IECEU D5.2 M17 Design and development process of the NMLA

D5.2 Desig

process of

I

Lead bene

Delivery da

Revision: 2

Dissemin

PU: Publi

PP: Restr

RE: Restr

gn and Dev

f the NMLA

mproving t

5.2

eficiary: Lau

ate: 05/10/2

2.0

nation Leve

c

ricted to oth

ricted to a g

elopment

the Effectiv

2 Design an

rea Univers

2016

el

her program

group specif

PRO

veness of C

nd Develop

sity of Appli

mme particip

fied by the c

Public

OJECT TIT

Capabilitie

pment Proc

ed Science

pants (includ

consortium

TLE:

es (IEC) in E

cesses of t

es

ding the Co

(including t

S

EU conflict

the NMLA

mmission)

the Commis

Contract

Start date:

Duration:

t preventio

ssion)

IECEU

no 653371

01/05/2015

33 months

n

X

U

5

s

D5.2 Desigprocess of

Thgrares

CONTEN

ACRONYM

EXECUTIV

1 INTROD

1.1 IECE

1.2 Obje

1.3 Struc

2 NMLA –

2.1 Why

2.2. Rev

2.2.1 C

2.2.2 M

3 DESCRI

3.1 Targ

3.2 Lear

3.3 Tech

3.4 Deve

3.5 Anim

3.6 NML

3.7 Rele

4 CONCLU

BIBLIOGR

gn and Devf the NMLA

his project has rant agreement sponsible for an

NTS

MS .............

VE SUMMA

UCTION ...

EU Project ..

ect and purp

cture of the

BACKGRO

New Media

view of eLea

Civilian crisi

Military crisi

PTION OF

et groups ..

ning objecti

hnical specif

elopment ph

mations, visu

LA Evaluatio

vance to cu

USIONS .....

RAPHY .......

elopment

received fundingno 653371. The

ny use that may

.................

ARY ...........

.................

.................

pose ..........

deliverable

OUND ........

a Based Le

arning and o

is managem

s managem

THE NMLA

.................

ives ...........

fications ....

hases ........

ual images

on ..............

urrent CSDP

.................

.................

g from the EU Fe content of thisbe made of the

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

e .................

..................

arning Appl

online learn

ment ...........

ment ...........

A DEVELOP

..................

..................

..................

..................

(html5) and

..................

P training ...

..................

..................

Public

Framework Progs document refle information it c

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

lication (NM

ning in CSD

..................

..................

PMENT WO

..................

..................

..................

..................

d voice-over

..................

..................

..................

..................

gramme for Relects the authorcontains,

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

MLA)? ........

P training ..

..................

..................

ORK ...........

..................

..................

..................

..................

r ................

..................

..................

..................

..................

S

search and Innors’ view and the

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

CSA projeStart date:

Duration:

ovation HORIZOe European Com

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

ON 2020 undermmission is not

2

................ 4

................ 6

................ 8

................ 8

................ 9

.............. 10

.............. 11

.............. 11

.............. 16

.............. 19

.............. 23

.............. 26

.............. 28

.............. 29

.............. 30

.............. 39

.............. 45

.............. 47

.............. 52

.............. 55

.............. 57

U

5 s

r t

2

4

6

8

8

9

0

6

9

3

6

8

9

0

9

5

7

2

5

7


Thgrares

ANNEXES

ANNEX

ANNEX

ANNEX

LIST OF

Figure 1 T

Figure 2 N

Figure 3 IE

Figure 4 T

LIST OF

Table 1 Wo

Table 2 Mo

Table 3 Op



S .................

1 Question

2: Question

3: Animatio

FIGURE

he framewo

MLA develo

ECEU NMLA

he timeline

TABLES

ordpress: a

oodle: asse

pigno: asse

elopment


ny use that may

.................

naire for the

nnaire for pi

on themes in

S

ork of NMLA

opment pro

A Pilot even

of the NML

S

assessment

essment. ....

ssment. ....


..................

e case stud

loting ........

n NMLA .....

A ................

cess. .........

nt ...............

LA developm

. ................

..................

..................

Public


..................

dy researche

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

ment ...........

..................

..................

..................


..................

ers .............

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

S


..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................


Duration:


..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


3

.............. 61

.............. 61

.............. 63

.............. 65

............. 14

............. 42

............. 43

............. 44

............. 32

............. 33

............. 34

U

5 s

r t

3

3

5

4

2

3

4

2

3

4


Thgrares

ACRONY

AKU

C3MC

CBT

CEP

CEPOL

CivCom

CMPD

CMPD

CSDP

CSDP

EAPTC

EDA

EEAS

EGT

ENTRi

ESDP

EU

EUFOR AL

EUMM

EUPST

EUSR

FINCENT

IAPTC

ICO

ICR

IDL

IECEU

IPA

MMA

NATO

NMLA



YMS

LTHEA

elopment


ny use that may

Auton

Certif

Comp

Cente

Europ

Comm

Crisis

Crisis

Comm

EU’s

Easte

Europ

Europ

The E

Europ

Europ

Europ

Europ

Europ

Europ

Europ

Finnis

The I

Intern

Intern

Intern

Impro

Instru

Monit

North

New


nomous Kno

fied EU Civi

puter-Based

er for Europ

pean Police

mittee for C

s Managem

s Managem

mon Securit

Common S

ern Associa

pean Defen

pean Extern

European G

pe’s New Tr

pean Secur

pean Union

pean Union

pean Union

pean Union

pean Union

sh Defence

nternationa

national Civ

national Civ

net-Based A

oving The E

ument for Pr

toring, Ment

h Atlantic Tr

Media base

Public


owledge Un

ilian Crisis M

d Training

pean Perspe

e College

Civilian Aspe

ent and Pla

ent and Pla

ty and Defe

Security and

ation of Peac

nce Agency

nal Action S

Group on Tra

raining Initia

rity and Defe

Force Alth

Monitoring

Police Ser

Special Re

e Forces Inte

al Associatio

vilian Office

vilian Repres

Advanced D

Effectivenes

re-Accessio

toring and A

reaty Organ

ed Learning


nits

Manageme

ective

ects of Crisi

anning Direc

anning Direc

ence Policy

d Defence P

ce Operatio

Service

aining

ative for Civ

ece Policy

ea

g Mission

rvices Train

epresentativ

ernational C

on of Peace

sentative

Distance Lea

ss Of Capab

on

Advising

nization

g Application

S


nt Course

s Managem

ctorate

ctorate

Policy

ons Training

vilian Crisis

ing

ve

Centre

ekeeping Tra

arning

bilities In Eu

n


Duration:


ment

g Centres

Manageme

raining Cent

u Conflict Pr

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


4

ent

ters

revention

U

5 s

r t

4


Thgrares

OMIK

OSCE

POTI

SSR

UNESCO

UNHCR

UNMIK

UNSC

UNSCR



elopment


ny use that may

Organ

Organ

UN P

Secu

Unite

Unite

Unite

Unite

Unite


nization for

nization for

Peace Opera

rity Sector R

d Nations E

d Nations H

d Nations A

d Nations S

d Nations S

Public


Security Co

Security Co

ations Train

Reform

Educational

High Comm

Administrati

Security Co

Security Co


ooperation

ooperation

ning Institute

, Scientific a

issioner for

on in Kosov

uncil

uncil Resol

S


in Europe M

in Europe

e

and Cultura

r Refugees

vo

ution


Duration:


Mission in K

al Organizat

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


5

Kosovo

tion

U

5 s

r t

5


Thgrares

EXECUT

The IECEU

developed

on one h

complimen

This delive

process of

developed

with other

underlying

related pha

software w

and update

The develo

user accou

target grou

national st

The structu

that after in

individual n

and planni

Then, the

subsequen

learning a

consisting

manageme

The delive

eLearning.

invested

manageme

has not b



TIVE SUM

U project fin

as a part o

hand, to su

ntary tool fo

erable will d

f the IECEU

in the cou

relevant tra

theories re

ases in NM

which provid

e. The platfo

oped NMLA

unt. After th

up of the eL

taff, researc

ure of the N

nitial introdu

needs and

ing and imp

platform de

nt compara

chievemen

of animati

ent.

erable sum

. The EU

in develop

ent related

been done

elopment


ny use that may

MMARY

ndings are

of the proje

upport the

r various EU

describe the

U learning

rse of the p

ainings has

elated to on

MLA develo

des a clear

orm can be

A can be us

hat, the req

Learning too

chers, educ

NMLA consi

uction to the

interests. F

plementatio

escribes an

ative studies

t. Finally, a

ons and in

ms up the

has demon

ping vario

training (es

in a coord


made avail

ect. The dev

project di

U crisis ma

e backgrou

application

project as a

been furthe

line learning

pment work

and light ba

accessed a

ed free of c

quired link

ol includes

cational inst

ists of seve

e tool, the p

First, the pla

on activities

nd summar

s. All the c

a chapter t

nteractive e

current EU

nstrated in

us eLearn

specially un

dinated and

Public


able a New

veloped NM

isseminatio

nagement t

nd, structur

. This appl

a part of the

er elaborate

g. Moreove

k. The NML

asis for com

at www.iece

charge. The

to access t

staff secon

titutions, st

en chapters

platform allo

atform prese

s related to

ries the eig

chapters w

titled Gene

elements, p

U/CSDP tra

creasing in

ning conte

nder ESDC

d well-orche


w Media bas

MLA is an e

n and on

training cou

re, learning

ication is a

e IECEU dis

ed in D8.5).

er, it describ

LA is based

mprehensiv

eulearning.

e user will o

the NMLA

ded to the

udents, civ

. The platfo

ows users to

ents briefly

conflict pre

ht IECEU c

ill be follow

eral compe

presents 13

aining in pa

nterest tow

nts to su

, ENTRi an

estrated m

S


sed Learnin

e-learning p

the other

rses and ev

objectives

a part of IE

ssemination

The delive

bes the deve

d on Opign

e content w

eu

only have to

will be ema

CSDP miss

il servants,

orm has bee

o navigate f

the most re

evention an

case studie

wed by a q

tencies in

3 generic to

articular wi

ards eLear

upport con

nd EUPST a

anner in s


Duration:


ng Applicati

platform wit

r hand, to

vents.

and the de

ECEU traini

n activities

erable briefly

elopment p

no/Drupal o

which easy

o create his

ailed to the

sions, contr

employees

en develope

freely to foc

elevant EU

nd crisis ma

es and the

quiz measu

conflict ma

opics relate

ith regard

rning and

nflict preve

activities). H

spite of the

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


6

ion (NMLA)

h an object

provide a

evelopment

ng toolbox,

(integration

y describes

process and

pen source

to maintain

or her own

e user. The

racted staff,

s of NGOs.

ed in a way

cus on their

institutions

anagement.

findings of

uring users’

anagement,

ed to crisis

to existing

that it has

ention/crisis

However, it

e potentials

U

5 s

r t

6

)

t

a

t

,

n

s

d

e

n

n

e

,

.

y

r

s

.

f

’

,

s

g

s

s

t

s


Thgrares

eLearning

the finding

creates a s

to support

eLearning

has increa

profession

tools in the

often diffic

aid, huma

interconne

eLearning

collaborato

effectivene



has as a c

s highlight

strong ince

EU’s comp

activities/p

sed consid

als joining

eir learning

cult to pin-p

anitarian a

ected. Train

platforms

ors in the

ess of the E

elopment


ny use that may

ost-effective

the need fo

ntive to dev

prehensive

latforms in

erably in EU

the CSDP

g and thus

oint causal

id, civilian

ing that pro

could ser

CSDP m

EU efforts in


e, practical

or enhanced

velop and u

approach,

a more ho

U countries

missions a

they can b

ities in seq

crisis ma

ovides unde

ve to enh

missions an

conflict pre

Public


and easily

d training am

utilize e-lear

it would be

olistic mann

s as part of

and operatio

e more res

quence of u

anagement

erstanding

ance the

nd operatio

evention.


manageab

mong CSD

rning in a m

e logical an

ner. The us

informal an

ons are mo

spondent to

nfolding ev

and milita

of this inte

competenc

ons. Ultim

S


ble complim

P mission p

more system

nd beneficia

se of variou

nd formal ed

re accustom

o it. Moreo

vents, trade

ary crisis

erconnected

ces and an

ately, this


Duration:


mentary tool.

participants

matic mann

al to try to

us e-learnin

ducation. T

med to use

over, even t

e politics, de

manageme

dness with

nalytical sk

could en

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


7

. Moreover,

. This need

er. In order

restructure

g solutions

he younger

e eLearning

though it is

evelopment

ent are all

the various

kills of the

nhance the

U

5 s

r t

7

,

d

r

e

s

r

g

s

t

l

s

e

e


Thgrares

1 INTROD

The EU a

Contempo

flows of ref

conditions

personnel.

Moreover,

way. One

one way t

(security) t

institutiona

requiring a

be update

enhance tr

At later sta

to utilize th

a curriculu

in future in

The eLear

to support

related to

blended C

learning pl

that individ

ideas and

1.1 IECE

Improving

May 2015

countries.



DUCTION

aims to pre

rary conflic

fugees see

in crisis

The EU ne

due to eco

tool for cos

to cut expe

training. Ad

al memory.

allocation of

ed, adapted

raining while

age of the IE

he NMLA in

m will be de

tertiary edu

ning platfor

Universitie

conflict pre

CSDP pre-d

atform is ut

dual learnin

experience

U PROJEC

the Effectiv

. The lengt

The main

elopment


ny use that may

vent conflic

cts impact a

king for she

manageme

eeds to refl

onomic con

st-effective

enses while

dditionally,

The eLear

f trainers. M

d and disse

e being eco

ECEU - pro

n training. S

eveloped fo

ucation prog

rm will be m

es and othe

evention an

eployment

tilizing is in

ng process

s.

CT

veness of C

th of the p

goal of the


cts and ma

an increase

elter and pr

ent mission

ect this cha

nstrains, too

and flexible

e at the sa

it can prov

rning is not

Moreover, th

eminated fa

onomically m

oject, a Han

Subsequentl

or this purpo

grammes, c

maintained a

er training o

nd crisis ma

training. Th

line with pe

is based on

Capabilities

roject is 33

e project is

Public


anage crisis

ed number

rotection in

ns and ope

anging envi

ols are nee

e (complim

ame time i

vide a way

t tied to a s

he new me

ast and ea

more efficie

ndbook (D5

ly, training w

ose) to faci

crisis manag

and up-date

organisation

anagement.

he learner

edagogical t

n the use o

in EU conf

3 months a

to discove


s in an inc

of civilians

EU countrie

erations ha

ronment wh

eded to con

entary) trai

it diminishe

for various

specific loc

dia learning

asily. In s

nt at the sa

.3) will be d

will be arra

litate the us

gement trai

ed also afte

ns to devel

. The appli

centred act

theory of co

of already e

flict preven

and it has 1

er new solu

S


creasingly c

s as has b

es. At the s

ave becom

hile develop

nduct trainin

ning is eLe

es risks rel

s missions

ation, time

g based app

hort, eLear

me time.

developed a

nged for tra

se of the IEC

ning, semin

r the projec

op further t

cation can

tive learnin

onstructivism

existing info

tion (IECEU

11 participa

utions for re


Duration:


complex en

been demon

ame time, t

me riskier f

ping its futu

ng in a mo

earning. It c

lated to sim

to store a

or residen

plications (

rning offers

and distribu

ainers (Duri

CEU learni

nars and wo

ct has been

their trainin

be used a

ng methodo

m which in s

ormation, on

U) Project l

ants from 7

esponding t

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


8

nvironment.

nstrated by

the working

for the EU

ure training.

ore efficient

can provide

mulation of

nd transfer

tial training

NMLA) can

s a tool to

ted on how

ng task 5.4

ng platform

orkshops.

completed

ng activities

as a part of

logy the e-

short states

n personnel

aunched in

7 European

to eventual

U

5 s

r t

8

.

y

g

U

.

t

e

f

r

g

n

o

w

4

m

d

s

f

-

s

l

n

n

l


Thgrares

threats and

funding the

order to de

The projec

case study

Balkans, A

can provid

and evalu

solutions.

different a

recommen

project are

1) Analysin

identify effe

2) Learning

3) Providin

stability

In the field

in the oper

and dialog

recommen

is necessa

making su

objectives

1.2 OBJE

The main g

the IECEU

subsequen

design and



d difficulties

e project. IE

etermine the

ct analyses

y areas, wh

Africa, and

e better an

ations the

In order to a

actors in

ndations for

e:

ng and asse

ectiveness

g from lesso

ng new solu

of conflict p

rational and

gue facilita

ndations and

ary througho

re that resu

for dissemi

ECT AND

goal of the

U Learning

nt findings

d developm

elopment


ny use that may

s. EU Fram

ECEU proje

e best pract

and evalua

ere Commo

Middle Eas

nswers to cr

project wil

achieve the

the opera

r EU to gua

essing the c

of EU exter

ons provide

tions, appro

prevention

d political co

ation. In o

d solutions,

out the proje

ults are tak

nation.

PURPOSE

deliverable

Applicatio

of the com

ent process


mework Pro

ect aims to

tices for res

ates the mis

on Security

st/Asia. Suc

reating mor

l identify th

e set goals

ational and

arantee the

current situa

rnal actions

ed by these

oaches and

and crisis m

ontexts ma

order to s

, commitme

ect impleme

en up by k

E

is to prese

on designed

parative an

s of the IEC

Public


gramme fo

gather diffe

solving futur

ssions’ and

and Defen

ch compreh

re effective

he best pr

IECEU proj

d political

long-term

ation of on-g

s and the im

missions a

d recommen

managemen

y require e

support the

ent of key e

entation. Co

key decision

nt and disc

d to exhib

nalysis of th

CEU Learnin


r Research

erent organi

re threats.

d operations

ce Policy (C

hensive ana

missions a

actices and

ject aims to

context.

stability. Th

going and p

mpact

nd operatio

ndations for

nt the coope

ffective solu

e impleme

end user gro

ontributing t

n-makers to

uss the dev

it the eigh

hese case

ng Applicati

S


h and Innov

sations to w

s’ effectiven

CSDP) activ

alysis of cu

nd operatio

d develop

o strengthen

The projec

he three m

past mission

ons

EU to guar

eration amo

utions in ter

ntation of

oups (espe

to solving so

o influence

velopment p

t IECEU c

studies. Th

on. This pro


Duration:


vation Horiz

work in co-o

ness in thre

vities are re

urrent exter

ons. Throug

new appro

n cooperatio

ct looks

main goals o

ns and oper

rantee long

ong the diffe

rms of com

the IECE

ecially in po

ocietal chal

policy-maki

process and

case studie

he D5.2 de

ocess cons

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


9

zon 2020 is

operation in

ee selected,

epresented:

rnal actions

gh analyses

oaches and

on between

to provide

of IECEU –

rations: to

-term

erent actors

mmunication

EU results,

litical level)

llenges and

ing are key

d content of

es and the

scribes the

sisted of the

U

5 s

r t

9

s

n

,

:

s

s

d

n

e

–

s

n

,

)

d

y

f

e

e

e


Thgrares

following fo

actual platf

1.3 STRU

After the

pedagogic

description

including t

eLearning

visualisatio

conclusion

covered by



our phases

form, 3) tes

UCTURE O

introductor

al concept

n of the bac

the use of

platform.

ons/animatio

n chapter, t

y the preced

elopment


ny use that may

s: 1) the req

sting, 4) imp

OF THE DE

ry chapter,

s of the e

ckground an

eLearning

It defines

ons (the 13

the chapter

ding chapte


quirements

plementing a

ELIVERAB

chapter tw

e-learning a

nd a short o

. The chap

the targe

3 develope

r four, will

ers.

Public


and specifi

and piloting

BLE

two will firs

and gamific

overview of

pter three d

et group a

ed animatio

summarise


ication anal

g the progra

st discuss

cation. The

current cris

describes t

and gives

ons are liste

e the proce

S


lysis, 2) to

mme.

some und

en, the cha

is managem

the develop

an accoun

ed in the A

ess and dis


Duration:


develop an

derlying the

apter two

ment trainin

pment proc

nt of the

Annex 3).

scuss sele

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


10

nd code the

eories and

provides a

ng practices

cess of the

developed

Finally, the

cted topics

U

5 s

r t

0

e

d

a

s

e

d

e

s


Thgrares

2 NMLA

This chapt

online lear

factual and

to crisis m

training rel

described

briefly disc

2.1 WHY

NMLA crea

from the IE

to different

based med

an overarc

laptop, tab

as social m

communica

augmented

ICT tools

European

developme

entirely ov

anytime, it

possible a

learning in

1 “Tools that Pekka, 2008,2 Sevillano-GTechnology &3 Eimeren, V4 Moore, M. G



– BACKG

ter will first

rning formin

d pedagogic

managemen

lated to civ

in more de

cuss how th

NEW MED

ates an ide

ECEU case

tiate betwe

dia. The IE

ching name

blet and mo

media and H

ate and p

d reality, mu

and resou

countries

ent on the

er the Inter

t has becom

and the ma

ncludes diffe

people use to, Sosiaalisen m

García, M. L., & Society, 18 ., & Frees, ErgG., Backgroun

elopment


ny use that may

GROUND

t briefly pre

ng the intelle

cal reasonin

nt training.

vilian crisis

etail in D8.5

e NMLA ca

DIA BASE

eal tool for t

studies. W

een old med

CEU projec

e for the co

bile phones

HTML5. Th

rovide feed

ultimedia an

rces have

especially

field of edu

rnet. With it

me popular

aterial was

erent sets o

o share contenmedian käsitte& Vázquez-C

(1), E. 2015, 1gebnise der And and overvie


D

esent the r

ectual basis

ng on the to

After that,

and to milit

5 Integration

n contribute

ED LEARN

the aim of p

hat is consi

dia (print p

ct uses term

ontent availa

s. The learn

ese conten

dback 1 . E

nd various l

significant

tablets a

ucation3. In

s potential

worldwide.

able to de

of learning

nt and to interaeestä. Cano,. The Im106–118.

ARD/ZDF Onlinew of contemp

Public


reader with

s for the dev

opic discus

the chapte

tary crisis m

n with other

e to the CS

NING APP

providing th

idered as N

press, TV, r

m New Med

able on inte

ning conten

nts often inc

Examples o

earning pla

influence

nd smartp

practice, t

for providin

The comp

eliver both

application

act, and the pr

mpact of Digi

ne Studie 201porary America


selected c

veloped pla

ssing how a

er will desc

managemen

r relevant tr

DP training

LICATION

he catalogu

NMLA? The

radio) and t

dia Based L

ernet throug

nt is also su

clude intera

of new me

atforms.

on teachin

hones are

the online l

ng flexible a

puters have

print and

ns, web res

rocess that thi

tal Mobile De

2. Media Persan distance ed

S


concepts an

atform. The

nd why eLe

cribe curren

nt (the exist

rainings). F

.

N (NMLA)?

e of best p

term new m

the new inf

Learning Ap

gh digital d

pported by

ctive eleme

edia include

g and lear

considere

earning tak

access to co

made the

electronical

ources, we

s interaction c

evices in High

spektiven, 7(8)ducation, 1990


Duration:


nd theories

chapter pro

earning can

nt crisis m

ting training

Finally, the c

?

practices an

media has b

formation te

pplication (

devices incl

the new m

ents and po

e websites

rning proce

ed as an

kes place p

ontent anyw

delivery of

l media.4 T

eb-based ap

creates.”, Erkk

her Education

), B. 2012, 360.

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


11

s related to

ovides both

n contribute

anagement

g has been

chapter will

nd findings

been used

echnology

NMLA) as

uding PC,

media such

ossibility to

s, games,

esses2. In

important

partially or

where and

education

The online

pplications

kola, Jussi-

n, Educational

0-372.

U

5 s

r t

o

h

e

t

n

l

l


Thgrares

and new c

learning ac

Changing

Improved

environme

communitie

previously

new digita

mainly sho

century, th

When the c

classroom

application

practice-ba

the learnin

based sol

concentrat

the curren

Behavioris

for the qu

backgroun

5 Means, et Learning Stu6 Zhang, D., of the ACM, 47 Gaebel, M.October-Dec8 Anderson, T9 Marsick, V.89, Spring 2010 Leinonen, 11 Kolb, D., EHall, 1984. 12 Mezirow, J13 Poikela, EValtonen, Pä14 Ibid.



collaboration

ctivities are

landscape

access to

ents and on

es social

taken place

al technolog

ow perceive

he online le

classroom b

based or s

ns in more

ased design

ng can hap

ving 13 . Th

ted in behav

nt online ed

sm answers

uestion “w

d in online

al., Evaluatiodies, 2009. AvZhao, J. L., Z45 (5), 2004, 7. & al., E-lear

cember 2013, 2T. Elloumi, F.,, & Watkins,

001, Jossey-BT., Designing

Experiential Le

J., A Critical Thsa & Poikela,

äivi (ed.). Kriitti

elopment


ny use that may

n technolog

increasing.

e of educat

and abilit

nline learnin

media plat

e in the corr

gies enable

ed benefits

earning has

based learn

structured a

based on

n research

ppen throug

he theory

viorism, cog

ducation to

s for the qu

why”. 14 The

e learning

n of Evidencevailable at: ww

Zhou, L., & Nu75-79. rning in Europ2014. Theory and PK., Informal a

Bass, A PublishLearning Too

earning: exper

heory of Adult, Sari, Kriittisyisyyteen kasv


gies. Moreo

.5

tion

y to use

ng. As a re

forms prov

ridors, class

e the e-lea

s of e-learn

been desc

ning is more

and the lea

the inform

when deve

gh own exp

background

gnitive and

ools and en

estion “wha

e researche

technology

e-Based Pracww.ed.gov/abonamaker, Jr.,

pean higher e

Practice of Onand Incidental hing Unit of Jo

ols. Methodolorience as the s

t Learning andyys ja ongelmvu korkeakoulu

Public


over, new ty

the interne

esult, the e

vides envir

srooms and

arning distr

ning in Eur

cribed as co

e structured

rning is in

mal learning

eloping lear

periences11,

d for onlin

constructiv

nvironments

at”, cognitiv

ers have

y. The tech

ctices in Onlinout/offices/list/J. F., Can e-l

education ins

nline Learning,Learning, Ne

ohn Wiley & Sogical Insightssource of lear

d Education. Jmaperustainen uopetuksessa.


ype of hybr

et have inc

educational

onment for

d after-scho

ribution wo

ropean cou

omplex, div

d and forma

the hands

g theories.

rning tools1

through c

e learning

vism learnin

s are deve

ve for the qu

raised the

hnology ha

ne Learning: /opepd/ppss/rlearning replac

stitutions. Res

2004. ew Directions Sons, Inc, 2001, Aalto Univerrning and deve

ournal of Aduoppiminen. T

. Tampere: TA

S


rid approac

creased int

landscape

r the learn

ol telephon

rldwide 6 . M

ntries7. In

verse, and

l, informal le

of the learn

There is a0. Based o

ritical reflec

environme

ng theories.

loped base

uestion “ho

criticism

as re-organ

A Meta-Analyeports.html ce classroom

sults of a map

for Adult And1. sity, 2010. elopment, Eng

lt Education 3Teoksessa JärAJU, 1999.


Duration:


ches regard

terest towa

is shifting.

ning that w

nes convers

Moreover, t

the beginn

rapidly evo

earning is n

ner9. Learni

a need for

on the earlie

ction12 and

ent develo

Furthermo

ed on thes

ow” and con

regarding

nized the h

ysis and Rev

learning? Co

pping survey

d Continuing E

glewood Cliffs

32 (1), 3-24, 19rvinen-Tauber

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


12

ing online

ards online

In today’s

would have

ations. The

the studies

ning of 21st

olving field.8

not typically

ing through

r academic

er theories,

in problem

pment has

ore, most of

se theories.

nstructivism

the theory

human life,

iew of Online

mmunications

conducted in

Education, no.

s, NJ: Prentice

981. rt, Johanna &

U

5 s

r t

2

e

s

e

e

s t 8

y

h

c

,

m

s

f

.

m

y

,

e

s

n

.

e

&


Thgrares

communica

practices

environme

active lear

theoretical

have raise

technology

Online trai

online lear

into guide

training an

the term “b

and teache

Moreover,

The learne

classroom

classroom

learning ex

show to en

The NMLA

education

simulation

maintain it

15 Siemens, G16 Hakkaraineeducational p17 Hakkaraineeducational p18 Siemens, G19 University 20 Marsick, V89, Jossey-B21 Carlson, Sand/or conflic22 Santonen &



ation and le

in online l

ents are dev

ners who c

insights h

ed the critic

y has re-org

ning enviro

rning enviro

d e-learnin

nd e-learning

blended lea

ers do not s

the e-learn

ers are not

based lea

based or s

xperiences

nable positiv

A is linked w

and enterta

games.22 T

t by engagin

G. 2004, Connen, K., Palonperspectives. Aen, K., Palonperspectives. AG., Connectiviof Helsinki, D

V., & Watkins, Bass, A PublisS., Using Techct, Final Repo& Faber 2015

elopment


ny use that may

earning.15 In

earning 16 .

veloped bas

onstruct the

ave raised

cism regar

ganized the

nments pro

onment can

ng, self-stud

g are comb

rning”19. E-

see each ot

ning is highl

required to

arning is m

structured a

provided b

ve learning

with the co

ainment. Ed

The underly

ng emotion

nectivism: A leen, T., PaavoAdvances in Len, T., PaavoAdvances in Lism: A learninepartment of CK., Informal a

hing Unit of Johnology to delirt, JBS Interna.


n 21 centur

Furthermo

sed on thes

eir knowled

the collabo

ding the th

human life,

ovide a varie

be utilized

dy online l

ined. The n

learning ca

her, also lea

y appreciat

o travel or

more struc

and the lear

by education

experience

oncept of ed

dutainment

ying princip

s and gene

earning theoryola, S. & LehLearning and Iola, S. & LehLearning and Ig theory for DComputer Scieand Incidentalohn Wiley & Siver educationational, 2013,

Public


ry the theor

ore, most o

se theories.

ge rather th

orative prac

heory back

, communic

ety of oppo

in many dif

learning an

new termino

an be implem

arners may

ted worldwi

use other c

ctured and

rning is in t

n technolog

es and impro

dutainment

often consi

pal of eduta

erating feeli

y for Digital Aghtinen, E., CoInstruction Sehtinen, E., CoInstruction Se

Digital Age, 200ence. l Learning. Ne

Sons, Inc., 200nal services to30.


retical insig

of the curr

According

han reprodu

ctices in on

ground in

cation and le

ortunities: te

fferent ways

nd multiform

ology of mu

mented as d

y be geogra

de because

costs to ha

formal, in

the hands o

gy and appl

ove learning

which can

ist of intera

ainment is

ngs of plea

ge, 2004. ommunities ofries, Amsterda

ommunities ofries. Amsterda04.

ew Directions 01. o children and

S


hts have ra

rent online

to construc

uce set of fa

nline learni

online lear

earning.18

aching can

s. Online te

m learning,

ltiform teac

distance lea

phically dist

e of its cost

ave access

formal lea

of the learn

lied in appr

g outcomes

be defined

ctive techno

to catch le

asure during

f networked eam, Elsevier, 2f networked eam: Elsevier, 2

for Adult And

youth in envi


Duration:


aised the co

education

ctivism, indi

acts. In 21

ng.17 The r

rning techn

n be organiz

eaching can

, in which

hing has be

arning, whe

tant from o

t-effective p

to training.

rning is no

ner20. Furthe

ropriate way

s21.

d as a com

ologies suc

earners’ att

g the learni

expertise: Pro2004.

expertise: Pro2004.

d Continuing E

ironments affe

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


13

ollaborative

tools and

ividuals are

century the

researchers

ology. The

zed and the

n be divided

classroom

egun to use

ere learners

ne another.

possibilities.

. When the

ot typically

ermore, the

y has been

mbination of

ch as digital

tention and

ng process

fessional and

fessional and

Education, no.

ected by crisis

U

5 s

r t

3

e

d

e

e

s

e

e

d

m

e

s

.

.

e

y

e

n

f

l

d

s

d

d

.

s


Thgrares

with the h

modules. I

What was

learning. T

elements o

reduce com

simplifying

can be int

during the

complimen

interactive

with pedag

on the use

Figure 1 Th

23 There is nonumerous exgames and pDixon, D., Khpaper for Min24 Malone, Th25 See, e.g., University Pr



help of gam

nitially, the

the rationa

The games

of curiosity,

mplexity of

social cons

tegrated int

e deployme

ntary tool to

manner. T

gogical theo

e of already

he framewor

o commonly axisting concepplayful designhaled, R. andndTrek’11, Sehomas, W., ToDewey, John,ress, 1990 and

elopment


ny use that may

ming. The p

idea was to

ale for gami

s can be e

fantasy an

phenomen

struct of rea

to crisis m

ent of the

o ensure th

The individu

ory of cons

existing info

rk of NMLA

agreed definitiopts and resea

n. Gamificationd Nacke, L., Fptember 28-30oward a theory Experience &d Piaget, Jean


platform inc

o include ga

ification23? A

ngaging if

d control ov

a and bring

ality to bring

anagement

staff. An

hat the tra

ally centred

tructivism25

ormation, o

on on term ‘gaarch on humn stands for uFrom Game D0 2011, Tampy of intrinsical

& Education, Nn, The Psycho

Public


cludes anim

amified elem

According t

they are g

ver certain t

g it to a com

g it to more

t training d

application

inees have

d active lea5 which in s

on personne

amification’. San-computer use of game d

Design Elemenpere, Finland. lly motivating iNew York, 193ology of the Ch


mations an

ments into th

to Malone24

genuinely m

tasks. A ga

mprehensiv

e operationa

diverse orga

with gam

e acquired

arning meth

short states

el ideas and

Scholars point interaction andesign elements to Gamefu

instruction. Co38/1998; Brunehild, 1972.

S


d interactiv

he catalogu

4, games ar

motivating,

mification c

ve level (like

al level). Ele

anisations a

ification fea

the necess

hodology NM

that individ

d experience

out that gamind game studnts in non-gaulness: Definin

ognitive sciencer, Jerome, Ac


Duration:


ve quiz at

ue.

re beneficia

challenging

can offer als

e societal th

ements of g

are providi

atures will

sary knowle

MLA is utili

dual learnin

es.

ification simplydies including

ame context. Ding “Gamificat

ce, 5(4), 1981cts of Meaning

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


14

the end of

al for active

g and offer

so a way to

heories are

gamification

ng prior or

provide a

edge in an

zing in line

ng is based

y summarisesg, i.e. seriousDeterding, S.,tion”, Seminar

, 333-369. g, Harvard

U

5 s

r t

4

f

e

r

o

e

n

r

a

n

e

d

s s , r


Thgrares

NMLA can

course of v

of edutain

developed

it is vital th

ensure the

the local e

often cost

which is ex

safe mann

areas. Gam

describing

The object

tool: New

lessons lea

the New M

different in

use of mo

decreased

provide a

items not d

learning to

The IECEU

audience o

and plann

various tra

enabling

thresholds

26 Santonen 27 Friedrich, University of



n help motiv

various trai

ment is stil

to systema

hat the desig

e high quali

environment

efficient co

xpensive in

ner. The sc

mification c

certain com

tive for the

Media bas

arned fast w

Media techn

nternational

odern techn

financial r

compliment

directly relat

ools, applica

U NMLA wi

on themes

ing. This a

aining, “digi

more cons

.”27

& Faber 2015

Pirjo, Web-baTampere, 201

elopment


ny use that may

vating learn

ning crisis m

ll new and

atically asse

gn of the N

ity and app

t and upda

ompared wi

n the longer

cenarios ca

can also of

mplex hot sp

WP5 state

sed Learnin

with open d

nologies and

actors of c

nology for t

resources a

tary tool for

ted to life sa

ations and E

ill offer a co

related to s

also becaus

ital tools do

stant inter

5. ased co-design13.


ers and as

manageme

rather und

ess the effic

MLA encom

licability of

ted easily t

th conventi

r term. Gam

n also be

ffer a way t

pot where t

es that Lear

g Applicatio

data access

d game env

crisis manag

raining pur

and, on the

r training th

aving skills

ELearning.

omplimenta

selected cas

se in spite

o not subs

action with

n. Social medi

Public


a result fac

nt training.

developed.

ciency of div

mpasses al

the produc

to keep it a

ional trainin

mification al

relatively e

to preserve

he internati

rning from t

on (NMLA)

s for the bro

vironments

gement trai

rposes. The

other hand

hat enhance

are seen a

ary tool to e

se studies a

of the pre

titute face-

h users a

ia tools to enh


cilitate reac

In terms of

In fact, no

verse eduta

l the inputs

ct. The NML

accurate in

ng which inv

so enables

easily updat

e some of t

onal staff is

the lessons

), which wil

oad audien

in conflict

ning there

e reasons c

d, on belief

es current m

s elements

enhance the

and EU cris

esented be

to-face me

and loweri

hance user-cen

S


hing better

f theoretica

solid theor

ainment app

from the di

LA can also

fast changi

volves a lot

creating hi

ted to refle

the institutio

s working).

s through th

l provide th

ce, and at

prevention.

is a commo

can be rela

f that new

methods. E

that could b

e knowledge

sis manage

enefits e-lea

thods, but

ng certain

ntered design


Duration:


learning re

l framework

ries have s

plications.26

iverse shar

o be tailore

ing field. Th

t of plannin

igh risk sce

ect the vola

onal memo

he develope

he best pra

the same t

. It seems t

on interest

ated, on on

learning m

Especially th

be delivered

e of a broa

ement decis

arning can

compleme

n users’ p

n and innovatio

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


15

esults in the

ks, the field

so far been6 Therefore,

reholders to

ed to reflect

he game is

ng, logistics

enarios in a

atile conflict

ory (e.g. by

ed learning

actices and

time testing

that among

to increase

ne hand, to

ethods can

he curricula

d via online

ad end-user

sion making

provide to

nt them by

participation

on process,

U

5 s

r t

5

e

d

n

,

o

t

s

s

a

t

y

g

d

g

g

e

o

n

a

e

r

g

o

y

n


Thgrares

2.2. REVI

Even thoug

is receivin

presents a

mission ar

learning. T

in civilian c

The limited

now eLear

deploymen

detail. The

of concept

able to exh

focus. The

and theref

that curre

missions a

key functio

organisatio

The main c

trainees as

financial im

mission tra

seconded,

classified i

when it com

28 For instan29 Jochen, R



IEW OF E

gh the main

ng increase

a perfect to

rea. Low ru

This chapter

crisis as we

d informatio

rning and N

nt training. T

e questions

tual framew

haust their

e questions

fore were n

ntly, there

and operatio

onaries (su

ons).

challenges

s well as th

mplications

aining. Fur

locals), the

nformation

mes to eLea

ce, by the cas

Rehrl, and Taitt

elopment


ny use that may

LEARNIN

n effort of C

ed attention

ool to educ

unning cos

r will discus

ll as military

on received

NMLA have

The idea as

with regard

work. Howev

entire ques

related to N

not fully cov

is no sys

ons. The fin

uch as ESD

of eLearnin

he co-ordin

of training

rthermore, t

e different p

in eLearnin

arning.29

se study repor

to, Petteri, Pr


G AND O

CSDP trainin

n. E-learnin

cate and tra

ts compare

ss and pres

y crisis man

d from the i

e been not

s such was

d to current

ver, the rese

stionnaires a

NMLA have

vered. How

stematic ap

nding was fu

DC civil se

ng include th

ation betwe

and time

the various

personal sec

ng modules

rt on EUPOL A

re-deployment

Public


NLINE LE

ngs still relie

g is indepe

ain newly s

ed to reside

sent how eL

nagement tr

nterviewee

t been broa

welcomed2

eLearning

earchers w

and they ha

very likely

wever, the s

pproach to

urther teste

rvants and

he content

een Headq

constraints

legal statu

curity perm

and sensiti

Afghanistan.

t eLearning fo


EARNING

es on reside

endent of t

selected sta

ential cours

Learning ele

raining.

s corrobora

adly and s28, but no fu

practices w

who conduct

ad to make

not been co

survey corro

implement

d (triangula

training of

of the eLea

uarters and

s, their role

uses of the

issions and

ive informat

or CSDP missi

S


IN CSDP T

ential cours

time and lo

aff before t

ses are als

ements hav

ated the as

ystematical

urther inform

were discuss

ted the rela

a judgeme

onsidered p

oborated th

t eLearning

ation) in disc

fficers with

arning modu

d Mission re

e cannot be

deployed p

d the learnin

tion accepte

ons/operation


Duration:


TRAINING

ses, the eLe

ocation and

their deploy

so in favou

ve been cur

sumption th

lly utilized

mation was

sed during

ated researc

ent call prior

priorities for

he desk stu

g activities

cussions wi

in the ENT

ules, the no

esponsibilit

e neglected

personnel (

ng content,

ed, can rais

ns, 2015.

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


16

G

earning part

d therefore

yment to a

ur of online

rrently used

hat up until

in the pre-

provided in

co-creation

ch were not

ritizing their

r the project

dy findings

within the

ith selected

TRi training

omination of

ties. As per

d in the in-

(contracted,

such as no

se concerns

U

5 s

r t

6

t

e

a

e

d

l

-

n

n

t

r

t

s

e

d

g

f

r

-

,

o

s


Thgrares

Training ca

While bas

internation

in a partic

therefore c

to deploym

to harmon

tasked to c

mission im

administra

communica

All mission

deploymen

staff and th

very limited

hence the

specific tra

specificitie

Mission, P

recruited f

Framework

mission/op

Participatio

locations, a

30 Previously(eHEST). Cobeen replacEnvironments31 For examcommon foumission perschapter 3.4.432 The agreethe CMPD hhttp://eeas.eu



an be categ

ic trainings

al crisis ma

cular field to

complemen

ment to ensu

ise the ma

complete on

mmediately

tive proced

ation proce

n trainings

nt trainings.

heir deploym

d.31 The rot

number of

aining need

s. Sometim

Press and P

from all EU

k Participat

peration (In

on Agreeme

and ideally

y, the personnompleting the ced by EEASs (SAFE), avaple, the perso

undation of prsonnel has a s4. ements providhas signed ovuropa.eu/csdp

elopment


ny use that may

gorised as

s provide p

anagement

o understan

ts basic tra

ure that per

nagement

nline hostile

y after de

dures when

dures for al

have nume

. Pre-deplo

ment, which

tation phase

f people to

ds and req

mes the tra

Public Inform

U member

tion Agreem

n most ca

ents (FPA).

in the miss

nel deployed t

course took S developed ailable at httpsons interviewere-deploymentsolid understa

e a legal basiver dozen of Fp/structures-in


basic, adva

participants

mission, a

nd how to

aining. Pre-d

rsonnel are

culture. Du

e environme

eployment

n joining th

ll mission m

erous challe

oyment train

h is genera

es between

o be trained

uirements;

aining must

mation Offic

states as w

ment with th

ases this p32 The train

ion languag

o the CSDP msome five hoBasic Aware

s://webgate.eced while condt training cananding of the

s to the particFPAs. Recentstruments-age

Public


anced or s

with the b

advanced or

use their e

deployment

equipped w

uring this ph

ent training

aiming to

he mission

members.

enges to ov

nings have

lly very sho

n the variou

d can vary

therefore,

t even be

cer). Anothe

well as fro

he EU and

partnership

ning must th

ge. With the

missions had ours and requeness in Sec.europa.eu/eeducting the c

n enhance mioperational e

cipations and t examples inencies/cmpd/i


pecialisatio

basic know

r specialisa

expertise in

t trainings a

with the nec

hase many

(eHEST).30

o further f

as well as

vercome, e

the time b

ort, therefore

us missions

a lot. Eac

each train

tailored to

er challenge

m non-EU

d have been

p is based

herefore be

ese challeng

to complete oired well-funccurity (BASEeas/security-ease study onssion effectiv

environment a

contributions nclude Colombndex_en.htm

S


on, pre-depl

ledge and

ation training

n crisis area

are perform

cessary kno

seconded 0 Induction

familiarise

s with the

specially w

between the

e the time a

/operations

h mission/o

ing course

o personal

e is also mis

states whi

n invited to

d on the

conducted

ges in mind

online based hctioning interne) and Secur-learnings/ Central Africeness and cond code of co

in/to missionsbia, Bosnia H


Duration:


loyment or

skills requ

g enables p

as. Advanc

med (immed

owledge an

personnel

training is g

personnel

security as

when we co

e selection

available fo

s are not sy

operation h

must adap

needs (e.g

ssion staff t

ch have co

o send pers

so-called

at differen

d, eLearning

hostile environet connectionrity Awarenes

can Republic oherence by onduct., IECE

s and operatioHerzegovina a

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


17

in-mission.

ired for an

participants

ced training

iately) prior

d skills and

have been

given in the

with the

spects and

onsider pre-

of mission

r training is

ynchronised

has its own

pt to these

g. Head of

that can be

oncluded a

sonnel to a

Framework

t times and

g is an ideal

nment trainingn. eHEST hasss in Fragile

stated that aensuring that

EU D3.3 CAR,

ons. Currently,and Australia.,

U

5 s

r t

7

.

n

s

g

r

d

n

e

e

d

-

n

s

d

n

e

f

e

a

a

k

d

l

g s e

a t ,

, ,


Thgrares

way to pro

deploymen

information

deploymen

authorities

their perso

responsibil

Although s

of mission

partners w

Germany,

course av

challenge.

to be mad

extensive

training po

implement

providers a

national au

providers o

name a few

their civilia

seems to b

mission (e

states do

deployed p

officers’ sh

of institutio

with requir

33 Rehrl & Ta34 “IECEU R35 Interviews



ovide pre-d

nt phase is

n and team

nt training

and CSDP

onnel for di

lities.33

some EU m

n personne

who have sp

ENTRi, ES

ailable with

In this sen

de available

research to

olicy in CSD

ed by mem

and project

uthorities, y

on a nation

w. It is muc

an (apart fro

be quite low

e.g. Althea)

not send

personnel a

hort duration

onal memor

red expertis

aitto 2015

Roundtable dis

s in WP2 (Balk

elopment


ny use that may

deployment

not a subs

m-building.

is part of t

P missions

ifficult work

member stat

l related to

pecifically d

SDC, etc.),

hin an app

se the eLea

e to EU m

o assure t

DP, existing

mber states'

ts. For civil

yet only a h

nal level for

ch more diff

om police)

w on the ag

) are some

their best

are also no

n of tours, u

ry, continuity

se combine

cussion of exp

kans) no. 24, n


t training fo

stitute for re

From a le

the employ

(for contrac

king conditio

es have ad

o training,

developed t

rather than

propriate tim

arning cour

ember stat

he overview

since 2003

training pro

lian side, th

handful of c

r civilian pe

ficult to dete

personnel

genda of so

etimes actua

personnel

ot qualified f

usually six

y and gener

ed with freq

perts,” May 24

no. 25, no. 14,

Public


or mission

esidential c

egal point o

yer’s duty o

cted person

ons so that

dopted lega

they are u

their trainin

developing

meframe fo

rses and NM

tes for thei

w of existin

3, which is

oviders on a

he training

countries in

ersonnel, e.

ermine if an

prior to the

ome of the

ally perceiv

to serve in

for the wor

months or

ral effective

quent rotatio

4, 2016, Jable

, no. 15, and n


staff. Neve

ourses, par

of view, an

of care tow

nnel) are th

t they are

l framework

using trainin

g centres (

g an autono

or the miss

MLA or sim

r own use

ng eLearni

being revis

a national b

for police

n EU has a

g. Finland,

nd how the

eir deploym

member sta

ved as a t

n missions.

rk they are

even less i

eness of the

ons is perc

e Castle, Slove

no. 21.

S


ertheless, e

rticularly wi

nd in more

wards its e

erefore res

aware of th

k regarding

ng expertis

e.g. Finland

omous capa

sion person

ilar e-tools

. However,

ng platform

ed for the la

basis or thro

and military

an establish

Sweden, G

other mem

ment. Since

ates, secon

raining opp34 Critics s

sent to do

s a significa

e operation.

ceived to be

enia


Duration:


eLearning

th regard to

e general t

employees.

sponsible fo

heir rights,

rights and

se of other

d, Sweden

acity. To fin

nnel often

play an imp

it would d

ms in CSDP

ast couple

ough EU-le

ry is provid

hed system

Germany, D

mber states a

the CSDP

ndments to

portunity an

say that a

.35 Moreove

ant challeng

The lack o

e the majo

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


18

in the pre-

o classified

terms, pre-

Seconding

or preparing

duties and

obligations

r European

, Austria or

nd the right

presents a

portant role

demand an

P. The EU

of years, is

evel training

ed by their

of training

Denmark to

are training

in general

the military

nd member

number of

er, the staff

ge in terms

f personnel

r challenge

U

5 s

r t

8

-

d

-

g

g

d

s

n

r

t

a

e

n

U

s

g

r

g

o

g

l

y

r

f

f

s

l

e


Thgrares

reducing th

at its best

skills to do

deploymen

tasks.36 Th

work actua

and autho

overall ref

capacity b

capacity.

2.2.1 CIV

The existin

Training In

EU Police

platforms a

training pro

specialisat

toolbox in

manageme

more effec

The Europ

organised

the EU de

security cu

activities in

36 “IECEU Ro37 Joint ActioJournal of the



he effective

only two m

o the job. To

nt training is

his view is

ally involves

rities as m

form proces

uilding and

VILIAN CR

ng platforms

nitiative for

Services

already pro

oviders offe

tion training

their induc

ent of traini

ctive in mee

pean Secu

as a netwo

ealing with

ulture, prom

n the field o

oundtable disc

on 2008/550/Ce European U

elopment


ny use that may

eness of the

months are

oo often gen

s perceived

striking tak

s training as

ilitary and p

ss in all be

training ta

RISIS MAN

s such as th

Civilian Cris

Training (E

viding pre-d

ering pre-de

gs, which inc

ction trainin

ing increas

eting identifie

rity and D

ork of the i

security an

mote better u

f CSDP at t

cussion of exp

CFSP of 23 Junion, L176, 20


e missions

actually ef

neralists are

d by the cri

king into co

s means of

police. Sec

eneficiary c

sks, aiming

NAGEMEN

he Europea

sis Manage

EUPST) are

deployment

eployment,

clude subje

ngs and all

es pro-activ

ed training

efence Co

nstitutes, c

d defence p

understand

the strategic

perts,” May 24

une 2008 esta0-21.

Public


significantly

ffective if th

e deployed

tics to be i

onsideration

conveying

curity sector

countries w

g to contrib

NT

n Security a

ement (ENT

e all releva

t training. IE

CSDP orie

ect on CSDP

l will benef

ve planning

needs.

llege (ESD

colleges, ac

policy. Its o

ing of the C

c level.37

, 2016, Jable

ablishing a Eur


y. Out of a

he staff pos

when spec

nsufficient t

that the a

‘European b

r reform is

with EU eng

ute to stren

and Defenc

TRi), Europe

ant. The E

ECEU traini

entation trai

P. Also the

fit from the

g and coord

DC) has be

cademies, u

objective is

CSDP by or

Castle, Slove

ropean Securi

S


six-month r

ssess the re

cialists were

to prepare

a great shar

best practic

namely an

gagement t

ngthening o

ce College (

ean Police

U should a

ing toolbox

nings or co

missions w

e training e

dination of

een establis

universities

to further e

rganizing an

nia. ity and Defenc


Duration:


rotation in m

required exp

e needed, a

the individu

re of CSDP

ces’ to recip

n important

through non

of local own

(ESDC), Eu

College (C

also draw

will mostly

ore courses

will be able to

evaluation s

activities, s

shed in 20

and institut

enhance the

nd conduct

ce College (E

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


19

most cases

pertise and

and the pre-

uals for the

P missions’

pient bodies

part of the

n-executive

nership and

rope's New

EPOL) and

on existing

benefit the

s as well as

o utilise the

set. Shared

so as to be

005 and is

tions within

e European

ting training

SDC), Official

U

5 s

r t

9

s

d

-

e

’

s

e

e

d

w

d

g

e

s

e

d

e

s

n

n

g

l


Thgrares

European

mission tra

"install and

training ac

2008. With

the first eL

Manageme

the ESDC

missions.

Again sinc

Presidenci

autonomou

institutions

military exe

The ESDC

running on

expert is

deploymen

In 2001 the

Manageme

on Training

and non-go

activities. W

Initiative fo

pre-deploy

ENTRi III w

38 The eLear39 Autonomo2016.; ESDC40 ESDC, Au41 ENTRi, av



Security an

ainings. Co

d run an Int

ctivities." Th

h the arrival

Learning un

ent (CivCom

was asked

ce 2013, the

es at the re

us knowled

s, procedure

ercises (MI

C currently

n the eLear

provided c

nt and in-mi

e European

ent to provi

g (EGT). Th

overnmenta

When ente

or Civilian C

yment traini

will in the la

rning Managem

ous KnowledgeC. utonomous kno

vailable at: htt

elopment


ny use that may

nd Defence

uncil Joint A

ernet-Base

his referenc

l of ESDC T

nits were de

m) delibera

d to provide

e ESDC ha

equest of th

dge units (A

es and the

LEX) 12 an

has 27 AK

ning Manag

cost-free. 40

ssion traini

n Commissio

ide training

his project t

al training b

ring in its l

Crisis Manag

ing as well

ast phase, u

ment System

e Units (AKUs

owledge units

tp://www.entrif


e College (

Action 2005

d Advanced

ce was repe

Training Ma

eveloped,38

tions and d

e an eLearn

as provided

he relevant

AKUs) on g

Treaty of L

nd 13 with t

KUs, consis

gement Sys

Since 201

ng.

on launched

at the ope

took the sh

bodies involv

ast phase

gement (EN

as on har

until 2019,

of the Europe

s) of the ESDC

.

forccm.eu/abo

Public


(ESDC) is a

5/575/CFSP

d Distance

eated in Co

anager Mr D

As a result

due to the c

ning course

"stand-alo

EU membe

gender, int

Lisbon. In th

tailor-made

sting of lear

stem "ILIAS

13, the ES

d a pilot pro

erational lev

ape of an i

ved in train

in 2010, it

NTRi). It foc

rmonisation

develop tra

ean Security a

C, state of affa

out/about.html


actively eng

P of July 20

Learning (I

ouncil Joint

Dan Trifane

t of Commi

conclusions

e for contra

ne" eLearn

er state. Th

ercultural c

he same ye

eTraining a

rning units

S". The cont

SDC has b

oject on trai

vel which la

nformal net

ning civilian

has been

cused essen

n and stand

aining packa

nd Defence C

airs – January

l

S


gaged in e

005 stated t

DL) System

t Action 200

escu a conc

ttee for Civ

s of the Les

act and sec

ing courses

e courses h

competence

ear, the ES

at the reque

and a conf

tent of cour

been involv

ining for Civ

ter became

twork comp

personnel f

renamed E

ntially on sp

dardisation

ages in sev

College, ESDC

2016, ESDC/


Duration:


Learning a

that the ES

m to support

08/550/CFS

ceptual fram

vilian Aspec

ssons Lear

conded staf

s for the in

have includ

es, history,

SDC started

est of CMP

firmation te

rses by sub

ved in prov

vilian Aspec

e the Europ

posed of go

for crisis m

Europe’s Ne

pecialised c

of course

veral fields,

C, 2014. /2016/009, 26

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


20

s a part of

SDC should

t the ESDC

SP’ in June

mework and

cts of Crisis

rned report,

ff for CSDP

coming EU

ded general

strategies,

d to support

PD/EUMS.39

est that are

bject matter

viding pre-

cts of Crisis

pean Group

overnmental

anagement

ew Training

courses and

curricula.41

to be used

January,

U

5 s

r t

0

f

d

C

e

d

s

,

P

U

l

,

t 9

e

r

-

s

p

l

t

g

d

d


Thgrares

by nationa

for examp

confirmed

Since 2007

EUPFT. T

policing m

European

additionally

live exercis

European

states and

for senior

officers an

by the nat

civilian pe

Foreign Af

is difficult

some, whic

Member S

another co

EU has in

crisis mana

the very w

staff to be

42 Decision a43 EUPST, a44 Council DJournal of the45 ENTRi con



al and intern

le Training

by the cons

7, the Euro

his project

missions. Af

Union Polic

y made fun

ses, modul

Police Coll

provides tr

police pers

d is free to

ional Police

rsonnel, wh

ffairs or by

to elaborat

ch are not s

States due t

ountry.

general pu

agement tra

ell-known e

e deployed

adopted at EN

vailable at: htt

ecision 2005/e European Unsortium meet

elopment


ny use that may

national trai

of Trainers

sortium yet.

opean Com

provides tr

fter the suc

ce Services

ds available

ar training

lege (CEPO

raining at th

sonnel. CEP

use.44 For

e or the Po

ho either re

some of the

te how muc

shared by th

o the limite

ut quite sig

aining in th

eLearning to

or posted i

NTRi consortiu

tp://www.eups

/681/JHA of 2nion, L 256, 6ting, 26-28 Ju


ining provid

s, will also 42

mission ha

raining at t

ccess of E

s Training -

e for EUPS

courses as

OL) is desig

he strategic

POL’s onlin

the police c

olice Academ

eceive train

e existing E

ch eLearnin

he Member

ed number o

gnificant stre

e future an

ools was the

in risk-asso

m meeting, 26

st.eu/about-us

20 September 63-70. ly 2016, Berlin

Public


ders after th

contain eL

as been fun

the operatio

EUPFT betw

EUPST l (

ST ll 2015-2

s well as ac

gned to tra

level, such

ne learning

capacities, t

my, this fie

ning by the

EU provider

ng is being

r States, tho

of personne

ess in deve

nd is financi

e e-HEST o

ociated or h

6-28 July 2016

s/ r 2005 establi

n.


he completi

Learning bu

nding The E

onal level f

ween 2008

2011-2014)

2018. The p

cademic co

ain the seni

h as strateg

platform is

training is in

ld is much

ir national

rs (ESDC, E

used by n

ough there

el, send the

eloping mo

ng them th

online cours

hostile envir

6, Berlin.

shing the Eur

S


on of the p

ut the topic

European P

or police e

8 and 2010

), the Europ

programme

onferences

or police o

ic planning

open to al

n majority c

more comp

training ins

ENTRi, othe

national aut

are some p

eir represen

re eLearnin

rough differ

se designed

ronments o

ropean Police


Duration:


project. Som

areas hav

Police Force

experts in in

0, it was r

pean Comm

comprises

and worksh

officers of th

of EU polic

l EU law e

cases offere

plicated for

stitutions, M

er different

thorities, bu

practices, w

ntatives to a

ng tools in

rent project

d by EEAS

outside the

e College (CE

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


21

me of them,

e not been

e Training -

nternational

renamed to

mission has

large-scale

hops.43 The

he member

ce missions

nforcement

ed in house

r the strictly

Ministries of

projects). It

ut there are

when certain

a training in

the field of

ts.45 One of

for Council

EU. It was

POL), Official

U

5 s

r t

,

n

-

l

o

s

e

e

r

s

t

e

y

f

t

e

n

n

f

f

l

s

l


Thgrares

revised in

Security) a

The Intern

association

education,

as method

Peace Ope

in 2013 to

coordinatio

the design

free of ch

policies, E

an EU-fund

In the las

trainings in

types of tra

project and

tools and d

and known

least partia

also locals

receiving a

ensuring s

phase will

four new s

in missions

46 EEAS, Se47 The Intern48 Folke Berntraining-netw49 EAPTC ht50 ENTRi con



2015 and

and SAFE (S

ational Ass

n of centre

and trainin

ds used in

erations Tra

o encourag

on and coop

n and provi

harge eLea

uropean Ne

ded project

t years we

n the field o

ainings and

d research

do not offer

n eLearning

al links to th

s and contra

any kind of

some releva

have a wo

tandalone e

s.

curity e-learni

national Assoc

nadotte Acadeworks/ ttp://eaptc.eu/e

nsortium meet

elopment


ny use that may

new eLea

Security Aw

ociation of

es, institutio

ng. Its objec

training fo

aining Cent

ge networki

peration, to

sion of trai

arning platfo

eighbourhoo

implemente

e could wit

of peaceke

d possible e

since the m

r them to its

g tools by

he EU. Sinc

acted staff,

training su

ant eLearni

rking group

eLearning s

ngs, https://we

ciation of Peac

emy, Educatio

en/news/view-

ting, 26-28 Ju


arning tool

wareness in

Peacekeep

ons, and p

ctive is to p

r peace op

tres (EAPTC

ng and pa

continue h

ning within

orm for the

od Policy, E

ed by the N

tness mush

eping and

eLearning to

main training

s public. T

organisatio

ce civilian m

any useful

upport befor

ing tools in

p on eLearn

sessions, wh

ebgate.ec.eur

cekeeping Tra

on and Trainin

-news-e-learn

ly 2016, Berlin

Public


was devel

Fragile Env

ping Trainin

programmes

promote bet

perations of

C) is one o

artnerships

high-quality

the sphere

e Neighbou

EU-ENP rel

Natolin Cam

hrooming o

conflict pre

ools they of

g providers

The above p

ns, joined

missions co

eLearning

re embarkin

n this field

ning, provid

hich will con

ropa.eu/eeas/s

aining Centers

ng Networks,

ing-platform-o

n.


loped, nam

vironments

g Centres (

s dealing w

tter underst

f all types.4

f the branc

with other

training an

e of peace

urhood whi

ations, and

mpus of the C

of organisat

evention. Re

ffer is far b

in Europe a

part is there

in different

onsist not o

tool would

ng on a mis

is not surp

ing overview

ntribute to b

security-e-lear

(IAPTC), http

https://fba.se/

on-enp-availab

S


mely BASE

).46

(IAPTC) is a

with peace

tanding of p47 The Euro

hes of IAPT

similar ne

d share goo

operations

ch offers s

related bes

College of E

tions, offer

esearching

eyond the p

are not awa

efore focusi

official net

nly from se

contribute t

ssion.50 The

prising; this

w of the ex

better qualif

rnings/ p://www.iaptc.o

en/how-we-wo

ble-online-052


Duration:


(Basic Aw

an open an

operations

peacekeepi

opean Asso

TC. It was e

etworks, to

od practice

s.48 EAPTC

short cours

st practices

Europe.49

ring differen

all this org

purpose of

are of those

ing on the e

tworks, whi

econded pe

to the easie

e recent EU

is why the

xisting tools

fied personn

org/

ork/courses/e

26.html

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


22

wareness in

d voluntary

s research,

ing, as well

ociation for

established

strengthen

s related to

developed

ses on EU

s, as part of

nt types of

ganisations,

the IECEU

e eLearning

established

ch have at

rsonnel but

er excess in

U’s focus in

e ENTRi III

, producing

nel, serving

ducation-and-

U

5 s

r t

2

n

y

,

l

r

d

n

o

d

U

f

f

,

U

g

d

t

t

n

n

I

g

g

-


Thgrares

The Trainin

proved tha

work cont

insufficient

also an ap

civilian mis

need to im

2.2.2 MIL

The EU tra

basis or th

adequate t

The part re

national de

crisis mana

and trainin

terms of p

same.52

In the mi

learning).

ATALANTA

confidentia

in advance

Military Sta

ESDC eLe

ESDC cou

51 http://in-co52 Panel of E53 Jochen, http://proceed



ng Impact E

at training i

ext and he

t training for

plication on

ssions are n

plement a p

LITARY CR

aining policy

hrough EU-

training, ma

eason for th

efence force

agement an

ngs that pre

protocol, pr

ilitary doma

The first

A (EUNAV

al briefings

e of the dep

aff. Both e

earning Man

urses are al

ontrol.entriforc

Experts (Minist

Rehrl anddings.elsecon

elopment


ny use that may

Evaluation,

in general

elped them

r civilians in

n CSDP lea

not using an

proper need

RISIS MAN

y in CSDP

level trainin

akes less co

his is as the

es. To enha

nd peaceke

esent a part

rocedures a

ain, eLear

eLearning

VFOR SOM

were includ

ployment to

Learning co

nagement S

so made av

ccm.eu/. try of Foreign

Taitto, Peference.eu/ind


performed

shortened t

m to prepa

n crisis man

rning as pa

ny eLearnig

ds assessm

NAGEMEN

is implemen

ng providers

omplicated

e personne

ance the int

eeping oper

t of an offic

and termino

ning is co

course in

MALIA) to

ded in an e

OHQ NOR

ourses incl

System.53 In

vailable for

Affairs, EEAS

etteri, Pre-dedex.php?r=site

Public


on Eulex p

the orienta

re for thei

nagement, t

art of ENTR

gn tools are

ment in the f

NT

nted by me

s and proje

for CSDP m

l deployed

teroperabilit

rations the

cer’s norma

ology acros

ombined w

the milita

facilitate t

Package w

RTHWOOD

uded a spe

n addition, i

the military

S Official and a

eployment ee/index&year=


personnel in

tion period

r deployme

the NMLA is

i available o

e aware of, t

field of eLea

ember states

ects. Ensuri

military ope

to operation

ty of the troo

officers par

l career. Fu

ss the mem

ith face-to-

ary sphere

he six-mon

which the de

. A similar c

ecific AKU

in the spirit

y. ESDC's I

a former OPC

eLearning fo=2015&index=

S


n 2012 as p

, assisted i

ent. With t

s partially fil

on the ENT

though ther

arning in CS

s' training p

ng that per

erations tha

ns are usua

ops and ind

rticipate in i

urthermore,

mber states

-face educ

was deve

nthly rotati

esignated ne

course was

and some

of compreh

nternet-bas

EN Official) 27

r CSDP m=papers&vol=1


Duration:


part of ENTR

in understa

the existing

lling that ga

TRi site 51, w

re seems to

SDP.

providers on

rsonnel hav

n for civilia

ally profess

dividuals se

internationa

, the militar

s is more o

cation (blen

eloped for

on phases

ew staff we

s developed

other AKU

hensive ap

sed Distanc

7 August 2015

missions/opera19#

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


23

Ri II project

anding their

g lack and

ap. There is

whereas the

o be a clear

n a national

ve received

n missions.

sionals from

erving in the

al exercises

ry culture in

or less the

nded/hybrid

Operation

s. All non-

ere to study

d by the EU

Us from the

proach, the

ce Learning

5.

ations, 2015,

U

5 s

r t

3

t

r

d

s

e

r

l

d

.

m

e

s

n

e

d

n

-

y

U

e

e

g

,


Thgrares

(IDL) is al

knowledge

The increa

by the m

complimen

The North

The releva

28 EU me

to develop

platform ca

different eL

the ADL s

2015 was

level. NAT

blended le

only oppor

common e

evolution a

The United

The UN P

members c

54 Brynen, Rgames, particfits and phttps://paxsim55 Advanced standards anat https://jadl56 Ibid. 57 North AtlaMarch 2012.



so widely u

e developme

asing eLear

ajor intern

ntary and ne

Atlantic Tre

ance of the

mber states

p its own eL

alled Advan

Learning co

ite, it is cur

accessed

TO is plann

earning “wh

rtunity for a

education a

as well.57 T

d Nations

Peace Ope

can access

Rex, Teaching cipants can gapractical solms.wordpress Distributed L

nd specificatio.act.nato.int/

antic Treaty Or

elopment


ny use that may

used within

ent are at le

rning opport

ational org

ew ways to

eaty Organi

NATO in te

s 22 belong

Learning con

nced Distrib

ourses deali

rrently the

by 85 000

ning to inc

ich prepare

a training co

and training

his area wil

erations Tra

s freely. The

about Peace

ain a better selutions, and.com/2014/08

Learning (ADLons known as

rganisation, E


n the milita

east partially

tunities are

ganisations.

teach issue

isation (NAT

erms of mil

g as well to

ncept in 20

buted Learn

ing with var

most comm

users arou

rease the

es student f

ourse prior

area. Thus

ll be in line w

aining Instit

e platform c

Operations, Iense of the dy

understand/13/teaching-a

L): NATO e-Lethe Sharable

Education and

Public


ry training.

y realized th

utilized na

. Digital ga

es related to

TO)

itary eLearn

o NATO. Th

03. The ou

ning (ADL).5

rious topics

monly used

und the wor

use of eLe

for resident

to deploym

s, use of N

with standa

tute (POTI)

contains va

International Pynamic relationd how misabout-peace-oearning, EducaContent Obje

Training Prog


Several co

hrough IDL

tionally with

ames seek

o conflicts a

ning training

he North Atl

tcome of th55 The platfo

related to m

eLearning

rld. Studies

earning furt

ial courses

ment”.56 NAT

NMLA can b

ards of highe

) provides

arious self-p

Peacekeepingnships at workstakes occuoperations/ ation & Traini

ect Reference

gramme Mana

S


ourses that

.

hin the Milit

k to raise

and peace o

g is based

antic Treaty

he process i

orm contain

military and

tool in NAT

s are availa

ther. In par

and provid

TO is worki

be seen as

er educatio

an e-learn

paced eLea

Vol. 21, Iss. k in complex er”, PAXsims

ng “Anytime, Model (SCOR

agement – Dir


Duration:


t focus me

tary training

awareness

operations.5

on the fact

y Organisa

is an online

ns a vast c

security. A

TO which b

able online

rticular, it f

des in many

ng towards

s a natural

n standards

ning platfor

arning cours

4, 2014.; ”Thenvironments,s blog, ac

Anywhere” foRM). The site

rection and Gu

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


24

rely on the

g as well as

s and find54

t that out of

tion started

e eLearning

atalogue of

According to

by the year

up to PhD

focuses on

y cases the

s creating a

part of this

s.

m that the

ses dealing

rough seriousexplore good

ccessible at:

ollows a set of is accessible

uidance No 1,

U

5 s

r t

4

e

s

d

f

d

g

f

o

r

D

n

e

a

s

e

g

s d :

f e

,


Thgrares

with peace

experts. A

Completion

Advanced

Nations De

for many d

National de

Also other

as Compu

transmedia

scenario-b

Moreover,

individual n

to develop

units to be

58 The comOperations aPOTI is avail59 The Basicothers coverecovered by tand animated60 The advanclearance whhttps://agora.61 More infor62 Moreover,currently usinmandatory to63 Helsingin January, 201



e keeping a

After succe

n. As regard

Security in

epartment o

deployed pe

efence forc

eLearning

uter-Based

a learning.

based trainin

armed forc

needs in ter

p and invest

actively us

mmon core coand Procedureable at http://w

c Security In ted by the UN he UN Securid modules. Monced course ishen travelling.unicef.org/cormation availa

, for instanceng these e-leao all personne

Sanomat, Pu6, article is ac

elopment


ny use that may

and related

ssfully com

ds security

n the Field

of Safety a

ersonnel, inc

es

tools are u

Training

Especially

ngs and exe

ces in vario

rms of comb

t in a battle

sed as a par

ourse topics es, Gender Awww.peaceopthe Field e-leSecurity Manaity Managemeore informatios mandatory fo to (or withinurse/info.php?ble at: http://w

the CMC Fiarning tools to l prior to their

uolustusvoimaccessible at ht


d topics.58 T

mpleting a

eLearning,

d60 training

nd Security

cluding UN

used extens

(CBT), imm

within peac

ercises are

ous membe

bat training

simulator w

rt of the trai

include: HumAwareness, Lopstraining.org/parning courseagement Systent System, ren is available or local and in) a country w?id=1831 www.un.org/un

nland, organireplace the odeployment. t ostaa uudenttp://www.hs.fi

Public


The conten

course, st

the UN has

courses. T

y (UNDSS)6

military obs

sively in im

mersive tra

cekeeping

underway.

er states ar

. For instan

which will b

ning of the

manitarian Coogistics and Hpeacekeeper-

e contains sectem (UNSMS)egardless of tat: https://ago

nternational UNwhere a secur

ndss/?q=home

zation respononline based H

n taistelu-simi/kotimaa/a145


nt of the co

tudents are

s developed

These cour61. Complet

servers.62

plementatio

aining, mo

training the

re developi

nce, the Finn

be introduce

military per

oncepts and History of Pea-training/ curity informa. The e-learnitheir function. ora.unicef.org/N staff. The cority phase is

e nsible for trainHostile Environ

mulaattorin var54127115262

S


ourses is w

e awarded

d Basic Sec

rses are pro

ting the cou

on of the m

bile learnin

e developm

ng digital le

nish defenc

ed in 2017 t

rsonnel.63

Human Righacekeeping O

tion for persong course is mThe course c

/course/info.phourse is mandin effect. Mor

ning of Finnisnment training

rusmiehille –


Duration:


written by e

with a Ce

curity in the

ovided by

urses is a p

ilitary exerc

ng (m-Lea

ment of simu

earning too

ce forces ha

to a numbe

hts, Mission Operations., In

onnel, family mmandatory for consist of sevhp?id=589 datory for obtare information

sh seconded g (eHEST) whi

hinta liki 10

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


25

experienced

ertificate of

Field59 and

the United

prerequisite

cises. Such

rning) and

ulators and

ols for their

ave decided

r of military

Components,nformation on

members andall individualsen self-paced

aining securityn available at:

personnel, isch used to be

miljoonaa, 31

U

5 s

r t

5

d

f

d

d

e

h

d

d

r

d

y

, n

d s d

y :

s e


Thgrares

3 DESCR

The object

disseminat

creating an

as a basis

their future

of stakeho

also neede

structures

Compilatio

The applic

hub for var

as the core

similar str

convention

fragmented

solutions, E

concentrat

technology

serve the

advancing

create po

manageme

and trainin

this variety

64 Examples ENTRi - inclSecurity Shttps://fairsha



RIPTION

t of the plan

te the find

n interactive

to introduc

e deployme

olders (civil

ed to reflect

for the app

on of vario

cation will b

rious crisis

e with its s

uctures or

nal web site

d that infor

ENTRI, Sph

ted approac

y is changin

purpose.

with speed

ossibility fo

ent related

g in decent

y of differen

of studied eLuded: Buildinector Advisaretraining.eu/

elopment


ny use that may

OF THE

nned tool w

ings of the

e training to

ce the new C

nt areas or

servants, t

t the scope

lication wer

ous platform

be starting p

manageme

tructure, bu

other diffe

es). Howev

mation is h

here, ISSAT

ch would cr

ng with spe

The return

d allowing th

or developi

courses. Th

tralized or c

t online lea

Learning platfog a better res

sory Team, /frontpage


NMLA DE

was primary

e comparat

ool which c

CSDP staff

in general.

rainers, stu

e and follow

re identified

m possibili

point for ’op

ent related e

ut other app

erent type

ver, the mo

hard to find

T, UN peace

reate synerg

eed and cre

n for the in

he use of ot

ng more

here is a po

centralized w

rning oppor

orms related tosponse, availa

available

Public


EVELOPM

y to exhibit

tive analys

could be us

to the roots

. The tool c

udents etc.)

w the timefra

and discus

ities

pen source

elearning an

plications ca

of applicat

ment the fi

and it is n

e University

gies and im

eating a rig

nvestment

ther type of

advanced

ossibility to

way. From I

rtunities is t

o comprehensable at http://at: http://is


MENT WO

the selecte

is. Second

ed in vario

s and dynam

can also be

) The devel

ame of the

ssed.

’ crisis man

nd online le

an included

tions (can

ield of new

ot being to

y just to me

mprove effic

id structure

could be

technologie

serious g

organize th

IECEU poin

o use the c

sive security -/www.buildingssat.dcaf.ch/;

S


ORK

ed eight IEC

ary, the de

us crisis ma

mics of diffe

used amon

opment pe

project. In t

nagement s

arning tools

d to it – eith

include ga

w media bas

used its fu

ention few64)

iency. At th

es will also

moderate

es in forese

games to

he technolo

nt of view, th

ommon and

other than theabetterrespon

Fair Shar


Duration:


CEU case s

evelopmen

anagement

erent conflic

ng the large

eriod of the

the beginni

site which s

s. The IECE

her applicat

amification,

sed applica

ullest (e.g. v

). A more fo

he same tim

not be pra

as the tec

eeable futur

serve var

ogy support

hey key asp

d relevant k

e ones offerednse.org/ ;There LMS,

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


26

studies and

t aimed at

t training or

cts either in

er audience

application

ng, various

serves as a

EU remains

tions with a

eLearning,

ations is so

various UN

ocused and

me, the new

gmatic and

chnology is

re. This can

rious crisis

ed learning

pect among

key words.

d by ESDC ore Internationalavailable at

U

5 s

r t

6

d

t

r

n

e

n

s

a

s

a

,

o

N

d

w

d

s

n

s

g

g

r l t


Thgrares

Modular a

The user c

assets, en

information

thematicall

any given

describe a

which cou

downloade

in mission

threats, ris

capabilities

Design had

goals to co

point in de

power is o

more visib

seeks to

comparativ

gamificatio

the applica

moreover b

projects.

Since IEC

comparativ

the IECEU

based lear

65 Nkhoma, Mrevised Bloom



approach

can select

ngaging w

n/exercise

ly well-struc

CSDP perm

nd inform t

uld be adju

ed to laptop

areas. The

sks, and r

s and secur

d to strike a

oncrete acti

eveloping m

often achiev

ble. In a sa

highlight

ve study o

on. The gam

ation is crea

be used a b

CEU –proje

ve analysis,

U knowledge

rning combi

M., Lam, T., Rm’s Taxonomy

elopment


ny use that may

a specific t

with local p

on that. Id

ctured easil

mission or

he new sta

usted on fie

p, tablet or m

e possibility

reporting p

rity of the m

a balance b

on steps. H

odels and a

ved by the s

me way, ga

the most

n the case

mification a

ated in a wa

basis in cre

ect made t

, NMLA cre

e and findin

ned with pr

Richardson, J.y. Proceeding


topic such a

population

deas for fu

ly adjustabl

induction tr

ff on the sp

eld office/h

mobile phon

y to adjust t

procedures

mission mem

between com

However, lik

applications

simplifying t

amification

important

es. The ac

pplication c

ay that it all

ating other

the decisio

eation was n

ngs as a fo

roblem solvi

, Kam, K., & Lgs of Informing

Public


as training,

or specifi

urther deve

le gamificat

raining. The

pecific miss

ub level w

ne could be

the NMLA

could crea

mbers.

mplexity of

ke in the cas

s is not to d

the surveye

seeks not

findings a

cquisition of

can be used

lows amend

learning en

on to stud

naturally su

orm of case

ing enhance

Lau, K. H.,. Dg Science & IT


pooling an

c region

elopment o

tion could p

e NMLA ca

ion environ

was raised.

e utilized as

to reflect th

ate a very

the researc

se of theory

describe the

ed phenome

to illustrate

and pattern

f the know

d in training

dments in t

nvironment

y different

upported wit

e studies. E

es the profe

eveloping casT Education Co

S


nd sharing

and the s

of the NML

provide a m

n be amen

ment. The n

The NMLA

s a part of t

he existing

y tangible

ched realitie

y in human o

e reality in d

ena when th

e the detaile

ns/causalitie

wledge is th

g on differe

he text cont

reflecting fu

case stud

th the unde

Earlier resea

essional ski

se-based learnonference (InS


Duration:


of military a

system wil

LA were id

mean to utili

ded by the

need of an

A which ca

the training

environme

tool to en

es and need

or social sc

detail. The e

he causaliti

ed survey

es found

hen provide

ent levels. A

tent. The p

uture trainin

dies and f

erstanding o

arch shows

lls developm

ning activities SITE) 2016, 8

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


27

and civilian

l generate

dentified. A

ze it during

mission to

application

an also be

conducted

nt, themes,

nhance the

d to reduce

ciences, the

explanatory

es become

results, but

during the

ed through

Additionally,

latform can

ng needs or

finalise the

of providing

s that case-

ment. 65 66

based on the5-93.

U

5 s

r t

7

n

e

A

g

o

n

e

d

,

e

e

e

y

e

t

e

h

,

n

r

e

g

-

e


Thgrares

3.1 TARG

IECEU Lea

and challe

group have

the units th

audience t

Internation

Staff work

prevention

internation

and UNDP

Organizatio

Researche

Researche

universities

with the co

the projec

security/de

relations, g

project res

with simila

understand

Training c

Training o

Integration

contribute

66 Harman, Tlearning facilAcademy of N



GET GROU

arning Appl

enges to th

e been take

hey visit ba

o use the to

nal organis

ing in vario

is potentia

al organisa

P), and Or

on for Migra

ers and thi

ers are also

s, will be st

onsortium a

ct impleme

efence stud

global gove

search. The

r topics wit

ding of the E

communitie

organisation

n of the IEC

to the train

T., Bertrand, litates critical tNutrition and D

elopment


ny use that may

UPS

ication is se

e structure

en into acc

sed on indi

ool. The ant

sations (IO

ous internat

al end-user

ations includ

ganization

ation (IOM)

nk-tanks

o importan

rategically t

nd provide

entation or

dies, EU s

ernance, etc

re are other

h the IECE

EU conflict

es

ns are prep

CEU platfor

ning. The tr

B., Greer, A

thinking in undDietetics, 115


eeking to re

to the pla

ount in the

vidual inter

ticipated tar

Os)

tional organ

s of the kn

de: The Eu

for Securit

and the No

t stakehold

targeted in

either enqu

applicative

studies, st

c.) are also

r on-going E

U. Ideally, t

prevention

paring pers

rm or some

raining inte

., Pettus, A., dergraduate n(3), 2015, 378

Public


each a broa

atform. The

design. Th

rests and ne

rget groups

nisations in

nowledge ge

ropean Un

ty and Co-

orth Atlantic

ders of IEC

disseminat

uiries on the

e research

tudies of i

o experts w

EU - resear

this can be

and crisis m

onnel for t

e parts of

egration rep

Jennings, J.,

nutrition educa8–388, availab


ad audience

different n

he modular

eeds. This

include:

the field o

enerated by

nion (EU), U

-operation i

c Treaty Org

CEU. The r

ion activitie

e progress o

h. Part of

internationa

who will pro

rch projects

used to cro

managemen

their work

it into relat

presents lon

, Wall-Bassettation: Studentsble at: http://do

S


, which crea

eeds and i

structure a

provides an

f crisis man

y the IECE

United Nati

n Europe

ganization (N

research co

s to further

or relevant

the resea

al organisa

ovide inform

which are

oss-check a

nt.

in the miss

ted training

ng term imp

t, E., & Babas describe theoi.org/10.1016


Duration:


ates both a

interests of

allows users

n incentive

nagement a

EU – projec

ons (espec

(OSCE), In

NATO).

ommunity,

intensify co

suggestion

arch comm

ations & in

mation relev

overlapping

and deepen

sions and

g curricula w

pact of IEC

atunde, O. T.e Big Picture. 6/j.jand.2014.0

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


28

added value

f the target

s to choose

for a larger

and conflict

ct. Relevant

cially DPKO

nternational

particularly

ollaboration

s regarding

munity (e.g.

nternational

vant for the

g or dealing

n further the

operations.

will directly

CEU project

, Case-basedJournal of the

09.003

U

5 s

r t

8

e

t

e

r

t

t

O

l

y

n

g

.

l

e

g

e

.

y

t

d e


Thgrares

findings. M

in future pr

manageme

EU projec

During the

(GAP) was

various co

phases, s

conducting

The ESDC

of 12 partn

separate i

relevant tra

Non-gove

There are

manageme

comprehen

are workin

manageme

the cooper

3.2 LEAR

The aim of

analysis ba

have an u

underlying

related to p

The IECEU

European

application



Moreover, th

roject and a

ent.

cts

e drafting ph

s launched

onflict preve

tructure an

g future proj

C that is an

ners, all reg

nternal del

ainings to e

rnmental o

e numerous

ent. The nu

nsive secur

g towards t

ent objectiv

ration and c

RNING OB

f the IECEU

ased on the

understandin

concept of

planning an

U eLearnin

Union’s (E

n, the user

elopment


ny use that may

he NMLA ca

applications

hase of the

d in Septem

ention and

nd the use

ject dealing

associated

gularly con

liverable (D

ensure the c

organisatio

s non-gove

umber is ev

rity. When

the same go

ves and act

contribute to

BJECTIVES

U NMLA is

e conducte

ng of EU’s

f comprehen

nd implemen

ng platform

U) crisis m

has obtain


an be up-da

designed t

e IECEU pla

mber with a

crisis man

er experien

with eLear

partner of

ducting trai

D8.5) of the

continuation

ons

ernmental o

ven larger w

observed t

oals. Increa

tivities amo

o the proces

S

to introduce

d research

conflict pre

nsive secur

nting CSDP

introduces

management

ned a basic

Public


ated, transf

to meet the

atform, a ne

an aim of c

agement tr

ces of the

rning/gamifi

the project

inings for th

e IECEU p

n of dissemi

organisation

when appro

through the

asing under

ng the pers

ss.

e users with

. After goin

evention an

rity. The use

P missions a

s the user w

t covered b

c understan


formed or s

future need

ew Horizon

creating se

raining. Exp

e platform

cation of re

is a networ

he CSDP a

project is p

nation even

ns (NGOs)

aching the

ese lenses,

rstanding of

sonnel of th

h the IECE

ng through t

nd crisis m

er will know

and operatio

with eight s

by the IECE

nding of th

S


ome of its e

ds of conflic

n 2020 proje

rious game

periences f

can be us

lated topics

rk of 70 org

and other m

prepared on

n after the p

operating

question fr

also huma

f EU conflic

he NGO co

U project ca

the all the m

anagement

w the most re

ons.

selected ca

EU project.

e EU proce


Duration:


elements ca

ct preventio

ect Gaming

e applicatio

from the de

sed in des

s.

ganisations

missions’ pe

n the integ

project.

in the fiel

rom the per

anitarian org

ct prevention

ommunity ca

ases and c

modules, th

t activities

relevant EU

ase studies

. After com

esses and

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


29

an be used

n and crisis

g for Peace

on to serve

evelopment

signing and

and ENTRi

ersonnel. A

gration with

ld of crisis

rspective of

ganisations

n and crisis

an improve

comparative

he user will

and on the

institutions

s related to

pleting this

institutions

U

5 s

r t

9

d

s

e

e

t

d

i

A

h

s

f

s

s

e

e

l

e

s

o

s

s


Thgrares

which are

(CSDP) m

coherent a

essential c

comprehen

ownership

An overvie

methods w

and operat

Congo, Ce

obtained b

activities o

describing

learning ta

objectives

3.3 TECH

Prior to the

developing

undertakin

programmi

commente

be defined

timeline as

platform. F

on augmen

Choosing

When choo

goal, the s

paid LMS



involved in

missions and

actions at st

concepts a

nsive secur

.

ew to the IE

which have

tions, name

entral Africa

basic unders

of the CSDP

the learni

argets which

of the anim

HNICAL SP

e developm

g IECEU N

g. The p

ing, Server

ed during hi

d to be twic

s well as t

For example

nted reality.

a free and

osing the be

selection is

solutions. T

elopment


ny use that may

n planning

d operation

trategic and

and topics

rity, security

ECEU proje

been used

ely: Kosovo

an Republic

standing of

P missions

ng objectiv

h the user s

mations inclu

PECIFICA

ent phase,

MLA. Deve

process re

maintenan

s presentat

e the time

the resourc

e, it was no

.

d open sou

est gamified

always bas

The criteria


and imple

ns. The use

d operationa

related to

y sector ref

ct (Improvin

d to carry o

, Bosnia an

c and South

f the dynam

and operati

ves are pre

should have

uded in the

ATIONS

a desk-top

eloping tech

equires div

ce) graphic

tion that the

assessed f

ces availab

ot realistic to

rce tool to

d, open sou

sed on the

for the sele

Public


ementing E

er is introd

al level. Add

crisis prev

form (SSR)

ng the effic

out eight ca

nd Herzegov

h Sudan. Af

mics of thes

ions based

esented in

e met after c

learning pla

study was

hnology su

verse expe

c design, co

e timeline fo

for the actu

ble for the

o consider c

create a g

urce Learnin

needs of th

ection was


U’s Commo

uced to the

ditionally, th

vention an

), mentoring

iency of EU

ase studies

vina, Pales

fter complet

e conflicts

on the find

the beginn

completing

atform are l

carried out

pported lea

ertise, incl

opywriter, c

or planning

al design d

platform cr

creating a 3

amified e-l

ng Manage

he user. Th

that the pla

S


on Security

e common

he user will

d crisis m

g, monitorin

U crisis man

on selecte

tine Territor

ting these m

and subseq

dings of the

ning of eac

the module

isted in the

to identify t

arning tools

uding ICT

ontent expe

including g

due to unfor

reated certa

3D game or

earning pla

ment Syste

ere are ove

atform need


Duration:


y and Defe

challenges

gain under

anagement

ng and adv

nagement c

ed EU CSD

ry, Afghanis

modules, yo

quent deplo

IECEU pro

ch module

e. The ration

Annex 3.

the existing

s is a resou

T experts

ert etc. A ga

game-eleme

reseen obs

ain limitatio

r an applica

atform

em (LMS) fo

er 600 diffe

ded to base

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


30

ence Policy

s related to

rstanding of

t including:

vising, local

capabilities)

P missions

stan, Libya,

ou will have

oyment and

oject. A text

to set the

nal/learning

options for

urce heavy

(computer

ame expert

ents should

tacles. The

ons for the

ation based

or a specific

erent free &

ed on open

U

5 s

r t

0

y

o

f

:

l

)

s

,

e

d

t

e

g

r

y

r

t

d

e

e

d

c

&

n


Thgrares

source cod

browser c

platforms w

closely. Th

require he

possess th

The pros

known Hu

compelling

account in

listed in the

Wordpres

Pros

Easy to us

Strong sup

Free and o

User friend

67 More infor68 A website mobile-friend69 More infor70 Jounghyun



de67 featurin

compatible 69

which have

he other fre

avy adjustm

he qualities

and cons o

uman-Comp

g user expe

the selecti

e following

ss

se.

pport commu

open source

dly – adapt a

rmation at: http

or web applicdly-website rmation at: http

n, G. K., 2015

elopment


ny use that may

ng desired 9 etc. Agai

the ability t

ely availabl

ments in th

the project

of the mos

puter Intera

erience). Mo

ion process

tables:

unity.

code.

also for begin

ps://opensourc

cation that disp

ps://www.joed

5.


functions:

nst these

to turn also

e tools bas

e server an

set forth to

t relevant t

action (HC

oreover, the

s. The argu

nners.

ce.org/osd

plays correctly

dolson.com/20

Public


options for

criteria, we

into powerf

sed on open

nd/or in the

achieve.

technical s

CI) practice

e IECEU Q

uments in fa

Co

Ne

an

Ne

ach

No

No

adj

y in mobile de

008/03/what-is


r gamified l

e selected

ful e-learnin

n source co

e administra

olutions we

s 70 ((a) fu

Quality Assu

avor and ag

ons

eeds third pa

e-learning p

eeds to be

hieve the des

ot as secure c

ot primarily

justments ne

evices, http://w

s-cross-browse

S


learning, m

three of t

ng solutions

ode are eith

ative side,

ere compar

unctional co

urance Plan

gainst the m

arty plugins a

latform.

heavily cu

sired user int

compared to

y intended

eed to be ma

www.seascape

er-compatibilit


Duration:


mobile friend

the most u

s to be exam

her incomple

or they sim

red accordi

ompletenes

n has been

most likely o

and themes

ustomized in

terface.

o Drupal.

for LMS

ade.

ewebdesign.co

ty/

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


31

dly68, multi-

used online

mined more

ete, or they

mply do not

ng to well-

ss and (d)

n taken into

options are

to make it

n order to

S, hence

om/blog/what-

U

5 s

r t

-

e

e

y

t

-

)

o

e

-


Thgrares

Heavy cus

and/or Ja

knowledge

Wide array

Gamificatio

Table 1 Wo

Moodle

Pros

It is free f

It is open

Support is

The tool

passive, l

71 Hypertext suited for http://php.net72 Cascadinguser interface



stomizations

avascript H

e, CSS372 is

y of plugins a

on plugins av

ordpress: as

for users.

source, so

s available

ls encoura

earning.

Preprocessorweb deve

t/manual/en/ing Style Sheetses written in H

elopment


ny use that may

can be don

TML progra

a must.

and themes.

vailable.

ssessment.

it is always

24/7

age active,

r (PHP) is a lopment an

ntro-whatis.phs (CSS) is a s

HTML. More in


ne with little

amming lan

s improving.

, rather th

widely-used od can be p style sheet lan

nformation ava

Public


PHP71

nguage

Us

Ga

cod

Cons

The s

and fa

. It tak

maint

The u

han Mood

interfa

hence

involv

open source gembedded

nguage commailable at https


er statistics a

amification fe

ded to our ne

s

setup is oft

ar from use

es a dedica

tain it.

user interfac

dle does no

ace requir

e, heavy

ved.

general-purpointo HTM

monly used to s://developer.m

S


achievable v

eatures nee

eeds.

ten criticize

er-friendly.

ated team o

ce is rather

ot address

ements rig

customiza

ose scripting lML. More i

define the vismozilla.org/en-


Duration:


via third party

ed to be ins

ed for being

of IT profes

old fashion

exactly to

ght out of

ations nee

language thatinformation

sual style of w-US/docs/Web

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


32

y plugins.

stalled and

g complex

ssionals to

ned.

o our user

f the box

d to be

t is especiallyavailable at

web sites andb/CSS/CSS3

U

5 s

r t

2

y t

d


Thgrares

It is secur

Can be us

Table 2 Mo

Opigno (

Pros

Easy to in

Not many

right out o

are: Forum

conferenc

on.

Good use

Easy to n

Active on

Free & op

More sec

Faster pa



re.

sed with an

oodle: asses

Drupal)

nstall.

y customiza

of the box. S

m discussio

ce capability

er interface.

avigate.

line suppor

pen source.

ure compar

age loads th

elopment


ny use that may

ny device

ssment.

ations are ne

Some of the

ons, user m

y, gamificat

rt.

red to Word

han Wordpre


eeded, can

e pre-install

essaging, li

tion elemen

dpress.

ess.

Public


Mood

be used

led features

ive video

nts and so


dle provides

Cons

Heavy c

be achie

program

s Theme

changed

function

S


s some gene

customizatio

eved by an

mmer.

is not recom

d with regar

alities.


Duration:


eral level st

ons are not

unexperien

mmended to

rds to its co

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


33

tatistics.

easy to

nced

o be

ore

U

5 s

r t

3


Thgrares

Personal-

Ability to u

Integrated

completio

Contains

Integrated

badges, li

Mobile co

playback

Table 3 Op

After asse

decision w

multiple re

group to b

platform,

communica

The compa

code and t

developers

resource c

our needs

user interfa

73 HTML 5 isdescribing http://searchs



-user as we

upload quiz

d ability to is

on.

a free appl

d gamificati

ive guide (w

ompatible in

content all

pigno: asses

essing the

was taken to

eason to se

be used au

such as

ations.

arison was

that could b

s with mor

constraints t

. It is integ

ace, learna

s a revision o

the contesoa.techtarget

elopment


ny use that may

ell as genera

zzes via Exc

ssue certific

ication store

on features

walkthrough

ncluding vide

done in HT

ssment.

technical re

o create a D

elect this te

utonomousl

Moodle, c

carried out

be deployed

e time to

that were se

rated with

ability and e

of the Hyperteents and t.com/definitio


al level stati

cel sheets.

cates upon

e for extens

s such as m

h), h5p integ

eo, sound a

TML573.

equirement

Drupal/Opig

echnology.

y. Hence,

containing

to choose

d as soon a

work with

et by the GA

gamification

ease of cre

ext Markup Laappearance

on/HTML5

Public


istics.

course

sions.

mozilla

gration.

and other

ts of the N

gno based o

First, the I

there was

several to

a platform t

as possible

the conten

A, Opigno s

n and e-lea

ating the d

anguage (HTMof Web


NMLA and c

open sourc

ECEU platf

no need t

ools to be

that is free

with minima

nt itself. Ta

seemed to b

arning funct

esired cont

ML) which is tb pages.

S


comparing

e eLearning

form is des

to opt for a

e used for

of charge, b

al adjustme

aking into a

be a versat

tionalities a

tent. In sho

the standard More info


Duration:


identified o

g platform.

signed to b

a maintena

r student

based on o

ents. This p

account the

ile package

and it provid

ort, Opigno

programmingormation av

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


34

options the

There was

broad focus

ance heavy

– teacher

pen source

rovided the

e time and

e which met

des a good

provided a

language forvailable at:

U

5 s

r t

4

e

s

s

y

r

e

e

d

t

d

a

r :


Thgrares

tool which

features an

set for the

content ma

and other

understand

Descriptio

IECEU eLe

is designe

Opigno us

with rather

preventing

navigating

The platfor

are brows

multimedia

content an

is needed

platform. A

environme

or transfor

has its ow

free of cha

The platfo

H5P modu

Opigno ap

separate o



h could be

nd changing

IECEU e-e

anagement

r various e

ding in desi

on of Opign

earning plat

d to be flex

ser interface

r small adju

the risk t

.

rm is mobile

sing sites w

a software

nd does not

to run Opig

As mention

ent. Howeve

rmed to ser

wn applicatio

arge and op

rm can be

ule integrati

pp store. H

organization

elopment


ny use that may

made ope

g visual sty

earning tool

t system. T

environmen

red topics.

no Manage

tform is bas

xible and s

e is clear w

ustments to

hat the use

e friendly, w

with their p

platform (w

require the

gno. Opign

ned earlier

er, if the futu

rve other pu

on store wh

en source.

easily gam

ion, all of w

H5P is an

n that is us


erational w

les I.e. colo

l. Opigno is

This system

ts that can

ement Syst

sed on Opig

scalable to

which makes

o the webs

er would lo

which is con

portable de

which addit

e use of oth

o contains

r, these fe

ure the IEC

urposes, the

hich hosts

These tools

mified with M

which are p

extension d

ed to gamif

Public


with small a

ors, certifica

s an Open S

m makes it

n be used

em

gno Learnin

meet differ

s its easily

server. The

ose his/her

nsidered ve

evices. M

tionally has

er special s

tools that a

eatures are

CEU NMLA

e functions

extensions

s can be uti

Mozilla bad

pre-installed

developed

fy e- learni


adjustments

ate layouts a

Source e-le

possible to

d to enhan

ng Managem

rent needs

accessible

clarity help

r interest d

ery importan

Moreover, th

s become

software in

allows it to

e not inclu

– or some

are availa

for the too

ilized in the

dges, user

d in the pa

for WordPr

ng with eas

S


s (such as

and so on)

earning plat

manage o

nce users’

ment System

related to

e and it can

ps the user

ue to cum

nt as today,

he system

a less use

order to run

be develop

ded in the

modules of

ble and can

ol. The ava

future to de

scoring, ce

ckage or o

ress, Mood

se, all done


Duration:


s removing

to meet the

tform based

online traini

skills, kno

m (LMS). O

content ma

n be made

r to focus o

bersome a

more and

does not

ed technolo

n. Only a w

ped as a co

e develope

f it - must b

n be includ

ilable appli

evelop the

ertification a

obtainable v

dle and Dru

e in HTML5

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


35

unneeded

e objectives

d on Drupal

ng courses

owledge or

Opigno LMS

anagement.

operational

on learning

and illogical

more users

use Flash

ogy) based

eb-browser

ollaborative

ed learning

be up-dated

ed. Opigno

cations are

awards and

via the free

upal from a

5, including

U

5 s

r t

5

d

s

l

s

r

S

.

l

g

l

s

h

d

r

e

g

d

o

e

d

e

a

g


Thgrares

video quizz

own.74 The

1. The

dev

2. Issu

3. Live

4. Imp

5. Use

6. Qu

que

vide

who

whi

dev

num

IECEU pla

design of u

kept limited

as a defau

deliberatel

The interes

designed i

systematic

the platform

74 For more i



zes. The H5

e following l

e tool also

vices.

ue certificat

e results an

port or expo

er accounts

izzes (true/

estion, grou

eo gallery,

o has succ

ich include

veloped pla

mber of use

atform does

user interfa

d. Secondly

ult in the O

y kept light

st of the us

n a way tha

cally guided

m needs to

information, se

elopment


ny use that may

5P extensio

ists options

has PDF

tes upon co

nd data stat

ort quizzes f

s, user man

/false ques

uping quest

user forum,

cessfully co

as a defau

atform will

ers.

s not use al

ace is base

y, due to ar

Opigno wer

t to make u

ser can be v

at allows ac

through se

be clear an

ee: https://h5p


on includes

s and functio

displaying

ompletion of

istics includ

from and to

agement (s

stions, mult

tion, fill-in b

, surveys, s

mpleted all

ult: student,

only have

l the listed

d on clarity

chitecture o

re not need

se of the N

very to a lar

cess only to

everal modu

nd self-guid

p.org/

Public


a wide arra

ons that are

capabilitie

f courses, m

ding charts

o excel.

security leve

tiple choice

blanks que

statistics, Au

l the modu

, teacher, c

administra

functions. T

y and there

of the applic

ded for the

NMLA easy.

rge extent.

o one of the

ules and the

ing.


ay of gamific

e possible w

s via HTM

modules etc

and other h

els etc.)

e questions

estion) with

utomatic PD

les, flexible

class' coach

ator and st

The reason

fore the op

cation, man

e IECEU p

The focus

As a result

e modules o

erefore, the

S


cation and n

with Opigno

ML5, making

c.

human read

s, matching

centralised

DF certificat

e access co

h, and adm

tudent/user

ns for this a

ptions for di

ny course-ty

latform. Th

group of th

, the structu

or to severa

e structure a


Duration:


new media

:

g it useful

able data.

g questions

d questions

te generatio

ontrol, base

inistrator (a

r functions)

are twofold.

ifferent func

ype function

he IECEU d

he applicati

ure of the m

al ones. The

and how to

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


36

tools on its

for mobile

s, long text

s database,

on to a user

ed on roles

at this state

), unlimited

Firstly, the

ctions were

ns available

design was

on is large.

module was

e user is not

navigate in

U

5 s

r t

6

s

e

t

,

r

s

e

d

e

e

e

s

.

s

t

n


Thgrares

Integration

Technical q

1) Apa

AP

HT

2) Lig

pro

3) (Ac

sing

app

only

4) Eas

5) SC

coll

(als

6) Tin

7) Cer

8) HT

inte

Using the

email addr

75 REST stan76 Represent77 JavaScript78 Extensible 79 Comma-se80 Hypertext T81 Requests d82 Data that cus/library/ee283 More inform84 More inform85 More inform86 More inform87 Experience



n

qualities we

ache Solr i

I.76 You put

TP80. You q

htweight Di

ograms use

ctive Directo

gle sign-on

plications w

y once.

sily scalable

CORM 2004

lection of s

so called e-

Can (xAPI

rtified LRS:

ML5 Packa

eractive H5P

NMLA tool

ress. No ad

nds for Represational State Tt Object NotatiMarkup Lang

eparated ValuTransfer Protodata from a spcan be receive267547%28v=mation at: httpmation at: httpmation at: httpmation at: httpe API, more in

elopment


ny use that may

ere:

ntegration (

t document

query it via

rectory Acc

to look up i

ory) 84and C

n protocol f

while provid

e due to its

4 compliant

tandards an

learning)

)87 complian

Learning L

age (H5P)

P elements

is easy. It i

ditional info

sentational StaTransfer, moreion, more info

guage, more ines, more inforocol, more infopecific resourced using a rec=bts.10%29.asp://www.graciops://u-tools.cops://en.wikipedps://en.wikipednformation at:


(Solr is a s

s in it (calle

HTTP GET8

cess Protoc

information

CAS integra

for the web

ding their c

internal Ap

t - Sharabl

nd specifica

nt

Locker, Wat

compliant

.

s required t

ormation is

ate Transfer, me information armation at: httnformation at: rmation at: httpormation at: htce, more informeive adapter, spx on.com/serverm/help/whatisdia.org/wiki/Cedia.org/wiki/Shhttps://tincana

Public


standalone e

ed "indexing81 and rece

col (LDAP)83

from a serv

ation. The

b. Its purpo

credentials

ps Manage

le Content

ations for w

tershed

which allo

to log into t

needed. Th

more informatavailable at: htp://www.json.http://www.xmp://edoceo.cottp://www.tutomation at: httpmore informa

r/whatldap.htmsad.asp entral_Authenharable_Conteapi.com/overv


enterprise s

g") via JSO

ive82 JSON3, is an Inte

ver.

Central Au

ose is to p

(such as u

ement Syste

Object Re

web-based e

ws creation

the system

he Opigno p

ion at: http://rehttp://www.rest.org/ ml.com/pub/a/9m/utilitas/csv-

orialspoint.comp://www.w3schtion at: https:/

ml

tication_Servient_Object_Reiew/

S


search serv

N77, XML78

, XML, CSV

rnet protoco

thentication

permit a us

ser identific

em

eference M

electronic e

n, use and

by providin

platform is b

est.elkstein.ortapitutorial.com

98/10/guide0.file-format

m/http/ hools.com/tag/msdn.microso

ce eference_Mod


Duration:


ver with a R

, CSV79 or

V or binary

ol that ema

n Service (C

ser to acce

cation and

Model (SCO

educational

d recycling

g your nam

based on o

rg/ m/

html?page=2#

gs/ref_httpmetsoft.com/en-

del

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


37

REST75-like

binary over

results.)

il and other

CAS)85 is a

ess multiple

password)

ORM)86 is a

technology

of various

me and your

pen source

#AEN58

hods.asp

U

5 s

r t

7

e

r

r

a

e

)

a

y

s

r

e


Thgrares

software a

connection

Audio

The voiceo

and quality

animations

Navigation

The design

topics NML

way, the t

respective

The applic

content o

missions/o

is aimed a

not manda

immediate

Quiz

All the mod

go through

score and

certificate,

correctly.

Domain O

Number of

url-address

will find an

used by th

products.



and it can b

n and a dev

over of the

y of the us

s). The voic

n

n has aimed

LA is dealin

topics/subh

page to en

cation is se

of the app

operations w

at a broad a

atory to bro

ly access to

dules includ

h the entire

d show the

the user h

Optimisatio

f business e

s of an inte

nd rank hig

he users. Th

For insta

elopment


ny use that may

be used fre

ice (PC, lap

application

er experien

e-overs are

d at providin

ng with are

headings in

sure clear o

lf-paced; it

plication ha

which have

audience, th

owse the ap

opics of his/

de quiz. In o

module in

e correct a

as to take

n

enterprises

ernet site/ga

gh their app

his has ass

ance, Goo


ee of charg

ptop, tablet

is created

nce (the vo

e embedded

ng a compr

e listed in th

cluded in d

overview.

allows the

as been a

been revie

he various e

pplication in

/her interes

order to ans

question. A

nswer with

all the quiz

spend con

ame/applica

plications b

sessed to h

gle chang

Public


ge. The use

or a mobile

by professi

oiceover tex

d in and syn

rehensive o

he main me

different m

user to fre

arranged i

ewed as a p

elements ca

n a predete

t.

swer to the

After comple

h short exp

zzes in the

nsiderable t

ation) to ens

based on th

ave a cons

ges its al


er only nee

e phone) to

ional speak

xts are prov

nchronized w

overview of

enu visible

odules are

eely decide

n chapters

part of the I

an however

ermined ord

multiple ch

eting the qu

planations.

end of the

time in optim

sure that th

he search w

siderable im

gorithms o

S


eds to have

access the

ker to ensur

vided also i

with the ani

the platform

on the left

listed in t

how to nav

s based o

ECEU proje

r been acce

der, but the

oice questio

uiz, the syst

In order to

modules an

mizing their

e major sea

words which

mpact on ma

on regular


Duration:


e a functio

platform.

re compreh

in subhead

imations.

m content. T

hand side.

the start p

vigate in th

on the th

ect. As the

essed indiv

e user can

ons, the us

tem will sho

o receive

nd score at

r domain ad

arch engine

h are most

arketing of

r bases t

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


38

ning online

ensiveness

dings of the

The various

In a same

age of the

he site. The

emes and

application

idually. It is

select and

er needs to

ow the user

a printable

t least 80%

ddress (the

es (Google)

commonly

services or

to prevent

U

5 s

r t

8

e

s

e

s

e

e

e

d

n

s

d

o

r

e

%

e

)

y

r

t


Thgrares

companies

engines in

them highe

analysing

screening

better resp

civilian exp

optimisatio

The select

which wer

project res

further in

depends o

material ab

as the dom

The applic

functional a

3.4 DEVE

The draftin

project wh

NMLA has

prevention

project find

The develo

users into

feedback f

reflected

considerat

used refer



s/other acto

stead cons

er in the di

the most

the domain

ponse on th

perts workin

on would ha

tion of the n

re necessar

sults or on

the course

on what oth

bout conflict

main name f

cation was c

and visual q

ELOPMEN

ng started

hich were n

s two main

and crisis

dings and co

opment of t

the progre

from the pa

in the NM

ions. There

rence point

elopment


ny use that may

ors from figu

ider educat

splayed link

commonly

n names of

he field of

ng in the C

ave taken pl

name of the

ry to consid

creating a

of coming

her contents

t managem

for the cons

chosen to b

quality of th

T PHASE

with the ne

necessary to

targets: Fi

manageme

ollects the g

the NMLA w

ess. The b

rtners. It wa

MLA. The

e are nume

ts are The


uring out ho

tion related

ks. Therefo

used sear

f other goo

humanitaria

CSDP missi

ace.

domain wa

der when c

an applicati

g years (an

s there will

ent, then…

sortium. The

be designed

e final prod

S

eeds asses

o be publis

rstly, it prov

ent training.

good practic

was design

broad focus

as also clea

systematic

rous docum

e Quality A

Public


ow the searc

sites (no-p

ore, it was a

rch words

od quality e

an aid and

ons. Their

as based on

choosing th

on that wil

n example

be under t

”). The task

e selected d

d in consulta

duct.

ssment and

shed in the

vides a new

. Secondly,

ces from th

ned to be ba

s group wa

ar that any p

c developm

ments deali

Assessment


ch engines

profit orienta

assessed th

was futile

eLearning a

In Control

domain na

n peer revie

he name: w

ll be maint

of peer rev

the same d

k leader pro

domain nam

ation with e

d defining t

platform. L

w complime

it offers an

e case stud

ased on co

as work is

possible de

ment progre

ng with the

for Elearn

S


define their

ated) more

hat making

(this was

pplications

created as

mes do not

ew which re

was the foc

ained and

view comm

omain: if th

oposed thre

me is ieceuL

xternal ICT

he element

Like stated

entary tool

n effective to

dies.

-planning a

a process

lays in the c

ess was s

e issue. For

ning: a Ben


Duration:


r rankings.

trustworthy

an extensi

further vin

– such as

s a practica

t suggest t

evealed vari

cus on pres

potentially

ments: “the

here will be

ee pre-selec

Learning.eu

T experts to

ts and find

in the beg

to be used

ool to disse

and integrat

that requir

case studie

scrutinised

r this work,

nchmarking

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


39

The search

y and place

ive effort in

ndicated by

Building a

al guide for

hat domain

ious factors

senting the

developed

best name

e also other

cted options

u.

ensure the

ings of the

ginning, the

d in conflict

eminate the

tion of end-

red regular

es would be

to quality

the mostly

g Approach

U

5 s

r t

9

h

e

n

y

a

r

n

s

e

d

e

r

s

e

e

e

t

e

-

r

e

y

y

h


Thgrares

produced

oppimateri

Education.

developme

for the goo

the validity

checklist fo

Pedagog

Case –ba

Learning

the prese

and stude

Instruction

used for l

Definition

platform?

Material m

use the m

Informatio

Material s

assessme

Supports

Informatio

Structure

Structure

Practical

Platform w

Informatio

88 Quality As89 Verkko-op90 Ibid.



by the Eur

aalin Laatu

. 89 The foll

ent. The pri

od content

y of one sin

or the on-lin

gical quality

ased Materi

skills, activ

ented points

ents.

ns for the u

eaning and

of the ta

must be flex

material on i

on whom to

stimulates l

ent and/or k

learning of

on provided

helps to co

helps to as

ity

works in mo

on relevant

ssessment for

ppimateriaalin

elopment


ny use that may

ropean Ass

ukriteerit” p

lowing sele

mary objec

are good le

ngle eleme

ne content in

y

ial supports

vation of th

s. The crite

users must b

what is its

arget/user g

xible and it

ndividual pa

o contact in

learning pro

keeping a le

complex to

d is well-gro

onnect earlie

ssess learni

ost common

to the user

E-learning: A

laatukriteerit,


sociation of

roduced by

ected point

ct of any giv

earning res

nt as a pa

ncludes:

s teaching a

e learner, c

ria will ensu

be easily ac

length.

group. Wha

can be use

ace.

case of tech

ocess of di

earning port

opics

unded and

er knowledg

ng process

n devices

can be fou

Benchmarkin

Työryhmän ra

Public


Distance T

y experts a

ts formed b

ven platform

sults. Howe

rt of a com

and learnin

challenging

ure that the

ccessible an

at kind of

ed for differ

hnical prob

ifferent type

tfolio

up-to-date

ge to new to

s

nd easily

ng Approach, E

aportti 2005, O


Teaching U

appointed b

basis, a ch

m is to crea

ver, in prac

mplex and in

g accuratel

exercises,

e platform p

nd compreh

skills/know

rent type of

lems or oth

e of users

opics

EADTU, Third

Opetushallitus

S


Universities8

by the Finn

hecklist for

ate learning

ctice, it is d

ndividual le

y and offer

validity an

provides va

hensive. Ho

wledge are

f learning/te

er inquiries

and offers

Edition, 2016

, Edita, Helsin


Duration:


88 as well a

ish Nationa

r the IECE

results. On

difficult to d

earning pro

rs pedagog

nd meaning

lue for both

ow the conte

needed to

eaching. Po

s

a possibilit

6.

nki, 2006, 12.

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


40

as “Verkko-

al Board of

EU platform

ne indicator

emonstrate

cess.90 The

ical value.

gfulness of

h teachers

ent can be

o use the

ossibility to

ty for self-

U

5 s

r t

0

-

f

m

r

e

e


Thgrares

Navigatio

When app

Content is

The most

System p

course of

Visualisat

high quali

Text flows

difficult

Quality o

Content i

allocation

Learning

End-user

Content d

Platform w

Technical

User feed

Received

The develo

feedback f

1. Analysis

2. Develop

3. Initial tes

4. Piloting

5. Revising

developme

consultatio

and/or dire



on on the sit

plicable, the

s divided in

t important f

provides fee

f action)

tions, includ

ity and they

s and there

of the deve

is develope

n of resource

objectives a

needs are

design is ca

will be doub

l maintenan

dback is col

improveme

opment wor

from the con

s of required

ping and cod

sting of the

of the revis

g the final s

ent phases

ons with the

ect consulta

elopment


ny use that may

te is smooth

e content is

to managea

features of

edback sup

ding voice-o

y run smoot

e are no gra

lopment pr

ed in a pre

es)

are clearly s

taken into a

arried out by

ble-checked

nce is agree

lected and

ent suggest

rk of the NM

nsortium me

d specificat

ding the pla

product (in

sed platform

structure an

s and on

e end-user

ations with s


h

printable (c

able parts

the platform

pporting the

overs (to ma

hly

ammatical m

rogress

e-planned a

set and refle

account and

y experts on

d carefully b

ed and conf

analysed re

tions are, w

MLA consis

embers and

ions,

atform,

cluding fee

m; additional

d learning o

the collec

s (EEAS, v

stakeholders

Public


certificate)

m are self-ex

e learning p

ake it possi

mistakes wh

and docum

ected in the

d reflected i

n the subjec

before the la

firmed prior

egularly

when applica

sts of five d

d end-users

dback colle

l phase to c

objectives b

cted feedb

various trai

s.


xplanatory

process if (

ble to study

hich would

mented man

e process

in the conte

ct matter

aunch

to the laun

able, execut

different dev

s.

ection and s

complete the

based on th

back). Key

ining institu

S


(correct or

y content in

make unde

nner (timeli

ent

ch

ted

velopment p

ubsequent

e developm

e experienc

points: u

utions etc.),


Duration:


incorrect a

mute settin

erstanding

ines, respo

phases inte

improveme

ment cycle

ce obtained

user-center

, online bas

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


41

nswers or

ng), are of

of the text

onsibilities,

egrating the

ent,

d during the

approach,

sed survey

U

5 s

r t

e

e

,

y


Thgrares

The develo

the future

Moreover,

stakeholde

1. Ana

The projec

each of the

visual elem

user/learni

quality e-le

process. In

This pract

description

the analyti



opment pro

needs eith

the proces

ers.

alysis of req

ct required a

e case stud

ments/anim

ng experie

earning env

nitially, the

tical appro

n of EU cris

cal chapter

elopment


ny use that may

F

ocess circle

her based

ss is charac

quired spec

a light platfo

dies and sub

mations usin

ence. Moreo

vironments.

structure w

ach has b

sis manage

r which sum


igure 2 NML

e describes

on up-dati

cterised with

cifications

orm where t

bsequent a

ng gamified

over, a des

The conte

was seen to

been maint

ment follow

mmaries an

Public


LA developm

the continu

ing the con

h feedback

to embed th

nalysis. Mo

d features

sk study w

ent of the N

reflect the

tained in t

wed by the

d presents


ment proces

uing develo

ntent/structu

k and inputs

he content

oreover, the

to create

was conduc

NMLA devol

content and

the structu

eight case

the most im

S


ss.

opment of t

ure or cha

s form the e

providing se

content wa

more enga

cted to draw

ved in the

d elements

re that co

study desc

mportant pr


Duration:


the platform

anging train

end-users a

elected info

as designed

aging and

w from exi

course of t

of the IEC

onsist of in

criptions an

roject findin

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


42

m related to

ning needs.

and various

ormation on

d to include

motivating

isting good

the drafting

EU project.

ntroduction,

nd finally by

ngs. A desk

U

5 s

r t

2

o

.

s

n

e

g

d

g

.

,

y

k


Thgrares

study was

relevant op

2. Dev

The conte

consortium

selected su

discussed

developed

provide de

3. Init

The initial

selected g

were colle

integrated

4. Pilo

Piloting wa

to participa

age. Only

manageme

disciplines

expertise i

the piloting

divided into

the test o

group was

second tes

use the pla



conducted

ptions are li

veloping an

ent and stru

m partners w

ubject expe

with the W

in a dialog

etailed guida

ial testing

testing of

roup of in-h

cted and re

into earlier

oting

as organise

ate in the te

few partic

ent activitie

. Some of t

in eLearnin

g phase is i

o two parts

rganisers o

s to collect

st group wa

atform.

elopment


ny use that may

d to identity

sted and co

nd coding pl

ucture of t

who also in

erts were co

WP5 partners

gue with gr

ance for ani

the produc

house expe

eflected in t

developing

ed in Laurea

esting phas

cipants had

es. The maj

test persons

ng/gamificat

included as

. The first g

on the platf

information

as not provid


application

ompared in

latform

he NMLA

n a broad se

onsulted du

s in regular

raphic desig

mation dev

ct was carr

erts were co

the subsequ

g and coding

a University

se. The test

d detailed

ority prese

s were ICT

tion (the qu

s Annex 2).

group receiv

form. The

n on the pl

ded prior in

Public


ns available

the section

in the Opig

ense prese

ring the pro

r conference

gner and IC

velopment in

ried out in

onsulted to

uent develo

g phase.

y of applied

t group con

knowledge

nted exper

T experts an

uestionnaire

The test g

ved instruct

main goal

atform con

nformation o


e for eLearn

n technical s

gno platfor

ent the end-

ocess. The d

e calls. The

CT expert.

ncluding vo

the course

comment o

opment pha

science. S

nsisted of b

e of the EU

ienced aca

nd/or held

e used in

roup was

tions from

with this

tent. The

on how to

Figu

S


ning platfor

specification

rm was dra

-users of th

developmen

e structure a

A detailed

ice-overs.

of the dev

on the tenta

ases. Initial

Some 20 pa

both men an

U conflict

demic rese

ure 3 IECE


Duration:


rm creation

ns.

afted in dia

he platform.

nt process

and visualis

script was

velopment

ative draft.

testing was

articipants w

nd women

prevention

earchers fro

EU NMLA

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


43

. The most

alogue with

. Moreover,

was further

sation were

s drafted to

process. A

The inputs

s moreover

were invited

of different

and crisis

om different

Pilot event

U

5 s

r t

3

t

h

,

r

e

o

A

s

r

d

t

s

t

t


Thgrares

As a resul

The collect

5. Rev

The final s

that all pro

Moreover,

Figure 4 Th

The curren

summaries

the root ca

and many

91 The test gof randomly sEvaluation R



t, the seco

ted informa

vision of the

stage of the

oject findings

the process

he timeline o

nt structure

s of the eig

auses of the

cases ove

roup providedselected anim

Report.

elopment


ny use that may

nd group m

ation was the

e final versi

e developme

s will be inte

s was trans

of the NMLA

of the NM

ght case stu

e respective

rall findings

d inputs on ove

mation. The tes


mainly prod

en assesse

on

ent is carrie

egrated into

sferred to th

A developme

LA includes

udies cover

e conflict, d

s an assess

erall layout of sting phase an

Public


uced feedb

ed and fed in

ed out in the

o the eLear

he timeline o

ent

s seven mo

red by the I

description

sment of th

the site, commnd related find


back on cla

nto develop

e course of

ning platfor

of the NMLA

odules/chap

IECEU. The

of the EU m

he situation

ments on the dings will be e

S


rity of navig

pment proce

f the remain

rm.

A developm

pters. The m

e summarie

mission/ope

. As the inf

used visual ellaborated in m


Duration:


gation in th

ess.91

ning months

ment in the b

modules wi

es include o

eration, con

formation a

lements, colormore detail the

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


44

he platform.

s to ensure

beginning.

ll introduce

overview of

nflict parties

available on

rs and contente IECEU D5.5

U

5 s

r t

4

.

e

e

f

s

n

t 5


Thgrares

the platform

consult the

eLearning

1. The eigh

2. Compar

3. General

The main e

3.5 ANIM

In the beg

developme

developed

designer d

work. Crea

setting. It w

programmi

changes.

visualisatio

was also d

reasons. T

would idea

to certain

recycled in

were accor

1. PR

2. Poo

3. Fra

4. Mis

5. Han



m can be o

e entire case

platform ar

ht (8) case s

rative finding

Competen

elements of

MATIONS,

ginning, the

ent process

. The visu

during M15-

ation of mo

was decided

ing time ma

Although th

ons were p

discussed. T

The picture

ally not be r

cases and

n the platfo

rding to the

R and setting

oling and sh

agmented a

ssion manda

ndover

elopment


ny use that may

only very lim

e study stor

re;

studies

gs

ces in Conf

f NMLA incl

VISUAL I

e new med

. In total, in

alisations w

-M18. The p

ore sophist

d to use ca

anageable a

he serious

referred to

The develo

es should n

recognisable

possibly se

orm providin

e IECEU cas

g expectatio

haring

pproach

ate


mited, the u

red at the IE

flict Prevent

ude differen

MAGES (H

dia support

n the course

were devel

project time

icated serio

rtoon like vi

and on the o

topic of c

keep light.

opers conclu

not show a

e. The real

et prior exp

ng long-term

se-based fin

ons

Public


users are p

ECEU web

tion and Cr

nt new med

HTML5) A

ted possibi

e of the proc

loped in a

eline and av

ous-game-li

isualisation

other hand

crisis mana

The possi

uded that u

ny operatio

pictures wo

pectations.

m building

ndings (WP


rovided wit

site. The th

isis Manage

dia functiona

AND VOIC

ilities were

cess, 13 an

cooperatio

vailable res

ike elemen

s from one

rather flexib

agement is

bility of usi

using photo

onal activiti

ould also co

Finally, the

blocks for t

P2-WP4):

S


h a link tha

hree main e

ement

alities, such

E-OVER

analysed

nimation the

on with ICT

ources set

ts would h

hand to kee

ble to accom

linked to

ng authenti

graphs is c

es. The pe

onnect cont

e animation

the platform


Duration:


at would allo

elements of

h as animat

in the IEC

emes (ANN

T expert a

certain fram

have require

ep the deve

mmodate a

human su

ic pictures

challenging

ersons in th

tent to spec

visualisatio

m. Created

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


45

ow them to

f the IECEU

ions.

CEU NMLA

EX 3) were

nd graphic

mes for the

ed different

eloping and

ny possible

ffering, the

and videos

for several

he pictures

cific themes

ons can be

animations

U

5 s

r t

5

o

U

A

e

c

e

t

d

e

e

s

l

s

s

e

s


Thgrares

6. Coo

7. Mo

8. Sec

9. Ge

10. EU

11. Mo

12. Nat

13. Dep

To balance

and challe

structure a

line with th

way, the a

generic be

further elab

The develo

and other

visualise th

several rea

not easily

visualisatio

importantly

criticism - e

the comple

came out

decided to

for the anim

(co-creatio

persons w

the person

seconds lo

problem ba



ordination a

onitoring pat

curity secto

nder

’s political f

onitoring me

tional staff

ployment of

e the conte

enges the E

allows the u

he idea tha

animations

eginning. Th

borated in D

opment of t

type of clea

he IECEU t

asons for th

y translated

ons establis

y, conflict

even when

ex contexts

in a peer

create gen

mations we

on) and on

who have wo

nnel can fa

ong) are fo

ased learnin

elopment


ny use that may

and exchan

trol

or reform an

framework f

entoring and

f mission/op

ent, the ani

EU staff co

user, if she/

at IECEU N

can be stu

hey can be

D5.4 Trainin

he animatio

ar and com

hemes. In t

his. Firstly, t

d into vis

shed certai

prevention

it can be su

in a balanc

review dur

neric animat

ere selected

various the

orked in the

ace in vario

ollowed by

ng approac


ge of inform

d functionin

for crisis ap

d advising

peration

mations we

nfronts dur

he wishes t

NMLA provi

udied indivi

e used in th

ng for the Tr

ons was a p

mprehensive

the course

the themes

sualisations

n limits wh

and crisis

ubstantiated

ced way can

ring the ini

tions which

d and devel

emes which

e CSDP mi

ous mission

quiz. Ped

h which is l

Public


mation

ng defence

pproach

ere created

ring the CS

to do so, to

des a com

idually. For

he context o

rainers curr

process. Init

e narratives

of the proce

(capabilitie

. The tim

hat was fea

managem

d – in a form

n be seen o

itial animat

bear a rele

oped both

h have bee

issions/ope

ns and ope

dagogically

ine with lea


to reflect a

SDP missio

o concentra

plimentary

r this reaso

of diverse p

ricula).

tially, the id

from the in

ess, this pro

es) of the IE

meframe an

asible and

ment topics

m of short a

offensive an

tion develo

evance to th

based on th

n identified

rations. Top

erations. Th

the contai

arning const

S


also some

ns and ope

te on speci

training/lea

on, the anim

presentation

dea was to i

ndividual ca

oved out to

CEU conce

nd resourc

what not.

are often

animations w

nd create u

pment pha

he most of t

he findings

important

pics provide

he short an

n elements

tructivist ide


Duration:


of the conc

erations. Th

ific modules

arning tool.

mations ha

ns (the cur

identify goo

ase studies

o be difficult

eptual frame

ces allocat

Finally, per

sensitive.

which cann

nwished fric

ase. Therefo

the cases. T

from the ca

by the end

e pragmatic

nimations (

s of case

eas.

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


46

crete topics

he modular

s. This is in

In a same

ave a short

riculum will

od practices

that would

t. There are

ework were

ed to the

rhaps most

Presenting

not describe

ctions. This

ore, it was

The themes

ase studies

d-users and

c examples

(roughly 30

based and

U

5 s

r t

6

s

r

n

e

t

l

s

d

e

e

e

t

g

e

s

s

s

s

d

s

0

d


Thgrares

Opigno allo

containing

functions

allocation

programme

easier ma

easily revis

the interac

ICT expert

3.6 NMLA

Evaluation

continuous

Moreover,

undertakin

provided in

5.5 of the I

Backgrou

NMLA will

learning to

prepared

evaluation

To

To

To

pub



ows use of

interactive

have been

these func

e the anima

nageable.

sed and cha

ctive elemen

tise and mo

A EVALUA

of the IEC

sly up-date

the evaluat

gs in this fi

n the follow

IECEU proje

nd

be evalua

ool, sustain

by M30 a

. The main

improve its

gather less

provide a b

blic, and inte

elopment


ny use that may

f various HT

e elements

n utilized in

ctionalities

ations to ha

Now, as th

anged with

nts would h

ore resource

ATION

EU NMLA c

e and impr

tion of the d

eld. For the

ing. The ev

ect.

ated under

nable use o

and encom

purpose of

s content aft

sons learned

basis for acc

erested thir


TP5 elemen

can be em

n the deve

can be ac

ave HTP5 fe

he quiz are

a little fami

have been

es.

can be see

rove the c

developmen

e purpose o

valuation wi

the followi

of resource

pass the

the NMLA

ter the testin

d for future

countability

rd parties.

Public


nts. In prac

mbedded int

eloped platf

ctivated lat

eatures also

created us

iliarisation b

integrated

en as an inte

content and

nt process c

of this delive

ll be elabor

ng approac

s and impa

overall find

evaluation

ng period;

activities w

y, including


ctice, this m

to the platfo

form. Howe

er on whe

o keeps the

sing Opign

by a person

into animat

egral part o

d functiona

can provide

erable, an o

rated furthe

ch to asse

act on the

dings from

is:

within the pro

the provisio

S


eans that a

orm. Only s

ever, with

en needed.

quiz which

o tools, the

with admin

ions, any c

of the quality

ality of the

e helpful les

overview of

r as a part

ss and gua

users. Eva

the comp

oject;

on of inform


Duration:


animations

some of th

limited ICT

The cho

h follow the

e text cont

nistrator righ

changes wo

y control an

e eLearning

ssons to sup

f the evalua

of the task/

arantee qu

aluation rep

prehensive

mation to the

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


47

and videos

e available

T expertise

oice not to

animations

ent can be

hts. In case

ould require

nd a way to

g platform.

pport future

ation will be

/deliverable

ality of the

port will be

eLearning

e donor, the

U

5 s

r t

7

s

e

e

o

s

e

e

e

o

.

e

e

e

e

e

g

e


Thgrares

Methodolo

Since it is

the acquir

multifacete

carry out s

“level of e

Reaction, l

assessmen

of evaluat

evaluations

Mission (IE

Categorie

Since it is

the acquir

multifacete

carry out s

“level of ev

systematic

CEP) will c

by the prod

NMLA Imp

92 KirkpatrickInstructional



ogy

a long path

red skills b

ed in order

several type

evaluation.”

learning, be

nt of the NM

tion that co

s by the us

EM).

s and Type

a long path

red skills b

ed in order

several type

valuation.” F

c and comp

conduct diff

ducers, NM

pact Evaluat

k, D. L., TechnTechnology, V

elopment


ny use that may

h from the e

by the eLe

to identify

es of evalua

Four such

ehaviour, an

MLA and its

orrespond

sers, In- and

es of NMLA

h from the e

by the eLe

to identify

es of evalua

Four such l

prehensive a

ferent types

MLA evaluat

tion Mission

niques for evaVol. 1, Englew


stablishmen

earning too

which aspe

ation, which

h levels of

nd results.

s impact, IE

to the four

d Out-Tests

A Evaluatio

stablishmen

earning too

which aspe

ation, which

evels of eva

assessmen

s of evaluati

tions by the

n (IEM).

luating trainingwood: Libraries

Public


nt of the NM

ol in the m

ects of NML

h involve a d

f evaluation

In order to

ECEU partne

r levels: N

s for the use

on

nt of the NM

ol in the m

ects of NML

h involve a d

aluation ca

nt of the NM

ion that cor

e users, In-

g programs ins Unlimited, 19


MLA to the p

mission, ef

LA need ad

different sub

n can be d

guarantee

ers (mostly

NMLA evalu

ers and pos

MLA to the p

mission, ef

LA need ad

different sub

n be disting

MLA and its

rrespond to

and Out-T

n Ely, D. P. & P979, 231-241.

S


possible ac

ffective eva

djustments.

bject matter

distinguishe

a systemat

CEP) will c

uation by t

ssibly a NM

possible ac

ffective eva

djustments.

bject matter

guished.92 In

s impact, IE

the four lev

ests for the

Plomp T. (Eds


Duration:


ctual implem

aluation ne

Hence, it

r or aims at

ed (Kirkpat

tic and com

conduct diff

the produc

MLA Impact

ctual implem

aluation ne

Hence, it

r or aims at

n order to g

ECEU partn

vels: NMLA

e users and

s.), Classic Wr

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


48

mentation of

eeds to be

is useful to

t a different

trick 1979):

mprehensive

ferent types

ers, NMLA

Evaluation

mentation of

eeds to be

is useful to

t a different

guarantee a

ers (mostly

A evaluation

d possibly a

ritings on

U

5 s

r t

8

f

e

o

t

:

e

s

A

n

f

e

o

t

a

y

n

a


Thgrares

Evaluation

Type

NMLA

Evaluation

In- and

Out-Test

6-Month-

Post

Questionna

ire



n Descrip

Evalu

produ

and

and

users

users

eLea

Peer

mem

Task

Feed

end o

Grou

partic

befor

part

of th

indivi

respe

chec

succe

a

The

case

gathe

taking

the

befor

elopment


ny use that may

ption

uation rep

ucer, partne

a piloting g

some agre

s): Focus

s perce

rning tool

review b

bers

leader repo

dback by th

of the eLear

p of use

cipate in tw

re and one

in the NML

he test is

idual perfor

ective user,

k on t

ess.

questionn

it will be

er a group

g part in NM

pre-deploy

re deploym


ports by

er organisat

group (pilot

eed group

lies on h

eived

by consorti

ort

e users at

rning tool

ers have

wo tests, o

e after tak

LA. The foc

not on

rmance of

, but rather

the learn

aire will

e possible

of person

MLA as par

ment train

ment to

Public


Level

Evalu

the

tion

ting

of

how

the

ium

the

React

to

one

king

cus

the

the

r to

ning

Learn

(in

to

nnel

rt of

ning

the

Beha


l of

uation

Pu

tion

ning

viour

S


urpose

“General e

success b

the users.”

Addresses

Reflects us

satisfaction

Measure o

learning.

Identificatio

and tec

understood

participants

knowledge

Estimation

of lear

behaviour.

Feedback

designing

future need


Duration:


estimate of

based upon

”

s users’ exp

sers’ opinio

n”).

of feelings,

on of prin

chniques

d and abs

s (cogn

e).

of NMLA-r

rning/knowl

to those in

NMLA con

ds.

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


49

f the NML

n the views

erience.

ons (“custom

not of act

nciples, fa

that w

sorbed by

nitive sk

related trans

ledge

nvolved in (

ntent to m

U

5 s

r t

9

LA’s

s of

mer

tual

cts,

were

the

kills,

sfer

into

re-)

meet


Thgrares

Impact

Evaluation

Mission

(IEM)



missi

perso

traini

deplo

to wh

to ap

skills

for th

Espe

integ

missi

ability

chan

organ

contr

imple

respe

Throu

interv

impa

1) C

k

n

2) T

in

3) T

in

b

p

fu

m

elopment


ny use that may

ion or a

onnel not

ng but only

oyment) se

hat degree

pply the kn

acquired

heir work in

ecially, the

rate quick

ion enviro

y to becom

ge wi

nisation, an

ribute

ementation

ective missi

ugh

views, IEM

ct NMLA h

Capacity b

nowledge,

etworks;

The use of c

ndividual in

The impa

ndividual u

uilt by NM

erformance

ulfilling t

mandate.


a group

receiving a

y NMLA bef

rve to asse

users are a

nowledge a

in the NM

n the missi

e ability

kly into

onment,

me agents

thin th

d the ability

to

of

on mandate

qualitat

M analyse

ad on:

building,

skills, attitu

capacity by

a mission;

act of

sing capa

LA on his/

e and

the miss

Public


of

any

fore

ess

able

and

MLA

ion.

to

the

the

of

heir

y to

the

the

e.

tive

the

i.e.

ude,

the

the

city

/her

in

sion

Resul


lts

S


Estimation

related b

organizatio

implemente

reasons

because o

data (two

compared

environmen

the NMLA

in it; perso

assess bot

performam

evaluation

of this proje


Duration:


of impac

behavioural

on (very d

ed due

but most

of to the lac

o groups

in t

nt, one not

and the oth

onnel supe

th groups r

mce in the

would go b

ect).

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


50

ct of NM

change

difficult to

to vario

t importa

ck of base

shuuld

he miss

t taking par

her taking p

ervisors sho

related to th

mission. S

beyond the a

U

5 s

r t

0

LA-

on

be

ous

ntly

line

be

sion

rt in

part

ould

heir

uch

aim


Thgrares

It is impor

achieved w

a compreh

later stage

number of

questioned

cooperatio

members t

Additionall

also gathe

participant

(number of

made ava

suggestio

to assess

environme

Since NML

leader to t

will be as

participant

complete a

NMLA. Tes

beginning

related to C

IECEU Qu

functionalit

related eva

by the imp

93 It is difficuof the training



rtant to note

within the IE

hensive and

e, once the

users could

d about po

on with ESD

to use it as

y to the abo

er informatio

s have actu

f wrong and

ailable for

ons for the i

a group

ent and che

LA is not in

rack all tho

sured, the

s in anony

an IN test p

sts will be a

of the test,

CSDP miss

uality Assu

ty, reliability

aluation of t

plementing/p

lt to assess atg.

elopment


ny use that may

e that the d

ECEU conte

d thorough

training org

d be detect

otential ben

DC such a

part of the

ove mention

on about th

ually compl

d right answ

users to l

mprovemen

of represe

ck after 6 m

ntended for

ose various

NMLA wil

ymous in-

prior to taki

anonymous

, which allo

sions.

rance Plan

y, usability,

the tool. Th

producing o

t this stage to


different lev

ext! Wherea

way, the fo

ganisations

ted prior to

nefits of N

IEM could

induction tra

ned evaluat

he number

leted it. The

wers they sc

eave a qu

nt of the co

entatives de

months in w

r one type

audiences

l be evalua

and out-t

ng part in t

but each s

ows the org

n (D9.4) lis

efficiency,

is part of th

organization

which level th

Public


vels of eva

as the first

ollowing lev

and missio

their deploy

MLA relate

actually be

aining).93

tion of the u

of logins

e eLearning

cored) and

ualitative

ntent. Ideal

eploying to

what way th

of the aud

using the t

ated by ch

tests. A g

the NMLA a

student will

ganisers to

ts several

maintainab

he evaluatio

n (Laurea) a

he training org


aluation acc

and second

vels should

ons started

yment and t

ed to their

e organised

usability of

to the learn

g tool will a

at the end

feedback

ly, an evalu

o a missio

he eLearnin

dience only,

tool. Theref

hecking the

roup of stu

and an OUT

receive a n

assess any

technolog

bility and p

on will be as

as well as in

ganisations an

S


cording to K

d level can

rather be s

using the N

then tracke

assignmen

d or if the m

the tool, the

ning enviro

also provide

of the NML

about the

uation missi

n, who co

g has helpe

, it might b

ore a testin

e learning p

udents will

T test after

umber, whic

y improvem

y quality

ortability fo

ssured in a

n a peer rev

d missions wi


Duration:


Kirckpatrick

and will be

seen as po

NMLA and

ed into the m

nt in the m

missions ad

e evaluation

nment and

e results o

LA, some sp

NMLA an

ion would b

ompleted th

ed them at

be difficult f

ng group o

progress o

namely be

r the comple

ch he would

ment in the

indicators

or a proper

comprehen

view by the

ill include the

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


51

cannot be

covered in

ossible at a

a sufficient

mission and

mission (in

dvised their

n report will

how many

of the quiz

pace will be

nd possible

be launched

he learning

their work.

for the task

f personnel

f individual

e asked to

eting of the

d put at the

knowledge

related to

technology

nsive report

e partnering

NMLA as part

U

5 s

r t

e

n

a

t

d

n

r

l

y

z

e

e

d

g

.

k

l

l

o

e

e

e

o

y

t

g

t


Thgrares

organizatio

financial co

Limitation

It is impor

described

Whereas t

coverage

changes a

NMLA. A

Baseline re

not indente

changes in

personnel

students. U

does not g

address th

NMLA itse

3.7 RELE

The releva

deliverable

retiming of

(DR Cong

received b

create the

be up-date

Drupal/Opi

rights to ea

are more d

requires di



on (CEP). T

ontribution a

ns of the de

rtant to stre

above mos

the first and

of the follo

are often h

shortcomin

ecording of

ed for profe

n the worki

who will t

Users may

guarantee th

his issue as

lf.

EVANCE T

ance and

es, namely

f the WP5.1

o) due to

by the end o

structure fo

ed and revis

igno based

asily perform

difficult to be

iverse expe

elopment


ny use that may

This parts of

and possibl

escribed ev

ess again th

st probably

d second le

owing level

arder to m

ng of many

f qualificatio

essional aud

ng environm

take part in

have also

hat they will

s well, sinc

TO CURRE

entry poin

in 5.3 NM

1 (Compara

partner cha

of the WP5

or the platfo

sed until the

open sourc

m changes

e revised a

ertise in for


f report will

e constrain

valuation c

hat the diffe

y cannot be

evel are co

s are test

measure tha

y eLearning

on, occupat

dience only

ment will be

n NMLA a

acquired th

l implement

ce that does

ENT CSDP

nts of IECE

LA Handbo

ative review

ange not a

5.2. Howeve

orm within th

e very end o

ce code pla

in the NML

nd changed

m of progra

Public


also descr

nts at produc

cycle

erent levels

e fully achie

overed (in-

fields, sinc

an reaction

g evaluatio

tion and ex

y but wider a

e limited to

s part of t

he necessa

t in their wo

s not nece

P TRAININ

EU NMLA

ook and 5.4

w of the ana

all the mate

er, this was

he allocated

of the projec

atform was t

LA content.

d due to the

amming, gr


ibe the proc

cing the NM

s of evalua

eved within

& out-tests

ce individua

and learn

ons is also

xperience a

audiences,

o the two g

the pre-dep

ary knowled

orking envir

essarily mea

NG

will be d

4 Training f

alysed case

erials neede

s foreseen

d timeframe

ct. One of th

that it allow

The anima

e fact that w

raphic desig

S


cess of the

MLA.

tion accord

the IECEU

s, NMLA ev

al level and

ing directly

the absen

re critical b

the impact

roups ment

ployment tr

dge, skills, a

onment, the

an there is

iscussed f

for the train

e studies) a

ed for refin

and the ob

e. The conte

he underlyin

ws the instan

ations, inste

work on them

gn, copy wr


Duration:


planning, p

ding to Kirc

U and NML

valuation re

d organisa

y after com

nce of bas

but since th

of it and an

tioned abov

raining and

and attitude

e evaluation

a shortcom

further in o

ners curricu

and delay w

ning the co

bject of the

ent of the p

ng reasons

nce with ad

ead, are ele

m is resourc

riting and v

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


52

preparation,

ckpatrick as

LA context!

eports), the

tional level

mpleting the

seline data.

he NMLA is

ny resulting

ve, mission

d university

es, but this

n report will

ming in the

other WP5

ula. Due to

with WP 3.1

ontent were

5.2 was to

latform can

for utilizing

ministrator-

ements that

ce heavy: it

voice-overs.

U

5 s

r t

2

,

s

!

e

l

e

.

s

g

n

y

s

l

e

5

o

e

o

n

g

-

t

t

.


Thgrares

Neverthele

animations

According

based on t

to contribu

specific civ

should enc

experts wi

knowledge

objectives

areas.95” It

be assesse

for that wh

based on

environme

unplanned

improve th

(the lack o

former CS

year-long f

the EU wa

Various do

ensure tha

coordinate

94 Europe’s Nwas initiateddeployment ithe end of thabout the polife and secuconduct. 95 ENTRi, Eucourse, SloveDepoyment_



ess, with n

s.

to the ENT

the assump

ute to the cr

vilian crisis

courage a

th heteroge

e about the

of the mis

t logically fo

ed, structur

hich instant

new media

ents availab

duplicatio

e general u

of easily ac

DP mission

field office

s or what th

ocuments (E

at all the sta

ed sharing o

New Training d in early 201in an internatihe training, palitical backgrourity issues. T

urope’s New Tenia 2012, 4, a

_Course_Conc

elopment


ny use that may

ew resourc

TRi94 course

ption that tra

reation of a

manageme

high degre

eneous bac

situation in

ssion itself

ollows that a

red and mad

tly support

a technolog

ble in a co

n. When m

understandi

ccessible k

n member s

presence m

hey were do

ENTRi ibid,

aff are on th

of existing e

Initiative for C11. ENTRI pronal crisis maarticipants wilound and the rThe courses w

Training Initiatiavailable at: h

cept.pdf


ces, the pl

e concept f

ainees have

common id

ent mission

e of group

ckgrounds is

the missio

despite the

also the var

de available

this. Firstly

gy is expen

oordinated

made, at le

ngs of the o

knowledge c

stated that i

many memb

oing in the r

interviews)

he same pa

eLearning to

Civilian Crisis Mrovides civiliaanagement mil have acquirerole of the miswill also raise

ive for Civilianhttp://www.entr

Public


latform can

for pre-dep

e received a

dentity and

among the

work, disc

s highly be

n specific c

e fact that

rious eLear

e in a comp

y, designin

nsive and ti

manner wo

east partial

objectives o

can hampe

in spite of t

bers of the

region.)

) high light t

age in the b

ools can co

Management an experts wiission, irrespeed knowledgession. They we awareness f

n Crisis Managriforccm.eu/ce


n always b

ployment tra

a generic co

purpose for

future miss

cussions an

eneficial in o

country as w

they will b

rning trainin

prehensive c

g and impl

me consum

ould create

ly accessib

of the EU cr

er missions

the EU brok

local popul

the need fo

beginning of

ntribute to t

(ENTRi) is a uth the basic

ective of the se about specifwill be familiar for inter-cultu

gement Coursertification/dev

S


e amended

aining, “the

ore course b

r the missio

sion person

nd role play

order that t

well as the m

be engaged

g course an

catalogue. T

lementing l

ming task. M

e synergies

ble for larg

isis prevent

work on o

kered peace

ation did no

r standard

f their deplo

these efforts

unique capaciknowledge a

pecific functiofic conflicts anwith the challeral issues, ge

e Concept forveloped course


Duration:


d by introd

training cu

beforehand

on specific c

nnel. Since

ys, the part

trainees gai

mandate an

d in differe

nd applicati

There are tw

learning en

Making the

s for trainin

ger audienc

tion and ma

operational

e accords a

ot seem to

pre-mission

oyment. Im

ts. Additiona

ity-building proand soft skillsons they fulfil ind their partieenges of miss

ender affairs,

r the pre-deploes/assets/pdf/

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


53

ducing new

urriculum is

d and seeks

country and

the training

ticipation of

in objective

nd strategic

ent working

ions should

wo reasons

nvironments

e eLearning

ng, prevent

ce, it could

anagement.

level. One

and several

know what

n training to

proved and

ally, the EU

ogramme thats required forin the field. Ates, as well assion work andand personal

oyment /Pre-

U

5 s

r t

3

w

s

s

d

g

f

e

c

g

d

s

s

g

t

d

.

e

l

t

o

d

U

t r t s d l


Thgrares

emphasize

various as

manageme

topics can

comprehen

humanitari

crisis prev

approach t

see them

security. If

through po

scenarios

would requ

then requi

have clea

EU/interna

Points for

As a part

assess the

manageme

effectively

further to m

Trainer – t

is not to

interaction

would also

platform fu

as to ident



es the con

spects: tra

ent…) Using

n enhance

nsive eLear

an aid). NM

vention and

the crisis fro

as an inte

f EU (and

olicy means

need to res

uire suppor

re military

ar financial

ational comm

r future dev

of the expe

e knowledg

ent to impro

in the future

more achiev

rainees inte

replace co

with a trai

o provide a

urther: insta

ify possible

elopment


ny use that may

cept of co

de politics

g existing a

mission me

rning tools o

MLA can p

crisis man

om a differe

rconnected

entire inter

s (trade poli

sort to hum

t in a form

crisis mana

implicatio

munity will h

velopment

ert consulta

ge of the u

ove the lear

e. This ‘big

ve better lea

eraction. As

onventional

iner coud d

fast way to

ant hot-wash

e knowledge


omprehensiv

, foreign p

and develop

embers und

on security

rovide a co

naging throu

ent angle. O

chain of e

national co

tics, sanctio

manitarian a

of civilian c

agement ef

ons: the re

have to reso

ation, it was

users (the

rning enviro

data’ could

arning resul

s stated, the

training.

deepen the

o collect fe

h-up with a

e gaps to be

Public


ve security

policy, elec

ping new ve

derstanding

in field. The

omprehensi

ugh offering

One way to

events whic

ommunity) f

ons, embar

aid (coordin

crisis mana

fforts. Thes

elated cost

ort to next p

s mentioned

most com

onment as w

d then provid

lts.

e main obje

Blended

understand

edback to

trainer/me

e covered b


y. The com

ction obser

rsatile eLea

g of the su

e Harvard U

ive tool to c

g an easy

o observe d

ch also ref

fails to prev

rgo, diploma

ated by EC

gement (M

se four sim

ts will inc

phase.

d that the u

mon mista

well as to ad

de a way to

ct of improv

training po

ding of the

improve the

ntor to dee

better in vari

S


mprehensive

rvation, cri

arning instru

ubject (for i

University of

create more

tool to put

evelopment

lects the id

vent escala

atic negotia

CHO. Furthe

MA, SSR).

plified phas

rease cons

user replies

kes) on co

ddress the id

o develop an

ved eLearni

ossibly con

platform us

e content o

pen users’

ious training


Duration:


e security

sis preven

uments cov

instance, th

ffers eLearn

re holistic a

on a differ

t leading to

dea of com

ation in a f

ations), then

er worsenin

The final s

ses are con

siderably e

s could be c

onflict prev

dentified th

nd refine cr

ing and use

sisting fee

sers of the

or functiona

understand

g activities.

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


54

consists of

ntion, crisis

vering these

he UN has

ning tool on

approach to

rent hat, to

o crisis is to

mprehensive

ragile state

n it in many

ng situation

stage would

nsidered to

every time

collected to

vention and

emes more

risis training

e of NMLAs

dback and

e content. It

lities of the

ding as well

U

5 s

r t

4

f

s

e

s

n

o

o

o

e

e

y

n

d

o

e

o

d

e

g

s

d

t

e

l


Thgrares

4 CONCL

The devel

versatile t

complimen

platform or

for many

contains fu

The chapt

developme

be carried

study on D

platform. C

different re

from the co

this, draftin

that the ca

elaborated

challenge s

In a same

by the exi

planned to

themes we

who are a

themes we

concluded

potentially

result, it w

number of

seconded

chapter tw

utilized.



LUSIONS

oped IECE

tool for ga

ntary trainin

r as a part o

other types

unctionalitie

ter three s

ent phases

out also la

DR Congo

Composing

equirements

omputer sc

ng good se

ase studies

d questions

still needs t

way, draftin

isting skills

o reflect the

ere identifie

also experts

ere conside

that, for i

a critical sh

was decided

f identified

staff to mis

wo, the train

elopment


ny use that may

EU Learning

athering a

g and learn

of larger cri

s of training

es (H5P) tha

shed light

are not rigi

ater on. Fu

D3.1 were

good qual

s needed in

reen and ye

et of questio

seek to con

. On the o

to be includ

ng animatio

s, resources

findings fro

d in all of th

s on the s

red sensitiv

instance, s

hort animat

d to create

issues –

ssions and o

ning potenti


g Tool serv

nd dissem

ning tool for

sis. Finally,

g content.

at allows cre

on the de

id and new

rthermore,

e delayed

ity content

n an online t

et the text s

ons is also

nvey. At the

other side,

ed.

ons which w

s and time

om the case

he case stu

subject mat

ve, regardle

some of the

tion of 30 se

generic an

such as d

operations –

ial new info

Public


ves three p

minating the

a broad gro

, the create

More gam

eation of an

evelopment

information

the fact th

extended t

for the pla

text. Most o

should prov

challenging

e same time

the questio

would add v

eframe was

e studies tur

udies. More

tters and p

ess if they w

e related g

econds of t

nimations. T

difficulties c

– were valid

ormation tec


purposes. F

e project

oup of end-

d open plat

ified eleme

nimations an

t process o

n and impro

at D5.1 com

the time fra

atform prov

of the users

ide a balan

g. The ques

e, the length

ons should

alue to the

challengin

rned out to

over, co-pla

potential en

were based

gender asp

them would

This was fu

created by

d for most o

chnology is

S


First, it pro

findings. S

users eithe

tform based

ents can be

nd other inte

of the plat

ovement in

mparative a

ame for co

ed out to b

s are not wi

ced view of

stions shou

h of the tex

also not b

platform wi

ng. Initially,

be difficult.

anning with

d-users –

on the case

pects are c

not do just

urther supp

the short

of the case

s offering to


Duration:


ovides a po

Secondly,

er as an alon

d structure o

e included

eractive ele

tform. The

the visualis

analysis an

ompleting th

be challeng

lling to read

f the cases.

ld measure

xt does not

be too sim

ithin the fra

the anima

No feasible

the project

revealed th

e study find

complex an

tice for the

ported by th

rotation tim

s. As discu

oday is not

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


55

owerful and

it provides

ne standing

offers basis

as Opigno

ements.

described

sations can

nd the case

he learning

ging due to

d long texts

. Related to

e the points

allow much

plistic. The

mes create

ations were

e animation

t partners –

hat several

ings. It was

nd creating

case. As a

he fact that

mes of the

ssed in the

being fully

U

5 s

r t

5

d

s

g

s

o

d

n

e

g

o

s

o

s

h

e

e

e

n

–

l

s

g

a

t

e

e

y


Thgrares

NMLA can

for the ex

blended/hy

lead to mo

in the EU

increase tr

Even thou

politics, d

manageme

online lear

of the colla

effectivene



n provide a

xperts partic

ybrid trainin

ore effective

countries

ransparency

ugh it is oft

evelopmen

ent are inte

rning tools t

aborators o

ess of the E

elopment


ny use that may

highly bene

cipating in

ng where e-

e training ou

and by the

y and under

ten difficult

t aid, hum

erconnected

hat could fr

of the CSDP

EU efforts in


eficial tool t

the CSDP

learning is c

utcomes. Id

e members

rstanding o

t to pin-poi

manitarian

d. Training t

rom its part

P missions

conflict pre

Public


to be used

P missions

combined w

deally, the p

s of local c

n EU’s crisi

nt causaliti

aid, civilia

that provide

serve to en

and operat

evention.


in the futur

and opera

with hands o

platform will

communitie

is managem

es in sequ

an crisis m

es understa

nhance the

tions. Ultim

S


re training c

ations. NML

on training

also be us

s in crisis

ment activitie

uence of un

managemen

nding of thi

competence

ately, this c


Duration:


courses and

LA can be

with trainer

sed by the l

and conflic

es and obje

nfolding ev

nt and mil

is merging

es and ana

could help t

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


56

d exercises

utilized in

rs. This can

arge public

ct areas to

ectives.

vents, trade

itary crisis

the various

lytical skills

to enhance

U

5 s

r t

6

s

n

n

c

o

e

s

s

s

e


Thgrares

BIBLIOG

Anderson,

Brynen, Re

Carlson, S

environme

Cascading

Council De

(CEPOL),

Deterding,

Defining “

Finland.

EAPTC,

http://eaptc.e

EEAS, Sec

Eimeren, V

2012.

ENTRi Abo

ENTRi, Eu

pre-deploy

http://www.en

Erkkola Ju

available a

ESDC,

http://www.em

ESDC, The

EUPST Ab



GRAPHY

T. Elloumi,

ex, Teachin

S., Using

ents affected

g Style Shee

ecision 200

Official Jou

S., Dixon,

“Gamificatio

News e-le

eu/en/news/vie

curity e-lear

V., & Frees

out, availab

urope’s New

yment

ntriforccm.eu/c

ussi-Pekka,

at: http://users

Auto

milyo.eu/sites/

e eLearning

bout, availab

elopment


ny use that may

F., Theory

ng about Pe

Technolog

d by crisis a

ets (CSS), a

05/681/JHA

rnal of the E

D., Khaled,

on”, Semin

earning p

ew-news-e-lea

rnings, avai

s, Ergebnis

ble at: http://w

w Training

course,

certification/de

2008, Sosi

s.jyu.fi/~juerkk

onomous

/default/files/2

g Managem

ble at: http://


and Practic

eace Operat

gy to deliv

and/or confl

available at

of 20 Sept

European U

, R. and Na

ar paper f

latform on

arning-platform

lable at: http

se der ARD

www.entriforcc

Initiative fo

Slov

evelopedcours

aalisen me

kol/sosmed_ka

kno

2016%2001%2

ment System

/www.eupst.eu

Public


ce of Online

tions, Intern

ver educat

ict, Final Re

: https://devel

tember 200

Union, L 256

acke, L., Fro

for MindTr

n ENP a

m-on-enp-avai

ps://webgate.e

D/ZDF Onli

cm.eu/about/a

or Civilian C

venia

ses/assets/pd

edian käsitte

asite_erkkola.

owledge

2026%20Auto

m of the Eur

u/about-us/


e Learning,

national Pea

ional servi

eport, JBS I

oper.mozilla.o

05 establish

6.

om Game D

rek’11, Sep

available o

ilable-online-0

ec.europa.eu/e

ne Studie

about.html

Crisis Mana

2012,

f/PreDepoyme

eestä, Taide

pdf

units

onomous%20K

opean Secu

S


2004.

acekeeping

ces to ch

nternationa

org/en-US/doc

ing the Eur

Design Elem

ptember 28

online, 20

0526.html

eeas/security-

2012, Med

agement Co

4,

ent_Course_C

eteollisen k

s,

Knowledge%2

urity and De


Duration:


Vol. 21, Iss

hildren and

al, 2013.

cs/Web/CSS/C

ropean Pol

ments to Ga

8-30 2011,

16, Acces

-e-learnings/

ia Perspek

ourse Conc

available

Concept.pdf

korkeakoulu

available

20Units_1.pdf

efence Colle

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


57

s. 4, 2014.

d youth in

CSS3

ice College

amefulness:

Tampere,

ssible via:

ktiven, 7(8),

cept for the

e at:

n lopputyö,

at:

ege, 2014.

U

5 s

r t

7

n

e

:

,

:

,

e

:

,

:


Thgrares

Folke Bern

work/courses

Friedrich,

innovation

http://lib.tkk.f

Gaebel, M

conducted

learning_s

Hakkaraine

Profession

Amsterdam

Harman, T

Case-base

describe th

available a

Helsingin S

miljoonaa,

Hypertext

IAPTC, ava

Jochen, Re

http://proceed

Joint Actio

College (E

Kirkpatrick

Classic Wr

Kolb, D., E

Cliffs, NJ:

Leinonen,



nadotte Aca

s/education-an

Pirjo, Web-

proce

fi/Diss/2013/is

. & al., E-le

in Octobe

urvey

en, K., Palo

nal and ed

m, Elsevier,

T., Bertrand

ed learning

he Big Pictu

at: http://doi.or

Sanomat, P

31 January

Preprocess

ailable at: h

ehrl and Ta

dings.elsecon

on 2008/55

ESDC), Offic

k, D. L., Te

ritings on In

Experiential

Prentice Ha

T., Designi

elopment


ny use that may

ademy, Edu

nd-training-net

-based co-d

ess, U

bn978951388

arning in Eu

er-Decembe

onen, T., P

ducational

2004.

, B., Greer,

facilitates

ure. Journal

rg/10.1016/j.ja

Puolustusvo

y, 2016, arti

sor (PHP), a

http://www.iapt

aitto, Petteri

ference.eu/ind

50/CFSP of

cial Journal

echniques fo

nstructional

Learning: e

all, 1984.

ng Learning


ucation and

tworks/

design. Soc

niversity

80040/isbn978

uropean hig

er 2013, 2

Paavola, S.

perspective

A., Pettus,

critical thi

of the Acad

and.2014.09.0

imat ostaa

icle is acces

available at:

tc.org/

i, Pre-deplo

dex.php?r=site

f 23 June

of the Euro

or evaluatin

Technology

experience

g Tools. Me

Public


d Training N

cial media

of T

89513880040.

gher educat

2014, availa

& Lehtinen

es. Advan

, A., Jennin

nking in un

demy of Nu

003

uuden taist

ssible at htt

: http://php.ne

oyment eLe

e/index&year=

2008 estab

opean Union

ng training

y, Vol. 1, En

as the sour

ethodologica


Networks, a

tools to en

Tampere,

pdf

tion instituti

able at: ww

n, E., Com

ces in Le

gs, J., Wall

ndergradua

utrition and

telu-simulaa

tp://www.hs

et/manual/en/in

arning for C

=2015&index=

blishing a E

n, L176.

programs

nglewood: L

rce of learni

al Insights, A

S


available at

hance user

2013,

ons. Result

ww.eua.be/

munities of

earning and

-Bassett, E

ate nutrition

Dietetics, 1

attorin varus

.fi/kotimaa/

ntro-whatis.ph

CSDP miss

=papers&vol=1

European S

in Ely, D. P

Libraries Un

ing and dev

Aalto Unive


Duration:


t: https://fba.s

r-centered

availa

ts of a mapp

/libraries/pu

f networked

d Instructi

E., & Babatu

n education

15(3), 2015

smiehille –

/a14541271

hp

ions/operat

19#

Security an

P. & Plomp

nlimited, 197

velopment,

ersity, 2010

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


58

se/en/how-we-

design and

ble at:

ping survey

ublication/e-

d expertise:

on Series,

unde, O. T.,

n: Students

5, 378–388,

hinta liki 10

15262

tions, 2015,

nd Defence

p T. (Eds.),

79.

Englewood

.

U

5 s

r t

8

-

d

:

y

-

:

,

,

s

,

0

,

e

,

d


Thgrares

Malone, T.

Marsick, V

Continuing

Inc, 2001.

Means, et

Review

www.ed.gov/

Mezirow, J

3-24, 1981

Moore, M.

NATO e-L

https://jadl.ac

Nkhoma, M

activities b

Education

North Atla

and Guida

Panel of E

August 201

Poikela, E

Taubert, Jo

TAJU, 199

Quality As

available a

Rehrl, Joch

Accessible



. W., Towar

V., & Watk

g Education

al., Evalua

of

/about/offices/

J., A Critica

.

G., Backgr

Learning,

ct.nato.int/

M., Lam, T

based on

Conference

ntic Treaty

nce No 1, M

Experts (Mi

15.

sa & Poike

ohanna & V

99.

ssessment

at http://e-xcel

hen and Pe

e via: http://pr

elopment


ny use that may

rd a theory o

kins, K., In

, no. 89, Sp

ation of Evi

Online

/list/opepd/pps

al Theory of

round and o

Education

T., Richards

the revised

e (InSITE) 2

Organisatio

March 2012

nistry of Fo

ela, Sari, K

Valtonen, P

for E-learn

lencelabel.ea

etteri Taitto,

roceedings.els


of intrinsica

formal and

pring 2001,

dence-Base

Learnin

ss/reports.htm

f Adult Lear

overview of

& Training

son, J., Kam

d Bloom’s

2016.

on, Educati

.

oreign Affai

riittisyys ja

Päivi (ed.). K

ning: A Be

dtu.eu/images

Pre-deploy

seconference.

Public


ally motivatin

d Incidenta

Jossey-Ba

ed Practice

ng St

ml

rning and E

contempora

g “Anytime

m, K., & La

Taxonomy

ion and Tra

irs, EEAS O

ongelmape

Kriittisyyteen

enchmarking

s/documents/E

yment eLea

.eu/index.php?


ng instructio

l Learning,

ass, A Publi

es in Online

tudies,

Education. J

ary America

e, Anywhe

au, K. H.,.

y. Proceedi

aining Prog

Official and

erustainen

n kasvu kor

g Approach

Excellence_m

rning for CS

?r=site/index&

S


on. Cognitiv

New Dire

shing Unit o

e Learning:

2009,

Journal of A

an distance

re” The s

Developing

ngs of Info

ramme Ma

d a former

oppiminen.

rkeakouluop

h, EADTU,

anual_full.pdf

SDP missio

&year=2015&in


Duration:


ve science,

ections for

of John Wil

A Meta-An

availab

Adult Educa

education,

site is acc

g case-base

orming Sci

anagement

OPCEN O

Teoksessa

petuksessa

Third Edi

f

ons/operatio

ndex=papers&

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


59

5(4), 1981.

Adult And

ley & Sons,

nalysis and

le at:

ation 32 (1),

1990.

cessible at

ed learning

ence & IT

– Direction

fficial) 27th

a Järvinen-

a. Tampere:

tion, 2016,

ons, 2015,

&vol=19#

U

5 s

r t

9

d

,

d

:

,

t

g

T

n

h

-

:

,


Thgrares

Rehrl, Joch

and Opera

Sevillano-G

Education,

Siemens,

http://devrijer

Teaching a

Zhang, D.

learning? C



hen, and G

ations, edite

García, M.

, Educationa

G., Conn

ruimte.org/con

about Peace

, Zhao, J.

Communica

elopment


ny use that may

alia Glume,

ed by Joche

L., & Vá

al Technolo

nectivism:

ntent/artikelen/

e Operation

L., Zhou,

ations of the


, “Cooperat

n Rehrl and

zquez-Cano

ogy & Socie

A learnin

/Connectivism

ns, Rex Bry

L., & Nuna

e ACM, 45 (

Public


tion and Co

d Galia Glum

o, The Im

ety, 18 (1), E

ng theory

m.pdf

ynen, Interna

amaker, Jr

(5), 2004.


ordination.”

me, 2015.

pact of Di

E. 2015.

for Digit

ational Pea

., J. F., Ca

S


” In Handbo

gital Mobil

tal Age,

cekeeping V

an e-learnin


Duration:


ook on CSD

le Devices

2004, ava

Vol. 21, Iss

ng replace

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


60

DP Missions

in Higher

ailable at:

. 4, 2014

classroom

U

5 s

r t

0

s

r

:

m

Qu

1.

ind

too

Ap

- P

qu

foc

op

- E

wh

mi

aw

eth

2.


Thgrares

ANNEXES

ANNEX 1

E-learning

As a part

eLearning/

appreciate

ca. 15 min

uestions

Has

duction trai

ols/New M

pplications96

Potential co

uestions: HQ

cal points

peration offic

Examples o

hich have

issions:

wareness tra

hics

If eLearnin

96 New metechniques



S

QUESTIO

g tools/NML

of the IEC

/new media

e if you coul

utes). Than

the miss

ining utilize

Media bas6 (NMLA)?

ounterparts

Q or field o

s, field

cers)

of eLearning

been u

eHEST,

aining, onlin

g tools/NM

edia technos, computer

elopment


ny use that may

ONNAIRE

LA questio

CEU-project

a based le

d contribute

nk you for yo

sion/operati

ed eLearni

sed Learni

s to pose t

office traini

office sta

g applicatio

used in t

landmi

ne training

LA have NO

ology is anrized system


FOR THE

onnaire

we seeks

earning app

e to our wo

our conside

Sub-q

ion

ing

ing

the

ing

aff,

ons

the

ine

on

If yes,

a) Wh

been u

c) By

author

trainin

d) Are

d) Wh

eLearn

f) Hav

effectiv

g) Wh

h) Wh

i) Wha

using t

OT a) Ye

ny type of ms or data n

Public


E CASE ST

to review

plications (N

rk by comp

erations.

questions

hat kind of

used?

whom the

rities, traini

ng)?

e the applica

hich kind o

ning environ

ve any ty

veness of t

at type of a

at type of b

at kind of ch

the online e

es, please

applicationnetworks.


TUDY RES

the current

NMLA) in E

leting the fo

application

y were use

ing provide

ations acces

of technical

nments are

ype of imp

he training

assessment?

benefits wer

hallenges (t

educative to

describe w

n meant to

S


SEARCHE

t practices

EU CSDP

ollowing que

s? b) Whe

ed (training

ed by the

ssible to the

specificati

using?

pact asses

utilizing edu

?

e gained by

technical or

ools / eLear

what kind o

o transfer i


Duration:


ERS

with regard

mission tr

estionnaire

en and whe

g conducted

mission, o

e public?

ions the le

ssment car

ucative lear

y using the

r other) wer

rning enviro

of applicati

information

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


61

d to use of

aining. We

(it will take

ere they hav

d by nation

other type

earning too

rried out o

rning tools?

application?

re faced wh

nments

ion could b

via digital

U

5 s

r t

f

e

e

ve

nal

of

ols/

on

?

ile

be

l

be

de

it w

3.

eL

4.

be

yo

uti


Thgrares

een utilize

eployment tr

would be he

Has in-m

Learning too

If no eLea

een utilized

u think tha

lize them?



ed during

raining, do

elpful to utili

mission tra

ols/NMLA?

arning tools

in-mission

at it would

elopment


ny use that may

g the p

you think th

ize them?

ining utiliz

s/NMLA ha

n training,

be helpful


re-

hat

helpfu

b) No,

c) No

zed a) Wh

b) Wh

c) Are

d) Wh

eLearn

e) Ha

effectiv

f) Wha

h) Wh

i) Wha

using t

ave

do

to

a) Ye

helpfu

b) No,

c) No

Public


l.

please give

opinion

at kind of a

en and whe

the applica

hich kind o

ning environ

ave any ty

veness of t

at sort of as

at type of b

at kind of ch

the training

es, please

l.

any reason

opinion


e reasons.

pplications?

ere they hav

ations acces

of technical

nments are

ype of imp

he training?

ssessment?

benefits wer

hallenges (t

application

describe w

ns given?

S


?

ve been use

ssible to the

specificati

using?

pact asses

?

e gained by

technical or

n?

what kind o


Duration:


ed?

e public?

ions the le

ssment ca

y using the

r other) wer

of applicati

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


62

earning too

rried out o

application?

re faced wh

ion could b

U

5 s

r t

2

ols/

on

?

ile

be


Thgrares

ANNEX 2

Please fill

improve th

Backgroun

Gender

Age?

Are you fam

Are you wi

SECTION

(1= Poor, 2

How would

How would

How would

How would

Other Com

SECTION

(1= Poor, 2

Which cas

Did you fin



2: QUESTI

IECEU L

in the que

e IECEU Le

nd informatio

Male

miliar with E

th EU confl

1

2= Satisfact

d you rate y

d you rate th

d you rate th

d you rate y

mments

2

2= Satisfact

e did you co

nd the introd

elopment


ny use that may

IONNAIRE

Learning A

estionnaire i

earning App

on Your a

Fema

EU Commo

ict preventi

tory, 3=Goo

your first imp

he visual lay

he navigatio

your user ex

tory, 3=Goo

omplete?

duction bene


E FOR PIL

Application

in requeste

p. The data

answers

le

n Security a

on and civil

od, 4=Very g

pression of

yout?

on (side bar

xperience?

od, 4=Very g

eficial? YES

Public


LOTING

Testing: Q

ed order. Th

can be use

and Defens

lian crisis m

good)

the IECEU

r, scrolling)?

good)

S N


Questionna

he data wil

ed also for o

se Policy?

managemen

Learning A

?

NO

S


aire

l be gather

other related

YES

t?

App?


Duration:


red in orde

d research

NO

YES

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


63

er to further

purposes.

NO

U

5 s

r t

3

r


Thgrares

Why?

Were the le

Which wer

General co

SECTION

Which of

competenc

What work

What did n

THANK YO



earning obj

re the three

omments an

3

the 13 an

ces in Confl

ked?

not work and

OU FOR YO

elopment


ny use that may

ectives defi

most usefu

nd feedback

nimations/in

lict preventi

d how to im

OUR COMM


ined clear?

ul elements

k

terative ele

on?

mprove it?

MENTS!

Public


Y

and why?

ements did


YES

d you com

S


NO

plete unde


Duration:


er section

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


64

7. General

U

5 s

r t

4

l

Anim

Lear

the b

Anim

Learhighlwhileconsexpe

Anim

Lear

unco


Thgrares

ANNEX 3

mation the

rning target: P

best without c

mation the

rning target: lighted in thee at the samsider concretert potentials

mation the

rning target

oordinated r



3: ANIMAT

me 1. PR a

Presenting re

creating wro

me 2. Pool

The user we course of thme time imprte ways to ewithin the m

me 3. Frag

t: The user

relief and cr

elopment


ny use that may

TION THE

and setting

ealistic but y

ng expectati

ling and sh

will understanhe IECEU. Troving compeenhance skil

mission/opera

gmented ap

is sensitize

risis manag


MES IN N

expectatio

yet optimistic

ons.

haring

nd the conteThe user whietences andls and comp

ations staff.

pproach

ed to the co

gement effo

Public


MLA

ons

expectation

ent of poolingle be empha

d subsequenpetences of

mplexity of

rts.


s for the mis

g and sharinasized with atly results ofthe mission

mission en

S


sion objectiv

ng (P&S) Im fact that cof the missionstaff by poo

vironment a


Duration:


ves conveys

mportance of oncrete way n. The user oling and ut

and to the o

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


65

the message

P&S has bto cut expenis sensitized

tilizing the la

outcome of

U

5 s

r t

5

e

een nses d to arge

Anim

Lear

The

Anim

Lear

prob

chan

Neve


Thgrares

mation the

rning target

CSDP miss

mation the

rning target:

lems of lack

nges in HR,

ertheless, rob



me 4. Miss

t: The user u

sions usual

me 5. Hand

The user u

king institutio

selection p

bust HOTO p

elopment


ny use that may

sion manda

understand

ly have non

dover

understands

nal memory

processes o

procedures c


ate

s that the a

n-executive

the lack of

have been i

of the memb

can diminish

Public


activities of a

mandates w

f institutional

identified as

ber states a

these challe


a CSDP mis

which rarely

l memory a

a challenge

are, howeve

enges both o

S


ssion are co

y allow proa

nd how to c

e in many CS

r, needed t

n strategic a


Duration:


onnected to

active actio

counter it w

SDP mission

to fully addr

and operation

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


66

o its mandat

n.

with HOTO. T

ns. Considera

ress this iss

nal level.

U

5 s

r t

6

te.

The

able

sue.

Anim

Lear

Anim

Lear

not c

activ


Thgrares

mation the

rning target:

mation the

rning target:

cover a CSD

vities.



me 6. Coor

The user is

me 7. Mon

The user is

P monitoring

elopment


ny use that may

rdination a

sensitized to

itoring pat

introduced to

g mission. Ho


and exchan

o the importa

rol

o a standard

owever, an u

Public


nge of infor

ance of funct

d day within C

unarmed non


rmation

ioning comm

CSDP monito

n-executive c

S


munication in

oring mission

ivilian crisis


Duration:


mission imp

n. The IECEU

mission is a

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


67

plementation.

U project doe

part of CSD

U

5 s

r t

7

.

es

P

Anim

Lear

susta

Anim

Learplan


Thgrares

mation the

rning target:

ainable post-

mation the

rning targetning and im



me 8. Secu

The user is

-conflict deve

me 9. Gend

t: The user umplementati

elopment


ny use that may

urity sector

sensitized to

elopment.

der

understandion phase.


r reform an

o the importa

s the reaso

Public


nd function

ance of safe a

ons and imp


ning defenc

and secure e

portance of

S


ce

environment

including ge


Duration:


as a conditio

ender into m

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


68

on for peace

missions’

U

5 s

r t

8

ful

Anim

Learprev

Anim

Lear

faced


Thgrares

mation the

rning targetvent or reso

mation the

rning target: T

d in some ca



me 10. EU’

t: The user olve conflicts

me 11. Mon

The user is i

ase.

elopment


ny use that may

’s political

obtains oves in a frame

nitoring me

ntroduced to


framework

erall understework of com

entoring an

o the concept

Public


k for crisis

tanding of tmprehensiv

nd advising

t of MMA an


approach

he elementve approach

g

d to the chal

S


s related toh.

lenges and c


Duration:


o EU’s instru

criticism EU’

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


69

uments to

s activities h

U

5 s

r t

9

ave

Anim

Lear

unde

betw

trans

comp

Anim

Lear

and

miss

cours


Thgrares

mation the

rning target:

erstand that

ween interna

sparent dialo

petency build

mation the

rning target:

operations.

sions and op

se of the cris



me 12. Nat

The user is

the staff ca

ational and n

ogue. The r

ding and fost

me 13. Dep

The user wil

The user w

perations. Af

sis managem

elopment


ny use that may

tional staff

s sensitized

an contribute

national staf

role of natio

tering local o

ployment o

ll obtain an o

will be introd

fter the unit,

ment activities


to a range

e to the wor

ff call for m

onal staff ca

ownership.

of mission/o

overall under

duced to the

the user is

s.

Public


of themes r

rk of mission

mutual respe

an be seen

operation

rstanding of

e planning a

able to def


related to wo

n in many w

ect and req

to go beyo

processes r

and implem

ine the mea

S


orking with n

ways. Well-fu

uire investm

ond the mis

elated to dep

entation pha

sures which


Duration:


national staf

unctioning w

ment in coop

ssion tasks

ployment of

ases of cris

h are taken

IECEUect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months


70

ff. The user

working relati

peration and

in the form

CSDP missi

is managem

prior and in

U

5 s

r t

0

will

ions

d in

on

ions

ment

the

Documents

IECEU D5.2 M17 Design and development process of the NMLA