28
United States Court of Appeals For the First Circuit No. 14- 1585 D A NNY B. , BY NEXT FRI END GREGO R Y C . ELL I OTT, and C A SSIE M. , BY N EX T F R I END KYMBERLI I RONS, FOR THEM SEL VES AND TH O SE SI MILAR LY SI TUATED, Pl ai nt i f f s, A ppel l ant s, v. G I N A M . RAI M O N D O , *  I N H ER O FFI C I A L CA PA C I TY A S GOVERN O R OF THE STATE O F RHODE I SL AN D , ET AL. , Def endan t s, A ppel l ees. APPEAL FROM TH E UNI TED STATES D I STRI CT COUR T FOR THE DI STRI C T O F R HODE I SLAND [ Hon. Mar y M. Li si , U. S. Di st r i ct J udge] [ Hon. Li ncol n D. A l mond, U. S. Magi strate J udge] Bef or e Sel ya, C i rcu i t J udge, Sout er , **  A ssociat e J ust i ce, and Li pez, C i rcu i t J udge. W i l l i am Kapel l , wi t h whom I r a Lust bader , Chi l dr en' s Ri ghts,  J ohn W . D i neen, J ar ed B obr ow, and W ei l , G ot s hal & M anges LL P w er e on brief, for appel l ant s. N ei l F. X . Kel l y, A ssi st ant A t t or ney G ener al , w i t h w hom Pet er * Pursuant t o Fed. R . A pp. P. 43( c) ( 2) , G over nor G i na M. R ai mon do h as been sub st i t ut ed f or f ormer Governor Li ncol n D. C haf ee as t he l ead def endant - appel l ee. ** H on. D avi d H . Sout er , A ssoci at e J ust i ce ( R et . ) of t he S upr eme Cour t of t he Uni t ed St ates, sitting by desi gnat i on. Case: 14-1585 Document: 00116825822 Page: 1 Date Filed: 04/21/2015 Entry ID: 5901427

First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 1/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 2/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 3/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 4/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 5/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 6/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 7/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 8/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 9/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 10/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 11/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 12/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 13/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 14/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 15/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 16/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 17/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 18/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 19/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 20/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 21/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 22/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 23/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 24/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 25/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 26/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 27/28

8/9/2019 First Circuit Apellate Decision -RIDCYF-141585

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/first-circuit-apellate-decision-ridcyf-141585 28/28