9
HOW TO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCO chief design engineer: When you're buying a variable wavelength LC detector, you'll have to sort through a lot of specifications and promises to find the right one. Here is some information I think will help you make your decision. Performance. Baseline noise is a better indication of the detector's sensitivity than the minimum absorbance range available. You can expect a good detector to have a dry cell, peak-to-peak noise of no more than 3 x 10-5 A with a 0.5 second rise time, at all wavelengths from 200 to 300 nm. Noise should be less if measured at a longer response time or only in the 240 nm region. Remember, noise specified + looks twice as good as peak-to-peak. Most detectors use a low-cost passive (resistor- capacitor) filter which reduces noise but also reduces response speed and distorts peak shape. Better detectors have active fil- ters, but they're not all the same - one highly-reputed instrument has an active filter with bad __ overshoot which is covered up by automatic baseline correction. Make sure that the bandwidth is narrow enough to give good ISCO's fourth generatio quantitation, and that the flow cell V4 has 190-750 nm rani quantitation, ~~~~~0.002 AUFS sensitivity; volume is small. Good detectors cells for LC, HPLC, and have bandwidths in the 4-6 nm lamp life; and a three-y4 range and cell volumes on the at $3995 without option order of 8 ml per cm of optical peak separator. pathlength. Versatility. The more flow cells available, the less limited you'll be. If you can't later buy a 1 ll or smaller cell for your detector, you won't be doing any mLC. Versatility is also enhanced by a wide wavelength range and the ability to read %T. Operating ease. Consider the warm-up time re- quired. Look to see how easy flow cell changing is: an easy-to-see cell isn't necessarily easy to remove. A plug-in cell cassette is best. Ask if you have to physically remove one lamp and put in another to change from UV to VIS, or whether you can just flip a switch. Is N2 purge required for coldroom or short wavelength operation? ge JA al That can be a real nuisance. And does the detector have any special features that will be useful to you? For example, our V4 can be supplied with a built-in 10 cm recorder and can control a fraction collector to put different peaks into different test tubes. Other detectors have different features, such as automatic wavelength scanning. Value. Always consider fea- tures and performance in relation to purchase and operating costs. See if the visible lamp and other necessary items are included in the base price. You should find out expected deuterium lamp life: 1000 hours is typical; over 5000 hours is exceptional, but it can be done. Is the lamp life wasted by using it at visible wavelengths or for long warm-ups? You can easily spend as much on lamp relace- ment over a three to five year variable detector. The period as you did on the detector a; 6 nm bandwidth; itIf 2 x 10-5 noise; 10 flow Itse LLC; 8000 hr median D2 You and I know that sales ir warranty. It's priced literature often doesn't tell the J built-in recorder and whole story, and that some manu- facturers use specifications ob- tained under questionable condi- tions. You should try the instrument first, or at least buy it on approval so you can send it back if it's not what you really want. And finally, how long is the warranty and what does it give you if something goes wrong? We designed the ISCO V4 with all these points in mind. It has top specifica- -u tions and many special features that make it a pleasure to use, yet it's almost the lowest priced variable detector you can buy. To learn about it, write or call us toll-free [800] 228-4250 for your catalog. Is ISCO, P.O. Box 5347, Lincoln, NE 68505. Circle No. 271 on Readers' Service Card 9 MARCH 1984 le "/ "I 11".11-f 1-1 1013

HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

HOW TO

VARIABLE

Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks,ISCO chief design engineer:When you're buying a variablewavelength LC detector, you'llhave to sort through a lot ofspecifications and promises tofind the right one. Here is someinformation I think will help youmake your decision.

Performance. Baseline noise is a better indication ofthe detector's sensitivity than the minimum absorbancerange available. You can expect a good detector to have adry cell, peak-to-peak noise of no more than 3 x 10-5 Awith a 0.5 second rise time, at all wavelengths from 200to 300 nm. Noise should be less if measured at a longerresponse time or only in the 240nm region. Remember, noisespecified + looks twice as good aspeak-to-peak. Most detectors usea low-cost passive (resistor-capacitor) filter which reducesnoise but also reduces responsespeed and distorts peak shape.Better detectors have active fil-ters, but they're not all the same- one highly-reputed instrumenthas an active filter with bad __overshoot which is covered up byautomatic baseline correction.

Make sure that the bandwidthis narrow enough to give good ISCO's fourth generatioquantitation, and that the flow cell V4 has 190-750 nm raniquantitation, ~~~~~0.002 AUFS sensitivity;volume is small. Good detectors cells for LC, HPLC, andhave bandwidths in the 4-6 nm lamp life; and a three-y4range and cell volumes on the at $3995 without optionorder of 8 ml per cm of optical peak separator.pathlength.

Versatility. The more flow cells available, the lesslimited you'll be. If you can't later buy a 1 ll or smallercell for your detector, you won't be doing any mLC.Versatility is also enhanced by a wide wavelength rangeand the ability to read %T.

Operating ease. Consider the warm-up time re-quired. Look to see how easy flow cell changing is: aneasy-to-see cell isn't necessarily easy to remove. Aplug-in cell cassette is best. Ask if you have to physicallyremove one lamp and put in another to change from UVto VIS, or whether you can just flip a switch. Is N2 purgerequired for coldroom or short wavelength operation?

geJA

al

That can be a real nuisance. And does the detector haveany special features that will be useful to you? Forexample, our V4 can be supplied with a built-in 10 cmrecorder and can control a fraction collector to putdifferent peaks into different test tubes. Other detectorshave different features, such as automatic wavelength

scanning.Value. Always consider fea-

tures and performance in relationto purchase and operating costs.See if the visible lamp and othernecessary items are included inthe base price. You should find outexpected deuterium lamp life:1000 hours is typical; over 5000hours is exceptional, but it can bedone. Is the lamp life wasted byusing it at visible wavelengths orfor long warm-ups? You can easilyspend as much on lamp relace-ment over a three to five year

variable detector. The period as you did on the detectora; 6 nm bandwidth; itIf2 x 10-5 noise; 10 flow ItseLLC; 8000 hr median D2 You and I know that salesir warranty. It's priced literature often doesn't tell theJ built-in recorder and whole story, and that some manu-

facturers use specifications ob-tained under questionable condi-

tions. You should try the instrument first, or at least buyit on approval so you can send it back if it's not what youreally want. And finally, how long is the warranty andwhat does it give you if something goes wrong?

We designed the ISCO V4 with allthese points in mind. It has top specifica- -utions and many special features thatmake it a pleasure to use, yet it's almostthe lowest priced variable detector youcan buy. To learn about it, write or call ustoll-free [800] 228-4250 for your catalog. IsISCO, P.O. Box 5347, Lincoln, NE 68505.

Circle No. 271 on Readers' Service Card

9 MARCH 1984

le"/

"I 11".11-f 1-1

1013

Page 2: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

Waters Pr

rfrthesepIca interimany compc

al compounds,uticals and virti Compound Shaved and Collected

ie allow faster sepaiity loss than any

Isolate peptides and proteins with 99% purity

C-)

z

TIME (min) 30 - _o4

A 10 111 13 1516 21 23

Analytical results

1

I 2 I3

ACN

30 (min) 0 19 (min)

mediate molecular weight proteins to 99% purity.

Solution: Isolate a crude synthetic peptide and proteinextract to 99% purity without loss of biological activity by:performing a thirty-minute reverse phase gradient, collect-ing an enriched fraction of product, and rechromatograph-ing a heavier load of the partially purified product underdifferent gradient conditions.

Sample: 500 mg Peptide Hydrolysate 0

Cartridge: PrepPAK®Cie, 57 mm x 30 cm (300A pore,30 ,im particle)

Solvent: A) 0.1% TFA in H20B) ACN: 0.1% TFA in H20, 40:600-100%o B in 30 min, linear

Flow Rate: 150 mI/minDetection: UV, 313 nm

iut,on: Bemloyingthe exc e shave/recycle fea-of the PrepLC 5OQA System, the effective col1umn

ith was increased to 26 feet (the sample was recycled,uccessive times without repetitive manual injectioncollection) and a 77% yield of pure isomers wasized. This compares favorably to a 26.6% yield achievedcolumn chromatography.'

Sample:Cartridgqe:eMobile Phase:Flow Rate:Detector:

0.75 g Labdatriene IsomersPrePPAKKR 500 Silica, 57 mm x 60 cmn-Hexane250 ml/minRI

'Journal of Liquid Chromatography 4(3) 525-532, (1981)

Let us show you how the Waters PrepLC 500A will purifyeven your most difficult mixtures with higher yield

IliW ateSreet so ciA 0

Circle No. 280 on Readers' Service Card

/Ir(

i process.

Prep run

EC

0

0

6.0

4

0

:j lIi

Page 3: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

For a complete product summary, write or call:

SCIENTIFIC SOFTWAREPRODUCTS, INC.

5726 Professional Circle Suite 105Indianapolis, IN 46241

(317) 244-6163Apple R II is a registered trademark of Apple Computer, Inc.

Circle No. 326 on Readers' Service Card Circle No. 260 on Readers' Service Card

SCIENTISTSAND ENGINEERSWORKING IN:structural analysis -materials science -pharmacology * chemi-cal synthesis * econom-ics * medical imaging-physics * fluid mechan-ics * aerodynamics-PLAN NOWTOATEND

The Conference on theForefronts of Large ScaleComputation Problems willexplore.the interdisci-plinary applications, newapproaches, and futuretrends of large-scale com-puting technology andfocus on experimental andcomputational problemsthat approach or exceedthe limits of traditionalmethodologies.

r,aL0'

For further information,contact William L. Schrader,Newman Laboratory,Cornell University, Ithaca,New York 14853(607)256-3455.

Speakers include:

* Kenneth G. Wilson* Enrico Clementi * JamesD. Gunton * Lawrence R.Klein * James A. Swanson* David A. Pensak * GaborT. Herman a Gary Demosa Roger W. Cohen mRoland W. Schmitt* PaulE. Rubbert

"0- SCIENCE, VO <Z3

-Xw32t ' t "''v[>+-_;?, '' 'l '' ''t'-t-- *' 0'z t,<it5V'>4tior9,t I

:{iJ Ft Tf1.,T ';.T_.,'flT,'PT( .-.

DESIGNED FOR SCIENTISTS

.~~~~~~~~~~~'- _. ;

MEASURECO2

CONTENT!Smallest electrode

available.Carbon dioxide can bemeasured quickly andeasily with the MI-720, ahigh quality electrodefrom the foremostauthority in microeLec-trode technology.

MNICIOELECTIIODS.IlNOak Hill Park, Londonderry, N.H. 03053 USA

(603) 668-692

I

4

-1

1016

Page 4: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

I7 M/

A1

r=I1 - Cn MICREX MC

44

8 ;XwssfA

s. 14

,I't. t

s~~~~~~~~~~~k ,els

, 1,

I JPI40 -IV,

%?7 .*Xlcl 1..,11 71 Lq -

olo4

Ir

I

x

I

/ 410

Page 5: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

with newwLKB Horizontal

L~~~~~~~~~~~~

T ~~Achoice of3 preparative methodsI

Preparative electrofocusing in Immobiline gels is thenewest, most efficientway ofseparating proteins inquantities up to 1 gram. LKB Immobilines combinegreatly improved resolution with sample recovery ratesofup to 98%. And the absence ofsoluble carrierampholytes means that high resolution preparativeelectrofocusing oflow molecular weight substances isnow fully practicable.

-preparative electrofocusing ofhemoglobin,pH 6.0-8.5

Preparative electrofocusing in granular gels is a moretraditional method using Ampholine carrierampholytes, and is also catered for by theLKBHorizontal Electrophoresis System. The enlarged

cooling plate ofthe new Multiphor II doubles the

sample capacity, while the movable electrodes giveincreased flexibility.

-preparative isotachophoresis ofhuman serumproteins

Preparative isotachophoresis is the third choice offered

by the LKB Horizontal Electrophoresis System, and is a

low-cost alternative giving good resolution for

separations based on protein mobility. The twin

integral buffer reservoirs permit gels to be run eitheracross or along the length ofthe cooling plate.

4 -preparative electrofocusing ofhemoglobin usingImmobiline,pH 6.5 to 8.5

This is one in a series ofadvertisements describing theunrivalled versatility oftheLKB HorizontalElectrophoresis System. For further information aboutpreparative methods, and the many other applications

- _______________________________________________ofthe system, send today for our brochure.

THE LKB SYSTEM

OnlyLKB can offer the researchscientist a complete, integrated systemin which each component works withand complements all the others. Basedon the new and improved Multiphor II,

the system also includes a5KV powersupply, thermostatic circulator, laserdensitometer and data evaluationsoftware.In addition to the instrumentation,LKB provides a range of18 major kitsplus a complete programme ofhighquality chemicals, supplies andaccessories, backedby the fullworldwide support ofthe market leaderin electrophoresis and electrofocusing.LKB-the electrophoresis experts.

LKB Instruments, Inc.9319 Gaither Road, Gaithersburg, Maryland 20877.

Te. 301-963-3200,Circle No. 161 on Readers' Service Card

Page 6: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

Since its introduction, the DMS 100 Spectrophotom-eter has enjoyed unprecedented popularity, becauseit simply offers more analytical possibilities for yourinstrument investment dollar. Scientists like the way theDMS 100 displays a spectrum on the video screen inreal time; the way it stores spectral information in itscapacious memory for later retrieval; and its intelligentcell changer.

The DMS 100 with the cell changer lets you* signal-average for each cell* monitor cell temperature* print out absorbance, slope, standard deviation,and temperature

But if you need* accurate measurement of differences less than

0.01 0 Abs* plots of temperature versus absorbance* measurement of highly absorbing, scatteringsamples

you need the ultrahigh-performance Varian-Cary2200 UV-Vis Spectrophotometer.

Computer compatibility? Of course!Both the DMS 100 and the 2200interface with the Varian DS 15 DataStation to form a completelyautomatic UV-Vis system.

Circle Reader Service Number 274 for moreinformation; circle No. 275 to discuss your UV-Visneeds with a Varian representative.For immediate assistance contact: FlorhamPark NJ (201) 822-3700 * Park Ridge IL(312) 825-7772 * Sugar Land TX (713) 491-7330* Georgetown, Ontario (416) 457-4130.Or write 611 Hansen Way, Palo Alto, CA 94303In Europe: Steinhauserstrasse, CH-6300 Zug,Switzerland

IntelligentAutomation... varianfmom Varian

Page 7: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

0 Cu CO2

I"4 Cu KC.0 co~

* C~~e~ *~";~ 20

= 2~~~~~ ~ b

= 00

e q

' CLci-

aL

O

4) C6 40

4 i cojF 0

COis 4-41

0

Cu Cu

0.

.2is

co- cc

cisC eCu

>C

@~0

'A.

WU)

r-

00i

cm)

0

B2

1.0) C

4) C4C

.=

-0

I...C

Sc

.00

0

S06

C's.0

C)o

C6C

co.2<

~ ~ ~ c

V11- LO00 CL

oe-~~~~~~~0 r

occ as~~~

cis,acl2,2

~~0c 0S

0..20

C.)0

ICu

@0

2-.= 8.0 %

0.- .-

.0

.2COCu

co C.-

CO

'a

a

.& .9

b Cu.

4

la

00

z0

2

Cu

C2)

0

06.

0 M

0 -'O C~-

.0 0-@0 Cu4

I~CuC

0m.

iv'20 9

=

.2 tC06.

.0

0.

0

'2

00

0

0)

9.0

*0

0 4-

0.

Cu)

CO

0qs-4

os:

-a

0,;u

2-C

0.-1

@0 r

so . .~

I0

E:. 0

OA

@0

Z~ee*

- 0I- M

0

;.0

F--

'0

m0%

0 a

0s z

.O 2

=

a

el < U)

z4 a

Co I

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~SCIENCE, VOL. 223

0o

0%

'0

@0

.0

Cu0.ri~

Cd

C,7

CA0Cu

0.

CuL0.

0n

0IPco

.0

'aa

= @0a r

@0

000,..

S00

4.2

2CO

co

.-.C

co

z

0.

CC)N'2 f

co

'.c

0

i2

.2

CauI.. 6*P

CO

Cu

4-4

@0

@0 ..-..'. CO

0 --C.)O4) 0Cu

2 .0..0.

4)-

0-'

.. -.

16aOPMO06,*Eaw

r"0 POO*aQQ

PE"CZ

r"ro

44!

06

CcCu6

0.)

CuC

1092

Page 8: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

i

A.

P

'S

xa

:I

II £* I

A

0 NS

I ia .---.acLd a 4,4A "d -,

." 444^ :M. -LI m-

410 4m -a 14W

le.

00

I F- Nk

00

a *!a I 'o0

togo Gn9 -.

7 4ar. -,I

;R

tt.l

9W%

4100Ji

2

I'-E0u.s 9

.6

12.

.9

q.2Im

iI t.l. 1.1

t,qW2

46

-Mkci.2

9i

94-Is8a

w

9

r-

E!e

asow

_m

14w .*a

i

.l. b

w8 I 9

e: _

._ ,

-0: Z)

;Roo

.%:

aE-IZ;

.1

1 a

I

I --

:-00

c

n 9.Opp

.5 a- a

"I

aN

[..;

4-:0 *!.io

a

Go

3ao

a

= %6._

CT W%o

CA

' g0

lii.= hR X *~~~fx *§6§2co yt;s x _w tR -.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o

X X } j CS-o

.!d

la

=.0

A6g

I!iz!i5*-.r

a

60%I

F6ar14

e4DS

I00

.011

cl.0

a0

'I92a9i

t .tla

I C

# ;zO.,

W-t

I A

a:&-X

sooe,-4

4

r4.Q

ot

IoaoC

a)

1-

*k

1@

Is g

.Ic i.-

a:e

tI

?8.2.o

= C

Ca .o

a E g

e0x

.9

SO

C4

8 a^

I

.-I

8

IaiIEa=1

00

-9

I;0%s0

m0.5ii0

oo

a Mk

A. A*

so

ra - no}

IC |-

AC g s

P6a

quo

G3 o0_

a i

i -

I _

as

:gI

.9

a a6 .

im a*p ]

C°026

r;}

!" ffi '.o C'g S

C'iW

0sa

-i

"*, to

a =

-A

_;

A

Ais

le1

Go

I

2R

iC-q4

CP

a0

9 MARCH 1984 i093

0S

so W

Page 9: HOWTO VARIABLE - Science · HOWTO VARIABLE Dr. Geoffrey B. Crooks, ISCOchief design engineer: Whenyou'rebuyinga variable wavelengthLCdetector, you'll haveto sortthroughalot of specifications

Iunr.mNvUA|L _ I _ _ wM_ isdator

TECHNOLOGY CENTERSThe US Army Chemical Research and

sources among United States institutions vibration isolation systemsof higher leaming with graduate-levelstudy programs for the establishment of

one or more chemical systems technolo-

gy conters. The program will involvecomprehensive research and engineer-

ing in subjects such as chemical and

biological sensors, air filtration, aerosol

technology, systems analysis/dynamics,biotechnology, and catalysts applicableto detection and identification, physical

program is envisioned to include interac- *tion between CRDC investigators and

the technology center staff through coop-erative research, personnel exchangeand training programs. Interested partiesare invited to request a Qualitative Re-quirements Information Package by writ-ing to the address below. Once regis-tered parties will be fumished, upon their * Prevents horizontal, vertical and rotational floor vibrations from degradingrequest, more details on the technology equipment performance.centers and/or an invitation to attend a * Eliminates "ships roll" motion commonly associated with simple traditional airbriefing to be held at CRDC on or about isolators.

15 April 1984 to discuss the technology * Peak performance, even with difiult to attenuate very low level, low frequency

centers. This will be followed by an invita- floor motion.

tion to submit an unsolicited proposal. * Precisionlevelingavailableasoption.

Telephone requests will not be honored. l H|Wrighly-dmpedplatforms attenuate "on-board" equipment generated vibration.Telephne reqests honred.* Wrt pcfcations, standard models and prices.Cdr, Chemical RArch and velonM-

Center, US Army Armament, Mu- Technical Manufacturing Corporationnltlons and Chemical Command, 185 New Boston Street * Wobum, Massachusetts 01801ATTN: DRSMC-CLY-R (A), Aberdeen Telephone: 617-933-0050 * Telex: 951408Proving Ground, MD 21010. TMC-10R

Circle No. 228 on Readers' Service Card

Varian's new

_

Send todayfor your free copy

This big, new book includes LC instruments, |data systems, our new line of LC components, instruc-tional books, training videocassettes, columns and pack- | a d mechanW er~~~~~~biotechnology and fluid mlechanIcs. W haweings, and Varian's complete line Ot parts and accessories. than any other source. CaU us today

Catalog No. 22 will serve every LC user, regardless --pa--l

of the kind of liquid chromatograph you own.

How to order: Write Varian Instrument Group,

D-070, 611 Hansen Way, Palo Alto, CA 94303, T Corprationor circle the Reader Service Number.

Intelligent Chromatography... valan U.S.A., 2415EWbay Palo Alto, CA 94303, (415) 424-1100, Teex: 334490

from Varian Oel Dlone Scientific Europe, P0. Box 594, Hiiversum, HoHand, 035-19587, Telex: 43084rN o

.Tx re y , 3747 , 4 4 3

Circle No. 276 on Readers' Service Card C_mf, luono Research Laboratories Ltd., Shelburre, Ontario, (519) 925-6850, Telex: 0697796

Circle No. 227 on Readers' Service Card

&%U MEO AU 4 C C_r 1

I