1
down-regulatory opiate alkaloids (e.g., morphine). Usually, relaxation is a result of the systemic down-regulation that occurs after stress response pathways get shut-down, following their initial induction. As pain occurs in the primary phase of this process, it gets an inhibitory push-back under the influence of endorphins and other analgetic endogenous signaling molecules in this still early, i.e., stress response-associated stage. The rationale of this phase would be that the ‘stressed’ organism chiefly fights against the stressor and then, subse- quently, cares about the possible wounds and traumas acquired. These secondary processes include endogenous morphine signaling, allowing the pain to come back again, yet in an altered and more ‘distant’ way, enabling the organism to face it and decide upon necessary actions for recovery and learning. This secondary phase also reduces over-stimulation, e.g., of the immune system, involving anti-inflammation. Hence, down-regulation serves recovery, i.e., systemic back- up. Stress induction and subsequent termination follow each other automatically and naturally, i.e., ideally, therefore activating, among others, endogenous limbic reward and motivation circuitries. However, little is known about the interplay between pain perception and its relationship with catecholamine molecules other than dopamine serving as an endogenous morphine precursor. We believe that the percep- tion of pain and the body’s self-attempt to alleviate it, utilizing conventional homeostatic mechanisms, is mediated by key catecholamines, and that this effect is further modulated by nitric oxide. We further propose a paradigm which biologically links pain, autoregulation, endogenous morphine and the catecholamines together, demonstrating a complex symbiotic signalling system. Integrative, complementary and mind–body medicine would, by their nature, include this paradigm in their underlying concepts and therapeutic strategies. Keywords: Stress; Trauma; Autoregulation; Limbic system; Motivation; Morphine; Endorphins; Catecholamines; Nitric oxide 10.1016/j.eujim.2009.08.029 PO-027 How do patients choose acupuncturists? A mixed methods project F. Bishop, Y. Massey, G. Lewith University of Southampton, School of Medicine, South- ampton, United Kingdom Question: Government policy is to develop statutory regulation of complementary medicine practitioners in the UK. Acupuncturists are not yet subject to statutory regulation and hence potential patients face difficult decisions. A qualitative study explored patients’ experi- ences. A quantitative vignette study investigated the impact of 3 practitioner-factors (gender, training location, quali- fications) and 1 patient-factor (gender). Methods: Qualitative study: 35 acupuncture patients were recruited from 7 clinics and the community (maximum variation sampling). Semi-structured interviews about their experiences of acupuncture were recorded, transcribed, and analysed using thematic analysis. Quantitative study: 83 participants imagined wanting to consult an acupuncturist for persistent back pain. They rated 8 fictional acupuncturists. Results: Acupuncture patients were concerned to find trustworthy acupuncturists and valued personal recom- mendations from trusted others. In the absence of such recommendations potential patients preferred female acu- puncturists (F(1,76) ¼ 30.63, po.01) with medical qualifi- cations (F(1,76) ¼ 125.72, po.01), who trained in China (F(1,76) ¼ 8.53), po.01). Conclusions: People are concerned about the trustworthi- ness and authenticity of acupuncturists. (Potential) patients need to be clearly informed about statutory regulation and its implications, and GPs could better support their patients in choosing complementary medicine practi- tioners. 10.1016/j.eujim.2009.08.030 PO-028 Application and subjective benefit of Crataegus extracts in patients with incipient heart failure with regard to perfor- mance and quality of life—A qualitative study P.W. Guendling, E. Mesenholl-Strehler Hochschule Fresenius, Lehrstuhl fu¨r Naturheilkunde und komplementa¨re Medizin, Idstein, Germany Background: Heart failure is one of the most common and most expensive chronic diseases in western industrial countries. And it is increasing because of the demographic development. While the effect of standardized Crataegus extracts for heart failure NYHA I-II is well proven [1], these results do not allow detailed conclusions about how the use of Crataegus extract influences quality of life and everyday life of patients with heart failure in an early state and how its personal benefit is estimated from a patient’s point of view [2] . Methods: Descriptive interview study with 3 groups of patients with heart failure in an early stage and with vs. without intake of a standardized Crataegus extract for at least 90 days. In total 40 patients were randomised from a patients’ file of a general practitioner and in order to maximize the variance of the probability distribution another 20 patients with the same requirements were acquired by advertisement. The severity of heart failure was estimated by screenings (history, Goldman’s Specific Activity Scale and NYHA criteria), pattern of utilisation and concepts of usefulness were collected by a semi-structured interview guide. Additionally the general and heart specific quality of life was evaluated by SF-36 and Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionaire (KCCQ) and the comorbid depression by PHQ-D. ARTICLE IN PRESS Abstracts / European Journal of Integrative Medicine 1 (2009) 223–260 238

How do patients choose acupuncturists? A mixed methods project

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: How do patients choose acupuncturists? A mixed methods project

ARTICLE IN PRESSAbstracts / European Journal of Integrative Medicine 1 (2009) 223–260238

down-regulatory opiate alkaloids (e.g., morphine). Usually,relaxation is a result of the systemic down-regulation thatoccurs after stress response pathways get shut-down, followingtheir initial induction. As pain occurs in the primary phase ofthis process, it gets an inhibitory push-back under the influenceof endorphins and other analgetic endogenous signalingmolecules in this still early, i.e., stress response-associatedstage. The rationale of this phase would be that the ‘stressed’organism chiefly fights against the stressor and then, subse-quently, cares about the possible wounds and traumasacquired. These secondary processes include endogenousmorphine signaling, allowing the pain to come back again,yet in an altered and more ‘distant’ way, enabling the organismto face it and decide upon necessary actions for recovery andlearning. This secondary phase also reduces over-stimulation,e.g., of the immune system, involving anti-inflammation.Hence, down-regulation serves recovery, i.e., systemic back-up. Stress induction and subsequent termination follow eachother automatically and naturally, i.e., ideally, thereforeactivating, among others, endogenous limbic reward andmotivation circuitries. However, little is known about theinterplay between pain perception and its relationship withcatecholamine molecules other than dopamine serving as anendogenous morphine precursor. We believe that the percep-tion of pain and the body’s self-attempt to alleviate it, utilizingconventional homeostatic mechanisms, is mediated by keycatecholamines, and that this effect is further modulated bynitric oxide. We further propose a paradigm which biologicallylinks pain, autoregulation, endogenous morphine and thecatecholamines together, demonstrating a complex symbioticsignalling system. Integrative, complementary and mind–bodymedicine would, by their nature, include this paradigm in theirunderlying concepts and therapeutic strategies.Keywords: Stress; Trauma; Autoregulation; Limbic system; Motivation;

Morphine; Endorphins; Catecholamines; Nitric oxide

10.1016/j.eujim.2009.08.029

PO-027

How do patients choose acupuncturists? A mixed methods

project

F. Bishop, Y. Massey, G. Lewith

University of Southampton, School of Medicine, South-

ampton, United Kingdom

Question: Government policy is to develop statutoryregulation of complementary medicine practitioners inthe UK. Acupuncturists are not yet subject to statutoryregulation and hence potential patients face difficultdecisions. A qualitative study explored patients’ experi-ences. A quantitative vignette study investigated the impactof 3 practitioner-factors (gender, training location, quali-fications) and 1 patient-factor (gender).

Methods: Qualitative study: 35 acupuncture patients wererecruited from 7 clinics and the community (maximum

variation sampling). Semi-structured interviews about theirexperiences of acupuncture were recorded, transcribed, andanalysed using thematic analysis.Quantitative study: 83 participants imagined wanting toconsult an acupuncturist for persistent back pain. Theyrated 8 fictional acupuncturists.

Results: Acupuncture patients were concerned to findtrustworthy acupuncturists and valued personal recom-mendations from trusted others. In the absence of suchrecommendations potential patients preferred female acu-puncturists (F(1,76) ¼ 30.63, po.01) with medical qualifi-cations (F(1,76) ¼ 125.72, po.01), who trained in China(F(1,76) ¼ 8.53), po.01).

Conclusions: People are concerned about the trustworthi-ness and authenticity of acupuncturists. (Potential) patientsneed to be clearly informed about statutory regulation andits implications, and GPs could better support theirpatients in choosing complementary medicine practi-tioners.

10.1016/j.eujim.2009.08.030

PO-028

Application and subjective benefit of Crataegus extracts in

patients with incipient heart failure with regard to perfor-

mance and quality of life—A qualitative study

P.W. Guendling, E. Mesenholl-Strehler

Hochschule Fresenius, Lehrstuhl fur Naturheilkunde und

komplementare Medizin, Idstein, Germany

Background: Heart failure is one of the most common andmost expensive chronic diseases in western industrial countries.And it is increasing because of the demographic development.While the effect of standardized Crataegus extracts for heartfailure NYHA I-II is well proven [1], these results do not allowdetailed conclusions about how the use of Crataegus extractinfluences quality of life and everyday life of patients with heartfailure in an early state and how its personal benefit isestimated from a patient’s point of view [2].

Methods: Descriptive interview study with 3 groups of patientswith heart failure in an early stage and with vs. without intakeof a standardized Crataegus extract for at least 90 days. Intotal 40 patients were randomised from a patients’ file of ageneral practitioner and in order to maximize the variance ofthe probability distribution another 20 patients with the samerequirements were acquired by advertisement. The severity ofheart failure was estimated by screenings (history, Goldman’sSpecific Activity Scale and NYHA criteria), pattern ofutilisation and concepts of usefulness were collected by asemi-structured interview guide. Additionally the general andheart specific quality of life was evaluated by SF-36 andKansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionaire (KCCQ) and thecomorbid depression by PHQ-D.