e;eAIJIJ?1 leo t0A$t|nfl0il bddo rssN 0859-0036

frr or e.r Hfi s?R'r?'t ua yfl atn rf eygrf,ofi 6.r9

(Good Governance)

d:c$rd'{Frrr

(Civilsociety)

n'rnTg

(Public Sector)

dd n4J'lflJ'lUnOtA'lJ LA

rssN 0859-0036

a q - A^illjljll 20 rT0.l d.:fl N tdn Ulfl 'lv{ ttayn a Lnlr ytt5q140t (Cood Governance)d

IOU 0:1"1U11 ffY'l tt'O?i'U

^ t ?,) a?,uJ1',loT.3vl 1 toau8tnflnil 2541

druru zoo reia.i

€

(d.:?unfldra)

^ ^ Aa, A - , vAqdylfi t111110.:dn1L%Xq U Ll l Anl:1"lEIUlll:U tl1€1 111 U

rarfi 565 {orj:r}.rrirrry.r 39 (rilr\fiar 1) trelljr{nuil nt.:r11r\'1 10310

fodL11r€{1,\yl (02) 718-5460, 718-5675-89

f1ll:drr (02) 7 18-5461.-2

E-mail: publications @leelal.tdri.or.th

frr or a.r mfi s?n1?\ $a sn atn :Jrvrrigfi 6(Good Governance)

RSJUA{I

A urircfrriruert rilir Good Governance fint:neirrfrlv ,^

l,i"r,d,rfi.,l,..rnrsietr115;gordturotu TottautyffiaI

lUO!hrt\6hJ\lrrJd!l

blrr,, ot, uId'6'o fi ulqr ofi riuunvnnno5L,1.u'lor',nn ro

4unr:tiu:vu'ittl:vuvef (lnternational Monetary Fund,

ilr4r') :Jq1:-jue':rruerrmo':riljt Good Governance ej{fiva i alAvo v 6 | A )

n1t3.rnJ1 lallttqnql{nutrav}.rh Lflot€lv!ilfi t.:"1 711,\ ululNda

orreumuro.:rirfi niu nr:t#eirir ':J:vtr5g uio nn'lnnrnio io d v

Tltntrrs.Jo[unlv\" u:4 "lTvtrol]:Mntr}40" u:a "naLn

Ao a v 1 I . , 6v i i:t{nlT?lo" 14T0 "Di:il:q" {.:olal't"l nund0ft?1il14}.t'tuli

d

vl lq v A v13]50 rauun 3rFtlt;rue.llUllatanalFt roaou trnyditn0tl-r3.r

v q ai uY ra q Aa,f, lJ dU LUnlsdA dl: tv'l:lv U.t L'.1'.J nl::J fLl ry 91 €f 1,"111 til1 l I v}l tljl.l

v .{ .i - v , ,q v \vdtnaflturlrfiT9l LYr Er rfl arouvtl tll fl tNl:n Ll I Lafl tinu lo o,:

t 5l dvv,d, ad6, q Y ' 6l t"quu tuflr*vvru.: $rerflau0YrLllufilnn LlmtBl L11u1]av L'rol Lo

- Xa qr" ,

:rrnuarllfi6rrLaL{citjr nn"Lnl:vm5o" ururjljr'cov-

ernance" tinv natnil:vtriqfrd' uyuriljt "Good Govern-

v,, ;- ; j ,r,-ance tljn 0Utl."l 0'l qlnLTyfl tO tunlTfl 0O?1,..]143.J1 U Ll,l tnOO?ll.l

oQ jtl1 tavq5.:nu

Lua{arnv?raLion Good Governance rirfilrilufi9 V v- ar v u )a

dil la trnu lo TlJnl:u03.nlJ? lt1Ju1,i'11ail 3.r€r1ll.rnl€rruql0n1:

fr'qerurfriorfifionra.:fiuert rilum:r utnvfint:freuutodr.lJo , Vu,: uu d'tl4rliljrurli€1 L14u :l:vrfiufrqvniorls]dldrurrnduT--.--..-- --r--e-'l-.-.-4v \4 Y,, - v v- ,O

1Un..,LO UraVVrCOUr.: U,r t1lU O14Tsllta lrU LO U0N:U1Oflnl

4-.

*f?v1{s swts*lits

fi urd ro:r*qfi ah unr u'loftiau'tr rrr,tr' fih irrrrp uavo.:r{nr

fi sr.r ur :yu'j r.: il : y ryr s{u a r r o r 6 n :6 .rhfr o r r a.: d r ei ry fi r n r:- v , -)^ v , -Aoo

1\ mtl,{] fl n LnL:vS]:fr 11 0 nn tnLTv?i'1:611 0 l.t o?1]J14 3.J1 U 0 Ul { tTdd

ruayqyfi olildrfrryolofieowhuo ajrr't: ronanqflud'lgiduo{rda

runvfi nuruurFqarn:.1}.r}.r0.:qirr1 ufi ouarrurorre.:fro rquuav, A v 6t -, XYet A

5',llJi',la.tfl 03t n tn u'tnufl 1'tl.,t LlJuNllj0.tfi 'tlt0u14,1 Lut:O.:fl 0{n1T!

^ qe ^ | ( (uulilrtnynm tlrfi?11.J148]1u riul€lo rrauiltydLnlfi*lJ0{a{nnT

:vu'iril:vnro eraooquhadavilrn:yyLqiol:ynro'hiuluj qzo' q , vo

our fl qr w\ o r'tr uru ro n nrr runt: wl cr rir,,rior tr#druir fi'fr fi riru99A y zi el -V,

tn u'tlJ 0i tLavhYtfl u tail't t1ls

9go I ' v Aaozl8JySn g rla&n'l? Lgnlna [n]J3cfl156fl o

d

r^r^ ^i ^^ r-^^ ^ .. ^ -.4 q 4lO1?1 Good Governance tl^'l.lljilnilttay8.ln1Tt{LU

jq-!1':nlTl 0':Un1?''ln15r flU tAnl?V'1 9ilUlnA Lnnl::.J:14'l:tt0ynlT

I w jv'!noTo.:1a.3fi 'tFrl.J ts.Jo tl]uluNlfr airuqirir Governance fiu

r r9 a8yv e Iuilna o H n {1,'raurun:il Lray}.J h Lf nu}.Jluturrnl to uv{au11nT}.1qt'Lr,inrtryartuta,:rilir

Governance 6'.:fi "Governance

mernc (1) tho ant nrndocc nr nnrrror nf nnr-, v-,/ernlng;2.4

government, (2) the state of being governed."- 8{yrnay6a.d"q

rtllnnuat.:fl nvillun{ nt?n?vYlt nftuluntT }1T001utatuAAetr--<'d6le

nr:11514r:nr:LnoT0 J fi n $.J a ttnlJTsnulQUl.J €11'l3.l1l3.Jl u tna

o j v v o I v i aYtfiU'ltnU?lO.inlJfrlXlRlOTS (State) {.l01aAvU}.Jlsln.tY]{

Y^^.^^ ta5glta (Government) ttayryllr:1$n1: (Civil Service)

^ dq , q ' 6o: or ru11 rlqllrurir:'rqrtuvu.:{drurunr:ii'u (n:vrrunr:firirui'::.r1unrflVg}rur) r.lrunr:i,i'unirnnn:m1uriunyfrsJrurfr{qril dnrfiu

i{'u rfi onr:fr qrurl:yryr oh r

arrl wrorfit{. zs+o m:rig il:vtrorl unva':+5n:fi.:ox randrfllrynalnnd?uT ru qr,{rnrn:rri*lyriyrurfiu.

The American Heritage Drctionary. Boston: Houghton Mfflin, 1982, p. 569.

x " ' qtlUOnAlnil 0111 Uovernance EJ.:AteeyUtrd'dtr4iU

q . q ; q

0{fl n:ljA':R1O t0ngu LUerl'l}.114;.ll Um tAV'llyLA1yq{ LUOIl}.J143J1 U

dryfirnrruir,rrnrrilnoiolyilrurru niu nr:td'irllfirLqir.ir

Corporate Governance fi qvulrt ufr .:nnlnlol m nnt:oir ufiua a e4 d t 6l d j qarl.ilu nfl nl naTy Llr uu r[aylnilt.:li 0.3oll: to o.:nn;fi u{ay l1 Lu

nr:riur:'i'onr:nr utur oruilr r.:ru

Enslyfrnsruil:rn4'lrordn:fr'oruroir.:1 rfi rellfi rir.jr

Good Governance 1ud':.:qluilci15:19 tggo dro.: 1uo6qt

r.tnr:i{rnr: unvo{c1n:nr:fisNuroirsl :ru#ouurn',:Tanj 6, 6 a -t iq'(World Bank) tta y IMF fr .: riluo.: o n:nr: rlu:yo'l lanfr Lrinr:

rir una6o:J:yrvroarrEnfr fi rlryymrrnr:riu ro r"lfrunyeiuro u

riuriljrnr:6'ont:nroig 116o pubtic Sector Management

(PSM) ruavnr:riyr:5ofiq uio Publlc Administrarion- T u au 3 '

Rruun.:Dulo'r: ranto.:14usl'r'lf Governance rrnfi u 6,:riiu

h n il 1 a r n a rG fl a r ae n r : d n urTo rrini tr n r:r a,: mr o r:Ta n6l ' f,vrqp " X "LUqOAAeI e.Jlfl : LO tliO?rl.t14l.JtU?J0nfl]uml.tnllfi'l'18.J141.t1ufl a,:

PSM

ilromlnnd'r.t'ir rilir Good Governance t,'tL'itfiqv Y q f i o, 6r

rm L{o:{ tt?n LilTtu.:]ulj0,:Dil'tom Inn $.Ja! 1 989 LuTtu{lu

60.: Sub-Sahara Afrrca: From Crisls to Susiainablel - q jy, , a

Growth fr .: riju:r u.: tur o.rDut otr Luuo rrrnfr 'La'n

6i't? 0.! 0 ? I s.t

dreirpto'rnr:fi Good Governance tLaynrrfiul^hffT:iloffa

run yqi a Nr r^r arr:finsrfi ? torvr.[r-]:yar nr:r,ir o,r IMF'lunr:

lri'rJ:vnroolr.rlY^ d A | ^ AUq'riurfiafiu{ro:qffafi{oafir nilra

e 9 | d i " Y 'r q a el X'd tn ry:J:rnr:yfl e fr d r L:ld errrilai rrE qlunrrfiluy'J:cuu

r6{r:r6fi qso{:lr!rl4Fldiua?rsrdrs1ta6ofl r{nratu 6a nrrd

ilertmoriu"l fi cooo Governance uacfinr:aitfiunlral$lf A\rie rlg , * . 3

$ [su1ud1r1ittrgfi 'ldornas

r? o EJ1.: rcn.: o?o uaq uyl.: da.:fiq c

o Og, ' "-yt'l Ll,rlJrslvtFl[ua"r1{1rd1rl,l?alt'erurn6'udrafi srnrulda cirs

!

6 ^ - Ai'a

€?61 [f ? [tACa! tU$fl 'l€V'l OllAlYltl{ ul{| ^ A\ uA A , A o d

00r..l1ttl,[']O113..]€lO% tOe.Jnll€inrylnll.lfl 1'l':fl U [|6U€]lU

d o \w- q 6 d I

nilnU18.J1 L5nU0 Ul'l LLy,l:llnlU LU1{n'lTILAy0$0nTtOTAll UlJ0'3

rur0r:T6n To u'lu:v uv u:nr filorikndtruool rewrarr u

ar3.J nro!or']r 6 os oenr:oi r rff unufi rfr ur fi :-Lr ar rt nr a.r

DulollLnnllo'lEJ Gorrernance and Development o.:uu

eilir Governatr"e 6.rrilufrrfrr"Lqfiu'ir ultufr.: "nrrdtuuo

Y " vana[noruralo.:ntoS6LunmLiytr,i'on]ryl;flutni fr.rdrud

r€f ru3fi a rlaufi.: n r]fl o{l:y ryr fl nd ohi'rfi o nr:ri'qilur "'lu:v u y

eIv,L: l.t ttSnDu't o tT Ln n Lo v'l u't u'tr.J 0 D llt u ft,t18.t148.t't ull0.t Fl 11 1

Governance'itqyqr:otloailfr .:o'lreruelr u : finrcruy 6a

ft1 . [n:ra5 tirlavrluruuotTyuaLrt{n1:1fi a.r

(Polltlcai Regime)

2. nryL?unrlLay{uqraufi rlfi drura'lunr:rfi a.rlfr'lu

ntrL;uti'i'r']nr:yiu trn:nrr ref :uqff a rrnvfr.t€ra.Jd

A-tvl 01.,'1 EilU1LiTV t}l f i

3. n?'r,.r drmrn? a.: {fr d rurolunr:l3ln:l:ymolu

nt:rxup.rurituuouTulrs uavnmrrilaruzuurravT V ,L ,avauhurullcinr:1fr rY6 oraaoaunr:r.lilnJd tuuur

ilr{ nr:Lifi 'rr:-Jrv rYl 61

d{fl ril0l}r r{r'lqurnyelil6o rlluflrrolu nurnr:Tan't6'riryuo

ruur 6 o'i r our o rrTa n ua vudr r.nuturniori r r'luqruyo.: rin:^6lanTTt.: uttny0.tFtnrl\qilu't:yo1J LnndtNtrfl ;.t d?1{t? u tianounti

vVqly\] slutna Lnl o.tfl .303.t Lulj:yLvt€ifil0;:Jnr:rir lru6ofr'rr,larutri

rflu Good Governance't6' Touqyarsl:n'l#nr:ariuauulu

nr:r(srurdrufr rfr urriufroaot uny{aau,t I o 1y" Xy ra

L t;]?ta y n,] 3.J nlT Lt€t tulj].t t[n lu:y u y rtTnl,']l1? 1 yu? u

as" i , v V{tudNl ft n.r Lfrlfr qiNriu Lrl niu nr nwn:::.n6nr: rfi adr I nrd o

oirunr:fimurrLotoerin: Organizatlon for Economrc Co-

operation and Deveiopment (OECD) rLay Overseas

Development Administration (ODA) 1a{;iljtfidur'tS-o ol w. a v T q

ot ruli'n:ff.r nqufi uil'L#rir rot ur n'uour or: Ln n Lul rxyfr Inter-

American Development Bank (IDB) fl.:{uroufiinr:1#eir

'jr n rn\'ruurlirrjls nr:rLir,t r:5gff q1fi'l4uaslu (Moderniza-

tion of Public Adminlstration) tiludu uonatnfi ffifii,a-

1U?U.llUfltTl\9ilU]Oul t5U fiUlolTty!AnlT?{9}tu'tL0tgU

(Asian Development Bank, ADB) aerinmnrttirtfio-, ^i':y1,1?"1{tlqfu!U (Japan htemational Cooperation Agency,

JICA) a.:dnmalil:yttstA (Unired Narions, UN) runvj c- qy" Xqn0lLul11n1t]ntroul nyu']lt5FlluLuFt?'t;.Jy8.nurou1nunl

^fuul'.r10.1fi.tT€t1:Lnn

OANl8]nl;Ul€lltLnyo'l',]3.1148.11 Ul0.: Good Governancedq Pl 9l v , 6 vuLr-i Lttunr:{qrurdruqir.r"r uiu oronr:{muruvi.:au:J:y-

Srgtfi (UniteO Nations Development Programme, UNDP)

6 .q v ., -qtuurrnu%l Lunlihanouttu?ft o ttaydtt.:n1lu0&TlJ:?3rnu tuqr , v -A^ - A-^

:y0ilLnn?1'nf, tnllly{11311Ottayn111"l9}U10U11U.:UuLllu

rJ:; u6udr dr-1fi'ki dr H r:n q y urrJn o a na r nfiu'ld' n a'[nrJ:ysrind, a"qv q - f " -

ril u:r n qr ufr r r Lri o u tufr r o :r to u:'u.: o d ir l ri'uo ei t fruG al'daq

9la av 6 v Y r r G, v do,tuu tT0,114111111Uilln;rU:9U4nfl{O}rLil?rayrluf,.:Ft}.J11

v Y a u A- "

I a rvly,l 9?lU] tta'lltTA fi n 0 3J14 U.l O 0 U1''l qJlUl fl

': Fl 8.llJTyTl DIJ [91 U1450

fi{oar rzu6qnr: 6o nr:aixnatn:J:ssr5ofi 6dare.rrrnd": ua€ud

Q e iJa , o X ---afiuauunrfl{erurou[udrerilfl el.iuu r]Tvreluu ur[DP td'a ^ d Yr6l f i€f nBT ttav0fi. 111u:t unvta ufi [? tur0nd]:uLulr'luti 0.1

Governance for Susrainable Human Development dttoiQs" o . XA- X 1 -V, ! , o 6rL14OrUUrilfl A.: O'r1^1l'tro tQU1JU1l tO U11't Ut nA [nljtgllt$ lllu, ;i r 6'

d2ltfl tfl ail Ls{o{Flurun ou$an fir erarfrr s drilr{r6'r sfi'u 6a

iltvtrfioetu (Civil Society) nlnqifiatangu (Private

Sector) uae nro;S (State u6o Public sector) 6'.rfiirnottu; - '- ;- a Y , - )aa 6, r

R1v,l?1 1 O{141{fl1€?'ld{FlSJilnAln!tcfl156ilonAvllllAnalfl

runulunr:airrn?ludiloaisu'jrsa.:r{:J:cnauoirr"l gatfiioer6)go1140"1?{A{ou€?sJnuoul{du6ds $asfi0oilfi lafi sjrnry{!t

V , v a . "iqn a Ln!:&11? a,.,t ]J111J1il a 1u1afi U 111 LUnl:O t[61JT141:d{

uaua,'i'onr:Lu s eiruda d'ruro::*Efio nt€rfia{ $asn1?!eulr', ., . ,a eil:srmq d.rqyfio.:r5il:ynouflo.3ror,r6?r{orura1rur11 3 oru

AUtsy6,a nalnilacl'tiaffiumav1fio (Economic Governance)

a -^.q . I jo148.11 U0.t nTy!?UnttntTqo fl u La ttnunt:ntuu9tu LuLt u11l.l ilfl

n:yilLqi oryLU rrl:rl3ff ant ulut o{il:ytylFf unvnry}1Lfi .rFl?t}.1

v u 6v ^ ifi 3.Jl"tUDnt_JTUlJlJ tftTbOn A AU.l

dn aInJ e st'6 a ffiun16 Lfr a i

(Political Governance) vslufr{ ntyu?unmnmdruuor' !o q

utu!'ruil}.r r.raoa:-l?.rflu tulryff e loiud SrAnr y6or.lrarnr:

A v | | 6t v o Y ,*"- a 6$.]4.: L;.J11aUtU11tJ tLllUAlnnlTLA0nA{ tt0,lEr.: 14:0t9.tOQnlT

t4^4*ay na lniliv'tli Efiqvian1nl1iln1t (Administrative Gov-4

,4Y61 'Ternance) 14;]l Un.: nA Lnt[AUnTvU']UnlT [UnmtL:-JA{U LU]llU

u q,r r A,runyr:1,,{ urnT tljdnt:ilfl !fl 0ut,:3.Jtjryd11Dntl,'t :JTUdl4I zunttny

raAtV"f0u],tr14u.:D:T8.J fl.:qUzutul4l{naLnntTnT4UOUlUljtUttny

r.t ir roru:Jfr ri6 6'rriu ffi oi rer:tyli o? I N14 rlt uri o.: rilj r Gov-

-Zdaaernance 9,,l'l8..lUUlNll.:qUU nO?T'.]O1l,.l113.JlU:lNn.: TyUU

A - v 6 r ! , -iaRlyt?] 1 Fl?13Jd$ty'tltf ?vUdrrna'Lnilrygr6qfi 6 $aydxucil{ dl so{ fr{ o$t

^ rY^.^ r-^^^^1111l1l1.:aln Presenratron Slides of Training Module: Developing Capaciries for Effecrive Governance:

A Workshop tor UNDP Country Offices, Management Development and Governance Divrsion, UNDP. 1997.

rtn{5fioronru(Private Sector)

il:vtr#qnx(Civil Society)

nrnYg

(Public Sector)

yt3.ll:

fe,i6vw6Lfl :.td:].: tLavn:v!?unt501.3fl 11?t{na tililao113.Jd3.1141.{!

;vu'ir{r€fruqfia nr:ffi0{r16vfi.:nrro,:il:vrnef3 ifiafinrod

drl roefrrorqvfieNuruavo pji':rfiuo dxarrfruGqr

v 6 , tl , o Aaa fl :9frtg tta g 0 { o:J5 ufl 0:Jlt 0 { n a [n:J€vfl 'l€6Yl o

cl

9 jq T v rLU9r illy?l fl .r o l.r tn n: a n o u ro u n Ln n tn'l I o:s ua ynlr

ri r.rr:5qfi q'i rriluna'ln uaunruLrunr:d rdrulunr:rr.r6^

natnfl.[14nti1JT141:1]iutvtfl ttqnt:ttd't.t1i1rt'ltN14].t1ufl 0{n1:

"1 , -Ao <,-l-i-l-l "11d.:O8tilnd.!OUAv8.t "nfl Ln!TU{1;6YlO' rljuflirt1,\{t:}.lgtucd

6u6"r :lqqfiu nr:duvro'r].r14Nruunuoil€irroreitrt nn'ln, - A^ a d 6l , d I1l:v{rrq?l0" ilnt:fln:9lluxnnlT{trav}.lt0nfl1T0u3.llnNludU

1 ' a , a X '. I 'cr a ^{lOUv,lllllnlTfl n:glljTvt9lUuil'lu tUrU t!UnlT€ln:JlYlq.:AH!U

^ 6l q -9 a

iln6ru,]Ja.rrru?ootunt:v!q}1umt056t1.t009t t{u ttu']00dd

,4ao pulti. Sector Reform, Civi] Service Reform ll6a

Bureaucratic Reform LL6V Financral Management andGt v iq a Yrd 4 a

Budgehng Hetorm tLilslU q.3 tU0OSl lONnl;fllbltlUttA'l

orit.:elnrruniufiuA vQ , Y , - io a, ' Y "-

nr?yayrlr La?rna tnilru5t5$140 t1lu0 u].r L:ilu 0.lQy

qlo.:oirufr': "nalrrJ:vtrigfilrjd (Bad Governance) f;

Y v I ^ . _^"'^"Y_AnuilvAUl.: L: tLAvYlnil{O3.J tOSlLtnlAvttd0{01nl10trl.3tla t4v ,' - q io

;ru{runr:finurro.r uNDP ld'afl4rurnfrtoer'lofrfi natn, - iv ,o - v, '

rJ:vtriqfr 'hi6'

aydr;.rlrnofinurxvuayornr:td'qrnfrlfi{od!

u n r u:l: y nrr uiu rJ: yrrrulufir o r'16'5ui n r: ar I r:ruvdtri fi

0{unrfl arnuxi? u.lruiltnr:uioioiaryfi a il:y ff clilo fin r-qd6l

" d c a I a v I v ^.q ,R 11,! tunt:n1liuo14:001 Luuu LUlrluu:ar$.t rLfl n]Tfl oflu LQoru

f 5l I v Gvu tuLt u tuttqa3lunN n hoil at o ttnvfl !fl u t}.l to 0 ulul^tu$lu

ilr{a{-tnlTrravrvqrtia ntr:-Jivnntr€rfiwo.ttJ:vtvef #l tvnrAAfr r:r H fr .:rl rxur nrr ri unr:o fi ts o.t:J:v tr d unvntrrtl4uo

, -in't , 6, a y,.y 6

nLilsvlJt [u?1 u.J n o o o n a.: nLdr tv\ o?1 ].t riluai{ lri a5x a::drq - q', -iV.,Luntrl,'rsiluTjtv$46f rrfi vnr:o1ltGl3.Jntr [?'alur [1]-itvdrDn]il

ruavil:uAtl6r.rn nrrririluonAus.nuuavrvrfl u!fi'lriaur:n

,auarv ;.v,ljfllrfl tOAUl.:ai{Q': nltntuuonanlLrau;yt!uLfl1{1 ytut tlj\ , T .6 , Y,l ,,9

dnrrufl'l.514tha!:y tu{ula{€tur_i'tnnast o?-t}.t L}.J H:.r Ldfl a.3

'^q d a , T 6

nTULnUnnqodu ta ilnffi"4aTfl ttnynnrrd't.Jfi]h]n!Ty Iu{ualnv 6^. e- ,")yt:1 ufl ufl tDlTtuy ttny1,!Lnt5?1Q:ao0T:lJtu1j0,:unnt;$t0n

u6t,ttnvll:1'bnl: tLuqru

j , q .i . a a$r alTrnn? rfl .:o8.J Lo?1 sr o.: rh{ru:Jru14t1450N 01n15o{

ndrr ff varr uenrrirfir oarlurruyfiulil fi " nntnrl:ym5od6 "

d V ,d V ^ - io o L:r :.r n a Ln n or n nr o.: d.: o r fr dr s.r'rirr o ?lJ o l.r nti:Jiy t:1i'o ntr

6l , Vva - ;,nluLurLaynluuon:J5yr11qILoo1.\0 urnd{o3.rl1lTydunTty

V , q V ra 6 ,a a I A ^- -nR tnl:utlTfr t8.ro nLil;utJrd}]Ou;lnntul0.:ol.tli'l8.toilnudry

I Gt w ) ^v - u )!nl^]TA,: rltufl .tO3.rl1fl TOn'.t fl8.tnuoilAil eJAtnnl?vlnqqr $] 0

ff .: o 8.J An0 u n I u [fl R t? vll'] o nn tnL:vTt5 qv o tuT ?'tlj tuvli{d

^ a q , i^ ^rfl :19qnanonouvS o tux?.r1,r rnolnqoDrr':ro:lgsfl aoxu[[6')

V,-^Y'^Xe6,qvA(^"tr^f t )yn'1ill.1a tnl]tyfl r:qil u.lounQUtljuljQQUYr{rt9ril Lyxnqa

d

111.r r€1519fi ff Aili errS.J:Urr:.: ttayL€fT:Jfi fl qlA{il5vrv€1qn9i 1dqd

,v

odrr:ro r5r fr.rfi ryrrvarnr:ilflur?lli'{fina,:rufrrnru'luuny

nruuonlryrllFtrnoolr;.J rfr 0fiu€firil'lunnlnlrytr;q fr{n}ld

lrooxre.rd.:udr lrvs'r$u16oo;au Trordfiuinr?,mr.:

rfl:bofiaunvnr:Liu r,lnfr,roxflrtridrs.J1rnil;:-Jil:{nnlndc

, u \4 va . q e X a 4 g u a ^:liyttr0 tot n au?1 1 114 nlTv!u1,'l :u1J:J L€fT:J6n a tu naLSt tdrt uT-dad

^ ^ f ., A qe ,qtt lv\ rrfi v rQ : m rfl 1.r Lfl n n t u tl_i u.ilull u t n ttn v L5 r't atutunl l Lu

fi.:o rfi fi Good Governun.uo viooTQavdr:l:v uyr oniraintrvv Yv

nlTnilauntu Lo

6lvA-6lav,-)aaa[u111{ 9r:.:1]1;.r n trvt d.: o N Lo 3.J n a Ln]]:35rrfi ?10 u5a}.r

a A d I ^

dt v v a dddGood Governance UULfl lJ 01Jil n A Lnil LLuli! A.:11J tO fl 0U11OY]

a'Aavluilurn5 a.:Euuuirnr:r5ur:nr:i'onr:mreuql:r*qfi q fi.toilunv

d

^ Y Y )J O, Anriffi o{fiuay6'{o qlru:rngrufr aYuo.:rilufr uoerirsaroueiru9 ,9 q -d a d I q , ,, I114il Lud.:o3.r {':Tx3.rfl .3rdu.tlras!Tv{ll'% LunnN r..roou t0nrd

a v - "l

ruavnos.rrdurnau frn:vurunr:{od::v5fl utnrqir.:1 fr rilu

'61 -mrsrsiaorlufr{or ff nr:'i'ontr:ulrtit€{rl*qfi afr ff rl:vRvr6nrnd

runul:uRilG zu a 6',:riu n r:ci r rff unrifl o.: fr{ o er tfi oSnut or t rq^a

dsroanl u nllj0{:vlj:_i t€lTlJona d{613.J ttavnlTHa.! av3.l€l'll}.,1qd

JoN UO.] il rdn Urn 1V\ LrA v!:v{l{U8] 01 1 }.r d.3L qll

TT\IT)P flnvomaneo fnr Sr,qarnahlo I{rrman T)orrolonmonr a IT\TDP Pnlrnr Tlncrrmont Tanrranr 1Qq7 htm //mpmat rrn.]n nrnlnnlimr/

4Prrhlre Qontnr 1\,4an:nomonr Gnrrorn:nco:nd (rrqrarnahlo H rman f)orrolnnmont A f)rcnrrccrnn P:nor T\Torar Vnrll I\,4enenomontuu v uruyrrrurr!

Deve)opment and Covernance Divrsron IJNDP, January 199\. p. 20-21..

Y ' - Ao ^ 3. vrY a G, a v ,!-nn tnuTyrT?Q?t oayLnolu Lftuu at tljt{yTo l}.J7td.:f]3.t

d

gvAv6rqqTdVc,j[o fl.ros.r14u.r sr o{ rr]ufr {€rs.J Lu Lnn ra5 rdal a rl "ijufr ur fr : rnni r

a i ' v\ tdv a v ' A- a aatnnl;fl nBtil htulJtu.t L8.t3.J?0elnuuuu?tn]Tild,:o8.J toaye.l

Y , .- AoY . a, , dt w ionn tnu:yttiqilouuat t!uqa.: n_iud{o;.Jyt8.Jnt:?!9Iu] trn? uTO

d

.Ft^.:j-^-..4- - ' ^,Y q' Y'XL1JUfl { fl 3.Jr3.J nt: !nOTA.: q 13.t1 yilAL!TU{]ffj Lqt u rdNa Ll rrL

A tv 9 vavluounL:_JQa uilt.119l.tt{D?i}.1 1,!ufituyt1.:nt:L}.J0,! ttnyol9d

e-.-.tl-s, 'u.,, ) 4 d, X quuN tufl {o}.r rtgtfi {fl]€1{u111 ljatnnt:flnulttnyt!u1,,'Juit11 lun]:e ut ' - ^^L ^ ;- q - :r"i

flTt tnn LnmyttrqilquuoantTrd.toS.l tod{03.t14%.: LoSln:uL?ud6l r

nnLunt: "fiqrurou' (Human Development) frff:J:yRrfi-

' A d v 6 ^ - Aoo,Jt11\ At0LUO.I ttnyilntta0t0{€tn: n0nTla.:d.:€tN11fttlullil

q I ! Y ' - )o Xolj:y ro3.r1r 0 J fl .r o N tunrrfi r1{nn tn:j:ytt5$ylo olnnt'tu}.lntT

6 v ^ ;a , 6u uu ua1no1t8.tt14 ul10.:unl t'tn]:il d nBtLJ:yd!n1Tilla,t

i , q i.tJ:vrneiort,tl 8':t'ru'rr nr:11d.:ol Loytfr :vo'lnt: "l{olureru"q - ji aT L 6 :, 6a 6, v io[1.tlyoljl/lsrl LtnyS.t Lfil.:fl: I I 0.tonTl' a0Lrr0n3]layrlud{o3.Jyl}.1

V , - Au 'o"nn Ln!5v$1:fi11 t8.JOO'r Ud

A ou ,- X ^ q - v , vQvt8.l 08.J1 0 fi :lJO.:U rtu? O O tuntTil 9ilU1n6 tnt:yli]Ts t14

*' V .i ^o V.- 6t a a \

tLuna tililoa{ [oT]to11].tffu LQttny8.tnt5fl nB]0ut.:n?1.31J?tn

I d t vtsAtLo r o.: n nr::vr,ri I r:l:y ry e1 qrtr 1 "Ld"L#n r:ariuarlu run vrirhJ,^-^l Y ----)y." 6, t 6 ,

t_tfl !0 gts'l 8.tyt i tMI,' 1,1 to n'1fi uol tljuttu?u tuljt ulj 0,:0,: eln:l]:-Ft- y- _. ; \4 - y , -nlva ,i

'4a Iflufl0:nlyuo t{ au Lln]Tl\clLtr]F L'tllly{]Tq tl H_ll"N0L 11.

'{ a,i ' : ueALl4utllUUArA:AUtnrt :6',1 yt IMF LO LyO'I8.{1Uruno

di

a e , Y , - !oauil{LQaLu nt5%util?Tna Ln!Tttnfriloo?TNantgfl{y

cd

' v "- Gt a ^ i0uti tTuu nu r3.rnt:0Dt_itLllllntnuatuttauu,:dt,.JtTnnntfi u{nt{qe 4. o,q d d A -tO tny?.]l I tUOUlO qO i3l?? qJlUlnl: ttnyNnlTdnBl t1,,'101\ 9?tu't

6 zot , ::: I -V c 6t

a.:61O?'l8.ll tUF )1^uL1^,J3.trU [@Un l1^']:?:.11'l tl nQte,Unnn-l: Lyn.

) " a o ,V,, Y - ^^Lil0aluct d{nufl:lj tft'I nn Ln!?utlTal.1ouuay}]anBilyrrnyd

o?rs.rys.n u0 ril€irfr drdnn'irnr:ncitrfi .:nntnnnLir,n:5qff qu6ocd

nnLeyn{rullo{nrormnr:d{droudn:grfiuelr'luadn rJru-

- Y ' - Aa t av A u' - AanBngll0.tnn Lnil:v1']TqllFtavn0 :a.lnnu0lcrtfl vr.!0u tljonu

d

t ntefr daudavzt a id1 fr'tl tuilla (Public P articipation)

d6'4;

o0rLlunntnnry:J?unr:rl]:y{r{% (trurLayur!.:) }.1

T d\ 5l - ^.6ltant fi tlnv:.r fl ?uT't a..t lun:uL?untTgt odu La0 u I,t t1,n t1,t u3..lnu

.\4'cT6lerqaY(Equrty) talllAttt]ut0nlfl L%n'lTtfl lT?3.1 LullTifl:'1fiT0141.:008.1

T , Avt.- o Y , tro u hlunn3.r t't rrylu:rba:il Lo:!nlTrn an9t.:aTntj5yfl'txuL0 u

^, i qve'o:- J D:rsl n't: ril o La nt dtr.lar nr:rurufi eir uiu a r]rs ra6fi :r et

4-- ,qV.4 ,4 5l s,a qn,lntT 114 td:ntfl tLn daN?atuLLnu Lu td;n11\Ltndtfi trIufu L1l

nrildo.r o?'t;.1 6 n rfi ua rjr.: aix a::ri o rufrnuru:dr dryrJ:v-AAdI

nr:ut.rfr drDtrnituayfr 6i?uir I 6 onr:fr :rJ u!unrflJnFtro.l^;ttAy!:y1T.:'lUyln:VA I UO tuta (Decentralization)

a l,,o2. n2lNdqanLLflg[1]zi td (Honesty and Transparency)

4,4t Y io f ',q i a drt0 t!unn Lnil l.lo?t8tda: arLny lili\t Ld{.t:?Nn{nmii

rvlllnfi nr uaunr:oir rffu.rud rilo rzu et st:llilqr Jsl l:yfltudr s.r'rrn r{r 6.: ua uld';:l{o }r nd tx dtra dti rd6 riiun::r nn olo.r9i

ruays.r!rufr rDn til fr.:ym tff rnr:fi rirfi ur{o.:fr',rur otri,jrqy

riluyilr rnun r fi:-Lo ua un y:l:yxt{udtiltrnfl rladoL $nyfi 0rI

v,ot,]tia Lo

g. fruosaatuiy fr ng ay oia#tfl:,t (Accountability)

a dr V.i^ Q qjo an r:[!una tnI].J0?'t].tTlJhoy0lJ LUllli1l1l1R]iy14Ut11

.i+ , T d v 6 a c 6AyN fl 0fl 1D]:tufiu to ua.t mTaoa.lfl niu;an]:ntuuona tnilfl yl

,o^irfiunr:orrfru.nurfi adua{aauoltstdo{nt:rLa.:nrjaloir.:1 lufi.ro,.10 ut.t r:lufi?rl] LuFt?tslye.,ltufi:rtfr lnr:fr fi Bureau-

cracy Accountabiiity ttay Polltical Accountability d.rOv

a.i3.1 0'll:.t14a.n ul,t ;Inn't lnr::.t o113.t:t_i zu 01011 railtyst 0 fu 1J.3€llJ

L 6t o iq tu rytluT ana 3.J td rlj uslurfl u.rl1 Lu nt:dulJduuytl{nt:$t a.r

I a o io , -ruqi q y ql ro r o a r fr .: r{uoy o m al f l fi o tolfr ff qi o fr .: o ru lo u:r e.t

i ^_sl r 3t ! n n n t:}lQ u3.t1^tuDyfi? I l]5! fi o{o! qi ofi{ o il niufr o{ fint

' vAA y v u )14Ut U'ilU rrAU t.t11 tn U?9lA{q0.11^1T0il $nvdtiltTnrQynnfl t?qUg

doLuny;o h6nr:qirrfiu.rru#t1urfi.::Jilrru oilnl\ $vRn6-1y - - "-nt1\ rLaynl:L5l1:1,,']utn5dtm:ruy o.tuu€tilnnvnrvla.trt?lN

T,,q q " - I * c, -Q " - qtljl ,t tfifl0 tiylt:J tua to !il fla.:a.: tlju141 Ladt€tnJ Lunttdl t.:

A nnnrrntahilitrr

Na.i4. nA mnnLNAnilflAilEffiN (PoLitical Legitimacy)

a dt V io € | uAa, u o ,)o a t! unn Lnil 3l a.:ftljiyn0ill0.t hyt tljl.ti$t_i1nfiT0 r..{14

r{rirerr?r,l:rlft ryr€fiifi o?r}rrouD:r& rilufi eroriltoreruluq 1 V.' T , Y o o "-n{ o }.t ro u:x 3.t t}.1 ? I ay Lo u nt; rrqi.: d,rr,r5o 16 o n 9t'r rrqiqyslo{ tiju- Au, "-rfr!1ar to:Lnt:uo8t:Latnl:y5151.{i1fi o?tsrfla6a fr orrH

dq

i o I ututl,'tu.tD:T}] ttayil01t8.rd]8.l1:n11ay!:yttljTyrl4€1 Lo

6d a5. n1lna$tifi afloaeu ua silo [4% (F air Leg a]

Framework and Predictability)

6 o fr n:arr o.: n gr.r al ud q 6 m:r uavrii ur::r druir

n{ru nuoix 1 tu#.r o e.r d.rn6 rn rur{fi nrd.r fiu1#ua yar rr:n'l#- - U,y I d I

u.3Ft]_J tO0U't.t,.,luTyfiilDn'tlt tLun0tnill4rrotQu{.:FtuLueq v yt

^ r Vd.:o3.iilnd'rur1r1 La dt}.nrnFtl0y?.3tray:?laytnohaau1.: t?q9

aY'j ( w A ,,"vso Lsr Ll.r a rir Luunrrgr e.r nq rn ruvm or d.r o r.r fr .: lra rirfi lfl unr:

l:vfi'unlr fiuo { fl ;yr Dr rrnvorlsr rfi a}Yur o.rl:v{rsu

a. ilsc3nfintwuaciJzc?nfiNd (Efficiency and

Effectiveness)

a 6t Y i^ , q . a { ,.o a r:_J u n a Lt vt 3.J 1J :v fi 11 D n tv{ Lun ltfi 1 tux{.:'11.{ l8.J'l T Q v

rfluoirunr:i'onrvulunrrfirnru nr:ioo.:c{n: n'nfiod:rd q! | ,

LOnlnr trnvilnl? tfllmil utn:dtDllruvsn.:l a ut{q}.Jotttau

Ms.rTvda.r fi nr:oir rffunr:unvnr'lrfirinrra',u',r*rd1fi r..ra fiufc, J, q v v e d

tUuylUl?"10 tAttAyn:v9lUnliv!$ilU]110.tfl{fi3l?1nO]U (nTT$J0.:

fr.:o erislun::al uavre:ugff a)

{ , v Aa a a o Ifl a [nu?vf,lrQYro rra c?nqosa{d{ 6t3J [?rrJd

, v 6, , j j \ttvvlJ 5U Lyl Fi Lll U LlJ Uljiy rYr €11 1.{,114 [0 U L9] :i.J €l?1 ].JS1 U rU n 0

Yu ^ y ^ 6r4.r oirunr:ui u*aydrul{t nlTatno{Fl nrfi qrur:yl4i'lnlTynl€l

9n.3"1 r{uL6 u?n'll:ymontn.rv{q}tut{{u61u o'r{u rl:ytttoY AYvv a ^

q "l

a qrd 6l

[14U4,] LolTU011DV{n LUn 0.:L[U?OOrrfiv LO3]n150'rLUU.:IU LUnrlv tv vl o -^^^^-- r^^^^ ^il qilUll"JTLLi.ln A tn nlT:JTY 1:n 1T:J n€150.: (Admrntstralive

9

. r -Y ,-A, r,1 aDevelopment) 3.n Lor uaa 0ouLa{ rrqr ds.J url:yryt€l 114 u}.Jnl:

rirSori,murl:vrvro d.::rrfi ,:nr:rjir:J:.::vrrnmuiunro.rv6tev v e , 6l A - < At1y

RlO5q turild8.t Uot? U [fU [Ude] Uaa3]1,^rnflqbf] Duvrxfl 1,1 LO

rdr air.: unvlr na'lnnr:me uhu:v6'utrA rfi o rfl un:or'lunt:tdY

fiqiluril:v rla 11 Lo r fi nr:d'.r drfin.:ruo {uvnr:}.J nr?fiqJrur nr:-

rfl rvifi a *aufi.r o s.r uil.:{r 6 fi n r:rJirr.i:rn aln nr:riyr: ua ydq

,fnrrorlJo,.r.rljlr:u8.,rtr* toufi nt?ttundlfin,tLt-J:viltrxoanqrn

n:uyt:x{nlTo fr.: Lrnyr u'r rJ.ilurrfl yllylt-iT1fl o{dtfintl:J:ytrruA v X ' I d y) 6{.ifl 0 tfl u0 rruyu hluo?re.rr'? u 114n09J0': r.r rtu?fl 1ruatn0{onlT-

X\, vd141j:Ufl lf 1 q %onqlnu LUOlUnl?y'l qilUl:ylfi nl?1JT141i']1U

e \e ^ \ua v dlolunll L14L:ntTdlfi Tildlj tO3tn1Tl"lqIUttiJUTylJilnlTll514lTA a, qr r a u)

.:tuttLlJttzuu.ilu {.t Uunl: 114011}.t5't u tua0alnht{u?{tryatn6ttG,,

0.l0nTq1.tl:yr11fl HJuau

nr:fr eilutyll{n1r rfi o{16'fi ox 1}.ty'l u'r uta.t'[unt:fr$Nuto i q"Vg a a v a

ntru.ra{ [v't0 114 [o:y]lLnt:$ta{ 1{110nm$ta\:[tnyunnl;u.l0.:!a--. ev v a q a11il fl nrn 1?'l arnl? sNulnm rra yrlTyt qilul111.3rtT r;.t 0{ Lua o ql

,t,uXiv d , V q

to 5 t1,1 L14UO1tr.J1^r U1 U1l.Jfl 0.:1_J:y[11Ff LylU LUnttl1.:i]n61uyt1{

nmffi o{dfi o?rH rilurhytr6ri'lqr s d.r riJuei'rur,rd.:'lun r:a::rara' t quu

rLnynrrrfl o Lanra Lr,r'ri uvrurj:ytt{ufr fi o?t}r{oLDrrNtrifit')q q -;i,^ oo.l a

ttrl:.Jl:-iT14l:lJ:ULli€l tLny LU!AA1-lUfl,]}lUlUUOO0t13.JAy8.J

nryL?urrrfr 0rad rlild nr:ilfi :ilyr.:nr:rfi o{nr uufi{nriq q9

, 4uurJ:vnro Lfi5gn:rsl1ru afiuiJ il.rt. 2b40

6l e 6l v u,v- Yt1.to'tuo?1'.t1,\ ulu'1,.J Lun1Tl,'l$.tutTUljllrl5nm Loqoqr.l

n0{fr'qr.rul?yrlUnt:!5ur:tt'6rya.:f5n? (Orqanization and, ) - Y '

qvd,Management) 11,\ 0?! qil U1n A tnl 0':1lU? Ufl f n 1T L14N1JTyd11D-

nlyi ttnynl;si',:no.:l:yLfi u'.in (Evaluation Divlslon) tfi oio

hanr;rir lfiu.Jlue o.r14ilx u,ru:unrrfi u lildtfin.u:J:yarrru

1u d' r u o r r al,r u r u r el'lun r rdi r r n a'ln n r : qr:'r a d a :rq,,"-

n]Til].]]UlJ0'314u',tUTttn]:tUU0qtA"t 3.t1 t5U n',tTq{Oily-

nr?llnr:lirLJlstNntryaeEtuav:J:vlrq6fitoL (:Jill ) n1rdo

^ ,

^qt{uul u.3'tu14ot'tluiln]Tq]T'lafi 0:Jo'tull1TL{untTnn{ ttu lt:8.t

6, yq:r r!snat.: rLayfl tunntufi :?a [{urrzuuourljuna tn Lunl:oT?a

dou unuf,il.ioxTlJtoun-:rsllJ O.rryllUrlsnt: riit,leluq

' , ,^"Luqnolom .nu6'runr:rJfr?l?uLUrttnrrfrniunr:

-tv-..-,e-.-.-7,Yvv,qaoaTljlu tLn uuil.ITUIJ! to:!Fl?13.tfl1.{ LA ttAUil ntTOt 11.{1.{.t1u}.t1 LO U

v,6t r i ' V,q ,d ' j f -naao rH11 t1.{s1.:7 zuluil]Ay U] IOT,] €1113]qt A Lilai tO UTSL1A

Y vv atFtfl .:orrlynT:].Jn1:LnT!:y:J1j:15n]:unt uu€tynt ud3.t u $.lntT

q

a Ayu-fr n:grfr Lo5rnr:afiLduuqrnil:vmefi(olur rufrroirrl L16yatn

( , ^ t,

- v -a.!rinl?dul:vr'rtrfi tu:lqqflu fu rrotruffio.irirLilunrr

oirunr:rlfi : :ir&LrJr1{nr: Lu:fi ae o rxvn::N nrrrvd':Jfl raqs Ej

ril a nr1ru0t11 €1111.1 n1T!nilJ:vlJlJT1fl nm

rufii rr.J:y rn o'ly er'td'lfrnlilr,nr eJr ursr o siNqio rfi o.r'lunr:e v v _ 6l g<, \4 Aau At{y

d:r{n]?v! 9r.rulnn tn10{n10:$ 114 rLunn tn}101o.:yt L9rnal'tllju, , a' )' - I '

q dfl 'r 0 ut.tl t.: fi u H_iu14u1 d.r Ln m 1 n1501 tuu.:]ulfi,ltul.t't Lila 0t ql

fi nq y rr;unr:airerJ:rfi rBnry{s o.rryrlrJ:rtnr: ril udru'lyniA.- , vY, L 6 v .i .vfr efr rIu'j rd.r hj dtsl:ndit{nfl rrru,ti uaynatnfr rirtrJ{nr:fi

v , - Aa )Yu I vna [n!ruttToyln q1N0111N14;.r1 ula.rdrnnyl lonn'l?].J'11't.tstu

d

r.laarno'rs.Jd ouual o{n6'ln:J:vtr5o'lufrioH'lrueirud

A , ^ -9 a14U.30{}.t1Q1 n ntTfi yta u{luotunt:il 0?.lu]0ua EJ1.:QT{a.: tilaoqlzi r - X A o A - vdlg.: u L u! I u I I T1\ sJr 1.{r o uu Ltr^'t .: }.J n 1: st uq'l ttn yL 1 t a t? Lu tr hu

frqrurro::gaffqu6yfiine.r*vi.rtrG arllfi e :lqr.lrfiavard

ufr arl:ynarrirn'l8.Jdat,luolJo.ro.:rin:oir,:1 flryull.:nr:

ffiot orrllufrorlr:rso.: Technocrats Lraua.:6{n::t{nt5 fra !v' ^ ^ 6 o )avutiu'Lo"itinq6nr:rxrtro:uqflq frrerl uaynn$.la.iyl

,vqil:vrmo'Lr urir6',r:l:ya! Lurlqq:-iurilunrryfr il:vmorirfitlro

Y r .-;^ ^ 6 6 q Gnatnl;vst:s1l0 ry{ltyilln?to;tyualnffntunt:flrJlluLund

q ' ) | u V a- ' iqytu u'l 114 h 1u8.11ff.to8.J Lllu3.J n nBr*ytt6uotntTuntud?u11

rudo.rfi':nt:fr Bad Governance oilr{fiorau dtnrnrirrloi'irv,

n"t?vnrfll0narnLryrl:ofr6frflydNN11.{1u nt?ufio{rilrld

A AY ^ q, { ' ,^lJ a a uuu{11 q'] rfl er 114 r€l:ryfi n a n o n a u LLn y d.: o }r t1i Er L9n d? n q 91

' c I L o* , , v 4 , i0 ut.::? o t:? tut'?{vat u Lo 0u11 htu}] I o.: zufl ntl €{nut nl.:l 7t

Yg^ ( e, vto? to:1v14Ltnl11Jnu

atV,qqr8.J014U3]'tO:JnJytytfl.:Ol] tl1 Ull:yd:J IU:JAaLU 1,'11J1 I

^ v i^ 3 q

nmv'rnnq1l t.: rfl:196 nal a.: 111 uy Lnolu Lu{? rlj 2540 }.t Lo Lno,d

a dt - ^T -1,1i 0 L:_i U t't n a I n n I 1't fr q a fi 1 0 n tT{y n a fl ? I 0.t tqll u6 n a La n 0.:

,i a q a ^Trful4r€r urfl oilr Luo6a r1^riluQtnil u,ltur€f:uqfr a Lanl:tnfl

'f ^f o'X ' oXV,,1 T tfl Un1l"1??3.J?A{t€l:Bfin a tAnl_iUOlO? layOlU L8.J'llayLllu

d

rci:lJ3ffaso.rd145goua.rinr 6'rnqu unvuuo:fiu riluqlu rin

Lcir.:g6r1rd${n rirti r:l nnrr o.:tvr r lilu:lrur.rrdu',r',nnr'ln,,a,dv

. ^i c, qu q , In]iL1141:4Onl? tflT196 fl Q{.t ullu:-lAa Unl U LU:ll y Ll1Ef to.l LO Ud

^ 6t q I Y Y

^1 tn:1y14?tljIu1 t tfl:Bonafl a.:dufl 0,: Llluuutnoalnnl;olLuu!

t,u tulJl u traunTTLtyn0Ln anT:3.J11T.:ntTt.rufl n00aunanT:}t

^il^aavt.t1r.: L€f :bqn a ou"l fr fr o1,'r nr o s.t t o dr,: qi o rfr a.: fr ,:il'j t ljluorr I^

j r I q V y^ ' , { | eehol,{ ntoililn t{l u Lufi lo}] Lo}] fl?u:lil ul Ntnnuo u ttu

n1nE1flq

a u^ ' \vov .61 u ,^. 3..1 nlTn t.:UQ] fl 9'll.ll-jTy til d 0 U''].: tT'l U U Yl I t141J:3..111U t.tilu v\ e q T . a Iny 6.1 t1,16 tlj 1 8.]1 LUUTy r11 FIAIU?U3]1,11 q{] n Lq UUt tnunU!

". q ^ iY'tyuyfi u}]1a{ru tunant:8]11 to 9^laq0! ttYtuTyEJyut')

Anmar Siamwalla. Can a Deve.oprng

.J T)onclaq Gihqnn I oe t rrre dolirrorod rt'1 6 lOOT n ?-7

'P ''

4q^u6^. '..1

nl:4,:?1 U IUD 5n Q 0d.t14lT ,.J7111.,'lU il1n tn Un?tNq9et,6l910{ntT1a.:qn-}o touLiTlefaln}.J1A:nn LUnl:ntta$

o'tlJ€1,.J

LA ^ 'X. nrrLnourruD:nar5ledolfludrurulrn ffiouffonny

rcf r1e6fi a{1r r{rnrja.ruirin riu4uolr.:1 fi n ao u 16oqr

' iq5ou frr Lueirudo ufr qy rfi uloi'jr Corporate Govern-

q d 6v, .6lvance nl U tuoi€t nT[On{Uto{n CJ{n}.] L}lA? ill L14LT:O]

ff Lllrifr'rnr u"Luuaynr uuon:J:y ryr€ilr1o o?ril 16olYuU!

a1n51Vn'tj

i '

I d Qg'. vl zu']u8.t'ty at uu111 u.tluil n'tT l5a 1 u,:u:_J?yl.l'1ilO u 1.3

v'l ar rfrl o u fi nr:a rr ut o:.t n q ntrri 1 rfi t,l.:11.t r? il#.: ntr

a.wp'luTortnr:dr.:1 fi rfl uTo:{nrturflhqj (Mesa

Proj e ct) o rir.r'l#fi €f ilrr ud ylr r oifi u'ki fi nl rTr.lirla

runvolahidaeet

d0r:-iilddrfiLoundrunnLtu olrrffuuTuuurr.:nn

^ -o

t

t,r{unmna{2o1,'lato 6151 niu nr:fl6r6'gtrln.lTrrnn

rlduu:yunyniruiuururfiu'lrl nr:drrfiuub:.lui,Lor dr anr:lunm riuqit$'l uayntryirJ riu rfri qi od:Jnq!

q ra - 6 .Y .61 yolJ0.tott.tut_Jlylatnuntn{nl LT al,|il] L14N1l?1ud'1i0.1

Y a - )a, - \1v1411 :LiTUr?1€ltAn LllUnOAlAUrt$yOlryr LtlU0Ust:1U

rir:rtnt:rrav:yull:1{n1T?10 nr:yimut uunyilft:rl:.:

'lrii'usi o n r: uJ fr uuurl a rr ar anrr ur o #ornr uuon

rua vfi ci r fi ry fr'.: { r :r rn r : run vri n n r : ffi o.rrL I o o i t }.J

u6)erryilfin lufruffi o?lil5]l fr otaLqia arm:nrvo siNa3.:i'.r

Technocrats'lun', "rltn',rd.:

uo u liluunudr'lunt:

Liln:ro:usff qsrunrodouuoa{ rlo ronnrv{ v6a'l+d

q 9 u e^ u aaflnun]y,,t tunlttllto't1jflil LLntlttay:_la.!nil?nqql

'qavvdq9n,:1 LUIJ l{n:ilU.:51 NN 0f :JUnn1: L}.t 0{ i'Unm LLfi l.t

r,rrzunrl:vTumiiufiu

its Macroeconomy? The Case of Thai.land. Paper prepared for

Studies, Oueen's Unrversity, Kingston, Ontario, Canada, Octobel

n^-^^,^^,, 1f^-^-^ucrrluulouy lvrorloqu

tho anhnnl ^f D^1,A,ur r urru y

ilail1sr1il%

. rlroefiuunvo'rsrffluntroooas.loLitiai{i":ttnvqroi o 6 .\4 q

tuo.t 3tn]:fi .:rutn.:nt [T tur:nail].to'll]..1 tfl u.: fl .: ttnus

1 Y 'Ye6l e a,L0unri^:?l.J [].J Lo t14riafl01Jttllu?rflilFrl tt',u n1:

d "V q v 6 :Y 6

nt111,{Ln.:nl tT tua'6l1o1 U ttaynntn.:nl LT LUD:ffQ

v6dt,0 fl .t1t15l]?1:v\ u tl1ilfl u

a qtr d, t Y !" a a. 3ln1:t{QlUtnUfl'114}.1t1,'!0U tOUUl.lfllU':n{hnn:vl']]-l

ar'rN fitnnljnnfulfluoirfier:.rlunrr9r011:vrYrfi{]fl tfr u:

i qu^ *, ?frusslnrrL{finara rh:vrvr tff utrt{v u o N Lfl uvfi rfl ufi u

addrvlY^.v

fl n00auNoluu3.l ttdv;lnnttl.:fl unm [tfi ur]1ilfl 1 tt1'!.1

^6lAayu6r ?1O dql tl{Jl]?Y€]]Jfl U {.::1 3.J tl.lJllv! nlT t111 I U14 A nml"l U

lufl arofi'u nr?vnT:nouLiuatndiltriunt:tiu ttav

rd a

nT; rr14{a du€r I Lv'l A n1:n n qu

i nqG rr.: "o:u3 ff a o5.:f, "tr,rr!1o

uav rj.: r. n nr ri rqF f:-l:ymql'lr lro uilru:l r1,\:rvflaafiutd:tgoff qtos:l:vtilofi

cd

nuro'h,rr!n'JrluaaYunoul frtJttturettlut"elil:vfi! unvdl.n:n

^ ^ \' Y ' ^ 5l L al

l^Ur.lt1nqarfl::Jnnatoua"ue:.: ttu'lnnqLqtlj6nQ tut'll1l

2527 r.rffqrfiru,fma:tt (Gross Domestic Product, GDP)

ra{ilrvr14flfi}lndrufiu.r l t: #rufrrurrr tusrxvfiil 2539 fi!

l.ra€ir 4.66 frrufrruw wil:vrrruuiluduil zszz rilu

druru tgz ooo frruurr urffrriiu 843,200 frtu::lt uaufi, -t .& o

l:vtrn:nfrelfrurfro:r 10 #ruou 6o fiil:vttn:rfiu.: so.s

, q ^, : d , q a, e -Ynluou Lul 2527 r1,\}]rlil 60.1 nru€tu tull 2539 0'r1.ru

- ^ i^ & Y Xa o' u Au v ,9 dllill4treltl*qnQr tn ofl uoT{ua i tul"llnlulll't'l_ltOun?'l tu00sl

vd

,:iv6lyn]uL141 tUO:,.tlQtnlJLAQUtravt.:AU[lnlUUOnrtAUnlL LU

unr ulrunr# r{rrr rfi m{o'rhi'irqvLiluol}.r tfr oetus aginn.:ruq , --:!- --q o.r,flfifiLutJTvrvr€{ nt?vqflfllvnr:}]tvaafl'l €111}.J8]utafl

qir.:trG nr:rff':rirhratrXndrriuq:rtirs.rtrG ttnvfiflilttan

r:Jfi mriurrvrfi'uru':u riiufru Rcfidrfiry 6o t:rff.:ttona'lnjaar-\1q,jo,^^

ttRULoTo.:N0 tunl:ttn Lfl lrLulqlr.:l Yls.lljlyF14Ihn [.AvU{llloA . g;4 u !r I d I

! Ft A l n:r q v tl l t tr tfl ! T-t 1,1 1 Lel a u 1 { 8.1 11 : t fi 14 i tr' 1.\

VV ^

dt d daqfl 'r5r I nr tfr n411f\nc" lfllBqnQ l!utl a :y3.111ill,l1n11fi 0{

ruorl ur.l{ o Li fi nr: uri.:l r::o uil.r}^l? n o ua h alivTutriur nv(o.r!{

travlidldftfl 10 0113J L{lutannril runr:qr9rfl u ta Ll ilv:laaflu5 r - u ' Z . q' ^ 1

Lo:.:di r.:rrrnrl rN o { Ei J La.r ro oo tux u tli nrrus urr':tu Lo u

ra1,'llvnr:!6vri rflT:gsff asrunl€t unvnlri'onr:oirunr:liunr:-c'V'tdl

o d.: tllu ul ilu'lJ3]1j:vfl1,1rfl lv\ 3.t01l5.ltt'll{ ttn:3 LtnvtLu

ra nnrl\ :vrL:lfl q qrlu fr,r ril olo nr alrinr: ffi o : irit ur:n ufl {nm\4erl v 6

1l:141:rJTUr1,t€l t9-r tUilnTvOlJ1lnA{On5 ttnvTvljLnl:!i1,t',ti.t]Ue r,,q i . ^ A

fl 0nu ftnt:t8.t 0{ t|nv1 tTt{nl:1]on1lN Lll:.: 1ffl1 LLil a5{fl.3

d] D]:rufl ulil dr il 1r0 e1:1 a do!16q d 6t

' ) Y

' .qTtrioosr 0.roll:vn0!d?u14%.t1j0{naLn!rv5n$tou

, q - G, . ioranlvl'l:lsnl: tuna3..l'i'echnocrats to utLluttnuuT140la.l

fi.:o:.r nr:rvnrnq:ff a rontuluqofru1'kifr nlerdrriry riJu

n:ff qo:oLoiruiadxm6 uavfrror'lrufr neierrifi nndnurrrnv

1luu1.:'leiriu6'1 ro':ar n r.ft-l n o:0.: ua vn 6i r.l,idtt a.: fr{ o s.t (Elite)c9

, a 4 d io ,$.lrr1li]Jr]{n]: t:14.:Nlloonr}.lo?l}.J?o?lild]e.J]Tn{luq! v \4u i '. - q )

1JT14t:LlTUrYt€l 114:0Ol\U']l lOUFrl4U.t tLqr1jQ-QLJULUljIUvll

r6:BSff a fi.:ou unvnr: rfi o{nr eruonfi nr:tild uuula{o dN:x oG 6, v | -ir1trr?nnt u tljudi Ft;.r1r 11 dlTll LTil:eJ ILOU nlOq:nQ t0ntUl U"l U

v A - qy TlaY0? l.rnr:n0Nu] Lrnv Lttl10 Lu La ur.:nl:oltl.ru.:luitnvnlT1l:14'lT

A- V ,v vYtvv , q

.:1U?r?lUd3.r U trfl nA Ln10,tnl0:fin15:J:Lfl ? Lotlnll ttav 111

i , -Y ra T .e1 l1,t t:0,:]l1.: d'tu u.t i8..1 3..1 nlrl_iT! fl ? TylJ:J Loi.t d:].:T]snl5fl 0.t

v a 6, , , I o i T aqtll UQ.: rllUSvlJlJ tn t ttn tT8] ;.r o ? 1 N tfi 0 3..] t14:3..l I ta u3.] utu141 fl vn].1

a ( ' 'T -Y ' L 9rfl r:.J anuilvljnfl I 0.: 0{o ntrnl rrn Lo uYll tll ttu I vliLnn tlt ha

El eiO aL LtlluLtAv:v1J!nl:A { ta! fl 6lnlfllYA': LtAVO lqA:.l ttYlUfl 1

r "9Yn'rlnroronru lrlr14RroialtoLflatrrfrfio'rl.rd]l.rmil fr

d u . 9ud']i:nn1il uaufr ern*nru {nttnmrrav:vllj5]5nl:11'l.t'lilnlu Lql

a Au a e dt o q 4ntoLnfl?vHrulj11:o5.t 1rlTltnl:n-iualu?u8.Jlnu{11oqafl lun

'lunr:lririnr:drsnruv uavlroaeuD?ir 6.:r.ir1:J{flryr.rr

^ <- '-

q d o

ilaT91FtA::!tUtU'].::lflnl:au1.5n1l$u'11.: tilattnuulll0.lv vol

nro5qfirtueiruloniv!1j:t{n1t (Technocrats) Ltav5-q!14d'd

ciou"roti:J:vRvGn l,r uavs roolrlllli.rld nr:i'ont:udaurltr

^ ^a v ^ i- V 'a "-?nq91A.:d:ldU 1llO14€f111.l1i5oLAU ttnUU.lS.Jt0nnlv'lIinm

q ,iaqo GDp qrndrfin.ru€rilynrrltnt?rVgu1.{rnrrrrl:tigffaunyfi.:€r;lul.i.r{rfi {o:rn.:Lrl:vxrruqtntond-lr.rtll:vmruarilff 1 ilu5riluqirElrlSuLlfru:-Jiltyqtil.:!l:y:.Jri 2534 uavrondrr.:rlrvlJrruilirf t ruSr:ruqirEiLliEl!LfuLl:vdrtl.:llrvrrru 2539 rilin'::t-

l:vrtrx rrnvdruruil:vtrniarnn:lln-rrlno:E': nf,v1t11.r3.u4ro1ru

- ^ q 4 ^ "

q ev0t 1 [uu.31u tta vnlta F] dl,t La {,1 u.:111 tvuna.:Ytuttn v dtDt;nrtu

1l'rfto11s.J rfi ofiuuaufl ;ilDrv,

6'.: uoilff or1ry r.,rri n q 6 4 n ilr u:ufrr5gLr n dfi u?'r a ron

^ 6l \4v I e.,4 ^ ,d

'rlAn U{tAUYD tOtill4l}.Jlfllnl:LtnLl?nilqtAV'llvYU'l ttaYl

^ Y I t4p q q , 6h'tu8.t tnmot tuu.Stu t8t 0 a u to t^t nun tuYt t\: 0:.:1J I a.t fl il]un tTll,l

nfi:-lrnrir un,:rnsnrv han:vmLarnrcf:uoff qerneirfilfinf;ucd

fro rquurnv:J:vtrr'u11nn10rdxuloi5ro'ru 16ooiou ffurfi oqrn, d , & )",

rtr'lvduolilrtt r11\{ rrnv0Tora{{?'tv!{q.:fl 1.r {.r riluzu6}]larn4ovl

nlTlUTlOlUtNU LT':.:rU0n drlrr::e] rLnvqTnaqT{l fl vnasr?

A AI A V YYfi50LOnAnt: tn0tntlvnl:11.t.:tu or0uFrT?1l105tuLo ttfiy

" A u v I v A'^ ^rr:.t.tluutunllnn!Lltdnlrt{uljfl ttaulaNaflul?qn 00 un{9

i tinr:runvfi n r€1r:e$11rdfl i uluor:rfiu4 tnrrfl dilrunr?'rfl r.l

^ V 4v u a a 6l a , qt o itf1T19an a Lv u Lu n fi L 0t t14 N 0u [ua o fl o.t q 0.] [t t'] a] a n:v uv14u.1

q, ,; \4v ; A- v dv,tLtavalaav lfl t? ElNtnn'tlvloto L? d.111d.:€t :.1 t71 uo.:14u 1,..ll\u

6 a zu a n:vvr:iq r nR 11 v tdrt*aff q ar n ei rfi qvili ruu:.ur ndu'ludc

u qy^ u{1.31J 2541 ttnv!illl.tllt.]tE1TlJ6nAavnrv9,tu Lu tn0t_iil141d':ft3.,l

dq

6u1 ona.mr6nslrn rdil :lryurartryrn::ru :lrpl.no:oloir

:Irpvrroru unau rlqu,nnr:fi n:-fl unv:Jruvrdulq d a "-o, , V

[utx J]_l 2540 rno!il.r]J lj:uryr€f tl4uxun Lu14r|rnRri

^ ^lo , o' 6r.l )nrv$d'rnqqrrNdrl1,\ rn?5r u n J4niu ail turdol,r r.: o on r1,\ o

L4 v ^ ;- 9vLtn L9itl ru141'r n q0 ref:Bsn ail :qLr an r u Lel n r:u]fl a{v,l 6 r0n

^ 6l V tv ^

q a I

{'1nfl u{laurD LogtoduLa€ta n1:ta:at1ao1't}t5?ut14flart.t

nrrLtuarn IMF 6.:qiae.:lruror?uvi.rilrvmel'lnuuavn:vvr:'r.:-

-Yv v^ o a , 6 vnl:oa I Lo fl iutil n rit{a )u1u 1.7 .2 l,^{untuo 06al:dura"1 aln

{d

/ ;-; ^ B :i ,^IMF HAIUr 21 d.:14tolt 2540 11 t01.{1tnuN]l1nqflill.:

^ q '- X 66 V, d Vrd ---_Vr qLt€i:UAnA tUO::U "rfitll"1l1+ Ulfrl-l3]11OlO t'lO0 llvll,' LOflnn{ tfi

; X I v'a "i V Qvo'llN?l"l U tun A til Av!uil Lfl :UonA LO U LO3.lnl5nlyllo tn0X{ Lll [1,1

{d

- V , c' V , ) o 't-Tfi LlA 114 U:_inlJfl 9t13rtr4Al U!:vnl: ttnU [!U t:J Al3.J110lO O A tO

dd

:rrfi rnr:&.: ri au'ltlunr:r1fr ::.1:v:.rr:rfl n t:d r lilunatnri'ruzi v u v 6, i ---- ! , 6, ad

r.rfirro'rnn"Ln:J:vtrig fiuriluuurrxfr tvrp lfr o'jrqvriluiffjq q -, T-

?l]nilu{ t%nl:?l'::lns lil tunl:dit': Good Governance tO Ud

e.narnl:vd:rn1:ilifi IMF'tdvlr.nuirelfilrJ:vmofrfl6u1 lu

l:v rdunr:iolJm1Jr1rfl o,:n1oiq'lriry rrvaru'lufi.ro rd.::rrufi ,:

" u Aqw ' t u , A ,nnnTUQlUAtutauutyl 114 Lrno{nnTTyoufl ainu nndT't.lTyljt J

ay T'r5l alnlTqrT? a d0L14 tuu€t?t'.J LlJr{ Ld n1:}] d?ut? 3.111 0.td]ilTr*{uA y t- ,,i q

tl"l 0L A.3nUttfi y1J:11111:'l3lnl:laTqlO0Trl]fu LUl'SSlfnlTttnU

nrrffi o.t uaunrrfiailurl:vRrinrr.r d.::rrfi cnr:ao$urollo\:

^qlru 1 u.tlult$n1T r[aunl:il5il:J:.:15 nr:drllTilv'lur]-l rr]JrJq9t-

dr1 d.:uoinr:riruToufi qnrrt#ron{u rdoaonrrunmmolu:

'v 6, v

tr6vLl.^'t3.Jn]:Lt9l.:',lru Lllufluda A6 a V ,i ____ A, - \,1 t4rilv

n'tT14t;0.:utlju[t0u t'1J1,1u.t110,: IMI,' q.]16uta L}1U to Ll{d

' 6 6'A- ddilnJltra??tay9t rrautuljt.t nFt.3tljul1go rau11dlu14u.na.3

!q

1nnfl tflTBqnQ€lT'lU']lQlnnl:ylt5l8.l Bad Governance tr4?0rd

v, - v Y-na rnLturtialo.: rlluuuu{frrJnJ141 drvSrl:vrveitru nr:

du

- V , -loY a, AA. a, u q, q

v\r G]rurnn Lfl rlTv{tr6110uuLlJud.:il41t!ut16v910.: Lyo1l3.Jdu lad

j v'q,, e A , uq,r o { til Lsl:v ldufr qvfl olj duo{ o?1}] d'oinrfl o': IvrF rvirriu

16, ; . a r , - Aoa,ruqtr!unlToIruLnl:11,,!an0:Jn5ta til:lvnn tnil:vtT:fi140tllu!d

^\4q^bluratT O.:1 A{OU L1'1 U LU{]fl Ay9''l 0\::'13..] tt:':T'l}..] LA1lUdTl.tllU}.J]Qln

ir n qr un r r u a N 5l ua v n r rfi dr uir H r a rr n dr u'iufr.r o il o si r'rdc

i o v , - AoaaTia.: $.t0rTTStnntnL:yslTQrono{ayt'teiuuSyuytlattl:

^ l. le"3 , v d ,na!n'rnqsto5{u Lr,ldun.: rray:JryLyd Lrufl qydrr.Jnnuaolntu

- vfi c .1.i" -Qrn?rurylr0r IMF Loturlanl0rT? d.ll1dtoiluontyuoatn,^ AA C, v Aa A

nI5n1 nnfl O 0Ayt!UnIT?l':Tlnql?nl:1,J qJlU'111 U.tuUd]l,liLj!r d

- V Qva u dd.: o:. [Yl U t14 r1]1"d.: O].J rdn U:n tv'l

q i v , - io q

tilnt?ylll]:yt11€{uw]ona Lnuiy5tTQllo 14u111.1 Lu

y 6 { Xq, - ^ & , *

n1:n dnl%nl:0{Fl:.1U Lll n dLl\n n1"lUd tqlTl*onAttnyfi.3O}..l11s!dAa^Y6l^

tdn uTn ll,i 91 .: to a.J o.: 91 0,: 3.1 nt::'l 8.Jf n nqtn ou lil{t a 0 L't.li , - v - A^.

8.t141€ftntv! atlN hfl nouttnyl,']G?rutnn Ln!:ys]:qr o d114:1J

- V - vr.l 6l - sadlor Lvr s ild{nr:fi qiluravrno to lrr oou Lutrql a r Lao'rrslvsll u

ufinnr: unvolar drdryn o':nt:fi na'lnrJ:vtrigfi 6 uavfi nrr

' q -q Y ' -ao:'r3.J u:.::1'J Lqflu Lunr:zudnfruuavir:.rair.:natn:J:vtr55ff 6

u"rY6l ^rvfi.:fiu 1n r'lr rfr rfr enr or:: erfitl:vt rru luttfr o.:a o{14u

qv " u .l a , a AQg.q - j "V,:.r 114 0't t:. d I onj t%n'1 €'nu1!1 v roLu Lll,1l I Lato tau

"1"1 0u1 LlJ

einr:cirufiunuo drrnnfrot tl ilvnt:fr audir.:nnlnrl:vtritd

7 " " - .:sr6 ffeyrlnr:|5lruhufrexrul'1 s]firff e urir ra 1u rondrrll:ynorlnr?frN;luldrun{ruFrruvnr:}.1n1:1,,,1$}lut ntltflTl$qta rrnvd{fr}r Lt14

i ^ -v I - ) -6or irqnro;rsgflqtyufiLnr:l5luhufiF?rur'1 qfiLrfr s iuviffi z fiurrqll z54o rA r.io.:rl{naneourru6ulfiuiqo{ qludnr:firrfiurin

l^rnrqr n?rrvrl\Y

o: f:rnrr orf rfidfl z5ao "inq6vrr.:rrt:r4jfla:a6firrnv:Jqqfu" Swasmswsfia r:r4rou-R.:v.ro:.r: vfir 5

AoY o Aia ou - A11 0 U1.r8.r FtltelUe.tl UyAtnn LrayS.llaq uil8.Jtnn'tlntT!31J:Ji.314:0

r-1fr ;rJ:vu:rtnr:'hiarrr:noir rfiu,:ruo sjr{fi :l:yfir6nrw uay

ljlyfilii'hn0u1.t11 r:t ro un0LillJst Lyt'tuu

X"aoa"3u0 ll a 1 n 11 Q y fl 0.t 8.t n tTo 1 tuu.:tuo'tuu a u l.: aTta,: ttn y

,i r .l ^ (; "qa tuo.t Lo u L:ilatnn tTl tftTlyy tv! aul019tau?'t d114T1Jd.lO3.J

v - q , i^ , v , - iotmU nl5y!$Nill LilffluaL:Un?l "nn LnliUtllsy0' flt8.tO'IN

yNr uf,tnad rijufi uorilo rir.rn{r.:tledqvLy}.t'ryds.Jfi!fi{o$.tY. ,,y d q 6l q vr" a Y V, v

114 Uil tnUA U 11,'l U.: LO LUil al:tuljrvryl€f Loot ruunnoy LT l1l rLn?

v A I q g i-V ' 6 a | 4 y Au Ot, 6l

:_J1i 8.tfl?U tOlJt.:yt U{ L}.tfl 3.JU5ilt }.ld',tu Loljt.:yla0,:ttn tl lorv A ' v j q'^ljl.tllo',lT:?'.tTllhoti'a! $nyo?Tol|uunlT0ut.t t:tl,'t0 L14tno

v ,q a ,^vaq 6l q

nT:uo}lTu tll] La tLavnaLnronu Luff.:olJ

,9at0fld1541.94{

Ammar Siamwalla. 1997. Can a DevelopingDemocracy Manage its Macroeconomy? TheCase of Thailand. Paper prepared for J.

Douglas Gibson Lecture, delivered at theSchool of Policy Studies, Queen's University,Kingston, Ontario, Canada, October 15.

Purchase, Bryne, and Ronald Hirshorn. 1994.Searching for Good Governance. I(ingston:School of Policy Studies, Queen's University.

LTNDP. 1995. Governance and Sustainable HumanDevelopment: A Discussion Paper. New York:Management Development and GovernanceDivision, LINDP.

1997. Governance for Sustainable HumanDevelopment, a IJNDP Policy Document, as ofJanuary. http : //megnet.undp. org/pol icyi

VanSant, Ierry. 1996. Governance as Stewardsship:Decentralization and Sustainable HumanDevelopment, a Review of Experience by theStaff of Research Triancles lnstitute, a paperprepared for the Asis Miniraila Conference onGovemance for Sustainable Growth andEquitiy: A Visison for the 2lst Century,18-21November. Parkistan.

World Bank. 1994. Governance; the World Bank'sExperience. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

.u A a 6 aav d I':luilnailLru.lott9tn.t LoLailral,'l ' nJnLnwDJfrO iufi 16

nuuTuu 2540 uu1 2 ttaY 74.

ilrnn omrfinfl. zs+0. 'inq6mr,rro:ugfiq : a6aruavflqqfiu'

:lylollstfirflB SwqeF..'svfrffq nrniltnN-R.:u1ail:

yrir q- to.

drfin.:ruo rxyn:::.J nr:fisJlut n: rqf ft16fr a rrfi yfi.: o:.t Lryi.:{r 6 2s40.

ffoyrnr:l5ruhuvvqrllr"r {xl!fi s yh ts "lu lonar:

lrynarnr:firrur 6a.: inqn lo:rEqfi q'lilErnLnr:il5ruzuu

frsrurr arilfi s 5uv1# 7 frurro:l 2540 il lio.:r-tr.:nan9G.66v6Ft0urlu:rurqur0a: FIx{untTott,}'u?l:a1^lRlqt n?{ty]y,l.1.

oe.]Tr y{.: drl^t S. zS+0. fi:rNYS :J:y{ror uaya{rinrfr,:os.J.

rondlr:J:yno!ntild?ut ru -or{rn.rn:nfu r,1riy trfiu.

Good governunce is key to restoring market conlidence

"... We get the impression that the government has so far been willing to actquickly and consistently ntostly on reform measures that do not require bigsacrifices on the part of its own rank and fle members and the political elite.However, the inrplementation of the programmes to develop goctd governance-bureaucratic reform, the removal of crony capitalism and the transparency andaccountabiliQ of the state budget-*-ha,s remained at a snail's pace.

The governtnent ctnd others in the political elite seem not to have fullyrealised that good governance is a key component ofthe economic fundamentalsand is crucial for restoring market confidence. Good governance also becomesmore urgent during this lrial period for naintaining the spirit of solidarity andoptimism among those who will suffer mo,st frorn the painful adjustments. "

qltt The Jakarta Post

drlfi,:'fu The Nation, l,lovember 15, 1997, p. A4

..:j tlj l{ t.{ .-rJ t_-1-{ arJ i{ .._{ .:lj f,,rj {13 alj {j{ i{ 3J {-:j {}.j t.i_i t,r*