Upload
twobirds-flying-publications
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/9/2019 Gen Stan McChrystal - Fair and Balanced
1/2
BLD MLWF Jliiefqnwy 7? Cufe 7;>;
Jl{ywodmq, Zn` [n`in agn Qtlgowaz)B`yofd [ug`ojnqolf, 7;>;& N`` wodmqz wezewrea&
Def Zqnf IjJmwyzqn` nfa qme Wl``ofd
Zqlfe Bonzjl&
Gy3 Zn` [n`in -Bl``lt ie lf Qtoqqew&jliQtlgowazb`yofd/
O alfq bee` qmnq aebefaofd Zqnf IjJmwyzqn` oz of iy
clg aezjwo{qolf flw al O jlfalfe Def IjJmwyzqn`z
`njh lb cuadiefq& Defewn` IjJmwyzqn` zewrez nq qme
Jliinfaewof)Jmoebz {`enzuwe nfa inhofd
aewldnqlwy weinwhz ql qme {wezz zmltz rewy {llw
cuadiefq ) {nwqoju`nw`y nq IjJmwyzqn`z {ny)dwnae&
Mlterew, mnrofd zewrea of glqm qme Nwiy nfa Fnry,
O ufaewzqnfa qme jmnof lb jliinfa rewy j`enw`y nfa
O ufaewzqnfa qme io`oqnwy iofazeq& Jnfaoa`y, O qmofh
qmnq iujm lb tmnq IjJmwyzqn` znoa ql Wl``ofd Zqlfe
tnz n web`ejqolf lb bwuzqwnqolf wnqmew qmnf njqun`
zefqoiefq&
O iy >7 yenwz lb zewroje, Ore ferew ieq nf lbbojew lw
ef`ozqea inf tml nq zlie {lofq of qoie aoa flq webew
ql n {l`oqojn` boduwe nz n alujme gnd lw lqmew jl`lwbu`
e}{`eqore& Of rowqun``y n`` jnzez, qmoz oz lwn` b`nqu`efje
nfa flqmofd ilwe&
Qmewe nwe qtl qy{ez lb `enaewz of qme io`oqnwy8 lfe
zeez qmofdz of g`njh nfa tmoqe& Qme lqmew qnhez n
ml`ozqoj n{{wlnjm&
Toqmluq hfltofd Zqnf IjJmwyzqn`, O jnf qe`` ylu
qmnq me mnz geef mnwzmew lf moize`b qmnf nfy {ufaoq
lw {l`oqojn` boduwe mnz lw jlu`a erew ge& O jnf
jnqedlwojn``y zny ql ylu qmnq me jnwez ngluq erewy
ieigew lb moz jliinfa, nfa gnzea lf tmnq O mnre
wena ngluq moz {wlzejuqolf lb qme tnw of Nbdmnfozqnf
me tnz e}ejuqofd ql {`nf&
Ob iy nzzui{qolf oz jlwwejq, qmef tmnq te mnre oz n
jnweew lbbojew tml zmlq moz iluqm lbb ql n
{ug`ojnqolf qmnq tnz n iuzq wena blw bl`hz tml z{efq
ilzq lb qmeow nau`q `orez {u``ofd n qwnof of qme Meodmq)
Nzmguwy aozqwojq tmo`e ozqefofd ql Wnro Zmnfhnw ql
dwnz{ qme ienfofd lb `obe&
Qmewe oz n`zl rewy dlla jmnfje qmnq qmewe oz zlielfe
of qme Wl``ofd Zqlfez we{lwqew defe {ll` toqm qmnq
e}njq obe e}{ewoefje& O al flq bnu`q moi& Mlterew, O
mnre aee{efofd jlfjewfz ngluq qme we`ernfje lb
cluwfn`ozi of 7;>;&
Tnz Wl``ofd Zqlfe qmewe ql jn{quwe we`ernfq ozzuez
nfa jliiefqz lw tnz qmeow iozzolf zoi{`y ql
jn{quwe {n{nwnsso zefznqolfn`ozi& Wl``ofd Zqlfe
feeaz ql nfztew qmnq ~uezqolf flq cuzq ofqewfn``y
guq ql qme tlw`a&
Lqmew ieaon luq`eqz zeei ql ge `ere`ofd ufaew qme
qng`e nzznu`qz lf Def IjJmwyzqwn`, znyofd qmnq
zl`aoewz nwe jli{`nofofd ngluq mnrofd qmeow mnfaz
qoea ufaew IjJmwyzqn`z jliinfa, qmeow mnfaz nwe
qoea nfa jlu`a flq bodmq&
Infy lb qmlze jliiefqz nwe nqqei{qz nq
zefznqolfn`osofd qme erefq blw n zoi{`e wnqofd nfa
`njh nfy zeig`nfje lb ufaewzqnfaofd&
Ql dore qmeze luq`eqz zlie {ewz{ejqore O ni dlofd ql
zmnwe n {ewzlfn` zqlwy tmo`e zewrofd nz nf >>G lf n
qwnofofd iozzolf of qme @lz [nawez Mo``z lb Jn`oblwfon&
Iy z~una tnz lwaewea ql infeurew ofql {lzoqolf ql
efdnde nf l{{lzofd blwje qmnq tnz zu{ewolw of
fuigewz& Qme nwen lb l{ewnqolf mna qmwee
n{{wlnjmez, guq lf`y qtl {wlroaea nfy jlrew& O
ilrea iy qeni uzofd n zin`` awoea worewgea qmnq
{wlroaea fenw {ewbejq jlfjen`iefq& Te wenjmea qme
NL geblwe qme l{{lzofd blwje zl O zequ{ iy I2;
b`nfhea gy n wob`einf ql jlrew moz e}{lzea ebq b`nfh&
Qme wezq lb qme qeni qllh n {lzoqolf lf`ofe& Qtefqy)
bore ieqewz of bwlfq lb uz tnz n zin`` zqwujquwe nfa
ngluq bobqy ieqewz of bwlfq lb uz qmewe tnz n `lfd nfa
fnwwlt gnwf& Qme zqwujquwe nq qtefqy)bore ieqewz
ljj`uaea n {lwqolf lb qme gnwf nfa {wlroaea jlrewqmnq jlu`a ge uzea gy qme l{{lzofd blwje ql
infeurew ndnofzq iy qeni& Tmo`e te tewe zeqqofd
u{, O menwa qme l{{lzofd blwje ilrofd qmwludm n
du``y qmnq wnf gemofa qme `lfd gnwf& O qmef wnf ngluq
45 ieqewz altfmo`` uzofd luw lwodofn` `nfe lb
n{{wlnjm& Oq tnz n modmew rnfqnde {lofq, zl toqm iy
IO@EZ e~uo{{ea I>2 O efdnde qme l{{lzofd blwje&
@ujho`y, blw ie, qmey aoa flq wejldfose qmnq oq tnz n
8/9/2019 Gen Stan McChrystal - Fair and Balanced
2/2
BLD MLWF Jliiefqnwy 7? Cufe 7;>;
Jl{ywodmq, Zn` [n`in agn Qtlgowaz)B`yofd [ug`ojnqolf, 7;>;& N`` wodmqz wezewrea&
zmlwq niguzm zl wnqmew qmnf ilrofd ndnofzq iy
{lzoqolf, qmey aejoaea ql aod of& Qmnq wnfd qme bwee
gubbeq ge`` of iy mena nfa O zqnwqea qnhofd luq
nfylfe O jlu`a awnt n gena lf& O qmef menw qme @Q
`enaofd qme l{{lzofd blwje zmluq Ilqmew Bujhew
guq ofzqena lb qwyofd ql b`nfh iy {lzoqolf, qme `oqq`e
iozjwenfq ql`a moz {el{`e, tml tewe flt gee{ofd,
ql qnhe luq qme gnqqewoez lf qme IO@EZ denw zl qmnq
qme gee{ofd tlu`a zql{& Te`` qmoz wen``y {ozzea ie
lbb zl O wnf gnjh ql iy z~una nfa ql`a iy qeni ql
l{ef bowe& Iy I2; duffew zqnwqz u{ O nzhea moi ql
u{ moz jnaefje n goq zl O jlu`a infeurew ql zeq u{ n
{lzoqolf of qme zin`` zqwujquwe ql jnqjm qme l{{lzofdblwje geblwe qmey jlu`a zequ{ of qme gnwf& Te``, of
qme menq lb qme iliefq, O b`nfhea `ebq tmef O zmlu`a
mnre b`nfhea wodmq nfa wnf njwlzz qme I2;z `ofe lb
bowe& Bowzq bwoefa`y jnzun`qy lb qme any guiiew.
Qmnq any, O enwfea qtl rn`ung`e ezzlfz8 bowzq n`tnyz
ge jldfosnfq lb tmnq ylu aoa toqm yluw I2;8 zejlfa,
nf ofbnfqwyinfz oaen lb n bnow bodmq oz ql wnaol of n
G57 blw n jnw{eq)gligofd wuf& Qmeweblwe, tmef n
zl`aoew znyz luw mnfaz nwe qoea oq wen``y ienfz te
jnfq jn`` of qmnq gligofd wuf&
N`` lb qmoz oz ql awore mlie qme {lofq qmnq, nzjlfzuiewz, te feea ql n{{wlnjm fetz toqm n ere`
lb men`qmy zhe{qojozi ufqo` oqz ~un`oqy jnf ge
rn`oanqea& Wedweqbu``y, of qlanyz efrowlfiefq yluwe
qme lfe qmnq feeaz ql al qmnq gejnuze infy lb qmlze
efqwuzqea ql al oq blw ylu mnre `oqq`e lw fl j`ue lb
tmnq oz dlofd lf&
Wenaewz, Def IjJmwyzqn`, aebejnqez z{ejoiefz lb
modmew ofqe``ejq qmnf ilzq lb qme `nqe fodmq qn`h zmlt
mlzqz, zl qnhe tmnq qmey zny nz flqmofd ilwe qmnf
{lzquwofd gy ofaoroaun`z qmnq njh n ilaojui lb
qn`efq8 deqqofd nudmz nq qme e}{efze lb nf ofaoroaun`
qmnq alez flq aezewre qmnq qwenqiefq&
Of [wezoaefq Lgninz {lzoqolf O alfq qmofh, doref
tmnq O hflt ngluq qme erefq, qmnq O tlu`a mnre
we`oerea IjJmwyzqn` lb moz jliinfa& Wnqmew, nz
[wezoaefq lb qme Ufoqea Zqnqez nfa JOJ, iy
jlfrewznqolf toqm Zqnf IjJmwyzqn` tlu`a mnre geef
nz bl``ltz3
[3Zqnf, ilzq ief ienzuwe qmeow infmlla of qewizlb 2 ofjmez qmnq aebofez iy dowqm& Nq qme iliefq,
qmewe oz 2 beeq lb iy infmlla e}njq`y lfe WJM bwli
qnhofd u{ wezoaefje of yluw nzz& Ob qmoz mn{{efz ndnof,
ylu to`` ferew aebejnqe jlwwejq`y ndnof&
Wezq nzzuwea qmnq Zqnf IjJmwyzqn` tlu`a mnre
ufaewzqlla tmnq tnz mn{{efofd, nfa of qme ofqewezq
lb hee{ofd moz glte` ilreiefqz toqmof Io`)Z{ej, me
tlu`a mnre jli{`oea& Mlterew, ilwe oi{lwqnfq`y me
tlu`a mnre glfaea ilwe j`lze`y toqm qme JOJ&
Delwde Z& [nqqlf tnz flqlwoluz blw moz ofaozjweqolfzguq me aoa nf ofjweaog`e clg of Euwl{e&
Qmnq efaz qmoz zqlwy.
)Z[