8/10/2019 GeoNetwork and ESRI GIS Portal Toolkit
Comparison-GDNBI3027
1/7
Information included in this document may not be disclosed to
third parties unless with explicit written approval from ESRI
Inc.
GeoNetwork and ESRI GIS Portal Tool kit Comparison
The following software are being evaluated for the GeoSUR
project for the implementation of GIS portal application for the
South American region. The information collected for eachsoftware
will be provided to the GeoSUR advisory board to be used for
evaluation and selection of the portal software.
General Requirements
ESRI GIS Portal Toolkit GeoNetwork OpenSourceRecent Version 9.3
2.20
Type Commercial. Current version of GIS Portal Toolkit is free
aslong as the ESRI training class is taken and the
otherprerequisite software is already purchased.
Final licensing for GPT 9.3 is under discussion. GPT 9.3
willrequire ArcGIS Server 9.3 Standard Enterprise.
Free and Open Source
Operating System Red Hat Enterprise Linux AS/ES 4.0 Update 2SUSE
Linux Enterprise Server 10Sun Solaris 9, 10 (SPARC)Windows 2000 SP4
ServerWindows 2003 SP2 ServerWindows Vista SP1 Ultimate,
Enterprise, BusinessWindows XP SP2 Professional Edition
MS WindowsLinuxMac OS XPotentially any Java Servlet
environment
Hardware Requirements See recommended hardware requirements
onhttp://support.esri.com
1 GHz or higher
Memory Requirement See recommended hardware requirements
onhttp://support.esri.com . Note that this depends on
deploymentmodels and expected use.
512 MB memory or higher
Disk Requirement See minimum disk space requirements
onhttp://support.esri.com . Note this will depend on type of
DBMS,size of the catalog and size of the data used in the map
service,gazetteer and optional data extraction service.
30 MB minimum / 250 suggested
Java Requirement Java 1.5 SDK is required. Either version
1.5.0_06 or 1.5.0_14may be used Java Runtime Environment (JRE
1.5.0)
Web Server IIS5, IIS6 or Apache 2.0.48 NA, Apache or IIS can be
configured to redirect traffic to the servletengine
Servlet Engine Apache Tomcat 5.5.17 or 5.5.26. Note: other
Servlet engines(IBM WebSphere, Oracle Application Server, Sun
GlassFish,ServletExec, ) may be supported on a case-by-case basis
perproject requirements.
Apache Tomcat or Jetty
Database Oracle 9i 9.2.0.7Oracle 10g 10.2.0.2Microsoft SQL
Server 2000 SP4
JDBC Compliant DBMS such asMySQLPostgreSQL
http://support.esri.com/http://support.esri.com/http://support.esri.com/http://support.esri.com/http://support.esri.com/http://support.esri.com/
8/10/2019 GeoNetwork and ESRI GIS Portal Toolkit
Comparison-GDNBI3027
2/7
Information included in this document may not be disclosed to
third parties unless with explicit written approval from ESRI
Inc.
Microsoft SQL Server 2005 SP2PostgreSQL 8.3
OracleMS SQL Server
Other Required Software ArcGIS Server 9.3 Standard Enterprise
(includes ArcSDE), ArcGIS Desktop is advised to author/manage oher
servicesused in GPT and manage metadata,
GPT 9.3 works with an LDAP user store and authenticationservice.
Verified to work are:
Apache Directory ServerSun OpenDSMicrosoft ActiveDirectory
Other LDAP servers may be supported on a case-by-case basisper
project requirements.
NA
Java applications
included:LuceneJeevesMcKoiJettyGeoServerSchematronInterMap
Required Apache SoftwareFoundation Packages
Sun JSF FrameworkSun Java MailSun JavaBeans Activation
Framework
Apache Commons Struts TilesJSP Standard Tag Library
Apache Commons File Upload Apache Commons IOJUnitZ39.50
Toolkit
NA
Supported Browsers GPT 9.3 supports IE 6+, FireFox, and Safari.
Firefox 1.5+, Internet Explorer Win v6+, Safari 3+ (Mac OS X
Leopard)
Notes Common practice is to install Catalog Services and
MetadataViewer on dedicated server with Catalog Services
databaseinstalled on separate dedicated server, however, everything
canrun on one machine. Alternatively, various
services(basemap/searchmap/placefinder) may be used from
ArcGISOnline and would thus not be hosted on the server,
thusreducing the load on the server. These services are free
ofcharge.
Common practice is to install all GeoNetwork components on a
singlemachine. Could be distributed.
Can interact with other GeoNetwork instances in a federated
catalgoueenvironment
Standards Implementation
ESRI GIS Portal Toolkit GeoNetwork OpenSourceMain Components
Portal Module, Map Viewer, Administrator Module, Publisher
Module, CSW Client for ArcMap and ArcGIS Explorer,Harvesting
Module
Metadata editor, metadata template system, user & group
management,harvesting management, backup management, map viewer,
pdf mapprinting, sending WMC & map preview by email, map server
(GeoServer)
Metadata Standards FGDC, ISO 19115, ISO 19139, Dublin Core.
Note: GPT 9.3 allows additional metadata profiles to be
configured by the implementor of GPT without compiling.
ISO19139 (19115 & 19119), FGDC, Dublin Core
![Integración del gestor de metadatos Geonetwork en el ... · hemos resuelto con la integración de Geonetwork y Geospatial Portal [4] logrando que la metainformación se visualice](https://img.pdfslide.net/doc/110x75/5e96ca2ab4d23c39de7de1cb/integracin-del-gestor-de-metadatos-geonetwork-en-el-hemos-resuelto-con-la.jpg)
