4
you are here : home | | one bangsar outlets lose court case One Bangsar outlets lose court case BERNAMA Wednesday, October 6th, 2010 20:17:00  KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here today dismissed an application for judicial review by nine restaurants in One Bangsar, Jalan Ara to quash the Kuala Lumpur mayor's decision disallowing a further extension of the planning permission of the outlets. Judge Datuk Mohd Zawawi Salleh made the decision in chambers and dismissed it with RM20,000 in costs. However, the court granted the applicant, Markibra Services, an interim stay of the decision, pending the hearing of a stay application on Oct 26. B. Thangaraj, appearing for Mayor Datuk Seri Ahmad Fuad Ismail, told reporters that Mohd Zawawi ruled that there was no legitimate expectation created by the respondent because the planning permission was granted on a temporary basis. He said the planning permission was to be renewed every year. The planning permission, which is a temporary approval for the change of land use from residential to commercial status, expired at the end of last year. The Kuala Lumpur City Hall had granted Markibra Services with the maximum of five-year planning permission. In its judicial review application filed on Feb 25, this year, Markibra sought the court's order to quash the mayor's decision in not allowing a further extension of the planning permission. It also sought the court's order compelling the mayor to grant a renewal of the planning permission for 10 years or any period deemed fair and reasonable by the c ourt. Markibra was represented by counsel Tommy Thomas. It was reported that Ahmad Fuad had said that the planning permission was not extended after taking into account residents' demands that Jalan Ara regain its resi dential status. Print er-fri endly versi on Send to friend COMMENTS good job and well done to DBKL. please dont give face to this bunch of people who do not know the meaning of `TEMPORARY`. Submitted by max on Thursday, October 7th, 2010.  reply Pls don't turn Bangsar into a entertainment area anymore... Go to Solaris or somewhere far far away la... Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 7th, 2010.  reply AT LAST REAL POWER IS RETURNED TO THE RESIDENTS! SUNDAY 10 OCTOBER 2010 Search  Most Viewed Most Commented Drug Mule's Joke Of '... Justice For Johnny Rude Treatment By Furniture... Zaid Accused Of Practising... Buckle Up For Your Own Safety Banting Murders: Suspects'... Worried About Being '... 'Namaste' From... Cops Pick Up Show-Off Biker At... Sabah MP Dies In Road Accident PICTURE GALLERY  HOME NEWS WORLD OPINION SPORTS HOTLINE/MAIL LIFE MAIL MOTOR CLASSIFIEDS CONTACT US Page 1 of 4 One Bangsar outlets lose court case | Malay Mail Online 10/10/2010 http://www.mmail.com.my/content/51482-one-bangsar-outlets-lose-court-case

Http Www.mmail.com

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

8/8/2019 Http Www.mmail.com

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/http-wwwmmailcom 1/4

you are here : home | | one bangsar outlets lose court case

One Bangsar outlets lose court caseBERNAMA Wednesday, October 6th, 2010 20:17:00 

KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here today dismissed an application for judicial review by nine restaurants in One

Bangsar, Jalan Ara to quash the Kuala Lumpur mayor's decision disallowing a further extension of the planning

permission of the outlets.

Judge Datuk Mohd Zawawi Salleh made the decision in chambers and dismissed it with RM20,000 in costs.

However, the court granted the applicant, Markibra Services, an interim stay of the decision, pending the hearing of a

stay application on Oct 26.

B. Thangaraj, appearing for Mayor Datuk Seri Ahmad Fuad Ismail, told reporters that Mohd Zawawi ruled that there

was no legitimate expectation created by the respondent because the planning permission was granted on a

temporary basis.

He said the planning permission was to be renewed every year. The planning permission, which is a temporary

approval for the change of land use from residential to commercial status, expired at the end of last year.

The Kuala Lumpur City Hall had granted Markibra Services with the maximum of five-year planning permission.

In its judicial review application filed on Feb 25, this year, Markibra sought the court's order to quash the mayor's

decision in not allowing a further extension of the planning permission.

It also sought the court's order compelling the mayor to grant a renewal of the planning permission for 10 years or anyperiod deemed fair and reasonable by the court. Markibra was represented by counsel Tommy Thomas.

It was reported that Ahmad Fuad had said that the planning permission was not extended after taking into account

residents' demands that Jalan Ara regain its residential status.

Printer-friendly version Send to friend

COMMENTS

good job and well done to DBKL. please dont give face to this bunch of people who do not know the meaning of 

`TEMPORARY`.

Submitted by max on Thursday, October 7th, 2010. 

reply

Pls don't turn Bangsar into a entertainment area anymore... Go to Solaris or somewhere far far away la...

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 7th, 2010. 

reply

AT LAST REAL POWER IS RETURNED TO THE RESIDENTS!

SUNDAY 10 OCTOBER 2010

Search  

Most Viewed Most Commented

Drug Mule's Joke Of '...

Justice For Johnny

Rude Treatment By Furniture...

Zaid Accused Of Practising...

Buckle Up For Your Own Safety

Banting Murders: Suspects'...

Worried About Being '...

'Namaste' From...

Cops Pick Up Show-Off Biker At...

Sabah MP Dies In Road Accident

PICTURE GALLERY 

 

HOME NEWS WORLD OPINION SPORTS HOTLINE/MAIL LIFE MAIL MOTOR CLASSIFIEDS CONTACT US

Page 1 of 4One Bangsar outlets lose court case | Malay Mail Online

10/10/2010http://www.mmail.com.my/content/51482-one-bangsar-outlets-lose-court-case

8/8/2019 Http Www.mmail.com

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/http-wwwmmailcom 2/4

 

Submitted by GOUNDAMANI on Wednesday, October 6th, 2010. 

reply

Post new comment

 Your name: *

 Anonymous  

E-mail: *

 

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly .

Homepage:

Comment: *

55

66

Ground rules for posting comments:

1. No personal attacks.

2. No vulgar or discriminatory language.

3. If you do not follow these rules, we will remove your comment.

Disclaimer 

In line with Malay Mail's tag-line "Your Voice", do use our comments service to express your opinions.

Kindly note that your comments will be moderated by Malay Mail before they are posted on this site. Malay Mail holds

the sole right to publish or delete a comment that has been posted at its absolute discretion. Malay Mail will also not

correct grammar or spelling mistakes that may exist in such comments.

We value your feedback and will strive to publish your comments as long as they:

* DO NOT contain anything which could be potentially libellous or defamatory.

* DO NOT contain foul language and are of a vulgar or abusive nature.

* DO NOT contain any offensive slurs.

* DO NOT contain religious or racial discrimination; and/or 

* DO relate to the post that you are responding to.

Comments that breach the guidelines will be deleted/ignored or modified with immediate effect and with no prior 

notification to the author.

Also please note that the views expressed herewith are the sole responsibility of the visitor who submits each

comment and not those of Malay Mail. Malay Mail does not bear the responsibility of any comment posted on the site.

The publishing of such comment does not and is not to be understood that Malay Mail agrees with it, endorses it, or 

believes it to be correct and/or true.

gfedc Email me about all replies to this article.

CAPTCHA 

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Math Question: *

3 + 0 =

Can't find what you were looking for? You

might find it in our Archives 

Featured Columns

Page 2 of 4One Bangsar outlets lose court case | Malay Mail Online

10/10/2010http://www.mmail.com.my/content/51482-one-bangsar-outlets-lose-court-case

8/8/2019 Http Www.mmail.com

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/http-wwwmmailcom 3/4

8/8/2019 Http Www.mmail.com

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/http-wwwmmailcom 4/4

Contact our advertising team to place an advertisement in Malay Mail, Malay Mail Online, and Mail on Sunday.

Copyright 2009 Malay Mail Sdn. Bhd.

Page 4 of 4One Bangsar outlets lose court case | Malay Mail Online

10/10/2010http://www mmail com my/content/51482 one bangsar outlets lose court case