History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
-
Upload
ixxi28
-
View
237
-
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
1/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
2/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
3/790
DC
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
4/790
Fc suoptudus mufeafchs, vd`le fc swjjt sdch,
Fc pf`turj spjlkfch wftg gjrdf` tdchuj,
Lca wftg ajvdut sdejocftfjs jctwfcja
Ptrfkjs td tgj sjlt dn hrl`j wftgfc tgj ofca 9
Gjc`j ndros tglt hefaj wftg swlc-efkj jlsj ledch,
Gjc`j odtfdcs, jvjc lofa tgj vuehlr tgrdch,
Qd lc glrodcfdus aj`jc`y `dcnfcja,
Ls fn tgj strjjts wjrj `dcsj`rltja hrduca,
Qgj `fty dcj vlst tjopej, ajaf`ltj
Qd outule rjspj`t fc tgduhgt lca ajja.
XD]APXD]QG,
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
5/790
^
Pgdwfch tgj olfc hrdwtg dr jvdeutfdc dn tgj vlrfdus styejs.
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
6/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
7/790
'
MV
(Ndrojrey Rrdnjssdr dn Lr`gftj`turj fc Kfch's @deejhj,
Edcadc)
LCA
MLCFPQJ] N. NEJQ@GJ], N.].F.M.L., Lr`gftj`t
(Zcfvjrsfty Jxtjcsfdc Ej`turjr dc Lr`gftj`turj ; Ndrojrey Ej`turjr
dc Lr`gftj`turj,
Kfch's @deejhj, Edcadc ; ].F.M.L. ' Hdawfc
'
Qftj' Rrfzj Ojaleefst,
<76:, Jssly Ojaleefst, <76>, Lr`gftj`turle Lssd`fltfdc
Ojaleefst ndr Ajsfhc,
<777, Ej`turjr lt tgj Lr`gftj`turle Lssd`fltfdc ; Gdc.
@drr.
Ojomjr dn tgj Lojrf`lc Fcstftutj dn Lr`gftj`ts ;
Lutgdr dn Lcarjl Rleelafl, gfs Efnj lca Xdrks, jt`._
NFNQG JAFQFDC, ]J^FPJA LCA JCEL]HJA
MV
EDCADC
O@O^.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
8/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
9/790
R]JNL@J QD QGJ NFNQG JAFQFDC.
FC tgj Rrjnl`j td tgj Ndurtg Jaftfdc F jxpelfcja tgj olcy
fopdrtlct laaftfdcs wgf`g gla mjjc olaj sfc`j tgj drfhfcle
pumef`ltfdc dn tgfs mddk fc
<76>, lca F ajsfrj td
pdfct dut tglt fc
tgj prjsjct Jaftfdc tgj clturj dn tgj rjvfsfdc gls mjjc dc lc
jvjc
odrj jxtjcsfvj s`lej, loductfch td tgj rjwrftfch dn tgj
hrjltjr
pdrtfdc dn tgj wdrk. Xgfej ou`g cjw olttjr gls mjjc fctrd-
au`ja, tgj fopdrtlc`j dn l tgdrduhg rjvfsfdc dn tglt lerjlay
jxfstfch gls cdt mjjc dvjreddkja, tgj utodst `lrj glvfch mjjc
tlkjc td vjrfny lee fopdrtlct stltjojcts lca altjs, lca td
lopefny
su`g ajs`rfptfdcs wgjrj tgfs lppjlrja ajsfrlmej. Qgjsj
rjolrks
ls td tgj tjxt, lppey jquleey td tgj feeustrltfdcs, wgf`g glvj
mjjc
fc`rjlsja my tgj laaftfdc dn sdoj 822, mrfchfch tgjfr tdtle up
td
lmdut =,222. Olcy dn tgj sumij`ts sgdwc fc tgj prjvfdus
jaftfdcs glvj mjjc rj-arlwc lca `drrj`tja fc tgj efhgt dn tgj
odst rj`jct afs`dvjrfjs.
Qgj slej dn ndur elrhj jaftfdcs fc tgj spl`j dn l njw yjlrs
lnndras strdch jvfajc`j tglt tgj mddk gls mjjc dn sjrvf`j cdt
dcey
td tgj strf`tey prdnjssfdcle stuajct lca tgdsj `dccj`tja wftg
ajsfhc
fc fts lppef`ltfdc td tgj ofcdr lrts lca `rlnts, mut lesd td
tglt
elrhjr mday dn loltjurs td wgdo Lr`gftj`turle Gfstdry fs yjlr
my yjlr mj`dofch l olttjr dn efvjey fctjrjst. Ft fs hrltfnyfch
td
kcdw tglt ft gls mjjc ladptja ls l tjxt-mddk fc Lrt P`gddes
lca fc tgj ejlafch @deejhjs lca Qj`gcf`le Fcstftutfdcs dn
Hrjlt
Mrftlfc, tgj Zcftja Ptltjs dn Lojrf`l, lca Lustrlefl, ndr ft fs
updc
tgjsj `jctrjs wj oust ajpjca ndr tgj ndroltfdc dn l
`uetfvltja
tlstj, lca tgj nuturj hrdwtg dn fctjrjst fc tgj Lrts.
Olcy `lusjs glvj `domfcja fc gjepfch tdwlras tgj prdpjr
lpprj`fltfdc lca jctgusflso ndr lr`gftj`turj lca tgj lrts dn
ajsfhc, lodch wgf`g tgj hrjltey fc`rjlsja nl`feftfjs ndr
trlvje,
tgj `dcau`tja jau`ltfdcle tdurs cdw sd pdpuelr, lca tgj
hjcjrle
fctjrjst fc pgdtdhrlpgy lrj ucadumtjaey fopdrtlct nl`tdrs.
Qgj Gfstdry
uctfe rj`jct yjlrs
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
10/790
vfff R]JNL@J QD QGJ NFNQG JAFQFDC.
mjjc l sjleja mddk td olcy wgd glvj wlcajrja lodchst tgj
odst mjlutfnue `rjltfdcs dn tgj mufeafch lrt wftgdut mjfch lmej
td
ucajrstlca tgjfr ojlcfch dr lpprj`fltj tgjfr qulefty l
Hrj`flc
tjopej, l ]dolc lopgftgjltrj, dr l Hdtgf` `ltgjarle rj`leefch
td
tgjo cdcj dn tgj jvfajc`js wgf`g rjcajr jl`g l rjnej`tfdc dn
fts
dwc pjrfda fc gfstdry, lca wgf`g hfvj td jl`g lc`fjct
mufeafch
l spj`fle lttrl`tfdc, mjsfajs laafch hrjltty td tgj fctjrjst
lca
jcidyojct dn fts jxlofcltfdc.
Lr`gftj`turj gls mjjc ajs`rfmja vjry truey ls tgj prfctfch
prjss
dn lee lhjs, lca ft lppjlrs prdmlmej tglt fc tgjsj alys dn
jcefhgtjc-
ojct tgj stuay dn Lr`gftj`turle Gfstdry wfee sddc tlkj fts
prdpjr
pel`j ls plrt dn l efmjrle jau`ltfdc. Ft fs surjey rjolrklmej
tglt
ft sgduea ndr sd edch glvj mjjc cjhej`tja, ndr fs ft cdt tgj lrt
wftg
wgf`g jvjrydcj fs mrduhgt fctd alfey `dctl`t, wgf`g sgjetjrs
us
nrdo tgj jejojcts lca hfvjs us Gdoj, wgf`g jcsgrfcjs
lca
feeuofcltjs tgj odst sl`rja dn dur tgduhgts, wgf`g fs tgj
dut`doj
dn `dcaftfdcs fctfoltjey mduca up wftg tgj gfstdry dn tgj guolc
rl`j, lca, nfcleey, fs ft cdt tgj odtgjr dn lee dtgjr lrts,
sfc`j
nrdo ft sprlch s`uepturj, plfctfch, lca tgj aj`drltfvj `rlnts
dn tgj su``jjafch lhjs 4
Qgj tfoj spjct fc tgj stuay dn tgj lr`gftj`turj dn tgj plst
wfee,
tgjrjndrj, cjvjr mj rjhrjttja, ndr jvjry rufc tjees dn tgj
gfstdry
dn dtgjr alys, lca jclmejs tgj `glrl`tjr lca `dcaftfdcs dn
ojc
dn plst pjrfdas
stuajcts lca edvjrs dn dea mufeafchs tgj jcidyojct dn `dctjo-
peltfch ndros wgf`g wfee tgjc glvj ndr tgjo l ojlcfch lca l
`glro.
F lo fcajmtja td oy mrdtgjr, Or. G. Rgfeefps Nejt`gjr,
N.].F.M.L., ndr gjepnue `rftf`fso fc tgfs jaftfdc, lca td oy
pum-
efsgjr ndr gfs `lrj fc tgj rjvfsfdc dn tgj mfmefdhrlpgy lca fc
tgj
hjcjrle prdau`tfdc dn tgj mddk.
Ft sgduea, pjrglps, mj ojctfdcja tglt, dwfch td tgj ajltg dn
Rrdnjssdr Mlcfstjr Nejt`gjr, tgj rjvfsfdc dn tgj ndurtg lca dn
tgj
prjsjct jaftfdc gls mjjc `lrrfja dut my oj.
MLCFPQJ] N. NEJQ@GJ].
EZAHLQJ @F]@ZP, J.H.
Cjw Vjlr's Aly, <62:.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
11/790
R]JNL@J QD QGJ NF]PQ JAFQFDC.
QGJ Lutgdrs' lfo fc wrftfch tgfs mddk gls mjjc, cdt dcey td
hfvj
fc `ejlr lca mrfjn ndro tgj `glrl`tjrfstf` njlturjs dn tgj
lr`gf-
tj`turj dn jl`g pjdpej lca `ductry, mut lesd td `dcsfajr
tgdsj
fcneujc`js wgf`g glvj `dctrfmutja td tgj ndroltfdc dn jl`g
spj`fle styej.
Qgjy lrj dn dpfcfdc tglt fc pumefsgja wdrks updc tgj sumij`t,
Lr`gftj`turj gls dntjc mjjc tdd ou`g fsdeltja nrdo fts
surrduca-
fchs, lca tglt tgj olfc pdfcts dn tgj pgysf`le hjdhrlpgy,
sd`fle
prdhrjss, lca gfstdrf`le ajvjedpojct dn jl`g `ductry rjqufrj
td
mj ucajrstdda my tgdsj wgd wduea stuay lca `doprjgjca fts
plrtf`uelr styej.
Fc drajr td mrfch dut tgj jnnj`ts dn tgjsj fcneujc`js, lca
lesd
tgj quleftfjs dn tgj styejs tgjosjevjs, l `doplrltfvj lca
lcleytf`le
ojtgda gls mjjc ladptja, sd tglt my tgj `dctrlst dn quleftfjs
tgj
afnnjrjc`js oly mj odrj jlsfey hrlspja. Ndr fcstlc`j, tgj
spj`fle
`glrl`tjr dn Hdtgf` lr`gftj`turj mj`dojs olcfnjst wgjc put fc
`doplrfsdc wftg tgj @elssf` lca ]jclfsslc`j styejs ; lca,
nurtgjr-
odrj, tgj sglajs dn afnnjrjc`j fc tgj ed`le dr cltfdcle pglsjs
dn
jl`g, `lc lesd mj jquleey arlwc dut my l sfofelr `doplrltfvj
trjltojct.
Qgj styejs tgjosjevjs lrj tgjc lcleysja lca tgj plrts `dc-
trlstja ; tgj lcleysfs mjfch `lrrfja dut dc tgj mlsfs dn tgj
jssjctfle
plrts wgf`g jvjry mufeafch pdssjssjs. Ls tgfs systjo pjrvlajs
tgj wgdej mddk, jftgjr tgj fcneujc`js, `glrl`tjr, jxlopejs,
dr
`doplrltfvj njlturjs dn jl`g styej, `lc mj `dctrlstja wftg
tgdsj
fc lcy dtgjr styej. Qgfs tgjc fs tgj s`gjoj dn tgj mddk,
wgf`g
gls mjjc afvfaja fctd nfvj sj`tfdcs fc jl`g pjrfda, ls ndeedws
9
f. FCNEZJC@JP.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
12/790
<. FCNEZJC@JP `dctfcuja.
fv. ]jefhfdc.
vf. Gfstdrf`le.
0. JWLOREJP DN MZFEAFCHP.
1. @DORL]LQF^J.
M. Xlees, tgjfr `dcstru`tfdc lca trjltojct.
@. Dpjcfchs, tgjfr `glrl`tjr lca sglpj.
A. ]ddns, tgjfr trjltojct lca ajvjedpojct.
J. @deuocs, tgjfr pdsftfdc, stru`turj, lca aj`drltfdc.
N. Odueafchs, tgjfr ndro lca aj`drltfdc.
H. Drclojct, ls lppefja fc hjcjrle td lcy mufeafch.
:. ]JNJ]JC@J MDDKP.
PJ@QFDC f fs afvfaja fctd tgj sfx ejlafch fcneujc`js tglt oly
mj
jxpj`tja td sglpj tgj lr`gftj`turj dn lcy `ductry dr pjdpej,
tgj nfrst tgrjj mjfch stru`turle, tgj cjxt twd tgj `fvfefzfch
ndr`js, lca tgj elst `dctlfcfch tgdsj jxtjrcle gfstdrf`le
jvjcts
wgf`g oly letjr dr vlry tgj ndrjhdfch.
PJ@QFDC = ajs`rfmjs tgj `glrl`tjr dn tgj lr`gftj`turj, tglt fs,
fts
spj`fle qulefty, lca tgj hjcjrle jnnj`t prdau`ja my tgj
mufeafchs
ls l wgdej.
mufeafchs fc
jl`g styej, mrfjney cloja lca ajs`rfmja, mjfch tgj `drpus, wgf`g
tgj
prj`jafch fcneujc`js lnnj`t lca nrdo wgf`g tgj sumsjqujct
`doplrltfvj lcleysfs fs ajau`ja.
PJ@QFDC 1 fs tgfs `doplrltfvj lcleysfs, fc wgf`g jvjry styej
dn
lr`gftj`turj fs rjhlraja ls tgj sdeutfdc dn `jrtlfc
nucalojctle
prdmejos, f.j. jl`g mufeafch oust glvj lee dr odst dn tgj
plrts
L td H, lca `dcsjqujctey tgjrj fs mdtg fctjrjst lca
fcstru`tfdc
td mj hlfcja fc ejlrcfch lca `doplrfch gdw jl`g styej gls
sdevja tgjsj pdfcts dn tgj prdmejo.
PJ@QFDC : hfvjs lutgdrftfjs lca odrj jspj`fleey afrj`ts tgj
rjlajr
wgd wfsgjs td pursuj tgj stuay dn lcy styej fc nurtgjr
ajtlfe.
Fc trjltfch dn tgj mufeafchs tgjosjevjs ucajr Pj`tfdc 0 tgj
lutgdrs glvj jcajlvdurja td lvdfa edch ajs`rfptfdcs,
wgf`g lrj
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
13/790
R]JNL@J QD QGJ NF]PQ JAFQFDC. WF
cj`jsslrfey tj`gcf`le lca fctdejrlmey ary, lca afnnf`uet td
ndeedw,
jvjc my tgdsj wgd glvj gla tgj tj`gcf`le trlfcfch, lca glvj
jftgjr tgj mufeafch dr `dopejtj arlwfchs dn ft mjndrj tgjo.
Qgjy
glvj tgjrjndrj prdvfaja tgj elrhjst pdssfmej cuomjr dn
feeustrltfdcs,
lca glvj `dcnfcja tgj tjxt td mrfjn, mut ft fs gdpja vfvfa, cdtjs
dn
tgj spj`fle quleftfjs lca `glrl`tjrfstf`s dn tgj mufeafch rjnjrrja
td.
Ft fs gdpja tglt tgj mddk wfee lppjle cdt dcey td stuajcts
wgd
rjqufrj lc dutefcj dn lr`gftj`turle gfstdry ls plrt dn tgjfr
lrtfstf`
lca prdnjssfdcle jau`ltfdc, mut lesd td tgj fc`rjlsfch cuomjr
dn
lrt wdrkjrs wgd lrj fctjrjstja fc lr`gftj`turj fc fts rjeltfdc
td
tgdsj l``jssdry lrts fc wgf`g tgjy lrj jchlhja. Elstey ; ft
fs
mjefjvja tglt l wdrk fc wgf`g lr`gftj`turj fs trjltja ls l
rjsuet
lca rj`dra dn `fvfefzltfdc, wfee prdvj lttrl`tfvj td tglt
fc`rjlsfch
pumef` wgf`g fctjrjsts ftsjen fc lrtfstf` ajvjedpojct.
=6, CJX M]FAHJ PQ]JJQ,
EZAHLQJ @F]@ZP, J.H.
Cjw Vjlr's Aly, <76>.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
14/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
15/790
RL]Q F. QGJ GFPQD]F@LE PQVEJP.
Hjcjrle Fctrdau`tfdc........... 1
Xjstjrc Lsfltf` Lr`gftj`turj ..... .... 0=
Hrjjk Lr`gftj`turj ........... 1:
]dolc Lr`gftj`turj . . . . . . . . . . < < <
Myzlctfcj Lr`gftj`turj .......... <6=
]dolcjsquj Lr`gftj`turj fc Jurdpj (Hjcjrle Fctrdau`tfdc) . .
.=<8 Ftleflc ]dolcjsquj .......... ==7
Nrjc`g ]dolcjsquj .......... =1>
Hdtgf` Lr`gftj`turj fc Jurdpj (Hjcjrle Fctrdau`tfdc) ....
=>8
Jchefsg Lr`gftj`turj . . . . . . . . . .=87
Lched-Plxdc
Frfsg Lr`gftj`turj . . .
Mjehflc lca Aut`g Hdtgf` . .
. . . 07:
. 108
Qgj Nedrjctfcj P`gdde 11>
Qgj ]dolc P`gdde 1:>
Qgj ^jcjtflc P`gdde . .' . . . . . -18:
^f`jczl lca ^jrdcl 1S7
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
16/790
WF^ @DCQJCQP.
Us Ofelc lca Hjcdl
Z Nrjc`g ]jclfsslc`j Lr`gftj`turj . . , . . . . . 168
^ Hjrolc ]jclfsslc`j . . . . . . . . . :S8
Mjehflc lca Aut`g ]jclfsslc`j . . . . . . . . .:=8 Pplcfsg
]jclfsslc`j....../..... :00
Jchefsg ]jclfsslc`j Lr`gftj`turj .. n...... :1:
Qgj Jefzlmjtglc Ptyej . . . U . . . . ::<
Qgj Il`dmjlc Ptyej . . . :><
:>8 Qgj \ujjc Lccj (Jfhgtjjctg @jctury) Ptyej/ .
U . . . :87
,, ,, <7:< td prjsjct tfoj . :60
Mrftfsg @dedcfle Lr`gftj`turj . . . . . . . . :68
Lr`gftj`turj fc tgj Zcftja Ptltjs . . :67
RL]Q FF. QGJ CDC-GFPQD]F@LE PQVEJP.
Hjcjrle Fctrdau`tfdc
<. Qgj Muaagfst Ptyej ><=
(m) @gleukylc . . . . . . . .
L . . >=0
(`) Arlvfaflc U.U . . >=7
@gfcjsj lca Ilplcjsj Lr`gftj`turj ..... / L . , >01 Lc`fjct
Lojrf`lc Lr`gftj`turj . . . . . , ... .>:= Plrl`jcf`
Lr`gftj`turj . . . . . . ,
U . , >:0
>68
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
17/790
Cd. Cloj,
S:. Rjelshf` Pystjo dn @dcstru`tfdc.
Qrjlsury dn Ltgjcs, sj`tfdc ... L
,, '
Qgj Hltj dn Efdcs, Oy`jclj J
L`rdpdefs lt Qfrycs, pelc N
<>. Hrjjk Jxlopejs F.
Hrjjk @dcstru`tfdc
,, ,, glen trlcsvjrsj
P. X. lchej dn Rlrtgjcdc ls rjstdrja . A, J, N
]jstdrltfdc dn l Adrf` jctlmelturj . . H, G, i
P.X. lchej dn Rlrtgjcdc ls lt prjsjct . K, E
<8. Relc dn tgj L`rdpdefs lt Ltgjcs
<7. Hrjjk Jxlopejs FF.
Qjopejs.
Qjopej dn Cjptucj (tgj Hrjlt Qjopej) lt Rljstuo ..... M
Qjopej dn Lpglfl dc tgj Fselca dn
SJhfcl ...... `
Qjopej dn Lpdeed, lt Ajeds . . . N
=2. Hrjjk Jxlopejs F^.
,, ,, ,, wjst pjafojct ,, ,, jlst jejvltfdc
tfdc Sy.S
rfahj`rdtjrfdc
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
18/790
Cd. Cloj.
=<. Hrjjk Jxlopejs ^.
Gjpgljstds
,, ,, Ojtdpjs, cdrtg lca
up |
,, ,, (glen sj
=:. Hrjjk Jxlopejs ^FF.
@doplrltfvj ]jstdrltfdcs dn tgj Ojtgdas dn Efhgtfch tgj Fctjrfdrs
dn Hrjjk
Qjopejs Ojtgda dn efhgtfch my `ejrjstdry .
Ojtgda dn efhgtfch my skyefhgt
=>. Hrjjk Jxlopejs ^FFF.
,, edchftuafcle sj`tfdc
,, ajtlfes dn Fctjrfdr
Lutgdrftfjs.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
19/790
Cd, Cloj. Lutgdrftfjs.
'
,, cdrtg jejvltfdc
,, ,, jejvltfdc .
pelc
,, ,, ,, jejvltfdc .
Relc, jejvltfdc, lca sj`tfdc .
Qdwjr dn tgj Xfcas, Ltgjcs, jejvltfdc .
,, ,, ,, sj`tfdc
tuo, Pf`fey, pelc . . . .
Qjopej dn Iupftjr Deyopfus lt Lhrfhjc-
tuo, Pf`fey, sj`tfdc .... Qjopej dn Iupftjr Deyopfus lt
Lhrfhjc-
tuo, jejvltfdc..... =6. Hrjjk Jxlopejs WF.
Qgj Fdcf` Drajr-
Qgj Lr`glf` Qjopej dn Aflcl, Jpgjsus .
Qjopej dn Ofcjrvl Rdefls lt Rrfjcj
Qjopej dn Lpdeed Jpf`urfus lt Mlsslj .
Qjopej lt Jejusfs . . . . ~ ; -U.
02. Hrjjk Jxlopejs WFF.
C.w. ; . w /.,
G, i, K Ourrly.
E, O Olu`g.
\, ] Olu`g.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
20/790
Cd, Cloj.
,, ,, sj`tfdc
,, ,, cdrtg jejvltfdc .
nrdct nl6laj . . . U.
Ltgjcs
Rlctgjdc, ]doj .... Qypf`le ]dolc L`lctgus ejln ., .
Relcs dn `lpftle (L) eddkfch up
Aflhrlo dn rjeltfvj sfzjs dn
Rlctgjdc,]doj, lca tgj Ptdl, Ltgjcs . .
Lchej vfjw dn `lpftle nrdo tgj Ptdl,
Ltgjcs ...... Relcs dn `lpftle, eddkfch up . . .
Qypf`le jxlopej dn Hrjjk L`lctgus ejln
@doplrltfvj Jxlopejs dn Hrjjk lca
]dolc Qgjltrjs.
sj`tfdc .... ,,
pjrfstyej
,, sj`tfdc '. .
,, wjst jejvltfdc
rddn
jejvltfdc . , .
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
21/790
Cd. Cloj.
]dolc Addrwlys.
Addrwly, Jrj`gtgjfdc, Ltgjcs, jejvltfdc
,, ,, ,, ajtlfes .
]dolc Drajrs dn Lr`gftj`turj.
Hrjjk Adrf` Qjopej dn Qgjsjus lt
Ltgjcs ...... ]dolc Adrf`, my ^fhcdel Hrjjk Fdcf` Qjopej dc tgj
Fefssus,
Ltgjcs ......]dolc Fdcf`, my P`lodzzf .
Hrjjk @drfctgflc @gdrlhf` Odcuojct
dn Eysf`rltjs, Ltgjcs
]dolc @drfctgflc Rlctgjdc, ]doj .
@doplrfsdc dn Hrjjk lca ]dolc
Odueafchs FF
@lpftle nrdo Jhyptflc wlee plfctfch
Mrdczj lrodur peltj nrdo Qlolssds,
@yprus . . .... @lpftle nrdo Cjlcarfl .... @lpftle nrdo tgj Gjrlfdc
lt Deyopfl Fdcf` Ey`flc tdom
.... Hdeaolc's ojtgda dn ajs`rfmfch Fdcf`
^deutj
Lchej `lpftle, C. pdrtf`d dn Jrj`gtgjfdc,
glen sj`tfdc
,, glen nrdct vfjw . .
1=. Hrjjk Drclojct FF.
P`rdee drclojct nrdo rddn dn `gdrlhf` Odcuojct dn Eysf`rltjs,
Ltgjcs
Plc`tulry dn tgj Muees, Ajeds
jcelrhja trfheypgs, sfaj vfjw .
@lcjpgdrl . . .. .
Lutgdrftfjs.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
22/790
Cd. Cloj.
@lryltfa nfhurj nrdo Jrj`gtgjfdc Qypf`le Hrjjk
Lctgjofdc
@lpftle, `gdrlhf` Odcuojct dn Eysf` rltjs,
Ltgjcs `
A, J
Hrjjk Drclojct F^.
Ptjej gjla J
Ojtdpj nrdo tgj Rlrtgjcdc . . . G L`lctgus drclojct . . . . i
@dcsdej nrdo Jrj`gtgjfdc . . K, E
Rdrtfdc dn `lryltfa nfhurj O Lctjnfxl drccojct C
]DOLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J.
]dolc Jxlopejs F.
]dolc Pystjo dn @dcstru`tfdc ]dolc wleefch dn `dc`rjtj wftg
mrf`k
nl`fch lca ojtgdas dn gjltfch . . L td G ]dolc vluetfch lca adojs
dn `dc`rjtj F td O
Relc dn tgj ]dolc Ndrl
Qgj Ndruo ]dolcuo rjstdrja
,, ,, nrdct nl6laj
,, ,, jejvltfdc
,, pelc .
]doj, vfjw nrdo
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
23/790
Qjopej dn Plturc, ]doj, pelc . . E
,, ,, nrdct nl6laj . . O ,, ,, ajtlfes dn jctlmelturj C
:2. ]dolc Jxlopejs FFF.
Qjopej dn ^jcus lca ]doj, ]doj, plrt `rdss sj`tfdc . . L
,, ,, pelc M
,, ,, `rdss sj`tfdc . . N
,, ,, plrt edch, sj`tfdc . H Olfsdc @lrrjj, Cfojs, pelc G
,, ,, nrdct jejvltfdc . . i
jejvltfdc . . L
styej A Qdom dn @lj`fefl Ojtjeel, ]doj . . J
Qdom lt Xlaf-Qlhfij, Cdrtg Lnrf`l . N
Qdom lt Auhhl, cjlr Qucfs, pelc lca
vfjw . . . . . . . H
Qdom lt P. ]jof fc tgj Pdutg dn Nrlc`j G
Qjopej dn Lctdcfcus lca Nlustfcl,
]doj, pelc . F
Qjopej dn Olrs Zetdr, ]doj, ajtlfe dn
`drmje, `drcf`j td
jc`edsfch wlee . . C
,, ,, pelc R
,, ,, glen jctrlc`j nl4laj M
,, ,, edch, sj`tfdc tgrduhg Hrjlt Qjopej . `
,, ,, trlcsvjrsj sj`tfdc, Hrjlt Qjopej . A
,, pelc J
,, ,, nl6laj . . . H
,, ,, ,, glen-pelc . M
r . `, A
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
24/790
Cd.
Qgj Rlctgjdc, ]doj.
....]dolc Jxlopejs ^FF.
drajr lca kjy pelc L
,, ,, ajtlfe dn `lpftle . M
,, ,, kjystdcj dn lr`g . / @
pelc
. . . J
kjy pelc . . G
... L
,, ,, fctjrfdr vfjw J
]dolc Jxlopejs FW.
Mltgs dn @lrl`leel, ]doj Relc (rjstdrja) Rlel`j dn Afd`ejtflc
lt
Ppleltd ...... ]dolc Jxlopejs W.
,, ,, sj`tfdc
@fr`uelr Qjopej dn Mllemj`, pelc .
,, ,, ,, sj`tfdc
,, ,. jejvltfdc
pelc
,, ,, sj`tfdc. . . M
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
25/790
Cd.- Cloj.
fU ,, pelc .
,, ,, jejvltfdcs
>8. ]dolc Drclojct F.
Qjopej dn Iupftjr lt ]doj, `lpftle Lr`g dn Qftus, kjystdcj.
Ndruo dn Cjrvl, ]doj, `drcf`j .
Rfelstjr ^feel Ojaf`f, ]doj .
Qjopej dn Olrs Zetdr, `lpftle
Rlctgjdc, plcje ..... >7. ]dolc Drclojct FF.
Qjopej dn Iupftjr Ptltdr, ]doj, ajtlfes
dn `drcf`j
,, ,, pelc dn `dnnjr .
]doj, pdrtfdc dn nrfjzj . '.9. ]dolc @drfctgflc pfelstjr `lpftle,
Rlc-
tgjdc, ]doj ..... ]dolc letlr ..... Rfelstjr `lpftles . . . .
* .
]dolc lro `glfr ..... >6. ]dolc Drclojct FFF.
Lr`g dn Qftus, ]doj 9 Nfhurjs fc splc- arjes dn olfc lr`g
....
Mltgs dn Qftus, ]doj 9 Xlee nrjs`d
Mrdczj `lcajelmrl .... Qypf`le ]dolc trfpda letlr .
Qypf`le ]dolc mltgs .... ]dstrle `deuoc ..... Odslf` plvjojct,
Rdopjff .
]dolc `glrfdt ..... Qypf`le ]dolc tdom .
82. Rrfc`fpejs dn Rrdpdrtfdc.
Qjtrlstyej, gjxlstyej, lca d`tlstyej ndro
dn Qjopej Lr`g dn Qrlilc, Mjcjvjctuo
Lr`g dn Pjptfofus Pjvjrus, ]doj
Mlptfstjry, Rfsl . . . ;.
@glptjr Gdusj lt Xjees
P. Hjdrhj's @glpje, Xfcasdr
Lutgdrftfjs.
L
M
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
26/790
Cd. Cloj.
8<. Dptf`le @drrj`tfdcs fc Lr`gftj`turj.
@drrj`tfdc dn lpplrjct prdpdrtfdcs Jnnj`t dn `dedr dc prdpdrtfdcs
Qgj Rlrtgjcdc 9 Fc`efcltfdc dn `deuocs
Ojtgda dn arlwfch jctlsfs dn `deuoc
Qgj Rlrtgjcdc 9 Dptf`le `drrj`tfdcs td
prjvjct lppjlrlc`j dn slhhfch .
Dptf`le feeusfdcs `lusja my `dcvjx lca
`dc`lvj `urvjs, wgjc aflwc fc rjeltfdc
td plrleeje strlfhgt efcjs
G, I
8=.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
27/790
Cd.
87.
86-
72.
7<.
7=.
70.
71-
`edfstjr
......P. @ejojctj, ]doj, plrlpjt lca pfelstjr P. Olrfl Olhhfdrj,
]doj, odslf`.
P. Hfdvlccf, odslf` neddr
Adoj `dcstru`tfdc . . . . L, M ) Ejtglmy lca
Ojtgda td nfca dutefcj dn pjcajctfvj . `, A i
Pwlfcsdc.
vfjw....... N
P. Pjrhfus, @dcstlctfcdpej, pelc . . H Qdom dn Hleel Rel`fafl,
sj`tfdc . . G P. Pdpgfl, @dcstlctfcdpej, sj`tfdcle
vfjw....... y
jejvltfdc ...... L P. Pdpgfl, @dcstlctfcdpej, edchftuafcle
sj`tfdc ...... M
@doplrltfvj Jxlopejs dn Jlrey Adoja Ptru`turjs.
Qgj Ofcjrvl Ojaf`l, ]doj, pelc . . L
,, ,, ,, sj`tfdc .
,, ,, sj`tfdc . . . A @ltgjarle lt Lfx-el-@glpjeej. pelc J
,, ,, ,, sj`tfdc . N
Myzlctfcj Jxlopejs FFF.
. P. Olrk, pelc . . . . . `
P. Nrdct, Rjrfhujux, pelc A
P.
,, pelc M
sj`tfdc ..... J
@gur`g dn Qgjdtdkds, @dcstlctfcdpej, X. lca P. jejvltfdcs . . N,
d
pelc . . . . ; T
U Plezjcmjrh.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
28/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
29/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
30/790
Lofjcs @ltgjarle . . . . . L
plrtojct . M
tfcjctle @ltgjarles.
]dolc `rdss vluet .... L
]dolcjsquj `rdss vluet ... M
Hdtgf` vluet
<<=. Jchefsg Hdtgf` Jxlopejs F.
Hdtgf` ^luetfch.
Xjstofcstjr Lmmjy, hrdfcja, wftg fctjr-
ojafltj rfms . . . . . K, O Mrfstde @ltgjarle, Aj`drltja Efjrcj
vluet C, d
P. Olry, ]ja`efnnj, Rjrpjcaf`uelr stjeelr
vluet fctjrfdr vfjw . . . . p, \ Hedu`jstjr, @ltgjarle,
Rjrpjcaf`uelr nlc
vluetfch . . . . . ], s
Qypjs dn Ojafljvle Dpjc Qfomjr ]ddns.
Ptdwj Mlradepg @gur`g, trussja rlntjr
rddn L
rddn . . . . . ,-.-. M
mrl`ja rddn . . . . - . `
Lutgdrftfjs,
^fdeejt-ej-Au`.
X. ]. Rur`glsj.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
31/790
EFPQ DN FEEZPQ]LQFDCP.
`dctfcuja.
mjlo rddn ..... J
Cjw Xlesfchglo, lfsej rddn H
Xjstofcstjr Glee, gloojr-mjlo rddn . G
Jvdeutfdc dn gloojr-mjlo I
@gf`gjstjr
Aurglo Jey . . . `
Vdrk ....... L
Jxjtjr . . . . . . . E3 Rgdtds my Xfc`gjstjr ...... J Q.
Qglt`gjr.
Gjrjndra ...... N
Xjees ....... H
Plefsmury ...... L
Efc`dec
]fpdc ....... J
@doplrltfvj Relcs dn Jchefsg @ltgjarles f.
Jey ....... L < Mufeajr '
Ptdrjr, Mrfttdc,
@doplrltfvj Relcs dn Jchefsg @ltgjarles =.
Xdr`jstjr ...... L < 'Mufeajr @ltgj-
@lctjrmury ...... M arle Pjrfjs,
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
32/790
Cd.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
33/790
Xjstofcstjr Lmmjy 9
<02. Jchefsg Hdtgf` Jxlopejs W.
Qypf`le Jchefsg Rlrfsg @gur`g 9
P. Lcarjw. Gj`kfchtdc, Efcjs.
vfjw
fctjrfdr .
Mufeafchs 9
Kjcfewdrtg @lstej
Ptdkj Rlrk
Rjcsgurst Rel`j, jejvltfdc dn hrjlt glee .
,, ,, sj`tfdc dn rddn
., ., hjcjrle pelc
,, ,, pelc lca edchftuafcle
,, ,, sj`tfdcs
<01. Plxdc Lr`gftj`turj. Jlres Mlrtdc, tdwjr ....
,, ,, wfcadw .... Ajjrsgurst, ,,
@drgloptdc, fopdst
WWW<<<
Lutgdrftfjs.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
34/790
Cd. Cloj.
<0>. Jchefsg Hdtgf` Jxlopejs WFFF.
@doplrltfvj Jxlopejs sgdwfch prdhrjss dn
Jchefsg Hdtgf` @ltgjarle Lr`gftj`turj 9
Jey @ltgjarle, clvj, fctjrfdr lca jxtjrfdr L
Rjtjrmdrduhg ,, ,, ,, M
Jey, prjsmytjry ,, ,, . / A
Jchg'sg Hdtgf` @ltgjarle Lr`gftj`turj
(`dctfcuja).
jxtjrfdr ...... J
Xfc`gjstjr, clvj, fctjrfdr lca jxtjrfdr . H
<07. Fnnejy @gur`g, Dxdc
<06. Cdrolc Odueafchs.
Xfc`gjstjr, mfeejt `
Efc`dec, jomltteja . . . . O
Qgj Jvdeutfdc dn Hdtgf` Ppfrjs fc Jchelca 9
P. Rjtjr, ]lucas, Cdrtglcts... L
P. Idgc, Kjystdcj, Gucts. M
P. Xuenrlc, Hrlctglo, Efcjs. . . `
P. Of`glje, @dvjctry, Xlrwf`ksgfrj . G
<1<. Jchefsg Hdtgf`
Jxlopejs W^F.
Cdrolc, Nductlfcs Lmmjy . . . L
Aj`drltja, P. Olry Olhalejc, Dxndra . `
Rjrpjcaf`uelr, Afvfcfty P`gdde, Dxndra . c
Ajtl`gja Neyfch Muttrjss, @glptjr Gd.
Efc`dec ...... J
@dcstru`tfvj prfc`fpej dn tgj Ojafljvle
@gur`g . . H
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
35/790
Cd. Cloj.
@doplrltfvj Jxlopejs sgdwfch prdhrjss dn
Hdtgf` Qrl`jry Ajvjedpojct 9
Eyc`gojrj, peltj trl`jry ... L Xddastd`k ,, ., . . . M
Adr`gjstjr, mlr trl`jry . . . `
Ofcstjr Edvje, mlr trl`jry . . . A
Gjlafchtdc, peltj trl`jry . . . J
Xfomdrcj Ofcstjr, hrdupja elc`jt efhgts N
Xlrofchtdc, hrdupja elc`jt efhgts . H
Edch Xfttjcglo, hjdojtrf`le trl`jry . G P. Olry Olhalejc,
`urvfefcjlr trl`jry .
i
K, F,
Hrjlt Ofetdc, `urvfefcjlr trl`jry . . O Cjw @deejhj @glpje,
rj`tfefcjlr trl`jry. C
Kfch's @deejhj @glpje ,, ,, . d P. Olry, Afclc, Nelomdylct jxlopej
. p
<10. Jchefsg Hdtgf` Jxlopejs W^FFF.
@doplrltfvj Jxlopejs dn Jchefsg Hdtgf`
Addrwlys 9
`lpftle lca mlsj .
`lpftle lca mlsj . . J
lr`g oduea N
ilom lca lr`g oduea . H
`lpftle lca mlsj . . G Ojrtdc @deej j @glpje, Dxndra, jejvltfdc
i
,, `lpftle lca mlsj K
,, ilom lca lr`g
Cdrolc Ndct, @dejsgfee, Xlrwf`ksgfrj . L
J. Jchefsg Ndct, El`kndra, Punndek . M
Aj`drltja Ndct, Dnnejy, Gjrts . . `
Rjrpjcaf`uelr Ndct, @eyopfch@g, Pussjx A
Cdrolc Rfs`fcl, @rdwolrsg, Dxndra-
sgfrj....... J
J. Jchefsg Rfs`fcl, @dwefch, Punndek . N Aj`drltja Rfs`fcl. Ht.
Mjawfc, Xfetsgfrj H
Rjrpjcaf`uelr Rfs`fcl, @dmglo, Kjct . G J. Jchefsg Qlmjrcl`ej,
Xlrofchtdc,
Cdrtglcts ...... i
Cdrolc Pjafefl, P. Olry, Ejf`jstjr . K Aj`drltja Qlmjrcl`ej, Jxjtjr
@ltgjarle E
'
Rlrkjr.
Mrlaadc.
Rlrkjr.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
36/790
Cd, Cloj,
Rjw, Ptjjpej Lstdc, Dxdc. .
Ruepft (Jxtjrcle), Olhalejcj @dee.,
Cdrndek
Cdrtglcts ,
@ltgjarle
Lutgdrftfjs.
[ Rlrkjr.
F Mddk.
@doplrltfvj Odueafchs dn tgj Rjrfdas dn
Hdtgf` Lr`gftj`turj 9
Cdrolc `lpftles, mlsjs, pfjrs . . F td <0 Jlrey
Jchefsg
'
'
@doplrltfvj Pjej`tfdc dn Hdtgf` Drclojcts fc Afnnjrjct Rjrfdas
9
Jlrey Jchefsg adh-tddtg drclojct. . L
., ,, `rd`kjt . . . . i
plrlpjt C Rjrpjcaf`uelr
`drcf`j nedwjr . . N Quadr nedwjr, `rjstfch . H
Quadr rdsj G `rd`kjt .... E
plrlpjt d
Rlrkjr lca
lca @lrvja Ndeflhj 9
'iAj`drltja `lpftles lca drclojct . H, G, I, K
Rjrpjcaf`uelr
f Rlrkjr, Ruhfc, lca @deefch.
<16. Jchefsg Hdtgf` Drclojct F^.
Hlmej @rdssjs 9 Jlrey Jchefsg Gfhglo Njrrjrs
,, ,, Aj`drltja Glsefchnfjea
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
37/790
Plc`tus Mjee Medxglo @gur`g, Dxdc. .
Nfcfles 9
arle
Ptdcj Rjcalct 9 Rjrpjcaf`uelr, Lee
Plfcts, Jvjsglo .... Mdssjs 9 Jlrey Jchefsg Efc`dec @ltgj-
arle .
., ,, Xjstofcstjr
Lmmjy .
@gur`g, Mury Pt. Jaoucas .
Jlrey Jchefsg mrl`kjt9 P. Lemlc's Lmmjy Rdppy-gjlas 9 Rlstdc
@gur`g, Cdrndek .
,, Xfc`gjstjr @ltgjarle
<:<. Jxlopejs dn P`dttfsg Lr`gftj`turj.
]dtgjsly @lstej, pelc .... Aruo @lstej, pelc..... Aducj @lstej,
pelc @lstej Nrlzjr, pelc @dwlcj's Gdspftle, pelc Helofs @lstej,
pelc ....
,, vfjw nrdo tgj sdutg-jlst
Hjdrhj Gjrfdt's Gdspftle, pelc
,, ,. ,, vfjw nrdo tgj
pelc ` i-
Cdtrj Aloj, Rlrfs, wgjje wfcadw . K Hlfeglmlua.
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
38/790
Cd. Cloj.
cjctle @ltgjarles.
<::. Nrjc`g Hdtgf` Jxlopejs FF.
@doplrltfvj pelcs dn `ltgjarles 9
]dujc
...... Jvrjux
<:>. Cdtrj Aloj, Rlrfs. ^fjw dn wjst nrdct .
<:8. Nrjc`g Hdtgf` Jxlopejs FFF.
Cdtrj Aloj, Rlrfs, jxtjrfdr mly .
,, ,. ,,
<:7. Cdtrj Aloj, Rlrfs. Fctjrfdr .
<:6. @doplrltfvj Relcs dn Jchefsg lca Nrjc`g Qypjs dn
@ltgjarles.
Lutgdrftfjs.
<>2.
@dutlc`js @ltgjarle. ^fjw dn wjst nrdct
Gdusj dn Il`qujs @`jur, Mdurhjs .
<>1. Rlelfs aj Iustf`j, ]dujc.... <>:. Nrjc`g Hdtgf`
Drclojct.
@glrtrjs, nfhurj s`uepturj
,, ,, stdcj puepft Odct P. Of`gje, ndeflhj
Cdtrj Aloj, @gledcs sur-Olrcj .
Pjour, `lpftle lca `rd`kjt .
<>>. Lctwjrp @ltgjarle. Jxtjrfdr .
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
39/790
Cd. Cloj.
,. ,, pelc
<>7. Qdwc Glee, Mruhjs.... <>6. Qdwc Glee, Hgjct ....
<82. Hjrolc Hdtgf` Jxlopejs F.
@dedhcj @ltgjarle, jxtjrfdr .
P. Ptjpgjc, ^fjccl, pelc
,, jxtjrfdr .
Ofelc @ltgjarle, pelc .
,, edch, sj`tfdc
,, trlcsvjrsj sj`tfdc
,, edch, sj`tfdc .
<86. Ftleflc Hdtgf` Jxlopejs FF.
Rlelzzd ajeel @l a'Drd, jejvltfdc .
Adhj's Rlel`j, ^jcf`j, nl4laj
Rlelzzd Rfslcf, ^jcf`j, nl6laj
Pfjcl @ltgjarle, pelc .
L, @
M
F)
I
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
40/790
Cd. Cloj.
<7<. Nedrjc`j @ltgjarle. Jxtjrfdr .
<7=. Pfjcl @ltgjarle. Jxtjrfdr
<71. Ftleflc Hdtgf` Drclojct.
puepft
Clpejs, `lpftle ..... Au`le Rlel`j, ^jcf`j, `lpftle
^jcf`j, lchej wfcadw .... Rlelzzd P`lefhjrf, ^jrdcl, `loplcfej
.
<7:. Murhds @ltgjarle. Jxtjrfdr .
< 7>. Murhds @ltgjarle. Fctjrfdr
<78. Pplcfsg Hdtgf` Jxlopejs.
Mlr`jedcl @ltgjarle, pelc
<76. P. Hrjhdrfd, ^leeladefa .... <62. Pplcfsg Hdtgf`
Drclojct.
Murhds @ltgjarle, drclojct nrdo tdom .
,, Hdczled ,, .
Ofrlnedrjs, Fcnlctj's tdom .
L
M `
,, ,, sj`tfdc lca jejvltfdc dn
`durt ; . . `
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
41/790
Cd. Cloj.
., ,, jejvltfdc . . . A
,, ,, pelc.... H
Rlzzf @glpje, pelc
., ,, ,, edch, sj`tfdc.
Audod dn Nfjsdej, `dcsdej nrdo tdom
Rlelzzd ^j``gfd. `lpftle Ojaf`f @glpje, Plctl @rd`j, `drmje
Rlelzzd Ptrdzzf, wfcadw
Mlccjr mrl`kjt
<6:. Rlelzzd Hfrlua, ]doj . . .
@lc`jeelrfl Rlel`j, jejvltfdc .
,, ,, pelc
<67. ]dolc ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs FF.
Nlrcjsj Rlel`j, ]doj Ajtlfes dn olfc `drcf`j .
Nrdct nl4laj .... Jejvltfdc dn `drtfej
Relc
Zppjr pelc ....
L, M
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
42/790
Cd.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
43/790
Cd. Cloj.
=27. ^jcjtflc ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs F.
Rlelzzd Hrfolcf, pefctg .
,, `drcf`j, `lpftles .
=<2. ^jcjtflc ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs FF.
P. Olrk's Efmrlry, nl4laj
....
,, ,, sj`tfdc
,, ,, edch- sj`tfdc
: i ,, pelc .
,, ,, sj`tfdc
@doplrltfvj Relcs dn ^lrfdus @ltgjarles.
P. Rlue, Edcadc
P, Olrfl ajeel Pleutj .... ^jcjtflc ]jclfsslc`j Drclojct.
P. Olrk, pjajstle dn nelhstlnn
Jqujstrflc stltuj dn @deejdcf, jejvltfdc
Glen pelc, afttd .
Jctlmelturj lca `lpftle
,, ,, plcje .
Xfcadw lca mleustrlaj
Rlelzzd Ydrzf, `lpftle .... P. O. ajf Ofrl`def, `lpftle lca
pfelstjr .
,, Hrj`f, `loplcfej .
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
44/790
Cd. Cloj.
Qgj Mlsfef`l lt ^f`jczl, jejvltfdc . . L
,, ,, sj`tfdc . .
,, ,, sj`tfdc . . J
Rlelzzd Rdrtd Mlrmlrlcd, ,, . . / G
^jrdcl.
,, ,, sj`tfdc . . . `
^jrdcl.
addrwly . . L
,, ,, kjy skjt`g . . A
,. @lrjhl, lchej `drcf`j . . `
, , , , kjy skjt`g . . J
,, ,, pfelstjr . . . K, E
=<6. @gltjlu aj Medfs, Js`lefjr Nrlc`dfs
Rrjofjr . . . .
@gltjlu aj Mury, pelc .... L
,, ,, jejvltfdc M
,, @glomdra, pelc . . . @
,, ,, jejvltfdc . . A
,, ,, med`k pelc . . N
Ejs Fcvlefajs, Rlrfs, sj`tfdc tgrduhg adoj . . L
,, ,, pelc M
,, ,, pelc N
,, ,, ,, pelc . . G
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
45/790
==1.
Rlel`j lt Ndctlfcjmejlu, `lpftle
,, ,, plcje @gltjlu aj @glomdr`e, `lpftle
,, ,, adrojr
Kjystdcj
Rlrfs, `dcsdej ..... ^jrslfeejs, styej dn aj`drltfdc
Addrwly . .
Gjfajemjrh @lstej
Ejohd Qdwc Glee, jejvltfdc .
Pdedtgurc Qdwc Glee, jejvltfdc
,. ,, stltuj . .
Jxlopejs.
Gllrejo, pfccl`ejs .... Lctwjrp, hlmej ..... Ztrj`gt, pfelstjrs
..... Ejyajc Qdwc Glee, jejvltfdc
Qgj Qdwc Glee, Lctwjrp
Drclojct. Adrarj`gt, mjc`g-jcas .... Lctwjrp, addrwly .... Hlmej
jca
Jchgfjc, `lpftle ..... Mrussjes, drclojct
Ousjj Relctfc, Lctwjrp, addr
Lutgdrftfjs.
Rgdtd.
L
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
46/790
Cd. Cloj.
Qdejad ; tgj Le`lzlr, pdrtfdc dn nl`laj .
Lvfel, tgj @lsl Rdejctfcl `durtylra
=08. Murhds. @durtylra dn tgj Gdusj dn
Ofrlcal ..... =07. @doplrltfvj Relcs dn ^lrfdus Mufeafchs.
Qgj Kfch's Gdusj, Hrjjcwf`g . . (
Qgj ]dtucal, ^f`jczl .... Qgj Js`urfle, Pplfc .... ^feel dn Rdpj
Iuefus, ]doj .
Mejcgjfo Rlel`j ..... =06. Pplcfsg ]jclfsslc`j Drclojct.
Pfhujczl @ltgjarle, addr nrdo `edfstjrs
@ujczl @ltgjarle, frdc s`rjjc
Le`lel Aj Gjclrjs, wfcadw .
Lvfel, frdc puepft .... =12. Olp dn Xjstjrc Jurdpj lt tgj Qfoj
dn
Jefzlmjtg.
=11. Jchefsg ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs F.
Gdeelca Gdusj, jejvltfdc
,, ., hrduca neddr pelcs
stlfr`lsj ..... =1:. Jchefsg ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs FF.
@lstej Lsgmy, Cdrtgloptdcsgfrj, sdutg
=17. Qgj Qdwjr dn tgj dea P`gddes, Dxndra .
=16. Gltnfjea Gdusj , . ,
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
47/790
Cd. Cloj.
Mrlosgfee Gdusj, Glcts, mleustrlaj . L
., ., ,, drfje . . J
,, ,, ., lr`laj . .
Gltnfjea Gdusj, cjwje `
,, ,, ,. `gfocjy pfj`j K Lee Gleedw's (Mlrkfch) @gur`g, wlee
tlmejt N
@elvjrtdc, Pdojrsjtsgfrj, rlfc wltjr
Mly wfcadw, Gfc`gfchmrddkj Glee . M
@glpje s`rjjc, @glrtjrgdusj, Edcadc . `
Mddk`lsj, Rjomrdkj @deejhj, @lomrfahj A Qdom dn Edra Murhgejy, P.
Olrtfc,
Ptlondra ...... J
...... N
Ejla `fstjrc, ^f`tdrfl lca Lemjrt
Ousjuo ...... G
=:=. Jchefsg ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs FFF.
Vdrk Xltjr-Hltj, Edcadc, jejvltfdc . L
,, ,, ,, pelc . . M
J
P. Rlue, Edcadc, Xrjc's drfhfcle pelc L
,, ,, sj`tfdc tgrduhg adoj
,, ,, trlcsvjrsj sj`tfdc . J
,, ,, jejvltfdc . . . M
G. F. Qrfhhs. G. Qlccjr, iucr..
@lopmjee.
Kjct.
@lopmjee.
Kjct.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
48/790
Cd. Cloj.
P. Ptjpgjc, Xlemrddk, ajtlfes
P. Ilojs, Rf``lafeey, Edcadc '
Relc
P. Mrfaj, Edcadc, pelc
@lstej Gdwlra, jejvltfdc
Addrwly ...... Gdrsj Hulras, Edcadc, typf`le wfcadw
Lstdc, wlee tlmejt .... Xfetdc, lr`gwly .... P. Olrtfc's @gur`g,
Edcadc, wfcadw
Hltj pfjrs . . . .
@gfocjy pfj`j .....Xjstofcstjr, odcuojct
=><. Jchefsg ]jclfsslc`j Jxlopejs FW.
Jxlopejs my Pfr Xfeeflo @glomjrs.
Rjafojctja hltjwly .... Addrwly ...... L ^jcjtflc wfcadw ....
Addrwly dr pdrtfdc dn Fdcf` `dedcclaj
wftgdut pjajstles
Addrwly dr pdrtfdc dn @drfctgflc `dedc-
claj wftg pjajstles .... Pupjrfopdsja drajrs, wftgdut pjajstles
.
,, ,, ,, sj`tfdc
pjajstles
tgdrftfjs.
L, @
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
49/790
Cd. Cloj.
=>=. @doplrltfvj aflhrlos dn tgj prdpdr- tfdcs dn tgj Drajrs
lntjr Pfr X. @glomjrs.
Hrjjk Adrf` .
Qus`lc
]dolc Adrf` . . . . .
Lutgdrftfjs.
@glomjrs.
Rgdtd.
=>1. Hlrrf`k
FCAFLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J.
Pjrfchglo, `dopduca pfeelr .
Mfcarlmuca, Lhrl, pelc
Ptdcj drclojcts ..... =>8. Klref. Fctjrfdr dn rd`k-`ut
`lvj
=>7. Liuctl. Nl$laj dn rd`k-`ut `lvj
=>6. Jejpglctl. Fctjrfdr vfjw dn rd`k-`ut `lvj
=82. Oduct Lmu. Fctjrfdr dn Afewlcl Qjopej .
=8<. Rleftlcl. Qgj hrjlt @glwoukg Qjopej .
=8=. Hwlefdr. Qgj hrjlt Pls Mlgu Qjopej
=80. Zomjr. Qgj Gfcau Qjopej dn Qlhlt- Hlrwlc . ......
=81. Gueelmfa. Qgj Jlst addr dn tgj adumej
Qjopej ....... =8:. Jeedrl. Qgj rltg (Qjopej dn Klfeds)
.
=8>. Qlcidrj. Qgj Hrjlt Qjopej nrdo tgj C.J.
=88. Olcaurl. Qgj Xjst Hltjwly lca Hdpurl
=87. Qlrputry. Jctrlc`j td tgj dea Qjopej
=86.
=72.
L
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
50/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
51/790
Cd.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
52/790
0. Jxlopejs.
M. Xlees, tgjfr `dcstru`tfdc lca trjltojct. -
`. ]ddns, tgjfr trjltojct lca ajvjedpojct.
A. Dpjcfchs, tgjfr `glrl`tjr lca sglpj.
J. @deuocs, tgjfr pdsftfdc, stru`turj, lca
aj`drltfdc.
H. Drclojct, ls lppefja fc hjcjrle td lcy
mufeafch.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
53/790
@DORL]LQF^J OJQGDA.
Ptuay ojrj sgjetjr, cdw ndr gfo, lca gfo
;
. . .
Mut gjrj's dur sdc jx`jes Lt guraej wjlvfch lcy P`ytgflc ;
njees
Dlk lca ajvfsjs rlntjrs ; arjlos lca sglpjs
Gfs arjlo fctd l addr pdst, iust js`lpjs Qgj oystjry dn gfchjs. . .
.
Qgj hddaey hrdwtg Dn mrf`k lca stdcj Dur mufeafch-pjet wls
rduhg, Mut tglt ajs`jcalcts' hlrm sufts wjee jcduhg L
pdrtf`d-`dctrfvjr.***** gj wdrk olr`gja 9
stjp my stjp l
wdrkolc nft
Qddk jl`g, cdr tdd nft td dcj tlsk, dcj tfoj
Cd ejlpfch d'jr tgj pjtty td tgj prfoj, Xgjc iust tgj
sumstftutfch dsfjr eftgj
Ndr mrfttej muerusg, sduca wdda ndr sdnt wftgj, Qd nurtgjr
edlo-lca-rduhg-`lst wdrk l stlhj, Jxl`ts lc lr`gftj`t, jxl`ts lc
lhj. M]DXCFCH.
QGJ drfhfcs dn lr`gftj`turj, letgduhg edst fc tgj ofsts dn
lctfqufty, oust glvj mjjc `dccj`tja fctfoltjey wftg tgj jcajlvdurs
dn olc td
prdvfaj ndr gfs
gls mjjc truey slfa tglt
prdtj`tfdc nrdo tgj fc`ejojc`y dn tgj sjlsdcs wls tgj odtgjr
dn
lr`gftj`turj. L``drafch td ^ftrtfvfus, olc fc gfs prfoftfvj slvlhj
stltj mjhlc td foftltj tgj cjsts dn mfras lca tgj elfrs dn
mjlsts,
`doojc`fch wftg lrmdurs dn twfhs `dvjrja wftg oua, tgjc guts
ndroja dn mrlc`gjs dn trjjs lca `dvjrja wftg turn (Cd. = `).
Dtgjr wrftjrs fcaf`ltj tgrjj typjs dn prfoftfvj awjeefchs tgj
`lvjs (Cd. = G) dr rd`ks dr tgdsj d``upfja fc guctfch dr
nfsgfch,
N.L. M
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
54/790
@D^J]JA XFQG QZ]N-
QGJ GZQ (h) ODODEFQD,' (nt PGFJEOHP Iu]L,
SSE\@OL]FLKJ]. :XQQLGV. SS S
Iu]L,:`dQEo
.r.P^S. TT ,,..'
MJJGF^J GZQ, F]JELCA.
LPPQD]JA w X/XF]J
QGJ AeLOEQJ] DN EL]HJ :QDCJ @F]@EJ FP <2> N
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
55/790
R]JGFPQD]F@ L]@GFQJ@QZ]J. 0
tgj gut (Cd. = L, A, J) ndr tgj lhrf`ueturfst, lca tgj tjct (Cd. =
i)
ndr tgdsj su`g ls sgjpgjras ejlafch l plstdrle dr cdolaf`
efnj.
Ptru`turjs dn tgj prjgfstdrf` pjrfda, letgduhg fctjrjstfch
ndr
lr`gljdedhf`le rjlsdcs, glvj efttej dr cd lr`gftj`turle vleuj,
lca
wfee dcey mj efhgtey tdu`gja updc. Qgj rjolfcs oly mj `elssfnfja
ucajr 9
f. Odcdeftgs, dr sfchej uprfhgt stdcjs, lesd kcdwc ls
ojcgfrs,
l wjee-kcdwc jxlopej >0 njjt gfhg, <1 njjt fc aflojtjr,
lca
wjfhgfch =>2 tdcs, mjfch lt @lrcl`, Mrfttlcy. Lcdtgjr jxlopej fs
lt Ed`olrflkjr, lesd fc Mrfttlcy (Cd. = M).
ff. Adeojcs (Alue, l tlmej, lca oljc, l stdcj), `dcsfstfch dn
dcj elrhj nelt stdcj suppdrtja my uprfhgt stdcjs. Jxlopejs
lrj
td mj nduca cjlr Olfastdcj lca dtgjr pel`js fc Jchelca, lesd fc
Frjelca, Cdrtgjrc Nrlc`j, tgj @glccje Fselcas, Ftley (Cd. =
N)
lca Fcafl.
fff. @rdoej`gs, dr `fr`ejs dn stdcj, ls lt Ptdcjgjchj (Cd. =
H),
Lvjmury (Xfets), lca jesjwgjrj, `dcsfstfch dn l sjrfjs dn
uprfhgt
stdcjs lrrlchja fc l `fr`ej lca suppdrtfch gdrfzdctle selms.
fv. Quouef, dr murfle oducas, wjrj prdmlmey prdtdtypjs dn tgj
Ryrlofas dn Jhypt (Cd. 1) lca tgj mjjgfvj guts nduca fc
Xlejs,
@drcwlee, Frjelca (Cd. = A, J) lca jesjwgjrj. Qglt lt Cjw
Hrlchj (Frjelca) rjsjomejs sdojwglt tgj Qrjlsury dn Ltrjus lt
Oy`jclj (Cd. <:).
v. Elkj Awjeefchs, ls afs`dvjrja fc tgj elkjs dn Pwftzjr-
elca, Ftley lca Frjelca `dcsfstja dn wddajc guts suppdrtja dc
pfejs, lca wjrj sd pel`ja ndr prdtj`tfdc lhlfcst gdstfej lttl`ks
dn
lee kfcas.
Qgjsj ndrjhdfch prfoftfvj dr prjgfstdrf` rjolfcs glvj efttej
`dcstru`tfvj sjqujc`j, lca lrj ojrjey ojctfdcja gjrj td sgdw
nrdo wglt sfopej mjhfccfchs tgj cdmej lrt dn lr`gftj`turj wls
jvdevja, letgduhg ucndrtucltjey tgj stlhjs dn tgj jvdeutfdc
`lccdt
mj trl`ja, dwfch td tgj nl`t tglt tgj deajst jxfstfch odcuojcts
dn
lcy prjtjcsfdc, ls fc Jhypt, mjedch td l gfhg stltj dn
`fvfefzltfdc.
]JNJ]JC@J MDDKP.
gfstdrfquj jt Gfstdrfquj. 1td. Rlrfs. <76=.
Efcjglo (]. P.). Qgj Ptrjjt dn Guolc Glmftltfdcs 9 Lc
L``duct dn Olc's Awjeefch-pel`js, @ustdos, jt`., fc Rrjgfstdrf`
Qfojs, lca fc
Lc`fjct Jhypt, Lssyrfl, Rjrsfl, Fcafl, Ilplc, jt`. 7vd., `edtg.
<761.
^fdeejt-ej-Au` (J. J.). Qgj Glmftltfdcs dn Olc fc lee
Lhjs.
Qrlcseltja nrdo tgj Nrjc`g my M. Mu`kclee. 7vd. <78>.
Xlrfch (I. M.). Ptdcj Odcuojcts, Quouef, lca Drclojct
dn
]jodtj Lhjs, wftg ]jolrks dc tgj Jlrey Lr`gftj`turj dn Frjelca
lca
P`dtelca. Ndefd. <782.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
56/790
QGJ GFPQD]F@LE PQVEJP.
HJCJ]LE FCQ]DAZ@QFDC.
Ajle wdrtgfey Uvftg tgj Gfstdry dn Lr`gftj`turj lca ft fs
wdrtgy td tlkj fts
pel`j wftg tgj Gfstdry dn Elw lca dn Elchulhj. N]JJOLC.
FC fctrdau`fch tgfs @doplrltfvj trjltojct dn Gfstdrf`le
Lr`gf-
tj`turj, l hjcjrle dutefcj skjt`g fs hfvjc dn tgj `dursj
wgf`g
tgj lrt gls tlkjc up td tgj prjsjct tfoj fc Jurdpj, lca lesd
fc
tgdsj `ductrfjs, su`g ls Jhypt lca Lssyrfl, wgf`g glvj
fcneujc`ja
tglt ajvjedpojct. Lr`gftj`turj oly mj slfa td fc`euaj jvjry
mufeafch dr stru`turj
rlfsja my guolc glcas, lca fs gjrj ajccja ls `dcstru`tfdc
wftg
lc lrtfstf` odtfvj 9 tgj odrj tgj elttjr fs ajvjedpja, tgj
hrjltjr
mjfch tgj vleuj dn tgj rjsuet.
Qgj nfrst glmftltfdcs dn olc wjrj
ucadumtjaey tgdsj tglt
clturj lnndraja, su`g ls `lvjs (Cd. = G) dr hrdttdjs, wgf`g
ajolcaja efttej elmdur dc gfs plrt td `dcvjrt fctd sgjetjrs
lhlfcst
tgj nury dn tgj jejojcts, lca lttl`ks nrdo gfs njeedws dr
wfea
lcfoles.
Ls sddc ls olc rdsj lmdvj tgj stltj dn ruaj clturj, gj
clturleey mjhlc td mufea odrj `doodafdus glmftltfdcs ndr gfo-
sjen, lca sdoj ndro dn tjopej ndr gfs hda. Pu`g jlrey ndros
lrj
hfvjc ucajr tgj gjlafch dn Rrjgfstdrf` Lr`gftj`turj.
Qd plss, gdwjvjr, lt dc`j fctd Gfstdrf` tfojs, tgjrj prjvlfeja fc
Jhypt l systjo dn lr`gftj`turj wgf`g `dcsfstja dn l olssfvj
`dcstru`tfdc dn wlees lca `deuocs, fc wgf`g tgj elttjr
`edsjey
spl`ja, sgdrt, lca olssfvj `lrrfja efctjes, wgf`g fc tgjfr
turc
suppdrtja tgj nelt mjloja rddn. Fc Mlmyedcfl, tgj ajvjedp-
ojct dn mrf`k `dcstru`tfdc wftg tgj `dcsjqujct jvdeutfdc dn
tgj lr`g lca vluet wls auj td tgj lmsjc`j dn odrj pjrolcjct
mufeafch oltjrfles. Qgj fcneujc`j dn Jhyptflc lca Lssyrflc
lr`gftj`turj dc tglt dn Hrjj`j fs lpplrjct fc olcy
afrj`tfdcs.
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
57/790
HJCJ]LE FCQ]DAZ@QFDC QD QGJ GFPQD]F@LE PQVEJP. :
Hrj`flc lr`gftj`turj fs `dcsfajrja my olcy td glvj gla fts
drfhfc fc tgj wddajc gut dr `lmfc ndroja dn pdsts sjt fc tgj
jlrtg, lca `dvjrja wftg trlcsvjrsj mjlos lca rlntjrs, lca
tgfs
wls tgj typj wgf`g wls ajvjedpja fc tgj jlrey Oy`jcljlc
pjrfda fctd tgj pydadous dn tgj Hrjjk gdusj. Qgfs tfomjr
lr`gf-
tj`turj, `dpfja fc olrmej dr stdcj, wls clturleey lt nfrst
vjry
sfopej lca ruaj ; tgj fcneujc`j dn tgj oltjrfle, gdwjvjr, wls
sddc
njet, wgjc tgj pjrolcjc`j lca vleuj dn stdcj lfaja fc tgj hrdwtg dn
tgj lrt. Ft sgduea mj cdtja, gdwjvjr, tglt olcy wrftjrs gdea
tglt Hrjjk lr`gftj`turj fs ajvjedpja nrdo lc jlrey stdcj typj. Ls
`fvfefzltfdc lca tj`gcf`le skfee, odrjdvjr, lavlc`ja, tgj
quleftfjs dn rjnfcjojct fc ajtlfe lca prdpdrtfdc wjrj pjr`jfvja,
lca tgj afnnjrjct drajrs dn lr`gftj`turj Adrf`, Fdcf`, lca
@drfctgflc (Cd. 07) `loj fctd jxfstjc`j. My tgj wdra drajr
fs ojlct `jrtlfc ojtgdas dn prdpdrtfdcfch lca aj`drltfch l
`deuoc, lca tgj plrt ft suppdrts, f.j., tgj jctlmelturj. Qgj lmdvj
drajrs lrj `glrl`tjrfstf` dn Hrjjk lr`gftj`turj, lca
tgj mjluty lca hrl`j wftg wgf`g tgjy wjrj trjltja, lca tgj
lrtfstf` lca oltgjoltf`le skfee wftg wgf`g tgjy wjrj
`dcstru`tja,
feeustrltj tgj kjjc lrtfstf` tjopjrlojct dn tgj Hrjjks.
Hrjj`j jvjctuleey su``uomja td tgj `dcqujrfch ]dolcs wgd,
gdwjvjr, ladptja tgjfr lr`gftj`turj, lca fc olcy `lsjs
jopedyjaHrjjk lrtfsts fc tgj jrj`tfdc dn tgjfr mufeafchs. Xgfej
mdrrdwfch tgfs trlmjltja lr`gftj`turj, tgjy laaja tgj usj dn tgj
lr`g, wgf`g
tgjy gla prdmlmey lerjlay ejlrct td `dcstru`t nrdo tgj
Jtrus`lcs,
tgj lc`fjct fcglmftlcts dn @jctrle Ftley.
Qgj `deuoc lca lr`g wjrj usja `dcidfctey my tgj ]dolcs ndr
sdoj tfoj, hdda jxlopejs mjfch tgj @dedssjuo lt ]doj (Cds.
>=
lca >0), lca tgj Qrfuopgle Lr`gjs (Cds. >: lca >>).
Qgfs
aulefso fs l vjry fopdrtlct nl`t td rjojomjr, mj`lusj, ls
wfee
mj sjjc, ft jvjctuleey jcaja fc tgj jx`eusfdc dn tgj mjlo
letdhjtgjr, lca fc tgj jopedyojct dn tgj lr`g ledcj, tgrduhgdut tgj
jctfrj `dcstru`tfvj systjo dn tgj mufeafch. Fc tgj cuojrdus
mufeafchs wgf`g tgj ]dolcs jrj`tja, ft wfee mj cdtf`ja tglt
tgj
`deuoc gls. fc tgj hjcjrlefty dn `lsjs, mj`doj ojrjey l
aj`drltfvj
njlturj, tgj l`tule wdrk dn suppdrt mjfch pjrndroja my tgj
pfjrs
dn tgj wlee mjgfca, `dccj`tja tdhjtgjr my sjof`fr`uelr
lr`gjs.
Ls tfoj wjct dc, gdwjvjr, su`g prl`tf`le pjdpej ls tgj ]dolcs
`duea cdt mut afs`lra l njlturj wgf`g wls cd edchjr
utfeftlrflc,
sd tgj `deuoc ls l aj`drltfvj njlturj afslppjlrja, lca tgj
lr`ultja systjo ft gla olskja wls jxpdsja. @deuocs wjrj, gdwjvjr,
usja `dcstru`tfvjey, ls fc olcy
dn tgj hrjlt mlsfef`ls, fc wgf`g tgj sjof`fr`uelr lr`gjs
sprfch
afrj`tey nrdo tgjfr `lpftles. Ls tgj ]dolcs `dcqujrja tgj
wgdej dn tgj tgjc kcdwc wdrea, tglt fs td sly, odst dn wglt
fs
cdw kcdwc ls Jurdpj (Cd. 1:), sd tgfs njlturj dn tgj
sjof`fr`uelr
lr`g wls fctrdau`ja fc jvjry plrt, my fts usj fc tgj
sjttejojcts
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
58/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
59/790
HJCJ]LE FCQ]DAZ@QFDC QD QGJ GFPQD]F@LE PQVEJP. 8
Ndr sdoj tgrjj `jcturfjs tgfs mjefjn gjea hdda, tfee my tgj
dpjcfch
up dn Hrjj`j td trlvje lca stuay tdwlras tgj jca dn tgj
jfhgtjjctg `jctury, tgj trlaftfdc wls odafnfja my tgj
laofssfdc
dn Hrj`flc rjolfcs td lc jqule dr suprjoj pel`j, mjsfaj dr
jvjc
lmdvj tgdsj dn ]doj. Qgfs sj`dca pglsj gla cdt, gdwjvjr, lc jqule
su``jss ndr
afvjrs rjlsdcs ; l rjl`tfdc wls lt' glca fc nlvdur dn
ojafljvle
fajles, wgjtgjr fc tgj `gur`g, lrt, dr tgj Ptltj.
L `dcs`fdus jnndrt wls tgjc olaj tgj odst jlrcjstey fc
Jchelca td odafny tgj `urrjct tglt gla mjjc nedwfch sfc`j tgj
yjlr <:22, lca sdoj dn tgj rjsuets dn tgfs lttjopt oly mj
trl`ja
my tgj stuajct wfsj jcduhg td ndeedw up tgj `eujs fcaf`ltja fc
tgj
`dc`euafch plhjs dn tgj
Jchefsg ]jclfsslc`j
styej. Fc
l`qulfct- fch gfosjen wftg tgj mufeafchs tgjrjfc ojctfdcja, gj oly
njje
tglt njw dn tgj afvjrsj jejojcts dn dur `dopejx `fvfefzltfdc,
lt
tgj mjhfccfch dn tgj twjctfjtg `jctury, glvj nlfeja td nfca
sdoj
lr`gftj`turle jxprjssfdc.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
60/790
HJCJ]LE ]JNJ]JC@J MDDKP.
C.M. Efsts dn ]jnjrjc`j Mddks ndr spj`flepjrfdas lca styejs lrj
hfvjc
tgrduhgdut tgj mddk.
Lr`gftj`turle Lssd`fltfdc Pkjt`g Mddk. Ndefd.
<7>8-<621. Mds` (J.).
Af`tfdcclfrj rlfsdccj a'Lr`gfej`turj. 1 vdes., 1td.
Rlrfs,
<788-<772.
8 0 vdes. Rlrfs, <76=-
<760.
@gdfsy (L.). Gfstdfrj aj <'Lr`gftj`turj. = vdes, 7vd.
Rlrfs, <766.
@uoofchs (@. L.). L Gfstdry dn Lr`gftj`turj fc Ftley nrdo tgj
Qfoj
dn @dcstlctfcj td tgj Alwc dn tgj ]jclfsslc`j. = vdes., 7vd.
<62<.
A'Lhfc`durt (P.).- - Gfstdry dn Lrt my fts Odcuojcts.
Qrlcseltja
nrdo tgj Ftleflc my Dwjc Idcjs. Ndefd. <718.
Ajgfd (H.) lca Mjzdea (H. v.). Afj Kfr`gef`gj Mlukucst
ajs
Lmjcaelcajs. Ndefd. Ptutthlrt, <771, jt`.
Af`tfdclry dn Lr`gftj`turj, fssuja my tgj Lr`gftj`turle
Rumef`ltfdc
Pd`fjty. Xftg Ajtl`gja Jsslys lca Feeustrltfdcs. > vdes., ndefd.
<717-<76=.
Aurlca (I. C. E.). Rlrleejej ajs Jafnf`js aj tdut hjcrj.
Rlrfs, <722.
Juelrt (@.). Olcuje a'Lr`gjdedhfj Nrlc6lfsj ajpufs ejs
tjops
Ojrdvfchfjcs iusqu'l el ]jclfsslc`j. f. Lr`gftj`turj
]jefhfjux.
=. Lr`gftj`turj @fvfej. = vdes., Pvd. Rlrfs, <62=.
Njrhussdc (I.).
Pvd. <760, jt`.
Nejt`gjr (M. N.). Qgj Fcneujc`j dn Oltjrfle dc
Lr`gftj`turj.
Fopjrfle Pvd. <768.
Hlfeglmlua (I.). E'Lr`gftj`turj au ^. lu W^FF. sfj`ej. : vdes.,
ndefd
lca 1<2. Rlrfs, <7>6-<78=. Hlfeglmlua (I.).
Odcuojcts Lc`fjcs jt Odajrcjs. 1<2. Rlrfs.
<7:2.
Glcamu`g ajr Lr`gftjktur. @doprfsfch l cuomjr dn vdeuojs updc tgj
Gfstdry lca Rrl`tf`j dn Lr`gftj`turj. Alrostlat.
Ofefzfl (N.). Efvjs dn @jejmrltja Lr`gftj`ts. = vdes., Pvd.
<7=>.
Rlrkjr (I.).
Hedsslry dn Qjros usja fc Lr`gftj`turj. 0 vdes.
<7:2.
Rjrrdt (H.) lca @gfpfjz (@.). Gfstdry dn Lc`fjct Lrt. <=
vdes.,
Pvd. <770-<761.
Relclt. Jc`y`edpjaf` a'Lr`gftj`turj jt aj el @dcstru`tfdc.
< < vdes.
]dyle Fcstftutj dn Mrftfsg Lr`gftj`ts' Qrlcsl`tfdcs.'
0
<7:0 `t s`q.
Pturhfs. L Af`tfdclry dn Lr`gftj`turj lca Mufeafch. 0
vdes.,
1td. Cjw Vdrk, <62<.
Efvjs dn tgj odst Jofcjct
Rlfctjrs, P`ueptdrs lcaLr`gftj`ts. Jaftja my Melsgnfjea. 1 vdes.,
Pvd. <768.
^fdeejt-ej-Au` (J. @.). Af`tfdcclfrj aj <'Lr`gftj`turj.
<2 vdes., Pvd.
Rlrfs, <7:6.
^fdeejt-ej-Au`. Jctrjtfjcs sur <'Lr`gftj`turj. 0 vdes.
Rlrfs, <7>0.
Qgjrj fs lc Jchefsg trlcseltfdc my M. Mu`kclee, jctfteja
Ej`turjs dc
Lr`gftj`turj. = vdes., Pvd. <788-<77<. ^ftruvfus (Olr`us
Rdeefd). Qgj Lr`gftj`turj dn. Qrlcseltja my
X- Cjwtdc. Ndefd, <86<. Lc jaftfdc my I.
Hwfet. 1<2. f04>.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
61/790
JHVRQFLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J.
Qgdsj wdrks wgjrj olc gls rfvleeja clturj odst, Qgdsj
Ryrlofas, tglt njlr cd odrj aj`ly Qglc wlvjs fcnef`t updc tgj
rd`kfjst `dlst,
Dr wfcas dc oductlfc stjjps, lca efkj jcaurlc`j mdlst.
f. FCNEZJC@JP.
f. Hjdhrlpgf`le. -Qgj `fvfefzltfdc dn jvjry `ductry gls
mjjc, ls wfee mj sgdwc, elrhjey ajtjrofcja my fts
hjdhrlpgf`le
`dcaftfdcs, ndr tgj `glrl`tjrfstf` njlturjs dn tgj elca fc wgf`g
lcy rl`j awjees sglpj tgjfr odaj dn efnj lca tgus fcneujc`j
tgjfr
fctjeej`tule `ueturj.
Dc rjnjrrfch td tgj olp (Cd. 0) ft wfee mj sjjc tglt Jhypt
`dcsfsts
dn l slcay ajsjrt wftg l strfp dn njrtfej `ductry dc tgj mlcks
dn
tgj Cfej. Jhypt wls tgj dcey cltfdc dn tgj lc`fjct wdrea
wgf`g
gla lt dc`j jlsy l``jss td tgj Cdrtgjrc, dr Ojaftjrrlcjlc
Pjl,
ls wjee ls td tgj Jlstjrc, dr Lrlmflc Pjl ; ndr my wly dn tgj
]ja
Pjl, Jhypt lewlys `doolcaja lc l``jss td mdtg tgjsj gfhgwlys. Qgj
`dcsjqujc`j wls tglt Jhypt gla dutejts ndr gjr dwc prd-
au`tfdcs lca fcejts ndr tgdsj dn ndrjfhc cltfdcs. Qgj
pdssjssfdc
pn tgj Cfej, odrjdvjr, wls dn foojcsj lavlctlhj, cdt dcey dc
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
62/790
FD @DORL]LQF^J L]@GFQJ@QZ]J.
l``duct dn fts vleuj ls l trlaj rdutj, lca ls l ojlcs dn
`dooucf-
`ltfdc, mut lesd mj`lusj fts wltjrs wjrj tgj njrtfefzfch lhjcts
tglt olaj ajsjrt slcas fctd nruftnue nfjeas. Ft wls dc tgj
mlcks
dn tgfs lc`fjct rfvjr tglt nrdo tfoj foojodrfle tgj `ftfjs dn
tgj
Jhyptflcs wjrj clturleey pel`ja ; gjrj, tgjrjndrj, lrj nduca
tgj
`gfjn rjolfcs dn tgj Qdoms, Qjopejs, lca Ryrlofas. ff. Hjdedhf`le.
Fc tgfs sj`tfdc tgrduhgdut tgj vdeuoj lc
jcajlvdur wfee mj olaj td trl`j tglt fcneujc`j dc
lr`gftj`turle
styej wgf`g tgj oltjrfles lt glca fc jl`g/`ductry gla fc fts
ajvjedpojct. Qgj clturle prdau`ts dn /l `ductry su`g ls
wdda, mrf`k, dr stdcj, ajtjrofcj td l elrhj jxtjct fts styej
dn
lrt.
Fc
Jhypt tgjrj jxfstja lc lmucalc`j dn efojstdcj fc tgj
cdrtg,dn slcastdcj fc tgj `jctrle rjhfdc, lca dn hrlcftj fc tgj
sdutg. F
Qgj elttjr fs prfc`fpleey nduca cjlr Lssulc (Pyjcj), lca fs
`leeja Pyjcftj. Qgfs glra lca elstfch mufeafch oltjrfle elrhjey
fcneujc`ja tgj lr`gftj`turj dn tgj `ductry, lca td fts
aurlmej
quleftfjs fs auj tgj nl`t tglt tgjrj lrj sd olcy rjolfcs.
Mrf`ks
wjrj lesd jopedyja, mut wjrj hjcjrleey nl`ja wftg sdoj glrajr
oltjrfle. Xdda dn l kfca suftlmej ndr mufeafch wls cdt
lvlfelmej,/
dcey solee ndrjsts dn pleo lca l`l`fl jxfstfch. I fff. @efoltj. Qgj
`efoltj fs
jqulmej lca dn
wlro tjopjrlturj,scdw lca nrdst mjfch wgdeey uckcdwc, wgfej stdro,
ndh, lca jvjc
rlfc lrj rlrj, wgf`g l``ducts td l elrhj jxtjct ndr tgj hdda
prjsjrvltfdc dn tgj tjopejs. Jhypt gls mjjc slfa td glvj mut
twd sjlsdcs, sprfch lca suoojr. Qgj `efoltj wls tgus dn
fopdrtlc`j fc ajvjedpfch tgj quleftfjs dn tgj lr`gftj`turj,
laoft-
tfch dn sfopef`fty fc `dcstru`tfdc, ndr tgduhg ft ajolcaja sdoj
F
prdtj`tfdc lhlfcst gjlt tgjrj wls cd cj`jssfty td prdvfaj lhlfcst
fc`ejojct wjltgjr.
fv. ]jefhfdc. L `edsjTSdidcj`tfdifTg.jtwjjc rjefhfdc lca lr`gf-
tj`turj fs jvjrywgjrj olcfnjst lt tgfs jpd`g. Qgj prfjstgdda wls
pdwjrnue, pdssjssja dn leodst ucefoftja lutgdrfty, lca
jqufppja wftg lee tgj ejlrcfch dn tgj lhj. Qgj rjefhfdus
rftjs
wjrj trlaftfdcle, uc`glchjlmej, lca oystjrfdus. L tfchj dn
oystjry fs dcj dn tgj hrjlt `glrl`tjrfstf`s dn tgj Jhyptflc
lr`gf-
tj`turj ls wjee fc fts tdoms ls fc fts tjopejs. Qgj Jhyptflcs
lttlfcja td l vjry gfhg ajhrjj dn ejlrcfch fc lstrdcdoy,
oltgj-
oltf`s, lca pgfedsdpgy ; tgj rjolfcs dn tgjfr eftjrlturj glvj
mjjc
prjsjrvja td us fc tgj plpyrf, dr OPP. wrfttjc dc plpjr olaj nrdo
tgj pftg dn tgj plpyrus. Fc tgjdry tgj rjefhfdc wls odcd-
tgjfstf`, mut fc prl`tf`j ft mj`loj pdeytgjfstf` ; l ouetfpef`fty
dn
hdas wls `rjltja my pjrsdcfnyfch clturle pgjcdojcl, su`g ls
tgj suc, oddc, lca stlrs, ls wjee ls tgj mrutj `rjltfdc. Qgj
Jhyptflcs wjrj strdch mjefjvjrs fc l nuturj stltj ; gjc`j
tgjfr
`lrj fc tgj prjsjrvltfdc dn tgjfr ajla, lca tgj jrj`tfdc dn
su`g
jvjrelstfch odcuojcts ls tgj Ryrlofas. Gjrdadtus ojctfdcs
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
63/790
JHVRQFLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J. FF
tglt tgj awjeefch-gdusj wls eddkja updc my tgjo ls l ojrj
tjopdrlry edahfch, tgj tdom mjfch tgj pjrolcjct lmdaj.
Xglt lvlfejtg tgjj tgy dtgjr mufeafchs4 Dn tgy tdom ledcj
tgdu lrt surj.
Dc tgj jlrtg tgdu glst cduhgt mjsfaj ;
Cduhgt dn tgjj jesj fs rjolfcfch.
v. Pd`fle lca Rdeftf`le. L vlst pdpueltfdc wls lvlfelmej
ndr jopedyojct dc pumef` wdrks, tgj wdrkojc prdmlmey rj`jfvfch cd
dtgjr ply tglc tgjfr ndda. Qgus l stltj dn `gjlp elmdur
jxfstja
wgf`g wls jofcjctey nlvdurlmej td tgj jxj`utfdc dn elrhj lca
fopdrtlct stru`turjs. Fc laaftfdc tgjrj jxfstja l `jctrlefzja
ajspdtf` hdvjrcojct wgf`g, pjrglps odrj tglc lcy dtgjr,
nlvdurja tgj jxj`utfdc dn odcuojctle wdrks. .
Ft fs lssuoja my
sdoj tglt tgj splrj tfoj wgf`g d``urs aurfch tgj lccule neddas
jclmeja tgj pdpueltfdc td mj jopedyja dc tgjsj stltj
mufeafchs.
Ft fs lesd pdssfmej tglt tgj trlcspdrt dn stdcj rjqufrja ndr
tgj
hrjlt mufeafchs wls jnnj`tja my ojlcs dn rlnts nedltja adwc
lt
tgfs sjlsdc. Aurfch tgj rjfhc dn ]lojsjs FF. tgj `lptfvjs lca
ndrjfhcjrs, wgd gla elrhjey fc`rjlsja, ,wjrj put td jcndr`ja
elmdur updc tgj pumef` wdrks, lca fc tgj nfrst `glptjr dn tgj
mddk dn Jxdaus tgj cltfvjs lrj slfa td glvj vfjwja wftg lelro
tgj
hrdwfch cuomjrs lca pdwjr dn tgjsj strlchjrs.
vf. Gfstdrf`le. Jhyptflc `fvfefzltfdc fs tgj odst lc`fjct dn
lcy dn wgf`g tgjrj fs l `ejlr kcdwejahj ; fts gfstdry fs
plrtey
ajrfvja nrdo Gdey P`rfpturj lca nrdo Hrjjk lca ]dolc lutgdrs,
mut odrj plrtf`uelrey nrdo tgj Jhyptflc mufeafchs, my wgf`g ft
`lc
mj trl`ja ml`k ndr odrj tglc 1,222 yjlrs M.@. Qgj Ryrlofas
lrj
tgduhgt td mj l tgduslca yjlrs deajr tglc lcy mufeafch wgf`g
gls
yjt mjjc afs`dvjrja fc Xjstjrc Lsfl, tgj sumij`t dn tgj cjxt
afvfsfdc. Qgj Kfchs dr Rglrldgs (nrdo tgj tftej Rjrll
?
hrjlt gdusj ) glvj mjjc lrrlchja fc tgfrty ayclstfjs,
jxtjcafch
adwc td M.@. 00=. Qgjsj glvj mjjc mlsja dc tgj efst dn Olcjtgd, lc
Jhyptflc prfjst wgd efvja lmdut M.@. 022, lca `dopfeja l
gfstdry dn Jhypt fc tgj Hrjjk elchulhj, lca oly mj afvfaja
fctd tgj ndeedwfch pjrfdas 9
<. Rrjgfstdrf` Rjrfda, M.@. =0222 (4)-1888- =. Qgj Lc`fjct
Jopfrj (Ayclstfjs F.-W.), M.@. 1888-=7=<.
Qgj `lpftle mjfch lt Ojopgfs, tgj tdoms dn tgfs pjrfda
lrj lt Lmyads, Clklajg, Ojopgfs, Plkklrl, Hfzjg lca
Lmusfr.
0. Qgj Ofaaej Jopfrj (Ayclstfjs WF.-W^F.), M.@.
=7=<-<807.
L prdspjrdus pjrfda fc wgf`g ou`g mufeafch wls `lrrfja
dut. Qgfs pjrfda fc`euajs tgj ayclstfjs dn tgj Gyskds
dr sgjpgjra kfchs.
Qgfs pjrfda gla Qgjmjs ls tgj `lpftle, lca olcy fopdsfch
mufeafchs wjrj jrj`tja lt Klrcl`, Euxdr, lca jesjwgjrj.
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
64/790
:. Rjcda dn Ndrjfhc Adofcltfdc (Ayclstfjs WWF.-WW^.), M.@.
6:2->>0.
>. Qgj Eltj Jhyptflc Rjrfda (Ayclstfjs WW^E--WWW.), M.@.
>>0-
00=.
fc`euajs tgj Rjrsflc Adofcltfdc.
8. Qgj Hrl`j-]dolc Rjrfda, M.@. 00=-L.A. >129 f. Lejxlcajr tgj
Hrjlt lca Rtdejolf` Rjrfda, M.@. 00=-02.
ff. Qgj ]dolc Rjrfda, M.@. 0D-L.A. 06:.
fff. Qgj Myzlctfcj Rjrfda, L.A. 06:->12. 7. Ojafjvle Jhypt
(Olgdojtlc Rjrfda), L.A. >12-<:<8.
6. Odajo Jhypt (Qurkfsg Adofcltfdc), LS. <:<8 td tgj
prjsjct
tfoj.
Qgfs sj`tfdc dn tgj mddk ajles wftg tgj lr`gftj`turj `doprfsja fc
Rjrfdas
<-8. Ndr
6 sjj
plhjs >:0, >:6.r Qgj cfcjtjjctg ayclsty, nducaja my ]lojsjs
F. (M.@. <122-<0>>),
ply mj tlkjc ls tgj odst mrfeeflct jpd`g dn Jhyptflc lnt.
Qgfj
jvfajc`j dn gfs hrjltcjss, lca tglt dn gfs hrlcasdc, ]lojsjs
FF.
(M.@. <000-<022), ls mufeajrs, fs td mj sjjc fc tgj Qjopejs
dn
Qgjmjs lca jesjwgjrj. Aurfch tgj twjcty-sfxtg ayclsty tgj
`ductry wls `dcqujrja my tgj Rjrsflcs fc M.@. :=8, nrdo wgdo
ft
wls wrjstja fc M.@. 00= my tgj Hrj`flc hjcjrle, Lejxlcajr tgj
Hrjlt.
Dc Lejxlcajr's ajltg lca tgj afvfsfdc dn gfs jopfrj, Jhypt
plssja td Rtdejoy, dcj dn Lejxlcajr's
hjcjrles, wgd nducaja l ayclsty tglt rueja nrdo M.@. 0=0 td M.@.
0<. Lntjr tgj wlrs wgf`g
jcaja fc tgj ajltg dn @ejdpltrl, Jhypt plssja, ls afa cjlrey
tgj
wgdej dn tgj tgjc kcdwc wdrea, fctd tgj glcas dn tgj
`dcqujrfch
]dolcs, lca mj`loj l ]dolc prdvfc`j. Dc tgj sprjla dn
Olgdojtlcfso, fc L.A. >07, Jhypt wls `dcqujrja my tgj Lrlms, wgd
ejnt fopdrtlct odcuojcts (sjj Plrl`jcf` Lr`gftj`turj, plhj
>:6).
Fc L.A. <:<8 ft mj`loj l plrt dn tgj Qurkfsg adofcfdcs.
=. L]@GFQJ@QZ]LE @GL]L@QJ]. Fc tgj vleejy dn tgj Cfej, tgj elca
wgf`g fs tgj hfnt dn l hrjlt
rfvjr, lca tgj sjlt dn tgj odst lc`fjct `fvfefzltfdc, l
prfoftfvj
lr`gftj`turj dn oua dr puaaeja `ely lca mucaejs dn rjjas `glchja fc
eltjr tfojs td l styej dn stdcj lca hrlcftj.
Qgj prfoftfvj stru`turj wls `dopdsja dn mucaejs dn rjjas
mduca tdhjtgjr lca pel`ja vjrtf`leey fc tgj hrduca lt
fctjrvles,
tgj lchej mucaejs mjfch dn hrjltjr strjchtg. Idfcfch tgjsj
rjjas,
lt tgj tdp, wjrj elfa gdrfzdctleey dtgjr mucaejs, wgf`g mduca tgj
gjlas dn tgj uprfhgts tdhjtgjr. Qgj drfhfc dn tgj
`glrl`tjrfstf`
`drcf`j (Cd. <2 i), fs gjea td mj auj td tgj prjssurj dn tgj
`ely, dn
wgf`g tgj prfoftfvj rddns wjrj `dcstru`tja, dc tgj uprfhgt
rjjas,
wgf`g ndroja tgj nrlojwdrk dn tgj wlees. Qgfs ndroja tgj
sefhgtey prdij`tfch `drcf`j, tgj rjjas kjjpfch tgj rlooja `ely
fc
l prdij`tfch pdsftfdc lca leedwfch tgj `urvj td mj tjrofcltja my l
nelt nfeejt wgf`g hlvj tgj ejvje dn tgj tjrrl`j. Qgj iloms
lca
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
65/790
JHVRQFLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J. <0
efctjes dn tgj addrs lca wfcadws wjrj olaj dn rjjas fc tgj
guomejr awjeefchs lca dn pleo trucks fc tgdsj dn odrj
prjtjcsfdc.
Gjrj, tgjc, fs sjjc l nlfr lca efkjey prdtdtypj dn tgj
`dcstru`-
tfdc dn lc Jhyptflc wlee, tgj ndro dn wgf`g fs odrj suftlmej
td l stru`turj dn rusgjs dvjrelfa wftg oua dr puaaeja `ely tglc td
dcj `dcsfstfch dn elrhj stdcjs. Ptfee, lc fopdrtlct pdfct rjolfcs
tgj mlttjr dr sedpj wgf`g fs fcvlrflmey hfvjc td tgj
wlees. ^fdeejt-ej-Au`'s tgjdrfjs ls td tgj drfhfc dn tgfs
mlttjr
ad cdt pdfct td tgj fcneujc`j dn oltjrfle, lca tgfs njlturj
fs
leejhja my gfo td glvj mjjc fctrdau`ja lt l eltjr stlhj, glvfch
mjjc prdouehltja my l rdyle aj`rjj. Gj fcnjrs tgj `ustdo td glvj
mjjc ajrfvja nrdo tgj Ryrlofas, wgf`g wjrj nduca td
rjolfc ucafsturmja aurfch jlrtgqulkjs, wgfej strlfhgt-sfaja
gdusjs wjrj upsjt, dwfch td tgjfr wlees mjfch odrj jlsfey
dvjr-
turcja. Ft sjjos, gdwjvjr, odrj rjlsdclmej td lttrfmutj ft td
l oua drfhfc, ndr cdtgfch wduea mj odrj clturle, fc drajr td
strjchtgjc su`g mufeafchs, tglc td sefhgtey tfet tgj mucaejs
dn
rjjas tdwlras tgj fctjrfdr, ndrofch ls ft wjrj lc lr`g, l
trjltojct
wgf`g fc lcy dtgjr oltjrfle s`lr`jey sjjos td mj njlsfmej.
Rrd`jjafch td tgj fctjrcle lr`gftj`turle njlturjs dn tgj styej,
l
vjry afstfc`t rjofcfs`jc`j dn tgj prfoftfvj rjjas tfja tdhjtgjr
lt
fctjrvles, lca `rdwcja wftg tgj edtus mua, fs nduca fc tgj
eltjr
hrlcftj `deuoc lca `lpftle (Cd. <2 E, O). Aurfch tgj Qgjmlc
kfchado jspj`fleey (M.@. 0222-0. `. =<22), jxlopejs fc stdcj
dn
`lpftles lca `deuocs ajrfvja nrdo tfomjr lca rjja drfhfcles
lrj
nrjqujct. Lt Mjcf-Glslc sdoj pfeelrs rjprjsjct l mucaej dn
ndur
rjjas dr edtus stleks mduca tdhjtgjr cjlr tgj tdp lca muehfch lmdvj
tgj efhlturj, sd ls td ndro l `lpftle, fc foftltfdc dn l
edtus
mua. Pu`g l pfjr oust jvfajctey glvj mjjc drfhfcleey jopedyja fc
wddajc lr`gftj`turj
dcey, lca tgj rddn wgf`g ft suppdrts, fc
tgfs fcstlc`j, rjprjsjcts l efhgt wddajc `dcstru`tfdc glvfch
tgj
sefhgt sedpj cj`jsslry fc tgj ary Jhyptflc `efoltj.
Qgfs typj dn `deuoc wls elrhjey usja fc eltjr Jhyptflc tfojs
fc l odrj sumstlctfle eftgf` ndro (Cd. <2 O), lca fc `dciuc`tfdc
wftg tgj gdeedw-ndroja `lpftle dn tgj mjee typj (Cd. <2
E), dn
wgf`g tgj jlrefjst jxlopej lppjlrja fc tgj jfhgtjjctg ayclsty. Fc
nl`t, tgrduhgdut, letgduhg oltjrfles `glchja, tgj ndros dn
tgj jlrey rjja lca `ely `dcstru`tfdc wjrj lagjrja td ; lca
tgj
jcajlvdur dn tgj `dcsjrvltfvj Jhyptflc wls td rjprdau`j fc
stdcj
lca hrlcftj, supjrfopdsja fc elyjrs, tgj lppjlrlc`j lssuoja
fc
tgj jlrey rjja lca oua typj.
Qgj surnl`j aj`drltfdc jxj`utja dc tgj eltjr hrlcftj
mufeafchs
(Cd. <2 p), lpplrjctey `loj nrdo tgj
shrlnnftd (fc`fsja pelstjr)
wdrk dc tgj jlrefjr oua wlees. Qgj surnl`js dn su`g wlees `duea
cdt
mj odajeeja dr `lrvja wftg prdij`tfdcs dn gfhg rjefjn, mut tgjfr
nelt
surnl`js, wgjc pelstjrja, prdvfaja lc laofrlmej nfjea ndr
aj`drl-
tfdc lca ndr fcstru`tfdc tgrduhg tgj usj dn gfjrdheypgf`s.
Qgj
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
66/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
67/790
Jhyptflc systjo dn aj`drltfdc `dcsfstja fc cdt `dctrlvjcfch
tgj
ndro ladptja, mut fc `edtgfch ft wftg l kfca dn arlpjry odrj
dr
ejss rf`g, wgf`g cjvjr prjsjctja l prdij`tfch dutefcj, `dctjctfch
ftsjen wftg jcvjedpfch tgj hjdojtrf` ndro ls wduea lc
jomrdfajrja
stunn, dr l aflpjrja `dvjrfch.
]jolrklmej tgjc ls wjrj tgj lrts dn Jhypt, ft fs `ejlr tglt
tgj
spfrft dn `rftf`fso lca edhf`le ojtgda wjrj wlctfch ; lca
tglt
trlaftfdcle ndros, gleedwja my edch usj, wjrj `euch td lca
rjprd-
au`ja wgjc tgj ojtgda dn mufeafch wgf`g suhhjstja tgjo gla
mjjc
rjpel`ja my dtgjr systjos. Jhyptflc lrt prd`jjaja dc lc ucfc-
tjrruptja efcj dr `dursj dn trlaftfdc, lca wgjc cj`jssfty
af`tltja
l `glchj fc tgj ojtgdas dn `dcstru`tfdc, dr fc tgj oltjrfles,
tgj
fooutlmej ndro wls cdt tgjrjmy lnnj`tja, mut wls pjrpjtultja
fc
spftj dn cdvje `dcaftfdcs.
Qgj prfc`fple rjolfcs dn lc`fjct Jhyptflc lr`gftj`turj lrj
tgj
Ryrlofas, dr rdyle tdoms dn tgj kfchs, lca tgj tjopejs, l
`dctrlst fc tgfs rjspj`t wftg Lssyrfl, wgjrj tgj plel`js dn
tgj kfchs lrj tgj `gfjn rjolfcs. Qgj Jhyptflc wlef-plfctfchs,
s`uepturjs, ijwjeejry, mrdczj fopejojcts lca utjcsfes, wgf`g
glvj
mjjc ucjlrtgja nrdo tgjfr tjopejs dr tdoms, sgdw tglt tgj
rl`j
gla lttlfcja td l gfhg ajhrjj fc lrt. Ls rjhlras tgj
lr`gftj`-
turj, tgj foprjssfdc hfvjc td tgj ofca dn tgj spj`tltdr fs
tglt
tgjsj mufeafchs wjrj jrj`tja ndr jtjrcfty, lee tgj rjolfcs glvfch l
`glrl`tjr dn foojcsj sdefafty, lca usuleey dn hrlca ucfndrofty. Qgj
Ryrlofas (Cds. 1 lca :) lrj tgj odst jxtrlvlhlct dn
lee lc`fjct mufeafchs fc olcy wlys. Qgj rjeltfvj rjturc fc
foprjssfvjcjss lca tgj gfhgjr mjlutfjs dn tgj lrt fs solee
wgjc
`doplrja wftg tgj loduct dn elmdur, jxpjcsj, lca oltjrfle
usja
fc tgjfr jrj`tfdc.
Qgj nfcfsgfch lca nfttfch dn su`g elrhj olssjs dn hrlcftj fs
rjolrklmej, ndr
olcy dn tgj med`ks, pjrnj`tey squlrja, pdefsgja
lca nfttja, lrj lt ejlst =2 njjt edch my > njjt wfaj. Qgj
ojtgda
dn qulrryfch lca dn trlcspdrtltfdc ndr edch afstlc`js my elca
lca
wltjr, lca tgj rlfsfch dn tgjsj med`ks dn stdcj fctd pdsftfdc,
fs
jvjc cdw uc`jrtlfc, letgduhg O. @gdfsy fc gfs eltjst wdrk
(sjj
]jnjrjc`j Mddks, plhj 02) gls prdau`ja olcy prdmlmej
tgjdrfjs.
Qgj Lr`gftj`turle @glrl`tjr dn tgj tjopejs fs strfkfch lca
`glrl`tjrfstf` (Cds. :, 8 lca 7). Qgj mufeafchs aj`rjlsj fc
gjfhgt
nrdo nrdct td ml`k, prjsjctfch l afs`dccj`tja `deej`tfdc dn
vlrfdus
sfzja stru`turjs, dntjc mufet lt afnnjrjct tfojs, lca tgus
ndrofch
l
afrj`t `dctrlst td tgj glrodcfdus wgdej dn l Hrjjk tjopej,
wgf`g
fs lee `doprfsja wftgfc dcj drajr dn `deuocs, lca wgf`g
fs
afstfc`tey, mdtg fc lppjlrlc`j lca rjlefty, dcj mufeafch.
Qgj `glrl`tjr dn tgj tdoms `dcsfsts fc tgj pelccfch dn tgjfr
oystjrfdus `glomjrs lca `drrfadrs, wgf`g, `dvjrja wftg plfctfchs
lca gfjrdheypgf`s, prdau`j lc jnnj`t dn heddo lca sdejocfty
dc
tgj spj`tltdr.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
68/790
JHVRQFLC JWLOREJP.
JKclr`t
FO EGOQGSX
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
69/790
0. JWLOREJP.
QGJ PRGFCW
(Cd. 1),
wgdsj altj fs uckcdwc, fs sftultja cjlr tgj hrjlt
pyrlofas, fc tgj `jctrj dn lc lc`fjct stdcj qulrry, lca fs l
clturle rd`k `ut td rjsjomej l Ppgfcx, wftg rduhg olsdcry laaja fc
plrts. Lc Jhyptflc Ppgfcx (Cd. <2 d) gla tgj gjla dn l kfch, l
glwk, l rlo, dr odrj rlrjey l wdolc, dc tgj mday dn l efdc.
Qgj afojcsfdcs dn tgj Hrjlt Ppgfcx, wgf`g rjprjsjcts l rj`uo-
mjct efdc wftg tgj gjla dn l olc, lrj ls ndeedws 9 ft fs >:
njjt
gfhg my <77 njjt edch, tgj nl`j fs <0 njjt > fc`gjs wfaj,
lca
tgj odutg 7 njjt > fc`gjs edch. Hrjltey outfeltja, ft fs stfee
l
olrvje, ls ft gls mjjc tgrduhgdut tgj lhjs. Qgj syomde
ndr lc
fcsdeumej prdmejo, ft fs, lca prdmlmey jvjr wfee mj, l oystjry. Ft
wls jx`lvltja fc <7<> my @lptlfc @lvfhefl, wgd nduca
l
tjopej mjtwjjc tgj plws, lca ft gls sfc`j mjjc jxlofcja my Olrfjttj
lca Olspjrd.
QGJ RV]LOFAP
dn Hfzjg, cjlr @lfrd, lee jrj`tja aurfch tgj ndurtg ayclsty
(M.@. 0667-M.`. 08=<), ndro dcj dn sjvjrle hrdups wftgfc
tgj
cj`rdpdefs dn
tgj lc`fjct `lpftle `fty dn Ojopgfs, lca rlck lodch tgj deajst
odcuojcts dn Jhyptflc lr`gftj`turj. Qgj dtgjr hrdups lrj tgdsj dn
Lmu-]dlsg, Ylwfyjt-je-Lrylc, Lmusfr,
Plkklrl, lca Alsgur.
Qgjsj wjrj mufet my tgj kfchs ls tgjfr nuturj tdoms, tgj
hdvjrcfch fajl mjfch td sj`urj foodrtlefty my tgj prjsjrvltfdc dn
tgj ouooy, tfee tglt tfoj sgduea glvj plssja, wgjc, l``drafch td
tgjfr mjefjn, tgj sdue wduea dc`j odrj rjturc td tgj mday. Qgjfr
`dcstru`tfdc gls mjjc ajs`rfmja my olcy wrftjrs, fc`euafch
Gjrdadtus.
Qgj Hrjlt Ryrlofa (Cds. 1 lca : `, A), my @gjdps (Kgunu)
(M.@. 0800-M.`. 0822) ; tgj Pj`dca Ryrlofa (Cd. 1), my
@jpgrdc (Kglnrl) (M.@. 0>>>->. `. 0>00) ; tgj Qgfra
Ryrlofa
my Oy`jrfcds (Ojckglrl) (M.@. 0>00->.`. 0>22), lrj tgj
mjst
kcdwc jxlopejs. Qgj Hrjlt Ryrlofa dn @gjdps fs squlrj dc pelc,
8>2 njjt
jl`g wly, fts lrjl mjfch lmdut <0 l`rjs, f.j., twf`j tgj
jxtjct
dn P. Rjtjr, ]doj, dr jqule td tgj sfzj dn Efc`dec's Fcc
Nfjeas,
Edcadc. Qgj nl`js dn tgj
pyrlofa lrj
jqufeltjrle trflchejs
elfa
sedpfch lca ojjtfch fc l pdfct. Qgj sfajs nl`j afrj`tey
cdrtg,
sdutg, jlst lca wjst, ls fc lee tgj pyrlofas, lca tgjy olkj
lc
lchej wftg tgj hrduca dn :< ajhrjjs :2 ofcutjs. Qgj drfhfcle
gjfhgt
wls 17= njjt. Qgj jctrlc`j (Cd. : `), wgf`g fs dc tgj
cdrtgjrc
sfaj, fs 18 njjt > fc`gjs lmdvj tgj mlsj, lca fs cdw rjl`gja my
ojlcs dn lc jlrtgjc jomlckojct. Qgj plsslhj td wgf`g ft
N.L. `
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
70/790
hfvjs l``jss nfrst sedpjs adwcwlras, lca lntjrwlras
rj-ls`jcas
tdwlras tgj gjlrt dn tgj pyrlofa, wgjrj tgj Kfch's @glomjr fs
sftultja. Fc tgfs `glomjr, wgf`g fs 01 njjt > fc`gjs my <8
njjt
lca <6 njjt gfhg, wls pel`ja tgj slr`dpglhus dn tgj kfch
`dctlfc-
fch gfs jomleoja mday. Qgj uppjr plrt fs jelmdrltjey `dc-
stru`tja wftg stdcjs dcj lmdvj tgj dtgjr (Cd. : A), lca tgj
jctrlc`j fs prdtj`tja my l olssfvj stdcj l`tfch ls l
pdrt`ueefs,
nfttfch fctd l rjmltj dr rj`jss, lca wjfhgfch nrdo :2 td >2
tdcs.
Qwd lfr `glccjes, jl`g lmdut 7 fc`gjs my > fc`gjs, eja td tgj
~4
dutjr nl`j dn tgj pyrlofa ndr vjctfeltfdc.
Qgjrj wjrj twd dtgjr `glomjrs fc tgj Hrjlt Ryrlofa, dcj kcdwc
ls tgj \ujjc's @glomjr, `dccj`tja wftg l plsslhj ejlafch dnn
tglt
td tgj Kfch's @glomjr, lca tgj dtgjr mjedw tgj hrduca.
Qgj jxtjrfdr dn tgfs pyrlofa wls drfhfcleey `lsja wftg l
sedpfch nl`j dn efojstdcj, mut tgfs gls cdw
afslppjlrja,'sgdwfch
tgj drfhfcle stjppja surnl`j fc tfjrs dn 1 njjt, dc wgf`g tgj
`lsfch
wls pel`ja, lca wgf`g stfee jxfsts fc tgj Ryrlofa dn
Oy`jrfcds.
QDOMP.
Mjsfajs tgj Ryrlofas dr rdyle tdoms lrj dtgjrs ndr prfvltj
fcafvfaules.
(l.) Fc tgj Lc`fjct Jopfrj tgj Olstlmls, prdmlmey ajrfvja
nrdo ruaj gjlps dn stdcjs pfeja up dvjr jlrefjr ouooy gdejs,
wjrj rj`tlchuelr stru`turjs, wftg sfajs sedpfch lt lc lchej
dn
8: ajhrjjs, lca glvfch nelt rddns. Qgjy wjrj afvfaja fctd
tgrjj
plrts 9
f. Qgj dutjr `glomjr, fc wgf`g wjrj pel`ja tgj dnnjrfchs td
tgj Kl dr
rjprjsjctltfdcs dn njstle lca dtgjr s`jcjs, wgf`g lrj
vleulmej nrdo lc gfstdrf`le stlcapdfct.
ff. Fccjr sj`rjt `glomjrs, kcdwc ls tgj sjralms, `dctlfcfch
stltujs dn tgj aj`jlsja, lca ojomjrs dn gfs nlofey.
fff. L wjee dn hrjlt ajptg, ejlafch td tgj `glomjr `dctlfcfch tgj
slr`dpglhus wftg fts ouooy.
Qgj Olstlml dn Qgy, Plkklrl, fs wjee prjsjrvja lca gls
mjjc rjstdrja. Ft altjs nrdo tgj nfntg ayclsty, lca wls
jrj`tja
td Qgy, wgd fc gfs aly gjea tgj pdsftfdc dn rdyle lr`gftj`t
lca
olclhjr dn pyrlofas. Ft `dcsfsts dn l solee vjstfmuej, mjydca wgf`g
fs l elrhj `durt wgjrj dnnjrfchs td tgj aj`jlsja tddk pel`j,
lca nrdo wgf`g l ouooy sglnt eja tgrduhg l plsslhj td l tdom
`glomjr. Qgj olsdcry dn tgfs tdom fs `lrjnueey idfctja lca
`dvjrja wftg nelt rjefjns, wgf`g lrj hjcjrleey `dcsfajrja tgj
mjst
spj`fojcs dn tgjfr kfca. Qgj prfc`fple rjefjns lrj fc l
sj`dca
tdom `glomjr, == njjt 6 fc`gjs my =0 njjt 6 fc`gjs lca <=
njjt
> fc`gjs gfhg. Qgjsj rjefjns rjprjsjct glrvjst dpjrltfdcs,
sgfp-
mufeafch s`jcjs, s`jcjs rjprjsjctfch tgj lrts lca `rlnts dn
tgj
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
71/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
72/790
=2 @DORL]LQF^J L]@GFQJ@QZ]J.
pjrfda, tgj seluhgtjrfch dn sl`rfnf`fle lcfoles, lca Qgy
gfosjen
slfefch tgrduhg tgj olrsgjs fc l mdlt wftg l surrducafch
plpyrus
tgf`kjt.
Jopfrj tdoms Uvjrj jftgjr dn tgj
Ryrlofale ndro, ls lt Lmyads, dr wjrj rd`k-`ut, ls fc tgj vjrtf`le
`efnns
mducafch tgj Cfej vleejy (Cd. >).
Qgj Qdoms lt Mjcf-Glslc,fc Zppjr Jhypt, ndro l rjolrk-
lmej hrdup dn tgjsj rd`k-`ut jxlopejs. Qgjrj lrj 06 fc lee,
lrrlchja fc l rdw fc tgj rd`ks ls sgdwc (Cd. >). Qgjy wjrj
olaj aurfch tgj twjentg ayclsty (M.@. =887-S:>:), l pjrfda
wgf`g
wls plrtf`uelrey rjolrklmej ndr tgj prdhrjss dn tgj lrts dn
pjl`j.
Qgj jctrlc`j td tgj Qdom dn Kgcjogdtjp, kcdwc ls Qdom Cd. 0,
gls twd sfxtjjc-sfaja `deuocs, sdojtfojs `dcsfajrja td mj l
prdtdtypj dn tgj Hrjjk Adrf` drajr. Qgjsj lrj sefhgtey neutja
lca glvj lc jctlsfs, lca tgj ajjpey prdij`tfch `drcf`j gls
stdcj
mjlos `lrvja dut dn tgj sdefa rd`k, fcaf`ltfch l ajrfvltfdc nrdo
l
wddajc drfhfc.
(`.) Aurfch tgj Cjw Jopfrj.tdoms wjrj rd`k-`ut lca
stru`turle,
lca fc olcy `lsjs l``doplcfja my sjpue`grle tjopejs.
Qgjmjs, wgf`g ndr l tfoj wls tgj cj`rdpdefs dn tgj Jhyptflc
kfchs, gls l elrhj cuomjr dn tdoms altfch odstey nrdo tgj Cjw
Jopfrj, lca ndrofch l `dctrlst td tgj pyrlofas wgf`g ndroja
tgj hrlvjs dn tgj jlrefjr kfchs. Qgjsj tdoms `dcsfst dn l
sjrfjs
dn `glomjrs `dccj`tja wftg plsslhjs gjwc fc tgj rd`k, lca
wjrj
fctjcaja dcey ndr tgj rj`jptfdc dn tgj slr`dpglhf. Lodchst
tgj
odst fopdrtlct dn tgjsj lrj tgdsj dn ]lojsjs FFF., F^., lca
FW.,
lca tglt dn Pjtgds E, usuleey kcdwc ls Mjezdcf's tdom nrdo
fts
afs`dvjrjr fc <7<8. Qgj stru`turj dn lee fs vjry sfofelr,
`dcsfst-
fch dn tgrjj `drrfadrs `ut fc tgj rd`k ejlafch fctd lc
lctj-rddo,
mjydca wgf`g fs tgj sjpue`grle `glomjr, wgjrj tgj hrlcftj
slr`dpglhus wls pel`ja fc l gdeedw fc tgj neddr. Qgj wlees,
nrdo tgj jctrlc`j td tgj slr`dpglhus `glomjr, wjrj s`uepturja
wftg gfjrdheypgf`s dn pf`turjs lca tjxts cj`jsslry td tgj
aj`jlsja
fc tgj nuturj efnj, lca odstey rjprjsjctfch gfo slfefch tgrduhg
tgj
ucajr-wdrea l``doplcfja my tgj suc hda. Qgj tjxts wjrj odstey tlkjc
nrdo vlrfdus mddks rjeltfch td tgj `jrjodcfjs wgf`g wjrj
jssjctfle ndr fcsurfch tgj foodrtlefty dn tgj ajplrtja.
Qgj odrtulry dr sjpue`grle tjopejs, su`g ls tgdsj dn Ajr-je-
mlgrf, Ojafcjt-Glmdu, tgj ]lojssjuo, lca dtgjrs, wjrj
utfefzja
ndr dnnjrfchs lca dtgjr nucjrjle rfhgts ndr tgj ajla.
QJOREJP.
Qgj purpdsjs ndr wgf`g tgjy wjrj usja lca tgjfr `dopdcjct
plrts lrj fopdrtlct. Qgjy wjrj slc`tulrfjs wgjrj dcey tgj kfch lca
prfjsts pjcjtrltja, lca fc wgf`g oystjrfjs lca prd`jssfdcs
ndroja l hrjlt plrt dn tgj rjefhfdus sjrvf`js. Qgjy afnnjr,
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
73/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
74/790
== @DORL]LQF^J L]@GFQJ@QZ]J.
tgjrjndrj, nrdo tgj Hrjjk tjopej, tgj @grfstflc `gur`g, lca
tgj
Olgdojtlc odsquj, ndr tgjy wjrj cdt pel`js ndr tgj ojjtfch dn
tgj nlftgnue dr tgj rj`ftle dn `doodc prlyjrs, lca cd pumef`
rftule
wls `jejmrltja wftgfc tgjo. Qgj prfjsts lca kfch dcey wjrj laofttja
mjydca tgj gypdstyej glee, lca tgj tjopej, tgjrjndrj,
wls l kfca dn rdyle drltdry rjlrja my tgj kfch fc tdkjc dn gfs
dwc
pfjty lca fc drajr td pur`glsj tgj nlvdur dn tgj hdas.
Qgj stuajct fs rjnjrrja td Ed`kyjr's tgjdrfjs ls td tgj
drfjctl-
tfdc dn tjopejs wftg rjhlra td tgj plrtf`uelr stlrs.
Qgj oloojfsf wjrj tjopejs (ajaf`ltja td tgj
oystjrfdus
l``du`gjojct dn F sfs)
jl`g `dcsfstfch dn dcj solee `glomjr wftg
stltuj lca letlr ls lt Jejpglctfcj, lpprdl`gja my l nefhgt dn
stjps.
Fc tgfs ndro tgjy lrj hjcjrleey `dcsfajrja td mj tgj prdtdtypjs dn
tgj Hrjjk tjopejs. Qgj odrj usule typj dn tjopej, Gdwjvjr,
`dcsfstja dn `glomjrs ndr tgj prfjsts, wftg `durts,
`dedcclajs,
lca glees, lee surrducaja my l gfhg wlee.
Fc drajr tglt tgj stuajct oly ucajrstlca tgj hjcjrle
afstrfmu-
tfdc dn tgj plrts dn lc Jhyptflc tjopej, l pelc fs gjrj hfvjc
dn
tgj Qjopej dn Kgdcs, cjlr tgj Hrjlt Qjopej dn Loodc, lt
Klrcl` (Cd. :), dc tgj jlstjrc mlck dn tgj Cfej, wgf`g oly mj
tlkjc ls l nlfr jxlopej dn tgj drafclry typj dn pelc.
Qgj jctrlc`j td tgj
tjopej wls mjtwjjc pyedcs, dr olssfvj /
(
nrdct dn tgj jctrlc`j wjrj pel`ja dmjefsks, lca fc nrdct dn ,
tgjsj lc lvjcuj dn spgfcxjs, ndrofch l spejcafa lpprdl`g td '
tgj tjopej. Qgfs jctrlc`j hlvj l``jss td tgj elrhj dutjr
`durt-
ylra, wgf`g wls dpjc td tgj sky fc tgj `jctrj, lca tgjrjndrj
F
`leeja gypljtgrle (nrdo twd Hrjjk wdras, ojlcfch
ucajr
tgj lfr ).
Qgfs `durtylra wls surrducaja my l adumej `dedcclaj
dc tgrjj sfajs, lca eja up td tgj gypdstyej glee, fc wgf`g
efhgt
wls laofttja my
ndroja my
tgj
afnnjrjct gjfhgt dn tgj `deuocs (Cd. : M). Mjydca tgfs fs tgj
slc`tulry, surrducaja my l plsslhj, lca lt tgj rjlr fs l
soleejr
glee ; mdtg tgj elst `glomjrs oust glvj mjjc alrk dr dcey
fopjrnj`tey efhgtja.
Qgj wgdej `deej`tfdc dn mufeafchs ndrofch tgj tjopej wls surrducaja
my l hrjlt wlee ls gfhg ls tgj mufeafchs tgjosjevjs.
Qgjmjs, tgj sftj dn w'gf`g d``upfja l elrhj lrjl dc tgj jlst
lca wjst mlcks dn tgj Cfej, wls tgj `lpftle dn Jhypt aurfch
tgj
Cjw Jopfrj (Ayclstfjs
W^FF. -WW.).
fopdrtlct hrdup dn Qjopejs lt Klrcl`, fc`euafch tgj Hrjlt
Qjopej dn Loodc, lca tgj Qjopej dn Kgdcs (twjctfjtg ayclsty). Lt
Euxdr, lesd dc tgj jlstjrc mlck, wls lcdtgjr Qjopej dn
Loodc (jfhgtjjctg lca cfcjtjjctg ayclstfjs). Dc tgj wjstjrc
mlck ely tgj Cj`rdpdefs dr Qdoms dn tgj Kfchs lca \ujjcs, lca
l elrhj cuomjr dn odrtulry tjopejs, wgf`g fc`euaja tgdsj dn
Ajr-je-mlgrf, tgj ]lojssjuo, lca Ojafcjt Glmdu.
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
75/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
76/790
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
77/790
JHVRQFLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J. =:
Jhyptflc lr`gftj`turj, lca wls jctfrjey jx`lvltja dut dn tgj
sdefa rd`k. Ft gls l ndrj-`durt, lt tgj ml`k dn wgf`g fs tgj
fopdsfch nl`laj, <<6 njjt wfaj lca dvjr <22 njjt gfhg,
ndroja ls
l
pyedc,
ndur sjltja `dedssf dn ]lojsjs FF., jl`g dvjr
>: njjt fc gjfhgt. Qgj jctrlc`j ejlas td l vjstfmuej, tgj
`jfefch dn wgf`g fs suppdrtja my jfhgt pfeelrs, tgj wlees glvfch
vfvfaey `dedrja rjefjns. Jfhgt soleejr `glomjrs, prdmlmey usja td
stdrj
tgj tjopej utjcsfes lca nurcfturj, laidfc tgfs vjstfmuej, lca
fc
tgj rjlr fs l solee gypdstyej glee, 0> njjt my =: njjt, glvfch
ndur
pfeelrs. Mjgfca tgfs fs l edch clrrdw `glomjr dut dn wgf`g
lrj
tgrjj lplrtojcts, tgj `jctrj lca elrhjst dcj mjfch tgj slc`tulry,
wftg lc letlr lca ndur sjltja nfhurjs dn tgj ajftfjs wdrsgfppja.
Qgj Qjopej dn Fsfs, Fselca dn Rgfesj, fs lc fctjrjstfch
jxlopej dn tgj Rtdejolf` pjrfda, lca, efkj jlrefjr jxlopejs,
wls
tgj wdrk dn sjvjrle hjcjrltfdcs. Qgj ndrj-`durt, jctjrja tgrduhg l
olssfvj pyedc, <:2 njjt mrdla lca >2 njjt gfhg, gls dc tgj
wjst
sfaj tgj Mfrtg Gdusj, l solee `dedcclaja tjopej ajaf`ltja td
Gltgdr-Fsfs lca td tgj ojodry dn tgj mfrtg dn gjr sdc Gdrus, lca dc
tgj jlst l `dedcclaja mufeafch usja my tgj prfjsts. Dc tgj ndurtg
sfaj dn tgj `durt fs tgj sj`dca pyedc, wgf`g fs <2: njjt
mrdla lca 12 njjt gfhg. Mjydca fs tgj tjopej prdpjr, `dcsfstfch dn
`durts, l gypdstyej glee wftg jfhgt `deuocs, twd solee vjstf-
muejs, l slc`tulry, lca dtgjr laidfcfch `glomjrs, lee cjlrey
fc
tdtle alrkcjss. Qgfs hrdup, fc`euafch tgj sj`dca pyedc, gls
fts
lxfs lt lc lchej td tglt dn tgj nfrst pyedc lca `durtylra. Qgj
jctfrj stru`turj gls tgj wlees, mdtg fcsfaj lca dut, `dvjrja
wftg
fcs`rfptfdcs.
Qgj Qjopej dn Gltgdr, Ajcajrl (L.A. nfrst `jctury), fs
lcdtgjr Rtdejolf` jxlopej, mut wls cdt `dopejtja tfee tgj rjfhc dn
Luhustus. Ft gls cd pyedcs, ndrj-`durt, dr jc`edsfch dutjr
wlees, mut gls l hrjlt vjstfmuej wftg twjcty-ndur `deuocs, sfx
dn
wgf`g ndro tgj nl6laj, glvfch edw s`rjjc wlees mjtwjjc tgjo dc
jftgjr sfaj dn tgj `jctrle jctrlc`j. Mjgfca tgfs fs tgj
gypdstyej
glee, glvfch sfx `deuocs wftg jelmdrltj Gltgdr-gjlaja
`lpftles.
Dc jl`g sfaj dn tgfs glee lca mjydca lrj `glomjrs, usja ls
elvltdry, trjlsury, stdrj-rddos ; lca mjgfca lrj twd
lctj-`glomjrs
wftg l slc`tulry mjydca. Ptlfr`lsjs dc jftgjr sfaj ejla td
tgj
rddn dn tgj tjopej.
Aurfch tgj Hrlj`d-]dolc pjrfda olcy tjopejs wjrj jrj`tja,
dn wgf`g tgj Qjopej dn Jandu, `doojc`ja my Rtdejoy FFF.
(M.@. =08), fs tgj mjst prjsjrvja jxlopej. L olssfvj pyedc,
nl`ja wftg rjefjns lca fcs`rfptfdcs, hlvj l``jss td l hrjlt
`durt,
surrducaja my l `dedcclaj. Qgj ml`k dn tgfs `durt wls ndroja
my tgj nrdct dn tgj hrjlt gypdstyej glee, tgj pdrtle dn wgf`g
wls tgj `jctrj fctjr`deuocfltfdc dn l rdw dn sfx `deuocs, tgj
clrrdwjr spl`js mjtwjjc tgj sfaj `deuocs glvfch edw s`rjjc
wlees
(Cd. 7). Qwjevj elrhjr `deuocs wftg jelmdrltj `lpftles
suppdrt
8/15/2019 History of Arhitecture Comparative Method
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
78/790
p f-G
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
79/790
JHVRQFLC L]@GFQJ@QZ]J. =8
tgj rddn dvjr tgfs glee, mjydca wgf`g wls l soleejr gypdstyej glee,
tgj rddn dn wgf`g wls `lrrfja my twjevj `deuocs, glvfch rf`g nedrle
`lpftles, jomjeefsgja my sd-`leeja gjlas dn Gltgdr.
Mjgfca tgfs wjrj vjstfmuejs,
lrj odcuojctle pfeelrs, drfhfcleey jopedyja fc plfrs mjndrj
tgj
prfc`fple jctrlc`js dn tjopejs. Qgjy lrj odcdeftgs, f.j.,
sfchej
uprfhgt stdcjs, squlrj dc pelc wftg sefhgtey rducaja nl`js,
lca
tlpjrfch sfajs, wftg l pyrlofale suooft. Qgj gjfhgt fs usuleey
lmdut cfcj td tjc tfojs ls hrjlt ls tgj aflojtjr, lca tgj
ndur
nl`js wjrj `ut wftg gfjrdheypgf`s. Qgj `lppfch wls dn ojtle,
ndr tgj hrddvj fctd wgf`g ft wls nfttja fs fc sdoj `lsjs
stfee
vfsfmej. Qgj qulrryfch lca trlcspdrt dn su`g l olss dn stdcj
wftgdut tgj pdwjr dn l stjlo-jchfcj wls lc jchfcjjrfch njlt
dn
`dcsfajrlmej skfee.
Olcy dmjefsks wjrj rjodvja nrdo Jhypt my tgj ]dolc
jopjrdrs, lca lt ejlst twjevj lrj fc ]doj ftsjen. Qglt fc tgj
`jctrj dn tgj Rflzzl dn P. Idgc Eltjrlc fs tgj elrhjst fc
jxfstjc`j.
Ft fs dn rja hrlcftj nrdo Pyjcj, lca fs <21 njjt gfhg, dr
wftg
tgj pjajstle <:0 njjt, 6 njjt squlrj lt tgj mlsj, > njjt =
fc`gjs
lt tgj tdp, lca letdhjtgjr wjfhgs lmdut >22 tdcs.
@ejdpltrl's Cjjaej dc tgj Qglojs Jomlckojct, lcdtgjr
jxlopej, mrduhgt td Edcadc nrdo Lejxlcarfl, letgduhg drfhfcleey
jrj`tja lt Gjefdpdefs (M.@. <:22), fs >7 njjt > fc`gjs
gfhg, 7 njjt
squlrj lt tgj mlsj, lca wjfhgs <72 tdcs.
AXJEEFCHP.
Lee tgjsj glvj afslppjlrja, mjfch dcey mufet dn wdda dr dn
suc-arfja mrf`ks. Gdusjs lrj sgdwc dc plfctfchs lca s`uepturjs
wgf`g glvj `doj adwc td us, nrdo wgf`g tgjy lppjlr td glvj
gla dcj, twd, dr tgrjj stdrfjs.
Fc tgj lmsjc`j dn lcy lutgjctf` rjolfcs, lc feeustrltfdc dn
tgj
Jhyptflc Gdusj fs hfvjc (Cd. 6), `dcij`turleey rjstdrja, lca
jrj`tja lt tgj Rlrfs Jxgfmftfdc, <776, my O. @glrejs
Hlofjr.
Qgj ajsfhc wls nducaja dc lc lc`fjct plfctfch, lca gla l hlrajc fc
nrdct, elfa dut fc l ndrole styej, wftg nfsg-pdcas. Qgj gdusj wls
afvfaja my l `drrfadr fc tgj `jctrj, hfvfch l``jss td tgj
rddos. Qgj stlfr`lsj lt tgj ml`k eja td l vjrlcalg, lca lesd
td
l nelt rddn, jxtjcafch dvjr tgj wgdej ejchtg dn tgj
stru`turj.
Qgj wgdej mufeafch wls trjltja wftg `dedr, tgj uppjr plrt dn
tgj gdusj mjfch plfctja l mrfhgt yjeedw, lca tgj edch
jxtjrcle
wddajc `deuocs meuj.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/history-of-arhitecture-comparative-method
80/790
1. @DORL]LQF^J.
wftg Hrjjk jxlopejs (plhjs <:
lca ls lerjlay cdtf`ja
tgjy wjrj jspj`fleey pelccja ndr fctjrcle jnnj`t. Qgj
gypdstyej
glee sjjofchey ucefoftja fc sfzj, `rdwaja wftg pfeelrs, lca
oystjrfdusey feeuofcltja nrdo lmdvj, rjlefzja tgj hrlcajst
`dc-
`jptfdcs dn Jhyptflc pelccfch (Cd. :). Jxtjrcleey tgj olssfvj
pyedcs drclojctja wftg fc`fsja aj`drltfdcs ndroja tgj `gfjn
nl`laj, l `