33
Financial Shenanigans Watch for: executive incentives which encourage managing financial statements poor internal controls quarterly financial statements (they are not audited) companies with weak control environment (board of directors is not independent; auditors not independent) management facing extreme competitive pressure management with questionable character fast growth companies whose real growth is beginning to slow basket case companies struggling to survive newly public companies private companies (especially those which aren’t audited) 1

Financial Shenanigans

  • Upload
    lordrai

  • View
    73

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

how to detect accounting fraud and manipluation

Citation preview

Page 1: Financial Shenanigans

Financial Shenanigans

Watch for: executive incentives which encourage managing financial

statements poor internal controls quarterly financial statements (they are not audited) companies with weak control environment (board of directors is

not independent; auditors not independent) management facing extreme competitive pressure management with questionable character fast growth companies whose real growth is beginning to slow basket case companies struggling to survive newly public companies private companies (especially those which aren’t audited)

1

Page 2: Financial Shenanigans

The Seven Shenanigans

1. Recording Revenue Too Soon shipping goods before the sale is finalized recording revenue when important uncertainties exist recording revenues when future services are still due

2. Recording Bogus Revenues recording income on the exchange of similar assets recording refunds from suppliers as revenues using bogus estimates on interim financial reports

3. Boosting Income With One Time Gains boosting profits by selling undervalued assets boosting profits by retiring debt failing to segregate unusual and nonrecurring gains or losses from

recurring income burying losses under noncontinuing operations

4. Shifting Current Expenses to a Later Period improperly capitalizing costs depreciating or amortizing costs too slowly failing to write off worthless assets

5. Failing to Record or Disclose All Liabilities reporting revenue rather than a liability when cash is received failing to accrue expected or contingent liabilities failing to disclose commitments and contingencies engaging in transactions to keep debt off the books

6. Shifting Current Income to a Later Period creating reserves to shift sales revenue to a later period

7. Shifting Future Expenses to the Current Period accelerating discretionary expenses into the current period writing off future years’ depreciation or amortization

2

Page 3: Financial Shenanigans

Gathering Financial Data

10-K auditor’s report

absence of opinion qualified report reputation of auditor audit committee (independent directors act as intermediary

with auditors) footnotes

accounting policies / changes (in policies or estimates) review inventory valuation (LIFO vs. FIFO / specific

id)(except technology) revenue recognition (after sale vs. At sale with risk

remaining) depreciation (accelerated vs. Straight line) amortization of goodwill (shorter vs. Longer) estimate of warranty (high vs. Low) estimate of bad debts (high vs. Low) treatment of advertising (expense vs. Capitalize) loss contingencies (accrue loss vs. Footnote only)

pending or imminent litigation (Item 3, better than footnote in annual)

long term purchase commitments (at what price?) contingencies or commitments industry specific notes segment information (showing unhealthy segment)

MD&A (management discussion and analysis) specific concise disclosures (liquidity, capital expenditures,

candor) consistent with footnotes

Annual Report president’s letter

forthrightness vs. Always upbeatProxy (for annual meeting)

litigation executive compensation turnover of management related party transactions

10-Q

3

Page 4: Financial Shenanigans

unaudited consistency with 10-K

8-K (special events) auditor changes

disagreements over accounting policies (opinion shopping) change in control of the company acquisitions dispositions resignation of directors bankruptcy

Prospectus past performance quality of management and directors

4

Page 5: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 1: Recording Revenue Too SoonRevenue should be recorded after the earnings process has been completed and an exchange has occurred.

earnings process should be substantially complete arms length exchange

Three Typical Scenarios

1. Shipping Goods Before a Sale is Finalized goods must be exchanged for cash or reliable promise to pay

before revenue recognized watch for early shipping before sale occurs (especially at end of

quarter) shipments in advance of delivery dates partial shipments of merchandise, containing only part of a

customer’s order shipments of merchandise for which customers had canceled

their orders long term contracts can be an exception (often use percentage of

completion); but their could still be problems: uncertainties exist – estimates of future costs interim measures of completion rate can be difficult changes in cost and completion estimates to manipulate

earnings political uncertainties can change contract (e.g., defense

orders canceled) new companies with uncertain products or markets

2. Recording Revenue When Important Uncertainties Exist there should be a high probability that goods will be paid for and

not returned must determine whether:

risks and benefits of ownership have been transferred to the buyer

sale of receivables to factor with recourse or without recourse

the buyer might return the goods does right of return exist

the buyer may not pay for the goods does buyer have financing to pay for goods

5

Page 6: Financial Shenanigans

is buyer’s purchase contingent on his ability to resell product

is buyer obligated to pay

3. Recording Revenue When Future Services are Still Due should only recognize revenue earned to date; remainder of

receipts are a liability often the case with franchisers

recognize revenue while still promising future services “area development rights” to have exclusive right to open

franchises in area these should not be considered to be current income

(defer until franchises open)

6

Page 7: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 2: Recording Bogus Revenues

Revenue should be recorded after the earnings process has been completed and an exchange has occurred.

Three Typical Scenarios

1. Recording Income on the Exchange of Similar Assets no gain should be recorded on the exchange of similar property

2. Recording Refunds from Suppliers as Revenue retailers often receive refunds from suppliers. This is not revenue.

3. Using Bogus Estimates on Interim Financial Reports must estimate sales returns, future warranty costs, longevity of

plant and equipment with quarterly report, estimate inventory level and cost of goods

sold often done by using “gross profit rate”

7

Page 8: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 3: Boosting Income with One-Time Gains

Revenue should be recorded after the earnings process has been completed and an exchange has occurred. Similarly, gains should be reported only after an exchange has taken place.

Four Common Techniques

1. Boosting Profits by Selling Undervalued Assets these are nonrecurring gains typical examples include:

selling assets acquired in a pooling transaction company that uses LIFO (especially with many inventory

pools, which allow management to especially manage cost of goods sold)

e.g., separate inventory into three pools. Each pool has inventory purchased in each of the last three years (higher prices each year). Use all of one pool to get to the lower priced inventory and increase earnings.

real estate (or other assets) acquired long ago

2. Boosting Profits by Retiring Debt this is especially interesting when new debt is issued at higher rates such gains do not recur

3. Failing to Segregate Unusual and Nonrecurring Gains or Losses From Recurring Income

nonoperating gains (e.g., sale of assets) noncontinuing activities (e.g, discontinued business) some companies try to argue that since they engage in a particular

type of transaction frequently, it is revenue from normal operations (e.g., a hotel chain that sells its old properties)

watch for the mingling of operating with nonoperating income i.e., income from operations, as opposed to revenue from

ancillary services (such as interest and rental income)

4. Burying Losses Under Noncontinuing Operations noncontinuing operations include discontinued operations,

extraordinary gains / losses, and the cumulative effect on income from changing accounting principles

8

Page 9: Financial Shenanigans

9

Page 10: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 4: Shifting Current Expenses to a Later Period

An enterprise should capitalize costs incurred that produce a future benefit and expense those that produce no such benefit. If the asset is immaterial or the benefit will be received over a short period of time, expense the item. Expenses should be charged against income in the period in which the benefit is received.As an enterprise realizes the benefit from using an asset, the asset or a part thereof should be written off as an expense of the period.When there is a sudden and substantial impairment in an asset’s value, the asset should be written off immediately and in its entirety, rather than gradually.

Three Common Scenarios

1. Improperly Capitalizing Costs shifts expense to a later period improper capitalization often includes start-up costs, research and

development costs, advertising, and administrative costs this is done by creating an asset (a deferred asset) it can also be done by charging some of this expense to

inventory (delaying the expense until the merchandise is sold)

2. Depreciating or Amortizing Costs Too Slowly slow depreciation (longer useful lives) can result in:

higher net worth (i.e., higher asset values) higher profits

compare depreciation policies with industry norms be especially careful of companies using long useful lives in

industries experiencing rapid technological advancement look at what depreciation would be if done on a replacement

basis, rather than a historical basis watch for overly long amortization periods for intangibles and

leasehold improvements leasehold improvements such as carpet or theater seats

should be amortized over the shorter of: the remaining life of lease the useful life of the improvements

watch for slow amortization of inventory costs

10

Page 11: Financial Shenanigans

in certain industries, it is difficult to determine inventory expense (COGS)

e.g., film expense capitalized and matched against projected revenues; life of film revenues and amount of revenues are crucial assumptions

be concerned when the depreciation or amortization period increases

often times, this is clear manipulation to increase earnings

11

Page 12: Financial Shenanigans

3. Failing to Write Off Worthless Assets a permanently impaired asset must be abruptly written off as a loss

e.g., accounts receivable become uncollectible or investments become worthless

while this hurts current year profits, it helps future years (since income will not be affected by depreciation in future). This can help stock price.

watch for bad loans and other uncollectibles that have not been written off

a bad loan must be written down to net realizable value must estimate amount of defaults (or bad debts) and

record a reserve (or allowance for uncollectibles. banks do this, as well as insurance companies

(estimate future claims) these amounts are deducted from profits in the year in

which they are estimated, not in the year a claim is paid out or a loan becomes worthless

when a loan is written off, the bank removes it from assets and deducts an equal amount from the pool of loss reserves (at this point, it does not affect income statement; it has already passed through statement)

each year, reserves are adjusted to maintain them at proper level

be wary of worthless investments investments in stocks, bonds, and real estate must be written

down if their market value declines and that decline is not temporary.

this is particularly important for insurers

12

Page 13: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 5: Failing to Record or Disclose All Liabilities

An enterprise has incurred a liability if it is obligated to make future sacrifices.Hiding liabilities, or keeping them off of the books, is often referred to as “off balance sheet financing.”

Four Primary Techniques

1. Reporting Revenue Rather Than a Liability When Cash is Received (Future Services Still Due)

e.g., franchisers, magazines, airlines (frequent flier programs) once cash is received, must ask if their are additional obligations

still due have the risks or benefits all passed to the buyer (or do some

remain with seller)

2. Failing to Accrue Expected or Contingent Liabilities losses should be accrued for expected payments related to

litigation, tax disputes, etc. must accrue if there is a probable loss and it can be reasonably

estimated accruing this loss takes from net income immediately (and sets up

estimated liability, or reserve)

3. Failing to Disclose Commitments and Contingencies future commitments and contingencies should be disclosed

e.g., a long term purchase agreement probe for a trouble company with fixed payments

e.g., leases that can’t be extinguished if business deteriorates watch for unrecorded postretirement liability (SFAS No. 106)

transition costs can be immediately recognized or deferred this is the difference between the obligations to which

the company has committed and the fmv of assets that they have set aside to pay this obligation (often nothing)

read debt covenants carefully for contingencies provisions often allow lender to call loan if ratios fall below

set level

13

Page 14: Financial Shenanigans

4. Engaging in Transactions to Keep Debt Off the Books examine any debt for equity swaps

as stock prices rise, a company might give bondholders equity. This reduces debt and interest expense. It increases equity. Also have gain from the difference between the value of the stock and the face value of the bonds (and no tax on the gain).

be wary of companies using subsidiaries for borrowing now, parents must consolidate balance sheets of all majority

owned subsidiaries watch for defeasance of debt

if a company has debt outstanding, it can buy treasury bonds which will have interest sufficient to cover the interest payments on the debt and with maturity value that is sufficient to pay the debt when it comes due.

not only is the debt wiped off the books, but the company records a profit equal to the difference between the book value of the bonds and the price of the Treasury bonds.

14

Page 15: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 6: Shifting Current Income to a Later Period (companies that have had better than expected years sometimes shift income to a later period)

Revenue should be recorded in the period in which it is earned.

One Primary Technique:

1. Creating Reserves to Shift Sales Revenue to a Later Period done by deferring sales revenue; record a liability initially and

transfer it to revenue the following year often done through reserve account can also be done by post dating shipping documents or

failing to process documents within fiscal year (so that products sold at the end of one year are recorded as sales in the next year)

the idea is to smooth income desire is to have steady earnings sometimes this is result of incentive plan which only

compensates manager for income up to certain level smoothing income usually brings unpleasant surprises later

many see nothing wrong with income smoothing. They don’t realize that investors and creditors should be using all available information to make decision.

be critical of successful companies with large reserves

15

Page 16: Financial Shenanigans

Rule 7: Shifting Future Expenses to the Current Period

Expenses should be charged against income in the period in which the benefit is received.

Two Primary Techniques

1. Accelerating Discretionary Expenses Into the Current Period be alert for prepayment of operating expenses

often times, you will see companies ordering large amounts of overhead items at the end of the year (e.g., stamps) and expensing them immediately

be concerned when the depreciation or amortization period decreases

e.g., fixed assets, intangibles, leasehold assets

2. Writing Off Future Years’ Depreciation or Amortization big bath accounting

having a bad year, so write off everything and get ready for a future without depreciation

new management often does this to show improvement in future

sometimes, it is admirable to take big bath, if firm is actually taking aggressive action to cut costs

16

Page 17: Financial Shenanigans

Cash is King: Study the Statement of Cash Flows

Accounting profit is result of accrual accounting (and subject to manipulation). Must look at cash flow statement and income statement together.

Cash Flow from Operations measures operating performance on a cash basis (net income does

it on accrual basis) this ignores sales for which money is due also ignores expenses for which money is owed

measures the quality of earnings compare CFFO with Net Income

if NI is positive, while CFFO is negative, (year after year) might be problem

similarly, if CFFO is continually less than NI this is particularly important comparison for

established companies whose sales, receivables, and inventory generally don’t fluctuate rapidly

less applicable to new, high growth companies which incur substantial costs to fund their growth in receivables and inventory

cash flow analysis may help predict bankruptcy may see CFFO negative for years while income positive.

May result from booming accounts receivable.

Additional Measures of Quality of Earnings

Quality of Income = CFFO / Operating Income

Interest Coverage = CFFO before Interest and Taxes / Interest

Return on Assets = CFFO before Interest and Taxes / Assets

17

Page 18: Financial Shenanigans

Keeping Everything in Balance: Inventory, Sales, and Receivables

Signs of Misleading Financial Statements That May Appear on the Balance Sheet

1. Overstating assets or showing balances at amounts in excess of their net realizable values

2. Understating assets – where companies attempt to smooth income by shifting future expenses into the current fiscal year

3. Understating liabilities, either by excluding them entirely from the balance sheet or by recording overly conservative estimates of future obligations

4. Overstating liabilities – using reserves to smooth income by shifting current year revenue to the future

5. Misstating owners’ equity

Watch the amount of capital. how quickly is it growing or shrinking

Overstated assets often indicate future declines in earnings in particular, watch inventory and accounts receivable

Compare growth in inventory to growth in sales they should match

Compare the growth in sales with the growth in accounts receivable these should match (if not, trouble in collecting from customers) otherwise, a company will experience negative cash flow

Compare growth in sales with both inventory and accounts receivable if both inventory and accounts receivable are growing faster than

sales, troubles are intensified if inventory is not selling and receivables are not being collected,

trouble will follow

Warning Signs for Uncollectibility of Receivables large amount of overdue receivables large increase in receivables with flat sales exaggerated dependence on one or two customers related party receivables slow receivable turnover receivables consisting largely of goods that customers may return

18

Page 19: Financial Shenanigans

Warning Signs of Inadequate Salability of Inventory slow inventory turnover large increase when sales are flat faddish inventory collateralized inventory insufficient insurance change of corporate inventory valuation methods increase in number of LIFO pools inclusion of inflation profits in inventory large, unexplained increase in inventory inclusion of improper costs in inventory

Warning Signs of Improper Valuation of Investments switching between current and noncurrent categories investments recorded in excess of cost risky investments that must be written off

Warning Signs of Obsolescence of Fixed Assets old equipment and technology high maintenance and repair expense declining output level inadequate depreciation charge change in depreciation method lengthening depreciation period decline in depreciation expense large write off of assets

Warning Signs of Overstatement of Intangibles slow amortization period lengthening amortization period high ratio of intangibles to total assets and capital large balance in goodwill even though profits are weak

Warning Signs For Liabilities warranties amortized quickly arbitrary adjustments over-reserve warranties (smoothing income)

Signs of Misleading Financial Statements liberal accounting policies

19

Page 20: Financial Shenanigans

unjustified changing of accounting policies deferring expenses (overstating income) income smoothing (understating profits) recognizing revenue too soon (overstating income) underaccruing expense (overstates income; understates liability) overaccruing expense (understates profits) big bath (future profits are boosted) changing discretionary cost (manipulating profits) low quality controls (risk of fraud) change in auditor (risk)

20

Page 21: Financial Shenanigans

52 Techniques for Finding Fraud

1. be alert for misguided management incentives2. watch for poor internal accounting controls3. question overly liberal accounting rules4. watch for qualified opinions5. favor companies with conservative accounting policies6. be alert for aggressive inventory valuation7. consider the significance of pending or imminent litigation8. question long term purchase commitments9. watch for changes in accounting principles10. read the letter from the president with a grain of salt11. focus on management and its estimates12. be wary when the auditor and/or lawyer resign abruptly13. watch for early shipping, before sales occurs14. weigh uncertainties of companies’ using the percentage of completion

method15. look for improper use of the percentage of completion method16. check whether the risks and the benefits have transferred to the buyer17. determine whether the buyer is likely to return the goods18. check if the buyer has financing to pay19. determine whether the customer is obligated to pay20. watch for hasty recognition of franchise revenue21. question how retailers account for returned goods22. be alert for revenue recorded on the exchange of property23. determine whether management estimates are realistic24. watch for the sale of pooled assets acquired in a business combination25. be alert for tricks with LIFO pools26. watch for gains from the sale of undervalued investments, including real

estate27. don’t be fooled by profits from retiring debt28. adjust for the mixing of gains from recurring and nonrecurring activities29. watch for co-mingling of operating and nonoperating income30. be alert for companies hiding losses as “noncontinuing”31. watch for the capitalization of start-up costs32. consider the propriety of capitalizaing R&D costs33. look for companies that capitalize advertising34. watch for companies that capitalize administrative costs35. question companies that depreciate fixed assets too slowly36. be alert for lengthy amortization periods

21

Page 22: Financial Shenanigans

37. be concerned when the depreciation or amortization period increases38. watch for bad loans and other uncollectibles that have not been written

off39. be wary of worthless investments40. ascertain that cash received has been earned41. probe for a troubled company with fixed payments42. watch for unrecorded postretirement liability43. read debt covenants carefully for contingencies44. examine any debt for equity swaps45. be wary of companies using subsidiaries for borrowing46. watch for defeasance of debt47. be critical of successful companies with large reserves48. be alert for prepayment of operating expenses49. be concerned when the depreciation or amortization period decreases50. use cash flow analysis to measure quality of earnings51. compare growth in sales with growth in inventory52. compare growth in sales with growth in receivables

22

Page 23: Financial Shenanigans

Profitability Ratios

Gross Profit Margin = Gross Profit / Sales margin available to cover expenses and yield a profit

Operating Margin = Operating Profit / Sales profitability from main operations

Net Profit Margin = NI / Sales earnings from each dollar of sales

ROA = NI / Assets return on investment of both stockholders and creditholders

ROE = NI / Equity return on investment for shareholders

EPS = NI / Number of Shares profitability to shareholders on a per share basis

Liquidity Ratios

Current Ratio = Current Assets / Current Liabilities extent to which claims by short term creditors are covered by

current (short term) assets

Working Capital = Current Assets - Current Liabilities cushion to meet unforeseen cash requirements

Quick Ratio = (Current Assets - Inventory) / Current Liabilities extent to which claims of short term creditors are covered without

the need for an inventory sell off

Inventory to Net Working Capital = Inventory / (Current Assets - Current Liabilities)

extent to which company’s working capital is tied up in inventory

23

Page 24: Financial Shenanigans

Solvency Ratios

Debt to Assets = Total Debt / Total Assets extent to which a company borrows money to finance its

operations

Debt to Equity = Total Debt / Total Equity the creditor’s funds as a percentage of stockholders’ funds

Long Term Debt to Equity = Long Term Debt / Total Equity balance between a company’s debt and its equity measures level of risk in meeting principal and/or interest on debt

Interest Coverage Ratio = Operating Income / Interest Expense measures the multiple by which operating income exceeds the

fixed interest expenses indicates the chance of defaulting on the payment

Activity Ratio

Inventory Turnover = Cost of Sales / Average Inventory number of times a company turns over all its inventory in a year how quickly inventory is selling

Accounts Receivable Turnover = Sales / Average Accounts number of times a company turns over all its receivables during a

year how quickly customers are paying bills

Sources

Almanac of Business and Financial Ratios (Prentice Hall)Annual Statement Studies (Robert Morris Associates)Dun’s Review (Dun & Bradstreet)

Other Books

24

Page 25: Financial Shenanigans

O’glove, Thornton. Quality of Earnings: The Investor’s Guide to How Much Money a Company is Really Making. New York: The Free Press, 1987.

Potts, Mark. Dirty Money. New York: National Press Books, 1992.

Staley, Kathryn F. When Stocks Crash Nicely: The Finer Art of Short Selling. New York: Harper-Business, 1991.

Sternberg, William, and Matthew C. Harrison. Feeding Frenzy. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1989.

Waldman, Michael. Who Robbed America? New York: Random House, 1989.

25