44
Page - 1 GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION NOTIFICATI0N No:RCT162011862(11)EX DATE:09022018 1. The result of the Combined Competitive Examination (Main) for the Recruitment to the posts of Gujarat Accounts Service, Class‐II & Gujarat Commercial Tax Service, Class‐ II (Advertisement No. 37/2016‐17) held on 2, 8 & 9 July, 2017 and personal interview test held during 1 st January, 2018 to 25 th January, 2018 is hereby declared as per AnnexureI 2. The above result is declared taking into consideration the provisions of the Gujarat Accounts Service, Class‐II & Gujarat Commercial Tax Service, Class‐ II Combined Competitive Examination Rules, 2013 (as amended from time to time) and other relevant applicable criteria, which are as under :‐ (A) As per Provisions of the Rule‐16 , the merit has been determined on the basis of the aggregate marks finally (total marks) awarded to the candidates in the Main Examination (written) and interview test. (B) As per Provisions of the Rule18, no Waiting List is prepared by the Commission. (C) As per Provisions of the Rule8(2)(b), “where a candidate has not given preference for any post, or has given preference only for one post, and the post for which preference is not available to accommodate him as per his preference, such candidate is considered for appointment to other post after the process of appointment of the other candidates, who have given preferences for both the posts, is completed.” (D) As per provision of the Rule17, the candidate, who fails to attend the Viva‐Voce, is not considered eligible for selection. 3. The result has been prepared taking into consideration the Judgement of the Honourable Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided on 18‐07‐2007, Public Service Commission, Uttaranchal V/s. Mamta Bist & Others, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 5987 of 2007, with Civil Appeal No.5982 of

GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Page - 1

GUJARATPUBLICSERVICECOMMISSION

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

1. The result of the Combined Competitive Examination (Main) for the

Recruitment to the posts of Gujarat Accounts Service, Class‐II & Gujarat

CommercialTaxService,Class‐II(AdvertisementNo.37/2016‐17)heldon2,8

&9July,2017andpersonalinterviewtestheldduring1stJanuary,2018to25th

January,2018isherebydeclaredasperAnnexure‐I

2. The above result is declared taking into consideration the provisions of the

Gujarat Accounts Service, Class‐II & Gujarat Commercial Tax Service, Class‐ II

Combined Competitive Examination Rules, 2013 (as amended from time to

time)andotherrelevantapplicablecriteria,whichareasunder:‐

(A) AsperProvisionsoftheRule‐16,themerithasbeendeterminedonthe

basis of the aggregate marks finally (total marks) awarded to the

candidatesintheMainExamination(written)andinterviewtest.

(B) As per Provisions of the Rule‐18, noWaiting List is prepared by the

Commission.

(C) AsperProvisionsoftheRule‐8(2)(b),“whereacandidatehasnotgiven

preference foranypost, orhasgivenpreferenceonly foronepost, and

thepostforwhichpreferenceisnotavailabletoaccommodatehimasper

his preference, such candidate is considered for appointment to other

postaftertheprocessofappointmentoftheothercandidates,whohave

givenpreferencesforboththeposts,iscompleted.”

(D) Asper provisionof theRule‐17, the candidate,who fails to attend the

Viva‐Voce,isnotconsideredeligibleforselection.

3. Theresulthasbeenpreparedtaking intoconsiderationthe Judgementof the

HonourableSupremeCourt,inthecaseofRajeshKumarDariaV/s.Rajasthan

Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007

decidedon18‐07‐2007, PublicServiceCommission,UttaranchalV/s.Mamta

Bist&Others, ‐CivilAppealNos.5987of2007,withCivilAppealNo.5982of

Page 2: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐2

2007 decided on 03‐06‐2010 and Judgement of the Honourable Supreme

Court in the case of Union of India versus Ramesh Ram and others (Civil

AppealNo.4310‐4311of2010)[ArisingoutofSLP(C)Nos.13571‐72of2008]

decidedon07‐05‐2010andGovernmentcircular,G.A.D.No.PVS‐1099‐MM‐l3‐

G4dated29‐01‐2000andPVS‐102003‐900‐G4,dated23‐07‐2004.

Accordingly, the followingreservedcategory31candidates(MRC),whohave

got either equal ormore than the Cut Off Marks fixed for General category

candidatesandhavenotavailedofanyrelaxation inage,qualifyingstandard

e.t.c. are to be recommended against unreserved posts as per Government

circular, GAD No. PVS‐1099‐MM‐13‐G4 dated 29‐1‐2000 and PVS‐2010‐03‐

900‐G4,dated23/07/2004.

1. TheSEBCcandidatesatMeritNos.09,12,16,19,21,30,34,44,48,50,51,

55,63,69,91and117=total‐16.

2. TheSEBCFemalecandidatesatMeritNos.17,41,56,57,99,102,113,174

and189=total‐09.

3. TheS.C.candidatesatMeritNos.31,43,74,83and104=total‐05.

4. TheS.C.FemalecandidateatMeritNo.81=total‐01.

4. The following31candidates, thoughhavesecuredtheirplace in themeritof

general category, but due to better preference available to them, they are

selected against the posts reserved for their respective categories in

accordancewiththeJudgementoftheHonourableSupremeCourtinthecase

ofUnionofIndiaversusRameshRamandothers(CivilAppealNo.4310‐4311

of2010)[ArisingoutofSLP(C)Nos.13571‐72of2008].

1. TheSEBCcandidatesatMeritNos.70,79,80,84,86,90,94,96,108,115,

120,125,128,133,141,144,147and149=total‐18.

2. The SEBCFemale candidates atMeritNos. 121, 142, 165, 171, 173, 178

and183=total‐07.

3. TheS.C.candidatesatMeritNos.89,123,124,126,145and150=total‐06.

5. PD (Physically Disabled) Candidates have been considered under their

respectivecategoryafterrelaxingupto10%marksoftheQualifyingStandard

fixed for their respectivecategory.ThePHcandidateswhohaveattained the

relaxedqualifyingstandardforthepostwithinthecategoryarere‐arrangedin

theorderofmeritofdisabledcategory.While considering forapost, special

reference has beenmade to the preference of posts given by the candidate,

Page 3: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐3

applicable disability Level & Type of disability for the post and cadre‐wise

posts reserved for PD candidates as provided in the Recruitment

Advertisement. All such candidates are accommodated against the reserved

postsfordisabledcandidates,intheirrespectivecategories.

While going through the process of selection, total 07 Disabled candidates

wereavailableforconsiderationforselection,afterrelaxingupto10%marks

oftheCutoffMarksfixedfortheirrespectivecategories.TheGeneralcategory

candidatesatRankNos. 28,158,195,205,241, SEBCcategorycandidateat

Rank No. 243 and S.T. category Female candidate at Rank No. 281, are

consideredasdisabledcandidates, after relaxingupto10%marksof theCut

OffMarksfixedfortheirrespectivecategories.

(a) WhileconsideringcadrewiseallocationofC.T.O.cadrepoststoGeneral‐

DisabledMale candidates, all the47C.T.O. cadrepostsofGeneralMale

categoryareallocated,inorderofmeritandtheCutOffMarksforC.T.O.

cadre posts of General category is derived, which is 449 marks. Then

aftersubtracting10%MarksfromtheCutOffMarksforC.T.O.cadre,the

CutOffMarksforC.T.O.cadrefortheDisabledcandidates isderivedi.e.

404 Marks (i.e. 449‐45= 404 Marks). The General‐Disabled Male

candidateatRankNo.28hasobtainedtotal472MarksandtheGeneral‐

DisabledMalecandidateatRankNo.195hasobtained total421Marks

i.e. above 404 Marks and hence, they have been allocated/

accommodatedintheC.T.O.cadreposts(i.e.theirfirstpreferences).

(b) TheGeneral‐DisabledMalecandidateatRankNo.241hasobtainedtotal

389Marks i.e. belowCutOffMarks forC.T.O. cadre i.e. 404Marks and

hence,hehasbeenallocated/accommodated in theA.O.cadrepost (his

secondpreference).

(c) While considering cadrewise allocationofA.O. cadreposts toGeneral‐

Disabled Male candidates, all the 52 A.O. cadre posts of General Male

categoryareallocated, inorderofmerit and theCutOffMarks forA.O.

cadre posts of General category is derived, which is 429 marks. Then

aftersubtracting10%Marks fromtheCutOffMarks forA.O.cadre, the

CutOffMarksforC.T.O.cadrefortheDisabledcandidates isderivedi.e.

386Marks (429‐43=386Marks).TheGeneral‐DisabledMale candidate

Page 4: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐4

atRankNo.158hasobtainedtotal428MarksandtheGeneral‐Disabled

Male candidate at Rank No. 205 has obtained total 418.25 Marks i.e.

above386Marksandhence,theyhavebeenallocated/accommodatedin

theA.O.cadreposts(i.e.theirfirstpreferences).

(d) While considering cadre wise allocation of C.T.O. cadre post to SEBC‐

Disabled Male candidate, all the 23 C.T.O. cadre posts of SEBC Male

categoryareallocated,inorderofmeritandtheCutOffMarksforC.T.O.

cadrepostsofSEBCcategoryisderived,whichis426marks.Thenafter

subtracting10%Marks fromtheCutOffMarks forC.T.O.cadre, theCut

OffMarksforC.T.O.cadrefortheDisabledcandidatesisderivedi.e.383

Marks (426‐42.6=383.4 Marks). The SEBC‐Disabled Male candidate at

RankNo.243hasobtainedtotal378.5i.e.belowCutOffMarksforC.T.O.

cadrei.e.383Marksandhence,hehasbeenallocated/accommodatedin

the A.O. cadre post (i.e. his second preference) reserved for SEBC

category.

(e) Similarly,WhileconsideringcadrewiseallocationofC.T.O.cadrepoststo

S.T.‐Disabled Female candidates, all the 06 C.T.O. cadre posts of S.T.

Femalecategoryareallocated,inorderofmeritandtheCutOffMarksfor

C.T.O.cadrepostisderived,whichis333.5Marks.Thenaftersubtracting

10%MarksfromtheCutOffMarksforC.T.O.cadre,theCutOffMarksfor

C.T.O. cadre for the S.T. Female Disabled candidate is derived i.e. 300

Marks(333.5‐33.35=300.15Marks).TheS.T.‐FemaleDisabledcandidate

atRankNo. 281 hasobtained total 317.75Marks i.e. above300Marks

and hence, she has been allocated/ accommodated in the C.T.O. cadre

post(i.e.herfirstpreference)reservedforS.T.Femalecategory.

6. TheCommissionregrets its inability torecommendanycandidate for the01

post reserved for Ex‐serviceman, as no candidate was available for the

interview.

7. In caseof equalmarks, themeritwasassigned taking into consideration the

dateofbirth(i.e.preferenceisgiventotheelder).

8. With regard to women reservation as provided for in the Government

Notification GAD No. GS/97‐13‐CRR/1096/2213/G‐2, dated 9th April, 1997

Page 5: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐5

andGADCircularNo.CRR/1096/2213/G‐2,dated22ndMay,1997,91women

candidates (General‐47, SEBC‐25, S.C.‐06 and S.T.‐13) are required to be

selected.Asagainst this,47womencandidatesofGeneralcategory(i.e.Rank

Nos.01,02,06,10,13,14,17,20,24,29,36,40,41,42,52,53,56,57,59,65,

68,72,73,81,93,99,100,102,107,113,131,135,146,153,159,161,162,

163,164,167,174,176,177,180,184,185and189),25womencandidatesof

SEBCcategory(i.e.RankNos.121,142,165,171,173,178,183,192,201,212,

213,215,216,217,219,220,223,224,227,229,230,231,232,233and235),

06womencandidatesofS.C.category(i.e.RankNos.221,228,234,236,239

and240),13womencandidatesofS.T.category(i.e.RankNos.237,250,252,

253,257,262,263,266,268,272,276,280,281‐Dis.), thus,total 91women

candidateshavebeenselected.

NOTE:‐

1. Thefollowingreservedcategory31candidates(MRC),whohavegoteither

equalormorethantheCutOffMarksfixedforGeneralcategorycandidates

andhavenotavailedofanyrelaxationinage,qualifyingstandarde.t.c.are

toberecommendedagainstunreservedpostsasperGovernmentcircular,

GADNo.PVS‐1099‐MM‐13‐G4dated29‐1‐2000andPVS‐2010‐03‐900‐G4,

dated23/07/2004.

a. TheSEBCcandidatesatMeritNos.09,12,16,19,21,30,34,44,48,

50,51,55,63,69,91and117=total‐16.

b. TheSEBCFemalecandidatesatMeritNos.17,41,56,57,99,102,

113,174and189=total‐09.

c. TheS.C.candidatesatMeritNos.31,43,74,83and104=total‐05.

d. TheS.C.FemalecandidateatMeritNo.81=total‐01.

2. Thefollowing31candidates,thoughhavesecuredtheirplaceinthemerit

ofgeneralcategory,butduetobetterpreferenceavailabletothem,theyare

selected against the posts reserved for their respective categories in

accordancewith the Judgement of theHonourable Supreme Court in the

case of Union of India versus Ramesh Ram and others (Civil Appeal No.

4310‐4311of2010)[ArisingoutofSLP(C)Nos.13571‐72of2008].

a. TheSEBCcandidatesatMeritNos.70,79,80,84,86,90,94,96,108,

115,120,125,128,133,141,144,147and149=total‐18.

b. TheSEBCFemalecandidatesatMeritNos.121,142,165,171,173,

178and183=total‐07.

Page 6: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐6

c. TheS.C. candidatesatMeritNos.89,123,124,126,145and150=

total‐06.

3. Incaseofequalmarks,themeritisassignedtakingintoconsiderationthe

dateofbirth(i.e.preferenceisgiventotheelder).

4. TheCommissionregrets its inability torecommendanycandidate forthe

01postreservedforEx‐serviceman,asnocandidatewasavailableforthe

interview.

5. TheMarkStatementsofVivaVoceofthecandidates,bearingE.No.908to

E.No.915,whowerecalled for interviewconditionally,arekept insealed

cover, in viewof theHonourableHigh Court’s order dated 23rd January,

2018,inS.C.A.Nos.22903/2017,22981/2017,23220/2017,23372/2017,

23402/2017and1297/2018.

6. The mere success in the examination shall not confer any right to

appointment and no candidate shall be appointed to the post unless the

Government is satisfied, after such inquiries as may be considered

necessary that the candidate is suitable in all respect for appointment to

thepost.

7. Theorderofpreferenceforthepostsindicatedbythecandidateshallnot

conferanyrighttohimforappointmenttosuchposts.Havingregardtothe

rank in the order of merit and the number of posts available, the

preference given by the candidate shall be considered and appropriately

allotmentwillbedecidedbytheGovernmentatthetimeofappointment.

8. Marks of the candidates, appeared formain examination, has beenmade

onlineforviewingtotheconcernedcandidateonlineonthe web‐link tobe published on the web‐site of the Commission from 15th February,

2018,12pmonwardsupto15days

9. Theaboveresult is subject torevisionafterrecheckingofmarksof those

candidates who apply for rechecking of marks of the Main Written

Examination,within30days from thedateof theNotification, asper the

Rule 20 (1) of the Gujarat Accounts Services, Class‐II and the Gujarat

Page 7: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐7

Commercial Tax Services, Class‐II, Combined Competitive Examination

Rules2013andamendmentsmadethereafterfromtimetotime.

10. Candidates appeared in the Main Written Examination and desire for

recheckingofmarks,arerequested tosendtheirapplicationalongwith

requisite information and fees as mentioned in the Advertisement for

recheckingofmarkswithin30daysfromthedateofdeclarationofthis

resultaspertheRule20(1)ofthetheGujaratAccountsServices,Class‐II

and theGujarat Commercial Tax Services, Class‐II CombinedCompetitive

ExaminationRules,2013

11. Candidates appeared in the Main Written Examination and desire to

receiveMark‐sheet ofMain Examination, are requested to send their

applicationalongwithrequisiteinformationandfeesasmentionedinthe

Advertisement within 15 days from the date of declaration of this

result.

12. Applications received beyond the above time limit shall not be

considered.

13. As decided by the Commission, candidates shall apply with fees of

Rs.100/‐perpapertoreceivecopyoftheirwrittenanswersheets.The

paymentshouldbemade throughpostofficeonlybydownloadingpost

office challan from https://gpsc‐ojas.gujarat.gov.in to receive digital

copy of answer sheet on the registered e‐mail of the candidate. Physical

copyofanswersheetshallbemadeavailableontheregisteredaddressof

thecandidatethroughspeed‐postfollowingtheabove‐saidprocedurewith

addition of applicable charge Rs.50/‐ as speed‐post charge. This system

will commence from 19‐02‐2018. Candidates are advised to visit

Commission’s website https://gpsc‐ojas.gujarat.gov.in for further

instructionsandguidelinestimetotime.

14. This result is subject to the final decision in the S.C.A.Nos. 22903/2017,

22981/2017,23220/2017,23372/2017,23402/2017and1297/2018.

Page 8: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

NOTIFICATI0NNo:‐RCT‐162011‐862(11)‐EX,DATE:‐09‐02‐2018

Page‐8

15. The result is also available on Commission’s website:

https://gpsc.gujarat.gov.in; https://gpsc‐ojas.gujarat.gov.in, GPSC

mobileapplication:GPSC(Official)andonTwitter:@GPSC_OFFICIAL

(H.J.PAREKH)

Place:‐GANDHINAGAR SECRETARY

Date:‐09‐02‐2018 GUJARATPUBLICSERVICECOMMISSION

Page 9: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

QualifyingStandards(CutoffMarks):‐

1) GeneralMale

2) GeneralFemale

3) S&EBCMale

4) S&EBCFemale

5) S.C.Male

6) S.C.Female

7) S.T.Male

8) S.T.Female

9) Disabled

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

1 101002606 Kum.AvaniBharatkumarVasani EDI 72 Fem. 518.25 65 583.25 26‐Mar‐93 1 2 GF‐001 GF‐AO‐01

2 101025947 Kum.HeenabaJagdishsinhJadeja EVF 568 Fem. 465.50 66 531.50 28‐Jan‐94 2 1 GF‐002 GF‐CTO‐01

3 101038202 ShriShaileshBabubhaiPatel QFH 822 459.25 55 514.25 16‐Aug‐80 2 1 GM‐001 GM‐CTO‐01

4 101007229 ShriChiragkumarHasmukhlalRajde EWB 577 454.00 59 513.00 29‐Jul‐92 2 1 GM‐002 GM‐CTO‐02

5 101000839 ShriRohanBipinbhaiMehta EBI 30 445.75 50 495.75 24‐Jul‐96 2 1 GM‐003 GM‐CTO‐03

6 101000751 Kum.JahnaviKishorbhaiDubal EBG 23 Fem. 435.25 58 493.25 24‐Dec‐84 2 1 GF‐003 GF‐CTO‐02

7 101006520 ShriKuldipsinhBhupendrasinhGohil EGP 153 443.00 50 493.00 15‐Mar‐89 2 1 GM‐004 GM‐CTO‐04

8 101006153 ShriSharadbhaiJayantibhaiGajipara EDQ 144 434.25 58 492.25 12‐Mar‐93 2 1 GM‐005 GM‐CTO‐05

9 101006409 ShriKetanbhaiDashrathbhaiPrajapati EGG 149 SEBC 438.00 53 491.00 3‐Jan‐88 2 1 GM‐006 GM‐CTO‐06

322.75Marks

Gen‐M–389.00,SEBC‐M‐378.50&S.T.‐Fem.‐317.75(upto10%ofcutoffmarksineachcategoryisrelaxed)

422.25Marks

415.75Marks

398.25Marks

406.50Marks

389.25Marks

326.25Marks

429.00Marks

GUJARATPUBLICSERVICECOMMISSIONANNEXURE‐I(Part‐I)

Part‐I:‐ListofSuccessfulCandidatesforrecommendationforappointmenttotheGovernment.

Post:‐AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17

DateofInterview:1stJanuary,2018to25thJanuary,2018

Page 10: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 2

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

10 101018956 Kum.BhoomikaGirdharbhaiGevariya EOQ 392 Fem. 442.50 48 490.50 12‐Nov‐94 1 2 GF‐004 GF‐AO‐02

11 101025913 ShriPraveensinghDalpatsinghJaitawat EVX 567 432.00 58 490.00 12‐Sep‐88 2 1 GM‐007 GM‐CTO‐07

12 101030823 ShriAnkitkumarSureshbhaiDhobi EZX 680 SEBC 437.50 50 487.50 7‐Apr‐89 2 1 GM‐008 GM‐CTO‐08

13 101024832 Kum.HimadriJaydevbhaiBhatt ETK 532 Fem. 434.75 52 486.75 13‐Jul‐90 2 1 GF‐005 GF‐CTO‐03

14 101006269 Kum.ViralkumariRameshchandraMakadia EFY 146 Fem. 431.25 55 486.25 19‐Jan‐78 2 1 GF‐006 GF‐CTO‐04

15 101007220 ShriAksharPrakashchandraVyas EFS 162 441.00 45 486.00 3‐Dec‐95 2 1 GM‐009 GM‐CTO‐09

16 101011901 ShriRajendrasinhBalvantsinhDodia EZQ 669 SEBC 428.25 57 485.25 19‐Oct‐82 2 1 GM‐010 GM‐CTO‐10

17 101003591 Kum.PujaHareshbhaiVaja EFM 91 Fem. SEBC 449.75 35 484.75 31‐May‐93 2 1 GF‐007 GF‐CTO‐05

18 101000510 ShriSandipkumarGovindlalBarot EOZ 361 419.00 62 481.00 22‐Jan‐88 2 1 GM‐011 GM‐CTO‐11

19 101032442 ShriJanakMerubhaiOdedra EZK 710 SEBC 408.00 70 478.00 29‐Sep‐90 2 1 GM‐012 GM‐CTO‐12

20 101022678 Kum.DeepaHasmukhbhaiKotak ESE 490 Fem. 440.50 37 477.50 2‐Nov‐87 2 1 GF‐008 GF‐CTO‐06

21 101029003 ShriVishnubhaiHirabhaiDesai EYE 625 SEBC 429.00 48 477.00 8‐Aug‐90 2 1 GM‐013 GM‐CTO‐13

22 101022147 ShriYuvrajsinhAnirudhsinhGohil ESL 476 423.75 53 476.75 29‐Jun‐90 2 1 GM‐014 GM‐CTO‐14

23 101040925 ShriRajnikantVinubhaiMania QHJ 878 425.50 50 475.50 19‐Jun‐90 2 1 GM‐015 GM‐CTO‐15

24 101006166 Kum.PinalArvindkumarThaker EGZ 145 Fem. 426.50 48 474.50 31‐Aug‐92 1 2 GF‐009 GF‐AO‐03

25 101026283 ShriBrijPushkerbhaiBhatt EVV 572 428.00 46 474.00 24‐Apr‐93 1 2 GM‐016 GM‐AO‐01

26 101013918 ShriHrushikeshDave ELM 284 411.75 62 473.75 5‐Nov‐85 2 1 GM‐017 GM‐CTO‐16

27 101008303 ShriYuvrajsinhPravinsinhJadeja EFU 187 418.75 54 472.75 23‐Aug‐93 2 1 GM‐018 GM‐CTO‐17

28 101003864 ShriKuvarsinhBharatsinhGohil ETD 473 Disabled 422.50 50 472.50 9‐Jul‐83 2 1 GM‐019 GM‐CTO‐18

29 101025233 Kum.KarishmabanuRasidkhanPathan EVE 555 Fem. 439.75 32 471.75 3‐Jun‐92 1 2 GF‐010 GF‐AO‐04

30 101003428 ShriBharatbhaiLimbabhaiJiyad EDC 86 SEBC 415.75 54 469.75 4‐Jul‐93 2 1 GM‐020 GM‐CTO‐19

31 101031170 ShriYogeshkumarKanjibhaiMaru EZP 686 S.C. 421.75 48 469.75 2‐Jul‐94 2 1 GM‐021 GM‐CTO‐20

32 101017380 ShriShahrukhkhanNajirahemadkhanPathan ELX 358 423.75 45 468.75 17‐Oct‐94 2 1 GM‐022 GM‐CTO‐21

33 101001180 ShriSanjaykumarKhushalbhaiThummar EOX 365 414.50 54 468.50 25‐Jan‐82 2 1 GM‐023 GM‐CTO‐22

34 101027968 ShriVipulBhanjibhaiPrajapati EWW 607 SEBC 426.25 42 468.25 20‐Jun‐82 2 1 GM‐024 GM‐CTO‐23

35 101001748 ShriPareshkumarVasantlalBarva ECD 53 431.00 37 468.00 10‐Jun‐92 2 1 GM‐025 GM‐CTO‐24

36 101033352 Kum.ArchanabenAshokkumarDube QCA 736 Fem. 417.75 50 467.75 28‐Jun‐88 2 1 GF‐011 GF‐CTO‐07

37 101017318 ShriRavirajsinhPravinsinhVaghela EMM 356 422.50 45 467.50 11‐Aug‐88 2 1 GM‐026 GM‐CTO‐25

Page 11: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 3

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

38 101039503 ShriSanjaykumarKhodabhaiPatel QFL 846 405.50 62 467.50 30‐Jul‐89 2 1 GM‐027 GM‐CTO‐26

39 101037159 ShriJigneshLabhubhaiVaghani QEH 791 438.75 28 466.75 6‐Jun‐93 2 1 GM‐028 GM‐CTO‐27

40 101001811 Kum.AvanibenPrashantbhaiJoshi ECV 56 Fem. 419.50 47 466.50 16‐Mar‐94 1 2 GF‐012 GF‐AO‐05

41 101019909 Kum.PoojabenRasikbhaiPrajapati EPQ 408 Fem. SEBC 406.25 60 466.25 5‐Feb‐93 2 1 GF‐013 GF‐CTO‐08

42 101016172 Smt.BijalJatinBhavsar EMS 337 Fem. 427.25 38 465.25 8‐Jul‐80 2 1 GF‐014 GF‐CTO‐09

43 101003956 ShriSwamanNeeravbhaiPatel EEJ 103 S.C. 424.75 40 464.75 19‐Aug‐89 2 1 GM‐029 GM‐CTO‐28

44 101003548 ShriHiteshkumarNaranbhaiDangar ECT 90 SEBC 414.50 50 464.50 12‐Oct‐82 2 1 GM‐030 GM‐CTO‐29

45 101000306 ShriMahipalsinhDolatsinhParmar EAO 9 419.00 45 464.00 31‐May‐90 2 1 GM‐031 GM‐CTO‐30

46 101022227 ShriMaheshkumarBalkrushnaPandit ESM 478 411.25 52 463.25 17‐Sep‐86 2 1 GM‐032 GM‐CTO‐31

47 101001985 ShriNikunjkumarGhanshyambhaiThakkar ERD 417 413.25 50 463.25 5‐Jul‐90 2 1 GM‐033 GM‐CTO‐32

48 101007023 ShriYograjsinhRajendrasinhBhambhala EUS 545 SEBC 411.75 50 461.75 11‐Aug‐89 2 1 GM‐034 GM‐CTO‐33

49 101018133 ShriAksharNayanbhaiShah EOH 378 407.00 54 461.00 12‐Sep‐95 2 1 GM‐035 GM‐CTO‐34

50 101027241 ShriGanpatbhaiRamsangbhaiSolanki EWC 596 SEBC 403.75 57 460.75 29‐Oct‐87 2 1 GM‐036 GM‐CTO‐35

51 101003437 ShriShaileshVallabhbhaiKalsariya ECE 87 SEBC 430.00 30 460.00 15‐Feb‐90 2 1 GM‐037 GM‐CTO‐36

52 101003471 Kum.NikitaRatilalPatolia EDE 89 Fem. 415.00 45 460.00 10‐Oct‐94 2 1 GF‐015 GF‐CTO‐10

53 101002543 Kum.ParvatibenOmkarSharma EDD 71 Fem. 422.75 37 459.75 1‐Jun‐82 2 1 GF‐016 GF‐CTO‐11

54 101014683 ShriBhavinAxaykumarBhatt EJW 299 407.00 52 459.00 31‐May‐80 2 1 GM‐038 GM‐CTO‐37

55 101015189 ShriNikunjMahendrabhaiPrajapati QFJ 815 SEBC 423.50 35 458.50 22‐Jul‐85 2 1 GM‐039 GM‐CTO‐38

56 101006916 Kum.DrashtiVinayPrajapati EHE 158 Fem. SEBC 410.25 48 458.25 11‐Jan‐92 2 1 GF‐017 GF‐CTO‐12

57 101000153 Kum.InabenJagubhaiVakatar EAP 5 Fem. SEBC 411.25 47 458.25 25‐Nov‐93 2 1 GF‐018 GF‐CTO‐13

58 101032362 ShriChiragkumarLallubhaiPatel QBC 709 419.50 38 457.50 15‐Jul‐90 2 1 GM‐040 GM‐CTO‐39

59 101009218 Kum.DhrutibenVijaykumarSoni EHT 213 Fem. 404.50 52 456.50 17‐Aug‐91 2 1 GF‐019 GF‐CTO‐14

60 101038810 ShriDharmeshMansukhbhaiLakhani QFE 831 410.25 45 455.25 4‐Feb‐89 2 1 GM‐041 GM‐CTO‐40

61 101000242 ShriBhaveshkumarVikrambhaiPatel EAC 7 395.50 59 454.50 7‐Aug‐89 2 1 GM‐042 GM‐CTO‐41

62 101019209 ShriRohitPrabhudasLalwani EPJ 397 395.75 58 453.75 23‐Aug‐86 1 2 GM‐043 GM‐AO‐02

63 101020182 ShriParimalSunilkumarRana ERU 423 SEBC 415.00 38 453.00 7‐Jun‐87 2 1 GM‐044 GM‐CTO‐42

64 101031890 ShriBrijrajsinhHardevsinhChavada QBH 703 401.00 52 453.00 20‐Jul‐89 2 1 GM‐045 GM‐CTO‐43

65 101019641 Kum.KeyuriHarsukhlalTrivedi EOF 405 Fem. 407.75 45 452.75 23‐Jun‐90 1 2 GF‐020 GF‐AO‐06

Page 12: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 4

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

66 101025153 ShriKrushnkumarsinhMahavirsinhGohil EVN 552 417.25 35 452.25 22‐Feb‐94 2 1 GM‐046 GM‐CTO‐44

67 101014223 ShriBrijeshkumarBharatbhaiUpadhyay QEG 779 386.00 65 451.00 21‐Mar‐83 2 1 GM‐047 GM‐CTO‐45

68 101004497 Kum.NaimishaRajeshkumarBhatt EEZ 118 Fem. 410.25 40 450.25 1‐Apr‐94 2 1 GF‐021 GF‐CTO‐15

69 101016665 ShriBhupatbhaiRambhaiDangar EMP 343 SEBC 419.00 30 449.00 13‐Jul‐84 2 1 GM‐048 GM‐CTO‐46

70 101011019 ShriVijaykumarGordhanbhaiBharvad EXU 617 SEBC 399.00 50 449.00 6‐Mar‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐01 SEBCM‐CTO‐01 Bet.Pref.‐01

71 101013026 ShriChetanChanabhaiSavaliya EKF 273 410.75 38 448.75 5‐Oct‐84 2 1 GM‐049 GM‐AO‐03

72 101024555 Kum.MoniAlkeshkumarUpadhyay EUL 523 Fem. 403.50 45 448.50 9‐Jan‐96 2 1 GF‐022 GF‐CTO‐16

73 101013964 Kum.SwetaShantilalMehta QEM 777 Fem. 388.25 60 448.25 10‐Mar‐86 1 2 GF‐023 GF‐AO‐07

74 101003611 ShriJaiminsinhGhanshyamsinhSolanki EEN 93 S.C. 415.00 33 448.00 19‐Aug‐94 1 2 GM‐050 GM‐AO‐04

75 101000771 ShriSagarChandrakantJoshi EBF 24 412.50 35 447.50 24‐Jul‐86 2 1 GM‐051 GM‐AO‐05

76 101001637 ShriChiragkumarKantilalPatel ECN 49 405.50 42 447.50 7‐Nov‐92 2 1 GM‐052 GM‐AO‐06

77 101010559 ShriJigneshkumarKirankumarSharma EHV 235 393.00 54 447.00 14‐Jun‐93 2 1 GM‐053 GM‐AO‐07

78 101019515 ShriMohammedsoyebGulamMustufaShaikh EPP 402 398.75 48 446.75 1‐Jun‐89 2 1 GM‐054 GM‐AO‐08

79 101008266 ShriAmaratbhaiMavjiMali EFR 186 SEBC 405.50 40 445.50 11‐Jul‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐02 SEBCM‐CTO‐02 Bet.Pref.‐02

80 101020400 ShriVikramDevarkhibhaiKanara EQE 429 SEBC 405.00 40 445.00 20‐Jan‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐03 SEBCM‐CTO‐03 Bet.Pref.‐03

81 101033751 Smt.YeshaNarendrabhaiSolanki QCB 740 Fem. S.C. 392.75 52 444.75 10‐Jun‐86 2 1 GF‐024 GF‐CTO‐17

82 101024356 ShriSandeepMukeshkumarRupella ETF 520 384.75 60 444.75 8‐Nov‐89 2 1 GM‐055 GM‐AO‐09

83 101007237 ShriDayanandKiritkumarParmar EGD 166 S.C. 403.25 40 443.25 24‐Sep‐83 1 2 GM‐056 GM‐AO‐10

84 101000638 ShriKalpeshkumarBachubhaiKatariya EAI 20 SEBC 403.25 40 443.25 14‐Jun‐94 2 1 SEBCM‐04 SEBCM‐CTO‐04 Bet.Pref.‐04

85 101000270 ShriDaxeshRameshbhaiPrajapati EBH 8 393.00 50 443.00 13‐Jan‐89 2 1 GM‐057 GM‐AO‐11

86 101029696 ShriGhanshyamTulsibhaiKesur EZE 651 SEBC 394.75 48 442.75 2‐Oct‐88 2 1 SEBCM‐05 SEBCM‐CTO‐05 Bet.Pref.‐05

87 101026764 ShriPradipManjibhaiMoradiya EVZ 587 400.75 42 442.75 3‐Sep‐89 2 1 GM‐058 GM‐AO‐12

88 101000776 ShriJayUmeshbhaiShah EBE 26 389.50 53 442.50 7‐May‐80 2 1 GM‐059 GM‐AO‐13

89 101001966 ShriJitendrakumarBhurabhaiParmar ECL 60 S.C. 382.50 60 442.50 24‐Dec‐83 2 1 SCM‐01 SCM‐CTO‐01 Bet.Pref.‐06

90 101014880 ShriMilanDilipbhaiChauhan EKG 302 SEBC 392.50 50 442.50 23‐Jun‐85 2 1 SEBCM‐06 SEBCM‐CTO‐06 Bet.Pref.‐07

91 101001321 ShriRavindraDayalbhaiLakum ECG 39 SEBC 389.50 53 442.50 28‐Nov‐89 1 2 GM‐060 GM‐AO‐14

92 101015930 ShriVijaykumarJaysukhbhaiSanghani ENQ 330 390.50 52 442.50 22‐Apr‐90 2 1 GM‐061 GM‐AO‐15

93 101002816 Kum.AlpakumariMansinhjiChavda ECM 77 Fem. 397.50 45 442.50 28‐Nov‐90 2 1 GF‐025 GF‐CTO‐18

Page 13: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 5

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

94 101023133 ShriSagarambhaiBachubhaiBaroliya ESQ 494 SEBC 407.25 35 442.25 18‐Jul‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐07 SEBCM‐CTO‐07 Bet.Pref.‐08

95 101038657 ShriKuldipsinhRajendrasinhZala QFI 827 394.25 48 442.25 10‐Jul‐91 1 2 GM‐062 GM‐AO‐16

96 101042096 ShriJitenNavinbhaiBhatti QHZ 901 SEBC 392.25 50 442.25 12‐Nov‐91 2 1 SEBCM‐08 SEBCM‐CTO‐08 Bet.Pref.‐09

97 101008128 ShriTejasRashmikantbhaiMehta EGR 184 398.25 44 442.25 25‐Oct‐95 2 1 GM‐063 GM‐AO‐17

98 101032680 ShriBaldevsinhDilipsinhJadeja QAF 714 399.75 42 441.75 19‐Feb‐90 2 1 GM‐064 GM‐AO‐18

99 101004644 Kum.BharatiJagamalbhaiRavaliya EFH 127 Fem. SEBC 409.50 32 441.50 18‐Oct‐90 2 1 GF‐026 GF‐CTO‐19

100 101015277 Kum.PujaChandulalVashnani EMW 311 Fem. 401.50 40 441.50 21‐Nov‐91 2 1 GF‐027 GF‐CTO‐20

101 101002815 ShriDevangPravinchandraVyas EBL 76 375.75 64 439.75 3‐Sep‐85 2 1 GM‐065 GM‐AO‐19

102 101008937 Kum.SwatibenChunilalNenuji EJA 208 Fem. SEBC 402.50 37 439.50 3‐Jul‐91 1 2 GF‐028 GF‐AO‐08

103 101005670 ShriDhavalRamjjibhaiBavadia EEH 140 396.25 42 438.25 21‐Jul‐86 2 1 GM‐066 GM‐AO‐20

104 101037599 ShriHarshadbhaiKanjibhaiMakwana QDW 803 S.C. 388.25 50 438.25 12‐Nov‐87 1 2 GM‐067 GM‐AO‐21

105 101015952 ShriRushirajsinhAjitsinhJadeja ELY 332 378.25 60 438.25 22‐Nov‐95 2 1 GM‐068 GM‐AO‐22

106 101041422 ShriDharmendrakumarSureshchandraThakor QIA 888 389.75 48 437.75 25‐Sep‐82 2 1 GM‐069 GM‐AO‐23

107 101029090 Kum.SurekhakumariPukhrajsinhPurohit EZG 627 Fem. 389.75 48 437.75 1‐Sep‐84 1 2 GF‐029 GF‐AO‐09

108 101032765 ShriShaileshkumarDaljibhaiChaudhari EZL 716 SEBC 382.50 55 437.50 19‐Jun‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐09 SEBCM‐CTO‐09 Bet.Pref.‐10

109 101032875 ShriVinodkumarPrabhulalMamtora EZM 720 383.25 54 437.25 6‐Nov‐80 2 1 GM‐070 GM‐AO‐24

110 101021184 ShriJigneshkumarSavjibhaiSavani EPY 445 397.25 40 437.25 24‐Aug‐88 2 1 GM‐071 GM‐AO‐25

111 101006497 ShriKanderpJagdishbhaiAcharya EFZ 151 385.00 52 437.00 27‐Sep‐94 2 1 GM‐072 GM‐AO‐26

112 101037939 ShriJaydipsinhKishorsinhJadeja QGG 816 409.75 27 436.75 29‐Nov‐92 2 1 GM‐073 GM‐AO‐27

113 101029321 Kum.JalpaKishorbhaiParmar EYO 637 Fem. SEBC 391.25 45 436.25 22‐Jun‐89 2 1 GF‐030 GF‐CTO‐21

114 101006368 ShriAbdussalamMohmadismailVhora EGY 147 376.00 60 436.00 23‐Nov‐89 2 1 GM‐074 GM‐AO‐28

115 101024948 ShriGopalRatilalPrajapati ETG 536 SEBC 411.00 25 436.00 30‐Jan‐90 2 1 SEBCM‐10 SEBCM‐CTO‐10 Bet.Pref.‐11

116 101010834 ShriJaydipsinhRajendrasinhGohil EJQ 238 393.50 42 435.50 7‐Mar‐92 2 1 GM‐075 GM‐AO‐29

117 101001647 ShriHardikkumarDineshbhaiPrajapati EDA 50 SEBC 411.25 24 435.25 22‐Dec‐93 1 2 GM‐076 GM‐AO‐30

118 101030167 ShriAshishBatukbhaiUkani EXP 656 395.00 40 435.00 4‐Aug‐88 2 1 GM‐077 GM‐AO‐31

119 101007254 ShriUdayDeveshbhaiDholkiya EXA 578 397.00 38 435.00 3‐Sep‐88 2 1 GM‐078 GM‐AO‐32

120 101002202 ShriMahavirsinhManubhaiDodiya EBS 64 SEBC 385.00 50 435.00 29‐Nov‐91 2 1 SEBCM‐11 SEBCM‐CTO‐11 Bet.Pref.‐12

121 101022421 Kum.HemanginiRajeshkumarGurjar ETE 484 Fem. SEBC 388.00 47 435.00 6‐Jun‐92 2 1 SEBCF‐01 SEBCF‐CTO‐01 Bet.Pref.‐13

Page 14: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 6

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

122 101029654 ShriMuzaffarhusenMohmediqbalMahesaniya EYG 647 379.75 55 434.75 22‐Aug‐83 2 1 GM‐079 GM‐AO‐33

123 101039568 ShriMaulikPravinbhaiShrimali QHO 848 S.C. 389.75 45 434.75 27‐Apr‐88 2 1 SCM‐02 SCM‐CTO‐02 Bet.Pref.‐14

124 101014759 ShriBhargavSureshbhaiPurani QFQ 813 S.C. 379.75 55 434.75 13‐Nov‐88 2 1 SCM‐03 SCM‐CTO‐03 Bet.Pref.‐15

125 101021549 ShriKishanlalGovindbhaiChavda ERE 456 SEBC 375.75 59 434.75 26‐Jun‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐12 SEBCM‐CTO‐12 Bet.Pref.‐16

126 101005455 ShriAshwinkumarMahendrabhaiSolanki EFI 136 S.C. 384.75 50 434.75 20‐Jul‐95 2 1 SCM‐04 SCM‐CTO‐04 Bet.Pref.‐17

127 101014129 ShriRavindrasinhDineshsinhGohil EJU 288 394.50 40 434.50 23‐Jul‐88 2 1 GM‐080 GM‐AO‐34

128 101011453 ShriRakeshkumarMadhavlalChaudhari ELE 255 SEBC 386.75 47 433.75 23‐Oct‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐13 SEBCM‐CTO‐13 Bet.Pref.‐18

129 101019966 ShriAbhishekBhemabhaiJoshi EPM 412 385.75 48 433.75 24‐Dec‐93 2 1 GM‐081 GM‐AO‐35

130 101027314 ShriDhavalKishorbhaiRaja EWX 597 395.75 38 433.75 8‐Aug‐95 1 2 GM‐082 GM‐AO‐36

131 101039755 Kum.SonalbenBhikhabhaiPatel QHN 851 Fem. 389.50 44 433.50 30‐Jul‐91 2 1 GF‐031 GF‐AO‐10

132 101009782 ShriPradipMansukhlalVasoya EIU 226 378.50 55 433.50 20‐Mar‐92 2 1 GM‐083 GM‐AO‐37

133 101037559 ShriJaydipkumarHaridanGadhavi QEV 801 SEBC 398.25 35 433.25 29‐Mar‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐14 SEBCM‐CTO‐14 Bet.Pref.‐19

134 101031285 ShriBhavinkumarDamodardasSangani QBE 690 375.50 57 432.50 15‐Mar‐85 2 1 GM‐084 GM‐AO‐38

135 101013714 Kum.KarunabahenLalbhaiPatel QIM 280 Fem. 394.50 38 432.50 13‐11‐1987 1 2 GF‐032 GF‐AO‐11

136 101017384 ShriVishalMukeshbhaiDharmadhikari EMD 359 403.25 29 432.25 1‐Sep‐88 2 1 GM‐085 GM‐AO‐39

137 101015765 ShriRajkumarPrithvirajsinghGautam ENK 328 400.25 32 432.25 14‐Jan‐89 2 1 GM‐086 GM‐AO‐40

138 101007230 ShriSanjaysinhRamjubhaJadeja EHD 164 388.00 44 432.00 11‐May‐88 2 1 GM‐087 GM‐AO‐41

139 101029382 ShriBhaveshPremjibhaiPatel EXM 638 387.00 45 432.00 13‐Jan‐91 2 1 GM‐088 GM‐AO‐42

140 101001563 ShriRajendrakumarRameshkumarThakkar EBZ 44 388.75 43 431.75 25‐Feb‐89 2 1 GM‐089 GM‐AO‐43

141 101024611 ShriHirenkumarVishnubhaiLimbachiya EUM 525 SEBC 378.75 53 431.75 23‐Jun‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐15 SEBCM‐CTO‐15 Bet.Pref.‐20

142 101008909 Kum.DimpleLaljibhaiDesai EJP 205 Fem. SEBC 389.75 42 431.75 21‐Nov‐95 2 1 SEBCF‐02 SEBCF‐CTO‐02 Bet.Pref.‐21

143 101009247 ShriNirmalBhagirathbhaiBhatt EXK 615 381.25 50 431.25 5‐Jan‐89 2 1 GM‐090 GM‐AO‐44

144 101014187 ShriJigarLaxmanbhaiPadhiyar QEA 778 SEBC 391.25 40 431.25 5‐Feb‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐16 SEBCM‐CTO‐16 Bet.Pref.‐22

145 101024655 ShriMaulikChandulalZala ETO 526 S.C. 391.25 40 431.25 7‐Jun‐92 2 1 SCM‐05 SCM‐CTO‐05 Bet.Pref.‐23

146 101021191 Smt.ShrutiDilipbhaiUpadhyay ERT 446 Fem. 373.00 58 431.00 25‐Jan‐85 2 1 GF‐033 GF‐AO‐12

147 101004438 ShriGopeshRameshchandraBarot EFA 117 SEBC 388.00 43 431.00 30‐Jul‐88 2 1 SEBCM‐17 SEBCM‐CTO‐17 Bet.Pref.‐24

148 101020236 ShriJigneshkumarTalshibhaiPatel EQA 426 382.50 48 430.50 11‐Jan‐86 2 1 GM‐091 GM‐AO‐45

149 101003223 ShriOmdevsinhPratapsangChauhan ESC 471 SEBC 379.75 50 429.75 1‐Feb‐83 2 1 SEBCM‐18 SEBCM‐CTO‐18 Bet.Pref.‐25

Page 15: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 7

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

150 101036711 ShriNaveenchandraRamanlalVaghela QED 783 S.C. 383.75 46 429.75 11‐Jul‐92 2 1 SCM‐06 SCM‐CTO‐06 Bet.Pref.‐26

151 101025270 ShriMilankumarKantilalKavthiya EUY 556 387.50 42 429.50 9‐Jan‐88 2 1 GM‐092 GM‐AO‐46

152 101028250 ShriMilanJayantilalAdodariya EWJ 612 397.25 32 429.25 14‐Jun‐86 2 1 GM‐093 GM‐AO‐47

153 101026614 Kum.AshabenRadheshyamKar EWI 584 Fem. 375.25 54 429.25 17‐Apr‐89 1 2 GF‐034 GF‐AO‐13

154 101014390 ShriParthAshokMishra ELL 295 371.00 58 429.00 5‐Nov‐90 2 1 GM‐094 GM‐AO‐48

155 101029060 ShriRavirajsinhHamirsinhVaghela EXR 626 384.00 45 429.00 2‐Apr‐94 2 1 GM‐095 GM‐AO‐49

156 101023493 ShriSujeetkumarVijaykumarGadhavi ETT 510 SEBC 383.25 45 428.25 25‐Aug‐88 2 1 SEBCM‐19 SEBCM‐CTO‐19

157 101017565 ShriBhargavkumarHasmukhbhaiSachaniya QHW 360 SEBC 373.00 55 428.00 23‐06‐1987 2 1 SEBCM‐20 SEBCM‐CTO‐20

158 101017634 ShriJayMukeshbhaiRao EPK 366 Disabled 373.00 55 428.00 22‐May‐92 1 2 GM‐096 GM‐AO‐50

159 101039295 Kum.PayalBhupendrabhaiDholakia QGC 840 Fem. 401.75 26 427.75 24‐Sep‐87 2 1 GF‐035 GF‐AO‐14

160 101016238 ShriUdaysinhDineshbhaiBarad ENG 338 SEBC 380.75 47 427.75 31‐Dec‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐21 SEBCM‐CTO‐21

161 101041869 Kum.TruptiRameshbhaiLanghnoja QIG 896 Fem. 379.75 48 427.75 30‐Jan‐90 2 1 GF‐036 GF‐AO‐15

162 101007690 Kum.HumakhanamMaarufkhanPathan EHF 176 Fem. 392.50 35 427.50 25‐Dec‐87 1 2 GF‐037 GF‐AO‐16

163 101002335 Kum.KrishnaVinubhaiRafaliya EDF 68 Fem. 382.50 45 427.50 28‐Feb‐91 2 1 GF‐038 GF‐AO‐17

164 101004233 Kum.AneriPradipSoni EET 114 Fem. 395.00 32 427.00 8‐Dec‐92 1 2 GF‐039 GF‐AO‐18

165 101030842 Kum.MeetaVrujlalSondagar QAK 681 Fem. SEBC 379.75 47 426.75 5‐Aug‐89 2 1 SEBCF‐03 SEBCF‐CTO‐03 Bet.Pref.‐27

166 101004532 ShriVijayGovindbhaiSadia EEC 121 S.C. 383.75 43 426.75 23‐Jun‐90 2 1 SCM‐07 SCM‐AO‐01

167 101024810 Smt.SwatibahenJayantilalPatel EUA 530 Fem. 381.75 45 426.75 14‐Mar‐91 1 2 GF‐040 GF‐AO‐19

168 101005248 ShriRajendrasinhKiritsinhParmar ETY 507 SEBC 388.25 38 426.25 1‐Jul‐87 2 1 SEBCM‐22 SEBCM‐CTO‐22

169 101012459 ShriJaydipsinhGovindsinhRathod EZU 671 SEBC 393.00 33 426.00 5‐Feb‐83 2 1 SEBCM‐23 SEBCM‐CTO‐23

170 101034988 ShriBharatbhaiVarsangbhaiRathod QCX 760 SEBC 378.75 47 425.75 10‐Jan‐90 1 2 SEBCM‐24 SEBCM‐AO‐01

171 101011759 Kum.JuhiRatilalPatel EKZ 263 Fem. SEBC 385.50 40 425.50 29‐Mar‐92 2 1 SEBCF‐04 SEBCF‐CTO‐04 Bet.Pref.‐28

172 101022034 ShriNavaldanRambhaiGadhavi ERW 475 SEBC 372.50 53 425.50 14‐Jun‐92 1 2 SEBCM‐25 SEBCM‐AO‐02

173 101021388 Kum.VarshabenMohanbhaiChaudhari EQD 449 Fem. SEBC 367.25 58 425.25 18‐Aug‐87 2 1 SEBCF‐05 SEBCF‐CTO‐05 Bet.Pref.‐29

174 101021085 Kum.DharmishthaBaldevbhaiChavada EQU 441 Fem. SEBC 388.25 37 425.25 30‐Apr‐94 1 2 GF‐041 GF‐AO‐20

175 101003791 ShriRiteshkumarDahyabhaiChaudhari EDW 99 SEBC 377.00 48 425.00 12‐Jul‐90 2 1 SEBCM‐26 SEBCM‐AO‐03

176 101025448 Kum.NidhiRajeshbhaiMer EVP 559 Fem. 385.75 39 424.75 2‐Aug‐88 1 2 GF‐042 GF‐AO‐21

177 101014535 Kum.AditiBhalchandraTrivedi QFB 812 Fem. 367.75 57 424.75 9‐Jun‐91 2 1 GF‐043 GF‐AO‐22

Page 16: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 8

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

178 101030263 Kum.UrmiChandrakantVaja EYZ 659 Fem. SEBC 377.50 47 424.50 9‐Sep‐82 2 1 SEBCF‐06 SEBCF‐CTO‐06 Bet.Pref.‐30

179 101015572 ShriPunitJagdishchandraPanchal ENB 320 SEBC 369.00 55 424.00 17‐Nov‐87 2 1 SEBCM‐27 SEBCM‐AO‐04

180 101016612 Kum.SonamKapilkumarShah QIF 342 Fem. 385.75 38 423.75 15‐07‐1986 2 1 GF‐044 GF‐AO‐23

181 101020850 ShriNishantTejabhaiDesai ERK 438 SEBC 368.25 55 423.25 18‐Sep‐88 2 1 SEBCM‐28 SEBCM‐AO‐05

182 101008210 ShriHiteshkumarIshvarbhaiChaudhary EGW 185 SEBC 373.25 50 423.25 16‐Aug‐93 2 1 SEBCM‐29 SEBCM‐AO‐06

183 101026474 Kum.HiralDineshbhaiRathod EVQ 576 Fem. SEBC 380.00 43 423.00 23‐Oct‐89 2 1 SEBCF‐07 SEBCF‐CTO‐07 Bet.Pref.‐31

184 101004060 Kum.FarheenbanuFarukbhaiPatel EFD 106 Fem. 378.00 45 423.00 27‐Jul‐93 1 2 GF‐045 GF‐AO‐24

185 101036631 Kum.ZalakKaushikbhaiPatel QCJ 773 Fem. 362.75 60 422.75 2‐Jul‐89 2 1 GF‐046 GF‐AO‐25

186 101030265 ShriKetanGanpatbhaiPrajapati EXW 660 SEBC 387.75 35 422.75 27‐Jul‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐30 SEBCM‐AO‐07

187 101015196 ShriMiteshkumarKaushikbhaiBarot EML 308 SEBC 382.50 40 422.50 21‐Jun‐88 2 1 SEBCM‐31 SEBCM‐AO‐08

188 101031930 ShriGautambhaiManubhaiDulera QBA 705 S.C. 372.25 50 422.25 1‐Oct‐82 2 1 SCM‐08 SCM‐AO‐02

189 101016885 Kum.VibhutibenNatvarbhaiMaheta EMK 348 Fem. SEBC 376.25 46 422.25 23‐Feb‐91 1 2 GF‐047 GF‐AO‐26

190 101030145 ShriRaviKiritbhaiFumakiya EYD 655 SEBC 382.25 40 422.25 24‐May‐94 2 1 SEBCM‐32 SEBCM‐AO‐09

191 101018934 ShriYagnikkumarBharatbhaiBarot ENU 391 SEBC 389.00 33 422.00 3‐Jan‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐33 SEBCM‐AO‐10

192 101029673 Kum.RekhaRambhaiModhavadiya EYJ 648 Fem. SEBC 366.75 55 421.75 1‐Nov‐92 2 1 SEBCF‐08 SEBCF‐CTO‐08

193 101013305 ShriSandipkumarNanjibhaiSarariya QBV 724 SEBC 364.50 57 421.50 19‐May‐90 1 2 SEBCM‐34 SEBCM‐AO‐11

194 101003063 ShriDarshanShaileshkumarKhalas ESD 470 SEBC 366.25 55 421.25 24‐Jul‐89 1 2 SEBCM‐35 SEBCM‐AO‐12

195 101004584 ShriMaheshkumarJerambhaiPatel EFJ 125 Disabled 379.00 42 421.00 12‐Mar‐76 2 1 GM‐097 GM‐CTO‐47

196 101029469 ShriMiteshbhaiMohanbhaiChavda EYV 642 SEBC 379.00 42 421.00 21‐Aug‐87 2 1 SEBCM‐36 SEBCM‐AO‐13

197 101026532 ShriVijayMandanOdedra EWG 583 SEBC 389.00 32 421.00 10‐Nov‐89 2 1 SEBCM‐37 SEBCM‐AO‐14

198 101009416 ShriHiteshkumarKanjibhaiPrajapati EII 219 SEBC 370.50 50 420.50 27‐Dec‐77 1 2 SEBCM‐38 SEBCM‐AO‐15

199 101001636 ShriNileshkumarManglubhaiVala EDB 48 SEBC 374.25 46 420.25 16‐Aug‐92 2 1 SEBCM‐39 SEBCM‐AO‐16

200 101004591 ShriVirendrasinhBhagvanbhaiChauhan EDN 126 SEBC 378.00 42 420.00 13‐Jun‐88 2 1 SEBCM‐40 SEBCM‐AO‐17

201 101008684 Kum.HemabenKishorbhaiGadhavi EGN 197 Fem. SEBC 384.75 35 419.75 25‐Oct‐86 2 1 SEBCF‐09 SEBCF‐CTO‐09

202 101006433 ShriHardikkumarChunilalNenuji EHI 150 SEBC 374.50 45 419.50 11‐Oct‐93 1 2 SEBCM‐41 SEBCM‐AO‐18

203 101004693 ShriParasChandubhaiMakwana EFL 128 SEBC 369.25 50 419.25 15‐Jul‐83 2 1 SEBCM‐42 SEBCM‐AO‐19

204 101008520 ShriJayeshkumarBhabhlubhaiKhachar EGV 191 SEBC 369.00 50 419.00 1‐Jun‐94 1 2 SEBCM‐43 SEBCM‐AO‐20

205 101001754 ShriGirishkumarSureshlalThakkar ECW 55 Disabled 375.25 43 418.25 30‐Apr‐80 1 2 GM‐098 GM‐AO‐51

Page 17: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 9

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

206 101030744 ShriVikramSadurbhaiKhungla QAV 675 SEBC 362.00 55 417.00 20‐Jan‐93 1 2 SEBCM‐44 SEBCM‐AO‐21

207 101018784 ShriAnkurkumarBharatbhaiSolanki ENV 389 SEBC 387.75 29 416.75 19‐Feb‐91 2 1 SEBCM‐45 SEBCM‐AO‐22

208 101004297 ShriNiteshbhaiVakhatsangbhaiChauhan EEX 116 SEBC 381.50 35 416.50 8‐Jun‐93 2 1 SEBCM‐46 SEBCM‐AO‐23

209 101036624 ShriNirmalkumarDhirubhaiGogara QDB 772 SEBC 358.25 58 416.25 24‐Jun‐91 2 1 SEBCM‐47 SEBCM‐AO‐24

210 101006830 ShriPrakashkumarPurushotambhaiChauhan EGK 157 SEBC 360.75 55 415.75 22‐Nov‐81 1 2 SEBCM‐48 SEBCM‐AO‐25

211 101038635 ShriJayeshParsottambhaiKukadiya QFT 826 SEBC 362.75 53 415.75 30‐Jun‐91 2 1 SEBCM‐49 SEBCM‐AO‐26

212 101005031 Kum.NiyatibenNitinkumarModi EFG 132 Fem. SEBC 383.75 32 415.75 22‐Aug‐93 1 2 SEBCF‐10 SEBCF‐AO‐01

213 101009084 Kum.EktaDineshbhaiAjagiya EYC 613 Fem. SEBC 373.25 42 415.25 14‐Dec‐94 2 1 SEBCF‐11 SEBCF‐CTO‐10

214 101023342 ShriUpendrakumarVirabhaiSutaria ESB 499 S.C. 363.25 51 414.25 1‐Jun‐87 2 1 SCM‐09 SCM‐AO‐03

215 101031352 Kum.PriyankaRajeshkumarKayasth QBI 691 Fem. SEBC 362.00 50 412.00 15‐Mar‐89 1 2 SEBCF‐12 SEBCF‐AO‐02

216 101002766 Kum.KantabenGovindbhaiDadukiya ECH 74 Fem. SEBC 364.00 48 412.00 27‐Jun‐92 2 1 SEBCF‐13 SEBCF‐CTO‐11

217 101037656 Kum.ManishabenIndukumarParmar QET 806 Fem. SEBC 371.00 40 411.00 1‐Aug‐80 2 1 SEBCF‐14 SEBCF‐CTO‐12

218 101003715 ShriKrunalBharatbhaiJadav EEV 96 S.C. 355.50 55 410.50 20‐Mar‐94 2 1 SCM‐10 SCM‐AO‐04

219 101021541 Kum.ParulSamatbhaiDhrangia EQJ 454 Fem. SEBC 366.50 43 409.50 13‐Jul‐87 1 2 SEBCF‐15 SEBCF‐AO‐03

220 101001475 Kum.AnjanabenPravinchandraPrajapati ERI 415 Fem. SEBC 370.00 39 409.00 28‐Oct‐83 2 1 SEBCF‐16 SEBCF‐AO‐04

221 101032245 Kum.RenuKarsanbhaiPadaya QAE 708 Fem. S.C. 358.75 50 408.75 3‐Jul‐90 1 2 SCF‐01 SCF‐AO‐01

222 101020211 ShriBharatkumarVersibhaiParmar ERN 424 S.C. 366.50 42 408.50 9‐Apr‐88 2 1 SCM‐11 SCM‐AO‐05

223 101017786 Kum.NayanaBijalbhaiNakum EPD 370 Fem. SEBC 368.50 40 408.50 1‐Apr‐93 2 1 SEBCF‐17 SEBCF‐AO‐05

224 101000801 Kum.RutikabenVijaybhaiDodiya EAB 28 Fem. SEBC 368.25 40 408.25 26‐May‐91 2 1 SEBCF‐18 SEBCF‐AO‐06

225 101013491 ShriUrveshkumarNatvarlalMachhavada QEU 775 S.C. 370.00 37 407.00 25‐May‐90 2 1 SCM‐12 SCM‐AO‐06

226 101014468 ShriRahulNagarbhaiMakwana EKA 296 S.C. 369.50 37 406.50 22‐Jul‐80 2 1 SCM‐13 SCM‐AO‐07

227 101032919 Kum.RipalArvindbhaiPrajapati QCE 726 Fem. SEBC 378.75 27 405.75 4‐Dec‐91 1 2 SEBCF‐19 SEBCF‐AO‐07

228 101029429 Smt.MinaxibenMaheshbhaiParmar EZC 640 Fem. S.C. 357.25 48 405.25 10‐Nov‐93 2 1 SCF‐02 SCF‐CTO‐01

229 101013023 Smt.AshabenHimenkumarNagar ELA 272 Fem. SEBC 373.50 31 404.50 26‐Jul‐83 2 1 SEBCF‐20 SEBCF‐AO‐08

230 101025162 Kum.NetalbaNarubhaSodha EVD 553 Fem. SEBC 365.75 38 403.75 8‐Nov‐83 2 1 SEBCF‐21 SEBCF‐AO‐09

231 101024681 Kum.PoojaAmarajiThakor ETQ 527 Fem. SEBC 361.75 41 402.75 10‐Aug‐94 2 1 SEBCF‐22 SEBCF‐AO‐10

232 101010375 Smt.MohineeJivrajbhaiDesai EIF 234 Fem. SEBC 369.00 32 401.00 3‐Jul‐95 2 1 SEBCF‐23 SEBCF‐AO‐11

233 101038902 Kum.PriyankabenRajeshkumarBarot QGD 834 Fem. SEBC 376.00 25 401.00 17‐Aug‐96 1 2 SEBCF‐24 SEBCF‐AO‐12

Page 18: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 10

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

234 101034152 Kum.KalyaniAshokbhaiKalyani QBZ 750 Fem. S.C. 353.50 45 398.50 28‐Aug‐95 2 1 SCF‐03 SCF‐CTO‐02

235 101019965 Kum.ZarinaAbdulmajidKhafif EOL 411 Fem. SEBC 353.25 45 398.25 23‐Jan‐84 1 2 SEBCF‐25 SEBCF‐AO‐13

236 101017031 Kum.PriyankaChaitanyabhaiChauhan EMV 351 Fem. S.C. 359.00 38 397.00 13‐May‐95 1 2 SCF‐04 SCF‐AO‐02

237 101015286 Kum.SejalKarsanbhaiRathava EMH 313 Fem. S.T. 366.50 30 396.50 19‐Aug‐93 1 2 STF‐01 STF‐AO‐01

238 101036149 ShriYogendraUkkadbhaiVasava QDF 769 S.T. 337.00 58 395.00 24‐Dec‐84 2 1 STM‐01 STM‐CTO‐01

239 101027385 Kum.TarunabenMohanlalVadvasiya EWF 598 Fem. S.C. 340.75 52 392.75 24‐Aug‐93 1 2 SCF‐05 SCF‐AO‐03

240 101023256 Kum.VarshabenNagarbhaiParmar ESS 498 Fem. S.C. 339.25 50 389.25 12‐Mar‐92 1 2 SCF‐06 SCF‐CTO‐03

241 101040272 ShriChiragManilalVachhani QHF 862 Disabled 363.00 26 389.00 15‐Apr‐88 2 1 GM‐099 GM‐AO‐52

242 101024965 ShriDipakkumarRamanbhaiRathva ETL 537 S.T. 325.75 55 380.75 5‐Mar‐84 2 1 STM‐02 STM‐CTO‐02

243 101016757 ShriPradeepAnandbhaiMalankiya EMC 344 SEBC Disabled 343.50 35 378.50 27‐Jun‐93 2 1 SEBCM‐50 SEBCM‐AO‐27

244 101015338 ShriKrinalMaganbhaiPandav QGW 847 S.T. 341.25 30 371.25 7‐Jun‐78 2 1 STM‐03 STM‐CTO‐03

245 101024534 ShriKamleshkumarNaranbhaiDiya ETM 522 S.T. 322.50 40 362.50 25‐Jul‐87 2 1 STM‐04 STM‐CTO‐04

246 101022288 ShriPriteshkumarDevrambhaiVarli ESG 481 S.T. 328.75 33 361.75 1‐Apr‐94 2 1 STM‐05 STM‐CTO‐05

247 101024226 ShriArjunNaranbhaiGalchar ETH 517 S.T. 313.00 48 361.00 24‐May‐93 2 1 STM‐06 STM‐CTO‐06

248 101010865 ShriMayurkumarDhansukhbhaiPatel EIL 239 S.T. 317.75 40 357.75 8‐Nov‐93 2 1 STM‐07 STM‐CTO‐07

249 101033773 ShriMiteshkumarThakorbhaiPatel QCP 742 S.T. 312.25 45 357.25 13‐Oct‐88 2 1 STM‐08 STM‐CTO‐08

250 101037163 Kum.LaxmiSarmanbhaiKatariya QEI 793 Fem. S.T. 328.00 28 356.00 26‐Sep‐88 1 2 STF‐02 STF‐AO‐02

251 101006079 ShriSunilkumarBalubhaiGamit EVR 542 S.T. 306.75 48 354.75 24‐Sep‐84 2 1 STM‐09 STM‐CTO‐09

252 101029170 Kum.KinjalDineshchandraHalpati EAL 629 Fem. S.T. 310.00 43 353.00 24‐03‐1991 2 1 STF‐03 STF‐CTO‐01

253 101014784 Kum.SumanSanjaybhaiVasava EKL 300 Fem. S.T. 323.75 27 350.75 5‐May‐91 1 2 STF‐04 STF‐AO‐03

254 101014234 ShriKamalkumarShantilalAsari EJV 289 S.T. 314.00 35 349.00 5‐Jun‐93 2 1 STM‐10 STM‐CTO‐10

255 101038016 ShriHimmatsinhKalujiMalaviya QFX 817 S.T. 318.00 30 348.00 26‐Dec‐82 2 1 STM‐11 STM‐CTO‐11

256 101024027 ShriJagdishSureshbhaiKukna EUN 515 S.T. 302.75 44 346.75 17‐Nov‐85 2 1 STM‐12 STM‐CTO‐12

257 101027395 Kum.KhushbuShantilalKatara EWM 600 Fem. S.T. 307.25 38 345.25 28‐Dec‐92 1 2 STF‐05 STF‐AO‐04

258 101030597 ShriBhaveshMeramanbhaiKodiyatar QBJ 672 S.T. 293.50 50 343.50 1‐Jan‐87 1 2 STM‐13 STM‐AO‐01

259 101012641 ShriHetalkumarIleshbhaiGamit ELD 269 S.T. 307.75 35 342.75 26‐Jul‐95 1 2 STM‐14 STM‐AO‐02

260 101032704 ShriJayeshkumarPunjabhaiHathila QAU 715 S.T. 311.75 30 341.75 15‐Mar‐83 2 1 STM‐15 STM‐CTO‐13

261 101016802 ShriPratikRohitkumarBaranda ENI 346 S.T. 283.75 57 340.75 8‐Feb‐88 2 1 STM‐16 STM‐AO‐03

Page 19: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐1Part‐IListofSuccessfulCandidates AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 11

Sr.No. SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code ENo.M/F.

Category

Disabled/Widow

WrittenMarks

VivaVoce

Total BirthDate AO CTO TreatedIndicativeAllotment

Remarks

262 101032812 Kum.AkankshaArvindbhaiAsari QAS 718 Fem. S.T. 305.50 35 340.50 9‐Aug‐93 2 1 STF‐06 STF‐CTO‐02

263 101021221 Kum.PrakrutiNatvarlalChaudhari ERO 447 Fem. S.T. 302.50 37 339.50 5‐Aug‐89 2 1 STF‐07 STF‐CTO‐03

264 101011627 ShriAshishChhaganbhaiKodiyatar ELG 260 S.T. 303.50 35 338.50 10‐Dec‐89 2 1 STM‐17 STM‐AO‐04

265 101021960 ShriPravinkumarMohanbhaiGamit ERF 467 S.T. 295.50 42 337.50 18‐Jul‐89 2 1 STM‐18 STM‐AO‐05

266 101023402 Kum.SonalNaginbhaiRathwa ERZ 501 Fem. S.T. 296.50 40 336.50 27‐Mar‐87 2 1 STF‐08 STF‐CTO‐04

267 101021605 ShriShaileshkumarBalubhaiDamor EQZ 460 S.T. 279.25 57 336.25 8‐Jul‐93 1 2 STM‐19 STM‐AO‐06

268 101011521 Smt.DipikaPratikPatel QAC 667 Fem. S.T. 297.50 36 333.50 13‐Oct‐89 2 1 STF‐09 STF‐CTO‐05

269 101008762 ShriDineshRajabhaiMusar EIX 200 S.T. 296.25 35 331.25 3‐Jun‐88 2 1 STM‐20 STM‐AO‐07

270 101009566 ShriJatinkumarHasmukhbhaiChaudhari EJC 223 S.T. 296.25 35 331.25 21‐Mar‐93 2 1 STM‐21 STM‐AO‐08

271 101021255 ShriSunilkumarRamanbhaiPatel EPX 448 S.T. 278.75 52 330.75 9‐Jan‐91 2 1 STM‐22 STM‐AO‐09

272 101041476 Kum.BijalbenMaganbhaiTabiyar QIJ 890 Fem. S.T. 302.50 27 329.50 16‐Jul‐93 2 1 STF‐10 STF‐AO‐05

273 101019887 ShriVinodkumarKasnabhaiSolanki EOT 406 S.T. 293.50 35 328.50 1‐Jun‐79 2 1 STM‐23 STM‐AO‐10

274 101028570 ShriYogeshkumarDhirabhaiBamania EXZ 618 S.T. 287.25 40 327.25 7‐Mar‐91 1 2 STM‐24 STM‐AO‐11

275 101005588 ShriVivekkumarMendalbhaiDamor ETN 509 S.T. 284.00 43 327.00 10‐Aug‐91 2 1 STM‐25 STM‐AO‐12

276 101035863 Kum.RajnibalaSomabhaiVasaiya QBW 767 Fem. S.T. 294.75 32 326.75 10‐Jun‐89 2 1 STF‐11 STF‐AO‐06

277 101014027 ShriShubhamRatilalUmat EJT 285 S.T. 284.75 42 326.75 25‐Nov‐95 2 1 STM‐26 STM‐AO‐13

278 101029389 ShriGaurangManubhaiDamor EZI 639 S.T. 290.25 36 326.25 7‐Feb‐88 1 2 STM‐27 STM‐AO‐14

279 101032529 ShriPratikkumarUdesinhChaudhari QAI 713 S.T. 285.25 41 326.25 2‐Nov‐89 2 1 STM‐28 STM‐AO‐15

280 101013165 Smt.AmitaKanubhaiDagara EKT 275 Fem. S.T. 289.75 33 322.75 18‐Mar‐85 2 1 STF‐12 STF‐AO‐07

281 101024799 Kum.DipikabenGulabbhaiTaviyad EUK 528 Fem. S.T. Disabled 287.75 30 317.75 28‐Jan‐91 2 1 STF‐13 STF‐CTO‐06

(H.J.PAREKH)Place:‐GANDHINAGAR SECRETARYDate:‐09‐02‐2018 GUJARATPUBLICSERVICECOMMISSION

Page 20: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

1 101000064 Kum.DevarshiMahendrakumarPatel EAN 1 Fem. 370.50 45 415.50 15‐Aug‐95

2 101000101 ShriNileshkumarMathurbhaiMakwana EAQ 2 350.50 20 370.50 21‐Jan‐90

3 101000144 ShriYogeshJamanbhaiBarvadiya EAR 3 343.25 35 378.25 6‐Oct‐89

4 101000147 ShriBhanabhaiNaranjiChaudhari EAD 4 SEBC 351.25 24 375.25 1‐Jan‐94

5 101000160 ShriRamrajsinhGajendrasinhDayma EAJ 6 SEBC 346.00 53 399.00 8‐May‐90

6 101000386 ShriRohitDanubhaiBokhani EAH 10 S.C. 339.25 45 384.25 27‐Sep‐85

7 101000455 Kum.ParulbenGirdharlalAhuja EBC 11 Fem. 338.00 55 393.00 13‐Apr‐87

8 101000498 ShriUmeshkumarBekhatmalMaheshwari EAS 12 370.50 57 427.50 28‐Sep‐88

9 101000501 ShriJayeshkumarKhushalbhaiVaniya EBD 13 S.C. 353.75 40 393.75 11‐Jul‐87

10 101000511 Smt.SnehalbenRakeshbhaiKaneriya EAF 14 Fem. 343.25 23 366.25 26‐Jun‐89

11 101000536 ShriKrunalKiritkumarLathigara EAU 15 400.75 25 425.75 7‐Aug‐91

12 101000566 ShriBhavikRumalsingRathava EAM 16 S.T. 282.25 35 317.25 20‐May‐92

13 101000595 ShriHirenkumarRavindranathRaval EAA 17 363.25 40 403.25 29‐Feb‐88

14 101000608 ShriChiragNaginbhaiRathva EAK 18 S.T. 275.00 35 310.00 18‐Oct‐94

15 101000636 ShriSubhashkumarChimanbhaiGamit EAT 19 S.T. 257.00 40 297.00 29‐Aug‐94

16 101000692 ShriBrijrajsinhDilipsinhZala EBJ 21 353.75 43 396.75 15‐Oct‐92

17 101000698 Kum.MeetabenChandulalSolanki EBA 22 Fem. S.C. 330.75 32 362.75 17‐Aug‐85

18 101000773 ShriVishnukumarAmaratbhaiBar EAV 25 SEBC 383.25 25 408.25 30‐Mar‐94

Marksobtained,inViva‐Voce,bytheUnsuccessfulcandidatesareasunder:‐

GUJARATPUBLICSERVICECOMMISSIONANNEXURE‐I(Part‐II)

Part‐IIResultofunsuccessfulCandidates

Post:‐AccountsOfficer,Class‐IIandCommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17

DateofInterview:1stJanuaryto25thJanuary,2018

Page 21: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 2

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

19 101000791 ShriSagarkumarShambhubhaiVaghani EAE 27 371.50 46 417.50 11‐Feb‐94

20 101000830 ShriDhavalbhaiVasudevbhaiPatel EBB 29 340.25 37 377.25 16‐Feb‐93

21 101000940 ShriDashrathbhaiVashrambhaiChaudhari EAX 32 SEBC 377.50 25 402.50 18‐Jun‐96

22 101001001 ShriMahendraPratapsinhKushwah EBK 33 349.25 22 371.25 29‐Oct‐86

23 101001015 Smt.ArzookumariArvindbhaiPatel EAZ 34 Fem. 346.25 32 378.25 3‐Nov‐90

24 101001037 Kum.ReshmaArvindbhaiLangdiya EAY 35 Fem. 369.00 35 404.00 16‐Jan‐93

25 101001050 Kum.VarshaKamdar EAG 36 Fem. S.C. 333.50 48 381.50 14‐Sep‐87

26 101001122 ShriMahmadjusabMahmadhanifKhatri ECO 37 356.75 44 400.75 19‐Nov‐94

27 101001136 Kum.StuteeIndravadanBrahmabhatt ECY 38 Fem. Dis. 312.25 38 350.25 9‐Jan‐92

28 101001327 Kum.AlpaRameshbhaiDesai EBW 40 Fem. SEBC 356.25 38 394.25 1‐Apr‐86

29 101001381 ShriSanjaykumarBahecharNinama EBV 41 S.T. 261.00 22 283.00 5‐Mar‐85

30 101001454 Kum.MayaMaganbhaiKiri ECQ 42 Fem. 360.75 22 382.75 28‐Oct‐78

31 101001464 Kum.NidhiKantilalDindod EBT 43 Fem. S.T. 261.75 22 283.75 20‐Mar‐96

32 101001598 ShriDhavalSanjaykumarPanchal EBO 45 SEBC 353.00 55 408.00 19‐Oct‐93

33 101001622 Kum.BansariManubhaiParmar EDK 47 Fem. S.C. 342.00 43 385.00 8‐Nov‐90

34 101001699 ShriHarpalsinhRamsinhGohil ECF 51 369.25 55 424.25 20‐May‐91

35 101001730 Kum.MansiGulabbhaiTarpara ECK 52 Fem. 344.00 35 379.00 9‐Sep‐88

36 101001752 Kum.KinjalbenSureshbhaiPrajapati EDJ 54 Fem. 372.75 32 404.75 12‐Jul‐91

37 101001825 ShriMaheshkumarBhagvanbhaiAal EBN 57 SEBC 356.50 38 394.50 26‐May‐96

38 101001911 Kum.ArtiRameshchandraNimavat QIC 58 Fem. SEBC 352.00 32 384.00 21‐Jun‐90

39 101001925 ShriPallavJayeshbhaiBhindi EBQ 59 349.50 52 401.50 1‐Aug‐92

40 101002078 ShriRanadhirsinhGambhirsinhZala ECB 61 351.50 50 401.50 31‐Aug‐84

41 101002087 ShriShaileshIshwarbhaiDesai ECR 62 SEBC 346.50 25 371.50 6‐Jun‐88

42 101002146 ShriKamalMansukhbhaiMakwana ECX 63 S.C. 364.00 23 387.00 26‐Jan‐87

43 101002227 ShriKawalMukeshMajmudar EBX 65 341.25 35 376.25 25‐Jun‐86

Page 22: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 3

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

44 101002294 ShriHardikkumarKishorbhaiBhalodiya EBM 66 349.25 23 372.25 29‐May‐90

45 101002310 ShriRavirajsinhDharmendrasinhVaghela EDH 67 340.75 45 385.75 21‐Jan‐90

46 101002360 ShriJayBaldevbhaiDesai EBY 69 SEBC 382.75 25 407.75 22‐Dec‐89

47 101002434 ShriHareshkumarBhagavandasBarot ECJ 70 SEBC 352.50 50 402.50 25‐Jan‐78

48 101002740 ShriRajendrabhaiTanajibhaiValvi EDL 73 S.T. 255.75 40 295.75 15‐Jun‐82

49 101002786 ShriHarishDevidasThakare ECS 75 387.50 33 420.50 31‐Oct‐88

50 101002834 ShriBhadreshkumarBabulalPatel EBR 78 385.00 42 427.00 28‐Apr‐86

51 101002912 ShriDurgeshPravinbhaiRathod EDG 79 SEBC 342.75 25 367.75 27‐May‐84

52 101002962 ShriMaulikMotilalPandya ECP 80 366.50 35 401.50 22‐Feb‐89

53 101002973 ShriNiranjanbhaiChothabhaiChaudhary EBP 81 SEBC 337.00 32 369.00 24‐Dec‐89

54 101003097 ShriDineshkumarKanujiThakor ECI 82 SEBC 353.00 22 375.00 5‐Aug‐85

55 101003101 ShriAnilkumarSenabhaiParmar ECA 83 S.T. 278.75 28 306.75 4‐Jun‐83

56 101003320 ShriKaushikbhaiBhikhabhaiGohil ECC 84 S.C. 353.00 42 395.00 7‐Aug‐83

57 101003356 Kum.AektaPravinchandraPatel ECZ 85 Fem. 339.50 30 369.50 9‐Jul‐81

58 101003451 Kum.PurvibenDeepakkumarPrajapati ECU 88 Fem. SEBC 355.75 22 377.75 9‐Jul‐82

59 101003602 ShriNavinkumarJayantilalGomtiwal EEA 92 389.00 39 428.00 1‐Jun‐94

60 101003676 Kum.PriyankabenBanshidharbhaiPargi EFF 94 Fem. S.T. 283.50 32 315.50 1‐Jul‐93

61 101003687 ShriShaktisinhRanjitsinhJadeja EEE 95 378.00 43 421.00 15‐Jun‐90

62 101003745 Kum.HemanginiJagdishchandraSoni EDU 97 Fem. 380.75 25 405.75 24‐Sep‐81

63 101003778 ShriIshankumarBipinchandraKhatri EEQ 98 361.25 45 406.25 30‐Dec‐87

64 101003819 ShriShaileshGovindbhaiSolanki EEO 100 SEBC 344.50 41 385.50 8‐Mar‐78

65 101003843 Kum.RajeKum.benRamjibhaiChaudhari EEM 101 Fem. S.T. 282.00 35 317.00 28‐May‐83

66 101003950 Kum.SonalbahenHarshadbhaiChauhan EEL 102 Fem. 367.50 25 392.50 13‐Aug‐90

67 101003957 ShriChandrashekharPappusingVerma EEG 104 342.75 54 396.75 22‐Jul‐93

68 101004012 ShriKanubhaiNaranbhaiRabari EDY 105 SEBC 350.00 35 385.00 10‐Oct‐84

Page 23: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 4

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

69 101004088 ShriYagneshHimatbhaiJoshi EEU 107 SEBC 342.75 34 376.75 17‐Apr‐89

70 101004104 ShriHiteshkumarJayantibhaiPatel EFB 108 366.00 35 401.00 2‐May‐88

71 101004168 ShriAshishkumarBhursingbhaiMachhar EDX 109 S.T. 276.75 33 309.75 17‐May‐94

72 101004173 ShriAmitkumarGanpatbhaiChaudhari EDR 110 S.T. 265.50 30 295.50 14‐Apr‐88

73 101004189 ShriChetankumarMavjibhaiPatel EDM 111 365.00 60 425.00 1‐Jun‐88

74 101004196 ShriJaydeepsinhMeghrajsinhJadeja EED 112 374.75 48 422.75 20‐Sep‐91

75 101004208 ShriDivyeshSureshbhaiAgravat EDZ 113 SEBC 343.75 53 396.75 23‐Jan‐88

76 101004280 ShriDharmeshHamirbhaiBoricha EER 115 SEBC 351.75 38 389.75 23‐Apr‐92

77 101004499 ShriDhavalkumarBabubhaiPatel EEW 119 349.75 35 384.75 25‐Jul‐91

78 101004528 ShriYuvrajsinhSabalsinhDeval EDP 120 354.25 46 400.25 26‐Aug‐93

79 101004540 ShriPankajkumarVahetabhaiSolanki EEP 122 S.T. 252.75 25 277.75 29‐Mar‐92

80 101004557 ShriSanjayDevjibhaiSagathiya EFK 123 S.C. Dis. 305.75 30 335.75 26‐Nov‐88

81 101004579 ShriSaddamhusenMajnuddinAnsari EEF 124 380.75 28 408.75 11‐Jun‐92

82 101004765 ShriIndrasinhMansangbhaiMasani EDO 129 SEBC 339.25 33 372.25 29‐May‐92

83 101004873 ShriMilanLaljibhaiDesai EES 130 SEBC 353.50 45 398.50 16‐Mar‐95

84 101004923 ShriBhaveshFaljibhaiChaudhari EEI 131 SEBC 359.00 45 404.00 18‐Jul‐89

85 101005373 Kum.VasantkunvarbaAmarsinhParmar EFE 133 Fem. SEBC 346.75 35 381.75 15‐Aug‐93

86 101005387 ShriPrakashkumarDevasibhaiKaneriya EFC 134 403.50 22 425.50 9‐Apr‐83

87 101005452 Kum.HiralAnilbhaiDhanesha EEY 135 Fem. 368.75 50 418.75 8‐Jul‐86

88 101005581 ShriJagdishkumarMohanbhaiMevada EDT 138 SEBC 341.00 20 361.00 11‐Mar‐77

89 101005589 Kum.PriyankabenVirsinhPargi EFN 139 Fem. S.T. 260.00 10 270.00 9‐May‐87

90 101005927 ShriNimeshkumarMahendrabhaiChaudhari EEB 141 S.T. 264.25 35 299.25 30‐Sep‐86

91 101006084 Kum.JalpaUmeshbhaiPatel EEK 142 Fem. 378.00 40 418.00 9‐Aug‐87

92 101006129 ShriSiddharajsinhVijaysinhRana EDS 143 346.25 50 396.25 7‐Jun‐88

93 101006408 Kum.NirzareeManojkumarLakhiya EHG 148 Fem. S.C. 340.75 22 362.75 28‐Mar‐89

Page 24: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 5

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

94 101006504 ShriVinodkumarSursinhKhadiya EFT 152 S.T. 263.75 32 295.75 15‐May‐93

95 101006584 Kum.MehrunnishaMohammadbhaiKothariya EHO 154 Fem. 334.75 38 372.75 28‐Sep‐81

96 101006701 ShriSanjaybhaiLakhmanbhaiMakwana EGL 155 SEBC 342.50 53 395.50 1‐Sep‐86

97 101006715 ShriPrakashbhaiMavjibhaiPatel EHP 156 367.75 28 395.75 14‐Jul‐89

98 101007000 Kum.NehabenMohitbhaiPandya EHL 159 Fem. 363.75 25 388.75 2‐Jan‐92

99 101007013 ShriRanjitkumarPashajiThakor EGF 160 SEBC 361.00 53 414.00 4‐Nov‐94

100 101007206 ShriRavikumarMaheshbhaiRathod EGM 161 SEBC 362.50 46 408.50 9‐Jul‐94

101 101007224 ShriRajuPrafulbhaiMange EGO 163 349.00 25 374.00 5‐Nov‐91

102 101007232 ShriBaldevbhaiKarmanbhaiVaviya EGI 165 359.50 32 391.50 18‐Jul‐93

103 101007264 Kum.SejalbenBakabhaiPrajapati EHB 167 Fem. SEBC 334.00 55 389.00 17‐Feb‐92

104 101007296 ShriHiteshkumarVinitrayParmar EGH 168 S.C. 354.25 47 401.25 13‐Feb‐87

105 101007306 Kum.SandhyakumariNavinbhaiChaudhari EHK 169 Fem. S.T. 259.50 25 284.50 1‐Oct‐93

106 101007309 ShriMohammedasadManzoorhusainShaikh EHJ 170 368.75 55 423.75 13‐Jul‐93

107 101007450 ShriMahendrabhaiNaginbhaiPatel EFW 171 S.T. 269.50 35 304.50 25‐Apr‐89

108 101007547 Kum.RajviDarshankumarVyas EGA 172 Fem. 337.50 25 362.50 30‐Nov‐94

109 101007561 ShriShaileshbhaiJaniyabhaiVasava EHN 173 S.T. 283.75 35 318.75 2‐Jun‐91

110 101007566 ShriRahulkumarJagdishbhaiLimbani EGC 174 360.25 52 412.25 4‐Dec‐91

111 101007652 Kum.SwatibaJaduvirsinhJadeja EGQ 175 Fem. 346.50 52 398.50 2‐Dec‐92

112 101007736 ShriAvinashkumarRakeshkumarAgrawal EHH 177 366.50 48 414.50 24‐May‐90

113 101007855 Kum.AnsuyabenShankarbhaiChavada EFX 178 Fem. SEBC 352.50 30 382.50 19‐Jan‐86

114 101007898 Kum.AvnibenJayeshkumarBattiwala EGX 179 Fem. SEBC 352.25 33 385.25 10‐Sep‐90

115 101007904 Kum.RiyaSanjaybhaiRaval EGU 180 Fem. 360.00 60 420.00 19‐Sep‐93

116 101007911 ShriHimatkumarVasantkumarBarot EGJ 181 SEBC 338.75 30 368.75 17‐Oct‐84

117 101007942 ShriVatsalbhaiSudhirbhaiDave EFP 182 348.25 40 388.25 26‐Jun‐95

118 101008117 ShriBajrangiRanglalbhaiGaud EFQ 183 383.25 37 420.25 5‐Jan‐93

Page 25: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 6

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

119 101008324 ShriMohammedsalmanGulammustufaShaikh EGB 188 355.75 28 383.75 10‐Jun‐91

120 101008512 ShriArajanbhaiDevayatbhaiSambad EGE 190 SEBC 353.00 56 409.00 1‐Jun‐89

121 101008546 ShriRakeshkumarHemrajbhaiChaudhari EGS 192 SEBC 337.25 42 379.25 7‐Jul‐87

122 101008593 ShriLalitkumarAmrutlalBhil EFO 193 S.T. 271.50 32 303.50 29‐Apr‐87

123 101008596 ShriSachinJagdishbhaiPatel EHM 194 370.50 35 405.50 31‐May‐86

124 101008656 ShriKhimjiMansukhKholiya EHC 195 Dis. 310.50 33 343.50 1‐Aug‐91

125 101008678 ShriDharmendrakumarDevchandbhaiDamor EGT 196 S.T. 254.75 45 299.75 11‐Jan‐79

126 101008709 Kum.VasantibenVashrambhaiJadav EHA 198 Fem. S.C. 349.50 38 387.50 5‐Jun‐92

127 101008756 ShriHardikGirishbhaiMehta EIC 199 354.75 62 416.75 16‐May‐86

128 101008802 ShriDhruvilMukeshbhaiTrivedi EHS 201 348.25 55 403.25 29‐Jun‐88

129 101008814 Kum.NandiniPrabodhbhaiShukla EIM 202 Fem. 361.25 57 418.25 10‐Apr‐76

130 101008861 Kum.SonalBharatkumarParmar EJM 203 Fem. SEBC 337.25 24 361.25 21‐Jul‐88

131 101008893 ShriDineshMaganbhaiMakwana EIG 204 S.C. 341.75 58 399.75 1‐Jun‐85

132 101008910 ShriSanjayRamjibhaiThakkar EIT 206 Dis. 307.00 40 347.00 9‐Sep‐84

133 101008915 ShriSalimkhanYashinkhanBaloch EHR 207 344.50 50 394.50 28‐Jul‐89

134 101008944 ShriVishalkumarJaysukhlalSoni EIP 209 363.75 30 393.75 20‐Aug‐86

135 101009036 Kum.HeenaPravinbhaiPatel EJH 210 Fem. 352.25 42 394.25 10‐May‐94

136 101009108 Kum.ChetanaAmrishbhaiUbhadiya EJN 211 Fem. 349.00 45 394.00 20‐Apr‐93

137 101009152 ShriAmarsinhRamanbhaiChaudhari EIO 212 SEBC 352.50 34 386.50 8‐Sep‐85

138 101009338 Kum.ShankhanabenMakabhaiVala EJO 214 Fem. SEBC 358.00 30 388.00 13‐Feb‐92

139 101009339 Kum.DayabenJerambhaiDudhat EJE 215 Fem. 349.25 42 391.25 27‐Jan‐92

140 101009357 Kum.SurbhibenVijaykumarThakkar EIB 216 Fem. 389.00 27 416.00 13‐Aug‐95

141 101009381 Smt.VaishaliSatishGhelani QIB 217 Fem. 358.25 43 401.25 04‐12‐1988

142 101009395 ShriMayankSKotak EIN 218 370.00 54 424.00 20‐Feb‐81

143 101009529 Kum.AanalBabubhaiChavda EJG 220 Fem. S.T. 281.50 30 311.50 18‐Dec‐91

Page 26: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 7

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

144 101009541 ShriKirtanRajeshkumarShah EIA 221 343.75 60 403.75 9‐Aug‐96

145 101009556 ShriDilipsinhHalusinhZala EHQ 222 373.50 48 421.50 4‐Feb‐91

146 101009667 ShriGirishkumarNemichandChitara EHY 224 SEBC 347.25 42 389.25 2‐Jul‐88

147 101009781 ShriRushiAjaybhaiBabariya EJF 225 374.75 43 417.75 26‐Jul‐94

148 101009785 ShriBijayMayurkumarShah EHU 227 342.50 35 377.50 26‐May‐90

149 101009804 ShriNileshbhaiNayankumarRaval EIE 228 375.75 40 415.75 12‐Jul‐83

150 101009805 Kum.ZalakBrijeshkumarPatel EJK 229 Fem. 339.75 35 374.75 21‐Nov‐88

151 101010012 ShriLakhamanVagabhaiSamala EJJ 230 S.T. 273.75 35 308.75 13‐Aug‐90

152 101010127 ShriHardevsinhAjitsinhRana EIV 231 377.00 45 422.00 30‐Dec‐85

153 101010187 ShriUmeshbhaiRajnibhaiPatel EIH 232 378.50 40 418.50 6‐Aug‐88

154 101010302 ShriJiralkumarMahendrakumarDamor EIJ 233 S.T. 278.00 32 310.00 14‐Sep‐86

155 101010580 ShriRajeshkumarBhachuJaru EHZ 236 SEBC 339.00 35 374.00 11‐Mar‐84

156 101010630 ShriKripalsinhBahadursinhParmar EIS 237 361.25 35 396.25 31‐Mar‐93

157 101010885 ShriKetanJentibhaiMathukia EJL 240 384.00 32 416.00 20‐Feb‐87

158 101010922 Kum.NamrataDipakkumarBarot EJD 242 Fem. 357.00 25 382.00 10‐Apr‐93

159 101010949 ShriNarendrakumarMaganlalGohil EIZ 243 S.C. 350.25 56 406.25 27‐Dec‐89

160 101010958 Kum.PriyankabenRameshbhaiPatel EIK 244 Fem. 337.00 50 387.00 6‐Nov‐88

161 101010976 Kum.HemangiIndravadanbhaiRathod EIR 245 Fem. Dis. 302.50 47 349.50 30‐Dec‐93

162 101011145 ShriVikramkumarGajendrapalNinama EHW 246 S.T. 280.00 35 315.00 26‐Nov‐92

163 101011162 Kum.AartiJagdishbhaiBhojani EJB 247 Fem. 361.75 40 401.75 3‐Feb‐90

164 101011185 Kum.DevanshiDineshbhaiPatel EIW 248 Fem. 338.50 25 363.50 8‐Jul‐96

165 101011226 ShriSanjaykumarRameshbhaiKhatri EIQ 250 377.50 28 405.50 1‐Jun‐92

166 101011232 ShriBhupendraChhaganbhaiBangal EID 251 S.T. 268.25 31 299.25 1‐Jan‐84

167 101011234 Kum.VaishalibenSatendraprsadPandya EIY 252 Fem. 336.00 35 371.00 25‐Dec‐85

168 101011355 ShriIliyasJamalbhaiVaraiya EKX 253 SEBC 347.75 47 394.75 28‐Oct‐87

Page 27: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 8

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

169 101011414 ShriRakeshAshokbhaiSorathiya EKK 254 363.75 35 398.75 8‐Dec‐91

170 101011473 ShriDilipbhaiChunilalChauhan EKO 256 S.T. 252.75 37 289.75 1‐Jun‐81

171 101011514 Kum.JollybenSureshbhaiDhingani ELQ 257 Fem. 341.25 53 394.25 28‐Apr‐85

172 101011550 ShriDharmeshBabubhaiPagada EKN 258 343.25 59 402.25 29‐Oct‐84

173 101011623 ShriJaydipsinhJagatsinhDiyol EKE 259 357.75 40 397.75 28‐Jan‐87

174 101011693 ShriVishalkumarMaheshbhaiPatel EJS 261 348.00 55 403.00 15‐Jun‐93

175 101011725 ShriAshvinkumarKalyanbhaiSuthar EKW 262 SEBC 344.75 38 382.75 7‐Mar‐95

176 101011811 ShriVipulkumarChetanbhaiGamit ELF 264 S.T. 262.50 28 290.50 10‐Sep‐85

177 101011953 ShriMehulkumarTansingbhaiNisarta EKU 265 S.T. 257.75 23 280.75 20‐Jan‐93

178 101012378 ShriJayeshKuberbhaiParmar EKC 266 SEBC 354.25 56 410.25 2‐Feb‐92

179 101012431 ShriAlpeshkumarMadhavlalPatel ELK 267 346.00 58 404.00 17‐May‐84

180 101012474 ShriChiragBharatkumarVaghela EKP 268 SEBC 360.00 55 415.00 20‐Sep‐94

181 101012864 ShriPareshBhimabhaiChopda ELO 270 S.T. 259.50 35 294.50 16‐Aug‐93

182 101012901 Kum.DinkalDineshkumarAlgotar EKJ 271 Fem. S.C. 351.25 37 388.25 16‐Jun‐91

183 101013149 ShriKetanMansukhbhaiVaru EJR 274 361.75 30 391.75 13‐Dec‐89

184 101013256 ShriAravindkumarHirabhaiChaudhary ELI 276 SEBC 364.50 45 409.50 15‐Jun‐89

185 101013346 Kum.HetalbenAshokkumarMahuvagara ELH 277 Fem. 349.00 50 399.00 20‐Jun‐96

186 101013368 ShriPriteshSanjaybhaiVasava EJZ 278 S.T. 292.25 32 324.25 5‐Jan‐94

187 101013661 ShriPratapsinhRanvirbhaiKamaria EKY 279 SEBC 367.50 35 402.50 1‐Jul‐89

188 101013864 ShriPrashantsinghChandraprakashsinghRajput EJX 281 360.00 38 398.00 29‐Apr‐87

189 101013870 ShriDhavalRohitbhaiJoshi EKD 282 343.50 50 393.50 28‐Sep‐90

190 101013876 ShriMilanJitendrakumarShukl ELJ 283 341.50 50 391.50 4‐Aug‐89

191 101014059 Kum.RekhaPolabhaiKalotra EKQ 286 Fem. SEBC 338.25 46 384.25 25‐Oct‐92

192 101014097 ShriUmmulsalilGulamhusenChauhan EKM 287 379.00 30 409.00 15‐May‐81

193 101014277 ShriTejaskumarVasharambhaiVadher EKV 290 SEBC 355.00 38 393.00 20‐Mar‐84

Page 28: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 9

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

194 101014307 ShriJatinNarendrabhaiChauhan EKH 291 S.C. 343.25 38 381.25 25‐Feb‐82

195 101014328 ShriKiranAmaratbhaiDesai EKB 292 342.75 42 384.75 12‐Feb‐92

196 101014360 Smt.PayalSandipSheth EKS 293 Fem. 350.50 38 388.50 23‐Jun‐88

197 101014368 ShriRahulImanuelDund EKI 294 S.T. 281.00 30 311.00 18‐Jun‐90

198 101014575 ShriJigarkumarMahendrabhaiShah ELC 297 SEBC 361.75 33 394.75 16‐Nov‐88

199 101014669 Kum.PoojaRameshchandraPujara ELB 298 Fem. 350.50 35 385.50 3‐Jul‐88

200 101014835 Kum.JinishaRameshbhaiHathila ELN 301 Fem. S.T. 268.75 25 293.75 17‐Oct‐91

201 101015057 ShriGopalVirabhaiBarad EKR 303 SEBC 346.00 45 391.00 19‐Sep‐86

202 101015059 ShriChiragVijaykumarMenat EJY 304 S.T. 269.75 30 299.75 16‐Jul‐84

203 101015085 ShriAnilkumarRadheshyamSadhu ELP 305 SEBC 347.25 40 387.25 23‐Oct‐93

204 101015102 Kum.NeepaPrabhudasHindocha ELR 306 Fem. 380.75 40 420.75 21‐Aug‐77

205 101015103 ShriVipulZaverbhaiDesai EMF 307 SEBC 363.25 38 401.25 10‐May‐95

206 101015216 ShriJaydeepsinhKiritsinhBarad ENA 309 SEBC 337.00 40 377.00 22‐Oct‐93

207 101015251 ShriRamjibhaiParmabhaiPatel ELU 310 SEBC Dis. 304.75 33 337.75 1‐Jun‐78

208 101015280 ShriHarshalNavinchandraPatel EME 312 372.75 47 419.75 10‐Oct‐93

209 101015298 ShriHirenJentibhaiRokad ELV 314 344.50 42 386.50 6‐Sep‐90

210 101015318 ShriArvindkumarHakmajiChaudhary EMR 315 SEBC 361.25 33 394.25 3‐Jun‐96

211 101015339 Kum.MittalbenKanubhaiParmar EMX 316 Fem. SEBC 347.75 45 392.75 2‐Jan‐91

212 101015459 Kum.NipaShambhubhaiSakariya EMA 317 Fem. 341.75 36 377.75 9‐May‐90

213 101015477 Kum.DhartibenDevchandbhaiSoni ELW 318 Fem. 364.25 36 400.25 4‐Jan‐92

214 101015480 ShriAshishkumarGovindbhaiPatel EMN 319 356.00 36 392.00 16‐Apr‐88

215 101015589 ShriSehjadahmedkhanMujaffarkhanPathan ENJ 321 349.25 40 389.25 28‐Jan‐90

216 101015655 ShriUtsavKiritkumarPatel EMY 322 339.25 35 374.25 21‐Sep‐89

217 101015669 ShriNareshkumarJayantilalThakar EMZ 323 353.00 31 384.00 14‐Jul‐80

218 101015673 ShriAtulbhaiKantibhaiMakwana ENP 324 382.75 38 420.75 24‐Mar‐88

Page 29: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 10

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

219 101015689 ShriNayangiriArvindgiriGosai ELS 325 SEBC 337.25 28 365.25 10‐Dec‐84

220 101015719 ShriAshishPremjibhaiRathod EMJ 326 SEBC 365.00 38 403.00 25‐Dec‐77

221 101015722 ShriShyambhaiSonubhaiAhir END 327 S.T. 276.00 48 324.00 24‐Jul‐85

222 101015818 Kum.CharmiKiritkumarAjmera ENC 329 Fem. 375.50 40 415.50 25‐Feb‐83

223 101015947 ShriDhansukhbhaiMotibhaiPrajapati EMB 331 SEBC 377.25 31 408.25 2‐May‐83

224 101015999 Kum.LeenaKunteshChauhan EMT 333 Fem. SEBC 347.00 48 395.00 10‐Sep‐90

225 101016007 ShriAmitPanchabhaiDesai ENO 334 SEBC 365.75 35 400.75 15‐Jun‐87

226 101016076 ShriAshokbhaiGhanshyambhaiMalaviya ENR 335 377.00 38 415.00 8‐Oct‐88

227 101016120 ShriManishkumarRavishchandraPathak ELZ 336 385.50 35 420.50 8‐May‐87

228 101016239 ShriHasmukhbhaiIshvarlalBarot ENH 339 SEBC 370.00 30 400.00 1‐Jun‐81

229 101016406 ShriAlpeshbhaiShaharbhaiRabari EMI 340 SEBC 339.25 35 374.25 22‐Nov‐90

230 101016588 ShriDhavalsinhBhammarsinhVaghela EMG 341 389.75 30 419.75 14‐Nov‐88

231 101016799 Kum.RuchitabenBabubhaiVaghela ENN 345 Fem. S.T. 255.75 35 290.75 25‐Mar‐95

232 101016817 ShriAshishPravinbhaiSavani ELT 347 355.50 38 393.50 19‐Jun‐95

233 101016905 Kum.RinaVikramsinhChauhan ENE 349 Fem. 383.25 35 418.25 3‐Jul‐89

234 101016994 ShriJaypalsinhChandrasinhGohil ENM 350 364.75 50 414.75 16‐Jan‐90

235 101017059 ShriVipulkumarGovindbhaiKhoradiya EMU 352 SEBC 367.75 30 397.75 16‐Mar‐88

236 101017081 ShriMayurVinodbhaiAmrutiya ENL 353 368.25 52 420.25 1‐Jul‐87

237 101017210 Kum.KrupaliSukhdevsinhVaghela EMO 354 Fem. 351.50 35 386.50 9‐Dec‐95

238 101017256 ShriDenishkumarGovindbhaiKhambhadiya ENF 355 364.25 42 406.25 12‐Oct‐90

239 101017322 ShriMunjalNarendraDave EMQ 357 370.00 43 413.00 4‐Jan‐83

240 101000656 Kum.NikitaBhupendrabhaiPathak ENY 362 Fem. 341.25 45 386.25 13‐Jul‐89

241 101000748 ShriDivyeshSuryashankarDave EOS 363 357.00 32 389.00 23‐May‐87

242 101001176 ShriDasharathbhaiPurushottambhaiPatel EOE 364 380.00 36 416.00 15‐Jun‐82

243 101017660 ShriKantibhaiMahadevbhaiBharavad EPO 367 SEBC 364.50 28 392.50 19‐Oct‐93

Page 30: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 11

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

244 101017714 ShriDalajibhaiParthibhaiChaudhary EOR 368 SEBC 358.25 56 414.25 23‐Jul‐92

245 101017773 Kum.KrishnaAtulbhaiBarad EOU 369 Fem. SEBC 344.50 40 384.50 5‐Jun‐94

246 101017877 Kum.PriyankaGhanshyambhaiSonagra EOO 371 Fem. SEBC 342.25 32 374.25 1‐Jun‐93

247 101018018 ShriSachinKanaiyalalBhatt ENW 373 344.50 30 374.50 13‐Oct‐79

248 101018032 Kum.JinalManubhaiSolanki EOG 374 Fem. S.C. 354.25 25 379.25 24‐Jul‐93

249 101018041 Kum.KusumbenGaneshbhaiGavit EPB 375 Fem. S.T. 280.25 28 308.25 1‐Jun‐90

250 101018053 ShriDipeshJayantilalShingala EPT 376 342.75 55 397.75 6‐Sep‐90

251 101018076 ShriDarshanHarishbhaiThakkar EPS 377 337.00 38 375.00 9‐Apr‐94

252 101018141 Kum.BhagyashreeKanaiyalalRathod EOK 379 Fem. SEBC 354.50 40 394.50 24‐Jul‐91

253 101018181 ShriVipulPrabhubhaiRathod EPH 380 SEBC 337.00 42 379.00 18‐Jul‐90

254 101018226 ShriIshvarbhaiRatnabhaiPatel EPE 381 SEBC 363.75 40 403.75 25‐Aug‐85

255 101018266 Kum.NazbinaNizamuddinShaikh EPI 382 Fem. 365.75 52 417.75 7‐Jan‐90

256 101018317 ShriAmitKantibhaiMakwana EOJ 383 S.T. 260.25 35 295.25 29‐Dec‐90

257 101018546 Smt.JalpaMombhaiParmar EPC 384 Fem. SEBC 338.75 32 370.75 14‐Apr‐85

258 101018582 Kum.SwatiKishorchandraAjamera EPR 385 Fem. SEBC 337.75 38 375.75 30‐Aug‐89

259 101018617 Smt.RanjanbenRatilalVasava EOM 386 Fem. S.T. 263.25 30 293.25 15‐Oct‐86

260 101018730 ShriVajuBhagvanbhaiJadav EOC 388 SEBC 343.25 57 400.25 1‐Jun‐87

261 101018834 ShriYuvrajsinhPravinsinhVaghela EOD 390 339.00 55 394.00 19‐Feb‐90

262 101018970 ShriVishalkumarJayantilalGogari EOI 393 360.25 45 405.25 10‐Apr‐89

263 101018993 ShriManishkumarAmrutbhaiDesai EPG 394 SEBC 364.00 45 409.00 23‐Jan‐90

264 101018997 ShriKenilShaileshkumarShah EOB 395 354.50 25 379.50 16‐Jan‐95

265 101019150 ShriDhavalJitendraBharwad ENX 396 SEBC 345.75 37 382.75 12‐Jul‐95

266 101019216 ShriVishalRameshbhaiGorvadiya EOP 398 SEBC 350.00 46 396.00 3‐Jun‐89

267 101019219 ShriMaheshdanKhumansingBarhat EON 399 SEBC 341.25 32 373.25 19‐Jun‐80

268 101019237 Kum.UshabenDahyabhaiKoradiya EPF 400 Fem. S.C. 357.75 30 387.75 18‐Dec‐83

Page 31: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 12

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

269 101019303 Kum.KamalDilipkumarMehta EPL 401 Fem. 355.50 50 405.50 18‐Oct‐92

270 101019517 ShriKetulkumarRanchhodbhaiPatel EPN 403 375.50 45 420.50 28‐Jul‐92

271 101019570 ShriSureshbhaiKhemabhaiCharel ENS 404 S.T. 253.50 50 303.50 2‐Jun‐90

272 101019897 ShriShivrajbhaiKathubhaiVaru EPA 407 SEBC 353.25 58 411.25 1‐Jun‐87

273 101019912 ShriTrusharkumarIshwarbhaiPanchal ENT 409 Dis. 305.25 42 347.25 1‐Nov‐78

274 101019937 ShriChintanJitendrakumarVyas EOA 410 342.75 47 389.75 5‐Feb‐89

275 101020019 Kum.JyotsanaManjibhaiBheel EOY 413 Fem. SEBC 337.00 30 367.00 26‐Dec‐84

276 101020074 ShriUmeshkumarRajubhaiShah EOV 414 350.75 53 403.75 26‐Jan‐80

277 101001729 ShriAshishAnilkumarAmdavadi EQN 416 369.25 50 419.25 13‐Aug‐90

278 101002048 ShriPravinsinhManubhaJadeja EPW 418 366.50 35 401.50 6‐Sep‐86

279 101002551 ShriSanjaykumarAmrutbhaiPatani EPU 419 SEBC 345.25 35 380.25 30‐Sep‐87

280 101020121 ShriAnkitPragneshbhaiPatel EQT 420 355.75 34 389.75 28‐Dec‐93

281 101020140 ShriMayurrajSukhdevsinhJadeja EQF 421 339.00 40 379.00 19‐Feb‐92

282 101020158 ShriJigarkumarAshokbhaiLimbachiya EQC 422 SEBC 338.00 40 378.00 30‐Jun‐93

283 101020232 ShriSunilkumarVishnubhaiPrajapati EQR 425 SEBC 338.00 40 378.00 20‐Nov‐89

284 101020262 ShriJayshilVikrambhaiPatel EQQ 427 355.50 29 384.50 25‐May‐89

285 101020339 ShriIsharahmadKhalilullakhanPathan ERA 428 337.50 30 367.50 19‐Dec‐95

286 101020412 ShriVishalkumarLaxmidasVekariya ERH 430 354.75 42 396.75 27‐Jul‐89

287 101020514 ShriNikunjkumarAjitsinhChavda EQI 431 SEBC 363.75 45 408.75 7‐Nov‐91

288 101020559 ShriHiralalRameshbhaiDesrani ERR 432 349.25 51 400.25 7‐Dec‐79

289 101020611 ShriFuldipNarayanbhaiPatel EQP 433 370.25 55 425.25 4‐Dec‐88

290 101020736 ShriDivyeshkumarMohanlalPatel EQL 434 SEBC 352.00 48 400.00 31‐Jul‐82

291 101020750 ShriMaheshbhaiKhemabhaiMali ERC 435 SEBC 355.75 42 397.75 21‐Apr‐94

292 101020799 Kum.TinubenKishanbhaiSolanki EQW 436 Fem. S.T. 268.25 28 296.25 2‐Dec‐85

293 101020835 ShriSanjaykumarPravinsinhGohil EQV 437 337.50 42 379.50 23‐Mar‐80

Page 32: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 13

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

294 101020887 ShriNareshkumarShamjibhaiParaliya EPZ 439 SEBC 350.75 48 398.75 25‐Jul‐88

295 101020965 ShriPragneshJethabhaiVaghela EQK 440 S.C. 339.00 27 366.00 29‐Jul‐91

296 101021132 Kum.SumitrabenJayantilalPandor ERP 442 Fem. S.T. 292.00 28 320.00 20‐Jun‐90

297 101021143 ShriHarshadMafatlalDesai EQX 443 SEBC 353.00 53 406.00 12‐Sep‐93

298 101021145 Smt.VaishaliKalujiMalaviya ERS 444 Fem. S.T. 270.50 33 303.50 17‐May‐88

299 101021431 Kum.EktaMansukhlalDadhaniya ERQ 450 Fem. 345.75 47 392.75 1‐Mar‐82

300 101021487 ShriParthAnilbhaiRaval ERM 451 338.50 46 384.50 6‐Nov‐88

301 101021491 ShriNiteshKantilalPatel QIV 452 366.00 45 411.00 01‐02‐1981

302 101021512 Kum.TarunabaKiratsinhParmar EQM 453 Fem. 342.75 48 390.75 20‐Dec‐91

303 101021543 Smt.DrashtiMilapRaiyarela EQH 455 Fem. 348.00 35 383.00 26‐Jun‐89

304 101021550 Kum.NeetiUpendrabhaiPathak ERB 457 Fem. 341.75 45 386.75 11‐Mar‐96

305 101021553 ShriAshvinkumarRamaniklalBhatt ERJ 458 346.50 45 391.50 16‐Jul‐91

306 101021574 ShriJaydeepShantilalSolanki EQY 459 SEBC 344.00 44 388.00 12‐Jun‐88

307 101021669 Smt.RanjanbenBhagubhaiVasava ERL 461 Fem. S.T. 253.25 30 283.25 4‐Jul‐83

308 101021751 ShriVirendrasinhDilavarsinhZala EQS 462 384.75 42 426.75 28‐Jan‐88

309 101021779 ShriVishalsinhLabhubhaiSindhav EQO 463 SEBC 368.50 40 408.50 27‐Sep‐83

310 101021818 Kum.VarshabenManchhibhaiVasava EPV 464 Fem. S.T. 292.25 26 318.25 25‐Jul‐81

311 101021874 ShriAshokChhaganBapodara EQB 465 SEBC 346.00 38 384.00 24‐May‐87

312 101021900 ShriVishalkumarDevendrabhaiPandya EQG 466 362.25 30 392.25 23‐Feb‐91

313 101022000 ShriNilayKishanbhaiHalpati ERG 468 S.T. 261.50 35 296.50 2‐Dec‐94

314 101002939 ShriMiteshkumarBhimabhaiPatel ETA 469 S.T. 263.50 30 293.50 18‐Mar‐85

315 101003478 Kum.SangitasinhHarshadkumarRao ESR 472 Fem. SEBC 364.00 28 392.00 19‐Oct‐89

316 101022015 ShriSanjaykumarRasiklalSakaliya ESO 474 SEBC 348.50 35 383.50 9‐Jun‐88

317 101022237 ShriMehulkumarBabanbhaiPatil ESA 479 378.75 46 424.75 16‐Nov‐87

318 101022271 ShriHiteshkumarMahendrabhaiPatel ESN 480 363.25 30 393.25 30‐Jul‐89

Page 33: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 14

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

319 101022320 Kum.KinjalbenSagarbhaiDesai ERX 482 Fem. SEBC 354.75 40 394.75 15‐Jun‐92

320 101022371 ShriJigneshkumarHarjibhaiGangadiya ESZ 483 S.C. 345.75 35 380.75 27‐Mar‐88

321 101022458 Kum.JainaMaheshbhaiBhutaiya ESP 485 Fem. SEBC 336.50 45 381.50 26‐Jun‐94

322 101022493 ShriHardikkumarBhikhajiThakor ERV 486 SEBC 376.00 36 412.00 22‐Jun‐93

323 101022593 ShriMayankbhaiSujitbhaiChaudhari ESY 487 S.T. 256.25 28 284.25 20‐Apr‐94

324 101022615 Kum.EktaYogeshkumarMehta ESV 488 Fem. 347.00 35 382.00 4‐Aug‐91

325 101022627 ShriParaskumarMangubhaiPatel ERY 489 S.T. 260.00 30 290.00 15‐Aug‐88

326 101022814 ShriPankajkumarMotibhaiBhabhor ESW 491 S.T. 257.50 26 283.50 29‐Sep‐87

327 101022848 Smt.TejalJagatsinhVaghela ESU 492 Fem. 364.75 28 392.75 29‐Mar‐79

328 101022862 ShriKrunalkumarPrakashkumarShah EST 493 371.25 50 421.25 6‐Oct‐86

329 101023143 ShriAshishJitendrakumarPatel ESI 495 371.25 38 409.25 25‐May‐87

330 101023212 ShriAkshaykumarChandrakantbhaiThakkar ESJ 496 344.25 35 379.25 14‐Jul‐93

331 101023227 ShriMunvarsinhMahendrasinhVaghela ESH 497 359.00 37 396.00 15‐Aug‐91

332 101023364 ShriMoianRajakbhaiSorathiya ESX 500 382.00 40 422.00 8‐Jul‐88

333 101023417 ShriKuldeepManharbhaiLakhani ESK 502 349.00 54 403.00 6‐Dec‐87

334 101023459 ShriTejasShashikantPachchigar ETB 503 380.25 47 427.25 8‐May‐90

335 101023463 ShriPankilChandrakantbhaiShah ETC 504 340.00 45 385.00 20‐Sep‐90

336 101004809 ShriSunilGulabbhaiTejwani EUB 505 342.50 50 392.50 25‐Apr‐91

337 101004879 ShriHiteshArvindbhaiVora ETI 506 356.50 40 396.50 28‐Aug‐87

338 101005426 ShriTusharbhaiManoharbhaiJangade ETX 508 376.50 35 411.50 30‐Aug‐88

339 101023873 ShriJitendrasinhPravinsinhVaghela EUH 511 345.50 32 377.50 10‐Nov‐89

340 101023890 ShriKalpeshDevrajbhaiBusa EUC 512 359.50 50 409.50 23‐Sep‐88

341 101023911 ShriChintankumarVikrambhaiPatel ETP 513 343.00 43 386.00 20‐Jun‐87

342 101024024 Kum.DeepaSamirbhaiThakkar ETU 514 Fem. 370.00 35 405.00 31‐Jul‐83

343 101024141 Kum.BhavnabenVisanjiThakkar EUJ 516 Fem. 361.00 37 398.00 20‐Jun‐88

Page 34: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 15

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

344 101024304 ShriBrijrajsinhNirmalsinhSarvaiya ETR 518 368.50 53 421.50 1‐May‐87

345 101024306 ShriParthUmeshbhaiMehta EUE 519 355.50 52 407.50 6‐Jan‐91

346 101024479 Kum.HardikaKshitijTrivedi ETZ 521 Fem. 356.00 28 384.00 2‐Jun‐87

347 101024586 ShriAnilbhaiBabubhaiGohil ETV 524 S.T. 278.75 43 321.75 14‐Jan‐84

348 101024806 Kum.ChandrikaParixitRaygor EUF 529 Fem. 367.00 32 399.00 30‐Dec‐84

349 101024823 ShriParthNarendrakumarSolanki ETW 531 S.C. 347.00 38 385.00 25‐Oct‐92

350 101024833 ShriMayursinhAnopsinhVaghela EUG 533 345.50 37 382.50 31‐Dec‐94

351 101024916 ShriChiragLalitkumarAmin ETJ 534 S.C. 354.50 50 404.50 16‐Aug‐84

352 101024925 ShriMukundPrakashbhaiTrivedi EUD 535 342.75 55 397.75 1‐Jul‐87

353 101024973 Kum.ChandabenGanpatbhaiBhoye ETS 538 Fem. S.T. 268.50 45 313.50 5‐Jan‐92

354 101024978 ShriDarshangiriShantigiriGoswami EUI 539 SEBC 343.75 35 378.75 24‐Apr‐88

355 101024981 ShriNarendrakumarGirdharilalKhatik EUO 540 SEBC 350.50 30 380.50 12‐Jun‐94

356 101006005 ShriPravinkumarManabhaiDamor EVT 541 S.T. 278.00 45 323.00 29‐Sep‐89

357 101006158 ShriSanjayRameshbhaiMehta EVL 543 384.25 30 414.25 23‐Sep‐88

358 101006763 Smt.ReetaGhanshyamNayak EVW 544 Fem. SEBC 345.25 40 385.25 29‐Oct‐89

359 101024989 ShriVijendrakumarPravinbhaiRevar EVO 546 S.C. 354.75 44 398.75 17‐Aug‐87

360 101024990 ShriBhaskarrayPravinkumarJoshi EUT 547 340.25 35 375.25 12‐Nov‐91

361 101025003 Kum.SahistaBabubhaiJuneja EVU 548 Fem. 335.00 20 355.00 7‐Apr‐89

362 101025021 ShriPradipsinhKishorsinhJadeja EVS 549 380.50 45 425.50 14‐Dec‐87

363 101025081 ShriChetankumarArjanbhaiKuvadiya EUZ 550 347.50 25 372.50 28‐Dec‐88

364 101025141 Kum.MittalbenRavjibhaiModiya EVC 551 Fem. S.T. 265.00 26 291.00 2‐Jan‐96

365 101025175 ShriVikramNathulalUpadhyay EUX 554 350.00 30 380.00 25‐May‐84

366 101025373 Kum.JuheebenRamanlalPandav EVA 557 Fem. S.T. 271.25 28 299.25 3‐Nov‐93

367 101025420 ShriBhavnishDipakTrivedi EVM 558 347.50 43 390.50 10‐May‐93

368 101025497 ShriManishsinhLalsinhSolanki EVG 560 342.50 40 382.50 1‐Jul‐92

Page 35: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 16

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

369 101025712 ShriMiteshAshokbhaPathak EVI 561 356.25 45 401.25 6‐Oct‐80

370 101025757 ShriNalinkumarRameshbhaiGamit EUR 562 S.T. 254.75 30 284.75 9‐Jun‐90

371 101025849 Kum.MayuribenKalubhaiKatrodiya EUV 563 Fem. 372.25 42 414.25 14‐Dec‐93

372 101025864 ShriNaranRudabhaiNagas EVB 564 S.T. 258.00 40 298.00 24‐Jun‐90

373 101025866 Kum.PunambenHardasbhaiSavaliya EUW 565 Fem. 334.50 32 366.50 23‐Sep‐87

374 101025891 Kum.JagrutiDasharathbhaiPatel EVY 566 Fem. 354.50 30 384.50 31‐Jul‐96

375 101026143 ShriMohsinGulamhusenShaikh EUP 569 378.00 30 408.00 27‐Jan‐89

376 101026189 Kum.MasumbenRakeshbhaiPatel EVK 570 Fem. 345.25 32 377.25 4‐Oct‐91

377 101026218 ShriRakeshkumarBhagvanbhaiRathavi EVJ 571 SEBC 341.00 40 381.00 5‐Aug‐92

378 101026338 ShriJayUmeshkumarChhatbar EVH 574 347.25 25 372.25 3‐Oct‐84

379 101026367 ShriSureshkumarMaragiabhaiVasava EUU 575 S.T. 268.50 30 298.50 15‐Apr‐85

380 101008285 Smt.JignabenNiravbhaiDave EXF 579 Fem. 348.75 40 388.75 29‐Sep‐82

381 101008724 ShriSandipkumarKantilalPatel EXD 580 S.T. 278.00 33 311.00 28‐Mar‐81

382 101009083 Kum.TwinkalVeljibhaiBhojani EWS 581 Fem. 334.75 22 356.75 29‐Jul‐87

383 101026484 ShriBalbhadrasinhPravinsinhJadeja EWL 582 341.25 40 381.25 15‐May‐91

384 101026667 ShriDhavalJayantilalPanchal EXG 585 390.25 30 420.25 14‐Aug‐89

385 101026669 ShriBharatkumarKantilalPala EWR 586 338.25 25 363.25 29‐Sep‐79

386 101026780 Kum.RitabenRatilalbhaiGamit EXE 588 Fem. S.T. 261.50 30 291.50 24‐Sep‐90

387 101026815 Kum.AnjaliRajendraShah EWD 589 Fem. 340.25 50 390.25 19‐Jan‐94

388 101026960 ShriTofiqaliNajamuddinSaiyad EWH 590 347.50 35 382.50 28‐Aug‐85

389 101026999 ShriChandreshRatilalButani EXI 591 384.75 38 422.75 15‐Jun‐93

390 101027162 Kum.LaxmiGovabhaiRabari EWE 592 Fem. SEBC 353.50 33 386.50 5‐Jul‐91

391 101027201 ShriKalpeshkumarBhagvandasPrajapati EXB 593 SEBC 378.00 32 410.00 18‐Jun‐84

392 101027216 Kum.MiralbenRashmikantbhaiDave EWU 594 Fem. 370.50 30 400.50 2‐Oct‐94

393 101027217 ShriKetankumarGirishbhaiSumesara EWQ 595 S.C. 349.50 49 398.50 29‐Apr‐90

Page 36: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 17

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

394 101027390 Kum.BindiyaManubhaiParmar EWY 599 Fem. S.C. 346.75 38 384.75 8‐Nov‐90

395 101027453 ShriChiragDilipkumarTrivedi EWO 601 342.25 40 382.25 21‐Jul‐92

396 101027667 ShriVishvanandKeshavdasJadav EWK 602 347.75 25 372.75 1‐Mar‐85

397 101027745 ShriKetankumarShankarlalPatel EWV 603 366.25 45 411.25 26‐Feb‐84

398 101027829 Kum.HetalkumariMahendrabhaiThathagar EWZ 604 Fem. 339.25 59 398.25 2‐Feb‐88

399 101027846 ShriShaileshkumarZinabhaiVasava EWP 605 S.T. 256.50 22 278.50 21‐Sep‐79

400 101027849 Kum.PriyaVaghjiAhir EXH 606 Fem. SEBC 358.75 35 393.75 14‐Nov‐93

401 101027969 ShriGauravkumarKarsanbhaiChaudhari EWA 608 S.T. 268.25 30 298.25 4‐Dec‐85

402 101028087 ShriMohitrajsinhNirmalsinhChudasama EWT 609 349.00 50 399.00 1‐Mar‐91

403 101028092 ShriGautamGopalbhaiHaran EWN 610 SEBC 367.75 40 407.75 20‐Nov‐90

404 101028166 Kum.ManishabenDhirajlalPatel EXC 611 Fem. 358.75 40 398.75 20‐Nov‐89

405 101009195 ShriNirmalkumarAtulbhaiVora EXT 614 359.50 48 407.50 25‐Jul‐90

406 101009711 Kum.AnitaNaranbhaiDangar EYY 616 Fem. SEBC 338.00 52 390.00 28‐Sep‐84

407 101028661 Kum.JahanviJagdishchandraTrivedi EZD 619 Fem. 363.25 52 415.25 27‐Feb‐95

408 101028773 ShriSandipGambhirsinhMod EXS 620 337.00 45 382.00 30‐Aug‐85

409 101028875 ShriMahipalsinhMadansinhRathod EYI 621 341.75 48 389.75 1‐Nov‐83

410 101028899 ShriJitendrakumarHirabhaiSolanki EYN 622 SEBC 342.25 50 392.25 1‐Jun‐78

411 101028935 Kum.MinalVeljibhaiBhojani EYH 623 Fem. 343.25 41 384.25 3‐Apr‐85

412 101028991 ShriDilipkumarParshottambhaiChauhan EXN 624 SEBC 339.75 53 392.75 5‐Jul‐90

413 101029101 ShriDharamkumarVinodbhaiSaliya EYP 628 S.C. 356.25 40 396.25 11‐Jun‐88

414 101029199 ShriPragneshDineshbhaiShah EXQ 630 375.00 48 423.00 26‐Jan‐81

415 101029203 ShriBhaveshBhurabhaiDesai EXY 631 SEBC 346.75 33 379.75 15‐Dec‐91

416 101029234 ShriRajendrasinhDeepsangjiVaghela EXX 632 365.25 30 395.25 4‐Apr‐88

417 101029258 Kum.DeepikaKishorsinghPawar EYA 633 Fem. 356.25 30 386.25 27‐Jul‐94

418 101029285 Kum.ShivangibaSahdevsinhChudasama EYX 634 Fem. 360.50 25 385.50 24‐Jun‐94

Page 37: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 18

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

419 101029290 ShriAshvinkumarBharatbhaiJadav EXL 635 349.25 40 389.25 1‐Jun‐87

420 101029314 Kum.HarsiddhbaKaransinhChavada EZB 636 Fem. 342.00 45 387.00 14‐Feb‐88

421 101029449 ShriHiteshkumarShankarlalParmar EXJ 641 S.C. 346.50 45 391.50 5‐Jun‐84

422 101029535 ShriSandipkumarKantilalRana EXO 643 SEBC 342.25 40 382.25 2‐Aug‐85

423 101029549 ShriBhavikDhirajlalDasani EYK 644 356.25 53 409.25 4‐Feb‐81

424 101029575 Smt.VibhutiMaheshKakadiya EZA 645 Fem. 377.50 42 419.50 10‐Aug‐85

425 101029595 Smt.HarshaBharatkumarBaldaniya EYR 646 Fem. SEBC 354.00 22 376.00 17‐Nov‐87

426 101029688 Kum.GayatribenRasiklalSoni EYF 649 Fem. 359.25 37 396.25 5‐Sep‐90

427 101029693 Kum.KundanbenRamjibhaiPatel EZJ 650 Fem. SEBC 346.50 32 378.50 19‐Oct‐87

428 101029900 ShriKuldipsinhRamdevsinhJadeja EXV 652 367.50 45 412.50 1‐Jan‐91

429 101029916 Kum.VaishaliGorchandbhaiNisarta EYL 653 Fem. S.T. 279.75 25 304.75 11‐Oct‐92

430 101029933 Kum.JagrutiChandubhaiRatanpara EYQ 654 Fem. 369.75 40 409.75 10‐Aug‐84

431 101030200 Kum.RajeshwaribaKaransinhSolanki EZH 657 Fem. 340.00 45 385.00 30‐Aug‐84

432 101030285 Smt.RamilabenBharubhaiMaliwad EYW 661 Fem. S.T. 291.50 30 321.50 29‐Jun‐82

433 101030325 ShriChetanDilipChauhan EYB 662 S.T. 258.00 30 288.00 29‐May‐89

434 101030358 Kum.BinnyHarshadbhaiChevli EZF 663 Fem. 354.25 37 391.25 3‐Apr‐87

435 101030500 Kum.HimanshibenGirishkumarSagar EYU 664 Fem. SEBC 341.00 23 364.00 21‐Apr‐94

436 101030543 Kum.RuchiAjaykumarTalati EYT 665 Fem. 355.50 35 390.50 31‐Jan‐89

437 101030556 Kum.SwetaPradipkumarSolanki EYS 666 Fem. SEBC 336.25 45 381.25 20‐Jun‐92

438 101011565 Kum.SandhyaManilalBhoya QAY 668 Fem. S.T. 271.25 35 306.25 16‐Feb‐91

439 101012315 ShriManishGyanchandRoyda EZV 670 364.25 40 404.25 24‐Apr‐89

440 101030609 ShriDharmeshKaramasibhaiDesai QAM 673 SEBC 337.75 20 357.75 11‐Dec‐88

441 101030685 ShriKirtiDineshbhaiManavadariya EZY 674 349.75 42 391.75 17‐Jul‐85

442 101030786 Kum.FarjanabanuAmirbhaiMalek QBB 676 Fem. 339.00 25 364.00 2‐Jul‐93

443 101030790 Kum.MehaSatishkumarTadvi EZT 677 Fem. S.T. 267.75 28 295.75 12‐Jul‐94

Page 38: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 19

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

444 101030803 Kum.DharatibenAravindbhaiPoshiya QAL 678 Fem. 345.25 25 370.25 14‐Jun‐93

445 101030813 Kum.HemaliBhikhubhaiPatel QAR 679 Fem. SEBC 355.50 32 387.50 3‐Dec‐93

446 101030874 ShriMayurRajendrakumarRathavi QAO 682 SEBC 347.50 44 391.50 27‐Sep‐81

447 101030939 Kum.RavinaShantilalMandli EZZ 683 Fem. SEBC 357.75 35 392.75 16‐Jan‐93

448 101031125 Smt.BhoomikaTulsibhaiAkabari QAW 684 Fem. 380.25 30 410.25 16‐Jul‐89

449 101031137 Kum.MisbaNajirkhanPathan QAA 685 Fem. 378.25 42 420.25 2‐Aug‐94

450 101031184 ShriBharatkumarPunabhaiAahir QBK 687 SEBC 380.25 35 415.25 20‐Jun‐88

451 101031244 ShriTrusharbhaiMaheshbhaiPatel QAJ 688 355.00 52 407.00 20‐Feb‐84

452 101031278 Kum.SurbhiBhupendrabhaiDalwadi QBF 689 Fem. 365.25 30 395.25 16‐Jan‐94

453 101031389 ShriNarendrasinhJayvantsinhSarvaiya QAP 692 349.50 20 369.50 4‐Oct‐89

454 101031405 ShriArjunsinghKaransinghRajput EZO 693 358.00 38 396.00 23‐May‐94

455 101031414 ShriVijaykumarGhanshyambhaiPatel QAZ 694 368.50 45 413.50 1‐Jun‐86

456 101031452 ShriVijaykumarChelabhaiPatel QAG 695 359.00 53 412.00 27‐May‐87

457 101031460 ShriNiketKetankumarModi QES 696 341.75 60 401.75 22‐Aug‐96

458 101031594 Kum.VaishalibaKanaksinhJadeja QAX 697 Fem. 378.75 38 416.75 9‐Jul‐94

459 101031647 ShriHardikKalidasPatel QAN 698 366.75 40 406.75 5‐Jan‐88

460 101031650 ShriPrashantkumarPradipbhaiShah QAH 699 344.75 55 399.75 4‐Apr‐96

461 101031659 Kum.VidhibenDineshbhaiMakwana QBG 700 Fem. S.C. 347.50 31 378.50 5‐Jul‐94

462 101031717 ShriVipulkumarOmprakashbhaiShah EZN 701 379.00 46 425.00 17‐Aug‐82

463 101031766 ShriMunafmohammedFakirmohammedMorvadia QAD 702 SEBC 346.25 43 389.25 25‐May‐87

464 101031906 ShriNikhilVasantbhaiGohel QAT 704 342.75 53 395.75 19‐Mar‐90

465 101031932 ShriNareshkumarKanubhaiChauhan EZR 706 S.C. 341.25 32 373.25 5‐Nov‐94

466 101032045 ShriHiteshbhaiLagdhirbhaiDesai QAB 707 SEBC 346.50 55 401.50 11‐Nov‐91

467 101032464 Kum.KalpanaDineshbhaiRathava QAQ 711 Fem. S.T. 262.00 23 285.00 16‐Oct‐88

468 101032511 ShriNareshJivabhaiKeriya QBD 712 S.C. 348.00 53 401.00 27‐Dec‐89

Page 39: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 20

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

469 101032789 ShriRamDevadanbhaiKhungla EZS 717 SEBC 362.50 47 409.50 4‐Jan‐94

470 101032842 Kum.AshabenMahendrasinhRaol EZW 719 Fem. 355.75 45 400.75 17‐Apr‐88

471 101012831 Kum.JignashaKanaiyalalSathawara QCV 721 Fem. SEBC 340.00 32 372.00 27‐Dec‐92

472 101012908 Kum.VanitabenBharatbhaiMalani QDL 722 Fem. Dis. 326.25 42 368.25 30‐Aug‐89

473 101013218 Kum.MitaNatavarlalBalat QCN 723 Fem. S.T. 283.75 30 313.75 31‐Aug‐89

474 101013381 ShriNiravVijaykumarDave QBP 725 385.25 35 420.25 5‐Dec‐83

475 101032936 ShriAlpeshThakershibhaiDhokai QDD 727 347.25 38 385.25 22‐Aug‐81

476 101032969 Kum.VidhyaRajeshkumarJoshi QCL 728 Fem. 339.00 50 389.00 15‐May‐80

477 101033037 ShriBhavikAshokbhaiDave QDJ 729 340.25 40 380.25 20‐Jun‐83

478 101033106 ShriBhaveshkumarAmratlalPrajapati QBY 730 SEBC 364.00 36 400.00 20‐Nov‐90

479 101033107 ShriVishalPrabhudasbhaiRadia QCO 731 395.75 27 422.75 13‐Mar‐89

480 101033228 ShriSunilkumarKantilalPatel QCZ 732 Dis. 315.50 53 368.50 20‐Oct‐85

481 101033273 ShriManishkumarRanchhodbhaiChapanera QBS 733 SEBC 343.25 50 393.25 20‐Aug‐82

482 101033318 Kum.AkrutiDevendrabhaiVasava QCI 734 Fem. S.T. 283.75 25 308.75 1‐Oct‐93

483 101033324 ShriShitalkumarIshvarbhaiChaudhari QCM 735 S.T. 285.50 22 307.50 15‐May‐87

484 101033598 Kum.FarhinMukhtarahmadChamdawala QCH 738 Fem. 350.75 45 395.75 1‐Jan‐95

485 101033623 Kum.SwetaGovindbhaiPatel QCU 739 Fem. 357.00 37 394.00 10‐Jan‐89

486 101033753 Kum.KajalkumariAshvinbhaiChaudhari QDE 741 Fem. S.T. 281.50 22 303.50 28‐Nov‐94

487 101033784 ShriDharmeshHarsukhbhaiSonara QCQ 743 381.75 45 426.75 23‐Dec‐92

488 101033862 ShriGulabshaBhikhushaJadeja QBL 744 SEBC 357.50 55 412.50 29‐Jul‐90

489 101033880 ShriDasarathbhaiDalsingbhaiMachhar QBX 745 S.T. 269.00 36 305.00 1‐Jun‐82

490 101033906 ShriMasudahemadSajjadhusenKazi QCT 746 337.50 35 372.50 17‐Dec‐85

491 101034009 ShriRohitkumarKarmanbhaiBharwad QBM 747 SEBC 338.00 30 368.00 16‐Aug‐79

492 101034100 Kum.RadhikaSejabhaiKhambhala QCC 748 Fem. S.T. 254.50 43 297.50 17‐Nov‐90

493 101034125 Kum.RiddhiBharatbhaiSolanki QBO 749 Fem. SEBC 340.25 30 370.25 30‐Jan‐89

Page 40: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 21

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

494 101034277 ShriArchitkumarChandrakantbhaiThakkar QCR 751 362.50 53 415.50 25‐Apr‐90

495 101034300 ShriAlpeshkumarNatubhaiVasani QDG 752 363.00 45 408.00 24‐Aug‐90

496 101034438 ShriDineshKishorbhaiMaru QDH 753 S.T. 274.75 40 314.75 16‐Oct‐88

497 101034553 Kum.NehalBhagwanjibhaiSindhal QCS 755 Fem. S.T. 262.75 35 297.75 3‐May‐88

498 101034558 Kum.TejalBharatbhaiLalapara QBR 756 Fem. 345.75 28 373.75 27‐Apr‐94

499 101034580 Kum.VimalabenGanpatdasPatel QDA 757 Fem. 366.00 42 408.00 1‐Jun‐77

500 101034614 ShriChampakbhaiSureshbhaiGavit QDC 758 S.T. 252.75 40 292.75 7‐Jun‐92

501 101034762 ShriDharmarajsinhUdesangbhaiSisodiya QBQ 759 365.00 42 407.00 21‐Jan‐93

502 101035012 ShriAnandbhaiHarjibhaiGoti QDM 761 366.00 52 418.00 15‐Sep‐92

503 101035203 ShriDevangSureshchandraKharsani QBN 762 SEBC 337.00 50 387.00 7‐Oct‐87

504 101035231 ShriAnandkumarAjmaljiThakor QCK 763 SEBC 356.75 26 382.75 24‐Nov‐91

505 101035290 ShriYashrajsinhRajendrasinhRathod QCG 764 380.50 40 420.50 5‐Jan‐89

506 101035632 Smt.AshaIshwarlalRamnani QCW 765 Fem. 358.25 38 396.25 16‐Oct‐87

507 101035785 ShriYagneshkumarPopatbhaiBhayani QCF 766 344.50 32 376.50 10‐Dec‐84

508 101035922 Smt.SnehalbahenDevjibhaiDulera QBT 768 Fem. 353.50 48 401.50 16‐Dec‐87

509 101036252 ShriVirendrasinhBhadrasinhJadeja QDI 770 341.50 40 381.50 6‐May‐89

510 101036428 ShriHarishbhaiSomlubhaiGanvit QCD 771 S.T. 279.00 25 304.00 24‐Apr‐88

511 101036643 ShriDivyeshkumarRatubhaiGavali QBU 774 S.T. 268.00 42 310.00 17‐Mar‐91

512 101013573 ShriPurveshVinodbhaiVaidya QER 776 376.25 50 426.25 14‐Jan‐82

513 101036644 ShriDineshDayabhaiChopda QEN 780 S.T. 280.50 40 320.50 26‐Oct‐90

514 101036655 Kum.DipikaKishorbhaiPala QEF 781 Fem. 335.50 42 377.50 29‐Mar‐87

515 101036680 ShriKalpeshkumarGambhirsinhSisodiya QEX 782 361.75 45 406.75 22‐Jul‐84

516 101036771 ShriVishwnathHiralalRamani QDR 784 374.25 45 419.25 25‐Dec‐85

517 101036799 Kum.ReenabaNarendrasinhJadeja QDO 785 Fem. 380.00 42 422.00 22‐Apr‐89

518 101036811 ShriRajendrakumarNarottambhaiPandya QDU 786 S.C. 352.00 30 382.00 30‐Jul‐90

Page 41: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 22

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

519 101036858 Kum.SwatiNavneetkumarRanpara QEO 787 Fem. 368.25 53 421.25 14‐May‐93

520 101036869 Smt.FalguniAnkitPatel QEP 788 Fem. 353.50 53 406.50 31‐Dec‐86

521 101037008 ShriManishkumarAmrutlalPanchal QDQ 789 SEBC 365.25 43 408.25 13‐Aug‐88

522 101037126 ShriSureshKarshanbhaiPindariya QDV 790 SEBC 350.00 62 412.00 11‐Feb‐94

523 101037162 Kum.ShobhanabenRameshbhaiAmbaliya QEQ 792 Fem. S.T. 275.25 25 300.25 1‐Jun‐94

524 101037169 ShriAbhishekRameshpuriGoswami QEJ 794 SEBC 342.00 48 390.00 19‐Sep‐89

525 101037286 ShriVishalkumarKanubhaiPatel QEK 795 364.00 27 391.00 24‐Jun‐91

526 101037347 ShriAjayNatvarlalUndhad QDT 796 346.00 30 376.00 22‐Aug‐89

527 101037357 ShriJatinkumarKantilalSharma QDZ 797 351.00 47 398.00 20‐May‐95

528 101037435 ShriRaviBharatbhaiJadiya QDN 798 366.50 41 407.50 20‐Jul‐91

529 101037448 ShriMaheshkumarKurajibhaiRamani QEW 799 345.00 28 373.00 7‐Jul‐90

530 101037549 ShriPankajkumarManubhaiAcharya QEC 800 349.00 58 407.00 11‐Sep‐80

531 101037585 ShriHiteshkumarDineshbhaiSolanki QDP 802 S.C. 372.00 22 394.00 21‐Jan‐92

532 101037649 Kum.AvaniSomabhaiDesai QDS 805 Fem. SEBC 351.25 30 381.25 16‐May‐96

533 101037721 ShriKartikKiranbhaiPrajapati QEE 807 SEBC 367.75 45 412.75 20‐Sep‐92

534 101037818 ShriNiteshkumarDahyalalSolanki QDY 808 S.C. 348.75 40 388.75 15‐Jul‐89

535 101037863 ShriNavghanbhaiSomabhaiDesai QDX 809 SEBC 337.25 45 382.25 16‐Oct‐91

536 101037888 Kum.AnjanabenParagbhaiPatel QEB 810 Fem. 365.50 18 383.50 14‐Feb‐90

537 101014350 ShriBhikhubhaiDevjibhaiChauhan QEZ 811 SEBC 345.00 38 383.00 1‐Jun‐86

538 101014946 ShriRameshBecharbhaiPatel QFO 814 SEBC 356.25 55 411.25 1‐Jun‐84

539 101038019 ShriDilipsinhChandansinhSolanki QGH 818 357.75 35 392.75 4‐Jun‐94

540 101038057 ShriJitendrakumarNatawarbhaiChaudhari QFZ 819 SEBC 337.00 32 369.00 14‐Mar‐93

541 101038072 ShriFakirmahammadNabimahammadParmar QFA 820 SEBC Dis. 304.25 35 339.25 6‐Nov‐88

542 101038132 Smt.PriyankaSuryakantTailar QFM 821 Fem. S.C. 332.50 23 355.50 28‐Oct‐89

543 101038406 ShriKandarpPurushottamKansara QFP 823 359.50 50 409.50 11‐May‐86

Page 42: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 23

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

544 101038438 ShriHanzilMahmadBadi QFR 824 354.00 32 386.00 26‐Mar‐82

545 101038617 ShriAshwinkumarBipinchandraPandya QFW 825 S.C. 364.75 30 394.75 11‐Jul‐85

546 101038754 Kum.PoojaAvadheshShukla QFF 828 Fem. 348.50 38 386.50 1‐Apr‐90

547 101038776 Kum.MalvikaKishorkumarJoshi QFU 829 Fem. 336.50 33 369.50 25‐Aug‐76

548 101038806 ShriIrfanYusufbhaiMalek QGB 830 354.50 45 399.50 30‐Dec‐80

549 101038871 Kum.BhavnabenMaganlalChaudhari QFS 832 Fem. 366.25 40 406.25 12‐Oct‐83

550 101038894 Kum.FalgunibenBachubhaiModiya QFD 833 Fem. S.T. 262.50 38 300.50 16‐Nov‐93

551 101039065 ShriHareshkumarDasharathbhaiChaudhari QEY 835 SEBC 351.50 30 381.50 1‐Sep‐86

552 101039083 ShriMahaveersinhJasvantsinhVaghela QFG 836 361.75 40 401.75 15‐Aug‐96

553 101039124 ShriAshokkumarJeshabhaiMaru QFK 837 S.C. 346.75 45 391.75 1‐May‐89

554 101039158 ShriVikasSitarambhaiPatel QGF 838 348.75 32 380.75 3‐Nov‐82

555 101039292 Kum.RupalKalubhaiVohaniya QGA 839 Fem. S.T. 253.00 23 276.00 1‐Jun‐81

556 101039309 ShriNileshbhaiBachubhaiPatel QFC 841 S.T. 253.50 35 288.50 22‐May‐89

557 101039313 Kum.HarshaGirishkumarGohel QFY 842 Fem. SEBC 348.50 34 382.50 15‐Apr‐89

558 101039351 Kum.NidhiHarshadraiBagdai QFV 843 Fem. 342.00 40 382.00 31‐Dec‐83

559 101039414 ShriJayLakhabhaiGaadhe QFN 844 SEBC 368.50 35 403.50 17‐May‐90

560 101039430 ShriHiteshkumarIshwarbhaiPanchal QGE 845 SEBC 338.25 33 371.25 1‐Jun‐88

561 101039622 ShriZahirabbasGulamdastagirShaikh QGX 849 363.50 48 411.50 1‐Jun‐82

562 101039882 ShriVipulkumarAmrutbhaiPrajapati QHK 852 SEBC 358.25 35 393.25 1‐Feb‐85

563 101039899 ShriMahammadAsharafJamalbhaiMomin QHR 853 378.75 47 425.75 22‐Jul‐88

564 101039929 ShriRicheshkumarShaileshkumarGavit QGN 854 S.T. 289.75 20 309.75 5‐Nov‐92

565 101039966 ShriDhavalManojkumarBhojani QHB 856 353.00 42 395.00 9‐Dec‐88

566 101039971 Kum.ShwetaAnilbhaiDholia QHD 857 Fem. 353.75 43 396.75 12‐Aug‐84

567 101040082 ShriEazazahmedkhanMujaffarkhanPathan QHI 858 371.50 35 406.50 4‐Nov‐88

568 101040105 ShriHardikRameshbhaiShelar QHQ 859 SEBC 346.50 45 391.50 1‐Jun‐90

Page 43: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 24

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

569 101040204 ShriRonakkumarVijaybhaiBarot QHG 860 SEBC 353.25 50 403.25 2‐May‐88

570 101040237 ShriMehulGaneshRajput QGU 861 345.25 25 370.25 6‐Apr‐90

571 101040363 ShriKetankumarDahyalalVaghela QGP 863 S.C. 358.50 38 396.50 4‐Jun‐85

572 101040446 Kum.AlkabenManubhaiKhatrani QHM 864 Fem. 349.75 32 381.75 29‐Dec‐92

573 101040543 Kum.VanitaIshwarbhaiRabari QHP 865 Fem. SEBC 347.50 35 382.50 22‐Aug‐92

574 101040602 Kum.RohiniDilipkumarVyas QGI 866 Fem. 371.25 33 404.25 5‐Jun‐90

575 101040675 ShriDhavalHemantkumarGhelani QGY 867 379.00 43 422.00 15‐Mar‐93

576 101040691 ShriAnopsinhJalamsinhSolanki QHL 868 345.25 35 380.25 1‐May‐94

577 101040697 ShriNiravKishorbhaiVasoya QGZ 869 352.25 33 385.25 18‐Mar‐90

578 101040735 Kum.MeghabenKanaiyalalPatel QGS 870 Fem. 356.00 22 378.00 18‐Dec‐89

579 101040773 ShriSandeepBhimabhaiChavda QGV 871 S.T. 272.00 46 318.00 9‐Nov‐89

580 101040774 ShriDilipkumarKanubhaiKhandvi QHC 872 S.C. 342.50 28 370.50 22‐Oct‐91

581 101040801 ShriDineshkumarKanubhaiChavada QGL 873 SEBC 356.00 45 401.00 5‐Nov‐84

582 101040875 ShriVirenkumarMaljibhaiRabari QHA 874 SEBC 338.00 26 364.00 23‐Apr‐89

583 101040895 ShriRafikbhaiKaiyumbhaiSumara QGQ 875 340.25 37 377.25 7‐Oct‐85

584 101040907 Kum.MeetaRajeshbhaiMandavia QHE 876 Fem. SEBC 344.50 25 369.50 20‐May‐83

585 101040914 ShriVivekHareshbhaiKantesaria QGJ 877 341.50 30 371.50 27‐Dec‐93

586 101040975 ShriVipulMansukhbhaiDesai QGT 879 340.25 42 382.25 15‐Apr‐88

587 101041004 ShriPratikkumarSureshbhaiDungrani QHH 880 339.50 35 374.50 9‐Mar‐93

588 101041041 Kum.VidhiMaheshbhaiShah QGM 881 Fem. 343.75 52 395.75 29‐Dec‐90

589 101041105 ShriAlpeshLaxmanbhaiRabari QGO 882 SEBC 342.75 40 382.75 2‐Nov‐88

590 101041154 ShriJitendrabhaiOghadbhaiBambhaniya QIO 883 S.C. 356.75 40 396.75 1‐Jun‐88

591 101041266 ShriYogeshkumarJayantilalPatel QHY 884 351.25 39 390.25 24‐May‐82

592 101041268 ShriLaljeeNagjibhaiChaudhary QIP 885 SEBC 344.25 47 391.25 11‐Jul‐86

593 101041309 ShriAjaysinhNajabhaiGangana QIQ 886 371.00 46 417.00 17‐Jun‐93

Page 44: GUJARAT PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Supreme Court, in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria V/s. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, ‐ Civil Appeal Nos. 3132 of 2007, 3773 of 2007 decided

Annexure‐I(Part‐II) AccountsOfficer,Class‐IICommercialTaxOfficer,Class‐II,Advt.No.37/2016‐17 Page No. 25

Sr.No.

SeatNo. NameofCandidate Code E.No. M/F CasteDisabled/Wid/Ex‐Ser.

MarksWritten

MarksViva‐Voce

TotalMarks

BirthDate

594 101041349 Kum.VijetaChandrakantbhaiVaja QIL 887 Fem. SEBC 351.75 37 388.75 29‐Jan‐93

595 101041446 ShriAshishkumarChandrakantJayswal QIT 889 SEBC 349.75 35 384.75 25‐Jun‐89

596 101041512 ShriVishnubhaiChhotabhaiPanchal QIK 891 SEBC 370.00 42 412.00 19‐Oct‐89

597 101041718 Kum.SejalVadsingbhaiChaudhari QHV 892 Fem. S.T. 297.75 17 314.75 27‐Jan‐87

598 101041720 ShriBharatRatilalGajipara QHT 893 373.25 42 415.25 15‐Jul‐81

599 101041815 ShriRohitNareshbhaiVaghani QHS 894 350.50 41 391.50 16‐Jan‐93

600 101041822 ShriAjaykumarDiyalbhaiSarvaiya QID 895 SEBC 343.25 46 389.25 7‐Jul‐93

601 101041920 ShriHemangPurasottambhaiPatel QIS 897 370.50 48 418.50 25‐Dec‐88

602 101041952 ShriPankajLaljibhaiSavaliya QIR 898 341.75 28 369.75 28‐Aug‐91

603 101042040 ShriJigarBharatbhaiDave QIE 899 339.75 40 379.75 7‐Feb‐86

604 101042061 ShriChiragSureshkumarBaria QII 900 S.T. 274.50 35 309.50 3‐Mar‐93

605 101003176 ShriVishalHitendrakumarShah QIH 902 337.00 37 374.00 08‐11‐1987

606 101012505 Kum.KrupaBhupendrabhaiThakkar QIN 903 Fem. 335.50 25 360.50 29‐08‐1994

607 101012559 ShriManojkumarPravinbhaiPurohit QHX 904 343.75 43 386.75 30‐03‐1980

608 101014913 ShriNitinbhaiRanchhodbhaiDekavadiya QIW 905 349.25 45 394.25 18‐07‐1988

609 101031808 ShriSoyebmahammedRafiqueJindani QIU 906 376.25 42 418.25 12‐03‐1988

610 101039521 Smt.RenukabenPurushottambhaiPatel QHU 907 Fem. 367.00 32 399.00 13‐05‐1984

(H.J.PAREKH)Place:‐GANDHINAGAR SECRETARYDate:‐09‐02‐2018 GUJARATPUBLICSERVICECOMMISSION