20
Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger- spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a , Joana Barros b , Daniel Wendel c Email a: [email protected] b: [email protected] c: [email protected] 1

Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: [email protected]

  • View
    221

  • Download
    5

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

1

Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Manwith an agent-based model

Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c

Email a: [email protected]: [email protected] c: [email protected]

Page 2: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

2

Suffolk, 1984

Page 3: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

3

StarLogo TNG - code blocks

Page 4: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

4

The Isle of Man in TNG SpaceLand

Page 5: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

5

Objective

Is there a relationship between where a beetle cluster originates and the number of agent elms that die?

If so, might that relationship be used to map the island to reveal locations where an infestation might potentially be more or less damaging?

Page 6: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

6

Isle of Man - Relief

• Scolytus beetles can only thrive where elms prosper

• Landscape determines elm habitats

• On Man, there is an ‘elm-line’ of ca. 160 metres a.s.l..

• Two ranges of hills exceed this elevation, restricting the flow of the disease across the island

• In the model, a ‘beetle-line’ was set at an arbitrary 25 % higher (200m) than the elm-line.

The combination of DEM, elm-line and beetle-line places elevation at the model’s centre.

• Beetles operating out of any given disease epicentre will find some areas accessible, others out of range.

Page 7: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

7

A single model run …Sets up tree, beetle, forester, bird

agents‘Infects’ up to 1.5% of elms with beetlesRuns an elm census at game turn (GT) 0Generates a single beetle clusterRuns a beetle census at GT 60Continues to GT 1,000Exports results to .csv fileResets to GT 0 and introduces next run

Page 8: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

8

Model agent flow chart

Page 9: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

9

The agents

Page 10: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

10

Model system flow chart

Page 11: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

11

SL-TNG OutputFor each run:

◦cluster originates in random location;◦number of elms surviving to GT1000

varies.csv run results ported to MapInfo

and SPSS for processing, then transferred to ArcGIS Spatial Analyst

Page 12: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

12

RCNS Calculation – step one

Page 13: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

13

RCNS Calculation – step two

Page 14: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

14

RCNS zones and regions

Page 15: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

15

Data processing flowchart

Page 16: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

16

Frequency of cell inclusion

Page 17: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

17

Cluster median centres and elm survival

Page 18: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

18

Modelled danger-spots

Page 19: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

19

Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Manwith an agent-based model 

Bruce MitchellData Visualisation CentreMethodology DirectorateOffice for National Statistics [email protected]

Joana Barros Department of Geography, Environment and Development Studies, Birkbeck, University of London, Malet Street, London, WC1E 7HX [email protected]

Daniel WendelLead StarLogo TNG DeveloperScheller Teacher Education Program Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyBoston, MA, USA [email protected] 

Page 20: Identifying Dutch elm disease ‘danger-spots’ on the Isle of Man with an agent-based model Bruce Mitchell a, Joana Barros b, Daniel Wendel c Email a: bruce.birkbeck@ntlworld.com

20