30
<#> © 2011 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013 Ben Granjé Sales Director Morningstar Benelux Request the full report via [email protected]

Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

<#>

© 2011 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Global Fund Investor Experience 2013

@ Trends Finance Day 2013

Ben Granjé

Sales Director

Morningstar Benelux

Request the full report via [email protected]

Page 2: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

2

Who We Are

Chicago

Toronto

Amsterdam

Copenhagen

Frankfurt

London

Luxembourg

Madrid

Milan

Munich

Oslo

Paris

Stockholm

Zurich

Bangkok

Hong Kong

Seoul

Shenzhen

Singapore

Taipei

Tokyo

Auckland

Sydney

Cape Town

Dubai

Mumbai

Morningstar

Global Operations

Mexico City

Santiago

Sao Paulo

Page 3: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

3

Who We Serve Worldwide

AdvisorsIndividualsInstitutions

Page 4: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

4

How we serve all aspects of the industry

Morningstar:

× Collect and validate Investment data

× Categorise securities within peer groups

× Distribute information and analysis

× Educate investors

Page 5: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

5

How We Serve Our Clients

Morningstar

strengths form the

foundation…

…for innovative

products and

services…

…that help clients

meet their business

challenges.

Page 6: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

6

Accurate, Timely, Complete Data

416,000investments

Page 7: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

7

Independent Research

Page 8: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

8

Morningstar Analyst Rating™ for Funds

Credit Ratings

Morningstar Analyst RatingTM for Funds

Page 9: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

9

Trusted Brand

Brand awareness and attribute information from 2010 Morningstar U.S. brand study. A third-party research firm conducted more than 1,300

telephone interviews with Morningstar clients and non-clients across all core audiences.

Page 10: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

10

× Evaluates the experiences of mutual fund investors across 24 countries in four categories:

� Regulation and Taxation (25% of overall grade)

� Information Disclosure (30% of overall grade)

� Fees and Expenses (30% of overall grade)

� Sales and Media (15% of overall grade)

× Goal is to encourage a dialogue about global best practices for funds from the perspective of fund investors.

× Information gathered from available public data and from Morningstar analysts.

× Higher weighting given to questions with empirical data answers.

Global Fund Investor Experience Report

Page 11: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

11

× Regulation & Taxation

× More regulations (that benefit the investor).

× Lower taxes are better with no taxes being ideal.

× Disclosure

× Regular, comprehensive disclosure.

× Standardized format for fee disclosure.

× Point-of-sale fund documents that are concise and specific to one fund at a time.

× Fees & Expenses

× Lower annual net expense ratios.

× Transparency and choice.

× Sales & Media

× Variety of sales channels with open architecture.

× Media that emphasizes long-term investing and calls out high fees.

Guiding Principles

Page 12: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

12

Overall Country Scores

Page 13: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

13

Regulation & Taxation Scores

Page 14: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

14

× Single, independent regulator with adequate staffing and prompt regulatory updates are ideal.

× Regulation or prohibition of soft-dollar commissions are also ideal.

× If fund companies do partake in soft-dollar arrangements, they should be disclosed.

× Low or no taxes is best.

× If there are taxes it is better to exempt fund shareholders until the fund is sold.

Regulation & Taxation

Page 15: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

15

× Created a hypothetical tax scenario that looked at all available tax credits and assumed that investors took action for maximum tax avoidance.

Regulation & Taxation

Page 16: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

16

Disclosure Scores

Page 17: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

17

Disclosure

× Regular portfolio holdings disclosure is key for investors to understand sources of risk and return. Quarterly or monthly disclosure is ideal; global standard is semi-annual.

× Portfolio managers names should be disclosed with start dates and compensation, just like public companies in other industries.

× Expense disclosure should be standardized, with breakdowns for:

× Management costs.

× Other operating charges – custody, accounting, etc.

× Distribution / payments to advisors.

× Belgium is in line with global averages, but investors would benefit from more frequent & complete disclosure of

× Portfolio’s to enable evaluation of manager decisions.

× Manager name’s and tenure

× Cost - breakdown

Page 18: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

18

Disclosure

× Point-of-sale disclosure is particularly important as it introduces investors to funds.

× South Africa and Hong Kong don’t have effective mandatory Simplified Prospectuses.

× KIIDs are mostly good and short, but are missing a few key features.

× Comprehensive disclosure is ideal

× Fewer than five pages – delivered for a single investment only.

× Includes TER and Illustration of Fees.

× Strategy is clear enough for experienced investor to categorize a fund.

× Risks only apply to the investment strategy at hand.

× Belgium : Belgian addendum for distributors is a good step.Improvement: a monetary illustration of fund costs that would convert ratio’s into monetary terms so novice investors may comprehend how much they are paying for services.

BG1

Page 19: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

Slide 18

BG1 key features on KIID missing: what are they?BEN GRANJÉ; 23/05/2013

Page 20: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

19

Fees & Expenses Scores

Page 21: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

20

Fees & Expenses

× Low costs result in better investor outcomes.

× Investors should have transparency and choice around advisor compensation.

× Commission bans have the potential to remove biased advice, but transparency on its own may suffice.

× Investors who do not receive advice should have the choice to avoid paying for it. The worst practices are full retrocessions paid for funds purchased through internet platforms without advice.

× Advisors adhering to a Fiduciary standard is a best practice. Most countries have a practice closer to a suitability standard.

× Commission bans will aid in transparency for investors, but may not result in lower overall cost of ownership. We measure TER not the cost of ownership.

Page 22: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

21

Fees & Expenses

× Most markets compensate advisors through front loads and retrocessions.

× The United States, UK, the Netherlands and soon Australia are the main exceptions.

× The United States has the lowest fees, and fees that decline as fund assets grow.

× Fees declining as assets grow is a best practice not found anywhere else in the world.

× Belgium receives a C due to the average-to-low cost of locally domiciled fixed-income and allocation funds.

× Pan-European products tend to be more costly than local funds.

× it is important investors have a choice in how they compensate advisors, and can avoid embedded fees.

Page 23: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

22

Page 24: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

23

Page 25: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

24

Page 26: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

25

Page 27: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

26

Sales & Media Scores

Page 28: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

27

Sales & Media

× A variety of sales channels is better for investors.

× Sales channels with open (or guided) architecture is better for investors.

× Sales channels that are technically open, but still promote related party products are not as good for investors as when advisors are not tied to fund sponsors.

× Sales contests should not be structured to generate biased advice or fund churn.

× Advisors should put the interests of investors first. Fiduciary standards are strongest, but other protections can be effective.

× The media should help investors see through fund marketing.

× Focusing on long-term performance is one measure.

× Highlighting high relative costs is another measure of media effectiveness.

× Belgium receives a D+, largely due to the closed architecture for retail audience. Bank & Insurance groups dominate fund sales, with a tendency to sell proprietary funds. In addition, the regulatory monitoring of Media communication is not conducive to better understanding.

BG2

Page 29: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

Slide 27

BG2 here was a comment about Belgium only having 2 of 5 sales channels available, which was heavily penalised. But what are the 5 channels, and how do we judge them to be unavailable in Belgium?

BEN GRANJÉ; 23/05/2013

Page 30: Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends Finance Day 2013actions.trends.levif.be/actions/trends/financeday/files/Ben_Granje.pdf · Global Fund Investor Experience 2013 @ Trends

28