8
ORPS SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7 fNJpfTr TbpTp lN Teb fNTboNAi tbpTboN ClirMNp lc Teb mAoTebNlN ANa MlabifNd lc Teb glfNTp’ MbCeANfCAi molmboTfbp bleniJbva qoumbakari N I aimitrios bgglezos O ABpToACT qhe paper reports aF the inJsitu trial load testsI which were carried out on the fourI out of sixI internal columns of the marthenon western sideI the lpisthodomosI during the recent restoration project EOMMNJ JOMM4F and bF the analytical assessment of their structural responseI including foundationI based on the obtained experimental dataKqhe dismantling of the entablature members during the anastylosis projectI gave the opportunity for the performance of in situ trial load tests in order to study the response of the columnsI interacting to their foundationK qhe testing project consisted in the application of a horizontal force of NMJNNkk at the capital of each columnK At the same timeI the horizontal displacement of the capital and the vertical displacement of the base marble blockI were measuredK qhe test was carried out twice in each directionI to account for differences in the foundation conditionsK cor the evaluation and the interpretation of the test results a backJanalysis was performedK cor the EPJd nonlinear elasticF analysis oockJjechanics principles were appliedK qhe idea is that dry masonry structureI from natural rock stone blocks connected with frictional ±joint” forces are analogous to a jointed rockmass systemK qhe comparison of measured values and analytical predictions are generally in good agreementI offering increased accuracyK According to the resultsI discrete modelling with properly determined parameters for monument’s geomaterials can satisfactorily be applied to restoration analyses of this type of structure and could form the base for more complex calculations involving dynamic effects eKgK earthquakeK heywords: eeritageI AcropolisI marthenonI ary masonryI gointsI fnJsitu testsI aiscrete structure modeling NK fNTolarCTflN qhe project described in this paper is part of the actions undertaken during the recent EOMMNJOMM4F restoration project for the anastylosis of the lpisthodomos EiKeK the internal colonnade of the western sideF of the marthenonK NKNK The marthenon qhe marthenonI the masterpiece of Classical artI was built on the Acropolis of Athens in a short period of timeI between the years 44T and 4P8 BKC by the architects fktinos and hallikrates and the sculptor mheidias who spent R years moreI to place the sculptures in position on the pediments xNzK qhe templeI dedicated to AthenaI doddess of tisdomI still existsI till our days dominating the summit of the Acropolis eill EcigK NFK N ar ptructural bngineerI eellenic jinistry of CultureI airectorate for the oestoration of Ancient jonuments etoumpakari]cultureKgr O Civil bngineerI mhaI mapanikolaou OMI AthensI dreeceI degle]teeKgr

fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

ORPS=

SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7

fNJpfTr TbpTp lN Teb fNTboNAi tbpTboN ClirMNp lc Teb mAoTebNlN ANa MlabifNd lc Teb glfNTp’ MbCeANfCAi molmboTfbp bleniJbva qoumbakariNI aimitrios bgglezosO ABpToACT qhe=paper=reports=aF=the=inJsitu=trial=load=testsI=which=were=carried=out=on=the=fourI=out=of=sixI=internal=columns=of=the=marthenon=western=sideI=the=lpisthodomosI=during=the=recent=restoration=project=EOMMNJ=JOMM4F=and=bF=the=analytical=assessment=of=their=structural=responseI=including=foundationI=based=on=the=obtained=experimental=dataKqhe=dismantling=of=the=entablature=members=during=the=anastylosis=projectI=gave=the=opportunity=for=the=performance=of=in=situ=trial=load=tests=in=order=to=study=the=response=of=the=columnsI=interacting=to=their=foundationK=qhe=testing=project=consisted=in=the=application=of=a=horizontal=force=of=NMJNNkk=at=the=capital=of=each=columnK=At=the=same=timeI=the=horizontal=displacement=of=the=capital=and=the=vertical=displacement=of=the=base=marble=blockI=were=measuredK=qhe=test=was=carried=out=twice=in=each=directionI=to=account=for=differences=in=the=foundation=conditionsK=cor=the=evaluation=and=the=interpretation=of=the=test=results=a=backJanalysis=was=performedK=cor=the=EPJd=nonlinear=elasticF=analysis=oockJjechanics=principles=were=appliedK=qhe=idea=is=that=dry=masonry=structureI=from=natural=rock=stone=blocks=connected=with=frictional=±joint”=forces=are=analogous=to=a=jointed=rockmass=systemK=qhe= comparison= of= measured= values= and= analytical= predictions= are= generally= in= good= agreementI=offering= increased= accuracyK= According= to= the= resultsI= discrete= modelling= with= properly= determined=parameters= for= monument’s= geomaterials= can= satisfactorily=be=applied= to= restoration=analyses= of= this=type=of= structure= and= could= form=the=base= for= more= complex= calculations= involving= dynamic= effects=eKgK=earthquakeK=

=heywords: eeritageI AcropolisI marthenonI ary masonryI gointsI fnJsitu testsI

aiscrete structure modeling NK fNTolarCTflN =qhe=project= described= in= this= paper= is= part= of= the=actions= undertaken= during= the= recent= EOMMNJOMM4F=restoration=project=for=the=anastylosis=of=the=lpisthodomos=EiKeK=the=internal=colonnade=of=the=western=sideF=of=the=marthenonK=

=NKNK The marthenon qhe=marthenonI=the=masterpiece=of=Classical=artI=was=built=on=the=Acropolis=of=Athens=in=a=short=period=of=timeI=between=the=years=44T=and=4P8=BKC=by=the=architects=fktinos=and=hallikrates=and=the=sculptor=mheidias=who=spent=R=years=moreI=to=place=the=sculptures=in=position=on=the=pediments=xNzK=qhe=templeI=dedicated= to= AthenaI= doddess= of= tisdomI= still= existsI= till= our= days= dominating= the= summit= of= the=Acropolis=eill=EcigK=NFK===

=

================================================N=ar=ptructural=bngineerI=eellenic=jinistry=of=CultureI=airectorate=for=the=oestoration=of=Ancient=jonuments=

etoumpakari]cultureKgr=O=Civil=bngineerI=mhaI=mapanikolaou=OMI=AthensI=dreeceI=degle]teeKgr=

Page 2: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

ORPT=

==

cigK N=qhe=marthenonK=siew=from=the=korthJtest==

=

cigK O=mlan=view=of=the=marthenonK=fn=red=frame=the=lpisthodomos=collonadeK=arawing=by=jK=horres==

NKOK The lpisthodomos qhe=lpisthodomosI=the=western=part=of=the=temple=EcigK=OFI=was=directly=exposed=to=the=disastrous=fire=in=OST= AKaK= and= experienced= the= explosion= of= NS8T= –= which= resulted= in= the= collapse= of= the= eastern= and=middle=part= of= the=building=–= as=well=as= the=various= earthquakes=that= have=occured=in=the=Athens= areaK=qhereforeI= it= bears= the= signs= of= a= complicated= mechanical= historyK= qhe= structural= restoration= of= the=lpisthodomos=was=the=main=target=of=the=anastylosis=between=OMMNand=OMM4=xOzK=fn=the=years=OMMNJOMMO=the= totality= of= the= architrave= blocks= were= removed= in= order= to= be= repairedI= leaving= the= four= northern=lpisthodomos=columns=standing=free=Ethe=southern=two=columns=are=in=contact=to=the=medieval=staircase=masonryFK= lne=of= the=actions= undertaken=in=OMMOJOMMP=was=the=planning=and=execution=of= inJsitu= trial=load=tests=on=those=four=columnsI=in=order=to=assess=their=structural=and=foundation=conditionsK====NKPK The coundation marthenon=is=based=partly=on=the=natural=limestone=of=the=hill=andJ=due=to=the=slopy=ground=of=the=hillJ=on=an=artificial= stereoJprism=consisting= of= discrete= large= stone=blocks= from=soft= rock= material= Eporos=stoneF=from=the=miraeus=coast=EcigK=PFK=qhe=height=of=the=foundation=prism=is=NN=m=on=the=pb=edgeI=S=m=on=the=pt=and=O=m=on=the=ktK==

Page 3: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

ORP8=

=aF======= bF= cigK P=deometry=of=marthenon’s=foundation;=aF=bast=view=Ep=to=kF=and=bF=mlan=viewK=araw=by=AK=lrlandos=ENVT8F==

=OK TbpTfNd molgbCT =fn=order=to=carry=out=the=trial=load=testsI=first=a=reinforced=scaffolding=was=built=and=testedI=to=serve=as=the=reaction=frameK=A=force=up=to=NM=kk=was=gradually=applied=at=the=middle=of=each=side=of=the=capitals=by= means= of= a= simple= scaffolding= screw= abutted= on= the= reaction= frameK= qhe= applied= force= was=measured= with= a= load= cell= and= the= horizontal= displacement= of= the= capital= as= well= as= the= vertical=displacement= of= the= isolated= marble= blockI= on= which= each= column= standsI= were= measured= with=mechanical=extensometer=and=isaqs=respectively=xPzK==As=a=totalI=PM=trial=load=tests=were=carried=out=and=the=corresponding=loadJdisplacement=curves=of=the=lpisthodomos= columns= lhNI= lhOI= lhP= and= lh4= and= their= foundation= were= obtained= in= the= 4=directions=Eto=the=northI=southI=eastI=westFK==

=PK ANAivTfCAi bsAirATflN ANa fNTbomobTATflN lc TbpT obpriTp =cor=the=evaluation=and=the=interpretation=of=the=test=results=in=respect=to=the=foundationI=an=analytical=approach= was= performedK= qhis= analysis= was= based= mainly= on=oockJjechanics= principlesK= qhe=basic=idea =was =that =the =nature =of =structural =materialsI =that =isI =natural =rock =stone =blocks =Emarble =or =suchF =connected= with= frictional= ±joint”= forces= in= a= dry= masonry= structureI= are= fully= analogous= to= a= jointed=rockmass= systemK= AccordinglyI= the= loaded= columns= are= simulated= as= a= discrete= element= structure=consisting= of= the= column= drums= and= the= column= capitalI= with= frictional= compressionJonly= springs=between=aF=successive=drums=and=bF=the=column=base=and=the=underlying=monument=base=Ecrepis=and=foundation=blocksF=lying=upon=limestone=bedrockK===

===

cigK 4=deotechnical=conditions=below=the=column=base=Ej=Z=marbleI=m=Z=marlI=a=Z=dolomiteF==qhe=subJbase=crepis=and= the=underlying=discrete= foundation=Econsisting=mainly=of=marly=blocks=with=potential=existence=of=soil=intercalationsI=and=locally=of=dolomite=blocksFI=is=simulated=as=a=two=layered=half= space= on= rigid= limestone= bedrockK= fn= this= case= the= geomaterials= are= modeled= as= an= elastic= –=perfectly=plastic=materialK=qhe=typical=formation=of=the=opisthodomos=column=subJbase=is=presented=in=the=section=of==cigK=4=x4zK=ft=is=obvious=that=the=column=is=based=on=a=two=layered=half=spaceI=consisting=of= the=superficial= marble=crepis= and= the=Emuch= thickerF= foundation= from=marly= Eor= locally=dolomiteF=blocksK=qhe=geometry=of=this= layering=is=differentiated=in=respect=to=the=direction=Ewest=vs=eastF=of=the=underlying=geomaterialsI=due=to=the=thickness=of=the=marble=crepis=EMKSOm==thick=to=westside=–=MKPM=m=thick=to=the=eastsideFK=

katural=oock=

Page 4: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

ORPV=

PKNK deomaterials qhe=geomaterials=involved=for=analytical=interpretation=of=the=results=are=the=followingW

– jarble=drums=and=Crepis=– moros=cooting=Blocks=Emarly=limestoneF=– aolomite=cooting=Blocks=– iimestone=Bedrock=

qhe=footing=blocks=came=from=the=rocky=geological=formation=of=the=miraeus=coastI=known=as=AktiteI=which=appears=typically=either=as=a=soft=rock=Emarl=to=marly=limestoneF=or=as=a=dolomiteK=

Table N=jechanical=properties=of=deomaterials=

=

= fntact=oock= oockmass== b==EjmaF= v= qu=EjmaF= γ=EkkLmPF= dpf= boj=EjmaF=

jarble= TMMMM= MKOM= 8M= OTKM= TM= RMMMM=jarl=== OMMM= MKOR= NN= ORKM= SM= NMMM=aolomite= N8MMM= MKOM= SM= OSKM= SM= NPMMM=iimestone= RMMMM= MKOM= NMM= OSKM= TM= PRMMM=

= =qhe=assignment=of=mechanical=and=geostructural=properties=to=the=above=materials=Evoung=jodulus=bI=moisson=ratio=vF=is=a=prerequisite=for=the=conduction=of=the=analytical=calculationsK=pince=these=materials=are=classified=as=rockI=the=application=of=dpf=method=xRJTz=applies=for=the=estimation=of=the=rockmass=with=application=of=ooclab=software=code=x8zK=fndeedI=as=it=has=been=shown=in=previous=research=ExVzI=xNMzFI= large= scale= dry= masonry= structures= from= discrete= blocks= Eas= the= case= in= hand= of= the= large=foundation=of=marthenonF=consisting=of= rocky=blocksI= may=successfully=be=simulated=as=a= continuumI=applying=rockJmechanics=principles=to=fractured=rockmassK=fn=additionI=this=approach=may=also=apply=in=small=scaleI=for=evaluation=of=isolated=structural=block=properties=Eaccounting=for=ageing=effects=and=presence=of=microfracture==netFK=qhe=initial=mechanical=parameters=for=application=of=the=dpf=method=Euniaxial= compressive= strength=qu=and=b=of= intact=rockFI=are=obtained=from=relevant= literature=xVJNOzI=while= the= value=of=dpf= is= based=on=expertise=macroscopic= estimationK= qhe= initial=parameters= and= the=results=for=rock=mass=properties=are=summarized=in=qable=NK==PKOK Analytical procedure qhe=comparison=of= experimental=measurements= to=analytical= predictions= allows= for= aF= calibration=of=geomaterial= parameters= andI= bF= interpretation= of= experimental= results= on= the= basis= of= geotechnical=conditions=prevailing=below=the=base=of= the=columnsK=pince= the=horizontal= loading=of=lpisthodomos=columns= was=kept= in= relatively=low= levelsI= the=unloading=of= the=column=was= fully= reversibleK= =qhusI=a=nonlinear=elastic=approach=is=justified=for=predictionI=according=to=the=following=stepsW==

– Application= of= elastic= solutionsI= for= calculation= of= EelasticF= settlementsLsubsidence= at= the=measurement=points=

– Assignment= of= geostructural= properties= to= proper= complex= springsI= for= modeling= the= contact=surfaces= of= the= column= drums= discrete= structure= Einterface= springsF= and= the= behavior= of= the=foundation=underneath=Ebase=springsFK=

– PJa= nonlinear= elastic= analysis= with= use= of= moros= cooting= Blocks= Eeither= marly= limestone= or=dolomiteF=

qhe=presentation=of=the=above=analyses=is=made=in=the=following=paragraphsK==

PKPK blastic solutions for calculations of settlements Lsubsidence cor= calculation= of= settlementsLsubsidence= of= a= layered= halfspaceI= uniformly= loaded= on= circular= or=rectangular=superficial=areaI=the=following=well=established=analytical=solutions=were=appliedW==

NK=According=to=tinterkorn=and=cang=xNOINPz==

=b

vqBcs d FNE O-= = =ENF=

=

OK=According=to=pteinbrenner=xNPI=N4z==

= ( )cffffbvqBs IIN

ON

O-= = EOF=

Page 5: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

OR4M=

fn=the=above=formulaeI=cd=accounts= for= the=geometry=of= foundationI= BZdiameter= of= circular= areas=orI=width=of=rectangular=ones=and=fi=Z=factors=depending=on=geometryK==As=far=as=the=geometry=of=loaded=surface=is=concernedI=two=cases=are=examinedW=

– uniform= press= on= circular= superficial= footing= of= diameter= equal= to= that= of= the= lpisthodomos=column=base=Ea=≈=NKTN=mF=

– uniform=press=on=a=square=surface=with=area=equal= to=half=the=circular=area=of=the=lpisthodomos=column=baseI=in=order=to=account=for=the=eccentric=vertical=loading=mv=of=the=column=baseI=arising=from=the=horizontal=thrust=of=the=column=capital=Ecouple=of=forces=–mvI=mv=≈=NMM=kkFK=

= cinallyI=for=each=column=ElhN=–=lh4F=four=layered=profiles=were=considered=EtotK=NS=profilesF=– qwo=plate=thick=marble=EMKSO=mF=on=marly=halfspace=EfoundationF=–=referring=to=the=west=side=of=

the=column=base=– lne=plate=thick=marble=EMKPM=mF=on=marly=halfspace=EfoundationF=–=referring=to=the=east=side=of=the=

column=base=– qwo=plate=thick=marble=EMKSO=mF=on=dolomite=halfspace=EfoundationF=–=referring=to=the=west=side=

of=the=column=base=– lne=plate=thick=marble=EMKPM=mF=on=dolomite=halfspace=EfoundationF=–=referring=to=the=west=side=of=

the=column=base=qhe=limestone=bedrock=of=the=rockhill=is=considered=rigidI=since=it=appears=in=a=practically=non=affected=from=the=loaded=surface=depthK==

Table O Base=pprings=EjkLmPF==

= morous===Blocks= aolomite=Blocks=bast= test= bast= test=

lhJN= NMMM= N8OR= 4NOR= RORM=lhJO= 88M= NRTR= PVMM= 48RM=lhJP= T8P= NPTP= PTRM= 4R48=lhJ4= TM8= NOOP= PSNR= 4PNR=

=qotallyI= S4= parametric= analyses= were= performed= EO= methods= ×= O= loaded= areas= ×= NS= geotechnical=profilesFK= fndicative= results= of= the= analyses= Evalues= of= base= springs= for= sqK= surfaceI= according= to=tinterkorn=C=cangF=are=summarized=in=qable=OK====PK4K deostructural parameters Espring constantsF qhe=mechanical=properties=of=geomaterials=and=the=analytical=results=from=subsidence=calculations=are=used= for= the= estimation=of=proper= spring=constantsI= accounting= for= the= simulation=of= contact= surface=between=the=drums=and=subbase=foundationI=respectivelyK==PK4KNK fnterface EcontactF pprings qhe=interface=springs=ENO=peripheral=and=one=centralF=per=unit=areaI=are=calculated=according=to==

= NMLI nso

in kk

hb

k »= = EPF=

=where=kn=represents=compressionJonly=properties=and=ks=frictional=behaviorK==fn=the=above=formulaeI=the=voung=jodulus=bi=refers=to=a=notional=loose=geomaterialI=filling=the=joints=between=drumsI =while =ho=Z=N=mmI= is=the=nominal= joint=openingK=qhese=springs=are=considered=to=have=constant=unit=area=value=for=all=the=peripheral=and=the=central=spring=respectivelyK=qwo=sets=of=contact=springs=are=examined=for=bi=Z=NRMMM=kkLmO=and=bi=Z=TRMM=kkLmO=respectivelyK===PK4KOK EsubFBase pprings qhe=subJbase=springs=are=evaluated=according=to=the=definition=formulaW==

= NMLI vsv

v kksqk == = =E4F=

=thereI=q=Z=contact=press=on=the=loaded=area=of=the=column=base=and=sv=Z=the=relevant=subsidenceI=on=the=assumption=of=rigid=baseK=

Page 6: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

OR4N=

=

cigK R=PJa=modeling=of=opisthodomos=columns==

PK4KPK PJa Analyses qhe=results=of= the=previous=paragraph=Espring=valuesF= are=utilized=for=nonlinear= elastic=PJa=analysesK=qhe=modeling=comprises=the=exact=Eidealized=geometryF=of=the=columnsI=with=contact=springs=between=the=drums=and=base=springs=for=modeling=of=the=subJbase=foundation==EcigK=RFK=qhe=PJa=analyses=results=are= more= or= less= consistent= to= the= measured= valuesK= qotallyI= VS= analyses= were= performedI=corresponding=to=aF=different=base=springsI=arising=from=the=elastic=calculations=of= the=PKN=paragraphI=bF=difference= in= geotechnical= subbase= conditions= Emarly= or= dolomite= blocksF= and= cF= difference= in=contact= spring= constantsK= qhe= results= of= caclulated= horizontal= drift= and= subsidence= from= the= PJa=analyses=are=summarized=in=qable=PK===

Table P jeasurements=vs=mredictions= =

MbAprobMbNTp = δhEmmF sv(μmF = E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2 E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2

lhJN NKR8= = NKVM=P= NK8TP= NK8M= J= J= J= J=NKRO= =====NK4M= NK8PP= ======NK8MP= = = = =

lhJO ==OKNM=P= NKVV= NKV8P= OKNR= R4= PO= 4MP= R8=OKMM= NKVV= NKV8P= = JO4= NP= 84= =

lhJP ==OKRMP= OK4V= OKPMP= =OKP4P= 48= JOP4= PT= OO== OKMM= OK4RP= ======OKRMP= = 44= N=4= NS=

lhJ4 ===OKOMP= OK4S= OKOMP= OKN8= 4NP= PM= PT=P= 4O=======OKOMP= =====OKRM= ===========EKSNIKSTINKNTFR= ======OKNS= 4VP= PO= ENPINTIOOFR= 48=

mobafCTflNp Eelastic solutionsFN = δhEmmF sv(μmF = moros=coundation== E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2 E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2

lhJN

=

NO= OO=lhJO N4= OR=lhJP NS= O8=lhJ4 N8= PN=

= aolomite=foundation== E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2 E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2

lhJN

=

4= R=lhJO 4= S=lhJP R= S=lhJ4 R= S=

mobafCTflNp EPJa analysesF = δhEmmF sv(μmF = E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2 E-W2 W-E2 N-S2 S-N2

lhJN =JOKNS= = = OKNS= JOKNV= OKNV= N8= OS= OP= OP=lhJO =JOKOM= = = OKOM= JOKON= OKON= OM= OV= OS= OS=lhJP =JOKOR= = = OKO4= JOKOS= OKOS= O4= PP= PM= PM=lhJ4 =JOKOT= = = OKOV= JOKPM= OKPM= OS= PT= PP= PP=

=

ENF=tinterkornCcang=EequivK=square=to=half=circular=baseFI=EOF=loading=directionI=EPF=extrapolation=for=mhZNMkkI=E4F=dolomite=foundationI=ERF=for=mhZPI4IS=kk=respectivelyK=

Page 7: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

OR4O=

cromI=the=results=it=is=obvious=that=the=best=simulation=corresponds=aF=to=subbase=springs=arising=from=a=uniform=loaded=square=with=area=equal=to=that=of=the=half=circular=column=baseI=for=the=elastic=solution=according= to= tinterkorn= and= cang= xNNz= and= bF= to= contact= springs= for= notional= infill= material= of=bi=Z=TRMM=kkLmPK=fndicative=comparison=between=measurements=and=analytical=predictions=for=column=lhJ4=are=shown=in=cigK=SK==

==

cigK S=Comparison=between=measurements=and=analytical=predictions=for=column=lhJ4==Eloading=directionW=p=to=kF=

=4K ClNCirpflNp =qhe=main=general=conclusions=arising=from=this=research=can=be=summarized=as=followsW=

– qhe= large= scale= nonJdestructive= testing= is= invaluable= for= the= interpretation= of= the= structural=behavior=of=monuments=

– qhe=performance=of=loaded=dry=masonry=structures=is=simulated=satisfactorily=with=the=application=of=rockJmechanics=principles=

– qhe= proper= analytical= procedures= supported= by= experimental= results= offer= a= stiff= frame= for=successful=estimation=of=the=essential=mechanical=parameters=of=monuments’=geomaterialsK=

fn= additionI= the= main= findings= from= the= interpretation= of= the= experimental= results= comprise= the=followingW=

– qhe=columns=horizontal=drift=is=governed=mainly=by=the=mechanical=properties=of=contact=surfacesK==– qhe=subsidence=depends=mainly=on=the=subJbase=foundation=material=propertiesK=qhe=assumption=

that= the=foundation=is=made=from=soft= rock=marly=limestone=blocks= interprets= the=relatively=high=subsidence=measurementsK=ln=the=other=hand=the=rather=limited=number=of= low=value=subsidence=measurements=may=be=attributed=to=the=local=presence=of=dolomite=foundation=blocksK==

qhe=practical=±equal”=drift=and=the=settlements=that=have=been=measured=on=columns=lhJP=and=lhJ4=verify=that=the=effect=of=foundation=thickness=is=limited=to=caK=RJS=m=below=the=lpisthodomos=column=baseK=cinallyI= according= to= the= resultsI= the= modeling= of= discrete= structures= with= properly= determined=parameters= for= monument’s= geomaterialsI= could= satisfactorily=be=applied= to= restoration=analyses=and=could= form=the=base= for= more=complex= calculations= involving= dynamic= effects= eKgK= earthquakeK= qhe=comparison=of=measured=values=and=analytical=predictions=are=generally= in=good=agreementI= offering=increased= accuracyK= qhe= proposed= modeling= approachI= supported= by= the= carefully= planned= and=executed=trial=load=procedureI=offers=a=well=–=founded=basis=for=the=analysis=of=the=highly=complex=and=demanding=issues=of=classical=monuments’=restorationK==AChNltibadMbNTp =qhe=authors=express=their=gratitude=to=the=Committee=for=the=mreservation=of=the=Acropolis=jonuments=for=having=supported=the=actionI=to=mrofK=bK=sintzileou=and=the=late=mrofK=fK=sardoulakis=for=having=lent=the=isaqs=and=to=ar=hK=wambasI=former=airector=of=the=Acropolis=oestoration=perviceI=for=his=advices=and=overall=supportK=

Page 8: fJpfrbpplebfboitbpbo lirplcebmoeblalabifd ... · ORP= =F===== bF= cigKP =dometr==mhenon=foundation=F=b==Ep==kF=n=bF=m=iewK=a==K=lrlando=ENVTF== OK bpfdmolgb = f=orde=t=carr=ou=th=tria=loa=testsI=firs==reinforce

=

OR4P=

obcbobNCbp =xNz kK= qoganidisI= marthenon= oestoration= mrojectI= mrocK uuf fnternational CfmA pymposiumI= MNJMS

lctober=OMMTI=AthensI=dreeceK=xOz bKJbK=qoumbakariI=ptudy of the bearing structure and description of the actions carried out for

the lpisthodomos structural restoration=EvolK=4FI=jinKof=CultureI=OMMTK=xPz bKJbK= qoumbakariI= oeport to the Committee for the mreservation of the Acropolis Monuments

Eas=well= as= Archives= of= the= Acropolis= oestoration= perviceFI= jinKof= CultureI= ganuary= OMMOI=cebruary=OMMO=C=jay=OMMOK=

x4z lrlandos=AKI=qhe architecture of the marthenonI=NV4SK=xRz bK= eoekI= CK= CarranzaJqorresI= and= BK= CorkumI= eoekJBrown= criterion= –= OMMO= editionI= mrocK

kAoMpJqAC ConferenceI qorontoI=OMMOK=xSz bK=eoek=and=jKpK=aiederichsI=bmpirical=estimation=of=rock=mass=modulusI=fnternational gournal

of oock Mechanics and Mining pciences 4P=EOMMSFI=OMPJONRK=xTz sKjarinosI=mKjarinos=and=bK=eoekI=qhe=geological=ptrength=indexW=applications=and=limitationsI=

BullK bngK deolK bnvironKI=S4I=EOMMRFI=RRJSRK=x8z oockscience=fncKI=ooclab NKMPNJ software codeI=qorontoI=lntarioI=CanadaI=OMMRK=xVz a=bgglezosI=aK=joullouI=aK=javromatiI=deostructural=Analysis=of=the=Athenian=Acropolis=tall=

Based= on= qerrestrial= iaser= pcanning= aataI= fnternational Archives of mhotogrammetry oemote pensing and ppatial fnformation pciencesI=PT=EOMM8FI=NMVPJNNMMK=

xNMz aK= bgglezosI= aK= joullouI= BackJanalysis= for= interpretation=of= a= structural=damage=at= a= specific=area= of= Athenian= Acropolis= korth= Circuit= tallI= Ein= dreekFI= mroceedings of the Sth eellenic Conference on deotechnical and deonviromental bngineeringI=solos=–=dreeceI=OMNMK=

xNNz dK= houkisI= AK= AndronopoulosI= deologicalJdeotechnical ptudy of the Athenian Acropolis areaI fnstitute=of=deology=and=jineral=bxplorationI=AthensI=NVTSK=

xNOz mK=qheoulakisI=AK=ptefanisI= fK=haratasiosI=dK=derogiannisI=mreliminary fnvestigation of Mortars for the cementation of porous Efrom miraeus coastF architectural members of the Acropolis MonumentsI iaboratory=for=Conservation=of=structural=ptoneI=AthensI=OMMVK=

xNPz eK=cK=tinterkorn=and=eK=cK=cangI=coundation bngineering eandbookI=jcdrawJeillI=kew=vorkI=NVTRI=N48JNSSK=

xN4z aKCK=tyllieI=coundations on oockI=b=C=ck=pmlkI=iondon=and=kvKI=NVVVK=xNRz tK=pteinbrennerI=qafeln=zur=petzungsberechnungI=aie ptrasse NI=NVP4I=NONJNO4K=