49

FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

  • Upload
    vandat

  • View
    216

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation
Page 2: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Tamas Budavari / Applied Math & Stats, JHU

FROM BALTIMORE TO THE STARS WITH DATA

Page 3: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation
Page 4: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Breaking the Divestment Cycle: Predicting Abandonment & Fostering Neighborhood Revitalization in BaltimoreTamás BudaváriApplied Mathematics & Statistics – The Johns Hopkins University

Page 5: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Baltimore overview• Baltimore has lost 1/3 of its population since 1950• Today, we have 16,500 boarded up vacant buildings• Of these, 13,000 are in distressed markets

M. Braverman

Page 6: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Boarded up vacants

M. Braverman

Page 7: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

data science

flexible data platform

predictive modeling & optimization

1data fusion

geometry + historyhighly extensible

Page 8: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

social science

modeling transition

estimating externalities

evaluating policy

2

Page 9: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

social science

modeling transition

estimating externalities

evaluating policy

2

Page 10: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

government

rapid response queries

assisting with strategic investments

mapping “unoccupancy”

3

Page 11: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Data in Baltimore OpenBaltimore

Hundreds of public datasets online http://data.baltimorecity.gov

Plus more administrative data

Page 12: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

DHCD’s Data Infrastructure Dept. of Housing & Community Dev

Study changes over time Support decision making

Statistics to help? Inference & prediction

M. BravermanJ. D. Evans

Page 13: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Jim Gray’s 20 Questions Data-driven studies

Low-level questionsWhat we see

High-level questions Help hone policy making Interventions

Page 14: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Built a Unique Solution Database of Baltimore City

Geospatial info for all parcels Time history of real properties

Easily extendable On the IDIES’s Data-Scope Novel indexing for fast links

Page 15: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Mapping Vacancy2010 2015

Phil Garboden

Page 16: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Mapping Vacancy2010 2015

Phil Garboden

Page 17: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Clustering of Vacancy Probability of finding a

vacant next to another

Quantitative comparison Over time Across town

Page 18: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Similar Neighborhoods Similarity graphs & eigenmaps

Page 19: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

What is a Neighborhood? Are neighborhood boundaries meaningful? Better grouping of houses?

Trends on a finer scale

Page 20: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Collapsed Vacants

Page 21: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Collapsed Vacant Ends of contiguous blocks of rowhomes

Alleys, gaps and demos break rows Need “sub-blockface” analysis

Time-dependent

Page 22: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Neighborhood Revitalization Modeling urban transitions

What factors catalyzereinvestment?

Disinvestment? Innovative use of data

New sources of information Zillow? Cell phone usage?

Page 23: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Neighborhood Revitalization Modeling urban transitions

What factors catalyzereinvestment?

Disinvestment? Innovative use of data

New sources of information Zillow? Cell phone usage?

Page 24: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Strategic Investments Governor’s budget

Unprecedented $75M City scheduling

Spring 2016 JHU map of targets!

Page 25: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Strategic Investments Combinatorial Optimization

Improve some objective, e.g.,or

Within a limited budget

Best objective? How to solve?

Page 26: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Optimize the Impact Different objectives

Same budget

Advanced tools For decision makers

Lenny FanAmitabh BasuPhil Garboden

Page 27: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation
Page 28: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Price Longitudinal data Environment Prediction Machine

Learning

Page 29: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Ambitious Next Steps

Ben Seigel (21CC)Katalin SzlaveczBen ZaitchikKeeve NachmanKatie O’Meara (MICA)

Page 30: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Spatiotemporal Multi-Level Modeling Hierarchical Bayesian statistics Include all aggregated data Joint inference for the

Individual houses and Ensemble distributions

Mengyang Gu

Page 31: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Predicting Unoccupancy Time-series data

Water usage BG&E usage USPS

Proxy for occupancy

Phil GarbodenHana Clemens

Page 32: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Satellite View Missing roof? Blue tarp = holes?

Page 33: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Looking up! Astronomy images Blurred exposures

We solve for it For high-res details

Image behind the Atmosphere

Coadded Image

Matthias LeeCharlie GulianRick White

Page 34: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Looking up! Astronomy images Blurred exposures

We solve for it For high-res details

Image behind the Atmosphere

Coadded Image

Matthias LeeCharlie GulianRick White

Page 35: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Image behind the Atmosphere Looking up!

Astronomy images Blurred exposures

We solve for it For high-res details

Deconvolved Image

Matthias LeeCharlie GulianRick White

Page 36: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Image behind the Atmosphere Looking up!

Astronomy images Blurred exposures

We solve for it For high-res details

Hubble Image

Matthias LeeCharlie GulianRick White

Page 37: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Differential Chromatic Refraction Even colors!

Matthias LeeAndy ConnollyCharlie Gulian

Page 38: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Differential Chromatic Refraction Even colors!

Matthias LeeAndy ConnollyCharlie Gulian

Page 39: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

At the Heart… Applied Math & Stats

Data mining Statistical modeling Machine learning Optimization Bayesian inference

Data-Intensive Science Hardware platforms Software solutions Streaming algorithms Database technologies GIS tools & indexing

Page 40: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Limitations of Machine Learning Many methods to choose from

And more knobs to tweak Latching on known features

Manual intervention to refine What’s left in the data?

Missing the Human in the Loop!

Page 41: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Use the Brain’s Detection Power

Page 42: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Rapid Serial Visual Presentation Current state-of-the-art is binary classification

Target / Distractor We look for the interesting

Dynamic behavior of brain: looking for new

Nick Carey

Page 43: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Human-Machine Co-Learning

Hide wireframe of 3D cube in high-D Looks like noise Random projections

Nick Carey

Page 44: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Human-Machine Co-Learning

Hide wireframe of 3D cube in high-D Looks like noise Random projections Trigger to explore locally

Nick Carey

Page 45: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Human-Machine Co-Learning

Hide wireframe of 3D cube in high-D Looks like noise Random projections Trigger to explore locally Converge on better view

Nick Carey

Page 46: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Human-Machine Co-Learning

Hide wireframe of 3D cube in high-D Looks like noise Random projections Trigger to explore locally Converge on better viewSubconscious Navigation!

Nick Carey

Page 47: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Human-Machine Co-Learning

Hide wireframe of 3D cube in high-D Looks like noise Random projections Trigger to explore locally Converge on better viewSubconscious Navigation!

Nick Carey

Page 48: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation

Summary

Promising first steps With direct applications already deployed

Common data infrastructure & approaches Surprisingly similar, e.g., across astro/city

Ambitious future plans Need help! And need more data…

Page 49: FROM BALTIMORE TO THE - idies.jhu.eduidies.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/budavari-slides-2018.pdf · Disinvestment? Innovative use of ... Rapid Serial Visual Presentation