32

evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

azertyuiop

Citation preview

Page 1: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002
Page 2: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

nnYYnn CCaa kkññúúggbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr EExxFFññÚÚ qqññaaMM22001111 ¬¬rrUUbbfftt ³³ GG>>vv>>tt>>kk¦¦

Page 3: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

esckþIepþIm

enAéf¶TI5 ExFñÚ qñaM2011 GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgén

GgÁCMnMuCRmHvisamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa)anepþImebIksvnakar

sYredjedal nigBinitüelIPsþútag bnÞab;BImansvnakarén

kareFIVesckþIsniñdæanecaTRbkan; nigelIGgÁesckþIénsMNuM

erOg002 Edl)anRbRBwtþeFIVeLIgkalBIéf¶TI21dl;23

Exvicäka qñaM2011 knøgmk. svnakarenH )ancab;epþIm

CamYynwgkarsYredjedalCnCab;ecaTTak;TgnwgRbvtþién

bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa rYmTaMgRbvtiþsavtarrbs;CnCab;ecaT

nYn Ca/ eGog sarI/ nig exov sMpn tamdIkadMeNaHRsay.

PaKITaMgGs;RtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHkRmit[sYrRtwmEtGgÁehtu

EdlBak;B½n§nwgRbvtiþbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa nigsavtarrbs;

CnCab;ecaTmñak;²Etb:ueNÑaH ehIyGgÁehtuenHRtÚv)anGan

CUnKUPaKI nigsaFarNCn[)andwgCamunedayRkLabBa¢Ién

GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg.

CadMbUg ecARkm)aneFIVkarsYredjedalCnCab;ecaT

nYn Ca bnÞab;mkCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI ehIycugeRkay

KWCnCab;ecaT exov sMpn. CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )an

eRbIR)as;siTi §kñ úgkarmineFIVskçIkmμ nigeqøIytbnwgsMNYr

TaMgLayrbs;PaKI rYmTaMgecARkmpg. rIÉCnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn )anGHGagfa xøÜnnwgmineqøIytbnwgsMNYr

TaMgLayrbs;PaKIenAkñúgsvnakarEdlecaTsYrmkelIxøÜn

eLIy luHRtaEtshRBHraCGaCJa)anbgðajPsþútagEdl

ecaTRbkan;mkelIxøÜnCamunsin. fIVd,itEt CnCab;ecaT exov

sMpn )anbdiesFmineqøIynwgsMNYrrbs;PaKIk¾edayenA

kñúgGMLúgeBlénsvnakar CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)anesñIsMuGgÁ

CMnM uCRmHGanesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;xø ÜnedImI,eqø Iytbnwg

cMNucTaMgLayénGgÁehtuEdlTak;TgnwgRbvtiþbkSkumμúy

nIsþkm<úCa nigRbvtþisavtarrbs;xøÜn. kñúgcMeNamCnCab;ecaT

TaMgbIrUb manEtCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca mñak;Kt; Edlyl;RBm

eqøIynwgsMNYrrbs;ecARkm nigshRBHraCGaCJaEdlecaT

sYrmkelIxøÜn.

enAkñúgsvnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nigBinitüelI

PsþútagenH edImbNþwgrdæb,evNIcMnYnBIrrUb nigsakISmYyrUb

RtÚv)anekaHehAmkeFIVskçIkmμenAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH.

sakISrUbenaHRtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHcat;TukfaCasakISsMxan;

EdlGacGnuBaØat[PaKITaMgGs;sYredjedalBIGgÁehtuTaMg

mUlénsm½ykm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. edaysarmUlehtu

suxPaB nigv½ycas;Cra sakISrUbenHminGaccUlrYmeday

pÞal;enAkñúgbnÞb;svnakareLIy ehIykarsYredjedalRtÚv

eFIVeLIgtamry³RbB½n§esatTsSn_BIextþbnÞaymanC½yEdl

CaTIkEnøgsñak;enArbs;sakISrUbenH.

svnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nigBinitüelIPsþútag

EdlerobcMeLIgedayGgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgenAeBlenHmin

Tan;bBa©b;enAeLIyeT svnakarenHnwgRtÚvbnþRbRBwtþeFIVenA

éf¶TI10 Exmkra qñaM2012bnþbnÞab;eTot.

1¦ GgÁehtusþIBIRbvtþibkSkumμúynisþkm<úCa nigRbvtþi

savtarrbs;CnCab;ecaTmñak;²

svnakarsYredjedal nigBinitüelIPsþútag)an

cab;epþImedayGanGgÁehturbs;RkLabBa¢IBIrnak;énGgÁCMnMu

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 1

svnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nigBinitüPsþútagkñúgsMNMuerOg002

éf¶TI5-15 ExFñÚ qñaM2011

qayQunlI/ DI suCata/ can R)afña nig lwm C½yTtþ

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 4: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

CRmHsaladMbUgTak;TgeTAnwgRbvtiþénbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

nigRbvtþ isavtarrbs;CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca eGog sarI

nigexov sMpn tamdIkadMeNaHRsayenAkñúgsMNMuerOg002

muneBlGgÁCMnM uCRmHGnuBaØat[mankarsYredjedalCn

Cab;ecaT edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI sakIS nigGñkCMnajGMBI

GgÁehtuEdlerobrab;xagelI.

k¦ RbvtþibkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

enAkñúgdIkabBa¢ÚnerOgeTACMnMuCRmHkñúgsMNMuerOg002

rbs;shecARkmesIubGegát)anelIkeLIgfa eRkayBIbkS

kumμúynIsþ\NÐÚcin)anrlayenAkñúgqñaM1951 GtItsmaCik

rbs;bkSenH)anbegáItGgÁkarbdivtþn_dac;edayELkBIKñaenA

kñúgRbeTsnImYy² ehIybkSfμImYyEdlbegáIteLIgenAkm<úCa

maneQμaHfa {bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Exμr}. bkSenHmankar

cUlrYmBIRkúm\sSr³edIm,ITamTarÉkraCüBIGaNaniKm)araMg

EdlkarTamTarenH)anTTYleCaKC½y nigRtÚv)anTTYlsÁal;

enAsnñisITTIRkúghSWENvkñúgqñaM1954. enAéf¶TI30 ExkBaØa

qñaM1960 bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Exμr)aneFVImhasmaC ehIy

)anbþÚreQμaHeTACa {bkSBlkrExμr} EdlenHCacMNuccab;epþIm

BitR)akdénkarbegáItclnakumμúynIsþExμr. bkSenH)an

begáIt {maKa’yuT§sa®sþ} nig {maKa’yuT§viFI} c,as;las; kñúg

qñaM1960enAGMLúgeBlmhasnñi)atbkSelIkTI1. enAEx

mkra qñaM1965 {bkSBlkrExμr} )anGnum½tesckþIseRmc

mYyEdl)anbdiesFcMeBaH {karpøas;bþÚredaysnþiviFI} eTA

kan;lT§isgÁmniym nig)anbBa¢ak;fa {CakarcaM)ac;EdlRtÚv

eRbIR)as;higSabdivtþn_} kñúgkarts‘URbqaMgnwgBYkcRkRkBtþi.

enAExkBaØa b¤tula qñaM1966 bkSBlkrExμrRtÚv)anbþÚr

eQμaHeTACa {bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa} Edl)anseRmceday

RbFanbkSenAkñúgGgÁRbCMuKN³mCÄim. enAéf¶TI17 Exmkra

qñaM1968 kgkmøaMgrbs;bkSkumμúynisþkm<úCa)anebIkkar

vayRbharelIkgT½Brbs;rdæaPi)alenAPUmi)aydMraM ¬PaK

xagtÚ,gRkúg)at;dMbg¦ ehIyrwbGUs)anGavuFmYycMnYn.

kalbriecäTénkarvayRbharenHRtÚv)anbkSkumμúynisþkm<úCa

kMNt;faCaéf¶kMeNItrbs;kgT½Bbdivtþkm<úCa ehIyb:unμanEx

eRkaymk kgkmøaMgrbs;bkSkumμúynisþkm<úCa)anbnþkar

vayRbharrbs;xøÜnenATUTaMgRbeTs. enAéf¶TI23 ExmIna

qñaM1970 semþc sIhnu )anRbkasbegáIt {rNsirSrYbrYm

Cati} edIm,IeFVIkarbHe)arRbqaMgrdæaPi)al EdlkarRbkas

enHeFVIeLIgeRkayBI ln; nl; eFVIrdæRbharTmøak;RBHGgÁenA

éf¶TI18ExmIna qñaM1970.Ca»kasl¥ bkSkumμúynisþkm<úCa

)ancgsm<n½§PaBCamYysemþc sIhnu ehIybegáItrdæaPi)al

nireTsfμImYymanmUldæanenATIRkúgeb:kaMgmaneQμaHfa {raC

rdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatikm<úCa} nigRbkasCapøÚvkaréf¶TI5 Ex

2 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

RRBBHHssggÇÇkkMMBBuuggeeddIIrrccUUllbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr

ssiissSSaannuussiissSSkkMMBBuuggttRRmmgg;;CCYYrrccUUllbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr

Page 5: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

]sPa qñaM1970. bkSkumμúynIsþ)anebIkkarvaylukelI

tMbn;EdlRKb;RKgedayrdæaPi)alrbs; ln; nl; CabnþbnÞab;

ehIyenAéf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM1975 bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

)anrMedaHykTIRkúgPMñeBj. EteTaHbICay:agNakþI GtßiPaB

rbs;bkSkumμúynisþkm<úCaRtÚv)anRbkasCapøÚvkarenAExkBaØa

qñaM1977.

x¦ Rbvtþisavtarrbs;CnCab;ecaTmñak;²

bnÞab;BIRbvtþibkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa RkLabBa¢I)anbnþ

GanGMBItYnaTI nigkarcUlrYmkñúgclnakumμúynisþrbs;CnCab;

ecaT nYn Ca/ eGog sarI nig exov sMpn muneBlénrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü EdlepþatsMxan;eTAelItYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaT

mñak;²cab;taMgBIkarcUlRbLÚkneya)ay rhUtdl;karcab;epþIm

énrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyükñúgExemsa qñaM1975.

11¦¦ RRbbvvttþþiissaavvttaarrrrbbss;;CCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT nnYYnn CCaa

CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )ancab;epþImcUlRbLÚky:ag

skmμkñúgskmμPaBneya)ayenAcugTsvtSr_qñaM1940 enA

xN³eBlEdlxøÜnenAkñúgRbeTséf. CnCab;ecaTrYbenH

)ancUlrYmCamYy{GgÁkaryuvCnRbCaFibetyü} Edlsßit

enAeRkambkSkumμúynIsþéf. bnÞab;mk CnenH)anvilmk

km<úCaedIm,IcUlrYmclnats‘Urbs;bkSkumμúynisþ\NÐÚcinenA

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 3

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

nnaayyTTaahhaannkkMMBBuuggttRRmmgg;;CCYYrrccUUllbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr

mm®®nnþþIIkkiicc©©kkaarrssaaFFaarrNN³³EEcckkeessoovveePPAAEENNnnaaMMrrbbss;;ssaallaakkþþIICCUUnnRRbbCCaaCCnn

Page 6: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

dMbn;sMLÚt edayTTYlbnÞúkxageXasnaenAkñúgbkS. enAkñúg

xN³eBlenaHCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anTak;Tgy:agskmμ

CamYyRkúmkumμúynIsþevotNam nigsmasPaBkumμúynIsþ

énclnaExμr\sSr³. CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)aneTAsikSavKÁ

neya)ayenARbeTsevotNamGs;ry³eBl2qñaM eRkay

mkk¾køayeTACaemdwknaMmñak;énclnakumμúynisþsm¶at;enA

TIRkúgPñMeBj. CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca RtÚv)aneRCIstaMgCa

GnuelxabkSenAExkBaØa qñaM1960 ehIycenøaHqñaM1970

nig1975 CnCab;ecaTrUbenHmantYnaTICaGnubBa¢akareyaFa

Can;x<s; kgT½BRbCaCnénclnarMedaHCatikm<úCa nigCaRbFan

Epñkneya)ayrbs;kgT½Bbdivtþn_.

22¦¦ RRbbvvttþþiissaavvttaarrrrbbss;;CCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT eeGGoogg ssaarrII

CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI ehA {v:an;})ancab;epþImcUlrYm

skmμPaBneya)aykñúgTsvtSr_qñaM1940 enAxN³Edl

xøÜnCanisSiténviTüal½yRBHsIusuvtßi. enAqñaM1950 CnCab;

ecaTrUbenH)anbnþkarsikSaenATIRkúg)arIsRbeTs)araMg

ehIyxN³enaH eGog sarI )ankøayCasmaCikbkSkumμúynisþ

)araMgCamYy b:ul Bt nigCnCab;ecaT exov sMpn. enAqñaM

1957 CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )anRtLb;mkRbeTskm<úCa

vij ehIy)ancUlrYmCamYyKNbkSbdivtþn_RbCaCnkm<úCa.

bnÞab;mkenAqñaM1960 CnCab;ecaTrUbenHRtÚv)anbkS

eRCIserIsCasmaCikKN³mCÄim nigCasmaCikeRtómén

KN³Gcié®nþy_ bnÞab;mkeTotenAqñaM1963 RtÚv)anbkS

eRCIserIsCasmaCikeBjsiT§iénKN³Gcié®nþy_rbs;bkS

kumμúynIsþkm<úCa ehIyenAqñaM1966 CnenHmantYnaTICaelxa

PUmiPaK|san. enAkñúgqñaM1970 CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI

)aneFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúghaNUy nigTIRkúgeb:kaMgedIm,Icg

sm<½n§PaBCamYybkSkumμúynisþcin. enAExFñÚ qñaM1970

CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)anerobcMeLIgvijnUv {viTüúsMeLgrNsirS

rYbrYmCatikm<úCa} EdlmanmUldæanenATIRkúghaNUy ehIy

dak;[sßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgedayCnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§.

enAqñaM1971 CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )antaMgmUldæanCa

Gcié®nþy_enATIRkúgeb:kaMgkñúgzan³CaebskCnBiessénGñk

ts‘UépÞkñ úgenAeb:kaMg ehIyCnenH)anRtLb;mkkm<úCaCa

Gcié®nþy_kñúgExemsa qñaM1975. kñúgfazan³CaebskCn

Biess CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)aneRbIR)as;menaseBa©tna

esñhaCatikñúgkarbMBak;bMb:n nigGUsTajRbCaCnkm<úCa[

cUlrYmCamYyraCrdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatikm<úCa.

33¦¦ RRbbvvttþþiissaavvttaarrrrbbss;;CCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT eexxoovv ssMMppnn

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn ehA{Ehm} CaskmμCnmñak;

kñ úgclnakumμúynIsþkm<úCa Edl)ancab;epþImcUlkñúgqak

neya)aycab;taMgBITsvtSr_qñaM50enARbeTs)araMgem:øH.

enAeBlRtLb;mkRbeTskm<úCavij CnenH)anbegáItkaEst

CaPasa)araMgEdlmaneQμaHfa {L’Observateur} ¬Gñk

4 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

eeGGoogg ssaarrII kkññúúggbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr ¬¬rrUUbbfftt ³³ GG>>vv>>tt>>kk¦¦

Page 7: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

segátkarN_¦ edaymankarKaMRTnigpþl;fvikaedayskmμCn

kumμúynIsþénRbeTskm<úCa. CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn RtÚv)an

EtgtaMgCaGnuRbFanrNsirSrYbrYmCatikm<úCa nigCaGKÁ

embBa¢akarénkgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnkm<úCa ehIyenAEx]sPa

qñaM1970 CnenHRtÚv)anEtgtaMgeFVICa]bnaykrdæm®nþI nig

Cardæm®nþIkarBarCatirbs;rdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatikm<úCa. enAqñaM

1971 CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)ankøayCasmaCikebkçCnrbs;

KN³mCÄiménbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa ehIycenøaHExmkranig

emsa qñaM1975 CnenH)anGMBavnav[RbCaCnTIRkúgPñMeBj

eRkakeLIgts‘UrMedaHCatinig)anRbkasfa {rNsirSrYbrYmCati

km<úCa} nig {raCrdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatikm<úCa} Gacnwgkan;kab;

RkúgPñMeBjnaeBlqab;².

2¦ karsYredjedalCnCab;ecaT edImbNþwgrdæ

b,evNI nigsakIS BIsMNak;ecARkmnigPaKIenAkñúg

svnakar

enAkñúgrebobvr³énsvnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nig

BinitüPsþútag GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg)ankMNt;fa karsYr

edjedalRtÚvcab;epþImBIkarsaksYrCnCab;ecaT bnÞab;mk

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI sakIS nigGñkCMnaj eTAtamlMdab;

lMeday.

k¦ karsYredjedalCnCab;ecaT

enAmunkarcab;epþIménkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIénkarsYr

edjedalCnCab;ecaT elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH nil Nun

)anRbkasfa karsYredjedalnwgcab;epþImmuneKBIkarsak

sYrCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca bnÞab;mknwgbnþeTACnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI nigcugeRkay KWCnCab;ecaT exovsMpn.

11¦¦ CCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT nnYYnn CCaa

kkaarreeFFIIVVkkMMNNtt;;ssmmÁÁaall;;rrbbss;; nnYYnn CCaa

muneBlsYredjedalCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca GgÁCMnM u

CRmH)anGnuBaØat[CnCab;ecaTeFVIkarbgðajBICIvitts‘UEpñk

neya)ayrbs;xøÜnknøgmk. eRkayBITTYl)ankarGnuBaØati

CnCab; ecaT nYn Ca )ancMNayeBlevlaesÞIrEtTaMgRsug

edIm,IbgðajBITwkcitþesñhaCati karRsLaj;yutþiFm’ nigkar

lHbg;rbs;xøÜnsRmab;CatimatuPUmi. Cak;Esþg nYn Ca )an

elIkeLIgfa {kalenAv½ykumarPaB EdleBlenaHRbeTs

kMBugsßitenAeRkamGaNaniKm)araMg xøÜn)aneXIjRbCaCn

ExμrRtÚv)aneKcab;eFVI)ab nigdak;kñúgmnÞIrXMuXaMg Gñkman

CiHCan;nigekgRbv:aj;kmøaMgBlkmμGñkRk}. nYn Ca )anbEnßm

fa minRtwmEtRbeTskm<úCaeT sUm,IRbeTséfk¾dUcKñaEdr

KWGñkmanCiHCan;GñkRk CaBiessCnCaticinCiHCan;CnCati

éf. edayeXIjsPaBEbbenH xøÜn)anseRmccitþcUlrYm

CamYyGgÁkaryuvCnRbCaFibetyü nigbnÞab;mkcUlbkS

kumμúynIsþéfedIm,IRbqaMgnwgkarCiHCan; ehIyxøÜn)aneFVIskmμ

PaBmYycMnYnRbqaMgnwgGñkkan;GMNacmYycMnYnenARbeTséf.

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 5

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

eexxoovv ssMMppnn kkññúúggbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr ¬¬rrUUbbfftt ³³ GG>>vv>>tt>>kk¦¦ nnYYnn CCaa kkññúúggbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr ¬¬rrUUbbfftt ³³ GG>>vv>>tt>>kk¦¦

Page 8: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

nYn Ca )anbnþeTotfa enAéf¶mYyxøÜn)anTTYldMNwgtamry³

sßanTUtéfEdlRbcaMkarenARbeTskm<úCafa RbCaCnExμrRtÚv

)anBYk)araMgcab;vaydMeFVI)ab. edaykþIGaNit nigRsLaj;

yutþiFm’ xøÜn)ansMukarGnuBaØatBIbkSkumμúynIsþéfedIm,ImkeFVI

skmμPaBts‘URbqaMgnwg)araMgenARbeTskm<úCa edayman

karKaMRTnwgpþl;CMnYyedaybkSkumμúynIsþéf nigbkSkumμúy

nIsþevotNam.

nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaminEmn

ekIteLIgBIkmøaMgenAkñúgRsukExμrTaMgRsugeT KWmankarrYmpSM

ecjBIGñkesñhaCatiEdlmkBIRbeTs)araMg ¬rYmman b:ul

Bt nig eGog sarI¦ bkSkumμúynIsþéf nigevotmij. Cn

Cab;ecaTrUbenH)anbnþfa evotNam)anRbmUlRbCaCn

ExμrRbmaN2000nak;ykeTAGb;rMenARbeTsevotNam

edIm,ITukGñkTaMgenaH[eFVICakmμaPi)alrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCa.

nYn Ca )aneFIVkarkt;smÁal;BIkarsmøab;RbCaCnExμrfa

KW {yYneTEdlsmøab;Exμr minEmnExμrsmøab;ExμrenaHeT}.

CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)anbBa¢ak;fa karsmøab;RbCaCn ExμrKWman

karbBa¢aecjmkBIhaNUyEdlsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKg

rbs;hUCImij ehIykalbriecäTéf¶TI7 Exmkra qñaM1979

KWCakalbriecäTEdlyYnvaykm<úCa edaysarEtkm<úCamin

suxcitþsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;yYn.

cceemmøøIIyyrrbbss;; nnYYnn CCaa eennAAGGMMLLúúggeeBBllssvvnnaakkaarr

RRbbvvttþþiibbkkSSkkuummμμúúyynnIIssþþkkmm<<úúCCaa

bnÞab;BIkarbBa©b;kareFI VkMNt;smÁal;rbs;CnCab;

ecaT nYn Ca GgÁCMnMuCRmH)ancab;epþImeFIVkarsYredjedal

CnCab;ecaTrUbenH edayelakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH nil Nun

RbKl;evTikaCUnelakRsIecARkmGnþrCati sIulevo xatr:ayf_

edImI,saksYrCnCab;ecaTBIRbvtþirbs;bkSkumμúynisþkm<úCa

nigtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaTenAmuneBlénrbbkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyü. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;elakRsIecARkm xatr:ayf_

CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anBüayambgðajBITwkcitþesñhaCati

rbs;bkSkumμúynisþkm<úCaTaMgmUlkñúgkarts‘UrMedaHRbeTs

CatiecjBIsßanPaBmYyEdlxøÜnKitfa CasgÁmmankarCiHCan;

edayvNѳskþiPUmi nigkMBugsßitenAeRkamkareRCótERCk

kan;kab;edayRbeTsevotNam. nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa

eRkayBIbkSkumμúynIsþ\NÐÚcin)anrlaybkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_

Exμr bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Lav nigbkSBlkrevotNamRtÚv

)anbegáIteLIg. EtbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Exμr nigbkSRbCaCn

bdivtþn_LavminmanÉkraCüBIevotNameLIy edaysarmaKa’

yuT§sa®sþ nigmaKa’yuT§viFIrbs;bkSTaMgBIrRtÚvGnuelamtam

bkSBlkrevotNam. CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anbEnßmeTot

fa ral;karGnuvtþ b¤seRmceFIVepSg²rbs;bkSRbCaCn

bdivtþn_Exμr KWRtÚv)ankarGnuBaØati b¤sarENnaMmkBIbkSBlkr

evotNam. dUcenHedIm,Ikat;bnßy\T§iBlrbs;evotNam

mkelIbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Exμr nYn Ca nig b:ul Bt )anTTYl

bnÞúkkñúgkarbegáIt {maKa’yuT§sa®sþ} nig {maKa’yuT§viFI} rbs;

bkSdac;edayELkmYy edaymankarsRmbsRmÜlBI TU

6 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

nnYYnn CCaa

Page 9: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

samut EdlmannaTICaelxabkSnaeBlenaH. nYn Ca )an

bBa¢ak;fa evotNammankarmineBjcitþcMeBaHbkSRbCaCn

bdivtþn_Exμr Edl)anbegáItmaKa’yuT§sa®sþ nigmaKa’yuT§viFI

edaymin)ansYreyabl;rbs;xøÜneLIy. dUcenH evotNam

)ancat;taMgbuKÁlmYycMnYn[bnøMxø ÜnedIm,IbMpøicbMpøajmaKa’

rbs;bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Exμr. eTaHbICay:agenHkþI maKa’

yuT§sa®sþ nigmaKa’yuT§viFIrbs;xøÜn)anTTYlkarKaMRTBIRbeTs

cin ehIyRbeTscinEfmTaMg)anpþl;CMnYy[GnuvtþmaKa’TaMgBIr

enHeTotpg. CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anbBa¢ak;fa karN_Edl

bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_ExμrbþÚreQμaHmkCabkSBlkrExμr KW

edaysarEtxøÜnmanbMNgkat;pþac;BI\T§iBlrbs;bkSBlkr

evotNam. eTaHbImankarpøas;bþÚreQμaHbkSkþI maKa’neya)ay

rbs;bkSminRtÚv)anpøas;bþÚreLIy.

kkaarrbbeeggááIIttmmaaKKaa’’nneeyyaa))aayyrrbbss;;bbkkSS

Bak;B½n§nwgkarbegáItmaKa’yuT§sa®sþ nigmaKa’yuT§viFI

rbs;bkS CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgy:aglm¥itfa kñúg

karerobcMnUvmaKa’yuT§sa®sþ nigmaKa’yuT§viFIenHKW b:ul Bt Ca

GñkTTYlbnÞúkkñúgkartamdansPaBkarN_enAtamTIRkúg cMENk

xøÜnCaGñkTTYlbnÞúkTak;TgCamYykmμaPi)alcas;BIsm½y

eRkaykic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaBTIRkúghSWENvqñaM1954. kñúg

karGnuvtþParkic©enH xøÜnTak;Tg)anPUmiPaKBay½Bü PUmiPaK

nirtI nig)at;dMbg cMENkÉ b:ul Bt Tak;Tg)ankmμaPi)al

PUmiPaKbUBa’KW eQμaH esa Pwm. eRkayBITak;Tg)ankmμaPi)al

TaMgenH nYn Ca )anesñI[esIubsYrBIsPaBkarN_enAtamCnbT

cMENkÉ b:ul Bt esIubsYrsPaBkarN_enATIRkúg. nYn Ca

yl;fa enACnbTPaKeRcIn 85PaKryCaksikrRkIRkEdl

RtÚv)anCiHCan;edayemPUmi emXMu b:UlIs Tah‘an nigGñkman

.l. rIÉ b:ul Bt kþab;)ansPaBkarN_fa manm®nþIraCkar

tUctacmYycMnYnEdlmanCIv³PaBxVHxat. nYn Ca )ansgát;

F¶n;fa ksikrRkIRk nigm®nþIraCkarEdlmanzan³tUctacTaMgenH

EdlnwgRtÚvemIleXIjkmøaMgEdlRtÚvTak;Taj ¬{enHeyIg

RtÚveXIjkmøaMg}¦. nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa munnwgeFVImaKa’

neya)ay bkS)aneFVIkarviPaKGMBIFatuBiténsgÁmkm<úCaenA

eBlenaH. bnÞab;BIsikSaGMBIsPaBkarN_enAeBlenaH bkS

BinitüeXIjfa sgÁmkm<úCaKWCasgÁmBak;kNþalGaNaniKm

nigBak;kNþalskþiPUmi. CnCab;ecaT)anbEnßmfa {sgÁm

km<úCaCasgÁmBak;kNþalGaNaniKm BIeRBaHvaenAmankEm¥l

GaNaniKmenAeLIy vaminTan;ÉkraCüsuT§saFenAeLIyeT}.

ehIyCasgÁmBak;kNþalskþiPUmi BIeRBaHvamanrbbnayTun

ehIyvaminEmnskþiPUmiTaMgduleT. dUcenHebIFatuBiténsgÁm

km<úCa CasgÁmBak;kNþalGaNaniKmBak;kNþalskþiPUmi

eyIgRtÚveFVIbdivtþn_CatiRbCaFibetyü}. nYn Ca )anbBa¢ak;

fa FatuBitrbs;bdivtþn_km<úCaenAeBlenaHKWCa {bdivtþn_

RbCaCatiRbCaFibetyü}. Bakü {bdivtþn_RbCaCati} man

n½yfa KWkm©at;\T§iBlrbs;GaNaniKm Bak;kNþalGaNaniKm

cMENkÉBakü {RbCaFibetyü} KWkm©at;\T§iBlrbs;BYk

skþiPUmim©as;dI. dUcenHsRtÚvrbs;bdivtþn_RbCaCatiRbCaFib

etyüKW {kEm¥lbreTs EdlenAeRbIGMNacGaCJamkelI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 7

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

¬¬RRbbPPBB ³³ bbNNÑÑssaarrmmCCÄÄmmNNÐÐllÉÉkkssaarrkkmm<<úúCCaa¦¦

Page 10: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

RbCaCnExμr enHKWCasRtÚvEdlRtÚvduHlag. ÉBak;kNþal

skþiPUmiKWTamTar[ksikrts‘UbnßyQñÜlERs karR)ak; bul

bNþak;}. nYn Ca )anbBa¢ak;fa {dUcenHminEmnykmnusSCa

sRtÚveT´sUmCRmab KWykkarRbRBwtþrbs;eKCasRtÚv}.

{etInrNaCakmøaMgbdivtþn_?} nYn Ca )anbkRsayfa ³

{eBlenaHKWksikrRk ksikrkNþalfñak;eRkam

eRkamsm<½n§PaBrbs;kmμkr ksikr CakmøaMg

bdivtþn_rbs;bdivtþn_RbCaCatiRbCaFibetyü

´sUmCRmab;[c,as; ÉeRkABIenHKWGñkEdlman

sμartIesñhaCati sμartIRbCaFibetyük¾eyIg

RtÚvRbmUlEdr eyIgminbdiesFGñkNaeT dUcCa

ksikrkNþal b¤ksikrman eTaHbICaFøab;man

karCiHCan;xagbulbNþak;xøH k¾eyIgmincat;Tuk

CasRtÚvEdr RtÚvRbmUlkmøaMgGs;enHmkcUl

kñúgbdivtþn_RbCaCatiRbCaFibetyü.}

nYn Ca )anbEnßmfa enAkñúgkarksagkmøaMgbdivtþn_

bkS)anbegáItmaKa’yuT§viFI EdlCaTUeTAehAfa {maKa’rN³sirS

rYbrYmCati} edayrN³sirSrYmrYbrYmCatienH eFVIkarRbmUl

kmøaMgRKb;CnCatiTaMgGs;EdlmansμartICati sμartIesñha

RbCaCn minerIseGIgBIGtItkalminfaCnCatiPaKtic minfa

CnCatiPaKeRcIncUlmkrYbrYmKñaCakmøaMgmhasamKÁICati

edIm,Its‘Ukm©at;rbbBak;kNþalGaNaniKm Bak;kNþal

skþiPUmi. cMENkviFIsa®sþénkareFVIbdivtþn_ KWcab;epþImeFVIBI

cugkat;mat;jk raldaleTATIRbCMuCn eTAtamTIrYmRsuk

KWeRbóbdUcCadMNk;eRbg EdlkalenaHxøÜn)aneRbIBaküfa

{eFVIbdivtþn_rebobdMNk;eRbg} ehIyeFVIkarts‘UedayRsb

c,ab; Bak;kNþalRsbc,ab; minRsbc,ab; ts‘UTaMgneya)ay

ts‘UTaMgesdækic© ts‘UTaMgvb,Fm’ ehIyebIcaM)ac;RtÚvts‘UTaMg

GavuFnigneya)ayrYmpSMKña. CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)anelIk

eLIgBak;B½n§nwgBaküesøakkñúgkareFIVbdivtþn_ nYn Ca niyayfa

{edIm,IseRmcbdivtþn_RbCaCatiRbCaFibetyü ts‘UyUrGEgVg

lM)akevTna xøÜnTIBwgxøÜn xøÜnseRmcvasnCatixøÜnedayxøÜnÉg

ebIcaM)ac;k¾eyIgmankarTak;TgCamYymitþRbeTsCamitþEdl

esñhasnþiPaB esñhayutþiFm’pgEdr ehIykarts‘UenHedIm,I

karBarCati bUrNPaBEdndIénRbeTseyIgGaenHBaküesøak}.

nYn Ca )anbBa¢ak;fa eRkayBIbkSmanmaKa’yuT§sa®sþ

nigmaKa’yuT§viFI clnabdivtþn_k¾ecHEtmankarrIkceRmInCa

lMdab;rhUtdl;vayQñHrbbln; nl; qñaM1975.

kkaarrccUUllrrYYmmkkññúúggccllnnaabbddiivvttþþnn__

bnÞab;B IRtLb;mkBIRbeTséfkñ úgqña M1951vij

CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )ancUlrYmy:agskmμkñúgclnabdivtþn_

enAkm<úCa. eRkayeBlmkdl;RbeTskm<úCaPøam nYn Ca

)ancab;epþImeFVIskmμPaBbHe)arRbCaCn[RbqaMgnwgkar

CiHCan;rbs;)araMgtamry³karsresrGtßbTkaEstmYy

cMnYn.skmμPaBTaMgenHRtÚv)anKaMRT nigpþl;CMnYyedaybkS

kumμúynIsþéf nigbkSkumμúynIsþevotNam. bnÞab;mkenAqñaM

1953 nYn Ca )aneTATTYlvKÁbNþúHbNþalEpñkneya)ay

enARbeTsevotNamcMnYnBIrqñaM. vKÁsikSaenAeBlenaHepþat

CasMxan;eTAelI {karRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgEpñkstiGarmμN_}.

eRkayBIeroncb;enAevotNam nYn Ca )anRtLb;mkRbeTs

km<úCavij ehIy)ancUlrYmCamYy b:ul Bt edIm,ICYykic©kar

rbs; TU samut. eRkayBI TU samut ENnaM[begáItmaKa’

neya)ayrbs;bkS nYn Ca nig b:ul Bt mantYnaTIy:agsMxan;

kñúgkarRbmUlksagkmøaMg nigbMpusbMpulRbCaCn[cUlrYm

eFVIbdivtþn_. bEnßmelIenH enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt nig eGog

sarI eTAtaMgTIsñak;karenARBMEdnevotNam eRkayBImankar

RbkasBIbuKÁleqVgniymcMnYn34nak; CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca

KWCabuKÁlsMxan;mñak;EdlmannaTItamdansPaBkarN_enA

TIRkúgPMñeBj ehIyraykarN_eTA b:ul Bt. tYnaTIsMxan;mYy

eTotrbs;CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca KWkarGb;rMneya)ayrbs;bkS

eTAdl;kmμaPi)alfñak;eRkam. nYn Ca niyayfa xøÜnmantYnaTI

sMxan;kñ úgkarGb;rMneya)aydl;kmμaPi)alfñak;eRkam²

edayEp¥kelITsSnavdþITg;bdivtþn_ nigÉksarmYycMnYneTot

dUcCaÉksarelakTsSn³ sgÁmTsSn³ ÉksarsþIBIkar

8 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 11: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

EbgEckvNѳkñúgsgÁmEdlxøÜn)anGnuvtþtaMgBImunrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyümkem:øH.

Bak;B½n§nwgkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBIRkúgPñMeBjéf¶TI

17 Exemsa qñaM1975 CnCab; ecaT nYn Ca )anbBa¢ak;fa

enABak;kNþalqñaM1974 mankic©RbCMuKN³Gcié®nþy_ nig

KN³mCÄimmineBjGgÁmYyedIm,IeFVIkarseRmcbBaðaCemøós

enH. enAkñúgkic©RbCMuenaHminmanvtþmanCnCab;ecaT exov

sMpn nig eGog sarI. eRBaHeBlenaH eGog sarI kMBugsßit

enAÉbreTs. cMENkÉ exov sMpn minTan;mansiT§iseRmc

kñúgkarCemøósRbCaCneLIy edaysareBlenaH CnCab;

ecaTenHminTan;køayCasmaCikrbs;KN³mCÄimb¤rbs;KN³

Gcié®nþy_eLIy. CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anbEnßmfa eRkay

BIkarbBa©b;kic©RbCM usþ IBIkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúg

PñMeBj esckþIseRmcenHRtÚv)anpSBVpSayeTAtamPUmiPaK

nImYy². CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa sßanPaB

rs;enATIRkúgPñMeBjenAeBlenaHmankarlM)akevTna RbCaCn

mYycMnYnFMhUbminRKb;RKan; ehIymanmYycMnYneTot)ansøab;

edaysarGt;GaharbriePaK. dUcenHkarCemøóseTAtam

CnbT KWCakarl¥eRBaHenA TIenaHRbCaCnmanCIv³PaBRKan;ebI

ehIyEfmTaMgmandIsRmab;eFVIksikmμeTotpg. ehIymü:ag

vijeTotk¾edIm,ItamdansPaBkarN_nigbeBa¢óskarsmøab;

RbCaCn EdleBlenaHevotNammanbMNgvaycUlTIRkúg

PñMeBj.

CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa enAeBlCemøós

RbCaCnecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj xøÜn)anR)ab;dl;kmμaPi)alfñak;

eRkam²fa RbCaCnEdlFøab;rs;enATIRkúgPñMeBj[eFVIkar

tictYc)an ehIyeRBaHBYkeKminFøab;eFVIkarF¶n;² ehIy[hUb

mYyéf¶bIeBl rYmTaMg[bEg¥mhUb1dgkñúgmYys)aþh_eTot

pg bEnßmelIenHxøÜnEfmTaMg)anGb;rMdl;GñkenAmUldæanmin[

mankarerIseGIgeTAelIRbCaCnfμIeLIy.pÞúyeTAvijCnCab;

ecaT nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaKW CabkS

esñhaCati lHbg;GVI²edIm,ICati ehIyminEdlsmøab;RbCaCn

ExμreLIy GñkEdlsmøab;RbCaCn nigeFVI)abRbCaCn KWGñkman

smasPaBminl¥enAkñ úgshkrN_EdleFVIskmμPaBedIm,I

bMpøajbdivtþn_.

kkaarrRRbbCCMMuuCCeemmøøóóssRRbbCCaaCCnn

Bak;B½n§eTAnwgkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúg TIRbCMuCn

epSg² CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa enAeBlkgT½B

bdivtþn_vaycUlkan;kab;)anTIRkúg b¤TIRbCMuCnNamYy RbCaCn

Edlrs;enATIRkúg b¤TIRbCMuCnenaHxøHRtÚv)anCemøós ehIyxøH

eTotminRtÚv)anCemøós KWGaRs½yeTAelIsßanPaBksikmμ

GMeNaypl. esckþIseRmckñúgkarCemøósenHecjmkBI

KN³PUmiPaKéntMbn;enaH EdlKN³PUmiPaKenaH)anTTYl

GMNacenHBI KN³mCÄim nigKN³Gcié®nþy_.

enAkñúgkarsYredjedalBIkarbegáItkgT½Bbdivtþn_km<úCa

GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anepþatCasMxan;eTAelITMnak;TMngrvagkarbegáIt

{kgkmøaMgBiess} EdlRtÚv)anbegáIteLIgedIm,IkarBar

snþisux[kmμaPi)alExμrRkhm nigkarbþÚreQμaHrbs;kgkmøaMg

enHmkCa{kgTB½bdivtþn_km<úCa}. eqøIytbeTAnwgbBaðaenH

nYn Ca )anelIkeLIgfa BYkkan;GMNacRbtikiriya ln; nl;

)ancab;RbCaCn nigkmμaPi)alExμrRkhmdak;KukedayKμan

ehtupl EdlkareFVIdUcenHGacnwgeFVI[bdivtþn_rlay. dUecñH

RtÚvmankgkmøaMgBiessedIm,IkarBarsuvtþiPaB[kmμaPi)al

ExμrRkhmenAeBlBYkeKedIreFVIkar eRBaHxøackgT½Brbs; ln;

nl; cab;kmμaPi)alTaMgenaH. kgkmøaMgBiessenHRtÚv)an

eRCIserIsecjBIkUnksikr ehIyedayeRbIGavuFdUcCakaMbiT

BUefA dMbg.l. edIm,IttaMgenAeBlmankarcab;kmμaPi)al

ExμrRkhm ehIykgkmøaMgTaMgenHk¾manParkic©EsVgrkKijpg

EdrenAeBlEdlmankarRbCMurbs;BYkkmμaPi)alExμrRkhm.

kkaarrbbeeggááIIttkkggTT½½BBbbddiivvttþþnn__kkmm<<úúCCaa

Bak;B½n§eTAnwgkarbegáItkgT½Bbdivtþn_ CnCab;ecaT nYn

Ca )anbBa¢ak;fa bkS)ankMNt;ykéf¶TI12 Exmkra qñaM

1968 KWCakalbriecäTénkarbegáItkgT½Bbdivtþn_. eRkay

BIclnae)aHe)arenAsMLÚt kgTB½rbs;ln; nl; )aneTAb®gáab

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 9

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 12: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

y:agsahaveXareXA. edaykarP½yxøacnUvkarb®gáabenH

RbCaCnenAsMLÚt)anrt;eTArs;enAtaméRBPñM ehIybnÞab;mk

GñkTaMgenaHmanKñaRbEhl7nak; )annaMKñaeTAvayRbharelI

b:usþ×b:UlIsenA)aydMraM ehIy)anrwbGUsykGavuF)anmYy

cMnYn. bnÞab;BIkarvayenA)aydMraMenH kgkmøaMgTaMgenaH)an

bnþvayCabnþbnÞab;eTAelIkgTB½rbs; ln; nl; rhUteTAdl;

17extþ.

enAGMLúgeBlénkarsaksYredjedalenHmankarkt;

smÁal;eXIjfa CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anBüayameqøIytb

esÞIrRKb;sMNYrEdlecARkmecaTsYrmkelIxøÜn edayerobrab;

)any:agek,aHk,ayBIRbvtiþskmμPaBts‘Urbs;xøÜn. enA

eBlmankarsaksYredjedalBIsMNak;shRBHraCGaCJa

EdlCaGñkecaTRbkan;dak;bnÞúkmkelIxøÜn CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca

PaKeRcIn)anbdiesF b¤GHGagfa xøÜnminyl;GMBIGIVEdl

shRBHraCGaCJacg;sYrmkelIxøÜneLIy. minRtwmEtb:ueNÑaH

CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anBüayambdiesFmþgehIymþgeTot

eTAelIPsþútagEdlshRBHraCGaCJa)anbgðajenAGMLúg

eBlsvnakar.

22¦ CCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT eeGGoogg ssaarrII

eRkayBIkarsYredjedalCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca GMBI

Rbvtþirbs;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa nigRbvtþisavtarrbs;Cn

Cab;ecaTrUbenH elakecARkm nil Nun )anbnþsYrCnCab;

ecaT eGog sarI edayepþatEteTAelIeQμaH nigRbvtþirUbrbs;

CnCab;ecaTrUbenHEtb:ueNÑaH. edayELk sMNYrepSg²

Bak;B½n§eTAnwgGgÁehtuEdl)anecaTRbkan;enAkñúgdIkadMeNaH

Rsay CnCab; ecaT eGog sarI )anrkSasiT§imineFVIkareqøIy

tb. enAeBlelakecARkm nil Nun esñI[CnCab;ecaT

erobrab;BIRbvtþisikSarbs;xøÜnemFavIrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI KWelak ém:xl xaNav:as; )aneFVIkarCMTas;edaymin[

kUnkþIrbs;xøÜneqøIytbeTAnwgsMNYrrbs;elakRbFanGgÁCMnMu

CRmH edayemFavI)anelIkeLIgfa enAExtula qñaM2011

kUnkþIrbs;xøÜn)andak;BaküesñIsMumYyeTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHsala

dMbUg edaysMurkSasiT§ ienAes¶ómmineqøIytbeTAnwgsMNYr

TaMgLayEdlecaTsYredayPaKIrYcehIy. emFavI)anbBa¢ak;

fa ecARkmGacsYrsMNYrTUeTAEdlBak;B½n§nwgkarkMNt;Gtþ

sBaØaNrbs;kUnkþIrbs;xøÜnEtb:ueNÑaH. elakemFavI xaNav:as;

k¾)aneFVIsMeNIeTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHGnuBaØat[kUnkþIrbs;xøÜnGannUv

esckþIEføgkarN_sþIBIkar{rkSasiT§ienAes¶ómmineqøIytb}enA

kñúgsvnakarCasaFarN³ edIm,IeCosvagkarsMNYrNamYy

mkelIkUnkþIrbs;xøÜnbnþeTot edayGHGagfa karrkSasiTi§min

eFIVskçIkmμ b¤mineqøIynwgsMNYrrbs;PaKIenaH KWCasiT§iEdl

RtÚv)anFanaedayrdæFmμnuBaØrbs;RbeTskm<úCa. eyageTA

elIsMeNIenH GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anseRmc[CnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI GanesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;xøÜnsþIBIeKalCMhrkñúgkarmin

eqøIytbeTAnwgsMNYrenAeBlsvnakar. CnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI )anEføgfa ³

{´)aTsUmeRbIR)as;siT§irbs;´kñúgrdæFmμnuBaØ

edayrkSasiT§ienAes¶ómmineqøIytbnwgsMNYr

TaMgLaynaeBlenH. siT§ienHmanEcgkñúgmaRta

31 nig38 énrdæFmμnuBaØénRBHraCaNacRk

km<úCa. ´)aTmanbMNgeRbIR)as;siT§ienHenA

kñúgkarCMnMuCRmHTaMgmUl ehIyminmanbMNg

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrNamYyeLIy}.

cb;esckþIEføgkarN_enHPøam elakemFavI xaNav:as;

)anegIbQr nigbBa¢ak;bEnßmCUneTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa kUnkþIrbs;

xøÜnnwgeRbIsiT§ienHedaymineqøIytbeTAnwgsMNYrNamYyenA

RKb;dMNak;kalénnItiviFITaMgGs; rYmTaMgcMNucTaMgLayEdl

)anecaTRbkan;enAkñúgdIkabBa¢ÚnerOgeTACMnMuCRmHpgEdr.

33¦¦ CCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT eexxoovv ssMMppnn

eexxoovv ssMMppnn eessññIIssMMuueeFFIIVVeesscckkþþIIEEfføøggkkaarrNN__nniiggbbddiieessFF

mmiinneeqqøøIIyyssMMNNYYrrrrbbss;;PPaaKKII

eRkayeBlCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )aneRbIR)as;siTi§

mineFIVskçIkmμenAkñúgsvnakar GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anepþImbnþnItiviFI

rbs;xøÜn edayeFIVkarecaTsYreTAelICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn.

10 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 13: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

muneBlénkarcab;epþImsMNYr emFavIkarBarkþIGnþrCatirbs;

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn EdleTIbnwgTTYlsÁal;edayGgÁCMnMu

CRmHkalBIéf¶TI21 Exvicäka qñaM2011 knøgmk KWelak

GakTYr EvkEKn (Arthur Vercken) )anegIbQr nigbBa¢ak;eTA

GgÁCMnMuCRmHGMBIeKalbMNgrbs;kUnkþIrbs;xøÜnfa kUnkþIrbs;

xøÜnnwgeqøIytbRtwmEtsMNYrTaMgLayEdlecaTRbkan;mk

elIxøÜnenAkñúgdIkadMeNaHRsayEdl)anGanedayRkLabBa¢I

kalBIéf¶TI5 ExFñÚ qñaM2011 knøgmkEtb:ueNÑaH. karsYr

edjedaleTAelICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn cab;epþImeday

RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHelakecARkm nil Nun edayepþateTAelI

RbvtþirUb nigRbvitþsikSarbs;CnCab;ecaTrUbenH. CnCab;

ecaT exov sMpn )anCRmabeTAtulakarfa eRkABIeQμaH exov

sMpn xøÜnmaneQμaHbdivdþmYyeTotfa Ehm ehIyminEdl

maneQμaH xag dUcCakarelIkeLIgrbs;CnCab;ecaT Duc

eLIy. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday exovsMpn )anTTYlsÁal;fa

xøÜnFøab;)aneRbIeQμaH Nn enAeBlEdlxøÜnrs;enA PUmiPaKnirtI.

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;CUneTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa xøÜn

ekItenAéf¶TI27 Exkkáda qñaM1931 enAXMurMeck RsukrMdYl

extþsVayerog. man«BukeQμaH exov Lúg nigmanmþayeQμaH

lI Kg; ehIymanbgb¥ÚnTaMgGs;12nak; nigmanRbBn§eQμaH

sU suCati man kUn4nak;. kalenAv½yekμgxøÜn)ansikSaenA

bzmsikSa nigGnuviTüal½yenAkñúgextþkMBg;cam nigbnÞab;mk

xøÜn)anpøas;mkeronenATIRkúgPñMeBjenAviTüal½yRBHsIusuvtßi.

enAcenøaHqñaM1951 nigqñaM1953 xøøÜn)aneFIVCaRKÚbeRgón

edImI,pÁt;pÁg;CIvPaB nigsikSaEpñkc,ab;enAÉTIRkúgPñMeBjrhUt

dl;TTYl)anGaharUbkrN_eTAsikSaenAÉRbeTs)araMgenAqñaM

1953 nigRtLb;mkkm<úCavijenAqñaM1958. enAeRkay

karsYredjedalBIRbvtþirUb nigRbvtþisikSaBIsMNak;elak

RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anesñIsMueTAGgÁ

CMnMuCRmHedImI,GanesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;xøÜnEdl)aneRtóm

TukrYcCaeRsc nigbBa¢ak; CUneTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa xøÜnnwgmin

eFIVkareqøIytbnwgsMNYrTaMgLayEdlecaTsYredayKUPaKI

mkelIxøÜneLIy rhUtdl;eBlEdlshRBHraCGaCJabgðaj

PsþútagEdlecaTRbkan;RbqaMgnwgxøÜn. b:uEnþmunnwgGnuBaØat

[CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn GanesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;xøÜn

RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHKWelakecARkm nil Nun )anGanbTecaT

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 11

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

eeGGoogg ssaarrII

ssYYgg ssuuIIeeKKOOnn

eexxoovv ssMMppnn

Page 14: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

Rbkan;TaMgLay nigbgðajBIsiTi§EdlCnCab;ecaTmaneTAdl;

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn. bnÞab;mkGgÁCMnMuCRmHk¾)anGnuBaØat

[CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn cab;epþImeFIVesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;

xøÜnEdleRbIR)as;ry³eBlRbmaNCag1em:ag nig30naTI.

enAkñúgesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;xøÜn CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn

)anBüayameFIVkareqøIytbeTAtamlMdab;lMedaycMeBaHral;

cMNucTaMgLayEdlRkLabBa¢I)anGanecjBIdIkadMeNaHRsay

enARtg;kfaxNÐTI1126 kfaxNÐTI1128-1129 nig

kfaxNÐTI1598-1600EdlecaT Rbkan;RbqaMgnwgxøÜn.

enAkñúgesckþIEføgkarN_enaH CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )an

erobrab;y:aglm¥itBIskmμPaBsMxan;²rbs;xø ÜnBIrvagqñaM

1953rhUtdl;qñaM1975 edayEbgEckeTAtamlMdab;én

RBwtþikarN_nImYy² Edlcab;epþImGtßaFib,ayBIry³kal

EdlxøÜneronenARbeTs)araMg mUlehtuEdlnaM[xøÜnrt;cUl

kñúgéRBenAqñaM1967 skmμPaBeRkaykarpÞúHrdæRbharqñaM

1970 nigtYnaTIenAkñúgbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa.

sskkmmμμPPaaBBGGMMLLúúggeeBBlleerroonneennAARRbbeeTTss))aarraaMMgg nniiggeeRRkkaayy

eeBBllRRttLLbb;;mmkkvviijj

eqøIytbnwgkarecaTRbkan;mkelIxøÜnEdlmanenAkñúg

kfaxNÐ 1126 nig1159 éndIkadMeNaHRsayTak;Tgnwg

skmμPaBenAeBlEdleronenARsuk)araMg CnCab;ecaT exov

sMpn )anelIkeLIgfa eBlEdlxøÜnenARbeTs)araMgxøÜnmin

Edl)anCYbnwg b:ul Bt eT KWCYbEt eGog sarI b:ueNÑaH.

enATIenaH exov sMpn )anCYbnwgmitþPkþicas;rbs;xøÜnmñak;Edl

Føab;eronCamYyKñaenAviTüal½yRBHsuIsuvtßi eQμaH »k suKn§

)anesñI[xøÜncUlrYmkñúgclna m:aksIus b:uEnþxøÜn)aneqøIytb

eTAvijfa xøÜnRKan;Etcg;)anÉkraCüb:ueNÑaH ehIyxøÜnminsÁal;

m:aksIusGVIeT. eBlenaHelak »k suKn§ )anR)ab;xøÜnfa

m:aksIusenHehIyEdlGacnaMeTArkÉkraCüsRmab;RbeTs

km<úCa. CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbnþfa eRkaymkxøÜnk¾

)ancUlrYmBinitüGegátenAkñúgclnaenHedImI,kMu[eKfaxøÜnCa

mnusSkMsak. EtedaysarsßanPaBneya)aytwgEtgenA

eBlenaH xøÜnk¾)anseRmccitþpøas;eTATIRkúgm:ugeb:lIey: enA

TIRkúgm:ugeb:lIey:enHehIyEdlxøÜn)ansikSaCMnajEpñkc,ab;

nigBaNiC¢kmμ RsbeBlCamYyKñaenaHCnCab;ecaTrUbenHk¾

)ancUlrYmRbCMuCamYynwgrgVg;m:aksIusenATIenaH. CnCab;

ecaT exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;fa bIqñaMeRkaymkxøÜnk¾)anpøas;

mkTIRkúg)a:rIsvij edImI,erobcMeFIVniekçbbTfñak;bNÐitrbs;

12 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 15: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

xøÜnxagviTüasa®sþesdækic©. enATIenaHehIyEdlxøÜn)ancUlrYm

RbCMuCaeTogTat;CamYynwgvg;m:aksIus. eRkaykarRtLb;

cUlRbeTsvijrbs; eGog sarI CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn

)anTTYlParkic©bnþBI eGog sarI kñúgkarCYybMpusclna

esñhaCatienAkñúgrgVg;BYkm:aksIus enATIRkúg):arIsenaH.

CnCab;ecaT exovsMpn)anGHGagfa enAeBlEdlxøÜn

emIleXIjsemþc sIhnu )anbdiesFkarRbkasCaÉketa

PaKIBIsMNak;GgÁkaresGatU dak;RbeTskm<úCa[sißtenA

eRkammøb;rbs;GgÁkarenH ehIyBüayamy:agGg;Gackñúgkar

Tak;TgEpñkkarTUtCamYyRkúmRbeTsEdlRbkan;ykrbb

sgÁmniym eFIV[xøÜnsgÇwmfa km<úCanwgGaceFIVkMENTRmg;

esdækic© nigsgÁmrbs;xøÜnedImI,TTYlRbB½n§esdækic©ÉkraCü

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 13

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

eexxoovv ssMMppnn

Page 16: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

mYyrbs;xøÜn dUcEdlRbeTsCb:unFøab;)aneFIV. dUecñHehIy

eTIbxøÜnseRmceRCIserIsykRbFanbT {bBaðaén]sSahUb

nIykmμkm<úCa} edImI,eFIVCaniekçbbTrbs;xøÜn edayeCOfa[Et

manviFankarsmRsb nayTunCatimYynwgGacrIklUtlas;

)an. enAkñúgniekçbbTenaH CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anecaT

CasMNYrsMxan;mYyfa {ehtuGVI)anCaehdæarcnasm<½n§esdækic©

enAeBlenaHminGac[mankarGPivDÆn_RbeTskm<úCa?} enaH

KWedaysarEtTMnij]sSahkmμrbs;)araMgmkRbkYtRbECg

CamYysib,kmμExμr EdlCaehtueFIV[esdækic©km<úCakøayCa

esdækic©ksikmμGn;fyeTAvij. enAkñúgenaHCnCab;ecaT exov

sMpn )anelIkeLIgnUvRTwsþIrbs;esdæviTUCnCati eGkUs mñak;

eQμaH Gadam sμIt EdlfardæRtÚvEtkan;kab;BaNiC¢kmμeRkA

RbeTs edImI,eFIVCa]bkrN_sRmab;CYydl;karrIklUtlas;

énsib,kmμ ehIytRmg;kmøaMgkargareTAxagBaNiC¢kmμ.

CnCab;ecaT exovsMpn )anbBa¢ak;fa enAkñúgniekçbbTrbs;xøÜn

xøÜnminEdlKaMRT[mankarlubbM)at;kareRbIR)as;luy lub

bM)at;kmμsiTi§ÉkCn b¤lubbM)at;TIRkúgenaHeT. enAGMLúg

eBlrs;enARbeTs)araMg exov sMpn )ancUlrYmbkSkumμúynIsþ

)araMgenAqñaM1955 nigcUlrYmenAkñúgkareFIV)atukmμRbqaMg

nwgs®gÁamenAevotNam nigs®gÁamenARbeTsGal;ehSrI

edayKitfa karts‘Urbs;RbCaCnEdlrs;enAeRkamnwmGaNa

niKmniym nigeFIV[GaNaniKmniymcuHexSay EdlGaceFIV[

RbeTskm<úCaqab;TTYl)anÉkraCüqab;rh½s. CnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn )anBüayamGHGagfa karTTYl)anÉkraCürbs;

RbeTskm<úCaBIsMNak;RbeTs)araMg minEmnedaysarRBHraC

bUCnIykic©rbs;RBH)aTsemþc neratþm sIhnu eT b:uEnþKW

edaysarEtkarts‘Urbs;RbCaCnevotNam nigC½yCmñH

rbs;evotNamenAsmrPUmi eDonebonPU eTAvijeT. CnCab;

ecaT exovsMpn)anelIkeLIgfasaxabkSkumμúynIsþrbs;xøÜn

KWxusKñaBIsaxabkSkumμúynIsþrbs; b:ul Bt eGog sarI nig rdæ

saemOn EdlCasaxabkSkmμkr rIÉsaxabkSrbs;xøÜnenA

tammhaviTüal½y. eRkaymkxøÜnk¾)anseRmccitþQb;

cUlrYmRbCMuCamYynwgbkSkumμúynIsþenaH edaysarEteK

elIkeLIgEtBIbBaðarbs;)araMg. eRkayeBlRtLb;mk

RbeTskm<úCavijenAqñaM1958 Cn Cab;ecaT exov sMpn

)anGHGagfa xøÜnminEdlmanTMnak;TMngCamYybkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCaeLIy eRBaHkarTak;TgCamYynwgbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

enaHGacnwgeFIV[xøÜnmaneRKaHfñak; edaysarman Kijtamdan

xøÜnCanic© sUmI,enAeBlEdlxøÜneFIVCatMNagra®sþ nigCardæ

elxaRksYgBaNiC¢kmμ. Tak;TgnwgkarkfaxNÐ1127 én

dIkadMeNaHRsayEdlelIkeLIgfa kaEstEdlCnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn )anecjpSayCakaEstEdl]btßmedayBYk

kumμúynIsþenaH RtÚv)anCnCab;ecaT exov sMpn GtßaFib,ay

faGñkEdl]btßmkaEstrbs;xø ÜnPaKeRcInminEmnCaGñk

kumμúynIsþeT eTaHbICamanGñkkumμúynIsþxøHk¾eday eRBaHBYkeK

CatMNagra®sþénsPaCati dUcCah‘Uyn;hU‘ nwmG‘uc Evn nigsU

En CaedIm. CnCab;ecaT exovsMpn )anrMB£kfa enAeBlRtLb;

mkRbeTskm<úCavij h‘U nwm nig h‘U yn; EdlCamitþPkþieron

CamYyKñaenAÉRbeTs)araMg )anesñI[xøÜnecjkaEstmYy

edImI,bgðajBIsMeLgrbs;yuT§Cn kaEstenaHe)aHBum<Ca

Pasa)araMg KWkaEstGubesva:T½r (L’Observateur).kaEst

enHecjpSaykñúgeKalbMNgKaMRTdl;clnaGBüaRkwtürbs;

semþc sIhnu nigsgwÇmfaGaceFIV[mankarcuHfyKmøat

CIvPaBRbCaCn)anxøHeRBaHkaEstenHe)aHBum<eLIgsMedA

sRmab;GñkdwknaMRbeTsGan edaysarGñkdwknaMenAeBlenaH

cUlcitþGankaEstCaPasa)araMg rIÉRbCaCnsamBaØminsUv

manGñkGankaEstenaHeLIy. CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )an

bgðajBIkartieToneTAdl;semþc neratþmsIhnu enAkñúgesckþI

EføgkarN_rbs;xøÜn enAeBlEdlCnCab;ecaTrUbenHniyay

dl;karecaTRbkan;kaEstrbs;xøÜnfaCa kaEstRkhm b¤

kaEstkumμúynIsþ. exov sMpn GHGagfa Baküfa kaEst

RkhmenHKWecjmkGMBIsemþc sIhnu cab;epþImmankarP½y

RBÜyBIKMnitÉkraCürbs;xøÜn. manéf¶mYyenaH xøÜnRtÚv)an

ekaHehAeTAsYrcemøIyenARksYgb:UlIsBiess enAeBlEdl

14 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 17: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

kaEstcab;epþImdMeNIrkar edayrdæm®nIþRksYgmhaépÞeQμaH

KU ruN )ansaksYrxøÜnedaypÞal;. exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;fa

enAeRkayeBlEdlxøÜnRtÚv)aneKedaHElg[RtLb;eTAvij

xøÜn)ansresrral;sMNYrTaMgLay Edl KU ruNsYrmkxøÜn nig

cemøIyTaMgLayEdlxøÜn)aneqøIyTaMgGs;edImI,TukcuHpSay

enAkñúgGtßbTkaEstrbs;xøÜnenAeBlEdlxøÜnRtLb;eTAvij.

CnCabe;caT exovsMpn )anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜncg;bgðajeTAtulakar

nUvsMNYrcMnYnBIrEdlrdæm®nþIRksYgmhaépÞeQμaH KU ruN enaH

)ansYrmkkan;xøÜnenAGMLúgeBlénkarsaksYrenaH. CnCab;

ecaT exov sMpn )anerobrab;fa sMNYrTImYyEdl KU ruN

)ansYrxøÜnKWfa {etIehtuGVIk¾GñkÉgs¥b;RBHbrmraCvaMgxøaMg

emø:H?} rIÉsMNYrTI2KWfa {ehtuGIVk¾GñkÉgminRBmeFIVkarraCkar

eRkayeBleroncb; EbrCaeFIVkaEsteTAvij? etIGñkÉgcg;

eFIVesþcb¤? ebIcg;eFIVesþcRby½tñedkenAkñúgmugeQI. Cn

Cab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbnþeTotfa ry³eBlbIExeRkayBI

karsYrcemøIyrbs;elakrdæm®nþI KU ruN manmnusSmYyRkúm

)ancab;vayeFIV)ab nigcab;sRmatexaGavrbs;xøÜnenAkNþal

pøÚv ehIykaEstrbs;xøÜnk¾RtÚv)aneKbBa¢a[biT. eRkaymk

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn k¾RtÚv)aneKcab;xøÜndak;Bn§naKar

ry³eBlmYyExedayKμandIkacab;xøÜnBItulakar. CnCab;

ecaT exov sMpn )anbnþfa enAqñaM1962 xøÜnRtÚv)anCab;

ecaTeqñatCatMNagra®sþénrbbsgÁmra®sþniym bnÞab;mk

RtÚv)ancat;taMgCardæelxaFikarRksYgBaNiC¢kmμedayPøam²

EdlkarEtgtaMgCardæelxaFikarenHRtÚv)anCnCab;ecaT

rUbenHGHGagfaRKan;EtCakarTijTwkcitþrbs;xøÜnBIsMNak;

semþc sIhnu Etb:ueNÑaH nigbB¢ak;faxøÜnenAEtrkSaKMniteFIV

kMENTRmg;esdækic©rbs;xøÜnCanic© eTaHbICaRtÚvTTYltMENg

enHk¾eday. enAGMLúgeBlEdlxøÜnmantMENgCardæelxaFikar

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )ancab;epþImman»kaskñúgkarTak;Tg

CamYynwgm®nþIEdlmanbTBiesaFeRcIn dUcCa elaksWnsan

elak mat; tg; nig elak Eb:n nut edImI,sÞabsÞg;BIlT§PaBkñúg

kareFIVkMENTRmg;esdækic©. exov sMpn )anCRmabeTAGgÁCMnMu

CRmHfa xøÜnFøab;)anBiPakSaCamYynwg elak sWn san Edl

mantYnaTICaeTsaPi)alFanaKarCatienAeBlenaHGMBIbBaða

karlYcbnøMrUbiyvtßúbreTsedImI,lk;enAkñúgTIpSarggwtEdl

bgá[mankarRBÜy)armÖcMeBaHesdækic©Cati edaysarEtenA

kñúgTIpSarCak;Esþg 1duløarshrdæGaemrik KWbþÚr)anRtwmEt

30erolb:ueNÑaH b:uEnþ1duløardEdleKGaclk;)an200

erolenAkñúgTIpSarggwt. KeRmagénkareFIVkMENTRmg;RtÚv

)anTTYlykedayelak sWn san bnÞab;mkelak sWn san

kar)anykKeRmagenaHeTAfVaysemþcRBHneratþmsIhnu

edImI,seRmcBIbBaðaenH. exovsMpn )anbEnßmfa

{semþc sIhnu eBlenaHk¾elakRBÜy)armÖBI

karEdlkm<úCakan;EtrNbCMnYyGaemrikkan;

EtxøaMgeLIg²ÉGaemrikecHEtKRmamkat;CMnYy

dUecñHCMnYyGaemrikeRbób)aneTAnwgkaMbitP¢g;

km<úCaCab;. KeRmagrbs;´enH k¾RtÚv)an

semþcsBVRBHT½yy:agqab;rh½s.}

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anKUsbBa¢ak;edayGs;

sMeNIcfa bnÞab;BIkarTTYlykKeRmageFIVkMENTRmg;BIsMNak;

semþcneratþmsIhnu ehIyxøÜnRtÚv)anFøak;BItYnaTICardæelxa

RksYgBaNiC¢kmμedaysarEtbBaðasac;eKaeLIgéfø. Cn

Cab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbnþfa karFøak;BItMENgenHKW

edaysarEtsemþc sIhnu RBÜy)armÖxøacxøÜnmanRbCaRbiy

PaBCagRBHGgÁ edaysarKeRmageFIVkMENTRmg;enaHKWxøÜnCa

GñkbegáIteLIg.

enAGMLúgeBlEdlCnCab;ecaT exov sMpn kMBugEt

erobrab;GMBIskmμPaBrbs;xø ÜnenAGMLúgeBlénrbbsgÁm

ra®sþniymrbs;RBH)aTsemþcRBH neratþmsIhnu TaMgecARkm

TaMgRKb;PaKI nigGñkcUlrYmTaMgGs;enAkñúgbnÞb;svnakar)an

sßitenAkñúgPaBs¶at;es¶óm edayepþatkarykcitþTukdak;rbs;

xøÜneTAelIBaküsmþIEdl exovsMpn elIkeLIg.

mmUUlleehhttuuEEddllnnaaMMrrtt;;ccUUllééRRBBeennAAqqññaaMM11996677

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )ancab;epþImbnþerobrab;GMBI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 15

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 18: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

mUlehtuEdlnaM[xøÜnrt;cUléRBenAqñaM1967 EdlmanelIk

eLIgenAkñúgdIkadMeNaHRsayRtg;kfaxNÐ1128 nigkfaxNÐ

1600. exov sMpn )anGHGagenAkñúgesckþIEføgkarN_

rbs;xøÜnfa³

{EdlnaM[´rt;cUléRBenH KWCakarbgçMcitþ.

citþ´ ´cg;bnþeFIVkargarrbs;´CatMNagra®sþ

b:uEnþ́ Kμan[pøÚvÉNaepSgeToteTeRkABIrt;ecj

BIPñMeBj BIeRBaHsnþisuxrbs;´ElgFana)an

eTotehIy. ´RtÚveKKMramcab; ehIynaMxøÜneTA

tulakarswk eRkamelsfa´CaemnaM[ksikr

bHe)arenAsMLÚt karBit´TaMgsÁal;fasMLÚtenA

ÉNapg. ehIy´k¾mineCOfa ksikrnaMKña

bHe)aredaysarEtkaEst´júHjg;enaHeLIy

eRBaHeKminGanGkSr)araMgeT.}

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbnþeTotfa cab;taMgBIqñaM

1966 semþc neratþm sIhnu RtÚv)ankmøaMgxagsþaMrbs;

elak ln; nl; EdlsiñTCamYynwgGaemrikh‘uMB½T§RBHGgÁCit

EdlCaehtueFIV[RTg;yl;fakarP¢ab;TMnak;TMngCamYynwg

shrdæGaemrikkøayCaerOgmYysMxan; ehIygakmkvay

Rbhar nigKMramcab;cgRkúmEdlniymeTAxageqVg EdleFIV[

xøÜnRtÚvbgçMcitþrt;ecjBITIRkúgPñMeBjehIykøayeTACarbs;

EdlmantémøsRmab;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaenAeBlenaH.

eeRRkkaayykkaarrppÞÞúúHHrrddææRRbbhhaarrqqññaaMM11997700

Tak;TgnwgkarpÞúHrdæRbharenAeRkayqñaM1970enA

Rtg;kfaxNÐ25 nig1129éndIka dMeNaHRsay CnCab;

ecaT exov sMpn )anGHGagfa enAeRkayrdæRbharrbs; ln;

nl; Tmøak;semþc sIhnu enAkñúgqñaM1970semþc sIhnu )an

GMBavGMnav[begáItrdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatimYyenAéf¶TI23 Ex

mIna qñaM1970 enATIRkúgeb:kaMg edaymankarCYysRmÜlBI

sMNak;elak CUeGnLay. b:uEnþCab;ecaTrUbenH)anbBa¢ak;

fa karBitesckþIGMBavnavenHminEmnCasñaRBHhsßrbs;

semþcTaMgRsugeT BIeRBaHesckþIGMBavnavenHRtÚv)anelak

CUeGnLay ykeTAbgðaj saLút s ehIysaLút s )an

lubecalcMNucxøHEdlTak;TgnwgsgÁmniym. exov sMpn

)anbnþfa enAeBlenaH saLút s min)aneTACYbnwgsemþc

sIhnu edaypÞal;eTAtamkaresñIrbs; elak CUeGnLay

eLIy EtEbCasresrsMbuRtmYyc,ab;epJIeTAsemþcsIhnu

edaydak;eQμaHxøÜn hU yn; nigh‘U nwm eTAvij ehIyfasMbuRt

enHepJIecjBImUldæants‘UenAkñúgRbeTs. CnCab;ecaT exov

sMpn )anGHGagfa xøÜn)andwgkarGMBavnavenHenAeBlbnÞab;

eRkayBImankarpSBVpSaytamry³viTüúb:ueNÑaH. CnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn )anesñIsMueTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHeFIVkarkt;smÁal;nUv

cMNucsMxan;mYyeTotfa mUlehtuEdlsaLútsminRBmCYb

CamYynwgsemþc sIhnu KW edaysarEt saLút s KWCaelxa

bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa EdlCabkSrbs;ksikr Blkrkm<úCa

ts‘UvayrMlMrbbskiþPUmi. ehtuenHtRmÚv[xøÜnRtÚveFIVCas<an

rvagbkSkumμúnIsþkm<úCa nigsemþc sIhnu edImI,eFIV[manclna

bRgÜbbRgÜmCati edayminRbkan;BN’sm,úrneya)ay. enA

eBlmkdl;RtwmcMNucenH CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anecaT

sYrfa {etIenHCa]Rkidækmμb¤?} nig)aneqøIyxøÜnÉgPøam²fa

{minEmneT KWc,as;CaminEmneT}. exovsMpn)anbEnßmfa

xøÜnmindwgxøÜnfa b:ul Bt )anEtgtaMgxøÜnCa]bnaykrdæm®nþI

enAeBlenaHeLIy edayniyaykñúgTwkmuxmWugm:at; nigsmþI

mYy²nigxøaMg²fa³

{c,as;ehIy KW b:ul Bt Edl)ancat;taMg´[

TTYlmuxtMENgEdl´min)andwgesaH enaHCa

]bnaykxül;rdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsxül; GKÁ

bBa¢akarxül;.l. enAeBlEdlbkSkumμúynIsþ

km<uúCaÉeNaHeT EdlCaGñkdwknaMkarts‘UtaMg

BIs®gÁamQøbenAkñúgqñaM1968-69mkrhUt

kñúgnamCakgBlkñúgs®gÁamBIqñaM1970eTA

75. ebIdUecñaH eKenAGHGagfa´CaGñkman

GMNacFMsemI,mNas; y:agenHy:agenaH)an

eToteT. Gt;eT vaeTAminrYceT. ebI]bnayk

16 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 19: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

xül; rdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsxül; GKÁbBa¢akar

T½Bxül;. karBit´Kμan\T§iBlGVI Etbnþick¾Kμan

EdreTAelIkgT½B sUmI,EtGgÁPaBtUcmYyk¾Kμan

enAeRkambgÁab;rbs;´Edr.}

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn elIkeLIgfa xøÜnmanGarmμN_

Rbhak;RbEhlnwgCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca Edl)anniyaykal

BIéf¶TI5 ExFñÚ qñaM2011Edr eRBaHxøÜnminGacQremIlRbeTs

km<úCaEdleTIbrYcputBIGaNaniKm)araMg nigGacrMedaHputBI

kNþab;édrbs;Gaemrik ehIyEbrCaFøak;eTAkñúgkNþab;éd

kumμúynIsþevotNameLIy.

ttYYnnaaTTIIeennAAkkññúúggbbkkSSkkuummμμúúyynnIIssþþkkmm<<úúCCaa

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;eTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa

xøÜn)ancUlrYmCasmaCikbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCakñúgqñaM1969

enAelIPñM»ra:l; CamYynwg hU yn; h‘U nwm nig b:uk dWkumar

EdlRtÚv)andak;bBa©Úleday tam:uk EdlCaGñkCMnYsmux[

bkSkumμúnIsþkm<úCa. karcUlCasmaCikbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaKW

tRmÚv[manskmμPaBRbyuT§ ehIyRtÚvqøgkat;karksag

lt;dMsakl,gkñúgkarts‘Ubdivtþn_. mYyeTotRtÚvmanvNѳPaB

l¥ EdlvNѳPaBl¥enaHRtÚvEtCakUnksikrRkIRk. dUecñHexov

sMpn )anbdiesFfa xøÜnminmanlkçN³sm,tþiRKb;RKan;edImI,

bMeBjlkçxNÐTaMgenHeLIy. müa:geTot xøÜnminEmnCakUn

ksikrRkIRk eRBaHxøÜnCaGñkEdl)aneronsURtx<g;x<s;enAÉ

breTs nigminEdl)ancUlrYmts‘UbdivtþeT edaysarkarrt;

cUlkñúgéRBenaHKWeFIVeLIg edaybgçMcitþ.

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;fa karEdlxøÜn)an

cUlCasmaCikeRtóménKN³mCiÄmenAkñúgqñaM1971enaH

KWedaysarEtxøÜnmannaTICas<anP¢ab;karTak;TgrvagbkS

kumμúnIsþkm<úCa nigsemþcsIhnu. tamkarBit b:ul Bt enAEt

cat;TukxøÜnfaCamnusSrbs;rNsirS ehIyeKminEdlcat;Tuk

xøÜnfaCasmaCikbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaenaHeT. exov sMpn

bBa¢ak;eTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa smaCikbRmugénKN³mCiÄm KWKμan

siTi§GMNackñúgkarseRmcGVITaMgGs;. edayelIkCa]TahrN_

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 17

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

nnYYnn CCaa bb::uull BBtt

kkuuyy FFYYnn

Page 20: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

fasmaCikmCiÄmepSgeToteKsuT§EtmanGMNacRKb;RKg

PUmiPaK b:uEnþxøÜnCasmaCikmCiÄmnwgeKEdr KWmannaTICaRtwm

EtCaGñksresrr)aykarN_CaeTotTat;CUneTAsemþc sIhnu

eTAvij. exovsMpn )aneFIVkareRbóbeFobxøÜneTAnwg\sSrCn

enAevotNamxagt,Úg EdleRkayBIevotNamxagt,ÚgRtÚv

)anrMedaHBYkGñkTaMgenaH)an)at;eQμaHKμantMENgGVIeLIy.

CnCab;ecaTCab;ecaT exov sMpn xitxMbgðajeTAGñk

cUlrYm nigRbCaCnkm<úCafa mUlehtuEdlxøÜnminmanGMNac

seRmcGVITaMgGs;enAeBlEdlxøÜnCaemdwknaMCan;x<s;enaH KW

edaysarEt b:ul Bt nigbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaEtgEtenA

cat;TukxøÜnfaCaBYkbBaØaCn.

munnwgbBa©b;esckþIEføgkarN_rbs;xøÜn CnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;bEnßm edayelIkeLIgnUvsMNYrmYyfa

etIehtuGVI)anCaRbCaCnkm<úCaPaKeRcInelIslb;pþl;karKaMRT

rbs;eKeTAdl;clnats‘UeRkamkardwknaMrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCa? sMNYrenHRtÚv)anCab;ecaT exov sMpn bkRsay

fa ³

{tam´yl; KWedaysareKGs;sgwÇmxøaMgnwg

rbb ln; nl; EdlBukrlYydl;qäwg ehIyCa

brivardac;éførbs;shrdæGaemrik EtebIemIl

mkclnats‘Uvij eKeXIjmnusSEdleKsÁal;

c,as;faCamnusSs¥atsM¥ ehIykarBarÉkraCü

nigGFibetyüPaBCatidac;xat eKenOyNay

edayeXIjEtGMeBIBalaGav:aEs GMeBI]Rkidæ

nigGnaFibetyüenAkñúgrbb ln; nl; Éxagkar

ts‘UeKlWfa vin½ytwgrwgNas; b:uEnþeKeRtómxøÜn

nwgTTYleKarBtam BIeRBaHeKeRskXøancg;)an

nUvsgÁmmYyEdlRbkbeTAedayKuNFm’ nig

sIlFm’.}

x¦karsYredjedaledImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

enAGMLúgeBlsvnakarelIGgÁesckþITak;TgnwgkarsYr

edjedalPsþútag GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg)anekaHehAedIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNIcMnYnBIrrUbedIm,Ipþl;skçIkmμenAkú ñ úgsvna

kar. edImbNþwgrdæb,evNITImYyKWelak køan viut rs;enAPUmi

Giun XMutaLav RsukGNþÚgmas extþrtnKIrI CaCnCatikack;

nigTIBIrKWelak rm:am yun ehA xaMPI manGayu70qñaM rs;enA

PUmikacUt RsukGNþÚgmas extþrtnKIrI. nak;TaMgBIrrUb KWCa

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNIdMbUgbg¥s;enAkñúgsMNuMerOg002 Edl

RtÚv)anGgÁCMnM uCRmHekaHehA[mkpþl;skçIkmμenAkñ úgGgÁ

svnakar.

enAGMLúgeBlénkarsYredjedalenAkñúgsvnakar

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNITaMgBIrrUbhak;bIdUcCamankarlM)akkñúg

karEsVgyl;BIsMNYrrbs;PaKIEdlecaTsYrmkelIxøÜn eRBaH

PaKeRcInéncemøIyrbs;GñkTaMgBIrmin)aneqøIytbeTAnwg

sMNYrEdlRtÚv)anecaTsYrmkelIxøÜneLIy. edImbNþwgrdæ

b,evNITaMgBIrRtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHbgÁab;[manGñkCMnYymñak;

edImI,CYysRmbsRmÜl nigCYybkERbral;BaküeBcn_ nig

XøaTaMgLayNaEdlmanPaBminc,as;las; edayehtufa

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNITaMgBIrrUb CaCnCatiPaKtic ehIymin

)aneRbIR)as;PasaExμrCaPasaedImrbs;xøÜn. müa:gvijeTot

bBaðav½ycas;Cra nigsuxPaBrbs;GñkTaMgBIr k¾RtÚv)ankt;

smÁal;edayGgÁCMnMuCRmH. elakecARkm nil Nun EdlCa

RbFanénGgÁCMnMuCRmH )ancab;epþImsaksYrCadMbUgTak;Tg

nwgRbvtþirUbsegçbrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI munnwgRbKl;

evTikaeTA[PaKITaMgGs;edImI,bnþdMeNIrkarnItiviFIsaksYr

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI. bnÞab;BIkarsYrsMNYrrbs;elak

RbFanGgÁCMnM uCRmH nil Nun emFavItMNagedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNIRtÚv)anRbKl;evTika[eFIVkarsYrkUnkþIrbs;xøÜn nig

bnÞab;mkCaParkic©rbs;shRBHraCGaCJakñ úgkarsYredj

edaledImbNþwgrdæb,evNI.

11¦¦ kkaarreeFFVVIIsskkççIIkkmmμμrrbbss;;eeddIImmbbNNþþwwggrrdd,,eevvNNII kkøøaann vviiuutt

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;shemFavItMNagedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNI nigtMNagshRBHraCGnþrCatiBak;Bn§½nwgkar

cUlrYmclnabdivtþn_ elak køan viut manRbsasn_fa mun

18 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 21: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

eBlEdlxøÜncUlrYmeFVIbdivtþn_dMbUg maneKmkR)ab;fa ebImin

cUlbdivtþn_eTenaHnwgRtÚvsøab; BIeRBaHxμaMgskþiPUminwgeFVI

)ab. enAeBlB¤dUcenH xøÜn)anseRmccUlrYmeFVIbdivtþn_

CamYynwgeK. cab;;taMgBIeBlenaHmkxøÜnRtÚv)aneQμaH v:ag

nig sIu cat;taMg[xøÜneFVICanirsaedIm,Irt;sMbuRt[kmμaPi)al

nigbnÞab;mkeFVIRbFanPUmiedIm,IeFVIkarGb;rMRbCaCn nigpÁt;pÁg;

Epñkesdækic©dl;bdivtþn_. elak køan viut )anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜn

Føab;)anCYbCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI EdleBlenaH)an

eXasnaGb;rM[xitxMeFVIkaredIm,IbeRmIbdivtþn_. elIsBIenaH

eTot eGog sarI )anbeRgóndl;emPUmi emXuM ku M[ehA

evotNamfayYn eRBaHevotNam Lav nigkm<úCaKWCabgb¥Ún

CIdUnmYy. bEnßmelIenHelak eGog sarI EfmTaMg)an

RbkasR)ab;fñak;Rsúk fñak;XuM [yl;BIGVICaxμaMg nigGIVCasRtÚv

eTotpg. elak vuit )anGHGagfa enAeBlenaH CnCab;ecaT

eGog sarI nYn Ca exov sMpn nig bu:l Bt KWmantYnaTICa

KN³PUmiPaK|sanþ. elak køan viut )aneFVIkarbBa¢ak;Cacug

eRkayfa mUlehtuEdlGgÁkareRCIserIsykCnCatiPaKtic

[cUleFVIbdivtþn_ edaysarCnCatiPaKticKWCamnusSl¶g;

mindwgGVICaxμaMg GVICabdivtþn_enaHeLIy.

22¦¦ kkaarreeFFVVIIsskkççIIkkmmμμrrbbss;;eeddIImmbbNNþþwwggrrdd,,eevvNNII rrmm::aamm yyuunn

elak rm:am yun KWCaedImbNþwgrdæb,evNITIBIr

Edl)aneFVIskçIkmμenAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH. eqøIytbnwg

sMNYrrbs;emFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI nigtMNag

shRBHraC GaCJaGnþrCati elak rm:amyun manRbsasn_fa

xøÜnRtÚv)aneKeXasna[cUlrYmeFVIbdivtþn_edIm,IrMedaHCati

nigbeRmIRbeTs[mankarrIkceRmIn bu:EnþeRkaymkGIV²min

dUckareRKagTukenaHeT. elak yun )anbBa¢ak;fa karcUl

bdivtþn_enHmankarbgçMxøHGt;xøH BIeRBaHGñkxøHmanbMNgcUlrYm

ksagCati ehIyGñkxøHeTotRtÚv)aneKbgçM[cUlrYmeFVIbdivtþn_

eday[BYkeKykRTBüFn;xøHedIm,IpÁt;pÁg;bdivtþn_. edImbNþwg

rdæb,evNIrUbenH)anbEnßmfa enAmunqñaM1975 xøÜnKWCaGñk

rt;sMbuRt[kmμa Pi)altUcFM CaBiessrt;sMbuRt[eQμaH v:an;

EdlCaKN³PUmiPaK|sanþ.

eRkayBIshRBHraCGaCJa sYrelak rm:am yun

RbFanGgÁCMnM uCRmHseRmcp¥ak nItiviFIsYredjedaledIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNIrYbenH ehIycab;epþImsYreTAelIsakSI Lúg

nrinÞ.

enAkñúgsvnakarenaH shemFavIkarBarkþI[CnCab;

ecaTTaMgbIRkúmminTan;man»kaskñúgkarsYredjedaledIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNITaMgBIrrUbenHeLIy edaysarEtkarsYr

edjedaledImbNþwgrdæb,evNITaMgBIrrUbenHRtÚv)anp¥akenA

RtwmBak;kNþalTI. GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anRbkasfa nItiviFIsYr

edjedaledImbNþwgrdæb,evNITaMgBIrrUbenHnwgRtÚveFVIbnþ

enAExmkra qñaM2012. mUlehtuEdlnaM[mankarRbkas

p¥ak;nItiviFIsYredjedjedaledImbNþwgrdæb,evNITaMgBIr

enH edaysarEtbBaðasuxPaBrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

TaMgBIrrUbmankarcuHexSay. CaBiessCagenHeTAeTot

GgÁCMnMuCRmHTukeBlevlaenHedIm,IsYrykcemøIyrbs;sakSI

KWelak Lúg nrinÞ EdlGgÁCMnM uCRmHKt;smÁal;faCakar

caM)ac;EdlRtÚvsþab;skçIkmμrbs;elak Lúg nrinÞ mun edaysar

sakSIrUbenHmanv½ycas;CraehIyEfmTaMgmanCm¶ WEfm

eTot.

K¦ karsYredjedalsakSI

enAkñúgnItiviFIénsvnakarelIPsþútagkñúgdMNak;kal

TImYy GgÁCMnM uCRmHsaladMbUg)anebIkkarsaksYrsakSI

TImYy KWelak Lúg nrinÞ EdlCaGtItbuKÁlikenARksYgkar

breTsenAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü nigCasakISdak;

bnÞúkrbs;shRBHraCGaCJa. karsYredjedalsakIS Lúg

nrinÞ eFVIeLIgenAeRkaykarp¥akkarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;edIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNIcMnYnBIrrUbxagelIedaysarEtbBaðasuxPaB.

karebIksvnakarsYredjedalsakIS Lúg nrinÞ muneKRtÚv

)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHpþl;ehtuplfaedaysarsakSIrUbenHman

v½yCra nigmanbBaðasuxPaB. m:üagvijeTot edaysar

bBaðasuxPaB v½ycas;Cra nigmanCMgWRbcaMkay GgÁCMnMuCRmH

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 19

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 22: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

)anseRmcGnuBaØat[sakISrUbenHGaceFIVskçIkmμBIcm¶ay

tamry³RbB½n§esatTsSn_ BIlMenAdæanrbs;elakenAextþ

bnÞaymanC½y edaymankarsRmbsRmÜlBIsMNak;GgÁPaB

KaMBarsakIS nigGñkCMnaj. enAGMLúgeBleFIVskçIkmμ buKÁlik

rbs;GgÁPaBKaMBarsakIS nigGñkCMnajmñak; RtÚv)anGnuBaØat

edayGgÁCMnMuCRmH[GgÁúyenACitsakIS Lúg nrinÞ edImI,CYy

sRmÜl nigbBa¢ak;sMNYrTaMgLayEdlsakISrUbenHminGac

sþab;B¤ b¤lM)akyl;GMBIsMNYrTaMgLayEdlecARkm nigPaKI

énsvnakarecaTsYr. elak Lúg nrinÞ RtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmH

saksYredjedalGMBIRbvtþisavtarrbs;elaktaMgBIeBl

munénrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü rhUtdl;kardYlrlMénrbb

ExμrRkhm. b:uEnþedaysarbBaðabec©keTsénRbB½n§esat

TsSn_ nigbBaðsuxPaBtRmÚv[sakISrUbenHesñIsMuGgÁCMnMuCRmH

cUlbnÞb;TwkCajwkjab; EdlbNþal[karpþl;skçIkmμBIcm¶ay

enHmansPaB rGak;rGYl nigmanPaByWty:av.

elak Lúg nrinÞ )aneqøIytbCaeRcIneTAsMNYrrbs;

GgÁCMnM uCRmH nigPaKIénsvnakarEdlecaTsYrmkelIxøÜn

Tak;TgnwgRbvtiþsikSa nigRbvtþikargarEdlFøab;)aneFVIkar

CamYynwgCn Cab;ecaT eGog sarI nigCnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§

enAmuneBl GMLúgeBl nigeRkayeBl énrbbkm<úCaRbCaFib

20 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

nniissSSiittkkMMBBuuggeemmIIllRRbbvvttþþiirrUUbbeemmddwwkknnaaMMEExxμμrrRRkkhhmmTTaaMMggbbII

Page 23: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

etyü.

RRbbvvttþþiissaavvttaarr

enAGMLúgeBlénkarsaksYredjedal elakLúg nrinÞ

)anelIkeLIgfa elakekItenAkñúgqñaM1938 bc©úb,nñrs;enA

PUmidUg XMum:aéL Rsukm:aéL extþbnÞaymanC½y. elak Lúg

nrinÞ ehA riT§ CaGtItnisSitFøab;)aneTAsikSaenARbeTs

eqkUsøÚv:aKI ry³eBl10qñaM kñúgGMLúgqñaM1960dl;qñaM1970

b¤1971 xagEpñkkayGb;rM kILa nigR)aN.

bnÞab;BIkarGMBavnavrbs;semþcRBH neratþm sIhnu

enAqñaM1970 elak nrinÞ )an RtLb;mkBIRbeTseqkUsUv:aKI

rYceFVIkarenATIRkúgeb:kaMg\mYYyry³. enA

TIRkúgeb:kaMg elak)ancUlrYmkñúgclnamYy

Edlmansemþcneratþm sIhnu CaRbFan.

enATIenaHelak)aneFIVkarenAkñúgRksYgkar

breTsénrdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatirbs;semþc

sIhnu edaymantYnaTICaGñkvayGtßbT

bkERbPasa nig vaysMbuRtepSg²sRmab;

Tak;TgBIRbeTsmYyeTARbeTsmYy nigBI

clnamYyeTAclnamYy. eRkayBIcak

ecjBITIRkúgeb:kaMg elak Lúg nrinÞ )an

mkbeRmIkargarenAkñúgsßanIyviTüúrN³sirS

rYbrYmCatiRbCaFibetyü enATIRkúghaNUy

RbeTsevotNam edayman eGog FIriT§

CaGñkRKb;RKg. elak nrinÞ )anGHGagfa

elak)ancUlbeRmIkarenATIenaHedaysμ½RK

citþ bnÞab;BIB¤CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI niyay

faviTüúenHk¾Cakarts‘UmYyEdr {eFVIkarenA

TIenaHehIycaMRtLb;eTARsúkvijk¾)an}.

enAGMLúgeBlbeRmIkarenAsßanIyviTüúenaH

elak nrinÞ )anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnmanmuxgarCa

GñkbkERbsMbuRtEdlmanelxsm¶at;mk

CaPasaExμredIm,IpSBVpSayeTAkñúg nigeRkA

RbeTs nig)aneFVICaGñkGb;rMsisSEdlman«BukmþayFøab;

rs;enATIRkúghaNUyeTotpg. eRkayBIcakecjBITIRkúg

haNUy elak nrinÞ )anRtLb;mkRbeTskm<úCavij

nigcUlbeRmIkargarenARksYgkarbreTsenAkñúgGMLúgénrbb

km<úCaRbCaFibetyüEdlman eGog sarI Cardæm®nþI. sakIS

rUbenH)anbnþfa enAdMNak;kalenaH RksYgkarbreTsRtÚv

)aneKehAfaCamnÞIrb-1 enATIenaHxøÜnmanmuxgarCaGñkvay

GtßbT nigeFIVkargarBak;B½n§nwglixitqøgEdnsRmab;GñkEdl

ecjcUlRbeTskm<úCa. CagenHeTAeTot elak nrinÞ Føab;)an

eTAbeRmIkarenAmnÞIrb-20Gs;ry³eBlRbEhl6Exnig

eRkaymkenAmnÞIr b-15. enAGMLúgénrbbkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyüdEdlenH elak Lúg nrinÞ k¾Føab;RtÚv)anEcgtaMg[

beRmIkarenAkñúgRBHbrmraCvaMg edaymanmuxgarCaGñkkarBar

semþc neratþm sIhnu xN³EdlRTg;Kg;enACaRBHRbFanrdæ

Gs;ry³eBlRbEhl6Ex.

TTMMnnaakk;;TTMMnnggrrvvaaggssaakkSSII LLúúgg nnrriinnÞÞ TTaaMMggCCnnCCaabb;;eeccaaTT eeGGoogg

ssaarrII nniiggbbuuKKÁÁlleeppSSggeeTToott

sakIS Lúg nrinÞ )anbBa¢ak;fa enAxN³eBlEdlelak

eFVIkarenAmnÞIrb-1 elakRtÚv)anGgÁkarsg½SyfaCaPñak;gar

esIukarN_sm¶at; es>GIu>Ga. enAeBlenaH CnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI )anbgÁab;[elaksresrRbvtþirUbpÞal;xøÜnrYcepJICUneTA

CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI tamry³elak sYg sIueKOn EdlCa

emRkúmrbs;xøÜn. sakSIrUbenH)anbnþfa xøÜnsÁal;CnCab;ecaT

eGogsarI dMbUgtamry³elak fac; Ca KWCamitþPkþieronCamYy

KñaenAeBlCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI nigPriyaKWCnCab;ecaT

eGog FIriT§ eFVIdMeNIrrYmKñaCamYyRKÜsareTAeRkARbeTs.

kalenaHelakRKan;EtsÁal;eQμaH eGog sarI b:ueNÑaH min

Tan;manTMnak;TMngCamYyKñaenAeLIyeT. bnÞab;mkelak)an

CYbnwgCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI enATIRkúghaNUy enAxN³

eBlEdlCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )aneFIV]eTÞsnamenAkñúg

kic©RbCMuenATIenaH. CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI Føab;)anRbCMuR)ab;

buKÁlikenAkñúgRksYgkarbreTsfa xøÜnnwgmin GnuBaØat[nrNa

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 21

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 24: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

mñak;naMykbuKÁlikénRksYgenHecjeTANaCadac;xat enA

eBl EdlxøÜnminenA. elak Lúg nrinÞ )anerobrab;R)ab;GgÁ

CMnMuCRmHfa xøÜnminmanTMnak;TMngCamYyCnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI eToteTbnÞab;BIqñaM1979 ehIyk¾mindwgfa eGog sarI

rs;enATINaEdrenAeBlbc©úb,nñenH. b:uEnþenAkñúgkarelIkeLIg

rbs;shRBHraCGaCJa)anbBa¢ak;fa enAkñúgqñaM1994 elak

nrinÞ Føab;mantYnaTICaGKÁelxaFikarénclnabRgÜbbRgÜm

CatiRbCaFibetyü EdlmanCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI Ca

RbFan. elak nrinÞ )an[dwgfa clnaenHenAEtmandl;

sBVéf¶ b:uEnþ minmanskmμPaBGVIeT.

enAeBlEdltMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati elak

eDl lIsak; sYrfaetI fac; Ca CanrNa elak nrinÞ )aneqøIy

tbfaeQμaH fac; Ca CaGñkEdlFøab;eronenAsalaCamYy Kña

nigFøab;elg)al;enAkñúgRkúmCamYyKña ehIyk¾CabuKÁlmñak;

EdlmanTMnak;TMngCamYyrdæaPi)al ln; nl;. b:uEnþelak

min)anbBa¢ak;GMBImuxgarrbs;buKÁlenHeT. elak nrinÞ

)anpþl;skçIkmμeTotfa edaysareBlevlaknøgmkyUrNas;

eTAehIy dUcenHelakminc,as;eTfa etIbuKÁlenHRtÚv)ankUn

sisScab;eFVIcMNab;xμaMgenAqñaM1974 nigeRkaymkRtÚv)an

)aj;smøab;CamYyrdæ m®nþIRksYgGb;rMenaH b¤y:agNa.

sakSIrUbenH)anbBa¢ak;GMBImUlehtuEdlxøÜn)anehAeQμaH

fac; Ca fa {Ga fac; Ca} enAkñúgRbvtþirUbrbs;xøÜnCUneTAGgÁ

CMnMuCRmHk¾dUcCashRBHraCGaCJaEdlkMBugsYrGMBIbBaðaenH

fa xøÜnehAEbbenH KWedaysarEtmanmitþPaBCitsñitCamYy

Kña. elak nrinÞ )anbBa¢ak;bnþfa elak)andwgerOgrbs;

eQμaH fac; Ca CaPñak;garesIubkarN_ es>GIu>Ga edaysar

eQμaHenHEtgEteTAsßanTUtGaemrikEdlCaRbeTsesrI xus

RsLHBIxøÜnEdlEtgEtTak;TgCamYyRbeTsGBüaRkwtü nig

RbeTssgÁmniym.

enAeBlEdleFVIkarsaksYrGMBITMnak;TMngCamYynig

kmμaPi)alExμrRkhmdéTeTot EdlmaneQμaHenAkñúgRbvtþirUb

rbs;xøÜn elak Lúg nrinÞ EdlCasakSIxagRBHraCGaCJa

RtÚv)anshRBHraCGaCJargGnþrCatisYrmþgehIymþgeTot

GMBIPaBsÞak;esÞIrkñúgkareqøIytbeTAnwgsMNYrTaMgLayEdl

ecaTsYrmkelIxøÜn. shRBHraCGaCJarg elak eDl lIsak;

)anbgðajBIPaBmnÞileTAnwgcemøIyrbs;sakSI maneBlxøH

shRBHraCGaCJayl;fasakSIBüayamminbeB©ajeQμaH

GtItRbFanrbs;xøÜn KWCnCab;ecaT eGogsarI enaHeT. elak

Lúg nrinÞ k¾RtÚv)anshRBHraCGaCJasYredjedalBITMnak;TMng

rbs;xøÜnCamYybuKÁlmYycMnYneTot EdlbuKÁlTaMgenaHrYmman°

1¦ tUc xaMeDOn nig hak;esog LaynI GtItbuKÁlikenA

RksYgkarbreTsCamYyKña eRkaymkRtÚv)ancab;xøÜn.

2¦ eTB sMGat GtItGKÁrdæTUt Føab;eFVIkarenAeb:kaMg

CamYyKña eRkaymkRtÚveKbB©ÚaneTAmnÞIrs-21.

3¦ va:n; BinI CaGtItelxaTI2 enATUteGhSIúb Føab;eFVIkar

CamYyKñaenAeb:kaMg.

4¦ KatQn; GtItbuKÁlikenARksYgkarbreTsCamYy

Kña b:uEnþenAEpñkniBn§.

5¦ CYn RbsiT§ Føab;eFVIkarCamYyKña.

6¦ Qn éh GtIteFVICakgkarBarsemþc neratþm

sIhnu enAkñúgvaMg.

7¦ elakhak; esogLaynI RtÚv)anGgÁkarcab;TaMgbþI

RbBn§

8¦sarin qak Føab;eFVIkarCamYyenATIRkúg eb:kaMg.

9¦sU hug CakμÜyrbs; b:ul Bt EdlmanEteQμaHenA

RksYgkarbreTs.

elak Lúg nrinÞ )anbBa¢ak;fa enAxN³eBlEdlxøÜn

eFIVkarenAkñúgmnIÞrb-1 elakEtgEtmankarP½yxøaccMeBaH

Baküfa {eTAeronsURt} edaysarenAeBlenaH karbBa¢ÚneTA

eronsURt KWeKbBa¢ÚneTAmnÞIrsnþisuxs-21 nigsaxarbs;

mnÞIs-21 dUcCamnÞIrbwgRtEbk nigmnÞIrRcaMgcMerH.

shRBHraCGaCJa elak eDl lIsak; )anesñIsMu[

sakIS Lúg nrinÞ Bnül;GMBIXøamYy Edl)ansresrenAkñúg

RbvtiþrUbsegçbrbs;xøÜnfa ³

22 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 25: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

{kñúgry³kalsikSaCIvitrbs;´KWexμAggwtsøúgsøúb

Tak;TgnwgBYkEdleRkaymkk,t;RbeTsCati nigcUlédnwgBYk

Gak,t;;. mü:ageTotkarrs;enAk¾mins¥ats¥M KWdUrluykak;rk

sIucgkarman)an.sIlFm’narIbursk¾mins¥ats¥M. edaysar

KuNGgÁkar eyIg´)anvilmkrkpøÚvRtÚvpøÚvbdivtþn_km<úCa. ´

)anxitxMksagxøÜntamkarENnaMrbs;GgÁkar}.

enARtg;cMNucenHsakSI Lúg nrinÞ )anBnül;fakar

sresrenaHKWRKan;Etcg;bBa¢ak;faxøÜnesμaHRtg;nwgGgÁkar

b:ueNÑaH minmanlak;elomGIeT ehIykalenAeronvamanerOg

EbbhñwgnaM[eBlbdivtþn_KWRtÚvxMRbwgEkxøÜn. eqøIytbeTAnwg

sMNYrEdlelakshRBHraCGaCJasYrfaetIelakmandwgeTfa

eQμaHEdl)anelIkeLIgenAkñúgRbvtþirUbrbs;elakenaHcug

eRkayKWRtÚv)aneKnaMykeTAkan;mnÞIrs-21. elak Lúg

nrinÞ )aneqøIyfaxøÜnmindwgBImUlehtuEdleK[sresrRbvtþi

rUbenHeT ehIyk¾mindwgfamanerOgGVIbnÞab;BIkarsresrenH

Edr b:uEnþelakmanCMenOfa RbEhlCaGgÁkarcg;dwgBITMnak;TMng

rbs;xøÜnCamYynrNaxøH.

enAkñúgsvnakarénkarpþl;skçIkmμedaysakSI Lúg nrinÞ

RkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn minmansMNYr

saksYreTAsakSIrUbenHeLIy. manEtRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab; ecaT nYn Ca nigRkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI b:ueNÑaH Edl)ansYredjedal.

enAmuneBlbBa¢b;karsYredjedalsakIS elak Lúg

nrinÞ mancMNucEdlKYrkt;smÁal;mYyKWfa CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca

)anesñIsMuGgÁCMnMuCRmHedIm,IsYrsakSI Lúg nrinÞ. CnCab;ecaT

nYn Ca )ansYrsMNYreTAsakSI Lúg nrinÞ edaysMdImaM²GMBI

karTTYl\T§iBlBI suWg g:ukfaj; EdlCaGñkRbqaMgnwgRBH

mhakSRt. elak nrinÞ eqøÍytbbdiesFedaysMdImYy²fa

xøÜnmin)anTTYl\T§iBlBI sWug g:ukfaj; eT. xøÜneBjcitþnwgkar

ts‘Urbs;elak suWg g:ukfaj; cMeBaHkarts‘URbqaMgnwg)araMg

ÉskmμPaBepSgeTot KWGt;eT. CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca ecaT

sYrbnþeTotfaetIelakFøab;manniyayfamansmancitþ

cMeBaH suWg g:ukfaj; edaysarbuKÁl enHRbqaMgnwgesþc nig

GaNaniKm)araMgEdrb¤eT? elak Lúg nrinÞ )aneqøIytbfa

kalenaHyuvCnExμrKWG‘Icwg ecHEtCeyaeTA EteRkaymk

)anTTYlkarGb;rMeTIbdwgfakareFIVEbbenHminl¥. CnCab;

ecaT nYn Ca )anbnþsMNYrrbs;xøÜneTotfaetIelakmanCab;

ninñakarneya)ayCamYy hg; Funhak; EdlCaédsþaMrbs;

sWug g:ukmij nigeRkaymkenAqñaM1972 eLIgCanaykrdæ

m®nþIenaHEdreT? etIelaksÁal; eGo sIucUv EdlCaédsþaM

rbs; suWg g:ukfaj; eT? nigsMNYrcugeRkayfaetIeQμaH

TaMgGs;Edlelak)anelIkenAkñúgRbvtþirUbrbs;elakenaH

etIBYkenHmaneFVIskmμPaBCamYysuWg g:ukfaj; eT? etIskmμ

PaBGVIxøH? elak Lúg nrinÞ )anbdiesFeTAnwgsMNYrTaMgGs;

xagelIrbs; nYn Ca CamYynwgBaküfa mindwg nigminsÁal;.

esckþIsnñidæan

svnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nigBinitüPsþútagEdl

erobcMeLIgedayGgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgnaeBlenH KWRKan;

EtCasvnakardMNak;kaldMbUgEdlepþatelIRbvtiþénbkS

kumμúynIsþkm<úCa nigsavtarrbs;CnCab;ecaTmñak;²Edl

ykecjBIEpñkmYyéndIkadMeNaHRsayedImI,ecaTsYrCn

Cab;ecaT edImbNþwgrdæb,evNIsakIS nigGñkCMnajEtb:ueNÑaH.

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsYredjedalTak;TgnwgRbvtþibkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCa nigsavtarrbs;CnCab;ecaT GgÁCMnMuCRmHnwgbnþykGgÁ

ehtuepSgeToténdIkadMeNaHRsaymkBiPakSasYredjedal

nigBinitüPsþútagEdlTak;TgnwgGgÁehtuTaMgenaH.

karpþl;skçIkmμrbs;CnCab;ecaT sakSI nigedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNI EdleFVIeLIgenAGMLúgeBlsvnakar)anCYbRbTH

nUvbBaðamYycMnYn edaysarEtGgÁCMnMuCRmHmanPaBlM)akkñúg

karkMNt;EbgEckeBlevlasRmab;PaKInanakñúgkarsYredj

edalenAkñúgsvnakar EdlCaehtueFIV[mankarBnüareBl

karsYredjedaledImbNþwgrdæb,evNI sakIS nigCnCab;ecaT

enAGMLúgeBlsvnakar. m:üagvijeTot bBaðasuxPaB v½ycas;

Crarbs;CnCab;ecaT sakSI nigedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI bBaða

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 23

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 26: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

bec©keTskñúgkareRbIR)as;RbB½n§esatTsSn_edIm,IsaksYr

sakSI nigkarCMTas;rbs;PaKIenAkñúgGMLúgeBlsvnakark¾)an

bgáPaBlM)akeTAdl;GgÁCMnMuCRmH nig)anTajdMeNIrkarnItiviFI

min[eTAmuxelOn dUcEdlGgÁCMnMuCRmHcg;)aneLIy.

eTaHCay:agNa svnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nig

BinitüelIPsþútagEdlRbRBwtþeFIVeLIgnaeBlenH KWCadMeNIr

vivDÆn_fμImYyeTotrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmHvisamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa

kñúgkarEsVgrkyutþiFm’ nigkarBit EdlRbCaCnkm<úCaTUTaMg

RbeTs)anTnÞwgrg;caMGs;ry³eBlCit32qñaM.

bBaðaepSg²

enAGMLúgeBlénkarGanGgÁehtuEdlmanenAkñúgdIka

dMeNaHBIsMNak;RkLabBa¢IénGgÁCMnMu CRmH CnCab;ecaT exov

sMpn )ansþab;karGanGgÁehtuecaTRbkan;RbqaMgnwgxøÜn

edayykcitþTukdak; ehIyenAerogral;eBl CnCab;ecaTrUb

enH)an»nmuxsresrenAelIRkdas Edldak;enAelIturbs;

xøÜnedImI,eRtómeFIVkareqøIytbeTAnwgkarecaTRbkan;TaMgenaH.

maneBlxøH CnCab;ecaTrUbenH)angakeTABiPakSaCamYy

m®nþIsMNMuerOgEdlGgÁúyenACitxøÜnCajwkjab;.

kñúgsvnakarelIPsþútagkalBIéf¶TI6 ExFñÚ qñaM2011

EdleFVIkarBiPakSaedjedalGMBIRbvtþirbs;bkSkumμ únIsþ

km<úCa nigRbvtþisavtarrbs;CnCab;ecaT GgÁCMnuMCRmH)an

ekaHehAedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIcMnYnBIrrUbedIm,IeFVIkarsaksYr.

enAkñúgkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFI shemFavI GnþrCatikarBarkþICn

Cab;ecaT nYn Ca KWelak ém:eXIl epsþEmn )anesñIsuM[edIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNIRtÚveFI Vsm,fmuneBlpþl;skçIkmμenH.

eqøIytbeTAnwgkarelIkeLIgxagelI elakecA Rkm nil Nun

)anbBa¢ak;edaysMdIc,as;²fa enAkñúgRkmnItiviFIRBhμTNÐ

ExμrqñaM2007 nigviFanépÞkñúgrbs;GgÁCMnuHCRmHkñúgtulakar

km<úCa mintRmÚv[edImbNþwgrdæb,evNIeFVIkars,feLIy.

elak eBC GgÁ emFavInaMmuxtMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI)an

bdiesFcMeBaHkarelIkeLIgrbs;emFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT

nYn Ca faedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIKWCaPaKIenAkñúgsMNuMerOg

dUecñHKat;mansiT§iniyayTaMgGgÁehtu nigGgÁc,ab; enAkñúg

eBleFVIskçIkmμ. elakemFavI eBC GgÁ )anbnþeTotfa enA

eBlEdledImbNþwgrdæb,evNIpþl;skçIkmμGMBIGgÁehtu KWmin

viFanNamYyGacEkERbzan³rbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI[eTA

CasakSI)aneLIy. eqøIytbeTAnwgbBaðaenH elakecARkm

hSg;m:ak LWEvg k¾)anelIkeLIgGMBIc,ab;km<úCaEdlcmøg

ecjBIc,ab;)araMg KWcat;TukedImbNþwgrdæb,evNICaPaKImYy

enAkñúerOgkþI. elakecARkmrUbenH)anbnþeTotfa edaysar

zan³enHedImbNþwgrdæb,evNImincaM)ac;s,fenaHeT ehIy

Gacpþl;skçIkmμGMBIBüsnkmμEdlxøÜnTTYlrg b¤GgÁehtuEdl

Bak;B½n§eTAnwgCnCab;ecaT)an.

enAéf¶TI7 ExFñÚ qñaM2011 enAeBlGgÁCMnuMCRmHeFVIkar

saksYreTAelIedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI emFavIGnþrCatirbs;Cn

Cab;ecaT eGog sarI KWelak ém:eXIl xaNav:as )aneFVIkar

kt;smÁal;nigesñIsuMeTAGgÁCMnuMCRmHmþgehIymþgeTotGMBIkar

sMu[mankarhamXat;cMeBaHkarR)aRs½yTak;TgKñarvagedIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNICamYynwgemFavIxø ÜnnigGñkepSgeTot.

elakemFavI xaNava:s )anbnþfa karR)aRs½yTak;TgenaH

GacnwgnaM[mankarb:HBal;dl;kareFVIskçIkmμ edaysarEt

karpþl;skçIkmμrbs;buKÁlenaHminTan;)anbBa©b;enAeLIy.

elak kaNav:as )anpþl;ehtuplfa enAkñúgc,ab;)araMg edIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNIminGaceFVIkarTak;TgCamYyemFavI)aneT

kñúgeBlsvnakarEdlkarN__enHvamanlkçN³pÞúyBICnCab;

ecaT. eqøIytbeTAnwgcMNucTaMgenaH shemFavInaMmuxtMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI elakeBC GgÁ )aneqøIytbfa enAkñúg

krNIenHminKYrmankarEbgEcksiT§i[manlkçN³xusKñarvag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI nigCnCab;ecaTkñúgkarR)aRs½yTak;Tg

CamYyemFavIrbs;xøÜneLIy. elakeBC GgÁ )anGHGagfa

vanaM[manPaBminesμIKña edaysarCnCab;ecaTmansiTi§RbwkSa

eyabl;CamYyemFavIenARKb;dMNak;kal cMENkedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNIEbrCaminmanenaH. elakemFavIbnþeTotfaKμan

viFanNamYyEdlhamXat;min[edImbNþwgrdæb,evNICYb

24 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 27: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

CamYyemFavIrbs;xøÜnenAkñúgkrNIenHeT. bEnßmeTAelIkar

elIkeLIgrbs;elak eBC GgÁ emFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæ

b,evNI elak emgXI )aneFVIkarCMTas;TaMgRsúgeTAelIkar

elIkeLIgrbs;emFavIkarBarkþI elak xaNav:as fa kareFVI

EbbenHvanaM[xuseTAnwgTMenomTmøab;kñúgkarGnuvtþc,ab;enA

km<úCa nigviFanépÞkñúgEdlGnuBaØat[edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

mansiT§iTTYlkarkarBarplRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnenARKb;dMNak;

kal. dUecñHkarR)aRs½yTak;Tgrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

CamYyemFavIrbs;xøÜn KWCasiT§imYyEdlKμannrNamñak;Gac

eRCótERCk)aneLIy ehIysiT§ienHk¾dUcCasiT§iR)aRs½y

Tak;Tgrbs;emFavIkarBarCnCab;ecaTCamYykUnkþIrbs;xøÜn

Edr. PøamenaH edaysarbBaðaEdlPaKIelIkeLIgman

lkçN³dEdl²elakRbFanecARkm nil Nun )aneFVIkar

bBa¢ak;GMBIviFan88¬2¦. viFanenHkMNt;sRmab;EtCnCab;

ecaT sakSI nigGñkCMnajbu:eNÑaH EdlmintRmÚv[mankar

R)aRs½yTak;TgKña ehIyenHKWCakarbBa¢ak;[eXIjBIzan³

xusKñarvagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI nigsakSI. edayeyageTA

elIviFanenHdEdledImbNþwgrdæb,evNImintMrUv[s,fenA

eBleFVIskçIkmμ ehIyKat;mansiTi§TamTarsMNgEdlsakSIBuM

mansiT§ienHeLIy. elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH RKan;EtbBa¢ak;

y:agxøIfaedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIGacTak;TgCamYyemFavIrbs;

xøÜnedayesrI.

enAkñúgéf¶TI15 ExFñÚ qñaM2011 xN³eBlEdlsh

RBHraCGaCJakMBugtaMgsMNYrelICnCab;ecaT nYn Ca GMBIesovePA

mYyk,alEdlmanbTsmÖasn_EdlCnCab;ecaTrUbenH)an

eFVICamYynwgelak eft sm,tþi mkeFIVkarsaksYredjedal

elakemFavI sun GruN EdlCaemFavIkarBar[CnCab;ecaT

nYn Ca )aneFIVkarbdiesFeTAnwgkarelIkeLIgenaH. elak

emFavI GruN )anGHGagfa esovePAenaHKWminGacykCa

kar)aneT eRBaHmanPasaEtmYy KWGg;eKøs edayminmanCa

PasaExμr nig)araMg. elakbnþeTotfa esovePAenHeXIj

manlk;enAÉpSar ehIyesovePAenHmindwgfashRBHraC

GaCJa)anBINaedIm,ImkeRbIR)as;pøÚvkarenaHeT KWxøÜnminTTYl

sÁal;CapøÚvkareT. eBlenaHelakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHyl;

fa karCMTas;rbs;elakemFavI sun GruN smRsb ehIy

bgÁab;[shRBHraCGaCJaminRtÚvsYredjedalBIesovePA

EdlelIkeLIgenaHeLIy eRBaHesovePAenHminTan;)andak;

enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmHenAeLIy. karsYrTak;Tgnwgxøwmsar

enAkñúgesovePAenHGgÁCMnMuCRmHminTan;)anseRmcenAeLIy.

Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenH elakemFavIGnþrCatikarBarkþICnCab;

ecaT exov sMpn )anesñIeTAGgÁCMnMuCRmH[kMNt;GMBIeBl

evlasmRsbEdlGacelIkykbBaðaénkardak;PsþútagenH

mkseRmc. bnÞab;BIkarBiPakSarvagecARkmenAkñúgsvnakar

rYcmk RbFan GgÁCMnMuCRmHelakecARkm nil Nun RbKl;

Parkic©eTA[elakecARkm hSg;m:ak LWEvg kñúgkareqøIytb

eTAnwgsMeNIenH. elakecARkm LWEvg )aneqøIytbfa GgÁ

CMnMuCRmH)anTTYlnUvkardak;ÉksarBIPaKIenaH ehIyvaRtÚv

kareBlevlaCaeRcInkñúgkarseRmc. dUcenHGgÁCMnMuCRmH

nwgeFVIkarseRmcenAedImqñaMeRkayenH edaymansvnakar

BiessmYysRmab;viPaKeTAelIkarbgðajPsþútag FatupSMén

PsþútagEdlmankarBak;B½n§mYycMnYneTAnwgdIkadMeNaHRsay

edIm,IseRmcBIPaBTTYlyk)anénPsþútagnigkarvaytémø

énPsþútagnImYy².

enAkñúgGMLúgeBlsvnakarsþIBIkarsYredjedal nig

BinitüPsþútag eXIjfamankarrGak;rGYlEpñkbec©keTs

mYycMnYn edayeBlxøHGñktamdandMeNIrkarnItviFIBIsal

svnakarsaFarN³min)anTTYlsMeLg eBlxøHmansMeLg

ecjBIbnÞb;rbs;GñkbkERbPasa EdlelIkeLIgfa xøÜnmin

)anTTYlsMeLgBIkñúgbnÞb;svnakar EdlRtÚvesñIsMueTAecARkm

b¤PaKI[niyaysaCafμImþgeTot.

RbtikmμCMuvijesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;CnCab;ecaT

QQUUkk EEkkbb GGaayyuu5522qqññaaMM mmkkBBIIeexxttþþeeBBaaFF××ssaatt;; eennAAPPUUmmii

bbwwggcckk XXMMuussüüaa RRssuukkkkeeNNþþóógg eexxttþþeeBBaaFF××ssaatt;;..

´)ansþab;elak nYn Ca ´KitfaGVIEdlKat;niyayKW

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 25

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 28: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

)at;karBiteRcIn dUcEdlKat;niyayfa kñúgsm½yhñwg[hUb

mYyéf¶bIeBl EtebIkalenaH´enAkñúgrbbhñwgEdr KWmindUc

BaküKat;faeT eTaHbIenAextþeBaF×sat;eFVIRsÚv)aneRcIn EtGt;

[RbCaCnhUbRKb;RKan;eT KW[hUbbbrBIreBlv:al;Evk

EckKñamYykMb:ug40nak;. enAeBlKat;niyayfadUcenH KW´

manGarmμN_xwg EtnwkeXIjfaTb;citþ ehIyGVIEdl´cg;)anKW

[Kat;niyaykarBit enAeBlEdlKat;niyayfaGt;dwg

´dUcCaGn;citþeRBaHRKÜsarrbs;´RtÚv)aneKykeTAsmøab;

ecal ehIyRKÜsarbgRsIrbs;´RtÚv)aneKykeTAsmøab;

TaMgGs;edaysarbþIrbs;Kat;Føab;eFVITah‘an ln; nl;.

eellaakk ssaann;; rruunn mmkkBBIIXXMMuubbJJssSSIIRRkkaass RRssuukkeemmaaggbbJJssSSII

eexxttþþ))aatt;;ddMMbbgg..

elak run )anmanRbsasn_fa karN_Edlelak nYn

Ca niyayfaKat;mindwgBIkarsmøab;enArbbkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyü KW´mineCO eRBaHKat;CaGñkkan;cgáÚt dUcenHebIKat;min

bBa¢a enaHKμannrNah‘an. cMENkkarEdlKat;niyayfa

mankarhUbRKb;RKan;enaH ´rwtEtmineCOmYyryPaKry

eRBaHenAkñúgkardæannImYy² GgármYykMb:ugRtÚvhUbBI30eTA

40nak;k¾man eK[hUbbbrsuT§EtTwk KWsøab;nwgGt;)ay

eRcInNas;.mYyéf¶eK[hUbEtBIreBlKat;niyayPaKeRcIn

CaBaküPUtPr karN_EdlKat;niyayfarbbkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyühUb1éf¶bIeBl RBwk éf¶ l¶ac nigmanbEg¥m KWniyay

kuhk eRBaHminEdl)anbEg¥mhUbeT.

mm::aann ssUURRtt GGaayyuu7788qqññaaMM mmkkBBIIRRssuukk))aarr::aayy eexxttþþkkMMBBgg;;FFMM..

elak sURt )ancUlrYmsþab;svanakar ehIyenAeBl

EdlKat;)anlWCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca niyayBIkarbriePaK

GaharmYyéf¶bIdg elakmanRbtikmμfa {karN_EdlKat;

niyayfa rbbGahar3eBlenaH KWvaGt;RtÚv eRBaHCMnan;

enaH)anEtBIreBlenaHBi)akpg bbrTaMgRBwk TaMgl¶ac Et

CYnkalman)ayxøH cMENkbEg¥mminEdlman.´manGarmμN_

xwgeRBaHKat;niyayminRtÚv ehIyeBlRBHraCGaCJasYr Kat;

EtgEtniyayBegVógmineqøIy dUcenHGVIEdl´cg;)an KWsMu[

niyayEtRtÚvmkfa ebIBIreBlfaBIreBl ebIbIeBlfabIeBl

niyayykEtRtÚv}.

llIIss ssMMbbUUrr eePPTTRRbbúúss GGaayyuu5555qqññaaMM rrss;;eennAAXXuuMMCCbb;;vv::aarrII

RRssúúkkRRBBHHeennRRttRRBBHH eexxttþþbbnnÞÞaayymmaannCC½½yy..

eBlB¤ nYn Ca niyayfamYyéf¶[)ayRbCaCnhUb

bIeBlenaH ´mankarxwgxøaMgNas; BIeRBaHkalCMnan;enaHeK

[´hUbEtbbrBIreBlbu:eNÑaH ehIyminEdlmanbEg¥mGI

enaHeT EtebIeBlcUlqñaM)anmþg. eK[eyIgeFVIkareRcIn Et

minEdl)anhUbeT ehIykarniyayEbbenH KWCakare)ak

R)as;eyIgeT. kalenaHeFVIERs)aneRcInEdr bu:Enþmindwgfa

eKykRsÚveTANa.

mm::kk;; vvNNÑÑII eePPTTRRbbúúss GGaayyuu5511qqññaaMM mmuuxxrrbbrrCCaakkssiikkrr

rrss;;eennAAPPUUmmiiRRssúúkkRRBBHHeennRRttRRBBHH eexxttþþbbnnÞÞaayymmaannCC½½yy..

kalCMnan;ExμrRkhm´eFVIkarenAkñúgkgcl½telIkGag

RtBaMgfμ ehIykarhUbcukCYbkarlM)akeRcInmanEt)aymYy

can Gt;manmðÚbeT hUbCamYyTwkRbhukdl;eRkaymkGt;

man)ayeTmanEtbbrehIyeFVIkarTaMgyb;TaMgéf¶. kñúgry³

eBlEdlKat;kan;GMNacbIqñaM R)aMbIEx émÖéf¶enaH ´minEdl

)anhUbbEg¥meT ehIydl;eBlB¤Kat;niyayGIcwg´Gn;citþ

ekþARkhayNas; eRBaHfaKat;CaGñkdwknaMTaMgmUlKat;famin

dwg ehIykarniyaydUecñH RKan;EtCakarniyayedaHsaryk

rYcxøÜnbu:eNÑaH.

ppgg;; ccrriiyyaa eePPTTRRssII GGaayyuu2211qqññaaMM CCaanniissSSiitteennAAssaakkll

vviiTTüüaall½½yyCCaattiiRRKKbb;;RRKKgg EEppññkknnIIttiissaa®®ssþþ..

´yl;fakarelIkeLIgrbs; nYn Ca niyayfaKat;

karBarCati bu:Enþ´KitfakarEdlKat;eFVIenaHKWkarbMpøajCati

eTAvijeT BIeRBaHebIKat;karBarCatiKat;minbeNþay[RbCaCn

Exμr Føak;cUleTAkñúgrbbExμrRkhm EdlnaM[mankarxUcxat

eRcInTaMgCIvitmnusS karEbk)ak;RKÜsar salaeron mnÞIr

eBTüCaedIm. ebItamsþab;«Bukmþay Kat;Føab;R)ab;´fa

enAsm½yExμrRkhm eKeFIV)abRbCaCn bg¥t;)ay nig[eFIV

kareRcIn.

26 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 29: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

tulakarkMBUlseRmcbdiesFkarbgÁab;[edaHElg

eGog FIriT§ edayKμanlkçxNÐrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmHsala

dMbUg

enAéf¶TI14 ExFñÚ qñaM2011 tulakarkMBUlénGgÁCMnMu

CRmHvisamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa)an ecjesckþIseRmcmYy

edaymanmtiPaKeRcInelIslb; seRmcbdiesFelIesckþI

seRmcrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgEdl)anbgÁab;[edaH

Elg CnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§ eday\tmanlkçxNÐ tam

BakübNþwgeTAGgÁCMnMuCRmHtulakarkMBUlrbs;shRBHraC

GaCJa cuHéf¶TI18 Exviciäka qñaM2011. enAkñúgbNþwg]T§rN_

enaH shRBHraCGaCJaelIkeLIgfa GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg

)anseRmcedaHElgCnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§ edayEp¥keTA

elIGgÁehtu nigGgÁc,ab;EdlmankMhus nig)anGnuvtþn_nUv

qnÞanusiTi§rbs;xøÜnedayminsmRsb. shRBHraCGaCJa)an

esñIsMueTAGgÁCMnMu CRmHtulakarkMBUl[eFIVemaXPaBeTAelI

esckþIseRmcrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg EdlbgÁab;[

edaHElgCnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§ edayKμanlkçxNÐ nigesñIsMu

[EkERbeTAelIesckþIseRmcenaH edaybnþdak;CnCab;ecaT

[enAsßitenAkñúgmnÞIrXMuXaMgedImI,TTYlkarBinitüeraKvinicä½y

b¤karBüa)alepSg² nigeFIVkarBinitüsaCafμIenAerogral;6

Exmþg dUcCakarENnaMrbs;GñkCMnajEdl Føab;)aneFIVeLIg

enAkñúgsvnakar.

Bak;B½n§nwgkarkMNt;BIsm,Tarbs;CnCab;ecaT eGog

FIriT§ kñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakar GgÁCMnMuCRmHéntulakarkMBUl

)anelIkeLIgfa GgÁCMnuMCRmHsaladMbUgmankMhuseday

xkxanmin)anRbwgERbg[Gs;BIlT§PaBkñ úgkarcat;viFan

karBüa)al dUcEdlGñkCMnaj)anpþl;Gnusasn_edIm,I[

suxPaBsμartIrbs;CnCab;ecaTmanPaBRbesIreLIg.1

GgÁCMnMuCRmHtulakarkMBUl)anbEnßmfa {edayBicarNaelI

karrkeXIjrbs;GñkCMnajevC¢sa®sþ nigedaykt;smÁal;

elIkarkMNt;BIsm,TakñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakarEdlCabBaða

Ktiyutþ GgÁCMnuMCMrHtulakarkMBUlyl;eXIjfa ral;viFankar

EdlGaceFVI)ankñúgkareFVI[suxPaBsμartIrbs;CnCab;ecaT

RbesIreLIgenaH minRtÚv)anriHrkenaHeT}.2 GgÁCMnMuCRmH

salakMBUl)anpþl;sMGagehtufa {eyabl;rbs;evC¢bNÐit

cn xaMEb‘l EdlENnaM[sakl,geRbIfñaM Donepezil Gac

manRbsiT§iPaBcMnYn 33PaKry KWbgðajGMBIPvnIyPaBEdl

minKYrRtÚv)anbdiesFtamTsSn³énplRbeyaCn_saFarN³

enAkñúgkarkat;esckþI}.3 eRkABIGnuvsasn_rbs;evC¢bNÐit

cn xaMEb‘l GgÁCMnM uCRmHtulakarkMBUl)aneyageTAelI

r)aykarN_rbs;GñkCMnajEpñkviklviTüaEdl)anpþl;Gnu

sasn_fa {karrkSacMnYnbuKÁlik nigbuKÁlikdEdl karrkSa[

manbrisßandEdl karbt;EbnedIm,IsRmbeTAnwglT§PaB

ERbRbÜlrbs;Kat; kareFVIlMhat;R)aNedaymankarvay

témø nigdMbUnμanBIGñkÉkeTsBüa)alEpñksrIr³ enAeBlEdl

RtÚvkar nigkarKaMRTkarcUlrYmkñúgskmμPaBEdl Kat;eBjcitþ.

bEnßmelIenHkmμviFICMrujstibBaØaEdlmanrcnasm<½n§Rtwm

RtÚvGacCYy)anEdr bu:EnþkmμviFIEbbenHRtÚvGnuvtþcMeBaHGñk

Edl)anTTYlkarhVwkhat; nigsßitenAeRkamkarRtÜtBinitü.

bEnßmelIenH karBüa)alCgÁg; nigkarQWcab;xñgrbs; eGog

FIriT§ nigkarBinitütamdanCaRbcaMeTAelIsuxPaBragkay

rbs;Kat; KWCakarsMxan;EdlRtÚveFVI. karbnþBüa)alelI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 27

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

1esckþIseRmcelIbNþwgsaTukçPøam²RbqaMgnwgesckþIseRmcrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg EdlbgÁab;[edaHElgCnCab;ecaT eGog

FIriT§ cuHéf¶TI14 ExFñÚ qñaM2011Éksarelx E138/1/7 kfaxNÐTI37 ¬esckþIseRmcrbs;tulakarkMBUl Éksarelx E138/1/7¦.

2esckþIseRmcrbs;tulakarkMBUl Éksarelx E138/1/7 kfaxNÐTI37.

3esckþIseRmcrbs;tulakarkMBUl Éksarelx E138/1/7 kfaxNÐTI35.

Page 30: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

sßanPaBevC¢sa®sþBIrEdlmanGtßiPaBrYmKñanwgeFVI[lT§PaB

énkarCasHes,Iyrbs;Kat;mankarekIneLIg. eyIg´kt;

smÁal;eXIjfa minmanGñkCMnajBüa)altamEbbeFVI[

skmμPaBBiessenaHeTenAkñúgRbeTskm<úCa bu:EnþRbsinebI

mankarvaytémøelIskmμPaBénkarrs;enARbcaMéf¶rbs;Kat;

GacmanRbeyaCn_ ehIydMbUnμansþIBIkarEksRmÜlNamYy

eTAelIbrisßanrs;enArbs;Kat;KYrRtÚvEsVgrk}.4

cMeBaHbBaðakaredaHElgCnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§ [enA

eRkAXMu GgÁCMnMuCRmHéntulakarkMBUl)anelIkeLIgfa {GgÁ

CMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgmankMhuskñúgkarsnñidæanfa xøÜnminman

mUldæankñúgkarbnþXMuxøÜnCnCab;ecaTteTAeTot EdlCalT§pl

énkaryl;eXIjBIPaBminmansm,Ta karbMEbkbTecaT nig

karp¥akdMeNIrkarnItiviFI}.5 GgÁCMnMuCRmHtulakarkMBUlpþl;

ehtuplfa GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgGaceRbIR)as;nUvral;

viFankarEdlmanedIm,IGacCYydl;CnCab;ecaT eGog FIriT§ [

mansm,TakñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakar. dUcenHGgÁCMnM uCRmH

tulakarkMBUlyl;eXIjfa mUldæan

EdlmanBImunEdlGgÁCMnMuCRmHsala

dMbUgykmkeFVICasm¥agehtukñúgkar

bnþXMuxøÜnCnCab;ecaTCabeNþaHGasnñ

RtÚvmansuBlPaBdEdl eBalKW

edIm,IFanavtþmanrbs;CnCab;ecaT

eGog FIriT§ kñúgGMLúgeBlsvnakar.

enAkñúgesckþIseRmcrbs;xøÜn

GgÁCMnMuCRmHtulakarkMBUlbgÁab;fa

GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg edayman

karBiPakSaCamYyGñkevC¢sa®sþ nig

EpñkvilcriksmRsb RtÚvesñI[mankarBüa)albEnßmdl;

CnCab;ecaTEdlGacCYy[suxPaBEpñksμartIrbs;CnCab;

ecaT)anRbesIreLIgedIm,I[CnCab;ecaTGacmansμartI

cUlrYmsvnakar)an. karBüa)alenHRtÚvEteFVIeLIgkñúg

mnÞIreBTü b¤kEnøgdéTeTotEdlsmRsbenAkñúgRBHraCaNacRk

km<úCa. CnCab;ecaTRtÚvTTYlkarBinitüBIGñkCMnajEpñk

evC¢sa®sþ Epñkviklcrik nig/b¤Epñkcitþsa®sþ min[elIsBI

ry³eBl6Ex cab;BIeBlcab;epþImBüa)almk. bnÞab;mk

GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgRtÚvkMNt;BIsm,Tarbs;CnCab;ecaT

kñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakaredayminmankarBnüaeBl.

GgÁCMnMuCRmHtulakarkMBUl)anseRmcfa karXMuxø Ün

CnCab;ecaTRtÚvGnuvtþenAkñúgmnÞIrXMuXaMgrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmH

visamBaØkñ úgtulakarkm<úCa rhUtdl;eBlkarerobcMcat;

EcgcaM)ac;nana sRmab;karBüa)albEnßmenAkñúgmnÞIreBTü b¤

kEnøgsmRsbdéTeTotRtÚv)anbMeBjrYcral;.6

Binitü nigepÞógpÞat;eday v:an;fan; eBAdar:a

28 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

4esckþIseRmcrbs;tulakarkMBUl Éksarelx E138/1/7 kfaxNÐTI36.

5esckþIseRmcrbs;tulakarkMBUl Éksarelx E138/1/7 kfaxNÐTI40.

6esckþIseRmcrbs;tulakarkMBUl Éksarelx E138/1/7 EpñkseRmcesckþI.

eeGGoogg FFIIrriiTT§§ ¬¬rrUUbbfftt ³³ GG>>vv>>tt>>kk¦¦

Page 31: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

QQuunnllII TTYl)an

briBaØab½Rtc,ab; BIsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

ssuuCCaattaa CanisSitfñak;

briBaØab½RtEpñkc,ab; sikSa

CaPasaGg;eKøsenAsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

CC½½yyTTttþþ TTYl)an

briBaØab½Rtc,ab; BIsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

C½yTtþ CaGtItC½ylaPI

fñak;CatienAkñúgkarRbkYt

svnakarRbDit qñaM2010.

RR))aaffññaa TTYl)an

briBaØab½Rtc,ab; BIsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

R)afña sBVéf¶kMBugeRtóm

RbLgsikSaviC¢aCIv³emFavI

enAkm<úCa.

llwwmm CC½½yyTTttþþ ccaann RR))aaffññaaqqaayy QQuunnllII DDII ssuuCCaattaa¬¬

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

RbGb;sMbuRtelx1110/ PñMeBj RBHraCaNacRkkm<úCa

TUrs½BÞ ³ ¬855¦ 23 211 875

TUrsar ³ ¬855¦ 23 210 358

GuIEm:l ³ [email protected]

eKhTMB½r ³ www.dccam.org b¤ www.cambodiatribunal.org

KeRmagenHTTYlCMnYyhirBaØvtßúBImUlniFi

John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation and

British Embassy-Cambodia.

Page 32: evidentiary-hearings-in case-002

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa rkSasiT§i ExFñÚ qñaM2011eexxoovv ssMMppnn kkññúúggbbnnÞÞbb;;ssvvnnaakkaarr EExxFFññÚÚ qqññaaMM22001111 ¬¬rrUUbbfftt ³³ GG>>vv>>tt>>kk¦¦