600 400 45,928.9

Survey # 117 Ato Awol Bashir Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

207 | P a g e   

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling, unplaster internal and external walls, no masonry work under the walls Corrugated iron sheet door ,mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (medium-small size) Kasale ( very small size) Fence work in meters (Chefeqa) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

12.54 2 1 11.2

650 35 20 55

8151 70 20 616 400 400 9657

Survey # 118 W/o Rahmet Ali Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof, no ceiling Internal and external wall plastered with mud no masonry work, Corrugated iron sheet door and window, mud floor Perennial plants (in piece) Kasale (big size) Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

4

19.6 1

1470 150

28812 150 400 400 29,762

Survey # 119 W/o Rahmet’s Neighbor Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit

Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall, corrugated iron sheet roof no ceiling, unplaster internal and external wall

13.87

650

9015.5

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

208 | P a g e   

masonry foundation, no door, mud floor Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

400 400 9815.5

Survey # 120 Ato Dereje Hailesellassie Region: Amhara National Regional State Woreda/City: Kiwet / showa Robit Kebele/Village 01

Type & Description of Affected Asset CLASS

Qty. (m2)

Unit Rate (Birr/m2)

Total (Birr)

Residential house made with wood, straw and mud wall and corrugated iron sheet roof no ceiling , unplaster internal and external wall, masonry foundation , no door and mud floor Demolition cost Transportation cost Total

21.735

650

14127.75 400 400 14,927.75

 

 

 

 

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

209 | P a g e   

VI. Land Allocations Commitment Letters

Letter 1 – Land allocation commitment letter from Shoa Robit Administration

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

210 | P a g e   

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

211 | P a g e   

Ref No: S/R/T/Adm/1005/67 Date: 29/020/2016

To: The Ethiopian Electric Power Addis Ababa

Subject: Land Allocation Commitment Notification from the Mayor’s Committee The Mayor’s Office of Shoa Robit Town Administration in a meeting held on 27/02/2016, has reviewed the EEP letter (dated July 7. 2015 with reference # 052/T/S/R/P) regarding allocation of replacement land for the 230kV high power transmission line project affected people in accordance to the RAP assessment study carried out for the project and list of PAPs currently residing in the power transmission line route in Kebele 01 and Kebele 04 of Shoa Robit town. After careful review of the proper nature of the request, the committee has accepted the request and passed the following decision:

1) Persons who will be removed to give right of way for the project will be provided with replacment land 2) The size of the land that will be allocated to each family will be determined in accordance with the town’s

standard and grade of land, which is within the range of 170 to 200 meter squars, 3) The location of the replacement land will be in Kebele 03 (northern part of the city) and all essential

infrastructures will be provided and available as soon as possible. The town administration hereby notifies the EEP its support for the project and readiness to implement allocation of land for affected people as proposed in the RAP study. The committee also has instructed all concerned local authorities to execute the decision expeditiously in accordance to the terms and conditions specified above. With regard, Zerefu Degefu Woldesellassie Head of Mayor’s Office of the Shewa Robit Town Administration (Signed and official seal affixed)

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

212 | P a g e   

Letter 2: land allocation commitment letter form Municpal Office of Senbete Town

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

213 | P a g e   

Emblem of Senbete Town Municipality Jile Tumuga District, Oromia Special Zone of Amhara Regions

Ref.NO: S/T/M/1143/08 Date: 01/03/2016

To: Ethiopian Electric Power Ethiopia

Subject: Issuance of Document As indicated in the subject the Ethiopian Electric Power 230kV high tension electric transmission line passes over Miriwa Kebele of Senbete town in Jile Tumuga district. On the account of the social and environmental impact study carried out in the town, people who are currently residing under the line route will be compelled to be removed to give way for the transmission line right of way. Therefore, this letter is to notify and inform the EEP that the Municpal office has been working to address and resolve issues of project affected people and is currently preparing replacement land for persons who are likely to be affected and displaced from their residential houses on the account of high power load transmission line project activities. A list constaining names of households who will be provided replacement land is attached with this letter.

With regards,

Said Adem Said

For Senbete Town City Manager

Official Seal of Oromia Special Zone of Amhara Region annexed

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

214 | P a g e   

Annex VII: List of Contacted People

No. Name of contacted person Title Institution Tel 1 Ato Miruts Birhane Substation Operation

Coordinator Legetafo Substation

0931 083737

2 Ato Gebru Zinabu Transmission Substation Operation Coordinator

Kombolcha Substation II

0913 835132

3 Ato Biruk Andargachew Substation Operation Support

Kombolcha Substation II

4 Ato Tagel Degefa Head, Northeastern region transmission & substation operation and maintenance

Dessie Transmission and Substation Regional Office

0921 967801

5 Ato Getahun Wolancho Regional Operation Service Manager

Dessie Transmission and Substation Regional Office

0913 191394

6 Ato Asen Endris Muhuye Zone Deputy Administrator

S. Wollo Zone Administration Office

7 Ato Birke Dagne Design & Construction core process coordinator

S. Wollo zone Urban Development & Construction bureau.

0914 716021

8 Ato Tesfaye Arage Transmission line coordinator

Dessie Transmission and Substation Regional Office

0922 941901

9 Ato Desalegn Getahun Substation Operator/Technician

Alamata Substation

0914 727554

10 Ato Denbegnaw Tafesse City Manager Shoa Roabit Town Administration

0912 378409

11 Ato Minale Meaza Deputy City Manager Shoa Robit Town Administration

0920205828

12 Ato Sasaw Getaw 01 kebelle Administrator Shoa Robit Town Administration

0910 676447

13 Ato Solomon Wegderesegn 04 kebelle Manager Shoa Robit Town Administration

0928 333832

14 Ato Akale Gonite 04 kebelle Administrator Shoa Robit Town Administration

0912 164430

15 Ato Alemseged Kitaw Committee Shoa Robit

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

215 | P a g e   

Representative Informal settler /squatter in kebelle 01

16 Ato Agonafir Derebe Committee Representative

Shoa Robit Informal settler /squatter in kebelle 01

17 W/ro Tigist Kefelegn Committee Representative

Shoa Robit Informal /squatter at in kebelle 04

18 Ato Ashine Dibabe Committee Representative

Shoa Robit informal /squatter in kebelle 04

19 Ato Teketelew Asaminew Committee Representative

Shoa Robit informal /squatter in kebelle 04

20 Ato Genemo Bedane Head of the Office of the Woreda Administration

Jile Timuga Woreda Administration

033 1180084

21 Ato Ahmed Mohammed Abdella

City Manager Senbete Town Administration

0912 652400 /0331180011

22 Ato Jemal Asefa Merewa Hayre Rural Kebele Manager

Senbete Town Administration

0910 081196

23 Ato Agegnehu Gashaw W/Mariam

Head of the Office of the Woreda Administration

Ambassel Woreda, Wuchalle Town Administration

0914 718221 033 2240215

24 Ato Daniel Solomon Kebede

City Manager Wuchale town Municipality

0913 498224

25 W/ro Leyla Saed Complaint Hearing Expert

Ambassel Woreda, Wuchalle Town Administration

0920 695898

26 Ato Yifru Zerihun Zone Administrator North Wollo Zone Administration

0914 740457

27 Ato Getachew Shiferaw Urban Land Management coordinator

North Wollo Zone Urban Development & Construction office

0912 339570

28 Ato Belay Wassie Design and construction core process coordinator

North Wollo zone Urban Development &

0913 743752

RAP for Stringing of the Second Circuit 230 kV Alama –Kombolch II-Legetafo Transmission Line

 

216 | P a g e   

Construction office

29 Ato Teshome Gorfu Abesha

Head of the Office of the Woreda Administration

Guba Lafto Woreda Administration

0913 624240 / 033 3311336

30 Ato Aragew Demelash Yimar

Woreda Administrator Guba Lafto Woreda Administration

0912 721679

31 Ato Fiseha Melkamu Sisay Head of the Office of the Woreda Administration

Habru Woreda Administration

0914 603898

32 Ato Bayu Teshome Engidaw

Vice Woreda Administrator

Habru Woreda Administration

0924 231105

33 W/ro Teyiba Hussen Muhammed

Head of the Office of the Woreda Administration

Kalu Woreda Administration, Kombolcha

0921 977713

34 Ato Endalkachew Haile Head of Valuation Committee for compensation

Kalu Woreda Administration, Kombolcha

0913 426167

35 Ato Girma Bekele Deputy Zone Administrator and Head of Zone Agriculture Office

Oromo Special Zone, Amhara Region, Kemisse

0911 088290

36 Ato Asres G/Slassie Coordinator of Construction and Industry Regulation Core Process

N. Shoa Zone Industry and Urban Development Department.

0921 141506

37 Ato Getachew Tessema City Manager Debresina Town Municipality

0913 852123/ 011 6800019