FSOR APPENDIX B: LIST OF COMMENTERS FROM 45 DAY PERIOD · Jennifer Post Inergraph PP&M Deutschland GmbH W21-1 9 W21-2 5 W21-3 7 Emily Borowski ... Arocles Aguilar; Helen Mickiewicz;

FSOR APPENDIX B: LIST OF COMMENTERS FROM 45 DAY PERIOD

Page 1 of 40

Name Organization Comment # Response #

Fernando W1-1 872 Fred Roth

W2-1 365, 366 W2-2 367

Dr. Johnny Ryan, FRHistS, Chief Policy & Industry Relations Officer

Brave Software W3-1 146 W3-2 34 W3-3 368 W3-4 22 W3-5 43

Mark Grace Grace Franchise Operating Company, Inc.

W4-1 903

friendofprivacy W5-1 336 Laurie Lamberth, VP Operations

Bulzi Media Inc. W6-1 33

friendofprivacy W7-1 349 Gerald Lamb MPP Co. Inc. W8-1 5, 6 Shawn Yadon, CEO

California Trucking Association

W9-1 523 W9-2 523

Stan Stahl, President

Secure The Village W10-1 924

Yaakov Shapiro W11-1 339, 340 Brian Pier W12-1 783 Anonymous

W13-1 841 W13-2 376, 382 W13-3 15, 565 W13-4 948 W13-5 841, 957

Anonymous W14-1 617 Webb Howell W15-1 25 Jason Kint, CEO; Chris Pedigo, SVP Government Affairs

Digital Content Next W16-1 519


Roger McNamee

W17-1 47, 560, 561, 611, 781, 920, 942, 956

W17-2 958 Thomas Folkes, VP State Government Affairs

Entertainment Software Association

W18-1 900, 901 W18-2 900 W18-3 375

James Harrison, Attorney for CCP; Alastair Mactaggart, Chair

Californians for Consumer Privacy

W19-1 932 W19-2 933 W19-3 934 W19-4 935 W19-5 936 W19-6 937

Kira Alvarez; George W. Jordan III, Chair

ABA Intellectual Property Law Section

W20-1 901

Jennifer Post Inergraph PP&M Deutschland GmbH

W21-1 9 W21-2 5 W21-3 7

Emily Borowski

SF Fire Credit Union

W22-1 867 W22-2 917 W22-3 906

Andrew Wippl W23-1 885 Mary-Lou Heighes Compliance Plus Inc.

W24-1 955 W24-2 907 W24-3 381 W24-4 373 W24-5 600, 601

Field Garthwaite, Co-Founder / CEO

IRIS.TV

W25-1 647 W25-2 683

W25-3 832 Annalee Akin; Michael Belote,

California Advocates, Inc.

W26-1 143 W26-2 246, 247,


Page 2 of 40


President 248, 249 W26-3 465, 466

W26-4 493 W26-5 221 W26-6 357 W26-7 648 W26-8 653, 677 W26-9 794 W26-10 68 Anonymous W27-1 168, 173,

182, 184, 192

W27-2 604, 605 W27-3 616 W27-4 516 W27-5 687 W27-6 754 W27-7 134 W27-8 432 W27-9 21 W27-10 29 Dalia Martinez, Executive VP Operations

International Bancshares Corporation

W28-1 5, 7 W28-2 906

Dale Smith, CIPT PrivacyCheq W29-1 95 W29-2 96, 114 W29-3 917 Elaine Morgan W30-1 2 Greg Badovinac W31-1 363 W31-2 97, 269 W31-3 102 W31-4 338 W31-5 376, 380


W31-6 779, 782 W31-7 855 W31-8 953 Anonymous W32-1 367 W32-2 451 Karen Davis; Clark Malak

Vigilant W33-1 151 W33-2 864, 865,

914 Anne Kimbol / Asst General Counsel and Chief Privacy Officer

HiTrust W34-1 106 W34-2 336 W34-3 582

W34-4 369, 698 Aloni Cohen, PhD W35-1 41 Arocles Aguilar; Helen Mickiewicz; Kimberly Lippi

California Public Utilities Commission

W36-1 503 W36-2 623 W36-3 503

Kevin Walsh; Tim Rouse, Executive Director

The Spark Institute, Inc.

W37-1 55 W37-2 56

W37-3 57 W37-4 123 W37-5 124 W37-6 875 W37-7 125 W37-8 125 W37-9 876 Joseph Doherty, SVP Chief Legal & Legislative Officer

Self Storage Association

W38-1 80 W38-2 98

W38-3 144 W38-4 172, 185 W38-5 212 W38-6 205 W38-7 314 W38-8 350


Page 3 of 40


W38-9 344 W38-10 376, 404 W38-11 409 W38-12 364 W38-13 424 W38-14 364 W38-15 466 W38-16 443, 452 W38-17 481 W38-18 495 W38-19 364 W38-20 582, 583 W38-21 641 W38-22 684 W38-23 728 W38-24 732 W38-25 743 W38-26 750 W38-27 768, 769 W38-28 756 W38-29 783 W38-30 812 W38-31 831 John Pettitt W39-1 959 Adam Teitelbaum, Deputy City Attorney

Los Angeles City Attorney's Office

W40-1 137

Jeffrey Dennis Newmeyer Dillion W41-1 98 W41-2 327 W41-3 373 W41-4 600, 601 W41-5 921 Seren Taylor, Senior Legislative

Personal Insurance Federation of

W42-1 867 W42-2 961


Advocate California W42-3 118 W42-4 63 W42-5 131 W42-6 144 W42-7 224 W42-8 239, 240 W42-9 261 W42-10 290, 291,

308, 310 W42-11 311 W42-12 316 W42-13 568, 601 W42-14 624 W42-15 751 W42-16 339, 340 W42-17 349 W42-18 376 W42-19 404 W42-20 440 W42-21 466 W42-22 493, 494 W42-23 505, 506 W42-24 585, 587 W42-25 652, 653 W42-26 901 W42-27 953 W42-28 977 W42-29 841, 857,

858 Gilbert Lara, Public Policy Director; Pat Fong Kushida, President/CEO

California Asian Chamber of Commerce

W43-1 883 W43-2 246, 251 W43-3 197

W43-4 35 W43-5 81


Page 4 of 40


W43-6 342, 653 W43-7 923 W43-8 873 W43-9 962 Donna Barstow W44-1 971 Jan Stieger, CAE, CMP

Recievables Management Association International

W45-1 7 W45-2 47

W45-3 112, 132 W45-4 98 W45-5 135 W45-6 147 W45-7 152 W45-8 162 W45-9 112 W45-10 112 W45-11 98, 271 W45-12 271 W45-13 283 W45-14 263 W45-15 293 W45-16 304, 305 W45-17 311 W45-18 339, 340 W45-19 338 W45-20 453 W45-21 905 W45-22 389 W45-23 370, 425 W45-24 575 W45-25 598 W45-26 633 W45-27 655 W45-28 82 W45-29 83


W45-30 723 W45-31 725 W45-32 702 W45-33 702 W45-34 729 W45-35 733 W45-36 737 W45-37 757 Stan Stahl, PhD., Founder and President

Secure the Village W46-1 924

Adrian Hansen W47-1 566 Steve Denis, Executive Director

Small Business Finance Association

W48-1 115 W48-2 848

W48-3 118 W48-4 116 W48-5 263 W48-6 32 W48-7 454 W48-8 454 W48-9 454 W48-10 455, 482,

483 W48-11 456 W48-12 456 Donna Barstow W49-1 959 Karris Standish, Legal Assistant; Richard Barlow, Founder & CEO

Wejo Ltd W50-1 925 W50-2 390, 466 W50-3 599

W50-4 28 W50-5 856 W50-6 868, 914 Donna Barstow W51-1 972 Max Kornblith, Radvocate Inc. W52-1 44


Page 5 of 40


Head of Growth; Teel Lidow, CEO Tanya Forsheit; Rachel Michelin

California Retailers Association

W53-1 867 W53-2 814

W53-3 814 W53-4 247, 254 W53-5 247 W53-6 833 W53-7 833 W53-8 815 W53-9 126 W53-10 134 W53-11 118 W53-12 342 W53-13 582, 587,

588 W53-14 604 W53-15 465, 466 W53-16 206, 208 W53-17 224, 225,

227 W53-18 606 W53-19 384, 385 W53-20 357 W53-21 685 W53-22 676, 678 W53-23 69 W53-24 648 Tanya Forsheit; David Chavern, President/CEO of News Media Alliance

News Media Alliance and California News Publishers Association

W54-1 130 W54-2 867 W54-3 130, 135 W54-4 134 W54-5 108

W54-6 206, 208


W54-7 466 W54-8 867 W54-9 541 W54-10 588 W54-11 604 W54-12 384 W54-13 664, 676,

680 W54-14 80, 685,

698 W54-15 349, 351 W54-16 10 W54-17 924 W54-18 874 Mike Signorelli, Attorney; Dan Jaffe, Group EVP, ANA; Dave Grimaldi, EVP IAB; Christopher Oswald, SVP ANA, Alison Pepper, SVP AAAA; Clark Rector, EVP AAF, David LeDuc, NAI

Associations of National Advertisers, American Association of Advertising Agencies, Interactive Advertising Bureau, American Advertising Federation, Network Advertising Iniative

W55-1 89 W55-2 306 W55-3 186, 187 W55-4 585, 588,

594 W55-5 575 W55-6 734 W55-7 105, 293 W55-8 105 W55-9 384, 701 W55-10 337 W55-11 604 W55-12 465

Michael Pepson American for Prosperity Foundation (AFPF) Coaltion

W56-1 7 W56-2 950 W56-3 950 W56-4 950 W56-5 948 W56-6 7, 951 W56-7 952


Page 6 of 40


Matt Kownacki, Director AFSA; David Knight, Executive Director CFSA

American Financial Services Association; California Financial Services Association

W57-1 868, 914 W57-2 82 W57-3 388 W57-4 105

W57-5 97 W57-6 144 W57-7 167, 170,

186, 187, 188

W57-8 207, 214 W57-9 238 W57-10 290 W57-11 293 W57-12 293 W57-13 311 W57-14 314 W57-15 357 W57-16 423 W57-17 369, 924 W57-18 433 W57-19 466 W57-20 480 W57-21 480 W57-22 493, 494 W57-23 670, 676 W57-24 684 W57-25 752 W57-26 768 W57-27 98, 113 W57-28 457 W57-29 438 Garrett Hohimer, General Counsel;

Alight Solutions W58-1 526


Tola Sobitan, Chief Privacy Officer Robert Holden; Julian Roberts, President AAPAN

American Association of Payers, Administrators and Networks

W59-1 898 W59-2 886 W59-3 46

Dan Jaffe, Group EVP

Association of National Advertisers

W60-1 247, 813, 818

W60-2 813 W60-3 246, 813 W60-4 818 W60-5 247 W60-6 585, 588,

594 W60-7 581 W60-8 594 W60-9 604 W60-10 604 W60-11 604 W60-12 604 W60-13 170, 186 W60-14 798, 803,

804 W60-15 89 W60-16 342, 343 W60-17 306 W60-18 475 W60-19 337, 577 W60-20 551 W60-21 541 W60-22 702 W60-23 352, 701 W60-24 465, 466 W60-25 293


Page 7 of 40


W60-26 281, 282 W60-27 302 W60-28 221 W60-29 673 W60-30 105 W60-31 115 W60-32 339, 340,

575 W60-33 105, 106,

111 W60-34 232 W60-35 364 W60-36 364 W60-37 706 Susan Kammerer; Jeremy Merz, VP State Affairs, Western Region

American Property Casualty Insurance Association

W61-1 106, 918 W61-2 867, 914 W61-3 106

W61-4 105 W61-5 153 W61-6 143, 144 W61-7 161 W61-8 223 W61-9 262, 263 W61-10 276, 277,

278 W61-11 284 W61-12 290 W61-13 303 W61-14 293 W61-15 375, 386 W61-16 391, 392,

403, 416, 426, 466, 506


W61-17 458, 466, 480, 484, 494

W61-18 530 W61-19 63, 316 W61-20 357, 404,

756, 768 W61-21 568, 575,

582, 585, 587, 616

W61-22 65, 66, 73 W61-23 5, 6 Katie Kennedy, Privacy and Information Security Counsel

Apple, Inc. W62-1 82, 684, 685

W62-2 685 W62-3 433 W62-4 755

W62-5 551 Timothy Tobin, Counsel; Jessica Simmons, AGC

Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers

W63-1 409 W63-2 410 W63-3 364, 393

W63-4 364, 597 W63-5 686 W63-6 28, 39,

459 W63-7 562 W63-8 50 W63-9 117 W63-10 117 W63-11 686 W63-12 393, 410 W63-13 564 W63-14 582, 587,

588, 590


Page 8 of 40


W63-15 590 W63-16 143 W63-17 143 W63-18 193 W63-19 317 W63-20 604 W63-21 767 W63-22 153, 156,

293, 444 W63-23 394 W63-24 302 W63-25 198 W63-26 774 W63-27 323 Steve Kirkham; Eric Levine Co-Founders

Berbix, Inc.; Berbix.com

W64-1 705, 707 W64-2 707

W64-3 744, 762 W64-4 705, 767 W64-5 615, 777,

787, 790, 791

W64-6 777, 790, 791

W64-7 615 W64-8 615 W64-9 797 Angelena Bradfield, SVP

Bank Policy Institute W65-1 867, 868, 871, 914

W65-2 466 W65-3 735 W65-4 289, 375,

752, 753 W65-5 493, 653,


676, 680 W65-6 495 W65-7 170, 194 W65-8 153, 293 W65-9 224, 226 W65-10 915 W65-11 774 W65-12 911 W65-13 224 Meghan Pensyl, Policy Associate; Kate Goodloe, Director of Policy

BSA Software Alliance

W66-1 541 W66-2 541

W66-3 551

Moises Rosales; Anna Buck, Legislative Advocate

California Association of Realtors

W67-1 477, 479, 696, 742

W67-2 804 W67-3 819

Andrew Cotten, Regulatory Counsel

Consumer Bankers Association

W68-1 565, 587 W68-2 369

W68-3 290, 293, 308, 316

W68-4 901 W68-5 47, 48 W68-6 524 W68-7 926 W68-8 916 W68-9 867 W68-10 914 Jennifer Barrera, EVP Cal Chamber; Dominique Shelton Leipzig, counsel; Megan Von Borstel, counsel

California Chamber of Commerce

W69-1 867 W69-2 581, 585,

587, 588, 590

W69-3 574 W69-4 604


Page 9 of 40


W69-5 617 W69-6 568

W69-7 601 W69-8 241, 247,

253 W69-9 446, 465,

466, 480 W69-10 357, 374,

384 W69-11 367, 369,

395, 441, 444, 448

W69-12 367, 369 W69-13 364, 410 W69-14 419 W69-15 423, 427,

509 W69-16 403, 444,

446 W69-17 541 W69-18 551 W69-19 445, 446 W69-20 90 W69-21 88 W69-22 628 W69-23 144 W69-24 899 W69-25 170, 186,

196 W69-26 144 W69-27 134, 164 W69-28 100 W69-29 180 W69-30 208, 224,


226, 227 W69-31 336, 342,

344 W69-32 357 W69-33 348 W69-34 652, 653,

657, 659, 661, 664, 668, 669, 676

W69-35 752, 754, 767

W69-36 735, 736 W69-37 289, 290,

291, 294 W69-38 314 W69-39 684 W69-40 737, 738 W69-41 778, 779,

784, 785 W69-42 820 W69-43 834 W69-44 797 W69-45 794 W69-46 512 Kathleen Ryan VP ABA; Kevin Gold, SVP, CBA; Susan Milazzo, CEO CMBA; Pete Mills, SVP MBA

American Bankers Association; California Bankers Assocation; California Mortgage Bankers Assocation; Mortage Bankers Association

W70-1 144 W70-2 227 W70-3 294 W70-4 465, 466,

493, 506 W70-5 581, 585,

587, 591, 601, 604

W70-6 652, 653,


Page 10 of 40


657, 664, 676

W70-7 685 W70-8 684, 691 W70-9 698 W70-10 688 W70-11 698, 708 W70-12 752, 753 W70-13 768 W70-14 917 W70-15 916 W70-16 901 W70-17 867 Paul Ruden Paul M. Ruden

Consulting W71-1 5, 11

Karina Alkhasyan Capco W72-1 452, 460 W72-2 452 W72-3 460 W72-4 835 W72-5 430 Keir Lamont Computer &

Communications Industry Association

W73-1 692 W73-2 364 W73-3 706 W73-4 737 W73-5 106 W73-6 856 W73-7 874 W73-8 883 W73-9 144 W73-10 221 W73-11 420 W73-12 465, 466 W73-13 541 W73-14 551


W73-15 587 W73-16 604 W73-17 652, 653,

664, 669, 670, 680, 681

W73-18 800, 805 W73-19 819 W73-20 246, 813 James Harrison, Counsel; Alastair Mactaggart

Californians for Consumer Privacy

W74-1 469 W74-2 134, 135,

136, 138 W74-3 138

W74-4 556 W74-5 556 W74-6 218 W74-7 582, 593 W74-8 572 W74-9 233 W74-10 199, 200,

233 W74-11 602 W74-12 604 W74-13 420 W74-14 528 W74-15 533 W74-16 543 W74-17 551 W74-18 78 W74-19 78 W74-20 93 W74-21 133 W74-22 147 W74-23 70


Page 11 of 40


W74-24 70 W74-25 209 W74-26 281 W74-27 355 W74-28 481, 485 W74-29 514 W74-30 461 W74-31 631 W74-32 693 W74-33 821 W74-34 114 W74-35 149 W74-36 172 W74-37 205 W74-38 237 W74-39 237 W74-40 260 W74-41 364 W74-42 364 W74-43 467 W74-44 496 W74-45 364 W74-46 557 Adrine Adjemian, Counsel

Trucker Huss, APC W75-1 159

Lauren Valenzuela, Counsel

Performant W76-1 963 W76-2 135

W76-3 526 W76-4 551 W76-5 47 Gary LaFever, CEO and General Counsel

Anonos W77-1 477, 478, 742

Ross Hutchings, California Self W78-1 15


Executive Director Storage Association W78-2 80 W78-3 98 W78-4 144

W78-5 314

W78-6 350 W78-7 344 W78-8 924 W78-9 373, 376 W78-10 404 W78-11 424 W78-12 466 W78-13 641 W78-14 706 W78-15 743 W78-16 768 W78-17 783 A. Lysa Simon W79-1 907 Marc Rotenberg, president; Christine Bannan, counsel; W. Hunter Daley, law clerk

Electronic Privacy Information Center

W80-1 31 W80-2 943

W80-3 364 W80-4 945 W80-5 863

W80-6 942 W80-7 836 W80-8 920 W80-9 959 David Dickerson, VP State Gov. Affairs, NMMA; Jerry Desmond, RBC; David Kennedy, BoatUS

National Marine Manufacturers Association; Recreational Boaters of California; BoaUS Government Affairs

W81-1 910 W81-2 887

Jason Kint, CEO; Chris Pedigo, SVP

Digital Content Next W82-1 43 W82-2 299


Page 12 of 40


Government Affairs

W82-3 663

W82-4 537 W82-5 604 W82-6 43, 613 W82-7 586 W82-8 587, 594 Matt Gardner, CEO California Technology

Council W83-1 841

W83-2 251 W83-3 625 W83-4 35 W83-5 81 W83-6 342 W83-7 923 W83-8 873 W83-9 962 Julian Peterson, counsel

Traditional Medicinals

W84-1 786 W84-2 700

W84-3 642 W84-4 877, 878 Andrew Kingman; Clarrisa Cerda, General Counsel

Pindrop Security, Inc. W85-1 537 W85-2 551

W85-3 551 W85-4 410, 415 W85-5 699 W85-6 730 W85-7 699 W85-8 699 W85-9 699 Marc Zwillinger; Anna Hsia

ZwillGen PLLC W86-1 165 W86-2 323, 324

W86-3 541 W86-4 174 Jennifer Gibbons, The Toy Association W87-1 809


VP, State Gov. Affairs; Steve Pasierb, CEO

W87-2 794, 797, 798

W87-3 810 W87-4 84 W87-5 817 W87-6 349 W87-7 60, 811 W87-8 106 Webb McArthur, Associate; Eric Ellman, SVP

Consumer Data Industry Association

W88-1 883 W88-2 867, 869 W88-3 66

W88-4 1 W88-5 100 W88-6 153 W88-7 144 W88-8 170, 186,

189 W88-9 208 W88-10 213, 214 W88-11 213 W88-12 217 W88-13 221 W88-14 226, 227 W88-15 247 W88-16 293 W88-17 303 W88-18 306 W88-19 264 W88-20 336 W88-21 357 W88-22 404 W88-23 427 W88-24 444 W88-25 466


Page 13 of 40


W88-26 480 W88-27 505 W88-28 505, 506 W88-29 540, 541 W88-30 551 W88-31 585, 588 W88-32 601 W88-33 604 W88-34 617 W88-35 652, 657 W88-36 684, 685 W88-37 739 Fatima Khan, Counsel

Okta, Inc. W89-1 964

W89-2 541 W89-3 551 W89-4 699 Barbara Lawler, Chief Privacy and Data Ethics Officer

Looker W90-1 52 W90-2 261, 983 W90-3 328

W90-4 946 W90-5 917 W90-6 924 W90-7 852 W90-8 787, 793 W90-9 247, 255,

678 Josh Fisher, Senior Manager, State Gov. Affairs

Association of Global Automakers

W91-1 50 W91-2 117

W91-3 188, 189 W91-4 82, 604 W91-5 82 W91-6 462, 562 W91-7 323


W91-8 364, 396 W91-9 403, 444 W91-10 587 W91-11 430 Katey Herman, Senior Counsel; Jeffrey Grimes, VP Astex; Jason Olin, Counsel Avanir; Paul Bolar, VP Reg. Affairs Pharmavite; Irene Fisher, Piping Rock.

Astex Pharmaceuticals, Inc.; Avanir Pharmaceuticals, Inc.; Pharmavite, LLC; Piping Rock Health Products, LLC

W92-1 480 W92-2 480 W92-3 480 W92-4 480 W92-5 480

Chiara Rustici W93-1 837 Wayne Sisk, Sr. Manager

Celigo W94-1 234 W94-2 25, 33

W94-3 878 W94-4 566 Brent Blackaby; Crid Yu

Confidently.com W95-1 349, 353, 515, 582, 698, 709, 752, 779

W95-2 698, 752 W95-3 779 W95-4 349, 353,

515 W95-5 582 W95-6 709 Jessica Lee W96-1 883 W96-2 867, 868 W96-3 105 W96-4 246, 247,

248, 249, 250


Page 14 of 40


W96-5 465, 466 W96-6 585, 587,

588 W96-7 842 Elizabeth Bojorquez; Jacqueline Kinney, SVP and GC

California Cable & Telecommunications Association

W97-1 883 W97-2 465, 466 W97-3 565, 581

W97-4 541 W97-5 604 W97-6 105, 106 W97-7 752, 753 W97-8 639, 645 W97-9 571, 576 W97-10 68 W97-11 981 W97-12 841, 935,

938 Kyla Christoffersen Powell, President/CEO

Civil Justice Association of California

W98-1 364, 409, 706

W98-2 384 W98-3 465, 466

W98-4 585, 587, 588, 616

W98-5 767 W98-6 541 W98-7 626, 628,

629 W98-8 638, 652,

653 W98-9 246, 247,

248, 251, 818

W98-10 189, 196


W98-11 72 W98-12 868 W98-13 12 W98-14 924, 925,

926 W98-15 841, 843 Anthony Helton, Legislative Coordinator; Craig Page, EVP

California Land Title Association

W99-1 82 W99-2 100

W99-3 91 W99-4 841

Jerrell Cook, consultant

California Manufacterers and Technology Association

W100-1 888 W100-2 879 W100-3 82, 684

Alisa Reinhardt, Director of Regulatory Affairs

California New Car Dealers Association

W101-1 841 W101-2 144

W101-3 170, 186, 188

W101-4 208 W101-5 213 W101-6 227 W101-7 228 W101-8 246, 248 W101-9 320 W101-10 357 W101-11 384 W101-12 404 W101-13 466 W101-14 493, 494 W101-15 501 W101-16 541 W101-17 576 W101-18 585, 587,

588


Page 15 of 40


W101-19 604 W101-20 626, 630 W101-21 638, 646 W101-22 773 W101-23 926 W101-24 917 W101-25 106 W101-26 867 W101-27 935 W101-28 891 W101-29 894 David Zetoony, Christian Auty, Andrew Maciejewski, counsel

Red Ventures W102-1 763 W102-2 763 W102-3 764 W102-4 404

W102-5 404, 405, 752

W102-6 405, 752 W102-7 465, 466 W102-8 466 W102-9 466 W102-10 466 W102-11 587 W102-12 587 W102-13 589 W102-14 589 W102-15 589 W102-16 585 W102-17 581 W102-18 604 W102-19 604 W102-20 604 W102-21 662


W102-22 674 W102-23 670 W102-24 660, 670 W102-25 668 W102-26 653, 664 W102-27 653, 664 W102-28 652 Nora Colbert, SAA, Regulatory Compliance & Policy; Kathleen Ryan, VP & Senior Counsel

American Bankers Association

W103-1 706 W103-2 710

W103-3 698 W103-4 711 W103-5 901

W103-6 524, 529 W103-7 342, 344 W103-8 343 W103-9 376, 377 W103-10 357 W103-11 349 W103-12 466 W103-13 505, 506 W103-14 468 W103-15 618 W103-16 601 W103-17 581, 582,

585, 587, 588

W103-18 604 W103-19 144 W103-20 698 W103-21 698 W103-22 698 W103-23 652, 653 W103-24 917


Page 16 of 40


W103-25 926, 929 W103-26 438 W103-27 452 W103-28 867 W103-29 914 Tracy Shapiro, Counsel

DLA Piper LLP W104-1 403, 444, 445

W104-2 167, 189 W104-3 384 W104-4 417 W104-5 585 W104-6 590 W104-7 604 W104-8 835, 838 W104-9 653 W104-10 653 Yelena Grant, Sr. Manager Legal Affairs

Mobilityware W105-1 10 W105-2 10

Cindy Yaklin, Legislative Chair CAC; Andrew Madden, VP of Governement and State Affairs ACA

ACA International; California Collectors Association

W106-1 853 W106-2 841, 843 W106-3 427, 505,

506 W106-4 293

W106-5 119 W106-6 397 W106-7 867 Maia Hamin W107-1 476 W107-2 474 W107-3 474 W107-4 470 Jaime Walsh, Counsel

IG US Holdings, Inc. W108-1 315, 614, 783

W108-2 144


W108-3 265 W108-4 7 W108-5 5 W108-6 13 W108-7 14 W108-8 15 W108-9 16 W108-10 17 W108-11 544 W108-12 21 W108-13 868 Tatsuki Tomita Vivaldi Technologies W109-1 566 W109-2 902 Mitchel Noordyke, counsel; Brian B. Schnell

Faegre Baker Daniels LLP

W110-1 903 W110-2 903

W110-3 903 W110-4 904 Carlos Enriquez, Compliance Officer

Farmers Insurance Federal Credit Union

W111-1 906 W111-2 907

Tony Ficarrotta, Counsel; Leigh Freund, President/CEO

Network Advertising Initiative

W112-1 51 W112-2 71 W112-3 336

W112-4 385 W112-5 384 W112-6 404 W112-7 465, 466 W112-8 506, 509 W112-9 620 W112-10 582 W112-11 594 W112-12 603 W112-13 604, 607 W112-14 604 W112-15 604


Page 17 of 40


W112-16 604 W112-17 495 W112-18 765, 767 W112-19 767 W112-20 775 W112-21 134 W112-22 196 W112-23 196 W112-24 301 W112-25 652, 653 W112-26 666 W112-27 144 W112-28 144 W112-29 541 W112-30 541 W112-31 247 W112-32 648, 649 Lori Annie Dolqueist, Counsel

California Water Association

W113-1 54 W113-2 47

W113-3 486, 487 W113-4 486, 487 Dileep Srihari, VP and Senior Policy Counsel; Alexi Mado, VP State Gov. Affairs

The Computer Technology Industry Association

W114-1 144 W114-2 144 W114-3 221, 227 W114-4 221

W114-5 248, 249, 251

W114-6 247 W114-7 541 W114-8 551 W114-9 573, 574 W114-10 582 W114-11 604


W114-12 652, 657 W114-13 661 William Harris, CEO; John Weiner, Chief Science Officer; Alan Thiemann, counsel

Association of Test Publishers

W115-1 889 W115-2 795

W115-3 856 W115-4 889

W115-5 53 W115-6 529 W115-7 901 W115-8 109 W115-9 38 W115-10 48 W115-11 5 W115-12 16 W115-13 18 W115-14 123 W115-15 175 W115-16 196 W115-17 880 W115-18 227 W115-19 157 W115-20 229, 595 W115-21 229, 595 W115-22 874 W115-23 874, 878 W115-24 881 W115-25 874, 882 W115-26 159 W115-27 847, 874,

882 W115-28 847 W115-29 874 W115-30 266


Page 18 of 40


W115-31 267 W115-32 274 W115-33 292 W115-34 27 W115-35 745 W115-36 329 W115-37 758 W115-38 754 W115-39 712 W115-40 466 W115-41 786 W115-42 316 W115-43 783, 786 W115-44 737, 924 W115-45 369, 698 W115-46 407 W115-47 409, 411 W115-48 323 W115-49 323 W115-50 349 W115-51 434, 435 W115-52 376 W115-53 376 W115-54 529, 536 W115-55 534, 551 W115-56 551 W115-57 554 W115-58 862 W115-59 632 W115-60 670 W115-61 653 W115-62 653 W115-63 653 W115-64 648


W115-65 868 Jeremy Grant, Managing Director, Technology Business Strategy

The Better Identity Coalition

W116-1 703 W116-2 699

W116-3 713 W116-4 713

W116-5 432, 744 W116-6 432, 699 W116-7 743 W116-8 749 W116-9 749 W116-10 770 W116-11 770 W116-12 770 W116-13 770 W116-14 770 W116-15 466 W116-16 746 Frank Salinger, counsel; Toni Bellissino, Executive Director

Card Coalition W117-1 867 W117-2 907 W117-3 855 W117-4 144

W117-5 293 W117-6 466 W117-7 480 W117-8 450 W117-9 551 W117-10 585, 587 W117-11 582, 587,

588 W117-12 585, 588 W117-13 582, 587 W117-14 652, 653,

669 W117-15 653, 664


Page 19 of 40


W117-16 658 W117-17 653 W117-18 794 Peter Blenkinsop, Secretariat

international Pharmaceutical & Medical Device Privacy Consortium

W118-1 841 W118-2 153 W118-3 159

W118-4 144 W118-5 917 W118-6 412 W118-7 417 Mark Micali, VP Gov. Affairs

The Nonprofit Alliance

W119-1 841 W119-2 167

W119-3 183 W119-4 187, 188 W119-5 195 W119-6 186 W119-7 190 W119-8 551 W119-9 551 W119-10 604 W119-11 604 W119-12 608 Jim Halpert, Counsel

State Privacy & Security Coalition

W120-1 884

W120-2 884 W120-3 587, 590 W120-4 582, 590 W120-5 585, 590 W120-6 589, 590 W120-7 144 W120-8 144 W120-9 144 W120-10 814, 822 W120-11 249, 251


W120-12 833 W120-13 367, 569 W120-14 364 W120-15 417 W120-16 398, 563 W120-17 538 Pam Dixon, Executive Director

World Privacy Forum W121-1 205 W121-2 219

W121-3 364, 406 W121-4 364 W121-5 364 W121-6 417 W121-7 469 W121-8 469 W121-9 469, 477 W121-10 469, 477 W121-11 469 W121-12 469 W121-13 469 W121-14 469 W121-15 469, 471 W121-16 637 W121-17 714 W121-18 714 W121-19 714 W121-20 714 W121-21 740 W121-22 759 W121-23 759 Howard Fienberg, VP Adovacy; Stuart Pardau, counsel

The Insights Association

W122-1 841 W122-2 783

W122-3 256 W122-4 256 W122-5 339, 340,


Page 20 of 40


575 W122-6 582 W122-7 591 W122-8 377, 601 W122-9 118 Donald Sherrill, President

California Creditors Bar Association

W123-1 853 W123-2 841, 843

W123-3 427, 505, 506

W123-4 293 W123-5 119 W123-6 397 W123-7 867 W123-8 954 W123-9 922 W123-10 913 W123-11 905 W123-12 555 W123-13 88, 90,

100, 134, 144, 164, 170, 180, 186, 208, 224, 226, 241, 247, 253, 289, 290, 291, 294, 314, 336, 342, 344, 348, 357, 364, 367, 374, 384, 395, 403, 410,


423, 427, 441, 444, 445, 446, 448, 466, 480, 509, 512, 541, 551, 568, 574, 581, 585, 587, 588, 590, 601, 604, 617, 628, 652, 653, 657, 659, 661, 664, 668, 669, 676, 684, 698, 735, 736, 737, 738, 752, 754, 767, 778, 779, 784, 785, 794, 797, 820, 834, 867, 899

Kate Tummarello, Policy Director

Engine Advocacy W124-1 841 W124-2 841, 843

W124-3 517 W124-4 883 W124-5 134 W124-6 144 W124-7 246, 248,

249, 251


Page 21 of 40


W124-8 336 W124-9 385 W124-10 541 W124-11 582, 588 W124-12 648 W124-13 765, 767 Thomas Lee, Policy Lead; Kathleen Lu, Counsel

Mapbox W125-1 843 W125-2 144 W125-3 144

W125-4 336 W125-5 336 W125-6 345 W125-7 345 W125-8 329 W125-9 346 W125-10 339, 575 W125-11 339 W125-12 339 W125-13 47 W125-14 48 W125-15 532 W125-16 582, 587 Erin Guerrero, Executive Director

California Attractions and Parks Association

W126-1 841, 883 W126-2 128

W126-3 841, 883 W126-4 121, 135 W126-5 135 W126-6 134

W126-7 135 W126-8 343 W126-9 342 W126-10 342 W126-11 357 W126-12 465, 466


W126-13 466 W126-14 465, 466 W126-15 466 W126-16 384 W126-17 384 W126-18 579 W126-19 634 Philip Recht, Counsel

Mayer Brown LLP W127-1 169

W127-2 167, 168, 189

W127-3 190 W127-4 183 W127-5 181 W127-6 604 W127-7 652 W127-8 656 W127-9 656, 884 W127-10 840 Alan Titus Licensed California

cardroom W128-1 859

W128-2 127 W128-3 127 W128-4 127 W128-5 127 W128-6 155 W128-7 257 W128-8 273 W128-9 273 W128-10 273 Matt Akin; John Mangan; John Shirikian

Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies; American Council of

W129-1 868, 914 W129-2 290, 308 W129-3 841, 844,

883 W129-4 106


Page 22 of 40


Life Insurers W129-5 143, 144 W129-6 105, 206,

207, 208, 221

W129-7 268 W129-8 290 W129-9 293 W129-10 298 W129-11 303 W129-12 308 W129-13 316 W129-14 867, 980 W129-15 376 W129-16 407 W129-17 466, 480,

488 W129-18 505, 506,

510 W129-19 551 W129-20 653, 655,

674 John Jennings; Jason Berkowitz

Insured Retirement Institute

W130-1 105, 106, 143, 144, 206, 207, 208, 221, 268, 290, 293, 298, 303, 308, 316, 376, 407, 466, 480, 488, 505, 506, 510, 551, 653, 674,


841, 844, 867, 868, 883, 914, 980

W130-2 106 Joseph Garibyan Styskal, Wiese &

Melchione W131-1 905

W131-2 4 W131-3 23 W131-4 45, 48,

524 W131-5 954 W131-6 498 W131-7 667 Segment W132-1 134 W132-2 285 Colman D. McCarthy

Shook Hardy & Bacon W133-1 342

W133-2 579 W133-3 318 W133-4 635 W133-5 700 W133-6 341, 578 W133-7 582 W133-8 779, 793 W133-9 552 Michael C. Stinson; Brian K. Atchinson

Medical Professional Liability Association

W134-1 484 W134-2 895

Mark Webb Prop 23 Advisors W135-1 855 W135-2 40, 275 W135-3 526 W135-4 150, 269 Lance Noggle Credit Union National

Association W136-1 7

W136-2 7 W136-3 906


Page 23 of 40


W136-4 369, 370, 917

W136-5 144 W136-6 272 W136-7 349, 626 W136-8 376, 377 W136-9 385 W136-10 601 W136-11 866 W136-12 868 C. Tapscott Buchanan

Student Loan Servicing Alliance

W137-1 269

W137-2 6 W137-3 549 W137-4 698 W137-5 379 W137-6 653, 669,

682 W137-7 695 W137-8 746 Ryan Marlow Envoy Media Group W138-1 15 Joe Scalone W139-1 148 Lea Kissner W140-1 574 W140-2 336 W140-3 819 W140-4 131 W140-5 752 W140-6 648 W140-7 360 W140-8 279 W140-9 98, 101 Michael J. Hoisington

W141-1 868

W141-2 411


W141-3 418 W141-4 819, 833 W141-5 105 W141-6 928 W141-7 370 W141-8 855 W141-9 924 Anna Westfelt; Derek Schwede; Todd Smithline; et al.

Working group of in-house and law-firm attorneys organized by Smithline PC

W142-1 144 W142-2 526 W142-3 541

W142-4 516 W142-5 518 W142-6 585, 587 W142-7 369, 698,

779 W142-8 47 W142-9 120 Paul Jurcys; Markus Lampinen

Prifina W143-1 242 W143-2 449

W143-3 402 W143-4 383, 602 W143-5 839 W143-6 559 Victoria Sheckler International

AntiCounterfeiting Coalition; National Music Publishers Association; Recording Industry Association of America

W144-1 947 W144-2 947

Katherine Fisher Commercial Finance Coalition

W145-1 100 W145-2 103


Page 24 of 40


W145-3 144 W145-4 167, 170,

176 W145-5 264 W145-6 289, 307,

375 W145-7 349 W145-8 357 W145-9 404 W145-10 427, 504,

505 W145-11 466 W145-12 480 W145-13 495 W145-14 504, 505 W145-15 570 W145-16 585, 587,

588 W145-17 604 W145-18 626, 627 W145-19 739 W145-20 767 Pedro Gonzalez W146-1 965 Rachel Sanford Nemeth; Michael Petricone

Consumer Technology Association

W147-1 107, 153, 293

W147-2 144 W147-3 290

W147-4 99 W147-5 246, 248,

249, 833 W147-6 373, 376 W147-7 384 W147-8 508, 509,

513


W147-9 466 W147-10 541 W147-11 551 W147-12 585, 587 W147-13 614 W147-14 765 W147-15 797 W147-16 644 W147-17 653, 657,

664 Melanie K. Tiano; Gerard Keegan

CTIA W148-1 143, 144 W148-2 144

W148-3 224, 227 W148-4 246, 247,

248, 249, 251, 258

W148-5 294 W148-6 336 W148-7 349 W148-8 373, 376 W148-9 384 W148-10 423, 508,

509 W148-11 465, 466 W148-12 541 W148-13 526 W148-14 585 W148-15 604 W148-16 601 W148-17 565 W148-18 626, 630 W148-19 652, 653,

654, 657, 661, 664


Page 25 of 40


W148-20 772 W148-21 704 W148-22 767 W148-23 797 W148-24 797 W148-25 794 Else Feikje van der Berg

Datawallet Inc. W149-1 145 W149-2 31

W149-3 521 W149-4 574 W149-5 368 W149-6 21, 22,

146, 155 W149-7 43 PJ Hoffman Electronic

Transactions Association

W150-1 144 W150-2 222 W150-3 247, 251 W150-4 294 W150-5 336, 349 W150-6 373 W150-7 508, 509 W150-8 466 W150-9 504, 509 W150-10 531 W150-11 541 W150-12 604 W150-13 652, 653,

657 W150-14 772 Eric Goldman W151-1 92 W151-2 417 W151-3 413, 698,

760 W151-4 761


W151-5 766 W151-6 466 W151-7 465, 466 W151-8 480 W151-9 574, 587,

588 W151-10 653, 671 W151-11 688 W151-12 819, 820 W151-13 248 W151-14 855 W151-15 5 W151-16 13 Brian Tengel; Jason Engel

Experian W152-1 423, 427, 939

W152-2 604 W152-3 167, 168,

177, 178, 187, 188, 189, 196, 867

W152-4 403, 444 W152-5 89 W152-6 306 W152-7 652, 653 W152-8 896 W152-9 563 Michele Forer W153-1 973 Celine Guillou Hopkins & Carley W154-1 924 W154-2 330 W154-3 541 W154-4 52 W154-5 848 W154-6 106


Page 26 of 40


Robert Famigletti; Miriam Wugmeister

Global Privacy Alliance

W155-1 144 W155-2 329, 342

W155-3 357 W155-4 373, 376,

377, 601 W155-5 604 W155-6 617 W155-7 349 W155-8 465, 466 W155-9 493, 494 W155-10 587 W155-11 423, 508,

509 W155-12 526 W155-13 541 W155-14 551

W155-15 134 W155-16 153, 293,

294 W155-17 221, 224,

227 W155-18 248, 249,

251, 816 W155-19 652, 653,

657, 661, 664, 676, 679

W155-20 767 W155-21 794 W155-22 867 W155-23 901 Matthew Rudolph HERE Technologies W156-1 16, 349,

856


W156-2 541 W156-3 617 W156-4 587, 588 W156-5 601 W156-6 662, 667,

670 W156-7 74 W156-8 874 W156-9 609 W156-10 152 W156-11 930 W156-12 924 Kristian Stout; Alec Stapp

International Center for Law & Economics

W157-1 935, 940 W157-2 867

W157-3 15, 35, 689

W157-4 246, 248, 249, 833, 838

W157-5 3 W157-6 715 W157-7 856 W157-8 966 W157-9 566 W157-10 919 Joanne Cooper ID Exchange W158-1 201 W158-2 236 Jeffrey Lokey Infoblox W159-1 15 Scott Stewart Innovative Lending

Platform Association W160-1 109

W160-2 134 W160-3 109, 286 W160-4 306 W160-5 331, 430 W160-6 421


Page 27 of 40


W160-7 480 W160-8 500 W160-9 731 W160-10 42 W160-11 36 W160-12 499 W160-13 756 W160-14 384 Alex Propes; David Grimaldi; Michael Hahn

Interactive Advertising Bureau

W161-1 134 W161-2 144

W161-3 187, 188, 196

W161-4 186 W161-5 123 W161-6 246, 247,

248, 251 W161-7 336 W161-8 378 W161-9 384 W161-10 455 W161-11 465, 466 W161-12 484 W161-13 364 W161-14 439 W161-15 541 W161-16 550, 935 W161-17 545 W161-18 581, 585,

587, 588, 594

W161-19 604 W161-20 626 W161-21 639 W161-22 685, 694


Kevin McKinley Internet Association W162-1 883 W162-2 883 W162-3 581, 585,

938 W162-4 841 W162-5 106 W162-6 59 W162-7 685 W162-8 87 W162-9 91 W162-10 191 W162-11 144 W162-12 134 W162-13 166 W162-14 224, 225,

227 W162-15 243 W162-16 253 W162-17 247 W162-18 288 W162-19 290, 291,

309 W162-20 321, 652,

660 W162-21 293 W162-22 316 W162-23 336 W162-24 334 W162-25 357 W162-26 359 W162-27 376 W162-28 395, 444,

448 W162-29 441


Page 28 of 40


W162-30 404, 405 W162-31 410 W162-32 423 W162-33 508, 511 W162-34 436 W162-35 465, 466 W162-36 541 W162-37 551 W162-38 525 W162-39 526 W162-40 576 W162-41 581, 585,

587, 588 W162-42 596, 604,

605 W162-43 621 W162-44 626 W162-45 636 W162-46 652, 653,

654, 660, 667, 674

W162-47 684, 685 W162-48 747 W162-49 698, 779,

785 W162-50 788 W162-51 797, 798,

800, 801, 802, 807, 808

W162-52 823 W162-53 246, 248,

249, 251, 252


London Biggs; Rick Gardner

LexisNexis Risk Solutions

W163-1 617

Heather West Mozilla W164-1 68 W164-2 688 W164-3 716 W164-4 653, 658,

665 Arlen Valdivia; Melissa Patack

Motion Picture Association

W165-1 841 W165-2 541

W165-3 541 W165-4 144 W165-5 143 W165-6 144 W165-7 144 W165-8 134 W165-9 134 W165-10 134 W165-11 134 W165-12 227, 466,

585, 616 W165-13 227, 466,

585 W165-14 227, 466,

585 W165-15 230, 466,

640 W165-16 230, 466,

581 W165-17 465, 588,

616 W165-18 466, 616 W165-19 588, 616 W165-20 616 W165-21 587, 616


Page 29 of 40


W165-22 251 W165-23 247 W165-24 247 W165-25 249 Emily Emery; Brigitte Schmidt Gwyn

MPA - The Association of Magazine Media

W166-1 843 W166-2 588

W166-3 588 W166-4 588 W166-5 499 W166-6 824 W166-7 246, 248,

249 W166-8 98 W166-9 142 W166-10 160 W166-11 234 W166-12 663 W166-13 662 Mahlet Makonnen National Association

of Federally-Insured Credit Unions

W167-1 908 W167-2 908, 967 W167-3 49 W167-4 47 W167-5 905, 906 W167-6 269, 907 W167-7 269 W167-8 339, 575,

581 W167-9 909 W167-10 825 W167-11 868 Jodie Applewhite; Robert Pinnegar

National Apartment Association

W168-1 399 W168-2 400

W168-3 848, 849


W168-4 541 W168-5 652, 653,

675 W168-6 644 W168-7 484 W168-8 105 W168-9 788 Kaylee Cox Bankston; Doug Bibby

National Multifamily Housing Council

W169-1 697 W169-2 968

W169-3 47 W169-4 698, 723 W169-5 411, 422,

722 W169-6 399, 411 W169-7 399 W169-8 700 W169-9 700 W169-10 700 W169-11 698, 778,

779, 788 W169-12 789 W169-13 290, 292 W169-14 332 W169-15 339, 340 W169-16 384 W169-17 484 W169-18 688 W169-19 685 W169-20 685 Madeleine Bugel; Philip A. Squair

National Electrical Manufacturers Association

W170-1 463 W170-2 778, 779

W170-3 246, 247 W170-4 333, 576


Page 30 of 40


W170-5 924 Richard Shanahan; Toshiaki Tokunaga

Hitachi Group Companies

W171-1 969 W171-2 5

W171-3 85 W171-4 726 W171-5 727 W171-6 698, 717 W171-7 535 W171-8 6 W171-9 20 Daniel J. Mustico; Kris Kiser

Outdoor Power Equipment Institute

W172-1 910

Brent Smoyer Professional Background Screening Association

W173-1 890 W173-2 883 W173-3 66 W173-4 306 W173-5 585 W173-6 585, 588 W173-7 867 W173-8 868, 869 Jake Snow Access Humboldt;

ACLU of California; CALPIRG; Center for Digital Democracy; Common Sense Kids Action; Consumer Reports; Consumer Federation of America; Digital Privacy Alliance; Electronic Frontier Foundation; Media Alliance; Oakland Privacy; Privay Rights

W174-1 43 W174-2 24 W174-3 43 W174-4 43, 520 W174-5 31 W174-6 31 W174-7 58 W174-8 65, 68, 75 W174-9 65, 68, 75,

110 W174-10 110 W174-11 141 W174-12 141 W174-13 145


Clearinghouse W174-14 169 W174-15 171 W174-16 179 W174-17 259 W174-18 260, 270 W174-19 347 W174-20 347 W174-21 354 W174-22 362 W174-23 364 W174-24 408 W174-25 408 W174-26 408 W174-27 364 W174-28 364 W174-29 364 W174-30 428 W174-31 322 W174-32 364 W174-33 469 W174-34 469 W174-35 364 W174-36 364, 597 W174-37 527 W174-38 547 W174-39 548 W174-40 553 W174-41 557 W174-42 572 W174-43 580 W174-44 610 W174-45 610 W174-46 558, 622 W174-47 651


Page 31 of 40


W174-48 672 W174-49 688 W174-50 706 W174-51 706 W174-52 743 W174-53 748 W174-54 750 W174-55 771 W174-56 776 W174-57 776 W174-58 750 W174-59 796 W174-60 826 W174-61 827 W174-62 828 W174-63 831 W174-64 836 W174-65 829, 836 Carol Stiles W175-1 970 Scott Ferber; Susan Murdock

Association of Claims Professionals

W176-1 860 W176-2 861

W176-3 507 W176-4 522 W176-5 541 W176-6 551 W176-7 855, 860 W176-8 860 W176-9 855 Saul Bercovitch; Stanton Burke; et al.

California Lawyers Association Privacy Working Group

W177-1 100 W177-2 100

W177-3 100 W177-4 98, 100 W177-5 143, 144


W177-6 144 W177-7 136 W177-8 105 W177-9 220 W177-10 215 W177-11 336 W177-12 344, 345 W177-13 348 W177-14 357, 360 W177-15 437 W177-16 466 W177-17 480 W177-18 604 W177-19 643 W177-20 650 W177-21 768 W177-22 806 Kristina Donnelly; Chris Ungson

Public Advocates Office at the California Public Utilities Commission

W178-1 68 W178-2 244

W178-3 313 W178-4 917 W178-5 429 W178-6 472 W178-7 552 W178-8 489, 490 W178-9 86 W178-10 830 W178-11 122 W178-12 931 W178-13 917 John Kabateck Small Business Data

Privacy Coalition W179-1 883

W179-2 376 W179-3 246, 251 W179-4 197


Page 32 of 40


W179-5 584 W179-6 625 W179-7 35 W179-8 690 W179-9 104, 342 W179-10 653 W179-11 923 W179-12 873 W179-13 962 Alexander Berger; Erik Pritchard

Motorcycle Industry Council; Specialty Vehicle Institute of America; Recreational Off-Highway Vehicle Association

W180-1 910

Katie Townley; Marissa Levinson

QuinStreet, Inc. W181-1 183, 196 W181-2 581, 587

W181-3 604 W181-4 626 W181-5 653, 676 Shane Wiley Cuebiq W182-1 143 W182-2 158, 210 W182-3 210 W182-4 312 W182-5 317 W182-6 346, 356 W182-7 617 W182-8 718 W182-9 592 Chip Thresher Refinitiv W183-1 167, 189 W183-2 604 Christopher A. Mohr

Software and Information Industry

W184-1 529


Association W184-2 37 W184-3 167, 181 W184-4 66 W184-5 76 W184-6 420 W184-7 551 W184-8 581, 582,

585, 588 W184-9 604 W184-10 626 Brandon Dennison; Bill Cheney

SchoolsFirst Federal Credit Union

W185-1 4 W185-2 48

W185-3 917 W185-4 866 W185-5 975 Melissa MacGregor Securities Industry

and Financial Markets Association

W186-1 868 W186-2 976 W186-3 949 W186-4 325 W186-5 289, 290,

307, 308 W186-6 307, 308 W186-7 375 W186-8 621 W186-9 349 W186-10 473 W186-11 491 W186-12 411, 412 W186-13 850 W186-14 977 W186-15 5 W186-16 907 W186-17 893 W186-18 106


Page 33 of 40


W186-19 883 W186-20 106 W186-21 153 W186-22 293 W186-23 444 W186-24 155 W186-25 306 W186-26 403, 423 W186-27 493, 508,

509 W186-28 79 W186-29 247, 251 W186-30 321 W186-31 652, 653

669 W186-32 581, 587 W186-33 465 W186-34 118 W186-35 144 W186-36 542 W186-37 648 W186-38 685 W186-39 924 W186-40 924, 925 W186-41 794 W186-42 794 W186-43 794 Cynthia Pantazis Google W187-1 541 W187-2 587 W187-3 759, 767 W187-4 144 W187-5 231 W187-6 153 W187-7 293


W187-8 667, 674 W187-9 442 K Royal; Hilary Wandall

TrustArc W188-1 466 W188-2 68

W188-3 384 W188-4 371, 414,

901 W188-5 897 W188-6 551 W188-7 18 W188-8 98 W188-9 98 W188-10 98, 245 W188-11 98 Braden Carkhuff; Jacki Monson

Sutter Health W189-1 855 W189-2 140

W189-3 144, 147 W189-4 204, 227,

230 W189-5 287 W189-6 295, 300 W189-7 334, 335 W189-8 469, 493 W189-9 587, 588,

604 W189-10 634 W189-11 719 W189-12 33 Courtney Jensen TechNet W190-1 854, 867 W190-2 69 W190-3 59 W190-4 118 W190-5 143, 144 W190-6 189, 196


Page 34 of 40


W190-7 202 W190-8 203 W190-9 208 W190-10 221, 222 W190-11 222 W190-12 246, 247,

249 W190-13 246 W190-14 251 W190-15 251 W190-16 294 W190-17 261 W190-18 336 W190-19 344 W190-20 349 W190-21 357 W190-22 364, 373,

384, 767 W190-23 369, 417 W190-24 410 W190-25 420 W190-26 423 W190-27 465, 466 W190-28 444, 504,

505, 508 W190-29 531 W190-30 541 W190-31 541 W190-32 551 W190-33 582, 585,

587, 588, 594

W190-34 604 W190-35 59


W190-36 626 W190-37 652, 653,

657, 661, 664, 667, 668, 669

W190-38 867 W190-39 772 W190-40 767 W190-41 698, 778,

779, 780 W190-42 797 W190-43 800 W190-44 802, 807,

808 W190-45 794 W190-46 834 Mohamed Hafez W191-1 6 W191-2 892 W191-3 15 Kate Friedrich; Steve Rubley

Thomson Reuters W192-1 604 W192-2 465, 466 W192-3 900, 901

W192-4 178, 187 Pierre Valade Jumbo Privacy W193-1 792 W193-2 361 W193-3 361 W193-4 383 Derek Onysko W194-1 941, 979 W194-2 944 MFF W195-1 973 Anthony Stark ZoomInfo W196-1 172 W196-2 168 W196-3 648 W196-4 499, 502


Page 35 of 40


W196-5 466 W196-6 358 W196-7 319 W196-8 314, 316 W196-9 375 W196-10 493 W196-11 501 W196-12 98 W196-13 98 W196-14 98 W196-15 98 W196-16 413 W196-17 619 W196-18 551 Peter Leroe-Munoz Silicon Valley

Leadership Group W197-1 144

W197-2 226 W197-3 246, 248 W197-4 290, 291 W197-5 358 W197-6 384 W197-7 582, 588 W197-8 644, 664 W197-9 720 W197-10 246, 248 Joanna L. Storey Hinshaw &

Culbertson LLP W198-1 546

W198-2 538 W198-3 539 W198-4 30 W198-5 912 Scott Jordan W199-1 68 W199-2 64 W199-3 154 W199-4 97 W199-5 296


W199-6 297 W199-7 447 W199-8 541 Ryan Bittle W200-1 845 W200-2 721 W200-3 622 W200-4 361 W200-5 326 W200-6 790 Gregory Guarnay Delete All My Data

Foundation W201-1 978

Jordan Crenshaw, Tim Day, Harold Kim

Chamber Technology Engagement Center, US Chamber Institute for Legal Reform, US Chamber of Commerce

W202-1 868

W202-2 144, 147 W202-3 336 W202-4 349 W202-5 343, 344 W202-6 466 W202-7 585, 587,

588, 616 W202-8 604 W202-9 652, 653,

658, 669 W202-10 814 W202-11 246, 247 W202-12 797, 800 W202-13 924, 925 Sarah Thompson Siemly Global, LLC W203-1 372 W203-2 464 W203-3 8 W203-4 4 W203-5 26 W203-6 67


Page 36 of 40


W203-7 77 W203-8 401 W203-9 61 W203-10 387 W203-11 147 W203-12 122 W203-13 464 W203-14 464 W203-15 387 W203-16 387 W203-17 431, 924 W203-18 435 W203-19 492 W203-20 497 W203-21 551 W203-22 567 W203-23 612 W203-24 612 W203-25 612 W203-26 612 W203-27 612 W203-28 612 W203-29 633 W203-30 641 W203-31 641 W203-32 694 W203-33 741 W203-34 756 W203-35 768 W203-36 804 W203-37 804 W203-38 804 Lindsey Tonsager, Gina Vetere

Entertainment Software Association

W204-1 364 W204-2 900, 901


W204-3 541 W204-4 664, 665,

669, 670, 676

W204-5 143 W204-6 280 W204-7 47 W204-8 797, 799 W204-9 626 W204-10 465, 466 W204-11 604 Robert E. Rutkowski

W205-1 979

W205-2 572 W205-3 43 Alan L. Friel Baker Hostetler, LLP W206-1 870 W206-2 927 W206-3 698 W206-4 105 W206-5 105 W206-6 211 W206-7 105 W206-8 105 W206-9 342 W206-10 357 W206-11 336 W206-12 159 W206-13 16, 19 W206-14 541 W206-15 814 W206-16 814 W206-17 851 Dan Jaffe Association of

National Advertisers W207-1 841, 846

W207-2 246, 247,


Page 37 of 40


248, 813 W207-3 246, 247,

248, 813 W207-4 581, 585,

588 W207-5 604 John William Templeton

W208-1 974

Susan Earley W209-1 62 W209-2 94 W209-3 129 W209-4 139 W209-5 147 W209-6 163 W209-7 216 W209-8 305

PUBLIC HEARINGS- ORAL COMMENTS


SACRAMENTO- DECEMBER 2, 2019

Mark Vinella Travis Credit Union OSac1-1 917 Chris Rosa Nonprofit Alliance OSac2-1 841 Mike Belote Civil Justice

Association of California

OSac3-1 384 OSac3-2 465 OSac3-3 585 OSac3-4 541 OSac3-5 926 Brent Blackaby

OSac4-1 582, 698,

779, 917 Anthony Stark ZoomInfo OSac5-1 114 OSac5-2 168 OSac5-3 648 OSac5-4 358


OSac5-5 314, 316 OSac5-6 375 OSac5-7 497 OSac5-8 501 OSac5-9 98 OSac5-10 551 OSac5-11 551 Margaret Gladstein American Property

and Casualty Insurance Association

OSac6-1 866, 867 OSac6-2 458 OSac6-3 391 OSac6-4 153 OSac6-5 954 Maureen Mahoney Consumer Reports OSac7-1 43 OSac7-2 520 OSac7-3 43 OSac7-4 43 OSac7-5 24 OSac7-6 610 OSac7-7 520 Heather Smith 3fold

Communications; American Advertising Federation

OSac8-1 585 OSac8-2 585 OSac8-3 841

Jarelle Cook California Manufacturers and Technology Association

OSac9-1 82 OSac9-2 172 OSac9-3 841

Desiree Fosnaugh Merchants Bank of Commerce

OSac10-1 906 OSac10-2 917 OSac10-3 47 OSac10-4 483 June Coleman

OSac11-1 118

OSac11-2 118


Page 38 of 40


Jessica Tassin N/A OSac12-1 478

LOS ANGELES- DECEMBER 3, 2019

Marsha Mathias Kinecta Federal Credit Union

OLA1-1 855 OLA1-2 917 Crystal Haase USE Credit Union OLA2-1 756 OLA2-2 917 Nara Hartmann USE Credit Union OLA3-1 106, 906 OLA3-2 756 Stan Stahl Secure the Village OLA4-1 924 Sarah Thompson Siemly Global OLA5-1 8 OLA5-2 4 OLA5-3 924 OLA5-4 387 OLA5-5 492 OLA5-6 497 OLA5-7 464 OLA5-8 756 Jessica Gross

OLA6-1 44

OLA6-2 48 OLA6-3 21 Justine Phillips Sheppard Mullin OLA7-1 924 OLA7-2 48 OLA7-3 872 David Greeley Greeley Thompson

LLP OLA8-1 264

OLA8-2 541 Joseph Garibyan Styskal Wiese &

Melchione OLA9-1 4

OLA9-2 906 Mary-Lou Heighes Compliance Plus

Inc OLA10-1 955

OLA10-2 906 OLA10-3 907 OLA10-4 35 OLA10-5 381 Peter Watson US Storage Centers OLA11-1 15 OLA11-2 15


OLA11-3 80 OLA11-4 342 Tanya Forsheit News Media

Alliance OLA12-1 153

OLA12-2 221 OLA12-3 466 OLA12-4 585 OLA12-5 541 Jeff Dennis Newmeyer Dillion OLA13-1 98 OLA13-2 327 OLA13-3 373 OLA13-4 601 OLA13-5 921 Leigh McMillan Whitepages OLA14-1 106 OLA14-2 787 Scott McElroy Paylidify OLA15-1 723, 724 OLA15-2 116 OLA15-3 600 Roman Hossain Review Squash OLA16-1 15 OLA16-2 931 OLA16-3 931 Dave Grimaldi Interactive

Advertising Bureau OLA19-1 21, 541

OLA19-2 585 Bo Kim Perkins Coie/

California Chamber of Commerce

OLA20-1 585 OLA20-2 106 OLA20-3 601 OLA20-4 248, 251 OLA20-5 466 Philip Recht Mayer Brown OLA21-1 167, 168,

181, 189, 190, 652, 656

OLA21-2 604 OLA21-3 652, 653 Ross Cohen BeenVerified OLA22-1 174


Page 39 of 40


OLA22-2 190 Jason Matthes Spokeo/ People

Search Services Coalition

OLA23-1 190 OLA23-2 106 OLA23-3 652 David Levine/ Kevin Walsh

SPARK Institute OLA24-1 873, 917 OLA24-2 55

OLA24-3 125 OLA24-4 57 OLA24-5 124 OLA24-6 123 OLA24-7 875 Field Garthwaite IRIS.TV OLA26-1 832 Unidentified Speaker Founder of small

startup OLA27-1 973

OLA27-2 973 Maxine Henry Cyvient OLA28-1 373 OLA28-2 924

SAN FRANCISCO - DECEMBER 4. 2019

Curt Augustine Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers

OSF1-1 39 OSF1-2 562 OSF1-3 50 OSF1-4 117 OSF1-5 143, 417 John William Templeton

National Black Business Month

OSF2-1 974

Joanne Cooper ID Exchange OSF3-1 236 OSF3-2 236 OSF3-3 236 Joanna Storey Hinshaw &

Culbertson OSF4-1 541

OSF4-2 538, 912 OSF4-3 912 Dan Jaffe Association of

National Advertisers

OSF5-1 246, 247, 248, 813, 846

OSF5-2 585, 588


OSF5-3 604 Todd Smithline Smithline P.C. OSF6-1 541 Alan Titus Robb & Ross/ Small

Family Owned Business

OSF7-1 859

Max Kornblith Radvocate OSF8-1 44 OSF8-2 559 OSF8-3 44 OSF8-4 235 OSF8-5 235 OSF8-6 559 Hayley Tsukayama Electronic Frontier

Foundation OSF9-1 43

OSF9-2 557 OSF9-3 31 OSF9-4 408 OSF9-5 826 OSF9-6 169, 171 OSF9-7 527 Edward Hu TrustArc OSF10-1 68 Rick Arney Californians for

Consumer Privacy OSF11-1 136

OSF11-2 556 OSF11-3 572 OSF11-4 602 OSF11-5 420 OSF11-6 528 Jason Mertz-Prickett Upward Credit

Union OSF12-1 866, 868

OSF12-2 917 OSF12-3 906 Kathleen Lu Mapbox OSF13-1 336 OSF13-2 329, 336,

345 Emily Borowski San Francisco Fire

Credit Union OSF14-1 866, 868

OSF14-2 917 OSF14-3 906


Page 40 of 40


OSF14-4 867 Wayne Sisk Celigo OSF15-1 234 OSF15-2 25, 33 OSF15-3 33 OSF15-4 33 OSF15-5 878 Emily Fisher Public Advocates

Office in the California Public Utilities Commission

OSF16-1 830

Henry Lau Privolta OSF17-1 559 OSF17-2 969 Clifford Waldeck Consulting

Company OSF18-1 931

Pierluigi Oliverio

OSF20-1 982 OSF20-2 982 OSF20-3

Barbara Lawler Looker OSF21-1 52 OSF21-2 106 OSF21-3 328 OSF21-4 946 OSF21-5 852, 924 OSF21-6 787, 793 OSF21-7 247, 678 Emily Emory Association of

Magazine Media (MPA)

OSF22-1 588 OSF22-2 499 OSF22-3 246 OSF22-4 98 OSF22-5 118 OSF22-6 234 OSF22-7 663 Ashkan Soltani

OSF23-1 574

OSF23-2 574


OSF23-3 839

FRESNO- DECEMBER 5, 2019

Rita Carpenter Educational Employees Credit Union

OFres1-1 866 OFres1-2 917 OFres1-3 906 Jessica Lee Loeb & Loeb OFres2-1 868 OFres2-2 106 OFres2-3 246, 247 OFres2-4 617 OFres2-5 574 Bryan Harley Commuity Media

Access Collective OFres3-1 559

OFres3-2 902 OFres3-3 826

Documents

FSOR APPENDIX B: LIST OF COMMENTERS FROM 45 DAY PERIOD · Jennifer Post Inergraph PP&M Deutschland GmbH W21-1 9 W21-2 5 W21-3 7 Emily Borowski ... Arocles Aguilar; Helen Mickiewicz;