Upload
dangdiep
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
12/5/17
1
Origin of Animals
1
EvolutionofDevelopment:EvolutionofAnimalBodyPlansasanExample
Or,anotherwaytoconceptualizetoday’slecture:
EvolutionofGeneRegulatoryNetworks:
EvolutionofDevelopmentasanExample
• WhatisanAnimal?• Whatmakesthemdifferentfromotherorganisms?
• WhendidtheyEvolve?• HowdidtheyEvolve?
Multicellular (metazoan)Heterotrophic (eat, not photo or chemosynthetic)
Eukaryote
No Cell Walls, have collagenNervous tissue, muscle tissue
Particular Life History-developmental patterns (this lecture)
WhatisanAnimal?
12/5/17
2
• http://www.wimp.com/planktonlife/
Aretheredifferencesbetweenplantandanimalevolution?
• Greaterdiversityinsexualsystemsinplants
– Abundantasexuality
• Morechemistrylessbehaviorinplants
• Developmentislessrigidandregulatedinplants:perhapsallowingformoreevolutionby“hopefulmonsters,”asdevelopmentalabnormalitiesaremoretolerableinplants
• Polyploidyistoleratedmorereadilyandcommoninplants
Outline• Today:Biggerpictureonhowradicalchangesinbodyplancomeabout
• EvolutionofDevelopment• EvolutionofDevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks(GRNs)
• HierarchyinEvolutionofGRNs• EvolutionofGRNs leadingtoevolutionofmajorphylogeneticbreaksinEarthHistory
Outline
• NextLectures:HumanEvolution…agreatexampleofEvolutionofDevelopment
• Mostdifferencesbetweenhumansandotherprimatesareduetoevolutionarychangesatafewdevelopmentalgenes
Reviewconceptsfrompreviouslectures:
• cis- andtrans-regulation• Transcriptionfactors• Pleiotropy• CambrianExplosion• Phylogeny
EvolutionofDevelopment:
• Whatisit?
• Howcanitleadtoevolutionofradicalchangesinbodyplan?
• Howcandifferenttypesofdevelopmentalchanges(mutationsatdifferentdevelopmentalstages)leadtodifferenthierarchicalevolutionarychanges(thatdistinguishphylum,class,order,family,genus,species)?
12/5/17
3
OntogenyRecapitulatesPhylogenyErnstHaeckel(1834-1919)
• Ontogenyisthecourseofdevelopmentofanorganismfromfertilizedeggtoadult;phylogenyistheevolutionaryhistoryofagroupoforganisms.
• Haeckelobservedthatasembryosofvertebratesdeveloped,theypassedthroughstagesthatresembledtheadultphaseofmoreancestral(“primitive”)organisms.Forexample,atonepointeachhumanembryohasgillsandresemblesatadpole.
• Haeckel’sideawasthataspecies’biologicaldevelopment,orontogeny,parallelsandsummarizesthespecies’evolutionaryhistory,orphylogeny
OntogenyRecapitulatesPhylogenyErnstHaeckel(1834-1919)
• Someofhisanalogieshavebeendiscredited(infavorofVonBaer’sideas)
• However,Haeckel'sgeneralconcept,thatthedevelopmentalprocessrevealssomecluesaboutevolutionaryhistory,appearstoholdfortheevolutionofdevelopmentalgenes.
Romanes's 1892copyofErnstHaeckel’sembryonicdrawings
TheCambrianExplosion
65mya:CretaceousExtinction(dinosaursgoextinct)
230 mya: Permian Extinction
570 mya: Cambrian Explosion
12/5/17
4
EvolutionofAnimalBodyPlans
• TrueTissues• TissueLayers(Diplo vs Triploblasts)• BodySymmetry• Evolutionofbodycavity(Coelom)• EvolutionofDevelopment
Cambrian Explosion
Howcouldthishappen?(geneticmechanism?)
TheEvolutionofDevelopment(Freeman&Herron,Chapter19)
• ThetremendousincreaseindiversityduringtheCambrianexplosionappearstohavebeencausedbyevolutionofdevelopmentalgenes
• Changesindevelopmentalgenescanresultinradicallynewmorphologicalforms
• Developmentalgenescontroltherate,timing,andspatialpatternofchangesinanorganism’sformasitdevelopsintoanadult
• ThediscoveryofHox genes– Notthe“mostimportant”devgenes– Nottheonlydevelopmentalgenes– But,amongthefirststudied
Hox genesaretypesofHomeotic genes,whicharegenesthatcontrolthepatternsandorderofdevelopmentinplantsandanimals.Forexample,homeoticgenesareinvolvedindeterminingwhere,when,andhowbodysegmentsdevelopinorganisms.
ExamplesofHomeotic genes:Hox genes,paraHox genes,MADS-boxcontaininggenes,etc.
12/5/17
5
Changesinafewregulatorygenescouldhavebigimpacts
• Mostnewfeaturesofmulticellularorganismsarisewhenpreexistingcelltypesappearatnewlocations ornewtimes intheembryo.
• Changesinthespecificationofcellfates areamajormechanismfortheevolutionofdifferentorganismalforms.
• Forexample,smallchangesingeneregulationcouldcausechangesintimingofdevelopmentalevents(heterochrony),whichcouldthenleadtodramaticchangesinmorphology
• StephanJayGouldin1977proposedthisasamechanismforevolutionarychange
So,whathappenedduringtheCambrianExplosion?
AllmajorAnimalPhyla(differentbodyplans)evolvedwithinarelativelynarrowwindowoftime
(1)Precambrian-PaleozoicBoundary (~570MYA)
Cambrian Explosion
Prec
ambr
ian
Cambrian
1400
1200
1000
800
600
Mol
lusc
a
Anne
lida
Arth
ropo
da
Echi
node
rmat
a
Agna
tha
Gna
thos
tom
ata
200
0Million Years Ago
Wray et al. 1996
BasedonphylogenyofanimalsbasedonDNAsequencedata,theradiationofanimalspredatesthegeologicalrecordoftheCambrianExplosion
“CambrianExplosion”Howcandifferenttypesofdevelopmentalchangesleadtodifferenthierarchicalevolutionarychanges(thatdistinguishphylum,class,order,family,genus,species)
TheGrandMystery
12/5/17
6
WhyhastherehasbeensolittlechangeinanimalbodyplanssincetheCambrianExplosion???
TheGrandMystery
Davidson&Erwin.2006.GeneRegulatoryNetworksandtheEvolutionofAnimalBodyPlans.Science.311:796-800.
Bigphylogeny
“Kernels”
“GeneBatteries”
1. ‘‘Kernels’’oftheGRN: Evolutionarilyinflexiblesubcircuits (ofregulatorygenes)thatperformessentialupstreamfunctionsinbuildinggivenbodypartsàmaindifferencesamongphyla
2. ‘‘Plug-ins’’oftheGRN: Certainsmallsubcircuits (ofregulatorygenes),thathavebeenrepeatedlyco-optedfordiversedevelopmentalpurposes
3. Input/Output(I/O)deviceswithintheGRN: Switchesthatallowordisallowdevelopmentalsubcircuits tofunctioninagivencontext(e.g.Hox genes)
4. DifferentiationGeneBatteries: Consistofgroupsofprotein-codinggenesundercommonregulatorycontrol,theproductsofwhichexecutecelltype–specificfunctionsà Speciesdifferences
DifferentHierarchicalComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
First,BasicsonDevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetwork
• ThebindingoftranscriptionfactorstoregulatoryDNAsequencescontrolsthespatialandtemporalexpressionofgenesinthedevelopingorganism
• Becauseeachtranscriptionfactorregulatestheexpressionofmultiplegenes,regulatorygeneinteractionsformanetwork.
12/5/17
7
S.Sinha
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetwork
• ThebindingoftranscriptionfactorstoregulatoryDNAsequencescontrolsthespatialandtemporalexpressionofgenesinthedevelopingorganism
• Becauseeachtranscriptionfactorregulatestheexpressionofmultiplegenes,regulatorygeneinteractionsformanetwork.
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetwork
Exampleshownforneuraldevelopment
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks(GRNs)
• Developmentiscontrolleddirectlybyprogressivechangesintheregulatorystateinthespatialdomainsofthedevelopingorganism.
• Asregulatorygenesregulateoneanotheraswellasothergenes,andbecauseeveryregulatorygenerespondstomultipleinputswhileregulatingmultipleothergenes,thetotalmapoftheirinteractionshastheformofanetwork.
• GeneRegulatoryNetworksconsistof:• Regulatorygenes,whichencodetranscriptionfactors• Signalinggenes,whichencodeligands andreceptorsforintercellularcommunication
Whatkindofevolutionarychanges(i.e.mutations)leadtotheevolution
ofGeneRegulatoryNetworks?
EvolutionaryChangeswithintheGeneRegulatoryNetworks• DevelopmentalBiologistshavehypothesizedthatmostchangeswithinregulatorynetworkswouldbe cis-regulatory (e.g.promoter,enhanceratthegene)
• Thereasonisthatcis-regulatorychangeswouldonlychangetheexpressionofonegene
• Ontheotherhand,Trans-regulatorychangesareoftenoverlypleiotropic,andthusdon’toccurasoften.But,whentheyoccur,theyhaveprofoundeffects.
• So,developmentalevolutionarychangeshavebeenassumedtobemostlycis-regulatory.
12/5/17
8
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks(GRNs)
• Comparativedevelopmentalevidenceindicatesthatreorganizationsindevelopmentalgeneregulatorynetworks(GRNs)underlieevolutionarychangesinanimalmorphology,includingbodyplans.
• ThenatureoftheevolutionaryalterationsthatarisefromregulatorychangesdependsonthehierarchicalpositionofthechangewithinaGRN.
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks(GRNs)
• GRNs arehierarchical,sothattheportionscontrollingtheinitialstagesofdevelopmentareatthetopofthehierarchy(earlyindevelopment),theportionscontrollingintermediateprocessesofspatialsubdivisionortheformationoffuturemorphologicalpatternareinthemiddle,andtheportionscontrollingthedetailedfunctionsofcelldifferentiationandmorphogenesisareattheperiphery.
DevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetwork
Exampleshownforneuraldevelopment
Thefundamentaldifferences
“Kernels”
“GeneBatteries”
Developmentoccursthroughasequenceofevents
• DuringDevelopment,regulationofgeneexpressioniscriticalfordeterminingthedifferentialfateofgeneticallyidenticalcells
• Morphologicalpatterningduringthecourseofdevelopment:Generalà moredetailed
• Developmentalchangesleadtodivergenceatdifferenthierarchicallevelsfromthemoreupstream“kernels”earlyindevelopment,tothemoreperipheral“genebatteries”
• Ontogenyrecapitulatesphylogeny: Christiane Nüsslein-Volhard and Sean Carroll
12/5/17
9
OntogenyRecapitulatesPhylogenyErnstHaeckel(1834-1919)
• Haeckel’sideawasthataspecies’biologicaldevelopment,orontogeny,parallelsandsummarizesthespecies’evolutionaryhistory,orphylogeny
• Haeckel'sgeneralconcept,thatthedevelopmentalprocessrevealssomecluesaboutevolutionaryhistory,mightgenerallyholdfortheevolutionofdevelopmentalgenes.
Christiane Nüsslein-Volhard and Sean Carroll
Architecturalchangesinanimalbodyplansmighthavebeenproducedoverthepast600millionyearsbychangesinGRNs (generegulatorynetworks)ofmultipleclasses,withextremelydifferentdevelopmentalconsequencesandratesofoccurrence.
• Themodularsub-circuitsofdevelopmentalGRNs differinevolutionarylability.
• Themostslowlychangingcomponents— calledkernels— consistofhighlyconservedregulatoryinteractionsthatestablishtheprogenitorfieldofadevelopingstructure.
• Theevolutionarystability(constraint)ofkernelscontrastswiththelability(evolvability)ofotherGRNsub-circuits.
EvolutionofGRNs
1. ‘‘Kernels’’oftheGRN: Evolutionarilyinflexiblesubcircuits (ofregulatorygenes)thatperformessentialupstreamfunctionsinbuildinggivenbodypartsàmaindifferencesamongphyla
2. ‘‘Plug-ins’’oftheGRN: Certainsmallsubcircuits (ofregulatorygenes),thathavebeenrepeatedlyco-optedfordiversedevelopmentalpurposes
3. Input/Output(I/O)deviceswithintheGRN: Switchesthatallowordisallowdevelopmentalsubcircuits tofunctioninagivencontext(e.g.Hox genes)
4. DifferentiationGeneBatteries: Consistofgroupsofprotein-codinggenesundercommonregulatorycontrol,theproductsofwhichexecutecelltype–specificfunctionsà Speciesdifferences
DifferentHierarchicalComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
1. ‘‘Kernels’’oftheGRN: Evolutionarilyinflexible(constrained)subcircuits thatperformessentialupstreamfunctionsinbuildinggivenbodyparts
• Oftendedicatedtomajorformationofbodyparts• Oftensub-circuitofinteractingtranscriptionfactors• Oftenhighlyconstrainedbypleiotropy• Oftencannotundergoevolutionarychangewithout
catastrophiceffects
• Examplesinnextfourslides.OtherpossibleExamples:anteriortoposteriorandmidlinetolateralspecificationofthenervoussystem(indeuterostomes andpossiblyacrossBilateria);eyefield specification[inarthropods];gutregionalization[inchordates];developmentofimmunesystems[acrossBilateria];andregionalizationofthehindbrainandspecificationofneuralcrest[inchordates]
DifferentComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
12/5/17
10
• Kernelsaresub-circuitscomposedofrecursivelywiredregulatorygenes(thatis,theyshareinputsthroughmultiplecis-regulatoryinteractions),whichoperateduringtheinitialphaseofregionalpatternformationforaparticularbodypart.
• Ifanyofthegenesinthesub-circuitarepreventedfromfunctioning,thebodypartfailstodevelop.
• Akernelinteractswithregionalregulatorystatesub-circuits,whichinturnactivateorrepresstheactivityofdifferentiationgenebatteriesattheperipheryoftheGRN(nextfigures).
• TheconservedstructureofdevelopmentalGRNkernelsmightberesponsibleforthephenotypicstabilityofanimalbodyplansthathaspersistedatleastsincetheEarlyCambrianperiod,520millionyearsago.
‘‘Kernels’’oftheGRNEndomesoderm specificationkernel,commontoseaurchinandstarfish,thelastcommonancestorofwhichlivedabouthalfabillionyearsago.
Fiveofthesixgenesinthekernel(allexceptdelta)encodeDNA-recognizingtranscriptionfactors
Thelinkagesarehighlyrecursive.Thecis-regulatorymoduleoftheotx genereceivesinputfromthreeofthefivegenes;thefoxa gene,fromthreeofthefive;andthegatae,foxa,andbragenesfromtwoofthesamefivegenes
Possibleheartspecificationkernels;assembledfrommanyliteraturesources.Dashedlinesshowpossibleinteractions.
Thesenetworksarealsohighlyrecursive
Acoresetofregulatorygenesareusedincommonandarelinkedinasimilarwayinaconservedsubcircuit ofthegenenetworkarchitecture(greyboxes)
GeneralModelforHeartSpecificationKernel
Zebrafish endodermkernel(subcircuit)
Photoshowsgeneexpressionof4transcriptionfactorsthatarepartofthiskernel
Tsengetal.2011
1. blank
2. ‘‘Plug-ins’’oftheGRN: Certainsmallsubcircuits thathavebeenrepeatedlyco-optedfordiversedevelopmentalpurposes
• Notdedicatedtoformationofbodyparts.Instead,theyareinsertedinmanydifferentnetworkswheretheyprovideinputsintoagreatvarietyofregulatoryapparatus.
• Oftenexpresseddifferentiallyinthe(species-specific)terminalphasesofdevelopment
• Theirconnectionsintothenetworkareevolutionarilyverylabile(evolvable)
• Examples:signaltransductionsystems,Wnt,transforminggrowthfactor–b (TGF-b),fibroblastgrowthfactor,Hedgehog,Notch,andepidermalgrowthfactor
DifferentHierarchicalComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
12/5/17
11
SonicHedgehog signalingpathway:
Keyroleinregulatingvertebrateorganogenesis,suchasinthegrowthofdigitsonlimbsandorganizationofthebrain.
SonicHedgehog(yellow)signalingcontrollingneuronalidentityinthedevelopingspinalcord
3. Input/Output(I/O)deviceswithintheGRN:Switchesthatallowordisallowdevelopmentalsubcircuits tofunctioninagivencontext
• Permitorprohibittheoperationoftheregulatorysub-circuits,andsignalsbetweentheregulatorysub-circuits
• Theycanacttopermitorprohibitpatterningsubcircuitsfromactingingivenregionsofananimal.
• Examples:regulationofsizeofhomologousbodyparts.regulationoffateofsegmentsinanimalshox genes,Ubx,pitx2
DifferentHierarchicalComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
Hox Genes
• Hox genesareexamplesof“Input/OutputDevices”…thatis,operatelike“on/off”switches
• Iftheyare“on”withinananimalregion,theywilldictatethefateofthatsegment
• Hox genesaretranscriptionfactors,whichregulategenesthatinturnregulatelargenetworksofothergenes
Hox Clusters
• Genefamilyformedbygeneduplicationevents
• Hox geneproductsare transcriptionfactors,regulatoryproteinsthatbindtoDNAandcontrolthetranscriptionofothergenes
• Hox genesdeterminetheidentityofsegmentalregionsalongtheanterio-posterioraxisofanimalsduringearlyembryonicdevelopment(e.g.legs,antennae,andwingsinfruitfliesorthedifferentvertebrateribsinhumans)
• Hox genesareaclassofhomeotic genesthatprovidepositionalinformationduringdevelopment
• IfHox genesareexpressedinthewronglocation,bodypartscanbeproducedinthewronglocation
• Forexample,incrustaceans,aswimmingappendagecanbeproducedinasegmentinsteadofafeedingappendage
Hox Genes MutationsinaHox genecausinglegstogrowoutofthehead
In this case, the identity of one head segment has been changed to that of a thoracic segment.
12/5/17
12
Hox genes in Drosophila
Hox genestendtobeclusteredalongachromosomeintheorderthattheyareexpressedinmanytaxa(fliesandvertebrates),butnotalltaxa
P.Z.Myers
EvolutionofHox clusters
• HOX-clustersundergoessentialrearrangementsinevolutionofmaintaxa
• Duplication,deletion,divergenceofthegenesleadtodifferentiationinbodyplans
• Otherregulatorygenes/genefamiliesarealsoimportant
Animalbodyplans
EvolutionarychangesinHox Genes
• Newmorphologicalformslikelycomefromgeneduplicationeventsthatproducenewdevelopmentalgenes
• Apossiblemechanismfortheevolutionofsix-leggedinsectsfromamany-leggedcrustaceanancestorhasbeendemonstratedinlabexperiments
• SpecificchangesintheUbxgenehavebeenidentifiedthatcan“turnoff”legdevelopment
Hox gene6 Hox gene7 Hox gene8
About400mya
Drosophila Artemia
Ubx
12/5/17
13
Differences in Hox gene expression distinguish the various arthropod segmentation patterns
• EvolutionofvertebratesfrominvertebrateanimalswasassociatedwithalterationsinHox genes
• TwoduplicationsofHox genes arethoughttohaveoccurredinthevertebratelineage
• Theseduplicationsmayhavebeenimportantintheevolutionofnewvertebratecharacteristics
EvolutionofVertebrates(PhylumChordata) • Polyploidizationisprobablythesinglemostimportantmechanismfortheevolutionofmajorlineagesandforspeciationinplants
Multipleroundsofpolyploidization mighthaveoccurredduringtheearlyevolutionofvertebrates
Vertebrates(withjaws)withfourHox clusters
Hypotheticalearlyvertebrates(jawless)withtwoHox clusters
Hypotheticalvertebrateancestor(invertebrate)withasingleHox cluster
SecondHoxduplication
FirstHoxduplication
4.DifferentiationGeneBatteries:
Consistofgroupsoffunctionallylinkedprotein-codinggenesundercommonregulatorycontrol,theproductsofwhichexecutecelltype–specificfunctionsandaremajordeterminantofcellspecializationinmetazoans
Theyareexpressedinthefinalstagesofgivendevelopmentalprocesses.
DifferentHierarchicalComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
12/5/17
14
4.DifferentiationGeneBatteries: Consistofgroupsoffunctionallylinkedprotein-codinggenesundercommonregulatorycontrol,theproductsofwhichexecutecelltype–specificfunctionsandaremajordeterminantofcellspecializationinmetazoans
• ResideattheperipheryofdevelopmentalGRNs,andareexpressedinthefinalstagesofgivendevelopmentalprocesses
• Theydonotregulateothergenes(incontrasttokernelsandplug-ins,whichareentirelyregulatory)
• Theydonotcontroltheprogressiveformationofspatialpatternsofgeneexpressionthatunderliesthebuildingofthebodyplan;inshort,theydonotmakebodyparts.
• Differentiationgenebatteriesbuildmusclecellsandmakeskeletalbiominerals,skin,synaptictransmissionsystems,etc.
DifferentHierarchicalComponentsofGeneRegulatoryNetworks
So....Kernelsofthenetwork:• Kernelsspecifythedomainforeachbodypartinthespatial
coordinatesystemofthepostgastrular embryo•• Highlypleiotropically constrained
o internalrecursivewiring—manylinkageso positionhighinthedevelopmentalnetworkhierarchy
Whensufficientcomparativenetworkdataareavailable,itislikelythatconservednetworkkernelswillbefoundtoprogramtheinitialstagesofdevelopmentofeveryphylum-specificbodypartandperhapsofsuperphylum andpan-bilaterian bodypartsaswell.
EvolutionwithinDevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks
Incontrast,peripheralregionsoftheGRN(i.e.differentiationgenebatteries)arelesspleiotropicallyconstrained,andmorelikelytoevolve.
Therearenodownstreamconsequencesinchangesatthislevel.
Examples:manycasesofspeciation,manycasesofadaptationtotheenvironment
EvolutionwithinDevelopmentalGeneRegulatoryNetworks
So,notallmutationsareequal:
Mutationsthatareretainedthataffecttheearlierstagesofdevelopment(e.g.kernels)willhavemoreprofoundeffectsonanimalbodyplansthanmutationsthataffecttheterminalstepsofdevelopment(e.g.genebatteries)
Sothen,whydidmassivediversificationofmajorbodyforms(evolutionarychangesinthepleiotropic kernels)occuratthetimeofthe“CambrianExplosion”
Andwhydidsuchchangesnotoccurafterthat?
12/5/17
15
Thekernelswouldhaveformedthroughthesameprocessesofevolutionthataffecttheothercomponents(whilenewlineageswereformingduringthelatePre-Cambrian-earlyCambrian),
But,onceformedandoperatingtospecifyparticularbodyparts,kernelstructurewouldhavebecomerefractory(resistant)tosubsequentchange(becauseofthecatastrophiccostsofalteringfundamentalstructures—becausethedevelopmentalpathwayshadalreadybeenlaidout).
MolecularphylogenyplacesthisevolutionarystageinthelateNeoproterozoic whenBilateria begintoappearinthefossilrecord,betweentheendoftheMarinoan glaciation atabout630millionyearsagoandthebeginningoftheCambrian.
Thereforethemechanisticexplanationforthesurprisingfactthatessentiallynomajornewphylum-levelbodypartshaveevolvedsincetheCambrianmaylieintheinternalstructuralandfunctionalpropertiesofGRNkernels:Oncetheywereassembled,theycouldnotbedisassembledorbasicallyrewired,onlybuiltupon.
DiversekindsofchangeinGRNs andtheirdiverseevolutionaryconsequences
Fig.3.Theleftcolumnshowschangesinnetworkcomponents;therightcolumnshowsevolutionaryconsequencesexpected,whichdifferintheirtaxonomiclevel(red).
Bigphylogeny
“Kernals”
“GeneBatteries”
SampleExamQuestions
1. WhichofthefollowingisFALSE regardinghox Genes?(a)Theyservetheroleofdefiningsegmentalregionsalongtheanteriorto
posterioraxisduringdevelopment(b)Theirfunctionshavediversifiedthroughgeneduplicationsfollowedby
differentiation(e.g.subfunctionalization),leadingtodifferentiationofsegmentalregionsinanimals
(c)Theyencodetranscriptionfactorsthatperformtrans-regulatoryfunctions(d)Theyareresponsibleforthemajordifferencesamonganimalphyla(e)Theyfunctionbyallowingordisallowingdevelopmentalsubcircuits to
functionwithinsegmentalregions(likean"on/off"switch)
2. Whichofthefollowingwouldbemostevolutionaryconstrained?
(a)Plug-insoftheGRN(b)KernelsoftheGRN(c)Input/Outputdevices(d)Genebatteries(e)Hox genes
12/5/17
16
3.Changesatwhichbelowaremostlikelytoberesponsiblefortheradiationofanimalphyla?
(a)Plug-insoftheGRN(b)SonicHedgehog(c)Input/Outputdevices(d)Genebatteries(e)KernelsoftheGRN
4.Whatarehox geneswithinanindividualanimal?
(a)Orthologs(b)Paralogs(c)Homologs(d)Xenologs(e)Noneoftheabove
5. Developmentalevolutionarydifferencesbetweenhumansandchimpanzeesaremostlikelytobeatthelevelof
(a)Plug-insoftheGRN(b)hox genes(c)Input/Outputdevices(d)Genebatteries(e)Kernels
• 1D• 2B• 3E• 4B• 5D
• OptionalSlides(foryourowninterest)
Differentsub-circuitswithinGeneRegulatoryNetworks
Don’tneedtoknowthis,justshowingasanexample
12/5/17
17
Changesthatcanaffectcis-regulatorymodules(CRMs)(canreviewlecturenotesoncis-regulatoryevolution)
• Internalchangesthataffectthefunctionofapre-existingCRMo Singlebase-pairmutationcancausegainofnewbindingsites,lossofsites,orstrengtheningorweakeningofbindingtosites.
o Insertionsanddeletionscanchangethedistancebetweeninteractingsites,causegainorlossofsites,oranincreaseinthecopynumberofgivensites.
o Insertionofmobileelementcarryingregulatorysequencescancausegainorpotentiallossofsite,changeinthedistancebetweeninteractingsitesandincreaseincopynumber,aswellasalterthestrengthofbindingatthesite.
• ChangesthatalterCRMrepertoireofpre-existinggeneso InsertionofCRMs fromelsewhere:carriedbymobileelements,byinversions,bytranslocations,orbyintronic retrotranspositions cancausegainofdevelopmentalfunctionswithoutlossofthegene.
o LossofaCRM:bytranslocation,largedeletion,inversionbreakageorinsertionofmobileelementcancauselossofspecificdevelopmentalfunctionwithoutlossofgene.
• Large-scale rearrangements that produce novel gene–CRM complexeso Regionalduplicationscanresultinsubfunctionalization andneofunctionalization.o Translocationscanbringnewgenesintolargeregulatorydomains.