2
Chapter II – ‘The Fire’ - The structure of the text is important, specifically the chapter organization. It provides a record of his experiences and interviews; however the structure follows the after effects of the bomb. - Sophie is the best. - Emphasis on the wounded and suffering - Dominant values and other – notion of the other and the yellow peril, based on the differences between the Japanese and west e.g. the physical and cultural disparities. - Americans saw the attack as justifiable, to end the war. They also saw themselves as a the superior race (Truman’s speech) - The publication impacted the reader as it was released after world had been sheltered from the truth and reality. Hersey’s account brought the reality to the readers, showing the humanization of the characters. E.g mother caring for her children, working in a factory. (Elaborating the point) - Hersey displays the pain and suffering through graphic portrayal forces the reader to revaluate what they had previously thought and believed. Challenges the dominant way of thinking. - Hersey actively chooses to (deliberately, on purpose) to portray accurate and confronting through journalistic style. - QUOTE : from scientist in Manhattan project, after reading ‘ Hiroshima’ ‘I am filled with shame to recall the whoopee spirit…’ - feels this due to the style of writing - QUOTE : ‘I wonder if we do yet what fully happened’ – Even a scientist from the project is left with questions around the capacity of atomic energy. - Ambiguity through presenting it as a journalistic report giving the reader the ability to interpret on their own - Characterisation of the Japanese as multi-layered people, evokes empathy in the American people due to the deliberate choice of two religious and doctors - Use of confronting images: QUOTE ‘houses nearby were burning, she heard two small voices nearby calling help help. Her baby was badly cut’ – emotive ‘baby’ deliberate - Journalistic style allows readers to witness history, challenging the dominant way of thinking by giving the reader an eye-witness account.

HSC English Extension I 2014 Hiroshima Chapter 2 Notes

  • Upload
    jk

  • View
    22

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Notes relating to HSC English Extension I on reading John Hersey's Hiroshima, Chapter 2: The Fire.

Citation preview

Page 1: HSC English Extension I 2014 Hiroshima Chapter 2 Notes

Chapter II – ‘The Fire’

- The structure of the text is important, specifically the chapter organization. It provides a record of his experiences and interviews; however the structure follows the after effects of the bomb.

- Sophie is the best.- Emphasis on the wounded and suffering – - Dominant values and other – notion of the other and the yellow peril, based on the

differences between the Japanese and west e.g. the physical and cultural disparities. - Americans saw the attack as justifiable, to end the war. They also saw themselves as a the

superior race (Truman’s speech)- The publication impacted the reader as it was released after world had been sheltered from

the truth and reality. Hersey’s account brought the reality to the readers, showing the humanization of the characters. E.g mother caring for her children, working in a factory. (Elaborating the point)

- Hersey displays the pain and suffering through graphic portrayal forces the reader to revaluate what they had previously thought and believed. Challenges the dominant way of thinking.

- Hersey actively chooses to (deliberately, on purpose) to portray accurate and confronting through journalistic style.

- QUOTE : from scientist in Manhattan project, after reading ‘Hiroshima’ ‘I am filled with shame to recall the whoopee spirit…’ - feels this due to the style of writing

- QUOTE : ‘I wonder if we do yet what fully happened’ – Even a scientist from the project is left with questions around the capacity of atomic energy.

- Ambiguity through presenting it as a journalistic report giving the reader the ability to interpret on their own

- Characterisation of the Japanese as multi-layered people, evokes empathy in the American people due to the deliberate choice of two religious and doctors

- Use of confronting images: QUOTE ‘houses nearby were burning, she heard two small voices nearby calling help help. Her baby was badly cut’ – emotive ‘baby’ deliberate

- Journalistic style allows readers to witness history, challenging the dominant way of thinking by giving the reader an eye-witness account.

- Deliberate use of statistics – dispassionate however provides an emotive response ‘the baby was cut’

- QUOTE: ‘In a city of 245 000, nearly 100 000 had been killed or doomed at one blow’ (p25)– Deliberate choice gives emotion and feeling by using statistics to show the effect on the people rather than the damage to inadamate objects such as buildings. This increases the readers understating of the large scale tragedy. Statistics such as this along with graphic realism forces the reader to reconsider the truth or authority and traditional institution. This started a shift in the immediate thinking after the bomb.

- ‘Huge drops of water the size of marbles began to fall, they were actually… (p25) This rose questions of morality and ethics and about the overall human issue of this technology.

- ‘Why is it night already?’ ‘Why did the house fall down’ questions children were asking reflected the many questions that everybody had.

- Religious & Philosophical Paradigms.

Page 2: HSC English Extension I 2014 Hiroshima Chapter 2 Notes

- Use of biblical echoes … - The challenge to belief and tradition to humanity are extreme at this point. However Hersey

continues his lack of direct comment and the readers are free to interpret the events in different ways. (Ambiguity)

- Mr Tanimoto – represents for the reader goodness and Hersey has actively chosen his acts of kindness. Challenges us to find this in humanity. (Compassionate Japanese man is challenging to pre-bomb thinking) E.G he ferries people across Asano River. He also organizes fire fighting and returns to town for food for the victims. In this sense he becomes a true Christian (Christian values in the ‘other’).

-