Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
EXFOR: Improving thé qualityof international databases
by E. Dup-
T he NEA Data Bank is an international centre ofréférence for basic nuclear tools used for thé
analysis and prédiction of phenomena in nuclearenergy applications. The Data Bank collects,compiles, disséminâtes and contributes to improvingcomputer codes and associated data.
In thé area of nuclear data, thé Data Bank worksin close co-operation with other data centresthat contribute to thé Worldwide compilation ofexpérimental nuclear reaction data in thé EXFORdatabase (NEA, 2012). EXFOR contains basic nucleardata on low- to medium-energy experiments forincident neutron, photon and various charged-particle-induced reactions on a wide range of nucleiand compounds. Today, with more than 150 000 datasets from more than 20 000 experiments performedsince 1935, EXFOR is by far thé most important andcomplète expérimental nuclear reaction database. Itis widely used to further improve nuclear reactionmodels and evaluated nuclear data libraries. TheData Bank supervises thé development of thé JointEvaluated Fission and Fusion (JEFF) file, which is oneof thé major evaluated nuclear data libraries used inthé field of nuclear science and technology.
As part of its mission, thé Data Bank works tomaintain thé highest level of quality in its databases.One method that was proposed to check thé mutualconsistency of expérimental data in EXFOR (seeNEA, 2011) is to test for outlier measurements morethan a few standard déviations from thé meanvalue as, in principle, several measurements of thésame reaction quantity should form a continuousdistribution. More recently, another method wasdeveloped to crosscheck evaluated and expérimentaldata in databases in order to detect aberrant values(SCM, 2014). It was noted that there is no évidence,on thé basis of numerical comparisons only, thatoutliers represent "bad" data. The fact that suchdata deviate significantly from other data of thésame reaction may, however, be helpful to nucleardata evaluators who focus on one or a few isotopesand may wish to discard such data after a thoroughanalysis.
The Data Bank also organised a comprehensivereview of cross-section data. An efficient reviewSystem and associated strategy were developed tosystematically compare more than 10 000 cross-section data sets from EXFOR with thé correspondingvalues in thé main evaluated nuclear data libraries,including JEFF. The review initially covered ail
neutron-induced threshold and activation reactionssuch as (n,n'), (n,2n), (n,p) and (n,a) (NEA, 2014). Theresulting statistical information showed variousinteresting trends in thé data, including a list ofsuspicious data sets for which thé cross-sectionvalues deviate greatly from thé major evaluatednuclear data libraries and/or other measurements.The original publications associated with thèse datahâve also been systematically checked. This workconfirmed that most of thé expérimental data werecompiled correctly in thé EXFOR database, and itidentified a few compilation mistakes that hâvesince been corrected. A second part of thé reviewdevoted to thé (n,y) cross-section is underway. Thispart of thé review is challengingbecause of thé largefluctuations of data in thé résonance région thatmake thé comparison more difficult. If successful,thé review could be completed with other non-threshold cross-sections such as (n,f), (n,tot) and(n,n).
Ail of thèse initiatives hâve been very useful tomaintain thé highest level of quality in thé EXFORdatabase. In addition, future development versionsof thé JEFF library can be automatically benchmarkedagainst other evaluated libraries and against a morereliable expérimental database. Such work willcontribute to improving thé quality of evaluatednuclear data for thé benefit of ail users.
RéférencesNEA (2011), "Statistical methods for thé vérification of data-bases", NEA News, Volume 29, No. 1, OECD, Paris.
NEA (2012), "NEA contributions to thé Worldwide collection,compilation and dissémination of nuclear reaction data",NEA News, Volume 30, No. 2, OECD, Paris.
Société de Calcul Mathématique (SCM) (2014), "Cross-checking of large evaluated and expérimental nuclearreaction databases", International Conférence on NuclearData for Science and Technology, Nuclear Data Sheets, Volume120, pp. 277-280, Elsevier.
NEA (2014), "Statistical vérification and validation ofthé EXFOR database", NEA Data Bank Report, NEA/DB/DOC(2014)3, OECD, Paris.
* Mr Emmeric Dupont ([email protected]) was, at thétime of umting, Administrator in thé OECD Nuclear EnergyAgency Data Bank.
28 News briefs, News 2014 - No. 32.1/32.2