Faleomavaega, Reply to Response to Motion to Intervene

8/13/2019 Faleomavaega, Reply to Response to Motion to Intervene

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/faleomavaega-reply-to-response-to-motion-to-intervene 1/10



!"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/0 1..2/(*(2) *2 *"# -3#4(5') 6'32'

728#4)3#)* ')9 :2);4#//3') <)( =>?> ='&#23'8'#;'0/ @2*(2) *2

A)*#48#)# (/ ()5244#5* '/ ' 3'**#4 2+ /BC/*')5#>D !"# :2B4* /"2B&9

'&&2E *"# @28')*/ *2 ()*#48#)# C#5'B/# *"#F "'8# /BC/*')*('& ()*#4#/*/

() *"# '5*(2) *"'* E(&& )2* C# '9#GB'*#&F 4#.4#/#)*#9 CF *"# .'4*(#/ *2

*"# '..#'&> !"# '4;B3#)*/ 2+ *"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/ *2 *"# 52)*4'4F

'4# )2* 2)&F B)/B..24*#9 CF 5'/# &'E CB* '&/2 +B)9'3#)*'&&F

()52)/(/*#)*>

!" $%& '(&)*+,- .,(/, 0/1&)-(&-2 '-3 4/-5)&66(,-

7,8&/(,1,&5, .%/983 :& 0),-2&3 !-2&)1&-2*/-"

!"(/ :2B4* /"2B&9 ;4')* *"# -3#4(5') 6'32' 728#4)3#)* ')9

:2);4#//3') ='&#23'8'#;'H/ @2*(2) *2 A)*#48#)#> !"# 1..2/(*(2)

+(&#9 CF *"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/ +'(&/ () &'4;# .'4* *2 4#/.2)9 *2 *"#

@2*(2) *2 A)*#48#)#> !"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/ 92 )2* 5"'&&#);# *"'* *"#

9(/.2/(*(2) 2+ *"(/ '..#'& 3'F (3.'(4 *"# @28')*/0 ()*#4#/*/ () *"#

'5*(2)I !"" @2*> *2 A)*#48#)# '* JI *"'* *"# ()*#48#)*(2) 2+ *"# @28')*/

E2B&9 )2* .4#KB9(5# *"# .'4*(#/ 24 5'B/# B)9B# 9#&'FI !"" $%& '* DLMDDI

24 *"'* *"# @28')*/ "'8# -4*(5&# AAA /*')9(); *2 .'4*(5(.'*# () *"#

1 Movants initially argued that Plaintiff-Appellants’ Opposition was untimely. We no longer

dispute the timeliness of the Opposition pursuant to Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure

26(c).

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( . 1B *>



3

!"#$%&' !"" $%& !# )*+),- .&/#0!1' #20 34!$&#$556788044!&#/ !9:;0 #2!#

<-=- =$9";$# 890"010&# 1%0/ &%# /;88%9# #20 !>!$4!?$4$#@ %5 $&#09>0&#$%&

%& !880!4' #2!# #20 $&#090/#/ %5 #20 A%>!&#/ !90 B!?/#9!"#'C !&1 #2!# #20

$&#090/#/ %5 #20 A%>!&#/ !90 $10&#$"!4 #% #2%/0 %5 #20 D&$#01 E#!#0/- 744

%5 #20/0 !9:;F0&#/ 5!$4-

G20 34!$&#$556788044!&#/ !9:;0 #2!# '()"*(+)$,(+- .($,(/ .01/

2,3+- 456 7& 83,9$"-%' ,H* D-E- *IJ K)LMJN' %&4@ B/;88%9#O/P $&#09>0&#$%&

?@ 8!9#$0/ #% QRST 89%"001$&:/ $& !880!4/ 59%F #2%/0 /!F0

89%"001$&:/'C 34!$&#$556788044!&#/ U88- !# V' ?;# #20 4!W $& #2$/ =$9";$#

89%>$10/ %#209W$/0- G2$/ =%;9# 2!/ !1%8#01 #20 9;40 59%F 83,9$"-% 5%9

!44 B$&#09>0&#$%& $( #20 "%;9# %5 !880!4/-C :+!!+3;<!"))! 83;,,- ,9 2+=

+) 0(%,7"*/ '(3& 7& .&8&' ))H X-,1 VVM' VVL K<-=- =$9- )LLVN' 3$)$(>

?<$-%$(> @ A,(!)& B*+%"! C"D)& 7& E"$3;' YI X-,1 )*VJ' )*H*6H, K<-=-

=$9- )LLYN- .& :+!!+3;<!"))! 83;,,- ,9 2+=' 5%9 0Z!F840' #2$/ =%;9#

!884$01 #20 83,9$"-% 9;40 #% !& !880!4 $&>%4>$&: !& !##!"[ %& !&

!&#$#9;/# /0##40F0&#- 8"" :+!!+3;<!"))! 83;,,- ,9 2+=' ))H X-,1 !#

VVL- 7&1 #2$/ 9;40 $/ "%&/$/#0&# W$#2 #20 "%;&/04 %5 #20 E;890F0 =%;9#

#2!# B#20 8%4$"$0/ ;&1094@$&: $&#09>0&#$%& O$& #20 X0109!4 S;40/ %5 =$>$4

39%"01;90P F!@ ?0 !884$"!?40C %& !880!4- 83,9$"-%' ,H* D-E- *), &-)I-

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( + 1B *>



4

!"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/ '0# /(1(&'0&2 1(/*'3#) 4"#) *"#2

5#/60(7# *"# ()*#0#/*/ 8+ *"# -1#0(6') 9'18' :8;#0)1#)* ')5

<8)=0#//1') >'&#81';'#=' '/ 8)&2 ?'7/*0'6*@ () )'*A0#B !"# (//A#/ ()

*"(/ '..#'& /*0(3# '* *"# "#'0* 8+ *"# 0#&'*(8)/"(. 7#*4##) *"# C8;')*/

')5 *"# D)(*#5 9*'*#/ ')5 /A66#// 72 *"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/ 48A&5

6"')=# *"(/ 0#&'*(8)/"(. () 50'1'*(6 ')5 *')=(7&# 4'2/B !"" C8*(8) *8

E)*#0;#)# '* FG,FH I#J.&'()()= 78*" *"# #$%"&' #$)%*$" ')5 .#0/8)'&

()*#0#/*/ 8+ *"# C8;')*/KB >80 #J'1.&#L *"# -1#0(6') 9'18'

:8;#0)1#)* (/ *'/3#5 4(*" #)+806()= *"# 5A&2 #)'6*#5 (11(=0'*(8)

&'4/ 8+ -1#0(6') 9'18'B !"" -1B 9'18' <85# -))B MNFBGHGF ") '"+

IHGFOKB PA* ' 5#6(/(8) *"'* '&& DB9B )'*(8)'&/ 780) () -1#0(6') 9'18'

'0# DB9B 6(*(Q#)/ 72 7(0*" 48A&5 0'(/# 58A7* '/ *8 *"# 68)/*(*A*(8)'&(*2 8+

*"8/# (11(=0'*(8) &'4/ A)5#0 *"# %0(;(&#=#/ ')5 E11A)(*(#/ <&'A/# 8+

-0*(6&# ERL 9#6*(8) HB !"", "-.-L /&*)"0 120.- 3 45&')- 6%$0"' 457&8*2 59

4$:0"& 457&); $&0 <*8*&*); =- >$;5% $&0 457&8*2 59 4*); 59 4$:0"&L

NST DB9B HGUL HFS IFVUNKW 457&8*2 59 ?&'- @."&)' 3 1%5A"%' =- B7$%C"D

B*:"&"EL OSO >B 9A..B H5 NXB TN,TT IYB%BZB HGGTKB

[80 '0# *"# ()*#0#/*/ 8+ *"# %&'()*(++,-..#&&')*/ (5#)*(6'& *8 *"#

()*#0#/*/ 0#.0#/#)*#5 72 *"# D)(*#5 9*'*#/B -&*"8A=" *"# C8;')*/

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( 7 1B *>



5

!"#$%#& $( )*++(,$ $-% +()"$"(# (. $-% /#"$%& 0$1$%) $-1$ $-% 2"$"3%#)-"+

241*)% &(%) #($ 1++45 $( +%,)(#) 6(,# "# 78%,"91# 018(1:; <($"(# $(

=#$%,>%#% 1$ ?@ A%8+-1)") 1&&%&B: $-% 78%,"91# 018(1 C(>%,#8%#$

1#& 2(#D,%))81# E1%4(81>1%D1 -1>% &"..%,%#$ "#$%,%)$) $-1# $-%

/#"$%& 0$1$%) "# $-") 81$$%,F G%44"#D45: $-% H%.%#&1#$I7++%441#$) &(

#($ (6J%9$ $( "#$%,>%#$"(# 65 $-% <(>1#$)F K-%$-%, 1#& -(L $-%

&")+()"$"(# (. $-") 91)% L"44 1..%9$ $-% !"#" %"&'" ") 1 9(#9%,# +,(+%,45

!"# L"$-"# $-% +*,>"%L (. $-% H%+1,$8%#$ (. M*)$"9%: 6*$ )N*1,%45

L"$-"# $-% +*,>"%L (. $-% D(>%,#8%#$ 1#& %4%9$%& (.."9"14) (. $-% +%(+4%

(. 78%,"91# 018(1F 7#& %>%# ". $-% H%.%#&1#$I7++%44%%) 1#& $-%

<(>1#$) -1& "&%#$"914 "#$%,%)$): 1) $-% O41"#$"..I7++%441#$) "#9(,,%9$45

"8+45: "&%#$"914 "#$%,%)$) L(*4& #($ +,%>%#$ "#$%,>%#$"(#F %(( )'"*( +,

-"*./: ?PI27IQRPR PR?P KS @RTUVVV AHF2F 2",F M*45 T: PR?PB A+%,

9*,"18BF

!!" $%&'()'**+,--.%%&()/0 1--2/')'2( 3(4.5/625./ 78.

!9-25)&(6. 1* !().5:.()'2( ;< 78. ,9.5'6&( =&92&

>2:.5(9.() ,(4 ?2(@5.//9&( A&%.29&:&.@& !( 78'/

,--.&%"

G-% O41"#$"..I7++%441#$)W X++()"$"(# $( $-% <($"(# $( =#$%,>%#%

+,(>"&%) (#45 .*,$-%, %>"&%#9% (. $-% #%%& .(, "#$%,>%#$"(# 65 $-%

78%,"91# 018(1 C(>%,#8%#$ 1#& 2(#D,%))81# E14%(81>1%D1 "# $-")

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( - 1B *>



6

!"##$%& ()$ *++,$+ "# +#"-$ *. #)*+ "//$"0 *!/0*1"#$ 12%$ "+/$1#+ 23

4!$%*1". 5"!2". 1,0#,%$ ".6 *6$.#*#78 92#) 23 :)*1) "%$ 23 /"%"!2,.#

*!/2%#".1$ #2 #)$ ;2<".#+ "+ #)$ 6,07 12.+#*#,#$6 =2<$%.!$.# ".6

$0$1#$6 >$/%$+$.#"#*<$ 23 #)$ 4!$%*1". 5"!2". /$2/0$& ?*<$. #)$

!"=.*#,6$ 23 #)$ *++,$+ "# +#"-$8 ".6 #)$ "9+$.1$ 23 "6$@,"#$

%$/%$+$.#"#*2. 23 4!$%*1". 5"!2". *.#$%$+#+ *. #)*+ "1#*2.8 #)*+ A2,%#

+)2,06 =%".# #)$ ;2#*2. #2 B.#$%<$.$&

()$ C0"*.#*33D4//$00".#+ "##$!/# #2 !*.*!*E$ #)$ *.#$%$+#+ "#

+#"-$ *. #)*+ "1#*2. 97 10"*!*.= #)"# #)$ *++,$ /%$+$.#$6 *. #)*+ "//$"0

*+ F6*+1%$#$G ".6 *!/0*1"#$+ F2.07 " +*.=0$ 3$6$%"0 +#"#,#$8HH C0"*.#*33D

4//$00".#+ I//& "# J8 9,# #)"# "##$!/# 3"*0+& ()$ C0"*.#*33D4//$00".#+

+$$- #)$ F$.32%1$K!$.#L 23 " 12.+#*#,#*2."0 %*=)#8G #)$ %$+,0# 23 :)*1)

:*00 9$ F#2 %$!2<$ #)"# *++,$ 3%2! #)$ /20*#*1"0 "%$." ".6 !"-$ *# .2.D

.$=2#*"90$&G !"# "# M& (2 29#"*. #)*+ %$0*$38 #)$ C0"*.#*33D4//$00".#+ "+-

#)*+ A2,%# #2 N$##*+2. 9*.6*.= 5,/%$!$ A2,%# /%$1$6$.# ".6 " 1$.#,%7 23

N,%*+/%,6$.1$ 6$3*.*.= #)$ 0$="0 %$0"#*2.+)*/ 9$#:$$. 4!$%*1". 5"!2"

".6 #)$ O.*#$6 5#"#$+&$%%

I/*.*2.8 P*+#& A#& P-#& Q2& RS T$U/0"*.*.=

#)"# #)*+ 10"*! *+ 32%$102+$6 97 #)$ !&'()*+ -*'%'VW '%% *)'. /.0&%' 1#

23"0%))8 XYR O&5& RSS8 RMX TXZ[XV& 5,1) " 6$1*+*2. :2,06 )"<$ "

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( 8 1B *>





8

!"#$%&$''()**+""#%&, ,++./ $& $, $0*1,,$2"+ &1 ,++ 345 !"# 1&4+6 &+66$&165

16 7+02+6 1' 81%96+,, 31:"; 2+ #2"+ &1 $%&+6<+%+ $% &4$, ,:$& &4#&

,*+=$'$=#""5 =4#""+%9+, &4+ %#&:6#"$>#&$1% ,&#&:, 1' )0+6$=#% ?#01#%,@

A4+ #69:0+%&, #;<#%=+; 25 &4+ !"#$%&$''()**+""#%&, $% &4+$6

B**1,$&$1% #6+ ':%;#0+%&#""5 $% &+%,$1% 3$&4 +#=4 1&4+6@ C'/ 1% &4+ 1%+

4#%;/ D# '#<16#2"+ 6+,:"& '16 !"#$%&$''()**+""#%&,E =1:"; $0*"$=#&+ &4+

6+*6+,+%&#&$1%#" $%&+6+,&, 1' D$%$&# 7+02+6 1' 81%96+,,E 16 &4+ #2$"$&5

1' D'()*+$& &+66$&16$#" 91<+6%0+%&,E &1 %+91&$#&+ 3$&4 &4+ F%$&+; ?&#&+,/

$& $, ;$''$=:"& &1 :%;+6,&#%;/ 1% &4+ 1&4+6/ &4+ =1%&+%&$1% &4#& &4$,

#**+#" 6#$,+, 1%"5 # D;$,=6+&+E $,,:+ %1& ,:''$=$+%&"5 $0*16&#%& &1 G:,&$'5

&4+ $%&+6<+%&$1% 1' &4+ 71<#%&,@ A4+ !"#$%&$''()**+""#%&,H +''16& &1

12,=:6+ &4+ ,$9%$'$=#%=+ 1' &4$, =#,+ &1 &4+ ?#01#% *+1*"+ '#$",@

"#$"%&'(#$

I16 &4+ '16+91$%9 6+#,1%, &4+ )0+6$=#% ?#01# J1<+6%0+%& #%;

81%96+,,0#% K%$ I@L@ I#"+10#<#+9# 6+,*+=&':""5 6+M:+,& &4#& &4+

81:6& *+60$& &4+0 &1 $%&+6<+%+ $% &4$, =#,+@

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( B 1C *>



Dated: October 17, 2013 !"#$"%&'())* #(,-.&&"/0

!"! $%&'()* +, -%**%(."

1.%23") 45 6.)).3-#1.%23") 75 4839:#:

;"<<.'"8 15 =3</*

> ?!>@7AB C D@@?E @@F

GHH 4.'&""<&2 E&8""&0 A565

63#2.<9&:<0 B5I5 JKKKH

L")"$2:<"M NJKJO PQRSHKKK

43%#.-.)"M NJKJO PQRSHJKK

/012")* 304 5') 6.)4%&(2 7(.0(

809)42.)25 (2: /02;4)"".(2 <2%+,=, +(*)0.(9();(

!"#$ #&'( )*+,-./. 01234(56 )*78*8+- 9:;(<= *>?*/?.>*+ @&A( B 1C *>



Documents

Faleomavaega, Reply to Response to Motion to Intervene